# Appendix — Gracia v. Trevino

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386013_1116%3A05

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1997
- **Citation:** 522 U.S. 865

## Text

20a

DWELLING LEASE

Account No.: # 15 No. of Bedrooms 2-Br.

Project/Site: Victoria Gardens

DESCRIPTION OF PARTIES & PREMISES: The
Housing Authority of the City of Brownsville, Texas:
(hereinafter called the Authority) does hereby lease
to Mr. Esequiel Gracia (hereinafter
called the Tenant) the premises located at 1817 Lin-
coln Street Brownsville, Texas 78520 for
the initial term starting April 1, 1985 and ending at
midnight on April 30, 1985 at a rental of $ 185.00
for such initial term, under the terms and conditions
stated herein. The premises leased are for the exclu-
sive use and occupancy of the Tenant and his house-
hold consisting of the following named individuals
who will reside in the dwelling unit:

Esequiel Gracia (Head)
Santos Gracia (Brother)

AMOUNT AND DUE DATE OF RENTAL PAY-
MENT: This lease shall be automatically renewed
(except as specified in Section I) for successive terms
of one month at a rental of $ 185.00 payable in
advance at the office of the Authority on the first .
calendar day of each month beginning May 1,
1985_: This rent will remain in effect unless
adjusted in accordance with Section 6 hereof.

SECURITY DEPOSIT: Tenant agrees to pay $
50.00 as a Security Deposit to be used by the
Authority at the Termination of this lease toward
reimbursement of the cost of cleaning and repairing
any damages beyond normal wear and tear to the

2la

dwelling unit caused by Tenant, his family depen-
dents, or guest and any rent or other charges owed
by Tenant. Any refund of Security Deposit due the
Tenant will be refunded within thirty (30) days after
the Tenant yields possession.

UTILITIES: The Authority agrees to furnish util-
ities as provided in the current Utility Allowances
posted in the Authority’s office except on projects
where tenants pay all or most of the utilities. Util-
ities used in excess of that authorized will be
charged to the Tenant at the actual cost to the PHA,
as posted in the Utility Allowances and will be pay-
able on the first day of the second month in which
the charges are accrued. The Authority will not be
responsible for failure to furnish utilities by reasons
of any cause beyond its control. Tenant agrees to
maintain sufficient heat to prevent freezing of piped
water. If for any reason, Tenant is unable to maintain
sufficient heat, he shall immediately notify the
Authority. Any damage to Tenants premises result-
ing from such failure to provide immediate notice
shall be deemed to have been caused by the Tenant
for the purpose of applying Section 10 of this lease.

EQUIPMENT: The Authority agrees to furnish a
range and a refrigerator in working order.

RE-DETERMINATION OF RENT, DWELLING SIZE
AND ELIGIBILITY: Once each year Tenant agrees
to furnish such information and certification regard-
ing family composition and income as requested by
the Authority for the purpose of determining Ten-
ant’s rent, eligibility, and appropriateness of dwell-
ing size. This determination will be made in
accordance with the Authority’s “Schedule of
Income Limits”, and “Statement of Policies Govern-
ing Admissions and Continued Occupancy of Low
Rent Public Housing” which are posted in the

22a

Authority’s office. Any rent charged as result of the
re-determination outlined above, will become effec-
tive on the established anniversary date. Failure by
tenant to provide truthful information on income or
family composition shall constitute a violation of
this Lease.

A. Rent as fixed in Section 2 hereof or as adjusted
pursuant to the above will remain in effect for
the period between regular rent re-determina-
tion unless during such period:

(1)

(2)

Family circumstances change as follow:

(a) Decline in income which would justify
a reduction in rent

(b) Change in family composition; or

(c) Such other circumstances as would
create a hardship situation.

It is found that Tenant has misrepresented
to the Authority facts upon which his rent
is based, so that the rent he is paying is less
than he should have been charged. If this is
found then the increase in rent will be
made retroactive.

In the event of any rent adjustment pur-
suant to the above, the Authority will mail
or deliver a “Notice of Rent Adjustment” to
Tenant in accordance with Section 13
hereof. In the case of rent decreases, the
adjustment will become effective the first
of the following month. In case of rent
increases, the adjustment will have effect
the first of the following month, unless the
rent increase results from finding of inten-
tional misrepresentations under 6A (2)
above.

23a

The Tenant agrees to pay adjusted rents
and back charges, if any, in accordance
with approved “Schedule of Rents and
Other Charges” and to accept a “Notice of
Rent Adjustment” delivered as prescribed
in Section 13.

B. If the Authority determines that size of the
dwelling unit is no longer appropriate, Tenant
will be notified in accordance with Section
hereof, to transfer to the appropriate size dwell-
ing unit when such unit is available.

C. The Authority shall not commence eviction pro-
ceedings, or refuse to renew a lease, based upon
the income of the tenant family unless it has
identified, for possible rental by the family, a unit
of decent, safe and sanitary housing of suitable
size available at a rent not exceeding the rent-
income ratio as defined by the Authority for the
purpose of determining rents, in accordance with
24 CFR 860, Subpart D, or 2) it is required to do
so by local law. Pending their removal from the
project such families are to be charged rents cal-
culated on the percentage of total family income
for rent purposes as defined by HUD Regula-
tions and the Housing Authority.

