# Appendix — Piney Run Preservation Association Association Association v. County Commissioners of Carroll County, Maryland (No. 08-96)

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386020_1147%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 2008

## Text

la

PUBLISHED

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT

THE PINEY RUN PRESERVATION
ASSOCIATION,

Plaintiff-Appellant, No. 07-1348

Vv.

THE COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
CARROLL COUNTY, MARYLAND,

Defendant-Appellee.

Appeal from the United States District Court
for the District of Maryland, at Baltimore.
Andre M. Davis, District Judge.
(1:06-cv-03019)

Argued: January 29, 2008
Decided: April 23, 2008
Before GREGORY and SHEDD, Circuit Judges, and
Patrick M. DUFFY, United States District Judge for

the District of South Carolina, sitting by
designation.

Affirmed by published opinion. Judge Shedd wrote
the opinion, in which Judge Gregory and Judge
Duffy joined.

2a

COUNSEL

ARGUED: Guerdon Macy Nelson, Towson,
Maryland, for Appellant. Linda S. Woolf,
GOODELL, DEVRIES, LEECH & DANN, L.L.-P.,
Baltimore, Maryland, for Appellee. ON BRIEF: Paul
N. DeSantis, Towson, Maryland, for Appellant. K.
Nichole Nesbitt, Joseph B. Wolf, GOODELL,
DEVRIES, LEECH & DANN, L.L.P., Baltimore,
Maryland, for Appellee.

OPINION
SHEDD, Circuit Judge:

Piney Run is a small stream with its
headwaters near the border of Carroll and Baltimore
counties in Maryland. For the second time, the Piney
Run Preservation Association (“the Association”) has
filed a citizen suit under the Clean Water Act
(“CWA” or “the Act”) alleging that the County
Commissioners of Carroll County (“the County”) are
violating the CWA _ by discharging treated
wastewater (i.e., effluent) from the Hampstead
Wastewater Treatment Plant (“the Plant”) into
Piney Run. The Association specifically contends
that the temperature of the discharged effluent at
times exceeds the thermal limitation set forth in the
County’s National Pollutant Discharge Elimination

3a

System (“NPDES”) permit.’ On the County’s motion
to dismiss pursuant to Rule 12(b)(1) of the Federal
Rules of Civil Procedure, the district court found
that the Maryland Department of the Environment
(“MDE”) was “diligently prosecuting” a CWA
enforcement action against the County for violating
the Permit; consequently, the court held that the
Association was barred by 33 U.S.C. § 1365(b)(1)(B)
from maintaining this suit. The Association now
appeals the order of dismissal, arguing that the
district court erred in its “diligent prosecution”
determination. We affirm.

1 The prior CWA litigation between these parties also
centered on the temperature of the Plant’s discharged effluent.
In that case, the district court held that although the County’s
permit (as it then existed) did not contain a thermal limitation,
the County was nonetheless Liable under the CWA.
Consequently, the court enjoined the County from further CWA
violations and assessed civil penalties of $400,000 against it.
We vacated the judgment on appeal, concluding (inter alia) that
the County did not violate the CWA because it “complied with
the discharge limitations and reporting requirements of fits]
permit” and its effluent discharges “were within the reasonable
contemplation of the permitting authority at the time the
permit was issued.” Piney Run Pres. Ass’n v. Cty. Comm’rs of
Carroll Cty., Md., 268 F.3d 255, 259 (4th Cir. 2001), cert.
denied, 535 U.S. 1077 (2002). As we explain below, the County’s
permit has been modified since that time to include a thermal
limitation for the Plant’s discharged effluent.

2 Section 1365(b)(1)(B) provides that a citizen suit may
not be maintained if the government enforcement agency “has
commenced and is diligently prosecuting a civil or criminal
action in a court of the United States, or a State to require
compliance with the standard, limitation, or order, but in any
such action in a court of the United States any citizen may
intervene as a matter of right.”

4a

I

Congress enacted the CWA “to restore and
maintain the chemical, physical, and biological
integrity of the Nation’s waters.” 33 U.S.C. § 1251.
“To serve those ends, the Act prohibits ‘the discharge
of any pollutant by any person’ unless done in
compliance with some provision of the Act.” S. Fla.
Water Mgmt. Dist. v. Miccosukee Tribe of Indians,
541 U.S. 95, 102 (2004) (quoting 33 U.S.C. §
1311(a)). One such provision, codified at 33 U.S.C. §
1342, “established a National Pollution Discharge
Elimination System .. . that is designed to prevent
harmful discharges into the Nation’s waters.” Nat
Ass’n of Home Builders v. Defenders of Wildlife, 127
S. Ct. 2518, 2525 (2007). “Generally speaking, the
NPDES requires dischargers to obtain permits that
place limits on the type and quantity of pollutants
that can be released into the Nation’s waters.”
Miccosukee Tribe, 541 U.S. at 102. An NPDES
permit “defines, and facilitates compliance with, and
enforcement of, a preponderance of a discharger’s
obligations under the [Act].” EPA v. California ex rel.
State Water Res. Control Bd., 426 U.S. 200, 205
(1976). “The Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA) initially administers the NPDES permitting
system for each State, but a State may apply for a
transfer of permitting authority to state officials. If
authority is transferred, then state officials .. . have
the primary responsibility for reviewing and
approving NPDES discharge permits, albeit with
continuing EPA oversight.” Nat’ Ass’n of Home
Builders, 127 S. Ct. at 2525 (citations omitted). The
State of Maryland is authorized to administer the

5a

NPDES program and does so through MDE. See
Piney Run Pres. Ass’n, 268 F.3d at 265.

“Although the primary responsibility for
enforcement rests with the state and federal
governments, private citizens provide a second level
of enforcement and can serve as a check to ensure
the state and federal governments are diligent in
prosecuting Clean Water Act violations.” Sierra Club
v. Hamilton Cty. Bd. of Cty. Comm’rs, 504 F.3d 634,
637 (6th Cir. 2007). Specifically, § 505(a) of the
CWA, 33 U.S.C. § 1365(a), authorizes citizens “to
bring suit against any NPDES permit holder who
has allegedly violated its permit.” Friends of the
Earth, Inc. v. Gaston Copper Recycling Corp., 204
F.3d 149, 152 (4th Cir. 2000) (en banc). We have
recognized that this citizen suit provision is “critical”
to the enforcement of the CWA, see id., as it allows
citizens “to abate pollution when the government
cannot or will not command compliance,” Gwaltney
of Smithfield, Lid. v. Chesapeake Bay Found., Inc.,
484 U.S. 49, 62 (1987). However, citizen suits are
meant “to supplement rather than to supplant
governmental action,” id. at 60, and the CWA —
specifically § 1365(b)(1)(B) — “bars a citizen from
suing if the EPA or the State has already
commenced, and is ‘diligently prosecuting,’ an
enforcement action,” Friends of the Earth, Inc. uv.
Laidlaw Envutl. Servs. (TOC), Inc., 528 U.S. 167, 175
(2000). This “statutory bar is an exception to the
jurisdiction granted in subsection (a) of § 1365, and
jurisdiction is normally determined as of the time of
the filing of a complaint.” Chesapeake Bay Found. v.
American Recovery Co., 769 F.2d 207, 208 (4th Cir.
1985).

6a

II

As we explained in the prior CWA litigation
between these parties, MDE has classified Piney
Run as a Class III-P stream, meaning that it is
protected as a source of public drinking water and as
a body capable of supporting a self-sustaining trout
population. The Plant is subject to the CWA and
since 1975 has operated under a series of NPDES
permits granted by MDE, the most recent one
having been issued in 1990. That permit contains
express limitations on the amount of certain
pollutants that the Plant can discharge, but heat —
which is a statutory pollutant — was not originally
listed in it. See Piney Run Pres. Ass’n, 268 F.3d at
260-61.

In March 2000, as part of ongoing
administrative litigation involving the Plant, MDE
modified the County’s permit to include a thermal
limitation for the Plant’s discharged effluent and
procedures for measuring ambient conditions in
Piney Run. The thermal limitation provides that the
effluent cannot exceed the higher of 20°C or the
ambient temperature of the stream. Following
contested proceedings before an adminis ‘iative law
judge, the modified permit became effective in early
2004. Several months later, the County applied to
MDE for an alternate effluent level (*AEL”) —z.e.,a
less stringent temperature restriction — and
submitted a Study Plan for Alternate Effluent

7a

Limitation for MDE’s review.* During the pendency
of this application, the County has provided MDE
with supplemental reports and appears to have
cooperated with MDE. MDE has not yet made a final
determination on this application.

Apart from its AEL application, the County
petitioned the state circuit court for review of MDE’s
decision to modify the 1990 permit. The County also
moved to stay enforcement of the modified permit
pending the outcome of the petition for review. In
turn, MDE filed a complaint seeking injunctive relief
and civil penalties against the County for, inter alia,
violating the thermal limitation in the modified
permit (“the MDE enforcement action”). Eventually,
the circuit court denied the County’s petition for
judicial review, but it stayed enforcement of the
modified permit until a final decision was rendered
on the County’s petition for review or November 20,
2005, whichever came first. In light of the circuit
court’s stay of enforcement of the modified permit
and the County’s appeal of the denial of its petition
for review, MDE and the County jointly moved the

3 The applicable regulation provides:

Thermal discharge effluent limitations or standards
established in permits may be less stringent than those
required by applicable standards and limitations if the
discharger demonstrates to the satisfaction of the
Department that the effluent limitations or standards
are more stringent than necessary to assure the
protection and propagation of a balanced, indigenous
community of shellfish, fish, and wildlife in and on the
body of water into which the discharge is made.

Md. Code Regs. 26.08.03.03E(1).

8a

circuit court to stay the MDE enforcement action
until the stay of the modified permit was lifted. The
circuit court granted the joint motion and stayed the
MDE enforcement action. On November 20, 2005,
the stay of enforcement of the modified permit
expired, and that permit again became effective.
Subsequently, MDE’s final decision modifying the
permit was judicially affirmed.*

In July 2006, MDE and the County entered
into a Consent Judgment in the MDE enforcement
action reflecting their “agreement as to appropriate
long-term and interim measures’ to _ imsure
compliance with the Permit.” J.A. 373. The circuit
court entered the Consent Judgment on July 25,
2006, and its terms became the order of the circuit

4 The primary point of contention concerning the
appropriate thermal limitation centers on the effect of the
discharged effluent on the Piney Run trout population, and the
parties dispute that effect. According to the County, the Plant’s
purification process does not involve heating the effluent;
rather, it consists of biological and ultraviolet light treatment.
Nonetheless, at times the ambient temperature of outdoor air
and sunlight exposure can affect both the temperature of the
stream and of the effluent before it is discharged. When this
occurs, the daytime temperature of the stream often exceeds
the effluent; however, at night, the stream cools faster than the
stored effluent, causing the effluent to exceed the ambient
temperature of the stream. Interestingly, in affirming the
administrative decision to modify the permit, the Maryland
Court of Special Appeals noted that the administrative law
judge found “that there was no evidence the Plant’s discharge
had any adverse -ffect on aquatic life that naturally occurring
conditions would not have” and that he also indicated that “the
discharge may even have a positive effect on the trout
population.” Cty. Comm’rs of Carroll Cty. v. Rowland, No. 2338,
at 30 (Md. Ct. Spec. App. 2006) (J.-A. 415).

9a

court. See Long v. State of Md., 807 A.2d 1, 7 (Md.
2002) (noting that consent judgments have the same
force and effect as other judgments).

The Consent Judgment initially mandates
that upon its effective date, the County “shall
achieve compliance with the thermal effluent
limitations” set forth in the modified permit. J.A.
374. It also provides that in settlement of all
violations of the thermal limitation that occurred
between November 20, 2005, and July 25, 2006, the
County would pay a civil penalty of $500 for each
day that a violation occurred. Pursuant to this
provision, the County paid penalties in the amount
of $13,500.

Prospectively, the Consent Judgment also
imposes stipulated civil penalties of $500 for each
day that the County fails to: (1) comply with the
thermal limitation of the modified permit; (2) meet
any requirement or complete any required work,
plan, or report; or (3) adhere to any required
milestone date or schedule. In recognition of the
County's AEL request and implementation of an
AEL study, the Consent Judgment provides that the
stipulated penalties automatically begin to accrue on
the day after performance by the County is due or
the day a violation occurs, whichever is applicable,
and will continue to accrue until the County
satisfactorily completes performance or the violation
ceases. If MDE approves an AEL and that approvai
is thereafter challenged, then stipulated penalties
will continue to accrue; however, if a final judgment
is entered approving an AEL, then stipulated
penalties for events that do not exceed the AEL will

10a

not be assessed by MDE. Conversely, if an AEL is
ultimately disapproved, then stipulated penalties
from November 20, 2005, to the date of the final AEL
judgment will become due and payable within 30
days from the final judgment date. Additionally,
upon final disapproval of an AEL, the County will be
required to submit to MDE a plan identifying the
measures needed to comply with the thermal limit of
the modified permit, and the County will thereafter
have 270 days to implement those measures.°
During that 300-day period, stipulated penalties will
continue to accrue for violations of the thermal
limitation.

The Consent Judgment also requires the
County to implement a multi-phase Environmental
Project (“EP”) to “mitigate any water temperature
increases caused by storm water runoff or
modifications to stream buffers in the Piney Run
watershed,” J.A. 376, and it imposes on the County
various obligations and deadlines associated with
the EP. According to MDE, “implementation of the
EP may result in reduced temperature impacts and
related environmental benefits to the Piney Run
watershed.” J.A. 268.

