# Transcript of Record — Standard Parts Co. v. Peck

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386008_0075%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1924
- **Citation:** 264 U.S. 52

## Text

Supreme Court of the United States.

OCTOBER TERM, 1930

Nees

THE PERMUTIT COMPANY, PETITIONER,
v8.

GRAVER CORPORATION

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED 8TATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT

PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED JANUARY 13, 1931

CERTIORARI GRANTED MARCH 2, 1931

(35,585)

Supreme Court of the Anited States.

Ocroser Tzrm, A. D. 1930.

No.

THE PERMUTIT COMPANY,
Petitioner,
v8.

GRAVER CORPORATION, :
Respondent.

ON PREBTITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT.

RECORD

Drury W. Cooper, Eseq.,
Mirrorp C. Massie, Esq.,
q Grorce A. Cunitron, Esq.,
Auuan C. Bakewe.1, Esq.,
Counsel for Petitioner.
Grorcz L. Wirzxrnson, Eso,
Cuaruzs L. Byron, Esq,
Counsel for Respondent.

INDEX.

Index to record of proceedings in the District Court of the
United States for the Northern District of Illinois,

SSS TEES a a ee ee ee i
I ce demeab ssedee cheese 671

Index to record of proceedings in the United States Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit:

RRR GPa rere ret ere re ree 673
Appearance of counsel for appellant, filed June 4,
Er rere ree rere rN eer re ee 673

Appearance of counsel for appellee, filed June 6, 1930 674

Appearance of counsel for appellant, filed June 19,
eta eee ee Lalu ve gad asuenews 675

Stipulation, filed July 15, 1930, relative to time for
filing briefs and requesting case be set down for

SUE GG, By, BI 6 vec ccc ccc ncccieccccvsss 676
Order of July 15, 1930 pursuant to stipulation...... 677
UN TE I oo vd cep eccudicesecacceccess 678
Opinion by Evans, C. J., filed Oct. 20, 1930.......... 679
Decree, entered Oct. 20, 1930...................... 691
Stipulation { » stay mandate, filed Oct. 30, 1930...... 692
Order of Oct. 30, 1930, staying mandate until further

oe a gloss ads 5 ucualy os aa aan 693
ee seh oun kwnwc x Ge hub ua anos 695

Unite States Gieuit ourt of Hapenls
For the Seventh Circuit

Ocroser Term, A. D. 1929.

No. 4390
THE PERMUTIT COMPANY,
Appellant,
vs.
GRAVER CORPORATION,
Appellee.

Counsel for Appellant:

MR. DRURY W. COOPER,
MR. MITFORD C, MASSIE,
MR. GEORGE A. CHRITTON,
MR, ALLAN C. BAKEWELL,

Counsel for Appellee:

MR. GEORGE L, WILKINSON,
MR. CHARLES L, BYRON,

Appeal frou the District Court of the United States for the Northern District
of Tilinois, Eastern Division.

|
:
cick Veer es
4 bal ae) SD ERS A SPOT EY LCP IAD ONO OMS Ms OS DIMMED SUNY” Meee ee ee

PAGE
Ss hae ance eee R Seah Ob Hob kahSnane ewes 1
Se” ctirceecadekcesdenaeantbadneKe ens 2
cs picccathins ¢ sgkeeGAOs ROARK DAES RA EES - KEK OKERKA 8
Demand under Equity Rule 58....................... 16
Letter, Mar. 18, 1920, The Permutit Co. to Dr. Chas.
LE cidade oneekeednenadokeanss haces 17
Stipulation to amend answer, and approval of Judge,
i ec cakctedinceeeknnantencease tens 18
EE ee re ee ee are 19
Stipulation to amend answer filed Sept. 5, 1929......... 20
Narrative Statement of Evidence.
Plaintiffs’ Witnesses:
a ois bss weaken eee mees 156, 32
a is oa eaves we ale ae ee 173
ERS Er eee ghee rR aA 184
idan es ae bd an ens whee ek edannnene 156
EE eee ee os eee heacad 154, 85, 22
Waterman, Frank N. ................ Da ak hse eta dh aaa 48
Defendants’ Witnesses:
ee eked eo 147
NS ne ae 193
NS ES ter ere an er irre 190, 148
EE tik wide desis sae bus on eens 189
Ms bos dunn ddvs vende nedaboenaens 186, 90
EE Sh eec kel kat edwehed ee cavmedeenankon 133
I he coi i a 188

Order approving Statement of Evidence .............. 196

Intro-
ducedin Repro-
evidence duced
atpage at page

Plaintiffs’ Exhibits:
A—U. S. Patent No. 1, 195, 923, R. Gans, Aug.
tt Mek bbae peered danepeooese 21 584
B—Volume of exhibits marked as follows:
No. 1—Stipulation as to certain facts, as

ie pd eeesenaene ee 21 197
No. 2—Defendants’ Bulletin dated Feb. 1,

iy EE a 21 199
No. 3—Defendants’ Bulletin dated June

EE a 21 209
No. 4—Defendants’ Bulletin dated Oct.

EE Re a 21 222
No. 5—Defendants’ ‘‘Model-D’’ Bulletin. 21 251
No. 6—Blueprint C-243 ................ 21 =—261
No. 7—Biueprint C-242 ................ 21 38263
No. 8—Blueprint C-240 ................ 21 3265

No. 9—Defendants’ ‘‘Model C’’ Bulletin. 21 267
No. 10—Defendants’ Bulletin ‘‘Soft
Water for Textile Purposes”’.... 214277
No. 11—Deposition of Sheridan S. Moston 21 279
Deposition of Samuel B. Applebaum. 21 280

Deposition of Arthur E. Howlett.... 21 3
No. 12—Photostat, ‘‘ Typical Precipitation
tt dent ieenensnnes 21 309
No. 13—Bulletin of Agricultural Station.. 21
No. 14—Photograph of piece of seale.... 21

No. 15—Page from publication ‘‘Power’’ 21
No. 16-—-Bulletin of Agricultural Station.. 21
No. 17—Page from publication ‘‘Canning
SE Det ca ntbcnndeedeseeiipewese 21
No. 18—Stipulation of plaintiffs’ test of
Mar. 27, 1909 and attached blueprints.. 21 3i1l
Blueprint ZW-338-A ............... 21 319

Blueprint ZW-608 .................

I IE oc Cnn ecctacecconsa 21

No. 20—Stipulation of plaintiffs’ second
test of May 15, 1929 and attached ex-

NEED 55000 6knenececeneeaacasensancee 21

Letter, May 15, 1929, Cooper, Kerr &
Dunham to Byron ............ 21

Letter, May 15, 1929, Byrou to
Cooper, Kerr & Dunham ......... 21
ee 21
C—Sketch made by Witness Tiger .......... 28
D—Sketch made by Witness Tiger.......... 28
E—Sketch made by Witness Tiger.......... 28

F—Photograph of paraffine sheet found in bot-
tom of tank in March test (marked for id.). 45

G—Sketch made by Witness Waterman...... 59
H—Sample of excelsior from excelsior bed
gg. ee een 145
I—Sketch prepared by Witness Hammer..... 159
J-—-Deposition of Francis Payne Mason...... 184
Deposition of Adolph Carl Noé......... 184
Deposition of Henry L. Nachman........ 184
Deposition of Felix Stern............... 184
Deposition of Sigmund Waldbott........ 184
Deposition of Alfred O. Lee............. 184
Deposition of George O. Haas........... 184
Deposition of Abram Lipsky............ 184
Deposition of Otto Luthy............... 184
Deposition of Carl V. Bertsche......... 184
Deposition of Alfred Mueller........... 184
Deposition of Dr. Alexander Green...... 184
Deposition of Bernard R. Regan........

Deposition of John W. Scholl...........

343

lv
Intro-
ducedin Repre-
evidence duced
atpage «ut page

K—Complete parsing by Dr. Scholl (Pltfs.’

Ms TE Se endincdivkonnhecdnedéussesedas 184 437
L—Comparative arrangement (Pltfs.’ Ex. 52) 184 444
M—Haas manuscript translation Gans’ article

SN GUE bac dad aendedadeweedesesan 184 445
Excerpts from testimony of Alfred Mueller.. 184 184

Defendants’ Exhibits:

No. 14—Pail of zeolite .................... 106

No. 15—Rubber gasket ....................- 106

Ps PT a vedachestwccvcesdsccusues 106

No. 17—Can of excelsior ................... 103

No. 18—Report of Permutit Co. dated Mar. 16,
1927 to Florida Filter Corp. .............. 154 = 455

No. 19—Rundschau device ................. 106

No. 20—Stipulation as to certain exhibits,
PE ED sh bbc db ccedsdaacceceanacens 89 457

No. 21—Agreed English translation of Ger-
Fe SU ah asbvansakuneanecceses 89

No. 22—Agreed English translation of Ger-
man Law on protection of Gebrauchsmuster 89
No. 23—Langner testimony in American Chain

Gt SD cc eaiwcecd cessed tecsaenseussures 89
No. 24—Rundschau article of Jan. 27,1909... 89 461
No. 25—Translation of Exhibit No. 24....... 89 465
No. 26—Enlargement of drawings in Rund-

I I kb ves cas beans cndeusxeeees 89 469

No. 27—Article from ‘‘The Practical Engi-
neer’’ June 4, 1909 with Affidavit of Edward

eee Pet re rT re rr mre 89 471
No. 28—Gebrauchsmuster No. 341,512 (Draw-

ing only reproduced) ..........ccisescecs 89 664
No. 29—Translation of Gebrauchsmuster 341,-

Dt cvbaevessGuedudses ocue bakwareke whine 89 665
No. 30—Gebrauchsmuster No. 313,671 (Draw-

Me CU DOIN on occ db cccceciavcens 89 660

EEL RSTRNT EOI OPEN SEES VISE I OSS LY CIN OT TAN reser recast mene a

Intro-

evidence
at page
No. 31—Translation of Exhibit 30........... 89
No. 32—Feldhoff article of Sept. 7, 1907
(drawing only reproduced)............... 89
No. 33—Translation of Feldhoff article of
Me I SE hh bndeséasénevexiescdess 89
No. 34—German Patent No. 211,064, to H.
SMIOE BOM. TR, BOG ccc ccccnccdccvcvcses 89
No. 35—Translation of Leister patent No. 211,-
Cs SE ne caddsontveceacaaecacess 89
No. 36—Down-flow softener in Permutit vs.
DE Wawieashthaee dean dibesbaaudasaale 89
No. 37—Down-flow softener in Permutit vs.
ME tints dwbntadkadsadsabedacesccuss 89
No. 38—Up-flow softener in Permutit vs.
SEE cbatebscunndhid wacnbiew ones. 89
No. 39—Up-flow softener in Permutit vs.
EE SG nV ad us chcduadiasudce a bescels 89
No. 40—Defendants’ drawing No. ZW-718, of
Rundschau water softener ............... 89
No. 41—Stipulation re. tests of defendant at
Hawthorne Laundry Service on Sept. 12,
OE ANE NO oiidb dh vielen aewhecetacacs 89
No. 42—Stipulation with notice, motion, affi-
davit of James Q. Rice and disclaimer at-
PE: Wtuddecbdedeannndneedesedd sidan uss 89
No. 48—Stipulation re: testimony of certain
witnesses as it appears in transcript of rec-
ord in Sixth Circuit, case of Permutit vs.
MEE. dead dshun eeediedeeiconeenk ics 89
No. 44—Deposition mentioned in Ex. 43...... 89
No. 45—Stipulation of Oct. 18, 1929 re: cer-
Oe Ss ON ikniccsncddsenivacaccesne 89

Deposition of Alfred Mueller from record
Pe I cls wane oxemuwe kascse 89

501

505

509

510

511

—

Intro- |
ducedin Repro- |
evidence duced ©

atpage at page

No. 46—Stipulation of Oct. 19, 1929 that Gans
article appeared in ‘‘Chemische Industrie’’

US EE cA Wh cacacencscntansea 89 512
No. 47—Gans article of Apr. 15, 1909 in
eh | 89 513
No. 48—British Patent No. 3870 of 1911 to
cena chee chttaeecetnncnes 89 647
No. 49—U. S. Patent No. 1,276,629, T. R. Dug-
i ED scence ckaaesnennawnane 89 638
No. 50—U. S. Patent No. 943,535, R. Gans,
— § 8 A ee 89 631
No. 51—Reissue Patent No. 13,688, R. Gans, |
ee ceelaakwnvetnnaeensee en 89 635
No. 52—U. S. Patent No. 478,261, O. H., W. M.
& I. H. Jewell, July 5, 1892...............+ 89 590
No. 53—U. S. Patent No. 678,532, F. E. Bach-
= Ee 89 614
No. 54—U. S. Patent No 630,870, V. C. Dries-
cic cc nesanbeeee as 89 602 |
No. 55—U. S. Patent No. 632,091, F. Bom-
I, Be, TI Be occ hs cccccewccncese 89 608
No. 56—U. S. Patent No. 707,899, F. Bom-
I I Ge BEE aeccvaccecnscennnnes 89
No. 57—U. S. Patent No. 519,565, F. Bom-
EE is Ka cdevcesccessccesss 89
No. 58—U. S. Patent No. 960,887, R. Gans,
PC cekdecabencaneadeanannen'ens 89
No. 59—Stipulation dated Oct. 25, 1929, re:
iid cncenhan eet wnaeecne 89
No. 60—Weiss thesis (drawings only repro-
IE Eee ee ee 89
No. 61—Translation of Weiss thesis ......... 89
No. 62—Letter, Mar. 18, 1920, Duggan to Dr.
EE rT OTT an 89

ph hank aa ESOS SON TAS Sey toes getty RRB OS IM RAINY SENG EE LOS Tg NB

Intro-
ducedin Repro-
evidence duced
atpage at page

No. 64—Blueprint showing curve referred to

MM EEE Sohhe ek bnkckacacxceccnancs * (eptee) * *

Plaintiff, for its bill of complaint, alleges:

1. That the plaintiff, The Permutit Company, is a corpora-
tion organized and existing under the laws of and a citizen
of the State of Delaware, and has a place of business in Wil-
mington, in said State, and that the defendant, Graver Cor.
poration, is a corporation organized and existing under the
laws of and is a citizen of the State of Illinois, and has its

rincipal place of business in the City of Chicago, in said

tate, and in the Northern District of Tlinoia, Eastern Divi-
sion, and is a resident and inhabitant of said City and North-
ern District, Eastern Division.

