# Transcript of Record — Rickert Rice Mills, Inc. v. Fontenot

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386009_0294%3A01

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1936
- **Citation:** 297 U.S. 110

## Text

' , p . ’ = . ;
4 ‘ ae : i
* 6 ” =
ir a ree .
A
&
oe 7

+ TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD

7 —_ 7 * i Pers .
Supreme Court of the United States
» . ,
OCTOBER TERM; 1935
: nog é .
| ere |
| , nant | ; 3 |
- RICKERT RICE MILLS, INC., PETITIONER, |
"RUFUS W. FONTENOT, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS °.
ACTING UNITED STATES COLLECTOR OF IN- ;
TERNAL REVENUE FOR THE DISTRICT OF
LOUISIANA
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIBCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT
a.
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED NOVEMBER 11, 1935. i
; ? CERTIORARI GRANTED NOVEMBER 25, 1935. N

ie a * i,
SUPREME COURT OF THE'UNITED STATES
; OCTOBER TERM, 1935

3 ™ 7
aT . A 7 ; : , de s
RICKERT RICE MILLS, INC., PETITIONER,
; vs. *
RUFUS W. FONTENOT, IN DIVIDUALLY AND AS
ACTING UNITED STATES COLLECTOR OF IN-
. TERNAL REVENUE’ ‘FOR THE DISTRICT OF
LOUISIANA
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIROUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT P
o a
' INDEX an ’s
ce? Se Page
Record from D, ©. U. S., Bastern Louisiana ....... eS pragpbecencess 1
Caption” peveceeteseerecers TTT TTT dees leseecossneeed Preceweces 1
S Ff PPP rere 2
Exhibit “A’—Administrative Rulings Relating to the 1935
Southern, Rice Production Adjustment Program....... see 27
Beit “DW” Comteact 20s ccsccccccccccscvcvceccteetescoes , OB:
Exhibit “C’—Section 21 ..........++... sevvccccccces qeeee «648
Beatie GH GEES cc ccccccvccccscccesceseesecvceseseceses eee OF
Return to rule to show cause why temporary injunction shoukd
not issue ...... WOdedaedeceecadvesdepessecegesessoveséeceesse oe
Order consol'dating all cases for neapeee of trial...... et eeeeeee \ 58.
Affidavit of 'W. M. Reid ............6.% aéanceves énesees agtecee. | Sf
. _ Affidavit of Homer L. Bruce .............. eghesevecegacceces 65
Joint affidavit of L. J. Bartel, R. F. Gould & J.J. Mayer oeceere :. =
Motion of plaintiff. for injunction pending appeal and order deny-
SO GH Diss ccccccecsusteccvecadetessesseccotbeeecess oes 80
Motion of plaintiff for appeal and order allowing SAaMe......... 81 Y a
- Assignment of errors ...... we edeceeeeede tee eeeeeeeeeens eeeee 82.
ms BE SEE 5.66b0 ce ctacetcevecacuseesesnes tea eeeseececees fox 83,
Precipe ........ st eeeeeeeeececccceccenseseccccsscccsccccsccs, BA
Clerk’s certificate ......, neues tenes eee e ee ee eee ebeMeeeeeeees a 8B.
‘ Jupp & Derwerter (INc.), Printers, WASHINGTON, D. C., Decemany 6, 1935.
—7199-0 ; . ar ¢

a7 - ' | tela aerecereneeis :

=.
*e : > ; ° -
11 ; ENDEX
: , Original Print
Proceedings in U. 8. C. C. A., Fifth Circuit.......... Occceee 87
Motion for preliminary injunetion pending appeal........... 87" 87
‘Order denying motion for emcmmaeed injunction pending on P
2 BBR: cccccbeccpowvcccesecccocgcscavecscerees Cocteveecs _ 98 °. 98
’ Clerk’s ‘certificate ...... eeoeesetoes (omitted in ptinting) .. 100 '
Order allowing certiorari’.............. Wtedstebvaseouess 101 94
*’ - P + « e
‘>
Ss
4
> ° ‘ . e
& a
: . bd 4
°
or e
q

oes,”

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, EASTERN *
- DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA, NEW ORLEANS
DIVISION. .

No. 321 (Equity).

| ‘=
“RICKERT RICE MILLS, INC.;

versus

RUFUS W. FONTENQT, INDIVIDUALLY AND

. AS ACTING UNITED STATES COLLECTOR

OF INTERNAL REVENUE FOR THE DBS-
TRICT OF, LOUISIANA.

Appearances: :

Messrs. ‘Homer L. Bruce, John P. ‘Bullington and

Baker, Botts, Andrews & Wharton, Attorneys

for Rickert Rice Mills, Inc., Plaintiff-Appellant.

~ Rene A. Viosca, Esq.} United States~Attorney and
Robert Weinstein, Asst. U. S. Attorney, appear-
ing on behalf of Rufus W. F ontenot, Individual-
ly and as Acting 8

and for payments authorized to be made under Section
‘8, in¢luding said rental and. benefit payments made
with respect to adjustment and reduction in acreage
or production for market or basic agricultural com-
modities, including rice.

6 Section 12(b) of said Act, prior to said

Amendment of August 24, 1935, provided
that, in addition to said $100,000,000.00, the proceeds
derived from atl processing taxes imposed under said
Title 1 were appropriated to be available to the Secre-
tary of Agriculturé for expansion .of markets and re-
moval ef surplus agricultural products and adminis-
trative expenses, rental and benefit payments, and
refunds on taxes. Section 12 (b) of said Act .as-
amended by said Amendment of August 24, 1935, pro-
vided that, in addition to said $100,000,000.00 a further
sum was appropriated to be available to the Secretary
of Agriculture for payments authorized to be made |
under said Section 8, including said rental and benefit
payments, said sum so appropriated to be equal to the
preceeds derived from all processing taxes imposed
under said Act.

eee ree.

Acting pursuant to. the purported authority given, |
to hirh under said Agricultural Adjustment Act, thé
Secretary of Agriculture under date of April 18, 1935,
through R. G. Tugwell, the then acting Secretary of
Agriculture, promulgated certain rulings relating to the
1935 Southern Rice Production Adjustment Program,

_ a copy of which rulings is attached hereto as Exhibit A
and made a part hereof as if fully copied herein at
this point. Under said rulings the Secretary of Agri-
culture allotted acreage to be planted in rice and bar-

* rels of rice to be produced, (a barrel being defined as
being one hundred sixty-two pounds of rough rice) .

9

in the States of Arkansas, Louisiana and Texas as
follows:

Acres. Barrels.

Arkansas ..... 135,000 1,834,722
Louisiana .... 364,500 3,898,333
Texas. ....... 142,500. 2,010,833

Said rulings provided for a State Committee appointed
by the Secretary of Agriculture for each State and
for various forms and applications to be filled out by
those desiring to produce rice and to be filed with the
said State Committee. Said rulings provided that the
base period for Texas should be the years 1931 to 1933,
inclusive, and for Arkansas and Louisiana should be
the years 1929: to 1933, inclusive. Said rulings further
provided that the said State Committee should make
an allotment to a producer applying to the Secretary
of Agriculture through said State Committee for.
permission to grow rice during the year 1935, by taking
the average acreage planted by such producer during

the base period applicable to him and by re-
7 _. ducing this‘result by 20%. in Arkansas and
ae in Louisiana and by 22% in Texas; and
should give an allotment or permission to said. pro-
ducer to plant said 80% -(in the case of Arkansas and
Louisiana) or 78% (in the case of Texas) of the aver-
age acreage planted by him during said base period.
Said rulings further provided for said State Com- .
mittee to allot to each such producer a quota of barrels
of rice that he might produce during the year 1935 bv
allotting to him 80% (if in Arkansas or Louisiana)
or 78% (if in Texas) of the average number of bar-
rels of rice raised by him.during said base period.

If a producer had produced rice during-any of the
years constituting his base period. he was eligible to
obtain an allotment and a quota from said State Com-
mittee, and if he should obtain such allotment and

‘ 3
vets nent tagntsstat sct eC NM ON AEE EARLE ARES. EEN ER EEDA LEE SEP NR LOE TE TT OT ee ea

0 eo

="

quota, he was then eligible to execute a contract with
the Secretary of Agriculture in thé form shown by

- Exhibit ‘B attached hereto and made a part hereof for

.all purposes as if copied in.full at this point. If said
producer executed said contract and it was accepted
by the Secretary, he was then eligible for the benefit
*pay ménts to be made by the Secretary as provided for
in said agreement. However, if a producer had not
produced rice during any of the years constituting his
base period, he was not eligible to execute said contract
with the Secretary and was not eligible for the benefit
payments provided for therein. Likewise, if a producer
did. not execute such contract, or if he exetuted such

--contract .and it was not accepted by the Secretary, he

was not eligible for the benefit payments as ; provided
for therein.

Plaintiff alleges that said processing taxes were not
levied under the taxing power of the United States
and for the purpose of raising revenue, but were levied
for the purpose of raising money with which the Secre-
tary of Agriculture could make rental or. benefit pay-
ments to producers of agricultural products, including
rice, who would agree with the Secretary of Agriculture

_ to reduce their acreage and production of agricultural

products, including rice, and for the purpose of con- °
‘trolling, regulating, and reducing the amount of acre-
age that would be planted to rice and the amount of
rice that would be grown, and to accomplish the pur-
poses set out in Section 2 of said Act, and that the
Congress of the. United, States had no authority under
the Constitution of the United States to levy said pro-
‘cessing taxes for said purpose*and for said objects. .
8.
Section 8 further provides that, in order to effectuate
the’ declared policy of the Act, the Secretary
8 is empowered to provide for a reduction in
_ acreage or a reduction in production of any

basic agricultural commodity through agreements with
_ producers, and to provide for rental or-benefit pay-
ments in connection therewith.in such amounts as
the Secretary deems fair and reasonable, but there is
no standard or measure established or provided in: said
Act by which the said Secretary shall be guided in
providing for said reduction in acreage or production
or in the amount of the rental or benefit payments,
and said provisions are wholly invalid and violative
of Article-1 of the Constitution of the United States
which vests all the legislative power in the Congress
of the United States and is ar invalid and ‘uncon-
stitutional delegation of legislative power by Congress
.to the Secretary of Agriculture. ee,

Plaintiff further alleges that the Secretary has made ©
no findings whatsoever, and if he has made any such
findings, they are wholly insufficient’ to support his
action in providing said. method of reduction of acre-
age and production of rice as above set forth, and his
said regulations and provisions concerning said reduc-
tion of acreage and reduction of production and. .
amounts of benefit payments are wholly arbitrary and
unsupported by any findings, or at least any sufficient
findiags, by the Secretary of Agricultfire and are not
authorized by said Act or the Constitution of the.
United States. .

° 9.

Section 9(b) of said Act provides. that if the Secre-
tary of Agriculture has reason to believe that the pro-
ceSsing -tax levied on any commodity will cause such
reduction in the quantity of such production domestic-
ally consumed as to. result in the accumulation of sur-
plus stock thereof or in the depreciation of the farm
price of the commodity, then he shall cause an in-
vestigation to be made on due notice and opportunity
for hearing’to interested parties, and if thereupon the

12

Secretary finds. that such result will occur, then the
processing tax on such commodity shall be at -such
_rate as will prevent such accumulation of surplus stock
and depreciation of said farm price. : Said provision
_applies to the ‘processing tax levied upon.rice. Said
provision sets: no proper standard by which the Secre-'
tary shall be guided in cetermining the rate of the
processing tax on rice or how long~said tax of one
-cent (te) per pound shall remain on rice, and the
continuation of said processing tax being® dependent
upon said action by the Secretary, said provision is an.
unconstitutional delegation. of legislative .powez, to the
Secretary of Agriculture in violation of Article 1 of

said Constitution vesting the legislative power
a in the Congress, and for said reasons.the said

Act in levying said processing tax is void and
illegal.

Tn ‘Steen to the foregoing reasons, the said Agri-
cultural Adjustment Act and its provisions for the
levying, assessment. and collection of said processing
taxes upon rice processed by this plaintiff are void,’
illegal and in violation of the Constitution ‘of the
United States for the following. reasons:

1. They are an attempt.and effort by the: United
States to regulate, control and reduce the production’ of
certain agricultural commodities specified in said Act,
including rice. The so-called processing taxes im-
posed by said Act. are an integral part of the scheme,
attempt and effort of regulating, controlling and reduc-
ing the production of such commodities, which attempt, _
effort and scheme is not within the scope of any of the -
powers vested in the Congress by the Constitution, and
if said power exists as a governmental function, it is
therefore within the powers reserved to the States as
expressly provided by the Tenth Amendment to the .
Constitution. :

¢
. -

2

2. The so-called processing taxes were not iniposed
under or in conformity with the power vested in the
Congress by Section 8 of Article 1 of the Constitution
- to levy and collect taxes, duties, imposts. and excises,
in that they are not imposed to pay the debts or to
provide for the common defense or the general welfare
of the United States, but were imposed for the benefit
of a particular. class of individuals, namely, the pro-
ducers of the warious agricultural commodities speci-
fied in said Act’ who conform to the conditions laid
down in said Act.

