# Defendants Brief — Lochner v. New York

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386019_0667%3A4

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Defendants Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1905
- **Citation:** 198 U.S. 45

## Text

"UNITED STATES.

-

No. 292.

JOSEPH LOCHNER, Pracwrrey mr Exzom,
fs 7 Re

THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, —
Derenpants my Error. As

Brief for Defendants in Error.

JULIUS M MAYER,
Attorney-General of the State of New York,
Attorney for the Defendants in Error.
The Capitol, Albany, N. Y.

ALBANY, N. Y.:
BRANDOW PRINTING COMPANY,
.« | Legisiative Printers.
1905

IN THE

SUPREME COURT

UNITED STATES.

UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT.
,

JOSEPH LOCHNER,
Puarmvrivs 1x Exzor,
08.

_ THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF
NEW YORK, Der'rs 1s Error

‘No. 292.

4

BRIEF OF THE ATTORNEY GENARAL OF THE
STATE OF NEW YORK ON BEHALF OF THE
DEFENDANTS IN ERROR, THE PEOPLE OF
THE STATE OF NEW YORK.

In error to the County Court of
Oneida County, State of New York.

This is a writ of error allowed on the 18th day of
May, 1904, directed to the County Court of Oneida
county, State of New York, to review the determination
of that court and of the Court of Appeals of the State
of New York, affirming the determination of the County
Court of Oneida comity, in the State of New York, con-

se
eg Lah

ending April 26, 1901, at his bisenit, bread and cake
__ bakery and confectionery establishment situated at No.

82-84 South street, in the city of Utica, Oneida county, —
New York. “(Rovord, pages 2 and 3.)

“The plaintiff in error demurred to the indictment
upon the grounds—

Pir. kittie thick cap tla io tinal te Oe
indictment, within the meaning of section 278 of the
| Code ‘of Criminal Procedure of the State of New York.

_ Becond, That more than ene crime is changed in the

nel 6 peck ak oe seen eons ares

stated, —

An appeal was taken to the Appellate Division of the
Supreme Ceara the Beste of on Kak, and ie Joly:
ment of conviction was affirmed. _

‘An sppeel was talun dacs this detereinstion te the
Court of Appeals of the State of New York, whiek is
the hightest court of law or equity of the State of New
York, and on the 4th day of April, 1904, the judgment
of conviction was affirmed and judgment to that effect
entered.

POINTS.
s&
This Court is without jurisdiction
to re-examine the judgment below.

The conflict, if any existed, between the laws of the
State of New York and the Constitution of the United
States, was not set forth in the demurrer to the indict-
ment, and no other or different pleading was interposed
by the plaintiff in error. There was no evidence taken,
or trial had, other than his refusal to plead and his con-
viction. He did not ask for any instructions, nor did
he exeépt to ary rulings of the court, and the question
of the conflict of the laws of the State of New York and

padi tan a Geavaiaos diaantcdhs Peo hora,
“ but only from averments so distinct and positive as to
“ place it beyond question that the party bringing a case
“here from such court intended to assert a Federal
“ right.”
Oxley Stove Co. v. Butler County,
166 U. 8. 648.
Levy v. Superior Court of San Fran-
cisco, 167 U. 8. 178.

It is true that the judges of the Court of Appeals in
their opinions discussed the question as to whether the
law under consideration offerided against the first section
of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Con-
stitution, or against sections one and six of article one
of the United States Constitution ; but there was nothing
in the demurrer interposed by the plaintiff in error in
the County Court of Oneida county which indicated that
the plaintiff in error (there the def»ndant) intended to
raise this Federal constitutional question.

) Baiate <Mae to,
Milt hy Rg? Cee t pt, SE

pri ie aes
Lae

eon

ere
2. Definitions. :

2 sens i eeaaldinke a day's ols

4. Violations of the labor law.

6 Hoar of labor oo sient sures and lvated, eth

14. Stone used in State or municipal works.
15, Labels, brands, ete., used by labor organizations.
16. Penalty for illegal use of labels, ete.; injunction pro-

20. Protection of persons employed on buildings in cities.
21. Factory inspector to enforce provisions of article.

in this chapter, means @ mechanic, workingman or lar
borer who works for another for hire.

