# Respondents Brief — American Fruit Growers, Inc. v. Brogdex Co.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386007_0498%3A09

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Respondents Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1931
- **Citation:** 283 U.S. 1

## Text

Rae

“FILE copy | AN 6

-
|
‘Broapax CoMPANY, . te SM ee
eer Plaintig.

BRIEF FOR RESPONDENT.

This case is before this Court on certiorari to the Circuit —
Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. The opinion of the
District. Court is reported in 21 F. (2d) 110-(Vol. I, 16),
and that of the Circuit Court of Appeals in a F. (2d)
106 (Vol. I, 571). )
The litigation began nearly five years ago, when suit was
brought in the District Court of Delaware for infringement
of the respondent’s Brogden & Trowbridge patent No. 1,529,-
461, relating to the preparation of fresh fruit for the market
in order to avoid or minimize losses from decay. The trial,

- which followed the taking of numerous depositions (mostly
on behalf of petitioner) in Florida and California, occupied
. Six days in open court. The District Court found for plain-
tiff in every particular. On appeal the entire situation was
reviewed and discussed at length before the Third Circuit:
Court of Appeals which affirmed the District Court in all
‘respects. Among the four judges who thus passed upon the ~
case below there was complete unanimity of opinion. There
haye been no conflicting decisions in any Circuit.

)
=

i eer Fruit Growers, Ine, the netitionnn-de ‘fenilant,.
is a powerful commercial fruit packing and marketing con
_ cern whose ac tivities in the business of handling fresh fruits
- and vegetables. are pational in scope (Vol. 1, 137, 285).
On. the petition for certiorarnt, the State of Florida files a. ;
brief amicus curia, and associated with if, in thut brief,
P sioent Florida Citrus Growers Clearing Hotse Association,
described on page 1 of the brief-as “the largest association.
of organizations and shippers engaged in the raining, se Hing
and distribution of citrus) friite in Florida, handling over:
SO per cent of the entire citrus crop of F lirida.”
The Department of Agriv ulture, re presented by the United.
‘States, also filed a brief, amicus curur, on the petition for
_cértiorari, The Department has been extensively relied upon. -
_ by petitioner for assistance throughout, this litigation. -In-”
its answer to the complaint, “petitioner pleaded, as one.of
its defenses, prior invention by Department workers (Vol 1,
12). At the trial, six witnesses who had beeh in the erp hoy
Of the Department for pe rinmls varying from five to nineteen, |
years, testified for petitioner. One of them-was still in the.
Department. . The others had resigned, two of them being
employees of defendant when they testified. Every effort was
made to show that the progres of the patent in suit had been
_ developed’ by the Department prior to the fling of the, appli
os yeation for the patent in spit, birt the testimony was wholly |
unconvincing to beth the trial court and thé Court of Appeals.
In fact, it appeared that, ever since the Department had ine ~
augurated its widespread and extremely expensive campaign
almost a quarter of a century previously, in the attempt to
_’ eliminate the enortnous losses from: blue mold decay suffered . |
- by fresh fruit packers ‘and shippers, the Department had
consistently held the view and. taught the.industry through: ©

_ Official publications and public addresses by ‘tx experts ~
that any attempt to control decay by chemical treatment
would be ineffective and. itideed worse than useless because
positively injurious. Not-until late in 1924, almost a whole
year after plaintiff had conducted a public commercial“:

“A Pics hae | ae) ee

ELE TOOL SHRI RENE AIRY EN ORE EON TEI ANE AIR EI RT PR eT NO ce mete once iN Lm

= N

demonstration of the process of thle \patent, which was at-
tended by Department and other EXPEC, did the Depart.

ment finally “alincove v ‘the borax treatment and announce it
toF hiriehat pac ke rs in official ¢ ommunic ations (Vol. 1b, 142 58)
which ahow on their face that the. experimenta, leading to the,
Departinent’ » “discovery " did not begin until ater —
made that public de qnonstration,

Thur, in effect, we here have certain laree commerce inl
‘fruit packing and tharketing organizations, inclu ding. he de-
fer lant, supported itv their attack on the patent in suiihy a |
Government department which habitually (and .p .

- competes with outsiders in developing methods o
and packing fresh fruit, but. whose asserted prior develop: \
ment of the invention of the patent in suit has been unhesi-
fatingly: rejec tend boy othr courts below, without a dissenting
voice, 4 P 4 ; °

Agilinst: thin powerfal combination stands the- ‘plaintiff,
a small corporation, ‘whose chief assets. ori yinally. were. an
_ abiding faith that the fresh fruit decay problem could be
solved in some way, and the persistetic aot inventors sufi.
ciently independent in thought to dareto go directly con-
trary to the settled beliefs and prejudices of. the recognized
experts by determining to solve the problem through chem-
ical control. Finally, the thing was done and the new proc. 2
ess was successfully demonstrated ¢ commercially, with the
pny hat packing house practice was in this respect revolu-
tionized.. .

The patent in ‘suit covers that revolutionary development.
The courts below-have in effect held it. tq be a pioneer patent. 7
It represents a property right’ created solely through. the
intelligent inventive efforts of members of a small business
: organization fighting on persistently in the very teeth of ©
unanimously adverse expert opinion and the settled practice.
of the art. Now that the advance has been ‘made and expert
opinion forced to reverse jtself, powerful infringers have
joined hands in an effort to overturn concurring decisions*of
the lower courts in an ordinary patent suit. There has been

vo.

—~ piss.

4

a

enlisted the aid of a Goetament Department evidently still
- smarting under the emphatically adverse holding of the lower

courts with respect to its own asserted priority in the field.
with which the patent deals. And’a brief has-been filed by.
the Attorney- -Generals of seven states’ in further recognition
-of the importance of a process-which their Depar tments, in;
had been unable to develop for themselves.

STATEMENT OF THE FACTS. —
The setihibecni discribe in this case arise largely because

of the fact, that the large fruit growing localities, California
and Florida, are far from the centers of consumption.

So the fruit’ (mostly oranges and lemons) -must be shipped

over long distances, and any: considerable decay. occurring

before the fruit reaches ‘the consumer results in large losses -
_to this important industry—and the losses “were enormous.

Even in 1918, there was an estimated loss of $800, 000, in the -

a Florida crop alone, due to.decay in shipment (p. 18, infra).
In 1921 such losses often left, to the grower, not more than
enough to cover handling and transportation charges (p.

18, infra). This occurred in spite of the fact that (as we
shall show) careful methods of gathering and handling fruit
to avoid cuts and bruises had been persistently preached ever
since 2, and had long been practiced. — .
‘Among. the conclusions ‘of the District Court and the ©

. Court of Appeals, in their concurring opinions, the following

are outstanding :

“41, Blue mold’ decay in commercial ihiprients of fresh
fruit, particularly citrus fruit, resulting from entry of decay
spores intp surface wounds which are always inevitable to a :

_: greater or. less extent in large-scale handling of fresh fruit
’ from the tree to the consumer, was the bane of the industry"

for many years prior to the invention of the patent in suit.

‘2. For nearly a quarter of a century there had been per-
sistent, systematic effort by the recognized experts of the

5 ee ee,
industry and ‘of the Department of Agriculture to solve thea
problem, but ‘the only remedies the experts could suggest
_ were to avoid all injury by very careful handling, and to
“refrigerate; but’ complete avoidance of injury was npr:

’ tical, and large decay losses continued. ci : e
3. The need for.a remedy to supplement. ee handling

and refrigeration -in ‘decay control was-a long felt. want ‘of

- the industry which the patentees of: the patent in suit’ were.

the first to supply.

4. The problem bare ivbived: nt that with which the
invention in suit Specifically deals, was “peculiar to commer- .
cial large scale methods of handling fresh fruit” ; that is,
‘those methods ‘led to inevitable surface injuries. to ‘the fruit,
- the evil consequences of which the commercial. fresh fruit
| packer had no way of avoiding. :

was a . , - pag

5. The ‘patentees’ of the patent in suit were the first’ to ~~
recognize that, by impregnating, and maintaining: impreg-
-hated, with a relatively mild chemical agent, the rind tissues
exposed by the inevitable surface-wounding of a large pro- -

_ portion’ of fruit. under the conditions prevailing in and
_ peculiar to the commercial large-scale handling. and packing»
- of fresh fruit. in preparation for market,. blue mold decay. ;
in fresh fruit shipments could: be — controlled and ~
| reduced toa practically arin minimum.

6. Such a thing was not taught by the prior art relied |
upon, by. defendant ; “for, ‘down to 1923, it was: the experi-.
“ence and settled belief of the industry and of the long line
of eminent Department of Agriculture. specialists and experts =~ |
in fresh fruit handling that, under the condi itions charac- |
' terizing commercial large- scale handling of fresh fruit, blue’ -.
‘Mold decay could ‘not. possibly be stopped through chemical ia
treatment unless one used highly toxie chemicals so strong .
Ompowerful in their action as to injure the skin of the fruit
and thus render it’ com nercially valueless. Hence, “the

ee ee

6

opinion was practically unanimous that chemical treatment —
was not helpful but harmful.”

7. There was no evidence sufficient t to ore any of the
- numerous prior uses alleged.

8. As soon as plaintiff had introduced the invention into
commercial use, it was eagerly seized upon by the industry
and lauded by the experts.

_. 9 “All this shows that the citrus-growing world had
found in this patent what it had been earnestly and unitedly .
searching for during a quarter of a century”.

This Court has held that,.in an equity case where both
lower courts concur, their findirigs will not be disturbed un-
less clearly wrong; and that where an examination of ‘the
testimony shows that it tends to sustain them, it canriot be
said that the conclusions which the lower courts drew from ~
that evidence were clearly erroneous. Continental Paper Bag
Co. v.-Eastern Paper Bag Co., 210 U. 8. 405, 416; Dun v.
Lumbermen’s Asen., 209 U. 8. 20, 23, 24.

Petitioner's position here, as evidenced by the statements
in its brief, is that the conclusions reached by the courts below.
in this case were all wrong and utterly mistaken. Notwith-
standing the complete agreement of the District Court and
the Court of Appeals in their decisions, petitioner contends
that they construed the evidence incorrectly on every point.
That position, however, is erroneous as will appear from a
review of the evidence upon which the conclusions were based. ”

The long and frujtless search, ’
for a remedy: 7

This is shown not only by the testimony to whieh we
shall, later, refer, but also by authoritative official publica-
tions of the United States Department of Agriculture and of
State. Agricultural Departments, which public documents

7.

are init facie evidence of the facts which they state. See.
Evanston v. Gunn, 99 U. 8. 660, 666.

At least as early as 1902, more than ‘twenty years before
the remedy was discovered, the yearly loss from rotting of
oranges and lemons due to decay attributed to blue mold ©
{penicillium digitatum) was appreciated, and it was pointed
‘out that the mold enters the fruit through wounds or abra-
‘gions in the rind (University of California Agricultural, Ex-
periment Station Bulletin No. 139, Vol. I, 605- 10). In 1904,
. the “outrageous losses by decay” amounting to several mil-
lion dollars during the preceding eight years, were com-
. plained of, and it was recommended that injuries to the fruit,
resulting in abrasions which the blue mold spores may enter,
should be minimized by more careful methods of gathering
and packing. (The Florida Agriculturist, Vol. I, 616; Citrus -
Fruits and Their Culture, Vol. I, 621). -

By 1905,. the vital necessity for going something‘ to
relieve the situation had spurred the t/nited States Depart-
’ ment of Agriculture into activity.. Its pomologist (Powell)
in charge of U. 8. Fruit Decay Investigations’ announced the
feginning of an investigation into methods of handling ¢it-
rus fruits in groves, in packing houses and in transit, to
determine the relation of these methods to the shipping and
keeping quality of the fruit, and said that

“most of the packing house afd transpoftation decays
in both oranges pnd lemons are caused by the common
blue molds * . These molds seldom attack a per- -
_fectly healthy fruit. They seldom gain entrance through
a skin that is not injured or that is not physiologically
weak.” (California Cultivator, Vol.’ 1, 624-5; and De-
partment of Agriculture Year Book, Vol. 1,638). ——

Careful Mandling, as a preventive method was recom-
mended; but it was also recognized that when the fruit is
packed in a house equipped with machinery the chance of
injury is increased (Vol. I, 639). As the industry grew in
volume, machiné-handling became a necessity, and, even as

\ .

8

early as 1905, the-industry was a large one, California aione
shipping 30,000 carloads valued at $27,000,000 (Vol. I, 634).
The magnitude of the problem had early compelled the
Department of Agriculture to extend its activities to Florida
where by 1907 an investigation of conditions in the citrus .
industry had been going on for some time, as appears from
the Proceedings of the Florida State Horticultural Society
(Vol. I, 649). . This publication contains an address, by
the Assistant Pomologist, Tenny, which states’ (p, 651) that
it was not uncommon for cars to arrive at destination with
20 per cent. or more decay, sometimes as much as 50 per
cent.; and 15 “per cent. was considered a conservative esti-
mate of the average decay. This Department -expert esti-
mates that. even at that early date, “you orange men of
Florida are losing each year close to $1,000,000 from this one
cause alone;” and he emphasizes “careful handling”, again
and again-(pp. 652-3). With regard to the matter of adding
substances to the wash water, that expert states (p. 660) :

- “I know of no wash yet discovered that will Kill the -:
spores of the decay fungus’ and at the same time not
injure the frwit. ~

In 1908, the Department of Agriculture issued Bulletin
No. 123, entitled “The Decay of Oranges While in Transit
from California” (Vol. I, p. 664), one of the classics in the
literature of the industry. Emphasis is laid upon the wide
spread character of the California investigation. It appears
*- that the extent of the work required the development of a

‘special corps of scientific workers of the. Department. The |
conclusion is reached that washing should be avoided wher-
ever possible (pp. 667-8, 687-691, 708-9). The authors fur-
ther say’ (p. 709) :

' “Tt has often been suggested that the blue mold might
be killed by a disinfectant in the wash water as is done
with the parasitic fungus of the lemon which produces
the broton rot, This does not appear from preliminary .
studies to be promising or advisable.”

