# Transcript of Record — New Jersey v. City of New York

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386008_0038%3A01

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1931
- **Citation:** 283 U.S. 473

## Text

| OFFICE = SUPRENE court, u. s.

A FOP e ee eseeeessepece

~-

APR 17 19§

FILE =

Supreme Court of the United States

OCTOBER TERM, 1930.

CHALLES ELAOME ¢

w/e

' Bt re | No. Mh.
STATE OF NEW JERSEY,”

2 VS. \

THE cITy OF NEW: YORK, Tye

-Artnur J. W. “Huy,

Corporation Counsel of the C. ty.
_of New York,

_ Wituiam A. STEVENs;

Attorney-General,

Duane E, Mrnarp, »
Assistant Attorney- General,
o Solicitors for Plaintiff,

State House, Trenton, N. J,

a Plaint: f°

_—

| As : ee Ny

\ %,/

‘Solicitor for Defendant,
Municipal Building,
City of New York.

* (22087)

Appointment of Special

. Opening Statement on Be

.
eee ee FOR PLAINTIFF, |
_Stenographer "*
; : 2 wk ree
€
Anderson, | Walter 8. ; ™ me
Girect examination... ce ececincdneosctecvessesseseessesccos. 1906 626
cross di! 5 | Maanidapintscablanani tases sintoketee eoccal 1933 633
oa il SPA SEESIESSS GES ST DR 1937 634
se-cross : #./ AEA AS OS ABLE Oe na 1929 634
Andrews, George C.
Re NINN ose) scaccssschssrcondcaotesaostuccchacctats! 1155 370
Ayers, Harry B.’ = 5
Girect examination....0..........ccc.cccscsiscctecsoessssieossteccces 331 86
Bailey, Frederi¢k
Givect examimaticin..:.........:;.ccccccincsseieaccececiecseesecsseeee 466 129
seg Ey ES RIOR” Be SE LEESON divaases 468 130
Cosine) te Liiiestad 474 132
re-cross =‘ eeesenesceadosensesessececsosesessooeenspece eaessors 475 132
Barbour, William Warren ;
direct examinatign..........:..cccccc.s0-00e-. piigroccegiscbeccssnen 352 91
cross - x euipbceseriscenbiend hidsécciniebsicesheiepbeasaneensa ; 357 93
__Barklew, Arthur. L, :
Givoct’ examina tii... .....e.s.cscesscoondscosdeseoocecsoo.cosésce.., 392 104
cross a6 sagdkebeeniahcod sal ponstovecsboocsnsesebissedacaite 394 105
' re-direct ORCA ea Gita badhcsstingi' ‘+ BO4 105
Bartley, Robert |" |
direct examination...... lossguaipasghtoinsbadipacshacess halle, . 1998 650
cros#- ‘4 stodebeesinnessesovctamsasequciiéedits ssesevetisaen 2001 651
re-direct ‘¢ ...... rib iiaakslinloadiinasdblenigestionionnc: 2006 653 °
Barton, J.'Shubert . ;
direct examination...........ccce:ccccsssscsscccsssossdsooooseess’ a 1250 405
cross rs tor etait d copie sihidalammpsanncmaais 1254 . 406
SM Re seiieenbobiasS sie + 1256 407
coe. gd RR pidvensseicinbihans mahabbidpsidonésenns 1257 ,_ 407
re.re-direet ‘¢ andesite Len tiieneasiisapnijeespieh sensuous 1248 407
re-re-cross ‘‘ ie = Ra Eon shadesescageosecoteccepeqe 1258 407
' Bearinger, Theodore H.: :
direct examination.................. Pe ee ere dr 14s". ° 966 .,
- Bennett, Frank 8, | se R ‘
direct examination.....0.00.0.00...ccccccecse. iniplasicidtteas 810 , 250°
Bergman, David D. sy rs Pe
, direct ORAMIM ALON aa eseeessssrssernetienssentern peli 871 272
’
_ = , s error,
.

Master

half of Defendant...

nn OSE eae INOS EES VOR Ae Sa WES RAT Ce a

OOOO eee eee eee eeeeeereeeee

, i :
ear Stenographer ’s
“Daa . baa me ha oo
; ie
‘Bets, Harry W. . - oe
direct examinatian.........00.0- a * » SOB
cross SOF gS ta A EEA Ne ee Pen! 366 ;
Berkenmeier, August G. ae ’
direct examination. .........c.ce-rnreeeee Pag aS Lace ait 409 n¢
Birdsall, ‘Claude } von . Pia . .
direct? examina tioin.....cscL.occcsse MIELE REDE ar ey
ea re I ne SALE Ss 718. 3= 838
Bock, Frank J- . Neg SE -
direct examination....:........:..0-00000« fentscossnstniend —— . 1488 496
«Bond, C. Alva, Jr. | . oem
direct examimation,.........2..0..gce-- a2 adden vetoes * 596 171
cross G6 * — « seavssepocnchossscsesesessonsescnpessssosssosooscece |» ° 598 +178 /
Borden, Frank C., Jr. rags , 5 /
direct examimation.......0......0crccsreeeeerenmnereeereennnnnees hh eee | ws
Borden, Ralph , ses 6s .
direct examination.................. Ep ells ea rete 1291 "418
- Bostick, George W. era .
* direct examination...........0c0vcssnescesmersemes oiaiilaigis 663° "197
cross sty git SL Oe AE _ 665 ° 198
Brackett, Winslow M. ba Senetinalhaicssndcihelsitaierenitienacses cisien 2025 = -.- «659
Do cacract,-» L AEE Raa eet 661 ©
Gruetzner, John G. : - ; ae :
direct examination.......... Leawesnsootesissiacnaeunstnsdachscnase _ 651 194
cross “e sei fle sinais cedescle ree i, aaibesiens ” 659 196
_ (recalled) direct .:.... rnidapatogici steteeceseeeeseensee «1346 437°
direct I io hina oi 1517 .« - 506 |
. €Toss A. a eta RNS CE 1532 512
j » Te-direct ‘¢ - sonocvtegewsnsnes tinteaeasenes 1532 + «512
Haas, John J. y . eed a BAe
* direct examination? 2) = a
cross - Lisnsapnipimiciipin EE POR 1956" - ~ 639
redirect «6 See ae . 1961 .° 640
Haley, Alonzo: . . :
SS direct examination. sees wienicaeiiiplisnbeiicn 873 - 272.
cross Eig cremate ° se ' 875 .. 273
Haley, Bert M. Page
. Hall, James. :
Sot I cc ehedieegaabahdcennpeceesipabosi 759
cross $6 fF SEER MEN ARS EON eto 760
- Hall, M. ‘s
direct examination..:......,............ fLeccncosesapenscsesoubeanaqees 429
cross a socqesoncosseshgosvasscosnspeesoessestoosopqecbeosen 437 ©
re-direct ‘‘ SEVERAL, Olin oe 442, 449
re-cross: ‘¢ Raicidbcabeaats i io acl thaiobpeiala 442, 450
Halsey, Van Rensselaer ;
ae NS isch castasyehcnnreeenimomnenirenhoonte 1550
-’ Hankins, Charles M. .
a. direct examination.................... ibaa TNE ee On 541
cross step : 549
Havens, Charles 7 ;
- direct examiination.........0...0..0..0.0:000-0 1294
' eToss ei lehaeesi 1298
Hayes, Edward E. ,

a direct examination d - 807
- -* * Herbered, Elias % :
E direct examination..... 975

‘Hetrick, C. E. F.
* - ‘direct examination 1177
cross S¢. 1203
he 1204
Hillig, John é
‘direct examination......, 688
: cross a 691
Hills, D. H. es 3
direct examination. 768
cross didlig 777
_ Hines, Thomas A.
: ESE EE DARE A LD Ser 1213
_tross | “¢¢ 1217
Hoagland, Joseph C.
NIE - MRR cccuncinhanninsinsnerypentndaasicaancosees 1559
_¢ross a 1563
re-direct © ‘‘ A) AANA R SANA A ROSIE EPID 1567
_ Holgarson, Anton
ar direct’ examination 205 °
‘cross - 212
"2 See =* 216
af re-cross -‘‘ a 216
_Holgarson, Carl
direct examination 217
cross veh 225
Holgarson, Gustave .
- direct examination . 320
Howland, Curlies “*
direct’ examination : 1066

Printed
Page

121,
122,

.

233
233

117
120

25

125,

517

be . ' Stenographer’s ;
. "ot sh, ; Transcript Printed
Ais a . Page. - Page
- Howland, Jesse A.
direct examination... “ Sovmnle 8) 98 . 26
“cross vi ponansan 111 30
Hurry, James ,
direct examination ..00.....0...ccccc:cceesccsssecse LEO 283 70
Jacobson, Neils :
_ direct examination...... seressnscescecnecseesesessesedesces 1163 4 373
Jarden, Mrs. Walter H. ee fe ' Hee
_ direct examination............ hes 1105 353
Jarden, Walter H. de ee we
aoe direct examination.....:..0......c..scsssccsecesssossoncsose ‘ "1102 351
Johnson, Garrett Irons . . R
1 ‘direct examination..........:.....: dapeipaacal 951 299 -
cross Pere al apes mas | - 970 305
“ re-direct.. - « Sutanaacadla 973 306
_ (reéalled) direct . _ ‘ feeeveee-L0'17, 1047 317, 332°
cro’s_ examination caches 1052. * 334
re-direct -‘¢ stectescnnasissneenticceneese © 1055 835
esis, See a Oa Sse
Joline, George E. «- ae aw ee | ; gece
direct examinatiom........ LE BS ae 1580 528.
pinion OR re 7 1589 _ 538t
ee, REE eee ssid a - - 1590 ~. 581
_ Jones, James William, es Laat eth sie “6
direct examination.................. 995 — 313
ap cross Bag toca es aire : ~ *, 300Q -. * 314°
"Jordan, William H. : . SE Te
direct examination 1071 —i‘ié/ BAL
EE age 1075 _ 342
eae 8" Rotate nib 1078 ~ 3843
Keyler, Havell Soni os
direct examination....................... 5 : - 1342 436
Kienli, Ferdinand pahlery Eagee ; eanee
_ direct examination.......... Dae PE age 413. 1
(recalled) direet ....... whe 765 235.-
_ 6. @POms* ‘examination. ... sesenedbinstdaties Mekionea Aideoeieidebuaassants 919
Klee, Daniel J.
, I a 1500
Landon, Miss Margaret |
CERTOUD - CITT ons occasccecccsccscnsovecscocconnsossnutecsonin 673.
Oia a A ee Caren Am . AURA Adon es NSS 675.
Larson, Hon. Morgan F.,
direct examination....... TEPC NI Ree EO RT CEN I eR TICE 372
Layton, Charles D.
direct I ioe ssneivsensinvnnshconminsecompigats 1150
cross te‘ faite Cos tict ws inte seat HOR wep 1153
" Malrer, Daniel J.. pad ame sn penne Sab
OMAMEMTACRON. one ccncceescaececieceeeeceees Sidi tesesnaest 1206
Mannschuer, Gottleib aes
| direet oo Bee 1543
ae OR ae oo cenicocianontenes 1458
Margerum, Mahlon R, ; !
= END UU occa casas ain edd insniedessicuaiivendcoemmass 1173
. Markus, Charles J. P
GEPOCE GUMBO ais oss cnncessecccsccnsecseiontenseracdien 865
Martin, George R. :
. direct OXAMIMALION.........-..-.-cseccseeeeseesseeneesneeneenennecene 857
- Marueci, Frank
- direct examination........ odialatabvucenbovaincaveniaetbiteperiiniitiol 778
Maston, George T.
direct examinatjon......,..........s0csccss0- 274
© .eposs.-. * Sa ME ake 278
Mathis, Thomas A,
direct examination...,........: 1422
_ eross ee," 1432
Mayer, Joseph —
eis: direct examination 823
cross ‘ile - 834
: ea 839
_ Megill, Joseph R.
direct examination 611
AE ee PS ‘615
re-direct ‘‘ 619
Meyers, William J. 4
direct examination 295
cross sapere 299 |
Minard, Inslee M. :
: direct examination 859 ©
cross.‘ ie : 865
*

‘Page

283

285 -

287-

600

201

202

~ Printed

Mitchell, L. E.
direct examination

Stenographer "8
. Transcript . Printed

cross pee

re-direct ‘¢

- Mix, Edward L.

direct examination..

cross he

- Moore, Hon. A. Harry
direct examination

_ Morris, Myron’'O. _
direct examination.

cross hg

Murray, John-P.—
direct éxamination

cross .

Murphy, Edward J >
$ direct examination

Macllroy, William H.-

direct examination...

McConnell, Miss Edith W.

direct examination
cross — ex

Page _ Page
“«
S11 isi88
6:
513 143
"698 208
698 210
1408 469
186° 242
' 790 244
401 107
407°» 109
1940 635
we eee
1322. 429
_: 1880. 432°

re-direct ‘‘

McDevitt, Patrick ;
‘ direct examination

~ 1332 432

cross. ._—s—‘§€

1472, 1484. 492, 495

McKenna, Bernard C.

ae

direct examination...,/

cross" ‘6

ré-direet 66

Aes

re-cross ‘¢

McLaughlin, Leon
‘direct examination

cross. ‘§$

MeVeigh, Charles 8. ’

direct examination

Neuhausen, William
direct examination

Newman, Benjamin F.

direct examination
cross

- Newmai, J. G:

direct examination
- Oleson, ‘Alex —

direct examination...

cross wnt

or 308 "99

re-direct ‘‘ -

1488 496
- 1567 523
1571. 685
1577.” «527
-1580.- ~—=s«527
620 - 181
629 - 185
1545 615
. oe |
478 133
480 . 133

793 245
299 75
306 7?

direct examination

Stenographer'’ ’s

is

742

cross se

‘* Osborne, Carrol

cross 66
_ Perrine, C. C. .
4 direct examination.
‘Peterson, Harry
. direct examination
wom. \ f%,
Peterson, Lars
direct examination
cross _—=s«=—s

* direct examination

| 747

979

Painter, Warren 8.
direct examination

367

cross =

371

Parker, Henry D. ne

504

direct examination.

(recalled) direct

(ee

cross examination.

Parker, Mrs. Richard T.
direct éxamination

514

686.

Parker, Richard T.

_. direct, examination...

Parker, William
‘direct examination

683

269

cross «= = (§*
Park, William .

direct examination..

» 274

1967

1974

exons. . -. **

re-direct is
' re-eross . S*
Patch, Mrs. R. B.,

direct examination

1976——~

~ 1981

681 —

Patterson, B, Y.

direct examination.

cross ig
Patterson, Dr. Robert D.
direct examination

450 .

