# Opposition Brief — District of Columbia Water and Sewer Authority Authority Authority v. Friends of the Earth, Inc. (No. 06-119)

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386016_1222%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Opposition Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 2006

## Text

t
: f
#2 } ; a a A fe F
| ; NOW 22
i

7 x ALE
| OFFICE OF rHE CLE!
No. 06-119 _SUPREME COURT U

In the Supreme Court of the Anited States

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA WATER AND SEWER
AUTHORITY, PETITIONER

Vv.
FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, INC., ET AL.

ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

BRIEF FOR THE FEDERAL RESPONDENTS
IN OPPOSITION

PAUL D. CLEMENT
Solicitor General
Counsel of Record
SUE ELLEN WOOLDRIDGE
Assistant Attorney General
JOHN A. BRYSON
Attorney
Department of Justice
Washington, D.C. 20530-0001
(202) 514-2217

aT
S.

vow»

QUESTION PRESENTED

Whether, under Section 303(d) of the Clean Water
Act, 33 U.S.C. 1813(d), the Environmental Protection
Agency and the District of Columbia are required to
express maximum pollutant loads for impaired dente
bodies on a daily basis.

tc a

(I)

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page
NS WOO 6 inde nanan Chddn Veewngrekn teenveusaeeaha 1
IO So oo seiko Kew ke con abe eeee tidbit ieee 1
NE Fcc nacicdccahsied cada ce cise bandsas neers ee 1
IG, 0.000 04ck 2 banwnde CAWRide A Ate 7
OD 5. o 2 oe ccckncnd chacebaindis nbaekaus cyanea 12
pS ee ee ere Te Pe FE PT Fee la

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Cases:

Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. NRDC, 467 U.S. 887 (1984) .... 5,9

FDA v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S.
Po eR errr Free al oe Per Sete an Es POE 7

NRDC v. Muszynski, 268 F.3d 91 (2d Cir. 2001) ... 6,9, 10
Pronsolino v. Nastri, 291 F.3d 1123 (9th Cir.

2002), cert. denied, 539 U.S. 926 (2008) .............. 3
Statutes and regulations:

Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. 1251 et seq. ..............-. 1
SO Ua SEO, pelevcddentecearsevirscaenebagada 2
Se REARS DAME 5 hbo ha bc nth cde ccccveneevevesaeis 2
SR TEGGs SET eases ek once 5 Ses hae ceees 2
SE LAA RIAA 6b os God ow esntuvtesaadew sedans 3
Se Aha SRD acc wich dun cewNienceeusaeueenaen 2
SB UBL. TRI bbc bh erecta vdesvsewevns 2, 3,8
SE ULL, ERS ed no shoe eeens tavanduape 2, 3, 8,9
We ULB, SR 6 kb kee aS ai dees evaaeeteees 3

FO UMA BOOS Fs dccercnkscovracsddevecscexes 2, 3, 11

IV

Statutes and regulations—Continued: Page
EE Se on oes x5 Saeed bebe Hdncad ceusewees 11
SEE SOS Boo eis Sines seein 11
Be Shar COE sick oc euRRRRG cans ced veneawess 2
BEAK SEE kn dbo bisceed dcp kecaeveces 2
SRT SS oc kbc dceds wodsdewinyinceredewes 2

40 C.F.R.:
Section 122.44(d)(1)(viiMB) ......... cece cece ee eee 3
See SR 6 ei eh eG 11
BONE DMEF) | isin Cop babesecenstuehensoauuets 3
SOUS SN). vere cc coed deeds kd ccae bes acaerees 9
SINE SIRS a Gd anwa ck? Rak keane Raa Rae 11

Miscellaneous:

GB Fak, Tee GC Ge od ss Sanh nbs hcevcriacnss 3
BO FOU. Be VERS oc cre hc kda wees sdansceetancsens 9
OO Pad, Raw: OB ON): 6.65 ooo Shiv ade) 11

In the Supreme Court of the Gnited States

No. 06-115

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA WATER AND SEWER
AUTHORITY, PETITIONER

Vv.
FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, INC., ET AL.

ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

BRIEF FOR THE FEDERAL RESPONDENTS
IN OPPOSITION

OPINIONS BELOW

The opinion of the court of appeals (Pet. App. 1a-13a)
is reported at 446 F.3d 140. The opinion of the district
court (Pet. App. 1b-37b) is reported at 346 F. Supp. 2d
182.

JURISDICTION

The judgment of the court of appeals (Pet. App. 1c-
2c) was entered on April 25, 2006. The petition for a
writ of certiorari was filed on July 21, 2006. The juris-
diction of this Court is invoked under 28 U.S.C. 1254(1).