In late August 2006, the Association’s counsel
notified the County and MDE by letter of its intent

®° In the event that an AEL is disapproved, it appears
that the Countys planned means of compliance with the
thermal limitation is the installation of mechanical] chillers
that will cool the effluent before its discharge. The County has
been reluctant to utilize chillers based on its concerns that the
chillers will impact the area’s air and water quality and will
cause noise pollution.

lia

to file a citizen suit to seek enforcement of the
thermal limitation in the modified permit. The
Association thereafter filed this lawsuit in November
2006. The County responded by moving under Rule
12(b)(1) for dismissal, arguing that the Association is
barred from maintaining a citizen suit because the
MDE enforcement action constitutes. diligent
prosecution within the meaning of § 1365(b)(1)(B).
The district court granted the motion and dismissed
the case, finding “that the consent judgment (even
though it does not mandate installation of the
chillers that are plaintiffs preferred remedy) and its
implementation comfortably come within’ the
relevant standards of ‘diligent prosecution.” J.A.
765.
Iil

We review de novo a dismissal under Rule
12(b)(1). Suter v. United States, 441 F.3d 306, 310
(4th Cir.), cert. denied, 127 S. Ct. 273 (2006).° The
Association, as plaintiff, bears the burden of proving
that subject-matter jurisdiction exists. Evans v. B.F.
Perkins Co., 166 F.3d 642, 647 (4th Cir. 1999). For
purposes of this case, this means that the
Association bears the burden of proving that MDE
has not diligently prosecuted the County’s violations
of the thermal limitation set forth in the modified
permit. A CWA enforcement prosecution will
ordinarily be considered “diligent” if the judicial
action “is capable of requiring compliance with the
Act and is in good faith calculated to do so,” and as

5 When presented with a Rule 12(b)(1) motion, district
courts are permitted to consider materials outside the
pleadings, Suter, 441 F.3d at 309 n.2, and the parties presented
such materials in this case.

12a

the Association acknowledges in its opening brief,
diligence is presumed. See Friends of Milwaukee’s
Rivers v. Milwaukee Metro. Sewerage Dist., 382 F.3d
743, 760 (7th Cir. 2004), cert. denied, 544 U.S. 913
(2005); see also Karr v. Hefner, 475 F.3d 1192, 1198
(10th Cir. 2007) (“Citizen-plaintiffs must meet a high
standard to demonstrate that [a government agency]
has failed to prosecute a violation diligently.”). This
presumption “is due not only to the intended role of
the [government] as the primary enforcer of the
[CWA], but also to the fact that courts are not in the
business of designing, constructing or maintaining
sewage treatment systems.” Friends of Milwaukee’s
Rivers, 382 F.3d at 760 (citation omitted).

“Section 1365(b)(1)(B) does not require
government prosecution to be far-reaching or
zealous. It requires only diligence.” Karr, 475 F.3d at
1197. Thus, a citizen-plaintiff cannot overcome the
presumption of diligence merely by showing that the
agency's prosecution strategy is less aggressive than
he would like or that it did not produce a completely
satisfactory result. Jd. Moreover, the fact that an
agency has entered into a consent decree with a
violator that establishes a prospective schedule of
compliance does not necessarily establish lack of
diligence. See Weinberger v. Romero-Barcelo, 456
U.S. 305, 318 (1982) (noting that “enforcement
actions typically result, by consent or otherwise, in a
remedial order setting out a detailed schedule of
compliance designed to cure the identified violation
of the Act” (internal quotation marks omitted)).
Indeed, when presented w: h a consent decree we
must be particularly deferential to the agency’s
expertise, and we “should not interpret § 1365 in a

13a

manner that would undermine the [government’s]
ability to reach voluntary settlements with
defendants.” Karr, 475 F.3d at 1198. As the Supreme
Court has recognized: “If citizens could file suit .. .
in order to seek the civil penalties that the
Administrator chose to forgo, then the
Administrator’s discretion to enforce the Act in the
public interest would be curtailed considerably.”
Gwaltney, 484 U.S. at 61.

The Association argues generally that the
district court erred in concluding that MDE has
diligently prosecuted the County’s CWA violations
“because the Consent Judgment ... provided a
benefit to [the] County and failed to ensure that
violations would not continue.” Brief of Appellant, at
18-19. As we have noted, a CWA enforcement action

will be considered diligent where it is capable of
requiring compliance with the Act and is in good
faith calculated to do so. Based on the record before
us, we hold that the Association has failed to meet
its high burden of establishing that the MDE
enforcement action does not satisfy this standard.

In reaching this conclusion, we initially note
that it cannot seriously be said that the MDE
enforcement action is incapable of requiring
compliance with the Act. Indeed, the evidence
establishes the contrary. MDE modified the County’s
permit in 2000 to include the thermal limitation, and
the modified permit only became effective in 2004 at
the conclusion of contested administrative
proceedings. Before then, the County’s discharge of
effluent did not violate the terms of its NPDES
permit. See Piney Run Pres. Ass’n, 268 F.3d at 259.

l4a

Within several months of the effective date of the
modified permit, MDE filed the enforcement action
seeking, inter alia, injunctive relief requiring the
County “to take all steps necessary to comply with
all terms and conditions of its NPDES permit,
including but not limited to the limitation on
temperature.” J.A. 325. Although the MDE
enforcement action was stayed pending resolution of
the County’s petition for review of MDE’s decision to
modify the permit, it culminated in the Consent
Judgment. Under the terms of the Consent
Judgment, the County is required to comply with the
thermal limitation of the modified permit and is
subject to monetary penalties for failing to do so. In
light of these facts, the MDE enforcement action
surely is capable of requiring the County to comply
with the Act.

The real question raised by the Association is
whether the MDE enforcement action, and
specifically the Consent Judgment, is in good faith
calculated to require the County’s compliance with
the Act.’ In challenging the motivation underlying
the MDE enforcement action, the Association points
to, inter alia, an alleged request by the County for
MDE to file the enforcement action, the fact that the
daily fine established in the Consent Judgment is
lower than the fine imposed in the prior CWA
litigation, and the fact that the Consent Judgment

’ The Association argues that the presumption of
diligence arising from an agency enforcement action can be
rebutted “upon a showing that the agency has engaged in a
pattern of conduct in its prosecution that could be considered
dilatory, collusive or otherwise in bad faith.” Brief of Appellant,
at 21-22 (internal quotation marks omitted).

l5a

does not establish a final deadline for compliance. In
our view, these matters simply do not establish a
lack of diligence on MDE’s part.

Even assuming that the County requested
MDE to pursue the enforcement action, “there is no
incompatibility whatever between a defendant’s
facilitation of suit and the State’s diligent
prosecution — as prosecutions of felons who confess
their crimes and turn themselves in regularly
demonstrate.” Laidlaw Enutl. Servs., 528 U.S. at 211
n.4 (Scalia, J., dissenting).° Moreover, to the extent
that the now-vacated prior fine is relevant, MDE’s
agreement to accept a lower daily fine in the Consent
Judgment appears to be nothing more than a
concession on the part of MDE in exchange for other
obligations (e.g., the EP) that are imposed on the
County. As we have noted, this is precisely the type
of discretionary matter to which we should defer.
Finally, the Association’s complaint about the
absence of a final compliance deadline in the
Consent Judgment is unavailing for at least two
reasons. First, the Consent Judgment requires the
County’s immediate compliance with the thermal
limitation and imposes a daily fine for its violations.
Second,_the open-ended nature of the Consent

8 Although Justice Scalia’s dissenting opinion discussed
the merits of the diligent prosecution question, the Laidlaw
majority did not decide the issue. Notably, however, the
allegation that Laidlaw played a role in facilitating the
enforcement action involved more than a mere request that the
agency file suit; instead, as the majority noted, the district
court found that “Laidlaw drafted the state-court complaint
and settlement agreement, filed the lawsuit against itself, and
paid the filing fee.” 528 U.S. at 178 n.1 (internal quotation
marks omitted).

16a

Judgment reflects the fact that the County is
lawfully seeking an AEL through the _ state
administrative process. Depending on the outcome of
that process, the County’s obligations under the
Consent Judgment may change significantly and
may include not only payment of any accrued fines
but installation of the mechanical chillers. Without
legitimate evidence that MDE had no intention of
acting responsibly on the County’s AEL application,
we have no basis to impute an improper motive to
MDE in this regard.

IV

Based on the foregoing, we affirm the district
court’s order of dismissal.

AFFIRMED

17a

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MARYLAND

CHAMBERS OF
ANDRE M. DAVIS
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

U.S. COURTHOUSE

101 W. LOMBARD STREET
BALTIMORE, MARYLAND 21201
(410) 962-0801

FAX (410) 962-0820
MDDAMDChambers@mdd.uscourts.gov

March 15, 2007

MEMORANDUM TO COUNSEL RE:

The Piney Run Preservation Association v.
County Commissioners of Carroll County
Civil No. AMD 06-3019

Now before the court in this citizen suit
instituted under the Clean Water Act is defendant’s
motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction on the
ground that the Maryland Department of the
Environment is “diligently prosecuting” an
enforcement action. No hearing is needed and I have
elected to rule in this informal manner.

I have read with keen interest and attention
your excellent briefs and the recorded history of
plaintiff s admirable efforts to enforce (once and for all
time) the CWA in respect to Piney Run. Piney Run
Preservation Ass’n v. Commrs. of Carroll Co., 268 F.3d

18a

255 (4th Cir. 2001), cert. denied, 535 U.S. 1077 (2002),
reug Piney Run Pres. Ass’n. v. County Commrs., 82 F.
Supp. 2d 464 (D.Md.2000), and Piney Run Pres. Ass ‘n
uv. County Commrs., 50 F. Supp. 2d 443 (D. Md. 1999).
And see Brewster v. Woodhaven Building, 360 Md. 602,
759 A.2d 738 (2000). Nevertheless, I am satisfied as a
matter of law that the consent judgment (even though
it does not mandate installation of the chillers that are
plaintiffs preferred remedy) and its implementation
comfortably come within the relevant standards of
“diligent prosecution” and that plaintiff is ousted from
its enforcement efforts at this time. See Community of
Cambridge Environmental Health and Community
Dev. Group v. City of Cambridge, 115 F. Supp. 2d 550
(D. Md. 2000).

Accordingly, by separate Order, the motion to

dismiss is GRANTED.
Very truly yours,

Is/
Andre M. Davis
United States District Judge

19a

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLAND

THE PINEY RUN
PRESERVATION ASSOCIATION

Plaintiff
v.

COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF CARROLL COUNTY

Defendant
Civil Action No.: AMDO06CV3019

ORDER

Upon. consideration of Defendant’s Motion to
Dismiss or in the Alternative for Summary
Judgment and Plaintiffs’ Opposition thereto, it is
this 15th day of March, 2007 hereby ORDERED
that:

1. The motion is GRANTED; and

rf The Complaint is hereby DISMISSED
WiTH PREJUDICE; and

The Clerk is directed to close this case.
/s/

HON. ANDRE M. DAVIS
United States District Judge

20a

IN THE CiRCUIT COURT FOR
C4aRROLL COUNTY, MARYLAND

CASE NO.: 06-C-04-041610

STATE OF MARYLAND
DEPARTMENT OF THE
ENVIRONMENT

1800 Washington Boulevard
Baltimore, Maryland 21230

Plaintiff
v.

COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
CARROLL COUNTY

County Office Building
225 North Center Street
Baltimore, Maryland

Defendant

CONSENT JUDGMENT

1. The State of Maryland, Department
of the Environment (the “Department” or
“MDE”), is empowered pursuant to the powers,
duties, and responsibilities vested in and imposed
upon the Secretary of the Environment by
Environment Article, Sections 1-301 and 9-301
through 9-344, inclusive, Annotated Code of
Maryland, to implement and _ enforce’ the
environmental laws, including water pollution

2la

control laws, of the State of Maryland, and,
accordingly, filed this ac‘icn alleging that:

a. The Department, pursuant to
the provisions of Title 9 of the Environment
Article, Annotated Code of Maryland, and
regulations promulgated thereunder, issued
Modification C of State Discharge Permit 88-DP-
0594C, NPDES Permit MD0022446 on or about
February 1, 2004 (“Permit”), to Carroll County,
authorizing a flow increase from 0.5 million
gallons per day (““MGD”) to 0.9 MGD of sanitary
wastewater from the Hampstead wastewater
treatment plant into the Piney Run, waters of the
State.

b. Special Condition IJ.A and B,
Footnotes (2), (3), and (4) of the Permit,
established effluent limitations and monitoring

requirements for temperature at the point of
discharge identified as Outfall 001.

c. Carroll County moved for a
stay of the permit modification until a decision
was reached by the Court of Special Appeals
regarding the merits of its appeal. The stay
request was granted by this Court.

d. The stay expired on November
20, 2005, and as a result, the Permit became
effective on that date.

e. When the temperature rises
during the summer months, past monitoring data has
shown that the temperature of the sanitary

22a

wastewater from the Hampstead wastewater
treatment plant will at times exceed the Permit
limitation of the higher of 20° C or upstream ambient
temperature. Carroll County has reported to MDE
that the effluent has exceeded the temperature
limitation in the Permit on various dates after the
effective date of the Permit beginning on May 30,
2006.

f. Carroll County has designed, but
has not installed, chiller equipment and has been
issued a permit by the Department to construct the
chiller system but has not taken any other measure
to reduce the temperature of its sanitary
wastewater to a level necessary to satisfy the
Permit temperature limit. Pursuant to COMAR
26.08.03.03E, an application for an alternate
effluent limitation may be submitted to the
Department. If an applicant demonstrates to the
Department’s satisfaction that the temperature of
the wastewater discharged will assure the
protection and propagation of a balanced, indigenous
community of shellfish, fish, and wildlife in and on
the Piney Run, the Department may approve an
alternative effluent limit. Carroll County submitted
an application for an alternate effluent limit in
connection with its application for a renewal
discharge permit, and on, May 9, 2004, submitted a
Study Plan for Alternate Effluent limitation for
review by the Department. On December 21, 2005,
Carroll County submitted its Final Report in
connection with its Study Plan to the Department.
The Department requested additional information
and the County submitted a supplemental report to
MDE on May 7, 2006. MDE is currently reviewing

23a

Carroll County’s report and the data submitted
therewith, and Carroll County’s request for an
alternate effluent limit remains pending

g. This action is necessary to insure
compliance with the terms and conditions of the
Permit.

