# Transcript of Record — North Carolina v. United States

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386404_0176%3A01

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1945
- **Citation:** 325 U.S. 507

## Text

x

| STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA, NORTH CAROLINA

INC.,, ET Ai... APPELLANTS,
“Us.

THE UN ITED STATES.OF AMERICA, INTERSTATE
_- COMMERCE. COMMISSION, ABERDEEN AND
ge ROCKFISH RAILROAD CO., ET AL.

‘No.. 561.

ISTRATOR, APPELLANTS, Px.

.

Sa. ~ | Deee
; THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, INTERSTATE
_ COMMERCE COMMISSION, ABERDEEN AND
ROCKFISH ‘RAILROAD CO.,. ET AL. .

te

—

THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF wirarteres CAROLINA

a
¢

” f {>

INDEX

Original Print
Record from D. C. U. S., Eastern. District of. North C ‘arolina 7
Summons and service... :..(omitted in printing).
Petition...”

rs ote Fee
ie

Appendices: ; {
Supplemental wnat and ofder of North © lina
’ Utilities Commission in Docket No. 2789, May
rw : ; ae. as 24
Affidavit of Frank A. Dow ning. : 32 2s
Affidavit of H. M. Nicholson. iN 37 33

Jupp & DretwEILER (Inc.), Printers, ‘Wasnincrox, D, C.,. January 8, [945.

—5901

"SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES =
OCTOBER TERM, 1944 irae

UTILITIES’ COMMISSION, CHARLOTTE SHIP-
. PERS. AND. MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION,

FRED M. VINSON, ECONOMIC STABILIZATION DI- -
: RECTOR, BY CHESTER BOWLES, PRICE ADMIN-

APPEALS FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE U NITED STATES FOR

ce "No. 560 et

vy
- i 2 : ; _
. -s ff.
ii ey pe INDEX |
liecord from Di C..U: 8.,°Eastern District of North Caro-
lina—Continued Sie ‘Original Print
Petition of Charlotte Shippers & Manyfactrers Association,
-Ine.s for leave to intervene... 38 34 -
Petition of. North Carolina. Division of the Travelers’ Pro- :
tective Association of America, et al., for leave to inter- ; x
WN. Sos co AS oan ee hanes tae annie Pyare ee 35
. Orders granting leave to intervene... .. 2.0... 43 | 36°
——Motion-of Fred M. Vinson, Economi nie Biahiljastion Director, é
_* for leave to ntervene..... a Gea ks We ACD ANE 5c earner ~ 47 37
' ‘Order granting leave to intervene................... wens 49 37
Amended’ complaint’ of Economic Stabilization Director... | 38
Appendix +—Affidavit of Doris S: Whitnack and attached
tables. |... .. Reece DCM E eRe OR eM eS male §.0a0.6'6a te ae 54
Answer of Interstate Gansianés Caishidaiion: ela eats has “85 57.
: Exhibit No. t—Report of Commission i in Docket No. \
| . 28963, ‘March 25, GSR SREASES AES setae: 95 69
* Answer of United States...:............. pat rer eet See
c Amended answer of United States. . Lorrie ene ep a
4 ____ Motion of Railroads of Jeaye to intervene. bey ROE Pile mies —_131_2—107—
Order granting leave to.intervene.:....°............, eee” ee
Answer of intervening Railroads. . Pitti asthe sd aoe eee
Transcript of hearing... Be ais ess cia, ee
Caption and appeariinces............,...--- Sikes 139 110
i ‘ _Colloquy between court and counsel..-......... on hs
FN EES PC ee Ee TT Pe OORT 145 114
- Offer in evidence— Proceedings before Sibinesbati Com-
merce Commission in Docket No. 29036: ... . eye 161 421
Petition on behalf of Railroads operating inthe , er
_ State ee rn ion rae 161. 121
; Appendix 1--List of petitioners............. 170 127
Appendix 2—-Report and order of North Caro-
- lina Utilities Commission in Docket No. . -
‘Sieh, ble 0, 1008.5 fe ID 8
; _ Order instjtuting investigation... ........ .:./. 188.) 4b
Transcript of hearing... . - ere Fearn cates a ee
Caption and appearances.....:. 4,-0.0 ..... 191 143
; etd a To. a eye 206 °° ‘Bi
E. E. Barry. ; 228 ~—.:s«&166.
W. E. Stier. ' 251 180
A T. K. Lynch 257 184 “
T. G. Hanes... .. “265 189
Pe 6 See 283 201.
E. A. Anderson a :
- ; No. t, 1944
z
j
s

‘To eondtitete a 3-judge court, to stay ‘temporatily. enjoin,
permanently enjoin. and set aside an Order of the Inter-
_ state Commerce Commission. :

>To the Honorable J udges of the District Court of the United :

—_" — ry ‘ Roy

‘North Carclkna s Requestfor Additional Data

#137. On or, about. April 8, 1944,. the North Cissling
Utilities Commission requested.tliat the Railroads furnish
certain statistical data for the calendar year 1943, such as
passenger revenue, passenger car-miles and | passenger

_ miles, in deluxe, reserved seat passenger service; and the

Railroads declined to furnish such data on the ground that
it is not ayatiable and could not be compiled. at this time.

North. Casdtian s Petition for Sent ne ‘Hearing.
#1 38. On or about April 26, 1944, the : plorth. Carolina

~,*3*,8

| {fommission ieee t C.C. Docket. No. 290: 6, a petition for
- extension of the 30-day period within whicl’ to adjust cer-
tain intrastate fares; for further hearing to receive sup- °

- plemental statisticaFevidence; and for modification of -cer-

tain findings in tlie Interstate Commerce Commission's

_Report/of March : 25, 1944; and for reargument; and for.

reconsideration, on behalf of the North Carolina Utilities
Commission, ‘harlotte Shippers & Manufacturers Associa-~
tion, Ine., and North Carolina Division of the Travelers

Protectiv e Association of America, as joint: complainants
-, and protestants in I. (. C. Docket No. 29036. (115.)"

#139. The said petition of the North Carolina Com-

‘fhission" sets forth with particularity numerons specifica-

- evidence at the hearing; and of the arbitre + failure of;

tions of errors of fact; of erroneous findings; of- errone-
ous omission of certain specifie findings which had -been re-
quested by the North Carolina Utilities Commission and
other joint Protestants; of erronébus: conclusions of fact;

of erroneous conclusions of law; of erroneous rejection of
the ;

interstate Commerce Commission to consi. ler certain/ pr e-
sumptions of‘law founded upon facts of record; all iy sup-

port of its prayers for further hearing to receivg further

. set forth herein in haec verbae.

evidence, for oral: argument; and for reconsideration; as.
set forth in North Carolina’s ‘Petition (2115.), which is
made a part hereof by reference as though the same were.

‘

. s

eo |. aris

|

.

(fol. 12) The amaiatiiiicas’ 8 Order

#140. On May 8, 1944, the ia: Commerce Ona.
mission entered its. Order as corrected ;May 24th, 1944, in
1. @. C. Docket Nos. 28963, 29000, 29036 and 29037, in which

the Railrf ds are notified and required, to cease and desist

on or before July-1, 1944, and thereafter to abstain, from”
practicing the undue prejudice ‘and’ preference and the un-
just discrimination found in said ,report to exist; and noti-
fying and requiring the Railroads to establish, on or before

July 1, 1944, upon.not less than thirty days’ notice, and, .

thereafter to maintain and apply, passenger fares for intra:
state transportation in the respective states which shall be

on bases no lower than the passenger fares presently main-
tained and applied by the respective carriers for: like ac- -

commodations in interstate transportation to, from, and
through*the respective States; provided, that the resulting
aggregate charge made by any of said Railroads for intra-
state transportation in any of the states shall not. excéed
the aggregate charge made for like accommodations and
for a like distance by the samé Railroad. for ‘interstate
transportation to, from or through such state. (#118.)

‘The North Carolina Utilities Commission’s Order Grant-

ing the Increase in Fares. to Weak Lines

~ #141. On or about May 16, 1944, the North Carolina.
Utilities Commission, upon receipt of further evidence in
the proceedjig before it under its Docket 2789, finding that
the passenger operating expenses of the Carolina, ‘Clinch-
field and Ohio Railway and the Norfolk Southern Railway
Company for the years 1942 and 1943 exceeded their ré-
spective passenger revenues for the two respective vears,
issued its Suppleniental Order. grariting the application of
those two Railroads, the C. C. & O. Railway and the N. & S.
Ry., for increases in their intrastate civ ‘ilian coach fares;

- and finding that there is no evidence as to other shorttites;

—amriteaving the original order interlocutory in form as to.

the A. C. L., L. & N., 8. A. L. and Southern Railways.

#141.1. A true copy of said Supplemental Report and
Order of the North Carolina Utilities Commission, dated
May 16, 1944, is attached hereto, and’ marked Appendix

141.1, and by reference made a part Remwot.

4
»

\

; 11
#142. ‘Whierefore, ‘it is now alleg red that the State of
North. Carolina and the North Carolina Utilities Commis-
sion have exhausted their. administrative remedies before
the. Interstate Commerce Commission before instituting
this proceeding for the purpose of staying, temporarily .
enjoining, permanentlySenjoining, and anuulling, vacating
and setting asidé said Report of ‘the Interstate Commerce |
[fol. 13] Commission of March 25, 1944, (#114.)- and Or-
der of May 8, 1944, (#118.) and for such’ other relief -as
may be herein requested and as may- -be Proper in the

premises.
> Grounds of Invalidity of the Commission’ 8 Re ‘port and 4
Order .
~-.-. $6943, Your Petitioners aver that said Re port (#114)

aud Order (#118.), here challenged, violate the provisions
of the Federal Constitution, particularly the Tenth Amend-

_ ment thereto; exceed the power delégated to the Interstate
~ Commerce Commission by the Statute and constitute an
exercise. of power in itself, and inthe manner of its exer-

cise,-so a-bitrary as virtually to transcend the authority.
conferred on said Commission for ‘the following sajd rea:

‘ sons, among others: .

Exhaustion of Remedies el
+144. The Interstate Commerce Commission erred in
' proceeding in said cause No, 29036, and in making its. said
Report (#114.) and entering its Order (#118:) before’
the respondent. carriers therein had: exhausted thr
remedies before the North Carolina Utilities Commission .
in the proceeding initiated by the said carriers in and be-
-fore the North Carolina Commission, in which. proceeding |
the Interloeutory Order: of the North Carolina Utilities
Commission still leaves the door eperto the Railroads with -

the exception of The ( ‘arolina, Clinchfield-rd-Ohio Rail
road and the Norfolk Southern Railway, as t6o- which their
application to the North Caroline U tilities £ ‘ommission |
has been granted by the North Carolina U tilities Commis-
sion’s Supplemental Order. (Appendix 141.1)

Full Hearing Denice d

"#145. The Interstate Commerce ( ommission erred in
, denying to North Carolina the full hearing to Ww neh it and

12 |
: . ”
other parties jomed therewith were’ and are entitled under
the provisions of.Sections 13(1), 13(2), and 15(1) of the

Interstate Commerce Act halen S.C., Title 49), in. the felow- = =

ing particulars, among

145.1. In that the: Interstate Commerce (Saieaaeltaabins
* refused to invéstigate the reasonableness of the interstate
‘coach fares of the Railroads under the changed conditions,
upon the Petition and Complaint of the North Carolina
Utilities Commission, the Alabama Publie Service Com-
' mission, and the Office of Price Administration, all of which

Petitions were filed before the proceeding in I. C. C. No.
29036 was instituted.

(fol. 14] #145.2,- In that the Interstate C ommerce 1 Cont:
mission’s Kxaminer, at the Hearing (+109.), ruled that the
question ‘as to the reasonabletiess of the interstate coach
fares is before the C ‘commission to the extent that it is a
‘burden resting upon, réspondents. to establish ‘that present
interstate fares are not in excess of maximum reasonable’
fares; that that was his understanding ; and that otherwise
it is not in issue’; and that it is not subject to attack,
and that the parties are at liberty to show what facts they.

have and their position on that. particular question (+ 109.,-
tr. 15), thereby precluding the production of any ev islence

by North ¢ ‘arolina as to that issue..

145.3. In that: said Examiner overruled at: the- Hearing
~ (#109.)-and denied North Carolina’s request for oppor-
tunity to file Reply Briefs: (+109... tr. 243), even though .in
such cases where no proposed report, was to be issued, the
filing of Reply Brief is petinitted by Rule 93 of the Com-
mission:’s Rules of Practice.

~

————

s

:
13

4

#145,4. In that said Commission denied North ( Cutelians ;

Petition. for Further Hearing, ete. (#115.) _

’ The Reasonableness of the Interstate. Fares

+146. The Interstate Commerce Commission erred asa.
matter of law in making the finding that the interstate coach

fares are just and reasonable in that:the Commission had
denied the Petition of the North Carolina Commission, the
Aiabama Commission and the Price. Administrator seeking
an investigation into-the reasqnableness of such interstate

coach farés; and in that the Examiner at the hearing ‘ruled.

.

that the. interstate coach fares were not in issue.

e- “~ rd
> ‘ °

. .
. Coy

— ee

at Cag ee

» «6 .
. * . . . >
“ . a . 4 3 S F
a. . = ! ¢ - . . . s : a
’ bad . ‘

+147. The said Commission erted as a yiatter.of law in
failing and refusing -to find, as specifieally requested by

‘the coach ‘fare of 1.5 cents per passenger per mile, prior to
‘the 10% increase, having been found not unreasonable of

* mission in Passenger Fares and: Surcharges, 214 1..C. C.
174 in 1936, and the said fare of 1.5 cents ‘Traving beriefited
_the Railroads by increasing the amount of: travel in passen-
“ger coaches over’ their respestive lines of railroad. during

heavily upon the. Railroads to justify. their petition to the
_ Interstate ‘Commerce Commission for authority to increase
[fol.15] their intrastate coach fares from .1.65 ‘cents
to 2.2 cents, during - ‘times ‘of: war preqpetity for the ‘Rail-
roads. (#115.) ~°-. :

+148. The said C ommission erred ; as‘a error of law in
basing its finding as to the reasonableness of the mterstate
* fare of 2.2 cents and. its’ finding that the intrastate fare of

of the ‘one interstate fare, which the said Commission had
‘authorized, under pre-war conditions, with the intrastate
fare, which the said Commission also approved as not un-
reasonable under pre-war conditions ; and thes aid Commis-
- sion erred in not heeding the principle of jaw which was
-enuneiated in Florida v. United States, 282 U. 8. 194, 212,
and which was invoked by North.Carolina in its Brief at

to 18, that a showing of: the mere difference between partic:
ular rates on interstate and intrastate traffic is not suffi-
cient. “

+149. The said Camtidanlets erred as a pore of law in
arriving at its findings that the interstate coach fare is yttxt
—and-rensonabie and that the intrastate. coach fare is sub-
sae in taking into consideration’ the evidence and its

curred by the Railroads in. the- movement of troop trains,
compensation’ for which is pot regulated by the North Caro-

fully be charged or.added in determining the reasonableness
of fares for civilian travel in coaches. ( #115.)

