# Transcript of Record — Joseph Schlitz Brewing Co. v. United States

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386018_0701%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1901
- **Citation:** 181 U.S. 584

## Text

(17,692. )

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

OCTOBER TERM, 1899.

No. 578.

THE JOSEPH SCHLITZ BREWING COMPANY,
APPELLANT,

Us.
THE UNITED STATES.

APPEAL FROM THE COURT OF CLAIMS.

INDEX

Original. Print.
PS ROL deh visit saawss oS ec daveb cvsee~ Bis oseeever 1 1
EINE Uo scu bse sass RR he peo Oe has Saat 5 4
CEES ies 205 their right to recover drawback also on the bottles and
corks.

On the entries so made for exportation of bottled beer manufact-
ured exclusively from foreign hops, barley, bottles and corks from
the Ist day of February, in the year 1893, to the 26th day of
October in the year 1894, the total amount of drawback on the hops
and barley, being the amount of duties paid thereon less the legal
retention of one (1) per cent., was two thousand three hundred and
seventy-one dollars and thirty-five cents ($2,371.35), and on botiles
and corks nine thousand eight hundred and seventeen dollars and

——e

4 THE JOSEPH SUHLITZ BREWING Co, vs.

niuety-seven cents ($9,817.97), making a total of drawback due on

such exportations, twelve thousand ove hundred aud eiglity-nine

dollars and thirty-two cents ($12,189.32), which amount the claim.

ant hereby claims.

. No other action than as aforesaid has been had on this claim ip

Congress or by any of the departments.

_ The claimant is the sole owner of this claim and the only person

interested therein; and no assignment or transfer of this claim, or
of any part thereof or interest therein, has been made.

4 The claimant is justly entitled to the amount herein
claimed from the United States, after allowing all just

GEORGE A. & WM. B. KING,

Attorneys for Claimant.

_ Stare or Wisconsin, has :
City and County of Milwaukee, ;

August Uihlein, secretary of the Jos. Sehlitz Brewing (Co.. the
claimant corporation, being duly sworn, deposes and says: I am
secretary of the Jos. Schlitz Brewing Co., the claimant in this ease.
I have read the above petition, and the matters therein Stated are
true, to the best of my knowledge and belief.

; AUGUST UIHLEIN,

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 17th day of January,

1898.
EUGENE W UESTHOFF,
[SEAL. ] Notary Public, Milwaukee Co., Wis.
5 II.— Traverse. Filed November 8, 1899.

And now comes the Attorney General, on behalf of the United
States, and, answering the petition of the claimant herein, denies
each and every allegation therein contained, and asks judgment
that the said petition be dismissed.

And as to so much of the said petition as avers that the said
claimaut has at all times borne true faith . ud allegiance to the
Government of the United States, and has not in any way volun-
tarily aided, abetted, or given encouragement to rebellion against
the said Government, the Attorney General, in pursuance of the
statute in such case provided, denies the said allegations, and asks

judgment accordingly.

L. A. PRADT,
Assistant Attorney General.

—

THE UNITED STATES.

6 11 1.—Findings ef Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Opinion.
Filed January 15, 1900.
Findings of Fact.

The following are the facts of the case as found by the court:

L The claimant isa corporation, organized under the laws of the
State of Wisconsin.

IL. Between the Ist day of February, 1893, and the 26th day of
October, 1894, the claimant exported from the port of Milwaukee,
Wis., bottled beer. The hops, barley, bottles, and corks used in
the manufacture of this bottled beer had been imported into the
United States from foreign countries, and duties had been paid
thereon upon importation. The bottled beer was manufactured
by the claimant at Milwaukee, Wis. The imported materials used
in the manufacture, when exported, were identified, the quantity
of the materials used and the amount of duties paid thereon ascer-
tained, and the fact of the manufacture of the articles in the United
States and their exportation were determined under regulations
prescribed by the Secretary of the Treasury. The total amount of
the duties paid on the materials mentioned so used and exported
was $12,189.32, divided as follows: Upon the bottles and corks,
$9,817.97 ; upon the hops and barley, $2,371 35.

