# Transcript of Record — Sigafus v. Porter

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386018_0541%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1900
- **Citation:** 179 U.S. 116

## Text

(16.821.)

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER ‘TERM, 1s0o9.

No. 48.

JAMES M. SIGAFUS, PLAINTIFF IN ERROR,
US.

DUDLEY PORTER ET AL.

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT.

INDEX.

Page.

Transcript of record from the circuit court of tie United States for the
CL ATINGEIOL OF NOW: YORK. ori nish oie ie Sia sins e dn ee csiewseun l
: TT ests SW Ah nee Taian Samadi era ates wea Ow Eee l
NG Pe ete Pe arf Siear ey a tar a eet er eta ar ere 2
eva fobs sectioned KN aha dE OR CA eye Meee eek Aeuw as 3
NE eas sh ova he sn bog neue sie vant bake eka bd dundee et ekawees 4
UA NceVipa sins. c\5cd, Pee Ee CACTAS MN SY-SEE RARE E RS as CUR bea ONCE EO ll
NE MUIIRIUU GL BIORE 5 coe iigidaik US Wate Lass Me a aceey Jan waaay 20
eee Mec UKM WIROIEIONE TON WOW CESGN a io ack ee sise Dh bn bee ee eas 0s 21
Judgment .......... bearers 20008 Vas hen sals hp sane Maio wa ee Cree 23
SIN ss ems lows Ga gk hap eieAS KAN PNA YIOR TW ERS Wee SOREN Ce 25
RC dE PRINCI regs para +o A's Vee GAS toa ae aren eee iets 26
PMNACNE CT ORNIOE 25, MOTO echo ons See Abba ps ewes ene’ 26
Belle Doran... sic terinhdae arcs et naie tee ie 36
SRE Dig I 6 0. 5 REG = 05 weiss eH 43
MINN SEI ss SiS S18 8 SF x00 SA Rew acas ian 51
We AO 85 bn hs vee a isa hake 52
FRB As WOR e555 ca sce ans dX sient ney 59
PUTS Bie OO 5 aids vor SNe KER oo 63
SOME Ba a kd so d.Ss eS eis crew FESR ces 73

CNN a MN ec dne ded Laces iw pent cules 119

INDEX.

Dep sition of John L. Hobson......0... 62...
William Foster. ...
Elbridge G. Wood

SN EIN Feels Cas sear seh s0s5es
Le ee eee Cre
Edmund H. Wilson. ..... Ee eee
Wm. H. Griffith (recalled). ........
Elbridge G. Wood (recalled)... ....
Anderson C. Moorehead. ......
Tanne NN. Boteowrt...
other enterprises in Colorado, and largely interested
in the mines in Colorado. With the report he en-
closed a letter, photgraphs, etc.

I had been engaged as manager and part owner
in property in which Col. Platt was largely inter-
ested. Mr. Morse and Mr. Platt employed me, and
beyond the price of the railroad ticket I paid every
other expense out of my own pocket. I worked
under Mr. Morse’s instructions, and he intended to
come with me besides.

Q. Then the expenses of the trip, exclusive of
the railroad fare way from Denver to Riverside and
return, and your expenses in California en route
and your services while employed in making this
so-called examination of the Good Hope Mine, a8

— —

95
John M. 8S. Egan. 283

testified to by you in your direct examination were
gratuitous on your part, were they?

A. No.

Q. Did you not state with the exception as testi-
fied to you paid all your own expenses?

A. I did.

Q. State what part of your expenses and services
were gratuitously rendered by you to Mr. Morse,
your employer, and what part you charged for, in
detail.

Well, they were practically gratuitous, except on
another occasion, if the property was satisfactory 984
Mr. Morse would help me in the purchase and re-
tain an interest.

. Then the retaining of this interest in the prop
erty was to be compensation for your services in
making the examination and the report thereon?

A. No: because I had done a good deal of such
work for Mr. Morse, and my bill of expenses had
always been paid when rendered. Idid not submit
any bills in this case. He was not in Denver on
my return from California. I was present at Mr.
McIntyre’s office in Riverside with Mr. Morse when
the title and check passed, and the property turned
over at that time. I didn’t present a bill to Mr.
Morse for services I had rendered, because he had
assisted me in obtaining an interest in the property,
and Col. Platt was also to bear part of that expense.
Through me Col. Platt became interested in the
property. In stock and notes payable to the pro-
portion, I don’t exactly remember. When my

- share of the property should liquidate notes made
by me for the purchase of stock, then Col. Platt
should have an interest in said stock.

Q. Will you swear that you didn’t know that the
property was conveyed by Sigafus to Griffith, and
that he gave back a purchase money mortgage
thereon? .

A. I heard it afterwards —was told about it.

285

——

96
286 John M. S. Egan.

Q. Were not all the details of the transfer in Mr.
McIntyre’s office discussed, and were you not then
present; and will you now swear that you didn’t
know at that time to whom Sigafus was to deed
the property, and that a mortgage was given back
to hin?

A. At this lapse of time it is hard for me abso-
lutely to »ecollect; but 1 don’t think I was present
when every detail bad been arranged, as I was out
of town at the Good Hope Mine part of the time,
yet I cannot swear that I didn’t know.

987 Q. In what way did you expect to be interested
in the mine—as a stockholder?

A. Yes. sir; I cannot swear that I didn’t read the
deed, as my recollection as to the various details is
not very strong. I will not swear that Mr. Me-
Intyre didn’t hand me the deed and explain to me,
Morse and Griffith concerning the same, together
with the other papers drawn by him at the time. I
know nothing of any papers being served by one
Maxwell on Mr. Sigafus, but knew that Maxwell
claimed a share of the commission.

Q. Don’t you know, and were you not present
when Mr. Sigafus stated to McIntyre and to your-
self, stating that he (Sigafus) was not going to

288 411 alaw suit, and didn’t care whether you pur-
chased the mine or not, as the matter has assumed
that shape that he (Sigafus) would not sell the mine
unless you and Morse gave him a bond of indem-
nity, which bond you and Morse did then and there
give, drawn by McIntyre, signed by yourself and
Morse, and acknowledged? ;

A. Any specific remarks made by Mr. Sigafus as
given in your question I do not remember, but I
remember McIntyre’s advice, as his legal adviser,
that such a bond should be given, and also remem-
ber signing it with Mr. Morse. I remember that at
that time in order to quiet Maxwell, Griffith gave
him two notes of $6,000 each, and that thereupon

97

John M. S. Egan.

Maxwell gave a release of all claims and de-
mands as to commissions, and that thereupon when
that was done Sigafus gave the deed, and that Mr.
McIntyre drew up a release under seal for Maxwell
to sign, and that he read the same to me.

Q. Now, Colonel, don’t: you know that the most
important paper in the whole batch must have been
the paper that transferred the title in the property
in which you were to become interested, as you
have testified to?

A. Yes, sir. I knew that a deed was given, and
I have since learned how it was given, and to whom
it was given, and I was satistied it was a good and
sufficient one, aS you were acting in the interest of
both parties in the transaction.

Q. What were you asked to do by Mr. Morse and
Platt when you got to the mine?

A. To thoroughly examine the Good Hope prop-
perty. and to see if the Burnham report would be
verified by such examination.

Q. What other papers were handed you besides
the Burnham report by Mr. Platt concerning this
mine?

A. In the letter enclosing the report there were
some photographs and maps, also a ietter from Mr.
Griffith to Col. Platt, asking that the property be
examined as soon as possible; and also detailing the
reasons why Mr. Sigafus desired to sell the prop-
erty, and his own delay on account of his father’s
death; the same letter contained other mining
reports.

Defendant’s counsel moves that last part of
answer be stricken out as incompetent and
secondary.

Motion denied. To which ruling of the
Court counsel for defendant then and there
duly excepted.

I never heard of Mr. Lockhardt’s having made a

a

290

291

292

293

294

98

John M. S. Egan.

report of the Good Hope Mine until within the last
year. I have never seen it., I never met Griffith
to speak to him, except a couple of weeks before
my going to examine the Good Hope Mine, and
then only fora few minutes.

(). How do you know that this (counsel handing
witness Plaintiff’s Exhibit ‘‘ A”) is the Burnham
report, or any other man’s report?

A. Because on the occasion of first meeting Mr.
Griffith to speak to him; amongst many other ques-
tions I asked him who made that report, as it was

not signed. He told me a California mining engi-

neer by the name of Burnham. The copy I re-
ceived has neither date nor signature, but from
details and statistics given I judge that it was made
earlier than 1892.

Q. If the so-called Burnham report had been
designated the Smith or Jones report, you would
have acted upon it just the same, would you not!

A. Not until I had inquired whom Smith or
Jones were, and I would alsoconsider the standing
of the party of whom I received it, and the party
owning the property. I cannot say positively when
I got the report because it came with several others,
and laid in my desk several days before | had time
to look at it, but the date of the letier was the lat-
ter part of September, or during the month of Oc-
tober, 1898. I cannot swear of my personal know]
edge that such a man as Burnham was on the
ground. Mr. Sigafus, Cheatham, W. S. Maxwell
and James B. Doran told me. I never saw any re
port on the mine but the Burnham report. Never
saw one dated July 5th. I didn’t place much
importance on the Burnham report, or any report,
until it was verified by myself, then I would.

Q. Then you wish it understood that you exam-
ined this property as a mining expert of twenty
years and over, and recommended its purchase,
based principally upon statements and figures con-

99

John M.S. Egan.

tained in a document unsigned, without date and
without seal, having no personal knowledge of the
characterof the individual, of the person whom
you say made the report, which information as to
the maker of the report, is purely hearsay?

A. Lasked what had become of the original re-
port, and was told by Griffith that it had been mis-
laid; the date was omitted as well as the name, but
that might be an error—that is, the omission of the
date made in making a copy. Again, the Burnham
report was so exhaustive and, as Mr. Sigafus stated,
extended over so long a time, that in the limited
time allowed me it would be impossible for me to
verify every little detail of the report. Therefore,
I had to accept the verification of the main details
of the report, and hence judge the truth of the rest
of it; and as to Mr. Burnham’s character, there are
many mining engineers in California who are un-
known in Colorado and vice versa, And Mr. Siga-
fus described him as a hard-working, capable little
feliow.

Q. Where are the maps that accompanied the
alleged Burnham report to yout

A. L left them in my office in Georgetown, Colo-
rado.

Mr. McIntyre: Defendant’s counsel now
gives notice to produce said maps upon the
trial of this case.

Mr. Sigafus showed me and I examined a very
complete and neat abstract of title to the property.

I found the vein to be a fissure vein in granite,
with a course a little east of north and west of
south, with fairly well-defined walls.

Q. Why is it that you are able to produce a copy
of the Burnham report and not the maps and pho-
tographs that accompanied it, had reference to, and
was connected with the same?

A. Because in my own office I read over the re-

295

296

298

299

300

100

John M. S. Egan.

port in going to Denver, and inadvertently left them
behind, and because Mr. Griffith particularly asked
me for them. I made field notes of my examina.
tion of the mine. They are made in a small black
memorandum book, which I had in my possession
up to the time I went to New York, and in a safe
place in my library, and on starting for New York
this summer I think every member of my household
hunted everywhere but could not find it. I also
made small maps at the time of the examination.
They were on that book until they were copied
into a larger book. They are also lost.

Q. Didn’t you make your own report to average
94 inches of pay ore, regardless of what you found
in the mine?

A. No, sir.

Q. You remember that the Burnham report re-
fers to a continuous development of 900 feet in the
ore chute, witha contract made for 200 feet more,
if this report was two or three years old, as you
have testified to, why didn’t you look for the addi-
tional 200 feet in the drift, if you verified this re-
port, as you say you did?

A. If you will notice in the Burnham report that
ne counts work done in the sinking of the vein as
well as drifting in his aggregate development.

Q. Do you know how much block one figured up
in length and height in the Burnham report, from
the drift to the grass? Lam examining you on the
Burnham report, and when I change to any other
report I will so state, so that you may not be mis-
led. -

A. I don’t remember the figures. My blocks
were different from Burnham’s, as there evidently
had been a great deal of development work in stop-
ing between the day I took to be the date of the re:
port and my visit, and not having made maps show-
ing the various blocks, I cannot now identify them
from memory after a lapse of nearly two years.

_—

John M. 8. Egan. 301

101

hadn’t the time to verify the Burnham report in
every small detail, in the more important parts I
endeavored to.

Q. The report states that the average width of
the pay streaks was ascertained by measuring every
10 feet through the workings, while it appears in
the table that there were only 110 measurements,
10 feet apart, or 1,100 in all; why did you verify the
average, and why wasn’t the other 1,800 feet meas-
ured by him, as you stated you verified the report?

A. Because I allowed for a great deal of ground
that had been opened up between his report and 29
mine.

Q. The report shows that there were no widths
taken in the shafts 1 and 3, and none taken in the
upper level north of shaft 2, except 34 measure-
ments, or 340 feet, and no measurements at all in
the lower level north of shaft No. 2. How do you
reconcile this, and what report did you make con-
cerning the same?

