# Respondents Brief — Carbice Corp. of America v. America Patents Development Corp.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386007_0501%3A06

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Respondents Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1931
- **Citation:** 283 U.S. 27

## Text

“PLECOPY | ems

Supreme Court of the United States. ‘

wy” .* ¢

-": Octrosze Txrm, 1930.
| No. 54. -

CARBICE CORPORATION OF AMERICA, . ~
, Petitioner,

vs.
‘AMERICAN PATENTS DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION

axp DRY ICE CORPORATION OF AMERICA,
Respondents.

BRIEF FOR RESPONDENTS.

‘ CHARLES NEAVE, -
v GEORGE C. DEAN,
CLARENCE D. KERR,
. o&f Counsel for Respondents.

December, 1930.

ae : S

The Evening Post Job Printing Office, Inc., 154 Fulton &t., New York, N. ¥.

Supplementary statement of the case..... Ne ken oe 2

Solid carbon dioxide.......... Sotinm ds ae\ssneus 3

Prior proposals as tothe use of solid ‘carbon dioxide. 4

The patent in suit ..:..... Se aieeseenecceees Yee 5
ARGUMENT. - We

I; The patent in suit discloses ¢ real and very meri-
torious invention LeUL GL EMe a Rebohen eek a haes Oa 9

. JI. The invention is properly claimed in the patent.. 20

Ti. The Petitioner infringes.................00% so ee
Reply to Petitioner’s brief............... -paeee 33
1. Prior refrigeration decisions of this Court. . ie
2: Morgan Envelope case.........., es tapers "34
3. Petitioner’s infringement................:. Sy See
4. Decree not in conflict with: Clayton Act.. 44
5. Patentable as a ‘‘ manufacture’’.......... Pee
6. Not for an aggregation Tn ip aki ea Ak ee ae
7. Not anticipated by prior pe: POT eee er — §2
res | Mosler No. 286,906..........:. meledeg athe 52
i. ~ Drummond Wo. 533,794......:......00065 *s
Rumpel No. 1,130, 932 Listis'sd sthwe ane or 52
Josephson No. 1,515,119......... ery - 53
Elworthy Patents. Po ERE ES: tobe, ae
8. No insufficient disclosure.................. 53
9. No prior knowledge or use............. Stes 53

SL 6 TN oo oo ivccccedtgevervesovcetas 4, 53

TABLE OF CASES.

Brown v. Piper, 91 U. 8. a... PSM MARE oie) sae

‘ Davis Electrical Works v. Edison Electric Light Co., ae
60 Fed. 276 (C. 0. A.M). ...--eeeeeey RL aaaees me
- Kurtz v. Belle Hat Lining Co., 280 Fed. S77 (0. 0;: 32° i

NS oyna saab Lee deh neo eee VR Rae CEES 19
Le eqgs & Catlin Co. v. Vv ictor Talking “Machine Co.,

213 U. 8. 325.2... eee ge Capa ones BB, 30, 36, 38

ny ‘Morgan Envelope Co. v. Albany Paper Co., 6U;8.°

SERA NE IS eRSE rere Saat QMemas Aiea Spee Wr eet poe 34
Motion Picture Patents Co. v. Uatvernal Film ie: 243:

U. 8. 502.0... eee eee CUSMLRRERN SESE Oe -» - 89
Seabury v. Am Ende, 152 U. 8. 561..-........ vas 50
Tidewater Oil Co. v. United States, 171 U. S. 210... 49
Yablick v. Protecto Safety Appliance Corp. ‘5°21 Py

(2nd) 885. (C. C. A. 8). EEUU iR ENERO ULeeerieas’ 19
Ae ‘OTHER AUTHORITIES.

Corpus RI OE es Ee ener LOY ETE , er eae 48

i STATUTES
The Clayton Act......05.0.00e eee ere rere apes
§ 4886 Revised Statutes............... casa hee Gee

AMERICAN PATENTS DEVELOPMENT CoRPoRATION and Dry

Suyieme Court of the United Bates,

~S_

geet OCTOBER TERM, 1930. -

No. 54.

CARBICE CORPORATION OF AMERICA, | _
Petitioner- Defendant,

a

"VB. meal hide Mean ea

ICE CORPORATION, OF America,
Respondents. Plaintiffs.

Se,

. BRIEF FOR RESPONDENTS. . °°
This equity suit, brought by the Respondents on patent

No. 1,595,426 (p. 187), is before. this Court.on a writ of cer- - |
tiorari to the Circuit Court of Appeals | ‘for the Second Cir--

cuit. * >
In-the District Court, the patent, was held not to be in-

_ fringed (p. 429; 2 25 F. (2ndy 730), so the matter of validity

was not there decided..; The Circuit Court of Appeals held
the patent (claims 2 ak 4 and 6 being in issue) valid and

” infringed (pp) 441- 453: 38 F. (2nd) 62). o-

This is the, =p suit in which this patent has been in-
volved. ' :
A statement, of the case, acacia! 4 to that in the’.
Petitioner’s brief, .is necessary for correcting inaccuracy. or
omissions in the Petitioner's statement.

; aad .

. *- . .
° 7 Cee ; : —
’

Solid carbon dioxide:

It has been known for nearly pening that carbon dioxide ©
(CO,) may exist in any one of three forms, namely, a gas,
a liquid and a solid. In all of these forms it is colorless and
odorless.
-The gas is readily reduced by cold and pressure to the
liquid form, known as carbonic acid. By rapid évaporation
of the liquid, it may be converted into a snow-like solid which
is intensely cold—very much colder than water ice; it has a .
temperature of about 110° below zero, Fahrenheit.
The solid, in passing back to the gaseous state, does so
without becoming liquid; that is, on “melting”, it changes
directly into the gas which, also, is extremely ‘cold, about
110° below zero. The volume of the gas thus-given off is :
about 500 times that of the solid (p. 142, fol. 205).
- All of the foregoing has been known for many, many years,
as is shown by the Petitioner’s numerous exhibits which also
set forth methods of producing the solid carbon dioxide. The
patent in suit asserts no novelty in solid carbon dioxide,
nor in methods of producing it, nor in the knowledge that it
is very cold, ete.
Solid carbon dioxitle, because of its known extremely low

temperature, natyrally suggested itself for use as a refriger-
ant, and its refrigerating value, as compared with water: ice,
was determined.

Experiment showed that it required twice as many heat
units to change solid carbon dioxide from its solid form as
it did thus to change water ice; so the refrigerating value of
the sdlid carbon dioxide was, and was recognized as being,
twice that of water ice (p. 143, fol. 206; p. 145, fol. 209;
p. 82, fol. 123; p. 87, fol. 130).

But the cost of solid carbon dioxide was and is ten times
greater than that of water ice (p. 214).

So the use of solid carbon dioxide for commercial refrig-
eration was economically impossible. ,

Oe Wore eee : % ; ——— |
= x

4

Prior proposals as to uses of solid carbon dioxide:

It was proposed for use, and may have been used on a
“small scale, for dermatological purposes, such as for ex.
_ ternal applications in lesions and skin diseases (p. 514 fol-.

‘lowing p. 428; and p. 118), and in connection with the cali-
bration of thermometers (p. 138).

Petitioner's witness Starr says (pp. 44-45) that, in 1900,
at the request of a St. Louis doctor, he made a small amount
of solid carbon dioxide for freezing some human and animal
tissues for microscopic-slides; but this experiment was per-
formed only once, as it was found cheaper and just as satis. .
factory to use ammonia (p. 47). And Goosmann made
some small pencils of the solid for use in freezing specimens
fot microscopic slides (p. 119)...

The solid carbon dioxide remained, largely, a subject for
interesting class room demonstrations, as Churchill used it -
in lecturing to a freshman class in elementary chemistry; ©
he froze mercury and eggs, and froze water in a red hot ..
crucible (pp. 57-58). And, abroad, Churchill used-it to pro-
duce low temperatures in vessels-in which he was carrying
_ on certain organic reactions, and to accelerate the erystalliza-

tion of certain liquids (p. 60).

~ There were a. few suggestions of other uses for solid
carbon. dioxide that are of more or less academic interest;
nothing came of them. Elworthy, for example, in his
U. 8. patent 579,866 and British patent 7436, suggested that
_ pieces of the solid be used to aerate and cool water by merely
' dropping a piece in the water (pp. 386-387), much the same
idea being proposed by Cremieu in his: patent 1,421,176 (p.
419). Petéttoner’s witness, Goosmann, states that solid CO,
is ineffective for this purpose (p. 122, fol. 178). And Heyl,
in his French patent 344,957 (p. 391) proposed a mechanical
method for keeping.solid CO, frozen.in order that it might
be shipped economically, the heavy steel cylinders required
for the liquid CO, being rendered unnecessary. Hey] makes |

no suggestion as to refrigerating foodstuffs.

5

. Elworthy, in his patents above referred to; says,that the _
solid carbon dioxide may be made “dvailable for nearly all
purposes for which’ ice is now used”, (p. 386). And this is
of real importance, for it is illustrative of the fact that the
very few suggestions contained in the prior art for the use
of solid carbon dioxide as a refrigerant, involved a mere sub-
stitution of one cooling medium (solid. carbon dioxide) for
another (water ice) in the belief that the one would function
just as the other had done, in the same way, and for the same
reasons, in the same environment and relationships (Peti- °
tioner’s witness Starr, pp. 51-52, fols. 79, 80). The prior art
never progressed beyond this simple idea of substitution,
never conceived the now evident necessity for a total reorgani-
zation of the refrigerating methods, apparatus, and relation-
ships as a prerequisite to the economical use of solid carbon
dioxide. . * ee

The prior art could never find a way to increase the
efficiency of solid carbon dioxide to offset its greater cost and
make it available for commercial refrigerating ~ purposes
( Petitioner's witnesses Starr, p. 87, fols. 130-131; Goosmann,
p. 210). -

In spite of all the knowledge that existed. as to carbon
dioxide, it does not appear that any of the solid was ever sold
or entered into commercial channels in any way.

The patent in suit: =~ ~

Then came the invention here in issue, under which the -
Respondents began commercial operation in the spring of 1925
(p. 18). In that year they sold 366,000 pounds of solid car-
bon dioxide and; up to the end of 1927, they had sold nearly
5,000,000 pounds of it. Of this amount about 90% has been
used as set forth in the patent in suit (pp. 19, 157). .To the
soliduearbon dioxide the Respondents gave the trade name.

_ “Dry-Iee”—the first time it had ever had any commercial te
name. |

Something had happened to introduce a change and open
solid carbon dioxide to a wide field of usefulness. ~

*. .
—_—_—_n | 5
eo 7. . ung 0 0 Se ee ee
. °

The location of the solid carbon dioxide, irrespective of
whether or not it is in the geometrical center, is further vari-
ously described as “in or among” (p. 188) or more specifi-
cally, “in the midst,” or still more specifically, “midway” of ©
the products-to be shipped.

_With this arrangement the solid carbon dioxide directly
absorbs heat which comes through the walls of the box con- -
taining the solid, and frou. the perishable products around *
that container (p.187). This (p. 187 ) produces —

“a corresponding amount of intensely cold carbon diox-
ide gas without any intermediate liquid state, said gas

being liberated in operative relation to refrigerate such
products, dry them and protect them from air.”

The gas “forces its way under the lid.of the chamber” in
‘which the frozen carbon @ioxide is contained, “end continu-
ously keeps the air and moisture displaced” (p. 188).
The specific arrangement in which “the carbon dioxide
_ is midway of the products to be preserved” is the particular.
“form of my invention” 4p. 188) which is illustrated’ in the
drawings of the patent.

