# Transcript of Record — Baltimore & Carolina Line, Inc. v. Redman

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386009_0242%3A02

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1935
- **Citation:** 295 U.S. 654

## Text

"SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES ,
OCTOBER TERM, 1984.

No. 178

_ BALTIMORE& CAROLINA LINE, INC., PETITIONER,

vs. *

DONALD REDMAN.

0 —
.

ON WRIT or CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THESECOND CIROUIT. ,

INDEX.

© 0 Original Print

Record from D. C. V. S., Southern. New Tor... 1 1

Docket entre N 9 224 anes 1 1
Complaitt ecg 4 3:
Aneder᷑õr-r „„ Pees 9 6

| | Order for bill of particular 12 7

— _ Plaintiff's bill of particular Yeewe sg. 1S 9
8 Bill of exceptions vee 2*2ũ2—ͥñ 44440 — 18 2
— Appearabee se 9 — f 18

Testimony of Mark J. Belton 9. ee. 18 f 11

f Dr. Herbert T. Wikle...... r

656 225„% „„ „„ „„

„ 6 „%%% % % πFFtfe e

Testimony of Dr. Joseph Perensns a

_ Alfred O. Suessmuth 8 1
P N William M. Hudson 223 182
5 . ; „ Webley H. Morris 50660 Keese 225 183
‘= Alfred O. Suessmuth (recalled) ..... 228 185
Jupp & Derwetizes (Inc.), PRINTERS, Wasuineton, D. C., Ocroszs 24, 1984.

22 * . INDEX oy * 0
1 Original § Print
Testimony of George Ramsey 230 187
: ' Herman-Charache ..... Rheeedsbee tee 208 10
uud Shetara .:.. whys & 56660000000 280 20
Donald Redman (recalled) ......... 289 238
"Stipulation as to arrival of vessel, tee... 205 i242
> Motion to dismiss, etc. . dee des ee eee eee eee 2905 242
a — —— Donald Redman (recalled) Soccepeces 206 243
‘Plaintiff's to charge 159 2 . 427 244
— tutunte ta. done: Codoccesess bee 304 248
Charge to jury .. PPTTTTT TTT ity * TTT TTY TITTTT ie 305 249
Verdict fesccces Sees 3109 260
— to: celebs — — 320 200
Plaintiff's exhibit I— Letter, dated October 28, 1082 321 261
. 321 2801
f a Letter, dated Norember 4, .
. . 192 40% %% % 0 0 00 0 322 202
4—Letter, dated January 9, 1933 324 2283
5—Letter, dated January 1 1083.
‘and envelope postmarked
5 January 10, 2 P. M., 1988838. 324 203
Detendant's exhibit A—Letter, dated March 12,1031 8 264
B—Afidavit of Donald Redman 326 - 204
. C- Additional statement, signed
2 by Redman. 330 267
D—Certificate of Department
P of Hospitals, Cumperiand _ a
ö cae e, 833 260 -
Stipulation settling bill of exceptions ese eee XR. 834 260
eee
38 270
836 271
888 272
439 272
340
1 dees 341 273
Stipulation as to record \........6eesedeeeeeeees veces 842 278
Order filing record ....... Won 212 274
Clerk’s certificate ......... 1 . e (omitted in printing) .. 843
Proceedings in U. 8. C. C. A., Second Cir cult. “B44 274.
eee 844 275
347 279
3409 281
351
382 ‘ese

(fol. 1]

IN THE UNITED STATES DIsTRIOT COURT,
_. SOUTHERN DISTRICT 6 yeas

Donato Ban
vs.

*

th 3 & Ono Line, Ivo.

P. R. Graves, 44 Whitehall St..
* Hill & Betts, 120 Broadway. f

Dooxer Henn

Filings, Proceedings, ete.

Aug. 37, 1°31—Filed prescipe and issued summons.
- Sept. 1, 1. —-Summons and complaint.
Sept. 18, 1931— Filed answer.
Sept. 30, 1931—Filed note of issue, motion for bill of
2 ret. 10/6/31. 7
Oct: 6, 1931—Filed affdt. & notice of motion for bill of
. 44 Mqmo end. Motion granted. No opposition
Bondy, J. 2
Oet. 13, 1931—Piled ais for bill of particnlare—
Bondy, J.
ä 14 1931—Filed bill of particulars.
Mar. 22, 1933.— Before Bondy, J. Trial begun, ad-
f journed to 3/2/83. ö
Mar. 23, 1933— Before Bondy, J. Trial continued, ad-
journed to 3/24/33.
Mar. 24, 1933— Before Bondy, J: Trial continued, ‘ad-
journed to 3/27/33.
[fol. 21 Mar. 27, 1933 Before Bondy, J. Trial continued,
verdict for plaintiff : for $5,000
. Apr. 10, 1933—Filed judgment #33140 i in Pavor of plain.
ä ttf for 042.50.
: Apr. 10, 1933—Fees collected.
ce May 16, 1933—Filed petition for Appeal.
. May 16, 1933—Filed order allowing appeal, Coxe, J
May 16, 1933—-Filed Assignment of errors.

1—178 — P — me *

*

„ be

May 16, 1933—Filed - - dupersedeas ‘pond on . for
$5,500. National Surety Corporation.

May 22, 1933—Filed citation of appeal—6/15/33.
June 10, 1933—Filed consent and order extending time
to file record on ap to 8/10/83,

Aug. 17, 1933— consent and order extending time
to file record on ap to 8/30/33,

Sept. 5, 1933— consent and ordé ex time
to file record on appeal] end return day of eite an to,
9/15/83. ' K

Sept. 15, 1933— Filed consent and order ages
to file record on appeal and return day of cita
10/16/33.

October 16, 1983—Filed consent and order extending
time to file record on appeal and return day of citation to
'. 10/30/38,
October 30, 1983—Filed consent and order
time to file r on appeal and return day of citation to ‘
11/6/33. ‘

(fol. 3] Ix: Usrren States District Court 19.
[Title omitted]

Sumions
To the above-named Defendant : °

You are hereby summoned to. answer the complaint in
this action, and to serve a copy of your answer, or, if the
complaint is not served with this eummons, to serve a
notice of ‘appearance, on the plaintiff’s attorney within
twenty days after the service of this summons, exclusive
ofgthe day of service. In case of your failure to appear or
answer, judgment will be taken against you by default for
the relief demanded in the complaint. '

Witness, the Honorable, John C. Knox, Judge of the
District Court of the United States for the Southern Dis-
trict of New York, at the City of New York, this 31 day of
August, A. D. 1931.

_. . Charles Weiser, Clerk. Frederick R. Graves, Plain-
tiff’s Attorney, Office and Post Office Address: 44
Whitehall Street, ase of Manhattan, ov" pee

. New York. |

~

*

(fot. 4) Ix, Untran States Durmor Covet ,
[Title omitted)

Court

3 Action under Special Rule for Seamen to Sue Without

&

Security and Pre-Payment of Fees for Enforcement of
Laws of the United States, for the Protection of Health
and Safety at Sea ‘

The plaintiff, by Frederick R. Graves, his attorney, com-
plaining of the defendant, respectfully alleges and shows:

First: Upon information and belief, chat at all the times
hereinafter mentioned, the above named defendant was and
now is a corporation organized and existing under and by
virtue of the laws of thes state of Maryland, and at all said
times was and is doing business in the state of New Vork,
with an office for the regular transaction of business in the
city of New York, state of New York.

Second : Upon information and belief, that at all; —
times hereinafter. mentioned, the above named defen
was the owner of a certain — called the Fr
Weems,” 4 &
{fol.6] Third: That upon ‘information and belief, that
at all the times hereinafter mentioned, the abeve named
_ defendant was in possession and control of the said Steam-
“ship „Frances Weems.

Fourth: Upon information and belief, that at all the
times hereinafter mentioned, the above named defendant
operated and ‘controlled the said Steamship ‘ Frénces
Weems.’’

Bifth: Upon W and belief; that on or about the
13th day of February, 1930, plaintiff was in the employ .
of the aboveonamed defendant on board the Steamship
Frances Weems as a seaman (second cook).

| Sixth: Upon information and belief, that at all the t
hereinafter mentioned, the above named plaintiff w
the employ of the above named defendant on board the
* Frances Weems” as a seaman (second cook).

= — 7

4 N
Seventh: Upon ene and belief, that it was ‘me
duty of the defendant to provide plajntiff with a safe place
to work wi reasonably safe tools and appliances, and to

in repair, with a suitable number of competent
ees and superior officer ; to promulgate and en.

to wa the plaintiff of the * e and 25

“sy ——

Eighth: That by reason of the negligent failure of. the,
defendant and its servants to perform the foregoing duties
and each of them, on or about the 13th day of February,
1930, while plaintiff was engaged in the course of his work
I[xol. 61 on board said vessel, and without fault on his part,
he -sustajned sévere and-painful personal i injuries when his
. foédt was pierced and lacerated when it came in contact with
a nail contained in some debris which littered the * of ;
said vessel in an unlighted portion thereof.

Ninth: Upon information and belief, that said injuries
were directly caused by reason of the dangerous, defective,
5 ang unseaworthy condition of said vessel, and particularly
because said deck which plaintiff was necessarily using as
passageway in the course of his work was litteréd with ~
debris Which contained sharp..gnd unprotected and un-

"guarded nails, and because said deck at said spot was not 4

property lighted, sb thaf said debris was an encumbrance |

da dangerous menace to life and limb; upon information
‘and belief, that said injuries were further caused by rea-
sch of the negligence of the defendant and its servants in
mat they caused or permitted said conditions to exist,

_ Sapa dacvero¢ remedy to make proper inspection or\ to take
to defects, in that they negli-
er tiff to work under danger-
ous conditions, negligently caused or permitted said debris
977 tnt anh eumede oh. ould att, saa
gently failed to remove the same or to light said spot, and
' negligently failed to warn the plaintiff of his danger.

Tenth: Upon information and belief, that by virtue of
Sectio 33. of the Merchant Seaman's Act of June 5th,
1920, amending Section 20 of the Seamen’s Act of March
Bee a brs eee e

railroad employees engaged in fofeign or interstate
% v0 commerce, and particulary Section 8657 and fol-

— — — ee are”

—
* 0 ‘ * ‘ 5
__ lowing of the United States Compiled Statutes, were made
applicable to seamen employed upon American vessels, the
Plaintiff is entitled to recover damages for the negligence’
of the defendant, and of his eo-employees in the defend-
ant’s service, ke ene oe fete 80
Eleventh; That by réason of all the foregoing, plaintiff
was rendered sick, sore, Jamed and disabled, has suffered
and will suffer great pain, has been and will be pr . N
from attending to his work for some time to come, hap lost
and will lose large sums of money which he otherwise would
earn, has paid out and will have tp, pay ouf large sums: of
money for. medical and surgical attention and medicines,
one of lg legs was necessarily amputated, and upon in-
formation and belief, that he has been — injured,
all to his damage in the sum of Fifty Thousand Dollars

+ (950,000), : at
‘For a second, separate. and distinct cause of action, plain- ©
tiff further. alleges: - Pe o ee

__ Twelfth: Repeats and re-alleges each and every allega-
ion of the complaint hereinbefore contained, with the same
~~force ang effect as if the same weré herein again set forth
_« Thirteenth: Upan information and belief, that, upon
plaintiff’s being igjured as aforesaid, it was the duty of the
defendant to provide him with prompt and proper medical
and surgical attentian and medicine, and to take steps
transfer him to a hospital where he could be: properly
treated, and to pay his expenses of travel, maintenance and,
Lol. 8] hospitalization, all of which could have been
promptly obtained by the use of reasonable diligence and
the performance of said duties by the defendant which It
owed to the plaintiff. . ; 8

Fourteeith: Upon information and belief, that the de-
fendant failed, neglected and refused to provide plaintiff

—
+

with the same and his failure to reveive them, his injuries —:
were greatly aggravated and his cure im and pre-
vented, and upon information and belief, that one of his
8 5

0 *
5 . "hed *
1
— 1 . tear os " * * 8 rT 8 * 1 5
0 1 2

.

8

lege was necessarily 5 by reason of said negli-
gence, and that he has suffered unnecessary pain and dis-
comfort and is permanently injured, all to his damage in the
sum of Twenty-five Thousand Dollars (628, 000).

Wheref tiff demands judgment against the d
fecidant in the — itty ane Dollars ($50,000) ;

= and expenses of maintenance and cure, together
with the costs and disbursements of this action.
* R. Graves, Attorney for Plaintiff, O. &
O. Address: 44 Whitehall Street, New York
city, New York.

>

[fol. 9) In Untrep Statzs Disrarcr Court
‘ - [Title omitted]

Axswun

The. a zen toy tie ator, Hunt, Hill &
Betts, answering the complaint, all .

Fi: rt: It denies the allegations — in 8

0 eighth, ninth, tenth and eleventh;

Second: It denies the allegations contained in Para-
graphs thirteenth and fourteenth of the complaint herein.

Por a first, separate and distinct defense to both causes
of action alleged in the complaint, defendant alleges:

Upon information and belief, that any injuries sus-
eee.
tioned in the complaint, were caused in whole or in*part, or

were contributed to by the negligence and want of care of

the plaintiff and not by any negligence or fault or want of
care on the part of the defendant.

[foh 10] For a second, separate and distinct defense to
the first cause of action alleged in the complain’ defendant
alleges : *

That pieintiff’s employment had certain risks incident -
thereto which were obvious and well known to plaintiff at
. all the times of said employment and also when plaintiff

F
q

i ‘ 7.
first entered thereon, and that said risks were assumed by
the plaintiff; that whatever injuries plaintiff received in
said employment and, which are complained of by him
herein, arose from and were caused by said risks, all of
which were taken and assumed by plaintiff at the time he
entered upon said employment and during the continuance

thereof. 1
Wherefore, defendant demands judgment dismissing the
complaint herein with costs: ' :

Hunt, Hill & Betts, Attorneys: for Defendant, 120
Broadway, New York, N. Y.

* (fol. 11] Duly sworn to by D. W. Barton. Jurat omitted
in printing. be ä

* —

— kol. 12] In Un Srarxs District Court
[Title omitted]
Onbrn ror BNL or Particunars—Oct. 10, 1931

A motion having been made by the defendant for an or-
der directing the plaintiff herein to serve upon the attor-
neys for the defendant, within ten (10) days after the serv-
ice of a copy of said order with notice of entry thereof, a

verified bill of particulars concerning matters contained in
said affidavit, and the said motion having regularly come on
to be heard at a stated term of this Court held in and for
the Southern District of New York at the Federal Court
House, Borough of Manhattan, City of New York, on the

- 6th day of October, 1931, and the attorneys for the defend-
ant having appeared in support of said motion and the

_ plaintiff having defaulted, .

