# Transcript of Record — United States Repair & Guarantee Co. v. Assyrian Asphalt Co.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386018_0761%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1902
- **Citation:** 183 U.S. 591

## Text

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1900.

No. 277.

UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY COMPANY,
PETITIONER,

re

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COUR
OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT

Cricaco:

Tne Guetrnore-Warren Peintixne Co.,
58 Dearborn Street.
1800.

Original. Print.

Plea- weyers

Bill of complaint

Subpwem@....---- ee Rees Fe

Return to writ of subperna.....

Answer to bill of complaint

Notice of exception to answer...... -.«+--

Exception to QDOWEF.. ..-.. 666 -- eens ne rene ete

Order of Sept. 11, 1897, to expunge 7th paragraph of
answer: that answer may stand as amended, and that
replication be filed instanter.... ..

Order of Sept. 11, 1897, as to taking of proofs. ......
Stipulation. ...-.-.65++ «6 i Gnbt eaves
Complainant's Evidence—

Stipulation...

Deposition of Melville KE. Dayton (expert)
Deposition of Henry R. Kasson. ,

Agreement of Sept. 4, 1897, between Barber As-

phalt Paving Company and City of St. Joseph,

Deposition of William Y. Warren...

Deposition of J. H. Cranford... ..

Deposition of William H. Lober.

Deposition of Henry N. Moss.....0---.--

Complainant's Exhibit Defendant's Device
Defendant's Evidence—

Exhibits offered in evidence.....-...

Deposition of Lewis M. SESE e TT CCT TT.

Defendant’s Exhibit Defendant's Valves (drawing }

Complainant's Exhibit Smith Drawing...
Defendant's Exhibits— ff,

Crochet French patent No. 137,208... ..
Official description of machines and processes, ete.
Annales des Ponts et Chausses, 1561
Bridge and Highway Annals........--- ++ +--+:
Memoires et Compte-Renudu des Travaux de In

Societe des Ingenieurs Civils...
Kepert on asphalt and bitamen, ete...

1

3
i4
15
16
iv
#u

21
21

22

95
482
29
440

Ss

a3
114
117
123
Iau
i4]

144
140
155
17H

178
Isl
183
vine

233
247

2

3
io
1]
i}
i4
16

Plate 1— Asphalt roads and roasting furnace.. 263 199

Pilate Il—Asphalt roaster yr ' 265 = 9oy

Plate I1[— Portable boiler, ete. . 267 903

Page from ++ Engineering,’ Mare 18, 1870 269 965
Minutes of Proceedings of the lostitution of Civil

Engineers, Vol. XLII... 271 207

Annales des Ponts et Chausses, 1S79 3) By

Bridge and Highway Annals.. BUR 989
Minutes of Proceedings of the institution of Civil

Engineers, Vol. LX 314 248
L) Asphalte, Sou Origine, Sa Preparation Les Ap.

plications. .. .. oS B24 953
Leon Malo—*+ ‘ Asphalt, Its Origin, Its Preparation

and Its Application’ . 335 965

Writ of Certiorari. S4h QT]

Stipalation...... . ; S42 979

Return to writ of sortior: ari 442 79

Complainant's Rebuttal Evidence

Notice 343 273

Deposition of Charles Edward Foster (expert) S46 ©6974

Stipulation.. 426 129

pepadtion 2 of Philip W. Henry 27 397

6 ‘ Henry J. Warren -. St

‘y olnes W. Foster j44 4il

$56 O38

458 338

‘ William H. Lobe 441 340

** Henry R. Kasson S7 63

440 347

‘ Charles H. Burwinkle $52 349

és ‘+ Eugene G. Schwendeman 454 351

“ * Volney W. Foster 544 411

3S 338

456 353

Stipulation 461 355

Notary’s Certificate 462 356

Stipulation as to affidavits Soe 464 357

AGidevit of A. L. Barber ia 455- 358

: * Stevenson Towle 470 = - 361

* Clifford Richardson .. 473 ° 363

Edward P. North ve 478-367

Deposition of Melville E. Dayton (expert) 29 23

co

iii
Deposition of Volney W. Foster..............- 438 338
456 353
5444
eee ey ee gery Ceti Ps ta 419
‘ \@idavit of R. C. Ruthven... . 0. 05. sess. SOL 4
Complainant’s Rebuttal Exhibits—
( io rea onan Foster eagery ere so
ts No. 3........ 569 499
Order of May 1, 1899, setting cause hie hearing...... 570 430
Heuring ..... Re teehee ete 430

Order of June 24, 1899, setting hearing on motion for

rehearing .... wiiéa 571 451
Hearing on motion for rehearing . . 572 431
Order of July 19, 189%, overruling motion for rehearing 572 «431
Decree ane 572 432
Petitiou for ‘appeal .. 574 454
Assignment of errors 574 435
Order allowing appeal 575-435
Bond on appeal. . 576 456
Stipulation as to printed record . 577 437
Precipe for transeript . 578 438
Clerk's certificate . 578 438
Citation PS ee 579 43%
Patent exbibits — :

No. §. 701, Feb. 3. 1852, J. A. Y- a % . 551 442
145,822, Dec. 23, 1873, C. . Waterbury. 5S4 446
Re-issue No. 5,697, Dee. 23, Po MC. Bogin -, 58s 450
157,559, Dec. 8, 1874, C. G. Waterbury... 592 454
++ 169,439, Nov. 2, 1875, J. P. Hayes........ 598 460
* 184,628, Nov. 21, 1876, 1. Kendrick ..... 603 464
* 269,368, Dec. 19, 1882, A. F. Zimmerling . . 608 470
383.346, May 23. 21865, Jd. B.-Can.. ....-.: 6 476
501,536, July 1S, 1893, A. H. Perkins... ss.
Northern Division. (

The United States of America To Assyrian Asphalt Company
and James P. Mallette, Greeting:

We command you and every of you that you appear before our
judges of our Circuit Court of the United States of America for
the Northern District of Illinois, at Chicago in the Northern Di-
vision of said District, on the first Monday in the month of July
next, to answer the bill of complaint of United States Repair and
Guaranty Company this day filed in the clerk’s office of said court
in said city of Chicago, then and there to receive and abide by

such judgment and decree as shall then or thereafter be made,
upon pain of judgment being pronounced against you by default.
To the Marshal of the Northern District of Illinois to execute.
Witness the Hon. Melville W. Fuller, Chief Justice of the
United States of America, at Chicago aforesaid, this 12th day of
June in the vear of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and
ninety-seven

S. W. BURNHAM,
(Seal.) Clerk.

MEMORANDUM.

The above named defendants are notified that unless they
and each of them shall enter their appearance in the clerk’s office
of said court at Chicago aforesaid, on or before the day to which
the above writ if returnable the complainant's bill will be taken
against them as confessed and a decree entered accordingly.

S. W. BURNHAM.,
Clerk.

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 11

MARSHAL’S RETURN.

I have served the within writ within my district in the follow-
ing manner to-wit:

Upon the Assyrian Asphalt Company therein named on the
12th day of June A. D. 1897, by leaving a true copy of the same
with James P. Mallette, President of the said company. Upon
James P. Mallette therein named on the 12th day of June A. D.
1897 by delivering a true copy of the same to him, personally.

J. W. ARNOLD,
U. S. Marshal.
By H. R. CLARK,

Deputy.

S. W. BURNHAM,
Clerk.

(Endorsed) Filed June 14, 1897.

Afterwards to-wit: on the fourteenth day of August, 1897,
came the defendants in said entitled cause by their solicitors and
filed in the clerk's office of said court their Answer, which said

answer is in the words and figures following to-wit:

16 UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT.
Northern District of Illinois
Northern Division.

U.S. Repair & Guaranty Company

= In Chancery
Assyrian Asphalt Company, and James -y,, 24,534.
P. Mallette. nt

ANSWER.

Filed Aug. 14th, 1897.

Joint Answer of the Assyrian Asphalt Company (a corporation),
and James P. Mallette, Defendants, to the Bill of Complaint of
U.S. Repair & Guaranty Company, Complainant.

These Defendants, now and at all times hereafter reserving
unto themselves all and all manner of benefit or advantage by ex-

wv UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. VB.

ception or otherwise, which can or may be had or taken to the
manifold errors, uncertainties, insufficiencies and imperfections jn
said Bill of Complaint contained, for Answer to said Bill, or to sq
much and such parts thereof as these Defendants ace advised, it
is necessary for them to make unto, answer and say:

I. Defendants are not advised, save as stated by the Bill of
Complaint, that the Complainant is a corporation duly oryanized
ang existing as alleged in said Bill; they therefore deny the alle
gation in that regard and leave the same to be proven as Com.
plainant may be advised. Defendants further answering admit
that said Assyrian Asphalt Company is a corporation duly organ.
ized and existing under the laws of the State of Illinois and hay-
ing its principal place of business at Chicago in the northern judi-
cial District of said State, and that said James P. Mallette, named
as co-defendant is the President of said Assyrian Asphalt Com-
pany.

II. Upon information and belief Defendants admit that the
letters patent sued on herein, viz: (A) No. 501,537, Method of
Repairing Asphalt Pavements, July 18, 1893: (B) No. 542,349,
Apparatus for Repairing Asphalt Pavements, July 9, 1895; (C)
560,599, Apparatus for Repairing Asphalt Pavements, May 19,
1896, were issued in due form on applications filed in that behalf
by one Amos H. Perkins of Chicago, Illinois, alleging himself to be
the first and original inventor of the subject-matter set forth and
claimed respectively therein.

These defendants deny that said Perkins was in fact such
inventor, but on the contrary allege that in view of the then
known state of the art no invention was requisite to produce
said several supposed improvements at the time each of them
respectively was by said Perkins first devised

III. Upon information and belief respondents deny that said
Perkins was the true, original and first inventor of the subject-
matter in said pretended Letters Patent set forth; they deny that
the alleged improvements disclosed therein constituted a new and
useful invention within the meaning of the Patent Law at the
time said improvements were first devised by said Perkins; they
deny that said improvements or substantially the same were not
known or used in this country or had not been patented or de-
scribed in anv printed publication in this or in any foreign coun-
trv before the clleged invention thereof by said Perkins.

IV. Further answering, respondents sav that, except as al-
leved by the Bill of Complaint, they have no knowledge of the
several assignments, mesne or final, by which the interest in said
alleged invention and Letters Patent were conveyed unto com-
plainant; respondents do not admit that the exclusive right of

‘7

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY, 13

making, using and vending to others to be used the improve-
ments set forth by said Letters Patent No. 501,537 is vested in
the complainant; and accordingly respondents leave the com-
plainant to prove the several allegations of the bill concerning
the exclusive right and title in said complainant under the Let-
ters l'atent aforesaid as it may be advised.

V. .Upon information and belief, respondents do not admit
that the improvements and inventions patented as aforesaid have
been in the exclusive possession and enjoyment of the complain-
ant nor that the same are of great value and profit to sald com-
plainant; respondents do not admit that the alleged improve-
ments have been extensively introduced in public use, nor that
the same have been received with great favor by the public, or
that the public generally has acquiesced in the alleeed exclusive
right of comnlainant under said Letters Patent, and respondents
call for strict proof thereof.

VI. Defendants admit that said Assyrian Asphalt Company,
under «lirection of said Mallette as president,isengaged from time
to time in the business of repairing asphalt pavements, and in
such business has occasion to follow well-known methods in mak-
ing said repairs and to employ certain tools and appliance in and
about the same. But defendants deny that said Mallette save as
president of the defendant herein is engaged in such business and
further deny upon information and belief, that the practices fol-
lowed and the appliances used in repairing asphalt pavements or
any of them do in any wise infringe upon exclusive rights law-

fully secured by Letters Patent unto said complainant.
18 “VII. Upon information and belief, defndants allege

that the pretended inventions respectively defined bv the
several Letters Patent and the claims thereof here in suit were——
long prior to the supposed discovery or devising thereof by said
Perkins—known to various other persons and were disclosed or
described in various antecedent natents and printed publication
at present unknown to these defendants, but which they are dili-
gently seeking to identify and when discovered, crave leave by
apt amendment at the foot of this answer or otherwise as the
Court may direct, to set forth and specify in detail for further
defense in the action, as by statute allowed.

VIII. Respondents deny that said complainant has any right
to an account for damages, profits, gains, charges or costs, to be
recovered fram these respondents; they deny said: complainant’s
right to any injunction, provisional or perpetual, and deny that
said complainant is entitled to any other or further relief whatever
against these respondents

a4 UNITED STATES RPPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. V8.

