# Transcript of Record — United States v. Idaho

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386010_0022%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1936
- **Citation:** 298 U.S. 105

## Text

ee

nes, eee

VOL. H

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

OCTOBER ‘TERM, 1935

No. 420

THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, THE INTERSTATE

COMMERCE COMMISSION, AND THE OREGON SHORT
LINE RAILROAD COMPANY, APPELLANTS
| vs. :
THE STATE OF IDAHO, AND J. D. RIGNEY, ET AL., CON-
STITUTING AND AS THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COM-
MISSION OF THE STATE OF IDAHO

APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR
THE DISTRICT OF UTAH

FILED SEPTEMBER 4, 1935

2
?

af

ERR INENRE TSA I RMR EA sar RR UNNI te

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OcToBER TERM, 1935

No. 420

THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, THE INTERSTATE
COMMERCE COMMISSION, AND THE OREGON SHORT-
LINE RAILROAD COMPANY, APPELLANTS

vs.

THE STATE OF IDAHO, AND J. D. RIGNEY, ET AL., CON-
STITUTING AND AS THE PUBLIC UFILITIES COM-
MISSION OF THE STATE OF IDAHO

,

APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT ‘OF THE UNITED STATES FOR
“THE DISTRICT OF UTAH

INDEX ,
Original Print
Record from D. C. U. S., District of Utah_........-.....-.---- 376 =. 237
Plaintiffs’ exhibit B—Exhibits filed at hearing before I. C. C.,
Finance Docket No. 90196_.--_......-.-.-----2..-.---- 376 . 237
Complainant’s exhibit 1—Contract between Director
F ' General of Railroads and Idaho Coal Mines Co., Sept.
GQ, Foe wuwansutccncsaccnsgucheenétsessnsacsunaen 377 = 237
Bee Br-GRD, dh deccsccactsnvenasanats Facing 388 242
Contract between Oregon Short Line R. R. Co. .and
Idaho Coal Mines Co., March 17, 1920__._.____- 389 - 243
SG PR, .ntactdanupsnenndaanaane Facing 395 246

Complainant’s exhibits 3 to 7, ine. —Statements showing
cost of work performed and maintenance—Talbot

Ps caccucacsagensasnnseunensenaeankaaeal 396 247
Complainant’s exhibit 8—Statement showing investment
in road and. equipment, ‘leased lines, etc_-_- ~------- 401 249
Complainant’s exhibits 9 and 10—Statements showing
. operating revenues and —- railway tax accruals,
Taacicapadssctecscsdassbasisnsndenaadiahaskans 402 250
Complainant’s exhibits 11 and 12—Statements of revenue ;
freight, showing cars and tons, etc................_.- 404 252

a

" INDEX

Record from D. C. U.8., District Utah—Continued. - ;
Plaintiffs’ exhibit B, ete.—Confinued. Original Print
Complainant’s exhibits 13 and 14—Statements showing ~
carload shipments. of coal originating at Talbot, Idaho,
BB ooo cnn ccsocecccnncooneseoooodocessoso== ee 406 254
Complainant’s exhibit 15—Statement of carload ship-
ments (other than coal) from and ta points on Talbot
Branch. ......-----------2--- we \
= bl ys : “sg, K,
S 4 see jaan we
1°23 N44 YOM g6O*t) HS 1 Hie ML
ear a ol
o . , . 5
a S s ; P + Bie
: £3 a6m i
Lon 4k ong td fail oe oe
Mele
elie i
oor bale id ADS '
mon a.

$7082 fans

” ; Kt {a auf
ee > rite | om 44h

} YWOHOIO™ E5046 OFS BSt- addi,

HAL UIOm ag 666°9) 191-7 2.1160! De e649 -———

na atgt} hehe,
1 THOR 74 40608 | ee

ee RRA ER

DROSS ig PydOeH ING 3d 7HO8C= : oie

x
‘
ned
bax4 2°"
! t
~~ tae
georres 36 OF
vw 40 0 ‘
‘
wy 40 99
* o
or.
7°?
‘ ve
: ett’. BARE ie 5 “A :
—— Wate a ,
t 350 8335; alow \* -w 3
. ’ 4) Fs
3
ean ’ E
be:
—* %:
ie
.

-

fay ‘’ -

At
' § \
“
. “
os
ann
SesBe. -+-
‘ ~az |
Wf --- ERS
Sw @ wes Sak aeeth js m
—-. 4
A i!
A )
' "
SY) 4 Bursting 0040-5 We tLieg |’
ie
m
J
* 3 0
\ ga’ poe, OT
VaqQre!
A 3 4et. 9acs0s 106 caret
ane = pert
= ors ore 9 ve
Sas Teh
5409 ’
\
4
‘\
‘
\
js \
x
- \ :
p \
\
\

* » Bete. offi oom

44, VOW Yq 066°P! 191-7 Li.0! 2
1 Seeger Paar et Baga rS) ah a =
~} Lia aseerneys 8.45 +104 tober) 2d b86FM ane te
ted Dd USL08 1,El- PEN AL 7. > ap

{
Van AALS ig b00+0*L EN MAL LOW 7S

‘ — wi

: t “73S —* a ‘ 44) hs Wendl ~S } > pga
j ta WS. S Fe aM eg bRIS yt. 406 1$8e§
e —toey eh ‘\t ” e | : 4
F be “wh \ j
3

-+ 3d “fey

-

| : 3! - 2. -
a ed sos BRN.
is ee 4 ? a
aS 6 ' OOS gn
¢ or Bledé aes { ' : \ See. eset
aw] ~ocnt. 3. he ee B55
Laat #§ ? WE > * oe cows Rand.
1g TTT 4068 1g: 04 OF ves i i
t a rt Si |
$35: 253 Erp: e ‘
pe: | pts eR = = r o-
ee} YOHHO207 gSO+b PFS YSt-aiddi, ores 350006 Tad 2a (9016 Ey : ' ,
9
#909

Nn” sa vy"
neg gure”, ,3c8
ie ‘ ‘
nas 4.0 200°"
y* vibe)
i ‘
, i)
, wsieithe x
A)? Oe $ : ? .
° gars \ - ; wet
n ured | sbowd , ue @
40152 pees aw Oy \ my \ we yon, 27" ;
,, wow 6” ai ! Or al yrs :
’ ¢ ? tig qret
. 4 ® 75
be? A _1 é gag 885 o>
7 A oe at dor ve
‘ ytee vit
. 2 5 989"
t
\
- \
L .
\
1
\ .
- °
’ \
F \
\
. \
. Broo
‘ Y \ ;
\ i.
\
\
is vom, “4 - - “e
Py eats ce aE "
4 “ . _ _ .

«aad
he th oY he

= i
“= @
‘ 4 e ¢
s* 2
ay

YA
sf
»”
Hay ur * ¥
| Ee! Senne
116 sSOPH HS B4S +104 r0brr, 2d Ob6m Raa
5 To 4d Dd (SL08 1 Ble REN 441 T> LE OND
, '
Gals sa gone
c {
Fan +, 8S ig 60000%L OM MALL OW;
i+ fy |
SOs ) ey
1238 "41 WOM Abo LY HS) BH
a : “4g 73 fetus” ig Otis lg *. 40¢ t$8e§ Uu
waa Ne 7, |
e ’ 6 ;
— 8 : Len 44 gored Med ids

~
.
.
z
co
4
”
c
*
>
°
a
~-
w
=
-_*
-
4

i
i
é
:

Fo Read Nena Br 6 Sin Nia sete

149990 Pc [41903 POT? SPR Sig mssgSO RT Lo
se wr /
RC 10°17 C L+t6'L seg PL. tain Trh.

RC. OTL CL Tre NOS ore L 8075) PC Treo?

er.

$! ROT Tre. WEL O+008 Pt Sm Tre NTA

a@
aie

EXHIBIT "8°
OREGON maton pink HATLRoat

: CONSTR OCTION
TETONER TO TITON Coan. BERD ase

PROPOSED LAYOUT OF TRACKAGE AT COAL MINE

~™ Ate emo" “Gun a” .
Gomer One wears OFF ce Oe.t Lane arr view
CCvBES svauet ce 8:0

Drews te) OL Teste A 11 @ weeds fi
¥ LEGEND
OSRLRR Trecks
Coal Company's Tracks
APES 86 RE
Fal GS Sree

erie.

Rae gs

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 247
-396 Enhabit 3
Docket No. 9096

Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin. Ex-
hibit No. 3. Witness Brown. Complainant’sy, Defendant’s Com-
mission’s. Date 5-6-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, Reporter.

