# Appendix to Respondents Brief — Rickert Rice Mills, Inc. v. Fontenot

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386009_0294%3A31

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix to Respondents Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1936
- **Citation:** 297 U.S. 110

## Text

| ‘DEC “ I
ON Os. 57 7-681, 585-587 :

- Guihe Supreme ourt of the Gited

OcTOBER TERM, 1985 .

Rroxmni Rick MILxs, ‘Inc, PETITIONER
o..' i
Rorus W. Fontenot, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS. Actin Unirep States —
Cotzector or INTERNAL RevENvE FoR THE Disreicr or LOUISIANA

A. B. mage, PETITIONER
‘ @.:
Rusvs Ww. “Forranor, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS ACTING Unermp States
Cotnector or INTERNAL RevVENUVE For rHE DIsTRICT OF LovIsIANA

UNITED Rion MILLING Propr ors-Ca., INo,, PRYITIONES
' ete, . ‘
Rorus W. Fontenot, INpIvipvalLLy anp as Acting Unirm States
OOLLECTOR OF INTERN AL Raverce FOR THE Dawraior oF LOUISIANA

Baton. Rouge RICE Mitt, INO., PETITIONER,
TA. v. ;
__ Rorvs W. Fonrenor, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS keane Untre, Srates —
CoLLecToR OF INTERNAL REVENUE FOR THE DisTeicr or LOUISIANA

[, SUMMON) PETITIONER
. F “5 ‘ v. . " 3 7 ~
Rorus W. Fonrenot, INpIvipUALLY AND AS ACTING Unite Srates
. CoLLector or INTERNAL REVENUE FOR THE’ Disratcr OF Lovistana

“Lavy Rice MILLING Co., INc., PETITIONER
. v. >
‘me W.. Fontenot, LA DIPEDUALLY AND As ACTING Unive STaTEs
- COLLECTOR OF INTERNAL REVENUE FOR THE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA

‘Farmers Rice Mrine Co., Inc., PETITIONER
Rurus W. Fontexor, Lypivipvatty and as Acting Unita Starzs
CoLLecTor oF INTERNAL RevENUE-FoR THE Disteicr or Louisiana

Nostz-TRorrm Rick MrxxuNe Co:, INC., PETITIONER
x ®.
Rurvus w. Fontenot, initoiiiineer ‘AND 'AB8- ACTING Unitep STATES
Coutmctor’ or” INTERNAL RevENvE For THE DIsTsicr oF Lourstana

ON: WRITS OF OERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUI T.
: COURT OF APPEALS ROR THE FIFTH CIROUIT

“APPENDIX "To THE BRIEF FOR. THE RESPONDENT

oom

\

“INDEX TO APPENDIX

Part A:

Statutes involved.................. jeebedtisdaamenwous
Part B:

Regulations 83 and Treasury Decision 4586..............
Part C: ; ,
Compilation from Monthly Reports from Commissioner of

Internal Revenue to Agricultural Adjustment Admin-
istration.......... seneequecednesoesede sSuaeeesoences
Part D.:

Marketing agreement for Southern Rice Milling Industry -.
Part E:

Statistical Data Compiled from Department of Agrifplture

Reports (Tables I, I, and ITI)..........-. a. ee
Pari F:
Congressional Record, 74th Cong., Ist Sess., Vol. 79, No.
a ciel et eeeiieaeeaee
Part G: ‘
Cases decided by lower Federal courts since August 24, 1935.

CITATIONS
Cases:

A, P. W. Paper Co. v. Riley, 3 U. 8. Law Week 133... ---
Baltic Mills Co. v. Bitgood, 12 Fed. Supp. 132...........-
Danahy Packing Co. v. McGowan, 11 Fed. Supp. 920... - . .
Fisher Flouring Mills Co. v. Vierhus, 78 F. (2d) 889......-.
Frye & Co. v. Vierhus, decided November 2, 1935- ..... .-
G. B. R. Smith Milling Co. v. Thomas, 11 Fed. Supp. 833-.
G. M. Peet Packing Co. v. Kavanaugh, decided October 15,
DU iiptinsescdautesdndswesdaudbdbevbdnadunesocee
Gold Medal Foods v. Landy, decided October 22, 1935-- - . -
Grosvenor-Dale Co. v. Bitgood, 3 U. 8. Law Week 84_..--~-
Henrietta Mills v. Hoey, 12 Fed. Supp. 61... ..........--
- Inland Milling Co. v. Huston, decided November 22, 1935.
. John A. Gebelein, Inc. v. Milbourne, 12 Fed. Supp. 105---.
Jones, Jedd, Jr. v. Viley, 3 U. 8. Law Week 119. -..~--~--
Jose Escalani: & Co. v. Fontenot, 79 F. (2d) 343.........-
Kingan & Co. v. Smith, decided September 30, 1935 - - -- - -
Larabee Flour Mills Co. v. Nee, decided October 3, 1935. . . .
Louisvil e Provision Co. *. Glenn, decided November 5, 1935.
Merchants Packing Co. v. Rogan, 79 F. (2d) 1. RR

Paes
35128—35—aPp—1 y

Caseg—Continued. ae ae :
Merkle, Inc.’v. Rasquin, 12 Fed. Supp. Oe ae j
Meridian Grain & Elevator Co. v. Fly,

cee EOE INE Ieee SEt sce ts Oa —— a
Queen City Cotton Co. v. Martin, 3 U. S..Law Week 119___ 125.
Riederv. Rogan, decided October &., aa 130
Shenandoah Mi!': 9 Co. v. Early, 3 U.S. Law Week 119___ 131
Stratton & Co. y. Gagne, 3 U. 8. Law Week 119_-________ . 127
’ Statutes: # ‘
Act of April 7, 1934, c. 103, 48 Stat. 528:
Sec. MiGRbd nbchindmonwamadadentlsce vacien: ith at sien 31
5 Sas. pititibsecsaawead Ae as. *
eed iy ao So eerie PAS SORE Soh Aileen 31
Be Pint edie oseansneraweniiuuignebeeresccuscc.,.. 31
; WE Mico cient desiece posrdicewinedbavewskudeces yas 31
4 . See. WetotiuWauiéamb sendin pahecianinxe 5 IEC LT a 10
re Act of May 9, 1934, c. 263, 48 Stat. 670: /
= ____ 5 Rent ae aaa EA 31
4 Séc. 3 wee eee eee wis Site eat each o a aus wae ee eee me 18, 19 ®
3 een egnehinedmakunsiieitinnns oonenccac.t.,. 28 i
q SE SPS heene ne nwnwehnsdeeurnananpenesecenecc 43 t
See. i2 | SE 45
a ete mI tn a 45 ¢
; Cin nibh ence bankicniaucesiece.¢. 8, .
ESE ne lua atin digler de bari har anne 35>
ee eee hetaeedibkoeooo cece aiseeie 49:
Act of June 16, 1934, c. 551, 48 Stat. 973_...._..._______ 41
: Act of June 26, 1934, ¢. 759, 48 Stat. 1241:
. NE PAUP ECR Peihuibhsipiak se kilo ceudc’ccmsnc.s cs net 36.
. PN Matidscnbvisewadiesine cite... ; EC ERNE De. a 27
OR eet dae iin owsineenearsicecnccn........ 46
Agricultural Adjustment Act, c. 25, 48 Stat. 31:
Sec. 1 (U.S. C.,, Title 7, Sec. a 1
Sec. 2 (U. S. C., Title 7, Sec. Ene 2
~ Sec. 8 (U.S. C., Title 7, Sec. Ga ‘ .
Sec. 9 (U. S. C.; Title A aie 15
Sec. 10 (U.S. C., Title 7, Sec. ASTM 28
Sec. 11 (U.S. C., Title 7, Sec. | \ildiees Nesibegiacthiene 31 j
Sec. 12 (U. 8. C., Title 7, Sec.612).... — |
Sec. 13 (U. S. Cx Title.7, Sec. ee 34
Sec. 14 (U. 8. C., Title 7, Sec. ae ERO. 35
Sec. 15 (U.S. C., Title 7, Sec. 615)_-.-._........____ 35.
Sec. 17 (U. 8. C., Title 7, Sec. 617)... ©... 440
Sec. 18 (U. 8. C., Title 7, Sec. 618)... — Se Sets BORE Say Saag A Co Soest ST
~ Sih it Usha Ge RA EE ELLE seat See ae ae PON NINE POLI LOE SE DOIG FEELIN LAE IRE

PART Ae

AGRIGULTURAL ADJUSTMENT ACT, C. 25, 48 STAT. 31, AS
AMENDED, AS OF AUGUST 24, 1935 2

f AN ACT pe
To relieve the’ exist national economig.emergency by in-
creasing agricul rchasing power, to raise revenue
_ for extraordinary expenses incurred by ®eason of, such
emergency, to provide emergency relief with respect to

; agricultural indebtedness, to provide: for the orderly liqui- _
i _ dation of joint-stock land banks, and for other purposes.

i oe Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Repre-

séntativés of the Umited States of America m

mt Congress assembied,

TITLE I—AGRICULTURAL ADJUSTMENT

DECLARATION OF EMERGENCY

, That the present acute economic emergency be-
_ - jing in-part-the-consequence of a severe and in- —
creasing disparity between the prices of agricul-
a tiral and other commodities, which disparity has’
[ largely destroyed the purchasing power of farmers
for industrial products, has broken down the ord-
erly exchange of commodities, and has seriously i im-

oe

1 Throughout this document italics are= _ to —
matter added by the 74th Congress by -way of amendment to
the Agricultural Adjustment Act, as previously amended.
In instances where the language was stricken, or changed, ’\
heavy black brackets are used to indicate the deleted matter.

(1)

o

‘ t
.

Cea rae hes Ree vert ae PEELE LL LE ILE LEO I

_

2

paired the agricultural. idiite supporting the
national credit structure, it.is hereby declared that
these conditions in the basic industry of agriculture
have affected transactions in agricultural commodi-
ties with a national public interest, have burdened
' and obstructed the normal currents of commerce in
such commodities, and render imperative the im-
mediate enactment of.title I of this Act. (U.S. C.,
Title 7, Sec. 601.) . :

DECLARATION OF POLICY

Sec. 2. It is hereby declared to: be the 7 of
Congress—
(1) [To] Through the exercise of the powers
conferred upon the Secretary of. Agriculture under
- this title, to estak-lish and maintain such balance
between the prodiction and consumption of agrir
cultural commodities, and such marketing condi- |
tions therefor, as will reestablish prices to farmers
at a level that will give‘agricultural commodities
a purchasing power with respect to articles that
farmers buy, equivalent to the purchasing power
of . agricultural commodities in the base period ;
and, in the case of all commodities for which the
base period is the pre-war period, August 1909 to
July 1914, will also reflect current interest pay-
ments pee acre on farm indebtedness secured by
real estate and tax payments per acre on farm
real estate, as contrasted with such interest pay- *
ments and tax payments during the base period.
The base period in the case of all agricultural com-
modities except tobacco and potatoes shall be the
prewar period, August 1909-July 1914. In the

ca

-
* ° ‘
POEL LER LESTE RES. RIEL EINK REE
:

~~ ee bk

Bwe ws

ot red A TS

3 Se

-- ease of tobacco and potatoes,’ the base period shall
‘be the postwar period, August 1919—July 1929.

[(2) To approach such. equality of’ purchasing
power by gradual correction of the present imnequal-

‘ities therein at as rapid a rate as is deemed feasible

in view of the current consumptive demand in do-

~mestie and foreign markets.

(3) To.protect the consumers’ interest by read-

' justing farm production at such level as will not
increase the percentage of the consumers’ retai! ex-

penditures for agricultural commodities, or prod-
ucts derived therefrom, which is returned to the
farmer, above the percentage which was‘ returned

-to the farmer in the _pre-war —— anew 1909-

July 1914.]
(2) To protect the interest of the conswmer by
(a) approaching the level. of prices. which ti is de-

olared to be the policy of Congress to establish in
subsection (1) of this section by gradual correction
of the current level at as rapid-a rate as the Secre-
tary of Agriculture deems to be in the ‘public in-
terest and féasible in view of the current consump-
tive demand in, domestic and foreign markets, and
(b) authorizing no action under this title which has
for its purpose the maintenance of prices to farmers
above the level which it is declared tobe the policy .
of Congress to establish in subsection (1) of this ..
section.’ (U.S. C., Title 7, Sec. 602.) |

> * _ & * : *

* As amended in Sec. 1 (#_and/Sec. 62 of Public No. 320,
74th Cong., Ist Sess., approved August 24, 1935, entitled
“An Act to amend the Agricultural Adjustinent Act, and
for other purposes.” Sec. 62 adds the words “ and potatoes.”

