# Petitioners Brief — DeForest Radio Co. v. General Elec. Co.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386008_0055%3A09

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Petitioners Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1931
- **Citation:** 283 U.S. 664

## Text

haa ae re oe

oo,

Ri col RN
eure he Ss

» Court of the United States -

Qetober Term, 1930.5

ee a Synapse BAe

. Pies ; nia ¢ x ‘ ae. a
; Dez Forest Rapio Company, a tee ts
4 Wega Petitioner,

v. ty » 5 c ie }

Gawznat Exzorrico Company,
% | Respondent.

<8 4

é Ne ENN CoD see i

"REPLY BRIEF ON BEHALF OF PETITIONER.

bee bt

‘the validity of patent covering an article of very great
_paaie, economic and industrial importance. . The patent
_ now stands established as valid, by the last decision of the
-Cireuit Court of Appeals, on the changed decision of one
- -jndge, who gives no reason for his change except in so far
as | » concurs in the opinion of another judge. ‘As pointed
_ @yt in our main brief, this opinion-is silent, orifquestions
of fact which were dispositive of the case as’ found by. the
‘Trial Judge, and accepted by the first decision of the @ircuit
Court of Appeals against the Respondent. We submit for
the careful consideration of the Court the question as tow
whether the-validity of a,patent of such very great public ©
_importane should be. ny dete-mined by the changed
a ‘bcissibiatle Soak tc ko ghost (pp. 5, 27) as to:

LO Phos coot nando ep RRR
_the Patebt Office and the Court of Appeals of the District :

bunals in the Patent Office (diametrically cppeaet in
theories), the opinion of the Court of Appeals of the

’ triet of Columbia, which ‘professedly adopted these dia-
_ metrically opposed positions, and the last decision of the

Court of Appeals which does not mention the nanan of

is priority.

So In order that undue idiviitideuss may not be ne

to the finding of ‘patentable invention by the Law Exam-
inet of the Patent Office—which finding is given prominence
in Respondgnt’s brief—it should be pointed out that the
_ question of: patentable invention had been raised by Dr.
_. Arnold during the pendency of thé interference procesd-

ings; but before it had been disposed of, a license agree-

ment had been entered into between the American Tele-
phone & Telegraph Company and. the General Elegtric

ee - Company, and,' thereupon, the Examiner was so notified.

The question of patentable invention was accordingly not
argued on behalf of Axnold but the brief which had ‘been -
" prepared prior to the license agreement was submitted.

i: Cones, to all intents and purposes, this. question BS

_ when considered by the Law Examiner was academic. This
question having been settled by the Law Examiner with-
‘out further opposition by Arnold, it was not open to any
-. of the other trikunals of tlie Bgecztttraetnn Senyeseesin
Ganesan iaeneuce 0 oner indicates

dl t he ik di t ha 3 fou nd. jee ae CS iN as iat op ae 4 wa
eee tex Be 4, io ie aire ec oa ys hat
Po
é:

© & On-page 27 of Respondent’s brief, ine statement is
o that Judge Woor.ey was incorrect in stating that the
evidence before Judge Morus Was substantially, more favor-
able to Arnold’s contention than the evidence before the

Patent Office: tribinals. Jndge Wépiury was absolu

right. The whole interference record (which comprised -
pode peg ah ay may arg egg was intro-

by stipulation before Judgé Moram. In

ie 1s, produced on behalf of the petitioner, the follow-
evidence which was. not, before the Patent tribunals,

oe Se

ceed

and the failure of the record to contain such was the main

ground upon which the Board of Examiners-in-Chief im the

The testimony of Dr. Becker and Dr. Kelly given in

open court before Judge Morais was entirely new, com- *
; pared with the cage in the Patent Office, and thoroughly

-rebutted Langmyir’s pretense of having made the: -inven- —

tion in 1912, on the Gates assumed for him by the Patent
© Office tribunals that had: decided in his favor.

5. Respondent's brief ‘states (p. 4) that the iesne of:
priority was not one of fact. If Judge Monrnis believed the
testimony given in open court by Dr. Milliken,.Dr. Jowett,:
Dr. Colpitts and Dr. ArnoM, not even the Respondeht can
deyy that.he must have found Arnold Was the prior inven-

_ tor.’ Indeed, Respondent in its brief‘ before the Circuit ©
Court of Appeals contended that these men were not enti-
tled to credence because they were testifying from memory. ~
If there @as-‘not thus presented a question of fact, it is difi- -
cult to coneeive when such an issue can. be presented. -

| 6p, On page 5 of Responilent’s brief, there.is uwoketens i
_ + from the: opinion of Judge Burrinctow wherein he refers '
_ « to the subject matter of the patent in suit as a tube ‘‘known

- eommercially as the ) Langmuir tube’. ‘The tube of the |
@ ~?: Langmuir pattnt. has never. beer known commercially as’ _
the Langmuig tube. ‘This is pointed out in Sudge Woouuey’s ©
BC - opinion (p. 46 of the pamphlet submitted with Petitioner's :
& ____petition and brief) where he states that ‘plaintiff frankly
‘ _s admitted at the argument” that this name had net been «
Be eS SNe eat ie

* ae 7 F
y
Tas se
fully mA
ree rt
Wife 3 Ss
: et *
a
t

APRS ee PRE ERT

POP

_—

/

Pras ar oe fo DN eae

,

EMRE Sk

FILE COPY

: Supreme Court of the United States

October Term, 1930.
No. 630. .

2

* DrForesr Rapro- Company, ne
; Petitioner,

v8. Rare ae

Genznat Siackan Company,
eer:

BRIEF FOR PETITIONER.

7 Tacuia G. ase, ce
_v Samunu E. Daney, a
* Counsel for Petitioner. .

As
0

Cart A. Ricxmonn, —

/Wuiiam R. Baran, yk 2

- Of Counsel as to ‘Point III’’ 2 eae
and the ‘related part of
Point Vv” only.

& uradition-— ae — pees

Statement of the Cane. arene oi asp eal

«

, Subject Matter Involved 1. «: :

What the Patent Purports to Cover...
Scientific Principles: fnvatyed.- nee 2 ee

Tonization. and Its Effect... i

The Methods of Getting High. Vaenum_

: History of the Langmuir Application —

- Arnold Interference ; Le EPI te lopment

_ Summary of ‘Argument — sce ace

Argument. :

. oe e
sighs
: °

ii

* 3

The Lack of Invention ‘Over the Prior Art

.: Disclosure as Evidenced by the Attitude

of the Experts of the Telephone sCom-
- pany and the General Electric Company

‘Poir:: iI—The majority opinion of the Court helow
_ sustained the patent on an untrue definition of
the alleged invention

° Gas as a Detector...

Earlier Attempts to Define the Sabin ‘

Terminology : as to Gas Conduction

‘Langmuir’s | ‘Testimony: as to Gas —
tion

The. Prior Art on 1 Conduetion of Blectricity
by Gas .

%

, Point Til—If the sie matter of the patent in-

volves patentable subject matter, then Dr.

oe Arnold was the first inventor are, and not:

Dr. Lanes, the patentee__.
7 onsideration Given Heretofore to

The Supposed Invention Involved in the
. Priority Issue —

°

* | Anwoun’s Worx—Cor pion: and Diselo-
ele sure of the Invention by | at

Wrens ihe Arnold's Disclosure of the
“Invention -

~ November, 1912—Andion ve
| 8 and May "Tribes fe

Be RT ile eh Bad op

‘PAGE.

» + wes
6 od abe
Stee
5
ees
. 3 in
2 i’

PAGE
asin! Did Not Hecoguine the Invention —
“In Anghel, Sgpaning Se Exe ee |

The Augnst Tube Did Not, in Fact, Hi
the Invention * x

Langmuir’s Case After November 1, 1912.

ae . Langmuir’s November Experiments .

+. Phe Coolidge-Langmuir Conzersation in
Lee appre iy ee tb December, 1912 seis eas ey
Langmuir’s Record After 1912.

&

Resumé of Priority

wy

Point IV—The patent is invalid because of gine
knowledge and public use__

_ Facts of Detector and Amplifier Operation.
Facts of This Defense ; ls

ae aad oe Testimony from Langmuir Bearing on the oh
a Pacts of This Defense.___

Tungsten Cathodes in the California Tubes ! 10

ae “Point V—The present sniafority’ debinion of the ’
ee Court of Appeals has reversed the dispositive -
ae findings of fact of the Trial Court without ad-
vancing any reason therefor, and without men- i :
tion of those facts or the defenses to —_ said ee
were directed —___. is 104

‘Pe oint VI—The saan is invalid ‘becanse of double Gee ee

: a Eee
; > $ hig! Sot ee Y z ee ne os
° anaaat 3 ; “te ELS he
*« ” 4 7 _ . > 2 Hise
bese - par z : oF i Pe A: aoe P “
’ ; ey roy Be pe7 Ege Pe
4 ‘

~

Portland 641 127 Fed. Bae 110

" Palmer Pneu Co. v. Losier, 90 Fed. ane *
~ Pearce v. Mulford, 102 U, 8.122.000 36
- Pittsburgh v. Cowles, 55 Fed. 301. a
oases Plate Glass Co. v. American Window Glass fia

“Railway Co. v. Sayles, 97 U. SD akc ante

gas

20
- Slawson v, Grand Street, 107 U. 8. 649_ Ce 8
| Bpot WelderCo. v. Ford Motor Ch Co,
Fed. 836. 2
¥- Prostar, 102 U, 8.707 a 33 —~ oe

sf

i
ee

p “e Cc of the < ma oes
hie ts 0 potent tafeiageneat sulk | Py ie
Judge Morsis in the: Diatrist: Court et Délaiware: cen
__. dered an opinion which is reported in 23 Fed. (2) 698*
|__ holding that the patent in sit was invalid on three distinat