Ill. The Treasury Department has not refused to pay the draw-
back upon the hops and barley, but such drawback could be paid
under the regulations of the department. It refuses to pay the
drawback upon the bottles and corks for the reason stated in the
following official letter dated March 24, 1895:

“TrpeASURY DEPARTMENT, March 24, 1893.

“Str: The department is in receipt of your letter of the 15th
instant, relative to the application of the Anheuser-Buseh Brewing
Association of St. Louis, Mo., for an allowance of drawback on im-
ported corks and tinfoil used, together with domestic bottles, in the
bottling of beer for export.

“The applicants represent that such corks and tinfoil are im-
ported materials used in the manufacture of bottled beer and are
therefore entitled to drawback under section 25 of the act of October
1, 1890, and they allege that such drawback is and has been allowed
at your port.

“You state that under existing law no claims on bottled beer
where the bottles are of domestic production, have been made at
your port.

“Tt appears, however, that in view of the department’s decision
of March 3, 1886 (synopsis 7445), authorizing allowance of draw-
back on imported bottles and corks used in bottling beer made
wholly from imported materials, under section 3019, Revised
Statutes, whick seems to have been based upon the assumption that
bottles and corks are ‘materials’ used in the manufacture of bottled
beer, your office would hold that the imported corks and tinfoil i

6 THE JOSEPH SCHLITZ BREWING Co, ys.

question are entitled to drawback under section 25 of the act of Oc.
tober 1, 1890, were it not for a more recent decision, viz. (Synopsis
10301, of October 28, 1890), that ‘ Imported bottles used in the bot.
tling of fermented liquors made in the United States wholly from
domestic grain and hops are not entitled, on the exportation of
such bottled beer. to drawback under the provisions of section 95
of the act of October 1, 1890.’

“In reply, you are informed that said decision of October 28,

has been reached.

“The department therefore decides that the present application
must be denied, and the earlier decisions authorizing allowance of
drawback on imported bottles, corks, and tinfoil used in bottling
beer for export are accordingly rescinded.

“ Respectfully yours, O. L. SPA ULDING,

“ Acting Secretary.
“ (28269.)

“Collector of customs, New York.”

IV. The Treasury Department, on March 31, 1886, rendered the
following decision :
“ TREASURY Department, March 31, 1886.
“Sir: On the exportation of beer manufactured wholly of im-
ported materials, bottled in imported bottles and corked with im-
vorted corks, a drawback will be allowed for the hops, rice, and
arley used in the manufacture at the rate prescribed by the de-
partment’s letter to you of the 25th instant, and for the bottles and
corks at the rate of duty paid thereon, less the legal retention of
10 per cent.
“ Respectfully yours, C. 8. FAIRCHILD,
“ Acting Secretary.
“Collector of customs, New York.”

7 The following is a circular issued by the Treasury Depart-
ment on August 17, 1886, so far as relates to this question:

“ TREASURY Department, August 17, 1886.
“The following list of drawback rates is published for the in-
formation of customs officers and all others concerned.
"&. & FAIRCHILD,
“ Acting Secretary.
“Collectors of customs and others.

“Alphabeticai list of drawback rates established under the author-
ity of sections 3019, 3020, and 3026 of the Revised Statutes, and
the acts of February 8 and March 3, 1875.

cad 1 * * * * *
“ Bottles and corks, imported, used in bottling beer made from
imported materials, samme as duty paid.”
cd * * *

; a4
7

THE UNITED STATES.

V. The rule announced in the official statements contained in
the foregoing finding remained in force until the following ruling
of October 25, 1890, was made by the Treasury Department:

“TREASURY DEPARTMENT, October 28, 1890.

“GeNTLEMEN: In reply to your letter of the 13th instant, you
are informed that, in the opinion of this department, imperted
pottles used in the bottling of fermented liquors made in the United
Siates, wholly from domestic grain and hops, are not entitled on
the exportation of such bottled beer to drawback under the pro-
visions of section 95 of the act of October 1, 1890, referred to by
you.

? “ Respectfully yours, QO. L. SPAULDING,
“ Assistant Secretary.

