# Transcript of Record — Silver King Coalition Mines Co. v. Conkling Mining Co.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386004_0481%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1921
- **Citation:** 256 U.S. 18

## Text

(27,244)

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER TERM, 1920.

No. 158.

SILVER KING COALITION MINES COMPANY, PETITIONER,
v8.

CONKLING MINING COMPANY

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT

INDEX
Origina Print,

Affidavit of Nicholas Treweek in the case of Nicholas Treweek
et al. vx. Silver King Coalition Mines Company et al. in
support of motion for an order to inspect and survey the
wining property of the Silver King Coalition Mines Company. 1 2
Order in the case of Nicholas Treweek ef al. va. Silver King
Coalition Mines Company et al. granting survey, etc., of min-

ing property of Silver King Coalition Mines Company... .. 5 5
a £0 GUNNIEE occeccoscvcvorresvcusteneveneees 6 6
Replication to amended answer...........----cccccscccccsece 25 22
Stipulation in re certain pleadings.............-..+++eeee000% 25 22
/Order, December 16, 1911, granting leave to file amended an-

tt Mcntuawceded beoetevube bee sb O0u sev enoretoworeceen 26 23
Amended answer to amended bill of complaint............... 26 23
of district court, filed November 28, 1916, as to defend-
ant’s motion to reopen the case for the introduction of fur-
NN AU as el ainw signs sue vue daa ween eae : §0 43

& Derwemtre (Inc.), Printers, WASHINGTON, D. C., OcToper 13, 1920.

ii INDEX.

Origina!

Opinion of the district court, filed January 4, 1917, as to de
fendant’s motion to reopen the case and plaintiffs motion for
a decree in accordance with the mandate of the U. 8, cirewit
court of appeals.......ceccec cece cereerrecaeeteeeeeees
Opinion of the district court, filed February 27, 1918, as to
ACCOUNTING 6.6 e ccc cece weer ern nereteeeeeeees - es
Decree of the district court, March 27, 1918.. pecceceoese
Stipulation as to the opinion of the district court, ‘filed ‘Febru
ary 27, 1918, being made a part of the record...... -
Order, April 17, 1918, making opinion filed February 27, 1918,

part of the record in this case.....-.+++-+-+++ neoeuccooees
Statement of CvIdeENCe......-cecereerereccssrssttarnenseneeee
CAPtion coccsccccccccevecsceeessersrrsreserennes

Amended bill of complaint.. sae eceneeend
Amended answer to omental bill of cumptatah.. powenesees
Recital of decree of district court of August 5, 1912......
Recital of opinion of U. 8. circuit court of appeals, Febru
ATY 12, 1916.... 2. eee cece erence eccsreernaees
Defendant’s motion to reopen the case for the introduction
of further testimony........----+-+eeeee onedéenee
Notice of defendant’s motion to reopen case........ —
Affidavit of James Humes in support of motion to re
open the case.
Thomas Kearns in ‘eupgeet of wettee to

R. H. Browne in support of motion to re

open the case. ; :

Interlocutory decree of the district om, Jeuuans 20, 4917
Defendant’s statement as to ore mined from Conkling
CIAIM, Cll. cc cccc cc ccc ccc crcesereeccr ces esrsssesessees

Proceedings, May 14, 1917, defendant granted leave to file
amended statement of account, etc... .-..+e-eeeeee renee
Testimony for defendant........---+eerrcesrenreerewseee
Testimony of Charles P. Brooks.. -
Data of development work Seen | on the ( vonkling
and Arthur claims, 1902, to April, 1916........
Testimony of Thomas L. Walden.....-- +++. +-+eseeee>
Cc. P. Brooks (recalled).......+.«+0+5.
Andrew L. Hurley.........-+sseseeeeee

David Bettla..cccccccccccccevcevesssess

M. J. Dailey (recalled) .........+50006

Letter, Nicholas Treweek ef al. to Silver King
Coalition Mines Company, December 19, 1907..

Priat.

—
—

-

INDEX. Th
Original! Print
letter, Thomas Kearns to Nicholas Treweek et al.
EY Ue ieienaneeebdsseedestnnheneeses 26 174
letter, N. Treweek ef al. to Silver King Coalition
Mines Company, January 6, 1908.............. 26 175
Testimony of C. P. Brooks (recaiied)................ 212 180
Edwin 8S. Maxim............... ‘eoeess 213 181
William Barben............. — Ta 182
tveorge irudeme............... 216 183
Ce Be ccccerescececeen 217 184
et Ap otencsndssemmenosbedien 218 IND
SED |, Heh tet reciaitaeinilebtattenciia tens i 220 186
Excerpt of record showing time of witness ax sta-
See) SEE GP Mndeeteesececesensecenecanae = 187
Testimony of John Forsman......................... 221 187
Stipulation ax to defendant's statement of account. 222 158
Testimony of M. J. Dailey (recatied)................. 222 188
See 2 189
Bart Mahoney.............. reseserees 227 192
En dnencecedheecdesencasa 230 195
Ge. Weedceonewasseceoesee a a4 197
GE Gb GN wecnscaveessoencen 237 200
ND Ce rca csncccunsenmune 41 204

Exhibit 47—Option agreement between DD. P. Robi
fing and Belmont Mining Company and assign

NS Fv cesesccscceseccocsccecetecceccece 242 24
Testimony of J. B. Scholefield....................... 244 206
SD Ge nbecccdccesecseonesenens 2 208

James Toole (recatied)................ “me 210

PE MH meweccceeseceoesesens 251 212

ey Web- Ml nnicncsneunensoneetnnnn 4 214

SD Be icecneccncssceceds one 215

George Holland........ kuulbeeetidbans ot 219
Cornelius J. (Neill (recalled).......... a1 220

Daniel Met'ann (recailed)............. aH 222

©. P. Brooks (recalled) ................ aH 222

Sen ah Bl eneneseeeveseecesse cus 267 225

Se OO Greccncccceccccevececece 269 226

Hl SE idesteuscheteoeceeesesonunss 270 227

WP Ge eecnececcosecccocescecesece 271 227

M. J. Dailey (recaiied)................ 22 228

C. P. Brooks (recalled) ................ 273 229
Certificate of assay of Exhibit 5®................ 275 230
Certificate of assay of Exhibit @0................ 276 231
Certificate of axsay of Exhibit @1................ 276 231
Certificate of assay of Exhibit @2................ 276 222
Certificate of assay of Exhibit @................. 276 22
Testimony of J. I. Scholefield (recalied)............. 2s1 236
(. P. Brooks (recailed)................ Pe) 242

M. J. Dailey (recalied)................ Pant) 243

4. B. Scholefield (recalled)........ -» Bo oH

—_———e CT OE LS NE RE age ta ee a

iv INDEX.

Testimony of M. J. Dailey (recalled).........---+++-
Cornelius J. O'Neill (recalled)
James Humes
John W. Christy ..

Frank Andersen

J. B. Scholefield (recalled)
Thomas Kearn« (recalled)......
David Keith.

Cc. P. Brooks (recalled)
Arthur Meliemald (recalled)
Cornelius J. O'Neill (recalled)
Daniel Met'ann (recalled)
Frank J. Hansen

William F. Dreviin

Frank J. Hansen (reealled)

4. BK. Sehotetield (recalled)

C. . Brooks (reealled)

F. J. Hansen (recalled)

Mining Company and the
American Smetting & Retin
ing Company, Setempher 19
1K o
Pabieltt 2 (lesking cost. oe
thems 10 feet apert)

> Section Ne @

6—Section No. 1

a

™

Sd

i

4m

IY DEX

7-—Hertien Ne 2

SBection Ne

» -Sectiem No 4

Section Ne. 5

11—-Sertien No 6

id Section Ne 7

13 Section Ne *

14-—-Section Ne. &

in—Section SNe bo

Section Ne 11

1j—Section No 12

1S Section No. 15

1)—Section No 14

)—Section Ne. 15

2+—Sketch map of the Alliance
and werkings from

Defendant » Eabiteit

t tenetee

the mouth te the west end
inlets Exh: 45 Map «of Conkling aim and 8 here
werk wes epg’ in 1900 weet
of the 155-fou tine eseept the
( lomittia rane
“—Ietter. Conkling Mining ( ompeny
te Silver King Coalition Minex«
Companys. Nevember 30 1fu~
*—Fins! summary. subject to elimina
ten of ore net from Conkling
ground
—Extract of ore sales from the Si!
ver King Coalition Mines Com.
pany during the period May 11
17. te March 21. 1906
70—Record of crude ore «ld tn thee
Kearns Keith Mining (compe pean ta)
during May and June. 1907
Defendant's Exhibit *¢. Map «hewing surface of what ix
known as the Belmont Mining
(ompeny’s greand. ete
“6—E.xtract of ore «ales from Silver
King Coalition Mines Company
for October, November. and
December, 1faG
W1—Report of James Humex « . _ ro : = Reem:

—

6 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO.
to enter upon and into the Hanauer tunnel, Etna tunnel and the

Apex tunnel belonging to the defendant company, and also,
6 upon and into the Alliance tunnel which on its course runs

into, underneath and beyond the Arthur and Conkling min-
ing claims described in the complaint from its commencement to its
end, and also, into and upon all drifts, winzes, upraises or st from
all parts thereof after it passes into and departs from said Arther
and Conkling mining claims and into the ground adjoining and
belonging to the defendant company and to the face thereof, and also,
to enter upon the surface and all underground workings of the
Walker and Walker Extension, Brave Columbia, Constitution and
Cumberland lode mining claims belonging to and described in the
defendant company’s answer, and to make such inspection and sur-
vey thereof as to the plaintiff's and their experts and surveyors may
deem important and will illustrate and aid in determining the apex
and dip of the vein, lode or ledge described in the anewer of def
ant as apexing within said last named mining claims belonging t
defendant and to measure and determine the course and strike of |
apex of said vein and dip thereof, and also to measure and deter-
mine the amount and value of the ore that may have been mined
by the defendant company from and underneath the surface of said
Conkling and Arthur lode mining claims and to determine and
measure the dip, strike and apex of the vein or lode upon which said
ore body is deposited; all to be done in such way as to give as little
inconvenience to both parties as circumstance will permit.

Done in open court the 30th day of June, A, D. 1908,
J. A, MARSHALL,
Judge

Filed June 30, 1908.
JERROLD R. LETCHER,
Clerk.

Amended Bill of Complaint.
(Filed in the U. 8S. Circuit Court July 5, 1909.)
In Equity.
No. 307.
ConkKLinc Mixino Company, a Corporation, Complainant,
vs.
Sitver Kine Coarition Mines Company, a Corporation, Defendant.

To the Honorable the Judges of the Circuit Court of the Unitet
States in and for the District of Utah:

The Conkling Mining Company, a corporation organized and
existing under the laws of the State of Utah, and a citizen of the State
of Utah, by leave of this Court first had and obtained, files this, i

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. Ys. CONKLING M. CO. 7
\inended Bill of Complaint, against the Silver King Coalition
; Mines Company, a corporation organized and existing under
the laws of the State of Nevada, and a citizen of the State of
Meads: and thereupon vour orator respectfully represents and
alleges

I.

That on or about the seventeenth day of September, A.D. 1908
Nicholas Treweek and J. Leonard Burch. the original complainants
herein. caused your orator to be duly Incorporated under the laws
of the State of Utah for the purpose and pursuit of mining

That the capital stock of your orator was paid for upon the in
corporation of said company by a conveyance and transfer te your
orator bw said Nicholas Treweek and J. Leomard Burch of all their
night. tithe and interest (heing an undivided three-fourths) in and
the Conkling Lode Mining Claim, patented ae US. Lot No. 689,
and the Arthur Lode Mining Claim. patented as U.S. Lot No. 690,
situated in the Uintah Mining Distriag. County of Summit and State
@ Viah, and also by an assignment and transfer to vour orator of all
manner of actions and causes of actions, suits, duce. deniatneds, con
inmversies and accounting of every kind and nature whatsoever in
favor of said Nicholas Treweek and J. Leonard Burch against the
defendant herein.

Il.

That said defendant corporation was organized and incorporated
wider the laws of the State of Nev ada, on or about the month of
May, 1907, to consolidate and take over sundry mining claims and
properties, including the Kearns-Keith Mining Company and the
Silver King Mining Company. respectively corporations. which sand

hamed companies theretofore and for a long time had been en-
gaged in the business of mining in the Mining District where said
Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims are situated.

That in and by said consolidation and merger the defendant cor-
poration succeeded to the interest then and theretofore owned by
“id Kearns-Keith Mining Company in and to said Conkling end
Arthur Lode Mining Claims, viz., an undivided one-fourth (1%)
iMterest therein.

That on or about the twenty-second day of September, 190%, said

earns-Keith Mining Company, predecessor in interest and grantor
& the defendant herein, became the owner of said undivided one-

fourth (14) interest in and to said Conkling and Arthur Lode
Mining Claims, and ever since continued to be the owner
thereof until the same was transferred to and merged in the

( nt company as aforesaid, to wit, on or about the twenty-
minth day of May, 1907.

se PEE OO = EE A me rN ee a

enn

« SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO.

(II1.}

That during all of the times said Kearns-Keith Mining
was the owner of said undivided onefourth (%) interest in «
Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims, the said Nicholas Ti
week, as tenant-in-common with said Kearns-Keith Mining Cor
pany, was the ewner of an undivided one-half (1) interest in a
to said mining claims and each of them.

That upon the transfer by said Kearns-Keith Mining Compa
to the defendant as aforesaid, said Treweek continued to be a tenat
in-common with the defendant herein in said mining claims a
each of them, and so continued to be until the transfer to vour orat
as here-hefore alleged.

Vv.

That said J. Leonard Burch since on or about the sixteenth 4
of May, 1906. until the tran-fer to vour orator herein, was @
owner of an undivided one-fourth (-/4) interest in and to «
Conkling and Arthar Lede Mining Claims. That as such own
since said sixteenth day of May. 1906, he was a tenant-in-comme
with said Kearns-Keith Mining Company in said mining cain
and each of them until the time of the transfer by said Kear
Keith Mining Company of its interests therein to the defenda
herein, and since the time of said transfer he was a tenant-in-con
mon with the defendant herein in said claims and each of then
until he transferred his interests to your orator as hereinbefo

alleged.
y

That on or about the twenty-third day of February, 1892 @
United States of America by its letters patent granted to the Ba
Mining Company. a corporation, those certain premises called tt
Conkling Arthur Lode Mining Claims, respectively situated i
the Uintah Mining District, County of Summit, then Territory, ne
State, of Utah. said Conkling Lode Mining Claim being particular!
bounded and described in said patent. to wit. }

“Bounded, described and platted as follows, with magnetic var
tion wen oy degrees at wy minutes —

inning at corner No. 1, a pine our inches squat

marked U. 8. 689 p. 1.
9 Thence first course north twenty-one degrees and nin

minutes west three hundred feet to discovery point six hut
dred feet to corner No. 2, a pine post four inches square
U. 8. 689 p. 2, being also corner No. 4, of Lot No. 191, the Lined
lode claim, and corner No. 2 of Lot No. 580, the Pirate King lod
claim from which U. 8S. mineral monument No. 4 bears nort
thirty-two degrees and fifty-two minutes west nine hundred am
thirty-nine and three tenths feet distant. and a pine tree four imehe
in diameter marked U. 8. 689 P. 2 B. T. bears north thirteen degree

west twenty-eight feet distant.