- grounds. ; a
ie _ (f) Because of, anticipation sad. wes of invention; a |
, question of mixed faét ‘andlaw. 2 is ne
(2) Because of prior invention, nein fc
isted ;—a question of fact. faite

8) Becussd of pice pablld was —o guest of foot.
Nore. Tali asain or le oervin

"Rec, Vol. 8, p18

tan Gin te Ghee Jn etary

of current which was at |

Sis iat
ee

is ins
ter when the vacuum is relatively peor. Respondent itself,
~ atleast until recently, has purposely made its detector tubes:
i a definite gas content.

tor tubes and — or |

€ .
é > ‘ 4
- s * ‘ Aye * . \

£ - PY ll
. / ~- . ‘
. z > 6 ~
*
‘ 5 ne -
<
a ;
4
a aa
+
.
« , . ~
o
5 4 : PES ee me 4

POO

,
e 8,
a
®
: * s
y a
as Q

fed
io ; 4
cent ; :
:
ms
‘ en
; ‘
a 3
‘
| ry : ‘ <
. ¢
. , ; .
*
‘4 def ; ) ; y
BS 74
‘ y x
| :
;
. :
.
aa oe . ,
‘
-
ae)
| ding pee, en

oom’

H

es

pape

Werte tree eirmirrert

. - ee —— en = Te aN eee La ARE
ria
“LA

oe nc Erne

F -- S
e ag
rs _ + a A °
-
. . >
— x . .
i . ~ y
«
;
ve"
* » .
:
Seti ee -
.S “
ps y
“ ‘ ¢
: ¢ he
,
r a ‘
i
se
.
: ive . 3 “ay eae oa
La es
*
“ ~ P. ee
* ‘ ig
. vi*
wr.
(ot
: . ‘
~ a ereewnremnneee tem cee w ; - sqrece. —— as. oe "+ :-S ~ - ba
»
:
.
:
i ‘
s '
a ne Io - ? A %
“ .
S
eo

as the rey Big
Ba Neh

muir patent, ani th: a difference Vatetenk
of evacuation of said

§ : x
- 5

; :

; ;

2
:
3

*]
-

i ion
‘
Mw 7
=
Ss
—- ‘
si
t *
5

4
' ;
{ ; i
2 a
- < {
i ,
~ yan a}
, t :
= Heal enti
: |)
w
’.
+
° : : ‘ans
° > 5 .
2 . i
ta"
WC R, ane 2 pay = > .
i eH at ¥ x ie are
? ; zy eer A
ra 4 ~
t @:
Mik ates ee fe ~
‘
s
ahedtebunbrinanee d at) oy ve, Oo il >) at kh ht ee ee OP Ue? ew wes Oe Ot see Eis
pet
2
+
~
}

{ ~ Are weet :
ad ,
© ’
“9 » 5 J .
‘ ep “ee ‘ :
powers * ~ :
. - > - ~ os *

. + =a , —
2

$ ~
< -
“ 4 - ’
Sods
= eee
n t Ad
iteele ne
} -
B ‘ es
“ .
’
j
i
o
ee
a
+ > so of on
SEs Laas z ret : ‘
: -

hh oe

'
eed

Tr

--

-Abwonce of Novelty in the Characteristics |
‘-of a High Vacuum Discharge, | :

‘We fiud also that the original 8 ion eines, ta to

‘some. extent, the character of the thermionic discharge’
through a wellvevacuated tube, But tha, discharge, itself,

‘even if new in kind, cannot be the invention because it is
_ neither an “art, machine, manufacture or composition of
matter’? whith are the only things patentable under the
. laws of the United States. © Phe discharge, whatever its
“nature, is merely a physical phenomenon. .

Besides, it was not new,—and it, ‘will be well to: hae

- this in mind because’ Langmuir and Respondent ’s counsel

ee a way of refe to his ‘‘new type of Simon as 4

if this were really new. -
“The characteristics of the dvtitins hamed in the orig:
_inal specification * are found on page 8, lines 11 to 27 of the

pe oe ena dg | Fe!
;

my invention fom ie ror ar, i A to detine 8), :

_ patent as issued, and are given, as it says, “In order to dis,

hoe an these dries are summed up in the simple wine.
ae ‘ent that there must be absence of ‘harmful ionisation”, ©
qs this term was employed pierre seine begaireerr
: ‘His statement was. jenesint Ty 3 eli

“How far that evacnaiion has toes why ‘seria ot |
ie pressure is not at all material. The importal a) oS
ae -jpto carry it to a point beyond which it is unneces-_
ary, to go in order to. avoid the harmful ionization: :
he aes jeffecote”?. | i ak glee a

: . shi 14 sl

| The original. DeForest andion gave a a dincharge having
ae ‘ val the wbove listed characteristics when operated in Octo- &
” ber, 1922, below certain voltages, as ‘i evident from Bes s
: - testimony of Jewett, Colpitts and Arnold, con
~Porest’s demonstration. to the Western Electric. Com

ott could. hot have so-beautifully amplified the weak

currents ‘if there had. been any hare ;
- Liliefifeld had discharges satistying all these
: 1 in his 1910 paper.’ Also such |

~ gharacteristics will be present, and 80 on. Langmuir ads
- mits that Lilienfeld had thermionic: discharges “substan
tially free froni the effects of positive ionization’? ;* also
that he ‘had discharges tinaffected. by further lowering of -
the gas pressure in the tube.” Lilienfeld’s “Ceti
es of the order of thourands. of volts.’ ©. - -
‘patentable thing cannot be the particular kind of
defined by the original specification since it is in- —
" herently: unpatentable subject matter, and moreover was
all old. : Sates ote
‘Respondent advanced the ‘pontention for’ the firet time
Korlanteveng aime arcaee pharendigohrebau

_ inventién ley in the substitution of a vacuum conductor for |

_# 0s condtustor. We ‘shall aargery! the prior art on this

'

.

oN ee 29
8 meng of the Laiieinaty patent; no
. There is no dispute about:

liety by the Respondent, as —
brief. No artful articulation of phr

a inherent, natural qualities, can co

? fp abeany

‘Lilienfeld Paper— . pi eieee mas eats
The: The Lilienfeld 1910 Beet p above refered: to, contains

_ lent to describe. elaborate means fr
treme varuuih desired, —

“Lilienfeld states as a characterization of his device:

= om a definite maximum density of the gan | ; fe
downwards. the discharge phenomena are indepen-
dent of the gas density in the ‘region investigated.”

This: is, in simple language, Langmuir’ 2 Afth character.
“gm as above listed (supra, p. 26).
Again he states:

. “Now asa matter of experience it-not only makes
no difference at all whether the cathode is’ very ©
strongly or feebly heated during the discharge pro- ” es
‘vided, ‘of course, that its temperature is high enough =
to insure. its proper functioning. : a

This. te a! ‘uhatacterietic ‘which has been iii referred
‘40 by Langaflir in thin tignjon and isthe asin of hin
patent claims 7 and 24. |

| Lilienfeld made readings of the current pasting through |
"his device’ and the ‘potential across the sounding terminals |
- that he employed, and he plotted his results and deduced his _ ’
_ laws concerning the discharge. ‘He made his plots logarith- -_
oops ye cs tgeabasenehnbepdipattatncns Nadel le

_ Panam s fourth ‘daviciiaila ‘AB above lated, which is,
\./the eriterioni of the patent claims 6, 13 and Ged iciietit Be
‘\? Tt willbe seon from the foregoing, therefore, ‘that the - A
Lilienfeld articles describe not only every. treatment or as

prodbis which Langmuir advances as necessary to produce

- his devices, dbut formulates the same laws, earmarks, or

characteristics, by which a device so processed and vane
may be identified when once produced. er
. jolt fe: unnecessary for us to: speculate as to. the effect ce
‘the disele sure of the Lilienteld articles, for Langmuir has
committed himself with respect thereto in the record of the
a caaé, as we will now show from excerpts of Pageant”

® testimony. It is interesting to note in connection +!

-’ with thdt Langmuir, himself, disposed of Respondent's. con-
tention which apparently was accepted by the snajority of
-—the Court of Appeals, viz., that the term’ “high vacuum’? fs
as tised today means something different : whi Sui se
‘ " meant before Langmuir’s time. , not \ ae
: Lane eed wth referent Lint wo
as follows:* cd: ite

sms “Lilienfeld proved bond ation I thnk ot x

Ne a/

low value, and in somé of his h
his electrodes by elec tror etary Bera
‘*Heating of glass anc electrodes, and exhaustion
_ to low’ pressure are elements which were used
nfe Id and were kxiown long prior to Lilienfeld’s
article ° . ‘ ey
“Factor No.1 which Ten i aniverto XQ86 ;
— tat the bulb’ ane heated during .