“ Messrs. Larzelere & Co., Philadelphia, Pa.”

VI. The manufacture of beer is a complicated process involving
many different steps, consisting substantially of the foliowing :

1. Washing, cleaning, steeping, and sprouting the barley.

9. Drying, storing, and crushing the barley, removing the
sprouts, and crushing the malt.

3. Making the mash by mixing the malt with water and raising
the temperature and drawing off the resulting liquor or wort.

4, Boiling the wort, adding hops, and reboiling.

5. Cooling the wort and mixing it with yeast.

6. Fermenting the wort, thereby making beer.

7. Storing the beer to produce desired chemical changes.

8. Clarifying the beer in casks by the use of chips and isinglass
and carbonating, for this purpose using a solution of young beer
called “ krausen.”

9, Racking the beer into barrels, if to be bottled ; otherwise it is
drawn directly into kegs.

VII. The manufacture of beer for bottling for export differs from
the manufacture for ordinary domestic use both because the ma-
terials must be selected with greater care, and the process must be
conducted differently in order that the bottled product may keep
without change under varying conditions of climate, temperature,
position, and transportation, and the beer preserve purity and
clearness under all such varying conditions. ‘Turbidity of bottled
beer made for exportation must especially be avoided, as this ren-
ders the beer commercially unsalable. This is chiefly caused by
the precipitation of albuminoids contained iv the beer, and the
differences in the process of manufacture between domestic beer
and bottled beer for export are chiefly intended for the elimination
of these albuininoids. It may also be caused by the germination
of living yeast cells, and this is prevented by the process of pasteur-
ization.

VIII. The differences may be summarized as follows:

In the process of malting a specially complete development of
the angospern is necessary and the process must be conducted very

——

8 THE JOSEPH SCHLITZ BREWING co. Vs.

carefully. In drying the malt the raising of the temperature jg
very slow and the process takes longer than in the case of ordinary
keg beer. The mashing is conducted at a higher temperature and
occupies a longer time. The malt must be stored for at least two
months for bottled beer for export, as against about three weeks for

the ability of the beer to Stay clear under all conditions. In the
cooling process, which consists of running the beer over cold pipes
in a glass inclosure into which filtered air is pumped, a stronger
draft of air is required, in order to impregnate the wort With a
larger quantity of oxygen to produce a higher fermentation and
consequently fewer albuminoids. The subsequent fermentation
process requires a longer time with bottled beer for export than
With keg beer and the temperature is not allowed to rise as high,
A higher attenuating yeast is used for the manufacture of bottled
r, taking out more albuminoids than the low attenuating yeast
used in the manufacture of keg beer. The beer requires longer
storage.
8 The quality of the beer prepared for bottling when iy
barrels prior to bottling differs from the keg beer at the
same stage in the fact that the keg beer has more albuminoids in
it, aud these give it a bread-like taste, described as palate fullness,
and increase its form-holding capacity. This is recognized asa
valuable quality in keg beer, and the absence of this quality is ree.
ognized as a detriment, unavoidable in beer bottled for export
because of the necessity for eliminating the albuiinoids.

IX. After beer intended for bottling for export is placed in the
barrels the following processes occur:

The barrels are hoisted to the required height of the filling ma-
chine, the stamp is taken off, canceled, and replaced, the keg is
opened, a faucet entered in the lower hole, and the beer drawn from
the barrel into the filling machine and through a proper disposal
of siphons into the bottles. The bottles are then sent to the cork-
ing machines and corked; a thin metal cap is placed over the cork
for the protection of the cork and a Wire attached to the neck of
the bottle and wound over the cork. The bottles are then placed
in the steaming boxes and these boxes carried to a steaming vat
which is filled with water and steam turned into the water, raising
its temperature to about 150° and remaining at that temperature
for about one hour, when it is cooled down to about 80° or 90°.
This process, known as pasteurizing, is for the purpose of destroy-
ing living yeast cells and is necessary for beer bottled for export.

P 2456

THE UNITED STATES.

This pasteurization may be omitted ia the case of bottled beer
for local use.

