# Transcript of Record — North American Co. v. Securities & Exchange Commission

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386405_0033%3A06

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1946
- **Citation:** 327 U.S. 686

## Text

Vol. VI |

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD

> }

Supreme Court of the United States

—_

OCTOBER TERM, 1042 -- ~-

a No. #21 /

, NORTH AMERICAN COMPANY, PETITIONER,

°

CURLEIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION

CERTIORART TO THE UNEDED STATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUL

PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED FEBRUARY 10, 1943.

CERTIORARI GRANTED MARCH 1, 1943.

nn ee a ene eee eee nee age

uited States Circuit Cattrt of Auprats

1

RANSCRIPT OF RECORD

j
( ‘
.
\ | 4 TT)
COIN { ee PSE ee ee
>
QD
i
a
Vs
~_—
ae | es 1. XP ’ 4 LAF A CA LT
PRLS ANd. BA ( cis LMLISSTON
]? » A yA +
| e: Uwe?
ones |
°

TESTIMONY

Volume VI
(Pages 2044 to 2499)

2

\
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Be are Volume VI.
: PAGE
Testimony ...... eee Tre ee eee eee. cecces wee

RESPONDENTS’ WITNESSES: _
0
Stanley Stoke®: |
Direct by Mr. Hamilton (Continued )
2045, 2249, 2417
Direct by Mr. Browning............. sive S108

John A. Woodbridge:
Direct by Mr. Browning...... sucavbeeees 2358

2044
6130 Bergre THE
Securities and GAchanoe Conunissinn
Docket No. 59-10

4
a

IN THE MATTER

of

THE NORTH AMERICAN COMPANY, et al.

6131 +

Heéariag Room 622, “
Securities and Exchange Commis.
| , sion Bldg.,

4 Washington, D. C.,

Wednesday, October 23, 1940.

Met, pursuant to adjournment, at 10 o’cloek a.m.

§132 ae
Before: W. W. Swirt, Trial Examiner.

Appearances: | ci:
S. PEARCE BROWNING, JR., and CHARLES 8. HAMILTON, JR,
of Sullivan & Cromwell, 48 Wall Street, New York City,

Attorneys for the Respondents.

RaLrH C. BrnForp and Arruvr J. BuSWELL, Attorneys for _
the Securities and Exchange Commission.
—2,634—

ee

24D
Stanley Nokes—By Respondents—Direct
PROCEEDINGS,

‘The Examiner: The hearing will come to order.

Mr. Hamilton: Mr. Stokes, will you resume the
stand? :

Whereupon, STANLEY STOKES resumed the stand and tes-
tified further as follows:

Direct Examination by Mr. Hamilton (Continued) :

Q. Yesterday, Mr. Stokes,

mission system of the Union Electric Group. Will yeu now

you described the main trans-
describe the sub-transmission system and begin, if you will,
with a statement of what you regard as being your sub-
transmission system? A. The sub-transmission system, as
referred to in this discussion, consists of the lines which
form the connecting link between the main transmission
system and the main power plant, with the distribution sub-
stations. Those sub-stations are step-down transformers
» Stations in most cases, which step the voltage down from
some voltage such as 14,800 or 33,000 volts, to a lower dis-
tribution voltage, such as 2,300/4,000, cr in some cases 6,600,
6.900, and other similar voltages. That is, we have several
such voltages in approximetely the same range.

The sub-transmission system of the, Union Electric Com-
pany, Group is a combination of overhead lines and under.
kround cables. The system includes more than ],200 circuit

—2,635—
miles of both overhead and underground transmission, di-
Vided inte 543.8 miles of 33 kv. pole lines; 43 miles of 33 kv.

6133

6134

3

ee

6136

6137

6138

- PO045-->
s

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

steel tower lines; 159.7 miles of 33 kv. submarine and under.
ground cables; 170.4 miles of 13.8 kv. submarine and unider-
ground cables; 248.2 miles of 12.95. kv. pole lines; 6.8 miles ef
13.8 ky. steel tower lines; 1.6 miles of 11 ky. steel tower lines;
34.2 miles of 11 ky. pole lines; 9.1 miles of 11 kv. underground
‘able; and 18.5 miles of 6.6 ky. underground cable. These
mileages are in addition to'those lines which have been previ-
ously described as main transmission system.

In general, the undergrotind system, so-called, meaning
the underground cable and: the conduit work, is confined: to
the urban and the more densely populated areas, while the
overhead circuits serve the surrounding, lesser populated
districts. Se |

In general, the City of St. Louis is largely supplied by
underground cable except for its 4,000 volt ultimate dis-

tribution circuits, Which are not under d/scussion here.

St.Louis County has both underground cable and over-
head lines, I would say predominantly overhead, The other
less populated districts have a larger percentage of overhead
construction.

The general basis of these circuits is to supply off them
60-cycle energy for practically all of the.growth of the load.
Certain areas which are already supplied by 25-cyele for in-

F —-2,636—
dustrial purposes or railway load, are continued that way.

Q. Now, if you will, describe that portion of the sub-
transmission system in and about the Keokuk plant?. A. The
Keokuk voltage at the plant is referred to as 11_kyv. Most
of our system is 13.2 or 13.8 kv. I would like to explain that
in the use of these voltages that are very close to each other,

2047

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—WDirect 6139

such as 13.2 or 13.8, or 66 kv. or 69kv., those are all used
synonymously. Actually, the voltage varies on such a cir-
cuit, and at the transmitting end the voltage would be some-
what higher than at the receiving end. So when I speak of
13.8 ky. cables, I am talking about the power plant end. If
I speak of 13.2, it merely means that we are talking about the
receiving end. But in any case, they may be regarded as
synonymous. | |

The Keokuk sub-transmission ‘system takes the supply of
power at 11,000 volts from the plant and distributes it in 6140
the vicinity of Keokyk, and by reason of transformation to
33,000 volts, it is also supplied to Fort Madison and other
[/ towns in the vicinity.

The two 11 kv. feeders supply 3,500 kw. of frequency
changers of the Central “Mlinois Public Service Company.
One 11 kv. feeder stpplies a 2,450 kw. frequency changer of
the Ilinois-lowa Power Company.

four 11 kv. feeders go to Hamilton, Tilinois, which is
located immediately opposite the Keokuk plant on the Il-
linois side of the river, where two of these four feeders sup-! |

—2,637— 6141
ply the Ilinois-lowa Power Company; and the other two, the
lowa Union Electric Company.

Three 11 kv. feeders go to the Keokuk terminal for 11
ky. distribution to the Keokuk and Jackson Avenue sub-
stations, and numerous customer sub‘stations.

The Keokuk terminal is just a name for a terminus, not
far from the plant. .

Two 11 kv. feeders supply large customers. Those are
big industrial eustomers who are heavy users of electric
power for electric furnace application. |

6142

6143.

6144

O48

-
*

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—-Direet

Two 33 ky. feededs go to Burlington, supplying nine
sub-stations of varying capacities, which are operated by the
Union Electric Group. The end of those feeders terminates
at the Burlington sub-station of the Lowa Southern Utilities
Company. I should explain that that reference includes the
line which was discussed under main transmission system,
but I have not included it in this mileage. The reason I have
mentioned it here is that those various-sub-stations which are
tapped off of that circuit, weré not included in the previous
discussion. They are smal] stations to-adarge extent.

In addition to the above feeders, part of the sub -tgansmis-
sion system consists of the taps on the main 110 kv. trans-
mission lines at Hull, and Meppen. Those points wefe dis-
cussed and located in the previous testimony, and in
addition to their features as wholesale points, there is some

| —2,638—
sub-transmission carried out to supply loads in the vicinity.

At Hull, seven sub-stations are supplied with energy over
33 kv. lines from that point, and in addition energy is sold
to the Central Illinois Public Service Company for use in.
their own frequency changers located at Hull sub-station.

At the sub-station which taps the main iine at Meppen,
a 9,000 kilowatt step-down transformer, 110 to 66 kv. voltage,
supplies a portion of the power going to the Central Illinois
Pubiic Service Company transformers, and frequency
changers; and a 66 kv. No. 2 single-circuit line, which is
earried to Alton. That line was mentioned yesterday. °

At Alton there is located 6,000 kilowatts in step-dow?
transformers. The line then continues to Hartford, where
8,000 kilowatts of transformers are in operation, and thence —

L049

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

to Lake Avenue sub-station in East St. Louis, which is 15.6
niles south-of Hartford.

“At Lake Avenue, 10,000 Kilowatts in transformers supply
2o-cyele service in the East St. Louis district, with a reserve
supply, over three 13.8 kilovolt submarine cables from the
Ashley. Street plant. That is, the service in East St. Louis
amounting to about 10,000 kilowatts,of 25-eycle load in that
vicinity, has a duplicate source of-cupply, aud in the event
that this circuit from Mappen sub-station wer to be in difti-
culty, the service would be continued within interruption

= —2,639-—
by cables going from the Ashley Street station under the
river and over to Lake Avenue. In that district- we ha&ve
the large packing companies, the National Stockyards, and
this service is quite important. -)

In general, as we go through this sub-tratismission system,
I should like to point out that the facilities are, in almest
every case, if not all, arranged to provide duplicated service;
that the extent to which duplicated service is provided in the
area supplied by the Union Electric Group is a very high
percentage. I think that is one distinctive feature of the
Union Electric system, the extent to which our main cus-
tomers have duplicated service.

Q. State the purpose of that duplication, if you will?

A. The purpose, of course, of the duplicated service, is to_
render less frequent possible interruptions, and not only -

minimize the possibility or probability of interruptions, but
to reduce the length of time if any should arise.
The success which a power company may heve in the long

run with these large industrial] customers is, in my opinion,

6145

6146

6147

1

6148

6149

6150

° : ?OD0
Staniey Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

to a great extent affected by the actual continuity of the
service rendered, as wel! as the voltage regulation and quality
of service. The fact that electric service may be tendered
and be of lower grade is not always appreciated, but it is a
fact that in industrial work, particularly, both regulation
and continuity are of the greatest importance.

ae —2,640—

The supply of. service by these underground sub-transmis-
sion cables is obviously more expensive than to do it with
overhead lines, but the reliability is much higher.

Q. Describe the portion of the sub-transmission system
in and about the Page Avenue sub-station in St. Louis, if
you will? A. The Page Avenue sub-station has been previ-
ously mentioned as a main transmission sub-stution, which
is its chief function; in addition to that, however, there
is a large group of sub-transmission feeders leaving tbis
station, and in addition to that, quite a large building con-
taining a group of distribution feeders which will not be
described at this time. :

When we constantly refer to the Page Avenue sub-station,
it is because that station contains, in the same. general loca-
tion, all of these facilities.

The sub-transmission feeders supplied out of this sub-
station are of considerable importance, The fact is that they
are very important, There are ten 13.8 kv. 60-cycle feeders
which supply ten sub-stations through 104,500 kilowatts of
13.8/33 kv. transformers; and 13.8/4.16 kv. transformers

25-eyele service, at 13,200 volts is provided by 24 feeders

which run to 12 railway sub-stations belonging to the Public
Service ‘Company, which is the local street car company, and

2051
Stanley Stokes—By Kespondents—Direct

sonie of these feeders go to Ashley Street where they in turn
are supplying railway joad.

gai

The 60,000 kw. of frequency changers, previously men-
tioned, are on the bus which supplies all of these facilities,
and I would like to make this point, that when some ques-
tion was raised recently about the possibility of supplying
reliable service to what is known as Lambert Field, an
airport some 9 miles from Page Avenue sub-station, and I
was asked whether I thought we could supply good service
to that point, I said that I could conscientiously reply that
if we couldn’t- deliver it at that point, I didn’t believe it
could be delivered anywhere. And I have summed up the
facilities by saying that we had two hydro-electric plants,
four steam plants, several duplicated types of substation
facilities, and a group of distribution lines—all available at
that point; and any one of which should be able to supply
that service many times over.

The extent of these facilities is a matter of real point
in this particular system. The St. Louis County area, which
_is adjacent to this sub-station, contains the highest grade

residential and some of the better commercial establishments

in the St. Louis area, including University City, which is the
largest single town in that district, and the requirements
for service are very severe at that point.

_ The ten feeders previously mentioned, 7 of which supply
energy to transformers having a total capacity of 82,000
kilowatts, which furnish the service for nine sub-stations,

—2,642—

are divided into two groups: seven 33 kv. feeders, and three

6151

6152

6153

AR ALA NE TA EIB REA a Be

6154

2052

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—VDirect

feeders supplying the Page Avenue distribution station

6155

6156

through 22,500 kilowatts of transformers at the lower voltage
delivered of 4,160 volts, three-phase, four-wire.

