# Motion — New Jersey v. City of New York

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386008_0038%3A12

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Motion
- **Published:** January 1, 1931
- **Citation:** 283 U.S. 473

## Text

“FILECOPY | was

= THE

Supreme Court of the Bnited States
- | QOcToBER rm, 1931. °

++
vo

No. 19min.

BLO
STATE OF NEW JERSEY,
Plaintiff,
_ 9.

THE CITY OF NEW YORK,
Defendant.

. MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ANSWER AND
APPLICATION FOR FURTHER RELIEF
_ AND SUPPORTING BRIEF.

eee eee te ne
_ [eee ne
Ls

W

~ArtHur J; W. Hity,
. Corporation Counsel,
Solicitor for Defendant.

¥

. Pandick Press, Inc., 22 Thames St., New York, U. S. A.

.

.
Vila noah Ske cee teie aac et

’
‘ °
e . . ‘
f . $ .
; ;
@. . *
. . e .
. ° 2 ¢ e .
oy ‘ : .
“ a a. O44
. s .
R t ; j .
: : ‘ / ‘
{ :
. ¥ .
«
. | ~
. :
e" td 7
, ° f . °
. . 7
. : ‘ . ‘
E
a ° ° . af
. ya . ‘4
= .
. e .
p . : : 5 *
.
. .
. . :
; . -
id .
. ad e Ld . .
‘ ’
0 , s ’
. a i
’ : ' hk |
. ‘ Pee ) : A
‘ ’ -
. ’ ‘ x ‘
. J / : ° :
° : Se .
. e,° & .
. © .
. + ‘
‘ :
‘ : 4 é
. a ° 4 . Py .
e
. “? ;
o 4 ‘@
. . . 3
’
ra . . P ’
e .
. ° = e t ‘ ®
: .
; : ' 4

: Motion for ec to File Answer and for ‘Further ye

cin Ok Mame ih erie nO As 2

coe dak: to Petition and Prayer for Further Relief... 3

| Defendant? S Brief. in Support of the Poregoing See
Application ee SR eat te No aaeere ee Wis Pe TEN eso ALER A 13 .

ae

IN THE -

Supreme Court of the United States

, OcToBER ‘TERM, 1931.
No. {3—Original

Srare or New Jenszy,
eet .
EPMA SETS PORE ESET oF Gre
-:

6

9. From abeuk midsummier'i in the year 1931 to the close.
of that year the defendant City could only obtain funds
for the purposes for which it was required to finance its
projects and operations through the sale of the short-term
corporate stock ‘notes authorized by Section 189 of the

' Greater New York Charter and contemplating: payment

out of the subsequent sale ier long-term corporate stock °
bonds.

=
f

.
eae
TP en Rema rae eopresc meme

10. On or * about December 93, 1931, the Comatnithat of
the defendant City, being, like the other members of the
‘Board of Estimate and Apportionment; gravely. concerned
as to the inability of the defendant City to raise funds in
the bond market, notwithstanding the true excellence of its

| fundamental financial condition, sought to. engage the co-
operation and assistance of leading financial houses with a -
view to enabling the defendant City to market its securi- |
ties and so provide the funds imperatively needed for past
incurred contract and land acquisition liabilities,

Answer to Petition - ‘and Prayer for Further Relief.

11, The confersiees of ‘the defendazit’ 's: Comptroller.

with the representatives of the aforementioned financial.
- and banking houses | brought no. successful result... There
' ‘was, however, sponsored as a result thereof, the adoption
+ by. the Legislature of the- State of New York.of a new sec-|
tion, to wit, Section 189- a of the Greater New York Charter

(New York Laws of 1932, Chapter 4) under which the de-
‘fendant’ 8 Comptroller was authorized to issue notes to be
known as special corporate stock notes not to exceed at any

wae - one time the amount of $200,000,000, which amount would,

and did, however, include all outstanding short-term cor--
porate stock notes of the defendant and was to be the utter. .
_limitation of the ‘borrowing power of the defendant City,

BB ecscoateatenived ens: eee rae

-
~s

except upen long- term ‘securities. :

: 12. The aforementioned sum of. $76, 700, 000, ‘ids was

payable within a year from date of issue, was included in °
the $200,000;000 referred to in .the preceding paragraph -

_ hereof and the amount: of special corporate stock notes made
available for use on Jariuary 20, 1932, by thesaforesaid Sec-

tion 189a of the Greater New York Charter, was the sum of — ie

$123,300,000. “Against this limit of $123,300,000 there were,

on January 1, 1932, outstanding liabilities for the following :

(a). Liability upon contracts registered

in the year ‘1931 and prior thereto... -, $136,745,000

(b) Liability for land acquired by con-
demnation, title to which had previ-—
ously legally vested in The City of

New York, estimated at-.............. aun * 52,500,000.

_- tiate its long term obligations ; apd this it will continue to 3
he unable to do until the financial condition of the country = |

. is prohibited fro
"than par.

|

Answer to Petition and Prayer for Further Relief. -

13. Nothing will cure, or be capable of. curing, the de-
| fendant City’s inability to engage in projects necessitating -. —
“the expenditure of capital finds except, an ability to nego-

- permits investors to. purchase long-term obligations. ‘In
* this connection the attention of the-court is’invited to the —
“fact that by Section: 182 of the Greater New York Charter
(New York Laws of 1915, Chapter 308) the defendant City

; pre m negotiating any of its securities at less:

_ 14. In the month of September 1931, and-tong prior to
the entry of the final decree herein, the proper authorities:
of the defendant City had been engaged in, and had com. ‘.
pleted the work of preparing plans and specifications for

‘four incinerators and the proposed contracts for each ‘of
the said incinerators. | | Fis

Ab. ‘These proposed contracts, plans and specifications. ,
were, on September 22; 1931, duly presented, as required by
the defendant’s Charter, to its Board of Estimate and Ap-
-. portionment for the approval required by law, preliminary —
to advertising for bids thereon and duly came before its.
Committee of the Whole on December 15, 1931, by which
they were restored to the. formal public calendar of the
City’s Board of Estimate and Apportionment fér Decem- |
ber 18, 1931, | ea re ane

16.. When the matter of the said four contracts came on

for public hearing before. the defendant’s Board of Esti-

9°]

\ ‘
ie. \ ’
. , . ‘
J “

g

Answer to Petition and- Prayer for Further’ Relief.

mate and Apportionment on December 18, 1931, objectors |

appeared and in regular course the matter was laid over to

January 15, 1932,

17. By January 15, 1932, when the matter of the said

_ four contracts again came on for public hearing before the
- Board of Estimate and. Apportionment. of the defendant

City, the firtangial situation hereinbefore-mentioned had be- ,
come so extremely acute that for the purpose of meeting its
accrued contract and land purchase obligations, the: de-.
fendant. City found it necessary to. adVoeaté the enactment
by the State Legislature of the above mentioned Section
189- a of the Greater New Tork Charter.

18. On J anuary 22, 1932, when the matter of the-afore-
said contracts again came: on for public hearing before: the
defendant’s Board- of Estimate and Apportionment, the
general financial situatien was even worse than it had there-

__———tofore been n thought to be, and, it was impossible for the

defendant City to enter into new obligations involving

the expenditure of capital funds. So dire, indeed; was the
situation, that the defendant Cjty has been obliged to dis-
continue very: many public improvements on which con-

“struction had been commenced. Amongst the improvements

which.the City has been so compelled ‘to discontinue are:

A. ‘The construction of the so-called Tri-Bor-

_. ough Bridge to connect the Boroughs of Manhattan,

Bronx. and Queens, spanning the East and Harlem

‘- Rivers. On this project, there had been, theretofore,

‘actually expended by the City of New. York a total :
of $4,000,000. The project’ was ulti ately te cost at

completion, a tatal of $40,009,000. \ | Cate

9

Answer to Petition and Prayer for Further Relief.

B. The Mid- Manhattan Tunnel Project, to con-
nect the west side of Manhattan Island ‘with New

Jersey, and the east side of Manhattan with ‘the

Borough of Queens, making possible one continuous
passage for vehicles from the State of New Jersey
under the island of Manhattan to Long Island, The
City: had actually expended or assumed a-total of -
"$2,000,000 on preliminary work-on this project and ~
up to the time it wag abandoned, no definite estimate
had been made of its ultimate cost, but it may be con- |

servatively stated to exceed that of the Tri-Boror
Bridge.

. During the 8 or 10. years prior to 1933, ‘the
' City of New York expended annually from $25,-

—_—

000,000 to $30,000,000 for the erection my equipping

of new school buildings and additions

to existing
school buildings: Commencing i in the Spring of 1932,
* the. City of New York entirely’ suspended the con-

struction of new school ices) and additions to.

existing buildings. 4

_ D. For several years the City’ of New York has *)
had under consideration the provision of additional _
sources of water supply from the watershed of the

Delaware River, and, in fact, was. obliged to. litigate

the question as to its right to such waters in this
Court. The plan contemplating the utilizing of the

Delaware waters has been estimated to require an |

expenditure of $250,000,000 to $300,000,000, and is
urgently needed so as to prevent an imminent short-

agé of water in the City of New York.. All work on |

this project has been suspended and, to dat®, all

authorizations for funds therefor have been either |

rescinded or refused.

\

Ber Sees is

: Answer to Petition and Prayer -for Further Relief.
_ a Patt
‘ E.° Commencing January, 1926, the City of New
York laid out comprehensive plans for the relief -
:of ‘¢ongestion in its then existing rapid transit sys-

_ tems and projected what has been ‘called the. Inde-
pendent: Subway System. . Despite the necessity for
completing this Independent System,.the City of New
York, commencing .in 1932, rescinded jauthorizations
‘then outstanding, and has refused to consider arly
‘further authorizations for expenditures of funds to_

/ extend said Independent System beyond the so-called -
ff - Eighth Avenue Line, and the links thereof then com-
“y . pleted or‘partially completed, . . Ditesh ieee}

‘

x _ F. The advancemént-of designs or the progress .
- Of construction on various types of buildings re-

quired for municipal purposes other than those above

_ discussed, such as hospitals and office buildings, has |

_ been entirely stopped. The City of New York las on
a plot in the Borough of - Manhattan, “oni rom
Centre, Leonard, ‘Worth ‘and Lafayette Streets, a
fgyndation erected for an office building for the De-
‘partments of Health, Hospitals and Sanitation, °
work upon which has been entirely. discontinued.

19. It is true as stated in the report of the Special

- Master upon re-reference, that appropriations have already

_ been provided for.incinerators in authorized localities; but

appropriations of. this natnre hy the B ard of Estimate

and Apportionment of The City of New York are merely

authorizations to the Comptroller to sell corporate stock
for the ‘purpose of raising the moneys appropriated. ‘

20. - Resolutions of appropriation merely indicate the —
purposes for which public funds, when raised, may be spent.
They do not indicate that the funds appropriated are in the
Treasury of the defendant City.

sd . 2 “ Aas! ; ” Pat) ‘ail

eT Sere
2 -

«

-

. Answer to Petition and Prayer for Further Relief. —

21: Despite: the impossible financial situation outlined ae

.

| ahove, with no improvement or prospect of “improvement
for the sale of long térnmi bonds of the City of New York, ‘|

the defendant ’s: Board of Estimate and Apportionment, in
the month of November, 1932, authorized the- Sanitary

_ “Commission of The City of New York to award contracts

for the construction of two incinerating plants, each with a
capacity of 750 tons per day of 24 hours, to, be located as ine
follows : ee te if sunnah , |
‘Contract A—215th-216th Streets, 9th to-10th Ave-
Pe? ea nue, Manhattan; «> ny,
Contract B—Zerega Avenue, between Lafayette

Avenue and’ Hermany Avenue,
ioe: a

the aggregate cost being $1,409,535, exclusive of plumbing
and heating. . ete oe ee eakien

22. The aforesaid contracts were duly registered pur- |

| _. Suant' to Section 149 of the Greater New York Charter, by

the Comptroller. of The City of New York, and constitute ~~
legal obligations of the City. © . Rs

23: The two above mentioned incinerators will be com- - |
pletedon April 1st, 1934; barring unforeseen contingencies, . —

24. When completed, these plants Operating as it is —
intended that they sifall operate, for twenty-four hours
per day on six days inthe week, instead_of through the
sixteen hours per day, which was the basis of the opinion
of the experts, upon which the Special Master framed the |

}
—_—
t
s
;
h
:
¥
4
A
t

: .
a ee

fed Se eee ee

‘Answer to Petition and Prayer for Further Relief.

recommendations contained in his report on re-reference, .

will incinerate a daily average of 950 tons of garbage. This

_. will reduce fhe amount theretofore disposed of at sea from

a maximum of 1,200 tons per day.to not more than 250 tons

ee: . : oe ahr atte

| ‘

v. 25. At no time during peoent years has the minimum
. daily quantity of garbage disposed of at sea been less th
800 tons per day. It is confidently expected that from an

. after the date of the completion ‘of the said two garbage

incinerators, it will no longer be necessary for the defend-
‘ ant City to dump any garbage atsea. —. . et

Wuxnzvons, the defendant, The City of New 5 Voit, prays, .
that the decree of this Court filed. herein on the 7th day of .
December, 1931, be modified by changing from June ist,
- 1933, to April 1st, 1934, the date specified in paragraph

numbered ‘1”’ ‘of the, said decree as that upon which its

employees and’ agents and all persons acting under its
authority will be enjoined from dumping any garbage or
refuse into the ocean or waters of the United States .off
the coast of the State of N ew Jersey.

And the defendant will ever pray.

3 — New seem, aad 8, 1933.

| Arraur J. W. Hny;
Corporation Counsel,

Solicitor for Defendant, The City _
"of New York.

DEFENDANT'S BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF THE
“FOREGOING APPLICATION.

“The fact that the decree herein of December 7, 1931,
was entered upon consent is, of itself, convincing evidence.
of the good faith of. the defendant City.

From. the facts stated in the petition it is ovidens that

the ‘unforeseen conditions,’’ to which the Special Master |
seg adverted at page 15 of his report upon the ~re- reference

herein, did not contemplate the financial distress Which the |

ed at large, very shortly thereafter, mat been | com-

pelled to endure. — 7
The City of New York, ‘like every. other municipality, |

is restricted as to the manner in which it may raise moneys

- for public purposes and is also restricted as to the amount

of indebtedness whieli .it may ineur. Under Article 12, ..

