# Appendix — AG Industrial Manufacturing Inc. v. Waterkeepers Northern California

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386003_1412%3A4

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 2005
- **Citation:** 543 U.S. 1050

## Text

la

APPENDIX A — MEMORANDUM AND ORDER OF
THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE
EASTERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
DATED AND FILED MARCH 13, 2003

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

NO. CIV. S00 -1967 MCE PAN

WATERKEEPERS NORTHERN CALIFORNIA,
a non- profit corporation, doing business as DELTAKEEPER,
and BILL JENNINGS, an individual;

Plaintiffs,
v.

AG INDUSTRIAL MANUFACTURING, INC.,
a corporation; and CLAUDE E. BROWN, an individual;

Defendants.
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

In this action for violation of the Federal Water Pollution
Control Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1251 et seq. (hereinafter referred
to as the “Clear Water Act”), Plaintiffs alleged that
Defendants AG Industrial Manufacturing, Inc. and its
president, Claude E. Brown (collectively “AIM”) have
repeatedly discharged industrial pollution into the
Mokelumne River and the San Joaquin River Delta since at
least 1992. On December 3, 2002, this Court granted
summary judgment in favor of AIM on grounds that Plaintiffs

COT Si naa ef NNO NE ARR A OCT iN EOC IC Het eh ‘ ists

2a

Appendix A

failed to file adequate notice of their intent to sue AIM as
required by the Clean Water Act at 33 U.S.C. § 1365(b)(1)(A)
and 40 C.F.R. § 135.3(a). The Court determined that because
of the inadequacy of Plaintiff’s pre-suit notice, it was without
jurisdiction to hear the case.

AIM now seeks to recover attorney’s fees in the amount
of $126,293.00 as well as costs incurred for reasonable expert
witness fees in the total sum of $15,034.00.' In addition, AIM
previously filed a Bill of Costs in the amount of $13,685.56
seeking recovery for additional expenses under Local Rule
54-292 and 28 U.S.C. § 1920. The Court rules on both these
matters below.

ANALYSIS

A. AIM?’s Motion for Attorney’s Fees and Expert Witness
Costs ;

The Clean Water Act provides that the court can award
costs of litigation, including reasonable attorney and expert
witness fees, to any prevailing or substantially prevailing
party whenever it determines that such an award is
appropriate. 33 U.S.C. § 1365(d).

1. As requested by AIM, judicial notice it taken of all pleadings
and files in the above-referenced action. The Court also takes judicial
notice of the Northern District’s Order Denying Motion to Dismiss
in San Francisco BayKeeper v. Tosco Corp. No. C00-0256, pursuant
to Federal Rule of Evidence 201(b). The Court declines to rule on
AIM’s evidentiary objections to the Declaration of Shana Lazerow
because the matters at issue therein were not necessary to the Court’s
decision on this motion.

nt Dylan tad tee RE ORAL EE I A RCL ETE TE.

EPL BALMS ADO AENEID

3a

Appendix A

Although it is beyond dispute that AIM prevailed in this
case by obtaining summary judgment, that fact alone is not
determinative in awarding fees to AIM as a successful Clean
Water Act defendant. Instead, such an award to a prevailing
defendant is appropriate only where the plaintiff’s action was
“frivolous, unreasonable, or without foundation.” Razore v.
Tulalip Tribes, 66 F.3d 236, 240 (9 Cir. 1995) (holding that
the frivolousness standard set forth by the Supreme Court in
Christiansburg Garment Co. v. Equal Employment
Opportunity Commission, 434 U.S. 412, 421-22 (1978), as
the benchmark for awarding fees in a Title VII case, also
governs fee requests by defendants under the Clean Water
Act); Morris-Smith v. Moulton Niguel Water District, 44
F.Supp.2d 1084,1086 (C.D. Cal. 1999), aff'd, 234 F.3d 1277
(9" Cir. 2000) (also applying so-called Christiansburg
standard in assessing fee award to prevailing defendant in
Clean Water Act case).