The statement there is not sufficient to make it clear, The -
seven 33,000 volt feeders which leave this sub-station, each
one having its own transformer, step up and supply 33,000
volt overhead lines which go out several miles in the different
directions to supply these step-dow n sub-stations, which in
turn handle the district for such towns as St. Charles, for
example, and various other Communities in that area. :

The three feeders which I mentioned. as going through
the 22,500 kilowatt transformers, step down right at the Page
Avenue ‘location, and go into this other large distribution
building which handles the 4,000-volt distribution.

The 25-cycle sub-transmission circuits from Page Avenue,
consisting of 24—13,200 volt feeders, have 8 feeders used as |
tie-lines to the Ashley Street plant. These are underground
cables. Also, ten feeders supplying 12 sub-stations of the
Public Service Company, by underground cables. You ut
derstand that 10 feeders can supply 12 sub- stations by tap-
ping one feeder to more than one. That sub-station probably
has another source of supply from some other location.

Six feeders leave Page Avenue underground, and then are
routed overhead, three going north, and three south, to a

: —2,643--
number of customer sub-stations. eee

That is a rather brief summary of a major investment in
feeders whose average capacity varies from a minimum of
7,500 or 8,000 kilowatts each, to 12,0007

All of these transformers on those feeders that step up
are provided with air-blast equipment which permits the

L058
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

transformer to increase its rating for emergency operation.
The later transformers instaHed on some of these equivalent
feeders are rated 10,000/13.333 k. v. a., that meaning that the
transformer which has a 10,000 kilowatt self-cooied rating,
with the radiators exposed to the air in a normal manner, can
automatically, by the operation of relays, turn on some
motor-driven blowers which blow air rapidly over the surface
of the radiators in the transformer, and raise the capacity of
the transformer. ;

This is used in connection with reserve service. If one
line of any three of ‘those were to go out of service, the other
two would pick up the load.

Q. Now if you will, describe the pertion of the sub-trans-
mission system in and about Ashley Street? A. Ashley Street
station, which was previously mentioned, has been in service
for many years, has the ground around the station for a dis-
tance of about a block almost paved with cables. I believe
that that statement is hardly wuch of an exaggeration.
Literally, it is getting difficult to find room to put any more

eae | ‘ —2,644—
conduits in that immediate vicinity, and the temperature rise
of such cables has to be carefully analyzed as larger numbers

6158

6159

of them are involved in close proximity, and each one con-—

tributes a certain amount of heat and the ground has to
radiate it. aa

Ashley Street both generates and distributes 60-cycle and
25-cyele energy. The sub-transmission system at Ashley
Street may be summarized for 60-cycle energy as: 21 feeders
going to six sub-stations, including the downtown AC low-
voltage network. This network is a relatively recent installa-
tion, and will be discussed in more detail later.

EM AB ra

Ce ee ww

Pe lL lee ES RRO Mle ee Ses CURR

6160

6161

6162

2054
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

The 25-cycle system supplies energy to six sub-stafions_
over 18 feeders, and also serves 13 Publie Service aie
(railw ay company) sub-stations over 13 feeders.

Q. Now have you stated the voltage of the feeders going
out of Ashley Street? A. No, I shall do that.

The steam mains out of Ashley Street are large, and
earry 200-pound steam pressure, and there has to be great
care exercised where the steam mains and the-eables are in
the, same vicinity, and problems of that type are the result
of concentration of load in congested city areas. Such
problems are not encountered in lower-load- den sity districts,
bnt they frequenthy present real difficulty for satisfactory~
solution.

In this case, we have to highly insulate the steam mains,

° —2,645—
and then provide special facilities for cooling the conduits,
and one of aur very large customers is a refrigeration com-
pany which has 10 to 15 miles of distribution refrigeration
service. They pump the refrigerant around the city and
expand it at different locations. Although we work very
closely together to eliminate any problems that may arise,
we get into some street intersections where the refrigerating
company and the steam heating mains, and all the electric
cables, converge. The steam heats the refrigerant, which
causes it to expand and produces difficulties in pumping -
it, and the steam main also may have a detrimental effect
on the electric cables; the electric cables may affect the re-
frigerating line, and they are not very good neighbors.

There is only a certain amount of space left in these
streets, and we have to utilize what there is with the great-

est care.

—

YU
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

Phe voltage at which the energy at 60 cycles is handled
out of Ashiev, is largely at 13,800 volts. There are 25-—
3.8 ky. feeders (four tie-lines tO Cahokia with 48,500 kw.
-in 13.8/33 Kv. transformers). | have got to mention that
at this point because, although it is located there and is
intimately connected with this sub-transmissionm system, it
was referred to and classified with the main transmission
sysiem, that is, those four feeders. They tie between the
Cahokia station and Ashley Street station.

| —2,646—

‘The balance, twelve 13.8 kv. feeders, go to five sub-stations
and customer sub-stations, and six feeders go to the down-
town network transformers.

The sub-station which we refer to as No. 6, and which is
located. within the Ashley Street power plant building, is a
4.160-volt, 8-phase, 4-wire distribution station. —° |

There are three gengrators connected to the 4,160-volt bus,
having a combined capacity of 42,000 kilewatts, and ip*addi-
tion, three feeders connected to the 13.8 kv. bus, through
“7,000 kilowatts of transformers. That is, there are several

, ° > ° ° \ °
uses In Ashley Street, all of which are duplicated, again at

Increased: cost, to obtain better service, and these buses are |

each used to supply certain load at the respective voltages,
and in addition,-each of these buses is connected with one or
hore of the others by a tie-transformer and cable.

The application there sounds complicated, but is re'atively
simple. It simply means that we have generation at/ more
than one voltage, and on more than one bus. We have dis-
tribution. to these sub-transmission cables at more than one
voltage. And in order that there may be available reserve

6163

6164

6165

6167,

6168

\ ——,

‘connected, and to which 25 feeders Are connected.

energy up to 13,200 volts; alsc eight 13,200-volt tie-line

energy can be exchanged.

‘the energy out to primarily the Edison sub-stations for con-

POG

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

service, each of these buses for the other, they themsely
i The sub-transmission system at the Venice plant has
three step-down transformers of a combined ‘apacity of 40,-
000 kilowatts, reducing the voltage from 66 kv. to 33. kvy.,
and supplying the cables previously mentioned, which go to
St. Louis, to two sub-stations.

There are also two 66 kv. feeders, previously mentioned,

tor the entire Alton district is supplied. The details of the

capacity of that station. will be reserved for a little later
7 | | —2,649—

discussion, It is rather a major station in our system.

/.
/
/
/

going to feed sub-stations at which point the general service

6169.

6171

61

61

73

74

L2058
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

The Venice sub-transmission system, under discussion
liere, is being modified and supplied in a somewhat different
manner at the present time, due entirely to the construction
of the new Venice station.

The concentration of all of the power in that location
at 66,000 volts, without any segregation by transformers,
would produce, by -the time the plant was extended to its
second section, such heavy short-circuits that system relia-
bility would be impaired. This does not mean tliat we could
not go ahead with the present service as now rendered,
which is highly satisfactory, but it does mean that at some
time in the future we. might be required to change the meth-
ods. We have looked into that matter carefully, und ana-
lyzed the possible effects On service, and have decided that
we are justified in spending the necessary money today to
connect those circuits into the new plant onto the 13,S00-

volt bus, and we are purchasing new step-up trahsformers to

do that. That is a question which in many cases, I think,

might be resolved on the theory that everything is all right,
why not let well enough alone.

We could save the price of four large transformers if
we were willing to risk the reduction in the grade of service
on the system. We have obtained approval to buy, these

SL
I like to bring these points out, because they represent.

transformers.

the added investment that is necessary in acsystem of this
kindif you intend to deliver the very best grade of service
Which you possibly can, and in a concentrated district, I
think that that is the only attitude to take. The service
demands that type of reliability.

nl

2049

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

”

° there at Venice. These three feeders which have been de-
scribed will be removed, the transformer will be removed, and
used elsewhere, and the new transformers will be located in
a row along the river on top of the levee, and each one of
these will be supplied directly from our new 13,800-volt
buses which were mentioned yesterday in the design of -the
new plant, and feed across the river very similarly to the
Cahokia feeders, through the underground submarine cables.

‘Q. Turning. new to the Cahokia plant, will you give simi-
lar information as to the sub-transmission system in and
about it? A. The facilities in and about Cahokia are, of

course, many times more extensive than any of our other sta- ©

tions, and yet there is ample room to get all of these facilities
“out in an orderly and very simple manner, which we now
appreciate. That is to say. the judgment which was used
initially in locating Cahokia and in acquiring adequate land
when the company obtained it, and in anticipating what the
picture wouJd look like 20 years later, has: certainly paid

a

ee” A) 2 65 —_

dividends. That is to say, it is making the station one of
excellent design today, whereas a lack of such foresigt it
would have crimped the situation entirely.

I like to point to Cahokia as being a station with as many
facilities going out of it as any that I know’of, and yet it
does not appear to be congested, and it is operating with per-
feet reliability. ‘s

z

The difficulties at Cahokia are few and far between, ‘ded :

hever Very serious.

I have very little-else that I think need be mentioned |

6175

6176

6177

2060

me
6178 Stanley Stokes~By Respondents—Direct

The plant has two 66 kv. circuits leading from the out- -
door sub-station:in the yard, supplying power to the Illinois. —
Iowa Power Company at Belleville. Those two feeders have

ON ee Oe a Ee

rv

been previously mentioned under our main transmission sys-
tem,: but because we are describing the supply to this area,
I mention them again.

PUNK BALE ISIE DTI.
7

CMS ES TALES B50

% Three 33 ky. feeders go to a sub-station in East St. Louis,
known as Winstanley, as well as one known as Main, and

: Lake Avenue sub-station. |
, 6179 =‘ Three 13.8 k. v. feeders supply a large number of cus-
i tomer sub-stations in East St. Louis, and the surrounding
: industrial area. That is, these three feeders, which have a
capacity of roughly 3,500 to 5,000 kilowatts each,:go around

OSS SE ak A

and tap various industiial plants where the plant itself owns
its own sub-station. We supply them with power. |
| jena — 2,652—

The larger portion of the power from the Cahokia
station crosses the river into St. Louis through a combined
total capacity of 202,500 kw. in 13.8/33 kv., step-up trans-
formers. These cables supply power to 12 A.C. sub-stations

en Re a A Mls aml oe a Ot ae Sli OF

which are connected ‘through 24—33 kv. submarine cables,
where they cross the river, and thence, by. ordinary under-.
ground lead cable in ducts, to the’sub-station. One A.C.
sub-station is supplied with power by two 13.8 kv. cables.
Four D.C. sub-stations receive power oyer four 13.8"
ky. cables. This makes a-total of 17 A.C. ‘and D.C. sub-
stations supplied by 30 cables.
At this point I would like to digress just a moment to
| illustrate that when we were describing, the 25-cycle system”
| ee at Ashley Street going into the sub-transmission feeders,

e

2061

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

we mentioned that some of those feeders supplied the sub-
stations which convert from 25-cycle to D.C. Xow from
Cahokia you have a similar group of 60-cycle féeders which
go to similar conversion sub-stations to convert to the D.C.
for the Edison system.

Thus we have about 34,000 kw. all told of Edison D.C.

load which is about equally supplied from 25-cycle and 60-

cycle systems, Thus, the most severe case of trouble that
you could conceive, which might conceivably, under that
assumption, shut down one whole system, either 25 or 60-
cycle, would still affect only half of the Edison system, be-
cause they are ‘not electrically ‘connected: between the 25

| / —2,653—
and 60 cycles in such a way that they can possibly affect
each other to any extent.

Thus, the degree of reliability Which we have obtaingd
on the Edison system by the use of the two frequencies in
Niat manner, would be impossible, as far as I know, to obtain
otherwise. The record of this Edison system has been very
good indeed. 7

4. Where is the Edison system located? A. That Edi-
son-sygfem represents the main downtown, heavy business
distri¢t, running about 10 or 11 blocks north and south, and
possibly 16 to 18 blocks east. and west. It is a very small
and dénse area. The Joad density in that area is comparable
with any part. of New York except a very few blocks right
in the Manhattan area. It is higher than the density of
New York outside of that point. But it is a very small

area, if only measures .4 square miles. It has, at the present_
time, about 75,000 kw. in that little area, which, if you-

divide it by .4, is a very high-load density.