The person, employing any such mechanic, working-
man. or laborer, whether the owner, proprietor, agent,
superintendent, foreman or other subordinate, i inig
nated in this chapter as an employer.

The term, factory, when, used ix. this, chapter, shall be
construe to inelude also any mill, workshop, or other
manuf«cturing or business establishment, where one. or
more pereons are employed at labor.

See

oa ee ae
‘be construed to include any building on the same lot
‘with any dwelling house and which is used for any of
the purposes specified in section one hundred of this act.

Sec. 5. Hours of labor on street surface and elevated
railroads.—Ten consecutive hours’ labor, including one-
half hour for dinner, shell constitets day's labor in
Ged Sptebiien of all thaich wasdace und sloveted ralirceds,
of whatever motive power, owned or operated by cor-
porations in this State, whose main line of travel, or
whose routes lie principally within the corporate limits
of cities of more than one hundred thousand inhabitants.
No employe of any such corporation shall be permitted
or allowed to work more than ten consecutive hours,
including one-half hour for dinner, in any one day of
twenty-four hours. In cases of accident or unavoidable
delay, extra labor may be performed for extra compen-
sation.

Sec. 6. Hours of labor in brickyards.—Ten hours,
exclusive of the necessary time for meals, shall consti-
tute a legal day’s work in the making of brick in brick-
yards owned or operated by corporations. No corpora-
tion owning or operating such brickyards shall require
employes to work more than ten hours in any one day,
or to commence work before seven o’clock in the morn-
ing. But overwork and work prior to seven o’clock in

TS apeaebiaes cae nian SERS

See 7. Regulation of hours of labor on steam surface
and elevated railroads.—Ten hours’ labor, performed
within twelve consecutive hours, shall constitute a legal
day’s labor in the operation of steam surface and ele-
vated railroads owned and operated within this State,
except where the mileage system of running trains is
in operation. But this section does not apply to the
performance of extra hours of labor by conductors, engi-
neers, firemen and trainmen in case of accident or de-
lay resulting therefrom. For each hour of labor per-
formed in any one day in excess of such ten hours, by
any such employe, he shall be paid in addition at least
‘one-tenth of his daily compensation. No person or cor-
poration operating a line of railroad of thirty miles in
length or over, in whole or in part within this State,
shall permit or require a conductor, engineer, fireman
or trainman, who has worked in any capacity for twenty-
four consecutive hours, to go again on duty or perform
any kind of work, until he has had at least eight hours’
rest.

Sec. 17. Seats for female employes.—Every person
employing females in a factory or as waitresses in a
hotel or restaurant shall provide and maintain suitable
seats for the use of such female employes, and permit
the use thereof by such employes to such an extent as
may be reasonable for the preservation of their health.
(As amended by L. 1900, ch. 533.)

Sec. 77. Hours of labor of minors and women.—No
minor under the age of sixteen years shall be employed,
permitted or suffered to work in any factory in this
State before six o’clock in the morning, or after nine
o’clock in the evening of any day, or for more than nine
hours in any one day. No minor under the age of eigh-
teen years, and no female shall be employed, permitted

_ when such work shall begin and end, shall be kept posted
in a conspicuous place in each room where they are
employed. But such persons may begin their work after-
the time for beginning and stop before the time for end-
ing such work, mentioned in such notice, but they shall
not otherwise be employed, permitted or suffered to
work in such factory except as stated therein. The
terms of such notice shall not be changed after the be-
ginning of labor on the first day of the week without
the consent of the commissioner of labor. The pres-
ence of such persons at work in the factory at any other
hours than those stated in the printed notice shall con-
stitute prima facie evidence of a violation of this section
of the law. (As amended by L. 1889, ch. 192 and IL.
1908, ch. 184.)

Sec. 78, Change of hours of laber of miners and wo-

wen.—When in ‘order to make a shorter work day on ~

the last day of the week, a minor over sixteen and under
eighteen years of age, or a female sixteen years of age
or upwards, is to be required or permitted to work ina
factory more ‘than ten hours in'a day, the employer of
such person shal] notify the commissioner of lsbor in
writing, of such intention, stating ‘the number of hours
of labor per day, which it is proposed ‘to require or per-
mit, and the time when it is proposed to cease such ‘re-

i Shey toronto

1908, eh. 184.)

required or permitted to work in a room in a factory
between the hours of six o’clock in the morning and six

provided such room is lighted by electricity at all times
‘during such hours, while persons are employed therein.