2. The parties have now _ reached
agreement as to appropriate long-term and
interim measures to insure compliance with the
Permit. In lieu of further litigation in this case,
before any testimony has been taken, and without
trial or adjudication of any issue of fact or law
involved herein, and without this Consent
Judgment constituting evidence against or
admission by either party to this proceeding or in
any other proceeding with respect to any factual or
legal issue, and without any admission by Carroil
County of any violations of State law and
regulations promulgated thereunder, or the Permit,
the parties have agreed, in full settlement of this
proceeding, to the entry of this Consent Judgment, as
provided in Rule 2-612, Maryland Rules of
Procedure.

Upon stipulation and consent of the
parties and having considered the allegations set
forth in the Complaint,

IT IS THIS 25" day of July, 2006, by the
Circuit Court for Carroll County, ORDERED:

24a

I. CORRECTIVE ACTION

A. Upon the effective date of this Consent
Judgment, Carroll County shall achieve
compliance with the thermal effluent limitations
for Outfall 001 set forth in Special Condition II.A
and B., Footnotes (2), (3), and (4), of the Permit.

i. PROGRESS REPORTS

Beginning with the effective date of this
Consent Judgment, Carroll County shall submit
quarterly progress reports to the Department,
including, but not limited to, describing the
significant activities and work completed during the
previous calendar quarter, summarizing any
problems or potential problems encountered, any
actions being taken or planned to rectify problems,
and projected work for the next reporting period.
These progress reports, due no later than the 10th
working day of the month following the end of each
calendar quarter (e.g. the 10th working day of July,
October, etc.), shall be submitted until the
obligations under Sections I, III, and IV of this
Consent Judgment shall have been completed.

Wi. ENFORCEMENT/CIVIL
PENALTIES/STIPULATED PENALTIES

A. In settlement of all exceedences of the
temperature effluent limitations of the Permit that
have occurred between the effective date of the
Permit (November 20,2005) and the date that this
Consent Judgment is signed by the parties, upon
written demand by the Department, Carroll County

25a

shall pay, no later than 20 calendar days after such
demand by the Department, a separate civil penalty
of $500 for each day that a temperature violation
has occurred. Payment of civil penalties shall not
relieve Carroll County from the obligations imposed
by this Consent Judgment or any other statute or
regulation, nor shall such payment limit the right of
the Department to seek to enforce the terms of this
Consent Judgment or any other statute of
regulation

B. Beginning on the day that this
Consent Judgment is signed by the parties and
continuing until all obligations under Sections I, III
and IV have been completed, upon written demand by
the Department, Carroll County shall pay, no later
than 20 calendar days after such demand, a stipulated
penalty of $500.00 for each day Carroll County fails
to comply with any temperature effluent limit of the
Permit or fails to meet any requirement or complete
any work, plan or report or adhere to a milestone
date or schedule required by this Consent
Judgment. Payment of this stipulated penalty shall
not relieve Carroll County from the obligations
imposed by this Consent Judgment or any other
statute or regulation, nor shall such payment limit
the right of the Department to seek to enforce the
terms of this Consent Judgment or any other statute
or regulation.

C. Where Carroll County has elected to
conduct an alternate effluent limit study, it shall pay
stipulated penalties as follows:

1. Stipulated penalties shall
automatically begin to accrue on the day after
performance is due, or on the day a violation occurs,
whichever is applicable, and shall continue to accrue
until performance is satisfactorily completed, or until
the violation ceases.

2. If MDE approves an_ alternate
effluent limit and if MDE’s approval of the
alternate effluent limit is challenged, stipulated
penalties shall continue to accrue. However, if the final
judgment, if any, approves the alternate effluent limit,
then such penalties for events that do not exceed the
alternate effluent limit will not be assessed or due and
payable to MDE.

3. If MDE or a final judgment does not

approve the alternate effluent limit, then the penalties,
from the effective date of the Permit (November 20,
2005) to the date of a final judgment, shall be due and
payable, and Carroll County shall pay the accrued
stipulated penalties within 30 days of such final

judgment.

4. Should the final judgment disapprove
the alternate effluent limit, then within 30 days
of the final judgment, Carroll County shall submit
a plan to the Department that identifies the
measures to be taken by the County to comply
with the thermal limits of the Permit, and within
270 days of the Department’s approval of such
measures, Carroll County shall implement the
measures necessary to comply with the thermal
limitations of the Permit. Penalties for violations

27a

of thermal limits shall continue to accrue during
this 300-day period.

IV. ENVIRONMENTAL PROJECT

A. To mitigate any water temperature
increases caused by storm water runoff or
modifications to stream buffers in the Piney Run
watershed, Carroll County shall implement an
Environmental Project (“EP”) in accordance with
the provisions of this Consent Judgment. By July
1, 2006, Carroll County shall submit a study plan
and schedule for evaluating the thermal effects of
storm water released into the Piney Run within
Carroll County. Within 30 days of the
Department’s approval of the study plan and
schedule submitted by Cairoll County, Carroll
County shall begin an evaluation of the storm water
management (“SWM7”) facilities upstream of or in
the vicinity of the Plant and the thermal effects
of storm water discharged from those facilities to
the Piney Run. Upon completion of this evaluation
and no later than September 30, 2006, Carroll
County shall complete the collection of stormwater
management facility based thermal data for
evaluation. After evaluation of that information and
no later than December 15, 2006, Carroll County
shall submit to the Department for review and
approval the evaluation, along with a storm
water temperature remediation plan based on
the findings of the SWM _ evaluation, an
implementation schedule for the remediation plan,
and a budget. Carroll County shall modify the
storm water management facilities in Carroll
County and provide for ongoing

28a

management of storm water in accordance with the
remediation plan and schedule, as approved by MDE.

Carroll County has previously planted a
riparian buffer on its property along the Piney Run
upstream and downstream of its discharge point.
During the 2006 planting season, Carroll County shall
survey and evaluate the status of the riparian buffers
from the headwaters of the Piney Run to Trenton
Road, plant and establish a riparian buffer on its
property where there is none, enhance any existing
buffer with appropriate supplemental plant stock to
accelerate effective stream cover, and place the
riparian buffer under a conservation easement. By
August 1, 2006, Carroll County shall submit a plan to
MDE for establishing an effective riparian buffer on its
property, indicating the size, quantity, and species of

the proposed supplemental stock, the proposed spacing
of the trees and dimensions of the buffer. The
additional trees will be native species appropriate for
the physiographic region.

By September 1, 2006, Carroll County shall
submit a plan for establishing a riparian buffer or
purchasing easements for establishing, on privately
owned property, a riparian buffer along the Piney Run
from its headwaters to Trenton Road. The plan shall
include a description of an offer by Carroll County to
riparian property owners to either 1) establish an
effective riparian buffer or 2) purchase of a
conservation easement at fair market value for the
establishment of an effective riparian buffer. Carroll
County shall use best efforts to obtain permission to
establish a riparian buffer or to obtain conservation
easements for the planting of a riparian buffer from

29a

such landowners. The plan shall include a schedule
and budget. The plan may also include any other
stream temperature improvement measures. the
County believes will be effective. Carroll County shall
implement the plan and schedule as approved by the
Department.

B. Carroll County shall monitor the water
temperature of the Piney Run near or at the
headwaters of the Piney Run, the County line and
Trenton Road before implementation of the SWM
evaluation and for a period of five years after
implementation of the SWM remediation plan and the
riparian buffer plans.

C. Beginning on July 1, 2006, and at the end
of every quarter thereafter until the completion of the

Environmental Project, Carroll County shall submit
documentation of all expenditures incurred in
connection with the $$Environmental i Project,
accompanied by a certification of the truth and accuracy
of each of the following:

l. That all cost information provided
to MDE in connection with its approval of the
Environmental Project is complete and accurate and
represents a fair estimate of the costs necessary to
implement the Environmental Project;

2. That except for the requirement
to perform the Environmental Project pursuant to
this Consent Judgment, Carroll County was not
required to perform the Environmental Project by
any federal, State or local law or regulation.

30a

D. Within 30 days after the deadline for
completion of the Environmental Project pursuant to the
plan to be submitted by Carroll County, Carroll County
shall submit an Environmental Project completion
report to MDE. This report shall contain a detailed
description of the Environmental Project § as
implemented; documentation of expenditures made in
connection with the Environmental Project, including
an itemized list of all eligible Environmental Project
costs; certification that the Environmental Project has
been fully implemented; and a description of the
environmental benefits resulting from implementation of
the Environmental Project.

An Environmental Projects Implementation
Schedule that sets forth the deadlines contained in this

Judgment.

E. After receiving the Environmental
Project completion report, MDE shall notify Carroll
County whether Carroll County has satisfactorily
completed the Environmental Project. If the
Environmental Project has not been satisfactorily
completed in accordance with all _ schedules,
stipulated penalties may be assessed under Section Ii
of this Consent Judgment.

V. PAYMENTS OF PENALTIES

All payments of penalties set forth in Section II
(““ENFORCEMENT/STIPULATED PENALTIES”) of
this Consent Judgment shall be made by check payable
to the Maryland Clean Water Fund, and shall be
mailed to the Maryland Department of the

318

Environment, Fiscal Services’ Division, Cash
Receipts/Advances Unit, P.O Box 2057, Baltimore,
Maryland 21203-2057.

VI. PERSONS BOUND BY ORDER

This Consent Judgment shall be binding upon
the Department and Carroll County and their
respective agents, employees, successors and assigns.

VII. NO ADMISSIONS OR WAIVERS

This Consent Judgment is understood and intended
by the parties to be without any admission of liability,
and nothing in this Consent Judgment shall be
considered an admission by any party in this
proceeaings. Except as provided in Section III
(“ENFORCEMENT / STIPULATED PENALTIES”)
of this Consent Judgment, nothing contained herein
shall constitute a waiver of the rights of the
Department to proceed in an administrative or civil
action for violations of the terms of this Consent
Judgment, any other terms or conditions of the Permit,
or of applicable statutes or regulations. The
Department may bring any action authorized by law to
enforce this Consent Judgment, including an action for
contempt.

VILL. NOTIFICATION

Unless otherwise specified, reports,
correspondence, approvals, disapprovals, notices or
other submissions relating to or required by this
Consent Judgment shall be in writing and shall be
sent to the following:

For the Department:

Robert M. Summers, Director

Water Management Administration
Maryland Department of the Environment
1800 Washington Boulevard

Baltimore, Maryland 21230

(410)537-3567

For Carroll County:

Kimberly Millender

County Attorney

225 N. Center Street
Westminster, Maryland 21157
(410) 386-2030

IX. DELAY

If any event occurs which causes or which
Carroll County reasonably expects to cause a delay in
the achievement of any requirement imposed by this
Consent Judgment, Carroll County shall notify the
Department, in writing, within ten (10) working days
of obtaining knowledge of the occurrence of such event
and of its impact on timely compliance. The notice
shall identify the cause of the delay, an estimate of the
anticipated length of delay, the measures taken and to
be taken by Carroll County to prevent or minimize
the delay and an estimate of the date by which such
measures will be completed. Carroll County shall
promptly implement all reasonable measures to
prevent or minimize any such delay and to comply with
all requirements of the Consent Judgment as soon as

33a

reasonably possible Carroll County may request, in
writing, an extension of any deadline for any
reason, at least ten ‘10) working days prior to such
deadline. The Department may, at its sole
discretion, grant an extension upon such a
request. If such an extension is granted, any
stipulated penalty, if applicable, shall not accrue.

X. FORCE MAJEURE

A. Carroll County shall perform. the
requirements of this Consent Judgment in the
manner and within the time limits set herein,
unless the performance is prevented or delayed by
events which constitute a force majeure. Carroll
County shall have the burden of proving such a
force majeure. A force majeure is defined by any

event or circumstance arising from causes not
reasonably foreseeable and beyond the control of
Carroll County, which cannot be avoided or
overcome by due diligence and which delays or
prevents performance in the manner or by a date
required by this Consent Judgment.

B. Circumstances beyond the control of
Carroll County include, without limitation,
earthquake, flood or other act of God, war, riot,
terrorism, injunction, fire, freight embargo,
compliance with any law, rule or order of any
zovernmental body either now or hereafter created
that conflicts with the requirements or obligations
of tibis Consent Judgment, or strike. Such
circumstances do not include increased costs of
performance, changed economic circumstances,
normal inclement weather, or failure to obtain

34a

(

federal, state or local permits unless Carroll
County has made timely and complete application
for such permits.