3. The said Act and provisions for the levy, assess- .
ment and collection of said processing taxes violates
the provisions of the Fifth Amendment to the Con-
stitution since the so-called processing taxes constitute
. the deprivation of the property-of one class of citi-
zens, including the plaintiff, namely, processors of
said specified commodities, including rice, without
due pracess of law, in that such processing taxes
constitute the taking of the property of this class of ~
“citizens, including the plaintiff, not for a public pur-
pose but for a private purpose, to-wit, the payment of
gratuities ar bounties or benefit payments to another
class of persons, namely, the producers of the desig-
nated agricultural commodities, including rice, and
particularly since this’ taking is without just com-
pensation to the plaintiff and said processors.

4. Said so-called processing taxes levied by the
Act are taxes in namie.only and not in fact. They
constitute merely an exactment and -imposi-
10 tion by the Government for the purpose, not
of raising revenue for the support of the
government, but of raising the price for farm products
and adjusting farm income and for carrying out the
policy of said Act as hereinabove set forth and for the
purpose of enabling the government to carry out and
effectuate the said attempt, effort and scheme of the
United States as hereinabove set out. |

14 es

ww

‘5. Under. the termis of’ Article 1, Section 1, of the
Constitution of .the United States, the legislative
powers granted to the Federal Government are vested
in the Congress; whereas, the said ‘Act purports to vest
powers in*the Secretary of Agriculture, who alone is
to determine, at "his own discretion and.without any
definite standard fixed by Congress, the method of
bringing about a reduction or adjustment in acreage
and production of agricultural commodities, including
rice; to provide for rental or benefit payments in con-
nection therewith in such amounts as the Secretary
may deem fair and reasonable; to determine how long
the said tax of lc per pound upon the processing of.
rice shall remain in effect, and if the Secretary changes
said rate, what rate shall be fixed. In’ said respects
.the said Act involves an invalid delegation to the
Secretary of-Agriculture by Congress of powers vested
exclusively: in it by the Consiitution and because of
said things the said Act delegates said legislative
powers to the Secretary. of Agriculture and said powers
-are conferred exclusively on Congress by said Article
1, Section 1;..Article 1, Section 8, clause 18; Article
_ Section’ 1; Article Lt. Section 7, clause 1;. and
Article 1, Section 9, clause 7 of the Constitution.

6. The said taxes if construed as direct, violate
Article 1, Section 9, clause 4; and Article 1, Section 2,
‘clause 3 ‘of the Constitution, because not apportioned
according to population.

a 2 The said taxes are not excise taxes, and are not
uniform throughout the United States as required by
Articie 1, Section 8, clause 1.

8. The said alleged taxes cannot be levied under
Article 1, Section 8, clause 3, regulating commerce,
because ‘neither the production nor processing of com-
modities, including the processing of rice done by plain-
tiff, is in interstate commerce and cannot be regulated

by ne and in s ne far-as this plaintiff is concerned,
its processing of said rice is not interstate commerce
and cannot be regulated’ by Congress. |

eget 11,

~

Bi Under the terms of said Act and orders: of the

_ Secretary of Agriculture and the Secretary of the ~

Treasury, the plaintiff is required to file returns. with
the defendant on or before the 30th day of October,
1935, showing the amount of rice processed by the
plaintiff’ ‘during the month of September, 1935, -and
the amount of said so-called processing tax on ac-
count of said rice processed by the plainsiff during
‘said month, and plaintiff is required to pay ‘said
amount to the’ defendant on or befpre Octaber 30,
1935. The amount of said processing taxés on account
of the rice processed by the plaintiff during said month
of September is $57,275.42. The defendant as said
Collector of Internal Revenue is charged with the duty
of collecting said tax, and if the plaintiff does not make
said payment ‘on or before October 30, 1935, the said
defendant will assess said tax against the plaintiff and
will serve upon the plaintiff notice and: demand for

‘ the payment of said tax, and the plaintiff will be al- . °

lowed ten days from the receipt of such notice and
demand within which to pay said tax. In the event
of failure to pay said tax within said time, the defend-
ant will assess against the plaintiff a penalty equal
to 5 per.centum of the amount of the tax and interest
on the tax at the rate.of-1 per centum from the date
of the tax until it is paid; if plaintiff fails to pay said
tax within ten days after receipt of said notice and
demand, the defendant will proceed to collect the tax,
penalty and interest by filing a notice of lien upon
all of plaintiff's property, and by distraining upon and
selling such of plaintiff’s property as may be necessary
in order to realize the amount of said tax, penalties and .
interest. Additional processing taxes for: months sub-

16

sequent to September, 1935, will accrue and will be
assessed against and collected from plaintiff, just as
the processing tax for the month of September will be,
in the manner described, unless the defendant is re-.
strained and enjoined from assessing and collecting said
taxes. Plaintiff has its rice mill at the plaee stated in
paragraph 3 hereof with a large inventory of rough
rice and clean rice, bank accounts and cash on hand.
Repeated levies upon. and distraint of its property from
month to month will cause plaintiff irreparable injury
and damage, in that such levies .and distraints will
impair the. valuable good-will of its business; will seri-

ously interfere with, if not prevent, the actual opera-

tions of its plant and the sales of its “product; and
will result in a ‘permanent injury to its business and
good-will.. Furthermore the tax, if once paid by
plainuf, will be irretrievably lost to plaintiff, to its
great and irreparable injury.

i : 12.

Plaintiff further shows that by the Amendment of
August 24, 1935, Section 30, of said amendment added
a new section to the Agricultural Adjustment: Act
designated as Section 21, a copy of which-Section 21.
is attached hereto and marked Exhibit C. Plaintiff
does not have an adequate and complete remedy at
law as to taxes levied and assessed under said Act
because of the provisions of Section 21(d) of said
Agricultural Adjustment Act. Under Section 21(d) a
recovery will not be allowed to the plaintiff for any
amount of the tax paid by plaintiff unless it shall be
established that the plaintiff has not directly Or in-
directly included such amount in the price of the rice
with respect to which it was imposed or passed.on any
part of any such amount to the vendee, ot included any
part of such amount in the charge or fee for processing,
and that the price paid by the plaintiff for rough rice
was not reduced by any part of such amount. “a

ee ee

17

Plaintiff states that it is an impossibility to prove
or attempt to prove what portion, if any, of. the pro-
cessing taxes paid by it has been either deducted from
‘the purchase price of rough rice or added to the sell-
ing price of clean rice for the following reasons:

‘Rice millers buy rough rice at the market price,
a price tHat is‘established by the competitive bidding
of the many rice millers. Rough rice is bought in
large quantities and kept on an average several months
before the clean rice made from it is sold, and because
“of said facts the miller has no way of definitely know-
ing at the time of the purchase of rough rice whether.
he will miake a profit or loss on the milling and selling
of rice. A major factor in determining the market
price of rough rice is the market price of clean rice
at the time the rough rice is bought but: sap is no
assurance, however, that the market price for chean rice
will be the same at the time the miller actually sells
the clean rice milled from the rough rice.

The miller who buys rough rice must pay the
market price as established under these conditions,
and has no power to fix or make the market price
himself. Having no power to make prices, he cannot
arbitrarily depress the market price of rice in ‘order
to pass the processing tax back to the producer.

Likewise, the miller sells the clean rice in com-
petition with many other rice millers, and also in com-
petition with many other food products, such as wheat,
potatoes, beans and other food products, that can be
substituted for rice.. ‘Under such circumstances, if the

price. of clean rice is pushed ‘too high, con-
13 sumers will shift to other products with the
result that the demand for rice will décline
until the price of rice falls to where people will: buy
it instead of other competitive commodities. Under
these circumstances the rice miller cannot fix or make

18

the price for clean rice, and cannot arbitrarily increase
the price of clean rice in order to pass the processing
tax on the purchaser of clean rice.

In addition, rough rice when milled producés many
grades of rice and products thereof. It produces extra
fancy head rice, fancy head rice, head rice, second
head rice, screenings, brewers, polish, bran, and: hulls,
all of which commodities have varying values, extra
fancy rice being the most valuable and the other grades
being of less vajue in the order above set forth. .F xtra
_fancy, fancy, head and second head rice are generally
sold for human consumption as rice. Screenings are
sold to some extent for direct consumption by human
beings. Brewers and screenings are a very. low priced
commodity and are used in general by breweries.
Polish, bran and hulls are sold generally for stock
feed. Some of such products, particularly brewers,
polish, bran and hulls are sold practically always for
a less price per pound than is paid for the rough rice
per pound. There is no definite proportion by which
the price paid for rough rice can be allocated in any
way to these different grades of rice, so that it is im-
possible to tell with any degree of accuracy how
-much-the rice and rice products that have been pro-
duced from any particular lot of rough rice have cost,
making it impossible to tell what amount of the pro-
cessing tax, if any, has been passed on to the ‘Pur-
chaser of these articles.

Furthermore, the processing tax is levied upon the
“first processing of the rough rice and must be paid
by the end of the calendar month following the month
in which the processing occurred. On the other hand,
When. a lot of rough rice has been processed in any
month, some of the grades may be sold immediately,
whereas some of the other grades produced from said
rice mav be kept for several months before being sold,
and it is thus impossible to tell how much has been

Bale Fotos Ae eee tee ee ee ee

19

a for the clean rice and its preducts that are
produced from any month’s processing, and it is im-
possible to tell how much, if any, of said processing
tax has been passed on to ‘the purchaser of. said clean
rice.

Indeed, it is impossible even to determine whether,

for any given month, the mill operations have resulted

in a gain or loss and it is only at the end of the
season that a gain or loss for the season can be de-
termined.

14 In addition, in the cost of rough rice pro-
: cessed during any month, there is’ an addi-
tional item of the cost of the milling of such rice.

The cost of milling rice depends upon many factors so_

that it is impossible to determine what has’ actually
been the cost of milling any particular lot of rice.
There are many varieties of rice, some of which have
longer grains than others, and some of which have
thicker or heavier grains than others. Different
processes of .milling must be used for each different
kind and variety of rice, and where the plaintiff and
other millers have on hand varied and sundry varieties
_ and kinds of rice it is necessary in the operation of the
mill to change quickly from one kind of rice fo an-
other as the milling of one lot of rice is completed and
the milling of another kind. begun. In addition, lots
of rice of the same variety will vary the one from the
other due to the varying amounts of moisture in the

rice, varying conditions under which. the rice was.

harvested, and many other factors, which. makes it
necessary to varyethe operation of the rice mill in many
respects as between lots of rice. In addition, the out-
put of a mill in barrels per day varies because of all
these factors very considerably. Under ‘all the cir-
cumstances, it is impossible for a mill to determine
the cost to it of the milling of any particular lot of

rice, which cost must necessarily enter into a deter--

>: eee

20

mination of whether in selling the clean rice-it has
included any part, or what part, of the processing tax
in the price for which it sells its clean rice and rice
products. ai .

In addition, owing to the peculiar nature of the rice

. business and the customary. manner of selling: rice
that prevails in the rice industry,\it is impossible for
the plaintiff and other rice millers determine the
cost of any particular rice- that has gone into the
clean rice that rs covered by: any particular sale. The
clean rice that is obtained from any particular lot
of rough rice is not sold in the trade ‘by. itself alone.
At the.beginning of the season plaintiff and other
rice mills know approximately the different kinds of
rice that they will have during the season. In th
early part of the season and as the season progresses
plaintiff. and other millers make up samples of rice
of the kind that they have determined they will be
able to supply during the season. Owing to the
varied character of clean rice out-turn from rough.
rice, these samples are made up of mixtures of -differ-
ent kinds of rice. It has been found impossible to
make up such samples. entirely of one kind of rice
from one lot of rough rice as it is impossible to match
in any appreciablé quantity a sample of one lot of clean
rice with another lot of clean rice. Clean rice is sold
on these samples and when an order is ob-

15 tained for a given amount of clean rice of a
certain sample, the plaintiff and other rice
millers then find what different lots of clean rice they
have on hand which by mixing will produce the sam-
ples upon which the sale has been made. As a result,
when a sale of clean rice is made, the order is filled
by a mixture of clean rice which is: made. up from
many different lots of clean rice. These different
lots of clean rice have been milled from different lots
of rough rice for which different prices have been
paid. As a result the, rice that goes into a clean

é = if > Pp? Spore a>
SPOTS SD ea ry hoes a
Peeters Ba Be saree, Ne, VR iD ste NN

21

rice sale has « come tele many different sources’ and has
been milled under many different conditions and it is
impossible to tell exactly the cost of such clean rice
under the circumstances. In addition, part of the
clean rice obtained from a lot of rough rice may be
carried for many months and mixed on different. sales
with innumerable combinations of other lots of clean
rice so that it is impossible to trace through the history
of rice processed during any month to determine what:
price was obtained for it, whether it was sold at a
profit or a loss, and what part, if any, of the process-
ing tax has been passed on to the purchaser.