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. va. « ONKLING M. Co. 9

Thence second course. south “Ixty degrees and forty-five minutes
west one thousand five hundred feet to corner No. 3
Thence third course south twenty-one degrees and nine minutes
east ix hundred feet to corner No. 4

Thence fourth course north sixty degrees and ferty-tive minutes
rast one thousand five hundred feet to corner No. 1. the place of
beginning; said lot No. G89 extending one thousand five hundred
feet in length along said Conkling vein or lode. and containing
Wwenty acres and forty-five hundredths of an acre of land more or
And said Arthur Lode Mining Claim leing particularly bounded
and described in said patent, to wit:

“Bounded, described and platted as follows, with magnetic varia-
hon seventeen degrees and twenty minutes cast.
Beginning at Corner No. 1, a pine post four inches square, marked
C8. 690 P. 1. with mound of stones heing alee corner No. 1 of Lot
Xo, 689. the Conkling Lode claim.

» first course, north twenty-one degrees and nine minutes
wet, three hundred feet to discovery point, six lundred feet te
comer No. 2. a pine post four inches square marked US. G0 Pp 2
® mound on stones. being also corner No. 2 of said Lat No. 689.
comer No. 2, of Lot No. S80. the Pirate King Lode Claim. |
comer No. 4, of Lot No. 191, the Lineoln Lode Claim, from whieh
U.& Mineral Monument No. 4 bears north thirty-two degrees and
4wo minutes west nine hundred and thirty-nine and thres-
tenths feet distant: and a pine tree four inches in diameter tnarked
C8. 690 P.2B. T. in mound of stones bears north thirteen degree.

=~ eS

i |

i i,

nee, second course, north seventy-six degrees and fifty-

seven minutes east nine hundred and fifty-one and eight
tenths feet to corner No. 3.
Thence third course south, twenty-one degrees and nine minttes
at one hundred and thirty eight and eight tenths feet intersect
line 2-3. of Lot No. 342, the Pay Rock No. 2. lode claim, at north
degrees and twenty minutes east one hundred and thirty-
our tenths feet from corner No. 3. three hundred feet
line 3-4 of said lot No. 342. at south seventy-two degrees
forty minutes east one hundred and five and three-tenths feet
corner No. 3 six hundred feet to corner No. 4.
course south seventy-six degrees and fifty-sever
- ft o~ —e oe tenths feet to
, the place inning. Expressly exc ing and ex-

these presents all that pastien of the po. herein-
described embraced in said mining claim or survey No, 342.
HM that portion of said Arthur vein or lode, and of all
and ledges, throughout their entire depth, the tops or
which lie inside of such excluded ground ; said Lot No. 690
nine hundred and fifty-one and eight tenths feet in

said Arthur vein or lode, the granted premises in said
ao actes and eighty-two hundredths of an acre of
or less.”

i

eeyret af ge
ea
iH
q
z
:

}

:

SILVER KING COALITION MOO vs. CON KLING WTO

vi

card moning
de for the ores and minerals therem

said aimee, That

vil

STTETEEESS EY Peetatedagese

ta mails Hat i
dale Hi + Ht . dit
wien GieHiG?. EAH
vedi teat WE
Laer Tait
HUeraauitaiia bath
nati it Hirt : + : al
yuna: aH HALE 1 rr ti
ih iieuhil: APEs

LVER KING COALITION MOO Ve CONKLEIXG w. co il

bat upen information and belief alleges the samme to cxeced om value
the cum of one million dollars ($1,000 000.00,

IX.

orater further alleges that «ad grantors of your crater did,
A thie actin. demand from «ad defend-
account to them. as temant=in-cemnecm wrth ot on ened
claus, for eres and munetals by rt and ite eed grantor
Tom said premises and cdispemed of and for ther just and

share of the value thereef, That «sid defemdant COnpanY
refused to give to said grantor: of your crater any ae
counting whatsoever for the ores ot minerals by said defewdant

company extracted and remwed from said premises, oF
to pay to them or either of them their just. or amy, pa por
thon of the value thereedt.
That after the incorporation of your orator. and after veur ore
succeeded to the rights and interests of «wid Nicholas Treweek
J Leemard im and te ssid mining claims. and each of
to-wit, on or the therteeth day of Nowerber, 190%) your
demanded of aid defendant on eecounting as tenet on
in and to said mining claims and for vour orators just
of the value of the ores mined from underneath the «ur-
Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Clams between
down vertically through the extener bewnderies of
Claims as herein deseribed. That «aid defendant com-

Lier

cE
j
|
i

your orator into the ron ef either of sad miming clare
manner eccount to or with your orator im the premscs

defendant asserts, pretends and claime= a exclusive in-
Tenant-in-common with vour orater) im a portion of

it hundred and thirty-five and
eard Conk Lode Mining Chom, a« here-
your orater. and to haw exclusive
omnes

tf :

vended curtielly foam the fellewing dona"
rem l

bounded on the southwest by the southwest ond lime of onl

. claim as hereinbefore bownded and described on

feet distant therefrom. and by the pe-
lines of said Conkling Mining Claim a« herenn' fore
: and said defendant has given out on weoch. and other.
exclusive mght te enter om upon sud prem.

(#
ef
H
t
1
=

a Ee
:
$ 7
:
1
;
:
'
:
:

STLYER KING COALITION M. OO. V® COR KLING WOT

12

the Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4. and ale leeouer 1 one

that the howndariee of eaid Conkling Clarm as ceeetibed om th

patent theres! and herein. are oa the 7 wer bemnticberw = thennal

he extent of inebuding the and southweet 15.5 fet of od Cob
ing Cte «2 Rene eae @ al

I

ead mvetlapqang and comfletong Siler Hill Neo 4 and Coeter
he benefit of the defendant and
oratet « tenante-in-commen in seid Conkling Lode Mining (
according to their respective interest theremn ae hereinbefore alleged
That the deserigtion of the beratron of sand Comklong Tok Mining
Claim, « described herein. i+ the . esanenseetndiiteentetanmentninantatinetmemianneniitia ated

SILVER KING COALITION M. OO. V8. CONKLING M. Co.

ZF in

vapeegtecegert ntnyy ee tennant
cans a

Hith Myiihy
Ht se

Hybigsesae dp iP
geeeiedhe ae pit itis
PCr eee et
ye ee ule aang! tae
ee Osada erate Abia
ti! iit Pca Hi HE bl
pobgesgcbteetytivaics er
i FTO eau a id
area a atae

MLVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING w. co. 39

(lam. lot No. 215, the “Cunvherland” Lode Mining (lain, Lat
Ne. 216, and the “Monroe Doctrine” Lode Mining Claim, Lot No
27
That the «aid Pinyon and Pinven Extension Mining Cleim &
bounced and described as follows tewit
egening at Pot No‘, and running thence on « trac cours
magnet variatem, 17 deg 20 min. Bast. North 57 dew 20 wan
Wet 20 feet to Pot Neo. 2: thence South 82 dee 25 mein Wee
4 feet to Pot No. 3; theme South 4 dee OO min. Eaet
M11 feet to Pot No. 4: themee North Ju deg. 1) win. Bat 28211
feet to Port No. 1, the place of beginning. From Pou No. 1 United
Sates Mineral Monument No. 4 bears south 43 deg 64 min. Wee
19881 feet diwtant
That the «aid Bose Lode Mining Claim ix bownded and de«erited
as follows
” Ieginning ot Pot Ne 1, and ronning themee on « true
rire. magnetic vermtion, 17 deg 20 wn Ket, South 12
+c 4) em. Eaet 207 6 fort to Pot No. 2. thence South 61 dee 24
mm, Weet 1481.1 feet to Pot No 3; thenee North 13 dee 50 rein
Wet 195.7 fort to Poet No 4: thence North dew 0 win. Pact
W412 feet te Pot No. 1, the place of beginning. From Pot No. 1
CS. Mineral Monument No. 4 bears North 59 deg 15 min, Weet
49 fort distant.
That the said Zephyr Lode Mining Claim is bownded and de-
wribed ws follows
Beginning at Post No 1. and running thence on « true cour.
magnetic variation, 17 deg 20 min. East, North 67 dee 41 min
Fat 567.8 feet to Post No. 2; thence South 48 deg 23 min. Fact
95 feet to Post No. 3; thence South 60 deg 34 min. Wet 5424
feet to Post No. 4: thence North 46 deg. O1 min. Weet 9245 fot to
Pet Not. the place of beginning From Post No TU & Mineral
Berwwnt No. 4 bears North 49 dee G5 mein. Kat 1272.1 fot dic
lant
That the said Brave Columbia Lode Mining Claim in bended
and dex tibed as follows
Reginning at Pot No. 1. and ranning thence in a tree cour.
magnetic variation, 17 deg 20 min. Past. South 45 dee Of win
Wet 206.9 feet ty Pot No. 2: thence South 45 dee 53 min. Feet
W2A2 feet to Poet No. 3: thence North 45 deg OT min. Fat 200
fet to Pot No. 4; thence North 45 deg 32 min. Weet 1437.1 feet to
Pot No. 1, the place of beginning. From Post No. 1 U. 8 Mineral
No. 4 bears North 89 deg 52 min. Bact 1810.1 feet die

he said Constitution Lede Mining Claim ix bewnded and
as follows
feginning at Pot No 1, and running thence on « true course,
Magnet variation, 17 deg. 20 min East. South 42 dee 55 min
feet to Post No. 2; thence South 46 dew 15 min. Fat
6 feet to Port No. 3; thence North 44 deg. 38 min. Eat 201.2
fet to Post No. 4; thence North 46 deg. 15 min. Weet 1426.6 feet
No. 1, the place of beginning. From Post No.1 U.S Mineral

uli
Hei ¥
2433 in 4
ee a pu
diese | tty Ay ata
: jt Hiss j pet if ii sé egal
ae tifa: That En peat
gS Ey ean ude io Pao H EH
eatin if; ry PH ct TEES ial
LA Hee sein
oa] sae 9 ie ge ipeet ie Hiv Ru
ase, f bee! ext the te AH
rr ngjhac* at uit rt alll;
tt sys we sit} Hit a any
i sreite ase ah We wt ul if HH ej
{3 ‘tei tail Tae ia ‘alin
pat I UE ida at
es
-

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. TS CONKLING Mw. OO. 41

57 feet, where, at ite apex and on ite course of atrike, it crows the
settherly «ide line of the anid Bee Mining Claim, to-wit, at ¢ pont
showt 125 feet easterly of the northwesterly corner of the «nid Bows
Mming Claim, at whieh _ at tte apex and on ite course oF etrike,
a cromes the southerly lune of the «ard Zephwr Mining Claim. and
thence. at ite apex and on ite course of ctrike. it traverses in a weeterly
direction the «aid Zephyr Mining Claim for a distance of about 57
fet. where it cromes the weeterty end line of the «ud Zephwr Mining
Gaim, at which point, at ite apex and on ite coure of atrike, nt
cree the located easterly «ide line of the «ad Brave Colunina Min-
ing Claim. and thence on ite course westerly and at ite apex, pases
to and actrome the weatetly lorated erde line of the «nd Brave Colunibta,
om its course of trike and at ite apex traverees the said
(octitation Mining Claim. ereming beth of the beewted aide lines
thereel. and thence on ite course of atrike and af ite apes travere=
the ‘weberiand Mining Claim, eroing beth of the located
te lee there’. and (ence on ite cours and oval

-
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO, 44

wenth paragraph of said amended bill of complaint, otherwise, or
at all, made or caused to be made cunning or any efforts to purchase

ihe interest in said mining claims owned by said Treweek
4] and said Burch, or either of them, or that said Kearns Keith

Mining Company, or anyone on its behalf, represented that
aid interests were of no special value, or that they offered to pay
for wid interests the sum of $15,000 and on more: but this defend-
at alleges that it is a fact that the interest of said Treweek and
aid Burch at said time, and of said complainant in and to saia
Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims, was at said time, and
snow of no great value, for the reason that there has been dis
covered in and beneath the surface of said mining claims no ores
d any especial or great value, and that the res which have been dis-
covered therein belong to and are part and parcel of a vein or lode
having its apex in mining cana and premises, owned, held and
posed by this defendant, since its incorporation, and prior
thereto, by its predecessors in interest, as hereinafter particularly
#t forth and alleged, and as to when the said Treweek and the said
burch first had any suspicion, as alleged in the 13th paragraph of
aid complaint, this defendant has no knowledge or information,
and therefore leaves the said complainant to make such proof thereof
wit may be advised.

This defendant, answering paragraph numbered 14 of said
mended bill of complaint, denies that after any failure whatever,
#any time whatever, to purchase any interest of said Treweek and
Burch, or either of them, in said Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining
(ims, as alleged in said amended bill of complaint, or otherwise,
wat all, the said Kearns Keith Mining Company, did, during the
month of April, 1907, or at any other time, or at all, purchase from
the Belmont Mining Company, a corporation, for the consideration
tamed in said amended complaint, or any other consideration what-
ever, the Custer No. 2 and the Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims,
w either of them, then owned by said Belmont Mining Company,
@ took a conveyance for the same, or either of them, in the name
4 Thomas Kearns, trustee, or any other person whomseever, and
denies that upon the incorporation of this defendant, the said Thomas

. a trustee, wrongfully conveved the said mining claims, or
either of them, exclusively, to the defendant herein, and to the
cntrary this defendant alleges that on or about, to-wit: The 6th
tay of April, 1907, the said Thomas Kearns, individually, and for
ad on his own behalf, took and received an assignment of an op-
tion theretofore given and granted by the Belmont Mining Com-
jany to one D. P. Rohlfing, to purchase the said Custer No. 2 and
the said Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims; that thereafter and
@ or about the 10th day of April, 1907, the said Thomas Kearns

did offer to the Silver King Mining Company, a corporation,
® to assign and transfer to it the said option to purchase, so

as aforesaid assigned to him, and on, to-wit: the said 10th
tay of April, 1907, the said Silver King Mining Company did duly
wept the offer of the said Thomas Kearns, and did thereupon
My to the said Belmont Mining Company, the portion of the eon-

78 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO.