“i e ag 10 Ge
hgpire aah

2 os ay eigeurte vet ny a Weenace =

3 ‘ Oy, e au >
Me . " . AT
wy { { 8)
et ; - Sri ne “ aes
t
% %& . a > tf
‘ “wad ‘ aera ah Lk ‘
4 x, 4
. Y ad
i 4 ;
i By cage :
> ; } i
-
\ ee na rf

bie

carbon filament and a perfectly cold metal

;

<@ubry perfect vacuum.”? ! SO ee

He ‘also states (p. wb PR

- The bulb must be bigty exhausted to‘about the’ ;
_ pressure-usual in the case.of carbon filament incan- —
“descent lamps and the meal cylinder ORE OE
: | Wf cade ar? OF y

iat ;

= In the Fleming patent No. 009,604, itis stated ip. 158,
196): Het 8 EPO Oye | pee

eh

8 aR ON Arnok
we =" .
a

he

Again he stated (p. 174):

bell

racuum is said to be low when the original normal —

air *n it is reduced to one-thousandth of an
atmosphere, or it may be only one one three-hun- ©
dredths. It is said to be high when it is a

Ect i aly ean er fre
specified by pnw

os wy ry Ya “on " ak ‘pes
Ncube at +A Bad ii dll

a

” the electron flow and, not ut all upon the residual gas, will

. be referred to later (p, 49 this brief) in discussing Respon-

dent 's new definition of the invention. Accordingly we shall -

“not quote it here. We may, however, call attention to the-
fact,that Watermar.’s testimony was given from. first-
_hand experience with Fleming valves’ He stated that he es
“was familiar wifh these tubes, having used gome supplied
to him by the ‘Marconi Company (owner of. the Fleming ae
patent) which had obtained them from the British Marconi -

- Company, by jvhich they were manufactured under the A
‘Fleming patent.” | :

“From the foregoing we think it clear that the Langmuir

"patent application, especially as filed in the Patent Office, — f

disclosed ng new kihd of vacuum, no new wsthed of: euiae.
ing a vacnum, no new ideas as to the effect of residual gases’ -
in vacuum tubes and no new physical structure for vacuum
tubes. The most that’ can be said is that present-day — ¥.
vacuum tuhes of the kind here said to infringe, ‘are ex-:
_ hanated maine completely thes wore Der oCeeEaeIy NA) :
in order that they may meet present-day commercial. ‘Te
| pit ‘That thisis
‘the limit to what can be said was:

Enos

"held that mere variations ih degree are not patentable: : f
-~ }/Munson-v. New York, 24U.8.601; Tes :
' © Milligan @H. Glue Co. v. Upton, 97 97 U. S. 3, 6; a ‘
_ Pearée v. Mulford, 102 US. 1125. |
Guiduet y. Brooklyn, 105 U.8..550, 552;
Slawson v. Grand Street, 107 U.'S.649;
. Estey v. Burdett, 109 U. 8. B38, 640;
‘Burt v. Evory, 133 0, § 349; &
_ French v. Carter, 137 U. 8. 239; ee)
| Ansonia Brass & Coppet Co. v. Electrical Bupply eS
~— Go., 144. U. 8. 19; # ss
Belding factisring Co. v.. ‘Challengé: Comm
“Plater, 152 U. 8. 100, ie :

. The sole ‘cision to this ute j wie the sintin in-dé :
a epee produces ‘some Wholly. uneSpected mesult causing the :
—— to function in an entirely different maniney. oe
s Tule e and not — Seoption — in the ages

aoe gages

Se ee all:
2 4 aA Pee . : a if ee 7 .
- ° EJ 4 ae .. + : ZB e

Its, perfect performance in amplifying the speech cur-- ee

rents is proo} positive that there was no harmful tomization, — os
or use is theultimate boat: on this a. from. which
”- there éan be no appeal... Ate :
There is no question, therefore, thai this’ prior xt alia ‘
operated precisgly as the ‘patent says. the patented tubes» >
+ ” should operate, i. ¢., by a grid-controlled space chargevffect
substantially unaffected by positive’ ionization. .. And. no -
matter how far up along the scale of: improved vacuum we
go we cannot get’any other kind of performance. than that.
- ‘The advantage of improving’ the vacuum lies not in getting — :
‘a. new kind of per ormance but in getting more of the same —
. kind,. That, is, instead of getting this: amplification with
~~ only a ittle electrical power, we can get it with a large -
power. The patent itself, both in the specification and the
claims} ‘teachts. that very. thieg and speaks ‘much more
loudly than’ Respondent’s counsel when they try to assert,
without supporting evidence, that there is some sort of gro
ae point or dead-line between the DeForest amplifier perform-
- ‘ance and that of more highly evacuated: tubes. The ane
he cation of the patent, as we have already noted supra (p.
* * 20), sayg that the degree of. evacuation. will be proportionéd -
: to the voltage it is desired. to apply to the tube, and the
- aims’ describ invention as including tubes perform-
ing at voltages all the way from 40 up. to 200 or more.” ‘As
- shown“above (p. 98) DeForest. audion amplifiers were op-
ited at voltages up to 50 and 60 volts. The patent claims
ght just as well have begun at:30 volts instead ex
What Langmuir sought to do was to patent the use o ,
uum tubes at any and all voltages above what he hen
new was being uscd. mae toes a Cm

tow

SO 3”,

1G S ewbe dna add a claim numbered 25 directed to cover 2 . tube
- deprived of sufficient gas to permit its tise with 30 volts.‘ a
‘This claim was canceled July 30, 1925,° after he had appar. «
‘ently learned that andions had been used with 30° volfs:
He no doubt had no knowledge of the practice i in California
"of using as high as 67% volts or he would undoubtedly have.
~~, eanceled all claime for use of voltages ‘below that anfount. —
‘In. this connection, Respondent relies, heavily: upon an :
iets statement or two of DeForest expressing the view
that the operation of his audion was in some way affect “I
‘by the residual gas. Well, DeForest was wrong (except i a
- the extent that the detectors are even’now considered some-
= what-better with # gas content): For a long time, it is likely, ©
he did not altogether understand the scientific explanation
of ‘his own invention; and it was not required that he.
should. But that does not change the facts as now clearly
® established by the evidence. Respondent will admit that =|
_ even Languiuir made some very seriou’ mistakes in connec-- |
= tion with the.very patent application here involved, 8 some _-
of which we haye already pointed out. aed
+. Since, then, the tubes now asserted to infringe operate |
Tike: the old DeForest tubes except asyto the amount of
power some of them can haridle, we think it clear that the
" “patent, ever’ considered in its most favorable light, is invalid -
a as covering a mere difference i in oo of vacuum: Bt

‘Rec, he aes 736. es

“

. , Bis ’ aeglig 2
. x “ ‘ Si Tami

- The Lack of Invention Over the Prior Arts
Ls Disztoeurc= 2s Evidenced by the Attitude —_
_ -@ff the Experts of the Telephone Company
| and the General Electric Company. | | oa
ee. tosthe- questior whether the tube of the seiea in ‘euit | ay
presents any invention in view of prior art, we find: a most
unusual situation, and one of ‘¥ery persuasive force. The .
thing which is now asserted tobe a wonderful and important ;
invention was separately produced in 1912 and 1913 by two -
- eminent engineers working in this art for two large indus- __
. trial companies—Arpold of the Western Electric Company vis;
‘ and the American Telephone and Telegraph Company
and Langmuir of the General Electric Company—and
neither one of them thought at the time that he had made
and invention at all. Langmuir claims, to have produced a
tube of the kind covered by the patent before: the end of
1912. He did not file an application for patent until latein’
- 1913, and. then even, tt did 1 not occur. to. him to claim sucha
: tube as his invew!con. ‘He ‘claimed merely a specific process a
for exhasting gases from: the contained electrodes (boms S
-sbardinent without heating). Arnold pr ced the same a
kind of tube in the Fall of 1912. Neithar hé nor those asso-
ciated with htm in the Western Hlectric. Company and the __
Telephone Company thotight of looking upon. itasaninven- _
_ tion, and no application for patent upon it would have ever
been filed by Arnold, had it not been learned that the Gen-
s eral Electric Company was attempting to patent. such a ' is
. tube in Langmuir’s name. Arnold, convinced of his own — ae |
= then filed an application 80 that ifa patent was to” |

Seo

an

Waited Sen

“fesired | load’ witho gas ionization, and it is quite ex
- that it seemed to each them that in so doing he had m

of claiming such a tube as an invention
when someone awoke to the possibility. of con

[ omungamemnamneen omens la ee
Paneer:

Appeals, ccna told the Court that E
‘tion was. @ tube in which he substituted a ¥
_ “eblumn “of conducting gas’” upon which the |
- DeForest vacuum tubes depended.’ © A
“This was a brand new definition of
presenting it to the Court below,
_mebnt, we think, to assert that the

PRR ARO OYA BF vem note? wore

me fos of Langmuir himself. 38° >.