C. Within ten (10) working days after
becoming aware of any event that Carroll County
believes constitutes a force majeure, Carroll County
shall notify the Department of such event in
accordance with Section IX herein (“DELAY”).
Failure to comply with the notice provision of this
section shall constitute a waiver of Carroll
County’s right to assert a force majeure claim.

D. If the Department determines that
the event or anticipated event which has caused
or will cause the delay constitutes a force majeure,
the time for performance hereunder shall be

extended for an appropriate period of time as
determined by the Department, but not less than a
period of time substantially equal to the length of
the necessary delay, and any applicable stipulated
penalty shall not accrue. This’ shall be
accomplished by written approval of _ the
Department.

XI. SUBSEQUENT MODIFICATION

Any modification of the Consent Judgment
may be made without approval of the Court but
must be in writing and approved by the parties. A
party shall not petition the Court for modification
without having first made a good faith effort to
reach agreement with the other party on such
modification.

35a

XII. NOTA PERMIT

This Consent Judgment is not and shall not
be interpreted to be a permit or modification of any
existing permit. MDE does not, by its consent to
entry of this Consent Judgment, warrant . or aver
in any manner that Carroll County’s complete
compliance with this Consent Judgment will result
in compliance with the provisions Title 9, Subtitle 3
of the Environment Article, Annotated Code of
Maryland, the Clean Water Act or with the
discharge permit issued to Carroll County.
Notwithstanding MDE’s review or approval of
any plans, reports, policies or procedures, Carroll
County shall remain solely responsible for any
non-compliance with the terms of this Consent
Judgment, all applicable permits, the Clean Water
Act, and State water pollution controllaws and
regulations.

Nothing in this Consent Judgment shall
be construed to limit any authority of MDE to
issue any orders, enforce any applicable orders,
or to take any action it deems necessary to
protect public health or comfort, or to limit
any authority. MDE has or may hereafter de
delegated.

XIII. SEVERABILITY

If any provision or authority of this Consent
Judgment or the application of this Consent
Judgment to any party or circumstance is held by
any judicial or administrative authority to be
invalid, the application of such provision or

36a

authority to other parties or circumstances and the
remainder of this Consent Judgment shall not be
aftected thereby and shall remain in full force.

XIV. CONTINUING JURISDICTION

This Court shall have jurisdiction to enforce
the terms and conditions of this Consent Judgment,
to modify the Consent Judgment upon petition of
either party, and. to resolve disputes arising under
this Consent Judgment.

XV. EFFECTIVE DATE

This Consent Judgment shall become
effective as of the date of approval by the Circuit
Court for Carrol! County and shall remain in force
and effect until all obligations and terms referred
to in Sections I through V herein have been
completed or satisfied.

The Plaintiff and the Defendants hereby
consent to the entry of this Consent Judgment.

CARROLL COUNTY

BY: /s/
TITLE: Chief of Staff
DATE: _ 7/7/06

37a

DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT

BY: f/ :
TITLE: Director, Water Mgmt. Admin.
DATE: __7/11/06

Dated and entered this 25" day of July 2006:

/s/ :
Judge, Circuit Court for Carroll County

38a

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLAND

THE PINEY RUN
PRESERVATION ASSOCIATION

Plaintiff

Ve

COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF CARROLL COUNTY

Defendant
Civil Action No.: AMDO6CV3019
Entered January 8, 2007

DEFENDANT’S MOTION TO DISMISS

Defendants County Commissioners of
Carroll County, by their undersigned counsel, move
to dismiss the complaint for lack of subject matter
jurisdiction, and in support of their motion attach
the following Memorandum of Law, which is
incorporated as if fully set forth herein.

WHEREFORE, Defendants County
Commissioners of Carroll County respectfully
request that the Court dismiss Plaintiffs Complaint
with prejudice.

Respectfully submitted,

/s/_ Linda S. Woolf

Linda S. Woolf (Federal Bar No. 08424)

K. Nichole Nesbitt (Federal Bar No. 26137)
Goodell, DeVries, Leech & Dann, LLP

One South Street, 20" Floor

Baltimore, Maryland 21202

(410) 783-4000

Attorney for Defendant County
Commissioners of Carroll County

42a

this case originally was issued in 1990 and sets
forth various limitations on the characteristics of
the Plant’s treated wastewater (also. called
“effluent”). (Ex. 2, Permit No. 88-DP-0594). As
originally issued, the Permit contained no
limitations with regard to temperature. (Id.).
Following a challenge by various landowners
(several of whom are members of the Plaintiff
Association),’° however, MDE introduced an effluent
limitation for temperature into the Permit and
issued notices of its determination. (Ex. 4, Notice of
Final Determination). Both the County and the
landowners challenged MDE’s Notice of Final
Determination, and a contested case hearing was
held in the Office of Administrative Hearings in the
summer of 2001.

At the contested case hearing, the parties
introduced extensive evidence concerning the
operation of the Plant and the characteristics and
condition of the Piney Run. (Ex. 5, Nov. 15, 2001
Proposed Order by ALJ). The parties stipulated that,
between 1993 and 2001, the Plant had made certain
improvements to its operating system intended to,
among other things, minimize the effect of

1? Upon the challenge by the landowners, a contested case
hearing was held and the matter proceeded through the
Baltimore County Circuit Court and into the Court of Special
Appeals, which remanded the matter back to MDE for a
determination of certain specific factual issues. (Ex. 3, August
17, 2998 Opinion of Court of Special Appeals, Woodward v.
Maryland Department of the Environment, Case No. 1660
(Sept. Term 1997)

43a

environmental factors on the stream. (Id. at 8-9).
The evidence demonstrated that the Plant’s effluent
generally did not exceed the greater of 20°C or the
ambient temperature of the stream throughout most
of the year, but on certain occasions “during the
periods of the hottest weather when solar radiation
and the air temperature become significant warming
factors on the stream itself,” the effluent exceeded
this criteria by “as much as 2 degrees C,” usually in
the evening hours. (Id. at 12-13). Nonetheless, the
evidence was undisputed that flow from the Plant
actually had a moderating effect on the temperature
of the stream, which was beneficial to the trout
population. (Id. at 35). A habitat assessment
performed just prior to the hearing demonstrated
that the Piney Run contains abundant numbers of
trout, as well as aquatic and plant species that are
beneficial to the propagation of trout. (Id. at 13-14).
The ALJ ultimately determined that the Plant’s
discharge, even in the absence of any temperature
limitation, had no adverse biological impact on the
stream. (Id. at 35). Nonetheless, the ALJ upheld
the introduction of the temperature limitation, and
MDE’s Final Decision Maker concurred. (Ex. 6,
MDE’s Nov. 18, 2003 Final Decision and Order).
MDE issued the new permit - with the temperature
limitation in place - on January 21, 2004. (Ex. 7,
Permit No. 88-DP-0594C).

B. The County’s Application for an
Alternate Effluent Limit

On July 9, 2004, Carroll County submitted an
application for an alternate effluent limit, pursuant
to the water quality regulations, along with a Study

Plan for Alternate Effluent Limitation for review by
MDE. (Ex. 1, Aff. of James Slater at 7f 23-24). The
applicable regulation regarding alternate effluent
limits provides as follows:

Thermal discharge effluent limitations or
standards established in permits may be
less stringent than those required by
applicable standards and limitations if
the discharger demonstrates to the
satisfaction of the Department that the
effluent limitations or standards are more
stringent than necessary to assure the
protection and propagation of a balanced,
indigenous community of shellfish, fish,
and wildlife in and on the body of water
into which discharge is made.

COMAR 26.08.03.03E(1). Given MDE’s findings
concerning the health of the stream and its
community of fish and wildlife even in the absence
of any temperature limit, the County sought a less
stringent temperature restriction and prepared
several extensive studies of the biological and
physical conditions of the stream to support its
application. (Ex. 1, Aff. of James E. Slater at {J 24-
36). The study process included’ extensive
temperature data collection and modeling of the
thermal characteristics of the stream and a multi-
phase biological and habitat study, based on a field
research program with a number of components.

(id.).

As of this date, the County has met all of
MDE’s deadlines associated with its alternate

45a

effluent limit study. On December 21, 2005, the
County submitted its Final Report in connection
with its Study Plan to MDE and it has provided all
additional information requested by MDE by way of
a supplemental report in connection with its
application. MDE has not yet completed its review
of the County’s application for an alternate effluent
limit. (Id. at J 25).

C. MDE’s Enforcement Action and
the Stay of Enforcement

While its application for an alternate effluent
limit was pending, the County petitioned for judicial
review of MDE’s Final Decision and moved to stay
enforcement of the Permit pending the outcome of
the appellate process. (Ex. 9, County’s May 25, 2004
Motion to Stay). Thereafter, MDE filed a Complaint
for Injunctive Relief and Civil Penalties against the
County for violating the new temperature limit in
the Permit. (Ex. 10, Complaint, State of Maryland
Department of the Environment v. County
Commissioners of Carroll County, Case No. 06-C-04-
041610 (the “Enforcement Action”)). The Circuit
Court for Carroll County denied the County’s
petition for judicial review but granted its motion to
stay and ordered that enforcement of the Permit
would be stayed until the first to occur of a final
decision of the case or November 20, 2005. (Ex. 11,
Nov. 23, 2004 Order of Hon. J. Barry Hughes).
Given the Circuit Court’s stay of enforcement of the
Permit and the fact that the County had noted an
appeal to the Court of Special Appeals, MDE and
the County jointly moved to stay the Enforcement
Action until the Circuit Court’s stay of the Permit

46a

(

was lifted. (Ex. 12, Dec. 20, 2004 Joint Motion to
Stay). The court granted the joint motion. (Ex. 18,
Jan. 25, 2005 Order Staying Enforcement Action).
Pursuant to the Circuit Court’s November 23, 2004
Order, during the duration of the stay, the County
continued to operate the Plant in full compliance
with its prior NPDES Permit, which did not contain
a temperature limitation. (Ex. 1, Aff. of James
Slater at J 7).

D. The Consent Judgment Entered
in the Enforcement Action

The stay of enforcement granted by the
Circuit Court for Carroll County expired on
November 20, 2005 and the Permit became effective
on that date. (Ex. 8, Aff. of David Lyons" at { 2).
By that time, the County’s request for an alternate
effluent limit was proceeding through the MDE
review process. On or about July 11, 2006, Carroll
County and MDE entered into a Consent Judgment
in the Enforcement Action, which reflected their
agreement as to appropriate long-term and interim
measures to ensure compliance with the Permit. (Id.
at { 3). The Consent Judgment reflects the parties’
agreement in full settlement of the Enforcement
Action, as provided in Rule 2-612, Maryland Rules
of Procedure. (Id.). The Consent Judgment was

1 Mr. Lyons is the Division Chief of the Water Management
Administration Compliance Program at MDE. He is responsible for
enforcement of the terms, conditions, limitations and requirements of
State and NPDES Discharge Permits and has been involved in the
enforcement activities with regard to the County. (Ex. 8, Aff. of David
Lyons at 7 1)

47a

entered by the Circuit Court for Carroll County on
July 25, 2006. (Ex. 14, Consent Judgment).

The Consent Judgment imposes stipulated
civil penalties of $500 for each day that the County
fails to comply with any temperature effluent limit
of the Permit or fails to meet any requirement or
complete any work, plan, or report, or adhere to a
milestone date or schedule required by the Consent
Judgment. Pursuant to this provision, MDE made
written demand upon the County for stipulated
penalties (and the County paid the stipulated
penalties) for each day that it failed to comply with
the temperature effluent limit of the Permit prior to
the entry of the Consent Judgment. The County has
made a total payment in the amount of $13,500 for
such stipulated penalties. (Ex. 8, Aff. of David
Lyons at {J 4-6).

The Consent Judgment provides that, in light
of the County’s application for an alternate effluent
limit and its implementation of an alternate effluent
limit study, stipulated penalties would
automatically begin to accrue on the day after
performance is due or the day a violation occurs,
whichever is applicable, and will continue to accrue
if MDE approves an alternate effluent limit and
MDE’s approval of the limit is challenged. However,
if the final judgment, if any, approves the alternate
effluent limit, then such penalties for events that do
not exceed the alternate effluent limit will not be
assessed or due and payable to MDE. If MDE or a
final judgment does not approve the alternate
effluent limit, then stipulated penalties from the
effective date of the Permit to the date of the final

48a

judgment shall be due and payable within 30 days of
such final judgment. (Id. at ¥ 7; Ex. 14, Consent
Judgment).

In addition to the provisions regarding
penalties, the Consent Judgment required the
County to design and implement a multi-phase
Environmental Project (“EP”) to mitigate any water
temperature increases caused by storm water run-off
or modifications to stream buffers in the Piney Run
watershed. The EP required the County to submit a
Study Plan and Schedule for evaluating the thermal
effects of storm water released into the Piney Run
within the County by July 1, 2006 and, within 30
days of the Department’s approval of the Study
Plan, to began in evaluation of the Storm Water
Management (“SWM7”) facilities upstream or in the
vicinity of the Plant and the thermal effects of the
storm water discharged from those facilities into the
Piney Run. The County was required to complete the
collection of SWM facility based thermal data no
later than September 30, 2006. The County was
required to submit, no later than December 15,
2006, a storm water temperature remediation plan
based on the findings of the SWM evaluation, an
implementation schedule for the remediation plan
and a budget. The County has met all of these SWM
temperature remediation milestone dates under the
EP. (Ex. 8, Aff. of David Lyons at {J 8-9).