GO1sl

§182

6183

Ais SIC AS BAN eb LEN I Oi LE hh

we nv
that method. | | |
On the low-voltage side of the receiving sub-statian, we
have a regular standard bus construction with all the low- .
voltage circuits in parallel; supplied through oil switches.
Q. You referred to tl rather extensive use of under-
ground cables in St. Lonis, and the area more or less con-
tiguous to St. Louis, in St. Louis County. Is the matter of
cable loadings a subject of considerable investigation by
—2,669—_
the’ Unien Electric Group? ntirely likely—in. fact, it is verv prob-
able—that neither cable willbe out during the hot weather,
in which case we could have increased that load to possibly
a couple of thousand, kilowatts higher, but we can’t assume—

,

Me

o

stanley Stokes—By Respondents-—Direct

that, so we limit the emergency rating, which is the rating
we will put on the cable when theother cable is out of service,
to these values. :

For a 350,000 cm., 3-conductor cable, which is the one
we use the most of, we. have 6,680 k. v. a. at 13,000 volts, and
14,500 k. v. a. at 33,000 voits.

The other two sizes, which’are in rather general use, are -

“4/0, rated at 5,030 k. v. a. at 13,000 volts, and 11,000 k. v. a. at

—2,672—
33,000 volts. The smaller one, 1/0, is similarly rated at
3,480 and 7,400. .

If we have a large number of these cables in a duct, cr
if we know that there are other cables in the street adjacent
to it, we apply a correction factor and reduce the rating
accordingly. In other words, we have got to make allowance
for the total heat liberated within a yiven ground area, and

as a result of considerable study and analysis of che life —
of cables in the St. Louis district, we feel fairly satisfied.

with these ratings. There is one question, however, and that
is it is entirely possible that some of these emergency ratings
can be materially increased without actually damaging the
cable. That is receiving much study at the present time.
Damage to cables is being carefully anatyzed and a post
mortem, so to speak, carried on after each cable failure, with
extreme care, trying to find ont why the cable failed. We
found that, among other things, the creepage of these cables
‘in the.duets, due to expansion and contraction with tempera-
ture changes, was such as to cause a crystallization of the
lead at the point where the cable leaves the duct and goes
into the manhole, and that many of these failures were

6229

6230

6231

6232

6233

6234

2078
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

attributable to such causes as that, and not directly to the
high temperatures. If those prove to be the majority of the
troubles, then it wiil be possible, by using more care in the
design of cable and duct arrangements, to actually run these
cables to much higher temperatures without ——
2,673—

There are some experiments being carried on to determine
that, and it takes several years to be sure of these figures.
It would mean a great deal to any company to be able to
increase these ratings by even 10 per cent., because the
investment in the cable system is huge. _

One other expedient that has been adopted i is this. Ww here
we go through a soil that we know to be particularly a poor
heat conductor, for example cinders, a cinder fill, we have
learned to increase the size of the cable. We wiil put ina
section of 450,000 em. in ‘a cable where the rest of it is
350,000 cm., thereby reducing the losses in that section, and
hence reducing the heat and es the temperature down
that way.

Q. Are the present. sub- transmission facilities of the
Union Electric group adequate for present loading and fer
presentiy anticipated loading? A. They are, and in addition
they have a large reserve capacity. : The approximate ratio
of loads on some of these cables, to their maximum capability —
or capacity, may be illustrated.

- The particular examples that I am using here are taken
from some alternating current sub-stations in the City of St.
Louis, but it would be equally applicable to any* of the
others. These happen to be more convenient to obtain the

information on.
—2,674—

2079

>

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct |

In a list of 23 stations which I prepared, the highest
loa ing that I could find was 75 per cent. of the capacity of
the transformer banks, and this occurred at the Page
Avenue station. That station is scheduled for an addition
in the near future.

The next highest loading in this group was 67 per cent.,

at a station known as Lesperance. That is still satisfactory .

down there at that station because of the interconnection
with other stations. If that were 100 per cent., we could
still operate satisfactory because we have ties with other
stations that would carry part of that load.

In general, looking over this group, we find figures as
low as 28 per cent., 30 per cent., 32 per cent., and the result
is that the average ratio of load to capacity does not exceed
about 50 per cent.

Q. Now, that percentages, is that the peak on the par-
ticular sub-station? A. The peak on the particular sub-
station, yes. It may not be at the time of the system peak.
That has no interest to a particular sub-station. It is only
concerned with ifs own annual peak.

“I might sh ca there is as much capacity in some
of these stations in reserve as there is. That is, if there
could be any criticism of this ratio it would be that we
haven’t got these stations loaded up high enough.

—2,675—

The answer is that a good many of these stations are
relatively new, and it is not practicable to put in these high

voltage underground cables and ducts ip small sizes. The

duct cost is high, and the cest of a 10,000 kw.-33 kv. cable
is only slightly moré than one of smaller size. In other

6235

6236

6237

\

6238 -

6239

6240

2680
2 Stanley Stokes—By Respondents-—Direct

words, the insulating requirements are the same, the dead
sheath isn’t much different, and whether you put 2 /smalj
wire in or a big wire, you have spent pretty near as) much
money. eee j

Therefore, it is better to put them i in as bigias as you intend
to put them in ultimately, even though you_have to carry
the fixed charges for a few years. The result is that we
change transformers as needed, and ship them from the
larger staticns to the smaller ones, but cables are usually
put in with ample capacity, and in these downtown or city
stations, we put tlie transformers in to match the cable.
Within a few years that ratio will be higher on these low

_ yalues. The lew values will increase, in other words, we

will have the stations Ipjded up toa higher ratic, but the
high values will be kept down for transfer of. load or add-

ing additional capacities. In general, there. is ample
capacity in this systém to handle much additional lead.

Q. Now, will you summarize the number of feedets on
the sub-transmission system, giving a total figure, if you
will? t
as a gift to the customer. I don’t see how you: can regard
it any other way, but it is one of the essential features. of

6319

632
Bt be ar Rang

6321

an

2108
6322 Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

such a change-over. The company undertook that obligation.

The city of Fort Madison, itself, is having its distribu-
tion system completely redesigned and the transformer con-
nection and such other changes made as are necessary ta
provide 60-cycle service in pla’ » of 25 cycle.

Q. Turning now to the distribution sysiem, itself, I think
you have given previously an overall statement of the num-
ber of customers served by the Union Electric group. Are
you abie to classify those customers in general by the county
6323 in which they are located in order to indicate the density of

service in a particular county? A. The particular date as
of. which I have this information is December 31, 1939.
The total number of customers as of that date is 349,096,
- distributed geographically as follows: City of St. Louis,
202,308; St. Louis County, Missouri, 74,674; St. Charles
County, Missouri, 3,633; Franklin County, Missouri, 4,773;
Jefferson County, Missouri, 7,794; St. Francois County, Mis-
‘souri, 5,254; Lakeside Division, Missouri, 286. .
Q. Now, that Lakeside Division you just referred to, is
that the territory around the Osage plant? bridges
and alleys, all of the power coming from the Union Electric
group. The lights and equipment on the municipal bridge, a
number of alley-lighting systems and a few. private systems
in the city are owned and operated completely by the Union
Electrie group. Outside of the city limits, that is in St. Louis
Ceunty and various other locations, the Union Electrie:group-

‘owns and operates the street lights, themselves.

. . re y . . t . . .
The city of Kirkwood, which is af municipality, owns and

operates its own street-lighting system and purchases the ’

*

2111

: Stanley Siokes—By Respondents—Direct
power from the Union Electric group. Clayton, Missouri
and Washington, Missouri-each own a few lights in their
_business district and all are supplied from the Power Com-
pany System. ‘

Q. By that you mean by the Union Electric group?

Q “These all-purpose facilities are ostributed rather
generally, are they, throughout, the territor: > A. Yes, they
are generally distributdd, but T wouldn't want. it thought
from that, that they are ctrélessly distributed. They are in
selected locations, selected with great care, You see if we
can analyze the number of trips made'to and from thesé
yards, afyer we get several years of experience, we can ind:
cate the possibilities of economy if the locations are changed, .
We have had occasion to change very, few, practically none.
There is only one yard that I know of that has been con-
cluded to be in not-the best location. This new one will take
care of that.

But the loc ation of a pole yard receives careful study
and analysis as to where these poles are going to go and how
much haul there: will be from that point, and Ww e try to pick
them so as to produce the minimum amount of haulage and
travel.’

— Q. The location o f the pole yards may determine to some .
extent the speed at which a repair is made? A. 4 would.

We do not know of ¢ourse-at what point repair work of

2131
- Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

an emergency type is going to be required. Therefore, we
have got to have these yards property distributed so that no
point on the system is excessively removed.

In general, however, I think the greatest economy is ob-

, : —2,735—
iained In the location where the normal operation, every
day, of hundreds of irucks hauling this material, will not
produce an excessive mileage.

The light type of trouble work is not entirely related to
these pole yards. The trouble man would get to an emer-
yency ina light cur anyway. He would be dispatchéd from a
garage. If the service was of some particular major import-
fince, if there had been some severe breakage of a pole, or
something like that, that pole would have to bé delivered
from the nearest point. |

(). Now, very briefly, if vou will, the nature and extent
of the transportation and construction equipment of ‘the
“group? A. The transportation equipment is an extensive
‘tem in a company of this type, referring to the Electr.c
“onpany of, Missouri, the Union Electric Company of
-lissouri and the group. We have quite a fleet of construc-
tion and miscellaneous equipment. About all I could ‘do
would be to summarize it, the totals, to give an understand-

ing of the magnitude of it. There are 198 passenger cars,

240 trucks, 72 of these large industrial trailers that are
operated from a tractor, 6 tractors; 2 portable cranes, and
one of those is designed to lift heavy foads and was specifi-
'* cally designed to install and remove and maintain these net-
“work transformers which have to be let down through a grat-
ing in the sidewalk from a truck located in the street, and

a) —2,736--

$391

6392

6393

6394

6395

6396

on

2132

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

you cannot afford to obstruct traflic for any length of time
in a busy area. That required ‘rather special design.

We also have concrete mixers——6; and 14 of these gaso-
line driven air compressors on wheels. _

The aggregate cost of this equipment is considerably over
$600,000. : :

We selected the equipment with as much care as we can,
keeping in mind all time the application for which itis-

intended. We do have a lot of street and paving work to do,

and concrete breaking and breaking of pavement, to get into
conduit lines, and economy in that work is very essential, and
machinery helps materially to do it.

Q. The list which vou have inst given includes trouble
cars, does it? A. Yes, that ineludes—well, I listed passenger
curs, but [ am not quite sure whether that figures inclndes
trouble cars or not. The treuble cars, as used by the indi-
vidual treuble men, are passenger cars. I believe that that
figure should include them. .

Q. Do von. mean “should” or does? A. Well, I can’t say
for certain whether it does or not but I can look that up if it
is of any importance. nm

“Q. Now, turning to the operations of the system, will you =
state the base load generating plants in the system and relete

—2,737--
the functions of the other plants to the operating of the base
load plants? A,’ The answer to vour question requires that I
again mention the same power plants that I have previously
mentioned from the standpoint of property, but withthe
intention now of stating something about how they operate

The Union Electric groap has this interconnect¢d gen-
erator system consisting of the 6 plants, 4 steam and 2 had,

21338
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

and the plant which is depended on for the higher load

factor work is Cahokia, where the better equipment is avail-

able in quantity. In combination with the hydro plants, we
assign to the different units in the different stations a load
which they can carry most economically at the time.

The hydro plants in this system are constantly varving
their output, and it requires a very close detailed attention
to keep the steam plants fitted In with the requirements of
the load, and at the same time utilize the hydro power inso-
far as possible.

The operation of such a system is much more complicated
than that of a straight steam system, and is somewhat difii-

cult to explain in a limited time.

The fivst situation which we encounter in attempting to

set loadings is that we have to find out what is the depend-
able capacity for different types of service of each of these
plants. .

‘The drainage area of Osage, for example, is not the same

| ek
as that for Keokuk. Therefore, there should be and is seme
diversity between these two properties. The Keokuk plant
has limited storage, and fhat has to be kept in mind, and if
there is any considerable amount of stream flow, that has
to be used.

Osage has storage, but it has to be scheduled and used
effectively to get the most good out of it.