2. That the jurisdiction of the Court depends upon the pat-
ent laws of the United States.

3. That letters patent of the United States, No. 1,195,923,
for water softening apparatus, were duly granted on August
22, 1916, to J. D. Riedel Actiengeselischaft, as the assignee of
Robert Gans, under and in accordance with the provisions of
the then existing Statutes of the United States, as by said
patent, or a duly authenticated copy thereof, here in court

to be produced, will fully and at large appear; and that
4 the plaintiff, by an assignment in writing dated November

10, 1916, duly recorded in the United States Patent Offi
then became and has ever since been and is now the owner
the entire right, title and interest in and to said patent and of

AN ae ae pe SF

Bill of Complaint. 3

» No. 1,348,977,
n roducing same,
j rge Leonard
provisions of
e United States, as by said pat-
py thereof, here in court to be

rge appear; and

recorded in the

were duly grant

patent and of all

and in equity, for profits and

e, because of in ringement

y said assignments, luly certified copies

— of the United
n

arge appear, and
that pla grant thereof and
is now the owner tle and interest in
and to said paten and demands, both
t law and in

8, Bor pencer patents
been of great bene age to the pub-
; that the public has gen and acquiesced

4 Bill of Complaint.

in the rights of the plaintiff and its said predecessors there-
under; and that defendant has had due notice of said letters
patent and each of them and of the rights of plaintiff and its
predecessors thereunder.

7. That the defendant, by making or causing to be made,
and selling or causing to be sold, and using or causing to be
used, in the Northern District of Illinois, and elswhere in the
United States, water softening apparatus made in accordance
with and embodying the inventions and improvements set
forth in said Gans letters patent No. 1,195,923, and more
particularly the inventions and improvements set forth in
claims 1 and 5 thereof, and by making or causing to be —_
and selling or causing to be sold, a water softening compoun
embodying the inventions and improvements described |
claimed in said Borrowman patent No. 1,348,977, and by -sing
or causing to be used a process of purifying water embodyi

the inventions and improvements described and dein
6 in said Spencer patent No. 1,455,363, has, wilfully and

without the consent of the plaintiff, as to said Gans and
Spencer patents, and of plaintiff and its predecessors in
ownership as to said Borrowman patent, since the respective
dates of said letters patent and within six years prior to the
filing of this bill of complaint, infringed upon said Gans, Bor-
rowman and Spencer letters patent, and each of them, and is
still continuing so to do, and has derived unlawful gains and
profits from such infringements, which plaintiff would other-
wise have received and enjoyed from and under said Gans and
Spencer patents and which plaintiff and its predecessors in
the ownership thereof would otherwise have received and en-
joyed from and under said Borrowman patent; and that de-
fendant has by its said infringement of said Gans and Spencer
patents caused damage to plaintiff, and by its said infringes
ment of said Borrowman patent caused damage to plaintiff
and its predecessors in the ownership thereof; and that said
damage arising from defendant’s infringement of said three
letters patent, and each of them, will be irreparable unless
defendant be enjoined from further infringement thereof.

8. That plaintiff, on or about the 3lst day of July, 1919,
brought a-.suit in the United States District Court for the
Western District of New York against Harvey Laundry Com
pany for infringement of said Gans patent 1,195,923; that
later the Refinite Company, of Omaha, Nebraska, intervened
as and became a party defendant thereto; that after trial on
pleadings and proofs, said Court, on or about July 6, 1921,
entered an interlocutory decree holding that, as to claims 1

Bill of Complaint. 5

and 5 thereof, said patent was valid and had been in-
7 fringed by the defendants, which decree was duly affirmed

by the United States Circuit Court of — for the
Second Circuit on an appeal therefrom by sai defendants ;
that on or about August 9, 1927, a final decree to the same
effect was duly entered in said suit az to the validity and in-
fringement of said claims 1 and 5 of said Gans patent and
also directing judgment in favor of plaintiff and against the
defendants for the gains and profits realized by them from
their infringements ; and that, except for an appeal now pend-
ing by the defendant Refinite Company as to the amount of
the money judgment therein — it, said decree is now
in all respects in full force and effect; as by duly authentt-
cated copies of said interlocutory and final decrees, here in
court to be produced, will more fully and at large appear.

9. That plaintiff, on or about the 9th day of October, 1918,
brought suit in the United States District Court for the East.
ern District of Michigan, against Frank L. Wadhams and
others, for infringement of the Gans patent No. 1,195,923 here
in suit; that later the Borromite Company of America inter-
vened as and was joined as a party defendant to said suit;
that after the trial of said suit said District Court held the
patent invalid and thereupon entered a decree dismissing

laintiff’s bill of complaint therein; that an appeal was taken

y plaintiff to the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for
the Sixth Circuit from said decree; that thereafter and after
due proceedings therein said Circuit Court of Appeals re-
versed the said decree and in its mandate duly issued and filed
in said District Court directed said Court to enter a decree
for plaintiff on claims 1 and 6 of said Gans patent; that

thereafter an order was duly entered in said District
8 Court on said Mandate; that thereafter a supplemental

bill was filed by plaintiff praying that the Wayne Com-
pany of South Bend, Indiana, be joined as a party defendant
to said suit; and that thereafter and on or about December
23, 1927, a final decree was entered in said suit in favor of
plaintiff and against all of said defendants, including said
Wayne Company, holding claim 1 and 5 of said Gans patent
valid and to have been infringed by said defendants, which
decree is still in full force and effect; as by a duly authenti-
cated copy of said decree, here in court to be produced, will
more fully and at large appear.

10. That plaintiff, on or about the 28th day of June, 1923,
brought suit in the United States District Court for the South-
ern District of New York, against Paige & Jones Chemical

ee ee Org ae

6 Bill of Complaint.

Company, Inc., for infringement of said Gans patent here in
suit, and immediately thereafter a motion for preliminary in-
junction against said defendant was made by plaintiff and an
order was duly entered thereon granting said motion as to
claim 1 of said Gans paient 1,195,923; that no appeal was
taken by said defendant from said order; that later another
motion for preliminary injunction was made by plaintiff
against said defendant as to other types of softeners manu-
factured and sold by it and an order was duly entered thereon
granting said motion as to claim 5 of said Gans patent; that,
on appeal from said order by said defendant, the United
States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
affirmed said order except as to certain of such other soft-
eners which it directed in its mandate should be further con-
sidered and disposed of at the trial; that thereafter and on or
about February 17, 1928, a final decree was duly entered in

said suit in favor of plaintiff and against said defendant
9 holding, as to claims 1 and 5 thereof, that said Gans pat-

ent No. 1,195,923 was valid and had been infringed by all
of the aforesaid softeners manufactured and sold by said de-
fendant, including those which said Circuit Court of Appeals
directed should be further considered and disposed of at the
trial and that said decree is now in full force and effect; as
by duly authenticated copies of said injunction orders and
decree here in court to be produced, will more fully and at
large appear.

11. That plaintiff, on or about the 6th day of February,
1928, brought suit in the United States District Court for the
Southern District of New York, against Paige & Jones Chem-
ical Company, Inc., for infringement of said Borrowman pat-
ent No. 1,348,977, and Spencer patent No. 1,455,363, and that
thereafter and on or about February 17, 1928, a decree, on
consent, was duly entered therein, with said defendant’s con-
sent, sustaining said patents and each of them, finding in-
fringement thereof by said defendant and granting an injunc-
tion against further infringement thereof by said defendant.

Wherefore, plaintiff prays for writs of injunction as well
provisional as permanent, issuing out of and under the seal
of this court, enjoining and restraining the defendant, Graver
Corporation, its officers, directors, clerks, attorneys, servants,
agents and workmen, from infringing upon said letters pat-
ent and each of them; that said defendant account to plaintiff
for the profits made by it and the damages sustained by said
plaintiff, because of its infringements of said Gans and Spen-

Bill of Complaint. 7

cer patents, No. 1,195,923 and No. 1,455,363, and by plain-
10 tiff and its predecessors in the ownership thereof use
of its infringement of said S3orrowman patent No. 1,348,-
977; that the plaintiff recover the costs and disbursements of
this suit; and that plaintiff may have such other and further
relief as may appear proper and be agreeable to equity; that
said defendant be required to answer this bill of complaint,
but not under oath, plaintiff hereby waiving verification of
defendant’s answer.
Tue Permutir Company
by H. KarecsHerm
President.
Purr, Sawyer, Rick & Kennepy,
220 Broadway, New York City,
DyrenFrortTH, Lez, Curitron & WIzEs,
Solicitors and of counsel for plainttff.

James C. Rice Marquette Building, Chicago, Ill.
Gzorce A. CHRITTON
Of Counsel. -

State of New York, ™
County of New York. ’

H. KRIEGSHEIM, being first duly sworn, deposes and
says that he is the President of The Permutit Company, plain-
tiff above named, that he has read the foregoing bill of com-
plaint subscribed by him on behalf of said Company and
knows the contents thereof, and that the same is true of his
own knowledge, except as to those matters therein stated to
be alleged upon information and belief, and that as to those
matters he believes it to be true.

H. KrizcsHEIM

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 21st day of Febru-

ary, 1922.
ArtTuur E. MarcanTE,
(Seal) Notary Public.
New York Co. Clerks No. 47
New York Co. Register’s No, 9048
Kings Co. Clerks No. 461
Kings Co. Register’s No. 9645
My commission expires Mar. 30, 1929.

11 Exhibits marked: Exhibit A, Exhibit B, and Exhibit
C hereto attached, but not copied.

(Endorsed) Filed Feb. 23, 1928. Charles M. Bates, Clerk.

€ Answer.

19a, 12 And on, to wit, the 18th day of April, 1928, came the
; defendant by its attorneys and filed in the Clerk’s office
of said Court a certain Answer in words and figures following,

to wit:

13 * °* (Caption) ° *
ANSWER.

To the Honorable the Judges of the United States District
Court, Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division:

Now Comes Defendant, and for answer unto the Bill of
, Complaint says:

1. Defendant denies each and every allegation in the Bill
of Complaint contained, except as hereinafter admitted or
specifically answered or avoided.

2. Defendant admits that it is a corporation organized
under the laws of the State of Illinois, and for the purposes
of this suit, has a place of business in the City of Chicago,
State of Illinois, but denies that it has committed any acts of
oo in the Northern District of Illinois, or else
where.

3. Defendant admits that Letters Patent No. 1,195,923 was
issued on August 22, 1916, to J. B. Riedel, Aktiengesellschaft,
but denies that Robert Gans was at any time the true, original
or first inventor of said alleged improvements, and that said
Letters Patent was granted upon proper application, and that

said Letters Patent is or was valid; but on the contrary
14 defendant alleges, as hereinafter more particularly

stated, that said Letters Patent is wholly invalid; fhat
the mechanism therein described and claimed was not new;
that the same had been known, described and used and pat-
ented prior to the alleged invention thereof by the said Rob-
ert Gans, and was in public use and on sale in this country
before Gans’ alleged invention thereof, and more than two
— prior to the filing of the Gans application for Letters

atent.

4. Defendant is not advised except by the Bill of Com-
plaint whether or not due and proper assignment was made
by the said Robert Gans to said J. D. Riedel Aktiengesellschaft,
and that proper assignment was made by the latter to plain-
tiff herein covering the aforesaid Letters Patent, and for
profits and damages accrued or to accrue because of infringe-
ment thereof, and therefore calls upon plaintiff to make
proper proof of same.

RES ELEGANS ES IS IRE TTL! BLEND BEEN STL NI TR

Answer. 9

5. Defendant admits that Letters Patent No. 1,348,977
was issued August 10, 1920, to George Leonard Borrowman,
for Water Softening Compound and Method of Producing
Same, but denies that said George Leonard Borrowman was
at any time the true, original or first inventor of said alleged
improvements, and that said Letters Patent was granted upon
proper application, and that said Letters Patent is or was
valid; but on the contrary, defendant alleges, as hereinafter
more particularly stated, that said Letters Patent is wholly
invalid ; that the compound and method of producing same
therein described and claimed were not new; that the same
had been known, described and used and patented prior to
the alleged invention thereof by the said George Leonard
Borrowman, and was in public use and on sale in this country
before Borrowman’s alleged invention thereof, and more than
two years prior to the filing of the Borrowman application

for Letters Patent.
15 6. Defendant is not advised except by the Bill of Com-

plaint whether or not due and proper assignment was
made to plaintiff covering the aforesaid Letters Patent, in-
cluding the rights of recovery of profits and damages accrued
or to accrue because of the infringement of said Letters Pa-
tent, and therefore calls upon plaintiff to make proper proof
of same.

7. Defendant admits that Letters Patent No. 1,455,363 was
issued May 15, 1923, to The Permutit Company, for a Process
of Purifying Water, but denies that Arthur C. Spencer was
at any time the true, original or first inventor of said alleged
improvements, and that said Letters Patent was granted upon
proper application, and that said Letters Patent is or was
valid; but on the contrary, defendant alleges, as hereinafter
more particularly stated, that said Letters Patent is wholly
invalid; that the process therein described and claimed was
not new; that the same had been known, described and used
and patented prior to the alleged invention thereof by the
said Arthur C. Spencer, and was in public use and on sale
in this country before Spencer’s alleged invention thereof, and
more than two years prior to the filing of the Spencer applica-
tion for Letters Patent.

8. Defendant is not advised except by the Bill of Com-
plaint whether or not due and proper assignment was made
by the said Arthur C. Spencer to plaintiff covering the afore-
said Letters Patent and for profits and damages accrued or
to accrue because of infringement thereof, and therefore calls
upon plaintiff to make proper proof of same.