Section 1, of the Constitution of the State of New York |
it is the duty of the Legislature to restrict the power of
the cities of the State to tax, to assess, to borrow money, —
to contract debts, and to loan their credit. -

This power has been duly exercised by the State Legis- °
lature, and finds partial ‘ expression in Sections 169, 189
and 189a of the Greater New York Chartet, to which ref- °
erence has been ‘made in the. foregoing,application. ig

The City of New York has by no means reached the
limit of the long-term indebtedness which it may, under the
Constitution and Laws ‘of the State of New York, incur.
Its. debt margin upon long-term obligations exceeds oy at
least $400,000,000 any existing obligations. ,
' ’. Its inability to borrow money. for capital improvements, |
such as gerbage incinerators, is due not to any lack of

14

“capacity on its part t6 meet its obligations, when: and as
they” accrue, but to the inability of the citizens: to lend
their moneys ‘for such projects during the present times.
This condition is not peculiar to The City of New York,
but exists to an intolerable extent in all: of. the greater.
cities of the Nation. ° In fact,. despite their wealth, some

‘cities haye“been unable to:-meet past. obligations.

It is not to be denied that the defendant City‘has not

| ~ completed and will not be able to complete on. June 1,.1933, |
_ the date when this Court’s final decre@-as. at present written —

becomes effective, the garbage ‘incinerating™ plants concern-

: oa ing which testimony was offered before the Special Master’

. : x a .
De ee ee yer Re . qd -
Bien OMS SAE REL He ER oe dciie ee oP gt
? .
°

-and to which he adverted in his reports.

If ‘the City could obtain, or could have obtained. ‘the
moneys necessary for. the erection of the garbage disposal
plants referred to in the petition herein and in the reports

of the Special Master, it would unequivocally have so done.

In The City: of New York, as'in other great cities:of the
country, taxes upon real property, which are the principal

' bases for the raising of moneys, have, in. stupendous fig-

ures, not been paid, —to such an extent, indeed, that sal-
aries of municipal officers and employees and State officers,

‘paid out of City funds, have been drastically reduced,

Without -Such curtailment of. the eminently legitimate 2
and necessary cost of conducting the municipal government, —~

“it would have beeri unable, efficiently, to continue, with the =

result that’ police and fire protection would be dreadfully

i diminished, ‘the educational establishment tremendously
reduced, and such mattei's as the care of the sick and relief

of the poor entirely discontinued.
The, City of New York,. like every sia municipal

corporation, does not exist for profit. and has no power to

ff

dt.

me

. ‘accumulate funds, during periods of prosperity, which can
“be applied to necessities in periods of depression.. It has

ee only the closely supervised and restricted power -of taxa-—

tion and the power to issue its bends for the purpose of
financing capital improvements. | : , eae
In the existing state of the securities market the defend-

| ant City can find’no buyers for its long-term obligations,

and, finding no buyers, is unable to convert the special cor-
porate stock notes issued under the authority: of Section

: 189a of the, Greater New York Charter, and being so

— the defendant City but for every other municipality in the - :

thwarted, cannot issue further short-term corporate stock
notes even if it could find buyers therefor. ie |

The situation in which the defendant City finds itself
is not of its own creation or of its own neglect. It is due

- to a financial condition entirely beyond its control and:in
_ the creation of which it had no part. ‘

The most unusual financial] situation which began, so far

as the defendant .City® concerned, toward the élose of the

year 1931, will not have passed by June 1, 1933. _ The ques-
tion of how long.that situation will continue, not only for

United States, cannot presently be answered.:

‘The defendant ‘City has been’ doing and will continue
to do. all that it is passible for it'to do under the present
adverse financial conditions, toward complying with the pre-
scriptions of this Court’s final decree of December 7, 1931.
It is earnestly desirous of. giving its full obedience to
the said final decree but for the reasons set forth in the

_ foregoing answer and application, and herein, is unable.so

to do: and.is thus compelled to seek the favor, of the Court.

.o

9 °

f .
i
;
am
a
i
=
t
&
14
:
a
8
.
: a
. ai
» -.
-
inf

_it'shall become operative from June 1, 1933 to April 1, 1934.

16 nn
- In Conclusion. * tas

. ‘The defendant City urgently requests that the final de- |
cree herein be modified by extending the date upon which

Respectfully submitted, ee of

ae : ARTHUR : W. Huy,
ew | ~ Corporation Counsel, - |
ee | ee ea Solicitor for Defendant.

i = . .
- LA B , |
; . wee : uC waaen eK Te EN INS ae ma Vane ees on on IA Aa

. x - . :
’ ; | |
. * .
. ; i | |
‘ . } ; , i |
wie | |
. ‘
| | | ° sn
. ¥ : |
. , , |
| é ‘ ‘
‘ f
° . |
- re 7 , | |
‘ ; : a ,
. .
Y . bd -“
* 4 . ‘
; °
> . |
. e ; . o : : y
) . ; Sieh ' F . 5
. . | | :
‘ | : : f ‘ . ? .
°
’ ;
F ; .
. ° ar ) |
2 ‘ a
e ; |
* : | |
F . . e
.
. | |
3 é
’ a | | .
> } |
‘
° \ ,
oe.
. rf . .
3 e . ° ‘ ; |
stun | | 7
. é | | | |
* : 7 |
« . ; : | :
| .
; . : tw Seti - ; |
F o |
a F ° | :
. .
ah , : ;
- é é : . ; a .
bs
_ et
a ee = : |
ees :
F :
i e ”
3 }
3 :
: : ° Pe :
. i ie ‘ ee complaint alleges. that the dumping of garbage ~

and refuse by defendant in the navigable waters’ of the
United States off the coast of plaintiff causes great dam-

_ age to plaintiff and its ‘citizens in. their health, welfare.
and property, and creates a public nuisance in its waters

and on its shores, which it asks this court to restrain.

The allegations of the: complaint are fully set forth in the

Special Master’s report (pp. 3-6).

Defendant’s original answer was a general denial,
but after the testimony . was’ concluded and’ February 4,

A931 had heen fixed: for argument before, the’ Special

Master, it applied, on February 2, °1931, for, and on

Sea age

. >

be vansibial ‘beyond a marine: league iia linus, ée Tf
‘defendant places any reliance upon the permits, or if,

by soliciting those permits it places a practical construc-
tion upon the Federal statutes which necessarily involves |
jurisdiction at the dumping grounds, it cannot say that

‘the jurisdiction of this court is not co- extensive with that
_ of Congress ‘or the Supervisor ef the | Harbor of New

York? : ig
Congress, and the Supervisor of the Harbor, have

- exercised, since. 1888, and with defendant’s acquiescence —
_.. since 1918, an unchallenged, or sustained jurisdiction, over

the dumping grounds as navigable waters of the United
States. Defendant cannot now challenge that jurisdiction.

‘ Prigg v.. Pennsylvania, 16 Peters 539, 567.

Like the.Court of Chancery in England, this court is
a superior court of general jurisdiction. It is insufficient -

‘to deny jurisdiction. It is necessary to show what court.
' has jurisdiction to give a complete remedy: Courts. |

of equity assume and ‘exercise their powers over subject
matters outside their territorial jurisdiction, if the parties

- are within their jurisdiction, ‘‘for a Court of Equity agit
'. tm -personam, and may give effect to its decree by con-

straining the person or. property of the defendant till
he perform ‘it.’’ 1 Daniell’s Chy. Pl. & Pr., 652-3; 1
Story’s Eq. Jurisp. Sees. 90-1; Massie v. Watts, 6 Cranch
148, 158; Penn v. Lord Baltimore, 1 Vezey 444; Hart v.
Sansom, 110 U. 8. 151, 154.

If the defendant’ s contention is sound: a strange situa-
tion is presented. If it.can carry the garbage beyond the
three-mile limit it may dump it regardless of the damage
eaused on the adjacent shores or the extent of the
nuisance thereby created. By the same token it might go
to the same place and fire a cannon toward, regardless
of how-much damage it did on, the shore. Plaintiff
would have no remedy. Equity suffers ‘no wrong to be
without a remedy. 1 — 8 Eq. Furisp., See. 94.

7 13
St a? |
_ The property affected is within the United States.

‘The -Court will take judicial notice that the shores and
the marginal sea of plaintiff are within the. United States.
Pearcy v. Stranahan, 205 U. 8. 257. fe

As will appear later, defendant was never in ignorance
of the fact that plaintiff’s waters and shores were affected |
by the garbage and refuse dumped by it at sea. -

Justiciable Controversy and Jurisdiction.

. The findings of the Special Master of the existence of
‘ a justiciable controversy and of*the jurisdiction of this -
court is amply sustained by the facts and the law.

; rat is (2)

-- Garbage and refuse in 1 ge quantities dumped by the
defendant in the Atlantic Ocean more than a marine league
from the.shores of the waters of the plaintiff is driven and
carried by the winds and waters to and upon the beaches
' of the plaintiff and its adjacent waters, thus creating a
public nuisance to the great injury of the plaintiff’s rights
and property, — eiers

_ -Under this heading defendant has grouped its exceptions
12 to 43, inclusive, which challenge the Master’s findings
. that. defendant’s dumping of garbage creates a public
nuisance in the waters and on the shores of the plaintiff,

Legal Rights.

The primary uses of the sea are navigation and ‘fishery _
(Gould on Waters, 1). The right of fishery within one
marine league of the shore vests exclusively in the people
of the adjacent state. 1 Moore Int. L. Dig. 717, 718,+719; |
1 Fartham, Waters and Water Rights, p. 9; Corfield v.

Ris jem eeatennGem

14

Coryell, 6 Fed. Caen 546. The ae use of the ocean, for
navigation and fishing’ is common to all mankind (1 K ent.
Com. 27, 3 Kent 410, 412, 414, 416: Marte v. Waddell’s

Lessee, 16 Peters 367 ).

-. The most valuable perquisite of the exclusive ownership
of water is the benefit of fisheries therein.

_ The free use of the seas is, however, limited by the :
“ proviso that there shall be no interference with the equal’ —
rights of others. Sic utere tuo ut alienam non laedas.
Angell on Tide Waters, p. 15. Gould on Waters, Secs. ‘17,
21, 86, 87; Farnham on Waters and or Rights, Sees.
mee | Se :
The public right of eleiie's on the shire and in ‘the sea,
is second only to navigation in importance and value. If
| provides ; the sustenance which Lord Hale mentions as
one of the\ principal reasons for sovereign title to the
marginal sea. Hardin v. Jordan, 140 U. 8S. 371, 381;
- Arnold v. Mundy, 6 N. J..L. 1, 14, 94; 1 Moore Int. L. Dig. —
- 699; 21. Am. & Eng. Ency. (2nd Ed.) 439; History and
. Law of the Foreshore and Sea Shore (Moore é Hall, 3rd.
' Ed.); Hale’s DeJure Maris, 384, 385, 669, 850; Angell on
. Tide Waters, pp. 20, 22-24, 124-5, 132; 3 Kent’s Com. 412;
13 Am. & Eng. Ency. (2nd Ed.), pp. 556, 559, 562, 565;
Corfield v. Coryell, 6 Fed. Cas. 546, 549, 551; Paul v.
Hazelton, 37 N. J. Law 106; ‘Smith - v. Maryland, 59 at
U.S. 71. |

‘ The most extensive use of plaintiff ’s seashore is for
surf bathing purposes. The common right of bathing on

'. the public waters has ancient recognition and is supported |

by eminent authorities. Blundell v. Cotterall, 5 B. & A.
268; Angell on Tide Waters, 17-18, 28-35, 192; Halls Es-
says on Rights of Crown in Seashore (3d Ed.) 523, 542;
Gould on Waters (3d Ed.) Sec. 26; Farnham on Waters ©
and Water Rights, Sec. 37; 21 Am. me Eng. Ency. (2d Ed.)

2 439.

oe

‘ Garbage and Refuse Dumped at Sea.

Defendant admits that for many years it has dumped
.. the garbage and. some refuse ‘in the Atlantic Ocean -
_ (Amended answer, p. 8).- Its Exhibit No. 12 shows the
following quantities: Tetras se

Sea ee . Cubic Yards

Wis ee 1,517,934.
ey ere rere SUE Cet? 1,303,119
Wisp ibsxissiesieeiice 1,219,416
a GORD or Mie AE ts a8. 1,378,572
MO Bistetivars PE eA 1,478,165

The average weight of New York City garbage is 1150

lbs. per cubic yard. (‘‘Collection and Disposal of Munici-
- pal Refuse,’’ Hering. & Greeley, McGraw-Hill Book Co., .
1921, p. 46.) Translated into tons, the amount dumped in
1929 equals 849,945 tons, or about 2833 tons per working
day. During the summer of 1929 defendant dumped *
as high as 192,000 cubic yards a month at sea (R. 580).
_ Prior to 1896 defendant dumped’ its garbage and refuse

at sea. The practice was discontinued from that year
‘until 1903 when it was resumed until 1906. “From 1906.
until 1917 garbage and refuse were handled in reduction
plants on Barren Island ‘and Staten Island (Exhibit 347,
p. q; R. 566-7). 4

_ The present practice of dumping garbage and refuse
at sea began in August, 1917, when the reduction plant
at Barre Tnland burned (Pl. Exhibits 298; 324, p. 1896)

and the quantity was increased in N ovember, 1918, when

the reduction plant at Staten Island ceased operation ‘( Pl,
‘Ex, 325, pp. 1997-8). When the Barren Island: plant
.burned, the Supervisor of the Po » “‘At’the request of
the New York City Commissioner of Street Cleaning and
at the urgent solicitation of the Commissioner of Health,’’
issued permits for dumping of garbage at sea ‘‘as a tem-

\

16 .

porary measure, to continue for two or three months only.”?
(Pl. Ex. 326, pp. 1993-4.) The ‘‘urgent solicitation of
the Commissioner of Health’’ referred to, was a letter
from Dr. Copeland to the Supervisor of the Harbor, dated
August 8, 1918, which described ‘‘a very serious situation,
and we hope it will not long continue: * * * but I want
‘you to understand that we do not contemplate any per-
manent use of so inadequate a system. [It is simply a
temporary. expedient to bridge over an emergency.” (PI.
_ Ex. 298; R. 449.) The ‘‘request of-the New York City
Commissioner of Street Cleaning’’ referred to was a let-

ter dated August 17, 1918, from A. B. McStay to the Super. .
_ visor of the Harbor requesting “that a temporary permit:
he granted for dumping of the said material (garbage) at
sea until about the 15th of September’ (Pl. Ex. 298, R.
~ 450). = eres EYE

--. No other means having been provided in the meantime, -

the Secretary of the defendant’s Department of’ Health —
wrote to the Supervisor of the Port of New -York on
October 5, 1918, stating ‘‘The City of New York is faced

with an acute situation approximating a public nuisance —

in relation to its garbage-disposal.