All of which matters and things these defendants are ready to
aver and maintain and prove as this Honorable Court may direct:
without this that any other matter, cause or thing in complain-
ant’s said bill of complaint contained, material or necessary for
these respondents to make answer unto, and not herein and here.
by well and sufficiently answered, confessed, traversed, avoided
or denied, is true to the knowledge and belief of these respond.
ents; wherefore these respondents humbly pray to be hence dis-
missed with their reasonable costs and charges in this behalf most
wrongfully sustained.

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY,
JAMES P. MALLETTE,
By PEIRCE & FISHER,
Solicitors for Defendants,
LEROY D. THOMAN,
Of Counsel ;

*Note. Paragraph VII expunged by order of court September

rith, 1897.

(Endorsed) Filed Aug. 14, 1897
S. W. BURNHAM,
Clerk.

19 Afterwards to-wit: on the ninth dav of September, 1897,

came the complainant by its solicitor and filed in the clerk's
office of said court a certain Notice and Exception to answer,
which said Notice and Exception are in words and figures follow-
ing to-wit:

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY.

NOTICE AND EXCEPTION TO ANSWER.
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
For the Northern District of Illinois.
Northern Division.

United States Repair and Guaranty Com-
pany, In Equity.

vs. General No. 24,534
Assyrian Asphalt Company et al.

To Mr. Leroy LD. Thoman, Solicitor for the defendants, Marquette
Bldg., Chicago:

We hand you herewith a copy of our exception to paragraph

VII of your answer in the above entitled cause together with a

copy of an order of court which we shall ask to be entered pursu-

ant thereto, and beg to notify you that the same will come on

for hearing before his honor, William J. Allen holding said Cir-

_ cuit Court, at his chambers Saturday morning next, September

ith, 1897, at g o'clock A. M. The judge, at our suggestion, has

made this appointment, our suggestion being that we desire the
pleadings to be promptly settled.

Very respectfully,
RAYMOND & OMOHUNDRO.,

Solicitors for Complainant.
J. H. RAYMOND,

Of Counsel.
Service accepted this 8th day of September, 1897.
LEROY D. THOMAN,
Solicitor for defendant.

14 UNITED STATFs RBPAtR AND GUARANTY CoO. vs,

20 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES.

For the Northern District of Illinois.

Northern Division.

United States Repair & Guaranty Com.
pany, In Equity.
vs. General No. 24534
Assyrian Asphalt Company et al.

EXCEPTION TO ANSWER.

For Insufficiency and Impertinence.

Exception taken by the above named complainant to the joint
answer of the defendants for insufficiency and impertinence.

For that, whereas, in the first, second, third, fourth and fifth
paragraphs of the complainant's bill of complaint, it is alleged
in the usual form and words uniformly employed, in such bills of
complaint, and not necessary here to be set out in extenso, that
the said Amos H. Perkins “was the true, original and first inven-
tor of certain new and useful ‘Improvements in Method of Re-
pairing Asphalt Pavements’ and in ‘Improvements in Apparatus
for Repairing Asphalt Pavements’ the said defendants have not
in and bv their answer filed August 14th, 1897, according to the
best of their knowledge. remembrance. information and belief,
answered the said allegations in said bill of complaint contained
hut do, in and by paragraph VII of their said answer reply to the
said allegations of said bill as follows to-wit:

“VIT. Upon information and belief defendants allege that the
pretended inventions respectively defined by the several letters
patent and the claims thereof herein suit were—long prior to the
supposed discovery or devising thereof by said Perkins—known
to various other persons and were disclosed or described in vari-
ous antecedent patents and printed publications, at present un-
known to these defendants, but which they are diligently seeking
to identify and when discovered, crave leave by apt amendment
at the foot of this answer or otherwise as the court may direct,
to set forth and specify in detail for further defense in the action
as by statute allowed.”

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 7

In which particular the said complainant is advised that the
said answer of the defendants is evasive, impertinent and insuf-
ficient and that the said paragraph should be stricken from
21 the said answer; and the complainant prays that the said

answer may be, by order of court, amended accordingly.

JAMES H. RAYMOND,
Solicitor and of Counsel for the Complainant.
Chicago, September 8th, 1897.

(Endorsed) Filed Sept. oth, 1897.
S. W. BURNHAM,
Clerk.

Afterwards to-wit on the eleventh day of September, in the
July term of said court, 1897, in the records of proceedings there-
of in said entitled cause before the Hon. William J. Allen, District
judge, appear the following entries to-wit:

ORDER OF SEPTEMBER 11, 1897.

United States Repair and Guaranty Com-
pany,
vs.
Assyrian Asphalt Company et al.

24534-

Upon the coming on to be heard of the complainant's excep-
tion for insufficiency and impertinence to the seventh paragraph
of the defendant’s answer, and both parties having been heard.
It is ordered:

First: That the said seventh paragraph of the said answer
shall be, and the same is hereby expunged.

Second: That the said answer may stand as thus amended
and

Third: That the complainant may file instanter a replication
to said answer.

18 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY co. vs.

ORDER OF SEPTEMBER 11, 1897.

United States Repair and Guaranty Com-

pany,
om, 24534.

Assyrian Asphalt Company et al.

The parties being before the court upon the excentions of the
complainant to the VII Paragraph of defendants’ answer, which
Exceptions were sustained, upon the suggestion of the com.
22 plainant, both parties having been heard. It is Ordered that
the complainant herein shall have to and including the 1st
day of October, 1897, for adducing its proofs in chief, that the
defendant shall have from the 2nd day of October until the 13th
day of November, 1897, inclusive, in which to take their proofs
in support of their joint answer: and that the complainant shail
have from the 15th day of November until the 11th day of De-
cember, 1897, inclusive, in which to take its evidence in re-
buttal.
(General Replication filed September 11, 1897.)

Afterwards to-wit on the fourteenth dav of September, 1897,
there was filed in the clerk's office of said court a certain Stipula-
tion, which said Stipulation is in the words and figures follow-
ing, to-wit:

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY.

STIPULATION.

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

For the Northern District of Hlinois.

Northern Division.

United States Repair & Guaranty Com-
pany,
VS.
Assyrian Asphalt Company et al.

In Chancery
General No

It is hereby stipulated and agreed by and between the parties
hereto as follows:

That each of the parties may adduce evidence herein upon rea-
sonable notice in writing before any notary public or other offi-
cer, authorized to administer oaths and all evidence so taken shall
be used and considered the same as if taken in all respects in full
compliance with the 67th Rule in Equity.

That each of the parties shall have the right to retain until the
hearing all their respective exhibits introduced herein, subject to
full and free examination by opposing counsel at all reasonable
times

That each party shall furnish to the other, without charge, full
copies of all testimony taken herein as the same shall be adduced
and copies of all drawings and similar documentary exhibits.

That the record herein on behalf of each party shall be printed

as provided by the rules of this court, and the cost of pre
23 paring such printed record, with exhibits, shall be taxable

herein as costs in this case; provided, however, that such
printed records shall in all respects comply with the rules of the
Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit: that not less
than fiftv comtes of each record shall be printed and that each
party shall in their respective printed records embody copies of
all their respective paper exhibits in the cause

That Patent Office printed copies of the specifications and
drawings of all United States Letters Patent and Blue Books of
British Letters Patent may be used in evidence without certifica-
tion, but subject to correction for errors, if any.

That copies of assignments of United States Letters Patent.
duly certified to by the Patent Office. mav be introduced in evi-
dence with the same force and effect as if the originals thereof

_— mee

20 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY Co. Vs.

were introduced and execution thereof duly proven, but subject
to correction for errors, if any.
RAYMOND & OMOHUNDRO,
Solicitors for Complai
PEIRCE & FISHER, _———
Solicitors for Defendants.
Chicago, September 13th, 1897.

(Endorsed) Filed Sept. 14th, 1897
S. W. BURNHAM.

Clerk.

25 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF
ILLINOIS, NORTHERN DIVISION

United States Repair & Guaranty Com-
| yany :
a Gen. No. 24,534.

Assyrian Asphalt Company et al
COMPLAINANT'S PROOFS.

Testimony taken and evidence adduced on behalf of complain-
ant, pursuant to the attached notice, before E. B. Sherman, Esq.,
one of the Masters in Chancery of said Court, beginning at 10
o'clock a. m., on Wednesday, September 15, 1897.

Present: Mr. O. R. Barnett, of Raymond & Omohundro, so-
licitors for complainant; Mr. James H. Pierce, of Pierce & Fisher,
solicitors for defendants

Thereupon it was stipulated by and between the solicitors for
the respective parties hereto as follows:

STIPULATION.

It is agreed between counsel for the respective parties, that the
Complainant company is a corperation duly organized and exist-
img under the laws of the State of Illinois in keening with the

final certificate duly issued and dated October 20, A. D. 1893.
26 Also, that Complainant company is the owner of Perkins
Letters Patent No. 501,537, for method of repairing asphalt

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 91

yements, dated July 18, 1893, and issued unto the Western
Paving and Supply Company, as grantee, by virtue of an assign-
ment in writing from said Western Paving and Supply Co. unto
said complainant, dated Jan. 1st, 1894, and then delivered and
dyly recorded as required by law, prior to the commencement of
this suit. The assignment last referred to conveys unto said
complainant “all claims and demands of whatever kind for royal-
ties, damages and profits accrued or to accrue for each and every
use of said improvement and inventions, or any or all of them.”

Further proof respecting the above particulars is hereby
waived

Thereupon complainant's solicitor offers in evidence Patent
Office printed copies of United States Letters Patent No. so1,-
537. issued July 18, 1893, to the Western Pavine and Supply
Company as assignee of Amos H. Perkins; No. 542.349, issued
july 9, 1895, to United States Repair & Guaranty Company, as
assignee of Amos H. Perkins; No. 560,599, issued May 19, 1896,
to United States fiepair & Guaranty Company as assignee of
Amos H. Perkins,“and the same are thereupon marked respec-
tively Complainant's Exhibit “Perkins Method Patent,” “Com-
plainant’s Exhibit Perkins Apparatus Patent No. 1,” “Complain-

ant's Exhibit Perkins Apparatus Patent No. 2.”
27 Thereupon complainant's solicitor presented a certain
stipulation duly signed by the solicitors for the respective
parties hereto and duly entitled in this cause, which stipulation
is in the words and figures following:

It is hereby stipulated and agreed by and between the parties
hereto, and by their respective solicitors, that the following facts
are admitted to be true and shall be, and shall be considered as,
evidence in this cause as fully as if duly proven in any usual
manner

FIRST. That subsequent to the dates of the patents herein
sued upon, and prior to the commencement of this suit, the De-
fendant, Assyrian Asphalt Company, has caused to be made for
it and has used apparatus for repairing asphalt pavement: and
that the drawing hereto attached, entitled in this case and marked
“Complainant's Exhibit, Defendant’s Device,” is a correct draw-
ing of so much and such parts of such apparatus as it purports
to show. .

SECOND. That the defendant, Assyrian Asphalt Company.
subsequent to the date of Letters Patent No. 501,537. herein sued
upon, and prior to the commencement of this suit, has used said
apparatus and caused said apparatus to be used in the repairing

99 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY Co. ys.

of asphalt pavements in the City of Chicago, Illinois. j; the fo}.
lowing manner:

(1.)_ The tank of said apparatus being supplied with any suit.
able oil, an initial pressure is created in said tank by the use of
the air pump thereto attached. which pressure causes the ojl jp
said tank to be discharged through the burners under the hood

or shield of said apparatus, and. upon said oil being ignited
28 in said burners, a blast of flame is projected horizontally yp-
der said hood or shield. and in such manner as to heat 3
portion of the supply pipe leading from said tank to said burners

2.) Said apparatus is placed over the portion of the nave
ment to be repaired and said burners. having been so ignited. the
portion of the pavement under the hood of said apparatus js
exposed to the heat from the blast of flame from said burners
until said portion of such pavement is sufficiently softened to the
depth of one-half inch, or more

(3.) Said apparatus being then removed from the portion of
the pavement to be repaired, that part of the asphalt of the
pavement which has been so softened is thereupon scraped ont
with rakes, hoes or suitable tools to the depth of a half inch or
more.

(4.) After such softened material is A. Previous to the use of this method of skimming it was
necessary to-cut out with axes any defects which were to be
repaired in an asphalt pavement from the surface to the concrete
base, taking out all the defective wearing surface and replacing
with new material. This was a tedious and expensive process,
and the use of the skimming process has remeved the necessity
for chopping out the pavement. as in the skimming process only
enough of the surface is removed to get a fresh surface upon
which to place the new material.

82

UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY co. ¥8.

O. 134. Please state whether or not by what you have referred
to in your last answer as the “skimming process” any desired
amount of bad or dead material can be removed?