10 Answer.

9. Defendant denies each and every etn set forth in
Paragraph No. 6 of the Bill of Complaint.

16 10. Answering Paragraph No. 7 of the Bill of Com-
plaint, defendant denies past or present infringement of

said Gans, Borrowman and Spencer Letters Patent, and de

nies each and every other allegation set forth in said para-

graph.

11. Defendant is not advised except by the Bill of Com-
plaint, with respect to the suits, mandates, decrees or injune-
tional orders referred to in Paragraphs Nos. 8, 9, 10 and 11
of the Bill of Complaint, and therefore calls upon plaintiff to
make proper proof of the same.

12. The defendant is informed and believes, and therefore
avers the fact to be, that said Letters Patent No. 1,195,923,
and each of the claims thereof, is invalid and void for the
following reasons:

a—Because Robert Gans, the patentee of said Letters Pa-
tent No. 1,195,923, was not the first and original inventor of
the alleged improvements described and claimed in said Let-
ters Patent, but the same thing, in all material and essential
features, was, previous to the alleged invention by said Robert
Gans, and more than two years before the date of the applica-
tion for the said Letters Patent No. 1,195,923, fully described
and set forth in the following Letters Patent of the United
— and foreign countries and in other publications, as fol-
Ows:

United States Patents:

W. Jasper No. 47,308 Apr. 18, 1865

F. Bommarius No. 632,091 Aug. 29, 1899

J. J. MeTighe No. 391,328 Oct. 16, 1888

G. D. Gerson No. 402,433 Apr. 30, 1889
. H. & I. H. Jewell No. 418,186 Dec. 31, 1889
. H. Jewell No. 423,430 Mar. 18, 1890
. H. Jewell No. 418,335 Dec. 31, 1889
. H. & W. H. Jewell No. 425,573 Apr. 15, 1890
. H. Jewell No. 377,389 Feb. 7, 1888
H. Jewell No. 377,390 Feb. 7, 1888
H. & I. H. Jewell No. 413,671 Oct. 29, 1889
vis & Riddell No. 450,223 Apr. 14, 1891

. L. Duggan No. 1,276,629 Aug. 20, 1918
. P. Allen No. 538,720 May 7, 1895
. B. Heideman No. 547,547 Oct. 8, 1895
O. H. Jewell, et al. No. 478,261 July 5, 1892
J. M. Davidson No. 544,566 Aug. 13, 1895
T. H. Boyer No. 554,858 Feb. 18, 1896

ejojoyo)

ojo}~)

9
Py
&

Answer. 11

W. M. Deichler No. 613,194 Oct. 25, 1898

V. C. Driesback No. 630,670 Aug. 15, 1899

F. Bommarius No. 707,899 Aug. 26, 1902

F. E. Bachman No. 678,532 July 18, 1901

R. Gans No. 943,535 Dec. 14, 1909

(Reissue) No. 13,688 Feb. 17, 1914

Massaciu & Newman No. 1,202,557 Qct. 24, 1916

(In part continuation of appl’n filed Nov. 18, 1910)

R. Gans No. 960,687 June 7, 1910.
Foreign Patents:

British patent—Wetter No. 26,842 of 1909

British patent—Evans No. 3,870 of 1911

German patent—F’. Harm No. 95,447 of June 2, 1896

German patent—Riedel Akt——Ges. No. 197,111 of Oct. 26,
1906

German patent—H. Leister No. 211,084 of June 24, 1909

German Gebrauchsmuster, J. D. Riedel, Akt. No. 313,671 of
June 27, 1907

German Gebrauchsmuster, August Neumann, No. 341,650 of
May 15, 1908

German Gebrauchsmuster, August Neumann No. 342,212 of
May 19, 1908

German Gebrauchsmuster, August Neumann No. 341,512 of
June 15, 1908.
Publications :

Pages 59 to 69, inclusive, of Vol. 3 of ‘‘V Internationaler
Kongress fur Angewandte Chemie, Berlin, 1903’’.

Page 1078 of ‘‘Chemiker Zeitung, 1903, No. 87.’’

Pages 691-°92 of ‘‘Chemiker Zeitung, 1907, No. 55.’’

Page 246 of ‘‘Best Sugar Manufacture & Refining, Ware,

Pages 367 to 369, inclusive, of ‘‘Outlines of Industrial
Chemistry—Thorp, 1898.’’

Pages 1172 and 1173 of ‘‘ Journal Society Chemical Indus-
try, Dec. 15, 1908.’’

‘‘Modern Methods of Water Purification,’? Don & Chris-
holm, 1913, second edition, pages 188 to 193, inclusive; pages
254 to 256, inclusive, and page 250. ;

Centralblatt fur die Zuckerindustrie #49, XV. Jahrg,

Magdeburg, 7 September, 1907, pp. 1307-1310.
18 Centralblatt fur die Zuckerindustrie, Magedeburg, 16
November, 1907, No. 7, XVI. Jahr, pp. 172-174 and 373-

4,
Poggendorfs Annalen Bd. 105 of 1858, p. 132.

12 Answer.

Landwirtschaft] Versuchsatationen, Dresden, Bd. 2, 1859,
p. 113 et seq., Dr. E. Peters.
Die Deutsche Zuckerindustrie, Berlin, Apr. 12 and 19, 1901,

7 Landwirtschaft] Versuchsatationen, Berlin, Bd. 55, 1901, p.
149, Dr. A. Rumpler.

Jahrbuch der Kgl. Preuss. Geolog. Landesenstalt und
Berga-Kademic feer 1905, Bd. XXVII., Heft 1, Berlin, p.
180-181.

Jahrbuch der Kgl. Preuss. Geolog. Landesanstalt und
Berga-Kademic feer 1906, Bd. XXVII., Heft 1, Berlin, p. 79.

Catalog of Permutit Filter Co. G.m.b.H. Berlin N-39. (Ex-
hibit 47 in Buffalo case).

Catalog of Permutit Filter Co. G.m.b.H. advertising the
‘‘Aquaril’’ Filter. (Exhibit 48 in Buffalo case).

Zeitschrift fur Angewandte Chemie und Zentralblatt fur
technische Chemie, Heft 2, Leipsig, May 28, 1909, pages 1019
to 1024.

Chemische Industrie, April 15, 1909, Vol. 32, pp. 197 to 199,
wherein appears the article ‘‘Ueber die technische Bedeutung
der Permutite, (der kunstlichen zeolithartigen Verbiundun-
gen)’’ von Dr. Gans.

Technische Rundschau, supplement of Berliner Tageblatt,
January 27 and January 28, 1909, pages 43 and 44, an article
entitled ‘‘Wasserreinigungs-Verfahren mit Permutit.’’

Die Saison, for October 1908, No. 241, p. 1025, wherein ap-
pears ihe article ‘‘Weichwasser-Filter, Aquaricl.’’
and in many other Letters Patent and printed publications
not known to this defendant, but the data concerning which
when discovered thereafter, the defendant prays leave of
court to furnish and incorporate herein by suitable amend-

ment. ;
19 b—Because the said alleged invention of the said

Robert Gans, in every material and substantial part
thereof, was known to and used by and was the completed
invention of others in this country prior to the alleged inven-
tion thereof by the said Robert Gans, and was in public use
and on sale in this country for more than two years prior to
the filing of the application for said Letters Patent No. 1,195,-
923; and the names and residences of the persons who in-
vented or who had prior knowledge of the thing patented,
and the places where and the names of the persons by whom
it was publicly used and on sale in this country for more than

Answer. 13

two years prior to the filing of the application for said Let-
ters Patent are as follows: :

Name Residence Place of Public Use & Sale
Omar H. Jewell—Chicago, Illinois—Chicago, Illinois :
O. H. Jewell Filter Co.—Chicago, Ill.—Chicago, Illinois
Charles P. Allen—Denver, Colorado—Denver, Colorado and

elsewhere ; a ’
Chester B. Davis, Edward H. Riddell—Chicago, Illinois—Chi-

cago, Illinois and elsewhere
University Hospital—Kansas City, Mo.—Kansas City, Mo.

since 1902
Samuel Hird & Sons—Passaic, New Jersey—Passaic, New

Jersey.

13. The defendant is informed and believes, and therefore
avers the fact to be, that Letters Patent No. 1,348,977, issued
August 10, 1920, to George Leonard Borrowman, and each of
the claims thereof, is invalid and void for the following rea-
sons:

a—Because George Leonard Borrowman, the patentee of
said Letters Patent No. 1,348,977, was not the first and orig-
inal inventor of the alleged improvements described and
claimed in said Letters Patent, but the same thing, in all ma-
terial and essential features, was, previous to the alleged in-

vention by said George Leonard Borrowman, and more
20 than two years before the date of the application for the

said Letters Patent No. 1,348,977, fully described and set
forth in the following Letters Patent of the United States
and foreign countries and in other publications as follows:

Geo. H. Widner No. 1,207,896 Dec. 12, 1916

Robert Gans No. 951,641 Mar. 8, 1910

Robert Gans No. 914,403 Mar. 9, 1909.

Valerius Kobalt No. 1,147,515 July 20, 1915

Robert Gans No. 1,121,490 Dec. 15, 1914

Robert Gans No. 943,535 Dec. 14, 1909

Robert Gans (Reissue) No. 13,688 Feb. 17, 1914,
and in many other Letters Patent and printed publications
not known to this defendant, but the data concerning which
when discovered thereafter, the defendant prays leaye of
court to furnish and incorporate herein by suitable amend-
ment.

b—Because the said alleged invention of the said George
Leonard Borrowman, in every material and substantial part
thereof, was known to and used by and was the completed
invention of others in this country prior to the alleged in-
vention thereof by the said George Leonard Borrowman,

14 Answer.

and was in public use and on sale in this country for more
than two years prior to the filing of the application for said
Letters Patent No. 1,195,923; and the names and residences
of the persons who invented or who had prior knowledge of
the thing patented, and the places where and the names of
the persons by whom it was publicly used and on sale in this
country for more than two years prior to the filing of the
application for said Letters Patent are as follows:
Place of Pub-
Neme : Residence lic Use & Sale
Geo. H. Widner DesMoines, Iowa DesMoines, Iowa
Valerius Kokelt Berlin, Germany
21 14. The defendant is informed and believes, and there-
fore avers the fact to be, that Letters Patent No. 1,455,-
363, issued May 15, 1923, to Arthur C. Spencer, and each of
the claims thereof, is invalid and void for the following rea-
sOns :
a—Because Arthur C. Spencer, the patentee of said Letters
Patent No. 1,455,363, was not the first and original inventor
of the alleged improvements described and claimed in said
Letters Patent, but the same thing, in all material and essen-
tial features, was, previous to the alleged invention by said
Arthur C. Spencer, and more than two years before the date
of the application for the said Letters Patent No. 1,455,383,
fully described and set forth in the following Letters Patent
of the United States and foreign countries and in other pub-
lications as follows:
Cornelius Massaciu No. 1,202,557 Oct. 24, 1916.
Ferdinand Blumental No. 1,212,007 Jan. 9, 1917
Adalbert Kolb No. 1,193,794 Aug. 8, 1916.
Adalbert Kolb No. 1,193,795 Aug. 8, 1916.
Permutit Filter Co. Br. 26,094 of 1910.
Deutsche-Filtercompagne Br. 3,057 of 1912.
Pages 683-684 of Dana’s System of Mineralogy, 6th Edi-
tion, John Wiley & Sons, New York.
Page 200, ‘‘Agriculture in Some of Its Relations With
we ° by Storer, 4th Edition, 1892, Vol. 1, Chapter
Encyclopedia Britannia, 11th Edition.
and in many other Letters Patent and printed publications
not known to this defendant, but the data concerning which
when discovered thereafter, the defendant prays leave of
court to furnish and incorporate herein by suitable amend-
ment.

EPSON ERE ELE BREIL LLL ENO BE ROGY EPTE LINEA OSE SLATE SES BLINN TERE NE RH

Answer. 15

22 b—Because the said alleged invention of the said Ar-
thur C. Spencer, in every material and substantial part
thereof, was known to and used by and was the completed
invention of others in this country prior to the alleged in-
vention thereof by the said Arthur C. Spencer, and was in
ublic use and on sale in this country for more than two years
prior to the filing of the application for said Letters Patent
No. 1,455,363; and the names and residences of the persons
who invented or who had prior knowledge of the thing pat-
ented, and the places where and the names of the persons by
whom it was publicly used and on sale in this country for
more than two years prior to the filing of the application
for said Letters Patent are as follows:

Place of Public
Name Residence Use & Sale
Ferdinand Blumental Cologne-Brannsfeld,
Germany

c—Because the said inventions purported to be covered by
said Letters Patent Nos. 1,195,923, 1,348,977 and 1,455,383, and
particularly set forth in the claims thereof, are devoid of
‘substantial novelty in view of the well-known state of the art,
and in each case does not constitute patentable subject-matter
or invention or discovery within the meaning of the statute.
- @—Because said Letters Patent Nos. 1,195,923, 1,348,977
and 1,455,363, set forth and describe old and familiar means
of common knowledge and in common use long prior to the
alleged invention thereof by said respective patentees, Rob-
ert Gans, George Leonard Borrowman and Arthur C. Spencer,
and that said alleged improvements required for their pro-
duction only the exercise of ordinary skill and knowledge of
those skilled in the art to which said inventions belong, and

in analogous arts, and that the details of construction and
23 the steps in the processes and methods required nothing

more than the merest mechanical skill commonly em-
ployed in the work where such alleged inventions might be
utilized.

15. The defendant further avers, upon information and
belief, that the claims of said Letters Patent Nos. 1,195,923,
1,348,977 and 1,455,363 are so limited and restricted by the
prior art, as well as by the acts of said respective inventors
and their duly authorized attorneys in prosecuting the appli-
cations for said Letters Patent, and particularly by the limi-
tations and restrictions made therein under the requirements
of the Commissioner of Patents during the proceedings in
the Patent Office while said applications were pending there-

BR SRB HT TAUPO EY Ue oR ER PRY bane neni ae cast am

PP ALS ELIE

MIE SEIS MES

|

. 26, 1930.

