# Petitioners Brief — Tm Duche & Sons, Limited v. American Schooner &C.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386004_0423%3A4

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Petitioners Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1921
- **Citation:** 255 U.S. 77

## Text

INDEX

Ii. Specification of Errors Relied | pon

Abstract and Statement of Case

Hf. Argument : ; ‘ ;
1. The “John Twohy” Was Unscaworthy
2. The Loss and Damage
\. Loss Arising From Injury to a Vart of the Car zo
Delivered in a Damaged Condition Was Pro»
erly Awarded to Libellant- \ppelle:
B. The Libellant-Appellee Is Entitled to a Deere
for Loss Due to Short Delivery Clearly
Proved to Have Occurred Through the Un-
seaworthiness of the “John Twohy”
1. The Intake Weight
2. The Outturn Weight
3. The Shortage
4. Discussion Sten °
(a) The Law
(b) Four Possible Explanations
(1) The Intake Weight Was Correct
(2) The Correctness of the Outturn
Weight Is Not Questioned

(3) There Was No Natural Shrinkag:

m Weight on the Voyage
(4) The Part of the Cargo Not Deliv
ered Was Pumped Overboard Dur-
ing the Voyage
3. The Action of the Circuit Court of Appeals Was Im-
proper
A. The Action of the Circuit Court of \ppeals Was
Inconsistent With the Rulings of This Court
in Irvine v. “The Hesper.” and Reid v. The
American Express Company, and Nullifies the
Rule That on an Appeal in \dmiralty the Case
Is Tried de novo in the Circuit Court of \p-
peals
i NE akntwbGosbnn bebeubverbeceoceecc..c.. ke...

42

TABLE OF CASES CITED.

lage
Aggi, The, 93 Federal 484 ................ vee ' 21
Atlas Portland Cement Co. v. P. Dougherty Co. 205 Fed-

EE EE cticialceadei Mula mudalsdlaiieiidwaaaddlbieciuiteswon sna > ae
Babin Chevaye, The, 208 Federal 966 ................. ; »
Benner Line v. Pendleton (D. C.), 210 Federal 67 ... — +
Benner Line v. Pendicton (C. C. A.), 217 Federal 497 ........ 15
Bradley v. Lehigh Valley Co., 153 Federal 350 .. , 7
Brigham v. Waterhouse, 32 Texas 468 .......... steetene 4
Caledonian, The, 42 Federal 681 .................0....2... )
Carib Prince, The, 170 U. S. 655 ......... Vdvatdaen - 6
Compagnie Maritime Francaise v. Meyer. 248 Federal 881 .... 18
De Sola v. Pomares, 19 Federal 373 ......... Pemaits — »
Edwin L. Morrison, The, 153 U. S. 199 .......... eee
Erskine M. Phelps, The, 231 Federal 767 .................... 17
Farr & Dailey Company v. International Navigation Co., 98

ME TE 3 5 ithe pds andie cdanbensowdaddvwéborsebivesdou 6
Indrapura, The 190 Federal 711 ............ iveetouwaadwes 7
International Navigation Company v. Farr & Lailey (Com-

i, Se ae Se evvecwccences Reedenda adie eae anita 7
fovins ©. Tie Meaper, 028 U. G. FOO .....cvcccccceccvcevecces 42
James v. Standard Oil Co. (D. C.), 189 Federal 719 _......... 24%
James v. Standard Oil Co. (C. C. A.), 191 Federal 827 ....... 7
Lady Franklin. The, 8 Wallace 328 ...............-0ccceeee- 29
RE, Ee NE BOD ve cncaveccecccscccccuvéuceeee 6
EY PE Cc vcacuundurenbocevescesedtare 7
Orcadian, The, 116 Federal 930 ........... 0. e eee cece eeee 21
Pendleton v. The Benner Line, 246 U.S. 353 (U.S.8.C.).... 13
Petersen v. Pry, 169 Mich, GOD .. 2... cccccccccccccccccscceseee 6
Planters Fertilizer Co. v. Elder, 101 Federal 1001 ........... 2”

Poe Gile, Tie, 06) Patel FOP cc ccvcccesextcvecezecssee BF
Reid v. The American Express Co.. 241 U. S. 544 ........... 42

River Meander. The. 209 Federal 931 ....................... 17
Sandfield, The, 92 Federal 663 .......... 22-00 cece ce cecee 6
ne go a eedaveweieesos 7

Ix THE

Supreme Court of the United States.

October Term, 191%. No. 943.

T. M. DUCHE & SONS (BUENOS AIRES), LTD,
Petitioners,
v.

AMERICAN SCHOONER “JOHN TWONY,” HER
TACKLE, ETC. ALBERT D. CUMMINS axe
HOWARD COMPTON,

Claimant «.

Os Warr or Cenrionam ro rae Usrrep Staves Ceri

Cover or Arrrats por tHe Tom Creer.

BRIEF ON BENALF OF PETITIONER.

1. ABSTRACT AND STATEMENT OF THE CASE.

The schooner “John Twohy,”’ warranted to be
“tight, staunch, strong and m every way fitted for the
intended voyage,’' was chartered by the claimants to
the libellant to carry a full and complete cargo of bones
from Buenos Aires to Philadelphia.

The **Twohy"’ was a reclaimed wreck. When she
sailed from Philadelphia for South America to enter
on the performance of this charter she had just under-
gone repairs after having lain in a badly wrecked con-
dition for fifteen months. In the course of her out-
ward voyage, it appeared that she was leaking, the
extent of the leak and other conditions attending her

a

re NER ame

hour, necessitating pumping every two hours, there
being at one time as much as five feet of water in the

The Court below found the
awarded libellant

of the short delivery, refused to award libellant any
damages on account of that claim.

A final deerce was entered on April 16, 1918, and
on April 27, 1918, an appeal was taken by the claim-
ants to the Cireuit Court of Appeals of the Third Cir-
cuit.

This appeal came on for argument in October and
November, 1918, and on each occasion was continued
at the request of the appellants. It again came on in
December, 1918, when the appellants moved for leave
to withdraw their appeal.

This motion was opposed by the petitioner here,
but on February 10, 1919, the Circuit Court of Appeals
over the protest and without the consent of the peti-
tioner, in an opinion by Judge Buffington (Record, p.
204), granted the motion, provided the claimants paid
the amount of the deeree of the District Court with
interest and costs within thirty days, which payment
the claimants offered to make.

‘om Mareh 14, 1919, a final decree (Record, p. 206a)
was entered in the Cirenit Court of Appeals ordering
the dismissal of the appeal.

On March 28, 1919, the petitioner filed with the
Supreme Court of the United States its petition for a
writ of certiorari. This petition was granted and on
April 17, 1919, the certiorari issued, and with the re-
turn thereto, was received and filed in the office of ti
Clerk of the Supreme Court on May 7, 1919.

The questions of law presented under these facts
and raised on this certiorari are the following :

I. Where a libellant in admiralty recovers a part
of his claim in the District Court, and is denied the
balance thereof, and the respondent appeals to the
Cirenit Court of Appeals, can the respondent-appellant
thereafter, and after the expiration of the time limited

a oe

a

4

for an appeal by the libellant, withdraw his appeal
over the protest and without the consent of the libel-
lant-appellee?

