# Transcript of Record — Chicago v. Fieldcrest Dairies, Inc.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386403_0017%3A03

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1942
- **Citation:** 316 U.S. 168

## Text

~

ae Vol HW © o&

one,

“3
eT et 1
os. 7 , - ee Ze o; 30% é

oe
‘ * / 4 %-.
e ° . ; Ps aK yon © wi &

(0

_ TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD

Supreme Court of the au States

- OCTOBER TERM, 1941

; °

© No. 706

CITY OF CHICAGO, A MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,
BOARD OF HEALTH OF THE CITY OF CHICAGO,
ET AL., PETITIONERS, — °

Vs.

° FIELDCREST DAIRIES, INC.

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH. CIRCUIT
£,
«

pag AS. ile se ele:
IN.

ing before capping................4 iene aus 1551
No. 35—Photograph of carton blanks ready for ship-

NE nk Vicks abu edhe 2A aloud baie eee eaw ee 1553
No. 36—Photograph of blank ready for gluing, capped . 1555

No -37—Photograph of carton blanks printed and ready

“) packed for shipment ...
v..
48—‘Bacterial Condition of wealiaih aiid sterilized - :
‘bottles in two plants in Chicago’’.......... 1575

49—‘‘ Bacterial Condition of 132 Pure-Pak paraf-
fined containers from eleven different milk

.. J|0—‘‘Study on the Bocteclobenioal Condition of ©

‘the Paraffin‘ Bath in Pure-Pak Machine’’. : . 1576

. 51—""Bactericidal Property -of Paraffining’’. . ..1578

52—‘‘Contamination of Milk by Pure-Pak-Machine
where practically sterile milk was bottled’*:,.1579 .

. 583—‘‘Number of Bacteria ae in the Pa-

per used for Dairy Products”? ..............1580

. 54—‘‘Bacteriological Condition of Paper Milk .

Containers beford eing)Paraffined’’*....... 1581

. 55—‘‘ Bacterial ae of Milk by the pour- ©

ing lips of Glass ‘Bottles’... 1........... .. 1582.

. 56—‘Number. of Bacteria-on and in Paper for

-Pure- Pak Container Pouring Lip’’........ 1583
—‘‘Bacterial Contamination of Milk by the —
Pouring Lip of Pure-Pak Containers’’...... 1584

. 58—‘ Effect of Paraffining on Bacteria when con-

tainers. were inoculated before Paraffining’’. .1586

No. 59—‘‘Bacterial counts of 50 glass bottles and 50
Pg ee”, gers eer rere ye ere 1587
No. 60—‘‘Bacterial Condition of Adhesives used in
: ~ Pure-Pak Containers” ......-.....- Tiyeiec ae 1588 «
No. 61—Letter Sept. 12, 1939, Fuchs ie... -, .1589
' *Public Health Service Sanitation Advisory
‘Board Action on Single-Service>Contain-
fx. i Ns ccs e Oba swaases cer cewkye ees 1590
No. 62—‘‘Sanitary Aspects of Paper Milk Con- -
ae RT sv gia's Solas tp ass tat atninen agen sn 1591 |
No. 63—‘‘ Are Paper_Milk Containers Sanitary?’’. ..1600

.64—Certificate of Incorporation of Fieldcrest .

Dairies, bt eee 1609

r¥gh # pares 1 to G00; Vol 1 pages 000 to 1e04; Vol. HIE pages 1888 to

1777.

No. 65—Certificate to do business i in Illinois of Field-

7 +2 a
\! ‘oft fa)
v

vi

crest co mis ig besae MEER CELE CLOT TEE OEE 1613
No. 66—Photograph of two trucks containing’ crated
Oe I i i ee ches Praavetees 1619

No. 67—Photograph” of ‘truck containing milk bottle

OD ONE ee Se ee Ree ot 1621 ©

No. 68—Photograph of truck containing milk bottle ©
Ws. ois can Sk oeekeewe oy eee ae
No. 69—Photograph of Blue on Bottle Co. build-

DP ic vawieka fads ale ceva rawness tke ees 1625
No. '70—Photograph of two ‘tac which crates con-
a tnin: wifi bottles. «.: .. ov césccayess ee een 1627.

No. 71—Photograph of truck containing mil&” bottle

; crates with crated bottles in shed in back-

; ground ....... Bihdveus beesecasetaeernee ». -1629
No. 72—Photograph of.. crate with empty milk bottles
Bee ee ere re Nee PPPS re ee tee ra eye 1631
No. 73—Photograph of milk bottle at laboratory with .
oa bs OME ee cease cancees apa geet 1633
No. 74—Photograph of colored man with milk bottle
at junk yard 2048 W. Lake Street ..... tay. 1635
No. 75—Photograph of close-up of bottles i in front of
Gy Se OA Fe i st eae -. 1637

Te ‘76—Photograph of “ucts ‘bettie in = Cen-

SG SE os esate Shgo cadeinkeccdbieees 1639

“No. 77—Photograph of: junk yard employees leading -

empty bottles into a milk dottle Crane 5.5. 1641

..- No. 78—Photograph of milk bottle at County Morgue..1643

No. 79-—Photograph of. ‘pysh cart man “Placing wapty’
ee rer ret eae eee 1645
No. ‘80—Photograph of E. R. Fatst-in front of filled

arate milk bottle crates in junk yard., pe wetness 1647

No. 81—Photograph of man at quarry dump picking )
Ce EPR Serr reverts Petree 1649

Vol. I pages,1 to 608; Vol. I pages G09 to 1294; Vol. III pages 1225 to
777. ~ 9 : cl soo

- No.
No.
- No..

eae

Nox 87—Letter Feb. 7, 1938, -Arnold to Scott........ 1658: -
.No.

%
83—Letter Dec. 17, 1937, Arnold to Scott........ 1651
84—Letter Arnold to Scott...........0...0.00. 1652

85—Letter Nov. 12, 1937, Fuchs to Dean, Jr... .1656
86—letter Nov. 26; 1937; Frank to Dean, Jr. . .. .1657

88—"‘ Arnold’ s suggestions to- Board of Health
BU AG hire vob vise cdedwensessibeseias 1658

No.’ 89—Letter Oct. 6,»1939, Dashiell to Bundesen. . .1661

No.
No.

No.
No.

No.
No.

No.
No.

No.
% No.
_ No.
No.

No:

92—Letter Sept. 16, 1939, Fuchs to Scott........1662
_ Derenpant’s Exuisits. eee
1 and 1B—List of questions by Rall submitted to

Carpenter before his deposition, ete. .......1663 _

1A—Index card containing notes of ‘Cakpenter.; , 1664
2—*Microbiology in pulp and paper manufac-
Pe ee ee pee Tee ep aneny ye Poke neg 1665
7—‘Nymber of bacteria enmeshed in the body
Pe ibe one yds pecs ‘5s 1671
8—Sample receipt stub Board of. Health, Bureau

OF Deity Preagueey . 2.5 05 tgs sscces err .. 1672 -
9—Laboratory card used in bacteriological and ie

chemical examination of milk by. Board of
NGI a ioc hss eevee xe dae eee ieuebeewee 1673

10—Tabulation of bacterial conterit of empty F |

milk bottles examined by Board of —
Sa | Pen ry Rann kee mane OOP ie Spr, Fee 1674

11—Record of bacterial content of empty 1 ‘a

milk bottles examined by Board of Health, etc. 1674

12—Sample as exhibit 11, oe, being tabulation
Pe NI as ys boo ve vac o's anes 1675 “°
‘13—Same as exhibit 11,. ‘but being for 4 quart
- bottles ..... Saas oh Sed ween Ca Kee 1675
14—Same as exhibit 11, but being ~_ 4 pint 3°
I Nero 1 Pa 6c wad ewes nea OE Boke og Chae .1676

15—Tabulation of laboratory record cards show- :

- ing violations but size of ‘bottle unclassified . . 1676

a7¥il F pages 1 to €08; Vol. I pages 600 to 1884; Yol TIT pages 1008 to

_s

a —
.

° No. 16—Seetion 10, U. S. Public Health avigs stand-

‘-ard niftk ordinance .............0....0008. 1677
-No: 17—Copy of section 10, of Publie Health Serv-

ee: ice milk ordinance as amended June, 1939. ..1678
* No. 18—Tabulation of samples of empty milk bottles

a and. results of bacteriological ‘examination,

an, ee es ee eS reeds 1679
“ No. 19—Tabuiation’ showing results of parelle experi:
, * ments Pere eee eee reer, See Terre ee 1687

No. 20—Report of tests using wet ‘and*dry plaques

after being run through paraffin bath, etc. ..1689 _

ie 21—Result of tests as:in exhibit 20, but experi-

ments conducted at later time’.......... Fees ae

No. 22—Letter January 13, 1936, Dean Milk Co. to—
_ Bundesen ..... S Om opie rere rere
No. 23—Letter August 2, 1938, — Corp..to

WN oo ivi s en habedeae sacs Pe |

No. 25—-Regulation adopted Angast 6, 1935 concern-
;, ing type of milk and cream to be used in man-.

ufacture of butter, ete. ..... Save ee css nuns ee

No. 26—Regulation adopted Nov. 12, 1935, requiring

: that milk and milk products be served and

dispensed to’ consumer in original unopened |
container as received from distributor... ..1697

No. 27—Resolution adopted July 18, 1939, as to use of

standard nutrient, agar, prescribed in 6th

. edition of American Public Health. Associa-

tion ‘Standard Methods of*Milk Analysis’’.1697 _

No. 29—Resolution presented to Board of Health Oct.
16, 1939 with respect to puacuariian con-

tainers for milk ...........ctccsegeeees - ++ 1698 ©

| No. 30—Letter June 27, 1939, Ranan to Bundegen... .1705
No. 31—Excerpts from minutes of- ‘Board of Health

- meeting May 15, 1939....... a Sbeeiae nwa ness 1705 .

Vol. ¥ pagve 1 to 008) Vol 1 pages 000 to 18M; Vol HIE pages 1006 to
ivv7?. :
a

’ ix ; ; é ‘ Si
Ckiddice. to depuitiiaine’ filed brit 27, 1940........1709
Master’s report filed April 27, 1940................ 1710
- Notice of objections filed May 7, 1940...... eae Cea 1737
_ Objections to Master’s report filed May 7, 1940..... 1738
Notice of motion filed May 14, 1900.25... ATO
Motion for decree filed May 14, 1940...... foeuae ot 1751
Order continuing motion for- entry. decree entered ‘
| Bs SOO cv citnnn oe ORs vcdceetsetacs ce eateeny 1752
Memorandum: filed October 18, eee ae ...1752
Findings of fact filed October 23, 1940............. 1756
Conclusions of law filed October 23, 1940............ 1758
‘Decree-entered October 23, 1940...0.......... eres
Master’s ‘certificate filed October 23, 1940.:........1761 .
Notice of appeal filed October’ 23, 1940.......... \.. 1762,
Statement of points filed November 15, 1940.:..... .1763 ©
Clerk’s certificate of service: ...........6.ccc ee eee 1765. -
| Appellant’s designation for short record fia hab onus 1766
CET PURE EPC ETTECLTT CLE RT ET ETT CS 1767
-. _ Notice of-motion ............... Ee Pee AT eS es eo | Sale
Motion for stay of decree filed October 24, 1940....:. 1770
-Order denying stay of decree filed October 24, 1940...1771
Designation of record.............+-s6seeeeeeeeees .1772
Order re filing transcript... 2......... ecene ie sacea 1774
-Stipulation as to exhibits............. ae eka 1774
SO Se II oi ee Sip keekswsknsninnasainnny 1775
Clerk’s certificate ..........+..... Seep csees ere 1776.

Stipulation as to printing .. Petra teeeeeeedti athe kas 1777 ©

“Est pages 3 wo oes Vol Ht pases 000 fo Sa04i Vol KI peawe 1A08 to

>

“F

Testimony of Robert A. Black. = = 1225

ROBERT A. BLACK, called as a witness on behalf of
pag’ iow: having been first duly" sworn, testified
» as OLLOWS :

on pears by Mr. Slade:
Will you state your nanie, ‘aie, Doctor?

Q.

A. Robert A. Black.

Q. d where do you live, sir?

A. Prado Hotél.

Q. And your occupation is what?

&@. Ph n, pediptrician.

Q. When w u licensed to practice medicine in

Q. : What educational institutions dia you attend,
: Doctor? :

A. Washington Academy, Iowa State Normal, Soon
Fr University and Northwestern University.

Q. Are you affiliated with any medical societies? .
A: Chicago Medical Society, Chicago Pédiatric.Society,
Chicago Institute of Medicine, American College of Physi-:
are the Ameri As ademy of Pediatricians, the A.

-Q, - “That is the
A. Yes.
7 Q. At the present time, doctor, are you connected with
any educational institution?
'. A. Loyola University.
Q. In what capacity?
- A... Presumably the head of the department of “Pedia-
trics, although I am still on leave, though still teaching.
Q.. Are there any other educational institutions that
you are now connected with, Doctor? —
A. No other educational. . ,
Q. What is the nature of your practice, Doctor?
A. Children, entirely.
Q. Are you connected with the Board of Health of the
__ City of Chicago?
2008 A. Yes, sir.
Q. In what: capacity are you samneaied with the
Board of Health of the City of Chicago?
A. As a member. |
Q. Have you served in, any other capacity? 4

Re aa

Te can Medical Association?

1226 Transcript of Testimony Before Master. |

A. I was acting president from some time in the latter
& of November until some time in the latter: part of

q. aoe of 1938 and May of 19397
es
Q. During th e you- have been connected with the
Board of Health\gf the City of Chicago — you had
occasion to consider the matter of the use of paper con-
tainers for the distribution of fresh fluid milk in the city!
A. Yes, sir.
~-Q. When did that matter first come to your attention,
Doctor, as nearly as you can remember? =
A. Some time in the last part - -of December or the -
early part of January. -
Q. Of what year?
A. Either December of 1938 or January of 1939, in
the very last or the gg | beginning. is
Q. ‘In your opinion, Doctor, is milk an ebeential item
in the diet of infants?
2009 |
A. . After you handle babies awhile you aveid every
appearance of evil, even. Ifyou know it is not particu-.
‘larly harmful, or if you have no thought that it is par-
ticularly harmful, you are going to.*avoid any chance
whatever, ‘anyway.
Mr. Schaefer: That is all.

