# Transcript of Record — Minerals Separation North American Corp. v. Magma Copper Co.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386007_0318%3A01

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1930
- **Citation:** 280 U.S. 400

## Text

Vol. I

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD

Supreme Court of the United States

OCTOBER TERM, 1929

No. 71

MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH AMERICAN
CORPORATION, PETITIONER,

vs.

MAGMA COPPER COMPANY

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT

PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED APRIL 23, 1929

CERTIORARI GRANTED MAY 20, 1929

(34,160)

(34,160)

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1929

No. 71

MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH AMERICAN
CORPORATION, PETITIONER,

Vs.

MAGMA COPPER COMPANY

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT

INDEX

: Page

Record from the district court of the United States, district of
SED Sb 0s.4 0166 004 Leen seus eha rer saUheiseos pNSs bensen bee he een'ys 1
I, SN 6 ayes 000cv navies eve ses ry Pern 520068 2:
Ly 500 tssnedevesa reeves sab oseewe Kosnebeee be viene 5
PEE. secicaaisuade Pps ere aren er yee ery TT eT e sae 16

Order and stipulation re filing of supplemental and amended
IC. OoccGiesi ces tex ve esnebed soo see sbe ks uwae en 24
Supplemental and amended bill of complaint..........-.....06. 26
Answer to supplemental and amended bill of complaint........ 34

Notice, motion, and affidavits re order to inspect defendant’s
mil) at Superior, ATigonA........ccsccccccccccccessccccsoces 42

Order permitting plaintiff to inspect defendant’s mill at Superior,
Ns cise cee eNSshus.e Soba S88 kN MON) bees beekes egy ere rere re TT ae 420
Testimony of Arthur H. Higgins cussed) cov eethe eee . =
Testimony of George A. Chapman oneniiel .. ina esaeess 551
Colloquy between court and coumsel.....-++++++> echeuwes, ie
Testimony of Arthur F. Taggart (recalled).....--- cvesweee 580
Ralph B. Yerxa (recalled) ....seeeeeeeeeeres 589
Arthur H. Higgins ‘sabia. ohkes ccsacces ae
Stipulation re testimony in prior litigation, etc....----- — —_
Offers in evidence......--eesserrrerrreers Sea neeawus cnc. Se
Colloquy between court ie counsel. ....++++ Seiseeeoe ee a ae
Stipulation re Roberts affidavit......--+++ rie e een eae 616
Opinion, Pedere, J..cccovsevserccorsnservovsrcccorssssonecsee® 617
Interlocutory decree.....-sseesseeeeee évasewes Pe ee 628
Notice of appeadl......scceeceeescecrercrrsceceeeeee® cave eae 630
Assignment of eFrors......-.sseerrererererersseee eee ee 631
Order fixing appeal bond......-+.ssserereeseereserserrsseeees 682
Bond on appeal......c..eeeeeeeeeececercere ERSTE eS Pee 632
Citation and service.........seeeeeeeeeereereeeeeeeeeeseess i oe
Order approving stipulated praecipe.....-..-++eo+eeeereseeeers 635
Stipulated preecipe for transcript of record.......eeseeeeees se OD
Stipulation as -to correctness Of record........sseeeerseereeees 637

Clérk’s certificate. ...... ccc cece cc ccc ccc ccrccccccccecscvensess 638

INDEX. lll

Page
Proceedings in the United States circuit court of appeals, first
SONG SNG5 aly 64s poiveretenncs Skvebo Ob visite CES bore 4S be % OO OoRie ers 639
Opinion, Bingham, J..... eer Tree RPWA Sunn SW Kae Ratue Pan oie ce 639
A. GER i sok be Noi s pasos Sb eobeescede We saeeseee pa see tee in CR
SD MN von nns sxsisiwbees vabbbeds davtessvrdeevieusscss cco, RR
Motion and order extending time, Supreme Court.................. 655
‘Order allowing certiorari..... eee EER dg eT TELE eee ee 659
Stipulation re transcript of record, Supreme Court................ 660
Plaintiff's Exhibits, district court of the United States............ 661
Re Ae OU BO, MND iis 6 cv a vanaan vs bueseevisuccevc, 663
6—Stipulation re statement of mill NS os. 0s kp wen dion es 667
7—Drawing of defendant’s Callow cell or Callow pneunatic
flotation apparatus...... eT RT ere eh ee eee §81
8—Picture of five-ton Callow pneumatic flotation set.......... 683
9—Drawing of five-ton Callow pneumatic flotation set........ 684
Statements re Exhibits 10 and 11........... Sewise sabeceaws - 685
12—Sectional views of pneumatic cell, plaintiff's Boston dem-
MIE Cre briei i bek ie Sse cbdednvnicnsueedce vest 687
13—Elevation of pneumatic cell, plaintiff's Boston demonstra-
RR SIN Venndesauactwritds cued Sev nhw ea Vadose sen esos 689
14—Plan of ball grinding mill classifier and two pneumatic
cells at plaintiff’s Boston demonstration 5s kick os 691
15—Manifest and packing list, Callow cells......... vee sepeeais 693

17—Roberts’ affidavit giving list of reagents used by American
licensees of Minerals Separation North American Corpo-
18—Roberts’ affidavit gives list of American licensees of
Minerals Separation North American Corporation........ 713
19-Roberts’ affidavit giving list of licensees and “tons of ore
SUMO. chou SeeGuave rans cess ews vok oe ol euesw seuss, 721
20—Roberts’ affidavit giving summaries of “tons of ore treated,” vs
“tons ef concentrates produced,” and “licensees reporting

OTN SO isi ie Soe eK incdsSveerecdecisieces TRH
102—Chart 6f velocity tests by Yerxa........... sicvovseresecce WET
103—Chart of velocity tests by Yerxa.............ccccceccceees 728
104—Certified copy file-wrapper and contents of patent in suit,

| ee eee eS Te ee eee 729
-05—Certified copy file-wrapper and contents of patent to John

Ss NOOO, ENOL sD Rrra so b8604 64 65 0 068s ve NGA OSS ie oe 757
106—Patent to John M. Callow, No. 1,124,856.............0000- 845
107—Patent to John M. Callow, No. 1,125,897, of January 19

Ee Re eee OPER ee Cer ee ee S49

108—Patent to John M. Callow, No. 1,141,377, of June 1, 1915.... 853
109—Patext to John M. Callow, No. 1,182,748, of May 9, 1916.... 860
110—Certified copy Canadian patent No. 160,689 to Metals Re-
covery Co., assignee of John M. Callow.................- 864
111—Patent to E. R. Gabbett, No. 444,345, of January 6, 1891.... 882
D—Pleadings, Minerals Separation, Ltd., against Miami Copper
Co., marked “Plaintiff's Exhibit D” for identification.... 887

lv INDEX.
Page
Defendant’s exhibits, district court of the United States............ 921
13—British patent 488 of 1860 to Haynes........ Sthesdivsa ss . &
14—German patent 42 of 1877 to Bessel Bros.....- ert rer 929
15—German patent 39,369 of 1886 to Bessel Bros............. 981
16—U. S. patent 348,157 to Everson.........sereeeereereceees 935
17—British patent 24,144 of 1892 to Sutton.....---+++++esee- . 988
18—British patent 427 of 1894 to Robson & Crowder. ......00. 40
19—British patent 2538 of 1895 to Robson & Crowder........ 944
20—U. S. patent 575,669 to Robson........+++++++ eT eT TT ET 947
21—U. S. patent 703,905 to Elmore....++++eessereereees ae 952
22—U. S. patent 776,145 to Potter......-seeerereeeerrrsreees 955
31—British patent 12,778 of 1902 to Froment......-.-+++++++: 959
32—British patent 26,295 of 1902 to Cattermole........-. imines TE
33—U. 8S. patent 768,259 to Cattermole......cccseeeeeeereneees 965
34—U. S. patent 763,260 to Cattermole..... er rreeyy rt” eee Tr 969
35—U. S. patent 777,273 to Cattermole.....--- re ee ees envs 973
36—British patent 17,109 of 1903 to Cattermore et al........-- 978
87—U. S. patent 777,274 to Cattermole et al........eeeee cree 982
38—U. S. patent 788,247 to Cattermole et al......eeeeeeeeeees 984
40—U. S. patent 793,808 to Suliman & Picard... cesccesesees 988
48—U. S. patent 826,411 to Elmore.....-++--++sserrrrererees 993
53—British patent 7803 of 1905 to Sulman, Picard & Ballot... 9%
54—U. S. patent 835,120 to Sulman, Picard & Ballot.......-.- 1002
65—New Zealand patent 19,633 of 1905 to Sulman, Picard &
Ballot .....00- (etpes vaneuee ese vevateswann pabiasere ess 1008
56—Pages 1815, 1817, 1824, and 1825 of supplement to The New
Zealand Gazette of July 27, 1905......--+- Saas ene vunes -- 1034
57—Title page and page 229, New Zealand Patent Office Jour-
nal, October 31, 1912..... ie kvceeeetewtensetasesses, Se
58—Title page and page 312, New Zealand Patent Office Jour-
nal, December 12, 1912.....+++++++ee+55 paee seeauee» wees 1040
59—U. S. patent 835,143 to Sulman......-++ Pro eer tT TTT ate 1042
60—U. S. patent 835,479 to Sulman, Picard & Ballot.....----- 1045

68—British patent 26,852 of 1908 to Minerals Separation, Ftd.. 1050
70—British patent 28,173 of 1908 to Sulman, Picard & Ballot.. 1058
71—U. S. patent 955,012 to Sulman...esccccccscccccsesescces 1058
72—File-wrapper and contents of U. S. patent 955,012 to
Sulman ...ccscecscccovcesscsovess ve wwe GuekSaeeees esos 1063
%5>—British patent 2359 of 1909 to Greenway, Sulman &
Higgins ......+eeeeeerrrs ete Renee Vea es ery ee
76—British patent 2359 of 1909 to Greenway, Sulman &
Higgins ....eeeeeeeeeees oawaeties | 7 1 CHARLES tealunc

VOLUME I.

ee

UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS |
FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT. |

OCTOBER TERM, 1927.

No. 2259.
MAGMA COPPER COMPANY,

DEFENDANT, APPELLANT,

Vv.

MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH AMERICAN
CORPORATION,

PLAINTIFF, APPELLEE.

APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES ©
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MAINE,
FROM INTERLOCUTORY DECREE (PETERS, J.), APRIL 20, 1928. |

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD.

VOLUME L
PLEADINGS AND EVIDENCE.

WILLIAM H. DAVIS,
Bee MERTON W. SAGE,
UY OF gR>~_ ALBERT S. WOODMAN,
eG, SEN, WOODMAN, WHITEHOUSE, SKELTON
& THOMPSON,
* 93

For Appellant.
en
Lo

HENRY D. WILLIAMS,
WILLIAM HOUSTON KENYON,
SIDNEY ST. F. THAXTER,
WILLIAMS, RICH & MORSE,

For Appellee.

:
es aammamemmeiaianeneaaas

UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT.

No. 2259. October Term, 1927.

MAGMA COPPER COMPANY,
Defendant-A ppellant,

v.

MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH AMERICAN
CORPORATION,

Plaintiff -A ppellee.

IN THE

District Court of the United States,

For tHe District or Mainz, SoutHern Division.

No. 800.

IN EQUITY.

MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH AMERICAN
CORPORATION

v.
MAGMA COPPER COMPANY.

DOCKET ENTRIES

Jan. 9, 1920 Bill of Complaint filed.
oe) Appearance of Thaxter & Holt for complain-

ant filed.

“ 10, ‘* Subpeena issued returnable Jan. 30, 1921—
10 A. M. ;

— a Subpeena returned executed. Ent. and filing
ret.

“« 29, ‘* App. of Williamson, Burleigh & McLean as
attorneys for defendant filed.

“ 30, ‘* Stipulation extending time for filing answer

filed and allowed.
Mar. 22, “ App. of Woodman & Whitehouse for Magma
Copper Co. filed.
“ 24, ‘* ‘Time for filing answer extended thirty (30)
days. (See stipulation on file.)

__ ON eRe EEN a

46

30, 1921

29,

22, 1923

30,

“eé

6c“

. 28, 1922

ee

‘é

Docket Entries

. 30, 1920. Time for filimg answer extended further pe-

riod of thirty days. (See stipulation on
file.)

Defendant’s motion for bill of particulars
filed.

Stipulation extending time for filing defend-
ant’s answer filed.

Hearing extended to May 11th, 1920 (Tues-
day).

Hearing adjourned to May 26, 1920—9 :30
A. M. by stipulation (filing).

Stipulation extending time for hearing on
defendant’s motion for bill of particulars
adjourned to Friday, July 30; also time for
filing defendant’s answer extended, ete.
(See stipulation on file.)

Hearing Hale, J. on motion for bill of par-
ticulars.

Finding of Court filed.

Defendant’s answer filed.

Order for taking deposition de bene esse of
Leslie Bradford filed. (Hale, J.)

Deposition of Leslie Bradford, witness for
defendant, filed.

Defendant’s motion for leave to take deposi-
tion of Theodore J. Hoover and order
granting same allowed.

Supplemental and amended bill of complaint,
stipulation and order of Court filed.

Defendant’s answer to supplemental and
amended bill of complaint filed.

Hearing on defendant’s motion that case be
set for hearing ordered for March 30, ’23,
10 A. M.

Hearing Peters, J. on motion that case be set
for hearing. Hearing set for June 18, '23,
at 2 P. M. Bangor.

