# Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Apex Oil Co. v. United States

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386017_1653%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Petition for Writ of Certiorari
- **Published:** January 1, 2010
- **Citation:** 562 U.S. 827

## Text

| Supreme Court, U.S.
, | FILED

\' 09102 3 FEB 23 7010

| No 09° OFFICE OF THE CLERK
eee EFC Sater Cer!

IN ‘THI
Supreme Court of the Hnited States

APEX OL COMPANY. IN«
Petitioner
\
LINITED STATES OF AMERICA

Respondent

On Petition for a Writ of Certiorart
to the United States Court of Appeals
fo) the Se neti > Cull

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

Bruce S. Sperling Thomas ©. Goldstein
hKugene Jd. Frett Counsel of Record
llarvey J. Barnett, Of Paul Gutterman
Counsel Brian Rothschild
scott lk. Hessell AKIN GUMP STRAUSS
Sperling & Slater, PC HAUER & FELD, L.L.P
02 W. Monroe St., Suite 3200 1333 New Hampshire
Chicago, IL, G0603 Ave., NW

Washington, DC 20036-1564
dames V. O’Brien (202) 887-4060
lewis, Rice & Fingersh, L4 tgoldstein@akingump.com

600 Washington Ave
suite % 900)
St. Louis, MO 6310]

February 23, 2010

VV it Li \ : d é ru a

ts _— =. oe _ iid ‘ey — * =r FF Pa ae TT TE
’ - oe

QUESTION PRESENTED

e a i. a
i
RULE 29.6 DISCLOSURI
Petitiones parent mpany } \p it
publicl held mp Own

- I OL SE Se Es Bip! ser wa,

| Lad MO DISCLOSUI
? Va. « ¢ Jj /
rsiuts OD] \ | iC]
| Pi it)! mneWI
« ) INTO) j { A
HI it ()
|
| Qk TI
i, | { | } 7 om j
'
'
j
’ | .
}

ay ep, eee a Ter TT eee

PABLE OF AUTHORITIES

ak VOX Vj é Pe? . “ } i)

“Ye Ys (YOOY) | YG
/ ( per Ci)il ¢

0. 8/-03804-BKC-BI (bankr. 11.0. M

Lu lO. 1990) (5
In re hate / ] ( Wp

M4 F.2d 997 (2d Cir. 199] ia
In re Ch Mlura Corp

Case No. 09-112385 GREG) (filed Man

009) (Bankr. S.D.N_Y.) 5G
In re Lyondell Chem. Co... No. 09-10023 (filed

Jan. 6, 2009) (Bankr. S.D.N_Y.) 65

if ( lorwico Elk

I Md 146 (3d Cir. 1993) ert

Us. 1046 (1994) UO, 34
fons OTL I Honne lal Ksant

1 US. 7% (1991) 1, 26
Veshrip Aft’ VY Ini

916 US. 479 (1996) 0, 27, 28
VUidlay An National Bank, Neu e } \

Vepartment of Environmental Protectio:

174 U.S. 494, 502 (1986) 1g
Vitchell Robert iB) Mario hi Pde ry In

Ol US. 2B8 (1960) af
()} »{ Kova

LOY | P14 (19RD) jp) ;

:
a iT
j Bere
Bt
'
Bini.
+ 1 ]
| » | I I '
,
j i { ry }
j j2 }
. ’ VQ) |
LX | 7 tf ‘
i
j VV}
| 114 Ol
iJ
}
;
'
; j
iA ;
+} i
}
, | : ’
I i]
{
'}
:
j |
b41(a)(1)
4 1) } 1)

— } l (59
|
}
‘ ) i I It! i] i
; ; ff 1
\} i tibial f i I
( i¢,!
ver r
OTHER AUTHORITHI
i i } j st)
f ;) rivl {
ri } | } } ‘
ioT Ti il i
7 . j
nen tI { l
| i ’ ' ' ;

~~ — ee et Ad) 1 Sd ee he
= - _—S ae

lt ell
.

! (1 }
’ ’ Mv . ,
— ‘ bia
; ' ‘
j
VT)} ) ’ } ' ,
ryt ) tif ’
a? t 1)
i { | ‘ | if t |}
; i] ,
P |
‘ teal Oly '
{ i | :

if
| I
|
' ?
}
; f
|
iil
ti] |
|
}
/ {
I f
; ‘

ew. ll
%

( >|
ing
|
I
{
tat
(|
|
‘ |
{ |
i
‘
'

I

ater id Red ta Sastre.
©‘ oy
tse pant demand i Te | t}
( henda | that bil it) i try ' } t }
fir t rhorin i (ial 7 i | i!
payment of clean-up cost Id. da. | ”
} { KCC]

/ (, | 79 | 9G) Chast tut
(ize! uit 4 10] bot not that
ith | } wekKi hed i t }

[ { { bil j i trict V/ }

i | f | | ( I 1) tcl

f 5 j ' :
I [
tia ( lon Wi
{ f tiycaf i
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRI
| i , ,
itl (1)
’ nT 1
i] i iit il l | |
Te (J) } 16d | | 7
| ’ | ti [ i it i] i I
} } il | } } }
| { 8 it i! i
I i] I LO] I pguidal
f | l ll bb il il
i oe i if Lye i ( i
} [ try ( {

I tee 1! mittict

{ { | (fi (oi if VbICH rea

{ hy an 1) ( ma thi ( ir

| a l | ! | I) tT) ter]
ipa debt n [ |

I i }) (| tL ta i] if i ) i
¢ | |

recut « yiddy l

Decause« if i!
(court ruling in
out for resolution

a) | Question

]
'

Irequently eake:

at Povernment

ip) liabulitue it)

Which COrpOration

ronmental liability COrvanlizZe or}

;

rm tbtariee cablon tion ©] | ra

Phe Seventh Cireuit’ Holding That An

tnvironmental Clean-Up Obligation, Absent

\n Alternative Monetary Kemedy, Is Not A

‘Claim’ Cannot Be Reconciled With Qhio t

Aot (i

i) ( ine

md
maou t polluting
if trivou

PELLTATIE

plain] to clean

i

yur Lo ] i¢ } naa ! Lic I yCleHI |
therwisi iPocate healt iret i | |
; } j / ! 1) ¢ » 7)
f f Ljnited tate }
e nec niplicatior ol f il Liye
i , ferpretatio re Ista
| rt of] >] I | f t th
puta right tia i 1) Ol it ¢
a i il ptit bherdat , i i Ih
a ! a Pi iy] held 4 bial blrist (
a> Thye cr ‘ | ila pool lemana |
{ 1) lf 1é | Ltnat I j iT t!
, t lo per ra
paint 1) Il i | le i li ici 14 {
! | (} ] Litiie | i! i pore |
{ | \
ln f rts] if
| ;, i,
| | i ] [ial I l ist
lf) ! i I Lau ripetin [
if | ! it | HO |
il i | i i { ! i |
| ! | tor Car | 1) il
( { | i] / ' ‘
H) if I
f ! le fort in) rid
} haf i for mu f
t| tun ) (| 0)
} i may f Cate
i] ! kT (|

retain i tacatoidit Chiat thre raiment estimate if
PloO million because it did not plate in myUuUNnctvIoNn
ch i rule VOUuld ¢ MOUTALE debtor to flout court
rder mid provide the yovernment with an incentive
c thstain from it duit lo polices iWVirohnmental
ean ly) l thi hop I NaAiItin Out eventual
Dank rtpt procecding Phat make aL Si nd
(lol re Cannot hia mitended ithe) Bat
losanal ruypole (code or the federal Cnvil mnental |
to ehncourams 1c t) iwl i maVIO!

Phe Seventh Cireuit addr ed the text of th
bankrupt Code onk no pa Phe court held
tat a larm did not arise rom the St ol the clean
up oblivation under the lanvuave of the Bank: tpt
(lode the cost to Ape x | hid a right pol the plaintiff]
lo payment lal i (bra ted isertior poryvinal)
But the bracketed phrase — “fof the plaintiff vhich
lhe heart the court reasoning. doe nol appt }
bry thie tatut Phe Code do notin fact require that
th) payment Ly owed to. thre polit tiff’ instead |

Iii Col tye part 1ii Kova that I] it i held h)
the re ‘ | ( PO) (5)

’ I tf] { |

iS ( {in Aova 145% 1 tha {

t « idl it the lepal ce puel ld ha (*4 I l
| Ii ikruptl petition ber] A receiver ha Ie
ppomnted and a trustee h been desiznated with the ust
| | [ Krups [riustec CTie npany I

| f i ft 1! { | i! ret ] yp

{ ‘a thice poe i a Krupp rust

i loth = poco 1 prope , ! hat rm nted im
' ibseg itly resolve V1 I

i I oO derse }) a

reaqitor
right
debtor
quitabl
cl 1i1h)}
lV I]

) (empha

fi] Ciaisé

entitlement equitab|l

Jironmental

hold
trong pre ie

L1rie Latlutlor
yment Pic? cil)

sean

uit we

intended “claim O eChnCOMpa

h the creditor itself is entitled
equitable ana monetal
a “claim
remedy for breach of perlormance to.

remedy

agelinition

thous ht) to

narrowly limit) discharge to the circumstance in
which money will be paid directly to the same party
that holds the equitable right (here, USEPA) rather
than a third party (such as a contractor), but mstead
to broadly Weep burdens on the debtor’s e: Late imnto
the scope of the bankruptcy. An equitable obligation
is a “claim (and thus is subject to discharge) if it i:
capable of being monetized such that it could be
invoked as a basi to deplet a debtor's estate. See 1]
U S.C. § 101(5)(B). As a matter of both the statutory
text and the policy embodied by the Bankruptcy
Code, it makes no difference whether the “equitable
and “monetary” rights are held by one party or two

the drain on the debtor assets is the same A
narrower conception of the right to discharge would
fail to provide the debtor with the “fresh start” that 1

essential to the Code functioning

Phe debtor's clean up obligation (Which thi
( purt held to be dd) chargeable lt} Kovacs) contrast

}

with its ongoing obligation not to pollute (which the
Court held was not di chargeable). At the time of t]

bankruptcy, the state had a legal right (backed by the
power to seize the debtor's assets) to requil thi
debtor in Kova lo expend money to remedy

(

prepetition pollution such an obligation, which
would deplete fhe debtor's estate or burden it
ICCCSSOI no le than the damape award that
Kovacs deemed to be dischargeable, 469 U.S. at 278
casily fits within the archetypal model of a “claim”
that as properly resolved through the bankruptcy
proce By contrast, the prospective injunction that
(he debtor “not maintain a nuisance pollute the

Wate! ot the state. or refuse to remove the source of

la if 2450, amounted to no mor

ized application ol the ordinaa

debtor not Violate Lhe law mn the

the debto) (like (Very Ohne

comply 1} if CONC U to OW

property alter the reorganizatiol

of the court | appeal contrary roudin

dischargeability in bankruptcy depend

ol the equitable remedy | (1h)

hold Live meht to “payment

ergent tatu Chat the eventl
ISSIgN to clean-up obligation
al environmental law USEPA
lor initially addr eet the

not RCRA, but the Clean Water
1201-1576, and CERCLA
both of which contain expr
St recover!
M321); 42 USC. & 9607(a)
tated that, if petitioner did not

t hve POV roment w nuld pray ior th

rennbursement See App
UPA Or) Cone coordinatoy; leat

i , Tf

AIV IST AApex Il Vou Gon t ¢

goings to doit and Were PoOrng

the money trom you be

not follow through on its thre:

‘an-up and seck reimbursement

vividly ilkustrated that the clean

dj charged iy) Clark ; bankrupte'
decision 11) Kovac: In tead

and dratted i comp! mnt to om

y from te pot ible

17tit

‘rnment

re Wdiny

yrdinat

ital 1} ibalitve

Bankrupt (

; I? }
Ai ; 10)
r j
LTOMMmMeCHLAl

Lod. 6]

i

(Court ha

expand thi

|
bal Phu / .
i Leycat ptyh) ( I |
Pron il] l i ft thie
| Bane i } | | {
j fhiil ( 5 KI 7 4 ‘ ;
beat I bil | 1)
I
| ] { tial i] I { { /}
Ao | if { | ‘
DoATIKI Lol | if [ | ( (| f
( ) } i] il I eo)
he i I { { Lf t|
i i ' I { it {| , { i)
] [ rial | {
acti 1] }
t¢) t) | i)
| i } } fee V4

hid i l¢ ral |
i i Lith |
i { : r ‘
| I { j if
j Hi f } } | ;
{ ‘ ; i va
ricatyl i
i it) if 1} ( /
/ / Wi /) , { ,' )
lady | ' r (ade cribbing nitive
between Second and Sixth Circuits) Buri] ‘\.