The basis of our operation may be expressed by stating
that as a result of many calculations and experience to date
which is about 8 years, we are confident that we can safely
assign, as u combination rating for Osage and Keokuk, the

6397

6399

gy

2134

6400 Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

ability to carry 200,000 kilowatts of our system peak for
the entire period of the winter peak.
That is, not 24 hours a day, but to cut 200,000 kilowatts
off of that peak each day for as many days as required.
2, sae
The individual ratings of those plants, of course, are
at various times much larger than that. You can get from
130 to 160 thousand kilowatts out of the Osage, — 135,000
out of the Keokuk plant.
6401 Now to illustrate the actual method of operation, Keokuk
never gets below, in an ordinary year, say, 70,000 kilowatts.
Any reduction below that is of very rare occurrence. That
being the case, that 70,000 kilowatts of water power energy
would either go over the dam or.we must make use of it.
So it is placed first, it carries what I would call the base’
load, 24 hours a day. |
Then the steam plant, the best unit available at the time,
probably 75,000 in our case, would be placed next, and oper.
ated at its maximum efficiency point. °
Then the next less efficient unit, and so-on until we
6402 finally get to the reserve plants, some of which may be
actually shut down cold.
In certain years, Rivermines will not be oper rated at all.
In other years it will be operated for a very short time.
Now that is the type of operation for which the Osage
plant is primarily designed. |
On the other hand, suppose that instead of having a very
Jean or dry year, and what we call a low send-out for wate? -
power, suppose we have a very good vear. Also let us assume
—-2,740—.

a

———

2135

4

y Respondents—Direct 6403

“~

Stanley Stokes—i

that we may have just installed a new large unit such as
the plant which is now under construction. Under those
wnditions we Would not have to reserve Osuge specifically
to cut this*winter peak, we could use it any way we wanted
to for that year. tee

And what we do do is to try to schedule the operations in
such a Way as to get>the greatest number of kilowatts,
‘ilowatt-hours, out of that plant in that year. ;

In the years just before such a unit is to be installed, the
greatest value that Osage can be to us is to make a firm 6404
cut-off of this 200,040 kilowatts, even if we have to sacrifice
afew kHowatt hours. The result is that in making that firm
winter Cut-oif, we schedule the fevel of the reservoir by what
is kuown asa rule curve. We have checked the rainfall for
i) vears, we have checked the records the years the plant
las been running, and we know whai the minimum rainfall
we can count on for the next certain number of weeks is.

lt may be greater than that and probably will be, but
that is the least.

Now, in pulling down the reservoir, you have got to watch
wo factors. One, you must not get it so low that you can't 6405
get it back full ahead of its winter peak, even though you
have got/the lowest rainfall on record. So whenever you
gett down to the point at which minimum rainfall: would

| | 2.741
just bring it up, th you quit drawing it down and start
tuning your lower efficiency steam plants. nae ;

On the other hand, if yea pull it down too far, then, even
_inan ordinary year where you are not concerned about the
winter peak, in trying to get more rainfall in the reservoir

6406

6407

6408

2136
™~ Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
you may overdo the job and have the effect of operating your
storage reservoir at a lower head than could otherwise have

been done. :
So it is really a very nice engineering operation and cal-

culation day by day to watch this operation and see to &

that the plants are sclfeduled to get the greatest good not
only from the equipment, so as to keep fixed charges at a
minimum, but from the hydro plant to get all the kilowatt
hours you can, and from the steam plants to be sure you are
operating the most efficient unit for the particular work at
the time. | ae

~The usual way of expressing this operation is to state that

a duration curve is constructed which can be described as 4

curve in which the ordinate is kilowatts, and the abscissa is
hours per year up from zero to 8,760, or the total year.

The product of hours, times kilowatts, is kilowatt-hours,
or energy. The result is that the area ander this curve rep-
resents, energy, and any particular height on the curve rep-
resents the kilowatts at that point, and the length over

; 5 | —2,742—
to the right of the curve indicates the number of hours per
year at which that particular load is used.

lor example, suppose that the system peak for the winter
of 1940 were to be 500 cr 515 thousand kilowatts. If we took.
200,000 kilowatts off of that, that would: leave us 315,000
kilowatts. Now we would examine this curve at the height
of 315,000 from the bottom, and go horizontally over until
we intersected the curve, and that would tell us how many
hours that 315,000 kilowatts would have to be carried.

At the top of the curve we know that it is just one hour,
and working out each step there, we can determine the num-

2137

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

ber of kilowatt-hours that it would take to cut 200,000 kilo-
watts off of our 1940 winter peak.

Then we analyze the storage of the reservoir and we find
that the reservoir just has enough kilowatt hours to do that,
including the rainfall that will be acquired, even on a mini-
mum year. : . | ?

All of these calculations have to be made in advance.
‘They are corrected as fast as the actual figures are available,
but we have to assume in these operations that each esti-
mate ahead is based on a minimum year, and then correct it
as quickly as the actual figures are available.

Ry that process of cut and try, each day, and correcting
a preliminary estimate and finally getting it pretty accurate,

—2,7438—
.we schedule the operation of both the hydro and steam
plants in conjunction with each other, so that the hydro
cuts this firm peak and at all other times, when it has excess
water, we use it for kilowatt hours, and shut down our big
units for overhaul during the period of flush water, and by
that I mean during the spring months, about three months.
It is possible to overhaul two of the largest units on the
system during the period of the plentiful water power in
the spring. At the present time we have occasion to only
overhaul one, because we only have two of those units, and
we alternate them, each one every other year.

‘If we were to acquire another large unit of equivalent
size, or even sligltly larger, there would be' certain years
in which we would want to overhaul two large units in the
same year, and ‘we could schedule both of them in that
period.

6409

6410

6411

6412

6413

6414

2138
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents-—Direct

During the valley of the load, after the summer peak is
over, there is opportunity to overhaul one of our next larg-
est units, such as the 50,000. By that method we operate
with a satisfactory and safe reserve, and still try to keep
the economy in mind at al! times

The hydro plants provide Siena quick-starting re-
serve, whereas, these large steam units require several hours
to bring them up to load from cold, because we do not dare

—2,744—
heat them up quickly.

So that at any time at which we were holding the reser.
voir full, and not using very many kilowatt hours,_intend-
ing to cut this winter peak each day, we always have avail-
able this reservoir with a capacity of from 135,000 to 150,000
kilowatts for emergency.

So during that period, if we were to lose a Jarge unit
without notice, the hydro plant, particularly Osage, would
pick up gas vant incest it until such time as we could
make other arrangements. ‘

To that extent it provides a type of Service that a steam
plant cannot provide. er

.Q. Do navigation requirements enter into the method
of operation of the Keokuk and Osage projects? A. The
navigation requirements are very intimately connected with
Keokuk operations. There is extensive navigation on the
Mississippi River. There is no actual real navigation en
the Osage River, and we are required to let through a cer
tain amount of minimum stream flow, but it has very little
effect on the operations of the plant. We probably would
do almost that anyway.

2139

Staule yi Stoke es —By Respondents—Divect 6415

—Q. You night state what those requirements are, and
what bearing they have on the operation of the plants?> A.
Yell, the Keokuk plant has to avoid radical Gr rapid fluctu-
ations ef the river. We tuust not do anything at the plant
. | ~—~2 745—
Avhich will interfere with the baits. | C
For example, if a boat is tied up to a dock in the evening,
and if we-were to suddenly let through a large amount of
water, trying to carry a little short-time peak, the river
would rise appreciably, and the boat might be damaged. A. 6416
howt would be affected really worse if we were already letting
through a good deal of water, and were to shut it off. Then
it might ground. |
The result is that we have to operate with great care so
that nothing will interfere with the river, and we are subject
to the requirements of the War Department Engineers, who
control river operations. |
| may say that they are becoming a little more rigid
in their requirements lately, which is brought about by the
operation of this series of dams that have been constructed ;
north of Keokuk to provide this navigation channel to Min- 6417
—heapolis, and we haven't been able to tell yet just what
effect thet. will have, numerically, but we think that those &
regulations will somewhat reduce our possible — at

Keokuk, but it wilt _ be serious.

s estimates that have
to be made of rainfall and the effect of weather ¢01

. Now: you have spoken o

IUTS

on storage capacity of the Hydro-electric plants.. Who makes
these estimates? A. What individual? |

6418

6419

2140

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

-Q. What department or individual? A. The hydraulic.
department. The individual is: this same ‘gentleman, Mr.
Albion Davis, of whom I spoke previously with regard to
his contributions to the art of turbine governing. Mr. Davis.
is the chief hydraulic engineer fur the company, and was
originally located at Keokuk for many years.

Q. Are these studies extensive and are they continuing?
A. They are, they are quite involved. I attempted to explain
only just the high spots here, and the simplest part-of the
calculations, and indicate the nature of the problem, but
still you could not possibly go into all the details in a con-
versation or in any kind of testimony.

I have a few statistics here, one or two of -which may
have been given, but I would like to mention them for the
system as a whole.

In 1939, the net generation was 0,468,395, 631 kilowatt
hours, The peak load was 476,000 kilowatts, but we have

_ since attained a load of 489,000 kilowatts, on July 9, 1940.

6420

The load was increased from 476,000 to 489 ,000 in 7 months,
or a little over 6 months. The increase in the use of kilowatt
hours during the current year is greater than the increase .
in demand. Such studies as I have been able to make of this

‘feature indicate to me that there are a number of industries

—2,747—
already operating on the night shift, as a part of the National
Defense program. There is no other.explanation for it.

We have examined all the factors that are available to
us, und\ that is our conclusion.

Q. So that you are picking up load at off-peak times dar
ing the day? A. That is right. We made an analysis of out

-"N

2141

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

minimums, rather than maximums; in other words, analyzed
the highest night loads in the middle of the night, and we can
see that those have come up appreciably, and although we
don’t have any specific knowledge of who these customers
are, or just what is going on, I expect we could attribute
quite a bit of that to possibly the shoe industry. The Inter-
national Shoe Company has received a major contract al-
ready. .

The coal burned during. the year was 1,123,537.tons. That
is a good many tons a day. At the same time, we must elways
keep in mind that in a normal year, normal hydro year,

roughly speaking one-half of the kilowatt hours is generated

by water power, and that has a major effect on the operation
of onr system, our steam system, and on the type of equip-
ment that we can use; and you must always keep that point
in mind in any comparison of the Union Electric Group with
any property which is operated as a straight steam system.

The hydro operation has a very marked effect on the

: —2,748—
system as a whole. Gite. hydro kilowatt hours, having
already acquired the plants, cost very little. In other words,
the total annual operating expense of a hydro system is
practically constant, year-in and year-out, and amounts to
less than .2 mills; in other words, it is less than 1/10th of
the production cost of a steam plant.

So that at auy time we can get a large amount of water
power, our total average cost of production per )i. vatt
hour goes down. The efficiency with which we prod: | it
may goup. The totals go down, but the unit costs go up, so
those things have to be taken into account.

6421

6422

6423

2142
6424 | Colloquy

Mr. Hamilton: I think this represents a good
breaking point, Mr. Examiner.
The Examiner: All right, we will recess until to-
morrow morning at 10 o’clock. ~-—
(Whereypon, at 4:3%0’clock p. m., a recess was
taken until 10 o'clock a. m., Thursday, October 24,
1940.)
—2,749—
6425

6426

2143
BEFORE THE

Securities and Exchange Conunission
| Docket No. 59-10

IN THE MATTER
of
THE NorTH AMERICAN COMPANY, e¢ al.
is 6428

Hearing Room 622,

Securities and Exchange Commis-
sion Bidg.,

Washington, D. C.,

Thursday, October 24, 1940.

.

Met; pursuant to adjournment, at 10 o’clock a.m.
‘Before: W. W. Swirt, Trial Examiner. / 6429

Appearances:
S. Pearce Brownine, JRr., and Cuaries S. HAMILTON, JR.,
of Sullivan & Cromwell, 48 Wall Street, New York City,
Attorneys for the Respondents.

Raven C. Rrnrorp and HerMAN OveELL, Attorneys for the
Securities and Exchange Commission.
—2,750—

6430

6431

6432

2144 °
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

Z ' PROCEEDINGS. ;

The Examiner: The hearing will come to order.

Mr. Hamilton: Mr. Stokes, will you resume the
stand? ‘

Whereupon, STANLEY STOKES resumed the stand and
testified further as follows: :

Direct Examination by Mr. Hamilton (Continued) :

Q. Mr. Stokes, you were deseribing the operations of the

generating system. Will you continue with that statement?

