# Transcript of Record — Southern R. Co. v. Prescott

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386003_0124%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1916
- **Citation:** 240 U.S. 632

## Text

RRR

So Ut CFT a Me ai,

(24,570)

UPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,
OCTOBER TERM, 1915.

No. 358.

UTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY, PLAINTIFF IN ERROR,
v8. -
W. E. PRESCOTT.

Y ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF SOUTH

CAROLINA,
INDEX,

Original. Print

RE ORSMINE Ki Siiersesnenve sate Ridge case earl ae oe a 1
script of record from the circuit court of Edgefield county. 1 1
BPE Seis eximisee sine sennv ah nen See iuae esr teh tae oe 1 1
SNe FOE CON i Sos ido cece hae ea 2 I
BERN gee re ri xWAlevaet aeds bin Fase, By SoT ee eee mee 10 7
pemanony of EW. Semele, oo bocce icc, 12 7
PO Ws DON ao sens Chie e eee cen fe 16 1]

woop hibth hae cg EEE PRCT Pe or OnE UN Es 22 16

sing lebaincarac prin CER TEE PELTH ae 26 19

tte Pidosocon gen Eanes ely 39 29

he Me SARE Casa ee ne EN 41 31

ts ig Seredptanad ETT eR hee 52 40

rsa yah de ce earpn Ee EE i AP 54 41

Wi Rn eben ea svakastosCertel Ae 63 49

OE OO anions ys weudivier ig ek 68 53

SA NEG Sus ew's ress pli caet ee 69 54

een PM ov Say ha bs Soe ee ee i fe 55

Fee ee AM eis n'a tere ee ee 73 57

Bs ik SONNE Foe SF sass ee 75 59

Fees ROEM CN ye as peas cae ns 79 62

& DETWEILER (1Nc.), PRINTERS, WASHINGTON, D. C., Fesruary 1, 1916,

sh ae

Rea tsb ear

‘i INDEX.
Original. Print

Exhibit 1—Bill of lading, original invoice and payee’s

FOCUIPLE, CIC. ccs s es iie er ter c tice remesaceesecs 82 64

2—Order of Interstate Commerce Commission and
bil! of lading: blank, eCtC.....

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 11

Q. You do not know what part caught first; which part fell in
first ?

A. The depot had all fallen in; the front of the office was standing
when I got there.

Q. The front of the office on Main street?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Is the depot in a respectable part of town?

A. Yes, sir.
16 Q. It was in a public, respectable part of the town?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. It was on the main street of the town, was it not?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Did you or not ever see those barrels of water sitting on the
platform?

A. Yes, sir; IT have seen water there.

Q. And the barrels full of water?

A. I think so.

Q. Do you know Mr. Townsend?

A. Yes, sir.
. Did you ever seen him smoke a cigarette?
. T don’t think so.
. Did you ever see Miss Richardson, the young lady who works
there, smoke?

A. No, sir.

Q. Did you ever see T. L. Timmerman smoke a cigarette?

A. T do not recall.

Q. You never saw anyone smoke a cigarette in that office?

A. No, sir; T never noticed that.

(By Mr. Thurmond:)

Q. There is no reason why sliding doors could not be constructed
and locked from the outside?

A. I think they could he locked from the outside.

Q. As well as from the inside?

A. Yes, sir.

QOD

Jesse W. Dorn (white), sworn:

Direct examination.
By Mr. Thurmond:

Q. Have you heen ahoxt the depot down here a good deal?

A. Yes, sir: a right smart.

Q. You had occesion to haul freight out of the depot for the mer-
chants?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. I wish you would state to the jury whether there was any paper
much in the depot?

A. They kept some hetween the depot and the office: they kept the
paper where they kept old papers?

Many?

Sac) Sa fren Raa

eee

RRL

a

PENTIMA RNS SII

12 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. BE. PRESCOTT.

A. A right smart.
Q. Between the depot and office?
A. Yes, sir.
17 Q. What sort of paper?
A. I thought they were old bills of lading and things they
used. .
Q. Many of them kept in there?
A. A right smart.
Q. Between the two rooms?
A. Yes, sir
Q. What other sort of papers were there?
A. T could not say.
Q. You just saw a lot of papers there?
A. The papers thev kept there
Q. Did you notice any lime on the outside of the depot or around

there at any time?
. T have seen lime there occasionally just in there and on the out-

Did you ever see any rats in there?

A. T have seen a good many rats there.

Q. Large rats?

A. Right smart size.

Q. Did you ever see any matches in the depot?
A. Yes, sir: T have seen matches there.

Q. What is the result if rats and matches get together in inflam-
mable naper?

A. T have alwavs heard that rats loved matches,

Q. Will they set fire to anything?

A. T supnose some of them would strike.

Q. Did vou notice in one of the corners of the depot if there was
a lot of stuff niled?

A. No. sir: T do not remember anvthing about that: of course in
the corners there was stuff. but T sunposed it was freight, or some-
thing they had had over a good while.

. What is the effect if lime is taken into a house if it gets wet?
. Tf it is not slacked lime. T do not know.
. Do vou know whether it will produce fire or not?
. T have never tried it mvself,
Do vou know the effect of water on lime?
No, sir.
Was there any way to extinguish a fire in the depot with water?
. Not that T know of.
Did vou ever see a hose there?
. No, sir.
. No hose to use in turning water on?

A. No, sir.
18 Q. Did vou have a nicht watchman there?

A. Not that T know of.

Q. Tow were those doors constructed: could you get into the
mee from the outside except going through the office?
. I think not.

O>PO>rO>rO>ro>o

oe

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 1

Q. Did yon have to go through the office?

A. I always thought you had to go through the office; they were
sliding doors and fastened on the inside.

Q. Did you ever notice much hay around the depot?

A. Yes, sir; I have seen hay there.

Q. Flour, and a lot of other freight inside of the depot?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Did you go to the fire that morning?

A. Yes, sir; but T was late in getting there; T discovered the fire,
and I hitched up my horse before I went, and it was all burned when
I got there.

Cross-examination.
By Mr. Evans:
. That depot was located in a quite respectable part of the town?
. Yes, sir.
On Main street?
. Yes, sir.
In a public place?
Yes, sir.
What was the condition of that depot on the 3d of July?
I think it was good.
Good?
Yes, sir.
What was that depot made for?
Made to keep goods in.
To keep freight in?
Yes, sir.
And you have seen all sorts of freight in cars or unloaded?
Yes, sir.
. And you have hauled freight out of that depot every day?
Yes, sir.
. And there was freight there all the time?
. Yes, sir.
. And there were barrels of water sitting on the platform?
A. Yes, sir.
19 Q. And buckets hanging over them?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. The papers that you speak of—did you ever go into Mr. Thur-
mond’s office?
A. Yes, sir: and yours, too (laughter).
Q. And you have seen the pigeon holes where they keep their
papers?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And that is what the railroad had?
A. In a ease.
Q. A case where they kept their blanks and supplies and writing
paper?
A. And old papers.
Q. They filed their papers there in those pigeon holes?

PPOPOPOPOHOPOPOPOPO>O

5
Sh eoRY eon

NT AAG ETL CERN Hip TY RET Do RO TIRE LEE Ray Hy CAE

ite as

Spe ER Pit: a RIL IS I ANE AL NEERING Abs AEN NRE A OAT OR POTN HA 0 OTN FP AP CED BIE AINE ain te

14 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS, W. 8. PRESCOTT.

A. Yes, sir.

Q. It was not loose paper throwing around on the floor?

A. I don’t know that I saw any.

Q. You have seen several depots?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. How did this one compare with others except the brick ones?
A. I thought this was very good.

Q. Was not this a good depot?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. “reshly painted?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Did you ever see any warehouse doors open in any other way
except the way that these opened?

A. Always opened and slid.

Q. Was that not a safe way to keep people from getting in there?

A. I suppose so.

Q. You mean to say that the warehouse and the depot that it was
connected with the depot, and the agent in opening up could open
the door to his office, and go in there that way?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And he would open the door between his office and the depot,
and then unlock and shove back these doors?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. How wide was the space to those doors?

A. I suppose eight or ten feet.

Q. How many doors were there in the depot?

A. Three, I think.
20 Q. One on the side next to Adams’ warehouse, one on the
end, and one on the other side?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And one leading into the office?

A. Yes, sir,

Q. Don’t you think that was the best way to secure those doors?

A. T don’t know; T guess it was as good as any.

Q. Don’t you know it was a safer way than to put a staple on the
facing and a hasp on that: and don’t vou know that by fastening
them on the inside it is safer?

A. Yes, sir; that would be safer.

Q. Did you ever see Mr. Townsend smoke a cigarette?

A. No, sir.

Q. Or T. L. Timmerman?

A. No, sir.

Q. “i Miss Richardson?

A. I don’t think she smokes.
There were only three people working in that depot; they were
the only ones there on the 3d day of July?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Mr. Townsend, Mr. Timmerman, and this young lady, and
you never saw a single one of them smoke a cigarette?

A. Not that I know of.

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT, 15

(By Mr. Thurmond: )

Q. State to that jury whether or not a lot of the stuff in that depot
could have been removed more quickly if there was a lock that could
have been unlocked from the outside?

A. I think it could if you could have gotten in from the outside.

Q. And would not the safety of the depot have been very much
promoted?

A. In a case of fire.

Q. Could you not have a lock to sliding doors without having a
hasp on the outside; could you not have it made in the door?

A. Yes, sir; you could have it locked.

Q. State to the jury whether or not you think a hose with some
water to get at from the outside would promote the safety of the
depot?

A. Yes, sir; I think it would have been.

Mr. Evans: I think my friend has gone far enough; that is not
negligence; a sprinkler system is not a hose system.
21 Mr. Thurmond: This covers it.
The Court: I think that covers it.

(By Mr. Thurmond:)

Q. Don’t you think a hose would have promoted the safety of the
depot?

A. I think it would have been better.

Q. Is there not a little sprinkler that puts out a fire that you can
use on fire with some kind of acid?

A. Yes, sir; I have seen them.

Q. Have you not seen them that you could put out fires well?

A. I could not say that.

Q. They are convenient?

A. Yes, sir.

(By Mr. Evans:)

Q. Is that any more convenient than a barrel or water with a
bucket?

A. I don’t know.

Q. Which had you rather have to fight a fire with?

A. As for my part, I had rather have a bucket to use; as T would
not know how to use the other.

Q. Has this town any water system?

A. I think not, except at the mill.

Q. There is no hydrant from the public square to the depot?
A. No, sir.

Q. Nor near the depot?

A. No, sir.

Q. There was no water there if they had had a hose there?
A. No, sir.

Q. There is no water there?

A. No, sir.

See ee ee te ee eS ee oe s — mute PAE OE BE AC aE tN PN IAEA —

16 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

(By Mr. Thurmond:)

Q. Will you state if any one could go in there with a fire on the
inside?

A. 1 was not there, and I do not know whether the office caught
first; I do not think so if the oflice caught first.

Q. There was no way to get in if the oflice caught first, unless you
broke down the doors?

A. No, sir.

Q. And the buckets of water on the outside would not do any
good?

A. Not if the fire was on the inside.

Q. This fire was on the inside?

A. I guess it was.

Q. What good would water in barrels on the outside do if

22 the fire was on the inside?

A. 1 don’t think it would do much.

(By Mr. Evans:)

Q. You don’t stop to unlock doors when you go to fight fire?

A. No, sir.

Q. You knock them down?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And then the barrels and buckets of water would have come in?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. If you had those barrels of water on the inside they would be
worthless; they would have been no good at all?

A. No, sir.

(By Mr. Thurmond:)

Q. If you had a hose, and could open the door, you could stand
there and shoot water in there when you could not go in there for the
smoke at all?

A. Yes, sir.

M. W. Pavcerr (white), sworn:
Direct examination.
By Mr, Thurmond:

Q. Have you even been around that depot much before it was
burned?

A. I would go there sometimes.

Q. Did you ever notice any trash in there?

A. Yes, sir; there was a little trash in one corner; [| don’t know
what it was, but there was something piled up in a corner.

Q. You noticed trash in one corner?

A. Trash and paper, but I could not tell you whether it was freight
or trash.

Q. A lot of stuff piled up there?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And paper in it?

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 17

A. As good as I could tell you there was paper; I could not tell
you positively that it was paper.

Q. Did you ever see any lime around there?

A. On the platform.

Q. You have seen plenty of lime there?

A. I don’t know whether there was plenty.
23 Q. Did you ever see any rats there?
A. Yes, sir; | have seen some rats there.

Q. Do you know whether they had a night watehman there?

A. I don’t know about that; | have not seen one,

Q. Did you ever see a water sprinkler system down there?

A. No, sir.

Q. Did you ever see.a hose to shoot water on anything?

A. No, sir.

Q. State to that jurygvhether there was any means at all of shoot-
ing water on that fire?

A. Not any that | know of.

Q. In the way of a hose?

A. No, sir.

Q. Was there anything except the water in the barrels on the plat-
form?

A. No, sir; I never saw any.

Q. Do you knew what generally happeus when loose matches and
rats get together?

A. | have heard that rats would strike matches.

Cross-examination.
By Mr. Evans:
Q. Do you mean to say that there was a pile of freight piled up in
the corner?
A. 1 don’t know what it was.
Q. It was not trash?
A. Some paper or something in the corner.
Q. Barrels and boxes and that paper hanging in there on the wall?
A. Yes, sir: those papers hung on the wall.
Q. And there were paners there in a bookcase?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Pigeon holes?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And that was all the paper that you saw in the depot?
A. I never took up any time with it.
Q. That was all the paper that you saw in there?
A. Yes, sir; that was all [ saw.
Q. You were the first one that got there?
A. I was at the store; | was in the store when they hollered fire.
Q. What time of day was it?
A. About sunup
24 Q. Just about sunup?
A. Yes, sir; I guess so,
Q. How far is your store from the depot?