Cost of work performed during September, October, and November 1924 at

various locations MP 0.0 to MP 9.0 in connection with rehabilitation. of
Talbot Branch

ce ALLEL IOLA ES T9208. 7% |.....--.-- $268. 74
ac picisss edeeteccssaeenamecemeumenens J-=-| 3, 507. 54 | $231.60 | 3, 739.14

Resheve emobomizment ... .........-. 22... 2222s .cccec nee ncn-seo-oee-- Y ae 2, 837.34 265.19 | 3, 102. 53
Ne: RS SSL IDS LOENESEPRO NEDA EIS N80 164.12 | | ' 164.12

0 A Ea LOL eM Er ee Ta 6,613.62 | 660.91 | 7,274.53

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company, Engineering re

397 Exhibit 4
Docket No. 9096
, __ Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket . No. oa » Fin. Ex-
hibit No. 4. Witness Brown. Complainant’sy, Dv’» dant’s, Com-

mission’s. Date 5-16-32. F rank Otterstrom, repo. -r.

Cost work performed in connection with construction of: wye tracks at end
of Talbot Branch during 1924 &@ 1925

Remissstins GttRRncccnngeneesssccadienceseescescnssencssnes ----- $353.81
16-span bridge oyer Horseshoe ee 8, 456. 30
13-epan bridge over Horseshoe Creek._.............--...--........ 7,072.83
Cost of cross tiles, switch ties and bridge ties.........-- escticeianindeasibitaat 1,116. 87
Value of 2,406 1. f. SH 90-ARA Rail___................_-._.._..._ 739. 95
Frogs, ‘switches, tie plates, and small fittings (includes inside guard
TF 1, 041.11
Labor handiing track material and installing trackage-...____..---- 5, 252. 06
SE sa esctinncinnnshenetieitns diccinindaitiitelinsiliindiniatininnhdeaitheisdiggieanspinsiiininadmenmaties 22, 082. 93
a Short Line Railroad Company, a it Department.
398 | Exhibit 5 s
Docket No. 9096

; - Interstate Commerce .Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin. Ex-
hibit No. 5. Witness Br®wn. Complainant’sy, Defendant’s, Com-
mission’s. Date 5-16-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, reporter.

Statement showing estimated cost of maintaining Talbot ~ae during year |

1932

New Cross Ties, 800 pieces__.__..._______- a acs did _ $1, 048
SH Cross Ties, 350 pieces._........_..___-_-- Ricsinuigsinstaiaimiaiaintetenipiensiiens 173
A TE eT 69
Reclaimed Track Spikes, 1,800 pounds____ — 33
Various Culvert Renewals and Repairs. , : 300

403

610

7

248% _ UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

Statement of estimated cost ‘maintaining Talbot Branch—Continued
as oe ninaenpeaennanieann jac “See
Work Trains, etc., Plowing Snow-__.--. poe eeaeneneaanananinineasenanisen meamreisecnahcna 300
Material Store Expenses bnadnnianionin cepeintnaseiveimnenchehdhtamdnenensneianeiancicasensen emesis 57
Tool Charges\_- —_— — en 36
Contingencies. sniceinsn engin noe elie if 324-

’ Total, Labor, $1,630; Material, $1,969__......._..---...--------- 8, 569

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company, Engineering Department.
390 +. 5 Ewhibit 6
Docket No. 9096

Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin. Exhibit
No. 6. Witness Brown. Complainant’s y, Defendant’s, Commis-
sion’s. Date 5-16-82. Frank W. Otterstrom, reporter.

Statement showing estimated cost of maintaining Talbot Branch during year
1933

New Cross Ties, ‘1,500 De Ee es
i. «. . a PEON EI ASS JUOCUIISOAT] JO JUGDIOg “ZI
60 ‘SEF ‘E96 ‘8 £F 061 ‘219 ‘FF ZO ‘OTF ‘666 ‘8 ZL "809 ‘O0T ‘6 &b 'bI6 ‘E96 ‘8 9€ 006 ‘606 ‘8 06 ‘99% “E98 ‘8 ips pita aaa ie eign qv UOjeOdsuBlT, =.
: ; Jopun pens00e SABY P[NoYys yoy sZuyusIe| *[]
Ze > Ze SIZ 88°E €9°9 e¢°¢ : i y Saar (ecigigs Stes Gt JUGUISAAT] JO JUGIIEg ‘OT
$9 ‘OTS “FEL ‘9 89 ‘289 ‘229 ‘ee 40 920 ‘20F ‘€ 92 “199 ‘SPT ‘9 EI 8Sz ‘S09 ‘8 86 "2ZE ‘b29 ‘8 Bod... iebeaeneetegen. emlooUT Zurjyeledo ABITIBI JON °6
Z8 ‘FPL ‘S69 ‘8z 60 “PZL ‘SLE ‘EFT £2 ‘789 ‘OS0 ‘bz GZ “FOP ‘P81 ‘8Z =|: $9 “BLE ‘ZEST ‘TE 69 ‘129 “S6F-'08 SF ‘I¥9 ‘608 ‘6z Roe isthe any ean ¢ S}}Gep—eouro0ou] Zulyesedg “g
98 19% ‘Ot ‘oe ‘QOE*IST“ZLT =| 22 802 ‘89% ‘2Z 09 "996 ‘ZeE ‘ve L9 ‘GEE ‘8E8 ‘68 LE “WS ‘690 ‘6¢ od 8. Sa eeeeeeanatee 1 8}{pe1o—ouml00U] BuyyBIEdO *Z
92 648 ‘S88 ‘col - "868 ‘6ZP ‘BLL 9 “SLZF ‘TIS ‘9ST 66 ‘OIL ‘692 ‘8ST 10 ‘IS% ‘OZ ‘SST LL ‘88L "¥S6 ‘PST OF ereee eat. 1° ee WO?}841OGSUBI} JO BOJAIOS OY}
: : é pesn pus 1oj prey Ayredod jo enyea 978 v9
OT ‘810 ‘68 08 ‘060 ‘Sz ‘F $6 “819 ‘258 96 ‘STS ‘248 96 “BIS ‘L¥8 96 ‘STS ‘248 J: SR aaa aba ite as eet: 0D Avamey ogoeg
ite UIOY}ION OY} 0} peses] seul] JO eNTBA—sseT “¢
26 "168 “FEL ‘OST =| 2968 bL9‘eRL | T9266 ‘RCE ‘ZCI | FE'SEz ‘LIT ‘BST | 96°6QL ‘299901 | ZZ ‘208 ee (eee ee ene 1830.1, “F
98 “298 ‘OTS ‘E Ze 6e FSS ‘ZT §~=—s|.—«HO. 69 ‘OEE ‘E PF ‘LPS ‘229 ‘E” 88 610 ‘029 ‘Ee 62 'OT9 ‘ves ‘e 89 ‘916 ‘008 ‘g 77777"*" "-serddns pu [e]1038ur Jo onjea—snid “g
62 "POL ‘8F6 ‘8 Lb TSS ‘ShL ‘bh | | OE BLL ‘EBL‘Z™.. | 09 829 ‘bz ‘6 99 "902 ‘Zz ‘6 10 ‘BLE ‘222 ‘6 ok.) > BR ebeneeeats pezesedo seul] pesee] jo onfeA—snjg *Z
LL 99% ‘S12 ‘HHIS | EB SBE ‘OLE ‘TeLs | Ie 08S ‘Sez ‘ObIS| 10 OLE ‘OZZ ‘OPIS | ZH ‘ERS ‘SoZ ‘EMIS | ZF GIF ‘S90 ‘EFI$ | 29 “CZF ‘9OT oc a! fae tt jueurdinbe pus pvol Uy yUeMysSeAu] “|
Bsvl0A Vy 18701, TS61 0861 “6261 8261 2261
apnea 7 193]
poled I8eX-¢ 381g Jequiedeq, pepue vox

0} 186 I ‘1G 4aquavagq papua suvafi ip
pup sasuadzea ‘sburusva ssos6 ‘sarddne"puv porsayow

-ureldurog

puayoo ay) 40f hupdwog pvospwy aur

IS61-L86I ‘porsed svah-¢ iof abvsaav pun yvj0} ‘aarsnpous ‘TE6]

T 1404S) U0ba1g ay} fo *9}a ‘amoour Burzosado fivmrps yau ‘sarv}
‘saul pasva) ‘yuamdinba pup phoy ut yuawmjsaauy—fuvdwo) pvospoy aurvy qoyg uobai—¢