A. We have mentioned that the bulk of our steam power
generation is produced on the [llinois side of the river at
St. Louis. There is very good reason for the location of the
Cahokia steam generating station at that point. There is a
difference in freight rates on coal which today amounts to
30 cents a ton, as between the West and the East side of the
riyer. That difference has varied. It used to be 25 cents
a ton for a good while, but in the last year or so, has been
made 30 cents. That is known as a “bridge arbitrary”. It
is simply a difference in the fr

ght rates from the coal fields
to those two points. That makes it much cheaper and much
,0wer on the east side of the

river. The transmission of power ynder the river by sub-

more economical to prodifce th

~ marine cables is more economical than hauling the coal aeross

the river when consideration is given to the fact that we only
have to transmit about half of it, half of it already being used
—2,751—

on the east side.

2145
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direcct

Coal in the St. Louis district and the Southern Illinois
field has a low fusing point ash, and a relatively high sul-
phur content, which has necessitated much experimentation
to avoid slagging of-boilers. The bigger the furnace becomes,
the higher the temperature uf the gases leaving the furnace,
if the pounds of .coal per cubic foot of furnace volume are
kept the same. That is more or less obvious, because in a
large furnace the walls of the furnace do not represent as
big a percentage of the volume as they would in a small
furnace, That is to say, the cubical content varies as ‘the
cube of the lineal dimension, and the area of the wall goes
up as the square of the lineal dimension, and you don’t, have
as Many square feet of cooling surface in the walls per cubic
foot of volume of furnace as the furnace gets larger.

The result is that you reach the point, unless care is ex-
ercised, at which, with low fusing point ash, the tendency is
for the ash to stick to the. boiler tubes, to coat them, and
that causes trouble. .

There is also a tendency, if you try to crowd the furnaces
too rapidly and burn too much coal per cubic foot of furnace
volume, to cause the ashes to slag and become molten, and
when that cools it is difficult to remove.

The result is that we have to give different treatment

to boiler design and operation in the Middle West than is
done in the Eastern part of the country with different coal.

All of those things are learned by experience, and we are
not obtaining very satisfactory operation. whereas, when
Cahokia was first started, we had many difficulties in burn-
ing thal coal successfully in the big units. ,

. 6434

6135

4

6437

6438

—«, IVC -

system costs would be about half.

°o

2151
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents——Direct

The hydro plants have been discussed as producing a
reliable annual peak cut-off of 200,000 kilowatts as of today,
with a possibility of extending this to 225,000 kilowatts by
the time our load reaches 600,000 kilowatts.

1 should like to mention that the highest all-time com-
bined output of those two hydro plants has been 278,950
kilowatts. I mention that because I want to show that our
200,000 kilowatt figure which we put in these reports as
dependable combined capacity of these plants, is materially
less than their highest record.

But it is as high a figure as we believe is conservative
and can be depended upon through the winter peak.

During the high-water season, as we have previously
pointed out, we take the base load of the system on the hydro
plant, and oftentimes all of the units are operated, as re-
ferred to in-the operating unit as “against the stop”. In
other words, if you can set a water wheel at its most efficient
operating point, and lock it there, fix its governor so it
Won't change, and let the steam system do the governing,
then you have the maximum efficiency in your hydro plant,
and get the most out of the water.

At these times we have customers, at Keokuk primarily,
whe can take power all the way from nothing up to 30,000
kilowatts, These are known as dump power customers, and
the sale of this power we refer to as excess power. It is sold

| | —2,759— }
to these customers, people like du Pont and others, who mak
a product such as 50 per cent. ferro-silicate, which can be
stored and can be held profitably until the market requires
its sale, and they take advantage of the low cost at which
we can sell this type of product, to produce the ferro-silicate.

6451

6452

6453

6454

6455

6456

,2152 .
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

We are uot required to guarantee the delivery of that
power, and it therefore acts just like a reserve plant as far
as we are concerned. We can discontinue it at will, or upon
relatively short notice.

So that that feature is an interesting purt of the opera-
tion of a hydro plant, that there is a good deal of water
power which is not continuously available and for which you
do not care to make a continuous investment, but which
returns both to the consumer and to ourselves a very nice
and profitable return. The customer return is in terms.of
very low cost power, and ours is because we do not have to
charge against that-type of power any fixed charges.

There is another class of service which has somewhat
those same characteristics, in which we have sold a very

_limited amount, known as what we call our 60-cycle reserve

service. That is not an important item, about 5,000 kilo
watts of it; and it is the type of load where the customer
can either discontinue for a while, or has another source of

| —2,760——
supply, and o# moderate notice we can discontinue his load
in the event ve need the capacity for our regular firm cus-
tomers.

The frequency changers which have been referred to previ-
ously as being very economical and saving considerable water
power, actually used or converted 100 million kilowatt hours
a year for over five years during the depression, which would
otherwise have been unusable and wouid have been wasted.
That was the basis of the statement which I made, that they
had saved roughly $2,000,000. I believe that valuates this
energy at about 4 mills. —

"

_,

2153
Stanley Stokes--By Respondents—-Direct

During the low water season, we utilize the hydro genera-
tion in combination with the steam to reduce the steam plant
operating costs. This is without reference to the detail of
how we do it, we fit it in carefully at the place where it will
produce the greatest economy.

The spinning reserve benefits in quick starting were men-
tioned with respect to Osage previously. That-is to say, we
pointed out the fact that you can pick up load in less than
three minutes.. We did not mention, however, that the use
of this spinning reserve costs about half what it does to keep
a steam turbine in reserve. It is economical to that extent,
that it will not only start quicker, but it actually is very
much cheaper to handle than the turbine, when carried for
reserve operation. You cannot run a steam turbine at zero

—2,761—
load, you have got to have a little load on it, and that means
that you are generating kilowatt hours at lower efficiency
under those conditions.

Q. Now where is control of the generating system cen.
tralized? A. Control of the plants which have been described,
and all of the lines and so on, for the Union Electric Group,
is centralized in a system load dispatcher, and his group of
system operators. The whole system is handtled exactly as
it would be if it were just one company, and the system oper-

ator or chief load dispatcher has full authority to see that_

and also his operators handle the switching
becomes necessary.

Q. Where is the chief load dispatcher located? A. He
is located in our 12th Street Office Building. We have a

the plants are operated in.accordance with hiy‘instructions,
lines when it

6458

6459"

6460.

6461

6462

2154
— Stanley wine ine Respondents-—Direct
large downtown oftice building in which the top floor is given
over largely to the/lead dispatching facilities. We have
rather expensive control boards, and elaborate facilities for
communication,” We have what are known’as Selsyn equipt
ment. Thai As an itteresting type of control in which the
position of any kind of a rotating device at one location can
be transferred to another. It isn’t practical to transfer me-
tered circuits several miles, as there would be losses, and
there would be lots of reasons why you couldn’t do it. But
2,762—
we can transfer the position of a meter hand at Cahokia to
the same position on a board at 12th Street, by what is
known as the Selsyn control. ;

It isa relatively simple device. If vou take a three-phase
motor and supply the fields from a common source, and these -
two motors are located at remote points, you can arrange
those so that they will take the same position exactly. If
one is moved half-way around, the other moves with it. These
motors do not rotate continuously, but they are designed and
built just like a motor, and if we turn this one, the other
will turn exactly with it. If this is regarded as a master
control, I can have as many as I want of these others at
different locations, and each will take the same position.

So that if that little: device is attached to a hand at

Cahokia, and is made to follow the meters over there, with

the meter scale and a device that looks like a meter over at
the 12th Street office, the operator can read exactly the same
thing.

If the meter at Cahokia were to say 100,000 kilowatts,
this one at 12th Street reads 100,000, and the load dispatcher

can tell what the loads are at some of the key points.

2155

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents-——Direct 6463

‘That is only one of the features.. We have, of course, the
eustomary board with its mimic buses, and little lights, and
relays, and all other things that go with an indicating sys-

tem so that the load dispatcher and his operators can have

9 TE

—2,763—
_...full information at all times as to what position all major
switches on the system are in; also as to what turbines are
on load, and approximately the loads handied by these; and
exactly the loads taken by the plant as a whole. —

We do not remove from the manager of the Cahokia plant 6464
the responsibility for keeping his stuff in regular operation,
and the load dispatcher in a system of this type does not
attempt to take over the detailed operation of a plant. In

fact, the less he knows about it, the better off he is, because

the man best equipped to take the responsibility for the -
thing is the man at the plant. All the load dispatcher needs

to know is information which is essential to coordinating
system operitions, In general, the load dispatcher is really

& man who schedules and predetermines the plants, wheels,

and other apparatus which is to be used a few hours or a

day later, and the system operators are those who carry out 6465
the detail operating. m

The hydraulic engineer, for example, gets forecasts of the
rain in the reservoir, the rainfall, and we have weather report
Stations up the river, and we have telephone communication
With those stations. We have men available to check all of
the hydrographic features, and all that information is ae-
cumulated in the central office, and with the caiculatious to

‘which 1 have previously referred, this hydraulic engineer
gives to the system load dispatcher the basic information as

—2,764—

o

§466

6467

6465

2156
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents— Direct

to what the hydro conditions are’expected to be the next day,
for example.

With that, the load dispatcher determines the loads that |

he will have to carry on his steam plants., In addition to
that, we subscribed to an experimental form of weather serv-
ice to try to even amplify the amount of information avail-
able as to the weather. I don’t beiieve that that in itself
was so.very successful, we didn’t think it would be, but we
didn’t want to overlook any opportunities. But it did stimnu-
late the Weather Bureau itself, who I believe didn’t par.

ticularly enjoy private groups going into the weather fore

casting business, and they set up a four-day forecast, four
or five days ahead. = going to a slightly more efficient cycle of
1,250 pounds, 925 degrees. We would really lose money, the
overall cosi iets yreater. (ncecnaeaat Ae
- Another thing, if we were to install 160,600 kilowatts of.
this new equipment at Venice, at the present time and with
present loads, Instead of ‘the S0,000-—-I am talking about
today, now, to bring them in for operation in the winter of
1941—we would be unable to give the additional S0,G00 kilo-
watts a high enough load factor, we couldn't ‘use it long
enough hours of the year te produce an overall cost as cheap
as we get in Cahokia. We would have to wait several years
before our load would be sufiicient that we could do it.

Our present system load at the night time is about 250,000
kilowatts, and there are times when we, for very short
periods, have that amount of hydro power alone. So I merely
repeat at this point the statement made once before, that all
of these figures have to be given careful consideration in the
light of the method of operation in connection with ‘the
hydro plant. If we were a straight steam system, we wouldn't
operate just as we do.

(). What department or departments operate and mail
tain the main and subtransmission stations of the Union
Electric Group? "the
2 792--

repaired and rebuilt. We used to rewind all of our distribu- /
tion transformer cores Ourselves, but within the last year or
so, we have largely adopted the practice of buying replace-
ment cores direct from the manufacturer. We take the old

transformer down, bring it into the shop, take the core out

ef the tank, clean the tank up, and sandblast it, and repaint
it or re-enamel it, and pnt in a new core, new oil, and it goes
back in service in all respects a new transformer, The reason
for this change is not that we can not do just as good a job
on these cores as the manufacturer—we have the facilities
and do—hnt it is that the gradual change in labor costs, and
increase-in quantity production methods in the factories,

-have made it cheaper to buy the replacement eore.

There are lots of other types of work, such as impregnat-
ing, baking, cleaning, spray-painting, transformer testing,
and similar work, which is done at this utility shop.

Flow pdinting is‘a new development being applied the
first time this vear to paint radiators on transformers. They
are relatively inaccessible to a paint brush, a.d it is very
difficult. to get them properly painted, and we simply set the

o

2isl
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

whole transformer in a big tank, lifting it into a big tank by
a crane, and flow the paint right down over it, and it gets
into every little crevice. We think we will noi have to paint
them one-third as often, by using this method, as we used
to have to when we sprayed them on or tried to paint them
—=2,793—
with a brush. aa
The sub-stations each require a local battery. That has
nothing to do with the main storage battery that I referred
to as having been eliminated in the Edison system. They
require batteries for operating the oil switches, and those
batteries are maintained by a crew of four men in the Elee-
trie Company of Missouri, the St. Louis district only, The
Electric Company of Missouri is the company which has the
subsidiaries, but it is also an operating company, and I am
referring to it now as an operating company in the city dis-
trict.

ft has this crew of men who continuously inspect these

°

batteries, and keep them up on a schedule that requires an‘

inspection of each battery every two weeks.

In a similar manner, we have crews in the other sections
of the Unton Electrie Group.

iach power transformer on the system is checked every
six months as to breakdown and condition of the oil. If
sludge is forming, or the dielectric value of the oil is low,

filtering is required. Otherwise, complete filtering is resorted

to only ow general overhaul. We have portable filtering.

equipment, and very elaborate stationary filtering equipment

for oil treating and handling.

6541

6543

6544

6546

91 x”?