Matflett, supra, 12 NORTON BANKR. L. ADVISOR 1 (D
O09) (commenting on the clashing decision mid the
CoOnsequent “continuing pol y conundrum ) Ingrid
Michelsen — Hillinges & Mic Ll 6G Hidlinigeer

Enoironmental Affairs in Ba ikruptcy, 12 AM. BANKER

INS L. REV. 33] 120 (2004) (observing that tne ca
law is a “mora and urging thi Court to Lep up to
mat plate and clear lly} Lhe CONLUSION): MeN i]

upra, 6 TULANE ENVTL. L.J. at 67 (‘In the wake of

Ohio | Kova CWO qaifferent appro es On hiaive
irfaced for determining — the bscharpveaby
COVITONH ital inypunction

i The Se venth Circuit held in thi Case thal

claim arise only when the POVETHMEeENL If elf ha ear

right to demand that thie debtor prchy the FC )\ ! rye |

'
Hii!

Mjyrad

it thi

ProspeclLue (jul

{

cilli

if)

thie mchUSIO! that the clean-up obligation 1 a
dischargeabl claim re also id “the ‘Third
Circuit ae on in Jorwico 3 1) apparent conthict
thy thi upreme Courts own holding in Kovacs and
Vith the decision of the xth Circuit in United Stat
f Whi CO Ini } ‘The lhird Circuit dec PO) fla
accordingly been justly criticized because it “deni
ind iWdual debtor a fresh tart and dens bu at
Geptlor the abuilit lO reorpanize in conthet with
lundamental poher Ol bankrupt bi Heid
pra, 56 U0. Pirr. LL. RI it 62
rie mkKNOWlLCdpE ¢ bhict 4 thie Ircut
unite 1 nd require this Court Intervention
Y pAeSLION resented control} Cy) bnancial
respon yilit ] i Mlicant Humbe)
nVvironmental clean 1p) round the pall Unde)
RCRA alone KPA ha Mentined GBo00 facilitv
requiring rective acti hiundred tf additional
{ ire it)) t te clean-up order under othe
federal environmental statutes mnncludiy CinkCLA
Ibi miportance Tt the qu Lio} pre ted
whniicanti pm plified 1) tiie prospect that man
po! Mon with CQIIViFOrniy ntal hiabilitue Will be
driven into bankruptey a i result of the urrent
CCOMOTIMME Pisl ee ee 4 eonard - CGroldpere
SOLA QJuestion 1¢f and the Day of Reckonin: for
fenvo_ronmental Remediation Claims, 9 AM. BANKR. J
1, 46 (2009) (Characterizing the ruling below. a
mnilicant and observin at the dischargeabilit
Ol clean-t pp ordael Will “have linportant Im plicatiol
i Hilo! the chapte: 1 Cast involving environmental
habit that will ( ral be filed a re it of
The ir? «4 ) i buat ) Unfortu ite]

Mn porlance

ving this que

LO provide aocleal

lla ardou: Wa fe and lsant

the Unasked (Juestion

© C1994) ( mpha ] added)

ential that t]
rathe
watlion
third parti
Corporation
Lees

VIPOIING I

rupt

APPENDIX

Appendix to the Petition for a Writ of

Certiorar)

Table of Content:

Pllinois Orde)

bilimot (Orde)

yp/t ey

Appendix

p)
nrel Led Lo thie qaistrict ude hndain wid
mclusion it J Whether thie VETIHMet Claim (

I papuNiclion Nol 7 cl irved Lil bankrupt mad

therelore cannot be renewed ina sub equent lawsuit

(tas iil ait panKruptl Thera nlirmati
(app. il) toa laim an Chapter I] proceed

i hears bie lebtor fron iT) debt that i} ‘
elore eat dete Ql econirm (Ion } | ‘ (

ehined bizaboudat 1) i ¢lain LOa¢ 12) na
Chaim eithes hit to ipyinent (1 (5) ) or
crit) it) beipre iy) OT Ta Case i right ce) in
equitable remedy for breach of perlormance if
react ive ri) irigent t payment nether o1
not ho mght to mn equitable remed j reduced

agyimen 1) Gd, contin ured bnmatured
Hsputled nd puted i} y} i! cured
O1(5)(B). Th rit question the mean of

r) nt }) ment
Is | | 1()] r aoe rehinin eeLemrs i f iil

i { ] house ypabilit { ail i} tip)

} i} ted ( i] A uid ive ) hire moti !
Ompany to do the clean up in order lo compl Nitty
Che myunct nm. te bnate that it w ld have lO p

wh a pan bloO million for the job. though i
might b ity le { It I Oly Ol tlie f } bist Prom
ther contnmbu lo the conta mation
ne natu readil Ol thie tuto) provi n that

e quoted teieat af ule vit r olan equitable « 1iY)

’ thie ent ti the ¢ uifable remed tur if

lo be unobtainable, obtain a money judgment instead
the claim is disch irgeable. if for « kample you have a
decree of pecihy performance (a type of injunction
ind therefore an equitable remedy) that you can’t
enforce because thre property that the decree ordered
the defendant to seil you wa old to someone else
(irom whom, tor whatever reason, you Cannot recove!
it) you are entitled to a money judgement for t hie

i

wheL QO] thie }>! yperty a C/ hey lad, 4 Southwe [

Cor) 4 ONG.2d 35 163, 365 (Und. App.2006)
Vinson t Marton & Associat 159 Ariz. | (64 VP.2d
{se (39-40) (App.1988) fuengasser 1 Jone

rr \pp gag i] iy) 2d 16 949 (1948) and pI

Claim to that ilue | a laim to a rigntl to recelve
payment na I a charge ible It) ear elles

bankruptcy. /n re Daot id 1] l16 (5th
Cor.1993): -noy Irizarry BO i4 (YY (9th
Cir. IAP 1994)

hn pmaailion yyie equitable remedy ueh
| mK pa orde}] It) CLP te ment ca 1) et (Jbe)
Pau 1o6 F.3d 704 fi4 €4th tor.2ann | ae
hepel Buick & GMC Truck. ] 20 F.3d 495, 500
()} (/t] Coir. Z00 fsroad 1x ( oO} Vow Fhe ¢)
115 F.3d 265, 271 and n. 1 (2d ( Ir. 2000), and orde}
( quit itode re itutlioi 1 Pay H Dobl ha
ij ried } { 1ed.199%) ire orde) { pa rnd
ula er dischargeablh cre | te) | pecihy
‘ eplions in the Bankrupt Coa CO, f Ider
Kobert A. Chaps Ltd., 405 | 1 O82, 586-87 (7H
Cor.2005). Bush v. Ta r, 9 i Yd 989, 992-98 (8th
Cir. 1990) (en bai Pha pul byde remedte rm
{ Orde) to | rnot to act, rather than te pa

lKlectronit Crcnile nie i Crarrity, 366 | en { |
In re CM ii / } el j
} (/th ¢ / }
/ (‘; '
( } } () fy (
{ ? ( p Tyye

bierely diy COSL « Bat Cry ia irtuall
1) crag Pyles che (]
| } Tt i} . i cle] | rye j l¢
tril (] ( i yy @rhnment r-1(*) mterest J
Cnvironimental quaiit pore Widhan) |) i |
| tte mr rvanIZavllol j mankriupt Cl die retulmcnt
le-rive ira! ; Lea (, Posaare 1d Phoma I {
Pac Kova ioxic W x Wn Bankrupt

COST it would have had te hiquidate it iid not have
reorpvanized With To a fiupre debt Verhanging it
ind had it liquidated there would be no surviving o1
1c Qr «@rnuit to conduct o7 pay for thy clean iy)
md so the full expense would fall on the government
Mut that 4 just ve iy tnat mn Corrie eC thie
yovernment maipht benelit from the rule that \ pr
pdvociute if) OUNCI not and apparent Lye
ypovernment peleve al present 9 anyway-lor it hi:
taken the Baird-Jackson position in the past (4

riile ad state

|: Corp

»D. Aceto Apricultural Chemica

(2 2d 137 646 (&th Cir. 1989): United States |
Apex Oil) Co 1/33 Supp. Ze 4 953 Nn {
(S.D1H.2006); Office of lenforeement and Comphancee

C2) aa riee nited Leite invironmental Protective

(-die Clie iyice ()] Lyi | ( ()} ecliol {O03 ay
NCE pp ) ((dct.1997) Wi Epa (
Compt mr surces/ po ci Cleanuy
reral | O20 pa (visited J 1 | 2Z0Q09)-that J
better off » Dal ‘ 1 I} { 1 cle ! lipo J hil
dischargveabs
\pr hake Lyie Uline ed yume nt Lia Lhe
biyunetion | mue (itis) and that Jtule G5fd) of the
i rule requir (and it does) that an imyunction
Leake { beriy pecihically 1d GQesceripe i!
yrasabole detail-and no I relerrine ti tiie
Complaint or other document-the wt oO ct
resti nea Or regi red We have an Led On Lrict
Complia { Ld) Lhe se require rier Viuxoll ex rel
Vuxoll ov. Indian Prairie School Dist. # 204, 523 3d
tt) t) / (/th Cor. 2008): Chicago Koard Of education
ubstance Irie 4 F.3d) 624, 641-82 (7th
Cir.2003); IDS Life Ins. Co. nAmerica Life Ir

Cy | 45 (7th Qi Reno Au

v. McCord, 45! edt 1.3
orning tne PicVue hlectronu
isd 156, 15%

«)

heaciny

ZU06)

2004) (per curiam)
rule equally to a
required )-an injgunction
Commands that act Hye

rather than thie

apple nyuUuNclion
1c that AS
adone rathes ot dor
more Common myunebiwo
International Longshoremen AA i 4 Philadelphia
Marine Trade As: as le 1-46, 646 5.Ct. ZO]
GY J, fd Yd 236 467): Petrello | Write pe,
Car.Z008)

alive

}t5 ee Crate
(9th Cir. 1996): 14 Moore
(3d ced ZOO9)

Shinn, Gs |
hederal Practice

2. tne mnpunctlion

require men}

hes

Contain
thiat Voc: Xx pyaa'

adequate

Ve apo!