, ‘IaOday “W01}s10}IO “AA YUBIY “FE-9I-¢ eq s,uoIsstuUIOD ‘squepueseq ‘As,quB

‘Wyoorddiy AA “Y SSOUTAA “8 ON FQIYXY “UL 9606 ‘ON JH0q ‘uorssrurUIOD VIIUWIOD 0} B4S19}UT

3 8 ON 0490 “9 ‘OI ise
8 QUA

tov

“ger ‘oe Tadv ‘GIN ‘4310 OAVT 118s “COWO 8,107} Pn V

€8°FIT ‘89 10°S89 ‘#9. | 89 $80 ‘6h 19 ‘E98 ‘Ee LE “S89"8Z ug “986 ‘el GL ‘691 ‘OT cma rr EO LE RES WOyeP peysqnumooy (LT)
7 28 ‘62P ‘E er 009 ‘10 “1€Z ‘ST 7 a) 08 "969 ‘8 28 ‘818 ‘E 6F 696 ‘S ee Se alltel (a1Qep) euooUy Buj;e1ed0 AGATE ION (91) .
ee rreunia: Sactcmeaas weimcrmuaa UP, Seemeeennnnnnt nr cr asecaad|scaseduagancos|nossecessescepns connsnenevooweceeererer Sect "S) iain: Ei a7
f 49 6II $6 “201 ge 020 ‘T 96 "$29 ‘I 8S "68 09 79% GE 68E £9 “889 ‘T PEATE ROL RAIN wqsp you—syuer yueuIdIND (41
Betas desacecalsvauesdastegua|ennasees seseee asses eee SSeS My nen res ata i gal ee ee ne SEAS Speiumereeaesncl gare Senusael ABATE O[G1}90[[00T /) £1)
° :
fr 20 se OIE t 8b 6b ‘S ZL ‘O12 ‘FI 61 ‘ese 2 '66L‘L zegss‘e == |: 61 09'S £9 169 ‘8 rae oe (s1qep) euoouy Suyeredo ABM T}CY 1).
q - 99-989 sen lower lesumey [truer [eevect jecwet [wr U ITI genes aed sores [BIOL (11)
OL “828 ‘I 88 7% ‘b 2 600 ‘ST 12 99% % 1g ‘cer'9 + | OF 697% 06 ‘092 ‘6 £9 ‘169 ‘8 eee sonueadel JA0 sesuedx A (OT)
9h 616 ‘I orn lwomer lee, [eras | ecsooe =| ev ze. $= | ugeeng sesuedxe Buyyes0d0 [P01 (6)
“gy SOFT 99 "62 Gi “S21 9T “E9T GZ “BLT LS ‘89 92 “LL w% CL REAR TRAIAN RAINE AS TF yereuep) (8)
Ei 96 StI 9 BLT 60 ‘OFL 0 ShL O€ “LLI ‘T £6 Z8F 61 ‘OeL SERS. eeteseheeaereaairmcee our] TVY—uopeyodsuBlL (Z) -

4
=
u
e3)
m
&
B
oqupy ‘eya070,1,
981 1S 009 AD scab amabesisens: oyspy ‘At
niches 08 ‘ZIT og T ceidaasbaaa oa Raqtaes ‘
i aaa Mactan SONI Cg
POE Ge Unie ROMER EmanERsETierse.. ouBp] aeine:
OFZ 98 Z6I WS wrngesecacse. Jiplghisicaie rae od

956 UNIFED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET Aly

408 Exhibit 14

sé. G. Docket No. 14

‘Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin., Exhibit
No. 14. Witness R. Whipprecht. Complainant’sy, Defendant’s, Com- »
mission’s. Date 5-16-32, Frank W. Otterstrom, Reporter.

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company.—Statement showing carload shipments of

coal originating at Talbot, Idaho, showing tons and O. SB. L., R. R. Co. revenue
by destination points for the period January 1, 1932, to March 31, 1932,

inclusive Q :

O. 8. L.

Destination Points . Tons | R. R. Co.

Revenue
Tee Ee ry ae 54.00
Pyke Siding --...---------------- Kc nandisicicdeciannnnehidsnasrhrsasniat Senet ee eens 161 209. 61
Be REE cnnnatpevndnstsseenennteneesseeteen en DinteneeaeeDeeEnTennOS OOS SS* 90 117.
) quscacdetnsatasssssasesesssssassesasesnasseeeesesaons 163 81.35
Bi BAIT « cnsinnetbapancacannnsaiasnecnnesnsetesinsssnitetntssse=aePeeseeereenneseee 35 48. 99
in sini kk aaah ARAAAAMATEEEEEA ALAA DSARAEAEOEEEB ELLOS ESS) 379 511.8

1 Note—From Dygert. _ : ;
Auditor’s Office, Salt Lake City, Utah, May 12, 1932.

3s

409

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

* Ewhibit 16

Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096. Fin. Exhibit
No. 15. Witness R. Whipprecht. Complainant’sy, Defeffdant’s, Com-
mission’s. Date 5-16-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, Reporter.

Oregon Short Line Railroad Co.—Statement of Carload Shipments (Other than
‘ Coal) from and to Points on the Talbot Branch Showing Date of Shipment,
Point of Origin and Destination, Consignor or Consignee, Commodity, Tons.
and Oregon Short Line R. R. Co. Revenue Segregated by Years as to For-
warded from and Received on the Branch, for the
December 31, 1931, Inclusive

257

Period July 15, 1924, to

Point of CO. 8.2

*Daneet os , R..R.

: Consigner or Con- *| Commodity | Tons} Co.
shipment , 3 Seer signee Reve-

Origin Destination & bd

; nue

®
FORWARD-

ED FROM
eee Pi acsainadnapatutcnnsssntnadceanckcbossvseeue ndekedauace f" A Er
775 | Accrued depreciation—
asa 132, 166. 88 112, 943. 30 94, 455. 77 79, 581. 42 65, 195. 75
776 ecrued depreciation— 2°
Equipment. ------------ 14, 762, 623. 64| 14, 161, 240. 65 13, 643, 939. 08} 13, 043, 316 37| 12, 927, 593. 10
717 | A de ion—
Miscellaneous physical :
778 Other unadjusted credits. 1, 876, 536. 13 "7; 602, 640. 33| 1, 598, 195. 48 "15967; 670. -68| 2, 103, 200. 56
Total unadjusted :
TT 18, 740, 109. 64| 18, 437, 926.75) 18, 493, 054. 65| 17, 410, 419. 48) 17, 317, 354. 48
CORPORATE SURPLUS
779 Additions to property
through income" and
Sa ar 6, 528, 205. 28 6, 529, 626. 08 6, 525, 031. 23) 6, 509, 639. 53 6, 508, 155. 68
F debt retired
through income and
CE costianatcanancnns 536, 828. 66 536, 828. 66 538, 828. 66 536, 828. 66 536, 828. 66
781 | Si fund reserves. ...-|--~-.---------]-----2--------]---------2-- == fo-ne sen nnnnnnnfonwnnnnnnonen
782 — fund
783 Approp EAs) ee A SAN BT mapa: pupTeepeet
cally invested._.-.| 14, 294, 901. 08| 14, 294, 901.08) 14, 294, 901. 08} 14, 204, 901. 08 14, 294, 901. 08
Total appropriated | -
. us......___---| 21,359, 935. 02) 21, 361, 355. 82 21, 356, 760. 97| 21, 341, 369.27 21, 339, 885. 42
784 | Profit and loss, credit bal- ;
ee err 60, 687, 689. 62, 094, 187. 59, 984, 544. 38) 52, 117, 157. 64 48, 673, 847. 30
Total corporate ; eS: ‘
i oe a eel 82, 047, 624. 72) 83, 455, 543. 52) 81, 341, 305. 35| 73, 458, 526. 91 70; 013, 732.72
Grand total-_....-- 286, 786, 450. 38|287, 281, 775, 33|292, 271, 104. 84/315, 222, 057. 86/312, 355, 495. 77

