# Transcript of Record — DeForest Radio Co. v. General Elec. Co.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386008_0055%3A03

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1931
- **Citation:** 283 U.S. 664

## Text

t 8 :
.
. .
8 a 8 ö
x -
.
5 F |
. * 8 ‘
. i 3 .
¥ .
. 3
f *
— 0 *
= —
. 0 5 : :
. :
. . ;
° :
se .
8 =
: — — ä — — E —
— — — — :
Oy ERI EST * Dr = © 5
— -
.
3 F i
— 4 3 N 5
« a .
siete 5 5
* — .
. f :
: :
. - 5 b
: 8 :
oe . 8
* e * . 75
. 5 K —
— ; ;
° 3 8 A :
. 4 2 4
* „ i
— a if 4 2 : :
: 2 * 7 8 8 .
e e * . 8 — * 8 ; yi
—
*
: * Pe * ot 1 .
liad ; ee E he Jah oe
. 1 * 4 t 5

. a N 3 8
AOL e

5 24 1 8 pare
RI APT e e
. me EA ey „ 8

*

7

K, do 2
— 2 - 2 8
0 *
- 7 2 25

5 14⁰⁰ 0 5 i Irving ee, | a ie

what I said. That 18, of course 1 said in ‘teh or fifteen:
minutes a great deal 1 more tHan is éontained in that
abstract, and when you have the problem of writing
down a short-abstract of that kind, and have te make
it readable as it stands, you have a great many other
factors coming in, in determining What you say, when
i have ten or fifteen minutes to present the paper.

a X 645. But of course, you tried to make the ab. ee
strane: representative of What you said, to make it. ‘4
trug an abstradt of what you said“! a

A: I do not know that. I pattioilarly’ tried ide ;
Bees T tried to make it just as'though it were a sep-
arate paper of very short length, dealing with the gen-

‘ eral subject, and giving information which ¥ think - 4
would be particularly interesting to dhe readers of the 3 ö
Physical Review. 1 probably said in my paper Mae

* dhings that are contained in qhe abstract, but I said

great deal more besides, sar I 46 bot Min a B

F er ect: seen Beg Re ea Peedi ed

a what T said. „
2. 646, wen wht aer Un 11 : or object ot

4. Well, it ee e at f To for be

.

( Received 20 per “Defendant 80 dau

, M for Identification.) " 3
XQ. 648. That abstract“ gives two 3/2 power law. =
equations, and you worked out some of the mathe-

. matics for those on the blackboard at’ tgs fag you,
male this: presentation, did yout N . Ae.

A. 1 do

I probably stated the results.

XQ. 649. And you-did not dive et the math:

ematical steps leading to those results. :
A. I do not remember “at all Whiethes T did or I

did not. I think itis rather quite improbable: that

7 did, because it is not. my custom A a rule, in lec-

tures, do give mathematical derivations. ae people |

is at out, Think

find them very uninteresting to listen to. * ;
. Mn. Ricumonp: Cr ition ‘dosed. ENE fe os
Mx, Hajour: Now, Mr. Darby. 8
ve Mr. RicuMoxv: Exeusè me, my part of it.
ee re Mi Danpy: P will be very brief.” ES
vated? Tse ieee aad. FV
/ 55 Mn. 1 3 2 :
535 As nnderetand dt, br. Langmuir, re-
ferxing to electron ah oe -
--- electrode to free if „„ ee
the electrode krom gas, At not? nigh 11 on rs
18 ht oma ot npn on
’ electrode the e ie by. 8 it

1 Ves. > hen ase
X. 653. Now, if you jl a a „

„ se
operate that device, it i

_ device, at eighty'volts thereafter, without having the
plate e ee can ee of wide

15
6 g i 8 a ay
1406 1 Irving ee i
> A. No. |

3 684. You can not! :
A. No. Not in general, no.
. 655. What is that?
a? A. Not in general. ae
5 CCC
a plate electrode for a certain necessary length of
time at one voltage, that that eléctrode will not give
, nf,,
A. No. There is no relationship. 1 f
AQ 687. There is no een between
the i
5 3 A
XQ. 657a. Is there no relationship between ‘the
|. voltages and the heat?! panes
ee A. No, not necessarily. kt
a SG Ge fees a 1 pesos aes cand coe
ate, or I could bombard a plate electrode at a high
voltage for a short length-of. time, and get a certain
amount of heat thereby, or I could bombard a con-

siderably longer length of time at a lower voltage,
onl aes meme ee „ ee

i)

2 , te 2 5 .

f will I thereafter. b hat

. 2 FS . W mores,
at the same or amount of curré
5 C Fos Aten ile

. ee to tll whether cr t te d hs :

Cr i

Irving Milage: oi | 1 Bee

3 freed Rene e diepiniiiaiiliate

there are many factors that are more important than

mere voltage and time. Thus, the amount of the
energy, the actual temperature to which the electrode
TTT
or current. .
X. 661. eee ‘And in the

ordinary practice of manufacturing the

? vacuum tubes eee do de ber eee 1 the plate dle oe

peer a Mive wel 5
XQ: 662, Electron Dombardment in all o of
tubes that you make / mm.
9 4. No, T.do usb disk bes e efithaek/!. Be
oe 20 d What do. you caploy to: heat th ele.

trodes outside of the bombardment? Teller
A. The most effedtive method used today. is the

“high Shquateyindnélien M Gaidibeswiaae

| ‘trodes can be heated red hot by means of & high fre- 5
gqueney 8e field applied nee eee We :
tube. i
By Ma. Dansz; ee
F
heat the glass vessel, does it! e e eee
ee ee com: 6

833

ee iy ak oe
ploys that e antl: a ee aE i de #
. No. ‘ + Piss The 311 5 175 8 1

ae B

14¹⁰ „ “Irving Langmuir. a
5 e e abksdeeagasdh chgeioateteing
manufactured today manufacturing vacuum tubes

%

where they employ the gas that is in the ee to con-

: Pre heat to the Raue electrodes? |

A ois fits
_XQ. 669. To get wem! hot?
As No.

| X00 670. Do won! see any reason ne e that could
rn ends N

| A. Ido deere cannot imagine wis 2 5 should a
de done. It me a. very ineffective method.

X 671. That was not my question. ‘Do you see

oF any reason why it could not be done?
A; Why what could not be done! ;

XQ 672. Applying heat to the outside its a —
and employing the gas inside of the vessel to conduct 5

that heat to the plate electrode to free it from gas, or
eee wu eee Se n- .

A. I do not see that the eee eee
ful function at all, nor do I see how the result e

ies pik
X. 673. 8 mrsenetie, :

0 674 T0 avoid any ‘post

3. ve 137 3

without qualification aka TET the teeta awa.

i ible imped te, D deter, a
| wl jou nett Ba as yc |

XQ. 675. pomp toed att 1 do not want :

0 rer you
1 * a tay “9
1

7 15 te 5 uy 5 pe 5 1 1 8 25 4
revi i pat of the réc- 2
4 we ¥ 7 50 E sang 7 41 Be ;

before explaining it: i teenage eae
coal answer, and followed: by the explanation that
| he did not give, so T think he is entitled to’ that |
ef right. You may answer. fe ae
„ 2h api ee 5
to me there are several things von ‘ask that are i
more or less incompatible to ene anetLSt
„ Mn Dakar; All right.- We will drop that for
5 a minute then.
XQ. 676. Tetinnd Me es : It an electrode bas,
— to 800 Ghigrbey 4. to tres it from gas) en
that electrode thereafter be ea:ploved in normal opera-
tion, Where its heat does not exceed 8⁰ — ‘Oy let oe
us. Sa Ss
Ses A. Bages actions sels ‘That ig; it can
be employed but I mean to say—of course, you can 4
ploy it, but you do not get a useful result.
XQ. 67% You: answered. hone T et tay :
ms e Dr. Langmuir. My. neee N
trode, a plate electrode, u three-electrode deviee has
been heated to the proper degree of heat) which 1 ee
understand from you is in excess of 400 degrees C., is cao
that correct to free it from gas—an excess of 400 de- Lee
grees C. trish ete creme eee e
ae magn that — a sufficient length of tine: 8
: 5 ,e „ seen 5 Beet e —
0 678. Want dere of ha een rie
Be mee A good, bright red heat. 5 8
. 679. Which is about? Bun .
ao 700 or 800 or 900, degrees. =
„ 00. Leeder thet to bea e . 400
| a -e

tube in normal . — iw threat eo
ae ee 5 [ELBE SES

» XQ. 6a, Bat not enngh acne bara .

„ — Carealitipes iis 7
ice ‘XQ.'682 What isthe normal heat of a plate de.
_ trode in operation on 8 three-electrode tube!
7 é "A. Tt depends upon the size of the tube and the
dest coming from the cathode. '* :
| ‘XQ. 683. Take your standard UV. 2017
FF but itis probably 200
or 400:degrees C
0 664. Wel, now, does ‘that plate electrode,
When it is heated up to three or f hundred degrees
C. in normal use give off sufficient gas cause harmful
ionization! effect. in the operation of the tube? |
‘A. Not if it has been properly treated for gas be
forehand, otherwise it dgea.
0h 688. Therefore, il pon ones heat the! des 5
: _ rede; getting bade ‘te: yi main question — 8
ö necessary degree of heat and maintain it at that heat
CCFCFTCTCTTTT meer 5
ther nen emed en en eee thires-

2 ——

3

ne coy

4 ————§˙’ a it
40 688, SOT ete tgt

XQ. 680. i a cy a
up to a high temperature it ox
does it not, the surface’ of the anode? ;
; X. No, I do not think 60 eee e, ‘
XQ, 690. Lon do not consider that itis
| nh ein of hat i ee

oxygen. 25 88 . .
XO. 691. .
ite color or appearazcet ‘owe es a A

~

ere ere ir, 43 re i e N 273 ‘pe 17 r
“HQ: 693. 11 vou raise a er eubstantis
3 eirt e get e
A. Les, some metals. 8 Rane 3 ee e
ee bt Pgs wee, de tr of nie, wor it

i isa, ae aves ae nt es es f 2: a
tl Mie etary ht = are,

10 hare an tk yoo loka he lt dtd so

“ate A. Tes. o io .

N the leads, which means that they, have been heated in. ee
a Sa she akon ee Beinn ee tek Fee
ä X00. 697..Can you give an idea as to xhat kind of

solder that is employed there! ay

A. Not very well. It doce nat. look like ordinary | 5

ol 0 698.’ Mond un m your opinion. be aller

older t . ee

| „A. 1 do not think 60. „ :
vellower color, than that. IJ. do not know very much

about the solder from looking at it. It is probably not

wade of lead and tin. That is about all I can sa.

Nei XQ. 699. Now let us consider a moment a vacuum |
tube that has merenry vapor in it. The mercury vapor 5

will in any circumstances readily form an amalgam
K ae

UE gone. ite

tes itn — Nob I be

15 | .
1 al trace of ene tS ae ge ibd. Sk ay 8 78 5
se penn opp vorking v

8 ia Irving — 1415
. + 5 — 10 1
e

1 is Merman vapor is enten tv. in
forming f
xQ. 700." Willyem:anewersaupqusstins dees then?”

ah. Je may or may no be. ee eee e e en

| FF—— that iin thot
anes after it is cooled and sealed off?

7 A. I suppose it would make some. . 5
X. 704. Ia which direction There woul be lee 9 55

mercury vapor.in the. tube? ä

A. Somewhat less merenry vapor. ct
XO. 705. i
filament let us aay-—frat let me ask you this question.
— — ets

a — a nmeaneent
__ by the thoriated filament, ves chsh

XQ. 707. was 6h confined. to emp
a snything of that Kind, uiry i

Pes na ee beat ui
y i 7 5 i typ RN ae

| baci aa ——— 4
| ic eae anain aaoada.

e toe gmap anv don ale
8. _ ways be operated ar a tungsten filament without any

2 beneficial results of the thorium. . ,
. XQ, 708, I want to get the bensicial-reeute of
“the thorium?

A. That means that yoo want fo operate at low a

0. 700, 1 Vun to get the beneficial results of
nee eee een are in
your mind. oe ee eS eke
N "A. Tus fall benefits-of the use uf thorium,”
ar Bais ot Cachet
A. The appreciable benefits? |
XQ. aul Any benefits, anything that makes i
better than the pure tangsten’would bet |
4. With that in mind, may I have the question a
agitad b. al 99
(SQ: 101 e eee ly de ebe een).
A. I think I can do 60, in fact I am sure.
8 0 712 In ocher words, the benefits to be de 5
ttywed dy using me on u thoriated
a tungsten filament in u high vacuum tube are not in any
: . ˙ 00 8
reagent; is that oorreot / 5
S 1 0
5 XO 713. 1 understand that, bat my question is :
‘that it wan not entirely dependent? , nee
A —
2 rete 1. Le nh wee W

/

is that correct, or from the walls of

‘menhi J ‘The same thing is

„

5 filament’ from
''. oxidizing as to wnt Mone tie the 4.
ee ee g 5

XC. 716. And in eee 3 ar.

* form that same functign, for example, with other

of filaments, would they not! Strike tät out, Let us

take the case of magnesium. You employ magnesium
to take up water vapor or any other gases that might
be evolved from any of the electrodes the tube;

716. . , til |
seen ne tec * that
correct ?

. —

A. The potassium dc —
other — besides.

. a „ “Irving Langmuir

a — gases.

5 or- potassium in those gases would not be
: dependent on the material of the filament. Be RTS. oe

: china for example, or the ‘surface film of thorium as :

by hauing the potassium take up or get the oxygen
ners ü. Were soon as they. are evolved- from any ;

. ng the electrodes; ee de ee ae
5 the filament you do that in that manner by having the 1

‘potassium or magnesium or whatever else is 3
combine with any gases that are given off eens any

e

5
: poe pe 19198? ĩ

ba ae
*

3 eren tube consisting of « Hanseat and a plate with |
; a grid electrode interposed between them? a

nun, and to some extent that was actually ied as
.

“XQ. 720. Confine itito water vapor ‘ita ben es

A. Then it is cs Chit hs deset eee,

XQ. 721. Now, in preventing ‘oxidation’ of tho-

you call by means of potassium, ‘you prevent that

rtion of the interior construction of the tube eng 2

‘A. Les. ä
XQ. 722. 56 d l teens the dee et

part of the interior of the tube! f
A. By-any gases again you are waeren io oxy- oe

XQ. 728. Yes. N
c

XO. Daene yo, “fod ‘never ES

. Not the DeForest audion. The tube that we :
XO 720 1 am referring to to „ thisedléotrode-

rr

— You conser that —— athree-lectrods « “

xe 727. . . . f

ö e aly ee lam! a
audion7 1
„ Yes. 8

seen on 7 8
ö XQ. 729, Had you vend anything about it prior to
that time that you recall? ee: :

A. I believe: I did in January after Mr. Amd
son had told me about the audion. I think I looked: b
up De Forest article at that time: January, 1913.

