# Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Bianchi v. Perry

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386002_0855%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Petition for Writ of Certiorari
- **Published:** January 1, 1996
- **Citation:** 516 U.S. 1094

## Text

or ae

Supreme Court,

U.S,

D

No. NOV 29 1995

CLERK

IN THE ;
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1995

M. BIANCHI OF CALIFORNIA,
PETITIONER

Vv.

WILLIAM J. PERRY, SECRETARY OF DEFENSE,
RESPONDENT.

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

Robert A. Brunette

4443 Chevy Chase Drive

La Canada Flintridge, CA 91011
(818) 790-0956

Attorney for Petitioner
M. BIANCHI OF CALIFORNIA

QUESTIONS PRESENTED FOR REVIEW

1. Whether it is in the public interest to strongly incentivize future
defense contractors to submit cost saving Value Engineering Change Proposals
(VECPs) under future contracts, by paying a fair, contractually agreed to
portion of initial cost savings to Petitioner from his military garment
fabrication suggestions which have saved the government over $1.5 billion
to date (as uncontested to by the sovernment at trial).

2. Whether the U.S. government-drafted contract Value Engineering
Incentive (VEI) clause should be liberally interpreted to carry out the mutual
intent of the parties, as testified to under oath, that the government would
share cost savings 50-50 (over a three year royalty period) with the Petitioner
on all future affected end-item procurements which used his VECP
suggestions.

3. Whether these important and farreaching questions of federal law
concerning the standard VEI clause used in every Government contract should
be settled by the Supreme Court rather than the U.S. Court of Appeals for the
Federal Circuit, which recently held (contrary to the language of the clause)
to severely limit VECP royalties to future purchases of the same end items as
purchased in the contract under which the VECP was submitted.

Opinions Below ..---- +++ 7°" bes v deed ae br eeeeenrnnpees*" ]
ceannenaits Oh PUMNOD «ous cen 0 8 FON EETR PSST |
Government Regulations TE OS ei ds, lah aia l
secniamnanih af GSEs ca Uo ete die U9 CON 2
Reasons For Granting den Pe. isn soo ndaw CROMER Ee IE 7

1.

Conclusion

The Value Engineering Incentive (VEI) Clause Will No Longer Provide
Contractors With An Incentive To Submit VECPs To The Government
If It Is Interpreted So Narrowly As To Negate The Government Stated
Purposes Of The Clause And A Reasonable Reading Of The Royalty
Sharing Provisions Of The Clause... ccscccccceresesneeere’ 8

A Liberal Interpretation of the VEI Clause’s Royalty Sharing Provisions
Will Benefit The Government And Makes Sense..----+s+0 7°" 10

The Supply Contract VEI Clause Literally Contemplates Royalties For
“Concurrent” and “Future” Contracts Which Occur After Performance
Of The “Instant” Contract Has Been Completed, And Should Be Treated
Differently Than The Construction Contract VEI Clause..------ 11

Under the Cardinal Rule of Contract Interpretation a Contractor's
VEI Clause Should Be Uniformly Interpreted To Carry Out The
Mutual Intent Of The Parties. The MBOC Interlining Decision
Threatens That Principle For Government Contractors ------: 12

MBOC Submitted Uncontradicted And Overwhelming Proof Into
Evidence At The Trial That VECP No. 2181 Was Accepted By The
Government, The Specification Was Changed To Incorporate
MBOC’s VECP Non-Woven Fusible Interlining Suggestion, And
That Other Contractors Did, In Fact, Implement MBOC’s Suggestion
On “Future” COMMCts. ..-.scccresernnereer ces e8E o 14

eee Se ene nn aa
Appendix: Page

A. Opinion of U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit

B. Opinion of the U.S. Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals 24

C. Order On Rehearing, U.S. Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit .. 6]

D. Judgment, U.S. Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit

E. Armed Services Procurement IS Sa eee 66

F. Memorandum of U.S. Army R&D Center (Natick, MA), Oct.26,1979
(Roy Roth, Chief Fiber & Fabric Technology Branch) ....... 78

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Cases: Page
AID Request for Decision, B-210103, 83-2 CPD 9116 (1983) ........-- 12
BE Goodrich Co. v. United States, 398 F.2d 843 (Ct.Cl. 1968) .......-. 11

Gulf Apparel Corp., ASBCA No. 27784, 89-2 BCA $21,735 (1989)... 8,11
John J. Kirlin, Inc. v. United States, 827 F.2d 1538 (Fed. Cir. 1987). . 2,8,9,11

