# Respondents Brief — Environmental Protection Agency v. New York, 127 S. Ct. 2127 (2007) (No. 06-736)

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386016_1799%3A5

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Respondents Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 2007

## Text

4

No. 06-736

IN THE

Supreme Court of the Gnited States

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMIEN” AL PROTECTION AGENCY.

Petitioner.

STATE OF NEW YORK. ef a/..

Respondents.

On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals
for the District of Columbia Circuit

RESPONSE OF THE NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL
DEVELOPMENT ASSOCITATION’S CLEAN AIR
PROJECT IN SUPPORT OF PETITION
FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

bistit Ste Rivrs*

LORANE Fb. HEBERT

HOGAN & HARTSON LLP.
SSS Thirteenth Street. N.W.
Washington. D.C. 20004

(202) 637-6575

*Counsel of Record Counsel for Respondent
National Environmental
Development Association's
Clean Air Project

WiILSON-EPES PRINTING Co., INC. — (202) 789-0096 — WASHINGTON. D.C 20001

PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDING
AND RULE 29.6 STATEMENT

The National Environmental Development Association’s
Clean Air Project (““NEDA/CAP”) was an intervenor in
support of the United States Environmental Protection
Agency (“EPA”) in the D.C. Circuit below, and is a respon-
dent in this case. EPA’s petition lists all the parties to the
proceeding. See Pet. ii-iiii NEDA/CAP is a non-profit
association of manufacturers that has no parent corporations

and has issued no stock.

(i)

ii

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDING .
AND RULE 29.6 STATEMENT..............cc:0000000 i
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES. .ccccccsccrvescecicceesscsrcsssesies iil
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE
Peer Bh GPO endesticninisciguensinideiiihiiedaidaiaibeastaatelidegaananasins |

ili

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Page

STATUTES:
8 UE © TICLE Ritcconncinncicencivotnicminindermnscsniccees 4
A Seiad a PU HE ickicatninksimasareaticasstatintemaeoieulls 2
RULES:
is ae NE TID visidesiletsninibitneicdeoipnabtrbnieeienicisesgesesoneiinst l
REGULATIONS:
QO CET. S SE. ROGER FID sccscevicectvivcecessesecncseniovsecs 5
65 Fed. Reg. 77623 (Dec. 12, 2000) ................... cai 2
OTHER AUTHORITIES:
Detroit Edison Applicability Determination

Detailed Analysis (May 23, 2000)...................0025 3

EPA, New Source Review: Report to the
I IEE Sid inc tiinecinrincaiaiiamsthedreltiameninls 5

IN THE

Supreme Court of the Gnited States

No. 06-736

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,

Petitioner,
V.

STATE OF NEW YORK, et al.,
Respondents.

t

On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals
for the District of Columbia Circuit

RESPONSE OF THE NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL
DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION’S CLEAN AIR
PROJECT IN SUPPORT OF PETITION
FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

Pursuant to S. Ct. Rule 12.6, respondent National Envi-
ronmental Development Association’s Clean Air Project
(“NEDA/CAP”) respectfully submits this response in support
of the petition for certiorari filed by the Environmental
Protection Agency (“EPA”) seeking review of the judgment
of the United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit
below. The D.C. Circuit invalidated an important regulatory
initiative under the Clean Air Act (“CAA”)}—EPA’s Equip-
ment Replacement Provision (“ERP”) rule—that sought to

2

bring much needed certainty and consistency to a complex
administrative scheme. The court’s decision adversely
affects thousands of regulated entitles nationwide, and has
deleterious consequences for regulators and the environment
as well. The Solicitor General has deemed this matter
important enough to merit this Court’s review. The petition
should be granted.