9

Precooling of fruit before shipment is discussed (Vol. I,
724-5) and, with respect to refrigeration. it is stated:

“The icing of the fruit retards the development of
the decay temporarily. It transfers the ited from the -
shipper to the receiver.”

Carétul handling of the fruit to avoid ceilidh in-
juries and omission of brushing or washing wherever this is
feasible, are the a ‘recommendations made (pp.
745-6).
In December, 1908 the Department of Agriculture also
reported on the work it had been doing in trying to, solve
the problem of decay in Florida fruit. It issued Bureau of
Plant Industry Circular No. 19 (Vol. I, 766) on “The Decay
of Florida Oranges while in Transit and on the Market. %
In conclusion the authors state (Vol. II, 776) that

“the decay of oranges is closely connected with rough
methods of handling the fruit. Careful methods result.
in good keeping quality. Rough and careless work
should be expected to cause decay, and the experiments
show that this is true.”

The widespread interest droused by the work of the De-
partment of Agriculture in investigating fruit handling
methods, and the general publicity it was given, are further
indicated by articles which appeared in the Aniefican
Review of Reviews in 1909 on “Improved Methods of Fruit-
Handling” (Vol. Il, 777), in the Bureau of Plant. Industry
Circular No. 26, of May 26, 1909, on “Some Factors Affect-
ing the Keeping Qualities of American Lemons” (Vol. II,
788), and in the 1909 Proceedings of the Florida State
Horticultural Society (Vol. II, 808) whieh contains an
address by an expert of the. Department of Agriculture.
In all of these 1909 articles, care in handling was still the
only thing recommended, but, here again, it was recognized
that in the large scale operation of packing houses it is im-
possible to avoid more or less rough handling and hence
injury to the frwit (Vol. II, 810-11). In another address

10

‘reported in the last cited publication, it is said that most
of the fruit is washed or brushed, and (p. 823) that:

“Some of it is run through a solution of permanganate
of potash to kill all germs, but Mr. Powell [expert of the
Department of Agriculture]+told me ‘that no chemical

. could be used that would ws the spores of blue mould.”

In 1910, Stubenrauch (in eas of fruit - transportation
and storage inv estigations by the U. 8. Department of Agri-
culture) delivered an address on “Causes of Decay in Florida
Oranges in Transit to Market’, and careful handling is again
urged as the only means of lessening decay losses (Vol. II, .
835). In the discussion. following the address is recorded the .
following colloquy (Vol. II, 848) :

“Mr. * *’*: I would like to ask if any success has
been met with ‘where antiseptics are used in the wash.

“Mr. * * *: I tried one experiment. I washed ‘the

‘ oranges with water in which there was a small percent-

- age of salicylic’ acid. After several days the oranges

were carefully examined and the decay was found to be
practically zero.

“Mr. Stubenranch : We tried a number of these ez-
periments in California, and had a man there one season
‘working on that atone, but we did not get any results —
that were worth noting”.

Thus again we find Department experts advising against
“chemical treatment of the fruit in attempting to control:
. decay, because chemical treatment was ineffective and was

proved to be ineffective by the work of the Department.
In 1911, one investigator, who had been trying . various
disinfectants, reported. ;
“Some of the chemicals we used appeared to increase

the amount of blue mold: decay due probably to injury
to the rind” (Vol. II, 870).

So we have here one more signpost pointing directly away
from the use of chemicals to prevent blue mold decay, and
_ the experts were still advocating only careful handling, and

11

' . decrying refrigeration because “a bruised “orange may: be
transported in sound condition if it is iced or precooled
quickly after picking, but it is likely to rot as soon as it leaves

- the car and becomes warm and moist enough for the decay to

develop” (Powell; “The Decay in Citrus Fruits While in
Transit”, Vol. II, 880).

A couple of weeks later the same Pow ell, who had done
so much work along this line as ‘an expert of the Department
of Agriculture, again warns against rough handling’ and
concludes (“The Prevention of Decay in. Citrus Fruits”,
Vol. II, 883) with a long list of “don’ts” to packing house
managers. Among these is the. following:

“Do not try to disinfect the water for blue mold. .
This disease cannot be killed by any strength of copper
sulphate or permanganate of potash that would not be
a to the fruit” (P. 887).

The blue maid decay problem was so serious in that year,
1911, notwithstanding instructions to the industry for some
“five or six years previous that all they had to’.do was-to
handle the fruit carefully to avoid decay, that the Depart-
ment of Agriculture found it necessary, at the request of the
- Citrus Protective League of California, to make another in-
vestigation of the industry (Vol. II, 889). This was done
post-haste and the results. published forthwith (Bureau of
- Plant Industry Bulletin, Vol. II, 888-96). In this bulletin
we find the same warnings’ and. recommendations as to
careful handling which appeared in earlier bulletins and

papers and which had, by now, become stereotyped. And |

the University of Florida Agricultural Experiment Station
(Vol. II, 899) reported that careful atid: is e tae remedy
for blue mold decay.

In 1912, Ramsey, another expert of the Sepdetmant of
| Agriculture, delivered an address on “The Relation of .
Handling to Decay of Florida Oranges in- Transit and on the
Market”, in which he outlined the work done by the-Depart-

of Agriculture in Florida continuously during te preceding
six years and states (Vol. Tl, 905) that

“during the last three seasons the work has been
extended to nearly every shipping point in the State,
and no effort has been spared to acquaint each and every
grower with the results of this work, and the necessity
of care in hanging both in the field. and packing house.” ~

And this Department. of Agriculture expert adds (pp:
905-6) : :

“We feel that it is now up td-the industry ‘to put :
into effect the results of the work as the cause of decay. |
is generally known and the methods of handling to avoid
losses from decay has been most fully demonstrated.
This has been done through actual work at a great

number of packing houses, and by a series of meetings ._ |

at various points where meetings were requested or suf-
ficient interest was shown to warrant’ holding them.
This season therefore will probably be the Jast that the
Department: of Agriculture will carry on the citrus
handling investigations in Florida.” ?

There now—that problem is solved and research work
is to end. This expert further says (Vol. IT, 915) :

“The question is often asked whether any chemical can
be put into the wash water to kilk the blue mold spores
in it or on the fruit. Considerable work has been done
-along this line and nothing has been found that can be
put into the water which will kill the blue mold spores

an injure the fruit. The only thing to do is to keep
the frurt free angi injuries.” :

That is, he agrees with the other experts that\chemical treat- |
_ ment is out of the question because it is ineffective. Careful
handling was still the only thing recommended as a cure «
(see, also,*“The Handling and Precooling of Fruits for
Transportation” by Stubenrauch, a Department of Agricul- .
ture Expert, Vol. II, 922; and “Better Fruit’, Vol. II, 926). -

° ‘
‘ . .
. © iat”
POOLE SIL EON, aE & ae ee - =.
. _ Te ee PDA et ey acetone sf. f. “pF a
?

ry fe

13

But, in spite of the finality of the conclusion, large losses
5 decay continued—and experimental work went on. _
In 1913, McKay, an Assistant in Fruit Transportation

_ and Storage Investigations, U. 8. Department of Agriculture,

delivered an‘ address on “Citrus Fruit Handling and Stor-
age” (Vol. II, 936) in which, again,“ reful Handling” was
hammered into the growers and. packers’ to prevent back-

sliding. ‘This Department expert. thought that packing house 7
- operations were by that time about as ‘nearly perfect as is

possible, but-that the main trouble was in picking and trans-
_ porting“ fruit to the packing house (Vol. II,. 941-2) :

. “If necessary, cut down the output of: your caching
house one-half during a period ef high decay, but see
that every orange you ship is handled carefully all the

- way from the tree to the car. Unless absolutely neces-
‘sary, and unless thorough drying can be obtained, it is ©

advisable not to wash fruit during the warm humid

weather.. There is ‘abundant evidence in support of the.

statement that carefully handled uninjured fruit will
keep under the most unfavorable conditions.”

But, in the, course of the succeeding discussion, it ap-

sagen Sag six years of practical experience it has
been thoroug proved that it is impossible ta avoid all

injuries from tree to packing house” (Vol. IT, 953). Evi-
dently: there were some insurgents who were not altogether
convinced that “careful handling” was or could be a uni-

versal panacea. ‘Though another man said, during the ,

course of this discussion, that “that is the whole secret—
get: your men interested, get them to. realize that careful
handling on their part is the secret of the whole ing
- (Vol. TI, 959).

. In 1914, another major publication of the Department of |
: Agriculture was ‘issued—Bulletin No. 63, on “Factors Goy- .
__ @fning the “Successful Shipment of Oranges from Florida”

(Vol. II, 967), which summarized very fully: the methods of
investigation, information ‘and data collected, the résults

of extensive tests of various kinds, and the conclusions :

nit

ie
reached. Careful hecaditiine is again the only answer to t
cxisting difficulties and (Vol. II, 991-2):

“An injured orange, -whether grown in California or
in Florida, will decay* whenever the conditions for the
development of. blue mold are favorable. A sound orange

in good, healthy condition, whether grown in California _-

or ‘Florida, is able tov resist blue mold decay”.

-

and (Vol. II, 1011):

a.

“As yet, no disinfectant has been found which proves
effective against blue. mold. Extensive investigation of .
this phase of the subject has shown the spores to be so
resistant that any solution used to destroy*them mist be
of sufficient strength to injure the surface of the fruit.”.

_.. Observe again the positive pronouncement by the’ experts.
that the matter of trying to. check blue mold by chemical

treatment has beer thotoughly: gone into and found to offer .

no hope whatever.

Ina 1914 Bulletin of the Porto Rican Board of Con!
missioners of Agriculture (Vol. II, 1052- -4); an expert oP the
U.S. Department of Agriculture tells of “The Handli@® of
Porto Rican Oranges”,,- ete. The decay of Porto Rican citrus
fruit is shown to'be due ¢
recommended, as usual, to stop blue mold decay. ‘The prob-
. lem seems to have been the same everywhere 1 that citrus fruits
were being grown.

In the 1914 Proceedings of the Florida State Horti-
cultural Society is: reported a symposium on “Packing and
Shipping Citrus Fruits” (Vol. IT, 1054), in which is repeated
what th» Government experts had been preaching abont’
careful handling, and one of the members states (Pp. 1058) :

“Let it be understood that my subsequent arguments
are. based on the supposition that the utmost care from “
tree to packing house, and through all steps in the pack-

Be This remained true until: the invention of the patent
in suit. . ae _ ren

~

» . . ,
° ee

blue mold. Careful handling is’ ~

wee: vie es RO err

ing house to car, including washing, have had the best . ‘
management as to personal and mechanical handling ; p
and that fruit with a perfectly sound rind is not inocu- \E
lable by blue mold—yet, in spite of this utniost care,
undiscernible injuries will pass the graders.
“Preyention from decay from these undiscoverable—
and accidentally overlooked—injuries has neem domes them
of my studies.”

7

' This idea was growing, namely, that, with ev
greatest care, injuries cannot be prevented.. Thus,(in the
same’year, 1914, Ramsey, who -had done so much work for
the Department of Agriculture, said (Vol. II; 1066) :

“There gre, however, tw factors-which maké/it ex-

: _ tremely di It to~ continuously and under all/condi-

a _ tions deliyer oranges.on the market in absolutely sound
condition, and to have them remain sound for a reqson-

. able time after arrival'‘on the market. Under commer.
cial conditions it is almost physically impossible . to
handle fruit with a sufficient amount of care to avoid
inflicting injuries of some sort. High winds oftentimes .
are \the cause of much fruit’ being thorn’ punctured on
the trees, and it is impossible to grade out all such >

. . injuries in the packing house. : If the weather following ,

‘such winds is mgist and rainy, there is certain to oecur ~

~ considerable decay, both in transit and on the market,
which cannot entirely be avoided by the most. careful
methods of handling. Another factor which enters into
the problem of delivering the fruit in sound ‘condition is

. the stem-end rot more or less prevalent in most sections
of the state. Decay of this kind cannot be controlled
through careful paced methods. aoe

© Ramsey then proceeded to niadinenie ees "1066-7 ) the
inconclusive results of an investigation by the Department
to determine whether such decay could be controlled me .2
refrigeration or precooling.
The far flung character of the blue mold decay problem
is further indicated by: an article in the Agricultural. Gazette
of New seeane Wales of November .2, 1914,;on vrangee and

a 3 16°

Oc Diseases of Citrus Trees” (Vol. II, 1075). ‘Blue mold
is discussed, and it is-said (p. 1079): ih ie

—

*“The best remedy is tor awoid most carefully any -

- injury to the skin, and then to wrap each fruit in paper;

‘the spores are thus prevented from spreading and the.

_ disease is limited to fruit infected before it’ is packed.”

.

Trouble with decay of citrus fruit in Porto Ricé: is. fur-

ther described in the Porto Rico Progress for December 23,- .
1914 (Vol. II, 1080). The article deals principally with a -

- form of rét believed to correspond to the Florida stem-end

. Pot. Referring to attempted methods of control, the article

Be states (p. 1082) :

“It was not expected from’ phe had ween noticed
that dipping the fruit.into a fungicide would give bene-
ficial results as such disinfection must be very super-
ficial at best and hardly able to penetrate to the poiri
of infection which is apt to be well i the. tissue at
_ the stem’end. Spores germinating on the surface would

be prevented from penetrating the fruit by such treat- .

ment and, as we have noted, it is not a question of spore
, infeet{on- from other fruits. However, oranges. were
- dipped-immediately after being brought into the packing
’ house into a two per cent. solution of. ‘copper sulfate for
five minutes. This fruit later showed @ somewhat larger
percen tage of decay than fruit picked at the same time
but not placed in the solution. Sitpilar results were

»,
ne \
a Le

~-

obtained with grapefruit. It would séem clear that this. -

solution is of no value so used. It‘is not believed any

solution of penetration and disinfecting power to kill the

infection and not injure the frit will be foynd, but fur-

ther. wore in ‘ths —— is being carried on.”