Julius Goldman's Egg City v. United States, 697 F.2d 1051

(Fed. Cir. 1983) 0... .. 2 cece cere cece cece eee cece eeeeerenesees 12,13
M. Bianchi of California, ASBCA No. 36518, 93-2 BCA §25,801 (1993),
aff'd mem. CAFC No. 93-1402 (Feb. 16, 1994)......--.ee eee eeeee 3,5,8
M. Bianchi of California, ASBCA Nos. 37029 and 37071, 93-1 BCA $25,309
(July 31, 1992) vacated 31 F.3d 1163 (Fed. Cir. 1994) .......--.---: 2,3,8
M. Bianchi of California, ASBCA Nos.37395 et al., 94-1 BCA 926,417
(Sept. 30, 1993), affirmed 61 F.3d 920 (Fed. Cir. 1995) .....-.----- 1,3,5,8
Northeastern Mfg. & Sales, Inc., ASBCA No. 38307, 90-1 BCA
922,562 (1990)... 0. ee ere ccceecccccerecscreerecerererscesers 11
Philco-Ford Corp., ASBCA No. 16197, 73-1 BCA 49917 (1973) ....-.. 1]
Randolph Engineering Co., ASBCA No. 4872, 58-2 BCA 92053 (1958) ..... 12
State of Arizona v. United States, 575 F.2d 855 (Ct.Cl. EE a kawyevs oes 12
Thanet Corp. v. United States, 591 F.2d 629 ee, er 12

Umpqua River Navigation Co., ENGBCA No. 3881, 78-1 BCA
913,051 (1978)... cece cere ccc cccecccvcncccseeecressceeceees 1]

W.R. Johnson, Inc., ASBCA Nos. 40251 et al., 91-3 BCA
WDA 1T2 CIDP). wo cc cccccccncvrevenccccavecsessserenssaveres 1]

Statutes: Page
28 U.S.C. § 1254(1) Courts of Appeal; Certiorari: Certified Question ..... l

41 U.S.C. § 605 Decision by Contracting Officers; Review ............. 3

41 U.S.C. § 606 Contractor's Right of Appeal to Boards of Contract Appeal .... 3

41 U.S.C. § 607 Agency Boards of Contract PE Cen dbcanetearieoe. 3
Regulations:
ASPR § 1-1703.1 Acquisition Savings ............................. l
ASPR § 1-1706 VEI Sharing Arrangements ...................... 1,1]
Pir | FARA VET NR ani 5 5 hiss Sook Be cee l
ASPR § 7-602.50 Value Engineering Incentive - Construction .......... 1]
Secondary Authorities:
J. Gabig & C. Cook, A Guide To Interpreting Contracts, 23 NCMA Journal, No.
bb cecneah MELE ET ee Oa nD 13
S. Williston, A Treatise on the Law of Contracts, § 618 (3d ed je 12
D. Fulghum, Aviation Week & Space Technology 76 (November 6, 1995) .. 7
BRIEFING PAPERS (January 1994) .............................. 8
2 Steiger, Federal Contract Management, DE ey ee 1]
Il Nash & Cibinic, Federal Procurement Law 1194 (3d ed.1980) ...... 2,11
CCH, Government Contract Reports, Jom Dl: Sen ee 1]
36 The Government Contractor, eee ee eee 9
R. Nash, VALUE ENGINEERING: Another Illusory Promise?, 9 THE NASH
& CIBINIC REPORT, No. 3 §20 (March ET OT a OOO Rae eae 10
M. Clancy & V. Antonocci, view: i

ircui ions, 24 Public Contract Law Journal,
areca hes, SR ES OI EE Ch SD ROT Hie 9

IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1995

M. BIANCHI OF CALIFORNIA,
PETITIONER
v

WILLIAM J. PERRY, SECRETARY OF DEFENSE,
RESPONDENT.

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT

M. BIANCHI OF CALIFORNIA, the Petitioner herein, respectfully prays
that a writ of certiorari issue to review the judgment of the United States
Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, entered in the above-entitled case
on July 21, 1995.

OPINIONS BELOW |

The July 21, 1995 opinion of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal
Circuit, whose judgment is herein sought to be reviewed, is unpublished
(except as to notice of affirmance at 61 F.3d 920), and is reprinted in the
attached Appendix A to this Petition, at p. 17. The prior opinion of the U.S.
Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals, entered September 30, 1993, is
reported at 94-1 BCA 926,417, at page 131,405; and is reprinted in the
attached Appendix B to this Petition, at p. 24.

STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION

The judgment of the Court of Appeals was entered on July 21, 1995.