XQ. 730 In your 1915 Paper in the proceedings .
of the Institute of Radio ee eee vou made 8
are statement, did vou not: 7250

My active . in 8 peel 3
began in connection with some en sane on
kane discharges. ee with sten
ps. 7 *

And then you onda reference ‘s Richardson’ 8 date mm 5
then you stated this: S e 5

— Nin We vse ta een
‘lamp is extremely high, and indi-

dred hours life the Fra A
than one-millionth 0

mat is correct, is it tf
A. Yes.
* Eben That in what you stated in yout leber:
A. Yes. i”

. r: .

e N gee

X. 728 Te hat th ans un. ad you ad ver eee

„„ 5
5 “XQ: 75. i joa yp eee ee

„ -Paking these two facts into account, the

existence of a seems 9
wire —
must be very small, if not . 2 a

Iw that sorrest? |
M :
. 735. 677777
| start eee.
tube, that the very existencé of a tungsten lamp meant
the existence of a vacuum as high as one one-thou-
sandths of ee vine: flan the armut, Ane
A. Les. 71
XO. 736. One one-thousandth. of « micron, ia that -
correct? 2 is
A. No. noe: teed Hie eel Win you
please read it? (Question repeated as recorded.) I
do not think there is really a question there. oe
XQ. 737. I will re-put it. Then you one at
| . pornstar le digs to ee
the work concerning which you have testified, that the
very existence of a tungsten lamp which had been in
operation one hundred hours, meant the existence of
„% ae
„ e
a: Shalld go ont . 5 eS
3 — You donot have toon my account, iit ä

: — xine oh gn amy prove

es

smaller; but did not themselves rove that ane

was high. 8
n 758. Did it not prove that the, very presence...
of tungsten as a filament in an incandescent lamp, due 8
b its eee eee ee ee, hi mum
: 2 No.
X. 740. It did not? 3
. No, it was not automatic. f 5
XO. 741. Oh, I see. — we of fh 85
word ‘‘antomatic’’? ;
A onhy bemmontneds Gane
" great many other things in that lamp besides the tung

den fllament that the vacuum became good. Many

lamps having tungsten filaments showed vacuum Satis
did not become good, but became worse... The mere
presence of mee is not sufficient ih get a ‘good
vacuum

0 742 Due he improper exhant of the lamp,
in its manufacture ; is that right? |

x XQ. 748. Take your standard methods of exhaat-
ing. incandesoent lamps that were employ
or weré being employed at the time you.

mee 4 t investigations, if the. ba and
2 eae: 3

: dee e eee

a eee n

1422° Irving Langmuir |
m nne nnn ee
the filament by bombardment; is that correct? .

A. You would get a shorter life if you tad: ‘eee
much gas ionization that you had no space charge,
then you would get too larre currents flowing across
the lamp; and the life of the lamp would be short, and
might be destroyed immediately on a constant —
Circuit.
XO. 745. And it was en ofthat! that Think
8 you testified that it was @ very serious problem, and it
was necessary to get the vacuum down 80 low that it
would not happen; that is in, effect correct; is it not? -

A. I do not know what it is that you refer to as
a serious problem. I think I was talking there
about the change in the conditions that were brought
about by the introduetion of wine a8 a ment 24
material in place of carbon |
XC. 746. I am ‘not concerned with that problem, 1
am concerned with the proposition that that is the rea-
son Why you had to get as much air oat of the lamp
as possible —

A. I would not say as much s possible. We had
to get the vacuum so good that this Edison effect would ;
e eee eee eee Beta foe ä 5

1 "You bt ‘that ah not 0 ih 2 Px 85 *.

rr

Hege 9 me Redes
x — as i 8 N =
Nenn +
erie 2
SEES SARS , Wg
direct >

— Seeman rua

eee eae 2
af sare e

93

2 i.
ig Ne

: ee, ee 5 ge, or some-
what above normal voltage, in 9 i meu t
whatever changes were going to 2 rin; :

Irving Langer

Ee r dne des e a i
1 rot a short ‘time. 15 8
a —

* Sees * Pe Me
baht east SAA eae
* . 7

early period of the life of the lamp
X. 750. And you can describe

treatment of the filament before they: sac 5 ke *
completed; is that eorreet ?:!

hg Pasty that and party to bring the vacuum in .

| the lamp to a steady stage.

XQ. 751. And they were n practice in we
incandescent lamp art ! At least, they were prac-.

_ ticed and employed by the General:Bleetrie Company?

A. I think at that time, I think all lamps were
given some aging treatment before they were shipped.
XO. 752. Now, with: reference to the work of Dr.

See Alexanderson, you stated i in answer to O. 1062

5 5 Mr. Ale eps de 145 a me 5 : 0 2 he want 4 ed 3
use an audion if an a 1 . — tained t
was not ‘slu 2 he purp

„

Mr Davis has offered i in evidence as Plaintiff’. Se

hibit No. 169 (indicating)? !
A. | thik Sean tatelaen con haitercnst Wades It

was probably February 5— m0. But that is not che let.

ter. No, that is not the letter I had reference to, and
perhaps the letter that I had referenoe to—in fact my
mn
5 possibly be February 5. iy 1
XC. 758. Who was the letter trom and who was

we letter addressed tot

A. I think the letter was addressed to Mr. A. G.
Davis, and a copy was rap pana Hawkins and he
me the audion.
XQ. 754. Have you got the copy al the letter that 5
you referred to in your testimony with you j Eyes
A. No, I have not. I remember testifying 3
the letter in the case up in Trenton on the Alexan-
derson patent, which was where it came into my mind.
A XQ. 755. You testified in the Alexanderson Inter-
ference case, the other parties to the Interference be a
ing Mr. Colpitts of the American pene & ae
| rand 8 , and Dr, DeForestt 15
A. I do not remember,
. FG. HA: Laken you a vosord: of task Lutesteruans
3 and I might state on the record that the testimony of
Mr. A m that I read to him last night, was
given September 17, 1919. Does this refresh your.
recollection, aa. e at: jot Settled fal Chat.
matter?

2 sare 1 é 1 8 PR ee Ae |
x } 757-58. Let me read this e ee ae
3 N77 „ 1
j a porti it. You 18 £3 2 4 r 75

*. 8 4 FFC“ 4
5 yr 8 CTT eee Se
Be EN, 3 3 ee 2 7 5 1 * 25 4
2

Sa eee ke A

A. I suppose Tdi, but T do not realy hee |

pburpose of sending radio

| — a
froquency generator by meson . te athe

vacuum electro

or anode of the rae — — oe ger
é { ti eu . a ’
queney een and the My the

8 ates

Pine este BS that time had clear ideas as
- low accomplished as ya as ae
thermionic devices were available.
that we were developing thermionic apy
the pure electron type which could

high voltage and it was nan that
took up with me the question of baude: such

voltage, rriicuk serve thermionic devi

8

ii

0
at

8

85

i
10
N
1
41
.

|
10
ih

: 1 4

f then pen were s, A tene eee,
e 8, What steps, if 685 you. take o.
ward ee into effect the ideas which Mr.

FFF Waite bod made These
tests showed that these a esr ape for

ye 112, under the date 5 12 1%
‘to some: work which showed that the

i 2 19 1 — to the fect. that a new assist-

ant of William is now W. 3

1 ives Mr. ir. White « on andions. I said: At pre
N is: Try out Alexanderson's of

8 e to control cur-
— sat aod 8 ——

B13, on page 810 50. my nok roa a ö
try describing the use of such a vo
r. device wi 5 —

‘ 0 a 0 at dy n 38
41 Fy
i we
.

XQ. 760 =e n a S . your
knowledge and belief at ‘the time sh —

x

aN

nee Lenni c ey. uu
A. na... 8 ‘haz & de ar U +k: ‘
0. 761: de ee Yon. Guanes emus
connection with Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 168, which

was the curve of the output against the plate voltage 5
of a three-electrode device, as an amplifier with gas,

8 and a three- electrode device as an amplifier without

aa “A Wl wae very ol iia ie

gos, and I think that you testifled as the result of the
exheriments on which this curve was based, that there
is 4 point in a gassy tube where it operates in a very
successful ——
stated? - ~ : |

AX Yes. 3 PER ee

XQ. 762. I notice that your Wee iniaad
on the gassy tbe when you brought the volt-
age up to forty the point being well below the
steep part of the curve, which I understood you to

state was the-operating portion of the eurve; is hat-

correct? —
A. Of course this in et 8 wel amp de,

‘iatie at all.

XQ. 76. 1 understand chat ite de ashi |

quality of the tube, is it not?:

1 ‘Yes, but in your reference 40 dhe upward bend- |

spoken of and this is not at all le with that.

XO. 764. eee eee

higher up on the millivolt ampere output ordinate that :
5 vou go, the more Lee neg F: w ou * ;
ae ahs of your testimony? ~ 00

J 8
„ :
4 * ye r ent 5
8 e sor 5 ey)
F553

XQ. 766. And what would have been the amplify-
„

A. Probably very much les.
XQ: 767. In accordance with the slope of the list

partion of the ear, it would be practically nothing

would it not? Adv ten

XQ. 768 You referred to Dr. Lälienfeld's X-ray

tube in your direct examination, and you expressed as

your opinion, as I understood it, that Dr. Lilienfeld’s
eee e e oe

A. That particular X-ray tube that we were talk-
ing about at that time—he has made many.

XQ. 769. Lam confining myself to your testimony,
the one that he showed in that article is the only one
4 you considered in giving your testimony, ‘was it not?
0 ian ame if you are considering some.

~ swer, I would iil e to know it now. In giving your an-

: N xi

ad A. Gought maybe you were referring u ste
r een) dont: i, st ig Bs Gy Mie

.

xX 772. Wen, does the article stn what the
‘dimensions were? | eee, ane ‘
A, . OR ih e si 8
XO. 778. No. Bors the article state what the di-
_ mensions oneal “ch” OR Lewin Beer eet . we

XQ. 774 Does the 0 state: ———
were employed?) ez. atl

7 A; It enn the voltage-was two diy eupgly H
XQ. 775. And von assume that to mean 250 volts
or thereabouts?
A. Yes. It wonld not have made any difference
whether it had been higher or lower in my conclusions,
| i 776. But it would have made a lot of differ-
ence if the dimensions! wore different, would it ‘not?’

A. Ne....
XQ. 777. Your 3 You
do not want me to understand from that that you
reached your conclusions first, and then drew up the

dimensions afterwards, to fit the conclusions, do you
Mn. Davis: A .
: strike out the question. 701 48 ef
2 oni Davee Lend pres it. sites
Sy ie e ee ee

“fied: sania ban et ag 5

hs 8 Wey BUTE

1430 5 P
‘a A. T do not know the difference betwoen «gues e

d an estimate:

XQ. 780. nr
a Mr. Davis: I beg your pardon. hide ot think
he was requested to guess.

M Dassy: I do not know ‘whither your 3

‘ n Guamnets 1 wan thal! swith 3
Fr ö
MX. Dans: Yes, sir.
A. What I mean is tis or ubat I. did was this,
32 the: Abeamem atitha tetbeicobbbeaitie os
22
know. I have no way of telling the dimensions of the
tube in any other. way than what is said in the article
_ about it. A diagram is shown. x4 |
Sent 0 77 500 ig

A. Les. “3
29.791 And tat he postive on came from gt
egg the tbe 28 of

A. Ten... 8

20. 792, Now, did you. m rstanc that Dr. Lil
ienfeld . ee ee, a Wehnelt eathode!

metal filan . 8

2s to both Wehnelt 5

i»:

——

iu Langmuir ee “1483.

haps it may bein the Rosenthal article that goes with .
the Lilienfeld article.
794. And you took’ that into consideration in

; ‘teaching your canclusion, did yon?

A. I did not say that it has anything to do with

the reaching of the conclusion
XQ. 798. Then you did not take it into considers
tion:
A. 1 dunn I took it into consideration, bat I do

- not think it was pertinent.

10 206: In eber Woch yout Se ö
enen eee ee x
a Wehnelt cathode? ; oe
4 Wo): it eld not hove bann in 5
XO. 797. You know, do you not, that a Wehnelt
cathode may furnish. a a ee supply of Positive
ions in a high vacuum! 8 i
A: No, I do not know that. $0 K in net :peopesty_
7 made it ‘probably gives, ñ —u
- jonization.
2 70. With reference be che Lennie . poe oe
mom what I refer to by that name, the tubes made on
he Lane ben sake? LER: SOE oR
XO. 799. e

- sili nee ee ee e, é
DeForest bulbs, because of the Bunsen‘ burner under 8

it. If they were heated a little hotter by means of the

2 Bunsen burner under it, would that have tended to free :
‘more water vapor from the interior of the v alls?

f A. It is a question not only of ture but

time and with proper provision for taking up gases.

It is one factor that would tand that way but there

RS 800. 3 into consideration the n he me a

as exhaust machine, is that the correct name!

| : actually do use phosphorus eee, 5 :

* matic exhaust machine.

1434 = rwing Langmuir
vapor.

. _*
ing of the bulb of Lamont with the Bun: en burner while

| remove water vapor from the bub:
3 phurie oxid would have. been more een ee 3

pentoxide tubes in the exhaust lines of those machines!

— the tube?

*

5 A. The mereary pump would not remove vater

XQ. 801. Tt would not remove water vapor?
33 4
Xiq 62. So that in your dente un mere be.

it was on the:spump —— — 4

the interior walls of the glass of water vapor? =
A. Of course, the more you heat it the more that

factor would tend to eee eee cee

XQ. 803. And ifthe pump was operating it woul 2

+A. Not: the pump but r

XQ. 804. At ney eau time: va nanuf ing
vacuum tubes they use what is ealled the wee

A. I think so. | 5
20% 06 Ad . . el e e,

A. Yes, sir, I suppose they do. I do not know
about it. They may in some cases use liquid air. ae
XQ: 806. Do you know of any instance whet

we mat familie with th pasion in .. 3

‘XQ. 807. Have you ever: — 2 08
aud, in a portion of them chine wh

4; 2 2 se te * 8 8
BR, ta ae ee 53
. ‘What beau do you n rotor tot 75
20 808. In 5 ; a
N * Pn ERT”: ast Dow Manes ee a
‘tubes? OE CES BA £46

Irving dente 1435

‘uta on the PaciSe Cot, the tube now is the :
Cunningham tube! Moe ie? :
. No. i i f
XQ. 810. Yon donot nent bo Wen 85
A. I have been told that the Cunningham tubes N
re made, a great many of them are made by the Gen. —
eral Electric Company, but I do not know where. 55 85
55 . (
rainbow flash? oe Gere
A. I do not think I have. 1 Paes is
XQ. 812. Do you know what kind of a flash mate. 5
ris! Cunningham employs in his tubes 5
„ Ne
| X. 813. Have you yourself ever employed eh
_ containing sugar syrup, Rees ee :
„ es
| 20. 814. Never heard of ita being used?
A. NO
R XO. 815. 1 think yon tentidied ‘this, 8g Wet
you read over your specification before it was filed :
: eee, od nh Saat iene Ss, Ee a ae
contained were true? 8
A. Is that a question?
X. 816. Did yout
e f
a 817. Did von 20 teetify?._
Mn Deux: It your. Honor

wid ‘referenee ‘to. Uns, Sah e name not e dis-
eee eee oolidt ga nd

14886 5 “Teving Legnei a NE 5
gale Tn Count: ‘ta the ‘absence of assurance a.
from the other side — . +
: Mn. Davis: ne to ee 3¢ i
Dr. Coolidge is not called, en eee nee

recalled for eross-examination. 6
Ma, Dauer: ‘That will be entirely ait,

111 eee With just one We on .
es Langmuir’s cross-examination. As 1 recall,
i aindtion of Dr. Arnold was not con-.

a : granted in the event that ann
x examination of some of the notebooks of the Tele-
phon my would seem to make it advisable
for the plaintiff to call him and we do not want

the cross- examination of Dr. Langmiur concluded ;
until that of Dr. Arnold is concluded. =
Tun Court: Is that satisfactory, Mr. Davis? e
* Ma. Davis: Yes, if your Honor please. Ot.
course the cross-examination of Dr. Langmuir—
ioe the only culty I have is that I assume the eross-
5 _'. @gamination of Dr. Langmuir should 1 7 ght =
oeerenoe to his testimony.: | |
Tau Court: gee 1e-Wwoedl Mues 10 be. x
I suppose Judge Haight has in mind the further
°°. gpogs-examination’ of Dr. Arnold may makes ad.
3 visable at Teast further cross-examination along
derten lines of Dr. Langmnir’s own testimony.