Capacilic and
required by

wbyect LO

Which is not

specilne ]

no criteri;

all wor]

rewriting

vr open-ended. The
(ne contaminate ah Wwe projyect

© complete (though

prc ily
the project in e od

gecree would ejythes
Impossible rigudit thie

pe riormance of 1
require Con

tant recourse to
Inlerpret 1On)

or modification of

ol

tif

( rib le

‘| hie
der

Very

dadecres qT ¢

trial

(prt?
federal courts }
cChool sy:

ha
pout {

the running of a

pubhe institution that lauded
rederal law in
Vv. Pitts, 503 U
lL, kud 2d 10%
Authority, 475 '
lo fund Repre
(99-#O0 (7th Cir.ZOO1): Glover 1
(Oth Cn
Kul

rule

(pTie rt Ql

189-90. 115
(,autreaux t

1D, C

lO /,
(199%)
3ad re

ldvri {

Pay AP Phe (*

199%)
65(a)

{ ‘ ‘
AQ

mnterpretalion ol

comply with the

‘The 65(d)

lor

Lo
Lo

am btuile
follow I} J!
myunction and lo protect defendant

LO follow

are
OCceeCdiIng the
In contempt tor failure
trap oO]
114

(1974); ODupuy ¢
CVC Intl, Ine. t
19 (4th Cu 1] (harles A
Miller, federal Practice
ed but

mo plan (? cif)

amibiyuily
oe

105 I SC

Dbecauuse
U3 iv
samuel:
& YAULSLSy
ZAVOW))
20 1QYD)
Willi inidle
be understood

bole

Mavoldable

ihe must

COmplance ton aya de

ambiruil j ul 1) oa

(*( ipod i Le d ChnVITONMeEen! 1 | ( L¢ il) lp

hot juilre thie Hypo style ‘bhere ]

Candia Pou rn Op

Le) M441) (/th

tho r Tre

another

V «ATIC dl by

PHLITLIITIAI Ze

a dire
Schmidt ¢

iia

Skippy Ine

Wright re
and Procedure

ma ase

A Watory
they take

Ww hye I)

tem or other complex

LO comply with

buoy
oe

Irreeman

Chicago Housing
o2 (7th Cir.2007)
City of Chicago, 2317
Johnson, 138 I

Alliance
isd 799
3d
thie

de fine

pot

OT)

da bol

Lhe oces
ol
from being |
that

Lessard,
lnd.2d 661
157, 759-60 (7th

214 F.3d 456
Arthur kh
2990, Pp

(jt)

] UWahce

Live

LA
WV al a]

that ansist
Interpretation ol
i] which Uc y)
leprae
orderiny
kkule dor
whi
kuroquill

Phi

a limit to

Car. 19BD)

P1if? moditied thie
CONLECIN pI IQ) Jiolating it
Motor ca

Prope rlete

(oir. | 9990)

AFFIRMED

Appendix B
nited States District
Hlinol

A
eo) Amer

\PEA OL, COMPANY, IN¢

10) Go-t.¥ 2Z42-DRH

July Ze ZU)
ORDER FOLLOWING BENCH TRIAI

(nel Judy

INTRODUCTION

PiyUNELy

Lyic existing and

heaith and thie
ol subsurtace
poe troleus

Oil and
roundwate1

valer Picee

FINDINGS OF FACT

I

Hartford Refinery-Karly Ownership

Hiding on the ist bank of the Mi
approximately velve miles northeast
Lou Missours. (PLEx. 143 at APEXDEPO 005359)
Yocording t© Ldve O00 0 censu Hartford has

‘

population — of | peopl ‘S
APE ADEPO OO

}

10, Wood River Oil & Refining Co. In
Kansas corporation now known as Koch Industrie
Ine. CWROR?’), constructed a refinery On What is now
known as Hawthorne Street in the northeast section
ol the Village of Hartford Mlino (the “Hartford
Refinery ). (Uncontroverted Facts at Para. 1). The

liartford Kefinery opened On OF AaArouna March
1434 (| nceontroverted bac iil Vara 1) Hy torically,
the Hlartford Refinery h been identitied as the

Wood Rive ! Ite ntrovertled beat “il

nelair KReliming

entered ato at)

amony other thingy WhO

rmerreed thie liartford Refine: LO ncelall

Kefimuiny | verted I; , ). The sale

MW. Clark Oil and Refining Corporation / Apex

Oil Company, Ine.

[yn « are 1 Sey Zh 19 | pinclan
Kelining sold the Hartford Refinery to Clark Oil and
nelining Corpor ibIONn a Wiscon Orporatlion

(clark Onl) (Uncontro\ ‘reed Fact

partnership lor mi (Old
(Uncontroverted | CT t | i (J CeCTODEe!

‘os Clark Q))] me 1 i puisith

It (an indirect y|] bsidia O)}d
\pex) ind Lp quisition Ise

ct red i] rie {.] I () i I Pini

( rporation ( ¢ I ) | ti

6 On Dd mbes i } ()
ubsidiars mchudin ( int (il ip I ce)
protection under ec 1) \j ( Cohiay QO]
{ nited Leite i} } pt ( 1¢ | t |
CY 1 L yae United ite bankrupt { . 3 |
astern District of l iri, | ern DD t
I { -( O4-BKC-] {)
1? ve t
d (On VemDb ( { ) P
biartlord heline) ( ri Ci |
Corporation Crit KI Lf pli
Corporation ha Ibsequent K |
Premeor Refining Gi y |i Prete
Lipper ead | the | i ruy f (| .
| icy it | I

1) {) ( } i | ()
MiCOPpOrated Oo eri j ( ‘ ( yt (
\p Va merged int ())] Decem a
199 (lLincontre rte act i Hea? {
wea or-t hier i 4 ! | ( rk () ’ { ) ( )

North ‘Terminal

air Ketining acquire

he imiford Retin I

qd termin

Piasa ) (Uncontroverted act at Para I?) ARCO
retaimed the Pumping S
at Para 12). Sub equently, Keller-Piasa sold the
North Terminal LO thie Hlartford/Wood Kives 1 rminal

{ OMpany (Uncontroverted Facts at Para. 12)

tation. (I ncontroverted Fact

IV. Hartford Refinery Pipelines
A. River Lines

1 | lo provide for barge tran portation ol it
products, WROR built a dock on the Missis: Ippi River
west of Hartford and con tracted product Pipeline
between thie liarttord hetinery and {rie doc}

(| ncontroverted Fact at Para 1.3)

I?. By Ordinance No. 232 adopted by the Village on
January 7, 1944, Hartford granted WROR the right
to lay three &- inch Pipeline and one 3-inch pipeline
underground through the Village travelling north
alony the east Wde of North Olive Street and then
west along the south ide of kim Street to the west
ide of North Old St. Louis Road (the “River Lin Ol!
“Original Rivets lunes ) (Uncontroverted Fact cil
Para. 14). One of the &-inch line was designated fo

transporting gasoline, one was for distillates Gf 1 and

Ho 6 hofuel oon) and one for hea Ol
(| ncontroverted Fact Para )

| Piac (original Rive. bine Were bere and lacked
protective Wrapping UuSed LO prevent COPrrosiol

(Faryan v | Day | al 10°2-03) war Onrneinal Rive)

l, lh¢ Litte red Mure row Le ak during thie ( lark Ayn *
era. (See Section XI. below). In April or May 197%

Clark Oil ceased use of the ‘asoline and distillate
liane at which time those ling were water washed
air blown and blinded off (Uncontroverted Fact cil
Para lI6). Clark Oil continued to utilize ons Ol at
Qrivinal Kiver line for the transfer of heay Qi]

(| ncontroverted | ic‘l ul vara | /)

14 In 199 ( ir} ()i] je nad ne pipeline
consisting of one ]O-mnch ga ne tine, one 1O-inch
fuel oi tine, one 1O-inch spare line, and one 14 inc
black ()} bine designed na mstalled (U1)
hepa ement River Line ) (Uncontrovertes act
t Para. 18). ‘Tihs Kheplacement River Lain becam
perational in late 19 (Uncontrovert bea

Para. | Phe Original River Lane were lett bu

mn place. (Ui hntroverted | it Para. |

Bb. North Terminal Line

(JT) i ice) a
(Jradinance i Which allowed Tit ti! V¢ l {
lO-inch pipelin wong and beneat or
rtl Clive tree Pron te)
pyre lI ite ly } crt it! i th Cel I (
Forest Street to Rand Avenue, then west alone th
ith cle | IX Cd \ ( 1Lit (] thre . S58 i ir a
Uf) orth Llerminal property (Nort berm |
Lin y. (t iMroverted bact i ara. 19). I ‘y
Inclair Kefimin ud the two 10-inch diameter Nov
herminal dane ne flor gasoline and one tor tf
vice ryerounad bpbetween thie ae Wwery i {| yortl
berminal. (U1 ntroverted | Paar

? 1} }? Iti (| (-})1 () (ie ti) , if
! Piva | i LP) coco praca) i} pl ( dey Led
jé if Cain iil } | ne i) ! Peilddi
(i Le 4 mse ele neratin bitler-mixed
i] fic | | | i iit (1 cre
( (lig ( 1 1) f i 14) |
“7 { ij] {

15 mit Main and | Pre dominant Phroughout

the Sate
{ j } j } Pye?) it] i
bivartlos i] tlord Keline is f
| [oe } i | ;itit }
rise re bdartlorad

Devas dy oy rain ne
| ( j | | { he il f {
| hail Joe] (] i] ri ] f
| | j } (ij iz
|) {
‘ bial ( |
| ) jot 1} j , 1 |
(17)]
id? | i | | ! (-] '
j { { r] ! J 1) J
rf (1 | ect I) f ()
VI rie oe
Oy if ft cy , (
}) (| I if MI i] i ' I

ff (‘7 f
fr iil i

(| |
j Is

J Mree jmore permeabie unit the North Olive

ravun the and tratum, and the EVA Lratum
mre found within the overlying venecr oO] ity-clas
(Vidux, 9G at WPA RPPO42621). In the north central

portion (| biartiord the North Olive Itaand and PPA

ments of Hartford hon re poneral eta
hie iA (haryan Test. Da lat 2ZOQ9). In certan
rte Of Iiartlord Wen a Ti Cini Of fuln
reel and North Delmar Avenue, the Main Sand 4
contact ith the A Clay, without any intervening
rata. (V1). [us h94 at EVA RPPOSGOO3-004)
POrviol Ol Hartford Wey) a yn) Chie hint
rey rere ryvuadt ayo iI Chai bea j ( msl above
1) d, separates tdayers. (PUI 194
hl RPL OSGO03-004
{ | 1 I I { (} } KI }
{ id th re] r ate (*7il it gid {J
riil j { preric i| j ) thal eile
! rej | Oy} ( OVeMment of lig a }
hydrocarhb it] 176
ME EOOLS TA: Peay dei (j 1())
Phe ‘ l Jractlure Fi req 1)
} { lermine to tl treme net VeNEI QO]
COnaditios (y7).] 1/2 il
I] L170) OOIGSO). tas re nized that many c]
rs lered to be ioapermeab olter
iY reed 1] { f j

IQ?) hiquid hydrocarbon and hydrocarbon apo!
migration. (PI.f h/ZatAPhADEVPO OO1LG650)

4 hracture mid permeable lense biiave Deen
dentified an “ela layers beneath North Hartford
hractures were observed in the A Clay in the test pil
excavated at the Hartford Communit (center in
2-004. (Vids (G at IPA HI?POO1873). Permeable
nses have been lound in sow borings mito the Bb Cla
if monitoring ell Jocation TIMW-46B On the
CCommunity Cente propert (171.1 1°94 if
WPA KRPTO42939-40: PL I ZOO at HPA KI’T041421)

VITI
I

hivas

Petroleum

hii

(

ocarbon ontaminats

Ou} t
I 1d) I : BSc es priitl rede f brake [pie
Cnvironment, petroleum hydrocarbons ( » relerred
lo as Liyht non-aqueous phase liquid r LNAPI,)
Hlmiyrate downward into the ubsurlace under thi
force of pr: 6 is >: (2 at APEXDEPO 001644
4.)) ller being leaked or pillar 11) i] petroleum
hydre rhs yoear an the ubsurlac CVeCTal
} Io)
| hesidua [p Ye hydrocarbon (i.e. J rocarbon
( ed 13S) ine c+ ye ted ii {Jie na |
rf rave I} ane pry } ride { rng 4t {|
ibsurl ( eke riiill porcuon of the ma ies ded
ehind, re md dn Soll pore space (171] 172 al
PiADEV?O) 001644 ()4°)) Mesidun prriase
nya rh) ppear petrolecum-stamed yy]
(Ho | Les { (4) be Mjtlia poriaase
rh) Pid] } pore if i! Ow

‘ ' ' | ‘ |
j } { j
il if | deplete
lit ! f ! ! 1 | i I ! rho
{*] jot | i) ry j if
i t | ' | |
' ‘ ;
} ii j I j
I i? | bDine?o) ()]) 654 (
’
f I por | }
| f i | ( ] | (
'
I | |
i
ii | (
iil i re
| (it rl | | re j
{ } { j
I

at itil i iia (*!} il yp) ttae yround ily] (il Thiele
rr ter bre macy (lilowe 1" | Lei t) { {>} -¢
ae M/Z at AVPEXADEPO 001644 45)