16 Demand Under Equity Rule 58.

in, as to exclude therefrom any constructions sold by the
defendant, and said Letters Patent are thereby limited and
restricted to the particular construction, arrangement and de
scription of parts, and processes and methods shown and de
scribed in said Letters Patent, and the plaintiff is therefor
estopped from obtaining a broader construction of said
claims, such as would include any structure made or sold
defendant or any processes or methods used by defendant.

16. Defendant denies that it has done any act or thing or
is doing any act or thing, or proposes to do any act or thing
in violation of any alleged rights, exclusive or otherwise, be.
longing to plaintiff or secured by it by said Letters Patent
Nos. 1,195,923, 1,348,977 and 1,454,363, or that the plaintiff is

entitled to an injunction or any other relief whatsoever,

24 Wherefore, the defendant prays—

That the Bill of Complaint be dismissed and the rea.
sonable costs and charges incurred by the defendant be taxed
against the plaintiff; and

That the defendant may have such other and further relief
as the circumstances may require.

Graver CorPoRATION
By Wrixinson, Huxuey, Byron & Knicut
Solicitors for Defendant.
Cuas. L. Byron
Of Counsel.

April 11, 1928.

(Endorsed) Filed Apr. 18, 1928. Charles M. Bates Clerk

25 And on, to wit, the 26th day of August, A. D. 1923,

came the Defendant by its attorneys and filed in ths
Clerk’s office of said Court a certain Demand Under Equity
Rule 58 in words and figures following, to wit:

26 ‘* * (Caption) * °
DEMAND UNDER EQUITY RULE 58.

Messrs. Cooper, Kerr & Dunham,
Counsel for Plaintiff,
42 Broadway,
New York, N. Y.
Gentlemen :
Pursuant to Equity Rule No. 58, demand is hereby made

t

Demand Under Equity Rule 58. 17

by defendant upon plaintiff to admit, in writing, the execu-
tion or genuineness of a letter dated March 18, 1920, and
addressed to Dr. Chas. F. McKenna, 50 Church Street New
York, N. Y., and written by or on behalf of plaintiff, and
signed by Thomas R. Duggan as technical manager of the
plaintiff corporation, a copy of which letter is hereto at-
ched.
ss Respectfully,
Wrxrinson, Huxiey, Byron & Knicut
Counsel for Defendant.
Chicago, Illinois.
August 23, 1929.
Service of the above Demand Under Rule 58 is hereby
a this 23d day of August, 1929, by and on behalf
of plaintiff.
Gzorce A. Curitron
Solicitor for Plaintiff.

27 The Permutit Company
440 Fourth Ave.
New York
March 18th, 1920.
Dr. Chas. F. McKenna,
50 Church Street,
New York, N. Y.
Dear Doctor McKenna :—

When talking with you over the phone a few days since,
I promised to send you some of the literature of this Com.
pany so that you might be acquainted with what we do.

We really are what you could call ‘‘Water Doctors’’, and
if anyone having any trouble with their water will kindly
send us a sample and particulars of the trouble they have,
we will undertake to cure it by some method or another,
mostly the ‘‘Permutit’’ Process but we do not confine our-
selves to that. We always hold ourselves open to any process
which might meet the particular case in hand, as there are
cases, though very few, in which the ‘‘Permutit”’ process
may not be suitable. When we have a case of this kind we
do not hesitate to suggest other kinds of processes, but we
have yet to find one which can not be treated by the ‘‘Per-
mutit”? process. There might be commercial reasons why it
would not go in but they are few and far between.

The process is a very simple one as you will notice by the
iteratures which we enclose. It is nothing more or less than a
filter but the bed, instead of being sand or some other mate-

18 Stipulation to Amend Answer.

rial, is a zeolite which is manufactured in our factory in
Brooklyn. Through this water passes, and in passing the
mineral constituents Calcium and Magnesium are exchan
for the corresponding Sodium salts so that all hardening
materials are taken from the water, leaving a water of abso-
lutely zero hardness which, as you know, is impossible to be
obtained by any of the older processes in existence—not even
hot lime soda will do it although that is not a bad process,
The apparatus is simpler than any other and requires less
attention, being practically foolproof.

Should you at any time come across any clients looking for

a process which will take up less room than the larger
28 methods require, we shall always be pleased to discuss

matters with you and either work through you as the
consulting man or take up the matter directly with any client
you may introduce to us.

We have now several thousand plants in operation, vary-
ing from 500 gallons per day water treated to as many as
3,000,000 gallons per day, without considering Government
plants and the like. You will notice in a Government bulletin
which we are sending you that the process is on record as
being worth consideration and we have several other inter-
esting pamphlets which you will no doubt cast your eyes over
and give us the benefit of your wide connection should occa-
sion arise.

Thanking you for your kind consideration, we are

Yours very truly,
' Tse Permutir Company
Taos. R. Duaaan,
Technical Manager.
TRD:MK
Enclosures

(Endorsed) Filed Aug. 26-1929 Charles M. Bates, Clerk.

29 And on, to wit, the 26th day of August, 1929, came the
parties by their attorneys and filed in the Clerk’s office
of said Court a certain Stipulation in words and figures fol-
lowing, to wit:
30 ° * (epties) * *°
STIPULATION.

It Is Hereby Stipulated, by and between the parties hereto,
that defendant may amend its Answer as follows:

LAS EU OIL ELE NL ILI CRANE NAMA RRR

Answer to Demand. 19

By adding to paragraph (a), page 4, line 6, after ‘‘and’’
the word —/or— | a

By adding to the list of publications on pages 5 and 6 of
the Answer, the following:
Pages 721 and 722 of ‘‘The Practical Engineer’, June 4,
909.
; Das Mangan im Grundwasser und seine Beseitigung, Dis-
sertation zur Erlangung der akademischen Wiirde eines
Doktor-Ingenieurs, eingereicht am 8. Juni 1909, von Weiss,
Stadtbaumeister in Glogau, Miindliche Prafung am 27. April

910.

Grorce A. CHRITTON
Solicitor for Plaintiff
Wuxinson, Huxtey, Byron & Knicut °
Counsel for Defendant.
Chicago, Illinois
August 23, 1929.
Approved
Wa rer C. Linpiey
United States District Judge.

(Endorsed) Filed Aug. 26, 1929 Charles M. Bates Clerk

1 And on, to wit, the 31st day of August, A. D. 1929, came

the plaintiff by its attorneys and filed in the Clerk’s of-

fice of said Court a certain Answer to Demand in words and
figures following, to wit:

32 -* fee *
ANSWER TO DEMAND.

Filed Aug 31, 1929.
Messrs. Wilkinson, Huxley, Byron & Knight
Solicitors for Defendant,
First National Bank Building,
Chicago, {]l.
Sirs:

Plaintiff, pursuant to Equity Rule 58 and without waiver
of exceptions and objections, admits the letter dated March
18, 1920 addressed to Dr. Chas. F. McKenna, 50 Church
Street, New York, N. Y., a copy of which is annexed to de-
mand of defendant dated August 23, 1929, was written on be-

EELS MESSI IER NPE PON SIM TE PHC BYRNE SION A MeO MH RE RR IN OR oe

20 Stipulation to Amend Answer.
half of plaintiff and signed by Thomas R. Duggan as its tech.

nical manger.
Respectfully,
DyrenrortH, Lee, Curitton & WILEs,

Solicitors for Plaintiff.
August 29th 1929.

‘Service of the foregoing answer to demand and the re
—_ of a copy thereof admitted this 29th day of August
1929.

Wirkinson, Huxiry, Byron & Kyieat,
Solicitors for Defendamt,

(Endorsed) Filed Aug. 31-1929 Charles M. Bates Clerk

33 And on, to wit, the 5th day of September, A. D. 1929,

came the parties hereto by their attorneys and filed in
the Clerk’s office of said Court a certain Stipulation in words
and figures following, to wit:

5, 1929.

34 ° ° @aptien.) ° *
STIPULATION

It Is Hereby Stipulated, by and between the parties hereto,
that defendant may amend its Answer as follows:

By adding to the list of publications on pages 5 and 6 of
the Answer, the worst

Chemische Industrie, Vol. 32, No. 8 (632), pp. 197-200
April 15, 1909, On the Technical Significance of the Permutits
(Artificial Zeolitic Compounds), by Dr. R. Gans, Director of
the Geonomic Laboratory of the Konig] Geologische Lande
sanstalt in Berlin.

DyrenrortH, LEE, Curitron & WILEs,
Solicitors for Plaintiff.
Wuxinson, Huxiey, Byron & Knicut,
Counsel for Defendam.
Chicago, Illinois
September 4th, 1929
Approved :

United States District Judge .
(Endorsed) Filed Sept 5-1929 Charles M. Bates Clerk.
35 (Endorsed) * * (Caption.) * * Stipulation.

See NI iM OSTA CARRERE RONEN A a _~d

Statement of Evidence. 21

was filed in the Clerk’s office of said court a certain
Narrative Statement of Testimony, in words and figures fol-
lowing, to-wit:

37 * ° (Caption) * *
NARRATIVE STATEMENT OF TESTIMONY

Be it remembered that on the trial of the above entitled
case in the District Court of the United States for the North-
ern District of Illinois, Eastern Division, before Honorable
Walter C. Lindley, Judge of said Court, the following pro-
ceedings were had, to wit:

Trial commenced October 29, 1929.

PLAINTIFF’S PRIMA FACIE TESTIMONY

Plaintiff offered in evidence a copy of the Gans patent in

suit No. 1,195,923, said patent being marked plaintiff’s Ex-
hibit A.
38 Plaintiff offered in evidence certain stipulations and
exhibits bound in a single volume, said volume being

marked plaintiff’s Exhibit B and contains the following :—

1. Stipulation dated March 30, 1929.

2. Defendant’s bulletin dated February 1, 1923. (Pl. Ex.
10 on Preliminary Injunction.)

3. Defendant’s bulletin dated June 1, 1925. (Pl. Ex. 11
on Preliminary Injunction. )

4. Defendant’s bulletin dated October 15, 1927. (Pl. Ex.
12 on Preliminary Injunction.

5. Defendant’s Model ‘‘D”’ bulletin. (PI. Ex. 13 on Pre-
liminary Injunction. )
6. Blueprint No. C-243. (Pl. Ex. 14 on Preliminary In-
junction.)

7. Blueprint No. C-242. (Pl. Ex. 15 on Preliminary In-
junction.)

8. Blueprint No. C-240. (Pl. Ex. 16 on Preliminary In-
junction.)

9. Defendant’s Model ‘‘C’’ bulletin. (Pl. Ex. 30 on Pre-
liminary Injunction. )

10. Defendant’s bulletin ‘‘Soft Water for Textile Pur-
poses.’’ (PI. Ex. 31 on Preliminary Injunction.)

11. Depositions of Morton, Applebaum and Howard.

36 And on to-wit: the 8th day of May, A. DL. 1930, there "4,

Statement of Evidence.

Exhibit 4 referred to in depositions.
Exhibit 5 referred to in depositions.
Exhibit 7 referred to in depositions.
Exhibit 8 referred to in depositions.
Exhibit 9 referred to in depositions.
Exhibit 10 referred to in depositions.
Exhibit 12 referred to in depositions.
. Stipulation of Plaintiff’s test of March 27, 1909
attached blueprints:
Blueprint -338-A
Blueprint ZW-608
Blueprint C-1941
20. Stipulation of Plaintiff’s second test of May 15, 1%
and attached exhibits.
Letter—Cooper, Kerr & Dunham to Mr. Byron.
Letter—Mr. Byron to Cooper, Kerr & Dunham.
Blueprint G-259.

39 HOWARD L. TIGER, being first duly sworn on behalf of
plaintiff, testified as follows:

Direct Examination by Mr. Cooper.

My name is Howard L. Tiger, I live at 240 West 98t
Street, New York City. I am an engineer with the Per
mutit Company, plaintiff here. I have been connected wit
it almost eleven years. I was technically educated; I tod
an rs course at New York University, obtained my
Bachelor’s Degree in 1918 and Engineer’s Degree the folle
ing year. I was in the employ of some other companies for
short period following my graduation, but for about elev
years with the plaintiff. I am Assistant Technical Manager
with the plaintiff. I have to do with its output and the qu
tity of its output; where the devices are put into use
what purposes they serve.

At counsel’s request I have taken from the books of
plaintiff, figures which show the output for years beginni
with the year 1919.

Mr. Cooper: I may explain to your Honor that in t
stipulated testimony the plaintiff’s business up to a part di
1919 is included in the papers in Exhibit B and I am simph

carrying it on from that point.
40 Q. Will you give the figures that represent the plai
tiff’s output of these water softeners and the zeolite
that go with them and the appurtenant apparatus?

Testimony of Howard L. Tiger. 23

Mr. Byron: Your Honor, of course, this is entirely imma-
terial and impertinent, and I see no reason why it should go
in. I have no great objection, but it is simply immaterial.

The Court: I suppose the purpose is to show the com-
mercial success. 1 don’t know as. it is very material, but he
may answer. Q

The Witness: (Continuing) During the year 1919 the
Company’s turn-over amounted to approximately $800,000.
During successive years it increased until in the year 1928
the Company’s turn-over amounted to approximately
$2,500,000. During the same year 1928 the business of the
Company’s licensees amounted to about six or seven hun-
dred thousand dollars, making a total of something over
$3,000,000 for the year 1928. During 1929 the rate of output
has been approximately the same as 1928.

When I spoke of turn-over I meant output, that is, the
sales.

In the textile industry these water softeners have had a
very marked effect. Whereas in previous years the textile
manufacturer was limited in his location by the need for an
abundant supply of soft water, the advent and development
of the zeolite water softeners has made him practically inde-

ndent of the hardness of the water. He is now, there-

41 fore, free to choose his location for other reasons because

he now knows that he can be assured of an absolutely
soft water supply by the use of the zeolite softener.