1. NEDA/CAP intervened in support of EPA in the D.C.
Circuit below. NEDA/CAP’s members are manufacturers
representing major industrial sectors, including the aero-
space, aluminum, automobile manufacturing, natural re-
source exploration, refining and petrochemicals, pharmaceu-
ticals, electronics, and home _ products industries.
NEDA/CAP’s members own and operate “major emitting
facilities” and “major stationary sources” under the CAA,
and thus are subject to the Act’s New Source Review
(“NSR”) permitting requirements when they undertake an
activity at their plants that constitutes a “modification”—
defined in the Act as “any physical change in, or change in
the method of operation of, a stationary source which in-
creases the amount of any air pollutant emitted by such
source or which results in the emission of any air pollutant
not previously emitted.” 42 U.S.C. § 7411(a)(4).

Manufacturers typically use multiple process lines—
consisting of dozens or even hundfeds of pieces of equip-
ment—-to make various products during different periods of
the year depending on economic demand and other factors.
Over the life of a piece of a equipment, manufacturers
undertake numerous routine maintenance, repair, and re-
placement activities to ensure the safety, reliability, and
efficiency of the equipment. Such activities typically do not
alter the equipment’s original design or production capacity,
but merely allow the equipment to function as it had before it
began to deteriorate. In other words, such activities do not
physically “change” a piece of equipment in any fundamental

3

way, but merely “maintain{] the [equipment] as designed.”
Pet. App. 46a.

2. EPA has long recognized that “Congress specifically
decided that existing sources generally would not be required
to obtain [NSR] permits,” id. at 117a, and that therefore
“Congress did not intend that every activity at an existing
facility be considered a physical or operational change for
purposes of NSR.” /d. at 13la (quotation omitted). Thus,
since the inception of the NSR program, EPA has excluded
from the definition of “physical change” activities that
constitute “routine maintenance, repair, and replacement”
(“RMRR”). See id. at 119a-12la. Prior to the ERP rule,
EPA had never sought to specify what types of activities
constituted RMRR. Instead, EPA applied the RMRR exclu-
sion on “a case-by-case basis,” using an indeterminate
“multi-factor test” that involved “weighing the nature, extent,
purpose, frequency, and cost of the work as well as other
factors.” Jd. at 4a, 31a (quotation omitted). In one applica-
bility determination, EPA considered 14 different factors in
determining whether a proposed activity constituted RMRR.
See Detroit Edison Applicability Determination Detailed
Analysis 10-11 (May 23, 2000); 65 Fed. Reg. 77623 (Dec.
12, 2000).

Over time, EPA came to acknowledge that the RMRR
exclusion has been difficult to apply and that it has produced
undesirable results. As EPA has explained, the application of
the exclusion on a “case-by-case basis” has made it “difficult
for the owner or operator to know with reasonable certainty
- whether a particular activity constitutes RMRR.” Pet. App.
32a. That uncertainty has led sources “to forego needed and
beneficial maintenance, repair, and replacement activities,
including ones that would likely have reduced emissions.”
Id. at 34a. It has also posed problems for regulators, who
must “devote scarce resources to make complex [RMRR]
determinations. /d.

4

To remedy these and other problems, EPA adopted the
ERP rule—a bright line rule that automatically excludes
certain RMRR activities from the definition of “physical
change.” Under the ERP rule, an activity falls within the
RMRR exclusion if it (1) involves replacement of any
existing components of a unit with components that are
identical or serve the same purpose as the replaced compo-
nents; (2) the fixed capital cost of the replaced component,
plus costs of any activities that are part of the replacement
activity, does not exceed 20 percent of the current replace-
ment value of the unit; and (2) the replacement does not alter
the basic design parameters of the unit or cause the unit to
exceed any legally enforceable emissions or operational
limitation that applies to any component of the unit. /d. at
4la.

EPA explained that the ERP rule would provide certainty
to regulated entities, ease administrative burdens by freeing
regulators from the task of “time-consuming RMRR deter-
minations,” and remove disincentives to RMRR activities,
“thereby enhancing key operational elements such as effi-
ciency, safety, reliability, and environmental performance.”
Id. at 36a.° EPA further noted that, “[ijn many cases, we
believe that maintaining safe, reliable, and efficient opera-
tions will have the corresponding environmental benefit of
reducing the amount of pollution generated per product
produced.” Jd. at 44a. Thus, EPA emphasized, the ERP rule
“{is] consistent with the central purpose of the CAA”—“ ‘to
protect and enhance the quality of the Nation’s air resources
so as to promote the public health and welfare and the
productive capacity of its population.’” Jd. (quoting 42
U.S.C. § 7401(b)(1).