Now, on reading and filing the notice of motion herein
dated September 29, 1931, together with the proof of due
(fol. 13] service thereof endorsed thereon and the affidavit
of H. Victor Crawford sworn to the 29th day of September,

1931 in support of said motion and upon the pleadings and
all the proceedings heretofore had herein, it is

Ordered that the said motion bey and the same hereby is,
granted and that the plaintiff within ten (10) days after the
service upon his attorneys of a copy of this order with no-

0

———

—

g

tice of entry thereof serve ‘upon the attorneys for the de-

kendant a verified bill of particulars as follows:

1. State the exact time of day, giving the hour and min-
ute when plaintiff sustained injuries on the 13th day of

_ February, 1930, as alleged in the complaint herein.

2. State the exact location on the deck of the S8 Fran-

ces Weems where plaintiff 's foot came in contact with a

nail, as alleged in Paragraph Eighth of the complaint, stat-
ing ‘the name of the deck, the position in respect to star-
board or. port side, and the _— and direction from *
nearest hatch, -

3. State the. ‘nature ‘of the debris which plaintiff alleges
in Paragraphs Eighth and Ninth of the complaint littered |
the deck of the vessel, and state when * debris was *
upon the deck. .

4. State what points on * vessel were connected by the
passageway referred to in Warn Ninth of the Com-
plaint. a 4

5. State the location of the nearest light to the spot re-

‘ferred to in Paragraph Eighth of the complaint, and state

(fol. 14] whether said light was bu — oe
alleged injury. :

6. State to what off or or person on the ship plaintiff re-

ported his alleged injury and the time when he made such
report.

7. State whether plaintiff received any treatment on

board the steamship for his alleged i injury.

8. State whether the plaintiff attended any hospital, giv-
ing the name of said hospital and the time during which
plaintiff was confined therein and when he first was ad-
mitted. . °

9. State whetlier plaintiff entered or + attempted to enter
any United States marine hospital at the time of his —
injuries.

10. State what sums 1s phintift has paid out for medical

and surgical attention and for medicines as — in Para-
graph Eleventh of the —

9 i ; | KS „ i é j
11. State what negligent acts, other than those alleged
in Paragraph Ninth of the complaint, plaintiff claims de-

' fendant or its agents committed.
William Bondy, United States District Judge.
{fol. 15] ' Ix Varike States Distaicr Covar
: | (Title omitted] *

Plalxrirr's BL or PauriouLAns

The. plaintiff, by Frederick R. Graves, his attorney, by
his bill of particulars in answer to defendant 's demand,
respectfully alleges: .

1. About 5 A. M.

2. After main deck, starboard ‘side, between the hatch
on said deck and the starboard rail. . '

w aie | ies? neh, ee
3. Empty crate; said debris had been on the deck for at
least seyenteen.{17) hours. 2 a

- 4. Plaintiff was going from his quarters to the kitchen
amidships, and said passageway referred to was the route
which was necessarily followed on said deck between said

points. | 5
5. There were no lights whatsoever. 2

6. Plaintiff reported the accident to the steward the next
day. . — @ . ”

7. Plaintiff did not receive any. treatment on the vessel,
said steward telling him that he was unable to do anything

kor him.

‘ [fol. 16] 8. Plaintiff was a patient in the Cumberland
Street Hospital, Brooklyn, New York, having entered said
institution on February 21st, 1930, from. which he was
transferred to Kings County Hospital, Brooklyn, New
York, on June 4th, 1930, where he remained until February
Ast, 1931.

9. Plaintiff was unable, on account of his condition, to
proceed to any U. S. Marine Hospital, and was obliged to
get treatment ut the nearest hospital. N

10 : a
10, Plaintiff expended various small sums of money for

liniment and ban ; no- hospital bill has been rendered
‘to him as yet, and plaintiff is unable to state what the
amount will be. 5

11. Failure to treat, as contained in the foregoing.

‘Dated New York, October 9th, 1931.

Yours, eto, Frederick R. Graves,-Attorne tor Plain-
tiff, O. & P. O. Address: 44 Whitehall Street, Now
York City, N. I.

To Hunt, Hill & Betts, Esqs., Atiorneys fer Defendant,
— 9 P. O. Address: 120 — New York 0 New
or

[fol. 17) Duly sworn to by Donald Redman. Jurat omitted ,
is printing, 2 —

2

a [fol. 181] Ix Unrrep States Distatct Court
| 150-2
DoxalD RapMan, Plaintiff,
8 ¥ against «
Bautimone & Conn Lixx, Ixo., Defendant
u of Bxoeptions
Before Hon. William Bondy, J., anda Jury

New York, March 22, 1933,
| 7 2:16 P. M.
APPEARANCES: -
Frederick R. Graves, Esq., Attorney for Plaintiff.
Hunt, Hill & Betts, Beqre., Attorneys for Defendant ; *
H. Victor Crawford, Esq., of Counsel.

A jury was impaneled, examined by the Conrt, and duly
2 :

*

| | „
Manx J.-Buutom, galled as u witness on behalf of the
plaintiff, being first duly sworn, testified as follows: |

Direct examination.

By Mr. Graves:
Q. Mr. Belton, have you been su by the plain.
tiff in this case to produce the hospital records * the Oum

berland Street Hospital, covering the case of Donald Red:

> [fol. 19] mant

A. Les, sir.

Q. And have you those in your i there
A. Yes, I have.

Q. Let me have them, please?

A. Yes (handing papers to Mr Graves).

Mr. Graves: You may leave the stand. (Witness ex-
cused.) 12} MOS

A Juror: Can we have a recess fer a couple of minutes?
The Court: Yes, we owe take a * tor flve minutes,
ö gentlemen. 4 toe "aay

(Informal recess.)

2

Un. Hanbrnr TznrIA Wixze, called as a witness on be-
half of the plantiff, being first duly sworn, testified as
folléws:

Direct —

By Mr. Graves: 4
. Dr. Wikle, are you a licensed physician and surgeon?
. lam.
How long have you been practicing!
. Abont fourteen years.
A

re you at the present time connected with any med
1 institution in New York City? |

I am.

And what is the name of that institution?
Cumberland Street Hospital, Carson-Peck Memorial
Hospital.

Q. Are there others? . a, *

ae > OPO

iret

ie
12 ;
A. Well, ‘I atm also connected with the Long Island Med.

ical College.
J. Were you connetted with the Cumberland Street Hos

pital in February, 19801

A. I was. ö é'
(fol. 20] O. In what capacity? 7
A. As a sur tending surgeon.

Q. Did you in February, 1930, come into contact as a at

tie @ man named Donal@Redmant

Q. And is that the man sitting in the art room now in
the tis row next to the window be grt scam no

A t 8 * .

The Court: When did you first see the plaintiff, Red -
mam
e Witness: Around the Ast or 22nd of February. 1
am not sure of the date. |

Q. 19907 a6 4
N i
Q. Have you an independent recollection of this case!
A. L have, yes. 3
Q. He was admitted, was he not, on February 21, 1930,
to that hospital? |
A. I4hink the records will show.
Q. Well, will you consult the record and tell us?

Mr. Crawford: Ik the record shows that, I will con-
cede it.

Mr. Graves: It does.

Mr. Crawford: * I will concede it.

A. Les.
Q. What was he suffering from at the time of ‘his ad-
mission?

A. Gangrene of the foot.
. Which foot?

The Court: You examined him, did you?
The Witness: J id. nig
= Court: Wha: did you find?
an) ow e foot.
(fol. 211 Q. — foot?
A. 148 foo

4

ss

,
. 8 **
* 13

0. Will you describe to the jgy ho how init of his foot was
é bete by gangrene at that time when you first saw him!
ar? A. About the distal two-thirds of the foot. That means
i toes and beyond the base of the toes

. Half way up to the ankle?

4. „ Ten":

show you, perhape.
Q. The middle of the instep?
A. About the beginning of the instep. The distal two-
thirds of the foot, as we term it.
ö — Lou treated him while he was in the © Reagent, did
x you
4 A. I did.
i Q: And you pottprmed an operation on his foot, did
you?
A. I performed an 77 on his leg.

The Court: Tell ul’ wiiat the treatment consisted of!
The Witness: The treatment?
The Court: Was he kept at the hospital.
f The Witness: Tes, he Was.
The Court: How long did he stay there?
The Witness: Well, the full length of time—I think he
was in there from the 21st of February to the 4th of. June.
Tykt was the entire lime. I did not tredt him over that
entire périod, however.
The Court: What did you dot What did your treat-
‘ment. consist of?
The Witness: My treatment consisted 4. * operation
upon the vessel of his leg.

. On what date was that operation performed by you?

A. I think it was—I will consult the chart here—on the
23rd, as I remember it—no; on the 24th.

[fol. 22] C. Of February?
A. February 24, yes. |
Q. Give us + the oan of the operation that you per-
. formed?

A. Periarterial sympathectomy.

Q. Now, tell the jury the nature of that operation.

A. It is the removal of the nerves about the artery. The
artery has several coats. The outer coat consists of sym-
pathetic nerves or in the outer coat are included the sym-
pathetic nerves of the artery; and the operation is the re-

. a e Ase

14 b

evel of those nerves; stripping off, in thet words, the
nerves around the artery, They were removed for a dis-
tance, in this case, I think, of about 14 centimeters, and
‘there are two and a half cetitimeters to.an inch.
Q. How many, centimeters? - Es
A. About 14. I don’t know whether it stdtes here on the
chart, but that.is the usual amount that I remove, and it is
the most that you can remove without interfering with
the
Q. What part of the anatomy did you perforin thet it opera.
tion upon?
A. On his thigh, on the inside.
Q. That is, the femoral artery?
The femoral artery. ~

4 And those arteries have — layers?

A. Chiefly, yes. ä
And the nerves are in the central ee
. No, the nerves are in the outer layer.

Q Well, that is what you . off?

A. Tes.

Q. And what was the purpose of tan operation?

A. The purpose of that operation was to give more cir-
culation to the vessel. The periarterial nerves contain the
_ fded to produce or to carry on à wave\that is normal -in al!

vessels, That wave is known as v ynstriction and vaso-
dilatation ; and by removing that coat, you aad the oon-
stricting element in the vessel.

[fol..23] C. Is that all you did?

A. I severed his femoral vein.

Pell the jury what you mean by that?
up the femoral vein and severed it, taking .
of it out, so that it would not function.

. 4 anything else

E 7212
1 fri:

*

SOP SOFPSYO PSO P SPS

proved, yes.” |

— it got worse, did it?

ve you 42 when the amputation was made
April 17th.

decided on another operation amputation!

3

ff

ie

1 2 . 1 ‘ 15 5

A. No; I did not, because I was not on the service at that 9
time; but an amputation became necessary. : .
Q. Did it becomé necessary? oes bles
. It did. 424 — 0 ö
Q. And was perfornied? - wes sian -
A. Yes. ‘cm 5 „ „4 3 2
44 . N
A. Dr. Shatara.
Q. Now, Dr. Shatara performed the actual ——
of the leg, did he

, A. He did. + tt be Set. 5
„. But it was flecessaty? ß 5 .

g . A. It was. *

e Q. On account of this gangrene! , Age | a

: ‘A. Yes.

Now, this man also had syphilis, did he not? 29

According to his en here, he did, yes.

Thé€ourt: Did you ex examine him for that? mi
The Witness: We had his blood examined, and his blood
was positive for the syphilitic test. )

And what did the test read?
A. 4 plus, Wasserman.
. Q. a you have 2 other 8 taken for that purpose!

wa Q. Did Yen examing hig blood otherwise, for
sugar and so forth? |
A. It should be here. His urine was exatiined for sugar.
His blood was not examined for sugar, so Mr as I can tell -
from this chart. Oh, yes, his blood was examined for
sugar; alsc urea.
Q. Was the result of those or did the result of those ex- .
5
A. Les. „

The Court: That is, the blood was normal:
The Witness: For sugar, yes.

| Q.-The only unusual cireuinstanee, then, was the 4 plus
= syphilis? —

A. That is right.
Q Otherwise, he appeared to bein d bodily health?

A. Ves.

4

: — woe

16

Q. Except for this gangrene?
4. Yes, except for the gangrene.
Mr. Graves: You may eross examine.

Cross examination.
By Mr. Crawford:

Q. Dr. Wikle, you thought that this man had some trouble
with = arteries in his leg and foot, did yout
A. I did. a
Q. And you made seyeral ‘examinations of his foot, your-
self?
A. Ves, I examined him. I don’t know how many times.
. Did you talk to him about his case?
A. Yes.
Q. Did he ever at any ume. — to you having run a
nail in his foot?
A. No. od
Q. Did you ask him how it happened that his * got into
this condition?
A. Tes.
Q. 22 did he say to .
A. He said that he had had a sudden pain in his. foot, and
. [fol. 25] that at the instigation of a friend of his, he had
soaked his foot in hot water, or applied very hot applice-
tions, after that this condition appeared.
Q. Did you observe any blisters on his foot at frst?
A. Yes, there were rs on his foot.
Q. And would that verify. his statement that he had ap-

3 Did you see on his foot any cyt or abeasion that would
indicate that he had run his foot on to a nail? 4
A. I did not.
a reine
nail, and this gangrenous condition developed in a period
of aboyt eight or nine days, would that or abrasion still .
de visible, had it ever been there? Bei

Mr. Graves: I object to that unless it is definitely stated
as to the character of abrasion and as to the extent of it. Sere
rr i
. — N *

ae aes „

The Witness: No.
The Court ou have not
The Witness: No. ; gus 5
The Court: Then, say so. Say that you can not.
The Witness: I can not. cote Ss 0
Mr. Crawford: We are a little handicapped because we
have not had the plaintiff’s statement as to what this cut

- Was, .

Q. Assuming that there was a nail wound in this foot,
Doctor, sufficient to cause a bad infection followed by

+ gangrene, do you think, from from experience, that you

would have been able to see that nail wound at the time you
(fol. 26] examined this man in the hospital some eight or

7

nine days after the alleged accident?

Mr. Graves: That is objected to on the ground that it
calls for a conclusion. :

Mr. Crawford: This is an expert witness.

The Court: He is not asking for a conclusion. He is ask-
ing for his opinion. He was not there. He knows nothing
about what happened, but he asks his opinion as a phy-
sician, whether after eight or nine days follqwing an injury
by a nail, it would cause an infection that he could see. The
' fundamental facts on which that hypothetical question is
based are not in evidence yet. | *

Mr. Graves: No. I object to it on the ground that I have
not examined the doctor as an expert, and that this is not
proper cross examination. 1 3

The Court: You have not examined him as an expert?

Mr. Graves: No, sir; just to testify to the facts,

The Court: Did you qualify him as an expert?