‘ t
v

“Langmuir tobe is a tube in which for éeampi® the gascous

conductor incidént to a Fleming valve and a DeForest
, audion is dispensed with and a vacuum substituted there-

for’’, and upon the assumption that this was true, it found _

_ that. Lengmuir-had made a patentable invention. . Indeed,
- if we-accept the definition, patentability. follows almost as‘

( the same or a better result by removing one of the elements’

is the very sort.cf thing accepted as involving

ee he See “@ simple’ and striking’ accomplishment °
nt expect a ready allowance from the Patent. Office,-

“But this definition is false, and with it must fall the :

entire theory upon which the Court found the patent valid.
_ It is contradicted by the whole history of the Langmuir.
patent in the Patent Office and in this litigation, by undis-
puted scientific facts as to dischanges in-vacua, and by the

brake sed ner dd it be

> @ matter of course, for to take an old combination and ro

© . ; F

the claims, and a total of sixty- two differentclaims weré sub-—
: tn a ater inn in orto aad he ora
and to define a patentable invention. The changes involved *
: in the repeated re-writing of the description of the inven-_.
‘tion, bulk one and one-half times the originaf specification.
If the invention had been:the sumple, clear out thing we are
now told it is, Langmuir would not have begun im 1913 by

sae

claiming an inoperative process of gas-freeing. electrodes,

en and ended wp in 1925 with thirty-two claims to something —

defined by references to a 3/2 power law, logarithmic plots
and ‘flat-topped temperature curves. He would haye-re-

b Gr Gnde cans tan padion, bx kaa A
pe Cree /
- sented to the Patent Oli i

"Interferences stated 2 iG . So weil
“4 contovorey ha aren to ot what

He SFr
3 anne,

. eeivaPhis patent in short order, and it would have had two

iy4

BR evs Of pa tugee
a ebi ies
* is NA Vay Hee,
“as ¥ Pera. ry yh Re

mshi be uly

ep

—— rb ei

"i

{ rage ee gy as hp
Mee As iat a Me: ersten

«ht
o ;
: .
. ™
;
>
2 ri
s
¥. . ’

Heh -

i pained my

2

| ste
Cie Phin ¢
we Ts hs

C
pak
¢
&

nology,. pect time ahs ed
SSS

“tase ina el dt he ra
wine ee rene ae rh a
when there was enongh-to cause ionization, was not a we
‘sduetor”? of the current. coh: ooh es, #
ewer gat2end epRopaeie AE mt

this patent, as first filed, made the mistake (as
aa oe le
as @ conductor. Ce te oan ae

ge last cers ¢ »

tthe positive ions -take part in the conduction of current ;
“by acting as conductors or cearriors of current.” The
'. anywer he gave was; ° ;

‘In my opinion¢he sceitans Seed ahekas Week
ble meaning if the word ‘conductor’ was left in for
it is inconceivable that ions could be condtletors of Che
% current. I will, therefore, confine myself tothe case
where the positive ions act as ‘carriers.’ -With this
_ correction I can say - that nse statement would not
have been true.”’

' Note that Langmuir says that it is not ss gensibie” to ‘ise,
the word “‘conductors’’ as referring to the ionized mole-
i cules of the gas, because ‘‘it is inconceivable that ions could —
ae Ss conductors of current.”’ Thus he reje
the use of the word “conductor” as | the.
. the sense of: Rogpondent’s belated dettaition And he goes
on to say that evén construing the word conductor to mean
patho still the statement is not, true... : eae
|. * ‘With R@spondent’s own witness Langmuir, the patenien Be
Sie himself, -thus positively denying that the gas content, even”
wheh ionized, is a conductor of the current in a vacuum
+. tube, we do not see how. at can, be pan cae :
ae the contrary. This seems to us itself entirely to dispose Y
of Respondent’ deventh hour definition of ms. invention

"perature of the deisel ; the
a. of Papacy a a. vacuum. oan bet

‘In this same paper he says that by certain
is able to show that the highest vacuum pi
#5 very good conductor’, and describing. the.

-- hapepergeheneen deen ee Be

“Let this bulb be exhausted as ©

e, so that in it the high aur
made. To achieve this, the flaments must be hee =
_ to bright eandeecenes while the exhantion ing

PHELAN

tronic, ar an ‘ation which gives us : h
result of electrons” emitted from the filament, ant
hot as. the result of any matter contained in the

space surrounding the filament. ”” ai

is that’ the action which takes place is an elec-.
action just as Fleming said it was, and as most
* of { e writers agree with this, and that is shown by
"ab Tus ORE Cha punto nothin place tly ty

oe -_ bulbs we notice that’ the blue are or siteede ben
cc eierieceaideniy at 1b0% Vela
~ tion the bulb is not sensitive” ' :

| . nd the following month he wrote:

Bee can, 2. os SR Look twa of the poorest of the dincarded 20
, “to a San Francisco glass-blower, ‘wnxnown to fame,

pine a? and had him exhaust same to as high a vacuum.as as,jis”
pumps: :would take. a reexhausted bulbs now |

. show.a sensitiveness eq ‘those of the first four;

Be 4 which proves eanolusively our ranean ie wor
ee . rect. 93 .o

coe - Respondent's own SS ig. testified concerning |
_ tthe DeForest tubes in a suit brought: by Hewitt against the
American Telephone and Telegraph Company, and he reaf-

. Sead and adopted that testimony in this recofd.™ ‘The.
eS “Telephone. Company was using high vacuum tubes corre-
“ sponding entirely to those asserted here to infringe. Hogan
having testified that he was familiar with the DeForest
ian was peked. to state how they ee the Tele

ip aa to the. aula of defendant’ 8 vacua
ae st a and the audions of DeForest, I believe that the.
__. residual gases must,play some rs rt in the opere

A doolalpegttsnd pe i part

: _ Yoltags and exhanation ao and that there ein nd 3
__ strict line of demarcation between them. — : ee

st ARS 8h NE EC Rte, ih aa

" Deft.’s Ex. 79A, Rec., Vol. 6, p.. 1061,
“Bec, Vol.1,pp-101-118

“Tubes made by the detendint's’
2 pity) and audion tubes made by DeForest ampli:
MaaT de pet Citak eae Youeke vay one it toes
_one side ‘of the fence and say, ‘They are ¢
‘and the others on the other side of the fence and

is
if
;
a
Ls
i
if
i
’

es

7

aa ed

Oo

RL ER ENT Be ET a

et ee are

am

os

o

-guppésed 3 biessian is, However, Siti tie See oe |
- shall consider below, it will be quite clear that whether it.

be ‘asstated in_the eleventh hour: presented by
"Respondent at the rehearing, or what the Commissioner
an “Patents said he would assume it to be for: he purposes 0

poses of deciding ealcathn sacneienl * ns allasiil es:

: 1 wil be soot thatthe present inedation lies not
in diseovering ‘or producing something rte in
perceiving the practicability of siggftific facts known .
in the laboratory, and in m “ P ee
devices embodying. the sciep ite
os laboratory’’.“* >

When we come to sua'sthdenes ts Galea: oe
become clear that what both Arnold and Kangmnit actually

ORR EONT TEN HH SEES
© the application of certain known facts concerning ther

_ talonic discharges-in vacua. :
eM: ‘The sizuple fact iw that, under ony definition, am old
7 isa t'collice: pmigied n.\ukein abba, ectpesitiigan’ se
_ the walls and electrodes, is a tubé of the Langmuit patent;
~ ue othe, change is necessary. ‘Phere is no dispute sbout ©
ag this,—it is admitted by the Respondent’ am
z Sh nlomenges orp pe tentab
-_. to the newcomer in the field (Corona Cord Tire’ Cav, Devan

* Chemical Corp., 276 Ts 8: $58).

- * See page 35, ante. —

Fee
eee | a:
5 #

tli OE ee tae

-

cae the i ceadlaibacing subsidiary of the ‘tonkee Compattyy
- Under Dr. Jewett was ‘Dr. E. H. Colpitts, directly m ch irge
eo a the Research Laboratory of the Wester Electric Com- © :
»- pany. In-more recent years this laboratory has been sepa-
. * rately organized as ‘the Bell Telephone Laboratories, oo
Ine.”’. Both Dr. Jewett and Dr. Colpitts were highly Pro. ote
- ficient as telephone engineers, and as theoretical and practi: a2
cal physicists." Under Dr. Colpitts was Dr, Arnold. oe
os . For nearly two years prior to his conception. ot “~ :
Le tly invention, Dr. Arnold had been working upon this
+ telephone repeater problem for his employer. and had. about:
perfected a very: ‘satisfactory, though comparatively ‘com-
plex repea/er element.of.the vacuum type using mercury —
vapor’ On- November 1, 1912, he first saw a DeForest -
gudion’ sét up—an_an- amplifier. ‘DeForest himself hed
"brought ’the apparatus to the Western Blectrie Company
two days earlier and demonstrated it to Dr. Jewett and Dr.
- Golpitts, officials of that ‘Company, in the hope of selling —
i rights under his patents to the Company. Both Dr. Jewett
. and Dr. Colpitts were electrical engineers of high standing
"nd Jong experience, and were quite capable. of appreciating — oe
* the virtues and defects of the audion, but they did not kas
what the defects were due to or how to. mmedy then

a,

ee
Sprig “

yes

Pod

gg

*
Bape

iw

®

no ae
Ye

3 BOF

tH.

epithe tite

@

signeated with a substantially perfect vacuum. |
“about in this. way». Colpitts questioned whether the elec-
trons would be emitted from the hot filament, if the acuul
were substantially perfect, that is he ques : vh
‘some gas might not be necessary for the
electrons. Arnold: informed ‘him ‘that this question bad
= been faced and settled by the scientific world, and that elec-
- trons undoubtedly would be emitted from the hot, cathode
jn the absence of gas.. Colpitts went on and: ques
_ Tarther why the electrons, if emitted, would not all easily °
push across. the space when only 4 volt or so of positive —
potential was applied t6 the plate; thus keeping the power
__-taitpat of the tube too low to be useful., In other words, if
- the electrons were emitted so easily why- should any ‘con.
_ sideraule voltage be necessary merely to move’

“the empty space from the hot cathode to the cold 04
dn reply to this question Arnold explained to him the eve
~ charge effect, the mutual repulsior a “the: eh ‘2
by which those ahead in the stream tended to. |

ae

back into the hot cathode, whence they *

: vacuum: fore e were wrong: both on the law and the

duce porns ‘pated invention. ‘The oscil construction
may, an and Hrejuantty will, require a —— known ba

ei: sie ta erect sais abba pubes inventions of all i:
__ time, invalid becanse, forsooth, DeForest was not a ?
blower and ‘so not himself possessed of the skill or knowl.
_ edge necessary to construct the thing?

