# Transcript of Record — Layne & Bowler Corp. v. Western Well Works, Inc.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386005_0222%3A3

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1923
- **Citation:** 261 U.S. 387

## Text

Vol. II

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,

OCTOBER TERM, 1922.

No. 278.

LAYNE & BOWLER CORPORATION, PETITIONER,
+ 98.

WESTERN WELL WORKS, INC.; ROTARY DRILLING AND
DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, STANLEY M. HALSTEAD,
ET AL.

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT.

SARE SSR RATE Re Sa MORN RN Ee TE RAE APE GAL te

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 915

Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 2.

METHOD of INSTALLING on
LUBRICATING .

CENTAIFUCAL PUMP... PIT
PREVIOUS TO

ME.LAYNES INVENTION

ity,
Meares 2)

wens mgs Y

Syn sages -
rey & ipl rho
ream qs” ———— 4 a

= arias Y — i anf

In Ses mama °

2 ges °
Sey "

Bre Ss ET
ee

at on FRAME

pT A
oaeaerepaaal as a ~ “ F
YY V]]) aes, remman .
Se Y P08 eh nome jf
pe Be Bm BO
Ee ere aren if 7]
Fig werin ge ol
fo '
4, 2 gf
SonpeareaY) 7 : * el | ee tin
Og tm BIR IT £ oa S/ Ev Smw—g ae
mags é 1. lig Lp ye Bae”
ney) ile oo ae Zita
be Eng ba = f a 24 - LY tty mere ae
= — \ 4 ‘ Sra =
spews pa ))) | Wl We = Zee
sere ee ' i ! Cc . Op a
oes H Hi ct \ Ewe a
HE enef ct yt}! BIN 1A yea
Fa “ | (/3 2
ean | AHH ses
~ \ i ow \ eter eee
A WU Nigel Ga
Y | wi 4 \ Geomein me
Z | | Boe wi
4 Be a ee VQewraese
y PA Zo tie
A y —_— = = WWE TR ES
4 ees a See eo (7 aywgoeeat
© saaiialataa a aia Us Dee 13" 190
vv w everen Pe a

a

916 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

[Endorsed]: 485-Eq. Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 2.
Filed Sept. 3, 1920. W.B. Maling, Clerk. By J. A.
Schaertzer, Deputy Clerk.

No. 3627. United States Cireuit Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Cireuit. Filed Jan. 6, 1921. F. D.
Monckton, Clerk.

Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 3.
CONTRACT.

THIS CONTRACT, made this first day of Octo-
ber, 1914, between THE LAYNE AND BOWLER
CORPORATION, a corporation duly organized and
existing under and by virtue of the laws of the
STATE of California, and having its principal place
of business at Los Angeles, California, hereimafter
referred to as first party, and STANLEY M. HAL-
STEAD, of San Jose, California, and P.. E.
VAUGHAN, of Los Angeles, California, herein-
after referred to as second parties,

WITNESSETIHI:

WHEREAS the first) party is extensively en-
gaged in the manufacture, sale and use of certain
patented pumps, screens, and other appliances used
in the making and developing of wells throughout
California, Arizona and New Mexico, and

WHEREAS the second party, S. M. Halstead,
who has been heretofore employed by the first party
in various capacities, and the second party, P. E.
Vaughan, are desirous of starting up together in
a separate and independent business, contemplating

CO eee ae!

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 917

the purchase of said patented pumps and screens
from the first party, and the subsequent use thereof
in the building, developing or equipping of wells, in
the manner and subject to the conditions herein-
after specified ,

NOW THEREFORE, the Parties Agree as fol-
lows:

PROVISIONS.
1.

The first party agrees to sell to the second party,
its Sereens, Pumps and Parts of Pumps for the
purposes of repairs, replacement or extensions, and
the second parties agree to accept delivery thereof
fob. cars Los Angeles proper (not Los Angeles
Harbor). The second parties agree to pay therefor
according to first party’s list price at date of order,
less the special discounts below mentioned. The
first party, however, reserves the right to change its
list prices at any time and in any particular, with-
out notice, but after such time as the second par-
tics have actual notice of the change in first party’s
list price, the second parties shall be entitled to
make purchases hereunder to the amount of Five
Thousand ($5,000.00) Dollars at the old list price.

The first party shall not be obliged to accept, on
any one day, orders from the second parties aggre-
gating more than Five Thousand ($5,000.00) Dol-
lars.

For Pumps, the second parties agree to pay first
party’s list price at date when order is received by
first party, less the special discount of twenty-five
(25°C) per cent from said list prices. Such list

| i ee ea

4. > POET LI HEP FN NE NN EN ET * oo - . . ae

918 Western Well Works, Ine., et al.

prices shall, approximately, be the first party’s re-
tail selling price.

For Wire Wound Sereen, the second parties agree
to pay first party’s list price at date when order is
received by first party, less the special discounts
of fiftv (50 ) per cent and twenty-five (25°) per
cent from said list prices. Such list prices, less fifty
(50% ) per cent, shall, approximately, be first
party’s retail selling price.

For Shutter Screens, the second parties agree to
pay first party’s list price at date when order is re-
ceived by first party, less the special discounts of
twenty-five (25 ) per cent and twenty-five (25% )
per vent from said list prices. Such list prices,
less) twenty-five (25%) per cent, shall, approxi-
mately, be first party’s retail selling price.

The above clauses reading in effect that ‘Such
list prices shall, approximately, be first party’s re-
tail selling price,”* shall be construed as having been
inserted into this contract for the purpose of insur-
ing the second parties that first party will adhere
to its present policy of selling its pump at list when
it can, and its wire wound screens at list, less fifty
(50°7 ) per cent, when it can, and its shutter screens
at list less twenty-five (25° ) when it can, and when
the first party cannot sell at these prices, then to
sell as close to them as circumstances will admit.
Said clauses are also inserted into this contract for
the purpose of insuring the second parties that the
first party will act in good faith and will not arbi-
trarily change its list prices for the sole purpose
of closing the second parties off the market or of
deliberately handicapping or abridging the second

: FERRI TONES
ae J

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 919

parties’ business contemplated hereunder. It is un-
derstood, however, that the first party’s ‘‘list price,”’
which is mentioned and referred to, and according
to which the second parties will pay less the dis-
counts mentioned, shall be its actual list price ae-
cording to the ordinary commercial meaning of this
term, and shall not be an average of its retail selling
prices, or anything else like that. Also, the above
quoted clauses shall not be construed as limiting
the first party to sell its pumps at list, or its wire
wound sereens at list less fifty (5067) per cent, or
its shutter screens at list less twenty-five (25° )
per cent. The first party never has sold exactly at
these prices, but has only endeavored to do so, and
has sold as close to them as the circumstances of
each particular case would admit, and it is not con-
templated by either party that the execution of this
contract shall require the first party to in anv way
change its policy concerning this relation between
its list prices and its retail selling prices.

The first party shall make delivery promptly, but
shall not be liable for any loss or damage whatever
caused by accidents, fires, strikes, civil or military
authority, or by insurrection or riot, or by any other
cause beyond first party’s control.

»

If the second parties contract with one of their
customers to furnish a pump, on condition that the
customer may return it to them if the well in which
it is to be installed does not furnish a specified
amount of water, or that the customer may return
it to them for any other reason previously stated
by the second parties to the first party ind accepted

920 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

by the latter in writing, the second parties may state
such condition or reason, and the particular amount
of water specified, in their order for the pump from
the first party, and if this has been done and the
pump is returned to second parties on account of
the well not furnishing the amount of water speci-
fied or on account of any of the other reasons pre-
viously agreed to in writing with the first party
concerning that particular pump, then the second
parties shall have the right to return such pump to
the first party, provided it is delivered up at first
party’s factory in Los Angeles, free of all expense
to first party, within ninety (90) days from the time
when first party delivered it to second parties, un-
less the second parties have previously made special
arrangements in writing with the first party, ex-
tending the time within which that pump may be
returned. In event a pump is so returned, either
within the ninety days, or within the time period
covered by said special arrangements in writing,
the second parties shall be allowed credit on such
pump amounting to the invoice price thereof, less
One ($1.00) Dollar per foot for its total depth, but
this minimum deduction of credit on any one pump
shall be Fifty ($50.00) Dollars. However, if first
party’s expenses in putting said pump in re-salable
condition exceed the total deduction for credit com-
puted as above, then the minimum deduction shall
be first party’s actual expenses incurred in this re-
gard.

3.
On the fifteenth day of November, 1914, and on
the fifteenth day of each and every month there-

ee Saag EO DRL?
Sar

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 921

after, the second parties shall deliver to first party
a sixty (60) day, seven (7%) per cent note, signed
by both of the second parties, and of bankable form
satisfactory to the first party, covering all purchases
and other indebtedness of whatever kind or form
incurred by the second parties of the first part
throughout the preceding calendar month, and all
such notes shall be paid in cash at maturity. For
this purpose, all delivery of pumps f.o.b. cars Los
Angeles, as hereinbefore provided, shall be deemed
a purchase on the part of the second parties, even
tho the latter have a right to return the same under
the provisions herein. However, the total credit
Which the first party will extend to the second par-
ties, including all of the second parties’ notes, open
accounts, and all their other outstanding obligations
Whatever to first party, shall lie wholly within the
discretion of first party, which shall have the right
at any time to demand cash on delivery for further
purchases made by second parties hereunder. How-
ever, if such demand for cash is made, and the same
is paid upon delivery, the second parties shall be
entitled to an additional discount of five (5% ) per
cent from the cash due.

For the guidance of the second parties in estimat-
ing the total amount of credit which may be antici-
pated under this contract, it is hereby certified that
first party's Board of Directors has duly and for-
mally passed the following resolution :

RESOLVED: That, under the contract this
day authorized between this Corporation on the
one side and Stanley M. Halstead and P. E.
Vaughan on the other side, and contingent upon

x
=
De
:
f
rs
&
+

FED ALE CES

eemenussteccrsesrresgcrange CISC ENR I oe GAY

rar

bo

Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

a satisfactory statement signed by said Hal-
stead and Vaughan, being delivered to first
party, and showing that their net assets, over
and above all their liabilities, reasonably amount
to Twenty-five Thousand ($25,000.00) Dollars,
the Credit Department of this Corporation is
hereby authorized to extend such credit as in
its discretion may seem proper, but not to ex-
ceed Eleven Thousand ($11,000.00) Dollars,
unless authorization for credit in excess of this
amount is first obtained from the Board of
Directors. This total credit of Eleven Thou-
sand ($11,000.00) Dollars, shall include all
notes, open accounts, and outstanding indebted-
ness of any sort whatever, due this Corporation
under said contract, and also the indebtedness
now due or owing to this Corporation from
S. M. Halstead personally, but shall not include
any indebtedness whatever which may arise be-
tween S. M. Halstead and this Corporation
under the former’s contract to purchase the
well rig which has been heretofore delivered
to him, nor shall it include the indebtedness
which shall be incurred by the said S. M. Hal-
stead and P. E. Vaughan on account of their
taking over the automobiles or furnishings of
this Corporation now used in conjunction with
its San Francisco and San Jose offices. The tak-
ing over of said automobiles and furnishings,
if at all, shall be under separate contract which
shall provide the terms of payment.

4.

In event the second parties send in any orders

BAB Hae a

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 923

to be shipped them at points where there is no au-
thorized Railroad agent to collect the freight, and the
first party advances or prepays the freight thereon
for the second parties, the second parties agree to
remit in cash the amount of freight so advanced,
within ten (10) days from the date when first party
mails the second parties the freight bill covering
the same. Money which has been thus advanced on
freight shall not be left to go into the next sixty
(60) day note mentioned in Provision 3, but shall
be paid in accordance herewith. Also, it is under-
stood that delivery shall be deemed to have been
made by first party to second parties at Los Angeles
as hereinbefore provided, and that at this point re-
sponsibility for the shipment shall cease in the first
party.
5.

In consideration of the foregoing provisions, the
second parties agree not to sell or use any other
pumps, screens or perforated casings of whatsoever
kind or form, in the building or equipping of wells,
except the patented pumps and screens purchased
of the first party in accordance herewith.

6.

It is mutually understood that the second party
shall have the right to drill and equip wells com-
plete anywhere throughout the States of California,
Arizona, and New Mexico, provided the first party’s
pumps and screens are used exclusively throughout.
The second parties shall also have the right to sell
pumps for installation in wells drilled by other par-
ties in California, north of the Thirty-fifth (35)
Parallel, which line the parties agree to use as ex-

a

SAAR EES 7 i airs wages

PR net

Sear

~

EERIE AL EIT Ss ge

oe ee ee eee snort so “ * x0 = —

924 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

actly demarking the so-called TEHACHAPI LINE
across California.

The second parties agree not to sell or furnish to
others, sereens delivered hereunder, for installation
in wells to be drilled by other parties in Arizona or
New Mexico, or in California south of the line just
mentioned, and the second parties also agree not to
sell or furnish pumps delivered hereunder, for in-
stallation in wells that other parties have drilled in
Arizona or New Mexico, or in California south of
said line. The second parties further guarantee that

such screens or pumps shall not be used or installed |
in violation of this provision, in Arizona or New
Mexico, or in California south of the line mentioned.

The second parties further guarantee that the pat-
ented pumps or screens furnished them hereunder,

shall not be resold or used outside of California,

> erereEE~

Arizona or New Mexico, unless the written license
or authority for such re-sale or use has been first ob-
tained from the party owning the patents thereon
in the place where such re-sale or use is made.
7

The second parties hereby acknowledge the valid-
ity of the following patents covering the above-men-
tioned Pumps and Screens, and which patents are
owned by the first party in and throughout Cali-
fornia, Arizona and New Mexico. The second par-
ties also acquiesce in, and agree to acquiesce in said
patents, throughout the life of each patent men- [
tioned. This provision embraces and applies to the |
following patents:
Patent No. 750,206, dated Jan. 19th, 1904, to M. E.