A. In the main shaft, as the first 250 feet is sunk
in the hanging wall, no measurements could be
taken of the streak. When I was there it was not
safe to go into the south shaft; as to any workings
uorth, the drifts may not have been driven at that
time. As far asI could tell, the first level south
was only stoped up 15 feet, and the second level
south, near the shaft, about forty-five feet, but a
fissure of ground was left in the shaft, except a
hole broken through for air.

Q. Wasn't the reason why you didn’t go down
into the south shaft because you were told that that
was the end of the mine, the dyke being there?

A. No, sir.

Q. Is it not a fact that openings led from it at
different points south of the south shaft, and that
the old workings south of the south shaft at the
upper level were open, and ran into the ground
there, and that the lower level was then open, a

303

304

305

102

John M. 8S. Egan.

drift south of the south shaft running in about 150
feet?

A. There were no workings of that kind appar.
ent to me.

Q. Did you not go into this level with Sigafus
and Cheatham and talk with them about the hard-
ness of the ground at this point?

A. No, sir; I don’t remember anything of the
kind.

Q. Will you swear you did not?

A. To the best of my belief I swear I did not.

Q). Is it not a fact that you went up the whole of
that shaft?

A. It is a fact that I did not.

Q. What did you find at the north end of the
ground when you stoped it over the 80 feet you
say was covered up; did you find good ore or poor
oret

A. We didn’t stope that up; we had put up the
raise abont $5 feet in height and bore over into the
foot wall before we found any ore. We uncovered
the 80 feet. There was no ore there. I testified
that I did uot examine all of the workings described
in the Burnham report; in fact, most of them had
caved in; all the main workings of the mine that I
could get at. with safety I examined. Mr. Sigafus
didn’t place any limitation on my time for making
an investigation and verification of the so-called
Burnham report. In testifying as to the value of the
mine I had in mind such portions thereof as I ac-
tually saw, and, of course, I took a great many of
Mr, Sigafus’s statements in walking over the surface
ground, the values of ore, that I had no reason to
doubt any statements he made

Q. Did your employer, Mr. Morse, tell you to
rely upon Mr. Sigafus’s statements?

A. He did not.

Q. Could you verify the statements of Sigafus
just as well and just as easily as you could the

a

John M. 8. Egan. 307

103

statements contained in the report which you didn’t
know?

A. I suppose I could, if I got any statement from
Sigafus; it was hard to get him to talk about the
mine, except by direct questions, and then he talked
in a general way about its great richness and his
reasons for selling, and it is a fact that I got the
data as to the main developments then in use from
Mr. Sigafus and used them.

Q. Therefore he placed you ina position, while
giving those figures to you, to prove the truth or
falsity of the same, if you chose? 308

A. Yes, sir. In my experience as a mining expert :
in passing upon the value of such property, before
I recommend the purchase I make an independent
examination. I would verify the owner's state-
ment myself. I did verify Mr. Sigafus’s statements,
to the best of my ability and with the means at my
disposal. That verification was before the sale to
Griffith. Mr. Sigafus didn’t make any statements
that were not true, but he neglected to tell me that
the second level north was driven 8% feet further
than apparent, and the second level south 150 feet
further than was apparent, and I don’t believe now
the ore from that mine averaged $20 per ton since
the working of the mine, as he stated. I found it
out quickly after starting to working the mine on
a larger scale.

Q. State the month and year you found it out.

A. In May, June, July, August, September, Oc-
tober, November and part of December, 1894.

Q. Did you communicate your discovery in writ-
ing to your employers?

A. Not as a discovery.

Q. What was the date of the first letter in which
you communicated the discovery to your employers
at Haverhill?

A. The returns of the bullion from the mill sent
in the regular reports to the company showed the

_

grade of ore which was mined was much lower
than expected.

(). Then I understand you to say that you merely
sent reports of that character to the company at
Haverhill, Massachusetts, unaccompanied by any
letter or suggestion of the discovery you speak
about.

A. I understand, Mr. McIntyre, ‘that you refer
to the fact of the ore running so much lower. As
I stated before, accurate reports were sent to the
company, accompanied by letters.

311. @. In your answer to cross-interrogatory No.
105 you say. “he did not make any statements
that were untrue, but he neglected to tell me that
the second level north was driven Sv. feet further
than apparent, and the second south 150 feet fur-
ther than was apparent, and I don’t believe now
the ore from the mine averaged $20 per ton since
the working of the mine, as he stated.” Now, I
will get you to state with that explanation if you
communicated the fact in writing to your em-
ployers of the discovery of the two drifts referred
to that you say Sigafus neglected to tell you of, and
also, if you communicated in writing the discovery
you made of the ore running less per ton than you
expected?

A. Yes, sir. I cannot give the date and the per-
sons to whom it was communicated; it was, prob-
ably, Mr. Wood, Mr. Porter, Jones or Morse. As
to the south drift early in the year 1894; as to the
north drift in the fall of the year 1894, 1 cannot
give the month. Such communications were sent
to some officer of the company. I kept copies of
my letters sent to the company —of nearly all;
not of all. They were kept in a copying-book—a
press copying-book. I cannot say where that book
is now. I left it at the Good Hope Mine and de-
livered it to William Foster, my successor as man-

104

310 Jobn M. S. Egan.

312

105
John M. S. Egan.

ager. Such letter-book belonged to the company,
and was part of its records.

Q. The bullion report in the Burnham report gives
the amount of bullion produced in the last 12
months at $57,800. I will call your attention to
that table, and that it doesn’t give the amount for
any specific 12 months, and especially for the 12
months covered by the expense period; how do you
get around that?

A. The summary gives a total expense of pro-
ducing that bullion as $15,509. On another page
the monthly expenses are given for a corresponding
period, amounting to $5,779.56, and the pay-roll,
$9,729.44, making the $15,509 referred to in the
summary. I paid little attention to those figures
(total product, $260,000), as it is stated it was made
from careful inquiry. It was one of those cases
that often happened in the early history of the
mines, when parties did not keep accurate records,
so-called; I paid little attention to that. In this
case the output was from old workings, as evi-
denced by dumps and caved shafts. I have no
doubt that a great many thousand dollars were
produced from that mine, but to verify that $260,-
000 is impossible, nor is it given great weight in
that report by Burnham himself. That $260,000
represents the product of the old workings.

Q. Then, certain portions of the report you acted
upon and gave credence, while other portions you
didn’t; is that correct?

A. This statement is under head of history, and
not as statistics.

Q. What do you understand by the summary of
a report?

A. The aggregation of figures given in the report.

Q. In your investigation did you give credence to
the summary in the report?

A. To those portions which I could reasonably

. demonstrate myself. I demonstrated the length of

313

314

315

=

ore chute to be over 3,000 feet. I made maps only
of the underground workings then in use. I found
the lowest depth in the mine to be about 385 feet,
The number of feet developed on levels was about
2,000 feet in the main workings. The width of the
fissure was from a few inches to five or six feet, or
more or less. The average width of the pay-streak
was a little over 24 inches. I found the tonnage in
that reserve 46,922. I asked Mr. Sigafus if the
statements as to the bullion returns were correct,
and he said they were carried out correctly in the

317 Sheet, giving the various dates, and that the ex-
pense account was correct.

Q. Didn’t you testify that you went out to verify
the Burnham report ?

A. Yes, sir.

. Then in this particular instance you didn’t
verify the Burnham report, but relied on the state-
ments of others ; is not that correct?

A. To the best of my recollection, the Durell
report states that those figures had been obtained
at the mine.

- Q. The Burnham report in the summary shows
$317,000 produced; how do you reconcile that with
the statement that $260,000 was produced?

818 =a. It adds, I presume, $57,000 with the $260,000.

Q. How does it do so?

A. I suppose the figures added together make
that amount...

Q. What did you find the product to be under
the ownership of Sigafus?

A. $9,618 added to the other tables. Mr. Sigafus
stated to me asa reason for not running the mill
and working the mine continually that he was
away a great deal of the time; that he shut down,
as he could trust no one to attend to his business.

Q. In the Burnham report the tonnage in re-
serve is given as 44,733, while in your report to
your employers you give the tonnage in reserve 0

106

316 John M. S. Egan.

107
John M. S. Egan.

be 46,900; when and how do you get those figures?

A. By measuring along the levels up the stopes,
and up the raises where practicable.

Q. In the Burnham report how did you verify
the width taken in shaft 1 and 3?

A. I don’t know which shafts they are; the south
shaft I was unable to get into, but I was able to get
to it from two stopes; the main shaft I was able to
verify, I think, within 50 feet of the first level;
from the first level to the second, and down to
where the water was pumped up below.

Q. How did you verify widths taken in the first
level north of shaft No. 2?

A. By measuring along the stopes; but under-

stand this, that I could not tell where Mr. Burnham
started to measure his 10 feet, soI could not verify
each individual measurement.

Q. Did you verify the measurements in the lower
level north of shaft No. 2?

A. I verified them as far as possible by taking
my own independent measurements.

Q. The Burnham report stated that the cars held
12.3 cubic feet; is that correct?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Is the weight per car stated in the Burnham
report correct?

A. Yes,’sir.

_ Q. The understanding between you and Sigafus
was that 3 cars be allowed to the ton, was it?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. In this respect you were following the custom
of the mine?

A. Mr. Sigafus and I thoroughly discussed the
matter in discussing the mill run, as the cars are
not always full. Different sizes and the ore differ-
ent degrees of moisture.

Q. I believe you testified that the figures in the
Burnham report as to the cubic feet per car and the
weight per car were correct?

319

320

321

322

323

324

108
John M. S. Egan.

A. Yes, sir. But I cannot say the same cars were
used, but if the same cars were used the figures are
correct. In going down the shaft I went down
slowly and reached out with a foot rule at every
opportunity, and in the stopes I measured. with the
foot rule the width of the quartz and the amount
of vein filling that would go to the mill, and meas-
uring the quartz every ten feet along the stopes and
in the drifts. I arrived at the mine to make the
examination in ‘the afternoon of November 19th.
The examination commenced that afternoon. I
cannot say exactly when the mill run commenced;
I think about the 2ist of November, 1893. It con-
tinued, I think, three and one-half days. On the
first day I went out I wore a linen duster; on re-
turning to Perris on the 17th it was so cold and a
heavy snow falling that I had to borrow an over-

coat from Mr. Sigafus; this weather continued

for a day or two; after that it was the usual
weather.

Q. Did the cold, severe weather continue during
the mill run?

A. Not as bad as that, because I was able to sit
around in my shirt sleeves out of doors.

Q. Colonel, in testifying tothe value of the mine
you base your computation upon what you exam-
ined and saw yourself? ©

A. Yes, sir; and other evidence and memoranda.

Q. Then when you testified the mine to be worth
$50,000 or thereabouts, the $1,000,000 computation
of value would be based upon portions of the mines
and notes thereof you didn’t see?

A. Yes, sir; but I saw the surface.

Q. During the mill run who remained in the
office, yourself or Griffith?

A. Griffith was there all the time. Putting in
the time as best he could and drying my samples;
I had him at work upon the crusher, but he got di
tired out. I think he went away aday or twobe- —

John M. S, Egan. 325

109

fore the mill run was completed; as to his being
there late at night, he and I used to spend our eve-
nings there until he went away; after that I spent
my evenings at Mr. Sigafus’s house. The yellow
house on the hill) That bouse is about 400 feet
from the mill.

Q. You say that the mill run itself lasted about
three and one-half days, after that what was done
by you and how long did you stay at the mine?

A. To the best of my recollection I stayed long
enough to see the retort made; I went away on
Saturday, the retorting was completed on Friday. .9.
I think the run commenced on Tuesday. Mr. Sig-
afus did the retorting at my request in the black-
smith shop. In my presence part of the time. The
weight of that retort was 51 troy ounces.

Q. Was it not avoirdupois and not troy weight?

A. I think it was 55 avoirdupois. Mr. Sigafus
kept the bullion.

Q. You left your samples, you say, with Griffith,
and had him crush out and grind the same for you,
I believe, you testified?

A. I didn’t say anything of that kind. I said I
had him assist me in doing the rough crushing
with the small hand-crusher. He was doing that
work in the company’s office where such work was
usually done.

Q. And he was in the office then doing the work
when you were out about the mine or at the mill?

A. No, sir.

Q. How much of the time were you absent and
where did you go?

A. Mr. Griffith. spent two or three days in the
mine with me till he got tired, and the rest of the
time previous to going away, he made the office his
headquarters, and I cannot say how often I was ab-
sent nor how long, but I went down in to the mine
several times; in and around the mill several times
_ and around the hoisting works.

327

—+

110
328 John M. 8. Egan.

Q. Griffith | ought the mine, didn’t he?

A. I believe so; a formal deed was made.

Q. Don’t you know that Griffith bought that
mine and that he sold it to the parties you repre-
sented?

A. I believe that was the form of the transaction.
I will swear that I didn’t receive any note nor any
money in that transaction. 1 was to receive some-
thing on the transaction. A proportionate interest
in the $50,000; about one-half. From Mr. Morse.
It was contingent on the success of the property, and

399 when I found it was not a success I threw it up vol-
untarily.