In 1915, there was panties Department of Agriculture aoe

if publication, on “Handling and Shipping Citrus Fruits tn the

Gulf States,” by the Department’s, “Pomologist in Charge

of Fruit Handling and Storage Investigations” (Vol. II, . :

-1097). Here it appears that, ten years after the industry

nad begun ‘to be told by the experts that careful handling. ~

would etipinete blue- mold decay Y; the losses were still enor-

EPL |

Te ~ . as
~ Ps am DasgNverNy: EOE E REBEL LRTI fF Prue sib a me ees

‘ EN

17,

‘mous due to the same old trouble, namely, the spores gaining _
entrance to the fruit through injuries to the skin (pp. 1099,
1114). But the expert still insisted, as did his predecessors,
that extensive investigations had conclusively demonstrated
that citrus fruits can be handled with suffitient care to pre-

veht mechanical injury and to. deliver a fruit sound on the
market, (p. 1101). :
In the same véer, 1915, a text’ book on Citrus Fruits”,

- stated that “the universal preventive for these decays is care- _

. ful handling of the fruit in the packing house, which, if.
conscientiously enforced, will reduce the loss to a minimum?”

(Vol. II,.1134). And, with reference to stem-end rot the

author says that “the application of fungicides. to the trees

_ or disinfectant to the wash-water does not control .the dis- -

ease” (Vol. II, 1135). This publication is another illustra-
tion of the general acceptance, at that time, of the principle
of careful handling as the sole. remedy, and the idea that
chemical. treatment of ‘fruit. in the packing houses 1s un-
availing. ee ee - el oihes
. In the next year, 1916, careful handling was again in-

sisted upon as the sole. remedy, helped out to some extent: _

by costly precooling and refrigeration, and’'in 1917 there was _

only thé same insistence (Vol. IT, 1186-1159). zt
In tlie J uly, 1918, Quarterly Bulletin of the State Plant _

_. Board of Florida, is an a article on “The Theory and Practice
of Sanitary Precautions in Grove and Packing House Oper- ,
ations”, by the Assistant General Inspector, State Plant §

Board. Regarding decay losses in transit the writer of this
~Florida State Bulletin says (Vol. TI, 1165- 6): ‘
eb Sets Re pe Babs e aL S eas Ri Ree AAR ‘
; 5 Ae

ete

Wane NCAS peauiahinmonehes

e
: z = "e
\ = es Ler
i: igs eeen oo a :
4 a *
is CY eet ; rf
%
.

| a es

especially, with a warm hnan: “we had perfectly, wonderful
results” (p. 71). It awas a new idea and gave new and un

expected results. » ms
In spité of the evidence reviewed ‘above, petitioner’ S ; brief

_asserts. (p. 74) that thére was no long: a. need and no > search
for aremedy.:.. ._.. pity

The evidence, how ever, € clearly shows s that, blue mold decay: '

presented a. constant “pr oblem’.; that “careful handling” did

not Solve it; that chemicals were unsuccessfully tried, and
that the patentees of the. ,patent in suit were the first to

‘discover how to combat ‘the decay problem successfully,

That was done by the use of borax properly applied and left

in place-on, the fruit, as we point out later.

That this was, in faet; something entirely . ‘new in. the
industry .is also emphasized by the fact that only after the -

introduction of the process of the pagent in suit did the borax _.
“ ‘manufacturers find that there was a field fo

heit. product: °

in the. citrus industry. (Austin, Vol. 0)—d field created

by the patent in ou Shi eas

. The decisions of the lower’ courts aptly. summarize the 3
settled beliefs and téaching of the art down to the time of
the invention in suit.. Thus, the- District Court said pik: -
I, 18): es

“The decay dsvesth attributable to blue mold amounted
-in some cases to as much'as 30 or 40 -per cent. of °
‘ the shipments. The. resulting ‘losses were enormous.

Time and time agdin the shippers in their distress

turned. to the Department of Agriculture but to their

inquiry the uniform answer throughout the years, until’
- the invention of Brogden’& Trowbridge, was the de
spairing one that nothing could be found that could be
. put into the wash that was effective against blue mold,
that ‘the only thing to.do is to keep the fruit free from,
injuries’. .* -* -* the Department reported | to the
_ growers from time to time that it had experimented with.
the use-of antiseptics, disinfectants and fungicides in
the wash.and that it had not obtained any. results that ,
were worth a aft ,

Carey ees an
The Court of Appeals said (pp. 571-2, 574) :

- “The ravages of blue mold decay result in enormous.
_ losses to fruit growers and packers, arid for years stren-
‘ ‘uous efforts had been made to overcome or reduce blue .
'. mold decay and ‘to prevent this loss. These efforts were
‘elaborate and organized and carried on with great care’
and energy, but the problem remained unsolved until.
the patent of Brogden and Trowbridge. -Up_to the time
' of this patient the teaching of the industry was that the
only practical-way.to prevent blue mold decay was by —
extremely careful handling, so as to. avoid the slightest

surface ey and if refrigeration. ig sine

—~

“There is no question about the need of some kind of
inhibiting agent to prevent blue meld decay nor about
the search of the ‘industry for it. From 1902 fo the
invention in 1923 the entire industry. engaged in grow-
ing, packing and selling citrus fruit, departments of
agriculture of states. and the federal government, to-
_ gether’ with such eminent horticulturists and pomolo-
- gists as Powell, Hart, Tenny, Woodworth, _ Dyer, . Faw-
-cett, McKay, Skinner, Sadler,’ Ramsey, Mann, Holton, |
Stubenrauch and others were ‘earnestly and laboriously ©
in a concerted and cantinuous - effort studying the
problem of finding. something to prevent blue -mold
decaye Concentrated study and continuous cooperatiqn
among growers, packers, dealers and scientifle men who. |
inv estigated the subject ‘resulted in the conclusion that - -
the only way to stop.or. minimize blue mold decay’ was-
- to prevent injury to the fruit by careful handling and by
refrigeration. >The opinion was practically unanimous
that chemical treatment was S not helpful but harmful.”

hs Then came the snadancomet of. the invention of the
ac patent i in suit, which completely changed expert _— and
8 cane dag practice.
d ‘ _ O
ie liveniion of the Ene : = ce:
patent in suit: aia == Ie RT

Two “outsiders”, Brogden and Trowbridge, the pistentiien

‘of the patent in suit, disregarded the teachings of the, prior ~~

a art and proceeded along sacar aed new lines and_ideas. |

oak

¢ «

e

ERE OEM: Santer oe eet eunnets
. 7 oes a
. re é 5 i; °

FREI

. :
See IS
re eS i

—
eee ee

ERIN TRIN Te

Thus, the patent states (P. 586, line 10):

26” : ee : « v4

They etampabatd (patent in suit, Vol: I, 686, ‘line 15’ to

Pp. 587, line 8) that surface injury of the fruit was inevitable.

in commercial largescale gathering, packing and transporta- ©
tion; that blue ‘mold spores would. necessarily enter these ;
wounds, ‘anil that these spores could not. be killed by chen: Be

- ieals.. But they then. conceived. that those spores could be?

rndered harmless by. preventing their develo ent or growth.

re Pate

fruit for market; and in particular it/relates to proc- .

: | ephig invention’ relates’ to ‘art of ra fresh

esses for the treaiment of citrus and other fruits in such

manner that the development of molds and the like upon *
the fruit, and especially the development of blue mold. —

and infection by blue mold .spores, is prevented or ar-
.. rested either wholly or to such large extent as greatly to
- prolong the marketable life of the fruit -beyond what
‘has been possible heretofore. id ne ey .

And fa. 589, lines 1- 10) these patentees :

“discovered,that 1 hy proper tr eatment of ne fruit i in the

| ‘packing hofise it is possible to greatly reduce,:and often

to absolutely prevent, the growth or development of blue: ”

',« mold on fruit for long periods of time, and thus to ma-
terially lessen or even eliminate the heretofore unavoid:
able losses from, decay. Moreover, it is possible to.

achjeve these results without upsetting or greatly chang-

ing present practice so far as concerns the mechanical

ae of dese in packing honses. oe. the modern type.”
_ The patentees point out that their process is ‘applicable
to protect: fruit against blue. mold and “all kindred rot and
decay organisms and diseases * * *” (Vol, I, 597), not to

“all diseases and decay producing organisms to which fruits’
‘ may be susceptible”, as, erroneously. stated on: pages 4-5 of:
petitioner’s brief (see also pages 10 and 42). No assertion |
is made that the process will stop decay or disease which. -
originates internally. ~

These patentees- proposed to treat the fruit chemically

before it is packed—not to kill the spores, but to inhibit ..

Eke: 3 ; oF = oT

their growth by using. borax, a mild and harmless chemical.
°. That is, (p. 589, lines 20- 38): : 50, :

“In gdneral, the process of the -invention involves °
applyi ng-to the fruit a mold- inhibiting reagent compris-
' jing. the | boric acid — radical, . said compound being most
* desirabl¥ alkaline in reaction, ,and being-employed. in
- concentration effective to render the surface. of the fruit - -
unfavorable as a medium for blue’ mold developinent. :
Ordwnary borax -(Na,B,0O; + 10H,0) has been found, °
/- . after‘exténsive investigation, to be especially potent in.
_ -. ts retarding and inhibiting action in this connection,
-*. and this stbstance is considered at present to be tlie most
desirable to employ i i practicing the invéntion:’ A water
solution of borax is alkaline in reaction, but is without.
. corrosive. or other’ deteriorating action upon fruit to
- which it is applied. Boric acid is not so effective as a
_- moeld-retarder as is borax;. but compounds: of boron,
/ whether acid or alkaline, appear ’ ‘to have a specific in-. -
. | hibiting action upon blue mold; and hence it is not |
| desired to limit the invention, 50. far as concerns com-
-pounds. of boron, to the employment ig
stp j . > Qrrges . “ 5 eo £ e@s
. .
, ,
‘
,

“ 29

ing a strong solution of borax maintained at around 115° to.
120° F. The fruit floats gradually to the other end of -this

‘soaking tank to an elevator 14 which removes it from the

tank and delivers it over a chute board 15 to a rotary brush-
roll washer 17. In the soaking tank the fruit becomes thor- ~

‘oughly wet with the. borax solution; and dirt and other for-

eign matter on’ the surface is loosened to a, considérable
extent. The rotary brush-rolls of the washer 17 now rub
the fruit vigorously while warm borax solution is sprayed on —
the fruit as it travels toward the lower end of the brush rolls.
In this way, the fruit is thoroughly cleansed and, at the same
time, opportunity is given for the borax solution to pene-
trate into and impregnate exposed rind tissues and surface
porosities. From the washer the fruit, still wet with borax

solution, is conveyed to a drier 27 in which surface moisture

is removed. Leaving the drier over. chute board 28, the fruit
then passes to rotary brush-roll polishers 29, 31, arranged in
series. The polislier 929 bruslies off any large excess of whitish’
borax residue that is’ unnecessaty to proper protection of
the fruit and t might render the appearance of the fruit
undesirable from the standpoint of the buyer.* Dees

*In passing over the second polisher. 31, the fruit may
receive an application of a very small quantity of a mixture
of paraffin with a highly refined light oil, which is “spread
in an extremely thin film over the surface of the fruit by
the action. of. the brush rolls”,—a film so thin that it
is not air-excluding, although it. does much to . diminish
loss of moisture through the, rind. As the patent specifi-
cation points’ out, the application of this thin film-like
coating of paraffin is optional but has the effect of greatly
retarding the natural withering of the fruit and of helping to
maintain the fruit in a plump and fresh condition. The
defendant, - although applying a little .solid paraffin to
its borax-treated fruit, does not apply it in such a way as to
get a continuous film coating. Because of the poor and im-
perfect’ way in which the defendant applies payaffin, and its
failure to get the result which this step is intended to pro-
duce when used as a part of the patented process, plaintiff is
not relying here upon any of the claims which include the

. application of a waxy material to the fruit.

30°

It will be noted that the specification states ¢p. 591, lines
16-18) that it is desirable that the treating solution contain 3
at least 2 per cent. of borax and, as tlie record herein shows,
it is nndoubtedly best practice to use a solution at least as
strong as this. However, the empioyment of less than 2 per. |
cent. of borax is in no sense excluded by the patentees, pro-

_ vided the percentage is not so small as to be useless, and pro-
vided the conditions of operation, other than concentration, .
are so co-ordinated therewith as to ensure effective impreg-

- nation of exposed rind tissues and other surface porosities —

and to attain-a distinct mold- -inhibiting effect. Thus the
specification states (p. 597, lines 6-10) :

race “Where a.warm treating solution is used, it-is usually :
sufficient for the fruit to remain two or three minutes
_in the soaking tank before it goes through the washer;
but where cooler and less concentrated solutions are used,
a longer soaking period is advantageous.” « .

Similarly, aatend of removing the unnecessary excess of
borax by dry-brushing the fruit After it has been passed .
through the drier,-it is feasible to give the fruit a light rinse—
with plain water after the borax solution has been applied .
and just before the fruit enters the drier. This method is.
the one commonly used by plaintif's California licensees
(Vol. I, 37,56). ;

It is to be particularly noted that the light rinsing of the
fruit, which does not occur until ‘after the fruit leaves the-
washing machine (p. 592, fol. 6) and serves merely to remove
the unnecessary excess of borax, is in no way comparable
with or equivalent to a washing (cleansing) of fruit with
plain water on washer brushes, which was the standard prior
practice.