June

iti

“6

30,

16,

“ec

Docket Entries 3

1923. Plaintiff’s motion for leave to inspect and to

sé

‘cé

sé

sé

‘é

sé

sé

6e

take depositions filed.
Hearing on same. Motion granted as per
decree filed.

Stipulation cf agreement as to mill opera-
tions filed by W. & W.

Defendant’s Interrogatories filed with order
of Court regarding same.

Answers and Objections to Interrogatories
filed.

Stipulation re deposition de bene esse of
Theodore J. Hoover filed.

Upon oral presentation by counsel each and
every of plaintiffs’ objections to the inter-
rogatories was sustained, and exceptions
to defendant were allowed in each case.

Defendant’s motion for further particulars
and order, Peters, J., granting same filed.

Defendant’s motion for subpoena to Seth
Gregory and Arthur H. Higgins and order
thereon filed.

Subpoena issued in accordance with order of
Court.

Defendant’s motion for subpoena to Wm. 8.
Stevens and Levi B. Shipley and —
thereon filed.

Subpeena issued in accordance with disié of
Court.

Appearance of Wm. H. Davis for deft.
filed.

Appearance of John F. Neary for deft.
filed.

Appearance of Merton W. Sage for deft.
filed.

Subpena to Wm. S. Stevens returned exe-
cuted.

Subpoena to Seth Gregory returned executed.

4 Docket Entries

June 29, 1923. Subpoena to Arthur Howard Higgins re.

turned executed.

" at aca Stipulation as to introduction of translation
of German Patent filed.

«« 95, ‘© Hearing begun before Peters, J., at Bangor
per stipulation filed.

«6 «666 ~~ fearing continued from day to day to and
including Friday, July 6, 1923.

July 6, ‘‘ Arguments made by both sides. Hearing
closed.
«6 Qounsel to exchange briefs by Sept. 25,
1923.
«= )~©6 Reply briefs to be filed within two weeks
thereafter.

«90, ‘* Stipulation that hearing may be held in
Northern Division filed.

Aug. 3, ‘‘ Order, Peters, J. allowing exhibits to be
withdrawn from the files for the purpose
of having copies made for inclusion in the
printed case filed.

“

“ 7

Arthur Fay Taggart 253

which will give to the Court a picture of the results as they
are plotted when you start out to find out how much oil
you need in any particular operation. That is, I understand
it is customary to plot the results and show a curve that indi-
eates the amount of flotation as against the amount of oil
used, other conditions remaining the same. Can you furnish
me with such a curve sheet?

A. I eannot now. I could prepare such a curve sheet.

Q. 146. I have something here that is not precisely what
I had in mind, but will answer the purpose. Within this
treatise is a diagram, showing the effect of decreasing pro-
portions of oil, according to its title. Will you please explain
to the Court what that diagram shows?

A. This is a diagram that is intended to show the facts as
between froth production and granule production, as in the
Cattermole process when the amount of oil is varied, all other
conditions remaining constant. It shows by the shaded
areas—in the left hand shaded portion, it shows the respec-

tive weights of granules with respect to the total amount of
in the froth, based on the total mineral in the ore, that is

raised or recovered with that particular quantity of oil. Thus
if we begin at the topmost horizontal line, namely, that labelled
6 per cent., it shows that a very considerable percentage,
somewhere, I should read, in the neighborhood of 90 to 95 per
cent. of the total mineral that was present in the feed, is re-
covered in the form of something granular, and a very small
percentage, perhaps less than 1, is recovered in the form of
froth.

By Mr. WiiuiaMs:

Q. 148. It says isolated floating granules in the chart,
does it not?

A. I accept the correction, that are floated in the form
of granules. Those may be floating there because of a bubble
that is attached to them, or they may be floating by skin flo-
tation. They are utterly unimportant with respect to the
recoveries that are made at that point. Now, if we come down
mineral present, and in the right hand shaded portion, read-
ing horizontally at any elevation, the proportion of mineral

~

a

254 Arthur Fay Taggart

to the line marked 3 per cent., say, there appears to be a slight
decrease in the percentage of mineral that is sunk, a slight
increase in the percentage of floating mineral, and that min.
eral is stated to be floating as flocks as distinguished from
granules, and again, those particles may be floating by reason
of attached air bubbles, or they may be floating by skin flo-
tation. At one per cent. there begins a considerable decrease,
according to this chart, in the amount of mineral that sinks,
and it is marked at that zone ‘‘granulation becoming indis-
tinct.’’ That is, the granules are probably not well formed,
but flocky, as it were, irregular, and rather difficult to sepa-
rate; the percentage of mineral thus granulated is less, al-
though not very greatly less, than it was with the larger
amount of oil, and the amount of the material that is floating
increases as the amount that is sunk lessens.
Tue Court: That is all very clear. I see down below
there the reason for the decision by the Supreme Court.

By Mr. Davis:

Q. 149. Professor Taggart, you said several times in
your testimony, speaking about the mineral particles in pulps
where the frothing agent was in solution, that the mineral
particles were coated with the frothing agent. Will you please
explain that physical phenomenon?

A. Whenever there is a solution of one substance in
another, the distribution of material in that solution is not the
same throughout, that is, it is different at the surfaces of the
solution, which may be the upper or gas surfaces, or the con-
tacts with the containing vessel, or the contacts with any
solid substance submerged therein, or with any other liquid
that is adjacent to the first liquid.

This particular phenomenon of concentration from solu-
tion at surfaces is the well-known phenomenon of adsorp-
tion. I know from experiment that it is impossible to pro-
duce an attachment of gas bubbles to clean mineral particles;
that the surfaces of the mineral particles have got to be coated
with some substance—and ordinarily it is some organic sub-
stance— and that it does not make the slightest bit of differ-

Arthur Fay Taggart 255

ence whether the coating is with some substance that may be
mixed with the water in such proportions that it does not all
dissolve, or whether it is with some substance which, when
mixed with water, will all dissolve. In either case, there is
this concentration of the substance on to the surface of the
solid particles as the absolute pre-requisite to the precipi-
tation of gas thereon. That is adsorption which is a universal
phenomenon. With any solute not substantially in solution,
there may be adsorption, but the amount of material that is
adsorbed out of a given solution, differs with different kinds
of material, and that is because the energies at the contacts be-
tween the liquid and the different kinds of solids are different.
Measurements have been made of the amount of adsorption
of various substances from solution, they may be liquid sub-
stances, or solid substances, or gaseous substances. I have
measured the actual adsorption in the case of certain flotation
agents, against certain particular gangue and sulphide par-
ticles, and proved to my own satisfaction that there was sub-
stantial differential adsorption as between the sulphides and
the gangue materials of these particular flotation agents, and
it is that that I refer to as coating.

Q. 150. Can you give us one or two illustrations of the
dependence upon the effect of adsorption in the arts, outside
of this flotation art?

A. One well known is the industry of dyeing silks and
other dyeing processes, which are built up very largely on
adsorption processes. The de-colorizing of oil is a function
very largely of the adsorption on some finely divided solid
of objectionable coloring substances in solution in the oil.
The removal of fusel oil from whiskey is another one of the
adsorption phenomena.

Mr. Davis: Now, if your Honor please, I have fin-
ished with the testimony of this witness in regard to this
subject of agents. I have brought out these processes,
because they come in naturally; and I will proceed now
and will close as rapidly as I can, to the defense of non-
infringement; that is, to the defense that their process
is limited to the agitation-froth process, that particular

256 Arthur Fay Taggart

aspect of the defense of non-infringement; of course, g

great deal has already been said to pave the way.

Q. 151. Professor Taggart, will you please compare the
defendant’s pneumatic process of flotation with those pulp.
body processes which you have already described, including
the agitation-froth process?

A. The defendant’s process, as described in the stipn.
tation that I heard discussed yesterday and have also read,
consists in the formation of a freely-flowing pulp, and the
mixing with that pulp of a flotation agent that is substantially
all in solution; then running that into a rectangular box with
an inclined porous bottom, and blowing air into the mixture
through that porous bottom. As a result of that treatment,
there forms on the surface of the pulp in the box a column
of bubbles—froth, if you choose to call it, although at that
point I do not think it is quite properly so characterized—a
column of bubbles, and these bubbles build up as the cell is
first being filled, until they reach the level of the sides of the
box, and then they begin to overflow as finished concentrate.

If you examine that particular operation with a machine
that has a glass side in it, the first thing that becomes strik-
ingly apparent is that as the bubbles come out of the body of
pulp they are the same color as the pulp. Now, if you have
heen looking at the agitation-froth process, or any of these
other pulp-body processes in the same way, and watching the
bubbles come out of the pulp, they are the color of the min-
eral particles, and it is immediately apparent to the eye that
the work of concentration has been finished in the pulp with
these processes. Here, however, there is no such completion
apparent, and, as a matter of fact, the exact reverse of that
is apparent, that the concentration has not even yet started
as the bubbles ermerge from the pulp. Then, as the bubbles
rise in the bubble column, there will be apparent a blackening,
usually, of the froth—because ordinarily sulphide minerals
are dark in color, and worthless minerals are light—and this
progressive darkening of the color of the froth indicates
a progressive increase in concentration. In other words, the
concentration is taking place in this column of bubbles resting

Arthur Fay Taggart 257

on the surface of the body of pulp. That particular visual
observation may be beautifully affirmed numerically by stick-
ing tubes in through the side of the machine and taking out
at the different depths small amounts of the material that is
present at those particular elevations and assaying them for
the percentage of metal that they contain. If that is done,
it will be found in the operation of the defendant’s process—
in other words, in the operation of the pneumatic process—
that just what has been seen, or what has been apparent to
+ the eye, is the fact, and that along that particular vertical
plane or section of the machine that is being investigated the
assay is precisely the same or substantially the same from the
bottom of the pulp to the top of the pulp; that the first sample
taken at the bottom of the bubble column shows a mineral
content that is substantially the same as that of the pulp
itself; and if it were not for the fact that there is a slight
variation in level there, so that it is extremely difficult to get
just an accurate sample, it would be precisely the same. Then
the next sample above that shows more concentration. The
next, more concentration, until finally we build up to the com-
pleted concentration of the cell at the top of the bubble column.
If the same kind of sampling is done in the spitzkasten
of an agitation-froth machine, on the other hand, as before,
the assay of the samples down in the spitzkasten are sub-
stantially the same throughout, because it does not make any
difference there whether the particles are distributed as indi-
vidual particles throughout the pulp, or whether they are
collected together on a lot of little bubbles. If you take a
cupful the distribution will be substantially the same in either
case, so that you would not expect any difference in assay
down there. The key assay is the one just above the pulp
surface. Now, in the pneumatic process that key assay is
substantially the same as the pulp. In the agitation-froth
process, it is finished concentrate; the evidence of the eye as
to that fact is absolutely confirmed by the chemical assay and
the figures thereof. This substantial difference in the place
of concentration is apparent.

258 Arthur Fay Taggart

There is also a substantial difference in the way in which
the thing is done; because in the agitation-froth process, the
gas precipitates on to the surface of the individual particles
down in the pulp, and hangs on to them, brings them up to
the surface, and there the particles and the bubbles collect
as a rather peculiarly coherent froth or scum. In the pnen-
matic process, in the first place, there is no attachment of
particles to the bubble in the pulp, because there is not pres-
ent in the pulp the peculiar condition of super-saturation
that is necessary to bring about that attachment; and when
the particles get into the bubble column, they are not rigidly
attached to the bubbles. They are falling back off of them at
all times; there is a race, really, between the rate at which
the sulphide particles are falling back and slipping off the
bubbles, and the rate at which the bubbles are going up; and
the cell, for proper operation, is so adjusted that the rate
of rise of the bubbles is a little bit more rapid than the rate
at which the sulphide particles fall back, and a little bit less
rapid than the rate at which the gangue particles fall back,
so that there is a differential falling back. The sulphide par-
ticles, you can see them—I confess that I do not know the full
reason for it, but this you can see—the sulphide particles
seem to hug the surfaces of the bubbles as they fall back, while
the gangue particles fall right straight through. Therefore,
each of the sulphide particles has a long fall, because it has
to go around all the corners in falling down, and the gangue
particle runs away from it, and thus there is a differential
draining, with resulting concentration.

Q. 152. Did you make one of the party that went to
Superior on this trip of inspection of the defendant’s plant,
in connection with this litigation?

A. Yes.

Q. 153. Of whom was that party made up?

A. Do you want the whole party?

Q. 154. Yes, if you have it here; both sides.

A. Messrs. Davis, Neary, Sage, Bacon, Yerxa, Taggart,
Perkins, Thompson, Callow, Williams, Kenyon, Grosvenor,
Chapman, Higgins, Wilkinson, Wilding, Trotter.

Arthur Fay Taggart 259

Q. 155. And did you during that inspection at the mill,
at Superior, make such tests of the bubble column, as you have
just described ; and if so, will you please tell us exactly what
you did, and whether the representatives of the other side
took part, and what the results were?