The City of New York is now in the throes of a so-called |
‘influenza* epidemic *. * *,

May we request you, therefore, to grant permission
* * * to take scows of garbage to sea and dump same ©
* -* * until such time, in the near future, when New
York City shall be able to make other provision for. the
disposal of its garbage?’ | fess, 3

“We thank you for your consideration in this matter and
trust that you may find it possible to assist the City of
New York in this emergency’’ (PI. Ex. 298 ; R. 450).

17

The practice thus began as a “‘temporary expedient to
bridge over an emergency,”’ has continued to the present
_ day, with constantly increasing deposits of garbage at sea.

.. Official Objections. are 1
‘In 1907, three distinguished. engineers, H. DeB.. Parsons,

Rudolph Hering and Samuel Whinnery, were appointed by

' Mayor McClelland of New York, City to make an investi- --.

"gation and report on an improved and more effective sys- :
tem of street cleaning and waste disposal. ‘The. following
is an extract from their report: ;

““Dumping at Sea.
_ All the refuse collections could be dumped into the
Atlantic Ocean, but unfortunately the least harmful
material sinks and the foulest floats, so that much of
the floatable. mass will be scattered along ‘the beaches,
through the action of current and wind. This fouling -
of the Ueaches creates a nuisance that the public -

should not-be asked to tolerate. The cost of sending .

the scows so far to sea that there would be no danger
of fouling the beaches, and the delays and interrup- -
tions caused by storms and ice, forbid the use of this
plan. The dumping of refuse at sea should not be re-.

sorted to except in cases of emergency, when the per-__

tod of such sea dumping will be of short duration.”’

g

. (Italics ours.) - Exhibit 346; p. 100, R.- 656.) _
In 1921 the subject of the collection and disposal of city |
waste was referred by M ayor Hylan to a committee of ten
heads of eity departments, including Dr. Copeland, Com-
missioner of Health. Their report includes the following
statements : i tse : aa
(p..5) ‘Sinee October 2nd, 1918, all garbage from ~
the Boroughs of Manhattan, The Bronx and Brooklyn.

has been disposed of by dumping at sea.”’ ©

(p. 10) ‘The greatest objection to the present sys- -

tem of disposing of waste material is in connection
‘with the method now being used-for getting rid of gar-
bage, which is both unsanitary and uneconomical.

18

__ .% © ©. “Aside, however, from the question of cost, it
~ seems undesirable to dump garbage at sea as it is be-
- ing done at present. It is known that the Federal au-

thorities quietly resent, if they do not openly object to.

it, and there is always the poeaibatity. of objections
from other communities which have in the past claimed
that they have been injured by the practice. When
these objections become sufficiently strong it may be
that New York will find itself so unprepared as to be

_ unable to quickly introduce a more satisfactory form |

_ of disposal.” (Exhibit. 347; R. 657.)

Mr. Kenneth Alien, Sanitary Engineer of defendant, in
- a paper-published in the. ‘‘ Proceedings of American Insti-

tute of .Civil Engineering,’’ November, 1926, stated: .-

_* © © “bot the floating refuse is unsightly, and. -

; with winds in the quarter of the southeast, there is

always the probability of ‘its reaching the shore and |

fouling the beaches’’.(R. 658).

and in an article, published in ‘‘Municipal Sanitation,”

_ January, 1930, page 16, entitled “How New. York Handles
Her Garbage and Rubbish Problem,’ Mr. Allen states:

“*Many complaints have been received from owners
and lessees of Long Island and New Jersey. bathing
beaches, of rubbish and garbage which drifts at times
to the shore and strand there.’’ (R. 658.)

The. annual reports of the Supervisor. of ‘the Harbor |
to the Secretary of War, and incorporated in:his annual _

‘ reports to Congress, contain many references ‘to the ob-

_ Jeetionable features of dumping of garbage. at sea; some’
_ -0f which are as follows: Ape : nok

‘*Garbage deposited at sea, no matter what. the dis-

tance from shore, is apt to wash up oh the beaches.
the operation is likewise expensive. It would be an |
_ advantage to the neighborhood of the beaches to se: ‘
eure legislation oe such practice, and to the city «

- to dispose of its gar
Bd ueaecnt (Plaintiff’s Exhibit’ 325, pp. 1997,
1998). pee 2 ibs:

0

he

ge in sanitary and unobjection-,:

«@

t

Me

_ This statement from the report of.1919 is repeated each

_ year in the annual reports of the Supervisor of the Har-

bor from 1919 to 1929, inclusive (Pl. Exhibits 226, pp. 1993,

1994; 327, p. 2016; 328, p. 2135; 329, p. 1980; 330, p. 1979;
331, p. 1894; 332, pp. 1892, 1893; 333, p: 1915; 334, p. 2013;

335, pp. 2080, 2081). aN }
_~ The following-is a statement made in 1930: by Captain

Walter S:; Anderson, Supervisor of the Harbor N .

“Garbage is a sore subject. The War Department
-has for a good many years, directly-and by the super-
_ Visor, urged New York City to provide other disposi-
_ tion of its garbage and refuse than by dumping it at
_/ sea.’’ (U. 8S. Naval Institute Proceedings, Vol. No.
56, No. 7, Whole-Nu: 329, July, 1930, p. 577.) ae}

The Supervisor’s reports also show that as éarly as 1920
he had ‘frequently discussed with the city concerning
_ the question of a suitable alternate plan of disposing of

such material.”’ (Pl. Exhibit 326, p.1994); that the desig-
nated dumping grounds were at times changed “‘to obviate
the complaints from the beach regorts of New Jersey and
Long Island in regard to contamination from this refuse’
{Pl. Ex: 331, p. 1894); and that *‘many ‘complaints have
been received from owners of property and from visitors
along the New Jersey coast of rubbish and garbage coming ~

in on the beaches, especially during northeast storms and ~

protracted periods of easterly winds.” (PI. Ex. 335, p. |

* 2081.)

Defendant promised the United States Government in
1921 to eliminate dumping garbage at sea. It received
complaints from garbage reaching the beaches on Long Is)-
and and in New Jersey, (R. 578). ; le TEES.

* In 1923 citizens and public officials of shore municipali-

. ties of New Jersey and Long Island joined in the organiza-

' tion of the ‘‘National Coast Anti-Pollution League’’ for

the purpose of combatting the public nuisance created by

. . defendant’s dumping of garbage at sea, The minutes of |

" a Eis a :

—~ pitfn.

two of its meetings; one held at gtk Park, } N. J:, on.

August 23, 1923, and another held at Long Beach, N. Y.,
on September 19, 1923, were offered in evidence as PL.

- ° Exs, 258 and 257, respectively. ~
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 298 contains a stateinent, with ace om |

panying correspondence, reviewing the efforts of pl
tiff’s Governor, George S. Silzer, during the years 1923 to
1925, inclusive, to procure, by negotiations with the de-

fendant and complaints to the War Department, some re--

lief ‘from defendant’s garbage nuisance (R. 445-469).

Among that data are a letter (Sept. 10, 1923) from the’

Secretary of War, stating that only: temporary permis-
sion was given ‘‘on the understanding that the practice of

dumping at sea was regarded as highly objectionable and :
that the city was expected to provide other methods of dis-.
posal as soon as: possible’’; a letter (Dec. 18, 1918) from’

the Supervisor of the Port to Mayor Hylan of New York

- City, referring to previous experience with dumping gar-

bage at sea and stating ‘‘I feel that I should not be called

upon to jeopardize the health of residents and’ sanitary .
conditions of the beaches along -Long Island and New Jer- °

t by modification of the conditions as to deposit of
offensive material as at present i in operation * * *

appreciated, and I am urging the Mayor of the City of
New York to use his influence in the matter of providing

ie other means of garbage disposal.”’ _ (Italies ours.)

2

Plaintiff’s Exhibit 299 contains a statement, with ac- ~
‘eompanying correspondence, reviewing the efforts of plain-

. ‘tiff’s Governor, A. Harry Moore, during the years 1926 to
- 1928, inclusive, in the same direction. (R.469-472.) Among _

the data included are a letter (J uly 1, 1926) from. the Su-

a .
AE RE OI HS ter oe

er ae eet ere a ae

s I have already stated to you in my. previous cominuni-
cation, the deposit of this material at’ the mouth. of the. -
harbor is most objectionable from every point of view’’; x
and a letter (July 9, 1925) from the Secretary of War stat-

ing ‘‘The objectionable features of which you speak are

aintean.

tes

PAP es © 40
a

a a act nneng SOc

a

21

pervisor of the arbor stating that the only solution of the
problem is the erection of incinerators to dispose of the
gerbage without dumping at sea. ‘Constant pressure is
being brought to bear on the municipal authorities’’; a let-
ter from the Secretary of War. stating that he had in-.
structed the Supervisor of the Harbor “to take necessary

action to insure that none of the New York’ City garbage ~ |

reaches the New Jersey coast’ and also that he had called |
the attention of the Mayor of defendant to the ‘*objec-
_tionable features of this method of garbage disposal and
the importance of the early completion * * *. of ifein-
erators * * *’’; a letter (July 18,:1927) from the Acting
Secretary of War, stating: ie ean Pye a

-*fAs you kriow the Federal laws prohibit the dis-
charge of refuse matter into the navigable waters-of
the United States are primarily intended to-protect

‘ navigation, being based upon the ‘power reseryed to

_ Congress by the commerce clause of the Constitution
‘\ to regulate’ and protect interstate and foreign com- ~

merce. Accordingly, this. Department does not con-

. sider that it ‘is authorized to control the discharge of

refuse matter which has no injurious effect“upon navi-

gation, but is harmful merely. on account of causing:
objectionable deposits on ‘bat ing beaches. or other
' property.’ = Se : ee

> ae + * . * . *

‘“‘The War Department has communicated several
times. with the Mayor of New York urging early com- _
pletion of this program and, while it:seems that the .
Department has done everything it can to improve the
situation, it will again call the matter to the attention ,

of the proper officials of New York.”” |
3 Plaintiff’s ' Exhibit 336 is a letter dated July 9, 1925,

from the Acting Secretary of War to Mayor Hylan of New |
York City, reading as follows: |. ~ |

park lg ig to (the. present practice of the City of
New York of dis osing of garbage by dumping it at. .
dy Hook, I would inform you that

State of New Jersey has protested —

4

22 y

to the Department against ‘the continuance of such
‘dumping as a nuisance, a. detriment to health; and,.as _
in many cases, almost destroying beaches both of New
York and New Jersey for bathing purposes.

As you are doubtless. aware, deposits of this kind
are forbidden by the Act. of Congtess approved June
29, 1888, as amended by Section 3 of the River and
Harbor Act of August 18, 1894, excepting under au-
thority of a permit granted by the Supervisor of the
Harbor. © \ '

That official gave permission for such dumping as an .
emergency measure soon after the destruction of the
Barren Island Garbage reduction plant.in 1917. The
action was on the understanding that the city would
-immediately take steps to dispense with the practice.
_. It appears, however, that it has been continued to the
present time, and-that there has been considerable
delay in ‘the completion of other means of disposal.
' In view of the representations made to the Depart- ~
ment by the Governor of New Jersey and others con-
cerning the objectionable features of such dumping, I
.feel constrained. to advise the Supervisor that steps
must be taken to terminate the privilege as soon as
possible, and I wish to ask that you will urge upon the
proper city officials the necessity of promptly taking
action to dispose of garbage othewise than by dump-
ing at sea.’’ Aes

Plaintiff’s Exhibit 337 is a letter dated July 18, 1927,

.*

. from the Acting Secretary of War to Mayor Walker of
_” New York City, reading as follows: |

“‘Reference is made to previous communications
from this Department urging that the City’s program
of construction of garbage incinerators be pressed to
completion as rapidly as possible.” ere

The Department is again receiving numerous pro-
tests. against the present method of disposing of New
York ‘City garbage by dumping at sea and I desire,
therefore, to renew at this time the suggestion that ‘
_ every possible effort be made by the City to expedite
the: completion of sufficient incinerators. to dispose of
all its garbage so that this objectionable dumping may
‘be.discontinued,’’ ~ ; :

é a *

-

About 13 years ago Dr. Copeland, Health Commissioner
of New York City, came to-Deal to attend a meeting held

‘to do something about the garbage. At that time Dr.
Copeland stated that the city: was building incinerators ‘

and he promised to take the matter up with Mayor Hylan
- but that was all the citizens of Deal ever heard of ‘it
(R. 240). The officials of Belmar complained to the War
Department; the reply from that department stated it
was trying to dog all it could’to bring relief. (R. 257-8).

On four or five ‘océasions during the past four years
inspectors from defendant’s Street Cleaning Department

have visited-the beach at, Long Branch to inspect the _

garbage accumulations there. One of ‘those inspectors
who ‘came in August, 1929, ‘told Mr. Porter, who oper-
ates a swimming pool at Long Branch, that he had
‘travelled all the way up the coast and had found the same
conditions all the way up. There Was garbage on the
_ beaches (R. 320). \ Ss

Governor Larson’s testimony shows that the pledge to
_ clean up the beaches of New Jersey by stopping the
nuisance of garbage from New York was in the Republican

platforms of New Jersey every year from 1922 to 1929, -

both. inclusive, and in the Democratic Platforms of New
Jersey for four of those years. It was discussed in
annual messages of Governor Silzer in 1924 and 1926;
of Governor Moore in 1927; and of Governor Larson in
1929 It was the subject of joint resolutions of the
legislature in 1927, 1928 and 1929 (Plaintiff’s Exhibits

66, 67 and 68). This suit was brought pursuant to ;

\ the instructions of the legislature contained in the reso-
lution of 1929. (R, 98-101.) wy

rene:

2 2

| The Proof. |
. Appendix ‘‘B”’ to this brief gives a list of 263 different

kinds of articles identified on the garbage Scows, in the

sea and on:the shore, connected up between the SCOWS. and
the shore, with page references to each place in the record
where each article is mentioned. The letters ‘“‘N. Y.”’ after

a page number means that at that place in the record that.

. particular article is identified as having come in the garb-

age from New York City. To avoid tedious. repetition.

these articles will be ‘Teferred to iy the general term
‘*Garbage.’’

Two hundred and twe sve witnesses testified. and three
‘hundred and forty-seven exhibits were offered, on—he-

half of the plaintiff.

~ An. alphabetical list of the witness, with page vat
~ erences to their testimony, both in the stenographer’ S-
minutes and the printed record, and a descriptive list -
of the exhibits with like page references, are cine

at the beginning of the record (pp. er

Dumping and Drifting of Garbage.

