# Transcript of Record — New York v. New Jersey

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386004_0506%3A13

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1921
- **Citation:** 256 U.S. 296

## Text

Comtaapria iesetet = ba bebbeit

No, 3, Original

ANTS

v2

tenA MP TN

INDEX

Mewarapier « repent ef a putt henring
ghem be the New York arte Iie
Theeerd. Deewenber & Tim

ltieqerrt of New Vork Bay ollation (ve
mieeion te Then. Prank Wayland Wie
gies. tervrotnet, March 31, 4

itt map of New York farixe wl
vietwity

eget of New York May Pollation (om
mieten te Hen. Frank Wayland Hig
gins, teerwetner. Aprll a Tie

May eee

May

Map

May

Jew & Trerweee (iec.), Parowrens, Waentweres, 1. C.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,

OCTOBER TERM, 1916

THE PROCLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK. COMPLAIN

STATE OF NEW JERSEY ANT) PASSAIC VALLEY SEWER
Vr COMMIs=lo NERS. DEFENDANTS

lage

iSereN.

t-pdetnat ttegrem ef bering deview for

pf fetll
Nie
HH
:
;

Fa

i
FE
z
a
|
z
i

Bd ATH
Hr wt Hk 7 rt Sqrezeay ePLts ist

+ ait eagle) Han bit Ha 3
5 Sar tee ul igs al Z a
BRTRERHITHAL Tesh aa pin 1 tt
- iit yaad ney T 382.2 Fs Tk pease fs
; gif? i beh Ute oH 4 tiaee ytd #
HG patties Hani aidhiqunats a
ay SH MS Herat Wa eta Bit ats
agit uf fart aie yiniinl Le
bps Hi erths ani a TURE Ae
Te ee iM i
Piet. Wye Poe alii
siedadest i H. tte ard

THE #TATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 291%

ant within their territory, and I do not blame them. I

any sensible man for not wishing to have it. This
territory ix Wuilding up; % thiesly populated, as are all
territories around New York City. In order to take care
« water—thix sewage, our opinion ix that it will require one
acres, and if #% was all taken care of by one plant, which
would be the sensible way, if that way wa* adopted, we
should have to take out of the area of City of Newark,
one thousand acres, Now, Newark has about eleven thou-
In the Southern district of Newark ix the great manu-
commercial city. The meadows at Newark which,
were looked on a= almost valucles, are now very
developments in the Newark Meadows in the wa
interests now amounts to hundreds « Penden |
might say, millions a year, and the future develop-
tremendous in their pow! ilities; they are increasing how
’ to are generally
expected will arveunt to many millions more. And the potenti-

ihe
j2

it

te
i ;
:
se
t

|

a

commercial land of the City of Newark, and, two miles away, is
art of Jersey City, and with Southwest winds, Jersey City
get the benefit of the -prinkling filters, and with Southeast
the City of Newark would get the benefit of the -prinkling
‘and, another ment important point, in my idea is, that you
will not find a «wage diqperal plant anywhere but what the
thes are innumeraide and 1 de, millions of flies, and,
with our present knowledge of sanitary affairs, we know that
eormous quantities of flies would be dangerous in the vicinity of

—, The only City that hax tried that on a large
i in. and Kerlin has fifteen hundred acres of sandy land
sewage diqural plant they do things differently in Ger-

_ Ruffner: Did you say fifteen thousand acres?
” Harrison. Fifteen hundred acres; that ix, one thousand acres
the city, and public lands in the vieinity—the —_ land«

in
but
great hartors of the world, they have not there the
waters we have here: the City of Merlin ix far from the
and there was nothing ele to be done, and even there, no

not a scholar, would be proud of the sewage dis

2914 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE 9F NEW YORK VS.

Now, to cure this evil, this Commission, after a thorough study
and after a number of the brightest of all our engineers have de
termined that the best disposition was the natural, first, disposal,
due to our situation and to our being part of the harbor of New
York, and to the magnificent advantage which this whole metro-
politan district has, with the large tlow of water and plenty of it,

tv take care of this project with safety, we finally decided
22 that the only, best, most economical and also the method

in the line of improvement, future improvement, was to
follow out somewhat the Boston method, somewhat the London
method, somewhat more the Boston method, and with improve
ments,

Now, we propose to take that sewage down to the shore of Newark
Bay, and there pass it through screens and sediment chambers,
settling chambers, and remove from the sewage the heavy grit,
all the floating particles, and, ax vou will perceive by our specifica-
ions which you bave before vou, we do not say just how much will
be removed; we say “all that is necessary or shall be necessary”
shall be removed, so that there will be no danger of an offense aris-
ing in the outlet.

Now, there is no question that we can do that. The City of
Hamburg does it, there, with a population of over one million.
They pass the sewage through a house there, through a house with
settling chambers—over screens—the City of Hamburg passes the
sewage through screens, then out into a settling tank or chamber
eighty feet wide by thirty feet deep, after it passes through this
chamber it passes through six sediment tanks, thence into tow-
boats, for the sediment, and then discharged into the middle of the
river, and the whole river traflic of the City, the ferrvhoat traffic
and general river traflic passes over it; the main ferry station cro-es
the river, and excursion boat traffic with a station right over in
front of the pump house and wharves in front of the pump house,

and the Hamburg-American Line docks, about a mile or two
23 below, are right in the track of this sewer, and you cannot
tell there is any sewer in there at all. The River Elbe—

Col. Ruffner: What is the rise and fall of the tide there?

Mr. Harrison: They have a rise and fall of about eight or ten
feet, the result being that in order to save pumping they made their
sewer so large, with their tide locks, that for feur hours each tide
the sewage flows up inside and filly up this very large sewer, much
larger than ordinary, and they have, from my own knowledge, a
great advantage. in the rise and fall of the tide, over what we have
on our low level—we do not think it a great advantage, but they
do that because it saves pumping, and then the gates open auto
matically, as the tide goes down and the flow goes out, there has been
an accumulation by the intercepting of the flow, causing the sewage
to back up in the sewer, which was made larger for this very purpose,
which results in this sewage being locked into the large main sewer
during the flood tide, so that practically sixteen hours’ stuff has to be
cared for on the ebb. Our project proposes a very large improve
ment over this method, as they have to provide for the accumulation

__

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2915

and have made the sewer larger than ordinary for the purpose ; while
we, however, will not have to hold this tide locked sewage. We im-
prove a great deal, | think, on that; they have a very coarse screen,
and the Hamburg sewage is heavy, is very heavy, it is very strong,
probably twice ax strong as the sewage in the vicinity of New York
or in any of our cities.
24 Now, there has been a great misapprehension as to the
amount of sewage—or a great misunderstanding, at least, as
to the ammount we propose to put into this trunk outlet sewer,

Now, I want to say to the Commission that the people of the Pas-
saie Valley are no different than the people of the City of New York,
and they do not furnish any more sewage per head than the people
of New York; and this mistake may have arisen from the fact that a
figure has heen used in our descriptions, and in all good faith, fixing
the maximum capacity of the sewer at 360,000,000 gallons per day
ultimately ; that is the ultimate capacity of the sewer, built to take
for four or five or six hours, the peak capacity, the peak of the
quantity of stuff which must pass through it; you all realize that at
certain times of the day the flow of the sewage is much greater than
at other times of the day of twenty-four hours, as in every com-
munity the same rule answers; now this figure is fixed as the peak of
the flow, the maximum capacity of the sewer, three hundred and
sixty million gallons; but the average capwaity of discharge to-day
is nearly—the average maximum discharge is only about two-thirds
of that. or two hundred and fifty million gallons, and that is a
capacity or average which we estimate will be effective around 1940;
that. in other words, is the ultimate capacity. That will include,
under the law under which we are acting, the house sewerage, a
certain amount of ground water which cannot possibly be kept out
of the sewer, and not more than ten per cent, of the trade waste, and
when I say trade waste, 1 mean the total effluence from factories,

much of it being clear water; the idea being that the operat-
vz) ing of this sewer in a separate system, which is required in all

communities, at tin.es. the factory waste will be treated, as it
is being treated at the present time and particularly as treated in
other communities, and reduced by this treatment so that ninety per
cent, of the water will pass right into the river, which, of course, will
not injure the river at all. T believe, from our investigation—there
have been investigations made in Paterson, N. J., by Mr. Hazen,
there is no trouble about doing this; there is no difficulty whatever
to do this.

Now, the present discharge is seventy million gallons of sewage;
the maximuin will be two hundred and fifty million gallons, and not
two hundred and fifty million gallons of standard sewage, because
the standard sewage — that will be the sewage from aboutone million
and a half of people and the standard sewage of one and a half mil-
lions people would not be over one and a half millions gallons, and an
additional one hundred millions would be made up of a large
amount of ground water, and it is very necessary that there should
bea large allowance made, because the Eastward slope of the Orange

2916 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

mountains is of gravelly formation and contains enormous quanti-
ties of underground water.

Now, after this sewage is pumped up, it is sedimented and passed
through screens, passed through a settling chamber, and then we pro
pose to send it through a twelve foot channel running under this

head, under pressure, the top of the tunnel being thirty feet be-
26 low mean high water; now, when | say not less than thirty feet,

I mean, if it should be determined that we will go some twenty-
eight or thirty feet below mean high water, it will be in the rock bed,
in case you want to dredge where T call the Jersey Flats, the Jersey
City flats, it will be in the rock bed, and hence no interference with
navigation

Col. Ruffner: What will be the depth of the top part of the sewer
below mean high water as it cro-ses the Bay down there?

Mr. Harrison: The top line of the sewer will be below the water
line—will be at an elevation minus fifty feet below; it must be re-
member- that in addition the -ewer is twelve feet, lying on the bed
of the Bay, or if it have a range from twelve to fourteen fect at the
outfall, we might say thirty-six feet below low water———

Col. Knight: Below low water?

Mr. Harrison: Below high water. The plan was based on the
idea that the requirements would not be over thirty feet below high
water in the rock bed in Newark Bay——

Col. Knight: In the Bay?