4. The D.C. Circuit invalidated that important regulatory
initiative. Although the court acknowledged that the term
“physical change” is “susceptible to multiple meanings,” id.
at 17a, the court nevertheless concluded that Congress’s use
of the term “any” before “physical change” mandated that the

5

term “physical change” be given its most “expansive mean-
ing.” Jd. at 12a. The court thus held that “physical change”
encompasses all “activities within each of the common
meanings of the [term] * * * when the activity results in an
emission increase.” Jd. at 17a. EPA, therefore, was not free
to “pick and choose among them.” /d. at 12a. The court also
held that the ERP rule was invalid because it “would allow
equipment replacements resulting in non-de minimis emis-
sions increases.” /d. at 17a.

5. This Court’s review of the D.C. Circuit’s decision is
warranted. The question presented is important and affects
thousands of regulated entities across the country in all major
industrial sectors. The ERP rule provides regulated entities
with certainty that certain types of repair and replacement
activities—those involving the repair or replacement of
components with identical or functionally equivalent compo-
nents that do not alter the basic design parameters of a unit
and that do not exceed 20 percent of the current replacement
value of the unit—fall within the RMRR exclusion. That
certainty will encourage entities to undertake critical repair
and replacement activities that promote the safety, reliability,
and efficiency of their equipment, and that may have the
“corresponding environmental benefit” of reducing emissions
from a source. /d. at 44a.

As EPA noted, the uncertainty attending the existing
RMRR exclusion has led sources “to forego needed and
beneficial maintenance, repair, and replacement activities,
including ones that would likely have reduced emissions,” id.
at 34a, rather than run the risk of triggering NSR review.
That is not only because NSR review is burdensome and
expensive, but also because it is extremely time-consuming
and results in significant delays. As EPA recently reported,
the entire NSR permitting process can take between 7 and 22
months. See EPA, New Source Review: Report to the
President 20 (2002). If NSR review is triggered, a source
may not undertake the proposed activity until a permit has

6

been issued. See 40 C.F.R. § 51.166(a)(7)(iii). Dozens if not
hundreds of repair and replacement activities that merely
“maintain[] the [equipment] as designed,” Pet. App. 46a,
could occur on a single process line over the course of a year.
If all such activities were subject to NSR review, manufactur-
ing in this country would virtually grind to a halt. See id. at
33a (noting that NSR delays present “a potentially significant
barrier to today’s global, quick-to-market industries, such as
computer chips, pharmaceuticals, and autos”).

The D.C. Circuit’s invalidation of the ERP rule has adverse
consequences for regulated entities, federal and state regula-
tors, and the environment. Moreover, as the Solicitor Gen-
eral explains (Pet. 23), the court’s ruling may limit EPA’s
ability to remedy the problems associated with the existing
RMRR exclusion and may even cast doubt on that exclusion
itself—even though EPA has “historically construed” the
exclusion to “encompass[] activities that are within the
broadest meaning of ‘physical change’ ” id. at 23, and has
“never construed” the exclusion “to encompass only de
minimis emissions increases,” id. at 17-18—as well as
several other exclusions that have been in existence for
nearly thirty years. See id. at 10,24. There is accordingly no
basis for the Court to wait until another day to resolve this
important issue. The Court should thus grant review and
ensure that NSR review is limited to “new” sources, just as
Congress intended.

7

CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, and those in EPA’s petition for
certiorari, the petition should be granted and the D.C. Cir-

cuit’s judgment reversed.

*Counsel of Record

Respectfully submitted,

LESLIE SUE RITTS*

LORANE F. HEBERT

HOGAN & HARTSON L.L.P.
555 Thirteenth Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20004
(202) 637-6573

Counsel for Respondent
National Environmental
Development Association's
Clean Air Project

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386016_1799%3A5. Public record. Not legal advice.