The bottles, previous to their use, undergo a special washing
process with hot water and soda so arranged that the bottles are
filled and emptied continuously. They are then washed in a tank
filled with luke-watm water on the outside by hand and on the
inside by brushes in the washing machine, and then rinsed with
cold water before being placed in the racks to be filled.

Old as well as new bottles are used.

X. In making bottled beer, from the time of purchase of the
ingredients until the completion of the finished product the process
must be so managed as to diminish the albuminoids. When pre-
pared as stated in the foregoing findings, bottled beer can stand
the heat at the equator without being spoiled.

XI. Beer bottled for export is understood to be beer intended for
shipment, whether to domestic or foreign points, and for use other
than local and immediate. When beer is bottled for local and im-
mediate use, it may be the same beer as hereinbefore described and
prepared in the same manner as for export, including pasteurization,
or it may be the same beer prepared in the same manner without
pasteurization, or it may be ordinary keg beer, differing from bot-
tled beer for export in the particulars described in findings VII
and VIII, and without pasteurization.

XII. When bottled beer is sold to retailers, it is delivered in
cases of bottles, and an extra charge is made to the purchaser for
the case and bottles, which charge is credited to his account on the
return of the case and bottles. A similar practice obtains on the
sale of the bottled beer by the case by retailers to their consumers.

Conclusion of Law.

Upon the foregoing findings of fact the court decide, as a
conclusion of law, that the claimant recover the sum of $2,371.35.

Opinion.

Nort, Ch. J., delivered the opinion of the court:

The position of the claimant is in substance this:

The general purpose of the legislation involved in this suit is
the imposition of customs duties which, incidentally, shall benefit
domestic manufacturers and producers and their workmen. That
benefit can accrue only in one way—by increasing the market
price of articles manufactured or produced. The principle, stand-
ing by itself, extends no farther than the domestic markets of the
country. So soon as the manufactured article seeks a foreign mar-
ket the action of the tariff is reversed and what was a benefit be-
comes an injury, and the person helped is the foreign manufact-
urer and not the American. In the foreign market the American
manufacturer labors under three disadvantages—he must pay
greater prices for domestic materials; he must pay duties on im-
ported materials; he must pay higher wages to his workmen.

2—578

ry

10 THE JOSEPH SCHLITZ BREWING CO. vs,

Henicé; in the foreign market he canuot compete with the foreign

manufacturer, who, manufacturing at less cost, can underse]] him.

To that extent the protective legislation benefits the foreign many.
facturer.

9 The true constituents of a purely and strictly protective
law must be that the American manufacturer shall mann. |

facture from American products for the American market, and

thereby help the American producer as well as himself. But the

materials coming into the country practically duty free. It is
manifest that if this favorable legistation is intended to put the
American manufacturer on an equal footing with his foreign com-
titor in foreign markets it must be as broad as the articles which

1€ manufactures, or, rather, as broad as the imported materials

‘Which he uses, so that anything and everything which enters into
the cost of production shall be absolutely free from the additional

In the case now before us it is manifest that the manufacturer
was compelled either to use bottles manufactured iu this country or
to import bottles upon which he had paid duties. As a matter of
fact he resorted to the latter alternative. He claims that these
bottles are materials used in the manufacture of bottled beer; and
it is but just to Say that he shows that this beer is manufactured
expressly for bottling and for exportation ; that it cannot be pre-
served and exported in any other way, and that from one point of
view the bottle is as much an element of the intended product as
the peculiar kind of beer which it contains. The manufacturer
maintains that these duties will preclude him from competing in
foreign markets with foreign brewers, contrary to what he believes
to be the legislative intent, decause he cannot manufacture this
kind of beer for exportation without bottles, and cannot afford to
pay duties on bottles when his competitors do not.

Nevertheless, if the intention was to put the American manufact- ,
urer upon an equal footing with the foreign manufacturer in for-
eign markets, the legislation of Congress has been imperfect and
incomplete, and the courts, moreover, have deemed themselves
confined to the words of the statutes when ascertaining the legisla-
tive intent.