3—358

18 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

A. I guess about thirty steps.

Q. You were in Mr. Ed Jolnston’s store?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And you were among the first that got there?

A. I did not get out to the fire at all, | had to stay in the store.

Q. You did not shut up your store and go?

A. No, sir; they all left the store that was in there and went to the
fire, and | stayed in there.

Q. Who was in there beside you?

A. There was not anyone in there at the time the alarm was given,
but a negro was in front of the store.

Q. There was no ove in the store but you?

A. No, sir.
~Q. You have seen that depot?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. What condition was it in on the 3d of July?

A. It seemed to be all right.

Q. In as good condition as any depot?

A, It seemed to be.

Q. There is no hose water system in this town?

A. Except at the mill.

Q. And that is for the protection of the mill alone?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. You mean the factory over there?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. They have got a water system of their own?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. They pump the water out of Beaverdam?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And there is fio water hose in the town by which you could
squirt water on a fire?

A. I have not seen any.

Q. You have been here long enough to know?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. Have you seen one here?

A. No, sir.

Q. Did you ever see those barrels of water with buckets
25 hanging over them down there at the depot?
A. Yes, sir; I saw two barrels.

Q. Full of water?

—. I do not remember seeing any buckets; I saw the barrels.

Q. They have no system in this town for the protection of dwelling
houses against fire?
. No, sir; if there is, I don’t know it.
Did you ever see any matches there?
There were cartons of matches there,
That came by freight?
. Yes, sir.
. Are you certain they were there the week before?
. It was when IT was in there.
And that might have been ten days before the fire?

OPOPoPo>

.

PROSITE en

AAAI OPTED OPO 4 St Ramis Be = maa pm a ° AB RAE LE gE Ne LIE 1 ir a

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 19

A. Yes, sir.
Q. You cannot say that there was a match in there at the time of
the fire?
A. No, sir.
Q. Or the day before the fire?
A. No, sir; I could not say.
Q. Was not that depot kept pretty clean?
A. Some times it was all right, and again it would be filled up a
right smart; there was a lot of freight there at times.
Q. But the depot was swept out?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. It was kept as clean as any store or depot could be kept?
A. Yes, sir; it was kept pretty clean, I think.
Q. Did you ever see Mr. Townsend smoke cigarettes?
A. No, sir.
Q. Or Miss Richardson?
A. No, sir.
Q. Or T. L. Timmerman?
A. No, sir.
Q. They are the only three people that worked in that depot?
A. Yes, sir.

26 M. C. Jackson (white). sworn:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Thurmond:

Q. How far did you live from the depot down here on the 4th of
July of last year?

A. About 120 or 125 yards,

Q. Do you recall the fire on the morning of the 4th of July?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Did you go to it?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. State to the jury the size of the fire when you got there.

A. I did not see any fire when I got there; I just saw smoke.

Q. What did you see next?
A. Some time after we got there the fire broke out at the top, a
blaze as big as two fingers; just a little bit of smoke.

Q. Did you see any ladder there?

A. No, sir.

Q. If they had had a ladder there could they have put that fire

A. I could have put two boys up there and it looks like I could.

Q. There was no way to get on top of it?

A. No, sir.

Q. If you could have gotten in the room there, in the warehouse,
if those doors could have been opened from the outside, could the
property inside, or a lot of stuff, could that not have been saved?

Mr. Evans: That is leading.

20 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

(By Mr. Thurmond:)

Q. Such as shoes, could they or not have been saved?

A. Yes, sir: I think so.

Q. Asa matter of fact the dours could not be opened from the out-
side; is that true?

A. No, sir. :

Q. What was the only way to get into that depot when it was fast-
ened up? Tow did you have to enter?

A. Had to go in throngh the front, through office, and go through
a little door and move the sliding doors,

Q. How many doors did that warehouse have in front of
27 the main warehouse?
A. It had two waiting rooms and one office.

Q. The one was between the waiting room and warehouse?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Now, explain to the jury how you could get into the ware-
house when it was fastened?

A. The way we went in we went in by the side of the waiting room
and went into the oflice and went through a little door about three
feet wide that went in from the office.

Q. A right narrow door?

A. Yes, sir; I would say three feet.

Q. Where was the door with reference to the partition between the
office and warehouse?

A. The door went this way, on the side here; it was half way be-
tween the end of the chimneys on each side and where they join at
the top a little coming through here not far from the chimney; I
would say five or six feet from the chimney.

Q. That was near the partition?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. With a fire in there at that partition, near that door, could you
pass from there to get into the main part in there?

A. T would not say so.

Q. You could not pass in there because of fire in the partition?

A. No, sir.

Q. How many doors did that warehouse have to it?

A. I think it was five: IT would not be sure about it. T think there
were two on this side and two on the other side, and one at the end.

@. You are not sure about that?

A. No, sir: but T think it is five.

Q. Could those doors be opened at that time, or were they opened?

A. I saw one fly open: after we got a whole crowd there we toted
off two buggies, and I saw one give way, the one next to my house,

[ saw it weaken and the fire flew out.
28 Q. That was after it was burning up?
A. Yes, sir; three-quarters of an hour.

Q. There was no way to get in from the outside because there was
fire near the partition?

A. I don’t see how you could to save your life.

~

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 21

Q. That was how high a house; how many feet of ladder would it
have taken to have put anyone on top of that house?

A. I suppose we could have gone on there if we had had a sixteen-
foot ladder, but it would have takea that much more to get on it, I
would say about thirty feet, where | saw the smoke.

Cross-examination,

By Mr. Evans:

Q. You did not know anything about this case the last time it was
tried?

A. I did not know it was tried before.

Q. You did not kaow it

A. No, sir.
Q. And you have been living in town?
A. Yes, sir,

Q. In the same place?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And you knew nothing about it the time it was tried before;
you never heard of it?

A. I heard it some time ago.

Q. When was the first time you ever told anyone this story that
you have told here?

A. I never said anything until Sunday evening; a railroad man
was sitting in the train Sunday night.

Q. Who was it?

A. 1 cannot call his name.

Q. Mr. McGee?

A. I do not know.

Q. Mr. Arthur?

A. I do not knov. his name.

Q. How do you know he was a railroad man?

A. He told me so.

Q. Where was that?

A. Sunday night at Johnston.

Q. When did you tell Mr. Thurmond about it; you said this was
on Sunday: when did vou tell him about it?

A. T never have told Will Thurmond about it.
29 Q. You never told him? When did you tell Dr. Prescott?
A. Not in my life,

Q. Or Wallace Prescott?

A. Not in my life.

Q. And you never told anyone until Sunday on the train?

A. I never knew anything about it myself.

Q. Don’t you know that when vou got to the fire that the whole
inside of that depot was on fire?

A. It did not look so to me from what T saw.

Q. You saw the fire burst out from where?

A. Coming through the top, a little place about that big.

Q. You know that house was covered with tin?

A. Yes, sir.

A ea RENE AA eee gigas ‘ MgO He A IPE A Bae ONL SAE DT MOAR Ce IOAN, © GATE AN BIH AN i a:

22 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

Q. And the fire had bursted through the wood?

A. A little place about that big. —

Q. Suppose the wareroom had been on fire, could you have gotten
anything out that was on the inside?

A. I was not in there; I could not tell you.

Q. You did not dare go in there?

A. No, sir; and I was not going in there.

Q. You could not have gone in there?

A. We saved three buggies.

Q. You say it would have taken a 16-foot ladder to go up to where
you saw that blaze?

A. Yes, sir.

‘ Q. And you say it would have taken sixteen feet more to go to the
re?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. You wanted two ladders to get to it?

A. I would say it would take about thirty feet.

Q. You know that was a flat roofed house and a man could run
all over it: could he not have gone to the comb of that house without
a ladder; how would you have made a ladder stay if it was that steep?

A. T have nothing to do with that; you could have fastened one

in the ground and stuck the other one up there.

30 Q. How could you handle the other part?

A. I said I never had anything to do with that.
Could you have done it?
. Being crippled as I am it would have been foolish,
Could a stout man?
. Yes, sir; a young man could.
Run up on the roof?
. Yes, sir; got a ladder and got up on there.
How long since you came back to Edgefield?
. Last October.
Why did you leave here?
1 George, I don’t know whether that is any of your business.
. It may be some of the jury would like to know; were you in-
dicted for anything?
No, sir; not a bit.
. What did you leave for?
. George——
Did they not catch you and fine you and you run off?
Not a bit.
Tell us why you left?
T became dissatisfied.
With what?
None of your business.
Became dissatisfied with what?
. None of your business.
The way the town was treating you?
. No, sir.
Q. What was it?

POPOPOPO>o

= ©

POPOPOPOPrOPro>

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 23

A. I have told you.
Were you run away?
. No, sir; I paid every dollar before I left here.
You had to go?
. I did not have to go anywhere.
. Why did you go.
To satisfy myself.
You got satisfied and came back?
Yes, sir.
When did you come back?
I came back on the 11th day of last October.
How many times have you been convicted in Court?
Never was in Court.
Were you not convicted for selling liquor?
No, sir.
And paid a fine for selling liquor?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did you not pay a fine before Judge Brunson for selling
liquor?

Mr. Thurmond: That. is not the way to attack his reputation.
The Court: If he answers no, that settles it.
Mr. Evans: He can answer it if he sees fit.

OPOPOPOrPOrPOrore

ee)
Nes

Q. How many people were at the fire when you got there?
A. It was between four and five o’clock, and Mr. Ed Johnson had
a little old dog that was mad-dog bit, and I wanted to kill the thing
for fear it would bite some children.
Q. How many people were at the fire?
A. There was no one when I got there but Glover Lowe and Mrs.
Pruitt’s little boy.
Who is Glover Lowe?
Hiram Lowe’s son.
How old is he?
I suppose he is fifteen or sixteen years.
How old was the other boy?
. About the same size.
Where are they?
. They were in the mill when they sent after me.
Pick Pruitt and Glover Lowe?
. I told them to run and holler fire.
They went with you?
. Yes, sir; and I told them to holler fire.
And they yelled fire?
. Yes, sir.
What did you set out of the depot?
. Thet was on the back side; we carried three buggies and put
them next to the oil tank.
Q. You saw those barrels of water setting there full of water?
A. I found some gasoline setting there, and I was afraid it was
going to burst open. _
Q. There was gasoline there?

POPOPOPOPOPOProre

et neeeey 3

94 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS, W. E. PRESCOTT.

A. They told me so.
Q. You do not mean to tell us that when you left there there was
gasoline in that house?
A. I was told so.
Q. Did you hear any burst?
A. No, sir.
32 Q. Was the gasoline in barrels?
A, It all poured out before the fire.
Who told you to tell that story?
No one.
Did you pour that gasoline around there?
No, sir.
You never saw it in your life?
No, sir.
. Was M. W. Padgett there when you got there?
A. That door was locked when I went there; if so, he shut the
door behind him and went inside.
Q. He did not come to the fire?
A. After a while.
Q. He came to the fire?
A. After a while.
Q. And what he says is not true; he says he did not go to the fire.
Now tell us where you saw him?
A. I saw him standing on the street at the gasoline tank, where
we put the three buggies, to keep it from bursting.
Q. You know this tank is clean across the street; why did you say
it was at the fire?
A. I was asked to help do that.
Did you ever see him at that fire?
. Which Padgett?
. Where was he?
. I do not know.
Was he or not standing at Ed Johnson’s store?
He was standing in the street when I saw him. In front of the
r at the gasoline tank.
Across from the depot?
Yes, sir.
The street that goes to Trenton?
Yes, sir.
And he was nearly on Main street?
It was right in front of the door at the oil tank.
And that tank belonged to Ed Johnson?
Yes, sir; it did at that time.
And you say that gasoline was Ed Johnson’s?
_ No, sir; I said a barrel on the platform that I was told it was
gasoline. ;
Q. I want to know what you know; did you see any gasoline
there?

OPOrere

POPrOre

do

=)

>OPOPOPoPre

A. Not to my knowledge.
33 Q. Why did you say that; you knew there was none there?

A. That is what I was told.

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. + ie

Q. And you are willing to tell anything?

A. I believe if I was you I would go straight; see if I have not
gone straight.

Q. You know nothing about this case?

A. No, sir; before God.

Q. And you were not summoned before in your life in this mat-
ter?

A. No, sir; never. I never knew anything about it until two weeks
ago.

Q. And you never told anyone what you knew about it before you
got on the stand, except a railroad man?

A. I had no talk with Mr. Thurmond, and no talk with Dr. Pres-
cott, and no talk with Wallace Prescott.

Q. Who did you talk to?

A. Last Sunday evening we were at Johnston, and me and some
boys got to talking about the case; I said what about it; he said what
about it; he said, I do not know myself, and that is all I had to say.

Q. That is all you ever said?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And you have never opened your mouth about it?

A. I never knew anything about it until a few days ago. I did
not know there was any case at all.

Q. You helped put out the cars?

A. Yes, sir; and helped draw water.

Q. Where did you get the water?

A. Out of my own well.

Q. How far is your house from where the fire was?

A. From where we are to the water tank.

Q. How far is the house from where you drew water?

A. About 120 yards.

Q. Down the railroad track?

A. Right square across there.

Q. Don’t you know that that coach was put out by water out of
those barrels?

A. If you drew 25 or 30 buckets.
34 Q. And you put it in the barrels?
A. We toted it in buckets.

Q. You used what was in the barrels?

A. Yes, sir; at first; and it did not put it out.

Q. And they helped to put the fire out?

A. They helped to put out the passenger coach after we run them
down the railroad ; it was too soon to have the engine fired up and we
pushed them off.