OCCUPANCY OF THE DWELLING UNIT AND
TENANTS OBLIGATIONS: Tenant agrees to sublet
or transfer possession of the premises; nor to give
accomodation [sic] to boarders or lodgers. Tenant
further agrees not to use permit the use [sic] of
dwelling unit for any purpose other than a private
dwelling unit solely for Tenant and the Tenant’s
household as identified in this lease. This provision
does not exclude accommodation of Tenant's guests
or visitors for fourteen (14) days with written con-
sent of the Authority and may include care of foster

24a

child and live-in care for a member of the Tenant's
family. Tenant agrees to abide by such necessary and
reasonable regulation as may be promigated [sic] by
the Authority for the benefit and well-being of the
housing project and the Tenants which shall be
posted in the Authority office and incorporated by
reference in this lease. Tenant further agrees:

(a) To comply with all obligations imposed upon
Tenants by applicable provisions of building
and housing codes materially affecting health
and safety;

(b) To keep the premises and such other areas as
may be assigned to him for his exclusive use in
a clean and safe condition;

(c) To dispose of all ashes, garbage, rubbish, and
other waste from the premises in a sanitary and
safe manner;

(d) To use only in reasonable manner all electrical,
plumbing, sanitary, heating, ventilating, air-con-
ditioning, and other facilities and appurte-
nances including elevators;

(e) To refrain from and to cause his household and
guests to refrain from destroying, defacing,
damaging, or removing any part of the premises
or project;

(f) To pay reasonable charges (other than for nor-
mal wear and tear) for the repair of damages to
the premises project buildings, facilities or com-
mon areas caused by the tenant, his household
or guests;

(g) To conduct himself and cause other persons
who are on the premises with his consent to
conduct themselves in a manner which will not

(h)

(i)

(j)

(k)

(1)

25a

disturb his neighbor’s peaceful enjoyment of
their accommodations and will be conductive to
maintaining the project in decent, safe and sani-
tary condition;

To refrain from illegal or other activity which
impairs the physical or social environment of
the project;

To leave the dwelling unit in a clean and good
condition upon vacating, reasonable wear and
tear excepted, and to return the [illegible];

Not to keep pets such as cats, dogs, animals,
etc., in the dwelling unit or on the premises;

Not to use firearms, BB guns, or pellet [illegible]
Authority property;

Tenant agrees to transfer to an appropriate
[illegible] and, based on family composition,
upon [illegible] by the Authority that such a
dwelling and is available;

(m) The tenant, member of the household and

(n)

(0)

(p)

guests shall not park their vehicles anywhere
else but the parking areas on the streets;

The Tenant shall not carry on any business
whatever not display signs of any type in or
about the premises;

The Tenant shall not use or keep inflammable
materials on the premises or in storage rooms
nor use any method of heating other than that
supplied by the Authority;

No nails, bolts, or screws shall be placed in the
walls, floors, doors or trim, and all electric wir-
ing shall be done or supervised by the Author-

ity;

26a

(q) The Authority in all cases shall retain the right

(r)

to control and prevent access into the building
and ground of all persons whom it considers
undesirable;

All personal property placed on the premises
shall be at the risk of the Tenant or owner of
such personal property and the Owner will not
be responsible for any damage to such personal
property from any cause.

AUTHORITY’S OBLIGATION ON MAINTENANCE
AND REPAIR:

A.

The Authority agrees to keep the building facili-
ties, common area and grounds, not otherwise
assigned to the Tenant for maintenance and
upkeep, in a clean and safe condition and to
make necessary repairs to the premises. The
Authority further agrees to:

(1) To comply with requirements of applicable
building codes, housing codes and HUD
regulations materials affecting health and
safety.

(2) To maintain in good and safe working
order and condition electrical plumbing,
Sanitary, heating, ventilating and other
facilities and appliances, including eleva-
tors, supplied or required to be supplied by
the PHA;

(3) To supply running water and reasonable
amounts of hot water and reasonable
amounts of heat at appropriate times of the
year (according to local custom and usage)
except where the building that includes the
dwelling unit is not required by law to be
equipped for that purpose, or where heat
or hot water is generated by an installation.

27a

within the exclusive control of the Tenant
and supplied by a direct utility connection;
and

(4) To maintain the premises and the project in
decent, safe and sanitary condition.

B. The Authority may authorize a Tenant by “Writ-
ten Rider” hereto specifying the task, in accor-
dance with Section 15 hereof, to perform
seasonal maintenance or other maintenance
tasks, as permitted by the nature of the design
and construction of the dwelling and according
to local custom, provided that such agreement is
made in good faith and not for the purpose of
evading the obligations of the Authority.

C. Maintenance and repair work (beyond normal
wear and tear) caused by the Tenant, his house-
hold or guests, will be charged to the Tenant.
Such charges shall be billed at a rate as specified
in the “Schedule of Charges for Maintenance
and Repair” as posted in the Authority’s office.
Payment for such charges are due and payable
on the first day of the second month following
the month in which the charge is made.