The siguiticant words of this act are “that where imported ma-
terials on which duties have been paid are used in the mauufacture
of articles” “there shall be allowed on the exportation of such
articles a drawback equal in amount to the duties paid on the ma-
terials used.” (Act Ist October, 1890, 26 Stat. L., p. 617, § 25.)

~~.

In the same case on appeal Mr. Justice Brown elucidates the dif-
ferent meanings which may be given to the word “ materials,” and
he points out that logs are manufactured into boards and boards
are fashioned into boxes; that the steel spring of a watch is
made from iron ore, but by a number of processes or transforma-
and that each successive step is a distinct process bringing
forth an article which receives a new and different name; and he
draws the general conclusion “that the finished product of one
manufacturer becomes the waterial of the next in rank.” (171 U.S.
R., 210-216.)

In the case of the United States v. Allen (163 U.S. R., 499) the
court held that the drawback authorized by this statute does not
extend to imported coal, considered as an article for consump-
tion ; aud the reasoning of the court leads to the conclusion that
the right to a drawback must rest on an exported “ article” com-

sed, in whole or in part, of imported “materials.” It may be
true that the bottles are as essential in the mauufacture of bottled
beer as the barley and hops of which the beer is made, but the
barley and hops whed they are imported are not beer, while the
bottles are bottles and as complete before the American
brewer uses them as when they are exported. We may infer
from the decisions that if he bad imported glass and manufactured
the glass into bottles, he would have had a good claim for drawback
as to any duties which had been paid upon the glass; but it must
be held, under the authorities cited, that bottles are a finished
product and not “ materials used” in that combination which is
the subject or basis of the present suit.

The judgment of the court is that the claimant recover the draw-
back on barley set forth in the foregoing findings, to wit, the sum

of $2,371.35.

THE UNITED STATES. 1l

tions,

10 1V.—Judgment of the Court.

THe JoserH Scuiitz BREWING Co.
vs No. 20976.

Tae Unrrep States.

Ata Court of Claims held in the city of Washington on the 15th
a January, 1900, judgment was ordered to be entered up as fol-
ows:

Tue court, upon due consideration of the premises, find in favor
of the claimant, and do order and adjudge and decree that the said
Joseph Schlitz Brewing Company have and recover of and from the
United States the sum of two thousand three hundred and seventy-

oue dollars and thirty-five cents ($2,371.35).
By trae COURT.

12 THE JOSEPH SCHLITZ BREWING CO. VS. THE UNITED STATES,

11 V.—Apptication for Apneal.
Filed March 22, 1900.
In the Court of Claims, Term 1899-1900,

THE Josepu Scuiitz Brewin Co.
vs. No. 20976.
THE Unrrep Strares.

Now comes the claimant herein, by its attorneys, George A. &
William B. King, and prays an appeal to the Supreme Court of the
United States from the judgment of this court entered on the 15th
day of January, 1900, sc far as the same is adverse to its claim, and

the claimant moves the court for an allowance of this appeal,

GEORGE A. & WILLIAM B. KING.
Attorneys for Claimant.

VI.—Allowance of A ppeal.

At a Court of Claims held in the city of Washington on the 22nd
of March, 1900, it was ordered that the foregoing application for an
appeal be allowed as prayed for.

By rHe COURT.

12 In the Court of Claims.

Tue Josepn Scauirz Brewine Uompany
vs. } No. 20976.
Tue Untrep Srares.

I, John Randolph, assistant clerk of the Court of Claims, do
hereby certify that the foregoing are true transcripts of the plead-
ings in the above-entitled cause, the findings of fact by the court,
the conclusions of law thereon, and the opinion of the court, of
the judgment of the court, of the application for and allowance of
an appeal to the Supreme Court of the United States,

In testimony whereof I have hereunto set my hand and affixed
the seal of said cou rt, at Washington, this 27th day of March, 1900,

[Seal Court of Claims. ]
JOHN RANDOLPH,
Assistant Clerk Court of Claims.

Endorsed on cover: File No., 17,692. Court of Claims. Term —
No., 578. The Joseph Sclilitz Brewing Company, appellant, vs. :
The United States. Filed March 27th, 1900. 4

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386018_0701%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