Under the Christiansburg standard, the terms
“frivolous,” “unreasonable” and “without foundation” are
essentially interchangeable. Thomas v. Bible, 983 F.2d 152,
154, n. 2 (9" Cir. 1993). A case is “frivolous” when it is
“groundless . . . with little prospect of success.” United States
v. Manchester Farming Partnership, 315 F.3d 1176, 1183
(9" Cir. 2003) . “The plaintiff’s action must be meritless in
the sense that it is groundless or without foundation.” Hughes
v. Rowe, 449 U.S. 5, 14 (1980); Christiansburg, 434 US. at
421 (defining “meritless” as meaning “groundless or without
foundation, rather than simply that the plaintiff has ultimately
lost his case.”’)

4a
Appendix A

The fact that this Court found Plaintiffs’ pre-suit notice
to be inadequate does not mean that the underlying suit was
itself frivolous. Indeed, because this Court ruled only on the
adequacy of such notice and did not reach the merits of
Plaintiffs’ claims, AIM cannot realistically contend that the
Court found the action “groundless” as opposed to
procedurally defective. Given the posture at which the case
was decided, the Court declines to make any determination
as to the substantive merits of Plaintiffs’ claims, let alone a
finding that Plaintiffs’ entire case was groundless so as to
justify an award of attorney’s fees and expert witness costs
against Plaintiffs under 33 U.S.C. § 1365(d). Therefore AIM’s
request for such fees is denied.

B. AIM’s Bill of Costs.

In addition to claiming entitlement to attorney’s fees and
expert witness costs, AIM has also submitted a Bill of Costs
totaling $13,685.56 for other allegedly recoverable items
under Local Rule 54-292 and 28 U.S.C. § 1920. Certain of
the items claimed, however, are not properly taxed. AIM
argues entitlement to $3,466.00 for witness fees incurred in
producing its expert, Steven Bond, for deposition. Expert
witness fees, however, may be taxed only where the expert
is appointed by the court; such fees are otherwise limited to
$40 per diem as set forth in 28 U.S.C. § 1821. Crawford
Fitting Co. v. J. T. Gibbons, Inc., 482 U.S. 437, 442 (1987).
Because no such appointment was made here, AIM’s recovery
for Mr. Bond’s expenses is limited to the per diem and
mileage fees enumerated in § 1821. AIM has not disputed
Plaintiffs’ estimate of those fees at $266.

(YEAR, MONTH,

M - Missing data,

START YEAR
UNITS

a1
OM OMOMCOMOKOORUA | NOOMOMOOMOKO LOOM HOOMOLOMOOMORONFOMOACOMOMAHOROROMOOMOMOMA TMOMCORHMH GAO LORCOMOROORA

OXOOOCOOO FO0OHI00000001GOFOOHO000000NFONT0090001 00000001 0 FOMOOOHOOOD FOOMOSOSOCIONIONAVOOCOOOMOL AR
a a ;

POCO FO009OMOHO00000008 00% 000000000007 0M0000000MOMOOD09OOF OM OMGOODOOOOHONHOOMIOOVO WHO RZOOQOOCOQIOONM
; . \o be

-

34

POCCHOOOHOT9040000000%000000000 00h 000 4000000000HN0000059 FHHDOOOODDO90999HONIOOHOMADOOOOOIOOMSO00R
th

9009000000000007000000000000000000000N 00M 990 0000Ml: HMO OBDOODOHOHOSODOOOONIOONOMOOIOOMIOIGOOOQOOHIOONG
o

ina chaciatalatalicis ahi aie eae 5 Ninian Kiosk UE its SOD NAN VhiN. gat aren esi 8 2 eet
nye

coccp coop cco eg o~socc D0 wor000000g 0m sp ooC HOOD OwODOOO CED SHOMOSCODOEOEoOHMOHAOOODOOMABOSOSSOODO INO
wn w

sapieneaetahiaten, sein rabies meee” bbe Baebes pMikios (eMac Stile Niee ee ee ee ee ee ee eS ee, > ee ee ee” ee ee ee

°o cvoecoessyiiocccovencnsobenesoconegegevocnesscesasesSenengaMseesse Oe Reneor sen rent eT ee

Nn >] 7

slats pitinialabainaat eaten Wiaiatalatial i Miia iii OTIS. INI RCE SI Sop am

%O000000000NF900000000N0000 200000 ONT080000000000000 0080 0000HSSOOSSOOOF SNe rOwWOODOL HHRQOHQQQQ9ORQ90%
rr

mw al

eqocoussdecadonenodsnoo saaaaia tas hie eb ntataaaaalales inlet ili i sie rintnte). Site pi ongihiepuiao fea kb oh.