A. Certainly, any amount of defective material can be re.
moved in this way.

Cross-Examination by Mr. Peirce.

X. Q. 135. How long is it since you were first practi
familiar with the mode of laying fresh or new asphalt pavements?

A. Since 1888.

X. O. 136. In laying such pavements when the job was left
incomplete at night, and the men began their work anew on the
day following what precaution, if any, was observed in effectj
a secure joint at the junction between the pavement already laid

and the material just about to be applied next thereto?
117

A. To prevent back pressure from the coil to the tank.

Q. 35. In practice do you know whether or not such check
valve does prevent the back pressure, as you have stated?

A. It does,

Cross-Examination by Mr. Omohundro

XQ. 36. How do you secure your initial pressure in the tank
D?

A. By an air pump.

XQ. 37. Is the discharge nozzle or opening in the burners ¥
equal to the capacity or cross area of the feed pipe J?

A. No, sir.

XQ. 38. It is a fact, is it not, that under the influence of the
heat from the burners to which the coil under the hood is sub.
jected the fuel is converted into a gas at considerable pressure in
the coil?

A. Yes, sir.

XQ. 39. Have you any idea as to what pressure would nor.
mally exist there during the operation of the machine?

A. Twenty-five pounds to the square inch, or nearly so

XQ. 40. What pressure do you initially produce in the tank

by the air pump?
158
5

|
;
| & impregnating schists:
;
'
'
/

I ting li [ Aaphalt
|S im og limestone (as
pal: ; Asphalt :

: ; eS Gee

\s can be seen by the above table the manifestations of bitu-
men are numerous; under all of its forms it has received in com-
merce, industries or constructions some considerable applications
and each day gives rise to new ones. The product that we detach
from this rich nomenclature to make the object of this stucy is,
after coal, that whereof the services are the most incontestable,
and although one scarcely knows from what-it comes thac is it
which extends far over our sidewalks or covers our tevelled . oad-
ways (terraces); there is even no accord about the name which one
shall give it.

It is then just and necessary to fix the individuality of this

213 body by an invariable expression which leaves it no longer to
the hazards of locality nor to the caprices of language, and we
propose to call definitely Asphalt not oxygenated bitumen, as the
chemist do, but lime rock impregnated with bitumen; this desig-
nation 1s almost wholly sanctianed by usage, it is in vigor at all
the mines of bituminous limestone, finally, its etymology (Aspha-
leto, | fortify) indicates sufficiently that the ancients had never

154 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. V8.

intended to apply it to the free bitumen which, solid or liquid, ig
incapable of filling the role of cement.

In the geologic ages, as often as a mass of organic material
imprisoned by powerful obstacles was subjected at once to a
strong pressure and to a high temperature, a bitumen was formed.

Thus when heaps of vast vegetations chanced to be buried
beneath strata of transition and to be exposed to the considerable
heat which was bound to irradiate for a long while the poorly
chilled crust of the globe their composition became modified, their
oxygen had almost entirely disappeared and a very stable bitumi-
nous material rich in carbon and in hydrogen—coal—remained,

It can be seen by comparison of the two analyses following
what transformation operated in the course of such a species of
distillation:

Cellulose - Oi
Carbon .. Tre ere Cea ee 89.31
Hydrogen .... Spey eae 4.92
CORSON oo ics “ear Pare .-. 49.38 5.77

100.00* 100,00**
If instead of vegetation it were upon animal remains that such
action was exercised, it had given birth to a more volatile
214 bitumen which at times was condensed at the very place of
its formation, at times escaped into the atmosphere to im-
pregnate it; herein the marl! beds as in the basin of the Allier, there
in the soft grits or conglomerates (puddingstone) as at Bastenne
and at Pyrimont, again in the limestones of the Jurassic form:
tion to produce the asphalt of Sevssel and of Val-de-Traverse
\gain we are permitted to put side by side the two analyses
below to explain the molecular modification which the animal
matter experienced on passing into the bituminous state:
Muscular Boechelbronn

Tissue Bitumen
Carbon: 33. 6... pices ee 7.00
Hydrogen ; 6.96 11.20
Oxygen 13.48 1.80
Nitrogen in Secs ek

100.00*** 100.00***

*and **Regnault
*** Boussingault.

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 156

Finally, when—by a phenomenon of which some examples are
till to be met with in various countries—the bitumen itself is
xposed to volcanic actions, subterranean and permanent, at at
taku in Persia, there is given off in this second distillation an oil
nore or less volatile which—when it is pure and colorless—is
amed naphtha and which—if it be tainted with oxidized bitumen
is called petroleum.

It has been affirmed that bitumen may be an igneous material
re-existent from the solidification of the terrestrial crust and
ondensed at the same time with the fusible rocks. We believe
hat no person to-day recognizes such system, organic traces are

evident in the bituminous deposits and moreover, nothing
115, is easier than to reproduce in the laboratory the operation to
which is due the creation of bitumen,

‘yhus we admit that at indeterminate epochs considerable
nasses of vegetable or animal remains buried beneath sedmentary
eds and heated either directly by the central heat or by the in-
asion of volcanic currents have given birth in an immense distilla-
jon to all of the bitumens. It is certain that such gigantic action
vas exercised in a very various manner; that according to place.
emperature, pressure, nature of adjacent rocks, epoch of opera-
ion, species of primary materials, the product obtained has been
riven differences of form, of aspect, composition and properties.
But the mode of formation has been the same throughout and
he resultant bodies include an identical principle, the bituminous
principle, which does not resemble that of any other body what-
ver and about which it is not permitted to be mistaken.

We leave aside the particular bitumen called “coal” and those
which, have a special role in industry to occupy ourselves with
none other than asphalt and some of the bitumens which intervene
in its preparation or in its applications. We thus quit generali-
Hes to enter upon our subject.

CONCERNING ASPHALT,

Principal deposits of asphalt. Free bitumen is abundantly dis-
tributed over the surface of the globe, it is encountered in almost
all voleanic regions and often impregnates the loam grits (Molas-
ses) superposed upon the Jurassic formation. Thus it is found in

great quantity and under the most diverse aspects in the
216 environs of Clermont-Ferrand, at times in perfectly free state

as in the Fountain of Pitch, at‘times mixed with fine ee
t

at Chamaliere and Gerzat, at times disseminated through t

156 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. VSB.

cavities of a spongy marl as at Point-du-Chateau~ The -mest-ordi-—
nary form of free bitumen is that of a mixture with the quartz
sands or green “molasses” of the neo-eocene (niocomienne) ag jt
is obtained at Pyrimont-Seyssel (Ain) and at Bastennes (Laudes
—the latter deposit to-day worked out. Free bitumen appears
again in Judea in the asphaltic lake at the Caspian Sea floating
upon the surface; at the Antilles (Island of Trinidad) imbrued with
an earthly base and solid at ordinary temperature.

Bitumen in a state of intimate combination or mixture is more
rare; under cover of a species of schist it is encountered stil! easily
enough in the coal basin of Autun (Saone-et-Loire), in that of
Buxieres (Allier) in P: ovince, in Dauphine, in the Nord and else.
where; but in company with limestone there is to be counted in
Europe scarcely three or four mines advantageously exploitable.

Bituminous schist is the primary material of an industry, recent
and already considerable; from it is extracted by double distilla-
tion an oil, light and colorless, which supplies (defrays) the impor-
tant commerce of mineral illuminating oils. We have no need to
occupy ourselves therewith in this note

Regarding bituminous limestone or “asphalt” properly so
called, the most rare of the manifestations of bitumen, this is a
rock formed of 90-94 per cent pure carbonate of lime arid of 106
per cent bitumen. Its aspect is that of plaster stone, its color
that of dark chocolate. When cut, the incised surface presents

that whiteish appearance which the knife also leaves upon
217 chocolate; the grain is fine, and when the structure is atten-

tively examined it is seen that each molecule of lime is sur-
rounded by an almost atomic coat of bitumen: every grain is thus
isolated from its neighbor by a varnish which serves at the same
time to glue them energetically to one another. During hot spells
this varnish becomes viscid, and often the sole weight of a block
suffices to rupture it into two or several fragments: in winter, on
the contrary, the bitumen becomes dry and the rock assumes a
remarkabie durability.

The deposits of asphalt are numbered: nature has shown itself
niggard of this precious material, and one will be little able to de-
termine by what law the richest known beds, it may be said the
only exploitable, are found almost thrown together into a very
contracted zone upon the chart of Europe. It is seen in effect if
a right line be drawn north and south from Wissembourg to
Chambery that, such line has traversed the four mines which to-
day supply (defray) the pavement industry Lobsan, Val-de-
Travers, Seysel and Volant, finally Chavaroche. It does not enter

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 157

— within the limits of this note to develop the conclusions whieh—
can be drawn from such a geographical situation as that of the
coincidence of said line with the direction of the Jura mountains
—that would be to enter upon a discussion too full of hypotheses.
No more do we dilate upon the probable mode of impregnation
of the bituminous limestones—opinions are divided on this point;
some will have it that in the train of the subterranean distillations,
concerning which we have spoken above, the vapors were dis-
charged into the atmosphere and forced a passage through vents
of the hard rocks to become lodged in the soft; others maintain

that the free bitumens of Judea or other remote countries
218 having appeared were carried upon the surface of the waters

by an universal deluge to impregnate the limestones cold.
Grave c biections drawn from the very structure of the material can
be opposed to both of these systems; the origin of asphalt must
then— until new studies have been accomplished—rest in doubt.

Whatever be its formation, the bank of asphalt which appears
to be of the same age in the four deposits we have cited, belongs
to the upper part of the jurassic formation, and is situated imme-
diately beneath the green “molasses.” Besides the mines before
indice: ted, there exist in several regions of France and of Spain out-
croppings of bituminous limestone of very inferior richness and
of doubtful purity.

20. Extraction, Pulverization, Sifting. Asphalt is obtained
after the manner of masonry stone (moellon) with powder and
tamping-iron; often the rock is sufficiently soft for one to make
blasting holes with the auger. Extraction proceeds, either in open
quarries, as at Pyrimont-Seyssel and Val-de-Traverse or under
galleries as at Volant and Chavaroche. The asphalt rubble is piled
upon the floor of the mine, in lots of 100 cubic meters; a part ts
forwarded to the public works in the state of rock, the rest is sent
to factories for the fabrication of mastic. There is need, ordinarily,
to avoid great production during summer, since heat causes the
rock to depreciate which tumbles, of itself, into powder. This
inconvenience ceases if the supplies be stored in the galleries
Summer is also the season most dreaded by miners who work in
quarries; under the action of the sun the bank of asphalt softens to
the pomt that the blows of the drill are without effect and the

workman is obliged to content himself with the pick, the
219 crowbar and the wedge. The cost of hand labor doubles
oftentimes frorn winter to summer.

Rock destined for the making of mastic is crushed, then pul
verized

158 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. VB.

Crushing: Crushing of the rock is a simple labor, out it does
not fail to assume a certain importance in the ensemble of
tions as the sequel of a special circumstance we have already sig-
nalized above. We have stated that asphalt—very hard in win
ter—softens considerably during hot spells; it results thence that
crushing—easy in the cold season—becomes very laborious jn
summer, impossible indeed oftentimes, when the blocks to cut up
have been exposed to a burning sun. Under the action of the
sun, the bitumen of impregnation liquefies, the material grows
slack and the crusher strikes against nothing more than a species
of paste which flattens without breaking. Therefore, the operator
avoids having this labor to do in summer, at least that it be not
carried out in the very galleries where the rock is extracted
(mined). It is admitted that on average, the hand labor for
crushing bituminous limestone varies from winter to summer in
the proportion of 3 to 5.

Ordinarily, the rock is broken to the size of the pebbles that
serve for the stoning of roads; it is shaped up for measurement: a
pile of block rock transformed into crushed rock loses—it is found
—about 20 per cent of its volume.

The crushed bituminous limestone is thereafter pulverized, then
sifted.

Pulverization can be effected in two ways: Hot, by decrepita-

tion; cold by grinding.
220 Hot Pulverization. The crushed rock is placed in open

cases of light sheet-iron, 1.00 meter, by 0.6m., by 0.2m. Said
cases are introduced into flat cast-iron retorts analogous to the hor-
izontal retorts employed in the distillation of bituminous achists:
under these devices a mild, uniform heat is maintained. The fol-
lowing phenomenon is produced: The bitumen with which the
1ock is impregnated—solid at ordinary temperature—softens and
flows; the calcarious molecules separate from one another and
tumble into powder. From time to time the cases are shaken to
present successively all parts of the asphalt to the action of the
reat; the material thus treated (shocked) is then thrown upon a
flat place when it is stamped in order to accomplish the pulveriza-
tion; finally it is passed through sieves which retain certain of the
more rebellious parts named (grabons) (“gravel’’); these “grabons”
are crushed apart by blows of the mallet and restored to the sieves
The powder obtained is ready to be transformed into mastic

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. - 159

Decrepitation is also produced in special apparatus of which we
will speak apropos the streets of compressed asphalt rock.