Layne, for Wire Winding Tool.

ANTE APOE or

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 925

Patent No. 805,211, dated Nov. 21st, 1905, to M. E.
Layne, for Well Sereen.

Patent No. 806,416, dated Dec. 5th, 1905, to M. E.
Layne, for Screen Device.

Patent No. 820,507, dated May 15th, 1906, to M. E.
Layne, for Wire Winding Machine.

Patent No. 821,653, dated May 29th, 1906, to M. E.
Layne, for Well Mechanism.

Patent No. 1,001,655, dated Aug. 29th, 1911, to M. E.
Layne, for Well Strainer.

Patent No. 1,079,679, dated Nov. 25th, 1913, to J. A.
Wintroath, for Well Mechanism.

Patent No. (Re-issue) 13,467, dated Sept. 24th, 1912,
to M. E. Layne, for Well Mechanism.

Concerning the above patents which cover the
pump, the second parties agree that the term ‘‘en-
closed line shaft,”’ or the term ‘‘a closed casing sur-
rounding the pump shaft from the pump to the
top of the well,” ncans and embraces any pump
shaft for a deep well centrifugal pump, which is
surrounded by a casing extending substantially from
the pump to the top of the well and is provided
with bearing parts for the shaft along its length,
and which casing is sufficiently closed to allow the
feeding of a lubricating fluid down thru said cas-
ing to the various bearing parts for the shaft
therein.

8.

The second parties agree not to sell or use any of
the patented screens furnished hereunder, for use
in oil wells or in any other kind of wells except
water wells, and the second parties guarantee that

iS
Sy
=

“a

Bettstresss saan cess oS RSS oR KAY, YB LN LL Eo EN ol Te eee rca eek en wiser

926 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

such screens shall not eventually be used in oil wells
in violation of this provision.

9.

The second parties enter upon this contract jointly
and severally, and agree to be bound jointly and
severally by each of its provisions. Furthermore,
for the purposes of this contract, and for the giving
of orders, the receiving of notices, and for the doing
of anything which may arise in connection herewith,
each of the second parties hereby appoints the other
as his agent, so that both of them shall become
jointly and severally bound by the acts or agree-
ments of either in the course hereof, the same as
tho they were partners.

10.

This contract shall not be assignable by the second
parties, or either of them, unless the second parties
first obtain the first party’s written assent thereto,
duly executed under the authority of the first
party’s Board of Directors.

EL.

It is a specific condition, and part of the consider-
ation, upon which the first party enters upon this
contract, that the second parties shall abide strictly
in each and every guarantee, condition, provision
and part of a provision, contained throughout this
contract, and any violation whatever of any such
guarantee, condition, provision or part of a provi-
sion, shall entitle the first party to revoke and can-
cel this contract entirely, so that no business shall

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 927

thenceforth be done hereunder. In order to so
cancel or revoke this contract, however, the first
party shall give notice to that effect by registered
letter mailed and addressed to either of the second
parties at their last known address, within thirty
(30) days from the time when first party first obtained
knowledge of the breach or violation, and if such
notice is not served within said thirty (30) days,
the first party shall be deemed to have waived right
to cancel or revoke this contract on account of that
particular breach or violation. Upon the giving of
such notice, the cancellation and revocation of this
contract shall be immediate and complete, and no
procedure whatever, either in law or equity, shall
be required on the part of the first party, in order
to cause such cancellation or revokation to take
effect. If the contract is canceled or revoked, how-
ever, the same shall not effect or change in any man-
ner, any liabilities previously created hereunder on
either side.
12.

The life of this contract shall be for four vears
from the date hereof.

IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF the parties have
caused these presents to be executed in duplicate,
the day and year first above written, the first party
signing its corporate name and affixing its seal thru
its President and Secretary, thereunto duly author-

=
as
>

opening

J

Ses a

oe

St Mt
Re

gE, BI

OPEL ELIT RA Finer

928 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

ized by its Board of Directors by resolution passed
on the 7th day of October, 1914.
THE LAYNE AND BOWLER CORPORA-

TION,
By P. D. BOWLER,
President.
[ Corporate Seal ] By W. E. BOWLER,

Secretary,
First Party.
S. M. HALSTEAD,
P. KE. VAUGHAN,
Second Parties.

[ Endorsed]: No. 485—Equity. Layne & Bowler
Corpn. vs. Western Well Works et al. Plaintiff’s
Exhibit No. 3. Filed Sept. 3, 1920. W. B. Maling,
Clerk. By J. A. Schaertzer, Deputy Clerk.

No. 3627. United States Circuit Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Cireuit. Filed Jan. 6, 1921. F. D.
Monckton, Clerk.

PUES aa eam

us. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 929

Defendants’ Exhibit ‘‘A-1.’’

[Endorsed]: In the United States District Court,
Northern District of California, Southern Division.
In Equity—No, 485. Layne & Bowler Corporation,
Plaintiff, vs. Western Well Works, Inc., a Corpora-
tion, et al., Defendants. Defendants’ Exhibit
“A-1."’ Hattie B. Lehman, Notary Public.

Filed Sep. 2, 1920. W. B. Maling, Clerk. By J.
A. Schaertzer, Deputy Clerk.

No, 3627. United States Cireuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Ninth Cireuit. Filed Jan. 6, 1921. F.
D. Monckton, Clerk.

ea ae |

peaieete ge teens eS tee

Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

930

PATENTED AUG. 11, 1903.

J. W. ALVORD.
MEANS FOR ALINING PUMP SHAFTS IN WELL CASINGS.

No. 735,690.

APPLICATION FILED HOV. 17, 1908.

2 OHEETS—SHEET:

Go MODEL

Yventor
Otte.ney

-
ca

OO A

° fo) ot

—= ~ © 2 PE CPE NII OKA EEO OO OSS OES ©

-

ZZ 4 ” von witha >: Sst thet
a — ZO ZZ (hs ems: LMA I
— SS =~ f= = = =

-----—----> / pea 4

'
> =

Ce REEDED

> > >>> et OO OOOO LOE Oo
rT

_=_—==—=—_—_—_———————————————————————_——={_——=—>—_== = = — = —
AOA ALAA ALL ALAA OAL AOA AOA AAP OA AP AP POPPA AAP PAPAL P= i x

! ~
% t

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 931

No. 735,690. PATENTED AUG. 11, 1903.
J. W. ALVORD.

MEANS FOB ALINING PUMP SHAFTS IN WELL CASINGS.
APPLIOATION FILED BOV. 17, 1902
WO MODEL 2 SHEETS—SBLET 2

16

Anventoe

Wrtwarses Othe: COWRA,

Jonna Aho . My

Loman Gf i

tale Ae asl beach TSC EE

Fa ie ani bdo a tee

932

No. 735,690.

Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

Patented August 11, 1903,

UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE.

JOHN WATSON ALVORD,

OF CHICAGO, ILLINOIS.

MEANS FOR ALINING PUMP-SHAFTS IN WELL-CASINGS.
SPECIFICATION forming part of Letters Patent No. 735,690, dated August 11, 1903,

Application filed November 17, 1902.

To all whom it may concern:

Be it known that I, JouN Watson ALVoRD,
a citizen of the United States, residing at Chi-
cago, in the county of Cook and State of Illi-
nois, have invented certain new and useful
Improvements in Means for Alining Pump-
Shafts in Well-Casings; and I do declare the
following to be a full, clear, and exact de-
scription of the invention, such as will enable
others skilled in the art to which it appertains
to make and use the same, reference being
had to the accompanying drawings, and to
the figures of reference marked thereon,
which form a part of this specification.

This invention relates to rotary pumps for
deep wells; and its object is to provide means
for automatically alining the pump-shaft.
The easing of a deep well, by which T mean
a well having a depth of one hundred feet or
more, is usually slightly erooked or sinuous,
so that the shaft of a rotary pump located at
or near the bottom of the well will not be
equidistant from the casing throughout its
entire length, but will be nearer to one side
of the casing or the other at different points.
It is of course necessary for the shaft to be
absolutely straight in order to reduce the
friction of the bearings toa minimum, My
invention aims to keep the shaft perfectly
straight, and yet support it rigidly in the
easing by automatic alining devices.

In the accompanying drawings, Figure 1 is
a longitudinal section of a portion of a well-
casing, pump-shaft, and shaft-tube, with a
shaft-bearing and a self-alining support for
the tube. Figs. 2 and 3 are cross-sections at
the lines 2 2 3 3, respectively, on a slightly
larger scale. Fig. 4 is a cross-section at the
line 4 4 on a still larger seale and showing
the tube eecentric to the casing. Fig. 5 is a
cross-section on the same seale at the line 55,
showing the tube and casing concentric.

The well-casing 1 is a metal pipe of suit-
able diameter and circular in cross-section.
It may or may not be perfectly straight
throughout its entire length. The rotary
pump (not shown) is located at the bottom of
the well and is driven by a vertical shaft 2,
rotated by any suitable means. (Not shown.)
The shaft is made in suitable lengths united
by rigid couplings, comprising, preferably, a
sleeve 3, fitting the reduced ends 4 of the

Serial No. 131,663. (No model.)

shaft-sections, and fastened by the transverse
keys 5 and cotters 6. The shaft is inclosed
in a shaft-tube 7, made in suitable lengths §
coupled together and considerably less in di-
ameter than the well-casing, so as to leave an
annular space & between them for the water
to flow up through. At suitable points in
the tube are bearings for the shaft, consist- 6
ing, preferably, of a bushing 9, rigidly secured
in the tube, as by the screw-threads shown,
and slightly tapered internally. Segmental
carriers 10 are placed in the bushing, having
flanges 11 12 at each end to confine the seg: &
mental bearing-blocks 13, which are prefer-
ably made of lignum-vite and fit the shaft
Ad justing-screws 14 are swiveled in
the flanges 1] and mesh with tapped holes in
lugs 15 on the adjacent end of the bushing, 7
so by turning the screws the carriers and
their blocks can be slid lengthwise in the
tapering bushing, and thus be set. in or out
to fit the shaft, The heads of the screws
are accessible through holes in the tube.
Hinged to the outside of the shaft-tube, at
points adjacent to the upper end of the sleeve
3, are a plurality of braces 16, preferably
sharpened along their under edges to reduce
the resistance to the rising column of water. $
The braces extend upwardly, and as each
brace is independently hinged it will natu-
rally fall outward in a radial plane until its
end rests against the inside of the well-cas
ing. If the shaft-tube happens to be eecet
tric to the easing at that point, as shown in
Fig. 4, the braces will stand at different an-
gles. Means are provided for locking each
brace independently in whatsoever position —
it assumes, so that the tube will be rigidly %
supported in the easing whether it is com
centrie or eecentrie therewith. The locking
deviee which I prefer consists of a wedge
or chock 17, preferably forked and fitting —
against the outside of the shaft tube and hav: $
ing a shank IS sliding in a longitudinal slot
19 in said tube behind the brace. Inside the
tube is a segmental weight 20, fastened to the
shank and causing the chock to drop until it
wedges in the angular space between the tube !
and the back of the brace. In this positon
of the chock the brace is rigidly held against
inward movement, and the codperation ©
the several braces supports the tube firmly

closely,

Pa

SV

23) ako
=

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation.

against any lateral displacement. To release
the braces when the tube is to be raised or

jowered in the casing, the shaft is so con-

structed and arranged as to be capable of an
jupward lengthwise movement sufficient to
bring the upper end of the sleeve 3 against

the lower ends of the segmental weights 20

and lift them and the chocks, thus unlocking

the braces and leaving them free to move in
) and out as they slide up or down in the casing
with the tube. When said tube has been re-
located, the shaft is dropped, and the chocks
again fall into place and lock the braces in
whatsoever position they may happen to be.
5 It is thus evident that my invention pro-
vides means for automatically alining a
pump-shaft in a well-casing whether the lat-
| ter is straight or crooked.
It will be understood that a plurality of
sing devices and locking and unlocking
means will be provided, according to the
length of the shaft.

Having thus described my invention, what
T claim is—

1. The combination with a well-casing, of
a straight rotary pump-shaft therein, and a
plurality of independent, automatic adjust-
ing devices located between the shaft and
the casing, whereby said shaft is automati-
cally braced in proper alinement irrespee-
tive of any deviation of said casing from
a straight line.

2. The combination with a well-casing, of
a straight rotary pump-shaft therein, bear-
ings for said shaft, and a plurality of auto-
matic, inlependently-adjustable devices serv-
ing to brace said bearings automatically in
proper alinement in said casing, irrespective
of any deviation of said casing from a
straight line.

3. The combination with a well-casing, of
a straight rotary pump-shaft therein, a tube
inclosing said shaft, bearings in said tube,
and a plurality of automatic, independently-
adjustable devices between said tube and
casing, whereby the former is automatically
braced in proper alinement irrespective of
rd deviations of the latter from a straight
ine,

4. The combination with a well-easing, of
a rotary pump-shaft therein, a tube inelos-
ing said shaft, bearings in said tube, braces
between said tube and casing, and means
fer adjusting said braces independently of
each other. :

es eee

eee, meee

b

. 735,690

ee ia Li AS eh

933

5. The combination with a well-casing, of
a rotary pump-shaft therein, a tube inclos-
ing said shaft, bearings in said tube,
braces between said tube and casing, and
means for adjusting and locking each brace
independently.

6. The combination with a well-casing, of
a rotary pump-shaft therein, a tube inclosing
said shaft, bearings for said shaft, braces
between said tube and easing, means for lock-
ing each brace independently, and means for
unlocking said braces simultaneously.