We can see an example of this development in the rayon
industry, which is a comparatively new industry. We can
find rayon factories located in various parts ef the coun-
try, where the water is hard, as, for instance, the big Du-
pont factories at Boffalo, where the water is hard, as the
water is at Chicago, the Great Lakes, and we can find rayon
companies in Pennsylvania in hard water districts, in con-
tradistinction to the location of the other textile industries
which previously sought natural soft water locations and
therefore concentrated in such districts as New England
anc the south.

The piaintiff’s business in household softeners amounted
to approximately 300 to 500 thousand dollars per annum, and
the business of its licensees for household softeners in the
year 1928 amounted to approximately $400,000 per annum,
at that rate.

I would say about $150 to $200 per unit would be an aver-
age figure to represent the individual selling price of the
plaintiff’s water softeners of the size for domestic use. And

24 Statement of Evidence.

as to its licensees, their average is probably a liittle lo

I would say about $100 a unit. |
42 I am familiar with the defendant’s water softenen

here which have been conveniently identified as to cop
struction by the defendant as its 1923 kind, being a down
flow softener and then its 1925 down-flow softener an
thirdly its 1927 up-flow softener. I am the author of th
three diagrammatic drawings illustrating the flow unde
various conditions in the defendant’s 1923, 1925 and 199
softeners.

Taking those three drawings which were known on the pre
liminary injunction motion as Plaintiff’s Exhibits 14, 15 an
16, and which are included in the Exhibit B in the trial,]
will explain first the conditions of flow in the defendant’
down-flow softener of 1923, represented by the diagram Ex
hibit 14 on the injunction motion.

Starting with normal operation, which is labeled, ‘‘Softes
-ing’’ in the upper left hand figure, in this figure the cours
of flow is as follows: the hard water enters through the Pe
6, passes upwardly through the pipe 7, out of the end o
pipe 9, which terminates inside the softener near the top
The water then passes downwardly through the zeolite be
into the collector system marked 4, out through the pipe I

and 11, through the meter 30 to service.
43 When the softener has softened its capacity of wate

it requires back-washing. That is described in Fig. 2 m
the drawing. The course of flow is as follows: the har
water enters through the inlet pipe 6, passing through pipe
12 and 10 into the softener and then out of the distributia
system at the bottom of the softener, upwardly through th
gravel supporting layers and the zeolite bed and out at th
top of the softener through pipes 9, 8 and 13 to waste. Dur
ing this operation—it is called back-washing because it is th
reverse direction of flow to what we had in the preceding
- operation. Its effect, if carried out at the proper rate, is t
remove from the zeolite the suspended matter or dirt anf
slime which has accumulated on the surface of that bed dur.
ing the softening of the water.

The proper rate of back-washing a softener is one thal
causes the zeolite bed to obtain a semi-suspended conditior
so that the granules of zeolite can rub against each othe
and the dirt can be loosened from the zeolites and carrie
off by the stream of water, into the sewer.

In the third condition shown on the Sub-Fig. 3 on thi
same exhibit, the zeolite bed is now ready to be regenerate

Testimony of Howard L. Tiger. 25:

or revivified by the salt solution and in Fig. 3 this is ac-
complished by opening the valve in the brine inlet line, that

is, the line eonnecting the brine preparation tank with the
44 softener itself. This permits the brine to enter through

the distribution system 15 whence it passes downwardly
through the zeolite bed, out through the collector manifold
at the bottom of the softener and out through pipe 16 to
waste.

The next operation is to rinse out of the softener the
brine which is still contained in there, and that is carried
out in the operation of regenerating or rinsing. In this op-
eration the hard water enters through the pipe 6, 7 and 8
and passes into the softener through the pipe 9, and then
downwardly through the zeolite bed and down to the bot-
tom of the softener, out through the manifold 4—the mani-
fold means the collecting apc through the manifold 4
and the pipe 16 to waste. is operation is carried out until
the water coming out of the softener is soft and the softener
is now ready to be placed in operation again for softening.

I will take up the defendant’s other softening apparatus
put out in the year 1925 as the various operations are illus-
trated on tho ‘drawing, which is plaintiff’s exhibit 15. This
is also a down-flow softener, that is, the water is softened
by passing downwardly through the bed of zeolite. In Fig. 1
in the upper lefthand corner the softening operation is illus-
trated. In this operation the hard water enters through the

pipe 6, 7, 8, enters the softener through the pipe 9 and
45 then passes downwardly through the zeolite bed, down

to the bottom of the softener through the notched ring
21, out of the pipe 10 to service. When the softener has soft-
ened all the water it can, the bed is back-washed. That oper-
ation is illustrated in Fig. 2. In this operation the hard
water enters pipe 6, _— through pipe 12, 11, 10, down to
the bottom of the softener, out through the openings in the
notched collar 21, upwardly through the supporting screen
20, and then through the gravel supporting layer and then
through the zeolite bed, out of the pipe 9, 8, 16, 17, to waste.

When the bed has been properly back-washed the softener
is ready for regeneration. That operation is illustrated in
Fig. 3 at the lower left hand. In this operation the brine is
introduced into the softener from the brine tank by means
of a water ejector; it happens in this case, passes in through
pipe 22, 8, 9, downwardly through the zeolite bed, down to
the bottom of the softener through the supporting plate,

26 Statement of Evidence.

through the notches in the collar, out through pipe 10, 18, 17,
to waste.

After the requisite amount of brine has been passed into
the softener, it is necessary to rinse the softener free from
salt. That operation is illustrated in Fig 4. In this opera.
tion the hard water enters through Pipe 6, 7, 8, 9, passes in
at the top of the softener, downwardly through the zeolite
bed to the supporting gravel layer, then through the perfo.
rated screen 20 and then down to the bottom of the softener

through the notches in the ring collar 21 and then out.
46 wardly through the pipe 10, 18, 17, to waste. This oper-
ation is carried on until the effluent of the softener is
soft and the unit is now ready to be placed in service again.

In like manner I will take up the defendant’s up-flow
softener of 1927 in connection with the drawing made and
which was known as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 16 on the preliminary
injunction motion. This is an illustration of an up-flow soft-
ener, that is, the water during the softening operation passes
upwardly through the zeolite bed. The normal operation of
softening is illustrated in Fig. 1 in the upper lefthand cor.
ner. In this operation the hard water enters through the
meter at 30, the pipe 11, the pipe 10, passes down to the bot-
tom of the softener, then upwardly through the supporting
screen plate 20, then through the gravel layers 3, then up-
wardly through the zeolite bed 2 and out at the top of the
softener through pipe 9, 8, 7 and 6 to service.

When the softener has softened all the water for which
its capacity is rated, it requires regeneration. This operation
is illustrated in Fig. 2. In that figure the brine is passed
into the softener by means of an injector through pipe line
22, then through the end of pipe 9 into the top of the soft-
ener, then downward through the zeolite bed, through the
gravel layer to the supporting screen 20, down to the bottom
of the softener and through the notches in the collar, out

through.pipe 10, 18 and 17 to waste.
47 When the requisite amount of brine has been intro-

duced the softener requires rinsing or washing, as illus-
trated in Fig. 3 of the drawing. In this operation the hard
water enters through the meter and pipe line 11, 7, 8, 9,
passes in at the top of the softener, downward through the
zeolite bed, down through the gravel layers, through the sup-
porting screen 20 to the bottom of the softener, through the
notches in the ring collar 21 at the bottom, upwardly through
pipe 10, 18, 17, to waste. When that operation is completed
it is necessary to displace from the softener the hard water

Testimony of Howard L. Tiger. 27

which is lying above the zeolite bed, that hard water having
been introduced during the previous rinsing operation. To
accomplish this hard water displacement or rewashing,
which is illustrated in Fig. 4 on the drawing, the hard water
is admitted through pipe line 11 and 10 and passes down to
the bottom of the softener, out through the notches in ring
21, upwardly through the screen, through the gravel layer
through the zeelite bed, out of the top of the softener
through pipe line 9, 8, 17, to waste until the effluent is soft,
at which time the softener is again ready to be placed in op-
eration.

Now, with reference to this diagram I have just been con-
sidering, these devices that resemble circles with crosses

through them, are just turn-on and shut-off valves. The
48 symbol c indicates a condition of closure and the symbol
o the condition of being open.

I have prepared sketches to show what changes would be
necessary in the defendant’s down-flow softener of 1925 to
make it into an up-flow softener of the 1927 variety. This
sketch which I have marked number 1 in the upper right-
hand corner is an illustration of the Graver 1925 down-flow
softener. I have noted on this sketch with red arrows the
positions to which two valves would have to be changed in
order to so arrange this softener that it could be operated
as an up-flow. In order to make that clearer, I have illus-
trated the softener with the valves in those new positions on
this second sketch marked number 2 in the upper right hand
corner. With this new location of the valves the pipe line
that was formerly the hard water inlet now becomes the soft
water outlet, the pipe that was the soft water outlet is now
the hard water inlet, so that this softener can be operated as
an up-flow softener.

The Court: Those are the only changes necessary?

The Witness: A change in the position of these two valves
and the change or reversal of the soft water connection with

the hard water connection.
49 I have prepared also a third sketch, which illustrates

how the softener of the type illustrated on sketch num-
ber 2 could again be changed so as to operate down-flow.
This change I have again illustrated in red. It shows that
by connecting the soft water outlet to the pipe which comes
out of the bottom of the softener instead of to the position
it occupies on sketch number 2 we have a softener which can
again be operated down-flow.

(Three sketches made by witness Tiger received in evi-

28 Statement of Evidence.

dence and marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBITS C, D and E.)

Now, on the three drawings which I previously explained,
the lightly dotted area at the right hand side of those vari-
ous figures of Plaintiff’s Exhibits 14, 15, and 16 on the in-
junction motion, illustrate approximately the position ana
extent of the zeolite beds as they are in the defendant’s soft-
eners and above that dotted area on the right hand side of
each of those drawings is space.

Cross-Examination by Mr. Byron.

50 Mr. Byron: Q. Your position, Mr. Tiger, in discussing

_ these three free hand sketches and the necessary changes
to change from an up-flow to a down-flow by shifting the posi-
tion of a few valves and changing the piping a little bit in-
dicates, I suppose, that you take the position that there is
no difference between an up-flow softener and a down-flow
softener, is that correct?

Mr. Cooper: Your Honor please, there again I am not
calling the witness on any matter of opinion, but simply on
a matter of fact.

Mr. Byron: Well, they have talked about the same thing.

The Court: I understand the examination of this witness
was confined to the question of how he changed it from one
form to the other. He gave no statement of any conclusion
or any opinion upon his part as to whether or not the change
lie invention or whether it had any significance at

Mr. Byron: Q. Then the change is a simple one, is it?

A. I would say it is.

Q. And you would say that a plumber could make those

changes?

51 Mr. Cooper: There again I will make an objection.

The Court: Sustained. This witness simply answered
this question. He says, ‘‘I changed it from that’’ and then
he said he changed it from ‘‘this to this.’’ ‘‘I changed two
valves and changed my connections on the soft water and the
hard water and I made it from a down-flow to an up-flow.”’
He did not express any opinion about it, but merely stated a
fact.

Mr. Byron: Q. In connection with Plaintiff’s Exhibit 16,
plaintiff’s injunctional motion, you stated with respect to
Fig. number 4 that the back-washing or re-washing, as it is
called in Fig. 4, the function of that was to wash out the

29

Testimony of Howard L. Tiger.

hard water above the bed of zeolite into the waste pipe, is
that correct?

A. That’s what I said. ,

Q. Now, if there is salt in the bottom portion of that
casing during that re-washing operation, that salt will have
a regenerative value or effect upon the upper layer of har-
dened zeolites, will it not?

A. That would depend upon a number of factors.

Q. I said, if there is salt it will have a regenerative ef-
fect?

A. That will depend upon several factors.

Q. What are the factors?

52 A. It would depend upon the extent of exhaustion of

these upper layers of zeolite and it would depend upon
the strength of the brine solution and it would depend upon
the quantity of the brine solution and it would depend upon
the rate of passing that brine solution upwardly through the
bed and it would depend upon the distribution of that brine
through the bed and perhaps some other factors that I don’t
think of offhand.

Q. Well, if all these conditions existed, you would get a
regenerating action, would you not?

A. If all what?

If the conditions which you mentioned prevailed.

A. I did not mention any conditions. I don’t think I men-
tioned any conditions.

Q. Well, you say under certain conditions is so and so
were a fact.

A. I mentioned they were factors which involved whether
the brine would regenerate or would not, but I did not men-
tion any conditions.

Q. Well, on the assumption, then, that there was a sodium
salt solution sufficiently strong:in the bottom of the casing
to have a regenerative action on that upper layer of har-
dened zeolites, when that sodium salt solution is washed
up through the bed it would then regenerate that hardened

layer of zeolites, would it not?
53 A. If the zeolites were hardened and if the sodium
salt solution were strong enough to regenerate the zeo-
lites and if the sodium salt solution came in contact with the ;
zeolites it would have some regenerating effect. i

Q. Referring to Plaintiff’s Exhibit 16, offered on the ;
motion for preliminary injunction, the pipe 10 which extends
upwardly, according to the sketch upwardly, centrally of the

a

a

A
i |

30 Statement of Evidence.

casing, is not connected to the lowest point of the casing, is
it?

A. It is according to what you mean by the word ‘‘con-
nected.”’

Q. I am asking you whether or not that pipe 10 is con-
nected to the lowest point of the casing. The answer is yes
or no.

A. Why, the pipe is not physically connected to the lowest
point.

Q. It is not connected to the lowest point of the: casing,

then, is it?
54

Q. All right. Now, then, on the single pew of flow of
back-washing and the single identical speed o upfiow in soft-
ing in the first instance you can get back-washing to wash
wu the impurities and to prevent channeling, and in the sec-
ond instance you get a good action in softening the zeolites
and preventing the channeling; is that not correct?