STATEMENT

1. Congress enacted the Clean Water Act (CWA or
Act), 33 U.S.C. 1251 et seq., “to restore and maintain the

(1)

2

chemical, physical, and biological integrity of the Na-
tion’s waters.” 33 U.S.C. 1251(a). Section 303 of the
CWA requires each State (as well as the District of Co-
lumbia, 33 U.S.C. 1362(3)) to adopt water quality stan-
dards applicable to its waters. 33 U.S.C. 1313(a)-(e).

The CWA prohibits the unauthorized discharge of a
pollutant from a point source into a water of the United
States. 33 U.S.C. 1311(a), 1362(12).’ A discharger may
comply with the Act by obtaining and adhering to the
terms of a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination
System (NPDES) permit issued pursuant to 33 U.S.C.
1342. NPDES permits contain technology-based efflu-
ent limitations that reflect the pollution reduction
achievable based on particular equipment or process
changes, without reference to the effect on the receiving
water. Where necessary, they also include more strin-
gent effluent limitations (known as “water quality-based
effluent limitations”) necessary to ensure that the re-
ceiving waters achieve applicable water quality stan-
dards. See 33 U.S.C. 1311(b).

Congress also required States to establish “total
maximum daily loads” (TMDLs) for “those waters
within its boundaries for which the effluent limitations
* * * are not stringent enough to implement any water
quality standard applicable to such waters.” 33 U.S.C.
1313(d)(1)(A) and (C). States must establish a priority
ranking for such waters, and then, in accordance with
that priority ranking, develop for each water body a

A “point source” is “any discernible, confined and
discrete conveyance * * * from which pollutants are
or may be discharged.” 33 U.S.C. 1362(14). “Nonpoint
sources” are sources of pollution that are not “point
sources,” such as runoff from agricultural activities.

3

TMDL for each pollutant that the Environmental Pro-
tection Agency (EPA) has determined to be suitable for
a TMDL. /bid. EPA has determined that “[a]ll pollut-
ants, under the proper technical conditions, are suitable
for the calculation of total maximum daily loads.” 43
Fed. Reg. 60,665 (1978) (emphasis omitted). States must
submit their TMDLs to EPA for approval. 33 U.S.C.
1313(d)(2).

A TMDL “shall be established at a level necessary
to implement the applicable water quality standards
with seasonal variations and a margin of safety.” 33
U.S.C. 1313(d)(1)(C). The term “total maximum daily
load” is not further defined in the CWA. EPA’s regula-
tions define a TMDL to be the sum of (1) the “waste-
load allocations” allocated to point sources; (2) the “load
allocations” attributed to nonpoint sources or natural
background; and (3) a margin of safety. 40 C.F.R.
130.2(g)-(i).

TMDLs are not self-executing. Like water quality
standards, wasteload allocations for point sources are
implemented through NPDES permits issued pursuant
to 33 U.S.C. 1842. See 40 C.F.R. 122.44(d)(1)(vii)(B).”
Load allocations for nonpoint sources are implemented
through voluntary or cooperative approaches, or by
State or local law. See generally Pronsolino v. Nastri,
291 F.3d 1123, 1126-1127 (9th Cir. 2002), cert. denied,
539 U.S. 926 (2003).

“Even in the absence of TMDLs, permits must
include effluent limitations as stringent as necessary to
meet water quality standards. 33 U.S.C. 1311(b)(1)(C).
A TMDL is simply one tool for establishing such
limitations.

4

2. The Anacostia River originates in Maryland and
flows through the District of Columbia before joining
the Potomac River. C.A. App. 665. Pursuant to 33 .
U.S.C. 1313(d)(1)(A), the District identified the portion
of the river that flows through the District as not meet-
ing its water quality standards for dissolved oxygen and
turbidity (muddy or cloudy conditions). C.A. App. 390,
666, 724-725. The two TMDLs at issue here address
those impairments.

The District’s dissolved oxygen water quality stan-
dard seeks to protect water quality by requiring a mini-
mum level of dissolved oxygen upon which aquatic or-
ganisms rely. Certain pollutants consume dissolved oxy-
gen. One measure of the rate at which dissolved oxygen
is consumed is a parameter called “biochemical oxygen
demand” (BOD). The District established the BOD
TMDL using a computer model that projected how a
given percentage reduction in pollutant loads would af-
fect dissolved oxygen levels. C.A. App. 146, 152-214,
269-272. The TMDL sets an annual average load reduc-
tion for BOD from storm water loads and combined
sewer overflows (CSOs) based on the results of the mod-
eling and the application of best professional judgment.
Id. at 396-400, 402, 408-442, 678-679, 684-685. The Dis-
trict concluded, and EPA agreed, that expressing the
BOD TMDL in terms of annual average loads of BOD
was appropriate because the undesirable increases in
BOD were attributable to the aggregate accumulation of
oxygen-demanding materials over an annual cycle. /d.
at 395-396, 398, 684.