7. The combination with a well-easing, of
arotary pump-shaft therein, a tube inclosing
said shaft, bearings in said tube, braces
hinged to said tube, and means for locking
said braces.

&. The combination with a well-casing, of
a rotary pump-shaft therein, a tube inclos-

ing said shaft, bearings in said tube, braces 7

hinged to said tube, and a chock for wedg-
ing each brace,

9, The combination with a well-casing of
a rotary pump-shaft therein, a tube inelos-
ing said shaft, bearings in said tube, braces
hinged to said tube, a choek for wedging each
brace, and means for lifting said chocks.

10. The combination with a well-casing, of
a rotary pump-shaft therein, a tube inclos-
ing said shaft, bearings in said tube, braces
hinged to said tube, and a chock for each
brace having a shank projecting into said
tube and adapted to be lifted by an upward
movement of the pump-shaft.

11. The combination with a well-easing, of
a rotary pump-shaft therein, a tube inclosing
said shaft, bearings in said tube, braces
hinged to said tube, a chock for wedging
each brace having a shank projecting into
said tube, and a weight secured to said shank.

12. The combination with a well-casing, of
a rotary pump-shaft therein having a sleeve
thereon, a tube inclosing said shaft and hav-
ing longitudinal slots therein, braces hinged
to said tube, a chock for wedging each
brace having a shank projecting through a
slot, and a weight secured to said shank
inside said tube and adapted to be lifted
by said sleeve when said shaft is lifted.

In testimony whereof I affix my signa-
ture in presence of two witnesses.

JOHN WATSON ALVORD.
Witnesses :
Ropert O. HARPER.
Frep G, WILBER.

=I

~

™

934 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

Defendants’ Exhibit ‘‘A-2.”’

[Endorsed]: In the United States District Court,
Northern District of California, Southern Division.
In Equity—No. 485. Lavne & Bowler Corporation,
Plaintiff, vs. Western Well Works, Inc., a Corpora-
tion, et al., Defendants. Defendants’ Exhibit A-2.
Hattie B. Lehman, Notary Public.

Filed Sep. 2, 1920. W. B. Maling, Clerk. By
J. A. Schaertzer, Deputy Clerk.

No, 3627. United States Circuit Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Cireuit. Filed Jan. 6, 1921. EF. D.
Monckton, Clerk.

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 935

Ho. 735,631. PATENTED AUG. 11, 1903.
3. W. SBVORD.
08 SPEED ROTARY PUMB.

SPCHONNTEE FELTY VEO. ga. rv02.

a EDTA.
fi
4 4
wat. 7
Ah
i!
429 .
we 28
g 1 i
i 1
is VAY emyd??
;
e+ t
|
3 Os I 2s§p2e
'
/ > a
y 30
2+ Hy 8
6)
26Ches "| 25
1s ‘i
|
it 4
S20 Nn 8 Ee
- 7
l 2 om a
3 3
iH 6
4 ; +t
Ruven ot
Aiiades : » meena
Nonna State

936

No. 735,691.

Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE.

Patented August 11, 1903

HIGH-SPEED

To all whom it may concern:

a citizen of the United States, residing at Chi
cago, in the county of Cook and State of Ili
nois, have invented certain new and usefu

and I do declare the following to be a full
clear, and exact description of the invention

10

to which it appertains to make and use the
panying drawing, and to the
reference marked thereon,
part of this specification.

This invention relates

figures

to

more in depth. In such wells the pump is lo-
cated far below the surface of the ground and
rotates in a horizontal plane, the shaft ex-
tending to the surface, where it is connected
to a suitable motor, The weight of this up-
right shaft and the other rotating parts, to-
gether with the superimposed water column,
is very great, and it is a serious problem to
guide and support the shaft. In another ap-
plication recently filed I have set forth means
for maintaining such a shaft in proper aline-
ment. The present invention has to do with
the supporting of the superimposed water
column, the shaft, and other rotating parts.

It has been proposed to balance the weight
of such shafts and superimposed water col-
umn by the pressure of the water column in
the uptake or delivery pipe.

My invention consists in certain novel con-
structions and arrangements of parts where-
by this result can be effectively accomplished
and automatically regulated. The shaft is
journaled in bearings which permit it to have
a certain amount of lengthwise play. Secured
to the shaft is one or more pistons, which
fits or fit in a cylindrical portion or portions
of the stationary pump-casing and each forms
one end of achamber. The under side of the
piston is exposed to the pressure of the water
column in the uptake, while its upper side is
subjected to the pressure in the chamber.
There is an outlet from the chamber to the
suction side of the pump, and this outlet is

o

or

JOHN WATSON ALVORD, OF CHICAGO, ILLINOIS.

SPECIFICATION forming part of Letters Patent No. 735,691, dated August 11, 193
Application filed December 24, 1902.

Be it known that I, JoHN Watson ALVORD,

Improvements in High-Speed Rotary Pumps;

such as will enable others skilled in the art

same, reference being had to the aeccom-
of
which forms a

centrifugal
pumps, and especially to those that are run at
high speeds and lift water from deep wells,
by which I mean wells a hundred feet or

ROTARY PUMP.

Serial No. 136,465. (No model.)
closing gradually as the shaft rises and
opening when it falls, As there is a constant
smal] leakage past the piston into the cham. §
ber, the pressure in said chamber tends to
gradually inerease, thus lessening the effect-
ive upward pressure on the under side of the
piston. The shaft therefore moves slowly
downward until it causes the outlet to open #
and relieve the pressure in the ehember,
whereupon the fall of the shaft is checked.
Thus by a series of constant adjustments
and readjustments of the relative pressures
on the two sides of the piston the differential §
pressure tending to lift the shaft is kept ap
proximately constant, so that the shaft re
mains floating on the water column in sub-
stantially a constant position irrespective of
the fluctuations in the actual pressure of 7!
the water column.

This invention is applicable to pumps
having a great variety of impellers and can
be carried out in many different ways. The
accompanying drawing illustrates one mode %
of applying it to a rotary pump having a
plain serew-impeller, the view being a
longitudinal section of the pump.

The easing of the pump is made in sections,
the lower section 1 being cylindrical to snugly #
inclose the impeller, which has a conical body

2 and helical blades 3, by means of which the
water is given an upward motion when the
impeller is rotated. The section 1 has de-
pending arms 4, supporting the lower bear §
ing 5 for the impeller-shaft 6. This section
also has a flange 7, on which is mounted the
preferably eylindrical body-section 8 by
means of the flanges 9 and bolts 10, The up-
per section 11 is preferably conical and is ¥
fastened to the top of the body-section 8 and
also to the lower end of the uptake or de
livery pipe 12, preferably by the flanges and
bolts shown. The body-section has a con
centric inner shell 13, preferably united with %
the outer shel] by radial webs 14, cast inte-
gral with both shells, The inner shell is pro-
vided at each end with a head, the upper one
15 carrying a bearing 16 for the impeller-shaft
and also supporting the lower end of the 1!
shaft-casing 17. The lower head 18 has a bear-
ing 19 for the impeller-shaft and also a cylin-
drical flange 20, inclosing a piston 21, on said

1

»

controlled by the lengthwise play of the shaft,

shaft just above the body of the impeller and

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation.
735,691

said body.

9»

htly less in diameter than
jway’ of the inner shell is a diaphragm =+
shiclh is a bearing 23 for the shaft 6. This
phragm divides the shell into two cham-
s, in each of which is a piston 24, secured
the shaft 6 and fitting the inside of the
I Below each piston one or more holes
are made in the shell, preferably by drill-
through both shells, the holes in the outer
Il being afterward closed by screw-plugs
It is evident that more than two cham-
rand pistons may be used, if desired.

The impeller-shaft 6 is tubular, its lower end
ing cllosed by a screw-plug 27, while its up-
rend! is closed by the inwardly-projecting
ser omd of the pump-shaft 28, which fits in
9 shaft 6 and is secured thereto by trans-
rse pins 29, The pump-shaft is preferably
lid to give a maximum torsional strength.
ts 30 are cut at suitable points in the im-
Jler-smaft just below the lower bearing 5
14 the bearings 26, 19, amd 23.

The operation of the pump is as follows:

he impeller is rotated at high speed and
ees the water up through the annular space
tween the outer and inner shells of the
oly-seetion S of the easing. The water
ases freely through the holes 25, and the
ressure due to the weight of the rising Wa-
column in the uptake-pipe is thus trans-
‘itted to the under side of the pistons 24.
iy properly proportioning the area and num-
erof said pistons to the total weight of the
stating parts and the superimposed water

olumn said weight can be balanced by the
ift on the pistons. Hence no step-bearing
srequired for the shaft. There isa little leak-
we of water past the pistons into the cham-
ers above them, and this water in time fills
he chambers. In order to prevent it from |
quiring a pressure equal to that on the un- |
ler side of the pistons, and thus neutraliz-
ing the lifting
ports 30 are so arranged with reference to the
tationary shaft-bearings that when the pres-
sure in the chambers reaches a_ predeter-

mined limit the consequent drop of the shaft |

vill bring said ports below said bearings.
thus permitting the water in the chambers
to enter the tubular shaft and eseape through
the lower ports into the well on the suction
side of the impeller. By closing the lower
end of the shaft and providing the lower set
of port’ ? form an intermediate chamber be-
tween ce casing and the well, and thus pre
vent too sudden changes of pressure in the
chambers; but as soon as sufficient water has
escaped to permit the resultant increased
pressure on the under side of the piston to
lift the pistons and shaft the ports will be
closed and the equilibrium reéstablished,
The shaft, pistons, and impeller thus have a
constant slight motion up and down as these
adjustments of pressure occur. Tt will be
noticed that they are independent of the ac-
tual pressure in pounds per square inch,

effect of the water column, the j an upright

ferential pressure on the under side of the
piston and not to the actual pressure of the
water column, It will also be noticed that 70
by means of the piston 2] and its chamber
and escape-ports the area of the impeller sub-
jected to a downward pressure is no greater
than that of its blades and that this is par-
tially balanced by the upward pressure of 75
the water column on so much of the conical
body of the impeller as lies above the blades.

lam aware that it has been proposed to
provide the shaft of a rotary pump with a
balancing piston and to utilize the water leak- 80
ing past said piston to lubricate the adjacent
shaft-bearing; but my invention aims to util-
ize the leakage to set up a differential pres-
sure on the under side of the piston, so as to
automatically balance the rotating parts ir- $5
respective of the height of the water col-
umn—a result not possible in the aforesaid
proposed construction.

I claim—

1. In a rotary pump, the combination with 90
an upright axially-movable shaft, of a bal-
ancing-piston secured thereto and having its
under side exposed to the pressure of the
water column, a stationary easing containing
a chamber above said piston, and means con
trolled by the axial movement of the shaft
for permitting the escape of water from said
chamber to the suction side of the pump, and
thus regulating the pressure in said chamber,

2, Ina rotary pump, the combination with 1
an upright axially-movable shaft, of a sta
tionary casing containing a chamber concen
trie with said shaft and having means to ad-
mit the pressure of the water column in the
uptake, a piston seeured to said shaft and 1
fitting the walls of said chamber, and eseape-
ports above said piston controlled by the
axial movement of said shaft.

3. Ina retary pump, the combination with
axially-movable tubular shaft, of 1
a stationary casing eontaining a chamber
concentric with said shaft and having holes in
its walls, a piston secured to said shaft and
fitting the walls of said chamber above said
holes, and eseape-ports in said shaft above 1
said pistons,

4. Ina rotary pump, the combination with
an upright axially-movable tubular shaft, of
a stationary casing comprising two coneen-
trie shells, the inner one being closed at the
top and bottom and having holes in its walls,
one or more pistons in said inner shell above
said holes and secured to said shaft, and es-
cape-ports in said shaft above said pistons,
controlled by the axial movement of said 1
shaft.

5. In a rotary pump, the combination with
an upright axially-movable tubular shaft, of
a stationary casing, comprising two concen-
tric shells, the inner one having a diaphragm
and provided with holes in its walls above
and below said diaphragm, heads closing the
top and bottom of said inner shell, shaft-bear-

1

since the balancing effect is due to the dif-

ings in said heads and diaphragm, pistons

~
uw

20

93 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

735,691 :

secured to said shaft above said holes, and
escape-ports in’said shaft adjacent to the
lower ends of said bearings.

6. In a rotary pump, the combination with
an axially-movable tubular shaft having its
lower end closed and provided with ports, of
a bearing adjacent to and above said ports,
a balancing-piston secured to said shaft and
having its under side exposed to the pressure
of the water column, a stationary casing con-
taining a chamber for said piston, and means
for putting said chamber in communication
with the interior of said shaft when the re-
sultant pressure on the under side of the pis-
ton falls below a predetermined limit.

7. In a rotary pump, the combination with
a stationary casing comprising two concen
tric shells, of a shaft concentric with said
shells, an impeller on the shaft having a con-
ical body carrying a piston fitting a chamber
at the lower end of the inner shell, means for

¥

permitting the escape of leakage-water fnz
said chamber to the suction side of the pum
and a balancing-piston in the inner shell e
posed underneath to the pressure of the wate
column and above to the pressure in a chan
ber in said shell.

8. In a rotary pump, the combination wit
a stationary pump-casing, of an impeller, it
shaft, a balancing-piston secured on the shaf
a easing surrounding said piston and con
municating below the piston with the uptake
and means for automatically regulating th
pressure on the top of the piston, whereby
the differential pressure on its under sid
will remain substantially constant.

In testimony whereof I affix my signatur
in presence of two witnesses.