) Pissolved phase hydrocarbos ie constitues |
hydrocarbon Chicit ai Ve iitlo Trounawate)

uriace water. (Howe Test. Day 6 at 6Y: Pl Iéx. 172 at
APE XDEPO 001651). Among PaAsolne ¢
benzene ys far more wate) Oluble than some of thre
heavier hydrocarbons and will disse

lito j wNnadwate!s al Will othe bisetal i h) drove irioah)

it) Jo por ! Clr ry } iP ise trom (
f itilavat ] | re hdual-p i ind ree-pha

pyc iPbon (liowe ‘Test. D al ft t ae 1
i 17] Di? OO165)) mat lose? at nares
( era Lia Ii il t! ( I @Cntira I I ipo
pol COnLaAMIINGI » th psurbace it

Bie | ey ( t (2-64)

1X Petroleum Beneath Hartford Prior Vnoalyse

of Apparent Product Thickn

tj { i { liil t
( ri} joe j re lymnited i { I Pyadat t
}) | i hipiet naersta iit 1 the it¢ | in]
] ( ti | i | Vil Hyart ra mad ft
biartlord beaey i) borin
havure (rit I Mhnalio

nt product thickne Is the measurement

the vertical thickne of free phase hydrocarbon
OalInY OL Wa well al until recently, wa

Ol thre Vn ds of determining the extent of
urface soils. (Howe ‘Te: Day

v2 at APEADEPO OO1G55). I

urrounding peolory

the apparen product

Cl) though the same

mating o7 thie Willer table

in ddition pulp of

cl paake

Lhickine

approximate

hydrocarbon

xX. Petroleum Beneath Hartford-Recent ROS

\nalyse

peciiie wavelength of ultraviolet light. (Pix. 168 at

APR TOOOI83S: Howe Test. Day 6 at 24-25). Livhte

Pol iypre hydro irbon Lich a PASOLING Can ay
distinguished Irom Neavie) hydro irbon lel i
giesel or crude oil. Laghter hydrocarbo: gyeneral
ippear as blue fluorescence, | ler hydrocarb
pps il i I t*T) I ello i ( [ [hé hie i {
nya It) tppeal Cd Thaore Cel ( (i’Lt {

VV tial 1.4) I (| [ ( o il ( | }
Del t* ree pha hydrocarbol bd resi halo pha
I ae ) rl 1) Live | il] | L¢ i | {| ! t* 1)
nads ) eda by the KOS T instrument nbe
{ ( I i ee ( | I) I I ‘ |
to [ I irl I rl

CrcCey tna

(Llowe

KPRTOOOY 10
t HHOW TI
» podurrnie

during the (

€ () ’
| “J
MM Biw } {
(,{ es { {) cq] j }
ue
awe. 1h
3 cj byeey ( { ) rial aay i!
rs biainik |
i Meh’) OOO tial x 1)
a hice dogaa
I’) | tu Kl
{ | { (Dj r r
i | rt | Piri | | I
| (171 |
| ( )(y I} | | (| ViIVDOOOO)
f | f i) } {)) | (
{ {) | li] ‘d] | il Perini | ie
pooviernal 1 odytateat 1 Ma Chicory Pago
| Plie | Poere PEA aap I
ine WnSIstil ()] CUR)
(i'l | l’] Dh POOO]!
( ( ) ] Vy f rk () i! itilized t
reli bea Lait Ie ( Pidgeon CL do] Potabsarye
Prot | tH) Pape Pubic (| ios Phe folle i]
beat (1) ie Cofeairk OOgd grartaate repairs ¢
@aik dha Ul rehy fey buat ted }

Which we

AVDIPO 001847)

i
booccile qd

i‘ MAD rE ridouile thie ¢ yydity bod thy bilie Lo thie

bia th) the two North Terminal dane Were bare
bit Oe oe pric dae bos Fives praca apart and had been
tityyerrt | no active Corrosion manhapvementl propran
(i'l. dex Goat APEXDEPO QO1l#%4/). The North
Perniin bie hacked cathodse protection, a method
J preventin Corrosion. thir ih electrical mean
(171.1 130) POINCOOOZ7Z: Gustafson Test. Day 7 at
i j
(é. (dark OW had been shipping 15,000 barrels of
proauct Ned Jia the North Perminal lane to thi

forth TPerminal, but the Terminal found that the
biipornie nil NOT 0 borre) hort each Were)
hice itinige that thie a ah Ae 8 € Wt'rt Oli at tae ie priec*y '

Perminal or that the poiypoe bne had a leak. (PbLbEx.96)

1 hie North Perma Ultimately lopped taking
bidporieni Prot { rk Git orth Permianal borne
because thie pment ere nvariabl hort

i (4) Jeatatdeal Mg ci hesah (| No () hue] ();]
occurred trom the River Lorne beneath Isim Street
(17] | x i cil APE ADEP® OO LOURY 9YI) 1 bie product

een leaching trom under the pavement On lolin
treet near North Delmar Avenue and enblermny thie
CWe! Ci DP Poat$ APEXDEPO OO1LG8G. Gg]

(31 talson iz { Diay dé al 21%) Approximately 100)

pallons of product: reached the Mississippi River
(idx. 34 at APEXDEPO 001991). Clark Oil tool
responsibilit fo (bye lea] (Pl es “4 =
APICXDEPO. OO} 99])

(
I I i
{ rti { ) } f
. } ‘ i | { «] "
. !
I (| Dp. i } ( AG
} L wi IH 4% i I | bili
| i I iil ( eoil l
} { if’) ‘ it t y
( ite I ii
(i| ‘ | ’ )
} L.] { (>i | ) |) }
l I { p>] Lé | (
| rent | 1 (| ( 1i\ re
il Qo] hed 1 if edt) 1} irl Is tl Cra
| l ii {) an I iv I ic] (| |
! | hea } na Lye ! ’ if j Wel Pode {
1] it clista ‘ rol I ( | ! |

|
} ,
'
i ' i ‘ ‘
|
i ’ l i

| yt | )
} ' )
] }
' ,}
]
|
\

I I

ee 2 ee eee ee 218 SAS" 6 — ee ee ee, =
i | | i} ited
17} il it)
é | rl | ierial
| | ’ (Carant
| i
PADEPO) O ' r} ’ {| tant
aval ISI oc 1(y)
lt if I
| fy) | | {, ’ lé |)
1] DhV?O OO
{ t ti
tl (
| ) |
| ELE WD
I i ( I
(] t) propel Cuil I
i ist A L¢ l atria rea (Carah iz
PLEX. | MPA KRPEO2ZO
>} ‘ l jor Chul I ( t Cit]
iaie Pproxi ile lel beet I
| ‘an rd) I ad bee pmaentill ‘ar A i i |
it i LAPR POOO2Z 19 Itt
EPA WEEE
4e | ii | na
ie (*} } pert te » WIKI rod
Dbsu to | in) ud lil Giese 1 i
i}>} ircda sf bye i pI iit (1 nheaviel produ | t
bserved patter contamination at the hefine!
{ tT i © in irea Where there na Tye } pibaee
release of different Kind l hydrocarbon product
nd where {rae hghter-ra ( produ { 1} ynmMati
ed away and tlelt tl lt produc

: _— SY SY See eS eS =." ous sori” = = * =e a SW — es) SS "Soa. SS

(a2 mar area 8) | thickest hydrocarbon
contamination beneath the Refinery (combined free
phase and residual-phase contamination as identified

by RKROST) inelude the area near the pipeline

terminus for the Refinery River Lane ind North
rermuinal Lines (which ls neal the Wastewate!
treatment area) and the main Refinery process areas

(hlowe best Levy () if / | 14-76 I] rf . IG at
EX PRTOOO? 10)

ALL. kree-Phase Hydrocarbons Have Migrated
hrom the Refinery to the \ illage

ae. A\ et forth mn detail below during the
Clark/Apex Era, petroleum hydrocarbons migrated
from the Harttord Kelinery to the Village of Hiarttord

in the following manne!

Hiydrocarbons which had accumulated due to lea
nd spills at the Refinery migrated deep into the
Main Sand beneath the Refinery due to. low
yroundwatel levels in the 1960 and early 1970

(Howe Test. Day 6 at 104, 107-108)

\ “structural high in the Main Sand acted a a
ramp running trom the Refinery toward the middle
Ol the Village ol Hartford (tlowe Test Day 6 at

F |

rs Prior leaks and spills lilled SOl] POre pace lh al

cormdor of the Main Sand between the Refinery and

mat Vill it’ and fori ed a prele re ntial pathway LO!

. ~S SS > oo = =z TS (68a Oe s* s ued ‘i
report entitled /lartford Underground ttydrocarbon
Investigation. OPLEx. 111). Illinois EPA concluded

that the hydrocarbon contammation then present

beneath Hartford had been leaked from pipeline:

associated with the Hartford Refinery during the

LO thie che like

ternal and the hye

lli at PRG. DOJO7ZT TRS)
0 concluded that a December
Q)il : i il a Avenue pipeline and lé i

rth ! dune during
perio

LT
I hip had contributed t
iti

Orderimy Hlartlord (i'l

RC, LOI07 ] )
Phiines | PA

mivestivgation found
thre hvdrocarbon

beneath Harthord

Olin With tetraeth
Se iree a rr id additive

PR DOSJO7I90O). The Shell and S

leak had consisted of unleaded ra

mconsistent with the lead

rt rude aa |

COMmMponent (1’} |

finding mi othe
ld) at PRODOJSJO7T190). Thine:

the alkylate traction of the

mples and determined th;

thie I) rolluorw acid proce
ie fine .%

prt cree

pit
md mconsistent with

i} ed | hell
PRO DOSO7 190)

| ) in A

) pal chromatograph

cin ple pmdiated that iit t hae

anipling location Bar h) dro

llarttord

CooTtl i | a) | *9{)

riite | With eat
mates

(ol fhidore sal

;

remainder beimy clit

Qo oat EPA RPTOZ6170

i “al 1S0-36) Almo t gl

if) theo © gee aee North CO1i\

lyirch Street contamed LOO {

IOSD pipeline

headed

blarttord

pilus cif

it]

Cline

t*]
1 dg

imipling

\ bua Cholsol lL 1) it a 4
te ater i best i) ‘yj { } i 14 {
Tia Di P?O) OOLOGS. 10 (49
it Ly I t Cd i i rol
I if phy t ite ! hyd rl mixture
1} pra 1h) isoparaiiin romats Piapotbvenne
mia an (wi | Hed PIAN®G nalysis )
mehe I ls Daa y at I nulbates 11)
eneral enriches | iraltin ma romats
Nichol 1) best Lis mi { PIANO i i! (
hucted on th mehol nip howed that th
pyapode ere dominated | lsoparallin id
prow id at Vere therelore consistent |
formulated pasoline Nacho n best. Da (j f
idk 67 at APEADEVP?O OO1070). The Nicholson
ipl | ere howl I) n nt will
lormiulates headed (SOHN Hi I i COMMPpPAarison
A ha leaded ¢ @ rele! ndard. (Nach
Pest 1) it iy
APEADEPO O01 f
1 ( Ly HOmson ana ead the ib iead ent of
| idndpole { date tl ire i the contami {
Potal dead found trie [ hel } Thbpoie
tent thy ore LORD ’ ’ if
‘ eal @) y rial ie ith 1 t ol cl
| i] pole ylected trom btfiana tha i i I

Ua

of lead per gallon or more. (Nicho
LO). A noted above lead | Were
generally below 0.7 grams per gallon in the 1980:

dropping below O.38 grams per gallon after 1986

(Nicholson ‘Vest. Day &® at ZO4). From January 1976
throu rt) (etober 1ogY the total lead pet gallon ot