2

_ #150. The said Commission erred as a matter of law in
basing its findings as to the reasonableness of the intrastate

| __ Nerth- Carolina at pages 6-to 12 of* its: Brief (#112), that .

otherwise unlawful by the said Interstate C ommerce Com- °

times of economic depression, the burden of proof rested

1.65 cents was ‘subnortia! solely upon a mere comparison

page 30, and in its Petition for Reconsideration at pages 15.

‘findings with respect to the unusually high expenses In- -

lina Commission, and the added costs of which cannot law: 2

33

3 fares upon.the faet that the puibienda have expended ——

sums of money in providing air-canditioned deluxe coaches,
and Diesel locomotives for streamlined trains? whereas the

‘uncontradicted evidence shows that ‘the North Carolina

intrastate coach travelers are practically excluded from the
use- of the expensive, deluxe, comfortable, reserved seat
coaches on fast streamlined trains; and°the Commission’s

‘action was arbitrary in.failing @nd‘refusing to find, as _re-

quested by North Carolina, that no. part of the added ex-
pense of, or the investment in, the deluxe coaches on stream-
lined trains -is chargeable to North Carolina’s intrastate

travelers who must ride in. over-crowded and antiquated

non- reserved seat coaches.

. —

Eas .
[fol. 16] #151. The said C ‘ommission-erred as a matter of

~ law in finding and considering the finding that all trains in’
each of the States are available to and-are used’ by both —

interstate and intrastate passengers, which finding i is with-
out evidence to support it; and which finding is contrary to
undisputed evidence that there are restrictions against the
use of deluxe, strea.nlined, reserved: seat coaches and trains
by North Carolina intrastate. travelers ‘so that aimost. no
intrastate travelers in North Carolina can use such trains. .
( #115.) .

43152. The said Commission made no ) finding that said
inftrastate fire is non-compensatory, which finding is an
essential prerequisite to the making of a valid order of the
character herein attempted to be made .by the Commission, |
and which ‘finding cannot be made-upon ev idence that was
vbefore it.

#153. The: said C omnrission erred as a matter of law. in
making the finding that the North Carolina reves —

—fare-of 1.63-cents-shewtd beinercaséedto the i

a

‘of 2.2 cents, in that there was ho evidence bafore it which
, would justify such finding, and the Commission made no
finding, aid there was no evidence, that the intrastate fare
of 1 .65 éents is unreasonably low to the extent that it is less
than the interstate fare of 2.2 cents. ys A

#154. The said Commission’ s action was arbitrary in .
failing to find and failing fo take into consideration, as re- ’
quested by North Carolina, the fact that the intrastate fare -
of 1.65 cents had been specifically approved by it-during
time of nationwide depression as being at unreasonable or

otherwise unlawful, and’ that the Lgvdiin of inna was upon _
the carriers to justify a proposed increase under changed .
conditions during. war times of increased travel ‘and traffic :
and greatly in¢reased net revenues from railway operations. ~

‘ #155. The said Commission’ S. action was arbitrary -in
failing to take into consideration and failing to find, fis: Ss: spe-
cifically requested by North Carolina, that, the burden being
upon the Railroads, their failure to shaw the relation of their
proposed intrastate fares per passenger mile in coaches
to their expenses per passenger mile in coaches iis evidence

of the strongest character against them; and that under
- existing conditions such intrastate fares are unreasonably _
high in comparison. with their expénses per passenger mile Sie oF
[fol. 17) i in coaches. (3112. and #115.) - cay aotat

#156. The said Commission’s action was whiny in
denying North Carolina’s Petition for Further Hearing to:
preduce evidence, which was before the said Commission,
that the number of passengers has increased much more

_ greatly in non-reserved seat coaches than in.deluxe re- °.
‘served seat coaches afd parlor and sleeping ¢ars during | -
the war vears,; and that the existing intrastate coach fares
-vield more than the expenses including fair return on value;
‘in proof whereof North Carolina hereby -tenders the affi-~
davit of Frank A. Downing, Rate Specialist for the North — ;
Carolina Utilities- Commission, vthich is attached bereto
and marked Appendix 156.1 and made a part hereof by ref-
erence, which shows the average expenses of the A. CG Ll.
L. & N., S. A. L., and Southern per ‘coach passenger were
0,97 cent per mile in 1942, and 0.91 cent: per mile in 1943,
and that their average passenger operating ratios were .
62.55 i in 1942 and 51.84% in 1943, and that their return on

heek—inrrestment, betore Federal income taxes, averaged
14.23% in 1942 and 18.07% in-1943; and that the combined
freight and passenger operating ratios of the -said four

lines, respectively, yn 1948 were higher than their aver-

age passenger ‘operating @atios in 1943, and that the said .
carriers” existing fares yield them more than the fair \
return to which they are entitled.

#157: The Interstate Commerce Coinmission. eenatatly ai
“and arbitrarily set forth in its: Report certain ‘statistical
facts, particularly for the atypical month of December, — .
1943, as to the operating incomes of the Railroads, which ‘

r
.

16 Sis

noone

were sevelved, incorrect, and erroneous, and whith gave rise _
to erroneous deductions and inferences , particularly in find- .
ing that certain nét railway operating income had steadily

declined from a deficit ; whereas, i in fact, the said net: rail-

Way operating income was a high profit; and ‘that the action

of the said Commission in taking such statistics into con- .

sideration was arbitrary; and that the said Commission’ s

action in denying North Carolina’s Petition for further

hearing to present supplementary statistical evidence, par-
ticularly for the complete year 1943 and those for the latest

‘ available months of the year 1944, so as to clarify and com-

plement the ineompiete and confusing statistics which the

said Commission. incorporated.in its Report, and so as to
: rebut the inferences, drawn therefrom by the said Commis-
sion was arbitrary.; in proof whereof North Carolina refers
[fol. 18] to the ‘Affidavit of. Frank A. Downing attached .

hereto and marked Appendix 156.1, “which shows ‘that the
net revenues from railway operations in the year 1943 were

greater than in 1942; and which further shows that the net.

railway operating income of the claSs one carriers in the |
southern region for the months of Jar ary, Febraary and:

March, 1944, respectively, was greater than ‘their net rail-

way operating income for the atypical-month of December,
1943 ;-and that the nionth of December, 1943, does not truly
represent that the trend of railroad earnings is downward.

» #158. The said Commission erred as a matter of law in’

requiring and authorizing the. Railroads by its Order to
increase the intrastate fare from 1.65 cents to 2.2 cents dur-
ing tines, of excessively high earnings of the Railroads
under| war conditions as a means of offsetting deficits in-

rs pore dn passenger train operations during times of law

at pages 20-31, that. losses of the business i iy one year are
not to be ater by adding them:to the tate base on which
a fair return\and depreciation allowance i is: earned.

#159. The said Commission erred as a matter of law ino
basing its findifig with respect to the Railroads’ rates of

return on value of their carrier property during ‘the war

sion ‘iva in not hodiiion the principle of law whieh: was .
enunciated in Federal Power Commission v. Natural Gas
| Pipe Kine Co., 315 U.S. 575, 62 S. Ct. 736, at page 590. (747) |
and witch principle was invoked by North Carolina in its -. |
Brief, at, pages 36.44 and-its Petition for Reconsideration: « &

—_

. . . °
aa B Sak alah .
BO a ke on OED Pere eee

i)

. Years of 1942 and 1943 ‘and at the time of the rendition of
its Report i in March, 1944, upon income Te Teft after deducting
federal income taxes: from: tet: income—commonly called -
‘‘after federal income taxes*’—contrary to the principle of.
law which the said Commission has adhered to in Reduced
Rates, 1922,68 — C. C. 676, 683, and Increaséd Rates, 1942

248 J. C.C. 545, . ‘—that: railway corporations should, like
- other corporation. . av their federal. income. taxes out of
the income rather th. -ollect it, in effect, from the public

in the form of transpo: ‘tion charges adjusted to enable "|

them to retain the designi. ‘d fair return over and above
the tax. ( #115.) iS ate ae

4

[fol: 26] Duly sworn to as Stanle y Winborné. - Jurat
‘omitted am printing. ' ;

(fol. 27]. ~ Appenpix 141.1 |
North Carolina. Utilities Commission, Raleigh, N. €.

Stanley Winborne, Chairman. Fred .C. Hunter, Commis-
4 sioner. R. G. Johnson, Commissioner

Docket No. 2789

Before the North Carolina U tilities Commission

‘In the Matter of Petition of railroads Operating in North °
Carolina for Authority to Increase Their Basie Coach
_ Fares from 1.65 Cents Per-Mile-to 2.2 Cents Per Mile - | -
for Civilian Travel and to Make Other Adjustments in

Passenger Fares. ~ ;
: . ze 4 .
4 Supplemental, Report and Order ,

Following the hearing herein on May 20, 1943, our report
and interlocutory order was entered on July 8, 1943, wherein
certain statistical evidence of record at that stage showing
financial results of passenger service operations, was dis-
cussed. Among other references to said statistics it was
stated : a regi : ; 3

‘‘The evidence which brings the operating veesilte of |
the seven Class I-railtroads up through December 31,
1942, indicates a very probable need for additional
revenue from Coach fares by two of the carriers, viz.,
Carolina, Clinchfield and Ohio Railway and Norfolk

Southern Railway C ompany.””

It-is also stated in the report. that one ‘of the two. rail-

- roads mentioned in the foregoing quotation is situated in
the western part of the State while the other is located in
the eastern part of the State; both of them away. from the
dense passenger traffic lanes. The former report reférs to
the remarkable increase of revenue and ‘income in 1942
over 1941 from passenger operations by: the. primary peti- .
tioning carriers, viz. Atlantic Coast Line, Seaboard Air’
‘Line and the Southern Railway, and the -lack of evidence:
**to indicate an immediate ahatement of the trend thus
apparent.’ |

\

sah

Le. | 25
[fol. 28]’ In light. of the grounds upon which petitioners
chose to stand it does not.seem logical that failure to submit .
-evidence of .unit éxpenses to justify the drastic increases
sought is other than an.act of deliberate omission; and to’

& supply that deficiency with respect to petitioning carriers

‘in the ascending i income group we carried out our purpose

as expressed in the prior report herein, petitioning the In--

terstate Commerce Commission to institute an investigation

_., eral Commission denied our petition but considered the
» relationship “of existing interstate -and intrastate civilian
-eoach fares in a proceeding on petition of the petitioning ©
- carriers herein under. C. C. Docket No. 29036, reported
on March 30, 1944. Our _ petition filed April 26; 1944, with
+— the Federal Commission seeking an extension of time within
which to adjust certain intrastate fares; for. further. hear-
_ ing to receive supplemental statistical evidence’: for modi-
' fieation of certain findings; reargument and reconsidera-
tion; to the contrary-notwithstanding cage following motion
of the North Carolina lines, petitioners in N. C. U. Cy Docket.
No. 2789 and I: C. C. Docket No. 29036, the Federal Com-
mission entered an order. requiring. inovant carriefs to
- establish the iricrease sought on North Curolina Intrastate
traffic én or before July. 1, 1944, upon the usual posting and
filing notice of not less than. 30 days, dnd at the same time _
ordered denial of our petition of April 26, 1944.
Statisties ‘submitted in evidence at the hearing in “our
. Docket No. 2789, ‘show results of passenger: operations-as
of December 31, 1942, but not thereafter. In the meantime
since service of the Federal Commission’s report in ‘Docket
* No. 29036,-on March 30, 1944, we have endeavoured to sup-
plement the record in our Docket No. 2789, by requesting’
certain statistics of the carriers to show passenger operat-
ing results for the entire vear of 1943. As supplemented
| fol. 29] the reéord shows continued deficits i in 1943 ineurred |
by the Caroliria Clinchfield and Ohio Railw ay and the Nor-
-.. folk Southern Railway: Company. -On the other hand. the
**Net Revenue From Railway’ Operations’’ in’ passenger
service of the trunk-lines continued to surge upward”
through 1943, as may ‘be noted from the tabulation set out
in Appendix ‘*A’? hereto.. The passenger operatitig ratie
of the Caroljna Clinchfield and Ohio Railway of.111.4 for
1943 shows considerable improvement over that of 144.4 for
1942, but that the expense of supplying the Service is still .

+

into the reasonableness of the interstate fares.. The Fed--‘

2 _ pany, the outgo to these carriers to earn a dollar or 100 cents
-. in 1943° was further reduced to a range. of 48.8 for the

26

greater than the: revenue received. therefrom. "However,
adversity of the Norfolk. Southern Railway C ompany.’s
ratio of 133.3 in 1943 is greater than that of 109.0 for the
preceding year of 1942.

The remarkably low ratios of the truink lines i in 1942, were.
even more favorable .to those carriers in 1943. ‘Ranging
from 57.5 for the Southern Railway Company in the former: °
year to 72.0 for the Louisville and Nashville Railroad Com-

Southern Railway Company, the lowest, to a high of 55.3 ©
for the Atlantic Coast Line Railroad Company. ge
There is no evidence of record before-us-with respect to
‘the results of passtnger operations by several of the peti-
tioning. lines, | viz:, Aberdeen and Roekfish Railroad Com-
pany, Atlantic and East Carolina Railway Company, Caro-
lina and Northwestern Railway Company and others of
the so-called short line category. -As to those lines*we are,
not now in a position to determine whether they lack suffi--
cient revenues to meet their needs. However, after ‘again.
considering the evidence of record as supplemented it is
clear that the four strong trunk lines shown in the : appendix
hereto with such magnificient net revenues. front. railway
operations in passenger service and such low ratios, have
failed to show their expenses per coach passenger mile in
‘fol. 3} relation to the existing intrastate+record shows. .
continned deficits in 1943 incurred by the Carolina-Clinch—
field and Obio Railway and the Norfolk Southern ‘Railway °
Company. On the other hand the ‘‘ Net Revenue From Rail-
way Operations’? in passenger service of the trunk lines.
continued to surge upward through 1943, as may be noted
from the tabulation set out in Appendix *‘A’’ hereto. The
passenger operating ratio of the Carolina Clinehfield and
Ohio Railway of 111.4 for 1943 shows considerable improve-. -
ment over that of 144.4 for 1942, but’ that the expense of
supplyi ing the service is still greater thay the revenue re-
ceivéd therefrom. However, adversity of the Norfolk
‘Southern Railway Company’s ratio of 183.3 in 1943. is
greater than that of 109.0 for the preceding} vear of 1942.

The remarkably low ratios of the trunk lines i ini 1942, were |
ever more favorable’ to those earriers in 1943. Ranging
from 57.5 for the Southern Railway Company in thé former

vear to 72.0 for the Louisville and: Nashville Railroad Com-_
pany, the outgo to these carriers to earn a dollar or 100

27

cents in 1943 was further reduced to a range of 48.8 for the
Southern Railway Company, the lowest, to a high of 54 3
for the Atlantic Coast Line Railroad Company. °

There is no evidence of record before. us with respect to

the results of passenger operations by several of the peti-

‘tioning lines, viz., Aberdeen and Roekfish Railroad Com-
" pany, - ‘Atlantic and East Carolina Railway Company, Caro-
lina and Northwestern Railway Company and others of the
so-called short line category. As to those lines we are not
now ina position to determine whether they lack sufficient
revenues to meet their needs. However, after again con-
~—— ede ring the evidence of reeerd as-supplemented™ it is clear

: >

operations im passenger service and such low ratios, have

failed to show their expenses per. coach passenger mile in.