Cross-Examination by Mr. Gariepy. ..

. Doctor, do you know any cases of record where

.2011 babies have been afflicted with any disease of the
intestinal tract and that the disease has been aggra- -

vated by reason of undissolved paraffin in milk?.

rOPopro

Testimony of Franc A. Duta 1231

A. Seven years.

As a member of ‘the Board of Health of the . City
‘of © icago have you had occasion to consider the question
. of the use of papey containers for the distribution of fresh
. fluid milk in the city?
. Yes, sir.- :

- Q. Wher did that matter first come ra your attention?
A. . Why, it is some time ago. I do not remember ex-

actly the date.
he What personal knowledge, if any, doctor, do you

have of the operation of paper mills? .
None whatever. :

Q. Which manufacture paper board for use in paper
milk containers? ,

A. None. - t

Q. Do you have any personal knoeienes of the op-
‘eration of any paper mills? :

‘A. Thave not.

. What personal knowledge, if any, do. you have of
the operation of plants in which paper board for. use in
milk@containers is cut end printed?
2018, ' A. None whatever.
. What personal knowledge do you have, if any,
as to the bacterial effect of paraffin on paper?

A. Ihave none at all: I don’t know much about = :.

.* Q. Doctor, have you any personal opinion as to whether
or not the use of paper containers for the distribution of
fresh fluid milk-should be permitted in the city of Chicago? —
_ Mr. Gariepy: I object to that question, as showing no-
qualifications or ability or knowledge on the part of this

witness to answer that” question intelligently.

. -The Master: I will sustain the objection. He has voted
as a member of the Board of Health. That is official action.

You are now. calling: him to impeach his own vote?

Mr. Schaefer: No, sir, I am not. You expressed some
concern as to why these witnesses were called. —

The Master: Not concern. Just interest.

Mr. Schaefer: Then interest. Let me ‘explain my posi-
| tion, if you will, Master.

What is involved i in this case, as I see it, is the reason-
ableness of an.ordinance of the City of Chicago. Going to
that question, you have been hearing evidente over an ex-

tended period, introduced on behalf of\the plaintiff.
2019 tending or intended: to show the unreasonableness of
that ordinance, and evidence introduced on behalf of

1232 , Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

. the iia cuittes or intended to show the réasonable- -

ness of that ordinance..

The Master: No, I don’t think that is stating the issue
- quite accurately. As I recall the pleadings, there are two
‘points here. First, that the ordinance should be const
- as broad enough to include within the term of Piss ae
milk bottle’’ paper containers. |

Mr. Schaefer: That is right.

The Master: And, secondly, if ‘the ordinance is inter-
preted so as to exclude the single service container, then
_ the ordinance or the acti on of the Board of Health there-
under is arbitrary. and¥discriminatory and unreasonable.

Mr. Schaefer: That is right, yes, sir. It is.to the second
point.that I-was addressing myself, as obviously this testi-
mony has not to do with the first point.

The Master: You are talking about the ordinance. No-
body ‘+has introduced.any evidence here as to the resolution
of the Board of Health, until you just brought it in here this
afternoon, and the Board of Health, up to this time,.in its’

answer at least, made the contention, or made a double ©
* 2020 contention, namely, first, that the ordinance, properly

construed, excluded the single service container, and,
secondly,. that the allegations of the bill of complaint, to”
the effect that the containers are safe and free from any
objection, are not well taken; in other words, you deny all
of their allegations as to safety.
Be a Schaefer: And we assert the ordinance is reason-

e

The Master: All right. -Now then, you bring in the reso-
lution of the Roard of Health, which is a recommendation to
the City Council to amend the ordinance to include the
_ Single service containers specifically. >
- Mr. Schaefer: Yes, sir.

The Master: It is to be assumed that unless they neal
the containers were Safe, they would not make any such
recommendation, so that, if anything, the resolution tends
to establish the contention of the plaintiff here, that there
is no objection to the containers on the ground that they
are unsafe or anhealthful.

Now, you come in here with witnesses from the Board of
Health. I do not know what their purpose’is. You started

* out, by putting them on as witnesses im chief, as just
202i further experts. The case was reopened here to give
you an rapperany to. ae in some evidence concern-

~~
5*
~ we 7
. ba
ee oo es
4 ‘ 4 . >

“but he has already gone on record,
by Exhibit 29, in saying the ordinance should permit their
‘use, and he cannot impeach his own action.
- The Master: That is another question. I think it. is
“agreed here that if paper ‘board containers are absorbent,
there is somésignificance to it. -
Mr. Gariepy >. . There cannot be any public health sig-
. nificance that means anything, otherwise _ would not
have passed a resolution ai
- The Master: | He says he does regard it ‘as significant.
‘Q. Now, you‘Have said that you regard it as of some
public health significance? ay
A. Yes. —
Q. ‘Do you have any teeksisioal eta as to in what
respect and what effect it may have? :
A. Well— - &

Q. Let me put it this way: Do you leks any technical :

pr pc concerning the e oat of the absorbing qualities
ns Gans milk containers ?.
Only that the United States Public Health Service
also ioien that they aré absorbent.
2034 - Q. I say, do you have any technical knowledge on
-¢ . the subject as to the effect on ‘the public health?

Am

1240 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

A. Only what I have been told by the Seton or mem--
bers. of the Board.

Mr. Schaefer: That is not my question. That questien
assumes that technical knowledge is necessary to dete!
"mine whether or not there is public health significance in _
the fact a milk container is absorbent. That I submit is a
matter that does not require any technical knowledge to.
_answer. Some of the other questions may, but that ques-
tion does not.

The Master: He has stated whatever he. knows about the
subject is based upon somebody’s else statements to him.

I think it is conceded here that if paper board containers
are absorbent, it is a question of public health significance.
Now then you proceed to ask him in what respect.

Mr. Schaefer: Yes, sir.

The Master: How can he now 3 in what respect?

_ sMreSchaefer: Let us sée whether he can answer that.

The Master: He stated he has no knowledge of the sub-
ject.

Mr. Sehasler: He stated in answer to-your question that ;

he had no technical knowledge.
2035. The Master: Yes.

___-Mr.-Schaefer: That, is a question for whith tech-
nical knowledge i is not necessary.

The Master: Let us see now. -

Q. Do you have any knowledge of any kind upon that
subject, of your own?

A. Only that if it is absorbent and milk is put into
the- paper centainer, the milk naturally will absorb any |
ingredients or bacteria that may. be in the paper.

Q. That is the extent of your knowledge on the subject?

A. (Witness nods affirmativ ely.)

Mr. Gariepy: The witness is shaking his head, ee
_ Reporter, yes. |
‘ . The Master: Anything further?

Mr. Schaefer: Q. Do you attach any public. health
significance to the fact that paraffin gets into’ the milk
which is placed in paraffined paper milk containers?

“Mr. Gariepy: I object to that question. It is an assump- -
tion on the part of counsel that it does. If this witness-~
is not qualified to answer from a public health a
‘then he should not*be permitted to answer.

The Master: Q. What is your business?

Colloquy. . | . 39a |

2036 A. What is my line of business? ,

_Q. Yes. I notice he called you Mr. Reynolds. 1.
don’t know whether he asked you your occupation.
A. Iam the layman member ofthe Board of Health. I
am president of the Independent Boiler and Tank Company.

The Master: How is this witness qualified to give an
opinion on the subject of the effect of paraffin?

* Mr. Schaefer: Here again I say it does not require any _
technical knowledge, bacteriological, medical or otherwise. _
Mr. Gariepy: Then you can ask a layman about it,
Master. ~ , ae ee 3 :

- The Master:. Yes. #§£#-- oe ie
Mr. Schaefer: That is what I am doing. ;
Mr. Gariepy: Then the Master takes notice of it as a
matter of common knowledge.’
’ . Mr. Schaefer: That is all, Mr. Reynolds.
Mr. Gariepy: That is all.
(Witness excused.) : | eee
The Master: Off the record.
_ (Disevission had off the record.) |
- Mr..Schaefer: I offer in evidence Defendants’ Exhibits
29 and 30. !
. The Master: What arethey? —_.

2037 . Mr. Schaefer: Defendants’ Exhibit 29 is a copy

__of a resolution adopted by the Board of Health of
the Cit} of Chicago on October 16th, 1939; with respect to
_ single service containers for milk, consisting of seven

pages, ;

Defendants’ Exhibit 30 is a photostatic copy of a letter
from Thomas Parran, Surgeon-General of the United
States of America, addressed to Doctor Herman N. Bun-
. desen, dated June 27th, 1939, received by the Board of
- Health July 5; 1939, transmitting to Doctor Bundesen
_ copies of the regulations adopted by the United States

Public Health Service with respect to paper containers.
That consists of three sheets. . ; seo at Paine

of agreement of counsel, the last two pages of the De-
fen ants’ Exhibit 30 are withdrawn,,because they are
identical with the last two pages of Plaintiff’s Exhibit 61.

The Master: Defendants’ Exhibits 29 and 30 may be
“(Said be st seni

id documents, being copy of resolution adopted by -
Board of Health, October 16, 1939 with respect “4 stiglo
service containers, and a photostatic copy of letter from

”
f

2

1242 Transcript of Testimony Before- Master.

Thomas Parran to Doctor Bundesen, dated June 27,
2038 1939, were received in evidence and marked respee
tively DEFENDANTS’ EXHIBITS 29 and 30, and

are attached hereto and made a part of the record hereof.) ry

Mr. Schaefer: That is-all, sir. We close now. .
Mr. Gariepy: We have Thureday, I understand, for |

_ our rebuttal?

The Master: Yes. ‘Let the vend show that this hear-

. ing will-be resumed at 10:00 o’clock A. M. on next Thurs-

day..

(Whereupon an adjournment was taken in the above en-
titled cause to 10:00 0 ’clock A. M., Thursday, October 26,

_ ) 7

Eoerwra of David J. Davis. | 3043

2039 ee oe (Caption) °

Thifrsday, October 26, 1939, .
10:00 o’clock a. m.

Met, pursiant to adjournment. —

Present: °

Mr. Gariepy, Mr. Rall, on behalf of plaintiff.
Mr. Schaefer, Mr. Horan, on behalf of defendants.

2040 Mr. Gariepy: Swear the witness please, Master.

“DAVID J. DAVIS, enlied an 0 wiknnes on teal of the
plaintiff, in rebuttal, — been first duly sworn, testi-
fied as follows:

Direct Sissies by Mr. ‘Gariepy.

‘ Q. State your name, please.

A. David J. Davis. 4

Q. And _ address, residence.

A. 721 Elmwood avenue, Wilmette.

Q. What is your business or occupation?
_ A. Dean of the College of Medicine, University of Illi-
nois.

Q. And hew long have you been such ?

A. Fifteen years.

Q. Is Doster Lloyd Arnold.one of the professors at the
University of Illinois, under your jurisdiction?

pe

Yes
Q. I iaiesiened you té produce the contract of employ-
ment between the University of Illinois and Doctor Lloyd
Arnold concerning his services there.
oA. Yes. Al road
Q. a = ‘that ith you?

. 2041 ny Will you. uce it, please! |

A. Yes (han ing document to Mr. Gariepy).

Mr. Gariepy: Mr. Golding, will you mark that Piain-

-tiff’s Exhibit 20 for identification? - . 7
(The document Yeferred .to was thereupon-.marked —

Plaintiff’s areas No. 90 for eenention.)

' ” 1711, to be exact, that he had a

ye
1244 ‘Transcript of Testimony Before Master. .

— Gariepy: Doctor, showing you Pluintiff’s Ex-
hibit No: 90 for i entification; which 4g just handed to
me, a blue piece of paper dated July 1939, is thatthe.
resent existing contract of the University of Illinois with

Bestes Lloyd ;Arnold for his professional services as a

professor and ember of the staff ? j

A. Yes.

. Q. Is there any other. contrast with Doctor Arnold con-.

‘cerning his services and the time he is to put in at the —

. University and the time outside? —

A. No.

. That is all?
—That is = a

Mr. Garie ‘I offer that in evidence, counsel. as

PLAINTIF % ‘EXHIBIT 90. -
Mr. Schaefer: The only objection to that is as to the

"a We are running up a record here. I do not

t Doctor Arnold’s contract with the University

2042 is pertinent. I do not have any feeling ®ne way or
the other, if. P ap want to let it in.

Mr. Gariepy : answer to that is that this is compe--

tent. - Doctor | Arnold 4: in the record, Page

act with the Board of
Trustees of the ‘University of IlMefois for 80 per cent of
his time.

_ Mr. Schaefer: That is what I say. If you want to put

‘it in, O. K.; I don’t care. To save time, I will withdraw

the objection. :

Mt. Gariepy: No, we withdraw the offer, ther’

- Q. Is there any other contract that you have with Doe- 4

os —_ concerning his services?
oO ;
Mr. Gariepy: You keep this paper pe doctor. ‘Is
‘there any cross-examination?
Mr. Schaefer: No.
; Pres a Doetor\Lioyd Arnoid, will ‘you take the ©
stan
Mr. Schaefer: Are you Rey with Dean Davis?
‘Mr. Gariepy: Yes.
(Witness excused.) — - 7
_ Mr. Schaefer: I am just asiibihie what the stehes of.
the tecord is. “ | .
The Master: This is rebuttal, now.
2043 ~Mr. Schaefer: Yes, I am wondering with respect
to this point. Doctor Arnold’s testimony is to the —

a

a

Testimony of Lloyd Arnold. 1945

effect. that his contract called for 80 per éent of his time
has been challenged and the contraet has been produced.

The Master: It shows in the record.

Mr. Schaefer: It has been subpoenaed all over; town.
It has been here. Os : ;
' The Master: The record now shows that he spends 80
per cent of his time under his contract or he igs obligated
to spend 80 per cent of his time. You made that state-
ment that the contract shows it and it is conceded by Mr.
Gariepy. | z
Mr. Behscten: If ‘that is conceded, all right. >
The Master: Although I do not know what the mate-
- riality is, whether he spends 80 or 50 or 40 per cent of his ©

time there. I don’t. know what that has to do with the

case. : .

‘LLOYD ARNOLD, recalled as a witnéss on behalf of the:
plaintiff, in rebuttal, having been heretofore duly sworn, -
. Tesumed the stand and testified further as follows: y

: . Direct Examination by Mr. Gariepy.