PaSOLinMe produced bb ark Qual at the Hartford
Refinery, on a monthly ranged between 2.599
wale 1 .OSe Pe rarni: ; r ( ‘ >, 1 cil
VPEXDEPO 001071 >. Li) > Lal cal
Pits DOJOS88S-84). krom ! ember 1979 through
Dec 4 | le: pel gallon of gasoline
radlon

?

and O.O57 grams pet
APEXDEVPO 001071; Pi dex. 226)

of lead contaimmed an the Nicholso

also matched the lead that wa added to

produced | « Hartford Refinery during

betraethyl ad wa the only

gasoline used through about 1960

mdustry ade veloped Other lead additive

that contamed mostly methyl lead

OHIpOuna (Nicholson Test. Day & at ZO6, 218). The
llartford Refinery used tetracthyl lead exclus)
if red re | olimne during thie { lark Apex

(Nieholson best Day ¢ at LU BaD. Its

APEXDEPO _OO1037, 3 ss PLEX. 226; PLibx. 227 at

PR DOJO8883-84; Pidex. 229 at PRO DOSJO892Z5

976). Amoco and Shell Oil used mixed lead package

during at least portions of the period between 1960

and 1980. (Nicholson Test. Day & at 21%; Pl.dex. 229

at PRG. DOJO3925-926). The Nicholson Samples were

dominated by tetraethyl lead and did = not ontamn

cle ated Ie ve] ol othes lead Compound thisat would be

('( if
Ulin
} tpt pt
| 1 pe
il i
VMP

tit} j
e | ;
iit I
Wned
1”)
i) I

t it
; ey

)
iKeM |
t. Da
ilil «i
it i}

11

hi’
eereae
benzene
headache
( lebil ol thre
rival heart !
oO od cell pt
BaD. Wy oat
ie) l 1 if j }
tlie Pasay | ra
1) Chiat no
Lyi IOWeESL 4
TU)

iid 1}? } j .
loth arycl
pyre
hyvare irl ! if
ibrats it |
in) ipor-phase |
d LO}
tion “nd ipor ii
1) LO; Viet
ri ion ] yt tye
AS nL eeLeme ifie
yprent rif i} )
it] Jol eit I

dro ail Dol

biti I
(Lule
t i |
yal
i}
iri te)
ity
|
i itl)
it Liye
'
Bridd i]
| }

\ Appar

lnhalation

Lic]
Wp, AY
Lit)
'
it} h I
wbor ]
I
ip) i
ia
ij {*3)
il wich

Health

i eee ] | i)
1) respi Q)!

I htheadne
mcreased hkelihood
(arrhnychninias) na

me. (Watte 1 Daa

MOOQODS > (auzelian

ne I the main health

mse 10 J rerall thie
Nn I CYiol Hye Uh)
110) haat {

Dee] i mated {

Clall aCcuile myeloid

DROOOS5S5 (guzelian

Hit? i (otic ol onl aie VW

Wied i { i \

itl i DCE]

I ca it i
be } : go
In addition
hydrocarbon ontai
toluens na lene
DIOlwovical Lem
eHlects and theretor
(Watters ‘Test. D
dial if7t Known i
Pic Tlidie ntimbne
paral ito odie
YISDROOOYR9-990
1 tae pyar 1!
Lverrast? CATSDE )
lor Disease (Control
neaith J Lit i Cli
(] monmental conta
t f
Pox) ca
report Chneralet
Phin i4 it tall
ment poltentia at
based Mui bry) Ht)
thie chit miical (Watt
it ATSDROOOSA0
ubjected LO revie
ditlerent topic are
on Ved] i (
I Lea J

ntaminy ay

additional

it G1). He mie Can cause ne
peripheral neuropathy hich
muscie weakne ind « if
entratiol (171) (5(
Lo DStance Md Piss (
ler agency ol the Cente:
that main!) rddre ( pul it
wed with exposure il ite ith
mination. (Watte) Pest. Da
Prolite if¢ beer Tpit i pe if
I VESDER that mnNnone OLnel
i thable researcn fiteratu
ith effect nd establish health
Levels (“MRLs ) for exposures t
rs test. Day at 10; Pl. tex Ly
»4Z) cological Profile are
vi VISDER committe
(such a health elect Mith.
lernal peer reviewe) (Watts
1?) | it PSDROOOS
k LA is the due for human
neved not to result in a harmilul
1O} parti ihe exposure route
} ‘a qd length of « posure

c*yat

at il

Lit il

| | ph (
uc] i

Liie iliie

f Phhiicil

mtermediate I chron CAPO Ure) (Watter

Liat } o>) p only addre Hon-Cance!

and do not measure cancer risk (Watter:

' at 23d} VESDI e the term “acute
ie

‘APO Td ee tO! CAPO Litt
and

intermediate exposure
lO} 1 year or more

C°A \ ‘

Day | - ‘S) ATSDR’: acute

chronn CXPOsSure
(Watter Test

inhalation MRI. for benzene is ppb (which « quate
29-50 “] t f I prey }
memorandum entitled Pure lpi
Statistical hvaluati fthe tf if Meteor

Mit mnNeNA ) ait / (Le ( ( fi [ }
event (i?) tux y() t EPA RPEOS 4) oT}
tud Included a number of time erie ree ()]
different data | 1d ’
barometri p! ire ibsurtace '
Nhi I 1p) fd) ie ] { rep rted |) ( |
period where multiple reported vapor « ipl
occurred within a few da (vapor ent ust
(Pit OatkhVPA KPI 116)

1%. | In oe zed that hie f ,
Variation oo t hae eorol | beat ci
comparative Carcity Of vapor event report made }
mreasonable to « Kpect to rdentil Latisticall on
correlation Prom thie data Du concluded th
correlation coellicient oO Viz to VY uild = |
Indicative of a strony degree ot correlatior (}?] |
HO at KPA RPTO385123). ENSR found that over t}
ong-term, Mississippi River tag ind = prior-
precipitation rrelate Dest itt reported |
event and that cluste) O] Vapor event report
correlat cate trol l\ { ted ae ! l

it i! y | } |
Watkin Lhe Walla i tamil t 1301 Watt
e tliat mii it IV6 |] Watkin ‘ear ; ‘
hamil t Watki bedwe fal
Q) Iuast WatK! i { | (
t W
On Ma publ itt
itt bitin yopartmen utd I | itl
received telephone = me e fro On
re cle { Ol 134 ] Watkin NV 1)) na ed that
he and her family had bee mwakened in the Teron
I the nigi | tron dol ir) had lett their | lie
1) na PV ilit | Li i Del I if
rren r repre tat sited ti home between
VOT) na NW) p.m it) rie ured { L thie
r exp @ limi (Wondanville ‘J t. WD
os: Def. | fi; 68787 ll6 at APEXDEPOOOI29))
fae PhOvryie yer] nici (¢ (Plt
’} DEO OO )
\ ite fi) itactin t 1} ] II
himerge! Response Unit in Collinsvil Hline
LOPE employee returned the homeowne) 1 re
made an ppointmen » meet the resident he)
house at OO pn place au unpling device
the | 1) nvii lest. I) E43 L Def
| 16)
lS p.m. on May | the Harttord Fur

omplaint at II6 Kast Watkin Phe resident
reported that hr had odor In his home for the past
three te four day and had been ventilating hy
house. (Plex. 115 at APEXDEPO 0024

hire Wepartment rt ponded qu ran Dut avDoUL aN

=
va
bh

hour passed before they took their first explosivity

readings in that home Vt 8:15) poem the = bure
Department found gases at 6% of the lowe: CXPLOSIVe
limit in the basement at 116 East Watkins. (PI Ex
bloat APEXADEPO 002479, 482)

224 Kmergency response personnel from — the
Hartford Fire Department and Hlinois EPA’) wert
already In =the neiwshborhood when the seme
employee arrived to collect indoor au sample at 164
Kast Watkins. (Dondanville Test. Day 2 at 155: Det
Kix. 16). The homeowner let the [DPPH employee into
her house to place the air) sampling device

(Dondanville Test. Day 2 at 155) The IDPH employe
avoided spending much time in the home, due to the

evident hydrocarbon odo} (Lond; nville L' { dean

225. An Illinois EPA employee placed another ait
sampling canister in the home at 130 East Watkin:
because the family who hived there also had children
(Dondanville Test. Day 2 at 156-58: Def. Ex. 1¢
Pikx. 116at APEXDEPOOOL 292)

26. Beginning at 3:40 p.m., the Fire Department
began screening the tollowing homes for explosivity
and vapors: 134 Kast Watkins, 130 East Watkin:
120 Kast Watkins, 122 Kast Watkins, and 126 East
Watkins. (Pl.Fx. 115 at APEXDEPO 002479). No
other elevated LEL readings were found during that
screening

227. The Fire Di partment and Illinois EPA advised
residents to turn off then pilot hehts to reduce the
possibility of vapors igniting and to ventilate thei

homes to try to dissipate the fumes. (Plex. 115

iT
aA

APEXDEPO 002478 Dondanville Test Day 2 at
157). A resident of 120 East Watkins told the Fire
Department that he had odor: in fit home tor the

i

iL { fe
| pidit
if rade
by das
it 4774
Picotiae

nt of 126 hast Watkin
home the night betore, |
r present. (VII 1 | if
Ome resident bad ailly
because their basement
best. Da P at
DnP?Oy OOLSOR) (thes
raed iPro Ompron 7
i yc A ()}) ] 1} (*t)t

if il! PE) podae cr
cy { unple LWo |
iti id Q) iuast Watki
| i a ee | read edd
iJ nd | | iy "4 (KI
OS). Oumple broom
reds to pringhieldd hi
een prpilaa had difficult
this rewmiel paged
nitrial (Wondas leo]
yy) pturda Via Au)
ekend-the TDVH empl
from oan dllinos ms

nd call to her hom

re ected (*}
ntration md there
rt thhoutl ae (ldond
G4

aT
"A(S)
Wd Odor
were }
()24 7%)
11) then

i
+ iL
irl I
|
ead hore
j
I! lf
116]
ito U
130) Iya
eV
if (*y¢

{

ij}
|

if il
i¢)]

I i

Philpoal | Ait pit ‘ } t*t) t'nat
(aipp! inate] Lf ry I } i \) Ma
‘ (kin moa C3 ppl Den ze ( (aipp ynate] tt
ryt m3) al s Inast Watkil based on 24-1] i]
lily ‘ i ‘ (i tron Mi | t« 14 ¢)()
(Dondanvalle best sh i( ot
1’ | KDhP?O OO] } iy Ollected Liye al |

iained () ppb ( ( pproximates ra
(Dondanvill Pest. D it 17 1 |

PiCK Pi?) OO ae

1] DEVO OO} 1%) i Hype recher i jd
Watkis rthe next (] Mi | nda
ha birst na ( «yy (,(

KI ree () ppl 69 ppl 166 ppl ) ppl
a » ppl ! ! | () higher t]
| 1] ) ppl 7 n Minimal ki Ly
lor ( ae PSDKOOOUS2Z). |]
part ( iret OKI i aL

i role J } () rey 1) Tele)
: noles taken fron e-filled | contained
() ote t ( | | / (AT SIROOORT 5)

I { ne level fe | ! |

‘ Lf i} I
‘ | | ID] }

| i peiil Pail bi il { i nf i
I VV I i i 14 ! ppb (app 1 yy
nul Ny } }
| A j j tif pipet (iapoy |
it ~ i }
‘) J ‘ KI 1 14 t ppb (appli 19 4.40)
il il
| VV t ‘ ' pb (appre {) )
iu i ri )
} 1 t | ply Capper j j
1 }
(j) she inville iz J Da i 4 “al it) if 7] x WA AT
\PEXDEPO_001312 PLE r 160 r

PSPDROOTLLS

PEXDEVPOOO] 28%)

Phe May ZOOZ ampling data was al alyzed by

1 Tilino KVA laboratory in Springfield, Illinois
though the Illinois HPA lab is not independently
certified, IDPH and the Ilhno MPA Collinsville