;

. - [fol. 31]. relation to the existing-intrastate civilian coach
fares and revenues. In the absence of such proof at this
time from the four strong trunk lines, and unless and until

the so-called short line group submit evidence we shall re-
serve to the future any further findings with respect to those
two groups of-carriers, which carriers are free to offet evi-
dence, or as the case may be, to improve the quality of that
thus far adduced.” The door is still open, it has never been
closed.

:

)

The record as supplemented clearly shows pane ee addi:
r ; tional revenue from passenger. operations by the two Class | :
:

)

:

petitioners which*continuea to sustain defici ts throughout
1945 ; it is‘therefore,
gt Ordered, That the Norfolk iieiiees Railway Company
and the Carolina Clinchfield: and Ohio Railway be and thre
same are hereby. authorized to increase their one-way fares
fgr intrastate transportation of civilian passengers travel
ing in coaehes to 2.2 cents per mile, and to increase their
_ round-trip fares for civilian passengers traveling in coache~
to the basis of 180 per cent ef the one-way coach t fares of
2.2 cents per mile or’ 1.98-cénts per mile traveled. Said
round trip fares’ to -be subject to a limitation of ‘three
months.
By the Commission.
,.. This 16th day of May, 1944. ce
| (S.) Stanley. Winborne, Chairngdu. (S.) Fred ©.
.. . * Hunter, Commissioner. (S.) R
missioner. (Seail.).

.

that the four strong trunk lines shown in the’ ‘appendix _

_ hereto with ‘such“magnificient net revenues from raillyay

G. Johnson, Com»

28
[fol. 32] ©, Appenpex' #1561. - 2 ——-

Strate or, NortH Carona,
County of Wake: ; :

* Affidavit ‘of F vend A Downing .
Before me, a Notary Public in and for the State of North

. Catalina, personally appeared Frank A. Downing, who be-

ing by me first duly sworn deposes and on oath says: That
le.is a citizen of Raleigh, North Carolina; that he’is, and
for the four years past, has been empleyed-as Rate Special .
ist by the North Carolina Utilities Commission ;..that. he
lias had more than fifteen years experience in statistical.
-and accounting’ work; that ‘as part of the duties fof: his
employment he is required to and does study the cur-
rent statistics of operations and income and the like of
common carrier railroads as reported by the carriers to, .~
and as required by law and by the Interstate Commerce
Commission and-the North Carolina. Utilities Conimission ;.

And that he is familiar with the brief ‘of thie North Caro: .
lina Utilities Commission dated February 16, 1944, in a’
proceeding before the Interstate Commerce Commission,

_¢ntitled ‘*North Carolina Intrastate- Coach. Fares, Docket

. No, 29036," and the statisties and computations set forth
in pages thirty-eight to fifty-three of said brief,and-the
computations therein made of: the expense per passenger .
inile in’ coaches of 1.75 cents for the year 1937, and 0.98
of one cent for the year 1942,-and 0.81 of one cent. for the
vear 1943 of six common carrier railroads operating in
North Carolina; that as toe two of the said six. carriers, -
to-wit, the Carolina, Clinchfield and Ohio Railway and Nor-
folk Southern Raikw ay C ‘ompany, the North Carolina Com-
inission has granted their application toiinerease their coach
fares for intrastate travel within North Carolina;
‘And that the'statistics of the four remaining carriers,
Namely: Atlantic Coast Line Railroad Company, Louis-
ville and Nashville Railroad Company, Seaboard Air Line
Railway Company ard Sonthern Railway Company for the
years 1942 and 1943-show that they incurred average oper-
ating expenses per passenger mile in coaches of 0.97° of
one cent for 1942 and 0.91 of one cent for the year 1943;
And that the said-average expenses per ‘passenger mile
‘in-coaches, namely 0.97 cent for 1942, and 0.91 cent for

eS eeEEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEewr

of literatets Comisieée Caimeedeadia ‘Bebehe of Statistics

North Carolina Utilities Commission, Raleigh, N. C., i

1943 were derived from statistics reported by enid « carriers
to the Interstate Commerce Commission, and furnished to

the North Carolina Utilities Commission by the Interstate.

fol. 33] Commerce Commission in letters, dated March

addressed to-Mr. H. M. Nicholson, Director of Traffic of th

tables showing for said four carriers the following aggre-
cate statistics for the twelve months ending. December 31,|
1943 and 1942: =

Pee 1943-1942
Passenger Revenue in Coaches $119, 641,756 $59,628,629
Passenger Miles in Coaches 6,812 2,586,122 3,826,231,523

‘Passenger ‘Train ( ‘oach Miles 155,512,389, 122,413,983

_And that’ the average passenger operating ratios of the

: four: said lines were 62.55. for the vear 1942 and 51.84 for
‘the -vear 1943, which averages are derived from the aggre-

gate of the passenger operating révenue and’ passenger op-
erating expenses.of each of said four carriers as they-appear
in hese respective —. ed reports of statiaties to the
1. C. Coand N.C. U.-C., and which mean that out of each
‘sites of passenger revenue received for’ the four said
carriers there was needed, for passenger expenses only 62.55
cents in 1942 and 51.84 cents in. 1943; pa cet

And that for the year 1942 dividing the said aggregate
coach passenger revenues. by, the aggregate coach passenger
miles produces an average revenue per coach passenger mile
of 4.56 cents; and multiplying that figure’ by ‘the operating
ratio of 62.55 produces an average expense per passenger

in coaches of 0.97 cent per-mile; and that similarly for.the --

vear 1943 theSai@ageregate coach. passenger’ revenues
divides by the. coach passenger miles produces an average .
revenue per coach passenger mile of 1.755 cents; and multi- -
plying that figure by the operating ratio of 51.84 percent
produces expense per — in coaches of 0.91 eent

per mile; ie

And that the said expenses per passenger mile in coaches
of 0.97 cent in 1942, and 0.91 cent in 1943 are substantially
less than the existing, one way coach fare in North Carolina

O23) eee co BPN
_ ef 1.65 cents, and were only 58,8% in 1942 and 55.1% re-
spectively of the intrastate fare of 1.65 cents;\that based
-on his experience he is of the opinion and believes that
the: North Carolina one way coach fare of 1.65. cents. per
p pega mile for the years 1942 and 1943 yields to said
our carriers farmore than ufficient to yield a fair return
to said carriers from coach passenger traffic ;
. And.that the combined freight and passenger sneian
ratios of the four respective carriers for the years 1942 and
~ 1943 as they appear in their Annual em to the Com- .
‘mission, were as follows:

. . [fol 34] a rae “Total Geicvadinn Ratios
as eee teks A, -1942. 1943
| ee Atlantic Coast Line Railroad Co. -* 54.69; 53.2
Beas Louisville-and Nashville Railroad @v. 58.66 56.6 -
Seaboard Air Line Railway.Co.. . . 60.78: ‘58.9
‘Southern Railw ay Company e §5.59 -55.6.

. And that the said- combined. freight and passenger oper-
ating ratios of eacli of the four respectiye lines for, the
vear 1943 were higher than the average emg oper-
‘ating ae of the four said carriers ‘ rear 1943 of
- 5184% 3 - pede SRN Se ge oe ee
‘And that the net idieare imouiied incomes in “the aggre- |
vate of the four said carriers before Federal Income Taxes.
‘tor tlie years 1942 and 1943, respectively, were $214, 412,298 .
and $277, 118,886; and that the rates of return. upon book’
‘investment in the aggregate ef the four said carriers, based -
_ upon said. net railway operating ‘incomes before Federal -
Ancone Taxes was 14.23% in 1942 and 18.07% in 1943, as
’ set forth in the appendix hereto. ee . 2
mos i “And -that the net revenues from railway operations (be-
_ fore deduction of both Federal Income and other taxes and.
equipment and joint facility rents). of the Class I railroads .
in the Southern Region in the aggregate during the cal-
~endar years of 1942 and 1943 were $429,960,167 and $540. ©
-- 337, 060, respectively, an incre&se of 25. 7% 1943 ov er 1942.
‘And that the aggregate net railway operating ‘income .
(after ‘deduction: of all taxés, and rents) was less by $19,-
- $91,732 or 9%. in 1943 than in 1942; but that there was
not. a deficit in the said aggregate net raifway opérating
incomes in either of the said calendar years. ‘

eae: : ier oe fi

Stee ae.
And that said aggregate net railway operating incomes

of’said railroads for the latest four months for whichsthe Sees
figures are available are as follows: :

Ma cs eA patos _ Net Railway
Month ee Operating Ineoine —

‘December, 1943 ot ene —... $347035,492
. January 1944 RP Oe . 14,411,720: :
February 1944 SO: |
~Marely 1s ae | : : 15,664,330

Bae

-And that increases over: the atypical month of Detein:
her, 1945, are, by subtraction in the tabulation next above, -
$3,376,228, $4,520,363 and $4,628,838 for January, Febru-
‘ary and Marel 1944, respectively, indicating an upward :
‘trend in said net railway epérating incomes of. said carriers
in those monflis of 1944 as compared with December 1943.

And that Anid net revenues from railway operations and
net dailwgf operating incomes of said carriers for the-eal-
[fol. 34] endar years 1942 and 1943. and for the months of
Dec ember 1943 and January, February and Mareh 1944
were obtained from monthly statement No. M-100 issued
und made public by Interstate Commerce € ommission, Bu-~
reau of Transport Economies and Statistics.

Mic panne Prank A, Downing, Affiant.
Babseribex and sworn: to before me this 3i day of
' May, 1944), Edgar Womble, Notary Public. My

Comsiubasian Creres: 1 July 27, 1945.. (Seal.)

Rone MO - aN e

cary |
oo

(9).

my uwnpo

“PhGL ‘Ez Avy
‘OCN “ymeey

‘OSE PU 1008 SNPIyoy —(g) uuNJoy*

6G PUY ERs SeINpaYyy—(Z). uUNJO,)
‘VOOZ PIPIPS~~(f) puw (1) suumnjo:

““WOIsSTUNIO,) IOUT) ayeysroyuy OU) OF SosawO INO ay) Jo syioday punu

uy

2 ¢ : e" 49 04 (¢) utunyo, ) Jo Ofjea oFuyusos08d ob stg) uumnpoy
‘WOUOZI RIP 943 04 (E) UID Juippe.puw (1) uUIn]oO.) ulody (7) UENO) Auyjowsyqns toss synsad (Hy ruyo, ‘
Lae: iat “Aah 2; : " r _ tistornyyndiwuo,)

_- PU’ Yse) sng

UeUTsaAUT Yoo MN...

(

~

FEO ‘ORO ‘£1
SEL" 10F!
Z1S 8220
89% £16"
91S" 160'CR

a€h6l ‘el saquiavo¢
26h L£68'tEI

SONOS
ZOE "C12 Lez ~ OF6'Z68'Z09'1 sour] & [eIMg,
Lou ‘coz ‘#6 421 ‘868 geo woe... |e
LE0'ZEL' se » OLL‘OLL' #8Z -"lvs
669‘ FOF £6 _ 869 18h bLE . ‘NOT
660‘ £0F IF IIb 268'c6z a is ie
Res'Ore BOG ose" Tee'zNe'T sour] moy,
Ige gee ze Isb'19e'geg nog
OFF 'Z6S FE | _ Le*Se6' 222 Pa sk
£E2 ‘799 PS ' FO6'LET'ROF . NPT
£96 “6th oF ~ S98‘ 980‘ RHz I'v
(sampoqy) Cavqod)
: SWoloid asuajacy jo vodoig
GONeenowy paniwoy uorwyodsuvs 7
Ceres age uy
., YOURDeudaq] ponrooy JUD SOAU] YOOs
(2) ieee sae

[98 ‘foy] -

,

‘[fol.'37] © a _ APPENDIX

Srate or Nortu Carona,
. County of , 88.7

*. Affidavit of H. M. Nicholson

Before me, a Notary Public i in and for the State of North
( cetaiians persoually appeared H. M. Nicholson, -whe-beins—
by me duly sworn deposes and on oath says; that he is —
Director ‘of Traffic of the North Carolina Utilities ‘oe

Ht. M. Nicholson:

" Sworn’ to and — before me this 31 day of
May A. D 1944. ‘Edgar Womble, Notary Public.

ae My Commission expires July 27, 1945. - (Seal.) .

/

“

ie See. ' [Tiile omitted]. —- °

“E

—-3

es on eee
[fol. 38] In Unrrep States” District Court

Petition ror Leave To InterveNe—Filed. June 5, 1944

To the Honorable the J udges of the District Court of’ the |

United States in and for the Eastern District of North:

= _ Carolina, Raleig h Division; race or

‘Comes now Charlotte Shippers & anufacturers Asso- -.
‘eidtion,, Inc., and respectfully represents unto this Honor-

able Court as follows:

Petitioner is a non-profit corporation organized and exist-

ing under the laws of the State of North Carolina, with its
principal office at Charlotte, N. C., and its: -executive wig
President is W. S. Creighton of Charlotte, N. C.: and sai

petitioner is engaged primarily in the ‘protection of its —

large membership of shippérs and. manufacturers, in mat-

ters pertaining to transportation ; thie said petitioner inter-
- vered_in the proceeding befere the Interstate Commerce:

Commission entitled, North Carolina Intrastate Coach
Fares, No. 290236, and is tlierein a complainant against the

proposed increases in “the farés. for vivilian travel: in pas-
senger coaches within the State of North Carolina ; and
. this petitioner joined the North Carolina Utilities’ Commis-
sion in presenting a brief, oral-argument and a petition
‘for reconsideration, ete., in- said proceeding before the In-

terstate Commerce Commission and this petitioner is en-
titled ‘to intervene in the above entitled cause, + U. S.C.

Title 28, See. 45a. ; :

Dated at. Chairlotte, N. C.,-this 26 day of bay” 1944.
. Charlotte’ Shippers & Mfrs. Asso., Ine. By W. S.
Creighton, Vice President.

May A. D..1944. -Thoes. C. Haves, Notary Public.
“(Seal.) -My Commission expires 2/28/45.”

wy UC. P. Ehringhaus, Wachovia, Bank Blde., Raleieh,.

F. C. Hillyer, ear! West Forsyth St., Jacksonville
2 Mi pear ee

Trot 39] » Service ace — and copy ree ceived this 6th day |
+ of June 1944... -- |

Sworn to and subseribed before me this 26 dav of

United States of Americ By Robert L. Pierce. Tn- .

terstate Commerce Commission. By J. Stanley
Payne. : :

°
Ww
qn

os —[fol. 40] In Usrrep SraTes District Court
q [Title omitted]

PETITION FOR Leave to Intervene—Filed June 5, 1944 . .
| ___To the Honorable the Judges-of the-District-Court-ofthe
¢ - United States in’ and for the Eastern District of North
* Carolina, Raleigh Division:

.% Comes now the North Carolina Division of the Travelers’ = *
Protective Association of America, and B. F. Russell. of oe

North ‘Carolina, Chairman of the Transportation Commit- ~ -
tee of the °T. P. A. of A., and’ respectfully represents under

this Honorable Court as follows: — . aa

4 | _ .The said Travelers’ Protective Association of America is

4 a-fon-profit corporation organized and existing under the

laws of the State of Missouri, and havi ng a division in

the State of North Carolina and a Pést at Raleigh, N. -_.