A. I did make such a test. We placed in one of the pneu-
matic cells in the defendant’s plant, at a point distant some
8 feet, I should say, from the feed end of the cell, a series of
¥-inch pipes, projecting through the side of the cell, about
6 inches into the body of the pulp and the bubble column
therein, at varying heights above the bottom, there being, as
I recollect, eight pipes in this vertical row. We also inserted
at the level of the lowest pipe in this series three more pipes,
one about four feet from the feed end of the cell, one about
12, and one about 16 to 18 feet, so that we had then two sets
of sample pipes into the side of this cell, one a set that would
take samples in a vertical section and another that would take
samples along the length of the cell. These pipes were
plugged with corks until the beginning of the sampling op-
eration. The other ends of the pipes in the vertical row
were connected by rubber tubes with either pails or bottles,
according to whether they projected into the pulp or into
the froth; the reason for the distinction in the method of
connection being that the froth will not flow out, of its own
account, of the sample pipes. We had to stopper the bottles
80 that we could connect to the suction apparatus. The other
sample pipes along the bottom of the cell were connected
directly to the buckets. After arranging with the plaintiffs
that they might have representatives with Mr. Yerxa and

myself, who took the samples of the material coming out
through the tubes, we started to sample by taking out the
plugs from these various pipes and allowing the pulp to run
out into the sample bottles and pails. At the same time rep-
resentatives of both parties took samples of what we call
heads, tails and concentrates, namely, the feed or heads to
the cell, the worthless discharge or tails, and the overflow or
concentrate. These samples were then, by representatives of
the two parties working together, weighed wet and dried, and

—

260 Arthur Fay Taggart

then weighed, and split up each into four parts, of which the
plaintiff took one part, one part was sent to the mill office for
assay, one part was sent to me for assay, and one part was
held for assay in case there was any dispute between us as
to the correctness of the results obtained. I sent the samples
that were received by me to Ledoux & Company, who are
recognized assayers in New York City, for assay, and I have
their results here, as also the results that were reported to
me of the assays at the mill. The samples were numbered
X-1 to X-14 in order, X-No. 1 being the sample at the bottom
of the vertical row, X-No. 8 being the sample at the top of the
vertical row, and the X-2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7, progressing in order
upward between the first mentioned and the last. X-9 was a
sample of the feed or heads of the cell. X-10 was the sample
that was supposed to be taken at the bottom of the cell, near
the head end. This one was about 4 feet from the feed end
and the bubble column extended so far down at this shallow
end of the cell that there was froth or bubble column down
to this level, and we could not make it flow off, so that 10 is
missing. X-11 is the sample along the bottom towards the
tail end from the vertical row. X-12 is taken from the bottom
near the tail end. X-13 is the tailing sample and X-14 the
concentrate sample from the cell as a whole. Now, we will
consider first those samples that were taken from the pulp
body. The assays are in percentage of copper as reported
by Ledoux: ;

0.97, No. 1; 1.01, No. 2; 1.00, No. 3; 1.03, No. 4; 1.02, No. 5.
That is, the maximum variation between those samples is
as between 1.03 and .97, no variation at all. The first sample
that was taken in the bubble column was 1.27. There isa
start of concentration. This was taken a little bit above the
level of the pulp, because it is extremely difficult in one of
these big operating cells to land right on the division line.
The level is changing a little all the time, so that here where
we are just a little above the pulp level, the first assay is 1.27.
Concentration has started. The next is 3.13—it is going up
gradually. The next is 5.68, still progressing. The final con
centrate taken right off the top—because we could not get

Arthur Fay Taggart 261

asampling pipe right up into the very top of that overfiow,
so that we have to use the final concentrate for that figure—
is 16.83. We go up then right regularly and gradually through
the bubble column with the concentration. The tailing of
the cell, which was sampled some 16 feet further along in
the flow of the pulp from the bottom of our vertical series
here, was 0.43, showing that the pulp had not been completely
impoverished, or at least as much impoverished as it was going
to be, at the point that we sampled, and the feed sample of
2.96 compared with our 0.97 sample, shows that in that first
seven or eight feet there had been an impoverishment of sub-
stantially 2 per cent. in the total mineral content in that dis-
tance.
The mill assays as reported to me were X-1, 1 per cent.
They did not carry that up to quite so great an extent as
Ledoux did. X-2,, 0.9 per cent.; X-3, 1.0 per cent.; X-4, .09
per cent.; X-5, 1.1 per cent.

Those were the pu!p samples, and they ranged between
0.9 and 1.1, a little greater range, but substantial check, con-
sidering that it was much rougher assaying by the ordinary
every-day methods at the mill, than Ledoux practices. Then
their samples in the bubble column ran along 1.5, 3.3, 6.1,
the same concentration indicated, and the final concentrate
of 16.9. Sample X-11 assayed 0.7; sample X-12, 0.4, sample
X-13, 0.5.

Mr. Wriuiams: Of course we need not state the stip-
ulation which we usually do, that the assays of an estab-
lished assayer will be accepted in evidence without any
further proof, subject to correction.

Mr. Davis: I call your Honor’s attention to the fact
that the witness spoke of the length of this cell, and it
was much longer than the cell in use at the last part of
the year 1919, which has been testified about. I did not
know whether that might introduce confusion into your
mind about it. These cells are 24 feet long.

Q. 156. During that inspection did the plaintiff’s rep-
Tesentatives make any attempt to measure the velocity of
flow or the degree of agitation in the pulp body and in the

lam

262 Arthur Fay Taggart

A. Yes, apparently.

Q. 157. Did you observe those attempts?

A. I did.

Q. 158. Will you please describe what occurred?

A. The apparatus that they attempted to measure the
velocities of the currents in the cell with was a very ingenious
apparatus. It consisted of a bent arm, carrying at the bottom,
mounted suitably, a little 4-bladed impeller that moved when
you blew at it, for instance, or moved it backward and for.
ward through water, very easily, so that it would record,
therefore, any current that flowed through it. Then there
was a little eccentric on the shaft of this impeller, connected
with a little rod that worked backward and forward for each
revolution in a little enclosed cylinder, and therein apparently
made an electrical contact, so that at each revolution of this
shaft the electrical contact was completed by means of the
eccentric rod. Wires extended from this apparatus to a mag-
netic pencil, with suitable electrical apparatus intervening,
so that at each revolution the magnetic pencil made a mark
on a piece of paper. There was also arranged another mag-
netic pencil, connected with a pendulum which, by suitable
electrical contact, recorded one-second intervals by marks on
the piece of paper—on the other edge of the same ribbon of
paper on which the first magnetic pencil recorded. You will
see, therefore, that by moving that paper along you would
get along one side a series of marks, representing seconds,
and along the other side a series of marks, representing rev-

olutions per second, and if you counted you would have, for
_ those particular intervals, the revolution of this little impeller.
The impeller was so arranged on the rod that was inserted
into the pulp that it could, from above, be turned around a
horizontal axis, so that it could be made to measure a current
that was coming downward, or one that was coming hori-
zontally, or one that was inclining upward, and then also by
moving the rod itself on its own vertical axis, you could get
eurrents that were moving along the length of the cell, or
currents moving across the cell, or those that were moving
diagonally. The operators had considerable difficulty with

Arthur Fay Taggart 263

the apparatus at first, in getting it to record, but finally got
itso that to my observation, at least, it was recording prop-
erly. That is, they, for instance, swung the apparatus back
and forward in the cell, and whenever they did that the in-
strament recorded, and as nearly as you can judge of course,
swinging your hand thus, it was moving at the rate of 3 or 4
or 5 feet per second. We don’t have to bother very much
with the difference between 3 and 5 feet. It is somewhere in
that general range. I observed this apparatus being swung
back and forward in the cell, and that was about the rate at
which it was moving, and on the assumption that that was the
rate, apparently the little impeller made about one revolution
for each foot per second velocity of the material that was
flowing past it.

Whenever they held the measuring apparatus still in
the cell, it would go quite irregularly. It might go along for
two or three seconds at perhaps two or three revolutions per
second, and then it would stop maybe for two or three sec-
onds. There was no particular opportunity given, because
the plaintiffs were not particularly satisfied with the results
that the apparatus was indicating, for us to take actual meas-
urements at a given place and pull the paper through prop-
erly and get the proper record, but I was observing the thing
very closely, and I think it is a perfectly fair statement of my
observation that in the neighborhood of three-quarters of a
revolution per second to one révolution per second would
measure the average maximum results that they got by ex-
ploring the cell. That, on the basis of the method of calibra-
tion that I have indicated, would mean that the apparatus was
measuring the velocities in the cell—maximum average veloci-
tiese—somewhere in the neighborhood of a foot or three-
quarters of a foot or a foot and a half per second. I am con-
firmed in my belief that those are fairly the right figures,
because investigations of my own have indicated that those
are about the velocities of the pulp currents in the cell.

Q. 159. Have you made such sampling tests, as you
describe in the answer before the last, on other cells than

264 Arthur Fay Taggart

those out at Superior, and particularly have you made them
on cells such as shown on the drawing accompanying the
stipulation as to defendant’s process?

A. Yes.

Q. 160. I will not ask you to go into detail, but simply
to state what results you got in those tests, whether they
checked with the results you got at Superior?

A. Yes.

Q. 161. You heard Mr. Wilding describe the demonstra.
tion apparatus that has been set up at Boston?

A. Yes.

Q. 162. Do you recognize that as apparatus that you
yourself have seen?

A. The description of it would fit, certainly, apparatus
that I have seen.

Q. 163. It was brought out yesterday on cross-examina-
tion of Mr. Wilding that in the demonstration cell the dead
space at the discharge end was considerably wider than the
corresponding dead space in the actual mill cell; and that
the demonstration cell was smaller than the mill cell, so that
proportionately the dead space was very much larger, that
is, in proportion to the total; do you recall that?

A. Yes.

Q. 164. In your opinion, would that have any effect on
the currents in the cell?

A. Yes, that would make, in my opinion—it would make,
to my knowledge—a considerable difference in the currents
in the cell.

Q. 165. What is your knowledge about it, and how did
you acquire it?

A. I have a cell myself, that is, one of these five-ton or
one-foot Callow laboratory cells, that Mr. Wilding describes,
and I have run it under a great many different ccnditions,
and have found that the proportion that the deed space,
so-called, namely, this space above the discharge out et, bears
to the total length of the cell, makes a marked difference in
the movement of the material in the cell. If the machine is
operated as received, a current more or less like that Mr.

Arthur Fay Taggart 265

Wilding describes will occur in the machine, that is, in so far
as direction is concerned ; and if a piece of board, for instance,
is dropped down into the cell at the discharge end, so as
to lessen more and more the proportion that the dead space
bears to the total length of the cell, the general character of
this movement of material in the body of pulp decreases; that
is, the smaller the proportion of dead space to the total length,
the less there is of this circulatory current, as it may be called,

Q. 166. Can you tell us briefly why that condition of a
large dead space sets up a circulatory current?

A. It is purely a question of heavy un-aerated water that
is over the dead space at the end where no air is going in,
just pushing down under the aerated water and floating it.
That, of course, starts a movement away from the tailing
end or the discharge end up the bottom, and of course as
water there sinks and pushes under the aerated water, the
water on top of it toward the discharge end of the cell settles
down to take its place, and then the water at the top, at the
head end, flows down hill into the depression caused by the
last-mentioned movement, and a circulatory current is
started.

Q. 167. Does that circulatory current have any effect,
one way or the other, on the operation of the cell?

A. If it is too violent, it hurts the operation, but other-
wise it has no effect at all.

Q. 168. It appears from Mr. Wilding’s testimony that
the ore which they used in the demonstration went right into
the flotation cell with its full content of copper. Does that
correspond to what actually happens in the mill, and if not,
what difference would it make? ;

A. It does not correspond to what happens in the mill,
because there, as described in the stipulation, the mill heads,
so-called, are first, after grinding, passed over gravity concen-
tration machines, namely, Wilfley tables, and there substan-
tially half of the mineral content is taken out, so that the ore
as it passes to the cells in the mill is very much lower grade
than this material that Mr. Wilding was treating. Several
results of that would be—it would be a little more difficult

266 Arthur Fay Taggart

for Mr. Wilding to get quite such low tails as they got in the
mill; it would be easier for him to get a better recovery than
is got in the mill, and, because of the greater mineral content
in the ore, there would probably be a difference in the con-
sistency of the froth that overflowed from the cell. The
stability of the froth is considerably affected by the amount
of solid material in it, and the greater the amount of sulphide
material in the ore, the more there would be in the froth.
Q. 169. The greater amount of mineral?
A. The greater amount of mineral.
Mr. Davis: That is all.
Mr. Garrison: May we have until tomorrow morn-
ing to prepare our cross-examination?
Tue Court: Yes; if you will try to make up to-
morrow for this half hour.
Mr. Gangison: Yes, we will.
Tue Court: We will suspend until tomorrow morn-
ing at ten o’clock.
(Whereupon an adjournment was taken until to-
morrow, Thursday, June 28th, 1923, at ten o’clock. A. M.)

FOURTH DAY.

Bangor, Me., June 28th, 1923.
Trial resumed.
Met pursuant to adjournment.
Parties present as before.

; a
ArrHur Fay Taacarr resumes the stand.
Dmect-Examrnation (Continued).

Mr. Davis: If your Honor please, Professor Taggart has
some samples of a number of organic mineral-frothing agents
in bottles, and I should like to simply have them identified,
so that your Honor can see them.

Tue Court: Yes, I would like to see them.

Arthur Fay Taggart 267

By Mz. Davis:

Q. 170. Professor Taggart, will you produce samples
of a number of these mineral-frothing agents and identify
them?

A. Would you care to have them set up?

Tue Court: No, I shall not look at them now, but

Mr. Davis may want to have you say what they are.

Mr. Davis: Yes, that is what I should like to do.

Mr. Wits: You had better put a question, and
get it on the record?

Tue Court: Yes.

Mr. Davis: There is a question on the record.

Q. 171. If you will go ahead, Professor, and take each
one and identify it.

A. This that I hold in my hand is a sample of refined
wood creosote mixed—50 ce. of refined wood creosote, mixed
with 50 cc. (that is, cubic centimeters) of water. The wood
creosote forms a layer of, as nearly as I can read, 50 cubic
centimeters on top of the layer of 50 cubic centimeters of
water.