Save

ded to ook up certain farther facts in

what you have found.
A. I stated yesterday that. 7 thong
sible that the distance between the ar anods
might have been changed between N 1255 that the
two curves were taken which were illustrated on page

ation of the notes of experiment 217 l 1 * ns tus.

ally what did take place. „ :
The first curve which i is. Teferred to pH curves 1 3
and 3 is obtained from the data which is on the record
sheet 1348 of these notes and the curve marked 2 and
4 is from the data on record sheet 1364, 0
On record sheet 8-1432-1 in the summary there
given it is clear what the sequence is of the two. curves
and in between those two curves a magne!
to the bulb and the results ‘show dist
after that magnet was applied pend
of the tubes changed in such a .
the distance between the electroc
and 1 remember distinctly that ny
effects that occurred when the x na

The way in which the curve. shan
was in the direction that i in indie
in the space charge current indies
B50. 819. Referring 1 the. ;
wee. you worked Carly in the sp
| to:the matter of slug it

ita ry oonn ected w

therewith. If you have done 80, e re les se sta | ~ ao ee

&

‘tion in the audion which T felt cure existed from e
fact that blue glow had frequently occurred.

When I visited John Hayes Hammond, Tee"
laboratory in April I asked wrticular
they had that the audion ‘was sluggish. And I found
that the evidence was simply of this kind that if a
strong signal was received, as for exam
ea

ack 9 sans FS: * . 8 4 ‘
‘also by Professor Pierce, whom Tua’ there, that
was the reason that they gave e for ier conclusion tat

the audion was sluggish, =>
on, or shortly thereafter, T realized that that

3 is à fact, is it not, that, before this

“the reat mast "Whit bad tia h i M

derson. I remember that conversation that

. remember t

tind that the tubes stat ard at that ie were
high vacuum tubes or the type |

we wood was actually ü, No.2

Mu Dow: That 1s all. ese

Tue Cover: Any further ¢ ross-exal
Mr. er Sees eir. e

By Mn. Bromo: 1 1
of your Phireical e pees D.

to Which von refer, the, high den
| e ee

8 5 x ae ¢ 72 * 7 tae 4
$45 5 FP es \ 1
8 * 5 3 ‘ > *
N

EEE CRRA f oe,
on the 1 oN Now, spies, 2
tube and with 148 Souda

16 a
f

22 tl “te ad ord ie result 3

5 :

J on thé fat topped part ot th’ earv=the changes i oe
curren that resulted from the gas pressure, disregard»
5 e
i r e „n-
d sees ix Figure 8 e of es paaheyaaaie
the current was, as I have just said; 64 milliamperes — wy
at 148 volts, you can make the comparison better by uae
comparing that curve with the curve obtdined just
after that, and which is referred to in the middle of
page 464, where the value b is given as 55,600. Nom, 1
those data occur on the records of Experiment 317 n
page 1366, e eee, 225
of the curve. You see the vacuum was good in that
case. It was relatively good. Tt was one-quarter ‘of 95
a mieron as compareſt with the 3.8 mierons in the run
above. The voltage was 167, and the current op the
flat-topped part of the curve was 4:1 milliamperés, and
the difference between the 5.4 and the 4. I, as the vacuum
improved, was due to the effect of positive ions in
modifying to some extent, the electron space charge;
that is, with the 4.1 milliamperes, the current was
limited by space charge practically independently of ”
| positive ionization, and then the pressure was 88 mi-
crons of hydrogen, there was enough positive ioniza-
tion to have raised the current from 4.1 up to 5.4. That
e of effect cat be ed to be’ du to: he effet of
positive ions. eee
5 — the dete:ta Mpertisens S07 dit eh
3 a great deal of care, and 1 And that on the last few.
| pages, there is a very completé summary of all the ex-
boden on Jost this ‘tet. Rote eee eee

no ‘matter how high the filament e was, but.
at 38 microns, yon only had partial neutralization of
space charge, that is, there is an intermediate region
detween the region where positive ionization has no
effect, and the place where positive ionization com-
pletely neutralizes the space charge. 0 |
RX. 827. Now, please turn to page 8.1374 of 11
the notes, for Experiment 317, and I understand that
this relates to a time after the chatige i in the spacing 0 of |.
the electrodes, does it! N Sy AST ) \
A. Yes 8 |
| RX. 928 And from the data on that · page, van 10
i von calculate the current at 177 volts? e
A. Well, there are two sets of data given on this
page, one on the top and one on thé. bottom. Which -
one do you refer to? | |
. 829. The to of the page. 4
As. I do not see y figure of 177 volts but 1 see :
a figure of 181 volts. According to these notes I find
that when the filament temperature was raised to 2390
and above (the temperature actually went up to 2620)
C aie
was independent of the temperature, that is, it was a i :
flat-topped curve and the value of that current was
practically exactly four milliamperes and the voltage
was 181 volts. ‘a 8 5
BXQ, 990) And "how mush ie that per un.
: ane ‘
X. - 2 milliamperes per square centimeter. 5 55
Mn. Brouwonp: That is all. . 9
ne denen e a

St

| : datet

pao

and I have a litter from Mr. H. B. ‘Beene of the :
Harrison. Works, er of. the Incandescent’ Lamp
Department of the General Electric Company, 8
- which I have shown to Mr. Darby and it is agreed.

as I understand it, that this letter is: fe be e
as evidence i in this case.

Mn. Dansy: I did not exactly mean that. Hie

Mitr purposes I would like to have it appear on the

record some date on which there will-be no con- a ?

-troversy at, which. time thoriated tungsten filament
lamps were on the market. Mr. Davis is now in a
position te authoritatively state, as I understand

it, that they were on the market at least as early Ss

as the fall of 1912, and his statement to that f.

_sufficjeht for my purpose.

fect, i to of any letters would ** re i

Mg. Danae: Is. 5 eee

Court: All you have inquired for isthe :

Mu. Davis: L am sorry, but 1 dislike + 0 ca

| that statement without making an additional state-

mente which while it is very obvious I think should
be made and that is that while Mr.

given me the date as.the fall of 1912 as r i
to market tungsten lampe he gon an- says that

it was a long time before we lamps

made with the Battersea filaments. Thastivers in

nee stock and it takes some time to change over and I

want it to ‘appear that we did not dispose of our
. final stock of amps made by the Battersea pro-
ess until the end of 1913 or very early of 1914. :

Tue Couꝝr: You are. not ee e with
ether they are on the market!

Mn. Darsy: eee eee the duet. 7

. "of whether they are on the market today.

Tn Court: Then I understand that you stip-

st ulate, with Mr. Darby that as to the date on which

*

- - a

2
*

Aa
s

py 8

1 l Discussion

thé thoriated 14 diane lamp . on the
market was the fall of 1912 and you add of your
on accord, Mr. Davis, the. supplementary. state-
ment tp which Mr. Darby does not En but
asserts it is irrelevant. é
5 Mr. Davis: Ves, sir; that is qui e
tory. Also defendant's counsel have spbken to me
and I think it appears on the record Mr. Darby
„have no doubt will agree with me, for the benefit
95 of the Court of Appeals (iti is not necessary here),
that there was no thoria in the Battersea wire.
Mp Dar: if that is the fact I will agree to
that.
: Mn Daves: Lol seat it as 0 fact
MIX. D I agfee to it.
MIX. Davis: fr this question of the testimony
given by Mr. Frank Waterman in a suit in New
„ Fork we are willing to agree that the eee 3
may read into this case provided he does it
ar tomorrow to give ns reasonable opportunity to
lock it up, questions Nos. 18; 19, 20, 111, 120, 186,
1395, 196 and 197 of the deposition of Mr. Frank
Waterman given in behalf of plaintiff, the Marconi
Come

suit brought in the Southern District-of New York aS
Hey that company against DeForest Radio Tele-
phone & Telegraph Company, the testimony y
5 being given in the year 1916, and any or all
pärts of the answers to such questions witn
. nama ep.

Dise se 1445
e may ned into the case any . of the

testimony of Mr. Waterman i in that particular suit,
: and further

Mn. Dansy: That. rst, is entirely betet 5

tory.

Mi. Dansy: ‘Up to thie point. ig, I think

: you correctly read the questions an answers that
we went over. I mean you did not | over amy

intentionally.

Mr. Davis: I hope thst I did rhe ‘Provided a

that our expert Mr. Hogan may not only comment
properly on Mr. Watefman’s statements, as he

may comment on any statement made by any wit- 5 i

ness of the defendant, but also may tell your Honor

what it was that Mr. Waterman was talking about 5
in each case. I do not mean by that more
than to say that at this paxticular time Mr. Water-

man was talking about a Fleming val e or at this

particular time he was talking something

55 else because I find myself in reading that testi -.

. mony that they used names quite different from.
hard to

i 5 find out what Mr. Waterman is talking about,

Tun Court: Then, of course, reserving to

Mr. Darby the right to examine Mr. Hogan.

; Mn Davis: Oh, yes, and he may calla wit: .

ness to show that Mr. Hogan is wrong.

cee 3 —

THE Coven By. bret you meun up to this : ae
point? 5 tr .

it is Le

sel ie Ca arbi hing 5

*

4

ne 1 mn en eee, :

Tas Court: 1 rather suspected tlint thero
might be that reservation, but I wondered whether
first if Mr. Davis had that mind, I think your
statement was made out of an abundance of cau-
Fa

Mr. Davis: I wish to be very clear that Mr.
Waterman used the word high vacuum and possi-
bly highest possible vahuum and if Mr. Hogan can
point out and show that he has used it in a cer-

' tain way I think he is entitled to draw the infer-
‘ence and that he can leave ‘to you the inference |
to be drawn.

„ Tu Covkr: 10850 make an abstract ruling
now, an anticipatory. Tuling, but I think that the
opportunity to.do that should be equally open to
both sides and that you mark the trail which the
other side will be able to follow.

9 Mn. Davis: I certainly will not go anything

. that the other side will not be permi to do.

Tun Cours: So that it will be understood that
Seas es far as Mr. Hogan goes the other side will like-

176 | wise hade en opportunity to do the game. 1

f ————— —— of the

ä reasons given by Dr. Arnold’s counsel for taking
testimony on the“motion to dissolve in the Patent

| "Office vas that the meaning of terms had changed.

Tu Courr: I enn understand that. And it

6 ‘ay be that wa testimony given in 1916 would not

—— id -Rincieaer” athens that
ee | same suit, which ch was Jost mentond, but before
Bae | on the accounting, ‘How long has it
| he r e ae

/

Discussion . 5 1

l le devids sheen] in ‘the Fleming patent

Das distinguiched from the Wegant type A. I be-
‘lieve if my W,
the America Mareoni Company always aedzired
its two-electrode tubes from its. company
in Great Britain, and 1 think that. the British we
Company. still continues to manufacture two-elec-
trode tubes, and that if called as a witness Mr..
Sarnoff would testify. to the same ‘effect in this
case.

Mr. Danny: That is correct. That i is e satisfac.
tory.

Tun Covrr: That coyers all that you ul

Mn. Dansy: All that I want plus the additional
statement to which T understand’ Mr. Davis bas

a ye no objection, that Fleming

Mu. Dayis: The statement which my brother
wants is that Professor Fleming had a signed hi
British patent to the British Marconi Company.

Tun Courr: And that you stipulate? —— |
Mn. Davis: 1 NG

e way, wns thet e
| a etd st to whch we ave refer

* *
. . *
2 Py > “ . ? 7
— 3
Ss
* we S

s Fe, 2. W. Ales

n eee e If these were
e testimony of a party I would —
: We chow e D Arnold, as 1
it, bat Dr. Arnold is not personally
" techaeally e party to, mis case and T am wonder. .
4 ing whether — ane
Tu Oobnr: Von Map recall him back for- the |
„ purpose of crovs-examination ‘and present that to aes
him. You may do it now. Ki
Paes ahah Mr. Davis: I would like to do that if iis a
5 ee ene ee

4 eat ae eae — 4 * 5 at 2 8 : ; 4
se iS | Si aie 3 5 8 2 |
bk — 20 > sims *. U ERSON.

2 frente
: Tie

3 „

4.

Electric Company.

. Q. 5. You know Dr. Langmuir? eared

A. Yes, sir. Si

Q: 6, Did yon ever, get in touch with him eo as

| am 1. 828 „
A. You, 1 never left the. employ of the General:

‘to come in contaet with any work which he was doing

on vacuum tubes: .
A. Les. .
. 7. Will you sate the circumstances, and abou .

i when it happened!

A. I had been interested in 6 0 8

kor many years. In 1904, Professor Fessenden re-

_ quested the General Electric Company to develop a
high frequency alternator, and I was assigned to the

job of doing this work. „One of these machines Was

built and used by Professor Fessenden in his first test
of radio telephony. . I thus kept in contact with the
. problems of radio telephony, and I realized that modu- 95
a r of Jango fonanamey: Wa ine of ö

the ree problems.

Mn. Davis: Just a moment, Doctor. 4 want 5

ire 9 Lee und

. f
0

85 Fre F. W. Alesanderson

ratively small ener, Gsrived diss the micro- .

phone.

I see it?

Q. 9. You have in a radio station obeenally an
out-going high frequency wave, perhaps ‘a million
cycles. In order that the signal may go out, you must
change that because as long as it is not chang 2, 10
signal out, and when they talk about modulation
from tlie telephone standpoint, they mean changing

the amplitude or the energy of that high frequency

Mn. Davis: Pardon me interrupting’ the ‘|
ness a moment. I want to be sure that thats
olear to your geg May I state it simply as

out-going wave in accordance with the voice wave

Vor the other sound wave which goes into. the micro-

phone, so that if you draw a curve which represeg@
the sound current, that would be the wa wrt

5 5 Ernst J. w. Alexanderson 25 | 1451 5

N. 12. ADA ti i emi es LP sors
tion with what generator? N
A. Of a high frequency’ alternator. . “gure
L. 13. Which, is usually called the Aead.
son Alternator”? ? Nen
A. Ves. .
Q. 14, And the other scheme that you. thought of,
of modulation? ;
A. The other scheme Was a. three-electrode mer-
eury are tube, with which I attempted to control. the
flow of current in a mereury are by the third electrode.
I obtained a patent on’ one of these devices, but I ob-
served certain practical difficulties, in the development dee:
i: „inen of the déviges that 1 hed used, and was, looking |
/for something that would be still more adequate and
/ ‘particularly more sensitive, About that I came
in contact with John Hays Hammond, Jr.,. end he
_ bought two of our high frequency alternators. I had
in mind the special problems of supplying the modula-
tion, gnd we discussed the use of the magnetic ampli-
NN We alen had ib,
mind special methods of reception, and Hammond
told me about the audion. In accordance with Ham-
mond's description of the characteristicg of the au-

inet F. . Alcdonilersin

75 with a seaman the Wboratory 8 aflairaand
. Dr. niet and Dr. Langmuir. ’ :
2. 17. And What resulted from that?