During the summer-of 1929 Mr. Smack made a special

- study of the garbage situation on ‘beaches and at sea.
With Gustave Holgarson and J ames Hall as members
of his crew, he went out on thirty-four different occa-
sions to observe where the New York City garbage Scows
dumped their garbage and what it confained (R. 13).
_ On fourteen of these occasions they were. close by when

_the seows dumped and they deposited postcards in bottles,
self-addressed and stamped, bearing a request for the

name of the finder, with place. and date of finding, and ~

that it be mailed. They were addressed to Mr. Smack

. (R. 7). . Sixty-one of these cards came back by mail from: |

finders on beaches from Long Island, New J ersey and New
——.

repiteeoy. 5 inate

15 ast EE Rates ta

ulrtMaenhcs aah cee Otc eee
™ .

pee hed

[gurney

25

i 2

On May 22, 1929, he observed the largest and foulest
garbage dump that he had seen. Three loaded scows
dumped and some other loaded Scows were going in the _
‘game direction. The returning scows left a trail of garb-
age in the sea after them. He followed the trail, for two
miles, to the dumping place-where he found garbage strewn
over the surface of the sea for an area seven miles long
and two miles wide. (R. 9,14). He was present when -two
other scows were dumped that day, - Piles of garbage
remained along the ridge of the. scows which _dropp

_ off into the sea.- These scows bore’ the initials D. S. C.,
_ representing the Department of Street Cleaning of the
City of New York and another identification letter which
' was used in the place of numbers,

‘On: June 30, 1929, he saw three New York City scows
dump garbage eighteen miles southeast by east of Seot-
land Light. He ran into the mass while > the dumping
was in progress. In addition to the body of a perfectly
formed child, the - garbage contained a great many dif-
ferent articles’ which are enumerated in a list he made ©
at the time and read into-the record (R. 10). They are
included in Appendix ‘‘B.’’ That list tallies with the
articles enumerated by other witnesses who testified to
conditions on the Shore. The ‘different kind of articles —
contained in the garbage in the scows, in the water and |
on the share are so numerous and some of them are
of.a nature and condition so disgusting and revolting
that they will not be separately; mentioned. ed

On that date Smack saw a number of scows dumped.
Garrett Johnson took pictures, which were offered in

evidence and identified by. Johnson and Smack as being _

Tepresentative of conditions which existed at or near
the dumping grounds and on the scows on ‘their way.
in, with large masses of garbage clinging to the ridges
which was pushed into the sea by the attendants as the
-- Scows neared the shore. : ;

i ial " sx vines ah ot eR Baa share peace ip phen ae om ceck,

26

On July 17th Smack went. out -again with Johnson,
Hall and Holgarson (R. 11), and took other pictures of
the dumping grounds and a trail of grease and garbage
on the sea. On that occasion the list of articles that
they saw on the scows or in the garbage as dumped. are.
the same as those listed on June 30,. 1929 (R. 9, 10). .
Those articles compared generally with what he saw- in ‘
the’ scows dumped in the sea on the fourteen different

oceasions when he actually saw scows dumping (R. 11).

Stormy weather holds back the scows, otherwise they ©
dump every day, but when they-have been held for a day
or two, particularly in warm weather, the ‘smell of the .
garbage on the scows will conquer everything but a very
strong stomach. The day he saw the infant in the garbage.
it was particularly bad smelling and made him sick (R. 11). ,

The type of scows are shown clearly in’ Johnson’s pic-
tures. These side dumping scows invariably have a large
amount of garbage clinging to the ridge which grad-

“ually falls off on their return. Exhibit 5 shows men clean-

ing ridge line of a scow. They do not start cleaning until

‘they are within three or four miles of Scotland Light .and

the cleaning continues until they have. passed that light
and are within approximatély- four miles of Sandy’ Hook

ye ee cee

Exhibits 4 to 11°also show scows and the accumulation
of garbage hanging on after they have dumped. The clean-

ing of these scows on the way in leaves a trail.of garbage

and grease on ‘the sea which can be followed for miles
(R. 13). Se enies

Exhibit. 12 shows a tow of scows returning empty. The
lighter section of the water shown in this ‘picture is the

wake of grease and-slick from the garbage which is left
+ in the water after the scow passes. The grease.is-of a _.

peculiar type .and’ consists of little flecks from the size

» of a, person’s fingernail down pe minute particles. It

.
. ‘ . : “7; f (BR. 295). Any, wind from ‘the east or northeast, carries.

-, . the garbage toward the New Jersey shore. The wind does
_not Have to blow hard 6 blow the stuff in. A mild’ wind

1 will do it, but it takes longer to reach, the’ shore (R.
:. 296). The tide has very little effect on the garbage. The
_'. wind has the greater effect (R. 297). He has followed the
garbage when it was coming in ahead of an ‘east.wind.

John G: Haas, Deputy Inspector éf Barges, office of
the Supervisor of the Port, investigated floating garbage

dumped by New York City at sea on six trips made in -

qi _ February, March and April, 1929. When the garbage is

i

oe eaet Seva coeds

dumped it stretches out a mile or so, 30 or 40 yards wide.
Wind influences the movement of. garbage on the surface -

~. (R. 636). On March 1, 1929, three scows dumped eight
miles southeast of Scotland Light. ‘The garbage drifted
to within nine miles of Long Beach (Long Island) in
twenty-four hours (R. 637). 7

On March .19, 1929, three scows dumped eight _ miles
southeast of Scotland’Light at a point about twelve miles
from the Jersey shore. In twelve hours it had drifted to
within three miles of the shore at Long Beach. There

was a twenty-five mile an hour wind and the garbage
‘ifted thirteen or fourteen miles during twelve hours
: nd had distributed itself over an area greater
_ than .he .coul
' two scows dumped eight miles southeast by east of Scot- |
"land. Light.’ He followed it from 5:50 P. M. to 11 A:

.

a Ss ag ee

¥ opposite Asbury Park, The most frequent. dumping \«
¥ - grounds he saw was between the nineteen and twenty-one- |

and fwenty-orie-mile points, which would be opposite the ©

from his boat. On February 25, 1929,. |

= -

“

31

M., the next day, The garbage worked northerly for four
or five hours and then back to the southward; then to

the westward toward the New Jersey shore. A thirty-
.. five mile wind toward the Jersey shore, compelled.him’ to ;
leave the garbage when it’ was approximately six miles .

from that shore and: moving in: that direction (R. 637,
638). ees ee Re
On March ']1, 1929, three scows dumped eight miles
southeast by east of Scotland: Light and the garbage

‘ drifted eastwardly before a southwest--wind;- On’ Feb-

ruary 22, 1929 he followed’ the ‘garbage for twenty-four
hours and in that time it drifted approximatély eighteen.

miles without much wind (R. 638). April 4, 1929, three
scows dumped twelve miles southeast: by east of Scot-.
land Light. He followed it for twenty-four hours. . It
drifted from eight to ten miles in that time (R. 639)...

Mr, Johnson accompanied Smack, Forsman and Hall
on some of the trips and took pictures (R. 299), ‘These
pictures show: the garbage floating on the sea after the
dumpings. (Pl. Exs. 12, R. 300; 14, R. 301; 15, 16, 17,’
18 and 19, R. 302; 21 and 22, R. 303; and 24 and 29, R.
304) ; show: scows ‘returning after dumping with quantities

of garbage clinging thereto’ or being pushed off into

the sea, (Pl, Exs. 3, 4, 5, and 6, R. 299; 7, 8, 9, 10 and ;
11, R. 300; and 23, R. 303); and the trail, or ‘slick’? of

~ grease testified to by numerous witnesses. . (Pl. Exs. 12,

R. 301; 20, R. 302). The garbage which Johnson saw in
the mass dumped by the: city Scows contained wooden
things; crates, boxes, ‘pieces of lumber,. short: sticks 3

or 4 inches wide, house utensils, brooms, hrushes and —

handles. There was a considerable proportion of wood

_ in the garbage. They saw some. dumps where there was

. More wood than in others (R. 306).

Pe

82.

\

bes

me

Interference With Navigation ‘and Fishing. 4

_ Free.fisheries are those carried on. by meaiis of hooks
and line, drifting gil nets, lobster pots and tackls on _
the bottom and such other.forms as do not provide fixed .
objects on or near the surface of navigable water.
‘‘An obstruction: is ‘such. .an impediment as ren.
ders navigation less convenient, less sectire,: and
less expeditious. — : :

‘Thus, .wire cables and ropes, anchors, gaspipes,
weirs, accumulations of logs, embankments and
jetties, and deposits of sewage and debris have been
decided to constitute obstruction * *.” © (Ttalieg
ours). - aa x =

| at i ¢ Eng. Ency. (2nd Ed.), p. 443. ° ;
Markus is Commodore of the Yacht Club at ‘Belmar.
He described ‘the conditions: of floating garbage which |
. they encounter at sea when sailing their boats, for fish. . |
ing or other purposes. The garbage accumulates in the
yacht club basin and has to be cleaned out as fast as it
comes ti, He has seen at Sea Girt a hundred’ men sit- °
ting around. waiting for a change of’ tide to carry the
floating garbage out ‘of the shore waters so they could

begin fishing. (R. 270-1).
+ ,
Mayor Barbour of Rumson, N. J., sails a yacht off —

_ the coast of Seabright and gives his experience in watch-. |
ing the defendant’s scows dump at sea and following the ‘og

drifting garbage to the shore. (R. 91-3).

~

The Fishermen.

- Twenty fishermen testified to conditions of garbage in
-the waters off plaintiff’s shores, where they have been en- |
gaged in fishing with nets and lines, and with lobster
‘pots, for periods ranging from_four -to seventy ‘years, ~
(Voorhees R. 36-41; Schweitzer R. 42-47; DeCamp R.
47-50; Peterson R. 50-52; Anton Holgarson R. 52-5; Carl
Holgarson R. 55-7; Oleson R. 75:9; Gustave Holgarson RB.

*

82.84; M. Hall R. 117-125; Cook B.'31-3; Carver R. 213-4;

»

Haley R. 818; Popp R. 347-51: Jacobson RB, 373-6; Hines .

Hankins R. 153-6). :

. |:

' They go to sea daily, whenever weather conditions per-,

mit, and observe. the defendant's scows dumping ‘ their

"R. 393.4; Edward Phillips R. 397-402; Charles W. Phi.
, lips R. 402-4; Harry Peterson R, 408-10; Woods R. 433-4 ;

_ garbage at sea and the effect of that ‘garbage upon. the

water and the shore. Mary of these men are lobster -

fishermen, who use strings of pots half a mile long an-

~ chored and buoyed at each end; with from thirty to thirty-

- five pots on a string. Portions of the ‘garbage which

sinks, and other portions that dritt. in suspension at vari:

ee

upon the lobster ‘pots and become entangled .with the

~ anchor and buoy ropes so as to render it. difficult, and

‘sometimes totally impossible, to lift the pots. (R. 351).

In sailing their boats they often encounter areas of float-
ing garbage, too dense to'sail through without jamming
the’ propeller or injuring: the. boat.- They have to pick
their way through thinner portions or sail around it. This

\

garbage comes from the, New York City seows-and—is-——

“more or less a regular thing every day. This garbage

affects lobster pots ‘five or six’ miles inshore from. the
dumping ground. (R. 402). Some of these fishermen

have had. to straighten ‘the propeller of ‘their boats as: °

often as two or three times a season, in order to repair

damage done by coming into. contact with the floating

- ous depths between - the bottom ‘and surfacé, such as”

‘Tags, clothing, pieces of: wire_and—rubber; drift into or

garbage and aecompanying -rubbish. - When the boats en-_

counter the garbage they. are required to slow down to
somewhat less than half speed and pick their way through.

They sometimes sail ‘twénty to forty: minutes, or for dis.
tances of from four to seven miles, through these ‘garbage |

themselves around the ropes, by which they handle their

\ ;

__ drifts: Some of the materials which settle upon or wrap |

’ and all manner of debris.

84

lobster pots, are unfit. to handle. These entanglements,
together with the cutting of ropes by floating debris,
frequently causes the loss of lobster outfits. One of these
lobstermen lost sixty traps during one season. The mate-
rial also kills;the lobsters .in the traps. (R. 351). Thé
garbage consists. of decayed animal: and vegetable matter

From the dumping ‘grounds these witnesses have fol-

_ lowed continuous .streaks of garbage all the way-to the

shore. It drifts according to the direction of the wind.
Whenever the wind is from-the east or northeast it drifts
to the New Jersey shore. + Thejr testimony positively

‘identifies garbageon the beach and m the waters as having
‘ come from the New York City scows dumped’ at sea:
Instances are mentioned where sticks and other material
_ In the garbage have punched holes through the hull of
MEE NOs 3

The accumulation of the garbage on the beaches. fre-

quently prevents the launching or landing of the fishing
boats. Men atid horses are required to remove the
-—.—~"mmaterial from.an area large enough for such purposes.
_ In 1929 this garbage destroyed 85 lobster pots belong-

ing to one fisherman. (R. 77). . . .

‘The garbage gives the water a milky color and is a

filthy mess of decayed matter, and at their landing places: |

on shore the fishermen have to get together and clean up
the garbage beaches and bury the garbage in the sand.

" (R. 119), The amount of garbage dumped at sea has. con-
‘stantly increased and the resulting pollution in the water
. and on the bottoms has driven away the fish and substan-

tially reduced the amount of the gains of the fishermen

-- from their trade. (R. 154),

In all kinds of fishing that require nets; such as mack-

\

- eral fishing, the garbage and refuse rajse havoe with

\

| hea eee |
| oe Ne F

he
-the’ nets which become entangled in, and torn and de-
stroyed by the sticks, tin cans and other rubbish. (R. 409).
The experience of these fishermen, more than half of
. whom have fished continuously since the defendant-began
_ to dump its garbage at sea in 1917, confirms. in every
respect the result of Smack’s investigations in 1929 Te-
‘specting the source of the garbage, its action on the water a
after dumping, its interference with navigation and fishing,
the identification of the garbage on the shore as coming
_ from: that source, and the general effect of the garbage i
on the shore. They recognized the conditions shown*in ~
‘Johnson’s pictures as.representing those with which they
have been familiar throughout their éxperiences. (R. -37,
39, 44, 45-6, 48-9, 50, 56, 75, 91-2, 117, 350). ape

Pound Fishing... .