“Water in the soaking tank: should be frequently

changed, and sprays of fresh water should be directed

against the fruit as ‘it passes through the oe :
_ machine.”

(U. 8. Dept. Agric. Bull. 63, Vol. II, 1050.)

eS Bay Ae,

The rubbing and scrubbing with an abundance of
plain water incidental to such a washing operation, if ap- _
plied to fruit previously washed with borax, would have the.
effect of removing most of the borax from the frvit rind

(including previously impregnated exposed rind tissues) and
‘rendering it non-resistant to blue mold decay, especially if
_.the previously applied borax solution were not very strong
and the fruit had nat been soaked in it for a relatiyel) long *
time. ae 5

+.

Froni the foregoing, it will readily be seen that the state-
ment in petitioner's brief (pp. 3-4) that,

- “the prime question here for review is whether or not
it is lawful'for an unlicensed person to /wash, dip or
soak any fruit or vegetable in water containing any sub--

stantiol amount of borax” oe ae

ieveives an entire misconception of the. matter; and, fur-

ther that petitioner’s definition of respondents’ process

(brief, p. 19) is incomplete, erroneous, and ao mislead-
- ing.

The quoted statement reads as though it were still
thought that all that is necessary is to kill whatever blue
mold spores may be on the fruit; and that, in the process of
the patent in suit, borax does this. and, having done this, .
has performed its function. But that is a mistaken view-
point. ° That is, the borax is not a germicide or killing agent
for blue mold spores. It has fo such power. Nor is it
merely a water-softener. acting to facilitate cleansing. and
-thereby being consumed or washed off the fruit with the dirt.
On the contrary the borax as such, over and above what may
be eliminated from the solution through water-softening
action, is applied to the surface of the fruit in mold-inhibiting
concentration and is deliberately left there to inhibit the .
growth of blue mold. spores which may be on or may |
subsequently reach the fruit. The borax continues its pro-
tective action long after the fruit is dipped or soaked in it;
it is to ee the wounds in the fruit ea remain there. -

a

. . - . . ~~ -
—_ Rom RN PEPE 2 em MRR : . foe reer ate ararggE rine em cer
S °

32

% eee

The viewpoint’ expressed by petitioner utterly ignores -
these and other fundamental considerations, upon which the
invention in suit is based, including (1) the fact that the fruit
to be treated is fresh fruit under going preparation for mar-

- keting as such; (2) the fact that the fruit to be treated is not
specially selected fruit free from blemish, but is “run-of-
mine” fruit which is being prepared ‘and packed under the
" severe conditions unavoidably characterizing modern large. °
a | scale rapid mechanieal handling, with the result that in any
_given lot or body of fruit thus handled the majority of the fe
individual fruits are always surface-injured to some extent,
however imperceptibly and are therefore subject to attack
by the omnipresent blue mold spores at & these paints where 7
_the rind tissues-are-exposed; (3) the fact th that these exposed
vind tissues must be thoroughly impregnated with. a borax
solution of adequate strength; (4) ‘that a substantial, even
; though smiall residue of borax must be left on the surface of:
’ the fruit, particularly in the exposed. rind tissues; and (5) .
the fact, that all this‘must be accomplished without affecting . —
the freshness and edibility of the fruit or rendering it un-
sightly and commercially undesirable. It is easy to say that
this if merely dipping fruit in a solution of borax, bit we
‘submit that the record here shows sucli a matement to be
. utterly superficial and misdescriptive.
‘Moreover, petitioner's evident contention that borax and.
boric acid stand’on a par and are equivalents for the pur- -
poses of the invention in suit is contrary to facts established
‘by the record. and is misleading. While the invention in its
~ greatest breadth, and as defined by claims 1, 16, 23 and 25
of the patent, properly comprises the use of either borax or .
boric avid,.the patentees found that in actual practice, under: .
the conditions obtaining in the packing house, boric acid is -
less effective than borax,’and they é¢mphasized this fact in
their specification (Vol. I, 589, line 33). With the excep-,
tion of the claims just mentioned above, all the claims
‘here in issue are directed Specifically to the use of borax.
That borax is superior in this connection was later strikingly
confirmed by Fulton and Bowman of ‘the Department. of

Sia dia Paa eS orate GS vie NASH G SEMI aa ee
+ % v

33

j jgeteaienne the results of whose tests, published in 1924 .
in the Journal of Agricultural Research (Vel. II, pp. 1226- 7),
showed borax materially more effective than boric acid. Peti>
tioners’ expert, Alsberg, on direct- -examination (Vol. I, p. -
274), testified that boric acid should be the more effective,
and was quite unable to explain, on cross-examination (pp:

299-300), why the contrary is true in the specific field of
treating fruit. To him, this was sins ade age

«

The claims sed upon’ (Vol. I, 597) are. those_nen-

bered 1 to 7 inclusive, 9, — 15-te 187 inélusive, and 23 to 26
____inelusive-———

All of. these Alms except 23 to 26 inclusive are directed .
to the process. Claims 23 te 26 are for the resultant treated
fruit, ‘as a new article of manufacture.

Of the process claims, claim.3 is typical, and is as follows:

“3. In the preparation of fresh fruit for market, the
process which comprises subjecting fruit to the action
of an aqueous solution of borax, the fluidity, strength
-and temperature of the treating solution, and the dura-
tion of the treatment, being such that exposed rind .or
skin tissues of the fr wit are effectively impregnated with
borax and rendered resistant to blue mold decay, while
at the same time the fryit is not’ scalded nor is its. fresh-
ness or a other rise wubspantially impaired. .

The article claims relied upon, 23 to 26, define the borated
fruit resulting from the process. Claini 24 is as follows:

“94. Fresh fruit of w ‘hich the rind or skin carries i
‘borax in amount.that is very small‘but sufficient to ren-
der ihe fruit resistant to blue mold decay. -$&

The product claims define ‘essentially an article of manu-
facture, since the article is not a natural product but the re-
sult of a process by which a. natural product is endowed
. with the characteristic property of being resistant to blue-
, ‘mold decay which it w ould not otherwise possess. The article
ee combination of a natural product, fresh fruit, with a
boric — applied to and | carried by the rind or skin —

ok.

St.

‘in an amount: which is small but sufficient to render the trait

Sra see article is not. found in
natur S produced by a manufacturing operation... It is

—~ therefore an article of. manufacture (see pp. 60- 64, Ps).

»

‘The effect of the invention
upon the industry and
upon expert thought:

We have alteady (pp. 6-24, supra) reviewed the
insistent teaching of the art during the twenty: or more years
prior to the time when the invention of the patent in suit
was brought tothe notice of the public,—that teaching which ;
led directly away from anything like the borax treatment.

- In the fall of 1923 and early in 1924, the plaintiff made
public demonstrations of its process in California, these dem- |
onstrations being witnessed by experts of the Department of

‘Agriculture and others interested in the fruit industry in

California (Vol. I, 43-5, 48-9; Vol. II, 1317-8): The plain- |
tiff’s trade name for the borax treatment of the patent in
suit . was “Brogdite” , and its name’ for the subsequent}
paraffin treatment was “Brogdex” (Vol. I, 26-7).

Beginning immediately after-these demonstrations by the
plaintiff, there is a sudden and remarkable change ‘in the.
work and in the voluminous writings of experts on blue mold
decay. All at once the Department of Agriculture experts
and the fruit ‘exchanges of California and Florida issue
bulletins and circulars about a new way of stopping blue
‘mold which is provimg highly effective. | From now on the
borax treatment stands out as a matter of absorbing interest
and extreme importance tothe entire surpass though never
before thought of. -:

The: first example of this sudden dieu is a circular. -
letter of June 20, 1924, addressed “To all Shippers”” from
‘the office of the California Fruit Growers Exchange by Dezell,
its General Manager, this circular letter being recompanied

.by a “Report of Brogdite and Brogdex Tests made by the

Field Department of the California Fruit Growers Exchange,

ig a ise

| Navel Orange Season 1923-24” (Vol. II, 1312) and sent out.
by that Field Department (Vol. I, 44-5). ‘In the letter,

‘Dezell: says that. Brogdite (the trade name for the borax
treatment of the patent in suit) was tested to. determine its
effectiveness in controlling blue mold decay; and (p. 1312):

; @, ori verp recently, the only practical. method of _

trolling blue mold decay .has been by preventing

mechanical injuries to the fruit through the most careful . /
handling in both field and packing’houses. Efforts,have- /
- for years been made by scientists and others to find / °

something that will kill the blue mold funyus and spores

but which would not injure the fruit. While a number
of substances have been found that will kill both the
blue mold fungus and spores, they either injifre the fruit,
are too expensive or impractical of application, or are
dangerous because of their poisonous properties.” a"

‘ The letter ‘then points out that the method of testing
employed was intentionally about as severe as could be de- _

.

. vised and that (p.-1313) :

\ “The great bulk of our blue mold decay is caused by 3

mechanical -injuries to the fruit before it is packed and
these experiments indicate that Brogdite properly ap-

plied to fruit mechanically injured will control the _

of these experiments showed that when blue mold had
developed to spots as large as a dime
stopped its further growth.” - .

development of blue mold that when cause. Some
the treatment

fa,

The seven-page report accompanying Dezell’s letter shows
_ the large number and variety of tests of ‘the Brogdite treat-

ment- particularly and is ‘clear evidence of the extreme in-

~~ terest it had for the Exchange Field Department.. And the
fact that elaborate tests and experiments were made, is clear
evidence that the California Fruit Growers Exchange, which
had been for years in close touch with everything going on
~ in the industry and very active in cooperating with the De-
. partment of Agriculture in dissemninating information which.

_*. would in any way help the growers and shippers to cut down

decay losses, had had no idea that blue mold growth could
be prevented by this use of borax. $5

-? . : .
bs " ; ’ % A ° - 8
? . . : : .
: : ‘ ‘ . \
os Se ie esters ae ‘ o : , HOSES SUNCENN EDeaes opener ses _—
, en
‘ \
.

53

In Pyrene Mfg. Co. v. Boyce, 292 Fed. 480, 484, the Court
of Appeals for the Third Circuit, in finding invention said:

“This history (the commetcial history) is interesting

* * * for it shows that when the device appeared in

the art it was regarded as so thoroughly useless that it

provoked mirth among automobile engineers. But later

it was accepted by the public * * .* and was adopted
by manufacturers”, (on a-large scale), °

the Circuit Court in New York, in Westinghouse Air
Brake Co. v. New York Air Brake Co., 59 Fed. 581, 593, said:

“Experiments made to ascertain the practicability of
the new use are strong evidence to prove that invention
was required to conceive of it.”

Why any experiments at all, if those skilled in the art
knew how to treat fresh fruity in preparation for market,
with borax for the prevention of blue mold decay?

The result, however, of all these tests was the conclusion
of the experts that “this is a most remarkable and marvelous
accomplishment” (p. 41, supra).

It proved to be the ee solution of the problem,
and went into large use.

As was said in Gandy v. Main Belting Co., 143 U. 8.
587, 594:

“In vielo of the fact that previous attempts, of which

there appear to have been several, to make a practical
canvas belt had been failures, and that Gandy had been
experimenting with the subject for several years before
he discovered that a change was necessary in the
structure of the canvas itself, we do not think his im-

provement is a change in degree only,‘or such an one |

as would have occurred to an ordinary mechanic, and
- our opinion is that it dees involve an exercise of the
inventive faculty.”

And, in Hibel Process Co., v. Minnesota & Ontario Paper
_ Oe,; 261 U. 8.-45, 53, 54, 56 it was said:

“A thorough examination of the whole voluminous

record produces a satisfying conviction, first, that for

> . .
P . . . .
¥
° ‘
IO Ree ee. + ~~ . a — ST 8 oe eee . “ -
>

'

ae

years news ‘print paper makers and manufacturers of .
paper- making machinery were engaged in seeking a
metliod of increasing the speed of the news print -ma-
. Gime. © °
“Our conclusion is confirmed, and indeed the import-
y ance of the issue of fact as to maxinrum speed before
/ Bibel is minimized, by the circumstance uncontroverted,

: that the owners of these fastest machiues, at once upon
Kibel’s publication of his discouery, adopted his. pitch
and increased their product.” * *.

“The fact that the Eibel pitch has thus been gen-
erally adopted in the paper-making business and that
the daily product in paper making has thus been in-
creased at least twenty per. cent. over that which had
been achieved before Eibel is very weighty evidence to
sustain the presumption from his patent that what he-
discovered and invented was new and useful.”

We submit that, tested by all the known rules, the pat-
entees of the patent in suit made a very real and important |
invention for which they are entitled to the protection of the
patent laws.

The Importance of the Invention Is Widely
Recognized. It Solved a Problem of Long
Standing and Supplied a Long Felt Want.

The success, value and importance of the invention in con-
troversy ‘would not. seem to require detailed discussion in
view of the insistence of. the defendants and others upon
using it (pp. 37-38, 46-49, supra).

We do not wonder that: they do wish. to use it because,

as the record shows, it has great utility and has been widely |
adopted by those operating under license. Thus——

1. It has largely reduced deeay losses (Knox, Vol. I,
25-26, 30-31; Wolstencroft, Vol. I, 45-47; Jacobs, Vol. I, 56-57;
Pierce, Vol. TT, 58; Cartwright, Vol. I, 74. 75; Hendrix, ‘Vol. I,
al; Ritchie, Vol. I; 84-86; Chase, Vol. I, 62- —

a ee . - .
al dane ne ate ie es a 2 ee qe RERD =
. - .
- : » :
.