LOL EL PT TE EE RY PBS ha: > RI It re een

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS

TH TLB PIS ZI | ST 'SEO ‘TL “HT | COROT ‘ShL ‘HT | 68 °LZ0'OLE TT | FI E89 '09G'R [o-oo yoswehjosvenensaveeny eur uy s8011) €
20 ‘O9T ‘oE9 ‘*b Ly 189 ‘e886 | 6F'6K0 ‘zh =| OC ELT ‘COR’. | IE FIT ‘269 oO ae aah iil at aah ln dah ch euloou] Zulyeedou0N [810], a
89 982 T 16 ‘292 retaereonseusses 00°¢ OES Pireenn rece veresssseesnenctesv}icerseevenenseewsnsvensuavesqun euroouy snoeueyjeosiyy | 619 &
TAUNTED CO SRMEethED deipbtgaenemeos SEAS tod, CE geReN DEES Rear a Kee SeTUBdUI0D 10430 UOJ} SMOTINGIIIUOD | 8I9 “a
Sateen ot RATT RS eee Uaeeariaanbes Day vite citnat: woe TTT EET Tees" """"""""409H papuny UO suINyuTeId Jo esealey | LIF Ld
ada "> RB: SMart COONAN ENaC Gants, Seem cimeriedat: aes maces. SPUN} GAIESOI 19430 PUB ZUTHUIS WIOIJ OUODUT | OIG
SF C02 ‘Ty OT "29 ‘Le 6F ‘208 ‘92 89°892 ‘es pL '18h 61 ee eee a eer errr th ee 8}UN0908 PUB S9}}]}INDes pepuNjuN w10Ij euTOoUT | GIS H
¥6 “WP ‘Zzz ‘T ees Sewers POPC ee, [PSUR Tee foo 8" ss hesersesseseessdecewesheccesesisnssseetueeves 89}}]INIes pepuny w10Ij euTEDUT | $19 {
00 “60 ‘TIL ‘% Ol “SZ ‘190'S §=—| QO'208 ‘STE .| 00 'OPS ‘099% | OOGOL ‘SER T |--= 7 Tnnrrnrrttrrrrtteenn enter nen en ee nnn e nese nes “"--guroouy puepyatq | £19 3
96 “S82 6 88 ‘TST ‘6 ee a eee a _ dasa Sesabom Ag ie eegesiiis ee Yo1g—so} edoid peyeiedo ater eg | ZI
¥8 89 9° 08 ‘S£0 ‘6 9€ ‘IE ‘9 aI ‘998% erage neta stent tntele as trigbity Gaiden Ayiodoid [wojshyd Zuyyesedouou snoouspjoosi | 11S t
OF 'B¥z ‘FF 20 ‘Z6E ‘08 $F ‘816 ‘89 66 ‘ETT ‘29 29 "109 ‘ez tt” SAR ead expences ode) ‘ates phlei vies @uL09U} yueI snoguBT[eOsI | O19 =
rT 6Iz ‘so BL “SOL ‘9 Th 892 ‘29 22 969 ‘29 ZS 699 ‘29 "re Reet atta aa EN (ERRNO e ee PBor JO see] WI0Ij EMT | 609
£6°89L ‘eZ, | 68 GOL ‘OFT 8 600 ‘OST ZE 26S ‘SbI PI ‘916 ‘Zor Tinea aka ant ania ie AORN ROh ecracAN Shape eUIOsUy yUed A4I[108} UTOL | BOE
WO '8t9 ‘9 12 962 ‘9 99 ‘219 ‘b ¥8 692 ‘9 Dy SSD Regie maeateeepeiatcideeetsbil bere ur bnighisbtnaieh to ddehese ras bhd: queuldjnbe x10m uI0Ij JUeY | 209
ee ee ee itor Gh Laan iinet tats mmm: ij. j= .. &) |
92 ‘L¥0 ‘961 - | 00 ‘98> ‘69T £E “609 ‘T0Z OL '8E9 ‘S9T 98-“98T ‘SFI Pecan artes soe aes Nee Bites Ree sehen lise S180 U}81}-103T' ur0yj 4Uex | GOS
£8 “ILL ‘0 $8 'SLb ‘ZZ £9 "229 ‘61 _» 3 AU 00 "829 ‘ITT 00 ‘Zoe ‘EIT 00 "Zoe ‘se GTS WH. — POPP ete mrrowencccoceecnccccccesccccccccscecccccestbeccccccoccccess 3804 SUpINP $7}QEP [BOL

00 (908 ‘OT 00 012 ‘9 00 ‘089 ‘te 00 £22 ‘I COWBD — [rrmesrereeceneencreeecennncrecenenceecncescercccseresconsccencscescscnsnednn MjQep sNoeAwILOs} Wi
PCa Ue kee rie Bae Ree SRS wen eRnenE RRR WinebeeeeenaseeneeameeeneRnCeRERtEnRnnnERnt? ME ||| me
00 FIL ‘69 00 “£22 ‘O01 WO OF ‘tr 00 “s¥9 ‘ee 00 6tz.'21 a RR CTA POEM TIE ER juemd|Abe pus peor perzyei uo s807[
_ Btenetantenceceslenecesneanseeeee| snnanceneaeecene|aneassnasseccrec|anscnnnnenecenee|seeeseerecetecaseaarecensesnneereerarssnescecseeeeeecete “Sntdins Jo Su0} WIdOIdds snoeaEl|oIs} WL
ELLIE EIDE EE! PEE CE LA IAEA S AEE. eocssececsececcooaperrarcesevececccerserore=ap¢=etpiaas imma aetna eas
0O"1e Ts 00 969 + 00 ‘t6e ‘ST 00 "Ve “I OO VOID rrrn nnn neeh ence n en nen enone een eceenenee Aqedoad [eoj84.gd a }700UI3804 UT Jo} per dv snidang
CaN: GE SOO Bae hel) TREORRREER RORREEEE -eeseeeeeNaheteEeaREneaeeatE bare. snidins jo saoy} de pueplaicd
ay I Wd) WLIO WRI TO DS OER RE RN AmeONNeNe
NYT SOS) EMEC APRESS BL AOReeeD and! “ee pee SCS” RRR aa a ata aa atin ir aerate agrees @WIOOU] WO PallejsuBs) GOUBTeg 4149CT
00 "668 ‘c99 % GOEL TEES | CO'UL USL § | CORIO ISDS § | CO TER UEST [~~ ~~“ “oomonenen nn nennnnnenennernnnororeronerncsensenenoresenses 1¥04 Supp S}Pesd [%70.L

00 "woot 00298 ‘t 00 'sa0 688"E | 00'LEy + MIRE a. penance epemcnncsDea pT ma RTS GARR NELURE ARRAN URIS DSLR EL. Spas SNOEUET[I0ST
0O'1ze ‘Tr 00 ‘969 ‘+ 00 '26E ‘ST 00 ‘Wet ‘I ——; HRI sapcep eas ages aacagetssnceeca NAC ans “paes aad ta ld NNN RSP suo} BAO]
00 ver ‘Z 0O'lIZ ‘> 00 "600 ‘f 00 'SIh 9 GPU. — PROAMF OC Ct rereoowoocccconescencecccccecswcccspsocesooscosaqecacssosso sam a8284920A0 o[qeUpunjalu yy
Seececesorcecccelocccevccscocces GOT GRR [Ott t tee eteee ti eses esses scores tfoceccceccccccccccccccescocccccoccccccrencccoccosccososetccsosscvesoccors® 9) eumlood} persed
ou: 00 ‘Oey 00 oF 00 's8 MES are nce PARRA? LIAO RRS IERTI SETAE IEEE plos yueudmbe paw peos Go 101d
COU BVT «=| COOMBES | CO MOTELS | OO'ZOO'OOPE § | COERL*LED'T [oon nn nnn nm neem nnn nnn nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnennnnnn ns @ULOOU] MOI} PALIE;SUBI} GOULTEQ 3}Pel_)

1281 0861 6261 8261 Lz61 SOAE"yREREE™ | =
2 5

Zz S § 8

IES i a te Se

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. . 269

427 Statement showing number of times fived charges were earned by the
“ 0. 8. L. R. R. and Union Pacific System compared with Class I carriers
in western district and United States as a whole for the 5-year period
ending Deo. 31, 1931 ‘

|
it
S#ZERESN

:
£
—

o |i

Statement showing net income and rate of return based on Interstate
Commerce Commission valuation and carrier's book value

OREGON SHORT LINE RAILROAD COMPANY
1. C. C. Valuation as of V
Ww tal
LC.C. apital
Carrier's Book Value (Accounts 701 and as of Valuation Date... .-................... 1
Excess, Carrier's Book Value over I. C. C. Value as of Valuation Date........:...____- ,

,

1927 1928 1929 1930

Investment in Road and Equi
Materials and Supplies,
708, 716 150,711,818 | 147, 664,549 | 147, 988, 368 150, 600, 812
LC.C. Valuation 9, 049, 230 9, 049, 230 9, 049, 230 9, 049, 230

Net Investment for Fate making pur- :
141, 662, 588 | 138,615,619 | 128,930,138 | 141, 551, 582
6, 936, 914 8, 574, 323 8, 605, 758 6, 148, 561

4 90% 6. 19% 6 19% 434%
4.0% ‘5.81% |, 5.82% | 4. 8%

‘

Aathority: Annual reports to P. U. C. L. and from I. C. C.

rr UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD COMPANY
LC. C: valuation as of valuation daté

Excess
Net in

27, 574, 669

Authorit r From reports to Interstate Commerce Commission, annual statistics of Railways of U. 8.
and from direct information from I. C. C. ss ;

270

400 F

UNION PACIFIC SYSTEM!