453

805

Penna, 8. Thomas .
direct examination

416

423

523

1267

195

Phillips, Charles Warner

_ direct examination

201

1240

Cross *

1245

Phillips, Edward
direct examination

~ 1226

cross se

1235

1261 z

Printed
Page

296

*308°

; xi ae
Stenographer’s
Transcript —
Poland, Charles * s at ya
direct examination sis 728° ape
Popp, August ee, i
direct examination . 1090 347°
Porter, Aubrey a.
a ireet ABamination............c.sccccccssssesesseees a 1014 319
Cross . ? : 1017 - 321
Potter, Weslie ‘ Mh, - 127
Rhodes, ‘Sidney H. , A ie te ee
direct examination = 1132 . 363.
Riddle, Lloyd C. ea at Sedan hares nie 4
direct examination : . 1460 489
_ Cross ‘- mes wosvensconcetertenstees . __ AGGR |_- _499- -—
re-direct ‘¢ = AR we . * 1467 | 491,492 ©
-Te-cross ‘¢ “ 1470 492
Roberts, Cc. H: a crs é
direct examination... ‘ ae ae
cross bt pousened shi 559, 572 159, 163
re-direct ‘‘ wee 559,566 159,161
Roe, Walter Wee gh Shae ; | ae
_ direct examination 310 an
cross SS WEE : a 81
‘sedireet .- , . $19 @1
Roswell, Edward « A i ots mi
| direct. examination N , - 681
cross ss ° | - 532
Salter, John C. Pl
direct examination is aaa 509 «142

PORE POET A an RG

’ Sherman, Charles H.

"+ Smack, Cyril A.
‘ direct examination.

x (recalled) direct.
»~ ' * e@ross examination

’ sa , Géoege Ww.
iieaias examination,

- Sandlass, William T.

| ie? :

Tr ript_. Printed
Page "“« Page

direct examination.
cross e

" Schock, Frederick F.

direct examination
_ ereas ‘§

re-direct> ‘*

Schweitzer, Alfred
direct. examination

ergns. ° et ee
re-direct .‘‘ he?

* re-eross ~ **

. Snyder, M. E. — a}

direct examination

cross ="
redirect ‘‘
re-cross. +.“
Steel,” Alex

direct examination

” eross. Me.
Sterner, E. Donald
direct examination

1058 336
1064 339
4530” 196
466 ° + 197
“or. *. 187:
- 159 42°
aha eee
170, 175. 45,46
174, 177, 180 46, 47
ee
536. 151
SI. se
1125° = 860
1128 42'S s36r
1130 362
1131 362
992 312
1368 445
eG. | Se
69. 20 ¢
750,936 229, 293
753,941 231, 296
634. 187
640 190.
1988s 645
1989 647
1991, 1996 648, 649
1994, 1996 649, 649
"229 Soe
253 61
268 + «64
262 64
ogee
- $B, s
840 261 ”

xiii
‘Stenographer "s
Teehoorigt _ Printed
Stickler, Herman "iat =
PS lot oa , 264 65
te oat bc A 290, 1270 72,411
cross examination... ccc... 291,1270 72, 414
SE res ae Ne tte »291 ~ 72
nos ae, OR Et ee aa ON 294» 73
Strollo, James - OS deht
' , direct. examination. ‘ 1272., 411
Stubbs, Willixm B. er
direct eramination...:..ecicsisseccssdecssccseetoe-. ‘ 812. 251
Sweeney, Walter J. ee : ve. 3
direct examination...:...:........ccccscccccsctieesesccsssssseeec.-.. 1513 "504
rupee alee aha nen 505,
- Swenson, Hilding . one caiagre
direct examination.... 1111 855"
cross sind MiaaedeineiSnilaain 1116 857
Townsend, W. D.
“. direet examination 499 140°
Truax, Judge Harry . - APs ies
direct examination 7 1001 315
- ¢ross BTA: Aeeeaibeisihapeienidieibinicuecaidh cis 1003 - 315 -
Tunney, Stanley - :
direct examination... 02......ccccccccscscssseeesesssseteecct.. 1496. - 499
cross eee 1499 ” 500
‘Ulrich, Joseph
; _ direct examination, eisai 1493 498
Van Nes, Selah H.. ve Sei
_ direct examination.......” 1320 429
‘Van Tine; Benjamin C. :
Gitect examination... 2 ...cesecsssctedeeesecczenseccssee 921 288
‘cross Sei. cate alia ernven 930 292
re-direct ‘ * 931 . 292
"- re-eross ‘ 933 293 -
Van Tine, Isaac
direct, examination 1160 372
Vaughan, ‘Joseph H.
ak direct examination... 708 214
. cross Bag TERE ne 714°: | ‘M7
Voorhees, Frederick I. , ; Cee We
direct examination.......)........... Whslafoeebthtnssidtecae Sucaskast 136 »: 86
cross gaia 150 40
re-direct ¢é P ‘153, 157 40, 41
. SP tant eae 155, 158 41
Ward, H. 8. ; |
: direct examination. » 1282 414
a I a 1289s 417
|
tas " 3 Fon

Weber, Frank
' ES ESTEE LL ETD

Weber, Fred

direct examination...

Wickham, Anthony E.
ae cross , “é
Wieger, Rudolph
direct examination

direct’ examination.... 3

eee eee ere)

Wilbert, Aaron

direct examination ;

Wilbur, W. H,
direct examination

cross ve
ré-direct ‘*

Willets, Edmund Robert

direct examination...

cross * sell
Woods, John J.

direct — D

cross. ° **

re-direct ‘‘
re-cross ‘*
Wooley, Brazil .

“direct examination.

om. *
re-direct ‘‘
> Gene. ares!
Zacharias, Charles R.

i

direct examination

cross SS
Tp: ae oo
” (recalled) direct

cross examination ‘
WITNESSES FOR DEFENDANT.

Anderson, Walter 8.
direct “examination

cross se
redirect {*

wey

"ae8 re-cross . ‘‘
_ Bergsten, John
' * @ifeet: examination
‘, eross ™

... Gainard, Frederick A. _
direct examination
cross . se .
Greene, Edward P.
_ direct, examination
_ cross ae
re-direct ‘
re-cross ‘¢ '
Greenwald, Arthur H. -
direct ation
- Cross “ leone
Kelly, Frank ;
direct examination...
‘~ Lawrence, Cliarles H.
' direct examination
cross |} 66

feet

re-cross ‘‘
44 Salle, Robert
direct examination
eress ... *
Schroeder, William, Jr.
direct examination
: ‘cross: t . 4 . 622 182
Milk bottle caps, Bradley Beach, . : :
January 12, 1929.: Seocestwoes yoo 4&2: * CBT 188
Ph8tographs, Seaside Heights,
December 13, 1929.°..... 4 651 194
in evidence’ resenee 8 1269 410
List of articles on beach at Sea- —~ sae
side Park, December 13, 1929........ ~f 653, 194
Photographs, Seaside Park, De- ;
cember 13,. 1929 ; 4 655 195.
Photographs, Belmar, Sunday be-' - :
fore Labor Day, 1929...................0-- 4 695 . 208
Photographs, beach municipali- § —
ties, h. Harbor, to Seaside a
‘Park, January 14, 1930.................... 4 732 223
Photographs, Spring Lake Beach,
April, 1929 5 787 242
Photographs, Spring Lake Beach, .
February, 1929 5 788 243
Photographs, Spring Lake Beach... 5° 788 243

_ Photographs, Spring Lake, Mon-
mouth and Essex & Sussex Hotels.. 5 789 243
‘Photographs, Belmar, material on

882 258

fee eI aes a _ Stenographer .%
a ; Transcript Printed Book
: 5 Description: . © - Vol. Page ~-Page
oe oe? List of articles and. names and ) eae
205 _ U. S. Coast and Geodetic Survey rite rs
‘Chart, July 25, 1925; New. York- ; ere ae sk:
New Jersey : 6 937- 294 Cees
206-211 _ " Photographs, Shark River Hills. BE eels
- and Belmar 6 967 ~ 304 _—
212-221 Photographs, Long Braiieli> 1927, ; .
: . airplane views 6 1007 . 317
222-228 . Photographs, scows in ” Hudson.” - st
CALS She River, January 20, 1930............--+.0-- “7 = 1055 338 .
229-238 Photographs, exhibits in _Asbury
: Park Casino 8 #41185 - 381
239-247 - Aerial photographs, Asbury Park... 8 1186 382 -
248-255 © Aerial photo ye ged Asbury Park ©
‘ and Asbury Park activities (Baby be dene
neh “Parade, etc.) ... > 8 1189 382
256 Annual report of Publicity es. ; |
‘*" \ reau, Asbury Park, 1929........,......... 8 1206 390 .
257-258 ; Minutes, National’ Coast Anti- — 7

Pollution League of America;
August 23, 1923, and September :
19, 1923, respectively. seosesices: 8 1249. 405

259A-259B ‘Examination papers, Hunter Col-
; lege, from Belmar Beach, January ,
5, 1930 ... ' 8. 1253 406.

260-261 Photographs, Seaside rie ie De... ;
cember 13, 1929 8 1269 411
262 Card from Asbury Park beach, Ros
_' June 4; 1929.. 8 1278 413 ©
263-264 Photographs, - Point Ploseait’:

beach, July, 1928 8 1296 -420

Exhibit No. .
265-266

267-272
273-278
279-285 ©

286A-286B.

. 287-297

298

Stenographer’s
_ Transcript Printed Book

Description :
Asbury Park Buredx of Informa-
tion Reports, 1924 to 1929, train
passengers arriving; and number
of conventions; summaries, yearly,

respectively
Folders, issued by Publicity Bu-

reau, Asbury Park

Photographs, Asbury Park beach,’
June 10, 1929: ‘

Photographs, Asbury, Park, beach .

conditions, February 6, 1929............

8 .

8

Letter ‘and envélope addressed to’ -

Thomas Bender, New York City,
August 15, 1928, from beach..........

Photographs, Asbury Park, beach
conditions, April 2, 1927 .2n.i.snsecgerniens

“File~of “letters—to_and- sfrom Gov.
Silzer, regarding peach pollution...:

Report of Chief of Engineers $0
Congress, Octdber 4, 1927,. ex-

tract, report of Captain Bennett

301-302

* 803-307

_ 308-316

_ 817-320
821-335

-336,°
for identification

337,
_ for identification.

. in evidence

- Letter from Acting Secretary of
-War to Mayor Walker of New

.to Chief of Engineers, regarding
. beach pollution.

Photographs, beach at Seaside
Heights, 1929 pecans

Photographs, material on the
beach, Manasquan, June 11, 1929...

Photographs, Monmouth Beach
Club beach, February / 24....:.............

Annual -Reports of the Chief of

Engineers of the United States

‘Army for the yedr 1915 to 1929,
inclusive, with _ particular refer-
ence to paragraphs entitled ‘‘New

York City Garbarge,’’ and ‘‘Street -
. Sweepings’’”

Letter from Acting Secretary of
War to Mayor Hylan of New York

York :
in evidence

9

9°

9.

Vol. Page ~

1330

1332
1349

1350

1351

1353

528
530°

— 632

.
°

.

for identification

839,
for identification

' 340,
. for identification

341, .
for identification
342-344

345

947 |.

' panies and others

. **Report of 1921”’

Stenographer ’s

Description
Letter
Street Cleaning of New York to
Captain Walter 8S. re teagan
in ovnjence

Article in. the: Sunday News for
January 19, 1930

from Commissioner of ©

Article from the New York Eve-

ning Post for July 10, 1926............

Article from the ‘‘ Consulting En-
. ? of January, .1930..........:.....

otices from Supervisor of New
York Harbor to Shipping Com-

‘Statement of frontage of. lands
under water on the Atlantic Ocean
-- noe Seabright. and Cape May,

‘¢Herring Report’? -

INDEX OF DEFENDANT’S EXHIBITS.

* Reports of Dumping tihissahoes nan

‘Statement of entrance and clear-
ance of vessels at the Port of New
York - a

Local law, November 13, 1929,
creating the- Department ‘of Sapi-
tation of the City of New York......

‘Photograph of Bouker’s dum
foot of East 11th street, New
March 17, 1930 - ‘ s

Photograph . of . Bouker ’s dumper,
March 14, 1930.......,.:.

Photograph of: EEK
August 24, 1927

ork,

taken

. Transcript Printed Book
Vol. "Page Page ~
1630. 544
1929 632
1729 ~—«574
* 1729 575
1737 577
1914 628
1943 636
; 2030 661
2030 661
1619 541
1661 554.
(1701 564
1914 600
1818 601
1848 612

3 we we ene eee PR

XXili

a ae |

, ~ Stipulation: ho
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES. —

Oocroser. Term, 1930. .

No. 17, Original.

STATE OF NEW JERSEY,, —-
| Plaintiff, .
vs. .

THE CITY OF NEW YORK, |
Defendant. —

\
|

The parties hereby stipulate as follows:

1. The printed record before this court on the exceptions
filed by the parties to thé report of the Special Master is to
consist of the printed abstract of testimony taken by the

parties on the hearings before the Special Master to and
including the hearing of April 8, 1930, together with a sup-
plemental abstract containing subsequent proceedings be-
fore the Special Master, and with the following additions
which were omitted from the transcript at the places”
_ specified. : mee s sehp Neetu BA

On page 541’ of the. printed abstract (stenographer’s |
minutes, p. 1619) the following ‘should be considered as in-
serted: iar :

o

_ ‘Mr, Minard. In order to clear up the situation—
I don’t want to create the-impression that we are
_ complaining because of the short dumping. That is
not our purpose, but we agree—— ag
‘ Mr. Crowe. I think this is entirely out of order
at this time. There is no question before the court
on which argument on this question may be ad-
dressed. Part of my case is putting in the testimon
of Captain Anderson with respect to permits. Coun

.
e :
/ ; .
e °
= : - * dee $rer ve RY NO] UPA Te
: mon . 4 - a q
.. 7 :
. is i .
oi \

. Stipulation.

sel certainly will hava ample time to argue his con- .
tention. —
\.,/ Mr. Minard. I don’t care to press it.”’

On. page 626 of the printed: abstract stenographer’ s
minutes, page 1904) the siti: should be considered as:
inserted: |

“Mr. teenie: Iam ecabtal to show; first, that the
dumping has taken place and, as a certificate of that
fact, I have offered to furnish those permits of the
‘Federal authorities. ;

Mr. Minard.. We admit that much ; but we want to
know how much garbage was ‘dumped. si

2.. The. parties reserve ‘the right to refer to the ene '

> ‘testimony.