If the inventor also devised a now method of ‘manu- ©
. facturing the. device, that would be a ‘and’ separate

beta igacal 0
‘The Commissioner noted and.

omy

by

‘

ag.
taka

7: ; :
: “a Ae
i
.
Sp
‘\ . ‘
\ 5 ty
Vera :
i |
ae
2 “sh
; :
{
}
|
rT, » {
's ¥ 2
& >
ae 4 x
: p> OR
iY a}

&

ages. pe tue asia ak ae Magn toe
the license from DeForest. having been secured near |
_ end of the preceding July. Rs ae
asa considering this ‘work, it it should be pnennerel ©

peater, not merely a | tube embodying the supposed inven-

tion here in issue.° There is a big difference, It would have
__ been very easy for him with his then knowledge and e 3

>
+
a

LS

80 that it would have embodied every claim i in n the J
muir patent, and still. it would have been far from |

ency, of the Audion”, which was recorded by his
Pierce. More particularly, this was’ “a precise

E A which slight variations of voltage in the: grid circuit pro-

“Que corresponding, but much larger, variations of current
in the plate cirenit), It was the first calculation ever made —
by anybody of how an audion works. This study was pre
“mised definitely on the assumption of high vaeyum,’ When i
the theoretical part, of the study was completed, Arnold —

Ae direotéd Pierce to make comparison with an actual case: of
a8 amplification of voice currents. This wes dns with Andie
os Vag and the agreement was remarkably close." =)

: This piece of work shows Arnold’s penetrating undoes ae
—. standing of the principles of the high veguum audion and
_ is one of the many items of. his activity. falling between hie

ae conception of the invention and: its introlentoon: into com-
i mercial use, NG

_ 4 new Gaede sindiciadwe pump. pny saieied: we gee, aS
_. from Germany at his request i in January, 1913, after he had —
_ failed to locate one in this country. From. January ass
- April,’one of his assistants, Trimble, was working on the

mechanical construction of tubes, experimenting with tan-

‘mechanism might be ready when their own

of the law of the marvelous “grid” effect by :

cglpargubeinipeeseyoyictor | ad

Ree Vol” 2, p. ci, £990; cs ee
Vol. 1, p. 614, QOL,

<

-talum ae ole and. another saviabat 3 — was tad

71

- 913. Bxperiments with oi iguleaiasbieaaaiaes i,
the toll lines between New York and Washington were begun. Be

at Philadelphia, September 5, 1913,° and a field trial under
: commercial service conditions was begun October 18, 1918."
* Guch repeaters have béen in continuous and increasing use

ever since, The following eteane 108 OR are ‘

new trans-continental telephone line. ;
. During this period from November, 1912, to Died
1913, while the DeForest audion was being converted into.
condition suitable for a commercial telephone repeater, -
there were at least three occasions, probably more, When
there was an ectual reduction to practice of the, high
vacuum improvement here in issue, Once in November
_ -when a ‘‘clean-up’’ of the residual gas was effected inne
- of the DeForest tubes (‘‘7-A Audion’’) ; again in April and ee:
May, 1913, during the try-out of the new Gaede. pump when
_ @ number of the.andions evacuated showed good vacuum
ahd no ionization effects under high voltage teste; ano
again in Sepfember and October, in tubes built for and |
used in commercial service at Philadelphia. = ie
x It really makes no difference at all which of these dates Ba
is considered Arnold’s date of reduction to practice, for he °
2 was abundantly diligont at all times from November 1, 1912, -
on; so that under the familiar rule,* his effective-date of

invention in any case booumes November 1, 1912, when the og

, Maprovement was conceived. -
a ie: refer briefly to each of these occasions.

oe a ~ Intert. Ree., ees 2257, middle, Dias ae
- ‘Interf. Rec.

- ebggar even ie anv he pr eods

: Pg howd eyeing ich mo pres,
Before the Diatet Cour). o oe hil Bees

of
. agi % -
. ;
G
’ 4 £
*
ie t
:
e ;
3
id
> a
.
;
vi
; ;
. -
i
. ‘
:
-
; |

ah

Awe >

.
te ee
Me
” ‘
w > oi
~~
+
4

=e

An eee ene ee

}
\

res

a:

ioe

ee eh
eas

tk

+

ig

i ~ €

oe

- * “
° .
.
°:
bd .
i weak ao
¢
“a ‘
- ?. dl
.
“* ° . f
s = :
+ ,
‘
' -
" oe
4
> .
’
:
Lf ’
ad
. -

nena tem tl apa aig

‘yepeator was switched in on the line bain York and
Washington’ for regular commercial service. This was n.
~ October 18, 1918, and since that date the co: ommercial ‘use
of high vacuum audions as telephone ‘repeaters has never |
been interrupted, and has expanded enormously. re
“Most of the tubés which first went into service in the
- telephone plant in September, October and November, 1913,
_ have, naturally, been lost or destroyed. ‘Three, however, og
were found and put in evi ence, and original data on one re
- other sufficient to show its character, are in evidence. The /
. three tubes in evidence are Audior 6. i, 64 and 100, ork
* the other tube is Audion 9.111.” dite dy ok ©
= ag "hese tubes, were evacuated? with the Gaede molecul
8 pump, baked, glowed and the’ electrodes bombarded jus
'. with the tubes of April and May, gbove referred to s¢
“09 paadaambbad aniston anon bs be 7s

; tion’ “of this patent. ‘The patent itself points out ea
" remoWal of gas is to be proportioned to the use to. which the
tobe i is to us put, and that tebe from: erratic operation 4

| measurements of their vacuum taken before the trial show
~ one and a half hundredths of a micron for the fret ane

refull made by. a penta approved by Dr. ;
fully described. on the stand by Dr. Kelly. ,

late Beg SM

| upward of 100 volts with a pure el
i. i ialiminee qiaek ek 4
‘ampere or more for tube 100.° These are
a
the patent, as for example claims 26 and 29.
| natargmplilenipansessice cc :

"At varios times Reopuadest hs uingSd-raslegewesoaad
me Arnold should not be awarded priority.
the petition for reargument in the Circuit Court of.
_ allcof these reasons were abandoned but one:
"therefore in this brief refer only to this reason.
_ toa demonstration by one, Richards, of the W
_ trie Company to some company officials in ei

. in which he used DeForest andions instead of

evacuated tubes made by Arnold, the arg

T chy. sachudat b eietecas ad eae eeipeaal deinen area

geueenh has

i «
. Z F ‘
,
‘
wi > a
i % :
~ 2 — i
: ‘ * +
¢ ‘
: « esr
. ‘ - t pes
3 s4 ; hone : s
Gane y j
.
¥ wed s
: ; ° pa ey

°

o
—

=
Ps

Vy.
Z >’,
. ™
v4
7;
7D 6
>* .
.
Re
.

+

ta)

_ \ secured by such a discharge prior to N. ovember iE 1912, nor.

~~-nized the rectifiers, like detectors, work better with consid-
3 - erable. residual gas. But if true, it would -make no differ-.
ence, “The only in.portant inquiry is whether Langmuir

y 2 |
* “ ° * 84 a’

\ ing * vacuum tubes: for amplifying, ete. ‘There is > nok one
nal word of evidence in the whole record that Langmuir had.
any conception of ‘this, or any other useful result tobe

for Some time thereafter. ! .
: Our opponents argue that the tube Languiate then ‘haa

- colitd have been used for rectifying alternating, currents on
with improved results. ‘This is not true because it is Tepog- i

then récognited such alleged £ fact. His. —_ above an
quoted, answers that. ; ee
So no matter what the August work was, iy is of no
3 consequence here. ENN ye

ey

\ oA

| “Tap Auguit Tube Did Not in | A Wo
__ Fact Embody the Invention. ee ‘a

| ut evidence taken before the Trial\Court which waswol. |

re the Patent Office shows that the August tybe was,

not an instance of “‘pure electron discharge. sub- -

laims,—mucl Jonas example of the application of such a
ins ré gs toa wpfal purpose that even had Langan

ec = : He ie ie wrong. "What it really indicated w

igieng | of the space charge effect, —still gceaily & affected ©
‘~ by ionization.’ “Space charge alone means nothing. It is

>. not even mentioned in. Langmuir’s original application.

“Respondent admits that the old DeForest audions had it.”