Q. Doctor Arnold, you are the same Doctor Ar-

2044 nold = testified here the other day? :

Q. And did I understand: you to say you were professor
of bacteriology at Loyola University in 1922?

A. ‘In 1921. I think I came there in 1921 or 1922, yes,
sir. Aen > | .
At what office, what position?

A. I came there in bacteriology, pathology, public
health and clinical diagnosis.

Q. As professor?

A. I came there as associate professor and ther was

‘promoted-to professor. _ sa

Q. And what year were you promoted to professor?

A. I have forgotten. The first or second year I was
there. I think the second year. |

Q. That would be what year? - Cee

A. About 1922, I expect, or 1923, I don’t know which. |

Q. Will you look at a bulletin of the Loyola University —
_ School of Medicine for the year of 1921-1922, especially
. with reference to page 18, listing you.as a-member of the

1246 §=Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

' faculty, and tell me ‘ibaa that is a correct listing on
. the lefthand sheet there? |
A. Yes, sir.
. Q. As assistant iia
2045

May I see them? . {oye

Q.
ve “ Yes. (Witness hands cards to Mr: ariepy. ).
A.

Are thesé inthe order they were made out, by dates?
-They are mixed. We had to get thein at random
this morning. We would have to bring in three hundred
of them, to bring them all in.
Q Can you pick out any of these cards by: —. tests,
Mr. Martinek, on Pure-Pak containers?
2049 A. These were all picked 4s Pure- Palthis 1 morn-
ing. The numbers were referred to, the ones we have
there, on the bottoms of the cartons. I can pick out any.
one you wish. | 13
Q. You say these are all Pure*Pak?
. Yes, sir. .
Q. What shows that?. ‘These are just blank numbers.

How do you refer to Pure- Pak or another container on |

there?

‘A.> This dairy number will be found on & Pure- Pak.
container.

Q. “Where are those sidiitdheasa®’

-A. They are right here, these cards here, right back

| there. I will bring them out for you.

Q. No, I will get them. Are these the folders in which

they came? .
- A. Yes. .
Q.° These’ are Bowman folders? :
A... We. just saved them. I don’t know that they ex-
actly came in those, bat we kept the carton: forms, those

. folders. .

6

Testimony of Matthew J. Martinek, 1249

. Where is there anythin on there about Dean or
'-Fieldcrest, on these folders? Ue got them around Cook _
an or within a radius of seventy-five miles didn’t
you
A. I suppose so.. I don’t know .where they got.
them. « :
2050 The Master: Q. You did not get them?
A. No, I didn’t get those, no. -
- Mr. Gariepy: Q. And these are the total inmhae of
- Pure-Pak containers that you say you performed these
tests concerning paraffin suspension in milk on? g
' » Avs No, sir, they are not.all. °
Q. How many more of them arg there, Mr. M artinek?
A. I don’t know. :
‘Q. There is about thirty of them? |
A. Here is the only. thing. When I counted these up
I counted them with the others, with the American Can,
so I don’t know. |
Mr. Schaefer: Mr. Martinek, you might explain ma the
_ Master at what time this subpoena was served on you.
A. It was brought in at 9:00. 0’clock his. morning. |
Mr. Gariepy: Q. These numbers that you refer to on
the cards, are these nurhbers indicated on the flaps, is that
‘right? - ab v4 ;
A. Xe. + ‘|
' Q. You don’t know. anything ‘about the condition: in
which these containers that you brought in here this ‘morn-
ing. were taken from the plant, do yout

A. I do not.
2051. Q. Or whether they were taken from the. plant?
_ A. I do not.

°. How many altogether, do you know, Mr. Martinek,
by looking at these cards, can you tell the Master you per-
— araffin suspension tests on?.

Oh, about twenty or’ so. : i '
Twenty or eof: =. on ae eee

Is. that all, or just Pure-Pak?
Well, nb.. There were three hundred, but my chem-
ran some pf the tests. I supervised the work.
oo ere threé hundred on Pure-Pak?

ae 3
‘Or three hundred altogether? ;
"A. .I don’t know how many on Pure- Pak. ; -I absolutely
have 1 no idea. ,

és Per

ist

>) re

g

1250 . ‘Transcript of Testimony Before. Master.

- Q And that applies ‘to the testimony you gave in the
record from page 1602 to page 1612 concerning this paraf-
fin suspension test on all of them? You sel |
ones it pertains to, is that it?

‘Mr. Schaefer: I fone to that. How can {the witness

: Q. De yon kao? ZS
2052 Mn scones If the Master please, he has not °
> seen the transcript. ;
The’ Witness: What is that? .
- The Master: Read the question.
z (Mr. Gariepy’s last question was read as above re-
corded.
Mr. Gariepy: Q. Whether Pure-Pak or another da
of container. -

fo I do not.
Q. ‘Did you perform any tests in connection with these
_ containers concerning lead content in milk?
wee {fF yf
Mr. Gariepy: That is all, Mr. Martinek.
~The Master: Any cross?

Cross- Examination by Mr. Schaefer.

Q. To the’ best .of your recollection, Mr. Martinek, how
many of ‘the containers that you examined for paraffin
suspension*in milk were ‘containers of the Pure-Pak type,
which is the type that you have here? ——

A. It is pretty hard to say, because wé had theni mixed.’
At one time we had quite a few Pure-Paks and then we
had the American Can also. It would be pretty hard to
tell, because it would be purely a guess and I wool not :

want to guess. -
2053 ‘ Q. The records would show? :
mtg. The records would show, if we sorted them
out. t is what we are doing now.

Mr. Schaefer: ‘That is all.
Redirect Examination by Mr. Gariepy.

Q. - Are they in the same condition, ‘these containers
you brought over this morning, as when you received
them ?. |

Testimony of William D. McNally. 4951.

A. They also have the methylene blue streaks in them
30 they might he slightly damaged. T would not —
t ;

Mr. Gariepy: I see. That is all. .

Mr. Schaefer: That is all. Thank you, Mr. Martinek.
(Witness excused.)

“ Mr. Gariepy: I have’ not had an opportunity to say

have néver him. So I am going to ask Mr. Rall, who has
talked to him, to ask him the questions.

2054 “WILLIAM D. McNALLY, called as a witness on be-
half of the plaintiff, in ‘rebuttal, having been first
| duly sworn, testified as follows:

ee noah a, a asntiatio’ by Mr. Rall.

‘Will you state your name, please?
William D. McNally. ;

Where do you live? é

3734 North Harding avenue, Chicago, Illinois. .
What is your profession or ‘occupation?

I am a physician and toxicologist. :

; Are you licensed to practice medicine i in the state of
- Tinois? .

A. I have practiced medicine and have been licensed -
over twenty years in the city of. Chicago, Cook County,
Illinois.

Q. Did you attend any schools in aki caress for the
practice of medicine?

A. I did..

'. Q. Where? |
. A. Phe University of Michigan, University of Illinois,
and Chicago Rush Medical College. —

Q. Did you receive any degrees from any of these

_ schools? -

2055 We will have a recéss of a few
minutes, then.

o

Mr. Schaefer: ahis i is off ~ ‘Fecord. It j is now 12:00 i

o’clock noon.
(Discussion off the record.) .
The Master: We will recess until 1 :30, in this room:

(Whereupon a recess was taken to 1:30 o’clock p. m.
of the same day, Thursday, October 26; 1939.)

2092 : oe * eee

Thursday, October 26, 1939, —
1:30 o’clock P. M.
Met pursuant to recess. | .

Present: Same as before.

_ The Master: You may proceed.

Mr. Rall: While we are waiting for the witness, there
are some exhibits which we want to offer that we might
consider. Mr. Horan and I went over the list. of exhibits
yeaterday.

Plaintiff ’s Exhibit 42, being a picture of a soaker bottle
washer, which was identified at Page 487 of the transcript,
. simply to show the type of machine the witness was dis-
cussing,’ was not offered in evidence, and we now desire
to offer it.

_Mr. Schaefer: . I have no objection.

(Bei b geod It may be received. .
hotograph of soaker bottle washer so of-
oe re naive in evidence, was marked PLAIN-
TIFF’S EXHIBIT NO. 42 and is attached hereto and made
‘a — hereof.)

r. Rall: plaintiff ’s Exhibit 47-A was included in a
general offer, identified at Page 946 of the transcript, but
was omitted in the list of exhibits received at Page 1025.
We re-offer that, to correct the record. __-

The Master: "Any objection?

Mr. Schaefer: No.

The Master: It'may be received.

(Said document so offered and received in ‘evidence, was
marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 47-A and is attached

hereto and made 8 part hereof. )

, :
@ ; . °

oe

: 1272—Trans cript of Testimony Before Master.

Mr. Rall: Plaintiff?s Exhibit 57, referred‘to by Doctor
. Prucha, was identified at-Page 988 of the Pacts. t, but .
was erroneously omitted in the offer of the exhi its at
Page 1025 of the transcript. We would like to offer that
' at this time.

The Master: Any objection? .

Mr. Schaefer: No objection. ha ess

The Master: It may be received.

(Said document so offered and received in evidence, was
marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 57, and is attached -

hereto and made a part hereof.

2094 Mr. Rall: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 58 was identified at _
: ' Page 990 of the transcript, but was erroneously
omitted from the offer of, exhibits on poet: 1025 of the.

_ transcript. We desire.to offer that. |

The Master: Any objection?

Mr. Schaefer: No. . .

The Master: It may be received. 7 .
(Said document sa offered and received in evidence, was
marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 58, and.is attached

hereto and made a part hereof.)

Mr. Rall: Apparently there was no exhibit described as |
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 82, but the transcript at page 1369, in
connection with the. offer of exhibits, refers to Exhibit 82,
so it will be understood that the exhibits should havé ended
at 81 in that offer, instead of 82.

_ Mr. Schaefer: Is there an exhibit 82 in the record at all?

Mr. Rall: There is not.

- Plaintiff’ssExhibit 83, identified on cross-examination by
Doctor Lloyd Arnold, is a letter from Doctor Arnold to
George D. Scott, dated December 17, 1937. We offer that
in evidence. It waa identified at page 1877 of the tran-

script.
¢ The Master: Any objection to that?
2095 Mr. Schaefer: - No, sir.

The Master: It may be received.

(Said letter from Doctor Lloyd Arnold to George D. °
Scott, dated December 17, 1937, so offered and received in
evidence, was marked PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 83, and
is attached hereto and made a part hereof.)

Mr. Rall: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 84 is a two-page original
letter of Doctor Lloyd Arnold to Mr. George Scott, dated
December 9th, 1937, a special delivery envelope, and-a pur-

rted carbon copy of a letter from Doctor Arnold to (
Sais Thomas Parran, snc mia dated December@

r

Colloquy. } 1273 7 ,

9th, 1937, identified “ Doctor Arnold on his cross-exam-
ination. , ;

The Master: Any objection?

Mr. Schaefer: No objection.

. The Master: It may be received.

(Said letter from ‘Doctor Lloyd: Arnold to Mr. George
Seott, dated December 9, 1937, special delivery envelope .
and carbon. copy of letter from Doctor Arnold to Doctor.

’ Thomas Parran, dated December 9, 1937, so offered and re-
ceived in evidence, were marked PLAINTIFF ’S EXHIBIT

84 and are attached hereto and made a. part hereof.)
2096 Mr. Rall: Plaintiff’s Exhibit.85, a o letter,

‘dated November 12, 1937, from A. W. Fuchs, Senior
Sanitary -Engineer, to S. E. Dean, Jr., was identified by
Doctor Arnold on cross-examination, at page 1888. I now
offer it.

. The Master: It may be received.

(Said letter dated November 12, 1937, fro A. W. Fuchs
to S. E. Dean, so offered and received in evidence, was
marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 85, and ‘is attached
hereto.and made\a part hereof.)

Mr. Rall: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 26. is a photostat of -a
letter dated November 26, 1937, from Leslie C. Frank,
Senior Sanitary Engineer, 'to 8. E, Dean, Jr., identified at
Page 1888, is offered in evidence. :

The Master: Any objection?

_ Mr. Schaefer: No objection.

The Master: It may be received.

(Said photostat of letter, dated November, 1997, from
‘Leslie C. Frank to S. E. Dean, so offered and received i in
evidence, was marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 86 and is
attached hereto and made a part hereof.)

Mr. Rall: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 87 is a one ‘pa e letter

dated February 7th, 1938, from Doctor Lloyd Arnold
2097 to George D. ‘Scott, identified at page 1951 of the
transcript.

The Master: Any: objection?

Mr. Schaefer: No abjection. .

The Master: It may be received.

(Said letter dated 1 February 7, 1938, from Doctor Lloyd
Arnold to George D tt, so offered and received in
evidence, was marked PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 87 and is
attached hereto and made a part hereof.) 4

Ma, Rall: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 88 is-not offered. ~

Plaintiff’s Exhibit 89 is a copy of a letter dated October ~

rf”

127 “Pranscript of Testimony Before Master. |

6th, 1939, from Walter N. Dashiell, Assocf&te Public Health
Engineer, United States Public Health’ Service, to Doctor
Herman N. Bundensen, to which he attached four type- —
_ written sheets, dated October 7th, 1939, entitled, ‘‘Section —
10 as it will appear in-the 1939, printed Public Health ©
Service Milk Code,’’-said four sheets being identical with
’ the text of pages 2, 3, 4, and 5 of Defendants’ Exhibit 29,
which is already in evidence. By agreement, the four. pages
g this exhibit already included in the. record as part of
efendants’ Exhibit 29 are omitted. ey o.. .
Mr. Schaefer: That is agreeable. 4
2098° The Master: Exhibit 89 is received. _ |
ee (Said letter dated October 6th, 1939, from Walter _ —
N. Dashiell to Doctor Herman N. Bundesen, so offered and
received in evidence,’ was marked PLAINTIFF ’S EX.

HIBIT NO. 89 and is attached hereto and made a part.

hereof.).

Mr. Schaefer: I have two documents which I want to
offer, and that will straighten out: this portion of the
record and we will have it allin one place. = - . .
- I want to offer Defendants’ Exhibit 7, which was iden-

tified by Doctor Prucha while he was testifying and which
‘is a table showing the reports of certain experiments fper-
formed by him. It was overlooked at the time the other
exhibits identified on that day were offered in evidence.