II. Under sueh facets is it within the legal disere-
tion of the Circuit Court of Appeals to permit the ap-
pellant to withdraw its appeal over the appellee’s ob-
jection and without its consent?

III. When a libel is filed to recover for short de-
livery and for cargo damage, and the Court finds the
vessel unseaworthy and allows recovery for the cargo
damage, can it refuse to allow for the short delivery
on the ground that it is not sufficiently proved and as-
sume that there is an error in the bill of lading weight,
in a case where the burden is on the ship to exonerate
itself and the Master testifies that he delivered all the
cargo he received but leaves entirely unexplained and
does not exclude an explanation of the shortage un-
der which the ship would be liable, and whieh is sup-
ported by the overwhelming weight of the evidence?

IT, SPECIFICATION OF THE ERRORS RELIED
UPON.
The petitioner relies upon and assigns the follow-
ing errors:

1. The Cirenit Court of Appeals erred in grant-
ing the motion of the appellants below for leave to
withdraw their appeal.

2. The Cireuit Court of Appeals erred in refus-
ing to dismiss the motion for leave to withdraw its
appeal.

3. The Cirenit Court of Appeals erred in refusing
to hear and determine on the merits the anpeal taken

5

,

from the District Court for the Kastern District of
Pennsylvania in this eatise.

4. The Cireuit Court of Appeals erred in not con-
sidering on the merits the claim of the appellee in
that court, the petitioner here, for additional damages
for short delivery,

9. The Cireuit Court of Appeals erred in refusing
to grant the petitioner damages for short delivery
Which had been refused in the District Court.

_—

II]. ARGUMENT.

The questions raised in this case may for con-
venience be divided into two sroups or classes, those
relating to the question of practice and those relating
to the merits, Primarily the case is before this Court
on the question of practice but as this question can be
best understood and decided with reference to the
particular facts, we desire for the sake of clearness
and orderly conside ‘ation, to present first, as briefly
as possible, the points raised on the merits,

The questions involved in the Cireuit Court of Ap-
peals were novel ones, of great importance in the ad-
niralty practice, not heretofore decided by this Court
or any other Federal Court; the decision of the Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals in this case is erroneous, tends
to complicate the admiralty practice, is contrary to and
to a large extent nullifies important decisions of this
Court of such long ‘standing as to have become set-
tled law, and if allowed to stand unreviewed and un-
corrected by this Court will, in many cases, as it has
in this, work the greatest injustice to suitors who act
in reliance upon the decisions of this Court for the pre
tection of their rights and the conduct of their litiga-
tion.

— ODO OLLIE ET PPE RET ll —

——,

6

Two issues were raised in the District Court—
First, the seaworthiness of the ‘““John Twohy,’”’ and,
Second, the amount of the loss. The second issue had
two branches: (a) Loss arising from damage to part
of the cargo delivered; ( b) loss arising from short
delivery.

The Distriet Court found the vessel unseaworthy
and awarded damages for injury to the eargo deliy-
ered, but denied recovery for the short delivery.

1. Tue “‘Joux Twony” Was Unseaworruy.

The evidence clearly established the unseaworth-
iness of the “John Twohy”’ as the cause of the loss.

In considering this branch of the case four points
should be borne in mind:

First.—The provision in the charter party that
the vessel is **tight, staunch, strong and in every way
fitted for the intended voyage’’ is an absolute war-
ranty of seaworthiness even against latent defects.

The Edwin L. Morrison, 153 U. S. 199;
The Lockport, 197 Fed. 213;
The Caledonian, 42 Fed. 681,

Second.—The Harter Act, which is not mentioned
in the charter, does not operate to relieve the owner
or the vessel from liability for the consequences of un-
Seaworthiness, even where it is proved that the owner
exereised due diligence to make the vessel seaworthy.
It is incumbent on the owner to provide a seaworthy
vessel, unless by contract he limits his obligation to
the exercise of due diligence to make her 80.

The Carib Prince, 170 U. 8. 655 ;

The Sandfield, 92 Fed. 663;

Farr € Bailey Co, v. International Naviga-
tion Co., 98 Fed. 636 ;

—

7

The Ninfa, 156 Fed. Rep. 512;
The Indrapura, 190 Fed. Rep. 711.

Third.—There is no provision in the charter party
limiting the obligation of the owners to provide a sea-
worthy vessel] or reducing their obligation in that con-
nection to the exercise of due diligence to make (be
vessel seaworthy.

Fourth—The burden of affirmatively proving the
seaworthiness of the vessel at the time of loading the
cargo, and at the commencement of the vovage, rests
upon the ship owner.

International Navigation Co, r. Farr &
Bailey Co., 181 U. S. 218;

The Wildcroft, 201 U. S. 378;

Bradley v. Lehigh Valley Co., 153 Fed. 350.

With these points in mind let us consider the facts
in the ease, which are essentially undisputed, These
clearly appear of record, and are as follows:

The ‘‘John Twohy” is an old schooner, which,
when built in 1891, was not properly fastened and be-
came badly hogged (Cummins, p. 145). In November,
1913, she was wrecked off the North Caeelina coust,
and from that time until February, 1915, was lying
in a wrecked condition at Southport, North Carolina,
and at Philadelphia (Record, p. 27),

During the period from February to June, 1915,
the ‘“‘Twohy’’ was repaired and strengthened, and on
June 18, 1915, sailed from Philadelphia with a cargo
of lumber, bound for Rosario on the River Plate,
where she arrived the early part of September (Ree-
ord, p. 30). On her outward voyage she was found
to he leaking, and at the conelusion thereof, the cap-
tain removed a turnbuckle rod which had been placed
athwartships near her bow and plugged the holes,

—_ —— ir z ; a A Nee ae etc

8

after which she proceeded to Buenos Aires to load the
cargo of bones here involved ( Record, p. 28).

Of the details of the outward voyage we have no
information owing to the loss or destruction of the
log of the vessel during the pendeney of this action
(Record, pp. 103, 148, 149). The only information
which we have is that on that voyage the **Twohy”’
leaked to such an extent that the master felt it nee-

a turnbuckle rod which had been put in to strengthen
her, and plug the holes (Record, p. 28).
The testimony is that the master did this on his

of whom swore that the turnbuckle rod was entirely
unnecessary, added nothing to the strength of the ves-
sel, and had no effect on her strength whatsoever: the

cargo here in question—the turnbuckle rod that had
been taken out was, by order of the claimant, put back
in the vessel agatn, at exactly the same place from
which it had been taken (Record, p. 148).