sideration to be paid to it, pursuant to the terms of said = wm
and did thereupon direct that the deed from said Belmont Mining
Company should be taken in the name of said Thomas Kearns,
as trustee for said silver King Mining Company, to be ——
by him to the nominee of said Silver King Mining Company;

on, to-wit, the 12th day of April, 1907, the said Belmont Mining
Company did execute a deed of conveyance to said Custer No. 2 and
Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claim, conveying the said claims and
each of them unto the said Thomas Kearns, trustee, and that there
after and upon the incorporation aud organization of this defendant,
and on, to-wit, the ie of June, 1907, at the request and pur.
suant to the agreement entered into by and between the said Thomas
Kearns and the said Silver King Mining Company, the said Thomas
Kearns did convey the said Custer No. 2 and the said Silver Hill
No. 4 Lode Mining Claims to this defendant, and that on said day
thix defendant did complete the purchase of said mining claims and
each of them, by paying the balance of the purchase price then due
thereon to the said Belmont Mining Company; that at no time
whatever did said Kearns Keith Mining Company acquire, have,
hold or possess any estate, right, tithe or interest, of, in or to the
said Custer No. 2 and the said Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims,
or either of them, or in or to any part or portion of either of them;
that no part of the purchase price of said mining claims, or either
of them, was paid or discharged by said Kearns Keith Mining Com
pany, or anyone on its behalf, but that the title to said mining
claims was purchased and paid for by said Silver King Mining Com-
pany and this defendant, as afovesaid, for the sole use and benefit of
said Silver King Mining Company and this defendant admits that
the said Custer No. 2 and said Silver Hill No. 4 Lode wat
Claims were by lette>s patent of the United States, dated June

1904, granted to the Belmont Mining Company, and admits that
said patent was based upon location notices antedating the loc
tion of said Conkling Lode Mining Claim ; and this defendant demes
that the said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims

wrongfully claimed by said complainant to be part and
93 parcel of the said Conkling Lode Mining Claim ;
that any part or portion of said 135.5 foot strip is embraced
within or Senelie’ of forms any part or portion of the said
Conkling Lede Mining Claim.
This defendant denies that at all or any of the times mentioned
in said amended bill of complaint, or while the said Treweek ané—
Burch and the said Kearns Keith Mining © y were tenants
in common in said Arthur and Conkling Lode Mining Claims, that

bill of complaint, or otherwise, or at all, in the actual, constructive
or any ne os whatever of any part or portion of the said 1355
foot strip of the said Conkling Lode Mining Claim, as set forth and

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. Co. “9

dleged in said amended bill of complaint, or otherwise; and denies
that the purchase by the said Thomas Kearns and this defendant and
aid Silver King Mining Company, a= hereinbefore alleged, of said
(wter No. 2 and said Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims, or
dither of them, from said Belmont Mining Company, was at all
made while said Kearns Keith Mining Company, or sid Treweek
«said Borel as tenants in common of said Arthur and Conkling
Lede Mining Claims, or either of them, were in the posession of any
art or portion of the said 195.5 foot strip, mentioned in said
mended complaint, or otherwise, and denies, as it has heretofore
denied, that «aid Kearns Keith Mining Company and said Treweek
wd said Burch were tenants in commen or any part or portion of sad
(54 foot strip or that any part or portion of said 135.5 foot strip
wer Was, at any time, part or parcel of the said Conkling Lode Min-
ng Claim: and this defendant denies that at the time of the purchase
w said Thomas Kearns, trustee, of said Custer No. 2 and said Silver
fill Ne. 4. Lode Mining Claims, that any ore bodies whatever had
wen found or discovered within any part or portion of said 1355
fot trip. and alleges that no ore was developed or found within said
5.5 fot trip until long after the purchase of said Custer No. 2
wd Silver Hill Neo. 4 Lode Mining Claims, and the convevance
thereof to this defendant, as hereinbefore alleged, and denies, a= it
we hereinbefore denied, that said Kearns Keith Mining Company
wd said Treweek and said Burch ever were, at any time whatever,
wnants in common, the one with the other, in or to any part or
portion of «wid 135.5 foot strip, or in or to any of the ores or ore
dies therein contained, and this defendant denies, as it has herein-
before denied, that said KearnsKeith Mining Company, ever
4 «at any time whatever, purchased said Custer No. 2 or said
Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claim, and admits that neither
this defendant, nor any of its grantors, held or claimed any right or
interest in or to any part or portion of said 125.5 foot strip until
the purchase and conveyance to this defendant of the same, as part
wd parcel of said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining
“aime. ax hereinbefore alleged. but this defendant denies that this
#fendant and its grantors and predecessors in interest did not have
my right. tithe or ownership in or to the lodes or veins in said
fmkling Lode Mining Claim, as hereinbefore in this answer de-
«tibed, and in and to the ores and veins in said 135.5 foot 4
forexaid, part and of said Custer No. 2 and said Silver Hi
So. 4 Lode Mining Claim ; and on the contrary this defendant alleges
that it and its predecessors in interest, at all times alleged that it and
te predecessors in interest, at all times alleged and claimed that it
and its predecessors in interest were the owners of and entitled to all
the ore bodies, veins and lodes in and beneath the surface of the
aid Conkling Lode Mining Claim and the said Arthur Lode Mining
Chim and said 135.5 foot strip, by reason of its and its predecessors
it interest, ownership of the apex of the veins or lodes in which such
ot bodief are found, as hereinafter in this answer specifically set forth
id alleged. And this defendant denies that either it, or any of its
predecessors in interest, have been, at any time whatever, or now is,

ee ee)

bal HLVER KING COALITION M. OO. VE. CONKLING M. co,

& tenant im commen with «wid plaintiff or any of ite predeceum
m interest of, in or te any part . portion of sud 135.5 fout arp, «
any of the one found of contend therm And thie defenden
wlwit+ that «od Kearn Keath Mining 4 comenpeanns bevet tate
tdependent Lom. or any cle whatever, te any part or portion d
eakl 155.5 fot ry, or any of the one of qumerals therem op
tated | beet thie defendant denies that it and ite predecessors in ip
tetest toads te ctebeqendeont on ether claun adverse to sad
aut, or any of its predeoe ot in interest, in of to anid 135.5 fon
of any pert there’, antil the Tith day of April, 1908, and on te
contrary the defemedant alleges that rt and its predecessors on umteret
have at all tees tone shipgving ore, 6.581 tone milling ore - value Se 242 FH

The eipewse chargeable to ore mined
i the Conkling growed tin 1909 wee as

fdleve s

Wining 1.741 tone @ 65.07 per tom 26
MWiat “ @ima * sou
Sapling & Tramming ©) T Shipping

i & @.e.. ee)
‘mpling & Trameing 1.908 T ‘Concen

mie & Go . o SS.S76.00
ne ie eee ee ee 41,129.00
Upper Coal Bim... .......-- cece cece cece cee eer cer sereeercrseers 3,742.10
Re Deemeh . occ ccc cccweseccvesersccesvecsnseccsvesveesres 27,781.00
Water and Fire System... ......-.60-c ec ceee eee er ere eneeeeerees 27,745.00
TN oe came RENE ENE Ree Nee SeerTeE! ee euErevers 314,695.00

Mill Building and Machinery..........--------+++++ $145,212.00

Machine Shop ...... 0.20. -sccccccccseccscceess - 2,681.00

—— 147,893.00

Total Building, Machinery and Equipment..........-.--- $462.588. 0

All of which buildings, machinery, trams, etc., were used, and necessarily
used, in the mining, extraction, treatment and marketing of the ores taken
from the Conkling ground.

Interest at 8% per annum on the above expenditure should properly le
charged against all ore mined and milled except that shipping (or first class)
ore should not be charged with interest on Mill Expenditure. Such a charge
from May tk, 1997, to June 30, 1910, would be as follows:

Interest at 8% Interest at 8%

on $314.696 .00 on $147,893.00
SD es, TE, vicnduduveusscesuvteresives $16,783.73 $7 887.68
12 ” oe 25,175.60 11,831.44
12 se ivcteabend ene eaed dkeienue 25,175.60 11,831.44
Be tT ciccndedbebudeedsteeetens 12,587 . 80 5,915.72

wa

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO. 115

The following summary shows the total ore extracted each year from all
of its properties, including that extracted from the Conkling claim, and the
proportion of the above charge to be made to each ton:

Extracted. Tons. Interest. Rate per ton.
1907 32,532 $16,783.73 51¢
1908 40,710 25,175 0 61¢
1908 ASAT 25,175.60 46¢
1910 20,607 2.587 . 80 61¢
Milled.
1907 19,360 7,887 .63 41¢
1908 22,912 41,831.44 52¢
1909 31,286 11,831.44 38¢
1910 14,392 5,915.72 41¢

The tonnage extracted from the Conkling ground and the interest charge
able thereto is as follows:

Shipping Ore.
1907 1,613 Tons @ 5l¢........... 822.63
1908 1197.5 “ @ Gl¢........... 720.47
1909 860 a 0 een 395 . 60
1910 242 MP rier ner wes 147.62
WE vevens Se Ce eT ee $2,086.32
Milling Ore.
1907 3,226 Tons @ 92¢............ 2,967 .92
1908 238 “ @1.13........... 2,695 . 05
131
1908. 6885 “ @ 0.84........... 5,780.04
oe eee ORR ia cicceses 1,975.74
Total

ORES N rv érecreds é§eedwedneceers $13,418.75

Grand Total May 1, 1907, to June 30,
DN Mc wucive peuppawaieied se tecuas.. $15,505 .07

_The hearing commenced Monday, May 14, 1917, and the follow.
ig proceedings were had:

Defendant Granted Leave to File A mended Statement of Account.)

Mr. Dickson: I ask leave, if your Honor please, to file an amended
«count; the amendments I have called Mr. Critchlow’s attention to,
‘me of them are due to errors that I got into in making computa-
wns, some of which are to our advantage and some of them are to
advantage of the Conkling Mining Company. I think they
y cancel each other. There is one error though in the cost per

116 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M, ©0,

ton in mining during the years 1915 and 1916, which accounts for
the principal difference in the amount which we allege to be due to
the complainant.

The Court: It may be filed.

Mr. Dickson: In 1907 in the account heretofore filed 1 had
1,6291% tons of first class ore. That should be 1,612 tons of first
class ore.

I had 3.379 tons of second class; that should be 3.226.

In 1908, in the statement heretofore filed, I had 1,249'2 tons of
first class which should be 1,19714 tons.

1 had 2,498 tons of second class; should be 2.385.

In 1909 I had 763 tons of first class; it should be 560 tons.

I had 8.011 tons second class; should be 6,681.

In 1909 I had 156 tons first class; which should be 242 tons.

I had 1,638 tons of second class; should be 1,937.

132 (Testimony for Defendant.)

Cuarces P. Brooks, a witness for the defendant, testified as fol-
lows:

My name is Charles P. Brooks. I am 65 years old and by oect
pation a civil and mining engineer. I graduated from the Sheffield
Scientific School, Yale College in 1870, and have practiced my pre
fession continuously ever since.

(At this point maps were marked by the reporter exhibits 1 to 20,
inclusive).

(Witness, continuing:) Maps from 1 to 20 have mostly been plat-
ted from the notes of surveys made by myself. Some of the note
were made by Mr. Anderson, engineer for the plaintiff Company.

Map “A” Conkling Mining Company vs. Silver King Coalition
Mines Company showing the development work done for the Conk-
ling and Arthur claims 1902; April 1916, scale 50 feet to the inch.
The Conkling is represented by two lines—black and red. The red
lines represent the ground as marked by the monuments, the black
iines according to the calls in the patent.

At the point marked Station 660 and drift, the main Alliance tut
nel runs to the southwest to a point marked drift, started October
27. 1908, which is the Teddy drift connecting with the Silver Hill
Station. There is a drift running from the Silver Hill shaft back
to the east connecting with the Elephant stope. * * * Part
the Conkling as described in its patent has been patented to the U. J.
Wenner. It is shown on the map in pink. a

There is a small triangular piece colored blue, survey No. Glos
patented to the Show-Me lode. There is also a large strip colored
yellow, in which occur the figures “24 850," which is a portion
the Custer No. 2 lode, survey No. 4850.

(It was here stipulated that the Custer No. 2 and the Silver Hill
claims are the properties of the defendants. )

i at ania ODE IES EDL DOES OP ny Ra SCOT MO

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO. 117

The conflict with the Silver Hill No. 4, survey 4850 is shown on
the map by the area colored green.

Exhibit No, 2 is marked “Conkling Mining Company vs. Silver
King Coalition Mines Company, Sheet No. 1,.— feet

From Station 1173 plus 11'>—from that point out te State
1174 i= BY feet From the lave of the west line of the Arthur down
to where the work connects with the main tunnel i about 45 feet.
from where it connects with the tunnel to the seutherly face w here
vou find the date February 25, TW, 2M! feet

From station 1176 to Station 1177-4 i« about 50 feet, b rem
1177-4 northerly vo where we have the date February 25, 1908, »
L354, feet.

Coming back to station where the face was when Treweek left
off. October 30, 1891, from that face westerly to station 1176 &
100 feet. From station 1177-4 westerly to station 577 plu 65
about S79 feet.

Taking the distance from station 577 plus 6 back te station 1174
plus 11. that distance would be G74 feet.

1 made my first survey im there after the K-K Company took
charge in December, 1902. The next one was February 25, 1998 ,
the next one June 22. 1903; the next ome ic marked July 25, 1904—
just west of station 601.

In making my computation of the work done under the Kh
management, | have not included anything outside of the line af
the Conkling as described in the patent

1 will give the distances from station 557 im a westerly directes
taking in the littl croscut as I go along. From station Byri
6 to 604 plus 25 equals 207 feet, heavy ground, tint ered ated
5 tegen 0 Go ceased en the map there.

From 607 plus 25—at 601 there is a drift running to the outh-
cast 56 feet, designated at the face “October 18, 14."

From station 601 plus 10 there ix « drift running a little ent
westerly 38 feet marked “October U8, 1904.” February 2
1905, 8. H. at the end standing for bulkhead,” to held the walt
back. That is also all within the Conkling.

Starting from 604 plus 25, from there to 605 plas 10, it & @
feet, at pong wd oe a drift starts off marked “drilled hole drift.”
this I have included just what lies within the Conkling claim.

jon is about 15 leet.
From 605 plus 10 to G60 equals 200 feet, heavy ground, tr

_

SILVER KING COALITION M. 00. VS. CONKLING M. 08, 121
bered and «piled; 660 ix right at the mouth of the MeKay cro
eut

138 From 660 te 664 whieh ix on the end line of the Conkling
as deseti! ed in the patent, i« a distance of 185 feet

i tation G61 from the main drift a drift te the right, (> feet,
eran, marked “February 20, 15.”

Coming back te station 660. at which peut the Mekay crecut
@ marked leaves the main line of working: cactetly and westerly,
we have, running from 660 te 660 plas 00) 190 fect marked January
1 1906. That i« not really the date of my survey beeaner that
work war being driven right through. and the date of my survevs
pat there im Mack, February 20, Jame 11, and that interpolated ;
dided tap in that time, running up te that date

1 wae trying te comply with coumeel = request te give thee sanvnevennet
d work dene in cach calendar wear, and that & the only way we
could de it interpelating between the two dates propertrenmatels

February 20, 1905, it wae at the point marked-in black “February
0, 1905"; Jame 1, 1906, it wae at the potet marked oo black right
ander the better “K™ in MeKaw. Between thee pevtte PT hewe ap
proximated the face ax it wae on January 1, 1H

From Jawaary 1, 1906, te Jaweary 1, 17, i 284 feet Todd
ot make a survey January 1. 1907. 1 needs ce Jame TT, 16,

tuber 6, 1906, June 2, 107
have indicated the face ae nearly ae 1 could apy Tekitnate en
the firet of January, 190%

From 1907, January I4.—to Jannwery 1, 18 —thete © 1 feet
@tiven on the MeKay eros-cut pedicated by Staten TE pla 10,
January 1, 1908, approximate; past below station 14 scone to he
% feet to the point marked That would be deme mm dewey |
1% and prier to 1909. it would be %) feet at the pool marked
@ation 2010. the drift rans off 110 feet te helper reevived 63.25 « day. and deveted half of bie tome to
te werk, We aleo had «a watehonan whee date it wae to wrth the
works, help dump the train that came out and keep a fire in the
ry room where we dried the miners’ clothes The wach man re
cowed 82.50 a dav.