The Anacostia River also fails to meet the District’s
water quality standard for turbidity. See C.A. App. 745.
Excessive levels of total suspended solids (TSS) were
identified as the main cause of these violations. /d. at

5

55. EPA developed a TMDL to protect fish, shellfish,
and wildlife by setting TSS loads at a seasonal median
average concentration of less than 15 mg/I for the period
from April | through October 31, which assures water
clarity sufficient for the growth of the aquatic vegetation
necessary to sustain aquatic wildlife. /d. at 94, 107, 745-
749, 803, 806. EPA also concluded that the required
load was appropriately expressed as a seasonal load.
While submerged aquatic vegetation provides essential
food and habitat for aquatic organisms every day
throughout the year, EPA concluded that TSS concen-
trations in the water column do not substantially impact
the submerged aquatic vegetation community on a daily
basis or outside the growing season of April 1 to October
31. Id. at 94, 113, 775, 803-806.

3. Respondent Friends of the Earth brought this
action against EPA for judicial review of the TMDLs,
and petitioner Water and Sewer Authority (WASA) in-
tervened as a defendant. Respondent contended, inter
alia, that TMDLs must be expressed as “daily” loads.
C.A. App. 808-825.

The district court granted EPA’s motion for sum-
mary judgment. Pet. App. 1b-37b. In light of the com-
plexity of the statutory scheme and the function of
TMDLs as an intermediate tool for achieving compliance
with water quality standards, the court concluded that
Congress had not expressed an unambiguous intent that
every TMDL must be set on a daily basis, “when certain
pollutants are more amenable to regulation through sea-
sonal or annual calculations.” Jd. at 12b. Accordingly,
the court determined that under Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v.
NRDC, 467 U.S. 837 (1984), it was required to defer to
EPA’s reasonable interpretation and application of the
statute. Pet. App. 19b-22b. Here, the court found that

6

EPA had reasonably established annual and seasonal
loads because of the specific nature of the pollution
problems being addressed. /bid.

4. The court of appeals reversed. Pet. App. la-13a.
It concluded that the CWA unambiguously requires
daily loads for all TMDLs. /d. at 5a-13a. The court
therefore rejected EPA’s reliance on its judgment that
the limits for some pollutants, such as BOD and TSS,
are more appropriately expressed with non-daily load
allocations. Jd. at 6a-8a. In doing so, the court declined
to follow a decision of the Second Circuit holding that
TMDLs may be expressed in terms other than daily load
allocations. /d. at 9a (discussing NRDC v. Muszynski,
268 F.3d 91, 99 (2001)).

The court also rejected petitioner’s argument that
Congress’s enactment of subsequent legislation address-
ing combined sewer overflows indicates that EPA has
flexibility in interpreting the TMDL requirements. Pet.
App. 9a-12a. The court held that the CSO policy en-
dorsed by Congress requires full compliance with the
other provisions of the CWA, and stated that petitioner
could not rely on subsequent legislation to establish the
intent of an earlier Congress. /d. at lla. The court re-
manded for the district court to vacate EPA’s approval
of the TMDLs, but allowed fae parties to seek a stay
pending the establishment 0° new TMDLs. /d. at 12a-
13a.”

°The court also rejected EPA’s claim that the case
had become moot because the District had, while the
case was on appeal, revised the water quality standards
for dissolved oxygen and turbidity that apply to the
Anacostia. Pet. App. 1la-12a. The court explained that
because “|t]he TMDLs at issue here have never been

ARGUMENT

The court of appeals erred in holding that the CWA
requires EPA to establish TMDLs as daily load alloca-
tions. Nevertheless, the court’s decision does not war-
rant this Court’s review. The judgment will have only
limited effect because it is controlling law only in the
District of Columbia. Moreover, EPA recently issued
nationwide guidance for expressing TMDLs as daily
loads. As a result, future controversies about the mean-
ing of the CWA’s provisions for TMDLs will likely arise
in significantly different contexts.

1. Contrary to the holding of the court of appeals,
the use of the word “daily” in the term “total maximum
daily load” is not an unambiguous direction that TMDLs
must be stated in the form of a uniformly applicable
24-hour load. “In determining whether Congress has
specifically addressed the question at issue, a reviewing
court should not confine itself to examining a particular
statutory provision in isolation. The meaning—or am-
biguity—of certain words or phrases may only become
evident when placed in context.” FDA v. Brown & Wil-
liamson Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S. 120, 132 (2000).