Mr. Harrison: Yes: in the Bay, and also on the Jersey Flats be
tween Robbins Reef and the Jersey shore; the Pennsylvania dredge is
about twenty-five feet, the foundation for the new Pennsylvania
yards is about twenty-five to thirty feet. Now, we probably will
put that down even lower; the question of whether that tunnel in
place shall be minus fifty feet or minus sixty feet has very little bear-

ing upon the case. We may be able to find the rock and
27 follow it throughout the Bay by going down a few feet more.

What we look for is a way for the tunnel: if the course can
be better had down ten feet below minus fifty, I do not think there
will be involved much more expense for the shaft, allowing us to
keep within the shaft—there will only be required a little more
pressure there with the air: if we have to use air; T don’t expect to
have to use air only for a very shore distance there.

Now, when we bring that out to Robbins Reef, where. in the
vicinity of the light house there ix now about, by our chart, five or six
feet of water at low water, that is nine or ten feet at high water; and
there,—or about there (indicating on map) we ask you for a shaft,
and we ask you for the right to establish a tank or gate house 10
which we can control the flow from the tunnel into the discharge
pipes although it is probably not absolutely necessary that we should
have that; but it would be better for the project, better for the United
States Government, better for all interests that there should be some
thing there where the flow of these pipes could be controlled, and in
order that they could be controlled in the flow; we would then be able
to throw a larger velocity through any one of the pipes or in all

“or , . Nea . . - . ’ Pee e/

Sims oS ned Pag oh BO AR te te el

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2917

them for cleaning out and scouring; also, in case of a repair to a pipe,
we would be able to shut it off there without going into diver work.
You already have an obstruction to navigation on that reef; a
Light House; the Reef was deeded by the State of New Jersey
Is to the United States, during the administration of Governor
McClellan and the United States holds it for light house pur-
wes; the State reserved in the deed the right of reversion if case it
dhould be abandoned for lighthouse purposes and any use for any
ther purpores.
Of course, the Commission acts under authority of the State, and
have the right to the use of any such reversionary interest of the
State or rights of the State in any way. Now, | am well aware, the
Commission is well aware, that probably the question of the location
of this building-——this structure is a small, common structure, archi-
wturally— as it is contemplated to put upon this rock as a shaft
and pump house—we know that the question of its location there
m that reservation does not, | believe lie with the War Department,
wat that the final location would probably lie, we understand, with
the Department of Commerce and Labor and as that Department
requires; but the question of obstruction comes to you; that is the
rason we apply to the War Department,—in regard to the obstrue-
tion, Now, if the Department of Commerce and Labor don't see
it—we think it should be as near the light house as possible,—in
fact, my own opinion is that if we put upa proper kind of a strueture
the upper part of it could be used for light-house purposes instead
ff the small light house there as it is—the light-house there now is
forty feet above high water; but, if the Department of Commerce
{ Labor don’t consider that a proper place to put it, three hundred
ind fifty feet from the light-house we are in the lands of the State
of New Jersey, and, therefore, we ask you for the right to put
% it there on the same reef, about the same height or elevation,
about the same part of the rock—we ask a right to put our
hhaft there.
Now, from this shaft and from this gate-house, which is prae-
tially the end of the tunnel, we propose to extend into the dis-
inbuting ground, a series of perhaps four, we will say, four hundred
four foot pipes; they will be rivetted; they may be rivetted steel,
may be cast iron.—but we are not determined vet what will be the
‘est use. They will. of course, have flexible | vints. They will be
aid in a shallow trench on the bed of the Bay. They will extend
mt toa depth of forty feet where there is water forty feet deep, on
iforty foot paral-el/ line vertically below high water, and there we
ull commence to allow the sewage to go out, and we propose then
® diminish the pipes across the channel, or into the channel, all
"thin the limits of the State of New Jersey, sloping the fall of
the pipes from 40 to 60 or 70 feet, and we propose to have openings
these pipes, in the several pipes, perhaps fifty or sixty openings,
as many as may be necessary, and the pipes, with these open-
ings, will he distributed over as large an area as necessary so that
wery part of this filtered sewage, as it comes out from the pipes,
Mill almost immediately be diluted with a proper proportion of Bay
Ex. No. 1——2

2918 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

water in order that the sewage may be thoroughly dispersed and
that there shall be no offensive conditions arising.

Col. Knight: Do ! understand that those pipes that you say you

will have come down a slope—when you speak about sloping,
30 do you mean that the pipes will slope downward from the

mouth of the tunnel for the length of the pipes, which you
say is to be about 400 feet?

Mr. Harrison: When I spoke of sloping down, I referred to hav-
ing the pipes slope downward toward the bottom of the bay, from
a depth of forty feet to a depth of perhaps seventy feet, depending
on the depth of the water.

Col. Knight: You propose to continue the pipes down to a depth
of seventy feet, on a slope?

Mr. Harrison: They will be put at a depth of forty feet, and sl
downward, with the several openings so distributed as to prc
best results in dispersion.

Now we do not limit ourselves in our specifications as to the prac-
tieal plans; we do not limit ourselves, nor in the contracts whieh
will be made with the municipalities under the law to how much
that area of distribution will be or how many pipes may be necessary
or how many openings may be necessary; we say we will give as
many openings and over ax wide a distributing area so that the
volume of water in the Bay, flowing from forty feet to seventy feet
deep will be sufficient to dilute the sewage as quickly as it comes
and we put it out in small units to mix it at once with the water
of the Bay. There we get the ideal practice. We get a great volume
of water in the New York Bay: the great trouble in all sewage s¥*
tems is the need of mixing quickly the sewage with the diluting

water.—the oxidizing water. Now, in regard to that thing,
31 1 want to give a few figures which are the result of our it-

vestigation and on which we base part of our argument; we
believe and we know that they are correct.

And. first, IT want to remind the Commission that the standard —
of dilution for Chicago was one to twenty; one part of sewage to —
twenty parts of lake water passing through ; that 1s the standard,—
one to twenty, or one unit—or four cubic feet per second of flow
for each one thousand people—the ratio of the diluting water as to
the population for the sewage——

Col. Knight: One moment; is the character of the Chicago sewage
that you are going to refer to now, of the same character as will
come from your effluence there?

Mr. Harrison: Well, leaving out the stock yards sewage, the
character of the Chicago sewage is much stronger, as much of it is
not screened

Col, Knight: That is what I wanted to develop.

Mr. Harrison: Let me say, in regard to the screening proposed, —
from the very best authorities when we have screened sewage and
when we have deposited we have thus reduced its pollution—its
powers of pollution—power of offense so that the oxygen required to
entirely destroy it is fifty-eight per cent of the normal ; that is, if it
takes one hundred per cent. of oxygen—that quantity of oxyget io

ete sg aga MEY ate
VINE LEE A RE EER ERI eS yey 9S art ne “e ——

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2919

destroy the power of pollution of ordinary sewage, screened sewage,
in the way we propose to put it through, as sedimented sewage, it is
about 58 or 58 and a half—fifty-eight and a half per cent. of
32 oxygen will do it; that is, we practically take out about forty
per cent of the putrifying substance. I give that on the
wthority of the English Royal Commission, Hall and Gibson,
wthorities on the subject.

Now, we will say that Chicago is as one to twenty ;—Milwaukee
is one to twenty-six,—in the improvement of the Milwaukee River.
In the English Royal Commission, the result of their experiments
dow, ax applied to American sewage, that it seems to be that the
dilution of one part of sewage with fifty parts of ocean water—
Bay water—salt water—sea water-—one to fifty, with absolutely no
knowledge whatever that anything was being put into the water—
I mean that the sewage may be taken care of with no knowledge
w the senses or to the observation that it was going into the water
tall. 1 only give this as a sort of measure or scale by which to
igure the figures we propose to give further on.

Now, from experiments we have made, only one or two, one
thich 1 happened to have right at my hand last night, an ex-
yriment made at ebb tide at Robbins Reef, in the Summer: we
found at the surface eighty-eight and five-tenths per cent. of the
normal quantity of oxygen in the Bay; that is, that the pollution
frst of the whole of New York, the whole of New York island,
the City of New York, the pollution coming through the Kills
ind mingling with the waters of the Bay had not cut that oxygen
down only eleven and a half per cent. Now the authorities are
ill agreed that water, as long as the oxygen is not cut more than

fifty per cent. the sewage can be put into the river water
% without offence to be taken care of. Of course, I am not

making that as a statement of fact. I do not want to go
wo deep into this thing; I am only stating points upon which we
base things. Now we find—at a point, you asked me in regard
to the constituents of sewage. The speaker is asked for a compre-
hensive view of this. Perhaps I am going further than should be
done. after having stated to vou, and | am willing to prove it,
that the sewage will be liquid; we propose to discharge liquid
ewage into New York Bay; sedimented and screened, and under
ection 1307 of the River and Harbor Law, liquid sewage seems
w be separated from the interdicted articles which are there legis-
lated against being thrown into the bay or into United States waters.

Now, there is a question raised that the sewage of the Passaic
Valley is particularly bad. That there is something in the sewage
of the Passaic Valley. it has been alleged. different from other
ewage: something that will rot timber, and tear out the bottoms
of ships and things of that kind. Now, these are the facts, and

. presumably, because they are so manifest on the Passaic.
Now, the facts are these: The population of the Passaic Valley
#scompared with the population of the rest of the district draining
into New York Bay is ax one to seven and six-tenths.

Col. Knight: One to seven and six-tenths?

2920 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

Mr. Harrison: Yes; to the population of the one, the population
of the other sections in this district is a= one to seven and *ix-tenths,
Now. the manufacturing establishments liable to pollute the

34 streams. | have taken from the United States Census; the
manufacturing establishments which are considered by
«ientilic men——sanitary men—as those of a class which furnish
large amounts of waste or polluting waste such as breweries, «ilk
mills, dyeing establishments, leather tanning industries—I! can give
the whole list if necessarv—any sanitary man would he able t
pick those out at once himself,—-they are in the ratio of one te
sixteen as to number,—that is, for sixteen of such establi

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2945

the way, will have to be applied to personally for privileges,
6 and I can say, personally, as representing eighteen or twenty

acres, that we will in no way interfere with the project but
hail it, and we thoroughly advocate the adoption, or, at least, the
wnsent of your Board to the privileges now sought for.

