# Petitioners Brief — Powers-Kennedy Co. v. Concrete Co.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386007_0435%3A12

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Petitioners Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1930
- **Citation:** 282 U.S. 175

## Text

Office Suprome Court,
PILED

FEB @1 1924
FILE COPY heme
CHARLES ELMORE Gi

CL

Se arene

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

CONCRETE MIXING & CONVEYING COMPANY (a Oorporation),
Plaintiff-Petitioner,

vs.

BE. C. STORRIE & COMPANY (a Partnership),
Defendants-Respondents.

BRIEF FOR PLAINTIFF-PETITIONER.

|

yn A. WILLIAMS,
LIFFORD C. BRADBURY,
+ ALBERT G. McCALEB,

For Petitioner.

‘STEPHEN J. COX,
Of Counsel.

Restman Gree, Ine, Law Printers, 542 &. Dearborn 81, Chicage.

BtAtOMeENE ...........---.--------s00n--cnecneerse-cnsnseecssnesenseccescenesesneneees
Lower court proceedings ............. Re Ssniastereinainceatietaeees
NI ONIN nines cei necnsetmrinonssnomrnecinnsinnnninivens
The problem which McMichael solved..........................
The McMichael apparatus ........2..00.2..2.ee ee ceeeee neces
The McMichael apparatus eliminates hand tamping
and insures better concrete than can be secured
by any other means. This is one of the reasons
why the McMichael apparatus is used to the ex-
clusion of all others in tunnel work......00.000.00000 00...
INE CNN ssiatsinsinsecsucsnsvarsesabexticencptatmiptarerntosed ane
The patent does not cover a theory. The correct-
ness of the inventor’s statement of the theory of
the invention is unimportant...
The commercial success of the McMichael apparatus
The great success of the McMichael machine in prac-
tical use is persuasive evidence that Xf{eMichael
was an inventor and entitled to the protection of
Be UE UI oo oale sic asrsavasss tad iasems copies nica gemesaonan

Rg es EF : . aaC tecee eee a errr
The patent describes and claims the invention fully
ET en een en am Cree
The respondents’ apparatus is a complete embodi-
ment of the McMichael invention and is operated
in a manner which fully realizes all of the advan-
tages of the MeMichael invention...
What Hackley, respondents’ engineer, said about the
identity of respondents’ apparatus with that of
MeMichael
The claims in suit accurately describe respondents’
devices

PE ALORA MON IT BRIS

bn ih ati het Sa wc Aae

pect erterstesecorror ALAC ARE OE AR marae

a

il

Tre Peso ARG ..-snicr-cccoseesesnessssevsveveovenssonnvorenswestoovenecssetenes 98
Petitioner’s position is strengthened—not weakened
—by the very number of patents and publications

relied upon by the respondents...........---.-.--:-1sseee 28
The publications .............--..:c-ceccessseseeeseeeees BS esa Es 9
The pricr patents ............-.-.--c-cecssscseercessseseseeesessneneeeescenees 99
Classification of prior art patents...........-.-.--2-.. 30

ances sssisneresvnenesinnonnmienereremmnoneis 30

Liquid flOW ...........0--scc-ceesssssseeseee soseersssnseeenseesnesnnseneeees 31
Discussion of ‘‘kinetie air flotation’’ patents.............. 39
Discussion of ‘‘liquid flow’’ patents...............-.-------...... 34
Liquid flow—cementitious materials...................... 35
Liquid flow—lift pumps .........-.-----------eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeetes 38
Liquid fow—entrained and suspended solids.............. 40
The Smith patent of 1872..................-. sstakisanakaantaiiae 43
The Duckham British patents Nos. 44Q0 of 1875 and

15,348 Of 1885 ............c-cccscscseseee ceoeres Spa erane® Ween 46
The Kolsche German patent..........-.---------:---2s--1ee-2eeee eee 50
The allegation of prior invention and use by Thomas

GS TPAC ..ceccencecescecercoccsess svsscnsonsvenssseceressoesesesscnsecseneseesnes d2

Leake’s sketch does not show a velocity nozzle and
Leake does not claim to have used such a nozzle
in his 1905 experiment ............---.-- ---:-e--eeeeee de
The documents dated after MeMichael’s filing date
which the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals regards
as evidence that Leake invented and used the in-
vention of the patent in suit before MeMichael’s
filing: Cate ...........--.---secseccesesseesseseeeestectenenseenenssenssenaenensess ay)
This is the first ease in which any Federal Court of
the United States has held that the oral testimony
of an alleged prior inventor or prior user—uncor-
roborated and unsupported by contemporaneous
writings, drafings or physical exhibits—is suffi-

ecient to invalidate an issued patent... aT
The law as to proof of alleged prior public use of a
patented invention .......... ela) cicedectaiea name ov

iii

The most that can be said for Leake’s 1905 device
is that it was a discarded and abandoned experi-
TOIIIE csvrevocseneovsseconvnseretinirisneesictininvesoieumenianetasenmmenns.....

These suits involving the McMichael patent are dis-
tinguished from Concrete vy, Gomery, 269 U. 8. 177

MecMichael’s original application adequately sup-
ported the claims in suit—no supplemental oath
was necessary ................... atta enbiitarsiadiainieedigidsdgekes aia

Tested by the rule laid down by this court in the
Kibel Process case, the McMichael patent is enti-
tled to liberal construction...

DON ses sinsssonssvcsnceseinmtnnonasbeismpigvaboeanebuiiaieie co

A new or better theory of operation properly may
be added to a specification in the prosecution of
an application for patent...

APPENDIX: r

The velocity nozzle 20.0.0... ccccsseoeeeeeees ! ieertes
A discussion of the experts’ tests of the *‘slug the-

sty, Pee ne AT oe A aS

61

63

64

66

ODA nae ara eeeres eno.

SYP PE ge ees icermge

PAREN ILS An

iv |

Cases Cited.

: Adamson v. Gilliland, 242 U. 8. 350.0000. 60
k Ball & Roller Bearing Co. v. Sanford Mfg. Co., 297

q I a ee aE 28
4 C. F. Mueller Ce. v. A. Zeregas Sons, 12 Fed. (2d)

i i oe eeee 57
r Cimiotti Unhairing Co. v. American Company, 115

‘ Wiad, Map. COG, WOR arrcissisiccc dh ccs ries 46
Cleveland Co. v. Detroit Co., 12 11 Fed. 853, 857.......... 71

Concrete Appliances Co. ». Gomery, 269 U.S. 177... 5
Concrete Mixing & Conveying Company v. Powers-
Kennedy Contracting Corporation eft al., 27 Fed.
Care MRI scorecbecessiiciccetnacb ate pas adieantann 9
Concrete Mixing & Conveying Company v. Ulen Con-
tracting Corporation et al., 12 ed. (2d) iv? 931.. 2
Deering v. Winona Harvester Works, 155 U. S. 286,

| | Vedete asa aeaiaeaenialaces taeeaetel RELIES Sieh hae 5, 59
Diamond Rubber Company v. Consolidated Rubber

Tire Co., 220 U. S. 428, 435... 0.0.0. ..ecceecee 16, G7, 68, 71
Fibel Process Co. vr. Minnesota & Ontario Paper Co.,

261 U. S. 45, 56; 45 Sup. Ct. Rep. 322..............18, 60, 64
General Electric Co. r. P. R. Mallory & Company,

Be FR, ey i iccckhees. Sacebsnee. cts cenencaeaavenn 6
Herman +. Youngstown Car Mfe. Co., 191 F ed. .

BU prctndaseatecvcsven. chee ee cust dines me etemg eer alae 72
Hobbs v. Beach, 180 U. S, 383. 45 L. Ed. 586.............. 70
Mayer v. A. & H. G. Mutschler, 248 Fed. 911, 914...... ay
Reed v. Cutter, 1 Story 590, 596 ..... PNAS AE ey sl avr BY
Sickles v. Gloucester Mfg. Co., 1 Fish. 222.00... 67
T. BH. Symington Co. v. National Malleable Castings

Cig Se hs Fie cack ceatvessucdiscatatunsraanponande 60
Topliff v. Topliff, 145 U.S. 156, 161; 36 L. Ed. 658;

12 Sup. Ct. Rep. 828.............. nae esede ee 66
Webster Loom Co. 7. Higgins, 105 U.S. 580, 591...... 67

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

No. 528.

CONCRETE MIXING & CONVEYING COMPANY (a Corporation),
eianenn &
vs.

R. C. STORRIE & COMPANY (a Partnership),
Defendants-Respondents.

BRIEF FOR PLAINTIFF-PETITIONER.

Statement.

This cause comes before your Honors by writ of cer-
tiorari.

The judgment to be reviewed is that of the Circuit
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit holding invalid
the McMichael patent No. 1,127,660, granted February
9,1915. The patent (Exhibit Book, p. 4) pertains to the
pneumatic transporation and placement of concrete. The
means of this patent is used, practically to the exclusion
of all other devices, for placing concrete linings in tun-
nels and subways.

The opinion of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals (R.,

oT TEER

x se pe

2

pp. 666-678) is reported at 27 Fed. (2) 838. The trial}
court opinion herein (R., pp. 610-622) is reported at 23
Fed. (2) 131.

The opinion of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals is
in conflict with two prior decisions' of the Second Circuit
Court of Appeals finding the McMichael patent valid,
viz.. Concrete Mixing & Conveying Company v. Ulen
Contracting Corporation et al., 12 Fed. (2) 929-931 (Cir.
cuit Judges Rogers, Hough and Mack), and Concrete
Mixing & Conveying Company v. Powers-Kennedy Con-
tracting Corporation et al., 27 Fed. (2) 668 (Circuit
Judges Manton, Learned Hand and Swan).

Plaintiff-petitioner, Concrete Mixing & Conveying
Company, an Illinois corporation, the owner of the Me-
Michael patent, has been engaged for many years, both
directly and through its principal licensee Ransome Con-
crete Machinery Co., in the manufacture and distribution
of pneumatic concrete placing machines embodying the
MeMichael invention (R., pp. 94 and 124).

Defendants-respondents, a partnership, having a place
of business in the City of Seattle, are charged with in-
fringement of claims 1, 2, 17, 18, 24, 29, 34 and 35 of
the MeMichael patent by the use, at the Skagit River
Project of the City of Seattle, of machines like the one
shown in the drawing, Plaintiff’s Exhibit 13 (Exhibit
Book, p. 84), and the one shown in the Hackley patent
application drawing forming part of Plaintiff’s Exhibit
12 (Exhibit Book, p. 74). The drawing, Exhibit 13,
shows an early form of the respondents’ (Hackley) ma-
chine as used at the Skagit River Project, whereas the
Hackley patent application shows a later and slightly
modified or improved machine which was used on the

1 The decisions of the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in the Ulen and
Powers-Kennedy cases, and the trial court opinions in those cases are
set forth in full in the ‘‘Appendix’’ to the petition for certiorari in the
instant case, :,

meee” ate

same job. The two accused machines are substantially
identical. They differ only with respect to the specific
way in which the air pressure pipes enter the machine

receptacle.

Lower Court Proceedings.

The proceedings of this case in the trial court and in
the Ninth Cireuit Court of Appeals are set forth at pages
6 and 7 of the petition for certiorari in this case.

The proceedings had in the trial courts and in the
Second Cireuit Court of Appeals in the cases of peti-
tioner vs. Ulen Contracting Corporation et al., and
Powers-Kennedy Contracting Corporation et al., are set
forth at pages 8 to 10, inclusive, of the petition for cer-

tiorari herein.

ra a§ coe gee

Questions Presented.

The salient questions (as presented by the petition for
certiorari) are: .
1. Was the Cireuit Court of Appealssfor the Second
Cireuit right when, in the suits of your petitioner versus
(1) Ulen Contracting Corporation et al., and (2) Powers-
| Kennedy Contracting Corporation et al., it found the Mc-
| Michael patent! valid; or
Was the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

1Claims 2, 17, 34 and 35 of the patent were involved in each of the
Courts of Appeals cases, being twice found valid by the Second Cireuit
Court of Appeals and being held invalid by the Ninth Circuit Court of
Appeals. In addition claims 4, 6, 21/22 and 28 were involved in the See-
ond Cireuit cases, and claims 1, 18, 24 and 29 in the Ninth Circuit case.
All claims before the Second Circuit Court of Appeals were held valid,
and all claims before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals were held in-
valid. The conflict between the two Courts of Appeals is fundamental,
and is entirely independent of the fact that each of the Courts of Ap-
peals had before it a few claims of the patent which did not happen to
be before the other court—due chiefly, of course, to minor differences in
the defendants’ structures churged to infringe.

AEST

—

right when, in the present case, it held the McMichael
patent to be invalid?

2. Was the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second
Circuit right in rejecting the Smith patent No. 122,498 of
1872 as a reference against the patent in suit, and in re.
garding the peculiar combination of static and velocity
air pressure means, including the nozzle ‘‘which injects
air into the concrete at its entrance into the discharge
outlet’’ as distinguishing the McMichael invention from
all prior devices not including such a combination and
such a nozzle; or

Was the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
right in finding the McMichael patent anticipated by,

(a) The Smith patent—twhich admittedly dis-
closes no such combination and no nozzle of any
kind.

(b) The alleged 1905 experiment of Thomas
Leake—which admittedly had no ‘such combination
and no nozzle of any kind, and was supported only
by a single uncorroborated and unsubstantiated dep-

4

osition.