The arrangement in which the frozen carbon. dioxide is
in direct freezing relation to some portions of the perishable
products to be frozen (whether or not midway in them) ‘is

_ Specifically covered by claim 2, which provides that the. ar-
rangement is such that “said gas, as formed, escapes in freez-
ing and insulating relation to said materials.”

Claims 3 and 6 bring out the function of the gas and, .
specifically, the idea. that the arrangement is such that the

Pee ee I ST

_ iokeae Me pai .

'- products to be frozen protect the solid carbon, dioxide from
external heat, that is, “said frozen carbon dfoxide is less
* accessible for exterior heat than said freezable products”.
. Claim 4 emphasizes that the freezable products are “in.
sulated by the gas evaporated” from the solid carbon dioxide,
that is, the constantly evolved cold gas tends to form a_
- barPier between the outside heat ee the products to. be
frozen.

The patent, and the claims, are not t for carbon dioxide °
_and are not for a container for carbon dioxide.

They: are for a combination constituting, when the parts
are arranged as specified, a novel package, or “transporta-
tion package” for transporting such a thing as ice ¢ream
and keeping | it solid and intact until it reaches its destina-
tion, ;
The invention has revolutionized the transportation of ice
cream. It has not only greatly reduced shipping and hand-
ling charges because of the much lighter weight of the pat--
ented package, but also has eliminated entirely the messiness
of dripping and leaky icé cream tubs, re-icing during ship-

-m¢nt and, in most cases, return of the containers (p. 204 and ~

Petitioner’s advertisement on 2nd page following).

As we shall now show, the invention in issue was effective
to make solid carbon dioxide a highly and economically
useful refrigerant by reason of the patentee’s discovery of
the combination in which the characteristic properties of
solid carbon dioxide ore utilized to produce refrigeration on-
new principles.

‘

° A . :
.
9 : '
¢ rs ;
sd .
.

ARGUMENT.

I.

“8 The patent in suit discloses a real and sneede
-torious invention. a ,

The prior art had taught what were supposed to be the
_proper relationships between a refrigerant, the things to be
‘refrigerated, and the enclosing chamber. For ‘example, in
shipping ice cream the ordinary practice was to pack water -
ice and salt in a tub around a can of ice cream. The water.
- iee was interposed between the exterior heat and the product,
‘which latter was cooled entirely by conduction. In the
domestic. refrigerator the water ice is ‘placed in an upper
compartment (the warmest -part of the refrigerator) and |
cooling is ‘effected by currents of air, cooled -by. the ice, de-
scending, coming in contact with and taking up heat from
the articles to be refrigerated, then rising to the ice, becoming
again cooled, deseending again, etc.
Slate rejected these teachings: He conceived that the mere
. substitution of solid carbon dioxide for water ice, in the old
| familiar relationship, was fundamentally wrong. He inter- °
+ posed the product to be refrigerated between the exterior heat
and the refrigerant. He deliberately avoided convection cur-
rents. Instead of using the solid carbon dioxide merely as a
- heat-absorber, he utilized it also as a cold gas ‘generator and
pump which continually forces thé cold gas through all the
"spaces and interstices of the package, carrying sufficient.
refrigeration to all parts, and constantly moving in one direc-
’ tion, outward, without return flow. ;

‘ Slate’s novel coordination of apparently simple elements
brought about a complex series of actions and reactions and
cooperative relationships (pp. 146-148). -

Thus: | °
First: Slate, by placing. the solid carbon dioxide in its
own container, maintains the solid in a bath of its own

evolved carbon dioxide gas, which has high heat- -insulating

10:

value and therefore tends to — the solid from external
heat..

Suconp: He places the foodstuff around the containgr of |
solid carbon dioxide, thus imposing-on the foodstuff itself _
' the affirmative function of a heat-insulating medium for the’:
' protection of the refrigerant. In other words, the foodstuff
is made to serve as an operating é€lement in the patented
. combination—not only in the negative sense that it is to be
refrigerated but in the positive sense that the fdodstiff is
one of thé working elenients, coordinated with the*other
elements, to preserve .the refrigerant against too’ rapid —
destruction under the influence of external heat. This util
ization of the things to be refrigerated as a medium of insula-
_tion and a3 a means of enhancing the efficiency of the refrig-
erant was one wholly novel phase of Slate’s invention.

TuirD: He utilizes the cold, evolved gas in three ways: .
as a refrigerant, as a heat-insulator, and as a heat- 7
‘we point out more in detail in a moment.

Fourtu: He adds another wall of insulation by Me
ing the whole ‘in an saa casing made of, or comprising,
heat-insulating material. Besides serving as a-further in- —
Sulation, this outer casing largely confines the cold gas to
hold it in refrigerating and insulating relation to the con-
tents and, in addition, unifies the embodiment of the inven-
-tion and maintains all of the cooperating: elements. in their .
intended relationships.

Those «re the ‘things and relationship specified in the
claims (pp. 7-8, supra). -This relationship between the
elements results in the eae actions and reactions
taking place:

-

First: Heat entering through the. walls of the outer ‘or
enclosing container is slowly transmitted by conduction
through the mass. of foodstuff to the solid catbon dioxide.

~~

: -_ —
- 2 Ma
FT ee siiaiatibled catia de | Ta o rime a @
. j

A ‘

i °
Since the foodstuff is a poor conductor of heat, it serves as |
an excellent insulator.

Srconp: As the solid absorbs heat, it gives off about 500
yolumeés of gas for each unit volume of the solid (p. 142, fol.
205). The more rapidly the solid absorbs heat the more
rapidly it turns into gas. The gas given off is extremely
cold, 110° below zero, Fahrenheit. ‘ ;

Tuep: The gas continuously flows through the entire
mass of foodstuff. Since the gas is much heavier than air,
it sinks to the lowermost parts of the outer container and
displaces air upwardly. Eventually the cold gas completely

-" fills all the spaces within the outer. container, envelops all

' the foodstuff, and effectively refrigerates even those portions
of the foodstuff most remote from the solid CO, (p. 147).

FourTH: Since the gas is an excellent heat insulator, and
since’ it completely fills all spaces or yoids within the outer
container, it is evident that it performs a definite function in
shielding both .the foodstuff and the solid carbon dioxide
from exterior heat (p. 147). | :

FirTH : Since the gas is constantly being evolved from the
solid, a continuous flow of cold gas keeps the outer container
and the interstices between the parcels of foodstuffs always
- filled with a bath of gas that is constantly moving outward,

constantly absorbing heat as it flows. This produces a valu-—
able purging effect in that the gas receives and bodily trans-
ports, so to speak, the absorbed heat from the’interior of the
outer container to the outside atmosphere (p: 150).

SixTH: One of the most striking things about Slate’s.
apparatus is that it automatically and with extreme sensi-
tiveness responds to changes in external temperatures. For
example, if externa] temperature increases materially, heat
increasingly penetrates the walls of the outer container, and -

_/ its effect slowly penetrates to the solid carbon dioxide. The
result is, that the speed of evolution of gas frem the latter is _
jncreased—the gas flows*at greater speed and in greater
volume through the interstéces of the foodstuff and into the
outer atmosphere—with the effect of enhancing the refrig. -

--erating action oe, with the penetration of heat .
‘ from the outside (p. 151).

The solid carbon dioxide is'an essential and distinctive °
element in the new apparatus in which the cold gas evolved
from‘ the solid’ carbon dioxide is utilized in an efficient
manner. It is the. presence of the solid carbon dioxide in the
combination and its essential cooperative relationship with
the.other elements. which constitute Slate’s invention, dis-
tinguish it from all preceding knowledge and teachings, and
establish its usefulness.

That what the sitentae here did wal ict obvious, would
seem to bé apparent from the facts that,

~First, although others had had the idea of using solid
- carbon dioxide as a refrigerant, they had proposed to use it .
as water ice had been: used and merely in substitution for
water ice; none of them had conceive@ that it might ‘advan-
tageously be used in such a manner gp to take advantage of
. the very characteristics which differ@Mtiated it from water
ice (see pp. 13-18, infra) ; and ae:
Second, the results achieved clearly show that what Slate —
did was essentially different from what had preceded. Prior |
to his time it was well known that solid carbon dioxide had .
a refrigerant value nearly twice as great as water ice, and -
it seemed. obvious to the prior workers that its refrigerating
‘efficiency could not exceed that. - But Slate so used the carbon
dioxide as to cause it'to have a much greater, and entifely
unsuspected, efficiency (p. 8, supra; 16, infra). He did a
it ‘was ‘obvious could not be done.

.
.
. ’ ‘
ev ; M
e ° .
OF Ao ore anrapeatlietn ne ’ - S aga ageale A he FOG IIO LG Fe IEP CE, onieengey PaETS

13

The record shows that prior to Slate’s invention, all of.’
the experts on .both ‘sided of the case believed. that the
“refrigerant value” ratio of two to one represented the maxi-
mum refrigerating effect that could be hoped for in any.
~ refrigerating apparatus no matter how efficient, and that
. this is far too small to permit substitution of expensive solid
carbon dioxide in place of water ice, for ordinary refrigerating
purposes. Consequently, when Petitioner’s expert Churghill-
tests a package made in accordance with the Slate patent and .
- finds*(as we shall see in a moment) that it actually shows a .
refrigerating efficiency very much in excess of 2 to 1, such
excess must be credited to the efficiency attainable by Slate’s
novel and ingenious arrangement.

Slate’s patent correctly states the 2. to 1 sable
value for th¢ frozen carbon dioxide (p. 3, supra),: He de- ERE F

- parcel post, without leakage or drip, in 4 ‘throw away’
‘paper package. Whatever the distance the ice cream
_ Will arrive in perfect condition, without re-icing. Fol-
lowing are some of the outstanding advantages of Carbiée
over water ice and salt: we ay Soe ese
“No picking up or shipping back of containers.
' . “Extends shipping radius. .
“Greatly reduces express charges by regson ‘of less
weight and bulk and no container returns,
_ “No re-icing during shipping.
“Solves problem of retail carryout trade and sale

_ to auto parties, picknickers, tourists. °
— * + a * ”

“Provides clean, sanitary-appearing -and smaller
package; more convenient for customer to handle.

am

“No leaking or dri (iad of vackeps sad no briny
residue for Dealer or Consumer to dispose of.

“No more tubs and cans with attendant repainting
and repairs.” ;

“Bakes up less storage space.

18 ie a

4

*

‘pach amount’ of Carbice ean he determined:for —
' proper refrigeration of any size package for given
= length of time.’ ” ;

o °

The proofs then aoe ‘that in Slate’ s novel combination the .
efficiencies developed astonished all of the experts, including
Petitioner’s expert Prof. Churchill,. who had been convinced .
and gone on record before the trial, as having been converted,

.. and Mr. Starr, who had for ‘or many years considered jit axi-
omatic that solid-earbon . .
‘ : ° Fe ete
»

Nata conirean woe

ments, which has an indefinite life and usefulness. ‘Some
a - last longer than others. A. familiar instance of this is
afforded by the Edison incandéscent electric lamp, the: ‘patent.
for which was sustained more often, probably; than was any |
other patent. The article consisted of a ¢arbon filament , -
located i in a vacuum in a glass enclosure. - ‘As in the present
case, the usefulness of the article depended entirely ¢ n the
relative arrangement of the parts. And, as in ‘the resent - ,
_ case, the article had but a short life; we certainly: renjember
“that the carbon filament soon “burned out”. ~ But, vhs it
lasted, the article consisted of a real and hinal useful combina-
tion-of parts. =... Fear
- Phe article, the complete “package”, in the present case
- may last, and is intended to last, only: until it has once per- _
formed its functions. . But, while it lasts, it is-:madé up ofa. -
combination characterized by such parts and arrangement i
of: parts that it - performs. very definite functions, utilizing. to
__ the fullest extent and in a new way the heat absorbing prop-
‘erties of solid carbon dioxide and the cooling and insulating,
properties of the gas evo}red from it. .
\ ‘We discuss this point further in our Tay to Petitioner's ra
brief ( pp,-43-50, eer: .