Pylverization by decrepitation such as we have just spoken of
in the first system which was employed; it presents the great ad-
yantage of requiring no motor whatever but it pays for this advan-
tage by numerous inconveniences. Were it possible to submit all
parts of the material to an uniform temperature and which was
maintained constantly between the melt-point of the bitumen of
impregnation and that of its vaporization, no other system—as-
surediy—could be preferable; but this condition which obtains—
it may be—in a laboratory with sustained attention is almost im-

possible to realize in practice. Whatever care is there brought

221 to bear the temperature of volatilization is always exceeded

and thus is lost a certain quantity of bitumen which needs to

he later restored—artificially; on the other hand, as all the mate-

rial cannot be heated equally, decrepitation of the interior parts is

set attained other than by burning those which touch against the
hot surfaces.

Pulverization by decrepitation is therefore, under the actual
state of its practice an essentially defective operation. Recourse
thereto should not be had unless the operator cannot do other-
wise, that is to say at times when he has not sufficient motive
force at his disposal. Nevertheless, it cannot be denied that the
lea of reducing the lime to powder by the simple softening of its
nils of impregnation is a seductive idea and one should not be sur-
prised to see that—even to this very time—it has not been com-
pletely abandoned. We will return to it certainly, the day when
the operator shall have succeeded in heating the rock uniformily
and methodically in such fashion that the temperature rests always
helow the point where the bitumen assumes the state of vapor.
That is an apparatus to contrive.*

However, the powder employed in establishing compressed
asphalt streets is obtainable up to the present by decrepitation.
We will take up this question again in its place.

Cold Pulverization. At the works where asphalt mastic is pre-
pared in gross, the rock is pulverized cold. Two species of ap-

paratus are employed: The crusher; the cone-mill. The

*Onty a few months since a means has been employed that appears to be a sc-
tution of the problemand which consists in introducing a jet of vaporintoa cylinder
where the rock isenclosed; undersuch action the rock tumbles into powder at theend.
ef 10minutes. Theapplications of this system are under study.

160 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. Ya,

222 first system is none other than the vertical burr of stone or

cast-iron furnished with scraper and the other aCCeSSOries
which are everywhere seen. The second resembles suffici
well the ordinary coffee mill in large dimensions; it has a cast-iron
cone 0.6 to 0.7m., at base and 0.8m., height mounted upon a ver.
tical arbor and moving within a shell of the same metal: the cone
and the shell are furnished with teeth which break the stone and
reduce it to dust.

On leaving the mill, the powder falls into cylindrical bolters of
about 0.02m., mesh; the sifted powder is ready to be delivered for
trying (cooking), the grabons (gravel) are returned to the mills,

34. Cooking: To make asphalt mastic such as is employed in
public works, the rock is subjected to a cooking under the condi-
tions following.

The operator provides cast-iron semi-cylindric boilers, some two
meters long and about one meter diameter placed horizontally
above return-flame furnaces. A shaft fixed at the axis of the cyl-
inder and carrier of radial guide blades agitates the paste and sue
cessively puts all parts thereof into contact with the hot surface:
each apparatus is surmounted by a shut-metal cover, also semi-
cylindric, which is raised from time to time to introduce the ma-
terial and watch the march of the operation: finally, exit pipes are
attached to the fanges of the boilers to vent the watery vapors
which escape abundantly at the commencement of the cooking.

At the beginning there is thrown into each boiler 90 tO 100
kilogr., of free bitumen which soon enters into fusion; when it has
almost attained its temperature of yolatilization, the agitator is

put in motion and shovel-full by shovel-full the asphalt pow-
223 der is thrown in; on falling into the hot liquid, the powder

deprecitates and mixes with it intimately; the introduction
is continued till the moment when the mixture ceases to he pasty
and becomes friable which the operator recognizes as that when
the material commences to attach to the bottom of the heater
and to the blades of the agitator. At such instant, the apparatus
has received about 100 kg., of free bitumen and 1,400 kg., of
asphalt powder. After being heated and agitated during six hours
the operator proceeds with the casting

Mastic is cast in built-up cylindric moulds each of sheet-metal
bent in semi-circle in fashion to form loaves of 0.3 meters diame
ter from 0.10 to 0.12 meters height and weighing about 25 kg.
A trade mark inerusted in one of the metal plates, imprints its
relief upon each loaf to attest its authenticity ; these are the loaves

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 161

which—sent about (i. e., scattered over) public ways—are re-cast
in movable cauldrons for making side-walks or other asphalt struc-

What passes during this period of cooking? What modifica-
tions are wrought upon the elements of asphalt? In sequel of
what metamorphosis does the bituminous rock become a powerful
mastic easily fusible and so different from its primary material?
It is indeed difficult to understand. The free bitumen added is
absorbed evidently by that already lodged in the pores of the lime-
stone; carried there it penetrates even into the most intimate
cavities of the asphalt as a drop of oil follows the path traced by
another drop: but it will not be pretended that the free bitumen
carries with it any new properties; its functions are purely acces-

sory; it aids in the fusion of the rock; it supplies the impreg-
224 nating oils lost by evaporation; it prepares the paste for tritu-
“ration and cooking as the saliva—if we may be permitted the
comparison—moistens the food, disposing it for mastication and
favoring its transformation.

Whatever may be the action of the added bitumen, it is a con-
stant fact that the more said bitumen has geologic analogy to that
with which the rock is impregnated, the better is the mastic ob-
tained. We shall speak elsewhere as to what can be the influence
of this more or less resemblance upon the duration of asphalt con-
structions.

Mastic prepared from rock alfundantly and equally impregnated.
fine of grain, added to a bitumen nearly its congener, is a black
body of reddish luster, elastic, infusible by the most burning sun
and endowed with a bituminous odor almost agreeable. We shall
return again to its special properties when we speak of its appli-
cations.

4th. Extraction and preparation of the bitumens which enter
into the production of mastic. We have just seen that free litu-
men plays an important role in the fabrication of asphalt mastic;
it fulfills another no less grave at the time of its application. Be-
fore going too far we cannot exempt ourselves from entering upon
certain details of this subject.

Thus—as we have said before—bitumen occurs either in abso-
jutely free state or else, and more generally, agglutinating quartz
sands or, finally, mixed with marly or earthy materials.

In the first case, of which the Fountain of Pitch is an example.
one is obliged to recover the bitumen at its exit from the ground,
to purge it by simple refining from all the impurities with which

—

162 UNITED STATES RBPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. YS,

it may be soiled, and obtains thus a viscid body of fine brilliant
black, in a word—pure bitumen.
225 _ In the second case, the operator exploits—as at Pyrimont:
Seyssel at Bastennes or at Claremont—the very i
banks of “molasse” (fine sandy loam) saturated with bitumen; the
blocks extracted are crushed into pieces of 0.07 to 0.08m.. on side,
thrown into cauldrons full of boiling water and stirred for about an
hour. Bitumen brought to 100° liquefies, the “molasse”’ falls inte
sand and the bubbling of the water, acting mechanically, each
grain strips itself of its bituminous envelope, which proceeds to
float ; the surface is skimmed to recover the bitumen and the sand
rests clean at the bottom; the sand is removed, the boiler re
charged and the operation recommences.

When the “molasse” is of large grain, as found at Lussat -
(Auvergne) the sand is completely precipitated and the bitumen is
almost pure; but it is very rare that the molasse is not of very fine
grain au then the material taken off by the skimmer contains
always a large quantity of disaggregated grit drawn in by the
ebullition and disseminated through the bitumen. To purge the
skimmings of this sand they are set boiling, the water evaporates,
the sand gains the bottom by virtue of its density and the work:
man decants. Bitumen obtained by this second operation is abso-
lutely pure but the sand left at the bottom of the boiler yet keeps
a volume almost equal thereto and which it is impossible to re-
cover practically. This system of extraction, costly and barbarous,
has been described by d'Alembert* like as it is still employed to-
day. It has not taken a pace in one hundred years. However,
novel processes are under study. Although they have not given
thus far the hoped-for results it can be foreseen that it will soon
be possible to suppress the methods so in arrears of the progress

of the industry.
226 ~=In the third case that where the bitumen is mixed with

earthy matters, the operator is obliged to have recourse to
other means; the bitumens of Trinidad for example, occur in im-
mense dry lakes the bottom of which is entirely composed of a
sort of blackish rock which is none other than bitumen solidified
by the presence of foreign matters and by the evaporation of a
certain quantity of essential oils. The rock is taken out. shipped
to France where it is subjected to the treatment following: A
part of the solidified bitumen is distilled and there is obtained

— suresnendesnetevaninnentibamentices - ee)

*Encyclopedia—Article: “: Asphalt.’

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 163

from the worm a bituminous oil analogous to the heavy oils from
schist ; such oil serves to dissolve in special cauldrons three other
¢ of solid bitumen. The dissolution is effected hot; the most
val earthy gangues go to the bottom and by a decantation the
bitumen is separated therefrom and is barrelled and sent off

into the industries.

In general, all bituminous materials—calcarious, schist, sand,
solid rock of Trinidad—yield on distillation the same product, an
oxygenated multo-hydrocarbon, the “petroleum” of the ancients;
sometimes the aroma varies, the bitumen of Clermont for exam-
ple, exhales a strong garlicy odor which is to be found nowhere
else: but among all the aspect, the composition, the combustion
are sensibly identical. Consequently, the operator has in certain
cases and when economy was found in doing it been led to sub-
stitute diZerent oils for each other. Thus, in the operation which
consists in dissolving the crude Trinidad bitumen in its proper oil
of distillation, it has been possible to replace said oil by that which
js obtained on distillation bituminous schists.

The principal species of bitumen which serve either in the fabri-

cation or else in the application of asphalt mastic are those
227 which we have just enumerated; we repeat them: Native

bitumen (Clermont); bitumen coming from the leaching
(trying) of “‘molasse” (Pyrimont-Seyssel, Bastennes, Boechel-
bronn, etc.); Purified Trinidad bitumen. Besides these three spe-
cies there are employed further: the bitumen drived from the
purification of heavy schist oils; the bitumen residue from the
distillation of coal; the mixed bitumens called grease bitumens.

The schist bitumens are utilized without disadvantage when
they are not too concentrated; their composition is almost the
same as that of natural bitumens and were it not very difficult
to obtain them always alike we would allow little difference be-
tween their usage and that of the best native bitumens.

As to the bitumens or tars of coal and of fats the presence
thereof ought to be proscribed as far as possible in asphalt con-
struction of slight thickness. Coal bitumen, also called “gas tar,”
renders mastic brittle in winter and soft in summer, it exhales on
application an insupportable odor; finally, its essential oils being
very volatile evaporate promptly on contact with air; pavements
into the composition of which it enters become friable and wear
out quickly when they have a frequent circulation to support. The
bitumen of tallow (fat bitumen) far more perhaps than that of
coal is to be dreaded in public works. The greasy elements which

184 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. V8.

“it contains far from uniting with the bitumen of impregnation of
the asphalt, dissolve it on the contrary and form thereof a maj.
leable paste which wears rapidly away under the feet of the
passers-by. Both of these bitumens are incapable of constitytj
good side-walks, and if their low price still causes them to be ad-
mitted by some contractors they should be severely interdicted
by architects and engineers.
228 5th. Application of Asphalt. The applications of asphalt
are unlimited; our design is neither to describe all those which
have been discovered nor to indicate those which remain to be
discovered. These should be the matter of a special treatise; we
limit ourselves to signalizing the principal uses man makes of it
either in highways or in hydraulic constructions and we follow, as
the more logical, the order here set forth, viz: 1. Application of
raw asphalt. Il. Application of asphalt mastic.

lL. Application of raw asphe t. Compressed asphalt roadways,
From the origin of asphalt it had been possible to recognize there-
in the following property: The carts which transported the rock
from the mine to the places for treatment* could often let fall
upon the road some fragments which the wheels crushed, when
the route was covered with this debris, summer supervened, the
heat softened the bitumen of impregnation, the wagons which
followed on compressed the material and there was formed a crust
—solid, dense, elastic, easy to the feet of the horses and of almost
no wear. We have seen in nearly all asphalt mines, similar road-
ways and one of these can be remarked at Pyrimont-Seyssel, of
which the vestiges—still robust despite the barbarous system of
braking in vigor in the country—are to-day nearly sixteen years
old.