* As amended br Sec. 1 (bbe Public No, 320,'74th Cong.,
Ist Sess.

_’ PART 2—COMMODITY BENEFITS.

vy

ca

__ GENERAL POWERS

". Sec. 8. [In order to effectuate the declared pol-
- dey, the Secretary of Agriculture shall have
powex— | | | J
i)
reductionNin the production for. market, or both,
-of any basic, agricultural commodity, through
agreements with producers or by other voluntary,
methods, and to provide for rental or benefit pay-
ments in connection therewith or upon that ‘part
of the production of any basic agricultural com-
modity required for domestic consumption, in such -
amounts as the Secretary deems fair and reason-
able, to be paid out of any moneys available for.
such payments;‘ and, in the case of suyar -beets
or sugarcane, in the event that it shall be estab-
lished to the satisfaction of the Secretary of Agri-
culture that returns to growers or producers, under
the contracts for the 1933-1934 crop of sugar beets
"or sugarcane, entered into by and between the-
processors and producers and/or growers thereof,
were reduced by reason of the-payment’ of the
processing tax, and/or the,, corresponding: floor-.
‘stocks tax, on sugar beets or sugarcane, in ad&i-
tion to the foregoing rental or benefit payments,
to make such payments, representing in whole or
in part such tax, as the Secretary deems fair and
_ reasonable, to producers who agree, or have, agreed,

‘The remainder of this sentence was added by the Act of
May. 9, 1984, c. 263, 48 Stat. 670, Sec. 14.

EE OE SEN LEN RITE IEE ME TMA TED IES NED

0 provide for reduction in the acreage or — .

_ No. 320, 74th Cong., 1st Sess., and subsections (1) to%€9),_ |

—.

‘

_

7)

5

to participate in the program for reduction in the *
acreage or feduction in the production for market,

or both, of sugar beets or sugarcane. In the case
of rice, the Secretary, in exercising the discretion
conferred upon him by this section to provide for

rental or benefit payments, is directed to provide

in any agreement entered into by. him with any rice

producer pursuant to this section, upon such terms

and conditions as the Secretary deter.nines. will
best effectuate the declared policy of the Act, that

the producer may ‘pledge for production credit in |

whole or in part his right to any rental dr benefit

‘ payments under the terms of such agreement and

that such producer may designate therein a payee
to receive such rental or benefit payments.” Under
regulations of the Secretary of Agriculture re-

oo 2 A. Panili¢ting far tha‘ ctarar fian
Guiring adequate tuciiities bur tie storage OL any

nonperishable agricultural commodity on. the |

farm, inspection and measurement of any such
commodity ‘so stored, and the locking and sealing
thereof, and such other regulations as may be pre-

seribed by the Secretary of: Agriculture ‘for the .

protection of such commodity and for the market-
ing thereof, a reasonable percentage of any benefit

payment may be advanced on any such commodity ~

so stored. In any such case, such deduction may
be miade from the amount of the benefit payment
as the Secretary of Agriculture determines. will
reasonably compensate for the. eost. of inspection

°> This amendment was made by Sec: 7 of Public No. 20,
74th Cong., Ist Sess., approved March 18, 1935, but this
entire subsection (1) was stricken out by Sec. 2 of Public

inclusive, were inserted in lieu thereof.

Lt

\
XG

6

and sealing, but no dedaction may be made for
4

interest.]. , |

(1) Whenever the Secretary of Agriculture has.

reason to believe that:

_ (a), The current average farm price for
any basic agricultural commodity is less than
the fair exchange value thereof, or the aver-

age farm price of such commodfty is likely to”

be less than the fair exchange value thereof
for the. period in which the production of

such commodity during the current or. neat.
‘succeeding marketing year is normally -

marketed, and |

(b) The conditions of and factors relating

to the production, marketing, and consump-
tion of such commodity are such that the
exercise of any one or more of the powers
conferred upon the Secretary under subsec-

tions (2) and (3) of this section would tend —

to effectuate. the declared policy of this title,

‘he shall cause an immediate investigation to be

made to determine such facts. ‘If, upon the basis
of such investigation, the Secretary firs the exist-
ence of such facts, he shall proclaim such deter-
mination and shall exercise such one or more of the

powers conferred upon him under subsections (2)°

and (3) of this section as he finds, upon the basis
of an investigation, administratively practicable
and best calculated to effectuate the declared policy
of this title. * | 5

(2) Subject to the provisions of subsection (1)

. of this section, the Secretary of Agriculture ‘shall

provide, through agreements with producers or by

‘other voluntary methods, °

}

+

‘>

ete, * 7 & ; A
(a) For such adjustment in the acreage or
in the production for market, or both, of any
basic agricultural commodity, as he finds,
upon the basig of the investigation made pur-
suant to subsectiqn .(1) of. this section, will
tend to effectuate the declared policy of this

title, and toghake such adjustment program |

- practicable to ‘Bperate and administer, and
(b) For rental or benefit payments in con-

nection with such agreements or methods in

such amounts as he finds, pon the basis of
such investigation, to be faiy and reasonable
and best calculatedto effectuate the declared
policy of t this title and to e such program
practicable to operate and a inister, to be
phid out of any moneys av le*for such
payments or, subject to the congent of the
producer, to be made in quaniiiies of one or

~ more basic agricultural commodities acquired ‘

by the Secretary pursuant to this title.
(3) Subject to the provisions of subsection (1)
of this section, the Secretary of Agriculture shall
make payments, out of any moneys available for
such payments, in such amounts as he finds, upon
__ the basis of the investigation pursuant to sub-
_ section (1) of this séetion, ae fair and reason-

able and best calculated to on the declared

policy of this title:

(a) To remove from the normal channels
of trade and commerce quantities of any
basic agricuiural .co dity or —
thereof ;

(b) To expand domestiy or sabhies mar-
kets for any basic agricultural commodity or
product thereof ;

29:

~~ = ae -

5
5
;
€
&
=
a
“mt
&
é
¥
4
%
4
4
ig
mn
B
a
g
2

Red
a
%&

Pa Lewy Bie aa eh A Sh Lai kee a A BSR CES ReaD RIMS PS AI Sin aha (a rst a SER RIM

10

of any nonperishable agricultural commodity on
the farm, inspection and measurement of any such
commodity so stored, and the locking and sealing
thereof, and such other regulations as may be pre-
scribed by the Secretary of Agriculture for the pro-

‘tection of such commodity and for the marketing ©

thereof, a reasonable percentage of any benefit pay-
ment may be advanced on any such commodity so
stored. In any such case, such deduction may be
made from the amount of the benefit payment as
the Secretary of Agriculture determines will rea-
sonably compensate for the cost of inspection and
sealing but no deduction may be made for interest.®
* : _* * * -

[(2)] Sec. 8b. [After due notice and oppor- ©
tunity for hearing, to enter into marketing agree-
ments with processors, producers, associations of
producers, and others engaged in the handling of
any agricultural commodity or product thereof, in

_ the current of or in competition with, or so as to
_ burden, obstruct, or in any way affect, interstate

or foreign commerce.’] In order to off ectuate the
declared policy of this title, the Secretary of Agri-
culture shall have the power, after due notice and
opportunity for hearing, to enter into marketing

agreements with processors, producers, associa-

tions of producers, and others engaged in the -
handling of an y agricultural commodity or prod-
uct thereof, only with respect to such handling as
is in the current of interstate or foreign commerce
or which directly burdens, obstructs, or affects

mterstate or foreign commerce in suche com-

® Added by Sec. 2 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong., 1st Sess.
"As amended by the Act of. April 7, 1934, c. 103, 48 Stat.

_ 528, Sec..7.

11

modity or. product thereof The making. of
any ‘such agreement shall not beheld to be in
violation of any of the antitrust laws of the
United States, and avy such agreement shall be
deemed to be lawful: Provided, That ’no such
agreement shall remain in force after the termi-
nation of this Act. For the purpose of carrying
out any such agreement the parties thereto shall
be eligible for loans from the Reconstruction
Finance Corporation under section 5 of the Recon-
struction Finance Corporation Act. Such loans
shall not be in excess: of such amounts as may be
authorized by the agreements. |

v

* » * * *
Sec. 8c.

* * * * *
(16) * * &

(B) The Secretary shall terminate any market-

ing agreement entercd.into under section 8b, or—
order issued under this section, at the end of the.

then current marketing period for such commodity,
specified in such marketing agreement or order,
whenever he finds that such termination is favored
by a,majority of thé producers who, during a rep-
resentative period determined by the Secretary,
have been engaged in the production for market
of the commodity specified in such marketing agree-
ment or order, within the production area specified
in such marketing agreement or order, or who, dur-
ing such representative period, have been engaged
in the production of such commodity for sale within
the marketing area specified in such marketing

agreement or order: Provided, That such majority
® As amended by Sec. 4 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong., 1st

Sess. -

12

have, during such representative period, produced °

a market more than 50 per centum of the volume

such ommodity produced for market within the

production area specified in such marketing agree-

_ ment or order, or have; during such representative

period, produced more than ‘50 per centum of the

volume of such commodity sold in the marketing |

area specified in such marketing agreement or order,
but such termination shail be effective only if ‘an-
nounced on or before such date (prior to the end
of the then current marketing period) as may be

specified in such marketing agreement or order.

*. * * * *
PROVISIONS APPLICABLE, TO AMENDMENTS

(47) The provisions of this section, section 8d,
and section 8e applicable to orders shall be appli-

cable to amendments to orders: Provided, That no-

tice of ahearing upon a proposed amendment to any

order issued pursuant to section'8c, given-not less

than'three days prior to the date. fixed for such hear-,
ing, shall be yleemed due notice thereof.°

° : P o *%

* * * , *
BOOKS AND RECORDS

Sec. 8d. (1) All parties to any marketing agrec-
ment, and all handlers subject to an order, shall
severally, from time to time, upon the request of
the Secretary, furnish him with such information
as he finds to be necessary to enable him to ascer-
tain and determine the extent to which such agree-
ment or order has been carried out or has.effectu-
ated the declared policy of this title, and with
such information as he finds to be necessary to

*As amended by Sec. 5 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong.,
1st Sess.

ORR “

et Sia te ee a
Beanies. Tr ramanr

13

determine whether or not there has been any abuse
of the privilege of exemptions from the antitrust

2 liws. Sueh information shall be furnished wm ac-
: cordance with forms of reports to be prescribed by
? the Secretary. For the purpose of ascertaining
2 the correctness of uny report made to the Secretary
4 ursuant to this subsection, or. for the purpose of
4 : obtaining the information required in any such
4 report, where it has been requested and has not
nf been furnished, the Secretary is hereby authorized

vk to examine such books, papers, records, copies of
income-tax reports,.accounts, correspondence, con-
tracts, documents, .or memoranda, as he deems

Ae wee
pA Onna SW nea a ce

them, and then only in a suit or administrative —
hearing brought at the direction, or upon the re-
) quest, of the Secretary of Agriculture, or to which
5s he or any officer of the United States is a party, |
and involving the marketing agreement or order
with reference to which the information so to be
disclosed was furnished or acquired. Nothing in
_ this section shall be deemed to prohibit (A) the

35128—35—aprp——2

a ME, relevant and which are within the control (1) .of
S any such party to such marketing agreement, or
. any such handler, from whom such report was re-
3 ' “quested or (2) of any person having, either directly .
A or indirectly, actual or legal control of or over such
party or such handler or (3) of any subsidiary of
i. any such party, handler, or person. ae
e (2) Notwithstanding the provisions of section 7,
& all information furnished to or acquired by the
3 - Secretary of Agriculture pursuant to this section
4 shall be kept confidential by-all officers and em-
% ployees of the Department. of Agriculture and only
3 such ‘information so furnished or acquired as the
| Secretary deems ,relevant shall be disclosed by

Lee aN gages
SRR NE) eISSN
Ae ee eet

14

. issuance of generadfstatements based upon the re-

ports of a number of parties to a marketing agree-
ment or of handlers subject to an order, which.
statements do not identify the information fur-
nished by any person, er (B). the publication by
direction of the Secretary, of the naite of axy per-
son violating any marketing agreement or any
order, together with a statement of the particular

provisions of the marketing agreement or order

violated by such person. Any such officer or em- '
ployee violating the provisions of this section shall
upowr conviction be subject to a fine of not more
than $1,000 or to imprisonment for not: more than
one year, or to both, and shall be removed from
el |
aatreanaseaninitate aie OF BASE PERIOD