Q. And that was when you drew the water?

A. I helped draw water. ;

Q. And that is when you drew it, when you pushed them off, but
you used the water at the depot?

A. I could not tell you, I guess by that time we had a hundred
people there; I could not tell who helped.

Q. Don’t you know that that depot caught in the warehouse?

4—358

eT ET ORE

> ae eon LO I ll ee ee ee en i a ee. Se ee ee. re Te f —

MP ae oF ES et ae : chee TORI iE Slt OS EH PON Bi OEE EF ND NRE A PEED PSTD ND IRE URAL ee

26 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

A. I don’t know it.

Q. Don’t you know the otlice and waiting rooms were the last
thing that caught?

A. All I saw is what I have told you.

Q. That was at the far end of the warehouse?

A. No, sir; the middle room between the warehouse and waiting
rooms.

Q. Where was the chimney; was it not the center of the ware-
house?

A. No chimney in the warehouse at all.

Q. All on the inside?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. You are as certain of that as you are about everything else that
you have testified?

A. In the office.

Q. The chimney was not in the office?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. You know there was not anything but a partition between the
warehouse and oflice?

A, The chimney was there, all right.

Q. Was not the chimney inside of the warehouse and not inside
of the office? ;

A. It was right where they joined together.

35 Q. Right where they joined together?
A. I do not believe they had any fireplace inside of the
warehouse.

Q. What was the warchouse used for?

A. For groceries and everything shipped there.

Q. Did you go there pretty often?

A. Thad not been in there for two months before. T was over on
the farm and not up here.

Q. You do not know what was in there and do not know how it
caught?

A. No, sir.

Q. When you got there you could not do anything to save the
building, could you?
. It looks like if we could have got help we could have done a

lo
Was it not early in the morning?

. Between four and five o’clock.

Between daylight and sunup?

Yes, sir.

No one was up at that hour except the watchman?

Tt was the 4th of July and every one was asleep.

It was the 4th of July and they were all out of the mill that

OPOPOPro”™ >

a
pS

A. Yes, sir.

Q. With no facilities in this town—there is no facility for fighting
fire in the way of water here?

A. No, sir.

Q. No protection for the homes?

ae ROAR

36

A

OPOPO>oprop

a>a>pe>

of an

A. Not unless you had water.

Q. You could not put out a fire with an empty hose?

A. It does not look so,

Q. You say the doors opened sliding: was that not the best way
to protect that building, to have the doors in that condition?

A. That is the way we have them in the cotton mill and in the
depot.

Q. That is the best door for a warehouse; they were just ordinary
warehouse doors; nothing peculiar about it: a sliding door on a ladder
or something and they were fastened every night?

A. As far as T know.

Q. They were not opened, and no part had been opened that you
saw ?
. I never saw it.

. All six or seven of those doors were closed when you got there?

buggies, and I did not go around there at all.
Q. Do you know whether he tried to get in at all?
A. No, sir.

. No, sir.
. Did you go to Mrs, Lynch’s fire the other night?

: Nothing could be done there?

. No water to throw on it?
. No, sir.
- No hose to shoot on it?

- They have a little piece of hose to run around here on the
square?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. That was no protection at the depot; they have no water-
works by which the depot could be protected ?

A. N

- Do you know when Mr. Townsend got there?
. Yes, sir; IT saw him.

. Saw him coming across the street to the depot.

: a SN Ol AIRE NR AS te Ee PSEEY wet WE ADS | ANDAR RA ROTM ‘
PANT EIE TOE Yea ele REE PRES! TIN ON Oo 19 Th, ome >

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY Ys, wW. E. PRESCOTT, 27

ed Pee eee

Yes, sir.

O, sir.

No, sir; we started to get it, and it would not go far enough.

Yo, sir. The town did not.
Except at the mill?
A. Mr. Adams did.
Q. And Mr. Adams got his water from the mill—the mill
furnishes them?
Yes, sir.
But there is no water system here for putting out fires?
No, sir.
No hose company, nor anvthing, no fire company?
No, sir.
What good would a hose do if you had no water: would it be
Vv use?

All closed as far as I saw.

Where did you see him?

Did vou see him get in?
I did not get on the front: T was helping Mr. Johnson move

Des aenashidtots eet “ - — —_
LAE. Si eg nts KE KERALA A a RAGE PS ERP RE Todd bo a

3 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY vs. W. E. PRESCOTT.

Q. If there was such a fire that he could not get into the office was

it possible for you to save anything?
A. That was fifteen or twenty minutes before he got there.
37 Q. You know that thing burned down in twenty minutes?
A. No, sir.

It did not burn down in twenty minutes?
No, sir.
How long did it take it to burn down?
. T suppose it fell in in thirty or forty minutes.
- In what condition was the fire when Mr. Townsend got there?
T could not say that, because T was helping move the buggies ;
IT do not believe it was falling in.

Q. You do not believe it was?

A. Tf so, T did not see it.

Q. The office part and the waiting rooms were not on fire when
you saw Mr. Townsend?

A. That was the first place I saw the fire, in the office.
You saw the fire first in the office?
_ Coming through the roof.
On the outside?
Yes, sir; at that time.
’ Was there any ceiling in that depot?
T could not tell you.
You saw the blaze through the roof?
. Saw smoke.
. Saw smoke?
T saw smoke.
Just smoke?
. Smoke.
~ You do not know what the condition was on the inside; was not
the smoke coming out all around the ends of that house and all
around it?

A. Not when T saw it.

Q. When did it come out of there?

A. Tn fifteen or twenty minutes or half an hour it was burning
through everywhere.
Q. You say it took it about forty minutes to burn up?
A. T said for the roof to fall in.
Q. Who did you say got there after you got there?
A. IT do not know.
Q
nd
A

OPOore

>

ake

DEQPOFrOrOroro

" Give me the name of any one you saw there except Mr. Town-

_ T sent the boys to Mr. Hughes, the engineer, and he came.
Q. What time did he get there?

38 A. Mr. Timmerman, that works with the agent, and they
all come running down there, and I could not tell you.

They were the only ones you saw?

. The whole town came there.

_ All of them saw you there?

. They ought to.

You are satisfied they saw you at that fire?

O>O>d

POEL LIE DN Sar srop tee

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

A. They ought to.
Q. You are satisfied you were at the fire?
A. Yes, sir.

Redirect examination.
By Mr. Thurmond:

Q. You were asked about when you first told this: do you recall
whether you were summoned Saturday or Monday; was it not
Monday you were summoned?

Mr. Evans: That is a matter of record.
(By Mr. Thurmond:)

Q. You had a talk with me a few moments ago?

Mr. Evans: Tle said he did not.
The Court: Do not lead him.

(By Mr. Thurmond:)

Q. When did you have a talk with me before that.

Mr. Evans: That is what he said, that he did not have any.
(By Mr. Thurmond:)

Q. I want to understand whether you meant you never had any
talk with me before while ago; when did you have a talk with me
about this case?

A. In that little room while ago.

Mr. Thurmond: T knew he meant before he came to Court.
Adjournment for dinner.

The following testimony of E. H, Prescott, taken at a former
trial, was read to the jury:

39 E. I. Prescorr (white), sworn:
Direct examination.

By Mr. Thurmond:

Q. You are a son of Dr, FE. W. Prescott?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Did you ever come up after freight a few days before this
depot was burned down here?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Did you have much freight in the depot?

A, No, sir, not then; there was some fine feed, I think. it had been
there longer than the shoes, and T concluded T would get that first,
as T could not carry it all, and I would get what shoes T could carry
and leave the rest there, because they had not been there as long.

Q. Did the agent tell vou the shoes were there?

A. Yes, sir, and I paid the freight.

Q. You paid the freight on everything you got?

4

30 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

Yes, sir.

. Everything?

. On all that was there; yes, sir.

. What was said when you paid the freight?

. Nothing.

. Who brought the shoes out to you?

. T think Mr. Timmerman delivered the stuff.
. Did he tell you the other shoes were there?
Yes, sir.

You paid the freight on everything that was there?
. Yes, sir.

_ And that was all that passed between you?
. Yes, sir.

>OrOrPOrOPoOrop

Cross-examination.

By Mr. Evans:

. You go there to the depot frequently?
. Not so very often.
- You haul freight to your father’s store?
A. Yes, sir. -
40 Q. That was on the 23d of June?
A, I do not remember the date.

_ Was it not about ten days before the fire?
. It was on the 23d.
_ Would you say it was ten days before that fire?
Yes, sir.
. You got a part of the freight and you were informed that
it was all there?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And you told them you could not carry it all on that load, and
you asked them to keep it until you could come back for it?
Yes, sir.
And they kept it at your instructions as an accommodation ?
I expected to pay storage.
You got them to keep it until you came hack?
We were paying for the accommodation.
And you were paying for that storage?
Yes, sir.
And willing to let it stay there under that condition ?
Yes, sir.
But there was no contract for any payment on it?
. No, sir.
Nothing was said about it at all?
. No, sir.
_ Did you see the barrels of water on the platform while you
were there?
A. T do not remember about that special date; T saw them nearly
every time I went there?
Q. Did you see any bucket hanging around there?
A. Yes, sir.

OO

DPOPOPOrOrorer

«eee

ie Re ee ee ke Si mae et in aes en

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. EF. PRESCOTT. 31

(By Mr. Thurmond:)

Q. What was said about leaving the freight?

A, Ie said all right, we could not carry out all a lot of times, and
it was all right.

Q. And you paid storage?

A, Not all the time; we would not wait that long.

Q. If you waited too long?

A. Yes, sir; so many days, and then storage begins.
41 Q. They charge storage on freight after it has been there
so long a time?
A. Yes, sir.

W. E. Prescorr (white), sworn:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Thurmond:

Q. You brought this suit?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where were those goods shipped from?
A. Petersburg, Virginia.
Q. Look at that paper (presenting same); what papers are those
and what did vou do with those papers?
A. In regard to some shoes that were burned.
Q. What did you do with those papers, were they filed with the
agent?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Of the Southern Railway Company?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Townsend?
. Yes, sir.
. Did they return them to you?
Yes, sir.
They refused to pay for them?
Yes, sir.
Whose shoes were they?
They were mine.
Ts that an invoice for those shoes?
. Yes, sir.
How many boxes were shipned?
. Of the original shipment there were thirteen cases.
Tlow many cases were delivered to you?
. Four cases.
What was the value of the nine cases not delivered?

PPOPOPOrOro>rore

Mr. Evans: We object to that because it is in writing. and here is
the account showing the valuation and evervthing and not in the
doctor’s handwriting and not made out by him. but that is a claim
he filed with us, and the paper should speak for itself.

Mr. Thurmond: We have to prove that the shoes were worth that.

The Court: Go ahead.

Dr ee ee ee Oe ee eee rm PP Pe 4 ee

32 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. p. PRESCOTT,

Mr. Evans: As to the account of the shoes, there is his
42 own writing, and that is the claim he filed with us, and we
submit that it is the best evidence of what they were worth,

The Court: You are not trying to vary it; you are trying to prove
your claim; that is what you are trying to do. ,

Mr. Evans: That is what he wants to do; the papers are the best
evidence: here is the claim he asked us to pay: that is the best evi-
dence.

The Court: Do you deny that?

Mr. Thurmond: He denies everything.

_ The Court: That is not as to the part of the paper not proven; he
is not trving to vary it.

Mr. Evans: If he can prove that paper is what he filed with us
and put it in, and not prove that this item was worth so much or
that one so much,

The Court: Is that what you are trving to do?

Mr. Thurmond: Prove the value of the shoes that were destroyed.

The Court: Go ahead.

(By Mr. Thurmond:)

Q. What was the value of the entire shipment of shoes?

A. I do not remember.

Q. What was the value of the nine cases that you did not get and
left up here; can you refresh your memory?

A. $236.35 and the freight on the nine cases amounting to $5.48,
making $241.78.

Q. State to the jury whether that was a fair value for the shoes
at this place?

A. That was the invoice price of the goods.

Q. With the freight added?

A. Yes, sir, with freight added.

Q. What date did you file these papers with the agent of the
Southern Railway Company at Edgefield?

A. T do not remember the exact date.

Q. Can you tell by referring to that paper there?

A. T think so; July 31, 19138.

43 Q. When did that fire take place?

A. July 4, 1913.
When did you get some of the nine eases of shoes?
Tt was about the 23d of June; about that time.
The 23d of June?
. Yes, sir.
_ Did you send your wagons up here before the depot was
burned?

A. T sent the wagons up for freight. and my son, FE. TH. Prescott,
and there was not enough freight to fill un the load that T knew was
there, and he found out that the shoes had come and he paid the
freight and Mr. Townsend delivered four cases to finish out the load.

Q. Did you send your wagon up after that before the 4th of July?

Q>oro

A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did they send the nine cases of shoes?
A. No, sir.