. Only when the. space charge is substantially unaffected a

positive ionization does it begin to have any significance —
here. It is upon-the substantial absence of ionization that

the original application repeatedly iiaists,-and upon ve

a tubo is shown first by the very ‘fact ‘of the sudden ¢

ese Arnold insisted in his November Ist disclosure... — aS
uif’s

¥

‘The presence of substantial ionization in the A a

ef current’value and also by the fact; shown by Langm
_ own. data, that every reduction i in gas pressure thereafter

es __was-followed id “hy a further’ drop in current.’ Also Becker -
testified that he. duplicated this experiment and then con-
tinned to reduce the gas pressure in steps toa really good

ak vacuum, and he found thatthe. current continued to fall,—

“as the gas was removed-—, to about one-half or one-third . :
* of what it. was soon. after therdrop. Langmuir stopped .
. when it had decreased only 20%. ‘This shows beyond ques-
tion that Langmuir’s dinanis was very materially af-
oe oF Po tee Seeiention” iss es : ee
_ Langmuir also points to a logarithmic plot ot two pitta: ae
taken in two different runs, at 250 and 200 praia ee =

aq ey tively,* as indicating that the discharge was su be
S “gael by. ionization because, as he are the ine of the

’

— Vale P. 188, 7 an vi Fuse ee at er |
san i vein ee

pe tHe f

~~ getid in that paper, ‘This difference is certainly due to ree

» mitted, after nei re that the stati aes through mer
- points was 1.83 rather than 1.5,° and that plotting just those |
Boe points didn’t have* much significa: nce anyway !* ae
_ Moreover, in his ‘Physical Revie ? paper of Decem-
bs 1913, page 470" Langmuir exhibited a logarithmic plot
of an experime run with d vacuum tube of like character
_ which showed a large number of points, giving a slope of.
171; and comparing this, with the theoretical 1.3 slope he.

sidual gas’’; yet he ‘asks the Court to believe that a plot of.
- two points showing a slope of 1.83 with « a “tube of the. —
_, Had: motnene gen effort! * ; iy yes )
It does not seem to us heceanaty to discuss the Xueot A
work any further. _.
Sopa admits that he did not then oe what sort

pileeadigh albeted bs tintin. And it is not
Saieed tat bo Nien thought of applying suck «

eee pur

- have ane after November A 1913, ‘ean ‘give him » prinity 4 :
because it is too late. - g Ree
tee to the priority i issue, we might logically rest our case
here. Seat |
There are, however, one or two things ne ‘Noweai:
Ist-in Langmuir”s. story which show so clearly-that he ¢ lid

le

wot have the inyextion until. a much later date, that. we |
os take nee. to refeg 0 them ssieaines Ney oe | e 4

- Between the 18th, and 22 a of November, 1912, ‘tae

muir made some wiore ex riments on tubes generaily
similar to his August tube,—i e., with two electrodes, both |

_ filamentary. This time, however, he was watching changes
. in the Edison current as the filament - temperature. was
changed,’ rather ‘than the clean-up effect upon the gas.
‘He made the» experiments because Richardéon, the great
ee authority. on, thermionic discharges, was coming to Sche-"
Ga | and Langmuir wanted. igs dacs
an chet of the Aceaeenin _— involved”.

"that they aired in’ his mind the faintest tina of 2 mY
idea that these oe could be turned to a definite use- aes
ful purpose. . |
i cspacaiees ltimself says that the experiment were andr a

taken

ape,
’

1 - . in. order to pete an 5 Aaah of the .
fundamental laws involved, and thus settle once for —
. +‘ all whether or not pure electron currents could be —
obtained in a preeeeny ree Meyers NE aS

“eee with: “the object of sibiailae the ind
“tron: emissior from tungsten filaments in the bent

cal ‘sua or at lenat, a very good vacuum’,

“ty was his state of tind befage the expertmanta
What was it afterward? At the time he Voatified. nthe
“ mterference, he'said’this: - * rp dis on.
8thtae-Iamportance to my mind lay tthe fact r
ee ae ta cece mahaees tiene teristic

3

”

of Richardson and Child; ma and they, like Langu, ba
* noted them simply as scientific facts, ‘

Tt is an axiom of patent law that patentable ee
- lies: in producing practical results ‘in the useful arts, not .

"Plaintiff baa émphasioed an alleged a rere
' invention by Langmuir. to Coolidge on Denman + 10, 1912,
- as to which both men gave testimony. At that date X-ray —
fe Semon nde sail etn ed Cogs
_ entertained the idea of an X-ray tube :

Ph

_ inuerely discovering seientific facts or principles." LeRoy «+ :
-y: Tatham, 14 How, 155-174; Detmold v, Reeves, Fed. Oas.
No. 0, 3831;. Morton v. N.Y. Rye Infirmary, Fed. Case 9865,
At the end of this Noverber work, then, it is clear that
iacsaneen was. not Masses e oP rane eines a

ne

We .
2 ene, .
. + *
BK PSN
_ ‘ als *
Ld 2
74 > .
‘ bs , : e+ og
“ ‘ c
Af
. Vas
. & mn:
‘ Mike ‘
se

ventic : fiat grew ont of it.. Having cect ts
iF Coolidge, the General Hletric Company ea

irate i for ‘Langmuir (post, p. 106)... f
“he theory of the: General Hlectric Company int

‘palgae: was ‘the inventor of the ‘broad: as
—— was the invent®¥ of the X-ray tube.” But a “ned :

eae ; t a certain kind

Aes,

sem ec 1 = oui eden

“ Sn
.

~The time of Langmuir’s actual prises we is pot. ett.
to ‘speculation. His own. revord shows exactly when it”
oth and what it ‘was. And it was, us we have already ‘re-

3 marked, ‘exactly. the thing Arnold had conceived some:

eat segue namely, a | DeForest audion with a better
“vacuum, :

~ Langmuir got stv first canine easly in Fobruary, 1918,
a put: ‘White to- studying it." Some’ ‘two weeks later they
were testing one of their own make but found that even
the 0.1 micron vacuum. they had would not ‘stay put’—

_ apparently becuse gae poured out e. tte clectrodes when

‘ in aoe
a “Phen after about a sich more of groping he sees
the light, and writes i in his note book under date of of MY

4, 1913:

“Now what I intend to x fi to ‘Basie an‘au-

So eres
eaten of hin atone op the

\ ~

‘Avention prior to November x 1912; is shown not. nity
by the failure of his proofs as to thht period, but by
positive evidence. from his own note books: :

Ke ry

keer armnrenday Ad A

per “Rayo et esr graony RRB NO EERO:
¢ " bled wnt ep velany: taper a i wotsich 7h olitaial tin ,

os eh

RS @ the f 1 te
oe a8

7% te", ‘"

M . r re -, ‘ , aS ie
Wie hoe ke eat

. *
me 7
ry . 5
? JS f - ory 4
. : . : : fea
; { ae ; ; tod a #
° e \ VS) veay
~ ;. \ ale
; | ~ ary
‘ ‘ . ' fat! : eT
> ‘ TAR
We
93 .

goncsived, for with date June 18, 1914, he records an effort’
» extending over several days, the culmination of -weeks of . i
» ° preparation, the object being to effect a wireless telephone =”
transmission between Schenettady and Pittsfield, less than

50 miles. All that was accomplished was that a portion of
the phrase *‘Hello, White’’ was heard at one time.” It was ~
in April, 1916, ten months later, when ‘the ‘Proposed
Demonstration’? was carried out and oe a ae Sa

| be
ry

g his products to Arnold and his associates.” It Nay

' yemembered, that the Arnold’ tubes had been used
‘ gially by the. TelephonesCompany beginning in ¢
1913, and that they were actuaily used in the.first tz

\ :
: 7

4

\
be De thas appears trae te overwhelming weighit of Re’ i

- evidence (some of which was not before the Patent Office ° ”

Opry
‘
vas
ae Pex...

‘

, tinental telephone line in the summer of 1914. ”

ae als) that Dr. Arnold conceived the alleged invention -
"of the patent arid disclosed it to others on November 1, 1922,
-. and thereaftor used due diligence in redifting it to praet x
-' ‘go that’ by the following October, tubes embodying *
-\glleged*invention of the patent were in commercial hse a
graph Company, ‘and in the following yoar were use

fe
shh
:

% x ; 4 ‘ « ae ¢ . . «i
: XS as : a 7. - ce . ¥ te
a abs ret “ie '} 4 : : $ ; . ig
: t $ ae * : : dd eee ie . 4 ©
* . : s . 5 $008 ie .

“seat NEE in a ssinlinalte perfect peniin’ ti Adee:
~ he discovergd that they could be so obtained, he apparently
conceived i useful purposes therefor ‘until March, 1913; —
- when he wrote in his notebook that he intended, ‘to con-
struct an audion which will operate entirely and exclusively
‘on tke electron discharge’’. . Moreover, although the Arnold °
“ repeaters ‘were being used in commercial telephone lines
in the fall of 1913, and ithe transcontinental line in the.
-summer of 1914, the first practical thing’ we find done by
- Langmuir with his tubes, was the attempted wireless tele-
S phone transmission: of less than fifty miles. in Jun¢ of 1914:
- where only. a part of the phrase ‘*Hello. White’ was heard, —
It is clear therefore:that if ‘the Lengmuir patent dis.
closes any, invention of a patentable nature, Arnold was the
| first inventor $d, not Langmuir, The Larigmuir patentis° =
‘obviously invalid for oe aie as was held by Sodge me
Morais and Judge W 7) |
The majority heiting Pe Court, of Apuedie did not -
advance any reason for a ‘different eondlusion ‘as’ to the ~ .
‘effect of Arnold’s. work, nor point: outPany error in the 2
‘@pnelusion of the lower Coury x nor criticize its reasoning. « - :
The Court of Appeals, was'in error in: not upholding —
hasicouact d oiahiede and. should be. soles that eee:

HEY

? j te ue \
; =] 5 ~
ty a: Cee f ‘ \% .
Pe eee a as te £.
i 5 . “ to *)
‘ bates ’ 4
- sabe ‘ a o z ‘4 ¢
Py Mey ee ae: 4 : ¥ :OFe .
= eas uate g SRA ON , ‘ ; Rc
Se % me y ‘ aie > . 2 te 4+
eee Bair ; ae . os Ve ty
Oe - $ a Spe my Seek * “4 ae
ais ay te eiht Vases ‘rbot 8 ZG
be orcies © Be ENS <
° : . ” ee
Be ates oe eae os :
eo i \ FEE ap _ 7
BS tg Se , Y o
ot &Y ae c

Se eae POINT Iv. eae
: = ‘The patent is invalid because: of prior nowledae

éd

“ PRis defense was sustained by the District Coiirt and by
J udge ‘WooutEy, and is not referred to in the majority —
or of the. Court of Appeals. Sy eee al

me

oe

a,

Facts of. Detector and Amplifier Operities. ee | |
- As ® ome defense, the established facts are as ‘follows: oe

me Be Tt is s abundanily shown by the reoord (and stated i in
* the Langmuir patent) that the ordinary DeForest audion —
_ detector was recdgnized as. a gas-device and as such. had an _
Ne - ioffizing voltage of about 25 volts. It was and i is therefore, _
' gustomary to use. the same with an impressed re of

| approximately 22% volts? ae
o eS When voltage very slightly: above ionizing voltage .