Sec. 8e. In connection with the making of any

marketing agreement or thé issuance of any order,

tf the Secretaryfinds and proclaims that, as to any

commodity specified in such marketing agreement
or order, the purchasing power during the base |
period specified for such commodity in section 2

of this title cannot. be satisfactorily determined

from available statistics.of the Department of
Agriculture, the base period, for the purposes of
such marketing agreement or order, shall. be the
postwar period, August 1919-—July 1929, or all that
portion thereof for which the Secretary finds. and

proclaims that the purchasing power of such com-

modtty can be satisfactorily determined from avail-
able statistics of the Department of Agriculture. ~

_ [(5)] Sec. 8f." No person engaged in the storage
in a public warehouse of any basic agricultural

10 As ‘amended by Sec. 6 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong.,
Ast Sess.

is
AIC EN AY SPENT SRT ON Er RISEN AG LAS SASSI LTE A BAIN RNID ANS Ue RO NTRS Se tee eed, eh —
°

uo. - a
E - eommodity in the current of interstate or foreign
4 commerce, shall deliver any such. commodity upon
= which a warehouse receipt has been issued and is
. outstanding, without prior surrender and eancella-
tion of such warehouse receipt. Any person vio-
i lating any of the provisions of this subsection shall,
q ~ -apon conviction, be punished by, a fine of not more
: than $5,000, or by imprisonment for not more than
two years, or both. [The Secretary of Agriculture
may revoke any license issued under subsection (3).
of this section, if he finds, after due notice and
opportunity for hearing, that the licensee has vio-
lated the provisions of this subsection.]" (U.S.C.,

Title 7, Sec. 608.) :

: PROCESSING TAX

' SEc. 9. (a) To obtain revenue for extraordinary |
expenses incurred by reason of the national eco-
nomic emergency, there shall be levied processing

* taxes as hereinafter provided. [When the Secre-
tary of Agriculture determines that rental or benefit
payments are to be made with respect to any basic
3 agricultural commodity, he shall proclaim such de-
3 termination, and a processing tax shall be in effect
_-_. with respect to such commodity from the beginning

of the marketing year therefor next following the
date of such proclamation.] When the Secretary
of Agriculture determines that any one or more
payments authorized to be made under section 8 are
to be made with respect to any basic agricultural
commodity, he shall proclaim such determination,
‘and a processing tax shall be in effect with respect to

anne ei alt A aah ete we RA Se wit
.

11 As amended by Sec. 7 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong., |
1st Sess.

s :

such. commodity from the beginning of the market-
ing year therefor next follawing the date of such
proclamation; except that [,] (1) in the case of
sugar beets and sugarcane, the Secretary of Agri-
culture shall, on beta the thirtieth day after the

adoption of this amendment, proclaim that rental or‘
‘ benefit payments with respect tasaid commodities
are to be made, and the processing.tax shall be in
_effect on and after the thirtieth day after the date of
the adoption of this amendment [.], and (2) in the
case of rice the Secretary of Agriculture shall, be-
fore April 1, 1935, proclaim that rental or. benefit
_ payments are to be made with respect thereto, and
the processing tax shall be in effect on and after -
April 1,1935. In the case of sugar beets and sugar-
cane, the calendar year shall be considered to be the
marketing year.and for the year 1934 the marketing
_ yearshall begin January 1, 1934. In the case of
rice, the period from August 1 to July 31, both in-
clusive, shall be considered to be the marketing year.
The processing tax shall be levied, assessed, and col-_
lected upon the first, domestic processing of the com-
' Mmodity, whether of domestic production or im-
ported, and shall be paid by the processor. The
rate of tax shall conform to the requirements of sub- -
section (b). Such rate shall be determined by the
Secretary of Agriculture as of the date the tax first
takes effect, and the rate so determined shall, at
such intervals as the Secretary finds necessary to
effectuate the declared policy, be adjusted by him
to conform to such requirements. The processing
tax shall terminate at the end of the marketing year
current at the timie the Secretary proclaims that’
[rental or benefit payments] all payments author-.

See DOPE NEVE SLED EEL OPE NEAG LOE SH IRENE BE se a REET ON SR RARE I GE ROS MW OS TE OO

Bee Bes

eased

ED bs So Eee
ok te CU Gets
Ree Dee tke

Solie Se ase nei ese abel abicdio n oy ROTA aced Alas Soiree Bre Sa + ¥ .
SPECIFIC TAX RATS —SIE

(3) For the period from April 1, 1935, to July
31, 1936, both inclusive, the processing tax with

respect to rice shall be levied, assessed, collected,

and paid at the rate of 1 cent per pound of rough
rice. ,

ADJUSTMENT OF’ RATE

(6) (A) Any.rate of tax which 1s prescribed im
paragraph (2), (3), (4), or (5) of this subsection or
which is established pursuant to this paragraph (6)
on the processing of any commodity generally or for

- any designated use or uses, or on the processing of -

the commodity in the production of any designated
product or products thereof for any designated use
or uses, shall be decreased (including a decrease to
zero) in accordance with the formulae, standards,
and requirements of paragraph (1) of this subsec-

tion, in order to prevent such reduction in the quan-_

- tity of such commodity or the products thereof do-

mestically consumed as will result in the accumula- .:

‘tion of surplus stocks of such commodity or the
products thereof or in the depression of the farm
price of the commodity, and shall thereafter be im-
creased in accordance with the provisions of para-
graph (1) of this subsection but subject to the pro-
visions of subdivision (B) of this paragraph (6).

‘
ae Bey, Roar Reet ee,
MIT hails ok as oe TERRES Ane eRe ese sey
SERRE SIR IE Se Pyke BEN SOR ;
Se Ae eT ee Ne we i a ie ta

SERN CN ID I ACT ARUN IRE AIRS Cate iyo. 2

BPE TO ODN eS PCIE a

RS LT PR RIE SiR ae NO lt

OS AS heen aa ake.

BARRA ad

22

(B) If the average farm price of any commodity,
the rate of tax on the processing of which is pre-

scribed in paragraph (2), (3), (4), or (5) of this

subsection or is established pursuant to this para-
graph (6), during any ‘period of twelve successive
months ending after July 1, 1935, consisting of the
first ten months of any marketing year and the last
twd-months of the preceding marketing year—

' (2) ts equal to, or exceeds by 10 per centum

or less, the fair exchange value thereof, or,

‘in the case of tobacco, is less than the fair

exchange value by not more than 10 per

centum, the rate of such tax shall (subject

' to the provisions of subdivision (A) of this

paragraph (6)) be adjusted, at the begin-

ning of the next succeeding marketing year,

to such rate as equals 20 per centum of the
fair exchange value thereof.

(tt) exceeds by more than 10 per centum,

but not more than 20 per centum, the fatr ex-
change value thereof, the rate of such tax
shall (subject to the provisions of subdi-
visions (A) of this paragraph (6) ‘be ad-
justed, at the beginning of the next succeed-
ing marketing year, to such rate as equals
15 per centum of the far ee value
thereof. .

(ut) exceeds by more than 20 per centum
the fair exchange value thereof, the rate of
such bax shall (subject to the provisions of
subdivision (A) of this paragraph (6)) be
adjusted, at the beginning of the next suc-
ceeding marketing» year, to such rate as
equals 10 per centum of the fair exchange
value thereof.

~

> ,

x
4
4
a
3

23
(C) Any rate of tax which has been adjusted

pursuant to this paragraph (6) shall remain at

such adjusted rate unless further adjusted or term-
inated pursuant to this paragraph (6), until De-
cember 31, 1937, or until July 31, 1936, in the case.
of rice. : | ;

(D) In accordance with the formulae, standards,
and requirements prescribed in this title, any rate
of tax prescribed im paragraph (2), (3), (4), or
(5) of this subsection or which 4s established pur-
suant to this paragraph (6) shall be increased.

(E) Any tax, the rate of which is prescribed in

paragraph (2), (3), (4), or ©) of this subsection -

or which is established pursuant to this paragraph
(6), sha. terminate pursuant to proclamation as
provided in section 9 (a) of this title or pur-
suant to section 13 of this title. Any such
tax with respect to any basic commodity which
terminates pursuant to proclamation as provided
in section 9 (a) of this title shall again be-
come effective at the rate prescribed in paragraph
(2), (3), (4), or (5) of this subsection, subject,
however to the provisions of subdivisions (A) and
(B) of this paragraph (6), from the beginning of
the marketing year for such commodity neat fol-
lowing the date of a new proclamation by the Sec-
retary as provided in section 9 (a) of this title, if
such marketing year begins prior to December 31,
1937, or prior to July 31, 1936, in the case of rice,
and shall remain at such rate until altered or term-
inated pursuant to the provisions of section 9 or
terminated pursuant to section 13 of this title.

(F) After December 31, 1937 (in-the case of the

commodities specified in paragraphs (2), (4), and’
(5) of this subsection), and after July 31, 1936 (in |

PEE LL ENG SE
— vp

Sa al Ua haat a a aes

.
axed oe

Mite ea taitiel ease OR Te

$a te ATE eto a

0 ER RE RE AS RAMBO ia LBLED SO

Nae

24

the case of rice), rates of tax shall be determined
by the Secretary of Agriculture in accordance with
the formulae, standards, and requirements pre-
scribed. in this title but not in this paragraph (6),
and shall, subject to such formulae, standards, and
requirements, thereafter be effective. °

(G) If the applicability to any person or cir-
cumstances of any tax, the rate of which is fixed -
in pursuance of this paragraph (6), is finally held’
invalid by reason of any provision of the Consti-
tution, or is finally held invalid by reason of the
Secretary of Agriculture’s exercise or failure to
exercise any power conferred on him under this
title, there shall be levied, assessed, collected, and
paid (in leu of all rates of tax fixed in pursuance
of this paragraph (6) with respect to all tax lia-
bilities incurred under this title on or after the
effective date of each of the rates of tax fixed in

pursuance of this paragraph: (6)), rates of tax °°

fixed under paragraph (2), (3), (4);.0r (5), and
such rates shall be in effect (unless the particular
tax is terminated pursuant to proclamation, as pro-
vided in section’9 (a) or pursuant to-section 13)
until altered by Act of Congress; except that, for -
any period prior to the effective date of such hold-
ing of invalidity, the amount of tax which repre-
sents the difference between the tax at the rate
fixed in pursuance of this paragraph (6) and the
tax at the rate fixed under parayraphs (2), (3),
(4), and (5) shall not be levied, assessed, collected,
or paid. | |
RICE—tSPECIAL RULE

(7) In the case of tice, the weight to which the

rate of tax shall be applied shall be the weight of .

rough rice when delivered to a processor, except

o* ; 2 OC
| that, where the producer processes his own rice,
the weight to which the rate of tax shall be applied
shall be the weight of rough rice when delivered to
the place of processing.”
* : * , * * a

[(c) For the purposes of part 2 of this title, the
fair exchange value of a commodity shall be the
price therefor that will give the commodity. the
same purchasing power, with respect to articles
farmers buy, as sueh commodity had during the
base period specified in section 2; and the current
average farm price and the fair exchange value
shall be ascertained by the Secretary of Agricul-
ture from available statistics of the Department
of Agriculture. ]

(c) For the purposes of part 2 of this title, the
fair exchange value of a commodity shall be the
price therefor that will give the commodity the
same purchasing power, with respect. to articles
farmers buy, as such commodity had during the
base period specified in section 2; and, in the case
of all commodities where the base period is the
pre-war period, August 1909 to July 1914, will also
reflect interest payments per acre on farm indebt-
edness secured by real-estate and tax payments per
-acre on farm real estate, as contrasted with such
interest payments and tax payments during .said

. base period; and the current average farm price
and the fair exchange value shall be ascertained
by the Secretary of Agrieulture from available sta-

tistics of the Department of Agriculture. The rate
of tax upon the processing of any commodity, in
effect on the date on which this amendment is

AS amended by Sec. 12 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong.,
1st Sess.

La hea tans angele Deg

Oe CR a RR ay 1h ee ee

26

justed or altered, unless the Secretary of Agricul
ture finds that it is necessary to adjust or alter any
such rate pursuant to section 9 (a) of this title.”