Tue Court: Have that marked.
Mr. Davis: Have that marked as Defendant’s Ex-

hibit 96, the bottle labeled Refined Wood Creosote, P. T.

& T. Co. No. 200.

(Received in evidence and marked ‘‘Defendant’s

Ex. No. 96. Refined Wood Creosote P. T. & T. Co. No.

200.’’) :

Taz Wirvess: The next is a sample of cresol U. 8.

P., the letters referring to a certain fairly high stand-

ard of purity, mixed with 50 ce. of water, the cresol in

this case being heavier than water, forming the bottom
layer. In so far as it is posssible to read, the mixture
consists of 50 ec. of each of the substances.

Mr. Davis: Mark it Defendant’s Exhibit 97, labeled

Cresol U. S. P.

(Received in evidence and marked ‘‘Defendant’s

Ex. No. 97. Cresol U. 8. P.’’)

Tae Witness: The next is a similiar mixture of

Arthur Fay Taggart

fusel oil with water, and so nearly as can be read, the
volumes are 50 ce. each. The fusel oil, being lighter thay
water, is at the top.

Mr. Davis: Mark it Exhibit 98, labeled Fusel Oil,

(Received in evidence and marked ‘‘ Defendant's
Ex. No. 98. Fusel Oil.’’)

Tue Witness: The next is a similar mixture of
steam distilled pine oil, an essential oil, with water, and
so nearly as can be read the respective volumes are 50
cc. The pine oil is lighter than the water and forms the
upper layer.

Mr. Davis: Mark it Exhibit 99, labeled Steam Dis.
tilled Pine Oil No. 5, Miami.

(Received in evidence and marked ‘‘ Defendant's
Ex. No. 99. Steam Distilled Pine Oil, No. 5 Miami.’’)

Tue Wirness: The next is a mixture of phenol,
marked C. P. (meaning chemically pure), with water.
The mixture was made by first putting 50 cc. of water |
into the graduate, and then adding solid phenol until the
hundred cc. mark was reached by the mixture. The
mixture was then shaken, and as I at present hold it,
there is at the bottom, up to about 43 cc. mark, a
settled mass of solid phenol. Directly above that a clear
layer, extending up to the 55 cc. mark, and consisting
of liquid phenol, or phenol with some water dissolved in
it, and above that is a layer of cloudy water, the cloudi-
ness being due to small droplets of undissolved phenol
dispersed through it, caused by the shaking to which the
mixture was subjected, in an attempt to dissolve the
solidified, phenol.

Mr. Davis: Mark it Exhibit 100, phenol ec. p.

(Received in evidence and marked ‘‘Defendant’s
Ex. 100. Phenol C. P.’’)

Tue Witness: The next is a mixture of kerosene
and water, 50 cc. of each, the kerosene forming a color-
less layer, as nearly as can be read, of a volume of 50 ce
above water.

Mr. Davis: Exhibit 101, labeled kerosene.

“a
aa
a

Arthur Fay Taggart 269

(Received in evidence and marked ‘‘Defendant’s
Ex. No. 101. Kerosene.’’)

Tse Witness: The next is a mixture of Stockholm
tar and water, mixed in so far as it was possible to mix
them, in the same proportions. The Stockholm tar has
settled to the bottom. The upper surface is quite irregular
and reads at somewhat less than 50 ec. I should average
it about 48 cc. There is a small amount of Stockholm
tar also floating on the surface of the mixture, in the form
of a brown scum, principally at the edges of the vessel.
The total volume of the mixture appears to be a couple
of cubic centimeters more than a hundred. That is due,
I think, to the inclusion of considerable air in the layer
of tur, and also to the fact that the tar being quite stiff
and viscous, is hard to measure with any greater degree
of accuracy.

Mr. Davis: Exhibit 102, Stockholm tar.

(Received in evidence and marked ‘‘Defendant’s
Ex. No. 102—Stockholm Tar.’’)

Tue Witness: The next is a mixture of amyl ace-
tate and water, made in the same way. The amy] acetate
forms a layer substantially, as closely as can be read,
of 50 ce. in volume above the water. The amy] acetate is
slightly cloudy, due to the inclusion therein of small
globules of water that were introduced by shaking, and
the fact that there has not yet elapsed sufficient time for
them all to settle out. I think they will settle out within
a few hours.

Mr. Davis: Exhibit 103, labeled amyl acetate.

(Received in evidence and marked ‘‘Defendant’s
Ex. No. 103—Amy] Acetate.’’)

A. (Continuing) The next is a sample of oleic acid and
water similarly prepared, the oleic acid forming a layer of,
as nearly as can be read, 50 cubic centimeters on top of the
water.

Mr. Davis: Exhibit No. 104., labeled ‘Oleic acid,
U.S. P.”

(Received in evidence and marked ‘‘ Defendant's

Exhibit No. 104.—Oleic Acid, U. S. P.’’)

A. (Continuing) The next is a mixture of coal-tar creo.
sote and water, the creosote forming a dark layer on the
bottom. This sample was prepared in the same way as the
others. The volume of the creosote layer is, as nearly as can |
be read, 50 cubic centimeters, and that of the water the same.

Mr. Davis: Exhibit No. 105, labeled ‘‘Coal-tar Creo-

sote, G. N. S. No. 22.’

(Received in evidence and marked ‘‘ Defendant's

Exhibit No. 105.—Coal-tar Creosote, G. N. 8. No. 22.’’)

A. (Continuing) The next is a mixture of blast furnace
oil in water, similarly prepared, the blast furnace oil forming
a layer of substantially 50 cubic centimeters on top of the
water, there being also a few droplets of the blast furnace
oil stuck to the sides of the container down in the water layer.
This sample was made up, as were the rest, by first placing
50 ce. of water in the container and then pouring in the oil.
The blast furnace oil is of nearly the same specific gravity as
the water, and the droplets broke down through. There is nota
sufficient buoyant force acting upon them to tear them loose
from the side.

Mr. Davis: Exhibit No. 106, labeled ‘‘Blast Furnace

Oil.’’

(Received in evidence and marked ‘‘Defendant’s

Exhibit No. 106, Blast Furnace Oil—Bernuth-Lembcke.”’)

A. (Continuing) The next is a mixture of coal-tar and
water, prepared in the same way. The coal-tar forms a
layer at the bottom, slightly less than 50 ce. in volume, as I
read it. There is quite a lot of coal-tar stuck on to the side
of the container in the water layer. The coal-tar is a very
sticky and viscous liquid and ran down the side of the glass
and adhered to it as it was being poured into the container,
and the water has not been able to displace it.

Mr. Davis: Labeled ‘‘Coal-tar—Miami.’’

(Received in evidence and marked ‘‘ Defendant's
Exhibit No. 107.—Coa] Tar—Miami.’’)

Mr. Davis: That is all.

270 Arthur Fay Taggart

Arthur Fay Taggart

Cross-EXaMINATION
By Mr. WittiaMs:

XQ. 172. Professor Taggart, you were asked at the
opening of your testimony to give a brief review of the art
of concentration by flotation with flotation agents which have
a “preferential affinity for metalliferous particles,’’ and
you stated that many processes have been ‘‘described and
used’’ in ore dressing practice within the last fifty or sixty
years; and then you gave a long list of patents and a few
publications commencing with the Haynes British Patent
No. 488 of 1860. Did you mean to say that all the things that
you described had been practically and commercially used?

A. No; many of them had.

XQ. 173. Now, confining yourself to commercial and
successful use, and of course, speaking not from your actual
knowledge which could not go back that far, but from what
you have studied in the literature of the published records of
successful and commercial mining operations, will you tell me
when first, according to this literature, successful and com-
mercial operations were carried on with what you have de-
scribed as ‘‘a pulp-body process of flotation-ore concentra-
tion?’’

A. I should say that the Bessel process described in the
second Bessel patent of 1886, was the first statement that I
know of a profitable application of pulp-body concentration
froth-flotation in the art. It is stated therein that by this
particular improvement over the prior boiling patent, the
entire process has now become lucrative or profitable.

XQ. 174. Well, that is in the second Bessel patent?

A. Yes.

XQ. 175. And as we have that in the agreed translation,
as I read it, there is a reference to the first patent, the state-
ment of the objection to it, and then this sentence: ‘Only
by this improvement has the entire process now

profitable.’’ You agree with that?
A. I think that is quite a fair statement.

become

272 Arthur Fay Taggart

XQ. 176. So that you take that to be an indication that
the Bessel process of the first patent was unprofitable and
that the Bessel process of the second patent was profitable?

A. Ido. I should think the first patent would have been
quite unprofitable, because it is a very expensive thing to heat
a large mass of pulp up to boiling temperature and keep it
there.

XQ. 177. As I read your testimony, you said that in that
first process there was a gas produced. What was that gas!
A. It was partly air and partly water-vapor, steam.

XQ. 178. And water-vapor—or steam?

A. Yes. Not necessarily visible steam.

XQ. 179. Well, steam ordinarily is invisible, is it not!

A. Yes. :

XQ. 180. And how much water-vapor or steam, and how
much air?

A. I should suspect the air was somewhat over two per
cent. of the volume of the liquid that was used. The balance
would be water-vapor.

XQ. 181. And in the bubbles that would be formed in
the mass would you have the air and the steam mixed?

A. As heating begins, as the process operates, if you
begin with cold pulp and begin to heat up as in a batch
operation, the early flotation is largely by air-bubbles and the
later flotation by bubbles that are largely filled with water-
vapor. There is a good froth formed throughout by using
either gas.

XQ. 182. And in the boiling operation, steam is genera-
ted in the mass, and that forms the bubbles with very little
air in it, and before the boiling operation, the bubbles that are
formed are more largely air—I have put it the other way, but
not with any wrong intention.

A. I should suspect that that represents the fact, yes.

XQ. 183. What is the next thing in literature that indi-
cates to you the carrying on of a successful and commercial
operation with one of these pulp-body ore-concentration
processes?

A. The Potter-Delprat process comes next in application,

Arthur Fay Taggart 273

if my recollection of chronology is correct, and the Austra-
lian publications and various A™erican publications of the
mining industry that I have read indicate that that was ap-
plied to the production of large quantities of concentrates
over a considerable stretch of time, particularly in the Broken
Hill field in Australia.

XQ. 184. Well, that is one mine. The large operations
were at one mine?

A. I do not recollect at present whether the records that
I have seen are confined to one mine or not.

XQ. 185. But you do know that at the Broken Hill Pro-
prietary, as widely published, it was used?

A. I am not sure that I have the names of the mines
straight in my mind at all.

XQ. 186. What was the next successful and commercial
process of ore-concentration of the pulp-body type, as you
have termed it?

A. I think the Elmore Vacuum comes next, and as my
recollection goes of the literature that was in competition
with the Potter process in the Broken Hill field I think
that it was also applied at some mines in Sweden; and I am
not at all sure, but I seem to recollect also somewhere in
Wales. I may be wrong on the latter, but speaking from
general recollection and knowledge as to the latter.

XQ. 187. And as to the year—of course, I do not need to
remind you that the publication that you have referred to was
1907?

A. 1907. Well, I cannot fix the dates of the various pub-
lieations that I have read, Mr. Williams. The 1907 one, of
course, I could.

XQ. 188. What does the literature show of the use of
that Elmore Vacuum process today?

A.-I know of no place that it is used to day.

XQ. 189. What does the literature show as to the next?

A. I should say the agitation-froth process was the next,
or coincident with the Elmore, so far as any knowledge that I
have as to the introduction is concerned.

XQ. 190. And I am not sure that you made it quite clear,

274 Arthur Fay Taggart

but what process did you refer to as the agitation-froth pro¢.
ess?

A. That described in the United States Patent No,
835,120.

XQ. 191. You said something about the Elmore Vacuum
process having been used in this country; did you?

A. No. I have seen the Elmore Vacuum apparatus work. |
ing in this country, however. I had forgotten that.

XQ. 192. On a commercial and successful scale and with
operations that were profitable?

A. Well, I could not answer as to profitable. It was
not doing as good work as the pneumatic apparatus that
was working parallel with it in the mill.

XQ. 193. Where was that?

A. At the mill of the Miami Copper Co., in Arizona.

XQ. 194. When was that, about?

A. I would say three or four years ago, as I recollect
it now.

XQ. 195. How long was it operated there?

A. I could not answer that accurately. I saw it operat-
ing during a visit of a week or ten days, and it is my under-
standing that it had been operating before that time,—no, I
saw it start, and it is my understanding that it operated for
a considerable length of time after that.

XQ. 196. And it was carried on in Section 7 Test Plant,
was it not, of the Miami mill?

A. I do not recollect the numbering of the sections. It
was not in the main part of the mill.

XQ. 197. In what they call the Test Plant, was it not!

A. It was outside the end of the main building furthest
from the office. I think that is the Section 7 Test Plant, but
I do not recollect.

XQ. 198. Now, that was honestly just a test operation,
was it not?

A. It was an operation to find out what the thing would
do. There was no idea of installing it as a commercial oper-
ation until it was found out what it would do.

XQ. 199. And, as a matter of fact, it was not installed
as a commercial operation?

Arthur Fay Taggart 275

A. It was not installed—it did not do as good work as
the pneumatic cell did alongside of it, as the pneumatic cell
was developed. I have felt for many years that, if the
vacuum machine had had the time and money spent upon
it that some of the present operating apparatus have had,
it would be a serious competitor.

XQ. 200. I did not ask you that.

A. I am sorry if I exceeded the question.

XQ. 201. In this operation in the test plant of the Miami
Copper Company of the Elmore Vacuum process, were the
slimes rejected before the ore was put through the process?