A. As far as the rate is concerned ; yes.

Q. Well, so far as the results are concerned ; let’s get
right down to brass tacks on this.

A. I am not sure.

Q. You don’t know then?

A. I don’t know what you mean.

Q. Oh, yes, you do.
122 Mr. Cooper: I don’t like that remark. The witness
says he does not understand.

Mr. Byron: That is perfectly clear.

I will ask the question again, if your Honor desires that I
ask the question in.

The Court: It does not seem to me that it makes any dif-
ference whether you back-wash or whether you soften. The
water proceeds through at the same rate, through the same
substance and the same result is bound to occur.

Mr. Byron: Precisely.

The Witness: So far as the lifting and grading of the
bed is concerned.

Mr. Byron: Q. I don’t want to quibble, but I want to

get in this word “‘channeling’’, and in so far as channeling
is concerned.

A. Yes.

Q. Now then, you say it is extremely difficult to prevent
vater from taking a preferred course, what is called chan-

68 Statement of Evidence.

neling. Then you must refer to a downflow softener; thg
is correct, is it not? ;
A. No. E
Q. What do you mean then? ;
A. Not having any reference to the direction of flow

Q. Well, you have just admitted that in upflow softeniy
at the rates we have been talking about here, you actualh

prevent channeling?
A. Yes; and only at that rate.
Q. Oh, no.
123 A. Yes. I beg your pardon. Not oh, no. Only at ths

rate.
Q. We are referring to a successful commercial upfloy

operation in the movement of the water upwardly t

a bed of zeolites and that would prevent channeling and
in this experiment. You have referred to a downflow softener
is that not correct?

A. Certainly not. I don’t see how you can possibly dray
that inference. May I say that I am talking about what!
assume you have been defining, entirely an upflow softeng
pt backwash rate? My answers apply to that and to thai
only.

The Court: Well, but counsel assumes that the rate yu
have been talking about is a commercially successful opera
tion. Do you mean that?

A. That rate, yes, sir.

Mr. Byron: That is all right.

The Court: Then bear that in mind on this question. I
seems to me you have not answered Mr. Byron’s question
directly. You have been quibbling on the questions. Tk
question, as I understand it, is whether, assuming this to k
at the rate of fifty-eight gallons per minute in that commer
cial operation of an upflow softener is a successful commer
cial operation. Assume that fact and admitting that that i
the rate and that is a wise rate at which the back-wash o
curs, does it not follow that the tendency toward channeling
must therefore be limited to downfiow softeners?

A. No; absolutely not.

The Court: Well, why? I want to know that.

The Witness: Yes.
124 The Court: If you are back-washing at the rate a
fifty-eight and that prevents channeling and you are soft
ening at the rate of fifty-eight gallons per minute and thal
prevents channeling— ;

Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 69

The Witness: I have been waiting for a chance to explain
nthe Court: I have not heard it. I have not heard any at-
tempt on your part to do so, I am frank to say. Go ahead.

The Witness: Suppose that the upflow softener has no
rate at that time.

The Court: Well, but the question assumes that it has.
Don’t you understand this question?

No.

A. anneling does not take place at that rate, your
Honor. I have said that repeatedly.

The Court: Yes; but then, if the upflow softener will suc-
cessfully operate without channeling at fifty-eight gallons per
minute—

The Witness: Or rather downflow.

The Court: —so far as that rate is concerned the only

type is the downflow type, isn’t it?
1% A. In downflow the softener works exactly the same.
The Court: But you have the channeling, you say, in
the downflow type.

A. No; the channeling difficulty occurs mostly with the
upflow :

The Court: I admit, Mr. Witness, it is impossible for me
to reconcile your statements with your present answer.

The Witness: Under the conditions of flow that are pre-

The Court: You have said to the contrary, if you analyze

it. You said yesterday, you told the court yesterday that one
of the great difficulties i i

uccessful commercial rate
is the same rate as a back-wash rate? You do not have any
neling, you just stay in the upflow rate, do you?
ery true, very true.

70 Statement of Evidence.

The Court: Then if you were to operate all these upfigy
softeners’ at a commercially successful rate, namely, fif
eight — per minute, you would not be troubled about
channeling? é

A. No. z

126 The Witness: (Continuing) There isn’t any definth |

description in the Gans specification of the patent ®
suit about a free or unconfined bed except as it is i
by the rest of the description at the inside of the stirring,
the description of the stirring apparatus. That i
not used, so far as I know, anywhere in the specification. Ty
equivalent is used, you have read it in part, where it &
scribes the back-washing and where it describes the use d
a stirring apparatus. You could not put the stirring ap
tus into a confined bed. When Gans refers to back-w.
my interpretation is he means a free and unconfined bed—
I inferred it from the drawings. Where Gans mentioned
place back-washing, my same definition obtained, that is, that
the bed of zeolites is free and unconfined.

Mr. Byron: All right.

Now, at this point, your Honor, I wish to call attention
to the fact that there has been more quibbling over a plan
little German sentence than a German charwoman coud
translate, there have been seven experts on behalf of pla
tiff in a lot of prior litigation, and five on behalf of defend.
ant; in this case of Permutit vs. Wadham, plaintiff contended
that a certain sentence there meant that the bed was abs
lutely locked, there was something, there was a screen dow
on top of the zeolite bed so it could not expand. Defend
ant’s witnesses all translated that German sentence as meat
ing that the bed was free and unconfined, and so they are at
a deadlock. Now then, in this same sentence, this same
graph, Gans, who wrote that article of April 15, 1909, specif-
cally refers to back-washing. Now, if Gans refers to back-

washing and means in his patent a free and unconfined
127 bed, then by the same token in his April 15, 1909 ar.

ticle, when he refers to back-washing, he means a free
and unconfined bed, and in that article you will find a more
complete description, if you please, of this Gans device illus
trated in the patent than his patent specification shows.

The Court: You may take that up in your argument.

Mr. Byron: Yes. I just wanted to make a point of it at
this time.

The Witness: (Continuing) Referring to the tests of the

Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 71

Graver upflow softener in Brooklyn. In spite of any speed
of flow in the bottom of that casing and after twenty-five min-
utes of down washing, there was more chloride, you say,
chlorine, I say, in the water in the bottom of that tank than
in the water which entered the top of that tank. There was
not a salt solution or some concentrate in the bottom of that
tank, as distinguished from the rest of the tank.

No there was not some concentration in the bottom of the
tank; there was salt in the water at the bottom of the tank,
but the concentration was less than above.

I am talking about the free portion at the bottom of this
casing where the zeolites are not located, down in the bottom

of that casing, this space I have defined as a seven and
128 a half gallon space, the water, the solution in that basin

of seven and a half gallons contained more chlorine or
chloride than the water entering at the top of that tank,
after a twenty-five minute down-rinsing; we did not carry it
as far as specified, but carried it until it was successfully
done

Asked if in my opinion, as a result of continued downflow
washing, you would ever be able to wash out all the excess
chlorine referring to everything over and above six p. p. m.,
which was the chloride content in the incoming water, I would
say it would take a long time. Of course, I can’t say from
personal experience with that particular softener, because
the tests represent all the experience I have had with it,
but I have had plenty of experience with a downflow soft-
ener and I know that if you tried to rinse the salt all out it
would take a very, very long time. I assume the same thing
is true here in the Graver upfiow softener.

When I spoke of the figures in the first test I changed them
from a quantity to a weight in order to get a ratio. Referring
toa memorandum I will show how I worked out the calcula-
tion, this is the calculation that I made—28 parts per mil-
lion is 28 milligrams per liter, and multiplied—there were
315 cc. for .375 of a liter,—I multiplied that by 28 and got
10.47 milligrams of chlorine. Then I set up the proportion
a8 follows: The atomic weight of chlorine is to the atomic
weight of sodium chloride is as 10.47 is to X. From which
Iealeulated that 28 parts per million chlorine represents 17.25

milligrams (NaCl) in the sample.
I converted that to grains by pointing off, and then
multiplied by 15.43 and obtained .267 grains in the sample.

In these tests by plaintiff of Defendant’s softener at Brook-

72 Statement of Evidence.

lyn, the Brooklyn water of 2 grains per gallon hardness wa,
— hardened by calcium sulphate. It was so stipn.
lated.

I do not know by my own analyses, what happens to cal.
cium sulphate as it passes through a soft bed which gives up
sodium but I assume it is converted to sodium sulphate, and
that the calcium goes into the bed. I have never investigated
what effect sodium sulphate has upon the standard soap test,
in so far as the reaction is concerned.

I do not know that sodium sulphate resists the five drop
standard B & B soap test by having tested it; I have up.
derstood that in sufficient concentrations it might. I did not
suppose that in any such concentrations as we are concerned
with it had any effect.

Assuming that it does have an effect to resist that action,
you would have to wash water through the zeolite bed a
greater length of time to get soft water when you used the
standard five drop test, and where sodium sulphate is in the
solution. My recollection is that we did not use the soap
test, but the chlorine test in the Brooklyn test. But making
your assumptions as to which I neither disagree nor agree,
I assume that your conclusion would follow.

Q. Then obviously, if with that peculiar reaction under
those peculiar circumstances, it takes longer to show soft

water, under those circumstances, there was a greater
130 opportunity, was there not, to wash out of that bed

and out of the water, a greater amount of salt than other-
wise would have appeared?

A. Well, the tests showed conclusively the longer you
washed the less salt, but the progress got very slow toward
the end.

May I make just one statement to prevent misunderstand-
ing, and that is I do not understand that sodium sulphate is
hardness, or that it has the effect of hardness, in the mat-
ter of soap tests. I simply do not want to have you misun-
derstand me.

Q. Now, I am not discussing that matter, and I want you
to answer my question.

A. I have.

Q. Answer it again then. I think that calls for a yes or
no answer. I think there is no doubt about that.

A. I thought that was better than a yes or no answer, but
I will say yes.

TEBE OUTRO eK

————

Testimony of Frank N. Waterman.

73

131 Mr. Byron: Yes.
The Court: Suppose he answers the question on the
same basis, what it would mean to him.

The Witness: (Continuing) Asked if this patent means
to me that it covers broadly the idea of softening water by
means of zeolites I say, I have never considered it that way,
but I should certainly say no. The patent broadly does not
cover the regeneration of zeolites after they are exhausted,
it includes that of course. On the same basis the Gans pat-
ent does not cover rinsing broadly, nor back-washing broadly.

You ask me if outside of the upflow type of softening
being superior to the downflow type of softening, there is
any other real difference in function in downflow and upflow
softening and I say I do not agree with your premise.

Outside of the question of channeling, and assuming that F
the several steps of the designer are carried out with equal

intelligence, there is no real difference in function in a
132 downflow softening operation and an upflow softening

operation. The question of channeling is the chief dif.
ference, and that is greatly in favor of the downflow soften-
ing.

if you had an upflow water softener, piped correctly for .
upflow softening, it would not be a very difficult matter to 8
change over to downflow softening. ,

You read me Mr. Hammer’s statement in the Paige & Jones

case, record page 94, where he said: i
“Once Gans had shown that the way to make a success- $
ful zeolite softener was to leave the bed free and uncon- f

fined, the arrangement of the pipes so that the water would
run one way or another is nothing but a plumber’s job.”’ t
I do not know just what Mr. Hammer meant by this, there- i
fore I do not know whether I agree with him or not, but ;
after you once understand the art as established by this Gans E
patent, any one with the intelligence to comprehend it can :
lay out the piping for either an upflow or downflow. I do {
not want to pass on the intelligence of the plumber. I think ;
plumbers are different. Certainly, I said if you tell the )
plumber what to do it is nothing but a plumber’s job. f
In an upflow water softener you are back-washing all the é
time. An upflow softener must work at a back-wash rate.
Why! the upward washing is used in the Defendant’s soft- :
ener, but not at that rate. In other words, all through the ~~
normal use it is running at a back-wash rate. When they

- a
Re... ‘ ,
Be F v9 ) " . .
. ite sie al SPT rte

VSO EE a |

74 Statement of Evidence.

push the hard water in the tank out to the sewer by an wm

ward flow they do not have to use that high rate.
133 In a downflow softener, the water is softened ag
goes downwardly, and I have stated that the water »
passing downwardly through the upper sand filter will leay
some of its mechanical impurities in the sand filter, but

is necessary to get rid of that dirt and slime so
zeolites can be effective.

In the downflow type of water softener, in the
which there is collected certain slime, I would not say its
necessary to back wash that bed to carry out the
slime at that time, before you can regenerate the bed @
zeolites. It is proper. It usually is done at that tim

how dirty it is. I know it is not because I
other way. I say that you have to wash the dirt out, bat #
is not necessary that it be done rather than lest. §
is preferable. In order to get the
erate, you have got to take off their litt
if that overcoat of dirt is excessive.

Q. Well, if it is there at all have
before the regenerating solution get t
lite. You have to rnd of the overenat

A. Until the ener wee ee

The Court: Can you say yee or ae

The Witness: No, your Hemor, 4 uw

Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 75

The Witness: Well, I will say no. In my own house it
js not true. The water—

The Court: Why isn’t it true? Now tell me that.

The Witness: t is what I am trying to do. Because
before it accumulates dirt when

t question is what
dition has been in every
last ten minutes, that heen put to you.

Mr Bree 3

ve hers 5 teed od gemtes ged ther geaditen oe gt et cee
dé there oe the epgee pertiee of the bed ere cheba evit
Get sed singe | New them we went te get red of tee Gort geet
ape tecture we ae te de thet of eeepc een
sere te lr we path tremeth om Amr ere gprs tbe ewnggele

‘Meet need: te cremumprre te ibepe ert seme cllemae o: ‘Hbet geet am”

& (0 eomree

i
Be Wittenas

The Witmece = | cmeriepeitr atbeeenli oF fie apseectnreny lipped penny
ie samme |) died) orotate ceenedibernssinenned)
er

I

site
a
0 a ~
Wie Beetrprenee Mie eo rpeet tee ondtbdderet of rte ttre! cerpptt
nm
He terre 8 ceapert conte te oRnegterte: tee crnteentiivne ne thee
| Se
J

emnttineneed le antttbiiibee «= coPPdt crttntiendll neeree ortnettitions «tiett th
Ang a ddttttdt —canetlbvrnettonet!

rT Hy Seppe t Wopees *preveee erties cit: etPae

‘seneesetngght

es A

76 Statement of Evidence.

The Witness: Beg pardon. I said knowingly.