Furthermore, there is no was in which the cost of
alot of rough rice can be allocated between the various
grades of rice and the various rice products produced

from such lot except by speculation or the use of’

arbitraries.
ae”

In short, it is impossible to determine, statistically
or otherwise, where the ultimate burden of the pro-
cessing tax falls—how- much of it is paid‘by the con-

sumer, how much by the producer, of how much by
the processor. . | _ ;

In view of the above facts, the purported remedy
given by Section 21(d) of said Agricultural Adjust-
ment Act is wholly inadequate and is in fact a statu-
tory denial of any legal remedy at all.:

t2,

In addition, the conditions imposed upon the right
of the plaintiff to recover taxes paid by it must,
under Section 21(d) be established to the satisfaction
of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, and no
provision is made for judicial review. The transcript
of the hedring before the Commissioner of Internal

22

Revenue is the sole record of the case on appeal to the

Courts. The effect of such section is therefore to
limit the function of the judicial review to the deter-
mination of whether there was any evidence submitted
to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue tending to
support.the findings of the-Commission. Said Section
| 21(d) therefore deprives the plaintiff of its
16 property without due process of law in viola-
tion of the Fifth Amendment to the Con-
stitution. |
14.

Under said Section 21(d) of said Agricultural
Adjustment Act, if the processing tax has been either
passed on or passed back by the plaintiff, then the
plaintiff cannot maintain any action to recover the
tax, if it is ultimately determined to be invalid, either
for its own account or for the account of the persons
to whom the processing tax has been thus passed on

or passed back by the plaintiff; nor can the persons

to whom the processing tax. has been thus passed on
or passed back maintain such an action on their own
account, but all right of action by a one to recover

-the tax, if it has been passed on or passed back,

has been wholly taken away by said amendments to
said Agricultural Adjustment Act. Moreover, Section
21(a) of said Act and Section 405 of the Revenue
Act of 1935 deprive the Courts of power to render
declaratory judgments with respect to such alleged
taxes. By reason of the impossibilities of proof here-
inabove referred to, the practical effect of said Act

will be to deny taxpayers and the plaintiff all means

of securing a judicial decision as to the constitutional-
ity of the processing taxes, unless the Court grants
the relief herein sought. ,

. we.

PisieGit farther shows that by Section 30 of said
Amendment of August 24, 1935, Section 21(a) was

ET IS Sis ov ee ets sony,

23

added to said Act, which in substance provides ‘that
no suit to enjoin the collection of any tax, imposed by
said Act shall be maintained. Plaintiff alleges that
said section is not intended to apply, and does not
apply, to the injunction prayed for by this plaintiff
inasmuch as plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law.
Plaintiff alleges, however, that if said section should
be interpreted as providing that no injunction should
be granted to the plaintiff as prayed for in this cause,
then the said section, together with the other provi- —
sions of said Act, is invalid and in violation of the
Fifth Amendment to the Constitution of :the United
States, that no person shall be deprived of his property
without due process of law, in that said illegal and un-
constitutional taxes will be collected from the plain-
tiff and the plaintiff will have no remedy by which
he may recover said taxes, and if said section is so in-
terpreted, he will have no remedy to prevent ‘the col-
lection of said unlawful taxes, and will be forever de-
prived of the right in any manner to test the consti-
tutionality of such taxes.

17 | 16.

Said Section 21(d) further denies to the plaintiff
‘a complete and adequate remedy at law, because a
multiplicity of claims and suits would be required to
enforce such rights as are granted thereunder and
because said subsection requires that the facts re-
quired to be proved thereunder be established to the
satisfaction of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue
and makes no provision for a judicial review of his
decision. :

17.

A refund of processing taxes paid by the plaintiff. -
could not actually be obtained even if it were possible

2440 ~

for the plaintiff to prove the negative facts required
_ by subsection (d) of Article 21, because Congress has
not appropriated funds for the payment of such refunds
_and plaintiff believes, that in view of the aggregate
amount involved, there ; is a reasonable doubt whether
such appropriation would ever be made.

18.
Plaintiff is ready, able and willing and hereby offers °
and agrees that in the event the injunctive relief herein
prayed for is granted, it will deposit at such time and in
such manner as this Court shall direct the said sums
claimed to be due from plaintiff for processing taxes on
account of the rice processed ‘by plaintiff during the
month of September, 1935, and the plaintiff further
offers and agrees that at the end of each month here-.
after it will file processing tax returns with the defend-
ant as required by existing laws and regulations and that
as and when processing taxes under said returns become
due and payable according to existing laws and regula-
tions or any extension lawfully granted to the plain-
. tiff, it will deposit.the amount of such taxes in such
manner as the Court may direct, all such deposits to
abide the final decree in this cause. “7

Wherefore, — plaintiff ‘pine - without an adequate
_— at law prays: :

1. That process issue and be served upon:the de-
fendarit requiring him to appear and answer this bill, -
but_not under oath, and answer under oath being here-
_ by. ‘ekpressly waived; :

» 2. That pending the hearing of the application for
a preliminary injunction hereinafter prayed for, a
temporary restraining order issue immediately enjoin-
ing and peattaining the defendant until the hearing

25

of its application for a preliminary injunction or until
| the further order of this Court, from assess-
18 ing or collecting or attempting to assess or
collect from the plaintiff in any manner what-
soever, whether by lien er jeopardy or by distraint
proceedings, in Court or otherwise, any processing
taxes under and pursuant to satd Agricultural Adjust-
ment Act and any interest or penalty on account
of plaintiff’s failure to pay said processing tax, and
from imposing or giving notice of intention to imposé
any lien for said taxes upon the-property, real or
personal, of the plaintiff;

3. That notice issue to the defendant advising. him
that plaintiff is hereby applying for’ a preliminary
injunction and that plaintiff’s said application will be
heard at a time to be fixed’ by the Court in said notice,
and that upon said hearing a preliminary injunction
pending. the final disposition of this case be issued
enjoining-and restraining the defendant from assess-
ing or collecting or attempting to assess or collect
from the, plaintiff in any manner whatsoever, whether
by lien or jeopardy or by distraint procedings, in
Court or otherwise, any processing. taxes under and
pursuant to said Agricultural Adjustment Act and
any interest or penalty on account of'plaintiff’s failure
to pay said processing tax, and fronf imposing or giving
notice of intention to impose any lien for said taxes
upon the property, real or personal, of the plaintiff;

4. That at the final’ hearing of this cause’ said
- preliminary injunction be made permanent, and if
said preliminary 1 injunction shall not have been granted,
then that a permanent injunction be granted per-
manently restraining and enjoining the defendant from
~ assessing or collecting or attempting to assess or collect
from the plaintiff in any manner whatsoever, whether
by lien or jeopardy or by distraint proceedings, in
Court or otherwise, any processing taxes under and

.

ee eeeeeeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeeEeEeEeEeEe—eEeE—eEe—eeeEeEeEeeeeeeee eee ee

26

pursuant to said Agricultural Adjustment Act and any
interest or penalty on account of plaintiff’s failure to
pay said processing tax, and from imposing-or giving
notice of intention to infpose any lien for said taxes
upon the property, real or personal, of the plaintiff;

5. That at the final hearing it be adjudicated that*
the provisions of said Agricultural Adjustment Act _
providing for the levying, assessing and collecting of
said processing taxes against and: from the plaintiff
are invalid, unlawful and unconstitutional on each and
every one of the grounds upon which they are herein-
above alleged to be. unlawful, invalid and unconstitu-
tional; and that the defendant has xo lawful right

to attempt in any manner. to cutlect said
19 processing taxes from the plaintiff or any

of the penalties or interest thereon purported
to be provided for in said Agricultural Adjustment
Act;

6. And plaintiff prays for such other and further
relief, both general and special, to which it may be
justly entitled.

(Signed) RICKERT RICE MILLS, INC.,
By FRED W. RICKERT, President.
(Signed) JOHN P. BULLINGTON,
(Signed) HOMER L. BRUCF,
BAKER, BOTRS, ANDREWS

- & WHARTON,
By (Signed) JNO. P’ BULLINGTON,

(Seal) Attorneys for Plairitiff.

State of Louisiana,
Parish of Orleans.

Before me, the undersigned authority, on this day
personally appeared Fred W..Rickert, who, having
‘beet by me first duly sworn, stated dn oath that he is
the President of Rickert Rice Mills, Inc., a corporation,

27

plaintiff i in the above cause, and that he has been duly
authorized by said corporation to make this affiuavit
for and in its behalf; that he has read the foregoing ‘
and above bill and knows the contents thereof and.
that the facts therein set out are true, except as to
such facts. as are therein stated on information and
belief, and that as ‘to those facts so stated to be on
information and belief{ he believes ‘them to be true.

(Signed) RED W. RIGKERT, -

Subscribed and Sworn to before me, this 25th day
of October, 1935.
(Signed) A. R: CHRISTOV ICH,
(Seal) Notary Public in and for Or-
leans Parish, Louisiana.

*-*

20 EXHIBIT-“A”.

Issued April 18, 1935.

United States Department of Agriculture,
Agricultural Adjustment Administration.

Administrative Rulings Relating to the 1935 Sauthern
Rice Production Adjustment Program.

vA

Explanation.

These Administrative Rulings apply to and are part
_of the Southern Rice Production Adjustment Contract
and documents pertaining: thereto.

If any of the provisions are not understood, the
Community or County Committee should be consulted.
No producer should make out aud submit to his
Community or County Committee an Application or a
Contract or other documents pertaining thereto with-—

28

out knowing exactly what he must do.in order to
receive the benefits of the program.

I. Definitions——As used in the Southern Rice Pro-
duction Adjustment Application, Declaration, Con- °
tract, Schedule, and these Administrative Rulings:

(a) . “Person,” “tenant,” “landlord,” “producer,”
and “well or canal operator,” include individuals, co-
partnerships, and corporations; and where it is re-
quired by the context, the singular shall include the
plural. ‘ e

(b) “Farm” means one contiguous tract of land
operated as one unit substantially separate from any
other such tract of land.

(c) “Producer” includes persons owning and oper-
ating their own farms; tevants operating farms rented
for cash; tenants operating farms under a crop-share
lease, contract, or agreement; landlords leasing to share
tenants; corporations, copartnerships, or individuals
furnishing water for production of rice on a share
basis; and such other persons or classes of persons
as the Secretary may determine to be eligible -to sign
Southern Rice Production Adjustment Contracts.

(d) - “Participation in the production of rice” means
sharing as a producer in any manner in the produc-
tion of rice on a farm.

(e) “Farming Operation” means the production of
rice or the particjpation in the production of rice by
a preducer.

(f) “Application” means any Application for Rice
Acreage Allotment (forms Rice 1 and 2) heretofore
or hereafter executed by any producer. “Application

29

serial number” means the serial number of any such
Application. |

(g) “Declaration” means. any 1935 Southern Rice
Declaration of Farm Acreage (form Rice 30) hereto-
fore or hereafter executed by any producer.- The “farm
serial number” means the serial number of any such
Declaration. :

(h) “Schedule” means any Producer’s Schedule of
Rice Acreage (Form Rice-37) heretofore or hereafter
executed by any producer. Each such Schedule shall
bear the same serial number as the Contract executed
by the producer who ‘executes the Schedule.

(i) “Contract” means any 1935 Southern Rice
Production Adjustment Contract (Form Rice-36) here-
tofore or hereafter executed by any producer. The
“Contract serial number” means the serial number of
any such Contract.

21 yp SS” means the period from Janu-
) ary 1, 1935 to December a1, 0935.

(k) 1934” means the period from January 1,
1934 to December: 31, 1934.. |

(1) The term “State base period” means the period
of calendar years 1929 to 1933, inclusive.

(m) The “State Allotment” shall be 135,000 acres
for Arkansas, 364,500 acres for Louisiana, and 142,500
acres for Texas. The “State Quota” shall be 1,834,-
722 barrels for Arkansas, 3,898,333 barrels for Louis-
iana, and 2,010,833 barrels for Texas.