(d) As.used in part 2 of this title—

(1) In case of wheat [, rice,], rye, barley, and
corn, the term ‘‘processing’’ means the milling or
other processing’ (except cleaning and drying) of
wheat [, rice,], rye, barley,* or corn for market,
including custom milling for toll as well as com-
mercial milling, but shall not include the grinding
or cracking thereof not in the form of flour for feed
purposes only.

* * * . * *

(7)-In the case of rice—

(A) The term “‘rough rice’? means rice in that
condition which is usual and customary when
delivered by the producer to a processor.

(B) The term “ processing’? means the cleaning,
shelling, milling (including custom milling for toll
as well as commercial milling), grinding, rolling,
or other processing (except grinding or cracking
by or for the producer thereof for feed for his own
livestock, cleaning by or directly for a producer

- for seed purposes, ard drying) of rough rice; and

in the case of rough rice with respect to which a
tax-payment warrant has been previously issued
or applied for by application then pending, the

17As amended by Sec. 13 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong.,
1st Sess.

18 Sec. 5 of Public No. 20, 74th Cong., Ist Sess., strikes out
the word “ rice”; Sec. 14 (a) of Public No. 320, 74th Cong.,
1st Sess., inserts the words “ rye, barley ”.

. adopted, shall not be affected by the adoption of
this amendment and shall not be required to be ad-

N

27

term “‘processing’’ means any one of the above
mentioned processings or any preparation or
handling in connection with the sale or other dispo-
sition thereof.

(C) The term “cooperating cideinea means

any person (including any share-tenant or share-
- cropper) whom the Secretary of Agriculture finds
to be willing to participate in the 1935 production-
adjustment program for rice.

(D) The term “‘processor’’, as used in subsection
(b-1) of section 15 of this title, means any person
3 (including a cooperative association of producers)
engaged in the processing of rice on a commercial
basis (including custom milling for toll as well as
commercial milling)."° |

[(7)] (8)* In the case of any other commodity,
‘the term ‘‘processing’’ means any manufacturing
or other processing involving a change in the form
_of the commodity or its preparation for distribu-
tion or use, as defined by regulations of the Secre-
tary of Agriculture; and in prescribing such regu-
lations the Secretary shall give due weight to the
customs of the industry.” |

(e) When any processing tax, or increase or de-
crease therein, .takes effect in respect of a com-
modity the Secretary of Agriculture, in order to
prevent pyramiding of the processing tax and
profiteering in the. sale of the products derived

1 Sec. 6 of Public No. 20, ae Cong., 1st Sess., adds para-
graph 7.
20 Sec, 6 of Public No. 20, 74th Cong., st Sess., renum-

bers paragraph “(7)” to “(8).”
*1 As amended by the Act of June 26, 1934, c. . 759, 48 Stat.
1241, Sec. 2.

ABS, «REAR eS a Pach os ye oe a rst
i ae So Poe aaa

eS EI

28

from the commodity, shall make public such in-
formation as he deems necessary regarding (1)
the relationship between the processing tax and
the price paid to producers of the commodity, (2)

sumers of products of the commodity, (3) the re-
lationship, in previous periods, between prices
paid to the producers of the commodity and prices -
to.consumers of the products thereof, and (4) the
- situation in foreign countries relating to prices

id to producers of the commodity and prices to
consumers of the products thereof.

(f) For the purposes of part 2 of this title, proc-
- essing shall be held to include manufacturing”
(U.S. C., Title 7, Sec. 609).

* * * * &
MISCELLANEOUS
*. * * * *

Src. 10. (c) The Secretary of Aavioltare ° is
authorized, with the approval of the President, to
‘make such regulations with the force and effect of
law: as may be necessary to carry out the powers
vested in him by +this title, including regulations
establishing conversion factors for any commodity
and article processed therefrom to determine the
amount of tax imposed or refunds to be made with
respect thereto. Any violation of any regulation
shall be subject to such penalty, not in excess: of
$100, as may be provided therein.

(d) The Secretary of the Treasury is authorized
to make such regulations as may be necessary to
carry out. the powers vested in him by this title.

22 Added by the Act of May 9, 1934, ¢. 263, 48, Staf. 670,
Sec. 6. e

the effect of the processing tax upon prices to con- -_

29

; (e) The action of any officer, employee, or agent —

in determining the amount of and in making any

[rental or benefit payment] payment authorized to

be made under section 8 * shall not be subject to

review by any officer of the Government other than

the Secretary of Agriculture or Secretary of the
Treasury. 4 .

(f) The provisions of this title shall be appli-

cable to the United States and its possessions, ex-

~ eept the Philippine Islands, the Virgin Islands,

American Samoa, tlie Canal Zone, and the island

of Guam; except that, in the case of sugar beets

and sugarcane, the President, if he finds it neces-

sary in order to effectuate the declared policy of

- this Act; is authorized by proclamation to make the

* provisions of this title applicable to the Philippine

ys Islands, the Virgin Islands, American Samoa, the

: ~ Ganal: Zone, and/or the island of Guam. The

President is authorized to attach by Executive

order any or all of such possessions to any internal

revenue collection district for the purpose of carry-

t
|
A

:
“4
i
Ye

qq ing out the provisions of this title with respect to
# the collection of taxes.”

. * * | * x *

i (h) For the efficient administration of the pro-

visions of part 2 of this title, the provisions, in-
3 eluding penalties, of sections 8, 9, and 10 of the
q Federal Trade Commission Act, approved Septem-
; ' - ber 26, 1914, are made applicable to the. jurisdic-

223As amended by Sec. 17 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong.,

1st Sess. ee.
244s amended by Public No. 331, 74th Cong., 1st Sess.,

approved August 26, 1935.
35128—35—app——3

eat Gee >

—_

30

tion, powers, and duties of the Secretary in admin-.

istering the provisions of this title and to any per-
son subject to the provisions of this title, whether
or not a corporation. Hearings authorized or re-
quired under this title shall be conducted by the
Secretary of Agriculture or such officer or em-
ployee of the Department as he may designate for
the purpose. The Secretary may report any vio-
lation of any agreement entered into under part 2
of this title to the Attorney General of the United
States, who shall cause appronriate proceedings to
enforce such agreements to be commenced and
prosecuted in the proper courts of the Wnited
States without delay.

(1) The Secretary of Agriculture upon the re-
quest of the duly constituted authorities of any
State is directed, in order to effectuate the declared
policy of this title and in order to obtain uniformity

— in the formulation, administration, and ‘enforce-

ment of Federal and State programs relating to the
regulation of the handling of agricultural commodi-
ties or products thereof, to confer with and hold
joint hearings with the duly constituted authorities
of any State, and is authorized to cooperate with

- such authorities; to accept and utilize, with the con-

sent of the State, such State and local officers and
employees as may be necessary; to avail himself of

the records and facilities of such authorities; to -
issug, orders (subject to the provisions of section

complementary to orders or other regulations
issued by such authorities; and to make available
to such State authorities the records and facilities
of the Department of Agriculture: Provided, That
information furnished to the Secretary of Agricul-

31
ture pursuant to section 8d (1) hereof shall be made
available only to the extent that such information
is relevant to transactions within the regulatory
jurisdiction of such authorities, and then only upon
a written ayreement by such authorities that the in-
formation so furnished shall be kept confidential by
them in a manner similar to that required of Fed-
eral officers and employees under the provisions of

section 8d (2) hereof * (U.S. C., Title 7, See. 610)..

COMMODITIES

Src. 11.”° As used in this title, the term ‘‘basie
agricultural commodity’? means wheat, rye, flax,
barley, cotton, fiddcorn, grain sorghums, hogs, cat-
tle, rice, potgtoes, tobacco, sugar beets and sugar-
cane, peanuts, and milk ‘and its products, and any
regional or market classification, type, or grade
thereof; but the Secretary of Agriculture shall ex-
clude from the operation of the provisions of this
title, during*any period, any such commodity or
classification, type, or grade thereof if he finds,

upon investigation at any time and after due no-.

tice and opportunity for hearing to interested
parties, that the conditions of production, market-
ing, and consumption are such that during such
period this title cannot be effectively administered

to the end of effectuating the declared policy with —

respect to such commodity or classification, type,

»

or grade, thereof. As used in this title, the term
**notatoes’’ means all varieties of potatoes included

**Added by Sec. 18 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong., 1st Sess.

© As amended by the Act of April 7, 1934, c. 108, 48 Stat.
528, Secs. 1, 3, 4, 5; and by the Act of May 9, 1934, c. 263, 48
Stat. 670, Sec. 1. |

aT eee F P !
| ee SRR Bony ie dee PLN DOM ae MS

32

vn . the species Solanum tuberosum ok iP S. C., Title

7, See. ae

APPROPRIATION

tec: 12. (a) There is hereby appropriated, out
of any money in the Treasury not otherwise appro-
priated, the sum of $100,000,000 to be available to
the Secretary of Agriculture for administrative
expenses under this titte and for [rental and bene-
fit payments made with respect to reduction in

-acreage or reduction in production for market

under part 2 of this title] payments authorized to
be made under section 8. Such sum shall remain
available until expended.

To enable the Secretary of Agriculture to fi-
nance, under such terms and conditions as he may
prescribe, surplus reductions and productions ad-
justments with respect to the dairy- and beef-cattle
industries, and to carry out any of the purposes
described in subsections (a) and-(b) of this section
(12) and to support and balance the markets for
the dairy and beef cattle industries, there is au-
thorized to be appropriated, out of any money in
the Treasury not otherwise appropriated, the sum
of $200,000,000: Provided, That not more than 60

. per centum of such amount shall be used for either

of such industries.”
(b) [In addition to the foregoing, the proceeds
derived from all taxes imposed under this title are

‘ ?7As amended by Sec. 61 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong.,
1st Sess.

*>As amended by Sec. 19 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong.,
Ist Sess.
*° Added by Act of April. 7 * 1934, c. 103, 48 Stat. 528,

Sec. 2.

See ee or ee ee ne Eee he ee ces .
- . .
A °
fixe
‘

4

=

hereby appropriated to ih available to the Secre- —

tary of Agriculture for expansion of markets and
removal of surplus agricultural products and the
following purposes under part. 2 of. this title:
Administrative expenses, rental and benefit pay-
ments, and refunds on taxes.] In addition to .the
foregoing, for the purpose of effectuating the de-
clared policy ofthis title, a sum equal to the pro-
ceeds derived from all taxes imposed under. this
title is hereby appropriated to be available to the
Secretary of Agriculture for (1) the acquisition

of any agricultural commodity pledged as security

for any loan made by any Federal agency, which
loan was conditioned upon the borrower agreeing
or having agreed to cooperate with a program of
’ production adjustment or marketing adjustment
adopted under the authority of this title, and (2)
the following purposes under part 2 of this title:
Administrative expenses, payments authorized to
be made under section 8, and refunds on taxes.”
The Secretary of Agriculture and the Secretary of
the Treasury shall jointly estimate from time to
time the amounts, in addition to any money avail-
able under subsection (a), currently required for
such purposes; and the Secretary of the Treasury
shall, out of any money in the Treasury not other-
wise appropriated, advance to the Secretary of
Agriculture the amounts so estimated. The amount

of any such advance shall be deducted from such .

tax proceeds as shall subsequently become available
under this subsection.

°°As amended by Sec. 3 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong.,
1st Sess,

a
y
a
oe.
te
f
£
E

*s
ad
it

Or ig a eek vie

©
— .
=
A=
5.
C
tg
pa
Re
ay
i
# *
&.
a
'
'
ie
a,
é

:
alia iailiaeiailaditaaienitaaa ——

34

Udid SRO a

(c) The administrative expenses provided for
. under this section shall include, among others, ex-
penditures for personal services and rent in the
District of Columbia and elsewhere, for law books
and books of reference, for contract stenographic
reporting services, and for printing and paper in
addition to- allotments under the existing law.
The Secretary of Agriculture shall transfer to the
Treasury Department, and is authorized to trans-
fer to other agencies, out of funds available for .
administrative expenses under this title, such sums
as are required to pay administrative expenses in-
curred and refunds made by such department or
agencies in the administration of this title (U. 8.
C., Title 7, Sec. 612).