Mr. Graves: No, sir. 7% |

The Court: You did not? 3
, Mr. Graves: I qualifled him as a physieian, but I have not
asked his opinion as an expert. I have only asked him to
deseribe what he found. - _ ete? 1

The Court: Then, I would suggest that you ask him
Mr. Graves: They may recall him on their case, for that
put pose, as part of their case, but not now on cross exami--
nation. 3 ; gee eae Boe
[fol. 27] Mr. Crawford: I think I am entitled, on cross-
examination, to go beyond the mere facts of this case, to

*

18

test Mis doctor's ability, if you like. I am quite ‘satiaflod
with it, but it ems to me that I may ask queries which
would tend to indicate his quali‘ications. 7
The Court: It is not cross-examination.
Mr. Crawford: All tight, sir, Will you repeat the quos-
tion?
Tuo Court: Where there has been a wound, through a
foot coming into contact, with a nail, which develops a
gangrenoua condition, would you say that there would be
evidence of that wound apparent in the foot eight or nine
days after the foot came into such contact?
The Witness: Yes, I would.

. But you saw no such evidence | in this case, Doctor,
‘did you?

A. I did not.

Q. Now, Doctor, there are various 3 of gangrene, are
there not? .

A. There are.

Q. And will you state what some of the causes of gan-
‘ grene are?
A. Exposure to cold, exposure to bent, clots forming in
vessels, acute illness, typhoid, scarlet fever, diphtheria,
pheumonia—definite diseases in the vessels, where the
walls of the vessels break down and accloy the lumen of

the vessel. a ö

The Court: There are many causes?

The Witness: Yes, there are.many causes.
The Court: Even more than you have mentioned!
The Witness: Yes, more besides those.

(fol. 28] C. One of the. causes, of course, is an open
wound—of gangrene?

A. It may be caused by an open i ectious wound, pro-
vided the right type of infeetion is carried in. through that
wound. |

1

Q. The gangrene that is caused by an open wound, does
that differ in any way from the gangrene caused by an ar-
terial stoppage, or one of those other types that you have
mentioned

A. It does.

Q. What is that difference?

A. Gangrene caused by an infection has with it also the
evidence of the infection, which gives it a pussy discharg-
ing surface, known as the wet type of gangrene. .

The Court: Can you tell upon an examination of gan-
grene whether it is-caused by,» physical condition of the
patient or whether it is caused by some external means!

The Witness: Yes. 7

The Court: They differ?

The Witness: Yes, they do.

The Court: The symptoms are different?

The Witness: Yes, they are.

Q. ‘Now, in this case, Doctor, from your examination
of this man on several occasions, and from the operation
which you performed on him, could you say that this con-
dition of gangrene which you found in this man’s leg was
caused by a wound or otherwise?
A. I think it was caused otherwise.
. And in your opinion it was this arterial, en that
you have mentioned! ;
A. Yes, sir.

The Court: You say that his gangrene was caused by an
arterial condition?
[fol. 29] The Witness: I think so.

The Court: And can you speak with reasonable certainty
when you say it was not caused by some W means?

The Witness: Yes.

Q. Now, Doctor, when you have a gangrenous wound,
do you attempt to localize it in treating it?

A. Yes, to limit the gangrene.

Q. To limit the * of the gangrene

A. Yes.

2. And in those cuses you do riot attempt to aid the cir-
witiee by shooting blood—more blood through by e an ar-
terial operation, such as you have described?

A. No.

Q. Tell us how you do treat an arterial gangrehe !

A. With the operation I have already described.

Q. And that is sympathectomy? a

A. Yes, and we also do a gangrene operation which goes
higher, and. attacks the gangrene before it ‘becomes part
of the periarterial course,

ꝙꝙ—

-
. The methods of — pom two types of wangrene

ate quite the reverseT |
A, They are, le, .

The Court: They are entirely different, are they!

The Witness: They are.

Tho Court: And they are not the same gangrene?
The Witness: They are not.

Mr. Crawford: That is all.

Redirect examination.
| By Mr. Graven: 2
Q. Doctor, le it not the fact-— -

[fol. 30) The Court: One is caused by an tnfectlein, and
the othier is caused by some external means!
The Witness: Les.
The'Caurt: While the other le duo to un Internal condl.
tion of the body 7
The Witness: Yes.
The Court: And are they, both called .
The Witness: Tes, they are both called gang rene“,

Q. Doctor,-is it not the fact that any kind of a puncture
of a Bid, skin or the tissues of the body, sufficient to
. * may be — to produce infection? — f

8 Me that if you — a person la liable to In-
teotlon— that la, predisposed to infection, with a system that
is in a condition to be infected by bacteria, the slightest

prick of a pin or any introduction of a foreign body with

ria in or on it, into the blood stream, will cause an in-
fection; is that not sof

A. Well,am I testifying as an expert, your Honor, now!

It seems to me that some of ‘these = are expert

questions?

The Court: Yes, he is 222 you * an expert opinion.

Mx. Graves: They have made him their expert, and T
am.cross examining him as an expert.

The Witness: Yes, that may produce an infection.

f 0 So that the slightest soratoh, sufficient to draw blood,
will be sufficient to cause infection, will it not?
A. It will be, yes. .

. *
. = n

(fol. 31] C. And auch u — soratch that you might not
he able to soe It eleven days later? a
A. Well, you would be able to seo It oleven days later,
you, bacause the infection . there would produce .
dofinite looal redactions where It originated,
Q. 1.21 hnve a diagram of this man's foot-in via aan —
ro
A. You, wo have a diagram hora,
8 | And that shows that on the left foot at the point—at
the top of the instop, that le, at the ankle poln.

Mr. Orawford: Iw this foie to be introduced in evi-
ee If wo, I wears like to know who drew it, your
onor '
Tho Courts Lot us noo what ho says, Do 10 want that

In evidence?
Mr. Graves No, leave it out,

g You tontified that you found blisters on his foot!
on

. Whore wero those blisters!
Around his ankle * just above the gangrenous
ron. N

Q. On the loft foot?

A. You;

J. And the skin was broken there, wan 161

A. It was broken, yes.

Q Dia you look under that skin to see whether there was

* — La
0, not,

Q. The blisters had broken, had they not

A. Not all of thom.

Q. Some of them had?

A. Yes,

3 You don’t know whether there was any panetare mark
under the blisters?

A. I do not.

0 The whole surface of that foot was raw

A. Not the whole surface,

The Court: Where were the blisters? Between the ankle
and the sole of the foot?
kol. 321 The Witness: They were on the upper surface
ok the foot, near the ankle.
The Court; Between the toes and the ankle?

-
1
— - — * — =~ 2 7 -
; I J gre P

The Witness: Yes, between the toes and the ankle; not
28 dottom part of his foot, but on the top part of his

Q. ‘Is it chown on that diagram?

A. Yes.
. And that shows right here in the ankle joint (indi-
cating) ? 2. N

A. Velo the ankle joint, yes.

Q. Right at the ankle joint?

A. Above the instep.

Q. Look at the diagram.

A. I am looking at it now.

Q. Is it not right at the ankle joint?
A. No, it is below there.

Mr. Crawford: Is that going in evidence?

The Court: The diagram will be the best evidence of
what it shows.

Mr. Graves: Are you willing to put it in—the diagram?

_ Crawford: I have not seen it. I don't know what
it is.

Mr. Graves: All right, here it is (handing paper to Mr.
Crawford).

Mr. Crawford: Your Honor, this is a pen and ink sketch
by someone—whom I do not know at all. I do not think this
is proper evidence in this case.

The Court: Do you offer it?

Mr. Graves: I will offer it if he consents. If he objects,
I will not.

Mr. Crawford: Yes.

(fol. 33] C. Have you any independent recollection of
where those blisters were, Doctor?

A. No, not all of them. I recollect that there were blis-
cc

a Court: Did you see any scar or sign of an abrasion?
The Witness: I did not look . for it, but I ex-
amined his foot, and saw no evidence of

You looked at it casually, did *
No, I looked
Did you examine it for a wound?

Q.
1
A. 1 — er it for whatever was there.

. 23
0. The dightest scrateh, sufficient to draw blood, is a com-
petent cause for causing gangrene?
A. You, it may.
Q. Provided the patient is predisposed to being 3

is not that so?
A. Yes.

The Court: Will general infection cause or give rise to
gangrene? Would that be a competent cause ot Dr
that you have described?

The Witness: No.

Q. If a man had syphilis, would that * a competent pro-
ducing cause? *

The Court: The syphilis itself?
Mr. Graves: No, a nail plus syphilis.

A. I could not answer that queation.

The Court: Assuming that a man has syphilis, and he
[fol. 34] scratches his foot with a nail, and it is infected,
could that infection cause the gangrene ‘which you have de-
scribed to the jury?

The Witness: No.

Q. Why not?

A. Not without producing definite seat evidence of the
infection.
Q. Do you mean to say there was no “evidence of any
infection in this case?

A. (No response. )

Q. Now, is it not the fact, Doctor, that infection can be
produced without bacteria?

A. Infection without bacteria?

Q. Yes?

The Court: Can that happen?
The Witness; No.

. Is it not true that gangrene can be caused without
bacteria? :

A. Oh, yes. We have already mentioned that it can.

Q. Now, is it not the fact that syphilis and many other
diseases are a cause of deterioration of the arteries?

A. Yes.

Q. And how many different causes are there of deteri-
oration of the arteries? ~

$

A. There are numorous causes of deterioration of the
artorlos, some of which wo have mentioned. Old age, sonlle
dogonoratlon

Aloohollem a

A. You, 5 N ,

J. Tobacco!

A. ¥

06.
Q. Diabetes! ;
A. Ves. é

The Court! Swift living?
The Witness: Vos, swift living and numerous other

LL

0. 4. fact, they are multitudinoust
: On,

ital 35] . And whether a person has good artorion or
not is simply a relative term, is it not?

A. Vos, it is, ©

Q. And many people aro born with poor artorlos !

A. That is true.

Q. And they W bo W ‘afflicted with poor
arteries? /

A. They may. N

Q. be they may be congenitally ufflictod with ayphilin?

A. That is right.

Q. And all those various. diseases, including © aoqulrod
habits, such as drinking and smoking?

8 ge that is right.

That L ried is Kable to have bad arteriost

x 4 Is it not tho 1 that the numbor of syphilitic persons
in the United States is woll in excess of a million—the

known syphilitios?

The Court: What has that got to do with this case
whether there are a million or a billion? It may be inter-
esting, but it has nothing to do with this case. I fool sorry
for them—did you say a billion?

VMI. Graves: No, I said a million, known.

The Court: That may be not so far afield.

Q. If a person has arteries that are depreciated or deté-

riorated, he is much more apt to gangrene from an
infection than if he has healthy arteries, is not that sot

A.’ Quite true, yes,”

Q. And as matter of fact people with syphilis may go
— ** life without getting any gangrene, is not that:
Aus/ :

A. They may, you,

J. And it le usually the introduction of some moving
cause, stich as the introdiction of infection into the sys-
— that brings on the acute stage of gangrene, is not that
right? °

A. No. .
fol. 30 Q. Do you say that syphilis, in and of itself, will
cause gangrene? —

A. No, not by itself,’

J. It must be in conjunction with something olset
A. Tho rosults of syphilitic degeneration in the arterial
system of tho. body prodisposes to the formation of clots
and Vegetation. ‘

. * mere syphilis itself wil} not cause gangrene?

A, 0. f
. Tnord must bo something else to bring about throm-
bowls? |

Tho Court: Syphilis will not produce it, you say, alone?

The Witness: No, syphilis wilt produce various condi-
tions in various parts of the body, It may produce vego-
tation upon the valves of the heart, and material may be
thrown from that into a vessel through the circulation, or
vogotatlon may form on the heart through the normal
span of life, and the person may die of other cause;
but if he has a sudden shock, or something happens to
him that he does not take care of properly, that vegetation
may be thrown into the circulation, and accloy a vessel
somewhere in the body.

. And that applies to any of the other diseases you
have spoken about f

A. Ves, that applies to the other diseases as well.

Q. Is it not the fact also that if a person has diseased
arteries, the introduction of infection is practically certain
to bring on gangrene? ;

7 |

Q. If it is an acute infection

A. No. , } ,

Q. Well, it can be a competent producing cause, can it
not? =. ‘ 0
A. Yes, it can be. 1

[fol. 87] The Court: If infection la (ho cause of gangrene, -
ln that gangrene different from gangrene which was not
brought on — hifection?

The Witness:

The Court: The two are entirely different?

The Witness: You,

Q. But you say that Infection van produce it ann be
a competent produolng cause?

A; With diseased arteries, you.

Q. And in that case the diseased arteries would be only
nN comgtientjont

. And as matter of fact did you not put down on the
records In thin case ‘ Complioationa, ** — i al
the firat page of that record (handing wit ra

A. No, I did not — down — at all

Q. Who put that

A. One of the internes. :

Q. called in a consultant In thin ease, dd you not? -

oa.
And what was his namo!

A. I did not call him in, no.

Q. And of course you conaldored hix opinion In arriving
at 4 * diagnoniat n

A. 1
. And you havo considered that now In all your tonti.
mony, have yout You have givon that vom wolght?
A. No, I have hot.
Q. Do you mean to any you havo disrogarded what tho
consultant told about the caso, aftor ho was called in?
A. Because the consultant was called in aftor I was
through with the case. Ho was called in just before am-
utation. I did not call him in.
kol. 38) C. Will you read what the consultant said on
that record?

Mr. Crawford: I object to that as not the proper way
of proving whatever this other doctor is going to say.
The Court: He may read that record to refresh his
recollection.
Mr. Crawford: Yes, but he cannot testify about it.

— -—-

8 7 2 - 4

ns 0 . |

5 Abe 97

The Witness: The question was antiluotio or tig
treatment, The dootor who ia the ayphilologiat forthe hone .

pital treate all 77 for ayphills, Ho makes a note here
“Gangrene o the foot; may not be luetio ca,.

may hot yo of ayphilitie aa
Q. Thatta what the Abort ald that you onlled In .

A. I didn't oall him In.
Q. Well, he was oallod-in?

A. You, he was, '
9 fle fs a reoogn Ped wuthority, in he not?
* In the treatment of nyphiltn, yon, N

The Courts What ighis namo
Tho Witness: Tan!
. Ho wai tllod m- hy the hospital as M consultant in

this dase

A. You. | |

Q. And in your toatimony that you have given on the
ae you given any wolght to Dr. Takami 's opinion
there? .

A. No. f 3
J Tou had road. It boforo, had you not!
A, No, 1 had not, : — *
Now, will you read it, and toll mo whether you wish
to change your opinion at all? 2 b
(fol. 89) Mr. Crawford! And road all of it this time,
Doctor. . 28
The Witnoas: This is the record of the consultant, Shall
Ireaditaloud! .

The Court: No; read it to yourself,
Ar. Graves: You road it to the jury before.
The Witness: I only read part of It.
Mr. Graves; Now, read all of it,
The Witness: ‘Gangrene of the foot may not be Inetic.
cause, but he needs anti-luetic treatment at once to sid

healing after amputation."’ 5 ed

Q. And by that you take it that that means s that syphilis

may not have been the cause of the gangrene, is that right?
No, I do not. 7 .