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct /
se °

Oil circuit breakers have their oil filtered every six
months, and indoor breakers are filtered every. once in two
years, except, howe: ev, when an oil circuit breaker has locked

) —-2,794—
out, after three reclosures, and then the oil is filtered before
it is put back into service. The regular crews of the snb-
station department carry on this work.

Q. Is an active program carried on to reduce the occur-
rence of accidents in the system? A. We have a very active
safety organization. -In addition to the various safety groups |
in each of the departments, who have regular meetings at
least once a month, and who discuss all of the latest methods

of safety work, we have a full-time safety inspector, who does:

‘nothing else but safeguard employees in their work, and try

to reduce their hazards. His job is to see that everything in

connection with safety work is carried on as it is supposed

to be. He inspects all phases@f it, and is a full-time em-
ployee.

That is not the whole story of safety work by any means.
it is quite an elaborate organization. When you take all of
the different groups, and take all of their individual safety
groups, we realize that there are a large number of meetings
each year, and it is a very major part of the business.

Even on construction work, we have a very carefully
worked out organization. On the new Venice plant, we have
# hospital on the job, carried on by the insurafice companies

wlio are interested in the werk. «They have an inspector, we

have one. We have a little group who get together once a
week, and list the aceidents or any other things which might

a —? 793—

2183
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

have contributed to accidents, and they make out a report
once a week, and attached to that is a dailv report of the
accident inspection work. I glance over those from time
to time. |

I noticed a remark on one of them, before I started up
here. The safety inspector on the Venice plant reported that
one of the contractors was not placing his equipment back in
the racks‘which had been provided for it, and was leaving
shovels lying around where men could fail over them; and
that will be reported to this contractor, and he will have to
be more careful.

In this particular case we are going beyond our own

organization and seeing to it that the contractors’ men shall
not have any aggidents.
o*Q. How are belays and protective devices tested and main-
tained 2 A. The relays and protective devices on the machines
and switchboards are tested at frequent intervals by special
crews engaged in this work continuously. This is a major
bit of work. Some of the more important relays or autos
matic devices may be checked once a week;, others may be
given routine-tests at regular, but less frequent intervals.

To give you an idea of the extent of this work, I should
like to list for you just a few of the devices, to give you an
idea of how extensive this is.

We have a regular’ maintenance schedule and testing

—2,796—
schedule on 6,842 protective relays; 2,790 oil circuit breaker
control devices; 695 regulating devices; 3,758 auxiliary con-
trol devices; 2,423 recording devices; 6 oscillographs; or a
total of 16,514 devices that have to be regularly maintained,

6547

¢

6549

6550

6551

6552

; / 2184
, | |
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

inspected and tested, and require a good, many. men in con-
tinuous operation | ‘to do that.

But the corre¢t operation of the sy stele as a whole is a
function of the ageuracy with which some one of these details
work, and in order to maintain,a high degree af service re
liability, it is not sufficient to have purehased and installed
good equipment and put it even in \he iright location, but
these little devices have to be in good eoperating condition
or the whole system would not function’ Jas it should. The
care with which this relay work and this maintenance work
is done, is, in my opinion, a most important, part of the
operations. ;

Q. How are overhead lines and underground cables oper-
ated and maintained? A. The main siideuiibitin system is
operated and maintained by three line divisions. These divi-
sions are loc ‘ted at Rivermines, Keokuk and East St. Louis.

The Rivefminee group work up on the Ilinoss side to
handle thos¢ circuits. The Keokuk division is responsible
for the operation and maintenance of the St. Louis-Keokuk
line, which ‘has been described. In addition, they take care

| | —2,797—
of all the ‘subtransmission lines in Lowa and Tlinois north
of Alton.

The Rivermines line division takes care of the operation
and maintenance of all of the 132 kv. overhead lines.

The underground cables are maintained by the St. Louis
underground division. That isa separate group not included
in the other three.

Tb give you-an example of one of these groups, the men
working out of Rivermines use three cars; 7 light and 3
heavy trucks; and they have located at the Rivermines sta-

2185
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—-Direct 6553

tion caterpillar equipment, and then there are three machines
used by patrolmen located along the line. These patrolmen
make regular inspection trips along the line, reporting every
type of repair that’ they can observe, aud those repairs are
connie’ ont by the line crews. In times of trouble those
jatrolmen act to help locate the place where the iroubie is.»
1 would like to point out that we depend on the service
from our Osage plant: We have fonr transmission lines avail- ,
able between the plant and the St. Lonjs plants, and the loss
of any one of those does not cause us to Tose anv service, and 6554
the loss of two of them would, under nearly all conditions,
not resnit in the loss of any service. The result is that we
vly on that transmission line to the same extent that we
would if the plant were in closer to town, and that means
‘hat we have to use an unusually high degree of. maintenance
—2e— =
vnd operating attention. : :
The list of-items that comes in after one of these inspec-
tions would not only surprise you, but might amuse you,
some of the tiniest little items. A loose nut, a single nut,
will be mentioned, and the crew will have to vet to that and 6555
lighten it. But those are the things that cause trouble if
not taken care of.
On the underground .cable system, that is handled as a
different and separate operation. We have to distinguish
in all of our work between different types of crews. An over-
head crew is specifically skilled on that work, but they would
not Know how to do cable -work, so you-can’t divide cable
work as to location geographically. You couldn’ t puta group
of cables here and a certain bunch of lines, and ‘put them in
charge of one crew.

6556

655 58

Vist

“Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—-Direct

-

a

So that the regular tests and cable work and repair is
ail handled by what is knewn as the underground crew, and
their headquarters are at St. Louis. Once each year cal)!
circuits are given insulation and electrolysis tests. During
the hot Summer months we make frequent temperature sur
veys, both in the duets and in the manholes.

St. Louis, as [ stated preyiously, has an’extremely high
ground temperature, and also has a ramification of railway,
circuits. Those two conditions have to be carefully coped
with, First, we make, probably, more elaborate temperature

: —2,799—

surveys in the ground in the summer time than any company
with which Tam familiar. We place therine-couples in the
ducts, we have thermometers in the manholes, and we have
ito keep going over the sysiem to be sure that no excessive
temperatures exist. :
On the electrolysis work, which is caused by stray cur-
rents which usually emanate from the railway systems,
getting onto our cables, and then leaving at some point, at
which point they damage the sheath, the electrolysis work
has required potential surveys continuously for many Years,
in whe. ) we go around and measure these very small. poten:
tials that exist, and try to bond or ground these cable sheaths
in such a way that.ne damage will be dont

I have stood in the hasement of our Page Avenue sub

‘station and seen as much as 6 or 8 hundred amperes eoming

in over the cable sheaths. That is leakage current from
railways over the system; because our grounds are better and
more extensive than the railway. system, the eprrent tends
to flow from their system down to our ground, and it gets
there via these cable sheaths. As long as we have them

218%

_ Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

os
b

properly bonded, and take them off at predetermined inter-
vals, we can eliminate the damage.

There is also one other condition which require coustant
attention, and that is the chemical action which, in certain
areas, operates to corrode the lead sheath. Lead is ordinarily

—2,800—
regarded as almost immune to che..ical action, but there is
a peculiar combination in certain of the soils that does
attract the sheath, ‘and we have to neutralize the ducts in
those areas so as to eliminate that difficulty.

Q. Are overhead lines inspected regularly? A. They are.
The inspections are carried on, as a rule, on the overhead
lines —well, I should qualify that ‘statement, overhead trans-
mission lines—that is, the main lines are inspected at regular
intervals and the crew at the time of inspection does not
attempt to make a repair. They make a very detailed record
of what they find, and that record is turned ever to the
superintendent of the repair work, and he assigns the repair
crews to the work. .

In certain other types of distribution work, we use the
regular linemen, who make a combined inspection and repair
at intervals, and where they find anything wrong, they fix it.

(. Now that inspection requires climbing and other

investigation, does it? A. It does. About once each month

the putrolmen make’ inspection tours, examining structures, -

Wires, insulators, and the condition of the right-of-way.
-Once each year a climbing inspection is made, during
Which each structure is climbed. In that case the men go over
the towers, and tighten the bolts while climbing the strue-
tures. All dirty insulators are cleaned. Frequently we have

6559

6560

6562

6563

6564

2188

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

to remove the insulators and replace them with new ones,

—2,801—
or with others that have been claimed, and bring them into
the shop where we chemically clean them.

There are various things, though, that adhere to porce-
lain insulators in the East St. Louis district: I mention that
particularly because it is a heavy industrial area there with
chemical plants—it is the headquarters for the zine industry
in this country. They quote zinc as f. 0. b. St. Louis. We have
the National Zinc Company there, we have got a fertilizer
company, a chemical company, and almost any other kind

of a company; and when the combined products from dll of

those companies settle on an insulator, you may have to take
it down and take it. into your shop if vou want to keep it
clean.
We have found that we can clean them very rapidly with
a.form of chemical that we heat, just dip them in and it
takes the refuse right ‘off. We replace them with uew ones
on the line, and put these back in stock.

That is one of the methods that we have developed which
has prevented a large number of serious outages.

Q). You have spoken of patyolmen who, in a sense, police
these lines. Are they stationed at many points along the
transmission lines? A. Yess I didn’t go inte any detail us
to their operations. We ustiglly try to pick a patrolman who
istoarried, and see tliat he is fixed up in a residence located
at a Strategic point along the system. A telephone will be

RS . —2,802—
placed in his home, and in addition to that, telephone bootlis
will be located atintervals along he line.

\
‘
p.,” SS

2189
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

There are certain points at which the patrolmen can al-
ways go and get in contact with one of our main stations,
from which all forms of‘communication are available to the
system load dispatcher. So that we have even gone so far
that the transmission line superintendent haz a radio re-
ceiver in his car, which will receive communications: from
the transmission line when the carrier current is in opera-
tion. These patrolmen have regular duties, to make regular
patrols, im addition to which they are sent out on special
patrols and do minor maintenance work such as can be ac-
complished by two of those men meeting at a point, and fix-
ing up small repairs. If it is anything of any major conse-
quence, they will call for help.

Right-of-way clearing and road maintenance, and other
work requiring unskilled labor—the patrolman is authorized
in such instance, within limits, to hire outside help, common
labor, and he reports the work done and the hours, worked.
Il¢ aJso does some clearing at various times himself.

They report by telephone to the system operator at regu-

lar intervals each day, and submit daily written reports to.

the line department. From these reports and those made-at

the time of the climbing inspections, maintenance work re-
quiring line crews is scheduled, and the werk carried out.

: Saccd —2,803—

Store houses are provided at intervals along these lines,

and in those are stored tools and supply materials. We also

locate, at certain peints, spare poles, if it is a wood pole

structure, and° we carry certain spare tower parts in stock
at Rivermines. We have discontinued, several vears ago, the

practice of trying’to keep spare towers. The reason for that

6565

6566

6567

6568

6569

6570

2190 4 es
Stanley Stokes—By sates hae

is that there are so many types of towers, sO many varieties,
that you, no maiter how many spares you had, probably

_wouldn’t have the one that you needed, and it wouldn't be

close tothe point where you needed it. If it weré the one you
needed, and were right at the point where you needed it, yeu
still couldn’t use it, because our experience has shown that
where a tower fails—and that is very, very rarely, once ina
matter ofgnaybe 20 years—the footings will be damaged, and
you don’t know to what extent, and you do not dare to use
them. Consequently, your first maintenance emergency work

is to put up a temporary wood pole structure, and restore
service quickly. Once the service has been restored, you might

just as well wait to get the rest of the tower while you are
getting the few parts.
_So, by some experience, we have decided that the main-»

“tenance of spare towers is not practical. I have experienced

several tornadoes, and there have been one or two towers de-
stroyed for other reasons over the 25 or 30 years, and in every —
case we restored service quickly by setting up temporary

; 3 —2,804—
wood pole structures, and rebuilt the towers later.. So that

_ is our present practice.

Q. In the proper maintenance of these lines, do you get
the cooperition of landowners in the territory covered by the
transmission line? A. We not only get the cooperation of
the landowners, but we go farther than that. We know the

methods that were used in the early days by right-of-way

people, who would get rights-of-way on a contract basis, and
then would not have to live with the lines afterward.

In the old days it wasn’t uncommon for these,right-of-way
nen to promise that immediately after the transmission line,

/ gators 2191 a.
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

there would be an electric railway follow, and when the
power company went out to maintain and operate this line,
they met with a very cool reception. Well, we, having*to live
with these lines, see to it that from the time negotiations be-
gin, to acquire rights-of-way, that no enemies are made.