. 3. The exhibits on file may be referred to in the briefs
and: argument without printing same as part of the record
herein, as freely as though they were printed and repro-
. duced in full, subject to any objections that may have been
made to the introduction of any: exhibits by any of the
‘parties, and either party may have the right to print as
* part of his brief or as an appendix thereto any part of: all
or any exhibit. or exhibits. aN

Dated: March ‘28, 1931. aX
. + Srate or New Jed: -
| ~Winuram A. Srevas, * ;
Attorney General,
“Deven K. Min arp, \

Assistant Attorney General, -
| Solicitors for Plain

. THE Crry or New York: x

ArruuR J. W. Huy, 3
Corporation Counsel,’
Solicitor for Defendant.”

4

3 eS
Appointment of Special Master. |
[1]. IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE .
, UNITED STATES.
_ Ocrosrr TzrM, 1929..

No. 18, Original. °

4 ” (THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY, |

oe | Plaintiff, a ae
; , ; v8. | ie ‘

THE CITY OF NEW YORK,

| Defendant. . ° 3

| pe

Asbury Park, New’ Jersey,
Wednesday, December 11, 1929.

The above-entitled: cause came on for hearing before —
-Hon.:Edward K. Campbell, Special Master in said cause,
appointed by the Court by its order of October 14, 1929,

'.. at the Berkeley-Carteret Hotel, at 10 o’clock' A. M. The ©
oath of the Special Master was duly filed: Appearances:
For the complainant, Hon. William A. Stevens, Attorney-
General of the State of New. Jersey; Hon. Duane. E.
Minard, Assistant Attorney-General. ai

For the defendant, Hon. Arthur J. W. Hilly, Corpora-
tion Counsel of the City [2] of New York, by Hon. Thomas
. W. A. Crowe, Assistant Corporation Counsel. 9

_ The Special Master. In the case of the State of New .
Jersey versus the City of New York, I file a copy of the
order of my appointment as Special Master. (The order
is in words and figures as follows) : ON,

_ “Supreme Court or Tue Unrrep Stars. No. 18 Original,
October Term, 1929. The State of New Jersey, Complain-

ant, vs. The City of New York. ‘Ow Consweration of
the motion for the appointment of a special master in this

Q

Appowmtment of Special Master.

cause, Ir Is Now Here Orperep by this Court that the |

said motion be, and the same is hereby, granted. Ann.

Ir Is Furtner Orperep tliat the Honorable Edward K.

' Campbell be, and he is hereby, appointed special master’

in this cause, with power to summons witnesses, issue
subpoenas, and to take such testimony as may be intro-

duced and such as he may desire to call. The master is.

directed to make findings of fact and conclusions of lay,
and to submit the same to this Court with all convenient
speed, together with his recom [3] mendations for a decree.

The findings, conclusions, and recommendations of the

master shall be subject to consideration, revision, or ap-

_. proval by. the Court. October 14, 1929.”

. I will swear the stenographer. (The stenographer was

‘ duly sworn by the Special Master.) -

Gentlemen, before proceeding I’want to-read an extract

. from ‘the opinion by Chief. Justice White in the case of

‘Virginia vs. West Virginia, which was an original suit,

as this is, in the Supreme Court of the United States.

He said: - ..

“*As we have pointed out in acting in this case

from first to last, the fact that the-suit was not an.

ordinary one concerning a difference between in-
dividuals; but wWas a controversy ‘between states -
involving grave questions of public law, to be de-
terminated by this court ‘indie
grant of power conferred upon it by the Constitution,
has been the guide by which every step and every
conclusion hitherto appears .to have been-controlled.
And we are of opinion that this guiding principle
should not now be lost sight of, to the end that when
_ the case comes up to be finally and irrevocably dis-
posed of, there may be no room for the slightest
inference that the more restricted rules applicable
to individuals have been applied to a great public
‘controversy, or that anything but the largest-justice,
‘after the amplest opportunity to be heard, has in
any degree entered into fhe disposition of the case.” |

r the constitutional _.

bey
3

Opening Statement on Behalf of Plaintifi.

[4] In the spirit of this utterance, ‘gentlemen; I trust the
present ¢ase may af.all times proceed. Will counsel now
enter their appearances:

Mr. Stevens. Counsel for the dpininant: William A.
Stevens, Attorney-General ;: spk Diane E. Minard, As-
sistant Attorney-General, State of New J ersey.

Mr. Crowe. Arthur J. ‘W. Hilly, Corporation Counsel of
the City of New York, for the City of New York, by.
Thomas W.. A. ASrowe, Assistant Corporation Counsel.

The Special Master. Now, Mr. Attorney-General, you
=~. proceed.

OPENING STATEMENT ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF,
| THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY. —

Mr. Stevens. May it please your Honor, this is an.
original action brought by the State of New Jersey as com-
“plainant against the City of New York, ‘charging the City
of NewYork with. maintaining a nuisance, a - public
nuisance, in that in the, handling of its garbage the. gar-
bage is carried to sea off the coast of New Jersey, and in .
time finds its way to our shores and pollutes our beaches,
- causing irrevocable -injury to our people, and against ~
"which we have for many years been complaining in an en-
deavor to stop those conditions which have confronted .
us,.and which we hope to show to this Court have been of
‘ such a:character as to do great injury to -the State of
New Jersey and its people along its shores. [5] We
have brought this suit, as I said before, in this Honorable
Court, and the City of New York has entered a general |
denial. We will produce witnesses here before your
Honor to prove the facts set forth in our bill of. com-
plaint, and if we succeed, we are hoping for some injunc-
tion that will prevent a continuance,of a condition from
which we have long suffered. belch

The Special Master. Mr. Crowe.

. ~~ @ ae 5 + hs oa ns Seer A pr -
? . Bie hai hc a Adi safle ct ast pasado Speers D ete ile ae i
MLR ELIDA AY OLDIE PALE ST RESIS RI AOR

* 4 4
NUL ih eathee eRe eFC. bee ANA ARE AP:
\ °
. ' -

Opening Statement on Behalf of Defendant.
: OPENING STATEMENT ON BEHALF OF |
DEFENDANT, THE CITY OF NEW. YORK.

a Crowe. ‘May it please: the Gear. at this time the
defendant will make a very brief opening. The Attorney-

-. General in his opening address has indicated that our de-
' fense is one of general denial. The City of New York is

not indifferent to the welfare of the citizens of New
. Jersey or of any other community within the commuting

distance of our own city. I dare say that during the
time that the various municipalities and cities ‘along the
Jersey coast reap their great harvest—that is, during

' . the summer period—perhaps the majority of the popula- |

tion of these summer resorts comes from our own city.
We are vitally concerned, therefore, in everything that
affects the-health and the welfare ‘of ‘any community
within reasonable commuting distance from the City of
New York. The garbage has been dumped at sea under
permit granted by the Federal Government. We have

lived up to the {6] terms of those permits. We believe
- that if, as claimed, this garbage does pollute your waters - -

and your beaches, it does not come from the City of New
York: We believe that the vast number of vessels that
patrol the coast ‘in-the wrens Pea ocean traffic will

‘prove to.be the real offenders. During the—past, four or

five years, perhaps longer, the City of New York has.

steadily pursued a policy. of. building mcinerators for the

destruction of its city garbage. .We do not favor, becanse
of the tremendous item of expense, the carting of garbage .
to sea daily. At the present time all of the garbage from
the two largest boroughs of the City of New York, the
Boroughs of Brooklyn and Queens,.is now entirely de-
stroyed by means of existing incinerators, the capacity. of
whieh at the present time is more than the anticipated

increase in population of the city, and therefore’in garbage. .
- It.is only 'a matter of a few years when the entire garbage .

— the - City of New York. will be a ia de-

7 5
For Plaintiff—Cyril A. Smack, ainad:

stroyed by means of incinerators in our own city. We ens
entered a general denial’ here because everything that it
has been within the power of our city to do, under the
_. supervision and control of the Federal Government, we
- have done. We stand. prepared to do even more.

‘The Special Master... Call your first witness. |

WITNESSES FOR PLAINTIFF. .

CYRIL A. SMACK. (7) On direct’ examination. I live
- at Seabright, New J ersey. I have lived there twelve years.
_ At the present time I am in the contracting. business at.
Seabright. When I. was a boy 17 years old I was a

‘life guard at the old Pannaci Bathing Beach in Sea-'—

bright. The succeeding year I was a life -guard at .
the Seabright Beach Club:* Then I was away from
Seabright for a time \and later came back as super-

. .intendent of the Seabright Beach Club, where I held the

position as superintendent for nine years. .In July of
last year-I resigned that position. [8] (The witness
marked on the map.) . The Seabright Beach Club is the
largest bathing institution in Seabright. At the time of
my resignation I. think the membership was a little over
400 families. It is a private, club—maintained similar to
a country club—for beach bathing purposes. [9] A great |
many of the members come from New York City. In
fact, I think the majority of them are residents of New
York, who have summer homes at Seabright, Rumson and
various surrounding places.

As a boy 17 years old at the Pannaci Bathing Pavilion
I had my first experience in Seabright’ with garbage.
Prior to that I had had it at the West. End—by the way, I
was a life guard when I was 16 years old at the West ~
End. In the course of each summer season there came,
of course, a number of storms from the east, and whenever
. the wind came from the east, garbage came too, and as,

:
: For Plaintiff—Cyril A. Smack, direct.

the years went on, the quantity constantly aiaed to in-
_erease. (Discussion on word ‘‘seemed.’’)
[10] I can say definitely that it did i increase, but I don’t

= mean to say that in each particular storm it increased,

but definitely it did increase in average, and it increased
‘* to the point where, while superintendent of the Seabright

Beach Club in the year 1904 we had masses of garbage that

I had the whole force—I
I had eight boys working there and two men out in the
parking space removing it. All of this was ‘in 1924. And
there ‘were times when I had to take all-of that force, as I.
could take them from their other various duties, and put
them to the cleaning of the beach, and still fail to keep
ahead of the garbage as it kept eoming constantly, and it
_ was a source of constant complaint from the members,

and a great many people would come down and lopk at the’

condition that obtained and would not bathe. Next door to
us there was a public bathing pavilion, one that. hada
very nice trade, and: when that condition obtained their

bathing dropped off decidedly. A great many people who

‘would come down, not knowing the conditions and pre-
pared to go in bathing, would turn back [11] and not /go

‘in, the water being foul with the garbage .itself, which |
always, when it.is coming, comprises not only. the ordinary

‘things of garbage but a great many little flecks of grease.

’ At the time I was superintendent of the beach club I
lived within 30 feet of the beach. At the present time I
’ live about 200 yards from the beach. I see the beach every -
day. The condition ‘improved ‘a little in 1926. I was

secretary of the Seabright and Rumson Chamber of Com- .

merce, and I was made a committee of one on this. subject
of garbage pollution, and if I may I will read from the.

_ record of the Chamber of Commerce on the subject some- -_

thing that will show a little slant on it. [12] (Discussion:
in re reading from record.) _
Commissioner ‘of Street Cleaning ‘Taylor of N ew York —

had four life guards employed, |

”

City, came down to aban and ic to t itis — —_ :

a é
? ‘es. *

7

For Plaintiff —Cyril A, Smack, direct.

Club in company with another man, and talked with my |

_ life guards, myself and other individuals there, and I can .
' show just.‘when. that: [13] time was. It was in August,
1925, and at that time he promised us that within a year,
if we would lay off of him—thosé were his words—that —
within a year New York would complete all the’ plans.
for incinerating all of New York City’s garbage. And.I ©
promised him on the strength of that promise of his that»

. I would. I made a particular study of the situation during .

the summer of 1929. On April 30th, aecompanied by a
crew of two men, Gustave Holgarson ‘and James Hall, I
made the first trip out with the intent of finding what the

garbage scov's were doing, how they were dumping at sea, _

--and on that first trip failed to find any garbage scows
in the act of dumping. We made a succession of trips.
_ Altogether we went out thirty-four times. [14] (Dis-
cussion on. record of witness regarding trips to' sea.)
' In the course of that time, on’ 14 times we succeeded in
' seeing at close hand the garbage scows dumping. In each
case I deposited 12 cards with ‘stamps on them, self-
addressed, with blank spaces on the reverse side for the
name of the finder; place where found, time when found—_
_ and they were dated, by. the way, under the date on which
they were dropped, with the exception ‘of one case, which I
. will show you later. (Offer in evidence a form of card -
- used for test at sea;) [15] . ‘The cards were dropped -
right in the masses, just as they were dumped from the
scows, after the dumping of the scows. [16]. The cards,
after filling out my name and address and putting stamps
_on the other side—were’ put in bottles. (The witness was
shown a card that had his name and address on the blank
side, with the stamp and all.) This-is the way, then, that .
they came back. (Sh®wing card filled in by finder atid
returned.) There were two lots of the cards, I believe,
that I didn’t get the dates in on this line. The rest of
_ them I had the date on which the bottles were dropped on
‘this line here.. [17] (Diseussion of admissibility of cards .

'.. ing.) [20] I put the card in a bottle and capped it and

‘.. in northwest of Scotland Light at.12 o’clock noon. -12:25

! | | 8 7 ~
For Plaintiff —Cyrit A. Smack, direct.
without bottles. Objection overruled and exception.) [18]
The cards were printed purposely for this work so that
the form and everything is distinctly individual for this -. .
particular purpose. [19] (A card was offered to show
method of test, dated June 20, 1929, arid stating that it

_ was found at Ocean Beach, off Dayport, Long Island, New .°
York, with the name of the finder and the date-of the find-

I dropped the bottle containing the card into the garbage,
_ just after it had been dumped from the scows of New
_ York City. I saw that card again T believe on the follow- -
‘ing day after the date of the post office stamp on it. [21]
(The card under discussion was withdrawn and a sub-
stitute that was dropped July 2, 1929, and post marked
September 18,-1929, was offered to show method .of the
. test.) [23] (Discussion regarding admissibility of card. —
-\ Objeetion to cards found in New York and Long Island.

\But cards admitted to show method of test used.) [24]
Altogether we dropped 240 bottles containing cards. [25]
Each one of those bottles was dropped right in the mass
| that had been dumped. from the scows of New York City,
immediately after the dumping. I received from finders, .
- from) various Long Island, New Jersey and New England ©
beaches, 61 eards back through the mail.