-Pound fishing is carried on in a-fixed location.. A pound
or trap is constructed of nets, and wings of nets are
stretched out between the pound and the shore for the pur-
pose of heading off schools Sf fish as they feed to the
shoreward, and leading them through the opening into the °

_ trap by such a-imeans as to prevent them of finding their |.
. way out. Since this method of fishing requires the exelu-
-Sive occupancy of a certain area of bottom and water it is
- authorized and regulated by statute. The following statu-
_ tory provisions of the plaintiff dea] with this subjeet: |
“License to operate fish pound nets. 1. It shall be
unlawful for any person or persons, corporation or
corporations, to erect, set, operate or maintain any fish
pound nets in any of the waters of the Atlantic ocean, —
‘within three nautical miles from the coast line of: this.
.,. State, or in Sandy Hook bay or Raritan bay, without
first obtaining a: license for such purpose as herein- |
after provided. — See: 55
2. Applications for licenses for the purpose. men-
. tioned in the first section of this act shall be made to © ce
_the Board of ‘Fish and Game Commissioners. Said |

: + @

Ue a @ . 4

board shall, upon the paymont to them of the sum. of -

fifty dollars. for each fish pound net to be erected or
. Set in the Atlantic ocean, and ten dollars for each
ound net to be erected ‘or set in Sandy. Hook bay or
aritan bay,/as a license fee, issue to the person or
rsons, corporation or ‘corporations, applying there-

or and paying said sums as aforesaid,
thereto under the provisions of this act, @ license duly
signed by the secretary of said board to erect, set,
operate and maintain a fish pound net in one of the

‘if entitled -

waters.above specified.’’ (N. J. P. L. 1919, Chap. 94,

pp. 214, 215; 1N. J. Cum. Suppl. 1364, 1365),

These licenses are issued to authorize. fish poundsgwithin
the exclusive territorial limits of ‘plaintiff. °

Following is a summary of the“testimony ‘of ten pound-
fishermen: Meyers has been. in the business for forty

years. Bedsprings and boxes from the garbage and refuse ‘

in‘ the water, tear the nets of his pounds in Galilee This

condition always follows an east or northeast wind. (Re

73-4.) Wooley has an investment in: fishing pounds at

Belmar between $18,000. and $20,000. and has been. in busi. .

ness for twenty years. “The value’ of his catches were:
1921, $55,000. ; 1926, $44,000.°; 1927, $41,000:; 1928, $29,000.

The’ number of men employed were: 1926, 29; 1927, 24;

1928, 23. The garbage is getting worse every year. It
tears holes in the. nets and lets the fish-out. It forms a
scum and slime that accumulates on the nets which, with
the dead things they collect from the garbage, drives the
' fish away and accounts for the decrease in catch as the
quantity of garbage dumped increases: - (R. 263-6.)

Frank Weber has been a pound fisherman at Monmouth’

" Beach for 33 years and has encountered the garbage’ at
sea as well as on shore. On one occasion he broke a pro-
peller shaft while trying to extricate his boat from a sea

of floating garbage. It damages their nets to the extent —

of from $2,000. to $3,000. in a ‘single storm. His fish pound

repre ents an investment of $40,000. “At times the ageu-

|
;

\
N

’ “4

37

‘7

mulation ° of. .rubbish against the nets has swept them .

‘entirely away. He vatches range from 800,000 to 900,000:

‘ pounds of.fish a season, the value of which ranges from.
. $35,000. to $50,000. per year. His experises are about $30,-

000, a year and he employs 18 men. (R. 308-10.) His son,

- Fred, is.associated with -him. in the business: and. supple-

mented his father’s testimony regarding the difficultics and

damage caused by the garbage, (R. 340.)

‘Prestley has been a pound fisherman for fourteen years

near Galilee where he has an investment of $12,000. and
. employes: ten men; His catches amount to: about half of |

those of Frank Weber. The ga rbage tears his nets and Jets

+ the fish ont. It canses damage to the extent, of from $1,000.

to $1,200. a year for ordinary repairs. ° (R. 311-2.)

; Siciliano has been a pound fisherman at. Long Branch
-! for five’ years. He has an. investment of $12,000.. and

caught 4,000 pounds of fish last year. He employs nine
men. The garbage is pretty regular in the ocean around
his pound. -It creates an .awful- mess and smeils-bad when. -
the sun shines on it.. He has to collect and bury it in order
to make a place to land his boats.. The rubbish in the gar-
bage cuts his nets, (Ry 312.)-° |, ,

Fred Cook is a pound fisherman. at Galilee and has an

. Investment of from $12,000. to. $14,000. His catch’ runs

from.35,000 to 40,000 pounds of fish per season. The gar- —
bage and refuse becomes entanged “in, and tears, his nets.
Repairs on this account cost from $1,000. to $1,200. a year.
He employs 12 men. The garbage is offensive to the smell

and ‘its accumulation on the beach renders it difficult at

_times to launch their boats. (R. 316.)

Swenson ‘has been a pound fisherman. at Manasquan for

25 years. The sticks in-the garbage cut through his nets
.and the nets catch all manner of stuff. It has’ been neces-
‘Sary for him and his men to spend from four o’clock to -

| ten o’elock in, the morning to clean the stuff out of the

s

’
.
38 |
,
. .

nets. It keeps the fish away. He has been required to use
15 men and four horses to clean the garbage off the beach
before they can move their boats. Storms do not affect .
theit nets except, when they bring in the garbage’ and
refuse and on such occasions sre tear’ the nets to pieces,
(R. 355-8.) Ge,

_ Fish pounds at Bradley Beach. repcsctnt an in¥estment
ef $50,000. and catch about $60,000. worth of fish) a_ year,
They employ 25 men. .(R. 175.)

This testimony covers only a small part of the pound :
fisheries: licensed by the plaintiff in the coastal area in-
volved in this suit, which represents about three-quarters
of the costal, grounds used for. such purposes. The
latest official figures available at the: time of the hearing
were given a by Governor Larson in PI. Ex. 71. AR. 101.)

7 Coast Guards.

In the coastal stretch affected. by this garbage there are
20 lifesaving stations of the United States Coast Guard
Service /{ Appendix ‘*A’’) between which patrols are con-

_ -stantly maintained to discover signs of vessels in distress.
_ Like that of a fire department, the service for which the
coast guards are called upon frequently requires the ut- .
most expedition and precision, yet 17 coast guard officers
- ‘testified to conditions caused by the accumulation of gar-
bage on the beaches at their stations, which greatly hamper
and interfere with their work, both as to launching of boats
and conducting their patrols. (Bailey, R. 129-132; New-
man, R. 133; Butler, R. 134-7; Townsend, R. 140; Gifford,
R. 140-1; Parker, R. 141, 143-4; Wilbur, R. 144-5: C,
Brower, R. 141-2; Salter, R. 142; Mitchell, R. 143; Perrine,
, R. 146; L. Brower, R. 145-6; Forsythe, R. 147; Cook, R.
147-8; Roswell, R. 148-150; Herbered, R. 307-8; Osborn, -
a 308. These witnesses ‘describe the measures they are
required to take to remove the garbage from the a ba

thee ced at

. its decayed condition, the quantity and contents. It has to
be removed to orovide a way for launching ‘their boats.
At some of the stations three men are kept. busy cleaning
the beach in the summer time. *(R. 146,) It must be
promptly retnoved on account of its bad smell. (R, 148, :
143.) It interferes with the use of their equipment. (R. ‘

307) and with their boat drills (R. 308). .

The Effect of Garbage Ashore. ~
/Twenty-nine separate municipalities, with assessed val-
uations of approximately $140,000,000. (PI. Ex. 69), oceu-
pying a continuous stretch of beach front of approximately
70 miles in length, are affected by. the garbage conditions
complained of. One. hundred and eighteen witnesses tes-—
_ tified to their. personal experiences, in official or private
- capacities, with the natare and extent of the garbage in

» the-water and on the beaches which interfers with the use

thereof for fishing, bathitig, and other recreational pur- .
poses. They show that at high tide the garbage is carried
up on the beach and deposited throughout the whole width
of the beach, between high and low water mark, as the tide
recedes. They also show that with the aid,of wind and .
high waves the garbage is carried under the boardwalks
. and buildings and into and across the streets to private

properties, where it. leaves accumulations. of bottles and | ‘

cans and offensive vegetable and animal matter. They
show that it is offensive to sight and smell and that the
odor enters the houses of. the community and creates an-
noyance to the people in their homes; that it breeds and
feeds swarms of flies which enter the houses; that it jeop- .
_ ordizes health. and produces: physical. injuries and infec- .
tions; that it occasions the expenditure of large sums of _

_ » Money to accomplish its Temoval and disposition; that it

depreciates the value of property and creates an. intol-

erable public nuisance which driyes people away from the
beaches,

° J
ES Neen eT RR ctl tap aia od al

Paes

40

It is impossible to.summarize this great mass of testi _
.| mony, or to describe the 347 exhibits, within any reason.
able compass, although the magnitude of the injury in.
flicted would, justify a somewhat. extenuated discussion... -
_ thereof. Some of the exhibits will illustrate this discus. |

sion. . : “ee

- Annexed hereto as Appendix ‘‘C”? is a tabluation of fig.

“ures given by witnesses-from 17 of the municipalities,
_ which happened to have the data’in available form, show-

ing, as near as could be ascertained from their records, the
winter and ‘summer populations, length of beach front,

value of hotels and boarding houses, assessed valuation, |

cost of boardwalks, jetties, piers, pools, pavilions - and
pleasure places, value of private hornes, cost of cleaning
béaches, and the cost of bathing facilities. It shows that
nine of the municipalities mentioned have spent for board--
walks $1,900,000:; five of them have spent.-for jetties to

-. protect their beaches, $899,000. and the state has spent an

additional sum of $838,494.28 for the same purpose (Pl.
Ex. 70; R. 101); six of them have spent for piers $8,495,-
000 ; five of them have spent for pools, pavilions and pleas-
ure placés, $825,000.; fifteen of them spend an aggregate

of something over-$10,000.00 a year to ‘remove the garbage —

from their beaches (in addition to the amounts spent for
that .purpose by private beach cluhs, bathing industries,
and by private individuals) ; aid in seven of those munici- ”

_. palities $3,750,000. have. heen spent for hathing: facilities. -

| Asbury Park. - .

. The largest and most important. seashore resort within

7 the area dffected by the garbage is the City of ‘Asbury -
\ _ Park, a birdseye view of which can be obtained from plain-

tiff’s exhibits 55 and 239-255. Other interesting pictures

-of recreational features are shown in plaintiff’s exhibits

o1 and 52, showing the convention hall.and theatre; hum-
bers 53 and 243, showing: beach and boardwalk as used

‘HOVE NO ADVauVD ‘£4 ‘ON LIGIHXa

wf

3 ab eit
ePID
we
cone

Dee

seem

‘SLHDIGH adIsvas ‘HOVad NO ADVENVYD “LIT ‘ON LIGIHXad

=" S..

7,

s

ea Keeey —
Pha a heats ta eta |

‘HOVAd NO FOVAUVD ‘Tie ‘ON LIGIHXG

.

—

p. 4

* ge 4
Mh ~ 2
> " , ~ i we staveme eh ?@ tose tebe an bill) 5
a Rte ie re: ~ Preveeeeeeearteses: rei tia 4

ut aya

as a So

— a
. .
. y e
> \
\
. 4 ie -
- .
ma ‘
» e . se Sey c

‘Iv ‘ON LIGIHXS

w
fe)
>
wy
S
=
>
=
Ee
os
>
m
.
=
>
mn
| w
S
y. 8)

°)
wR:
2
-

his MERE Be apo

41

in the summer time; Exhibit 241 shows crowds on Easter .
Sunday; number 56, showing the Monterey and other’ ho- “
tels and. the parked automobiles ‘of visitors; number 57,.
showing the beach and boardwalk ; numbers 229-238, show-_
ing exhibits at agricultural. and other shows. held in the :
Casino. Plaintiff’s exhibit 256 is a copy of the annual re- ©
port of .the municipal: Publicity Bureau of Asbury Park
for 1929; Exhibits 265 arid 266 are annual reports of the °

_ Asbury Park Bureau of Information which is.a depart--

ment of the city government conducted by Miss McConnell
as Director. Her testimony (R. 429-432) contains statis:
tical information showing the’ very great extent and’

varied nature of the recreationa] activities in that city.-

: ‘The testimony of Mayor Hetrick (R. 377-390) and of Mr.

- Burley, Executive Secretary of the Chamber of Commeree -
Pea |S 426-8), and of Mr. Gruetzner, Municipal Superintend-

. ent, shows the very extensive expenditures and develop-
ment along the beach front and elsewhere, and the various
attractions provided at public expense, solely for recrea-

_ tional purposes, and the extent to which they are used.
These improvements include boardwalk, convention hall, .
theatre, casinos, jetties, piers, bathing facilities, and golf_
and country club, aggregating more than $50,000,000. in
expenditures of. public moneys. Some of these- expendi-
tures, and similar .expenditures by some of the other mu-
nicipalities, are included -in Appendix “CQ.” :

Exhibits. 40, 41 and 45 illustrate the use of the .beaches |
at"Ocean Grove: 7 :

Governor Larson testified that shortly after his inaugn-

*. ration (1929) he consulted the Attorney General for advice
as te the necessary action to stop this nuisance by com-
pelling the defendant to discontinue the dumping at sea.

- He caused to be prepared the resolution for that purpose,
which was adopted by the legislature. (Pl, Rx. 68.) He
had been familiar with the conditions for the past six or
Seven years and realized that unless this pollution was’

: stopped it weet 3 ruin are beaches as sis flbGide. - He
considers these beaches as-one of the greatest assets of
the state, which benefit. the people from all parts of the.
state, as well as’ people from other states and countries,
who resort thither for recreation. He discussed the sub-
ject in his inaugural message to the legislature in J —
1929. (Pl. Ex. 72, R: 98-101.)

The testimony of 118 witnesses, including the Mayors
of fourteen of the municipalities, and twenty-nine other .
muhicipal officials, describes the’ nature and extent of this
_ garbage nuisance in the several. municipalities, the amounts

expended annually for its removal and its general detri-
- mental effect upon the attractiveness, development, and
welfare of the people. It is possible in this brief only to
touch upon the principal features of this nuisance.