Q. Well; what does that mean, Doctor?

111 1
— 2 —

n.d haan ected Gor ene idaho tall ia va bre: .
in the first place. He was asked relative te anti-luetic
treatment, and he gave an opinion that the man needed
. anti-luetic treatment; and he also stated about. gangrene,
Which he was not asked about.

Q. That it might not have been due to syphilis?

A. Yea
_ Q. In other words; he, put something down there that 4
you did not ask for? „

A. That is right. N 1 N ,

Mr. Crawford: I object to that.
The Witness: And he is not an expert in gangrene.
The Court: Is he in court?
The Witness: I do not see him here.
The Court: Where is he now? Is: he living?
The Witnésg: Oh, yes, in Brooklyn. :
(fol. 40} The Court: In Brooklyn?
The Witness: Yes.
The Court: He can be gotten?
The 1 Witness: I suppose so.

Q. Now, Doctor, you say that he put down ates
that was not asked for? g

A. Tes.
ä Q. I thought you just said you had never seen that
opinion before, and.that he came into the case after ‘you
dropped out? How do you know that?
A. Bevause I didn’t ask him to come in to see it

The Court: Were you there when he came int
The Witness: No, I was not there.

. He came in long afterwards?

A. Yes.

. How do you know he was not asked that, if he came 72
in after you were out of the case?

A. — it states up here, in the consultation sheet
what the — ey mpi

Q. And you do not think that is broad enough to include
2 5

A. No. :
@. Bat even if it were, you would not give his opinion

on that any weight? 5
A. Not relative to the gangrene; because be ie not an

on gangrene.

. 0 : a # ”
J. He is an expert.on ayphilis 0

. Tes. °

Q. Can not a man who is an expert on.syphilis be an
expert on the results of syphilis? PV ie
A. He can, yves. Se .
he . Bt you would not give his opinion any weight as
to what syphilis: may cause? . 2
A. Les. 2 2

Q. As matter of fact, gangrene might be a symptom
that a man had some syphilis in his system!
A. It is possible. a
{fol. 41] Q. But at the same time if that man stated any-
thing along that line, you would not give it any credit?
A. If I thought. it was entirely due to his syphilis, I
would, yes. f
Q. Now; Doctor, as matter of fact, any kind of infection,
where a man has diseased arteries, is very apt to bring
on gangrene, is it not?
A. Quite likely, yes. . ; a
Q. And assuming that this man did have a puncture of
his foot on February 13, and that bacteria was introduced
into thé blood stream, and an infection ensued, and that
the man hf syphilis, as evidenced by a 4 plus test, would
vou not say that the introduction of that nail into the
blood stream, and that bacteria, and the consequent in-
fection, could be a competent producing cause of the gan-
grene / a f 5
A. Not of the type of gangrene that he had, no. ~~
Q. What do you mean by that?
A. He did not have the type of gangrene that is pro-
duced by, infection, g
Q. You mean a. wet gangrene? |
A. He had a dry gangrene, and there was no evidence
of infection.
- .Q. matter of fact, was not this gangrene wet at th
beginning; when he first came into the hospital? * .
A. No, it was not. |
Q. Look at the records and see if it is not stated that
„the gangrene is beginning to become dry’’?
A. There may be a statement in here made by an in-.
terne, of which I know nothing, but it was not during my
period of observation of the case. ‘

—

80
Now, Doctor, gangrene is nothing more nor less than
a shutting off of the blood? That-is what it is caused by,
los it not f N
A. Les. a
(fol. 42] C. A choking up of a blood vessel, of the blood

7
N. is right. ° f
Aud the tissues mortify or die below the point of the
obstruction? eas
S a .
. And it may be caused by various things, but an in-
fection can bring it on in an acute stage, is not that right?
A. If you have already got an existing arterial condition,

Q. In other words, if you have impaired arteries, an in-
fection will precipitate that condition, is not that right?

A. Yes.

Q. And will induce it

A. Yes. |

Q. And be a competent producing cause of it?
A. Yes. | ‘.

© Q. Now, in this particular case you did not have any
pathological tests made of the tissue of the blood vessels, |
did you? . j
A. I don't know whether it was made or not. It should
have been. .
Q. Look at that record and tell us whether any such tests
were madef
A. As a general rule, they have to bury a membei_ of
the body when it is amputated, and pathalogical specimens
are very rarely taken, if a foot or an arm or a hand is
removed, because they have to be buried, according to the
law of the city; and I. don’t think a specimen was taken.
It usually is not unless specifically requested.
Q. No specimens were taken of the tissues?
A. There is no mention of it here.

Q. So no test was made to ascertain the extent to which
the impairment had progressed? 5
A. Not at the time of the operation.

Q. Now, this operation that you performed on the fe-
moral artery was simply an exploration!
A. No, it is a definite 6
Q Is it not experimental?
A. No, it is not. N

.—— —
31

(fol. 431 Q. Are you familiar with a work called De-
Costa on General Surgery’’? 9 . ;
A. Yes.
Q. Is he a recognized authority on surgery?
A. Yes.

Mr. Crawford: I can see no purpose in this particular
phase of the examination, unless it be for Mr. Graves to
impeach his own witness, -.

Mr. Graves: You mage him an expert.

Mr. Crawford: And I therefore object to any further
questions along this line, ' ?

The Court: You produced him as your witness.

Mr. Graves: Only as to primary facts, but my opponent
made him an expert on his own behalf, and I have a right
to cross examine him. .

The Court: Well, you may have your exception. I think
vou are technically right.

Mr. Crawford: I think I am too. Exception.

The Court: Yes. N

Q. IJ will show you this, and you can verify whether what
I am reading is true. I will read this and ask you whether
you agree with this statement at page 93 of the tenth edi-
tion of DeCosta.

A. What year is that?
. Q..1931 (reading). Do you agree with that statement?

A. I agree with that statement coming from a group of
surgeons in this country. The profession is divided as
to the efficiency of those things. However, they are not
on trial, because the particular operation I did has existed

_ since 1899. 85

Lol. 441 Q. Well, that is on trial, is it not?

A. It is not on trial, when it has existed that long, no.

The Court: Did you operate for exploratory purposes?
The Witness: I did not.

Q. Was it on trial when that book was published in 19311

A. No, it was not. ' N

Q. You do not agree with that statement, then, do you?

A. I do not.

Q. So that when ye come right down to it, if thio man
actually had his foot punctured with a nail, the whole
ourse of your opinion would be altered as to whether or

1

32
not the syphilis was the’ cause of this thing or amy a |
complicating cause, is not that right?

A. Yes, |

Q. So thut it just comes down to a question of whether
no did have a scratch, and infestion ensued, and then the
nail would be a competent producing cause, is not that
right, as you have just stated?

A. Yes, infection as a result of the nail, that would bo.

Q. Of course, you are basing this theory of an embolus
on your opinion?

A. Yes.

Q. But you do not know 8 an embolus was thore,
because you did not find one?

A. No, I do not.

Q. And you did not have an examination of the arteries
or the blood vessels to find out whether the diseased con-
dition of the arteries had progressed so far that there
was an embolus or anything of that sort?

_ A. Had there been an embolus, it would not have been
in that part of the leg that was amputated.

* Lou did not see any embolus at any time?
A. No. N

[fol. 45] The Court: Before you operated on him did you
make an examination of him?

The Witness: Yes.

The. Court: Did you examine - the condition of the ar-
teries?

The Witness: Yes. :

The Court: What did you do?

The Witness: By testing the surface temperature of his
leg, by palpating for pulsation in the two main vessels of
his foot, the anterior and posterior vessels, and there was
no pulsation in either, and the surface ef the leg was cold,
and the temperature lowered, as we always have in a com-
pletely obstructed vascular condition.

‘The Court: War that general throughout the body or
localized !

The Witness: The obstruction of the vessel was localized.

Q. As matter of fact, you never opened his arteries or
any of his blood vessels?
A. Yes, I cut some of them.

7 — vou did not out into the main artery?
A. No.

Q. So you do not know whether there were any emboli
in them or not?

A. I know there was none in the area I operated.

| Phe Court: Can you tell from an examination of a pa-
tient 's eyes, the fine blood vessels of the eyes, what his
condition is? | 7
The Witness: Yes.
The Court: Ig that an indication of the — on of tue.
blood vessels?
The Witness: Yes, particularly in arteriosclerosis and
[fol. 46] the diabetic type of degeneration. ~
The Court: Can you tell by touching the patient?
The Witness: Yes, you can tell by touch,
The Court: The general condition of a man’s arteries?
The Witness: You can, yes.
The Court: Did you examine his arteries?
The Witness: I did.
The Court: All right.

Q. Is there any place in that record ci you = pet down
any result of an examination of his eyes by yout
A. No, there is not. fi
Q. You did not examine his eyes? . ¢
A. No. 8
Q. All you did was to make or perform this operation
on the thigh, to scrape the surface of the artery?
A. Les. N
Q. And the purpose of that was to cut off the nerve
_ connections?
A. Yes.
Q. To eliminate the . spasmodis closing of the ä
.
Q. And you did not open the artery and find any emboli?
A. No.
Q. And, it is purely guesswork as to whether any emboli
were present at all?
A. No, it is not guesswork.
Q. How could you tell that there were any emboli pres-
ent without opening and actually finding an embolus?

3—178

—

A. Of course, that would be the most definite way of
telling it, but there are many things that we can tell other-
wise. ,

Q. All right, tell us what the symptoms were of emboli!

A. The man had a definite history of a sudden onset of
(fol. 47] pain; he treated his foot with heat, where the cir-
culation was already impaired: and we find in diabetes and
all forms of circulatory disturbance that heat and cold will
produce gangrene of the type that he had. He had, as I
say, a history of a sudden onset of pain, which, in my
opinion, means some sudden, definite happening to
the circulatory apparatus. He was not of an age where
we would begin to think of senile degeneration of the vas-
cular system. He ‘did not have, in his laboratory examina-
tions, any evidence of diabetes or nephritis; and because
of those things, and because of the lowered temperature on
the surface of his leg, we felt that he had a sudden stop-
page, and that sudden stoppage must have been due to
emboli, It is fairly definite, because those are the symp-
toms you have to deal with, and you can, by other patho-
logical examinations, eliminate other conditions that would
produce the same

Q. Now, Doctor, an embolus may be caused by any one .
of numerous different things?

A. Yes.

Q. And you did not find any embolus, but you guess there
was an embolus present or you formed that opinion from
- certain other things that you have described, is that right?

A. I felt reasonably sure that there was.

1 2 ee ae

es.

G. Is pain also a symptom of infection?

A. Yes.

*Q. So that pain could be caused by infection as well as
by these other things that you have described!

A. Tes. .

Q. Is that right?

A. Yea.

Q. Now, thrombosis can cause the same condition as an
embolus?

A. Yes. .
[fol. 48] Q. A thrombosis is a blood clot?

A. Yea.

; 80

d. And an embolus is some foreign body or portion of
tissue that has gotten ioose, and is obstructing 4 blood
vessel? | |

A. That is right. aie

. So far as your examination of his leg is concerned,
without ‘opening any of those arteries, you can not tell
whether it is a thrombosis or an embolus, can you?

A. No, I could not.

Q. And it is simply a guess on your part that this was
an embolus? 755

A. No, a thrombus comes on, as a general rule, in the
lower leg more gradually. It is not as sudden in its onset.
. A thrombus can be brought on by infection?

X. Yes, a thrombus may be brought on by infection.

Q. And when a thrombus is brought on by infection it
is yery rapid in its formation? 5

A. It can be. 3

Q. And gangrene develops rapidly and acutely?

A. It begins very gradually—gangrene produced by a
thrombus. 7 *

Q. As soon as you have a complete stoppage

A. (Interposing.) Yes, but in thrombus you do not get
a complete stoppage-immediately. a

Q. Well, you may have the two together?

A. You mean gangrene and a thrombus?

Q. Yes. .

A. You may have the two together, yes.

Q. At any rate, all you know is that this man had syph-
ilis, and there was a stoppage in his blood vessels or ar-
teries of his leg at some point or other, and gangrene
developed, is not that right?

A. That is right.

Q. And that stoppage could have been brought on by
infection—by even the small prick of a nail, provided bac-
teria was introduced, is not that right?

A. That is right.

(fol. 49] C You are not being paid anything by me, are

yout
“A. I don’t think so; not that I know of.

The Court: Are you being paid anything by the other
side? 0

The Witness: Not yet. .

The Court: Have they promised you anything?

The Witness: No.

The Court: Has the other side subponaed yout
The Witness: Both sides subponaed me.
The Court: Both sides subpœnaed yout

The Witness: Yes.

Recross-examination,

By Mr. Orawford:

Q. Gangrene of this type sould not be brought on by in-
fection—the type of this man 0 Redman?
A. It could not, no.

Mr. Crawford: That is all.
Mr. Graves: That is all.

_ (Witness excused.)

The Court: We will adjourn now until tomorrow morn-
ing at half past ten, gentlemen,
Mr. Graves: Will the Court direct the witnesses to re-
turn tomorrow?
Tho Court: I will, but I do not know what good it does,
They are entitled to a fee. I will direct 2 but I cannot
punish fhem if they do not come.

(Adjourned to Thursday, * 23, 1933, at 10:30 o’clock
A. M.)

|

[fol. 50 . New York, March 23, 1933,

Trial Continued: ;

Mr. Graves: If the Court pl I offer in evidence the
deposition of the first officer of the steamship ‘‘ Frances
‘Weems’’, Terence M. Burrows, taken by the defendant on
March 11, 1932. I offer the entire deposition.

Mx. Crawford: I think the — way to do that in this
court is to read question and answer.

The Court: Yes; how otherwise would the r know
what was said. ;

‘*Terence M. Burrows, a witness called on behalf of the
defendant, having been first sworn, testified as follows:

—

— ?ꝶ ⁵ꝛ. — — — ——üä—

‘Direct oxamination.

By Mr. Meagher :

N. „J. Mr. Burrows, 7* are now in the employ of the Bal-
\. thmore and Carolina Line, Ino., are yout
„A. No; A. H. Bull & Oo. They operate the Baltimore
and Carolina Line.
. And on what ship are you employed now?
WAL On the ‘Jean’,
„. Where is that vessel now?
„A, At Pler 29, Brooklyn. She is going to shift to Pier
27 about noon,
„. And where are you going from there?
tA. To ports in Porto Rico and back again.
„. About how long do you expect to be away?
“A, About twenty-one to twenty-seven days.
fol. 511 „“. What job do you hold on that ship now?
tae Chief mate,
„,. And how long have you been going to svat
„A. It will be seventeen years this coming June.
„. And what licenses and certificates have you!
„A. 1 have a master’s license, unlimited, and nine en-
e for pilot licenses.
„9. Now, on: * 13, 1930, were you employed by
the Baltimore and Carolina Line, ino. f :
„A. You, sir.
„. On board the steamship ‘Weems’?
“A, You, sir.
„. And you were first mate on that vonsol, were you
not?
„A. Chief mato, vos.
“(Q, Whore was the Francos Weems’ on February 13,
19307
1 „A. The neareſt I can come to that is that we sailed Sat-
urday, whatever day Saturday was, and I am positive that
we were at Pier 27, Brooklyn, because we came in and
anchored and went to that pier the whole time we were in
New York. What date was Saturday? I think it was the
15th,
40. As far as you can recall, you were there on the 13th
of February, 19301
„A. We were there, undoubtedly.