* Le creel onc ns 9
Bir: Seals ot a oe kee site se

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. RB. PRESCOTT,

Could they have sent them?
Yes, sir,
. Who did you send?
My son.
. Did you send him every time?
I do not remember every time.
You do not remember whether he came after that?
. He came frequently for me.
. How far do you live from here?
. Ten miles.
That was a very busy season of the year?
Yes, sir,
. When they kept your freight any length of time did you pay
storage?
A. I have paid storage.
Q. Did they notify you that they would not keep this freight any
longer?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did they give you any notice at all?
A. No, sir.
Q. However, you knew your shoes were here, as your son had told
you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did they write you that they would not keep these shoes here
as warehousemen at all and that you must get them out?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did you have occasion to visit that depot frequently before
that fire?
A. 1 was there frequently.
44 Q. What did you see in the depot, if anything, in the way
of trash or papers?
A. T saw a lot of papers, trash of different kinds,
Q. Where was it?
A. In the northwest corner, principally, of the building.
Q. The northwest corner of the building?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you see any ladder out there by the house?

i= SERS ‘ he : Se Se On Tn ene ee a Tne
|

POPOPOPOrepe

=)

Mr. Hvans: That is not alleged as one of the acts of negligence ;
here is the specifie charge which we are to meet,

The Court: He is on the question of warehouseman: he did not
have to allege any negligence at all; all he has to prove is that you
were in possession of it as a warehouseman.

Mr. Evans: We only have to show that we exercised ordinary care
as a warehouseman.

The Court: If vou are a gratuitous bailee, you allege all of these
specific acts, he did not have to allege it.

Mr. Thurmond: T did not have to do it.

The Court: Because the law is you were in possession of it, and you
are the only one that can explain how it was burned up.

(By Mr. Thurmond:)

Q. Did you notice any ladder about that building?
5—358

coo

Pe aN ON, me EY , : EEO

34 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.
A. I do not remember seeing any.
Q. Did it have any sprinkler system in it?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did you ever see any hose around there?
A. No, sir.
Q. Do you know whether the building right next to it, Captain

Adams’ warehouse, has a sprinkler system?

Mr. Evans: What is in another house has nothing to do with what
we have got.

Mr. Thurmond: We are showing how easy it would have been to
get water from Adams’ warehouse; we are showing that he had a
sprinkler system in his warehouse.

The Court: What has Adams’ warehouse got to do with this

case?
45 Mr. Thurmond: To show that they could have gotten water
there if they had had any hose; they could have gotten water
in twenty yards if they had had a hose; water was convenient if
they had had a hose.
The Court: Go ahead; IT think you can prove that.

(By Mr. Thurmond:)

Q. Do you know whether Adams’ warehouse has a sprinkler
system? .

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And plenty of water?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Did you ever see any hose around this station ?

A, No, sir.

Q. What height tower would it have taken for a tank to have
given plenty of water to put out a fire at that place?

Mr. Evans: We object.

Mr. Thurmond: My purpose is to show that if they had had a
well and tower and tank at this warehouse that they could have
put it out very easily.

The Court: Go ahead.

(By Mr. Thurmond :)

- What height tower would have been necessary ?
. Fifteen or twenty feet.
It was rather a low topped warehouse?
. Yes, sir.

Q. If there had been a tower and a tank and some hose you could
put out a fire pretty well?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. There was no such thing there?

A. No, sir.

Q. Did you see any equipment at all except those barrels of
water out on the platform—did you ever see anything else there?

A. No, sir.

Q. What account would that be without a ladder when the fire
was on top of the house?

>OPro

PNRM IEC eG wes

GPU OR Re ANE Vr A ee ANRC OR ENS SORE Wnt WA aint EN BARE Ne Ba Foret BNE NanPe Mae et ie Ts RI

FHO>Oo>

46

O>o>o

fyin

—s

litt

Q>o>ro>

47

O>O>O>rO>ro>

>O>o

A aI mi Nnk MORI ASS A Regabbsh

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 35

. Ido not see how you could get up to it.

. The railway company has never paid you?

. No, sir.

. The railway company has refused to pay you anything?
. Yes, sir.

We offer these papers in evidence,
(Exhibit No. 1.)

Cross-examination.

By Mr. Evans:

You testified in this case the last time it was tried?
Yes, sir.

. You testified at the last trial of this ease here?

Yes, sir.
Did vou not sav at the last trial that you received a ecard noti-

g vou that vour freight was there?

A, No, sir: T do not think T did because T do not know anything
about it.

Q. Did vou not testifv further that that depot was kept as clean
and in as clean a condition as any vou had ever seen?

A. IT do not think T went that far that it was as clean as any I
ever saw.

Q. Was it not as clean as any vou ever saw?

. IT do not think so.

What was the matter with it?

. There was a lot of trash there.

Where was the trash?

. T have seen it on the floor and in the shelf,
. What did the trash consist of?

Oats, corn, flour, ete.

Did you ever see any hav in that depot on the inside?

T do not remember that T ever saw any on the inside.

You never say anything on the floor except corn, oats, and a

e flour?
. Trash and papers scattered around.

Where did vou see the papers?

. On the floor and shelves.

That is where they kept their supplies to run the office?
T don’t know.
Were they not in pigeon holes?
A. No, sir. -
Q. What were they in?
A. In a bundle tied up.
And in the cases on the shelves?

. Yes, sir.

Thev were not scattered around there loose anywhere?
Those that were on the shelves were not.

Q. You did not see any seattered in the corner, did you, you never
saw any loose papers in the corner?
A. I have seen papers in there.

OA Ae AD tate Se PPS. . St aaa ah

36 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

Q. Did you ever see any gasoline there?

A. I do not know that I ever saw any gasoline there.

Q. Is it not a fact that you did receive a postal card like that
(presenting card)? That is the one that was shown you at the last
trial.

A. No, sir.

Q. Eustis told you the goods were there?

A. He brought out four cases and said the shoes were there; I
knew nothing about it until he came back home.

Q. Eustis was authorized to act for you?

A. I sent him after freight.

Q. You sent him to transact business and bring freight?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And he found this freight, and paid the freight on it, and gave
his receipt to the agent?

A. T suppose so.

Q. And receipted for a part of it?

A. Four cases.

Q. You do not know anything about what Eustis and the agent
did; you do not know what arrangements they made?

. No, sir.

You never had to pay storage on these goods?

No, sir: but T have on others.

No demand has been made on you for storage on these goods?

No, sir.

You say you never received a card like that?

T do not remember that T did.

Didn’t vou testify # the last trial that vou received that card?

T don’t remember that T did; T might have received it after
Eustis brought the shoes home, but before that T never re-

48 ceived it, because T did not know anything about the shoes

being there until Eustis got back.

POPOPOPrO>

Q. You knew these shoes were there on the 23d day of June?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. And this depot w as burned on the 3d of July, 4th of July?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. How many days is that?

A. Fight or ten days, somewhere along there.

Q. How many days are there in June?

A. Thirty.

Q. And how many days in July until the 4th?

A. Four.

Q. That is about ten days?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Do vou know whether they got there early in the morning—it

was ten days that the goods remained in the warehouse?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And you made no effort to get them out?

A. T sent miy wagons there.

Q. cage that brought back a load of freight as far as they could
carry

WSL ORIN EN ME es oe re ;

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 37

A. I do not know that they brought back as much as they could
carry.
Q. Sometimes freight is very bulky and you can’t put much on
a wagon?
A. Sometimes.
Q. They brought a load of freight every time they came?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. During those ten days how many times did you send your
wagons here?
. I do not remember.
Two or three times?
T ¢» not remember.
. Would you be safe in saying once?
. I think so.
You do not remember who came with your wagon?
. I do not know whether Eustis came or not.
. You knew the only freight in the depot on the 23d of June
were those shoes; that the only freighi in the warehouse on the 23d
of June, and they hauled out this load, was these shoes?
A. As far as T know,
Q. That is all he left?
A. Yes, sir.
49 Q. And you received no notice to carry off the freight
from the 23d of June until the 4th of July?
. I do not remember.
You sent your wagons back between those two dates?
Yes, sir.
. And they did not bring the shoes?
No, sir,
. Although the freight had been paid and you receipted for
them?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You had these papers (presenting same), you had all of those
papers in your possession ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. They acted for you in shipping those goods?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Who are those people here?
A
Q

DQPOPo>ro>

DPoO>ro>

. Augustus Wright Shoe Company.
. They acted for you in shipping these goods on this bill of
lading?
A. Yes sir.
Q. You know that that depot was, as a matter of fact. burned,
was it not?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was it not a comparatively new depot?
A. T think so.
Q. You are a farmer living ten miles from here; what stock ot
goods do vou carry?
A. Four or five thousand dollars.
Q. Have you a sprinkler system in your store?

38 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.
A. No, sir.
Q. Have you got a barrel of water setting around in case of fire?
A. No, sir.
Q. And you carry five or six thousand dollars’ worth of goods?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you have no sprinkler system and no water tower to put
water on anything?
A. No, sir.

Q. And this town has no water system?
A. I think so.
Q. Where is it?
A. T see a tank out there on top of the tower.

50 Q. You mean this little tank out here?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. Ana yo snow this only extends around the square?
A. IT do not know.
Q. You know it does not run down to the depot?
A. No, sir.
Q. This town has no general protection against fire?
A. No, sir.
If a man keeps a warehouse and there is no protection against

fire, and he keeps barrels of water and buckets hanging on them,
don’t vou think he is pretty well protected?

ru

sh

. I do not know.

He is taking the care of a prudent men + protect his property?
. He could have put in a sprinkler system.

Suppose he did not have the money?

. The Southern Railroad has got plenty of money.

Suppose you do it, you have the money?

. The Southern Railroad has lost the depot and you have not.
You have the money to put in yours, why don’t you do it?

T don’t know about that.

You have not got it?

No, sir.

You know Mrs. Lynch’s house burned?

Yes, sir.

No water to protect it?

No, sir.

. What would be the use of hose without water?

T do not know.

_ Tt would be a nice ornament to hang on the wall?

T guess so,

. It would not be any good at all if you did not have water to
through a hose?

A. Tt would be no service.

Q. Was not that depot located in quite a respectable part of town?
A. T think so.

Q. In a public place?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Who went back with your wagon the second time after the
oes were left there?

5 D>OPOPOPOPOHOrOrOroO>

BRET EEA hts got

2 : ; ra ; mt ee ee ee ae os ne Tees
2 NAMEN RAL bee BRT Hats ae, 4 hs ea eel o - |

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT, 39

A. I do not know whether Eustis did or not.
51 Q. Do you remember what sort of freight they brought
back?

A. I do not know what it was,

Q. You run a grocery store?

A. A general store.

Q. That is the bill and the value of the goods shipped you (pre-
senting same) ?

A. The whole business.

Q. By Augustus Wright & Company at Petersburg.

Q. You filed this with the company; the Augustus Wright Com-
pany made that out? P
Yes, sir.

. It is their own writing?

A. Yes, sir.

. And they made this out for you?

. Lsuppose the railroad company did that.
. They signed it?

. I suppose so.

And it is for your benefit?

Yes, sir.

a>

>OPO>O

Plaintiff rests.

Mr. Evans: We ask your Honor for a nonsuit or the direction of
a verdict under the first count in the complaint, as to common car-
rier. The evidence here shows that this freight arrived here on the
23d of June, and that the freight was paid and receipted for by the
agent of Dr. Prescott. He came for it and paid the freight: and I
submit that where a common carrier delivers freight in good order,
and has it in its depot and paid for, then its liability as a common
carrier ceases.

And, further, there is no evidence going to show negligence, from
which the jury could infer negligence as set out in the complaint.

The Court: You are on the first count?

Mr. Evans: Yes, sir; that they are liable as insurers,

The Court: And they can only be relieved from that by an act
of God or a public enemy.

Mr. Evans: I see the grounds of negligence in the warehouse
transaction are set out in the first cause of action and as a common

carrier; they are both the same, exactly.
52 Mr. Thurmond: There is no negligence in the first cause
of action at all.

Mr. Evans: We ask your Honor for a nonsuit on the whole busi-
ness. There is no testimony to show that they are’Tiable as a com-
mon carrier.

The Court: We will wait until the testimony is all in: you know
when you are on actions of this kind, the Supreme Court looks for
a scintilla, and that is a very small thing; when the testimony is all
in, I will give my decision as to directing a verdict. Go ahead,

LM LOLA BALL LEA LLL LAL LIEDER AMA. ALP ANE LA ALA EA en

40 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

Testimony for the Defense.

R. B. Artuur (white), sworn:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Evans:
Q. We offer in evidence the certificate of the Secretary of the In-
terstate Commerce Commission, under the seal of the Court, by its
Secretary.

The Court: All right; you are going under the Carmack Act?
Mr. Evans:. Yes, sir.

Q. What position do you hold?) |
A. Commercial agent at Augusta, Georgia,

@. We offer this in evidence. (Exhibit No. 2.)

Q. This, a certificate of the Interstate Commerce Commission, is
the freight rate rules?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Read that rule?

A. “The reduced rates specified in this classification will apply on
property shipped subject to the condition of carrier's bill of lading.
Property carried not subject to the conditions of the carrier’s bill of
lading will be at the carrier’s liability, limited only as provided by
common law and by the laws of the United States and of the several
States, in so far as they apply. Property thus carried will be charged

ten (10) per cent. higher (subject to minimum increase of
53 one (1) per cent. per hundred pounds) than if shipped sub-
ject to the conditions of the carrier’s bill of lading.”

Q. How were those goods shipped?

A. They were shipped released, subject to the bill of lading.

Q. What do you mean by released ?

A. It is a railway rate specified in the bill of lading: if it is goods
that the shipper wants to specify some value on, and do not want to
ship them under the conditions of the bill of lading, he is charged
ten per cent. higher; if he wants to put other conditions than in
the bill of lading he would have to pay ten per cent. higher.

Q. It was shipped under the rule that makes the bill of lading the
contract between the parties?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Has that rule been filed with the railroad offices?