Q. Was that the understanding and agreement
between you and Morse, and was such understand-
ing an agreement in writing that you were to re-
ceive such interest prior to the sale?

A. It was not.

(). But the agreement of your receiving the $25,-
000 was, of course, prior to the sale, was it not?

A. Yes, sir. Mr. Griffith didn’t send for me to
come to California and make this examination of
the mine. It was not understood and agreed by
and between myself and Griffith, that if he, Grif-
fith, purchased the mine I would share in the com-
mission. I testified about going over the surface
ground with Mr. Sigafus. We passed over a
porphyry dyke that runs parallel with and west
of the vein.

Q. Don’t you remember at that time Mr. Sigafus
telling you that the shaft No. 1 there was at ex-
treme south end of the mine, or what he called the
end of the mine, where the dyke or footwall made
sharp turn to the west?

A. I took the figures he gave me and put
them in a book. To the best of my recollection now
the sketch was on a sheet of paper very unhandy to
carry around in the mine. It was an ordinary sheet _
of wrapping paper about 18 inches square. I first —

330

111
John M. 8. Egan.

met Griffith to know him. I think it was, in 1892.
I was introduced to him sometime in October, 1893,
at the Oxford Hotel, in Denver, Colorado, I had
no direct correspondence with Griffith at all. He
expected Mr. Morse and I to come, that was an un-
derstanding at a meeting at the Oxford Hotel, at
which Morse, Platt, Griffith and myself were pres-
ent. Colonel Platt introduced me to Mr. W. H.
Griffith and told me to talk over that California
matter with him; I did so and Mr. Morse joined us
and asked me what I thought of the report. I said
if that report is true, that mine had been made to
order. I asked him on that occasion who made the
report; why it was not signed and dated. He told
me who made it, and said he had lost the original,
and I said that was pretty rough.

Q. Is it customary among mining experts to en-
trust the crushing and manipulation of ore samples
toa stranger during the running of a mill test to
ascertain the value of the mine from the assay then
made?

A. No, sir.

Q. You stated that the mill run was three and
one-half days, you thought—you didn’t know;
don’t you know that it was impossible for that mill
and the force at your disposal to make a test of 63
cars of ore during that time?

A. No, sir.

Q. Will you swear that it can be done, and was
done at that time?

A. I will swear that it can be done, but as I am
not positive of the number of days I cannot swear
to the second part. .

Q. Will you swear that those 63 cars of ore were
put through in the time you say this mill run was
made?

A. To the best of my information and belief, yes,
sir

Q. Do you remember the circumstances of Sigafus

331

332

112

John M. S. Egan.

stating to you that Doran wanted the position of
storekeeper at the mine on account of his enfeebled
condition, being sick at the time, and as he would
probably never be able to do severe labor again, and
asking your consideration in his behalf; you stated
that you were always glad to help an old miner
.whenever you could, and prior to your leaving,
*Sigafus took you up to the house, introduced you
to Doran, and that matter was discussed between
Doran, Mrs. Doran, Sigafus and yourself?

A. No, sir; I do not. I talked with Doran and
Sigafus separately after my return. I invested
$15,000 in that mine. I paid it, I think, to Dudley
Porter and John L. Hobson, the trustees, and $5,000
to E. G. Wood, treasurer. I borrowed $10,000 from
C. W. Morse and $5,000 from Mr. John L. Hobson.
It has not been repaid. The company was capital-
ized at $1,000,000. I got $75,000 shares; represent-
ing in value to me an investment of $15,000. I
considered at that time that Mr. Morse did mea
great favor in loaning me that $10,000. I didn’t
pay the money in, but borrowed of Mr. Morse, and
he paid it in for me through the bank.

268 Q. Was not the mine sold by Griffith to your
employers?

A. As I stated before, I believe that was a form
gone through, but the money from my employers
paid direct to Mr. Sigafus’s attorney, yourself.

269 Q. Wasn’t the deed made by Sigafus to
Griffith, and wasn’t Griffith given back a $100,000
mortgage, and wasn’t that arrangement made so
‘that certain notes might be kept and divided among
the sellers?

A. Lunderstand that such was the case—that a
mortgage was given back, but for the purpose I
have no knowledge about that.

970 Q. Were you not to have one of the $6,000 -
notes that was covered by that mortgage!

A. I believe so.

113
John M. S. Egan.

271 Q. Did you receive the $6,000 note that was
to come to you in that figuring?

A. No, sir; I didn’t.

372 Q. How is it you didn’t receive it?

A. Because, I believe, that I was told that it was
paid to Maxwell. :

273 Q. With whom did you have the conversa-
tion—was it not with Griffith—about the receipt of
this $6,000 note by you?

A. No, sir; I had very little conversation with
Griffith.

274 Q. What was the purchase price of the
mine?!

A. I think it was $230,000.

I was told by Morse that I was entitled to a $6,000
note. I was not expecting anything of that kind
on the first mortgage. Mr. Morse and myself exe-
cuted a second mortgage covering the same prop-
erty, and signed notes at Riverside about that
‘time. When Mr. Morse and I executed that
mortgage and signed those notes, we signed the
same by virtue of a power of. attorney for Hobson,
Morse and Porter, the plaintiffs in this action. The
mortgagees named in that instrument were, to the
best of my belief,

Samuel F. Thompson, ; $5,500
Charles M. Derrickson, 2,750
C. E. Whistler, 1,375
W. K. Graham, 1,375
Caroline F. Grittith, 3,000
Samuel B. Griffith, 3,000
Jacob Fillius, 108,000 .
Total amount, $125,000

That mortgage was part of the purchase price
that had been paid for the mine.

Q. Did you not state that the purchase price of
the mine was $230,000 in favor of Sigafus?

A. Yes, sir. 7

337

338

339

341

342

114
John M. 8S. Egan.

Q. Then, to the $230,000 purchase price in favor
of Sigafus was to be added this $125,000 which was
to be the figure that you people were to sell the
mine for to the Haverhill parties; is that correct?

A. That is less than the price which I reported to
Mr. Morse the mine was worth. The total price
was $400,000.

Q. Is it not a fact that this mortgage of $125,000,
together with the notes secured thereby, was re-
pudiated as a fraud, and that a Jacob Fillius made
to disgorge and surrender his note, which he did do,
and the same was cancelled by the parties you had
these transactions with?

A. Not to my knowledge, sir.

Q. Wasn’t your removal as superintendent and
manager of the Good Hope Mine, because, and on
account of these dealings, and the execution of
these notes and mortgage?

A. No, sir; it was not. As the company months
before acknowledged the transaction and I volun-
tarily gave up all the interest I had in the notes. |
had an interest in the note of Jacob Fillius of $25,-
000 or $30,000.

Q. Then if you had an interest in the Jacob Fil-
lius note of $25,000 or $80,000, you, under such
power of attorney, made a note payable to your.
self to the extent of such sum, and you had an
equity in said note to the amount of $30,0008 —

A. Yes, sir. Mr. Morse asked me whom | would
like as a personal friend to act as trustee of that
note, and I told him Mr. Jacob Fillius had been my
attorney fora great many years. The vote was
made to Jacob Fillius, as trustee. I gave up all my
interests, as did Mr. Morse, in that note, long be-
fore the suit was started by Maxwell. I think late
in July or early in August, 1894. I left the man-
agement of the Good Hope Company as a result, of
a letter from Mr. Porter, the president of the com-

pany, in which he stated that there was great diss |

John M. 8. Egan.

115

satisfaction amongst the stockholders from the
meagre returns of the mine; that he had been led
to believe, not only from myself, but others who had
visited the property, it was lying in my engage-
ment; after that I telegraphed my resignation to
Haverhill, Massachusetts, and it was accepted.
That letter did not demand my removal, but,
after reviewing it, I considered the best thing I
could do was to telegraph my resignation, and it
was accepted. To the best of my knowledge and
belief, as expressed by that letter and official let-
ters received after I telegraphed my resignation,
my action in signing that mortgage had nothing to
do with my leaving the company. The company
never questioned orally or in writing itself, or by
any one representing it. my action in the execution
of that mortgage, and the notes secured thereby.
The Griffiths whose names appear in the said note
as payees and mortgagees named in the mortgage
are relatives of the W. H. Griffith who assisted me
during the mill test, in the manner, and at the
time, as testified by me. The giving of those notes
to the said Griffith was in accordance with an un-
derstanding by me with W. H. Griffith at the time
the same were executed.

Q. Don’t you know that Jacob Fillius only sur-
rendered that note in which you had an interest of
$30,000 in the face of a criminal prosecution, and
that he got frightened and surrendered the note,
and that the same was cancelled by the company?

A. I had no personal knowledge at all.

i remember going to the end of the second level
south, 250 feet south of the main shaft, with Mr.
Cheatham. I remember Cheatham asking me
about climbing over some kind of an obstruction in
one of those south levels; which one it was I don’t
remember. When we came out where this drift
left the main shaft I made a remark to Cheathata
about the hardness of the drift. Cheatham and I

346

347

116
John M. 8. Egan.

visited the north end of the first level. I remem.
ber there was a rich streak of ore there. I took my
samples at the face of this drift when Cheatham
told me there was this rich streak which I have al-
ready testified I took my santples from. Besides
the regular samples I took in the breast, I took
samples of the rich sulphurets and put them ina
sack, but those were not placed with my regular
samples. I asked Cheatham also to get a sack of
rich ore, and he did. I remember of some ore that
ran, during my examination of the mine, $800 to
the ton. It is a fact that the rich ore that I assayed

‘that ran $00 per ton was taken from this very

drift. My salary as manager was $500 a month up
to October, 1894, when I volunteered to cut it down
one-half myself. I drew three months’ salary at
$250, and nine months at $500. I paid an assayer
$125 per month, a bookkeeper $125 per month, as
bookkeeper and cashier and storekeeper. We had
three to four engineers at the rate of twenty-five
cents an hour, and ten or twelve up to fifty miners
at the rate of $2.50 per day each. I might have had
sixty-five men underground. I cannot answer
whether there were seventy. The regular force on
top was: head machinist, at $100; blacksmith at
$90 per month; these two men worked Sundays
and nights or days, if called upon; there was a
‘‘ roustabout,” at $2 a day; two trammers, they
were paid $2 each; and from three to four men in
the mill, one at $3.75 per day of twelve hours, one
at $2.75 per day of twelve hours, the other at $2.50
per day at twelve hours each; one man at the
pumping-engine, half a mile from the mine, at
twenty cents an hour; as repairs or extra construc-
tion were required there was extra laborers re-
quired for that purpose; in the number in the mine
was included the head foreman, who received from
$100 to $125 per month, and the night boss, who —

received $3 per day; also included timbermen, | a

John M. S. Egan. 349

117

varying from two to four in number, who received
from $2.75 to $3 per day each. I never took a day’s
vacation during the time I was manager of that
mine; whenever 1 was in Los Angeles I was on the
company’s business. I cannot say how often; not
so often as once a month on the average. I con-
sidered that I was buying a million-dollar mine for
$230,000.

Q. Colonel (handing witness a paper), I will get
you to look at that paper, and state if it isin your
handwriting, to whom it was written, from where,
and the date thereof. 350

A. It was writtem to James M. Sigafus, from the
Good Hope Mine, June 25th, 1894, on one of the
official letter-heads of the company, showing my
name as general manager.

Counsel asks that the original of that let-
ter be identified by the notary, and that the
copy of the same, duly proven as being a
correct copy thereof, be identified by the nv-
tary, and marked by him as Defendant’s
Exhibit “‘ A,” and that it be admitted in evi-
dence as part of this deposition.
So marked,
351
Mr. McIntyre (handing the witness a letter):
Is that letter in your handwriting and the signature
thereof and the postscript at the bottom?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. To whom was that letter written, from where
and what date?
A. To James M. Sigafus, Perris, California;
from Denver, Colorado, November 29th, 1893.

Marked ‘‘ B.”

Mr. McIntyre (handing witness paper): I will
; now get you to state what that paper and letter

—ry

A. A letter from myself to Mr. Sigafus at the
Good Hope Mine in California, written from George.
town, Colorado, November 30th, 1893, and signed
by myself. The writing and signature to the same
are my own.

Marked ‘‘C.”

118

352 John M. 8. Egan.

Q. I call your attention to your letter in evi-
dence as Defendant’s Exhibit ‘“‘C,” referred to,
wherein you state as follows: ‘I must have made
some serious mistake in sampling the tailings, as

353 Mr. Graham's assay give 2.80 au and 1.70 ag,
whilst the crude ore only run 1.50 au. and 1.00 ag.”
When you found the serious mistake why didn’t
you return to California and make another exam-
ination and rectify the error, as you call it?

A. Because the return was so outrageous and the
mill run of the crude ore was so satisfactory that I
didn’t deem it of sufficient importance, especially
as I didn’t in my report make any estimate of value
of the pile of tailings in the dump.

Q. Did you inform your employer of the discov-
ery of the mistake referred to in your said letter,
marked Defendant’s Exhibit ‘‘C ”?

354 A. I presume I did, as-I talked over every detail
with him, and showed him this list of assays, as
-well.as several others. I met him by appointment.
Mr. B. B. Jones, attorney for the Good Hope Mine,
first asked me to testify in this case.