The effect of this garbage upon. the development . of the
. Municipalities and the use of the. beaches is very harmful
(R. 17, 151, 105, 106, 164, 172,-179, 209, 225, 249, 275, 314,
359, 364, 415, 427-8, 477, 481). It depreciates the value’
of property and interferes with the raising of municipal
revenue (R. 505). The garbage and refuse renders it
impossible, at times, to bathe or use the beaches (R. 17,
34, 32, 111, 112, 151, 61, 66, 68, 104, 86, 88, 172, 176, 179,
201, 202, 203, 204, 205, 214, 218, 227, 242, 247, 256, 313)..
When it reaches the beach it is often putrid (R. 18, 29,
145, 184, 189, 191, 203, 207, 252), and .is repulsive and
disgusting (R. 251). It includes dead: animals, which are

_. very offensive and: have to: be immediately disposed of

(R. 108, 29, 115, 103, 88, 102, 164, 191, 214, 216, 222, 336,
244, 360, 364). It leaves gobs of grease which nticks- to
_ bathers’ feet and bodies (R. 29; 32, 111, 306). In summer
the garbage has an objectionable odor which affects’ the.
atmosphere for a considerable distance from the beach
- (R. 108, 151, 152, 67, 80, 103, 158, 143, 148, 215, 216, 245,
249,. 321, 337, 341-2, 352, 353, 395, 416-7, 488,. 498-9).

SO i

A great. deal of time and expense is required to clean Eaete

up and dispose of the garbage which accuraulates’ upon the
beaches (R. 27, 112, 235, 236, 102, 103, 156, 251, 321, 322,
323, 360, 392, 424, 485, 498, 520, Appendix *‘€’’). On one

~. oceasion in 1927, and on another in 1929, the municipal
authorities of Bradley Beach .carted off four loads of

garbage per hour each day for a week (R. 188-9). ‘Fifty, :
loads, of garbage were removed at one time from another

-section of beach about half mile long (R. 112, 236). On

February 7, 1929, they removed 63 truck loads of garbage,
bottles, cans- and other trash from ‘a, similar stretch of

-heach (R. 116). In April, 1929, it required nine men-an‘en- .

tire week to remove one garbage ‘accumulation from the
beach at Spring Lake. It contained three full loads of -

" bottles (R. 241).

On. one vecasion in the summer of 1929, 8 to 12 men, |
and two trucks each hauling 10 loads a day, of 1% tons.

per load, were required for two and one-half days to re-

move one accumulation of garbage from the beach at Bel-
‘mar (R. 272-3). : es .

Practically every witness stated that the condition .
caused by garbage in the water and on the beach was a_
matter of constant complaint and discussion among the ~
residents and guests in the seashore municipalities. These ©
municipalities comprise a purely recreational community..
There are no industries and people come/solely for the
seashore (R. 174, 175, 179, 200, 201-3,. 226-7, 234, 237, :254,

258, 276, 285, 363, 427, 443, 474).

os Garbage affects bathing and business conditions; since |
the shore municipalities and hotels depend upon the beach
for their attraction (R. 34, 108, 152). 3

‘Surf fishing is greatly interfered with, and there are
many fishing clubs along the shore (R. 275-6, 417-18).

At times it.is impossible to fish because the water is fall —-“*

of garbage (R. 109, 161, 417 y.

ieee

\

_Beach (RB: 221). On another occasion at Spring Lake ¢

28, 221, 245, 261, 314, 319-20, 344, 371, 369, 488). Last

44

As Appendix ‘‘B”’ shows that many of the articles
the garbage were identified as having come from N (
York City. Almost every witness has made such ide

_ tifieations. : Seen se
The garbage comes in whenever the wind is to the nort

east or east (R, 33, 66-7, 106, 86, 156, 164).

Menace to Life and Body.
On ‘one occasion between, 3,500 and 4,000 bottles we
collected from one accumulation of garbage at Bradk

_truck loads of bottles were picked up from one: garbag
aceumulation (R. 245). 5

Bottles in. the garbage break in the undertow ‘and on th

shore and strew the heach with broken glass (R. 28. 16:
We ee 7 eee :

It draws flies of all kinds in great swarins (R. 417).

; The garbage contains. various articles -unmentionable ‘i
their nature and highly objectionable to the touch (R
76-7). enn |

, One of the fishermen stepped an a broken bottle whilk
landing his boat and was taken to. the hospital where ter
stitches were necessary to be taken in his foot (R. 77)
Another fisherman testified that the horses which they usec
on the beach stepped on nails in boards in ‘the garbage
and wereinjured (R. 313). Fane are
- The use of the beach or waters when’ the garbage is
there involves the risk of stepping on nails in the drift.

. wood or broken glass which comes with the garbage. Many

‘such cases of injury appear in the testimony (R. 312, 149

’

‘Summer at Long Branch a gentleman eut his foot severely
on a broken bottle in the surf which required seven

"Stitches. Similar. accidents have securred to children

@. AT aah
- (R. 391). A great many instances of that kind -ha 2 0C-
curred at Point Pleasant and a good many of such cases.
have been taken to Dr. Deniston’s hospital’ there; some
_ of them of a serious character (R. 415-16), ene

é >

| __ The bathing clubs and pavilions maintain first-aid kits:
and some of them first-aid squads, for the sole purpose of
treating people whose feet or body are injured by tt

SOS Ree

glass, nails and other refuse in the garbage, either float
ing in the water or stranded on the beach (R. 17, 259, 284;
338). In 1927 the City of Asbury Park was sued by a|
bather who had received a bad cut on his knee while
‘bathing on one of the beaches owned by the city (R. 509). |
Some of the bottles in the garbage are labelled ‘‘Poison’’
which. still have material in them. The situation is
serious, especially if a child happens to pick up such a
bottle (R. 106-107), AS ge

The presence of the garbage in the water and on the
beach produces an unhealthy and a very dangerous condi-
tion (R. 314). Bathers must avoid the garbage and debris
in the water because it would injure their bodies ‘and
would be a menace to their health (R. 328, 363, 164, 198,
482, 351-2). When: it has laid in the sun some of it
smells terrific and it is dangerous to go on the beach —
when it is there (R. 499-500). The witness: Mosten has -
‘gone down to the beach to bathe when it was so nasty _
that he could not go in without getting the garbage in

his mouth. “It forms a nasty yellowish.foam, on the water
fear: tial a baa: ping NE

Officers of the Seabright Beach Club have had repeated

: >

= {B. 18): People are afraid to send children to the beach,
lest they he. poisoned ‘by picking up things (R. 367-8).

Mrs,’ Jarden, who has a summer home at Mantoloking, ;
testified: that if they had realized the conditions caused

*

Rs 4. 5
SO Sa

a

Sele

by the garbage ‘and had to do.it over again, they would
buy further south where the beaches are clean and sani-
tary for.children. ‘(A mother wants a clean, safe, sani-
‘tary beach for a\child to play on.. These conditions are
\absent at Mantoloking because. of broken glass, ‘dirt,
Aebrs and disgusting dirt.’? She described the odor of
the garbage as very disagreeable and intolerable. It-is
terribly offensive. She objects to the rags and mattresses.
She fears that the children will get cut and pick up things ~
(B.\ 352-3). i eee | oa
Tenants complained to Mr. Kirch, who is in the real
estate business at Long Branch, that they: are afraid to
have théir children go into the water because of the boxes -
and nails, garbage ‘‘and various. other. things which |
do not care to name at ‘this particular time, which are
_ more offensive. .Some of the articles in the garbage are
' ° so offensive that I prefer not to name them’’ (R. 359)

The average mother recognizes the possibility of typhoid
q fever in floating garbage of this nature and there-has ,
| been typhoid fever.in Red Bank where the ‘witness who --
gave this testimony lives (R. 331). Some of the niaterials
y mixed with the arbage comes from sick rooms. and has
|. to be buried: or burned (R. 336-337). Children ‘have to *
/_. be kept away from the beach .at times on account of the
filth (R. 102, 107). “Mrs. Patch described the garhage
as very disagreeable, not only because of its presence, but
because of the things whieh thé small children pick
from it (R. 204). .°. ~ eae 3 oar

The. garbage brings in @ scum and filth on the océan a ;
consisting of dissolved particles. It-is dirty and smells:
It ‘is disintegrated vegetable matter, dead animals and
rotten meat (R. 215-16). It is highly unsanitary. It
has an objectionable odor and it is. disagreeable to tread é
upon. It makes the beaches an unpleasant place for
children to play and it is actually unsafe at times to bathe
because of the large amount of refuse in the water (R.
351-352). ses

\

ed re eee
rpeeforinsiice mememcarnl

A

ai
——

Se ee

Maeiie: Hills of Spring Lake ‘has had many complaints
from. familiés concerning their children. and women. They ,
were much alarmed and afraid their children would con-

tract disease from the garbage (R. 239). Mr. Ward has to .

keep his own children away fromthe beach when the
garbage is there. The doctor ordered it because he did

not want the children to run the risk of contracting disease

oF gain an inféction ‘from . the garbage: (R. 415-16). °
Mrs. Rhodes will permit her children to go td the

beach until she ascertains what_the ‘garbage conditions °

are, .That is the general practice in the community (R. ©.
363). , | et a
|

.Dr. James A. Fisher, of Asbury Park, an eye, ear, nose
and throat specialist, testified that he was familiar with
the conditions of garbage on. the beach and believes ‘they
play a part in his professional work. He has. prepared
a summary of the diseases of the ear. and the sinuses
forthe months~of- June, July and August to see if there
has been an increase in those diseases during those months.
In 1928 he had four! cases of furunculosi; in 1929 he had ©
twelve cases. In 1928 he -had.one case of external otitis,
which is a ‘swélling and inflammation of the ear canal.
In 1929 he had eleven suck cases, ‘Tn '1998 he had eleven
cases of middle éar infection, including the reddening of
the eardrum, which required the drum to be opened.
in 1929 he had fourteen such’ cases. Tn 1928 he had =
eight sinus ihfection cases, In 1929 he had eleven such
cases. In each: of those cases bathers came in with the
Temark that they had gotten something from: the sea
bathing. Pure sea water has a high chlorine content:
and is quite antiseptic; infection ‘is therefore quite
contrary to the natural condition of sea water. .The

IN cases which ‘he mentions were only those that. ap-

peared in his records under A, B; C and D. His records
Were too numerous to complete: the investigation for all -
the letters of the alphabet in his records (R. -84-86).

a

Rha ben \ age ea °
tks is i aie Se i N . | %.
Sat al » =

a ae

. 48
_ The Hotels.

The effect of the garbage upon. the hotel business is
'_. deseribed by the proprietors or managers of some of the |
important. hotels (Penna, R. 113-5; Schock, R. 126-7;

Hillig,/R. 206-8; Hayes, R. 250; Stubbs, R. 251-2; Dut.
field (President, Asbury Park Hotelmen’s Association)
.R, 421-2; Butcher, R. 422-3; McElroy, /R-424; Van Ness,
R. 429; Kinmouth, R. 440-5; Manneshuer, R. 487-8).

ing the nature and extent of the hotel business and the
' number and character of the guests who come to the
seashore for recreational purposes during the summer, It
shows that the’ sole attraction of the municipalities and
the hotels is the beach-front and the opportunity for
' bathing, fishing and other recreation to be found there.
It also shows that the garbage conditions are the cause
of constant complaint and dissatisfaction among the guests

particularly among those whose circumstances permit only |

a short vacation. If the garbage on the beach or in the
water prevents them from bathing for two or three days,
as frequently occurs, the major part of their vacation is
ruined. :This applies to guests who come for a week, but

these circumstances are particularly unfortunate for those. —

~who come on day excursions or for week-ends and hap-
pen to find garbage conditions existing at the time. This
testimony also shows that the presence of garbage in the
water and on the beach. has a direct effect upon: the vol-

. ume of the hotel business and the satisfaction of the

guests. Instances are mentioned where guests were s0
‘ disappointed by the garbage on the beach that they packed
up their bags and went elsewhere-to spend the remainder
of their vacation (R. 207). Instances appear where guests
stopped coming to these resorts entirely because of their
disgust with the garbage condition (R, 250).

This testimony gives considerable information regard. -

_. lant Lightship, (Pl, Exs. 321-325).

ee

_ At the Monterey’ Hotel at Asbury Park in Julf, 1928, .
a group of seven guests who had been accustomed pre-
viously to:stay for protracted periods, told the manager -
that the beach was a mess, that they could not fut up
with it, and they left (R. 443-444). ft =
. The president of the Asbury Park Hotelmen’s Asso- °
‘ ciation stated that the garbage condition is the most dis-
* couraging thing which-the hotel men have to deal with in ©

their business (R. 422). The Asbury Park. hotels sg
general advertising program to attract people from dib-

. tant places (R. 424). “ 4

‘Defendant's Proof.

As the Special Master observed (Rep., p. 50), plain-
tiff’s testimony showing that the garbage drifted to the
plaintiff’s shore, its affect on navigation and fishing in
plaintiff’s waters, (within three miles of the shore)
and the shore, was not contradicted by any evidence. of-
fered: by defendant. -. | ris

.' ‘There is therefore no dispuie concerning these facts,
or as to quantity of garbage dumped by defendant at sea
or the location of the dumping grounds, as designated by -
the Supervisor of the harbor-at various distances, accord-
ing to season, up to 20. miles, southeast by east of Scot-

That Lightship: and the various ship channels at the .
mouth of New York Harbor and off the coast of New
Jersey, are shown on Appendix ‘‘A’* annexed to this
brief. The locations of several of: the dumping grounds,
are shown on Pl. Exhibit 205 (R. 294-5).

The fact that defendant’s garbage reached plaintiff's
shores ‘was constantly ealled to its attention, without de-
nial, during the negotiations of Governors Silzer, ‘Moore
and Larson, in the correspondence contained in Exhibits |
298 and 299, and-in Exhibits 257 and 258 there are fre--°

®

quent admissions of the fact by official representatives of —

, defendant. In August, -1925,. Mr. Taylor, Street Clgan-

‘ing Comissioner of defendant, came down to the Séabright
Beach Club, in answer to complaints from Smack. He ad- .
-mnitted that the plaintiff’s garbage littered the. plaintiff’s _

beaches, and said-‘‘I am going-to ask you, I am going to
_* beg you to lay off me. -You-are making my life a. hell.
~, If you will, within one year we will have completed all

our plans for incineration and we will dispose of all of -

New York City’s garbage in that way.’? (R. 19). 2

At the hearings defendant undertook to dispose of plain-

, tiff’s proof by ‘the testimony of three witnesses confined
to three’ specific occasions, all.in the. winter time’ (Janv-

ary 30, February 1,.and February 29, 1930) who attempted

_ “to show that the garbage dumped at sea was so beaten up

by the wind and waves that it either sank or was dissi-

pated. (Gainard, R. 547-57; Lawrence, R. 581-9; Bergs-
ten, R. 614-621). - The testimony of these witnesses is in
. entire accord with that of Haas, Smack, and. the fishermen
respecting the action of garbage efter being dumped at
sea and the manner in. which it floats before the wind.
On their first inspection they drifted with. the garbage

for a distance of about-ten miles until they were required -
‘to discontinue on account of.a snow storm (R. 549).—On.

that oceasion the garbage was dumped at a distance of

twenty miles, and drifted to within fourteen miles, of the ~

Jersey shore before they left. (R. 550). On the second
‘ occasion “they put bettles overboard in the garbage to

test the floating but did not-gather them up. because ‘‘they _
were floating to the Jersey’ shore.” (R. 557). Since -
‘these inspéctions were made at night and one, at least,
during a snow storm, it is not strange that the garbage

disappeared from their view.

i "

gs) ba ica

. See se

“Summary of Facts.