¢ (n) The term “base period” in Arkansas and —
Louisiana means the period of the calendar years

30

1929 to 1933, inclusive, and in oo the years 1931
_ to 1933, inclusive.

(o) The‘ ‘production. history” of a producer means,
as the context may require, the producer’s rice acreage
or rice production, or both, for the base period as ad-
* justed to the official figures and accepted by the State
Committee.

(p) The “producer’s Allotment” and the “pro-
ducer’s Quota” means respectively the -rice acreage
and the rice production assigned by the State .Com-
mittee, acting for and on behalf of the Secretary, to
the producer. for 1935 and determined according to the
procedure set forth in Administrative Ruling II hereof.

(q) The “acreage allocated” by the producer means.
that part of a producer’s allotment which, in a De-
claration, he allocates. to a given farm as a basis for
determining his share of the total rice acreage planted
on that farm in 1935.

(r) “Producer’s share of the rice acreage planted”
and the “Producer’s share of the acreage planted to
rice in 1935” each means with respect to any farm,
that acreage which bears the same ratio to the total
rice acreage planted on that farm in 1935 (as de-
termined upon checking compliance with the Contract
in the manner prescribed by the Secretary.) that the
acreage allocated by the producer to that farm in a
Declaration, bears.to the total rice acreage allocated |
.to that farm in such Declaration.

(s) The “Secretary” means the Secretary of
Agriculture of the United States.

(t) “Rice Section” means the Rice Section of the
Agricultural Adjustment: Administration.

31

(u) “Official figures” means the records of acreage
and production prepared by the United States bial
ment of Agriculture.

(v) A “barrel” means 162 pounds of rough rice.
(w) A “bushel” means 45 pounds of rough rice.

Il. Determination: of Allotments and Quotas.—l.
The allotment of a producer shall be determined by
each State Committee as follows: (a) Add the
acreage of rice planted annually -by each producer
for his own account during the base period, after ad-.
justment of acreage of all producers to the official
figures for each state foreach of the years of the
base period; (b) Divide the total thus secured by
. five (5) in Louisiana and in Arkansas, and the total
thus secured by three (3) in Texas; (c ) Reduce the
result obtained by 20 per cent in Louisiana and in
Arkansas and the result obtained by 22 percent in
Texas.

The total allotments assigned to saiiisiaas in each
state shall not in any-event exceed the state allotment
for that State.

2.. The quota of a producer shall be determined by
each State Committee as follows: (a) Add the number
' of barrels of rough rice produced annually by each
producer for his own account during the base period,
after adjustment of the production of all producers
to official figures for each state for each of the years
of the base period; (b) Divide the total thus secured -
by five (5) in, Louisiana and in Arkansas, and the
total thus secured by three (3) in Texas ;\ (c ) Reduce
the result obtained by 20 percent in Louisiana and in

Arkansas and the result obtained by 22! percent in
Texas.

32

The total quotas assigned to producers in each state
shall not in any event exceed the state quota for that
state.

3. If the total of allotments and quotas deter-
mined according to the provisions of sections 1 and 2
of this numbered ruling, in any state, is less than the’
State Allotment and State Quota such excess may
be allocated to producers by the State Committee, sub-
ject to approval by the Secretary or his authorized
agent. ,

:; 4. The Allotment and Quota are based ~
upor the personal production history of the producer,
regardless. of where the rice was produced and are
the measure of such history. The producer’s produc-
tion history shall not be transferred except as the
State Committee shall, in writing, approve transfers
made pursuant to the provisions of subsections a, b,
and c of this numbered paragraph 4 of Administra-
tive Ruling II. All requests for transfer of produc-
tion history shall be in writing, signed by, or on behalf
of the producer by his duly authorized agent, and ap-
proval thereof shall be in writing signed by at least
two members of the State Committee. In no event
shall the State Committee approve the transfer of
production’ history by reason of foreclosure, execution
or any forced sale. :
(a) If a producer has died or has been declared
‘legally incompetent by a Court of competent juris-
diction and has not executed, prior to the date of such
death or incompetency, an Application for an allotment
and quota, his records of production may be used by
such heirs or devisees, or such member of the family
of such deceased producer or by such members of the
family of such incompetent producer as are continuing
the farming operation of the deceased or incompetent
producer, upon their furnishing proof of such relation-

ship and succession to the producer’s farming opera-
tion. ” : .

(b) If a well or canal operator voluntarily sells
his well or canal system and has not executed an
application; his production history shall be trans-
‘ferred to such successor, provided that the former well
or canal operator was not engaged in farming sania
tions in 1934,

_(c). If a paftnership is* dissolved before an applica-
tion for an allotment and quota has been executed
by or on behalf of the partnership, its records of rice.
production for the base period shall be divided among
the partners in such proportions as is agreed upon
by the partners or their authorized ‘representatives in
Writing submitted to the State Committee.

5. In all figures representing final ‘determination
of individual allotments and quotas, fractions amount-
ing to one-half a ‘unit or less shall be dropped and
fractions amounting to more than one-half a. unit
shall. be considered a whole unit.

6. If a producer — the base period had oper-
ated in more than one state, he shall apply for an
allotment’ and quota to the State Committee of: each
state in which he had farmed during the base period.
Only the history é¢arned by the producer in that state
shall be presented to the State Committee in his
Application. No producer shall be assigned Allot--
ments and Quotas in two or more‘states, larger in
the aggregate, than the Allotments and Quotas assign-
able to him in one state, had all of his farming opera-
tions been confined to that one state.

7. The sum of all pn and of all. Quotas
within a State shall not in any event exceed the State
Allotment and Quota, respectively.

34

III. - Transfer of Allotment and Quota.—The pro-
ducer’s Allotment and Quota shall not be transferred
except as the State Committee shall in writing approve
transfers made pursuant to the provisions of sub-
sections a, b, c, and d of this Ruling III. In no event
shall the State Committee approve the transfer of an
Allotment or Quota by reason of foreclosure, execution,
or any forced sale. - All requests for transfer shall be
'made in writing signed by or on behalf -of the pro--
- ducer by his duly authorized agent, and approval there-
of shall be in writing. signed by at least two members
of the State. Committee.

(a) If a producer dies or has been declared in-
competent by a Court of competent jurisdiction after
executing an Application but before executing: a Con-
tract, his allotment and quota may be transferred to
such ‘heirs, devisees, or such members of the family
of such deceased producer or such members of the
family of such incompetent producer as are continuing
the farming operations of the deceased or incompetent
producer, upon their furnishing proof of such relation-_
ship and succession to the producér’s farming opera-
tion. ;

23 ~ (b) If a producer voluntarily withdraws,

either wholly or in part,.from the production
of rice after executing an Application but before. exe-
cuting a Contract, he may transfer all or part of his
Allotment and Quota to such persons as are continu-
ing his farming operation, upon: proof of such with-
drawal and _ succession. |

(c) If a producer has become disabled and has
retired from the production of rice after executing an
Application but before executing a Contract, he may
transfer all or part of his Allotment and Quota to such

» 35

person as is continuing his farming operations upon
proof of such disability, retirement, and succession.

(d) Upon dissolution of a partnership, after an
Application has been. executed by’ or on behalf of the
partnership, but before a Contract has been executed
by or on behalf of the partnership, the Allotment and
Quota shall. be divided among the partners in such
proportions as is agreed upon by the partners or their
duly authorized representatives in writing submitted
to the State Committee.

IV. Use of Allotment and Quotas by Well or Canal
Operators.—If a well or canal operator has an allot-
‘ment and quota assigned to him by the State Commit-
tee on the basis of his personal history as a furnisher
of water on a crop share basis, such well or canal
operator shall-not change his status, so as to use such
allotment and quota in a capacity other than as a ‘fur-
nisher of water on a share crop basis.

V. Signing of Application, Declaration, Contracts,
and Other Documents by a Person in a Representative
Capacity.—

(1). ts the event any document is to be exevaued
on behalf of a Corporation, it shall be signed on behalf
of the Corporation by an officer of the Corporation,
who shall state his title, and affix the corporate seal
to the Contract, (If the Corporation has no cor-
porate seal, the following statement in writing shall
appear over the signature, “No corporate seal re-
quired or adopted,”) or by a representative of the
corporation other than an officer, who has been au-
thorized by the corporation to execute the contract
by power of attorney, under seal, duly executed on
behalf of the corporation on a prescribed form and

36

filed with the Comptroller of the Agricultural ~~
justment Administration at Washington, D. C.,
attached to the contract, which authorization shall be
considered a part of the contract documents.

(2) In the event a document is to be signed by
an executor, administrator, guardian of an incompe-

tent person, receiver, or other person appointed by a-

Court in a fiduciary capacity, there shall be furnished
either the original or a. certified copy of the Court
order of appointment or a certificate on a prescribed
form showing that such person was duly appointed
_as such fiduciary and that the appointment is still in
full force and effect.

(3) Where a document is signed by a manager or
an agent for a producer, the original or a certified copy
of a Power of Attorney, on a prescribed form, author-
izing the manager or agent so to sign shall be fur-

nished.

(4) If.the producer is a Governmental body or
agency, there shall be attached to the document a
certified copy of a resolution of the Board or other
authority authorized by statute to lease and contract
in regard to the land and personal. property covered
by the contract, authorizing the execution of such
document by the person executing the document on

its behalf.

(5) When one'producer has several documents to “

be signed by the same agent or. attorney, a properly
executed power of attorney may be filed with the
Comptroller of the Agricultural Adjustment Adminis-
tration to cover all such cases, and shall be considered
as a part of each document, so signed.

(6) A document to be signed fot.a_partnership
shall be executed in the name of the partnership and
of each partner as an individual, by each member of

37

the partnership, or on behalf of each partner .

24 who does not personally sign, by an agent

duly authorized to so -sign by a Power of
Attorney, on a prescribed form.

VI. Pica of Adjustment Payments.—Adjustment
payments may not be assigned under any condition.
This is forbidden by the ieebiaieg as well as prohibited |
by law. |

However, the producer’s right to adjustment. pay-
ments under the Contract may be pledged in
order to obtain funds (or credit) for carrying. on the
current operation of the farm. The expression “funds”

(or credit) for carrying on the current operation of

the farm and “current production credit” means funds’
or credit to meet any necessary expense of preparing
of land, planting, cultivating, watering, harvesting, and
marketing of the rice crop grown in the year 1935.
Without in any way limiting the exclusiveness of the’
above definition, the expression shall not include cash
‘rent or debts incurred in connection with the produc-
tion of past crops.

No pledge of any producer’s right. to adjustment
payments under his contract for any purpose other
than to procure current production credit as defined
above shall give rise to any obligation under the Con-
tract upon any payee designated therein by the pro-
_ ducer to distribute such payment, when and if accepted
by such pay ee, to the person claiming to hold such a
-pledge not given for current production credit.

Dated April 18, 1935.
R. G. TUGWELL,

Acting Secretary of Agriculture.

EXHIBIT “B”.

- Form Rice 36,
U. S. Department of Agriculture,
Agricultural Adjustment Administration, -
Rice Section.
Form .approved by Comptroller General, U. S.,
May 1, 1935.

4

1935 Southern Rice Production Adjustment Contract.

(Pursuant:to and to effectuate the purposes of the
Agricultural Adjustment Act, approved May 12,
1933, as amended, hereinafter. referred to: as the
Act.) .

I. Performance by Producer:

1. The undersigned producer (and each and all
of them if more than one signs this instrument) here-
by offer(s) to enter. into a contract with the Secretary
of Agriculture (hereinafter referred to as the “Secre-
tary”) upon the terms and conditions hereinafter set
forth and subject to such regulations or administra-
tive rulings (which shall be part of the terms and

conditions of this contract): as have been heretofore or. °

mzv hereafter be prescribed by the Secretary relating
io .935 Southern Rice Production Adjustment Con-
tracts. This contract shall apply to every farm upon
which the producer participates in any manner in the .
production of rice in 1935 (hereinafter referred to
as “the farm(s) covered by ‘this contract”). This
_ offer shall become a binding contract upon its accept-
ance by ‘the Secretary.