We hia A” timber-franer ales, whe fratneed tivehers in the slav-
tee and helped dump the cars on the den We hed a reper mean
those duty it was to fix the ditch and track and ties keep the treet
@ and keep it in repair and work on the ditch here was a lot of

ee eer —

138 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO.

work necessitated in keeping the track up on account of the low
of water. We did not keep the repair man there all the time. but
sometimes we had three or four repair men working on the diteh at
the same time. Repair men received $3.25 a day.

We used also about 50 pounds of powder in twenty-four Lours,
It cost $5.95. That was about an average. We used about 120 feet
of fuse in 24 hours. which cost fifty-five cents. ,

We used caps, about 24 in twenty-four hours, cost thirteen cents,
Also about a quarter of a box of candles a day, $1.07. Then for oil
we spent about twenty-two cents a day. We had also two horses
employed all the time, cost $1.00 a day for grain and hav for the

horses.
159 The machines cost, we estimated, $1.50 a day, including
the fittings to keep them up.

Daily expense for air hose was $1.60; blacksmith coal about sixty
cents a day. We had to haul the coal from the railroad depot by
wagons and sleighs, a distance of a mile and a quarter, or a mile and
a half,

The air pipe, including the fittings, everaged about fifty-eight eents
a day. We had two kinds of pipe. The 10-inch pipe we used for
ventilation, and the 2-inceh pipe for the compressor. The ten ineh
air pipe was $2.25 a day, for 24 hours, and the black iren pipe
fifty-eight cents a day.

Our rails cost us $36.00 a ton. The average cost per 24 hours for
rails was sixty-four cents. Then there were splices for rails. . The
cost of these for 24 hours would be twenty-two cents, and there are
track spikes. The cost of these per day would be sixty cents; track
holts ten cents; two inch plank for covering the track so the men
could travel back and forth, those planks cost ninety-six cents a day.

There was Oregon fir used for ties across the diteh, The cost of
that per day was twenty cents. Ties cost twenty-six cents a day.

Power from the Silver King Mine cost us $4.00 for 24 hours.

I have an item here under the head of miscellaneous, tool steel,
picks, shovels, carts, shoeing horses, repairs on harness, ete., estl-
mated cost per day $2.00, which I think is a fair and reasonable
estimate.

Then I have an estimate of timber used in the very bad ground,
94% board feet. 8 by 8. That is as near as | remember what we
put in there. It cost $28.75 a thousand.

I have recently gone through the Crescent drift with Mr, Brooks.
I pointed out to him the 60 feet of very bad ground I spoke of
yesterday. There was 470 feet of ground outside of that 60 feet of
ground that had to be spiled. I pointed that out to Mr. Brooks
correctly. That was about six weeks ago. That 60 feet of ground 1s
here near the Drill-hole drift, It is indicated on the map by an
arrow pointing to 60 feet. The other 470 feet is shown on the map,
207 feet here. 207 feet from Station 577 plus 6 to 604 plus 25. The
other 200 feet was just bevond the 60 feet westerly. That was all
heavy ground that had to be spiled with a good deal of water. We
spiled it overhead and on the sides.

Outside of this 60 feet and exclusive of the 470 fect of spiling

REE" PY AZT PP TORR IY AIRS LIS: IIH CE a OE ar inca eRe AOC TR

—_

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO. 139

ground, the balance I estimated to cost $15.38 a foot. I
160 estimated the cost of the 60 feet at $61.00, and some cents,
and of the 470 feet, $26.00 and some cents.

I knew the expense of miners, muckers, repair men, watchmen,
trammers, skinners, foremen, blacksmith, blacksmith’s helper, cost
of timbers, powder, fuse, and the quantity of such material we would
use in 24 hours. I was familiar with the entire cost of the various
items, the cost of which entered into the doing of the work.

Cross-examination of Mr. Walden:

I was foreman engaged to look after the men, keep their time,
and I kept it. I commenced the work at station 666, where I com-
menced the two drifts. This was a prospect tunnel, and | was sup-
posed to follow the vein there and I followed it by my own judgment.

We were attempting to make the tunnel about four and a half or
five feet. There was a track in the bottom and under the track there
was water,

1 found very bad ground—not the worst ground—the very bad
ground beginning at station 577. That 55 foot drift at station 601
was a prospect drift, and the one on the east side beginning at station
601 plus 10 was a lost heading. We lost out in driving that and had
to come back and change our course a little. There was a heavy
volume of water there. The size of the 56 foot cross-cut going out
from station 601 was about seven feet high, and five or six feet wide.
It was in fair ground,

In doing this work we were trying to follow the course of the
vein. T cannot tell you how extensive the timbering was, but I
should judge that one-third of the work was timbered at any rate.
Ierannot say with certainty how much of the 1.063 feet was timbered,
I know we used some timber in that 1.063 fect. and it ts a part of the
charge of $15.38 a foot.

C. P. Brooxs recalled for the defendant. testified as follows:

The Alliance tunnel from its mouth to the west end line of the
Conkling as described in the patent is in round numbers a little
over ten thousand feet.

I am familiar with all the werk done on or beneath the surface
of the Conkling claim, and I know of no work on that claim on
or beneath the surface except as is shown on the maps which have

been introduced in evidence, except there are a few little holes
161. dug in the surface soils; do net know of any extensive work

done on the surface. If there were some I would know of it.
There are some prospect holes; might be some little drifts in twenty or
thirty feet. I never surveyed them, [have seen little depressions
in the ground which led me to believe the work had been done in
sme prospect holes; how much they were | could not tell, and the
sie of which you could estimate by the size of the dumps. 1 never
aw anything on the surface that exceeded fifty feet in depth. It
was all apparently very old work, probably patent work for the

ms,

140 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO.

In respect to the heights in the Elephant stope, the first record |
have of it is on January 29, 1908. It is marked on the map 9 feet
high, 3 feet under track. That is right at the north side west of the
K-K raise.

The next one is at a point marked by the arrow from the end of
which reads “13 feet high, 5 feet under the track.” That is at
about the center of the north easterly end of the stope. The stope
was extended five feet below the track and from the bottom to the
top was 13 feet. That was January 29, 1908.

At a point at station 366 to the right of that is marked 12 feet
high, then there is a mark “filled, January 29, 1908," and at the
south east end of that line where it intersects the south side line of
the Elephant stope is marked 10 feet high,

On September 29, 1908, [ made a survey through a portion of
this stope with Frank Anderson. We were at station 3041; the origi-
nal station 3041 is at the word “chute” marked so on this map, ex-
hibit 2, as 3041. At that point the height of the stope was 74 feet;
we ran to 3041 A. so marked on Exhibit 2.0 That is right almost on
the west end line, within a foot. At that point the height of the
stope is marked 7 feet. From there we ran southwesterly down to
a place marked “September 20, 1908," at a distance of plus 21 feet.
Along this line the height of the stope is marked. it would be in
the neighborhood of 2082, as shown on this map, 6.2 feet. It is 17
fect west of the west end line. At the face the height of the stope
is marked “8.5 feet.” These elevations or heights of the stopes are
taken where we could see any change made in the average: they are
intended to be average heights, along those sections.

Mr. Anderson and I both took them earefully and agreed upon

those average heights, because it is impossible to read in an
162 irregular stope, you have got to average the floors and the

roof. You cannot measure them to feet because you would
have a million measurements. We only take the average as near
as we can measure by our eve in order to estimate the volume.

Starting again at 3041, we go north to 3041-B, at that point we
have the height of the stope marked 6.2 feet. That is 114% feet
inside the Conkling. From that point we have a drift stope anf
running out to a point indicated by this broken and dotted Tine.
The stope drift in its north side is marked “September 29, 1908,
and the note “average width 6 feet, average height 61, feet,” fora
length of 651% feet. That drift crosses the westerly end line of the
Conkling. ve

Our next point is from 3041-B to 8041-C, so marked on Exhibit
9. a distance of 11.85 feet. The height of the stope at 3041-C Is
4.2 feet. That is inside the Conkling. Then from that point we have
a line represented in green on this map—and | will say right here
that the green lines represent surveys made in common by Mr. Ander-
son and myself—joint survey lines. That line is running from
3041-C out to a point marked by an elevation mark of 911.0. inside
the Conkling. We have the height at the end of that marked 6 feet.

I have a point plus 1215 feet on that line, the height of the

een POPIIOF OR IFS I ae Ne ES SPOR I IAI RETA! BE RIN BS —

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. Co. 141

stope marked 6 feet; that is, 121 feet from 3041-C, along that green
line, height equal to 6 feet.

From 3041-C we have another green line running in a northeast-
erly direction, It is running from 3041; all these are running from
SH41-C and running to a point marked by an elevation 907.8; the
height of the stope at that point is 3 feet. Then from 3041-C we
have another line represented in green running north easterly. It
rans from 3041-C and ends on the edge of the stope at an elevation
marked 910.6 feet. The height of the stope as marked in the notes
at that point was 2 feet, that is between the end of that green line
and the one previously given, and then in the edge of the stope. I
have about the middle of that point the mark “H” equal to five-tenths
of a foot.

At a point on the edge of the stope and about opposite to the
figure “S” in 1908, south of this other, I have the mark “Height of
sttope 2 feet.”

From 3041-C we run to 3041-D. We start from 3041-4C. Tt is a

distance of 40 feet practically. IT have a height marked at
lis SOAT-D, the height of the stope is equal to 6.7 feet. The

height of the stope at 3041-44 is 4.2 feet. The height of the
tope at BO4T-D is 6.7 feet.

It would be a line drawn from these two heights that would
sive you the average roof and floor. There is one intermediate one,
il feet at 19 feet from 3041-C.

Now beginning again at 3041-D and running southwesterly fol-
Wing a green line to the edge of the stope, which is practically
on the west end line of the Conkling, the height of the stope at that
point was 8 feet; that is a little east of station 478.

From station 3041-D we go to station 3041-E, which is marked
it the Wet Chute so marked by figures 3041-E. From 3041-E we
mun southwesterly to 3041-F, which is just under the letter “H”
og stope, and is so marked with an arrow pointing to the station
3041-F

At a point plus 39 feet, there is a course taken to the southeast
if 161 feet, at the end of which it hits the edge of the stope and
is a “Height of stope 7.3 feet—midway between sections 1
and 2.

From Station 3041-F running in a southwesterly direction to the
fae and indicated by a broken green line running to the face of
the stope marked “September 29, 1908,” the elevation or height
if the stope is 714 feet. That is 14 feet west of the west end line
of the Conkling.

Mt a point between the words “August 24, and September 29,
= underneath the Hat stope, the height of the stope is 314
eet.

Then | have a drift stope running from Station 3037 to face.
“37 is between sections 7 and 8 in the Joint Survev stope. At
that point I have a note “stoped overhead,” and from that point is
‘course south two degrees and thirty minutes east, which takes you
lo the south edge of the Joint Survey stope, marked “Edge of stope,
Wethead, six feet high.”

142 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M., CO.

From Station 3037 running north, 87 west, 12 feet to the edge
of the stope, we have a width marked across there 10 feet, and under
that is 7 feet high, which means an average height across that point
of 7 feet.

Then T have a number of seetions made on the drift running
from Station 3087 southwesterly to its face, 45 feet. At plus
there ix a section. That would be the section line 6. There isa

section in my book which shows the bottom of the stope to be
16d 16 feet on the left hand side of the line as you go to the

southwest, 2.4 feet on the right hand side of the line as you
go to the west; on the left hand side of the stope the vertical height
was eight feet: on the right hand side of the stope the vertical
height was 5.5 feet: the center of the stope over the line of sight
was 7 feet, and across the top of the left hand side of the center
line it was 7 feet, and on the right hand side it was 4.8 feet.

There is a note made at that point “Average width of ore appears
to be about two feet.” At plus 31 end of showing of ore; at plus
41 T have another section end of showing of ore.

I have a cross-section on the bottom. It is 2 feet to the left of
the line. 3 feet to the right of the line. The sides go up inclined
probably, the first angle being vertically 3% feet above the floor on
the stope, thence goes up vertically 4 feet to the left hand top; on
the right hand side it goes up on an incline for four feet.

The distance across to the top of those two inclined portions on
the left hand side is five feet; on the right hand side four and a half
feet: on the right hand side from that line would be seven and a
half feet to the upper edge.

The next one is the face of that drift, six by six. We took a
section at the face, stoping along drift from Station 3037. It would
be in this joint survey stope—Station 370, whieh is Mr. Anderson's
station, and then to Station 369—Anderson’s station; that is i
the Elephant =tope right east of the chute.

At 3027 we have marked to the left 15 feet; it was 6 feet high right
underneath it. On the right hand side we have the words “Stoped
up 8 feet out; there is no height given at that point.”

At plus 15 from Station 3037 towards Station 370, by Anderson.
we have an elevation of 7 feet high. On that same line going
towards Station 370, at plus 22 feet, we have 7 feet high.

At Station 370 we have the words “Average 7 feet high, from
370 to the left. a distance of 101% feet westerly.”

The edge of the stope on the right hand side is only 1 foot away.
From there it is 40.6 feet to Station 369. At a point 17 feet
to the southwest from Station 369, a bench is marked out to the
right indicated by the line marked “September 30, 1908.” 17 feet
back would be in a stope. About 8 feet from there to the edge of

the stope, and then at a distance of 21 or 24 feet back, the
165 — stope goes 9 and 9.2. making altogether 18 feet and seveD-
tenths back to the edge of the stope with 9.2 feet, with 10
feet at the lower side and indicated on this map by a broken line,
and inside that broken line it is marked 4 feet high, being a
average height. To the west of that broken line and north of Ste

—

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO. 143

ion 370 we have the marks 5 feet high, which would indicate that
fae taken as the average height at that portion of the stope. From
here on we have a note “Drift in line 7 by 7.”

The next survey | made in there was October 27, 1908. I have
verlooked one, Station 3041-E plus 74% feet, height of station 5
et. The next survey I took was January 8, 1909. I can find no
eight at that point. The next one is March 19, 1909.

Beginning at Station 2215, which is a point at the raise about
4 feet southwest from the west end line of the Conkling as patented.

Beginning really at 2123, which is near the raise at the extreme
esterly end of the stope and in a drift running from there to 2213,
hrough the drift at a distance of 1614 feet southeasterly from Sta-
on 2123 along that line there is a course taken to Station 2212,
hich would be at the tope of a raise, 2123, from there we run
rom 2214 to 2215, which is the bottom of the raise. At 2215 the
eight of the stope is 6 feet.

At a point marked by a small “a” the height of the stope is 5
eet. .