TERMINATION OF ACT ”

Sec. 13. This title shall cease to be in effect when-
ever the President finds and proclaims that the
national economic emergency in relation to agricul-
ture has been ended; and pending such time the
President shall by proclamation terminate with
respect to any basic agricultural commodity such
provisions of this title as he finds are not requisite
to carrying out the declared policy with respect to
such commodity. In the case of sugar beets and
sugarcane, the taxes provided by this title shall
cease to be in effect, and the powers vested in the
President or in the Secretary of Agriculture shall
terminate [at the end of three years after the adop-
tion of this amendment] on December 31, 1937,"
unless this title ceases to be in effect at an earlier

“ea

58

the total quantity of any article which may be im-
ported ] from any country which reduces such per-
missible total quantity to less than 50 per centum
of the average annual quantity of ‘such article
which was imported from such country during the
period from July 1, 1928, to June 30, 1933, doth
dates inclusive.

(c) No import restriction inital by the
_ President. under this section nor any revocation,
suspension, or Modification thereof shall: become
effective until fifteen days after the date of such
proclamation, roveoation, vagyennon, or _ modifi-
cation. |

(d) Any decision of the resident as to facts
under this section shall be final.

(e) After investigation, report, finding, and
declaration in the manner ‘provided in the case of a
— proclamation issued pursuant to subsection (b) of
this section, any praclamation or provision of such
proclamation may be suspended by the President
whenever he finds that the circumstances requiring
the proclamation or provision thereof no longer
exist, or may be modified by the President when- .
ever he finds that changed circumstances. require
_ such modification to carry out the purposes of this
section.“ :
| REvIseD STATUTES

wie. 3210, [As amended by Sec. 1031 (b) of the
Revenue Act of 1924, c. 234, 43 Stat. 253.] (a) Ex-
cept as provided in subdiwsfon (b) the. gross
amount of all taxes and revenues received under
the provisions of this Act, and collections of what-

** Added by Sec. 81 of Public No. 320, 74th Cong., 1st Sess.

_—t

_the depositor and t

ever nature received or collected, by authority of
any, internal-revenue law, shall be paid daily into
the Treasury of the United States under instruc-
tions of the Secretary of the Tr@asury as internal-
revenue collections, by the officer receiving or col-
lecting ‘the same, without any abatemént or deduc-
tion on account of salary, compensation, fees, costs,

claims of any. description.
ayment, stating the name of
specific account oy which the
deposit was made, signed by the treasurer, assist-

charges, expenses, |
A certificate of su

ant treasurer, designated depositary, or proper> |

officer of a deposit bank, shall be trahsmitted to the

‘Commissioner of Internal Revenue.

* os * a * | 7

(U. S. C., Title 26, See. i761.)

SEC. 3220. [As amended by See. 1111 of the Rev-
enue Act of 1926, c. 27, 44 Stat, 9, and Sec. 619 of
the Revenue Act of 1928, ec. 852, 45 Stat. 791.] ~ Ex-
cept as otherwise provided by law in the case of
income, war-profits, excess-profits, estate, and gift

the‘Treasury, is authorized to remit,-refund, and

pay back all taxes erroneously or illegally assessed.
or collécted, all penalties collected without author-.

ity, and all taxes that appear to be unjustly ‘as-
sessed or excessive in amount, or in any manner
wrongfully collected; also to repay to any collector
or deputy collector the full amount of such sums

_ of money as may be recovered against him in any

court, for any internal-revenue taxes collected by

him, with the cost and expenses of suit; also all —
damages and costs recovered against any assessor,

/

_ taxes the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, sub--
ject to regulations prescribed by the Secretary of -

eae

60

assistant assessor, collector, deputy collector, agent,

or inspector, in any suit brought against him by °

reason of anything done in the -lue performance
of his official duty, and shall make report to Con-
gress at the beginning of each regular session of
Congress of all transactions under this section
(U.S. C., Title’ 26, Sec. 1670). ae

SEC. 394. No suit for the purpose of restraining
the assessment or collection of any tax shall be
maintained in any court (U. 8. C., Title 26, See.
1543).

Sec. 3226. TAs amended by Sec. 1103 of the Rev-
enue Act of 1932, c. 209, 47 Stat. 169.] No suit
or proceeding shall be maintained in any court for

_._ the recovery of any internal-revenue tax alleged |

to have been crroncously or illegally assessed or
collected, or of any penalty claimed to have been
collected without authority, or of any. sum alleged
to haye been excesSive or in any manner. wrontt-

. fully collected until a claim for refund or ‘credit -

has been duly filed with.the Commissioner of In-
- ternal Revenue, according to the provisions of law

in that regard, and the regulations of the Secretary.

of the Treasury established in pursuance thereof ;
‘but such suit.or proceeding may be maintained,
whether or not such tax, penalty, or sum has been

paid under protest or duress. No such suit or pro-
ceeding shall be begun before the expiration of six.

months from the date of filing such claim unless
the Commissioner renders a decision thereon
within ‘that time, nor after the expiration of two
“years from the date of mailing by registered mail
by the Commissioner to the taxpayer of a notice

of the’ disallowance of the part of the claim to

«61
Tl which such suit. or proceeding’ relates (U. g, C.,
4 Title 26, Secs, 1672-1673).
«Sec, 3228. [As amended by Sec. 1112 of the

. .. ‘Revenue Act of 1926, Sec. 619 of the Revenue Act
| of 1928, and Sec. 1106 of the Revenue Act of 1932.]

(a) All claims for the refunding or crediting .of
any internal-revenue tax alleged to have been er-
i -roneously or illegally assessed or collected, or of
. any penalty alleged to have been collected with-
~ out authority, or of any sum alleged to have been ‘
; - excessive or in any manner wrongfully collected
ss must, except as otherwise provided by Jaw in the
: case of income, war-profits, excess-protits, estate,
i aud gift taxes, he presented td the Commissioner
or Internal Revenue within four years next after
, the payment ‘of such tax, penaity, or sum. ‘ihe
amount of the refund (in the case of taxes other
than income, war-profits, excess-profits, estate, and
gift taxes) shall not exceed the portion of the tax,
penalty, or sum paid during the four years im-
mediately preceding the filing of the claim, or if
no claim was filed, then during the four years. im-
-mediately preceding the allowance of the refund.
a ot Sie a

(U.S. C., Title 26, Sec. 1433. ) oe

_ Revenve Act or 1926, c. 27, 44 Srat..9 |
| {TITLE VI—EXCISE TAXES |

Src. 600. There shall\be_Yevied, assessed, col- -
lected, and paid upon the following articles sold
or leased by the manufacturer, producer, or im-
porter, a tax equivalent to the following percentage
of the price for which so sold or leased—

- . ~ * sae

- 35128—35—aPrp—5

Src, 602, Every person liable for any tax im-
“posed. by section 600 shall make monthly returns

- .,.under oath in duplicate and pay the taxes imposed

ch section to the collector for the district in

ns shall contain such information and
. be made at sych times.and in such manner as. the
Commissioner, with the approval pf the mecretary,
may : regulations prescribe.

The ‘tax shall, without assessment by the Com-
missioner or notice from the collector, be due and
payable to the colléctor at the time so fixed for filing
the return. If the tax is not paid when due, there
. shall be added as part of the tax interest atthe rate

‘lecated the principal place. of business.

f i per centum a month from the time when the ©

teat became dué until paid (U.S. C., Title 26, Sees.
1121, 1122).

TiTtLE XI—GENERAL - ADMINISTRATIVE PROVISIONS
Laws MADE APPLICABLE |

SEC. 1100. All administrative, special, or sees
‘provisions of law, imcluding the law relating to the
assessment of taxes, so far as applicable, are h eby
extended to and made: a part of this Act ind 8. C.,
Title 26, Sec. 440). °

REVENUE Act oF 1982, c. 209, 47 Svar. 169

Sc. 626. RETURN AND PAYMENT OF MANUFACTUR-
ERS’ TAXES,

(a Every person liable for any tax lacie by
this fitle other than taxes on importation (except

tax ynder section 615, relating to tax on soft drinks) |

‘shafNnake monthly returns under oath in duplicate

‘and pay the taxes imposed by this tithe to the col- ©

. ‘
gtd Ona EE eR Bk Oe Pkt Kee SPAIN Bry ict ecto Rae

lector for the district in which is located his princi- |
pal place of business or,-if he has no prineipal place
of business: in the United States, then to the col-
lector at Baltimore, Maryland. Such returns shall »
o- contain such information and be made at such times
and in such manner as the Commissioner, with the.
approval of the Secretary, may. by regulations
prescribe. peor
(b) The tax Mall, without assessment ‘by the
Commissioner or notice from the‘ collector, be due |
* and payable to the collector at the time so fixed. for
‘filing the return. If the tax is not paid when due, -
there shall be added as part of the tax interest at
the rate of 1 per centim-a month from the time |
when the. tax became due until paid. |

rs

ma

. . ne -
PRIMO NO SL) Sat aan Ng! Ie URE PERN CARS See aera tnaRnan mann aemaaraY

PART B |
REGULATIONS 83 (SEPTEMBER, 1934, ED.), o. IT

Art. 2, Scope of chapter—The provisions of this

chapter apply to the procedure to be followed in

order to ‘obtain a refund of the dmount of tax
which -has been paid with respeet to a product ex-
ported to a foreign country.

Art. 3. Claim for refund.—(a) The claim for re-

fund shall be executed by the claimant on the pre-

_. seribed form, P. T. Form 27, in accordance with
the instructions. contained thereon, and in accord- .

ance with these regulations. The claim must be

_ filed with the collector for. the district in which is

located the principal place of business of the claim-
ant. If the claimant has no principal place of

' business in ‘the United States, the claim must be

filed with the collector at Baltimore, Md. One
claim may cover a number of export shipments.

The party named as consignor in the bill of lading ©

under which a product is exported shgll be entitled

to the refund unless the exporter shall have re- .

served the right to refund, and the bill of lading
bears the proper disclaimer by the consignor. « ..
(b) Each claim for refund shall show with re-

spect ‘to each export shipment (1) the serial num- *

ber given by the collector of customs to the appli-

_eation for inspection (article 4), and the name of
' the port where filed (mail exportations excepted,

see article 11), (2) the number and kind of pack-
ages, (3) the actual ‘net weight of each product

exported, together with such a description of the

product as will enable the Commissioner to apply

the proper rate of tax, (4) the quantity of the com-

modity in-each product with respect to whith claim
(63)

*

is-made hat tax was paid, (5) the rate of tax ap-
plicable thereto as determined by the conversion
factor established in regulations of the Secretary

oof Agriculture, and (6) the amount of refund

elaimed thereon. .
. (c) In the'case of a shipment other than by mail,

‘a copy of the export bill of lading required with

respect to such shipment shall be filed with each |

and shall be deemed a part thereof.. In the
ease of exportation by mail, the executed. applica-
tion for inspection, as provided in article'11, must
be filed with the claim and’ will be deemed a part,
thereof. 4

(d) Each claim shall be supported by teat satis-

factory to the Commissioner that the tax, refund
of which is claimed, was actually paid to a collector —
of internal revenue,

‘TREASURY DECISION 4586, INTERNAL REVENUE BUL-
LETIN, VoL. XIV, No. 37, P. 15 2

i XIV-37-7696. T. D; 4586
PROCESSING TAX AND COMPENSATING TAX WITH RE- ~

- SPECT TO RICE. UNDER THE AGRBUULEURAL, ADJ UST-
. MENT ACT, AS AMENDED | ’

TREASURY DEPARTMENT, 3
OFFICE OF COMMISSIONER
OF INTERNAL REVENUE,
Washington, D.C.

| Collectors of Internal Revenue and Others Con-

’ cerned:
ParaGRAPH A. Section 9. (a), Agricultural Ad-

justment Act, as amended by the Act approved
’ .March 18, 1935, provides; in part:

* * * When the Secretary of Agricul-
ture determines teat rental or benefit pay-

Wy

66 7 } :

ments are to be made with respect to any
basic agricultural commodity, he shall pro--
claim such determination, and a processing
tax shall be in effect with respect to such
commodity from the beginning of the mar-
keting year therefor next following the date
of such proclamation; except that * * *
in the case of rice, the Secretary of Agricul-
ture shall, before April 1, 1935, proclaim that
rental or benefit payments are to be made ?
with respect thereto, and the processing tax: i)

. shall be in effect on and after April 1, 1935.

* * In the case of rice, the period from |

ates 1 to July 31, both inclusive, shall be .
considered to be the marketing vn * * *

Par. B. A proclamation of the Acting Secretary
of Agriculture, dated March 18, 1935, provides:

* * * JT, M. L. Witson, Acting Secre- —
tary of Agriculture of the United States of
America, have determined and hereby pro-
claim. that rental and/or benefit payments
are to be made with respect to rice, a basic |
agricultural commodity. , |

Par. C. Section 9(b) of the Agricultural Adjust- |
ment Act, as amended, provides in part: |

(3) For the period from April 1, 1935, to
July 31, 1936, hoth inclusive, the processing
tax with respect to rice shall be levied, as-
sessed, collected, and paid at the rate of 1
cent per pound of rough rice.