One sample was from eight inch streak, the rich
streak speken of; that was with my other samples,
not included in my average assay of the ore body
of the mine; I also took another sample for my
own use of some very heavy sulphurets; these I
had assayed and never mentioned in my report.

Defendant’s counsel, at the request of
plaintiff’s counsel, reads in evidence the let
ters A, B and C, which, during the cross-ex- —

119

Charles W. Morse.

amination of Mr. Egan, were identified by
him as being in his handwriting, and were
then marked for identification, being dated

respectively ‘‘ Good Hope Consolidated Gold.

Mine, November 29, 1893, November 30,
1893 and June Z5th, 1894,” all being addressed
to J. M. Sigafus.

355

Plaintiff’s counsel offers in evidence the —

Burnham report, reading only the most ma-
terial portions, the copy produced being veri-
fied by the notary, and identified in the dep-
osition of Doran and Egan.

Defendant’s counsel objects to the offer as
immaterial, not connected with the plain-
tiffs, and not shown to be a copy of the
original.

Objection overruled. Paper admitted in
evidence, and marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit A,
to which ruling of the Court counsel for de-
fendant then and there duly excepted.

—_———

CHARLES W. Morss, called as as a witness on
behalf of plaintiff, testified as follows:

I reside at Haverhil!, Mass. I have been in
Denver for nearly two years. I am one of the
plaintiffs. I knew Colonel Egan in his lifetime, and
have met Mr. Sigafus, the defendant, in connec-
tion with the purchase of this property. Mr. Egan
made an examination of the property. William H.
Griffith first suggested this property to me in Den-
ver in November, 1893. _I first came into commu-
nication with Colonel Egan at the same time—that
is, in relation to this property. I had known Mr.
Egan as a consulting engineer in a silver property
in Ouray, Colorado, in which I was interested. The
property was mentioned to Colonel Platt and my-

356.

357

120

858 Charles W. Morse.

self by William H. Griffith, and after talking the
matter over, Colonel Platt said: ‘‘We will send
down and make an examination of the property.”
Mr. Egan at that time had the Burnham report and
he made the remark that if the Burnham report
could be verified it was a mine ‘‘ made to order ”~
that is, a good paying mine, but he didn’t believe it
could be; that is why wesent him down. Colonel
Egan went down four or five days later. I did not
go with him. His instructions from Colonel Platt
and myself were to examine the mine and report
to us on it, with a view to our possible purchase of
it. I next met him, I think. in the Astor House,
New York, about the first or second of December,
This examination of the mine had then been com.
pleted.

When he left Denver to examine the mine noth-
ing whatever had been said as to the arrangements
for its purchase. No decision had been reached
that we would go into the property; we were wait-
ing for his report. At that time nothing had been
said as to his having any interest in the purchase.
And at that time no arrangement or bargain of any
kind had been made with Mr. Griffith. This inter-

360 view which I have just testified to between Mr.
Griffith, myself and Colonel Platt lasted, I should
say, five minutes. Egan made a typewritten re-
port, signed by him. This paper now shown me
{Plaintiff’s Exhibit Egan Report) is, to my best
recollection, the original paper.

e

359

Mr. Stickney: The paper is already in evi-
_ dence and it is endorsed ‘‘ Report of J. M.8.
Egan, Elbridge G. Wood.”

This report of Egan was shown to me. A copy
of the Burnham report was put in my _ possession
by Mr. Egan at the same time this report was given
to me. Up to that time no decision had been

121
Charles W. Morse.

reached as to my going into the property in any
form, or to Egan’s having any interest in the pur-
chase. There was no one else so far as I knew who
had any connection with this examination down to
that time. When Colonel Egan arrived in New
York with his report be telegraphed me to come
over and meet him here, from Haverhill, and I did
so, and we had a meeting in the Astor House, of
Colonel Platt, Mr. Griffith and myself, at which
this report was read, and there was then talk of
how we could interest some people in it to purchase
the mine at that time. Mr. Griffith thought
Colonel Platt was a millionaire and could handle the
whole thing, but he fell down after a talk and said,
“Tam sorry, but I have all I can do in connection
with these paper mills and I cannot put in a cent;
I cannot do anything with it.” Then we left
Colonel Platt, came down-stairs, talked the matter
over and I said I had some friends in Haverhill that
I thought I could interest in the property, and after
talking the matter over, the next day I went home
to Haverhill and I took the report to Mr. John L.
Hobson. I gave him the Egan report and the
Burnham report and told him of my connection
with the whole matter up to that date. 1 told him
to look the report over and keep it confidentially
and if he did not want to go into it, to bring me
back the report the next day. The next forenoon
he came into my office and asked me if I had any
objection to his showing the report to Mr. Dudley
Porter. I told him no. Later in the same day,
they both came into my office and asked me
whether Mr. Egan could be seen. I told them Mr.
Egan was in New York, and they asked me if I
could get him over and I told them I could and
they asked me to go to New York and I went to
New York and brought Colonel Egan to Haverhill
-and introduced him to Mr, Porter and to Mr. Hob-
-gon and he had the samples of ore with him and

361

362

363

364

865

366

122
Charles W. Morse,

showed them to them and then he went to Boston,
and the trade was made that week to buy the mine,
Mr. Hobson. Mr. Porter and myself made a con-
tract with Mr. Griffith to purchase the mine. Mr.
Griffith. He went to Boston. We passed the
papers between myself and the Haverhill people on
one side and Mr. Griffith on the other in Boston.
I depended in going into this enterprise and in get-
ting these other people to go in with me on the re.
port of Mr. Egan.

Q. What dependence did you place, if any, on
the Burnham report?

A. That he had verified it. Without those two
reports I would not have looked into it. The paper
shown me is the original agreement between Mr.
Griffith, Mr. Hobson, Mr. Porter and myself.

Plaintiff’s counsel offers in evidence and
reads the agreement between Griffith and
Porter, Hobson and Morse, dated the 1th
day of December, 1893.

Marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. |.

That was executed on or about the date that it
bears. The paper now shown me is the subscrip-
tion paper between us, under which the parties put
up their moneys. It is dated December 18th, 1893.
I signed it on that day.

Paper offered in evidence.

Defendant’s counsel objects to the offer if
it is introduced as evidence of liability to
anybody except the individual plaintiffs in
the case and as immaterial.

Objection overruled. To which ruling of
the Court counsel for defendants then and
there duly excepted.

Marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 2.

Plaintiff’s counsel reads as signers tothe —

subscription paper, John M. S. Egan, $10,000;

123
Charles W. Morse.

Charles W. Morse, $15,000; John L. Hobson,
$15,000; Dudley Porter, $15,009; but omitted
the other executions and amounts.

[loaned Colonel Egan the money to make his
payment; sol know that he made it; I paid the
money to Mr. Porter. I paid my own subscription
of $15,000. Mr. Porter and Mr. Hobson’s subscrip-
tions were paid. The paper now shown me is a
power of attorney from Mr. Porter and Mr. Hob-
son to Mr. Egan and myself, to receive the convey-
ances and execute the mortgages and make pay-
ments.

_ Plaintiff’s counsel offers in evidence power
of attorney, dated December 20th, 1893.

Marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 3.

I took charge on our side of the actual delivery
of the papers and the closing of the transaction.
The transaction was compieted and the papers
_ passed, in Riverside, California. I met there on

the other side when the papers were passed, McIn-
tyre & Taylor. I saw Mr. Sigafus at that time
at McIntyre & Taylor’s office and at the Glen-
wood Hotel. I think I had a conversation with
Mr. Sigafus about the transaction. The first time
I met Mr. Sigafus was in the evening at McIntyre
& Taylor’s office, and we talked generally about
the purchase of the property, and. I wanted time
to look up the title, and I think they had to have a
meeting of the corporation, to authorize the corpo-
ration to transfer the property to Mr. Sigafus be-
fore he could transfer it to us.

Q. Do you mean to Mr. Sigafus?

A. The old Good Hope Company had to have a
meeting to transfer the property which was in their
name to Mr. Sigafus, who controlled the stock, it
was all in his name, or in the name of his family,
but the meeting was held all right and they gave a

deed to him and hea deed to Mr. Griffith and Mr.

367

368

369

124
370 Charles W. Morse.

Griffith a deed to us, and then there were some
papers served upon him. There were some papers
served upon him by Mr. Maxwell, and Sigafus ob-
jected to transferring it without getting a bond to
hold him harmless. That was one entire transac-
tion. Mr. Sigafus said that the stock was all in
the family. He turned over to us, besides the
deeds of the property, the stock-book and all the
stock of the old company. He and his lawyers did
it; he was the only man outside of the lawyers
that we saw.
371. McIntyre and Taylor, in that transaction, acted
for both of us. As tothe payment of the $150,000
cash. I had a verbal agreement with Mr. Sigafus
that the checks should be endorsed over to him,
when the deeds were passed, as part of that trans-
action. All the papers were passed at the same
time, as one and the same occurrence. I had in-
structions from parties in the Kast, to have the pa-
pers all passed and the money paid at one time and
T carried the certified checks with me. We went
up to the Register of Deeds’ office. Mr. Taylor, of
the firm of McIntyre & Taylor, and myself went
up, hecarrying the papers and I carrying the money,
‘and when he deposited the papers I handed him the
checks which were endorsed to the order of James
M. Sigafus. The understanding between Sigafus and
myself, before the deeds were passed was that the
checks and the deeds should be delivered simulta-
neously. The checks were delivered to his attor-
ney, Mr. Taylor. Mr. Sigafus was not there. But
the.arrangement had been made with him person-
ally. Mr. Griffith was not there at that time. He
had nothing to do with the transaction at that time;
he and Sigafus were off togother somewhere. The
two papers shown me are two checks; one of
$90,000 and one of $60,000, payable to the order of
myself and J.. M.S. Egan, and by us endorsed to
James M. Sigafus. I know Mr. Sigafus’s hand-

872

125

Charles W. Morse.

writing. That is his signature on the back of these
checks.

Plaintiffs’ counsel offers checks in evi-
dence.

Marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibits 4 and 5.

Griffith’s name does not appear on either check.

Q. Did the whole of them go on record at the
same time?

A. There was one paper that he could not give
us, because he had to get his son-in-law’s signa-
ture, a man by the name of Bird. Mr. Sigafus had
to get his signature: but the other papers were all
recorded at the same time, as part of one transac-
tion. This paper is one of the papers that was
passed at the same time. The defendant was not
there at that time; it was all done through his at-
torney. This paper is the deed of the old company
to Mr. Griffith.

Plaintiffs’ counsel offers deed in evidence.
Marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 6.

This is the next one, the deed from Mr. Sigafus
to Griffith.

Plaintiffs’ counsel offers deed in evidence.
Marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 7.

This is the next paper, being the deed from Grif-
fith to Porter, Hobson and Morse.

Plaintiffs’ counsel offers deed in evidence.
Marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 8.

This is the next paper, being deed from Bird to
Porter, Hobson and Morse; the paper that came
later and was recorded afterwards.

Plaintiffs’ counsel offers deed in evidence.
Marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 9.

373

374

375

126
876 Charles W. Morse.

This is one of the papers; the mortgage from
Griffith to Sigafus, given at the same time.

Plaintiffs’ counsel offers a copy of mort-
gage in evidence dated 28th of December,
1893.

Marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 10.

This paper is the second mortgage.

Plaintiffs’ counsel offers in evidence mort-

gage from Morse, Porter and Hobson, to

377 Thompson, Fillius and others, dated January
9th, 1894.

Marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 11.

That was delivered at the date of it, I should say.
I first made the arrangement as to this $150,000
mortgage, the second mortgage, with Mr. Griffith.
That arrangement was first spoken of, I think, when
we met in Chicago, on the way to California. Mr.
Egan was to have, inthe second mortgage, some
$54,000. That is half of the $108,000. I think that
arrangement was made between Mr. Griffith,
Colonel Egan and myself at the Victoria Hotel, in

378 Chicago, after we had started to go to California.
I should say the 23d day of December, 1893.

Q. And, down to that time, had there been any-
thing said or done as to giving Colonel Eagan any
interest at all, except his interest in the purchase
under his first payment of cash?

A. Oh, yes; it had been talked over some two or
three days before that in Boston.

Q. When was the very first time that it was
spoken offeven, that Colonel Egan should haveany
interest in the second mortgage?

A. I think the first time was after Mr. Griffith—
that is, by myself—was after Mr. Griffith came over

from New York, after Mr. Egan had been in Hav- |
erhill. The arrangement, such as it was, with Mr.