Mr. Payne: | am here, representing the Riparian Commission of
the State of New Jersey, simply in answer to the invitation of this
Board, and I have nothing to say in addition to what has been so
ably said.

The Riparian Commission is intrusted with the improvement and
ale of its riparian lands, and anything that would enhance or raise
their value is, of course, in line with their duties, and they feel sure
that the Commission in the direction of this important work, are
itending to it properly, and [ have nothing further to add.

Mr. Lebkuecher: I do not think it is necessary to call anv more
idvecates after the presentation that has already been made: there
sonly one thing T would like to add, and that is,— when this proj-
at of discharging the Passaic Vallev sewage into New York Bay
ms first brought forward by the engineers employed by the Passaic
Valley Commissioners, we, as commissioners were uncertain as to
whether that was the proper thing to do, and we were told by the
agineers and assured that it would cause no pollution whatever.

The question also came up, advanced by other people in the State,
iid the Legislature passed an Act that we should first find out, and

get the best information possible as to whether there would
% be any injury in New York Bay. by reason of this discharge,
if discharged as proposed, after screening and sedimentation,

In pursuance of that Resolution of the Legislature, the Commis-
dners got the opinion of a number of experts from the Army Board,
nd we have here (( handing the Chairman a paper) our report,
aving the opinion of General Henry M. Robert, Lieut. Col. C. W.
Raymond, and C. 8. Greene Jr., Civil Engineer, and T would like to
abmit it as accompanying our application,

If there are any questions to be asked, these gentlemen are ready
o be interrogated.

Mr. Dean: The State Commissioner of Health, Dr. Porter is here,
ind says he will have to catch a train back to Albany—

The Chairman: Dr. Soper was going to address the Board—

Dr. Soper: Mr. Chairman, if you will hear those who are down on

programme when their names are called, they can make their
rmarks—the questions might come afterwards—otherwise a num-
ler of people here | know want to go out of town and it is impos-
ible for them to come back, and they will not have an opportunity
o be heard.
Mr. Dean: It is absolutely necessary for me to ask certain ques-
tons, to cross-examine, some of these witnesses for the reason that
they have not given certain details it is necessary to have in order to
understand the nature of their application entirely—
sv Mr. Riker: IT do not think there should be a eross-examina-
tion of our witnesses; there is a litigation pending between
the State of New York and the State of New Jersey, before the Su-

2948 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Ys.

preme Court of the United © ~~
poet «, offen
af
rfl
F

24333!

TET tl fo i Witees ee aite
eigaan Li ; Hi + ' AL at
P “it } tid. a5] = 22 : 5 why ean . |
eee bine ql aL akin ee
Bi sit Hs iit i ; BHaaRRH
! lene Hite | bjigaieyts
7 : Hf Hi FE aL siethe EEE bs bere
= {: 4 ‘| est = : t= 4 #87 4 Foy: > 425s : AS
rai eel at aH
HE TE nib |
a Hinds s eestebeyeP herr i

THE #TATE OF NEW JER®RY ET AL. 2955

fom the Treaeury Department on that question relative to some-
tung along that lime——

Mr. Kiker. May I b# allowed to interrupt for a moment? Does
dw Beard propose to hear argument’ We did not understand that
the Koord would hear leyal argument——-

The (hairman We will leave that out—-

ir, Darlington We will leave that out, bat, let me say that, on
eowont of having juriediction, the Department of Health of the

City of New York would certainly exercixe the jurisdiction
™ «of the City of New York SETS
oOSe- PG LV ee 8 Teele a Ae me a ed Sint BES apes © » wi

9996 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK YS.

Dr. Jackson: The fresh water is at the very top where the sewage
is discharged into the salt water at the outfall, it boils right
190 up to the surface, and above the surface, then gradually
becomes quiescent, and the part which precipitates comes
In contact with the salt water?

Col. Knight: When you spoke of the volume, as to so many parts
in a million, the dilution was to be all by water? ‘

Dr. Jackson: All by water.

Mr. Child: May I have the privilege of presenting, as part of
the case of the petitioners, certain extracts which T have caused to
be made from the United States Coast Survey Reports?

The Chairman: Do vou wish it to form part of the record?

Mr. Child: If I may.

The Chairman: That will be done.

(The following was submitted) :

“Extracts from United States Coast Survey Reports:

In our opinion the conservation of ample channel ways at Sandy
Hook is due in some measure to the tidal circulation which the
Hell Gate entrance permits. This circulation is the life-blood of
the harbor, cleansing the channels from the silts of its rivers, as
well as from the sewerage of its cities, and even sweeping the sands
from its grand avenue to the ocean.

New York Harbor is visited by two derivations from the tide wave
of the ocean. one of which apyroaches by wav of Lone Island Sound.

the other by way of Sandy Hook entrance. These two tides
191 meet and cross or over-lap each other at Hell Gate: and since
they differ from each other in times and heights they cause
contrasts of water elevations between the Sound and the arbor,
which call into existence the violent currents that traverse the East
River.
Extract from U.S. Coast Survey 1867, pp. 158 and 159.

Two tide waves visit New York Harbor, meeting and overlapping
at Hell Gate.

(2) Near the meeting point of these two tides the observed
heights and times of the compound tide are intermediate.

(3) The currents of Hell Gate are called into existence by the
variations in the relative heights of the Sound and Harbor: their
epochs have no direct relations with those of the local tide, or its
components, and their velocities do not depend upon the local rates
of rise or fall of tide.

(4) The current flowing westward through Tel] Gate occupies a
greater section than that flowing to the eastward, because the former
prevails during higher stages of the local tide than the latter.

U.S. Coast Survey, 1867, p. 161.

Although the tidal currents of New York, especially in the East
River, appear to move to and ovo with ebb and flood in monotonous
repetition, like the swing of the pendulum, there is a net gain, under
ordinary conditions of river discharge to the westward, i. e., a perma

ef

BERR LRRD LACED AIS.
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2997

nent transfer of water from the Sound through the Harbor
192 and out into the ocean over Sandy Hook Bar. This state-

ment, if true, involves so many consequences affecting the con-
dition of the Harbor (its navigation and its improvement) that I
have put it in the form of a proposition to be demonstrated, first,
fom the most general relations of the Sound and arbor tides, as
oscillations of the sea “interfering” at Hell Gate; and second, from
a strictly inductive study of gaugings made by different observers
at different dates. I shall show that it ought to be theoretically, and
then show that it is true practically.

U.S. Coast Survey, 1886, Page 409.

The peculiar quality of the East River current as compared with
the free tidal current is that the former is a gravity stream, namely
itis water running down a slope, as in a fresh water river.

U.S. Coast Survey, 1586, Page 410,

Although the Hudson, and other rivers flow into New York Har-
tor, and slightly raise its level, the conditions illustrated in our dia-
gram are very nearly realized in the Seasons when the fre=h water
discharges at a minimum. One of these Seasons is the Autumn;
the other is mid-winter when the land waters are ice bound. At
ach times the greater velocity being westward, and the greater depth
of water being that of the westerly flow, there is, as a net result, a
dreulation of sea water through the Harbor from the Sound to the
Y\eean. Im Mid-Winter this circulation renewing the water before
itean get chilled, and lowering the freezing point by mixing sea

water with the river discharge, serves to keep the port open
1% = to commerce. One may form some estimate of the value of

the four degrees difference of the freezing points between
¥a and river waters when it is remembered that in severe Winters
Halifax, Portland and Boston have not closed before Philadelphia
weven Baltimore.

The indirect value of this influx from the Sound during the dry
Season lies in the partial supply of the underrun of sea water which
weurs when the head of the river is insufficient to counterbalance
the greater density of the sea water. We do not find this under-run
(or preponderance of inflow) at higher levels than the deepest chan-
nel beds of the har except on rare occasions; but one may easily see
that the withdrawal of the influx from the Sound would cause the
lar to rise and work inward, The fresh waters that enter from the
Hudson and other streams play an insignificant part in the physics
the Harbor: but the circulation of the sea by way of the East
River, although small in quantity, is the element which determines
the superiority of New York Harbor over nearly all the sand barred
inlets of the World. It is this cireulation which keeps the port open
in Winter and sweeps the sand from its threshhold.

U.S. Coast Survey, 1886, page 411.

The whole amount of water which flows into the New York Har-
bor in the course of each tide through the East River is sufficient of
Ex. No. 1——7

2998 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Vs.

itself to raise the water of the Harbor by one foot and one tenth,

The ebb commences two hours before the turn of the tide in
194 ~~ the East River and during these two hours the flow is toward

the East River instead of from it. Next the amount of flow
into the Harbor must be proportionately diminished and reduced to
nine tenths (.9) of a foot. Now the Harbor at high tide has four
and two tenths (4.2) more of water in it than at low tide, which
runs out during the ebb, together with the flow from the Hudson,
which is about the same as that of East River. The whole of the flow
then through the Narrows which is independent of East River, cor-
responds to five and three tenths (5.3) feet in elevation of the sur-
face of the Harbor,-and this is the amount which would run if East
River were to be ent off. The additional nine tenths (.9) of a foot
which arises from East River gives a total of six and two tenths
(6.2) feet as representing the flow through the Narrows and over the
dar. If the East River were cut off, the corresponding decrease in
the flow of water would involve a proportionate decrease in the water-
space over the bar or a reduction of the depth of water upon the bar
of about three feet and a half. Such is the measure of the impor-
tance of East River to the preservation of the entrance to New York
Harbor. The loss of this river would involve a fatal injury to the
Harbor and any obstruction to its flow or reduction of its capacity
must be proportionately injurious.

U_S. Coast Survey, 1571, Page 110.