It was not until about 1850 that this lesson of chance was vol-
untarily put to profit. A Swiss engineer, Mr. Merian, built at
this period in the little village of Travers (Canton of Neufchatel)
a roadway from heated and compressed asphalt rock. According

to the experience of Mr. Merian the asphalt was simply spread

229 out upon the macadamized road and subjected to the roller;

despite the instability of the site and the irregularity of re-
pair the route at Travers is still in sufficiently good state

The same year Mr. Darcy, inspector-general for bridges and
highways, on return from a specia! mission to London, pn

* Before it was thought to aatie asphalt for building a and streets it
was sé au ministre des tra- —
yaus publics ', « que la solution de la question si importante et si con-
« troversée de la viabilité dans les villes se trouve dans l'emploi judi-
« cieux de la roche asphallique, » il allait méme jusqu'd en proposer
application immédiate sur une partie des boulevards.

Ce ne fut cependant qu’en 1854, que la premiére chaussée en asphalte
comprimé fut par les soins de MM. Homberg, ingénieur en chef, et Vaudrey,
ingenieur ordinaire du service municipal, établie 4 Paris rue Bergére,
sur les débris d'un essai ot le bitume avait joué an rdle, mais qui n'a-
yait vécu que quelques mois. Depuis ce moment la chaussée de la rue
Bergere, sauf4a portion située en face de la rue du Conservatoire et qui
est en asphalte coulé comme les trottoirs, n'a jamais été réparée.

A partir de 1854, le systeme des chaussées en asphalte s’es, développ¢
suivant une progression rapide.

En 1854, les premiers essais occupaient une surface de 7 4 800 métres,
quatre avs plus tard cette surface s'élevait 4 8,000 métres, aujourd'hui,
comme je l'ai dit tout a heure, elle est supéri.are 4 cent mille métres
carrés.

Les chaussees publiques ne sont pas d’ailleurs le seul débouché de
l'asphalte comprimé; les cours de l’hdtel du Louvre, du Grand-Hotel,
des gares de l'Ouest et du Nord, et d'un grand nombre de maisons parti-
culigres ont recu des applications dont le nombre tend chaque jour A s’ac-
croitre, moins peut-dtre & cause de la solidité de la surface qu’a cause de
son insonorité qui, dans ce cas spécial, est son avantage le plus re-
cherché. .

Il ne faut pas croire cependant que ie systeme qui fait l'objet de cette
communication ait été préservé des écoles et des mécomptes inséparables
de toute innovation qui cherche sa voie ; les épreuves n'ont pas manqué.
Sans parler des difficultés nombreuses qu'il a fallu traverser pour ar-
river 4 une bonne préparation de la matiére, difficultés & peine vaincues
en ce moment, le nouveau procédé s'est trouvé en face de la défiance, ou
tout au moins de la timidité que rencontre toute idée nouvelle chez les
mieux disposés et les plus compétents. Un incident que je ne puis passer
sous Silegce, car il a eu tout le monde pour témoin, est venu méme porter
aux chaussées en asphalte un coup dont elles ne se seraient pas relevées,
si elles n'avaient su trouver dans un échec apparent les élements d'un

nouveau succes. Je veux parler de la réfection de la rue Neuve-des-
Petits-Champs.

|. Aumotes des poxts et chaussécs, 2* série, 1850.

mit néanmoins & l’ceuvre. Le travail fut des plus

jamais a sécher le béton, et l'on fat obligé, dans l'impossibilité ou

trouvait, d’obstruer longtemps une rue aussi fréqueatée, de poser la poy.

dre sur des surfaces humides. Au bout de quelques jours des affaingg.

ments se manifestérent sur toute Ja longueur de la rue, la crofite asphal.

tique se dégrada, on fut obligé de !'enlever: on s'apercut alors que is
mouillé avait

je V'ai indiqué plus haut et avec les précautions que
Vexpérience a enseignées, la chaussée en asphalte comprimé jouit des
propriétés suivantes -

Elle ne produit ni boue . The two modes are alike in that they result in uniting the
two parts or sections without any dividing line, because the new
material is mixed with and becomes a part of the old pavement.

8. The two modes are alike in that in neither is the use of tar
required for the purpose of uniting the parts or sections of material
inasmuch as they will unite perfectly without such use.

I find therefore that the stipulated mode embodies every step

or operation of the patent mode pursued upon the same ma-
362 terials having the same characteristics and carried out in like
manner to effect the same results.

My attention is called to the fact that it has been testified on
behalf of defendants, while not stated in the stipulation that in
the defendants” mode of repair the edges of the opening are coated
with dope or cement. I am aware that it is common in carrying
out the process of the patent in suit to paint the edges of the open-
ings or depressions with cement which is practically the same as
the asphalt mixture without the sand and in a melted state. This
is only done when the new material cannot be added at once after
the old material has been operated upon, and it is done in order
that there may be a smooth even surface to which dust and dirt
will not adhere so that the opening can be readily cleaned out
when the new hot material is to be added. It further tends to
keep the particles of the old material at the edges in their opened
up condition. It is not in any sense a solder because as soon as the
hot new material is deposited the cement becomes incorporated
with and a part of the material and is practically absorbed or Tost
so far as having any separate identity is concerned.

ee re

286 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. VS.

I do not regard this feature of difference between the defend.
ants’ mode and that of the patent as militating in any way against
the fact that the two are the same for the reason that the use of
the cement is merely an added feature which does not modify or
detract from the efficacy and effect of the other steps of the pro-
cess. Further, for the reason that there is no statement in the
patent or requirement to the effect that the cement must be dis-
pensed with in all cases but merely a statement that certain opera-

tions are performed and effects produced without the use of
363 tar for the purpose of uniting the parts. Further, the refer-

ence in the patent is to tar, a substance which in the old pro-
cess was used as a solder, being a different material from any in-
gredient in the pavement and softening at a lower temperature,
while the material used by defendants is not tar but a cement
which is practically the same as the material of the pavement.

Comparing the stipulated method with claim 1 of the patent in
suit, as I have before expressed my understanding of it, I find that
the claim calls for repairing asphalt pavements by a method
in which heat is used and new material added “substantially as de-
scribed.” I find that in the stipulated method the heat is used
substantially as described in the patent in suit, that is, as specified
in claim 1, the spot to be repaired is subjected to heat, and, as de-
scribed, the heat is for the purpose of enabling the surface portion
of the old material to be agitated in order that the new may be
effectively added thereto..

I find also that in the stipulated method new material is added,
substantially as described in the patent in suit, that is, the new
material is deposited upon that part of the old surface which has
been agitated and opened or picked up, and it is deposited in a
highly heated condition.

I find also that as called for in claim 1, the stipulated method
embodies the operations of smoothing and burnishing.

I therefore find that the stipulated method is the same method
set forth and claimed in claim 1 of the patent in suit embodying
the same steps as described in said claim and in the specification
to which reference is made, carried out in the same manner to pro-

duce and producing the same effects or results. My attention
364 has been called to the fact that the defendants in carrying out
their mode of process sometimes permit a certain interval of
time to elapse between the operations upon the old material and
the deposit of the new material. I do not regard this as embody-
ing a step different from anything called for in the patent. There

BN 6S POLITE YEA LE CTE QUO OOS KD OREGON LEY SEMEN NPT Y ROMANE Sw ae eae

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. ~ 98%

is no statement in the patent that the steps shall be carried on con-
secutively without a substantial intermission of time, and in fact,
this would not be understood by any one skilled in the art reading
the specification because every one skilled in the art would recog-
nize that in the repair of asphalt pavement by the method de-
scribed, it in many instances would not be practicable to have the
fresh material on hand to fill each depression immediately after the
surface therein had been agitated. Those skilled in the art would
recognize the fact that very frequently the place where the fresh
material is prepared is several miles away from the point where
the repairs are made and that the carts are frequently delayed
in passing to and fro that sometimes the pavement is operated:
upon to soften the old material and prepared for the reception
of the new just before the hour of stopping at night or at noon,
and under the operations of the patent, as practically carried on,
no attempt was made to insure the immediate addition of the new
material after operating upon the surface of the old layer.

An expert like the patentee, Perkins, or any expert reading
the patent in suit, would as a matter of course recognize these es-
sential well known conditions and no one familiar with the art
would have been misled into understanding that the mode of the

patent embodied any immediate succession of steps so far as
365 the heating of the surface material and the deposit of the new
material were concerned.

Adjourned to Thursday, Feb. 24, 1898, at 10:30 a. m.
Washington, Feb. 24, 1898, 10:30 a. m.

Met pursuant to adjournment:

Parties present as before.

Mr. Foster’s testimony continued.

Q. 7. Have you read French Letters Patent to Crochet, No.
137,208, introduced into this case as Defendants’ Exhibit Crochet
Patent and if so, do you understand the same?

A. Thave read and I do understand the French Letters Patent
to Crochet.

QO. 8. State your understanding of the said Crochet patent and
also whether or not you find set forth therein the process of the
patent in suit?

288 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. VS.

A. I understand that the Crochet patent relates to a process
for the repair and renewal of a compressed ashpalt pavement. At
the date of the said letters patent to Crochet, and at the present
date, there were and are practically two classes of asphalt paving
materials in use in France, that is, those which are known as “com-
pressed asphalt” and as “bitumens” or “mastics,” both, however,
made from rock asphalt. I find upon reading the Crochet patent
that it relates to operations to be performed on a pavement of
compressed asphalt, which pavements were and are made from
Neufchatel or rock asphalt or Seyssel asphalt; that is, a limestone
or sometimes a sandstone rock containing a certain percentage of

mineral tar or bitumen and any one skilled in the art at the
366 date of the Crochet patent, reading the same, could without

any positive statement in said patent, have understood that a
rock asphalt pavement was the character of pavement upon which
the patentee proposed to operate. The patent itself, however,
states beyond a doubt the character of the material by setting
forth its characteristics. For instance, the reference to the effect
of the pick in starting or swelling up the adjacent parts indicates
one of the characteristics of a pavement made of rock asphalt. A
pavement made from an asphalt composition such as is in use to-
day in the United States will crack Or-split under the action of a
pick. The further reference in the specification to the effect of
heat upon the pavement which “decrepitates and becomes friable”
shows beyond a doubt that the pavement to be operated upon
is a rock asphalt pavement, as no other kind of an asphalt pave-
ment is thus affected by heat except rock asphalt. The statement
that after the parts are heated the rake forms upon the part re-
maining “numerous striae” describes a result peculiar to a rock
asphalt pavemént for when heated the teeth of a rake will cut into
the same and form scratches precisely as they would in the surface
of dry solid clay or chalk. Again reference is made to the asphalt
“in powder-like state.” This alone would determine the charae-
ter of material intended to be operated upon and with by the
patentee because rock asphalt alone among asphaltic pavement
materials is in a powdered condition whether cold or heated. [
note, however, no statement in the Crochet patent requiring that
the fresh material shall be heated.

For illustration I here produce a box containing rock or Seysse!
asphalt in powder in the shape in which it is employed and which
I have seen employed for laying pavements and I also produce

a portion of such rock asphalt which has been heated by me

~

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. ose

367 to above 300 degrees Fahrenheit. The effect of heat upon
rock asphalt is not to materially change its powdered condi-
tion. It is not necessary to assume that the asphalt powder re-
ferred to in the Crochet patent must have been heated or was
intended to be heated by the patentee in order to carry out his
process because rock asphalt will weld under impact or pressure
whether cold or hot, my own experiments tend to show that a
better weld or consolidation can be obtained with the cold than
with the heated material. I produce herewith a number of blocks
of compressed asphalt which I made in a die by impact, consolidat-
ing thereby some of the material taken from the box of powder
which I have produced. The box of asphalt powder is marked
“Complainant’s Exhibit Rock Asphalt Powder.” That which has
been heated is marked “Complainant’s Exhibit Powdered Rock
Asphalt After Heating” and the blocks are marked “Complain-
ant’s Exhibit Compressed Block Asphalt.” It is a fact that the
rock asphalt has been used upon roads when compressed thereon
inacold state. The usual purpose of heating rock asphalt is not
to render it adhesive and capable of being consolidated and com-
pacted but is just the reverse, that is, for the purpose of breaking
it up into a powder, and sometimes instead of grinding the asphalt
rock in order to fit it for pavement purposes, the said rock is re-
duced to a powder by the application of heat. The further refer-
ence in the Crochet patent to the use of the system for recharging
streets “of bitumen” indicates the other class of rock asphalt pave-
ments termed “mastics” and intended for light driveways and con-
sisting of rock asphalt with the addition of a small percentage of
mineral tar. The usual addition of the mineral tar to pave-

368 ments having stone for their foundation does not change the
characteristics of what are called in the Crochet patent and
what were then known as “compressed asphalt pavements.” I
have given a great deal of attention to the construction and com-
position of asphalt pavements during several years, and have read
various works and articles on the subject and have conversed with
many who are familiar with the art of laying such pavements, both
in the United States and Europe, and I have no knowledge of the
use of asphaltic mixtures, such mixtures, that is, as have the char-
acteristics of the asphalt pavements at present in use in the United
States and described in the Perkins patent in suit, as being em-
ployed in France at any day. I am aware that such asphalts as
Trinidad asphalts have been used to a slight extent in France for
paving purposes, but merely for the purpose of extracting the

UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. VS.