The Court: Perhaps not knowingly. If you don’t knoy.
you should know. That is the reason I say you should m
derstand these questions. You have taken all forenoon for a
examination that should have taken a half hour.

Mr. Byron: Q. In about how many patent cases have yu
been an expert witness?

A. Ido not know.

Q. Several hundred?

A. Ido not know. I never counted them.

Q. Now, getting back to the upflow softener, I started out
twenty-five minutes ago to say that in the upflow softener,
in the upflowing action of the water through the bed of zeo.
lites, with that type of softener, it:is not necessary to back.
wash, is it?

A. It is unless the softening is done at a back wash rate.

Q. Well, let us assume that the water is flowing at a rate
sufficient to hold that bed in a state of semi-suspension, the
one that we have assumed in general operation; under thow
conditions, with a bed of zeolites in a semi-state of sus
pension, any dirt or slime coming in with the water would go
directly up through that bed of zeolites, would it not?

A. If that is true clear to the bottom of the bed, yes;

otherwise not.
137. The Witness: (Continuing) When there is no dirt

in that bed in the upflow softener, it is not necessary to
back wash. I have no statistics which say that in an upflow
softener, there is the economy of water to the extent of the
amount of water that is used in back wash in the downflovw.
You have two washings in either case. I do not know the
relative quantities of water involved.

Q. I have said for a long time now that in an upflow
softener, in that up softening action, no dirt or slime,—we
are considering that as settled—no dirt or slime finds itself
in that bed of zeolites, and therefore you answer it was not
necessary to back wash. Now then let us go to the Gans
patent and the downflow. The water in passing downwardly
through the bed of zeolites, dirty water, left dirt and slime
on top of the bed or in the upper portion of the bed of zeo-
lites. Now then we have to get rid of that dirt and slime
in the down wash softener.so we back wash with water. Now
we used some water in back washing, didn’t we?

A. Of course. ;

Q. And we did not back wash in an upflow softener. So
the economic advantage in so far as wash water was con-

Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 77

cerned, in the example I gave you, is in favor of an upflow
water softener, is it not?

A. I don’t know. You have not completed the cycle.

Now, regardless of the cycle, in considering the same
cond:tions, what is your answer? I am just speaking about
the presence of a back flow washing and the non-presence

of an upflow washing, the economy is in favor of the
138 situation in which no back flow washing is required; is
that not so?

A. That would be true.

The Witness: (Continuing) I do not know why the plain-
tiff uses a duplex gauge or two gauges on its downflow type
of water softener. In connection with plaintiff’s downflow

of water softener I have seen that there is a gauge that
measures the pressure of the incoming water, and that there
is also a gauge which measures the outgoing water. I don’t
know whether it is universal or not. I don’t remember
whether I ever saw two gauges compounded into one gauge
known as a duplex gauge or not. The function of that gauge
or of the two gauges is to indicate the two pressures.

I understand that in an upflow type of water softener, as-
suming that the zeolite bed is mounted on a gravel bed, that
the gravel bed in the use of dirty water, in the upflow will
act as a strainer to collect any dirt or alime. I am sure I
don’t remember if I ever said that it does. I don’t think I

have mentioned it in this case.
139 Q. Please refer to the Duggan patent 1,276,629, which
is called a prior art patent; this is one of the two pat-
ents that was involved in the suit of Permutit versus Wad-
ham, in Detroit, in the Sixth Circuit.

Mr. Cooper: I object to this as beyond the scope of the
Direct.

The Court: He may answer that, if he knows some other
identification.

Mr. Byron: It is all on the same question of channeling
with the locked beds. It is all interlocked. You cannot get
away from it.

Q. Do you remember whether that was in the suit or
not?

A. I don’t remember.

Mr. Cooper: I will admit it was in the suit if counsel
says that it was. That is a matter I don’t know about,
but if counsel says it was in the suit, I will admit it.

Mr. Byron: I will make the statement if you believe me.

Mr. Cooper: I am taking your statement.

78 Statement of Evidence.

Mr. Byron: It was put in the suit originally and it way
withdrawn from the suit.

Mr. Cooper: That was before the trial?

Mr. Byron: It was during the trial.

Mr. Cooper: Well, I meant before the submission. It dig
not go before the court?

Mr. Byron: No.

140 The Witness: (Continuing) In the tests which I have

made in an upflow softener where a screen was placed
down on top of a zeolite bed, channeling occurs very markedly,
I determined that there was channeling in that upflow soft-
ener in two ways. One by testing liquid at different parts
above the bed, and finding that it differed, and second by
using a glass container and using a colored liquid.

I have not tabulated those tests so that I can present them
to the court. It was years ago. I have not forgotten the
results. I could not tell you how many years ago it was,
Maybe ten years ago.

Mr. Byron: Q. De you agree with this statement, and
it has reference to a zeolite type of softener, in which the
top of the bed has pressed down upon it a screen. The state.
ment is:

‘‘The channeling difficulties are more accentuated where
the flow of water to be softened is down through the bed
than where the flow is upward.’’

A. Well, from the limited experience that I have on that,
I do not agree with the statement that he read.

The Witness: (Continuing) In the first part of my tes-
timony I said that I had been working on these water soft-
eners for ten and a half years. Based upon that ten anda
half years experience I cannot give an answer, my experi-
ence of lock beds has been rather limited, and the impres-

‘gion that I derived from it is that the reverse of that
141 statement is true. I cannot speak as of wide experience
on lock beds.

The distribution of water uniformly over the area of the
bed during the softening period in the downflow softener
of the Gans patent, is secured by the uniform resistance of
the bed, which comes as the result of proper grading of the
bed in a back wash operation, as I explained.

I stated in all the litigations that even distribution was
controlled by a fine layer of high resistant material on the
top of the bed, that is the result of grading. I suppose such
upper layer of highly resistant zeolites to be essential to
the proper distribution of water in a downflow water softener,

nse —

Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 79

to avoid channeling, but I do not know that I ever used any
that did not have it. That is zeolites always differ in size
and therefore there are always fine ones on top.

What I am uncertain about is whether it ever could be
absent. Zeolites always have some fine particles. In back-
washing they always take the top. And where I have delib-
erately disturbed that layer or where the bed ig put in with-
out any attempt at gradeage then a tendency to channeling
ollows :

a a result of back wash, in the Gans patent, there is
formed on the top portion of the bed a uniform layer of high
resistant material to uniformly distribute the water in its
passage downwardly through the bed. I so regard it as
necessary to prevent or to minimize channeling in a down
softening action, in the Gans arrangement.
142 In an upflow water softener, that is a softener in
which the water passes upwardly during the softening
action, a layer of high resistant material on the top of the
bed could have no influence or effect or control upon the
distribution of that water passing upwardly through the zeo-
lite bed, unless the rate was very low. Very little under any
circumstances, probably none.

The distribution of the upflow water in up softening ac-
tion, in an upflow type of water softener, would be controlled
in the sense of distributing the water by some means below
the bed of zeolites. I will explain, so long as the injection
of water avoids a jetting action, that is so long as it does
not produce a projection of water against a local spot on
the bed, then the channeling is prevented, in working at a
back wash rate, by the instability, the unstable equilibrium,
of the bed.

The more closely the zeolites are held together the more
efective will be the collection of suspended material in the
wolites.

Ido not think that your statement is correct as a matter of
mechanics, that in a downflow softener, the zeolites are held
packed together because of their own weight, and in addi-
tion because of the weight of the column of water coming
_ upon them, but by whatever the loss of pressure through

e bed is.

To the extent that the weight of the water so acts, it is
correct that there is a cumulative weight, first the weight of

; NOES LONER RNIB RNR ois er

.
PRICE PNT NNT er as

80 Statement of Evidence.

the material itself and then the weight of the water, to ho
the particles of zeolites close together.

143. In an upfiow softening action the zeolites are held,
a semi-suspended condition, so that taking your fist y

a grain of zeolite in a semi-suspended position, the who,

surface of that grain is exposed to the water, of course th

suspension is not complete; it is semi-suspension.

Now then in a downflow softening action, the zeolites ap
not in & semi-suspended condition; me! are in a packed om.
dition; therefore it may be true to a slight extent that fin
is less actual surface, zeolite surface exposed to the wate
passing downwardly through the bed of zeolites. Of coum
the grains are very irregular. They do not fit together x
you illustrated with your fist. There is not proportionately
a great deal of interengaging surface, in a zeolite bed of th
downflow type. There is enough to sustain the pressure, |
mean proportionately to the total surface. I really don}
know whether it is true or not that there is less surface e.
posure of the grains of zeolite in a downflow softening action,
than in an upflow softening action.

No, it is not necessarily true that the efficiency of upfoy
softening would be greater than the efficiency of downfly
softening, due to the difference in surface exposure of th
zeolites, there being more in the upflow than in the dow.
flow, but if you assume that it equally effectively contacts,
that is there is no channeling, the water is evenly distrib
uted, then it may be true.

Mr. Cooper: The whole matter is speculative.

Mr. Byron: There is nothing speculative about it.

144 The Court: It seems perfectly obvious to the court

that if you had a particle of sand with a zeolite on top
and water on top of that, that the force of gravity of the
material itself, the water on top of it, and the water flov-
ing, would hold the material back. That is ordinary common
sense and knowledge of the laws of gravitation. On the con
trary if that water is forced up through a body of sand #
that the values are in suspension or semi-suspension optim
subversion, there is to a certain extent a counter action
against the gravity, and the force of gravity is not exercised
to the extent it is when it comes down, because there is some
thing pushing against it. I do not see any necessity for
any great detailed examination upon those things because
those things are perfectly natural. It seems to me the wit
ness should admit that.

Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. $1

In patent cases where you get on the witness stand gen-
tlemen who are classed as patent experts or engineers, and
testify as experts, time and again they are asked to testify
to things that are largely matters that seem to me the court
ought to have some knowledge about himself.

I repeat myself in statements in the past upon that sub-
ject, and I shall continue to repeat myself upon it as long
as it comes back. I am asked time a‘ter time in patent cases
to sit and listen to some gentlemen who I think has no more
intelligence than I have on subjects regarding the laws of
nature, to give sworn testimony as to perfectly obvious facts.
I suppose counsel are alweys entitled to put in expert tes-

timony for the purpose of explaining to the court that
145 which is difficult to understand, but no amount of tes-

timony can change established facts, known to be true
the world over.

It does not matter whether this gentleman accedes or
whether he disagrees. The fact is that when water comes
down into a body the force of gravity tends to pack it. The
fact is that when water is going up it is counteracting to a
certain extent the force of gravitation, and therefore the
packing is less. It may reach the stage of complete suspen-
sion. It may reach the stage of partial suspension. I do
not know what material those obvious facts are going to have
in the outcome of this law suit. It seems to me perfectly
obvious, if I am not assuming something that because of
ignorance on my part is rot obvious to others.

You may proceed.

The Witness: (Continuing) I am qualified to disenss this
standard five drops of B & B soap so.ution as the determin-
ing factor of whether or not there is soft or hard water, I
have done it many times. If you am a permanent lather with
five drops of soap all put 40 C.C. of water in at once, you
say you have soft water, but not zero. I have been accus-
tomed to use three. If you need more soap the water is
harder. Many use five, many use three drops B & B soap
test in the commercial world to determine whether or not
you have soft water commercially or hard water commer-
cially. You never use more than five that I know of. I
would not be surprised nor would I disagree if in an in.
stance eighteen drops of this standard B & B soap solution

were used to be the test of whether or not there was
146 soft or hard water, not if thet is the kind of water the
user wanted. Kighteen drop water is not soft water
in ordinary tests. It may be soft enough for the purpose of

82 Statement of Evidence

the man operating a filter that way.

If by this test five drops determine soft water, then more
than that is harder than five drops of course. Hard is not
an absolute term. I never have so understood it. If eight.
een drops of standard B & B solution were used in forty
cubic centimeters of water I would say from my point of
view that you had hard water.

You read me what you say is a report of the Permutit
Company dated March 16, 1927, to the Florida Filter Cor.
poration, subject Health Refining Company, Tampa, Florida,
containing two pages, on the second page of which, para.
graph 10 it states:

‘*However the zeolite plant to follow can be figured on an
adjusted hardness of 20 grains for this well water No. 1, ca-
ee a7 grains, the special soap test, that is nine drops in
20 C. C.’’

I do not admit that that woud be a practical test for soft
water or hard water. I assume that that assumes a brackish
water, and you cannot do any better than that with brackish
water oftentimes. But it is not soft water according to my
understanding.

(Said circular was marked for identification Defendant’s
Exhibit 18).

The definition of a free and unconfined space perhaps

147 depends on the point of view, but I should say room for

the bed to expand and boil, when operated at a back

wash rate, this is ordinarily above four and not exceeding

six gallons per square foot of bed per minute. If you mean

in a given tank, I suppose it is all the space from the bed
up to the outflow.

A locked zeolite bed is one which is held so that it cannot
expand and grade when treated with an upflow of water ate
back wash rate. A locked bed is one in which the screen is
right down on top of the zeolite bed so that the water in
passing upwardly through the zeolite bed cannot substan-
tially expand at all. If it can expand there is an unlocked
bed, or a bed which is free and unconfined. A locked bed is
one in which the zeolites are not free to have substantial
expanding and grading.

Mr. Byron: I would like to have a definition of a locked
bed without the word substantial in it.

Mr. Cooper: If your Honor please, the witness has given
his definition.

The Court: He may ask him what he means by substantial,
if he wishes.