(7) In the ‘case of rice, the weight to
which the rate of tax shall be applied shall
be the weight of rough rice when delivered
to a processor, except that, where the pro-
ducer processes his own rice, the weight to
which the rate of tax shall be applied shall
be the weight of rough rice when delivered
to the place of processing.

get | 67

Par. D. Section 9 (d) of the Agricultural Ad-
justment Act, as amended, provides jn part:
(7) ie the case of rice
(A) The term ‘“‘rough rice’” means rice in
that condition which is usual and customary
when delivered by the ‘producer to a pove-
essor.
AB) Ths Were ‘+ palideesing” means the
cleaning, shellimg, milling (including custonr
, milling for toll as well as commercial mill- ,
- . ing), grinding, rolling, or other processing
7 (except grinding or cracking by or for the
* producer thereof for feed for his own live-
stock, cleaning by or directly for a producer
/ for seed purposes, and drying) of rough
rice; and in the case: of rough rice with
respect to which a-tax-payment warrant had
been previously issued or applied for by
application then ‘pending, the term ‘‘proc-
essing’ means~any one of the above-men-
tioned processings or any preparation or
handling in connection with the sale or other

- disposition thereof. a 7
(D) The term ‘‘processor’’, as used in sub- aN |
section (b-1)* ’ =
° ‘2

78

The exemption under subdivision (3) does
not apply if (a) a tax-payment warrant has
been issued, or (b) a tax-payment warrant
has been applied for by application then
pending, with respect to such rough rice,
and such rice is prepared or handled in con-
nection with a sale or other disposition
thereof.

When rough rice is (1) processed for the
producer thereof, for consumption by his
family, employees, or household, or (2)
ground or cracked for the producer thereof,
for feed for hgs own livestock, or. (3)
cleaned directly for the producer for seed
purposes, if the above exemption with re-

-spect thereto applies, the processor shall
procure at the time of delivery of the prod-
uct an affidavit or certificate in duplicate on
P. T. Form 29-A. One copy of such affi-
davit or certificate shall be kept on the
premises of the processing plant, and the
other shall be filed by the processor with his
monthly return on P. T. Form 5,. on which
deductions are taken for such’ processing,

- grinding, cracking, or cleaning.

(d) The form prescribed for return of
processing tax is P. T. Form 5. The return
for each month shall be filed on or before
the last day of the month following the eal-

-endar month in which the processing is
done. The amount of tax shown to be due
on each such return must be paid at the

time when the return is filed, or if the time
for payment be postponed, then at the time
or times designated for payment in such
postponement.

(e) Each person engaged in the- process-
ing of rice shall keep a written record show-
ing with respect to rough rice (1) the quan-

79

tity on hand at the beginning of the month,
(2) the quantity received during the month,
(3) the quantity shipped or delivered dur-
ing the month, (4) the quantity sold or
otherwise disposed of during the month, (95)
the quantity on hand at the end of the month,

and (6) the quantity put in process during’

the month. These quantities must be the
actual weight of the rough rice when de-

livered to the processor, or when delivered~

to the place of processing if the processor
is also the producer.

Arr. 3. Compensating tax on -imported
articles—A compensating tax became effec-
tive at the earliest moment of April 1, 1935,
with respect to all articles processed.or man-
ufactured wholly or partly from rice im-
ported on and after said date, into the
United States or any possession thereof to
which the Act applies, from any foreign
country or any possession of the United
States to which the Act does not apply. The
amount of compensating. tax payable with
respect to an imported article is based on
the rate in effect with respect to such article
at the time of importation and not.the rate
in effect at the time of the withdrawal- of
such article from customs custody or con-
trol. The tax applicable to such articles is
given in article 4 of these regulations. De-
tailed regulations as to this tax are contained
in Chapter IV of Regulations $1, as amended
by Treasury Decision 4501, approved De-
cember 4, 1934 [C. B. XITI-2, 524].

Art. 4. Rates of compensating tax or of

She

refund.—_-(a) The rates of compensating tax .

or of refund with respect to articles proc-

essed wholly or partly from rice are as fol-

lows:

.
st Dundas dah a CS RC

. Fermented beverages:

80

(1): In the case of an article named be-
low, the rate is: |

Rate of tax or

Classification of refund

(cents)

Per pound
CET, a Se ee Py ee Os eee 1.00
ee NOMI ogo See tes oo os ota eaes be wctieeocat oe 1.01
PE SO Re ire ee ene ee eee ee ee eae 1.30
Lb | Sa ee rs TE i oars ERR Nt Pa Renae eee 1. 30

Milled rice:

NOE NG ec stcudcw «kaesedo sew sasccevnesussubcux . 75
ee ee ea eee 1.45
SENT 6 ee RE SSE ard 10 ee ae ea ae .75
Ue Sai ES Renee eee nese SD, nia eterno aaa ee 75
RUM rte ee tab eae cout cw etasswestosuscucs 2.15
Mice powder... =. ono sn cence SEPA STE Dean ee 2 hula) ere eee yy 2.15

Rice breakfast feods:

(a) Rolled or flaked types, consisting chiefly Ortiee........-. oe 1.78
(b) Puffed type, consisting chiefly of rice--__....._..__.---- a 3.77
Lak SESS Recs RU, sees let Arey ee ena eee Y 09

(a) Beer, if made from materials of which rice cinntitneted, by | Per barrel of

weight: ! 31 gallons
Over Yio percent and not over 10 percent__---.--___--__.- 3.10
Over 10 percent and not over 15 percent_-._._---__---___- 5. 04
Over 15 percent and not over 20 percent... ----.-------.- 6.97
Over 20 percent and not over 25 percent -_._-__--___-_--.- 8.91
Over 25 percent ard not over 30 percent___.....________.- 10. 84
Over 30 percent and not over 35 percent__._.._...______.- 12.78
Over 35 percent and not over 40 percent___._.____._____.- 14. 71
Over 40 percent and not over 45 percent..__.._.._.__.___- 16. 65

Oe oT Ree aE ARE ER, Meee ee 18.59 ~

. . ‘ Per gallon
RO) EetCes WiNNG On SHINS 8c 3s ie te hn seca 8. 87
Ve Se eee Be SRR ate ene ES ae 5 30.0

! Exclusive of water added during the manufacturing process.

(2) In the case of an article not named in’

(1) above, part of which was made directly
or indirectly from an article named in (1)
above, the rate of tax or of refund with re-
spect to such part shall be the rate for the
named article from which such part was
made ; and, if such part was made indirectly
from an article named in (1) above, and
directly from another article named in (1)
above, the rate of tax or of refund shall be
the rate for the named article from which
such part was directly made. . For example,

‘
&
+4
e
‘

aR ane eran,

81

if such part was made from milled rice, the
rate of tax or of refund with respect to such
part is the rate for milled rice.

(3) In the case of an article not named in
(1) above, part of which was made directly
or indirectly from rice, but not as to such
‘part directly or indirectly from an article
named in (1) above, the amount of tax or of
refund shall be equivalent to the amount of
tax on the processing of such quantity of
rough rice as was actually used in the pro-
duction of such part. :

(b) In the event that the Commissioner of

Internal Revenue finds,.or any taxpayer, or

any. person entitled to a refund, establishes,
that an article processed from rice, with re-
spect to which a tax is imposed, or which may
be the subject of a claim-for refund, which

is included in the above list, contains more |

_ or less rice content than represented by the
conversion factor prescribed therefor in
paragraph F (4), above, then the amount of
tax or of refund shall be equivalent to the
amount of tax on the processing of such
quantity of rough rice as is shown to have
been actually used in the production of the
article. |

.(c) Any refund or credit of tax, made

pursuant to the provisions of section 15 (c)
or any refund made under the provisions of
section 17 (a) of the Act, as amended, shall
be made only on the following basis:

(1) If the tax paid was a compensating
tax, the amount of refund shall be the
amount of tax actually due and paid with
respect to the particular product delivered
or exported.

(2) If the tax paid was a processing tax,
the amount of refund shall be determined in
accordance with the rate of processing tax
.in effect at the time of the first domestic

‘
3
E
Pi
e
3

i
:

82

processing of ricé from which the delivered —

of exported product was processed and in
accordance with the proper conversion fac-
tor in effect at the time the product was
delivered or exported. .

No refund under the provisions.of section
17 (a) of the Act, as amended, will be made
with respect to articles processed from rice
which are exported unless it is shown that
the tax with respect to such articles was
actually paid in cash or by the tender of tax-
payment warrants. No refund under the
provisions of section 15 (c) of the Act, as
amended, will be made with respect to
articles processed from rice delivered for

charitable distribution’ or use unless it is:

shown that the tax with respect to such
articles was actually paid in cash.

Claims for such refunds shall be: sup-
ported by the affidavit of the processor show-
ing when the processing occurred: which re-
sulted in the particular rice product ex-
ported or delivered, and when the tax was
paid to the collector. If the claim is made
under the provisions of section 15 (c) of the
Act, as amended, such affidavit must show
that the tax was paid i in cash. The affidavit
of the processor must also show the quantity
and kind of product sold, the name and
address of the person to whom delivered, and
date of delivery. The claim shall also be
supported by the affidavit of each person to
whom such rice product is subsequently de-
livered, showing the quantity and kind of

_ product received, the name and address of -

the person from whom received, and date of
receipt, and to whom all or part thereof was

delivered, the quantity and kind delivered, .

the name and address of the person to whom
delivered, and the date of delivery. These
affidavits must trace such product from the
processor to the person who files the claim.

¥,
9
+
a.
i 3
bs
bs
'

83

Art. 5. Forms.—To insure the proper re-
turn and collection of the processing tax
imposed by the Act, and to facilitate the re-
fund of taxes, certain forms are herein pre-
scribed. The prescribed form.must be used
as required by the applicable provision of
Regulations 81, Regulations 83 (September,
1934, edition), and these regulations, and
must be carefully filled out in exact accord-
ance with the applicable provisions of the
proper regulations and the instructions con-
tained on such form. The following forms
with respect to rice are here prescribed :

Form No. Designation Required by—
DP. T, PRR Gi ccaccee Processing tax Ec lweses Regulations 81, article
; : : Bi.
P. T. Form O......
The discount for Sightly Seedy iat rice under
rough rice containing not more than 0.1 percent of
weed seeds shall be 3 percent of the selling price
per barrel. |
The discount for Seedy ona rice under Slightly

Seedy rough rice shall be 4) wine of the selling

price per barrel. |
The diseount for Very Reedy rough riee under

Seedy rough rice shall be 0.1 percent “of the selling

_' price per barrel for. each 0.1 percent of weed sgeds
. in excess of the percent of weed seeds allowed for

the designation Seedy.
In case a lot, or part of a lot, of rough rice is, of:

a quality more than one grade, or more than one

special, designation, below the quality, of the. rice
sold, the discount for the lot or part of lot, as the
ease may be, shall be the accumulated discount be-
tween the quality of the rice sold and the quality
of the inferior lot or part of lot:
For the factor Chalky Kernels:

The discount for Slightly Chalky rough rice

under rough rice containing not more than 3 per- -

cent of ‘chalky kernels shall be 2 2 percent of the
selling price = barrel. :

*

“

. 4
/

The discount for Chalky ‘rough rice under ©

Slightly Chalky rough rice shall be 3 percent of the
selling price per barrel.

TheAiscount for Very Chalky ona rice under
Chalky rough rice shall be one-half of 1 percent
of the selling price per barrel for each full 1; per-

cent of chalky kernels in excess of the percent of

chalky kernels allowed for the designation Chalky.
In case a lot, or part of a lot, of rough rice. is

of a quality more than one ‘grade, or more than .

_ one special designation, below the quality. of the

Tice sold, the discount for -the lot or part of lot,

as the case may be, shall be the accumulated dis-
count between the quality of the rice sold and the
quality of the inferior lot or part oflot. . = ~™
For the factor Muddy Kernels and Mud Lumps:

The discount for Slightly Muddy rough rice
under rough rice containing not more than 1 per-
cent of muddy kernels and nut more than 0.1 per-
- eent of mud lumps shall be 3 percent of the selling
price per barrel.