JOHN WATSON ALVORD.
Witnesses :
ARTHUR MCLEAN,
Cuas. B. Burpick.

en ter st cetera, AEE Rha end . ea LE pantie ia hag aaa te ee ee ee aoe |

939

a

o

2

=

=
: °
= =)
2 = HOR —— ° ies a
- iq Hy ..-. > :
S g =
m EAS enean n ccconaier

; Be 2

2 5
Bs
¥) BE
=
>
Ss
a
%
>

Be. 796,001.
mm.

o
BW ituresses

ou

or

r—)

940

No. 735,691,

UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE.

JOHN WATSON ALVORD,
HIGH-SPEED ROTARY PUMP.

SPECIFICATION forming part of Letters
Application filed December 24, 1902,

To all who mit may concern:

a citizen of the United States, residing at Chi-

|
Beit known that I, JOHN WATSON ALVORD, |
|
cago, in the County of Cook and State of Lli- |

5 nois, 1ave invented certain new and useful | gradually increase, thus lessening the effeet-

Improvements in High-Speed Rotary Pumps;
and I do declare the following to be a ful},
clear, ind exact description of the invention,
such is will enable others skilled in the art
to whch it appertains to make and use the
same, reference being had to the aceompany-
ing dmwing, and to the figures of reference
markel thereon, which forms a part of this |
specification.
This invention relates to centrifugal |
pumps, and especially to those that are run at |
high speeds and lift water from deep wells,
by which I mean wells a hundred feet or
more in depth. In such wells the pump is lo-
eated far below the surface of the ground and
rotates in a horizontal plane, the shaft ex-
tending to the surface, where it is connected
to a siitable motor. The weight of this up-
right shaft and the other rotating parts, to-
gether with the superimposed water column,
is very great, and it is a serious problem to
guide and support the shaft. In another ap-
plication recently filed I have set forth means
for maintaining such a shaft in proper aline-
ment. The present invention has to do with
the supporting of the superimposed water
column, the shaft, and other rotating parts.

It his been proposed to balance the weight
of such shafts and superimposed water col-
umn by the pressure of the water column in |
the uptake or delivery pipe.

My invention consists in certain novel con-
structions and arrangements of part, whereby |
this result can be effectively accomplished |
and artomatically regulated. The shaft is
journaled in bearings which permit it to have
a certain amount of lengthwise play, Secured
to the shaft is one or more pistons, which
fits or fit in a cylindrical portion or portions
of the stationary pump-casing and each forms
one enl of a chamber. The under side of the
piston is exposed to the pressure of the water
columr in the uptake, while its upper side is
subjeced to the pressure in the chamber.
There is an outlet from the chamber to the
suctior side of the pump, and this outlet is

Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

controlled by the lengthwise play of the shaft,

Patented August 11, 1903,

OF CHICAGO, ILLINOIS,

Patent No. 735,691, dated August 11, 1903,
Serial No, 136,465. (No model.)

closing gradually as the shaft rises and open-
ing when it falls. As there is a constant
small leakage past the piston into the cham- %
ber, the pressure in said chamber tends to

ive upward pressure on the under side of the
piston, The shaft therefore moves slowly
downward until it causes the outlet to open
and relieve the pressure in the chamber,
whereupon the fall of the shaft is checked.
Thus by a series of constant adjustments
and readjustments of the relative pressures
on the two sides of the piston the differential 6
pressure tending to lift the shaft is kept ap-
proximately constant, so that the shaft re
mains floating on the water column in sub-
stantially a constant position irrespective of
the fluctuations in the actual pressure of the 7!
water column,

This invention is applicable to pumps hay-
ing a great variety of impellers and can be
carried out in many different ways. The
accompanying drawing illustrates one mode 1
of applying it to a rotary pump having a
plain secrew-impeller, the view being a
longitudinal seetion of the pump.

The casing of the pump is made in sections,
the lower section 1 being cylindrical to snugly §
inclose the impeller, which has a conical body
2 and helical blades 3, by means of whieh the
water is given an upward motion when the
impeller is rotated. The section 1 has de
vending arms 4, supporting the lower bear §
ing 5 for the impeller-shaft 6. This section
also has a flange 7 mounted the

7, on which is
preferably cylindrical body-section 8 by
means of the flanges 9 and bolts 10, The up:
ner section 11 is preferably conical, and is ®
fastened to the top of the body section 8 and
also to the lower end of the uptake or de-
livery pipe 12, preferably by the flanges and
bolts shown, The body-seetion has acon
centric inner shell 13,’‘preferably united with §
the outer shell by radial webs 14, cast inte
gral with both shells. The inner shell is pro
vided at each end with a head, the upper oie
15 carrying a bearing 16 for the impeller-shaft
andalsosupportingthe lower end of the shaft: |
casing 17, The lower head 18 has a bearing
19 for the impeller-shaft and also a cylin:
drieal flange 20, inclosing a piston 21, on sal
shaft just above the body of the impeller and

aa

BR vs. payne we power Vorporanon. ——— — IFt
735,691

btly less in diameter than said body.
way of the inner shell is a diaphragm 22,
shich is a bearing 23 for the shaft 6. This
h divides the shell into two cham-
phragm Myeige . ‘
in each of which is a piston 24, secured
the shaft 6 and fitting the inside of the
|, Below each piston one or more holes
are made in the shell, preferably by drill-
‘through both shells, the holes in the outer
I) being afterward closed by screw-plugs
It is evident that more than two cham-
sand pistons may be used, if desired,
The impeller-shaft 6 is tubular, its lower end
ng closed by a serew-plug 27, while its up-
end is closed by the inwardly-projecting
rer end of the pump-shaft 28, which fits in
. shaft 6 and is secured thereto by trans-
se pins 29, The pump-shaft is preferably
id to give a maximum torsional strength.
rts 30 are cut at suitable points in the im-
ller-shaft just below the lower bearing 5
d the bearings 16, 19, and 23,
The operation of the pump is as follows:
e impeller is rotated at high speed and
rees the water up through the annular space
tween the outer and inner shells of the
dy-section 8 of the casing. The water
sses freely through the holes 25, and the
essure due to the weight of the rising wa-
rcolumn in the uptake-pipe is thus trans-
itted to the under side of the pistons 24.
y properly proportioning the area and num-
tof said pistons to the total weight of the
tating parts and the superimposed water
lumn said weight can be balanced by the
ft on the pistons. Hence no step-bearing
required for the shaft. There is a little leak-
ge of water past the pistons into the cham-
rs above them, and this water in time fills
ve chambers. In order to prevent it from
quiring a pressure equal to that on the un-
er side of the pistons, and thus neutraliz-
ig the lifting effect of the water column, the
orts 30 are so arranged with reference to the
lationary shaft-bearings that when the pres-
wre in the chambers reaches a predeter-
tined limit the consequent drop of the shaft
ill bring said ports below said bearings,
hus permitting the water in the chambers
denter the tubular shaft and escape through
he lower ports into the well on the suction
ile of the impeller. By closing the lower
al of the shaft and providing the lower set
f ports I form an intermediate chamber be-
Ween the casing and the well, and thus pre-
tnt too sudden changes of pressure in the
tambers; but as soon as sufficient water has
saped to permit the resultant increased
ressure on the under side of the piston to
ift the pistons and shaft the ports will be
and the equilibrium — reésti.blished.
¢ shaft, pistons, and impeller thus have a
onstant slight motion up and down as these
djustments of pressure occur. It will be
otieed that they are independent of the ac-
tal pressure in pounds per square inch,
ince the balancing effect is due to the dif-

ferential pressure on the under side of the
piston and not to the actual pressure of the
water column, It will also be noticed that
by means of the piston 21 and its chamber
and escape-ports the area of the impeller sub-
jected to a downward pressure is no greater
than that of its blades and that this is par-
tially balaneed by the upward pressure of
the water column on so much of the conical
body of the impeller as lies above the blades.

I am aware that it has been proposed to
provide the shaft of a rotary pump with a
balanecing-piston and to utilize the water leak-
ing past said piston to lubricate the adjacent
shaft-bearing; but my invention aims to util-
ize the leakage to set up a differential pres-
sure on the under side of the piston, so as to
automatically balance the rotating parts irre-
spective of the height of the water column—a
result not possible in the aforesaid proposed
construction,

I claim—

1. In a rotary pump, the combination with
an upright axially-movable shaft, of a bal-
ancing-piston secured thereto and having its
under side exposed to the pressure of the
water column, a stationary casing containing
a chamber above said piston, and means con-
trolled by the axial movement of the shaft
for permitting the escape of water from said
chamber to the suction side of the pump, and
thus regulating the pressure in said chamber.

2. In a rotary pump, the combination with
an upright axially-movable shaft, of a sta-
tionary casing containing a chamber concen-
tric with said shaft and having means to ad-
mit the pressure of the water column in the
uptake, a piston seeured to said shaft and
fitting the walls of said chamber, and escape-
ports above said piston controlled by the ax-
ial movement of said shaft.

3. In a rotary pump, the combination with
an upright axially-movable tubular shaft, of
a stationary casing containing a chamber con-
centrie with said shaft and having holes in
its walls, a piston secured to said shaft and
fitting the walls of said chamber above said
holes, and escape-ports in said shaft above
said pistons,

4, Ina rotary pump, the combination with
an upright axially-movable tubular shaft, of
a stationary casing comprising two concen-
tric shells, the inner one being closed at the
top and bottom and having holes in its walls,
one or more pistons in said inner shell above
said holes and secured to said shaft, and es-
cape-ports in said shaft above said pistons,
controlled by the axial movement of said
shaft.

5. In a rotary pump, the combination with
an upright axially-movable tubular shaft, of
a stationary casing comprising two concen-
trie shells, the inner one having a diaphragm
and provided with holes in its walls above
and below said diaphragm, heads closing the

top and bottom of said inner shell, shaft-bear-

ings in said heads and diaphragm, pistons

75

1

_

—_

—

942

and
the

secured to said shaft above said holes,
escape-ports in said shaft adjacent to
lower ends of said bearings.

6. In a rotary pump, the combination with
5 an axially-movable tubular shaft having its
lower end closed and provided with ports of
a bearing adjacent to and above said ports,
a balancing-piston secured to said shaft and
having its under side exposed to the pressure
of the water column, a stationary casing ¢on-
taining a chamber for said piston, and means
for putting said chamber in communication
with the interior of said shaft when the re-
sultant pressure on the under side of the pis-
ton falls below a predetermined limit.

7. In a rotary pump, the combination with
a stationary casing comprising two concen-
tric shells, of a shaft concentric with said
shells, an impeller on the shaft having a con-
ieal body carrying a piston fitting a chamber
at the lower end of the inner shell, means for

Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

735,691

permitting the escape of leakage-water fro
said chamber to the suction side of the pump,
and a balancing-piston in the inner shell ex:
posed underneath to the pressure of the water
column and above to the pressure in a cham-
ber in said shell,
8. In a rotary pump, the combination with
a stationary pump-casing, of an impeller, its
shaft, a balancing-piston secured on the shaft,
a easing surrounding said piston and com
municating below the piston with the uptake,
and means for automatically regulating th
pressure on the top of the piston, whereby
the differential pressure on its under side
will remain substantially constant.
In testimony whereof I affix my signature
in presence of two witnesses.
JOHN WATSON ALVORD.
Witnesses:
ARTHUR MCLEAN,
Cuas. B, BuRDICK.

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 943

Defendants’ Exhibit ‘‘A-3.’’

[Endorsed]: In the United States District Court,
Northern District of California, Southern Division.
In Equity—No. 485. Layne & Bowler Corporation,
Plaintiff, vs. Wester Well Works, Inc., a Corpora-
tion, et al. Defendants. Defendants’ Exhibit
“A-3.°? Hattie B. Lehman, Notary Public.

Filed Sep. 2, 1920. W. B. Maling Clerk. By
J. A. Schaertzer, Deputy Clerk.

No. 3627. United States Cireuit Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Circuit. Filed Jan. 6, 1921. F. D.
Monckton, Clerk.

Sy ees Editions

An India ead Comp
A Division of Information Handling Service

CARD HI

>
3 -
7 «
. A :
= 5
eo rm)
nied =
7 $
a
3 &
a
be a
65 &
a Zz
S > .
- So
~ Oo a3
ss aa
2 Am «a
; a}
. aa3
= 223 Vy WY
as ey ViLiLiee> Viti
= "8 a |
~~ . 2 & :
C "~aos
~~ mm 3
— os
ioe] ;
S
DB x | |
Ned ps )
ee ; |
4
s #3
o
= 2
« :

944

vs. Layne & Rowler Corporation. 945

No. 735,692. PATENTED AUG. 11, 1903.
J. W. ALVORD.
HIGH SPEED ROTARY PUMP

APPLIOATION FILED MAB. 30. 1903
BO MODEL. ® SHEETS—SHEET 2.

49.2. a Aig +3.

Jiventos

AV tresses Neh W, Aled

946 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

No. 735,692. PATENTED AUG. 11, 1903.
J. W. ALVORD.
HIGH SPEED ROTARY PUMP.

APPLIOATION FILED MAB. 30. 1903.
Bo MODEL 8 SELETS—SEEST 3.

a
>A
NY

we

S
\
‘
NA
is fj

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 947

No. 735,692 PATENTED ADG. 11, 1903.
J. W. ALVORD.

HIGH SPEED ROTARY PUMP.
APPLIOATION FILED MAR. 30. 1903
Bo MODEL ' 8 SHELT®—SHEET 4.

2

Tnventor

Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

948

PATENTED AUG. 11, 1908.

ALVORD.

1. W.
HIGH SPEED ROTARY PUMP.

No. 735,692.

APPLICATION TILED MAB. 30. 1908.

6 SHLESTO—SHEES 6.

Sg. 74.

BO MODEL.

a
%
4

\ 2
Oo eMacarcos

(FOSS SOOM EBAL POPOL OL Oey S
Z '

iy
ca nagp eras astOUE sees

Anventor

Qi tresses

us. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 949

No. 735,692. PATENTED AUG. 11, 1903.
J. W. ALVORD.
HIGH SPEED ROTARY PUMP.