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

~r
I. C. C. Valuation as of Valuation Dates ?......--------------------------+-++------2----7- 520, 881, 843. 00
Working Capital Included in I. C. C. Valuation. ----- SS LITT
I. C. C. Valuation less Working Capital ----------------------- a eens patiolbaieia 775. 0
Carrier's Book Value (Accounts 701 and 702) as of Valuation Date... ---------------------- 678, 511, 100. 00
Excess, Carrier's Book Value over I. C. C. Valuation as of valuation dates. -------------- 345. 00
1927 1928 - 1929 1930 ©

Investment in Road and Equipment, Materials and f

Supplies, and Cash; Accounts 701, 702, 708, 716....| 868, 741; 241 | 878, 302,629 | 893, 762, 566 | 912, 637, 924
Excess of Carrier’s Book Value over I. C. C. Valua- . ;

ee kaa teeanene ns esenaeans am 174, 202, 345 | 174, 202,345 | 174, 202,345 | 174, 202, 345
Net Investment for rate making pyrposes- ---..----- 694, 638, 896 | 704, 100, 284 | 719, 560,221 | 738, 435, 579
Net Railway Operating Income- ------.--- icaempns 39, 483,390 | 43,818,995 | 45,325.568 | 35, 297, 722
Rate of Return on I. C. C. Valuation Brought up to

PE I a ES EEE 5. 68% 6. 22% 6. 30% 4.78% .
Rate of Return on Carrier’s Book Value------------ 4. 58% 4.99% 5.07% 3.87% °

- ye From reports toI.C.C. Annual Statistics of Railways of U. S., and from direct information
‘om I. C. ‘ 4

1 Includes 0.-W. R. & N., 0. S. L., L. A. & S. L., and Union Pacific, °
2 Valuation Docket No. 329—June 30, 1916; Valuation Docket No. 1007—June 30, 1916; Valuation Docket
No. 26—June 30, 1914; Valuation Docket No. 1060—June 30, 1919; Valuation Docket. No. 102—June 30, 1916.

Statement showing number of carloads of revenue freight originated at
stations on Oregon Short Line in Idaho for years 1927 to 1931, inclu-
sive, compared with carloads originated in Western District and United
States, also percentage comparison using carloadings for 1929 as 100

431

percent
5 a Northwestern | Central western | Southwestern Total United
8 region - region region States
nated

Carloads Index; Carloads Index Carloads |Index| Carloads |Index| Carloads | Index

89 | 7 22.905 97 | 7,411, 808 96 | 3, 944, 320 51, 635, 806 98

100 } 7, 24., 410 97 | 7,601, 190 98 | 4,115,712 98 | 51, 589, 887 98

100 | 7, 447, 923 100 | 7, 726, 832 100 | 4, 220, 437 100 | 52,827,925 100

4 | 6, 366, 268 85 | 6,863,779 89 | 3,760, 949 89 | 45,877, 974 87

87 | 4,770, 332 64 | 5,710, 143 74 | 3,177, 969 75 | 37, 272,371 74

Authority: Monthly Reports O. 8. L. to P. U.C.1. Infotmation Bulletin of American Railway Ass’D.

: UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.: 271
} :
' 432 Statement showing number of cars of freight forwarded from Stations on”
: Victor Branch of Oregon Short Line as to commodities shown’ below for
the years 1928 to 1932, inclusive, and the first 3 months of 1932 :
3 3 =,/5 /34 a ; ,
g 2 sii S a ee a S/ES/esio | a | 8
i) e/2)2)]2/ 2 |22|s*/ 22/2/23] 3
=) OlO!l|BE le la [o™lg 38 o/ala
1] 152] 989 2 2 | a ae 619
11} 165] 787 3 42; os] ‘1/...... 217 | 376
Ga 3 5 See oe |b et et 2| 331 | 365
aosass 76 | 587 1 1 1 | eee ed ee
pea 2 | nen TOS UN TOE NE eg BE
E - = .
& F
B/2/F/2/2 1/4] 8/2 Z/13/¢4
2}|A}o;aAl/olel[a ie; a]/e] s
ees eee Soe 95 hi 2 eae A ee 33 7] 260 |_____. 266
SOREN E RCE. 5 aes 149 } 2 awe, 34 9] 249 |.--___ 86
SEC GoRE Rie: gi ) ees. 3 See 36 je | soe 5
_ OTe Toi Lips 165 |.....- 15 1| 583 5] 28] 14 1
CREO HE SUE earn | aoe | eee Sew Coes
=i 3a |2 3 3 3
a be [= °o
are Ee oa z |S /@ |8
& | 32/35 g™ | #a 38/08/08
2/3 2/2 |se/3 wee f ie
P/E le le | 2/28/21] 8/2 [2 fz
‘@l aia [Ss je ls (2 12818 18 &
cee 11 1 2 ven ee ee
eee Bf..8 St... 8): Bree
9 i teres _Y Saas COR 60 | 2,260
7 § Re ie coe eee 164 | 2, 202
R* Mieteiastiasonbiintaensnnceiate te. _) “SRS Ree DB hissistes 3| 268
Authority: O. S. L. monthly reports filed with P. U. C. I.
DAYS

: .

272 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.
433 ° (“oe Sie ae |
1... C. Docket No. 1758

Oregon Short Line Railioad Company—Statement of carload shipnients of
coal from Wyoming: and Utah mines to Snake River Valley points, Blackfoot
to Idaho Falls including all points on branch lines connecting with main
line at those points; showing tons to each destination station, for the year

1931 °
- Destination Station Tons Destination Station Tons
po ae 6 17,966 || Egin, Idaho........-.-.------------------- 277
Wapello, Idaho. .:.........-.....- = hae ee Oe Tt Pim FOO. . «ooo ced cnsnigasdncncnsnene 38
SO Se eres ea 1,906 || Parker, Idabd...............--..---.------ 142
Shelley, Idaho- ---- EI ee 4, 594 || Pyke, Idaho---_--- Re eee 1, 442
Cotton, Idaho---------- ey een 213 || Grainville, Idaho- --....------------------- 70
Tdamo Walls, 1dano.......----..-s222006-0- 43, 360 || Drummond, Idaho lll e
Cg Sg SS Sa eee re a8) Vetoma; Idano............-. a
8t. Anthony, Idaho ; 6, 327 || Darlington, Idaho---.-.-------------------- 73
Chester, Idaho------ Gt EARL RANG. 0 cba S coca acewcnesdcncsenssess RS)
Ashton, Idaho-- 2,087 |] Mackay, Idaho. -.....---.---------------- 1, 829
Lincoln, Idaho---- 1, 207 || Rockford, Idaho-----.-------- See a ee 154
Iona, Idaho.------ 730 1) Pines, 106n0....-..--=.~--.-nc02+--5--
—
Ss

Kemmerer-Rock

Wyoming Mines in
Springs District

f coal were made from Talbot

OD OD OD OD SH et tt gt

Slack | Lump

RRRERRARS

OD G2 OD 09 09 OD 09 OD OD
. -

Nut

Peery

OD OD OD OD SH et et tt gt

Utah Mines in Castle
Gate District

Lump

SSRBSSESSEY

UNITED STATES ET AL, VS. STATE OF IDAHO Ef AL.

mines located in the Castle Gate district. in

the Kemnerer-Rock Springs district in W
to points in Idaho where shipments o

during the year 1931

Statement of rates in cents per ton of 2

Ot. ABURORY. .... Sterlin

ee ae eR TN ET! OTe ae

eT Se te —

274 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

436 Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096-Fin.
Exhibit No. 20. Witness counsel. Complainant’sy, Defend-
ant’s, Commission’s. Date 5-17-1932. Frank W. Oiterstrom,
Reporter. . : 7
Only one Supplement to this Tariff will be in effect at any time.
Sup. No. 7 to O. S. L. R. R—I. C. C. No. 2076 (Cancels Sup. No.
6). Sup. No. 7 contains all changes from the original Tariff that
are effective on the date hereof.