These points | am now giving are located about 65 feet south-
wsterly from the westerly end line of the Conkling. From a we
up on a dotted line to 6, height of the stope 7 feet. From there
« go lo ¢ northeasterly, height of the stope 7 feet. From there
«go tod, the height of the stope 7 feet.

From b to ¢, well they are both given as 7 feet; that would be the
Nerage.

At plus 9% feet from d, I have it marked “stoped 7 feet high ;”
t¢no height marked. .

At Station 2212, 6 feet high; at F 5 feet high; at g 5 feet high.
1 marked on exhibit 2, 1 have no height of stope at that point;
ut I have marked from g to h, running along the line off to the
ight of it, height of stope 6 feet, shown by the words “6 feet high,”
bout half way between the two.

From h, the line runs from the face of the old drift or connects

with the old drift. From station 4, or from the top of the

‘i Wet chute I have the measurements of the Hat stope 60

feet long by 15 feet wide. I have the memorandum made

“my note “The old stope is 8 feet high,” then above that is a
wor given us 60 feet long by 15 feet wide and 10 feet high above
le old stope; that would be 10 feet above the 8 feet.

That survey was made March 19, 1909. Then there is a portion
{that stope for 40 feet in which I have “stope 14 feet high,” above
he word “stope”; that would make a total of the two stopes 2? feet.

is what is known as the Hat stope.
aking the Chute stone from the top of the raise, or marked

Chute” here, 18 feet above the drift that goes underneath it was a
(are set, stope 25 feet long by 20 feet wide, the two southerly or
vathWesterly sets, so marked on this map and indicated by a dotted

, Wo sets high.
tom a point 8 feet over Station 2216, | have indicated the level
eath running to station 2217, and on the edge of that sto

Ihave it inarked 7 feet high, edge of stope, over level. That would

.
= © LLPIOLES LOLCLONL BS ODO LE LETTE LEE TEENAGE! SEA DA EE ALE OGL LO AG CO LE LIF ARG

144 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M, CO,

be along this broken line which runs from the chute at 2216, north
easterly; this would be the line of the stope; it is covered really
by this heavy black line, on the west line of the Conkling.

Running out from station 2216, there is a broken red line going
Northwesterly for a distance of 12! 2 feet altogether, making 20 feet,
goes practically in a straight line for 30 feet, and the pout is i
dicated by the dotted lines that are the junction of them, which is
west of the word “junction,” at a distance of 28 feet from the west-
erly end line of the Conkling claim, surveyed for patent.

At that point the height of the stope is 7 feet, Back at a point
121. feet and right about under the “o’ in the elevation height of
S02, the elevation was 7!» feet.

There is another point here marked “stope filled 6 feet high,
‘June 23, 1909." It is in the Chippie drift stope.

Running from 2284 in the Chippie drift stope to 2254-A, from
there I have a portion of that stope measured at that time, running
to the northeast for 20 feet, marked June 23, 1909, and for that
20 feet I have it marked “stoped 6 feet high.”

Running from 2284-A to Station 2284-B, I have the stope marked
in my book “Stoped 7 feet down, same width.” On the other side
“Stoped 7 feet high,” whieh would mean practically two

floors.
167 From 3037-B in the Bench stope, I have the memorandum

June 23, so marked on the map, the edges of it stoped 5 feet
down and 13 feet over this floor. I have marked what is the ail
floor of the Chippie drift stope. stoped 7 feet high. 1 had a survey
made in the Bench stope September 21, 1909. That is the last one
[ think I have in there; first floor up at 2308, plus 14 feet, towards
2309, that is northeasterly direction, and is marked by a little cirele
on the red line between the letters “i” and “f” in drift. At that pomt
the stope was 10 feet high.

Off to the right, between the two stations, it was 10 feet 1
Going back from that station to the southwest to the face 21 feet
about half way between, about 10 feet from that station it was 15
feet high; at the face it was 11 feet high; in the center 12 feet high;
along the southeast corner 12 feet high.

Running from 2308 plus 14 to the northeast towards Station
2309, at plus 19 feet, the stope was 10 feet high, At 5 feet back
from Station 2309, it was 10 feet high. At the face marked here by
a dotted line. 6 feet high, station 2309, it was 10 feet high,

Commencing at station 3037-C, Bench stope, running southwet-
erly at 3037-C, I have two—one at the line or right at the station—
14 feet high, one 11 feet out to the right, that would be to the
west, 9 feet high.

Running from station 3037 to the southwest along this dotted
line terminating at the figure 2, August 2, 1909, that same line
being marked also September 21, 1909,

Going towards that face at plus 10 feet and 17 feet to the right
of the line, would be 10 feet high. At half way between 1 and ?
feet, about 17 feet, it would be 10 feet high.

_ 7” - wee SOLERO I PIECE YA OL wee np trem |

=

SILVER KING COALITION M. ©O. V8. CONKLING M. Co. 145

At the face it was 14 feet high, where the line intersected the face,
and 10 feet high at 23 feet to the right.

Station 2081 is in the drift between sections 5 and 6, near the Wet
chute—from 2081 to 2081-1.2, there is stoping done along that drift,
making the drift wider than the ordinary size, and I have a note,
stoping 2 feet high. My recollection of that is it was below the floor
of the drift, some stoping had been done.

Then I started from station 2081! continuing that same work
north 38, 42 west to station 2216 in that same drift, and there the
doping continues for a distance of 31 feet, towards station 2216,

and is stoped 2 feet high.
168 From station 221 towards station 2217, the extra stope is
shown right there, stoped down below there. It is indicated
on that section 2. At section 2217, I have the mark “Stoped 8 feet
high.”

At station 2217, stoped 16 feet over tation,

At station 2218, these last two points were about 5 or 6 feet outside
@f the Conkling line—station 2218 is inside of the Conkling line.
The memorandum is “Stoped 14 feet over station ;” at 2218, plus 5,
7 feet high. Then I have the note that is written here. “All the
way from 2218 to 2346," which is marked the mouth of that little
drift, stoped along drift on right fill, as near as I could make it on
the right hand side, 14 feet high; that is in the Chute stope.

Beginning at station 2346 going to 2347, at the top of the incline
at 2347—2346, I have 4 feet high. Running down the incline to
B48, 1 have the height 5 feet, stoped five feet high—then to 2349,
height of stope 6 feet high ; 2350, 6 feet high; 2351, 7 feet high. If
it is marked 8 feet on the map it is a mistake. It is 7 feet high at
sation 2371.

At station 2352, it is 8 feet high. At 2354 it is 6 feet high. At
2355 from there on to the face I have it marked 6 feet high.

208112 running from that station for a distance of 30 feet, that
was 5 feet high at the end of the 301% feet. From there running
south 38 east, 20 feet along that line it is 6 feet high, indicated by
two lines which show the width of the drift; the drift is really higher
than the stope.

On the left hand side it is marked “Stoped 4 feet high ;” thence
north 57 east for a distance of 32 feet, 8 feet high, and at a distance
of about 3 feet, little bit wider than half of the drift running along
parallel to that line is a bench in the roof which segregates the stope ;
that is 8 feet high. .

2348 to 2348-A, this survey was made June 13, 1910. At 2348-A
Ihave it marked 5 feet high; 10 feet beyond it is marked 5 feet
; 7 feet beyond that 5 feet high; at plus 17 feet 6 feet high.

n the Incline stope I think the date is marked on the map. Then
Ihave a memorandum at station 2348-D, “Stoped up to old stope

fe running from the level”—I mean the Chippie drift; there is
that if connected in. 1 had the height on the upper one; I

not very well measure the height at that point. It was not
sfe at that particular time ; there was waste piled in there and some

10—158

146 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO.

timbers had given way; I don’t know that the roof was caving
169 particularly ; they had dumped waste in there and it was too

hard to get over it—it was dangerous, but I knew the work,
I had been through it before.

2348-d, I run out to the southeast for 7.8 feet to what I marked
as the wall of the stope from 2348-c, the wall made a step down or
up, and I measured out to that wall. I also connected that station
2353 from that point, that is, from 2348-d; from 2348-d I ran south
westerly from 2348-¢, and from that point | measured out to the foot
of the bench and to the edge of the stope and marked to the roof 11
feet above my point that I was standing on. That gave the height of
the stope there at that point as 11 feet, at station 2345-c.

June 13, 1910, there was a small piece of work done or stoping
marked from station 208114, shown by this station marked 20811,
LetwWeen sections 0 and 1.

The point nearest the easterly end of the Elephant stope where |
have the height determined by actual measurements, is at station
366. and represented by a line across there marked “filled” ; that is
the point nearest.

I have the height also at the extreme easterly end, marked 12 feet
high. As I travel westerly from this line | have just spoken of, 1
have no height of stopes I think, until I get in the neighborhood of
of our time in there. At that period we only had that
iliance -ide to look after. We did not have to go over on the King
le

I refer to the latter part of 1909 and 1910, up to the time I left.
e ) about six hours out of eight in the stope. It was certainly
w duty as shift boss te observe the character of the ore that war
ing mined and classified and classify it as first or second class, and
did that every time I went into the stope. We could not prevent
me high grade getting in with the second class, because in blasting
it would Iweak, some good ore with the poor ore, Tt would be so
wall we could not pick it out. Sometimes it war as «mall a= a pea,
en sualler, Large pieces of high grade never got inte the second
wm to any extent, oe pieces were surted out. We would take
any first class that could be readily picked out. We sent first
class to the «melier and second class to the mill.

“ I knew Mr. Nicholas Treweek in his lifetime, and remem-

her his spending several days visiting the easterly portion of

w Elephant stope when IT was there. He would be in company
th a Mr. Gillettee, and his son Samuel Treweek. 1 remember
wm being here in this portion of the stope, 30 feet westerly from
« bottom of the K-K raise. It was in 1908. It was during the
me 1 worked in the eut-off drift, bat | was in the Blephant stope
ere showing these gentlemen around.

I was shift boss and the foreman over me in this particular work
# Frank Dailey. Ben Liovd was shift bow, Pat Rvan was a shift
™. Dean MeCann was shift bos. Don't think McGann was there
1197. I know he was there the latter part of 1909, and a part
(1910. Bill Kneal also was there as a shift boss in 1909 or 1908;
ut he is dead now,

(Witness, continuing:) The ground arownd what we call the Wet
huite was wet and hard to hold, heavy grownd; great weight on the
mbers. It would crush the timbers, It would crush bulkheads
hat were built five or six or seven feet high, crush them down to a
felt of three or four feet, down to a solid mas of wood: bulk-
tals Imilt of S by 8's. In order to hold the ground these bulk-
eas were filled in with waste, filled in practically solid from the

to the top, still they would be crushed in.
¢ wouldn't intentionally send ore that went better than 16 per
vit lead to the mill.

ee ee —. eeow 6 ane gee

160 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO,

Mr. Critehlow: We will stipulate in respect to Mr. Frank Dailey,
whom vou say ix in Idaho, that if he were here he would testify a
Mr. Horley did, if that will «uit you.

Mr. Dickson: Yee, thank you.

Tuomas Keagns, « witness eworn for the defendant, testified »
follows: °

My full name is Thomas Kearns. I am a resident of this city,
and director and vice-president of the defendant Company.

The defendant Company was organized in May, 1907. Prior to
that time I was President and Director of the Kearns-Keith Mining
Company from the time of its organization until it conveyed all its
helding= to the defendant Company here.

I have Leen mining in Park City thirty-four years. 1 ‘save been
everything from a tool bey up to President of a mine. 1 have been

interested in mining all the time, and have worked at it a-
IST) = most continuewsty. I have had charge of mines, directing

the running of drifts and other openings in unde
rites.

Iam acquainted with what is -ometimes called the \Miance tunnel
amd sometimes the Crescent drif:. 1 have been in it very frequently,
and was in it when it was being worked and driven ahead. I am
familiar with the character of the ground it was driven through. |
am able to and | have formed a judgment as to what the cost per
foot would be of driving that tunnel through the ordinary ground
through which it was driven. My judgment is that a reasonable and
necessary cost per foot of running that tunnel through the ordinary
ground through which it runs, not speaking of bad ground, would
he from $12.00 to $20.00. I make that variation because it is 4
very long tunnel, and the farther in it you get the sore it would
cost. Farther in the air becomes bad, the labor not so efficient
and the movement of the material requires more labor. You would
have to lav ties and rails as the work progressed.

This tunnel was the only means of reaching the ore, anles 4
shift had been «unk. The shaft would have to be 1,360 feet deep,
and of at least two compartments, although it i by

S i! 35
dr Hal :

HH

178 STLVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. co.

The ore which we took oat im renning from ation 15% @
through the K-K drift te the point where we fire encountered a fall
face of ore, were ponder ted of the same quality and sane kund
of ove, same value as the other ore, that is, 1 mean the other ores w
afterwards encountered in the Elephant — pnne? enemy e — -

184 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO.

I can tell by the payroll easy enough when I was tending station.
I remember that when I was tending station we would peg the ore to
designate first class and second class. 1 would keep a record on the
tally board by means of the pegs in the holes, of the ears sent ap,
first, second and third class. The station tender had to receive every.
thing that came down, send everything up that went wp and ride
the cage from bottom to top. | was careful to designate by means
of the tally board every car that went up and what it was
217 ~—s I did it to the best of my ability, and did it correctly. * * *
I have examined the books now since I was on the stand
yesterday, and | have a memorandum taken from them showing the
times that I served as station tender. 1 examined the books in the
presence of Mr. Taylor, one of the plaintiffs witnesses vesterday
afternoon. My memorandum is as follows:
For 1908: January 31 days; February 20 days; Mareh 31 days;
April 30 days; May 30 day-; June 25 days, July 4 days
In 1909: February 8 shifts: March 90" shifts; April 28 shifts;
May 341 shifts; June % shifts,

Cross-examination of Mr. Prudence:

I don’t remember when they first did take ore ap through the
500; but if I am not mistaken it was somewhere along in 1909. |
was working there when they were cutting the station at the 500.
They were hoisting waste from the station up to the main shaft.

Why yes, after the connection was made through the cut of
drift to the shaft at the 500, they hoisted quite a considerable amount
of waste there; ] mean after the connection was made and they com-
menced to hoist ore; we hoisted a car of waste oceasionally at differ
ent times, got it cleaned up around the station.

Redirect exxamination of Mr, Prudence:

I have no distinct recollection as to taking up waste on any partic
ular occasions after the connection was made: some was covered up
around the station, yes; | have no recollection as to whether any

other waste was sent up or not.

Georce McCarre ry, sworn for the defendant, testified as follows:

My name is George McCarrell; | am 22 vears of age; I ama
miner and am working for the defendant Company. | have worked
for the defendant off and on since 197. I was in the Alliance m
1912. I was working for George Blood.