The jurisdiction of this Court is invoked pursuant to title 28, U.S.C. § 1254(1).
GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS INVOLVED

This case involves the following, government Value Engineering Incentive
(VEI) regulations in the Armed Services Procurement Regulation (ASPR),
as superseded by the Defense Acquisition Regulation (DAR), and currently
the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR): ASPR § 1-1703.1 and .2 (entitled
“Acquisition Savings” and “Collateral Savings”, respectively); ASPR Clause
7-104.44, subparagraph (e) (entitled “Sharing”); and ASPR 1-1706,
promulgated by Defense Acquisition Circular (DAC) #76-26, which identifies
the “Sharing Arrangements” for all affected end items for supply and services
contracts and for construction contracts. These regulations are reprinted in
pertinent part in Appendix E, at p. 66.

l

eae

VX

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

1. Background

The Value Engineering Incentive (VEI) clause is a provision common to
all government contracts. The Department of Defense (DoD) pioneered value
engineering in 1961 through regulatory policy and clauses, which were revised
in 1964, 1967, 1974 and 1977.' The DoD attempted to provide sufficient
incentive to induce supply and services contractors to submit cost savings
ideas, called Value Engineering Change Proposals (VECPs), to the DoD by
promising to pay the contractor 50% of the government's cost savings (for an
initial 3 year royalty period) for its use of essentially the same item (i.e., the
VECP suggestion) in all “affected” end items in instant, concurrent and future
contracts of the procuring activity. The government keeps all cost savings
beyond the 3 year royalty period. Engineering development or low rate initial
production contracts (such as a “production test” or “limited production”
contract), use a future royalty cost sharing period which is the highest 36
consecutive months of planned government production when the VECP is
accepted.

The VEI Clause was quite literally intended to strongly incentivize
contractors to submit cost savings ideas to the DoD. However, when it comes
to actually compensating the submitter of a VECP Suggestion once its
received, the government is often tempted to hold down awards by setting up
two hurdles which tend to prevent the submitter from receiving a reasonable
reward...or any reward at all, as in this case.

First, the government agency can simply hold up review or approval or
implementation of the VECP until after the submitter’s “instant” contract is
fully paid for and closed out...and the contractual relationship has ended.?

Secondly, even if the VECP is accepted and implemented into the instant
contract, the procuring agency (or the Federal courts) can narrowly interpret the
language of the VEI Clause so as to only allow VECP royalties on concurrent or
future contracts for the “the same” military garment as initially supplied by the
submitter. They deny any reward for hundreds of thousands of other “affected
end-item” garments purchased by the government on future contracts which utilize
the very same VECP idea.

The “net” result is an extremely disenchanted and disincentivized
contractor who is not about to submit another cost savings idea to the DoD.

This results in exactly the opposite result than the drafters of the VEI Clause
intended.

' II Nash & Cibinic, Federal Procurement Law 1194 (3d ed. 1980)
* John J. Kirlin, Ine, v. United States, 827 F.2d 1538,1541 (Fed.Cir.1987); and M. Bianchi
of California v, Perry, 31 F.3d 1163, 1167-68 (Fed.Cir.1994).

2

ee

The Federal Circuit has recently established this narrow interpretation,
which is contrary to the weight of lower court ASBCA case precedents which
urge a liberal interpretation favoring contractors so as to maximize future
VECP submissions. This is an important question of first impression which
the Supreme Court has never addressed, and is too important to leave with
the Federal Circuit.

2. The Bianchi VECPs
M. BIANCHI OF CALIFORNIA (MBOC), is a sole proprietorship. In
1979 and 1980 MBOC was competitively awarded three contracts by the
DLA’s Defense Personnel Support Center, in Philadelphia, PA (DPSC) for
the production of U.S. military garments in various amounts. MBOC’s first
contract was for 43,000 Navy enlisted men’s raincoats, the second contract
was for a production “test” run of 26,250 Air Force women’s pantsuit coats,
and the third contract was for “limited” production of 125,240 Army men’s
all weather coats.

MBOC was informed by the DPSC of their VEI Program even before he
bid on these contracts, and each contract contained the VE] clause (identified
in their Master Contract Terms as the JO9 Clause). He subsequently submitted
eight VECP’s, five of which are the subject of this appeal, all of which were
denied any sharing of cost savings by the DPSC. MBOC submitted claims
for all of these VECPs which DPSC failed to respond to, such that in 1988
MBOC appealed them to the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals
(ASBCA) under the jurisdiction of 41 U.S.C., § § 605(b), 606, and 607. The
ASBCA severed the appeals into three VECP categories for hearings:

(a) The Stitching claim (VECP 8680), for about $6 million, which eventually
resulted in an ASBCA award of $58,613.03, plus interest.’