The CWA neither defines the term “total maximum
daily load” nor specifies how a TMDL should be ex-
pressed. Instead, the Act explains that TMDLs are in-
tended “to implement * * * water quality standard([s],”
and therefore:

repealed or superseded,” they continue to be relevant to
the NPDES permitting process. J/bid. On further
reflection, the government agrees that the case is not
moot.

8

shall be established at a level necessary to imple-
ment the applicable water quality standards with
seasonal variations and a margin of safety which
takes into account any lack of knowledge concerning
the relationship between effluent limitations and wa-
ter quality.

33 U.S.C. 1313(d)(1)(A) and (C) (emphasis added). Thus,
the crucial hallmark and function of a TMDL is not
that it is expressed in daily terms, but that it is set at
a “level necessary to implement the applicable water
quality standards with seasonal variations.” 33 U.S.C.
1313(d)(1)(C).

Because the “necessary” level can vary, especially
“with seasonal variations,” 33 U.S.C. 1313(d)(1)(C), the
term “daily” should not be read in isolation to require
that every TMDL be established on an inflexible 24-hour
basis. In some circumstances, TMDLs with non-daily
allocations best reflect the levels necessary to meet a
water quality standard for a particular pollutant in a
particular water body (be it a river, stream, pond, lake,
or reservoir). While many TMDLs can easily be ex-
pressed in terms of a 24-hour time period, such as those
for some pollutants discharged from point sources in a
predictable and continuous manner, other TMDLs may
more appropriately use a non-daily load, such as an
hourly, weekly, monthly, seasonal, or annual load.

In this case, for example, the pollutants of con-
cern—BOD and TSS—primarily enter the Anacostia
River during rainstorms. Thus, discharges of BOD and
TSS will vary widely from one day to the next. In addi-
tion, BOD affects water quality indirectly by fueling a
variety of biological and chemical reactions that reduce
dissolved oxygen in the water. These reactions are de-

9

pendent on such factors as temperature, biological activ-
ity, sunlight, tides, and the volume and speed of flow of
water in the river. C.A. App. 183-214. This variable
reaction rate means that the BOD discharged today may
not cause a problem today, but can accumulate and un-
der certain conditions affect dissolved oxygen levels in
the Anacostia River in the future. Jd. at 221.

Similarly, TSS can have a negative physical effect by
blocking sunlight from reaching submerged aquatic veg-
etation, which prevents or slows photosynthesis and
thus affects the growth and survival of such vegetation.
For this reason, TSS discharges are not significant if
they occur on any given day, but rather when they re-
duce water clarity overall within the growing season to
the extent that the reduced sunlight affects the growth
and survival of submerged aquatic vegetation. C.A.
App. 777.

The varied and complex circumstances of water pol-
lution underscore that Congress’s direction that TMDLs
be “established at a level necessary to implement the
applicable water quality standards with seasonal varia-
tions,” 33 U.S.C. 1313(d)(1)(C), does not unambiguously
impose a rigid one-size-fits-all requirement that every
TMDL be expressed as a 24-hour load. The court of ap-
peals’ contrary reading “loses sight of the overall struc-
ture and purpose of the CWA.” NRDC v. Muszynski,
268 F.3d 91, 98 (2d Cir. 2001). It is also contrary to
longstanding EPA regulations and guidance entitled to
deference under Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. NRDC, 467 U.S.
837 (1984). See 40 C.F.R. 130.243) (“TMDLs can be ex-
pressed in terms of either mass per time, toxicity or
other appropriate measure.”); 50 Fed. Reg. 1776 (1985)
(“TMDLs * * * may be expressed in terms of an ap-
propriate averaging period, such as weekly or monthly,

10

as long as compliance with applicable [water quality
standards] is assured.”).

2. The Second Circuit correctly upheld non-daily
TMDLs in Muszynski, 268 F.3d at 98-99. There, the
court approved TMDLs that were expressed as seasonal
and annual loads and declined to ascribe to Congress the
irrational intent to impose a strict requirement of daily
loads, “given that for some pollutants, effective regula-
tion may best occur by some other periodic measure
than a diurnal one.” /d. at 99.

The conflict between Muszynski and the decision be-
low does not, however, warrant this Court’s review. The
decision below is controlling law only in the District of
Columbia. TMDLs are written by the States and ap-
proved by EPA Regional Administrators, or generated
by EPA, and they are generally reviewed under the Ad-
ministrative Procedure Act in federal district courts in
the States where the impaired water bodies are located.