—

38 | .
„5. What work was being done aboard tho vessel on the
12th, say on the 12th of — 19301
. I wish 1 had my log book with me, The ship was un-
XI. ing cargo at that time.
t kind of cargo?
— ok General cargo.
1 . long docs that loading of cargo continue dur-
ng t

%,. by a tule, from seven to eight in the — until
five o'clock in the evening, unless in a rush they work over-
time, then they work nights.
kol. 53] . What were your duties as first mate on this
vessel!
A. In charge of the ship dur the captain's absence,
and directly in charge of the deck rtment. .
„. When you -say, in cha * the deck department, :
just what duties did that inol
„A. The upkeep of the ship, the hull of the ship, and the
deck, the upkeep of the cargo gear, and the handling—I
mean, the loading of the cargo, and in general charge of
the decks of the ship,
„„No, do you ‘recall What the condition of the deck
was on February 13, 1930?
„A. No, I could not recall that. I could say about what
it would be.
„Win you state that?

Mr. Graves: I object to that. It is too speculative.
Mr. Meagher: All right.

ben among Pom as first mate to inspect the
condition of the

“A. At all times : am responsible for the condition of
the deck.

„But you do not recall what the condition of the deck
was on February 13, 19301

„. No, sir, I could not.

„bo you know what the condition was at about five
arg te pe eh pn ev be

„A. No, sir; I could not recall that.

Wat dime did you knock off duties on February 12,
r '

„ My duty ends at five o clock, unless They are work-
ing cargo, and then I was on-duty, unless I am needed, that
is; I am on duty at all times whenever I am needed, but on

39.
that date I cannot say because it is too far off; I cannot
remember. | : |

. Now, when you abandon your duties for the day is
[fol. 53]. it customary for you to give any orders to any
other members of the crew? | .
* „A. Yes, sir, I give orders to the mate on watch, the
d second or third mate, whichever it may be, to see that the
watch is kept, and the lines attended, and it is my custom to
give the orders to him'that the t watehman shall clean
up the decks during the night, so that the ship will be clean
to start with the next day, to coil up the lines and straighten —
the decks in general. 1
10. Do you recall giving such orders on the evening of
Fobruary 12, 1980 : |
„A. No, I cannot recall that. .
0. Do you recall not giving such orders .
A. No, sir; in fact, I do not always give them. I give
them to the mate when he comes aboard, and tell him that.
that is the custom. This was the case just last night.
Knowing of this case, of course, and the condition of the
decks, unconsciously I gave the order to the mate last night,
a new third mate wha had just joined the ship, for the
watchman to sweep the decks and coil up the lines and have
them in a clean condition to start this morning with.

„. Did you know the second cook aboard the ‘Frances
Weems’ on February 13, 19301

A. No, sir; I remember the name distinctly, seeing it on
the articles, but the man I. tried to recall and cannot.

„ Would you recognize him if you met him?

“A. I would; if I met him I would recogmize him; yes,
sir. The steward I remember distinctly, and every one of
the crew, that is, if I saw them, for, of course, you live with
them and you know them. é a

“Q. Now, you know that Redman claims to have sus-
[fol. 54] tained an injury aboard the ‘Frances Weems’ on
F 13, 19301 ’

“A. Yes, sir.

„. When was the first time that you learned of any
such claim by Redman?

‘A. When I received a letter from the company’s law
yers asking me regarding this claim. :

„. Did Redman br anyone else report any such injury
to you? .

“A. Not to me. .

— kee

„. (Continuing: ) —wia from the advice from the line?
„&. That is it.”
“Q. What was the custom aboard the ‘Frances Weems’ |’
—au=a€ Was there any ryle
7
„& Yes, sir. The rule is to report to the head of the de-
partment aboard the ‘Frances Weems’ when any injury
occurs. 0
* Head of the department! :
“A. Yes, that have been the steward. ,
*Q. a depa t to which the man injured belongs !
1 A. es. j
) “Q. Ail in that dase whom would that be!
A. The steward. \,
„0. And was it customary, was there any rule to the
".* @ffect that the steward should report that injury to any
higher officer? *
A. Tes, sir.
“Q> What officer would the steward report that injury
to? oe
5 & Either to the mate or to the captain.
Tou state that no report of any injury to Redman
was ever made to you?
A. Not to nie, no, sir.
fol. 55) ‘*Q. You spoke about giving orders to any man
vessel!

9 Was it the custom on the ‘Frances Weems’ to advise
any members of the crew of the rule that you have just
X. No, sir, not to the men. They are directed through
the.officer only, The men are directed only through the

. injory ooourred aft of the main deck on starboard side be

41
same Co teach und hs ented ot, Did you know
whether or not there are any lights aboard the Frances
. Weems’ around that vicinity?
„Les, sir; I know; — ee
side you say?
"

A. Yes, sir, :

„. And you had one hour to eat and clean up before you
went ashore; is that right? a

“A. Les. i 2
fol. 601 „. You went ashore at six?

A. Yes, sir. |

„. Every evening?

‘A. I don’t remember. I don’t remember every evening.

‘*Q. You said you were ashore every evening?

„A. I was, g

„ You went ashore usually at six o’clock, didn't you?

„A. Ves, sir. ; ! a

„. And you had one hour from the time the longshore-
men quit work to eat your dinner and clean up to go ashore?
Is that right?

„A. That is right.

*Q. Of course, you wanted to get ashore as soon as pos-
sible after a hard day’s work; is that right?

„A. That is right. +

„. Your work was over at five o’clock, wasn’t it?

„A. Yes, sir, but I would not be in a hurry to go ashore
because I live in Baltimore. I only went ashore in New
York to visit friends. | |
Didn't you state that you went ashore every eve-
ning? |

A. Yes, sir.

„. At six o’clock?

„A. I said about six o’clock. 5

„It may have been before or a little after?

A. It may have been. 6

„. At any rate you went from your work right to eat
and from there to your quarters; is that right?

—

“A. That is right.
„To dress up and go ashore, is that right?
“A. You, sir.
"Q, You would then go ashore; lo thet right?
„A. Ves, air,
„. That was the course you followed every day in port!
MA. Yes, sir,

. Would you Ar before dinner or afterwards?

“A, Afterwards. N

"Q. Now, you aay it was, your duty to seo that this gen-
eral cleaning up of the decks was made each day after the
fol. 61] men off work, is that right?

* That is right.

„And you said that the men themselves could not be

trusted to do thet, the sailors?

A. No, sir, they cannot be.

„I- that right?

„A. That is right.

„ Because somebody had to ovortee them to see that

that was done? N

„A. Yea, sir.

. de tree on thai chip?

„A. That is true on all ships.

„Lou knew that at that time?

“A. Ves, sir, I knew that.

„Lou had to have someone stand over the men and
see that the decks were cleaned up; is that right? |

„A. That is right.

„Would the longshoremen do that or the sailors?

A. Sailors.

„And some officer of the vessel had to see that the
sailors did that work every day; is that right?

„A. That is right.

**Q. You had found that unless that was done in the first
place that they did not do it properly and had left debris
round, is that right?

„A. That is righ
**Q. So that you had notice of the fact that some officer

—
re

E

„A. That is right.

„And you say that was your duty?

„A. That was my duty.

* Who was on watch when you went ashore?
„A. I don’t remember.

AS ee Seen Son © One right? f/

„Lou don't know who was on watch?

“A. Either the second or third officer.

. You do not remember any particular day

„A. No, they alternated. :
ou do not recall on any r date in Feb-
[fol. 62] ruary, at Pier 27, what r was on duty at five
o'clock on?

“A. I do not. |

„ Were you still on duty technically at five o'clock?

A. Yea.

Lou were

„A. No; that word technical

Lou were on duty until you left the ship?

A. In charge.

„In general charge? _

„A. Ves, sir.

„. You were the boss of everybody else except the
Captain?

„A. That is right.

* — you were in complete charge of the decks? .

A. Yes,

„And your duty was to see that they were cleaned
up?

„A. Yes, sir.

Lou do not recollect speaking to any of the other

„ What time did you back on board the ship on
those various nights that were ashore?

„A. Lean only say about midnight.

„May it have been later?

„A. It may have been an hour later.

. Could it have been two hours later?

„A. Yes, sir.

„. And could it have been three hours later?

„A. No, sir.

“*Q. Do you recall the time?

A. No, I do not recall it. N

“*Q. You do not recall what time you came aboard any
night, do you? . ;

/ SS ae 0

—

4a

„ And-you may you vinited friends ashore!

„A. You, alr, |

570. And you do not recollect what tlie you ane bak
to the ahip?

„A. TL always leave there they stay up late, about ane
Tal, G8) d Me- - would leave there woll, Ik would be
from twelve to one,

„. When would you get up in the morning of those vari
uus daye while the vessel wan at ler 27 in — LU

„A. Not later than seven o'elook, .

„. And then you would have your breakfast?

A. You, alt, g

„ When would you wet baok on the after lok ln the
morning!

„A. Lani Hable to be there before seven dk,

„. Well, do you remember any particular oconslon
what time you got out on deck?

„A. No, 1 do not.

„. It might have been after bronkfhat or It might have
boon before breakfast Lethat right?

„. That le richt.

„. No it might be quite a while after bronkfant upon
those diya? .

„A. L would be absolutely up on desk right Immediately
after broukfaat, not later than olght oak,

„. But you were not on dook at any time at five o'clock
in the morning on these dates, wore yout

‘A> No, alr,

. You do not know actually from your personal knowl.
edge that the lights wore burning at five o'clock in the
morning on any of those dates, do you?

„A. No, air, *

„. You have no personal knowledge as to whether the
lights were burning at any time between two o'clock in the
morning and five o'clock in the 1 on any of those
datos?

„A. No.

„„. You have no personal knowledge as to whether the
lights were burning between two o'clock and seven o'clock
in the morning; you were 2 at that time?

“A. Asleep, yes. .

„„. You know there were certain riggin-s there for
[fol. 64] lights where you say lights were burning?
„A. Phat is right.

— ew — —

„. Dut whether the lights were burning, of that you
have no personal knowledge?

„A. Not betwoon thowe hours m0, ale,”

9 That de what Ham talking about; that le right?

„A. That In right,

„9. You have no reoollevtion of any partioular day as
to when Achte were burning?

„A. No revollootion for that day bu

at ‘Or any other the?

"A. You, thone chte wore burning always w | wae
on the ship, /

„. Do you reoall any partioular Hime when they actually
wore burning? ° |

„A. You, alr, '

„J. Where were you at the time on. this ooonslon that
you rooall 1 5
„A. Coming aboard the ship,

„. Whont |

A. At night,

„. What date?

„A. I cannot say tho dato,

„J. What time of night?

„A. I canpat.any tho timo of night; when I returned
fronrvialting my friends,

„J. Let us bo frank about this,

„A. You, slr.“ |

„. Inn't this the situations You think the lights must
have boon burning because they should have boom burning,
le that right? | :

„A. I Know that whon I came aboard the «hip if they

wore out It would strike mo ax a shook, I could not go
hack, I could not go through a dark passageway.
„. Inn’t this the sabstanco of your testimony, that you
do not. rooall actually any particular time whether the lights
were burning or not, and that you also do not recall that
they were not burning? ;

„A. That is a fact; that is too long ago.

„. You simply do not recall them not being burning,
and therefore you assume that they must have been burn-
ing; is that the substance of your testimony?

„A. That is the substance when you put it that way. If
[fol. 66] you come in this room in the night and it is dark

you would know it.

4—178

—

— —— —— — —

. How long had these other mates been on board the
Voanelf

N — Hoe long had — board the on Feb:
* ow long t on vease on 0
ruary 13, 1980

„ The second mate, Mr. — was aboard four
months.

"Q. The third?

„A. And the third mate the same Tertath of time. They
came together.

They came tegether?-

A. Ves, air.

**Q. Was the captain ashore every evening, too, when —
vessel was at Pier 27?

A, I could not say; I don’t know.

„. Ana rule everybody went ashore except the man on
watch?

A. Yeu, sir,

**Q. Is that right?

A. Ves, air,

_ “*Q. You just kept one officer, one deck officer?

. One deck r in charge.

And the reat of them were all off; is that right?
A. Ves, sir.

Lou do not particularly remember this Redman
A. Only his name. |

“Q. Can you mi him at at allt

K. No, I canggt describe

“0 Have you any — at all of what he looked

like
A. No, sir.

„No recollection at all?

„A. Not a bit.

- “*Q. You do not remember ever — talked to him?

“A. Ido ber his face. '

ln fact, do not recall any members of the crew

~ -4g, You have discussed this case with somebody before
have you? e
Ming — sir, with this 3 (indicating Mr,
er);
‘ak No.
4 By Gen von refer to Mr. Meagher!

„. — — ae any statement in the 4 * *. .

„A. Yes, sir.

HQ. Have you read that over to refresh. your recollee-
tion? i ¥

4% K. Yes, sir,

Are you testifying from your — recollection .
or from your recollection as refreshed by that paper?
9 “A. From my present recollection because that state-
ment of my pe that I could not recollect anything definite
t man.
700. So you signed @ statement to the effect that you
(fol. 69] could not recall anything in regard to these o-
currences that you have testified to? That you could not
recall — about these matters you have testified to?

0 ‘Did you discuss this matter ‘with any ef the offcers

of the company? oe
A. No, sir. ,
*Q. @Vith any officials? * .

“@, a with Mr. Meagher!

@ about the condition ‘of the d

ne 7 7
.
54 : : 2 80 *
*

A, Yea; sir, only with Mr. Meagher.
„When did you'iqet Knew you wore going to be a
witness in this case

„A. Yesterday morning eben * we 9

“Mr, Grayes: That is all.

ö ‘Redirect examination. | .
, „By Mr. Meagher: Ne

„And about how long did you discuss this case with
me, Mr. Burrows!

“A, T should say five minutes N you. were. aay
over the telephone most of the Hm.

Mr. Crawford: May it be noted that the suifetlons ere

‘ asked by the other side. My opponent is reading from a
deposition. He has a right to read evéry question in the
deposition: If he reads it it is his question.

. Graves: I cannot read and ask if he has disoussed
it with me without asking the question, 1 have Bright to
find gut who he is referring to. .

Mr. Crawford; Then say referring to Mr. Meagher It
is not my qudstion. It is your question.