(25 volts) was impressed tipon the ‘DeForest attdion de-"

tector, it would “blue glow’’.-

fe mee... The use of an. audion ag in ssid ces
ae ay * to mete | 1912, the —: te claimed by Lang- -

oS aeartir ie ne very slightly above! the ionizing voltage, -
es thre amplifier becomes inoperative.’ . a te ee

: 1 Hogan was never able to use oa an 3
.. “an andion detector prior to 1914; XQ46, p. 100,
s ——_ ee. * see Vol. . me

2 Ome as 6
“all of the foreqoitix facts are not only conclusively estab- er y

: - lished, but are undisputed. a) 9 re 4 e :
—-}t-is perfectly obvious at the outset, therefore, that if
an audion tube was used or was capable of being used as an
amplifier with voltages over 25 or 30 volts, if was so used
or capable of being: used only because the. gas in the tube
“had been evacuated to a degree’which would permit the use
of siete higher voltages.

> °

x

"Facts of This Defense. EtG oct a a we :
. The facts of the California use may be bricly narrated
‘as follows: pee ss /

3 The Eedéoral Telegraph Company of California, for wt
-_ whom Dr. DeForest was working in 1911 ard 1912 (until ~.
Ie’ September of that year), was engaged i in the commercial. -
' transmitting and reception of radio messages. This work
included the employment of audion detectors. as. well as
" audion amplifiers. The amplifiers were ‘‘tliree stage ampli- —
”, i. @., three audion amplifiers connected in serigg ‘or oo
- tandem. . The audion ‘tubes used as. amplifiers were distin-
_ guished ‘from and classified apart from audions used as
detectors. It is, of ‘course, common knowledge that when
‘an audion ‘is used as‘an amplifier, the higher, the fice
s8ec ‘between. the plate and’ filament, the greater. the
ir — We therefore find Dr. ‘DeForest, |
rdions fon Fora Tegan

Sy Ath he

ett
i Se )
proper sensitiveness test. Apparently the vacuumin &
the other bulbs is. too low, because in these latter
ace -____bulbs-we notice thatthe blue ‘arc or cathode beam —
ee starts suddenly at 15 or-20 volts, under which condi- ih

6

F

' cisco, by the name of Lamont, who put in tungsten filaments |

- and repumped the tubes at DeForest’s request. Asa result, —

“Dr. DeForest wrote the MeCandless Company under date of

3

, _ * dDeft.s Ex.

a mWe here 8 see, therefore, that dae: use. as an onsitier, De..
_- Forest not only.realized that he wanted a higher degree of.
a _vaewum, and that’ the degree of vactum he wanted "should
be as high as possible, but that he made a revord of: his
knowledge of this fact, not in the sense of establishing a
. date of invention, however, because it is evident from De- |

Forest’s correspondence and his operations in California Re a

that a difference in the degree of:vacuum ‘was not consid. —
ered by him to be an Acsepies but a mere manufacturing: |
operation. Driven : Bese

Amplifier sek were + sapleyad by the Federal Tele-
graph Company in 1911, 1912 and 1913 sand formed part of"

its standard commercial equipment , with aB battery com- . Ee

prising 36 cells (54 volts). We further find ‘that Hewlett
used a three electrode tube evacuated on Lamont’s pump-
’ with 45 cells i in peries.' Forty-five cells gives a voltage. of
OM | ai ees eg
. Tes :
on n the Facts of This Defense. |
From the foregoing, it j is apparent that ‘these. devices

: operated : at voltages much above gas. ionizatitn voltage (5
: volts) and. still functioned as amplifiers in amplifier cir- y
cuits; hence they could not haveoperated otherwise than as
pure electron. flow devices’’. _ And this: is established by .
_ Langmui "8 own ‘testimony * in connection with his dia

- Pie + PS
i a x .
~ if , *

\

“XQ761. I watit;to ask you just 6 one eention oe ae
- gonnection with Plaintiff’s Ex. No. 168, which wes
_ the curve of the output against the plate voltage of a
_ three electrode device, as an amplifier with gas, and
‘a three electrode device, as an amplifier, without gas,
and-I think that you testified as the result of the ex- ta
> periments on which this curve was based, that there .
is é point in a gassy tube where it operates inavery
successful manner as an amplifier ; is that sorreetly
stated?
‘cA, Yes. |.
“XQ762. And I notice.that your curve stopped on _
the gassy tube when you brought the voltagé upto .
forty volts, the point being well below the steep part —
of the curve, which I understood¥ou to state was the ©
operating portion of the curve; is that edrrect? ee
“A, Of course this is ‘not a volt ampere cheraes.

*

-. teristic at all. 7 oan ere -
a —#%Q763, T understand 4 that it is the amplifying >
quality of the tube, i isitnot?

‘‘A. Yes, but in your etevenes ‘to ie upward — :
bending part of the curve, I think you were referring
fo volt ampere‘characteristics, that I had previously —
spoken of and this is not at all comparable with that. i
© ¥Q764. I-see, but as I understand this curve, —

the higher up on the millivolt ampere output ordi- i

| a ht pong, he more mt the aplifier is;

i Sect ieee

-_

volts or more without (a) blue glow and hence paralysis of _
_ the tube, and (b)-with any amplifying power whatsoever, pS

Peers ay UE Eta BE os
A ae @

3 ks Probably aileg winch less. | |

‘«XQ767. In accordance with the slope of the last

portion of the curve, w would be oerane nothing,

. would not? ‘G
“A, Very likely. I Pagers know that. ‘You can:
not safely extrapolate, because you go to higher “—

- voltages, the current becomes limited by saturation —
from. the filament, and then.the amplifying power
- becomes zero, and remains sero, as ae wenagns
are reached. agi eet ee

From the foregoing rae eee in wlicncaihen with Plain-

_ tiff’s Exhibit No. 168E, it is perfectly apparent that mai-
mum amplifying power of an amplifier tube containing gas’ ag
is secured at approximately 27 volts, and the Court will see
that a mere fraction of a volt above that causes the ampli-
fying power of the tube to drop to practically zero. It is
therefore obvious that it would have. been impossible for
- the Federal Telegraph Company to. employ audion ampli-—
fers in their commercial operations with voltages of 30 —

ue ~ unless the tube had been evacuated below the degree of 2
e ue contained in, a soft audion detector tube which wos

oa

difference between claim 26 and the remainder of the claims
” -jgin the recitation of the characteristics, which are inherent —
in the operation of such a tube, or the recitation of different _
values of voltages and currents. It is believed that it'is too
obvious to require discussion, that'the claims, a
60, 100 and 200 volts do not desgribe separate inventions —
_ fromi those specifying 40 volts. Otherwise we might as we!)
Have c. thousand claims to as many separately patentable
inventions by the ‘simple expedient of i increasing the speci-
fied voltages by small steps. | |
Jtis indeed significant that Langidie made no nnn
Rc. ga his patent to the use of an audion as an amplifier. ‘It is
_ indisptable that his description of the audion and its limi-
- tations as‘to gas content and sauces: voltagen: was in
: complete’ and inaccurate. Sawn oe ie ye fs
He

é ;

- “Tingston Cathodes in the California Then,

7 _ Another avenue of ‘approach ig that of considering the
* “inherent results of using tungstert as the filament in a
vacuum tube. Langmuir stated in his paper of 1915, in the

‘pr Beer before the Institute of Radio oe

It was known that. the. —_— in a ‘tur
Bs ape decree tent

Sn eere cine
Teen te meh petal}: na ~~
. hikewise the reco-d is replete with references to the
“Geocpateyaperoanionaranng awe tas
as to produce ‘“blue glow”. In other words, in the _
"intentionally brought-about and Dr.
his book?"

nae In general, over edu iss elllhit' sig
re id cae dency oath wre eo

eo i oa « EN Me °

is eae 103 ¥ :
ee. the diegtiaithion. of Ralph Hyde, that the filaments he em-
+ ployéd were drawn tungsten filament, i. &, thoriated tung-.
- ston filaments. Hyde testified that from 1911 on he re-
ee acne and replaced filaments of vacuum tubes.* ‘He also”
ee | “Qui. What . wntnelal filament did you use for
\. +. the repair or replacement work? A. Drawn Tumg-
_, stem wires, - “s
ks '«Q18. Did you use any other. filament? A. No,
a ‘you pean since, I started, from that time up to the
ees present?
aes ‘619, I mean up to 1914, particalarly? A. Noth-
* ing but drawn tungsten wires.’

. It developed from his testimony that the drawn tuigeten ‘
wire. that: he used was obtained from ie i Coe Electric re
| eum for Gaspedesl admitted 3 in ‘the record for the
purpose of this noint at pages 1442, 1443, Vol. 3, Record,
that thoriated tungsten filament — were put on Prag:

ees of 1912 '
The fact then i is, ineeators, that aia as yee a:
te tangsten filaments ‘were. used, with audion tubes and
a by reason of their inherent ‘‘clean-up" effect = gher

- and without mention of those facts or the defenses to
| which they were diested.