Moreover, EPA recently issued a guidance memoran-
dum for the States and EPA Regions “recommend[ing]
that all future TMDLs * * * be expressed in daily time
increments,” even in States within the Second Circuit.
App., infra, 2a, 3an.1. The guidance explains, however,
that there is flexibility in how the daily loads may be
expressed. /d. at 3a-5a. For example, in some circum-
stances TMDLs may be “expressed in terms of differing
maximum daily values depending on the season of the
year, stream flow (e.g., wet v. dry weather conditions) or
other factors.” /d. at 4a.

As a result of EPA’s new guidance, the current dis-
agreement between the D.C. and Second Circuits will
have only limited prospective effect, because new
TMDLs will likely be drafted in a way that is consistent
with the D.C. Circuit’s decision but that also provides

11

the necessary flexibility. Because any future controver-
sies concerning TMDLs will likely arise in the signifi-
cantly different context of the approach outlined in
EPA’s new guidance, this Court’s review is not war-
ranted at this time.

3. Finally, there is no merit to petitioner’s argument
that requiring TMDLs to be expressed on a daily basis
“directly conflicts” with Section 402(q) of the Act, which
concerns combined sewer overflows. As EPA’s new

guidance explains, expressing 7MDLs on a daily basis
does not require that permits be expressed on that ba-
sis. See App., infra, Ta-1la.

Section 402(q) states that discharge permits, orders,
and decrees “shall conform” to EPA’s Combined Sewer
Overflow Control Policy (CSO Control Policy), 59 Fed.
Reg. 18,688 (1994). 33 U.S.C. 1342(q)(1). Petitioner
correctly describes (Pet. 13-14) that policy as promoting
a flexible, site-specific approach for achieving compli-
ance with CWA requirements. See 59 Fed. Reg. at
18,688.

Consistent with the CSO Control Policy’s call for a
flexible, site-specific approach, and with the flexibility
provided by the NPDES provisions, the permitting au-
thority may establish water quality-based effluent limi-
tations in an NPDES permit that are not expressed as
daily limitations. The statute and regulations provide
flexibility in the manner in which effluent limitations for
non-continuous discharges such as CSOs are expressed.
See 33 U.S.C. 1342; 40 C.F.R 122.45(e). While water
quality-based effluent limitations must be consistent
with the assumptions and requirements of available
wasteload allocations in TMDLs approved by EPA (40
C.F .R. 130.7), those assumptions may include irregular-
ity in the volume and frequency of storm water flows.

12

See App., infra, 5a-6a, 9a-10a. Thus, as EPA’s new
guidance explains, a TMDL expressed as a daily load
can be implemented in an NPDES permit authorizing
discharges of overflows from a combined sewer system
consistent with EPA’s CSO Control Policy and Section
402(q) of the CWA. See App., infra, 7a-10a; cf. Pet. App.
lla (“[T]he tension between the CSO Policy’s flexibility
and the perceived rigidity of daily loads exists only if
daily loads must of necessity be set so low that any
storm-event discharge would violate them—a premise
unsupported anywhere in the record.”).

Because expressing a TMDL as a daily load does not
interfere with a permit writer’s authority under the reg-
ulations to translate that daily load into the appropriate
permit limitation, which in turn could be expressed as an
hourly, weekly, monthly, or other measure as appropri-
ate, petitioner’s concern is misplaced. No court of ap-
peals has rejected that approach to reconciling TMDLs
expressed as daily loads with the CSO provisions.

CONCLUSION
The petition for a writ of certiorari should be denied.

Respectfully submitted.
PAUL D. CLEMENT
Solicitor General

SUE ELLEN WOOLDRIDGE
Assistant Attorney General

JOHN A. BRYSON
Attorney

NOVEMBER 2006

APPENDIX

November 15, 2006

MEMORANDUM

SUBJECT:

FROM:

TO:

Establishing TMDL “Daily” Loads in
Light of the Decision by the U.S. Court of
Appeals for the D.C. Circuit in Friends of
the Earth, Inc. v. EPA, et al., No.05-5015,
(April 25, 2006) and Implications for
NPDES Permits

Benjamin H. Grumbles,
Assistant Administrator

Director, Office of Ecosystem Protection,
Region 1

Director, Division of Environmental Plan-
ning and Protection, Region 2

Water Division Directors, Regions 3-7 and
Region 9

Director, Office of Ecosystems Protection
and Remediation, Region 8

Director, Office of Environmental
Cleanup, Region 10

The purpose of this memorandum is to clarify EPA’s
expectations concerning the appropriate time increment
used to express “total maximum daily loads” (TMDLs)
in light of the recent decision by the U. S. Court of
Appeals for the D.C. Circuit in Friends of the Earth,

(la)

2a

Inc. v. EPA, et al., No. 05-5015 (D.C. Cir. 2006). In
Friends of the Earth, the D.C. Circuit held that two
TMDLs for the Anacostia River (one established by
EPA and one approved by EPA) did not comply with the
Clean Water Act because they were not expressed as
“daily” loads.