So we

2. It has reduced the necessity for refrigeration in ship-
ment (though some of. the trade still use it). ‘Refriger-
ation delays decay, but causes the fruit to decay more
rapidly when it comés out of refrigeration and into the
hands of the dealer and consumer (Knox, Vol. I, 28-29; Wol-
stencroft, Vol. I, 45:47; Earley, Vol. I, 87-88; Cartwright,
Vol. I, 74-75; Hendrix, Vol. I, 81-82; Skinner, Vol. I, 68-69;
Parrish, Vol. I, 98). The saving in refrigeration is most
pronounced when respondent's complete process,. including
the final film-coating with paraffin is used.. But since the
paraffin treatment alone. was not altogether successful com-
mercially (page 22, supra) and was made so only through
development of the borax treatnient, the latter is primarily
responsible for the saving. ;

ni Bes

3. The treated fruit may, without injury, be held in pre-
coolers before shipment, which is of importance as, in this
way, it ‘is possible to tide over a period characterized by a
glutted market and low prices and thus regulate distribution
(Knox, Vol. I, 30-31; Pierce, Vol. I, 58-59).

- 4. More fruit is available for shipment. Prior to the use
of respondent’s process much perfectly edible fruit was culled
out and thrown away because of minor but visible’ surface
injuries which would inevitably have caused decay. Nowa
large part of such fruit can be treated, packed and shipped
without decay (Wolstencroft, Vol. I, 46; Cartwright, Vol.
I, 75-76 ; Hendrix, Vol. I, 82).

5. Because of these advantages the respondents. process
has gone into very wide use. ars : a
_ Knox, a-director of the California Fruit Growers Ex-
change, and manager of the sub-group of packing house asso-
ciations known asthe San Antonio ‘Exchange (Vol. I,
24-5), testifies that the borax treatment was adopted gen-
erally by the packing houses of the San Antonio group
“because of the remarkable record of the season of 1924
at the Walnut House”, whose manager (Wolstencroft) testi-

. > . : .
. F . .
ree BRON oO ee Ra ER OP Oe atin el tite ° eee omD mee INA SOP eRe a nant Ta
‘ 2 .
° .

iets -

esp

He :

° 56 7
fies at length (pp. 44-5) regarding those 1924 commercial
operations and tests and tells of how they were attended and
witnessed by many men prominent in the fruit industry,
including Barger, of the Department of Agriculture, mem-
bers of the field department of the California Fruit Growers ©
Exchange, the largest fresh fruit shipping and marketing
organization in the world, and Dezell, its managing exect-
tive, all of whom showed the most intense interest, some even
to the extent of personally participating in the tests and
taking away samples of the treating material for further
test. And as a result, the California Fruit. Growers Ex- |
’ change issued on June 20, 1924, its bulletin “To All Ship-
pers” (Vol. II, 1312), based on the results of elaborate tests
and investigations by. its own field department, recommend.
ing the Brogdite (borax) treatment as the long-sought solu.
tion of a difficult problem. This bulletin is’ identified by -
mee. Wolstencroft (Vol. I, 44). In December, 1924, the Ex-
change sent out another Bulletin (Vel. I, 33-4; Vol. 11, 1307)
again. warmly commending “To All Shippers” the borax
treatment which, in the meantime had been “discovered” by
the Department: of Agriculture as we have already seen (pp.
3, 36,\38, supra) and enthusiastically endorsed by Depart: ".
ment experts. |
Earley, general manager of the Mutual Orange Distrib- .
utors, the\second largest'citrus fruit shipping and marketing
organization in California, testifies (pp. 88-9) :

“I had every oné of our association managers inves-

. tigate the same thoroughly on his own behalf and report
the findings. It was unanimous that it was a splendid
advance inthe keeping of oranges and then I brought
the matter to the attention of our board of directors
and they instructed me to make a } contract for our entire

organization. r | , | 13° ee

ne

By the time this suit came to trial, a majority of the
- constituent associations of the California Fruit Growers Ex-
change were using the borax treatment, either under license
from respondent, or as infringers using the so-called “Gov-

4
*

57

- ernment formula”, according to the testimony of Knox, a
director of the Exchange (Vol. 1, 3 32-3). Wolstencroft, basing -
his statement on the offiejal reports sent out daily by the
Exchange to all its shippers, estimated that 80 to 90 per cent
_~ of the Exchange associations were then using the borax
treatment (pp. 47, 49), and all except those licensed by re-
gpondent were using borar alone, without the subsequent
waring or Brogder treatment (Knox, 53). ° Over 70 per cent

of the entire citrus fruit ¢ rop | of ¢ ‘alifornia is packed through
he IF att another large infringer, the Florida. Citrus
Exchange, took up the borax treatment under the name

_ “Zeltrocide” (Vol. I, 104, 110-111; Vol. II, 1424- 32); and
\ the re is also extensive licensed use there (Vol. 1, 63, 94, 98,

Qs
Y. attempting to salnioniee these. facts, Petitioner's brief,
in effect,. represents Dezell, general manager of the Califor-
nia Exchange, as a spineless individual with no mind of
“his own, pitiably Jed astray by “the glamor of the Brogdex
and Brogdite publicity” (brief, p. 95), and petitioner also’
says (p. 94); | og

“The courts below gave a deep. meaning to what was

merely high sg ieee publicity, orcrrsnene A and effectively —
applied. 4) ; .

Assertions of this kind are quite unsupported by the record.
The circular. (Def. Ex. 5, Vol. 11, 1465-6), which petitioner's
—. brief. goes ‘on to imply was publicity bait.by which the San
Antonio Fruit Exchange and the Mutual Orange Distribu- |

tors ‘were lured into. bec oming réspondent’ s licensees,.is the

- ole matter which petitioner even attempts to cite as justify-
poe gree these allegations, But that eircular was put out in 1921,
which was before respondent came into existénce and more

than a year before Trowbridge (who, with Brogden, jointly

made the invention in suit) came on the scene in November,

_ 1922 (Vol. 1,97). It has nothing to do with the borax treat-
ment. A similarly misleading: reference to that circular ap-

" pears at the top of page 56 of petitioner’s brief in the discus-

SL OOO IM ARLE I EID ASO Mn 0 era a pence
.

Fa ill a

a
- 58 an ee ee
-sion of the Bishop “use”. That circular merely refers to an.
~ earlier and unsuccessful. attempt to kill the spores by means
of “antiseptic” solvents: mixed with paraffin, these solvents —
evaporating and ‘leaving on the fruit a covering of paraffin
of such character as to constitute an air-tight coating (para- .
graphs 6, 7 and 17 of circular, pp. 1465-7). That was along
the lines of the unsuce essful Bishop prior patent and was
“similarly unsuccessful (pp. 100-101, infra). The optional’
paraffin coating described in the patent in suit, but not’ in —
‘issue here, does not include antiseptics in its composition
and is so applied that it is not air- tight but permits the fruit
to breathe (Vol. I, 593, 595-6).
It is perfectly clear that the invention in suit was enthu-

siastically adopted: ‘by the industry solely ‘on its proven
merits.

Beginning at page 99 of petitioner’s brief, considerable
-- spaceis devoted to a discussion of commercial success as bear-
ing on the question of patentable invention. Evidently de-
fendant conceives proof. of commercial success to have been
plaintiff's principal object in offering testimony showing the
widespread adoption and use of the Brogden and Trowbridge
invention during the last few. years. But defendant . migses
the point.
Although great commercial success is clearly shown, the:
evidence also conclusively establishes something still more __ .
_ important, namely, that for a quarter of a century there had
, been a crying. need for some means of effectively controlling
blue mold decay, that s¢ientists and workers in the industry. |
-had been vainly endeavoring to find a satisfactory solution
of the problem, and that immediately upon introduction of
the borax process into the industry by plaintiff, the industry
at once recognized «it as the thing that had been soughi for
so many years. and adopted it universally. Under such cir-
cumstances there is always a strong presumption that what .
has been done amounts to patentable invention, a fact which
has often been recognized by this Court. McClurg v. Kings-
land, 1 How. 202; Gandy v. Main. Belting Co., 143 U. 8. 587, —

ae oe : |

"594; Eibel Process Co. v. Minnesota € Ontario Paper Co., 261
U.S. 45, 53, 54, 56; Mowry v. Whitney, 81_U. 8S. 620.
In the case of Heller Bros. Co. v. Crucible Steel. Co. of
America, 297 F. 39, the Circuit Court of saciid for the oeied
- Circuit said (p. 48):

“We think the patent in suit not invalid for want of
invention. For upwards of 50 years various methods for

“*

producing hollow drill. steel in commercial lengths had. .

been triéd. None fulty satisfied the. want. ‘The method’
of the patent does.”

In United Verde Copper Co. v. Peirce- Smith Converter
Co., TF. (2d) 13, the Cir cuit Court of wih 2 for the Third
Circuit said (/p. 17):

ys ta lead Moreover, were the question of invention.
closer than it seems to be, the position which the inven-
tion promptl took in the art would
for it is recognized that the fact the

Ren ‘a Sie piace use and has produce
ical results, speak for its inventive character. ae
(Citing cases,) — oy G

In Trane Co. Vv. Nash Engineering. Co., 25 SF (24) 267, . i
269, the Circuit Court of Appeals for the First Circuit said:

“By November, 1926, over 17,000 of these systems had
heen installed. This is strong evidence, from market
overt, of the value-of this combination; it met a long
felt want.: As pointed out by. Judge Morton (20 F.
[2d] 439), ‘the defendant and its predecessors had long
been in the heating business and none of their engineers
had ever solved the problem. David v. Harris (C. C. A.)
206 F. 902; Kurtz v, Belle Co. (C, C. A.) 280 F. 277..
Jennings substantially changed the art of vacuum steam
heating.”

ae

Iv.

The Patent Properly Covers the Invention. /

The patentees, as we hdve seen at pages 26-27, supra,
recognized the fact that blue mold spores will enter the i inevi-
table wounds in the skin of the fruit, and that it is useless to —
attempt to kill them, but: they should, in some way, be pre-
vented’ from growing and spreading to cause decay. |

They fully Set forth in their patent in suit (pp. 27-28, .
supra, the advance made by them in the art, namely, the ap-

__. Plication of this principle for the first time to solve the “prob-
lem peculiar to commercial large-scale methods of handling

fresh fruits”, as the Court of Appeals understandingly

characterized ff (V0, I, 573).

The patentees carefully describe typical procedures by
which growth and development of the spores may be pre- :
vented through the-use of a-solution of borax, properly ap-
plied. They describe the desirable strength of the solution, ,
and its method of application whereby it is caused thoroughly
to enter the pores of the skin and impregnate etsars skin —
or rind tisgues with borax (pp. 30-31, supra).

The process is covered by certain of the ats one of
which we ‘have quoted at page 33, supra. It emphasizes the
effective impregnation of the exposed rind orskin tissues (i.¢., /
exposed by the ineyitable, though often elight, mechanical ,_
injuries) with the borax solution, the fluidity, strength and
temperature of the solution, and ‘the duration, of’ treatment,
being such as to bring this about. - .

Also, the borax, having impregnated the wounds in the -
skin, is not to be washed off, but is to remain there i in effective |

- quantity until the fruit is consumed. It is to continue to be ©
' present and continue to act: to ane the growth: of the

spores. ;
That i is, bythe manufacturing process an article has been -
produced Ww hich never before existed—fruit, the rind of

SENG EE OI OAT AN Nt pcarsey ag et se SNE AR

FF fi smarts P 7 HON Rat SN NR Ke en ager et ae RAGES POSS ANH Sag RSi po awh sc hagunany apes
° . ' oR vas ATs IG : * wR

ee ~ 61 eee
. | Was Pie Ss : )
_ which carries borax. That article does not grow; it is made ° *
by using, as a part of the complete article, something which
has grown—much as one uses wood or other products of
nature as a part of manufactured: articles. fe
-As.was said by the Circuit Court of Appeals for the-Third.
Circuit in Riter- ‘Conley Mfg. Co. v. Aiken, 203 Fed. 699, 703:

“Thus,. whether required in’ that case or not, the
statement of Judge Acheson in Johnson v. Johnston
(C. 6), 60 F. 618, that ‘the. term,
used in the patent law, has. a very comprehensive sense,.

_ embracing whatever is made by. the-art’ or industry of
man, not. being a machine, a c osition of matter, or
a design’ i is in our judgment sound.” \ =

_ In the présent case, the Circuit Court of Appeals held
“(35 Fed. (2d) 106 and Vol. I, p. 574) : oN

~ “The product claims define an article of manufacture,
since the fruit is the result of a.process which is defined
and described and not a ndtural product. The product,
is a combination of the natural fruit and_a_ boric com:
pound carried by the rind or skin in an amount suf-\

“manufacture” as’ -

ficient to render the fruit resistant to decay. The com- \

_ plete article is not ‘found in nature’ and is thus an —s
- article - manufacture. “3 3

And that is entirely stead pee

Section 8 of the Constitution provides that “the Congress
‘shall have power * * * to promote the progress of science
_ and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and
“inventors the: exclusive right to their re writings
and discoveries”. ' .

Pursuant to this granted power, the Congress has ‘enacted.
Section 4886: of the Revised statutes (Title 35. y 8. C. A,
Sec. 31), which provides that.

“Any person who has invented or discovered day new
_and useful art, machine, manufacture, or composition
of matter, or any new and useful improveiients a veanest :

. may obtain a patent. therefor.

:
eo a a a

62

“The term “manufacture” is defined not only in Riter. ~
Conley Mfg. Co. Vv. Aiken, from which we have quoted, but
also in many other cases.