May 22nd was the day of the largest and most foul -
~ smelling deposit, and this is a duplicate copy—I made the
typewritten copy myself from my own report of what.
happened that day. Left Seabright at. 10:30 A. M. on .
fishing cruiser OCEANIC. Crew, James Hall and Gus-

_ tave Holgarson.: 10:40 A. M., passed two Jettison scows
and one tug loaded, going out to the northeast of Sandy
Hook. Passed a tug and two empty garbage scows coming .

P. M., passed one tug and three Jettison scows and another
tug and two Jettison scows, all going southeast by east,
loaded. Supervisor of harbor’ boat nearby. 12:29 P. M.,.
passed one tug and two empty Jettison scows coming in.

29 is ered. Tass

For Plait ntif—Cyril A. Smack, direct.

At 12:28 three loaded scows got. first signal from tug to
unload. Other signals were followed by dumping of all
three scows. [26]° 1:45. Came abreast of tug Woodson
with three New York City S.C. D. scows in tow, loaded
with garbage, going southeast by east. .We slowed down
to pace them out to dumping point. A few minutes later —
we sighted one tow boat and ‘one garbage scow loaded,
going southeast by east. They gained away from us; as |
we were going at slow speed. Paced tug Woodson and her .
scows of the Department of Street Cleaning. 3:25, passed
tug Joseph H. Moran with three New York City S. C. D. |
garbage, scows in tow going northwest, a trail of garbagé
showing in the sea after them. Speeding up, we followed -
this trail with no difficulty, as we watched the garbage .
and grease for about two miles. Then we stopped and
awaited Woodson. After Woodson and scows had passed
us, we started _after her once more and trailed her through
great area of. garbage-strewn sea at least: seven miles in
length and over two miles wide. The. men badly pol-
luted section we have seen to date. __

| [27] Tn trailing Woodson we ‘passed a Navy vessel tow-
ing one empty garbage scow, and believe these to be the -
scows we sighted going out earlier. They are now return-
ing with: scows empty. At 4:52 P. M., Woodson signalled
three scows to dump, and _ started winding in a circle.
Dumping continued until 5 :19, at which time dumping
_, Was. apparently considered done, although piles of gar-—
~ bage remained in_ spots along ridge lines of all three
- scows. In the meantime we deposited in floating mass
of garbage 12 bottles with ards dated May 19th, and 12 —
with cards dated May 22nd. We netted with the crab net
18 bottles. in the mass for future analysis before leaving
the scene of ‘dumping. The scows were the D. 8S. C. 0.,
D. 8. C. R. and D.'S. CO: D. :

‘Sunday, June 30, 1929. Overtook Tug Woodson and

three garbage scows, D. 8... R., D., and E. at 11:35.
— to start. dumping given at 12 :15, about 18 miles |

_— -
;

is : 10
‘For Plaintiff—Cyril A. Smack, direct,

southeast by east of Scotland Light. Ran into mass ‘while
dumping was still in progress. In the mass I saw an in-
‘fant child’s [28] body perfectly formed, as far as-I could
‘see, but very small.: I judged about two pounds. Called
James Hall, but he was too late to see it. Hall and I
observing ‘mass saw bed mattresses, pillows, laces; cords,
timbers, signs. made of wood, newspapers, bundles of
. various kinds of papers, many condrums, apple skins,
oranges, orange skins, lemons, grape fruit, plum, canta-
lope, honey dew melon rinds, potatoes in various forms,
' skins, three cats, two dogs, pieces of lamb, various fowls
and meat, celery stalks and trimmings, asparagus, lettuce,’
‘tnillions of grease particles, carrots, lace curtains, various
articles of wearing apparel, turnip skins, catnip, milk and’
medicine bottles of all-sizes and kinds, many electric light.
bulbs of all sizes and kinds, many rubber, cork and wooden
balls, toys of many kinds, large and small wooden boxes
and crates, paste board boxes, vanity ‘cases, sanitary nap-
kins, kotex boxes, parsley, carrots, _beets, beet tops,
spinach, cords, pieces of rope, small broken step ladder,
shoes and slippers. Twice we had great difficulty in free-"
ing the propeller of masses that had stopped us com-
pletely. We deposited 12 bottles at this date in the mass
and returned home, observing as we passed the scows
great patches. still clinging to them and dribbling off, -
leaving as usual grease trails and garbage patches behind. ays
July 2, 1929. /Garrett Johnson, photographer, ac-
companied [29] us today. We passed tug and three gar- |
_ bage scows of D. S.C: They were returning empty, with
patches of garbage, however, visible one-third mile dis-
tant. This'was 10:20 A.M. At that time we heard signals |
ahead and sighted another tug aid three scows going out.
‘Continued ‘out. Saw them turning on signal blast, then -
head in. 11:55 A. M.,.passed Tug Woodson with three
scows, D. S. C., E., N., T. Mr. Johnson took phototgraph |
of them. Grease trails and garbage patches were dribbling —

from masses still clinging to ScOWS. - Continuing out to
BS aa tia age : |

For P laintiff —Cyril A. Smack, direct. °

dumping point, as we turned in, as we came. about, Mr.

Johnson fell and damaged his camera. He made sufficient :

repairs on the way in, however, to take five additional
_, photographs of seows, all within two miles of: Scotland
Light, one of these taken within one mile of the lightship.
-. This is Wednesday, J uly 17;'1929. -Garrett Johnson,
: photographer, with us again today. James Hall, Gustave

Holgarson and I aboard Oceanic. Passed Tug Joseph H.

Moran with three scows in tow, D. S: C. S., W, and U, at

. 11 0’clock A. M., as they returned. Mr. Johnson took
- photographs of thease: We continued on out to dumping °

_ point. [30] . Mr. Johnson took several photographs from

various angles of the mass. At 10:12 A. M.; we passed the-

Tug Woodson and D. S. C. scows B, T, ind M. Mr. John- |

son observed with us the very definite grease and garbage

trail as. we followed it out. to the dumping point, which
these three scows left behind them. We went out thirty-—
‘four times and saw them actually dumping fourteen: times.

_The list of the things which I mentioned as having seen on
_ the garbage scow compares exactly with the general run

of garbage scows that I saw dumped-on these-14 different .

times. The condition of: that material depends on’ weather
conditions. It depends [31] on how long it has been held
‘back before dumping. I believe that in the northeasters,

or when, the storm conditions are bad, they hold back _

until the conditions improve. When the. weather was hot,

after a northéaster, even as you approached the scows,

you had to have a very strong stomach to endure it. The
day on which I saw that little infant hody, the. mass was
particularly foul smelling anyhow, and it was. just so bad
that by the time I got up on the ridge—I had been having
a battle in the meantime, and I was just about as sick to
my stomach as I ever have been, and I think a man would

require a terribly strong stomach to endure what I did _

endure going out there through those masses.
There are two different forms of scows.. [82] (The

witness was shown page 3 from section 9.of the New York -

—-

Se) a
_ For Plaintiff—Cyril A. Smack, direct.

. Snnday Times of July 21, 1929—showing the method by

_ pictures and descriptions of the handling of New York’s.
garbage. On the bottom of that: page there was a-picture |
entitled ‘‘Dumping New York City’s refuse at sea.’’) .

That illustrates one kind of barge that I am talking about.

I think that is still another kind. I have never seen one.
working in this shape, with men throwing it off. I have

seen men working on. the ridge line within a mile of
Scotland: Light, discharging great quantities of it that
were still clinging to the ridge line. There is a barge that

is called a “side dumper,’’ [33] that has gates or doors |
on ‘the side. They swing out. When they swing out, the |
center of the barge is pointed and the contents just slide. .

. off into the jsea. [34] (Pictures of scows were marked Heat Se

for identification as. to ‘type of scows.) [35]. (Pictures

were shown to witness. ), I recognize these pictures.. They ig

were taken by Mr. J ohnson, from the Oceanic on the trips
that I described in my reports. I was present when the
pictures were taken ‘and I recognize them. [36] The scows

of this type which open out on’ the side almost in-
variably “when they — dump they Jeave clinging to the
ridge line great masses of garbage, and that mass that /
clings there at that ridge line gradually falls. off. Aj.
quantity of it falls off and goes dribbling along in the sea ©
as: they progress. towards shore from the dumping point.
Identification No. 5 shows the men’ cleaning. In each case .

where I saw. them, followed in after them, it was just

exactly:as they:are shown there, but they didn’t start in on

that raking off until they. got within three’ to four. miles

_ of Scotland Light, and that almést invariably brought them:

_ to the point where they were still cleaning garbage while _
_ they were passing Scotland Light, cleaning it from the -
ridge of the ‘one The point at that time would be ap-

proximately /four miles from-Sandy Hook.
[37] These/pictures, four to eleven, ahaa. for identifi-
-eation, are the scows that I saw on one or more than one

trip. ‘These are the actual s scOWs that I referred to. and :

-

a \ ' :
‘ a on 13

For Plaintiff—Cyrit A. Smack, direct.

followed and saw dumped. These pictures show the con-

' ditions of the scows after the dumping had beén com-

ra
LO
+ ae
J °

°

pleted and as the men ‘were cleaning them off by hand.-
_ That picture—I am not sure that you could say that it’ |
showed the scows with the sides opened or closed. There ff
are'some pictures that show them decidedly open where
: they are sliding out. -[38] As\\these men clean these .
_ barges, the garbage came out into ‘the sea and I followed
the trail of it all the way in past Scotland Light. The
' garbage that they were cleaning off thée\scows was trailing
in the:sea behind them, a grease trail and occasional spots
of garbage. [39] (Witness was-shown a picture marked
No. 5 which was marked ‘‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 12 for -
identification.'’) That is a tow of garbage scows. going
back.’ That I followed. y That was taken by Mr, Johnson ©
' while I was there. There appears-to be one secfion of
water that is lighter than the rest, in the wake of those
barges. “Looking at.it with thé eye, as we did look ‘at it,
it is very clearly: a grease mass what is called by the—
fisherman a ‘‘slick.’? [40] It is “left behind by the
barges. All this little area is a coating of grease. It.is
that particular type of greasé which is always found —
_ where garbage is dropped in the water, little flecks from

: _ the size of one’s little finger nail on down. to the most -

minute particle of grease, definite grease flecks and grease’

~ scum. it comes from garbage, greasy substances that are” ~*
-.in the garbage. [41] On the signal, when the barges
reach the dumping point, on thé signal from: the tug, the. —
scows begin their unloading, and the tug comes around in
a.circular motion and the dumping proceeds. Well, when

' they have completed the dumping—it amounts ‘almost ‘in-
variably, to a continuity of the mass of the garbage that

_ they have deposited, they have dropped into the sea. -
Well, that mass sometimes piles as high as a foot clear - -
of the water, and gradually displacement takes place, the
stuff crowds out and the heavier stuff finds its way

- through the mass floating in the water. (Witness was

eee er
ere

: 14
For Plaintiff—Cyril A. Smack, direct. ;
shown No. 15.) You can see the heavier objects sinking.
You can see some objects floating more than half-way out
of the water. (Witness was shown 19, 18, 22, which with
15, were offered for identification.) I was present when .
* thew were all taken. They are part of: the picture that .
Mr. [42] Johnson took at that time: ( The pictures were
‘marked 14, 15, 16, for tdentification.) Identification num-
bers 13, 14 and 15 illustrate what I have just said about
the density of the mass supporting objects out of the:
water. ‘The mass spreads, of course, invariably when you
have got the second lot of scows dumping after the first
have durhped. The proximity..of the dumping point is —
such that in a short time the spreading of the mass brings
. it into still greater islands of garbage. [43] I have seen,
for ‘instance, the second three. seows dumping in’ close |
proximity. to the point where the apparent dumping of |
the others has been made—and when I say ‘‘apparent’’
I mean that I have seen, for instance, -the first three
_. secows coming in from the. dumping point just after having .

‘left the point which the second three scows were approach-
“ing, which I have been following, and so I know they are
definitely the ones that have emptied—and then, the masses .
being dumped at this nearby point by the. second three ~
scows, as that spreads out in the course of a half hour’s —
time or less ‘they become one island. I have seen ,them
cover an-area at least seven miles long. [44] We actually
measured by sailing our boat alongside the mass in a
straight line. In a boat that was going at the rate of seven
miles an hour we ran for 43 minutes along the mass, which
is approximately five, or a little over five miles, along one
side of it.. I have seen them. seven miles long. They will |
run as wide as two miles.

The largest: number of scows that I saw duniped iy many -
individual day was the day of May 22nd. [45] Atl 3 on
that day we came abreast of the Woodson with three New
York: City D. S. C. scows in tow. At 3:25, passed Tug ©
Joseph H. Moran with three New York City’ D. S.. a

wet
es)
7

15- ‘
For Plaintiff—Cyril A. Smack, direct.

garbage scows in tew—no, 12 was the most that we saw
coming and going in one day. [46] The garbage was just -
so dense*that in going through the masses repeatedly we
‘had the experience out there of having to reverse the
motor, after the motor -was stopped by the stuff that
would clog up the propeller. - The vegetable and animal
matter in there was very odoriferous. It was in a decay- ~
ing process. It was offensive ‘to the smell as well .as
"the sight. eek: ane a ae at ae i
[47] Repeatedly we have stopped and observed just what |
the garbage mass did under different conditions of wind
_ and tide, and we found that invariably it went ahead of the:.
wind, if the wind was blowing with any intensity at all, no.
matter how the tide was going. [48] _ The garbage goes
ahead of the wind, if it ig blowing with any degree of
intensity. Regardless of the direction of the tide. When
the wind is blowing lightly and the tide gets going in a
definite’ direction—say the wind is blowing from the west
' and the tide is coming in, under that condition the wind
would have to blow harder from-the west to carry it off-. -
shore. “I saw where those islands of garbage went. In .
_ Some cases.when' the wind was from the west they went
decidedly off-shore immediately from th ‘time we saw
them dump. [49] And in cases where the wind was from
. the east at-the time of dumping they came ahead of that
_ wind toward the shore... Most of the times that we went
out, we caught a wind fromthe south, which carried _
_ it in the direction of the Long Island shore. (Witness was
\ shown for identification picture No--16, ati unnumbered |
\ picture that was marked “A 12, 1%, 21, 10, 20,13, 23.7".
‘ These were offered’ for identification [50] were marked
‘“‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit 17”. to ‘‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit 24” for .
identification. ) Identification numbers: 17 to 24, I reeog-.
lize these pictures as having been taken by Mr. Jolinson
on the trips that I have described. They show the areas.
_ Of\garbage in mass and also in the process of distribution’
_ as they drift to the shore. - [51] (The witness was shown _.