The Friends of the Earth decision has raised some
questions regarding the establishment of both TMDLs
and effluent limits in National Pollutant Discharge
Elimination System (NPDES) permits that implement
wasteload allocations established in TMDLs. As
explained in more detail below, EPA recommends that
all future TMDLs and associated load allocations and
wasteload allocations be expressed in terms of daily time
increments. However, EPA does not believe that the
Friends of the Earth decision requires any changes to
EPA’s existing policy and guidance describing how a
TMDL’s wasteload allocations are implemented in
NPDES permits.

EPA’s Expectations Regarding “Daily” Loads in TMDLs

EPA continues to believe that the use of the word
“daily” in the term “total maximum daily load” is not an
unambiguous direction from Congress that TMDLs
must be stated in the form of a uniformly applicable 24-
hour load. However at this time, there is significant
legal uncertainty about whether courts across the
country will follow the reasoning of the D.C. Circuit
decision in Friends of the Earth or that of the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in their decision

3a

in NRDC v. Muszynski'. In light of that uncertainty,
EPA recommends that all TMDLs and associated load
allocations and wasteload allocations be expressed in
terms of daily time increments. In addition, TMDL
submissions may include alternative, non-daily pollutant
load expressions in order to facilitate implementation of
the applicable water quality standards. TMDLs must
continue to be established at a level necessary to attain
and maintain the applicable water quality standards,
account for seasonal variations and include a margin of
safety. Because water quality standards are expressed
in a variety of ways and because pollutants and water
bodies have different characteristics, EPA believes that
there is some flexibility in how the daily time increments
may be expressed. The following are a few examples of
this potential flexibility:

¢ If consistent with the applicable water quality
standard and technically suitable for the pollut-
ant and water body type in question, a TMDL and
associated load allocations and wasteload

' In NRDC v. Muszynski, 268 F.3d 91 (2nd Cir. 2001), NRDC
challenged EPA’s approval of nutrient TMDLs with annual loads
established by New York for reservoirs. The Second Circuit held that
“the term ‘total maximum daily load’ is susceptible to a broader range
of meanings” than loads calculated on a daily basis. 268 F.3d at 98-99.
The D. C. Circuit decision in Friends of the Earth is controlling legal
precedent for cases brought in the District of Columbia Circuit while
the Second Circuit decision in Muszynsk7 is controlling legal precedent
in cases brought in the Second Circuit, which includes the States of
New York, Connecticut, and Vermont. EPA encourages the three
States within the Second Circuit, to submit TMDLs with “daily” loads
in a manner consistent with this memorandum. EPA also recognizes
that, while the Second Circuit did not vacate the TMDLs in question
merely because they did not contain “daily” loads, it required a rea-
soned explanation for the choice of any particular “non-daily” load.

4a

allocations may be expressed as both minimum
and maximum daily loads, or as average daily
loads. For example, a TMDL for the pollutant
parameter pH may include both minimum and
maximum values consistent with how the applic-
able WQS for the parameter pH is expressed
(commonly as a range.)

If technically appropriate and consistent with the
applicable water quality standard, it may also be
appropriate for the TMDL and associated load
allocations and wasteload allocations to be
expressed in terms of differing maximum daily
values depending on the season of the year,
stream flow (e.g., wet v. dry weather conditions)
or other factors. In situations where pollutant
loads, water body flows, or other environmental
factors are highly dynamic, it may be appropriate
for TMDLs and associated allocations to be
expressed as functions of controlling factors such
as water body flow. For example, a load-duration
curve approach to expressing a TMDL and
associated allocations might be appropriate,
provided it clearly identifies the allowable daily
pollutant load for any given day as a function of
the flow occurring that day. Using the load-
duration curve approach also has the advantage
of addressing seasonal variations as required by
the statute and the regulations.

For TMDLs that are expressed as a concen-
tration of a pollutant, a possible approach would
be to use a table and/or graph to express the
TMDL as daily loads for a range of possible daily
stream flows. The in-stream water quality cri-

5a

terion multiplied by daily stream flow and the ap-
propriate conversion factor would translate the
applicable criterion into a daily target (TMDL).