A. I thought Dr. Coolidge and Dr. W n

e be interested in these possibilities, and I partieu- »
_ larly discussed with Dr. Langmuir the design of a spé-
cial high frequency relay, and he explained to me that
the new type of discharge, high vacuum pede: |
which he had discovered, way, instantaneous, and would
undoubtedly. give the result which I had in mind if the
tube was developed with three electrodes along these
: lines. I therefore arranged to get the audion from
0 y
X. 98.. Are you quite sure ° that he coring BS
38 yout x : :
* hats my recollection. 18 8
8 99. And he indicated that to you before von:
made any such suggestion to hint, did he not!
A. I do not remember how. matter was men-
tioned in our conversation, but I recolleet that we both
came to the conclusion that if che audion was detective |
5 a e very likely owing to the presence etme Era.
: E. 100. See if I can refre eee .
| he timony whic Fae pave e eee 3
te ding. ‘Do: you focal gx 7 : |

ee ting a timed ny port .
“18, 1 e e to, te e

‘
„ as

—

bn . . aue. ö 1456 ee
‘J : : :
radio Ac of J ohn Hays Haumsend Jr., of
Gloucester, Massachusetts, where two of my 100,
000 cycle alternators were installen for *
5 mental purposes. „ :

898 =

: =
he Yeu may check up with me, to. make sure I : .
richt, Doctor, and that I am reading it correctiy: „ 55
. “During the progress of the tests I conducted „ 5
= with Mr. Hammond we had various discussions of d

radio problems in general and particularly of the
Problem of telephonic modulation of high fre-
25 . energy. During these discussions Mr. ie
| nd told me about the chhracteristieg df .
. om st audion, and I gained from him the im-
pression that While the audion had proven to be
‘+ an efficient amplifier of telephone currents, it could
not. be used as a relay for radio frequeney cur- „ -
ents, because of an inherent ‘sluggishness in its
action. In connection with my experimental work - . [f-
‘mercury vapor relays of the type described
in my patent No. 1,042,069, I had noticed a certain
. +. sluggishness in the action of these tubes, and in |
5 my own mind I explained this sl gi ess üs due
do the inertia of ionized vapor. 1 was, of the ober
band, in a general way familiar with the results of . N
_ the work of Dr. Langmuir and Dr. Coolidge in
— —— — 8
n N the s 8

—
5
2
% : 2 ex xt Me oe
5 4 F - —
5 N i
3 1 7 ;
1 j
agi 4 * 7
5 2 5 se.
ae > 752 8 J ¢ *
0 ‘ 4 =
8 0 55 3
Bes ’ . 6 *
ae ‘ Berg — .
PY eae: 99
* ; 7 o
aie * *
5 5 4 a
2 5 8 ee
. * . —
. —
gf?

,

was it not, Dr. Anme sat is now?

1466 Braet rim. Alewanderson

a @ tube of the DeForest type, and was in favor of

x the testimony, No. N is the one, a COPY, of vie |

And then you were asked:

; | 0. 6. When sid you first, disclose . idea
to gthers?’’ .

T0 To wich vou answered:

A. After one of the discussions with Mr.
Hammond, which I referred to, I communicated’.
my ideas to Dr. Coolidge and Mr. Hawkins. Dr.

Coolidge confifmed my opinion as to the probable :
results of the use of a higher grade of vacuum in

=

‘research work being started along’this line. For

this purpose I obtained from Mr. Hammond a
sample of a DeForest audion, which I gave to Dr.
ieee who had taken up this investigation.“ ö

That binde was true at the time you gave i,

A. Les. ,
XQ. 102. And the patent that vou een to in ,

I now show you?
A Yes, that is richt. ta |
Mn. Dansy: Tank do have it marked for ider
tification. 8 Oe * \
(Received and marked “Defendant? ;
K for Identification.) .
Mn. Dansy: I think that i is all.

~ 4

| William C. White BT
WILLIAM C. WHITE,

Wüste d. Wartz, was calla in tobuittal a’ vit: :
ness on behalf of the plaintiffs, and after. 1 been
5 worn, ‘testified as follows: :

Direct Examination. -

Qe ‘What is your occupation, Mr. Whiter. 3
; A. Research engineer for the General Electric
“Company, employed in the research date at |
. How long 580 you been employed by the
General Electric. Company? 32
„AK. Continuously since July, 1912. ie
Q. 3. And was it in a the: research laboratory all
that time? / 25
he See
Q. 4. Do you know Dr. Langmuirt
A, Les. 85
2. 5. And you have been working bor him for how |
long? 5
A. I worked immediately under his 3
for a period of several years, and have been closely ee
associated with his work until the present time. 6
a Q. 6, And what is the time when this period began
5 at which you worked. immediately. under: his ‘direction?
A. The early part of 1913. ae
OF And what had you been doing before that? ©
A. I had been employed on experimental work
in connection with mereury are devices, |

. whol ee been mastend 1

Plaintiff's Exhibit F for Tdentifieation, ge —_ os
d you recognize it :
e a
9. What is it! ates 7
"A. Tt is my notebook No, 453, :

William C. White

0 10. Covering approximately What period?”
: im nd 5 dae er

stent ab the time of the pie to the best of your = ;
— and belief? 1 75 .

ae, (The cee Was Wenirel in 1 5 *
Pica ‘‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 171.“ See Voy
ume IV, Plaintiff’s Exhibits, page 91.
. 12. 1. find in this notebockr un entry ön page,
20. It is very mee eee yee Wet Gatien toad 15 =
the last four lines. a
A. On page 20, under a he of Monday, rab i.
Fe Ts Sica 5

5

anne F
hs ae stated nee —

55 place, or very shortly 1 1 Langmuir
showed me some tests on a lamp with two filaments,

O. 15. What was the general nature of the test!

A. The. general nature othe fe a le

William o. White.

trate how the current between a cold an

5 could be Anited either by electron mons or r space,

55 eee eee

„. 16. — did 5 ä this! e
A. He illustrated this by putting a 3

positive voltage on the cold electrode, and ‘hen slowly ue |
raising the filament temperature, showing that the cur.

rent went up with this temperature. He also ran the
fllament at a normal e and inereased the

voltage on the cold electrode re krom zero to some rela-
tirely higher positive value, showing how also in this
5 the electron current increased. with ug voltage. 5

17. Were these increases in ; ay
ae Ne. ‘He then ilstratod. that if the lament :
age would. only cause an increase. of curs

Ae ap to eran valigs vlog od ind ha

——

1470 5 William C. White -

‘on the, cold filament and Wied nn the filament
temperature. Again, ir this case, the electron current
rose rapidly at first, and then above a certain point
nd appregiable increase of electron current was noted
as the filameat was. raised te a still vig nas tempera- 15
ture. os
„ Q. 2% You cack of the voltage being put on the
| cold filament; actually where were the Tannine of
the source connected? 3
A. As I remember it, this tube had two Nera 5
hairpin filaments, so that it had four wires coming out
of the stem. One of the pairs of wires went to the -
cold filament which was used as the positive terminal.
Q. 23. And what was the negative terminal?
A. The negative terminal was the hot filament:
Q. 24. Now Dr. Langmuir having shown you
those things, did he ask you to do anything?
A. He told me that he wished to build tubes in
our o laboratory, and that he would obtain for me
a De Forest audion to make the tests with, as he be-
1 such a device employed electron currents. oe
N. B. Did eee e about a vacuum . 3
A. He told me that for the 40 8 ot tubes he ute N
to make, I would have to install à much better type
ae of vacuum system than I was employing in my mer- og
7 hag are experiméntal- work. 5
2. 28. ‘What did you do in that direction! 5 aoe
me _ A Shortly afterward 1
. 1 ‘do not now want the details, but simply: oun
1 wer, 5 . or — nat Ld a ne age ven eg 7

ey William C. White nr
4 Dr FFC
wished e leu and he wished me to exhaust and
„ ORE
e Now, 1 refer to the‘entty in hear Mathe
on page 23, February 13, 1913, to February 25, 1913:
„Away from Aab. am needunt ils“ 5 5
Do yon remember that incident? „„
. 10% . Wess sty”
. 30. What was the situation when you got back
with respect to this tube? lee
A. As I remember, progress had been made by
the glass-blower in the manufacture of this tube, so
that I was able later to start exhaust work upon it.
Q. 31. What was Dr. Langmuir’s habit in a case
of this sort with ‘reference to Lanig with the .
blower? 5
A. t en be make 8 0 of wteniie.
sired, and either to take it in himself or give it to one |
“of his assistants to take in the glass-room, and very...
often in devices in which he was particularly inte-
*’ ested, he A Se go in be learn’ „ .
“ress was being made.
Q. 32. Now, on Thursday, March 13th, that is on e
page 32, under the höading, Thursday, March 13 to „
Saturday, March 15, I find an entry: Will you tel! 8
CFC ae
which you need not read unless you want to? — W
A The entry covering Märch 13 to March löth,
. ͤ system 'asid eahanated 3
an all tungsten audion.’? 8 40 eee as
2. 33. What audion was thͤt: e eee
. R
2. 34. Firat, I will ask you if you re

| exhibit, this tube, which is marked —
8 No. 10 p | es
AT do revogniae it: ES = . Be ae

Hy Baws ale
fee Bay Aes

ele Not. sok but 2 at ee Sh ak 22
1 38. Now, I hand yon a: collection ‘of: papers
are marked for identification, ( Plaintiff 's Ex.

A. TEE.

Q. 46. So far as you know, is there
bg re OM eren .

ee “Mx Dive: I noe in that conection If you
: ch e

p

. 47. Now, 2
eee Is it s library or estslog card.
or ee eee,

*

1 *
N N

mean, „Time, un 1

@. 54. he frat column in: headed: Date“ The 1

second column is headed: Tir What das that 7

Meas ;
57. ‘and the next ne is what? 2
MS a

which was attached to the system near the tube.

45

2

. a =e

9.4% What de you: have, if anything, between

McLeod gauge and the tube?
A. A liquid air trap. s
Q. 60. And this column marked - temp,“ what

does that refer to? © |
: ature of the oven sed for baking

— 1010 just a re. the exhaust,

i

e ROR ore ANOS ii =

ao

rul ror plate ae also in the pene of | a flamient, 1

*

&

e ‘William C. White ue 1478

5 -
7 Flashed plate filament well and filament WwW
does that mean, if I have read it correctly?
‘A. It is difficult for me to on now jast\what
that was intended to mean, but I think it was to rep-
eee ma 5
Q. 64. It says “and flament one, plate Mlamont and es
‘lament, one” a
ce 4. That probably: referred to the: oa |
2 ee ee

2. 67. Now, the Wand übst ik’
please tell us what these headings
of the columns, just read them across:
NA

Vo. 2. Starting from the left, the first colimn is

date. The next column is headed “Lamp amperes,”

Continuing to th right, nother txt is recorded, 3
moe first column of-which is again: ‘Amps, L
Next, Degrees C. absolute.“ The next ‘Plate V.
and again two columns with a co eading, 10
son I,” The first headed Meter, and the (rea
Mi a ne 0

1% A wanne. White : =
Ln nat carton n of the. meter 2 : :

e b. What pomp id yA ch n poping an
cendion No. 2. 4
A. Nds rotating taéroury: Gaede Pump. “tH 3
e eee eee eg 2
cury Pump and the tums e & ae
A. Yes, the liquid air trap. 35
0 L notice’ this sheet R. 8. awe a d, 4
- right-hand o figures, K. 107, K. 1, and so
forth. u please explain what that meang? : 8
5 A. Those figures represent the calibration con- 3
ee CF ee f. eee. neee e fe .

Q. 71. Why do they vary? |
4. Tile is due. to: the fast that on thie test, ‘two
nee were used. One was direct reading

whereas the other required a correction constant.
| ee ee

23

. White? -
901 A. Because the current range in the test was
bester than could be accommodated on any one in-
8 3 5
a3 0 7% That is, you would go up to a certain eur. N
went en ane instrament, and then what? .
ids Change the instrument to one having the higher
are
. 21% eee eee recorded by
. e c
— . 1 CY es. —

7 nis 78 I hand you sheet R. 8. Wo, and that is
1 1913. bo
the be of the columns correspond in meaning to

—— — m
de No. 781 “Exar oven

. A iat 5 e ey rt ae 1 te + fee, 4 a he a :
— on era . — ‘ ; oy .

n gerd there’ icine

Q. hy „

> thew additional columns?’
„„ Ther is one column heed Grid weten
{other pair admit headed Geng E 5
d Which is watt
A. Meaning urid een 2 MWh fet at these
two columns with this common heading have the word
: Meter“ at the ae eee far ‘word
Mili Amp.“ wee

Q. 79. And these sheets recra the tats dnn wer — 5

3 made by you on that dri , *
8 De e. tit ans :
7 Q. 80. What vd the energy arne in the
2 allen e that Inst Seat! 5 3
4. In the last test? ! r
| pr On fhe tnt a halt set shoal sy,
3 tice in one cas with a plat voltage of 115.
a current of 11 ‘milliamperes is
: M Davis: This sheet R. S. —
ting in for oornpleteness. I have already called at-
tention to the fact that somebody has made some
marks on it which are not oontemporaneous and it
a anne
date it.
: Tus Count! That is the 1-2/8 column,
Mn. Davis: Yes, it was very recent.
Tu Courr: Ton ard oxelnding-that column
#53 from’ the offert
~~ Mz. Darm: Oh, yes. It is no part of the record
and it is: |

that sheet. 55
eee 82. Do you Sama tre |

.
. . os 5
1 8
a « 4 -
*

William 0 White .

cae a sheet folowing after a8 w. 79.
preceding 617 15

SL And 51 is datod whent bi a 5 f
* what do vou know aise the date of st |
It was between March 17 and March 20, 1913.
MI. Davis: And the four columns in which ve
are interested here need not, not, I think, be explained.
They have the same heading that the others had.
a Q. 86. I hand you R. S, W. 81. ee e,
5 your ozigiual — : : 8
ae he Th aes chs 4
a N e And it is ann recording tents on ne
Me BP kn: i * 9
ec eg ae eh

: e And there are no terms there that you have
not already explained, are there! , |
Bee A. I notice one column is headed total current.

Q. 89. What.doesthatmean? —

A. There are no entries under the column so tha
I cannot be sure.

Q.. 90. RS. W. 08s dated April 22, 1913 What is
that?
— 9 . ‘This is another record. Sheet. Some of the en

tries refer to tests of andion 9-B and other readings

of tests of audion No.2.
| n I. would M 10 60 backe for a moment {0
R. S. W. 81 and ask you what the nature of that test was,
_ what you were trying to do when you made that test!
: A. I was using a constant filament current ande
relatively constant plate voltage and taking the read- -
eee eee
34 92, — object! n

e and agen carat ave

*
Pes 4
* ;
E * ~

1

‘William C. White 1

0. 93, There ie an entry there end, i, not 5
~ giving sat. 1
e is apparent that Dr. b re-
quested some particular ¢ curve showing saturation and
that after carrying on a few readings this particular
characteristic was not n due to an improper choice
of voltages and therefore the entry N. G. 115-V not 775
giving sat, meaning that this 115 volts 8 Siving 8
3 saturation expected. ) e :
Q. 94. Why did it not give it? eo N
8 A. Probably because the filament ‘temperature
was too high. ö
: Q. 95. I notice on page 98 that the first quarter or
perhaps sixth of the sheet has to do sa .
audion; is that correct?
A. Les. „„
Q. 96. Otherwise the . on that sheet refer to
what?

A. Audion No. 2. =f

Mr. Davis: I offer the various „ Which
have previously been marked. for i ation G,
in evidence.

(Received in. e and a “Plain- :
tiff’s Exhibit No. 172.“ xan Volume IV, Plan-
tif 's Exhibits, vage 108.)