; ‘The Petitioner infringes. i

Petitioner is charged with contributory -infringemént.

The evidence shows, as we shall: point out, that Mar-
_ chiony ( the primary infringer) at one time had purchased
- golid carbon dioxide from Respondent and employed it, under
Respondent’s limited permission, in making the “refrigera-
(4 ting apparatus”of the patent-in-siit-—_—— “--

3 .Petitioner induced Marchiony to buy solid carbon dioxide

from, Petitioner, tore use, in —_— rs apparatus” 7

CES ee OS ERR FT UNIT re
- ?

- exactly like that previously mails iby Marchiony i in accordance ee

with the patent in sujt. Petitioner i is shown to have‘had full
knowledge of the facté and ‘to have initénded that its solid .
carbon dioxide be used by Marchiony just as he had previ-
ously used Respondent’s. . s :

* The primary infringement by Marchiony is not open to:

plausible’ arguinent. ’ ‘The Circuit Court of Appeals found:

; “There can be no reasonablé doubt-about the defend-
nt’s [petitioner’s | complicity: in Marchiony’s infringe-
"jest of the fiatent, which is‘all-one means by" contrfbu-
tory. infringement”. EEN el eee :

Peas

Petitioner sold Marchiony the solid biden “dioxide intend- ee
ing it to be used by him in a an indefinite number
of. embodiments of Respondent’s patented combination, the

Petitioner) thus: ‘know ingly ‘contributing the major element Pak
. essential to each-such act of construction.

‘This Court has stated the general rule, in Leeds é Catlin

a Te Victor Pafiteg Machine Co., 213 U. 8..325, 29 8. C.
503, thus:

petitioner had, made-and slit a iets ele- oe
ment of the claims of the Berliner patent, with the intent
.. that it should be united. to the other element And com:
pre the combination, and this is -"n ingement. %

e
ee

In the same opinton it was said:

- ,“& combination is a composition of élements, some
of which may be old and others new, or all old or all new.
It is, however, the combination that i i§ the invention, and —

* is.as much a unit in contemplation of the law as a-single i
or non- composite instrument. .Whoever uses it without

* permission is an infringer of it. Whoever contributes to

re such use is an safringor ie aaa ae i AS

Now we shall review the facts relating to infringement.
-_in the present case. | by eevee nea

The Respondents began their ‘pasion wider the patent

in suit in 1925 =, as. We have s seen, immedia ly created eee

el A

‘

24

very large commercial use of solid’ carbon dioxide, whereas

no such use had theretofore existed, though efforts had previ-

ously been made to find such a use for it. : .
After the Respondents had, in ‘accordance with the inven.

j tion of the patent in suit, created and established this busi:

ness and had educated customers as to how to make the

‘patented package to exhibit its advantages to the highest. .

degree; the Petitioner entered this business.

The Petitioner was promptly given notice of infringement
ofthe patent in suit by letter to Ditmars (p. 198, fol. 289),
who was pregident of the Petitioner (p. 35) ; and the Peti-
tioner itself was likewise notified (p. 209, fol. 301). ~

The Petitioner, like the Respondents, does not sell the |
complete packages but makes and sells the solid carbon
dioxide to be used: in accordance with the teachings of the -
patent in suit.

The Petitioner's course from the beginning has been
directed to appropriating Respondents’ business under the
patent in suit. Ditmars organized and became. president of .
Petitioner in July, 1926 (p. 35). In August, 1926, not repre. -
senting himself in his true light as a future competitor but
as-connected’ with a prospective customer, he called on Mar-
tin, of the Respondents, who says (p. 21):

“On August Sth of 1926 * * * Mr. Ditmars called
in my office and we discussed the manufacture and sale
of ‘Dry Ice’, he at that time representing himself to be
connected with the Southern: Dairies, Inc.,- I think it is,
of Washington, whom we desired to obtain as a customer
‘for the next season. 24 ‘

Next, on October 15th, Ditmars again called on thé Re .

. spondents. and. requested to be allowed to visit their plant.

As his activities were then known, that request was refused -
(p. 21).

Shortly afte? that, on “ October 27, 1926, Respondents
notified Ditmars of his and his associates’ infringéments; the
notice appears as Exhibit 15 (p. 198).

-

on RE

25

‘Petitioner’s commercial operations began early in 1927, :
and were patterned ds closely as possible after Respondents’. ~
“Its name, Carbice Corporation of America, is as ned Re-
spondents’ “Dry Ice Corporation of America” as it dared
“go.” Respondents’ trade name “Dry-Ice”; Petitioner’s “Car-
hice”. Respondents sell to their customers only the solid;
so does Petitioner. .

What the Petitioner did was to go direct to Sitesi
customers and- offer to sell its solid CO, at the lower price .
of 444 cents. It, of course, was put to no development ex-
pense, as it had the benefit of Respondents’ experience, and
all it had to do’ was to say to Respondents’ customers “Use
our solid carbon- dioxide instead of the Respondents’ and the
package will give you just as good results”. And, of
course, the’ package did give the same results, for it used
solid carbon dioxide in exactly the same way to refrigerate

jee cream in containers of the same sort as those originally ees
recommended by Respondents.

Of course Respondents lost. business to ‘Petitioner. Ten.
former customers of Respondents bought solid CO,, during
1927 from Petitioner instead of Respondents.( pp. 20, 206-07).

Respondents, so-as to save the Court from having to’con-
sider the many variations of Slate’s package in which Pe-
titioner’s product has been knowingly assembled, has taken

’ the unauthorized use of Petitioner's produet by Marchiony, in
two Wifferent forms, as typical cases of infringement (pp. 29-
30, and second and third pages following page 196) which
are Chinese copies of what is shown in the patent in suit.’

The circumstances of the: Marchiony use make it per:
fectly evident that Marchiony did assemble the various ele-
ments of the claims into the patented. combination without
the consent of Respondents, and that the Petitioner after

due notice of infringement did sell solid carbon. dioxide to

‘Marchiony, knowing exactly how Marchiony was to use it
_ and intending that it should be assembled and used by
Marchiony in- the patented combination in exactly the same

26 4

way that Marchiony had assembled the Respondents’ product

in the patented combination prior to the Petitioner’ S sales to

Marchiony.. '
Marchiony’s testimony describes wick use of the inven- .

tion in question ¢pp. 28-30) :

“We use various insulated ‘containers of corrugated . 9
board or Balsa bosrd, mineral. wool, and so forth, and
we pack the ice cream around the container and place
the solid carbon dioxide in the center so as to refrigerate |
the contents, the ice cream. ‘In speaking of packing the
ice cream around the container, I mean around the in-
side walls of the container. The ice creani is usually
put up and packed in pint and quart packages. ©

“This‘is a cardboard carton, one of our usual car
tons for packing our ice cream. ° '

. * } » @: - . * x

“The box [Plaintiff's Exhibit 9] snown to me is-a
corrugated box. insulated with corrugated board, and ,
the ice cream is placed inside the box. The ice is placed
in the center of the hox. This is one of the containers ;
which we use in shipping our ice cream to various places.

_In the brown paper in the upper middle portion is solid
carbon dioxide wrapped in wrapping paper. In this
box the ice cream is placed in -eartons similar to the
one just offered in evidence.

e . * *- 7. * = *

“We use a Balsa wood box. for shipping our ice
cream. This is such a box.

“By the Deait:

as ' 2 That i is for shipping hiss distances? A. Shipping
long distances.

* ae ar * i

wo

“The drawing handed me- correctly. shows the way
the iee cream and solia CO, are packed in our shipping
cases. This is. the way and method which we use in
packing ice cream in the container. : on
“Marked Plaintiff's Exhibit 11 in evidence [see sec-
ond page following page 196 of. the Transcript].

Be « * * * + *

ale

27

“The sketch handed me of a box somewhat similar
to the corrugated paper carton heretofore offered in
evidence, shows the way we used the refrigerant and the
material refrigerated.

* * * - , * -

“Marked Plaintiff's Exhibit 12 3 in evidence [see third ~
page following page 196 of the Transcript].

* *, . * ” *

. «We began using these various ways of packing and
refrigerating ice cream about October, (1925, I er

So all these uses of the exvénttion were being pa on
by Marchiony when he was approached by Clark, of the Car-
:bice Company, in March, 1927.

Marchiony purchased solid carbon dioxide from the Pe-

. titioner for about two months at the lower price of 4%

cents {p. 31). In connection with getting’ these orders,

Marchiony wrote to the Petitioner the following Jletter, anton
March 15 (p. 197): a

“Referring to your offer. to sell us Dry ice at 414
=» per pound, as this is cheaper than we are able to buy
solid carbon dioxide from the Dryice Corporation, we
are willing to try out your product at the price in ques-
tion, provided that you will give us a written assurance
that it will give us as satisfactory results’ in shipping
icecream under our present conditions of’ use as the -
product of the Dryicé Corporation and you .will be

prepared: to keep us supplied after we begin using it.
“In justice to ourselves we cannot change our present

_ source of supply other than as above stated.” |

And received in reply Petitioner’s letter of March 18, as
‘follows’ (p. 198) :

“Replying té your letter of March 15th, we - hereby
__.guarantee to make daily deliveries of Carbice to you in
any quantities you may desire. Further,.in an emer-

gency, we will make delivery to you within two hours
between 8 4. M. and 6 P.’ M.

.
co” _— -
ES Otis ore .

~

28

“We also guarantee ‘that Carbice will be found as
satisfactory as dry. ice in any and every way, and being
; made under greater compression than the latter product,
} > will prove to be a more efficient refrigerant.

| “Assuring you we will codperate With you in every
‘way and advise you as to the most economical use of
our product, we remain.’

That is, the Petitioner gave the written assurance that
Marchiony asked for, that the Petitioner’s product “will give
as satisfactory results in shipping ice cream under’ our
present conditions of use as the product of the Dry Ice Cor-
poration.” And Marchiony ‘states that the solid carbon
dioxide purchased from the Petitioner was_ used “as-stated——
before inthe same manner, form and me method”, and, that there
was no change or difference in the way he was using the solid
carbon dioxide purchased from Catbice from that purchased
from the, Respondents (p. 31).

Hence, it is clear that Petitioner did supply Marchiony
with solid carbon dioxide knowi ing exactly how it was to be
aased, and that it was to go into’ the combination of the pat:
erit, as comparison of the patent drawing (following page
186) with drawings (second. and third pages following p.

196) of Petitioner's packages will show, the patent draw ing
' beitig almost identical | as to structure and arrangement.

Under cross-examination it was brought out that Marehi-

ony changed the places from which le was getting both his
- inside ice cream cartons and the outside container cartons.
His testimony thereon is as follows (p. 32): ,

“Q. And I think you also testified that when the dry ¢
ice people first interested you in using solid carbon
dioxide they told you where you could get the cartons,
and you did not change ‘the place you were getting your
ice cream cartons from, did you?