The Consent Judgment also required the
County, during the 2006 planting season, to survey
and evaluate the status of the riparian buffers from
the headwaters of the Piney Run to a location
downstream in Baltimore County, to plant and
establish a riparian buffer on its property where

49a

there is none, to enhance any existing buffer with
Suppicmental plant stock, and to place the riparian
buffer under a conservation easement. By August 1,
2006, the County was required to submit a plan to
MDE for establishing an effective riparian buffer on
its property. By September 1, 2006, the County was
required to submit a plan for establishing a riparian
buffer or purchasing easements for establishing a
riparian buffer on privately-owned property along
the Piney Run from its headwaters to Trenton Road.
The County has met these milestone dates for the
enhancement of the existing riparian buffer and the
establishment of additional riparian buffers along
the Piney Run. (1d. at 110).

The Consent Judgment requires the County to
submit quarterly progress reports to MDE
describing the significant activities and work
completed. Beginning on July 1, 2006, and at the
end of every quarter thereafter until the completion
of the EP, the County is required to submit
documentation of all expenditures incurred in
connection with the EP, certifying that all cost
information provided to MDE is complete and
accurate and represents a fair estimate of the costs
necessary to implement the EP. The County is also
required to certify that, except for the requirement
to perform the EP pursuant to the Consent
Judgment, the County was not required to perform
the EP by any federal, state, or local law or
regulation. The County has complied with this
quarterly reporting requirement since July 1, 2006.
(IA at J 11).

50a

Additionally, the Consent Judgment requires
the County to submit, within 30 days after the
completion of the EP, a completion § report
containing a detailed description of the EP as
implemented, documentation of expenditures made
im connection with the EP, including an itemized
list of all eligible EP costs, certification that EP has
been fully implemented, and a description of the
environmental benefits resulting from _ the
implementation of the EP. (Id. at | 12). This
deadline has not yet occurred.

Absent the requirements of the Consent
Judgment, the County would not be required to
perform any aspect of the EP, including the
enhancement of the existing riparian buffer in
Carroll County, the establishment of an effective
riparian buffer downstream in Baltimore County or
the monitoring and remediation of the thermal
impact of storm flow from the SWM facilities in
Carroll County. (Ex. 1, Aff. of James Slater at J 38).
MDE believes, however, that implementation of the
EP will result in significant environmental benefits
in the Piney Run watershed, including a significant
alleviation of any thermal impacts on the stream.
(Ex. 8, Aff. of David Lyons at J 13).

The County already has expended significant
amounts of money to improve the condition of the
stream, both prior to the Enforcement action and in
implementing the EP as required by the Consent
Judgment. In 1998-99, the County spent $250,000
to remove an 800-foot concrete channel and
construct a natural channel above and below the
Plant, create a riparian buffer, and retrofit three
SWM facilities upstream of the Plant. (Ex. 1, Aff. of

5la

James Slater at | 21). The expenditures associated
with the application for an alternate effluent limit
have, to date, totaled $189,814.38. (id. at J 36). The
health of the stream has benefited significantly by
this action, as shown through numerous studies.
(Id. at {{ 31 -35).

MDE and the County used the same kind of
holistic approach in reaching the terms of the
Consent Judgment. Under the terms of the Consent
Judgment, and, specifically the EP, the County has
performed an assessment of the thermal impact of
the upstream storm water discharge. The
temperature loggers and software required for the
assessment cost $1,878, and a total of $57,450 was
paid to EA, the County’s consultant, during the
period from June through January 8, 2006 to
support their efforts in assisting the County in this
effort. The County has submitted a proposed plan to
retrofit SWM facilities upstream of the Plant that
will significantly reduce the thermal load on the
stream, with a projected cost of $355,000. It has
proposed a buffer enhancement plan for the land
along the stream within the County that would cost
an additional $24,000. It has also submitted a
proposed plan to establish riparian buffers or obtain
conservation easements on private land in
Baltimore County that could entail significant
additional expenditures. (Ex. 1, Aff. of James Slater
at (9 37-45 and Project Table attached as exhibit B
thereto).

Notwithstanding MDE’s Enforcement Action
and the extensive corrective and_. beneficial
environmental activity resulting from it, Plaintiff
brought its citizen’s suit on December 4, 2006.

52a

STANDARD OF REVIEW FOR THE
JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION
IN THIS CASE

Pursuant to Rule 12(b)()) of the Federal Rules
of Civil Procedure, a complaint should be dismissed
if the court lacks subject matter jurisdiction over the
action. FED. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(1). When a defendant
challenges subject matter jurisdiction, “the district
court is to regard the pleadings as mere evidence on
the issue, and may consider evidence outside the
pleadings without converting the proceeding to one
for summary judgment.” Evans v. B.F. Perkins Co.,
166 F.3d 642, 647 (4" Cir. 1999). “The district court
should grant the 12(b)(1) motion to dismiss ‘if the
material jurisdictional facts are not in dispute and
the moving party is entitled to prevail as a matter of
law.” Community of Cambridge Environmental
Health and Community Dev. Group v. City of
Cambridge, 115 F. Supp. 2d 550, 553 (D. Md. 2000)
(quoting Evans, 166 F.3d at 647)).

IV. ARGUMENT

The provision of the Clean Water Act under
which Plaintiff has brought this action provides
that “[n]o action may be commenced under
subsection (a)(1) of this section... if the
Administrator or State has commenced and is
diligently prosecuting a civil or criminal action in a
court of the United States or a State to require
compliance with the standard, limitation, or order”
that the plaintiff alleges was violated. 33 U.S.C. §
1365(b)(1)(B). “This provision is a necessary
precondition for the court’s jurisdiction,” and “[t]he

53a

Plaintiffs have the burden of proving that [the State
agencys] prosecution is not diligent” in order to
defeat a motion to dismiss. City of Cambridge, 115
F. Supp. 2d at 554; see also Gwaltney of Smithfield,
Ltd. v. Chesapeake Bay Foundation, 484 U.S. 49,
64, 108 S. Ct. 376 (1987). “This burden is a heavy
one because diligence on the part of the enforcement
agency is presumed.” City of Cambridge, 115 F.
Supp. 2d at 554 (quoting Friends of the Earth, Inc.
v. Laidiaw Envir. Servs., Inc., 890 F. Supp. 470,487
(D.S.C. 1995).

The purpose of the statute is to ensure that
citizen suits do not play a “potentially intrusive” role
in enforcement of the environmental laws; it is
important to preserve the “government agency’s
discretion to act in the public interest.” Arkansas
“Wildlife Federation v. ICI Americas. Inc., 29 F.3d
376, 380 (8" Cir. 1994). Thus, citizen suits are only
appropriate where federal and state authorities
appear “unwilling to act.” Lockett v. Environmental
Protection Agency, 319 F.3d 678, 684 (5 Cir. 2003)
(quoting North and South Rivers Watershed Ass’n
v. Town of Scituate, 949 F.2d 552, 555 (1" Cir.
1992)). “Duplicative enforcement actions add little
or nothing to compliance actions already underway,
but do divert State resources away from remedying
violations in order to focus on the duplicative
effort.” Scituate, 949 F.2d at 556.

Here, MDE’s Enforcement Action against the
County and the terms of the resulting Consent
Judgment undisputedly constitute diligent
prosecution, such that Plaintiffs cause of action is
jurisdictionally barred.

54a

A. Plaintiff Cannot Establish a Lack
of Diligent Prosecution

The issue this court must determine is
“whether corrective action already taken and
diligently pursued by the government seeks to
remedy the same violations as duplicative civilian
action.” Arkansas Wildlife Federation v. ICI
Americas. Inc., 29 F.3d 376, 381 (8 Cir. 1994).
Thus, there are three issues: (1) whether MDE has
taken corrective action; (2) whether MDE is
diligently pursuing the corrective action; and (3)
whether the action seeks to remedy the same
violations as the civilian action. Id., All three
factors mandate dismissal in this case.

ei MDE has taken corrective action
in this case.

MDE filed the Enforcement Action more than
two years’ before Plaintiff ffiled suit. The
Enforcement Action sought injunctive relief and
civil penalties against the County for discharging
wastewater “with temperatures higher’ than
permitted by the NPDES Permit issued by the State
of Maryland for discharges to State waters.” (Ex.
10, Enforcement Action Complaint). It encompassed
violations from June 2004 “continuing to the
present.” (Id.). The Action was stayed by court order
until November 2005, at which time MDE and the
County began the process of determining the best
manner to address the temperature limit violations.
This process culminated in an extensive Consent
Judgment through which MDE has required the
County to engage in the following action:

pay civil penalties of $500 for each
day that the County fails to comply
with, any temperature effluent limit;

design and implement an
Environmental Project (“EP”) to
mitigate any water temperature
increases caused by factors other
than Plant discharge;

submit a Study Plan and Schedule
for evaluating the thermal effects of
storm water released into the Piney
Run within the County;

evaluate the Storm Water
Management (“SWM7”) facilities

upstream or in the vicinity of the
Plant and the thermal effects of the
storm water discharged from those
facilities into the Piney Run;

submit a storm water temperature
remediation plan based on the
findings of the SWM evaluation;

survey and evaluate the status of
the riparian buffers from the
headwaters of the Piney Run to a
location downstream in Baltimore
County, in order to further address
thermal aspects of the stream;

56a

plant and establish a riparian buffer
on County-owned property where
mere 1s none;

enhance any existing buffer on
County-owned property with
supplemental! plant stock;

place the riparian buffer under a
conservation easement;

design and implement a plan for
establishing riparian buffers’ or
obtaining conservation easements on
properties owned by private
landowners in Baltimore County;

submit documentation on a quarterly
basis of progress made, problems
encountered and all expenditures
incurred in connection with the EP;
and

submit, within 30 days after the
completion of the EP, a completion
report containing a detailed
description of the EP as
implemented, documentation of
expenditures made in connection
with the EP, certification that the EP
has been fully implemented, and a
description of the environmental
benefits resulting from the
implementation of the EP.

57a

(Ex. 14, Consent Judgment; Ex. 8, Aff. of David
Lyons at 79 7-12). Ali of these actions were
designed to address the effects of thermal discharge
into the Piney Run. (Id.). Without question, MDE
took corrective action against the County.

2. MDE is diligently pursuing the
corrective action.

The Consent Judgment requires continued
involvement of both the County and MDE to pursue
the corrective action. The County is required to
report on a quarterly basis to MDE with regard to
the progress of implementing the EP and the costs
associated with its activities. It has submitted
timely quarterly reports since the execution of the
Consent Judgment. (Ex. 1, Aff. of James Slater at
48; Ex. 8, Aff. of David Lyons at J 11). While the
County engages in these environmental
improvement activities, MDE continues to assess
penalties against the County for each day the
County is in violation of its permit. The County has
made a total payment in the amount of $13,500 for
such stipulated penalties. (Ex. 8, Aff. of David Lyons
at {[ 6).

Although the County is seeking an alternate
effluent limit (AEL) that would change the
temperature restriction, the stipulated penalties
continue to accrue while the application is being
considered. If MDE does not approve the AEL, the
stipulated penalties become due and payable within
30 days of the final judgment. If MDE approves the
AEL but that approval is challenged, stipulated
penalties continue to accrue until the time of a final

58a

judgment. Assessment of penalties will only cease if
a final judgment is entered approving the AEL and
then only to the extent that past or future violations
do not exceed the AEL. (Id. at 9 7).

In addition to assessing the stipulated
penalties, MDE has required the County to spend
significant resources implementing the EP. The
County has paid nearly $2,000 for equipment and
over $57,000 to its research consultants. The SWM
retrofit project is predicted to cost an additional
$355,000. The County will spend an estimated
$24,000 to complete a buffer enhancement plan in
the Carroll County portion of the stream in spring
2007. It may incur significant additional expense in
connection with the establishment of riparian
buffers/conservation easements in Baltimore County,

although this will depend on the willingness of
private landowners, including members of the
Plaintiff association, to participate in-this project.
(Ex. 1, Project Table attached to Aff. of James E.
Slater)

It is clear from a comparison with other
cases that MDE’s action meets the threshold of
diligent prosecution. In City of Cambridge, for
example, this Court held that the threshold had
been met when MDE:

brought a_ judicial, rather than
administrative action; it sought and
obtained a monetary penalty from the
City, though minimal; it limited future
connections to the sewer system; and it
has required, reviewed, and approved the

59a

planning, development, and construction
of a new system to eliminate wastewater
problems and alleviate unauthorized
discharges.

115 F. Supp. 2d at 556. Similarly, in Scituate, the
state agency required the municipality to submit
monthly, weekly, and daily test results from
monitoring wells, spend close to one million dollars
planning a new treatment facility, and enforce a
sewer hookup moratorium. 949 F.2d at 557.

Here, MDE has required the County to pay
stipulated penalties for violating its permit, conduct
comprehensive studies on the thermal impact of
other discharges into the stream, engage in extensive
remedial activity to address temperature concerns,
and meet strict reporting requirements. The County
is expected to spend more than $435,000 to meet
MDE’s requirements and is diligently working to
comply with the terms of the Consent Judgment.
Absent the Consent Order, the County would not be
required to do any of this investigatory and remedial
work, and the stream would not see the resulting
improvement.