The authorities cited by petitioner do -not sipport its
contention that the product. of respondent’s process is not
an article of manufacture within the moaning of the pans ;
_ Statutes. 4

~The tagged oyster case (aaaivoms Seatas Comporeriok

v. Smith’s Island Oyster Co., 254 Fed. 821) well illustrates ;
what is and what is not an nelicks of manufacture. The Court
there found that neither an oyster nor ‘a spring ehicken be |
comes an article of manufacture “simply because of-bzing —
_ tagged”. That is to say, the oyster remained the same oyster,
- and. the chicken the same chicken, both absolutely unchanged
in any respect. Affixing the tag’ ‘éndowed neither of them
- with any characteristic or property dsc it did not already
possess. ;
In the present case, the situation is aliopethes different,

-* Plaintiff's treated orange is not the same orange it was before .

treatment. Its rind,. and especially any rind tissue which
may be exposed by ucratchon. cuts. or.other injuries, however.
minute and practically invisible they may be, carries borax
‘which functions to endow it with characteristics it did not
previously possess, namely, ability to resist the ravages of —
blue mold decay. For this reason it is no longer ‘the same
thing as an orange in the natural untreated state. Itisa new.
and different. orange, positively and accurately distinguish-
able by: chemical examination, of its rind and by its keeping
' qualities: from the tintreated orange. And it results from a=
‘definite manipulation of.or operation upon_a natural, orange,

a _. that is, it is “made by the. art or industry of man”. It is

obviously not classifiable as a machine, a composition of mat-
- ter, ora design ; it is an article of manufacture. |

__ The tariff cases cited by petitioner are. not applicable t to.
— narrow the definition of an article of manufacture as contem-
plated by the patent statute: This is because the question tf
what is ‘and what is not an. article of manufacture under the

adil bd > va —
Ps AO SARA a PARR AR aR IRMA AEN bE IB 05 oN RS MRM RGR EY icebin
Haynes and Brearley. 0% they. magnify it.~. There
are many inventions which stem to hawe been gathered,
as it were, from the scrap heaps of human effort. They .
appear to observers as the results of accident, rather: -
than intelligent design: But whére men, doubtless well
‘equipped for a particular-sort of work, have hoped and
investigated and even prophesied as to what’ could be
done, but never did it, and other men similarly equipped
have by intensive study and skillful experiment sue:
ceeded, such success commands and should receive a—
greater meed of intellectual appreciation than is ac-
_ corded even to the cleverness of picking up and utilizing
an unconsidered or discarded trifle. a

-71

In referring to the work of certain prior British patentees
set up as an anticipation, the Court said:

“They were perhaps among the prophets; but it re-

quires more than prophecy of what may be done, ‘or*

than declarations.of what ought to be accomplished, to
make a good patent reference, not to speak of’ an antici-
pation. It is necessary to show-with reasonable cer-.

tainty how the desired result can be accomplished.
S. = 789 “| ee i ae

In Westinghouse Air-Brake Co. v. ‘Great Northern Ry.

(o. (2 C. C. A.), 88 Fed. 258, 263, Judge Shipman said :"
“The prophetical suggestions in English patents of —

what can be done when no one has ever tested by actual
and hard experience and under the stress of -competi-
tion the truth of these suggestions, or the.practical diffi-
culties in the way of Reid accomplishment, or even
whether the suggestions“a

.

ments.” .

In Fleischman Yeast Co. y. Federal Yeast Corporation
(D. C: Md. 1925), 8 Fed. (2) 186, 197, Judge Soper said:

__ “If the foreign patents and. the Henneberg articles
cited against the patent are compared with its dis-
closures, it will bé seen that, so far as the step of neu-
tralization in the manufacture of bakers’ yeast is con-
cerned, the. former are vague and indefinite, while the

latter makes: specific and-clear statements that the em- *

ployment. of alkaline substances are of great advantage
in the quantity and quality .of the product. It is one
_ thing to show that, wheh yeast is used in fermentation

processes, its fermentative power and duration of life °
will be enhanced by offsetting deleterious acidity or that .

in producing pure yeast cultures in the laboratory with
distilled water, antacid substances should ‘be used and

it is quite another to demonstrate that, when the end in |

| re feasible, do not carry con-. .
viction of the truth of these frequent and vague state- —

view is the production of large quantities of yeast for -

its-own ‘sake, neutralizers may be advantageously em- -

ployed. As has so often been said in patent cases, it is
‘the last step which.counts.” (Citing cases. )

‘This case was affirmed on appeal, 13 Fed. (2) 570. In
speaking of certain earlier workers in the field, J — Rose

said (p. 570) : pha tinge LI es;

eee Some of heat were among ‘Hie most highly
skilled of.the world’s experts in the yeast-making art.
They were in immediate and almost daily touch with
the practical men of the industry, as well as with those’
who controlled the capital, employed in it. They were
on the look-out for every possible improvement in its
| methods. If they had known of the Hayduek process,
Pian they would have made prompt use of it.” -

The defendant’s theory, -in putting é in this mass of mate..
rial, seems to have been that any prior patent or publica-
tion mentioning borax or boric acid as being used, or
attempted or suggested to be used, as a preservative, is perti-
nent. Such patents and publications might be pertinent. if
Brogden and Trowbridge were claiming to have. discovered _
that borax or boric acid was an antiseptic. They make no
such claim. What: they did do was to @certain that borax
was a particularly good inhibiting agentfor their purposes, .
namely, controlling bluegnold decay in the commercial large’ _

scale handling of fresh fepit, when applied in their manner,
and what they have patented is a process for applying it and —
the product resulting from such. application. .

-The prior patents and publications show nothing of that.
They disclose, what we fully admit, that: borax and_boric
_acid had, many years ago,’ been proposed aS: preservatives

.” in canning and pickling processes—even before any problems
had arisen in connection with the decay caused by blue mold —
on fresh citrus fruits, and also in subsequent years. But —
. . they do not disclose any process by. which the results of the
invention in issue could be attained.
- The teachings were, in fact, contrary to any idea that
they were effective for that purpose. | :
Both « the lower Courts held that the prior art did not

. Ad *

disclose the invention of the patent in suit." The District
Court said (Vol. I, 18): : z
“Such process: is nowhere found in ihe disclosures of the

prior art though it is true that, viewed retrospectively :
-. and ignoring the long unsuccessful search for ar medy,

_ the claimed process would seem to be wa
tion over the disclosures of the prior art’

ing in inven-

ing the Patent Invalid Are A Ac ually Reasons
for Sustaining It. .

The petitioner conceives that there are a good reasons

why the patent is void:

First, petitioner’ says borax and — acid had long

. been known. and used as- antiseptics ‘and food preserva-
tives. If that is’ true, the. conclusion is the reverse of.
that which petitioner would draw. In spite of such_

» assumed knowledge, the whole art of: preparing fresh
fruit for market, seeking long and earnestly for means

of inhibiting blue mold decay, concluded that no chem-
ical would do it. So there must have been a real problem

in spite of the assumed knowledge, ‘and Brogden and

*It might possibly be inferred from what is said in the

“first. paragraph on page 6 of petitioner’s brief that, with. .

respect to the prior patents and publications (among other
things) the District Court said *

“That borax was used in the preparation of citrus fruit

for market by Several persons prior to the date of the '
invention in suit: cannot, I think, be seriously -
,Woned. 2 /

The. Coast made this statement, aot with yespeet to the -

prior patents and publications, but solely in.connection with -

. the evidence which petitioner offered in support of the alleged

prior uses, which evidencewas held insuficient for the pur-

‘ pose. See decision, Vol. I, 519.

rd | -

(Vol. I, 18):

ad .
“4 ;
rr) . F H .
ve ‘ i $ -« a fe &
. ‘ . ‘ - :
: ve e
—_ : rs °
PO eas se a -_ a ; ; -
ia 3 . *. sae Nn a tg ey Peay 3 “ wt
, : ° :

Trowbridge solved it -after So many others had given it
up. ‘Thats one of the situations which demonstrates the
existence of invention.
_ Second, petitioner says, it had long been known that
borax and boric acid were toxic to blue molds. (This state-

. - ment is too broad, as it takes no account of culture media, -
conditions of use, and other factors ; but even if it be
assumed to be true, the invention is — emphasized for _
the reasons just indicated.

Third, petitioner says, the prior patents and publica. ies
tions and public uses show that the patent in suitis .
invalid. There were prior patents and publications, but

they did not teach the inyention- herein accomplished.

There were no prior uses. . are

To paraphrase the langidige of this Court in Diamond
Rubber Co. v. Consolidated Rubber: Tire Co. , 220 U.S, 428 |
(441), petitioner gives the,tribute of its ; «ise to the prior
art; it gives the Brogden a Trowbridge p process the tribute
of its imitation. ,

The defense in this case is well characterized by the :
language of the Court of Appeals of the 8th Circuit in
Naylor v. Alsop Process Co., 168 Fed. 911 (at p. 917):

“The prior art that tia been brought to our notice ©
is mainly literary. [Defendants- have ransacked patent:
offices in America @nd Europe, and brought together:
L a formidable collection of patents. Many y of them are
ie aU _ paper patents and‘others relate to remote arts. Piecing _
' together -excerpts ‘and elements from tltis: wide: search, . °
they have built up a formidable speculative argument to
, show how .simple and easy was ‘the step: taken by -
_» Andrews. This is a form of argumentation familiar
in patent litigation. Though it seldom succeeds it is
q often the only recourse of the infringer. ‘The patent. law,
ee however, has its proper ‘place in the realm of actual in-
bi . dustrial life, and not in the limboes of parchment casuis-
try. The merit of a-patent is to be determined, not’ by
its standing in dialectics, but by. its qotuas effects im oe
‘art to which it - ‘belongs,’ ”

75
' This principle has often beén affiryied. Thus, this Court

in 1 Diamond Rubber Co. v. i Rubber Tire Co., ; 220°
. U.S. 428, said at page 435:

“Knowledge after the event is always easy, and. probs
_ lems. once solved ‘present ‘no difficulties, indeed, may be ©
Sh ge represented as never having had any, and expert wit- |
: nesses may’ be brought forward to show that the new
thing which seemed to have eluded the search of the
_ world was always ready at hand and easy to be seen by
ae: a merely skilful attention. . But the law has other tests
| _ of the invention than subtle. conjectures of what might
_have been seen and yet was not.”

In General Electr ic Co. Vv: Hoskins Mfg. ¢ C., 224 F. 464,

) the Circuit Court of a ts for the ibdens ‘Cireuit ‘said
(PD. 467) :. :

ay, ow, the law is well settled, that in order to antici:
pate a later i invention, the prior descr iption must be such
as to show that the article described in the patent. can
be.certainly arrived at by following the prior descrip-
tion without the assistance of local knowledge or local
prior use in the locality. where the description ‘is pifb- ¢
~ lished and without experimentation. .

o Hanifen v. Godshalk, 84 F. 649, the Circuit Court of
Appeals for the Third Circuit said at page ‘651:

“Now, it-is a well settled and familiar doctrine -that
an “invention patented here is not to be defeated by a
prior foreign patent unless its descriptions or drawings
contain. or exhibit a substantial representation of the
patented invention in such full, clear; and exact: ‘terms
as to enable any person skilled in the art or science*to
_which it appertains, without the necessity of making ea- .
en, to practice the invention. Seymour Vv: Os-

boxne, 11 Wall. 516, 555; Cahill v. Brown, 3 Ban. & A. -.
—. 580; 587,. Fed, Cas. No- 2,291. oe

Robinson on Patents, Vol. L page 450, auc, 329, states

“The invention. described in the publication ‘must be.

_ identical in all respects with that whose novelty it eon-
_,.tradicts. The same :idea of means, in the same. stage
of seis Somaru as that which the inventor of the later

ys

oa

» _
ee ne eee see ey

. a .
OUR CS ca cad ote it
.
. ’ :

-» Circuit in Badische-Anilin Co. vy. Kalle Co., 104 Fed. 802,
‘at page 808:

76 Pi gas

oe A:
has embodied, must be thereby communicated to the -
public. The invention thus described must also have ~

- been a complete and operative art-or instrument, ready
for immediate employment by the public. And‘ "it. must

7. described, not as a mere hypothesis either in method —

or in possibility, but as an existing fact already known.” |

No reference here fulfills these requirements. No pub- »

lication describes a “complete and operative art or instru- -

ment, ready y for immediate employment by. the public” or

“capable of being put into practical use” “without the neces-.

sity of making experiments.” —
As stated by. the Circuit Court of Appeals for. the ond

-
‘ °

“The © description in a printed publication’ of the:
statute is to be found aithin the four corners of such
printed publication. Judge Coxe tersely and accurately
expresses the law and the reason for it in the following
passage :

The question’ is, what does the prior ileal say?
not what it might have said or what it should have said. .
If prior patents and publications can be reconstructed
by extrinsic evidence to fit the exigencies of the case,
the inquiry will no longer be confined to what the publi.

-eation communieates to the public but it . will be
transferred to an endeavor to ascertain what its author
intended to communicate.” :

Again in Loew Filter Co. v. German Am. Filter Co., 164
Fed. 855 (C. C. A., 6th Cir.), the Court said (p. 860):

-“The Zimmer publication must be given effect as an
anticipation only to the extent that it actually gave to _
_the public information of a process of filtration, It is
mpetent to read into such a publication informa-
it does not give, or by expert opinion explain

an otherwise uninforming statement by evidence of some

apparatus or article not itself competent as an anticipa-
tion. Badische Anilin & Soda Fabrik v. Kalle é Co., ©
. 104 Fed. 802, 44 C. C. A. 201" |

- >)

a

‘The patentability of the taveitlon in issue is clear, but if
there. were any doubt it should be nich in favor of
patentability :

oe.- 7: &

°

, patent process, as against cemplete failure or non- -user

of the other should turn the scale in favor ‘of pat- .

entahility and non-anticipation.”
Schmertz Wire Glass Co. v. Western Glass Co., » 178
Fed. 990.

“An admitted ; success aoniid not. be destroyed- by an

admitted failure.’ Cimiotti-l ‘nhairing Co. v. American ~

Unhairing Co, (C. C 3, A., 2d), 115 Fed. 498 (502).