a t~mm
a

200000000000 90000000000000000 000000 F ANNODOO90090N 0000000000000 FOOSCONHON SHIiMeDOOhOOOOOHQMHOOGIONO TE
. ” moa . . ‘

COHCOCCCOD OMTOHOHHED0000000000000008MONOOOOSO990Oh 1 DOGDOSOOOrI NOOO BOODOONHBOMNIDSOIVOHIOMMNHIDOQOQOONG
w

MOSQSOSOSKNS HO ONGSSSSASSOSSSSSSSOSNS- STO FosSese Sesser seres = Coco CCCCOOCOOCOCONnNOHHOOOCCOOCOCCCOCOCOCCCOCOCCoCOCOSCO

29352172

5
1
z
1996 4PR 6

1392 9PR
199210PR
239510PR
2000 2PR
2000 3PR

SOSH OS FONG HHO SSOSSSSSANSeSOOSSOSSSINSHGSOSOOSOS: It DODOOCOSCHOWDOOOOOONOOOHOOOOSOOOSSCOHF NMOOCOOOOHOMNG .
nm

HohoosoSOCONrins SOCOSOOOSONOSL COSOSHNESOASOOMODSOSSHOONSHSOSONOSr|MSSISSSAISOShOOHIII9eROee acesinatnalcet aficde tastes’ Waco :

OF N000000001719000000000000000000004 21/00 BNBOTGOrIMNDOWOOOSOOONIOOOOO00OG OF DOSOCOSOTOSHROGQODOO0OHOROO.
: ta) rs mm. 3

SOoosossenHiwooesesoeseonosooooostosioeacosaeser loonoceccco~nooocooconnogg ooo ooo oo woHooqooosoCoNCRD,

99000000 9000080000000800N000000lNN 00100090001 00000000000H 20020 0HOOHHr Mri amoDOONOHADOOIIOOHIOOrIr:

'

'

‘

‘

'

‘

i]

'

'

i

‘

‘

io

'

'

!

‘

‘

'

'

'

'

i]

‘

‘

'

'

'

.)

'

'

!

'

'

,

‘

'

!

‘

'

'

'

.]

'‘

’

i]

'

'

'

'

‘

'

‘

i]

lenohoooooosoqoncosooooshoosooescousotan : lalla wibialebianete Na rnliciitce waite hiubihacbinstenncuiR gn ~ ao ord a * ee .
CEEEEEE ET ENCCOCO EC EEC ECS Sccce sce ececON EEE EE EEEOSS
: Cc
oe <u om. Wea S idk. SS mane acetal
ELEEECE ECR OCCSCOS EES ESS ECSoeHooESSEER EEE EERE EDSS
= is ‘S fav A2 wi th. iti: Caz 2 (J: whic tae yt é ‘f Wie he?
. om ron -- C8 g Ay FR 240° HIAVW Sus oo ots oP rem
€ SSOCCOEFERFESCCE EV EF EEEEEC OSS
oT ey? £2. ssewrrwca¢ue 6 s *:. “ees Tet
STOU {@ eal; SDN E Pin Pe fos
$ Beas eee eee ee sees
8 £33232 5323353533225 2335353
eset ee as aPbr le eagle eee ee

m
0 012 063

0

0 0. oO 035

10 0.16 ,.1.02' 008:

0

So

EO oOo

EEEC ES
°o

“
EE&EEeeR

aa

0 024 026 008

004

ecaogoocso

004

@zeceo

-

0 031

eccoogoa

ECECCS

eeeeco
Seeeece

zsceoce
°

0 063 016 0.04

0 213 012

ececeso

Beeecesc

eg2eco

ecoegeco

095 004 0.12
0

SO ECE

Qo O51

-9999

0 Q75 0.43
m

Eeeeco

of-o0ooC ESC

esceeceo

0 044 004 004

€ceeece

COOEECE

1.02

Seeececco

Qo 047

SEES EEOC

0

cEEooEesc

Seeeeoo

EeEEECCS

0 O16 O39 008

EEEOCOOCO

tt)