APPLICATION FILED MAR 30. 1903
WO MODEL 8 SELETS~SELET SO

Suventos

Orr W. Alvwrd,

2, trrgones

950 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

No. 735,692. PATENTED AUG. 11, 1903.
J. W. ALVORD.
HIGH SPEED ROTARY PUMP.
APPLIOATION FILED MAR. 30. 1903

FO MODEL 8 SBELTS-SHEET 2
41G.23.-

AC Bresces

Ss
oy

Bi itiie oF

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 951

No. 735,692. PATENTED AUG. 11, 1903.
J. W. ALVORD.
HIGH SPEED ROTARY PUMP.

APPLIOATION FILED MAB. 30. 1903.
BO MODEL @ SHLBTS—SBLET 3.

71g. 25.

Witrrerses

\

. wus western wet works, Inc., et at.

No. 735,692. Patented August 11, 1903
UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE.
JOHN WATSON ALVORD, OF CHICAGO, ILLINOIS.
HIGH-SPEED ROTARY PUMP.

SPECIFICATION forming part of Letters Patent No. 735,692, dated August 11, 1903.
Application filed March 30, 1903. Serial No. 150,184. (No model.)

0 all whom it may concern: mined limit, the impeller and shaft will dre :
Be it known that I, JouN WATSON ALVORD, | slightly, thereby opening an eseape-port az
a citizen of the United States, residing at Chi- | relieving any excess of pressure in the ¢
eago, in the county of Cook and State of Illi- | ber, so as to keep the differential balaneig
nois, have invented certain new and useful | pressure at about the same point at all tims
Improvements in High-Speed Rotary Pumps; | irrespective of the fluetuations in the aetul
and I do declare the following to be a full, pressure of the water column. In anotbe
clear, and exact deseription of the invention, | form of impeller the water column is not com
such as will enable others skilled in the art] pletely reversed, but is diverted from an up
to which it appertains to make and use the} right longitudinal direction in the casing »
same, reference being had to the accompany-|a_radially-lateral direetion while passizg
ing drawings, and to the figures of reference | through the impeller and is then turned up
marked thereon, which forms a part of this | ward again through the upper part of th
specification. easing. This impeller is provided with th
This invention relates to high-speed rotary | same balancing-chamber and escape-pors
pumps for deep wells, by which I mean wells | automatically controlled by the rise and fal
a hundred feet or more in depth. In such] of the impeller as have been described it
wells the rotary pump is located far below | connection with the reversing-impeller.
the surface of the ground, being operated by It will be readily understood that. othe
an upright shaft rising to the surface ani | forms of impeller may be employed, but ther
there driven by some suitable motor. In] must be such as to produce an upward by
deep wells the weight of this long shaft and | drostatie pressure on the under side of th
its attached parts is very great, and many | impeller, and this must be partially balane
schemes have been proposed for supporting | by leakage-pressure in a chamber controll!
it or for counterbalancing it. by the longitudinal movement of the iz
My invention relates to that mode of coun- | peller due to the slight variations in the dif
terbalancing which utilizes the hydrostatic | ferential pressure.
pressure of the rising column of water in the In the accompanying drawings, Figure 118
uptake or delivery-pipe of the pump. In or-}| a longitudinal section of the reversing-it
der to cause this column to exert a lifting | peller and its easing. Fig. 2 is a bottom
effect upon the shaft and its attached parts, | plan view of the impeller. Fig. 3 is at
I so construct the impeller that the water] plan view of the same. Figs. 4, 5, 6, and!
eolumn is reversed in direction in passing | are diametrical sections of the same on th
through the impeller, so that at the point | correspondingly-numbered lines in Fig. *
where the water leaves the impeller it is flow-) Fig. & is a side elevation of said impelle
ing downward, being subsequently reversed | Fig. 9 is a perspective view of a developmet!
again in passing through the impeller-casing, | of the web and flange-wall of the impeller
> so as to thereafter pursue an upward course | Fig. 10 is a top plan view of the lower s&
into the uptake. The hydrostatic reaction | tion of the easing. Figs, 11, 12, 13, 14 ih)
on the impeller at the point of delivery there- | and 16 are radial sections of the same on thé
from is sufficient to lift and sustain all the | correspondingly-numbered lines in Fig. 1
rotating parts. In order to automatically | Fig. 17 is a top plan view of the upper s*
regulate the lifting effect within predeter-| tion of the casing. Fig. 18 is a side elev®
mined limits, so as to maintain the shaft and] tion of the gland for the stuffing-box on 4
impeller in substantially the same position | larger scale. Fig. 19 is a diametrical sectiot
while running, I provide above the impeller | of the same. Fig. 20 is a bottom plan vieF
a chamber into which the water under pres- | of the same, Fig, 21 is a diametrical sectitt
sure can leak past the periphery of the im- | of the upper section of the casing. Fig. =
peller. When the pressure in this chamber | is a ton plan view of the same. Fig. 23188
reaches a given value and the consequent | side elevation of the inner shell of the sam
differential pressure on the under side of the | and the radial helical partitions. Fig. 24¥
impeller has been lessened to the predeter-| a top plan view of the same. Fig. 25 18!

or

—_
=

—
uo

ts
—

te
ur

va
—J

60

65

5 shown.

3 cross-section

vs. Layne cw power Vorporatron.

735,692

2

longitudinal section of the radial impeller
and its easing. Fig. 26 is a perspective view
of said impeller partly broken away.

The rotable pump-shaft 1 passes down
through the uptake or delivery-pipe 2, being
preferably inclosed in a easing 3. The shaft
bas bearings 4 5 in the upper and lower sec-
tions of the casing respectively. In the lower
ends of the upper section is located the im-
peller, which is a cireular structure concen-
trie with the shaft, to which it is firmly keyed
or otherwise secured. The impeller has a
hub 6, surrounded by a «disk-shaped body 7,
which is provided with a peripheral flange 8,
containing packing-grooves and fitting snugly
inside the cylindrical lower end 9 of the in-
ner shell 10 of the upper section of the ¢cas-
ing. Said cylindrical end 9 is long enough to
allow the impeller to have a certain amount
of longitudinal play.

Referring now especially to the figures of
the drawings illustrating the reversing-im-
peller, it will be seen that between the hub
and the periphery »f the impeller is a cylin-
drieal flange 11 extending preferably down-
ward below the bottom of the flange 8 and
having a rotating fit inside the upper end of
the inner shell 12 of the lower section of the
casing. The joint is preferably a rabbeted
one, as shown, and the flange 11 has a water-
packing groove in it. At certain points,
preferably two, a web 13 connects the flange
1] with the hub, whose surface below the disk
7 is preferably tapering and coneaved, as
The outer edge of the web 13. re-
mains always in the same transverse plane,
but its inner edge rises in a regular helical

line along the surface of the hub, departing |

farther and farther from the center as it
rises until it reaches a point longitudinally
in line with the flange 11. That portion of
said flange above the plane of junction with
the web also veers outwardly, similarly to the
web, so that a space of substantially uniform
is maintained between them,
the flange-wall moving downward as the web
rises until at the point where the web as-
sumes a position parallel with the axis of
the hub the flange-wall becomes horizontal
and terminates. The relative positions of
the web and flange-wall are illustrated in
Fig. 9, which is a perspective view of them
as they would look straightened out instead
of following the circular contour of the hub,
as they actually do. In the drawings two
webs are shown starting at diametrically op-
posite points and each continuing for three-
eighths of the cireumference of the hub, It
will be seen from this construction that the
water rising through the supply passage in
the inner shell 12 will be continuously lifted
by the radial edges of the two webs and car-
tied from a point inside the inner shell and
flange 11 first upward, then outward, and
finally downward to a point outside the
flange 11 and between it and the peripheral
flange 8. Here it enters an annular cham-

YOS —

ber in the lower section of the casing concen-
trie with the supply-passage 12. The walls

of this chamber 14 are twisted on helical 7

lines in a fashion similar to the web and
flange-wall of the impeller, so that the stream
of water is carried first downward, then out-
ward, and then upward through an outer
concentric annular chamber 14’. By a care-
ful study of Figs. 11 to 16, noting that they
are successive radial seetions of Fig. 10
through a quarter of its circumference, it is
thought that the course and operation of the
chamber-walls_ will be understood. From
the outer chamber 14’ the water passes up
through the annular space 15 between the
inner and outer shells of the upper section
of the casing, whence it flows into the up-
take. In order to counteract the rotary mo- 8
tion of the water as it issues from the cham-
ber 14’, the space 15 is divided into segments
by helical radial partitions 16, uniting the
two concentric shells of the upper casing-
section and so inclined as to check the whirl
of the water and send it into the uptake in
substantially longitudinal lines.

It will be seen that at the point in the im-
peller where the water is reversed from an
upward to a downward direction there will
be an upward hydrostatic pressure due to the
weight of the water column in the uptake.
This pressure tends to lift the impeller and
its shaft, and by properly proportioning the
parts this lift can be made to counterbalance
the rotating parts, so that the shaft will re-
quire no step-bearing, but will float, as it
were, on the water. In order to regulate this
counterbalancing effect so as to maintain the
impeller automatically in substantially the
same position irrespective of the fluctuations
in the water-pressure, I provide above the |
disk of the impeller a chamber 17, formed =
inside the inner shell of the upper section of ©
the casing. At its upper end the chamber is
made water-tight by a stuffing-box surround- |
ing the shaft 1. The gland 18 of the stuffing- 4
box is flanged, forming a cup to receive the
upper end of the hub 6 of the impeller, which 4
has a snug fit in the flange 19. Through said j
flange are cut ports 20, and the longitudinal
motion of the hub inside the flange will open
and close these ports. One or more eseape-
duets 21 are made through the impeller from
the upper end of the hub to points below the #
disk 7 and opening into the supply-passage 12. 9

In the operation of the pump the pressure §
of the water column causes a certain leakage
of water past the periphery of the impeller
into the chamber 17. As this leakage accu-
mulates in the chamber it counteracts the
lifting effect of the pressure on the under
side of the impeller, and if allowed to go on
unregulated it would soon become so great as
to balance that pressure and destroy the value
of the water column as a balancing agent for}
the rotating parts. The ports 20 are there-
fore so located that when the back pressure
in the chamber 17 reaches a predetermine

954

point, at which the differential pressure on
the disk of the impeller is just sufficient to
properly balance the rotating parts, then the
downward movement of the impeller has been
sufficient to open the ports 20 and permit an
escape of all subsequent leakage into the
chamber to the suction side of the impeller.
The device is thus self-regulating, and the im-
peller will maintain its normal position irre-
spective of the actual pressure of the water
column in the uptake. This automatic regu-
lating action is also secured by the impeller
shown in Figs. 25 and 26, which operates by
forcing the water outward in radial lines into
the lower end of the upper section of the
easing. Said upper section is similar to
that used for the reversing-impeller; but the
lower section is less intricate, being merely
a pedestal 22, containing a lower bearing for
the shaft 1 and having at its upper end a ecy-
lindrical shoulder 23, into which fits a cylin-
drical packed flange 24 on the impeller. The
peripheral flange 8 on the impeller extends
upward instead of downward, as in Fig. 1.
Under the disk 7 are one or more eccentric
webs 25, beginning at the flange 24 and end-
ing at the periphery of the disk and joined
to the flange by horizontal plates 26. When
two such webs are used, as shown in the
drawings, they each run half-way around the
impeller. When this impeller is rotated,
these webs, whose inner ends are in advance,
continuously cut the water and force it ra-
dially outward into the upper section of the
casing, where it passes up through the com-
partments between the helical partitions,
and so on to the uptake. The hydrostatic
pressure of the water column is exerted in-
wardly on the webs and upwardly on the
disk and plates. The water leaking past
the flange 8 is received in the ehamber 17.
and its escape is regulated by the ports 20
and the ducts 21 and hub 6, just as in the
ease of the reversing-impeller hereinbefore
described.

In using these pumps in deep wells I place
two or more of them at different depths, each
delivering water into a common uptake, or I
May arrange them tandem, all acting on the
same water column, so that the lower pumps
each deliver into the one next above.

Having thus described my invention, what
I claim is—

1. In a rotary pump, the combination with
an impeller having its under side exposed to
the hydrostatic pressure of the water column
in the uptake, of a casing having a chamber
above said impeller and in which said im-
peller is free to move longitudinally, and
means controlled by the impeller for regulat-
ing the pressure in said chamber.

2. In a rotary pump, the combination with
an impeller having its under side exposed to
the hydrostatic pressure of the water columi
in the uptake, of a casing containing a leak-
age-chamber above said impeller, and means

now

Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

: arcs era“:
“ie / > ° A psp provided mith a closed driving shaft ot
ing: extending to the tep of the well froa the pump, a pipe ox ‘
tendin, downward from the pus ca: ing and means for fixing’ the

" pmp at any desired point i. the well casings substantially

describec. 2 eae rae! eee

x A) OA pump provided with a closed ariving|ahagt ear cas-m
ing extending to the top of + the well from the pump, @ Pipe. ar é

. sz Cy pending ro at 2p Be cus: rg and reans for fixing tt of a

ee ot talon an a
2.4. LE a at a:f/Gesffed fat in’ tie center of the soli ae

supstentially & es desorited. Sa

é J bk. The ccmbination with a puxp of an extensible= R,
> purp shaft therefor ania means for supporti rg ‘the purp at ‘any

% w« +/ Gesired point in the wel ly orued, greet porendontl woffa fore “{

The combination with a_rotery pump of an wae.