“Q. How long was the ‘Frances Weems’ in port here

at New York on this occasion?
A. T cannot recall exactly bit: it was about ti Ne da
[fol. 70] C. Now, you said in answer to Mr. .

questions that as the time of sailing approached you be-* |

came less and less concerned about the condition of the
deck. Did you mean to convey by that the impression
at the end nd of the first day you were very careful about

th condition of the deck, and at the end of the second dax

you were les vateful about the condition oi the deck, and
at the end of the third day you were n carele
about the condition of the deck? .

“Mr, Graves: 01. ee incompetent, iraerans anc
immaterial,” a |
! _(fquestion unanswered.)

“Q. * whet didi you meen ey that vtathnent, thet 6s
the time of sailing approached you became less concerned

*

—

> | .

“Mr, Graves: Objected to as incompetent, irrelevant and

immaterial,
$ “A, Tne, mnt tata any tne beams ne ton
cerried about the condition of the deck. *

0. What did you mean ?

Mr. Graves: Objected to as n eben irrelevant and
immaterial. 0 a

„A. I meant that at and dent sailing time it was
possible for me to be as careful.about the condition of
» deck as it would have been at any other time. “5
0. en you say ‘at and around sailing time’ what do

vou mean
„A. I mean from one.hou ore leaving the dock until!
the ship is 338 prepared for entering upon the high \

[fol. 71
„0. And 4 about how many — in all would that be, one
hour béfore leaving the dock until the | ship was completely
prepared for her voyage? ~ 8
‘A. In New York, two hours, | .
„. Altogether? . ; ;
“A. Altogether. .
„8 yen vod be less concerned about the condition
„ $s * deck an hour before sailing and approximately an
our after? *

„A. An hour poy ver hay ey bgp and then ITturned
2 my whole mind on cleaning the d

|e ©

„. After that. 5
„A. After that one hour of preparing the hatches and
doerricks, the next main job is e the decks.
‘ . And what about the time preceding the hour prior
to sailing?

. Always the decks are of the utmost importance with
es me ; 1 under the conditions of — —

Zo that the are not concerned
about the condition. of: ‘the * is for a | two-hour. .
| ‘aa N.
2 “A, Two-hour period. 8
f * From an hour before sailing u an hour ctier sail

be Tes srs when the goniton of th ship for combat ;
: ing, sone is of the wtmoet ee

6% ” '
“Q. Now, you spoke, Mr. Burrows, about coming back

ia

““Q. Returning to the - after, these vun, to you
friends? . 2 |
„A. Tes, * °

0. And a I rca it, you state that you had rtarned
ae midnight to one odo in
„4 Or perhaps two o'clock. *

„. Do you N
New Tork from these visits and actually seeing
(tel 73) the lights you vetoyees to te your testimony

Mr. . a
e Court: Never mind the argument.
„ And do you recall ever sesing them not’ burning? y
„&. I must say. no.

ne: “Q. You do not recall ever seeing them not burning?
&. I can say no to that definitely.
“Q, Now, when returned from these visite at what

Qe Where gangway .
4. At that time on the starboard well-deck rail abreast
of No. 4 hatch at the foot of the steps leading up to the

“Q, . boarded that gangplank how would
ted hg tp hatte cook had ascended

of these visits do you recall
n

2
are
ate
1
11116
mi

SSE
:

if

“A No.’ ’ :

f „ Or-anything of Met nad!
: A. Ne 4 Masti oe

Sy RS ees 5 ode!
(fol. 73] „ Now, you say these returns would take place
— from twelve o’clock to two o’clock in

the
“A, Yeo, .. 33
„. Is there any loading work done aboard the
from two o’clock in the morning until five? *
No; not upon that ship at that time
. There was not any during that time 7/ 0
„& There was not. 3 28
r. Graves: Between what time! 4
„Mr. Meagher: Between two o clock and five in the morn-

“She Witness: Mey’ 5 .

Mr. Meagher: That is all, „

“‘Recross-examihation. |
By Mr. Graves: 18 W

4 0. ere was uo loading done on that ship between 0
five in The evening and seven in the morning, was there,

at this port aes, 9
„A. I do not remember that. It may have been six. .
They work es until six. I do not r. r.

Didn't you testify that around sailing time

4 A. Because as mate of the ‘by a stick
on deck where i would ben 2 ra t ploking
"it u ir Tt is a
— — nee ts ‘tothe effect, isn’t
it, 18321 o this t port at Pler Nin February,
__--ff6l, 74) 1980, that von aid not go on these decks between
~~ five in the evening et return to the vessel early in
the morning; is that
„K. No. T had ay — off that deck 5 ashore and
come back. I had to pass on that dock whore: he olaima he ;
hurt himself on. N
And you say the mop might have still. loading
at rey they * 2 worked u to alx n
. 16
And it was nix o clock or a little rl that you 2
went ashore? .
A. T anid about sit o’clogk when I wont ashore *'

„0. At rate, you do not remember exactly the a
' pate 4 the deck at any —— timo, do you, 5
8 * of ‘that vessel! 5
“A. Of course, I recall the appearance of the decks.
. As to what was n the decks!

A. Yes, sir, I do. | 2 —
**Q, In the way of debris? we oe
. Yea, air, ; ¥ >,
. Name an any particular time that you — the ddcks,'
' particular time? 2
A. I remember the boxes and d which the. pravi-
sions came in distinctly being , in the corner behind

the ladder; I rem r that distinctly,
6. They were to be loaded on r 4
„A. No, sir; they were taken off. ip’s stores and
put there in the corner.
„ They were carried along that deck there, weren t

ae No, sir, they were passed out the doors and right
around the corner of the door.

And put out on the dock? vehi

“A. In the corner of the deck. anil

„ But there was debris on the deck at various times
when these men were loading cargo! or |
r. one : 51.

N * ° —
88 *

—

* 5 * 59 *
[fol, 5): 4 . Bet ye ou do not remember rtloular mo-
— 4 N t iat de l looked like or any — dt thmber
lo
A. No, only the stores, that: pile of pieces of box that
bar in *— one — } be 4
4 ore were boxes o stores on o deck, were there,
on the after main deck?
„A. No, gir, there were parts of bones.
‘ *. Broken boxes
. Broken boxes, ‘ 755 J ‘
„Lying on the deck . 9
„A. In the dory y on deck in a corner, not on the deck.
“ar > at is, ya noticed that In a corner! «
06.
ri “"Q, You dif not notice whether they w were any ä
w. 5

ok No. * e
0. And there wor. roken boleg there, were there!
tA. On that day the qtoren came aboard,
. Broken crates? |
(Spore :
40. And do you remombor whkt particnlas day that was 7
NA I do not,
* Do they open the boxes up on the deck and take the
provisions out / *
„A. No, ; *
ran BS But there wero broken boxes lying around?
ü No, sir, not lying around; there were broken boxes
lying in the corner, >

Mr. Meagher: Just a moment, - 1 ‘obicot to the question
as trying to put words into the mouth of the witness. Hoe
has testified that these broken boxes were in a corner and
not around the deck.

“Q, Didn't you say they v were lying einai when I ona?
_ you whether there were any broken. boxes on deck?
„A. I aid lying in the corner.
„. They were lying on the deck, weren't they!
7 fol 76] thle sone were 1 a — — deck, which in
. [Yo a pe covery neta
EL f
4 What portion of the desk, forward end of the wall

“A, Forwisd'eid of the woll-deck,

4 —

* «
*
* *
.
‘ 0 . 1
‘ * 1

4 Where you go into amidshipet
: |

Amidships superstructure!
A corner about this large (indicating). *

Ar. Graves: Indicating six feet square?

“The witness: No. |

Mr. Meagher: No.

“The Witness: J· would Gay shoot two and half to
three feet.

Ho. 1 * : 8

. AY a ; i

"Q, Were these brokan boxes piled on top of each othert

A. Yes, alr,

2 crates? /, —

2 Yon Tal son anion’ ends sticking tt
I

. . it to see whether there were any |
ends there?
"A, No, sir, because in the tion that it was in it was

—

„. Three feet to the t? 4
left, 1 door, behind the ladder.
was on the starboard 8 was it!.

"A, S

e remained there at that 7
1. ay Ter er e
ovor

„Vo did not sive any instructions too have them 2

taken away!
“A No, air.
. "Or rmored to yar a, yout, 1

„60. lg ES there!
VA. knew they were there. .
ou never made any particular on to see
. ere else, did
you, as far as you recollect? : .
„ . No, I cannot recollect that.

Mr. Gravesy TRat is all.
Ar Laacher, That isa.”

1 Done Raman, the plaintiff, sid 6a 0 ee ba Mo
own behalf, being gat amy sworn, testified as follows:

Direct examipation.
By Mr. Graves:
Q. Mr. Redman, how old are yout

4. Forty-one.
(fol. 78] C. Where were yos born! 2
A. British West Indies, Island of Barbados.

. And duting that time have you been practically con-

| tinuously employed on board vessels?

eee

and back to New York and all foreign countries.

Q. On February 13, — were you employed anywhere?
0 , ” / ,

How much were your wages? ,
— dollars a month. o~ *

Including your board and lodging!

Fr ages
*
a
E

., A, Yes, sir.

2

Have you at ather a éarned more money then,

that in that same kind of position? . 15

Mr. Crawford: Objected to aa incompetent, immaterial

and irrelevant; what he earned at some other time is
- irrelevant here.

Court: You can show what kind of work he did and

hat he has been paid, and make it specific. i

By the Court

Q. How long have you amy a cook aboard ship?
A. Full cook about eight years.

kol. 79] Q. What wages did you get during these eight

years?
A. Off and on I worked for the Standard Oil of New. Jer-

dey, ond 1 got a handred dollars 4 month. _

>

Q. How much. did you get befare, when you were hurt?

Did you sign ship’s papers for every 1 separately
Yes, air.

*

0

By Mr. Graves:

O. You say you were employed on Nr 18, 1930, on ny

board the Weems as * 7
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How many men were in the stoned 18. department?
A. Me and the steward and two others.
By the Court: — ee
Q. How long had you been on that ship in Baltimore,

l day of January, 1930, 1 joined the Frances

W and made a trip Charleston and the Coast;

back to Alexindriay Virginia..“She brought bac

sot Presa rock ; discharged it in Alexandria, Virginia,
and proceeded here to New York, “I don’t — what day
she got in; she came here to load cargo for San Domingo
and Porto Hioo.

Q. You were on the ship a month before that day
A. Not quite a month. Ithink I was, however, in Alex-
andria, Virginia, eighteen days or seventeen; I am hot posi-

tive. Then we started from there to New York and she paid

[fol::80] off and signed on men before the United States’ |

Commissioner for San Domingo and Porto Rico.

Q. Where were your quarters on the a Weems” —

A. Back aft. 3 2 K

Q. That is your living quarters? 92
. :

Q. Where were your working quarters?
A. Coming forward on the ship. j

Q. In the midship superstructure?

A. Yes, sir; upstajrs abaft the smokestack. -

Q. How dig you go back and forth between those two
spots? 7

A. You come by the upper part and come down the stair-
way like this, a ladder on the rd side or port side.

Q. Are there ladders on both sides? ae

A. Both sides. Then there are two divisions; you can

From the deck on which the kitchen is you go on she
lower or main deck by ladder? —

* *
‘ * 9 4 *
. .
‘ +
* 6³
0 * ,
N 5
, wo ‘

a *

OFC

4

71 A. On the port side.

side vou go to the. firemen’s quarters.

Mr. Crawford About 40 feet.

4 there is a ladder on the port and starboard side? -
. Yes.

Then you walk on the deck?
. On the deck, | re
You walk aft!
.. You have to walk on the deck.
How far aft must you walk?
I couldn't imagine the feet, but it is quite a 8
- Quite a walk f
A. Yes, sir. I consider myself from the stairway to the
‘principal deck, back to where those lights are—I don’t
know—from this distance heré when you leave your en-

gine haat a
. You got to walk on, the deck
A. Les.
_ Q. Is there a door on both the starboard and port side?
A. One door. .

Q. On w which ug. ofthe ship in that?

[fol. 81} C. You have to go up to the port sidet 3
„A. No; the stairs are on the starboard side, then you go
into the cook’ *s—the mess man’s quarters, and on the other

Q. But to get to your quarters you have to go to the
port side .

A. Yes. 3

Q. Then you go up steps?

> Sa

2. 4 you go down the steps to your quarters? °

: . S Wotld You say the distance vonn be dn 35 or 40
ecet?

(It is stipulated the distance is 40 feet.)

Q. In that aft well deck were there hatches?
aa Yes, there were two hatches there; I am quite sure of

t.

2. And you have to pass on one side or the other of ha-
* hatehes? .

A, Yes, sir. 8

Q. Lok as you wel (0 — —

The Court: He will fell us.

‘ , N | 1 ose ;,

*

Q. How would you go! .

A. When you come ont from your quartérs you come
out on the well-deck. T en you walk to fee ladder to get to
where the kitchen was. You,have to go up this ladder on
either side. 8 f

Q. There are two ladders there, port and starboard?.
A. Yes. : |
*

—

= By the Court:

Q. Wier you go up on the deck and have to walk to the
‘ ladder, are there hatches there?
A. Yes, sir. 8
[fol. 82] C. How many?

A. Two hatches, if I am not mistake .
° Q. Between the ladders and the door that lead to the .
Space: N a

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Two hatches?

A. Yes, sir.

By Mr. Graves: |

Q. Do you remember the 13th day of February, 1930?

A. Yes, I was aboard the Frances Weems”’.

Q. What time did you get up that morning?

A. The witchman calls the cock at a quarter to five so

he would be on the deck at five. - -
_ Q. What time did you get on deck that morning? © aan

A. Five o’clock. 1

. Was it light or dark?

A. No lights whatsoever.
. Were there any artificial lights burning?

A. No lights; no, sir.

Q. Wamthe aft well-deck — or fight?

A. Dark. 0 8

Q. What was the weather? .
A. Misty. i

By the Court:

Q. What did you do when you got up that morning at a
- quarter—you dressed?
A. Dressed.

5—178

—

QW did you do then!
* out on the well- deck to proceed forward to
the *

Q. Was there any light i in other quarters?
A., Yes. |

-Q. Any light on the steps?

A No, when I came on the well-deck where the ladder
was there was no light burning whatsoever.

Q. After you left your quarters did you see any 1

5 on the ship? 5
Didn't see any lights whatever. ä .

8 The last light you a on the . was in your quar-
ters?

A. In my quarters. ,
[fol. 83] C. Did you see any. other lights?

A. No other lights.
Did you have a light to light yourself when you got
out of your quarters? 2

A. No, I didn't have any light.

By Mr. Graves:
Which side of the hatch did you got — ＋

Starboard side. gg 1
2. How many feet did You go e anything — .