This fact alone is sufficient to impeach, if not ut-
terly to discredit, the testimony that the turnbuckle
rod was useless and unnecessary,

out was to let her settle back and loosen her seams
(Mowatt, pp. 98, 99), all Of which were recalked and
recemented after she discharged hey cargo at Phila-
delphia ( Record, p. 1

—

9

It is submitted that the above facts alone are suf.
ficient to show that the vessel was unseaworthy, Sup-
plemented, however, as this testimony is by the other
evidence, and the facts as they developed on the voy-
age, the unseaworthiness of this vessel at the inception
of the voyage here involved is clearly and undeniably
established,

The vessel left Buenos Aires on October 21, 1915,
bound for Philadelphia. Here again we are confronted
with the loss or destruction of the log book pending
this action. The extended protest made by the master
upon arrival at Philadelphia gives us no details of the
Weather, the progress of the vessel, or the amount of
leakage for the days from October 21st to October
29th.

The first detail appearing from the protest and
from the other evidence before the ( ourt is that of
October 30th, when the weather became a little heavy
and continued so for a day and a half.

This, however, was ordinary had Weather, noth-
ing extraordinary or unexpected. As stated by the
master (Forsyth, p. 157):

“Q. How would you describe this vovage
which you made from Buenos Aires up to Phila-
delphia with the cargo of bones!

A. About the usual thing. 1 suppose you
would have about eighty per cent. fine weather
and the rest bad, tw ‘uty per cent. bad,”’

Forsyth, pages 1645:

“Q. You say vou had a northeast gale and
that you very often do not get those kind of
gales?

A. When is this?

Q. On the way back.

A. Oh, ves.

Q. But, vou do get, I have you down, as get-
ting a northwest gale?

ee

and ]

Q. And this season of the year, that gale was
unusual?

A. Which one?

(). The one that you had, the northeast gale?

A. No—in October.

Q.' It was not unusual?

A. This southwest gale in October?

Q. Yes.

A. That is very strong down there. No, it
Was not an unusual thing to get the southwest gale.
You ex those things, you look for them.
ou talked about northwest gales you don’t

A. No.

Q. But thet are about the same as the south-
west gales, are they?

A. About the same as what our southwesters
are around here. You can reverse them, and you

have it down pretty near.’’

Forsyth, page 167:

“@. And the hatches were battened down all
the way during the voyage and the only water that
came in over the top of the vessel and got in was
; ’

Q. And the cabin door was open at the time
this wave happened to strike the vessel]?

ee

1]

Q. During this voyage were any of the deck
fittings torn away from the vessel? No
was done to the deck fittings of the vessel, was
there?

A. I don’t remember. | don’t think so.

Q. No lifeboats carried away or anything of
that sort?

A. No.”’

Forsyth, page 168:

“Q. You have told us that the vessel was leak-
ing six inches per hour?

A. Yes, six inches per hour.

Q. Is that ordinary or extraordinary !

A. I think it is too much.

(. How long did that continue ?

A. From the time we got that northwest
gale of wind until—of course, she always made
lots of water after that, but she wouldn't make as
much in moderate weather, she wouldn't make as
much as when she would get into a blow, tumbling
and slapping around.

Q. Did you ever have any sounding made as
to the amount of water in the hold?

A. Yes, after she sprung that leak, we
sounded her pretty much all the time, always
somebody with the sounding rod in their hand.

Q. What was the greatest amount of water
you had?

A. It seems to me at one time we had five
feet.”

A reference to the protest shows that the vovage
consumed altogether sixty-nine days, out of which
there were six days of bad weather—les« than ten per
cent. bad—whereas the master states (Forsyth, p.
157), that on the average voyage between Buenos
Aires and Philadelphia at that season of the vear the
average weather would be about twenty per cent. bad
—and as set forth in the testimony above quoted (For-
syth, pp. 164-165, 167, 168), the bad weather experi-

The burden clearly rests upon the claimant to
prove that the “John Twohy’’ was, at the inception
of the voyage, in all respects seaworthy. This ix xo

Benner Line v. Pendleton, 10 Fed. 67 DOS bp
NX, Y.), where, at page 72, Judge Holt says:
“I have no doubt that the believed
her to be seaworthy, and that Fletcher,
a ver the duty of patting the chin en,
intrusted Y of putting in order,
‘wd her to be Vv.

st

qantity and degree than that offered im this case now
at har. Vet the Court found in the case cited:

vessel was much «t

* Bat admittedly the Weather was not heavy

' Weather Was nothing so extraordinary
about it that a ship in prope: condition to make ay
ocean Vovage should not have been in condition to
undergo the strain, - - ~ J have no doula that
fe auners believed her to he seaworthy Bat facts
fact th nienee Peak loader than wostha net

it, is, in my opinion, not consistent with her beornige
seaworthy at the beginning of the vovage."’

“Bat neither the goed intentions of the re.
spondent nor the competency A this captain cay

Meneed.
To constitute seaworthiness the bull must he
80 tight Fong as to be competent to

cell ordinary netion af the mew se pete
- ay anc complete the vovage without damage
carge."’ :

16

stand the strain. The fact that the vessel sprang
so bad a leak, and that no satisfactory explanation
of the fact has been made, indicates to us, as it did
to the Court below, that the vessel was not sea.
worthy as to her hull at the beginning of the voy-

age.”?

The only points upon which the case just cited and
quoted can be distinguished from the ease at bar is
that the loss was more serious.

Essential fact for essential fact the cases are iden-
tical and the words quoted from the opinions of the
courts apply even more strongly to the present ease
than to the case in which they were written, and the
decision in that case flatly rules this one.

Other cases without number might be cited to the
same effect, but it is perhaps unnecessary to do more
than state as briefly as possible the heldings of a few
of them.

In Atlas Portland Cement Co. v. P. Dougherty Co.,
205 Fed. 508 (C. C. A., 2nd Circuit), a libel was filed
to recover for damage by sea water to a cargo of
cement.

In support of a defense based on perils of the sea,
respondents showed that the vessel encountered very
heavy weather, twice broke her tiller and that her gaso-
line engine broke down, rendering her pumps useless.

The Cirenit Court of Appeals affirmed the decree
in favor of the libellant on the opinion of Judge Veeder,
who said:

‘‘In the first place, the evidence fails to show
that the ‘Patuxent’ encountered any peril of the
sea. None of the witnesses called by the respond-
ent placed the velocity of the wind any higher on
the Beaufort Scale than a fresh gale; they put it

between forty and fifty miles an hour. = me

17

others words, there js nothing to indicate that the
Weather encountered was anything beyond what
was to be expected along the coast in the autumn.”’

In The Erskine M. Phelps, 231 Fed, 767 (D. CLN,
D. Cal. (1915}), Judge Dooling, holding a vessel not
excused by perils of the Sea, said:

‘But the storms encountered were not greater
than, might reasonably have been expected in
rounding the Horn at that season of the year and
in accepting this shipment, it must be presumed
that it was accepted in view of the character of the
goods, the character of the crating and the Weather
likely to be encountered, ”’

See, too, the language of Judge Holt in The River
Meander, 209 Fed. 931 (U. §. D. C., So. D., N. Y.),
1913:

‘*In the first place there can be no presumption
(of seaworthiness ) in such a case as this. The
Wilderoft, 201 U. S. 378, 26 Sup. Ct. 467, 50 L. Ed.
794. It must be affirmatively proved by the ship
owner. Now there is no evidence in this case that
the vessel was seaworthy when she began her voy-
age.