Bek. Veisible pump shaft: therefor ant-méand_for r_suprorting the, pug ;
at any desired point An the well. ©, =. ae os :
Fo ” =F

v %. The coubinat _ withag racy yor a soot isha

* att casing surround irejeetd pup shart ant Srecting to. »
ght

eee See 2a: ae

PO. _

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 973
ee FE Ty. ee ee ace RES ete,
PA top of the well and. means for tixine the pop in position at; -
ee any desired Point of the well caging... om, Tete Atte’
ae Re Oe
> , d pee Re “tn wil nechanism i cobinaton it a Baas a
as then-tethe-piyly 2." Page
isa * serics of wedges operated fron the! t top. of: the ‘weil: Dy means: of) bo
a links, @ series of. wedges carried by. the pump Casing and operat 7
| __ ed by toggle links attacked to's rod extended tothe top of =
bY the yell ; for. the purposes spevitied? © = Ae Ras =. ee

with rolatiott te sect
b.. * other to wedge the ‘said pump.éasing 16 sides oF bin
ee — tall casing, substantially as feasts : Lui pws Soa

nex 4 te. In combinat ior with a well casing anda . 1
a sertes of wedges suspended by réds from the top of “the |
operating the same to wedge the pump easing against the ¥
casing, subetantiafly as atcennegs Wa, ie . : ee

a

¢ nN, “Te well. ‘noshonien ry pop Saning provided ity a4
‘ series of wedges mounted upony toggle links theréin tot dg a .
said casing against. the side walls of the well faving, a r.

; stantially as aesor ited. ‘ > pl Oe ; .
ne. xs
Ps ere: >
by “g oa ¢ ‘te. Ty. well necbanien the hocks a
; pump. af a jointed pump shaftaad ‘8 Otused. casing rropnding iid

2s

i Mh pump shaft feos the ° wap te ‘theitop, ‘of me wi. eS

* 24

lrwverntor.-

Makin £ hagoe,
1 byt Amal

ay

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 999

No. 821,653 PATENTED MAY 29, 1906.

M. E. LAYNE.

WELL MECHANISM.
APPLICATION FILED APR. 28, 1903,

4 SHELTO—SELET 2.

%-

44-33

thhresses:

ae, Hh ober k

.

Tne., et al.

orks ‘

Western Well W

1000

No. 821,653

PATENTED MAY 29, 1906.

M. E. LAYNE.
WELL MECHANISM.

APPLICATION FILED APB. 28.

1903

4@OHEETS—SHELT 3

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 1001

Mo. 82) ,653. PATENTED MAY 29, 1906.
M. E. LAYNE.

WELL MECHANISM.
APPLICATION FILED APR. 38. 1003.
6 QERSTS-SEEST ¢.

i oe Alle 62

HN oo TT TI >

Ub ses,
kao. HEheok_ 7)
Crean Sfiurmagl, Sy ke Kosrncetroe

i

Ke iatiaintice atte poe

On 8 eat Meroe

1002

Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE.

MAHLON E. LAYNE, OF HOUSTON, TEXAS.
WELL MECHANISM.

No. 821,653.
Application filed April 28,

To all whom it may concern:

Be it known that 1, MAHLON E. LAYNE, &
citizen of the United States, residing at Hous-
ton, county of Harris, and State of Texas,
have invented certain new and useful Im
provements in Well Mechanism, of which the
following is a specification.

My invention relates to the apparatus used
for drawing water from driven or Artesian
wells, and particularly to the means for ad-
justing a pump therein, The objects of the
invention are, to provide means by which the
piping and the pump may be all assembled
in proper shape before inserting it into the
well; to provide means by which a pump
may be placed in any desired position in a
well, centered, raised or lowered and fixed in
position by manipulating from the outside
entirely; to provide means for adjusting the
length of the piping leading from the pump
to the surface at will and to lower the pump
from time to time without taking it out of
the well; to provide improved means for cen-
tering and fixing the pump in proper position
in the well casing; to provide improved
means for manipulating the packing of the
pump shaft, and proper adjustment of the
pump in place by means at the surface of the
ground; to provide for the proper action of a
pump without stopping up the well, so that
water may be either flowed into or pumped
out of the same at pleasure; to provide a su-
perior mounting for a centrifugal pump in
the well, manipulated from the surface of the
ground; to provide an extensible pump
shaft separately supported at intervals along
its length; to provide an automatic center:
ing device for the pump in the well; to pro-
vide for mounting the pump and the shaft in
a closed easing which is open to operate from
the top; to obviate the necessity of making
large wells for descending into them in order
to arrange the pump, and to generally im-
prove and cheapen the apparatus used for
the above purposes.

The above objects, as well as other advan-
tages which will hereinafter appear, I attain
by means of the construction and assem-
blage of parts as illustrated in preferred
forms in the accompanying drawings, where-
in—

Figure 1 represents a section of a well

showing the preferred form of my apparatus

in place therein.
Figures 2, 3 and 4 are horizontal sections

Specification of Letters Patent.

Patented May 29, 1906,
1903. Serial No. 154,704.

of the shaft casing respectively taken on lize
2 of Figure 1, and lines 3 and 4 in Figur 5

raged Me — enlarged central vertices
section taken through the pu ;
ing of the well. . aetna ae

‘igure 6 is a horizontal secti ‘igure j
taken along the line 6. oe

Figure 7 is a section of a top of the wel
casing containing the pump shaft and its
mounting; Figure 8 isa similar section taker|
at one of the joints of the pump shaft casing

Figure 9 is a section taken through th
casing containing the pump shaft at the cd:
lar 28 in Figure 1
; Figure 10 is a vertical section of a well bar
ing a modified form of the apparatus therein

Figure 11 is a side view and partial sectio
of a centrifugal pump mounted by a modified
method,

Pi get 12 - a half plan and half section
of the pump shown in Figure
the line 12 ‘therein, : Pas

Figure 13 is a partial vertical section takes
through the shafting and its mounting show
in Figure 10 at the point marked 68,

For convenience of illustration the apps
ratus is shown as applied to a well whic
passes through two water bearing strat
separated by an impervious stratum, the to
surface of the ground being also an impe:
vious layer of earth. The upper chamber 15
of the well may be protected by wooler
framing as customary, or it may be buts
continuation of the chamber inelosed by the
casing 16, which may be carried to the sur
face if desired, and the chamber 15 dispens!
with, Below this is a sereen 17 in the sani
layer, and still below the sereen 17 is another
casing 18, into which extends the suctit
pipe 22, from the pump 21, and below thi
another screen 19.

In the approved form as illustrated in Fig
ure 1, I use a centrifugal pump 21, single
in a series, as may be desired, and having!
top discharge. It is attached to a casing 2)
which runs to the top of the well and incloe
the driving shaft 39 of the pump, which my
be driven by a pulley 25, mounted in th
framework 24, in any approved manner. A!
outlet pipe 23 leads from the pump to t®
surface to carry off the water. An shown it
Figure 2, the shaft casing 20, and the outkt
pipe 23, are bound together by means of th
block-and-strap arrangement 26. These cor
necting devices are distributed at interval

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation.

1003

2 821,653

along the length of the shaft easing. In or-
jer to previously assemble all the parts and
then put the pump into the well and fix it in
position therein, I provide a system of
wedges 33, which serve to fix the pump in
place and hold it in the proper vertical posi-
tion, designed to be operated by means from
the top of the well, avoiding the necessity of
,man’s going into the well in order to fix the
ump in place. Pivoted to an extension on
the head of the centrifugal pump casing 37, |
provide a series of toggle links 34, which are
tarried in slots in the extension 36 of the cas-
ing, and at their euter ends bear wedge blocks
33, which embrace and codperate with the
vertically movable wedges 33, placed against
the easing 16. The wedges 33 may be at-
tached to links 29, which are carried by a
diding collar 28 on the casing 20, the collar
28 being operated by a rod 27, which runs to
the top of the well, so that from the top the
wedges 33 may be raised and lowered into
place and ean be tightened therein. The tog-
ie links may be also connected by links 32,
toa collar 31, and the collar 31to a rod 30,
which extends to the top of the well as be-
fore, in order to manipulate it without going
into the well. Thus in order to obtain
greater power and fix the wedges more se-
curly in place, it will be observed that by
pulling up on the rod 32, the toggle links 34
will eause the wedge blocks 35 to press with
great power against the wedges 33, and thus
fx the pump casing in place wherever de-
sired,

The pump shaft 39 is inclosed in a shaft
easing 20, which latter is made in joints and
may be of any desired length. The pump
shaft also is made in sections 39, 39’, 39”,
shih are attached together by means of
diding keys so as to allow of some vertical
play with relation to each other. From Fig-
ure 5 it will be seen that the shaft 39 passes
through a block 47, and at its top is fixed in
the bearing block 48 by means of the pin 50,
as shown in Figure 4. The next section of
the shaft, 39’, is inserted into the block 48,
and prevented from rotating by means of the
tey 49, which is splined therein, The weight
of the shaft and pump below the block 47 is
carried by the block 48; and from Figure 8 it
rill be seen that a similar arrangement is
made at the top of the next section of the
staft casing, where the block 47’ supports the
weight of the section of shaft 39° by means
of the collar 48’, connected by a pin and key
38 before.

At the top, the casing 20 is closed and is
povided with a stuffing box 50, closed by the
ap 51, at the top of the shaft 39”. The
taft 39 is fixedly keyed to the vanes 38 of
the centrifugal pump, and below the pump
‘sing 21 is a pipe 22, which extends down
teow the water level and is extended any
isired depth in the well.

The casing 20 also contains a tubular rod
44, which has a bearing in the block 47 on top
of the pump casing 37, as shown in Figure 5,
and is provided with a square opening which
codperates with the head of the screw 42,
used for adjusting the cap 41 of the packing
box 40 for the pump, and compressing the
packing in place. In order that this cap 41
may be raised and lowered evenly, the screw
42 is provided with a sprocket wheel, and
two other screws of a similar kind are dis-
tributed about the cap, as shown in Figure 6,
and connected by means of the sprocket
chain 46, so that by means of the tubular
shaft 44, all three of said screws 42 may be
turned at once to compress the packing in
box 40.

This pipe or tubular shaft 44 also serves
the purpose of providing convenient means
for forcing the liquid out of the pump shaft
casing. By forcing air in at the top of the
casing 20, by means of the pipe 52, the liquid
can be foreed down to the bottom of said eas-
ing 20, and by means of the small opening
45, in the bottom of the tubular shaft 44, the
fluid can be forced out at the top 54, and
keep the casing clear in order to leave the
bearings clean therein and not interfere with
the working of the pump, or by forcing fluid
in at the top 54, the operation will be re-
versed, and the fluid ejected from pipe 52.

It will be noticed that the weight of the
pump and its shaft is supported at each end
of the sections of the casing by the blocks 47,
47’, etc. By reason of this arrangement the
pump shaft and the shaft casing can be made
in separable sections, and consequently the
pump may be inserted at any desired depth
and the parts assembled before putting them
into the well. The wedge system illustrated
for tightening the pump easing in place may
also, if desired, be used to center it with re-
spect to the easing. The outlet pipe 23 is
also preferably made in sections to corre-
spond with the sections of the pump shaft
casing.

In Figures 10 to 13 I have shown a modi-
fied form of the apparatus which uses a sim-
ple series of wedges for fixing the pump in
place, as illustrated best in Figure 11. The
pump easing has a platform 61, and a de-
pending ring flange 66, and a series of wedges
63 are placed around the depending flange
66, and are connected to the top platform by
means of a series of screws 65. A series of
cooperating wedges 62 may also be provided,
suspended from the platform 61 by means of
the serews 64, and the two series of wedges
surround the whole casing. It will some-

times be convenient to dispense with the out-

let pipe 23, and extend the casing 16 to the
top, to act itself as the conveying channel
for the liquid. In each case, of course, the
pump casing 21 and platform 61 will be made
water-tight within the casing 16, and for this

85 |

95

_

—

os

el

1004

purpose the wedges 62 will be made in over-
lapping sections, in order to break the joints
seen in Figure 12. The pumps will then de-
liver directly into the upper casing. It will
be plain that by turning the screws 65, the
bottom wedges are drawn upward against
the wedges 62, by which the casing of the
pump is fixed in any desired place and tight-
ened in the well casing 16. The screws 65
may be operated by means of a_ socket
wrench placed upon a long rod and reached
from the surface of the ground, or may be ex-
tended to the surface of the ground, as de-
sired.

In the case illustrated, the top of the pump
shaft may be provided with a pulley 25, as
before, and a bearing fixed on some part of
the framework, as on the cross beam 57.
Extending downward from the beam 57 may
be provided a timber 56, and part way down
a bearing and support provided for the cas-
ing of the pump shaft 60, by means of the
block 67, which is carried upon a cross frame
68; and a packing box therein, 71, is closed
by a screw 70, the whole being attached to
the timber 56 as shown in Figure 13. Be-
low this point the shaft 39 may be inclosed
in a casing 60, which is screwed in the block
67, as shown in said Figure. For additional
security the block 67 may be attached to the
timber 56, by means of the strap 69, which
surrounds the same. The casing 60 may be
in sections and of any desired length.

I prefer, generally, to allow for free flow of
water down the well outside of the pump cas-
ing and the pump, in order that the water may
be drained into the well when desired, rather
than pumping the water out; which | attain
by dropping the wedges 63 and thereby
loosening the wedges 62 from the casing 16,
permitting water above pump to pass into
the strata supplying the well.

I generally prefer to extend the piping 22
entirely through the first water bearing
stratum and into the second, as shown in the
screen 19; it being understood that the water
from the first stratum will flow down the
casing 18 to the second when the water level
falls sufficiently therefor.