Pha COT) mereda thie hal) ge Lill reliablh becau e the

lb jollowed a tandard methodolo had menificant
experience periorming th LYpe Ol analysi OW ned
thie ampling and analytical equipment and = haa
perated it for a long time and quatlity-controllea

heim daata (Dondanville le I Day Zat 18! | I, >
117 at APEXDEPOUOO12Z88). The information had
gathered for informational purposes to inform
residents of} potential Gxposure and the imformation
that was provided directly to the residents inciuded

tiie laboratoy GaIiscialmMme] that l| Wa nol

ndependently certified. (Dondanville Te

(yg

236. Several weeks of heavy rain had preceded the
May 2002 vapor intrusion events on ast Watkin
Street. (Dondanville Test. Day 2 at 167; PLEex. 321 at
AVPIEXDEPO 001305). Flooding occurred in Hartford
durmy this time, with some residents applying fon
flood rehet. (Dondanville Test Day 4 at Jor

Ze mar basement ol the Mast Wath 1) motreet

homes he in a salt layer and are only separated from

the Main Sand by approximately five feet of ity
Clay (171. de> 199 at MV?PA RP?TO26243) ROS
Am pling 1h) thie area identihed al ] »-foot those Ke 7)

residual-phase light-range hydrocarbons (gasoline) in
the Main Sand at monitonnmg pomt HROS'T-50
located on Watkins Street in front of 116) [ast
Watkins Street. (Pldex. 199 at KPA RPTO2614#

243). ROST sampling at HROST-51, located in front
of 134 last Watkin how both 15 feet of leht
range residual hydrocarbon in the Main Sand and
heavy-range residual hydrocarbons (such as Six Oj)
mm the silty-clay trata, less than 5 feet below nearby
Lorne basement (Pi.dex 199 at KPA RPTOYZG6GISS
243). Additionally a ewer line run beneath hast
Watkin street and he in the it and cilty-cla

layer. (PILIex. 199 at EPA _RPT0O26243)

XXL. ATSDR / IDPH Health Consultations and
Hlealth Assessment

a A Health Consultation is an ATSDR document
that addre ( a pecily health-related question
about 4 ite and a pecihic exposure pathway
(Watte Test bay fat 32-33). A Pubhe Health
Assessment is an ATSDR document that meludes a
proade!s COpt of review of potential COM MULLS

ee i Re ee ana l tit re-V ie WIth}? multiple pathway

multiple che
Hiealth Consultation
nis can be prepared by
conjunction with
Treecmen!
ite-prepared Tlealth

anda : 1] Hdecalth A ( lent are

VESDR technical project’ officers and

idditional ATSDE division it

Al. |i July

Health Consultation

biome 1X.) mn tatiol
ompared Je, | | an arbon

(()T) tituent

Ga

comparison values and concluded that) residential
Vapor intrusion in Hartford constituted a publi
health hazard for person: mm altected home:
(Dondanville Test. Day 2 at 174-174; PL ex. 321 at
APEXDEPO 001308). The Health Consultation also
concluded that similar weather conditions could lead
to additional vapor intrusion events which could
present an urgent public health hazard. (Ddondanville
Test Day 2 at 174 ia D>: 42 | cal
APEXDEVPO O001308-309)

242. In dune 2ZO08, IDPH and ATSDK issued a Publi
Health Asse ment that W ii entitled ‘Hartlord
Residential Vapor exposure (Pl.iex.326). Th
document incorporated the as ampling result
detailed in the ZO02 Health Consultation as well a
ome follow lip ampling (Dondanville Vest. Day Z at
1&9). ‘The Pubhle Health Assessment also compiled
Information collected trom esidents through 11%
completed questionnaire repvardiny past odor
complaints and health concerns. (Dondanville ‘Test
Day Z at 190-191: PLEex. 826 at APEXDEPO 001495
196 yp} 1-516) Phe Publ Health Assessment
concluded that) residential vapor intrusion in
Mlartford had constituted a pubhe health hazard for
persons imo affected homes and could again pose a
public health hazard in the future. (Dondanville Test
Day 2 at 193; PL dex. 326 at APEADEPO 001498)

2438. In September ZO05, LDPH and ATSDK issued a
Health Consultation regarding certain quarterly
mdoor air sampling that IDPH) had performed in
Hdartford. (Pi dex. 156). De velopment of that Health
Consultation had been recommended by the 2004
Pruibo dae Health Ass ment! to attempt to capture
easonal Variations in vapor mtrusion. (Watters ‘Test
Day 4 at 3%). In the 2005 Health Consultation, JDPH

oncluded thisat bCsthy? term CX POsure LO benzene and

1 S-butadiene iW) home from Vapor mitrusion
constituted a public health hazard to person 1)
affected homes. (PlEx. 156 at APEXDEPO 000294)

244 MOPH also concluded that) condition till

existed in Harttord that could cause high level Vapo!

Intrusion to occur again, which could amount to an
urgent publ health hazard (171. box lob at
APEXPDEPO 000794). That IDPH report focused on
chrome risks and at least one ATSDR public health
prote onal expressed concern that the Health

(Consultation did not adequately retlect t hie

liporlance Ol potential

mtrusion in Hartford. (Watters Test. Day 4 10

acuLle 1) ks po ed by Vapor!

KPA Involvement at Site

20038, the Illinois EPA requested that

assign an On-Scene Coordinator |

conduct a Libiie critical removal

ment asse current ite competion and
termine if possible removal actions are warranted
North Hartford Premcor Site located in
County, Hlinois.” (Uncontroverted

». EPA assigned two On-Scens

Coordimatos Steve Faryan and Kevin ‘Turner, to
bevyin a ( my the condition at the Site anda to
aie velop hort-term and lonp term plan for
iddressing the problems at the Site. (Uncontroverted
Facts at Para. 28; Turner Test. Day 9 at 167-G&, 174

1 (t>)

16 F PA assumed primary responsibility fos
addressing the problem at the Hartford S In the
uinmer of 20038. (Turner Test. Day 9 ; 16%, 174-75
Def. kx. 47). On August 14, 2003, Tlinois KPA sent

op VPA a memorandum that recounted some ol the

ye ol Hartlora

wnd

mtamMiy

(Farvan L‘
rt) O0}

(fkaryan ‘Pest Ddiay |. .X 140 at
APEXDEPO 005378) Minally le Mhreat
Memorandum found = =a “unavailability of other
appropriate federal or state response mechanisms to
respond to the release,” due to Illinois KPA’s referral
the Hartford matte: ; a rf
aryan Test Day
APEXDIEPQOQ 005328)

ZL, \ Administrative (Orde. On
entered on March 7 ZA)UA betwee 1)
and Premecor, Shell Oil, and BP Amoco. (PL E

mieclair lates yomned in the efforts undertaken by

yroup of compante Which became known a
Hartlord Working Group. (karyan Te Day | at
Turner ‘Test. Day 9 at 176). To date, Apex Oil

ret - { Alice I parbicipal I) al Dh
aactivitie lat have been undertaken by the Hartford

Working Group. (Purner Test. Day 9 at | 1s)

Ziad. % f\ Ad trative Order or
required I Working (aroup to take
numbel Ol acllo ‘ trae Ite, melding
Implementing vera ypes of Interim Mea

try to addre momediate

prol lem it sob bne Ney 1) conducting a

turds Lo Ar L¢ / Cf) iLure and
hydrocarbon contan atl thie
Propo 11)?

for hydrocarbon

Clurner

Tt quired

Upery

7a

ume (I {

\ppendts is to that ryan
130; Pil 146 at APEADIEPO OO
vork identified in Appendix B has fos
been completed with the except
additional di Ived-phase proundwa
ork. (karyan Test. D it 130)
AAV. Interim Measure:
\. Contingency Plan
Core ( ) | f Lep wey
administrative Orde mn Coon nit
rial ze Contingven Vian ce]
esponse ft ipor Complaint, Ti
liartiord. (fat in best Da at 13
EPA RPTO OH) Under the Cor
resident re idavV) | COTM t thre
Departme hack hn respond qu
yirhe 1O CXP (pot CONC
itidate the home nec \! (haat
t 163% ae () MPA RPEO
( Dec) DQ ( NELTTIO HY
( UAaATIO!I V4 | i ! thie Leit
ene! td/O)} flartford I 1)
Mail in) l¢ Da i 140-4]
MPA KRPPO35226-227). If a voluntar
recommended tiie Hiartford Worku
yT aie ternative lodviny irrah ve
iffected resident (faryan Vest. Da
() it KPA RPTPO35227) het
ip pre Kimate] Le) yuntar ( mua
WPA became In ed ats the ite
nt O urril l OO. | a2 34
y| in ldition 1 t| Contings
wees rative (J) ( nsent

Mii ur md an enha nd ex]
: ipor ¢ trol , yr )

Bb. The In-Home Interim Measure Pros mM

I} bn-Hi l
1] ( i¢ 1 elt l
povlentl IQ) (por nits
is in North Hartford i”

biartfon é lo part |

mid t le I nd the tlartford Wor Ci) |

( Yeu tea ¢ t¢ ‘ ,

participat (rarya ’ t 6: |
1) t) Det | { Deft I (54

, Q)nyee 1) ( re | }

Pion Pnte. Nie ‘ |
the tlarttor Wi Ca! if t tie
ij ea ’ yur]

’ mie plet
Vritten ! I . * é '
residen nduct 1) '

i] pect i¢ I ’ tO? | fey t)
|) thwa [ lLirt-lloore re
i ci bea c*Tiie rii ed I } f ‘
md un led | | it | adit

|) ye |)
104

(I .

( leted 1
hol rt

Work! Group ritt tor nor {tie
NOmMeowihie! lette that meld ( | QT ear
Oompleted surve result i the p mbinary 11
mpling na fley [ stall prop od
mitigation packa r the part lar hom I tae
| pre qd mitivgatiol pil } f | ( LOmIZzed (| j
(ne rest of the need i ( mentin that hom if)
j blbat 11} 1cit ley coe | POuUrt I W CONC! {
Poor i floored rawl peace r | emen
existin cract ( ent Wis of}
( Will tlt} l }) Lril mnstalli ()] \
| ( | i! | i] } >? t} WO} i}
1 if} { | I l ( | Vt i L¢ | I
i n | es ( ' [) (

(pr) I ! } }) j li | }
ered | he Hartlord Workin Ay | { ra !
| [ a |) rio? | revulal ir] LO] it tf

t In MT il | I! ‘ {

le the J t Quarter [ i Ca

i Meath ti 1} il | l
inter} bas} hail I |
monitoring ports. (Faryan Test. D
i I I St |) }
(44 uri r. Ss j i } } ' t |
Hiarttord Wort 1) (4) i} ( LT I } 1)¢
trys | r ine ' i] I | [ Te t ear ay ‘ (
' ) r Vhyett | it} t

LODa

(such as re-sealing cracks in basement walls and
floors). (Faryan Test. Day 2 at 16-17; Turner ‘Test
Day 9 at 184)

265. There are approximately 230 homes in North
Hartford. (PLEx. 178 at EPA) RPTOOLO33). The
owners of about one-half of those homes in North
Hartford have accepted a mitigation package and are
participating in the quarterly monitoring and follow
up imspections under the In-Home Interim Measure:
program. (Faryan ‘Vest. Day 2 at 16; Turner Test
Day 9 at 184; Pi Ex. 178 at EPA_RPT001083). A:
required by the Administrative Order on Consent
the Hartford Working Group has borne the cost of the
[n-Llome Interim Measures, including the cost of all
mitigation measures installed ino individual home:
and the cost of all ongoing monitoring and follow-up
work. (PI.Ex. 145; ‘Turner ‘Test. Day 11 at 197)

C. The Area-Wide Vapor Control System

266. When US. EPA assumed a lead role for the Site
In 20038, there was a pre-existing Vapor Control
System that the oil companies had installed in the
Village in the early 1990s. (karyan ‘Pest. Day 1 at
146-47; ‘Turner Vest. Day 9 at 168-69, 172-73; PlEx
208 at EPA 0038412; Plex. 858). The pre-existing
Vapor Control System included a set of twelve soil
Vapor extraction wells beneath a few streets in the
northernmost portion of North Hartford. (Faryan
Test. Day 1 at 146-47; Turner Test. Day 9 at 172-738:
PlLEx. 358 at EPA) RPT085917). That system was:
originally installed after a spate of hydrocarbon odor
complaints and several fires in 1990. (PLEX. 191 at
KE PA_RPT022288-289, 291; Def. Ex. 586 at 47-48
(Table 2 at 6-7))