A. Yes, sir; in every office in this country; it is filed with the
Interstate Commerce Commission at Washington.

Q. Is that rule in that book?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Has that been filed in the offices of the Southern Railway Com-
pany?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Can you show me this rule in this book?

A. Yes, sir. (Reads Rule No. 1.)

is, Ses OR One A a UPR Ura atten —— - . wee

ee a eee Pe es eae | — ae

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 41

Q. It is simply a contract as to a common carrier; it does not
go to the warehouseman.

The Court: I just wanted to get it straight.

(By Mr. Evans:)

Q. You say that was on file in your office?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is that the rate under that bill of lading that the goods were
shipped, under Rule No, 1?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is there any rate on there?
A. Not from Petersburg.
Q. What are the freight charges?
A. It does not show on here; 82 cents per 100 pounds; that is
shown from Lynchburg.
54 Q. And that comes under Rule No. 1, and that is a copy
of it?
A. No, sir.

No cross-examination.
J. A. Townsenp (white), sworn:

Direct examination.
By Mr. Evans:

Q. What was your position the 4th of July?

A. Agent for the Southern Railway.

Q. Were you railroad agent here on the 23d of June?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Do you recall the date the depot was burned?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. What was burned at the depot?

A. The depot and the freight that was in the warehouse.

Q. Were your records burned?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. How far did you live from the depot at that time?

A. About one hundred yards.

Q. Who are your assistants?

A. Mr. T. L. Timmerman and Miss Richardson,

Q. And they are the only three persons that work in that depot
with you and under you?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Do you recall that Dr. Prescott had some freight that arrived
here about the 20th or 21st’ of June?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Do you know whether or not notice was given him that the
goods were there?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. What was the notice?

A. Only a card.

6—358

Oe ee ewe Sie teen) et 2 ee BONEN PNR BEE SEE INO NS 1 SOAR TE BOP LM ALI a Wp _—

42 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. FE. PRESCOTT.

Q. A card like that (presenting same) ?
A. Yes, sir.
We offer this card in evidence. (Exhibit No, 3.)

Q. That was mailed to him from your office?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What other notice did Dr. Prescott have?
A. He came there and receipted for the freight.
Q. Came there and receipted for it?
A. Yes, sir.
55 Q. What was done?
A. We delivered him four cases of the shoes.
Q. They were all there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Who came to the depot?
A. Dr. Prescott’- son came there.
. Did he or not pay you the freight on all the goods that were
there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Why did he not take the others?
A. He wanted to carry some groceries home with him and did
not have enough wagons to carry the shoes,
Q. He carried groceries and left the shoes?
A. Yes, sir; he carried a part of the shoes.
Q. Were those shoes delivered to him?
A. Yes, sir.
(). Were they his property at that time and out from under your
control?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You had accepted the freight for it?
A. Yes, sir; and had his receipt for the goods.
Q. What has become of them?
. They got burned in the fire,
All the records of that office were burned? ‘
. Yes, sir.
. Did Dr, Prescott send his wagons back to the depot between
the 20th and 23d of June and the 4th of July besides that load?
. Yes, sir.
What did they get then?
They got stuff, such as flour, and the like.
But they did not take the shoes then?
No, sir; he got freight, but he did not get the shoes,
Got other freight and did not take the shoes?
No, sir.
He left them there?
Yes, sir.
What was the agreement witlkreference to holding those goods?
He just wanted to know if it*vould be agreeable to leave them
there, and I said it would be.
56 Q. You did not make any charges for storing them?
A. No, sir.

OPo>

POPOPOrOorer

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 43

Q. And did not expect him to pay any?

A. No, sir.

Q. And that was the agreement between you and Eustis Prescott
that he would come back and get the shoes, and that you would let
them lie there as a matter of recommendation?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. How long had the shoes been there before the fire?

A. Ten or twelve days. We delivered him four eases on the 23d
of June.

Q. You delivered Dr. Prescott freight between the 23d of June
and the 4th of July that came into the warehouse after the shoes did?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Tle sent down there and got freight that eame in after the
shoes had been there for quite a while?

. Yes, sir.

Groceries and the like?

Yes, sir.

. Do you smoke?

No, sir.

. Smoke cigarettes?

. No, sir.

Do any of your assistants smoke cigarettes?

Not that T know of; Mr. Timmerman may smoke cigarettes,
. Did you ever see him smoke in the office?

I do not recall,

That young lady down there, does she smoke?

. No, sir; she does not smoke.

. It is alleged here that vou had a lot of trash and stuff in the
warehouse; state to the jury what was in that depot?

A. There was no trash in the depot, only freight.

Q. And that was the only place you had to keep freight?

A. Yes, sir. We had records on the shelves,

Q. On the night you left that office, that freight office, on the
3d of July, were there any matches in that warehouse?

A. Not that I know of.

Q. You locked your doors that night?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. As you always did?

A. Yes, sir.
57 Q. Had vou had any fire there that day?
A. No, sir; it was summer time and we needed no fire.

You did not have any sprinkler system there?
. No, sir.
’ gg town has no waterworks for protection against fire?

0, sir.
What protection did you have against fire?
. We had water barrels around the depot and on the cotton plat-
form, with buckets on them, and we always kept them full of water,

Q. They are good big barrels?

Yes, sir.

POPOPO>O>ro>ro>

=)

>O>O>o

44 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

Q. How many did you have?
A. Six or eight on the warehouse platform and about the same
number on the cotton platform.
You mean on the platform by the side of the railroad?
Yes, sir. All around the building.
A® around the building?
Yes, sir,
There were buckets there?
Yes, sir.
That morning were those barrels full of water?
Yes, sir.
When did you get to the fire?
. About 5:30 a. m.
Who was there when you got there?
. There was five or six there.
. Were you among the first that got to the fire?
. Yes, sir.
. What did you do when vou got there?
; Sy went to the office door and tried to get in, and I could not

OE POPOPOPOPOPOP Ore

ge
Ay Ww as vour office on fire then?

A. No, sir.

Q. What part was on fire?

A. In the wareroom.

Q. Was the partition between your office and the wareroom on
fire then?

A. No, sir.

Q. Your office was between the waiting room and the warehouse?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And the waiting rooms and your office were the last part of
the station that burned?

A. Yes, sir.
58 Q. Did you make any effort to save the freight and things
there?

A. T tried to get in the office, and there was smoke in there and |

could not get in.

Q. It was too far gone when you got there?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. Did you see Marion Jackson there?

A. No, sir; I do not remember seeing him.

Q. Who went there with you?

A. Cesar Simkins,

Q. And that was on the side the cars were on?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. They burned?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And you did not see Jackson there at that time?
A. No, sir.

RO Serre a . - . 7 rR TRS
wry F e wee

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 45

Cross-examination.
By Mr. Thurmond:

Q. Did you see him there at all?

A. I do not remember it.

Q. There was a lot of people there?

A. There was a good many there.

Q. Your rules require you to charge storage after goods have been
there for so long a time?

A. Forty-eight hours,

Q. You would charge warehouse fees: you mean you would charge
storage after they were there 48 hours?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And if you did not charge a man storage during that time
you held his goods there as a common carrier, did you not; you held
them as a common carrier?

A. Yes, sir; I suppose so.

Q. That was your custom, was it not? That was your practice, was
it not?

A. We generally collected storage.

Q. You collected storage?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. But as T understand you, you did not mean to charge storage
in this case, because you held them as a common carrier; did you
mean to charge storage on the goods?

A. There was nothing said about storage charges.

Q. You held them as a common carrier?

A. No, sir.
59 Q. Is that right?
A. No, sir; they were held at his own risk.

Q. You sent him this card; you said you would charge him storage,
is that correct? Did you say there you would charge him storage?

A. I do not know exactly how the reading is: it says on here that
demurrage and storage will be assessed at the expiration of the free
time provided by the rules of this company.

Q. What were the rules of the company?

A. The rule of demurrage and storage was to collect storage,

Q. Until you began doing that you held it as a common carrier?

A. It was held 48 hours.

Q. And that was your custom and your practice; you collected the
insurance on those goods?

. Insurance?

. Yes, sir.

- No, sir; we did not collect any insurance.

You did not get any insurance?

. I do not know about that.

Did not the railroad get the insurance?

No, sir; I do not know.

‘ oo not the insurance company pay the Prescott loss?

0, sir.

PO>O>Oro>

EV ake =A RS Pont once RNR OL PC Ca Nin eek aN LY ogi Ma ee ree te A ae -~ 2a ie Oe ———

46 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

No insurance adjuster came to see about that loss?

. He looked after the freight.

The insurance man did?

. To make his adjustment with the insurance company,

Did not the insurance man come and look after the freight and
ascertain what freight was destroyed?

A. Yes, str.

Q. And did not th: .ompany collect the money for the freight?
A. No, sir; not Zor Or. Prescott.
Q
A

O>oOre

. For all the freie.ht in the depot?
. No sir; I do not know that.
Q. You Jo not know that all of that freight was insured,
60 and thai your company got the insurance on all of it?
A. No, sir; I do not know it.
Q. The insurance man came and you gave him all the freight?
A. I gave him a record of it.
Q. And did not the company get it?
A. No, sir.
And don’t you know that the railroad was going to charge Dr.
Prescott enough to cover the insurance?
A. No, sir.
Q. How much freight was there in that depot?
A. In dollars and cents?
Q. Yes, sir.
A. 1 do not know.
Q. You do not know how much there was?
A. No, sir.
Q. Who represented the insurance company?
Mr. Elmore, superintendent of the insurance department at
Washington.
Q. Superintendent of insurance at Washington?
Yes, sir.
He was the man?
Tlis representative,
You have no sprinkler system there?
. No, sir.
The Adams warehouse has a water system?
. Yes, sir.
He can put out a fire in his warehouse when it starts?
I do not know.
Do you know what a gasoline engine costs?
. Various prices, I guess.
What is the fair cost of an engine: could you not get a pretty
one for one hundred dollars?
T suppose so; a small one.
What would it cost to dig a well?
T do not know.
Tlow deep would a well have to be there?
. About 35 or 40 feet.
. That would not cost more than $25 or $30?
A. I do not know.

32
[~)
OP OPOPZLOPOPOPrOro rer

RESTA SRN iaaR i ie)

a S z een att allls SERS Be te Some
= LALA LALA OMB ET PRE ah AI Male EK ESE BED Tp OOS PMN AEA ID POLE A” ye

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY Vs. w. E. PRESCOTT. 4?

61 Q. How much would it cost to put up a tank?
A. 1 do not know.
Q. Two or three hundred dollars would give you a plenty for the
whole thing?
A. I do not know.
Q. Would that not make it more safe in case of fire?
A. I guess it would make it a little safer.
Q. With an expenditure of two or three hundred dollavs you could
make it more safe,—did you have a watchman there?
A. No, sir.
Q. Had no watchman there?
A. No, sir.
Q. Was there any way to enter that warehouse except by going
through the oflice?
A. No, sir.
Q. A little narrow door?
A. It was not a narrow door.
Q. About three feet wide?
A. Yes, sir; about three and a half feet.
- And you had to go through that door in order to get into the
warehouse?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And if a little fire started at that door it would cut you off from
the warehouse?
A. Which door?
Q. From the office into the warehouse?
A. Yes, sir; if the fire was in there.
Q. There was no way to open any of those doors; they were sliding
doors?
A. You could knock the doors down very easily.
Q. Are not those sliding doors and will not fall?
A. We very often have to pick them up and put them back,
Q. Did they not try to knock them down?
A. That morning they tried ; they knocked one down in the end of
the depot.
Q. Did it take so long?
A. Mr. Johnson said he gave jt one or two licks; I know I could
do it in two or three.
Q. What are those doors put there for?
A. For protection, to keep people out at night.
Q. And you think a door that you could push down in two or three
kicks would keep people out at night?
A. Yes, sir.
62 Q. And if you could give it two or three knocks and knock
it down it would keep people out: if you take a sliding door
can’t you put a lock on the outside: I do not know whether you know
anything about the mechanism of that or not; you do not know that
you could put a lock on the outside that it would make it more safe
that you could not knock it down with half a dozen licks, but could
go and unfasten it on the outside and let it slide?

48 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS, W. E. PRESCOTT.

A. If you had it fastened with a lock, I don’t suppose so, you
could knock it down.
Q. Could you not put a lock on a sliding door and lock it on the
outside and make it safer?
A. You could get into it easier.
Q. In that case you could unlock it and get into it quicker?
A. Yes, sir.
Did you have a ladder to go up on top of that house?
Yes, sir.
Where was that ladder?
At the back end of the depot.
Did you send anyone on there?
No, sir.
What sort of a ladder was it?
. An iron ladder.
Where did it set?
Two ladders nailed together there and hanging on nails,
What sort of a ladder?
. An iron ladder.
Fixed up against one of the posts?
Hanging on nails at the end of the depot.
How long a ladder?
I suppose it was 12 or 16 feet long?
An iron ladder?
Yes, sir.
Hanging on the end of nails inside of the depot?
Outside.
Which end?
The rear end of the depot.
The rear end of the depot?

BOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOPOrOPOProre

Yes, sir.
p And you had some barrels of water around there on the plat-
orm?
A. Yes, sir.
63 Q. And no attempt was made to use that ladder?

A. Not that I know of.
Did you go and see the ladder?
. No, sir; I did not go around to the end of the depot.
You did not go around there at all?
No, sir.
Where did you keep the records and oils and things of that

We kept the oil in an oil house away off from the depot.
Where did you keep the other things, the reports?

In the office and in the warehouse.

. What else did you have in the office besides records?

We had some packages of clothing and things.

Where were they?

In the office.

All of those things were right in the office?

Yes, sir.