If we can accommodate these farmers by: letting them
farm a little of the right-of-way, with crops that don’t grow
high enough to do any damage, it works out very well, and
helps keep the weeds down, and keeps them satisfied.

So we start, from the time the contracts are first entered

into for the right-of-way easements or purchase, and see to

it that these contracts provide for some damages to fences,
and any other type of damage, crop damage or anything, so
| : —2,805—
that the first time that the wire stringing crew goes right
through there with a caterpillar and goes through the fence,
the farmer is satisfied that he will get paid for that, that
there will be no loss there. He may even get a better fence.
- ‘There is no trouble, and there is n8 more of this meeting you
at the edge of the lot with a shotgun.
If we have easements where a transmission line is under

6573

construction, we recognize that the owner is entitled to com-

plete his crop, and that that doesn’t go with the easement.
And we either see to it that he can, or pay him for it.

Now when it comes to operating the lines, these farmers
are of great assistance to us. They report trouble. If a man
sees a flash at some time, he will go to the phone and call in.
If that turns out to be a case of trouble on our system, and
has been of help ‘to us, we will give him some form of nominal
payment, anything from a-dollar to ten dollars, depending

-

2192
B574 S tanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

on how uch trouble he went hb: and you would be surprised |
how much trouble they will 5a | to for a dollar.

So it has proved to be very deneficial. We hire them also
for right-of-way clearance. That is another point. A farmer
at certain times of the year has no work that he can really
‘do. efliciently on the farm. At other times he has more than

_ he can.do. In the slack periods he is very glad to get a little
extra money, and we hire him to do the right-of-way work.
een 2,806—_
6575 Fence and creek crossings are prov ided, so that our
regular patrolmen that have to go through regularly, can get

along without damage and without delay.

Drainage ditches along the line are kept open to prevent
flooding, and to prevent land erosion, and that is of assistance
not only to ourselves byt to the farmer. Keoads and trails

~ are maintained. om ne s
So that, in general, we niake extra efforts to ay the
- cooperation through these many miles of transmission line,
bec ause we have found by experience that it is profitable to
do se, and an economy to the company. - | 7
6576 Q.._In the construction of these lines, is it frequently «
necessary to cooperate with other utilities? A. Yes, we have
to cooperate with the other power companies and telephone
companies. That has become almost a routine procedure,
and is carried out almost automatically. We both have the
same re quirements to. meet for wire crossings, permits of all
kinds; and there is very ue if any, eae tsy oie in that partic-

uar part of the work.

eeaee ~ ith the’R. E. A. groups, they are not skilled in ee:
in all cases, and they have to make these wire crossings, and
~ they have to make reports to commissions, and in general

2193
Stan ley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

their idea is to. put these Tines up and get all theve little
items straightened out later, and we have found that it is
very beneficial to help them, and at little cost to ourselves,
: —2,807—
and for our own protection, by making wire crossing prints.
If a wire line is going to cross under one of our transmission
lines, we like to know that the clearances are going to be as
stated, and also like to have a complete print and record of
it, and grant this wire company a formal permit.
In order to do this, there is required a standardized
print, engilieering drawing, of the crossing, showing all

clearances, giving a plant and elevation. We have made a °

number of those for some of the Illinois R. E. A. groups, and
that has expedited both their work and saved ourselves con-
siderable delay and annoyance, and they appreciate ‘it.

4). Llow are the sub- ‘transmission circuits operated. and
maintained? A. It is the duty of the overhead and under-
ground divisions of the operating departments, located a
ales throughout’ the Union Electri¢ Group, to

operate tind maintain the distribution sub-stations, trans-

mission sub-stations, and to carry on certain construction

work, — ‘ ete

The operation includes inspéctivn, switching, except in
‘the plants or sub-stations¢ location of trouble; emergency
minor repairs and re placements,

The ieee ae the work Tequiring wregie of
‘men, and consists of pole ‘and tower eplacement, “ |

Maintenance includes the clearing, ¢able repairs, “replace:

~ nent; andsaH-ether such work which is not penis as new
—2,808—

construction. yr

6577

6580

6581

6582

2194
Stanley Stokes—-By Respondents—Direct

The major portien of the sub-transmission system was
built by the Union Electric’s own men, installed from time
to time, and they maintain the system.

Q. Are: maintenance groups distributed throughout the
territory? A. They are. That is a matter of importance to-
see that these repair and maintenance groups are strategi-
eally located so that minimum delay is had in case they are
called ujy:on to handle any trouble work, and also to minimize
their mileage, the mileage which they have to cover in their
ordinary routine work. |

The largest greups are located at Webster Groves, East
St. Louis, and Alton, Illinois, and at Keokuk, lowa. ss

To facilitate handling of the sub-transmission circuits,
they haye materials and supplies and equipment maintained
at these locations in a quantity sufficient for any emergency
which may arise. We have even had, as you recall in respect
to our main transmission: system, tornadoes, and we had

‘ample material to repair the damage.

Q. And is it, or is it not, true that in the maintenance of
the sub-transmission system as well, the testing of under-
ground cable, and electrolytic testing, and dielectric testing
is made? A. I fail to quite get the question.

| —2,809--

(The question was read by the reporter.)

The Witness: There is a joint coordination of all
of this work. The general supervision heads up in the
load dispatchér, and in the system operators, and they
are in constant communication with all of the differ-
ent sub-divided groups, and in the event that a line

2195
- Colloquy

were being maintained, and should be required sud-
denly for service due to the failure of some other
facility, the load dispatekes, through his operators,
ean contact, through this communication equipment
which has heen described, this maintenance crew and
get that line into service before it. had been anticipated.

Those things are all necessary if we want to make
the fullest use of our reserve facilities. The line would
not have been taken out of service without the permis-
sion of the lor’ dispatcher group, to begin with. The
special telephone facilities are maintained between
these operating groups and the load dispatcher and
the system operators, and those facilities are in addi-
tion to the main telephone facilities which I have previ-
ously described. |

These facilities also are employed in connection
with the safety work, such as placing hold-otf tags on
equipment upon which work is to’ be done, and to
restore the equipment to service. |

Much time can be unnecessarily lost in taking a
circuit out of service and getting it back again if

communication and an orderly, systematic group of...

—2,810—
men have not been provided. We feel that we operate
that feature very carefully.

The dielectric tests of underground cable are made
with a high voltage Kenotron equipment. This js a
vacuum tube high voltage device, which can produce
around 150,000 volts of direct current, and we take
the cable out of service and .apply this voltage, and

6583

6584 -

6586

6587

2196

Colloquy

gradually raise it until the test specifications which
the cable is supposed to meet, have been reached. For
example, take a 13,800-volt cable which is scheduled
to be tested at 26,000 volts. This machine gradually
raises the voltage to 26,000, and holds it there for a
predetermined time. If the cable fails before we get
to 26,000, that is what we wanted to know. It needed
repairs.

So we have periodically tested all of our cables,
and the results of these testings usually are confined
to the cable joints, they seem to depreciate, or maybe
they never were made right in the early days. Wher-
ever we can blow up a cable joint in tests, we feel that
we have saved one failure in service. As soon as the

cable fails in a test, we repair it completely and test

it again, and when it finally will withstand this test, |
we know that it has withstood a voltage about twice as
high as it will receive in service. oe |
We have rather elaborate equipment for locating
faults-in cables. . I won't go into that in particular
detail, but we have a " Wheatstone bridge, which is a
means of measuring resistance, and from that we
7 ey —2,811—-
locate the probable fault within.a block or two. Then
we go out with what is Knownas_a Lundin fault ana-
lyzer, and having put an alternating current waye with
a very saw-toothed type of wave on the cable, we just
go along with this exploring coil of this Lundin ana-
lyzer, walk right along the top of the ground, and find

_the point at which the fault is located. We can get

2197

Colloquy Pes 6589

a

that within a matter of feet, and then we know. right

where to go to work and pull out the damaged links.
Temperature surveys, I have previously mentioned,

and also the chemical erosion and the electrolysis.
The Examiner: We will recess until 2 o’clock.

(Whereupon, at 12:35 o’clock p. m., a recess
was taken unti! 2 o'clock p. m., of the same day.)
—2,812—

e

6590

_—

—- 6591

6592

6593

6594

2198
Stanley Stokes—-By Respondents— Direct

AFTERNOON SESSION
(The hearing was resumed at 2 o’clock p. m,)

The Examiner: Let us resume.

. Whereupon, STANLEY STOKES resumed the stand and tes-

°

tified further us follows:

Direct Rramination by Mr. Browning (Continued) :
Cc

Q: J ust before the noon recess, Mr. Stokes, vou had been
describing the ‘operation and maintenance of the transmis-
sions systems. Could you now teil us briefly about the
maintenance of the distribution system? A, Yes, the distri-
bution system “Gn the Union Elecfric group 4s under the
jurisdiction of a distribution department in each operating
division. ~ ;

Distribution, as we classify it, is the operation, mainte
nance, and construction of the lower voltage ‘distribution

circuits. In most cases these are 2,300/4,000 volt cire nits.

The necessity for close contact with. this system, and-
the volume of work that is entitled in the distribution sy stem,
requires that each system have its own organization.

They all function in conjunction with the main organiza-
tion in the city who supervises the general design and the
majoi features. All of the organizations are on, exactly the

_ Same gfneral, pattern, and I shall describe the St. Louis City

‘ ‘ -—2.813— "
Division which will, to a large vextent, typify the ot!

smaller ones.
The St. Louis distribution wyiten was previously stated
to represent about one-fourth of the invest ment in the system.

2199

Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct 6595,

‘When I say “St. Louis distribution system” in this case,
that is not altogether definitive. I should say the distribu-.
tion system of the Union Electric group that represents
about one-fourth of the total investment in the system. And
it is readily observed that that must constitute a huge
quantity of poles, on, meters, transformers and other
associated equipment ‘ 5
~~ AN parts of the system, of all voltages, outside of the
pow er plants—I am referring specifically now to the distri-
bution system—are under the jurisdiction of a distribution 6596
division. . The functions of the ‘division include, first, de-
sign, engineering / design, field survers, estimating, and
preparation of. specification® are carried out by copperative
consultation with related de partments such asith¢ electrical
power plants, and consultiag electric al lengineeting depart-
ments. By that I mean, te convey that the distribution /
‘department does their own specific engineering and does not
require advice on the duy ‘to-day fynetioning of dither design,
Inaintenance, or operation, but that; freq ye ntly the problem
in the ‘yhtribation/ departinent ovetlaps and extends into
other dfvisions, ji which case they are required to consult 6597
att the other Alepartments® “and Optain advice.
! ) —2,814—
A simple illustraYion ‘of that is a ‘cable from a power
plant to a sub-station is in the sub-transmission group as owe
Shave defined it, and yet, because the distribution departme nt
had thee able men uader their supervision, they would install
that cathe and instal! the duct and they would repair it if it
got in trouble. That is beeause it is necessary io maintain
4 large cable department in the distribution system, and we

6598 N Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

6599

6600

as ‘\
‘
=

ped 111)

\

donot dhplicate it for the substransmission system, that is
the cable group is really the same.

So that if ascable were to be instailed, one end of it at
the power plant inXolves an oil switch and a transformer, the
other end involves a transformer and a substation. The sub-
station involves outgoing distribution feeders. It is obvious,
therefore, that if additional facilities are required at a sub-
station; that the responsibilities and authorities of at least
three departments would become involved. In other words,
whenever a facility has to be added or changed.that extends
beyond the distribution system, they sometimes do not have
full responsibility for that. But they do do all of their own
engineering, design and operation within the striet scope of
the distribution department and may extend, by joint epera-
tion with other departments, into some of the other work.

Construction involves the installation of overhead cir-
cuits on pole lines, underground cables, in conduits, or buried

—2,815—
direct in the ground with proper protection ; submarine cables
laid across the Mississippi River for sub-transmission and
supply circuits to-the distribution stations.

/

Operation invol¥es emergency repairs, switching of cir-
cuits, switching out of circuits for reserve or for repair work;
and the handling of circuits in emergency.

Operations also involve meter testing and periodic surveys
of voltage conditions.

At this point I wish to explain that the same functions
have to be performed in the distribution system as oceur in
the sub-transmission svstem, such as voltage surveys, corro-

sion of eable sheaths, electrolysis, and such matters.

2201 -

seid Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

When I discuss these items which have been previously
sieched on in the other divisions, I shall attempt to be as
brief as possible. pate

In the operations—the meter testing, as such, which is
strictly a part of the distribution department operation, is
carried out in the meter division, which itself is under the
supervision of the power planis Cepartment.