Computations made upon the observations at different depths in
1858S gave for the discharge of the Hudson, at the close of the set
Season (Ist June), 6,088,000,000 of cubie feet, and at the
195 close of the dry season (September) 3,560,000,000, Our more
extended observation of 1S72 (October) give nearly equal in
flow and outflows amounting to 4.511,000,000, which is about the
mean of the two gaugings of IS58.) Now this added to the ebb vol-
ume of the East River, which was 4,383,000,000, gives 8,894,000,000,
If to this we add the Harbor tidal prism 17,862,000,000, (which in-
cludes Newark and Raritan Bays, and the Kills), we have 26,756,-
000,000 of cubic feet. The gauging across the mouth of the Harbor
from Sandy Hook to Coney Island gave, from observations of 1858,
an outflow of 27,663,000,000 of cubic feet, which is only about two
and one half per cent. more than the preceding computation.
* * * Without claiming that all the water which comes in
through the East River goes out over the Bar, and aids in the scour
of its channel, I think this computation authorizes us to regard
the East River stream as too important to be treated lightly.

I must add one general statement concerning a harbor with two
or more outlets. It does not follow even when such a Harbor 1s
visited by only one tide that there is a disadvantage in having more
than one pathway to the sea, on the contrary a majority of the
first class harbors of the world have several. Among sands it is not
wholly upon the strength of the current that effective scour depends.
but upon the power of these to dispose of the material advantageously.
Equal and opposite tidal currents, however strong, cannot remove

=a => = Ls 22 = at

—_— SS ea = ae FF

i

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL, 2999

the bars of our southern inlets, because in the short period of
196 six hours the very slow dune-like movement of the sand has

not carried it beyond the influence of the adverse stream
with which it works back to its old place; but where the ebb and
ood are unequal, the material is swept entirely away from the mouth
of the harbor. Now, with harbors of two outlets, it often happens
(and J speak here with plenty of observed data at my command )
that one channel is more favorably situated for discharge than the
other, so that, in effect, there is a circulation in at one door and
out at the other.

U.S. Coast Survey, 1871, Page 118-119.”

Mr. Dean: Captain Parsons, who spoke yesterday, and who was
formerly president of the Maritime Exchange, would like to add a
little further to what he said,

Captain Parsons: Mr. Chairman and Members of the Board, in
my desire to be explicit, and not occupy valuable time, | omitted
wme things that it was desired | should refer to. One of those was
the effect of the sewage upon the metal on the bottoms of wood
vesels loading in localities where the water is perceptibly polluted,
ay, for instance, that at Newtown Creek. Vessels going into New-
town Creek, and loading with oil, have frequently—with a new coat
of metal, have frequently been obliged to re-metal their vessels at
heir destination on account of the metal having been perforated by
the chesnical action of this polluted water. So much so has this pre-
vailed and to such an extent that frequently merchants in charter-

ing freight vessels to load here have excepted Newtown Creek
197 from the privileges of the parties making the charter as to
the parts of the City where vessels might be loaded.

Another was that, of the amount of expense incurred in dredging
out the piers and wharves, caused by the deposits, made annually,
n 1905, 1 must speak from memory because | have mislaid the
doument which I had secured, in 1905, over $800,000.00 was ex-
pended in dredging the slips and wharves just on account of this
deposit made from the matter contained in the water where there
was no action of tides, and this was very largely augmented by
amounts expended by private individuals and for private wharves
and piers, which must be done by themselves, in order to enable
them to receive vessels drawing a reasonable draught of water.

The question of carrying the sewage directly to sea, whieh has

Na prevalent opinion, until this matter was discussed a few years
ago, has been very conclusively proved to be an error from the fact
that the current—for instance, objects spread,—started from the
Battery, even on the first of the ebb tide, will not reach the sea,
but when in the lower bay, down within four or five or six miles of
Sandy Hook, will meet the flood tide and be deflected into the bays,
that which is further up, into the lower or Gravesend Bay, and that
in the lower bay takes a circuit and finally comes back up through

Narrows again into the lower Bay.
I referred yesterday to the filling up of channels across
1988 which the tide flowed rather than through them directly.
This, of corse, occurs where the channels are shallow, where

3000 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

they are used mostly by our smaller class of vessels and so largely
has this prevailed, that some of the anchorages used by this small
class of vessels, such as the bay into which the Gowanus canal
enters, the charter has found have been shoaled to such an extent
as to almost practically destroy their useful/ness to owners of vee
sels who have been formerly in the habit of anchoring in thos
places.

I was asked in reference to the apparent quantity of sewage in
New York Bay and in the lower Bay, out where it could be seen. I
desire to say that in my personal connection as a navigator in this
Bay and in this Harbor, that it is not much jn evidence in the stress
of the current. That part of the harbor and bay which is used by
the larger vessels it does not appear except the lighter material which
floats on the surface. 1 have seen a dead horse make excursions up
and down the river until he finally decided to locate himself some-
where along the South shore of Raritan Bay, but, ordinarily, the
sewage is not much in evidence: but it is in the water and deposits
itself along the shores. 1 have noticed upon a comparatively flat or
sloping beach that the largest amount of the deposit was at the point
of high water, but that it prevailed all the way down this sloping
beach until it reached the flat surface, diminishing in quantity, usu-

ally, that there was more of it on the surface. but that it was
199 continually settling wherever the water was not in action,

In making the statements which I] have made yesterday and
to-day, I make them, not so much as an expert as from the view-
point of a practical observer, and coming in contact with these in-
terests to which I have alluded. The questions to which I referred
vesterday, of its affecting the paint of vessels, that also shows very
plainly over the painted surface as there will be a well-defined water-
line derived from contact with the surface of the liquid around the
vessel the paint of which is light-colored enough to permit it to be
shown or which can be readily discovered even in black paint. I
believe that is all.

Col. Ruffner: | want to ask you one question, if you please:
What, if any efforts have been made by the municipal authorities
to lessen the amount of destructive material poured now by the sew-
ers into Newtown Creek, and what difference has that made?

Captain Parsons: ] know that some efforts have been made: I
know that the question has been very thoroughly discussed from
time to time but up to the present time IT know of no material im-
provement. I know that one year ago we had a vesse! of about
one thousand tons capacity that was painted white inside, that is
all her waist and houses, etc. were painted white. and she went into
Newtown Creek to load, and her captain requested me to go over and
see the vessel because she was in such fine condition. | went over
when he had been there two days, and the vessel, all her white

paint, had turned almost black and there was nothing about
200 the appearance of the vessel which would invite the inspec-

tion of one who felt any interest in her. That, I will say,
was just about one year ago,

Col. Knight: I would like to ask, in connection with your te

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY FT AL. 3001

marks about that, I would like to call your attention to this extract
from the New York Bay Pollution Commission report: “That the
reduction in the numbers with the depth is striking and indicates
that most of the sewage and other decomposible refuse with which
the bacteria were associated was floating around at the surface and
not mixing uniformly with the water.” That is from the report
of the Pollution Commission of New York City.

Captain Parsons: Well, | remember reading that document.

Col. Knight: But you disagree with that?

Captain Parsons: I disagree with that to this extent—as I said,—-
but there is more of it manifest upon the surface; that is, more of it
deposited at the surface of the high water, yet it prevails all the way
down as far as you can see it where the water leaves the ground.

Col. Knight: Well, if you could judge by simple figores, the dif-
ference between five feet and forty feet is the difference between one
hundred per cent. and twenty-five per cent.; that is simply the
report—taking those figures for it

Capt. Parsons: A vessel that is so unfortunate as to be sunk in
those waters anywhere round where Gowanus enters the bay, wi!!

immediately commence to accumulate a deposit of sediment
21 =and the expense of the removal of that sediment from the

vessel is very often equal to the expense of raising her, so
thoroughly has this deposited itself all over the inside of the vessel,
adding greatly to the weight of the vessel and making the raising of
the vessel that much more difficult.

Mr. Dean: Mr. Chairman and Gentlemen, the next speaker we
have to offer is Professor Lanéreth of Union University and dean
of the engineering school there and who, for ten years, was con-
sulting engineer to the New York State Department of Health, be-
aides a great deal of other experience. He has not prepared a set
yeech and it may be found convenient, to jog his memory, if 1
may be permitted to ask him «a few questions as he goes along in the
tages of the questions or subjects we expect him to talk on.

Prof. Landreth: Mr. Chairman, I have been asked to say at first
afew words concerning an outline of the history of the activity and
the position which has been taken by the State of New York with
regard to the comprehensive question of the sewage of this Metro-
Politan district, regardless of State laws, not only as a proof of the
activity of the State of New York and in its efforts to solve this mat-
tr comprehensively and effectively, but also as a basis for just one
o two statements I wish to make concerning my personal observa-
tons in the Harbor.

In the year 1903, I think it was, the State of New Jersey,

2 by the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission. first proposed
to discharge sewage into New York Bay. At that time the

State Commissioner of Health of the State of New York determined
© investigate the fact, and, on inquiring, concluded that it was a
hatter of sufficient importance to draw it to the attention of the
fovernor: which he did. The Governor at once concluded that a
commission of inquiry was desirable and a bill was accordingly, at
request, passed by the legislature of that vear, providing for the

ma io ae Sema
3002 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.

establishment of a New York State Commission, or, better, called
the New York Bay Pollution Commission having for its object prin-
cipally the examination of the relation of the proposed sewerage dis
charge from New Jersey into New York Bay and its probable effect
on the commerce and navigation of the bay, as well as its sanitary
relation,

On studying the question for a year or so, that Commission, first,
reached the conclusion that it wax undesirable that that sewer should
be constructed ; secondly, that the question was not a small one, and
that it was not confined to the case of the Passaic Valley sewer, but
that many other problems were concerned intimately with it, firt
of all the problem of the disposal of the sewage of New York, Greater
New York and, as a corollary to that, to dispose of and purify the
sewage of the metropolitan district; and that Commission reported;
in its report it recommended the establishment of a commission of
wider power which should coiperate with a similar one from the
State of New Jersey to study the matter in a comprehensive way,

and to reach conclusions as to the ultimate disposal of the
2023 sewage of the entire district so that whatever efforts should

be made for the adoption of such plans should be made along
comprehensive lines and should not result in the throwing away
useful funds and efforts, but in the correction of alvuses.