POPOPO>OPtoro>ro

sg

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY Vs. W. E. PRESCOTT. 49

(By Mr. Evans:)

Q. Where did you keep your papers and blanks and supplies
that you used?

A. We had them in two places, in the office and Wareroom.,

Q. You heard them testify about the papers being in a bundle;
what were those papers?

A. We had records in the wareroom and also on shelves,

Q. In pigeon holes?

A. Regular shelves; just a month's work, we would lay it on the
shelves.

Q. And after a month’s work was checked up you would file it
away?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And those papers were kept in the wareroom?

A. Yes, sir.

J. W. Peak (white), sworn:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Evans:

Q. What is your business?

A. Merchant.

Q. You receive freight at the Edgefield depot?

Yes, sir.
6-4 Q. What is a reasonable time to get freight?
A. I think they claim about 24 hours.

Q. What is a reasonable time for a man living in the country to
move his freight, or have you had any experience on that?

A. No, sir; not any whatever.

Q. You removed your freight in 24 hours?

A. Not always.

Q. Have you ever allowed your freight to stay there as long as
five days?

A. I suppose I have.

Have you ever allowed it to stay there as long as ten days?

A. I do not remember about that; sometimes you don’t want it

right away and let it stay there a while.
And sometimes you make it the same day.

A. Very often as soon as I get notice.

Q. You have had occasion to go in that depot before it was burned?

A. Yes, sir. I was there every day or two.

Q. What was the condition of that depot as to its being clean and
free from rubbish?
. It always seemed to be in fair condition.
. Was it not a pretty depot?
. I think so.
. Did you ever see any trash piled up in one corner?
Yes, sir; you could see some trash there sometimes,
. Old freight or what?

7—358

OPOPo>

Pact eet ~. wie iA Res a AR HLL VO WATS ER bP mb ee DED A PDS LEN TI BE YS SE NEY RR: AOA A Otae Sih! —_e

50 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

A. There was always freight in there; I do not know about it being
old freight.

Q. You say there was a little trash in one corner?

A. Sometimes you would see a little trash.

Q. What kind of trash?

A. Waste in the depot.

Q. What you saw was corn and grain that was scattered about,
and such as flour that would burst the sack?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. How much would be there of that sort?

A. I never noticed any unusual amount.

Q. As much as a peck?

A. It would be scattered about on the floor; I do not know what

amount.

65 Q. It would be scattered about?
; A. Sometimes it would be piled up while they were sweep-
ing.

©. Preparing to take it out?

A. I do not know what they were going to do with it; I have seen
it swept up there.

Q. And swept up in the middle of the floor?

A. At different places.

Q. Did you not sign a statement in this case?

A. I do not remember.

Q. Do you remember giving Mr. Townsend a statement as to the
condition of affairs down there?

A. Yes, sir; I remember that.

Q. That was the truth when you made it?

A. Yes, sir; as I understood it; I do not remember what the state-
ment was or what it was about.

Q. You testified before, too, did you not?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Were you in that office a day or two before the depot was
burned?

A. I was there every few days.
. Were you there a few days before it was burned?
. I think so; I was there nearly every day.
This office and wareroom were in a clean condition?
They seemed to be.
No old papers or trash on the floor; did you say that?
Yes, sir; I do not know about seeing no trash.
. You wrote that (indicating) ?
No, sir.
It is signed J. W. Peak?
. No, sir; I did not write that; I signed ay name to it.
And you read it before you signed it?
. I suppose I did.
. The day before you went there and there was no trash on the
r of that depot?
Bd I did not notice any.
Q. Did you notice any water barrels there?

Bae ak Ne a ee e
ts RRS CAMS tran ON siete py : » *

paerererarerere

-

SR a PARSE MMOS

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 61

. Yes, sir; I noticed them usually.
. Were they full of water?
. Always full of water.
And had buckets there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. This town has no fire protection?
A. No, sir.
No system of waterworks?
. Nothing only that little tank.
. That is only for the public square?
. Yes, sir.
. It is no general protection?
No, sir.
. And the town has no water supply for the purposes of fire
protection?
A. No, sir.
Q. You say you noticed those water barrels; how many water bar-
rels did you notice around the depot?
A. There were several barrels.
Q. The warehouse and depot were some little distance from the
cotton platform?
Yes, sir.
. They were not connected at all?
. No, sir; there was a street for wagons and buggies to pass.
. It was 30 or 40 feet from the cotton platform to the depot?
. Yes, sir; I expect it was 40 feet.
There were water barrels around the wareroom and depot?
Yes, sir; and on the cotton platform, too.
And the buckets were there with them?
Yes, sir.
. What were they there for, do you suppose?
. I suppose they were there to put out a fire.
. Would or not those barrels on the outside with a fire on the in-
side, would they have been any good if they had been locked up on
the inside?
A. Not if you could not get to them.
Q. Would they be of any use if the doors were locked and they
were on the inside? ;
A. They would not do any good.
Q. Would you put them there to prevent a fire?
A. On the outside.
Q. Do you know anything about the sliding doors there?
A
Q

O>op>

for)
o>

OQPoOro>o

O>OPOrOSroro>

. T know the depot was fastened with sliding doors.
. And it was properly fastened; it was a good depot?
A. I do not know that T have ever been in there after it was
fastened.
67 Q. It was secure?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. It was a wooden depot?
A. Yes, sir; a wooden building.
Q. No one was allowed to store anything in there unless he was

emmemnunta Dips oe an FWA ni Ao! = Meat ON, ee

52 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

going to ship it by freight, you could not take a load of freight
there and say, I want to store it?

A. I never tried it.

Q. Did you ever hear of anyone doing it?

A. No, sir.

Q. This warehouse was for the purpose of the railroad in handling
its freight?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. That was the only place it had to put it?

A. That is all IT know of.

Q. Do vou know vf any other place in town that they have any
fire protection or sprinkler system,—is there a sprinkler system in
your store?

. No, sir.

. Any barrels of water around there?

. Nothing of the kind.

. Is there anything of the kind in town?

. T suppose the factory and Adams’ warehouse.

We know the factory has waterworks of its own?

Yes. sir: and Adams’ warehouse.

And that is furnished by the mill?

Yes, sir.

And that is the only water protection in town against fire?

A. There are a good many people who have windmills and water
tanks: T do not know whether thev have much protection; not any-
thing that I know of.

Q. No public fire protection?

A. Nothing except that little tank out there (indicating).

Q. And the depot is the only place where they have any water
barrels?

A. None that T know of except at the depot.

Q. None in the business part of the town?

A. No, sir.

Q. Did vou ever see a barrel of water with a bucket on it up town?

A. No. sir.
68 Q. Did vou ever seen one between your store and home?
A. There was none that T know of except at the depot.

O>O>Ororo>

Cross-examination.
By Mr. Thurmond:

Q. And the railroad company knew that and did nothing to
prevent it?

A. Tt seems they should have done it.

Q. The agent lived right here in town, and he knew that; they
knew that there were no waterworks in this town?

A. They must have known it.

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT, 53

By agreement the following testimony of Miss Richardson, given
in a former trial, was read:

Miss Ricuarpson (white), sworn:

OPOPO>POPO>PO>roOro

Direct examination.

By Mr. Evans:
What position do you hold with the Southern Railway?

. Clerk-operator.

You are the telegraph operator also?
Yes, sir.

You do all sorts of work in the office?
Yes, sir.

Did you ever deliver any freight?
Yes, sir.

. You have delivered trunks sometimes? —
. No, sir; I never did that.

In what condition was your office kept there?

. It was very neat and clean.

Were there any loose papers around your office?

. No, sir.

Where were your supplies kept: the blanks, and so on; one

witness testified that there was a cupboard or wardrobe in the
warehouse room: was that pigeon holes where your records — kept?
A. They were kept in the office.
Q. And the daily records were kept in the office?

69

POPOPOPOHO>O>PO>O>O

A. Yes, sir.
Q. What was kept in those pigeon holes?
A. Old records.

They were filed?

. Yes, sir,

And placed in there for future use?

. Yes, sir.

They were not left lying around in there?

No, sir.

Was there any pile of trash in that warehouse?

No, sir; no trash.

What did you have there for protection against fire?
Barrels of water and buckets on the barrels.

. Buckets hanging over the barrels?

Yes, sir.
Do you remember how many there were?

. No, sir: T do not remember how many there were.
. Those barrels, so far as you know, were kept full of water?
. Yes, sir.

Do you smoke cigarettes?
No, sir.

AS Si al a SE GE AEE A LOOMED AEDS BOSE BED DLE EON LIE NOTTS LMG a

54 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT,

J. G. Boyp (white), sworn:
Direct examination.

By Mr. Evans:

Q. You were the cotton weigher in the town of Edgefield last year?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you have occasion to go into the depot nearly every day?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. W hat was the condition of the depot as to trash in the ware-
house?
. Fairly good.
Was there any trash in there?
. I never saw any.
And you were there nearly every day?
Yes, sir.
Did you see any trash in the corner?
I did not inspect it; I did not see any.
You never saw it and you were there nearly every day?
Yes, sir.
. If it had been there you would have seen it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You call that in good condition?
A. Fairly good.
. What do you mean by fairly?
. Good.
. Was it not swept every day?
. Yes, sir.
Swept out nearly every day?
T think so.
There was no piles of papers or anything?
T never saw any.
Did you see anything piled up there that was liable to set
fire to anything?
. No, sir.
Were there any protections against fire, any provisions against

~]
fo)
ProroPere>|

PPOPorere

fir
. Nothing more than barrels of water.

. Were there any buckets there?

. Yes, sir.

Buckets on the barrels?

. Yes, sir.

Were the barrels full of water?

. Yes, sir.

They were put there for the protection of the warehouse?
Yes, sir.

And even had them on the platform?

. Yes, sir.

Were those barrels full of water on the 23d of June?

. T could not say about that.

. Did you notice them?

. I never did see them dry; they were always full of water.

POPOP>OPOPOD>O>rOr%O>

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. FE. PRESCOTT. 55

Cross-examination.
By Mr. Thurmond:

Q. As I understand it, in passing to and fro you never noticed
it very closely to see if it was clean, and your eye did not fall on any-
thing that struck you as being trash?

A. No, sir.

Q. In fact, you never noticed especially about it?

A. No, sir.

Q. You never went in and looked into the corners?

A. It was not my business to inspect it at all: I just went in and
out.

Q. You do not deny what these other men said about trash being
piled up there; you do not deny that?

A. No, sir; I said I never saw it,

71 (By Mr. Evans:)

Q. You never saw any such thing?

A. No, sir,

Q. If there had heen any piles of papers and trash you would have
seen it?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. How many doors did that thing have to it?

A. I do not remember,

Q. As many as six?

A. I suppose so.

Q. You do not know anything about how those doors acted or any-
think like that?

A. No, sir.

R. C. Paneer (white), sworn:
Direct examination,

By Mr. Evans:

Q. You live in town here?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. What is your business?

A. Cotton buyer and fertilizer business.

Q. Did you have occasion to go to the depot frequently last sum-
mer?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. What was the condition of that depot as to it being kept clean,
and free from trash and inflammable matter?

A. I do not remember seeing any trash or anything around the
depot on the inside.

Q. If there had been any there you would have seen it?

A. More than apt to have seen it,

Q. Did you see any trash piled up in the corner of that ware-
house?

A. No, sir.

AG SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

Q. Did you ever see any loose paper lying around over the floor?
A. No, sir.
. Has this town any water protection against fire?
A. No, sir.
Q. Nothing except this tank out here?
A. That tank there, and it is just for the square.
Q. Was that or not a comparatively new depot?
A. It was comparatively new,
72 Q. It was the same style one as is there now?
A. Yes, sir; so far as the warehouse is concerned.
Q. About the same as that?
A. The warehouse is about the same.

Cross-examination.

By Mr. Thurmond:

Q. Did you have occasion to go there in the summer much?

A. Yes, sir; I went down there every day after the cotton season
is over and the fertilizer; my fertilizer runs into July and T went
very frequently, and in the summer months I stay around the store
and look after things.

Q. When you went there you went to look after your freight?

A. Mr. Kemp was sick and I stayed around the store.

Q. You never noticed any trash?

A. I was not looking for trash.

Q. You never noticed a lot of paper next to the walls?

A. No, sir.

Q. You overlecked that; you never saw that?

A. I did not see it; I do not remember seeing it.

Q. You do not remember seeing any paper in the pigeon holes?

A. I saw paper in the pigeon holes in the office,

Q. You saw papers there?

A. I saw papers in the pigeon holes in the office.

Q. Did they file the records there in the office?

A. I do not know whether there was any records or not; there
generally was, though.
~ Q. Do you know anything about any gasoline there?

A. No, sir.

Q. You do not know whether there was any there or not?

A. No. sir: I have seen gasoline there, but I think they kept it
on the outside on the platform; T have seen it on the outside.

Q. You have seen it on the outside?

A. Yes, sir.

73 (By Mr. Evans:)

Q. A railroad handles all kinds of freight?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. That was what that depot was for, to keep freight in?
A. Yes, sir.

By agreement the testimony of W. P. Hamilton, given at a former
trial, was read to the jury.

. aes’ ee ne

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 57
W. P. Haminron (white), sworn:

Direct examination.
By Mr. Evans:

. You lived in town here the 4th of last July?
. Yes, sir,
Do you remember the morning that the depot was burned?
Yes, sir.
Was it or not on the 4th of July?
Yes, sir.
Q. You were well acquainted with the depot and the conditions
there?