\

4

“ ‘ . .
Ld .
cal bed e
. _ ™, °
\ . % tie e + ‘
e A ’ F at, .
\ °

. \ 16
For Plaintif—Cyri A. Smack, direct.

identification number 13.) That is the pic picture of the
time whén they were still cleaning the barges as they .
passed Scotland Light\and with the eye, observing from
the Oceanic at that time\you could see the men still work-
ing on that barge. You couldn’t see to say positively that.
‘the barge was open, but the fact that the garbage was
.dribbling behind indicated that. Of course, it was too
remote for us to see it at the ‘time this picture was taken,
but after a matter of a half-hour’s sail. we were over
behind it, and ‘there we could definitely follow the trail.
‘They were cleaning the barges at that time. I have seen -

_ them. cleaning the barges for three hours, with. two men’

- working on tlie ridge. [52] I have never seen them start
cleaning immediately after the dumping. They seem to —
wait until they get near Scotland Light before they start
that. They shove off at least as high as 25 cubic yards
on their way into the shore from one'scow. In a northeast
wind, - the garbage .flows ahead of that- wind toward the
‘shore.- I have seen it go to the shore. I have seen it
work to the north, for instance, ahead of the wind from —
' the south, and the wind-cut across it from the northeast,
and definitely the garbage would change its course and

= drift ahead of that northeast wind. [53] toward the shore.

As it approaches the shore there is garbage and refuse-in

-. the undertow. . At the time that stuff works to the shore,

by the time it gets ‘inside the’ breakers, it is all thrown in
a mass, everywhere in the water. It distributes on’ the ~
~shore all the things I have described. And I have had
the experience oftentimes of having people remark the .
- fact that they could not make soap work on them.\under °
the showers after coming out of that water, because of the
grease that was fast on their bodies. It leaves a horrible
' mass of garbage right there on the beach very definitely.
For instance, you can have guards cleaning up the beach

_ after a storm. has brought a mass of that stuff in, and = ©

after they have done all the raking they can on it, why;
peojde walking i in that will still be walking in grease which

” _

For Plaintiff Cyril A. Smack, direct; ;

“will cause the sand to cling to the feet: hebvisen the toes.

[54] The seven mile area of garbage positively did not
come from passing vessels. I saw them come from the -
New ‘York Street Cleaning Department barges. I have
over a period of years observed these barges going out
to sea only at a distance. IF have not followed them per- .
sonally. From the time I was a boy 17 years old I have
seen them going out:when visibility was good. Of course,
‘you can’t see it-from the beach excepting when the visi-
bility is good. The effect upon the development and the
enjoyment of the use of these beaches during the years as
a result of ‘this garbage from the scows, I think has been
very harmful, There are times when bathing’is absolutely
impossible on\account of garbage. There are times when.
people who have [55] any nicety in them at all would not.

think of going into that ocean. I have seen times when

the waves were full of floating matter, bottles and every-

- -thing that went with the garbage. My experience at the

Seabright Beach Club—I had always two and sometimes
three first aid kits, and I have-had three first aid kits in
use for people’s feet who had cut thémselves with glass in

_ the water, where that stuff had broken in the-surf. I

have seen the islandseof :garbage float very definitely |
toward the [56]. shore repeatedly, and I have seen them, -
- follow the definite trail to the point where they deposit
some quantity at Sandy Hook. (Motion to strike out en- |
tire testimony of the witness. Overruled. Exception.)
The garbage contains practically the same mass, excepting .
. those things which are heavier, as the mass that is dumped
at sea. Always in that stuff at sea, when you get to the
outside, of the mass, so you can look down underneath,
you can see a percentage of stuff dropping down into the -
water. As sdon as the density of the mass is released, °
those things that will sink do sink. But the lighter stuff
comes [57] drifting right ahead of the wind, and that is-
‘just exactly. the content of the stuff that is deposited on
thevbeach. It consjsts of cats, dogs, various kinds of meat, .

ety 7 18
For Plaintiff—Cyril A. Smack, direct.

and all kinds of fruits and vegetables—the articles which
I described in_that one count. -It isn’t a Very nice thing
to say, but ‘repeatedly in my experience as. guard and

superintendent of the Seabright Beach Club I. have had -

to stop little children who had picked up condrums from
the masses of that garbage, little children in the act of.
blowing those things up. The ‘condition of this mass when
it comes ashore is putrid. Some of the time that I was at
the Beach Club we had it carted away—that is, quantities
of it carted away. Then again we buried great quantities
of it, having men, for instance, at times digging holes con-
stantly for the wig ae in of that niet. the reception
. ¢ Wee

I am not: very. iealiione with anything. south’ of [58]
Island Beach on the Jersey shore. That is approximately |
- twenty-six or. eight miles below here. I am not sure of

that myself. [59] (Discussion on form:of question.) -I°

have seen garbage on practically all of that entire beach
from Seabright right down to Island Beach. I have not
spent much time out on the water. [60] I have done more
swimming in the water than I have sailing on it. I have
made complaint to the City of New York about this gar-

bage. In the capacity* of committeeman of the Seabright. -

and Rumson Chamber of Commerce, and as secretary of
. the Chamber. -In fact, I have the resolution here that I
drafted for the Chamber, on motion of the Chamber. I
communicated: in New York with Mr. Taylor, who is in”
charge of the Street Cleaning Department of the City of.
New York. I got a response from Mayor Hylan. [61]. It
was by letter that I received, a reply from Mayor Hylan.
_I had a visit from Mr. Taylor. _He wasn’t there to see
- the ‘condition at its worst, but he did_see what after three
days following a storm remained uncleared, after men had

been working for.that period on it. [62] The actual cost —

of removing garbage I could only say was that of the men
who came and carted it away, but the fact that the garbage
came in such mass accounted for the fact that we had

ight
,

ae
oe oe

For Plaintiff —Cyril A, Smack; dineal.

three life guards on the beach, wharess we otherwise
- would have had two; and it accounted for the fact that _
_ we had eight boys instead of six.. So that the wages of ©
the one life guard and the two boys throughout the-entire
season could be chargdd to the garbage. . Prior to the
visit of Mr. Taylor it was a different wind that brought
the garbage to our shores. After that I know that they
went out further. Prior to Mr. Taylor’s visit the wind
that brought the garbage in came from further around to
the north. [63] Mr. Taylor at the beginning of our con-

- versation insisted’that it was not New York City’s garbage
and that there was no justification for our claiming that it ~—

was, but before he departed he really admitted that he
believed it was New York City’s garbage, and he* asked |
.us to lay off him—those were his own words. ‘He said:
‘‘T am going to ask you, I am going to beg of you to lay
off me. You are making my life a hell.” Those were his
words, and he said: ‘‘If you will, within one year we will
have completed all of our plans for incineration and we
will dispose of all of New York City’s garbage in that
_ way.’? Immediately following, it was a different point of.

wind that brought us the greater mass of the garbage. It. -

was further around, ‘in other words, to the south. The |
point of origin of that garbage had been changed. - It can
- come under different conditions. Now when the wind
blows from the south after the mass is dumped, and then
[64] a northeast wind springs up, that may have ‘been. .

- earried ten miles-to the north directly ahead of the south.
- wind, and if it is cut across at that time by a norther, it.
will drift: southwest from that point, but if the drive at
the time it is dumped is right from that point, from the

~ northeast, it will take it epee ten miles further

to the south. |

[65] I have coliseted exhibits and seen paler: on the
‘shore that would identify the source of it. [66] I have
‘seen theatre tickets dated.a few days before the date on
which they were found; personal letters, including love

ky ae
For Plaintiff —Cyril Pi Smack, cross.

letters, that. were dated only a few days before the ‘date

they were found on our beaches addressed to New York
City addresses. They had invariably been opened. I
have seen milk bottle caps ‘of New York City addresses,

business cards of various kinds, forms and letterheads.

I have seen boxes addressed to New York firms, with names
printed on them, in every case New York firms. [67] My
little ist sakeed up some a few hours ago. I saw her.
The wind was northeast this morning and I asked miy little
girl to go out on the beach. (68) 4 have not looked for

anything récently.

On cross examination. Quite a large slieiadiie of the

population of Seabright commutes back and forth from
‘New York every day. The population of Seabright is -

very largely derived.from: New York. I was employed
to make these trips -to. sea and take these photographs
to which I’ have referred, the photographs offered for

_ identification by the Attorney-General’s office of the State
of New Jersey. [70]. I made thirty-four trips to sea. ©

I cannot give the dates of the trips now. I could at a later
date. (Discussion regarding production | of dates.) I am
at the present time engaged in the business of contracting,
carpentry, general building contracts. [71] Outside of

“my experience along the coast, I have never been to sea— .
‘ ‘only swimming, and short trips from the shore. I have ‘
- -been swimming-on the high seas. I have gone out

about as far as anybody. has on the high seas, I think.

‘I swam out eight miles and returned, not~in the last

few years though. TI did: that when I was 17 years.
old. [72] I am'41 now. I made the first trip to sea,
pursuant to my retainer. by the Attorney-General of the

' State of New Jersey, on April 30, 1929. Captain Hol-
. garson and his son, Oscar Holgarson, and myself con--

stituted the party aboard on: that occasion. We made. the

‘trip in the fishing schooner Oceanic, a 34-footer, with a.
gasoline driven engine. [73] (Discussion regarding dis-

21
For Plaintiff —Cyril A. Smack, ¢ cross.

tance between Seabright and the outlet frous Raritan Bay. )

I have lived in the vicinity of Seabright for 12 years. I
am not generally familiar with the condition of [74] the
waters of Raritan Bay. I do not know whether or not. the
waters of Raritan Bay are véry much polluted by sewage
from New Jersey. I actually trailed the garbage for. a °

length of time on my trips to sea. [75] On the first trip :

we made no connection with a garbage scow at all. We -
went out at night and we didn’t find any. That date was

_ April 30th. The next day that I went to sea, pursuant

to my retainer. by the Attorney-General, was May. 2nd,

' if I am not mistaken. This was the date on which we

caught the first dumping.. But it may have been May- 1st.
I am not sure of that because I have not the full record.
On the day on which we saw them for the. first time in the

act of dumping, we rowed up to the mass and deposited the

12 bottles, then: observed the content of it; and that was
practically all. [76] No pictures were taken on that date.

- These pictures that have been offered for identification .

here were taken on the days of July 2nd and July 17th, .
I believe. There were only two of the dates of the thirty-
four on which I went to sea, when pictures were taken. _

(Witness given pictures previously offered for identifi-- -
cation. ): [77] (Witness used letter of photographer dated —

July 25th.) Number 5 is a picture of scows returning to:
shore, taken July 2nd at 11:55 A. M: [78] Identification:
numbers 2, 3, and 4 being plaintiff’s exhibits for identifi-
cation 3, 6, and 10, were scows returning to the shore.
These pictures were ‘taken at approximately 11:55 A. M.,
on the morning of July 2, 1929. Five is exhibit No. 12,
identification No. 12, secows returning. Note slick in water.
That is the photographer’s note. That was taken just in
the sequence of time in which we could ride that distance.
from the scows and the tugs, about. 12 o’clock on July 2nd.

_ 1, 6, 7,8, and 9—being exhibits for identification’9, 4, 7, 8,
and 5 are scows photographed approximately one mile |

from Scotland Lightship [78A] taken. on the day of July

~

For Plaintiff—Cyril A. Smack, cross.
2nd, ‘about 2:30-in the afternoon. “Print. No. 10, being

* eomplainant’s exhibit No. 13 for identification, was taken.
~ on the 2nd of July following after, a matter of about five.

or ten minutes, possibly about 2:45. Prints Nos. 11 and 12
being complainant’ s exhibits Nos. 11 and 20 were taken on

_ July 17; 1929. ‘Prints ‘Nos. 14, 15,16, 18, 19, [79] 20 and

22, being complainant’s exhibits for identification Nos. 17,

18, 13, 14, 15, 22 and 16, were taken-on July 17th. Every _
‘ ‘seow shown is a side dumper. I have never been aboard |
one of those scows.. I have been close enough to one of © -

these scows to reach out and touch if. I do not know the

length: of the ridge pole on the scow positively. I-think |
that they vary some, ‘sonie of the older types and the.
- newer—approximately 100 feet. I-do not know the width:

of this ridge pole on the side dumper. I have never been
'.where I could examine it. [80] The width would not have

'- anything to do with the approximation of the quantity of ‘
- garbage, because you can. see the garbage from the end,

- but you can’t look-down and see that ridge. and see how
wide it is. That ridge line is concealed from that end.

. When we go out around there we can’t see from the end. °
“You can only look at that side. You can’t tell how wide

that is. I wouldn’t say a thing in regard to the width.

[81]. While I was-out there watching | these scows in opera- -

- tion, going to and fro, I saw federal inspéctors and harbor

boats but not: always. I couldn’t say positively whether
or not every one of those scows, as shown in that picture, —

_ have the side open for dumping or closed. :[82] ‘(Witness
shown identification No. 8 and asked what on picture
would indicate that sides were open or closed:) The fact
of that discrepancy there in that line certainly tells that

+ that one at least is open. I can’t say that it is open or

. closed. (Witness shown complainant’s Exhibit No: 7 for
identification.) [83] I can’t say that the photograph shows
that it is open or closed. (Witness shown complainant’s
Exhibit. No. 4 for identification.) From. an examination

of the picture I could not say whether the scow, a ~

per > 4 ees er %

2 a ec
For Plaintiff—Cyril A. Smack, cross. 7
- gide dumper, is open or closed. (Witness shown several.
“more pictures. ) Iean’t say that the photograph indicates
that it is either open or closed. (Witness shown complain-
ant’s Exhibit No. 5 for identification and: asked what part
--he understood to be the ‘‘ridge pole.’’) [84] I haven't re- .
ferred to it once as the ‘‘ridge pole.’’ I have referred to -
it as the ‘‘ridge.’’ Because a pole constitutes something
_ that I don’t know whether it exists in that case or not. I
' mean the uppermost line, in other words, that which comes
nearest to the sky line there, excepting where the garbage
; interferes, and the men. It is the. dividing line between the-

two sides. It is that part.of the scow shown in complain-
ant’s Exhibit No. 5 on which a man appears with a rake *

in his hand pushing: off the garbage or deposit on that
scow:. There is nothing to indicate where this scow was at
the time this picture was. a excepting that it was.on |
the water.
[85] Through the. major ea of the conversation with
. Street Cleaning Commissioner Taylor of New. York, there
were two of my life guards present, Jerome Welch of Sea- -
bright and Oscar. Nelson, if I am not mistaken, was. the ‘
name of the other guard, but I am not sure of that. Sea-
bright is: Oscar Nelson’s address at present and I don’t

——know that of the other man. Most of the conversation

‘took place on the beach in front of the Seabright Beach
Club in Seabright. I am not sure whether I-can fix the —
date any closer.than. August, 1925. [86] -There wa ps -}
** other man with Mr. Taylor. I do not know who the othe

, Man was. I was introduced to him, but I have forgotten .