“In my opinion, if a ship is shown to be un-
seaworthy during a voyage, the inference may be
drawn, in the absence of any explanation to the
contrary, that she was unseaworthy when she
started. Cargo Owners usually cannot prove un-
Seaworthiness at the time a voyage begins.

“It is the duty of the ship owner to know that
his ship is seaworthy before the Voyage begins,
and if he does know it he can prove it. If a vesse]
proves to be unseaworthy during a Voyage the
burden should be on the ship owner to prove affirm.
atively that she was seaworthy at the time the Voy-
age began.’’

The claimant here does not know and did not know
whether or not the vessel was seaworthy on this voyage,

18

His attittide is perhaps best illustrated by his testi-
mony (Cummins, pp. 150-151) ;

“Q. Never heard that the vessel leaked on
that voyage going down?
A. Yes,

Q. You heard that?
. Yes,
Q. How mugh did the vessel leak on the voy-
age going down?
A. The captain will answer that. I don’t
know. I wasn’t aboard.
Q. What did the captain report to you?
A. The vessel leaked.
Q. How much of a leak?
A. Didn’f report how much.
Q. Did you look at the log book when the cap-
tain brought it back to see?
_N

0.
. The log book showed, didn’t it?
- I don’t know, I didn’t look at it.
- The fact is the vesse] leaked?
. | don’t know.
- You don’t know anything about that?
I know it leaked. I don’t know how much,
- You never even looked in the log book to
see how much it leaked?

A. No, She got there and back, that is all |
was interested in,

Q. That is all you care, so it went down to
South America and got back again?

A. Yes.”’

PObOb>S>

oO

Can anyone contend that the above testimony is
that of a careful, prudent ship owner? ( ‘learly it ean-
not be said that it is. Nor is the language of an owner
who is performing his duty, which, in the language of
Judge Holt, is, “to know that his ship is seaworthy he-
fore the voyage begins,’

See, too, the very recent case of Compagnie Mari-
time Francaise ¢. Meyer, 248 Federal 88] (C. C. A.,

19

Ith Cireuit, 1918), where a French bark, within four
days after leaving Brest on a voyage from Rotterdam
to San Francisco, without having encountered weather
which was unusual at the Season, was found to he leak-
ing so that she had to be pumped cae}; day thereafter
until she reached the Vicinity of Cape Horn, when,
meeting stormy weather, the leak increased, and she
was obliged to seek a harbor of refuge. It was held
that she was unseaworthy at the beginning of the Voy-
age, although surveyed at that time, and the libellants
were awarded damages for the breach of the Warranty
of seaworthiness,

In delivering the opinion of the Cireuit Court of
Appeals, Judge Gilbert Said (p. 883) ;

‘The evidence Was that such; Weather was not
unusual or unexpected in that Vicinity at that sea-
son of the year. It has been held by this court and
by other courts that the development of 4 serious
leak, occurring from no mishap or accident within
a short period of time from leaving port, is ey.
dence from which it may be presumed that the
vessel was not seaworthy at the time Of leaving.
In The Warren Adams, 74 Fed. 413, 20 0. OA.
486, Judge Wallace, for the Cireuit Court of Ap
peals for the Second Circuit, said:

"Where a Vessel, soon after leaving
port, becomes leaky, without stress of weather
or other adequate cause of injury, the pre-
sumption is that she was unsound before set.

“Other decisions to the same effect are Pa-
cific Coast S. §. Co. vy. Bancroft-Whitney Co., 94
Fed. 180, 36 C, ¢. A. 135; The Aggi (D. C.), 93
Fed. 484; The Arctie Bird (D. C.), 100 Fed. 167;
Oregon Bound Lumber Co, y. Portland & Asiatic
S. S. Co. (D. C.), 162 Fed. 912; Steamship Welles-
ley Co. v. (. A. Hooper & Co., 185 Fed. 735, 108
C. 0. A. Ti: Carolina Portland Cement Co, y. An-
derson, 186 Fed,”’

a PIE LEY ee aa sn ie ies

20
In The Edwin L. Morrison, 153 U. 8. 199, at page

210, Chief Justice Fuller, delivering the opinion of the
Court, said:

no obligation to look after the matter rests upon
the owner of the cargo. The Northern Belle, 9
Wall. 526; Work y. Leathers, 97 U. s. 379. If
there be a defect, although latent and unknown to
the charterer, he js not excused. 3 Kent, *205,
Valin, Com. Ord. de la Mar. liv 111, tit, 111. Du
Fret; Art. XI, Vol. 1, 654; Lyon y. Mells, 5 Kast.
428; Work v. Leathers, supra.

“As said on cireuit by Mr. Justice Gray, in
The Caledonia, 43 Fed. Rep. 681, 685: «| n every
contract for the carriage of goods by sea, unless
otherwise expressly stipulated, there is a warranty
on the part of the ship owner that the ship is sea-
worthy at the time of beginning her voyage, and

her seaworthy. The warranty is absolute that th,
ship is, or¢shall be, in fact, seaworthy at that time
and does not depend on his knowledge or ignor-
ance, his care or negligence,’ ”?

And in the Babin Chevaye, 208 Fed. 966 (1913),

Judge Wolverton, quoting with approval from Cebal-
los v. The Warren Adams, said at page 975:

‘Where a vessel, soon after leaving port, be-
comes leaky, without stress of weather, or other
adequate cause of

21

In the present case there is not even a suggestion
that the weather encountered was any more severe
than was ordinarily to be anticipated at that time ain
place. The only testimony on this point is that of tne
master—the claimant's own witness—and that estab-
lishes clearly and indisputably that the weather en-
countered by the **John Twohy”’ on this voyage was
not only not worse than was ordinarily to be expected
at that time and place, but was actually much better
Weather than could have been anticipated,

In The Agyi, 93 Fed. 484, it was held that storms,
although they may have been adequate cause for the
damage, wil] hot relieve the carrier where they are not
of such unusual character but that they should have
been anticipated,

And in The Orcadian, 116 Fed. 930, it was held
that where the weather is not more severe than is to
be expected from the season and the locality, perils of
the sea is no defense,

The only evidence which claimant presents as ty
seaworthiness js confined to the time the vessel lef;
Philadelphia—what may have happened to the vessel
on her outward voyage, what weather she may have
encountered, what obstructions she may have hit jy
the river, what strains she may have been subjected
to before loading this cargo of bones, are all in the
dark and unknown,

Because of. the destruction of the ship’s log book
by the claimants while this action was pending, we
are unable to obtain any evidence ag to this outward
Vvovage. It is entirely possible that events occurring
on that outward voyage may have rendered her ey.
tirely unseaworthy before she reported at Buenos
Aires for the voyage here involved.

— oe Re OTe» oe ae oe ONE SEO ese are.

22

The destruction of this log opens the way and en-
titles the libellant to the benefit of the presumption
that had the log been produced, its contents would have
heen unfavorable to the claimants’ case,

The rule is well stated by Professor Wigmore in
his work on Evidence, Vol. 1, See. 291, page 383, where,
after carefully considering the cases, he says:

“The failure or refusal to produce a relevant
document, or the destruction of it, is evidence from

which alone its contents may be inferred to be
unfavorable to the possessor, ’!