. The case of Seabusy v. Am Ende, 152 U. 8. 561, cited
-and discussed at’ pages 126- 127 of petitioner’s brief, is de-:
structive of much of petitioner’s argument in the present;
suit, since it.establishes that-a valid patent can be obtained
for a product employing boracie acid as an ingredient, not-

withstanding the fact) as found by the Court, that boracic., °

acid was old and .w of known as an antiseptic.

In the Am Ende case the Court pointed out that the
“merits of the complainant’ s invention received immediate
‘and wide-spread recognition” and it is apparent from the
opinion that this fact had great weight with the Court in
reaching its conclision that the patent was valid..

'- As to the contentions of the defense that the invention
was anticipated the ‘Court said: '

“Undoubtedly the evidence ‘ah that the specific quali-
ties of glycerine and of boracie acid were. known, and
_that these articles had been succéssfully: used in the.

instances: narrated.. But we agree with the Court below -

in thinkinig.that ‘this evidence does not disclose that
anyone prior to. Am Ende accomplished what he. has
‘described and claimed ;-that the fact that others had
.done something quite similar and had used separately,
or in different combinations, the ingrédients of his claim,
should not affect his patent. All that is described in the
prior publications -the worenaant may yore with perfect
immunity *.* *,”

in case of doubt,. complete success in the -

.

ee | :

° i 78 . i° , QQ
|
But in the present ease the petitioner is not interested

in using the processes or making the products of the prior

art. ‘It will be satisfied with nothing but the right to use.

the particular process and pr oduct of respondent’s patent,

VII.

7 The Alleged Prior Uses Are. Sedans,’ Inher. ;

‘ently Improbable, and Not Proved.

‘In'spite of the. fact that the documentary evidence aid
the testimony show conclusively that, for more than twenty

years the industry had been seeking for some chemical treat-~

ment that world control blué mold decay, and that none had
been found, the defendant pleaded ten’ prior uses, nine of

which it still urges before this Court.

The first comment that occurs in this connection -is that
there are toomany. There must have been recognized defects
in each to have: induced the. attempted duplication.

The next comment which urges itself insistently upon
one’s mind is that these prior uses cannot possibly have ex-

isted, remembering how the whole industry was repeatedly.

investigated -by the Department of Agriculture, and how

‘. growers, packers, scientific men and societies were all co-
operating.-with each other, were writing and publishing -
papers, even engaging in public and private discussions, were —

. in every way searching for some cure for blue mold decay,
ze were trying. and rejecting chemical treatment—and during .
that whole period of twenty-odd years the process now in con-

troversy never came to light. . The combing of thé industry
and. of all branches of-it had been thorough and complete.
No borax process fdr the control of blue mold existed. «

The final comment is that none of the alleged prior uses

is proved. The witnesses testify, solely from. recollection in ,
_ every instance, about ev ents which they allege happened many
years ago. Even with the best of intentions, memories fade
and, therefore, the rule. has been established that the proof
in such situations must carry cony iction beyond a reasonable"

on

79 ae

doubt, ond it is generally held that this burden of sais can-
not be sustained in fhe absence of some contemporaneous,
tangible evidence such as that of. proved writing or structures.
No such evidence exists here. _ \

_ The'testimony of somé of ‘the defengant’s witnesses may,
be excused ‘on the theory that they are testifying honestly

inhibiting | process, they have confused the use of other
chemicals for other purposes with the uses now in con-
troversy.

'. AS was fai by Judge Mayer in Sans v. Blatt. (1920),
263 F. 392 , 393; in rejecting testimeny of prior use;

. “Mr. Koch was not able to produce any contenipo-
raneous records or exhibits of any_kind-er description.

~ The .subtle influence of mental suggestion to a man’s

cult for even'a man himself to realize.”

It is ‘undoubtedly trie that some chemicals had been
used for some quite different purposes. Thus,’ Pond of the

uses is Said to have occurred, wrote: in 1914 (Vol. II, 1078- 9)
that in washing fruit 5 : EAS Pe set AES

of washing powder to remove the white fly.”

And, in 1915 (Vol. II, 1086), a publication stated:

ing tank filled with hot water, containing an alkaline
cleansing’ powder, especially ‘where the fruit is black
from sooty mold from the white fly. Gold dust or other
alkaline powders are now used in the water.”

And, in 1917 (Vol. II, 1163), there was a publication
stating: °

“Lyé, washing powder’ and bora. ‘ax are sometimes rec-
ommended for softening water, but are not’ always reli-
able because they do not neutralize all water- hardening
minerals.”

- and to the best’ of their recollection but that, due to the lapse. .
of ‘time ‘and their present. knowledge of the borax mold: : .

memory after he-has seen an article is sometimes diffi- —

Eustis Citrus Growers Association, where one of the prior

\-
\
\

“We use froin five t to. seven pounds of most: any kind ~

“The best outfits for washing, now consist of ‘a soak:

Se RII toi IRI ae

80 “
_ With this background, some confusion in the minds. of the
witnesses would seem to be natural.

The law ‘is that the burden of proof: is strongly on the

» defendant in attempting to prove prior use or prioy inven-

tion, and ev ery reasonable doubt should ‘be resolved cent
him:

. » In Coffin v. Ogden (1874), 85 U- s. 120, Justice Swayne
said at page 124:

é «* * * The iny ention or ‘discovery relied upon as
a defence, must have been complete, and capable of. pro-
ducing the results sought to be accomplished ; ‘and this
must be shown—by-the defendant. The burden of proof
rests upon him, and every reasonable doubt ‘should be

- resolved against him. If the thing. were embryotic or

\ inchoate ;- if it rested in speculation or experiment; if

_. ‘the process pursued for its development had.failed to
‘Peach the point of consummation, it cannot avail to

'. defeat a patent founded upon a discovery or invention
which was completed, while in the other case there was
only” “progress, | however, near that “progress may have —

____approximated “to the end in view. The barca requires re

not conjecture, but certainty.’

~ In The Barbed Wire Patent Case (1892), 143 U. 8. 278,
Justice Brown said at page 284:

aie ie liave now to deal with certain. unpat: -
ented devices, claimed to be: complete anticipations of _ ,
this patent, the existence and use of which are proven = °
only by oral testimony. In view of thé unsatisfactory
character of such testimony arising from. the forgetful-
mess of w itnesses, their liability. to mistakes, their prone-
ness to recollect things as the party calling them would
have them recollect them, aside from the temptation to -
actual perjury, courts have not only imposed upon de--
fendants the burden of -proving such devices, but have:
required that the proof shall be clear, satisfactory a and be- .
yond a reasonable. doubt. Witnesses whose -memories.are
‘prodded by the eagerness of rere parties to. elicit
' testimony favorable ta themselves
depended upon for aceurate information. The veryy eet,
which courts as Well As the public have’ not failed to rec-

re not usually to be |

‘ . ‘ .
a das. b : - i on .
oe" rei
‘ x : A
. ee : :
. ° : . . '
5 .
)
‘

81

ognize, that slvalins every. ticaetuse patent, from the ye
cotton. gin of Whitney to the one under consideration, —
has been attacked by the testimony of witnesses who -
imagined they had made similar discoveries long before.
the patentee had claimed to have invented his device, “ ve
-has tended to throw a certain amount of discredit upon—— :
-*. all that class of evidence, and to demand that it be sub-
jected to the closest scrutiny. Indeed, the frequency ©
‘with which | testimony is tortured, or fabricated outright, — wen
to build up the defence of a prior use of the thing pat-
'- ented, goes far to justify-the popular impression that
_ the inventor may be treated. as si lawful ‘prey of the.
~~infringer.” os

In Beovinis

*

One of the principal arguments advanced by petitioner,
here ‘as well as below, in an attempt to offset the published
teachings of the Departnient of Agriculture, is that the
experts of that Department, beginning with Powell, well

+ Sil

87

knew as far back as 1904 that the blue mold decay problem ‘
could be solved for the industry by the use of boric acid, but
that’ they did not announce it because the use of such a
chemical would violate the Pure Food Law, which, it may be
" noted, did not come-into existence. until 1906—two years
after the asserted knowledge by the Department, and which

never prohibited the application of any chamien} to the rind

or peel of an orange.

This argument rests primarily upon an alleged disclos-

ure to Powell by a food chemist, Gore, who testified for ‘peti-

tioner at the trial. It is petitioner's contention, notwithstand-
ing its admission, that what Gore did was an abandoned ex-
periment (brief, p. 71), that Gore’s testimony proves he made-
_ successful tests with boric acid on citrus fruit for blue mold
decay prevention. We submit that Gore's testimony: estab-
lishes quite the contrary.

But, if it. be asswmed that Gore’s tests were successful,
that Powell was fully informed of them and. realized that
- an effective practical solution of the blue mold decay problem
was thus actually at hand;-and that this same knowledge was _
' transmitted to Powell’s nu@erous expert associates and suc-
cessors throughout the long line of those who taught the
industry 80 persistently and insistently for the next twenty
years that “careful handling” was the only remedy for blue
mold decay in the packing and marketing of fresh fruit,
. Where.does that leave the petitioner?

The petitioner's argument disregards some. of the very °
essential facts in which the record abounds. It sounds very.
‘ plausible to say that, by ‘reason of Dr. Wiley’s ideas and .-
the resultant Department. policy with respect to the Pure
Food Law, respondent’s evidence proves merely that “the
results of these experiments were never published, never
given to the industry, “for the “simple reason that it would
have been impolitic to do so” ( Petitioner's brief, p: 71). But .
Powell and the rest of the army of experts who were engaged
throughout that twenty years in trying to find some way to
solve the blue mold decay problem for the industry did not
stop at merely failing to recommend chemical treatment, or

88

at offering mere tacit discouragement of its use. They told —
the industry that chemical treatment of fruit in preparing |
it for market was absolutely ineffective to prevent klue mold
_ decay, and furthermore that it would injure the skin of the
fruit. Not once was there any/mention of the Pure Food
Law or the slightest suggestion that the use of chemicals in
\ this way. would run counter to any pure food regulations, -

SO ow

“T know of no wash yet discovered that will kill the
spores of the decay fungus and at the same time not,
injure the fruit.” (Tenny in 4907, Vol. I, 660).

“Do' not try to disinfect the water ‘for blue mold.
This disease cannot be killed by any. strength of copper
sulphate or permanganate of potash that would not be
injurious to the fruit.” -( Powell in 1911, Vol. IL, 883).

“The question is often asked. whether any chemical,
can be put into wash water to kill the blue mold spores.
in it or on the fruit. Considerable work has been done
along® this line and nothing has been found that can be

_ put in the water Which will kill the blue mold spores and + -
not injure the fruit. The only thing to do is to keep the
fruit free from injury.” (Ramsey.in 1912, Vol. II, 915).

“As yet no disinfectant has been fourid which proves

. effective against blue mold. Extensive investigation of

- this phase of the subject has shown the spores to’ be so’
resistant that any solution used to destroy them must
be of such strength to injure the. surface of the fruit”
(Stubenrauch, Ramsey, Tenny and Me Kay in 1914, Vol.
II, 1011).

The foregoing are mérely typical of the statements: which
. the experts made repeatedly down to: 1924.
; Reduced to its essentials, therefore, the argument offered
| here by petitioner rests upon what is tantamount toa charge
that Powell, Tenny, Stubenrauch; Ramsey, MeKay anil the
other experts of the Department of Agriculture deliberately
lied to the growers and ‘packers when they told them year
after year in official bulletins and addresses that chemical
treatment had been investigated and found useless-——and
worse than useless because any chemical-powerful enough to
. kill the blue mold spores would injure the surface of the
fruit. : ‘.
. if these eminent experts did indeed know that the. losses

89

from blue mold decay from which the industry suffered con-
stantly down to 1924 could satisfactorily be overcome by
treatment with borax under the practical conditions of opera-
. tion prevailing in the packing house in preparing fresh fruit: - -
for market, and even if it be assumed that because of Dr.
Wiley’s views they considered it “impolitic” to recommend
such a remedy, then it necessarily follows that, in repeatedly
and. unequivocally condemning chemical treatment and ad-
vising against even attempting it, not. because of any sup-
posed violation of the Pure. Food Act by such treatment (for
no such thing was.even hinted at in any of their publica-
tions), but solely because of its alleged utter ineffectiveness,
these experts, with the official sanction of the Department
of Agriculture, must tiave been guilty of practicing a bare-
faced and expensive fraud upon the American people) in
whose service they were, a fraud which they kept alive! by ;
systematic official misrepresentation throughout the better
part.of twenty years. . bet eae |
' . We ourselves should regard such a serious indictment of
the Department: of Agriculture and its experts as quite un- .
" wartanted, but petitioner's argument necessarily assumes the.
' contrary. Obviously the only reasonable view is that these
highly skilled experts and specialists, instead of being: trick-
sters, as petitioner's argument presupposes, were -honest in
their published statements and that what they thus told the
public was indeed the well considered opinion of the.best
_- minds.of the industry. Plainly they are disinterested state-
ments by recognized experts, wholly unbiased and free from -
the more or less natural partisanship of experts testifying
inthe heat of litigation, and for that reason these statements
are more than usually dependable and convincing.

}

90.

a .

The New Matter Relating to the Department
Experiments, Proposed by the Amici Curie for _
Consideration by the Court, if Received, Would

‘Further Establish the Highly Inventive Char-
acter of What Brogden and Trowbridge Did..