2.
A.
ro Well, I got just down near the hatch.
Q. Tell the jury what happened?
AL as
and

1

I came out the weather was bad, couldn’ 't see,

By the Court:

Q. What was it you pulled off; wood?
A. No. on the end of the slat was a nail,
[fol. 84] Q. Did you see the nail !. halle
‘A. I could‘ see it, not altogether Shecorn it or how large
it was at the. time, but you could feel the shape a it at
the end of the box.
Q. You are sure you took wood from yous leg?
A. Yes. ‘aw
Q. Was there also a nail t . .
A. Yea, haste ö
. Did you see the nail? aS }.
Q. Tell us what you saw? * 1
A. Then I took-it and throwed it—
Q. What did you pick up?
A. The slab of a box. |
5 7 How big was that piece that you picked api
; * Little wider than that (indicating width of hand),
le a crate with hinges on; something * that.
68 Couldn't see the slab?
I Phe slab consisted of about three or four tithes.
Q. Show the jury about how big the piece of slab was.
A. It could be a piece of about that length from
to there (indicating about three feet).
Q. Then you took that away and threw it where? ne
A. I threw it on the side of the ship. zon Ne fap eee
Q. Show us how you took it from your foot? ©
A. I bent over like that (indicating). I couldn't see very
well, but I could feel something sharp: I discerned the
nail at the end of the slat and I threw. it on * side of the

Q. Afe you sure you could see the nail?
‘ A. You could not discern it s0 well, but you could feel it.
| Q. Did you see it? i

~

1222 the end of the wood.
. Show us where the nail was !

The nail was at the end, just like that.

J. 85} C. How far did 2 out

1

erke

x bee 5 ok %
A. Small nail. I couldn't tall you what Sta the alat came
re t it wie a thin slat,
* the nail come out from the slat, the end

A. ‘The ond of the nal] was like that, from the bor (in-
„ dioating).- * f i ie f .
Dy Mr. Graves: . pike:
9 Yon aay the end of the nall projected from that slat?
ented you held that slat to your face?

Fad ta 7 ’

Tes.
Q And

! nail,
sticking out- :

Sate yo .
A. Juat like that, low shoes, just Ihe I have on.

N

He

All day? 10 7 N

. id yoo anh gb telin: as;

Q. When you next go down on the well-deck after

your foot and washing the blood off iS Ser)

4. or six o'clock I went and it was cleaned up. When
I went out-on the deck I saw all these boxes around .
there and two or three boxes crushed with In them.
I did not think —I gald to myself—— —

Mr. Orawford: We don't oare what bp sald to h. t
a dy the Court:

Q. Waa wcame down you saw be, about! ,

| 1 F
Mite ene Sones and walked amay to gut to the a *
der, passageway to the ladder.

—

By-Mr. Graves: | 2 . is

Q. Describe those boxes! -
A. Some were whole and about two of them was broken
out. .

A. Yes, alt, che biken boxes was ‘filled up with d nails
[fol. 87] C. Crushed. up?

. 25 «
70 7

A. No, that day the foot was actually the same way,
nothing sore or wrong with it that day. ‘
Q. What'time did you get up the next morning? -

A. Five o’clock; the same hour.

2. Did you look at your foot the next morning, the 14th?

By the Court: |
Was the ship at the pier! ae
es, sir. ARE

/Q. Did you live aboard the ship? , ad
„A. Tes, sir; I didn’t go ashore. In the morning when I

got up the watchman turned the light on, and when I got
dressed I noticed my foot swollen and discolored in the

same direction where the nail went in. This discoloration —

came from therg.and it was swollen. At that time no sharp
[fol. 88} pain came from it. I put my clothes on and went
to work just the same.
. Did you work that morning? © a4 a
A. Yes, sir, worked right on. ‘4
. Tell what happened that morning? ,
A. After getting breakfast and the steward came around !
and everything was O. K., he came around about six-thirty.
I said I came out yesterday morning and a nail ran into
my foot, I didn’t think anything serious, and I noticed this
morning it is discolored and red; so he suggested liniment.
Q. What did he say to you when you told him that?
A. He suggested liniment.
Q. What did he say about Hniment .
A. He said I will give you liniment.. 0
Q. Did be give you liniment !
4. n

By Mr. Graves:

Q. Pell. everything else · that happened that day!

J A. After he didn’t get any liniment, I was on the deck on
the 14th stores fot the ship’s voyage. This was

Adont ten o' clock or ten-thiii A doctor came aboard the

ship to examine before the voyage, so he came to

the crew
the kitchen and said who is going on the ship go past the
doctor. The steward, George Ramsey, said, I will go up

aw

_ + Q. Did the mess boy come and tell 5
vent myself. I.said, did the steward

| 7 7
The Court: Did you know the doctor who was examining

the orew . * 8
The Witness: Ves, he told ma.

. Did you go to see the doctor? -

A. He said I will go up and see the doctor first. Then I

came down and stayed in the kitchen and was looking after

(fol. 89] the work, and he said you go next. I said I would

Uke to show the doctor and see what he thinks of it. He

said I haven't much time; he said, go ahead, be examined

by the doctor, and when the doctor gets through inspecting .
the crew you gan tell the mess boy—the captain meant when

the doctor is there—and then you can go up and have him
examine your foot. : 3

A. I didn’t see the mess boy come, MA aw nothing, so I
I. dell you anything to
tell me? He said, yes, but T was in the captain 's rom
working, and by that time the doctor was ashore, and I
didn’t see the doctor. 72 a

By Mr. Graves:
. Did you then dontinue your work4
A. Yes. CPS ae
2. Did you see the steward next day? :
A. I asked him did he receive any liniment. He said I
don’t know, all the’ stores.isn’t aboard yet, but later in che
evening I will look around. I continued with my work and

‘ *

didn’t receive no treatment.
By the Court: 8

Q. What did you do that night did you go ashore after
your work. was dene

A. I went back after he ‘ania he had no liniment and

didn’t get no.liniment. I said, I think I will go ashore and
buy some my own self. He said, are you going ashore!
I said, yes, I am going ashore, I am to buy some stuff
for my foot, liniment, and he said, all right; [ will go along

with th , cathe ,
@. waht ti «steward, George Ramsey along.

t time did you leave the ship?
(fol. 90} Q. Where did you go?

.

72 ‘
A. We took a crosstown line and went to Willoughby and
Hudson Street. The steward said, do you know wy A a
where I can get a hairout. I said, yes, I know. r.
mare
drug s

3
1

z
:
177
i

3

5

1 2
F

4.

XN after we came from the drug s
ped in a restaurant. He said we are going to have

some to eat. I said, I don’t feel very good, I don't

want anything to eat. I sat with him. He sat and ate

5 88 At the time my foot kind of hurt me
a little. é es:
Q. Did von go back to the ship then?’ :
A. No, I didn't ge back that night. I said, I don't think
I'll go back to the ship, I will get & room and sleep ashore,
my foot kind of lirte me alittle. He said, tomorrow morn-
ing if your foot is worge—you come about noon, and if fou
cannot go with the ship, I will get a man in your plate, and

| the Marine Hospital.

| got

t, a hotel? oer Re

Fulton. Street. . )

uts was it; do you know the number?

I don’t know the number.

*
.
.
.

Py
5
3
8

—
4
8
>

:

ore
75

*

3
9
A.
20
:
a:- *@
A.
8
A.
Q.
fol,

H

[fol, 91 —

to on my .
n b

In the morning the foot was swollen more and discol-

.
ored ; I could Rn
didn’t wake until noon — —

iN
If

11
if

f
17

. foot.was swo

You go to the Marine Hospital?’ ?
A. No sir, didn't have.no Marine Hospital slip. The

52.

and could hardly walk mite =.

* | go
A. Cumberland Street. I asked the landlord to get a
policeman beca 4 0 «
{fol. 92] C. You went to Cumberlatid Street Hospital
A. Les, ir. 0 P
Q. Did you see the doctor there?
A. Yes, sir. e

Q. Was that the doctor that testified yesterday?
A. That was not the doctor that received mé.

-s

yous e know the name of the doctor who received
you , \ © Lan + + bre

A. I am not certain that it was him, but the doctor hat
received me at the time; I had high fever and the foot wus

Q. Did you stay in the hospital then? 72. 5

A. Tes, sir. Bik 4 * . 8

Q. Did he let you stay in the hospital? ee

A. Tes. 1 . :

Q. How long did you stay there? |

capital: | Pasty to Ath of June, in Cumberland Street

af

y=)
E

78
G

the jury what happened in the hospital? -

: : 4

—

.

74

A. After being operated on, the investigators came
around, and after The leg was taken off they asked me if
„Iba money l the bank, or, 1 L had any income or

family.

Mr. Crawford: He is talking about a conversation with
some inves rs, I don't know who they are.

The Court: Tell us what they did to you personally at the
hospital? ©

The Witness: After being in the hospital, first they gave
me a bath, and then on Monday Fthink I was taken. up for
an operation.

Q. Did they give you anything to put you asleep!

A. Not at that time.

Q. Tell us what they did in the operation?

A. Operated on me.
1 93] C. Whereabouts? -

A. (Witness indicates thigh.) „ to £

Did they cut you open there?

-A. To operate on this leg they put me to sleep. I didn't
understand you the first time.

. —— is the first operation; put you to sleep.

es.
When you awoke up did you have pain?
I should say I did.
Tell us all that - happened ; is that the only place they

open?

Right here on the thigh and thengthey took the leg

not right away. )
re did they eut you open the first time?

„Here ‘(indicating thigh).

Is that the only place 6 ‘

Q. Then You went to bed again? |

Soy Sag Se ee ay Sees Sey Gay ters of

your leg? . g

A. Stayed in bed- up — two months. “9.

By Mr. Graves:

Q. Yoh ‘stayed in bed until you lett the hospital?
A. Ves. sir. fiom
| What did they do in April to yout

, * de 15
A. In April they consent shat the ber
and there was no use to try to wep ft would ever
better. a
. What did they do? ! 1 22
A. Took the leg ff.
Q. rs the time you were in the hospital did you have

A. "pain every day;
Q. You left Cumberland Street no t
A. 4th of June.
Q. 1930 7
A. 1930.
Q. Where did you go from —
A. They sent me to Kings County Hospital.
4 How long did you remain there?
L

94] A. Remained 2 out the 21st of Feb-

ruary, 1931.

Now, before you left the ship on the 14th, did anyone .
tell you what time the ship was scheduled to sail the next
day?

time do you think the ship will get away? He said the W
will not sail before three or four o elock.

Q. What time did you get to the pier on the 15th?

A. One-thirty to two o’clock.

Q. Have you done any work since you left the hospital 7

A. No work to speak of. I have to walk on this brace,
and I. go around and shine up a couple of automobiles to
make an honest living. I cannot bend with this thing. .

2 How much do you make at a time?

A. Sometimes a dollar.

By the Court: —
A dollar a day?
Yes, sir. 8
Dollar a job or a day
. Dollar a day. I cannot do oi
Hlow tush hace you made luce. you wore hurt?
ttt not suggest. I - very | little.

7

About 6250. 4

a al your cartes sate yo wery hart
os. i

*

debe

A. Les, Ar, the second mate, Johneon. I asked him what ;

„ 1
Orose-examifiation.
‘ By Mr: Crawford:
f . Redman, what work were you doing on this job on the
1 „ e e eee

i 9 Did hne to do with, these boxes of stores
that came aboard?!

A. No, I did not.
(fol. 95) Q. nns

N

A. ‘Yes, Yap deck hands and the steward and the mess:

boys.
Q. You say they handled bent
A. Yes, sir

(Informal sabe 83 oa
Mr. Redman, are you an American citizen?
The Court: What difference does that make? The court

, Bf wy ee be ag pty deg eho mr]
ord: I was just interested in knowing. He

. A. I aoe

The Court: What difference does it make?
. ‘Urawford: Perhaps it doesn’t; I withdraw the ques-

“The Court: It doesn’t make any difference. Every.

| litigant in this court stands on the same poms, whether
white or black.

By the :
Q. Did you open the crates at all? -
A. I didn’t help with the stores; I was working in the
} Q. Did you open the crates?

D

f
8

2
*

t you open them! |
Not ne the weward and tbe mu boys.
. You never opened them
„ No, your Honor’

By Mr. Crawford:

Q. You saw them doing it? hei! ;
A. Yes, the steward and mess boys ware doing it
neg nt ther had boxes to open where did they open
em!
A. On deck, if it is for the ice box.
2. What did they do with them} where did you ste the
* A. They opened the stores and put the stores in the ice
boxes and threw tlie boxes on deck.
S- Want newt of Ob Gosh G6 Gey Grow them!
0

iff

—
fa
BRE
3
583
E
§
i

A
them.

2

e 7
didn’t see them. At that ‘time T worked inthe kit

pera athens &

pelpererorof pe
8 28

S$

By Mr. Crawford: N.

. You didn’t see them work on deck after dark that
it, did you /
A. Yes, they were working when I left for my room.
Q. What time was that?
A. Around eight o’clock.
Q. They were still working on deck?
A. Still working, putting away stores.

The Court: What were they doing!
The Witness: Cleaning-out the icebox and taking stores
and putting them in there.

7 Did any more stores come aboard after dark that
night?

A. The stores were ‘there, They were distributing them
where they belonged. -_ .

4 were on deck before dark?
es.

ry And all these boxes that had been pane up had been
opened before dark, had they?

A. I don’t know.

Q. How many times did you cross the deck that day.

A. From my quarters to the kitchen, once, that is all.

. What time :

A. One-thirty to two o’clock, I was in the kitchen work -
ing. I had no time to go back there.

Q. Now, what time were you in the kitchen?

A. About seven-thirty.

Q. Did you ever go out on deck after seven-thirty?

A. Yes, to my quarters after that.

[fol. 98] By the Oourt:

Q. When you finished work that 5 vou went trom the
kitchen to ag pur quarters!
A. Yes,

Were
2 Y oe ight rang were 1

you go out that night?
0, I T didn’ go out that night, and not on the 13th

7
I go and never come forward any

8

19

Q. But the lights were burning?
A. Yes, )

By Mr. Crawford: f
Q. So you don’t know after seven · thirty whether these

boys were working or not?

A. Yes, when the boys came in my room I was reading
theſpaper. I said what are you doing so late? He said
we Were working in the icebox.

-Q. You didn’t see them work?

A. They told me that.

Q. They told you they had been working in the icebox ;
they didn’t tell you they worked on the deck?

A. Nobody go there but the steward and these boys. f

Q. Did these boys tell you they were working on deck?

A. They didn’t tell me that. | g

Q. You crossed that deck every morning at five o'elock!

A. Every morning at five o'clock, 12

Q. And the morning before at five o’clock thé lights were
burning? | ä

A. Les. . ’

Q. And this was the only occasion you say the lights
wers out? 12 ' 3
A. Since I joined the ship

By the Court: 55

Q. Since you were on that ship almost a month you got
(fol. 99] up in the morning and went from your quarters
to the kitchen—were the lights burning every, morning?