Thereupon the State of New York provided a second Commission,
the term of the first having expired, after, in fact, having been ex-
tended by request of the Governor, for a year to take the matter up
more fully, and in the latter part of 1905 the State of New York e&-
tablished a second Commission, called the Metropolitan Sewerage
Commission of New York, and while that was a Commission estab
lished by the State, the expenses of the commission were to be paid
by the City of New York and the appointments were made by the
Mayor of the City of New York, and that Commission com
its inquiry in 1906, and is still in existence.

For the first, I may say that I was a member of the New York
Bay Pollution Commission, and, also, for a year and a half a mem-
ber of the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission. | say that simply
to explain my reason for appearing before you and stating these
facts.

Now, the efforts of the State of New York to codperate
with the State of New Jersey have not been satisfactory.
An invitation from the State, through the Secretary of State
to the Governor of New Jersey to have a similar body ap

pointed resulted in the matter being referred by the Governor
204 = to the State Poard of Health of New Jersey, and no satisfae-

tory coéperation ever resulted from that Board, so that the
State inquiry as to the ultimate disposal of the sewage of the entire
district has been carried on by the two States distinctly and inde-
pendently, without coéperation So much, Mr. Chairman, as
basis for the observations which I am to refer to.

The question as to the swing of the tides and the swing of the
sewage borne above them in the Harbor has heen mentioned. Floats
placed in the harbor at different points at the beginning of the ebb

PPLELLA LE 8, ELLIE EG IOL LLG Vy LIES awe es ee ar POOP Oe be oe oe ie

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2002

ide, make trips of different lengths according to the state of the
ide, whether it ix neat tide or spring tide; also according to the
direction of the wind, although precautions have been taken to
diminate as far as possible the influence of the wind, that has not
wen fully successful, so that the lengths of the runs are not entirely
asained,—they are modified or disturbed by the effect of the wind.
They, usually however, may be said to represent the flow of a float
d from ten to fifteen miles, consequently the flow of the flood for
hat distance. Floats have been placed at the Battery at the begin-
sing of the ebb and have passed out as far as Sandy Hook. At
dher observations, the floats have not gone so far. Similarly, floats
iave been placed at Sandy Hook which have come up above Robbins
heef, and where observations have been m

The Chairman: That i on the flood tide?

Prof, Landreth: That is on the flood tide, yes, sir; and in

% some instances they have shoaled on the shore. The swing

of the tide does occur, These observations leave the progres-

don, besides, towards the sea; that is, the movement is clearly to-
winds the sea, but it is by no means an overwhelming one.

These observations, coupled also with observations of the density
@ the water as determined by current determinations, indicate that
sout one-half or something less than half of the water which goes
wt of the Narrows never returns; that the remainder is the same
water which went out. That fact is, I suppose, largely accounted
ft by the fact that the sea-way beyond the bar is not an open sea
atirely but is confined between the two lands at right angles—the
lesey shore on the North shore, of Long Island shore Eastways, and
eae into that, acquiring a large standard figure of the
food tide drawn up in the same way and returns in part the same
tater that went out on the ebb.

Concerning the matter of deposit, the borings that have been

—a good many borings have been made on the bottom of the
arbor by apparatus designed for bringing up samples not only
fom the surface but from several points below the surface simul-
uneously, and these borings show very general deposits of mud,
atgely organic in appearance and, as far as can be detected, it has
the organic contents, all the essentials of organic sewage which has
jased through a fairly advanced stage of decomposition and some
it having. at last, reached the mineral stage, where it is generally

similar to natural mineral material and it all contains the
% = characteristic sewage indicator, the B colae comus. At a

depth of from six to eight feet, as I recall—l am speaking
fom recollection merely—I am not positive how deep the B colae
sobserved in the mud, it is very general, however for the first foot
two, in fact in some cases increasing frequently as the distance
ito the mud is penetrated and rapidly diminishing below that
pornt———

Mr. Dean: Professor, what would that B colae show?
Prof. Landreth: The B colae would show original sewage or animal
contamination.
. gentlemen, are much better observed where—that is I
tak as to the phenomena—on the inner slope of the bar at Ambrose

| in

3004 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF XEW YORK Vs.

Channel, and the observations which were made at the available
places, indicated, as you of course know, quite a large amount of
organic matter, of harbor sludge or harbor deposits has formed on
the inner slope of the bar. Borings from there involved a crow
section of the bar where the sand is fairly clean, to a depth of ei
to twelve feet on the inner point of the slope and diminishing
up to the normal shoaler flatness further up the Bay, suggesting a
possible explanation that in the efforts of the material in going back
and forth and lying close to the bottom, still moving partly in the
sand wave, to reach the sea, but practically moving back and forth
in the same place, partially influenced by the current, somewhat
will accumulate on the bar.
I should like to add only one or two words to the exposi-

207 ~—tion of the Boston construction and the conditions there a

compared with New York, which Dr. Jackson very clearly
set forth, and that is, to emphasize the fact that New York has one
outlet to the sea through which sewage may pass, and doubtles a
remote one through the East River channel, whereas Boston has
five or had heen made te verify 0. Vou knew, of coum
1 will make that «atemwent te wour henerable Medy.—-water dw
net ron ap like the body of «a wheel—it rum ap faeter im the
centre of stream than it dees at the sides, and fester at the ae
face than it dees at the bette, and, therefore. to make any prop
nestication a te jut where that «wage would go, or how far it &
geing. is a matter that cannet be anewered off-hand
Mr. Lebdwecter: Tew bone will ¢ take t dilute the ae
244s age «© discharged”
Mr. Hering: 1 think & can be dilated « that wou could
net see it at all within perhape—well, | make « gues now, baed
on rather long steady _> ee

gre Tr aT aT SS S:hlUSlhUCUCULrl! lUC*SS

——_

THE STATE OF SEW JERSEY ET AL. 3037

dengeide the ferry slips, at low water,—which I have seen at
(urtlondt Street, and at 34th Street, and at 42nd Street, and,
apecially there alongside the gas houses; we all know that New-
wen Creek ix another Passaic; and it ix no wonder, with the sewer
eaem in vogue; that i« the point we want to reach—this sewage
dould not be brought into the pierheads, but should be so dis
harged into the tidal waters a* to mix it and disperse it with the
aormous quantity of water we have got here. In Boston they
have done it, and we improve, in our proposition upon the Boston
uttheds, and I do not understand at the Boston works that they
propose to give it up.
m5 Here we have the State of Mas @

i a a

+ IS

=

—

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 3041

there is one point,—they seem to have an idea here that we are re-
lving entirely on currents, Now, we do not. If you put one

83 part of sewage into fifty parts of ordinarily clear and pure
water, water with the natural amount of oxygen in it, whether

alt or fresh water, and fresh sewage, the sewage so put in is ineecu-
ws, in salt water in a tank, In sea water, or in anything else, That
wint is Of importance to us; of necessity,—the currents of useful-
aess,—the presence of the currents is advantageous as it involves the
mesence Of a large body of fresh water and of clean water, and we
an arrange our sewage for passing through it. As Mr. Hering told
sou it is our purpose to have the sewage go out slowly; we can regu-
ate it as it goes through our works. Boston cannot. Boston sends
tout by gravity alone, without control. With us, in our sustem, it
sonly a matter of a litthe more coal to get a greater head on, or a
ittle less coal and a slower head, That is arranged by the pumps.
We let it go out as we want it to go, and we mix it or carry it in
he diluting water, Now, when you get one part of that sewage into
ifty parts of New York water, it don’t go five hundred feet away
‘efore it is imperceptible, totally passed out of sight and dispersed.
In all the investigations made by Great Britain of the sludge from
he London sewers as deposited in the River Thames; they take their
ludge in large boatloads, take it down the estuary of the Thames to
ide—deep water; when it is down twenty miles, they again throw it
werboard, steam around in the same place, opening gates in the lower
wart of the boat, and allow the sludge to drop out. In ten to fifteen
minutes, or in a very short time after that sludge is dropped
Mit is impossible to detect that any sludge has been
put into the water, so far as the closest bacteriological and
chemical tests can determine; it is gone. They steam around; maybe
# the boat go down the river and special tests show that it has been
uken up by the oxygen in the water, by the bacteria,—taken up by
he small animaleulee around there; and there are a great many
ound there, it is a great place for fishing, anv number of people
ways fishing around in that locality. That is what we think is the
ase here with our proposition in New York Bay, and we think that
ill last until fifteen or twenty million people populate this district,
ind then, by that time, the engineers, I think will take care of it,
ind it is ridicuous folly for the engineers of today to say what
they are going to do with New York sewage twenty years from now,
You might as well have asked the engineers the plans of the Hud-
on tunnel thirty years ago; they never would have been able to build
‘according to those plans,—and in fact they could not do it with the
jlans then made for that tunnel; and when I talk about plans of
hirty years ago, for that work, I am talking from experience, as
lhave heen closely connected with the railroads and with terminal
waters of the Pennsylvania Railroad, and with the terminal af-
its of other railroads, for the last thirty vears, and when I first
ok those matters up, we thought that it was foolish to undertake to
wild the tunnel, we thought that there would never be a time when
he needs of the country would require it; nobody ever thought of

3042 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Vs.

dredging to a depth of thirty feet in the lower Bay, and
285 equally unthought of was the building of such a structure

as the Pennsylvania Railroad is building today, and which is
absolutely necessary for terminal facilities. I then made a report
on the subject, and when it was put in, was practically concurred in
by all of the Pennsylvania Railroad engineers; it was folly, we
thought, to think that they would ever have such a railroad ter-
minal, Then, I may say, in those days in considering dredging
matters, we figured on forty or fifty cents a yard for dredging, and
as high as Two dollars a cubic yard for filling; and now, with the
improvements in mechanism for this work you know how the meth-
ods and costs have been modified: We dredge now for ten cents a
cubic yard, and we get all the fill in we want for twenty cents
a cubic yard; so that work which would then have cost upwards of
twenty thousand dollars is now easily done for Five thousand dol-
lars.