127

Charles W. Morse. 379

Egan was made by me; but it was finally made in
Chicago. It was in writing. Ido not know where
that paper is. Mr. Fillius, of Denver, held the
$108,000 note because he was a friend of Mr. Ea-
gan’s—to protect Mr. Eagan. I was to have the
other $54,000. There was later, as to myself,
an arrangement made by which my interest under
that second mortgage was to be given up. I never
saw Mr. Egan after that day; the day I left him
when we bought the mine. As to myself, I think
it was in August, 1894. At the instance of Mr.
Jones. He had been to California and had seen Mr. 380.
Egan and Mr. Griffith and the property had not
turned out as we expected, and he said it ought to
be turned back and we turned it back. There was
some talk that I ought not to have taken the mort-
gage. Nothing else. I did not have any commu-
nication with Colonel Egan about his giving up
his interest. I went in and asked Mr. Fillius to
assign that mortgage to Mr. Jones, and he did it.
Right away. My subscribers in Haverhill did not
know that I was to have half of that $108,000. I
first learned of it at this same talk in Boston.

By the Court:

Q. You say you were not aware of it?

A. Not on that date. I knew that I was to have
something, but it was arranged in Chicago after-
wards—after we had left.

y. But you knew that they were subscribing on
the basis of that amount to be paid for the property?

A. Yes, sir. I never had anything to do with the
three $6,000 notes covered by the first mortgage to
Mr. Sigafus. They were delivered by Mr. Griffith
to Mr. Maxwell; I think Mr. Griffith had one and
Mr. Maxwell two. I did not have any conversation
with Mr. Sigafus after that. .

Q. But they were included in the mortgage that
was made to him?

381

882

383

384

128
Charles W. Morse.

A. Yes, sir. I knew that he received the
$82,000 note—or his attorneys did for him—and
made no objection to not receiving the other three.
That was Mr. Griffith’s note. This is one of the
$6,000 notes.

Plaintiffs’ counsel offers note in evidence.
Marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 12.

Cross-examination:

I had not, prior to this time, had any experience
in mining matters, or been interested in the sale or
purchase of mines. I had an interest in a silver
mine in Ouray, which originally took me to Color-
ado. I had Mr. Egan in the Ouray mine. That
is where I became acquainted with him. On this
occasion his expenses were paid. I think Colonel
Platt paid them. I knew Mr. Griffith had the prop
erty for sale. 1 saw Griffith, Egan and Platt at
Astor House, New York, about December 1, 1893.

By the Court:

Q. How did you know that he had the property
for sale?

A. Because he made the offer of selling it. I did
not know whether he owned it, or who owned it,
at that time.

By Mr. Wetmore:

Q. You did not know who owned it?

A. No, sir. All I now know is by the deeds. I un-
derstand that Mr. Griffith did, in California, make
a deed to me, Mr. Hobson and Mr. Porter. And the
consideration of that deed is $400,000, and that
$400,000 was part cash and part secured by mort-

gage and notes. as set forth in that contract. Up 4
to the 18th of December, the day when I signed —

129
Charles W. Morse.

that contract, I had no communication, written or
oral, with Mr. Sigafus. I never saw him until I
met him either in Riverside or Perris. I don’t
remember which. Prior to my making this con-
tract Mr. Egan showed me what has been called
the Burnham report, and also his own report, in
the Astor House, in New York. That was the first
time I had ever seen the Burnham report or the
Egan report. I read the Burnham report. I should
say I read it all through. I based my judgment on
Mr. Egan’s report. I took Mr. Egan’s word, as
represented in his report, as the basis of what I
acted upon as supplementing the Burnham report.
I did not know Burnham: didn’t know who he was
and don’t to-day.

Q. Did you notice that the Burnham report re-
fers to prior reports made by Burnham?

A. I probably did. I don’t recall it. I saw none
of those prior reports. There was no map with the
report that I saw. I relied on Colonel Egan as to
the accuracy of the statements that were made in
his report. At the time I executed the contract
of December 18th, the subcription paper already
referred to had not been filled. I had signed it, but
I do not know how many others had. Subsequently
Porter, Hobson and I conveyed to a company.

Q. Was any money paid to either yourself or Mr.
Porter or Mr. Hobson, after that conveyance from
the treasury of the company?

A. I cannot testify as to Mr. Hobson, but there
was none paid to me.

-Q. You stated that Col. Egan put in some money.
Ithink you said you let him have it?

A. I did.

Q. Did he give you his note for it?

A. Yes, sir.

_Q. Was Col. Platt’s name on the note?

A. No, sir.

— Q. His individual notet

386

387

388

390

130
Charles W. Morse.

A. Yes, sir; secured by stock in the company.

Q. Secured by a pledge of the stock in the com-
pany?

A. Yes.

Q. You took the stock?

A. I took the stock and note and paid him
$10,000.

Q. Was the stock put in Col. Egan’s name or in
yours?

A. I could not say as to that. 1t was left in the
book by the officers of the company; they under-
stood it, because I then went West to live—and I
have not the stock myself now—but I suppose the
officers of the company have it in my name as
collateral.

Q. Then this stock was paid for by you, and Col.
Egan gave you a note for $10,000?

A. No. The facts were these: I endorsed Col.
Egan’s note for $10,000 and took the stock as col-
lateral. When the note became due he could not
pay it, and I had to.

Q. Has he ever paid it?

A. No, sir; nor the interest.

By the Court:

Q. In your direct examination you spoke of hav-
ing loaned him some money on his note. When
you took this note I suppose you intended to take
care of it.

A. No, sir. I loaned the money because I en-
dorsed the note, and got it discounted, and he gave
me a note covering it. The original note was given
to Mr. Porter, as the others were. 2

By Mr. Wetmore:

Q. Did you discount any other note?

A. I think I discounted my own note for $15,000.
Q. That resulted in $25,000?

A. Yes, sir.

™ oe to Mr. Jones..

131

Charles W. Morse.

Q. As a matter of fact you gave your own note,
endorsed Col. Egan’s note, and obtained $25,000
from the bank?

A. Yes, sir. ~
_ Q. And the corresponding amount of stock was
issued to you?

A. No. I took $15,000 of the stock and then en-
dorsed Col. Egan’s note for $10,000, for him to take
$10,000 of the stock, taking the stock as collateral
for the note; and when the note became due he
didn’t pay it, and I afterwards did.

By Mr. Wetmore:

Q. You went out to Riverside with Col. Egan
with the amount of cash, in the checks which were
provided for in this contract with Mr. Griffith, and
with the power of attorney that has been read here,
for the purpose of making the payment and receiv-
ing the deeds?

A. Yes, sir. I think every thing was executed on
Saturday, December 30, because there was a great
controversy as to whether January Ist was a legal
holiday, and we were all afraid that Sigafus
wouldn't trade with us. When we got to Riverside
Mr. Egan and I went up to Perris to the mine and
Mr. Griffith remained behind, and we came back
that night or the next morning; and we probably
met Mr. Sigafus the next day—the day after I
arrived there—or possibly in the evening. I went
out to the mine; went down in the miue, pre-
sumably all through it. I went with Mr. Egan and
Mr. Cheatham, I think his name was. He took us
down.

Mr. Jones told me that the company had not made
much money and that I ought to give up the $1v3,-
v00 note. The request that I give it up was verbal.
I gave back the note, and had the mortgage assigned

391

392

393.

394 Charles W. Morse.

132

Redirect-examination by Mr. Stickney:

These four letters are in Mr. Egan’s handwriting,
also (indicating) dated November 13, 1%, 19 and 21,
1893. Those papers were received by me in due
course of mail, as soon as they could reach me after
their dates. These other two I received from Mr.
Egan (indicating) in due course of mail. This tele-
gram I received from him, dated November 29,
1893; they are all in relation to this mine. I placed
dependence upon the statements in these letters,
among other things, in coming to my conclusion to

395 go into the purchase of the property.

Counsel for plaintiffs offers in evidence the
letters and telegram identified by the wit-
ness.

Objected to by defendant’s counsel as not
binding upon the defendant, and as imma-
terial, irrelevant and incompetent. To which
ruling of the Court counsel for defendant
then and there duly excepted.

Marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibits 13, 14, 15, 16
and 17.

Cesar A. Roberts was Colonel Platt’s private
secretary. This letter, dated November 21 (indi-
cating), is in Mr. Egan’s handwriting. This letter
dated Perris, November 21, 1893 (indicating), is in
Mr. Egan’s handwriting.

Counsel for plaintiffs offers in evidence the
two additional letters identified by the witness.

Objected to by defendant’s counsel as not
binding upon the defendant and as imma-
terial, irrelevant and incompetent.

Objection -overruled. To which ruling of
the Court counsel for defendant then and
there duly excepted.

4 Marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibits 18 and 19.

396

133

John L. Hobson. 897

-Joun L. Hosson, called by plaintiffs, sworn and
examined:

I have lived in Haverhill, Massachusetts, over 40
years. [am trustee of an estate. I am also engaged
in the paper business. I am one of the plaintiffs in
this action. I was interested in this purchase. Mr.
Charles W. Morse was the first person who brought
the matter to my attention. It was in 1893, either
the latter part of November or the first part of De-
cember, at my house in Haverhill. He had two
papers, the Burnham report and the Egan report.
These (identifying Plaintiffs’ Exhibits A and C) are j398
the papers. They are the identical papers. I have
no doubt of it. I read them after he left either that
evening or the next day carefully. In coming to the
conclusion to go into this investment I depended
upon the statements in those two reports. In the
Burnham report and in the Egan report. I believed
them to be accurate, so far as I could determine’
about them, and so far as I had any knowledge of
mining matters. The next day I made inquiries
about Colonel Egan. When he (Morse) passed the
papers to me he told me they were reports of a min-
ing property made by Mr. Burnham and Mr. Egan,

, and that they were both mining engineers. Whether
he made that statement voluntarily or as a result of
my questions I don’t know. The result was we then
signed the contract with Mr. Griffith and started a
subscription about the same time.

Q. At that time had-the other subscribers, all of
them, or many of them, come in? :

A. Many of them had. I cannot say whether all
of them had or not. But we took the responsibility
on our shoulders of raising the necessary money. I
put in $15,000, my subscription, and I contributed
$15,000 in anticipation of the payments by the other
subscribers who had not yet paid in their money.
This I did before Morse went to California to take

the deeds and pay the money. I loaned Egan $5,-

399

134 |

400 John L. Hobson.

000. I took his note endorsed by James H. Platt,
and one-third of his holding in the shares of the
company as collateral. The endorsement of Colonel
Platt was put on later. Then I, with Mr. Porter
and Mr. Morse, executed the agreement with Griffith
that has been put in evidence here; and executed
the power of attorney. I contributed the payment
of my subscription and $15,000, and that $15,000
which I contributed in anticipation of payments by
subscribers was afterwards returned to me. So
that my payment and interest in the mine was
401 $15,000.

Q. Did you show these same reports to other peo-
ple who invested?

A. I did, that is to some of them. I mainly put
my dependence on coming to my decision on the
statements in the Burnham report of the twelve
months’ mill run; the statements of ore reserve in
the summary at the end; and the expense account
for those twelve months, as given in detail, which
was part really of the twelve months mill run,
although stated in a different place in the report.
In the Egan report I mainly depended upon the
statement with which he opens his report, that his
examination thoroughly substantiated—I may not
use the exact words—the Burnham report which
had been submitted to us; his twenty-five ton test
mill run, which he made down there—that is, the
result from it; and his confirmation substantially
of the ore reserves as given in the Burnham report.

402

Cross-examination by Mr. Johnson:

Q. Did you rely on any other statements in mak-
ing your investment than you have testified to this
morning?

A. I think the general tone of the report may
have influenced me, but the specific statements—
with the exception of perhaps the bullion returns,

- 136

John IL. Hobson.

which I think I omitted to state—attracted my at-
tention.

Q. Nothing definite other than what you have
testified to?
A. No, sir.

By the Court:

Q. Do you remember whether Mr. Morse showed
you any letters that he had got from Colonel Egan?

A. No, sir; hedid not. Referring, of course, your
Honor, to the letters that have been submitted
here?

Q. Yes, sir.

A. No, sir; I never saw those.

(Witness continuing). There is no signature to
the Burnham report, Exhibit “‘A.” I noticed that
then. I think I noticed, also, that there was no
date. At the time I made my investment I under-
stood that paper spoke from a date subsequent to
the twelve months’ mill return. I had no more
definite idea than that. I don’t think I made any
inquiries in regard to it. The specific things that
I have testified —that I relied on in that report—are
contained in what is called a summary, at the end.
I understood that that summary was a summary
of that paper at the time. I did not look to see, in
the sense of verifying, but I read that paper
through.

Q. Did you put any reliance in that paper, aside
from Mr. Egan’s report?

A. The credit that I gave to this paper—this
Burnham report—was based on the information
that I had from Mr. Morse or Mr. Egan, or both,
that this was a report made by a Mr. Burnham, a
mining engineer, and the confirmation which Mr.
Kgan’s report gave to this report.

Q. You did put some reliance in that, then, other

than Egan’s confirmation of it?

403

404

405-

407

408

136°
John L. Hobson.