I was station tender at one time. 1 pegged ore from the 500 level
station. The cars were pegged, There was a bin at the 500, twe
compartment bin, one on cach side, for first class and for second clas.
You would tell from the appearance of the ore what was mill ere

and what was first class. as well as from the manner in whi
218 = it was pegged. When I loaded cars on the cage 1 immediatelt

pegged the tally board. recording the number of first
second class and waste that was vent up. 1 did that all the time and
did it correctly.

ee ee ee ee EGE «I I 5 a ea:

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CoO. 185

Cross-examination of Mr. MeCarrell:

I had ne tender or helper on the 500; all the ore 1 took out of the
bins | pegged. There were compartments te the bin, one for firet
dass and second class. 1 do not think there was any waste pot out
Ihad nothing to de with putting the ore in the bin, What 7 teek
from the first class bin 1] pegged as first class and what [tech from
the second class bin | pegged as second clas. * * *

Since I [hare] my other testimony yesterday | have examined
the payroll with Mr. Taylor and Mr. Dailey. The memorandum
taken from it shows that I commenced in 1910: February 3 shifts;
March 14 shifts; April 18'% shifts; May 2 of. of there bemg a
parate account af these ores Thee t re fir ontemetoen thet anv
vach account was kept 1 wae ander the teenreion that fone hal
teen. 1 will cow in Salles anewer that whether it come from cme qeieening sopatin Gave en ne put
for i. I take it wae so decided bey this court, bat § don't know hee
et

pig

7 Wil .
ity |
t .. yo:
Bue
: csifeg
Heh
i aE
: , ied

aie Hi
sede
Hide

4 f i SF ge
sirtedtiteh
Taattettan
MUEHI NS
Nita b
AHS us s5u43
(i jana ae
dndlahe?

iggret

ae eat
Ht or ; ist
iit i

LF

ih
Hil : f

ee ae
of the
Lake (ty, U
confessed

yi v aad Evidence )

SULYER KING COALITION M. 60. 1# CONKLING M. C0, 208,

on por to April 25, 1907, and the remaining one rumdred them
cand dellers (3100,000.00) om or prter to July 25, 1007

Lyon the wid initial vewent of 8251000, (te be made on oF
pri tr Agetl 25, 1907, race the ane shall be retanmed bw

erty to ontel Wledlifinng, Wie beets cr cmmigeree steed thee
3

—F can't rewember 1 didn't know | wae going

Then I got the $100.00 I did met find oat free any
gat it for 1 ceauldn't ewear now what I get it for.
remember whether anyhedy told me what I got it for.
idea now why I got the extra 8100.00 anlee |

jit
our own business and deing cur work,

apy
hilttt
Lee a ) Cross-examination of Mr. Brooks:

It was only yesterday that I completed the ealculations of the
amount taken outside of the Conkling ground in the 600 stopes. I
had the notes, but I have never 1iade the calculations before, hence
these calculations were not used by Mr. Dickson in making up the
account of ores taken out from the 600 stopes.

The work in the Conkling claim, of course, was done between the
limes | made surveys, and T couldn't tell within a week or a month
of the time any particular work was done, but the figures represent
the total cavities, as nearly as we could get them.

I haven't computed the cubic feet of material removed from the
Hlephant stopes proper westerly of the west end line of the Conkling
elim as patented. T have got the survey notes, but T haven't figured
them out yet.

>

224 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M, CO.

The maps, Exhibits 1, 2, 3, and 4, shows all the workings under the
Conkling claim that I know anything about, all det 1 ever heard of.
I can't tell anything about the actual aniount tak: out, for instane
in 115, beeause TE did no surveying in the stope between October
1914. and April 1916, a period of eighteen months—no surveying
at all in 1915, there. There are no notes of mine that would show
what work was done in 1915, [tis merely from information. 1 have
ne recollection of going into these stopes at all in 1915,

I think | nest have misunderstood your question. My notes here
show that on January 20, 1915, 1 was in the Silver Hill shaft, 600
and 700 levels and stopes. and made a survey. Here is my record of
the surveys. | conn need at 2O10 on the 600 foot level of the Silver
Hill and run a line to 4126 in the 600 stope. At that time |
measured up the floors of the GOO foot stope; that is, outside of the
Conkling. 1 carried this survey on; it goes about 25 feet in the
600 level, that much surveying [| did in 1915, in January. I als
surveyed the top and the bottom.

The next place 1 surveyed in 1915, is shown here, July 7, 1915,
10.8 feet northeasterly from a point in the 700 foot level marked
station 4276; that would be practically to the south side line of the
Conkling. The survey was outside of the Conkling up to that
point. July 12, 1915, 1 surveyed in those stopes. [have a com

plete survey of the stope as it stood outlined by its boundaries
267 ~~ October 10,1915. On October 10, | measured this stope whieh
is known as the 700 drift stope, shown on sections 11 and 12

I was in error when J stated at first the dates when I made surveys
in the Conkling ground in my first testimony. My error arose from
the fact that | had reference particularly to the Elephant stope, not
to the whole of the Conkling ground. I did always consult the
superintendent as to the progress of the work that had been done
| consulted Mr. Hume about the dates I have given. If he told me
there had been no work done in some portion of the mine I didn't
go in there; | took his word for it. If he told me they were working
in the 600 stope | would go in. He would say sometimes simply
there was nothing to be done in there. It is his oral declarations
that constituted the data from which I attempted to state the year
in which any work was done, but the amount of work done as hom
by the excavations is the result of the surveys.

Redirect examination of Mr. Brooks:

As I have stated my last survey in 1915 was October 10th. I sur
veyed up to the faces as they were then found in the Conkling
in these stopes. The next survey was April 13, 1916 with Mr. Frank
Anderson. We were there then a week. _

The 600 Top stope is all one stope; it is marked in two places
help define it. It will be noted that there is a difference in the
ing inside and outside the Conkling.

—

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO. 225

Recross-examination by Mr, Brooks:

Of course, if I couldn't get into any particular place I couldn't
survey there. It happened sometimes in the Elephant stope that
between surveys there had been caving. I have endeavored hereto-
fore to point out where such caving occurred and the extent of it.

Harry G. Hume, a witness produced on behalf of the defendant,
testified as follows:

My full name is Harry G. Hume. I am thirty-four years of age.
I reside in Park City. I am a miner. Studied at the School of
Mines Butte, Montana and the Columbia University of New York.
I have followed the business of mining since 1905. I have been
employed by the defendant company since November, 1915 as shift
boss on the Alliance side. There was no mining done from
2%8 the 25th of October until the 10th of November, 1915. The
miners went on a strike. I continued as shift boss after
November 10, 1915 until June 9, 1916. 1 never knew anything
about the so-called Elephant stope. Referring to the stopes below,
generally spoken of as the 600 I will say that the 600 sill stope and
the 600 middle stope were exhausted when I went there as shift boss
first; they had been entirely worked out then. The stopes worked
under my supervision as shift boss were the 600 Top and the 704
Top stopes. The 700 Drift stope was worked out. While I was
shift boss I kept a proper record of the number of cars of first class,
second class and waste that went out on my shifts. I was one of those
that worked with Mr. Frank Anderson and Mr. Taylor, representing
the plaintiff the other day in compiling the result of the entries in
these ore record books. I identified the entries that I was responsible
for and did so correctly, of course. I made my entries from the
tally boards on the 600, 700, and 500, and sometimes from informa-
tion given me by the car men when they went off shift. The entries
were made daily. The ore that came from the 600, 700 and 900
would be taken up the Silver Hill shaft on the 500 level and from
there it would be loaded out of the bin into cars by the motorman or
his helper. The bin was a two compartment affair, one side was
used exclusively for waste from the shaft and the other side was
used either for first class, second class or waste from the mine. If
there was one kind of material in that side of the bin that was used
for the three classes of material and we wanted to put in something
else, we would first clean it out. On the stopes that were worked
under my supervision down to the time work ceased in the Conkling
ground, there was probably not more than one [care] of first class
taken out to 75 or 80 of second class. 1 am referring to the 600 top
stope. Day after day we would take out nothing but second class ore.
The first class was sorted from the rest. It was easy to distinguish it.
We did not take any ore from the 700 prior to the last of March,
1916, on the Alliance side, inside the Conkling ground.
Q. What about the 704 stope?
A. That all came down from the 600 drift. It was all second class

15—158

/ ae PALS ap CBE SE ee ee a

926 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO,

ore. There was some shipping ore left there when we stopped work
upon being ordered to do so, after learning of the decision of the
Court of Appeals. If I remember right that shipping ore was about
ten or twelve inches thick. There never was any ore taken out of the
900 level within the Conkling ground.

269 = Cross-examination of Mr. Hume:

1 was there when the strike was called about the 25th or 26th of
October, and it lasted until the 10th of Nowember, 1915,

When | was shift boss on- O'Neill was my foreman and superior
and my father was his superior as assistant general manager of the
property. The shift boss opposite me was Geo, Holland. In that
600 stope sometimes we would have two men working on a shift.
sometimes three, that is, men working in ore; we had mucker too
I don’t know how many men worked on the shift opposite me but
you can tell by referring to the time book.

You are liable to get some first class in bunches at any time when
you work in second class ore. The only first clase | ever saw in thie
stope is the one place | have pointed to down here where we hed
the square sets, which ore was about five or «ix feet in length and
about a foot wide and I don't know how deep. When I say you
are liable to get a bunch of first class any time vou work in second
class ore | am speaking generally.

The ore production record at any rate shows all the ore that came
out of the Top stope and the classification of it. | don't remember
that from November 10, 1915, to the time I quit working in thie
Top stope what we mined in waste or took out any. | don't mean
that there wasn’t any but we were filling the waste back into the

stopes.

le Manh, 1916, when we had orders to quit, we were inside the
Conkling ground, although I didn’t know it. We got word to quit
the 704 raise stope. I was not working on first clase ore. There
was first class ore exposed, but I had not been working on it on my
shift. I don’t know whether somebody else's shift had been work-
ing on it or not. I found it exposed there and it is exposed there.
I can show you two or three faces of first class ore that were exposed
that were not worked. My explanation is that when that fire clas
ore in there was struck I was over to the Silver King doing some
special work for about a week or ten days. I don't know what the
other shift was doing. I don’t know whether the first class ore was
exposed for a week or ten days. It was there when I got back.

Kwnicut L. Crapp, produced on behalf of the defendant, testified
as follows:

270 My name is Knight L. Clapp. 1 am an accountant by pro

’ fexsion and have been for twenty-five or thirty years. In
that capacity I have audited the books of the defendant company. !
audited the books for the year ending 1910. I have in my hand
here the result of the one ending April 30, 1910. 1 have another
one but I haven't it here right now.

ee eo

SILVER KIXG COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. Co, 227

Mr. Critchlow: We have offered and do offer to admit in the
record the authenticity of these reports made out by this gentleman
and that bear his signature.

Mr. Marioneaux: That he examined the same books that Mr, Ed-
munds did and will give substantially the same testimony?

Mr. Critchlow: Exactly.

Mr. Marioneaux: Except, of course, that he would testify to a
different set of vouchers regarding a different period.

Mr. Critchlow: If there appears to be another one and we think
it is material, you will offer the other one?

Mr. Marioneaux: Yes, * * * While we are on the subject,
Mr, Critchlow, we might ask you whether you will require us to pro-
duce the book-keepers who kept these books which these auditors
examined,

Mr. Critchlow: We will admit if produced they will testify they
kept the books correctly from the data furnished them at the time.

Sim Soro, a witness produced on behalf of the defendant, being
duly sworn, testified as follows

My name is Sam Sgro. | am 3S years old and live in Park City.
lam working for the Daily-Judge Mine’ 1 worked for the defend-
ant in 1913, 1914 and 1915. (Thereupon the witness gave the date
that he worked for the defendant during said years. )

| quit the Silver King February 20, 1915. On the 500 near the
Silver Hill shaft there was a tally board upon which was tallied the
number of cars of first class, second class and waste that came up.
I sometimes did the tallying. When I did it I did it correctly. I
remember when ore was struck on the 600 level, it was on the 24th
of July, 1914. It was all that ore | would help to load and tally.

71 Lee Jouxson, produced on behalf of the defendant, hav-
ing been duly sworn, testified as follows:

My name is Lee Johnson. 1 am farming at the present time and
reside in Heber City. 1 worked for the defendant in 1914 on the
motor and in June, 1915 and part of 1913 and 1914, aot always
on the motor, however, * * *

Mr. Ray It might save time if we could offer to admit here that
these motormen [abd] station tenders will testify that they pegged
woh ore correctly while they were there or attempted to peg it cor-

Mr Dickson: Just show then the time they worked there is all

that is necessary.
Mr. Ray: And if all of them were available they would—we will
make it broader than that. We admit that the station tenders or
loaders or other men whose duty it was to peg it, that they attempted
to carry out their duty whoever they may be.

Mr. Marioneaux: That is all?

The Court: Have you the time prepared.

Mr. Marioneaux: It will be unnecessary -in view of their state-

LAGGY CUI ET I Nt BOR TA WS Oy

928 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO.

ment. They say they assume there were motormen and station
tenders, helpers and loaders there all the time and if produced they
would testify-——you say for all the time?

Mr. Critchlow: Yes.

Mr. Ray: We mean in that admission merely as a basis for the
records which you produced here, not to go beyond the record of
the books.

Mr. Marioneaux: In addition to this we want to prove by this
gentleman, not only that they have pegged it correctly, but that
they actually reported it to their foreman.

Mr. ¢ ‘ritellow : That whatever reports they made were made cor-
rectly, either oral or written.

Mr. Marioneaux: Yes, and that it was their duty to report. We
want to prove by them that they did report to the shift boss or fore-
man and attempted to report correctly.

Mr. Critchlow: Yes, we have attempted to admit it.
272 Mr. Dickson: Then the only thing is to show the time
they worked.

Mr. Marioneaux: Mr. Critchlow says at all times. There were
always such men there and we could produce them whenever they
were there.

Mr. Dickson: Lest I should forget it, your Honor, will recall that
when Mr. Walden was on the stand testifying to the cost per foot
of various sections of the Alliance Tunnel or Crescent drift, that he
testified as to the cost of various kinds of material that we used in
the running of that drift which he obtained from Mr. Flannigan,
the bookkeeper, and that Mr. Flannigan had made out a statecmnt
and handed it to counsel oa the other side, and [ understand they
will admit that the cost as testified to by Mr. Walden is a corrcet
cost of the various kinds of material «1 that period.

Mr. Critchlow: Is not this better? We admit that Mr. Flannigan,
if produced, would testify that the costs and value of materials as
stated in this Exhibit or document were currently correct according
to the dates therein given.

Mr. Dickson: That is all right.

The Court: Or took them from the books of the company or made
them as an expert.

Mr. Critchlow: We don’t care where he got them.

M. J. Datrey, recalled by the defendant for further direct exam-
ination, testified as follows:

I have made a determination of the amount in pounds of shipping
ore that would be in a mine car and how many pounds of mill ore in
a mime car. I made the determination in hos and 1909. The
= of shipping ore in a mine car would be a little more than

100 Ibs. and of mill ore there would be a little less than 1650 pounds.

I am satisfied that is a very close approximation, within a few
pounds, during that period.

Q. Do vou remember whether that determination was arrived at
by taking the entire number of cars of crude ore that had been ship-

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO. 229

ped during a given period, or the number of tons of crude ore that
were shipped?

Mr. Critchlow: We object to that.
Mr. Dickson: I don't care about it if vou object te it.