Mr. Rall: No objection. —

The Master: It may be received... :

(Said table identified by Doctor Prucha so offered and
received. in evidence; was marked DEFENDANTS’ EX-

-HIBIT ‘NO. 7, and is attached hereto and made a part

a ag 9 g ; oe seats
Mr. Schaefer: The other document which I would (ike
to take up is Plaintiff’s Exhibit 88, which was identified at
the last hearing, and referred to by counsel for the p\ain-
| tiff in examining certain of the witnesses who tes-
2099 tified on that day. That document was a r@port of
certain proceedings taken by the Board of Health on

May 15th, 1939.. I have here an excerpt from the minutes
of the Board of Health on that day, which show the action
of the Board boca Ea” aay to that matter, and. I would like
to have that marked for identification and received in evi-
dence as Defendants’ Exhibit 31. The plaintiff has not
seen fit to offer tts Exhibit 88. ~- | bees

The Master: Do you object to this, Mr. Rall?

Mr. Gariepy: Yes.

Colloquy. aces as 1275

Mr. Rall: Unless we Gan get an agreement as to who |
was present, so we can make the record in that respect

— lete.

e Master: You have already testified to this, haven’t.

you to who was present?

ll: No. Doctor Bundesen referred to the minutes, |

but t dia not say who was present.

Mr. Gariepy;: Let us find out who was there. .

The Master: What is this supposed to be?

Mr. Schaefer: That is action taken -by the Board of
Health in respect to— .

eg Master: What is it, minutes” ot what?

Schaefer: Those are minutes of the Board of ,
we iealth yes, sir. That is what I stated at the out-.

2100 set. These are minutes of the. Board of Health of &
meeting held on that day. F
-Mr. Rall: Our objection is that it is not complete, but

-. that may be’obviated by his later information.

2

. i

Mr. Gariepy: Showing who was ‘present, to make it
complete. °

The Master: Subject to putting in the facts as to who
were presént—

Mr. Rall: And the vote on the cenolation.

The Master: (Continuing.)’ —and the vote on the reso-

roy agg document thay be’ received as Defendants’ Ex-
it

(Said excerpts of minutes of Board of Health meeting,
held on May-15, 1939, so offered and: received in evidence,
was marked DEFENDANTS’ EXHIBIT 31, and is at-
tached hereto and made a part hereof.) -

‘Mr. Schaefer: -It is stipulated that at the meeting of
the Board of Health on May 45th, 1939, all of the members
of the Board of Health were present, except Doctér Bunde-
sen, and all present voted in favor of the resolution.

‘ The Master: How about these cartons that were iden-
tified this morning? Do you want to put those in?
2101 Mr. Rall: We will offer im ‘evidence Plaintiff’ .

Exhibit 91 the green. printed carton referred to in |

Doctor McNally’ s testimony.
The Master: Is that the only one?
Mr. Rall: Yes. 3
The Master: It may be received. |
(Said green. printed carton so offered dod. Teceived in

evidence, was marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 91, and is
attached hereto and made a part héreof.) —

\ |
\ ,

"1276 Transcript of. Testimony Before Master.

* Mr. Rall: Mr? Reporter, will you mark that Plaintiff’s
Exhibit 92 for identification? -°

(The document referred to was thereupon marked by the
reporter Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 92, for identification.)

Mr. Rall: I offer in evidence Plaintiff’s Exhibit 92, an
original one page lé$ter, dated September 16, 1933, from
A. W. Fuchs to George Scott.

The Master: A. W. Fuchs is of the United States Public
Health Service? ’ :

Mr. Rail: Yes. .

_ The Master: And Mr. Scott is sales manager of the.
Ex-Cell-O Corporation,:the Pure-Pak division?

‘Mr. Rall: Right.

. ‘The Master: It may be received. .

2102 . (Said letter from A. W. Fuchs to George Scott,

| dated : September 16, 1939, so offered and received in
evidence, was marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 92 and is
attached hereto and made a part hereof.)

The Master: , Are you ready for the witness now? |

Mr. Schaefer: Yes. * ie

Mr. Rall: There is one question that I would like to .
ask before the cross examination.

WILLIAM D. MeNALLY, a witness ied by the Plain-
tiff, in rebuttal, having ‘Ween heretofore duly sworn, re-
sumed the stand and testified further as follows:

Direct Examination (Continued) by Mr. Rall.

Q. We referred this morning, doctor, to milligrams of
paraffin. Can you give the Master some equivalent as to
- describing what a milligram of. paraffin is? ©

A. Yes, I can tell you what a grain is in milligrams and’
give’the English picture of how the grain*and milligram
came into existence. : 5

The grain is the average weight of a well dried kernel of
“ ._ wheat. That was our early English system of desig-
* 2103 nating weights. As this measure was transposed -into
the metric system or the French system, we _ then
' began to use grams and ‘fractions of a gram.. A. gram is
15.45 grains. A grain is 0645 grams. So if you can picture
a well dried kernel of wheat, you have the pitture of a
grain which is 64.5 milligrams. 3

Testimony of William D. McNally. 127

Q. Is that the measurment by weight?

A. That is the measurement by weight, given in the
United States Pharmacopoeia, National Formulary, United
States Dispensary, and a recognized measure used by the
pharmacists and the practicing physician. |

Q. About how large would a piece of paraffin ef 107
-milligrams be? — |
_ A. It would be a little larger than “Gin of wheat.

Mr. Rall: ,That is all.

é
' Cross-Examination by Mr. Schaefer. |

Q.: Doctor, what do you mean by a hazard to health?

A. Anything that would cause injury. to that particular
individual’s well being.

Q.. Is lead taken, into -the human body through the.
‘mouth beneficial to health? ee. 5

A. No, sir, it is not. Tn small cailbiias it would have . |

“?

* no effect. :
2104 Q. Just answer the questions that I ask you, doc-
tor. You have testified a good deal’and you under-
stand. So just answer the questions that are put to you.
Does milk contain lead? |

A. Yes, sir, it does.

Q. Does milk, fresh fluid milk 3 as it comes from the cow,
contain lead? “9

-A. It contains lead as I have examined it from. glass
containers. I have never examined it as it came from the
udder of a cow and put into pyrex bottles.

-Q.. Pyrex what? 2

A. Pyrex bottles, which are lead-free. They are glass

Cz, ;

. containers which are lead-free.

Q. How much lead does milk contain?
A. That varies: :
. Q. With what? :
A. With the length of time that the milk has been in
' that container, with the type of food that that— .
Q. What container, doctor?: . ‘
A. Glass container. . ;
. Are you saying that the lead gets into the milk ies
the glass container? 7
A. I believe so, yes, sir. I can take water and put it
in a glass bottle, distilled water, and ‘that water after a
mumber of days shows traces of lead.

1278 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

2105 Q. What have you done with your glass bottle _
before you put the water in it
A. It has been washed out with distilled water first.
2 Ringed out with distilled’water?
. Rinsed out with distilled water, yes, sir. ©
9. That is the a. treatment that you gave it?
.* Yes, that is
2. Where was it befgre it was rinsed out?

. I ecouldn’t tell you that. It was probably around
the laboratory for weeks or so before it was rinsed out
or it may have been one that was just used a day or two
before, with milk contained in it and then used for this

riment.

-How would lead get on to the glace. milk bottle?
Lead is a substance that is found in all cheaper
| "a ‘of commercial glass. It is not found in the pyréx
or chemical glass. It is nd in glazes, in chemical work,
in enameled ware.
Pe Is glass porous, doctor?
No, it is not, in the usual sense of the wonl, of

_— Would you explain how the lead that is in the glass
- gets inside of —
A. That is a matter of solvent action. The glass
2106 is gow alkali.
. Wait until I finish, doctor, please. Will y
uestion so far, Mr. Golding?
red the uation ’s last question was read as recorded.)
o " Schaefer: Q. (Continuing.) —dgets into the liquid
which is placed in the glass bottle?

A. The glass as it is fabricated into bottles contains
lead, and water or other things take up this lead in traces
of definite cmounts that we can estimate in 8.

Q. Now, after the bottle has once been rinsed, will the
et ae into ‘the bottle continue to take up lead from the

A. Yes, it will continue to take up lead.
.Q. Where will that, lead come fron?
' &. It comes from the inside of the coating of the Vidieiee
There is a little silicate formed there.
2 How does if get out? ‘
It is‘a sodium silicate that breaks. up and liberates
cate lead. sine’ some lead silicate with the sodium sili-
ca

Testimony of William D. McNally. 1279

"What do you mean by a lead silicate?
_A. The lead ‘i is there. We put lead in glass: We put
manganese in glass.
2107 Q. No, I want to know what a lead silicate is.
_.. A. It forms with the silicon oxide when it fuses.

Q. What does a lead silicate look like, doctor?

A. White.

Q. Is it visible to the naked eye? -

A. In the form of the amount there, it.is not visible. It
is transparent. :

Q. It is transparent? :

A. It is transparent. It is just like your glass, part of
the structure of that glass. Sodium silicate is water-white
also and in thin portions it would not be discernible to the
eye, until it is ty but if it is fised into glass you would
not notice it at al
_ Q. ‘What tests have you employed to determine the

presence of lead in glass bottles?

A. The Fairhall method. BD

. What is that?

A. ‘And I have used the dithizone method.

Q. Describe that method.

A. Fairhall is the method: I have used in ‘reporting on
lead cases in court.

Q. Will you describe that method?

A. Yes, I wiil be glad to go into it in detail. |

Mr. Rall: How do you spell the other method?
2108 The Witness: The other method is the dithizone
. method... That is the colormetric method. |
We will start with 1000 cc. of water or urine. Let us
‘start with urine. Make it more difficult. To‘ this 1000 ce.
of urine ina silica dish, fused silica dish, we put 15 ce.
of nitric acid. Evaporate this to dryness and ash it.

The nitric acid oxidizes the organic matter in the urea
and sometimes goes’off with a flash, due to sudden combus-
tion of the organic matter.

Then you take it up with distilled water, after it is,

cooled. Add hydrochloric acid and tartaric acid, so if

there are phosphates present the phosphates will not inter-

fere with the lead determination. It will break up any .

calcium phosphates that might be present, :

The acid is completely neutralized, after it has been
filtered from this incineration process. ‘It:is filtered into
an Erlenmeyer flask and neutralized with sodium hydroxide.
To it there is added an indicator, such as methyl orange..

—T

1280 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

We now pass in hydrogen sulphide, this gas ob-
tained from sulphide of iron, to which 1 to 7 a ¢ acid
is added. That is dilute sulphuric acid. s.
_, 2109 Before it is passed into this ‘solution, while we are
. trying to find out whether lead is present, it is washed’
through water and passed into the unknown solution.

The lead sulphidg will precipitaty It may be-in very.
small quantities so. Pest you can hardly see it.. Any iron
that is there will also be taken down as a sulphide.

This is filtered off through a filter paper, washe? with

‘warm water, and dissolved and washed through into
other Erlenmeyer, by means of nitric acid, 1 to 1. e

The nitric acid is now boiled, to free this second filtr
from hydrogen sulphide.

It is then taken up with more water, usually 50 cc.,
~ mame again with sodium hydroxide, until it is alka-

ine

It is then acidified with strong acetic acid, and at this
point one-half cc..of a 10 per cent potassium chromate,
normal chromate, is added.

‘This solution is now boiled for several minutes, covered
and allowed to stand over night, so that the lead will have
an opportunity to be Dae emis as lead chromate, a diffi-

cultly soluble substance
2110 This is now filtered off through a very small filter
paper, washed with warm water, and when found to
be free from chromate by. using dithizone solution we add
hydrochloric acid, 5 to 10 ce. of 1 and 1 strength, washing |
the material into a third clean Erlenmeyer flask.

To this is added 1 ce. of a 20 per cent potassium iodide
solution, also a few drops of hydrochloric acid. In the
presence of lead a blue color will be obtained.

This is now titrated with an N/200 normal solution of
sodium thiosuiphate, and a blank is run using all of these
re-agents as enumerated above, and the blank is subtracted
from any titration that we may obtain in the unknown.

The Master: Off the record, please. | :

(Discussion off the reeord.)

Mr. Schaefer: Q./ When you get ieee what deter-
mination do you have?

A. The determination of tlie lead.

In what?
A. In that sample of water.
Q. In that sample of urine you started out with.

inony of William D. McNally. - 1281.

‘The Master: Just a minute.
Mr) Schaefer: Will you read the question that I
2111 asked the witness? It is quite aways back.
- (The record was read as follows: |

“‘Q. What tests have you employed to determine the
’ presence of lead in glass bottles?

‘A. The Fairhall method.

““Q, What is that?

“A And I have used the dithizone method.

Will you describe that method?’’) ’

My Schaefer: Now I move the answer be stricken.- |

The Master: He is telling you what he did.

Mr. Schaefér: That isn’t what I asked him. What I
am asking the witness is how he determined the presence
‘of lead in glass bottles. He is telling me how he deter-
mines the presence of lead in urine.

The Master: Do you have any different answer than
what you stated, doctor?

The Witness: I stated what I thought was a Bane
answer. ‘If the attorney, young attorney here, will just
clarify what he wants—

Mr. Schaefer: Let us just cut that out. . If the Master
please, I resent that.

The Master: You don’t have to tell us whether the at-
torney is young or old: You can answer the question.

The Witness: Hehad it read to him, sir. Why have it

repeated?

2112 e Master: You have no/ ‘right asa witness to
: chide or take the lawyer to task. Now, you can just
answer the question. What is the question now? You
asked him how he determined the presence of lead in glass
ny ‘

. Mr. Schaefer: That i is right.

_ The Master: Now, is the answer that you gave the
answer you would give to that question?

The Witness: The answer is exactly the same. The
procedure would 8 the same.

Mr. Schaefer: Q. Now, a

ppl |
_ A: I have not finished yet. Seven put me ta finish
it? -

Q. Applying that procedure, doctor, what you deter- .~

mine is the lead content in the material which is placed in
the bottle, is that correct?