cEeEEECES

coEeEec EO

Page 1 of 2

ee

7. eters

29a

Appendix B

oe ea ee, 8
» ee

zle ° ‘eee i@e € -@ €e€ ‘@*- €é'iG -E7tee oe
eC TE MENS SOGGE. sitar ee €O) 95 i SP iv
Wu Si° S€°GEFECEEEEE EFFEEEEEEEE LC ELEEEEE
<x % *, oo ow a Boo tense ne Societies
s RO ESS EEECSEEE GEEECEEEEERE ELEEEEEE
. oe 2°. cde 09°53 ‘SF ple Ee ot ee ? al .
5 - at me ey Se oe ye + Ne ° ha) - 8 ses em He tee
ved gjcoeecetee Satake gta tl bale adele dado o Se
oe aoe he pen | ae 2 are eedivatibe Spite Se Sm - dd oa Ble Or
ol ww meee he wwe se . «¢ oa = =i See eed s
iv » ic iad: galled salar caslnd dcchabe aera
a , re Beer ang oa ed wap
= myc ee niesegeadeenuceiscacteseneas,
ico” ee, St By vi“. sRa eo *% tg ec + eS el ee
a fae Ses <9 Mee on ee pene
Se ECCCERREEEEEEEEEECEEEEEEEEREECEEE
ad a J tiie = ;
3 a Nie -"y .
z ajg ECCCER REECE EEECEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERE
oO Tt A Sain Gee o AR. de a eee, wee
= RS ECERESEC EEE CEFELEEEEFESEEEEEEEEE
ra) io. ‘ s hs Piel, : — =
© ae aay “a ‘i gl cen eae LES eli
oe, giyCCOEESEECECE ERE EECEEEEEEEEEEEEECE
Qa - . ~ - 2 w Seo ate _/~
ra RISC ECC CCFC CEC EEE EELFEEEELEEEEEEEEEEE
<x co ce ee ‘, ’ f % :
9 RIZSSCESCECECLCLEERLEEFCEREELEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
s PIOCETECECLEEFCECEEFEEEEFEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Oo SJOSCSCEFECECECLCESCEEFELFEFEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
. _- - -
Ww a ite es oe coy rs . ae
=. ROO ETECCESEEEREEFEEELEEEEFEEEEREEEEEEE
oc og es eae é i eet ge g.
8g SOCECECEECEEEEEEEELEELEFEEEEEEEEEEEFEE
.2 =
Pe PPC ECCEFCEECERFEEEEEEFEEELEEEEEEEEFEEEEE
-|fo . -_° - - ° P. °
~ yt 1 ane - “ oe .
z$ TIOSCEEESCERCECCEESCEEELEEESCEERFEEEFEEEEEEEE
.—<
Pao) MIC ESCCECESELCLERCELEELCEFEFEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
~ = R
”
=s NIZSSCECESERCCEEEEEEESEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Oo.. . -*
98 TICSCEEESCERCECCECE EEF EL ERFEEEERLEEEEEEEEEEEE
=
Co ’ ake
<$ SIOSCEECSCEFELC EEC EEELEFCELEEEEEECEEEEEEEEEEE
zs ei
M— PCCCEEFEFEFCECLEFELFEFEFELFEECEEEEEEEEEEEE
so .=§
tio
a < POSSE SECECLE EEC ERELEEELESESEELEEEEEEEEEEE
Oz o “ ‘
eo MIONECCELEEEEEFFEEEEEFEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Ws ag
DO cologececcce cee EEEECEZELEESESSEEEEEEEE
oa *
Ts)
ow WISEEEESCEELEEECELCEEEFEFEEEEFEEEEEEEEEEEE
” %
a
Oa “ICEL ECTEECECFCECEFELFEFEELCEEEEEEFEEEEEEEEE
Le So ‘
ape ,
<< MOS ESCERCECEEEEEEEEEEFEECELEFEEFEEEEEEEE
<0 , |
—f WIZCECEREEEEECEEEEFEEESEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
<
e & “IRCCS EFEFECFEEEEEEEEEFECECEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
~O fe
al
i eeees rE
meee $4332353 38%

Re
it.

aes tes
Seee Sa.

TSN teens 8G saath BBLS are

we tt ole enn *

Sine Sey ‘

Table A2

‘* Js. quae,

ewan

Page 2 of 2

\(coutiaaea) * Aap

on eee ee “egte ett me tderteniget mpi ee | detracts ne Rad 7

le* vies ate

“a . . en,
iA NOD a geere Ze

ome cet

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386003_1412%3A4. Public record. Not legal advice.