5 ‘By un Davia:
5 Q. 97. I notice on page 34 your notebook a
statement that it was necessary” to run the filaments
: for quite a time to get results consistent
_ day’s results. First results 10 or 20 per cent. too high.
-. Whatisthat phenomenon? —_- 3
oe 3 c
r nis effec Be
8 e eee n ande fe ae dar. |

*

. ‘William 0. White.

ture effects on the mechanical constraction causing. ex.
15 pansion. or contraction.. 5 a
: 5 98. Win you: ‘illustrate that just what it might a

: n in thoes particular tubes it wen die to a
Bie Wariner of the grid wires as the temperature of ae
. ithe parts was increased by the heat from the filament.
Bo Q. 99. The manne was ne er the lament, 5
was it? a b eo:
; A. Les, foil
2. 100. Has that d sine? ei
A. On well designed tubes it is not a common 0c-
0 101. The effect would be to change the 4
tanoe -

Me A. The probable effect was to change the relative
distance of the grid either from the filament or the
pleted ce :

: Q. 102. And ‘cee change the amplification factor 7
A. Les, and also the plate current. :
. Se oe 103, On pages 43 and 44 under date of Apr! es
7, 1918, there is an entry and I will first ask you, Mr.
: White, what these red ink marks which are I find en
ee that page and in several places in the book? ? rie
A. They were placed there during an Interference
ä proceeding in which a notebook was used some ig 5

104 That is, ygp were asked by obunsekz :
| | AL was asked by counsel to mark certain plas
in the book for identification. 8
d 305 An ay ed ak in that Dok, i tat e *
of an entry t. . er 5 ee.

N an Hy past 111 ce we
18 "108, Now, tell f. what the nature et ber tas
wire teferred to on thoes pagest

IAS OO page e Aa bod HG DE &
. eee |

. a William d. White

epee oni! ons ung 6 a Weiedvatlaad on 5
e fer 9 ine BE oF
. 107. That is, by means of what?

A. By means of a combination of a vacuum tube
and an inductance in an associated circuit. Saal:
a Q. 108. That is, you had this audion, which “if the
Vvay was No. 2, was it!
sak A. Yes. here ah
N. 109. And des age 48 it ie noted?

A, Les.

0. 110. And you put the plate Par of that au |

= dion i in series with the 250-volt shop cireuit and with

a heavy inductance? - = e's
„„ Auk Ea eee hoe: ee
benen 5 4 * % , * mh es” Ie
2 5 3
77 ß ĩͤ pore ars
. 155. That i is 5 the | :
Lee? oe 4
1 * 8 * = rs
it?
a

XQ. 156. "hs wa beet
een investigation that yon have ee tia

A. I do not know.

XO. 157. I understand that the General mean |

oe ge

action, and that the General Electric UV-2 tb inn ä
high vacuum tube that ene, deen ol gas; .
is that correct? ‘i aes

: Sie aval 1 am wondering what part ofthe Shs
direct examination relates to these tubes? -/ aye

rebuttel on behalf 3
JJ ap maton eae 5
to take the time eee eee some work
Qe sot ns lat at af

“Willian Di Coolidge a “er a

A. Targets for the most party targets with plat
1 0.20 ‘And made of what material? ; et
A. Platinum. That is; : |

: 3 i CFF
many cases, and was in many cases attached first to a te =
little disc of roy e ee en u panic N
e soldered to a block of copper.
II. Was aluminum ever used?
A. Not so far as I know, Mr. Dar.
e eee e i
i
13. Well, what was Se ae een
=. eee 5
A. Aluminum. 5
; _ 14. Ao wan there nny moana provided for baat
ing the cathode?
2 15, That is, we are dealin ih te 92 5
davor ay ber Sea 8 N
5 R
V
CFC
4 PPT

. : 1. a * 3 5
T
E oh that „„ of somes of

ice — to the dee * the peg

3 8 5 *
3 ae ; x
A . *

e Mein tern W
longer stable; that is, the operator in
bad arranged the apparatus and the plate f.

as 3

K i
let us say one second at a certain voltage; but 48
matter of fact, perhaps he got 30 milliamperes for ou
hundredth-6f a second, and then no more current
would pass through the tube. Under such con ms,
the tube was spoken of as being a cranky tube.

19. Now, you spoke of using tungsten in the
e Laer e word Tice
yes, you did! re 1

A. Tes. ;
„ Q 20, Have you here among the exhibits, =
wing which will illustrate the target h Nan ere
n 5 a

A. Yes, the target in ‘this tube here (indicating)
Q. 21. Just a moment, De or. e
hibit number—Plaintiff’s s Bxhibi N

T
e aon to find out, is whether, in the old Crockes

Wiliam Be — „

ccc

By Mn, Dav 59 ae
Q. 28. Will you answer that, Doctor? 8
A. The early. Crookes date had two drei.

both of aht a fat cipedlar

as à cathode, and then either a litt

C0000

that case being placed at one side of the tube ax The
catlode rays then coming from the cathode in t » eatly
Crookes tube went the length of the tube, and there
coollided with the glass wall of the tube, causing this
beautiful green fluorescence, and of course there pro-

- ducing X-rays, although that was not known until la-

ter that X-rays were produced where the cathode rays,

‘collided with the glass wall of the tube, or with any

other body that Crookes may have placed inside the

tube in the path of the cathode rays. —

a That ia, « cathode ray striking anything
is pt to produoe-an X-ray, is that it, Wee .

A. It does produce X. rays.

. 28. I do not think you. ave oe u.
Honor’s question. e eee
1 tn Goat Ais tunderstondijn thes d olidge
| X-ray nne, Fame

ia, 5 . a
Ae ie

E f
was a solid mass of metal in the old Crookes tube,
and was not a weer eee

13 i 2 8 4: . ee

1500 William 9. Coolidge 155

and that the heat in the inside was 5 thin ead 4.
the bombardment and operative to that extent on
-a different e from this tube. Si

By Mr. ‘Davis:

Q. 29. That statement is 1 is it not? =
A. That is correct, your Honor. The mechanism
of the emission of the electrons front: the cathode was 4
an entirely different mechanism. There was gas in
the tube, the gas was ionized, and then under thè: in-

ftuenoe of the electric field, positive ions were driven

against the cathode, and there “caused rd ha: “4
emission. i
8 Tn Court: In short, maybe I can ee it
this way the old Crookes tube did hot use the
Edison effect, or start with the Edison effect!

| 5 Wrrxnss: Did not use it. „

Cover: And your tube does? r

9 — Witness: Yes, sir. Bot ae
2. 90, It is à very accurate test, is it not
Doctor, that there was no Edison effect in the old thbet
: A. Ai sir; there was no Edison effect i in hia old

tube. 1

e Bui the 9 Sida ia Saab wre eon
| called a elf - gust Maucher, was it not?

. Yess. sir. 185 .
ay „32. Which means a discharge « e bythe |

5 1 35 on in the tube : ae
„ is correct. | :

Mꝝ. Davis: Or perhaps more ont put,

che conditions necessary to the discharge.
és Tun Court: Ves, I think I have that now. 5
„ 33. Saya you Sv 4 ven uot, pat uf lg ,

" stenstarget embedded in copper on the market? 0
X Yeg, tat was. put on the market.
Q. 34. About what time .
3 A. an that was lao in a.

William D. Coolidge 1501

0 35. Do you remember and 1 think you have
also testified to that In this Court something about
ordering an X-ray set?

A. Les, sir. In connection with the development
of this copper-backed tungsten target, it became nec-
essary for us to do some experimental work on the

' X-ray tube. That is, for us to abuse the target as much
as we could, so as to find, by. experiment, a design of
target which would stand the most punishment, and I
did go to Philadelphia to order a so-called ten- milo-
watt shook machine for this purpose. cK
Q. 86. Dector, you have not said souicthing be-
cause it is so obvious to you. What is the strain, what
is the abuse put upon e target? Whst does it have to
stand!
A. The cathode ray stream in ‘the X-ray sofia is
all concentrated in this cage on the little tungsten but-
ton in the target. If 1 may go back one step, all of
the electrical energy delivered, may I. change that, be-
cause that would not apply to the tubes in which these
meee targets: were first used? 1
Q. 37. You are e ach now of . old N

tube?
Les. 2215 | Elte
G. 38. With your y cla . f you 8 ee
A. Yes. And in those tubes a Very large frac-

tion of the electrical energy delivered to 1 tube ter-
minals was put into kinetic energy of the moving elec-
trons i in the cathode ray stream and as these rapidly -
moving electrons collided with the target, two things
happened; something like 99.9 per cent. of the energy 5
i of the rapidly moving particles was changed into heat 5
delivered to the target and the other perhaps one.
e eee went into the production of X-ray’.
Q. 39. What is the difference between that and
what vs bare ien of in this case an heating the an, |
# 9 5 ind bombardment? 5

—

72 . . i a 7 a 2 8 15 ai |
05 N Wittiom D. Coolidge „

A. In this case we are beating the d in the
case that you speak of, we are heating the anode by
~ eathode ray bombardment. We are not doing it in a
very high vacuum: As I have already said =
2. 40. Just for the moment I am trying to show.
or to bring out—we have talked in fon a a great
deal about eleetron bombardment of an and it has
been testified that that heated the anode. Just think:
ing of that bombardment, is that any different from
what you are’ talking about; in character, I mean?
1 A. No, sit.
Q. 41. There is, 8 one difference that 1.
ould like to bring out and that is, will you discuss
what you call the focal s t in the anode? 1
A. The focal spot is t e area on the target on.
Which the cathode rays are all made to impinge. a oP
. 42. Why is it necessary that there should be a
se limited spot like that? 3
A. If the tube is intended for Aae diagnostio
use the size of that spot becomes very important be-
cause the X-rays are in that case to be used to produes ae
a shadow picture and the sharpness of the shadows ‘ :
will be determined by the size. of the focal spot ahd of

.
*

ad

ge 43. Let us op there’ and be sure we have made 4
hat cleat
| Ta Cover Is that spot then like the shutter

William’ D. Coolidge 9 . 508 See
wa you compare this focal N with the source of
2 . it : |
A. Yes. NE BGs
. 45. The X. rays come from all over: this spot ® | 55
A. Ves. eon Ng
| Q. 46. You think of a shinee of aniobject coming. 1
from light coming from a point and you can draw Baas
Une from that point to the object and you would get
a perfectly clear shadow, but if you had two points and 1
drew lines from those two points thro the object |
to the table under the object, len you got two different 15
shadows differently located? |
Tun Oourr: If I understand i I katowsivery
little more about camerfis than I do about X-rays, _
but as I understand it, the more you close a re N
ter through Which the licht passes, the sharper a
photograph you get on your plate, and I am won- -
- dering whether the smaller the area upon the an- Sto
ode in an X-ray tube upon which the cathode a
Lin com Ra PHN cote ee 8 :
e ‘thease 98 youn Eneay tas, .
2. 47. Is that right, Doctor 8 e
A. Ves. Thee is this-ebjecticn de de ess of 5

camera, perhaps an objection to the a 1

e

comparison in that one of the functions of the dia-
phragm in the camera is to limit the portion of the lens
_ Which is used. The lens is not well corrected if you
use a very large aperture. a REE 8
ease which Mr. Davis mentions of the projecti a8

40 the shadow as possible:

—
%

vou have hy the construction of the tube limited the .
tube if you will. So much so if you like that you will

tion of energy.

| ‘diagnostic work, you make that focal spot small enough —

able tinie, in a time during which the patient or mov-

D

: eee dene .

1504 2 D. Coolidge *
sible, so that there will be as little penumbra 1

Q. 48. When you speak of abusing a target, you
mean heating it by the cathode stream? .
A. Yes. It is, possible in the X-ray tube where

size of the focal spot to something definite, it is then
possible to pass a great deal of energy through that

melt and vaporize any material that you put there at
the surface of the target. There i is such a concentra-

In the case of the X-ray tube built for medical

so that under the concitions in which the doctor uses
the tube the shadow of the bones, let us eay, or other
objects in the body shall be sufficiently sharp for the
purpose, but on the other hand yon must not make the
fal spot too smally because if you dp it will then not
be possible to use sufficient energy so as to get suff.
cient X-ray intensity to make the picture in a reason -

ing organs inside of the body can remain stationary.
I might’ add just one word to that. Tou use 3

of the high melting point of tung:
sten and the low vapor pressure which will then let vou
with a given amount of ees t focal spot

just as small as possible. That always us

* William D. Coolidge 1505

: L bunt it wa late in 191, either late in 1911 or
early in 1912. 5
80. When it came did you put it into use? ,

A; Yess, | -2> 8
2. 51. Testing the targets which you made and 10
forth / wy
* Ves. r BR . 55 . |

C. 52m What is this bookt 0

A. That is my. notebook, beginning witn Jeon
25, 1911, and éxtending t and %, December 20, Se
1912. a |

Q. 58. And this was oue of the regular laboratory 0.
notebooks kept by 9 you in the course of vent id
ment N ia

5 A. Ves, sir. yo

toy a eee f
correct to the best of your ene and belief at the :
time you made them?

A. Yes, sir. 7 f he
5 Tue Court: Before 3 you go into .

3 ask one question to make sure that sgt NR

Is cathode ray Wannen e with
_ electron bombardment? |

. 55. Is that right?

A. oe cathode Faye are rapidly moving streams ae
of electrons. 5

i think u det ee h b
FFFFFFFFTTTTTTTT goe oy -vh gl
speak of it as electrons.

K We: e e ne tos ee 5
.
t present we use the term cathode Brat
— cme ro ad on hee

BS * 8 l Dav bee anden.

Ne

$506. William D. Coolidge ae

e of Resdived in evidence “ind ‘tatked „Plain,
tiff's Exhibit. No. 174. See rewe IV, Plain-
ties Exhibits; page 121.) 2 ee
Q. 57. 1 ask you to look at pages 171 and 172.

Phat i is the date of the entry beginning four or five

lines ‘down on page a he

A. May 8, 1912. ’ .
58. Without taking the trouble to 5 that
entry, will you explain it and tell what rere as
recorded there on those two pages? a &
— I say in this entry that I have received e
036, from Wiggin. Mr. Wiggin was of the

— a McAllister & Wiggin in Boston. They were

X-ray tube manufacturers and I had sent to Mr. Wig-

gin a . tungsten anode, that is, an all tungsten anode

and a l dished, concave, range disc to be used as a

cathode.

I had had trouble prior to this with the melting
of aluminum cathodes when I had operated tubes with

a great deal of current and so had been anxious to try 3

tungsten cathodes. This was my first opportunity to

do it. This tube had been built for me by Wiggin in ere |

, 5

f
were — 1 cupped, or. not? , :

Davie. foe, a
n ae ee een ant, 5

“William Di Coolidge 1507
~ Because the tungsten ‘cathode contained 80

uttle gas. &

Q, 63. Is that the nature of wrdughs n
A- Ves, I would say 80, because of the method of
| ination used.
2. 64. But you finally got that ‘tbe: going?
A. By an artifice, yes, sir.
Q. 65. The artifice consisting of intiodubing gas
W en this gas. producing arrangement! 2
A. Yes, sir. Repeatedly introducing’ gas and
operating the ‘tube with high voltage. +
é Q. 66. And you finally got it going very vell i

nn ekg e

Ol Qh And how did it rum, that in, what were the

circumstances or method of operation? — i.

N A. The cathode became strongly heated and then’
| the tube ran very steadily. aie

Q. 68. What heated the cathode?

A. Positive ion bombardment. |
. Q: 69. On pages 173, 174 and 175. appear motes
5 and suggestions of Dr. Coolidge to use a ase by cathode
in an X-ray tube.