(c) The British Patents to Duckham Nos. 4,400
of 1875 and 15,348 of 1885—disclosing machines
which for many reasons are structurally incapable
of handling concrete, and which patents, while mak-
ing passing reference to certain unilustrated air and
water agitator nozzles for stirring mud, do not de-
scribe the location of any kind of a nozzle in the post-
tion required by the McMichael patent and which
years of practical experience with McMichael’s ma-
chine have demonstrated is essential to the success
of a pneumatic placer of concrete?

3. Was the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Cireuit right when it regarded your Honors’ decision in

_—

the case of Concrete Appliances Co. v. Gomery, 269 U.S.
177, as affording a basis upon which to hold the Me-
Michael patent invalid; or

Was the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second Cir-
cuit right when (in the Powers-Kennedy case) it distin-
guished the facts and principles in these suits involving
the McMichael patent from the facts and legal principles
involved in the Gomery’tase ?

5

4. Was the Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Circuit right in holding that the alleged prior invention
and public use of MeMichael’s invention by one Thomas
Leake was established by the verbal testimony of one
witness, given more than twenty years after the alleged
event and uncorroborated by any other witness, or by
any contemporary device, drawing, photograph or other
visible or tangible evidence; or

Was the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second Cir-
cuit right when (in the Powers-Kennedy case) it applied
the established rule of the Supreme Court, as set forth
in Deering v. Winona Harvester Works, 155 U. S. 286,
300, and many other cases, that an alleged prior inven-
tion or public use to defeat an issued patent must be
‘proven by evidence so cogent as to leave no reasonable
doubt in the mind of the court’’?

5. Was the Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Circuit justified in attaching importance to the alleged
1905 experiment of Thomas Leake, notwithstanding
Leake’s testimony that the experiment was discarded and
abandoned iminediately after it was made; or

Was the Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Second Cir-
cuit right when (with reference to the alleged prior pub-
lie use testified to by Artingstall ef al. in the Powers-
Kennedy case) it said:

‘Such casual and abandoned uses do not contrib-

_—~

—_

; ~ e

6

ute to the stock of knowledge which makes up the
art. If we may invalidate a tu such prior
uses so proved, no patent w be safe’’?

6. Was the Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Circuit justified in accepting as competent evidence, rel.
ative to the alleged prior invention and use by Thomas
Leake, certain statements appearing in a Patent Office
preliminary statement (ex parte affidavit) made by Leake
more than a year after MeMichael’s filing date, and cer.
tain statements made more than a year after MeMichael’s
filing date, in Leake’s patent application, by Leake’s
attorney (not called as a witness) or

Is such evidence inadmissible because unfair and in-
competent (as your petitioner contends), being the kind
of unfair and incompetent evidence which was strongly
condemned by the Cireuit Court of Appeals for the See-
ond Cireuit in General Electric Co. v. P. R. Mallory &
Company, 298 Fed, 579, 586?

7. Was Judge Bourquin (and inferentially the Ninth
Cirenit Court of Appeals) right in finding that defend-
ants-respondents’ machines do not infringe the Me-
Michael patent; or

Was the Second Circuit Court of Appeals (and Judge
A. N. Hand) right in finding the McMichael patent in-
fringed by machines which are substantially the same
as the machines used by the respondents in this case!

The Problem Which McMichael Solved.

Concrete is a mixture of rock, sand and cement with
a Varying quantity of water, preferably only sufficient
water to wet the aggregates and hydrate the cement. It
is approximately as heavy as solid rock, and when set
forms artificial rock. These aggregates must be ther
oughly mixed and proportioned, and the mixture must be

7

so intimate that each piece of rock and each particle of
sand is thoroughly covered with cement. This intimate
mixture must be so handled that the aggregates are in
no way separated from each other between the point
where they are mixed and the point where the concrete
is ultimately placed,

Pneumatic conveyors were, of course, known before
MeMichael made his invention, but prior to the MeMichael
invention there was no pneumatic conveyor which in prac-
tice could successfully be used for transporting concrete,
and there was no pneumatic conveyor which operated in
accordance with the plan or principle which is char-
acteristic of the McMichael machine and which is of the
essence of the McMichael invention,

All of the pneumatic conveyors which were known prior
to the McMichael invention fall into cither one or the
other of two generic classes. Firstly, there was that class
of conveyor wherein the conveyed materials are carried
along a conduit in suspension by the kinetic energy of
an air stream. Secondly, there was that class of con-
veyors wherein air is applied to a liquid, or to a fluid mix-
ture of a liquid and entrained solids, to cause the liquid
or fluid mixture to flow as water flows through a hose
or pipe or as tooth paste emanates from its collapsible
container.

Neither of these well known old style types of conveyor
was suitable for conveying concrete. If MeMichael had
merely attempted to convey concrete by utilizing one or
the other of these old style types of conveyor which were
known prior to his invention, his efforts to transport
concrete pneumatically would have proved a failure and
the lining of tunnels, subways and the like, would, in
all probability, still be accomplished by the expensive and
unsatisfactory hand methods which were in vogue prior
to the advent of his invention.

eee

Ree Wo ae

8

Conveyors which cause the conveyed materials to be
carried along in suspension by the kinetic energy of an
air stream serve very well to transport materials such as
grain, ashes, excavated materials, etc., where separation
of the materials is a matter of no consequence, but such
a conveyor would be worse than useless if applied to the
transportation of concrete. It would cause separation of
the rocks, sand, cement and water which constitute con-
crete, and would undo the thorough mixing which all en-
gineers are agreed is absolutely essential to concrete,
Moreover, the quantity and velocity of air required to
hold such heavy materials as rocks in suspension would
entail such an extravagance of power for the supply of
compressed air as to render such a plan wholly uncom-
mercial. With any,available pressure and any practica-
ble strength of condWt nothing would result but a piling
up, a jamming and a plugging up of the entire apparatus.

A conveyor which causes a liquid, or a fluid mixture of
liquid and entrained solids, to flow through a pipe is
totally unsuitable for the conveyance of concrete, because
of the characteristics of concrete. Concrete will not flow
through a pipe; at least with any certainty. It is a mass
of heavy solids, usually only moderately wet. It has an
inherent tendency to bridge or arch! in contracting parts
of the hopper and in the conduit itself, and thus to jam
and block any conduit through which an attempt may be
made to cause it to flow.

MeMichael was confronted with the problem of con-
veying a material, concrete, which for very practical rea-
sons, could not be carried in suspension in an air stream
and which would almost invariably jam and clog in any

1 By ‘‘bridging’’ or ‘‘arching’’ as these words ure used in the record
herein is meant the piling and wedging of pieces of rock against each
other in such a way as to create a stoppage.

pipe through which an attempt might be made to flow it
by pressure applied behind it.

We now know that the types of pneumatic conveyor
known prior to McMichael were unsuitable for his pur-
pose. McMichael is dead and, therefore, cannot tell his
story as to the development of his invention, but it is
clear that he discarded the old types of conveyor, if he
ever attempted to use them, and resorted to a novel
principle of operation which results from a definite ar-
rangement of the various parts of his apparatus,—an
arrangement which is clearly defined by the claims in suit
and which has been followed in the respondents’ (Hack-
ley) machines.

To solve the problem of lifting, conveying and placing
heavy concrete—sometimes called rock in the making—
by air would seem to be sufficient to sustain any patent.
To do this and keep the accurately and intimately
mingled, yet uncombined, coarse and fine aggregates
from separating, was evidently too great a problem for
any engineer or inventor up to McMichael’s time. Yet
MeMichael solved this problem in a manner so simple,
complete and effective that now, many years after his
application for patent, we find his invention in universal
use and no other solution suggested.

The McMichael Apparatus.'

The McMichael apparatus involves:

(a) A closed chamber, in which a heavy mass of con-
crete forming materials may be placed, said chamber
comprising a portion which gradually tapers or con-
verges toward a discharge conduit ;

(b) Means for establishing air pressure upon the

1 The patent appears at Exhibit Book, page 4. Commercial forms of
the MeMichael apparatus are shown at Exhibit Book, pages 90 and 111.

oe

10

mass of concrete within the chamber to crowd and pack
it into the tapering portion of the chamber and toward
the discharge conduit; and

(c) An air nozzle discharging at the point where the
mass packs, due to the pressure behind the mass and the
converging walls of the chamber, to detach or cut off
slugs, or successive portions of the mass, and send them
along the conduit weder pressure without any substan-
tial separation of the rocks, sand and cement constituting
such slug or detached portion.

MeMichael appreciated or ascertained that he could
detach sub-masses or slugs from a compacted mass of
concrete. He, therefore, provided his receptacle with a
tapering portion anterior to the conduit and supplied air
pressure to his receptacle behind the mass inv order to
crowd and pack the concrete into the tapering portion of
the receptacle. The net result of the pressure behind the
mass and the converging walls of the chamber is a com-
pacted mass of concrete at the very beginning of the dis-
charge conduit.

MeMichael then did the thing which experietice has
demonstrated was a master stroke. He applied a velocity
jet of air to the concrete compacted at the point where
the chamber merges into the conduit so that the jet
would successively detach portions or sub-masses of the
compacted concrete and cause them to travel along the
conduit as piston-like parcels, which do not suffer any
substantial separation of thg aggregates of which they
are composed.

The location of the velocity jet at the very point where
the concrete becomes compacted in passing from the
chamber into the conduit is of the very essence of the
MeMichael invention. Regardless of whether or not re-
spondents disagree, or pretend to disagree, with Me-
Michael’s explanation of the mode of operation of his

11

machine, they cannot seriously deny that the location of
the velocity jet, precisely as MeMichael located it, is
absolutely essential in a machine which is to transport
concrete successfully and without separating its aggre-

gates.

The McMichael Apparatus Eliminates Hand Tamping
and Insures Better Concrete Than Can Be Secured
By Any Other Means. This Is One of the Reasons
Why the McMichael Apparatus Is Used to the Exclu-
sion of All Others in Tunnel Work.

Prior to the MeMichael invention, tunnels were lined
entirely by hand, that Jif, by shoveling the concrete to
position behind the tunnel forms and then tamping the
concrete so far as was possible, by projecting the end of
a shovel, a stick or a tamping bar into the space between
the forms and the rough wall of the tunnel.

Of course, it is practically impossible effectively to
hand tamp concrete which has been placed behind tunnel
forms. The walls of the funnel, particularly when cut
through rock as is customary, are jagged and literally
filled with large and irregularly shaped crevices. It is
impossible for a workman standing at the open end of a
tunnel form, to tamp concrete into these irregular crev-
ices. As a result, concrete, as hand placed and hand
famped prior to the MeMichael invention was of uncer.
tain density, frequently contained voids and never com-
pletely filled the crevices in the rough tunnel walls (R.,
p. 107).

The MeMichael apparatus eliminates the necessity for
hand tamping and insures the formation of a well packed,
dense concrete, which completely fills the space between
the forms and the rough wall of the tunnel, and which is
projected under pressure into all of the crevices in the

JEN AG Bao,

12
tunnel wall. This is so because the McMichael apparatus
delivers concrete to the forms with such momentum that
the concrete is automatically packed much more effec.
tively than could be accomplished by any amount of hand
tamping.

The effectiveness with which the McMichael apparatus
packs the concrete which it delivers is due almost entirely
to the peculiar way in which the McMichael apparatus
functions,—i. e., by delivering the concrete in successive
slugs or parcels which are projected behind the tunnel
forms with great momentum,—the product of mass and
velocity. No conveyor of the prior art,—whether it be
one of the conveyors which caused the conveyed mate-
rials to be floated along by the kinetic energy of an air
stream, or whether it be one of the conveyors which
caused mixed and entrained solids to flow in a liquid,
could possibly deliver any material with the momentum
which enables the McMichael apparatus to form perfect
concrete without any necessity for hand tamping. In this
connection, the testimony of Mr. Kirkland (R., p. 107) is
very instructive. Mr. Kirkland testified as follows:

‘*. When the concrete is conveyed through the
duct or conduit of the McMichael apparatus and
reaches the form or the key of a tunnel arch in which
the concrete is to be set, what is the effect of the
discharge of that concrete upon the concrete itself—
the quality and characteristics of the concrete?

‘‘A. The concrete, weighing perhaps a ton is dis-
charged from the end of the pipe into a tunnel form
where concrete has been previously put, and dis-
charges into the previously placed concrete with
such foree, going perhaps 60 miles an hour that it
gives it a tremendous shock so that the whole mass
will quake and it makes a very dense mixture and
packs it in solidly.

‘“(). How does concrete thus formed by the use of
this method and apparatus compare in quality with

13

concrete formed by hand manipulation—put in place
by hand and tamped by hand?

‘‘A. Concrete tamped by hand is very likely to be
porous whereas pneumatic concrete is very dense
and fills up the spaces against the rock much more
tightly than could possibly be done by hand; also in
tunnels where there is timber used, it is necessary to
pack in the concrete in all the vacant spaces. . . .

‘‘Q. How far into a form can concrete be placed
or thrown by hand processes and tamped?

‘“‘A. Just as far as a man can reach with a stick
or shovel to tamp it with.

‘‘Q. How far is that?

‘‘A. A few feet—three or four feet.

‘‘Q. How far can—is concrete carried from the
end of the discharge duct of the McMichael appara-
tus to tne place in the form at which it is to set?

‘‘A. About 20 feet. The ena of the pipe is usually
carried to within 20 feet of the rear of the forms.

‘‘Q. Is the pipe carried over the form and be-
tween the form and the rough interior of the exca-
vated tunnel?

VA... tea on”

The Slug Theory.

MeMichael in his patent carefully pointed out what he
helieved to be the mode of operation of his machine.
MeMichael’s explanation or ‘‘slug theory’’ as it has been
called, has been recognized by the Patent Office, by engi-
neers generally, and by the courts of the Second Circuit,
as a very sound and logical* explanation of why Me-
Michael is able to transport heavy concrete by air
through pipes, even for great distances, without separat-
ing the aggregates of which it is composed. It is the
ouly theory ever advanced which is compatible with the
accomplished fact that MeMichael’s machine does trans-
port concrete by air without separating the aggregates
thereof.