204 The ongeinal Vapor (lontrol SVstem Wal

1)

I

p1pgtatlio

Ol

Line

Pnteri

It}

relative! hallow dept! ho Vapor mtrusion
mitigation (such as in the A Cla North Olive and
md stratigraphic units), so they are not efficient in
Complishings ma removal of free-phase anid

residual phase hydrocarbon contamination in deeper

nl ayes (such a im the Main Sand and Main Silt

i‘ | i bnteri JI lyre po) raw. y vere 1C% ] y the Hart
lure Department ,¥ 1 ou» 176
KPA RPTOOL846; KF; ay J at 216)

OOrdinato

ord

d il
ford

al

nh (4700.5) [f) bial i Outside Chie police COrar
room (€-C4) nd the cateteriva torare room (€-€-5)
Py. a 87 at KPA RPTO38102% UZ) In August
O04, a contractor for the Hartford Working Group
duet ing work in the basement and reversed

i it ia Cn i323 U7 t had been installed in the
here tora roon i! Vlarch (| f i
vii en 12 4 december ZO04 dditional ly
( il Pid) } brit I itt pied ben ith) tlie

i! [ er r hadi LAA ealetel i AS a
thwest cA itheast CC 9-nos l) police

{ , , (( { i | } } (¢ } il

‘1 ec) | rie ibol { i} ( | pil | | /
1d ! i11)] rediect i! i ntrats
) | i ) { i I i i ( pene
Pat thr maple | tion. ¢ ya best da
brie i inion Conds
I I pri 4 md tron ist 70) sf
yu : } 1] Mmidoot imp! (
j ted i A K | | | I errit I tye iit
1 (17h.4 Lap RVPLOSTO bndoot 1)
| COC l iat | (1) (‘Hf huded
I
I is =
( bl RP 1TO)

hl ie
reheat
| Kl
i?
Kil
if
ii}
'
'
’
ie
il
Kd
i

I I t i’) ft
() { ( ( ; t) me I lt
( { loc} ' ) | RE" ht 4
( , ake [ 4 KILO 194
(* ( bol KE" ] i]
( ! Wis KI 4
. I bt Kt 19
1 fl Kd" | (
| EA ITO
| ie |
( bl Eh
rd il
BA hil
)} 1 bl Re | t
| ie ono
bul I
I KI” |
rt i !
tot {
i
I i]
LO
I bd ry
( ; ea I
‘ i tl Kl
n% Kl
( I KI
( ¢ I I
I i'd
( ( bt Te ae &
( bl a]
{ ( mS 1? oe
t I VRE I
\ Red
( bt nd" |
( ( { EVA RPI
( he Kil
( (| | RPPOS)
| KETO

a

:
BB. Gseolopy and Subsurface Contamination Neat

the Community Center

994 [yn the area near the (ommunity Center, there |

iyilicant hydrocarbon contamination in) thie

bntermediate it and and jaye) a el) a by) Udy
KA

erlying A Clay aie he underlying Main mid

byes HW) area ofl ri hiuad-pha ( LNAPL

COontamiiabion iia vii Ay ¢ biay Withon ] 1 Jeet Ol Lhe

yr id urface just northwest of the Communit

Center. (V7) dcx 9G at LVPA RPTOZG1I74-75, 199)

fn the relat (*] meal urface North Olive tratiun
here 3 i mixture of vasohne range and diese)

riil residual phase Contamination Oouthwest of
( propert near the gntersection of West Arbor

reel nd OId (. luotss toad, and there is diese

! buliil-pohia Vi, contamination just
rt} tol the Community Center. G71.) pd at
hy? PPOYON 4 4(){)
Cater a Hoan f Mand ratum, there 3
(y] Ohne- ranye ana diesel rat
COntamimatiolr | Lic Oulhwesti
yf j cree aL Ol We bao tre | (j Cie
| id 1 thie bese)-y i] |
tail bicil itt) ( hie
( { piled } |
ion (| ((
| {ihe M rit r bye
{ bit { bite i me i (l) wmiixed iSOlibie
qd diesel rag | Vy, te he northea na
U} (is) Ge range |, is Pee Cll a
«a range and diesel range INAV lO Ul
rihiwest nd (ii) diesel-ranpe LNAPI, to the
r rd 4 t. (V1.4 199 at deh’/ KI POY 6208
bhice ree phase | AViL in tl iain na

sidential Air Monitoring Data

of the In-Home
tiie biartlord Worl Pri}? Croup pial

odic indoor and sub-slab sampling in mi

(orl liartford Although most of that d
Obtamed since in-home mith
(he expanded area
ain information in that re
pros Le trong evidence of thr

qrocarbon Japor rmtrusion mnto biartiord }

d below. (Del. Iex.1] ] 116)

pundation have

pola Ve bisyial

tude

pLPuUSION proble
Study 1: A tTlome on Kast Watkins Sti

in the Southernmost Part of North Harttlord

ETCETH Phat monworineg howed Pridicanl
mcrease im hydrocarbon vapor levels 3 hallow an
I hiatlow nil beneath hast Waitt
between Januar (> Wd Januar i
! I he'd
ae iriace |
‘ ( ii' l {
rt od blen na { i. 3 lel
{ Cl l ( irrail dby the i Wort
( , } ! ranuay | WS I I

t t i | le OE } 1]
' 1) ( itractol 1]
\\ } { | breed (} iT | |
@ lov ve timit con L
( } | | i | ( t | | { i i
i) | j | | i ‘
) | | i] 1)! rv if { I a
| (pol ru
| \
’ ! ? 1} | ‘

(Pd. buy bea, | EPA ne rOvz6 i Phiat Lc] tl-poth

Bb. Case Study 2: A Home on Birch Street in the
Northernmost Part ot North Hlartford

154i

shove the detection liniit) for that Canaple. (lyed. bes
bdo oat 4%) G6). Ta sueh eases, the reported numerical
valuedus the benzene detection lanait for the partieulas

itniple A presenibed by US EPA data quality
it bhp cada puidanee doctient: mF in quaditied Value
Cian doe ore ported and treated gu that Wade r, oO thiey
can be reported at one-half of the detection dimiat, af
there as reason to beloeve that the sample actually

Cotitisspseadd thy compound bait that atl was not detected

Cita te, tdae Comparatively larye minountl: ol other
hydrocarbon Compound (Weis Test. Day 5 at 190-22:
Ldet due (HU at JOp day thas anstanmee, the farst floor

reo tilt fev) Peeeyiseedee were .U qualified bois (iis
besarte itt were not. Def. dex. DIIT5 at 2)

a PAL Eee OY heed assessment that wa:
Comipleted rT en home the Dlartlord Work hip
(aioli: Contractor peosbsadbed ae neaatageaatnony prea kiapre iil
the drome, whieh aneladed installing a vent fan
eam all floor and wall cracks, unused floor draims,
and utility conduits, and repauunp a broken sewer
pipe and gastalling a pate valve an the sewer line
(Cahnovsky ‘Test. Day & at 146; PLIx. 372 at
HePAGOLIZ 7) The broken sewer pipe was the result
of the homeowners’ attempt to prevent water from
entermyp thea basement during wet weather

(C'ahimovsky Vest. Day 4 at 146)

MA) Despite the repaurs and sealmp work, the
homeowners Continued to have problems wath water
nile riny their basement co they tired a firm to
Knotall asamp ptimp oo December 2004. That
required the contractor to cut through the basement
floor and diy a hole for the samp. After that had been
done. the contractor and the homeowner smelled very
strong hydrocarbon odors coming from the sump
(Cahnovsky ‘Pest. Day % at 136 13%, Ph flex. 237 at
AVEXOO 1TIPZ29-40, 1167)

j ‘ ye lob prool biti] poudnip and al Crycire

pore WiZalion tenis for the hor 1) Lyie

though quarterly monitoring ha Hnown no
| ()] (prio Vat pO! bhitrusion Wilo thie biconne
(py Ub-slab depre uriZAtion yVSteni Wa
led the sub-slab momitonmnp has continted to
levated hydrocarbon levels beneath the home

yy
1S] | Oe a
t ho tI to mitigate the risk Ol i!
ntrusion problem il { the nome the
Working Group ultimately re-located an ¢

M4 repor
dd V rking
tablished
Lace VALCI
drocarbon
ted that
ce ite)

controlling

ly uriace

ul

022204)

nil if

liartford

APOr

Lol

Val Pol ePxTraAction well on We { Date rytre i oth [ |

Wil Choser to t he home { 4 annoy K \ t 1)

Ir. Case Study 5: A Home on North Delmars
Avenue in the North Central Part of North
liartford

L fhe ney 1 the home it 119 West D { re
USO ON the home at 504 North Delmar Avenue
he current! rent the home to a barge compan
that use it fo hous ome ofits employer Who worl
n the area. In the uimmer of 2007, two married
COULLp I Were iving in the home ine ot the women
Who lived in the home wa prepnant l the tina
(ahi Pest. Da sat 141-4 furner Test. Davy

treet, the owner asked that the home at 504 North
Delman \venue be idded to the In-Home Interu
Mea r | yvram. (burner Test. Day 9 at { |
Before the incident that occurred im 2007, thers
no documented history of prion odo} nN pian
it oth home on North Delmar Avenue wtchnoupn
there had been at least one fire and rtd Crow odor
miplame i other locations within a block of the
home Gn | 9/9 1990) 1Q9Y5. ZOOA ind ZUUD)
rl. Demo. | 621; PL 19} at KPA RPTO
Oy, 291: Def. I 6 at 43-49)
9.8 vi WI) f eral ih por ¢ Lract Chl
erg read yperatin beneath North Delmar
\venue near the home, and two more nearby well
ere if uwled in August and October ZOOW a part ol
the Phase » CXpansion Ol thie Vapor (Control Systen

5
» \ »
LA

(Groundw:

i i} il
i) t} | ’
rid I +} i
tt} 1) ) ’
|
ite i
: i
’ ’ f i
‘
i ! } ’
By i i-pl { 17] l il {
ne} tL ol Vil e ot lat ,
{ : ‘ iti if
(‘iT | I ‘ ‘ ] Te ‘ 4 ; itl
|
{| if t t iJ { if }

()9)
I (| | |
t ! rae. I J 11
re threshold uch
itaminant Ls Is CME] ) ¢ rblishe
Ww; mal Prima Drink!

p prepare weLe bit under thie
(J) | i Qn 4 | 1) | é } if
I I ile) j i} if} |) nted ’

nder that reemet! (burner Pest. Day
ae -00 0] ae i, 20
|
i
Ol Whos Classilte the proundwate!:
biaar ra Cola Potable Resource
i I vhich mean that the vyroundwater 1
for rrent or future arninking wate.
best ba j~ 6a) dino ha
i ! IO} (ja f Gaeneral Use
I mich ipp f round ater tha
hated | mid ri yricultura t
(( sf it ¢1-/2Z)
Md ndards re Clit level ol
, (*| md Cla
orth bi) Minos
e, Part 620. (Cahnovsky ‘Test. D
r both | lel VICI ind tilimois EPA
! 1dv [ aqard the drinking wate
I Tye ene J mMmawater I »ymICcrovram
lL, ). (Peay 1 best. D it 194
PSDROOOKSG-5 : OC bl 1} .6]
‘ t iit
Hected | itt, = the
Hiartior exhibited benzene
1) KN) mu /| level
O60 t | 1] (P11 m4 oat
iz y€ C959) j nm helo roundwatle!l
Nlected jwonitormng wells throughout
hiartior nave contamed benzene

il are at least TImMe the MCL,

Indwate imple information 1

north LO uth througho { thie

ita taken from Pl. Ex 2Zo4 al

Well LIMW-49D is | ead ©) rth |
morth = of inand \yvenue Ccroundwa ! it
Hlected at HMW-49D } med |
mcentratiol hi A