‘\\

"Judge Monimm in the Diatriot Court, held that the patent
a raid for the’ reasons, inter alia, (a) prior invention
an Arne” ee d (b) prior knowledge and“use by Dr. De-

ae

as

eer ee

=>

es : tee

by ate Sead Sot by Langmuir, and held the patent invalid
for this reason.

Similarly, Petitioner ‘produced the depositions ons of able ©
witnesses taken in California bearing on the defense of
prior knowlédge and use. Testimony of two*Witnesses was
given in operr court by pape ‘directed ‘to the same

subject matter.
The Trial Court, on this duties likewise merous

this defense.
© The Court’ of Appeals, after the first hearing, in its
per curiam opinion adopted as its own, the findings and con-
-_ elusions of the District Court (with J udge Burrinetow dis-
. genting without opinion). On rehearing, however, the ma-.
jority of the Court of Appeals reversed the above findings
- of act. of the Trial Court, which alone were dispositive of
the lifigation, without referring to the evidence, the defense
to which it was directed, or the findings of the Trial Court,
.. na henee. without giving any reason eaten soar 80.
The rale of law applicable to. the findings of fact ae a
Pages Coxrt was.stated by. Mr. Justice Hormes in. Adamson -
i 242 U. 8. 350, i in‘ the congluding eS
the opinion at page 353 as follows: ee ie :

_ “Considering that = patent ba has been

a
.
a —
7 2 .
. oo CP =
patos, :
le
= < 9 a t
“ ro > ie ‘
J fe ° = ;
% Ns «
3 . - be 5 ee a
é ‘ = "
¥. : % = ae
ae \
* ee. ; “e

«Inthe cage at bar there oh aconilict of & ein and"
E dic uioaseity of the Trial Judge passing upon the ¢ bali tr
_of witnesses. Not only was there testimony, ‘‘consish
- with the finding’? of the Trial Judge but, asa reading ot
his opinion: will demonstrate, and as we have shown, no
~ pther finding could reasonably have been made, ~~ -
~The reversaPof the District Court by the Court of Ap
“peals, under such circumstances,” ‘we assign as an error |
-_Mhich should be correéted by this Court. Mh

Se 2 MOINT NE
invalid because of. double patenting.

"The Court below did not pass upon this defence. oS
ee acs beck cee

__, Between five and six ‘months Aaa that is, on October —
15, 1913, the General Electric. Cony any filed an amendment —

“ered 32; 33 and 34, specially amphas i ip ce
' aspect of the invenfion as belongi ig to Coolidge.*. ‘Then =
one day. later, that is, on October 6, 1913, the General

~ Electric Company filed a patent apx

lice ‘ion in the name of —
its employee Pangmuir: This is the havptieiiiets on-which |

the present patent in snit issued. Consistently with the —
earlier Coolidge application and consistently. with the
‘amendment therein filed the day before, this Langmuir
_ application explicitly acknow wledged Coolidge’s priority,’ as -
‘Respondent admitted in its main bret in the court below:
® 941). =
Ss Algo, consistently with the situation as it had been de-
- veloped to that time, the langmuir application made no . u
-. @aim to the high vacuum tube as an invention, but claimed“
_ ta sete proms of fleting th erention of wah |

: Chin a; Wa 6 20

ae So

: 108 :

/ Wavering attitnde. the General Electric pieione may ine

e "shown in the meantime, it claimed the invention of the high
_ vacuum pure-electron discharge tube in the Coolidge patent

| ge it issued on October 31, 1916. Among the claims of that.

Patent, wo direct attontion particulary to claims:1, 16 and ae

baat ‘Claim 1 is as follows: ep

a= In p device for the production of. tee the

, combination of a tube provided with electrodes, the _

*. vaeuum in the tube being so attenuated as practically .
to eliminate. the production. of positive ions, and ~

st eae] means for generating electrons at, the cathode or —
- megative electrode substantially independently of =
the voltage impressed upon said electrodes’’."

The: only pretense of a distinction that this claim makes: :
from the’ alleged | invention. of the Langmuir patent in suit —
is that this claim i is limited ‘‘for the production of X-rays’’. i
~ Similarly for claims 16 and 32 of the Coolidge patent. In
> other ae the invention of the Langmuir patent. was
me Coolidge within. a certain domain, ‘‘for the pro-
“ays a it is not permissible to apportion —
| iy on a single: invention in aree

va

| i =. rere de valid pat- :
| jon. _Thatsss Feat ai i :

General Blectric schiaiinir is tempting to do by its 2 La i
i, muir patent herein suit. = ae
“fhe last paragraph of the Coolidge sabi before he a
. seine: a paragraph that went in by attorney’s amend- <
ment the last thing. before allowance of the patent says?

> 4Certain broad’ aspects ‘of the. apparatus aa :
; * : methods hereindisclosed are not of hy invention but. ze

-. are the invention of Irving Langmtir*and are de-

aes tend tr ie cs oa ates eRe ee

_ which patent 1,558,436 was issued]:” - =
Speaking strictly and properly, inventions are noite
_ broad ‘nor ‘narrow; breadth and narrowness. are attributes i
of claims of patent, not of inventions. The Coolidge X-ray
_ tube as claimed in claims 1, 16 and 32 is one invention and

the ‘broad aspect’’ is not another invention. Once having —
a secured the grant of the Coolidge patent on a certain inven- j

tion, whether or not there claimed as broadly as possi |
“the patentee, the General Electric Company, cannot 1]
ee after. have the Langmuir patenf’as a valid patent clair
that same invention, even ‘Sones its elaims bé of different
pee “When the General Electric ade decided to, ck : ; es
ie its position and claim the high vacuum electrom digct :
a device for Langmuir, it failed, to restrict all the claims of
. the Coolidge fatent to inventions essentially distinguis ;
- from what it later claimed for Langmuir. To illustrate the:
~. kind of restriction necessary, it may be noticed that’ the :
S ‘X-ray tube required a focusing shield, and it may be that B
ue Coolidge’s provision of this element was an invention quite
: ible from the invention of. the fac vacuum ¢ beer |

"ies, V Vol. 6p. 1016.

’ ; :

ee ER refer to this tooling shield as, for konto claim.
“49. Ifthe Qoolidge patent. had been restricted to’ such
" claims, the case would have appeared much better | for the
ee General Electric Company i in its. effort to secure at broad

ores diskacee tube tor Coolidge, and it cannot there- |
| after secure a valid pparent on Sees same invention for a

“The Laxignouir patent is ‘therefore invalid Yer double | “ _
“geese / :

&

“Miller v. ack Manufacturing 60, 151 U. 8, 186; yes

In re Dunbar, 278 Fed. 334; ee
_ ‘Thompson Spot Welder Co. ¥, Ford Motor Car :
Co,, 268 Fed. 836; S
- Otis Elevator @o. ¥: Portland Co., 127 Fea. 551;
Palmer Pneumatic Tire Co: v. Lozier, 90 Fed. 712; os
Caldwell v. Firestone Tire and Rubber Co., 13 as
or Fed. (2) 433; |
ai American Bell Telephone Co. v. National: Man.
0g - facturing Co., 109 Fed. 976; aoe
eae Industrial Manufacturing Co. v. | Wilteos Boosh
ee - Gibbs, 112 Fed. 535; oS
: Dey Time Register Co. v. Syracuse rite Recorder :
oe - Co., 162 Fed. 440; ° et ee
ed er: Glass Co. v. American Window
Glass oe 276 Ped. 187 E aaiaat 276 weit
hae

Mae, V6 a

‘ m1 ete

oe é a Miller v. -Eagle aenaskening Co., ‘peri this Oe
-_-\gid down the broad principles relating to the — *
double patenting, in the following language: | a

= “The result of the foregoing Std: oar ee
“ities is that no patent can issue for an invention
> actually covered bya former patent, especially 10 = :
- the same patentee, although the terms of the claims -
may differ ; that the second patent, although contain-
rs a broader claim, raore generical in 1 ‘its oh character —
| the specific clains contained in the. prior patent, —
is also void ; but that where the second patent covers. —
"matter described i in the prior patent, essentially dis & -
. ‘tinet and separable from the invention covered there-
~ by, and claims made thereunder, its srairecte may be
sus
__. “In the teat class asim ti es
pear that the invention covered by the later paterit —
_ was a separate invention, distinctly ‘different and —
"independent from that covered by the first patents © ,
ae other words, it must be something substantia a
RE ‘different from that comprehended in the first patent.” ~
: st consist.in something more than a mere dis- —
- finction of f. the bredtith and scope of the claims of
each patent. If the case comes within the first or
second of the above. ety, the et Lapin is -
-absolutely void’. ey ;

The temaining cases. above noted are all ‘octal we
applicability of the doctrine of double patenting to the facts &§

——) inthe present. cast. : Thus, in In re Dunbar, supra, the Court: 2
: oe _ of Appeals for the District ‘of Columbia held that “thesame —
ee patentee” embraces a common assignee of two applicants.
+. he reasons for the. doctrine of double patenting ap-

plied to a common | assignee: or. _— as | wet forth ~

“Of Counsel, as 0‘ Point IIT’ and the —

related part of “Point V’’ only —

(see the footnote on page 56),

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386008_0055%3A09. Public record. Not legal advice.