It cannot be said that MDE’s efforts in
pursuing the County have been “dilatory, collusive
or otherwise in bad faith” as would defeat the
presumption of diligence. See Connecticut Fund for
the Environment v. Contract Plating Co., 631 F.
Supp. 1291, 1293 (D. Conn. 1986) (“The court must
presume the diligence of the state’s prosecution of a
defendant absent persuasive evidence **+ the state
has engaged in a pattern of st in its

62a

Americas Inc., 842 F. Supp. 1140, 1147 (E.D. Ark.
1993). The Court’ should_ refrain from
“circumscrib[ing] the administrator’s discretion to
implement a plan that, in his expert judgment,
adequately addresses a violation.” Id. (quoting
North and South Rivers Watershed Ass’n v. Town
of Scituate. 755 F. Supp. 484, 486-87 (D. Mass.
1991); see also Arkansas Wildlife Federation v. ICI
Americas. Inc,, 29 F.3d 376, 380 (8 Cir. 1994)
(“courts must afford appropriate deference to the
expertise of the agency enforcing the _ state’s
environmental laws.”).

Here, Plaintiffs concern about the thermal
impact of the County’s discharge into the Piney Run
is being addressed comprehensively by MDE, the
State agency charged with the responsibility of
enforcing the Clean Water Act’s requirements. In
fact, the Court of Special Appeals has already
determined that deference is due to MDE in its
handling of this very Permit. The court expressly
relied on the “expertise of the agency” to affirm
MDE’s final decision wit! regard to the
temperature limit in the Permit. (Ex. 15, Jan. 17,
2006 Order, County Comm’rs of Carroll County v.
Rowland, No. 2338, Sept. Term 2004, at p. 13).

Deference to MDE is particularly appropriate
in light of the pendency of the County’s request for
an alternate effluent limit Maryland’s water
quality regulations specifically allow MDE to tailor
a temperature limit to a particular discharger’s
effluent so that the discharger is not faced with
unnecessarily onerous restrictions as long as it can
ensure that the health of the stream will not be

63a

impacted adversely. The County has worked with
MDE for a number of years to address the thermal
and other qualities of the stream, and both MDE
and the County have determined through extensive
studying of the stream that taking a _ holistic
approach - such as by addressing the riparian buffer
and stormwater contributions — has had a far
greater benefit to the aquatic life than any
mechanical process would have. If the Court allows
this case to proceed, the AEL process will stall and
the proven, successful approach currently being
taken will have to terminate in favor of installation
of environmentally-unfriendly and _ completely
unwarranted mechanical chillers. This Court should
defer to MDE’s expertise in this area and allow it to
continue its enforcement of the County’s current
permit and its evaluation of the AEL, as MDE is in
the most appropriate position to do both.

V. CONCLUSION

Because MDE has engaged in _ action
calculated to address any violations by the County
of the temperature limits in its Permit, Plaintiffs
action is barred and this Court lacks jurisdiction
over this case. Accordingly, the Complaint should
be. dismissed with prejudice. Alternatively,
judgment should be entered in favor of the County.

64a

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ _Linda S. Woolf

Linda S. Woolf (Federal Bar No. 08424)

K. Nichole Nesbitt (Federal Bar No.

Goodell, DeVries, Leech & Dann, LLP
One South Street, 20" Floor
Baltimore, Maryland 21202

(410) 783-4000

Attorney for Defendant County
Commissioners of Carroll County

26137)

65a

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 8th day of
January, 2007, a copy of Defendants’ Motion to
Dismiss, or in the Alternative, for Summary
Judgment, Memorandum of Law in support thereof,
proposed Order and Notice of Filing of Lengthy
Exhibits was sent electronically to:

G. Macy Nelson

Suite 803

401 Washington Avenue
Towson, Maryland 21204
Attorney for Plaintiff

/s/ K. Nichole Nesbitt

K. Nichole Nesbitt

66a

ENTERED NOVEMBER 14, 2006

IN THE UNITED STATES DISCTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF MARYLAND

The Piney Run Preservation
Association

3423 Black Rock Road

Upperco, Maryland 21155

Civil Action No.
Plaintiff AMDO6CV3019

Vv.

County Commissioners of
Carroll County
225 North Center Street
Westminster, Maryland 21157
Serve on:
Julia W. Gouge, President
225 North Center Street
Westminster, Maryland 21157

COMPLAINT FOR CIVIL FINES
AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF

The Piney Run Preservation Association, by
its attorney, G. Macy Nelson, files this Complaint
against the County Commissioners of Carrol] County
(the “Defendant”) and alleges:

:. This a citizen’s suit, brought under §
505 of the Clean Water Act (the “Act”), 33 U.S.C. §
1365, for the Defendant’s violation of the terms of

67a

the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination
System (“NPDES”) Permit No. MD0022446 / State
Discharge Permit 88-DP-0594 (“Permit”) (attached
hereto as Exhibit A).

Jurisdiction

2. This court has’ subject matter
jurisdiction over the claims set forth in this
Complaint, by virtue of § 505(a)(1) of the Act, 33
U.S.C. § 1365(a)(1), and 28 U.S.C.§ 1331.

3. On August 25,2006, Plaintiff gave
notice of the Defendant’s violations of the Act and its
intent to file suit via letter (“Notice Letter”) to
Franklin G. Schaeffer, Deputy Directory of Utilities,
Carroll County Department of Public Works; Joseph
Curran Esq., Maryland Attorney General; Kendl
Philbrick, Maryland Department of the Environment
(“MDE”); Julia George, County Commissioners of
Carroll County; Kimberly Millender, Esq., Office of
the County Attorney; Nancy Young, Esq., Assistant
Attorney General for MDE; Steven Johnson, United
States Environmental Protection Agency (“EPA”);
and Steven Field, Esq., EPA, as required by §
505(b)(1)(A), 33 U.S.C. § 1365(b)(1)(A) (see Notice
Letter attached hereto as Exhibit B).

4. Over sixty days have passed since the
Plaintiff gave notice to the Defendant, and neither
the EPA nor MDE has commenced to diligently
prosecute a court action to address the violations.

5. Venue is appropriate in the United
States District Court for the Northern District of

68a

Maryland pursuant to § 505(c)(1) of the Act, 33
U.S.C. § 1365(c)(1), because the source of the
violations complained of is located in this district.

Parties

6. Plaintiff, The Piney Run Preservation
Association, is a non-profit association whose
purposes include the protection of the Piney Run
stream in Baltimore County. Piney Run is a trout
stream with its headwaters near the border of
Carroll County and Baltimore County. MDE has
classified Piney Run as a trout stream and given it a
designation of Class IIIP. Piney Run leads to the
Loch Raven Reservoir and is also classified as a
stream to be protected as a source of drinking water.

7. Members of The Piney, Run
Preservation Association reside in Baltimore County
in the vicinity of the Piney Run stream. They
recreate on or near, and otherwise use and enjoy,
Piney Run and the water systems of which it is part.
The quality of Piney Run and the waters of the state
of Maryland directly affects the agricultural, health,
recreation, aesthetic, property, and/or environmental
interests of the members of The Piney Run
Preservation Association. The interests of The Piney
Run Preservation Association’s members have been,
are being, and will be adversely affected by the
failure of the Defendant to comply with its NPDES
Permit requirements.

8. The Defendant, Commissioners of
Carroll County, is a county in Maryland.

69a

General Allegations

9. Section 301(a) of the Act, 33 U.S.C. §
1311(a), prohibits the discharge of any pollutant
from a point source into a navigable waters of the
United States, except as allowed by an NPDES
permit.

10. A discharge is any “addition” of any
pollutant to navigable waters from any point source.”
33 U.S.C. § 13862(12)(A).

11. The term “pollutant” includes
substances such as municipal ‘waste, heat, biological
materials, sewage, and garbage. 33 U.S.C. § 1362(b).

12. Under § 404(a)-(b) of the Act, 33 U.S.C.
§ 1342(a)-(b), the Administrator of the EPA has
authorized MDE to issue NPDES permits in
Maryland.

13. MDE issued to Defendant NPDES
Permit No. MD0022446, which authorizes Defendant
to discharge from its wastewater treatment plant
(“Plant”) limited quantities of specified pollutants
into Piney Run.

14. Defendant's NPDES Permit prohibits
the discharge of effluent warmer than the higher of
68° F or the ambient temperature of the stream.

15. Defendant discharges effluent warmer
than the higher of 68° F or the ambient temperature
of the stream.

70a

16. The continued addition of effluent
warmer than the higher of 68° F or the ambient

temperature of the stream violates the Clean Water
Act.

17. The discharge of effluent in excess of
the Permit limits, which occurs during the warm
weather months, has occurred in the past, is
occurring now, and will continue to occur in the
future.

18. A separate violation occurs on each day
in which Carroll County discharges heated effluent
warmer than the higher of 68° F or the ambient
temperature of the stream

19. Defendant’s discharge of heat degrades
the water quality of Piney Run.

20. Defendant has violated the terms of the
Clean Water Act and of its Permit.

21. #=

any other IU that:

a. discharges an average of
25,000 gallons per day or
more of process
wastewater (excluding
sanitary, non-contact
cooling and boiler
blowdown wastewater); or

contributes a process
wastestream that makes
up 5% or more of the
average dry weather
hydraulic or organic
capacity of the POTW;; or

is designated as such by
the POTW on the basis
that the IU has a

reasonable potential for

adversely affecting the
POTW’s operation or for
violating any pretreatment
standard or requirement;
or

is found by the POTW, the
Department, or the
Environmental Protection
Agency . (EPA) to have
significant impact either
individually or in
combination with other
contributing industries to
the POTW, on the quality
of the sludge, the POTW’s
effluent quality, or air
emissions generated by the
system.

“TSS” (Total Suspended Solids) means
the residue retained on the filter by an
analysis done in accordance with
Standard Methods or other approved
methods.

“TKN” (Total Kjeldahl Nitrogen) means
organic nitrogen plus ammonia
nitrogen.

“Weekly average” means the highest
weekly average of the month, calculated
by dividing the total mass (and
concertration, if appropriate) for each

80a

week by the number of samples
collected and measured that week.

“NPDES” (National Pollutant
Discharge Elimination System) means
the national system for issuing permits
as designated by the Clean Water Act

“Ambient Temperature” means. the
temperature of the surface water
measured in Piney Run at the closest
practicable monitoring location in the
stream upstream from the concrete
culvert and apron, approximately 30
feet above the discharge point.

“Effluent Temperature” means the
temperature of the discharge measured
at outfall 001.

II. SPECIAL CONDITIONS,

A. Effluent Limitations, Outfall 001- see
footnotes (1)(2)

The quality of the effluent discharged by the facility
shall be limited at all times as shown below.

cP

cP
0€

sur

Of

0€
02

[sur

V/N

(O€)FT
(ST) 89

V/N

V/N
V/N

(P/SQ]) /P/2Y

V/N
V/N

(OPE) OST

(OVE) OST
(0&2) OOT

(P/SQ) /P/2¥

(OZ) OOT

(0€Z) OOT
(OST) 89

(P/SQI) /P/PY

d [FOL

(O€/F-1/0T)
(0€/6-1/S)N-““HN

SSL

(O8/F-T/OT)
(0€/6-1/S) *Gog

dseloAy
ATI30 M4

ddeIOAY
ATYIWOY

ayeYy SuIpEoy]
Alreq

sey SUIPCOT
ATH99\\

Hey Super]
ATU} MOT

SONSLIa}OeIEU.)
quanyyq

‘ MOT] STI} PIsdXe 0} peyadxe si MOT BtT} S1OJOq sABP ORT 1889] 38 quowyredeq
ay} 0} peprroid aq 04 WOBIpION ‘smOryelMo[eo uoryeI0]7e 948K OT pest sem (pds 000°006) psu 06'dJo “AOU V

‘AUNOUTE GBI} UST} eyj}O WeO} O[ {si Jo sprjos ZuyEoTy jo eSreyostp ou eq [TeYs S104, (Z)
‘paziqryord st ‘sueuryredad at} Aq pauruLieyap 8B “syuNoUTe 9TKO} UT [TBS WMOYS 300 gaomreysane I1x0} JO BdTVYOSIP
ay, ‘suorEyTUNTT BAoge et{} 0} Tenba aq jou Avw suolEyUN Med att} ‘pameuel St qruued sq} Ue (1)

(g¢ eded 908) Jayeai8 81 JeAeyTyA ‘18z8M adBpINs ty} JO emnjyerodwia} JueIquIe 6} IO
(9 80018ep 0Z) J gaaisep gg psedxe jou Awul TyeyyNo 3q} 38 ganyeseduia} UNUITXBUT ot], ginjye1edulay,
‘9 C8 Hd
‘guut} Aue 78 1/301 0'9 V/N washxQ pealossiq
‘payiqrgosd st 1878 M9}SE A JO juauneey ety} wI spumodusoo auLIo[yO
ZuTureyW09 SUTIOTYO 10 SULIOTYO JO est aU renpisey [OL

‘ante
ugaul Bo] ATIUOW] TUOOT/NdW 002 SULIOFIOD [BF

TITIMUTAB I] Sosa ese)
quenyya

II. SPECIAL CONDITIONS, Continued

v
©
.
S
©
S
ao
2
e)
o
foe
°
)
S
@
a
=)
oO
)
a
:
3
a
g
°
=
nm

footnotes (1)(2)(3)(4)

established in

Special Condition II.A. shall be monitored as

The effluent characteristics
follows:

pep1ovey

qeiy
qbig)
qeip
qBigy
qeih
ayIsodui0d IP,

azISOduoo ‘IUPZ
e}Isoduroo “14g
ayisodm0d “Pz
a}IsOdulo0d ‘Iq g
aztsodmod ‘Iq g
azIsOduio0d “Iq g
daky,

snonurjyuor)

AB XZ
AB] XZ
Yoo XT
qyaoW XT

YyUOY XT
Yoon XZ
YyUOW XT
oom XZ
Yom XZ

Yoo XZ

AWSNbeLy oauUEg

MOLY

(€)(N'] BouTayep as)
aingeisduray, yUeIqury

(Z) sinyeleduiay, yuenTy 7

Hd

wesAXGQ Paalossiq
WIIOFIIOD PRIAT

([) wadoqIN oruesIQ
(Wa302}1N)

(T) OFET}IN + 97BI}IN
usSOQIN BruOWUTY

+ snoioydsoyg oyyI9Q
snioydsou, [830],
spljog pepuedsng [ezo],
"do

SotjslidjowIey.) USNS
JUsUISINSeO]y

84a

(1) Monitor only-parameters shall be reported on the
monthly operating report as individual results and
on the Discharge Monitoring Report (EPA Form
3320-1) as a monthly average concentration and
monthly average loading value. All nitrogen
parameters shall be measured on the same daily
sample.