14

Of course, the respondents’ counsel in this case, as did
the defendants in the Second Circuit cases, scoff at the
slug theory. But respondents do not, because they can.
not, advance any counter theory which is reconcilable
with the fact that machines embodying the McMichael in-
vention (respondents’ as well as petitioner’s) do trans-
port concrete by air without separating its aggregates,

In the appendix to this brief we have carefully consid-
ered the petitioner’s tests which substantiate the slug
theory and the test made by respondents which is said
to disprove that theory. We think it abundantly appears
that the slug theory is sound. The important thing to be
borne in mind, however, is that McMichael does trans-
port concrete by air without separating its aggregates.
He does this because his apparatus operates differently
trom the conveyors of the prior art. He does this be-
cause of some peculiar way in which the several parts of
his apparatus co-operate to prevent blecking and tc sep-
aration of the aggregates. Respondents want to get and
do get MeMichael’s result. That is why they place their
velocity nozzle exactly where McMichael taught that it
should be placed and that is why respondents utilize each
and every other essential feature of MeMichael’s ma-
chine.

Even if MeMichael, the Patent Office Examiners, emi-
nent engineers and the Judges of the Second Circuit,
were wrong as to the theory of operation of MeMichael’s
machine, still respondents have used like apparatus, es-
sentially different from any prior device, and accomplish
the same result upon whatever principle or theory these
like machines may operate.

The Second Circuit Court of Appeals, in deciding the
Powers-Kennedy case, hit the nail on the head when, in
referring to the dispute about the ‘‘slug theory,’’ it said:

‘To us the dispute seems irrelevant. The patent

wa

15 |

method of operation. . . . But whether the con-
crete goes forward as we imagine or in some other
manner, there is no sufficient reason to suppose that
defendants’ machine does not operate in the same
manner as plaintiff’s whatever that manner may be.’’
(27 Fed. (2) 670.)

says nothing which commits the patentee to the slug

The Patent Does Not Cover a Theory. The Correctness
of the Inventor’s Statement of the Theory of the In-
vention is Unimportant.

Assuming for the sake of the argument that the re-
spondents contentions in regard*to the so-called ‘‘slug
theory’? are correct and that the machine invented by
McMichael does not in fact operate upon the theory that
he thought it did, such a situation will not vitiate Me-

Michael’s patent. McMichael sought to arrive at a new
result—that of conveying and placing concrete, without
separation of its aggregates, by the use of compressed

air. His patent discloses an operative machine which

achieves the result sought. This is all that the law re-

quires. The law does not require that the practical

minded mechanic who invents a new machine shall know a
the complex and oftentimes obstruse theory upon which
his machine operates.

MeMichael would have heen entitled to his patent had
he never heard of the now controverted ‘*slug theory.’
His patent does not and cannot cover a theory of opera-
tion. It must and does cover the means for arriving at
aresult. This being trne, McMichael should not be de-
prived of the protection to which he is entitled under his
patent merely because he, or his patent solicitor, was a
man of sufficient intelligence to work out a reasonable
hypothesis to explain the functionings of his machine.
(And this is true even though his hypothesis may not
have been the correct one.)

—y

To hold that a patent is invalid because the inventor
does not understand or misstates the theory of operation
of his machine would result in invalidating a large part
of all patents issued. To hold that a patent is invalid
because of the inventor’s faulty conception of the theory
upon which his machine operates would mean that the
theory and not the practical means of arriving at a re-
sult is the thing which is patentable. Indeed, this would
be a peculiar construction of a statute which says that
the things which are patentable are an ‘‘art, machine or
manufacture.’’ It is absurd to read into this statute the
added fertile field of ‘‘theories.’’ If patents are to be
held invalid because of the inventor’s erroneous concep-
tion of a theory of operation to explain his invention, then
it follows that it is the theory which is patentable and
any exponent of a new theory would be entitled to a
patent for that theory itself, regardless of its practica-

16

bility.

The Supreme Court has discussed this matter in its
opinion in the case of Diamond Rubber Company v. Con-
solidated Rubber Tire Co., 220 U. S. 428 (1910), where, on
page 435 U.S., it is stated:

‘*A patentee may be baldly empirical, seeing noth-
ing beyond his experiments and the result; yet if
he has added a new and valuable article to the
world’s utilities, he is entitled to the rank and pro-
tection of an inventor. And how can it take from his
merit that he may not know all of the forces which
he has brought into operation? It is certainly not
necessary that he understand or be able to state the
scientific principles underlying his invention, and it
is immaterial whether he can stand a successful ex.
amination as to the speculative ideas involved. (Cit:
ing numerous authorities.) He must, indeed, make
such disclosure and description of his invention that
it may be put into practice. -In this he must be clear.
He must not put forth a pttzzle for invention or ex-
periment to solve, but-the description is sufficient 1!

17

those skilled in the art can understand it. This sat-
isfies the law, which only requires as a condition of
its protection that the world be given something new
and that the world be taught how to use it. It is no
concern of the world whether the principle upon
which the new construction acts be obvious or ob-
scure, so that it inheres in the new construction.’

The Commercial Success of the McMichael Apparatus.

The evidence herein shows that MeMichael’s apparatus
revolutionized the art of placing concrete in tunnel lin-
ings, and, solely by reason of its great merit, has achieved
remarkable commercial success in the hands of petitioner
and its licensee, the Ransome Concrete Machinery Com-
pany. |

Practically every tunnel of consequence constructed
within recent years has been lined with the MeMichael ap-
paratus (R., pp. 101 and 103),

Kirkland, chief engineer of Concrete Mixing and Con-
veying Company, and Robinson, sales manager of the
Ransome Company, testified concerning the many large
tunnels in connection with which the MeMichael appara-
tus has been or is being used (R., pp. 99 and 124) and
each of these witnesses produced a list of the more im-
portant tunnel projects for which the Concrete Mixing
and Conveying Company and the Ransome Company
have furnished the McMichael apparatus (see lists, Ex-
hibit Book, pp. 92 and 96).

Prior to the advent of the MeMichael invention, tun-
nels were lined by hand. Concrete was shoveled and
tamped by hand behind the tunnel forms. Progress was
slow and expensive. The MeMichael apparatus will line
& tunnel in but a fraction of the time required for hand
Placement, and will do a much better job, because it car.
ries the concrete to its final position with great momen-

18

tum and packs the concrete so tightly that hand tamping
is not required.

The McMichael apparatus not only entirely displaced
the former hand methods of concrete placement in tunne!
linings and like situations, but in so doing, reduced the
cost of placing it by one-third to one-half (R., p. 101),

All in all, the testimony in this case, as did the testi-
mony in the Second Circuit cases, fully justifies the state
ment of Judge Augustus N. Hand, in his opinion in the
Ulen case, that:

‘‘The McMichael invention is a most interesting
one and has apparently met with general acceptance.

‘*.)6. His device has displaced all other
methods for rapidly and economically conveying,
lifting and placing concrete at long distances from
the initial source of supply, and has been used in
numerous great enterprises.’’ (12 Fed. (2) 931.)

The Great Success of the McMichael Machine in Practical
Use Is Persuasive Evidence that McMichael Was An
Inventor and Entitled to the Protection of the Patent
Law.

The great practical value of the McMichael machine
and the commercial success which it has achieved are
very persuasive evidence that McMichael exercised in-
vention in its production.

In the case of Eibel Process Co. v. Minnesota & Ontarw
Paper Co., 261 U. 8. 45, 56, 43 Sup. Ct. Rep. 322, this
court, by Mr. Chief Justice Taft, said:

‘*The fact that the Eibel pitch has thus been gen
erally adopted in the paper making business, and that
the daily product in paper making has thus been m-
creased at least 20 per cent. over that which had
been achieved before Eibel, is very weighty evidence
to sustain the presumption from his patent that what
he discovered and invented was new and useful.

, 19 vr

And he also says:

«| , and the final fact that, when he made known
his discovery, all adopted his remedy, leave no doubt
in our minds that what he saw and did was not ob-
vious, and did involve discovery and invention.’’

THE PATENT IN SUIT.'

The Patent Describes and Claims the Invention Fully and
Accurately.

An understanding of the subject-matter of the Me.
Michael patent can easily be arrived at by quoting some
of its characteristic claims. Eight claims (1, 2, 17, 18,
24,29, 34 and 35) are involved in suit. We shall quote
but two of them.

Claim 2 reads as follows:

‘2. In combination, a chamber for containing con-
crete forming materials, a conduit leading therefrom,
a compressed air inlet pipe connected to a part of the
chamber remote from the conduit, and another com-
pressed air inlet pipe leading through the chamber
wall and terminating within the chamber near the
opening into the conduit in 1 nozzle directed toward
said opening.’’

Claim 17 (another of the claims in suit) refers more
specifically to the peculiar construction and arrangement
which produces the effect of detaching and delivering the
mass in ‘‘ successive portions,’’ It reads:

‘17. In a device for treating and moving a mass
of concrete forming materials, the combination of a
chamber for receiving and containing the said mass,
a discharge duct connected with the chamber, an air
inlet pipe connected with the chamber, means for
preventing the flow of air or materials, out of the
chamber except through the discharge duct, means
for supplying air under pressure through the said

1 The patent appears at page 4 of the Exhibit Book.

20

pipe to the chamber back of the mass of materials
therein to puSh the said mass toward and into the
discharge duct, and means for causing a jet of air
to inpinge upon successive portions of the mass ip
the general direction of the discharge duct to di-
rectly assist their movement therethrough.’’

The material—concrete—to the handling of which the
improvements are appropriated, and limited by the pat.
ent, is defined as follows (Spece., p. 2, lines 100-108):

‘“ As is well known, the material referred to as con-
crete is a composition containing relatively large
pieces of rock or stone, as uniform in size as pos-
sible, together with predetermined proportions of
sand, cement and water. The purpose of this com-
position is, ultimately, to have, in a desired position,
a hard rock-like body which will resist disintegration
and fracture.’’

This material may be mixed in any desired proportions,
and may be of any desired consistency, but one of the
objects of the invention is to enable the user to use a
relatively stiff or ‘‘dry’” concrete mixture, in which a
minimum of water is employed, as that has been con-
sidered the ideal mixture for many years> Thus the
specification says (p. 3, lines 42-55) :

‘‘One of the important advantages incident to the
use of a device embodying my invention is that this
undesirable excess of water can be reduced to a minl-
mum or entirely eliminated, satisfactory coating of
the rock pieces being found to be possible when the
binding material is relatively stiff. While an appa-
ratus embodying my invention is especially well
adapted for the handling of a mass of concrete form-
ing elements containing little or no excess of water,
it will be understood that its use is not limited to
the handling of such a mass.”’

The operation of the invention is fully described in the
specification, and particularly at page 2, lines 45-100, from
which we quote in part:

‘‘It will be observed that the upper air pipe 8

a 2 ARR EER ARTLINE a

21

serves merely to supply air to the upper part of the
chamber 1, the pressure of the air being uniformly
applied over the entire upper surface of the mass.
The lower pipe 10, however, serves to direct a jet
of air moving at a considerable velocity directly
against portions of the mass as they move toward

~ and into the discharge duct. The two pipes thus act
in very different ways, the upper pipe supplying air
which acts by pressure and the lower pipe supplying
air which acts by velocity. . . . Air from the
lower pipe 10 may force itself into the body of the
mass, and the relatively small air jet acting upon the
relatively large stream of outward moving materials
directly engages with the sub-masses to push them
along.”’

A further description of the construction and operation
will be found elsewhere in the specification.

Referring to the drawing of the patent, 1 is the re-
ceiving chamber for the concrete, 2 the smooth, tapering
portion leading to the outlet, 3 and 5 the charging open-
ing and door respectively, 4 the head of the chamber, 6
an air reservoir, 7 the air compressor, 8 the pipe sup-
plying compressed air near the top of the chamber and
9 the valve controlling it, 10 the air pipe for supplying
the jet of air near the outlet of the chamber and 11 the
valve controlling it, and 13 the discharge conduit.

In the embodiment shown in the patent, there is a small
pipe 12 leading into the chamber for water, which ‘‘may
be” used ‘‘as a lubricant’”’ (Spec., p. 1, lines 99-102) and
the discharge conduit has a U-bend 14 in it so that the
concrete masses will be ‘‘more or less tightly packed”’
(Spec., p. 1, line 97), as they leave the chamber. Water
is usually supplied before the concrete is placed in the
chamber, and the U-bend is omitted in most cases, as the
resistance of the discharge pipe has been found sufficient
to pack the concrete. The bend, however, is still used by
the petitioner in some eases (R., p. 122).

The conveying conduit shown in the patent extends up-

f
j

22

wardly, and in all or nearly all cases will extend upwardly
more or less to reach the top of the tunnel or other work
but it may extend entirely on a level (Spec., p. 4, line
82).

While the particular action of the invention in hand.
ling conerete is described in the patent and has heen
brought out fully in the testimony, to show that the in-
vention involves a principle of operation entirely its own,
the claims are not all limited to this precise mode of oper.
ation. In a broad sense, the invention is characterized by
the fact that it first reduces the concrete to a compact
mass and then conveys and delivers it by combined pres.
sure and nozzle action. And it does this with relatively
low air pressure, pressures of 80 to 100 Ibs. per square
inch being employed.

The Respondents’ Apparatus Is a Complete Embodiment
of the McMichael Invention and Is Operated in a Man-
ner Which Fully Realizes All of the Advantages of the
McMichael Invention.