A. I cannot say that IT was well acquainted, of course, seeing it
from the outside, but not on the inside,

Q. Give me that statement?

A. I only made it in justice to Mr. Townsend.

Q. You were the first man that got to the fire?

A. I was the second; Mr. Townsend crossed the road as I came
around.

Q. Mr. Townsend crossed the road as you started around?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. How far did he live from there?

A. He did not live but a short distance,

Q. About 50 yards?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. And when you got there what was the condition of the depot
and warehouse?

A. There was no chance to have put it out.

Q. If all five of these big doors had been open when you got there

could you have gotten in there to save anything?

74 A. I don’t see how you could; it was burning then and had
almost caught the cars on the railroad track,

OPOPore

Q. It had almost set ure to the coaches then?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did it set fire to the coaches?
A. Yes, sir, and three or four negroes and | run them off.
Q. Did you not use water out of those barrels to put out the fire
on the coaches?
A. Yes, sir; [ used water from the barrels.
Q. The barrels were there with buckets?
A. Yes, sir; I bursted in the coach door to get in.
Q. You had no trouble bursting in that door?
A. A man can burst into most anything if he wants to.
Q. Have you ever been in that depot?
A. Not enough to say much about it.
Q. Just an occasional visit?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you know Mr. Townsend?
A. Yes, sir.
8—358

58 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

Q. Do you know whether he smokes cigarettes?
A. I cannot say.

Q. Or T. L. Timmerman or Miss Richardson?

A. No, sir.

Q. Do any of the three employees in that office smoke cigarettes?
A. I don’t know; they may and I don’t know it.

Q. They are trying to make it appear here that those doors were
not properly fastened; that they ought to be so they could be un-
locked from the outside; how were they fastened?

A. I don’t know; | know they were what I call rolling doors.

Q. Sliding doors?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Is that as safe as a door like this (indicating) ?
A. I think so.
Q. As against thieves is not that the better protection?
A. Yes, sir; I reckon it ought to be against thieves,
Q. Because if you went to batter you would not know
75 where?
A. Because you could batter the hasp off otherwise.

Q. Because they could push off the lock without any trouble and
they could not do that with sliding doors?

A. They would understand where the hinges were and cut them
off. I do not want to be classed a burglar or anything like that.

Q. But those sliding doors are safer than doors that open like this?

A. I think — that opens on the inside is safer than one that opens
on the outside as against burglars.

Cross-examination.
By Mr. Thurmond:

Q. Have you ever examined the doors of the Adams warehouse?

A. Yes, sir; I think so.

Q. And they open from the outside?

A. Yes, sir, they open from the outside; I think they open from
the outside.

Q. The testimony shows——

A. 1 would not say for certain about that; 1 would rather not say,
because I am not certain about that.

Q. Did many rats run out of that house?

A. Yes, sir; a great many.

Q. And big ones?

A. Some large enough to make a good pie; when the building got
to burning they would not stay there. They had to go.

Q. A lot of them run out of there?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Did you notice what papers they kept in the corners, or any-
thing?
A. No, sir; I never had any business except in the office.

ZOSFOSOSOSo>

Miss

Q
A
Q
A
Q
A
Q
A
Q
A
Q
A
Q
A
Q
A
Q
id

d

Or]

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 59

. L. TrmMeRMAN (white), sworn:

Direct examination.
By Mr. Evans:

. You are a clerk at the depot?
A. Yes, sir,
a. Were you working there during June of last year?
. Yes, sir.

. Do ae recall the time that Dr. Prescott’s shoes arrived?

. Yes, sir; some time in June.

. Did you or Mr. Townsend deliver them?

. I think Mr. Townsend delivered them.

. You saw them in the warehouse?

. Yes, sir.

. Do you know whether or not Dr, Prescott sent his team there
after that?

.
.
.

.
.
.
.

A. Water in barrels.
Q. You had buckets there?

_ — “ tic iy Pde Wot 2 Rye eM PR ie
— — FORA QUAPR OI TDS ° . ‘f

. Yes, sir.

. Do you recall how many times?

. Several times,

. What did he carry off?

. Other freight.

. That was freight that arrived after these shoes left?

. Yes, sir.

. The shoes were always left and the other freight taken?
. Yes, sir.

. Who else worked there besides you and Mr. Townsend and
Richardson ?

That is all.

. Do you know whether or not he smokes?

No, sir.

Do you smoke cigarettes?

Not while I am on duty.

You do not smoke down here?

Not on duty.

You do not when on duty?

No, sir.

Did you go to the fire?

Yes, sir.

What time did you get there?

It was burning right along when I got there.

At the top of the roof?

Yes, sir.

Where did you board?

At Mrs. Hill’s, on the hill above the depot.

And you went as fast as you could go?

Yes, sir.

What precautions did you take down there in case of fire; what
you have to stop a fire?

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS, W. E. PRESCOTT,

A. Buckets on the barrels.
Q. Were they inside’or outside?
A. Outside, right at the doors,
Q. Do you know what caused that tire?
A. I do not.
Q. Were there or not any matches in that depot the day before

the fire occurred?

A. Not that I know of.
Q. You do not know whether there were any matches in bulk?
A. I do not remember any being there in bulk; I do not remember

whether there were any in the depot.

oft

he

Q. You know that no cigarette stubs were thrown around in that
ice?

A. T never saw any.

Q. You did not throw any?

A. No, sir; I did not throw any.

Q. What papers, if any, did you keep down there; it is alleged
re that there were loose papers in the warehouse that caused the

fire?

We did not keep any loose in the warehouse,

Were there any loose paper- anywhere?

. I never saw them.

. What sort of a thing did you have for your loose papers?

. A waste basket.

. And your waste papers were put in there?

. Yes, sir; and emptied every day and sometimes twice a day.
What papers did you have in the warehouse?

I do not know of any in the warehouse.

Did you keep any of the old records on the shelves?

Yes, sir; we had some records laid up on the shelves.

Did you keep any blanks or supplies in there?

. I do not think any blanks were in there.

. Were those records in a bundle?

. Yes, sir; tied up.

Was there any trash in any of the corners of the depot?

. No, sir.

Tlow often was it swept?

. Once a day and sometimes twice a day, morning and night; it

SOrOroO>

a
— ORNS

O>ororo>

-

4
.

was swept up the last thing at night,

78

Q. Was there any oil, flour and stuff mixed up in the depot?
A. There was flour, but I do not think there was any oil.
Q. Was the flour mixed with the oil?

. I did not see any.

You brought the flour in in sacks and put it my itself?

Yes, sir.

And the oil was put by itself?

If there was any oil it was outside,

Was there any gasoline there?

. Not that T know of.

. You would have known it?

Qroreore>

iQ BMD PR AER ora yim o

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 61

Yes, sir,

And there was none there?

. Not that I know of.

How many doors were there to the warehouse?

. Five big doors and the door that lead into the office.
The door leading into the office was like this?
Yes, sir (indicating).

And there were five doors eight or ten feet wide?
. Yes, sir,

How were those doors fastened?

They were sliding doors.

POP>PS>POPorop

Cross-examination.
By Mr. Thurmond:

Q. Do you have any idea as to the quantity of freight that passes
through there in a vear: | do not suppose you can form much of
an idea?

A. T could say about the amount of freight received; something
like fifty thousand dollars a year.

Q. That is the charges on the freight?

A, Yes, sir.

Q. What do you do with what you call old hoss freight?

A. Ship it back.

Q. How often do you ship it back?

A. Every six months.

Q. Where did you put it there?

A. 1 do not think we had enough to put anywhere.

Q. When did you make a shipment?
79 A. I do not think there had been any there to ship; we
had shipped it off and the warehouse was clean,

Q. Did vou not at times have right good accumulation there:
where was that put?

A. When it was there it was put in the middle of the warehouse,

Q. In the middle of the warehouse?

A. Yes, sir,

Q. And you have a pretty big pile of it sometimes?

A, Very hardly ever have any to amount to anything.

(By Mr. Evans:)

Q. Why did you put it in the center of the warehouse?

A. We generally packed it where we had the most room.

Q. Was it not your custom and practice to put the merchants’
freight along by the wall where you had their names?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And every man’s freight was put under his name? —

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And the only vacant place was in the middle of the house?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And you put this freight in there?

A, Yes, sir.

62 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT.

J. H. TompxKins, sworn:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Evans:

Q. What position do you hold with the mill?

A. Paymaster and cashier.

Q. Did you or not have occasion to go to the station pretty fre-
quently?

A. Yes, sir,

Q. How often would you say?

A. I would go every day sometimes and maybe a day or two |
would not go.

Q. You went four or five times a week?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And you knew the people there, Mr. Townsend, Mr. Timmer
man and Miss Richardson?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Did you ever see any of them smoking cigarettes while
80 on duty?
A. I ean not recall it; probably I have, but I can not say.

Q. Do you know the condition of that warehouse as to its being
kept clean and in a proper condition for handling freight?

A. It was kept as clean as the average warehouse, and I think a
little more so; in the summer the freight is lighter than in the fali,
and it is usually clean for that kind of a warehouse.

Q. That warehouse was used for freight that comes in and goes
out?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And it is not like the Adams warehouse that anyone could
store freight in?

A. No, sir.

Q. Did you go to the fire?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. What part was standing when you got there”

A. The front of it.

Q. You mean the office?

A. The waiting room part of it: I think the roof was all burned in.

Q. All the warehouse had fallen in?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Do you know what protection or precaution they had taken
against fire?

A. They had barrels full of water, and buckets.

Q. How long do you all generally leave freight there?

A. We generally haul it out as fast as it comes in; we generally
make it a rule to haul freight once a day.

Q. What would you consider a reasonable time to move your
freight?

A. Three days, I suppose. I think that is the time they give you:
I think they charge you storage after 72 hours.

Q. You always got yours out before that time?

PERT red Pein Me ce |

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. W. E. PRESCOTT. 63

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Would you consider it a reasonable time to move it after you
got notice?

A. Yes, sir; I think so,

Q. There are no waterworks in this town for the protection against
fire?

A. No, sir.
81 Q. Nothing except the mill, and that is the only place there
is?

A. Yes, sir; and Adams’ warehouse,

Q. That is protected against fire, is it not?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Is your mill allowed to furnish water to anyone?

A. No, sir; we could not furnish it to anyone, but the Adams ware-
house; when anyone has a fire we are always glad to help them to pro-
tect ourselves if it is in distance.

Q. Is it not a fact that the insurance companies will not allow you
to furnish water on the outside?

A. They will not let us run out of water; we have to keep water
for our own protection.

Q. They will not allow you to furnish it to other parties?

A. No, sir.

Q. And Mr. Adams could not furnish any water except what he got
from you?

-

21

The rule of decision in the Federal Courts, which it is
submitted was a right and privilege the plaintiff in error
could claim under the Act, required the Court to charge
the law as laid down in those decisions instead of charging
it with regard to the burden of proof as he did or in
attempting to follow the rule of the Supreme Court of the
State of South Carolina. The most recent decision on this
subject was the Central Vermont Railroad € ‘ompany vs.
White, reported at 238 U. S., page 507. This was a case
under the Federal Employer's Liability Act, brought in the
State of Vermont, where the burden of proof respecting
contributory negligence rested upou the plaintiff and not
upon the defendant; whereas the rule under the decisiens
of the United States Supreme Court placed this burden on
the defendant. The Court, in disposing of this question,
finds as follows:

“But it is a misnomer to say that the question as to the
burden of proof as to contributory negligence is a mere
matter of State procedure. For, in Vermont. and in a
few other States, proof of plaintiff’s freedom from fault
is a part of the very substance of this case. He must not
only satisfy the jury (1) that he was injured by the neg-
ligence of the defendant, but he must go further, and, as
a condition of his right to recover, must also show (2)
that he was not guilty of contributory negligence. In
those States the plaintiff is as much under the necessity of
proving one of those facts as the other, and as to neither
can it be said that the burden is imposed by a rule of pro-
cedure, since it arises out of the general obligation im-
posed upon every plaintiff to establish all of the facts
necessary to make out his cause of action. But the United
States courts have uniformly held that, as a matter of
general law, the burden of proving contributory negli-
gence is on the defendant. The Federal courts have
enforced that principle even in trials in States which
hold that the burden is on the plaintiff.

“Washington & G. R. Co. ve. Gladmon, 15 Wall., 401
(1), 407, 408, 21 L. ed., 114-116; Hough vs. Texas & P.
R. Co., 100 U. S., 225; 25 L. ed., 617; Jnland and Sea-
board Coasting Co. vs. Tolson, 139 U. S., 551 (4), 557,
35 L. ed., 270, 272, 11 Sup. Ct. Rep., 653; Washington &
G. R. Co. vs. Harmon ( Washingion &: G. R. Co. vs. Tobri-

TAL AP SAE IT oh A BS NNER Dy BS in io a

At SAO PEEP 0 SSE ORION AD eR ENB 4 ote as OP

22

ner), 147 U. S., 581, 37 L. ed., 288, 13 Sup. Ct. Rep., 557;
Hemmingway vs. Ill. Cr. Co. 52 C. C. A. 477, 114 Fed.,
843. Congress in passing the Federal Employers’ Liabil-
ity Act, evidently intended that the Federal Statute
should be construed in the light of these and other deci-
sions of the Federal Court. Such construction of the
statute was, in effect, approved in Sezboard Air Line R.
Co., vs. Moore, 228 U. S.. 434, 57 L. ed., 907, 33 Sup. Ct.
Rep., 580. There was, therefore, no error in failing to
enforce what the defendant calls the Vermont Rule of
Procedure as to the burden of proof.”