Tun Court: What date is this”. _ ae
MIX. Davis: May, 1912. I am not trying to
prove any earlier date than we pleaded... I want

to show the facts. As has been suggested, this

perhaps may be immaterial’ and I will just call
attention to Weed pages that mention this sugges-

tion. t

1 Osu Does that menn to heat the cath-

“ode by external heat?

55 i Min, Dar: 5

1 e

Q. 70. eee 5
by ‘positive ion bamberdent ihe

ae n 8

1508 ct William D. Coolidge
4. 1 should say not. It certainly was not a very

“

conventions tube to handle as it was quite: an art. to

get it started.

@. 72. I notice the suggestion at the bottom of
page 175 to have a tungsten cathode © wound on a sort
of spool made of what?

A. I think made of fused alumina or fused sifica.
Q. 73. Woulf that as you now know have been

possible?
A. It would certainly not hate. been an operative

525 week Thot is, it would not have been a pure electron

discharge tube.

. 74. At the end of all this it says, ee
near the end it says: I will this tomorrow.“ Did
you do it tomorrowf ac | :

ih & No, sir. °

2. 75. Now, I call your attention to page 266 and

ask you if you will describe that Firs
5 eee muffle:

76. What was the experiment! :
In this this tube we had a tungsten’ cathode and
eee e
3 The tube a

the
No.
78.

8
rer

5

Ie

cathode externally? |

— gus tube, was it?
was a gas tube.

erferer
28738

5
72

both of tungsten? | ea

effect“
e ‘ead ug ashy. Starting vim
re The

:
7

—
i
&

are ere e eg eee e,

Was there or was s not any means of 4

"And You ran that tube with those two ele

b. Now, will you tread the paragraph begin >

/ 4

15 5
William D. Coolidge „ 1500

; e both heat up angie and there is a white
bot fecus spot on both cathode and anode.’?

Q. 81. Why was there a white hot focus spot on

the cathode?

A. The cathode was heated by positive ion bom-
bardment and there was a strong focusing agtion of

the positive ions causing their bombardment to take

over a very ſimited area on the cathode.

Q. 82. Will you continue, please, n that W

oa
A. “The pump was running all the time but it
was arranged so that by means of mercury the connec-
tion between the tube and the pump could be broken.“
. 83. So now if the, pump is turned on it means
that you connect the tube with the pump and start the.
pump? *
A. That is it. „Now, if. the pump is turned on and
the current. kept on so as not to let the Senos a

tage cur-

cool off by thie current I mean the high

rent passing: through the X-ray tube the resistance
ol the tube quickly rises to a point where no more cur-
rent will pass. |

ee 1 William D. Coolidge
a aun" 3
8 j Who Potential dns in chin case: being me,

. in wn was then a customary manner for .

X-ray work by means of a spark gap, connected in par-
allel with the tube. That is, this spark gap consisted of
a pair ol pointed metal electrodes, the distance between
which was easily regulatable from a distance, and the
: method of using the device was to simply, while the
tube was runningꝭ bring these points closer and closer

. together until finally the high tension discharge to-

the path between the tezminals of the 91 gap rater

8 than going through the tube.

2.887. Was that high: or low voltage i in thse .
kor Xrray!

a A. That was aii as high voltage. at was ged a on”
apie tubes at that time.
2. What did you conclude from this experi:
ment ?

= e ae it 3 as though we did not get *
eee, from! 1 en in aig vacuum.
ae Not sit 8 | 5 8
Fs 720 90. Then you must have d ived yourself j in

some way in this experiment. — please expla g
en eee ee ee you were deceived? }

. I think that as the vacuum improved alten |
ug the connection between. the tube and the
the positive ion bombardment; sank to such 1 :

i

| .

8

ee 0 92. In layman's language, the cathode cooled
off. a e

A. That is wicht. e 2 8

2. 93. Why. did vow: e e feel a. „

* probably did see it cool off, but not until the ·

high tension discharge had stopped; that is, that cool.

ing off would have been such a very: rapid process;

that is, you must bear in mind that the very hot spot

in the centre of the cathode where the Positive ions
were focused was a very tiny area and that the bal-
ance of the cathode, the surrounding metal, was prob-. .

4 - ably only at red heat so that it would take a very small

fraction of a second, a very small fraction indeed, when
the positive ion bombardment ceased, for the tempera-

ture of that central very hot spot to sink to essentially
that of the surrounding metal. 5

Q. 94. Was it a thing that you ‘could: ‘conveniently 35
and safely observe anyway, . 5

. A. Not as. conveniently as one 8 sieve in

oe incandescent lamp, because of the need of Protect;

ing oneself from the X-rays.

0.98. How cool would that hot spot au the cath
"= ode have to be,\looking at it from the present knowl

6 . tao make ring

“out electrons sufficient to maintain that tube in action 5
Ae gp ep, sa he Ale e ehe g
“below 3 eer sox tion ti ;

Les. :
0 „

3 PRT Red ord

5 e 7 0 4. y
wae Ros 4 N ei a 5

* 0 a Why in mmm Sit at ea amen; De-
A. It is convenient for the Dobtor using the tube

to have his patient placed in many cases horizontally
with the photographic film underneath, and: ‘then the .

é 133, And. that will throw the X-rays down, will

ja maseive tungeton anode like he |
0 185, Which is Plaintiff's Exhibit No, 42. What

z, all panel: ‘which are — this e
lidge filed his ap-

eee

-William-D. Coolidge —

fancy there will be no trouble going over the book
with defendant’s counsel. eine
MX. Hatomr: I understand mat that ig he
4 vouched for by Dr. Coolidge?) :
Beth etn Mr. Davis: It is another book. This is the
second book. I offered the first one.
„Tus Cours: This one has now to bgshown—
We, ‘the last question was abet to this book, was
it not? Sma ves 929 N *

7

Mx. Davis: Ves. 8 ‘ae
Q. 136. I have not asked him whether: the ‘entries 5
are correct, and now do sot "
A. Yes, Mr. Davis, to the best of ‘my knowledge
and belief.
Mr. Davis: I offer in silent the selected »
pages of this book to be supplied. wok 5
MX. Darpy: Do I understand that you offer 5
this book up to the filing date of the —— Be
2 or Coolidge patent? 5 g
Mn. Davis: Coolidge.
en ane Tabou think, but 1 ‘do. not.
‘know-——. |
M Dav: I am perfectly willing that my.

*

i ene An right, ‘ho yee to be sp
lie given a

56 7

oy Pati 8

— Coolidge 7 7 1510

ae Les. pny ee
139. Now, will you read the paragraphs 1
from the very first!!
A. Work with tube 112% 1

140. No. I mean the paragraph beginning
n the words, From the very first. 20

A. (Reading: N

“Prom the very first turning on of the cur-

rent, this tube has focussed sha As a result,

it has been easy to heat the target so as to get the

gas out of it. The tube was therefore in excellent

condition after perhaps one hour’s work. on my
after it had come ont of fhe oven.“ ina

141. do on.
A (Reading): MESES

5 were fresh. ones, 80 » this ex-
periment demonstrated conclusively that the tar
get has been the troublesome source of gas,
the lack of focussing, when running as an ordin
arxy tube, that is, before getting the

g _ ‘eum, has boon what hag made the tabe exhaust
2 e end e way

1520 Wahan D. Coolidge

* Q. 144. Did you have any trouble getting tus gas
out of the electrodes?
A. We had a great deal of trouble; if the tube was.
operated while the vacuum was too poor, the glass 5
which supported the cathode structure was bombarded
and liberated gas. This, of course, increased the gas
pressure in the tube, and hence the positive ion bom.
bardment, and we had a more or less run-away ,
and in the first plare rs
« Q 145. I am not sure that is clear. I would Ihe
to ‘be very sure that is clear. Your cathode een
ment heated what? a

1

Ys A. The glass. tube supporting the atrue-
5 ture: that is, the positive: ions are dir _ by the
5 electric foree towards the cathode end of the —
if and with the early designs which we used,

düse ions would bombaid the glass su to the ath 3

e exhaust, Doctor v. :
are-talking about, nau! 1721 i

„ During the exhaust; ind by their bomburdet
| would liberate from that glats tore. gal, and that

0 90 — Coolidge | 1521

2

@ 148. That is aotually melting’ « hole throngh

4 the glass, is it? wie

A. The hole & usuhlly melted through after the
erack has taken place, Thé electrical discharge, then
goes through as the air rushes in, and by its ant,

caves a melting of the glass. 8

Q. 149. Win vow ee e ee e ‘yom
were saying when I interrupted you!

A. We had this trouble frequently, that the high
tension discharge instead of confining itself to the,
tube—afid bear in mind, pleasef that the tube was in
these egrly experiments connected to the pump sys-
tem the electrical discharge instead of confining it-
self to the tube, would often go down this connecting
tube towards the pump and puncture the glass conneci-
So com ors

Q. .

5 5 “of a work?

rotary oil pump, such as used inthe inc
south exhaust.
. 151. And between han pump andthe tab, what
d you haves idle

| ore re 2

me .

Ss re —
to

A. It did S cee high’ venue,

Sy 2 ABRs What dd fon d As
A. I acquired N | n e

a er Does that give the high vacuum? ed

penne 27

seen cena pcre e wie
7 : : 0 a tei 5

.
Wipes egy buy Pr aR) SOS
re

*

kor this work !:?!

a are of . bet N

nba yh e e
1 F Wes i 1 :
eee Dita oo
, yp elmer Puig ey sat ra OP Bete
* A 5 ve 8 ae * f
enn ee

Willian D. Coolidge 1 15²9
Mn Davis: Yes, sir. The difference between

ait e eee Fleming valve take the keno- 5 25

tron. It is the modern three - electrode tube with-
ont the third electrode. We are running into ques-
tions of terminology, but my understanding is that
if the voltage is high enough to get-up a velocity

in the electron to cause it to emit X-rays when it

1 atrikes the anode, that that is an Xray tube
5 whether you call it it 80 or r not. eae Me
5 es

By Ma Dai Dee | latent

. 184. Ts that right? „
A. That is right.
. 185. If you ran a e at 100,000 Ba you

8 want to protect people around it against the 5

4 X-rays that would come from 8

A. There is this thing to be said, Mr. Davis, that
‘when the hot filament of the kenetron is e
as cathode, yon have a voltage drop of only perhaps a

few hundred volts between cathode and anode, so that. 9

‘the electrons then F 5
tron have a velocity e only toa a rape a A

ended vt On the next half as 8 asgur

tt ge noo hare a leans ee
| — ee me

a r a "

1580 | William 5. 2

Q. 187. That is, in one case you are using De
in the kenotron you are using it in series with
5 nas and you are eee the voltage i in 1 13 d
hah A. Tes.
188. And in the Kray tube you consume b :

voltage where?! „
A. In the X-ray tube itself. The less voltage that ,
you consume in the naten the more dale the de
Vice becomes. Sut oe
2. 189. But the kenotron must bold back be
whole voltage? *
A. Yes, on the ae alt wave, and let it b

x through freely on the other half wave. 35

5 5 q

Q. 190. Referring to this Lilienfeld-Rosenthal : =
ticle, are you familiar with the disclosures of those 9
articles taken as one! anon 1
A. Lam.
. 191. If the tube therein disclosed + were *
time in a condition of exhaust such that if a disch
_ flowed in it it would be a pure electron disct

* No, Mr. Davis, it could not.

* t higher than that
FFC Me

William D, , Coolidge

a 4. L bend soy that it would, e
2. 196. And as vou _ continued to increase the
vacuum, what would happen 5

„A. The number of available positive is would ang
decrease and the positive ion bombardment of the main
- gathode would decrease and the current then, the main

discharge current flowing through the tube, would oe
- Grease.. s
8 197. ‘Tn: that tube d Weh Gib f e
is a certain auxiliary anode which is described as an

aluminum sheath: Do you remember that description? 3

A. Yes. ae !

. 198. What is the We Gon deseribed and ee

illustrated, the structure and artangement. of 8955 .
ee ee RE mt 5 A abet ae

A. Shall I read, Mr. Davis? W e
199. Tell a ie 44/8 peil waves Ber .

A It 00 ists of a tube of aluminum as I remem-
tert, VCC
0. 200. e fio: 58H e eee ile teehes :

pity of lasing up tat anode sha so sf

have it reasonably free of gas? a
a FP :

Mx. Davis: That is all of the direct: ia
) Tua Covnr: ee e t ben td 1
defer the cross-examination of Dr. oe or
e en that this afternoon ?

a — mada we ae prepare :

the atio , but we would like to

1532 Wiliam D. ‘Coolidige ae a f 5
82823 Wa e D. Oe resumes the stand. * ee
3 4 _-Onoss- Examination, iat i ae

By Mn. Datev:

XQ. 201. The X-ray tube, Dr. Coolidge, is an
tron discharge device, is it not? That te enna |
_ confine it to the so-called Coolidge X-ray tube; ‘that in
an electron discharge device, is it not!
. I would say so, yes. 8
1 XQ. 202, And in those X-ray e e
von always employ pure tungiten, electrodes as distin.
_ Suished from filaments containing beneficial addi
tions f
„eee
X. 208. You still do 8 8
ae een
XO. 204. And when did am 8

Coolidge
X-ray tubes first come.on the market, commercialy;it

you know!

iy ty eo op pie ©
> laboratory w. t ont late in 1913. I do not remember,
ue Beige emen

e was at tubo that left the ab

cB

„
‘ee

e 1
geese gon do ben tens

0

| 9 2 Willian D. Coolilige ~ "1588

/

- XQ: 210. And that was the. first, disclosure he,

ead to you of the results of work he! d been carry: i
ing on up to that time?
A. The question seems a little bit v

45

eee eee. 225
X. 211, Let me make it more ba find on

poaage 325 of your notebook: 8

cathode is with a very fine of one
or two- hun . is At higher
Baieon coren bose measurable a
2500 degroes e rca ue at about
% Tos there recorded whist Dr. Kg
+ |. that ig correst, is it not!? !
A. That is correct. pga
Boe gS 8 sad a Sem nal eee Ripon: .
7 te * Wert a
ne Bias cathode elem
a 05 ant id ot teying tot in an Kray tbe was ae
+: wn origina idea, was it not! 5 2
1 . Langmuir suggested to me that I try this
3
a Bae
SS) day: BAB. e eee e
a : out on an X-ray tube eri |
0 A. Les. N e ee

Hs,

e erer ihn haar thin a wtp of :
Edison effect, the current in the dase ‘of a hot

ee set The enen does a 80 o at, ai viet 910

e to me, a

*

- 8 da
— «2 2
„
Oe TOKE TS
.

i SEE fos wu D. bebe,

. May thee aeons on onee more. ( 0 215 .
ne repested ag rscörded.) 1 An just a little bit confused.
as to whether you mean the note here or Wis T have.
3 testified o. .
. XO. 216. I wean that it is yout eben 2
. ne ‘of the conversation had that day in the —
absence of any statement to that effect in the note-
„ book, that Dr. Leni: told you t try this daf in an :
Tray tube? 185 .
A. it he suggested. tos me to be ta if; out in an 55
Fray tube yes, sir. +
XQ. 217. and then the note in your notebook
- Rontinues: ;

“The share easy be i in line with my obser- oe
vations on pages 171 to M 085

That is correct? 5 5
. That is correct. ste

XC. 218. And the entries on pages 171 to 175 5
late to work that was done ‘on May 8, 1912; is that
yer cen 2

Na Evade hiked Vhsckl pag once tacke!

XQ. 219. Pages 171 to 175, the same ones that
you mentioned?