A. No, the machine was tested on the regular run of
mill pulp.

XQ. 202. So the slimes were mixed in with the coarse
material. There was no separation of slimes, is that right?

A. None whatever.

XQ. 203. Now, you do not know that that was a success-
fal and profitable commercial operation, do you?

A. Well, I thought that I stated that it was not doing
such good work as the other.

XQ. 204. But I have asked the specific question, you do
not know that that was a successful commercial operation?
A. No sir, I have not the dollars and cents on the opera-
tion.

XQ. 205. Was that the only time you saw the Elmore
Vacuum process at work in the mill?

A. Yes. ;

XQ. 206. And just to get the proper perspective of that
test operation at the Miami mill, that was carried on during
the accounting proceeding then under way, was it not?

A. Yes.

XQ. 207. At the time when you and others were spend-
ing a good deal of time in my office every week in connection
with the testimony in that suit, and in a little interregnum
in that testimony?

A. It was not carried on at the time we were in the
office

XQ. 208. Of course that was physically impossible, but

—

276 Arthur Fay Taggart

it was during an interregnum in that proceeding that you
went out and saw this test operation going on at the Miami
mill, is that not right?

A. Yes.

XQ. 209. And that was one of many variations of oper-
ation that were tried in that mill during and preceding that
accounting proceeding?

A. Yes.

XQ. 210. Now, the first patent that you took up was
the Haynes British Patent No. 488 of 1860, and at the end
of your description of that patent, you said:

‘‘Subsequently it was possible to separate the oily
matter containing the sulphide material from the muddy
water containing the gangue, by floating the material
ge

What did you mean, what material did you float off?

A. The bulk of oily material containing the solid matter.

XQ. 211. What is your authority for that in the patent!

A. Have you got a copy of the patent? I haven’t.

XQ. 212. Yes.

A. I,think that the description beginning at page 4, line
29, describes it:

‘‘Whereupon the agitation being still kept up, the
agent acts upon the metal, and gradually effects the
separation of the metal from the earthy or non-metallic
matters of tae ore or matrix, or ore and matrix, the
earthy matter sinking to the bottom of the water, and the
metal being retained by the agent.’’

It seems to me that it is quite clear, knowing what we do of
the properties of the products there used and the tendency
for a mass of the light oil and solid to float in a pulp, that
the statement is intended to mean to make the separation by
flotation. The bituminous matter or oil and fatty matters
are generally of less specific gravity than water.

XQ. 213. Do you remember the percentage that was pres
ent in that patent?

A. Yes; I think he says about 1 part of the agent to 5 tod

Arthur Fay Taggart 277
parts of the sifted ore, and then he gives some other varia-
bles there. There are variations, but 5 to 9 parts covers.

XQ. 214. So you think those masses of oily minera]
would float off?

A. I think without doubt, yes.

XQ. 215. And your authority in the patent is the state-
ment that the gangue sinks?

A. Yes, as quoted.

XQ. 216. In regard to the patent to Carrie J. Everson,
No. 348,157, of 1886, you described the first method of the
two methods disclosed in that patent, making a materia] by
treating cottonseed oil with sulphuric acid; and you say that
that is put into water containing a small amount of acid.
What is your authority in the Everson patent?

A. It did not seem to me that I said that, Mr. Williams.

XQ. 217. I heard you distinctly, and the stenographer
80 reported it.

A. I thought I said that after the making of the mixture
of cottonseed oil and sulphuric acid that water was added
thereto to make a substance of somewhat Salve-like consis-
tency, and subsequently that was mixed with the ore and then
the mass put into acidified water. That is my recollection
of what I said.

XQ. 218. That is what the stenographer Says you said
and what I remember that you said.

A. I have not read it.

XQ. 219. This mass “is then kneaded into the dry ore
and then the mass of dry ore with this material distributed
through it is put into water containing a smal? amount of
acia, and kneaded around therein.”? That is not true, is it?

A. Are we discussing what this mass means, or whether
there was acid in the water that the mass was put into?

XQ. 220. Whether the Statement that the record says
you made, that this mass is put into water containing a small
amount of acid, is a true description of what the patent dis-
closes?

A. I notice in connection with this first method at page
2, line 39:

—x

278 Arthur Fay Taggart

‘‘The stirring or incorporation of the ore with the
liquid should of course be thorough for the purpose of
bringing the mineral into contact with the oil and acid
as completely as possible, and after such incorporation
the mass is then in condition for the washing out of the
quartz by the action of water which will be applied to
the mass in sufficient quantities for this purpose.’’

Now, as the admixture of oil and acid and ore is stirred
into the water, the water is, of course, acidulated.

In the second method——

XQ. 221. I am only asking about the first.

A. I beg your pardon.

XQ. 222. And then if the water is acidulated it becomes
so by reason of the sulphuric acid in the compound that is _
put into it with the ore; is that right?

A. Sulphuric acid that is free in the compound.

XQ. 223. And the water before the ore is put into it is
not acidulated water, but just plain water, according to the
patent?

A. Well, the water into which the mixture is put immedi-
ately becomes acid, so that the acidulation starts as soon as
the mixture goes in, it is rather hard to draw a line. If you
take a basin, of course, before you do anything to it, it has no
acidity init. —

XQ. 224. So far as the basin is concerned, you start
with plain water?

A. Plain water.

XQ. 225. And then you put the ore and oil and acid that
have been mixed together in it, a pasty mass—you put that
in?

A. Simultaneously.

XQ. 226. And then as she describes it, you work it with
your fingers!

A. Yes.

XQ. 227. And that squeezes out the gangue, and then of
course there is another suggestion, is not there, of doing it
in a machine?

4A. Yes, I believe there is.

Arthur Fay Taggart 279

XQ. 228. Now, you said something there about that oily
mass being separated by floating it. I am talking about the
Everson first method.

A. Yes.

XQ. 229. Do you stand for that as an accurate statement?

A. Oh, absolutely.

XQ. 230. New, if you will look at the description, you
will find the last three lines of the first column, on page 2:

“The concentrated mineral will accumulate in a pasty
mass or lump or lumps and will contain the metallic por-
tion of the ore,’’——_
and so forth.

A. That is a quite accurate description.

XQ. 231. Those lumps float, do they?

A. Yes.

XQ. 232. How much oil was in them?

A. It is rather difficult to say.

XQ. 233. About five per cent.?

A. I think it is,

XQ. 234. It was generally agreed in the former litiga-
tion?

A. There is quite a lot of air in those things.

XQ. 235. Do you Squeeze it in with your hands?

A. Yes.

XQ. 236. Do you call the Everson a pulp-body process
of froth-flotation ore-concentration?

A. No, sir.

XQ. 237. And you do not call the Haynes that either?

A. No, sir.

XQ. 238. Who first invented that term ‘ pulp-body
process’’?

A. I think that I did.

Patent No. 676,679, issued June 18, 1901, but you did not at
that point at least describe the process of that Elmore pat-
ent. Will you just briefly describe it?

A. I think it was quite accurately described in the specifi-
cation as follows:

ao,

280 Arthur Fay Taggart

“‘T * * * mix the ore with water—as, for instance,
by the wet crushing method in common use — using a
sufficient quantity of water to make a freely-flowing mix-
ture, the fineness of the ore depending upon the particu-
lar kind of ore treated. I then place the ore in water in

a suitable vessel, add a quantity of the oil depend
upon the particular kind of ore under treatment, a
then agitate the mixture without breaking up the oil
into small globules. The metallic particles will adhere to
the oil and be buoyed up and floated by it while the other
constituents of the ore will remain in the water. The
water and attendent impurities are then drawn off, leay-
ing the oil and metallic particles.’’

XQ. 240. That is the process in which the oil buoyed up
and floated the metal, that mineral that had been entrapped,
is it not?

A. Yes.

XQ. 241. I think in the art there is a generally accepted
term describing that kind of process, is there not?

A. ‘*Oil buoyancy”’ is the term that I think describes it.

XQ. 242. And then there is another term which is not
so descriptive, ‘‘bulk oil,’’ is that right?

A. That has been used.

XQ. 243. That process was very widely advertised and
promoted, was it not?

A. That I cannot say.

XQ. 244. Has not your study of the literature made you
aware of the fact that that was very widely advertised and
spread all over the world and the knowledge of it?

A. There was a great deal said of it in the literature
of the art, yes.

XQ. 245. Was it a commercially successful process so
far as you know from your study of the literature?

A. Well, the only place that I know of its having been
applied in mill operations—and what I say is from a study
of the literature—is in Wales, I think it was. That is the
only thing that I recollect at present. I have a sort of 8
vague recollection of its having been used at other places
but, of course, it could not compete in economy with present
day processes.

Arthur Fay Taggart 281

XQ. 246. It has disappeared quite completely, has it not?

A. It has disappeared most effectively, if you wish.

XQ. 247. Now you said in your evidence that Elmore
Patent No. 703,905 was a patent dealing witiy the same type
of process, and in view of the fact that this patent shows an
oiled belt, greased belt, which picked up the minera! Particles

belt, what in general did you mean when you said that it was
the same type of process?

A. That it utilized the preferential affinity of oily sub-
stances for metallic particles over gangue, for effecting the
separation. I was not considering at that particular time
the details of the method of making the mechanical] separa-
tion after the selection had been made. I think it is quite
accurate to describe this in so far as the mechanical feature is
concerned as an oiled belt process.

XQ. 248. Well, it is also true, is it not, that it is a proc-
ess in which the oil grips and takes hold of the mineral, and
is the medium whereby the mineral is pulled out of the pulp?

A. Yes, it is held to whatever particular means is em-
ployed for getting it out.

you used the expressions ‘‘beaters,’’ ‘“‘beater blades, ’*“‘ blades
of the impeller.’? Now, what is your authority for that in
patent No. 835,120? Have you got a copy of the patent?

tical impeller, carrying near the bottom end, in the diagram-
matic drawing, a section of a cone, in so far as the drawing
is concerned, suspended in the air around the vertical spindle.
Of course, it cannot be so suspended, and I know that it is
attached to the spindle by rods or arms, and these rods or
ams are the effective means of beating the air into solution

—w

282 Arthur Fay Taggart

in the pulp and out of solution, as is necessary for the opera.
tion of the process.

XQ. 250. What does the revolving cone do in that ap.
paratus?

A. Well, it purports to and does cause some guided flow
of the pulp in the apparatus, but it has positively nothing to
do with the concentrating operation that takes place. I have
operated the thing in the position shown, and turned upside.
down, and removed, but with the impeller arms left in, and
absolutely the same result is got under the three differen:
circumstances.

XQ. 251. What you call the impeller arms are the little
spiders—the three-armed spider that supports the cone; is
that right?

A. Yes.

XQ. 252. And they do all of that work of beating in
that you have referred to as the principal feature of the
process?

A. Yes, quite successfully.

XQ. 253. And for :dentification, what is the name in
the art of that type of agitating vessel in which there is a
rotating cone supported by a spider?

A. It is named Gabbett mixer.

XQ. 254. Named after the inventor Gabbett, is that
right?

A. I presume so. |

XQ. 255. I show you United States Patent No. 444,345,
of January 6, 1891, to Edmund R. Gabbett. Do you recognize
that as the patent for the Gabbett mixer?

A. Do you want me to read the patent or look at the
illustration?

XQ. 256. I thought you were familiar with it, Pro
fessor?

A. I don’t think I have ever read it.

XQ. 257. Well, just look at the illustration.

A. The illustration is similar to the apparatus illus
trated in patent 835,120 for agitating the pulp, but the sides
of the apparatus illustrated in the figure of this patent are

Arthur Fay Taggart 283

not so high in proportion to the width as they are in the
apparatus illustrated in patent No. 835,120 and do not
extend so far above the top of the cone.

XQ. 258. Then this patent shows internal ribs in the
cone. Those are not present in the Gabbett apparatus as
used in this art—that is right, is it noti

A. They are not present in the Gabbett apparatus I have

XQ. 259. And this has two spiders, and what you used
has one spider; is that right?

A. No. The one that I used had two spiders, one at the
top and one at the bottom.

By tae Court:

XQ. 260. What is a spider, Professor?

A. It is a piece of metal that fits around the shaft and is
fastened thereto, and has arms projecting from it out to
this conical-shaped piece, and supports the conical-shaped
piece at a distance from the shaft.

XQ. 261. What is the purpose of it?

A. It is to support the conical-shaped piece, so far as
the apparatus is concerned; it is to beat in the air in the
pulp in so far as it is—

XQ. 262. And the arms of the spider are the beaters?

A. Yes, sir; and their purpose is to beat the air into
the pulp.

By Mr. WitttaMms:

XQ. 263. And it is these spiders that compress the air
in front of them and form a vacuum behind them and cause
the action of the process, is that right?

A. Yes, quite accurately stated.

XQ. 264. And there is not anything in the patent about
“beating in’’ or anything in the patent about the compres-
sion ahead of the spiders or the vacuum in rear of the spider
arms?

A. I can answer you out of my head as to the latter
part of the question. As to the ‘beating in’’ I will look
it up if you wish.

a

284 Arthur Fay Taggart

Tue Court: Which patent are you referring to
now?
Mr. Wiiuiams: Patent No. 835,120.

A. I find no use of the words ‘‘beating in’’ or ‘‘beating
air’’ in the patent; of course, the operation is implied through-
out to anyone who understands the process.

XQ. 265. And then you said that you could answer as to
the other part of my question, but you have not?