A. Yes, sir. g N .

Q. This was the first time

A. They were not burning. The weather was very bad;
it was dark, and you could see only hardly. |

By Mr. Crawford:

Q. You could just see the nail? ey

A. I could see the nail. because when I felt the sharp
shock I held on and found the-slab. !

Q. And this slab as yon call it that the nail was in, was
that this ordinary light color ‘that boxes generally are
made of with provisions in them? *

A. Yes, sir. ’

80

The Court: And the color and shape

The Witness: Yes, and the shape of an egg bor, or it
might be an orange box.

Q. WAG & have 0 label oc &t tha) ypu mow off

A. No, air.
Did you say it didn’t have a label on it

that you say your foot came in contact with,

—
Will you tell the jury exactly what happened from the
left your quarters at five o’clock in the morning
got in the kitchen?
I came out on the well-deck going towards the kitchen.
It was dark; I couldn't see. Just as I get to the ladder I
stumbled right over these boxes. I made a grab for the
ladder and my left foot went right in these broken slabs.

[fol. 100] By thé Court: |
Q. How far from the ladder did you strike the slab?

34
se |
The Court: That was the night before after you left the
kitchen, after eight o’clock.
The Witness: Oh, well, when I left the deck that night.
I could see; it was clear.

Q. The deck was clear too, wasn’t it?
A. If the deck was clear?

in the morning episode the deck was clear? :
A. Yes, the night I won't say it was clear. Tou
vould see if there was anything on the deck, you could

Q
By the Court:

Q. The night before there were lights on this deck, when
you got through with your work and went from your kitchen
to the quarters, there was a light on deck? .

A. Yes, sir.

Q. You say the deck was clear; were there any crates on

At eight o'clock?
I didn’t see none on deck.
Q. You say they were taking on ship’s stores at eight

deck
A. Not at that time.
Q.
A.

o'clock?

A. I don’t know after I went to my quarters what they
took on, but the mess boys that lived in my room, and didn’t
come in until late, I said, what are you doing so late. He
said I been giving a hand to the steward.

By Mr. Crawford:
Q. Now, tell us what happened when you were going
forward in the dark; begin when yon left your quarters?
A. When I left my I came on deck; was going
towards the ladder’ I stumbled into these broken
crates, broken slabs. a
By the Court:
Q. How many? § 1
A. When I came down after six o clock there werb about
6—178 . ,

deck near the ladder.
108) C. Which side of the ladder’

A. Starboard side.
. Which: part of the starboard part of the deck?
. Near the ladder, going towards the kitchen.

By Mr. Crawford: . *

48. Were a on the left side of the ladder or right side
* I don't * left or right; it was a starboard side.
ws ree,
“ ;
A. No, that is toward the same side as the right hand
1 orward of the ship. If you are going forward it is
right, Coming aft it would be left, right by the
hae eee Maybe I am
ucky I am alive today.
55 10 100 Q. You say the boxes were alongside the rail?
I didn’t tell you that.
Q. Please tell me now.

By the Court:

Q. When you came down that morning did-you see any
boxes or slabs? 7
A. Slabs and whole boxes.

„ By Mr. Crawford: eed

4 Q. Wher e, were they from the bottom of that ladder, to-
a ward the sailor toward the hatchet :
2 l gward the ladder, the ail of the ladder, ‘side of

*

*

left side

fig i fe
fo woop f.p he 44
: 11. ak 3 1 3
1 3 e Ge
Q. A lot of blood on it?
| A. Yes. ;
Q. How did you treat the 3 afterwardst: | N
ö A. I didn’t put nothing on, I just took a clean cloth with
ä some hot water and wiped it and put the sock on and-con-
tinued my work. N
Q. Did you put back that sock with the blood on it!
„A. Yes, and after I finished .
. Was that sock wet with blood?
A. It was not so wet, but I put it back on and continued
my work.
Q. Before you put on that sock again did you put any-
thing over your scratch?
6 ip Sieb e your Honor, just took a clean cloth and wiped
N A come off yes you wiped

re Oeics. |

A. Not a lot of blood.
Q. You said it was about an inch and a half; how *
did it take to heal?
A. It didn’t heal.
Q. Never did heal, did it“
A. No. ,
Q. Got worse, didn’t itt
A. Yes.
Q. When you said it never did heal, how did it look? *
A. After I changed socks and bathed the foot in warm
kol. 109} water that.scratch seemed to form a kind of
- blister, then the blister and skin peeled right off.
Q. There was not a formation of dried blood over the
scratch?
A. It was dry and then there was a blister, Then I
applied the water and it is afterwards—— :
Q. Did you ever have blisters before? .
A. Both feet were there; I never had no kind of scratch

wa my foot. ,

Q. Did you ever have blisters? 7

A. No. Q

Q. Never? :

A, No, your Honor. sae oe

By Mr. Crawford:

Q. Was it a blister with blood in it or white colored

blister?

A. After a couple of days the skin came right off and it
formed a kind of blister, swollen like. That blister broke
and another blister came. :

By the Court:

Q. When it broke, what happened; did blood come out?
A. A little blood and water.

Q. Another n came!

A. Yes. *

By Mr. Crawford:.

Q. And that stayed there as an open sore, didn’t it?
A. It was kind of red.
Q. Red on one side?
A. Les.

, > it got worse every day, didn’t it?

80

nd that particular spot was very bad a t the time
t to the hospital, wasn’t it? *

>

§.685. 3...
ae sie
anh
fy el
1
7 21 *
F 45
1
r fei
t
Aike
8

o blister; the skin rose “ight o aver. — After
hot water another blister came.
ou burned your foot with the hot water?
dn’t burn my foot. I used luke warm water.
And when you got to the hospital you told the doctor
an a nail in your foot?
When I got to the hospital—I was in hore before and
him what had happened.
But you didn’t tell him you ran a nail in your foot?
No, I didn’t tell him.

1

8
5
2

to

Oro

A. At that time I was out of my mind. '

Q. How do you know you were out of your mind?

A. I couldn't sleep for two days, I had high fever, and
this doctor that took my statement, he don’t talk very
English, and half the questions he asked me, I didn't —_
what he was talking about.

Q. Did you tell him yon ran a 2 in your foot?

A. I told him the same statement ;

Q. Did you tell him you ran a nail in your foot; yes, or
no; can you answer that question? i

(No answer.)

By the Court: 0 | 4

Q. Did you tell the doctor? ,

A. Yes, I gave the doctor a description of how it hap-
pened.

Q. Did you tell him it was scratched?

A. Yes.

By Mr. Crawford:

Q. Did you tell Dr. Wikle that—the doctor who testified
„
A. Yea.

. OF \ *
[fol. 111] 9 5 talked to you about your foot _ how it
got that way, didn’t he!

A. He never said nothing to me about the foot, just came
around and examined the foot.

Q. Did ever point to your foot and say that is where
Irana in my 2 (0 Dr. Winkle !

(No answer.)

By the Court:

Q. Dr. Wikle was on the stand yesterday and he was
asked whether you ever said anything about being scratched
by a nail; now counsel wants to know what the story le; did
you tell him you were scratched by a nail !

A. The doctor that took my statement I told what hap-

pened.
Q. You told what happened? | ;
A. Yes. a .
Q. Did you tell Dr. Wikle?
A. I told Dr. Wikle last winter how the accident hap-
. Did you tell him when the accident happened?
A. No. een er I think it
was Dr. Peres.

a: By Mr. Crawford:

Q. When did you discover he could not talk very good
English? 5
A. When I went to the hospital. f
Q. But is that the time you found out he could not speax
good English?
I couldn't understand half of what he asked me.
of the fact that you were deliriou

(Continuing:) —you now say you don't know inet
Dr. Peres?

Peres took a statement.

know whether you told him about the nail

Dr. Wikle asked me about my foot.

But you are sure you told Dr. Peres?
es; he is the man who took my statement. He said
oot? I said a friend advised

3
34
AF
pur

E

277215
75
af

5
5
5

Tres
A4

f

r e — — - —

0

91

Q. didn't ask you that; when did you get paid off for.
this voyage?
A. Paid on the 14th,
. What hour?
Hour after I signed on, about four o’clock,
Q. Four o’clock on the 14th?
A. Four or five o'clock.

By the Court:

8 24 hurt bofore you signed on again?
A. Yes 4

Q. Before you signed on?

A. Yes.

By Mr. Crawford:

Q. And you signed off on the old articles at the time you
got paid?”

A. No, we signed on first,

Q. You signed on first and then signed off; when yon
signed on this’ voyage you had to go before the doctor on
the ship?

A. Yes, I went before the doctor.

2. Don't you know you just said on your direct exami-
— that you didn’t go to see the doctor at all?

er the doctor.
ich is true
4 — Honor, will you please listen to my statement

By the Court: : | | :

Q. Maybe I will be able to help you; the jury want to
know the facts; thr . came aboard ship to examine the
crew?

A. Yes. .

(fol. 113] C. Did you see the doctor?

A. I seen the doctor and was examined for the foot.

Q. After you were hurt?

A. After I was hurt.

-Q. After you said you were hurt on the ship and you
had this accident you saw the doctor !

A, Yes, sir.

Q. And did you tell that doctor anything about your

“foot?

E

Q De remember telling the Court and jury bef

ore
2 oka Semen oo tates aus mn 0 othe
and said the mess mate would come in to tell you when the
SS
66.

. Then you went up and the doctor had gone!

Tn said to me when after I went on to
be examined for the trip,

7
:
:
4
eg
4
3
E
E

to him, in the captain’s room, where he was, Did you tell i

‘
the doctor I wanted to see him He said, ‘‘I forget about
it, I was called to the ca ’s room and was working. I
didn’t see the doctor.“ t’s what I said but the doctor
didn't see the foot. | ‘

By Mr. Crawford:

Q. And you didn’t show it to him?
A. I didn’t show it to him because he had gone ashore.
Q. He had examined you once? Ae:

Did you tell him at that time! 2
[fol. 114] A. No, I didn’t tell him. I had to go on the deck
and when the doctor gets through the crew then
you can go up and see the doctor and he tell you what
to put on the foot. '

iv

By Mr. Crawford:
Q. You went one by cite where the dogtor was? 1
Qi And you ware alone in the room withthe dost.

S :
And on the morning of the 14th you said the foot be-
to hurt you worse? : |
4 Yea, 5
Q, And you didn't tell the doctor the foot was paining
you
A. No, he said, ‘‘Next, next, and had no time. I

„
}

"after the doctor was through examining the crew then I

could go up and show him this foot.

time did you go ashore with Ramsey that night?
0 : : 4 f
oe was ont x at

ere

228

af
1

2

Hudson.

How far did you have to walk before you got to the
Oe + One DAT Oe

[fol.
A.
Q..
A.

7
A.

and
.

car;
A.

Tus Court: Where was the car, right near the end of the

dock?
The Witness: Yes, sir, right over by Columbus Avenue.

.Q. How far did rideinthecar? —
A. Rode from to Hudson Avenue and Willoughby

Is that where you knew this barber shop wast
cae ee

were you there I don’t care what the barber
you there half an hour or an hour?

besides the haircut at the barber

i
17 1

lere 5
F EEE
= 24

eo
11
45
Es

or twenty minutes. gic ez, 2
the barber shop to the drug store? |
a Block a half to two blocks.
Where did you leave Ramsey?
Hudson and Willoughby Street.

4
:

75
31

SOrerręerer

4
A
k

—
O
——

88
FE
8. 2
3

suppose that was?
eleven o clock. * |
about the time you decided you would stay

:

Ss

ere

) vou go after Ramsey left yout 1

1771

are at Hudson and Willoughby; where did yon go

ent to Fulton Street and slept there in a rooming :

*
8
3

150
i

f

„

you walk along the street looking for à rooming 1

Y
1
F
F
8
3

*

where this place was then?
was rooming houses there because |

Eror
A
ii
th
itt
45
:

i
4
g

0 you got to the hospital you

1
i
‘i
F

Q.

8

A.
oP .

Dr.

A.

4

A.

i
E
E

The Coutts Do you drink. ity
The 8: I won't lie, I do take 4 4
you get drunk
The Freer don't use tobacco and never crave for
drink, I admit I a drink like any person. That night
the steward was with me right — and when he left mo
I vas quite geber.

By Mr. oravtord

0. oe were quite sober
D 4 J
[fol. 117] Q. Tou had had en 0
A. Had nothing. | i
Q. After you left Ramsey? wel
A. ‘After Ramsey left me I went and got a room and went
to bed. I had the liniment with me. He said Lam going
aboard.“ I said, ‘I don't feel well on hoard the boat, the
room is cool and I am going to get a room arid will dome
down tomorrow.“
Q. We have had that before; you went to a perfectly
strange rooming house; how far away; half a mile
A. The boat was at Brooklyn. Fulton Street is moro
than a mile.
2. And yet you went to this perfectly strange Yooming
. °, house and stayed alone? ?
A. The reason I went there was because the room was no
good, iron floor and no heat. 5
Q. And yet you signed on for another voyage 1
8 Just just came from. —
. ust answer my questions; don 't keep making
speeches.

The Court: Don’t characterize that. —

Q. The next morning what time did you wake up :

A. Noon.

Q. You slept from eleven o’clock to noon?

A. No, I didn’t sleep all the time.

Q. Did you go right down to the ship as soon as you
woke up?

A. Yes. ;

Q. What time do you think you got there?

A. By my estimation around one-thirty to two o clock.

feels

*

Freretererer ke

iri

1
f

The Court: What time did she sail?
The Witness: The steward said the ship would not sail

until three o’clock. The man at the gate the ship sailed
_ half an hour ago.

(fol. 118] Q. You were supposed to be on duty the next
— weren't you

A. Yes.
Q. And you didn’t get there until one-thirty to two; is

that ee *

Q. And you tell the Court and jury you didn't have any- |

thts Oo aks tet ean

A. No, we don’t have anything to drink.
. — you tell Dr. Peres you had plenty to drink lately?

ALN

Q. You mean to say you never told Dr. Perez you had
been

A. No, I da- tell him. Hs asked me Are you a drink-

Mr. Crawford: I don't want to hear any more.
The Court: You have a lawyer; he will protect you.

. What did vou do when you got down to the ship and

found it was gone?

A. When I got to the ship and seen it was gone—the taxi

in—I said Where do you go for cheap rooming
He said, All right; I will take you up to 19
, and I went there and stayed four days.
What time did you get there on this first day, on the

—

15th, in the evening, after the ship went.
Sr
Two: thirty to o lock.

do anything else that afternoon?

180 to bed right away.
8 room and stayed there, stayed in the room. a

4

119} Q. Just sat in a chair?

| Z cepsleinas tee
read!

read; I had nothing in the room to read. I

ed tere until it was time to go to bed.

you went to bed, is that right?

Novnoting ea *
at
RR

Seren I getup about nine o'clock

What did you do when you got up?

sat in the room, because my Got had

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386009_0242%3A02. Public record. Not legal advice.