The drawings opposite this page, show how completely
the respondents have copied MeMichael’s invention.

The first drawing is taken from the McMichael patent.
The second illustrates an early form of the respondents’
apparatus which was used on the Skagit River job, and
the third drawing, taken from the Hackley patent, shows
a later machine also used by the respondents on the
Skagit River job.

The apparatus of the patent is a ‘‘vertical’’ machine,
whereas each of the respondents’ machines is ‘‘hori-
zontal.’’? The horizontal type of machine is more convell-
ent when the apparatus is used in tunnels having little
head room. This form, along with the vertical type, 18

ee tee Mee eee ee eS ee es ks Ts EX ReaD

4

PATENT IN SUIT

AiR INLET ~- REMOTE FROM COMOW/T

f CLOSED FRECEPTACLE

thy

)

ys

AY COMPRESSED AIR

M / SEMNO MASS OF CONCRETE
sr \ Ra Pek
in pA xs BS
@ —~ my’ - 4 Sy

/WVetociTy NOZZLE __
ACTING OW COMPACTED MMATERIALS.

| TAPERED PORTION __OF KECEPTACLE.

RESPONDENTS’

a I. THE MACHINE

OxENHAM SAW ON OCTOBER I0T 1923
(RECORD P 78)

COMPRESSED AIR
\ BEHIND MWIASS OF COIYCRETE.

CLOSED RECEPTACLE

TAPERED PORTION
OF RECEPTACLE

9 4%
NSS, | ‘I SSN
U
4
Y
;
4
UN

Yt OPS

=
d re — = ft ¢ 40 oath
“ ZR WANG SUOTETAD ITT TE

‘as >

4

CONDUIT
Air INLET -REMOTE FROM CONOU/T.
x
VetociTY NOZZLE \

ACTING ON COMPACTED MATERIALS.

RESPONDENTS’ bye APPARATUS

| I. THE MACHINE II. THe MaAcnine
\OxENHAM SAW ON OCTOBER 10% 1923 or tHe Hacker PATENT “1619,297
(RECORD P 78) (ExHiIBIT BOOK P 78)

Arso useo BY RESPONDENTS
ON THE SKaaitT River Jos.

COMPRESSED A/R COMPRESSED’ AIR. .
GEAINOD MASS OF COLYCRETE. BEHIVD MASS OF CONCRETE

ee a

TAPERED FORTION CLOSED RECEPTACLE

OF RECEPTACLE
CLOSED RECEPTACLE |

SSS

|
i

aA TAPERED PORTION tS ase
AN ae 27) SSH OF RECEPTACLE aot | ee ae CP ED ED ED SESE ob «> aD —-- boa — we £_— a

RAL VPS SV Ree eee tes

AANA

CONDUIT

ie INLET -KEMOTE FROM CONOU/7,

VesociTy NOZZLE \ bvecoci7y NOZZLE
ACTING ON COMPACTED PIATERIALS. AC T/NG ON COMTPACTED 4A TERIALS.

AiR INLET - REMOTE FROM CONOUT-

Stew Sete EP ARSE OE TER OLLI, = LILES A NELLIS LEN ELT ET IE EER SE ' id 1S Nem aerrwet

23

also used by petitioner’s licensee (see illustrations of
Ransome Apparatus, Plaintiff’s Exhibits Nos. 22 and
04—Exhibit Book, pp. 102 and 105). Furthermore, this
‘‘horizontal’’ type of machine is the kind of machine
which Judge A, N. Hand, and the Cireuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Second Circuit, found to infringe the Me-
Michael patent in the Ulen case (see drawing on page
181, Ulen R., Plaintiff’s Exhibit 4).

It is perfectly obvious that, except for certain imma-
terial differences peculiar to the horizontal type, the re-
spondents’ (Hackley) machine is nothing more nor less
than the device of the McMichael patent turned on its
side.

Both the apparatus of the patent and respondents’
apparatus comprise receptacles which converge or taper
toward the discharge conduit. Kach apparatus is pro-
vided with a sturdy door to permit the insertion of the
concrete to he conveyed and to withstand the pressures
which are created above and behind the mass of concrete
when compressed air is admitted to the receptacle
through the several compressed air pipes. Each appara-
tus has a velocity nozzle disposed at the point which Me-
Michael ascertained was the necessary point,i.e., the point
at‘which the concrete is compacted, and where it tends to
arch and jam, due to the influence of the pressure in the
receptacle and its tapering walls. The devices are prac-
tically identical. As one operates so must the others.

It was suggested in the courts below that since in re-
spondents’ machines the air inlet pipes ‘‘remote from
the conduit’’ are located in the lower part of the cham-
ber, there might not be ‘‘pressure above the mass’’ of
concrete in the chamber. It seems obvious, however, that
air pressure must and does build up in the chamber, re-
gardless of whether the air for this purpose is admitted
at the top or at the bottom. Indeed, in the Powers-

24

Kennedy case, one of the machines used by the defend.
ants relied solely upon air admitted through the velocity
nozzle to build up a pressure above the mass of concrete
in the chamber. Of this machine, Judge A. N. Hand ip
his opinion, correctly said:

‘*There is undoubtedly a pressure behind the mass
in defendants’ machine far greater than ordinary
air pressure and varying according to the freedom
with which the air in the outlet tube is passing
through it. . . . If this were not so, the hi

pressure through the discharge pipe would hold back
the concrete.’’ (Exhibit Book, p. 31.)

What Hackley, Respondents’ Engineer, Said About the
Identity of Respondents’ Apparatus With That of
McMichael.

If any reasonable doubt could exist as to the absolute
similarity of the respondents’ devices and that of the
MeMichael patent, the doubt would be dispelled by con-
sideration of the very accurate description given of the
respondents’ (Hackley) machine by Mr. Roy C. Hackley
at the time he made application for patent thereon. The
drawing avd specification as originally filed by Mr.
Hackley ja 1924 are in evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 12
(Exhibit Book, p. 32). Mr. Hackley, the designer of the
respondents’ machines, reviewed this original specifica-
tion and its accompanying drawing when he took the
stand in this case and testified that they properly de-
scribe and illustrate the machine which was used by the
respondents at the Skagit River Project (R., pp. 72 and
73).

Mr. Hackley, in his said original patent specification,
and in referring to the drawing accompanying it, says:

‘It consists of an elongated container which is
substantially egg-shaped in cross-section, as shown

.

in Fig. 4. The container is provided with a filling
opening through which each batch of concrete is de-
livered, and the opening is in turn provided with a
closure, such as generally indicated at 30, which is
securely fastened when air under pressure is deliv-
ered to the interier of the container. The forward
end of the container is provided with a cone-shaped
nozzle, as shown at 31, and this in turn flanged as
| indicated at 32, to permit the steel discharge-pipe to
be connected thereto. A smooth, continuous, unin.
terrupted passage is thus formed between the inte-
rior of the container and the discharge-pipe, and
choking or blocking of the nozzle is thus prevented.
‘One of the air-pipes leads to the nozzle of the
container, while the remaining pipes, indicated at
34, 35 and 36, terminate at intermediate points.
They extend through the rear head and are extended
to advanced position, the pipe 34 terminating di-
rectly in the nozzle,' the pipe 35 at a point approxi-
mately one-half of the length of the container, and
soon. The air discharging from the pipe 34 insures
a pressure in the discharge-pipe, and it also applies
air to the concrete at or near the point where it es-
capes from the main container. This causes the
mass of concrete to discharge with considerable
velocity and to travel in the general direction of the
discharge pipe. It furthermore insures agitation
and mixing of the sand, cement and rock, and as
such produces a uniform coating of the rock in the
mixture. The air furthermore mixes with the con-
crete and as such prevents it from discharging as a
solid mass. In fact, the concrete delivered to the
container is advanced forwardly by the pressure
exerted by the air discharging from the pipes indi-
cated at 35 and 36, but as the pipe 34 is disposed
directly in the nozzle, the mass is broken up into
portions which are driven ahead under high velocity
by the jet of air discharging from the pipe 34, t iis
being of considerable importance, as it positively
prevents choking or blocking up of the apparatus.’’
(Exhibit Book, p. 44.) (Emphasis ours.)

1 **Nozzle’’ as here used means the tapering portion of the receptacle.

ae > Une ar-aRves Ty
26

When Mr. Eackley filed his original patent applica.
tion, he swore that the foregoing was a clear, concise and
exact description of his invention, viz., the apparatus
which was used by the respondents at the Skagit River
tunnel. It was just that. Moreover, it is an excellent
description of a machine embodying the invention of the
McMichael patent in suit. Hackley’s specification and
drawing not only show it to be an embodiment of the
MeMichael invention, so far as its structural characteris-
tics are concerned, but also points out that the device
operates in accordance with the plan or principle which
MeMichael and the plaintiff have always attributed to
the apparatus of the patent in suit.

This Hackley patent application was filed on March 26,
1924. His machine had been in use at the Skagit River
Project at least five or six months before this application
was filed. (Oxenham saw the Hackley machine in opera-
tion on October 13, 1923, R., p. 78.) Therefore, Hackley
was describing bis machine on the basis of experience
when he filed his patent application.

After the filing of this suit in April, 1924, Hackley’s
attorneys (representing respondents herei) rewrote the
Hackley specification in a belated attempt‘to make it
appear that the Hackley device operaies differently from
that of McMichael, notwithstanding that the devices of
Hackley and MeMichael comprise the same elements, ar-
ranged in the same way, and therefore must operate in
the same manner. The original Hackley specification was
written at a time when Hackley and his attorneys had
no motive for misstating the operation of the machine.
The specification was changed to the form in which it
appears in the Hackley patent (Exhibit Book, p. 78)
after this suit had been brought and at a time when
Hackley and his counsel were more concerned with meet-
ing what they conceived to be the exigencies of this case

Ce LL bh Re aR

than :hey were in having the Hackley patent properly
describe the machine which it illustrates.

27

The Claims in Suit Accurately Describe Respondents’
Devices.

Each and every of the claims in suit is for an appara-
tus, and each of these claims (1, 2, 17, 18, 24, 29, 34 and
35) reads upon and accurately describes each of the ma-
chines which respondents used at the Skagit River tun-
nel, 7. e., the device shown in the drawing, Plaintiff’s Ex-
hibit 13 (Exhibit Book, p. 84), and the later and slightly
modified machine shown in the Hackley patent applica-
tion drawing (Exhibit Book, p. 83).

Applying claim 1, for example, to the drawing, Exhibit
15, we have the following:

‘In combination, a chamber for containing con-
crete forming materials (the respondents’ device, of
course, has such a chamber), a conduit leading
therefrom (the respondents’ device has the conduit),
and having its walls joining the chamber walls with
substantial smoothness (the respondents’ conduit
obviously does join the chamber walls in this
fashion), and two compressed air inlet pipes con.
nected to the chamber (the velocity nozzle located
directly in the tapering exit end of respondents’ con-
| tainer is the terminal of one of these pipes; the other
| pipe may be any one of the other pipes entering the
| chamber,—for instance the pipe which enters the
lower part of the rear end of the chamber), one of
them terminating in a nozzle (the velocity nozzle)
inside the chamber (like in McMichael’s patent, re-
spondents’ said nozzle is located inside the tapering
part of the chamber) directed toward the opening
into the said conduit and the other pipe opening into
the chamber at a point remote from said nozzle.’’
(The aforesaid pipe which enters the lower end of
the rear wall of respondents’ chamber is certainly
‘‘remote’’ from the velocity nozzle.)

EN CE heer ees se GT Se: Seay yen .

28

Each of the other claims in suit is Just as aptly and
accurately descriptive of the respondents’ machines as is
claim 1 above quoted.

There is no escape from the conclusion that each of
the respondents machines infringes the claims in suit, if
your Honors find that the claims in suit are valid.

THE PRIOR ART.

Petitioner’s Position Is Strengthened—Not Weakened—
by the Very Number of Patents and Publications Relied
Upon by the Respondents.

At the trial respondents placed in evidence literally
hundreds of pages of printed matter in the form of pat-
ents and excerpts from periodicals. Only a portion of
these are included in the enormous Exhibit Book in this
case. The answer and amended answer plead 166 prior
patents and 80 printed publications in alleged anticipa-
tion of McMichael.

It is obvious that if counsel for respondents had a sin-
gle good reference, or even a fair reference, he would
have been content to rely upon it, and would not have
loaded the record with the appalling number of prior
patents and publications which it now contains.

Respondents’ counsel in offering dozens of patents
and dozens of publications and scores of pages of depo-
sitions concerning alleged uses of sulphur mining appa-
ratus, dredgers, grout and paint shooters, ete.. is simply
trying to ‘‘make omelettes of bad eggs,’’ to use ihe words
of his Honor Judge Hough in Ball & Roller Bearing Co.
v. Sanford Mfg. Co., 297 Fed. 163, 167, wherein it was
said: .

‘‘The voluminous record at bar is the best (or
worst) example recently presented to us of useless

oe

and misleading references to earlier patents and
publications. It seems necessary to apply to patent
litigation from time to time the maxim that one can-
not make omelettes of bad eggs--no matter how
many are used. One good reference is better than
fifty poor ones, and the fifty do not make the one
any better.’’

The Publications.

The many publications, in the form of excerpts from
domestic and foreign periodicals, proceedings of techni-
cal societies, ete., offered in evidence by the respondents,
add nothing to what is shown by the many patents upon
which the respondents also rely. Kor the most part the
publications have only to do with uses, here or there, of
apparatus such as is shown in one or more of the patents.
We shall, therefore, refrain from analyzing the publica-
tions. The patents actually disclose all and more than
can possibly be gleaned from the publications, no matter
how carefully the latter may be studied.