The claimants’ failure to produce evidence as to
the seaworthiness of the schooner at the inception
of this voyage and the fact that they confined their
testimony to a point of time prior to her outward
voyage from Philadelphia to Rosario, coupled with
the destruction of the log, are, we submit, sufficient
to warrant a finding by the court that the outward
voyage developed and made clear defeets in the vessel
that demonstrated her unseaworthiness before the i.

The claimant's witnesses have been most insistent
upon the point that all wooden vessels leak to some ex.
tent. If this is 80, and is such a matter of common
knowledge, then it is clear that no mention would be
made of this ordinary leakage by the vessel on its out.
ward voyage. Yet Cummins testifies (pp. 150-151) that
the master reported to him that the vessel was leaking
on her outward voyage.

The only explanation of this report would seem to
be either that the testimony that all wooden vessels
leak to some extent, is false, which we do not believe,
or that on this outward voyage the leakage of the
“*Twohy’’ was excessive, which we do believe. Under
either explanation the “‘Twohy”’ was unseaworthy, and
of this unseaworthiness her master and owners had
knowledge.

SS

23

The claimants have endeavored at great length, as
did the owners of the “Edith Oleott” in the case of
Benner Line vy. Pendleton, to establish the seaworthi-
ness of the vessel. Like the owners of the ** Edith
Vleott”’ they have failed to do so, and have failed be-
cause the facts were against them and the Vessel was
not in fact seaworthy at the inception of the voyage
as the subsequent events clea rly aud undeniably proved.

The burden was clearly on the claimants and the
vessel to establish the seaworthiness at the inception
of the voyage, and just as clearly they have entirely
failed to support this burden,

We submit that this case is flatly ruled by the deei-
sion of the lower courts, affirmed by this court in the
case of the Benner Line v. Pendleton, above quoted,
and that it cannot be seriously contended that the
“John Twohy”’ was seaworthy at the time of the in-
ception of her voyage here in question,

For the damages flowing from this ulisea Worthi-

ness it is clear that the libellant was entitled to a de-
cree.

2. Tue Loss axp Damace.

As above set out, libellant's damages were of two
kinds, viz, :

(a) Loss arising from injury to a part of the
cargo delivered in a damaged condition.

(b) Loss arising from the non-delivery of a por-
tion of the cargo,

These items we will consider in order,

A. Loss Arising From Injury to a Part of the Cargo
Delivered in a Damaged Condition Was Properly
Awarded to Libellant,

It is for this item that the Court below awarded to
the libellant, the full amount claimed. The facts in
this connection are these:

ee oe

24

“I think I called them dark, dirty bones, very
wet, and a with mud, and slime coated f rom
t of the v

excess moisture was sixteen per cent. or 62,305 pounds
making the net weight of damaged bones 327,102
pounds (Burrichier, Reeord, pp, 77-78; Stoehr, Recor,

The undisputed evidence of the witness Burrich{er
is that these damaged bones were worth $5.70 per ton

worth $27 per net ton; the damaged bone being wort)
only $21.30 per net ton.

Burrichter testified that $21.30 was a fair price for
the damaged bone, and the market price so far as

- —o

+ ee

Reese ~

there was a market, that it was the price at whieh the
sellers of the bone settled with the purchasers of the
cargo after extensive inquiries and offers to sell to
others (Burrichter, Record, pp. 75, 79, 80, 91, 94).

This evidence is not in any Way impeached, con.
tested or controverted by the claimants and may be
taken as conceded.

It is in fact supported by the clear evidence of the
Withess Stoehr, who testifies ( Record, Pp. 66, G9), that
the damaged bones were found to he deficient in their
most essential elements, ammonia, aud phosphoric acid,
and by the statement of Burrichter (Reeord, pp. 80, 81),
where he testified as follows :

“Q. What was necessary to be done for these
bones to make them saleable?
A. re were four or five different eCXPetses,
The first one was the expense in connection wit);
the handling of these bones because they had been
Separated from the sound portion. That meant
carting and handling to a separate pile. The hone«
to be dried out before they could be used. They
were very dirty and wet. ¥ could not be used
in the mill by themselves, Tho chemist explained
that they were deficient in ammonia and phosphoric
acid. In order to make them available to use, it
was necessary to buy high-priced material, which
runs very high jn nitrogen, or ammonia, which ix
the trade term, and combine it with the hones, Also
it was necessary to use a small percentage in the
grinding of the wet bones with a g£00d portion of
the sound bones, You cannot grind wet bones,
'y will give a bone meal which results very dark
in appearance. They were dirty. We cannot sel]
dark bone meal, It is necessary to put it in with
the whiter, cleaner bones, making the resultant
bone meal lighter jin color.’’

The existence and amount of this damage, being
thus ascertained there remains to be considered oniy
its cause.

HE

2:3:4

&

Lik

Under these circumstances, it jis submitted that
the intake weight is clearly extablished ax being 2.670,
MO pounds.

2. The Outtare Weight.

The out-turn weight, while a littl more invelved,
is clearly established and has at no point in the case

It was clearly shown by the witness Lyons (Ree.
ord, p. 57), that the actual gross out-turn weight on
the whole cargo was 283,581 pounds, of which A G7
pounds were wet.

Ky the testimony of the witnesses Stocher (Ree.
ord, pp. 62 and 63), and Burrichter (Record, p. 77),
it was clearly established that the excess moisture in
the 380,407 pounds of wet hones Was sixteen per cent.
or in weight 62,305 pounds.

Neo attempt has been made “0 far in this case, and
we do not assume that any will be made in thi« court,
te attack or impeach the correctness of this weight, but
it should he mentioned in connection therewith, that
the libeflant (Record, PP. 38, 71, 78), settled with it.

!

7
i.
“i
Hi
$:
F

ment satisfactory proof to the contrary, ix conclusive
on the point,
The Lady Prautlin, * Wallace 228,
Planter's Fevtitiee, Co. ©. Elder, WA Ped.
LD
_ DieSeha &. Vomarrs, 19 Fed. 373,

In The Presque Ide, 140 Fed. Wy Dy
N. V.), 1905, it wae san:

“It is auiformly held that
prima facie evidence of
dise and ite comlition
Amer. & Enev. of La 7
ref. at. =. 16, 17 LL.
N. V. 520: The T. Cj, 12 Pel.
174; Lazarus ». Ka «©. AL), 196 Ped, 54a)"

This is the number stated in the bill of lad.
ing, aul the statement in the bill of inding of ar:
mumber of cases recvived is strong prima face
evidence of such reeript, but it ix not comelasive "'

(nm appeal the decision wad affirmed, 191 Ped.
27 (C. C. AL Sed Cire.), Judge Ward “ying, page

The bill of lading in respect to the quantity
received ix a receipt and, theagh entitled to gteat
Wetrht as an admiasion n it i .
elasiy«, The barden live apron the chip of thay.
oughly satisfying the Court that he actually has
delivered all the cargo she has received, aud that
the bill of lading is ervoncons,””

Reese.