It is difficult to adequately describe the nature and ex-
tent of the development of the plaintiff’s seashore resorts
or the extent to which they are used for bathing, recrea: . .
tion and other useful: purposes: There is probably no
" place in the world where people resort in. such. large num-

-bers to, the seashore for the primary purpose of beach and
_- bathing pleasure as in New Jersey, and the resorts along
the section in question are second to none in their aggre-
“gate importance, value and ‘extent of patronage.
The exhibits and the testimony show that these ‘shore
municipalities, which adjoin each other and stretch along
; the shore for a distance of seventy miles, constitute the
greatest park and playground in the world. _ They serve
the people of the adjacent municipalities, the people of
the entire state, and people from all parts of the United
States and some from abroad. In addition to the general
use for recreational purposes which plaintiff undertakes -
to preserve, :there has developed in the twenty-nine muni-
cipalities involved property values aggregating more than
one. hundred thirty-nine and one-half million dollars
(Plaintiff’s Exhibit 69), which depend for their main-
tenance upon the preservation of these recreational ad-

vantages. . ;

’ Those municipalities have a permanent population of |
over 160,000 people, whose Support and welfare depend

upon recreational enterprises. In addition to that,
- there are | increases in the population in the sum-

mer of people who operate summer hotels, shore-front
concessions and business enterprises and those who ‘as-
sist in the general work of lodging, feeding and entertain-
ing the. many thousands of guests or residents who come
in the summer. | ca

.

_ The record shows that here is a large and important. -
industry, one of the most valuable in the plaintiff’s state,

_ of the seashore communities; depreciates the value of

- §9- -

which ‘suffers constantly in annoyance and expense: from :
the public nuisange caused by the defendant’s dumping of
garbage at sea. It retards the development and growth fe

real property; reduces and impairs the development of
_ commercial enterprises; and retards the general’ pros- —
perity; impairs and at times.déstroys the use and en-
joyment of the advantages of valuable. public beach front
and of -the shore waters. for bathing purposes; creates
a menace to life and limb from nails in boards, floating
‘wood ,and broken glass brought in with the ‘garbage;
exposes the frequenters of the beach -to infection -and
disease from decayed and putrid vegetable and animal
matter and from disgusting, repulsive «and unmention-
able unsanitary articles therein contained, and the people -
in public places and in their houses ‘to the annoyance
of foul odors emanating from such decayed. matter;
incurs what amounts in the aggregate to a very large ?
annual expense for cleaning the public and private
beaches and removing the offensive material from streets - ©
and public places; and exposes the people about the }
beaches, streets and other. public places and in their
‘houses’ to infections and disease carried by the vast -
swarms of flies which feed and breed in the putrid
- masses of the garbage. No. essential fact remains to
complete a powerful indictment against’ the defendant
for creating a public nuisance within. the territorial limits’
of the plaintiff by.reason of the dumping of its garbage
at sea, . :

-«

Public Nuisance Proven. °

The Special Master’s conclusions that the conditions
shown by plaintiff’s uncontradicted testimony amount to
a publie nuisance (Rep. 53), and that plaintiff has
the right to. bring this suit and to have injunctive relief,
are amply sustained by all the authorities. 7 Bacon’s

“ $4555

53 .

~~ Abr., (Nuisance) pp. 223, 228-230, 233; 21 Am. & Eng. |
Ency, L. (2d ed.) pp. 682-3, 688, 711; 1 Wood on Nuisances: |
(3 ed.) Sees, 14, 19-20; Gould on Waters (3 ed.) Secs. 21,
92-3; .1 Spelling on Injunction, Sees. 373-4; N. orthwestern
Fertilizing Co., v. Hyde Park, 97 U. 8. 659; Georgia v. -
Tenn. Copper Co., 206 U. S. 230, 237, 239; Kuehn v. Mil-

_ waukee, 92 Wis. 263, 18 L. R. A. 553, 504-6; Block v.

- Baltimore, 149 Md. -39,- 129 Atl. Rep. 887, 891-4;.
Huffmire v. Brooklyn, 162 N. Y. 984, 57 N. E. 176, 177-8;

_ Peck v. Michigan City, 49 N. EB: 800, 801; Kansas v. Con- °
cordia, 96 Pac. 487, 20 L. R. A. (N. S.) 1050, 1055-7;
Board of Health v.. Lederer, 52 N. J.-Eq. 675, 682-3;

~ Mugler v. Kansas, 123 U.S. 623, 673; Baltimore dc. R. R.

| Co. v. Fifth Baptist Church, 108 U. S.°317; Attorney:
General v. Jamaica Pond Acqueduct Corp., 133 Mass.,
363-364. sass ;

ie Compliance by the defendant with the provisions of the |
Act of Congress of June 29, 1888 (29 Stat. 209) as amended,
and the permits:to dump garbage in the Atlantic Ocean at
' /& distance in excess of one marine league from the shores
| of New Jersey issued by the Supervisor of the Harbor of
New York in accordance with said Act, do not relieve the
defendant from the effect of the public nuisance resulting

from and created by said dumping. . ~ |

Under this heading defendant has grouped its excep-
tions 44 to 50, inclusive, which challenge the Master’s
_ findings that the permits of the Supervisor of the Harbor
do ‘not. authorize or justify the defendant to commit a
public nuisance’ in- the waters or. on the shores. of the
plaintiff. : é Nae. ie | :
Defendant claims the right to dump its garbage and

refuse at sea by virtue of permits issued by the Super.

the following Act of Congress: _

‘“‘The placing, discharging, or depositing, by any
' process. or in any manner, of refuse, dirt, ashes,
cinders, mud, sand, dredgings, sludge, acid, or any
other. matter: of any kind, other than that flowing
from streets, sewers,.and passing therefrom in a
| liquid state, in the tidal waters of. the harbor of’.
ee _ New York, or its adjacent or. tributary waters, or.
eee in ‘those of Long Island Sound, within the limits
: which shall be. prescribed by the’ supervisor of the
harbor, is hereby strictly forbidden, and every’ such ©
act is made a misdemeanor, and every. person én- -
gaged.in or who shall aid, abet, authorize, or insti-
ran a a violation of: this section, shall, upon eonvic-
tion, be punishable by fine-or imprisonment,: or both,
such fine to be not. less than $250 nor more than j
. $2,500, and the imprisonment to be not less than _
- thirty days nor more than one year, either or both |
| ania as the judge before whom conviction is. ob-- _
_ tained shall: decide, one half of said fine to be paid ‘
,

vier. of the Harbor of New York, under authority of:

S \ to the\person or persons giving information’ which
Fans shall lead to conviction of this misdemeanor. (June
29, 1888,,c. 496, Sec. 1,25 Stat. 209)’ (U. S: C. A.

Title 33, Sec. 441, p. 455). * 3 |
‘‘In all cases of. receiving on board of any ‘scows
or boats such forbidden matter or substance as de-
‘seribed in section 441 of this chapter,:the owner or |
master, or person acting in such capacity on board |
of such scows or boats,, before proceeding to take or {|
tow the same to the place of deposit, shall apply for, [>
_ and obtain from the supervisor of the harbor ap- -

_ pointed as provided in section 451 of this chapter,

a permit defining the precise limits within which

the discharge Of such scows or. boats-may be made;
and it shall not be lawful for the owner or master, ©
or’ person acting in such capacity, of any tug or
towboat to tow or move any scow or boat so luaded
with such forbidden matter until such permit shall
have been obtained and every person violating the
foregoing provisions of this section shall be deemed
guilty of a misdemeanor, and on conviction there-
- Of shall be punished by a fine of ‘not more than

) - . a . = .
~— — . ‘ x
q
; : 55 é ”
eee | 5 .

$1,000, nor less than $500, and in addition thereto

the master of any tug or towboat so offending shall
have his license revoked, or suspended for a term

to be fixed by the judge before whom tried and con.

victed. (May 28, 1908, ¢. 212, Sec. 8, 35 Stat.

426)” (U. S. C. A., Title 33, Sec. 443, p. 458). 2

The only authority of the federal governnient is to

protect navigation. ; ree
_ Wisconsin v., Illinois, 278 U. S. 367, 41%.

- The above-quoted act does not confer plenary power to

authorize defendant to dump its garbage and refuse at -

sea. Such are the uniform decisions of the courts

in construing similar’) acts, such. as the Rivers and

Harbor act of 1899, under which the Secretary of War

- tssues permits for structures in or over navigable-waters.
Cummings v. Chicago, 188 U. 8. 410; Montgomery v. Port-

_ land, 190 U. S.. 89; Attorney General v. Hudson County
Water Co., 76 N. J. Eq. 543; 22 Op. Atty. Gen’l, 332;

~ Cobb v. Lincoln Park, 202 Ill. 427; International Bridge

Co. v. N. ¥., 254 U. S, 126,

There is no difference in-principle in this respect, be-
tween the River and Harbor Act involved in the authori-

+ ties above cited,?and the act to prevent obstructive and °
injurious deposits in New York Harbor and adjacent .

waters above quoted.

A statute which’ purported -to confer authority:-to dump

defendant’s garbage at sea. so as to. affect ‘Pilaintiff’s

property would be in derogation. of the common law, ..

and therefore.must be strictly construed. Attorney Gen-
eral v. Hudson County Water Co., 76.N. J.. Eq. 543, 552.
_ The above statute so construed does not give any such
authority. Moreover, that act does not appear to. confer
_ upon the Supervisor of. the Harbor authority even to

permit: defendant to dump garbage in the places used for La

that’ purpose. It authorizes: him to prescribe limits within
Which dumping of materia] is forbidden (See. 441). See-

f m

*4

-- seribed at pages 293-6, shows that the dumping places §

| \\ a
o"8 56
tion 443 implies, but does not expressly authorize, the
issuance of permits, before scows, of forbidden matter
ean be moved, defining ‘‘the.precise limits within which
the discharge of such scows or boats may be made.”
There is no evidence in this case showing what, if any,
‘*preeise limits’’ were defined in the permits for any of
defendant’s scows. ‘The various reports of the Super-
“visor (Exhibits 321-334). prescribe the direction and dis-
tance ‘‘southeast by east from’ Scotland Lightship”’ for
the dumping of scows containing garbage or other mate-
vials, but the statute says the permit itself, in each in.
. Stance, shall define those -‘‘precise limits.” It is, there.
fore, impossible on this record to determitie eyen the
. validity of the permits, or permission to use the dumping f

grounds which defendant’ does use. |

That act is distinetly limited in its application to “‘the
tidal waters.of the harbor of New York; or its adjacent .
or tributary waters, or in those of Long Island Sound.”
Outside of those limits another statute applies, namely .
section 407 U. S. Code, Title 33 (30 Stat: 1152, Sec. 13),
which contains similar prohibitions ‘with authority to the’
Secretary of War, ‘‘whenever in, the judgment of the
Chief of Engineers anchorage and navigation will not be
injured. thereby,’’ to permit the deposit of material in
the tiavigable waters of the United States, upon. such
conditions as he may prescribe. It does not appear that
the Secretary of War ever. issued any permit to defend-
ant: On the contrary iodeaaiet claims that its permits
were all issued by the Supervisor of the Harbor, and See-
retary of War Weeks in a letter dated September 10, 1923,
advised Governor Silzer that ‘‘no permits therefor - have
been issued by the department”’ (Pl. Ex. 298)...

_- There is a question whether the waters twenty miles
southeast by east of Scotland Lightship are ‘‘adjacent”’
waters of the harbor of New York. ‘Exhibit 205, de-

e

57 :
observed: by Smack were located ‘approximately 1114 |
miles off North Long Branch and approximately 1914 miles
off Asbury Park.. The dumping grounds ‘most frequently
used, were off the New Jersey shore between Deal‘ Beach
and North Asbury Park. | It* is therefore a question
whether’ the dumping grounds used by the defendant are
within the limits described in. the act of 1888.: U. 8. v.

- Sadie, 41 Fed. 396; City v. Leland, 45 Fed. 380. -

The Special Master points out (R. 46) that these dump-
ing grounds. are not’ within the limits of the: definition
of the Harbor of New’ York as‘ prescribed bythe Secre-:
tary of the Treasury, under the Act of February 2, 1895
(28 Stat. 672), as “‘a line from Navesink Lighthouse to _
Scotland Light, thence. to Whistling Buoy in Gedney’s |
Channel, and thence to’ Rockaway Point (see Plaintiff’s
Exhibit 205). | eS | ;

However, we are here confronted with the converse of
the question discussed under ‘Point 1, respecting jurisdic. -
tion. Defendant claims authority under the permit issued ~
_ pursuant to an act of Congress, but denies jurisdiction .

of the Court over the place to which it: claims the per- oa
_- mit apply. In any*event it is plain that the Master’s.

.. €onelusion is correct (R..49) that possession of, and com-. .
pliance with, the permits issued by the Supervisor. of the

.