Mr. Rall: I am going to object. If the witness is not
permitted to finish the answer to the question, which was

1282 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

for him to describe the method, counsel ought not to be \
permitted to proceed, unless he withdraws the whole ques-
tion.
The Master: Well, let the record stand as it is. made
now. What is the question now?. .
( Mr. Schaefer’s last question was read as above re-
corded.) :
2113 The Witness: A. That is right.
rf Mr. Schaefer: Q. Now, what I want to ‘en |
decker, 1 is how you determine the liad which you have de- ~~
. scribed as being contributed from the glass bottle to the
liquid placed in that bottle. :
A. ell, the same method,. using the same chemical
procedure.
_ Q. You have said that by that procedure you deter-
— the amount 5 lead in the material placed in the bot-
tle?
a .
Q. Now, how do _— determine what percentage of that
lead came from the bottle, if an
A. By taking this same eiedks and evaporating it
in a platinum, dish or in a silica dish which is free from
‘ lead, and running that as a bJartk.
Q. When did you perform such tests with yeapest to
glass milk bottles?
- A. T have been doing that for years and years.
Q.. For what purpose? -
A. Determining the lead content of foods sae foods
stored inglass. ;

2114 from g es a the” i Tien ‘pila

Wisc Thafis all I am interested in.
” I have so answered you.

2 Now, what tests have you performed to deteinhie he
what amount of lead, if any, is contributed from place milk
bottles to the contents of those bottles? fete ass eet
. 1284 — Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

Q. How many times have you tried to do it?
A. I could not tell you how many times.
Q. Did you ever try to do it?
A. Absolutelys - .
A 9. Now, doctor—

What do you think I am 5 hills you here? A bunch
of falsehoods? Iam a research man. -

The Master: .No, he is just asking you questions.

The Witness: Yes, but I don’t-want him to try any in-
sinuations like that.

‘. The Master: He is not making any insinuations. -

The Witness: ‘‘Did you ever try it?’? What do you
think I am telling you here?

‘The Master: - He j is just asking you and you ean telf

him.
2117 The Witness: Certainly.
Mr. Schaefer: Now, Mr. Golding, will yon read’
the last question before the witness’ most recent outbreak?

(The question referred to was read as follows: ‘‘What
I want to kndw is how many fimes you have prepared a
glass milk bottle so that it was free of lead.’’)

Mr. Schaefer: .Q. Now, what I want to know now, doc-
tor, is the procedure that you- employed in attempting to
prepare a glass milk bottle so that it was free of lead. ;

A. Ecould not do that.

The Master: Q. Let us put it this way. You put in ©
some ogee water to wash ‘it out?

es
Just how carefully did you wash itt
It will always take up some lead again.
The water ould? -
Yes. i Gets
ms How long would you let this distilled water | remain
in the bottle?
A. As long as the fluid contained i in it had been. submit-
* ted to me. If the fluid had been in there seventy-two.
__ hours, then I would run a blank seventy-two hours.
2118 mm” ba © you mean by a blank?. Just an empty
ee
A. You take this bottle. Suppose it contains 800 cubic
centimeters of urine. JI don’t know whether all of that
lead in that urine came from an individual. Some of it
might have come from the glass container. That is not—
onl id bottles, but other bottles. oe
ee |

aor"

Prerers

- ‘Testimony of Wilkam D. McNally. 1285

It-will do the same thing. So we allow the same _
amous Auid to stay in that container.
Distilled water? , .
rom the time the party submitted it to us, and
they say this was in this bottle twenty-four hours. Then
I am only. satisfied with distilled: water. staying there
twenty-four hours, and then I run that right through this
process, and it may show a trace and it may show—
°Q. . The idea is to make a comparison?

A. We have to subtract the amount of lea#from this
particular container. oe
Q.: Now, the distilled water would,not contain any lead? —

A. No. It is distilled. | if
_ °Q. You put that into the glass bottle? _
.2119
A. I know of no intoxieation from the lead.from print-

“ing in containers such as you have exhibited here.

Q. If Plaintiff's Exhibit 91 were turned inside out, so -
that all of the printing on the outside of the container were
ne to the milk and the container was not paraffined, do

(1998 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

you have an opinion whether there would be any lead in the.
milk, if it were so handled? —
2144 A. Yes, I have an opinion. :

Q. What is that opinion? ~~

I think there would be some lead in that milk.
And in what quantity?

It would be very small, but there. would be some lead.
agg outside were turned in?.

prover

* Wonka that quantity be within the range that you
fee ‘would have no:effect on the human body?
A. Yes, it would.

Q. So, in addition’to your answer belng based on the
insolubility of lead in milk, the quantity that might possibly
get into the milk is also a factor, is that. correct? :

:A. . It always is a factor, yes.

The Master: Q.. How would the lead get into the milk
in such a sithation?:

A. That has not been brought out by either stae, but I

believe it would get in there in this manner; that wherever
. you have printing and you are handling large quantities of

‘ these things, there i is a very fine dust gets onto the paper,

and if I had my microscope here I could demonstrate that
theré is some dust coming off of then.

.2145 Q. Coming off of the printing?

. Yes, sir. Some dust coming off of that print- .
ing. So the expert cannot say trathfully that there would _
be no lead in that milk. It would not be from the solubility,
but from the dus If you go intog: lithographing plAnt and
see these things piled up—and I have made dust counts in
these places—you can see this green powder on the floor,
if they haven’t swept their place. Or if you take an air
sampling, such as I have, you can find that dust in the air
where these men are working. When it is in that condi-
tion—of course, you are Erg that to a very rigid test by
‘putting that in. I would be willing to drink that every
day, the way it is, out of these containers, but still there
would be some lead in there.

Q. Is that the only way the lead would get into the milk?
A. Yes. It is insoluble in milk. Iti is insoluble in water,
this particular pigment.
_ Q. Let us see if we get this straight: ‘You said there
= an oxidation film over the printing? :
. Yes. :

Testimony of William D. McNally. 1299
Q. 2 8 that would Prevent aclation of the lead into the

2146 A. Yoo ae ff

. You say, however, there is a dust which might

fall into the milk?
A. That would come if we would put it to the most
rigid test, which would not do. These things, which are

= packed together, there is a little ‘friction in here. It is

-microscopic. If I dusted this all off I might not. find any-.
thing, because it has been exposed to the air. . All you
might find is silica, floating from the outside air in here. -
But there will be 'some lead come on. Up — ae would
_ be practically nothing. © .
Q. Referring to the offset. .
Mr. Rall: . Referring to the offset on the inside

- of Plaintiff ’s Ehibit 91?:

A. No, sir. Because that has been dried, and when that —
thing is pulled off there is an infinitesimal amount. :
The. Master: Q. Let us get back to this, doctor. You

‘say, first, there‘is this oxidation film that would pre mee

solution of the lead into the —_ Fi hes
A. That is right. ; .
However, you say there i isa dnt on the paper which
would fall into the milk, without necessarily being in solu-
tion in the milk?
2147 A. Yes, but a person will get that if they drink it.
Q. How is that? | i

‘A. A person will get it if they drink that milk.

Q. Now then, Mr. Schaefer pointed ut that the ink
which constitutes the printing is not there in even layers,
but may be there in ridges?

A: That is because I said under the microscope it would
be discernible-to the naked eye. fi
_ Q. Those ridges might-be worn off a little bit, so as
to make this dust, tod?

A. Oh, that is so small. That is sitcroscbpie. It might
_ be one tliree-hundredths of an inch.

. . I mean, it would enter into this, being a source of .
oe

A. ‘Yes.- Just the fact.of rubbing these things, you can —
create dust, and a man piling. that across like that, and he
keeps doing that continually, he is going te raise ‘a little
dust, so if these things were not shaken down like that,

probably. they do get dust from the street and — like

4

and (
1300 Transcript of Testimony Before Master, a

that, so there surely would be seme lead get tito the milk,
offhand, in that way, but not the other.
Mr. Rall: Q. Arid when you refer to it gettingein *
2148 in that way? ——
A. I mean if I made a’teat of thattnilk, without —
any previous tests, I would find lead in ‘iat milk.
Q. If it-was so handled?
A. Yes. . :
Q. Under the severest tests, you 2 still say there’ is no
problem o —_— hazard involved?
ts O - From the way you have explained it to
Sy pa .liealth hazard, |»
a Rall: That is all. . |

Recross Examination by Mr. Schaefer.

Q. Why would not dust come from the offsets, doctor?

- A. That would be so infinitesimally small. This print-
ing here would: be— .. Jee

The Master: The printing on the. outside?

A: ‘The printing on the outside would have. several thou-
sand times more of lead, expressed ‘in milligrams or frac- -
tions of milligrams, then what I could get from here.
~ Mr. Schaefer:. Q. But there would be dust, there might
be dust on it?

"A. It be very small, because this is exceedingly

“sma
2149 Q.° Of course, the amount of dust will depend upon;
the amount of printing, I suppose?

A. Yes. If you took all: of the printing from these
oe and put it in the milk, you would haye some lead
there
- Q. But apart from the quantity, is there anything in
the nature of offset as opposed to the direct printing—

A. No, this offset.will be smoother. — 7

Q. I haven’t asked you anything yet, doctor. Let me.
finish my question. :

A. Yes. .

- (Continuing) —that would prevent dust from occur-
ring from the offset?.
_A. Yes, because -the offset is so infinitesimally small.
. I said, apart from the quantity. —
= * Apart fromthe —
. Yes.

9 : Testimony of William D. McNally. : 1301

‘A. No. You cari get even ica of paper from here, if
they were not shaken or handled in .that form, you would
get some little dust.

« Q.. Then your answer is, apart f rom the quantity, there

ES is no difference between the offset and the printing?
2150 es
A. .But the iimanit reaction and the chemical prop-
erties are essentially the same. There i is just the difference
Na mating points.
. Now, have you ever heard of administering undis-
solved paraffin to infants. under the age of one year, for
any purpose?
__A. No.» Mineral oil’ or vaseline would be preferable.
The paraffin would not liquify in the body and therefore .
” would not spread over the whole intestinal surface. It
' would go through as‘a foreign body.
- Q. Are you a pediatrician?
A. No. I am a surgeon. :
Q. And do you think yourself competent to testify as”
. an expert with respect to matters of pediatrics?
_ A. Within: limits, because I do pediatric surgery.
¢ 2160 Q. But, apart from pediatric surgery, do you con-
sider yourself competent to testify as an expert?

A. I am not a trained pediatrician. Of course, I have

ad more or less experience with children, but I am not a
pediatrician.

Mr. Schaefer: That‘is all. | | :

Mr. Gariepy: That is all, doetor. ‘

_ (Witness excused.)

Mr. Gariepy: With the exception of the. depositions,
everything’ else is in. ;

The Master: Do you want to show ‘proofs ‘closed, out-
side of the introdnction of. the depositions? :

Mr. Gariepy: Yes.

Mr. Ralt: As a matter of fact, at the close of the plain-
tiff’s case in chief we did niake an offer of the depositions
and they were; received, subject to the Master’s, ruling on
the written objections which Mr. Schaefer was’to attach.

Mr. Schaefer: That is right. —

The Master: Then let the record show proofs closed,
with the exception that Mr. Schaefer may present his ob-
jections to portions of the depositions o or such — as.
he may see fit to object to.

Proofs closed.

Report of Conference with Master.

| us ihe
2161 3 ie (Caption) .. *

Stenographic report of informal conference had at the
office of United States Master in Chancery Jacob I. Gross-
man, Suite 753, United States Court House, Chicago, Iili-
* nois, at 11:00 a. m., Saturday, March 9, 1940.

Present:

Mr. Fred A. Gariepy and Mr, Owen Rall, popeenent: .
ing the plaintiff;

Mr. Walter V. Schaefer and Mr. Chaise P. Horan,
representing the defendants. —

°

The Master: I read over the briefs in this matter some
‘time ago and some questions have occurred to me. One ‘
thing I have already mentioned to you gentlemen, as to
whether this suit in the court at this time may be a little
premature. My thought is this:
It seems to be agreed that the subject of milk containers
is proper to be included in an ordinance, that health meas-
- ures concerning milk which affects municipalities gen-
2162 erally first receive the consideration of the United
States Public Health Service, that the Public Health ©
Bureau has framed a model ordinance, which has been fol-
lowed ‘by municipalities generally, and that. whenever a.
change: is to be made in general practice concerning milk
. usually the United States Public Health Service is the .
first to consider and pass upon the change.
In this matter it appears that the United States Public
Health Service -has been investigating the subject of paper
‘ milk containers: for some time and has made suggestions
voncerning that type of container, and finally:-the Bureau °
has made an amendment to its model ordinance.
While this suit ‘was pending the Board of.Health of the
City of Chicago learned of the amendment, and, following
the usual course, promptly recommended to the City Coun-
cil that the ordinance be amended so as to follow the recom- -
. mendations of the. United States Public Health Service. -
The City Council Committee has the matter under consid-

° eration.
That all dooms to be the usual course. The pitas
_ has been\introduced in this case, but of course the
2163 Council Committee or the Council itself would be free
_ to consider any kind of evidence, whether it be strictly

¢

1308 | Report of:Conference with Master.

admissable in a court or not. There are many considera-
tions entering into thé passage of an ordinance which are
not strictly admissible in a court proceeding.

The Council Committee has stated that it Sill defer con-
sideration of this question until after_the court has ‘passed

upon the matter.. I have been n wondering whether the correct |

procedure should not be the-‘feverse, that the Council Com-

mittee should be the one to first pass upon this, rather than

the. Court.
That question in my, mind opened up a rather broad field.

lative bojlies, so that statutes or ordinafices may have re- |

For inst , we.can imagine that over a period of years.
ey such as this have been decided by legis-

_ solv uestions in controversy from time to tirfié by. in-
serting in the legislation a statement that a particular thing
or process or something else should be used.

Now, let us imagine that some inventor decides that he
-has perfected a device or process,or whatever it may. be,
' which is superior to the thing mentioned in the ordi-

2164 nance. Ordinarily we all know it takes some time for

a new. device or process to stand the test béfore such
‘a thing is adopted generaly. For instance, we recently
» heard of the magnanimous act of some doctor who said that
he had found a medicine which could be put on: the teeth to
take away aii- unpleasant sensations attendant upon _the
dentist grinding the teeth, and he dedicated that discovery
to the profession and people generally. I am told that the

dentists went after that with considerable enthusiasm, but

- ina short time they decided that the new thing was not ex-
- actly what its inventor promised. I presume he was about

- as much disappointed as the dentists generally. So I say
it takes a little time for a new thing of that sort to stand
all of the tests necessary, and it takes some time: for it
to percolate into legislation.