A. To that extent, I did. I hope I am careful in
my investments. If I find that a paper is inconsist-
ent in itself, [ do not place reliance upon it, as a
paper, without explanation or confirmation from
other sources. The twelve months’ mill run that I
have spoken of as contained in that summary is
$57,000 in round figures. I understood that that
was asummary of something in the report itself. I
read the statement in the report with reference to
this mill run. It isin the body of the report, where
he has a written statement in regard to the mill run.
There is also 4 statement in the report at another
place, in the ore reserves, where he alludes to this
same millrun. I noticed that there was a table
on page 9 of the report, giving returns of gold bul-
lion from the United States Assay Office. I think
it is the only table in the paper giving those returns.
I did not look at that paper to see how many dollars
there was there. I have since. I think about
$48,000. The first date in that table is March 4th,
1890, and the last February Ist, 1892; March, April
and May of 1891. Those returns appear on their
face to be for a portion of the year 1890, and for
the year 1891 and a portion of the year 1892. Those
were the only bullion returns given in detail in the
report. ;

Q. If you had noticed that the bullion returns
did not bear out the statements in the summary,
at the time, you would not have relied upon that
statement in the summary, would yout

A. At that time I did not connect these returns
as being the identical returns of that mill run.

Q. So that if you had read the reports at that
time carefully, you would have noticed that it cou-
tained a mistake in regard to that question, would
you not?

A. I should have found a discrepancy.

Q. A very serious discrepancy, is it not?

A. Well, I should regard it so. I relied in this

a 137

John L. Hobson. 409

report upon the statement of ore in reserve -
—the exposed portion, that could be measured ac-
cording to the recognized principles of engineers.
T understood that was a statement of the judgment
of the engineer who made the examination. I re-
lied on the judgment of the engineer; in the Burn-
ham report—on Mr. Burnham’s judgment. I never
heard of him before; only as I heard of him from
Mr. Egan and Mr. Morse. His name is not signed.
I had before me the report of an engineer as to the
ore in reserve that was signed, and whom I had
= 410

Q. Which did you rely on?

A. I was influenced by both of them. At the
time I made my investment I understood that Mr.
Egan’s report was some time subsequent to this
paper that I call the Burnham report. I was buy-
ing the mine on the representations as to what his
judgment was of the contents of the mine at the
time of the examination for Egan’s report. I sup-
posed that the Burnham report was made at leasta
year and a half before that. I relied upon the ex-
pense account in the Burnham report as being part
of that mill run. I relied upon it as stating the
cost to take ore out. That was the only thing that
I relied on in making my investment. so far as the
expenses of running were concerned.

Q. (Egan’s report shown witness.) I will -ask
you if you read on page 4of the report that you
have called the Egan report, and on page 5, the cost
of production which he gives?

A. I suppose I did, for I read the whole report.

Q. You did not rely on this statement, ‘That
the mine is not as expensive as the ordinary mine
to work, from the fact that the walls are hard and
regular, and that the dip of the lode relieves the
stulls from weight,” did you?

A. I don’t think I did.

411

412

413

414

—

138
John L. Hobson.

Q. You did not rely upon his statement that
‘* Miners receive $2.50 a day and trammers $2}

A. No, sir.

Q. Or upon his’statement as to the cost of timber
at the mine?

A. No, sir.

Q. Or as to the cost of coal at the mine?

A. No, sir; not specifically.

Q. Nor as to the price of breaking ground on
contract and drifting?

A. No, sir.

Q. Nor upon his statements of the actual cost of
his mill run?

A. Of course, I took the cost——

Q. Did you or didn’t you?

‘A. Certainly, the cost of his mill run was a
factor.

Q. Did you rely upon his statement that, ‘I con-
sider $2.35 a ton a fair amount to be charged to
the cost of production per ton through the whole
mine”?

A. I suppose that might have had an effect upon
me.

Q. But you do not know whether it did or not?

A. No, sir.

Q. You mean this Court to understand that you
relied upon a statement of cost of production ina
paper that had no siguature and bore no date, and
whose reputed maker you had never seen, and
which spoke of a time a year and a half prior to
your investment, and did not rely upon a state.
ment as to the cost of production in this mine, or
an estimate of it, made by an engineer whose
paper, signed and dated, you had, and whom you
had talked with about the mine?

A. I mean to say that I relied upon the Burnham
report as confirmed by Colonel Egan.

Q. Will you answer that question?

Q. (Repeated. )

139

John L. Hobson.

A. If Lmay be allowed to use the language of
the Court, I should say that I did not analyze these
things as I should if I had expected to make a loss
upon it, and I was governed by the general state-
ments of these reports. My note for $15,000 ad-
vanced was paid after the first of Januar, 1894, as
subscriptions came in. So far as I know, all the
money paid by Egan for his stock was loaned by
me and Mr. Morse.

Redirect-examination by Mr. Stickney:

Q. The term ‘mill run” has been used here.
Which did you intend to apply it to—to that period
of about a year where the production of the mine
was given, or to the mill run made by Colonel
Egan?

A. I was influenced by both of them.

Q. But how did you use the term?! You spoke,
and I understood Mr. Johnson to speak, of ‘‘ mill
run.” We have been using the term ‘‘ mill run” as
applied to Colonel Egan’s test there of three or four
days?

A. When we have had the Burnham report I
have spoken of the twelve months’ run, and with
Egan’s report I have referred to the twenty-five
ton test mill run.

Q. As to the Burnbam report, you mean to use
that term about the twelve months’ reported
product?

A. Yes, sir; where the return was $57,000 and
the expenses $15,000, showing a net profit of about
$40,000.

By Mr. Johnson:

Q. At what time was that? :
A. Twelve months prior to February, 1892.

415

416

417

418 William Foster.

WiLuiAM Foster, on plaintiff’s behalf, by deposi-
tion, testified as follows:

I reside at Boston, Massachusetts. I am a mining
engineer and metallurgist. I took the prescribed
course of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology
in the Mining Department. Was assistant to Pro-
fessor Richards at the Institute of Technology three
years in the Mining Department. I have since been
superintending the working of mines and smelters
and metallurgical works and work for the Govern-
ment on the Tenth Census. Examination of ores

419 for the Tenth Census under the United States
Geological Survey. I have been superintendent of
gold and copper mines. The Columbia Mine, in
Ward District, Colorado; the Glades Mine, in
Georgia, and the Good Hope Mine, in California.
Most of my work has been expert exaniination of
mines for prospective buyers in their interest, to
examine as to merits of properties whether it was
proper investment to buy or not to buy. | was
general superintendent of smelting works in Pue-
blo, Colorado. I have done everything from sharp-
ening the steel in the blacksmith’s shop to putting
in timbers and striking the drill, loading the holes
and running the cars—everything that is done un-
der the ground. In all together I have probab),
worked two years under ground io that way at the
miners’ work. Then I have been around it about
twenty years of time. Last twenty years mining
has been my regular occupation, and I have given
my entire time to it. I arrived at the Good Hope
Mine the 11th of December, 1894, and immediately
took charge. I succeeded Colonel John Egan, and
remained until March 5th, 1895. On arrival at the
mine I made a general examination of it. I went
all over the surface to examine the surface indica-
the hoisting plant and mill and all the appli-

420

tions;

ances. connected with the mine, and then I went
under ground to look through the different old and

141
William Foster.

new workings. I found the mine opened by an in-
cline, which was the only meats of taking ore out
from the mine, about practically 500 feet deep, I do
not remember exactly to the foot, and from that
incline there were three levels; the first one at
950 feet deep, the second one 100 feet deeper—
that would be 350 feet—and the third one
100 feet deeper again, making 450 feet to
the lowest level, and below that there was
asump for collecting the water. The upper level
was practically 1,100 feet long, 250 feet south
from the shaft and about 800 feet north from it;
and the second level I do not remember the exact
distance north, but it was a little over 250 feet
eouth—there was nothing in that; no ore in that;
so I did not pay much attention to it. The third
level was about 250 feet in length south and 64 or
65 feet north from the shaft. 250 feet south of
this incline was another incline which went down
as far as the first level, but it was-not rigged to
hoist any ore; there were no appliances there for
hoisting; we simply used it as a passageway for
the men, and sent down some timbers there. About
400 feet north of the main incline there was another
incline which ran down to the first level; there
was no hoisting apparatus on that; it gave ventila-
tion and gave access to the mine for a few of the
hands that went down those two separate shafts.
There was one block of ground between the second
and third level south of the main incline containing
three or four thousand tons which Egan had
blocked out. but it was not ready to stope at the
time I arrived there. The rest of the mine had no
ore ready for extraction, practically no ore; there
were little bunches here and there which we took
out, but no regular stoping ground open. Ore in
reserve is ore so opened that it can be measured
or taken out anytime as wanted, ore prepared
ahead for mining. There was some ore above the

421

422

423

424

425

426

142
William Foster.

first level both north and south of the shaft, but not
in a shape to measure it up and give any accurate
tonnage of it. It was small portions mostly where
the meri found it broken up into small stringers;
sometimes it would be in quite a little body, but
they were small bunches. Between the second and
third level north the ore had not been touched.
Between the first and second level the ore had been
worked out as far as the levels went. The ore had
practically all been taken out 70 feet above the
first level; from there to the grass roots the main
portion of the ore was in place. It was danger-
ous ground, a man was liable to lose his life there”
any minute, and it was never measured to the top,
to measure it exactly; in some places it was, but
the whole space was never measured by me; they
were old stopes that were shaky and it was hard to
get a man to [go there at all. We had one man
nearly killed before I went there, and one man
badly hurt afterwards. The ore body in the mine
is quartz mainly. Some of the rock surrounding
that quartz is soft material deconiposed granite,
and in some parts of that mine carries value. Be-
tween the second and third level south the quartz
was in a very fair continuous vein, only in one or
two places it was spilt up, but above the first level,
above these old stopes, the vein was broken up into
a number of quartz veins, varying in thickness
from two or three inches, or a stain up to three
feet which was the largest I saw there. In the
surrounding ground the granite is what we call
underground, blocky. It would come out in great
big chunks, so that in order to take out eight
inches of quartz you were obliged sometimes to
take twelve or fifteen feet of waste rock. It would
come out itself and it took a great deal of timberto
hold it in addition to being quite dangerous to the
men. There were no cases in those old stopes
above the first level where there was no quartz at —

143
William Foster.

all. A great deal of that quartz though did not
carry gold enough to pay to work; one vein would
be good, and sometimes another. You never could
tell which one was the one you wanted to follow;
you follow ita little way and the value would
cease. The main portion of work while I was
there was done on the ground between the second
and third level south of the main hoisting incline
that was on the stoping ground. Then I hada
party of men driving a contract on the first level
north, and we also in the new ground that we
opened put in the stulls and started stopes on that
level, and before I came away we also started
stopes in the third level north, where we had a
body of quartz which showed in the back of the
drift. We took ore from all portions of the mine,
but nearly all the ore we worked in the mill
- came from the second and third level south of the
incline. I had one or two men on each side of the
shaft on first level almost all the time I was there,
prospecting around and getting out all the bunches
of ore they could. The average bullion value per
ton of the ore that I took out of the mine while I
was in charge of it was practically $10 a ton; the
average value of the ore between the first level and
the surface I suppose would be $8 to $9. I got the
best ore between the second and third level south
of the shaft, the cheapest mining and the best
quality of rock. -Ore chutes are the richer portions
of the vein. The proportion in quantity the ore
contained in ore chutes bore to the general ore
body of the mine was between a fifth and a sixth.
The average per ton was about $10 in the chutes
and I should say $5 or $6 outside. Total average
value of ore taken out was $10 and a fraction a ton.
The average value per ton of the entire ore body of
the mine was $7 to $9. I made formal reports to
the home office once a month. Three inall. They
are accurate statements of what they contain.

427

428

429.

430 Willism Foster.

Reports received for identification.

The average value per ton in December was
$10.49. The average cost per ton of producing was
$10.70 aton. The average value per ton in January
was $12.71. Cost of: production, $12.01 per ton.
The average value per ton in February was $10.84;
cost, $12.36. Ido not think the mine was worth
much of anything when I went there. Leaving
out the mill I would not set it at over $10,000.

Cross-examination:

431 The three mines I had worked before had well-
defined walls, and we took out all the vein. In the
Good Hope the walls were mostly well defined.
The quartz, instead of being in one vein, was in
several which branched out from the original, and
each one of those veins had its own foot and hang-
ing walls. The character of the wall between the
different sections of the vein and between the
outermost walls, foot and hangings, we designated
blocky ground; it was in large and small blocks
which would slip out. It was altered granite. The
altered granite between the main foot wall aud the
main hanging wall was softer; the foot wall was
very hard in that mine and the hanging wall soft
and shaky. The main hanging wall was not well
defined. In places it was. The distance between
the hanging and the foot wall varied from nothing
to five or six feet. Between the first and second
levels on the north end it was nothing but a stain,

Q. State with some definiteness where this was.

A. I cannot give it to you in feet and inches.

Q. Was it north of the shaft, or south?

A. There are plenty of places in the mine in the
south end where there is no show of any ore,
pinches out to nothing.

Q. Were there any such places north of the main
shaft between the first and second levels!

A. Yes.

432

145
William Foster.

Q. How many?

A. There was one, quite a long piece of ground;
I cannot give it to you, the place, it was all stulled
up as though it was good ground, but in fact there
ig nothing in it as far as you can see on the
outside.

Q. How far does this state of relative positions of
the walls continue at that point!

A. Well, that is all timbered up and I could not
follow it the whole way, but I imagine, from the
way the timber is put in there, it is perhaps two or
three hundred feet; you can see it at each end and
in the middle. .