E and that the Nofth Carolina Division of said Association

~ has more’ than 3,600 members; that-the object of the “Asso-
ciation is ‘to secure benefits for the members and improve-
ments in services of members of the Association through-

out the State as. well as insurance ‘benefits that they en-

. joy; that the said B: F. Russell is »traveling salesman for

2 » E. F, Craven Co. of Greenshefo, N..C., engaged ‘in the”

q sale of heavy construction equipment, contractors’ equip- -

. ment and things of that kind, and having six traveling sales- lower than the pasvenget i famed Siaiaialy main-

made by any of said railroads for intrastate-transportation

‘in North Carolina shall not exceed the aggregate charge

made for like accom-odations and for a like distance for the
same railroad: in -intérstate ——— to, from, or
through such State.

10. In the: report mentioned in BSS 7 hereof, the
Interstate Commerce Commission failed or refused to give
full effect to wartime conditions ‘and the stabilization legis-

lation, although it was under a duty to do so.

[fol. 58] (a) The Commission erredgas ‘a matter of law;
in concluding that its consideration of the stabilization legis-
lation should be limited to a finding that common carriers

- making rate increases have complied with the requirement

_ tained and applied by said railroads‘for like accom-odations
_in intetstate transportation to, from, and through North &
Carolina; provided, that the resulting aggregate charge .. |

of Section-1 of the Stabilization Act, by the giving of notice — |

and consent to intervene to the désignated Federal agent.
In addition to such-a fiiding, the Commission was ‘under a

_ duty to accom-odate the provisions of the Interstate Com-

merce~ Act to the statutory wartime programs of. the
Emergency Price Control Act of 1942: and the amendatory.
Stabilization Act of October 2, 1942, and was under a duty

to adjust its actious as indicated by the desires of Congress .
to have the policies of said price ‘control and stabilization -
_ legislation leay ened or implemented i in the enforcement of:
the various specific provisions of the legislation with which Zi

the Commission is primarily and directly concerned. .

(b) The re ommission failed or “refused to determine that —

increases of coach fares over those in effect on September
15; 1942, were inconsistent with-the declaration of Congres-
sional policy in Section.1-of the Emergency Price Control

[fol. 59] Act of 1942, namely, that it,is necessary to the ~

effective prosecution ‘of the present war, and certain pur-

poses of that Act are, ‘‘to stabilize prices ‘and to prevent —

speculative, unwarranted, and abnormal increases in prices
and rents; to eliminate.and. prevent profiteering, hoarding,
manipulation, speculation, and other disruptive practices

; f 43

“-

esl ‘ine , 3 : . ; e 3 7 a oF . ‘ @,0
resulting from abnormal market conditions or scarcities

caused by or contributing to the national emergency ; to as-
sure that defense appropriations are not dissipated by ex-
céssive prices ; to protect persons with relatively. fixed and

limited incomes, consumers, wage earners, investors, and:
persons dependent on life insurance, annuitiés, and pen-.
sions, from.undue impairment of their standard of living,

7 2 wend °

(c) On the contrary, the findings. of the Commission, and

the uncontradicted evidence submitted to-the: Commission
by the railroads at the hearing metitioned in paragraph 6°
hereof, reveal that the increases of passenger coach fares

in the Southern territory and North Carolina over those in

effect on September 15, 1942, were abnormal in relation to _
peacetime cofiditions, and that said increases were made

possible or practical because of inflationary wartime condi-

. tions and the restricted use of automobiles during the war.
* “[fol. 60} emergency.. From December 1, 1933, to November

14, 1937, inclusive, the general basis of interstate and intra-
state coach fares in Southern territory and North Carolina

was 1.5 cents per mile. From November 15, 1937, to Janu- .
ary 14, 1939, inclusive, the general basis—of. coach-fares,

interstate aiid intrastate in said territory: -and North Caro-
lina, was 2:0 cents per mile: On January 15, 1939, said fares

were reduced to the basis of 1.5 cents. per mile, to which 10

ing the basis of said fares to 1.65 cents per mile. Said’ fares
of 1.5 cents per mile Were maintained primarily to attract
traffic that had been diverted chiefly to private automobiles.
The reduction in fares from the basis of 2.0 cents to 1.5 cents

percent , increases at added: on February 10, 1942, bring-

per mile, effective January 15; 1939, resu! ited from the con-

clusion of certain Southeastern railroads, that ‘‘it would
be to their advantage to restore the former one-way coach
fare of 1.5 cents per mile’® (1. C. C. Record, in. No. 29036,
Exhibit No. 1, ‘‘page 8’’, decument +110 attached to the

Petition of the State of North Carolina and the North C aro- .

lina’ Utilities Commission in this action). - The adverse
effects. upoti traffic of the increases of said fares for the
fourteen months following November 15, 1937, for 6 North
(fol. 61] Carolina railroads, are shown by the following data

voluntarily subinitted by said railroads to the ¢ ‘ommission

44

—— =— -

————

ve

in ‘their ‘Exhibit No. 9 lis roe shoveisa-a document #110) ~
in the proceeding mentioned in paragraphs 6 and 7 hereof:

. Revenue Passenger Miles Per Train Mile
» (Exhibit 9, pages 25 and 26)

19387 —ss«447..53
1931 25.83 1988 37:60
1992. 23.83 - 1939 16
} 27.64 1940 175
1934 35.85 1941 75.11
1935 38 . 26 1942 145,85
1936 44.59 Ist 7 mo. 1943 211.10
Revenue a Passenger | ~
Passenger venue vice ‘assenger
7 _Mile in Per coach . Operating - ‘Miles per
Coaches Mile Ratio Coach Mile
Ex. 9, p.15 _ Ex. 9, p. 17 Ex.9,p. 11 Ex. 9, p. 31
MOT... SR doce... 1.494¢ - °22.02¢ 117% 14.74%
1088... eee, 1.806 - 19.51 . 125 * 1 j 10.81
_+ ( Percent change Favorable Unfavorable Uidaverahde| “Unfavorable ):
( 1987 to 1938 20.68% . 11.40% 6.84% 26.66% )
SOS ae 20.17¢ 124% ~ 14.46
. . Seenanrers | Se - 1.362 23.30 123 17.11
\' a a 2 30.93 101} 28.05 ©
1942.22... a 32.44 63 33.62

Ast 7 months 1943 44.96 -
"(Percent change © Favorable . Favorable Favorable 4, Favorable)

( \ 1941 to 1942 11.19% 69.54% 37.62% 52. 17% )

©

Keonomic podditions since 1939 have greatly ‘mniadd,

and the increased intrastate fares required by the-Commis- .

sion, as nientioned in paragraph 7 hereof, will produce
| fol. 62].added revenues: The Tisha Commerce. C'om-
mission failed or refused to ‘determine, however, w hether

the North Carolina railroads are earning-less than a fair.
return and whether said railroads are in need of the:addi- -
tional | revenues ‘from the inerensed intrastate fares for:

the purpose of earning a fair return.

(d) In said report the Interstate Cémmerée Commis-
sion failed or refused to be governed by the declaration or
finding of Congress in the Stabilization Act of Oc ober 2,
1942, that general increases of common carrier fates: or
charges above those in effect on: September 15, 1942, are
inflationary per se, and that stabilization of such fates and

‘charges is necessary to aid in the heenive: prosdeution of
. the;war.
- The said corrected order of Max 8, 1944, mentiondd in”
paragraph 9 hereof, having begh ‘issued contrary to the

.
OT OI Se ee Oe Nae Oe | Ce ee ee Te aa io

ae ———— ery eee —
ec shnsnsmenaternsren ematatste ———————————
SO

— ———
a
—————— t

iktentions ¢ and desires of Congress, itiuan the Peon
mission’s constitutional and statutory powers, and j is unlaw-
ful, void, and of rio effect. / ¢

11. In the report ‘mentioned’ in paragraph 7 4 sinitaait thie
Interstate Commerce Commission acted in disregi ird of the
executive orders of the ‘President set forth in paragraph
3 hereof, although said Commission had both the power
and duty to. cooperate in the wartime stabilization program
-{fol. 63] of Congress as set forth in. the Kmergency Price -
ansren Act of 1942 and the Stabilization -Act of October
», 1942. The said corrected order of May 8, 144, men-
tioned in paragraph 9 thereof, having been issued epntrary

‘to the said executive order, therefore: transcends the Com-
‘mission’s constitutional] and statutory. sala and is un-
lawful, void, and of no effect. +. - |

12. Yn said report of Mareh 25, 1944, mentioned § in para-
; ea 7 hereof, the Interstate Commerce Commission did
not make sufficient findings of basic facts to support the
~ Commission’s sixth’ enumerated finding and conclusion-that
“* the North Carolina intrastate coach’ fares cause and will
cause yndue and unreasonable advantage to and preference
of persons in intrastate commerce, undue and unreasonable
disadvantage to and prejudice against persons-in interstate
commerce, and undue, unreasonable, and unjust: discrimi-
nation against interstate comnyerce. Under the Interstate
_Cotimerce Act, the Commission-is empowered to prescribe:
“intrastate rates, farés, and charges only after findings ‘of
‘facts that any advantage, preference, prejudice, or dis-
crimination from the intrastate fares causes some result -
Which is undue, unjust, or unreasonable as respects , inter-
stite commerce. The said report of the Commission does
net ‘state any finding of fagt showing, any undue, unjust,
vy unreasonable. result eatised by the differences’ between
the interstate and intrastate coach’ fares mentioned in-said
{ fol. 64] report.+ ‘The said corrected order of May 8, 1944,
haying been based: upon insufficent findings of basic ‘fact, °
therefore transcends the Commissions constitutional and
. statutory powers, and is unlawful, void, and of no effect.

. The record before the Interstate Commerce Commis- .
sion in the proceéding mentioned in paragraph 6° hereof
does not contain substantial evidence to clearly support the
‘sixth enumerated finding mentioned in the preceding para-

46 . Es ameae Oa Cc

- graph. Said finding j is seeing en ‘The Commic-
. sion’s said corrected order of May 8, 1944, mentioned in

/, paragraph 9 hereof, being based upon said arbitrary find-

ing, is also arbitrary, transcends the Commigsion’ 8 con--
‘stitutional and statutory powers, and is vorl and of no
— Sateen y, od

\14. The Interstate Ganaiees Commission sides. as.a

eres March 2), 1944, mentioned in- paragraph 7 r

state satne exre ines fate peseenes fares than -the

intrastafe passengers, and that maintenance of such intra-

state fares, causes undue and unreasonable advantage a _
preference of tlie intrastate passengers, and undue an
reasonable disadvantage wznd prejudice of ‘the in oretate
passengers. The said corrected order of May 8, 1944.
having been based upon an error of law, therefore tran-
scends the Commissions’ constitutional and statutory
powers, und is unlawful, void, and of no effect.

{fol: 65] 15. In said report of March 25; 1944, mentioned in
paragraph 7 i hereof, the Interstate Commerce Commission

_ erred in that part of its fifth enumerated finding that ‘*‘traf-

fie moving under these lower intrastate fares is not con-
tributing its fair share ‘of the revenues required to enable

e respondents to rende Tr —— and efficient transp rtation |
_ service.’

(a) The oiaed idling ene based in part upon find-.
ings of. facts with respects to so-called passenger serv-

_ice net railway operating deficits from 1936 to 1941, .-

‘inclusive, incurred while interstate and intrastate

coach fares were on the same general basis. The North -

Carolina railroads are not entitled toiregulation by the
Commission which will insure that the said railrgads’

bysinesses_ will produce net revenues, nor does the -—

“Constitution require that the losses of such businesses
in past years be restored from future earnitigs..

(b) The quoted finding of the Commission was made
without.consideration of the fact that said Commission
‘had authorized general levels of freight rates to include

er law, in its fourth and six enumerated. findings of

biti. id Rui mouse: citi

Oe PARRA IVE

a

“tee in, italia ERY Il

2 = |
“4
x
-

a factor for the support of said passenger | service be.
cause of said deficits. Passenger Fares and Sur-
charges, 214 I. C. C. 174, 227, the Commission said:

“That the generally unprofitable nature, for the last

, secade, of the rail passenger service: throughout the

: country has been consistently given consideration by
us in determining, the reasonableness of freight rates,

2 P
is-amply demonstrated by expressions in our annual
° reports to » th Congress: and i in humerous decisions

te ee ea j
e ; . f > ‘
. F ara = -

“ {fol. 66} : Inthe Fiftec n Percent Case, 1937-1938, 226

“i Cos , the Co mn i authorized the railroads of the °

country to make a‘10 percent increase in Treight, rates. gen-
_erally, with certain Cea and said (p. 54):

“This deficit in the ‘passenger traflic as'a whole has
continued from /at least. 1926, nrounting ‘steadily: toa

“* peak in 1932;\and_ receding .only ‘slightly thereafter.
* Passenger Fares and Surcharges, : 214 C.-C. 174, 183.

' The interrelation of the freight and passenger traffic ©

has often been commented on by us, and we ‘have de-
clined to atcede to the proposition. agailt repeated here
’ certain ;protestants’ that we.can authorize ‘no in-

senger business : to meet its full share of the rf revenie
burden. pa ; *

tc) In contradiction to tie tinding quoted i in the opening
sentence of this paragraph, the Commission found in said
report that beginning with 1942 the principal railroads
operating in the State of North Carolina have received: net

)

: crease im freight, rates to correct deficiencies in aggre-
vate earningsjgrowing out of the inability of the pas-*

_ritlwiiy operating income from passenger services imexcess
of expenses; but the Commission failed or refused to make -

any finding that such net railway operating income was
less than a fair returnecfor North Carolina railroads, al-

though evidence on the subject matter was contained in the -

record before the Cominission: On the ‘contrary the In-
terstate Commerce Commission found in said report that
the-passenger operating revenues for five principal North
Carolina railroads were substantially greater for the 12
{fol. 67} months ended October 31, 1943, thar those for 1942;
und that the passenger operating ratio (percentagé of oper-

, a Ve

48 : ata
railroads and 2 other railroads operating in North Carolina,
as estimated by the witness for the Price Administrator for
the first 9 monghs: of 1943, unlike that for 1942, was some-
what more fav8rable, than the freight operating ratio of

these railroads for the same ported. Said ratios for the «|
. first 9 months of :1943 were 02.3 for the passenger service

and 57.7 for the freight service, as compared with the 1942

operating .ratios of 63.9 and 54.7 for the passenger and .
| freight services, respectively, . Rates of return for the said-

7 North Carolina, railroads, fron). net railway operating in-

‘come before deduction of federal income taxes, but after

deduction of rent for leased: road and equipment, for the.
12 months ended October 31, 1943, averaged 18 percent of a
base computed: from said railroads’ -book investment in
transportation property, plus cash, materials and supplies,

- jesS aeerved depr eciation’ and accrued amortization of de-

fense projects.

‘(d) The Cotnmission includél within the revenues so re-

quired, according to said finding, amounts of increased taxes.
paid by railroads in the southern region, and did not con-:

[ fol. 67a] sider. net revenues. ofthe said railroads prior
to deduction of wartime ineom. ‘ taxes:

hereof, having been based upon errors of law, transcends
the Commission’s constitutional and statutory powers and
is unlawful, void, and of no effect.