4 C. P. Brooks, recalled for further direct examination, tee
tified as follows:

The face of the Cut Off Drift is ane op on & aes

the Elephant stepe right eqqmmrte te the K-K rane about 20 ft
i aetna aii os oii endl euaiall Ye aR)

Sample No 4 from the Kecetvers

£
a
l

Praxk Hasse. produced on behalf of the defendants, testified
follows
chemat

oo
My fall name & Prank J. Heaneen. | am an assever and «

cad | con in the conpday of the dxérufent company. | have been a

its employ since October 1, 1914

MLTR KING COALITION M. CO. VS CONKLING M. Co. 273

nu I know what ix mecant by cell brads and quill taille Ax
amayer it was my luty to make daily of the heard
and tails that cone from the mull and | did so every I have here

(Exhibit 99 marked by the reporter )

(Witness, continuing ) I made assays of the head> and tails every
and entered the result daily in these books

g
:
;

oa SILVER KING COALITION M. Oo. 1%. CONKLING M. Oo.

twill, | have got to get a composite sample from my asseyer of the
mill bet run for whatever amount of daye it may be of the heads and
tatle and | get returns of ore concentration from our «melter «ttle
ments of the value and dry weight, and by wing an aay formula,
deduct the tails from the cote

Q What iv the formula’

A. Comeentrates minw tails, divided by heads, minus: tail, wil
give you the rateo of concentration

Q The amay of the heads would give you the gro value of the
etude ote’

A. That would give me the ratio

Q The away of heads taker: daily would vive vou the gro
value of all metals comtained in the crude ore”

ony given petted and the vale ver ten of the dry comeentrates, you
would know hew many tons o erode ore must have gome inte the

the mull.
A. Dry toms 1520.260, and the product in dry concentrat= ¥a
163. WA.
( Witmee ) I commenced as assistant mill man on

handwriting I have identified bis handwriting : have
before me here and also Mr Buck's handwriting 1 have from thes

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO. 275

hooks made « computation of the wumber of tone of mill ore that
went through the sill for the veur 1914 aud the number of tons and
tie of concentration in 1914 ix ax follows: There was milled 59,-
#5 290 tone: that wae crude ore: and there wae shipped from the
will 12.119.313 tome of concentrates. dry weight ;—tatio of concen-
&M. Ley Ky the output of snill ore from the entire mine

7

het
of tons of erude ore that went from the entire mine

in 1915 equals 45,734.29 tome rade mill ore; 5064955 tons of con-
ertrates shipped —ratie of concentration was 54.
first three necnth. of 1916 the bowks show 6.775 tons of
and 1.142 toms of mill concentrates aebepeeee enw eee ane 16.6 8
5. &. Avg. TB ence Bat TAMAGGS. «2c cecccecccccecces 40.2 33.5
” “ pile Ist main tunnel Hanauer.......... 37.3 19.2
° ee Se BR nvceccaes 7.6 4.5
A. M. to J. H. Col. raise $3 drift hanging.......... 56.3 19.
" ae etdeddseesees 18.4 35.
A. M. to J. H. Col. raise $3 right side.............. 13.7 12.
“ a © Tbe bbnke aires 5. 21.

J. H. Avg. 18 cars int Hamawer............-cc0ee0. 33.4 35.
# “ 4 cars 2d main tunnel Hanauer......... 6.4 5.

4 “ of face level $3 C. McCann............ 3.1 6.4

a “ 1 car ist $5 raise Hanauer............ 72.4 59.2
Ae OO LEE OLD AOL 2 YEN.

nay

294 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO.

1914. Tead. Siive
Percent &%
J.H. Avg. 2 “ 2d $5 raise Hafawer........+-++- 2.8 4
= “ pile 24 main tunnel... ... eee ee 4.3 46
1915.
oun. 6. J. H. Avg. 4 cars 24 main tunnel Wansuer 2.6 7
14. sy os a" st oe 19.7 1
= & main drift under track fre
GS ccccevsessoveeoveceeses 14.6 if
- | “ WHanauer main tunnel 2/c from pile .......... 17.8 i
* ef °° “ DO GUAGE ccccccevccecceecovceceseses 7.1 4
o 1 Class from pile... .. 6666s cece eeeee m6 18.6
a 7 a © B BPG B/C. cc cccccsevccceceseccesese m0.6 24.
" & ” * Dae Bits cs eves i2ecceeeoeroeveress 26.8 us
- OD WSrcccccecvescooccoveccocors 2 54
“ 19, ad " Main Tunnel 2/3 from pile.......... 12.2 64
. “ DONG Bhi ccccvcccocccevevececceoes &.7 5
. “ si No. 1 Inchime.....ccccecsvecesesees 2 4
- * wd B ERID BlOcccccccccevccevesesveceses 7.4 64
e “ 2/e from top Z1 ralwe.... . 666s eceee 4.2 4a
= - Main Tunnel from pile 2/e.........- 3.7 i
= - a al © QED ccceccocese wT
“ 21. ONeill 700 Silver Hill Ist class from fare. ......... TH5
“ 22. J. H. Hanauer 3 cars 1/¢... 2.2.66 0c een peoeeneees 4.6
J. H. Hanauer 2 cars 2/c....... PTT TT TTT TTT Ti TTT 7.4

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO. 295

Percent Oz
1915. Lead. Silver
Fe 23. J. H. Hanaver from winge...... var dneeubes & 1.2
J. 1. Hanauer Main Tunnel winze 2/c. poeecaevecoos 2.7 3.1
4. H. Hanaver 4 care 2/c from stopes.............. 7.4 s.0
Poem. 24. J. HW. Mamawer 3 care 1/0... 0... ccc ccc cceeeecees 4.4 9.3
5. GR © GND Bsc ccccccvcvevercccccecees 5.7 68
“ 2. J. W. Hananer West Raise 5 ft. lewel.............. 7 1.46
4. H. Hanaver West end 3 ft. lewel................ 2.4 3.7
27. J. 1. Hanawer tot Gass ander track 5 ft. level... .. 28.6 “47
27. J. H. Nananer GO stope Allianee............6..4. 3.1 2.4
Seott Hanaver Tunnel Stope $1 2/e............-4.. 7.45 wi
Seott Hanaver Tunnel Stope $1 1/c................ 22.8 20.6
Seott Hanaver Tunnel Stope £1 3 ears 1/e......... 4 17.8
28. Seott Hanaver Tunnel $1 yellow Carbon back...... 1.4 1.2
Seott Hanaver Tunnel Main tunnel fissure in winzge. 8.1 q

Q Whe was Mr. Scott”
A. Shift bees up there at one time.

oe & &, G Ge © GD BMoccoccccevoseecoeceesorss 24 15.6
— B@ Be He GD ae Bee ccccceccceveesccesevoocoes 4 1.6
Seott Hanaver Tunnel Level incline Main tannel 2/c. 11.4 10.8
“ © Seott Manauer 50 ft. level stope $1................. 6. 19.2
“ 11. Seott Hanaver 50 ft. level stope £1 2/e............. 9.4 9.3
Seott Hanauer scale in back of $1 stope scale on
SUES GD cccweveecocevcesecoevecsseceseeces - 45 12.
Be)
" DL. Seoett Hanauer 5 ft. level stope $1 Sand carbonate
Ss WEP Biv ccecoccsccececeocsvececessoseeoese a.7 47.2
> &. Fe Gee DS GEG Gievcceccocsetvecsevescoeses 5.8 2.9
Bo Te SED Ge Ge Ge cen cee cocesseecoocses nD 3.7
16. () Neill G00 Silver Hill muck pile 50 ft. from tep G0
POPP TTTT TTT TTT TTT TT Tere 13.2 16.6
Mar. 164. (Neill G00 Silver Hi Ist Cl. Uzellas place........ 33.6 4.1
“ 17. (Y Neill G60 face of stope Sth floor................. 3.1 1.8
“ 78 J. 11. G00 right side floor wall MeCann............. 5.2 2.7
4. H. GO 2d floor right side. .... 2.2.66. 6 66 cece eee 4.3 2.5
(Y Neill 600 face of staope Uzellas place 5.0 3.8
> Ge Th Ga Be Bee ccccccccescococcecesecocs 25.7 7.8
4. H. GOO raine light grey Mc..........cccccceccees 39.4 12.4
4. H. Hanaver raise muck from pile............ 11.6 9.6
4. H. Hanaver Incline main tunnel 1/e............ 5.2 2.8
“ 22. J. WH. Hanaver main tunnel incline 2/c............. 4.1 3.2
4. Hi. Hanaver 2 cars 2/c from stopes.............. 17.6 19.0
“ 2h. J. A. Hanaver Main Tannel Incline 2/e............ 13.3 5.2
4. H. Hanawer 4 cars 1/c 1 level.................. m.2 6.4
44. 64. 1. Manaver Main tennel incline 2/c. sooo BD 13.2
Cunningham 900 Creole Cunningham's place 2/c.... 22.3 12.
“ 25. J. H. Hanauer stopes 6 cars 2/c.......... peered «-» 9.6 9.5

17.
18,

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO.

Percent On
Lead. = ‘Silver.
4. H. Hanawer 5 ft. level from pile ie... .. .. 98 a4
J. H. Hanauver 50 foot level from pile 1/e.......... 28 “7
Sy > CE BD GD Bee cccescccccsccccoceccoes a4 wi
4. H. Hanaver Main Tunnel incline 2/e............ 10.8 55
4. H. Hanawer 1 car 2/c iat stope................. 4.3 42
4. H. Hanaver Main Tunnel inetine 2/e............ a4 54
4. H. Hanawer 2 cars 1/c from stope.............. 19.7 ™.
4. H. Hanaver Main Tunnel incline pile 2/e........ 7.8 54
4. H. HManawer 4 care 2/¢ from stope.............. 7.1 i2.1
4. H. Hanawer 2 cars 1/c from stope............... 21.2 m7
4. H. Hanawer Main tonne! incline from Pile 2/r... 9.1 42
4. H. Hanaver Main tunnel incline 2 ears 2/e...... 5.7 *
4. H. Hananer weet end 5 ft. level... 2... 2.6... 2.4 2.
4. H. Hanawer 4 care 2/e...... nece GCF 97
(Neill 600 %. H. Hard lime behind £1 raise pecesous 246 15
Cee A> > BS, BP GD Doc cc cccccccececesecs 5.1 Le
Se Ge ee GP GE Si oscvcusccceceoscocensocs 1.2 4.2
4. H. Hanawer 5 ft. level 3 cars 1/e................ 2.1 21.
4. H. Hanaver main tannel incline 1 car 2/e....... 11.2 63
> Hee Be © GD Be cocscvdeccoccococevoscce 12.4 “1
4. H. Hanaver main tunnel incline 2 cars 2/c....... 14.2 74
J. H. Hanauer from stopes 4 cars 1/c.............. 30.4 19.2
(Neil 700 8. H. 6” bed of ore 704 Drift........... 3.7 124
J. H. Hanaver main tunnel incline 2 cars 2/e....... 44 wes
ip ae SD GD Encbececdvcceecccosesooonce ~ 9.2
J. H. Hanawer 6 car 1/c stopes.................... an 16 &
J. H. Hanawer 3 cars 2/c stopes.................. 12.2 1
E> Gee 6 GI Bireccvescocescocevosces ++ D4 64
4. H. Hanauer © ft. level ore from pile... ......... 19.8 Ww 6
4. H. Hanaver main tannel incline 2 ears 2/e....... a4 a4
4. H. Hanawer 5 cars 2/e open... . 2.6... ee cee eee “4.7 11.2
4. H. Hanawer 5 cars 2/e stopes.................. 14.2 &.2
i Ey OD Bic cececccccececececececes 2 17.8
4. H. Hanawer 1 car 2/c main tunnel inetine........ 10.6 74
4. H. Hanawer ® cars 2/c slopes... oo... eee eee 44 61
i ee ee OD cn pececeeesoocuser wees . O94 13.2
4. H. Hanauer 6 cars 2/e.. oa yn eweeewen 11.6 m4
4. H. Hanauer 5 ft. tered um ofie Be ie wie oademion a9 a1
4. H. Wanawer 3 cars i/e................ senceoeves GS 446
4. H. Hanauer Ist from pile 50 ft. lewel... 0... BT mM.
4. H. Hanauer 6 cars 1/c from stopes........... m4 4
4. H. Hananer Hanawer from pile 1/¢............. me. uA
4. H. Hanaver from pile main tennel incline... .... 5.8 15
> ee He OP ED BM. ccor-cvcecccccecedecetecn 19. 3
4. H. Hanauer 50 ft. level from pile ie... yeewede 9.4 4.2
4. H. Hanauer from pile 1/e...................... 4. as
4. H. Hanauer from stepes 2 ears I/e.............. 2.2 wA

4. H. Hanawer G cars 2/e.............
(YNeill G0 11 care 2
(¥Neill 700 Block ore 704 drift.

4. H. Hanawer 5 care ive...

4. H. Hanawer 4 care 2. ppaceveoneuce

4. H. Hanawer from pile bie.. S “4.2
4. H. Hanaver from pile I/e...... ne R25 4
4. 4. Manawer 5 care 1/e... -eon ° . B.4 m.2
Ge Se eeecoreceesetecececece ss cxekeoes 2.2 2.4
4. HH. Wanawer 5 care 1/e peees 4 2.8
4. H. Hanawer 4 care 1/...... evens - BA 1.2
4. H. Hanawer 6 cars 1/¢ , — 2 4.6
4. 1. Hanawer from Pile ante canned inctine 11.8 3.2
4. 1. Hanawer main tannel from pile 2/........ 7 2.8
4. H. Hanawer 6 care 1/¢ pcecevees - w2 7.4
4. H. Wananer from pile 1/e........-... peves a4 ms
4. HM. Wanawer 5 care 1/e......... : sees 12.5 a4
4. H. Manawer Win I/e........ peeneceuess —_ zs
4. H. Manawer tin 2/r.........-.. pesecsencosoaee UE 0.4
J. H. Hanawer 5 care 1/e......... seenecsooores ws 42.8
Deason Wanawer 12 care 1/...... 6.666 eee . 21.4 mM.
J. H. Manawer MeBvoy place 1/e........ sveeeoeecos SE 47.3
J. 1. Hanawer EA | ere 11.2 2.2
43. H. Hanawer 5 ft. level from pile 2/e.. _— ne 13.4
J. H. Hanauer Main Tunnel from pile De. ......... 44 6.3

H. WHanauer Raise ft. lewel.. .... - 122.4 14.2
H. Hanaver from pile W ft. lewel Tie... sone Gee 2
HH. Hanawer 1/¢ Crom raice ft. lewet. - 4 mS
HH. Hanewer bc from pile Mewes place... ..... M7 8.7
i. Haneuwer 1/¢ Pontker« place... .. coos .2
H. Hanawer Main tennel tecline from pile 2 7.1 a
Hi. Hananer 16 care tet 1..... ag ~~ es MH %.2
H. Hanawer raiw WH ft. lewel Tie... oo. eee... MH m4.2
HH. Hanauer MePvoy from pile Pe.............. 278 ae
H. Wananer 5 care 1/e...... 7.4 "7
Hf. Hanawer from pile 2 ¢ 2.2 * 2
Hi. Hanawer 3 care 1/¢...... ‘i wees Se Mm.