Harbor furnish no defense to relieve defendant from -the

_ effect of a public nuisance resulting from its action thére- -

under. Joyce on Nuisances, Sec. 284; Brayton v. Fall -
. River, 118 Mass. 218; Franklin Wharf -v. Portland, 57

Me. 446; Huffmire v. Brooklyn, and Block vy. Maryland,
cited’ above. Be | : ated

a 561). . This would ‘equal 100 Ibs. of garbage. per day per

58

/ (4) : ae
_ Such garbage and refuse as reaches the plaintiff’s shores -.
from the dumpings by coastwise and other vessels and from
other sources is negligible in comparison with that dumped
by defendant and reaching plaintiff’s shores and consti-
- tutes no defense to plaintiff’s complaint. -

- Under this heading defendant has grouped its excep-
tions 51 to 69, inclusive,- which challenge the Master’s
findings that whatever garbage and refuse reaches plain- |
tiff’s shores from passing vessels and other causes and
other dumpings are negligible in comparison with that con- .
“stantly being dumped by defendant and carried by winds -
and ‘waves to and upon laintiff’s shores, and the Master’s
failure and refusal to find as: requested respecting sewage.
' from Long Branch and Asbury Park, . -

_ - Defendant contends that the garbage dumped by. defend- |
ant was so mixed up with condemned food stuff and |
garbage dumped by passing ships that it was impossible
to tell the source from which the garbage on the beaches
comes. Defendant’s three witnesses, Gainard, Lawrence
_ and Bergsten testified to’the number of passing vessels
_ and the. alleged accumulation of garbage on the decks,
_ amounting, according to Gainard, sometimes to 50 tons, —
_ accumulated in ten to fifteen days in port (R. 560), oceupy- :
_. ing a space of 50-cu, ft. to the ton, or 2,500 cubic feet of ©
_ garbage and ‘refuse piled on the deck of, a. vessel‘ (R.

man for ten days for a-crew of 100 men. , Neither Law-
rence. nor Bergsten were willing to go that far, but
Lawrence thought that he had dumped as much as from
25 to 30 tons of accumulated garbage at-one time (R. «
591). The rebuttal evidence shows. that this testimony is
incredible. Such dumping is in violation of the Act ‘of.
- ’ 1888, and of the regulations ‘issued by the Supervisor of
_ the Harbor. (Exhibits 342.4) as shown by his testimony’ ~

(R. 628). , He (Captain Anderson) ‘testified that in the

-/.. enforcement’ of the law he employs two patrol boats and
hag the co-operation of the Custom Guards, Prohibition ~
Officers and Coast Guards (R. 629) ; that\if it were the
ordinary practice of. vessels to accumulate, garbage in
port and dump it at sea in ‘the manner and quantities tes-

- tified’ by Gainard, Lawrence and Bergsten, he or his in-

spectors would have: been likely to have discovered some - :

instances-of it. It could riot continually escape \\their
notice. An occasional violation might not be detected\but .
a prevailing practice could not escape detection. me

During the hearings counsel for defendant attempted \
to obtain on cross examination. of fishermen who testified >.
for plaintiff. admissions that passing vessels dumped gar-

' bage into the sea, A’ number of those witnesses admitted
that“small quantities were so dumped but: all of. them
testified that there was téo much garbage in the sea to -
have come from passing vessels (R. 45, 130), since vessels
threw out only a very small amount, like.a bucket-full, ata
time. (R. 131-40). - In reply. to such a question on cross |
_ examination, Mr, Bailey, who had been a coastguard officer
for 28 years, said: . ‘‘If the garbage came from the. pass- .
ing’ vessels it would come on a southeast wind, as well as
-.on-a north or northeast wind, but it does not come that ”
way. It comes only on a east or northeast wind’? (R. 132).
'/In, answer to a similar question,. Mr. Howland replied
that it. was impossible ' for ‘the garbage to have
_ come from passing ships. He could see no reason why
_Aarbage from the passing ships would blow ashore, while
garbage from the defendant’s dump would go in the
other ‘direction, on. the same wind (R. 29). One of the ~
fishermen said: ‘I have seen quantities larger than the ~
. Steamer could.carry’’ (R, 40). ae i

Other rebuttal of defendant ’s testimony came from two
of plaintiff’s witnesses. William: Park, Superintendent of
. the Clyde and Mallory Lines, has. been engaged in

oo

.

coastwise shipping as captain and otherwise for mor |
than thirty years. He operates 21 ships out of ‘the port

so
R
®
~_—
ee
a
~~
®
ae
nM
D
Qu
ee
~
co
)
—s
4
jor)
ae
mM
uo)
o
t
Qu
°
=t
oS
S-
2.
an
m
°o
7:
ry
S
RET SRT OI NOMS 51 Pla NED GATE Dg! 2

Saw any, quantity of garbage |
dumped at sea by any. vessel. He has sailed through .
the garbage areas of defendant’s dumping grounds at x
sea and has seen quantities of garbage which could not es
have come from passing vessels. He shas riever: seen © |
accumulations of garbage on the decks of vessels, as ‘€
testified to by Gainard and his associates. Hé made the. -|.
significant statement that ‘‘No good sailor would cover |.’
his deck with slippery, slimy garbage (R. 645-9).

61

3 Sewer Pollytion.

Defendant also alleges, and attempted to prove, that
the waters and beaches at Long Branch and Asbury
Park were, polluted by insufficiently treated and unsani-

tary sewage from tho

Se cities. With respect to Long |

Branch it subpoenaed the Director and records of plain- |
tiff’s Department of Health. . The records. consisted: of

defendant’s Exhibit 9,

which included three resolutions,

all adopted: ‘September 14, 1926, relating ‘to the sewer
system of a‘ private company called ‘“‘The Long Branch _
Sewer Company.’’? Resolution (a) accusés the company .

of ‘polluting the waters of the ocean by insufficiently ~ 4

- treated sewage, and calls upon it to remedy the condi-

tion prior to June 15, 1927 3 resolutions (b) and (¢) show
that thereupon the company”applied to the Department-of-

. Health for permission to make certain. extensions and

_\ changes which were approved b

y the Department as pro- -

viding ‘‘a sewage ‘treatment plant satisfactory to this

Department.’’ “Defend

ant also produced as its Exhibit

No. 10 a report made in 1928 by: Messrs. Watson, Pugh,
and Lendall, Consulting Engineers: of New York City,
for tle City of Long Branch, for the purpose of valuing ©

of ‘the sewer system of
~ the purchase of whi
_’ Although ‘that report

the sewer system.’ by
“mention ‘of time and n

the Long Branch Sewer Company,
ch the ‘city then contemplated. ©
purports to refer to criticism of
“‘the state authorities’’ without.
ature, the engineers recommended

_ the purehase of the system ‘‘at the price asked_by ‘the

company.’ \ _(Defendan

t’s Exhibit No: 10, pp. 1, 2:) .

There is‘ no other evidence of any deficiency in, or.
pollution from, the Long Branch Sewer System.

With respect to ‘the

Asbury Park. sewer, two of de- ;

fendant’s. te proglienens} that on March 11, 1930,

they examined: the

utlet of that sewer, located in thé ~

ocean at a point between 1,000 ‘and 1,200 feet from the.
Shore and observed articles of decomposed fecal matter

4

- P 4 . i : . . ®
te MZ oe Prato’ f ; o + ‘
“ is aes . ae . , - $
: Py ag res , . eee .
4 . o ° » .

-and pieces of orange shall abe toilet! paper s and other -
objects floating in the water..-They did not say this _
matter’ came from the sewer (R. 612-14). In ‘rebuttal —
the Supérintendent of the Asb . Park Sewer System
described the method of sewer treatment, and stated
that no-fecal or solid matter goes into ‘the sea and that
the effluent is not of the character ‘that will pollute the
water. He further testified that for a short period each
winter they open the valve for the purp se of flushing

. out the sewer system and that happened to\be the condi-_
tion existing on- March 49, 1930, when defendant’s wit-

nesses examined the sewer outlet (R. 650-3).

"Defendant offered as its Exhibit No. 11 ana bill of
complaint filed by the plaintiff’s Department of Health

against the City of Asbury Park on November 10, 1930,

alleging pollution of the shore waters by the sewer system

of that city ‘‘due to the inadequate, improper and insuffi- ©

cient capacity and ‘unit design of said sewage treatment
works,’’ and praying for an injunction. . These allega-
tioris were denied in the city’s answer filed December
30, 1930. In due course that case will come to trial on the
merits. - Whether’ the Department of Health succeeds or
fails in its attempt to prove the allegations of the com-
2 plaint is not important in ‘this case for the reasons:
first, if it sueceeds the occasion merély serves to illustrate
the indiscriminate diligence of plaintiff in. the protection
- of its beaches, and second, the cause of action alleged
in that complaint arose after the record in this case was
completed, and if those allegations are proven they
could not have any effect upon ‘the conditions of oe
pollution alleged -and - proven.

a

i
Other Testimony of Defendant.
Defendant produced the ‘records: of the Office of the

Supervisor of the Port showing that seven. different

companies obtained permits for dumping mud, cellar .
dirt and excavated yock at points from four to six-.

_miles southeast of Scotland Lightship. The proof does
‘not show that any of these permits were ever used or that

any such material was ever actually dumped, but that
is immaterial because none of those permits authorized
the dumping of .garbage or other floating material, of

which plaintiff’ complains “(R. 546-7).

Another witness of. defendant testified to the location —
of ‘certain private docks \in New York City which he -

had inspected between March 3 and 12,. 1930, and‘ de-

scribed certain scows by name and certain classes of
material, consisting in part of garbage and refuse and dirt,

‘with which the seows were bei & loaded (R. 595-602).

No testimony was offered that ‘any of these scows had
permits or. were dumped at Sea, or where they were
dumped, and none of the names of those scows are _in-

cluded in those given by plaintiff ’s:-witnesses, who, on

_ the contrary, distinctly identified, as belonging to the

Departinent of Street Cleaning of the City of New York, .
by the initials ‘“D.S.c.” thereon, the,scows which they
testified were dumping garbage off the plaintiff’s coast. -
If all of the scows mentioned in this testimony had

- dumped their material off plaintiff’s coast ‘the amount
- oftheir contents would have been infinitesimal and in-

consequential as compared with ‘the dumping by de-—
fendant of 192,000 tons per month in summer or of an av-
erage of 2833 tons of garbage and refuse each and every ©

* working day throughout the year.

. Defendant’s exception No. 57 refers to the failure —
and-refusal of the Special Master to find, as requested,
that Brooklyn Navy Yard scow containing refuse and
garbage also. dumped h sea at the regular dumping

~

oF

64

points at which defendant’s garbage is dumped.. A
score or more of plaintiff’s witnesses saw defend-
ant’s scows dump garbage at sea, but they never saw
a Navy Yard scow dump-any material, and defendant
produced no evidence of any such dumping. oe
Defendant’s contention that a similar nuisance is being
created by. passing ships, private contractors, or the
Brooklyn Navy Yard is not a valid defense. 21 Am.
Eng. Ency. L. (2d ed.) 690; Rowland v. N. Y. Stable
Manure Co., 88 N. J. Eq. 168, 175. iat

The Master was therefore justified in his conclusion
(Rep. p, 36) that whatever garbage and ‘refuse reached

_ - plaintiff’s shores from these other sources are negligible

‘in comparison with that constantly being dumped by
the defendant, and frequently carried by wind and waves
from the dumping places to and upon plaintiff’s shores.

(5) a oe
Particular exceptions to the Special Master’s report-and
to his failure to find facts and make conclusions of law as
requested by defendant and in support of its contention
that all of the evidence, a case for equitable relief in favor
of the plaintiff, was not made out. \ | - nae

Under this heading defendant has grouped its excep-
tions 70 to: 92 inclusive, which challenge the Master’s
findings respecting the construction and operation. of in- —
cinterators for the disposal of - garbage, his finding
that the defendant had delayed the adoption of a proper |
method for that purpose, and ‘other miscellaneous findings
or failures to refusals to find as requested on certain
minor points. - \.

The finding of the Master that the evidence does not
show the cause of apparent ‘delay by the defendant jin -
adopting and putting in operation the incinerating system

65

and that this delay has been unreasonably long (Rep.
p. 30), which is the basis of defendant’s exceptions 70
‘and 71, is amply justified by the record, as appears from.
the discussion under the heading “‘Official Objections” in. _
Point (2) of this brief. ‘In spite of ‘constant complaints |
from plaintiff’s officials and municipalities; in spite of the |
numerous admonitions of the Secretary of War and the
Supervisor of the Harbor; and in spite of the numerous
promises of defendant’s officials, all unfulfilled, defendant ’s:
Exhibit -12, and the testimony of defendant’s witnesses,
show that, in spite of the Incinerators which’ defendant
‘claims to have constructed and put in operation,’ the
amount of garbage dumped at sea in the year * was”
greater than that of the three previous years, = \
After. a number of years of experience with defendant ’s
promises, Captain Anderson, Supervisor of the Harbor,
in a published statement of J uly, 1930, said:

3 _ ‘Official statement has been made to the Super-

* _ visor that this desirable situation (the discontinuance

: of dumping at: sea) would be reached by the end of
Sees j

Experience in the past indicates that these sanguine
estimates are not to be taken too literally, however.’’
(U. 8. Naval Institute Proceedings Vol. No. 56, No.

‘7, Whole No, 329, July, 1930, P. 577.)

NMEA OC. BETES LATS SS SETS SO

Defendant’s exception No.. 91° challenges‘ the . Master’s a
failure and, refusal to conclude as a matter of law, as
requested, that the plaintiff has failed to prove facts
sufficient to constitute a cause of ‘action in equity for the
relief demanded in the complaint or for any relief what-
ever in equity. , |

On the argument before the Master defendant contended
‘that even though it was a city, rather than a state, it was
entitled to the benefit of the rule stated in Missouri v..
Illinois, 200 U: S.. 496’ and: New York v. New Jersey,

— 296 U.S. 296, that in order to control the conduct of one 4

state at the suit of another, the injury must be of serious
magnitude and clearly ‘proven. Plaintiff contended, on

the contrary, that the different rulé established in Georgia.

v. Tenn. Copper Co., 206 U.S. 230, applied, namely:

(p. 237) ‘‘Some pecularities necessarily mark ‘a

suit .of this\ kind. the state has a case at all, it

_ is somewhat more certainly entitled to specific relief
_ than a private party might be.” ae

(p. 238) ‘‘This court has not quite the same free-
dom to balance the harm that will be done by an
injunction against that of which the plaintiff com-
plains, that it would have in deciding between two

subjects of a single’ political power.”’
Defendant: has not the ‘status or sovereignty of a

state, but is a citizen of the state of New York, Wis- .
consin v. Duluth, 96. U. S..379; Trenton v. New Jer-
“sey, 262 U. S. 182, 189; Metropolitan. R. R: Co. v.

‘District of Columbia, 132 U. S. 1; Cincinnati v. First

_. Presbyterian Church,.8 Hammond 298; 1. Sharswoods

Bl. Com. 191, Note 6.

_ While we think this contention is correct. we are also -
convinced that the Master was correct in his conclusion ©

(Rep. p. 57) that there has not only been an invasion of
‘serious magnitude of plaintiff’s ‘rights extending through
Some years, but it is continuing and is threatened for ‘an

indefinite period. For these reasons we think the Master
_ was also correct in failing and. refusing to conclude, as

requested, that defendant is entitled to a dismissal of the
complaint, with costs. (Defendant’s exception: No. 92.)
eer be = |
Recommendations For Decree.
Under this. heading defendant has grouped its excep- _
tions 93 and 94, which challenge, respectively, recom-

mendations numbered land 2.of the Master’s report (pp.
59, 60).. _

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386008_0038%3A12. Public record. Not legal advice.