(2) Effluent temperature will be measured at least
every hour on a 24-hour basis. The effluent will be
measured at Outfall 00I with an instrument meeting
the appropriate standard in 40CFR Part 136 and
accurate to at least 0.1° C.

(3) Because of daily, seasonal and interannual
variation in temperatures, no single or seasonal or
default value can be used to characterize ambient
temperature. Therefore ambient temperatures will

be measured at the closest practicable monitoring
location in the stream upstream from the concrete
culvert and apron. approximately 30 feet above the
discharge point.

(4) Temperature Reporting and Determination of
Compliance

Ambient and outfall temperatures will be
measured and compared daily. For compliance
purposes, the comparison will be made using a
statistical test to determine if differences
between the effluent and ambient
temperature are significant. This method
allows compliance to be determined with a
specified level of certainty. The 95% certainty
level will be used with a “one-tailed” test. If

85a

the maximum effluent temperature
measurement for any day is greater than 200°
C, then the 24 effluent and ambient
temperatures for that day will be compared
using a +-test at the confidence level of alpha
= 0.05. If the calculated t value is greater than
t 0.05, and the average effluent temperature is
greater than the average ambient
temperature for the day, the effluent will be
non-compliant for that day.

The maximum effluent temperature for every
day, +-test results, and the average effluent
and ambient temperatures for the days
requiring t-tests will be submitted each month
with the Discharge Monitoring Reports.
Complete records of the ambient and effluent

temperature measurements will be available
to the Department upon request.

86a

SPECIAL CONDITIONS, Continued

C. SCHEDULE OF COMPLIANCE

The permittee shall achieve compliance with
the preceding discharge limitations on the
effective date of the permit.

D. PREREATMENT PROGRAM

The permittee shall be subject to the following
requirements in order to assure that POTW
pass-through and interference from industrial
discharges into the sanitary sewer do not

occur.

(1)

The Department shall
periodically review the

permittee’s Sewer Use Ordinance
to assure that it affords the
POTW adequate authority to
regulate its significant industrial
users, including, but not limited

to the authorities required under
40 CFR Part 403.8(f)(1).

The permittee shall modify its
Sewer Use Ordinance per the
results of the Department
Ordinance review, as required by
section D(1), above.

The pennitte shall draft permits
for R.W. Sauder, Inc.( formerly
Maryland Fresh Eggs) and Dalib

87a

Inc.(formerly Bauerlein Meats,
Inc.) and submit them to the
Department for review prior to
renewal or modification by the
permittee.

Prior to allowing a significant
industrial user to discharge to
the POTW regulated by his
permit, the permittee shall notify
Department in writing, = as
follows:

(a) For significant non-
categorical industrial
users, at the discretion of
the Department, the
permittee shall either

issue a permit or enter
into an agreement which
describes the
responsibilities of the
significant industrial user
to assure that the quality
of its discharge to the
POTW will not cause
interference or pass-
through or otherwise
violate State and Federal
pretreatment

requirements as defined in
COMAR 26.08.08 and CFR
Part 403. All permits and
agreements between the
permittee and significant

88a

industrial users shall be
subject to approval by the
Department prior to
issuance.

For industrial users
subject to Federal
categorical standards:

(i) The permittee shall
notify the
Department, in
writing, of the
intent of an
industrial user
potentially subject
to Federal
categorical
standards to
discharge process
wastewaters into

the POTW.

The Department,
after being notified
of the categorical
industrial user’s
intent to discharge
process wastewaters
to the POTW, shall
notify the industry
and/or the permittee
(in the case where
the Department
independently

determines that an
industrial user
plans to locate in
the sewer service
area of the POTW),
in writing, and shall
draft a permit based
on the applicable
Federal Categorical
Standards. Upon
review by the
permittee and the
categorical
industrial user the
permit shall i be
issued by the
Department.

The permittee shall perform
monitoring of all significant
industrial users at least once per
year to determine compliance
with pretreatment requirements
and standards.

The Department’ shall be
responsible for the issuance of a
discharge permit to, periodic
inspection and monitoring of and
taking enforcement action
against Ridge Engineering, Inc.
for any non-compliance with
pretreatment requirements and
standards in the Department’s
issued permit.

(7)

(8)

(9)

90a

The permittee shall enforce all
requirements of permits issued to
its industrial users including, but

not limited to, discharge
limitations, sampling
requirements, and_ reporting
requirements.

Annually, on or before’ the
fifteenth day of February, the
permittee shall submit to the
Department a list of all
significant industrial users
within the entire service area
which discharge to the POTW
regulated by this permit.
Informatica on this list shall
include the legal name of the
industry, street address, flow,
type of wastewater being
discharged into the_ sanitary
sewer, contact and_ telephone
number. The report shall also
include a listing of the dates and
results of any SIU inspections,
SIU monitoring activities, and
enforcement actions against
SIU’s. The report shall cover the
period from January 1 through
December 31 of the previous
year.

The permittee shall send the
Department a copy of all notices
of violation and other

9la

enforcement actions taken
against its significant industrial
users.

EK. BIOMONITORING PROGRAM

5.

Within three months of the
effective date of the permit, the
pennittee shall submit to the
Department for approval a study
plan to evaluate wastewater
toxicity at Outfall 001 by using
biomonitoring. The study plan
should include a discussion of:

a. wastewater and
production variability

sampling methods

source of test organisms
source of dilution water
testing procedures
data analysis

g. quality control

h. testing schedule

The testing program shall consist

of two acute testing events, three
months apart. This testing shall

92a

be initiated no later than three
months following the
Department’s acceptance of the
study plan.

a. Each of the two testing
events shall include a 48-
hour static renewal test
using fathead minnow and
a 48-hour static renewal
test using a daphnid
species.

If the receiving water is
estuarine the permittee
shall substitute estuarine
species for those species
specified above. Approved
estuarine species for acute
testing are sheepshead
minnows, silversides,
grass shrimp and mysid
shrimp. In all cases,
testing must include one
vertebrate species and one
invertebrate species.

The samples used for
biomonitoring shall be collected
at the same time and location as
the samples used for the
chemical analysis required for
this outfall. For chlorinated
effluents, samples’ shall be
collected after dechlorination.

93a

Testing shall be conducted in
accordance with the procedures
described in Methods for
Measuring the Acute Toxicity of
Effluents and Receiving Waters
to Freshwater and Marine
Organisms, Fifth Edition, EPA--
821 — R — 02 - 012, October 2002

Test results shall be submitted to
the Department within one
month of completion of each set
of tests.

Test results shall be reported in
accordance with the
Department’s “Reporting

Requirements for Effluent
Biomonitoring Data” (3/21/03).

If testing is not performed in
accordance with the Department-
approved study plan, additional
testing may be required by the
Department.

If the test results indicate that
the effluent is toxic, additional
biomonitoring or a_ toxicity
reduction evaluation will be
required by the Department.

If plant processes or operations
change so that there is a
significant change in the nature

94a

of the wastewater, the
Department may require the
permittee to conduct a new set of
tests.

If a significant industrial user
locates within the service area so
that significant change in the
nature of the wastewater might
be anticipated, the Department
may require the permittee to
conduct a new set of tests.

Submit all Biomonitoring related
materials to:

Maryland Department of the Environment
Water Management Administration

Compliance Program
Montgomery Park Business Center
1800 Washington Boulevard, STE 425
Baltimore, Maryland 21230-1708

TOXIC CHEMICAL TESTING

1. Concurrent with the
biomonitoring study plan, the
permittee shall submit to the
Department for approval, a study
plan to perform analytical testing
for toxic chemicals.

The toxic chemical testing study
plan shall include a description
of:

95a

sampling methods;
analytical methods;

practical detection levels;
and

d. quality control procedures.

Concurrently with the first
toxicity test, the permittee shall
perform analytical testing for the
toxic chemicals identified in the
Department’s “Toxic Substance
Analytical Protocol” (7/92).

Toxic chemical testing shall be

performed in accordance with 40
CFR Part 136 and the
Department-approved toxic
chemical testing plan.

Substances other than _ those
identified in Section 3 above may
be detected in the effluent. If so,
the permittee shall identify and
quantify the ten present in
highest concentration.

Testing results shall be
submitted to the Department
with the results of the first
toxicity test.

96a

Toxic chemical testing results
shall be reported in accordance
with the Department’s
“Reporting Requirements for
Priority Pollutant Analytical
Data”.

If testing is not performed in
accordance with the
Department’s approved study
plan, additional testing may be
required by the Department.

Submit all toxic chemical testing
related materials to:

Maryland Department of the Environment
Water Management Administration

Compliance Program
Pretreatment Data
Montgomery Park Business Center
1800 Washington Boulevard, STE 425
Baltimore, Maryland 21230-1708

G. TOXICITY REDUCTION
EVALUATION (TRE)

The permittee shall conduct a Toxicity
Reduction Evaluation (TRE) when a
review of toxicity test data by the
Department indicates unacceptable
acute or chronic effluent toxicity. A
TRE is an investigation conducted to
identify the causative agents of effluent
toxicity, isolate the source(s), determine

97a

the effectiveness of control options,
implement the necessary’ control
measures and then confirm’ the
reduction in toxicity.

A.

Within 90 days of notification by
the Department that a TRE is
required, the permittee shall
submit a plan of study and
schedule for conducting a TRE.
The permittee shall conduct the
TRE study consistent with the
submitted plan and schedule.

This plan should follow the
framework presented in Toxicity
Reduction Evaluation Protocol
for Municipal Wastewater
Treatment Plants (EPA/833B-
99/002) August 1999.

Beginning 60 days from the date
of the Department’s acceptance of
the TRE study plan and every 60
days thereafter, the permittee
shall submit progress reports
including all relevant test data to
the Department. This shall
continue until completion of the
toxicity reduction confirmation.

Within 60 days of completion of
the toxicity identification, or the
source identification phase of the
TRE, the permittee shall submit

98a

to the Department a plan and
schedule for implementing those
measures necessary to eliminate
acute toxicity and/or reduce
chronic toxicity to acceptable
levels. The implementation of
these measures’ shall begin
immediately upon submission of
this plan.

Within 60 days of completing the
implementation of the control
measures to eliminate or reduce
toxicity, the permittee shall
submit to the Department, for
approval, a study plan to confirm
the elimination or reduction of
toxicity using biomonitoring.

If, for any reason, the
implemented measures do not
result in compliance with the
Department’s toxicity
limitations, the permittee shall
continue the TRE.

Submit all TRE-related materials
to:

99a

Maryland Department of the Environment
Technical and Regulatory Services Administration
Environmental Health & Risk Assessment Program
Montgomery Park Business Center
1800 Washington Boulevard, STE 540
Baltimore, MD. 21230-1718

Ill. GENERAL CONDITIONS

A. Monitoring and Reporting

Be

Representative Sampling

Samples and measurements shall
be taken at times that arc
representative of the quantity
and quality of the discharge, and
at evenly spaced intervals.

Monthly Monitoring Results

a. Discharge Monitoring
Reports

Monitoring results obtained each
month shall be summarized on a
Discharge Monitoring Report
form (EPA No. 3320-1). Reports
shall be submitted to the
Department postmarked no later
than the 28th of the month
following the reporting month.
Duplicate signed copies of these
reports shall be submitted to:

100a

Maryland Department of the Environment
Water Management Administration
Compliance Program
Montgomery Park Business Center
1800 Washington Boulevard, STE 425
Baltimore, MD. 21230-1708

b. Monthly Operating
Reports

The permittee shall submit
monthly operating reports
on a form supplied or
approved by the Inspection
and Compliance Program.
Reports shall be submitted
to the Inspection and
Compliance Program
postmarked no later than
the 28th day of the month
following the reporting
month

Sampling and Analysis Methods

Analytical and sampling methods
shall conform to test procedures
for the analysis of pollutants as
identified in 40 CFR Part 136 -
“Guidelines Establishing Test
Procedures for the Analysis of
Pollutants.”

Monitoring Equipment
Maintenance

The permittee shall
calibrate and maintain all
monitoring and analytical
instrumentation to ensure
accuracy of measurements.

Environment Article,
Section 9-343 provides
that any person who
falsifies, tampers with, or
knowingly renders
inaccurate, any monitoring
device or method required
to be maintained under
this permit shall, upon
conviction, be punished by
a fine of not more than

$10,000 per violation, or by
imprisonment for not more
than six months per
violation, or by both.