H. Hanaver main tonne! iactine : 2 ears 2/e. 9.2 6.1
Wi. Wanawer 4 care 1/e......... pesecensevens 2.4 4.2
Ml. Hanawer from Pile x Meqpe 7 Mi eseesevenons B.7 %.2
Sey © Gas Bile oc ccccorvcercosscceosees B.2 42.4
H. Hanaver lonikers place oun ‘pile 7 Mieccesss wz 2.6
Hi. Hanawuer 4 care 1/c.. Jeeeneeoeeseeeeoss EEE @.7
H. Hanawr MeEvey ae ye Pe receesoees ee 73.

HH. Hananer 4 place from pile Die...) . 62.66. 19.2 22.

H. Wananer from pile Zier... 6. 66 ee cee 13.2 m4
H. Hanauer 5 care 1/e.......--.-- peendeewevose zZ.3 a2.0

.

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VE CON KLING MOO.

ler cont
tend

3. Benewer Zedierh ware from pier i a7
3 @ Benewer Meteor plere 1 “5
3. 0 Wenewer 6 core i 7.
3 8 Henewer Wien plere 2+ “we
3. 0 Wenwwer 7 core 1 “4
3.0. Mensur 6 core te b.2
3. . Waeneeer Bretl ple te 4
1.0. Henewr WT tewel Ze ; 7
3.0. Wenewer 6 core te , “us
5. 0. Sanscer fram pate $2 tege 2/4 ‘
3 4. Wenewer Pouthers plere tevet Gramm pile
BY sexs wa
5. 0. Mencew 6 care ie “a
4. 0. Gencure Grub fram Witenn plore ue
3. . Henewet from pile WH M. bewet Te “7
fwecen Hanwuet Avg 9 cat- from chate Z.2
3. 0. Wenewer Meee pere tr 7.*
3. 0. ener 7 core i a4
3. 1. Heneeer 160 bewet etape TH) Mileer TO “
3.0. Wenewet 5 core te . 4
Ieemeem Avge 42 core chate ; m4
leeeeen Honea care ctrate tor mw 4
3.0. HMenewer Wf. bowel from pile Ie mea
3.0. Wenewer 5S core te... “7
3. 7) Metenn Seer 4.2
3 Mean Seer 57
3 @ Wenewer 5 core 1 2
3.0 Wenewer * core 2 "Ne
3. Henewer 1 vere 2 72
30. Wenewer 4 core te 7.5
3.0. Weneerr 2 core 2 a4
30. Weneerr 5 core te az.4
CVNet 760 TOR etepe Iie Milwer FON
3.0 Weneeer 1 cor i’ - :
3.0. Meneeer Wien pare from pile
3.0 enews W care 2
3.0. Wenewr 1 cor le
3.0. Weneeer Wien pare
3.0. Henewer P44 plere tie
3.0. Heneeer Wilken place from pile
3.0. Menewer 2 core tye...
3.0. Meneeer 1 care 2
4.0. Wenewer Anderty piece from pile te
3.0. Wenewer 4 core 1

m

— —

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS CONKLING M. CO. 2799

leet) = Swe

wer D4. enews * cre 2. we “7
3 0 Mensur 5 core te az 4

3 1 Benewer from Wilson plore mA m5

Seett Henewer stope 1 1/¢ tenet fever! “it 23.2
Henewer tepe gi 26 tannet eve! 24 we

2% Beet Henewer Tanne Level tape 1 Wilson ptore we Pe
Seett Hanewer Toennet Level @tepe b Iie z.1 “4

feett Hanewer Tennet bevel Stepe | 26 73 9.5

Ze poceeeeceerreoorres . “~ Ne A.2
Seett Hanewer Mtope $1 Tenet Iewet tie. a7 mS
Sewtt Hanewer Stepe $b Twnnet Level 2 6 "n* 74

St. Seett Hanener Mtepe 61 Tower bewrt Pe eee mT “1
Seett Heneeer Mepe 61 Tenet Lew oe |. an “iT
Jone 1) Beett Henwuer Tanned Lew! Mtepe st tr —y “*
Seedtt Hanener Towne Lew! Mteqe Poe... wa m4

2 seett Hennwet Tuwnet Levet Stepe Pde os m5 “*
Seratt Hanawer Tunnel Level Stee 1 or ——— we

S Seott Menewer Tewnet Level Stee Too . 4 7.*
Seott Hanener Tenet Level Mtge Pe te.. a | “2
seott Hanwner Tunnel West rif! | 2.1

5 Soot Meneeer Tenet Wet Step ot te a. “6
Seett Henweer Tonnet Weet Steppe So * ma

& Seott Henawer Tonnet Weet drift sto: i m4
Seott Henneer Tanne! (Hin~ © tna 24 2.4
sett Hanewer Tanne 1: 2 “7

7 Seett Hanewer Tannel Stepe 51 - « 4.2 wa
Seott Hanewer Tennel Stepe =f t+ a4 on

& Seott Henener Tenet Mtge ft 2 + 4 a

x4

® Seett Henewer Tennel Mieqe ct tr ae “a
Seett Menewer Tenet Steqe f Bes = pare 2 6 wa w.4
1 Seott Henseer Teweel Mtape 1 Me peer © “us “.
Seeat Hanener Tannet Btepe 1 Wit place te - 2.4

11. Seott Heneeer Tanne! Beye fire... , OF “6.2
Seott Henewer Tene’ Step 1 2 mt “5
1 Geott Heneeer Tune Step | 2 2.3 3.1
1 Seett Menewer Tunnel Step stot aa ee
Seett Hanaver Tannel Stop 2” aa “1
scott Hananer Tannet Sto ter = ww 6
6 Seott Menener Tene! Step © pe | m.2
Sent? Hanawner Tarnet Stope 2a mx ae
1 Seett Hanewer Townel Sepe OM. cee oeeue Ge me
Seett Hanawer Toenet Steper | %.2
1% Seott Heneuer Teneel Step i m4 m4
Seett Hanaver Tunnel Sto OM. «cesevess » “2s
Ch. Seott Maneuver Tunes! Step 2 12.2 15 6

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING Mw. ©O.

fect
lend Silver
Jeane Zi. Seott Hanewer Tennel Stop le ™ 4 p=
2 Seott Henewer Tunnel Stor i” mt me
Seett Hanewer Tenn! off filings tm Hewring ftom
Dew peceaeus 54 ws
= 40 Det ete from Pile fT. teow! m2 “sé
4.05 cure tye...... — - pe a4
% J... Reertng Liew , - ——ae ve
3 0 Henseer 44 filling frem Keering bertine ‘ i”
4. 0. Wenewer 5 core te ; 4 B |
an Spens phere toe 2.4 |
wey
3 " 5 care 1 = me
". 2 "7 m4
n". ._w
n. x2
nn "
-. ~ &
”. 2
". c
”. aa
” .
5 mz.
t.
» &

—_—_———

SILVER KING COALITION M OO. YS CONKLING M. CO.

Menweer So atege 5 core 1

1. Hanewer 2 care 1 -

1. Maneeer 7 care 2/e 61 chate —_—
1 Henewet 50 ft. tewet from pile Ze.
i. Maenewer So etepe 2 core Ie

1. Menewer 7 care Zr...

Henweer from pile $5

» s

i wt - a4
Seett Heneuer $1 stepe 2« paces eeooeus a
1 See’ Meqewer £1 etepe Ze 4
1 Seett Mewewer 1 wtepe te 88 ccc cee pod
Seett Meneeer 61 tegpe Ze , oe
70. Seetr Manewer $1 etege Zr... 7.4
Seett Wannwer St efepe Dir... .. «00s u4
= ett Menweer (44 Giling Nearing Lice 2.1
Seett Henweer step $1 Ie uu.
2 ett Neneerr atop Sf 2 6.4
Seett Hennwer steqe St 1 ™
Seott Hanewer stepe So be. ms
Seett Haneuer tepe £1 2 « ~
Seott Menewer tepe SF 2... ms
Seett Naneerr tape £1 1 « a4
2 Seott Mensur stope SI te ....... mT
Set! Meneeer tope SF I. _— scce GBS
= Seett Manewer tope SI 2 e........ — “4
Seott Haneerr Male Tanne! Geoure 1°" etrenk 14
™ Seott Manewer step Si Ze “4
Set? Hanwwer stope $3 bh « ma
Seott Hanawer stope 2 1 . BA
St Seett Menewer stope S1 2 ¢ 2.4
1. Seott Menewer stope £1 Ie 2
Seett Hanawet stope $1 Ze. 24

5. Seott Manewer ope $F Ie......... : a
4. Seott Hanawer stape Nearing Liew Ze. ............ a4
Seott Hanewer stope Rearing tien Ie. ........ m2

5. Seett Henewer Rearing $7 1 _ ea
Seott Hanwuer Reering $1 2/¢ “4

“% Seett Hanawer etope gf 2/c.. o4
Seott Hanewer stope SI Iie. aa

* Seott Henewer Rearing Lien 2/¢ i6
Seett Hanewer stepe [ Z/e.. 44
© Seott Hanseer stepe 3 2/e.. “4
Seott Henswer stope BS iye........ 37.2
1). Seott Maneuer stepe 1 Zye.-........ BA
Seott Hanawer stape 4% i/c.. . @.

302 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO.

Percent Oz.
Lead. Silver.

hee. 12. Mertt Bamater etepe 18 Z/e.n cows sceccecccrcecens 10.7 14.6
Bost Cianawet stome F BAC. oo acces swiwercivovevus 43.2 20.8
ee ae err rere rer Terr rT Te 7.1 13.1
Boots Tlameter whepe FB U/C. 6c ciciccwcsccssccsewes 34.8 17.8

4, Meets Camamet ates FS Bec wews ccwcecsccsvicwsagwe 6.7 3.6
%. Sontt Manmewer atepe & 8/C..00.-ccscscicccuvssess 41.8 21.6
eats Tipmater stent BBs eke vccvevesevvcnes 8.2 9.4

De Tee Sees ON OS Bcc ks ccc eiacesyerens 40.1 20.2
17. Scott Hanaucr stope $1 4 cars 2/C..... 2.6262. cess 9.1 8.2
18. Scott Hanauer stope 3 2 cars 2/c. ........--.0s00 7.2 8.4
Scott Hanawer stope 62 cars 2/C... 2560.0. ccccee 6.4 14.7

23. Seott Hanewer stepe 1 4 cars 2/c... 2.2.22 -ccescces 7.3 7.8
Scott Hanauer stope 3 3 cars 1/c............-000- 25.8 13.
Scott Hanauer stope 3 2 cara 1/C.....cccceccccese 34.2 2.2
Scott Hanauer stope 3 5 cars 2/ce........--...005- 1.2 10.8

23. Scott Hanaver stope 1 4 cars 2/c......---sscccees 9.6 6.4
Scott Hanauer stope 33 cars 1/e.............-... 29.4 13.6

“. Scott Hanauer stope 8 2 cars l/c . 41. 22.
Scott Hanauer stupe 1 4 cars 2/c.........-. 2 eee 17.2 17.1

26. Scott Hanauecr stope 33 cars k/e. . 40.6 32.1
Scott Hanauer Ollus Winze 1 car 2e........ . 26.4 22.2

27. Seott Hanauer stope 21 4 cars 2/e . 4 27.8
Scott Hanauer stope 3 2 cars 1/e...........-..... 47.5 21.3

zs. Seott Hanauer stope et, a ery 9.4 10.6
Scott Hanauer stope 3 3 cars 1/c.............---. 3.5 23.8

23. Scott Hanauer stope 3 3 cars 2/e. ...... 2. ccceeee 5.6 45
Scott Hanaver atepe 2 2 cars 1/¢.......0-.66 2000 43.2 23.3

31. Scott HManeuer stope 3 1 cars 1/c..........eccesnee 35.6 18.
Boskt Tine SE GOO. 2 osc ccc hccsedseweer towne 22.3 13.4
357 C. P. Brooks. recalled by the defendant. testified as follows:

I have been familiar with the Hanauer Tunnel country ever since
the Hanauer tunnel was driven and familiar with the mining opera
tions in the Hanauer tunnel and to the north of it. There was a
long cross-cut ealled the Thayne cross-cut which ran from the
Hanauer tunnel northerly at least 1,500 feet. Ore that was reach
by this Thayne cross-cut was generally referred to as Hanauer ore.
There are large ore bodies lving to the north of the Hanauer tunnel
reached by this cross-cut. These ore bodies lie at least a thousand
feet north of the ore bodies in a part of the Crescent fissure, and
these ore bodies to the north are in an entirely distinet vein having
no connection with the Crescent fissure.

The nearest ore body in this vein to the north of the Hanauer
Tunnel is a little over a thousand feet from the Crescent fissure.
The ore bodies and workings of the Roaring Lion claim of the de
fendant company were about 1,600 feet northerly of the Crescent
fissure. That was the first place where they reached ore in the

ME ROLE LO REE SESE dg ce ce

a a a

i x wa aS =: =e x lew

=

SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO. 303

hayne cross-cut from the Hanauer tunnel. There is no connection
tween the ore bodies in the Crescent fissure and those lying to the
rth that T have mentioned. The intervening country is solid rock.
] was familiar with the work being carried on in the ore bodies
ached from the Thayne cross-cut at the time the work was going on.

THoMAS KEARNS, recalled for the defendant, testified as follows:

There is a cross-cut running northerly from the Hanauer tunnel
lich intersects the vein which is over a thousand feet north-ly of the
escent fissure on the Hanauer Tunnel level. The ore that came
tof the Hanauer Tunnel and out of that cross-cut is generally re-
med to as Hanauer ore. The ore that is reached through the
layne cross-cut is not from the same vein as the ore in the Elephant
spe.

(At this point it was stipulated that if Mr. Davip Kerrn were re-
led his testimony would be to the same effect as that just given by
t. Kearns )

S (Testimony for Plaintiff.)

Frank ANDERSON, sworn for the plaintiff, testified as follows:

lama civil mining engineer. [ was employed by the Conkling
ining Company first in 1908, and made a survey of this property
controversy in September of that vear. Mr. Treweek, President
the Company, was out there with me when T began my survey.
edied eighteen months ago. He was a mining man of this state.
The dates of my surveys are as follows: My first survey, September
th to October 3rd, 1908.

Next survey November 12th to 17th, 1908.

Next survey November 8th to 20th, 1909.

Next survey January 16th 24th, 1912.

My last survey April 12th to 26th. 1916.

I have been out to the mine once since then with Mr. Taylor on
arch 10th and 11th, 1917, but not to survey. When I went out
tte to survey in September, 1908, there were open for observation
¢ MeKay cross cut and a drift run through ealled the K-K drift,
tough which you first go to enter the stopes, shown on Exhibit 2.
le part called the Elephant stope on Exhibit 2 was open at its
terly end from the part marked “filled” on the map, January 29,
08, to the easterly boundary as marked on the map. The main
pe Was caved, filled with caved stuff and cribbed up, where the level
at through, so it could not be entered except at a place
r

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386004_0481%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