—

30

Under these authorities and the circumstances of
this case, the bill of lading weight must stand as cor-
rect unless the ship, in the words of Judge Ward,
“thoroughly satisfies the Court that she actually has
delivered all the cargo she has received, and that the
bill of lading is erroneous,”’

The rule being thus well settled by the decided
cases, the question arises as to whether the vessel
has in this ease rebutted the presumption arising out
of the admission contained in the bill of lading.

sively demonstrates that the loss was due to a cause
for which the ship was not responsible,

(b) Four Possible Explanations.

In this case there are four possible explanatibis
of the shortage: ©

First.—Mistake in the intake or pil] of lading
weight.

Second.—Mistake in the out-turn or delivered
weight.

Third.—Natural] shrinkage,

Fourth—That the part of the cargo not delivered
was pumped out on the voyage,

If the shortage was due to either of the first, see-
ond or third causes, the vesge] would be exensed from
liability; if to the fourth cause, it would have to re-
spond in damages,

a

iia

ae) See

31

So far in the ease there has been no dispute as
to the out-turn weight. The claimants contended that
the shortage was due to mistake in the bill of lading or
intake weight, to natural shrinkage or to a ecombina-
tion of the two. The libellant consistently maintained
that the undelivered cargo was pumped overboard,
and that the bill of lading weight was correct.

Bearing in mind that the burden rests upon the
ship to ‘* thoroughly satisfy the Court that she actually
has delivered all the cargo she has received and that
the bill of lading is erroneous,’’ let us examine the
evidence to see how far, if at all, it sustains each or
any of the four possible explanations of the shortage.

1. The Intake Weight Was Correct.

The unqualified statement of the weight of the
eargo in the bill of lading is very strong prima facie
evidence of its correctness, which in this ease is sup-
ported by the other evidence in the ease.

Captain Forsyth, the master, called as a witness
on behalf of the claimants, testified that libellants’
men weighed the bones as they were put aboard the
schooner, and (Record, p. 162), deseribed the method
used, which seems to be careful and exact. He said:

‘They have a little trolley track lying in the
yard, and they have a little flat trolley and the
men will fill those baskets. This little trolley car
is weighed in the morning with so many empty
baskets. Then they will fill those empty baskets
and put them on the trolley car, and run them
down and put them on the seales, and each man
will take a basket and carry it across the street
and dump it down the hold.’

In its essential particulars this system of weigh-
ing is the same as that which was used when the vessel
was discharged, and which gave such satisfactory re-
sults.

32

The captain was so satisfied with the weighing at
Buenos Aires that he was content to sign a clean bill
of lading without inserting any of the customary quali-
fying phrases, such as “‘shipper’s weight,” “said to
weigh,’’ ‘weight unknown,”’ ete., and presumably paid
the stevedore on the basis of the weight shown.

The shipper, the libellant, had no incentive to pad
the weights inasmuch as the cargo was sold on the
delivered weight.

The stevedore, the only person interested in pad-
ding the Weight, had, as the master testified ( Record,
pp. 162-163), nothing to do with the weighing,

All these matters tend most strongly to support
the correctness of the bill of lading Weight, and to
give it an evidential value much greater than its mere
presence in the bill of lading.

Against these facts there is no countervailing eyj-
dence sufficient to rebut them.

The captain testified that he delivered all the
cargo he received. This is a mere statement of a con-
clusion, and if it were to be given controlling weight,
shippers and consignees would be placed entirely at
the merey of unscrupulous masters, The other evi-
denee does not Support the captain’s averment, which
was predicated, as appears from his later testimony,
on the facet that when the loading was completed, the
hatches were closed and battened down, and were not
again opened until the vessel berthed at Philadelphia,
and that there was no opportunity for anyone to steal
any of the cargo.

As we will point out later, these facts are entirely
consistent with that which we contend is the true
theory—namely, that the missing part of the cargo was
pumped overboard with the water which leaked into
the vessel, because of her unseaworthiness,

In this conneetion it is to be noted that the eap-
tain qualified his Statement that he had delivered all

33

the cargo he received, when on cross-examination he
admitted ( Record, p. 1 71), that the fine particles of
bone might have been pumped overboard.

Manifestly the Statement of the captain, qualified
as it is by his admissions on cross-examination, is vot
such evidence as will thoroughly satisfy the mind of
the Court that the ship here delivered all the cargo she
received, and especially is this true when we consider
that it leaves entirely open the possibility, which we
will later demonstrate to he the fact, that the cargu
called for by the bil] of lading, and not delivered, was
actually pumped overboard as the result of unsea-
worthiness of the vessel,

We feel that it cannot for a moment be success-
fully maintained that a ship can rebut the strong
prima facie evidence of an unqualified admission in a
bill of lading by an explanation which leaves entirely
unanswered a Wholly reasonable explanation of the
loss which js entirely consistent with all the facets
proved in the ease,

The only other evidence which it could be argued
might tend to impeach the Correctness of the bill of
lading weight is that referred to by the District Court
where it ealls attention to the faet that although the
bill of lading ealls for 287 bags of an average weight
of 98 pounds apiece, the out-turn shows the delivery of
241 bags, averaging in weight about 841,, pounds each.

A further examination of the evidence, however,
discloses that there is no basis fo Support the pre-
sumption sought to be raised,

In addition to the 241 bags counted, a very con-
siderable number of bags were broken, and were
heaved up on deck, together with the bones they had
contained,

' No one counted the broken Bags, and when the
master was asked by the Court whether he thought as

34

many as forty-six bags were broken, replied, ‘They
must have been’? ( Record, p. 161).

The presumption that there was a shortage in the
number of bags in the out-turn is purely speculative
as there is no evidence whatsoever as to the actuaj
number of bags delivered.

So, too, with any argument based on the differ-
ence between the average intake and out-tury Weights
of the bags.

These bags were of all sizes, and in no wa y uniform
in weight or otherwise. It is exceedingly doubtfu!
whether they were tightly sewed, and it is most likely
that a great quantity of the contents could have fallen
out, even from the bags that were discharged with
bones still in them.

The method of loading was exceedingly likel to
break the bags, as was also the working of the cargo
on the voyage from Buenos Aireg to Philadelphia, and

riage of this cargo, and the rough handling to which
it was subjected, the bags most likely to break would
be the ones most heavily filled,

Any argument based on the difference between the
average intake and out-turn Weights of the hags is
therefore entirely speculative.

It is thus apparent that to argue from the differ-
ence in count and average weight of the bags of bones
is to pile speculation upon speculation to reach a re-
sult so wholly speculative as to be impossible of be-
lief.

The existence of the shortage is equally consistent
with any explanation that may be made of it, and
consequently cannot be urged as impeaching the eor-
rectness of the bill of lading weight.

We, therefore, submit that the evidence in’ this
case tends much more strongly to Support than it does

35

to impeach the correctness of the intake weight, as
set forth in the bil] of lading.