16.. The maintenancé’ ‘of. passenger oouah fares to, from,
and between points in North Carolina, in interstate and

intrastate commerce upon the general basis o' 1.65 cents

per mile under present, conditions would: not impose an

undue burden upon ‘nor undue : injury to interstate or,
’ foreign commerce.

(a) AG albown by the attached aifidavit of one Doris

. §. Whitnack, with. accompanying tabulations, attached,

hereto and made part hereof,*the 1943 total rate of

‘return for eleven North Carolina railroads, commuted
upon by: the’ method described in paragraph 15(c¢)..

hereof, was 18.00°7.. The 1943 operating ratios for. the
_six Class I North Carolina railroads (as classified for

_ statistical purposes by the-Interstate Commerce. Com-

: .
: . ie : -
. oe .. ts y >
e .
) .

ating expenses to operating revenues) for said 5 principal

°

The said order of May 8, 1944, mentioned in paragraph 9 -

[fol. 72 (b). The ( ommission failed or refused to con-
sider A need, in the public interest, of ‘adequate and
efficient transpertation service at the lowest cost con-

sistent with tbe furnishing of such service,’’ as re-
quired by Séction 15(a) of the Interstate Commerce _

Act. The data in paragraph 10(¢c) hereof. indicates by

Approxinmtio that in 1942, such unit cost of passenger

serv ice in coachfag was about .98 of 1 cent per passenger
nile as.- compa rec |
rate of 1.65 certs qnd the interstate sate of 2.2 cents
per mile (revenue per coach mile—52.44¢, multiplied
by ratio of passenger service expenses to revetues—
63, divided. by passenger miles per coach mile—33.62,
equals 98).

bd

(c) The Commission erroneously considered the need
of added revenues by North Carolina ‘railroads for the
purpose of recouping for passenger service deficits
from 1936 to 1941, inclusive; and failed or refused to

.

vith the North Carolina intrastate:

‘no effert. _ ;

qr.
>.

os,

‘consider whether the North Carolina -railroads -are
presently éarning a fair return, and failed or refused
to consider that the Commission hag previously estab-.

' lished freight rate levels for the purpose of supporting
‘the passenger service and compensating for such defi-
cits, as mentioned in paragraph 15(b): hereof, which
support factor in freight rates has been multiplied by
the wartime increase of freight traffic.

fol. +3] (d) In derogation of the requirements of
said section 15(a), the Commission held that ‘*the most
helpful evidénce in determining the reasonableness of
rates or fares i is comparison with other rates or fares
for like services’’. ‘In making such a holding the Com-.
mission erred asa 1 uiatter of Tp ‘

*The said sacninhed order of May 8, 1944, ncaa in para-
graph 9 hereof, having been ‘based upon errors of law,

‘therefore transcends the Commission's constitutional and |
statutory powers, and is unlawful, void, and of no effect.

20, By said report of March 25, 1944, arid the orders of -
May 8, 1944 mentioned in paragraphs 7, 8, and 9 hereof, the
Interstate Commerce Commission has failed to recognize,

as a consideration justifying the maintenance of the intra-— -

state passenger. fares at a level lower than the interstate
fares, that .n denying increases of intrastate rates, fares
and charges over those. i in effect on September 15, 1942, the

‘North M'arolina Utilities Commission was sine in aia of

the effective prosecution of the war in accordance with the
policy of Congress as expressed in the ‘said Stabilization
Act of October 2, 1942, and as requested of the-North Caro-_

dina Utilities Commission by the President in said Exeeu-
- tive Order 9328 as set forth in paragraph: 3 hereof. The
‘said report and orders of the Interstate Commerce Cam-

mission therefore interfere with the cooperative efforts of
[fol. 74] the North: Carolina Utilities Cominiission to: aid
in the effective, prosécution of the war, contrary’ to the

-intention of Congress. The said corrected order of May's,

1944, having been issued contrary to the intentions and de-
sires of Congress transcends the Commission’s constitu-
tional and statutory powers, and-i is unlaw ful, void, and of

: : 53 .

21. Dnles’ said corrected suis of May 8, 1944, men-

tioned in paragraph 9 heréof, is restrained and perman-

ently enjoined and set aside, your petitioners will be caused

- great und substantial injury in the performance of their
duties tinder the Stabilization legislation.

(a) The increased fares will add to’ the cost of liv-
‘ing and will inflationary to the detriment gen-
erally of the wartime, program to stabilize prices,
rents, and. wages:

_ (b) Common carriers and public utilities will’ be «

. encouraged to-make inflationary increases of intra-
state rates and to take advantage of wartime condi-
tions.to make excessive and unprecedented profits.

" (e) State and municipal regulatory agencies will be’
‘discouraged from cooperation in the wartime stabiliza-
tion program to the end of maintaining rates) fares,
and charges in intrastate commerce, in effect in Sep-
tember 15, 1942, which are less° than those applicable
to interstate, commerce; which aetion may be over-

: ruled by the Interstate Commerce Commission to con-
-- form intrastate rates, fares, and charges to the inter-
state shit

2 «

{fol. 75] - 22. . Plaintiff herein’ hae no adequate remedy
law. eae foe P °

t

Wherefore, your petitioner Says:

First: ‘That his netition: be heard bya three judge ¢ourt
at the earliest availahte date, and that the constitutional
and judicial matters be -tried.de novo with respect a the
Allegations of paragraph 16 hereof.

Second: That pending the final hearing of -this cause;

' the court issue am interlocutory injunction and restraint
enjoining said railroads from:complying with said cor-
rected order of May &, 1944, nientioned in paragraph i
hereof.

Phird: That upon final hearing the court adjudge, or-
der, and decree that said’. -rected order of May 8, 1944,
. mentioned in paragraph -9 hereof, is and at all Aimes has

/ «

A
, ieee
°
ee

54

been in violation of the Interstate Commerce Act by rea-
son of-the Commission’s failure properly to interpret and
apply its constitutional and statutory authority to protect
interstate commerce from undue and unreasonable bur-
dens from intrastate commerce, and its ‘failure to aceom-
modate the exercise of its powers to the Congressional
policies embédied in the Emergéncy Price Control Act of |
1942 and the Stabilization Act of October 2, 1942; and that
. said corrected order is'and has been beyond the lawful
- authority of the Interstate Commerce .Commission; and
. {fol. 76) wholly null and void; and that said corrected or-—
der be perpetually set aside and annulled, and the enforce-
ment thereof perpetually enjoined. ,

-

Fourth: That the court grant to your petitioner such
other relief as may be proper in the premises.

Respectfully submittéd, Fred M. Vinson, Director of
the Office of Economie Stabilization, by Chester
Bowles, Price Administrator of the Office of Price
Administration; Richard H. Field, General Coun-
‘sel, Office of Price Administration; David F.
Cavers, Assistant General Counsel, Office of Price
Administration; M. D. - Miller, Attorney, Office
of Price Administ ration, 5319 Federal Office Build-

- ing No. 1,-2nd and D pen Gete, S..W., Washington

95, D.C. Sr

[fol. 77). Buly sworn to a MM. - Milter durat omitted
in-printing.—

—

=

[fol. 78]. APPENDIX To AMENDED COMPLAINT

Desewae T OF C ‘OLU MBIA:
| ‘Affidavit of Doris S. W hitnack —

Before .me, a notary public in- and for the District of ..
- Columbia, personally appeared Doris S. Whitnack, who
being by me first duly sworn deposes and on oath says:

‘~_A. That she is a*resident of the. District of Columbia and
since July 1941 "as been employed as an, Economist with
the Transportation Branch of the Transportation and Pub-
lic Utilities, Division of the Office of Price Administration,
and for about four years has had experience in economics °

2

Nf okt Go ae

and statistical work inv siving use and examination of the

_ statistical and accounting reports filed by raiisonds with the
Interstate Commerce Commission. \

2. That on December 29, 1943, she testified at the-hear-
-ing in Raleigh, North ¢ ‘arolina, in the proceeding before -
tthe Interstate Commerce Cotamission in No. 29036, North
‘Carolina Intrastate Coach Fares, giving evidence relating .

‘to Exhibit No. 20 in that proceeding.

3. That she has prepared the Tables, }, IL, and ill, at-
tached hereto, from the data set forth in the annual and

monthly reports of the railroads named in said tables;.
filed by said railroads with the Interstate’ Commerce Com- .,

tnission, and she states that the data and computations: in
said tables are trué.and correct to the best of her knowledge,
- information, ‘and belief.

- 4. That the 1943 rate‘of return for the ten North Caro-

lina railroads, n d in ‘Table I attached hereto, f rém to-
tal 1943 net railway operating income of said railroads be-
fore Federal income taxes, but after deduction of rents
for leased-road, was 18.00 percent of a‘total: of said rail-
roads’ book investments, plus cash, materials and supplies,

less accrued depreciation and amortization of defense pro-

jects, as of December 31, 1943.

d. ‘That the 1948 operating ratios for the six Class I North
Carolina railroads, named in Table II attached hereto,

-were 52.06 pere ent and 5 57.71 percent for their passenger and.

freight service respectiv : eee :

6. That Hering 1943, the av erage cost of the anni ee

service ad coaches by the said six North Carolina Class T

railroads, named in Table HI attached hereto, was about
63 of 1-cent per mile.

‘Dori is S. Whitnae *k.

[fol. 79] ” Sworn té and subseribed before me this
* 10th day of- July, 1944. Eugene R. Wood, Sr.,

Notary Public. (Seal.) My Commission expires —

Now. 30; 1945:

°
« :
.
rn
4
. pit
eee
-
e 2
\
‘
- i
\ f
,

. (Here follow 2 pasters, folios 80-84). -

Pies Ne ee

9?

[fol. 80) an oe a, sae > 5 ci Pa ey ae tie
: . . TABLE! ? ya
: ae :
* Railroads. Operatiag in North Carolina
oe
ad: . “Investment in -: .
: Carrier A Transportation Cash, Materials Accrued
Property and Supplies
as
_ Dee. 31, 1943 . * Dee. 31, 1983 Dae. 31, 1948
| (a) 2) Jo @ (4)
1. Aberdeen and Rockfish R. R. Co......... figanke $548 , 264 $58 , 575 $97 , 107 13.55%
2. Atlantic and East Carolina Ry. Co.............. 176, 483 317,002 ‘ 27 008 20.88
3. Atlantic Coast Line R. R. Co........... eneee 295,397,411 . 35,091,516. 2,127,812 20.13 -
4. Carolina and-Northwestern Ry. Co.....°....... 3,477,084 298 71,998 4.40
B. Colsebbielé Be RR. Care... cc ccc cece scene Ness 4,560,738 5,917,688 826, 278 38.91
6.. Danville and Western Ry. Co.................. 1,628 ,969 7 64,150 © ; 1.42
. 7. Louisville and Nashville R. R. Co.............. 472,561,455 52,913,268 13,143,876 . 19.76
8. Norfolk Southern Ry. Go.................5.... 18,988,619 1,661,979 2,081 ,060 1,307 6.65
9. Seaboard Air Line a | Sey Pee rrr ers ere , 284,170,710 26,273, 512 8,619,353 44,704. 16.23
. 10. Southern pony ieeiehe Re eeigis vedenanas 553,893,127 | 39,401,738 4,703,300 5 92, 367 ; | 16-66 *
11, Winston-Salem Southbound Ry. Co..:.......... * 5,989,197. 453,408 250, 696 6, 182,923 tM 6xc45400e0%. | 620.559 - 10.04
Total—11 carriers above...... Lee he Ge ETT $1,641 392,057, $162, 613,682 $24,021,642 $1,549.984,097 $285, 458,837 $6 , 460,748 $278,908, 089 18.00%
Sources—1943 Annual Report to the Interstate Commerce Commissi 2 a. js .
: Column (2 hedule 200A—Accounts 701, 702, 702-1/2A, and 1702-1 /2B-P.200. > - ;
Column (3 shedule 200A—Accounts 708 and 716-P.200. ‘
Column (4)—Schedule 200L—Accounts 775-1/2, 776, and 776-1 /2-P. 201. . : : .” F
Column (5)—Colump (2) plus Column (3) au Column (4). . :
__.. Column {4)—Schedule 3001—Line .No. 80 plus Line No. 87-P.301A. : ; -
~ Column ( hedule 3001—Line No. 35—Account 542-P.301A. . . ; A
Column (8)—Column (6) minus Column (7). . _ ‘ os +
Column” {9}—Column (8) Divided by-Column (5). / ;
fol. 8} > oa +. . ;
, ee er. nes . 4 TALE Il : oe ; ; :
2 - ithe , Class I Railroads Opeating in North Carolina : Ae
. | : . . } B43 : ; . . ; .
(1) — ao a (4) (5) ; (6) (7) . 8) (9)
mene oe Total Operating - Ve Pa Assigned to Freight Service i to Passenger
ere 3 OFReeioe ‘ : Opssating
. , Revenues , Expenses Revenues +» Expenses - Ratio Revenues _ Expenses Ratio
1. Atlantic Coast Line -R..R. Co... ............ '$153,601,015 $81 , 782,633 53.24 $108,857,749 $54,285,253. - 52.27% $49,743,266 $27 . 497.380
2. Clinchfield R. R. Co........... eeu h oil ans 12,796,775 6, 201,834 48.46 - 12, 583 , 264 5,963,934 13,511 237 , 900
’ 3. Louisville and Nashville R. R. Co........... - 208,799,302 118, 152,434 56.58 154,592,230 90,458,542 58.51 5, ,072 27 693, 892
4. Norfolk Southern Ry. Co........... wink a aN 8,377,575. 6,181,654 73.79 7,918,086 5,569,318 70.34 ,489 612,336
5. Seaboard Air Line Ry. Co.......... pe ee . 137,257,803: 80,823,710 58.88 89, 466 , 395 55, 264,091 61.77 "47, 791 ,408 * 25,559,619
6. Southern Railway Co...................855: 245,532,051 136 ,604, 153 55.64 176 , 593 635 102 , 959,676 58.30 68,938,416 . 33,644,477
7. Total All Class I Railroads......-......... 766,364,521 429,746,418 56.08 545,011,359 - 314,500,814 57.71 - 221,353,162 . 115,245,604.” |" 52.
: Source: 1943 Annual Reports to the Interstate Comannace Commission.
Columns (2), (5), and (8) Schedule 310, Roe s : “
, Columns (3), (4), (6), (7), (9), and (10) hedule 320, pp. 312-313. ;