_ his.name. ‘From the time ‘material is dumped off the scow,
“it depends on just exactly the position, of the stuff-which
does submerge, about its position in: relation to other stuff
. that will float and will-float sufficiently high to float things .
‘that otherwise would submerge, until it has stretched to
the point where the stuff can drop that is heavier. Now,
I think if. you want me to explain what I mean by the an-
swer, . can show you in one. of the .pictures here. The

.
if a.
' ve
. - - 4 \ ‘
Pete: . . Ne!
j

j

7 ee

A —
' For Plaintiff —Cyrit A, Smack, cross. :

material comes off the scows in masses. [87] It becomes -.
immersed: It spreads, and you can see from the sides of /
it some of the heavier-stuff-constantly settling down for a

_ time, but as the stuff straightens out, that dropping down
of stuff ceases. I have tested and observed it pretty well.

You can see down pretty well in that water down there.
_ That is good clear water when you get. outside, but when
you get up to the bar there is nothing clear ‘there. You

can seé the garbage submerging from the. outside of it, but ”
not all of the garbage. You can’t see the lighter stuff sub-. —

‘merge; all. you can see is things like heavy stuff that ‘is
heavier. than ‘the water it displaces. [88] The garbage
floats in large masses above the surface of the water for
an appreciable length of time after the dumping. [89]
I. have known it-to float for hours, and I would say at

least five hours, in great masses. [90] That is my im- .

pression. I have trailed the garbage that I saw dumped
on one of these dates in a definite lin@right to the beach.

_. The point jat which the dumping was@done was approxi-
mately: 20 miles southeast by east of Scotland Light,.and
_ the beach jwas. four. miles, approximately, from the. light. —
We moved right along with a definite line of garbage to rs

that point, just offshore of Sandy Hook.

[91] I do not know when this particular dumping took
place. JI have the means of finding out from my own
records in the matter, but-I haven’t it with me. (Discus-

“gion regarding production of record.) [92] The period
of time during which I stayed with and traced the course.

and direction of the garbage was approximately 4%

hours. I can’t recall the date. ‘The wind condition was.

that the wind :was slightly south of*east. I think it was
._ blowing perhaps at the time that we came in thirty miles

‘an hour. We were in a gasoline boat of 34 feet on this:

- occasion. [93]. The hardest the wind was blowing at any

time that I was out there was perhaps fifty miles per :
- hour. We were always in the same boat. When I traced’
the garbage, we were moving under our own motive power

For Plaintiff —Cyril A, Smack, cross. \

\

at less than half speed. I have. _given time and study to the
question of tides and currents. As they concern the J ersey
shore, anything that floats on the surface. of\ the. water is
not affected to any appreciable degree by the tides when
the-wind is blowing.at all hard. [94] The data or basis .
upon which I rest this conclusion. is from observing it day
after day, the ocean and things floating on the surface of it,
under all conditions of tide and wind, and many days and
many years: The surface current at or about the vicinity of

the dumping grounds is inspired by the winds. Whether .

science recognizes it or-not; if it arrives at the right con-
clusion they would, because every fisherman who goes out
there can tell you that. I. think that when the wind is *
driving hard in the east, a falling tide simply means that
the water underneath i is going out. [95] The wind affects
the surface currents. To what extent or depth the wind

_affects the surface currents has never been involved in my
' ‘study. .Any objects floating on. the surface would drive
' before the wind. Objects ‘that submerge are affected by
the wind. - [96} I “know. in regard to objects near the
beach, they are positively affected by the wind. For in- .
stance, coal, things that will settle to the bottom but not
settle hard perhaps in the sandy bottom, when the wind is
from the west those things which settle to the bottom will
work up on the beach. I think that it must work. from
perhaps an 18 foot or greater depth, . Which only goes to
prove ‘that it is the law of nature that the waters are
governed by in the matter, of seeking their level, ‘that’
when this water is blowing off here, that under water is
carrying things this way (illustrating). I would say that
wind would affect water to a depth of at least 18 feet. [97]
- I have never verified the statement I have made, with the
reports of the U. S. Hydrographic Bureau. . (Witness to ©
be recalled at which time he is to produce records.)

26° te ia,
For Plaintiff Jesse A. Howland, dives.

[98} JESSE A. HOWLAND, witness for id on behalf
of the plaintiff, on direct examination. My post office is
Seabright; my residence Rumson. I have ig within a
~ thousand feet of the beach for 59 years.”

-out in the water as far as seven or [99] eight hundred
feet. I am familiar. generally with. the seacoast along

here. I have beén engaged in the bulkhead business along —

the’ north end: of: Jersey from: Sandy Hook to Bayhead,

) business is ©
bulkhead and jetty building—contractor. I Hi been in
that business about 38 or 39 years.. My: business takes me ~

and have done considerable work at Ocean. City and...

Margate, which is below Atlantic City. Starting in from.

Sandy Hook I have worked for the: United States Govern-
. ment, Seabright, Monmouth Beach, Long Branch, and
down to Ashbury Sah st the. way along, Allenhurst,
- Ocean Grove, Bradley Beach, Avon, Belmar, Bayhead,

Beach Haven. In 1884 I was bathing master at the Octa-°

gon Hotel-at Seabright. I was-there two seasons, 1884 and
1885. _[100] I had been on the beach all my life from the

’ . time I was abie to walk, to get out of the house. ‘In those

days we lived 80 th ‘you could toss a stone into the
_ ocean.

‘I am very familiar with this autos of wishes
along the shore, I: have been so from the time that I was
‘able to walk and get out on the beach, about 55 years. I
was bathing master at the Normandie Hotel: From the
time I was-able to work I have spent my life on the beach.
The last 40 years my business has been on the beach: “In
the last two years I haven’t been—well, I have had just
as much work if not more work; but I haven’t been so
active; but I have been on the jobs every day. I have seen
no end of tows, dump, scows, going .out [101] to sea
loaded, and I’ have seen lots of-them come back empty.
-That observation was made by different trips on’ ocean
liners. I never saw the actual dumping operations. I

was able to identify the scows because scows came ashore |
along with garbage: In my lifetime I have known of. about .

+ For Plaintiff—Jesse A. Howland, direct. Pe
- six. There was one or two landed below the Highlands,
below what we call-Highland Beach, three. down towards

the point of the Hook, and up against’ the Keansburg dock.

One that came ashore in a very bad storm about'six years

ago I was requested by the owner of the‘scow to take men
‘ and’go down first and make an observation to see if she
could be saved; and then I was -requested to take men
down, and a boat, a small boat, to run lines to the Cahill
Towing Company’s large tugs, and. they: floated her. [102]
None of these scows belonged to the New York City Street
. Cleaning Department. _ They were hauling garbage from
New York City. © seeen Rae rei th

When I was bathing master at the Octagon Hotel and
at the Normandie Hotel, it was. one of my. duties to keep
_. the beach clean, and we had so much garbage at times that
it ‘was ‘impossible for me to find spots on the beach to
bury it after it was raked up. At’ least three hours, an
average of three hours a. day was spent by ‘myself in
raking garbage and burying it. It consisted of all kinds
of vegetable matter, broken furniture, eggs, electric light
bulbs. I. have in my lifetime seen two dead babies come
ashore on. the beach—cats, dogs, ‘all. kinds of decayed °
fruit, rotten meat—most any and all kinds of refuse
_ matter that’ would come from a large city. [103] TI no-
_ ticed’ there broken victuals, refuse from the table. It
consisted of orange peelings, half an orange skin, half a
grapefruit skin. Often out of .curiosity.I have picked up
bundles: of papers and cut’ them open—they were tied up
—cut them open to:see where they were from, arid I found -
memorandums from business houses down around Cham-
bers street,'in the produce district, and theatre tickets, can-.
celled stubs from New York. T have picked up obscene
matter, printed literature and cut the strings and opened
it. And no end of memorandums, letters and things picked
up, letters, envelopes, [104] addressed: to -New York,
There were not any other ‘address on them than New
York. These things that I picked up and opened have

> &

9°
-

For. Plaintiff —Jesse A. Howland, direct:
; extended over a period, I would say, of perhaps 45 fo 50
‘years of time. I have seen old broker crates ‘and boxes

- ‘with addresses on them, in stencil—that’ is, marked out,
stenciled . oui. Some were cut ont, stenciled, mafked over .

. -mark off the’name on them. . They were addressed to New
. York. I won’t say positive that I eyer found bottles that -
still had labels on them.’ I have seen’ no end. of bottles. “I.

have’seen in my lifetime, I guess, close to a million bottles.

with a brush, and others where you just take a brush and, © :

- om the beach. The bottles break up, T.have had lots of > |

: people—if there happens to. be a ridge. of ‘gravel in the
undertow and [105]: the bottles ‘are thrown down into it,
they break, and I have had lots of people, lots’ of ‘bathers

under my charge who had cut their feet very badly on the

‘. bottles. -There are times that garbage comes in in unlimited
quantities. ‘I have seen it come in so that between high and"

_ low water you couldn’t find clear sand enough to lay. down

. on the beach. The beach was. absolutely covered. I have seen ee

quantities or masses of it floating in the sea. ‘I have seen
it. with the beginning of a northeaster, with the current), °

‘ coming in out of the northeast I have seen [106] garbage
almiost as far as you could look. Standing on tlie beach,

- you could observe it a distance of probably three miles.

I have gone by on ocean liners going across... I have seen
the scows. I have not moved through the dumping ground.

_ . I know that the material, from the material that I have
~ picked up on the beach and examined, that it, originated in
New York City. Whether it came out by-steamer or by
barge I don’t know-but'I know positively that one of [107]

* these barges that came ashore up at Keansburg had half

* a poeket of garbage in her that .wasn’t dumped. . This

garbage come in on northeast, edst, southeast winds.’ The

: ing ground, as I understand the Government. regula-

tions, iid be a little south. of: east from Seabright.
* That is the direetion from which the garbage comes on |
°° the winds that bring it in. Hf it came from vessels it —

. “would have to come from the same direction. If any of’

>

- al
. sve : .
. 4 . s
>
** ‘ . ; :
. .
. .
e ‘
‘ ‘
- . ° ® 4
ow
q
it out with the tide;-so-that when they dump. they can
come home with the tide. During the week, if they happen
to get out there when the time seems to be inc. I see them >
every day I go there. I go. with a motor’boat, regardless
of the tide whenever .the weather permits. Whenever I .
am out there, when the tidé happens to be favorable to
their movements, I see them dumping. They leave a great
big mass that. lays there and. doesn’t sink, and what does |
sink there is a southeast sea, ground swell, comes out ‘of
the southeast and runs northwest, and that ground sea has
brought garbage from the dumping grounds to some of ,
my lines in shore four or five miles. [161] I have sailed
around it to avoid hitting the wheel; and oftentimes hit the
wheel, which caused me to run slow to get home, and I
have had to straighten wheels. That is my business,
straightening wheels or shafts, whatever damage is done
_ by drift stuff. If you are fortunate, you may go through a
whole season and not hit a wheels again you may go out
there day after day, two’or three days at a time, and
every day hit something. That is a common thing among —
the fishermen. I have. actually seen it drift toward the. ~
shore [162] to about five or six miles from the shore. I
have not seen it closer to the shore as it wasn’t in my
course. I go from the point of the Hook to the Lightship,
and from the Lightship I run southeast: by east. Some-

43
For Plaintift—Alfred Schweitzer, direct.

- times almost the whole course out there you have to pick
your way so as not to hit logs and driftwood and so

_ forth, and garbagé, so as not to injure your boat. I have
sailed under such conditions from 30 to 40 minutes. My
boat travels about 16 miles an hour, but you can’t run
‘that fast through it. You travel, I should judge, about six
‘or seven miles [163] an ‘lout—pick your way. For four ~
or fiveemiles I have sailed through that drift of garbage
to get out of it. I have seen the garbage on shore on one -
occasion down as far as Seaside. That-is’ just t abreast of
- Toms Riyer.—t-have not frequently seen it on the shore |
because I don’t get to the ‘shore here. On the Highland ©
Beach shore. we do. not see so much. -The tide seems to ©
keep’the stuff clear of the Highlands, but it seems to come
‘down this way, kind of runs southwest and always strikes

. ° in towards the beach—aot always, but according to weather .

- conditions, wind and tide. I see in this garbage most
everything that can be seen in any ‘garbage can. I have |

_ seen rags, cans,. bottles, chicken entrails, small dead ani- . ©
mals. And we have been troubled off-shore'on our lines’ - |
with sanitary rags and all that trash that wasn’t. hardly ©
fit to put your hand to. [164] hen we have a little east-.
-erly weather, the ground swell fills up and makes our pots -
drift on- the*bottom, and acts the sare on the garbage,

- and then in turn the working of our'lines, raising and fall-
_ing, allows this garbage to get tangled with the lines,
‘which often times causes: lass of lines. Year before last
I -lost two lines. It. was impossible to raise the lines to
the top, the surface of the water because there was so

much garbage you. couldn’t raise the Buoy line. There |.

- were 80 traps on each line. We have trouble like that’
every year accordnig if: we have any easterly storm, if
there is a ground sea. If there is.any-size of: ground sea,
af the storm happens to be off shore, this ground sea
“travels in. ' (Witness shown Identification number 18.)
‘I have never seen the surface of the ocean look as bad as
that. (Number 13. [165] Parts of it I have seen like

Seeker,
For Plaintif—Alfred Schweitzer, direct: :
‘that. I have seen conditions_hke that right after a dump.

* T have seen conditions like that shown in 18 the length of

—_ = ast

the-seow right after dumping, and it would gradua!ly.

spread owt. I have seen conditions like identification —

number 12, but not like number -15. Ihave seen the con-
ditions similar to number 24. [166] Just as soon as the
scow gets.a chance to clear away from it, it comes right to

- ..the top. I have seen it string out in the sea like on num-
ber 24 after it has been dumped. ‘The ocean is clear before -

the scow gets there, and that stuff shows up just after they

‘get done dumping. © Driftwood was among the garbage
which was dumped. And it would be ‘the driftwood that -
would damage my boat. [167] It would have to be a:

pretty good sized piece of material to damage: the boat.

ws Other. refuse gets tangled up in the propeller and I have

to clean it out. I have seen parts of the garbage which I
noticed one day, and the following day have seen it again.