And, so I say, when these gentlemen talk about the waters of the
harbor becoming a nuisance, or becoming clogged up, if we will
measure the waters of New York Bay in the light of this big project
that has been undertaken by the Pennsylvania Railroad, with refer-
ence to what was thought would be the case, and if we look at this
matter on a large, broad scale, there is no reason why the great
advantages of New York should be, or be attempted to be, changed
from what we have learned they are, and it would really be a great
mistake in a great community like this, where the first question
is: Can you dispose of sewage by mixing it with water? Can you

arrange its dispersion so as not to create a nuisance? and,
286 ~— secondly, If vou can, don't think of anything else.

Dr. Soper: Representing the Metropolitan Sewerage Com-
mission, | read a statement yesterday in which the opinion of the
Metropolitan Sewerage Commission was expressed, opposed to the
Passaic Valley project.

After listening to all of the statements that have been made since
then, I do not think that I should want to change the wording of
that statement. It represents, of course, not my own views, but
those of the five members of the Metropolitan Commission, all of
whom have given this subject coiusiderable study.

At the same time, in the proceedings which followed my remarks,
my name has been mentioned several times, and some of the state
ments that I made have been criticized. For one thing, the name
of Mr. Allen Hazen has been brought into this discussion as having
contributed to the discussion of a paper which I read before the
Sanitary reception of the Boston Society of Civil Engineers.

I should like to have Mr. Hazen’s complete discussion before you,
and, if possible, the discussions of Mr. Harry Clark, Chemist of the
Massachusetts State Board of Health, and Mr. Coney, the Engineer
of the Massachusetts State Board of Health. Mr. Hazen’s remarks,
if I remember them—I have not seen the discussion of the paper
now for some time, referred to the inadequacy of the data upon
which he based his discussion, and recommended that the studies

GIGS = Po

-—

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 3043

which were being discussed be made very much more full
#87 «= and_ complete; those studies are now being made much more

full and complete. The Metropolitan Commission exists for
that purpose.

Mr. Harry Clark's discussion, if | remember it correctly, shows
the danger of polluting tidal estuaries in the direction of injuring
the purity of oysters and shell-fish. That point has been referred to
here, in these statements that have been made before your Board.

Briefly: It may be unnecessary for me to extend them. It has
not been brought out, however, that, within the limits of New York
(ity, there are annually produced upwards of five hundred thou-
and bushels of oysters. They are marketed here and are eaten, for
the most part, without cooking. Cases of typhoid fever have been
weounted for, just as reliably, | think, as typhoid can well be traced,
w the eating of some of those oysters; oysters cultivated and grown
in the waters of New York. According to the latest statistics that 1
have been able to collect, there are grown annually about seventy
thousand bushels (7) seven (7)* thousand bushels of oysters in
upper New York Bay. This used to be a famous oyster-producing
ground.

Mr. Hazen’s discussion of my paper before the Boston Society
df Civil Engineers, in common with the opinions of many other
angineers with respect to the diluting-power of the waters of New
York harbor for sewage, were based upon the assumption that all
if the water of the harbor was available for diluting and assimilating

the sewage, and, apparently, upon the assumption that that
88 water was immediately available for diluting and assimilat-
ing the sewage.

It has been demonstrated, and fragments of the evidence have been
put before your Board, that sewage discharged into the waters of
New York harbor does not immediately become dispersed. It has
een stated that the sewage floats about upon the surface to a very
wnsiderable extent. We should, then, consider, not the tidal volume
of water,—not the total volume of water which lies there in the basin
of the harbor and floats in and out,—the quantity which floats in
and out with the tide when the tidal prism does, as available water
for diluting and assimilating sewage, but its surface area, multiplied
by the ceriain depth—the exact depth we do not know as yet—
which is all of that volume of water so available.

One of the most diflicult problems which we are studying to-day
a the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission, is how sewage discharged
into these waters can be so dispersed as to become inoffensive before
itis distributed.

With regard to this matter I would invite the consideration of your

to a report of the State Board of Health of Massachusetts
won the discharge of sewage into Boston harbor, dated 1900. You
vill find there evidence in the form of an official report, and a map,
o which I would especially invite your attention—considerable evi-
tence upon the effects of the outfalls of the Boston drainage, and

ee,

*(Stenographer: Probably seven. )

Sa ee Or

par Py s

3044 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

— drainage system—also some facts, one of which I will briefly

289 (Reading. )

“At the outlet in our Deer Island Beacon, which is four and
two-thirds miles from Long Wharf in Boston, in the windfall
East of the main ship channel, sewage from the North Metropolitan
District is allowed to discharge as it comes, in all stages of the tide.
The quantity of sewage discharged in twenty-four hours now reaches
about fifty million gallons, and this quantity, while distinetly visible
along the Northerly edge of the channel for a half mile towards the
City, on the incoming tide, and towards the sea, on the outgoing
tide, gradually becomes less distinct at greater distances from the
outlet, and disappears entirely within a distance of one and a quarter
miles.”

The material is distinctly visible and described as “offensive” in
this report; such material it is as would not be retained by screens
nor by settling basins; it is material which floats upon the surface.

That is a sample or type of the local nuisances which exist to some
extent in New York harbor to-day, and which we believe would very
probably result from the discharge of the Passaic Valley sewerage
under the plans proposed.

With regard to the exhibit of bottled experiments that I offered
you—Mr. Hering brought up the question whether solid matter
did deposit more rapidly in sea water or fresh water. I offered that
exhibit to show you, in a graphic way that sewage sludged or de
posited more rapidly in sea water than in fresh water. The experi

ment may be easily repeated by any one; it was done
290 ~=in this way: Sewage sludge was taken, in equal quantities,

and put into each of two bottles; one bottle was then filled
with sea water and the other with fresh land water; the bottles
were allowed to stand; at the end of the periods of time indicated on
the photograph cards the effects, which can be noted, were photo
graphed.

Mr. Hering has indicated that Mr. Fowler, connected—Dr. Fowler,
connected with the Manchester Sewage Disposal Works, has, I think,
an opposite view. I would refer your Roard, for substantiation of
what I was saying, to an appendix,—appendix number eleven, of
the report of Mr. John Sylvester Freemen to the Committee on the
Charles River Dam, Boston, 1903: I can briefly say that there are
photographs reproduced there which illustrate, and in more
haustive manner, and with various changes, what my photograp
showed you yesterday, and I would ask permission to read this brief
statement, from page 286: ;

“In the course of this investigation, and in connection with ob
servations of the appearance of the river at present during times of
storm, certain experiments have been made upen the en ee
degree of rapidity with which bodies of turbid fresh water an turbid
salt water clear themselves. It has been shown v arly that
salt water acts like a precipitant, especially if the turbidity is caused
to some extent by bodies such as are present in sewage * *

hd

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 3045

This is true if the matter causing turbidity is well mixed with the
_ * * © If turbid fresh water is placed above salt weter,
the turbidity will disappear slowly when the water is quiet.
1 «This effect is shown bw the photographs ;” and so on.
Those are documents which are well worth very ful! con-
aderation.
With respect to the kind of turbidity produced by my experiments,
od with these (indicating book previously quoted from), I would
wk you to consider (hat the solid matters are not such as would be
mmoved by screening, nor by simple sedimentation for the brief
yriod which Mr. Hering has indicated, so far as we understand his
meaning.
The Mercey and Elbe rivers have been described as places where
yantities of sewage were being disposed of without injurious con-
ce,—in fact, without being visible. I would ask you to con-
iter that they are both turbid rivers, particularly the Elbe, and that
aperiments have been made, and analyses of the Elbe, which show
hat, although the sewage ix discharged only on the outgoing tide.
eidences of it are clearly discoverable at the water works of the
‘ity considerably above stream.
t is not a question alone of producing wholesale nuisances
troughout these harbors that objection is made to increasing the
mount of sewage pollution. he question of extensive local
wisances is one of very considerable import.
It has been urged that cost—Mr. Hering said, that cost should
wt control in this matter—The Metropolitan Sewerage Commission
would urge that you give considerable weight to that point.
w2 «of there is wo other reason than cost—if there is any other
reason than cost to prevent the purification of the sewage or
the handling of it in other ways without discharging it in the raw
sndition proposed, we believe—we do not appreciate it.

We believe that the disposal of the sewage under water in the
wanner proposed is in the nature of an experiment, and, although
*e are not prepared to say to what extent the harbors and channels
rill be silted, nor to what extent precisely other injuries may come
» navigation or to the public health, we believe that safety requires
hat no question of doubt be allowed to attach to that matter.

I would also ask you to consider that there is a difference between
he discharge of the sewage ai the Passaic outfall and into rivers, in
his respect at least; that, whereas the discharge of sewage into a
eam running in one direction, may load that stream with, for the
ime, we will say, uniformity,—with a current such as flows back-
urd and forward in New York bay, the water would get «a double
of sewage, or, at least, some of it would. The current which
up stream towards the end of the tide would return and get
% cond dose on its way towards the sea.

Mr. Hering, and I think perhaps others, have suggested that ex-
Miments be made to give us more light upon this uncertain ques-
wn of diffusion. We know very little about the phenomena of dif-
of sewage in salt water particularly. The Metropolitan

Soeomeaewr? ==

Y,Toecu ara Trae & Ff &

ehSGa6 57, S237 Fo Se

Ex. No. 1——10

3046 THE PROPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.

Commission considers that a heavy burden re=ts upon it for
293 = ascertaining some of those essential phenomena. [If it is ad-

mitted that we know little now about those matters, we think
there is more reason for considering that uncertainties attach to the
projects of discharging the sewage in accordance with the proposed
plans of the Pas

Dr. Soper Mr. Hering, didn't vow «ay that that question of &

should net be a controlling medent”

Mr. Hering: 1 did say that.