.
_ >,
s ~

: a ov (
+ ‘ Fi
‘ n aa L
far) Meee Mon BETS PERE Ee Lee ee MPR -E : x °
| . ‘ 56B :
eee nee : ; ae . ns: ; at ; ‘ ie sa ; ay :
_—— eee ar ; ae TABLE II me : : eens
Fee te en ee Est of, Unit Costs Per Coach Passenger-Mile
ae ; ee s I Railroads Operating in North Carolina ;
abe Tt id SRR te a ynard 1937-1943 er ee ; | SS ee :
. ee 7 ° ane an, aire ys ~. Expenses Per Coach Expenses
: : a. dee Expenses 4 . - Passenger Passenger: Miles Per Coach
4 ; es j _ Assigned . Passenger Passenger- _ Passenger Car-Mile or Per er Passenger-Mile
; ee: Pig Sia - to Paasenge _Car-Miles Miles in Coaches Coach-Miles ‘Coach-Mile _ Coach Car-Mile ~ (Cents)
ste Service a . | Le A tae w (Cents) (2)/(3) -. (4)/(5) ——- ~— (6) /(7)
- 1.2AUantic Coast Line......... avs danSesng sds 68 , 261, 183 201,279,614 15,847,773 18. 15¢ ” 60,494,322 =: 281,363,635 21,066 ;363 23.85 10. a ie
4. Norfolk Southern............. etiquette! ae 998 , 781 2,049,048 + - 416,311°—* ¢°. 28.82 12 5.86
5. Seaboard Air Line.............---+++5- se. 11,809,540,” ——49, 386 , 785 228,809,547 = 12, 888, 171 ., 22.900 ° 17.7, 1.29 °
6. Southern: ........ St ee eet ay .... 917,267,881". -78,902,125 273,930,278 22,236,844 - “* 21.89 12 32 4178 -
a, saree Se ORR RT Re 55,879,553 - 256,444,410 | 935,481,110 73,589,784. = .21..79 12.71 71 ;
' 1940 1. Atlantic Coast eS CNR Ee 13,761,907. 71,466,099 . . 208,435,674. - 19,15 > aa 19.26 15.32 1-26 . ‘
2d 2. Clinchfield. Se a ate ee ere eee - 171 ,677 : 726,136, -. 2,956,274: | * 407,879 ~ >. 23.64. 7.25. 3.26
3. Louisville & Nashville......-..... poeta ir S- 15,347,728 . 62,368,021 256 , 453,201 21,697,518 24 61 11.82 208 -..
4. Norfolk Southern........”...-. eee ae :* 319,638. : ~ 968,075 . 2,221,026 - 353,596 33 02 6.28 5.26
5. Seaboard Ait Lint... .......--6-.62056: w..2 12,870,159 52,934,037 «317, 106,521 14,650,944 23.37 21 64 - 1 on ;
eye cus na ieee: § Fy 79,798,391 3 22.68 13.97 : 1.62 :
- Total... . >. Se a isee's aa ete emncr ain? — 60,067,112. 268 , 260,759 _ K 22.39. 15.07. 1.49
RN eee ist, « Sees S x
1941 1. Atlantic Coast Line. ..\.°..-.--.---- oe ae its 15,494,743 . 77,578,922 . - 19.97. 21.07 ons’ *
capt 5 ; va a
ere *, : ee ene at + et ae ete w, Tbe et nwa aster ee ateadto + eter ewe V atdl Unin-waae \Veuw, .
See Re “Service Ror ee 2! (Conta) (2)/8) 4/5) CT)
a) ae ; oe | wees: 6 (ee a Ona (8)
‘Mitiattie CATING, 5.5 cco s eects sncsceaes $12,301,040 °. 68,261,183 314
3. Loubvillo & Nashville... +.... 0.6.0... 000 15,045,666 —-.63, 219, 808 294 , 867,671 22,726 , 968 - 23.80. 12.53 .- 1.90
6, Meme PAI ooo cece pen cs cecceiwes: /157 1,375,078 - 5,330,683 --. 792,455 | 28.59 6.74 4.23 -
5. Seaboard Air Line... ..... RR ea Fn . 10,759, 112° 48,383,349 189,684,100.) 11,371,856 22.24 16.68 1.33
@ Re RS a wlysae.sk 18,890,778 84,944,242 — 344,883,906 | :27,892,745 21.80 12.36 1.76
otek: "Aad aee seteer eer ere — BF; 814; 065 266; 945,892 -1,029,566,913° 79,039,802. . 21.47 - 13.03" 1.65
te Const Lie... sighs cose. sees] 54,724,494 250,255,314. 661,166,152 70,184,580 21.87 - 9.42. 2.32
on + Cc Sy mri OIE 12,389,714 ; 65,942,853. 196,683,229: 16,573,203 “18.80. 11.87. - 1 58-
wale Aa Got Lie... beeas cabiataadente . 186,686- . :s 719,544 © 2,644,473 . 408, 892 35 08 S.47 4.01
3. Louisville & Nashville.......... ae ie. 14,427,918 60,494,322 231,363,635: 21,066, 363 2385 10.98 2.17
4. Norfolk i SpE RR NT WR Ms : 287,819 - 998, 781 2,049,948 416,311 28. 82 4.92 5.86
5. Seaboard Air Line...... i ias bias aun “711,300,540. - 49,386,785 | 228,809,547 12,888,171 22 90 17:75 Se rere Were er. 18,096,003. ° 79,798,391 -- 307,338,176 _ 22,003,737 “ 22.68 - 13.97 1.62
eg. a SCE ERED 2: 60,067,112 268,260,759 1,179, 510,872 78,266,535 22.39 15.07 1.49
+ ffol, 83-84) | 3 : . ae eo. 7
SNE eo POR rey 15,494,743 .° 77,578,922. 477,708,832 22,673, 122 19.97 21.07 95
_ : Riootie Cock Lipo... Serves verte 3 «th he 170,3 . 748,798: 3,344, 286 ¢ 410,022 22.750 8.16 2 79.
3. Louisviue & Nashviue.......000.5:.---4-48 16 024, 767 66 , 230,540 356 499, 273 23, 282, 987 24.20° - 15.31 1.58
4. Norfock Southern......,. ...:..-- Leer aca 312,476 989,667. 2,915,628 331, 368 31.57 8.80 3.59
5: Seaboard Air Line.........+.-. eished ng caeen . > 14,550,679- 61,296,640 ~ 452,214,413 © 17,664 ,869 * 23.74 | 25.60 .93
ie ee epee cc cockdy umadentaaes 191726194: = 88,664,956 - 489,114,686~ 26 , 666 , 633 22.25 18 34 131
cau)” ORE aR a RS ... | 66,279,236 . 295, 509,523. 1,781, 797,118 91,029, 001 22.43 19.57 1.15
; tie Coast Line.....- 6.0.0... eee. see... ~~, 20,093,085 - 94,949,819 _ 971,960,340 31,353,218 21.16% 31,00 68
ISS Gaede. SS a 140,006 6,288,688" a7 28 8.6 13.29 2:15
8. Louleville & Neshville............. ciiiciess | 1,UN9018 85,444,354; 790,901,585 30,610, 537 “4.72 | 28.13 95.
4 Norfolk Southern .. aaeee Serer eee eee eee ee a ’ AL + 4 11,630,561 : ‘ 25 a 3 - 4 1.07
wd Air Lime... ... .- 00 ee cece cnee R ; t ® . 4 i ? me:
—...... At IS wes, ‘Geolrae 1.ieetor.oeo: ~~ oe.0en.7a. 18 32.16 a
iia... ree TIeT “eer; ek a a.
1968 1. -A 100,225,009 1,008,004,635 © 36,757,304 25.17 —- a
g . - By 74 1.0 4.94
: Hy 109, ‘Fe 1.80 78 2,357 as 8 45.90 ri
3 ‘08 ‘ : : A. . 1.60.
. : 974 4 87 193, ft] ad 27 .@2 4.11 .61
: tit 4es | °1,616,816.430 17 31308 27 04 40.54 0
788, 6,884, 075, 302 150, 253, 563 27.13 42.91 63
Brera Anal Raper te Intraatd Cmmere Oxmenie, orcch carr indent fr yore 107 through 1045; and Form APT, Analysis of hesenger Traffic, for each carrier named,
for the of the 1987 ‘ :
" Col. Annual Reportg, p.311 in 1937 and p. for. 1988 through 1968. = its ee, ‘
Col. (3)—Annual Re EP ace Sante 43, 44, 45, 46,47. . ‘ .
Col. of Passenger Traffic. i's
Col. (5 508, Col. D, Line 42 plus 50% of Line 47
Col. (6)—Col. 2 plone by Gol. (3) ; a oe Secky
S|. oS 4) Divided by Col. (5). aa ae ‘ . : se
Col. ) Divided by Col. m3 : ‘ aa Oe : at ene
“ .. 4 8 . oS 5 We
- oh
ty

*

.
.
.
é .
.
”
.
©
.
.
:

\ x : ou i 57

_[fol. 85] Ix Unrrep States District Court

° ‘ : et f t i tle emitted a . ° -@ =,
ANswer OF Sieben Cunuenen ‘Tilninaeti~ Pied Kn une
se MW

The defendant: ‘Sudbéetete Galatians Commission, herein-
after called the Commission, in answer to the ‘petition of

the State of North C: ‘arolina and the North Carolina Utili- ;

ties Commission; Tes] ectfully states:
> J

.

1. The Commission admits for the purposes of, this suit |

~ the-sllogationa contained. in Darsergens. 100 to Rad bo

inclusive. °

.

2..(a) Further answering said paragraphs the C ommtis-
sion admits and alleges: It made the report dated March
25, 1944, and the order dated May 8, 1944, as corxected
May 24, 1944 (the order sought to be set aside in this
action). Said report and order were made in a-proceed-

-ing -entitled No. 29036, North Carolina Ihtrastate Coach —

Fares , Which involved the question whether the North Caro-
lina intrastate fares for passengets in coaches lower than

_/the interstate oach — from, to and between .points in.

vorth: Carolina, were violative. of, section 15( ayand (4)
(4)), which orbids and declares to be unlaw ful anv ‘‘rate,
fare, charge, classifieation, regulation, or. practice’? which

‘causes any undue or unreasonable advantage, ‘preference,
or prejudice e as bétween persons or localities in intrastate

\Vof the vemos C Commerce, Act (49, U. SIC. see33(3) and

commerce on the one hand and interstate or foreign com-’

merce on the other.hand, or any undue, unreasonable,
“unjust discrimination against interstate or foreign com-
merce.’

— (b) Said proceeding was instituted by the Comiunission
by order dated October 13, 1943, in response to’a petition
dated July “22, 1943, filed ander the authority of -section
13(3) of said Act, by certain, common carriers by railroad
engaged in the transportation of persons and property in

interstate commerce to, from and between points in the.

State: of North Carolina and also in the transportation of

persons and property in intrastate commerce between points ~

_in North Carolina. Said petition alleged inter rsalia that the

s

$
7. *

basic coach fares applicable on. iealesiabaie traiiie reuwli:
out southern territory (east of the Mississippi and south
__of the Ohio and Potoniac rivers}-and-generalty-on inter: ~
* [fol. 86] state traffic throughout the United States was then
2.2 cents per mile, having been established. pursuant to the ©
authority of orders of the Commission in Ex Parte 148,
- Increased Railway’ Rates, Fares, and Charges, 1942, 2
J. C2 C. 545, in which the Commission found that peceacke
fares in coaches increased 10 percent from.2 to 2:2 cents ©
per mile on interstate traffic throughout the country were 4
just and reasonable; that the intrastate coach fare then
generally in effect in North Carolina was 1 .65, cents per
~ mile; that petitioners had applied to the North Carolina -
- Utilities Commission (hereinafter called the North Caro-
lina Commission) for authority to increase the North Caro- .
. lina intrastate coach fare to the level of the interstate coach
fare then generally in effect throughout’ the, United States ©
and that such authority had been denied; and .that this :
denial of such authority by the North Carolina Commis-
sion caused violations of ‘section 13(3) and (4). of the
Interstate: Commerce Act... “ :

\
\

: (c) The Commission's order of investigation of October
13, 1943, named the petitioning railroads and all other com-
non. carriers by railroad operating within the State of
North. Carolina subject to the. jurisdiction of the Commis:

- sion as respondents, and ordered that a hearing be held for
the purpose of. receiving evidence to determine whether
the disparity between. the: interstate and intrastate. coach .
fares'caused any undue or unreasonable advantage, pref-
erence or prejudice as between persons or localities in intra- .
state-‘commerce on the one hand and interstate commerce
on thé other hand or any undue, unreasonable or unjust is®
crimination against interstate commerce ; and to deterniine \
what fares | and charges, if any, or what maximum or
minimum or maximum and minimum. fares and charges
should be prescribed to remove such unlaw ful advantage,
preference, prejudice or discrimination, if any, as might -

__ be found to exist.

oe After due notice a hearing ‘was held at Raleigh,
y..C., on December. 28 and 29, 1943 at which the interested
carriers (hereinafter called respondents), the North Caro-
lina Commission, the Prive. Administrator, and certain |

.
. ear . . ad . . ‘ )
: se : a
° - ‘

sf | ~j " 59
other parties, -by their respective coutisel, appeared and
_ participated. Substantial evidence —*xas—introdticed, the- |
testimony filling 243 typewritten pages supplemented by
21 documentary exhibits. Thereafter briefs were filed by:
the several parties and on February 18, 1944 the issues were
orally argued before the’Conimission at. Washington, D. (.
+ (e) On March 25, 1944 the Commission isgued its report
' which embraced also three -other ‘similar vases, viz.,. No.
: 28963, Alabama Intrastate Fares, No. 29000, K entucky In- ;
trastate Fares-and No. 29037, Tennessee. Intrastate Fares...» -—
- Said report appears under the title: ntrastate
___Fares, 258 T-€.-€2433, am officially printed copy of which
is attached hereto, marked Exhibit No. "hes

(f) In said report the Commission found that the inter-
state coach fare of 2.2 cents ‘in effect to, from and ‘throngh
points in North Carolina is just and reasonable; that the -

intrastate-coach fare in North Carolina of 1.65 cents is

dower than the corresponding fare of 2.2 cents applicable
interstate-generally: throuzhout southern territory and also
- generally throughout the Unit States ; that the regulatory .
authorities. of Florida, Geofgid, Louisiana, Mississippi,
__Virginia and South Carolina had approved Théfcased in
the intrastate coach fares in those States from 1.65 cents
to the interstate level of 2.2 cents, and that the 2.2-cent

-[fol. 87] fare was in effect on intrastate traffic generally
'. throughout .southern territory except intrastate in North

Carolina, Alabama, Tennessee and Kentucky; that the con-

ditions affecting the transportation of passengers in coaches

within these four States intrastate on the one hind and in-

terstate to, from and through those respective States on the ; °

other, are substantially similar; that interstate passengers
in those States travel.in the same trains and generally in the
same cars with intrastate passengers but-are forced to pay
(“higher fares than theintrastate passengers for like services,
to the undue and unreasonable advantage and preference,
of the intrastate passengers and the undue and unreason-
able disadvantage atid prejudice -of the interstate pas-
sengers; that the revenues of the respondents under the -
- lower intrastate fares are less by at least $525,000 ‘per
“annum, in North Carolina (and $725,000 per annum in
Alabama, $500,006 per annum in Kentucky. and $525,000 per
annum in Tennessee) than they would be if- those fares.
“wereincreased to the level of the corresponding interstate

‘

‘fares, and that traffic moving under these lnicase’ intrastate
fares is not contributing its fair share of the revenues re--
quired to enable respondents to render adequate and ef-
. ficient transportation service ; that the maintenance of in-
trastate coach fares in North Carolina {and Alabama, — =
‘Kentucky and Tennessee) ‘to the extent that sueh-fares are
.on a lower level than the corresponding interstate fares,
causes and will cause undue and unreasonable advantage
to and preference of persons in intrastate c6mmerce, undue
and: unreasonable disadvantage to and prejudice against
persons in interstate commerce, and ‘undue, unreasonable
and unjust discrimination : against’ interstate: commerce |.
(in'violation of said section 13(4)) ; ; and that- this unlawful-

“ness should be removed by increasing the aforesaid intra-. -
~ state fares in the respective States-to the level of the cor-:

responding interstate fares contemporaneously maintained ~
‘by respondents to, from and through such States.