Q. Was there any point south of the main shaft
between the first and second levels where this state
of affairs existed?

A. Yes.

Q. Whereabouts?

A. About 250 feet at the south end of those drifts
it is the case.

Q. Do you mean 250 feet from the main shaft?

A. From the main hoisting incline.

Q. How long a space is there there?

A. Ido not know how long. They ran right into
dead ground and stopped.

Q. Between the main shaft and the incline or
shaft south of the main shaft how much of this
ground was there?

A. I should not say there was any. I examined
the surface of the ground on first going out there
and found the quartz outcropping in a few places;
mainly south of the south incline, extending along
for six or eight hundred feet along the line of it.
There had been a few holes sunk there, I do not
know how deep. They were some distance south.
The ground, as I walked over it north from the
south opening, was largely waste that had been
thrown out, taken out from the mine and from
prospect holes which had been sunk along there.

433

434

435

146

William Foster.

The ground was adobe. Going south from the
south shaft that is more rocky there, country rock

scattered around more. 1t was rock scattered

437

438

around and also rock that outcropped there.

Q. How much cropping of rock is there south of
the south shaft, and how closely?

A. There are a good many points, I could not tell
you how much; a good many points where you can
see country rock. I do not think I could follow
these outcropping of country rock at all north.

Q. When you arrived at the mine did you find
the vein between the second and first level stoped
out? Was this stoping clean from the end to the
hanging wall south of the main shaft?

A. Yes, the ground was all taken out there.

Q. Had it been stoped clean along the foot wall
between: the second and first level south of the
main shaft?

A. Yes,

Q. You are positive about that?

A. Yes.

Q. How did you ascertain that fact?

A. I went through the stope, the old stopes.

Q. When you arrived at the mine did you find it
had been stoped clean to the hanging wall between
the second and first levels and north of the main
shaft?

A. If I may be allowed to remark, that question
of yours cannot be answered. Your definition of
hanging wall and mine may be a very little differ.
ent. What I call the banging wall in the mine
there is as far as the ore pays to take out; strictly a
geological hanging wall I do not think it was. That
ground was all worked before I went there; I could
not see it; I did not see that work. I do not know
whether it was stoped clean to the strictly geological
hanging wall of that vein, nor whether it was stoped
within six feet of it; I do not.

147

William Foster.

Q. Do you know anything about what was stoped
between those two levels and those two shafts?

A. Of course I don’t; I was not there.

Q. You testified on your direct-examination that
it was all stoped out. Will you please reconcile the
two statements?

A. Probably I don’t give the right terms to con-
vey iny Meaning. What appeared to be the ground
occupied by the vein once—I do not say there was
any vein there—it was taken out.

How do you know it was?

. Icrawled through it!

Whereabouts did you go through at the levelt
. Icrawled through the stopes.

. Did you go through at. the level?

. I went through the level.

_ At that point was the distance between the
foot and the hanging wall excavated hard?

A. Between the first and second it was in places.

Q. Did the level occupy the whole space between
the foot and hanging wall?

A. Lshould consider so; of cvuurse I do not know
how far the vein may have been there.

Q. Do you know whether it did or not?

A. I would like to be sure of your meaning; I
know what I conclude to be your meaning.

Q. Do you know whether you did or not?

A. Yes, I should consider it was—in the level
it is.

Q. How did you get from the level into the stope
when you crawled through it?

A. Climbed up through the mill bole.

Q. Was the opening of the stope you crawled
through parallel, or nearly so, with the level?

A. Yes.

Q. How far above it was it!

A. It ran up to the next level above—100 feet.

copropropreo

Q. How near was the horizontal opening of the

stope that you crawled through to the level above?

439

441

442

443

148
William Foster.

A. I did not crawl through any horizontal open:
ing; I went right through the mill hole from one
level or down the other; you could go either way,

Q. The only portion of that stope you went
through, then, were the mill holes that went
through from one level to another?

A. No.

Q. What others did you go through?

A. The places between the mill holes.

Q. What was the nature of those openings?

A. An open stope with stulls in it.

Q. Where you went into the opening that was
stulled, was the distance between ‘the foot of the
hanging walls of the mine excavated clean!

A. I should think so.

Q. What was in the stope at the parts of it that
you did not see?

A. I do not know what was in that.

Q. Was there much of this stope that you did
not see

A. No, I should net think there was.

Q. Had the ore been stoped clean from the hang-
ing to the foot wall from level to level south of the
main shaft?

A. Ido not know that. I do not know whether
it had been stoped clean along the foot wall
throughout the entire stope or for a quarter of it;
nor whether it had been stoped clean to the foot
wall throughout half that stope or a quarter of it.
I do not know whether it had at all in that stope.
I do not know whether the ore had been stoped
clean to the hanging wall in any vein in that
stope.

Q. You have testified that it was entirely stoped
in your direct examination between those two
levels and between those two shafts; how do you
reconcile your direct testimony witb your testi-
mony now as to these facts?

A. Iconsider that they had been stoped out, al-

149
William Foster.

thongh I could not be sure of it; I say now, I con-
sidered that ground worked out.

Q. Do you now wish to correct your direct ex-
amination by omitting that section of the mine?

A. No. As to the space north of the main shaft
between the first and second levels, I do not know
whether the ore in that ground had been stoped
clean to the foot wall throughout the entire space
or throughout half the space, or throughout a quar-
ter of the space.

Q. Do you know whether it had been stoped
clean at all to the foot wall in that space?

A. Yes.

Q. For how much of it?

A. The greater part of it, I should consider; that
is my opinion; I do not say I know it.

Q. Do you know whether the ore in this last sec-
tion of mine, to wit, the section north of the main
shaft between the first and second levels, had been
stoped clean throughout that section to the hanging
wall?

A. I should think so.

Q. Do you know?

A. No, I don’t. I do not know whether it had
been stoped clean throughout half or quarter of
that section to the hanging wall.

Q. What examination, if any, did you make to
find out as to what had been stoped out of that
section of mine?

A. I went through those stopes for the purpose
of seeing what there was there, and what there was
not there?

Q. Did you go through the second levels north of
the main shaft?

A. Yes.

Q. Was that dug out from the foot to the hang-
ing walls throughout this entire course?

A. No.

445

446

447

449

450

150
William Foster.

Q. Was it dug out to the hanging wall through
any of its course?

A. That I do not know.

Q. Was it dug out to the foot wall through any
of its course?

A. I should say so. A large proportion of it.

Q. Which end, if either?

A. A large proportion of it was taken out; the
greater portion.

Q. Your testimony as to whether the second
level north of the main shaft had been excavated
the entire width of the cavity between the foot and
hanging walls throughout the entire length has
been read to you; have you any corrections to
make to it?

A. The level is cut into both the foot and hang-
ing wall in most places.

Q. Do you know whether the ore north of the
main shaft and between the first and second levels
had heen stoped clean to the foot wall?

A. I should consider so. I did not see that work
done, but I should consider it so.

Q. Do you know?

A. No, I don’t know.

Q. Do you know whether through half of the
space it had?

A. I should think it had.

Q. Do you know?

A. No.

Q. Do you know whether it had through quarter
of the space?

A. No.

Q. Do you know whether the ore had been
stoped clean through this section of the mine to the
hanging wall through the whole space!

A. No.

Q. Do you know whether it had through half or
a quarter?

A. No.

—_agameeemacint

William Foster.

151

Q. Was this space that had been stoped between
the first and second levels and north of the main
shaft all done when you went through it?

All that I went through was.

Can you answer that question ves or not
No.

How much of it was open?

_ Seventy-five per cent.

What, if anything, filled the rest of the space?
A. Waste.

Q. You testified that the portion of the mine
above the first level south of the main shaft was
dangerous to work in; was that true at the time

ou were out there?

A. North of the shaft.

Q. Was it true south of the shaft?

A. Not very; that was not very bad. It was
dangerous to work north of the shaft, on account
of the danger of falling rock from the roof of the
stope.
Q. Did this rock that was likely to fall, or did
fall, in this portion of the mine come from the vein
or from the hanging wall?

A. The conntry rock. It was the hanging wall,
the country rock of the country; there was a vein
behind the rock which fell and wrecked that por-
tion of the mine and made it dangerous to work in
in some places.

Q. From what portion of the mine did you take
ore while you were out there, other than the chute
or chutes that you testified to?

A. From the north end of the first level and from-
the streaks of ore above the first level and north of
the shaft or the main incline. We did take some
above the first level south of the shaft, very small
in quantity though; those are the only places ex-
cept the chutes.

Q. What proportion of the ore that you tock was
taken from these places other than the chates?

Cropper

454

455

456

152

William Foster.

A. Those weights were not kept separate, so I
shall have to estimate it. I should estimate it was
a tenth came from other portions of the mine than
that portion between the second and third level
south of the shaft.

Q. What was the average richness of the ore, the
entire ore, that you mined and milled while you
were out there?

A. About ten dollars.

Q. Icall your attention to the items in Exhibits 1.
2 and 3, showing the average production for the
months of December, 1894, and January and Feb-
ruary, 1895, to be $10.49, $12.71 and $10.84 respec-
tively; is that the average for the entire amount of
ore that you took out?

A. Yes.

Q. You testified that the average of all the ore
body in the mine would have averaged about $9;
what do you mean by all the ore body in fixing that
average?!

A. I mean all of the ground which I had any-
thing to do with in extracting ore.

Q. Do you mean the average of the ore you ex-
tracted!

A. No.

Q. What do you mean?

A. I mean all which was opened up by me or be-
fore I went there which I could mine.

Q. Now, do you include in that average the ore
which you took out?

A. In the $7 to $9, yes, and I include some that

‘I did not take out.

Q. Did you include all that you took out!

A. Yes.
Q. What ore did you include that you did not

take out?
A. Ore above the first level north, and-also on the

third level north.

153
William Foster.

Q. How do you determine the value of that ore
in fixing this average?

_ A. By taking it out, some of it, and testing it by
panning and with my eye.

Q. Did you measure the vein throughout this
level from which you took these panning!

A. With my eye; no other way.

Q. What was the width of the pay streak at or
at the nearest point to the shaft north of it?

A. There was no pay streak; there was no pay
in it.

Q. What was the width of the ore streak?!

A. It varied from three inches to two feet or two
and a half feet. I did not take any measurements
except with the eye.

Q. Is there any other way of fixing the value of
ore in reserve approximately without first ascer-
taining the average width of the ore and vein?

A. No, I should think there was not. I should
think there was no other way.

Q. How did you fix the average value of the
ore in reserve or the ore opened up which you have
included in your average above the third level north
of the main shaft?

A. I did not fix it.

Q. Did you include that in your average?

A. Only the samples that you asked—carried
nothing—thegee few samples I took from there and
they did not have any gold.

Q. Did you find any gold in the 350 foot level
north of the main shaft?

A. Yes.

Q. Exhibit 1, the report for December, do you
know whether the statements in that report are
true or not?

A. Yes; they are; all of them, to my knowledge.

Q. Will you look at the report for December, Ex-
hibit 1, and say whether it is your testimony that

457

458

459

461

462

154

William Foster.

all the statemeuts in that report are true to your
knowledge?

A. All but one, and that may be. I don’t under.
stand it—that is, oneitem. The item here put in
by Wilson of permanent improvements and water
developments; that I don’t know about.

Q. What time did you go out to the mine!

A. The 5th day of December.

Q. You have testified in your direct-examination
that you arrived there on the 11th?

A. 1 did get there on the 11th; I got mixed up
with my dates; I left on the 5th of March.

Q. Do you know what took place before the 11th
of December in the mine?

A. No, except by hearsay.

Q. Do you know how many tons of ore were ex-
cavated before the 11th of December?

A. Only from the account; no other way.

Q. Do you know how much waste and quartz
was hoisted before the 11th?

A. Only from the account.

Q. Do you know how much of the product of
the ore was retorted before the 11th of Decem-
ber?

A. Only from the account. One week’s retort
appears there, $874.26.

Q. Do you know whether that $874.26 was the
retort product of your mine in December?

A. Only from the account. I do not know; I
was not there.

Q. It is not true, then, is it, that you know the
statements of Exhibit 1 to be true, all of them, of
your own knowledge?

A. I expect that is so.

Q. Do you know any of them to be true?

A. Yes, I do.

Q. How many skips were there at the mine at
that time?

: 155

William Foster. 463

A. Three; there were only two that were fit for
use.

Q. Did they all hold the same amount of ore#

A. Practically, yes.

Q. How many cubic feet of ore did the skins
hold?

A. I never measured them to see.

Q. That is three skips to a ton, is it?

A. Yes.

Q. How did you fix that number of skips to the
ton?

A. We weighed it. 464

Q. All of it or only a porticn of the rock?

A. We weighed it at different times—skip loads.

Q. I notice that the number of tons of quartz
crushed is identical with the number of tons of ore
produced and does not include the mine waste, what
was the mine waste spoken of that was hoisted?