As previously discussed, the sub-transmission circuits are
handled and operated under the direction of the system load
dispatcher, but the distribution department is directly in-
volved in many of these operations, and it keeps in close touch
with the load dispatcher.

Maintenance of the distri. ution system guest the re-

| 2,816—
placement | or repair of all parts of the system for whose
operation that department is responsible. That is largely
poles, wires, cables, conduits, services and many other items.

Iv the district outside of St. Louis, outside of the St.
Louis area , these same functions are carried on but are in
hany instances combined with some other group for economy
reasons.

in St. Louis County, the operation of the distribution
system is’earried on in conjun¢tion with the operation of the
St. Louis County Gas Company. That company was men-
tioned only once, I believe, at the beginr.‘ag of this hearing,
and described.

The St. Louis County Gas Company

(). (interposing) I don’t believe we‘need to go into the
gas campany at this time. A. { merely intended to men.ion
that they worked with the distribution department and to
that extent were a little different than the city group.

6601

6602

6603

6604

6605)

6606

| 2202
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct

In the Iowa Union Electric Company, the operations up
there are carried on as economically as possible in conjune-
tion with their local requirements for that gas company in
that district.

And in every respect they attempt to utilize their facil.
ties to the greatest advantage in the interests of economy.
Q. Is the organization set up functionally? .

customers are obtaining. We have to watch the high voltage
in close to the sub-station, at times of light loads, and low
voltage at. the extreme end of the circuit at times of heavy
lead, and to see that this variation is not greater than the
prescribed limit. .

A chief clerk supervises the performance of all of the
clerical fatictions which, can be reduced to a rougine.

The superintendent of records maintains the system dia-
gram, plat records of all properties, has charge of the permit
/and easement files and directs a limited amount of drafting
work for the departme |

lu St. Louis Coun y, the general handhng of the distri-
bution system is very fi
In ihe distribution department there are a large number
of employees. It is one of the largest single divisions of the
entire company. f won’t attempt to go into particular de-
fails with respect to these employees, but I would like to
mention just a few of aid types, and I will illustrate the
number of men. ‘ -
Supervisors in St. Louis city—there are 12; in St. Louis
County and outlying plants—9; in Illinois, 7; in lowa—2.
In all there are 30 supervisors.
In a similar manner there are 34 engineers, 28 estimators
—2,819—

tain that all of their customers are receiving suitable and

6607

6608

6609

6814

6815

6S16

”
erepm rd

ww tea
Stanley Stokev---Cy Respondents—Direct

But inasmuch as the puswhasing department is carryis.
on the complete fuartions for tie time the order is placed,
until the material is received, we send this man there under
their direction, and the whole process is therefore Kept in

s

; ——2 S97--
one croup, and under ane general control, It is working out
very nicely,

As an example of sojae of these facilities, recent emer-
geney requirements of wire for both Towa Union Electric
Company and the St. Lonis x Belleville Electric Railway
Company, were obtained to their advantage, kurgely dueeto
the broader contacts whi i the electrical buyer is able to
maintain by virtue of the large volume of these products
purchased for the group. Also, in the coustruetion of a new
freight office boiidiae for the St. Louis & Belleville Electrie
Railway Company, the department functioned not oniv to
obtain the best pid, but also to assist the railway conipany
materially in analyzing the proposals, cogether with the
ability of the various contractors to best meet the require
ments of the user, Tn othe words, the Belleville Campany
makes very few contracts, dat will be the oniy one of that
kind that it wili make for the vear. And the larger group
are nuiking contracts right atone, vied they know the ability
of these various contractors to do tne work,

The department functioned to, be of assistunce to the
Union Electric Company of Lilinois im the shipment of some
large transformers whieh were urgently required. The traf:
fie clerks’ handling of transportation and expeditang, re-
sulted in a net saving of one week's time ine f

2

ing the
’

equipment into service,

oe
—2,898—

ooeem ed

a
Stanley Ntolkes —By Re spondents——Direct
‘This transportation problem required spechilized han-
(ing because of certain clearance difficulties, They were
too big to be shipped by ordinary route and by makipg a
earefnl study, they saved that much tinse.

The avidlabilitw of engineering buyers has been men-
tioned and that again is of consideraile importance. — I
wont stress that any further, but we liave made three trips
hack to the factory for the purchasing devartment in the
last six months, and in eaeli case picked up a number of
changes required in che equipment just before shipment, any
one of Which would have more than paid the cost of these
trips. |

Ii has the further advatituee that the eneineer who sees
the equipanen. af the plant all assembled is ia position to
assist the local construction forces when it is received,

Some of this new equipment, pariicularly in air circuit
breakers, has changed in its coliploxion so rapidly that the
iin Whe hasm’t put in anys for a vear, doesnt recognize the
stulf when he sees it. To mean the previous switches which
he would have received would be ou: circuit breakers,

(). Does the operation of a centralized purchasing depart-
ment result in obtaining low unit prices? A. These activi-
ties, such as those cited, do resulé in low prices. The most
obviows are reductions brought abour by the purchasing of
larger quantities with larger discounts, the coordination of
standards, net only as between the various operating units,

—-2,899-
bur with industry standards, and manufacturing standards,
Which contributes to lower prices hy the avoidance of spe-
ciai runs, as well as by taking advantage of inereased quan-
tities,

OS17

6S1S

GOST

“y;' ses
6820 Stanley Stokes-—By. Respondents—Dhirect

The broader contacts of a specialized buying greup per
mit more intelligent appraisal of price levels, and a better
timing of purcbases, all of which contribute to lower first
cost.

I would like to cite just a few examples, and make it as
brief as IT can, of this type of economy,

Take jine wire, and service cable. Normal requirements
of line wire for the lowa Union Electric Company will run
only about 25,000 pounds annually. Purchasing in a central-

6821 ized deparviment takes advantage of better market timing,
and based on quantities which are never less than 100,000
pounds, results in marked savings to that subsidiary.

In connection with the recent change-over from 25 to
60 cveles at Fort) Madison, the Lowa Union Electric Com-
pany required 143,600 pounds of bare and weather-proof
Wire, whieh were furnished on contracts made by Union Elec:
tric of Missouri, prior to and in anticipation of the market
rise in the fall of 1939. ‘These contracts w: made with
copper at 1014 cents, which wire, when released to them, was
taken with copper at 1114 cents, and resulted in a saving
fron, three-quarters to one cent a pound.

—2, 906

The same is true of Union Electric Company of Illinois,
and to a lesser degree of the Lakeside Light & Pawer Com-
pany.

The requirements of service cable for these subsidiaries
follow much the same pattern, Unit prices that they would
obtain, being based on a minmum of 50,000 feet on central-
ized purchasing, Whereas their possible maximum would only

he JO.000 feet in any one order.

oo

eases 60)
Stanley Stokes— Buy Rs spondents—Direct

Heavy underground cables for the transmission system,
and special rubber insulated cables, are used largely in the
St. Louis metropolitan area. THowever, such cables are occa-
sionally required by Union Electric of Hlinois, and frequently
hy some other subsidiaries, such as Union Colliery Company,
and the St. Louis and Belleville Railway Company. For
example, Union Colliery Company uses large quantities of
rubber insulated machinery cable. In the last few months,
we purchased, from the centralized division, 15,000 feet of
this cable at substantial savings.

A recent order for transmission cable for Union Electric
Company of Plinois ameunting to approximately $100,000,
was bought at 6 per cent. below the level which would have
heen paid by them bad it not been grouped with the other
COnTrUCTS.

On watt-hour meters, a quontity discount of 6 per cent.
is ohinined dne te the large quantity which the Union Elee-
tric Company buys. Tt is doubtful if any of the subsidiary
companies contd earn any quantity discounts at all, with the

——2,901—

possible exception of Union Electric Company ef Illinois,
Which would earn a maximum of 3 per cent,

The purchase of lime hardware, and line specialties, in
the quantities invelved for the whole group, is consistently
lade at price levels ranging from o per cent. to Lo per cent.
tider comparable prices if each individual unit were to make
its own purchases.

(). T think vou have illustrated sufficient? the poing you

Were making,

6823

ss)" &

6826 Stan ey Stokes--By Respondents— Direct

In the operations department. is it necessary te eniploy
a salvage salesman to dispose of salvaged material? A. Yes,
the purchasing department employs a full-time salvage sales-
man. That is really a pretty good sized business, and he
sells everything from the scrap materials to machinery,
When von finish a large job, vou dOnt try to carry over
machinery for many years, you sell it and buy it again if
you need i}, So that when the Osage project was completed,
there was a large amount of machiners on hand which had
6827 to be disposed of, and as a regular process we burn the in-
sulation off of old wire and sirip the lead off of cables, and
reduce it to serap copper or scrap lead, or scrap of other
kinds. We do some salvage too, *s which some of thift stuff
Which is in pretty good condition is repaired and put back,
into service.

The snosidiaries’ scrap are ail accumulated into the cen-

—2,902—
tral warehouse, and all handled at one time. We get from
half a cent to a cent a pound more by getting it all in one
group that way, than the sinall conipianies would for their
small quantities,
* The Examiner: Let us have a short recess

(Wherenpon, 2 short recess was taken, after
Which the hearine was resumed. )
The Exuminer: Let us resume.
The Witness: T merely want to illustrate the mag-
nitude of the scrap transactions. A single transac:
tion recently involved the sale of over a million and a

quarter pounds of accumulated scrap wire, and ihe

om—itt
Ntanle y Ntokes- By Re spondents—Direct

other surplus in serap represents abeut Si0,000 a

vear, or something on that order of magnitude.

by Mr. Hiamilion:

Q. Does the operation of the departinent involve the
study of the appleability of various sales tax statutes? A.
Yes, the matter of properly contracting for, delivering and
applying equipment, requires, these days, that some reason-
able study be given to the matter of sales taxes and other
features. This is Something of Uunportance. For example,
one individual purchase transaction made during the past
several months has involved the question as to the proper
applicability of taxes in amounts ranging from £2,000 on one
item to S27,000 on another. In other words, by a certain
| —2,903—
process of buying and shipping. von can resolve what ap-
pours to be ap interstate commerce transaction into a mere
intrasiate transaction, in which the combination of cirenm-
stinees Inieht require you to pay sales taxes, and if the same
temmsaction is handled in some other manner, only slightly
different, it does not require vou toe pay ary,

(). Without going into detail, will you give us very
brietly the general pattern of the Operation im your ware-
houses and storerooms, which d understand from your previ
ous testimonv—in which vou huve to some extent loeated
the physical facilities. —-is an item of substantial importance
iy the operations of the system? OA. Yes, the various store
roolus and the handling of material are one of the major
iteiys of the company’s business, Lam trying to condense

and reduce my remarks on this, to a very minimum, but I

6830

G83

G3

6835

6834

sro

newede wits ~Pdire ct

Stanley Stokes —By Res;

must mention the central stores office, whieh is a clearing
house and a control center for all the stores operations,
and there is where the general stack records are kept, and
the headquarters of the general storekeeper and his assist
ants. It is a pretty large department. I know there are
some do or 40 clerks there in the one room, just by observa:
Ytion, and the utility shops and other facilities there.

Tie particular location of this general storeroom is at
th and Gratiot Streets, and at that point they have just

—2.904—

/ recently constructed another large material handling area,

with modern facilities,
—? J—

In addition to the stock record, it is the function of this
office to see that the minimum quantities of stock are at all
times on hand, and replenish the stocks as fast as the minima
are reached, and to see to it that the previously set maximum
amounts are not exceeded,

Q. You might give us, if vou will, the number of em-
ployes who devote (heir time to this particular phase of
operation, and alse the extent of the transactions handled.
A. There are six store rooms located at six of the power
plants, and quite a number of other individual points at
Which material is distributed, in addition to which this same
stores department serves the properties in both Missouri and
Hineis.

The number of emploves for the past vear, or at some
point toward the end of the vear, amounted to 181 at the

time this count was made..

mam te
Stuntey Stokes By Respondents—Direct

They inetude two emploves at the store room of the Mis-
sissippt Power Company and one at the Tewa Union Elee-
tric Company.

In the operation of the stores department facilities, some
200 different items of material ave stock, the averuge value
being about two million. Abeut $50,000 items are received,
aid TO0,000 disbursed annually, The approximate value
of the net annual issues of materia! is three and one-half
million dollars.

Eexeluding tuel and other items which do not pass through
the accounts of the stores department, 825 railroad cars of
niaieriais are unloaded annually, and a further large quan-
tity of materials received by t

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386405_0033%3A06. Public record. Not legal advice.