2. The producer,

(a) Represents that he has allocated to each farm
upon which he will participate in any manner in the

39

production of rice in 1935 some part of his allotment
and that the total acreage allocated by the producer
‘to. all such farms does not exceed his allotment;

(b) Agrees that he will not share or participate in
any manner in the production of rice in 1935 on any
farm to which he has not allocated a portion of his
allotment ;

(c) Agrees that for‘the purpéses of checking com-
pliance and making payments under this contract “the
producer’s share of the acreage planted to rice in
1935” on each farm covered by this contract shall be
that acreage actually planted-to rice on such farm
in 1935 which bears the same rati- to the total acre- .
age planted to rice on such farm in 1935 that the
acreage allocated by the producer to such farm bears
to the total acreage allocated thereto by all persons
participating in the production of rice thereon;

(d) Agrees that his total share of the acreage
planted to rice in 1935 on all the farms covered by
this contract shall not exceed his* allotment ;:

(e) Agrees that the acreage permitted under this.
contract to be planted to rice in 1935 shall be farmed
in a workmanlike manner throughout 1935;

(f) Applies.for membership in the Rice Production
Control] Association organized pursuant to Form Rice

35 in each County or Parish in which a farm covered
by this contract is located;

(g) Agrees to permit access by any authorized
agent of the Secretary to the farm(s) covered by this
contract, and to all fiscal books, records, and -docu-
ments, regardless of where located, pertaining to the

40

production and/or sale of rice on or fram any
26 and all of such farms, and expressly waives
any right to have such records kept confi-

dential ; a! ; : ;
(h) Agrees nat to sell, pledge, transfer, or assign,
in whole or in part, this contract ~or his right to or
claim for payments under this contract, and not
to execute any power of attorney to collect such .
payments, and any sale, pledge or assignment, order
or power of attorney shall be null and void, except
that the producer may pledge or hypothecate his right
to any adjustment payments under this contract for
the. purpose of obtaining funds (or credit) for carry-
ing on the current operation of the/farm(s) covered
by this-contract (hereinafter referred to as “current
production credit”) and such pledge or hypothecation
shall operate to establish an interest or right on the,
part of the pledgee * in and to said adjustment pay-
ments as against any other person or persons, but
the pledge or hypothecation thereof shall not alter the
provisions of paragraph 5 that all adjustment pay-
ment checks drawn in compliance with this contract
shall be made pavable to the payee therein stipulated.
If the aceite teed payments herein provided for shall
have been pledged by the producer for current pro-.
duction credit, the producer, or.if'a payee is designated
in: paragraph 5.hereof and accepts such payment, then
such payee if notified in writing of the pledge, shall
receive the adjustment payment in trust to pay there-
from to the pledgee the amount of the obligation owing
for current production credit secured by such pledge
and to pay the balance of said payment to the producer.
If a payee other than the producer is named in para-
graph 5 hereof, and if such payee shall not have been
notified of any pledge of the adjustment payments °
for-current production credit made pursuant to the
terms of this numbered paragraph, such payee shall
receive such payments in trust to pay the whole amount

41

thereof to the producer, it being expressly understood
‘and agreed that the Secretary shall have no duty or
obligation to see that distribution is made in accord-
ance with the foregoing provisions, but shall have the
right to, enforce the performance of said trust by the -
payee; ?

(i) Represents that the statements contained here-
in are true to the best of his -information and belief.
Without limitation of. any other right’or remedy of
the Secretary conferred, by law or this’ contract, a
material misstatement herein or in any. information
furnished by the producer in connection with this
contract or any noncompliance by the producer with
any of the terms hereof, or with any applicable regula-
.tion or administrative ruling which has been or inay
‘hereafter be prescribed by the Secretary with reference
to 1935 Southern Rice Production Adjustment Con-
tracts shall be grounds for termination of this contract
by the Secretary. The determination of the Secretary
that any such misstatement or noncompliance has
occurred shall be final and conclusive. In the event
of termination of this contract by the Secretary, the
producer shall return to the Secretary all payments
theretofore made under this contract, together with al!
costs incident to the collection thereof.

II.. Performance by Secretary:

3. Amount of Payments.—The Secretary shall, as
a consideration for the performance by the producer
of all-the terms and conditions of this contract, and in
the manner and at the times specified in paragraph 4

hereof, make

(1) A first* adjustment payment at a rate of 81
cents per barrel of rice, and

42 ia.

(2) :
That the United States of America is the real party
in interest, which may not be sued without its con-
sent.

ITT.

That there ‘is no actual controversy between com-
plainant and defendant or between any partjes over

~

ee pt nt a ee ee eee ee ee er ere.

56

which ilate ‘Court has jurisdiction within the purview
of the iain | sicaataiaat Act,

; el

That the ee Judgment Act was not intended
by the Congress. to be used for the litigation. of ques-
tions arising under the Revenue Laws, and particu-

/”

. darly was. not intended as a means ‘for: obtaining. in-

junctive relief, , 7
This proceeding is prohibited by the provisions of

the Declaratory Judgment Act, as: amended, and can-.

not be maintained. (Revenue Act of 1935, approved

August ' 31, 1935, ‘Section 405).

V of ° Oe tob er. iG3z5

+ eee y of Oetober, 1935.
(Sed.) RENE A. VIOSCA, .
| , United States "Attorney.
(Sgd.) ROBERT WEINSTEIN, =
Assistant United States
‘Attorney.

¢
\

36 RETURN TO ‘RULE TO SHOW CAUSE.

WHY - TEMPORARY INJUNCTION
SHOULD NOT ISSUE.
-}

Filed Oct ei 1935. .
- (Title Omitted. )

To the Honorable the Judge of the District Court of |

the United States in and.for the " astern District

of Louisiana:
Now into Court comes Rufus W. Seaiin Acting
Collector of Internal. Revenue, Defendant in the above .
entitled and numbered cause, through Rene A. Viosca, .

»

= 57

United States Attorney in and for the Eastern District

of Louisiana, and Robert, Weinstein; Assistant United
States: Attorney for said District,. his. attorneys, and
by virtue of the rules and practice of this Court* re-

quiring the defendant in rule to file all defenses to the

rule on the date set for the hearing on the application
for a temporary, injunction, and with full reservation
of all of his rights under the pleadings in this cause,
answers the rule,by stating that for. lack of sufficient °
informationyto’ justify a belief he denies all of the
allegations of paragraph two, three, four, five, six,
sevén, eight, nine, ten, eleven, twelve, thirteen, four-
teen, ‘fifteen, sixteen, seventeen and eighteen’ ‘of the
Bill of Complaint, and also denies the allegations of
paragraph one with the exception of the statement
relative to the defendant, which statemer't is admitted.

Your Respondent further avers tha roceedings
should be dismissed for the reasons that this Honor-
able Court has no jurisdiction and that the Agricul-°

3
TO

‘- tural Adjustment Act is constitutional, valid and

senforceable. .

Wherefore, your Respondent prays this Honorable
Court to dismiss the Bill of Complaint at Complain-
ant’s costs and to refuse granting any injunction in

these proceedings, and: for all general and equitable.

relief.
; (Signed) RENE A. VIOSCA.
| United States Attorney.
« + (Signed) ROBERT WEINSTEIN,
4 Asst. United States Attorney.

37 os Verification.

State of Louisiana,

Parish of Orleans.
Before. me; the undersigned sathosity, nr

‘ a

came Rene A. Viosca, who is the United States mt

a ©

torney tee the Eastern District of Loulsiahe, who in -
-‘his oath says: That in his aforesaid official capacity
he is of counsel for defendant in the above case; that
he has drawn’the return to the rule to show cause and
that all the allegations of fact therein are “true. and
correct-to the best of ‘his knowledge, information and |
‘belief. | ,
; (Signed) RENE A. Nieeatiel
* + Sworn to and subscribed before me this 28th day. of .
3 October, 1935. |
(Signed)) CLAUDE D. SHAW’

— | a Deputy Clerk, U. S. District

| Court, Eastern District of

(Seal) Louisiana. é

| 38 ORDER CONSOLIDATING ALL CASES
J FOR PURPOSE OF TRIAL. , *

Filed Qct. 28, 1935).

y United States District Court, Eastern District of ”
: Louisiana, New Orleans Division.

Docket No. 321 (Equity)
Rickert Rice Mills, ins.,

‘versus .
Rufus W. Peannst: Individually and as Acting
. Collector of Internal Revenue.

Docket No. 322° (Equity).:

ial

A. B. — doing business under the name of The
Dore Rice Mill,
' -versus
| "Rufus: W. Fontenot, Individually and as Acting
7 Collector of Internal Revenue.

Docket No. 323 (Equity).

United Rice Milling Products Co., Inc. ,
i versus. ~~
Rufus W. Fontenot, Individually and as Acting
_ Collector of Internal evenue.

Docket’ No. 324 (Equity).
Baton Rouge Rice Mg Inc.,

* versus
Rufus W. Voninet. Individually. and as Acting:
Collector of Internal Revenue.

Docket No. 325 (Equity).
" T. Simon

, versus
Rufus W.. Fontenot, Individually and: as “Acting .
Collector of Internal Revenue.

‘ Docket No. 326 (Equity).

Levy Rice Milling Company, Inc.,
versus by
Rufus W. Fontenot, Individually ‘and as Acting
Collector of Internal Revenue.

Docket No. 327 (Equity). , a

‘Tomes Rice Milling a weed Inc.,
: versus *
Rufus W. Fontenot, Individually ory as Acting .
Collector of Internal Revenue. ;

, . Docket’ No. 328 (Equity).
Noble-Trotter Rice Milling Co., Inc.,
‘ versus

; ~ Rufus W: Fontenot, Individually ail as Acting
Collector of Internal Revenue.

‘ “ = 60

4
Considering the stipulation and agreement of coun-
_ Sel for all parties made this day in open Court; +

. It is Ordered that the above numbered. and ‘entitled
- Gases be and they are hereby consolidated’ for the
. Purpose of trial and that the. affidavits and evidence m

offered in one case be considered to apply’ to all.
(Signed) JOHN .McDUFFIE, Judge.

New Orleans, Louisiana, Octobem28, 1935. én

> % AFFIDQVIT OF W. M. REID. \

Filed Oct. 28, 1935. :

; “Copy.”
State of Louisiana, “
Parish of Orleans. -
_ Before me, the undersigned authority, on this day:
. personally appeared W. M. Reid, known to me; who
* being by me first duly sworn in terms of law deposed
and said on his oath as follows:

re My name is W. M. Reid. I reside in New Orleans,
Louisiana, and am Executive Secretary of the Rice”
Millers’, Association. My principal duties are the
preparation and interpretation of statistical and econ-.
omic data with regard to the rice mlling ‘industry. I
-have been engaged in, the rice fhilling business since
1909, and from 1916 to 4928, I ‘personally ‘operated
a rice mill. I am thoroughly familiar with ‘the ‘rice
milling industry in all of its phases.
I have read all of the allegations contained in Sec-
‘tion 12 of Plaintiff’s bill of complaint andsEquity 321,
“Rickert Rice Milling Company vs. Rufus W. Fontenot,
Equity 322, A. B. Dore vs. Rufus W. Fontenot, Eauity
323, United Rice Milling Products Company, Inc..
vs. Rufus W. Fontenot and companion cases, and all

%,

61

‘of guch allegations are true and cofrect i in every re-
spect.

-It is true that-rice millers, when they purchase rough
rice, consider Tact that they will have to pay a .
processing tax on the milling of sugh rough rice. How-
.ever, this is simply one of the many factors entering
into the miller’s deternfination of what he ought to
pay for rough rice. As a practical matter, when the
rice miller negotiates for the purchase of a given ‘lot
of rice, he first estimates what he believes’ he could get
‘for such rice after milling on the existing market for
clean rice and rice products.. He then estimates what
‘he thinks it will cost him. to process the rough rice
into its various grades and products, and in @is esti-
mate is included the amount of the processing tax, as
weil as other taxes. Having made these estimates,
he determines what ‘he ought, to pay for the rough rice.
_ However this is not necessarily what he does ,pay, be- -
cause each individual miller is buying in competition
with other millers. ‘Thus, if other millers are paying
more. than he thizks he ought to pay, he has to meet.
the price the others are paying, if he is to get any
rice. No individual millér| makes the rough. rice
market. It is a-market made ‘of the composite piir-

chasing of all millers in ,the particular terri-

40 _ tpry. While the estimates above referred to
are made with regard to the market for clean

‘rice and rice preducts. at the time of the purchase of
the rough rice, that market, however, does not: nec¢s-
sarily control since rough rice is not ordinarily milled,
. and the clean rice and’ products .sold until several
months after the purchase of the: rough rice. |

' Since the market for clean rice and rice products
fluctuafés from. day to day and morth to month, ‘the .
prospects of the.future market has a bearing on whats
the miller may have to pay for rough rice. Optimism
with reference to. the futlere market for clean rice on
the part of a sufficient number of rice millers will
force up the market for rough rice, and all millers will

e ,
*.

aft lon

Houston, Texas, and again on December 27,
1934, and ran through January 2, 1935.