Sec. 92. Laundries.—A shop, room or building where
‘one or more persons are employed in doing public laun-
dry work by way of trade or for purposes of gain is a
factory within the meaning of this chapter, and shall be
subject to the visitation and inspection of the factory
inspector, and the provisions of this chapter in the same
manner as any other factory. No such public laundry
work shall be done in a room used for a sleeping or liy-
ing room. All such laundries shall be kept in a clean
‘condition and free from vermin and all impurities of
‘an infections or contagious nature. This section shall
not apply to any female engaged in doing custom laun-
‘dry work at her home for s regular family trade.
(Added by L. 1901, ch. 477.) .. :

Sec. 93. Employment of women and children at pol-
ashing or buffing.—No male child under the age of eigh-

‘teen years, nor any female, shal] be employed in any
‘factory in this State in operating or using any emery,

- tripoli, rouge, corundum, stone, carborundum or any
abrasive, or emery polishing or buffing wheel, where
articles of the baser metals or of iridium are manu-
factured. The owner, agent or lessee of a factory who
employs any such person in the performance of such
work is guilty of a misdemeanor and upon conviction
thereof shal] be fined the sum of fifty dollars for each
such violation. The cornmissioner of labor, his assist-
ants and deputies, shall enforce the provisions of this
section. (Added by L. 1899, ch. 875; renumbered by
L. 1901, ch. 478; amended and renumbered by L. 1903,
ch, 561.)

ARTICLE VII.
Tenement-Made Articles.

Section 100, Manufacturing, altering, repairing or finishing
articles in tenements.

Sec. 100. Manufacturing, altering, repairing or fin-
ishing articles in tenements, — No tenement house nor
any part thereof shall be used for the purpose of manu-
facturing, altering, repairing or finishing therein, any
coats, veste, knee-pants, trousers, overalls, cloaks, hats,
caps, suspenders, jerseys, blouses, dresses, waists, waist-
bands, underwear, neckwear, furs, fur trimmings, fur
garments, skirts, shirts, aprons, purses, pocketbooks, slip-
pers, paper boxes, paper bags, feathers, artificial flowers,
cigarettes, cigars or umbrellas, without a license therefor
as provided in this article. But nothing herein con-
tained shall apply to collars, cuffs, shirts or shirtwaists
made of cotton or linen fabrics that are subjected to the
laundrying process before being offered for sale. Appli-
cation for such a license shall be made to the commis-
sioner of labor by the owner of such tenement house, or

by his duly authorized agent. Such application shall de-
scribe the house by street number or otherwise, as the case-
may be, in such manner as will enable the commissioner
of ‘labor easily to find the same; it shall also state the
number of apartments in such house ; it shall contain the
full name and address of the owner of the said house,
and shall be in such form as the commissioner of labor
may determine. Blank applications shall be prepared
and furnished by the commissioner of labor. Upon re-
ceipt of such application the commissioner of labor shall.
consult the records of the local health department or
board, or other appropriate local authority charged with
the duty of sanitary inspection of such houses; if such
records show the presence of any infectious, contagious
or communicable disease, or the existence of any un-
complied with orders or violations which indicate the
presence of unsanitary conditions in such house, the
commissioner of labor, may, without making an inspec-
tion of the building, deny such application for a license,
and may continue to deny such application until such
time as the records of said department, board or other
local authority show the said tenement house is free
, from the presence of infectious, contagious or com-
municable disease, and from all unsanitary conditions.
Before, however, any such license is granted, an inspec-
tion of the building sought to be licensed must be made
by the commissioner of labor, and a statement must be
filed by him as a matter of public record, to the effect
that the records of the local health department or board
or other appropriate authority charged with the duty
of sanitary inspection of such! houses, show the existence
of no infectious, contag’ous or communicable disease
nor of any unsanitary conditions in the said house ;
such statement, must be dated and signed in ink with
the full name of the employe responsible therefor. A
similar statement similarly signed, showing the results