290

more liquid portions or securing the bitumen to be used for tem-
pering rock asphalt mixtures.

In laying pavements of the character specified in the Crochet
patent the natural rock is reduced to a powder by heating or
grinding; this powder is then generally but not always heated and
is then spread upon the foundation and compressed or consoli-
dated preferably first by tamping and then by rolling. A high
degree of pressure and preferably percussion has been found de-
sirable in order to consolidate the material in making pavements
of this character for unless so consolidated, the material on cooling
will retain its granular condition. The purpose of the patentee
Crochet in effecting repairs of such a pavement in applying heat
to the part to be repaired was to disintegrate or decrepitate the
portion of pavement, and this he effected by the application of

heat until that portion became friable. The word “friable”
369 fairly indicates the effect of the application of heat to rock

asphalt as I have found in actual practice. That portion of
the pavement at the surface heated beyond a certain limited tem-
perature loses its slight elasticity and toughness and becomes fri-
able and flakes and crumbles so that it can be readily scraped
away or swept away, but the portion beneath is in
its original hard, compacted condition and practically as regular
as the upper surface of the unheated part of the pavement. The
patentee, in order to “augment the adherence” of the additional
material and secure some kind of mechanical union between the
old and the new material roughens or striates the surface by
scratching the same with the teeth of a rake. I have found that
the only effect of the teeth of a rake in such a case is to form
scratches such as would be made by the same instrument in ordi-
nary chalk. The fresh material is then placed in the depression
formed by the removal of the heated portion of the old material.
There is no statement in the Crochet patent directly to the effect
that this fresh material is to be hot, and it is possible that the
patentee proposes to unite the parts under pressure alone. If I
assume the fresh material in its powdered condition to be added
in a heated state and then compressed under the high pressure
necessary to compact it, it would simply constitute a slab or plug
filling or plugging the opening in the same manner in which such
material had been commonly employed in repairing rock asphalt
pavements where the injured portion had been. cut away by means
of a pick. It is obvious to me that the Crochet patent describes 2
process which never did and never would go into any extended

~

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 291

ractical use. Any one familiar with the characteristics of rock
asphalt and of the effect of heat upon lime rock would recog-

37¢ uize at once upon reading the Crochet patent that it would
be impossible to effect anything but a frictional union be-
tween the old and the new material even if the latter was heated
under the conditions specified by the French patent. My knowl-
edge oi the characteristics of rock asphalt, as derived from read-
ing, and in consultation with those familiar with its characteristics,
at once led me to the above conclusions on my first reading of the
Crochet patent and subsequently in order to avoid any possible
error in the matter I carried out the process of repair proposed in
the Crochet patent in the effort to repair a Seyssel pavement and
my first opinion was fully confirmed. In so doing I heated the
fresh material to over 300 degrees Fahrenheit. I heated the sur-
face to be repaired by means of a heater substantially like the
Perkins heater. I thoroughly scratched or striated the surface of
the depression, and while the latter was still in a heated condition
I deposited the heated powdered asphalt in the depression and had
it thoroughly packed therein by means of rammers using greater
pressure than would probably ordinarily be employed, and did
everything which in my opinion weuld thoroughly carry out the
process set forth in the Crochet patent and which would tend to
secure a union with the old and the new material. Notwithstand-
ing my careful attention to carrying out every detail specified in
the Crochet patent, the only result was to form a solid block filling
the depression, and on subsequently cutting out the repaired por-
tion of the pavement, found that there was absolutely no welding
of the old and the new parts but merely a frictional adhesion so
that the new part readily separated from the old upon receiving a
slight blow. I have further at different times endeavored to

371 weld together a compressed block of rock asphalt and a body
of fresh material sometimes cold and sometimes heated by
compacting the fresh material upon the already moulded block,
but have never secured anything more than a mechanical adhesion,
the parts separating under a very slight strain, and my experience
, in this respect corresponds fully with that stated by others with
whom I have had occasion to converse. There is quite a large
amount of Seyssel pavement in use in the United States at the
present time, and I have repeatedly during the past three years
made inquiries as to whether any repairs have been effected upon
such pavements by any process like the Perkins process of the
patent in suit and not only have not been able to.learn of any such

299 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. VS.

operations having been effected but have been advised by those
familiar with the Seyssel pavements that in their opinions they
could not be effected; and I believe I am right in stating that this
is a generally recognized fact among those skilledin the art. The
only effect of the operations specified in the Crochet patent which,
to my mind, is attended with any advantage is the disintegration
of the pavement by the heat of the tray which is carried over the
pavement which facilitates the removal of the portien heated, dif-
fering in this respect from the effect of heating a pavement of as-
phalt mixture and I recognize that by “the repeated passage of
the movable furnace,” referred to in the Crochet patent, the rdck
asphalt pavement might finally be disintegrated to any desired
depth so as to permit the introduction of a very substantial plug
of new material.
Comparing the asphalt mixture of the character operated upon
in securing the result set forth in the Perkins patent and the
372 material of the Crochet patent, they are essentially different
in many of their characteristics. Thus the rock asphalt is in
the form of a powder, after it is ground and whether it is hot or
cold. The asphalt mixture when heated is pasty, slightly granular
but not friable. The grains are not loose but sticky and adhesive.
The rock asphalt when cold is in the form of a brown powder.
The asphalt mixture when cold is a substantially solid mass, so
tough and solid that it is with difficulty broken by a pick. I here
produce a specimen of such a mass of asphaltic mixture as it fell
irom a cart in this city a few days ago, and the same is marked
“Complainant’s Exhibit Asphalt Mixture.” The asphalt mixture
when cold is tough and solid even wher it has not been subjected
to pressure, while under similar conditions the rock asphalt is still
a loose powder. After the rock asphalt has been compressed and
consolidated the application of heat disintegrates it and causes
portions to flake off and renders all the heated part friable so that
it will readily break or crumble and become sandy. The asphalt
mixture when heated after compression to any degree short of
burning becomes sticky, pasty, soft, partially melted and easily
worked, being very much of the consistency of fresh mortar. The
application of heat to compressed rock asphalt while it softens and
breaks it up does not impart to it any adhesive characteristics
while the application of heat to asphalt mixture after compression
melts the asphalt therein, renders it soft and pasty and sticky ard
imparts a fresh lustrous surface so that it will adhere readily to
fresh material. After the removal of the surface portion of a

~~

i f
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 993

heated rock asphalt pavement the application of a rake to the part

below simply scratches the hard surface of the unimpaired
373 portion. After the application of heat to a pavement of as-

phalt mixture the effect of the rake is to penetrate the soft-
ened and partially melted body of material lifting it up and sep-
arating the particles very much as the rake would operate upon a
laver of fresh mortar. Upon the addition of fresh material to the
old material in a rock asphalt pavement there is no admixture of
the old and the new and the effect of pressure is not in the welding
of the parts of the old and the new together. Upon the addition
of fresh material to the opened up surface of the old material in a
pavement of asphalt mixture the particles of the two are com-
mingled or mixed along the plane of union and there is, as I have
found by repeated tests, such a close welding that the new part
is practically integral with the old, so that as stated by the pat-
entee Perkins “there is no dividing line because the new material
has been mixed with and become a part of the old material.’’ Apart
from the fact that the patentee Crochet makes no statement as to
whether the fresh material is to be hot or cold, I still find that the
Crochet patent does not set forth the process of the patent in suit,
because it does not describe a process embodying the same oper-
ations upon the same material to secure the same result. If I as-
sume that the operations specified in the Crochet patent are the
same as those set forth in the patent in suit their effect on the ma-
terial is so entirely different in its characteristics that it does not
constitute the same mode or process any more than a series of
steps upon syrup to clarify it constitutes the same process as the
same steps upon coal oil to refine it. Neither are the operations
of the Crochet patent accompanied by the same results as the op-
erations specified upon the material of the Perkins patent. In

one case there is an absolute welding together of two ma-
374 terials so that after renewal the pavement is practically in the

same condition as when it was first laid. In the operations
of the Crochet patent, there is practically no welding of the old
and new parts but simplv the accurate fitting and consolidation or
plugging up of the depression in the old material with a solid block
of new material with a very clear line of demarcation between the
two, permitting a ready separation. I recognize that the patentee
Crochet proposed to solder the new material perfectly to the old
without break in continuity but I cannot recognize this as a state-
ment to the effect that the new pavement is thereby homogeneous
because the process set forth in the Crochet patent is altogether

294 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. V8.

ineffective to such a result. I therefore fail to find set forth in the
Crochet patent the process of repairing pavements specified in the
patent in suit.

Noon recess.

Q. 9. State whether or not at the date of the application for
the letters patent in suit the Crochet French patent gave sufficient
knowledge to the public to enable those skilled in the art, without
the exercise of invention, to effectively repair pavements made of
asphalt mixture?

A. I fail to recognize that any such information was given by
the Crochet French patent, or that it gave any information of
value to those skilled in the art. On the contrary, the effect of
the statements of the Crochet French patent upon one skilled in
the art would probably be to discourage the use of the steps sper-
ified in that patent. Anyone familiar with the characteristics of
rock asphalt would upon reading the description in the patent,
set aside the process if intended to secure a welding union between
the old and the new, described in said patent, as visionary and im-

practicable, except to the extent to which it would plug up
375 an opening with a material separable from the old material,

There is nothing whatever in the Crochet patent which would
enable anyone to know that the hard, compressed material of an
asphalt mixture pavement could, after it had long been in use,
be so softened and opened up without burning and so intimately
combined with fresh material as to effect an absolute weld or union
of the two. I am confirmed in this opinion by the fact that not-
withstanding the existence of the French patent, presumably well
known to many skilled in the art, it was the universal practice up
to the date of the Perkins invention to effect repairs by means of
the ineffective and expensive laborious process of cutting away
the entire surface mixture to the hydraulic concrete foundation.

It is true that the Crochet patent sets forth that by the applica-
tion of heat to the surface of a rock asphalt pavement the heated
portion of the latter may be disintegrated and readily removed,
but no one on being made acquainted with this fact which was
known before the date of the Crochet patent would know that it
would be practicable to operate upon the surface of a compressed
asphalt pavement without disintegrating it but merely so as to
melt and soften and reduce it to the pasty condition in which it
was laid. Any one familiar with the characteristics of an asphalt
mixture pavement and also familiar with the absolute destruction

~~

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 295

of the same as sometimes happens from building fires thereon
would suppose that any other result would ensue upon the attempt
to carry out the process set forth in the Perkins patent in suit.
Naturally any one skilled in the art would assume that the appli-
cation of sufficient heat to secure the softening of the lower body
of material would result in practically destroying or burning out

so much of the material as would defeat the purpose of the
376 operation. It is only from actual experiment that one learns

the fact that upon the application of a blow pipe blast as sug-
gested in the patent in suit there at once forms upon the extreme
upper surface a thin carbonaceous crust which practically protects
all of the material below trom overheating and reduces it to a
pasty or molten condition for a considerable depth. This is the
very opposite of the suggestion of the Crochet patent that the
effect of heat is to disintegrate or decrepitate the material for a
depth of a half an inch or more.

QO. 10. State whether or not if the process and apparatus of the
Crochet French patent were to-day used in repairing asphalt pave-
ments, consisting of an asphaltic mixture employing the precise
steps and apparatus described in said patent, an effective operation
would result?

A. Insuch a case an effective operation would not result. The
patent prescribes that the old pavement is to be heated until the
portion heated becomes friable. This would be practicable with a
rock asphalt pavement with the apparatus specified and illustrated
in the French patent, and this would result in the absolute de-
struction of an asphalt mixture pavement, because the under.
neath portion would become so highly heated as to lose its bitumi-
nous and adhesive characteristics and be unserviceable. There is
no intimation in the French patent of any modification of the
process in its application to different purposes, and therefore any
one literally following the said patent upon an asphalt mixture
pavement would destructively burn the latter.