EPA will issue additional technical guidance pro-
viding specific information regarding the establishment
of daily loads for specific pollutants that will take into
consideration the averaging period of the pollutant, the
type of water body, and the type of sources the TMDL
needs to address.

Facilitating Implementation of Wasteload Allocations
through the NPDES Permit Process

In certain circumstances (e.g., impairments caused
by storm water), or where the applicable water quality
criteria are expressed as a long-term average, it may be
appropriate for TMDL documents or their supporting
analysis to clearly set forth the implementation-related
assumptions underlying any wasteload allocation ex-
pressed as a “daily” load. To facilitate implementation
of such a load in water bodies where the applicable
water quality standard is expressed in non-daily-terms,
it may be appropriate for the TMDL documentation to
include, in addition to wasteload allocations expressed in
daily time increments, wasteload allocations expressed
as weekly, monthly, seasonal, annual, or other ap-
propriate time increments. When this approach is
taken, the TMDL and its supporting documentation
should clearly explain that the non-daily loads and
allocations are implementation-related assumptions of
the daily wasteload allocations and are included to
facilitate implementation of the daily allocations as
appropriate in NPDES permits and nonpoint source

6a

directed management measures. The supporting docu-
mentation should discuss the reasons for, and assump-
tions behind, the non-daily loads to facilitate their
understanding and use in the implementation phase.

Recommendations Concerning Existing TMDLs and
TMDLs in Process

Through significant effort of the States and EPA
regions, more than 20,000 TMDLs have been esta-
blished, most of them in the last five or six years. EPA’s
database also shows that approximately 65,000 causes of
impairment still need to be addressed by TMDLs. EPA
believes that continued development of TMDLs pur-
suant to State TMDL development schedules is the
highest priority at this time. If already existing TMDLs
need to be revised in the future, revision of the TMDLs
and allocations should be consistent with the recom-
mendations in this memorandum.

For TMDLs under development that have not yet
been adopted by States or established by EPA, EPA
recommends that such TMDLs and allocations be
revised, if feasible, to be consistent with this
memorandum prior to their adoption or establishment.
If States adopt and submit TMDLs expressed solely in
non-daily terms, EPA expects to ask the submitting
State to provide written documentation regarding how
the submitted TMDLs and allocations would be
expressed in daily terms. Such documentation provided
by States could then be included in the administrative
records supporting EPA’s decisions on the TMDLs. If
it is unable to obtain such documentation from a State,
EPA may develop calculations for its administrative

Ta

approval record demonstrating how the State’s TMDLs
and allocations would be expressed in daily terms. In
this case, EPA would make it clear that its approval of
the State’s TMDL is contingent on the assumption that
such TMDL contains the daily load calculations
developed by EPA.

We recommend that States consult with EPA regard-
ing specific TMDL projects early in the development
process to determine appropriate approaches to ex-
pressing the TMDLs and allocations. We are working to
provide technical support as soon as practicable. First,
we will be providing a draft of a technical document
outlining an approach for deriving daily limits for
bacteria, TSS, sediments and nutrients using the load
duration curve approach. In addition, we are preparing
a series of technical fact sheets and case studies based
on typical averaging periods of criteria, types of water
body and types of sources, to provide technical support
in developing daily loads for all pollutants. These should
be available for review and comment within the next few
months.

Implications of the Friends of the Earth Decision for
NPDES Permits

The Friends of the Earth decision does not affect an
NPDES permitting authority’s ability to use the
discretion available to it under the CWA and the
NPDES regulations in establishing permit effluent
limits and conditions.

There is no express or implied statutory requirement
that effluent limitations in NPDES permits necessarily

8a

be expressed in daily terms. The CWA definition of
“effluent limitation” is quite broad (“effluent limitation”
is “any restriction . . . on quantities, rates, and concen-
trations of chemical, physical, biological, and other
constituents which are discharged from point sources
...”). See CWA 502(11). Unlike the CWA’s definition of
TMDL, the CWA definition of “effluent limitation” does
not contain a “daily” temporal restriction. Indeed, the
central statutory requirement for water-quality based
effluent limits in NPDES permits is that they implement
applicable water quality standards. See CWA
301(b)(1)(C). Such water quality standards will include
water quality criteria for various pollutant parameters
that are expressed in terms of differing temporal
periods of duration, including hourly, daily, weekly,
monthly, seasonal, and annual, as appropriate for each
pollutant parameter.” Accordingly, effluent limits in
NPDES permits may be written in a form that derives
from, and complies with, applicable water quality
standards that use any of these various time measures.
See 122.44(d)(1)(vii)(A).