(g) The. foregoing findings ‘were “without prejudice to
- the right of the authorities of the affected States, or of any -
interested party, to apply for modification thereof as to
“any specific intrastate fare on the ground that such fare.
is not related to interstate fares, i in‘such a way as to con-
. travene the provisions of the Interstate Commerce Act. ghee

th) The Commission did not immediately issue ar eles
in connection with said report. In accordance with its
practice in such proceedings, it left to respondents and the
respective State commissions the matter of adjusting the
intrastate fares to conform to said findings, but stated that
if this were not accomplished , within 30 days from the
service of the report, consideration would be given to the
entry of an appropriate order.

(i) On April 27, 1944 the North Carolina. Ceiansiosion .
_filed a petition for. further hearing, reargument and recon-
sideration of the Commission’s: report of March 25, 1944. .
On: April 26% 1944 the Price Administrator filed a petition .
- for reconsideration. On May 5, 1944 the respondents filed
a reply to said petitions. By order ease May 8, 1944 the
Commission denied said petitions. : :

(3) ‘On May 1,'1944 the respondents filed a ‘sith ‘aver-
ring that the North Carolina Commission had failed to _

- [fol.’88] (k) On May 8, ‘1944

%

- form to the findings contained

1944 and moving that. the Comm
order. — We Mae ae

order hereinbefore referred to
1944 it requires that responden

July 1, 1944 (later extended: to August
‘after maintain ahd apply pass

—\s 6
rt of March 25,

fer an appropriate

x
‘
x

», : o S/ _ ai
he Commisston issued the

As corrected on .May 24,

sal extblish on.or before
» 1944) and there-- .

' nger fares for intrastate
' _ transportation in North Carolina ‘(an in Alabama, Ken- .

tucky. and Tetinessee): which a on bases\no lower than

the respective respondents for lik

accommodations in ititer-

States; provided that tlie resulting aggregate charge made

state -transpertation to, froni i through the respective

_ by any of said respondents for in

rastate. transportation in

any of the’States ‘shall not excedd ‘the aggregate charge
made for like accommodations and for a like distance by the

- same-respondents in interstate tratisportation to, from or.
_ through such States. oe |

3. Answering paragyaphs 120,

| ‘ « &

‘ e . ,
121 and 122,.the Commis.

sion admits the allegations thereof td the extent they are

connection the Commission respectfully refers to the report

comprehensive history of said fares; and to its report of
February 28,. 1936 in Passenger Fares and-Surcharges;Q14 —
ther respectfully refers to -

IC. 1.174. The Commission fur

"its report of March 2, 1942 in Increased Railway Rates,

Fares and Charges, 1942, 248 I. Cc. C. 545, especially pages
964-566 and 606-613; to its report of April| 6, 1943 on fur- -
299 I. C. C, 357, and espec-_

ther hearing in the last-cited case,
lally pages 385-388, 394 and 395;

and to its subsequent re-

ports in that case, 256 I. €.C. 902, decided November. 8;

1943, and — I. C. C: —, decided*M
it considered thé’ revenue needs

riers of the United States.

4.-The Commission admits the
123 to-130 both inclusive,

ay 12, 1944, in all of which
of the interstate rail car-

allegations of paragraphs

c

ee

the‘intra tate fares to con:
n the ke
wi

~

= the passenger fares presently maintained and applied by |

consistent with the findings of fact in the aforesaid repert
‘of March 25, 1944, but the ea alleges that ‘said
_- paragraphs do not set forth a full, ace

urate and complete .
__ history: of the one-way. coach fares in the South. - In this

- of March 25, 1944, which,.on pages 134-136, gives a brief but |

137.

_ of March 25, 1944 (pp. 145). 150523

Je Sieiiniii paragraphs 131 and 132, the Connmiacton
admits that its exaniiner ruled that reply briefs would not -
be ‘perinitted, alleges that no complaint was made to ‘it

~ because of such ruling, alleges that oral argument ‘was syb-

sequently held, in which the. parties had full opportunity

— to reply te each other’ 3 arguments in brief and orally, said

oral arguments having been held before the Comimjssion at

ee ashington, D. C. , February 18, 1944.

6. Answering paragraphs 133° to 136 both inclusiv e, ‘the

‘Cia admits the allegations of paragraphs 133, 134,
‘135 and 136, and admits that paragraphs 133.1 to 133.6
. both inclusive summarize some of the findings i in the report

of March, 25, 1944, but the\Commission respectfully refers
the Court to the report itself\ for full, complete and accurate
information as to its — :

7. The Commission denies the allegations of paragraph :

8. Answering cuseieaghia 138 and 139, the Commission
admits the filing of the petition by the North Carolina Com- -

‘. mission asking, among other things, for rehearing, as alleged

in paragraph 138 (see paragraph: 2(i), supra), but denies

the alleged errors specified in paragraph 139.

[fol. 89] 9. The Commission admits the allegations ‘of.
paragraphs 140, 141 and 141.1.

10. Answering. paragraph 142, the Commission admits

_ that the North Carolina Commission pursued its adminis-
- trative, remedies before the Con\mission to the extent of

filing a petition for rehearing and reconsideraiion before

jnstituting the action before this ‘Court.

11. The € ommission denies the allegations of ‘paragra

- 143. . hee

——+

and: in this connection the ‘eon raneey ealls the
Court’s attention to the following findings in its report

‘By petition filed October 12, 1942, with. tk » North
Carolina’ Utilities Commission, the: several railroads;
operating in: North Carolina, with the exception of.
"the Norfolk & Western, sought authority to increase the

zn i
;

° .
Cd “. :
of ¢ F rea :
% a aie bey °
. a ‘
f -
: 9° s 4 . ~
AD f é . ’ ‘ .
. % pe 5 F > .
‘ . 4

_ the alleged- ruling was nfade in the. brief of any party. -

64. ta 4 mo os

[fol 90] 12. The Commission denice the ealleations of par-
“agraph 145.

-i4.. Answering paragraph 145.1, ‘the Commission admits
and alleges: ~The North Carolina Commission by petition
dated July 8, 1943, the Alabama Public Service Commission
by petition dated August 27, 1943 and the Price Adminis-
‘trator by petition dated July 31, 1943, requested the Com-
mission to make a further investigation of the reasoiiable- -
ness of the interstate coach fares in southern territory. |
‘Although the ‘interstate coach fares in southern. territory .
were then at the 2.2-cent level, and this level prevailed
throughout the rest of the country on interstate traffic, these ~
‘petitions made no request for a general investigation of the
reasonableness of the interstate coach fares throughout, the
country, but were restricted to southern territory. A réply
was filed by the southern territory carriers dated ‘August -
9, 1945. uging; among other things,. that there was no need
for a general investigation of the reasonableness of the ©
interstate coach fares in°effect throughout southern terri-
tory, as the Commission had recently investigated the level
of such interstate fares and had specifically approved thein —
_for general application throughout the United States. -The
Commission gave careful constderation to said. petitions .
and the reply thereto and by letter dated October 13, 1943
advised the parties that on October 11, 1943 it had —
to deny the petitions.°

15. Answering, paragraph 145. 2, the Commission denies
that any action of its examiner at the hearing in No. 29036
precluded the production of any evidence by the° North
. Carolina Commissien. or any other party bearing om the
reasonableness of the interstate fares; and alleges that the
examiner did not refuse to receive any evidence profferéd:
by the protestants at said héaring, that-no objection to the

- examiner's alleged ruling was voiced by the North Carolina
Commission: or any other party, and that no objection to

16. For answer to paragraph 145.3, the Commissioi re
spectfully refers to paragraph 5, supra. & :

17. Answering paragraph’ 145.4 and- further answering
paragraphs 145, 145.1, 145.2 and 145.3, the Commission
alleges that in the aforesaid proceeding the parties thereto,
ineluding the North es vemcex wine ‘esi were accorded the

¥
”

= 2 ; /-- * ’ >

7 full hearing provided for in and by the Interstate Commerce
Act, and the Commission denies each of and all the allega-
tions to the contrary eontained in said petition. ieee Es

_ 18. Answering paragraph 146, the Commission denies.
. that it erred in finding that the Jmterstate coach fares are

+ just and reasonable, and denies that its examiner ruled that

the interstate couch fates were not in issue. ,

-- 19. (a) Answering paragraph 147, the. Commission’ de-
nies the allegations thereof, and denies that said paragraph ‘

fully and aceurately states the holdings made in 1936 in”:
Passenger Fares and Surcharges, 214 IL. C. C. 174.- That
proceeding was a nation-wide investigation into the pas-
senger fares and charges maintained by all common car-—

Tiers by. railroad subject to the Interstate Commerce. Act.

The report finds that the basic fare prior to World War I

' Was—not, uniform throtghout’ the country, but. averaged’

about 2.5 cents per-mile. By order of. the Director General

-of Railroads the basic fare became uniform with few excep-

tions at 3 cents, béginning in 1918. In 1920 it was inereased
20 percent to 3.6 cents as autliorized by the Commission in
' Increased Rates 1920, 58 1. C. C: 220, :In the latter proceed-
ing the Commission also authorized the establishment of
(fol. 91] a 50 percent surcharge on -passengers in Pullman
. ears. (214 I. C.C., p. 186.) The latter basis remained

" in effect generally throughout the country until about 1933
- when many of the carriers in the South and the West put
~ into effect-experimental fares of 1.5 cents‘ per’ mile in an

effort to regain some-of the passenger traffic which they
had lost through the competition of “buses and the use
of private automebiles, as fully explained in Passanger

- Fares and Surcharges, sipra. (See 214 1, (. C.,fpp. 18s-

, 201 regarding the southern district, and pp. 201:206 réeard-

, ing the western district.) The 1920 basis remained in effect. -
, in the East until 1936. In the last-cited report the! Conimis-
sion reduced the 3.6-cent fare to 3 cents in Pullmans and 2

cents, in coaches, and eliminated ‘the surcharge, redicated

upon a finding that the regular passenger. fare sttucture of
. the rail. carriers throughout the country was and for the

‘future would be unreasonable to the extent that/it-exceeded

or might exceed fares of 3 cents ‘in Pullmane ani 2 cents in

coaches without prejudice to the ‘maintenance of lower fares ©
in any major district of the country.| (214 LG «,

* (5+560-561_ SO SALRSS. |

Ee f

- e . ; Fs *.
. . *]
. ° *
‘ ° .
© * 7 ; : j
, , ; ° ° /

NB

66.
256.) The Commission also theré found the then- exieting
cnpaateniantal ‘fares in the southern and western, districis
‘ were not unreasonable or otherwise unlawful. ( 214 Lc. Lm
e _ p. 257.) The ‘Commission alleges, as shown by the last:
cited. reports, that. said experimental fares of 1.5 cents per
mile in southern territory were. voluntarily established* by
“the carriers and were not prescribed by the Commission;
that said report, while finding that a coach fare-of 2 cents".
“would be a reasonable fare for.all interstate rail carriers,
- Gia not condemn the lower experimental fares of 1.5 cents
in the southern &nd western districts, and, though said vol-
untarily established fares were lower than the fare found
reasonable by the Commission for general application |
throughout the country, did not require’ those fares tobe
_ increased. The Commission respectfully calls attention to
its finding in the report of March 25, 1944, pp. 134 and 135,
that ‘The 1.5-cent fare in effect front December 1, 1933 to
\ . Naveniber 14, 1937 and from January 15, 1939 to February
A 9, 1942 [in southern territory ] was a subnormal fare main-
\tained. primarily. to attract traffic that had been. diverted «
chiefly. to priv ute automobiles,’’ (/b.,.p. 137.) -

$°

-(b) Answering the allegations of said ‘paragraph 147
A Fae respecting the burden vo pale in’ No. 29036, the Commission.
ar ran ~ alleges that the respondent rail carriers assumed_the bur
sen of proving, as alleged in their petition, that the North
eee ae Carolina intrastate coach fares cause undue preference or ‘ §
tn ord - prejudice as between persons or localities in intrastate com- ’
vs J ? merce, on the one hand, and interstate commerce on the other
} i3* , hand, and undue, unreasonable or unjust discrimination
7 es mF gainst inte’ ate ,commerce ; that said respondents pre-
Z sented substan evidence directed to sucha showi ing, and
thereupon thepfotestants presented their ev idence in oppo-
‘sition to such allegations; ;and the C ommission, after consitl-
_ fering all the ev idence, made its aforesaid report ynd deci-
-—- ° | sion. The Commission denies that it eommitted any error
; in this regard.

al

H 20. The Commission denies the allegations of paragrapli
148 to 155 both inclusive. . . os

21. ‘Answ ering piragr aph 156, the Commission denies the
allegations thereof ; and the Conmission respectfully objects
“fo the receipt as.ev idence of the ¢ affidavit referred to theremn

Y

- : \

¢

ie ee ee

. 4 ‘.

the ground that said affidavit contains new matter not intro-
duced in evidence in the proceeding before the Commission,
- is tendered as evidence de novo and is inadmissible before
[fol. 92] the Court in this suit. The Commission respect-
fully moves that said affidavit be' stricken from the petition.

157 to 165 both ‘inelusive.

23. Answering paragraph 166, the Commission denies
that its action was arbrtrary for the reason stated therein
and respectfully calls attention to the fact that it is author-.

“ized by the provisions of section 13(4) of the Interstate

whenever it’ finds after full hearing in any investigation
‘Instituted under section 13(3) that any fare made or imposed
by-#uthority of any State causes the prejudice or diserimi-
nation there forbidden, to prescribe such fare'to be gharged
‘thereafter as in its judgment will remove such prejudice or
discrimination ; and that:therefore no petition or complaint
by any other person, firm, corporation or association is
legally necessary. -- aus cheer 8

—.

it erred for the reasons stated: in said paragraph; and in
this connection the Commission. respectfully refers to its
‘answer in paragraph 23 whereof to paragraph 166 of the
_.. petition. ti Per eek ' : ,

25. Answering paragraph 168, the Commission denies that
it erred in the respect alleged i reaching the conclusion
. that the North Carolina intrastate coach fares lower than

‘preference of intrastate passengers,

_ 26. The Commission denies the allegations of paragraphs
169, 170 and 171. Further answering paragraph 171, the
- Corunission alleges that any claim or disclaim of the rail-
road petitioners in the proceeding before the North Caro-
_lina Commission is here immatérial and irrelevant.:.

21. Answering paragraph 172, the Commission denies that
it erred in aking said finding No. 6, denies that said findine:.
has the meaning ascribed to it in said paragraph 172, and’
denies the allegations of fact in said paragraph.

oy *
2 . : he .
- .
. : L
, : ‘
. - ’
‘ 3 . . ; we”)

and attached to the petition as ‘« Appendix No, 156.1,” on

22. The’ Commission denies the allegations of paragraphs :

Contmeree Act, upon the petition of the carriers concerned,

- of Answeritig para rra »h-167, the Conimission denies that ie
ig paragray

the corresponding interstate coach fares caused undue -

* -etpngeremameniastbor > cath mai y

bond pec se ; RS SS -—
erate 2

28. The Commission denies the allegations of paragraph
173. Sree

~ 29. The Commission dinites the allegations of: paragraphs

_ 174 to 180 both inclusive-and. denies that it erred en any

of the reasons alleged 1 in said paragraphs.