The Prior Patents.

At ap earlier point in this brief, we stated that the
pneumatic conveyors which preceded McMichael, and
which were unsuitable for his purpose, belong to two
generic classes. Firstly, there is that class of conveyor
wherein the conveyed materials are carried along a con-
duit in suspension by the kinetic energy of an air stream,
or, in other words, are carried as dust is blown in the
wind. Secondly, there is that class of conveyors where-
in air is applied to a liquid, or to a fluid mixture of liquid
and entrained solids, to cause the liquid or fluid mixture
to flow as water flows through a hose or pipe or as tooth
paste emanates from the familiar collapsible container.

ee

30

The twenty-five patents of the prior art which were
offered in evidence by the respondents at the trial, fall
into these two generic classes, as shown by the classiti-
eation following this paragraph. In this classification
conveyors of the type which transport materials through
a conduit in suspension by the kinetic energy of an air
stream appear under the heading ‘‘\inetie Air Fota-
tion.’’ Those patents which disclose conveyors in which
liquids, or fluid mixtures-of liquids and entrained solids,
are caused to flow, appear under the generic heading
‘*Liquid Flow.’’ There are twenty patents in this last
mentioned group which, for convenience, we have divided
into three sub-groups, ?. ¢., the patenfs showing devices
which handle cementitious materials constitute one sub-
vroup, the patents which show lift pumps constitute a
second sub-group, and the patents which show devices
which cause the flow of a fluid murture of liquid and en-
trained and suspended solids (other than cementitious
materials) constitute a third sub-group.

Classification of Prior Art Patents.

Kinetic Air FLoTation.

Goldie, 707,840—dry cement (p. 514).!

Sickels, 99,360—sand and earth from caissons (p. 614).

Warren, 671,303—sand blast (p. 650).

Butler, 660,946—sand for locomotive sand boxes (p.
654).

Kolsche German, 18,394—sand, granules and coal-slack
(p. 658).

1 The pages given are those of the Exhibit Book.

31

Liquip Fiow.

Cementitious Materials.

Smith, 122,498—so-called ‘‘Liquid’’ concrete of a con-
sistency which will flow through valves and “settle to a
perfectly level surface’’ (p. 484).

Goldie, 676,128—grout (p. 498).
Goldie, 676,129—grout (p. 506).
Moir, 778,878—lime grout (p. 520).
Canniff, 873,345—grout (p. 544).
Mellvrid, 958,421—grout (p. 560).

Lift Pumps.

Pohle, 487,639—water ( p. 566).

Saunders, 597,023—water ( p. 572).

Frasch, 799,642—liquid sulphur (p. 582).

Frasch, 800,127—liquid sulphur (p. 590).

Frizell, 233,499—water (p. 636).

Harris, 759,100—deep well fluids (water-oil) (p. 640).
Harris, 814,601—water (p. 644).

Entrained and Suspended Solids.

Duckham British, 4400/75—mud or spoil from dredges
(p. 598).

Duckham British, 15,348/85—mud or spoil from
dredges (p. 606).

Hussey, 497,427—water and mud from dredges,
“gravel, mud, debris and other materials” (p. 662).

Hussey, 526,530—water and mud from dredges,
“ground, gravel and other debris in water”’ (p. 670).

Rix & Donahoo, 635,270—water and spoil from dredges
‘p. 618),

Church, 487,606—alabastine paint ‘‘atomization by air
‘pray nozzle’? (p, 624).

Discussion of ‘‘Kinetic Air Flotation’’ Patents.

Of the five patents in this group, two of them, namely,
Goldie 707,840 and the Warren patent, were urged upon
his Honor Judge Hand in hoth of the prior suits involv.
ing the McMichael patent, and the Kolsche German pat.
ent was pleaded but not put in evidence. (See records in
Ulen and Powers-Kennedy cases, Plaintiff’s Physical
Exhibits 4 and 11.)

The Sickels and .3utler patents do not differ essentially
from the others of this generic class of kinetic devices,

in all of these devices the material to be conveyed,
whether it be dry cement, as in the Goldie patent, sand
from a sand blast machine, as in the Warren patent,
slack, sandy or granular material, as in Kolsche, is car-
ried along im suspension due to the kinetic energy of a
moving current of air. The material conveyed is swept
along as dust is carried by the wind in a storm. Ina de:
vice of this kind the lighter particles of the conveyed
material are, of course, carried ahead of the heavier par-
ticles. All of these patents disclose devices which operate
in accordance with a principle—kinetiec air flotation—
which renders them totally unsuitable for use in the trans-
portation of concrete. Incidentally, if either McMichael
or respondents used kinetic conveyors (which, of course,
they do not) the volume of air consumed would be colos-
sal,—the expenditure for compressing and supplying that
air would be prohibitive. It would take an enormous
volume of air traveling at fearful velocity to carry as
heavy a material as concrete in suspension.

The Goldie patent No. 707,840 shows a proposed method
of placing cement under railroad ties by first raising each
tie and then blowing dry cement—an almost impalpable
powder—along with moisture, under the tie. There is no

tina:

pressure back of or behind the material and no material

to be acted on as a mass, The dry cement passes out of

the vessel by gravity alone, and the material is conveyed

and delivered in a completely disintegrated state. The
apparatus is not adapted to be used and could not be

used to handle any material in the manner provided by

the patent in suit, and is not adapted nor intended to be

used with concrete for any purpose,

The Sickels patent No. 99,360 shows a scheme for lift-

ing excavated materials ont of a caisson by a current of

air blowing into the lower end of a pipe which projects

into a caisson chamber in which a workman digs. When

the comparatively gentle blast which blows through the

pipe due to the working pressure of the caisson is not
sufficient to pick up the materials, the velocity of air
through the pipe may be increased by opening a valve g.

The Sickels arrangement obviously taught nothing to
MeMichael or any one interested in transporting concrete

without sparating its aggregates.

The Warren patent No. 671,303 shows a sand blast ma-

chine of the conventional type, wherein sand flows down

into a rapidly moving air stream and is carried along

in suspension due to the velocity of the air.
The Butler patent No, 660,946 shows a pumping appa-
ratus for water or sand. The patent shows two devices, |
one for water and the other for sand. This patent dis- .
closes nothing more than a small pipe adapted to be pro-
jected more or less into a sand or water receptacle, and ;
which is provided with an air injector tube to establish
4 vacuum at the intake end of the pipe and establish a
draft in the pipe to cause the transmission of the water
or sand to be conveyed. When handling sand, the Butler
device is a kinetic conveyor. When used with water, it
has the characteristics of an ordinary water lift.

33

a a Tree

= —

34

The Kolsche German patent No, 18,394 shows a typical
velocity conveyor of the kind commonly used for trans.
porting sand, grain and other granular materials which
feasibly can be blown along in a pipe as dust is carried
in the wind, In the Kolsche device the materials to be
conveyed drop down into a current of rapidly moving air
and are swept along in suspension by that current to the
place of deposit. This is an excellent example of a kinetic
conveyor,—totally unsuitable for the conveyance of con.
crete. It is one of the patents said by Judge Bourquin
to be anticipatory of MeMichael. (The Ninth Cireuit
Court of Appeals did not mention it.) We have therefore
considered this patent in more detail, at a later point in
the brief, under the heading ‘*The Koische German
Patent.”’

Discussion of ‘‘Liquid Flow’’ Patents.

The patents of this generie group differ considerably
as to details of construction, but they all have one thing
in common which distinguishes them from the concrete
conveyor of the MeMiehael patent and renders them to-
tally unsuitable for the conveyance of concrete—they all
contemplate carrying the conveyed material as a fluid,
i. ¢., as a liquid or as a fluid mixture of a liquid and en-
trained solids.

Counsel for respondents has gone beyond all reason
in the citation of prior art patents, and as is to be ex-
pected has cited a number of patents in this class of
‘Liquid Flow’’ which counsel in the Second Cireuit cases
wisely did not see fit to cite. It is interesting to note
that many of the representative patents of this group
upon which counsel relies in this case were presented in
the Eastern cases, i. 2., the Smith patent 122,498, the
Goldie patent 676,128, the Canniff patent 873,545, the

- ~- - — © eo el
. = - - -

Mellvrid patent 958,421, and the Church patent 487,606
(see records in Ulen and Powers-Kennedy cases, Plain-
tiff’s Physical Exhibits Nos, 4 and 11), It is also inter-
esting to note that during the prosecution of the Me-
Michael application the Patent Office considered the Pohle
water-lift patent No. 347,196, which is representative of
all of the patents in the sub-class of ‘‘Lift Pumps’’ upon
which counsel for respondents velies in this case (see
action of Jan, 24, 1907, MeMichael file-wrapper, Exhibit
Book, p. 205).

Liquid Flow—Cementitious Materials.

Of the six patents in this sub-group only two (Goldie
676,129 and Moir 778,878) were not presented in the New
York cases.

All of the six patents in this sub-group are intended to
handie liquids which do contain cementitious materials,
but are fluids nevertheless. Ali of the patents in this
sub-group, except the Smith patent, have to do with
handling grout. Grout is simply a fluid mixture, some-
times a plastic fluid mixture, which can be easily forced
through a pipe, even a very small pipe, by pressure ex-
erted upon the fluid mixture, in a container from which
it is to be ejected. The Smith patent is intended to
handle a so-called ‘‘liquid conerete’’ of a consistency
such that it will flow through valves and ‘‘settle to a
perfectly level surface.’’ None of the parties whose pat-
ents are included in this sub-group was concerned with
the transmission of a material having the physical char-
acteristics of ordinary concrete. More important, none
of these patents discloses any arrangement of parts
which will act upon a conveyed material as does the
structure of the MeMichael patent. No one of the patents
in this sub-group discloses anything even remotely sug-

a

ilies

36

gestive of McMichael’s velocity jet, which acts upon a
mass of concrete at the very point where it is compacted
at the ingress end of the conveyor conduit. |

The Smith patent No. 122,498 is one which the Ninth
Circuit Court of Appeals regards as anticipatory of Me-
Michael, notwithstanding that this patent was considered

and found not anticipating by the Second Circuit Court
- of Appeals in the Powers-Kennedy case (see Powers-
Kennedy R., Plaintiff’s Physical Exhibit 11). There.
fore, we have given it special consideration under the
heading ‘‘The Smith Patent of 1872.”’

The Goldie patent No. 676,128. Goldie says in his pat-
ent (p.,/3, line 43) that it is his intention ‘‘to form a
plastic body of cement of grout sufficiently fluid to flow
from the basin into the feed pipe 14.’’ The ingredients
to form a fluid grout are placed in an ordinary funnel
which is provided at its lower end with a stop cock.
After the materials have flowed down out of the funnel,
in the delivery pipe, the stop cock is shut off and air is
pumped into the delivery pipe with a hand pump to cause
the grout to flow under railroad ties. This patent simpiy
fails to disclose any of the essential features ofgthe Mc-
Michael invention.

The Goldiz patent No. 676,129 shows an apparatus
which is identical with the apparatus shown in the other ,
Goldie patent 676,128. It is not believed that Goldie in-
tended the disclosures of these patents to be different in
any respect. One covers a method of injecting grout
under railway ties, and the other covers the apparatus
employed in carrying out that method.

The Moir patent No. 778,878 discloses a structure .
wherein a piston operating in a, cylinder acts directly
upon a fluid mixture of ‘‘lime grout, lime cement or other
viscous fluids’’ to cause them to flow through a pipe,—
exactly as tooth paste flows out of its container, or as

e , >

37

grease flows out of a grease gun. The Moir structure
lacks all of the essentials of the McMichael combination.
It has absolutely nothing in the way of a velocity jet act-
ing upon a compacted mass of materials at a particular
place for a definite purpose. If the Moir patent is of
any significance in this case, it is only because it shows
that the handling of fluid grout is an entirely different
proposition than the handling of concrete. Grout is a
true fluid and can be squeezed out of a compressor of the
piston type just like grease or any other material which
will flow.

The Canniff patent No. 873,345 shows another device
for handling fluid grout. Canniff developed a device
which was a very successful grout mixer and conveyor
and which is being used by the Ransome Company and |
others to the present day. It is generally recognized as
an excellent grouting machine. But Canniff never con- *
templated that it should be used for handling concrete.
It is not adapted for handling concrete, and has never
been practically used for that purpose. The mode of
operation of the Canniff machine is essentially different ;
from that of the McMichael apparatus. Canniff first in-
jects air into the fluid mixture of grout to mix it. After
this mixing has been accomplished, he causes the fluid
mixture to flow out of the apparatus by a pressure of air ’
exerted upon the mass. Being a true fluid, the grout will |

a El |

BY Alka I9 89

wy PFOA OPMG AT eHEn Ta NMW At pad oF 20 AEH

flow perfectly out of an apparatus of this kind. Respond-
ents put in some testimony to show that they did cause
something which might be called ‘‘concrete’’ to flow out :
of something which they called the Canniff apparatus.
The alleged Canniff device which respondents employed
was, however, a reconstructed Canniff device. It is of
unknown origin,—possibly constructed within recent
years. Even if it did eject concrete after a fashion that
is a matter of no consequence in this case, because the

Bet cc nt tanta... .

yj

Canniff apparatus, even in the reconstructed form in
which respondents attempted to use it fer concrete, can-
not and does not operate as does the McMichael appara-
tus. It does not comprise the peculiar arrangement of
elements which co-operate to make possible MeMichael’s
characteristic mode of operation.