A. The entries ee Ne rg a dual .
carried out on that date, and in part to experiments .
which I of trying. 2

1% 3QO8 Brat teas tac! was made on May.

a

winiam D. Coolidge

eic . course, it is high enou gh, and that
eS there. will no longer be any such thing as 4 too
high vacuum. The tube resistance will apparently ;
de determined by the temperature of the eathode.’’
That is a correct reading of the entry in your note: -
“AS Ven Shalt igs) 226 Fh

52

X. 222. And it is to that matter that you re.

ferred, in part, at least, in your entry under date of
December 10, 1912, where you stated: e
The above would be inline with my obser-

vation of pages 171 to 175.“ 3
A. That is correct. rite! es Oe

_ XQ. 223. That portion of the-entry that I have

- just read to you that appears on page 175, is not that

exactly the same thing, or is not that the same thing
that Dr. Langmuir told you, or at least that you testi-

fied Dr. Langmuir told you on December 10, 19127

.

A. I should say nßo.

*

William 2 Coolidge:

_ ‘where ee stopped while the. 1 Was eal
het?.« 44.4
i BaF
XO. 227. You: knew ‘that the enthiode was rnin.
tained at a high temperature by ion bombardment, did
: you not?
8 A. Yes, but. I did not understand it as ‘well then
as I do now.
XC. 228. You: knew. that if the ions be,
scaroer, the heating would become less, did you not
8 Les, unless there. was some other cause of
beating. a |
ines 229. And you ed knew. that the i ions 1 1
become less as the vacuum got better? ‘
an,,
Mr. Davis: I do not like to Ss eat the cross-
examination, but if my. brother’s purpose is to
a. prove that Dr. Coolidge would have. reasoned 30
and 50, if he would have been more intelligent
pits then he was at the time, I think it would be im
| terial.
3 Covrr:. I do not Scie Mr.
Darby's questions to be to that effect. I under.
stand them to be somewhat different, and for
_ that reason I am not sustaining the objection.
_ XQ. 230. You were running your pump at . 8
time that observation was me by. 08. were 8
not? . 5
es ‘Yeu, Mr. peg ea |
Sa SIS a tc ra

~ William D. Coolidge. eee

5 X 233. And un I veidaeateind ie 1m e died

of the fact that it did not occur to you at that time

that you were so much impressed by the result of 15
current stopping; is that correct? =
A. I think that is correct. 4 58

ae 0 kr pen eit il mos: de 80 bad: # rill
want any guess on it, just what reason for this effect
did you think of at the a sen that m of the current
suddenly stopping? 5

8 Fenn den yon: at mis lese gest Wit iy
5 state of mind was at the time, except that I drew this
discouraging conclusion that I did not get electrons
from hot tungsten in a good vacuum.

XO. 235. Did this convince vou that e
would not come out of the tungsten uy dasaling white
heat in a good vacuum?

A. That was the: conclusion’ that 5 drew at e
time, ves.
XQ. 236. And was this the first ade that 704

| “hed ever obtained yourself. that igtPated this?”

A. I should say so, yes.

XX. 237. And up to this time you thought elec
_ trons might come out of mek re N in a ae
; 20.54 But this — convinced you'that
your former pinion wa, rong nd
8 XO 239. sa re you ny we one.

: “conclusions were erroneoust | =
A. That is correct. Ae PRES ee
ao 240. ‘Whien aia you become « conv’ 1 ah nat

: Beery word f * ee TR: e N 5
8 = 241. Ten wür know, 7 do you mo hati you

„ wien b. ‘Coolidge: oe
—.. eetunlts Mivaindk trae anit =

a the tube would have kept on operating as the vacuum
got better and would have kept on operating at jut
the time that vou n 98 e mar

~~ tungsten plate, it is my ux

stopped?
A. That i is .

aide souroe to very high temperature, you know that

XQ. 242. 1 . wat shove. eal have a é

: tices still enough gas to produce some ions under such
a condition and that this hitting sueh a hypothetical 13
hot cathode might have caused it to have a short life
unless the filaments were quite large, but without con-
_ sidering that phase

A. Excuse me, Mr. Darby, you confuse me a little oe 5

bit by. talking about filaments. I thought you were 5
talking about this e of tangaten. that was used in
‘that early tube.

XQ. 243. Did you not employ also. a filament 205 3 5

‘that early tube?

: XQ. 244. It was the pate of tungsten that you a
heated to incandescence? 1
A. Yes, sir: 5 A

20 245. That is right. If at the time ofthat,

experiment you had had a filament in place of the hot

85 = been still 3 to aay read ions nd

*

e I had‘at that time a very massive tangsten tar 2

ve 0 246. Then, as 1 understand it, it ie your be-
a lief that the amount of ionization present, would have
been harmful, is that it? © ©.
| Tun Oovrr: Wen’ 7 rend that question

5 (XQ. 245 eee ti the stemigtepher.)
A. (Continued.) I think, Mr. Darby, that the
g mount of positive ae would have er wer
great because—— = 5
X. 247. Would it e ee eee 5
ened, e Ves, Mr. Darby, harmful, if I may finish, harm-
ful in this way, certainly, that the tube would have
been very unstable indeed, that is, the filament would
certainly have been heated by that positive ion bom-
bardment in the vacuum which I would have had at
that time in that tube and that would have made the
tube very unstable as an X-ray tube. i
| XQ. 248. Now, in connection with your direct ex-
amination on the claims that were in your application

es they were originally filed, have you any independent

recollection today of the interpretation that you gave

oe
tion?
: 4 Mons whatever, Mr. Barbe
ee _ XQ. 49, Will you jut very brich tell me the dit !
3 of

. e We u and. te t e tube? 4 :
eee a Jn the old X-rey tube the electrons were lib

B40.
“number, the old’ X-ray tube: ö

- Tn order to coe these cate metal will

uin the X-ray tubes mel, th art, I. remove the

Cause of the trouble, namely, the gas in the tube

and p the 2 from the cathode nt.

essary to the ——— of the X-rays, not bya

os bombardment of the cathode by positive ions die
_ to ionization of the gas by the voltage impresge

upon the tube, but by heating the cathode to in.

3 _, gandescence by energy from a suitable sour oe. :

As Dr. ‘Langmuir told you that, did he not?) 5
A. Les. e eee
„ in the X-ray tube as a source.

75 XQ. 259. 250. Ten four patent goes on: a 45
In tubes made according to W
5 pass -gliminate, the action of positive. —— far as it

4s ssible to do so by evachating the. tube to the
: 2 vacuum which can possibly be ed
and by . rae the e frm

= ge on Langs did that to you; hat was is
5 nete 5
ae Ai, a not b bone un make a X-ray .
eig the pare electron discharge. 8
ositive ee eee it n possible ee . en
in; the taube to the highest vacuum which ould.

88

: ee 8

wien D. Coolidge

att XQ. 261. You ‘new? Hid 1a
A. I knew from my own 4
XQ. 26 2 Do you deny that he did?

A. No. I knew of my own knowledge about
: the harmful fet of positive ions in X-ray tubes of
the prior att, but q Ve it whey, that he told me
that.
: Mn. 93 5 ad the previous question.
(Previous N Ne record se soasieeis as re-
corded.)
ie XO. 263. He did not t all you car it, but * 2
0 told vou. to do it; is that pussy, * 8 8

0 A. He suggested that 1 do it, that is correct.
X. 264. And in doing it, hi told you-to eliminate |
the action of the positive ions, did he not?

or ‘Well, I do not er to me, oe

Mr. Darby. : :
X 2865. Did he tell you to e thé tube to
ae. the highest vaenum which could possibly be obtained“?
A. I do not think so, Mr. Darby. T think Dr. Lang-
muir told me about his own experiments.

XQ: 266. That ison ety Aae Docter Did

a he tell you to thoroughly free the electrodes from gas!

A. I do not think so, Mr. Darby.”
XX. . V
those things, did he not? i
A. Not sane
0 206 Ta wi Gesten dinchange device?
ee

MED ivdl’. The Ray Covlidge eee j'ai

- of in guit, and again I dislike in the slightest degree
d interrupt cross-examiniation that has a value,
baut it it is directed to the validity of the Coolidge

patent, T object. That is to save time. The pat-

ent is already in the record.

. ent here.

Mn. Dakar: I an not t the Coolidge pat. ae

a) | William: D. Coolidge

85 un Gonne I think this cross-examination is on
_ within the field of reason, Mr. Davis. ae

By Mn. Danpy: - @
XQ. 269. VV od
Dr. Coolidge, that an X-ray tube is an electron dis.
ass device; that is correct, is it not? na
A. That is correct...
XQ. 270, Then your patent states:

uns a cathode I ordinarily use a tangs fila-.
ment.“

.

Dr. Langmuir told ve, to use a tungsten filament, did
he not!
„ only he: i of that question that trou
bles me at all, Mr. Darby; I do not know that Dr. tangs
| apc ap) caverns: ae taba cammpepe saul atten
_ X-ray tube, but he did tell me about his experiments
in which he had used tungsten filaments. 3%
ere ee asym ee da pen that :

somite your original idea, don't “=
. gees ha e alracdy.to ose cans | 8
in which Id ee ee eee

uree of electrons in an X-ray tube. =
274. I see. en that was your original idea,
u carried 1 tr ith you eee ee
912; J unders eee ee 5

William D. Col 5 15⁴⁵

ee repeated by ane stenographer as
follows: N
A, 1 did abandon the idea.’ 0

i X. 275. And the ultimate result of the present
tube employing a a tungsten filament was Dr. Lang
mirs suggestion to you'of December 10, 19127.
A. It was the result o . Langmuir’s communi-
"alos ioe Of Dede Ot. |
j 10 278. AuGt that communication explicitly con: 0
= ata aunt hea Lares a
12285

40 a. All richt. W de pet an 3

“I have found that ag ct will be emitted |

trom such a cathode.” 5
ae filament dete e,

which electfons will traverse the space between
the cathode and the targe 1 35
the ‘electromotive force impresse upon the tube,
e of the target, il ge i s
to Xrrays.“ . Tg

3 Mak wan part of what Dr. Langmuir ragged to you, you,
ght 3 5
1 A. Well, Dr. Langmuir cortainly did 01.
2. 278. Can you answer that?

Mn. Davis: Let him answer it. 3 a

se *. 279. Will you anéwer the question, please, and
0 = in it later i
a A. Well, I guess the answer is yes and no. 1 ae
“may explain, I should say that the experiment which

Dr. Langmuir described to me, the work which he told
ie about, was h small tube with two metal filaments,
ö filaments in it. It certainly was not an X.

abe, and I did not feet tien, and do not feel now. ae

1546 wise, b. Cooliage

that Dr: Lange told me how to make an X-ray taba,
He suggested to me that I make an X-ray tube em 8
ploying the pure electron discharge. i hed 0 oe
deal to learn, Mr. Darby, in deing that work. i=
told you about that point. as

3.080. Nou hewe'aid several times, Doster, ai.
em confining my entire cross-examination to -ex
pressed to vou on express things. Now,

T understand fundamentally that you say that Dr
Langmuir that you constract an X-ray tube,

having a hot f 2 sp mans
tron flow ie that vorrect! ;

A. That is correct.
XC. 281. Dr. Langmuir suggested that to yout
A. That is correct.

XQ. 282. And I also am assuming in my ques
tions, that Dr, Langmuir knew wast an X-ray ae
was, or that he would not! Abs t

. am sure he did. 4

Be e eee

EF

A. Gertainly. 5

S eee

rs 5 = ow, my question i by
1 reed pit 5 |
“electrons willl |

William D. Coolidge - 1

10 287. I bee. Was he sure that you knew that
3 would be emitted from the testen :cath-

Ma ne l Darby, just how sure he 8.

PPP
micht very safely have assumed that, because I had
~ the greatest faith in what Dr. Langmuir told me about
his work.

XO. 288. The next statement of the patent is:

Ret in this new type of tube positive ions ap-
- pear to play no role whatsoever.’

Dr-Langmuir told you “hat, did he ‘hot, that in d tube
construeted in accordance with his suggestions, that
positive ions would play. no part HOTS: in the oper-
ation of the tube?

A. I do not say that, Mr. Darby. ib 3

XQ, 289. You do not think so? #

A. I do not believe Dr. ee peal e
D

thousand volts on that tubeQ.

| 10 290, You do not think he told you hatt

A. Ido not think so.
5 XQ 21 Then he nxt eue in your .

eee

S

566 we N Cooliage — ae

.
. 298. Then you state: |
* te Be;
eum . ¥ 358. They seem to be fairly full there; 4
this time, . along every day, don’t they (hand- L
ak ing book) T
A. I hope so. I am afraid not every dax.
359. Look before you get up. I say every
day. I mean practically every day.
A. think it depends on what part of that note
book you strike.
OO 300. ieee ss eee
richt along here, where the going is good.
A. Here, Iesee a certain adh
X. 361. And before that the öth !
A. Lou will find them ERener after this, J
: Haight, because we soon became very much i ateres
"indeed in that type of X-ray tube. a 4
i XQ. 362. You have. no other suggestion 6 5
tio why, Jon did ot rie down e de We
ten of tls petite Wo tay thes, an tet ‘act th i
Sn ii

-

ie

G

dene v. . Hogam 5

A. No, sir. l
Mn. Dany: : That i is —
Mn. Davis: That is all.

ee Wes PMY HOP od

| 1 Mn. W Your Honor, at the close of

| cross-examination of the witness Kelly, re-
quests were made for some data, and I now wish

to have marked for identification Kelly Data for

Defendant’s Exhibit No. 56,’’ E for Identification.
‘This data we submitted to our opponents . the day
before yesterday.

(Received and marked Defendant's Exhibit :

for e J . BS

JOHN V. L. HOGAN.

7 Joun v. I. Hogan, was recalled i in rebuttal, on be
half of the plaintiffs, and having been ned ind :

sworn, ne further as follows:
4 N. Dmner —
By Mr: Epmonpe:

Q. 104. Mr. e i

“with the defense’s material in this case, including the

‘the deposition as taken in Sen Francisco?
A. That is correct

“dectror .at at 8

| re ater for unit rae than nll rut tl papi

2 55 195. gp frre al

ot patents and publication as referred to by Pro- ©
Chaffee, and the prior knowledge and use and 2

1

1564 9 John F. L. Hogan 2 |

- independentiy’ of. and in tae presence af positive ion
ization? . 3
ae a | do not. : „

196. Do you find in that material a Aries op

j “erating by pure electron discharge independent of.

positive ionization having a conductor comprising a
refractory metal and a surface ‘film of thotium metal
vaporizable at. a temperature above about 2900 de.
grees K., and haviilg a greater electron emission whe;
at incandescence, in a non- striking vacuum than said.
refractory metal? : nel Ovens
A. No, I do not. 98 *
Q. 197. Do you find there an electrical discharge |
device, having an electrod» comprising in part at least

. _, oxidizable thorium material, said electrode ‘having

ay

at a temperature of ahout 1300 to 1380 degrees abso-
lute an electron emission substantially equal to that

or tungsten at about 2000 degrees absolute 5

A. No, I do, not. .

Q. 198. And finally, an electrical discharge deve |
having an dlectréds comprising métallic tungsten and
thoria, said electrode being subjected to a temperature -
of about 2200 to 2350 degrees K., and: having an seg
‘tron emission a thousand times as great per unit e

ah %% (( 7

positive ionization? —
A No.

Q. 199. Do you find! red
apart from any reference to the Wehnelt cathode

John P. 2 Hogan

N N 0. 3 with proper temperature treatment,
the film would not form use thorium is so. sen-

5 sitive to oxidation that the partial pressure of oxygen

in ev the best X- ray vacuum of the old days would

de enough to destroy (by oxidation) the: thorium as
fast as it appeared. pee

; Q. 201. I think you might explain that.a little more

a fally at this point if you will.