Especially is this true in view of the fact that the
evidence most clearly establishes an explanation of
the shortage entirely consistent with the correctness
of the bill of lading weight, and much more reasonable
then the appellants’ theory that the bil] of lading
weight is erroneous,

2. The Correctness of the Out-turn Weight Is Not
Questioned.

The out-turn Weight has not been, and, we assume,
will not be, questioned in this ease. Its correctness
was clearly demonstrated by the testimony of the wit-
nesses, Lyons, Stoeher and Burrichter, The bones
were carefully weighed as they were taken from the
Ship, and the excess moisture jy the wet portion of
the cargo was accurately determined by carefully and
properly conducted tests. The claimants accepted pay-
ment of their freight, and the libellant settled with the
vendee of the cargo on the basis of the Weight thus de-
termined, and there is nowhere fn the evidence any
Suggestion that it is not entirely correct.

The out-turn Weight must therefore be taken as
conclusively established,

3. There Was No Natural Sh rinkage in Weight on
the Voyage.

In their efforts to avoid liability for the short-
age, claimants argue that there js generally shortage
in these bone cargoes. This may in fact be admitted.

to two per cent. as a fair average ; that three per cent.

Biren 2g ot ae . Tene

a

36

ent case, the shortage is approximately five and «i X-
tenths per cent., far in excess of even what would he
considered very unusual.

Clearly this defense, if sustained on the facts jy
the case, could not be available to the schooner to any
extent greater than the ordinary or customary short
age of one or two per cent.

We submit, however, that no allowance ean in this
case be made for any shortage on the ground of ens.
tomary shrinkage inasmuch as the facts here exclude
the possibility of the existence in this ease of the
causes of such shrinkage on the ordinary voyage.

From the evidence, it appears clearly that th»
ouly explanation that can be given of the ordinary
shortage is that bones dry out during the Vvovage
(Record, p. 158). It also appears from the evidence
that bones when soaked in water act like sponges, and

On the voyage of the ““Twohy”’ here in question
the undisputed evidence is that for a period of up.
wards of two months her hold constantly had a em.

this period the vessel was leaking at the rate of six
inches an hour. The hatches wore tightly hattened

A great quantity of the bones was constantly soak-
ing in the water in the hold, and, coming up through

37

These facts rendered it altogether impossible for

the bones in this cargo to dry out on the voyage, and
it is manifest that in this particular case the explana-
tion of the shortage cannot be sustained as a usual
and customary thing.
) The shortage here was far in excess of the average
and, in fact, was practically double what would be and
is considered a very unusual and excessive shortage.
In the seeond place, the cause of the usual shortage,
viz., drying out on the voyage, could not have been and
Was not operative in this case. Owing to the constant
flooded condition of the hold of this Vessel, the cargo
here should have shown on delivery an increased rather
than a decreased weight.

The excess moisture contained in the wet bones
alone was much more than sufficient to counterbalance
the one per cent. or two per cent. loss in weight which
it was stated would be the fair average, [y addition
to this, however, we have in the present case a differ.
ence of 86,746 pounds between the established intake
weight and the gross out-turn weight. Manifestly the
usual or customary drying out on the vovage cannot
explain the loss existing in this case.

From the foregoing discussion, it is manifest that
the three possible explanations of the shortage which
would free the ship from liability are not supported by
the evidence in this case, and it remains to consider
the fourth possible explanation.

4. The Part of the ¢ ‘argo Not Delivered Was
Pumped Overboard During the Voyage.

The fourth possible explanation, the one which
the evidence demonstrates was in fact the true cause
of the shortage, is that the missing part of the cargo
was pumped overboard during the vovage in the form
of ammonia and phosphorie acid in solution, and in
the form of fine particles of bone.

—— i OE . -

39

These finer particles would all sift to the bottom
of the hold, and thence through the ceiling into the
pumps, and thence overboard.

Under ordinary conditions, perhaps, the quantity
of bone pumped overboard might seem large; but in
view of the heavy leakage, the practically constant

have been pumped out of this vessel in two months,
while she was leaking at the rate of about twelve feet
1 of water a day, the amount of bone pumped overboard

last explanation of the shortage, as there is with the
others ; but, on the contrary, the evidence and the facts
clearly point to the last explanation as the true man-
ner in which the shortage occurred.

The foregoing explanations of the shortage are
the only ones possible.

den of proving the incorrectness of the bill of lading
weight by “thoroughly Satisfying the Court that she
actually has delivered all the cargo she has received
aud that the bill of lading weight is erroneous” when

We submit that the evidence most clearly estab-
lishes the vessel's liability and that the District Court
erred in failing to award to libellant its fall claim.

It remains to note a suggestion found in the opin-
ion of the District Court, and which, if the ineorreect-

Reeser

EUR I eon ce apr,

Furthermore, the error of the trial Court's theory
is most clearly demonstrated mathematically by the
accompanying table on the opposite page.

PL PIDIS—seqr want yey, MOBY J ds40) ayy WIGS ©® pores os

Pes sep bow s ery aul iw ouyey 4 e@y> > suey yr) aa) ” wenger ye) (emi w ahaa hd Ueda neg pres ® You] .
0 san 44940204 4800 S807] jo seony ¢
me tee 7 ; {4940084 Joy
eri tty I of oof “4 OPt7 4°94 Gos > ¥qy OVOP! 49 WML, S80)
terwc GOOF 494 Goze & “4 OB oF) As24Hap poys a0) Saeed
eT? 76 "4! Gor 4°94 Ores eq TO1 AY O48 Asnten soy some ey
(0a10904 [Ta WPUPGIT ‘Pemoye Asarores mi}
of She 78 . ; METPGr] OF SFO] FEMIOYy “¢
~ es ise or 90000000006ene00 sudiaas pay
ve esz 9 "4 OFT 424 GOs & vqy ME WET WO WMALy Seer) '
6 FOr ef '
ro oN ; nome “4 GOO? 494 OF IZ ~ %qy POL ere ;
YF 179 ars " GOor 494 gO ”7s w ¥qy eli rely '
9419993 PIP Pasaaqep AITEQI28 OBse> 4) UO WwETPQr] 7 :
9 VOR ATS POOPSS SPOS Se er ceeeesesoececeos ‘ ° . Sees — Sihiaces wy i
OL 781 Z os ‘Sol Op77 424 Goose MH owes uo my ™Ma44 S827)
~ oro oS “4! Ohor 4 GOLzTs © Sq) CopOnrs

Pees ee PROG VeRMORET ‘Peseeney wong poy Sue? Jo ING BH) 69 20) po? soueg ow He jp 1
‘S3OVWVG F1aN0G aNV @VTHIAO OL SY MOTRE L4NOD 40 ANOSHL aHL OL 43MSNV

A. Tue Actiow or THe Cmevrr Cover or Arrrais Is
IecoNsteresy Wrrn rug Revues of Tus Cover
1s leviwe v. Tye Hesper”’ axp Rew v. Tue
Americas Exrnrsx Co. asp Newiprex THe Rruz
Tuar ow ax Arrean rs Apiary tie Come Ie

Under Che decisions of this Court in Irvine ¢.““ Th,
Hesper,”’ 2s U.S. 256, aul the many eases following
that decision, Particularly the recent emphatic ap
Foetin, 7, ts doctrine by his Homor, the present Che
Justice, in Reid ¢. American Express Company, 241
UF ok S44, am appeal in Admiralty vacstee the ce
the ns Distriet Comrt; and brings the whole case tenn”
the Cireuit Court of Appeals for » trial de nore

organ,” 115 “= (9,
'

been if both parties had appealed, or if the appeal
had been tales only by the daimants.”’ (Italies

This holding was reaffirmed in Reid r, The Ameri.
can Express Co. (supra), where his Honor, the present
Chief Justice, sand:

It is not denied that in the Second Cireuit
the right to a de novo trial was considered as an
ted by Munson S. 8. Line \. Miramar 8. 8. Co.

contention is plainly without merit aud that the
right to a de neve trial in the Court below authori-
tatively resulted from the ruling in Irvine v. ‘The
Nesper,’ 122 0. = Th, a j ich j

the authorities on the subject contained in the
opinion in the Miramar Case. Entertaining this
view, we do net stop to consider the various argu.