Wel LiMW biart
( niunit Coente propert i! mse

f West Rand \venu () { |
cwoad. Garoundwatet hype ected biMW

ive Onlaiine ben {1}

0) n

Well HTMW-46¢ tiartlon
Communit Center proj {f West Rand
AVvenu Detrweenh thi Old l i i! I i

ru Delmar Ave if Carol agwatel 1m}
collected il biMW-46 | é ( ned nz

entrat itt
. Well HIMW-47( le af ti Lio
Community Cente propert rie I hie Orne
hana \venui ware U] Del é l
Lal mMmawatle! Ana pode eck biviw-4 1)
} | }

rth Uhh ‘

ected at HMWA48D h

' }

—

Ihe Wile! CLIO! i 1) Old | ee Rioad
(;roundwater AmMpi lected at MP | heave
ntammed benzene concentration high a 1? 300)

- Well MP ois located » VV t Cherr treet
wtween rth Old St Lavi} ltoad id= North
Delmar Aven C;round ter samples collected at
lI’ ( have contained ben ne concentratiol
high as 17,200 nu

* Well MI 1) is located on West Cher tre
betwee! mt (old boul load id North
Delmar Avenue. Groundwate! ample collected at
MI’ 1) ar vt ontained by SPA Gee. COnCeCHLrAaLIONn
high a » OU mu 45

© Well MP’-34C ts located on W tC} } [reev ne I
Lyle mitersection Wit rth Delmar \Veriure

-—»

—

—
—

(sroundwat

tained benzene concentrations as |

y" 1] { i { i ’
| t | yt } { ) ‘ }
rroundwat pl lP-64C |
| |
|
i
MW run Y
‘ ] VV 1}
',} . | | { | { biMW » | ‘
ed | t

b Lhe :
tree
pie
!

|
i |
j Vill
lected
'

De] ‘ ‘
UNnUWa Le
{

t ILVA
; |
i jt
tL Wali
HRO
hich as 1
ist
' Lrbor

I 1)
ple treet al
ind orth Ol
lected at MP-6
t | high
roti Whi
Watki Ure
PMW ( ty
tt
1 201 bite
toluene
1! } Ca-p
a Ol
ind = re ue]
RP TOA
‘ f tlio)
mie. Gre hay
) oh nt
{) i
t of |
res (3) 1d \
| I
i 7] i l]
treet. © 5
| ey yt)

~ yas

v4 4 iral | ‘ bit) round ile)
rth tlarttord id normally tlow to the
nd to thre thwe { irate Vlissi Ipyp
iver (a | toward the recharys (nie or tiarttlord
hoapaal (| (ti e best. Day 6 at 4 ne
Dds ) if va Ut) i¢ I | it i
MAPPER POOOTS ¢, Pi OO at KPA RPTO11360. 3
ae () WPA RPTO bit Phe recharge zone o1
i id pl ‘ L}o] rea ] eat irea Trom bach the
Liat ' Is dra Grinkil iter, the i ithun
nui ma cl cone of inthuence. (hag no lest
i) it | ) Hf contamination reach thie} nary
l re 3 i fhig?rh Gt lbhhood that { if b1ip t ti
bhinKI cl 1} I li » thie i (] ! ls
i] rycat in iler Tl I tered
ir t» cd 1) , ‘
trial ccuhite neha i
1 | lord Kefinery propert Least the Village, at
Le f Cul heeding Ca Iie nortl i rive
i nad at thie rine! > tte Ih lortheast
Liie V ilbiagre ré i] eearen' lel at M 1
nd Aquifer generally flows in northe direction

AAXI Mit

Kemedys

qd (Jurnei

(and (itil

AAATL. Ch round
‘ )}
" ’
reequuuired
}
'
’ ,
,
’
er iat '
riij | :
rai tf , | | |
14 7) ‘ |
, ? |
:
|
. i
,
EPA RPTOA1360- 36

(0) .404 al ( 1} ( I mportant
enforcement tool na if ntended te broad
thority to th ( uirt t¢ rant ii] rehet n ( i} |
ensure complete protection of the public health and
the environment ld. (quott C/niite ite
( ; } Wwior ( Jie ( ) Oi) | " | i ¢ yh)
{ V\ |) M ee, ») { V\ g iil } ( d { / if
Waste Ind [rie 1 k.2d 159, 167 (Ath Cir. 1984)
Lion CU). re ul on date t it 1
f nel | nee piled
I ist ane fron id
ti i(radous \ ef hadi anciud !
pot I na I lerve ped Dey} hot
f» ’ ‘ { } ‘
i ( 4 I ( ! } ) t |
! ( | } cok ( ,
aul } ? | | ' ‘

bb. Conditions at the Hartford

May Present an Imminent and Substantial

bndanverment to Health and the kKnvironment

( myrinuanilly
quantilial it

belore ail}

iterpretatiol in) of Le PIsSlative | a6)

or dictional definition of the

tj

require
} , ’ ; |
puantilicaty ] ) l al I ] i Progol | rial
number ; I (po ed tf)
agaeatn Wik | } be é \ upply

contaminal

¢ ‘
Gry |]

Inlende CO) upon the court

yrant alfirma

vith

hould

Ontamll

( Phe Kkndangerment at the Hartford Site

Stems from the Handling, Storage, Treatment,

Pransportation, and/or Disposal of Solid Waste.

i] irtiord

Dd. Defendant Apex Oil Co., Inc is a Person that

ha Contributed to such Handling, Storage

breatment, Trans portation and/or Di: po: al

disposal of “solid wv te at the Hartlor it

the meanim ol ROCKA Lie UU i {
t it) ‘9 fa. yj {

if (lar i] l Clark {) Ap ( narved

pilled ind leaked | Irocarbon 1) ) their Nort!

berminal Lane vhich constituted “contributing 1

Nithin tl meanmy of KCl ti CVV 3¢
| ‘Bee lele. S44 { ), OY, i)

} f ( in} { )y ’ sat ( )) | (j ‘ )
piled, and leaked drocart in nnectio1 ith
the) product recovet ellort bh Le |
li hord Vhich constitutes rit tin Lo thie
Gispo | | old waste it the Hartford L¢ ithan
the meaning of RCK ect (OU45Ca) ‘ | \ ‘

690 » H903(0277). GO7T3(a)
1694 (| ()) (| I ()) } > | } r
deposited pilled wee eaked hydrocarbon AL LU!
Hiartlord ketimer which constituted CONLFIDULIN
Lo thie (i) po i | ()] hid WASTE Within the Silerseeeee
of RCRA TOE i) C4 { { OHY0 5038). BYOABCZ |
{p34 i)
if me Of the I I MPO) Wale i} | i ri}

htefline? al () VV CPT 4 hnazardou WV ol i ¢ Wilhin Lae

, » 4 -P /\ ; if ( {*) |
Mian O| KORA f l ‘ACLerelese, COS { (

6597
it) / ( a Lye 1a A i ¢ tf) c1ari {)
Cola ()i] |) MmSCchnarver dey ) ied Ca

i1Ked if tie Hiartlord Refine: 1 mivyrated
beneath the Village of Tlarttord. Clark O nd (ojart
Qul-Apex thereby “contributed to thi id waste
that may present nh iwnminent bid ist
( lanverment at the Hartlord Site
1¢ e of ti i t I ce con ()
( irt Ci) Ap on nar ( ageposited ied 1)
ked at the Harttor Refine remain tri t
Hartford Refine) propert but { mn rat
breryne h th Wiage of Hartlord. Clark © 1 ¢ |
(i ‘ i | 1) tributed ( Liye r pat
n 1} present b PINE i I

} me nt a Lie ti rtiord na

Kk. Defendant Apex Oil Co., Ine is Jointly and

Severally Liable for Taking Such Action as May

By Necessary to Abate the Hydrocarbon

Contamination at the Hartford Site and All

Associated Conditions that Present or May
‘

Present an Imminent and Substantial

endangerment to Health or the Environment

169. Laabilit under KCRA Section 7OQOS 4 bht and
( eral where the harm | midivi ible ; Ls ul]
ippropriale lor a wateal polluter LO [ye hela i] tye i

ibating an « ndanverment, even i thre 1 bien tem

from multiple parties commingled wastes. See Main
Peopl Alliance M1 F.3d at 298 Cine nt and
everal nature of environmental lability make |
hitting to hold a ingle pollute respon ble for the
totality of the damape where, a here the harm 1

mdivi ble ) (OX 56 I dat 5() | I} > / (0)? Crvoatio?

(nen O19 Upp | is bs, Vuwrora Nat i Rant C404/

i
Water be /) ( ‘
(ya l/ i ra / i
(/th ( } 1) ( if ) 13 { Liye peravion I that I il WOT l
mevitably colored by the nature of ti 1d 1
purpo of the underlying environmental statut
(here, RCRA) Vatne Peo; \/ |
G6. | 1 RCRA endangerment case, th traditional
balhanci of the « puaitie it the rehef st odes nheavi
mfluenced b i CONLTe l ral thumb on the Case 7
{ Or @ { aa 1} LOT) { { Je ae) it (/) f ‘
Bethlehem Steel Cor; Psd 8 | ,
Lr. F934) | 6(mnoOtINn rainari 1)
bay ted te mat { 1h eq it I> bycalaal I {| cry
Dbetore IwWardll mnct reel le}
é } mmental Lat L¢ Whi pre | iil i I (
hh rele] t { rethel I ldin hei 11 rici
( it properly dered bye ‘ ! lel I}
bethlehen Without nae LKInN i rwrrin Of ti
Cquitie or makin hnding Of irreparable harm )
KPA v. Enovtl. Waste C ri {) I (
Cir. 1990) (Where th piaintif! 3 ereign
where the activit ndanyve! he public healtt
myunctive rehet prope without rtf
balancing Gntert quotations omitted))
176. In balanecin Lhe equith bha rin UT

r puilable batanee LIP trong In fave Ql ¢ tt Olt!
myuncetio1 mht by the United Irom tl
ePVIGEehce il trial Cal thie ent) 1 hh
requested injunction would benefit: the citi
Llarttord ha promote the Cor re i Lily ‘oD ed

CONCLUSION

\ppendix ¢

lL d/ntroduction and Bacil pround

i { ( Pel j Bley {> /
kfendant rea lexpands uy
rj } tyical }
{ J i ted { i
( I I ( i
hea Det lant
; | j ) ry)¢ |
1¢-} Liye | foil (
nn ) {
}
( {)
()] ( c)(] tty

Il. Analysis

mIideration

{
PLOT TOT

? f " A The lik j
biG AL TOT) WOUTG PIKE LY

hi matte? ha
tober. 2ZOOGB. (Doc. 9.)

motion at this late juncture

{ a final re Olution of thi

| ped Lry-COd) ae]

SO ORDERED

Appendix JD

MIEMORANDUM AND ORDE!
High NDO
lL. d/ntroduction

| t ! (

( titi I j

( { a |) |
f ( | if ( I ’

{ { 1} f , { |
11 | ( ij j |
wschal Pie ! | ! (

IH. Backpround

A. Summary Judyment

Under the bankrupte Yy ode

I ' } ’ | | ,
| ‘
! } I | j , }
' ' '
a’?
( i
f : ¢ } } }
' : )
; | '
) } } '
) , i (
/ ' ( i
i
I
| {
t i
:
; ; i
| i
' | | ? i |
f ) "
t
’
, | '
A 4 i
| jf f ’ '
i ' , i s |
:
‘ ‘ |

' CfConcluston

Phu the (¢ irt (al i , ,

boy | roia Phighbiaal pli I I (|) ) Pun

ss | ( () | he ( rt here! DiC] Kit

} Inyunets hit } re { fore
f @oOl ACcTIOI a] 5 @ | aryere {
Dean 1y>t |! I i Ded

pred

ITT ISSO ORDERED

\ppendix I

\ppendix I

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386017_1653%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