LIU GT RROD ory

TE TOF ERE I PRE IF AL MLL LT

-—

Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 83

The Witness: (Continuing) I mean by substantial in this
definition that the expansion of the bed produces no material
results that are different from what it would be if it was
clamped tight, or the weight was right down on it. The
primary differences between a locked bed and a free bed
are that you cannot wash the locked bed and it does not

grade. You cannot grade it.
48 The Court: He may tell in that respect whether he
means by locked bed ‘whether the locked bed is placed im-
mediately in front of the top surface of the bed, or whether
there is any intermediate space; what he means by the term
locked bed.

The Witness: I mean that it is either in direct contact,
so close that the expansion of the bed on a flow at a back
wash rate cannot free the bed from dirt.

The Court: How much space would be necessary to pro-
duce that back wash?

The Witness: Ten to twenty per cent of the height of the
bed

The Court: Do you mean the vacant space between the top {
of the plate, the over-lying plate, to get 10 to 20 per cent of f
the volume of the bed?

The Witness: Of the height, the depth of the bed, yes.
That is the height should be that much.

The Court: And if you have 10 to 20 per cent then you
do not call it a locked bed?

The Witness: No.

The Court: With less than ten per cent you do eall it a
locked bed ?

The Witness: I would not like your Honor to bind me
down to that.

The Court: I am trying to get you two gentlemen at a
definite point if I can.
The Witness: That is my estimate, of the minimum that
would be effective, but I would not like to swear.
49 The Court: You have your opinion at this time that
less than ten per cent would not be effective in the wash-
ing process, and that might therefore be termed locked bed?
The Witness: Yes.
Mr. Byron: It is a big issue in this case, your Honor.
The Court: He has given you his opinion on it. :
In commercial use what is the depth of this body in the é
plaintiff’s machine, do you know? i
e Witness: Not less than two feet. From two feet up i
according to the size of the container. f
;

'
pain a |

84 Statement of Evidence.

The Court: Do you know when this is put into commerce
how much the bed is, how much vacancy there is above the
top of the bed?

The Witness: I have seen them, I think, all the way from
two feet, usually not less than three, ’ to six or seven,

The Court: When the bed is two feet thick from top to
bottom, how wide a space do you have above it free, nor.
mally, the average; the same?

The Witness: No. Oh, no, I could not say normally. May.
be 30 or 40 per cent.

The Witness: (Continuing) You read to me the follow.
ing from my testimony in the Detroit case, on page 210:—

‘‘Not only is the salt objectionable if the water is used
for drinking or other purposes; but that the salt water, as
your Honor remembers, has taken the lime, and the lime is
what we want to get rid of, so it is very important that there
should be enough washing done for each regeneration to
insure that the lime holding salt has been gotten out, and it
is for that purpose that the patentee emphasizes particularly

the attachment—attachment—of an exit pipe at the low.
150 est point so that there shall not be a pocket for the salt

to form. Salt water as your Honor knows is much heavier
than plain water. That is why a person floats more easily
when he is in sea water, and it will tend to hug the bottom,
and even though there be quite a violent inflow, if the salt
water can get to a point lower than the outflow pipe, it will
stay there and gradually diffuse its lime into the water, and
stay for one or two or three or four hours. After e soft-

ening has begun it will be continually contaminati + Wa-
ter; therefore the outflow pipe is advantageousi «~ fact
necessarily placed at the bottom if there is going soft

water, and that is the feature of the invention that is recited
in Claim 5.’’

I do not see the need of harmonizing the quotation with
the answers I have given in this litigation. They are en-
tirely in harmony.

SDS Bryer
FE BREINER IE RNR OTR IE ETFS RNC Rs ee IN

Testimony of Howard L. Tiger. 85

Wednesday, October 30, 1929,
Two o’clock p. m.

HOWARD L. TIGER. recalled, testified as follows:

rect Examination by Mr. Cooper.

grains, thirty grain
sulphate hardness. We used it in the Brooklyn tests be-
cause we had the Brooklyn city water available and that,

n chlorides
is, hardness chlorides, would have increased the chloride con-

we were going to look for in the tests. That left us only
to take the hardness ommpeunds which were sulphates
ates.
he use of calcium sulphate in the quantities used in
the Brooklyn tests has no substantial effect upon the subse-
quent soap test to which we subjected the water.
In the ordinary course of my business with the plaintiff,
I have had occasion to determine in connection with the de-
sign of its commercial output, the relation between the ex-
pansion of the bed of zeolites and the rate of back wash.
I can express it orally and by a curve. If you pass the water
upwardly through a zeolite bed, the bed mes expanded
appreciably when the rate of flow upward corresponds to
about two io two an done-half gallons of water per square
foot of area per minute. And it continues to expand more
and more as that rate is increased. Now, when you get toa

.
4,
MEI se rspapme ae ont OR, PSNI CY aren E aR DET NOR OF Ra ROD Yara fate,

2 IED

PSR AE RTW. ORS LTE Se

—_——qy

86 Statement of Evidence.

rate of about four gallons per square foot per minute that
expansion is about five to ten per cent of the bed. And when
you get to a rate of about six gallons per square foot per
minute, that expansion amounts te about twenty to twenty-
five per cent of the bed, and in stating these expansion fg
ures I refer in my expansions always to the original vol-
ume of the bed before starting the wash.

Cross-Examination by Mr. Byron.

Waters occur occasionally in nature which contain as the
main constituent calcium sulphate, that is, the hardening
constituent. I would say that waters containing calcium sul-
phate occur occasionally, but not very much; but waters high
in sulphate hardness, that is, sulphates of calcium and mag.

nesium, occur more frequently.
153 Now, in those Brooklyn tests by plaintiff of defend.

ant’s device, you say it was not a question of hardening
or exhausting the bed, but in making any test of a zeolite
softener we always consider the capacity of that softener
for softening water and a test run means to me a run car.
ried out from the time you begin to get your soft water until
you no longer get soft water.

Plaintiff’s object in running tests on defendant’s upflow
softener in Brooklyn wes to determine whether or not there
was a salt solution left in the lower part of the casing after
the down rinsing operation, under the usual commercial con-
ditions.

I don’t think we can say the bed could have been hardened
by any hardening water and still reach the results that plain-
tiff was after in the tests on the chloride contents, for this
reason, for example, if you took a water containing we will
say about 200 parts per million of chloride hardness and as-
sume that water after softening would contain 210 parts per
million of sodium chloride. Now, to measure the difference
between 200 parts per million of sodium chloride and 210
parts per million is more difficult than to measure the differ-
ence between 10 parts and 20 parts per million, although
the difference is the same in each case, that is the differ-
ence between the chloride before and after is the same in
each case.

The hardening elemnt in th Brooklyn city water, as always
is the salts of calcium and magnesium. The use of Brook-
lyn city water would not have confused plaintiff’s test of
defendan\’s upflow softener at Brooklyn so far as chlorides

EEN ER SAR ATOR PSC NS Pe a gpe em (caine

Testimony of Howard L. Tiger. 87

are concerned. I don’t think there was any peculiar rea-
son why plaintiff wished to use calcium sulphate. The
154 hardness of Brooklyn city water runs between one and
two grains per gallon. The total hardness in the water
used for hardening the bed and rinsing the bed by plaintiff,
of defendant’s softener was 18 grains hardness, according to
the stipulation.

The difference between 18 grains and two grains or one
and one-half grains, as the case may be, represents the dif-
ference, 16 grains of calcium sul kate.

I said that sodium sulphate i
effect on the soap test, but I deny that I said that calcium
sulphate has no substantial effect upon the soap test. The
calcium sulphate is used and passes through the zeolite bed
and therefore it is changed into sodium sulphate. I said
that sodium sulphate in the amounts that it would be present

in that water after softening had no substantial effect on a
soap test. The calciu i

on My experience in the treatment of such water and the
operation of zeolite softeners, I will explain why it has no

substantial effect; when we test water for hardness we
155 add to the water a soap and we shake the water with

the soap. In other words, we measure the soap consum-
ing power of the water. Now, as we add soaps to the water,
these soaps re-act with the hardness in the water, that is,
with fhe caleium and magnesium salts to form insoluble prod-
ucts, insoluble soaps. For example, if we consider a soap

, the soap is consumed in the reaction and the prod-
uet formed is caleium and magnesium stearate, which is in-
soluble. Now, we have to continue adding soap until we
have consumed all the hardness present in that water. Then

dium salt. Sodium salts do not form insoluble soaps and
therein lies the secret of the utility of zeolite softened wu. 4

ERA ge a MET Ra ee Hor REET ME LEDER ON RR RS NC en 3

88 Statement of Evidence.

ters for processes which use soap. That’s why after you
soften the water by zeolites and you take out the calcium and
magnesium salts and you have sodium salts, these sodium
salts do not influence that water where you have to use soap,
In other words, you now have a water which contains a cor-
responding amount of sodium salts, but the sodium salts
do not consume the soap that you use and the soap is free
to produce a lather.

The sulphate is the radical which is combined with the
sodium. The acid radical does not combine with the soap, it
is the sodium or the calcium, the so-called metallic radical
of a compound which would react with the soap if it could
react, and therefore what I mean to say is that there is no
appreciable reaction I know of between the sodium salts and

soaps.
156 It may be true that sodium chloride is frequently

used to salt out soap in its manufacture, but there it
would be used in quantities which are probably very large
compared to those we are talking about. I am not familiar
with the system of manufacture of soap. I therefore can not
pass upon the question as to whether or not sodium sulphate
can be used or if it could be used, what quantities would be
required.

Q. There was a point that came up yesterday while you
were on the stand that I was mislead by and I am afraid
the court was also, and I think we should be straightened
out on it. You were referring to the profit of this plain-
tiff company as being two and three-quarter millions or three
millions of dollars.

A. That’s the total, not the profit.

The Court: I understand.

Mr. Byron: What was it?

The Court: The volume.

Mr. Byron: All right.

Q. The volume of business, is that it?

A. That’s correct, yes.

Q. And that’s the total volume of business for the whole
company?

A. For the Permutit Company, yes, sir.

. Yes. Now, I was led to believe that the only business
that the Permutit Company had was the manufacture of
zeolites and the manufacture of tanks in which the zeolites
were used. Now, I want you to tell me what other lines the
Permutit Company manufactures.

Testimony of Howard L. Tiger. 89

157 The Witness: (Continuing) We also manufacture

auxiliary equipment that is used in connection with zeo-
lite softeners. For example, if you have a dirty water and
want to soften it by zeolite we have to filter it before we
soften it. In that case we would sell the zeolite softener
with a filter. Another example I might give you is, if we
were going to treat a water of a certain volume for certain
purposes, for example, suppose we were going to treat a
water very high in bicarbonate hardness to be used we will
say in boiler feeding. If it happens to be a large installation
it is desirable to reduce the soluble salts in the final effluent
to as great an extent as possible. That can best be done by
treating the water before it goes into the zeolite softener
by means of a lime treatment and then finishing the treat-
ment with zeolites. We call such a plant a lime zeolite com-
bination softener and we have such plants in operation and
manufacturing them.

It happens occasionally that we sell lime water softener
equipment even in places where we do not sell the zeolite
in connection with it.

Mr. Byron: As a matter of fact, there are hundreds and
thousands of installations in the country of lime softener
equipment, all over the country?

Mr. Cooper: Of the plaintiff, do you mean?

Mr. Byron: All.

A. There are.

158 The Witness: (Continuing) We manufacture also a

CO, recording and indicating instrument for use in com-
bustion work, and that amounts to a very small proportion
of our total business. We also manufacture a continuows
blow-off system used in connection with zeolite a system for
boiler plants. Those are all the products I think of right
now. We do occasionally have a call for manganese re-
_ system, perhaps one in five years, or something like

t.

Whereupon the defendant, to maintain the issues on its
behalf introduced the following evidence :—

DEFENDANT’S EXHIBITS NOS. 20 to 62 offered and
marked in evidence.

90 Statement of Evidence.

159 DOUGLAS V. MOSES, being first duly sworn on behalf
of defendant, testified as follows:

Direct Examination by Mr. Byron.

My name is Douglas V. Moses, I am 34 years old. M
sasiilation is 4406 Barring Avenue, East Chicago, Indiana. 1
am by profession a chemical engineer in charge of technical
work at the Graver Corporation, the defendant. I never
have testified in any suit before.

The Witness: (Continuing) I attended Iowa State Col.
lege, receiving the degree of Bachelor of Science in 1919, the
degree of Master of Science in 1921, and the degree of Doe
tor of Philosophy in 1925, all degrees with a major in chem.
ical engineering. For the eight months immediately follow.
ing my Bachelor of Science Degree I was employed by the
Engineering Experimental Station at Iowa State College
as assistant chemical engineer, and that would take up to
the beginning of 1920. From 1920 to 1925, including the
school year, I was instructor in chemical engineering at
Iowa State College. In the summers of 19235 and 1924 I was
employed by the United States Bureau of Public Roads sta-

tioned at lowa State College.
160 I have been employed by the Graver Corporation since

August 1925. During the first portion of my employ-
ment, | worked in connection with the preparation of zeolite,
very shortly after that on the solving of various problems
connected with water softening and research, now on elabo-
ration of the same duties, together with the recommenda-
tion of the various treatments for water softening purposes.

My work had been of a practical nature in and out of the
factory and in and out of plants and examination of zeolite
water softening plants, the designing, construction, and s0
forth, very general.

As a result of my education and experience, I feel quali-
fied to design, construct, operate and generally give consult-
ing advice for water softeners and particularly the zeolite
type of water softener. In my opinion there is no great prob-
lem or difficulty in the softening of water by the zeolite proc-
ess, regeneration of exhausted zeolites, and the washing out
of the salt from a bed of zeolite. In my opinion up-fiow soft-
ening is preferable. My reason, first, the lower pressure flow
of the up-flow machine. In the down-flow machine the bed
of zeolite offers a considerable resistance to the passage

Testimony of Douglas V. Moses. 91

of water and causes a pressure load during the time that the
water is passing through the zeolite bed. In the up-flow ma-

chine with the bed in suspension or semi-suspension, as
161 it may be, the pressure load is, of course, practically

missing, such pressure load as is the result of the water
passing through the bed is practically missing. In addition
there is with the

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386008_0075%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