In general I prefer the form of apparatus as
shown in Figure 1, both because the means
for fixing the pump in place is more easily ad-
justed, and because of the superior mount-
ing of the pump shaft inside its sectional cas-
ing as therein shown, and making the pump
shaft in sections. But in cases where the
pump will not be moved for a long time, the
device of Figure 11 may be used for wedging
it in place.

It will be seen that by fastening the pump
within the casing in such position as to leave
an unobstructed passage around it, I pro-
vide for draining water into the well in cases
where this is desired, as often happens when
fields are flooded, and when it is desired to

Western Well Works, Inc., et al.
821,653 3

drain the fields. The whole apparatus be
ing self-contained, can be put together in
proper form and lowered into the well a
once. It will be seen also that the to
levers used for actuating the wedges Px.
used or not, as desired, since the w
alone will be amply sufficient in the appara-
tus of Figure 1, as wellas in that of Figure 10,
I consider it of great advantage also to ar
range the pump shaft in a closed casing with?
stuffing box at surface of ground at top of
pump, so that by the use of the packing
boxes an air-tight chamber can be maip-
tained, and water kept out of the casing 20,
or kept filled with clean liquid, if desired,
thereby providing an efficient lubricating
system for all bearings of the pump.

The many advantages of this apparatus
will be apparent to those familiar with the
use of such devices, from inspection of the §
drawings.

Having thus described my invention and
illustrated its use, what I claim and desire to
secure by Letters Patent, is the following:

1. A pump provided with a closed driving §
shaft casing extending to the top of the well
from the pump, a pipe extending downwari
from the pump casing and means for fixing
the pump at any desired point in the well
casing, substantially as described, ’

2. A pump provided with a closed driving
shaft casing extending to the top of the well
from the pump, a pipe extending downward
from the pump casing and means for fixing
the pump at any desired point in the center!
of the well casing and sealing said shaft of
from water in the well, substantially as de
scribed.

3. The combination with a pump of an er
tensible pump shaft therefor means for sup-!
porting the pump at any desired point in the
well, and independent supports for the shaft

4. The combination of a rotary pump, and
extensible pump shaft and protecting casing
for the shaft, and means for supporting the!
pump and shaft and casing at any desirel
point within the well.

5. The combination with a rotary pump,
of a sectional pump shaft easing surrounding
the pump shaft and extending to the top of!
the well and means for fixing the pump it
position at any desired point of the well cas
ing.

6. In well mechanism in combination with
a pump, a series of wedges operated from the!
top of the well by means of links, a series of
wedges carried by the pump casing and op
erated by toggle links attached to a rod ex
tended to the top of the well, for the pur
poses specified. |

7. In combination with a well casing and
a pump, a series of wedges suspended by rods
from the top of the well for operating the
same to wedge the pump casing against the
well casing, substantially as described. |

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation.

‘ 821,653

8, In well mechanism a pump casing pro-
sided with a series of wedges mounted upon
toggle links therein to wedge the said casing

inst the side walls of the well casing, sub-
stantially as described.

9, In well mechanism the combination
sith a pump casing, of a rotary pump of a
jointed pump shaft and a closed casing sur-
rounding the pump shaft from the pump to
the top of the well.

10. In well mechanism in combination
sith a pump and a closed shaft casing, a
pump shaft supported at intervals by blocks
pinned thereto and having splined joints in
sid blocks whereby the different sections of
the pump shaft may have vertical play with
relation to each other.

ll. A pump casing provided with a stuff-
ing box and stuffing box plug, a closed shaft
casing protecting the bearings from the wa-
ter screws for raising and lowering said plug
and means for moving all of said screws at
one and means for operating the screws
from the top of the well, substantially as de-
scribed.

12, In pump mechanism the combination
with wedges for fixing the pump in the well
casing, of a casing for the pump shaft, a col-
lar thereon and Jinks extending from said
cllar to the top of the well and to the said
wedges.

13. The combination with a pump and its
actuating shaft of a sectional casing therefor
provided at each end of each section with a
fred block with bearings for the shaft, the
asing being closed at the top and provided
with an air vent.

14. The combination with a pump of a
pump shaft casing closed at the top and bot-
tom and provided with an interiorly disposed
hollow rod for the escape of liquid from the
staft casing and an air inlet at the top of the
casing.

15. In well mechanism the combination
rith a rotary pump of a pump shaft made in
sections independently supported and joined
ty blocks and keys in the blocks and ends of

the shaft sections, and a closed casing around
the shaft.

16. A pump shaft made in sections, each
section being suspended on a bearing by
means of a block pinned to the shaft section
and the next section being splined into said
block to rotate therewith.

17. The combinatioin of a rotary pump,
of a pump shaft and shaft casing surrounding
the shaft, the shaft and casing being in sec-
tions and connected by bearings at each end,
and the shaft section being separately sup-
ported in each section of the casing, as de-
scribed,

18. In well apparatus the combination
with a pump and means for suspending it
from the top of the well, of a casing separat-
ing the pump and bearings from the well,
and devices for fixing it at any desired point
in the well casing, and means for operating
the fixing devices from the top of the well.

19. A pump shaft made in independently

supported sections and suspended in a closed 7

pipe and provided with bearings and means
for lubricating the same.

20. The combination of a well casing, a ro-
tary pump therein, and a line shaft for the
pump entirely closed off from the water in
the well.

21. The combination of a well casing, a ro-
tary pump therein, means for fixing it at any
desired point in the well, an extensible line

shaft for the pump and a shaft casing en- 30

tirely inclosing the shaft and bearings.

22. The combination of a well casing, a ro-
tary pump therein, means for fixing it at any
desired point, a shaft casing, and a discharge

outlet from the pump independent of the &§

shaft easing and communicating with the
pump easing only at the bottom of the well.
In testimony whereof I have hereunto set
my hand, this 3d day of April, A. D. 1903, at
Chicago, Illinois.
MAHLON E. LAYNE.
Witnesses:
PauL CARPENTER,
ALBERT ©. HOWARD.

I TE Te at ae a an ee

1006 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

2—421. DIVISION IX.

1903
CONTENTS:

Application O. K. papers.

1. Rej. June 1/03.

2. Amendt. A, Feb. 1, 1904.

3. Rej. Feb. 15/04.

4. Amendt. B, Dee. 9, 1904.

5. Rej. Dee. 20/04.

6. Amendt. \/ Dec. 23, 1904.

7. Amendt. C, Dec. 31, 1904.

8. Rej. Jan. 13/05.

9. Amendt. \ Oct. 24, 1905.

ee PLUS chee h ee tase ees

A Bion ee eer ray Peg ir

Sy ete ng Ahh pene Mate:

a a Era ne are aI
AES PE ee

Re Seton, Seton tan re Pe Pe

OE eee eR rn sols sree eA

ae te IC ne a

Sea a eek canes Kaas Ok

DES cities Cenk ecw

DE icncs bation Cina eakeas

MEG kes heen tae Sakae ek

AE ER Ren tp Wein

Me Sate SOE Sohee aos Cees

TITLE:
Improvement in Well Mechanism.
Class 103-PUMPS.
Rotary Single Piston.

154,704.

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 1007

[Endorsed]: No, 485—Eq. Layne & Bowler
Corpn. vs. Western Well Works et al. Defts. Ex-
hibit “‘D.’”? Filed Sept. 3, 1920. W. B. Maling,
Clerk. By J. A. Schaertzer, Deputy Clerk.

No. 3627. United States Circuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Ninth Circuit. Filed Jan. 6, 1921.
F. D. Monckton, Clerk.

Defendants’ Exhibit ‘‘E.’’

In the District Court of the United States for the
Western District of Louisiana.

No. 925—IN EQUITY.

MAHLON E. LAYNE et al.,
Plaintiff,
Vs.
FRED I. GETTY,

Defendant.
OPINION.

This is a suit brought by Mahlon E. Layne, pat-
entee, and Layne & Bowler Company, his licensee,
for infringement of patent, with the usual prayer
for injunction, and an accounting for damages and
loss of profits. A preliminary injunction was re-
fused, and on appeal the ruling was affirmed with-
out prejudice on final hearing (222 Fed. 918).

The object of the patent in controversy is a pump-
ing apparatus for use with a rotary pump in a
drilled well, designed primarily for irrigation pur-

~— Soa Gy ah at ie EAR POY AH
Lee ht ata A SRR ANID NOEL MRI TRIE TENT RIAA “'

1008 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

poses. The invention claimed is not in the pump it-
self, but in the apparatus for the protection, lubri-
cation and alignment of the revolving shaft through
which the power is transmitted from the surface of
the ground to the blades of the pump near the bot-
tom of the well. From this rotary or centrifugal
pump, a pipe for discharging the water leads to the
ground, and this pipe and the shaft from a point im-
mediately above the pump are inclosed in a metal
easing extending from the pump casing to the sur-
face.

In this shaft casing bearings spaced about six
feet apart, and at each end, where the shaft passes
out of the casing, the specifications of the patent
call for an air tight packing box. This packing
box, however, has long since been abandoned and a
sleeve bearing, or bushing, is used in its place. The
shaft is oiled at the end above ground, and the oil
passes from bearing to bearing on down to the
end of the shaft where it escapes through the last
sleeve bearing or bushing, the clearance between
the shaft and the bushing being sufficient to permit
the passage of the oil. The patent originally pro-
vided a method of forcing the oil out of the eas-
ing from time to time by air pressure, but this is
not found necessary in actual use, since the sub-
stitution of the bushing for the packing box. The
effect of the constant feeding of oil during the
operation of the pump is to cause a pool to collect
above each of the bearings and the pressure of this
head of oil through the bearings and the bushing
at the bottom of the shaft keeps the water from

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 1009

entering. Thus, the casing is practically a closed
one against the entrance of dirt and sand which
would cut and wear out the bearings. These bear-
ings further serve the purpose of holding in a
straight line the shaft which otherwise would have
a tendency to bore out, or whip, when revolving at
high speed. These functions of the apparatus,
lubrication, protection and alignment, it is claimed,
are infringed by similar construction in the Getty
pump. The specifications covering the features of
the patent alleged to have been infringed are num-
bers 9 and 20, which read as follows:

**9. In well mechanism the combination with
a pump casing, of a rotary pump, of a joined
pump shaft and a closed casing surrounding
the pump shaft from the pump to the top of
the well.

20. The combination of a well casing, a
rotary pump therein, and a line shaft for the

pump entirely closed off from the water in the
well.”’

These two specifications, as held by the Court of
Appeals in Van Ness vs. Layne (213 Fed. 804), are
in effect the same, the only difference being that
in number 9, a jointed shaft is called for. No in-
fringement, however, is claimed because of defend-
ant’s use of a jointed shaft. Consequently, the two
specifications may be regarded as one and the same.

The defendant in answer first denies the validity
of the patent, anc second, denies, if the patent is
valid, that the Getty pump is an infringement. It
is claimed by defendant that several prior inven-

1010 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

tions, and particularly the Crannel pump, patented
several yeats before the Layne pump, embraced
substantially the same features as Layne’s patent,
and so anticipated the latter.

In the suit of Layne vs. El Campo Machine Com-
pany, from the Southern District of Texas (195
Fed. 83), involving this patent, the Circuit Court
of Appeals, Fifth Circuit, modified the decree of
the lower court sustaining the validity of claims
9, 13, 20 and others of the patent, by striking out
the finding of infringement as to all of the claims
except 18. The validity of claims 9 and 20 was
not passed on, but these claims were held not to have
been infringd.

Subsequently, in the case of Layne vs. Van Ness,
this court sustained the validity of claims 9 and 20
and held them infringed by the Van Ness pump.
The decree was affirmed by the Court of Appeals
(213 Fed. 804). The contention in the Van Ness
case, as in the case at bar, was that claims 9 and 20
of the Layne patent were invalid, having been in
effect, covered and anticipated by the Crannel
pump, previously patented.

The Crannel apparatus, which was not a com-
mercial success, provided for a closed casing around
the shaft transmitting power to a rotary pump,
but did not provide intermediate bearings along the
line of the shaft. This absence of intermediate
bearings is practically the only difference in prin-
ciple between the two mechanisms in so far as
claims 9 and 20 are concerned. It is urged by the
defendant that the adding of intermediate bearings

1

WR de Ante ee |
ue

:
:
vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 1011
to prevent the shaft from whipping does not in-
volve invention; that it is something that would
occur to anyone skilled in the art, and that, like-
wise, the method of oiling by letting the oil run
down from bearing to bearing, would occur to any-
one, and had always been the method of oiling
vertical shafts.

The Court is much impressed with this argument.
The insertion of additional bearings to prevent
whipping of the shaft where the distance between
bearings is too great, is as simple and natural a
thing to do as the putting in a fence of extra posts
to prevent sagging of a barbed wire, where the
posts of the panels are too far apart. Were the ‘
question a new one, I should be inclined to hold the
patent invalid, but the same issue was raised and

i
=
;
f

PIPES FR

PRM SVX

directly passed on by this Court and by the Court F
of Appeals for this circuit, in the Van Ness ease :
sustaining the patent. :

It is contended by the defendant herein that the ‘

evidence in the Van Ness case was to the effect that
the Crannel pump would not work, whereas, by
physical demonstration on the trial of this case, the
contrary was shown, and the court therefore should
not feel bound by the ruling in the Van Ness case.
The opinion in the Van Ness case, however, does

PEPER GS TOI NE PINT IO LY 8

not appear to have been based on the evidence that ;
the Crannel patent would not work. The Court
held:

‘1. It seems quite clear that the idea of a
protected casing of a pump shaft without re-
strictive interpretation would contain no

ae ol «

1012

Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

novelty and would not be patentable, and, if
this element in the patent is given the unre-
stricted meaning that its language admits of,
it would destroy the claim. The contention of
the defendant is that it should be given the
unrestricted generic meaning suggested by its
broad language, and that of complainant, that
the specifications should be looked to to inter-
pret the claim, and that it should be held to
mean only a protective casing of the kind and
with the functions set out in the specifications.
It seems that the complainant’s contention is
supported by the authorities cited in his sup-
plemental memorandum and that the argument
that the patent granted by the Government
should be construed so as to prevail rather
than be forfeited, since that must have been
the intention of the Patent Office, is a sound
one, for limiting the breadth of the language
of the claim to the disclosure of the specifiea-
tions of the patent, if necessary to sustain the
patent. If so limited, it would seem that the
protective casing intended to be covered by
the claim was one of the kind described in the
specifications and having the three functions
attributed to it by the specifications, namely:
(1) To exclude water and detritus from the
shaft and its bearings; (2) to provide a means
of lubricating the bearings of each section of
the shaft from the top of the well without re-
moving the apparatus from it; and (3) to align
the bearings and the shaft so as to prevent

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 1013

lateral displacement in the well and keep the
shaft in a vertical position.