A. I thought I had. Let us find out the other part of
the question now. (XQ. 264 repeated.) There is no descrip.
tion in the patent that sets forth the fact that there is com-
pression of the pulp in front of the beater arms, the solution
of the air thereby caused and the production of a vacuum
behind the beater arms with consequent precipitation of the
air on to the sulphide mineral particles.

XQ. 266. And there is no mention in the patent of beater
arms, you said, I think?

A. I think I answered that.

XQ. 267. And there is no mention in the patent of the
spider, no description of it?

A. No, ‘‘spider’’ is not mentioned.

XQ. 268. And it is not shown in the drawings?

A. No; in the drawing the cone is shown floating in air,
so far as any support is concerned with respect to the spindle.

XQ. 269. The part of the patent, page 1, commencing line
89, following the description of putting the materials in and
agitating them in the Gabbett reads ‘‘when agitation is
stopped, a large proportion of the mineral present rises to the
surface in the form of a froth or scum which has derived its
power of flotation mainly from the inclusion of air bubbles in-
troduced into the mass by the agitation.’’ That is the deserip-
tion in the patent of the introduction of the air bubbles into
the pulp, is it not?

A. Yes; that is correctly quoted and describes what hap-
pens in so far as drawing air into the pulp is concerned
when a pulp is agitated by one of these rotary agitators. It
has nothing to do with the way in which the attachment of
the bubbles to the mineral particles is effected.

Arthur Fay Taggart 285

XQ. 270. But is there any other description in that pat-
ent either of the introduction of air or of the manner in which
the air bubbles become attached to the mineral particles?

A. In answer to the first question, no. In answer to the
second, there is no description anywhere in the patent, so far
as I can see, as to how the bubbles become attached to the
mineral particles.

XQ. 271. I read to you from your testimony yesterday,
in answer to Q. 23, the end of the sentence: ‘‘I went ahead
and checked out and actually measured the fact that there
was a vacuum produced behind the propeller blade, and made
the thing perfectly tight from the point of view of truth.”
Did you say ‘‘propeller’’ there or ‘‘impeller’’?

A. I do not know which I said. ‘Impeller’ is prob-
ably the proper word.

XQ. 272. How did you actually measure the vacuum
produced behind the impeller blade?

A. I made an apparatus, one of these rotary stirring
apparatus, with a hollow shaft and with one of the blades
of the impeller hollowed out in such fashion that the hole
connected on the inner end with the hole through the center
of the shaft and at the outer end the hole emerged on the
back of the blade near its outer tip. The upper end of the
hollow shaft was connected by means of a stuffing box to a
tube and from thence to a vacuum gauge. The impeller was
then operated at different speeds and the vacuum behind the
blade measured. The vacuum increased rather irregularly,
that is, the vacuum started off very small until the speed got
up, as I recollect it, between 300 and 400 revolutions per
minute. Then there was a steep and substantially straight
line inerease in the vacuum up to the maximum that we were
able to measure, which was about 121% feet of water at some-
where in the neighborhood of 2000 revolutions per minute
in this little three or four-inch impeller. At that point the
device was beating air out of the water so fast that the air
went into the hole back of the impeller blade and went right
through and filled up the vacuum gauge, so it could not meas-
ure the vacuum beyond that point.

286 Arthur Fay Taggart

XQ. 273. What do you mean by a vacuum of 121% feet
of water?

A. The vacuum was as much below normal atmospheric
pressure as is required to support a column of water 12%
feet high.

XQ. 274. Well, take the normal column of water at
atmospheric pressure, how much is that roughly?

A. About 30 feet.

XQ. 275. Now, what would this column be reduced to
with the condition that you have spoken of as a 12'4-foot
vacuum ?

A. It is somewhere in the neighborhood of half a perfect
vacuum. And of course the reason that I could not
carry any further there was due to the defect of the apparatus,
The vacuum is much greater in the actual big machines than
I was able to measure.

XQ. 276. Was this with the Gabbett?

A. No, this was with an ordinary cross-arm straight-
bladed impeller. I also made the same measurement with a
forty-five degree impeller and got a slightly smaller vacuum
for a given degree of revolution. What I mean is that with
what I call the straight impeller with the blades up and
down there is a greater vacuum pull than behind these
inclined blades.

XQ. 277. The measurements you first gave were with a
four-armed impeller with the vertical blades?

A. Vertical blades.

XQ. 278. Vertical blades.

A. Yes.

XQ. 279. Standing up vertically as they swing around!

A. Yes.

XQ. 280. And then you took some measurements with
forty-five degree blades?

A. Yes.

XQ. 281. Which was the higher part as it went around!
Was the inclination such that it tended to push the water
up, or the inclination such that it tended to push the water
down?

|

|

Arthur Fay Taggart 287

A. To push the water up.

XQ. 282. Did you take any measurements at 900 revolu-
tions per minute?

A. Yes.

XQ. 283. What were those measurements?

A. Somewhere in the neighborhood of five or six feet
is my recollection of the figures.

XQ. 284. And then at a thousand revolutions per minute?

A. A thousand would be a little less than a foot more.
The curve was such that it went up somewhere in the neigh-
borhood of two-thirds of a foot per hundred revolutions per
minute.

XQ. 285. What was the diameter of the impeller?

A. Four inches, I think—no, three inches,

XQ. 286. And what was the width of the face of the ver-
tical blades?

A. One-half or three-quarter inch.

XQ. 287. You do not know which?

A. I do not know which. It is a couple of years ago since
I made that measurement, and the curve is quite fairly
impressed on my memory, but the actual dimensions of the
apparatus are not. I can get them for you if you like.

XQ. 288. Why, I think we would rather have your
record than just your memory after two years,

A. The recollection as to the curve is substantially cor-
rect. That is, you can g0 ahead on that, if you wish. [I
can furnish it to you, I think, and the dimensions of the
machine I think I can give to you this afternoon, because I
have got an actual record of those here.

XQ. 289. And would that cover what you did with the
45-degree impeller, too?

A. The 45-degree does not, as I told you, go up so
steeply.

XQ. 290. I mean, can you give me the particulars of
that with the other?

A. Yes, sir.

XQ. 291. Well, if you can give them at a later time we
Wwon’t take any time on it now.

288 Arthur Fay Taggart

A. No, I will have to get these for you at lunch time.

XQ. 292. Now, you said in your testimony yesterday
that with the usual proportion of oleic acid for froth flota-
tion you had made ‘‘actual quantitative determinations of the
amount in which oleic acid is dissolved, and found that it
was quite a sensible amount.’’ What were those dimensions
in figures?

A. Crude oleic acid 5.6 per cent,, and U. S. P. oleic, 8.02
per cent.—call it 8.0. I won’t claim an accuracy up to around
.02 for the method.

XQ. 293. Now, in the first place, how much oleic acid did
vou start with in proportion to water?

A. One part to 4000.

XQ. 294. Now, how did you determine that in the one
ease 5.6 per cent. of that oleic acid was dissolved and in the
other case 8 per cent. of that oleic acid was dissolved?

A. You understand that those were two different samples
and two different substances.

XQ. 295. Oh, yes, that is perfectly clear.

A. The same method of procedure was used in both
cases.

XQ. 296. Just describe the procedure.

A. I took a jar that was square in cross-section, about 4
inches on an edge, and 12 or 14 inches deep, placed therein
1500 cubic centimeters of water and the proper amount of
oleic acid to make the proportions 1 in 4000 (as I recollect
the figures about .35 grams). This mixture was then agitated
violently, as in the agitation froth process for 9 minutes by
means of the ordinary square-bladed rotary stirrer, and then
at the end of nine minutes there was added about 16 grams of
finely ground infusorial earth, and the agitation was con-
tinued up to 10 minutes. It takes some time to get this
earth in, so that probably the last of it was in only a few
seconds before agitation was stopped. Then the mixture was
poured onto a suction filter, and the first few cubic centimeters
that came through (which are usually‘ a little bit cloudy, show-
ing there is still in the mixture some of the actually mechan-
ically suspended oleic acid) were taken out and passed through

Arthur Fay Taggart 289

the filter again, and the mass was filtered to a clear mixture
of oleic acid in solution in the water. The filtrate amount-
ing to some 1500 cc., less what little bit is held back by the
filter, is then divided, and a thousand cubic centimeters
accurately measured are taken for the extraction there-
from of the oil dissolved in the water. To that solution was
added about 250 grams of salt, in order to get a strong brine
solution, and then four 100 ce, portions of ether were shaken
up successively with the briny solution and Separated there-
from. The ether was next evaporated in a small side-arm
distilling flask and there was left as a residue at the bottom
of this flask the oil that had been extracted from the water.
In order to make sure that we were not weighing as oil more
than was actually there, after the weighing we always test this
residue for salt, and if there is any suggestion of salt in the
residue, discard the test completely and repeat.

The oleic acid, therefore, that is in this Side-arm dis-
tilling flask represents two-thirds of the total amount of oleic

we started with 1500 ce.; so that the weight of oil recovered
multiplied by 1.5 and divided by the original weight of oil
taken, gives the percentage of the oleic acid that passed into
solution at that particular temperature, and under those par-
ticular conditions of agitation and proportion of oleic acid
to water,

XQ. 297. And that operation was carried out at what
temperature? ;

A. Ordinarily at 20 degrees within one or two degrees
up or down.

XQ. 298. Normal temperature?

A. Yes. We did not work in a thermostat there.
By Mr. Garrison:

XQ. 299. Twenty degrees C.?
__ A. Twenty degrees (.
By Mr. Witxrams:

XQ. 300. And that is about 60 degrees F., is it not, or
alittle more?

a

290 Arthur Fay Taggart

A. I will agree with you on ‘‘about,’’ somewhere.

XQ. 301. How did you identify this oily residue as oleic
acid?

A. We made sure that it could not be anything but oleic
acid, by running through a blank determination, in which the
same operation precisely was carried forward, except that no
substance was added to the water. We had also previously
re-distilled the ether to be sure that there was no residue
left from the ether itself. Then in case that in the blank
operation there was any substance as residue, we deducted
that from the amount of material recovered in the actual test
before saying that the balance was oleic acid or any other oi
that might be present.

XQ. 302. Of course, the blank operation was one in which
you did not add oleic acid?

A. Yes. One in which we did not add oleic acid, but
everything else was carried through in just precisely the
same way, the agitation and the addition of the calcined
earth, the filtration, the extraction with ether, and the sub
sequent collection and evaporation of the ether. |

XQ. 303. Did that cause you to make any substractionst |

A. Very small. The figure that we ordinarily got was,
as I recollect it, about 0.006 grams. If it departed very far
from that we threw out the infusorial earth and threw ont
the ether and used other substances until we got blanks that |
came to about that, because our experience in a great many
of the solubility tests had shown us that we could get con- |
cordant results that agreed with published results and with.
experience, with that kind of materials.

XQ. 304. Now, how did you identify that residue as oleic
acid?

A. Purely by elimination. There could not possibly be
anything else there but that which had come out of the oil that
was put in, and the oil that was put in was material that is
bought under that name in the market. Of course, we assumed
by elimination, that was oleic acid. There was no chemical
test made for the actual determination of this material, be
cause whether it is oleic acid, chemically pure or not, was not

Arthur Fay Taggart 291

of any particular importance in this particular connection.
It was something that was soluble there and explained the flo-
tation that we were getting with the different agents. We
found always that when the solubilities ran down very low,
we could not get any flotation.

XQ. 305. Can you give me the prior history of those two
specimens of oleic acid?

A. Those particular two? Oleic acid, U.S. P., is material
that was purchased from Eimer & Amend. I have bought, I
do not know how many, one-pint bottles of it, but certainly a
very large number, so I cannot identify it any closer than that.
We analyzed many of them, and the figures run along from six
to eight per cent. on all of them. The crude oleic acid is either
—I can get it within three different substances—it either came
from the Utah Copper Company, the Butte & Superior Mining
Company, or, I think, it is Perry Brothers of Chicago. It is
what is known as ‘‘red oil.’’ We analyzed all three of them.
I do not know which particular one this is; all ranged right
around that same general position.

XQ. 306. That Perry Brothers’ oleic acid was the first
material used by the Butte & Superior in its flotation opera-
tions?

A. That I cannot say.

XQ. 307. You never saw the records of the company that
showed that?

A. I may have seen the records that showed it; I do not
remember. .

XQ. 308. And it was one of these three you used, and you
do not know which one?

A. I do not know which one, but I say we analyzed all
three, and the figures were just about the same, so it does not
make any difference at all which one you take.

XQ. 309. In these tests, could you see the undissolved
portion of the oleic acid in the water after the agitation, the
original agitation?

A. We could not in these particular tests, you see, because
we had added infusorial earth during the last minute of the
operation. If we had not added the infusorial earth, you

292 Arthur Fay Taggart

would have seen some amount of it surely; at least you would
have seen the cvidence of it in cloudiness of the water.

XQ. 310. How about the clarity of the material that you
extracted? Was that interfered with by the infusorial earth!

A. No, not at all. The infusorial earth was used to clear
it out. We filtered the mixtures.

XQ. 311. Did you look at that carefully?

A. Yes.

XQ. 312. Was that absolutely clear, and with no opales-
cence?

A. If they were examined just here, it would be clear,
If you got into full sunlight, as was the case with quite a few
of the others, there was the slightest suggestions of opales-
cence. It was apparently utterly impossible to filter out to
perfectly clear mixture. You see, the material is undoubtedly
dispersed there in all sizes from molecules and then aggre-
gates of molecules as colloids, and then larger and larger
groups, and, of course, the filter will take out at a certain
dimension, so there were possibly some of the particles that
were slightly larger than molecules that gave the opalescence.
Of course, the opalescence is given by material that is in col-
loidal solution; and therefore that explains it.