Q. 11. Have you read Defendants’ Exhibits Malo Articles

377 Nos. 1, 2 and 3, Beckwith Article, Engineering Article, Cha-
brier Article, Correspondence on Asphalt and Malo Book and

the several translations thereof, and if so, please state whether you
find in any of said exhibits any more or better infoimation or in-
structions regarding the repair of asphalt pavements than you find
in the Crochet patent; whether you find anv reference to or de-
scription of the “asphaltic mixture” pavements in common use in
this country at the date of the Perkins patent in suit: and whether

296 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. V8.

you find therein any support for your conclusions regarding the
Crochet patent and the disclosures therein, and particularly with
reference to the kind of pavements treated of and the instructions
given to those skilled in the art?
A. Thaveread the said Exhibit Articles and find the therein state-
ments which correspond substantially with other statements re-
lating to asphalt pavements in various other publications which [
have read from time to time. Without going into detail I would
state that I find that the articles referred to to point out the use
of rock asphalt in making pavements called “compressed as-
phalt pavements,” and those termed “mastics.” They also
point out the common method of repair of rock asphalt pave-
aents by cutting through to the hydraulic foundation or “beton,.”
They also refer to the fact that for a limited time repairs had been
made by first heating the compressed asphalt to render it friable
or disintegrate it, then scraping away, repeating this for any de-
sired number of times and then plugging up the opening. I do not
find any statement anywhere to the effect that after cutting any
pavement so repaired the old and the new material were found to
be welded together. If such statement had been made it would
not be a true statement, for it is absolutely a fact that the
378 new material cannot be applied to the old and compressed
thereon if either or both are hot or cold so as to unite the
two forming a tomogeneous article or structure. I would refer to
the Chambrier article, page 283, as showing how much more ad-
hesive rock asphalt is when cold than when heated which is the
reverse of what is the case with asphalt mixture, and T would refer
to the section at the top of page 290 as substantiating what I have
said about the effect of heat in reducing the consistency of rock
asphalt. The article termed Bridge and Highway Annals, etc.,
under the fourth heading “Extraction and ‘Preparation of Bitu-
mens, etc.,” refers to the use made of Trinidad asphalt for securing
a bitumi.ous oil which is thereafter used for other purposes and
this article further on refers to the laying of pavements by com-
pressing the rock asphalt cold, but I cannot agree with the state-
ment therein that this does not result in giving so homogeneous
and solid a body as when the rock asphalt is compressed in a
heated state, and it appears to me that the writer treats the mat-
ter theoretically only. Where such results were not obtained it
was probably owing to the presence of moisture or to a defective
foundation which would not allow sufficient pressure.
I do not find that any of the said articles go further than the

a

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 997

Crochet patent in describing a means of readily forming the ¢
pressions in a rock asphalt pavement and plugging them up. I
do not find that any of them even hint at the use of such pavement
compositions as constitute the asphaltic mixture pavements upon
which the Perkins process could be employed, and I further find

that in all those cases where reference is made to plugging
379 rock asphalt pavement by the steps described in the Crochet

patent, this mode is alluded to in such terms as to indicate
that the same was experimental in its character at the time. There
is nothing stated as to the character of the pavement so repaired,
the usage to which they were subjected, and nothing to show
that the repairs resulted in anything more than plugging up an
opening with compressed asphalt without any real union between
the old and the new parts. No one skilled in the art could under-
stand from any one of these publications that it would be ‘practi-
cable to heat and melt the surface portion of an asphalt mixture
pavement without destructively burning a large proportion of the
same, nor could they have known this fact from said statements
and without the necessity of actual experiment and demonstra-
tion.

Q. 12. Have you examined and do you understand the inven-
tions or improvements set forth in, Letters Patent No. 560.599.
in suit granted to Amos H. Perkins, May 19, 1896?

A. I have examined the said patent and I understand the ap-
paratus therein set forth.

Q. 13. Please state your understanding of the invention de-
scribed and claimed in said Letters Patent, and also compare the
same with Complainant’s Exhibit Defendants’ Device and state
whether you find in said device the invention described in said
Letters Patent and summed up in the claims thereof.

A. Referring to Letters Patent 560,599, I find that it relates
to that class of apparatus for repairing asphalt pavements in which
a hood is carried to a position above the parts to be repaired and
a mixture of gas and air is burned beneath the hood in order to
soften the surface of the latter. In prior constructions certain

objections arose in practice pointed out in the specification
380 of patent 560,599, such, for instance, as the escape of flame

and heat around the edges of the hood which could not be
brought close to the pavement without cutting off the air supply
—the burning out of the valve of the numerous burners previously
employed—and the necessity of using a high grade of burning -
fluid. The patentee sets forth that he overcomes these objections

298 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. VS.

by the use among other things of a hood which is open at one end.
This permits the hood to be set directly upon the ground if neces-
sary while sufficient air can get access to the burners even if they
were arranged within the hood. An arrangement is shown, how-
ever, with the burners outside of the closed end of the hood and
projecting into or towards openings in the hood constituting a
sort of Bunsen burner whereby the jets of flame are projected hor-
izontaliy from one end without any tendency to direct the blast
beneath the edges of the hood even should the latter be elevated
from the pavement. Instead of a series of burners arranged be-
neath the hood the patentee makes use of burners arranged to dis-
charge the flame horizontally into the hood from the direction of
the closed end thereof with a supply pipe leading from a reservoir
beneath the hood in position therein to be heated by the flame
projected from the burners to which the supply pipe extends. By
this means the use of numerous joints is prevented, the oil being
vaporized in the pipes by the flame from the burners which are
arranged back of the point where the heat is generated so that
they are not burned out, while the burners may consist simply of
short tight nozzles without valves and permitting the use of light
oils without pressure or of heavy oils with an artificial pressure in

the tank. As shown the whole apparatus is mounted upon
381 wheels so as to be portable. In Fig. 7 of the drawing and

page 2 of the specifications, line 110 et seq., there is shown
and described a modification in which the burner has a hood P
projecting through the rear end of the hood H.

Referring to the claims, I find that they all relate to an appa-
ratus for repairing asphalt pavements. Each claim calls for a hood
and all of the claims except claim 4 require that the hood shall be
closed at one end and open at the other. Each claim calls for one
or more burners. Claims 1, 4 and 5 require that the burners shall
be arranged to discharge horizontaly into the hood. I understand
this to mean that the arrangement of the burners is such that the
gas therefrom shall pass horizontally from the burners within the
hood either from the burner arranged wholly outside of the end of
the hood, as shown in Figs. 1 to 5, or with a part of the burner
extending into and through the wall of the hood as shown in Fig.
7. I do not understand that the difference is material as re-
gards the requirements of the claims, as in either case the flame
passes longitudinally through the hood and in contact with the
pavement. From the word “horizontally” I understand that this

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 299

is the general direction of the flame as called for in the claims
where that word is used. Claim 2 calls for the burners arranged
to discharge into the other or closed end of the hood without any
jimitation as to the flames being horizontal. Under the terms
of this claim as well as under the terms of claim 3, the burners
might be arranged at an angle and yet the combination would
come within the terms of these claims.

Claim 3 calls for perforations in the closed end of the ho!
and burners arranged to discharge into the hood through such

perforations. I understand that this relates to the specific
382 arrangement of burners outside of the hood opposite perfora-

tions in the closed end, the flame or gas from the burner pass-
ing through the perforations before entering the hood.

Claim 4 embodies the additional element of the supply pipe
which of course is implied in the other claims, but it requires that
the same shall be disposed underneath the hood, and I under-
stand that thereby the oil passing through the pipe is oxidized by
the heat of the pipe imparted by the flames from the burners.
Claim 5 also calls for the supply pipe passing beneath the hood
and has the further limitation that the pipe shall extend and ter-
minate at a point beyond one end of the hood.

Claims 1, 2, 3 have no limitation as to the portabiiicy of the ap-
paratus, and any hood which had the other features of the said
claims combined with it would be in the combination called for in
the said claims. I recognize, however, to come within the gen-
eral requirements of the said patent, the apparatus should be cap-
able of transportation from place to place upon the pavement as .
required, but without any limitation as to any particular means
of mounting the apparatus. Claims 4 and 5 call for a portably
mounted reservoir which I understand to require that some means
as, for instance, wheels or runners, shall be provided whereby the
reservoir and the parts combined therewith can be readily shifted
in position. Referring to Complainant’s Exhibit Defendants’ De-
vice, as shown in “Complainant’s Exhibit Defendants’ Device,”
I find therein the following elements of the claims of patent 560,-
599. I find that said Defendants’ Device is an apparatus for re-
pairing asphaltic pavements. I find therein a hood which is open

at one end and closed at the other as well as at the top and
383 sides. I find that the closed end of the hood has two perfor-
ations therein. I find that there are two burners and that the
said burners are arranged to discharge horizontally into the hood,
that is, they project through the openings in the end of the hood

300 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. V8.

‘so that the flame passes horizontally substantially the whole length
of the hood or can do so if of sufficient length. I find a supply pipe
which leads from a reservoir, and I find that it is disposed under-
neath the hood so that the flames from the burners will cause the
same to be heated. I also find that the supply pipe terminates at
a point beyond one end of the hood and is connected with the
burners. I also find that the reservoir is portably mounted upon
wheels so that the reservoir and parts combined therewith can be
readily carried from place to place, and I also find that in use thé
hood will confine the heat within its own limits as specified in the
claims, that the burners are not in position to be affected by the
heat, that the hood may rest directly upon the surface of the pave-
ment, and that the burners need not be provided with valves.
While I do not find that the defendants’ apparatus has burners ar-
ranged to discharge into the hood through the perforations at the
end literally as described and illustrated in the drawings of the
Perkins patent 560,599, I do find that they are arranged to dis-
charge into the hood. and that the gases discharged by the burners
are conducted thereby through the perforations so as to effect all
that would be required if the burners were set back with their
ends a short distance outside of the end of the hood and opposite
the perforations and I fail to recognize any practical difference in
the slight difference in the position of the burners. The same
result would ensue in both cases practically, and I must consider

then substantially the same thing. If the Court should con-
384 strue the claim literally, however, to require that the gases

from the burners must leave the burners before passing
through the openings, then in that case I would not find the com-
bination of claim 3 in Defendants’ construction.

Adjourned to Friday, Feb. 25, 1898, at 10:30 a. m.
Washington, D. C., Friday, Feb. 25, 1898, 10:30 a. m.

Met pursuant to adjournment.

Parties present as before.

Q. 14. Please compare with the patent in suit No. 560,599 and
with the invention described and claimed therein, the U. S. Let-
ters Patents set up by Defendants as showing the prior state of
the art and state whether you find in any of said patent, the inven-
tion described and claimed in the said patent in suit, or whether

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 301

find therein any construction embodying any claims of said
tent in suit, in your opinion?

A. Ihave made the comparisons called for and will refer to the
different Letters Patent seriatim.

Craig’s patent 8701. This shows the plate mounted on runners
and carrying the fire box through which a blast is directed to
carry the hot gases below the fire box onto the grass, weeds, etc.
Comparing this with the Perkins claims, it does not show any
hood, the space below the plate being. open at both ends and in-
capable of confining heat longitudinally nor does it show any burn-
ers or any means of directing flame horizontally.

Bogia’s patent 5697. This is an apparatus for removing snow
provided with a platform, the space below which is not enclosed

in any way. The platform supports a blast furnace which
385 directs gases downward in front of the platform. This ap-

paratus does not enibody the hood or the confining heating
space or the burners of the claims of the Perkins patent.

Waterbury’s patent 145,822. This is a snow melting machine
having a platform below which are sides E and a front G with
a furnace above through which a blast is driven downward into a
space below the platform. This shows a hood with a space closed
at the top sides and one end, but it does not show or embody any
burners arranged horizontally or otherwise nor any means for di-
recting discharged gases horizontally nor does it show any reser-
voir or pipe leading therefrom and to burners as called for in the
Perkins claims.

Waterbury’s patent 157,559 in its general structure is like that
of patent 145,822, but there is an arrangement for discharging
steam jets into hydrocarbon burners driving the flame vertically
downward. There is no arrangement of burners to discharge hor-
izontally or into the end of the hood either from the outside or
within the same, nor is there any supply pipe arranged beneath the
hood as called for in the claims of the Perkins patent.

Hayes’ patent 169,439. This is a device for burning paint from
painted surfaces and consists of a burner at the end of a pipe C
which is coiled so that the flames from the burner shall pass across
the coil inside of a conical flame tube B. These parts together
constitute practically the burner which is supplied from a reser-
voir. The end of the burner extends into a guard or shield D con-
sistiug of a flat plate bent down at opposite sides. Assuming that
I can term the guard plate or shield a hood, it is not a hood closed

B02 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. VS.

at the sides and one end, nor is it provided with an end hay.
386 ing perforations, nor is there any supply pipe extending be.

neath the hood, as called for in the claims of the Perkins
patent. The flame tube B cannot be considered the hood, as it ig
practically a part of the burner. Assuming, however, that it is to
be compared with the hood of the Perkins patent, it is not closed
at one end as called for, nor is it open at the bottom.