The Bay City Rice Mills in that proceeding took
the position, and so advised the Secretary of Agricul-
ture’s representatives, that it was utterly impossible, .
owing to the manner in which the rice industry is con- '
ductéd, through the sale of clean rice on samples made
up of mixes of different lots of clean rice, as more
fully set out in the bills of complaint presented to the
United States District Court at New Orleans in the
processing tax ‘suits, to determine in the case of any
lot of rice, whether the clean rice had been sold tor
79¢ more than the rough rice had cost, or for the
: amount above the cost of the clean rice that
46 the Secretary required under Section 1 of

Article IV. ;

The Secretary of Agriculture’s representatives had
access to all the books, vouchers and records of the
Bay City Rice Mills, both in connection with its
rough rice purchases and its clean rice sales and had
several auditors continuously working on those re-
cords. The amount paid for the rough rice purchased
from Fvoritt, Powers and Reed, as set forth in ‘said

Charge II was established. The clean rice derived
from the rough rice purchased from these three pro-
ducers was traced at.the hearing into the. sales of
clean rice into which they entered and the price of
clean rice sales was established. However, owing to
the’ fact that each quantity of clean rice that went
into a sale was made up of a mixture from various
lots of:clean rice, which were. in turn produced frem
_Vvarious lots of rough rice bought from different pro-
ducers, and owing to the fact that there was, as is
usual in the rice business, an almost infinite variation
in the combinations of these mixes of clean rice lots,
and owing to. the fact that rough rice when milled,
- produces different grades of clean rice, as set forth in

the above mentioned bills of complaint, ‘the Secretary of —

Agriculture was never able to show .in that case whether
or not the Bay City Rice Mills had obtained for the
clean rice derived from the Evoritt, Powers, and Reed
rough rice the amount (roughly 79c) above the cost
of the rough rice that Article IV, Section 1, attempted

me

to require the mill’ to get. Although that was one .-

of the charges most vitally affecting the entire rice
program in affiant’s belief, and although the Secretary
of Agriculture through his two attorneys who prose-

cuted the case and through his several auditors who -

Were continuously working on the records of the Bay

City Mills made every effort to prove the charge, the - ©

Secretary of Agriculture in his findings did not find
that the charge had been proven and did not find that
the Bay City Rice Mills had violated the license in the
manner set forth in Charge 11.

‘Affiant believes, and on that belief states, that the ©
reason the Secretary of Agriculture did not find that
Charge 11. had been supported by any evidence was
, because it was utterly impossible practically to show
. whether clean rice had been sold for the amount above
the rough rice cost that the license ‘required.

71°

The charge referred specifically to the sale of clean

rice lots 36, 43 123 and 124. Evidence as -

47 to the history of those clean rice lots is as set -
out below. nA

The cléan rice in each case was included in various
sales, each sale being represented by a separate invoice.
The history of those clean rice lots was as follows:
(As shown /by. . record in that case.)

‘Clean Ricebot J.

This rice came *from rough rice lot 33 from C. E.
Everitt. It was mixed with various other lots of rice
and went in as a part of the rice sold and represented
by the following 9 invoices: Invoice Nos. 6615, 6622,
6634, 6639, 6645, ‘ore? 6770, 6771 and T-162 (R.
324-326). .

The rice covered by invoice No. 6615 was made up
of rice from various lots as follows:

39 pockets from lot 17, fancy _

125 pockets from lot 31, fancy -

200 pockets from lot, 36, fancy

26 pockets from lot 33, heads

26 pockets’ from lot 31, heads
(R. 472.)

Invoice 6622 consisted of the following :
75 pockets from lot 26, fancy
250 pockets from lot 35, fancy
175 pockets from_ lot 36, fancy .
(R. 475.) :

Invoice 6634 consisted of the following:

148 von from lot 34 EP ©
75 pockets from lot 35 EP

~

-Invoices but they: were all mixes.

2 °°

75 pockets from lot 36 EP
81 pockets from lot 37 EP
. 68 pockets fr§m lot 38 EP
150 pockéts from lot 43 EP
. 201 pockets from lot 45 EP

© ; AR. 478.)

There was no evidence whatsoever as- to the different
lots going to make up the rice on any of the other
invoices heretofore or hereafter referred to, but each
invoice represented a‘ mix from various lots.

Cate Rice Lot 43:

This lot went into invoices 6634, 6639, 6644, T-126,

' 'T-127, T-128, and P-1006 (R. 327-329). No evidence -

was introduced as to the component part of those in-
voices, except invoice 6634 above set forth, but they all
consisted of mixes.
Chee Rice Lot 123:

This rice went into sie following Invoices :

”

48 Invoices. Nos. 6832, 6833, T-187, T-18

6840, T-195, 6839, T-200, 6885, 6886, T-201,
T-202, T-187, T-188,-and T-182 (R. 329 et seq.). No
evidence was ‘introduced as to the lots going into these

bd

Clean Rice Lot 124:
Affiant docs not have the record at this time as 74
what invoices this lot went into but it was mixed into

a number of mixed invoices.

To have traced the cost of the various lots of clean
rice that went into each invoice would-have beey long
involved and in fact practically impossible, “ad then
to trace the cost of all rice going into all invoices into
Which any _one of these clean rice lots went would

‘i \

a 73.
have involved further and innumerable records and
evidence. , . *

.

This: is further illustrated when. it is noticed. that
a large number of rough rice’ lots and clean -rice lot
were involved, as, for example, in Charge 11. it re-
ferred to rough rice lot as high as No. 154 and clean

* rice fot. as wen as No. 124.

No charge was’made that B&y City Rice Mills did °
not keep accurate and compete records of its opera- _~

tions. a P 4
” d

Nor was any issue made as to the fact that fhe
selling of rice by samples And mixing rice was ust
and customary. \

4

For exampie, Mr. F. A. _—s who ventified as a

, witness for the Secretary of Agriculture, and who is the

"Manager of Standard Rice Company, one of the largest

* rice milling companies in the United States, testified
as follows:

~

“Mr, Farda:

Well, it is not commoa practice, in fact it is not
a practice to make a mixture just in order to put it in
a warehouse and keep it. You make the mixture
when you sell your rice, get ready to sell it, you sell it
on a sample and then you make your composite mix-
ture and your lots match your sample. That is a
common practice.

“Mr. Davant:

Is it not ‘a practice to make up these samples prac-
tically in the beginning of the’ season and to send
them out as types? ,

-

i Ce ee le a x

Ey eae ee

74

“Mr Pads:

The pratice is to make hand mixes, and to send them
samples, and when you sell on the samples you make
your actual mixture, make it up.” (R. 420-421.)

* ’ * * * :

“Mr. Farda:
The usual practice is, you don’t make your mix
until you have the rice sold.” (R. 429-430.)

*

“ 49 “Mr. Farda:

You néver make a mix until you have

- a sale made, because it would not be of material ad-

vantage to do so because you may not find another
market for that particular blend that you*make. You
therefore keep your rice in the original lots to be in
a position#te make.a blénd of whatever the trade or
market requires at that time.”” (R..430.)

In connection with the above lots of clean rice, the
Secretary’s attorneys tried to make some allocation
of the cost of rough rice to the different grades of
clean rice produced as between fancy rice and head
rice, but this was realized by all to be purely arbitrary
allocation of cost without any real or sound basis for

the same.

The above proceeding against Bay City Rice Mills
was a proceeding before the Secretary of Agriculture
to forfeit the license of Bay City Rice Mills for alleged
violation of the license. The hearing was held before
a representative of the Secretary of Agriculture.

In the foregoing affidavit the figure .of 79c above
rough rice cost has been referred to. That, as stated,
was used only roughly. Under the license, the price’
for clean rice was to be. the price fixed for rough rice
plus the conversion charge plus the carload rail rate

)
75

for transporting rough rice to the miller’s mill plus

the admpfiistrative assessment of 5c per barrel. The.

conversion charge was 70c’per barrel plus 9c per barrel

if standard one hundred pound, single packages were

used for clean rice plus Sc per barrel if cotton or paper
interlinings were used. This would make the spread
between the rough rice price and clean rice price ap-
proximately 89c extlusive of the freight item.

(Sgd.) HOMER L. BRUCE.

Subscribed and Sworn to before me, the undersigned

authority, by Homer L. Bruce, this 27th day of Octo-
ber, 1935.
(Sed.) RAYMOND REILSON, ©
(Seal) - Notary Public in and_ for
Harris County, Texas.

50 AFFIDAVIT OF'L. J. BARTEL, R. F.
GOULD AND J. J>MAYER.

Filed Oct. 28, 1935.
“Copy.”

State of Louisiana,

Parish of Orleans.

We, L. J. Bartel, R. F. Gould,.and J. J. Mayer,

each first being duly sworn, deposes and says:

That we are Deputy Collectors of the Treasury)

-partment, Internal Revenue Service, Louisiana Dis-
trict, working in connection with the rice processing
tax division, and that the experience of each in the
ricé industry, prior to becoming Deputy Collectors, is
as follows: L. J. Bartel has had actual experience of

at

ae

: { :
76 | |

approximately twenty years in buying rough rice;
operation of rice milling plants, and the distribution
of milled rice and by-products. R. F. Gould has had
actual experience as follows: Fifteen years with the
‘largest rice millers of the industry as Office Manager,
and Chief Accountant; one year as Secretary, and |
auditor of a rough rice buying agency for New Or-
leans rice mills, and one and one-half years as traveling
auditor for the Millers Committee, an agency operat-
ing under a Marketing Agreement for the Southern
Rice Industry. J.-J. Mayer has had approximately
seven years actual experience in buying, sciling and
grading’ rough rice and distributing milled rice, and
by-products. Our broad experience, as above out-
| lined, reveals the following facts as existing in the | Tice
milling industry:

‘There is no established market price on rough rice,
and. the method of buying the rough rice by the millers
is a competitive bidding method. Each miller has
his buyer, who makes the competitive bid on the basis
outlined to hint bythe management of the mill. The
basis is as follows: Rice millers determine the price
to make their bid to a producer for his rough’ rice
‘based on the prevailing market price for milled rice
computing the values to the different grades and by-
products obtained from the processing of the rough
rice being bid upon.. For example:

A lot (parcel) of rough rice, estimated to produce
(per barrel of 162 pounds) the following articles,
grades, classes, etc., when processed, with estimated
values as set out for each of the respective grades,
classes, ete.:

Fancy Head Rice—100 pounds at 4%4c ......
Second Head Rice—4 pounds at 3c ........ At

77

Screenings Rice—6 pounds at 2¥%4c ........ oe

Brewers Rice—2 pounds at 2c ............ 04
Total a per barrel—112 pounds. | .
Se I ns) one Kae ceeles hese $4.81 plus
Approximate revenue rn by-products

(25c per barrel of 162 pounds) ..:.... .25
co | a Lea eee te $5.06

Competitive bidding. basis prior to the processing
tax law requiring payment of a processing tax in cash:
The above $5.06 is the gross value of milled
51 - rice articles-and by-products resulting from a
162 pound barrel of rough rice. The mill
would deduct from this gross figure the conversion
charge, this conversion figure including the mills ex-
pense for processing the rough rice, and the estimated
profit. Assuming that this conversion would be 60c
per: barrel, the oni! would then bid the producer $5.06,
less the 60c conversion, or $4.46 per barrel for the
rough rice. The affiants solemnly swear that they
have used and seen records of various rice mills estab-
lishing the basis as outlined above.

; Competitive Bidding Basis after the Processing Tax
Law requiring Payment of a Processing Tax in Cash:

_ Since the beginning of the 1933 crop movement, which

become available for market during the month of July,
and on which the processing tax applies, the rice millers
use the same basis to determine values; however, in
addition to deducting the conversion charge, the rice
millers deduct also the 18 per pound processing tax
on the rough rice, or $1.62 per barrel, and submits his
bid to the producer, less this deduction, as follows:

_ For the value of the same lot of rough rice as above
- illustrated, estimated to produce milled rice and by-
products with gross values of $5.06 per barrel, the. rice

78

miller deducts the following: Conversion 60c and pro-
cessing tax $1.62, or a total of $2.22 per barrel, and
makes bid to the ‘producer of $2.84 per barrel for that
particular lot of rough rice.

The affiants further solemnly swear that in their
practical experience they have prepared, and have seen
prepared profit and loss statements for certain. given
periods other than the entire season; further that these
profit and loss statements are prepared on particular
lots of rice, which is essential and necessary in their
accounting procedure. Should the Agricultural .Ad-
justment Act be held unconstitutional, the affiants
state that the rice processors should enjoy the remedy
and benefits given by Section 21 (d) of the said Agri-
cultural Adjustment Act, as amended August 27th,
1935, because the records of buying processing and.
selling kept by the rice mills are adequate enough to
properly allocate the cost of various grades of milled
rice and its by-products, resulting from the processing
of the rough rice; also to properly allocate in this cost,
the processing tax, proportionately to the various grades
of each lot of milled rice sold by ,itself alone’ or
mixed. The greater portion of the milfed rice sales are
straight mill run lots without’ blending.