The discount for. Muddy rough rice under
Slightly Muddy rough rice shall be 5 percent of the
_ selling price per barrel.

The discount. for-Very Muddy rough rice under me
Muddy rough rice shall be 0.1 percent of thé selling ©

price per barrel for each 0.1 percent of mud lumps

or each full 1 percent of: muddy kernels in excess.
. of the percent of mud lumps or percent of muddy

‘kernels allowed for the designation Muddy.

In case a lot, or part of a lot, of rough rice is of
a quality more than one grade, or more than one
special designation, below the quality of the rice

sold, the discount for the lot or part of lot, as the |

Ny
5

case may be, shall be the accumulated discount be-

. Tennessee, entered

‘of 162 pounds. of number 1 prime milling quality

: rauch rieas as foliows: Early Proli ifie 9.75:

$3.15; Edith $3. 40; Fortuna $3. 45 ; Rexoro $3.50.

%. HT

Fel

tween the quality of the rice sold and the quality
of the inferior lot or part of lot.

_ APPENDIX

I, Henry A. Wallace, Secretar¥ of Agtdane of
the United States of America, acting under the
Agricultural Adjustment Act, approved: May 12,
1933, as amended, an purstant to Article 4, See-
tion 2 of the Markeiing Agreement for rice milled
in the States of s, Arkansas, Louisiana’ and
by certain ricg millers in
the States of Texas, Arkansas, Louisiana and Ten-
nessee, and the Secretary of Agriculture, effective
October 16, 1933, do hereby fix the price per barrel

ough
Japan $2.85; Blue . Rose $3. 15; Lady ° Wright

In witness whereof I have hereunto set my hand
and thé official seal of the Department of Agricul-
ture affixed in the City of Washington, District of
Columbia, on this 14th day of October, 1933.° _
—_——-— _H, A, WaLLacs;———*_—

Secretary of Agriculture.

.

PART K

bd
.

“Statistical Data Compiled from Department of

‘gdotine Reports, showing Monthly Farm Prices

of Louisiana Rice and Wholesale Price of Clean, .
Fancy Blue Rose Rice (Tables I, II, and III):

Tame 1.—Monthly Farm Prices of Louisiana Rice, 19238 to Date*

[In Dollars Per Barrel)
- «
Year Aug. | Sept.| Oct. | Nov. | Dec. | Jan. | Feb. | Mar.| Apr. | May | June} July :
‘- \
1923-24"... 3.71 | 3.89 | 4.00 | 3.85 |.3.82| 3.96 | 4.00 | 3.89 | 4.03 4.68 | 4.86 | 4.93
11924-25.....- 4.75 | 4.64 | 4.61 | 4.72 | 5.08 | 5.18 | 5.08 | 5.00 | 4.97 | 511 | 5.36 | 5.40
"1925-26. ... 5.26 | 5.15 | 5.18 | 5.47 | 5.51 | 5.54 |°5.40 | B15 | 4.72 | 4.03 | 5.08) 5.26
1926-27... ._. 4.43 | 4.25 | 4:03 | 3.92 | 3.74 | 3.85 | 3.89 | 3.74 | 3.78 | 3.74] 3.76 | 3.74
wonr-ce..2 isliaizicsiasw!tecslsotaswisal ssi Sai Sssi sss
1928-29. __._. 3.20 | 3.06 | 4.20 | 3.28 | 3.42 | 3.38 | 3.42 | 3.46 | 3.31 3. 35 |, 3. 38 | 3, 38
1929-30... 3.53 | 3.56 | 3.53 | 3.46 | 3.53 | 3.56 | 3.85 | 3.71 | 3.85 | 3.82) 3.745 3.56
1990-31-_...- 3.17 | 2.88 | 2.95.] 2°74 | 2.63 | 2.74 | 2.81 | 274 | 2.77 | 2.66 | 266) 2.63
1931-32__.... 2.02 | 1.69 | 1.84 | 2.16 | 2.12 | 2.02 | 1.91 | 1.87 | 1.76] 1.76) 1.73 | 1.66
1932-33.....- 1,69 | 1.48 | 1.48 44.| 1.44 | 1.37 | 1.30 | 1.44] 1.51 | 2.02 | 2.02 2.20
133-34...8_.| 2.23.} 2.45 | 2.77 | 2.74 2.70, | 2.74 | 2.84 | 2.84 | 2.84 | 2.74 2.77 | 2.70
+ 1934-35_...-- 2.84 | 2.52 | 2.77 | 2.95 | 2.81 | 2.77] 2.95 | 3.06 | 3.10 | 3.13 | 3.24] 3.17 -
1935-36.....- re aie, Abo CS) a ne Ee Pe a Fen eee enone
seo

1 Avérage spot prices, as of the 15th of the month.

Source: Bureau of Crop Estimates, United States Department of ‘Agriculture, data from
August 1923-November 1934, published‘in December 1934 in Crops and Markets. Subsequent
data published December 11, 1935, in Average Prices Received by Louisiana Farmers for

«, Rice (Rough) September, 1934 to date.- These quotations are published in terms of “cents
per bushel’? of 45 pounds and have mee converted is & barrel of 162 pounds on the basis of

3.6 bushels to 1 barrel.

(118)

‘@

* 1930-31.| 4.50 | 4.12 |.3.88 | 3.62 | 3.62.) 3.50 | 3.62 | 3.50 | 3.50 | 3.50 | 3.38 | 3.38
1931-82.! 3.25 | 3.12 | 2.88 | 204] 2.04 | 2.94] 266/247) 228) 212)221.) 200) 264
+ 1932-83. |, 2.08 | 2.26 | 2.14] 2.01 | 1.04] 1.89 | 1.81 | 1.96 | 209/265) 270) 280) 221
1933-34.| 3.18 | 3.45 | 3.75'| 8.80 | 3.87 | 3.90 | 3.90 |'3.90 | 3.90 | 3.90/3.90/3.% | 3.78 *

: 4
> 1934-85.| 3.74 | 3.70 | 3.68 | 3.55 | 3.57 | 3.42 | 3.38 | 3641 3.76) 3.05 | 408 416] 3.72
1935-36.| 4.07 | 4.10 | 4.28 | 4.52 |.....:|.....,]..---.]...--- ss bate: Hantte ;

1 Average for 11 months. o ‘

SouRCE: 1935 United States Department of Agriculture Year Book, pag August 1924-
December 1934. Prices from Jarfuary 1904, trom wouky Market. News Se ce, United States
TDenartmant at Agrienltnra.

. Tame III. Mathematical computation based on Tabies Land II, show-.

ing Calculated Spread Between Fancy Blue Rosé, New Orleans, and

Monthly Louisiana Farm Price Cents ath pound or Dollars per °

100 pounds ‘

Year | Aug. | Sept.| Oct. | Noy.| Dec. | Jan. | Feb. | Mar. | Apr’ May | June | July
1923-24...... .85'| 1.234 1.50 | 1.40 | 1.06 | 1.29 | 1.25] 1.73 | 2.83 | 1.44 | 1.26 | 1.57
1924-25...... 1.87 | 1.74 | 1.27 | 1.68 | 1.48 | 1.67 | 1.80 | 1.75 | 1.72] 201 | 202], 2.10 6
1925-26... 1.86 | 1.47 | 1.44] 1.65 | 1.68 | 1.84| 1.65] 1.85 | 216] 207] 1.80] 1.62
1926-27...... 2.32 | 1.75 | 1.50} 1.20] 1.261 1.03 | .99)1.07| .88/ 1.14] 1.29] .86
1927-28...... 1.45 | 1,45] 1.08] .71]\.72]'.76| .76| .81] .60] .92] .97) °.90;.
1928-29.-
a court of competent jurisdiction, and, upon .
‘the record as it is set Up, he can prosecute
° his case.

° .

Mr. Kina. Mr. President, I join in the
request of the’ Senator from Idaho. MayI |
call the attention of the Senator from Idaho ©
to this language in the settion to which the
Senator referred, namely: —

“Neither the claimant nor any person di- :
rectly or indirectly under his control ‘or |
having eontrol over him has, directly or |
indirectly, included such amofint in the price :
of the article with respect to. which it was -
imposed or of any article processed from the

‘commodity ‘with respect to which it was
— or passed on”’
his is the point— ;
‘any part of such amount to the vendee or
to any other person in any manner, or in-
cluded any part of such amount in the charge
or fee for processing’’— -

And so forth. Which would mean that if .
the Government had, as he believed, illegally
_ @ollected a thousand dollars, and he demon-

strated that he had not passed:on any part
of it except $1, he then would be denied relief
ae ‘under the interpretation of that language.

| a eer ee >

- 7 " @s *-: *
Mr. Gironaz.. Mr, President, I desire to be
heard on that point.

I do not wish.'to have an incorrect inter-
pretation placed upon the bill? The inter-
Baie placed upon it | the Senator from_-

an is not correct. At first blush, it’

,

o¢ 7 — °
- .
? .
’

RBI ar eens a SY PRC MERE TTI pumepe NM Reseiwioa MER A

“seemed to me to be the proper interpreta-

tion; and when we were consitering this
matter originally in the Senate that was my

_econclusion, A careful reading of. the lan- |
* guage, however, will disclose that the inter-

pretation is not correct. °
If the Senator will bear with me, I will

read:
“NoDrecovery, recoupment, set-off, re- °

fund, or credit shall be made or allowed of,

nor shall any counterclaim be allowed for,
7 | amount of any tax’’—
he ‘‘amount of any tar” refers back to

that original subject, and it is not subject to
‘the interpretation which seems to be about

. to be accepted here. I wish.the RECORD |
to show what is the correct interpretation
. of the language as I construe tl.

* * . * e .: .

“Mr. President, the amendment is not all

that I. desire, but I believe it preserves at.

least some legal rights of the claimant to a
refund or to a credit for a tax illegall col- 5
lected or a tax improperly collected... In my *
ju dgment, “‘the amount of any tax’’ refers

ack to the original language at the begin-
ning of this particular section.

I desire to call attention to the fact that
this is not a provision for. autherte for the
claimant to sue. It is no grant of the right
to sue. It is nothing but a limitation upon
that right.. In my judgment, it would not be
strictly or technically construed .b

court. It fon be given a fair and ‘alnerat
Therefore, if the claimant >

interpretatio
should make o it a just case and secure a
judgment of ‘$500 for taxes illegally ty

. lected, I cannot believe-the court would then.
deny a judgment simply because the claim-

¢ °
we)

ant had passed on a smgll amount of the
$500 to the ultimate consumer, because I

think it would be construed as it properly
:is—merely a limitation upon a right other-

wise existing, and merely a condition. »
I, myself, wish very much that the broad,

_ unrestricted right of the claimant to come

into court might have been given without so
many hedging phrases and so much lan-
guage ; but,-looking to what thé court would
ultimately do with this section, I have. no

doubt that a substantial right is given. It

it true that the claim must first be made
before the Commissioner of Internal Reve-

. nue, but that is true now in many instances.
That was true under the revenue act which

permitted a claim for refund for unsold-
automobile parts, and it is also trie even jn
the administration of veterans’ legislation.

Before any suit may be commenced or main-

tained upon a policy of insurance, the vet-
eran must make out his case and obtain an
affirmative approval or- disapproval of his

alleged cause of action by the Administrator

of Veterans’ Affairs. |
Properly construed, the real purpose,

' whether it be always properly administered,

is to give the Government opportunity to
settle a just case when all of the facts have
been made to appear. Although the Com-
missioner of Internal Revenue is a politi-
cal officer, of course, and generally is dis-
posed to construe an act favorably to~the
Government, nevertheless, in many instances
the facts are found properly, correctly, and
justly, and the Government, is enabled to
make refunds without the necessity of
further court action upen the record actu-
ally made up. (Italics supplied.) |

1

Re

PART G_ .

The following isa list of cases decidéd since the ©
adoption on August 24, 1935, of the Amendments

to the Agricultural Adjustment Act by District

courts or, Circuit Courts of A.»peals, in which it

was sgught to restrain the collection of processing.
taxes@@ogether with a summary of the Court’s
vigtys the questions considered : F
‘In H@nrictta Mills v. Hoey, 12 Fed. Supp.” 61

és. D., N.. Y.), decided September. 5, 1935, it was
held (1) that Sec. 3224 bars suit, cmmead cir-
cumstances not: being present ;, (2) that Sec. 21
(d) (1) affords an adequate remedy, since the

court would not assume that.it will be unfairly ad- ~-

ministered by an executive officer; (3) that Sec.
21 (a) (2) takes away-power to render a declara-
tory judgment. ,

In Merfel, Inc., v. Rasquin, 12 Fed. Supp. 215

(EK. D., N. Y.), Yedided September 5, 1935, it was’

held (1) that Sec. 3224 bars suit, exceptional cir-.
cumstances not being present ; (2) that the legisla-
tive threat: of the removal of al right to sue for .
refunds had been removed, é

In Jedd Jones; Jr., v. Viley, 3 U. S. Law Wesk..-
119 (Idaho), decided ‘September 6, 1935, it was held
(1) that Sec. 3224 bars suit, and that the remedy
at law is adequate; (2) that the jurisdiction to

render d@laratory judgments had been removed.