10. DEFECTS HAZARDOUS TO LIFE, HEALTH -
SAFETY: When conditions are created which are
hazardous to life, health, or safety of the occupants,
the Tenant shall immediately notify the Authority of
the damage. The Authority shall be responsible for
the repair of the unit within a reasonable time, pro-
vided, that if the damages were caused by the Ten-
ant, Tenant’s household or guests, the reasonable
cost of the repairs shall be charged to the Tenant,
payable on the first day of the second month follow-
ing the month in which the charges are made.

11.

28a

If repairs of the defects or damages cannot be made
within a reasonable time, the Authority shall offer
standard alternative accommodations, if available, in
the event the Authority fails to fulfill its respon-
sibility the Tenant's rent shall abate in proportion to
the seriousness of the damages and loss in value as a
dwelling except the cost of utilities furnished by the
Authority shall not abate. Rent shall not abate if the
Tenant rejects the alternative accommodations or if
the damages were caused by the Tenant, Tenant’s
household or guests.

INSPECTION: Before occupancy by the Tenant, the
Authority and the Tenant or his representative shall
inspect the dwelling unit and the Tenant will receive
a written statement of the condition of the unit and
the equipment furnished therein. Tenant agrees that
the authorized agent, employee or representative of
the Authority will be permitted to enter Tenant’s
dwelling unit for the purpose of performing routine
inspection, maintenance and for making improve-
ment and repairs, or to show the premises for re-
leasing. Such entry may be made only during rea-
sonable hours after a two day advance notice in
writing to the Tenant of the time, date and purpose,
provided however, the Authority shall have the right
to enter Tenant’s dwelling unit without prior notice
to Tenant if the Authority reasonably believes that
an emergency exists which requires such entry. The
Authority shall leave on the premises a written
statement specifying the date, time and purpose of
entry prior to leaving the premises whenever entry
is made when the Tenant and all adult members of
the household are absent. When the Tenant vacates,
the Authority will inspect the dwelling unit and give
the Tenant a written statement of the charges, if any
for which the Tenant is responsible. Tenant and or
his representative may join in such inspection.

29a

12. TERMINATION OF LEASE: This lease may be ter-
minated by the Authority at any time by giving a
written notice as set forth in Section 13, except that
such written notice may only be given for serious or
repeated violations of material terms of the lease
such as failure to make payments due under the
lease or to fulfill the Tenant’s obligations set forth in
Section 8 or for other good cause. If the Authority
should elect to terminate this lease, the written
notice of termination must be given:

(a) Fourteen (14) days in advance in the case of
failure to pay rent;

(b) A reasonable time depending on the seriousness
of the situation in the case of creation or mainte-
nance of a threat or safety of other Tenants or
Authority employees; and

(c) Thirty (30) days in all other cases.

The notice of termination of the Tenant shall state
reasons for termination and shall inform the Tenant
of his right to:

(a) Make such a reply as he may wish; and

(b) Request a hearing in accordance with the
Authority’s Grievance Procedure.

THE TENANT MAY TERMINATE THIS LEASE AT
ANY TIME BY GIVING FIFTEEN (15) DAYS WRIT-
TEN NOTICE IN THE MANNER SPECIFIED IN
SECTION 13 OR BY NOTIFYING THE AUTHORITY
IN PERSON AT THE OFFICE OF THE AUTHORITY.
IF THE TENANT DOES NOT GIVE THE AUTHOR-
ITY FIFTEEN (15) DAYS NOTICE, THE AUTHOR-
ITY MAY CHARGE THE TENANT FOR ANY
VACANCY LOSS. THE HOUSE KEYS MUST BE
ALSO PROMPTLY RETURNED TO AVOID ANY
ADDITIONAL RENTAL CHARGES.

13.

14.

15.

30a

Notice by either party to this lease may be given on
any day of the month.

LEGAL NOTICES: Any notice required hereunder
will be sufficient if delivered in writing to Tenant per-
sonally or to an adult member of his family resident in
the dwelling unit, or is sent by certified mail return
receipt requested properly addressed to ie. ant. Notice
to the Authority must be in writing, and either deliv-
ered to the office of the Housing Authority, or sent to
the Authority by prepaid first class mail.

GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE: All grievances or appeals
arising under this lease shall be processed and resolved
pursuant to the Grievance Procedure of the Authority,
which procedure is posted in the Authority’s office and
incorporated herein by reference.

CHANGES: This lease, including any future adjust-
ments of rent or dwelling unit, is the entire agree-
ment between the Authority and Tenant. No change
herein shall be made except by a Written Rider,
signed and dated by both parties, other than with
respect to the “Notice of Rent Adjustment” as pro-
vided in Section 6 hereof.

IN WITNESS HEREOF, the parties have executed

this lease Agreement this 1st day of
April 1985 at Brownsville, Texas
(State)

HOUSING AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF BROWNS-
VILLE, TEXAS

V /s/ Esequiel Gracia

(Tenant)
By: /s/ Frances ReMeza

Authorized
Representative

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386013_1116%3A05. Public record. Not legal advice.