United States Railroad: Administration
W. G. McAdoo, Director General of Railroads. ..

Oregon Short Line Railroad and Union Pacific Railroad (Fx5 No.
6) in Connection With Camas Prairie Railroad (Fx5 No. 3), Great
Northern Railway (Fx4 No. 200), Northern Pacific Railroad (Fx2
No. 101), Oregon-Washington Railroad & Navigation Lines (Fx5
No. 3), Southern Pacific Company (Fx5 No. 2), (Oregon Lines),
Spokane, Portland & Seattle Ry. (Fx4 No. 24).

%

Supplement No. 7 (Cancels Sup. No. 6),

Sup. No, 7 contains all changes to Joint. Freight Tariff—o. S. L.

No. 2112-I, S. P. & S. No. 501-D, O.-W. R. & N. No. 157-D, U. P.

No. 2052-A; Nor. Pac. No. 991-H, So. Pac. No. 264-L (Which took
effett_ September 20, 1917), applying on soft coal, all kinds, carloads
(except blacksmith coal) from Cumberland, Diamondville, Kem-
merer, Rock Springs, Superior, Wyoming, and points shown herein,
to stations on the Oregon-Washington Railroad & Navigation Lines,

_ Southern Pacific Co. (Oregon Lines), Northern Pacific Railway,

Great Northern Ry., Spokane, Portland & Seattle Ry. and Camas
Prairie R. R., in Oregon, Washington, Idaho, and Montana as shown
herein.
‘Refer to tariff and amend as shown herein.
Published for the Director General of Railroads and filed on one
day’s notice with the Interstate Commerce Commission * under
Freight Rate Authority No. 3660 of the Director, Division of
Traffic, United .States Railroad Administration, dated January 6, '
1919.
Issued January 9, 1919. Effective January 16, 1919 (Except as
noted in individual items). b>
; J. A. Reeves,
General Freight Agent, °
Oregon Short Line R. R.,
Salt Lake City, Utah.”
_ Folio 94. (File 17623) (900). . .

= — >
Index| Wyo., Rock Springs,| 2 _ | & R
No Wyo., Almy, Wyo., I 8 z
* |«# and points shown in | @ ai 3s 2
* Item 25-A to— co] = a
: e=i' 3] 8
; 1)
as} & oy
Ee| e138
— 4 7)
O. W. B. & N. CO.—contd.
%&28 | Wallowa, Ore_____.__.. 5.30 | 480) 450
oe a. — Pineaasicasibsndiel
a wynne, Ore__..____-
%31 | Enterprise, Ore____.___ 5.40 | 4.90} 4.70
%&32 | Joseph, Ore______..____ ,
*%33 _—— Ore., to and in-
cluding .70 | 4.20] 3.90
%*47 | Pendleton, Ore__.____. Z
*48 | *Birch, Ore., to and in-
cluding 90 | 4.40 | 4.20
%52 | Pilot Rock, Ore_..-..__

ES LR TIY LE LL IE ET TT NE I I I TT TR

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE .OF IDAHO ET AL.

Y

-——TIndex

No.

: Rate in Dollars Rate in Dollars
& Cents per ton & Cents per ton
of 2,000 lbs. of 2,000 Ibs.
om ~~ Cumberland, zs a“ From. Cumberland, = my
~ Rock Springs, | = _ | & ® |lndex| Wy¥0- Rock Springs, 2 afta] aR-
Wyo., Almy, Wyo., | S& g a ie Wyo., Almy, Wyo.,| SR] g a
and points shownin| qj $ = * |. and points shown in | @& g| $ 3
Item 25-A to— zs 3 3 Item 25-A to— 33 3 Ps
an R woias|?s
agi =| 4 as| =|
— } + 13)
heel 3 3 3 t=] 3
n Z a. y Zz a
O. W.R. & N.co.—contd. 0. W.R. & N. CO.—contd.
Rieth, Ore., to and in- \.70 er bend SBoardy ong LEME E
cluding ki . y oardman, Oreg------- 4.901 4.40} 4.20
Umatilla, Ore_...--.--- %333 | Messner, Oreg.-------- ; ‘ .
*Saxe, Ore., to and in- %334 | Irrigon, Oreg......-----
cludin .70 | 4.70 | 4.20 || #335 |*Shutler, Oreg_-..-.---- 5.20 |-4.70 | 4.40
Kennewick, Wash.--.- %336 |*Rack Creek, Oreg--..--
*Leslie, Wash., to and %337 |*Barnett, Oreg--_.------- 5.30 | 4.80 | 4.50
including ‘ .80 | 4.80] 4.30 Le wena =
North Yakima, Wash-. : “a es cree
“Husneriat, Wash., to %&340 |*Speece, Oreg.-_-.------- 5.40 | 4.90 | 4.70
and including * 164.70 | 4.70 | 4.20 bird pgs ee ‘ :
*Joseph, Idaho--------- ondon, Oreg-_.....---- .
ay 1918, 4343 Arlington, Oreg., to
up. 2 . 4351 and * aoraeae Biggs,
Fort ‘Tae, Idaho.___| 4.90 | 4.90 | 4.40 ; “eae teeters | 4.90 | 4.40] 4.20
RNa ag Idaho_-_--| 5.10 | 5.10 | 4.60 Lm “Grebe, on PEERS: ee re
*Bundy, Idaho---.----- _ SS . . 3
sremenih. ROARO.....-.- fs, 30 | 5.30 | 4.80 || #354 Wasco, | eee
Culdesac, Idaho---..--- 355 *Klondike, Oreg., to
Reuben’s, Idaho-_.--.-- ° 280 and oe Maro, .
*Craig Junction, Idaho-|}5.90 | 5.90 | 5.40 ee 5.40 | 4.90] 470
Volimer, a ‘ *&361 *Erskinville, Oreg... 2.- \s. 70 | 5.20! 4.90
Ferdinand 1dahe---~--H6.00 | 6.00 | 6.00 | NS | es Grow heand |
Geaeville: Tdaho....7|}82 | 6-20 | 5.70 || #306 |) Groene, S78 | 5 oo | 5.40] 5.0
*Canyon, Wash., to 367 '|*Free Bridge, Oreg......| 5.20 | 4.70 | 4.40
— gn .70 | 4.70 | 4.20 = Me aye a a \5 50 | 5.00 |. 4.80
naville, Idaho-------- : , jua@e,-Oreg....--- a ae : ue
*Linfor, Idaho, to and *%370 |*Tunnel One, Oreg P
_qneludin Q 4.90 |.4.90 | 4.40 wen goes po 5.20] 4.90
mith; Idaho..-.-....-- aupin, Oreg.......-_-- 2
*Steamboat, Idaho, to |} ~ 4373 *McLennans, Oreg., to
and including 5.20°| 5.20] 4.70 4379 and including South
*Paragon, Idaho--.-.-- . Jordan, Oreg....__..-| 5.90 | 5.40] 5.20
== 1918, : see, 1918, :
n Su n Su
*Pine Creek, Idano___-| 4.70 | 4.70 | 4.20 || %380 deene. Oreg., to
—— oo 1918, *%390 poe | samen Bend,

Footnotes at end of table.

280. «UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

Soft Coal—Carloads (Rates in Dollars and Cents per Ton
of 2,000 Pounds)

»
7

ete con po A Sows is item 25

FROM«s@"| Cum

. Index
no.

Other .
than Nut}; Nut Slack then et Nut | Slack
and Slack lack

To— (See Item 15) (See Item 15)

0. 8. L. BR. n.—continued

59 *Martha, Idaho, to and including. . 3.70 |. 3.70
67 | Minidok®s faho, to and including... | rt _ = el 8 10 si, aoe
ceq' daho, Ss ° ©
Paul 233 |}? s20|- “2e0l, stoi a0) 2%
4.20 3.70 3.30 420} 370| 390
3.90 “2901 ¢.
| 3) 3.30) 230 sie) °° 2%
sh 30 |} 3.70 3.30 aot 370 3.30
3} fro]. a30 se 3o |} 270] 380
£3) 3.70 3.30 If id} 3.70} 3.30>
4.2 3.70 3.30 4.20| 3.70) 330
Judi 4.20 3.30 2.80 420)\ 330) 290
Sos | Fn, Taso, to sid ineldlng. =| st : oo
ni 0, to and including. .....
; , 370 3.30 3.70) 230
108 | *Haggardt, [daho........-.- 4404 «439 3.70 aa} 290| 370
%199 | Horse Shoe Bend, Idaho...