Now, if every inventor could immediately run into court’
and demand that the court hold a hearing on his invention .

' and decide that that invention is what he claims it to be,

- the effect would be that the usual procedure would be

changed and the usual tests to which the thing must be

2165 put before it is generally adopted would not have to
be used any more.

That is just a orief statement. of the broad question that

is involved. In other words, should legislation be permitted
to follow its natural course, or — the courts interfere

Report of Conference with Master. - 1309

and upon the suit of any inventor immediately tell the legis-
latiye body that-their existing legislation is invalid and vir-.
‘tually mandamus them to pass-a-new set of regulations, or
that _the-eeurt will simply permit this new device to be
~ used? Should the courts undertake what is essentially a
legislative function that early in the game?
_ I was wondering whether. a more accurate statement
would be that the ordinance does not yet permit, and that -
is something that is more’in harmony with the actual facts
in the case. That is to say, if you discover somethitig new,
naturally it would not be the subject of any ordinance and _
it was never in contemplation at the time the ordinance was =
passed. The question is whether you are going to give the
legislative body an opportunity to permit the use of the
new device. And the ordinance does not yet permit, because
the legislative body has not had the opportunity in the
suisy * course that I have described to permit the new
evice. we .
2166 I have stated this rather generally. I have talked to
ou both, and you get my general idea. I thought I
would ask you that. ; : eS

In connection ‘with that same subject, this thought: oc-- °
curred to me: Assuming t}fat the courts should hold that
this ordinance is too narrow and that. these containers
should be permitted, can the court order a permit without
machinery therefor? ; pee :

The thought that I. he there is that in the existing
ordigance there is provision for regulating the use of the .
glass bottle, namely; there are provisions as to cleaning
the bottle and for inspection right along.

Now, if the ordinance is invalid as to plaintiff, does it
necessarily follow that a court should say, ‘‘Well, you
go ahead and use these paper containers, even though there

_ .1s no system of regulation whatever.’’? es
It may very well be that the particular containers pre-
sented in this case may not be subject to objection, but is
_ that. an assurance that future containers, manufactured
~ even by the same plaintiff, would be sterile, or essentially’ |
sterile, as you put it, or that the conditions under which’
’ the bottling is done would remain the same?
2167. In other words, in the case of bottle cleaning there
js a.continuous regulation. The mere fact that there _
is an inspection, say, "today does not mean that the clean-”
ing process is going fo remain exactly the same for a year.

Pd

at

1310 | Report of Conference with Master. -

There i is a periodical examinatiot, so as to keep them obi
serving the regulations. ;
. No, if the ordinance is invalid as to plaintiff, doei, it
- necessarily follow that it~is invalid as,to glass bottles? .
That i is aquestion I have in mind also. ~ -
There i is some suggestion in the brief of the City which |
' gives rise to this question: Does the glass milk bottle,’
_. the so-called standard milk bottle, give the purchaser an
opportunity to see whether the milk is dirty or not, whether
there is any dirt in the bottle? What is there in ‘the ordi-
nance to the effect that the glass. milk bottle is not re-
quired in order to prevent fraud; in other words, give
the purcha8er an opportunity to see what he is getting?

The statement in the brief of the City which gave rise
to that was the one about the cream line. A- purchaser |

‘ might look at a glass bottle and see whether there is a
2168 cream line or not. He would also see whether. there is
dirt in the bottom or something floating around.

-Of course, you might say in answer fo that, ‘‘What
about the can of condensed milk? You cannot see what is
in that.’’ I heard of a case, or somebody mentioned a
case about a can of condensed milk, where they found a.
foreign body in it, and suit was. filed.

Mr. Rall: They found a mouse. That was in tle Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals.

The Master:- That’is the case. They sued them. But

- that goes back to the other question: Is this glass milk
bottle something for thé benefit of the purchaser, so he
can see inio the bottle before using - ‘it? There might be
something else floating around.

Stating specifically the question I first raised, you both

- geem to agree that this ordinance prohibits the’ use of
paper containers, When I say that, I am passing your
contention that the ordinance is broad enough to permit
the use of paper containers. But after you pass that
first contention, you sayothat it does prohibit. !

Now, there is another qnestion I taarked down, about
absorbency. At first the ‘plaintiff in its brief possibly

got out, on a limb when the contention was made .

—2169 that there was no absorbency. The City in its an-_

’ gwering brief pointed to some evidence which showed
there was absorbency, and then, as I understand it, the.
reply brief conceded ‘that there might be some slight ab-
—— but so slight that it could not be considered as
materia

Report of Conference with Master. . 1311

Therefore, is it necessary that there should be inspec-
tion so as to insure that there will not be more absorbency
' tharf the amount that is present now, even though it may
be immaterial at the present time? For instance, one
batch of containers would not necessarily besthe measure
_for the next batch. There might be a change in the method
of manufacturing. As TI have said, there might be a change
‘in the method of cleaning glass bottles. “That is why they
have a system of inspection that periodically requires an
examination of the method of cleaning. - 3
_ Should the court grant relief, which would practically
‘be a mandamus to enact. a systém of regulation? -You .
see, the first question in that connection is: Should the
court first say that the ordinance is invalid, and then-throw _
the whole thing open for the use of paper containers, —
. 2170 if the court realizes: that even if paper containers
are permitted there should be some system of regu-
lation or check to see to it that even if such containers
are all right under the evidence now, they will be in the
future? ses :
.That raises the other question. If there has to be. some
_ system of regulation, should the court, if it says that these
_ containers are all right, be required to enact a code for ©
the regulation of the use of these containers as incident to
its decision that these containers are proper? In other
words, is the court going to assume legislative power?
Shouid the court go ahead and say to the community that
these paper containers are all right, and while the conrt
knows :that they may be all wrong in six months, if the
same safeguards are not followed and observed, yet the
court simply will not do anything more? Or would the
‘court in a case such as this say that while these things
may be permitted that the court: might, as an incident to
granting relief, require certain. safeguards? And if it
should do that, would not the court really be passing an
’ ordinance by itself, a. regular system of regulation, in order
_ to.make ‘its relief effective and yet safe?
2171 «If the court should say that the plaintiff’s con-
tainers in evidence are all right; I suppose that that
would not’necessarily include other paper containers: each -
paper container would have to stand on its own evidence.
The effect would be, as I noticed in the contentions of
- the City here, that the plaintiff would. have a monopoly of
per containers, because other companies would either
ve to bring a suit or wait until an appropriate ordinance

I

. near future, and the City Council might. pass an ordi-

oe]

1312 Report of Conference with Master.

is passed permitting paper containers, and they would all |
have to qualify... F
The other question I have is: What kind of an order
would you want the court to make? - That is. all suggested:
in what I have said.
Mr. Schaefer: I think each of us can answer that, but
the answers will not be the same.
_... The Master: Well, that’in general is what shinee
tome. The principal thing I talked about was this, ques- —
tion of the court’s waiting until the City Council should
be given an opportunity to act-upon it or whether the
court should go ahead and let the City Council say that
it will wait. for the court to decide what is essentially a
legislative matter. The practical effect of all this
2172. wall be that if the City Council would pass on it, *
the City Council would do it within the reasonably

nance. permitting the use of paper containers.” On .the
other hand, if the matter is a lowed to remain in court,
there:is no telling when the litigation might be ended. It
might take, you several years before the whole thing is
. finished, and then you might have te. go to the City Coun-
cil after all.

Now, it is. just as important from the standpoint of
the plaintiff as of the defendants to decide just what the
scorrect procedure here is. If this thing remain-in-the .
courts and the City Council. stands on the sidelines, it
will just remain in the court for a while, and then after
you get through you may not be further along than you
were in the beginning...

As I’ w@rded this question originally, the court has to
look at the jurisdictional question itself, whether either
side raises it. While this may not. be strictly a jurisdic-
.tional question, it is a question which is in the nature of
a jurisdictional one: the propriety of the court doing any-

’ © thing in a matter that is assentially legislative, and
2173 even if I go ahead and decide every single issue that

~*« you have presented or even.if the District* Court
does it, some upper court may, on its own initiative, sav -
that this is a legislative matter, and throw the whole thing
out and put you right back to where you were in. the
beginning.

I thought I would put that question up to you, because
it seeins to me to be important to both sides. If there is
a short ‘way open and it may decide this one way or an-—

O.- — Colloguy. > 1318

other and present this very narrow question, maybe that
is the way fo go. I know at a previous stage of these
aa dings there was a time when it seems to me that
sides had decided to pass up the Master’s hearings,
and we did not. have any hearings here for a month or
two, when it seemed that the Council was going to pass
. upon this matter immediately. It seemed to me that both
“ sides then thought that—
_ Mr. Schaefer: Both sides did not. We never did. :
The Master: I mean the Board of Health, when it
passed this resolution; then it seemed to me, at least, for.
a time, that there was some prospect that the City Coun-
cil might act upon the matter. Proceedings were .sus-
pended, I know, at that time. — ae :
oo Mr. Schaefer: No proceedings were possible at
2174 that time. The question there was, when the plain-
5 : pg filed its brief, the plaintiff delayed. in filing its
rief. me
The Master: We will put it that way then.
Mr. Schaefer: But the hearings were continued.
_ The Master: Then we will say the plaintiff thought
- that possibly the City Council might do something. © ;
Mr. Gariepy: No, the plaintiff did not have any thoughts .
at all, because the plaintiff had waited three years for the
-\ Board of Health to take this matter in its teeth, and —
, when on October 26th it took this action.the plaintiff had
the right to assume that the Board of Health was going
to'make some suggestion to the City Council to do some-
thing, since it was the guardian of the public health. Ap-
parently the plaintiff or’the public 6r the Master or coun-
sel for the defendants were all mistaken, because the Com-
mittee said, ‘‘We will wait until the court passes upon it;
we will not do anything until the court passes upon the
. legality of this subject.’’ And there is our status.
° The Master: Now, the question is whether the Coun-
cil’s Committee should decide this legislative question it- .
self at the present timesor whether even if the court
2175 should go ahead and decide, the Council Committee
__ would have to decide it at some future time. In
other words, the court might say that so far as the evi-
dence here is concerned the plaintiff is entitled to some-
othing, but it is all the legislative question, and it depends
upon the City ‘Council affer all to pass regulations -
which might be necessarf¥, even if it should be\ proved that
this particular batch of containers would pass muster. I

1314 -.°" . .. Celleguny.

have suggested the question, the mere fact that you have
some proper containers here now- does not necessarily .
mean that future containers, even manufactured by you,
would be the same, so that there might be some justifica- |
tion for an inspection measuré to passed which would —
be operative in the future, so as td see that what you
started out with would remain about same.
Mr. Gariepy: We-can all agree, Master, that the coj
and the Master will not tell the City what regulationsYo
establish, but the court can pass upon the legal questions
presented here without prejudice to the right of the City
to set up such suitable regulations as will protect health.
. - That is the burden of the City, to go ahead and es-
2176 tablish those regulations to protect public health, the
same as they did with the glass bottles. They got
regulations to take care of that, -and.they ought to have
fegulations ta take care of this. But standing by and
waiting for something to be done and saying wait until the
. - court does something I don’t think is doing us any good.
~The court stands by and the Committee adjourns sine die
and so on, and we just: wait. SA “i
—- . The Master: Have you any thoughts on this general. :
subject that are more concrete than that? You said you
had some memorandum that vou might present on it. 3
"Mr. Gariepy: The contention of the plaintiff is that the
Court should pass upon the question with regard to the .
validity of the ordinance concerning the containers coming
/ within the ordinance or whether the ordinance kicks the
| containers out or prohibits the containers from being used.
That question can be decided without prejudice on the .
. part of the City, the defendant, to establish or set up rea-
sonable rules and regulations, such as the United States
_Public Health Service has already suggested and set up in
‘ ‘their model ordinance.. The City can set them up or adopt,
_those concerning the matter of control-of containers,
2177 paner containers, in the same way as they have regu-
lations now concerning the use of the glass bottle. If
they have one, they ought to have the other. There ‘isn’t
anv ‘reason why the regulation should not be established.
~_/ __ That is the beacon light the United States Public Health
- Service has shown them, and it Has taken some action to
give them the road to follow. I don’t think the Master or -
_ the court should tell them just what the regulations should
be, but they should be those reasonably to protect and con-

serye public he »

O°.

a ‘Report of Discussion with Master, — 1331

' could appear. The defendants’ case was closed on October

13, 1939.. On October 16, 1939, the Board of Health made —

_its recommendations to the city council. On October/19,
1939, the defendants requested and were granted leave to

~ reopen proofs and submit further, testimony. Ac-
2210 cordingly, on October 23, 1939, the Arendants offered

re

further evidence, and again closed’ their case. The |

plaintiff completed its proof on October 26, 1939. The
recommendation of the Board of Health was referred. by
the council to its committee on health. While the matter

was under consideration by the committee, plaintiff’s brief -

was not filed before me. On November 22, 1939, the com-

- mittee on health voted\to defer action ge an amendment -

-to the. ordinance pending the outcome of this case. There-

r, briefs’ were filed in the case at bar, the plaintiff’s.
brief on December 19, 1939, the defendants’ brief on .Jan-
uary 27, 1940, and the plaintiff’s reply brief on February
15, 1940. Further proceedings were had in the case on
March 9, 1940, the: transcript of which is made a part of

the. record. Additional memoranda based upon those fur- '

_ ther proceedings were filed March 15, 1940, and on
_ April 13, :1940.. On April. 26, ‘1940, which is today, the
record was reopened for the purpose of formally inépr-

porating the above facts-in this record. —

Now, is there anything further that’ ought to go into

| , this record? Is there anything tligt either side.here -
2211 has raised in the objections which go merely to the .

lige

- » question of the record? an
Mr. Gariepy: I have got one suggestion I would like to
put into the record at this time, before we také up these
suggestions that are filed by counsel and by plaintiff. |
Within the last two weeks, it is a matter of common’
knowledge that homogenized milk is being sold in the City
of Chicago, and being sold by and with the permission of
the defendants. The:Master, in his report filed here some
. 1l or 12 days ago, made reference to the matter of the cream
line, and he made reference-to the matter of the fact that
the cream in the paper bottle became diffused, and did: not.
concentrate or localize itself.. The homogenized milk, by
its very definition, is milk where the cream line is not.ob-
servable, and where the milk is of the same quality through-
out, or the cream ‘is diffused throughout, so that it is one,
continuous quality of milk from the bottom to the top.. .