The affiants further solemnly swear that they have
kept -or have seen rice millers’ records which reflect
correct cost of production, profits from sales, etc.,
properly allocated to milled rice of various varieties,

and grades, and by-products, and similarly al-
52 located as to profits in selling prices, and

should the Agricultural Adjustment Act be
proven unconstitutional, each rice processor has suffi-
cient records to enable him to recover in accordance
with Section 21 (d): of the Agricultural Adjustment
Act, as amended. : i

79

‘Summed up, the introduction of the rice processing
tax has in no wise altered the customary manner or
procedure followed by the rice milling industry in
conducting their business.

(Sed.) - L. J. BARTEL,
(Sed.) = R. F. GOULD, ~
(Sed.)° JAMES J. MAYER.

Subscribed -and sworn to before me this 28th day of
October, 1935.
(Sgd.) HOMER R. ROBINSON,
Deputy Collector.

53 DECREE.

Filed October 28, 1935.
United States District Court, Eastern District of
Louisiana. New Orleans Division.

Rickert Rice Mills, Inc.,
: versus . No. 321 (Equity).
Rufus W. Fontenot, Individually and as Acting Col-
lector of Internal Revenue for the District of
Louisiana. : .

This cause came on today to be heard upon the
application of the plaintiff for a preliminary injunc-
tion, as well as upon the motion filed on behalf of the
defendant to dismiss the bill of - complaint, and was
argued by counsel for the respective parties ;

Whereupon, and upon consideration thereof, and for
the reasons orally assigned;

“It is Ordered, Adjudged and Decreed that the .ap-
plication for the Preliminary Injunction be and the
same is hereby denied ;

80

It is Further Ordered, Adjudged and Decreed that
the plaintiff’s petition and bill of complaint i in all re-
spects bé dismissed.

(Signed) JOHN McDUFFIE, Judge.

. New Orleans, Louisiana, October 28, 1935.

MOTION OF PLAINTIFF FOR INJUNCTION
e PENDING APPEAL & ORDER. |

54 Filed Oct. 29, 1935.

In the United States District Court for the Eastern
District of Louisiana.

| Rickert Rice Milling Company, Inc.,
versus No: 321 (In Equity).
Rufus W. Fontenot, Individually, etc.

Comes-now the plaintiff in the above entitled and .
numbered cause and moves the Court to grant plain-
tiff an injunction pending appeal for the reason that,
unless such injunction pending appeal is granted: plain-
tiff, plaintiff will be compelled to pay the taxes re-
ferred to in plaintiff’s petition before plaintiff’s appeal
can be determined by the Circuit Court of Appeals,
thus causing it great and irreparable injuries. Plain-
tiff offers to furnish good and sufficient bond by a

' solvent surety company in an amount to be fixed by
the Court, if the Court should grant its prayer for
injunction pending appeal.

BAKER, BOTTS, ANDREWS
& WHARTON,
By JOHN P: BULLINGTON.

Motion denied. | . vee
(Signed) JOHN McDUFFIE.,. Judge.

q

OS ae ee

81

MOTION OF PLAINTIFF FOR APPEAL AND
ORDER ALLOWING SAME.

55 Filed October 29, 1935.

United States District Court for the Eastern District
of Louisiana.

Rickert Rice Milling Company, Inc., ?
: versus’ No. 321 (In Equity).
Rufus W. Fontenot, Individually, etc.

On motion of plaintiff in the above cause, and on
suggesting to the Court that plaintiff is aggrieved
by the decree entered by the Court herein on the 29th
day of October, 1935, granting defendant’s motion to
dismiss, and that plaintiff desires to appeal therefrom

with a " supersedeas and a stay of proceedings in the >

District Court, pending appeal to the United States
Circuit Court ‘of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, and

On further suggesting to the Court that said Sueons
is contrary to the law and the evidence for the reasons

set forth in the assignment of errors filed in plaintiff’s
behalf herein; and

On further suggesting to the Court that this motion
being filed in open Court on the-entry of such decree
and in the presence of counsel for défendant, no cita-
tion of appeal is necessary or need issue herein;

It is Ordered by the Court that the appeal of plain-
tiff from the decree entered herein to the United States
Circuit Court of.Appeals for the Fifth Circuit be and
the same is hereby allowed with supersedeas, on appel-
lant’s furnishing bond with good and solvent surety,
conditioned as required by law and to be approved by
the Court in the sum of $250.00 said bond to act as a
supersedeas, as well as a bond for costs and damages;

82

It is Further Ordered by the Court that the appeal -
of plaintiff from the decree entered herein be made
returnable to the United States Circuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Fifth Circuit at New Orleans. Louisiana,

- on or before November 27th, 1935, and that a certi-
fied copy of the record. herein be transmitted to said

Court of Appeals by the Clerk of this Court, and that
no citation of appeal is necessary or need issue herein.

(Signed) JOHN McDUFFIE, Judge.

56 ASSIGNMENT OF ERRORS.
Filed Oct. 29, 1935.

- United States District Court for the Eastern District

of Louisiana.

Rickert Rice Milling Company, Inc.,
versus No. 321 Equity.
Rufus W. Fontenot, Individually, etc.

Comes now plaintiff and says that, in the record in
proceedings of the said Court in the above entitled
cause and in the decree made and entered therein on .
the 28th day of October, 1935, there is manifest error
and for error the said plaintiff assigns. the following:

(1) The . Court erred in sustaining defendant’s
motion to dismiss plaintiff’s Bill of Complaint, because
such. action was contrary to the law and the evidence. :

(2) The Court erred in over- -ruling and not sus-
taining plairitiff’s motion for a preliminary injunction

-bécausé said ruling was contrary to the law and the

evidence,

Wherefore, plaintiff prays that said Decree be, in
all things, reversed, with instructions to the said Dis-
trict Court to grant plaintiff a preliminary injunction.

BAKER, BOTTS, ANDREWS |
& WHARTON, |
By JOHN P. BULLINGTON.

83
APPEAL BOND.

Filed October 29, 1935. —_

United -States District Court, Eastern District of
Louisiana, New Orleans Division.

Know all Men by these Presents, that we, Rickert
Rice Milling Company, Inc., as principal and Hartford
Accident & Indemnity Co., as surety, are. held and
firmly bound unto Rufus W. Fontenot, in the: full
sum of $250.00, to be paid to the said Rufus W.
Fontenot, his attorneys, executors, administrators .or
‘assigns, to which payment well and truly to be made
we bind ourselves, our heirs, executors and adminis-
trators, jointly and severally by these presents; sealed
with our seals and dated this 29th day of October,
1935.

Whereas, lately, in the District Court of the United
- States for the Eastern District of Louisiana, judgment
was rendered against Rickert Rice Milling Company,
Inc., and in favor of Rufus W. Fontenot, denying
plaintiff's application for a Preliminary Injunction
‘and dismissing plaintiff’s Bill of Complaint, and the
said Rickert Rice Milling Company, Inc., having ob- |
‘tained an appeal to reverse said judgment, citing and
admonishing the said Rufus W. Fontenot to be and
appear at a session of the United States ‘Circuit Court
of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit to be holden at the
City of New Orleans, La., in said Circuit Court on
the 27th day of November, 1935. ,

Now the condition of the above obligation is such
that if the said Rickert Rice Milling Company, Inc.,
shall prosecute its appeal to. effect and answer all
damages and costs, if it fail to make its plea good,

84

then the above obligation to be void, else to remain
in full force and effect.
RICKERT RICE MILLING
, COMPANY, INC.,
(Signed) BAKER, BOTTS, ANDREWS
& WHARTON,
By JOHN P, BULLINGTON,
Principal.
HARTFORD ACCIDENT &
_ INDEMNITY CO.,
j Surety.
By VALENTINE DELL, .
(Seal) Attorney-in-Fact.

Approved, October 29, 1935.
(Signed) RUFUS E. FOSTER, Judge.

58 - PRAECIPE.
Filed October 31, 1935. ok

In the District Court of the United States for the
_ Eastern District of Louisiana, New Orleans Divi-
sion.
Rickert Rice Mills, Inc.,, Plaintiff,
| Vs. No. 321 (In Equity).
- Rufus W. Fontenot, Individually and as Acting United
a States Collector of Interrial Revenue for the Dis-
trict of Louisiana, Defendant.

' To the Honorable H. J. Carter, Clerk of the United’
States District Court for the Fastern District
of Louisiana:

You will please include in the record upon appeal
in the above entitled cause the following documents
and procedures:

1. Plaintiff’s original bill of complaint.

85
2. Defendant’s motion to dismiss and answer.

‘3. Order of Court consolidating causes \for trial
and providing for evidence in cause No. 324 in Equity,
Baton Rouge Rice Mill, Inc., vs; Rufus W. Fontenot,
etc., being considered as evidence in this cause:

4. Affidavit of W. M. Reid.
5. Affidavit of Homer L. Bruce.

6. Joint affidavit of L. J. Bartel, R. F. Gould and
J. J. Mayer.

*“,

*

7. Decree of District Court.

_ §. Plaintiff’s motion: for injunction pending: appeal
and order denying same.

9. Motion and order for appeal.
10. Plaintiff’s assignment of error.
11. Appeal bond.

12. This Praecipe.

13. Clerk’s certificate.
HOMER L. BRUCE,
JOHN P. BULLINGTON,
BAKER, BOTTS, ANDREWS
' & WHARTON,
By JOHN P. BULLINGTON,
Attorneys for Plaintiff and
Appellant.
Approved: ) .
-(Sed.) ROBERT WEINSTEIN, _
Asst. U. S. Attorney, Counsel
for defendant.

59 Clerk’s Office:

I, HENRY J. CARTER, Clerk of the Dis-
trict Court of the United States for the Eagtern Dis-
trict of Louisiana, do hereby certify that ‘the foregoing
58 pages form a full, true and complete transcript of
the record, assignment of errors, and all proceedings in

the cause entitled “Rickert Rice Mills, Inc., Plaintiff,
‘vs. Rufus W. Fontenot, Individually and as acting
Collector of Internal Revenue for the District of Louis-
iana,” No. 321.In Equity of the Docket of this Court,
as made up in accordance with the praecipe for trans-
cript copied therein.

. Witness my Hand and the seal of the said Court
at the City of New Orleans, Louisiana, this 31st day
of October, A. D. 1935. :

(Seal) «+H. J. CARTER, Clerk.

87

(fol-87] In Unrrep States Crrcvorr Court oF APPEALS FOR
rHE Firra Circuit, at New Organs, Louisiana |

No. 7937

Rickert Rick Miuurne Company, Inc., Appellant
v.

Rurus W. Fontenot, Individually and as ‘Acting United
State Collector of Internal Revenue for the District of
Louisiana, Appellee —

Morion or APPELLANT FOR A PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
Penpinc AppEat—Filed November 4, 1935

Comes now the Rickert Rice Milling Company, Inc., ap-
pellant in the above numbered and entitled cause, and after
due notice given to the appellee above named, respectfully
states to the Court that the said appellant on the 25th day
of October, 1935, brought a bill in equity in the United
States District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana,
- New Orleans Division, entitled Rickert Rice Milling Com-
pany, Inc., plaintiff, v. Rufus W. Fontenot, individually and
as Acting United States Collector of Internal Revenue for
the District of Louisiana, defendant, and numbered 321 in |
equity, inthe New Orleans Division of said United States
District Court. In its bill of complaint in said cause ap-
pellant prayed for a temporary restraining order to be
(fol. 88] issued immediately, and for a preliminary injunc-
tion after notice to the appellee, and for a permanent in-
junction on the final hearing of said cause, enjoining the |
appellee from assessing or collecting or attempting to as-
sess or collect from the appellant in any manner whatso-
ever, whether by lien or jeopardy or distraint proceedings,
in court or otherwise, any processing taxes levied under and
pursuant to the Act of the Congress of the United States
known as the Agricultural Adjustment Act and amend-
ments thereto, or purported to be levied by said Act, upon
the appellant for the processing of rice during the month
of September, 1935, and for subsequent months, and any
interest or penalty on account of appellant’s failure to pay
said processing tax, and from imposing or giving notice of
intention to impose any lien for said taxes upon the prop-
erty, real or personal, of appellant. That said application

1—d77

88

for a preliminary injunction was set down for: hearing
before the Judge of said District Court at New Orleans on
Monday, October 28, 1935. The notice thereof was duly
waived by the appellee. Prior to said hearing the said
appellee ‘filed his motion to dismiss and answer to said bill
of complaint, copies of which motion and also of appellant’s -
bill of complaint are eontained in the record in this cause
filed in this Court.