#200 | *Gardena, Idaho. ..---------------- }} 470) 4m] 390 470| 420) 39
#202 | *Mains, Idaho, toand including....--\\| 4 go 440 ‘. ao} 440) 42

—- Idaho, to and including..... } 5.20 4.70 440 5.20 4.70 4”

daho
- %&213 “il ar), [dabo, to and including.
227 WOGUD co taconcccenccccssneses } 42 3.70 3.30 42} 370) 3%

*228 x an, Oregom......--- , scesesoess 40 3.80 3.70 4.40 3. 80 3.70
* $229 | *Adrian, Oregom......-----=---**00" 4.70 42 3.90 4.70 4.20 38
%&230 | *Napton, Oregon... ~..----- ETE OTE

#231 | *McCoard, Idaho... .-.----------9° } 40) 40 4.20 400} 440) 42”
*%232 | Homedale, Idabo......-------+*++--*

233 | *Arcadia, Oregom... ..--------98eee- =

*ZA | *Malheur Jct., Oregon ...----------- 4.2 3.70 3.30 “42)| 3.70 3%
235 0 dD, OTEZOM... .-- nen en wnnnn es

Lins Se Sea sacheaeree rane mace } 4.70 42 3.00 470) 420) 30
Hou | "Hope Oragoa ons} ewe] awe] 4m] 4m) tel te
423 | *Harper, Oregon... ...--------*---- 5.2 4.70 4.40 5.2) 470 4”
We2A5 *Namorf, Oregom...--------] gol so
lortage, Utah....----.------.--------
339 | *Woodruff, Idaho, to and including--|\ ’ 2.80 2. 80
LR 9 7 ap sapdaliceepnenenanaesnate } @3.10| @3.10| @3.10 a
: : @2. 60 200 || 2.20} 2.00
206 | Baleares, Utab.....-.-------0----0020-0 { S220 |} O20] ©2.00 em | a 41.50
, ey
Z 2. 20
395 | *Call’s Fort, Utah, to and including..|_ 2.60 + ao 2. 20 2.00
423 | §§*Lewiston, Utah -..-.---.--.------ Gy2.20 |} 2.60} 2.00 $0 |f 12-00] 11.50
= ae, saeme, to and including- ---| Ae } @2.60! . @2.00 2.20 2.20 2.00
reston, SE. a tnacessemidedadoancaee be
429 | *Hammond, Utah, to and including--| 2. 60 } @2. 60 @2.00 { . 2.20 2. 20 2.00
£3 | eat Guo ioand iia | #04 arent Bers he
eston, aho, to and inciuding----- a } 1 2.20 2.00
oF | Ceted See aad inainding | “GRO Gane Beas Gere
‘ wan e, Idaho, to and including- ; 3 2. 2.00
Ant Se Rs cecchcnkceacdael @§2. 20 } @2.60} @2.00 { 9390 \ 2.60
444 *Tyhee, ss. inknuceo’ eniaeanees 3. 10 3.00 2. 60 3.10} 3.00 2. 60
ons Pig Fay 25, 1918, in Sup. 3).
” peaepaamrereamnes cies 3. 10 3.00 2. 60
446 | *Gibson, Idaho----....--.------------- 3.10 3. 00 2. 60
447 | *Younsg, Idaho. .......-.....---------- a ap peed }
448 | Blackfoot, Idaho. -.....-.....---.---- ore] on! azo} 310) 300) 20
W440 | *Collins, Idaho------.---------------- 3. 30 3 3.30 “
St Semen ME... goss Li nedensacusuaes y ‘ 3.30| 3.30 3. 30
a .,.......... 7 ip te ae oe }
#452 | *Moreland Jet., Ida_.....2.....------- °s.a0 3.70 3.20 \ 3.90} 3.70| 3.30
. 4. ; ./
#453 |.*Rockford, Idaho.........--:--------- @s.10] @x10 ‘O27 \ 4.00} 3.70] 3.30
%454 | *Virden, Idaho, to and including----- 4. 20 A , 2 - 3.30
460 | Aberdeen, Idaho. .....-.----------- { @3.30 3. 30 @2.70 4.20] 3.70
#461 | *Taber, Idaho. -----.----------------- 00 @3. 00 @2.7 _ 3.90] 3.70 3. 30
462 | *Furey, Idaho, to and including. ----- OF 3.70 3. 30 } 4.20 3.70 3.30
471 | Mackay, Idaho..-.-----.------.------- Oo 20 oes 30 @2.70 , 7
472 | *Wapello, Idaho, to and including---- 2 = at zak Tt ee Ts or
477 | *Bach, Idaho... ---.----.------------- §3. 10 |.....- LEP TREE " | poet Seteeo
478 | Idaho Falls, Idaho 3. 20 3.00 2. 80 3.20} 3.00 2.80
i cae, Se Sst ee 2a.
7 2, ee, ee pee ye ‘ 5 Ree) SS es Perr Ce
3. 60
; 3. 20 3.10 3. 60
W481 | Iona, Idaho.....---------------------- 83 @2.0| @1.80| §3. a0 |} 320] 3.10
4 é 3. 80 3.20 3. 10 3:80} 3.20] 3.10
482 | sMilo, Idaho. -..-------------------- aad Bian S| Waar mom
183 » Idaho.....------------------- @2.00 | @2.00 | @i.80 |... 2... ooo
ss . 20 3.10 a3 3. 20 3.10
ies i DO nin cots ek iaansone 5°) RES eRe IIE: $3. 10 |.......-]--------
cabs . 3 1.9 = Cee Ee SK
4c | “RIESE dake to and inctuding seo, sil aio | ae [SiO
ens Hennassen ye, eae
n " 2, et SERA EN WERK Bee eee
' lm oe YS Seer Seer see :
512 | St. Anthony, Idaho_______.___.______ 4. 20 3.70 3.10 4. 20 3. 70 3.10 a
: Py 10 oY ye Lo Seen Meares .
: 1. 60 1. 60 - ) Se) Se ee ‘
513 | *T win Groves, Idaho___.._._.___.___-
a er | ied i PT al
. @1. 40 @1. 40 @1. 40 4.20 3.70 3. 30
515 | Ashton, Idaho.__.___.__ Phe ree © oo ee 5.20| 4.70| 4.40
‘ 5 " ls 4. 40
526 | Driggs, Idaho- ----------------------- @1.00 @1.00 OES EES ESE TEER, a
527 | Victor, Idaho-.-.----- eucaataansnae Mokee gt . . = : . 5. 40 4,90 4.70
Ne i. 40 Or ae | ote CRY SRO SRE
528'| ‘*Ingling, Idaho... .------------------- 4.20 3.70 3. 30 420} 3.70) 3.30
, 4. 40 3.90 3.70 4. 40 3. 90 3.70
529 | *Warren River, Idaho---------------- Pi ¢ — ‘i 3 “Sie lS aepeeaties Seeeeren
530 | *Payne, Idaho, to and including. .-... 3.20| + 3.20 3.20) 3.20] 3.20] 3.2
535 | *Hawgood, Idaho---.-_-.--------- oS > | Vy Gee et Ae, Se
536 | Hamer, Idaho, to and including 2. 40 , ae MO oS Sennen aaBlosaanecn
Sat Bie WO. cc concccacc-scssegecs 3. 20 2, 20 3. 20 3. 20 3.20
540 “High Bridge, Idaho, to and including @2.60 e #60 |.---. 30 bao faa
Eg © ee eer . f j ;
544 | *Snowline, Mont., to and including--|f @2.70 @2. 70 Soy ay 8 Eee! SAS eae
B47 | Dell, MOU. «65. 2222-5200555-000052555 -3, 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20
548 | *McKnight, Mont., to and including.|f @2. 90 @2. 90 Op 1) eee hee arenas Cama
551 | Armstead, Mont. .-..-.-..-----..------ 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 $. 20 3. 20
= et —« to and including.--- @3. 4 7 = a = Beene ae eT ats
ae aid adad 3. : i ;
*&557 | Apex, Mont., to and including--.----- 3. 20 3. 20 * 3.20 3..20 3. 20 3.20
%570 | Butte, Mont---.----------------------
B., A. & P. RY. ." .
%571 | Butte, Mont., to and including-------
581 | *Brown’s, Mont.......------- eaeip 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20
*%&582 oe a effective June 25, — has
. >
ot St A cae Sn, ane ne ete en eee 7
PRLS EP LIL LRT PE ER LEE COST CLINI LIE IES GON T

B n
i
5
3
|
&
A= |

Mission
Otte

No. 34.