@

~~
b

eee

fe -
x

1332 _—-Report of Discussion with Master.

If the city of Chicago and the Board of Health, the de-
fendants, permit the sale of homogenized milk at this
time—and homogenized milk is, as the name suggests, milk

where the cream line is not observable, even in glass
- 2212°containers, and the. cream is. diffused equally and

; evenly throughout the milk—then the comment in the
Master’s report in his findings, and reasons therefor
given, .are of sufficient importance. to the plaintiff for the
plaintiff to ask leave at this time to offer proof that homo-
genized milk is now being sold, and has been sold, during
the past 15 days, and was not at any time being sold dur-
ing the pendency of this law suit before the Master, so we
were not negligent or derelict.in our duty in not presenting
.the point, and could riot have presented it, since it was not
‘a fact in- being at the time. e Master has given those
factors significance in his report, and I think we ought to
be given an opportunity to meet them. |

The Master: Do you agree that that kind of milk is be- |
ing sold, or do you agree in the statement, Mr. Schaefer?

Mr. Schaefer: Well, I agree that homogenized milk is
being sold in the City of Chicago without interference by
any of the defendants.. Homogenized milk, however, is
' being sold as such—labeled as such—and the homogenized.
_milk which is being sold is required by the State Depart-

ment of Public Health to be of such a quality, that
2213 samples taken from the top of the bottle, and from

the bottom of the bottle 48 hours after the milk has
‘ been bottled, do not show a variation in the butter fat con-
tent greater than a small percentage of one per cent.

Mr. Gariepy:' With regard to the State Board of Health,
there is nothing in-the ordinance on homogenized milk.
Perhaps there would be something in the regulations of the’
Board of Health rape oe A pa in the last 30 days to
legitimatize the sale of this milk, so to speak. :

; Master: At any rate, this homogenized milk is be-
‘ing sold, as Mr. Gariepy states, with the exception, as you
' state, Mr. Schaefer, that it is labeled and sold as such,
isn’t that right? ;
‘ Mr. Schaefer: That is right, and that it meets certain
equirements. |
Master: Yes. Is that agreeable with you?
. Mr Gariepy: Yes. mete, :

The Mastet: So that the record now shows the fact

-with reference to homogenized milk. — |

%

2214 Mr. Gariepy: ‘(Con

Report of Discussion with Master. ~ — 1333

Mr. Gariepy: There is uothimg in the ordinance, you
agree with me on that—
Mr. Schaefer: (Interrupting.) at is ri ht, and there
has been no regula gulation of the! yard of Health.
puing-) 5 a *—passed. to permit .
‘its sale. It is just being“dones. »-
Mr. Schaefer: No, by virtue of state regulations.
The Master: At any rate, it is being sold; that is all ©
we are interested in. We don ’t care how it is being sold,
but it is being sold. -

- Mr. Schaefer: Yes.

Mr. Gariepy: In glass bottles—let ’s put ‘that j in, too.

Mr. Schaefer:. Put that in my statement. 7

Mr. Gariepy: In glass bottles. - : i

The Master: Yes. Now, is — anything further that
is.to go in the record?

Mr. Gariepy: You agree with my statement, also, Mr.
Schaefer, that at the time of the trial that was not per-
mitted, so we had no i, rchnsegrs A to go into that matter?

Mr. Schaefer: Yes agree to that.

The Master: “Anything further?

Mr. Schaefer: To be added?

The Master: An lager further to go into the record! i

Mr. Schaefer : , sir.

“The Master: Let the record show proofs closed.

Proofsglosed.

2308 And on, to wit, the 24th day of May, A. D. 1939,

there was filed in the Clerk’s office of said Court
certain Depositions, originals of which are in words and
figures following, to wit:

‘2310 Iw tHe Distaicr Covet or rae Unrrep Srares.

* © (Caption—316) ° °
(Filed May 24, 1939, Hoyt King, Clerk.) .

" Deposition of Paul. V. Keyser, Jr., a witness in behalf

of plaintiff, taken, pursuant to notice to take depositions
served on the defendants —_ 15, 1939, at the office of
Mudge, me Williams & Tucker, 20 Pine Street, New
York, N. ¥ . on Tuesday, April 25, 1939, commencing at

1884 Dojesiiies of Paul V.. Keyser, Jr.

2:00 o ‘clock, p. m., before Irvin Taber, a Notary Public i in
and for the County of N ew York, State of: New York.

Appearances :

-Gariepy & hice Esqs., Attorneys for Plaintiff,
by Owen Rall, Esq., of counsel.

2311 Barnet Hodes, Esq., Corporation Counsel of the City

of Chicago, by “Walter V..Schaefer, Esq., and

Charles P. Horan, Esq., . Assistants Corporation

Counsel. - ; ene

PAUL V. KEYSER, IR. ‘a witness of lawful age, having

fol first duly sworn by the es eee, testified as
ollows:

‘Direct Examination by Mr. Rall.

Will you state your name, please?
Paul V. Keyser, Jr.
And where do you reside?
At 142 Wést 11th Street, New York City.
And your business address?
Is 412 Greenpoint Avenue, Brooklyn, New York.
And, for the purpose of the record, yout age?
Thirty- two.
And what is your occupation? .
- Tam a chemical engineer. \
Connected with whom? | /
vir} Socony Vacuum Oil Company, Incorpo-
rat
23132 Q. Js that sometimes commonly called the ae
Vacunm Corporation?
"A. It is.
Q. How long have you beeh so engaged?
A. Nine years. :
Q. And previous to that time were you engaged i in any
business or profession? ¢ |

A. No. . ' . :
Q. What brififyhas been, your oduestion? : e*.
A. I graduated-from M. I. T. in 1929. |
. That is the Massachusetts Institute of oe
at ton?
A. The Massachusetts Institute. of Technology i in Cam-
‘ie. Massachusetts.
, & vam, { in pcr ‘And with what brats

Bindd >PO>rO>ropo

‘
ae ee **

MBesision of Paul V. Keyser, Jr. 1335

A. With the degree of Bachelor of. Science i in Cliensieal
Engineering, and, in 1930, with the degree of Master of
Science in Chemical Engineering.

Q. .Previous to your entry into the Massachusetts In-
stitute of Technology. you had a high school course?

A. I had a high school education in Washington, iss C..

Q. . And also a grade school education?
| A. Yes.

2313 Q.. At the same place! ree
A. At the same place. $
. Now, you referred to a Master of Science degree. —
What additional schooling did you take which authori
the granting of that degree?

A. The course occupied one full year and followed ‘the
curriculum outlined by the Institute, which included ad-

vanced work in the general field of chemical engineering
* and a practice school which involved six months’ training
in various industrial organizations.

Q. And did that work follow without pees cona your -
Bachelor*s degree? 3

A. Itdid. — - 9

Q. And you then enstered the employ of the company y by
whom you are now employed? _

A. 'I did.

Q. What briefly has been your experience since entering
the 7 of the company?

ave been employed constantly i in the general
laboratories of thé corporation. : =
. 9. And where are those laboratories located? 4
2A. Located at 412 Greenpoint Avenue, Brooklyn.
‘Q. How many men are now engaged | in ‘that labora-

wae i
2314 Approximately 160.
Q. Inthe laboratory? .
A. In this division of the laboratories.
State briefly what the business of the company is.
The company is in the petroleum business, and its °
scope includes the — refining, and — of
petroleum products of all types. - |
Will you name a few of them?
Amongst which might be mentioned fuels, lubricants,
Pprocessing-materials such as waxes and so forth?
Q. Paraffin wax, I understand, is a product resulting
from refining?
A. That is correct, of petroleum. : :

1336 Deposition of Paul V. Keyser, Jr.

~ Q. Of petroleum. And where does your company man-
ufacture—at what refineries does your company manufac-
ture paraffin wax?

A. Paraffin wax is manufactured at our Long Island
City refinery, amongst others. |
_.Q. Do you know whether or not the paraffin wax manu-
'factured at that plant is sold to the Dean Milk ey
and shipped to emung, Illinois?

A. 6” it is. ; |
Have you made an ‘investi ation to determine’
2315 wink - quality is of the par wax so sold and

Pc og

‘9 Will you state what it is? se

A. The paraffin wax manufactured at the Long Island —
City refinery and shipped to the Dean Milk Company is
refined os araffin wax with a melting point of 125 to 197
degrees Fahrenheit, A. M. P.

Q. Is that capital A, capital M, and capital P?

A. Capital A, capital M, and capital zs

Q. What do those initials stand for?

_ A. American Melting Point.

Q. Are you familiar with the process of manufacturing
this wax?

A. Yes.

Q. Will you describe it, particnarly with reapest to the
sanitary conditions under which it is manufactured?

A. Yes. Paraffin wax is extracted from a distillate re-
moved from the crude by distillation.

Q. When you refer to ‘‘crude’’ it is crude petroleum?

A. Crude petroleum.

Q. Crudeoil? —

A. Crude petroleum oil. Prior to the removal of the wax
; the distillate is treated with a acid to remove
2316 certain unsaturated bodies. It is then pressed,

_. sweated, further treated withT@eid and washed with
caustic soda, passed through a filter. and finally molded
into cakes.

Q. When you tefer to “sweating”, of what does that
process consist?

A. The sweating process may be described as a frac-
.tional crystallization whereby the paraffins at the proper
melting point are removed from the materials at other melt-«

ing points and from the oil admixed with the wax at that
_ point in the manufacturing operation. ; ;

“

é Deposition of Paul V. Keyser, Jr. 1337),
- Q.- Can you tell us briefly how that sweating is accom-
plished? 3 ty | ‘

A. The sweating is accomplished by introducing the
slack wax, which is a mixture of wax and-oil, into pans of
rather large area but shallow, where, by a careful control -
of temperature, the law melting point of the material and |
the oil is selectively drained from the mass of solid crystal-

- liné wax. a ;
.’ Q. And that which remains is the paraffin wax that you

are referring to? : |
_ A. That which remains after the sweating process has —
been carried out a number of times, over and over again,

that is, is the paraffin wax. The wax, after a complete |
2317. sweating operation, contains only a trace of residual \

oil, and ‘this oil is completely removed by the final ..
filtration. --~" . ee ee ;
Q. How is this filtration accomplished?

A. This’ filtration is accomplished by percolating the
molten wax through bone black. :

_Q. Through what? 3

A. Bone black.

Q. Is that a substance?

A. Bone black is a very pure form of carbon.

Q. You speak about it being molded into cakes. Does
that process occur after the filtration process that you have
described? | : : --

A. . Yes. -

Q. Now, during the course of this manufacturing or re- —
fining operation is heat applied in the various stages? ..

- A. Heat is applied in the various stages jn order to—
in the first place, to separate the paraffin distillate from the
crude oil, and, secondly, to maintain the subsequent wax -
oil mixtures and eventually the pure paraffin wax in a
molten state. sears,

Q. Immediately prior to its being pressed into cakes ,
what is the temperature at which the paraffin is maintained? -

A. Approximately 160 degrees Fahrenheit.
2318 Q. Well above the melting point? 3

A. Well above the melting point. |
.Q. Of what materials are the machines made which are
used in this manufacturing or refining process that you
have described? Tee Ao ,

A. The entire system is carried out quite ‘generally in

we:

a

1338 Deposition of Paul V. Keyser, Jr.

steel or cast.iron equipment, all of which is enclosed, the
process being in the early stages largely a continuous one.

Q. That is, -without manual assistance the machinery
does the work? —

A. No human hand at any time touches any of the ma-
- terial throughout the operation or process.

Q. And does that apply to the entire process that you
referred to? ;
A. It does until the cakes are finall$—of the finished
wax are finally removed from the moMing machine and
packed in suitable containers, which is a hand operation,
| And in what form is the paraffin yax that is shipped
‘to Chemung, Illinois, by your company; that is, — it

comes from the molding machine?

_A. It is in eleven-pound cakes.

Q. And about what size are these?

‘: A. Approximately sixteen inches by eleven inches
2319 by.an inch and a half to two inches thick. That is

the approximate size of the cake ; I don’t recall the
exact dimensions.

Q. Now, you referred to that being removed from the
molding machine being a hand operation. Do you mean
that someone actually picks up the cake or lifts it from the
‘machine, or just what is that process?

A. The cake is actually lifted from the mold and packed
into‘a container.

Q. And just liow is that process accomplished? _ When
you refer to its being packed, are you familiar with the
packing of this specific paraffin that we are discussing?

- A. The paraffin is removed from the molding machine
aud immediately packed in paper-lined burlap bags.

Q. Right next to the paraffin is what!

A. Is paper. |
_ Q. Of what kind? Is it a wax paper. or parchment of
some kind?

A. It is a treated craft which is sealed to the exterior
burlap bag.

a ne that aars kept under sterile conditions: in your
plan

A. Yes, in so far as that is practicable.’

Q. Just how is that accomplished?
2320 Pa ag have reference to the keeping of the con-
er

Deposition of Paul V. Keyser, Jr. 1339

Q. Yes, of the container into which this wax in. these
eleven-pourid cakes is packed?

A. Well, the bags as received are in sealed closed
_ packages, and they are kept in that shape in rooms-wherein |
practices of cleanliness are observed, and these packages
are not opened, nor are the bags opened up to receive wax, —
_ until immediately prior to the introduction of the wax into
the paper container which comes in contact with the wax,
being inside of the burlap bag.

Q. What is the practice with respect to the cleanliness
of the operator who performs this operation of removing
the wax?.

Mr. Schaefer: Well, I object to that.

Mr. Rall: You may answer subject to the objection.

A. Why, the operators who remove the wax from the
molds and place them in the paper containers are men who
are regularly cautioned .to observe good practices with
respect to personal cleanliness and particularly to keep
- their hands free from dirt, and during the operation they
do not handle any material other’than the wax and the
receiving bags.

Q. You: referred to toms practices.’’ Will you state,

subject to the same objection that has been made,
2321 specifically what the instructions to these men are?
A. Goad practice in our estimation involves regu-
lar washing of the hands with soap and water at ——_
intervals.
Are these men who remove the wax under the super-
Vision of a-superior?