A. Ihave made an additional assumption and that
is to say that in addition to putting in a lamp filament

one gave it a-temperature treatment corresponding to

activation treatment that is described in the s&cond

patent, and I: have said that even though that were
done so that thorium would distill outward through

the filament to the surface, as it appeared. on the sur-
‘face of the filament the oxygen ‘which would neces-

| sarily be in the tube at a pressure of three microns or

more, that is to sdy an X-ray tube pressure, it would
instantadeously, practically instantaneously. oxidize

and destroy the thorium on the surface of the filament

and 80 prevent its contributing to emission.
g Q. 202. So that what emission you got vom such

u tube would be tungsten emission and not thorium 15

emission? 8
a "A. It would be practically the emission of pure
. tungsten, and, of course, if you do not give it the tem-

1 perature treatment the thorium would not even come

out of the filament that then the emission would be

55 0 that of e Seu

a a i gt NEY eta
| the highest possible vacuum, were given a tube and the

_ tube was operated at the normal filament temperature

PPP
Fe dite: 4 5

i. on a

high vacuum ents as would be e a
charge operation in accordance with the first patent
in suit, but also the character of vacuum, the quality .
of vacuum, which has a partial pressure of oxygen
fat below below that which is necessary for the 3/2 power
22 and sufficientiy low to prevent rapid or in
act any oxidation.of substantial amount of thœium.
If the F 6
as good in the vacuum in the modern tubes using al!
—— the patents in suit, and the filament were op-
erated at normal cathode temperatures for tungsten, ©
that is to say temperatures above 2400 degrees K., the |
eee ee ee ee eee eee 5
tungsten lamp, (which were exceeded if anything in 1
ö used in 1913, or re
te rium if there was

ine
“Hi
Bi
He

fed and secondly, he emision would be lite if
higher pure tung- —
—— r the exhaust it would be no higher * 3
ezeee, eg, .

; Kei. te pAb 44

yeti ewe die
Seth N He mils I heats

8 * *
iy atime A N
We n „ one of Pre
* noth; Alera aie !

John V. L. Hogan 1507

stantially absent, and a quantity of a vaporizable re-
- ‘ggent capable of preventing ‘the oxidation of thorium
in communication with . . space within ven envelopt
A. No, I do not. vie
Q. 206. Or a disclosure of 2 an dictate discharge
Pa comprising electrodes, one of which consists of
metallic tungsten and a thorium material i an oxid-
- jgable state, an inclosing envelop, and a quantity of a
vaporizable réagent within said envelop capable f
preventing the oxidation of thorium at an elevated tem-
A. No, that be does not appear.
«3, . 207. Or an electrical discharge device oompris-
Ds a sealed envelop, electrodes therein one of which
is of the thoriated type and a film of magnesium de-
posited onthe inner surface of 21d envelop? |
A. No., ue
2.208. ‘Or an electrical * devioe compris-
he’ a container, electrodes therein one ok which con-
sists, largely of refractory metal and co an ox -
ide of a metal of high electron emissivity'which when
is sensitive to ion bombardment > BG

55 oS Jop

2 > AL Yes, I haye read all of them, i ar
. 1 8 0 I wish/you would take up those abe ae. re :
. the order in whic Professor Chaffee discussed then,
if you find that cgnvenient, and say what if anything
Fou find in them/bearing upon the second, mird and. 4
; ‘fourth patents: ih this suit? 1
: . If it is. equally. satisfactory I think it. might
be more convenjent to take these up in the order 04
the exhibit numbers, that is to say in the order in. whi
they were introduced. I think that agrees in general
with the order that Dr. Chaffee used, but it es it
more pr less chronological. ee. :
. The first patent is that issued to Malignani, No 92
537,693, April 16, 1895. This is a lamp evacuating |
ent and has to do with the so-called chemical evacua-
tion of lamps. Malignani in the process ‘described
first evashates thevdamp to about two millimeters gas

pressure, page 1, line 36 of the. patent. That corre 4 |

sponds to 2000. ee pressure.

He then lig * filament, driying off, of as he
calls it: eee in the filament, the. refer
ence being Page I, Iine 40, and then he vaporizes ar- :
' genic; what. he calls ‘‘gulphuric,’? r ioding,, which as

Vapors are intended to combine ith gas within ths.
85 lamp and to precipitate. 20
The Malignani process as it in referred 10 in n the
lamp industry uged phosphorus instead of arsenic or
iodine or sulphuric, which I believe means sulphur,

and in any event the whole e exhausti effected de-

pends upon ionization ‘of the vapors o and i.

: : not a simple a tion; that is to n th hi

e phosphorus was vaporized in the da i .

hi —＋ peroes he filament terminals and in that e
ese ag intense ionisation. the i

thorium filament. d

us to a fair lamp vacuum as of that tir

‘John V. A Hogan a a.
The Peel was nit used so far as e
0 on low voltage A
son that without high voltage across the filament tereni-
nals, the necesgary ionization would not se ee is ae can
Ot course, the disclosure and the 4 use ot, ay
the process involved lamps, not thermionic tnl t
tubes containing any metals or electrodes vt
the filament. Ot course, there was no hi 4

The initial pressure was 3 7 it he
was reduced by the vaporizing and i an ae

pes vn eh eee e :
tronic device. | “ately
As. to any indication of the am
; it due may call the phosphorus 8 re. :
up, it is perfectly clear and it is’ — at
ok ; patents a I may sortie falignani

f commercial articleQ..

to ioding, mile I know of no tests having been made

must be Smoke The re for the
ple. The reason is that the device is a lai
walls must not be cloudéd if it ‘into be a

is 9 As to the specific materiale: este a 3
nani, it hae heen: fend in
iated filament by temperature treatment in the pres-

5 ende of vapors of arsenic, sulphur, or phosphorus. As

eee enen ne eee

of,. no utility in a thermionie devioe.

Weeall xeroember: béttles-of dedine in cha chew:

ical laboratories in which the blue vapor even at room

temperature is perfectly visible, and that of course

2 men very: high: pressure:.in}terme: ese ope

sures: @ PEI
n there in si e e ice Moliguanl: ae

eae of any ne action as @ result. of wee Of

8 : 2 4

ete

8

e = 1570 5 ee ＋. Hogan. it

the at til used. The clean-up. is a simple lamp
dlean- up going from a very high pressure of thou- |
Sands of mier to a lamp pressure of the order of |
ten microns of less, not below one or two microns in
any-event, and once that is done the reagent is through,
its funetion has been performed and there is no sug-
gestion that it has any further utility.
One other point might be mentioned i in ecmmoction ‘
with this Malignani patent, and that is, that in the .
customary use of mercury pumps with lamps, the
' phosphorus. that was used in the Malignani process,
that is, phosphorus in general, and I am not referring
to any particular kind of phosphorus, but phosphorus
aß used in the Malignani process, does not take up
the mercury vapor so far as I have been able to find,
and consequently the partial pressure of mercury
: amounting to a micron, and a half at room tempera-
N 3 ‘Saxe wend setmain within ny tube in-which one ursd
8 a. une it without wpecial means of enen
ho gee think that e the Malignani patent and I will”
| e Defendant's Exhibit 7, which is U. S.
Patent 596,694, issued to Dwyer on Jeriuary 1% 18085
Tguis again is a lamp evacuating patent and in the
| process described. Dwyer pumps his lamp, as for ex- a
. . ample by a mechanical or mercpty pump, page 1; line
21, to what was probably a lamp vacuum of a few « —
microns. ‘He then lights his filament to expand che —
gases and to drive off gas particularly from the joints _ :
aes as illustrated in Figs. 2 and 3 of the patent, the joints
Coe the filament is fastened to the lead-in wires. 1
211. May ‘I> interrupt, Mr. Hogan? This
vaouum that you have referred to in connection with
5 this patent corresponds: to what he speaks of as 4
partial or incomplete vacuum at vein ag of the first’

et a ue ae

725

John .. Hogan “asm, ae

A. Les. He; says that that is readily: Ae By"
a good mechanical or mercurial pump, and in saying
two or three microns, I have given him the benefit of
‘the déubt. The partial vacuum which is insufficient —
might be as high as fifteen or twenty microns, because
the Tange of carbon lamp vacua, 80 far as I have been
able to determine may b as high as ten mierons.
: After heating the ent he vaporizes a con-
deer gas (and he suggests phosphorus for that
se) to displace the residual gas. The description
: i ybased-apen’ thé ides thet rou: whall piap! out to-a |
fair vacuum, a partial ‘vacuum, as stated, and then,
displace the remaining gases by means of some con-
|, densible gas and thereafter condense that oondensible
gas so leaving presumably a high vacuum.
: The practice with phosphorus is more likely 15
" correspond with what is understood to be the Malig-
nani effect rather than any displacemen of mol
which are widely separated in a partially evacua ;
vessel, by putting in another gas eee are
also widely separated, which does not re On en
„ displace gases at atmospheric pressures or thereabouts
with other gases, because of the collisions which will
force out the displaced gas, but when one is working
in an approximately or even fairly god vacuum, this
displacement does not oceur in the same way. 55
He specifies: that in any event the e 8
amount of material must be used, because of the pos-
sible coloring of the globe. He refers also as prior
‘practice to the use of mercury, iodine, sodium, potas-
sSium and arsenie by introduction and cooling, and
Dwyer’s improvement seems to be the use of phos-
www.... ((( .
phorus.
e ise ene en ee ia; i J Alii’ A
5 — all the gaen in the fube and —
Se the — —— of ssc repla | ee

¢

a)

WD Hogan

“Somewhat the. same comments apply to this 1
as to the Malignani patent and the practical Malig.
‘nani, process e 1d discussed iri-conncotion wit

* N

the Malignani patent.
It is not a ee 1 there are no electrodes

other thaiNthe simple lamp Glament; the filament it-
‘self is not ah oxidizable thoriated filament, that not
even being known at the time. There is no initial

low pressure, the pressure when the chemical and a
heating. treatment are applied Being high i in compari- o.

son with vacuum tube pressures.. The.same’ impossi-

bility of forming a thick film exists on account of the 8

device being a lamp. N

Tests have shown that the eee which is

shown as the best displacing.means will prevent the 3

activation of the thorium filainent when used to get
the vacuum according to the Malignani process, and

there is no hint of een a vacuum in a lamp of this oa
0 kind by Dwyer.

‘With reference to the prior art materials e
to at page 1, WWF

a pressure for use in vacuum tubes. It ionizes at room

temperature under a small voltage. Iodine I have men-

tioned before has the same disadvantage or the same

_ Characteristic which would prevent it «from being

used. Sodium and potassium, two matgrials men-.
tioned here, will work to attack oxygen and water
vapor and clean a vacuum of those gases if it is used :

as described in the third patent in suit here, but it
cannot be used that way in a lamp. No coating could

be tolerated in a lamp. There is no suggestion that

does “materials be aged in that way. :

There is no oxidizable filament to prpbect l 3
dhe pressures that Dwyer used, the sodium and potas.
sium would, I believe, be completely exhausted in any
—_— that eee ieee: in an et lamp

ce Jide . L. Hogan . 1578 |

den down to ome extremely thinatiA values that can. ex-
ist in a thoriated filament. vacuum tube without kill-
ing the emission of the filament in. a very short time.
Of course, there is no suggestion of any cold action,
any action in the absence of heat ee, of these a. ;
ep te ie Dwyer patent.
. 212. Before leaving that patent, Mr, en ‘
will you note that in the last paragraph on the second
page there is a feference to the use with greater or
less success, as Dwyer says, of ammonium euprous
chlorate : What have you to say as to that? artes
A. Thave never used ammonium cuprous chlorate =
in connection ‘with a vacuum tube, but I have no idea S
that it could be used with any effect. It would break
up and give off chlorine, probably hydrogen angpnitro-
gen, and while it might conceivably be partially use-
Jul for such a purpose as Dwyer’s, I am confident that
it would not 7 a sensitive thortam activated
klament. ie, „ 4
213. In any any event: the patentee erte ex-
1 a preference for phosphorus over all of the
8 other materials mentioned in this patent! he
A. Yes, there is no doubt about that. At page 2,
ie line 131 he says: I prefer: phosphorns to other ma-
terials.”” .
The next bib a which I 3 a rene ie
is a paper by Doane which is Defendant’s ‘Exhibit
II, and which appeared in the Electrical World and
Engineer for May 21, 1904, beginning ‘at page 963.
_ ‘The title is A Resume of ct ete
_ Exhausting.’’ And it is/an interesting running de-
Fk hau e e een gene gone .

ili nas mainly to do with mereury and } cephoras
p exhausts as they were used in the practice. Com-

8880
„

1574 Saar John v. ba Hagen

snes the type of oxhanst treated is alis ‘the
same. n
| I. might point ont that / on page 965 there j isa
warning that the operator has to be careful not o
*'_. *¥aporize too much phosphorus for the reasons that!
have indicated. The decrease of vacuum securable -

in the carbon lamps that were made with these er.
haausts, mercury and phosphorus exhausts, were very

a high compared to thermionic tube vacuums. 1
As TL have said; ten microns pressure was ordl.
Qo 2 satisfactory and might be reduced to a matter of

two microns in a carbon lamp. 85

10 On page 964 the Doane article refers (o a pre
liminary mechanical exhaust prior to a chemical ex.

haust which brings the vacuum down to 125 mill.
meters which is 125 microns. The further evacuation
to a satisfactory lamp vacuum being the —
evacuation of the sort that I have described. | :
As to the mercury exhaust referred to, of 4
. mermionie tube is l,

ee Fs the: bombardment of the ee e ve
fllament or n ions as soon as ionization 8

Saree Job F. L. Hogan 138575
i |. The purpose of the magnesium is given at page l.
"bib 77, to absorb injurious nitrogen and oxygen re-
maining within the co N i
The pressures in a device of this sort are of course
high. He refers to a very high degree of exhaustion ©
in an iron chamber at page 1, line 80, the thought be-
ing that if iron is used the attack of magnesium on
glass can he avoided. We all know from our experi-
ence with mercury vapor converters in steel casings,
that it is impossible to keep even the pressures that
are necessary for successful operation i in the practical
eases without having a pump going all the time, that
is to say, a vacuum pump. Iron or steel casings will
not permit a high vacuum to be held and yet such a
ing is suggested for what Von Recklinghausen calls
a very high degree of exhaustion at page 1, line 81.
Q. 214. The plain indication being what?
„„ fate plain indication being that his pressures
were really high, and what he called a high vacuum
cb would be what we would call in thermionic work or 5 5
even in lamp- work a very péor vacuum. oe
Trhuis converter or mercury lamp is not a ben |
dnie device, it has no filament, certainly no highly
_ oxidizable’ t; if there were such a filament as a
- thoriated catifode put. into a chamber of thie kind the
mercury ionization would at once strip the thorium —
uurface from the cathode. There is no low pressure
gases in the chamber at. any time, either in its con-
pie ese There is no hint in the specifi:
n sure |= ete eee Le

ee eee eee eee .
eee eee ee —

8 oe sod th robes ' 8 5

John V. L. Hogan

in fact I think I can say the certainty is that the x
oury vapor, the hot mercury vapor in a tube of t
sort would attack and wash off any film of m i
CCF
boat were vaporized rather than merely warmed e
heated.

80 tar as I know, ae is no vapor combination

| magnesium and mercury. ' Mercury.

vn por and that is an impossible condition of affai

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386008_0055%3A03. Public record. Not legal advice.