XQ. 312. Did that liquid that you looked at, that had been
separated, come up to the standard that you gave us yester-
day?

A. What do you mean by that?

XQ. 313. You said, if it was perfectly clear and you could
not see anything in it, then it was in solution?

A. Oh, yes, because if I were to take the thing right here
and look at it, you would find it was perfectly clear. If you
get it out there in the full sunlight and hold it against some-
thing dark, you would get a suggestion of opalescence.

XQ. 314. When you were talking about solubilities yes-
terday, you referred to Van Nostrand’s Chemical Annual,
Fourth Issue, 1918, for valerianic acid solubility. I think you

_

Arthur Fay Taggart 293

took the figure on line 25, page 374, did you not, and the solu-
bility on the facing page 375?

A. Yes.

XQ. 315. Now, what is that little ‘‘n”’ alongside of ‘‘va-
leric acid’’; what does that mean?

A. I suspect ‘‘normal.’’

XQ. 316. You are pretty sure that it means normal, are

you not?
A. That is what I think, yes; that is what I accept that

this means.

XQ. 317. The other book that you referred to yesterday
was the Condensed Chemical Dictionary, of the Chemical Cata-
logue Company, Inc., First Edition, 1919; and this says ‘‘acid
valeric, insoluble in water,’’ that is what you refer to, is it
not?

A. Yes, sir.

XQ. 318. If you just look at the other page, you will see
under ‘‘acid valeric normal,’ ‘‘slightly soluble in water’’; did
you notice that?

A. No, I did not happen to notice that yesterday. I think
I probably have noticed it before.

XQ. 319. That agrees with the table of solubilities, does
it not? aed Ss ‘

A. Yes, fairly.

XQ. 320. And the substances that you picked out, instead

of being acid valeric normal was acid valeric iso?

A. Yes. i

XQ. 320-a. And that was a different substance?

A. Apparently.

XQ. 321. Then you made a mistake; I do not suppose you
meant to, but you did make a mistake, did you not?

A. I would say that I did not make much of a mistake in
what I was attempting to prove, and that is that the books
were utterly unreliable on the subject of solubilities.

XQ. 322. So that the statement in the one book is con-
sistent with the statement in the other book, when you take
them as related to the same substance, is it not?

ee

294 Arthur Fay Taggart

A. That is certainly true when you accept the ‘‘n’’ in this
‘book for ‘‘normal,’’ and I so accepted it.

XQ. 323. You produced a chart of solubilities yesterday,
Who made the determinations of the solubilities that are
shown in that chart?

A. My assistants, under my direction.

XQ. 324. Now, this chart, Defendant’s Exhibit No. 95,
shows a determination of the solubility of kerosene; as I read
it, about one-half of one per cent. went into a solution of 1 to
4,000 parts of water?

A. Yes, that is what it reads on there without doubt, be-
cause I could not get it smaller. The figure for local kerosene
was 0.012 per cent. Then there was another kerosene, rather
more crude stuff, that has been used for flotation, that ran 0.4
per cent. That chart that you have is not to be read, I should
say, within an accuracy of more than a half of a per cent.

XQ. 325. And in this determination of the solubility of
these two kerosenes, you do not need to repeat, of course, but
was the method followed substantially the same as you have
described for oleic acid?

A. Just the same.

XQ. 326. And is that true as to all the materials that are
shown in this chart?

A. Yes.

XQ. 327-8. And were there any chemical determinations
of the residues made in these experiments?

A. To what do you refer as the residues, please?

XQ. 329. The residue is after you had performed all your
separation and evaporated your ether and you got your little
oily material; did you make chemical examinations of those
residues to see what they were?

A. In no cases that I recollect.

XQ. 330. Now, taking the definition which you gave yes-
terday of a practical kind of solubility, not, for example, the
solubility of glass, did you in the work that you did in making
the investigations, the results of which are represented in this
chart, determine in each case that the filtered liquid which

Arthur Fay Taggart 295

was separated was clear and free from opalescence in a bright,
strong light?

A. Yes. Of course some of these things were made on
days that were not sunny, and we did not hold up for sunlight.

XQ. 331. You used artificial light?

A. Yes, of course, that was merely the ordinary incan-
descent lamp, and all of them would show clear through that.
You have got to get them in a pretty strong sunlight to dis-
cover any degree of opalescence at all.

XQ. 332. You were asked about various processes dis-
closed in the prior art yesterday, and testified about some ob-
servations of the processes, and particularly the Kilmore
Vacuum process. You have given us the only instance, have
you not, in which you saw the Elmore Vacuum process at work
in the mill?

A. What do you mean by ‘“‘particularly the Elmore
Vacuum process,’’ Mr. Williams?

XQ. 333. You were asked about several at this place to
which my question related?

A. What place was that?

Mr. Wruuums: I withdraw the question.

XQ. 334. At page 330, Q. 137, you were asked: ‘‘Does
the Elmore Vacuum process recover the slimes?’’? You
answered: ‘‘Yes.’? Now, that knowledge which you there
asserted of the fact that the Elmore process recovered the
slimes, based upon actually seeing the process at work in the
mills, was based upon what you said this morning, the opera-
tion in the Miami Copper Company mill; is that right; I am
confining you now to knowledge of practical operations in a
mill. Is there any other basis for it?

A. Why, yes, there are other bases for it. That is the
only place that I saw the process in operation in the mill, but
in this treatise there is a statement made——

XQ. 335. What treatise?

A. This treatise of Sulman and Picard.

XQ. 336. Well, we will leave that out.

A. You asked me for the other bases, I believe, for my
statement.

296 Arthur Fay Taggart

XQ. 337. Actual knowledge?

A. If you are going to draw the line to what I have seen—
in the mill, of course. |

XQ. 338. That is all you ever saw of the Elmore Vacuum
process at work in the mill?

A. I stated that a little while ago.

Mr. Wruuas: I just wanted to make that perfectly
clear.

XQ. 339. Now, you were asked as to whether the oil was
used at all for levitation in the Elmore Vacuum process, and
you affirmed the statement that it was not; and then you were
asked: ‘‘ Was it true of the Froment process?’’ That is, that
the oil was not used at all for levitation, and you said: ‘‘ Yes.”
Now, have you ever seen in a mill anywhere the practical oper-
ation of the Froment process?

A. I have never seen it in practical operation in the mill.
I have been very much surprised that it did not develop into
practical mill operation, because it does such remarkably good
work in the light of what the state of the art was at that time.

Tue Court: He only asked you whether you have
seen it.

Tue Wirness: I beg your pardon.

Mr. WiuraMs: I did not want to stop you, Professor.

XQ. 340. Now, you testified of inspection of the defend-
ant’s mill at Superior, Arizona, attended by representatives
of the plaintiff and the defendant. When did that occur?

A. Somewhere early in May of this year, was it not? Do
you want the exact date? May 2d and 3d.

XQ. 341. Yes, May 2d and 3d of this year. On what date
was it that you took those specimens that you have described
from the defendant’s pneumatic cell?

A. May 2d.

XQ. 342. What were the dimensions of that pneumatic
cell from which you took these measurements—these samples
which you used as a basis of your figures?

A. Roughly 3 by 24 feet, as I recollect.
XQ. 343. And how deep?

Arthur Fay Taggart 297

A. I think about 14 inches at the head end and in the
neighborhood of 18 inches at the discharge end.

XQ. 344. How was the ore fed into the cell at the head
end?

A. Through a pipe that terminated a couple of inches
above the bottom of the cell, and the pulp, therefore, entered
very close to the bottom of the cell.

XQ. 345. And this was a vertical pipe, substantially?

A. Well, at the point that it discharged it was vertical.
It turned from horizontal right at the back of the cell, so that
there was about a 6 or 8-inch vertical extension downward
from the turn.

XQ. 346. About how much material was rushing into the
cell through this pipe?

A. What do you mean by rushing?

XQ. 347. Flowing then.

By roe Court:

XQ. 348. How large was the pipe?

A. The pipe was, I think, 6 inches as I recollect it.

XQ. 349. In diameter?

A. Yes, it was not flowing full, and 1 do not recollect
exactly—I think about a hundred tons of solids per 24 hours,
if my recollection is correct. It may have been somewhat
more.

By Mr. Wituiams:

XQ. 350. About 500 tons of water?

A. Between 400 and 500. They say nearer to 500.

XQ. 351. How was the X-cake solution introduced into
the cell?

A. It was introduced through a small pipe that entered
the mass of material in the cell near the feed end.

XQ. 352. Right alongside of the pulp feeding pipe, was
it not?

A. Well, in that immediate vicinity. I don’t believe
that I saw their relative positions down in the cell. I don’t
believe that I noticed them.

XQ. 353. What was the depth of froth? Will you take

ee .

—

298 Arthur Fay Taggart

the word froth? What was the depth of froth in those cells}

A. If you include also bubble column.

XQ. 354. i will let you include it, but I won’t.

A. All right, sir. The depth of bubbles was at the time
that test was taken I think somewhere in the neighborhood
of ten or twelve inches, it may have been more right at the
—certainly acted as though there were more right at my No,
10 sampling pipe, or my first sampling pipe along the bottom.

XQ. 355. And then there was one place where you could
not get a specimen of pulp?

A. That is the point I refer to. Right there at that pipe
I think there was undoubtedly a solid column of bubbles from
the blanket up. Certainly the evidence was all to that end,
because I rammed a wire through that pipe myself several
times, and know that it was clear through, so that the only
thing that prevented material from coming out was the fact
that there was froth right down to the level of that pipe at
that point.

XQ. 356. And the froth will not flow in a small pipe,
will it?

A. Not of its own volition; no.

XQ. 357. It is a very viscous mass of material, is it not!

A. It is viscous, and there is not much weight to it to
cause it tu flow.

XQ. 358. Why is it that you mentioned the fact that
this surface between the froth and the pulp is changing all
the time?

A. Because that is the faet.

XQ. 359. Kind of a wave action, is it?

A. I don’t think you would call it a wave action; no. At
one period it may be at one height, and half an hour later
a half an inch above that, and another half hour a height of
an inch below, more or less, according to the way the cell
is being operated. The particular importance of my state-
ment there was that these pipes are more or less fixed things
after they are placed, and while we attempt to get one of them
in at the pulp level, and may get it there for the day on which

Arthur Fay Taggart ' 299

the thing is put in or what it was the day before, it is just as
likely to be running an inch below the next day, and an inch
above the next day.

XQ. 360. Then I perhaps misunderstood you. During
the time when you were drawing these specimens was there
any change taking place so as to vary that factor?

A. I could not see it, Mr. Williams, and I could not
distinguish closely enough with my hand to say so. I had
my hand in there, because one or two of the pipes that we had
connected onto the suction, with the expectation that they
were going to be in the bubble column, proved to be in pulp,
or just at the pulp-bubble column line, and if we had allowed
them to run under the influence of suction they would have
filled up the bottles much more rapidly than the other bottles
filled, and consequently could not have been sampled through-
out the period of the test. So those two I put my fingers over
the inner end of, and then opened them, first one and then
the other, as evenly as I could possibly do it, and for short
intervals running throughout the test, so that the samples
as taken from those two pipes were entirely comparable in
percentage of material with those taken from the rest, but
were not of course comparable in total elapsed time required
to take the samples. That is, they were not flowing all the
time. They were flowing for ten minutes, we will say alto-
gether, but for perhaps half of that time I had the pipe shut
off at short intervals, so that there was no flow coming at those
XQ. 361. You put your finger against the end of the
pipe and stopped the flow?

A. Yes.

XQ. 362. Now, have you got those determinations that
you produced yesterday?

A. Yes, I hand you the sheet I read from. The typewrit-
ten part of that sheet and the printed part is Ledoux’s
report to me of the assays that he made. The figures thereon
in pencil are my own figures, representing the assays at
Magma as reported to me, and set against the respective
corresponding figures of Ledoux.

300 Arthur Fay Taggart

XQ. 363. I notice that the list does not include sample
X-10.

A. That is quite correct. That is the sample that I men.
tioned yesterday as having failed to run, because of the faet
that the bubble column probably extended to the bottom of
the cell at that particular place. The sample tags were all
made up before the test, and we just omitted that particular
number.

XQ. 364. As I remember it, you did not read ont
yesterday the figures for the sample X-9. What was that a
sample of?

A. X-9 represents the feed sample.

XQ. 365. And what are the figures?

A. 2.96 per cent. by Ledoux, 3.0 per cent. by Magma.

XQ. 366. Just exactly what is the feed sample?

A. A sample of the material that enters the cell.

XQ. 367. So that the material that entered that cell was
about 3 per cent. copper. Is that right?

A. Yes.

XQ. 368. I am not quite sure that you particularly gave
us the height in the cell of those pipes that were arranged in
the vertical column.

A. I did not. Mr. Perkins and somebody of your repre.
sentatives together measured, and I believe it was the under-
standing that they would agree upon the measurements of
those pipes, and I think that I can get them. I perhaps can
get them from Mr. Perkins if you would like. I haven't
got them.

XQ. 369. You haven’t yourself that information?

A. No, I did not measure them myself, and have not
seen those other figures. I saw of course that they were
in their proper positions in the cell, but what those precise
positions were I did not measure.

Mr. Wiiuiams: Mr. Davis, we will have a complete
representation, will we not, of that cell and of those
pipes in it; you will supply that?

Mr. Davis: Why, I had not intended to, but if you
will tell me what you want I will try to get it.

=

Arthur Fay Taggart 301

Mr. Witu1aMs: I want a drawing of the cell, and I
want a sketch of the cell, showing the location of these
pipes.