fects of plumbing that will permit the free entrance
-of sewer air, that such building is in a clean and proper
-sanitary condition and that the articles specified in this
-section may be manufactured therein under clean and
healthfnl conditions, he shall grant a license permitting
‘the use of such building, for the purpose of manufac-
turing, altering, repairing or finishing such articles.
Such license shall be framed, such frame to be furnished
by the commissioner of labor upon receipt by him of ure
dollar for which a receipt in writing shall be given,
and shall be posted by the owner in a conspicuous place
in the public hallway on the entrance floor of the build-
ing to which it relates. It may be revoked by the com-
missioner of labor if the health of the community or of
the employes requires it, or if the owner of the said
tenement house, or his duly authorized agent fails to
comply with the orders of the commissioner of labor |
within ten days after the receipt of such orders, or if
it appears that the building to which such license relates
is not in a healthy and proper sanitary condition. In
‘every case where a license is revoked or denied by the
commissioner of labor the reasons therefor shall be
stated in writing, and the records of such revocation or
denial shall be deemed public records. Where a license
is revoked, before such tenement house can again be
used for the purposes specified in this section, a new
license must be obtained, as if no license had previously
existed. Every tenement house and all the parts thereof
in which any of the articles named in this section are
manufactured, altered, repaired or finished shall be
kept in a clean and sanitary condition and shall be sub-

31

ject to inspection and examination by the commissioner-
of labor, for the purpose of ascertaining whether said
garments or articles or part or parts thereof, are clean
and free from vermin and every matter of an infectious
or contagious nature. An inspection shall be made by
the commitsioner of labor of each licensed tenement.
house not less than once in every six months, to deter-
of such house and the plumbing thereof. Before mak-
ing such inspection the commissioner of labor may con-
sult the records of the local department or board charged
with the duty of sanitary inspection of tenement houses,
to determine the frequency of orders issued by such
department or board in relation to the said tenement
house, since the last inspection of such building was
made by ihe commissioner of labor. Whenever the com-
missioner of labor finds any unsanitary condition in a
tenement house for which a license has been issued as
provided in this section, he shall at once issue an order
to the owner thereof, directing him to remedy such con-
dition forthwith. Whenever the commissioner of labor
finds any of the articles specified in this section manu-
factured, altered, repaired or finished, or in pro-
cess thereof, in a room or apartment of a tenement
house, and such room or apartment is in a filthy con-
dition, he shall notify the tenants thereof to immedi-
ately clean the same, and to maintain it in a cleanly eon-
dition at all times; where the commissioner of labor
finds such room or apartment to be habitually kept in
a filthy condition, he may in his discretion cause to be
affixed to the entrance door of such apartment a placard
calling attention to such facts and prohibiting the man-
ufacturing, alteration, repair or finishing of said articles
therein. No person, except the commissioner of labor,
shall remove or deface any such placard so affixed.
None of the articies specified in this section shall be

FLEEES
Hi
| +6
ial
if
ait
FEZES

terminated, and that the said room or apartment has
properly disinfected, if disinfection after such dis-
‘is required by the local ordinances, or by the rules
tions of such department or board, None of,

articles specified in this section shall be manufac-
tured, altered, repaired, or finished in a part of a cellar
or basement of a tenement house, which is more than
one-half of its height below the level of the curb or
ground ontside of or adjoining the same, No person
shall hire, employ or contract with any person to
manufacture,, alter,, repair, or, finish, any of the
articles named in this section in any room or apart-
ment in any tenement house not having a license there
for issued as aforesaid, None of the articles specified
in this section shall be manufactured, altered, repaired,
or finished in any room or apartment of a tenement
house by any person other than the members of the fam-
ily living therein, which shall inelude a husband and
wife and their children, or the children of either,
Nothing in this section contained shall prevent the em-
ployment of a tailor or seamstress by any person or
family for the purpose of making, altering, repairing,
or finishing any article of wearing apparel for the use
of such person or family, (As amended by ch, 101, 1,
of 1899, and ch, 550, L. of 1004.)

ail

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386019_0667%3A4. Public record. Not legal advice.