After a hearing had on appellant’s motion for a prelimi-
nary injunction and on the said motion to dismiss, the Hon- -
orable John McDuffie, acting judge of said District Court
on October 28, 1935, refused appellant’s motion for a pre-
liminary injunction, granted the motion of the appellee to
dismiss the said bill of complaint and dismissed the said
bill of complaint to which appellant herein duly excepted.
[fol. 89] Thereafter, on the 29th day of October, 1935, the
appellant herein in open court and in the presence of coun-
sel for appellee filed its petition for an appeal, which was
duly allowed by the said judge of the said United States .
District Court who tried said cause, and filed at the same
time its assignments of errors, and also a cost bond was
duly filed and approved by the said judge of said District
Court. At the time appellant presented: its said petition
for appeal, it also petitioned said judge of the District
Court to grant it an injunction enjoining the appellee in
the manner set out in its request for a preliminary injunc-
tion in its bill of complaint, pending the appeal of appellant
to this Honorable Court, but the said judge of said District
Court on October 29, 1935, refused appellant’s said petition
and refused to grant appellant said injunction pending said
appeal.

Appellant has therefore perfected its appeal to the Cir.
cuit Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, making said
cause returnable at New Orleans, Louisiana, as provided
-by law. Appellant has duly caused to be prepared a tran-
script of the record in said cause and has filed the same,
in accordance with law, and within the time allowed by law,
in the Clerk’s office in the Circuit Court of Appeals at New
Orleans, Louisiana. |
"Th said bill of complaint appellant alleged that the
amount of processing taxes on account of the rice pro-
cessed by the appellant during the month of September,
1935, was $57,275.42, and that under said Agricultural Ad-

RE URE BIN =

89

justment Act appellant was required to pay said amount
to appellee on or before October 30, 1935, and that appellee
was charged with the duty of collecting said tax, and if
[fel. 90] said tax were not paid on or before October 30,
1935, appellee would assess said tax against the appellant
and serve upon appellant notice and demand for the pay-
ment thereof and would allow appellant ten days from ré-
ceipt from such notice within which to pay the same; that
‘n the event said tax should not be paid within said time,
‘appellee would assess against appellant a penalty equal to
5% of the amount of the tax and interest on the tax at the
rate of 1% per month from the due date of the tax until
paid; that if-the appellant failed to pay the tax within
said ten days, appellee would proceed to collect the tax,
penalty. and interest by filing a notice of lien on all of ap-
pellant’s property and by distraining upon and selling such

’ of appellant’s property as might be necessary to realize the
amount of said tax, penalties and interest; and ‘that addi-
tional processing taxes for months subsequent to Septem-
ber, 1935, will accrue and be assessed against and collected
from the appellant in the same manner as the tax for the
month of September.

Appellant alleged that the ‘said processing. tax was il-
legal and unconstitutional, and violated various provisions
of the Constitution of the United States in many particu-
lars, more fully set forth in appellant’s bill of complaint.
The appellant also alleged that under an amendment to
said Agricultural Adjustment Act approved on August 24,
1935, a Section 21 (d) was added to said Act, which section
provides in substance that appellant should be allowed no
recovery of any of said taxes paid, if the same should be
illegal or unauthorized, unless appellant established to the
satisfaction of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, and
[fol. 91] the Commissioner should so find, that neither ap- |
‘pellant nor any person directly or indirectly under appel-
lant’s control or having control over appellant, has, directly
or indirectly, included such amount in the price of the rice
with respect to which it was imposed or of any article
processed from the rice with respect to which it was im-'
posed, or passed on any part of such amount to the vendee
or to any other person in any manner, or included any
part of such amount in the charge or fee for processing
rice, and that the price paid by the appellant or such per-
son for said rice was not reduced by any part of such

90

amount. Appellant in said bill of sdeeianiibs, a as
more fully set out in said bill of complaint, that under said
Section 21 (d) it had no adequate remedy at law by which
it could recover any part of said taxes if same were un-
constitutional and illegal, and that it was impossible, owing
to the peculiar conditions existing in the rice milling in-
dustry and in the purchase, milling and sale of rice, for
appellant to discharge-the burden placed upon it by said
Section 21 (d), all as more fully set. out in appellant’s bill
of complaint.

Appellant further alleged.that in said amendment of
August 24, 1935, a new section known as Section 21 (a)
was added to said Agricultural Adjustment Act, which in
substance provided that no suit to enjoin the collection of
said processing taxes should be maintained in any court.
Appellant further alleged that said section was not in-
tended to apply, and did not apply, to the injunction prayed
for by appellant, inasmuch as appellant had no adequate
remedy at law. Appellant further alleged that if said sec-
tion. should be interpreted as prohibiting the injunetion
[fol.92] prayed for by appellant, then the said section,
together with the other provisions of. said Act, was invalid
and in violation. of the Fifth Amendment to the-.Constitu-
tion, that no person shall be deprived of his property with-
out due process of law, in that said illegal and unconstiltu-
tional taxes would be collected from appellant and appel-
lant would have no remedy by which he could recover taxes
and would have no remedy to prevent the collection of said
- unlawful taxes and would be forever deprived of the right.
to test the constitutionality of said taxes. .

Appellant further alleged that said Section 21 (d) de- ©
nied the appellant a complete and adequate remedy at law
for the various other reasons set forth in said bill of com-
plaint. .

At the hearing before the District’ Judge appellant intro-
duced in evidence the affidavit of W. M. Reid,’ Executive
Secretarv of The Rice Millers Association, a man of twenty-
' six yeai experience in the rice business, in which affidavit
he set out fully and in detail the methods of conducting the
rice business and the manner in which the rough rice mar- |
ket and the clean rice market is made, showing that it would
be utterly impossible for any rice miller to accurately deter-
mine whether he had made a profit or a loss on any given
transaction, much less prove whether he had passed the

91

tax, or any part thereof, on. Appellant also introduced in
evidence the affidavit of Homer L. Bruce, a practicing attor-
ney at the bar at: Houston, Texas, setting out in detail the
proceedings under a complaint brought by the Secretary
of Agriculture to revoke the license of a rice mill under
the Act in effect prior-to the present Act. .The- Secretary
of Agriculture sought to revoke-the license of this mill for
[fol. 93] failure to sell clean rice and rice products proc-
essed from rough rice at a price approximately 79c higher
than the price paid for the rough rice. The affidavit showed
that although the Government was able to prove the cost
of the rough rice and to trace the particular rough rice into
various ‘‘mixes’’ of clean rice and the price procured for
these ‘‘mixes’’ of clean tice it was never able to prove that
the price procured for the clean rice processed from the
particular lot of rough rice was not 79c more than the price
paid for the rough rice because of the fact that clean rice
is customarily sold i in ‘‘mixes’’ of various lots of rice and
there was no way to allocate the pricé procured for the
mixed rice sold to the various ave of rough rice which wert
into the mix. :
In the meantime, appellant alleges that for the foregoing
reasons and those set forth in its said bill of complaint in
said cause, and because the judge-of said court in his said
order dismissed said bill of complaint and refused to grant
appellant the injunction prayed for pending the appeal in
this case, the appellee herein will, to the irreparable dam-
age and loss of the appellant herein, proceed to collect the
said taxes for September, 1935, which are now due and
unpaid, from appellant, and said taxes for subsequent
months, unless restrained by a preliminary injunction
granted by this court. The appellant alleges that- not, only
_ has.it no complete remedy at law, but in fact no remedy
at law at all, for the reasons hereinabove set forth and set
forth more in detail in said bill of complaint, that it is faced
with the alternative of paying the tax with the certainty
that no remedy at law exists for its recovery in case it be
held that it was unconsitutionally assessed, or of gefusing
[fol. 94] to pay and running the risk of becoming liable
for the heavy civil and criminal penalties provided in the
Act, and that the said judge of said District Court should
not have dismissed said bill of complaint, but should have
overruled the same, and upon the hearing should have

——

92

granted the preliminary injunction as prayed for in said
bill of complaint.

Appellant would further show that there is now pending
in the Supreme Court of the United States a case involving
the constitutionality of the said Agricultural Adjustment
Act, being the same case in which the Circuit Court of

_ Appeals for the First Circuit declared the Act to be un-

constitutional, and that the Supreme Court, according to
press dispatches, has set said cause for oral argument ‘on
Monday, December 9, 1935; that a decision by.the Supreme
Court of the United States upon the validity of the said
Act may be expected within a reasonable time thereafter ;
that the first benefit payment to farmers provided for in
said Act has been made, and that under the standard form

- of contract between the Secretary of Agriculture and rice

farmers no further payment is due until such time after |
December 1, 1935; as the Secretary shall determine and
declare what further amount of benefit payments shall be
made and when they shall be made; that the taxes to be
collected under said Act are for the purpose of making
these benefit payments and that since the Secretary of
Agriculture need make no further benefit payments until
such time after December 1, 1935, as may be fixed by him,
the delay of the Government in collecting these taxes which
might be occasioned by the granting of the injunction
[fol. 95] prayed for herein will not occasion any injury to
the Government nor will it unduly interfere with the
achievement of the program set out in said Act if the Act
be held constitutional. On the other hand, as hereinabove
alleged, great and irreparable damage will be done to plain-
tiff in the event: the law is held unconstitutional unless the
injunction hereinafter prayed for is granted. . -

Appellant further shows that unless an injunction pend-
ing appeal be granted so as to preserve the status quo, the |
subject-matter of the suit will be lost and the jurisdiction
of this Honorable Court defeated. Such injunction is
necessary to preserve the jurisdiction of this Honorable
Court, and in order that appellant may enjoy the just fruits
of a favorable decision on this appeal. -

The appellant states that it is ready and willing to give
any reasonable bond or other security that may be required
by any order of this Court, including the deposit from
month to month of the amount of tax due, in a depository
to be designated by the court, and therefore prays that this

93

Court make an order granting appellant a preliminary in-
junction enjoining and restraining the appellee from as-
sessing or collecting or attempting to assess or collect from
appellant in any manner whatsoever, whether by lien or
jeopardy or by distraint proceedings, in court of otherwise,
the said processing taxes for the month of September and
subsequent months and any other processing taxes under
and pursuant to said Agricultural Adjustment Act upon.
rice processed by appellant, and any interest or penalty on
account of appellant’s failure to pay said processing taxes,
and from imposing or giving notice of intention to impose
[fol. 96] any lien for said taxes upon the property, real or
personal, of the appellant, pending the hearing of appel-
lant’s appeal in this case and upon such conditions and
terms as to this Court may seem just. ©

John P.. Bullington. Homer L. Bruce. Baker,

. Botts, Andrews & Wharton, of Counsel. ‘

[fol.97] Duly sworn to by John P. Bullington. Jurat
omitted in printing.

(fol. 98] In Unirep Srates Crrcuir Court oF APPEALS FOR
THE FirtH Circuit

No. 7937
. ' [Title omitted]

Before Foster and Sibley, Circuit Judges, and Strum,
| District Judge

Orper Denyina Motion or APPELLANT FOR A PRELIMINARY
_Iwsunction Penpina Appeat—Filed November 5, 1935

By the Court:

On consideration of the application for an injunction to
stay collection of taxes levied under the provisions of the
Agricultural Adjustment Act, as amended by the Act of
August 24, 1935, the Court is of the opinion that the’ tax-
payer has a remedy at law to recover back any taxes il-
‘[fol. 99] legally exacted and, further, that the provisions
of the Act as amended deprive the Court of jurisdiction to
grant injunctive relief.

It is ordered that the application be denied.

94

- [fol. 100] Clerk’s certificate to foregoing transcript
omitted in printing.

. [fol. 101] Supreme Court or THE Unirep Srates
Orper ALLOWING CerTrIorarI—Filed November 25, 1935

The petition. herein for a writ of certiorari to the United
States Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit is
granted, and the case is assigned for argument on Monday,
December 16, next.

And it is further ordered that the duly certified copy of
the transcript of the proceedings below.which accompanied
the petition shall be treated as though filed in response to .
such writ.

Endorsed on cover: File No. 40,131. U.S. Cireuit Court .
of Appeals, Fifth Circuit. “Term No. 577. Rickert Rice
_ Mills, Inec., Petitioner, vs. Rufus W. Fontenot, Individually
and as Acting United "States Collector of Internal Revenue
for the District of Louisiana. Petition for a writ of certio-'
rari and exhibit thereto. Filed November 11, 1935. Term
No.. 577, O. T., 1935. — :

.(7199-C)

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386009_0294%3A01. Public record. Not legal advice.