While neither the’ authorities’ cited by the amici curif in
their brief at page 45, nor any others known to us, appear to
warrant judicial notice being taken of the mass of new
matter, digested in the appendix of that brief beginning at
page 37 and by this method sought for or the fi first _tinieto-be—~*
injected into this case_neverttieless ‘it seems appropriate. to

- state that, if this new matter were properly before the Court,
it would tend to establish. quite conclusively certain im-
portant facts, ineluding the following :

eee: | y Department did. ‘experiment extensively with boric
‘acid for a long time beginning in 1904, with a view to find-
ing out whether, by its‘use, it might be possible to control
blue molt decay in, the commercial handling of fresh citrus
fruits. From this it, follows that all of the many. prior
patents and publications of date prior to 1904, relied upon .
t by petitioner, were utterly insufficient to teach even these
highly skilled experts in the art that such a thing could be
done,—otherwise why the necessity for experimenting? .
- These “experiments” with borie acid proceeded in the
laboratory to a_point where the method appeared “promising”.
See Schedule 11, Letter from Scott to Powell, February 6,
1905, in which Scott says:

“The results of the borie acid test are quite promising,

* . .
‘

“A 3% strength of boric acid used asa dip seems. to pre:
vent the development*of the Penicillium rot in oranges
and lemons almost perfectly. J am airare; however, that |
ithen brought to actual test in the. field. and under coin-
mercial conditions the treatment may prove worthless,
but the results obtained here in the laboratory are cer:
tainly sufficient to warrant more extensive tésts.”

* ad - .
sy peonpeaniey mrt rent , : t : * “$4 ‘ li
a ’ . Ye we ° :
. .

L——-

already been recognized by Powell also, who said:

“T have not thought of suggesting it wntil the boys work
a good deal more on it. Then we may try it on the quiet
on a commercial scale.’ (Letter from Powell to Taylor,
- Jan. 1, 1006.) . =.
ae
Why wait “until the boys work a good deal more ‘on it”
when, according to. petitioner’s argument, the matter of pre-

venting blue mold decay as described and claimed in the.

patent in suit was something that any housewife would know
enough todo? (Petitioner's brief, p. 50.) Paton hears
Without going into more detail, it. will: be | gafficient : to

__referte-only one more of these letters, namely, from Powell »

to Shamel, dated October 26, 1909. Powell says: ¢

“We hate been asked many times to work out methods of
- \killing blue mold in the wash water for oranges, and two
Sy aeage ago Dr. Wheeler was in Riversidé all winter work-

ng on the effect of different fungicides on the death of .

_-penicillium. At the end of this work we were more than

ever convinced we were on the wrong track and the thing *

to be constantly driven home was the pe of a soune
orange or lemon to freedom of decay.”

i— ee

So that, after all the experimenting, the final conclusion
was that it was out of the question to try to remédy the blue
mold decay troubles of the fruit pac er through chemical
methods; and. this conclusion was based on the definite proof,

. to the satisfaction of Powell, that the chemicals simply would ——

not work, and not upon any consideration — the Pure
Food Law. ,

_ The documents ‘*«bmitted ‘by the amici curia show that -

2 among those who had knowledge of this extensive experi-
menting and abortive attempt to work out a chemical treat-

‘ment of commercial value, were Taylor, Powell, Fulton, Scott, |

Gore, Stubenranch and Tenny.
It ig particularly interesting to note Taylor's letter of,
January 5, 1905, to Powell, in which he SAYS :

“Mr. Fulton will i in clone touch with these —
. of the wey?

The necessity for tests under commercial conditions had —

= SD ee ‘

_ unsuecessful tests: of the boric acid tredtment under com-.
mercial conditions.

ISM Et SIE RARE Bato 28 wu ena {honda ai

“tests very Sekadaas in addressing the Florida State Horti-

‘rots, said (Vol. II, 12 aT):

Also Gore's letter’of the ee date to Powell in which }
he: ‘appake of sons ee ; Sek

per ade
eer esis oe
hich .were- brought’ out.
jeleedlar in ais ission of the boric acid. werk by
a Pay or, Fulton, Beott and myself. ae :

All these men agdoubtedly knew about the Department’s

Gore and Scott, who testified ion petitioner at the tria),
neglected to mention them.’ ae : .
‘But Tenny had .no doubt about them when, in 1907, he
said (Vol. -I, 660):

Go. tags . ¢ . .
“I know of no wash yet discovered ‘that will kill the
" Spores of the eter ay fungiis and at the same time not ~
injure the fruit.”

aie had Powell, as and Tenny, joint authors
of Department of Agriculture Bulletin’ No. 123, ee
in 1908; when they said (Vol. T, 709):

“It has often been suggested that the blue mofil ae
be killed by.a disinfectant in the wash water as-is done
with the parasitic fungus which produces the brown rot. _
This does not appear from preliminary studies to be’
promising or advisable.”

dnd 1 in 1910, ‘dar recalled those unsuccessful

cultural Society (Vol. If, 848):

“We tried a number of these experiments in California,
and. had a man there one season working on that alone,
* “but we did not get any results that were worth noting.”
“Even as late as 1925, those failures were evidently ‘still
vivid in the mind-of Fulton, who, in talking to the members
of the Hortic ultural Society about blue.mold and stem end

“For a long. time fruitless search has been made forea ;
satisfactory chemical agent that will control these rots.”

. f s
988.

The material which the’ antici curve ask this Court to.
judicially notice would therefore ‘seem to show that these ¥

skilled Government ‘technologists, to whom the public: is

: rightly accustomed to impute a high standard of integrity,

were not guilty of cheating the public for twenty years. “for

the simple reason that it would. have been. impolitic” to tell
‘ the truth, as petitioner’s brief (p. 71) assumes. °

‘xi. .
The Experts of the Industry Proceeded for

Many Years on the Mistaken Theory that it was,
Necessary to ‘‘Kill’’ the Decay Spores.

_ The failure of the Department experts and the industry
to find an effective chemical method for ¢ontrolling blue mold
decay in the commercial large se ale handling of freslr fruit :
was probably due to the universal belief that, owing to the
extremely resistant character of blue mold spores, the only —

_ possible hope of treating fruit chemically ‘under packing ——
house conditions to prevent blue mold decay lay in the-use’
of strong toric chemicals of positive. fungicidal action to kill
the spores. Tlius, as is shown by the literature we have
reviewed, we find repeated suggestions. that copper sulphate,
ammoniacal copper carbonate, and the like, were being tried

with a view to killing the spores. But. when used in sufficient ———

‘strength to kill, these chemicals were found to injure the
‘rind of fruit and, therefore, to be useless. And so the De-
partment announced over and over again that chemical: con-
trol was hopeless. In view of the exceedingly severe con-
ditions characterizing large scale packing house practice,
So favorable to blue mold spore dev elopment, and since experi-
_ ments showed -that. boric ‘acid would not “kill”: blue mold
spores, it never occurred to anyong then that a ‘mild agent like
borax could possibly solve a en where active and highly

. é vA / 94

polsonous farighcldes had failed. In viewof those failures, how °
- could borax Ke expected to have any useful effect “under prac.
tical. packjfg house conditions, with the dirty water in the”
soaking | nk teeming with those higlily resistant blue mold
spores, And. with the washer brushes scratching the fruit and-
rubbing those Spores into every scratch? It was simply un-
thi able.
a Winston, in his alleged laboratory experiments, ‘says, he’
ane mercuric chloride (corrosiv e sublimate), a strong fungi-
‘cide and deadly poison, in preferénee to berax. (Vol. I,

© 217-8). And, of course; Powell knew of Gore’s unsuccessful

and abandoned laboratory experiments with boric acid. Yet

~ neither Gore nor Winston, in their alleged tests, was work:

‘ing under conditions even remotely approaching, in point
of severity, the practical packing | house conditions just
° ¢ 7 °

_ mentioned.

Obviously the idea of spore-killing inevitably led directly ;
away from anything like borax for solving the blue mold
‘decay problem of thie industry. Note, moreover, that spore.
killing chemicals could be washed off the: fruit after per:

‘ forming their killing function, so that this consideration .

led away from Brogden, & Trowbridge’s further idea.of leay-

ing a permanent residue of ‘mold- ‘inhibiting agent on the rind

of the fruit. aay
The correctness: of this explanation as to why the indus-

~ try never heand of the borax treatment prior to. Brogden |

and Trowbridge \ is strongly indicated by the gnnouncement
of Fulton and Bowman in 1924 that they -

“have undertaken the testing of a large number of
mild chemical reagetits with-a view to finding inhiditiog
rather than killing substances” (Vol. II, 1225).
‘Thos, « fter the reaioiident ‘s process becaine known to the.
Department, the Department followed that line of work. And_

_ then it recommended the use of borax. The Pure Food law
idid not deter such announcement, The only sane conclusion

is that the Pure Food law had and has nothing to do with the.

matter. The Department ait’ “not earlier announce the use

ve ; ; ! =

: bee : s
ig ; - i “ . . e rf
5 car ;
? WA a? va . Fad
wrote fewer " ‘ tm — eee side Ta oth hast we eT “ SMR
-

|

. c .
, “ .
. ; os
ieee net pe ‘ —_—— — sree . a
: . 5 . Z
~ ‘ x a
.

. See

soe
ture and practices ‘of the art, and by testimony of certain
of —— ‘witnesses.

13. The alleged prior uses are ‘not’ ares and. are un:
believable in view of the literature and: eneuces of the art.

14. Infringement i is admitted. Lh ee ) -
- The whole matter is well summed up ina ‘decision by’ ihe
Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, in O'Rourke Engi-
neering Const.Co. V. Me Mullen, 160° Fed:, 933, 938, where
the Court, speaking by Judge Ward, said:

“The principal question th: such cases. is: Has the
patentee added anything of valne to the sum of human -
- knowledge, has he made the world’s. work easier, cheaper’
_ and safer, would the return, to the prior art be a retro .
~ gression? When the court has answered this question,
or these questions, in the affirmative, the effort should be _
to give the. inventor the just reward .of the contribution,
he has ninde. The effort should increase in proportion
as the contribution is valuable. AVhere the court has
to dval with a device which, has achieved undisputed: ,
" suecess and accomplishes, a resnit never attained before, *
~ Which is new, useful and in large demand, it is generally
' safe to cone Inde that the man who.made it isan inventor.
The court may resort to strict and, it may even be, to
harsh ¢onstruetion when the patentee has: done nothing *
"more than make a trivial improvement upon a well
known structuré which produces no new result ;-but it
should. be correspondingly liberal when‘ convinced tha
the patentee’s. improvement is?so radi al as to. put the old .
methods out of ge tion.”

&:
‘ne

Tn: educheston” we ask that the’ decision of the Court a
Appeals be affirmed.

_ Respectfully submitted,

- CHARLES Neaves

ate ee ’ . MELVILLE CHURCH,
Re erOe mre STEWARD,
| bs ie ete Mirrokn ©. Makstr,
tone Pie Of coer for Respondent. Ppaiatt

/ | f ae ae At ° eee |

Te APPENDIX. Lr ee

p™

‘De failed. Discussion. af Prior Publications
and Patents. 4

(a) The Prior Publications :, is Fi

ie While, | renerally speaking, the ites of using borax and.
boric acid. as a pregervi ative in food and for some other pur-
_ poses was old; very curious and. contradictory results had —
~ been reached in, the investigations that are reported. In one -
~ case, in connection with cigars, one strength, of solution did -
some good; half: that. strengtl did harm; quarter that
strength alid good again (True, Dephetment « of Agriculture, /
Vol. II, 1503). In 1883, ‘the use of borax for preventing \
“thildew in vineyards (mildew is no closely related to peni- |
: eillium ,—Alsberg, Vol. I, 278), was discussed (Journal
@Agriculture, Vol. II, 1566) and again in 1892 (Morel,
Vol. II, 1538).; but.in 1913 , it was discouraged as being de
structive to foliage (Bourcart, Vol. If, 1523); ‘Incidentally, ;
_ Bourcart points out (Vel: II, 1448-9) that penicillium |
glaucum (blue mold) is capable of growing in a‘concentrated |
-sqlution of blue vitriol (copper sulphate), Or oa cry stal of
_ silver pitrate, or in a1. per cent solution of corrosive subli-
“mite; yet these are very powerful reagents. .In 1909, in the | ans
“course of an investigation of the effect of sodium benzoate’ |
on mold development in preserved ketchup, * other eheinicals
were tried, and‘-among them (as a “somewlhiat accidental”
matter,—Alsberg, Vol. I,-279) ‘were. borax and boric acid,
* which were found to be less effective than the rest (Bitting, . " ‘
Vol, II, 1510-12). As late as 1922, an investigation con-
duéted. by the Department of Agriculture resulted in the a5
conclusion that -boric acid is not-very effective in pireerying ;
-eafined goods - (Circular 237, Vol. 11, 1492). See
Another-article. (Bitting, Vol. 1, 1525) bate with three
molds, none of which is found on citrus fruits. This article fi
a primarily a study, from the purely scientific and labora:

.* : 7 ; @ \e

\

‘ The Storer British Patent: ys +) ‘0
‘Storer, _in\ his. British patent 214 of ISNs (Vol, I,
1598), proposes ’ to saturate material such. us sawdust or.
ehaff with a solution of boracie acid or an. alkali borate or
biborate, then: to Shorouphly dry the sawdust or chaff, and
en to pack fruit im the dry treated material. ‘It is sufi.
et robvious that ‘ue ha proc edure would entirely fail
‘to\ impregnate exposed rind tissues with the reagent used,
even if it were intended to treat. any but, perfect and ‘unin.
jured fruit (which is not suggested ), and would therefore

be wholly ineffective to prevent “blue mold decay:*

Yo el

“

(d) The patents: to Spear, Gata Raced and Hauf

‘These * patents obviously relate - to fant prerersing ‘proc:
esses proper, such as canning, pickling or otherwise incor.

~porating a. preservative ofssome kind: in food. “They are
therefore even tore. remote, if possible, from the invention
in suit than the patents ‘already discussed. None of them ,
touches in any. way upon the subject ‘of blne mold dee ay or.
the problems involved in.its control in the commercial mar.
keting of fresh fruit. They will, however, be brietly dine uxsed, :

gag in his gry old U.S. Patent 67921

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386007_0498%3A09. Public record. Not legal advice.