Dr. Soper. And that you are not considering expense in the

¥

Mr. Hering 1 did ay thet, and | wanted to advert to that ner.
Gur experience in this matier t- confined to Europe and the United
States, and this whole question of sewage purnficstion har veen ote
that has changed its aspect every few years, and we have not
nat teliewe that over the whole situation of “ewark you would
available spot to-day for putting works of this kind, and I é
jeve that i a very permanent intitation 1
belief that the people would object t) it and that you nm
works of the bi there. and | beheve that they would have
to ob) because that very
. 1 count that wery highly.

<2fW4
piezs

i

:

E

Fs
5
F
=
;
3
ig
;
e
i

THE STATE OF SEW SPRORY ET AL wae

dmet, into existence, of some part of a department, to run thir

ame
Xow 1] have alwave felt that cities <hould be recommended that
thich i+ mest sienple— taking that pat of view, that is. decidedly,
he arvqelest melistion for a large prrbiie work it ders net require any
aye force for attendance. (ond vou do net know whether they are
eave going t de evervthing just as it should be done ) whether vou
@ net going to get an oder, which i+ particularly evyjectionable. or
iat «mething won't go wrong. We find that even im well-requlated
farpe. and. therefore, that hae always born a very weights comed-
etien with me. for if 1 could diepewe of the sewage in a simple
—particularly Ww dilution—1I would always do it even if it was
om expensive. If it wae more expensive even, | should recor:
ond thie evetem than to have a work of purification. provided it
«4 he more. than would accrue in thi- cave, and I only se dixed-
atage | de net we any advantage in the ultimate revult ever this.
ad | wee the di-edvantages of the large force of operation as well as
te dixadvantage to the people living around it, even thongh they
wel half a mile away from it
Therefore, | am abeclutely of the opinion that this ir decidedly
the lest «tem for the territery te adept, and I shewld not
solike te he eeieendertoed in that matter.
The Chairman le there anything ele’

Wr Herne: Now, | should joe like reply « moment to Ir
ger. with reference to those jars of «ewage—I refer to the attled
exage where all the suspended matter i¢ deposited first. and that is
dt Dr. Fowler epenks of: thir ix not settled sewage: thir i raw

owngr

Dr. Soper | hea your perdon, this ix settled sewage
We VWerime Well. then. von «ill hawe to aettle that with Dr.
omer
Dr. Soper I know hin cery well I showld be Pleased te
Mr. Mering. Another point ix, 1 would like te mention, ard that
sahout the fice, It wae brought ap twice, Now, gentlemen. the
im thong | heard of mm Earepe this Sunnie, and this wae in Eng-
ad they were claiming hew fine they were getting along —-that
here wax an odor. but faint, “Bat the flie''” There hae never been
wh an exhibition of flies in England or anywhere, than -ince these
tepemnl <vstetis have been ret rednced Thes fill the comtact beds
ter beved right ander the stones. You pick ap a stone, perhaps,
ad under the edge, under a little bit—all fie. We know that
ter are fice in connection with these plant+; there may be a way
dwereemming that feature it hae net been thereuahl: densest rated

ax vet. there are flies, floods of them in every plant and com-
M plained of very generally. Therefore, the fly question could
not he used as an argument in faver of this «vetem of sewage

Mtificstion | have not the slighest dew there will he found some
Sane to reduce that evil, «o I do not place any weight on it, but it
~ ectnal fart that a <plendid breeding place for flie- i- right under

tome

Then. tao. one thing more that ic what Dr Soper said shout the

SO Nh OSS OO

Mr. Schondeimeier My name ix Schondelmeier
mmr the Pray Wav: rade a he Right Rar Tre
Brooklvn

This matter of -ewage har been under consideration for quite a
tre in these berenghite. It i« « abject we all know i« growing

1 will met take Far Coe Wy eget; ches top tom a
vesterday today ; that it i- —that it would
wr he chjectionalle if this truamk sewer were constructed and the

sewage emptied inte the Ray 1 will just mention a few cas
that are proof in evidence in (his day that sewage plant: can be con
structed and operated saticfactorily. 1 will refer vou to the
plant of Floetrurst. which is just abewe the Flushing Bay a
tance . it does ite work so perfectly that ax the water leaves
it « a clear a the water on the table which we use for
We have anther a = the <ewage

Ht

i

i
i
ir
i

i
yi
a3
+?
i
:
a
f

ie there in Jersey,
11,54, & here. right near our river

WS are disposing of i im a method
Therefore we do ep ae protest we offer
we do

Ht emphatically and earnestly, we do feel ,
ime made tw the City of New York ork and by organizations interested
in the dixpenal of sewage in a way,—we do feel
shunld eneourage u- in this and net ask us to permit
do what we are to overcome ourselves

Mr. Lebkuecher May I ask the gentleman what efforts

THE STATE OF NEW JERORY ET AL. 3051

4 Brooklyn, or what efforts the City of New York has made,—what
tas heen done towards a sewage disposal plant in the City of Brook-
°

tl Knight: I fear you misunderstood him; he referred to the
forts made at Elrnburst.
Mr. Lebkueecher: | did misunderstand him.
Mir. Child: Mr. Chairman, and Gentlemen: ta the few remarks
| devire to make, I propose to discuss entirely the questions of ob-
éraction to navigation. 1 have been living im an atmosphere of
eeage for the last seven vears, and the mere mention of it gives me
of the stomach; and I have no desire to discuss that.
As | andertand it, the province of this Board, the peculiar juris
fiction of the Roard is to see to it that navigation ix not interfered
vith, either by inaproper construction or in any ether way.
lalko wederstund that in considering the question of the wants
of navigation, that this Beard will take a lvoad. comprehen-
i «ive view,.—not confine itelf to the limited section in the
imomediate neighborhood of Robbins Reef Light, but will
ok over the whole field. .
It ix known to you, gentlemen, that the Newark Bay ix a v
considerable body of water. It ix« known to you that the Passaic
seer ix a navigable river for many miles up from the Bay and that
the commerce of the Pasnic river ix very great. It i* aleo known
» vou that vou have had probably a* much trouble in keeping
matters in a proper condition in the Newark Bay and in the Passaic
fver as in any other territory under your jurisdiction.

Now, vou cannot but «ey that thir improvement—and we call
fan ieprevement. and advieedly «o—that this improvement will
ie in the interest« of navigation «« far a* the Newark Bay is con-
ered. and the Paxwic River. We will take out and we will keep
ot of that river the very thing: which make your task in keeping
Ravigation open threwg)eut that territery so difficult. That ix one

Now, in the next place, it ix alleged, and that ix all. it i« alleged
thet «ene obstruction te navigation may result at the outfall of
this «owner. It hax not heen shown that, in the Metropolitan Dis
tet of Reston, any euch obstruction hax resulted. No complaint
has heen made by the Harbor Line Board having charge. unless
ru gentlemen may have, having charge of that territory. No one
he shown to you that any result, so far as navigation ix ,
injuries, have existed in connection with work of thi. character;
<» that vou heave, what? On the one side. a certain, positive
% benefit to navigation over there in the Passaic Valley and
in Newark Ray; certain, sure, unq-ertionable. On the other
ide, you have mere speculation of something which may possibly
weur. Nothing has oreurred in the whole history of trunk sewers,
~in England, all over thie country: No one has shown that it
wer had occurred but it may occur.

Now, gentlemen. right in that connection, ecriticiem has been
made because these plane are said to he ineufficient in detail with
tlerence to the settling basins, the sereens, and the outfall pipes.

OI RA ANNOY TO NN EPL IRAE LA ARLEN IIE AI ALTE DLAI: ED SEAL ARE AE ARAL Pip ta ARE

co

052 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

Now, is there any uncertainty? That which can be made certain,
is certain. It is certain!
This application which is pending before you is almost an exact
reproduction of the application presented by the Metropolitan Dis-
trict (of Boston) to the Department for permission to locate each
of their sewers.
Mr. Brown, who is in charge of that great Boston work, has been
in our employ for years. He has been one of our consulting
engineers; and, at my request, Mr. Brown sent us a copy of the
last application that was made for a trunk sewer in Boston; it was
on the exact lines with this, using the identical language.
Now. what do we do? What do we ask? And, before coming
te that--I may be ignorant, and, if IT am, I am willing to be in-
structed.—-but I do not understand that. when the Department at
Washington, acting on the recommendation of this honorable
Board, grants its permission, that its jurisdiction is gone.

306 1 do not understand that. It is to be only a permission:
It is not a grant. It is always within the control of the
Government.

Now. what are we asking? We are not asking, as has been asked
thousands of times, and, IT suppose, a great many times, of you,
ventlemen, a right to obstruct navigation. We do not propose to
take from the navigable waters any space at all. We are not
proposing to build out bulkheads, extending the lines of bulkhead
and pierheads: But. what are we asking? We are asking the
privilege of constructing a sewer, which we represent to you will
not result in any obstruction to navigation. If it does obstruct
navigation. then we will stand shorn and naked of all rights com-
ing to us by virtue of this consent, because no plea of ignorance
of right principles of construction could possibly avail.

That is what I understand to be the true position, and no other
position would be safe. I take it that, if the Commission should
be given this consent, and we should construct a sewer and it
should prove an obstruction to navigation, in the harbor of New
York, in these waters, why the power is in the Department to do
one of two things: Either to compel us to stop using the sewer,
stop creating the obstruction, to change our plans, and to remove
the obstruction.

Now, what risk does anybody run? We propose to put Twelve
million five hundred thousand dollars into this project as an a

surance to you gentlemen, representing the Government,
307 that we are acting in good faith; that we have faith in our
representations to you, as made to you, and with the full
knowledge that if those representations are false, we take nothing.

Now, what do we do? In this application, we provide here, an¢
in the plans, and in the report which is submitted, which is made
by our Commission, we are bound by every representation I have
made, as wéll as every matter which is alleged here in this petition.