About south of the Cholera Bank in that vicinity, where it
~ has been dumped. [168] All we have to loeate our line
is compass and time and a stick sticking above the water: »

with a small flag on it, and naturally we are looking for

anything, and often times the garbage catches our eye, and

in that way we notice different things drifting. I would
be able to identify garbage on one day as having been
deposited at some time previous on another day by the
shape of the article that I happened to see, like a box. I

would distinguish that box at the time it was dumped, by |

:. the way the top happened to be broke, and in what position

‘it happened! to be broken. When I saw it again, it would

“attract my attention and I would know I had seen.it be-

. the following day to run across it, on my course south.

2 GABBY ORE toe

fore. [169] ‘The tide and so forth would bring it to a
different place, ‘and‘it happened to be om my eourse on

there in fishing. The object én the second day would be
three or four miles from the position where I saw it
dumped on the first day. My identification would depend

7 — my ——e of the shape of the ‘box. »

/

ern

45 ; :
For Plaintiff—A lfred Schweitzer—re-direct. |

[170] On re-direct examination. This stuff get in what

' we call the tide streak and forms into a line, and if you °-

see these different objects on one day, then if on the
following day you happen to see them in the tide streak,

it attracts your attention in that-way. If I saw a coffee »

pot, sailir across in front of me, I would recognize that =

the next day if I saw it.: In this garbage floating on the

surface I see straw, fruit, like orange peel, small animals,’
dead animals, and I don’t know if I am in position to

speak of that—men’s safety devices, small crates, and
most any- [171] thing that. is used as a receptacle to

carry garbage—arfything that would float. I-se¢ large

quantities of these things that I speak of. At times I
have seen the vessels passing through the field that I sail
in. I have seen .the vessels ‘throw very little garbage
overboard. I would see. an ihdividual throw something
overboard, but other than that I don’t. know as Ihave

seen. any garbage thrown overboard.. It would be im- ~ &

possible for the garbage I have seen in the ocean to come
from: passing vessels. I have seen the. same class of
. Material dumped from the: scows. {172] When it first:

is dumped overboard, it seems to stay in a body the size *. [

of the scow and the longer it lays ‘there it goes into tide

_ streaks and drifts wherever the tide may carry it. It. =
strings out in long streaks.’ Its. motion is affected by.)

both the wind and“currents of the water. When the tide
and wind get in a certain position they will. come ashore. °
It goes whichever way the wind and tide seems to carry

it... The condition. of this matter that I see is mostly
decayed, and stuff that will drift. (Witness shown. identi-

fication number 12, the condition of the water following . ©

[173] the barges, was pointed out.) That is what you

- call the tide streak. It consists of- the garbage and so _

forth that washes to one*side, which forms like ‘an. eddy,
and the current kind’ of keeps it one side, and it seems
_to build up into the slack of the water and gives anything
that will float a, chance to accumulate and hold together.

VA

y

-

4

-~e a

- For Plat iff—Alfred Schweitzer, re-cross—re-direct.

- There j grease in those slicks. You can just see the top
of the’ water is oily, greasy. It affects my boat when I

| it at. times. ;
[174] On re- cross examination. On this one occasion I

as down at Seaside Park on the beach and I. saw gar-
bage on the beach. I was not able to identify the garbage
_as the same I had seen dumped: at sea, I never followed
‘it. IT wasn’t interested enough. —

[175] On re- direct examination. It was the same kind

of material. . There is a dump where the heavy stuff is |

_ dumped, anyways‘from a mile to five miles south, south-

east of Ambrose Lightship, and that is practically on our .
good fishing ground, and that is where they dump the
heavy stuff, and that is where a whole lot of our lines are - -

destroyed also. We fish for lobsters’ there and we fish
off south of the Cholera Banks. [176] The “heavy
stuff” consists of stone, mud, dirt, iron, parts of auto-
mobiles. When they dump. there, there ‘isa lot of. drift-

wood dumped from\them. We know it to be driftwood

from them, because if we are working there. before they

dump, there is.a clear sea, and after they dump there is

wood shows up..

(177), On __re-cross examination. I have seen ‘scows
dumping stom and other materials out there. They
dump on top of: the lines and it destroys the buoys and
makes it impossible for us to grapple. for the lines, due

to the fact of the heavy stuff that they dump on our”
lines. We are not able to grapple our lines, and we sim- ~

ply lose them.- This is not the material that I had refer-

ence to as destroying our lines and our pots-when I testi-
fied before. [178] I was talking: off-shore, south of the
Cholera Banks before, where they dump garbage. On

re-direct examination. These scows having other refuse

come out pretty well every day. I have seen marks on’
them.. One particular name that I remember is O’Brien.
They have big letters on them:. [179] The letters are-

/ iff

Ps ' } »

4 ‘ °
. ; or Riva
4 . . ;

Prins

; | sa . + 47
For Plaintiff—Louis H: De Camp, direct. te
similar to those shown on identification number 6. - [180]

On re-cross examination, There are two classes of scows
with respect to the material they carry that go to sea.. One
carries garbage and the other heavy material. [181] It
is not: this material deposited by these scows that does

- the great damage to the lobster fishérmen. The garbage -

-, that is wound up on our lines by the ground swell is what '
_ - does the biggest part of our damage. [182] I have been
. very close to’ these scows that dump heavy material at

the time of dumping. I can tell what I saw them dump
only from what I have seen on my lines the next day. I
saw them tripping the fall. [183] I saw the top or cap- |

‘ping of the material on the scows. The ‘capping would

project up, and it looked like ‘stone and sticks, and occa-
sionally pieces of iron sticking out. : Ge, tee

[184]. LOUIS: H. DECAMP on. direct examination. | a
live at Highlands. I am a fisherman. [185] I have been |

_ in that business about fifteen years. I fish for lobsters in ut

.the ocean, in the bay. I generally start in the bay in: the

' spring early, and-we work on:out and go to the Lightship, |

from the Lightship work on out-to the southeast, until as

' far as the Cholera. Banks, sometimes a little. further, I

go out where the garbage scows dump. I have seen them
dump out there, plenty of them. The days I am there I
either meet them on the way in or early in the morning I —
will meet them coming out. I am right there when they
dump at timés. I fish just'a short distance from them.
[186] I try. to keep at just one ‘side, just out of their line,
within a quarter of a mile. “J have seen as high as five - °
scows out there in a day where I was fishing. When they ~
dumped these scows most: of the material comes to the _
top. Of course, some of it sinks to the bottom; and then—
there is a’big puddle of it comes up to the top. If you are |

- fishing there for a while, then if you return by there you
will still see it coming up, still keep bubbling and floating |
along on the water. It covers a pretty good space of

4.
l

, 48
* For Plaintiff—Louis H., ‘De Camy, direct,

water when they dump the ccow. When it comes up I
' suppose it spreads out over a place of about two or three
hundred feet. That is altogether in a close mass. After
that, it strings out, spreads out and floats along, and goes

- with the different currents and divides up and goes [187]

all over. I have seen the mass after-I got through lifting
my lines. I have run through it when the wind would be a
little light. I have seen it pretty close to the shore drift-

ing. It comes into shore if we get an east wind or a i

‘northeast wind, We generally hit it coming in this side
of the ship, coming’ in, because it generally works here
to the. south, generally coming in about’ southwest. I .-
haven’t seen so much of it in the Highlands, because we
are out of the way of it. All that comes:to shore at the
Highlands comes in the gurrent, works to the north and
comes up on the shore and works up the beach, and then
_ you get stuff on the beach that comes from the undertow,
such as orange peels and turnips and bananas and oranges"
and chicken entrails and stuff like that, that lays in the
underow, that can’t float, that will wash ashore: I have
seen that. [188] Identification number 22, number 16,

~ ‘number 21 are right after a dump. Number 19 is sgt Cae
_ after a dump.

Q. How long does it remain in that condition? - :

A.. It will remain. that wah, I suppose, for probably
~ an hour, | according. to the wind, how strong..it is.’ If
theré is no wind it will float around that way and spread
out; keep working loose, but if there is a little wind it
will work loosé: a little bit quicker. “It won t. hold
together so much. |
(Referring to number 18.)° There. are water leads in.
through it.° I have seen that condition. I have picked

out ways many a time and run through it’ like that,
just little spaces. ‘This is from one side. off the scow \
and that is from‘the other. That is where th scow just. \ 3
went through. The streak at the top thereon number —
_ 18 is where the scow has gone through. [189] Number

49

‘a For Plaintiff Louis H. De Camp cross.

17 is the same thing. That is right after a dump, toa. °
Number 22 that is immediately after a dump. That is all ©
together in a heap. (Referring to number 14.) That has —
been spread by. the scow. That happens more or less like
that,. when: it. is together like that, where the ‘scow. goes
through, where it probably all works out at one time. Num-

‘ber 24 that has, been dumped quite a little while. . That is.

the way it stretches out after it has been dumped. I have.

_ run through it, I suppose, for ten or fifteen minutes, some-—
_ thing like that, running as slow as I possibly could Fun.
t, Ot course, if you get that refuse around the ‘wheel, that
means that you have got/to get ‘out and ent it off 1190]

or do something with it, because you are stuck. and you
won’t make’ over two miles an-hour if your engine is wide

: open. “I have followed , it pretty well in.’ I have come

clear in to the ship- pier, inside of the ship pier, to the
south of them before I, get through it, inside of Scotland:
Lightship. I have seen it all down below there, all

' through in tfe tide streaks, working in here on the south,

working southwest, about off of Seabright. I have
seen it there within, I suppose, two miles and a

. half of the beach. [191] he stuff consists of mostly _

everything, all kinds of refuse. I have seen orange

peels and tomatoes, lemons , and oranges, chicken
entrails and ‘pieces of ° meat, pieces of grapefruit.
[192] { have seen dead chickens and dead eats and dogs
and mostly everything that is imaginable. I saw big

pieces of meat where it had been dumped and then laid on -

the bottom’ and’ popped up from the bottom; all white,

full of ‘gas. It rag to the top and Boats around.

On ‘cross otienhdaaaiic The diatéion. from the J ersey
shore to the Scotland Lightship is two miles and three-
eighths; in a straight course directly from the. shore.
[194] I have occasionally trailed the garbage at sea. Since
you asked me I will tell you, I-have run pretty well i in with

them when they have been sailing along, and the stuff ;

50

7

Kor Plaintiff—Lars Peterson, direct.

would naturally bubble up and follow the scows pretty .
well in before they could get rid of it. The stuff lays in
a pocket there and keeps drifting otit as they go along,

_ keeps working out, bubbling up. [195] .I have just simply . |

' . followed = scows, in behind them sometimes. - When the

sea has been pretty heavy I generally .run along pretty .

~ glose to the. scdws, keep pretty well to the leeward of es
them, so they break the sea. I ‘cannot say how long 1:
have observed the dumping operations of any of the scows
** because I never took any particular notice of how long I

have watched them. I havé saw them dump, that’s all. I

. have been working on my gear = saw them dump, and
I would be busy. -

LARS PETERSON. ‘Ow direct examination. I live at
North Long Branch. [196] I am a fisherman. I have been in.
that business for 20 years. I fish lobster. I go out where

fe they dump garbage. Every time I am out there, if it is

Ss clear weather I can see them, every day pretty near. They
sf dump off the shore about 18 miles. They don’t dump al--
» ways-in the same place. -It -would be close by. [197] -

As’soon as they dump. it, that stuff floats on top of the -

_. water, what will float, and the rest.goes down to: the bot-.

4
- ;
§ {RMR Sota tata S¥ 2" ys ig Mths Ror, ;

tom, part of it sinks and ‘part of it floats.. I have seen

conditions existing there as shown in Exhibit 21, just-after’
a dump. I have seeh conditions existing as shown in num-

er’ 15; also number 18; also number 13. I have seen them
‘often. That is the general appearance of the thing after it

has been dumped. Number 14 shows it spreading out. a
little bit. After this stuff has been in the water for, a little

while [198] it spreads out, gets bigger, and then it drifts.

Number 14 shows it drifting according’ to the tide. I -
see that stuff drift around there. I remain out there after-

a dump, out there where the garbage is, sometimes five or -
six hours, or more than that. -At that time it will be -
moving. The tide and the wind moves it. Ihave seen it
drift toward shore. Mostly it is the.tide that causes this. °

ol

ae Plaintiff—Lars Pécun, cross.

The northeast wind moves it.in. I have followed it right
on to the beach, all the way into the beach, [199] at Gali-
lee. The name‘of the municipality at Galilee is Monmouth

Beach. I am able to say that garbage that was dumped
_ from the scows came right in on to the beach at Mon-
mouth Beach. I am still fishing for lobster although I ©
stopped in October or November for this year. I have
‘not seen it this year because I have been going inside this
year: When I was going outside, I saw that occur fre-.
quently. [200] In the garbage floating around there is

' oranges, bananas, onions, all kinds of vegetables, grape-
'. fruit, tin cans,’ bottles, bedding, all kinds of stuff, every-

- thing that floats on the water. I saw animals in it, and
victuals, pieces of meat, chicken and anything of that
sort. I have’ seen’ marks on that material to indicate
where it came from; [201] I saw fish boxes come from

ee Fulton Market.

On cross dalaiasieiabaan, This garbage came in on the

-. beach at Monmouth Beach most .any. time. [ haven’t — i

- got ‘any dates. I can’t tell approximately when it came
int I was at the dumping grounds when the barge

dumped the garbage. The dumping-took place at all times. * 5

— of the day. [202] ‘Sometimes I have been laying out and
-the garbage would be drifting by, and then 1 start for
_ shore; ‘and that garbage would :, be. way in shore. -
The garbage as to which Ty ‘have testified. came
- ashore, -was garbage that I saw~ dumped. ‘I went
* out to the pots at four o ‘clock in the morning. [203]
I saw it dumped about 7 o’clock. I was out there lifting ”

' ‘the lobster pots. After I saw the garbage dumped, I de-’

‘posited my lobster pots. Then I started for shore. - I

‘would get back to ‘shore at two or three o’clock in the

afternoon. After returning to shore I would pull the |
boats up and then go for home. I would return to pick
up the pots the next day. The next day I would: go out
the same time. [204] I would arrive out at the pots about

52
For Plaintiff —Anton H olgarson, Bivenk.

. the same time, about 7 0 “lock in the morning. Some...

times I take 214 hours going out, sometimes 3. I would
pick up my’ pots after I got out there. Then I.would re-
drop them again after I had rémoved whatever had gotten .
into the pots.- I never did drift with the garbage because

-we use power. | I was going to and from a place for the

purpose of managing my pots, [205] I was never out on
the water at night: ‘When I went: back and forth from
my pots, I didn’t go for the purpose of following garbage.