The Mcllvrid patent No. 958,421 shows another ma-
chine for causing a fluid grout mixture to flow by pres-
sure exerted upon the surface of the fluid mass within a
chamber with which a hose is connected. Aside from
certain features of construction, which are of absolutely
no interest in this case, the grouter of the MclIlvrid pat-
ent does not differ in any material respect from the de-
vices of the Moir and Canniff patents, supra.

38

Liquid Flow—Lift Pumps.

It is probably because counsel for respondents has in-
jected this group of lift pump patents into this record,
that he contends the prior art presented in the case at
bar is different from the prior art presented in the See-
ond Circuit cases. As we view the matter, counsel for
the defendants in the Eastern cases are to be compli-
mented, rather than censured, for not having imposed
upon the courts the consideration of patents so far afield
from conveyance of concrete as are these patents show-
ing lift pumps.

These patents are all concerned with getting some
liquid, 7. e., water, oil, or liquid sulphur, out of a hole in
the ground by injecting air into a pipe containing a col-
umn of the liquid to lighten the column and permit it to
rise. Quite cbviously, no one of these patents discloses
anything which was ever used for the transportation of
concrete, or which could be used for such purpose.
Counsel for respondents seem to believe that these

i
lift pump patents have some degree of pertinency
to the case at bar, because in the operation of
these lift pumps the lifted fluid usually comes out
of the upper end of the pipe in gulps, that is to
say, first a certain quantity of water, then a quan-
tity of the air which was used to lighten the column,
then another quantity of water, etc. We freely admit
that lift pumps do operate in this way. They have been
known from time immemorial. The lift pump art is much
older than any of the patents cited by respondents. It
seems entirely sufficient to say that no one of these lift
pump patents discloses MeMichael’s structure, that no
one of them could be used for conveying concrete, that
no one of them was ever used for conveying concrete.
The structures of these lift pump patents are as different
from the McMichael structure as anything that can be
imagined. No one, not even the respondents in their
extremity, has ever attempted to use the lift pump theory
in transporting concrete. The operation of a lift pump
depends solely and simply upon lightening a column of
liquid by injecting air into it. Concrete is simply in-
capable of being transported or lifted by any such treat-
ment.

The Pohle patent No. 487,639 discloses a water lift of
the most simple type. A column of water is lightened
by injecting air into it. The lightened column naturally

39

CEN Se areae eA

rises due to the hydrostatic head of the liquid surround-
/ing the pipe into which the air is injected. .

/ The Saunders patent No. 597,023 discloses another lift F
) pump wherein a column of water is lightened and caused 1
to rise out of a well by injecting air into it.
The Frasch patents Nos. 799,642 and 800,127 show E

nothing more than the utilization of the water lift idea
in the elevation of liquid sulphur. The liquid sulphur
devices of the Frasch patents operate upon precisely the

Pwewrtenw ss

Re a LA, ene.

40

same principle as do the earlier water lifts of Pohle and
Saunders. Much testimony was taken to show that liquid
lifts of the type shown in these Frasch patents were used
in sulphur mining. Surely they were used for mining
liquid sulphur, but no one, not even the respondents, con-
tends that these devices could be used for transporting
concrete. Moreover, these devices are totally incapable
of being reconstructed to handle concrete. They involvea
principle of operation which is not applicable to the trans-
portation of concrete.

The Frizell patent No. 233,499 shows another water
lift, and deserves no special comment. This inventor
tried to get away from having his water gulp out of the
top of his pipe, and accomplished this objective by light-
ening his column of water by air admitted ‘‘in the form
of minuce bubbles.’’ °

The Harris patents Nos. 759,100 and 814,601 are also
concerned simply with lifting a liquid out of a well by
lightening a column of the liquid by the admission of air
to the column. Harris was concerned primarily with the
elevation of oil out of oil wells.

Liquid Flow—Entrained and Suspended Solids.

The six patents of this sub-group are all concerned with
handling fluids which have solids, such as mud, sand,
rocks, ete., entrained in the water which is the carrying
medium. All of these devices work upon the theory that
water can be pumped, whether it be clean or dirty, and
that the presence of entrained solids (even very large*
solids in large pumps) will not prevent the water from
being pumped. For’ the most part the patents of this
sub-group relate to pumping and dredging operations
where water containing mud or ‘‘spoil,’’ sand and gravel ‘
is merely pumped in one of the oldest ways known to

<0

41

mankind, that is to say, by causing the water and its en-
trained solids to flow into a closed chamber and then ex-
erting pressure upon the water to flow it out of the cham-
ber. Devices of this kind operate in accordance with a
principle which is of no avail in the transportation of con-
crete, namely, that a pump will handle solids if accom-
panied by sufficient water. Neither McMichael nor re-
spondents pump concrete. It is obvious that if sufficient
water were gdded to concrete to permit it to be pumped,
it would be unusable for any practical purpose. Before
a mixture of water and entrained solids can be pumped,
the water must be the predominating ingredient of the
mixture. Water is not and should not be the predominat-
ing ingredient in concrete. Even the wettest of ‘‘wet
concrete’? does not comprise anything like the propor-
tion of water which is necessary before mud or spoil from
dredges can be pumped.

The Duckham British patents Nos. 4400 of 1875, and
15,348 of 1885, show mud pumps, 7. e., devices which are
adapted to discharge water and entrained mud from a
barge by air pressure applied to the fluid mixture of
water and mud. The patents lack all of the essentials
of the MeMichael apparatus, operate differently than
does the McMichael apparatus, and could not be utilized
for the conveyance of concrete. However, counsel for
respondents and the courts below in this case lay par-
ticular stress on these patents—because they speak of
(but do not illustrate) the use of air and water nozzles
as agitators, or, as Duckham says, so that ‘‘the particles
are prevented from settling and are kept in suspension
until the whole is expelled from the tank.’’ These Duck-
ham patents certainly fall far short of being ‘‘anticipa-
tions’’ of the McMichael invention, but since the Ninth
Cireuit Court of Appeals regards them as important, we
have discussed them quite fully under the later heading,

ns

t
'
i
z
E

42

‘“‘The Duckham British Patents Nos, 4400 of 1875 ang
15,348 of 1885.’’
The Hussey patents Nos. 497,427 and 526,530 show go.
called ‘‘vacuum dredges,’’ which, by condensation of
steam, suck water and entrained solids into a chamber,
and then, after the closing of the intake port of the cham.
ber and the opening of a discharge port, cause the water
and its entrained solids to flow out of the chamber by
applying steam to create a discharging pressure,
These Hussey dredgers were probably very satisfactory
devices for the purpose for which they were intended.
Respondents’ counsel has taken depositions to show that
they were successful dredging devices. The important
consideration, however, is that the Hussey vacuum dredger
lacks all of the essential features of the McMichael strue-
ture, and operates in accordance with an entirely differ-
ent plan. The McMichael apparatus is certainly some-
thing entirely different from a device which sucks water
and entrained spoil into a tank and then merely ejects
it by applied pressure. Being a different kind of device,
the McMichael apparatus embodies different means,—a
different combination of elements—a combination of ele-
ments which Hussey does not disclose.
The Rix & Donahoo patent No. 635,270 shows another
type of dredger which conveys mud and ‘‘spoil’’ by flota
tion in water. The apparatus of this patent has no rela-
tion to the McMichael apparatus and operates according
to an entirely different plan. It would be totally unsuit.
able for the conveyance of concrete. :
The Church patent No. 487,606 shows a device for
spraying alabastine paint. The defendants in the New
York cases, like respondents in this case, cited it, but for
what reason we are unable to perceive. It is as remote
from the McMichael invention as anything that can be
imagined.

43

The Smith Patent of 1872.
(Exhibit Book, p. 484.)

In speaking of this patent the Ninth Circuit Court of
Appeals in its opinion said:

‘“‘The device contained all of the features of ap-
pellants’ (petitioners’) patent except the nozzle for
admission of air near the point of exit.’’ (R., p. 669.)

Since the device of the Smith patent admittedly lacks
that essential element—the velocity nozzle—it is imma-
terial whether or not the Smith device will work. If it
will work, it works differently from the McMichael ma-
chine and differently from respondents’ machines, be-
cause both the McMichael machine and respondents’ ma-
chines depend for their effectiveness upon a velocity
nozzle located just where the concrete passes from the
container into the conduit.

We believe that your Honors, bearing in mind that
the velocity nozzle is a distinguishing element of all of
the MeMichael claims in suit, will agree with the Second
Cireuit Court of Appeals when, in the Powers-Kennedy
case, it says of the Smith patent: ‘It cannot be regarded
a8 an anticipation.’’

In comparing Smith’s device with the MeMichael ap-
paratus, counsel for respoudents has said:

‘Smith operated on the same object or material,
for the same purpose and with the same means.’’

Let us see whether or not Smith did act on the same ma-
ferial as.McMichael, and also whether or not Smith did
utilize the same means.

Smith was not handling the same material as Me-
Michael. . This clearly appears in the specification of the
Smith patent. The material which Smith handled, al-

though = called liquid ‘‘conerete’?’ was in fact a

ie --

PIRES I AOE TD OM . — ee cores

44

very thin watery mixture which would flow through
a tortuous passage d from the mixing hopper (
to the air chamber F. Over and over again in
his specification, Smith emphasizes the fact that
the composition must be thin enough to flow with
great facility. In the fourth paragraph of his speci.
fication, he says that his device is to handle a composition
‘‘the properties of which are adapted to be conveyed and
laid while in a fluid state.’’ In referring to how the
liquid composition gets from the mixing hopper C throngh
the tortuous passage d, Smith says: ‘‘I then open the
valves and let it flow off through the pipe D.’’ He also
says that the composition is ‘‘ sufficiently liquid to settle
to a perfectly lege] surface.’’

It is clear t concrete to be used in tunnel linings,
ete., or for any other useful purpose, as _ con-
veyed by the McMichael apparatus, is not the
same as the soupy fluid which was the only thing which
the Smith apparatus could handle. Concrete such as is
used in tunnels (such as is used by respondents) could
not possibly flow through the tortuous passage d of the
Smith apparatus. Moreover, concrete such as handled
by McMichael, and such as is placed by the respondents’
is certainly not ‘‘sufficiently liquid to settle to a perfectly
level surface’’ as specified by Smith.

The particularity with which Smith specified that the
composition handled by his machine must be a ‘‘liquid
composition’’ emphasizes the dissimilarity between the

1 The concrete used by respondents is described by the witness Oxen
ham (R., p. 530) as follows:

‘*Q. When you observed the operation of the pneumatic placing
apparatus in the Skagit River Tunne! and the operations there of
the Hackley machine, did you observe whether the concrete form
ing materials were of a consistency auch as that they stood in a pile
with sloping sides or whether those materials would, of their owa
flow assume a level condition?

‘A, Stood in a pile.’’

45

Smith structure and that of McMichael. The MeMichael
apparatus is not limited to the use of such a useless ‘‘li-
quid composition.’’ If it were so limited, it would be an
unused device, just as the Smith device is unused. It is
not even limited to a ‘‘wet’’ composition (Pat., p. 3, lines
49.59). The Smith patent shows on its face that Smith
did not know how to handle ordinary concrete like that
handled by the McMichael machines, that is concrete such
as is used in tunnels and in building operations, which
has an inherent tendency to bridge and arch and to block
and jam any passage through which an attempt may be
made to cause it to flow. Not knowing how to handle the
kind of concrete which everyone wants to use, Smith was
obliged to confine himself to liquid concrete,—something
which no one wants to use, or would be permitted to use.
Therefore, the Smith patent passed into the oblivion from
which it first emerged to meet the exigencies of the de-
fendant in the Powers-Kennedy case.

But even if it were admitted that Smith did contem-
plate handling concrete like that handled by McMichael,
the fact would nevertheless remain that the means em-
ployed by Smith is different from that of McMichael. If
there is any one salient fact which is emphasized in the
MeMichael patent or which has been demonstrated by the
testimony and arguments in this case, it is that Me.
Michael's velocity jet, acting upon a compacted mass of
concrete at a definite point for a particular purpose, is an
absolutely essential element of the MeMichael combina-
tion, This element, as well as the sloping walls of the
container, which co-operate with the velocity jet to give
4eMichael's apparatus its characteristic mode of opera-
tion, are lacking in the Smith disclosure. Smith did net
get MeMichael’s results. The Smith device is and al-
ways has been a failure. It was never heard of in the
forty-three years between its grant and the grant of the

a

MeMichael patent. This is so because Smith does not
disclose the means of MeMichael.

Because Smith did not disclose the means of the Me.
Michael patent, he was obliged to limitshimself to ‘‘liquid
concrete.’’ If respondents want to use the Smith appa.
ratus, we shall not quarrel with them. But the respond.
ents do not want to use the Smith apparatus... The re.
spondents use MeMichael’s essential combination in order
that they may get MeMichael’s results,—in order that
they may successfully transport concrete of a character
which Smith could not handle. v

The language of Judge Coxe in Cimiotti Unhairing Co,
v. American Company, 115 Fed. Rep. 498, 500, is ap-
plicable to the Smith patent. Judge Coxe said:

46

‘‘Tt emerged from oblivion solely to meet the ex-
igencies of this litigation.’’

The Duckham British Patents Nos. 4400 of 1875 and
15,348 of 1885.

(Exhibit Book, pp. 598 and 606.)

The Duckham patents mention but do not illustrate cer-
tain nozzles for stirring up mud in a tank.

The Ninth “ireuit Court of Appeals in its opinion
quotes from the Duckham 1875 patent as follows:

“T prefer to inject compressed air...
through a number of nozzles at the bottom of the
tank, said nozzles being pointed toward the outlet.
By this means the particles are prohibited from
settling and are 7 in suspension until the whole
is expelled from the tank. Compressed air may,

moreover, be admitted into the discharge pipe with
the same object.’’ (R., p. 669.)