Recording of Results

For each measurement or sample
taken pursuant to the
requirements of the permit, the
permittee shall record’ the
following information:

a. the date, exact place and
time of sampling’ or
measurement;

102a

b. the person(s) who
performed the sampling or
measurement.

c. the dates analyses were
performed;

d. the person(s) who

performed each analysis;

e. the analytical techniques
or methods used; and

f the results of such
analyses.

Additional Monitoring by

Permittee

If the permittee monitors any
pollutant at the location(s)

designated herein more
frequently than required by this
permit, using approved

analytical methods as specified
above, the results of such
monitoring shall be included in
the calculation and reporting of
the values required in_ the
Discharge Monitoring’ Report
form (EPA No. 3320-1). The
increased frequency shall also be
reported. The results of any other
monitoring performed by _ the
permittee shall be made

103a

available to the Department
upon request.

Record Retention

All data used to complete the
permit application and 6 all
records and information resulting
from the monitoring activities
required by this permit,
including all records of sampling
and analyses performed,
calibration and maintenance of
instrumentation and recordings
from continuous monitoring
instruments, shall be retained for
a minimum of three years. This
period shall be extended
automatically during the course
of litigation or when requested by
the Department.

B. General Requirements

1.

Permit Noncompliance
Notification Requirements

All discharges authorized herein
shall be consistent with the
terms and conditions of his
permit. The discharge of any
pollutant not identified in this
permit, or of any pollutant
identified in this permit at a level
in excess of that authorized shall

104a

constitute a violation of this
permit. If, for any reason, the
permittee does not comply with
or will be unable to comply with
any permit condition, the
permittee shall, within 24 hours,
notify the Department by
telephone at (410) 537-3510
during work hours or at (866)
633-4686 during evenings,
weekends, and holidays. The
permittee shall provide’ the
Department with the following
information in writing within five
days of such oral notification.

a. a description of the
noncomplying discharge
including its impact upon
the receiving waters;

b. cause of noncompliance;

c. the duration of the period
of noncompliance and the
anticipated time the
condition of noncompliance
is expected to continue;

d. steps taken by the
permittee to reduce and
eliminate the
noncomplying discharge;

105a

e. steps to be taken by the
permittee to prevent
recurrence of the condition
of noncompliance;

f. a description of the
accelerated or additional
monitoring to determine
the nature and impact of
the noncomplying
discharge; and

g. the results of the
monitoring described in f.
above.

Change in Discharge

The permittee shall report any
anticipated facility expansions,
production increases, or process
modifications which will result in
new, different or an increased
discharge of pollutants’ by
submitting a new application at
least 180 days prior to the
commencement of the changed
discharge or, if such changes will
not violate the effluent
limitations specified in _ this
permit, by providing prior
written notice to the Department.
Following such notice, the permit
may be modified by the
Department to specify and limit

106a

any pollutants not previously
limited.

Facility Operation and Quality
Control

All waste collection, control,
treatment and disposal facilities
shall be operated in a manner
consistent with the following:

a. Facilities shall be operated
efficiently to minimize
upsets and discharges of
excessive pollutants.

The permittee shall
provide an adequate
operating staff qualified to
carry out operation,
maintenance and testing
functions required to
ensure compliance with
this permit.
Superintendents and
operators must be certified
by the Board - of
Waterworks and Waste
Systems Operators located
at 1800 Washington
Boulevard, Baltimore,
Maryland 21230 in
accordance with Title 12 of
Environmental Article,

107a

Annotated Code of
Maryland.

Facility maintenance work
which adversely affects or
may adversely affect the
discharge quality shall be
scheduled during non-
critical water quality
periods. The permittee
shall follow the reporting
procedures listed in
General Condition 111.B.7
of this permit,
Noncompliance
Notification.

Adverse Impact

The permittee shall take all
reasonable steps to minimize any
adverse impact to waters of this
State, human health or the
environment resulting from
noncompliance with any effluent
limitations specified in this
permit, and mmust_ perform
accelerated or additional
monitoring aS necessary’ to
determine the nature and impact
of the noncomplying discharge.

108a

Bypassing

Any bypass of treatment facilities
is prohibited unless the bypass
does not cause any violations of
the effluent limitations specified
in Special Condition 11.A. and is
for essential maintenance _ to
assure efficient operation, or
unless the permittee can prove
that:

a. the bypass is unavoidable
to prevent loss of life,
personal injury, or
substantial physical
damage to property,
damage to the treatment
facilities which would
cause them to become
inoperable, or substantial
and permanent loss of
natural resources; and

there are no _ feasible
alternatives to the bypass;
and

the Department receives
notification pursuant to
General Condition 11.B.1.
above. Where the need for
a bypass is known (or
should have been known)
in advance, this

109a

notification shall be
submitted to the
Department for approval
at least ten days before the
date of the bypass or at the
earliest possible date if the
period of advance
knowledge is less than ten
days; and

the bypass is_ allowed
under conditions
determined by the
Department to be
necessary to minimize
adverse effects.

Sewage Sludge Requirements

The permittee shall comply with
all existing State and federal
laws and regulations that apply
to sewage sludge monitoring
requirements and_ utilization
practices, and with any
regulations promulgated
pursuant to Environment Article,
Section 9-230 et seq. or to the
Clean Water Act, Section 405 (d).
The permittee is responsible for
ensuring that its sewage sludge
is utilized in accordance with a
valid sewage sludge utilization
permit issued by the
Department.

Power Failure

The permittee shall maintain
compliance with the _ effluent
limitations and all other terms
and conditions of this permit in
the event of a reduction, loss or
failure of the primary source of
power to the wastewater
collection and treatment
facilities.

Right of Entry

The permittee shall allow the
Secretary of the Department, the
Regional Administrator of the
Environmental Protection
Agency, and their authorized
representatives, upon the
presentation of credentials to
enter upon the _ permittee’s
premises and:

a. to have access to and to
copy any records required
to be kept under the terms
and conditions of this
permit;

to inspect any monitoring
equipment or monitoring
method required in this
permit;

10.

lila

e. to inspect any collection,
treatment, pollution
management, or discharge
facilities required under
this permit; or

d. to sample any discharge of
pollutants.
Propert» Rights/Compliance

With Other Requirements

The issuance of this permit does
not convey any property rights in
either real or personal property,
or any exclusive privileges, nor
does it authorize any injury to
private property, invasion of
personal rights, or any
infringement of federal, State or
local laws or regulations.

Reports and Information

a. Upon request, the
permittee shall provide to
the Department, within a
reasonable time, copies of
records required to be kept
by this permit. The
permittee shall also
furnish to the Department,
within a reasonable time,
any information which the

112a

Department may request
to determine whether
cause exists for modifying,
revoking and reissuing, or
terminating this permit; or
to determine compliance
with this permit.

All applications, reports or
information submitted to
the Department shall be
signed and certified as
required by COMAR
26.08.04.01 and 40 CFR
122.22.

Except for data
determined to be
confidential under
COMAR 26.08.04.01,all
data shall be available for
public inspection at the
Department and the Office
of the Regional
Administrator of the
Environmental Protection
Agency. Effluent §§ data
shall not be considered
confidential.

Environment Article,
Section 9-343 provides
that any person who
knowingly makes any false
statement, representation,

113a

or certification in any
record or other document
submitted or required to
be maintained under this
permit, including
monitoring reports’ or
reports of compliance or
noncompliance, shall upon
conviction be punished by
a fine of not more than
$10,000 or by
imprisonment for not more
than six months or by
both.

Transfer of Ownership or Control

In the event of any change in

ownership or control of facilities
from which the _ authorized
discharge emanates, the permit
may be transferred automatically
to another person only if:

a. the current permittee
notifies the Department, in
writing, of the proposed
transfer at least 30 days
prior to the proposed
transfer date;

the notice includes a
written agreement
between the existing and
new permittees containing

lida

the specific date of
proposed transfer of
permit coverage, and of
responsibilities and
liabilities under the
permit; and

neither the current
permittee nor the new
permittee receive
notification from the
Department, within 30
days of the Department’s
receipt of the agreement,
of its intent to modify,
revoke, reissue or
terminate the _ existing
permit. If this notice is not
received, the transfer is
effective on the date
specified in the agreement
mentioned in paragraph
4(b) above.

New Effluent Standards

This permit shall be revoked and
reissued or modified to meet any
effluent standard, water quality
standard or prohibition
established under the
Environment Article, the Clean
Water Act, or _ regulations
promulgated thereto, and the
permittees shall be so notified.

Industrial Users

The permittee shall require all
industrial users of the
wastewater treatment facility to
comply with user charges as
established by the permittee,
pursuant to Section 9-326(a)(i) of
the Environment Article.

Noncompliance

Nothing in this permit shall be
construed to _ preclude’ the
institution of any legal action for
noncompliance with State,
federal or local laws and

regulations.

Oil and Hazardous Substance
Liability

Nothing in this permit shall be
construed to preclude’ the
institution of any legal action
against the permittee or to
relieve the permittee from any
responsibilities, liabilities, or
penalties to which the permittee
is or may be subject under
Section 311 of the Clean Water
Act or under the Environment
Article.

16.

YB

18.

116a

Waterway Construction and
Obstruction

The permit does not authorize
the construction or placing of
physical structures, facilities,
debris, or the undertaking of
related activities in any waters of
this State including the 100 year
flood plain.

Construction Permit

This permit is not a permit to
construct. For a new facility, in
order to make this permit valid, a
construction permit shall be
obtained to meet the
requirements of COMAR
26.03.12.03(A) and Environment
Article, Section 9-204(d).

Severability

If any provision of this permit
shall be held invalid for any
reason, the remaining provisions
shall remain in full force and
effect, and such invalid
provisions shall be considered
severed and deleted from this
permit.

117a

C. Permit Expiration, Modification, or
Revocation
Z Expiration of Permit

This permit and the
authorization to discharge shall
expire at midnight on _ the
expiration date of the permit
unless permittee has submitted a
timely and complete
reapplication pursuant to Section
111.C.2 below.

Reapplication for a Permit

At least 180 days before the
expiration date of this permit,
unless permission for a later date
has been’ granted by the
Department, the permittee shall
submit anew application for a
permit or notify the Department
of the intent to cease discharging
by the expiration date. In the
event that a timely and complete
reapplication has been submitted
and the Department is unable,
through no fault of the permittee,
to issue a new permit before the
expiration date of this permit,
the terms and conditions of this
permit continue and remain fully
effective and enforceable.

118a

Oo

Permit Modification - Request of
Permittee

A permit may be modified by the
Department upon the written
request of the permittee and
after notice and opportunity for a
public hearing in accordance with
the provisions set forth in
COMAR 26.08.04.10.

4. Permit Modification, Suspension,
Revocation - Violation of Laws

A permit may also be modified,
suspended or revoked by the
Department, in the event of a
violation of the terms. or
conditions of the permit, or of
State or federal laws and
regulations and in accordance

with the provisions set forth in
COMAR.

Wastewater Collection System

Discharges from the sewer collection
system are not authorized. Should a
discharge occur, the permittee shall
report it in accordance with the
Notification Requirements set forth in
Section III, General Condition B.1.
However, the written reports on the
overflows shall be submitted monthly
with the Discharge Monitoring Reports

119a

(DMRs), unless the Department
specifically requests the report to be
submitted within 5 days after the
permittee becomes aware of _ the
overflow. A copy of any 5 day report
should also be submitted with the
monthly DMRs.

IV. CIVIL AND CRIMINAL PENALTIES

a Civil Penalties for Violations of
Permit Conditions

In addition to civil penalties for
violations of State water
pollution control laws set forth in
Section 9-342 of the Environment
Article, Annotated Code _of
Maryland, the Clean Water Act
provides that any person who
violates Section 301, 302, 306,
307, 308, 318 or 405 of the Act, or
any permit condition or
limitation implementing any of
such sections in a permit issued
under Section 402 of the Act or in
a permit issued under Section
404 of the Act, is subject to a civil
penalty not to exceed $25,000 per
day for each violation.

z, Criminal Penalties for Violations
of Permit Conditions

120a

In addition to criminal penalties
for violations of State water
pollution control laws set forth in
Section 9-343 of the Environment
Article, Annotated Code _ of
Maryland, the Clean Water Act
provides that:

a. any person who
negligently violates
Section 301, 302, 306, 307,
308, 318, or 405 of the Act,
or any permit condition or
limitation iumplementing
any of such sections in a
permit issued under
Section 402 of the Act, or
in a permit issued under
Section 404 of the Act, is
subject to a fme of not less
than $2,500 nor more than
$25,000 per day i of
violation, or by
imprisonment for not more
than one year, or by both.

any person who knowingly
violates Section 301, 302,
306, 307, 308, 318 or 405
of the Act, or any permit
condition or limitation
implementing any of such
sections in a permit issued
under Section 402 of the
Act, or in a permit issued

under Section 404 of the
Act, is subject to a fine of
not less than $5,000 nor
more than $50,000 per day
of _ violation, or by
imprisonment for not more
than three years, or by
both.

any person who knowingly
violates Section 301, 302,
306, 307, 318 or 405 of the
Act, or any permit
condition or _ limitation
implementing any of such
sections in a permit issued
under Section 402 of the
Act, or in a permit issued
under Section 404 of the
Act, and who knows at
that time that he thereby
places another person in
imminent danger of death
or serious bodily injury, is
subject to a fine of not
more than $250,000 or
imprisonment of not more
than fifteen years, or both.

any person who knowingly
makes any false matz#rial
statement, representation,
or certification in any
application, re

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386020_1147%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