ANTON HOLGARSON. [206] - On direct. examination.
I live at Monmouth Beach, New Jersey. I have been =
lobster fishing for. the past six: years. I do my lobster

fishing within two miles of: the beach, and on out 12 or 14

miles east and southeast, and a little further to the north
at times. I never go out where the garbage barges dump.

I have seen the garbage in the sea after they dumped it.

On or about the 14th day of November we had a hard

southeast wind, a little breeze before; and-this day it hap-—

pened to_be calm, no wind at all, but there was [207]

southeasterly tides running in toward shore, and we run . |
through this different kinds of stuff for about 40 to 50.
minutes, but we didn’t run. so fast, we had to slow dow

the motor on account of it was such thick stuff. I do not

- . know the rate of speed at which I was moving, perhaps

seven to eight miles an hour. (Witness shown pictures
taken at sea.) I have seen a lot of this stuff. ©[208]
I would say not quite as quick as either that or this (in-

dicating spots on picture number 24). But of the smaller.

stuff, something like this here (indicating).’ It was,more
sticks of wood, pieces of coal, and there was loaves of
bread, papers, and wire for: the use in machine shops, full.
of oil; waste, yes, floating around, and such stuff. There -
was orange peelings and grapefruit peelings and such
stuff, garbage from houses. [209] The day I was speak-
ing of was about the 14th day of November of this year.

During the period that I have ‘been sn out there, I :

>

- 53

For Plaintiff—Anton Holgarson, cross. '

have seen the garbage condition often. I couldn’t say _
how. often, because I never paid much. attention, but it,
was during the entire time that I have heen fishing there.
I have seen the garbage drift on the surface of the sea..

It drift with the tide. If there is no wind, the tide will .

‘take it wherever the tide runs:’ If the tide runs from the

east, it will bring it right clean into the ‘beach. I have

never followed the garbage into the shore itself, but I
have run through it all the way in to the shore, clear into
the beach... [210] This was at North Long Branch. -

I have taken up papers and different things off the sea
~ to show where it came from. They were letter sheets and
- things from New York, bundles of papers. The effect of
the. garbage on my lobster fishing is this: I find the lines
wrapped up with rags and different things, and bundles of
wire, electric wire. They drag along the bottom if they
‘have a swell, and they .get up against the lines and get

; . wrapped around them, and we get up a lot of stuff. That

is material that sinks from the garbage. [211] I have
had a hole knocked right thgough my boat, because the

propeller picked up a little stick and throwed it around

and up against the planking of the boat and knocked.a hole
in it. I have had occasion ‘to sail around it to get some

place where it is not so thick and pick out thin places.

to sail through. I-have seen this garbage on the beach
where I launched my boats.. At times we have to clear

the beach off, so that we can pull the boat around—clean Z
off a lot of stuff that is floating up on the beach. There

is lumber and there is paint cans, tin cans, bottles, .and
of course pieces of lumber. [212] Vegetable and animal

matter comes ‘up on the beach. I have seen what they. call -

‘slicks’? of grease in among the garpage:

On cross examination. [213] The date I testified
to was around about the 14th day of November. I
am not sure whether it was the 14th or 15th. I did
not see the garbage scows dump on that day. I saw

. ,
:

we

i For Plaintiff —Anton Holgarson, redirect:

. garbage for the— first time. on that day about 5 or 6:
- miles off from ‘the beach. I was taking the pots --in.

54 | 4
oe

I was going in with a lot of pots.. I was making .
for North Long Branch; the north end of Long Branch, |
I was moving at the time not over six miles’ at the

best, and then down to much lower than that, two or
: three miles. We run through this stuff for 40 to 50 °

minutes. [214] Outside it wasn’t so much, after I- run
on two hours or more, two hours and a half. The garbage
was all the way into the beach. When we struck for the

_beach it followed us all the way to the beach, I would
say about five miles or six, or four. . I couldn’t tell ex-° _
actly. ‘I ran through it, came through it.-.Had to go |
~ through it because it was scattered all over the water.

On the beach I saw tin cans and empty glass bottles and |
pieces of wood and small pieces of cork and: such things.
[215] I did not see large pieces of cork, maybe 10 or 12

inches long by 3 or 4 inches in-thickness. I would pick
‘them up if I see them, because TI could make use of them.

The pieces of cork that I sdw were small pieces, ground |
up cork, broken up like. They had been in ice boxes or
something like that, linings of different things.’ It was .
garbage all the way in to the shore from that point where »
we struck into it. «It took me 40-or 50 minutes at slow

_ speed to pass through the garbage that I mentioned. [216]
My vessel was moving faster than the, motion of the. tide,

On re-direct examination. When we -got under way. we

_ got through the garbage. The drift of .garbage that I

struck five or. six miles out was continuous all the way:
into the shore, and I went through it all the way. until I

' got to shore. When I got to the shore, there were parts

of it had already gotten ‘there and piled up on the
beagh. I didn’t notice any vegetables and fruit and
meat and things like that in the stuff that had already
gotten in on the shore. -There were cans, tin cans, and

bottles and auch stuff, pieces of wood and so forth.

| Poe Plaintiff —Carl H olgarson, direct.

On re-cross. examination. I saw a large quantity of “§
_ wood on the shore many times. On re-direct examination.
' [217] The garbage that I see floating out in the ocean, »
has wood and sticks and boards i in it. :

CARL HOLGARSON. On direct. examination. I live in
North Long Branch. I am-a lobster: and net fisherman.
I have been in that business ten years. [218] I have dis-
continued work for this season: I quit the middle of No-
os vember, about. My fishing .season during. the year is |
from the first of April up till that time. I went. out to
where the garbage is‘dumped in “August, September and
October.- I have seen them dumping. Sometimes, accord-
“ing to the-wind and tide, sometimes they dump at seven
in the morning, sometimes at ten, on, maybe ‘dt twelve. I saw
them dump almost every day. I have seen the conditions.
of the garbage in the ocean out there after the dumping.
I can show you pictures here that’ represent .the condi-. —
tions that I recognize (indicating photographs). *I have
' seen streaks of it that looks just [219] like number 19.
That isn’t so wide.: That only runs one way. That is a
tide streak. I have seen them for miles long, two or
three miles. These tide streaks are not so wide, 100
yards or so. I have seen conditions like number 14 pic-
ture shows: It is opened up a little. Those strips can
be scattered out for a long distance.. I haven’t seen them
so big, but I have:seen them two or three miles.. [220] I
recognize the ‘condition shown in number 24. That is
"more séattered out. . We try ‘to go through it where if
is not so much, but sometimes we- have to change. our
~ course in order to get to a place wheré we can get through.

. And then it slows us down. But we get through. These’
garbage areas drift with the tide mostly. The wind
_ affects it, wind and tide mostly, because I have drifted
with it. I have drifted with the garbage, sometimes to.
the shore and sometimes off-shore, sometimes north and §
‘sometimes south. I have never followed drifts: of this’ |

+

= .
| ae
Sol Xp te .
° .

“re hte, Cc}
For Plaintiff—Carl H olgarso#y irect.

garbage all the way to the shore in coming home -on the

. drift. [221] At different times I have seen it closer a

little bit, at different timés farther out; sometimes closer
a bit; sometimes a mile off, sometimes ten miles off. I

_ have seen it right on the beach. I have seen it drifting. .
- from distances away onto the beach. It looked to be the -

same general mass of garbage. You see mostly every-
thing in the garbage; all kinds of vegetables, cans and
bottles and boxes, oil waste and ‘all that‘stuff. There are

particles of wood and boards and all that [222] sort of
\ thing mixed in it, and there are heavy logs at times. I
\ havé seen "the oil slicks’ or grease slicks following the ‘

“barges, like: number. 12, as it was testified that light place -
was. When the garbage floats along, after it floats along

_ awhile there seems to be more oil, but after it is dumped _
I wouldn’t see any oil in it right away. The condition _ See

the things that I. see there differs. Sometimes they are
fresh and sometimes they look pretty: sour. I have seen
the garbage on the beach. Sometimes it look pretty.
[223] sour and sometimes it looks fresh. I have seen

- oranges, grapefruit, banana peelings and that kind of

stuff on the beach.. I have seen vegetables. Once in a
while I see animals. I don’t’ see many of them, though.

.Sometimes a-dead dog or a dead. cat. . I have seen the -

beach covered with garbage. Some places it’ might be a
hundreds yards or so; 200 yards or so. Out to sea it inter-
feres with my boats, but not on the beach. Sometimes it
interferes with the landing or launching | of boats. [224]
When that: happens we have to go through it and take a |
chance. We have a man that cleans up the beach. We
lease or rent the beach, and we have a man there to take.
eare of that. I have seen some bundles of paper I picked .

“up, and boxes once in a while I have noticed marked New
-York. There. was some papers come from the business

places in New York, business clubs or something... I don’t
know exactly. I have nevé? seen any that came from any

other place than New York [225] and Brooklyn.

57
For Plaintiff—M. E. Snyder, direct. toes

On cross examination. I am in the or as
the previous ‘witness, who is my brother. I am engaged
in business with my brother. Our place of business
is located. at North. Long Branch. We ,have ninety
foot of seashore front. . The testimony I have given
here relates to that ninety. foot. I have been drifting -
with the tide twelve hours at a time. That is the
longest I have..been with it. You drift with the tide.
[226] Whether it would be an outgoing tide differs, .
according to the. tide and weather. -The tide does not
change .every six hours. Fifteen, miles from here. \I
- don’t think there. is’ any certain tide. It is accordin

to the wind and weather. The tide runs two or. thre

_ days sometimes, runs south two or three days, runs
from different directions for a long time, the same tide.

Of course, I can drift as high as’ seven miles in twelve
hours. in one direction, going in the tide. I go out
with my lobster pots as far as 18 or 20 miles. I go out
to the dumping grounds. The greatest length of time I
have drifted has been twelve, hours. With the nets I have
drifted, gill nets. That isin June and July. [227] When
I am drifting the most I travel is seven miles’ in twelve
. hours, with the tide.. The fastest time I have ever made

drifting with the tide has been seven mating 3 ‘in twelve hours.. - §

[228] M. E. SNYDER. [229] “On dices: examination.

I live at Ocean Grove. I have been: general superintendent
of the Ocean Grove Camp Meeting Association since. April
1, 1926. It is a religious organization, composed of
twenty-six trustees who run‘a camp meeting. resort. It is
a corporation under the laws of New Jersey. It has been
in existence at Ocean Grove since 1869. Its purpose is
to hold a camp meeting and. provide a Christian resort.

’ .We hold meetings from the. second Sunday in June until

the second Sunday in September. There are numerous :
meetings being held from time to time during that period,
meetings [230] every day, some days as nee as 12 and 13.

4 @6For -Plaintif—M. E. Snyder, direct Sous |
| . We lave a very elaborate form of concert. entertainment
‘and lectures. We usually try to secure the outstanding -
- preachers of all denominations for the summer Sunday
| program. In\.1926 we had Bishop Freeman of the
\ Episcopal Church and Bishop Wilson, of ‘the Methodist
Church, Mark Matthews, who was then the moderator of
_ the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church, and .
men of that type from all over the world. In 1927 we
had two bishops. In 1928 we'had three bishops, and in
1929 we had three bishops, and.likewise the outstanding’
men of various denominations. ‘Two years ago we started
' a count system-of our preaching services: In 1928 there
' were 97,710 persons attending the preaching services. ’
alone. Last year the number was 85,216. We have con- -
certs such’ as are furnished by Galli Curci, Madam
‘Schuman-Heink, John McCormack, Kreisler, Marion Tal-
ley—all the outstariding artists of\ the world and some-’. .
- times they draw. a. capacity [231] house, which is .about:
10,000 people. This represents (exhibitirig a photograph),
"the auditorium of the Ocean Grove Camp Meeting Asso-
ciation. There are accommodations to seat about 8,000
people. (The qhotograph was marked ‘‘Plaintiff’s Ex-
hibit 30’’.and admitted in evidence.) (Exhibiting a photo-
_’. graph.) That is a view of the interior of the auditorium.
__.. (The photograph was marked ‘‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit 31” and ©
_. admitted in evidence.) : Number 31 looks toward tha pulpit
end. This picture (exhibiting a photograph), [232] shows -
_ . the interior of, the auditorium, looking from the pulpit
_.. towards the west, or rear of the building. . (The photo-
graph was marked ‘‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit’ 32’’ and admitted
- In-evidence.) Those pictures (numbers 31 and 32), were’ \
' ‘taken more than two years ago. I can’t give the date of
‘those. The exterior of the auditorium was taken two
years. ago by Adams and Brown. The resident population.
.of Ocean: Grove is between 3,500 and 4,000. . [233] ©
I have complete charge of the business affairs of the asso-
ciation, and ‘we are a municipality — that eed a quasi-

:

Va”

\

S \
X

- this testimony. )

59

“For Plaintiff E. Bayder, direct.

municipality—and_ I have the enforcement of the laws. I |

. act. réally as the mayor, the council and everything in. ,

general. Our summer population runs from twenty-five
to thirty-five. or forty thousand people.,’ We have a great
thany summer residences thete and a great many. hotels.

The collector informed me that the tax ratables for 1928

amounted to $9,240,295. (Discussion as to relevancy of
5]. The colleétor’s name is Edward
(Further discussion. ) [238] The approx-
ortion of the property ratables represented by.

- summer hotels and. boarding houses is three million [239]
. dollars. The amount of those tax ratables/ that. are de-

voted to summer homes for private parties is approxi-
mately $1,500,000. The proportion that is represented by

purely pleasure resorts is $25,000. Ocean Grove has in-
vested in boardwalks $45,000, approximately. It is very

nearly accurate. We have spent for piérs and jetties to
preserve_the beach about [240] $60,000. We have. spent
for bathing pavilions and bathing facilities or clubs along
the beach $50, 000. We have a beach frontage of approx-.
imately three- quarters of a mile. (The witness produced.
records to show the amount spent per year for ‘the pur-
pose of cleaning garbage off the beach for years 1926,
1927, 1928, 1929.) (Objection to their admission. ‘Over.
ruled. Exception.) [241] These are the time sheets of
the employees of the Ocean Grove. Camp Meeting. Asso-
ciation who work upon the beach in c

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386008_0038%3A01. Public record. Not legal advice.