44

below or that this case for reasons which are
Wholly unsubstantia] may be distinguished and
made an exception to the general rule, because to
do so would serve no useful purpose and would be
at least impliedly to admit that there was room to
discuss a question concerning which there was no
room for discussion whatever.”?

What do these cases mean? Obviously and neces-
sarily they mean what they say, that in an admiralty
appeal the Cireuit Court of Appeals is not sitting as a
court of review, but as a trial court, hearing and
determining the case upon the pleadings and proofs
submitted in the District Court and any additional
proofs that may be properly introduced in the Cireuit
Court of Appeals. x

Is it conceivable that any trial court has the legal
discretion, at the defendant's request and over the pro-
test and objection of the plaintiff, to refuse to hear and
determine the claim made by the plaintiff against the
defendant where the parties and subject matter are
properly before the court and within its jurisdiction?

Manifestly it cannot do so; and yet, such is the
necessary result of the ruling of the Cireuit Court of
Appeals in this case, inasmuch as under the decisions
in Irvine v. “The Hesper”’ and Reid v. The A merican
Express Co., the Cireuit Court of Appeals must be re-
garded in this ease as a trial court.

This point here raised is a novel one, as was recog-
nized in the opinion of Judge Buffington in this case
When he says (Record, p. 204) :

; ‘We find no reported case involving the pre-
; cise question here raised,’

3

; The decision of the Cireuit Court of Appeals in
this case has a most far-reaching effect. Its seope is
wide and its applieation broad. If it is to stand, an

Pi eae aS Die Le YR ey 8 en ee IAI IS IR gD OME

— ~

45

appellee in admiralty, a part of whose claim was denied
in the District Court, ean no longer rely upon the
decisions of this Court in Irvine v.** The Hesper”’ and
Reid v. The American Express Company, to secure him
his right to be heard thereon in the Cireuit Court of
Appeals. To protect himself he will be under the nee
cessity of assuming the burden and expense of taking
a cross appeal, thereby eneumbering the reeord and
adding most materially to the expense, annoyance and
inconvenience of litigation, increasing its complexities,
and in most eases undoubtedly, causing additional de-
lay—already one of the greatest objections and most
serious defects in the administration of justice,

It is suggested in the opinion of Judge Buffington
in this case that to refuse the motion and hold the ap-
pellant not entitled to withdraw his appeal will work
a great hardship to ‘he appellant by limiting his con-
trol of his litigation. But this suggestion is a mistaken
one,

In the words of Mr. Justice Blatehford in Irvine v.
“The Hesper,’”’
‘When the libellants appealed they did so in

View of the rule, and took the risk of the result of
a trial of the ease de novo,”

The appellant, therefore, js confronted by no
hardship—he acts with his eves open.

The result of refusing to permit the appellant in
such case to withdraw his appeal over the appellee’s
objection would, on the other hand, be most wholesome.

It would go far to eurb and put an end to the tak-
ing of hasty and ill-advised appeals, would seeure to
the appellee his right to be heard de novo without the
necessity of complicating the admiralty procedure by
taking a cross appeal, and would prevent the most pat-

46

ent injustice to an appellee who, in proper reliance
upon the decisions of this Court in Irvine v. “The
Hesper’’ and Reid v. The American Express Company,
has felt secure in his right to be heard, would other-
wise find that this right has been swept away from him
at a time when his own right to appeal had expired and
he was no longer able to avail himself thereof.

While there seem to be no Federal Court decisions
on the precise point here raised, there have been one
or two State Court decisions thereon and these plainly
and clearly support the rule for which we here contend.

In Peterson v. Frey, 109 Mich. 689, a case where an
appeal was taken under a statute which provided that
the appellate court should “‘become possessed of the
case, the same as if it had been originally commenced
in said Appellate Court,” it was held that an appellant
could not dismiss his appeal without the consent of the
appellee.

In Brigham v. Waterhouse, 32 Texas 468, a case
where under the statute an appeal effected a trial de
novo in the appellate court, it was held that the appel-
lant could not withdraw his appeal without the consent
of the appellee.

The rule announced in these eases is, we submit,
correct and consistent with good practice and the deci-
sions of this Court.
What diseretion an appellate court has to permit
the withdrawal of an appeal is necessarily limited by
legal precedents and rules, and certainly should not
and cannot be exercised to deprive an appellee of a
valuable and substantial right.

In the present ease, and in all cases where by an
appeal the cause is brought before the appellate court

TE gE BOIL TOTS ML OC TL ME HSMN AIS

47

for a trial de novo, an appellee, a part of whose claim
has been denied in the District Court, hias a right to
have the appellate court hear and determine his claim
de novo, as a court of first instance,

This right is a valuable and substantial one, of
which the appellee should not be deprived without his
consent, and we submit that it is nO more within the
legal discretion of the appellate court in such a ease to
deprive the appellee of this right, than it is within the
diseretion of any other trial court at the defendant's
request and over the plaintiff's objection to refuse to
hear and determine on its merits a cause in which the
parties and the subject-matter are properly within its
jurisdiction and before it for determination.

IV. CONCLUSION.
In conclusion we submit:

First—That the action of the Cireuit Court of
Appeals in permitting the claimants in this case to
Withdraw their appeal was improper, inconsistent with
the decisions of this Court, and, if allowed to stand
uncorrected, will complicate the admiralty practice,
go far to nullify important decisions of this Court and
will work the greatest injustice to litigants who act in
reliance upon the decisions of this Court for the pro-
tection of their rights and the conduct of their litiga-
tion,

Second.—That the Cireuit Court of Appeals in
this case should have heard and determined on its
merits the whole case brought up by the appeal from
the District Court.

48

Third.—That the action of the District Court in
refusing to award the petitioner the full damages
claimed by it was erroneous and should be reversed.

Fourth—That the petitioner before this Court
should be awarded the full amount of its claim with
damages equivalent to interest thereon from January
lo, 1916, and costs.

Respectfully submitted.

CONLEN, BRINTON & ACKER,
HARRINGTON, BIGHAM & ENGLAR,
Proctors for Petitioner.

Witutam J. ¢ ‘ONLEN,
Advocate,

wa.

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386004_0423%3A4. Public record. Not legal advice.