In Queen City Cotton Co. v. Martin, 3 U.S. Law
Week, 119 (Vt.), decided September 4, 1935, it was

85128—35—arp—9 (125)

Sates | iloas f= _

126 ©

held (1) that the entire Agricultural Adjustment

Act was constitutional on the grounds that since it -

was not entirely clear that the Act was invalid the
court thought it should not declare against consti-
tutionality; (2) that Sec. 3224 bars the suit; (3)
that See. 21 (d) (1): affords an n adequate vemely at
law.

In Jose Escalante & Co. v. Fontenot, 79 F. (2d)
343 (C. C. A. 5th), decided September 13, 1935, the
court refused application for a temporary injunc-
tien on the ground that taxpayer has a plain and
adequate remedy under the Agricultural Adjust-
ment Act, as amended.

In @. B. R. Smith Milling Co. v. Thomas, 11 Fed. '

Supp. 833 (N: D., Tex.), decided September 20, 1935,
it was held that Bee, 21 (d) (1) does not provide an

adequate remedy at law, and that for that reason |

See. 3224 is inapplicable.

In Meridian Grain & Elevator Co. v. Fly, 12 Fed.
Supp. 64 (S. D., Miss.), decided September 21, 1935,
it was held (1) that Sec. 3224 bars the suit ; (2) that
See. 21 (d) (1) affords an adequate vemnby: (3)
that a multiplicity of suits is not present; (4) that
- unusual circumstances or exceptional hardship have
not been shown; (5) that jurisdiction to render a

‘declaratory judgment has been removed. -
In Fisher Flouring Mills Co. v. Vierhus, 78 F.
(2d) 889 (C. C. A. 9th), decided August 24, 1939,
the court denied plaintiff’s application for a tem-

porary-injunction on the ground that Sec. 3224 of -

the. Revised Statutes barred injunctive relief.

In Merchants Packing Co. v. Rogan, 79 F. (2d)
1 (C. C. A. 9th), decided September 24, 1935, the
court granted a temporary injunction pending ap-
peal. The court distinguished the former decision

ar INS rer rs ho td ™
PA aainaehsD Sousa mtg eat e's & ALA
SHRP es Pe Lhd aA avis tear TM Ae Or

.
(Oo renee EARS s+

427

in Fisher Flouring Mills cases’ by saying ‘‘ The sit-

uation is changed by amendment to the law affect-
ing. the remedy of a es to recover an invalid

tax.”

(Conn.), decided August 28, 1935, it was held that
Sec. 3224 does aot bar suit because (1) See. 21
(d) (1) does nét:afford an adequate remedy, and
(2) under that section a multiplicity of suits would
be necessary.. The court overlooked Sec. 21 (a)

entirely, but considered its applicability in Grosve- -

nor-Dale Co. v. Bitgood, infra: —
In Grosvenor-Dale Co. v. Bitgood, 3 U. S. Law
Week 84.(Conn.), decided September 26, 1935, it

was held (1) that Sec. 3224 does not preclude all -

equitable relief; (2) that Sec. 21 (d) (1) does not
provide an adequate remedy; (3) that Sec. 21 (a)
removed all jurisdiction to grant injunctive relief

in processing-tax suits. (Compare the court’s deci-

sion in Baltic Mills Co. v. Bitgood, supra, where
See. 21 (a) was overlooked.) On October 16,
1935, this opinion was modified, restraining the
collection of taxes imposed on or before August 24,
1935.

In Stratton & Co. v. Gagne, 3 U. S. Law Week
119 (N. H.), decided September 28, 1935, it was
said that on the particular allegations of plaintiff’s

bill of complaint, exceptional circumstances taking 1

the case out of operation of See. 3224 were not
shown.
In Kingan & Co. v. Smith, not yet officially re-

ported (S. D. Ind.), decided September 30, 1935,

it was held (1) that Sec, 3224 is declaratory of the
common law; (2) that Sec. 21 (d) (1) does not
provide an adequate remedy; (3) that a motion to

In Baltic Mills Co. v. Bitgood, 12 Fed. Supp. 132

128 .

dismiss admits facts establishing factual basis for

remedial inadequacy of law; (4) that a multi- —
Plicity of suits would be oe under 21 (d)

. |
In Larabee Flour Mills Co. v. Nee, 1935 ©. c. B

Vol. III-A, { 9584, 182 (W. D., Mo.), decided Ge:
tober 3, 1935, it was held (1) that See. 3224 does
not bar suit unless remedy at law is ‘‘clear and un-

questioned’’; (2) that motion to dismiss admits the

truth of allegations of processor as to factual im-
possibility of showing whether the tax has been
passed on—hence 21 (d) (1) does not afford an ade-
quate remedy; (3) that the original act is uncon-
stitutional because of delegation of legislative
power; (4) that the ratification is ineffectual to
validate taxes imposed before the amendment; (5)
that the amended act cures prospectively the dele-
gation of power and is valid; (6) that Congress may
tax for the general weltane, which power i$ not
limited to the effectuation of the sarees
powers.

In G. M. Peet Packing Co. v. Kavanagh, not " |
officially reported (E. D., Mich.), decided October .

15, 1935, the court held that See. 21 (d) (1) did not
provide an adequate remedy principally on the
ground that the processor would be denied a trial
by jury, and that the record before the Commis-
sioner, so far as the truth or untruth of the evi-
dence is concerned, would bind the court.

In A. P. W. Paper Co. v. Riley, 3 Law Week 133
(N. D., N. Y.), decided October. 18, 1935, the court
held (1) that the original act is unconstitutional ;
(2) that Sec. 3224 does not bar suit; (3) that See. 21
(d) (1) does not provide an adequate remedy-; (4)
that if either Sec. 3224 or 21 (a) be construed as

.
CaaS oe *
FE OR LY BUBB PRR Ste ah Meth Ime To NS ee 2 ANS AS CEE OLEH 8 *

"499

denying all access to equity court, relegating de-
fendant to inadequate remedy at law, it is uncon-
stitutional; (5) .that the amended Agricultural
Adjustment Aét does not-cure the delegation of
power and is unconstitutional, ratification being
ineffective because act ig invalid on grounds other
than delegation; (6) that Sec. 21 (d) (1) is faulty
in denying a trial de novo on a new’record in Dis-
“trict Court; (7) that ti cia circumstances
exist.

In Gold Medal Foods v. Landy, not yet officially
reported (D. C., Minn.), decided October 22, 1935,
it was held (1) that See. 21. (a) is no broader than
Sec.. 3224 (Note: The taxes involved all accrued

» prior to the amendment), because Congress wished
only to make it clear that the prohibition against
injunctive relief applied in tax cases despite allega-
tions that the processing levy was not a tax at all,

___and Congress did not intend to do away with equity

ee jurisdiction if the relief it set up in 21 (d) (1) was

4 inadequate; (2) that the possibility that taxpayer

may recoup a payment from third party is not suffi-

cient to oust equity jurisdiction; (3) that Sec. 21

(d) (1) provides an inadequate remedy, because it .

is indefinite and uncertain, and open to objection be-
cause the District Court does not try the errr de

: novo.

“ —s In Danahy Packing Co. v. McGowan, 1 Fed.

: Supp. 920 (W. D., N. Y.), decided October 24, 1935,

4 it was held that See. 21 (d) (1) does not provide

an adequate remedy, on the premise that the mo-
tion to dismiss admits factual impossibility to prove
tax was not passed on. The court also expressed
grave doubt as to whether 21 (d) is constitutional.

a:
et
fe
a
Ea
‘2
<
5
ae
om
ef
a
Bs
x
aay °

: sr Oe Be — oan - - - - - an —_
RG ate ME ARE NM oy SE NY ONES ROE ON TORT DTS OLR ES AH LOL GLO IES AL OSI I TES NOY 33

130

In Anton Riedeyx v. Rogan, not yet officially re-
. ported (S. D., Cal.), decided October 28, 1935, it
was held (1) that the Agricultural Adjustment Act
is constitutional; (2) that Sec. 3224 is applicable,
exceptional circumstances not being shown, and: the
fact that Congress might not appropriate funds to
discharge established refund claim being irrel-

evant; (3) that Sec. 21. (a) prevents injunctive

relief as well as Sec. 3224; (4) that Sec. 21 (d) (1)
provides an adequate remedy, since difficulty of —
- proof is not a basis of equity jurisdiction, and that —
if-21 (d) is an impossible burden it is invalid, and
taxpayer may disregard it in a suit. for refund;
(5) that multiplicity of suits would. not be neces-
sary, since the issue could be’conveniently tested .

in one suit by the one persop, and prevention of a

series of suits for periodic trespasses in collection |
of tax is not sufficient; (6) that no jurisdiction
exists to grant a declaratory judgment..

In Frye & Co. v. Vierhus, not yet officially re-
ported (W. D., Wash.), decided November 2, 1935,
it was held (1) that Congress is free to regulate a
suit against the United States in all its aspects;
A2Y that Sec. 21 (d) (1) must be construed as only
‘ applicabie to a suit against the United States, and
that if applicable to a suit against the collector it
is invalid; (3) that right to sue the-¢ollector is un-
impaired; (4) that taxpayer’ s remedy at, law is
plain and adequate.

In Louisville Provision Co. v. Glenn, not yet offi-
cially reported (W. D., Ky.), decided November 5,
1935, it was held (1) that no exceptional circum-
stances removing the case from operation of Sec.
3224 are shown; (2) that Sec. 21 (d) (1) affords

- complete remedy (on authority of Jefferson Elec-

trie Co., 291 U. 8. 386); (3) that. jurisdiction to
render declaratory judgments had been removed.
In Porte Kicax American Tobacco Co. v. Tait, not.
yet officially reported (Porto Rico), decided Novem-
ber 18, 1935, it was held (1) that See. 3224 barred the
~ suit; (2) that the remedy provided by See. 21 (d) (1)
is adequate. ees
In‘Shenandoah Milling Co. v. Early, 3 Law Week
119 (W. D. Va.), decided September 23, 1935, it was
held (1) that Sec. 3224 is only declaratory of the
common law; (2) that Sec. 21 (d) (1) does not af-
ford an adequate remedy, it being factually impos- .
sible for processor to meet its requirements; (8)
that the Government is in no position to urge ‘‘un-:
just enrichment’”’ of processor ; (4) that exceptional

~ circumstances exist.

In Inland Milling Co. v. Huston, not yet officially
reported (S. D. Iowa), decided November 22, 1935,
it was held that (1) Sec. 3224 does not bar injunc-
tive relief; (2) that Sec. (d) (1) does not give an

adequate remedy. a

In John A. Gebelein, Inc., v. Milbourne, 12 Fed.
Supp. 105, 121 (Md:), decided October 1, 1935, it was
held that (1) the ratification is ineffectual because
the Agricultural Adjustment Act is invalid on
grounds other than delegation ; (2) that Sec. 21: (a),
as applied to taxes accruing prior to amendment,
did not alter Sec. 3224, the court indicating the view
that with respect to taxes accruing prospectively,
Sec. 21 (a) is absolute in denying injunctive relief ;
(3) that Sec. 21 (d) (1) gives no adequate remedy
because taxpayer is required to show more than
mere fact that tax has been passed on. It is fact-
ually impossible for taxpayer to make the necessary
proof, and Sec. 21 (d) (1) is faulty in denying trial _

“- 7 .

4

- suits; Congress may have intended the amendments

132

de novo in District Court; (4) that it is doubtful
that Sec. 3224 has any application to processing-tax

to substitute a completely new system of ‘‘ corrective’
justice’’; (5) that if Sec. 3224 is still applicable,
nevertheless, the instant proceeding came within:
exception of unusual circumstgnces, since Sec. 21
(d) (1) provided a wholly rich, remedy.

v.s. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 1938

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386009_0294%3A31. Public record. Not legal advice.