_ A. Yes, wedid,change. We got the ice cream cartons .
‘from a different place. A different printer made up our
‘cartons at various times; depending on the price sub-

mitted and the quantities. The-prite and delivery was
an important feature for us, and we changed the places

« ‘ ; : ‘ Be ‘
. . 4 SpoPates . * oo those in the instant case, as to warrant a‘iiore
extended comparison. Typical claims. in issue in each case -

age
Tae

31
passive elements,—thé “protective: casing”: and the “freezable -
- product”— to perform affirmative functions.

The pertinent analogy is tliat the Leeds .& Catlin claim ey
and the Slate claim. each ‘recites. a primary dynamic element
and relatively passive elements. The’ complaint in the Leeds.

& Catlin case, as in the present case, was that the sale of the
primary a: element . falthough itself unpatented) with |
intent that it be used with the other elements to construct.
the claimed combination; ‘constituted contributory infringe-
ment.

In the Leeds & Catlin case tlie Court said:

- “It will be observed how. important the record [the
disc]-is to the invention embodied in the claims. [t is
the undulations in the side walls of the spiral groove
which vibrate the stylus back and forth, transmitting
the recorded sound waves to the diaphragm, at the

same time propelling the —. as ‘it engages with the
' record.”

Likewise, ‘it will be observed how. important the solid
carbon dioxide is to the invention émbodied in Slate’s claims.
It is thé low temperature of the solid carbon dioxide, and its ©
continuous emission of. cold gas, which refrigerate’ and in-
sulate the “freezable product” and fill the “protective casing”
with the cold gas, thereby initiating the responsive functions —
“of both “product” and “casing” which enhance a. prolong
the efficiency of the solid carbon: dioxide. ° 4a

Further, this Court said: ——_—— se Mee ot v7

~~ Si Se comparison may be made between the im-.
portance of the elements, as high a degree (if not a
higher degree), must be. awarded to the disc with vo
lateral undulations as to the stylus.” * * *

“It is the disc that serves to distinguish the inven-
tion —to — the ady ance upon the prior art. ‘

at, a comparison may ss made between the importance of |
‘the elements, certainly a. very much higher degree of import-

Aah eaMgnS :

i ee f }
eer Cree, -& ocd hates é
ance.must be awarded to the solid carbon dioxide and its cold
gas, than to’ the other elements: ‘And it is the solid carbon -.
dioxide, with its enhanced efficiency in the specific relation in
which it is used in the claimed combination, that serves to .
distin — the invention—to mark the advance —_ the
‘ prior/art
//Purther, in the Leeds é Catlin case, ‘this Court said:

if «“* * * the plaintiff in error [ petitioner] knew sid
sold its records with the knowledge that, -if its output |
was to be used at all by the public, it would be used with '
. the Victor machine and in the combination protected
_ by the claims of the Berliner patent, above referred to”.

_ Likewise, the present petitioner. knew, said sold: its solid
carbon dioxide with’ the proved knowledge and intent that
‘. it was to be used in the combination protected by the: claims
“of the Slate patent. And this is infringement.: |
_ The Petitioner, as well.as others, is perfectly free, so far
as concerns the patent in suit, to make and sell solid carbon
_dioxide to be used in combinations other than that. of the
patent in suit. That patent is not for solid carbon dioxide ~_
nor. does it attempt ‘to monopstize that product. The Peti-
tioner, however, knows full well that.the product ‘it. sells is
to be used in the exact way Slate taught in order that it may
_ havea large refrigerating-efficiency and thus more than com:
pensate for its INgh cost as- compared with that of water ice.
, We’ discuss hn matter of infringement further in our
_ reply to Petitioner’s brief {pp: 34-44, infra). ,

amend hoek
Iv.
"Reply to Petitioner's Brief.

We shalt-here consider the Petitioner’ S brief topic by topic, |
in the order appearing in that brief.

1. Petitioner, on pages 15 and 16 of -its brief, refers to..
- four refrigeration: cases previously. decided. by this Court,

between the alleged invention in the above case- and the
_ alleged invention of the case at bar i is believed to be striking”.
There is no such analogy ; but the’case referred. to furnishes
an .lluminating contrast with the present one.

- In that case, Brown v. Piper, 91 U. 8. 37, it appeared that —

the claim was for “preserving fish or: other articles in a close
"chamber by means of a freezing. mixture having no contact 3
with the atmosphere of the freezing chamber”. This “was |
held to be “completely and directly anticipated by a prior
corpse preserver and by other existing knowledge* which had -
been applied by the patentee ‘without the development of
any idea which can be deemed new and original in the sense

- and, as to one of them, concludes that “the close analogy -.

“of the patent law. The thing was within the circle of what. _

_was well known before and belonged ‘to the ‘public”,
Similarly, in each of the three other cases cited at the
foot of page 15.of Petitioner's brief, the patent was-held antic-
ipated as involving only ideas which were old.
- In the present case, on the contrary, the idea was radi:
cally new, namely, that the large volume of cold gas continu-
ously given off by solid carbon dioxide could be utilized, in
addition to the direct refrigerating: effect of the solid itself,
to act as a refrigerant and to prevent warm air from entering :

|‘ freezer. And it is interesting to note that that freezer was
one in which the ice surrounded the article to be frozen (91
U.S. 44), as is the case in the known forms of.freezer where .
-water ice is employed. It is such a teaching of the prior art
* that the patentee of the patent in suit discarded in so utiliz- .
. ing the characteristics of solid carbon dioxide as to make it

ss extrordinarily efficient as a cies refrigerant.

_. "The Court took judicial knowledge of an ice cream

ee.

the package, to drive out stch air as is there and,) together
with the food products surrounding the solid, to help to
insulate the solid to prevent its too rapid change to.a gaseous
state. The embodiment. of this’ idea involved a specific ar. —
rangement of the solid with reference to the food products,
by which they, too, took on affirmative function. The idea
‘was new. The arrangement -was new. ‘ And the results were’

- almost unbelievable—there were strenuous doubters who ©

‘were converted by experience (p. 13-16, supra).

. All of this—the fact that, by the use of this invention the

. refrigerating efficiency of the sol#d carbon dioxide cari, be

made to be 15 to 24 times as gréat as that of water ice, though . -

its refrigerating value as measured by thé number of heat
units required to melt a’ given quantity of the’ solid is only -

> twice that of water ice—is entirely overlooked it in Petitioner’ ae

brief.

2. The Petitioner's brief, at pages 16 to 22, argues that
the Petitioner’ s sale of the solid carbon dioxide cannot con- |
- stitute contributory infringement,.on the basis of the deci- |
sion of this Court in Morgan:Envelope Company v.. Albany |.
Paper Co., 152 U..8; 425. At the top-of ‘page 17 of its
- brief, Petitioner purports to state the facts to be bad in mind

_ in this connection. But there are additional pertinent faets.

The Petitioner sells solid carbon dioxide for use in mak- -

_ ing up the patented combination. - ‘That solid, when so po”

_. chased, is not combined with other, and permanent parts pur-.

* chased from the Respondents. The Respondents liave sold

no fixture or machine (such as the fixture to hold the oval ~

paper roll of the Yorgan case, or a wood cutting machine) -

which is to operate-on things which are. expected to be used

» up and require renewal.” When the Respondents’ sell solid

. carbon dioxide, they do not sell the casing ‘of tie package,

and do not sell the food product which becomes a ‘part of the \ ~

package. When the transportation package reaches its des- \

tination, the solid carbon dioxide has disappeared ( it having —

- gone off in the form of a gas), the food prodiict is ——
for. ae ea and the casing is usually thrown away, a8

. a oe ; : | | | lke

it, is ae merely a read: board: éarton ‘adapted 3 tox use e only
once (p. 196, fols. 285-6; p. 204, fol. 293). -In some instances
aight wooden box is used as the casing of the package; but
‘Athere is no evidence that the Petitioner sold its solid carbon
: dioxide for use only in a casing which had once sar used
| with Respondents’ solid carbon“dioxide.* ~
aN So ‘the: Petitioner is not at all.in the heated “Heap
-something like the paper roll to be used for renewal in the .
fixture in.the Morgan case, or like logs to be operated on by
- a patented sawing machine. It is contributing to the mak-
ing of the patented combination from the beginning. -
The Court of Appeals, in its decision, rightly concluded, *
that the Morgan. Envelope case had no application to — case
“at -bar, stating (pp. 451-452) : lane 6

' “Whether the ahs Enyelope opinion be -inter-
preted as a holding‘that the combination of fixture and/
paper-roll was not. a pat ntable combination, despite its ©
somewhat perfunctorily sserted assumption. to the con-*
trary; or whether it be interpreted as an_exception to the
rule of contributory i ringement, based upon implied
license to renew ‘ephemeral d subordinate parts-of a

patented combination, we if not think it can ‘control the

*Even if it had done 0, or even if the’ Respondents had
sold the container of the. package, or the whole package, there-
would have arisén no license to renew the/solid carbon
. dioxide. That could not be done-without destroying the whole
- combination, element by element, that is, the solid earbon
dioxide would. have ceased to. exist,’ the’ice cream in the
package. would have been removed and the protective casing. .
would have heen opened. . To provide’ new solid:carbon di- |
oxide, new articles to be refrigerated and to close the cas ne
again would constitute a complete infringement-—the m
facture of the package from the very beginning, just as in the
case of the Edison electric lamp. When the filament burned ©
out, a person desiring to insert a new filament ad to open
~ the’ enclosing glass bulb, destroy the vacuum, remove the
remaining portions of the filament, seal up the bulb again and
_.. ereate a new vacuam—and this was held to be an infringe ~
. Ment of the patent on the combination of those elements—
filament, vacuum and enclosing glass bulb. Davis‘Electrical.
Works y. Bilao Electrio ieee Co., 60 Fed. si we: C. AT),

36

case at bar. The doctrine of implied license to renew
perishable and subordinate parts is based upon the pur.
chase from the patentee of enduring and important parts
of the patented combination. Heyer’ v. Duplicator Co.,
263 U. 8. 100; Wilson rv. Simpson, 9 How. 109; Williams
. © Barnes, °34 F. 339 (C. C. A. 7); Heyer Duplicator
’ Co, v. Ditto, 6 F. (2dy 578 (C. C. A, 7); ; Lyman Mfg.
Co. v>Bassick Mfg.,Co., 18 F. 12d) 29; Bassick Mfg. Co.

’ ». Ready om ed Co., 22 F. (2d) 331, 340 (D. C.
E. D.N. In the Morgan Envelope case the’ impli-
cation le pe the purchase of a dispensing machine
intended to deliver a subordinate-element ‘which must
be renewed periodically whenever the device is put to
use.” Marchiony purchased nothing from the patentee
except the dry ice. When that evaporated in use he re-
tained nothing acquired from the patenfee from which to
imply a license to renew or repair the purchased ‘device.’

_ It is true that the shipping-box, may be an enduring part
of the patented package; and perhaps this should be
considered as though purchased from the patentee, since
its use in the combination was authorized although
purchased from others, - But to refill the shipping case

_ with its vital element, the dry ice, would be not to renew
a subordinate part but to reconstruct the patented
package. That Mr. Justice Brown's opinion did not
sanction such .a reconstruction is clearly implied: from

his citation of Cotton Tie Co. v. Simmons, 106 U. 8. 89, | ,

’ and his illustration of refilling the shell of a patented
torpedo, to which \ we have already made reference.”