Mr. Davis: Well, your representatives were there
and took all the measurements; why don’t you have
them make one?

Mr. Wruu1ams: We cannot make a drawing of your
cell. Have you not the blue print of your cell?

Mr. Davis: We have not, Mr. Williams. If you had
told me in New York I could have gotten one from
Magma, but we have not any here.

Mr. WiuuaMs: It is just a matter of getting the shop
blue print, is it not, of the cells?

Mr. Davis: Yes, but it is a matter of getting it from
Superior, Arizona.

Mr. WiiuiaMs: Will you do that and we will put it
in evidence after the trial, if you cannot get it during
the trial?

Mr. Davis: I will, certainly.

XQ. 370. Professor, you testified as a witness in the case
of Minerals Separation, Limited, and others, versus Butte &
Superior Mining Company, at Butte, Montana, in 1917, did
you not?

A. Yes.

XQ. 371. I will read the questions and answers from the
Supreme Court record. At page 1742.

‘«XQ. 126. Did you write or participate in the writ-
ing of an article which appeared in Metallurgical & Chem-
ical Engineering, Volume 15, November 1, 1916?

A. I cannot remember the particular date of its
appearance. I think I can identify the article.

XQ. 127. I show it to you.

A. Yes.”’

Did you so testify?

A. I think I probably did. I am assuming that you are
reading correctly, and that sounds familiar.

Mr. Davis: Have you got another copy of the
record?

302 Arthur Fay Taggart

By Mr. Davis:

XQ. 372. You wrote the article, did not you, Professor,
that is referred to there?

A. I wrote the article, yes.

By Mr. Wrmu1aMs:

XQ. 372-a. And you so testified—I will let you have a
copy of the Supreme Court record, so that you may follow my
reading and save time. That was on page 1742, XQ. 126-127.

A. Yes.

XQ. 373. And is that a photostat of the article in ques-
tion (handing paper)?

A. Yes, I suppose it is, Mr. Williams. I never saw this
Metallurgical & Chemical Engineering thing.

XQ. 374. What I now have is the paper as prepared for
reading, is it?

A. That I recognize as a paper, a reprint of the article
published by the American Institute of Mining Engineers.

XQ. 375. Amd you and Professor Frederick E. Beach,
both of Yale Sheffield School, were writers of the article; is

that correct?

A. Yes.

XQ. 376. In testifying in the Butte & Superior case, did
you testify as follows, page 1744:

“*XQ. 134. In testifying in regard to what you have
called the agitation-froth process, you have confined your
description to the agitation in one vessel and separation
of = — in another, as I understand it, is that right?

. Yes.

“‘XQ. 135. You are aware, are you not, that the proc-
ess is carried out with an agitator at the bottom of one
vessel, air flowed in at the bottom of that vessel and the
froth taken off at the top of the same vessel; that is
known as sub-aeration; are you aware of that?

A. Yes, I have heard of it.

‘*XQ. 136. And then there is another variety, is there
not, wherein there is no agitator in this vessel, but the
air is broken up by flowing in underneath, through a por-
ous medium and flows up and the froth is taken off at the
top?

A. Yes.

Arthur Fay Taggart 303

**XQ. 137. And referring to that, did you in this
article state as follows: ‘The principles involved in this
method are the same as explained in the agitation-froth
process. The only difference is in the method of intro-
ducing air. The result of this difference is that the bub-
bles in the pulp are much larger than in the agitation-
froth method. They arrive at the surface less heavily
loaded in proportion to their weight. The bubble films
are therefore less viscous and the froth less persistent’?

H *‘A. Yes, sir.”’

Did you so testify?

A. I did.

XQ. 377. Did the article prepared by you and Professor
Beach, and published at the time spoken of, contain the fol-
lowing: (under the heading ‘‘ Pneumatic Froth Process’’) :

‘Sulphide and gangue minerals mixed with water
and oil, with or without acid, are run into a tank with a
orous bottom through which air is forced. The air
ubbles rise to the surface with a coating of solid par-
ticles, preponderantly sulphide, while the gangue par-
ticles sink.

“The principles involved in this method——”’

That is just a repetition of that which I have read to you
before. Did this paper contain that statement?

A. The paper contains that statement.

XQ. 378. On the last page of the paper, I read:

‘*But the agitation of the pulp in the mechanical and
pneumatic-froth processes and the generation of carbon
dioxide gas on carbonate particles in intimate contact
with sulphides in the acid-froth process, are sufficient, in
their——

And that means the authors does it not?
A. Let me see. (Handed to witness. )
Yes.

XQ. 379. —‘‘opinion, to bring every sulphide particle
into contact with a bubble film. Once in contact, the
preferential adhesion of the contaminated layer to a sul-
phide surface in the presence of water is sufficient to —

304 Arthur Fay Taggart

account for the persistent attachment of the sulphides to
the bubble films, while on the other hand the replacement
of gas or oil by water on the surface of gangue particles
explains the wetting and continued immersion of the
latter.’’

That is a correct reading of what is in that article, is it not?

A. That is a correct reading.

XQ. 380. In that quotation you speak of the ‘‘acid froth
process’’; what process was that?

A. Let me see it, please. (Handed to witness.) Where
was that, Mr. Williams? (Indicated.) Now, let me have the
question, please. (XQ. 380 repeated as recorded.) The Pot-
ter-Delprat.

Mr. Wuu1aMs: I will just have the paper marked for
identification. It was marked in the Butte and Superior
suit.

(Marked ‘‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit A for Identification.’’)

XQ. 381. In regard to the introduction of what you have
called pulp-body processes of froth - flotation ore-concentra-
tion, can you from your knowledge of literature tell me what
was the first introduction of any process of that kind into use
in this country in a mill in commercial operations?

A. No, I cannot, Mr. Williams.

XQ. 382. You do not know that the Butte & Superior
Hyde operation, which was testified about in the litigation in
which you testified, was the first use in this country of a pulp-
body flotation process?

A. No, I do not know that.

XQ. 383. Do you know of any earlier one?

A. No, I do not know of any earlier one.

XQ. 384. Do you know of any use of Potter-Delprat proe-
ess at a mine as a commercial and successful operation in this

country?
A. No.

XQ. 385. If I have understood your testimony correctly,
you distinguish between a pulp-body process, which you con-
tend is old and is the kind of process disclosed in the patent in

YY

Arthur Fay Taggart 305

suit, and the bubble-column process, which you contend is the
operation of the defendant ; that is right, is it not?

A. Yes.

XQ. 386. And that you contend is the essential difference
between the process disclosed in the patent in suit and the
defendant’s process, is that right?

A. What? You say, ‘‘That you contend’’; what do you
mean by that?

XQ. 387. One is a pulp-body concentration process, and
the other is a bubble-column process.

A. I say that is an essential difference, certainly.

Tue Court: You say ‘‘an’’; he said ‘‘the.’?

XQ. 388. An essential and important difference, that is
as far as you will go?

A. Why, that is certainly an essential and important dif-
ference. However, the operation that is described—there is
an operation described in the second patent in suit in which
a soluble agent is used. A soluble agent is also used in the
defendant’s mill, so that in so far as that particular feature
is concerned, there is a parallelism between that which is
described in the patent in suit and that described in the
defendant’s mill. Of course, the use of soluble agents was
also old.

XQ. 389. That is not in answer to the question.

Tue Court: You said, the second patent in suit.
Tue Wrrvzss: I thought I said the patent in suit, sir.

I meant the same thing, because the second patent in the

older litigation was the patent here.

Tue Court: This is the second patent in the former
suit?
THe Wirness: Yes, sir.

XQ. 390. I will put this to you over again: The essential
difference—and note, that I use the definite article ‘*the’’—
is it the essential difference between the process disclosed in
the patent in suit and the process used by the defendant, that
the one is a pulp-body concentration process and the other is
a bubble-column concentration process?

—w

306 Arthur Fay Taggart

A. No, it is not the only essential difference, certainly.

XQ. 391. What are the other essential differences be.
tween the two processes?

A. Another is that the reagent that is used by the defend.
ant for floating is something that is not pointed out, as far as
I can see, in the patent in suit, as anything that it discloses to
the art that is new.

XQ. 392. Anything else that you deem essential?

A. Yes, there is another. The pulp at the defendant’s
‘plant is alkaline, and as I read the directions to the mill man,
to carry out the operation in this patent in suit, the pulp is
supposed to be acid.

XQ. 393. Any other essential difference?

A. Well, I do not know whether it is really an essential
difference or not. This patent in suit says that the frothing
agent is in solution, and implies that it is not on the mineral
particles, and if that is accepted as a correct explanation of
the statement of what that patent means to describe, then the
operation described in the patent is also different from the
operation that takes place in the defendant’s plant.

XQ. 394. But if the operation described in the process
in suit takes place as you believe it takes place, then that
is not any difference at all, is that right?

A. That what isn’t any difference?

XQ. 395. What you have just specified, that i in one case
the frothing agent stays in solution, and in the other case
the frothing agent is deposited, I think you said, on the min-
eral.

A. I say that in the process as carried out in the defend-
ant’s plant, the frothing agent is on the mineral. Now if
the process that is described in the patent in suit excludes
that from the operation, then the processes are essentially
different.

XQ. 396. But don’t you know from tests how the process
described in the patent in suit works?

Tue Court: In that respect?
Mr. Wiuiams: In that respect.
A. I know that whenever I have carried out the opera

Arthur Fay Taggart 307

tion of agitation froth flotation with a soluble substance,
there has been material adsorbed out of solution onto the
solid particles, that constituted a more or less complete coat-
ing upon the solid particles, yes,

XQ. 397. Did you ever try to use your solution again
without adding any more frothing agent?

A, With the solution drained off, oh, yes, I have done
that. It does not take very much reagent in comparison
to the amounts that are used, in order to get a coating on
the particles.

XQ. 398. So that you can use the same solution over
again, without adding more frothing agent and get a froth?

A. Get a froth, yes. You cannot use this stuff indefi-
nitely, by any means. There is a certain amount taken out
every time, and if you started with the minimum amount that
will produce the result that you require, then you have got
to add some more reagent for the next test. The stuff does
not last on indefinitely. You have taken it out on the min-
eral,

XQ. 399. And you have taken out some water, too, have
you not, with your froth?

A. Very little. You can filter the water off the froth
and get that back in. You have stil] got to add more froth-
ing agent for your next test.

XQ. 400. Is that your experience?

A. Absolutely. I have tested that out quite carefully.

XQ. 401. With what mineral-frothing agents? —

A. Well, amyl acetate, as I recollect, because that was
one of the agents of the patent in suit that we could make
work, and cresol, I think, was the other. Those are the
only two that we could get any really good flotation results
with.

XQ. 402. And what ore?

A. We worked with Butte and Superior ore, which is
a zine ore, and with one or two copper ores, I have forgotten
which, Miami copper ore for one—I do not know. I have
several other copper ores around the laboratory, and I think
some of them were used at one time.

308 Arthur Fay Taggart

XQ. 403. Porphyries?

A. We were having considerable difficulty in getting
good flotation results, and we had to fish around more or
less among the copper ores, in attempting to get one that
would give good results with a small amount of the sub-
stance.

Mr. Wiuiams: If we can suspend now, I probably
am through, but I would like to talk with my colleagues,
your Honor.

Tue Court: How long a time will you require in
re-direct, Mr. Davis?

Mr. Davis: I have only two questions and they will
take about five minutes.

Tue Court: We are practically through with this
witness in a few minutes more.

Mr. Wiuuiams: A few minutes more, and possibly
no more.

Tue Court: Very well, we will recess until two
o’clock.

AFTER RECESS.

XQ. 404. Have you now the dimensions that I asked for
this morning, and if so, will you please read them?

A. I have the dimensions of the vertical bladed impeller,
which are as follows: Blades one-half inch wide, that is up
and down, one-quarter inch thick, and about 1% inches long
each. The shaft is three-quarter inch in diameter, making
the dimensions from tip to tip of opposite blades, slightly
over three inches. The 45-degree blades are of substantially
the same dimensions, except that they are turned 45 degrees
to the vertical plane, instead of being in the vertical plane.

XQ. 405. And the interior dimensions of the vessel in
which they rotated, have you that?

A. Four by four, I gave, by some twelve to fourteen
inches high.

XQ. 406. Did you locate the opening in these blades
through which you measured the vacuum that you produced!

Arthur Fay Taggart 309

A. That is about one-eighth inch from the end of the
blade and is one of the four blades only.

XQ. 407. And how big an opening?

A. About one-sixteenth inch diameter.

XQ. 408. Round?

A. Round.

XQ. 409. Did you participate in the preparation of a
paper entitled ‘‘Surface Tension and Adsorption Phenom-
ena in Flotation,’’ by Arthur Fay Taggart and A. M. Gaudin,
issued with ‘‘Mining and Metallurgy”’ of August, 1922, for
the San Francisco meeting of 1922 of the American Insti-
tute of Mining & Metallurgical Engineers?

A. I did.

XQ. 410. And the document that I have before me, is
that the paper that was thus jointly prepared?

A. Yes.

XQ. 411. Before reading an extract from that paper, I
would just like you to give a few definitions. What is galena?
A. Lead sulphide.

XQ. 412. That is the sulphide of lead that is recovered
in the flotation operations of treating ores containing lead,
is it not?

A. Yes.

XQ. 413. Now, tar acid, I think you have defined as a
material that is soluble in the portions used in flotation. That
is right, is it not?

A. Well, I think th

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386007_0318%3A01. Public record. Not legal advice.