EPA’s regulations at 40 CFR § 122.44(d)(1)(vii)
require the permitting authority to ensure that: (a) the
level of water quality to be achieved by limits on point

* Section 2.lof EPA’s Technical Support Document for Water
Quality-based Toxics Control (TSD) dated March 1991, describes the
basis for establishing water quality criteria. EPA’s recommended water
quality criteria consist of three components: (1) magnitude, (2) duration,
and (3) frequency. Magnitude refers to the concentration of the
pollutant. Duration is the period of time (averaging period) over which
the in-water concentration is averaged for comparison with criteria
concentrations. This specification limits the length of time that in-water
concentrations may exceed the criteria concentrations. Frequency is
how often the criteria can be exceeded.

9a

sources is derived from, and complies with, all applicable
water quality standards; and (b) effluent limitations
developed to protect a narrative water quality criterion,
a numeric water quality criterion, or both, are consistent
with the assumptions and requirements of any
available wasteload allocation for the discharge
prepared by the State and approved by EPA pursuant
to 40 C.F.R. 130.7. This provision does not require that
effluent limits in NPDES permits be expressed in a
form that is identical to the form in which an available
wasteload allocation for the discharge is expressed in a
TMDL. ‘Rather, permit limits need only be “consistent
with the assumptions and requirements” of a TMDL’s
wasteload allocation.’ To facilitate implementation of the
TMDL, one of the stated “assumptions” of a TMDL’s
daily load or daily wasteload allocation might be that,
for purposes of NPDES implementation in an
appropriate context (e.g., storm water), the permit
writer has the flexibility to express the permit’s effluent
limitation using a time frame in keeping with, and
appropriate to, the water body and pollutant in question
and the applicable water quality standard. Indeed, the
TMDL submission might even include such alternate
temporal expressions of the total load or the wasteload
allocation as implementation assumptions.

The Friends of the Earth decision does not affect the
NPDES permitting authority’s ability to use all

* EPA’s position on this issue was affirmed by the Environmental
Appeals Board in Jn re: City of Moscow, Idaho, 10 E.A.D. 135, 148 (July
27, 2001) (“While the governing regulations require consistency, they
do not require that the permit limitations that will finally be adopted in
a final NPDES permit be identical to any of the WLAs that may be
provided in a TMDL.”)

10a

available tools to translate TMDLs and their wasteload
allocations into enforceable effluent limitations in dis-
charge permits. For example, while the NPDES per-
mitting regulations require “daily maximum” limits for
continuous discharges from some point sources, the
same regulations specifically authorize “average
weekly” and “average monthly” limitations—rather than
daily limitations—for discharges from publicly owned
water treatment plants. See 40 C.F.R. 122.45(d).
Moreover, the regulations further authorize the permit
writer to use other unspecified units of time if it is
impracticable to calculate daily, weekly or monthly
limitations. 7d. For non-continuous discharges, the
regulations provide flexibility as to the manner in which
such discharges are to be limited based on a con-
sideration of factors, including frequency, total mass,
maximum rate of discharge of pollutants and prohibition
or limitation of specified pollutants by mass, concen-
tration or other appropriate measure. See 40 C.F-.R.
122.45(e).

NPDES permit regulations do not require that
effluent limits in permits be expressed as maximum
daily limits or even as numeric limitations in all
circumstances, and such discretion exists regardless of
the time increment chosen to express the TMDL.
Therefore, expressing a TMDL as a daily load does not
interfere with a permit writer’s authority under the
regulations to translate that daily load into the appro-
priate permit limitation, which in turn could be ex-
pressed as an hourly, weekly, monthly or other measure.

EPA will continue to use existing guidance and policy
memoranda to guide the development of WQBELs that
are consistent with both 40 CFR § 122.44(d)(1)(vii) and

lla

40 CFR §122.45(d). These include: the Technical
Support Document for Water Quality-based Toxics
Control (TSD) dated March 1991, an EPA Memorandum
titled Establishing Total Maximum Daily Load
(TMDL) Wasteload Allocations (WLAs) for Storm
Water Sources and NPDES Permit Requirements
Based on Those WLAs dated Novermber 22, 2002, and a
memorandum titled Annual Permit Limits for Nitrogen
and Phosphorus for Permits Designed to Protect Chesa-
peake Bay and its tidal tributaries from Excess Nu-
trient Loading under the National Pollutant Discharge
Elimination System dated March 3, 2004.

n S its
EPA recommends that NPDES permitting author-
ities continue to establish effluent limits that implement
wasteload allocations established in approved TMDLs in
accordance with existing regulation, policy .nd guidance
as described above.

cc: Ephraim King
Steve Neugeboren
Suzanne Schwartz
James Hanlon

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386016_1222%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