Then the court reaches a conclusion as follows:

‘*We think it indisputable that Duckham in pre
scribing tbe use of pipes for the admission of com-

atl

47

pressed air in the tank, the came distributed along
the bottom of the tank, and one of them locatable at
the exit, presented the use of all that is included in
the appellant’s combination, save and except the U-
Gs 6 ‘

We respectfully submit that the matter quoted from
the Duckham 1875 patent does not justify the conclusion
that Duckham contemplated a ‘‘nozzle locatable at the
exit.”’ Obviously, Duckham could have had many pipes
“at the bottom’’ and ‘‘ pointing toward the exit’’ which
would not in any sense act upon the material (mud and
water) at the place where the material passes from the
container into the conduit.

Furthermore, the statement quoted from Duckham that
air might ‘‘be admitted into the discharge pipe’’ can, and
we think certainly does, mean something entirely dif-
ferent than placing a nozzle as did MeMichael at the very
place where the material passes from the container into
the conduit. The mere placing of a nozzle in a conduit
is insufficient te meet the requirements of a concrete
placing machine. As taught by MeMichael, and as
demonstrated by the commercial practice of petitioner,
the respondents in this case, and the defendants in the
New York cases, the nozzle must be at the very place
where the container merges into the conduit. - |

There is, therefore, in the Duckham 1875 patent no
justification for the conclusion of the Ninth Cireuit Court
of Appeals that Duckham prescribed the use of nozzles
“‘locatable at the exit.’’

Moreover, the Duckham 1875 patent contains an addi-

tional statement which is entirely out of harmony with
the conclusion that Duckham might have had a nozzle at
the place where his material passed from the container
into the pipe. Duckham says:

“To prevent the choking of the pipes a screen or
grating is provided through which the mud or spoil

dite

a

ee | UPON PS 0 ort ees - eer iw

TOD Ae RG REDMON
‘

‘ q

passes before it enters the outlet pipe.’’ (Proyi.
sional Spec., p. 2; Complete Spec., p. 4.)

Therefore, the thing which Duckham had at the point
where the material passed from the container into the
conduit was a screen or-grating. The unillustrated noz-
zles were undoubtedly located away from the screen or _
grating and ‘‘along the bottom’’ or even perhaps in the
discharge pipe at points away from this screen or grat-
ing. -

Even if the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals entertained
a doubt as to what Duckham tntended, that doubt, under
authorities too numerous to mention, should have been
resolved against Duckham and not against the McMichael
patent. ie

Particularly should any doubt be resolved against
Duckham when it is considered that the Duckham appa-
ratus, even if it were provided with an air or water nozzle
placed at the junction of chamber and conduit, would re-
quire other radical changes before it would be available
for handling concrete. For instance, the Duckham con-
duit does not join the chamber walls with that ‘‘substan-
tial smoothness”’ which is recited in some of McMichael’s
claims and which is so very necessary in a concrete
placer. Moreover, to handle concrete, Duckham would
necessarily have to use entirely different pressure than
the fifteen pounds per square inch which he used in hand-
ling mud and spoil. Pressures of approximately one
hundred pounds per square inch are required in a con-
erete placer. These arébut two of the reasons why the
Duckam apparatus would require radical modification, in
addition to providing it with a nozzle at the beginning
of the conduit, if an attempt were made to use the Duck-
ham apparatus for placing concrete.

The Duckham idea consisted in providing a barge with
enormous cylindrical tanks for the storage of water and

49

entrained mud which was to be transported by the barges
from a point where it was taken off of the sea bottom.
Duckham discharged the water and its entrained mud by
flowing it through pipes. The fluid mixture of water and
mud flowed so readily that it couid be ejected by a pres-
sure as low as fifteen pounds per square inch (see~the j
publication Defendants’ Exhibit 29, Exhibit Book, p.
188).

Obviously, when mud and water are stored in an enor-
mous tank such as was used by Duckham, some of the ’
mud will settle to the bottom of the tank and must be
stirred up if it is going to flow off with the water. Duck-
ham in his patents suggested two ways of stirring up the
mud so that it would flow off with the water. He did not
illustrate either way in his drawings. One way which
was suggested was to use mechanical agitators. The
alternative scheme for stirring up the mud was to use
air and water nozzles.

The Ninth Cireuit Court of Appeals refers to the
minutes of the proceedings of the Institution of Civil

~ Engineers for 1887 (Exhibit Book, pp. 187-188) and e
quotes therefrom, as the language of Duckham, an ex-
cerpt from an article which apparently was not written
by Duckham but which article, in referring to a Duckham
device of some kind (whether or not it was the device of
the Duckham patents does not appear), said:

‘‘with clay or stiff mud, if the nozzles of the air-
injection pipes were too small, the compressed air f
instead of driving out the material simply pierced :
holes through it, escaping through the discharge pipe
and carrying along with it all the liquid and thin
material in the tanks. This defect was easily recti-
fied by rearranging and increasing the size of the

injection nozzles, and the apparatus now gives most
satisfactory results.’’ (R., p. 670.)

So Sf smuiey

ie M ta Cl es ee eee od ae

The fact that the nozzles of Duckham performed their

pewrr We SS ey

wager <8
a a

‘peice

50

mud agitating function better after some ‘‘rearranging”
certainly does not justify the assumption that Duckham’s
nozzles were ‘‘rearranged’’ or ever arranged in a posi-
tion corresponding to the position of the velocity nozzle
of the McMichael concrete placer.

The Kolsche German Patent.'
(Exhibit Book, p. 183.)

Judge Bourquin, in referring to this old German patent
No. 18,394 of 1881, said (R., pp. 619 and 620):

‘‘The third is Kolsche’s German patent 18,394 of
1882 for ‘apparatus for conveying substances slack,
sandy or granular material, by means of a current
of air.’

‘“The apparatus is like McMichael’s without the
U bend. That is, it is gn upright cylindrical con-
tainer with hopper bottom terminating in a dis-
charge pipe. Compressed air is applied above or
behind the material in the container to force it down
and into the discharge pipe, and at that point like
air is admitted to assist in driving the material
through the pipe.

‘*‘Without any change, perhaps save adjustments
to circumstances as always, Kolsche’s apparatus
and method will transport concrete as does Mc-
Michael’s. Kolsche could rightfully devote it to
that analogous use. It follows that MeMichael’s
essentially unchanged application of Kolsche to an-
alogous materials and uses, is not invention. In
principle, essential design, function, operation, ob-
ject and result, Kolsche and McMichael are one and
the same. Either reads on the other.

‘‘Kolsche, if later and devoted to concrete, might
infringe McMichael, and by the same token being
earlier, he anticipates him.’’ (Bold-face ours.)

Apparently Judge Bourquin arrived at the above con-

=
; ore

1 This patent was not mentioned in the opinion of the Ninth Circuit
Court of Appeals although one of the prior art patents stressed by re-
spondents below.

51

clusions from mere inspection of the Kolsche drawing.
Certainly if he had read the specification of the Kolsche
patent he should have perceived that it illustrates and
describes a kinetic conveyor which operates in a manner
radically different from the operation of the concrete
placers under consideration in this case. In the following
quotation from a translation of the Kolsche patent (Ex-
hibit Book, p. 183) the bold-face is ours:

“GERMAN PATENT No. 18394

‘‘Ludwig Kolsche, Haardt, Westfalen, ;
‘‘Protected from Oct. 16, 1881: Issued July 4, 1882:
Class 35. .

‘‘ApPARATUS FOR CONVEYING SUBSTANCES SLACK,
Sanpy or GranuLar MaTeriaL BY MEANS OF A
CuRRENT OF AIR.

‘The apparatus comprises the intake nozzle a and
the air passage d e, through which a continuous cur-
rent of air is driven by means of a blower (fan).
This current must be of such strength that the par-
ticles dropping down through the opening ¢ ¢ are
engaged and carried along through the entire air
passage d e and collect in a heap on discharging
from the passage e.’’

A TRE EA COR ee Lone

It is clear from the Kolsche specification, even from
a careful examination of the Kolsche drawing, that this
patent describes a kinetic conveyor, t. e., one in which the
conveyed materials are carried along in suspension by the
velocity of a current of air.

It is also clear that Kolsche does not disclose any-
thing corresponding either in cgnstruction, location or
function to MeMichael’s slug forming velocity nozzle.

Kolsche employes a blower or fan, not shown, which
is located somewhere to the left of his machine (as shown
in the patent drawing) and the blower sets up a current
of air which picks up and carries along ‘‘particles’’ which
‘drop’? down through the openings c-c.

ates ii oe

52.

If concrete were put in the Kolsche device, it would
immediately arch and jam at the small openings c-¢.
More important, from the standpoint of this case, there
is no slug forming nozzle in the Kolsche disclosure.

Judge Bourquin was clearly in error when he said:

‘*Kolsche, if later and devoted to concrete might
infringe MeMichael’”’
because the Kolsche construction lacks, among other
things, the salient feature of the McMichael claims. It
has no nozzle or anything which could function as does
the velocity nozzle of McMichael.

If respondents care to use the kinetic conveyor of
Kolsche, or any other kinetic conveyor for that matter,
they will become involved in no quarrel with this peti-
tioner.

The Allegation of Prior Invention and Use by Thomas
S. Leake.

In an attempt to show that the invention of the patent
in suit had been known and publicly used in New Orleans
prior to the filing of MeMichael’s patent application in
January, 1907, the respondents, in 1927, took the deposi-
tion of Mr. Thomas S. Leake (R., pp. 578-609). The trial
court did not see the witness. At the time he testified
Mr. Leake was 67 years old and relied entirely upon his
memory in testifying about things he was supposed to
have done in 1905—22 years earlier. His testimony is
full of inconsistent statements and repeated assertions of
poor memory in regard to the events of 1905.

Counsel for respondents did not attempt to corroborate
this deposition by the testimony of any other witness.
The device alleged to have been used in 1905 was shown
to have been almost immediately destroyed (R., p. 593).
A pencil sketch made by Leake is in evidence as ‘‘ Defend-

wa

ants’ Chicago Exhibit 127” (Exhibit Book, p. 694).

There is nothing in the record to show when this sketch

was made. (We happen to know, however, that it was

made less than a year and a half ago while Leake was
testifying in another case involving the McMichael pat-
ent.) The record does not contain a shred of contempo-
raneous documentary or physical evidence to support
Leake’s recollection of what happened in New Orleans in
1905.

53

Leake’s Sketch Does Not Show a Velocity Nozzle and
Leake Does Not Claim to Have Used Such a Nozzle in
His 1905 Experiment.

All of the McMichael claims involved in this suit in
one way or another recite the velocity nozzle as an ele-
ment of the patented combination. This velocity nozzle,
which acts upon the concrete at the point which it is com-
pacted in passing from the chamber into the conduit, is an
absolutely essential element of the pneumatic concrete
placers with which this suit is concerned. Therefore, any-
thing which Leake may have done in New Orleans in 1905

“would seem to be entirely immaterial to the issues of this
case, when it clearly appears that whatever he used cer-
tainly did not include the velocity nozzle. Ps

The Leake sketch, Chicago Exhibit 127, shows no
nozzle at the junction between the container and the con-
duit.

Furthermore, Leake’s testimony very clearly indicates
that the New Orleans experimental device of 1905 did not
have anything corresponding to the velocity nozzle.

On direct examination Mr. Leake was asked various
questions intended to draw forth a comparison between
his 1905 experiment and a device which he, Leake, after-
wards placed in the Webster Building in Chicago in 1907

~~ em ——

54

or thereafter, i. e., long after the filing of McMichael’,
application. This later device, at the Webster Building,
did comprise something like the velocity nozzle which was
new with McMichael. The New Orleans experiment did
not. The testimony is as follows:

‘“*Q. That (the Webster Building machine made
long after McMichael’s filing date and having a ve.
locity nozzle) was the same machine in theory, using
new materials, but constructed in the same general
design as the one you had used in New Orleans, was
it not?

fA. Oh, no; the New Orleans one had nothing
automatic.

‘*Q. But as far as applying the principle of con-
trolling the mixture through the application of air
and sending it to the higher point?

‘*A. Oh, no. This (the later machine of the Web-
ster Building) takes air on the bottom and top both.”
(R., p. 598.)

When Leake said the New Orleans experiment ‘‘had
nothing automatic’? he meant that it had no velocity
nozzle. This is made clear by his next answer, which in-
dicates that the New Orleans device was different from
the later device of the Webster Building which ‘‘takes
air on the bottom and top both.”’

Although Leake’s testimony is vague throughout, the
foregoing quotation from his deposition, together with
the sketch, Defendants’ Chicago Exhibit 127, makes it
clear that the 1905 experiment in New Orleans was abso-
lutely devoid of the most essential structural feature of
the MeMichael apparatus. Its lack of the velocity nozzle
undoubtedly accounts for the fact that it was an aban-
doned failure.

59:

The Documents Dated After McMichzel’s Filing Date
Which the Ninth Circuit Court ot Appeals Regards as
Evidence that Leake Invented and Used the Invention
of the Patent in Suit Before McMichael’s Filing Date.