Now, what do we sav? “All work in or below navigable waters,
both permanent and temporary to be subject * * *”—to what?—

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 3053

to the approval and supervision of the United States authority
javing jurisdiction over the said waters.”

Now, suppose we should—assume that our representations are
alse,——assuming we should construct these works without screens,
rithout a settling basin, and that we should discharge our sewage
aw, and containing heavy matter, and that it should result in an
iistruction to navigation: Why, there is the authority,—we have
Bvot to get out!

There are many things of this sort that are of no use, that can-
Biot be determined definitely, until the thing is done. But, when
:man comes before you, and who claims to possess the requisite
Ainowledge.—the man upon whom the loss, if any, must fall by
Fracon of his failure, if it proves a failure, and he is willing to put
Fup as an evidence of good faith an investment of over twelve mil-
ion dollars, to give this Board, or the proper authority a bond
vhich will compel us to remove each and every thing which this
Board will determine to be a nuisance-——How does that
WS hecome a question of such great moment? The size of the

settling basins! The size of the screens!

But, we go farther than that; and we want you, gentlemen, to
Hill us, after we have constructed the settling basin, after it is all
Fone, and after our money is in it. if it is too small, and, if it is
Tio small. we will make it larger—and we will keep on increasing
7 the size until vou are satisfied.

As compared to a twelve million, two hundred and fifty thousand
J dollar expenditure, why, that is a bagatelle! It amounts to noth-
Jing! A piece of masonry, the size of this room, compared with
qthe expenditure of twelve million, two hundred and fifty thousand
lollars!) So that that is simple enough.
4 It is the same thing with the screens. Why, with this bond,

and with this conditional assent (because it is nothing else) it is
were to our interest, having all this money at stake, to see that
proper screening is effected than it can possibly be to any com-
munity. let alone any individual. Because, assuming—assuming
A these gentlemen who are so filled with fear and apprehension, that
itimay be that their fears may be realized within a reasonable time,
—why, how simple it is to remove it!

Now we come, for instance, to distribution.—to the arrange-
ments for distribution at the outfall of the plant. T do not know
4 anything about it (and as I have heard these engineers
9 testifying here 1 was almost glad I did not know anything
about it), I do not know whether one pipe, or five hundred
pipes may or will be necessary; but, gentlemen, if five thousand
pipes are necessary, we are prepared to put them there.

Now. that is all. Now, what more can we do? We say here
how,-I say that all we sav here, all T say, this binds us, and. as
amember of this Commission IT acknowledge the obligation im-
wsed upon me when this application was presented te vou gentle-
f nen.

Sefore the sewage enters the pumping station it passes through
- git chamber to remove all gravel, sand and other heavy matter,

Lpypst A Neg MLE AE OE AE MEIER OETA EM AE SAE AA AEP LN EO A LEAL DEES PEE i

é Pe 1 = De em iE Hee . ~ REGS Apc on MG BE ET al Ste A LEM

3054 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V3.

and through a screen chamber, where all floating matter will be
removed. Now that is the proposition. Now, if we do not do that,
then, when the time comes, you withhold your sanction and we
will rest content.

It, seems to me that the question is of no possible importance.
It cannot be told now, as these engineers say. Well, they know |
more about it than we do (of course, T ought mot to say that, be-
canse vou gentlemen are skilled and learned in these engineering
matters,—but I meant myself), but, whether they do or not, I do
not know; but they tell us that they have got to wait in order to
determine this. Now we will wait, but we are waiting all the time.
—all the time! The grip of this Board,—the grip you gentlemen
have on us is not relaxed at any time. Your successors, if there
should be such, five years, ten years, from now,—indefinitely, now

and then, will have exactly that authority.
310 So that I do think, gentlemen, with all deference to the
various discussions that have been made, that these two
matters are provided for, and that they are provided for in the
best and the safest way.

What greater assurance could the Metropolitan District—and
these plans are identical, as | have said—give to vour Board than
that it should be something which you, gentlemen, selected on
account of your peculiar ability, with your knowledge, acquired
after years of experience, and with your special education, should
sav was safe; that it was sufficient? Could any jury be selected
to decide a question of this nature, more competent, or better quali-
fied to determine such a matter?

But we will give the bond as an additional assurance; and we
known that the Government will not refuse a bond-——

The Chairman: Well, we don't know as to that, Commissioner.—
probably vou do——

Mr. Child: Well, that is my point-of-view. being unfortunately
a member of the legal profession.—I have had a great deal to do
with the legal matters connected with this case, which I do uot
propose to discuss at all. There is a tribunal before which it must
be discussed before long, and Mr. Dean said that he trusted that
you gentlemen would defer your decision of this matter until ad-
judication had been had by the Supreme Court of the United States
on the pending litigation between New York and New Jersey.

The questions involved in the litigation in the United States

Supreme Court are entirely foreign to any question pre
311 sented to you, gentlemen. The question which you are

called on to determine, as T understand it. is whether this
proposed work will be an obstruction to navigation. Whether it
is in the State of New York or in the State of New Jersey is of no
possible materiality. If it is an obstruction to navigation, you
ventiemen would refuse your consent if the application was made
by New York or by New Jersey or if made by both. provided you
believed that that would be the result. :

That question is not involved in the litigation in the United
States Supreme Court at all: That is purely a question of sovereign

|

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 3055

ight. To withhold this until after that decision would be, I
hink, a manifest injustice to my Commission. Because, there is
igreat deal of preliminary work which must be done in any event
vith reference to the construction of this sewer. Because drawings
we to be made, in greater detail, of all things, and contracts pre-
wred, ready to be put out in proper shape, and all matters of
that kind, which we assume will take us from eight to ten months,
ind will involve the expenditure of a large amount of money.

The condition, as you heard it described here, is terrible, and
mght to be abated with reasonable celerity. Now, to hold us back
inti] the Supreme Court of the United States, acting with reference
the litigation of other questions, should render their decision
would be, gentlemen, I submit to you, gentlemen, tantamount to
denial of justice. If we are entitled to it, then we ought to have

it. If we are not entitled to it, then this Board ought to
2 declare that. And then. of course, some other procedure

will have to be resorted to for temporary relief.—or we
nust bear the ills we are now subject to.

And as in this litigation the animus of the suit between New
York and New Jersey being solely with reference to the suppression
of this sewer,—if you should (1 do not anticipate it, and do not
ve from my standpoint, how you can do it), but if you, in your
wisdom, should determine that we are not entitled to the use of
that which we are here asking for, that decision on your part would
inno way affect this case —it could not possibly have any influence
upon the pending litigation in the United States Supreme Court,
that is, so far as this Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission is con-
erned. | presume that. the object having been obtained in an-
ther direction, it would lead to an abandonment by the State of
New York. So that there is every reason to conceive of why the
decision. and a reasonably quick decision, should be reached now.

It may be said now that all matters of etiquette and propriety
must he decided by each individual for himself; and, of course.
this Board is able to decide any question of that character. Now
itmay be that at first thought it will appear that it would be dis-
courteous to the United States Supreme Court to anticipate their
action. Now, as against that, I have this to say: That we were
first in the field. We made our application before the suit was

brought. and, on the other hand, if we had not made our
43 application to your honorable Board, the suit) would not

have been brought: when we made the application, the suit
was brought.
_And then, inasmuch as this question is not before the United
States Supreme Court, and cannot affect—either directly or in-
directly—so far as the legal considerations are concerned——any de-
asion which they may reach, I do not see how it is a violation of
any of the rules of strictest courtesy.

Of course. if you consider the character of that tribunal. and of
the honorable body of men sitting to-day in the United States
Supreme Court. it would be folly for any man to believe that they
would be influenced in their determination of a question of right,

CerlCr? C'S

OS RG? EE

— PP Sh Ree dir A ok ee OB ie:

3056 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

by a conclusion reached by another tribunal on another and in-
dependent point.

Now, with these remarks, gentlemen, I am through; thanking
vou for the courtesy of your attention. I trust that this Board
will see its way clear to grant to the State of New Jersey,—the
important part of the State of New Jersey, the relief so imperatively
demanded.

Mr. Lebkuecher: May I be allowed to ask Mr. Riker to make a
few remarks?

The Chairman: On this phase of the question?

Mr. Lebkuecher: Yes, sir.

The Chairman: I do not think it necessary, that is, if I under.
stand it to be in duplication or reiteration of what has been said——

Mr. Lebkuecher: Merely for the purpose of strengthen-
S14. ing it—

The Chairman: I do not think it ix necessary. Do you
undertsand that if there is anvthing further to be brought out, he
Board is prepared to continue this session, tomorrow. if necessary.

Mr. Lebkuecher: I think we are about through. Mr. Chairman:
we have nothing more to present.

The Chairman: Gentlemen, is there any one here who desire
to say anything more on this question? The Board desires to give
everybody an opportunity——

Mr. Sandford: One remark I would like to make is that I do
not know whether the gentlemen are aware that the United States
Government, at the present time, are spending a great deal of
money on the Passaic river, to make it navigable for jarger
vesse|s——~

The Chairman: That is entirely within the knowledge of the
Board.

Mr. Sandford: I wanted to say, in connection with that, that
unless we can get factories and warehouses and so forth. along that
shore, where people can work in, why, the deepening of that river
wil] be lost to the community.

Mr. Lebkuecher: Have you all of the data vou require, from
our Commission ?

fhe Chairman: Everything that has been handed to the
ionrd——.

Mr. Child: I do not know as to whether 1 was understood this

morning, when I handed you the extracts from the United
315 States Coast Survey Reports.—I spent considerable time over

the Coast Survey reports, and I think you will find them
very interesting. They cover all the principles of New York har-
bor. as to currents, and so forth. 1 am not going to refer to all
of the different data, but it is a comprehensive index to the Bay.

The Chairman: The Board will be prepared to receive any ¢om-
munications bearing on this subject at any time up to and inelud-
“ne Monday——

Col. Knight: Why not make it Monday a week, and give them
ample time——

The Chairman: Up to and including Monday, December 21s.
The hearing is adjourned.

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386004_0506%3A13. Public record. Not legal advice.