Story on Bailments, Section 410, lays down the follow-
ing rule as to the burden of proof of negligence:

“The question may here arise, as in many other cases
of bailment, upon whom lies the burden of proof of negli-
gence or of repelling it? With certain exceptions, which
will hereafter be taken notice of, as to innkeepers and com-
mon carriers, it would seem that the burden of proof of
negligence is on the bailor, and the proof merely of loss is
not sufficient to put the bailee on his defense,”

The general rule on this subject was given a r.gPitney
in the case of Sweeney vs. Ewing, 228 U.8., 233, where he
sums it up as follows:

“The general rule in actions of negligence is that the
mere proof of an ‘accident’ (using the word in the loose
and popular sense) does not raise any presumption of
negligence; but in the application of this rule it is recog-
nized that there is a class of cases where the circumstances
of the occurrence that has caused the injury are of a char-
acter to give ground for a reasonable inference that if
due care had been employed by the party charged with
care in the premises, the thing that happened amiss would
not have happened. In such cases it is said, res ipsa
loquitur, the thing speaks for itself; that is to say, if
there is nothing to explain or rebut, the inference that
arises from the way in which the thing happened, it may
fairly be found to have been occasioned by negligence.

“The doctrine has been so often invoked to sustain the
refusal by trial courts to nonsuit the plaintiff or direct a
verdict in favor of the defendant, that the application of

SS OT SINT RE me peer ate , ’ . we ~ ecg

PES. CA TIOE LS AOR ISEB Sp Cee NG LPI OIE KIB CISION BERET RM CE Nal Pe mL Dre aa? oma |

23

the rule, where it does apply, in raising a question for the
jury and thus making it incumbent upon the defendant to
adduce proof if he desires to do so, has sometimes been
erroneously confused with the question of burden of
proof. But in the requested instruction now under con-
sideration, the matter was presented in no equivocal form.
Plaintiff's insistence was not merely that the evidence of
the occurrence of the injury under the circumstances was
evidential of negligence on defendant's part, so as to
make it incumbent upon him to present his proofs; the
contention was that it made it necessary for him to prove.
by a preponderance of the evidence, that there was an
absence of negligence on his part. hi

“In our opinion. res ipsa loquitur means that the facts
of the occurrence warrant the inference of negligence ;
that they furnish circumstantial evidence of negligence
where direct evidence of it may be lacking, but it is evi-
dence to be weighed, not necessarily to be accepted as
sufficient ; that they call for explanation or rebuttal, not
necessarily that they require it; that they make a case to
be decided by the jury, not that they forestall the verdict.
Res ipsa loquitur, where it applies, does not convert the
defendant’s general issue into an affirmative defense.
When all the evidence is in, the question for the jury is
whether the preponderance is with the plaintiff.

“Such, we think, is the view generally taken of the
matter in well considered judicial opinions.”

PED YEE, FT ROR: SERN in, Beto

To the same effect see:

Southern Rwy. Co., Carolina Division, rs. Bennett, 233
U.S., 80.

This is also the doctrine of Mr. Freeman’s nete in
Schmidt vs. Bland, 24 Am. Dee., 153, reviewing the author-
ities as to the burden of proof in bailment cases.

It will thus be seen that whether the shipment was held
by the carrier as a carrier or warehouseman, the rule of
law for determining the liability, and where the prepon-
derance of testimony should be, is that prescribed by the
Federal Courts, and when the State Courts attempted to
try the case under State laws as to where the burden of
proof rested, there was a contravention of the right of the
plaintiff in error, under the Federal Statutes and decis-

Ri paws. - ‘ sy : ‘ ee

oo ae a lo ere - blather, "apal

ei eed a te ane

ions, for which he is entitled to a hearing and reversal in
this Court.
BENJAMIN L. ABNEY,
FRANK G. TOMPKINS,
Attorneys for Plaintiff in Error.

APPENDIX.

THE ACT TO REGULATE INTERSTATE COM-
MERCE.

Sec. 1. (As amended June 29, 1906, April 13, 1908, and
June 18th, 1910.) “That the provisions of this Act shall
apply to any corporation or any person or persons en-
gaged in the transportation of oil or other commodity,
except water and except natural or artificial gas, by means
of pipe lines, or partly by pipe lines and partly by rail-
road, or partly by pipe lines and partly by water, and to
telegraph, telephone, and cable companies (whether wire
or wireless) engaged in sending mesages from one State,
Territory, or District of the United States, to any other
State, Territory, or District of the United States, or to any
foreign country, who shall be considered and held to be
common carriers within the meaning and purpose of this
Act, and to any common carrier or carriers engaged in
the transportation of passengers or property wholly by
railroad (or partly by railroad and partly by water when
both are used under a common control, management, or
arrangement for a continuous carriage or shipment), from
one State or Territory of the United States or the District
of Columbia to any other State or Territory of the United
States or the District of Columbia, or from one place ina
Territory to another place in the same Territory, or from
any place in the Uniled States to an adjacent foreign
country, or from any place in the United States through
a foreign country to any other place in the United States,
and also to the transportation in like manner of property
shipped from any place in the United States to a foreign
country and carried from such place to a port of trans-
shipment, or shipped from a foreign country to any place

val anger oe tt et ee isn heen renee eee

PA DE AY CES STH PFO BN Leh a NP aint.

25

in the United States aad carried to such place from a port
of entry either in the United States or an adjacent foreign
country: Provided, however, That the provisions of this
Act shall not apply to the transportation of passengers or
property, or to the receiving, delivering, storage, or hand-
ling of property wholly within one State and not shipped
to or from a foreign country from or to any State or
Territory as aforesaid, nor shall they apply to the trans-
mission of messages by telephone, telegraph, or cable
wholly within one State and not transmitted to or from a
foreign country or to any State or Territory as aforesaid.”

By the Hepburn Act it was declared that the term trans-
portation—

“shall include cars and other vehicles and all instru-
mentalities and facilities of shipment or carriage, irre-
spective of ownership or of any contract, express or
implied, for the use thereof and all services in connection
with the receipt, delivery, elevation, and transfer in tran-
sit, ventilation, refrigeration or icing, storage and han-
dling of property transported; and it shall be the duty
of every carrier subject to the provisions of this Act to
provide and furnish such transportation upon reasonable
request therefor, and to establish through routes and just
and reasonable rates applicable thereto.”

LITRE A BEM NE NINE OT LIS At RNR aS i tN Ho SEGALL NING ORI

" be ,

0

TABLE OF CASES.

P

Adams Express Company ys. Ky., 206 U. S., 136......
Boston & M. R. Co. ys. Hooper, 233 U. 8., 97........
Charleston & Western Carolina Railway Co. ys. Varn-
ville Furniture Co., 237 U. S., 597..............
Carr vs. Railway Co., 194 U.S......................
Clark vs. Railroad, 12 How., 272 et ons CREE POE ee
Memphis Railroad vs. Reese, 10 ey BOOS oes kes ek

Sweeney vs. Ewing, 228 U.8.,233...................

STATUTES.
Section 1 of Interstate Commerce Act, as amended by

Act of June, 1906

GE

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

OCTOBER TERM, 1915.

No. 826.

SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY, Plaintiff in Error,
vs.

W. E. PRESCOTT, Defendant in Error.

IN Error ro THE SUPREME Cour?T OF SourH CAROLINA.

Brief for Plaintiff in Error Opposing Motion to Dis-
miss or Affirm.

SENJAMIN L. ABNEY AND FRANK G. TOMPKINS,
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF IN ERROR.

Statement of Plaintiff in Error.

The writ of error asks a review of a judgment of the
Suppreme Court of South Carolina, filed September 28,
1914, affirming a judgment of the Court of Common Pleas
for Edgefield County, South Carolina, in which judgment
had been entered on the verdict in favor of the defendant
in error.

The record for this court has not yet been printed,
although transcript has been filed. For that reason, refer-
ence herein to the evidence and findings of the Cireuit and

2

Supreme Courts of South Carolina will be made to the
Case filed in the Supreme Court of the State of South Caro-
lina for the April Term, 1914, which we understand is on
file in this case, for the purpose of this motion.

It appears that a shipment of thirteen boxes of shoes was
made over the Southern Railway from Petersburg, Vir-
ginia, to Edgefield, South Carolina, arriving at Edgefield
on the 23d day of June, 1913. The following day an agent
of the defendant in error called at the depot of the plaintiff
in error for the freight, and, on account of the crowded
condition of his wagon, carried away only four of the thir-
teen boxes, though he paid the freight at that time for the
entire shipment, leaving the other nine boxes in the posses-
sion of the plaintiff in error to be called for later. The
defendant in error did not call for the said boxes previous
to the 4th day of July, 1913, and on said day the freight
house, or store room, of the plaintiff in error, with all of its
contents, including the said boxes, was burned down.

The defendant in error demanded payment for the loss,
which was refused. He then brought his suit, on three
causes of action, which are set out in the Case for Appeal
at pages 2 to 10, inclusive.

The answer of the plaintiff in error set up, after a gen-
eral denial of the material allegations of the complaint,
that the plaintiff in error was a railroad engaged in inter-
state commerce within the provisions of the Act of Con-
gress to regulate interstate commerce and amendments and
supplements thereto controlling and governing interstate
railroads, and that the shipment in question was an inter-
state shipment and should be governed by the Act of Con-
gress of 1887, and various amendments and supplements
thereto. (See page 11, Case for Appeal.)

At the close of the case for the defendant in error, plain-
tiff in error moved for a nonsuit or direction of verdict and
the following colloquy and ruling occurred :

“Mr. Evans: We ask your Honor for a nonsuit or
the direction of a verdict under the first count in the
complaint as to common carrier. The evidence here

3

shows that the freight arrived here on the 23d of June,
and that the freight was paid and receipted for by the
agent of Dr. Prescott. He came for it and paid the
freight; and I submit that where a common carrier
delivers freight in good order, and has it in its depot
and paid for, then its liability as a common carrier
ceases,

“And, further, there is no evidence going to show
negligence, from which the jury could infer negligence
as set out in the complaint.

“The Court: You are on the first count?

“Mr. Evans: Yes, sir; that they are liable as insur-
ers.

“The Court: And they can only be relieved from
that by an act of God ora public enemy.

“Mr. Evans: I see the grounds of negligence in the
warehouse transaction are set out in the first cause of
action and as a common carrier; they are both the
same, exactly.

“Mr. Thurmond: There is no negligence in the first
cause of action at all.

“Mr. Evans: We ask your Honor for a nonsuit on
the whole business. There is no testimony to show
that they are liable as a common carrier.

“The Court: We will wait until the testimony is all
in; yon know when you are on actions of this kind, the
Supreme Court looks for a scintilla, and that is a very
small thing; when the testimony is all in I will give
my decision as to directing a verdict. Go ahead.”

At the close of the case the attorney for the defendant in
error withdrew his cause of action against the plaintiff in
error, aS a Common carrier, and his cause of action for the
penalty and asked for judgment on an alleged cause of
action against the plaintiff in error as warehouseman, at
which time the following argument and ruling occurred :

“Mr. Thurmond: The plaintiff withdraws his cause
of action against the defendant as a common carrier
and withdraws his cause of action against the defen-

4

dant for the penalty, and the case proceeded to trial
only on the cause of action against the defendant as a
warehouseman.

“Mr. Eve s: We will ask for a verdict on the other,
as he has withdrawn the actions for the penalty and
as common carrier.

“The Court: It is on the question of a warehouse-
man.

“Mr. Evans: We take the position that under the
Interstate Commerce Commission Rules, as adopted
and published by the railroads, that the bill of lading
which my friend has introduced in evidence, we are
entitled to have the action as to the warehouseman dis-
missed ; we think we are entitled to have your Honor
instruct the jury that the contract between Dr. Pres-
cott and the railroad company, as contained in this
bill of lading, is the law. The bill of leding was the
contract under which the railroad accepted this
freight. We take the position that the bill of lading
is the law and the contract in this case, and that we
are entitled to a verdict.

“The Court (after hearing arguments): Go to the
jury, gentlemen.”

Upon the close of the arguments to the jury, the Court
delivered the following charge: (See pages 91-92, Case for
Appeal.)

After verdict for the defendant in error, the attorney
for the plaintiff in error moved for a new trial on the
ground that the Court had held that there was no Federal
question raised in the case, and had charged that the bur-
den was on the plaintiff in error to prove that there was no
negligence on his part in the loss of the goods; whereas
the burden of proof, under the Federal Act, was on the
defendant in error to prove negligence on the part of the
carrier before he could recover, and there had been no such
negligence shown.

The trial Judge admitted that he had charged the jury
that the Federal decisions were not binding, that he was

5

trying the case under the South Carolina decisions. (Pages
96-97, Case for Appeal. )
This case was appealed to the Supreme Court of South
Carolina and an opinion was rendered affirming the judg-
ment of the Court below.

In the said opinion the Court, after finding the facts
substantially as stated here, held that the attorney for the
plaintiff in error had conceded that the contract of earri: ige
had ended, and that the plaintiff in error held the goods
by a separate contract, which prevented the liabiilty of
Plaintiff in error as a common carrier or warehouseman
under the Federal Statute from bei ing considered by that
Court, in the following words:

“The defendant claims that inasmuch as this is an
interstate shipment, the Federal Statute governs.
This question does not legitimately arise in this case
for the reason that the appellant moved for a nonsuit
on the ground that ‘the evidence here shows that this
freight arrived here on the 23d of June, and that the
freight was paid and receipted for by the agent of Dr.
Prescott. He came for it and paid the freight, and I
submit that where a common carrier delivers fre ight
in good order, and has it in its depot and paid for,
then its liability as common carrier ceases,’ The Court
reserved its decision on that qu

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386003_0124%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