The Ninth Cireuit Court of Appeals, being unable to
find a particle of contemporaneous physical or documen-
tary evidence corroborating Leake’s testimony concern-
ing the alleged prior use in 1905, quotes from a patent ap-
plication of Leake, filed after McMichael’s filing date as
supposed corroboration of Leake’s testimony concerning
events said to have happened before MeMichael’s filing
date, and the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Cireuit regards a preliminary statement (affidavit)
made by Leake in 1909 as acceptable corroboration of
Leake’s testimony concerning events said to have trans-
pired in 1905. The preliminary statement (R., p. 582)
was filed in an interference between Leake and Mc
Michael. The interference terminated favorably to Me-
Michael, because petitioner, which eventually owned both
applications, concluded that McMichael and not Leake
was the inventor of the essential ¢6ombination including
the velocity nozzle. That the interference was properly
terminated is demonstrated by the fact that Leake does
not even claim to have conceived anything corresponding
to the velocity nozzle before MeMichael’s filing date. Ad-
mittedly the 1905 experiment did not include it because
the sketch which purports to illustrate the 1905 experi-
ment is devoid of any such nozzle.

The only conceivable proper purpose to which the
Leake preliminary statement could have been put in the
present case would have been to impeach or discredit
Leake as a witness. But as evidence to sustain the con-
tention that Leake was a prior inventor, it is palpably in-

SON TES TREE A I BLE IE IONS i fy My

. ee |

ne

competent. Originating after McMichael’s filing date,
it cannot establish events preceding McMichael’s filing
date.

Furthermore, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals re.
gards certain statements made in Leake’s patent applica.
tion in 1908, by Leake’s attorney, who did not even pre.
tend to have first-hand knowledge of the facts, as com.
petent evidence corroborating Leake’s verbal testimony
as to the alleged happenings in 1905. The attorney was
not called asa witness. These are simply laudatory state-
ments' made by the attorney in behalf of his client. All
of this argumentative laudation is consistent with the
fact that Leake made the apparatus of his patent applica-
tion after McMichael’s filing date. The attorney did not
say when Leake’s use of his patent application machine
was made. Yet the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals re-
gards the laudatory statements made in 1908, after Me.
Michael’s filing date, as evidence that a device made in
1905 was practical and satisfactory.

There is.no theory upon which the unsworn statements
of Leake’s patent attorney in an ex parte prosecution of
a patent application can be considered competent evidence
for or against either of the parties to this litigation.

In the Powers-Kennedy case the defeadants attempted
unsuccessfully to persuade the courts to give favorable
consideration to the same kind of incompetent evidence
which has been favorably considered by the Ninth Circuit
Court of Appeals in this case. The Second Circuit Court
of Appeals said:

56

‘‘The new defense of prior use was held by the
district court not sufficiently proved; and with this
we agree. This use was of a machine which Arting-
stall and Fanning said that they saw laying a con-

1 These statements appear in the amendments, papers 5 and 9, of the
Leake file-wrapper (Exhibit Book, pp. 367 and 378).

57
crete floor in 1903, subsequently cone the date
Oo

to 1904. That was twenty-two years before they gave
their testimony, and there was no documentary cor-
roboration of’any kind. It is true that in 1918 Art-
install described very generally before a meeting of
engineers that this process was practiced in 1903, but
that can not be deemed documentary corroboration,”’
(27 Fed. (2) 669.)

The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit clearly
erred when it accepted statements in Leake’s 1909 pre-
liminary statement, and laudatory statements made by
Leake’s attorney after MecMichael’s filing date, as cor-
roborative of Leake’s verbal testimony concerning the

alleged experimental device of 1905.

This is the First Case in Which Any Federal Court of the
United States Has Held that the Oral Testimony of an
Alleged Prior Inventor or Prior User—Uncorroborated
and Unsupported by Contemporaneous Writings, Draw-
ings or Physical Exhibits—Is Sufficient to Invalidate
an Issued Patent.

Such, however, was the decision of the Ninth Circuit
Court of Appeals relative to the prior invention and use
which the respondents claimed to have been made by
Thomas 8. Leake at New Orleans in 1905.

In support of the conclusion that the uncorroborated

and unsupported deposition of Leake is sufficient to es-

tablish prior invention and use, the Ninth Cireuit Court
of Appeals cites the following cases:
Reed v. Cutter, 1 Story 590, 596.
C.F. Mueller Co. vy. A. Zereqas Sons, 12 Fed. (2d)
517, 518,

Mayer vy, A. d I. G. Mutschler, 248 Fed. 911, 914.
These cases do not support the proposition which they

ure cited to sustain.

“sr

tl

a meat 7 ye Ee ee Se

ae FITC 6 EE Or

58

Reed v. Cutter, 1 Story, 590, 596, in no way treats of the
kind and degree of evidence required to establish prior
invention or prior use. This case merely asserts the
familiar rule that when a public use has been satisfac.
torily established, it makes no difference whether the use
was known to a large number of people, or to only a few,
or even to but one. But this well-known rule does not
for a minute sustain the proposition that prior invention
or use may be established, in the absence of any contem.
porary device or writing, by the uncorroborated testi.
mony of a single witness.

C. F. Mueller Co, v. A. Zeregas Sons, 12 Fed. (2d)
517, 518. No patent was held invalid in this case bacause
of any public use. The trial court had held three patents
valid. The Court of Appeals found one of them, a de-
sign patent, invalid only because of lack of patentable
subject-matter. The case involved a dispute between a
patentee and a rival inventor, but the trial court resolved
the dispute in favor of the patentee.

Mayer v. A. € H. G. Mutschler, 248 Fed. 911, 914. This
case was cited by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in
support of the proposition that the testimony of one
witness may be sufficient, but the cited case is readily
distinguished from the case at bar by the following quo-
tation from the opinion:

‘‘The rules as to prior use are severe and rightly
so and Archbald is a witness hostile to plain
tiff; but the existence of the machine is not denied,
its date of erection proved by other testimony than
Archbald’s, as also is its unchanged condition, and
still another witness swears that it was in 1911 as it
is now.’’

Clearly the testimony of Leake in this case was not
corroborated and supported as was the testimony of
Archbaid in the case cited.

59

Such are the cases cited by the Ninth Circuit Court of
Appeals in support of the startling conclusion that the
oral testimony of Leake, given 22 years after the fact,
may be accepted without corroboration or contemporane-
ous evidence of any character to defeat what otherwise
isa valid and valuable patent.

The Law as to Proof of Alleged Prior Public Use of a
Patented Invention.

It is well settled that to invalidate an issued patent a
prior use must be proved ‘‘by evidence so cogent as to
leave no reasonable doubt.’’

Perhaps the leading authority is Deering v. Winona
Harvester Works, 155 U. S. 286, in which the court said
(p. 300) :

‘““As we have had occasion before to observe oral
testimony, unsupported by patents or exhibits, tend-
ing to show prior use of a device regularly patented,
is, in the nature of the case, open to grave suspicion,
The Barbed Wire Patent, 143 U. 8. 275. Granting
the witnesses to be of the highest character, and
never so conscientious in their desire to tell only the
truth, the possibility of their being mistaken as to
the exact device used, which, though bearing a gen-
eral resemblance to the one patented, may differ
from it in the very particular which makes it patent-
able, are such as to render oral testimony peculiarly
untrustworthy; particularly so if the testimony be
taken after the lapse of years from the time the al-
leged anticipating device was used. If there be
added to this a personal bias, or an incentive to color
the testimony, in the interest of the party calling the
Witness, to say nothing of downright perjury, its
value is of course, still more seriously impaired.
This case is an apt ulustration of the wisdom of
the rule *equiring such anticipations to be proven
by evidence so cogent as to leave no reasonable doubt
in the mind of the court, that the transaction oc-

naka > eae

aS ST

60

curred substantially as stated. The very exhibit
produced by the witness Heller contradicted, so far
as it could contradict, his testimony, and the wit.
ness who ought to have corroborated his story, gave
a version which showed it to be untrue in more than
one important particular.’’

This holding, as to the degree of proof required to es-
tablish a prior use, has been reiterated by the Supreme
Court in recent cases. Adamson v. Gilliland, 242 U.S.
300, 1917; T. H. Symington Co. v. National Malleable
Castings Co., 250 U. S. 383, 1919, and Eibel Process Co,
v. Minnesota & Ontario Paper Co., 261 U.S. 45, 1923.

In the Eibel case, the latest pronouncement of the Su-
preme Court on the proof required to establish prior use,
the court said (p. 60):

\ ‘‘It is true that some witnesses testify that they
realized before Eibel’s application that speeding up
the stock to equal velocity with the wire would solve
the difficulty and aid the speed. But there is nota
single written record, letter or specification of prior
date to Ejibel’s application that discloses any such
discovery by anyone, or the use of the pitch of the
wire to aid the speed of the machine. The oral evi-
dence on this point falls far short of being enough
to overcome the presumption of novelty from the
granting of the patent. The temptation to remen-
ber in such cases and the ease with which honest
witnesses can convince themselves after many years
of having had a conception at the basis of a valuable
patent, are well known in this branch of law, and
have properly led to a rule that evidence to prove
prior discovery must be clear and satisfactory.”

T. H. Symington Company v. N ational Malleable Cast-
ings Company et al., 250 U. S. 383, 386:

‘‘This court has pointed out that oral testimony
tending to show prior invention as against existing
letters patent is, in the absence of models, drawings.
or kindred evidence, open to grave suspicion; par-

61

ticularly if the testimony be taken after the lapse of
years from the time of the alleged invention. Deer-
\ img v. Winona Harvester Works, 155 U. S. 286, 300.’?

The Most That Can Be Said for Leake’s 1905 Device Is
That It Was a Discarded and Abandoned Experi-
ment.

The alleged 1905 experiment of Leake was unquestion-
ably discarded and abandoned almost immediately after
it was made.

Leake says:

‘‘A. No; that was nothing but a crude machine
put up there to see whether I could put concrete up
in the air.

‘‘Q. What happened after you used that?

“‘A. I tore it down.

“‘Q. Did you keep that?

‘‘A. No. It was nothing only a lot of two by
four stuff put up with hoops.

‘*Q. So that is not in existence now? 5

‘A. Oh, no.

‘*@. Do you know of any other pictures or blue-
prints of that device other than the one you have
referred to here?!

“A. No.” (RB., p. 586.)

This is the Leake device which the Ninth Circuit Court
of Appeals credits as a prior public use of MeMichael’s
successful combination of elements.

In striking contrast, the Second Circuit Court of Ap-
peals in the Powers-Kennedy case says:

‘*It is one thing to say that a continuous use to date
may be found on oral testimony to have started at

a given time, and quite another to say that such tes-
mony 1s enough when it describes only a casual

1 The ‘‘one you have referred to here’’ is the sketch made by Leake
himself in connection with his testimony in 1927 (Exhibit Book, pp.
693, 694).

em

ee on 7

62

use, abandoned thereafter, and never entering into
the art until after the patent in suit was applied for,

Such casual and abandoned uses do not coun.
tribute to the stock of knowledge which makes up the
art. If we may invalidate a patent upon such privi
uses so proved, no patent would be safe.’’ (27 Fed,
(2) 670.)

The language of the Second Circuit Court of Appeals
is particularly applicable to Leake’s casual and aban-
doned experiment of 1905. Leake after MceMichael’s fil.
ing date did apply for a patent. Leake’s patent appli-
cation, however, was essentially different from his aban-
doned experiment of 1905. The patent application in-
cluded MeMichael’s essential velocity nozzle. The aban-
doned experiment of 1905 did not include that essential
element. This, we think, was the salient reason why
Leake’s 1905 experiment was an abandoned failure and
why the world had to wait for McMichael to produce a
practical pneumatic concrete placer.

These Suits Involving the McMichael Patent Are Dis-
tinguished From Concrete vs. Gomery, 269 U. 8. 177.

The structure of the Callahan patent involved in the
Gomery case was not new, What Callahan did was to
apply an old and substantially unchanged machine to a
new use, 7. ¢., the gravitation of concrete through inclined
chutes. This court held the Callahan patent invalid.

But the machine of the McMichael patent is a new ma-
chine. Nowhere in the prior art can there be found a
machine which comprises a velocity nozzle acting upon
a mass of concrete at the point where it is compacted in
passing from a container into a discharge conduit. There-
fore, there is not in the prior art a single machine capable
of handling concrete as it is handled by the MeMichael
machine. Since the machine of the MeMichael patent is 4

63

new machine, both structurally and in the manner of its
operation, it follows that the rule in the Gomery case does
not apply.

The Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit was
dearly right when, in the Powers-Kennedy case, it dis-
tinguished the McMichael patent from the rule in the
Gomery case, and Judge Bourquin and the Ninth Circuit
Court of Appeals erred in holding to the contrary.

McMichael’s Original Application Adequately Supported
the Claims in Suit—No Supplemental Oath Was Neces-
sary.

It is, of course, true that McMichael, during the prose-
cution of his application, largely rewrote and amplified its
descriptive part more accurately to set forth his method
and theory of operation. But never at any time did Me-
Michael add to or detract from the apparatus shown in
his patent drawing. The apparatus is identically the
same as it was when the application was filed on J anuary
14, 1907.

If method claims were involved in this suit, as was the
ease in the Eastern suits, the amendments to the specifi-
cation pertaining to methods and theories would undoubt-
edly require the same careful consideration which was
given to them by the judges in the Eastern cases. And
in passing upon the method claims now before this court
in the Powers-Kennedy case, we are confident that your
Honors will agree with the opinion of Judge Learned
Hand in the Ulen ease, citing Westinghouse v. Metropoli-
fan, 290 Fed. 661 (Exhibit Book, p. 15), that no ade-
quate defense, even as to method claims, can be predi-
cated upon the file-wrapper history of the MeMichael
application,

But in this case, apparatus claims only are involved.

PME LEOORAL IEA LE ALE OB La Se BE Ta RE A

64

No matter how many times McMichael may be said to
have changed his theories or ideas as to method, the
apparatus always has been and now is th

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386007_0435%3A12. Public record. Not legal advice.