30. Answering paragraph 181, the Commission calls atten-

3 tion to. the fact. “that said paragraph does not/contain any

allegations of fact and deals entirely with questions of law
determinable by reference to the provisions of the Inter
state Commerce Act and pertinent decisions of the federal
courts, particularly the Supremé Court of the United §tates,
and in this connection the Commission respectfully invites
attention to the decision of the Supreme Court in Florida
v. United States, 292 U.S. 1,12; and the Commission alleges
that under said decision and other pertinent decisions, peti.
tioners are not entitled to a trial de novo in a case of this
kind.

[ fol. 93] 31. (a) Farther answering. - the petition, the Com.
mission alleges that in the aforesaid proceeding the partie.
’ thereto, including North Carelina Commission, were, and

that each of them: was, accorded the. full hearing provided

forin and by the Interstate Commerce Act; that in said hear-

- ing substantial evidence bearing upon ‘the issues Was sub-

mitted, that in briefs and in oral argument questions relat-
ing to the issues were fully argued and submitted for deter-
mination, and the Commission determinéd said matters and |
entered and served upon the parties its aforesaid. report;
that said report and said order include the Commission's
findings of fact, decisions and conclusions, and that upon -

the ev lees ‘aforesaid the Commission made the findings

and stated the conclusions upon which said. — and order
are based. — .

(b) The Coininibaion further alleges that the findings
and conclusions in said report are fully supported by the
evidence, that, in making said report it- considered and .
weighed ‘edrefully each fact, circumstance and condition .

- called to its attention on behalf ‘of. the parties by their re-

spective counsel, that said order was not made or-entered

either arbitrarily or unjustly or contrary to the relevant evi- :

dence, or without evidence to support it, that in making: said:

order the Commission did not exceed the authority which.
‘ had been duly conter red upoii it, and ay ( ‘omission denies

“

/ Sa Sa praia

each of and all the allegations to the contrary contained in
said petition. sais, ats :

s

(c) Except as herein expressly admitted, the Commission.
denies the truth of each of and all the allegations contained
in the petition insofar as they conflict either with the alle-
vations herein or with the siatements, findings, determina *

- tions or conclusions of fact contained in, the aforesaid report
of March 25, 1944. The Commission respectfully refers the
{ ourt to said report for full, complete and accurate informa-
tion concerning the confents thereof, which said report is
herehy incorporated hy reference and made a part of this

All ef whieh matters and things’ the Commission is ready
to aver, intain and prove as this Honorable Court shall .
dint, aml herelw prays that said petition be dismissed.,

Interstate Commerce ( ‘ommission, by J. Stanley
Payne, Assistant Chief Counsel:

Haniel W. Knowlton, Chief-Counsel, Of Counsel. - oP ’

tol. 98) Duly sworn to by Claude R. Porter. Jurat omit-
| ted in printing. ee

(fol. 95) | ‘Exuistt No. 1 to Answer’
~ "Interstate Commerce. Commission
No. 289637 -

yee ‘o
en Alabama Intrastate Fares

| Submitted February 18, 1944. Decided March 25, 1944 : | ;

Intrastate Passenger Fares in Alabama, Kentucky, Nort
Carolina, and Tennessee, where Lower than the Corr¢-
Sponding Interstate Fares, Found to Cause Undue Ad-
vantage, Preference,. and Prejudices as between Persons
in Intrastate Commerce on the One Hand and Interstate

—

1 This report also embraces No. 29000, Kentucky Intra-_
state Fares; No.. 29036, North Carolina Intrastate Coach
Fares; and No. 29037, Tennessee Intrastate Fares.

!

}

| fae
i
;

.

* .
° o . .

. - .
. ?

Ks ? .

-
‘ 7
: .

. Commission; Hubert Meredith and M. B. Holifield for Com-
_monwealth of Kentucky; Frank L. McCarthy, Jack E.

Price Administrator and Economic Stabilization

‘Commerce oa the Other, and Unjust Discrimination :

Senteng, tnteratete Commerce « i
Wiliam C. Burger, Charles Clark, J oseph P. Cook, James .
B. Gray, Frank W. Gwathmey;, Y.’D. Lott, Jr., Edward D.
Mohr, W. A. Northcutt, L. L. Oliver, vand Charles P. Rey- °
nolds for respondents. Oh hae yeaa gs F
Hugh White,.W. C. Harrison, ‘Gordon Persons, J.. Gi: ~
Bruce, and Norwood Johnson for Alabama Public Service

|
|

Fisher, Mrs. John W. Langley, and J. E. Marks for Railroad
Commission “of Kentucky; Stanley Winborne,: Fred C.
Hunter, R. G. Johnson, F. C. H illyer, and H. M. Nicholson
for North Carolina Utilities Commission ; and Leon Jourol- - j
man, Jr.,and J. O. Hendley for Railroad and Public Utilities

Commission of Tennessee. - _
M. D. Miller, George J: Burke, David F. Cravers, Warren
Price, Jr., Richard H. Field, and Bernard M. Fitzgerald for &

rail carriers operating, respectively, in Alabama, Kentucky,.

state application on October 1, 1942, causes any undue or »%

. e,°% . . . *
tween persons or localitids in intrastate commerce on the

James E. Burkett, W. R, McDonald, Crawford L. Pilcher, §
A.J, Young, Frank L. McCarthy, J. E. Marks, W. H. Ame-
rine, F.C. Hillyer, and Henry M. Johnson for other inter-:
veners.: poy ee os ~ seme

~ . Report of the Commission

By the Commission :

', These proceedings were heard and briefed separately, but
were orally argued together. They embody similar issues,
upon which the evidence adduced in ‘the respective proceed-
ings is substantially similar, and will be disposed of in one
report. © - | ‘ a hee
They are investigations instituted upon petitions by the
North Carolina, and “Tennessee, to determine. whether the- °
refusal of the regulatory authority of those States to av-
thorize-or permit the application to the transportation of
[fol. 96] passengérs traveling intrastate therein of fares
and charges corresponding to those established for imter-
unreasonable advantage, preference, or prejudice as’ be-

one hand, and interstate or foreign commerce on the other,
fae : . ae

Pp +

_ ’
, -
e A * ’ .
’ ° a ; .
. .

71

e

or any undue, unreasonable, or unjust discrimination
_ against interstate or forei commerce; and to determine

.what fares and charges, if Dap, at aes aoe or mini-

mum or maximum and minimum fares and charges, should -
__be prescribed to remove such advantage, preference, preju-

dice, or discrimination, if any, as might be found to ‘exist.

All common ¢arriers by railroad operating within Alabama,

Kentucky, North Carolina, ‘and Tennessee subject to our ”
- jurisdiction were made respondents, and those States were
* notified of these proceedings. | . .

The regulatory commissions of the respective ‘States in-
_tervened each in the proceeding wherein lies its chief .in-
terest ;the Price.Administrator in behalf of himself and the -
Director of Economic Stabilization intervened in all of the -

- proceedings; and several other persons or associations of
persons or corporations appeared in one or more of the pro-.
ceedings to protest against any increasg in fare.

History of rail fares.—In southern passenger association
territory, hereinafter referred to as southern territort,

—which, generally speiking, 1s.that territory east of the Mis-
sissippi River and south of the Ohio and Potomac Rivers, -
the basis of one-way fares from April 1, 1908, to June 9, 1918,
was generally 2.5 cents per mile in all classes of equipment.
On June 10, 1918, under an order of the Director General of:
Railroads, the fare was increased to 3 cents per mile in all
classes of equipment. This fare remained in effect until
August 25, 1920, but during the period’ June 10‘to Novem.
ber 30, 1918, an additional charge of 16%5 per cent:of ‘the
one-way fare was assessed for travel in sleeping and parlor.
‘cars. From August 26, 1920, to November 30, 1933, the fare
xenerally was 3.6 cents per mile in all classes of. equipment,
plus a surcharge on transportation in sleeping and. parlor

“cars on and after December 1,.1918, of 50. per cent: of the

charge madé for space occupied in such ears. Si alte
Daring 4932amd 1933, certain of the carriers operating in
‘ southern territory experimented with fares lower than 3.6
-. cents in attempts to attract additional passenger business in
competition with transportaiion by private automobiles and
in busses. . For example, from. April 1° to November 30;
1938, « experimental oneAway fares of 3 cents per mile in
sleeping or parlor cars, without a surcharge, and 2° cents
per. mile in coaches, were: maintained by the-Atlanta and .
West Point Rail Road Company, the Western Railway of

?
.

pe

oe

‘ “ .
. a
-
s A ° ‘ ole ame :
. 5 \ 7
‘ : ee an,
- ‘ ° __ \
, R e a ‘ >
- e a

. 2 . , : . e
og 6 . . 8 P
nf ° s ¢ ‘ . -
ne OO SSC CANE R ener eat atte Cea sentnsn nent iivtatiradhinti ns. me + thud erica FF a ESN OES onal
* - ‘ wie i
‘ 4s Se we a)

‘ % oe coat as a 7 :
_. Alabama, Mobile and Ohie-Rait Road Company (now part
é Gulf, Mobile and ‘Ohio Railroad Company), Louisville
+: [fol.97] and Nashville Railroad, Company, and The Nash-
ville, Chattanooga & St. Louis Railway. During the same
period the Southern Railroad system lines were experiment-
ing with coach fares of }.5-cents per mile on certain portions
of their lines. See |
On December 1, 1933, most of the lines in southern terri- -
tory established experimental fares. of 3 cents per mile in: .
sleeping and parlor cars, without a surcharge, and 1.5 ode
per mile in coaches, which remained in effect.through No- -
vember. 14, 1937.. However, a: humber of railroads kept
their one-way coach fares at 2 cents per mile during ‘this
period, but met the 1.5-cent fares maintained by other roads
where competition made that necessary. Among the lines
which retained the 2-cent coach fare during this period were
the Illinois Central Railroad Company, Mobile & Ohio, and
the St. Louis-San Francisco Railway Company. (J. M.
' Kurn and Frank A. Thompson,trustees). Recep ce
, ; | cided February 28, 1936, we reviewed railroad passenger .°
‘cc fares throughout the.nation; and found the basic fares '
to be unreasonable. “We prescribed maximum: reasonable
fares of 2 cents per mile, one way and rouid trip, in
coaches, and 3 cents per mile, one.way and round trip, in
standard pullman ears,, without prejudice to the mainte-
nance of lower fares in ¢oaches or pullman cars. The
pullman.surchiarge was found unreasonable and its cancella-
tion was required. The existing experimental fares in
- .° southern territory. were found not unreasonable or other- —
"Wise unlawful.- : , ds Se ag Ee Soe |
| On November 15, 1937, the carriers which had been
_ .Maintaining the experimental coach fare of 1.5 cents in-
creased that fare to 2 cents: per mile; but restored the
1.5-cent fare on January 15, 1939. Again, certain of the
southern lities, including the Illinois Central, Mobile &
Ohio, St. Louis-San Fransisco, and Norfolk and Western:
Railway Company, retained the 2-cent fare basis. .
By order of January 21, 1942, in Ex Parte No. 148; we
found that a Nation-wide increase of. 10 percent in fares
proposed’ by, the railroads was -necessary to enable the
7 pétitioners to continue to ‘render adequate and efficient
r transportation service during the’ national emergency, and -

—

that the proposed increased
and otherwise lawful.

and Charges, 1942, 248 J, (.

effect unti | February 10, 1942,

cents became 1.65 cents: fares
/ and fares.of 3 cents -became
/, fares were modified to. reflect.
[fol.98] fares) On various
creased fares also beeame effe
_all of the States,

in coaches in that territory to
of the coach fares then 3

098 Cents.

fares would be reasonable

See Increased Railway Rates, Fares,

C. 545, 565, 966, where the

foregoing findings were renewed and affirmed. .
The reestablished coach fares

of 1.5 éents remained in
on which dgté the 10 percent _

‘increase in fares for transportation, in both coaches and
* pullman ears beeame effective,

On that date-fares of 1.5
of 2 cents became 2.2 cents:
~The round-trip
the inerease in the one-way
subsequent dates these in-
ctive on intrastate traffic in.

"On July ‘14, 1942 the’ railroads operating in southern
‘territory filed with us a petition for
their.lower fares. for interstate one-way transportation

nuthority to increase

os

cents a mile, the basis
ghout the

remainder of the United States.

Having foun

lin Pas-

senaer F. ares and Surcharges, supra, that 2 cents per mile-

was a reasonable hasie codeh fare for application on rail-
\ Toads generally througtiout the country, including the lines
_of petitioners, we authorized petitioners by our. order of
August 1, 1942, to apply the increase of 10 percent ap-
proved-in Ex Parte No. 148 to a basic fare of 2 cents per
mile, and modified accordingly the original order in the
latter proceeding. Pursuant to that authority, one-way
“coach fares of 2.9 cents a mile tere published ‘to become
(flective October 1, 1942, on interstate traffic. Effective on
‘the same date the railroads generally throughout southern
territory, published a uniform basis of interstate round-
trip fares. to displace the round-trip fares theretofore in
effect, namely, in coaches on the basis of ‘180 percent of the
"One-way fare of 2.2 cents, or 1.98 cents a mile, with a return
limit of 3 months; and‘in sleeping*and parlor ears on. the
basis of 16654, percent of the one-way fare of 3.3 cents in
such cars, or 2.75 cents a mile,-with-a return limit of 3
inonths.. The. increased fares proposed for application
in southern territory. were protested and suspension of
their 6perations was requested by the Price Administrator,
but we déclined fo Suspend. The farés so: incrbased are
now in effect*on interstate traffic.

aR re te en eee ses

Fa’

eee An gene eee

Thereaftet, with the approval of the rate regulatory —-
authorities of those States, the. intrastate one-way and
_ round-trip coach fares and the round-trip fares in sleeping
and parlor cars were increased to the respective levels of
‘the corresponding’ interstate fares in Florida, Georgia,
Louisiana, Mississippi, Virginia, and South Carolina, and
the round-trip fares in sleeping and parlor cars were in-
‘ereased to the level of the interstate fares in such cars in
North ‘Carolina and Kentucky. The, rate regulatory-au.
thorities of Alabama, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Ken- ;
tucky have declined to authorjzé the increases sought by the |
railroads in one-way and. round-trip coach fares-in those -
’ States, andthe rate‘regulatury authorities of Alabama and
Tennessee have also. refused to authorize the increases in
the round-trip fares’ in sleeping and parlor ears: It is
those farts in the four States last ‘named which are here
under investigation. Spat sts 7
Asa basis for a finding of violation of section 13 (4) of -
the act, the interstate fares must be shown to be reason- -

Tfot99} able. Georgia Public Service Comm. v. United
States, 283 U.S. 765; United States v. Louisiana, 290 U.
S. 70. Therefore, before proceeding to a .consideration
of the evidence submitted in the respective proceedings -
bearing directly upon the issues under section 13 (4), we
shall first consider the evidence bearing upon the reason-

.‘ableness of the interstate fares.

Level of the Inte

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386404_0176%3A01. Public record. Not legal advice.