‘So it is-evident that the Morgan Erivelope case is not in
point, because the essential element that the Respondents
sold, i. ¢., the solid carbon dioxide, was not retained as the
basis of making up other or subsequent transportation pack-
ages by the customer, but, instead, that essential element was
the solid carbon dioxide purchased from the Petitioner?

In this same connection, the Petitioner refers, at pages 19
and 20 of its.brief, to Leeds & Catlin Co. ¥, Victor Talking
. Machine Co., 213 U. 8. 325. This case, in so ‘far as it, has
to do with the Morgan case, merely affirms and does not
extend the doctrine of that case. It emphasizes that the
“determining circumstance” in that case was that “the paper

Oe ge

perished by its use, and a periodical renewal was indicated
‘whenever the device was put to use’”, which does not at all
apply to the case at bar. , ea
But this Leeds & Catlin case is of further interest in that
it very definitely supports Respondents’ and not Petitioner’s
position in the present case as we have shown at pages 23, 30,

supra. Further, in that case this Court said:

“The combination in the case at bar is. valid, as we’
have unhesitatingly declared. The function it performs
is the result of the joint action of the dise-and the stylus.
The dise is not a mere concomitant to the. stylus; it
co-acts with the stylus fo produce the result. Indeed,
as we have seen, it is the distinction of the invention,
constituting, by its laterally undulating line of even
depth and the effect thereof, the advance upon the prior
art. To confound its active cooperation with the mere
passivity of the paper in the mechanism described in the
Morgan Envelope Company case is not only to confound
essential distinctions made by the patent laws, but -
essential distinctions between entirely different things.”

So, this Court has clearly defined the meaning of the
Morgan Envelope case. And it is clear that if doés not apply’
to the case at bar in which there is an “active coopération”
between the solid carbon dioxide and the other parts of the
combination-due to their relationship (see pp. 10-12, supra)
and not “mere passivity” as in the case of the paper in the
- Morgan Envelope fixture. That is, in the sale of solid car-
bon dioxide with the intent that it be uséd in the patented
combination, Petitioner was not furnishing merely.a passive
element, as in the Morgan Envelopie case, but has been fur-
‘hishing the cold-gas generator which gives Respondents’
packages, in the relationship in which it is there used, the .
high refrigerating efficiency which has, made them so.suc-
_ cessful. | | ‘ :

The combination of the.patent in suit results in active |
cooperation between’ the elements—not the mere passivity
Which exists between a cigar wrapper and a cigar, a box and
the candy therein, or a bottle and its contents, as instanced

38

_by the Petitioner. In the case,at bar, one element and the -
gases evolved from it.act on the other elements, and they on
it—to perform functions and secure results not involved in
or resultant from “mere . passivity. ” °

The Leeds. & Catlin case also completely answers Peti-,
tionér’s argument (p. 20) that because the solid carbon
dioxide is perishaljle the furnishing of it cannot be construed
as contributing to the infringement of any patent. In the |
Leeds & Catlin case the Court said:

- “And it would also seem On prineiple that there could

be no license implied -from difference in the durability
of the elements or periodicity in their use.’

Accordingly, the talk about the perishable nature of the solid
carbon dioxide in the case at bar amounts to nothing. So
long as this element exists; it is working and cooperating in
the patentee’s new ways, producing new results. e
_ The Petitioner. states at page 21 of its brief that |
“It is quite obvious, of course, that respondents are |
attempting, by means of the Slate patent, to create a_
monopoly in the unpatented commodity, solid carbon
dioxide, for use as a refrigerant in the transportation
of food stuffs. ss |

This is satin “obvious” nor true. The Respondents
make no claim to a monopoly of solid carbon dioxide. They
have, however, discovered and patented one way in which to
use it efficiently, and they are here objecting only to the
Petitioner’s infringement of that patent by contributing to
the use of the solid in that way. The Petitioner may use.

- it as it was used, or attempted to be used, in the prior art;
-° it may‘use it in a new way if it devises some new way instedd
of attempting to take advantage of the one way covered by
the — in suit.

3. But the Petitioner urges, at pages 22-24 of its brief,
that “there has been no infringement to which con
could be made”—this on the theory that (a) M
first: purchased solid carbon dioxide from the

ae ¢ ; °
4 4

— 39 a

and was instructed where to obtain cartons for the trans-
portation packages, and “was thereby, in legal effect,
licensed” under Respondents’ patents, and (b) “it was in
these licensed packages and’ cartons that Marchiony pack- |
aged his ice cream and the refrigerant, solid carbon dioxide,
obtained from both Respondents and Petitioner.” Consider-
ing these two branches of the assertion separately:

‘(a) Respondent sold Marchiony solid carbon dioxide and

nothing else. With each sale it issued to Marchiony a

- limited license, to use the solid carbon dioxide then purchased
from Respondents in the combinations of the latter’s patents.
There is not a scintilla of evidence from which any license ~
beyond this can be worked out:

Respondent advised Marchiony where he could obtain car-
tons suitable for his purpose. There was no privity between
the supplier of cartons and Respondent. Petitioner’s charge

that the cartons carried a license from a is based
neither on fact nor on ey idence.

(bj The Petitioner states that “it was.in -these licensed
packages and cartons that Marchiany packaged his ice cream
_ and the refrigerant, solid carbon dioxide, obtained from both
Respondents and Petitioner.” No. In connection with Mar-
chiony’s initial purchase of solid carbon dioxide from Re —
spondent he was advised where he could get the. cartons,
~ but thereafter he obtained them wherever he saw fit depend-
ent solely upon price and delivery. as is shown by .the Tran- .
script and stated by Petitioner at pages 11-12 of its brief.
Petitioner's contention, stated simply, is that once Marchiony
had purchased a single pound of solid carbon dioxide from
Respondent, and once he had been told where he might, if he
wished, buy his cartons, then he could forthwith cease to
buy solid carbon dioxide from, Respondent but nevertheless
would be forever after entitled to use Respondent’s inven-
- tions. The absurdity and lack of even a vestige e equity in
such a contention is obvious.
The Petitioner, however, attempts to construe the notice
printed on Respondents’ invoices (following p. 196) as bring-

—_—_ tomy Merc atone

~ Nes ‘ TIS ras
VHS Py

40 :
Lt ve tale .
ing the present case within - the devision of this Court in |
- Motion Picture Patents Co. v. Universal Film Co., 243 UV. 8,
502. But that notice does not mention the patent in suit, hor-
have the Respondents- ‘ever, provided any containers. They
have approved them, of course, in instructing their ¢ ustomers
what containers are best fitted for use with their solid carbon
. dioxide, and have given their customers the right to use the
solid carbon ‘dioxide, which they sell, in any suitable con-
tainer. The notice amounts, at most, to-a license to use
Respondents’ solid earbon dioxide in the transportation pack.
age. Certainly there is no restriction here such as. is dealt
with in the Motion Picture Patents case, where thé attempt
_ was made to restrict the use of the patented moving picture ;
’ machines to licensed films. |
; Thus, the Court of Appeals Was ‘entirely correct, with
reference to the Motion Picture I’ atent case,-in stating. (p.
449): : .
“It is only unpatented materials which form no part
of the patented machine which the Supreme Court held
the purchaser of ‘the machine may use at will. Mar
chiony might legally use defendant's carbice in any way
not covered by the patent in suit, but he could not mann -
facture the patented package without plaintiffs consent,
a consent which they withheld unless the vital ingredi-.
ent of its manufacture was purchased from them. To
extend the doctrine of the Motion Picture as defendant

contends would en cased destroy the monopoly " ea

plaintiff's patent.”

The opinion ofXhix Court in the \ Motion’ Picture case
supports this view, fdr it states clearly and inthistakabls,
‘in the reasons for i}s fonclusion, that the film was not part
of the invention (p. 518), saying: |

“Such a restriction is invalid becatse «uch a film is.
-obviously not any part of the invention of the patent
in suit; because it is an attempt, without statutory war
rant, to continue the. patent: monopoly. in this particular .
character of film after it has expired, and hecanse to

enforce it would be to create a monopoly in the mana

facture and nse of moving pictures films, wholly outside

of the patent in suit and of the ‘patent law as we have
interpreted ie

, » ‘ .
° A aaa 2 OP ROD Ret Ow 9 GDR g eens ‘ony eed

- 41

Claim 1 of the patent there in suit, which is quoted in
Petitioner's brief at page 24, was not involved in the Motion
Picture Patents case. The claim there under examination
- was claim 7 (see 243 U. 8. 505). Criticism of the Court of
Appeals’ decision on the basis of a claim not involved in the _
Motion Picture case is decidedly -beside the point. Even
if the claim on a motion picture ‘machtne had mentioned the
filmi as an element, it is obviois that such mention did not
make the film properly a part of the machine combination.

_ Both the Morgan Envelope and Motion Picture cases
fall into the class in whie +h the alleged primary infringer
had derived from. the patentee himself the. right to use cer-
tain patented apparatus—a tissue-paper holder in the one
casecand a motion picture projec tor in the other, This Court.
held that the legitimate possessor o of. the apperatus might
. obtain'from any ‘desired source the merely “pagsive % and inert
objects upon which the patented apparatus. was intended ta
‘operate—the tissue paper _ the one case; the. motion retnae
film in the other. ;

. The dec isions turned largely upon the right in the legiti- :
mate possessor of the apparatus to act in accordance with
the implied intention or license of the patentce, The pat-
enter, having authorized tlie possession and use of the
apparatus, was presumed to have intended that the user be
free to procure at will the transifory supplies of the inert
paper or film. “Oby jously, since the user was held to be act-
ing in accordance with the implied intention or license of the
patentee; there vonld be no primary infringement ; and no —
participation in the non ‘infringing ‘use could be deemed con:
tributory infringement, ; '
_-. These circumstances alone exclude petitioner's case from:
the reasoning of the Morgan Envelope, Motion Picture and

‘Similar casex. The primary infringer, Marchiony, con-
’ structed the patented combination (tsing Petitioner's re-
frigerant) withoat the slightest authority from Respondents,
expressed or implied. None of the elements so used by Mar-
chiony in making the combination, originated with Respond-

| ents or otherwise carried its license.

42

Respondents had sometimes sold solid carbon dioxide to
Marchiony and, as an incident to such sale; had permitted
Marchiony to use the particulansolid carbon dioxide in mak- -

. ing the patented combination. In other words, with each
delivery. of solid carbon dioxide, Respondents gave Mar.
chiony-a license to use it under the patent: in suit. The —
only compensation for that license was the purchase-price |
paid for its solid carbon dioxide. In each instance the -
license terminated with the consumption. of thé particular

—solid carbon dioxide; the purchase-price compensated Re-

spondents for that specific use‘alone. Obviously, Marchiony —

ae quired no continuing right to make a multitude of embodi-
ents: -of the patented combinatidn, using therein ‘essential
operating elements (expressly claimed in the patent) which
carried no license from and-no compensation to ‘Respondents.
Petitioner's brief (p. 23) mistakenly refers to | “Mar.
chiony’s use of Petitioner's refrigerant in the ‘licensed’ car
tons”. This has an. extravagantly erroneous implication. —

There was no such thing as a “licensed” carton. - The only

license ever given by Respondents was a limited right append-

‘ant to each sale of Respondents’ own solid carbon dioxide.

There was no medium through which a‘ license might’ move
from. Respondents to Marchiony, excepting by, and to the

limited extent of, Marchiony’s pure — of Respondents’

solid carbon dioxide.