A. They are under the supervisiof of a foreman.

Q. Are you acquainted with the chemistry of the com-
— — that you have described?

a tell us what its chemistry is?
z: Paraffin-wax is substantially a mixture of crystalline,
waxy hydrocarbons, characterized as being membeis of
the saturated straight chain paraffin family ‘best . repre-
sented by the generic formula Cn H2n +- 2 and having an
average approximate carbon atom content of 24.to 28.

Q. Are there any regulations or formulae which describe
or regulate the substance that you are discussing?

A. Wes. Those regulations include the specifications of
:, Our own corporation, and this wax is.manufactured so as.
- to meet tlie requirements of the U. 8. —

di

1340 —-—~dDeposition of Paul V. Keyser, Jr.

, Are the standards of the U. S. areiananeaaae ”
lished from time to time?
' A. They are.
2322 Q. Are “ies published ond og :
ar A. To the best of my knowledge, at rather irregu- .
lar intervals, depending upon the, necessity for revision.

Q. That consists, does it not, of definitions of various —

types of substances, chemical definitions?
A. » It does..
Q. Does that contain a definition of the paraffin wax, , the
substance that you have described?
A. It does, under the general heading ‘‘Paraffnum.”
Q. You have before you a-volume entitled: ‘‘Pharma- ~
copoeia of the United States, Eleventh Decennial Revi-
‘sion,’ bearing the Roman numeral XI., which appears to
be an official copy, No. 137111, entered, according to Act of
_ Congress, in the year 1935 by the Board of Trustees off
_the United States Pharmacopoeial Convention in the office
of the Librarian of Congress at Washington. Is this vol-
_ ume the one that is commonly referred as the U. S.
Pharmacopoeia?
A. It is.
. Will you refer us to the page upon which you find
- the standards relating to paraffin wax which describe thé
wax which you have just told us of? ~
' -A, Page 276...
Oo” Subject to the right of the defendants to de-
2323 mand the production of an original volume, this vol-
ume being peepery of the Socony Vacuum Corpora-
tion, which the plaintiff agrees to produce if required, I
will ask you to read into the record the standard contained
in that volume for the phage wax which it is your testi-
‘ mony this product you have described complies with? —
ye reading.)
‘*A purified mixture of solid hydrocarbons obtained from
_ petroleum. |
‘*Description and Physical Properties—A colorless or
white more or less translucent mass, frequently showing a
crystalline structure. It is without odor or taste and is
slightly greasy to the touch.. Paraffin is insoluble in water:
and in alcohol; slightly soluble i in dehydrated alcohol ; fre-
quently soluble in chloroform, in ether, in benzine, in
‘ petroleum benzin, in carbon arr in volatile oils and
in most warm fixed oils. .

é
Deposition of Paul V. Keyser, Jr. 1341

‘‘Tests for Identity and Purity—Specific gravity, about
0.900 at 25 degrees Centigrade. It melts between 50 de-.
_ grees and 57 degrees Centigrade (page 455). When
strongly heated, paraffin ignites, burns -with a luminous
flame and deposits carbon. -

2324 °‘‘Heat about 0.5 grams of paraffin in a dry test

tube with an equal weight of ur: the mixture
evolves hydrogen sulphide and becomes black .due to the
liberation of carbon. Shake melted paraffin with an equal |
volume of hot alcohol: the separated alcohol does not:
redden moistened blue litmus paper Sage 9 Pour 5 c.c.
of paraffin at a temperature just above its melting point, and.
-5 ec. of ‘sulphuric acid into a glass stoppered cylinder
which has previously been rinsed with sulphuric acid and
heat in a water bath at 60 degrees Centigrade for ten min-
utes, shaking the mixture at intervals of one minute: the
; remains unchanged in color and the acid does not
me darker than pale amber (carbonizable substances).’’.
. The quotation that you have read refers to the
melting point as being from 50 to 57 degrees Centigrade.
Can you translate that for us into Fahrenheit? —— ,

A. Approximately 122 to 135 degrees Fahrenheit.

Q. The quotation that you have read refers to the de- -
posit of carbon and the burning of the paraffin in case it is
strongly heated. nade? Hit 7

A. With sulphur present.

ad

' Q. With sulphur present. Heating this. paraffin

2325 wax to a high temperature, that causes it,to disin-
oe does it? —

‘A. Yes.

Q. And at about what point Fahrenheit does it com-
mence to change its form? _ ;

A. The temperature at which incipient thermal decom-
f oo takes place is approximately 650 degrees Fahren-
ei

Q. And what occurs at that point?

A. If no air is present, or oxygen, the wax thermally
‘decomposes, forming hydrocarbons of lower molecular -
~~ less saturated and perhaps some free carbon.

. Q.. If oxygen is present, what occurs? |
A. If onyeen is present and the material is ignited at
that temperature the ‘hydrocarbon will be completely con-
‘verted to carbon dioxide and water. : :
Q.. The paraffin wax that you have described I under-

t,
a3

2.
1342 . Deposition of Paul V. K eyser, Jr.

stood you to say complies with the definition ae paraffin
wax as given in°U. S. Pharmacopoeia XI.; is that right?
A. It does. ;
Q. Are you also familiar. with the standards of U. S.
Pharmacopoeia X., which preceded this?

A. Iam.
Q. Would your testimony with b respect to that be the
same? |

_* 2326 -A.. It would be.

Mr. Rall: Now, I-will “ak ‘that the Notary mark
this carton as ‘Plaintiff ’s Exhibit 1’* for identification.
__(The carton referred to was marked for identification
‘*Plaintiff’s Exhibit 1, April 25, 1939.’’) -

(Then there followed some discussion off the record.)

Q. I show you Plaintiff’s Exhibit 1, identified by the
N6tary, and-ask you to state what occurs when a carton
of that type is immersed in the paraffin wax that you have

_ described, heated to a point between 170 and. 185 or 190
degrees Fahrenheit and then removed and cooled?

A. Depending upon the time of immersion, there is a .
certain amount of penetration, of the wax into the board,
and even in a brief time sufficient penetration to give good .
adhesion of the surface ffm, which is a continuous film,
which is subsequently left upon the carton after removal
from the wax bath during the draining period.

_ Q. When you refer to,adhesion, you mean the adhesion
of the paradin wax to the fiber board; is that correct?
; 0.
2327. Q. Is there any’ chemical reaction cénnected with
this process that you have referred to? a

A. There is not.

Q. Is the wax after the i immersion and subsequent cook.
ing of the. same chemical composition that you described
. in your testimony, referring to the paraffin wax manufac-
tured by your company?

-A. It is. ; ge

Q. _ With respect now to the properties of-a fiber board
such as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 1, before and after the immer-
sion in paraffin, with respect to liquids, the effect of liquids
such as water or milk on the exhibit, what, if any, change
does this paraffining process bring about? ene

Mr. Schaefer: What is the question? — ‘a

(Question read by the reporter.)

Mr. Rall: bb my question clear to you?

—

a

.. fe Itdoes at temperatures below the melting point
of the wax.

Q. As 3 understand your testimony, eiow the melting
- point of wax it is impervious to water or what you have
_ described as an aqueous phase liquid?

oo “ao ( *

Q. And is milk included in that definition!

A. Yes.

Q. Have you given any study to the question of the
coating of fibers and papers with this paraffin wax manu-
' factured by your company?

A. Yes; a very considerable amount of technieal- work
has been directed to this problem in our laboratories.

Mr. Schaefer: I object to that because it fs not re-
sponsive. - .

Q. _Have you yourself notte studies in ‘that connection ?
- A. I have, personally, and additional studies have been
made under my diréction.

.Q. Is this process that you have described of. coating .
with paraffin a fiber:tarton such as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 1 sub-
tantially the same process that is used in what we call wax

paper or papér cups or things of that type?
2329 . Mr. Schaefer: I object to. that as immaterial. -
& Mr. Rall: a may answer . or to the objec-.
ion. ae

A. It is. | ~~

Q. - For what purposes is the paraffin wax manufactured
by your company, which _you-have described, used?

Mr. Schaefer: That is also objected to as immaterial.

Mr. Rall: You may answer subject to the objection.

A. It is very largely used in the paper industry as an
; impregnating and coating material. -It is also used as a |
household ‘sealing-wax for fruit and jelly jars.. It i is used
as an ingredient of wax polishes and finishes. It is used
‘as an ingredient in the sizing of paper. It is used as an

The

poses.

of this testimony stands.

62

1344 | Deposition " Paul V. Keyser, Jr.

electrical insulating material, and for. many other pur-

Q. Does your company sell wax’ “for the purpose of seal-
— jars?
4 r. Schaefer: That is objected to as immaterial.
A. Wedo. ©
Q. And does that have a trade name? 7
A. Yes, in various territories it is known as either Pare- |
wax or as Paraseal wax. :
Q. In what size cakes are those sold? |
Mr. Schaefer: Do you want me to object ay
oF .’.
r. Rall: No; your objection to the materialit of
The Witness: Will.you repeat that question? _ °
(Question repeated by the reporter.)
; In quarter-pound cakes, packed four to. the one-
pound box.
Q. And the box is substantially the size of a pound of
butter, is it not? |
. 2
Q. And the wax so used is melted by the housewife and -
poured on the top of fruit for’the purpose of sealing it in
the preserving process; is that true?
.A. That is correct. .
Q.. Is this product you referred to as Parowax, sold for
the purpose méntioned, the same or a different product than
the paraffin wax that you shipped to Chemung, Illinois? ==

A» It happens to be identically the same material as that _

_whict. has been shipped to Chemung,4llinois, for the account

of the Dean Milk Company.
Q. The difference being, I take it, in the form of the

ae of the cake and the method of packaging the article?

A. That i is correct.
FN: referred to the use of this paraffin wax in
2331 the impregnating and coating of papers by the paper.
industry. What is the purpose of that?
A. Probably the most important purpose is to render

the material being coated or impregnated moisture proof.

Q. And is the reason that that material, when so im-

_ pregnated or coated, is moisture proof the same reason that

es have given for your statement that when Plaintiff’s
xhibit 1 is immersed in wax it papceaueade impervious to an

— phase —

| Bepeiee of Paul V. Keyser, Jr. : 1345

A. Yes.

Q. Will you give us so far as you can think of offhand
examples wherein paraffin wax is used for that purpose in
other products or packages containing liquids or intended ~

for liquids other than a container for milk? © |
. Mr. Schaefer: That is also objected to. . :

Mr. Rall: Your objection stands as to the materiality. .
until I tell you that I am changing: my line of questions. ~

Mr. Schaefer: Fine.

A.° Containers intended for the packaging of such mate-
rials as ice cream and cheese; containers intended to hold
for a brief period of time coffee, water, tea or other bever-
: ‘ages and so forth, represent good examples.

a 9332 _Q. Would the ‘tiny sealed cup containers that the

air lines use for the cream, dispensing of cream to
their passengers, be an example of what you have referred
to, or are you acquainted with that? .

‘A. At least some of ‘them would be. I know of some
which are paraffin wax coated.

_ Q. Are ‘the paper cups that are used for individual
drinking cups largely within the class of products that you
would refer to? ;

_ A. They are.

Q. Do you know the names of any that are a
with the wax manufactured by you?

A. You mean the trade names? b

Q. Yes. > ; ;

A. No, Ido not./ I cannot anéwer that question ,

Q. Is there any difference between the penetratin §
powers of milk and cream into a paraffin coated fiber boar

and the penetrating powers of water?

“Mr. Schaefer: I object to that for the additional reason
- that the witness has not been qualified to express. an opin-
ion on, that’ subject. .

_A. .Technically there is ‘some difference. =
. And what is that difference, if you know? ©

2333 A. Milk contains a certain amount of butter fat in
a suspension in the water, which ay x fat has a greater.
dissolving effect upon the wax-coatin n ordinary water,
and therefore a container coated with wax will hold water
. generally for a longer period of time without failure than |

+

-. will a similar container filled with milk or cream.

. Q. Does the depth or thickness of the coa of. the
_— on the container have a _— to the time that

a

1346 ~~ = dDeposition of Pad V. Keyser, Jr. -

the container remains impervious to penetration by milk
or cream? ae

A. Yes. /

Q. And the thicker the coating, the more impervious
it will become, or the longer will be the time that it will
retain its imperviousness to penetration? _

A. Other things being equal, that is correct.

Q. Have you or has anyone under your direction—I
think it is fair to say now that I am changing my line—have
you or has anyone under your direction made any tests with
respect either to the desirable thickness of the coating of
paraffin on milk containers or as to the time, depending
upon the-thickness, that the container remains impervious ©
' to the _ tion OF milk? ,

2334 $ Have those studies ean based upon the thick-
P nes of the paraffin by measurement or upon the immer-
sion time jn the paraffin bath of the carton?

A. There has been no actual measurement of the thick-
ness of the film, but the thickness of the film has been’ ap-
proximate. by observations connected with the details of .
the method of appfifation of the film and the amount of wax
applied to a unit area of board, the higher. the temperature

‘and the longer the period of immersion giving greater pene-
. tratior and lesser surface film, and the shorter the time of

immersion and the lower the temperature of impregnation,
followed ‘in some cases by chilling, giving increasingly
on films, thicker continuous films of wax upon the sur-
ace

Q. What is the effect on bacteria that might be present
“either on the surface of the fiber board, such as Plaintiff's
Exhibit 1, or in the paraffin of the heating process and the

immersing of Plaintiff’s Exhibit 1 in the paraffin bath!

Mr: Schaefer: That is objected to on the ground that
the witness has not been qualified to answer that question.
A. Ajthough I am not a bacterialogist, I understand
from reputable sources that paraffir is an active sterilizing
material, particularly at the ra casei ata of applica-
tion referred to.
I agree with Mr. Schaefer that I am not in a posi- ©
tion to answer that question. You should get a bacterialo-
gist to answer it. / ¢
Mr. Rall: I think you-may cross-examine subject to one
question that I will ask ¢ on further direct.

A :
‘

“4

Deposition of Paul V. Keyser, Jr. - ‘1847
Cross-Examination by Mr. Schaefer.

. When you were referring to, the impregnation of
paper and the thickness of the resulting coating from im-
mersion in greg what temperature ranges and what
time intervals did you have in mind?

A. We work in temperature ranges from 140 to 220,
perhaps 240 in one or two isolated cases, degrees Fahrenheit
for times of immersion varying from a second up to a

minute or longer, wi

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386403_0017%3A03. Public record. Not legal advice.