A. Rock carrying no value.

Q. Was the ore sorted before it was milled?

A. Yes. That was the usual method of milling—
always as far as I know.

Q. In a true fissure should the foot wall be well
defined or substantially so?

A. Yes; 1 should think so.

Q. Iv a true fissure should the hanging wall be
well defined or substantially so?

A. I should consider so; yes.

Q. Do you know whether the space above the
first level, both north and south, had been exca-
vated to the hanging wall, where excavations had
been made at the time you went out?

A. No.

Q. In your work above the third level, did you
excavate to the surface of the fissure, which would
constitute its upper wall?

A. Yes.

Q. Completely ?

A. Yes.

465.

466

467

468

156
William Foster.

Q. Are you sure that those show the whole dis-
tance between the main shaft and the south shaft?

A. In the work that I did; yes.

Q. Did you so excavate where you took out min.
eral in other places in the mine than the block
south of the main shaft and below the second
level?

A. Yes.

Q. You are sure that you did so at all places that
you excavated?

A. We took out the whole of ‘each crevice that
we worked on.

Q. Completely to the true hanging wall of the
fissure?

A. Yes.

Q. When you so excavated above the first level,
did you find that at the points where you com-
menced the excavation in the stopes it had been
especially excavated to the true hanging wall of the
fissure?

A. Casually, I should say yes. I did not pay much
attention to what other people have done. [should
consider that to be so, though I don't know.

Q. Do you remember any places where it was

‘not so?

A. No.

Q. When you testified that the distance between
the foot and hanging walls in the section of the
mine between the first and the second levels was
sometimes no more than a stain, did you mean that
that was the distance between the fissure walls!

A. Yes.

Q. Do you mean to testify that at any place north
of the south shaft and above the first level, there
are any places in the mine where the two fissure
walls abut so near together that the distance is
merely a streak?

A. No.
Q. Was there any other places in the mine where

William Foster. 469

157

the true fissure walls approached nearer than two
feet other than the section of the mine between the
first and second levels and north of the main shafté

4. Yes. In the third level both sides of the shaft
was so; not throughout theirentiredistance. When
they went through with the shaft there was no
vein there. They ran cut south practically to the
end of what is the present tunnel, or was when |
left there, and there was very little overhead, a
good deal less than two feet, I believe, all the way;
I do not believe there was a point where it was be-
tween the main shaft and a point 250 feet south. I 470
mean the distance between the walls of the fissure
was less than two feet, which would be the quartz
crevice. Besides the places on the third level and
between the first and second levels north of the main
shaft, there was a place on the first level north, at
the north end of it where the fissure was as narrow
as two feet.

Q. What is the gangue in mining terms?

A. Is it usually meant now as the rock which ac-
companies the ore in the vein, which is either bar-
ren or practically barren of what you are seeking
for.

Q. It is the rock in a fissure vein that lies be-

tween the walls of the fissure aside from the ore- 471
bearing rock?

A. Yes.

Q. In the portion of the mine that you exca-
vated did you break the gangue clean to the hang-
ing and foot walls?

A. Yes.

Q. Throughout your entire work?

A. Took the whole crevice; all there was.

Q. Can you answer the question yes or not

A. That answers it.

Q. All the gangue, did you?
A. Yes; all there was in the crevice; we took
everything from wall to wall.

473

474

158
William Foster.

Q. Is it true that you broke out where the veins
split; sometimes one vein and sometimes anothert

A. Yes; and we broke just as little of the rock
between as we could. That was impossible in most
cases.

Q. What was the effect upon the excavation that
you made as to its sides—of that sort of work; did
it leave the foot wall clean as you worked!

A. It would leave the foot wall of whichever
streak we carried on the foot. It would leave the
foot out of that streak.

Q. Was there a foot wall of the entire mine, as
distinguished from the foot walls of separate
veins?

A. I don’t think there was.

Q. Did you do any excavation that would deter-
mine that in your mind, or make any observations
that would determine that in your mind?

A. I feel convinced in my mind that there was
none.

Q. Was there any hanging wall to the mine, as
distinct from the hanging wall of particular veins,
when there were several veins?

A. I don’t think there was. In distinction to
the hanging wall to each stringer that came in
there I thfnk there was not.

Q. Did you ever excavate more than one vein
where the vein was split?

A. Yes. I found a foot wall under the lowest,
and another under the next above it.

Q. Was that foot wall under the next above it
continuous up and down, or did it terminate where
the vein united again at one or more points?

A. Lcannot conceive of a case of its being per-
manent, continuous—if they are all branches of
one vein it is an impossibility. ;

Q. What breaks are there now under the lowest
of the foot walls you have testified tot

159

William Foster.

A. It goes down in steps in some places; goes
down in one plain off-set.

Q. Are there any portions where the rocks of the
foot wall is not continuous?

A It is the same rock all the time.

Q. When there is a vein underneath a wall
which extends between two branches of the vein
where it is split, how does that sound compare
with the rock underneath the entire vein?

A. It would vary with the distance between the
two; the sound would not be always the same.

Q. Do you know whether you excavated the
rock in the mine where you did work between the
exterior upper hanging wall of the mine and the
exterior lower or foot wall of it clean?

A. Of each vein we did.

Q. Where there were more than one vein did
yout

A. I don’t know whether we did or not.

Q. In your work do you know whether you
mined the vein which was the best one?

A. No, I don’t. It is a matter of judgment, and
I had to use the best judgment I could on it. A
good part of the month of December was devoted
to getting all stopes ready; there were not any ready
there when I went there, except above the first
level. There was no stope in that ground Egan
blocked out that I ever saw at all; the stulls were
not even put in.

Q. In determining the value of the mines for
prospective purchasers did you take into account
any prospective value of ground beyond the devel-
opment at either end of any of those mines

A. No.

Q. Did you reckon the ore in reserve in making
such determination?

A. Yes.

Q. How far down below the last level did you
usually reckon ore in sight?

475

476

477

478

479

480

160
William Foster.

A. Right on the upper surface of the bottom of
that level. ;

Q. What do you understand ore in sight means!

A. What you can see and what you can measure.

Q. Does it differ from ore in reserve, and if so,
just how?

A. [should not think it differed from the proper
reserves.

Q. Would you take inte account any ore below

‘the lowest level in the mine in appraising it!

A. No, I do not think I should.

Q. Do you reckon any ore below the lowest level
as ore in reserve

A. Not in setting a value for a prospective pur-
chaser.

Q. Do you reckon in setting a value for pro
spective purchaser, the value of any ore beyond the
development at either end of the mine within the

mining Ciaim
A. It would be an exceptional case to cut any
figure.

Q. Are the principles of such estimate well un-
derstood among mining experts?

A. Yes, [think so. It is nota thing that can be
laid down to exact rules; each man has to use the
best judgment he has. It is not a recognized prin-
ciple among reputable mining experts to estimate
the value of ground beyond the development. It
is not a recognized principle among mining experts
to estimate the value of ground below the lowest
developments of the mine.

Q. What was the condition of the mine when
you took charge of it with reference to the work-
manlike manner with which it had been operated!

A. Well, I considered it rather a poor piece of
work.

Q. In what particulars?

A. Well, the hoisting incline was crooked and

small.

161

William Foster. 481

Q. Any others?

A. You could not hoist with the same speed you
could if it were straight, and there was no ladder-
way in it.

Q. Any others?

A. The leves were crooked and poorly broken.

Q. Any others?

A. The balances appeared to be all right.

Q. And as to the excavation, was that done in a
workmanlike manuer?

A. The stopes, I think so.

Q. Did you think that the development had been
carried on in a workmanlike manner at the time of
the excavation?

A. Yes, with the exception of those points that
I have mentioned.

482

Redirect examination by Mr. Ordway:

Q. You were cross-examined at some length as
to the condition of the mine and the work of de-
velopment between the first and second levels both
north and south of the main incline; will you
please state as fully.as may be what examination
or investigation you made, if any, of that region,
with reference to continuing work there?

A. I examined those portions of the mine as any
man would passing through them, and lookiag at
the timbering that was done and the stulls that
were put up, all prepared for stoping, and where |
could get at it from the chutes, I could see the
waste which had been put in for filling when the
ore had been taken out, and the waste had been
put back there to fill up the ground again, but I
was not there to report on the property, and so
never took any steps to take that out and be sure
that all the ore had been taken ‘out of there, or
that ever any ore was taken out, but so far as |
could see it was waste matter put in there to hold

162 bs

William Foster.

the ground; most any mining man would say that
a piece of ore had been taken out.

Q). Are you able to recollect whether north or
south of the main shaft?

A. Both.

Q. Did you make any examination of that por.
tion which lay north?

A. I went through portions of that which were
open and climbed around over the stulls from the
first down to the second level. The ore had always
been taken out, but no waste had been put in
there. Portions of that ground north of that shaft
had been filled and some it was filled during iny
stay in the mine between the first and second level
with waste.

(). How were those levels run out there with
reference to the side walls, or the hanging or foot
walls as they have been called here?

A. They were evidently driven with the idea of
getting the best effect from the powder to take ad-
vanta,e of all the slips which were in the rock
which is done by every miner to make his work as
cheap and rapid as possible. Sometimes both slips
were cat—foot and hanging—and sometimes only
one.

(). Did vou make any enquiries from your pre-
decessor, Col. Egan, or from the foreman at the
mine as to the condition of that portion of the mine
which laid between the second and third level?

A. Yes, [ had a number of talks with Col. Egan,
and almost daily with the foreman; I talked with
regard to the other parts of the mine.

Q. Did you, during the three months that you
were in charge of this mine, take out all of that ore
body which you have mentioned as lying between
the second and third jevels to the south of the main
incline?

A. No.

(). Did you ever measure that ore body!

« —

163

William Foster.

A. No, only by my eye; estimated it.

Q. Why did you not do sot

A. For the reason that it was all I had, and the
main thing was to get it all into the mill; I did not
care how much there was, but to get it into money
value.

Q. What was your object and purpose while you
were superintending and running that mine—what
was the object you had in view?

A. To try and pay off the back debts and
straighten out the mine in a position to go ahead
and pay.

Q. Did you or did you not endeavor to get as
larze an amount of bullion as possible at as small
a cost as possible?

A. Yes.

Q. Why did you take so small a proportion as
you have estimated, a tenth, from the rest of the
mine and not the chutes?

A. It was so expensive for timber, and the
amount of ore produced so small and the risk to
the men, that I simply did a sort of prospective
work in the hope that we would strike some big
patch that we could last for a week or two weeks.
I did not strike any big patch. Referring to the
report of December, 1894, I made up so much of
that is represented work done and expenses prior
to December 11th, when I arrived, from the ac-
counts which were daily turned in to the office from
the mine; the result of the hoisting works and of
conrse of the time-book. It was actually made up
from them. I had no reason for testifying that
they were incorrect.

Where there came a split in the vein into two or
more veins I selected the one that we should work
somewhat by its position to the work which had
preceded it in regard to getting the ore and waste
out; also by samples and testing, we took the ore
of several if they were there. The on» that showed

457

488

489

490

491

492

164

Elbridge G. Wood.

best that looked as if it were getting to enlarge,
we would follow that.

Q. In your judgment’ did the portion of the
claim which lay north of the ends of the levels
have any prospective value? ,

A. Thad no means of determining at all. That
was where I would look for values though.

Q. How about the portion of the claim south of
the end of the level?

A. The same way; there was nothing to desig.
nate its value without doing work under ground.

Q. Was there anything to indicate without work
that there was not any prospective value

A. No.

ELBRIDGE G. Woop, sworn and examined as a
witness for plaintiffs, testified as follows:

[live in Haverhill, Mass. My age is fifty five.
Tam one of the gentlemen who took an interest in
the purchase of this mine

My business is banking since I was eighteen years
old. I was one of the directors and treasurer of
the Good Hope Mining Company, and have been all
thetime. The stock of the Company was issued to
the original associates in the purchase in proportion
to the amounts of money they paid in for the pur-
chase, and one-eighth of the stock was delivered to
Mr. Griffith’s assigns under the agreement. The
$25,000 for machinery, for the mill, as called for by
the agreement, was paid for that purpose. Jobn
L. Hobson showed me a paper called the Burnham
report, and afterwards a paper called the Egan re
port. These Exhibits A and C are the identical
papers that were there in Haverhill shown to me.
I made the memorandum, ** Burnham report,” on
the Burnham report, and the memorandum, ** John
M. S. Egan report,” on the Egan report. Tread the

—

Elbridge G. Wood.

165

Burnham report first, and afterwards the Egan re-
port. It was on the faith of those two reports
combined that I made my investment. Then at or
about that time I obtained some subscriptions from
different associates. The Burnham and the Egan
reports | used in obtaining those subscriptions.

Mr. Stickney: We offer to read the other
subscriptions. So far I have only read in
evidence Mr. Egan’s, Mr. Morse’s, Mr. Por-
ter’s and Mr. Hobson’s. Is there still any
objection to these?

Mr. Wetmore: Yes; objected to as incom-
petent and immaterial, and on the ground
that the plaintiff cannot in this action re-
cover in a representative capacity for an al-
leged deceit practiced upon these other sub-
scribers, at least until there is proof that the
other subscribers we

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386018_0541%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