Petitioner, at page 26 of its brief, has connaietly ad-
mitted Respondents’ whole case‘ on es ae
ment, in saying that:

“As pointed out by this Court in the Morgen Envelope

and Leeds & Catlin v. Victor cases (supra) .a contribu.

‘ tory infringer must supply a necessary part to a com-

pleted. patented combination with the knowledge that,
the ultimate infringement: will, or is apt to occur.”

eve the Petitioner did vanes the necessary solid carbon
dioxide of the completed patented combination, ‘with the
knowledge of the ultimate infringement, since it knew
. {#upra, PP. 23, 26-28), just how Marhiony intended to use.

aoe
, . a
é bd . . . . »
. of A 3
- : a ae 0 an RI ALTO ne te tS pt Nee A NaI
; ’ -
: os

43

that solid carbon dioxide, and, in addition, had been notified:
of infringement. (p. 198). 5 e
The Petitioner continues: 3 s Pa

“Thus, one can contribute to the infringement of a
- patent for a.-machine by supplying a part of that ma-

chine. One may likewise contribute to the infringement :

of a patent for an art by performing a step in the
process. Similarly, oné may contribute to the infringe-
ment of a patent for an article of manufacture by con-
tributing a part or ingredient of the manufactured ar-
ticle. Logically, therefore, one could contribute to the
infringement of a. valid ‘patent for ‘a transportation
package’ if one supplied part of the materials employed
in the fabrication of the package.”

_ Thus, Petitioner admits that if solid carbon dioxide is a
legitimate element of the patented combination package,
furnishing ‘that element is contributory infringement. We
have shown (supra, pp. 6-12), that solid carbon ‘dioxide is a
legitimate element of the patented combination, . and hence
- contributory infringement is proved by the Petitioner’s own
‘admission.
But the Petitioner's brief contirfues, on page 26:

“But no contributory -infringement would occur by
merely supplying the goods to. be transported by the ;
" package.
“In the case at bar, solid carbon dioxide forms no
part of the structure of ‘the’ transportation package; it
merely comprises - -the refrigerant that is ysed in the
package.”

.. Here the Petitioner is giving to the word “package” a

' Meaning analogous to that of a box, or container, of any -
kijnd—a meaning not warranted by, but opposed to, the plain .
teachings of the patent. The transportation “package” of |
the patent.is what a “package” usually i is, namely, a covering ©

material together with the contents.. Claim’ 8 is for a trans: ’
‘portation “package” which is there defined as “consisting of”

a vented protective casing, frozen carbon dioxide and freez-

able products in a specified relation to the solid> carbon

dioxide. The solid carbon dioxide is a part of that package...

_. produce to support such a charge would be very difficult;

2

The Petitioners brief ecibide (Pp. 26)

“It [the yolid carbon dioxidé] stands in exactly the same
category as the food stuffs to. be shipped in the package, :
{ Here, ‘again, is the same misuse of the word package;
‘the food stuffs are-a part of the package.] ‘If the specific
: refrigerant can be considered to be a part of the package
\ structure, then,\by pure logic,-so,can the ice cream that -
is refrigerated by the specific refrigerant. Pursued. to
its logical conclusion, the grocer. W ho sold the sugar and
\. Other ingredients going into the ice ¢ream, as well as.
\ the cow that supplied the milk, would all be contributors.
' to the infringement. “There is no distinction between
the refrigerant and the material to be refrigerated in the
claims of the patent. If one is ‘an element the other, of
necemity, must a] rere

Mit is all a question of intént—which we assume can never
_ be attributed to the cow, and probably never to. the grocer.
Only when the grocer intentionally aided or conspired with
the direct - infringers’ would he be guilty. of contributory _
infringement. The proof which the patentee would have to |

it would probably be’ impossible to obtain with relation to ©
‘such ‘ordinary articles of merchandise ‘as sugar -and, the
ingredients of the ice.cream, all of which have myriad uses
entirely unconnected with the patent in suit. The situation
. with reference to the solid carbon dioxide is, however, very
different. It was not an article of commerce prior Ae the
invention in suit; not a pound of it had been sold in\the—
almost a century that it had been known. The.inv vention ‘i
suit made it an article of commerce and, so far as appears, \
its present commercial usefulness is dependent upon its being
used in the way first disclosed by the patent in suit.

4. The Petitioner, at page 25 of its brief, asserts that the
construction given by the lower Court to the patent in suit
is; in effect, stamping with legality under the patent laws

‘ that which is illegal under the Clayton Act; and argues that
this emphasizes the error of that Court. This argument is —
based on the assertion that “the obvious purpose of the com =
ee of sale. imposed. by Respondents, as er in its

a ea ea

45

invoices, was to tend to Greate a monopoly in the’ sale of

golid carbon dioxide”’.

That is not at all the situation.
The purchasers of the solid CO, from the ‘niesiudinne have’

> been, from. the beginning of the Respondents’ sales in May,

‘appeared on‘ all of Res

1925, licensed to assemble and use the patented combination
to the extent that they employ frozen carbon dioxide pur:
chased from the Respondents. ‘The following notice has
dents’ invoices since they began |
ay, 1925 (following p. 196):

commercial sales in

“The merch fidise herein described is shipped upon the *~
following condition: That Dry-Ick shall not be used ae

except in Dry-Icg Cabinets or other containers or appa-
ratus provided or approved by the DryIce Corporation
of America; and. that Dry-Ice Cabinets or other con-.
tainers or apparatus provided or approved by the DryIce
Corporation of America shall be refrigerated or used

ee only with Dry-Ice. These uses of-Dry-Icp are fully |

«|

covered by our Basic Method and Apparatus -Patent No.
_ 1,511,306. Granted October 14, 1924; and other Patents
Pending. ad

This contains nothing whiel tends “to create a rr }
.in the sale of carbon dioxide”.
There is nothing in the notice to restrain the- purchaser

from buying shipping cases or cartons wherever he chooses;

nor from buying solid carbon dioxide wherever he chooses;

- nor from using either of them. But if he chooses to pur-

chase solid carbon dioxide from others, he. gets no license;
and if he uses it to make up the patented combination, he

, becomes an infringer.

Thus, in so far as, the notice relates to sale of commodi- -
ties, it does not express or imply any. céndition that the
purchaser will not use or deal in those bought from | a com-

‘ petitor.. = °

. Nor is the effect of the lower Court’s decision ‘ale

\ to the Clayton Act. That decision gives to the Respondents no.

Snore | in carbo. dioxide, but only a’ monopoly in thé pat-
package in which it is used ina specified way and to -

ee

46.

| which use the Petitioner contributes. The correct. view point
is indicated by the admission in Petitioner’ s Bbetet, quoted ante .
page = uf 0:
“Logically, therefore, one one contribute to the-in.

fringement of a valid patent for ‘a transportation |

pac age’ if one supplied part of the materials employed
in, he fabrication of the package.” ber

5. The Petitioner argues, at pages 27 to 34 of its brief,
that “the Slate patent is invalid as being for subjec ts matter
unpatentable under Section. 4886. R. 8.”—this being on the
. theory that it is not an “art”, nor a “machine”, nor a. “com:
position of matter”, nor a “manufacture”,

The Constitution provides, in Article 8, ‘that “the Con-
gress shall have power .* * * to promote the progress -
of science and the useful arts, by securing for limited -times
to authors. and inventors the exclusive right to their re-
spective writings and discoveries”.

_ Acting upon this authority, the Congress has, in Section
4886 R. S.. provided that

“Any person who has invented’ or discoveréd any. new or
useful. art, machine, mane{so ture or composition of
matter” 3s) eee ed :

_ may obtain a scitennt therefor. The words “art, machine,
manufacture. or composition of matter” were evidently in-
‘tended to be all- inclusive. — : tens?
-There ‘can be no question but. that the patentees of the
‘patent in suit -have invented or discovered something | which
is highly new and useful. .
: ‘They. have embodied their discOvery in a ‘transportation a
package made up in a certain specified manner. It is a thing —
. which is made by hand. It. is Mmapufactured. It is a man-
ufacture:
. .» The Court of Appeals held, in ‘the present c case (pP. 445.
447):
: “The. patent, if sstatecii: must fall within the
statutory phrase’ ‘machine, manufacture or composition
“of matter’. Rev. Stat.,.Sec. es _ defendant denies
that.it is either. ee

/

a \

_ Manufacture’ seems the most apposite.’ The co

,

have given it a comprehensive definition.. In Johnson v. ©

Johnston, 60 F, 618, 620 (C. C. W. D. Pa.), AcheSon, J.,”

Mes a

“. *
‘ ~ ”~ -
. ~~ GATT ANGS ST eT On ee RRR A ep MAT ATID SR

na

chamber, S tp. 1, lines 67.6%). A pochnge, so made up, using
slid carbon. dioxide ip flace of water ice, would not only
have none of the features of arrangement of the invention of
the Slate patent but, also, would hate none of its advantages. :
The Bam pel patent of 1915 (p. 404) ix for a lunch box,
wind the entire putent. is dlirected to means whereby, upon
‘the me Iting of the waterice used to pefrige rate the box, the
+ water will he kept away from the lunch. The art of properly
using solid carbon dioxide a» a refrige rant could not, and did
net, learn anything from this patent.
| Joscepheon patent TA1S AL op. Ald) shows a device for

attempting to utilize carbon dioxide or similar gas supplied

from the usual carbon dioxide cylinder’ As the valve is on -
top of the cylinder, it. is obvious that when the valve in
opened no liquid: would - «merge from it and po snow would
“te formed, as ix admitted ty Charchill (p. 58). Further,
the specification contains no disclosure about the formation
of snow or solid carbon dioxide. Bo, ob iourly, the patent
ix not in pont. ees
The Eli ovthy pate nts have been dine used at pages 4-5,

supra. : ; A

8. The letitioner urges, at pages 41-44 of its brief, that
the patent in suit¢is void for insufficiency of disclosure—
this upon the testimony of Jones. there referred’ to.

Hut Jones ix not there stating the things found to be
necessary to produce a “practical” structure, as Petitioner
asserts; he is stating the things to have in mind and provide
for in order to ntilize the invention to its highest efficiency
(pp. 150-151), As Jones said (p. 154, fol. 220), “a knowl-
edge of thosé factors would be sufficient to design an efficient -.
package, but an efficient. package’could be constructed with-
out a knowledge of any of them.”

8. Finally, the Petitioner urges, at pages 44 48 of its |

_ brief, that: the patent in suit is invalid because of prior
‘ knowledge and use by. four oe

° i : en . a
Me

The Churchill alleged prior use, illustrated in drawings
(following p. 326) which, however, was made for the pur.
_poses of this suit (p. 62), was merely an isolated use of ex.
perimental apparatus in 1915; he has never used it since that —
time (pp. 75-76). The arrangement, moreover, has nothing
whatever to do with the issues in this case. As shown in the
drawings referred to, the solid carbon dioxide was used just
as water ice had been used ; the product to be refrigerated»

-. was surrounded by the carbon dioxide, justras, in the Drum.
mond patent mentioned above, the product was surrounded
by water ice. Churchill used solid carbon dioxide in lecturing
in elementary chemistry ; he froze mercury and eggs, and froze ~
water in.a red hot crucible. And, abroad, Churchill used it _
to produce low temperatures in vessels in which he was carry. .
ing on certain organic reactions, and to accelerate the crpetel
lization of certain liquids, (p. 4, supra).

He did not do what is disclosed in the patent in suit; and
the work which he did do had no effect whatever in oc
the use of solid carbon dioxide. .