472

.

Exhibit 37

I. C. .C. Docket No. 37.

- Oregon Short Line Railroad Company—Tons of coal received at stations on
the Oregon Short Line Railroad within 150 miles of Driggs, Idaho, from
Wyoming mines for the eleven months ended November 30th, 1932

304 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

Destination, Station - | Jarf | Feb. |Mar. | Apr. | May | June} July | Aug. Sept.] Oct. | Nov. | Tota)
“

St. Anthony. -...-.....--].----- a nee eae a a a ee 6m
a i ; | Se BE Ee ee ee ee eee oe a
Idaho Falls. ......-...,--| 323 | 180} 128 83 92 51 90 41 45 91} 125| La
ee ae 5 Meet Hoes ee ee eee ee ee eee ee eee »
Blackfoot. ....----- 77} 144 76 su et eee ae ee) | 52 47 9) sR
Fort Hall a 233 189 192 140 7 8 a eee eee Aw
TNS)” 6 caiman 1,061 1,313 | 950} 201} 165] 280] 186 | 274 | 882 /1,198 | S06 | 7.4%
OGRE. oc nunc nenpene 1,694 (2,560 |1,383 | 548 | 304 389 | 276 | 366] 979 [1,336 |1,022 1087

Auditor’s Office, Salt Lake City, Utah, December 13, 1932.

Interstate Commerce, Commission. Docket No. 9096. _ Exhibit No.
37. Witness, Wipprecht.
sion’s, Applicant’sy. Date, Dec. 15, 1932. Reporter, Frank W.

Otterstrom.

Complainant’s, Defendant’s, Commis-

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO-ET AL, 305-
473 Echibit 38

Interstate Commerce Commission. ‘Docket No. 9096. Exhibit—
No. 38. Witness, Wipprecht. Complainant’s, Defendant’s, Com-
mission’s, Applicent’sy. Date, Dec. 15, 1932. Reporter, Frank W.
Otterstrom. , .
Oregon Short Line Railroad Company—Tons of Coal Received at Stations on

the Oregon Short Line Railroad within 150 Miles of Driggs, Idaho, from
-Utah Mines for tle Eleven Months Ended November 30th, 1932

am

evBS sn SRSBauEsURE

w
no
i)
—
te

re
Bee

4

“ATS

306 —
Exhibit 39

Interstate Commerce Commission.
No. 39. Witness Wipprecht.
sion’s, Applicant’s¥y. Date Dec. 15, 1982.

_ Otterstrom.

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL,”

Docket No. 9096. Exhibit
Complainant’s Defendant’s Commis.’
Reporter, Frank W.

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company—Operating revenues, operating expenses,
railway tar. aceruals, wncollectible railway revenues, equipment rents—net,
joint facility rents—net, and net railway operating income of the Talbot
Branch, Talbot Junction to Talbot, Idaho, for the period April 1 to October

31, 1932 inel. and accumulated deficit since July. 15, 1924

‘ Apr. 1, 1932, to
Item Oct. 31, i
incl,
; REVENUES .

ES I iictandn adenennadee Rie cinedaddaseas en Ar wr GE I ono os ccscacncandccdanssuckucensdsacanseauns ” 935.8

3 — Or Sidi csctdaknkadennscedcasensakenckbadcqanxdsaueeuanasanee s

SEES SAE ES REE OT AEE Aa Rtn wae em Ne fair MT LO 8

8 Ge Transportation— Rail NR Sa taccuabd seednstalsassanaackeenussucseasdannbladeaaense 526.01

) General.......-..:----------------------+-------------------------------------+------ 107.8

ER I ee ee Ree AEE ROE RTE: PRN : 1,737.0

(10) Expenses over Revenues.___.-.-----..--------------- PEE RT, a Ea FY 1, 358.52

RED SUE Bots cided cdc ccncdenecdsasannsancced a Sa eee Oy Re HREM nett” 815.06

(12) - - Railway Operating Income (Debit)............-.------- Amiinataceseehastenmanee 2, 173. 8

* (18) Uneollectible Railway SE I OO eo a ka piauabebgeeoe al ese a

ee) ee IP I oo 2s Secs ccnacnaenaananadsmasaenasmashenosexea B18

Oe SUNE UNNI SI ROU cin casesadcindectsktinnntsececcnccanacncaddaces nackawaseccslcanseancreunie

- (16) . Net Raliway Opaating Tneume (Debit) ..................5.5...........2..... 2, 405.07

(17) Accumulated ee SN FH BE WO iis wim Whsickeatckecinsuncecncts innascscdecnces 61, 765. 06
Auditor’s Office, Salt Lake City, Utah, December 12, 1932.

UNITED STATES. ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 307
476 CO Exhibit 40
I. C. C. Docket No. 40

Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No.- 9096. Exhibit
No. 40. Witness Wipprecht. Complainant’s, Defendant’s, Commis-
sion’s, Applicant’s¥. Date Dec. 15, 1932. Reporter, Frank W.
Otterstrom. er

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company—Carload shipments (Other than Coal)
from and to Points on the Talbot Branch Showing Date of Shipment, Point
of Origin and Destination, Consignor or Consignee, Commodity, Tons and
Oregon Short Line R. RB. Co. Revenue, Segregated;as to Forwarded ‘from and
Received on the Branch for the Eléven Months Hnded November 30th, 1932

Point of
_ - - = Commédity Tons HH, Go,
ment Origin Destination : :
FORWARDED FROM
BEANCH
6-19 | Dygert, Idaho... Civicago, linois.| Androson Davis+.| Potatoes....| 18| $71.71
| RECEIVED ON BRANCH ;
42 Blackfoot, eGeno. 4.0.35. Dygert, Idaho__| Cecil Harris._..___ Stock Feed..) 14 ; 57.14

"Auditor's Office, Salt Lake City, Utah, December 7, 1832.

308 UNITED STATES ET AL, VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL,

ATT Ewhibit 41

Interstate Commerce Commission. ‘Docket No. 9096. Exhibit ¥
41. Witness Wipprecht. Complainant’s,. Defendant’s, Commigg
sion’s, Applicant’sy. Date, Dec. 15, 1932. Reporter, Frank ¥,
Otterstrom.

Estimated revenues and expenses of Talbot Branch based on daily shipn onl
of 50 tons, and on average actual expense of operation of, branch for
5 years (1927 to 1931 incl. ) ‘

Revenue per ton accruing to branch during first 10 months 1932
a a a a a ee eee et kl

50 tons per day would amount to 18,250 tons per year @ $0.1663
would a rn a ee a 3,

Total gross revenue per year at 50 tons per day____.__-_-__~_ 3, 793.
_ Actual operating expenses on branch for years 1927 to

SR ec a dca leah aeca aha ens ean nics feces nei taednieda Ha eae $34, 146. 41
Taxes during same OS RSE BEE TRS II ee 6, 518. 94
Keuipment rents for same period. _.............-....<< 3, 770. 40

Total Bupesse for Period... .ncanccacs 44, 435. 75
a P| UR ee DR a ee eC 8, 887

Average net loss per year____-____-___--_----___-_------_____-_- _ 5, 008. 48:

Nore.—The average shipments of coal ‘during the period 1927 to 1931
16% tons per day. The expense of moving 50 tons per day would obvioug
be somewhat more than for moving 16%. tons. “¢

478 _~- In the District Court of the United States for the
District of Utah p

Unitep States or AMERICA,
District of Utah, ss:

I, W. B. Wilson, Clerk of the District Court of the United States
for the District of Utah, do hereby certify that the Photosts :
copies numbered from 1 to 48 is Plaintiffs’ Exhibit lettered E
being the original Exhibit duly admitted by the Court in the cas
of State of Idaho and J. D. Rigney, M. Reese Hattabaugh, ani
Harry Holden, constituting and as the Public Utilities Commitsiog
of Idaho vs. United States of America, Interstate Commerce Com

‘mission, and Oregon Short Line Railroad Company, a corporatio on
No. 12873, Equity. . a

In witness whereof, I heivebe subscribe and affix the seal of 's
Court at Salt Lake City, ; in said District, this 11th day of Janu ry
1936. a

[sEaL] W. B. Wi1s0n, a

: Clerk, U. S. District Court.

By V. P. Anisrrom,

Chief Devel

&S

.

U. S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING orice:

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386010_0022%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