Kendrick’s patent 184,628. This is an apparatus for melting
snow from tracks and corresponds with the apparatus of the Craig
patent 8701 in its general features, except that it is upon wheels
instead of runners and is open at its forward end with burners F
directing the flame downward. The burners are arranged in what
is termed a combustion chamber “T,” which seems to be an oblong
box suspended by bolts #, Fig. 3. This, I understand, is enclosed
at the top and on all sides. I do not find in this construction the
hood open at one end only or burners arranged to discharge into
the end of the hood either from the inside or outside or perfora-
tions for the passage of burners discharging horizontally, nor a
supply pipe to heat a hood communicating with the burners.

Zimmerling patent 269,368. This is a combined flat iron and
heater, the heater having a burner at F, F’ supplied with oil from
an elevated reservoir and directing the flame into a feed tube C2
which is connected with the burner. The burner and tube are
passed through an opening in the rear wall of the flat iron which is
a practically closed box except for the purpose of air holes A’ and
the rear hole for the passage of the burner and which is reversible
so that the top when sufficiently heated by the flame from the -
burner can be brought underneath. In other words, the burner

acts to heat the top of the box which is the reverse of the
387 action of the flame from the burners in the Perkins apparatus.

I find nothing in this flat iron structure corresponding to the
hood open at the bottom and one end or the combination of such
a hood and end burners or burner as called for in the claims of the
Perkins patent, I do not find the supply pipe arranged to be heated
by the burner but no claim is made for this by itself and apart from
the particular combination in the Perkins patent.

Curl’s patent 383,346. This also shows a flat iron consisting of
a reversible block into which a burner extends through a hole
in the rear the flame from the burner heating the supply pipe.
The remarks I have made concerning the structure of Zimmer-
ling’s patent 269,368 apply equally to that of Curl’s patent 383,-
346.

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 308

Risdon & Toliver patent 531,648. This is an apparatus for fir-
ing grass. There is no hood but two side guards A’, A’ the space
between them being open at top, bottom, and end. There are
burners B near the center of this space supplied from a reservoir.
I do not find in this structure any hood or any burners discharging
into a hood, nor any perforations in the end of a hood, nor any
supply pipe beneath a hood and communicating with burners as
called for in the claims of the Perkins patent

Considering these various patents together I do not find that
any one of them embodies the combination of any one of the
claims of the Perkins patent, nor that they set forth a structure
which is capable of use like that of the Perkins patent in suit for
the purpose of projecting a flame or flames horizontally over a
pavement confining the heat to the pavement without heating the
burners and affording a proper supply of air for combustion to the

burners. I find that some of the apparatus have hood, more
388 or less open and means for directing air blasts downward but

these would not remedy the difficulties which were remedied
by the structure of the Perkins patent in suit, as set forth therein.
Further, their use would be attended with great danger of such ©
unequal action as would burn one part of the pavement while in.
sufficiently heating another, and I fail to find anything in any one
of the structures or in all together that would naturally suggest to
anyone skilled in the art the use of the combinations or any of
them set forth in the claims of the Perkins patent in suit.

I can state as within my own knowledge that the construction
of said Perkins patent 560,599 was only arrived at after a large
number of experiments with preceding structures extending over
a considerable time and involving quite a large amount of expense,
and I have myself seen large numbers of these discarded and ex-
perimental or partly experimental structures among waste ma-
terial in the shops.

Counsel for complainant here offers in evidence the sketch
referred to by the witness in his answer to Q. 4, on page 10
of the typewritten record, and the same is marked “Com-
plainant’s Exhibit Foster Sketch.”

Counsel for complainant also offers in evidence the several
samples referred to by the witness on pages 27 and 33 of the
typewritten record under the titles designated by the wit-
ness, as follows:

“Complainant’s Exhibit Rock Asphalt Powder.”
“Complainant’s Exhibit Powdered Rock Asphalt after
Heating.”

304 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. VS.

389 “Complainant’s Exhibit Compressed Rock Asphalt.”
“Complainant’s Exhibit Asphait Mixture.”

Counsel for complainant, in view of the proofs of defendant
as to the character of the valve K of defendants’ machine, and
as illustrated in Complainant's Exhibit Drawing Defendants
Device, notice is hereby given on the record that infringement
of Letters Patent in suit No. 542,349, apparatus for repairing
asphalt pavement, granted A. H. Perkins July 9, 1895, will
not be further urged in this suit, and that at a proper time,
of which defendants will be given notice, leave will be asked
of the court to dismiss as to so much of complainant's bill as
relates to said patent, without prejudice.

Mr. Peirce—Defendants" solicitor denies the right of com-
plainant to dismiss its bill in respect to patent No. 542,349
“without prejudice”; the issue being framed in respect to the
infringement of said patent defendants are entitled to have
such issues tried along with the others unless it be conceded
that the defendants’ device does not evade said patent.

Counsel for complainant not having been afforded an op-
portunity for examining all of the apparatus used by the de-
fendants, is unable to concede as to any apparatus regarding
which it is not now informed. In view of the objection made
by counsel for defendants, counsel for complainant desires to
withdraw his notice on the record as to patent No. 542,349.

Cross-Examination by Mr. Peirce.

X-Q. 15. It appears in evidence that “The Barber Asphalt
Paving Co.,” a corporation under the laws of West Virginia,
390 is a licensee under the Perkins patent here in suit; what, if
any, professional relation do yoy sustain towards said com-
pany?
A. I have for several years been one of the solicitors and ex-
perts for the Barber Company.
X-Q. 16. Who is the President of the company,
Objected to as irrevelant and immaterial, and also as in-
competent. :
A. Col. F. V. Greene is President, I believe.
X-Q. 17. Has that company a general office in New York City?
A. It has.
X-Q. 18. At one time Col. Greene was an engineer commis-
sioner of the District of Columbia, was he not?

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY.

A. I believe that he was from what I have heard. I never met
him in that capacity.

X-Q. 19. How long to your knowledge has Col. Greene been
connected with the Barber Company?

A. To my knowledge about three years, how much longer, I
don’t know.

X-Q. 20. Do you regard him to be competent authcority on the
subject of asphalt pavements?

A. Upon some points possibly. Of course he is an engineer
and I understood that he has given the subject of asphalt pave-
ments a good deal of attention. Whether or not he is competent
to speak of details of such matters from actual personal operations
I do not know.

X-Q. 21. As the term “asphalt mixture” is used in the course

of your testimony, I understand that it covers a compound
391 of asphalt, a tempering material—such as petroleum residuum
—and heated sand. Am I correct?

A. Generally speaking, yes. The asphalt is generally refined,
and sometimes there may be a little stone dust.

X-Q. 22. In about what proportions are these several ingre-
dients admixed?

A. The amount of petroleum and residuum to the asphalt
forming what is called the cement will vary somewhat according
to the character of the pavement intended and the geographical
location. You may assume generally 10 per cent of residuum.
The cement and sand are used, roughly speaking, in the proportion
of 15 of cement to 85 of sand.

X-Q. 23. Compare the geographical location of Buffalo with
that of Washington. For the same traffic, in which pavement
would the residuum enter in larger proportion?

A. There would be less residuum in the warmer climate. The
difference is very slight, generally not over three or four per cent
between extreme climates, and different parties have different
views as to the proper proportions.

X-Q. 24. Speaking in round numbers, according to the general
data just stated by answer, am I to understand that the asphalt
mixture as a whole consists of about 15 per cent asphalt, 8 per
cent residuum and 77 per cent sand; am I correct?

A. Approximately that would be the proportion of the ingre-
dients put into the mixture; undoubtedly in the course of heating

and laying and also in the course of use a certain proportion
392 of the residuum or the more volatile elements thereof would
disappear.

306 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. V8.

X-Q. 25. What is the object of adding the residuum to the re-
fined asphalt?

A. It was found upon making the first experiments with as-
phalt mixtures in laying pavements that the pavements would
flake off and crack, especially in cold weather, and the use of pe-
troleum oil and petroleum residuum was finally resorted to to cor-
rect this defect, and after the proper proportions were discovered
proved to be effective. It was some years after pavements began
to be laid before these facts were fully approved and recognized.

X-Q. 26. In making up the asphalt mixture, you speak of the
use of “hot” sand; why should the sand be hot?

A. In most instances the sand is received in a wet condition,
sometimes so wet that the water runs from it, and one of the most
difficult problems in making asphalt pavemei ts is to get the sand
dry, because the presence of any moisture prevents adhesion be-
tween the particles of sand and the asphalt. Naturally in this
drying operation the sand becomes heated. Assuming the same
to be absolutely dry, I know of no other reason for heating it ex-
cept to prevent it from chilling the melted asphalt.

X-Q. 27. In preparing mixture, the residuum is heated and the
refined asphalt added thereto; at what temperature does this
occur?

A. No; the asphalt is melted and the residuum is then added
and mixed with it. I have forgotten the boiling point of the as-
phalt. Residuum is of course in a liquid state or semi-liquid
state.

X-Q. 28. When the so-called “asphalt cement” is thus
393 formed, at what temperature is it maintained when the hot
sand is admixed? :

A. The mixture itself as I have tested it after the sand is added
will run as high as 250 degrees. I believe the usual regulations
of contractors require that it shall be brought to and dumped
on the pavement at not less than 300 degrees. If the temperature
is reduced much below this it becomes hard and solid before
spreading and cannot be raked or spread by means of rakes and
other tools used.

X-Q. 29. When this asphalt cement is heated in readiness to
receive the sand addition, what is the consistency of such mix-
ture?

A. About that of West India molasses. That is about as good
a comparison as I can make. It is not so fluid as heavy oil, but
will run freely when hot.

ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 307

X-Q. 30. The “refined asphalt” which is used as an ingredient
of these pavement mixtures; what is this?

A. It has been derived from different sources. For the best
pavements in the United States, asphalt from the Island of Trini-
dad is used and after being heated to permit the settling of the
impurities is poured into barrels and becomes so hard that it will
retain its shape after the staves are knocked from the barrels, al-
though it will soften under heat during warm days and finally
spread in a layer of four of five inches on anv flat surface.

X-Q. 31. How does this refined asphalt differ, if at all, chemi-
cally, from “glance pitch” or “mineral bitumen”?

A. I am not sufficient of a chemist to testify on that point,

but I can state within my own knowledge that a very large
394 number of bituminous substances which to the eye and ordin-

ary physical tests seem to be practically the same as Trini-
dad asphalt, are utterly unsuitable as a substitute therefor in the
making of asphalt pavements. Generally speaking, when I have
had these articles tested, I have been informed that the proportion
of bitumen was insufficient. While I have seen such tests made,
1 am not sufficient of a chemist to point out the differences or
their chemical effects.

Noon recess.

X-Q. 32. About what per cent. of bitumen is present in refined
Trinidad asphalt?

A. I have never gone carefully into the chemistry of asphalt
so as to be able to answer this question. I have had various an-
alyses of asphalt made and reports made to me as to the amount
of bitumen, but I have forgotten the proportions.

X-Q. 34. Do you know the relative proportions of the asphal-
tine and petroline present in the bitumen contents of such refined
asphalt?

A. I can I think fully inform you as to the use of asphalt
in making pavements, but I am not a chemist and do not know
anything about the various chemical constituents of these sub-
stances.

X-Q. 35. Aside from the Trinidad variety, what other forms of
refined asphalt have you had occasion to consider in connection
with their use as an ingredient of asphalt mixtures for pave-
ments?

A. The Trindad is used almost exclusively for the best class
of pavements. The asphalt first used in the United States for lay-
ing pavements was brought from Virginia and used under the

308 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. VS.

“names of Grahamite and Ritchie asphalt, being taken from Ritchie
County, Virginia. It proved however to be simply a pocket
395 which soon became exhausted: Of late years, some asphalts
have been brought from California, and one or two western
states, but so far as I have information on the subject, they are
not equal to the Trinidad asphalt in making a durable pavement.
1 do not know of any others being actually used, although constant
experiments are being made with bituminous deposits from differ-
ent places.
’ X&-Q. 36. Your practical knowledge of refined asphalt as used
for pavements extends to what varieties thereof?
' A. The only refined asphalt which I have had any personal ex-
perience with has been the Trinidad asphalt.

X-Q. 37. I believe there is upon the market a variety known as
Bermudez asphalt. If the pavement mixture contained the Ber-
mudez in lie

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386018_0761%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