2. Giving the claim this significance, it
fairly appears from the record, as we see it,
that there was no protective casing in the
prior art of the kind and with the functions of
that of the patent in suit. It also seems fairly
to appear from the record that such a pro-
tective casing as that set out in the specifica-
tions contained novelty enough to constitute in-
vention, ”’

Accepting the view of the Court of Appeals as to
the validity of the patent, there is left only the
question of infringement. The structure of the
Getty pump consists of a shaft with casing held in
alignment by bearings and connected with a rotary
pump resting on the bottom of the well. The shaft
is oiled in practically the same manner as the Layne
pump shaft, the oil passing on down the line of the
shaft from bearing to bearing and past the last
sleeve bearing to the outside. The chief difference
urged is that the shaft casing in the Getty ap-
paratus, is not entirely closed; that no packing box
is used, as provided in the Layne patent; and,
therefore, that there is no infringement. While it
is true that water might ordinarily pass up between
the bushing or sleeve bearing, and the shaft while
the pump is not in action, when it is in operation,
and the oil is being constantly fed in at the top of
the shaft, the weight of the column of oil pressing
downward between the shaft and the bushing,
would keep the water out, just as in the case of the

rote ae:

ExSe

SS IEY OPS I ORR ret pete RA au HEE

ae Se

er ray

ne

a en , ae
Kg

1014 Western Well Works, Ine., et al.

Layne pump, except in small quantities. The same
contention was thus disposed of in the Van Ness
Case:

‘If the idea is considered patentable, the last
question is whether the defendant’s pump in-
fringes; that is, whether his pump contains the
element of a closed shaft casing in the sense to
be attributed to that element in the claim of
the patent in suit, i. e., one of a kind described
in the specifications of the patent and having
the same three functions. The defendant denies
that his pump shaft casing performs any one
of the three functions attributed to that of the
patent in suit. He denies that it is a closed
casing in any true sense. It seems not to be
closed so far as concerns the entrance of air.
However, the proper interpretation of the
words ‘closed casing’ is a closure only against
What is necessary to be excluded for the sue-
cessful operation of the invention, and_ that,
in this case, as we understand it, is water and
sand, because when not excluded the first cor-
rodes and the second wears the shaft and _ its
bearings. It seems also true that the closure
against water is only partial, since the lower
bearing of defendant’s apparatus is not within
the inclosing casing, though the intermediate
and top bearings are. So it seems doubtful
whether the defendant's pump casing keeps the
water from the shaft and bearings when it is
not in operation, and the argument is that in
the rice country, where it is principally used,

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 1015

it remains out of service nine months of the
year. For these reasons, it is argued that the
defendant's ‘asing is not a closed one, even
against water and sand. However, the record
shows that protection against water and sand
is afforded by defendant's ‘asing to all but
one of the bearings and to the shaft in the
same degree as by that of the patented casing,
at least during the period of the pump’s opera-
tion, and that the protection afforded by de-
fendant’s casing is different only in degree
from that afforded by the patented casing.
The closure in the patented casing is effected
by stuffing boxes as well as by the presence and
downward pressure of the oil between the bear-
ings and the shaft, which serves to keep the
Water from pressing upward into the shaft
casing between the bearings and the shaft. The
closure in defendant’s casing is effected by the
last method only, and Without the use of pack-
ing or stuffing boxes. Each ‘asing serves to
affect at least a partial closure against the
water and sand. The difference is one of
method and degree only, and for that reason it
seems that the defendant’s casing infringes
this element of the patent, at least to some ex-
tent.”’

5 LAGAN SRON A RR NEN REISS > tps th SE

a

POE a en ener sanse eS ew

TRE fe Gar RPA IES IS. rar

Ca

There is this difference between the Van Ness
and the Getty apparatus. In the former the Weight
of the shaft is largely sustained by a thrust bear-
ing near the bottom of the casing, so that the pres-
sure on the thrust bearing would tend to make

1016 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

the casing nearer water proof. In the Getty ap-
paratus, which rests on the bottom of the well, there
are no thrust bearings, but all the bearings are of
the ordinary kind, so that, as argued by counsel,
more water would pass into the shaft casing of the
Getty pump than into that of the Van Ness pump.
Each casing, however, as was said by the Court of
Appeals in comparing the Van Ness and the Layne
casing, ‘‘serves to affect at least a partial closure
against the water and sand. The difference is one
of method and degree only.’’

As stated by the Court in the Van Ness case, the
questions both as to patentability and infringe-
ment are close ones. The evidence on the first ques-
tion is practically the same in the case at bar as in
the Van Ness case, and on the second question, I
think there is no substantial difference in the
features of the Van Ness and Getty pumping ap-
paratus as to which infringement is claimed.

Following the ruling in the Van Ness ease, speci-
fications numbers 9 and 20 must be held to be valid
and to be infringed by defendant’s pump.

A decree will therefore be entered ordering an
injunction as prayed for and an accounting for
damages and loss of profits.

GEO. WHITFIELD JACK,
Judge.

[ Endorsed]: No. 925. U. 8S. Dist. Court, West.
Dist. of La. M. E. Layne et al. vs. Fred I. Getty.
Opinion of Court. Filed Feb. 15, 1919, 11:22 A. M.
W. B. Lee, Clerk, U. S. District Court, West. Dist.
of Louisiana.

- ee ee

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 1017

CERTIFICATE OF CLERK OF COURT.

United States District Court, Western District of
Louisiana.

Clerk’s Office:

I, W. B. Lee, Clerk of the United States District
Court for the Western District of Louisiana, do
hereby certify that the foregoing seven pages, num-
bered from one to seven, inclusive, contain a true,
full and correct copy of opinion of court in a
cause entitled Mahlon E. Layne et al., versus Fred
I. Getty, No. 925 on the docket of said court, as the
original of same appears on file in this office.

WITNESS my hand and seal of office, at the
City of Shreveport, Louisiana, on this the 12th day
of March, A. D. 1919,

[Seal] W. B. LEE,
Clerk United States District Court for the Western

District of Louisiana.

[Endorsed]: No. 925. United States District
Court, Western District of Louisiana. Mahlon E.
Layne et al. vs. Fred I. Getty. Opinion of Court.
Copy Certified Under Seal. Filed Feb. 15, 1919,
11:22 A.M. W.B. Lee, Clerk United States Dis-
trict Court, for the Western District of Louisiana.

No. 485—Eq. Defts. Exhibit “E.”’ Filed Sept.
3, 1920. W. B. Maling, Clerk, By J. A. Schaert-
zer, Deputy Clerk.

No. 3627. United States Circuit Court of Ap-
Peals for the Ninth Circuit. Filed Jan. 6, 1921.
F. D. Monckton, Clerk,

1018 Western Well Works, Inc., et al.

Defendants’ Exhibit ‘‘F.’’

[Endorsed]: No. 485—Eq. Layne & Bowler
Corpn. vs. Western Well Wks. et al. Defts. Exhibit
“FR.”? Filed Sept. 3, 1920. W. B. Maling, Clerk.
By J. A. Schaertzer, Deputy Clerk.

No. 3627. United States Circuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Ninth Cireuit. Filed Jan. 6, 1921. F.
D. Monckton, Clerk.

+

vs. Layne & Bowler Corporation. 1019

(No Model.) S. N. EISLER.
ROTARY PUMP.

No. 522,518. Patented July 3, 1894.

x

Sig 5.

Uuacsses Suvenror.
Crd Ad/. 5 Whew i sher.

Ao Seirek. Hester

Attorney,

STEPHEN N.

To all whom it may concern:

Be it known that 1, STEPHEN N. EISLER, @

citizen of the United States, residing at New
Orleans, in the parish of Orleans and State of
Louisiana, have invented certain new and use-
ful Improvements in Rotary Pumps; and I do
hereby declare that the following is a full,
clear, and exact description of the same, refer-
ence being had to the annexed drawings, mak-
ing a part of this specification, and to the let-
ters and figures of reference marked thereon.
My invention relates to certain improve-
ments in rotary pumps, and has for its ob-
jects to provide a novel construction and com-
bination of parts whereby the forcing of the
water upward to the point of delivery is in-
sured, and to provide novel means for oiling
or lubricating the parts of the structure w ith-
out dismemberment and while in operation.
To these ends my said invention consists in
the novel construction and combination or ar-
rangement of parts hereinafter deseribed and
claimed, reference being made to the accom-
panying drawings, in which—
Figure 1, is a vertical section of a pump
constructed in accordance with my invention.
Fig. 2, is a bottom plan view of the lift and
force piston. Fig. 3, is a top plan view of the
same, and Fig. 4, is a sectional view, taken on
the line r—z, the piston being shown in dot-
ted lines.

In the said drawings, the letter A, indicates
the pump-casing or framing, which is com-
posed of a bottom or base-piece 12, from the

5 four corners of which rise standards or beams

0

5

0

6, secured to which are interior and exterior
walls 4 and 7, which are separated from each
other to provide water-passage-ways or con-
duits 3, of which four are shown in the draw-
ings, (see Fig. 4.) The interior walls 4, ex-
tend upward beyond the exterior walls 7, as in
Fig. 1, to prevent the water passing up the
conduit 3 from overflowing into the interior
of the casing or framing A.

Secured to the exterior walls 7, at or near
their top edges is a trough 5, of which there
may be four, one to receive the water flowing
from each conduit or passage 3, or one con-
tinuous trough extending around the casing
A may be provided. This trough or troughs
receive the water from the conduits 3, and

EISLER, OF NEW ORLEANS, LOUISIANA, ASSIGNOR
ONE-HALF TO JOHN D. BELTON AND SHAKESPEAR & SWOOP,
OF SAME PLACE,

ROTARY PUMP.

Western Well Works, Inc., et al.
UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE.

OF

SPECIFICATION forming part of Letters Patent No. 522,518, dated July 3, 1894.
Application filed June 15, 1893. Serial No. 477,745.

(No model.)

may be suitably connected with means of cor-
veyance, (not shown herein and forming no
part of the invention,) for carrying the wate
to any desired point of use.

The numeral 24, designates a shaft verti-
cally arranged within the pump-casing A, At
its lower end, this shaft rests upon a ste
plate 13, set into the base-piece 12, and r
volves or rotates in a bearing 14. — ‘

A collar or cap 15 is seeured by a set-serer
to the shaft 24, and lies upon the top edge of
the bearing 14, preventing the access of sani
or other foreign matter to the bearing of the
shaft. The shaft is supported and steadied
laterally by floors or partitions 8, 9 and 10,
arranged at suitable intervals vertically, and
provided with openings through which the
shaft 24 passes, and bearings 19 and 23, ar
ranged in connection with the floors or parti-'
tions 8 and 9. In order to retain the shaft
in proper vertical position for operation and
prevent any vertical movement which might
otherwise be induced by the work performed,
I firmly secure collars 20 and 22, to the shaft’
by set screws said collars being arranged in
contact with the bearings 19 and 23, as showa
in the drawings, one of said collars being ar
ranged above the bearing 19, and the other
below the bearing 23; in this manner it wil
be seen that the shaft is prevented from any
vertical displacement or movement.

In prior pumping-apparatus it has been i
ficult and inconvenient to lubricate the bear
ings of the propelling shaft, since it was e&
sential that parts of the structure be remove
for that purpose. By my invention, I avoil
the inconvenience and provide a novel lubr:
eating means by which the shaft-bearing
can be lubricated automatically so long as the
supply of oil lasts, and whereby oil ean be
supplied without dismemberment of the ap
paratus, said means consisting of a vertical
pipe 26, arranged interiorly of the pump-ta*
ing as shown and communieating at its up
per end with the outlet of an oil supply
cup 25,

_Branch pipes 27 extend from the vertied
pipe 26 and lead to the shaft-bearings 14, IS
19 and 22, so that the oil or lubricant is a
tomatically fed to said bearings. The 0
supply-cup 25 is arranged so that oil can b

placed therein without taking apart the cas-
ug or any of the supports of the shaft.

A water-inlet opening 1, is provided at the
bottom of the casing A, which extends on all
sides of said casing, and extending inwardly
in said casing immediately over said opening
is an intercepting-plate la, above which an
opening 2, is provided in the inner wall 4,
of the casing, leading to the passage or con-
duit 3.

The numeral 17, designates a combined lift
and force piston which is secured to the shaft
4, so as to rotate therewith, by means of a
st screw, or in any other suitable manner
aid piston being located in the compartment
formed by the partition 10 and the intercept-
, the form thereof being illus-
. 2 and 3, wherein it is shown
asa solid piece of material, the periphery or
alge being shaped or formed into a series of
inlined pushing surfaces 17a, The shaft 24
is rotated by means of a belt (not shown),
tuning upon the pulley 21, and driven from
any suitable source

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386005_0222%3A3. Public record. Not legal advice.