The first of Starr's alleged prior uses was twenty: -four
years ago, and consisted in placing solid CO, arid human .
tissues in an insulated box “in the usual way that refriger-
ants are used to produce a very low temperature in the small #

box refrigerator” (p. 46). The ugual way is not to sur-
Fone the refrigerant with the product, but the reverse.

His second use, nineteen years ag6, was in an ordinary
‘household refrigerator—“we made a test of this Dry-Ice and
water ice by using two refrigerators of exactly the same con-
struction side by side and using water ice in one and the s0-
called. Dry-Ice in the other” (p. 51). Also, “there was no
question as-to either one or the other producing refrigeration

_ in the same way and for the same reasons” (p. 52). |

And his conclusion was that a pound of solid carbon

dioxide would do the work of approximately. twe pounds of
_ water ice (p. 87) ‘and, as he.then proceeds to say (p. 52):
“I was able to make a comparison of the cost of doing

a certain amount of refrigeration one way and doing it
the ‘other way. For ordinary refrigerating a the .

ae

‘eost of dry ice seemed so ‘very much in excess_ of. the
cost of doing the same work with water ice that it led
to the conclusion that for that purpose water ice would
be the more expedient and the better thing to use. The.
most: practical thing to use seria i

Thus Starr, like others; attempted to ‘use solid ‘eaibon
dioxide just as ‘water-ice had been and is used. When used —
in that manner, the advantage gained is so small that the
cost is prohibitive. There was no market for it. Starr, testi-
fying about his experiments in. 1910, -was asked and said

(p. 86) :

“Q. At that time there was no market for solid-carbon
dioxide, was there?

A. Oh, no, It was not ala, Wew ere trying to find
‘out whether there would be a market for it.” .

And he—a man of whom Petitioner’s brief states (p, 46)
- that he is perhaps the leading authority in the United States
on commercial refrigeration—failed in his ‘attempt to do
anything which would make a market for solid carbon
dioxide.
The Lavigne alleged prior | use was a stock promotion
scheme initiated in 1923, which resulted in failure. The story
is that.a cylinder, holding liquid carbon dioxide under pres-
gure, was attached to a box into which led a pipe from the

cylinder; when a valve at the cylinder was opened the gas, :

under pressure, entered the box and there expanded and pro-
duced a cold gas or, perhaps, solid carbon dioxide and thus
chilled the interior of the box and froze water there (p. 100).
It is said that a unit was made up, intended to go in a refrig-
erator, but’ it is not pretended ‘that a satisfactory unit was.
obtained until well along‘in 1924 (pp. 113, 131, 181-185) and
the patent in suit was filed in January of that year. In-any ©
event, the thing was entirely unsuccessful (pp. 114, 184). It
is asserted that: some containers were made for shipping ice’.
cream; but that, also, was after the invention in suit (p. 104).
_ Not only was the whole of this stock promotion scheme

a.failure, but nothing definite was done until after Slate’s

56

filing date of January 10, 1924, and as the supposed Lavigne _
use. was not set up as an instance of prior invention it can
_ ‘not be considered here. Further, its inception was after the.
. Liquid Carbonic Company had begun to supply liquid: car.
bon dioxide to the Respondents’ predecessor, The Prest-Air

Corporation, for the manufacture - of solid carbon dioxide - —

(pp. 137-138) for the CeRayerees development of the Slate .
invention.

The Geennsun ; prior use consisted in . proposing for use
and using solid carbon. dioxide for external applications -
. in lesions and skin diseases, and for freezing small _speci-
' mens for miscroscopic slides (p. 118). Goosmann admits.
that, in spite of his extensive writings, the only use that he
has mentioned prior to (the Slate invention) is for medical
purposes ( pp. 122-3): “ath ;

In spite of all the knowledge which existed as to earbie
dioxide, it does not. pi that any of the solid was ever
sold or entered into commercial channels in any: way.

The prior art presented by Petitioner contributed ab-

solutely nothing to the practical art of refrigeration. The’
prior patents and publications of record were mere paper
suggestions of no practical value. There is mot a word of
evidence that any prior art suggestion was ever practiced in
commercial refrigeration, or that solid carbon dioxide was —
- ever manufactured industrially for any refrigerating pur-

posés.

Conclusion.
Respondents’ case may be summarized thus:

1. Slate was the very first to teach how to use solid 00,
as a practical refrigerant. ~~

, 2. Slate rejected the prior sugenetions that solid 6d, |
éould be merely substi sre for water-ice in the customary
combinations and relationships; and conceived, with rue

vision, that refrigerating methods, and the relations of the
bar cae | aia sea i ae

oC 8 AS ae ag reer to

oe sn\ pe AY vee.
dinate involved, must be radically inanioet in order to

obtain from solid CO, a high refrigerating efficiency commen- .
surate with its relatively great cost. Ne

| Slate suvented such a combination ms coordination ‘of
elerhents that the solid CO, was rendered from fifteen to
twenty or twenty- -four times more efficient than, water- -ice—
_as contrasted with the universal. belief in the prior art that
it gould not be made more than twice as ect as ones -ice.

4. By teaching how to use solid CO, with astonishingly
high , efficiency,- Slate created the first demand that ever
existed for commercial production of solid CO,; a demand
(emerging directly from: Slate’s accomplishment) which was\,
the sole inducement to this Petitioner to undertake its in-
fringement.

5. In three years diaiiablite have sold nearly 5,000,000
pounds of solid CO,, about 90% of which has been used as
the essential element of the combination of the patent in
suit—this sharply contrasting with the non- -existence of any |
business i in the sale of solid ms prior to Slate.

6. Thé mechanical combination of elements pinion by —
Slate was novel per se. The idea was radically new; that is,
it/was new to.interpose the food to be refrigerated between
the outer container and the solid CO., so that the latter

/should be “less accessible for exterior heat” (Claim 3 in suit;
‘ supra, p. 20) than the very food which is to be protected
pst that “exterior heat”—a concept utterly a to
Fc, prior art teachings.

- 7. The use of this. new mechanical combination produces
generically new results. Four different: elements of insula-
tion are made to protect the solid CO,, and greatly prolong

. its life and enhance its efficiency (supra, pp. 9-10). The solid
C0, and its sublimated cold gas are caused to provide a
‘refrigerant; a self-insulating medium ; a heat purge not only | |

,08

forcing out warm air but flowing out~and carrying off
‘ units; and an automatic control of refrigerating effect
responsive to temperature changes (supra, pp. 11- we

8. Slate’ 8 invention is eonspievtously inventive, If it had
involved only obvious adaptation of old. elements, the prior
art could not have persisted for nearly a century in suppos-
ing that solid CO, can never have more than twice the eff.
ciency of water-ice. The art would not have waited for Slate
to teach-how to use solid CO, With fifteen to twenty-four.
times water-ice efficiency. . Petitioners’ skilled experts would
‘not have been so astonished when finally convinced of the .
high efficiencies ‘obtainable by using Slate’s invention (supra,-
‘p. 13 et seq.). Petitioner itself would not have lauded s0
highly the “new refrigerant”, in its own, advertising (supra,

p. 17).

9. Petitioner infringes by furnishing .the solid 00, ~~
which is the dominating element of the patented combina-
tion, knowing that it is to be used in that combination in
which, alone, its efficiency as a refrigerant economically man-

=
ifests steel,

e ‘submit that the decision of the Court of t Appel ;
should be affirmed.

‘Respectfully submitted,

CHARLES Neave,
ftir GrorGE C. DEAN,
CLARENCE D.. Kir,
aoe 3 Of Counsel for Respondents.
. December, 1930.

3376—B

FILE COPY

rCLED

—_

. MAY 16 193)

a IN THE-

- Supreme Court of the United States

October Term, 1930.

No. 54. ee,

— a

Cansice Corporation Or AmMeEniIca,
Petitioner.
vs.

Amentcas Patexts DevetoPment Corrpora-
rios and Dry Ice Corporatios or Amenica,
Respondent.

.
—_— ce a ee eel

PETITION, FOR RECONSIDERATION AND
OTHER RELIEF.

Samvet B. Darsy, Jr.,
Attorney for Petitioner

PEED er aren pop etary pre rep +> © yr CRT EESEEy 8 wery. PENI REE OF eg Petree eet Le

IN THE

Supreme Court. of the United States

October Term, 1930.
No. 54.

CansBice CorPoRATION OF AMERICA, ,
Petitioner,
vs.

American Patents DeveLopMENT Corpora-
tion and Dry Ice Corporation or AMERICA,
Respondent.

PETITION FOR RECONSIDERATION AND
OTHER RELIEF.

To the Honorable, The Chief Justice and Associate
Justices of the Supreme Court of the United States.

Your petitioner, Carbice Corporation of America, re-
spectfully prays for a reconsideration of the above entitled
case with respect to the following matter:

1. This cause, a patent infringement suit, was before
this Court on writ of certiorari, granted April 21, 1930
(281 U. S. 711), directed to the Cireuit Court of Appeals
for the Second Circuit.

="

2. The suit was based on Slate patent No. 1,595,426;
the claiméd invention of which was the locational arrange-
ment, in an unpatented container, of a specific unpatented

2

refrigerant (solid carbon dioxide) relative to food stuffs:
to be refrigerated (such as packagés of ice cream).

3. The validity of the Slate patent was denied by peti-
tioner on the following grounds, among others:

(a) Because the locational arrangement of an
unpatented refrigerant, relative to unpatented mate- .
rials to be refrigerated, in an unpatented container,
did not’ constitute patentable subject matter.

(b) Because the claimed invention was not pat-
‘entable under Section 4886 R. 8. ,

(¢c)’ Beeause of anticipation..

_ | 4 The case was briefed, argued, and submitted to this
Court, and on March 9th, 1931, this Court, speaking through
Mr. Justice Branveis, announced its decision reversing the
judgment of the Court’ of Appeals for the Second Circuit.

D. _ Although the opinion of this Court expressly pointed —
out that the validity of the patent was one of the issues
raised, this Court did not expressly pass on that question,
“but ruled, in effect, that the patent owner could not employ
the patent to secure a limited monopoly in the unpatented
refrigerant, ‘solid carbon dioxide:

6. On or about the 10th of March, 1931, one-day after
the opinion of this Court was announced, the Dry Ice Cor-
poration released to the public press a statement relative
to the decision of this Court in this catise.. This statement
is reproduced in full ih the appendix hereof (p. I). As
appears from an inspection thereof, the statement was care-
fully, worded to convey, and did convey to the public press,
that the Slate patent in suit No. 1,595,426 was sustained by
this Court as valid. As a'result, there appeared in the morn-

ing edition of the New’ York American of March 11, 1931
(reproduced in’ full in the appendix hereof, p. ILI) the news
item encaptioned in ‘large type ‘‘Dry Ice Corp. Patent
Monopoly Sustained’’, In the afternoon issue of the New °
York Evening Post of the same date (reproduced in full in
the appendix hereof, p. IV) a similar news item appeared
under the heading ‘‘Dry Ice Plans to Sue’’. ' Included in
the news item is the statement ‘‘The Supreme Court re-
cently upheld the patents of the company in its suit against .
the Carbice Corperation’’. In the Wall Street Journal of
Wednesday morning, March 11, 1931 (reproduced in the
appendix: hereof, p. V), appears an article to the same
-. effect urrder the caption ‘‘ Dry Ice to File New Patent Suit’’.

7, The statemént of the Dry Ice Corporation released -
to the publie press indicates the commencement of and-an .
intention. to continue a wide campaign of intimidation by
patent infringement suit, undér the Slate patent, and threat
thereof, to-users of solid carbon dioxide. Quite obviously
such intimidating threats and infringement suits will be
directed only to customers of petitioner and those who do —
not acquire their unpatented refrigerant from the Dry Iee

Corporation. t

8. Thus, due to the fact that the Court did not pass
upon, the validity of the patent, Respondent is put in a
position, stated by it to be with the sanction and approval
of this Court, whereby it can institute a mass of vexatious
litigations, and wage a campaign of intimidation to accom-
plish indirectly. what this Court has. held it cannot directly
accomiplish, viz.: establish a limited monopoly in the manu-
facture and sale of the unpatented refrigerant, solid carbon
- dioxide, for use. in connection with the transportation of
food stuffs. ,

4

- patent No. 1,595,426.

;

WHEREFORE YOUR PETITIONER PRAYS:

_ (a) Fora reconsideration of the case to.the extent that
this Court rule on the validity of the patent.

(b) That the mandate of the Court include’ direction
‘to the District’ Court to enter a decree of invalidity of Slate

(ec) For such other or additional relief as: to the Court
may-seem just, or the circumstantes warrant. —

Tnasmuch-as the’ issue of validity of the Slate patent
has been briefed by both Petitioner. and Respondent, and
was orally argued before the Court, an oral rehearing j is *
not necessary or requested by this petition, unless the
Court desires oral argument on the point.

a s

Respectf ully submitted,

Samuet E. Darsy, Jr.
' Attorney for Petitioner.

Dated, New. York, N. Y., March 14, 1931.

OO
‘ .

‘says:

Srate or New York,
County or New York,

Samven E. Darry, Jr., being duly sworn, deposes and

That he is the attorney for petitioner herein; that he |
prepared the foregoing petition and that the allegations”
thereof are true as he verily believes; and the petition is

~ presented in good faith and not: for delay.

- Samvuen E. Dany, Jr. |

‘Subscribed and sworn to before aut :

this 14th day’ of March, 1931.

Rose A. BaTTERMAN, :
Notary Public, New York County.
N. Y. Co. Clk’s No. 64, Reg. No. 2B44.

‘” Commission expires March 30, 1932.

[szaL]

.
* .

a

eR /
- « Gdiate Release

one ad >; oryiee Corperation of

3 * lof Yanderbilt “Vermme ,

é
a a

~~ ft : Ow Lork, NH °y
7
‘ ° °
' \
= \
ao
‘i ’ . \
fe e
. v .
.
. .
F 5 a a an ; ye at 5 =e
me ndn, aren", 1931, the Supreme Court
1 : - > 2 _— _— ”~
hended: dow tS decision in the suit bre Sy the Drylee
AGE ~~ : e oy
. = ’ Y _—_—_
% . = y »"s i S . £ wh. A a > on ee
vorpemat.er.;.under ore of “ts ‘ane undred a Gita arainst
. Z « +: . s
+, Som) jan Carr: rat ‘mali
w.é var vic Veit ws ll.e ; +
- . e
: i oi as — 3 * ’ 5 £ °
g 4¥, tne,.same suit, the revierail Circuit Ceurt
" BB & Appeals pkh. the-naccuns veiid, aud that holding of
hie . P : -
i AE . : ° ; . = } ‘ ; “. — :
wallcity wak nco+ MLIEUVOGA .¥ the S ipreme Court Gecision,.
. . . * :
: . /
* ® e
is fer a oe cnlar kinig ot a peelare enmlov nO Scelid carbcn
- 4 . © * . ss
é 4 i
] SAYvchHeEe °
. NSPE ¢
: 4 > = ‘ 77 - » “6 : -
. } “2:00 the validit:: of tre ve ent, «& sustained
~~ + 4 . ° @ : . am e % « -
7 the Pom yneals,: las not beer ‘istutoed, the Drvice
4 « - @ . ’ .

. YOrns og oe ~"> = ¢ a ‘
anevoeay 23 Orcea to seek its renecdies. for infrince-
ere , i ie 1@ ee mh, Bea “ 32 2 2 “qe Pa) =

ee’ [ekS patent by suince Clrectl:- arcinst the user -of f
ns | : ; :
‘ans 4 4 Gore . ' ; i i
Ohad cabs ONLAE Vier nestle natente “"acvage- witnout
: ° il yk .
Ana; : bY . . » - .
~2 Cli [> + ~ ee ’ _ > axe ~~ ae 2 o 5 . . e - = : % - ‘

“he urylee Corporsiton of “mertens :
"fete Rerat lor. .of rai lpond ears, trucks, si Ships ard eee
| packages for mail and express shipmen t. E it is of. se ar id.
“proving o Sepertanre in ¢, © rei niverstod soups meat,

z

fish, ice cream, milk, frozen foods ar 1 many other peri shab] te-

products, m2 rin the vear, past avprox is ‘ately 30,000 ols of

“DRY*TCE" were used i: the United Sta ates, Tn its dect son,

ckted above, the y &.Chreutt’ court of: Appeals pointed “out that

the’ “Dry Hee Corhoration had. "ones, ted a-new in dustry", ; e

reg -_ .
-
» * *
-e
‘ - id
s
. rs . .
° .
‘ e e
. . -
¢ . . .
. , i
: °
° ’ os
‘ ¢
e
. ° ol °
- ;
R F ° °
°
4 . ? - ‘
* - .
. ow) ~*% -
. ad “i
™ ; ° \ ~
“ e
+ - -
: > .
»
: JZ
} et > :
. é .
. F :
. $ »
*. é °
?
= *
s
“- ° ,

II]. e

| -
New York American, March 11, ri |:

_ Dry Ice Corp. Patent ‘
f Monopoly Sustained oe

= _+43-_D.- Shfall. vice- ‘esulent of |
Drv -Tve Corporat ians. comment -

‘NE relative ta the Procedure
necessary 'O protect company’:

pa'ent right. declared yesterday: |
Since the validity of the I

he upon the Supreme Court ir

o

Paient. as Sustained by the
Court of \ipeals, has not been
disturbed. che Dry Ice Corpora- -
tions are now forced to seek | :
* their remedies for infringement oe

of this patent by suing directly [

ee ce
-
-
cv
~
¢
se]
fe)
a
s
>
; ; &
=
a
—
=
&
6
&
&
ee ee

f
| In no way was the true patent
Mononaly limited or curtailed,” |

es

, * . >
; ®
.
b ~
P ¢
4s 6 ;
s
° .
. .
t
. xf ”
«
-
. 3 3 ° 7
:
s .
i
*
:
,
. “ .
-
*.
;
*.)
« °@ °
7 ae ——_—_——__—_—_——"» .
:
oe ‘ >» .
:
é *
‘
e /
. ° a
o, . -
, ¢
:
=
a —— ae .
RS Tae SALINAS ee as
- J
* ° ;
e .
é
-
:
:
.

~—\not to sue consumers, but had pre

me

DRYICE PLANS TO SUE

I
| Threatens to ‘Take Leen Action for:,

New York Evening Post, March 11, 1931.

Patent Infringement ane?

The Qryice Corporation of America.
|, {Mn A statement issued today, indicated
,it would take legal action- for infringe-
i|ment of‘ its patents against users of ~
,SOlid carbon. dioxide making patented

| packages without a license.

The Supreme Court recently upheid |
the patents of the company ‘in its suit.
‘against + the Carbice—Cerporation. t
|} “Since the validity of the patent. as
;Sustained by the Court of Appeals, has
‘not been - disturbed,”- the company .
‘stated, “the Drylce corporations are -
‘now forced to seek their bemedies for
infringement of this patent. by suing °
| directly against the user of solid carbon |
dioxide who makes the patented pack- :
‘age without license.
| “The Drylce corporations had desired.

_{to confine their infringement suits to
those who séjl solid carbon dioxide for
‘infringing use. But, as we interpret the,
decision, the Supreme Court disapproves
that procedure. and indicates that the
proper way .to enforce the. patené
monopoly is by directly suing those whe
use solid carbon dioxide in the patented
combination without licenre:”

°
. > 6
°° . .
: .
a F .
°
- ; :
: 3 : s
° . ai . : .
.
a ;
: ca
«he : e
*e
- °
sd ”
ke ee -
*
Dy , é
t .
.
°
7 .
»
™~ re
“
a. 2
‘)
. e
* yf, ;
. ASS
7s x ’ :
0 ‘ y
: a Ae : ;
ie ey
. “a
° a
2 -
oe:
bal
s : y H
. f .
. ‘ i
. ‘ ‘. s .
. bd 2 et
« .
. . : : q
\
rs .
t

’ -
4

‘ .
: .
; . .
. °
a is
. -
o 7 . . *
-
vo oe
‘ os a
. A. ry
ve 4
4
‘ * : Ps
nl as . :
‘ fare ;
. 4
°
. 7h
- 7 ° -
«
. my
.
. a P
en
“
.
*?*
.
‘ ’
. F : ;
: ie . . e
. nm .
. . x
.
4
° .
‘ \ . ‘
a -
.
/ ts
. . ¥ aod
* ,
. | . ‘
* =
. ‘4

ay Wall Street démrnel, March 11, 1931. . fi
ee PERO aaa = aca eR Sl
DRY ICE TO FILE.
~NEW PATENT SUIT
+ Official of the Company’ Says “Action
Will Be ‘Taken Against
\ the Consumer. *

‘

’
geet. Sy Slane -aeneen,

|
WE

mas. : oN A
. J.D Small; vice president af DryIce Corp. |.-- ° ——
| of America, issued the following statement: it aie
‘| “On “Monday, March 9. 1931, the Supreme, -
‘| Court handed down its decision in the suit
brought _by the’ Dryice Corp.,, ‘under. ‘one
~~of its one hundred patents, against the Carbice |
_Gorp. oe au : i -——
| “In thé same suit, the Federal Circuit Court | - oe \ F
. of. Appeals held the patent valid, ano ihat.hold- | Les
| ing of’ validity was not disturbed by the Su-'°

|preme Court decision. , | |
“The Supreme Court said that the invention |
. Claimed is for a particular kind of a package |
employing solid-carbon dioxide “in a new coni- | Ste
‘I¢nation and pointed out that if the patent is)
| valid the owner can, of course, prohibit entirely |
/the manufacture, sale or use of such packages |
or can grant licenses. :

| "Since thé validit} of the patent, as sus-

| tained by the court of Appeals, has not been ti
disturbed, the DrylIce- Corporations are now; .
| forced to seek their remedies for infringement
of this patent by suing directly against the user
of solid carbon dioxide who makes the’ patented |.
package without license. For this purpose a
“new suit is being filed immediately. Sen 4
‘' “The DryIce Corporation$ had desired not to
Sue consumers, but had preferred: to confine their.
infringement Suits to those who sell-solid carbon |
_ dioxide for infringing use: -But, as we interpret | ane
the decision, the Supreme Court disapproves
that procedure, and indicates that the proper”
way to enforce the patent monopoly is by di-|
rectly suing those who use Solid carbon dioxide
‘in the patented combination without license. Ia
no way was the true patent: monopoly limited or
_ curtailed. = Ae RGe. ae
“Since the validity of the patent remains un- |”
disturbed, the Supreme Court decision is bene-| _. -

_

¢

~ficialto—the- DryIce Corporations because it
designates a proper procedure for protecting the |

company’s valuable patent rights.”

lite - - . “-

—

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386007_0501%3A06. Public record. Not legal advice.