(b) The Boxes claims (VECPs | 180 and 8780), for about $30 million, for
which the ASBCA denied any award, and which the Federal Circuit vacated
and remanded to the ASBCA*‘; and

(c) The Interlining. Gimp Thread and Label claims (VECPs 1280, 1380,
2181, 2880, and 3380) for about $207 million, for which the ASBCA denied
any award, and the Federal Circuit affirmed’, and is the subject of this Petition.

This appeal involves the third category of VECP claims. Three of the
VECPs (3380, 1280 and 2181) suggested changing expensive woven, fusible
interlining (in collars, cuffs, etc.) of military garments for a new European
style Pellon #SG4 13/#8325 series nonwoven fusible interlining, which could

> M_ Bianchi of Califomia, ASBCA No. 36518, 93-2 BCA 25,801 (Feb.10,1993),
aff'd mem CAFC No. 93-1402 (Feb.16, 1994)

‘ M Bianchi of California, ASBCA Nos. 37029 & 37071, 93-1 BCA $25,309 (July
31,1992), vacated 31 F.3d 1163 (Aug.10,1994)

SM _ Bianchi of California, ASBCA Nos. 37395 et al., 94-1 BCA {26,417
(September.30, 1993), affirmed 61 F.3d 920(July 21,1995)

3 ,

be fused to the military garment via Pellon’s new “point seal” process, saving
substantial labor and material costs per garment, as well as collateral storage
and handling costs.

This suggestion was repeatedly submitted by MBOC (on all three
contracts) at a time when the government's fusible interlining program was
at an absolute “standstill” (on October 26, 1979). Appendix F, at p.78, contains
a government memorandum that confirms this fact.

Samples of Mr. Bianchi’s new Pellon interlining fabric were tested at
the U.S. Army Research & Development Center, Natick, MA from July 1979
(on the Navy garment contract) through written acceptance of the same Pellon
interlining suggestion (VECP 2181) on March 31,1981, and incorporation
into the third MBOC contract as a change to the manufacturing interlining
component specification for the Army’s all weather coat.

At the ASBCA Hearing on April 20-23,1992 MBOC submitted 41
changed U.S. military garment specifications into evidence (without
government objection, or subsequent contradiction), 28 of which now require
“mandatory use” of nonwoven fusible interlining components (i.e., Pellon
SG#413/#8325 or equivalent), and 13 which allow nonwoven fusible
interlinings as an alternate component.

Another idea (VECP 1380) suggested substituting inexpensive cotton
V-T-280 button thread for silk thread around the gimp of buttonholes for the
Air Force’s pantsuit coats. This VECP was also expressly accepted by DPSC
on May 20, 1980 and November 3, 1980 in contract changes to the garment
specification. At the ASBCA Hearing on April 20-23,1992 MBOC submitted
32 changed U.S. military garment specifications into evidence (again without
government objection, or subsequent contradiction) all of which now require
cotton V-T-280 button thread as a “mandatory requirement”.

A third idea (VECP 2880) suggested substituting one garment label which
combined size and identification information (previously included on two
labels) on the Air Force’s garment. This suggestion was denied by the DPSC
onApril 2, 1980. However, the DPSC constructively accepted this suggestion.
At the ASBCA Hearing during April 20-23,1992 MBOC submitted 13
changed U.S. military garment specifications into evidence (without
government objection, or subsequent contradiction), 7 of which require
“mandatory” use of MBOC’s suggestion.

MBOC asked the ASBCA for concurrent and future contract “acquisition”
savings and “collateral” savings on all affected U.S. military end-items
wherever the VECPs were used on buttonholes and interlinings, and wherever
separate labels were combined, and that required the above changed
specifications. During the ASBCA Hearing on April 21-23,1992 the cost
quantum savings were demonstrated by MBOC via uncontradicted testimony
of three expert witnesses who authenticated one hundred (100) separate

4

volumes of evidence concerning DPSC’s future contract procurements and
cost savings data, calculations and reports, which in total cumulated to be
about 15 feet thick. The government was simply overwhelmed and did not,
in fact, contest any of MBOC’s quantum evidence, it simply contested
MBOC’s entitlement to any cost savings under its interpretation of the
language of the contracts’ JO9 Value Engineering Clause. That is a fact.
Government counsel even stated that they would beat MBOC on the
entitlement issue, not the quantum of damages issue.

MBOC experts testified as to engineering, labor savings and extended
life cycles for each “affected” end-item specification. MBOC also submitted
uncontradicted evidence of the procurement history of each “affected” end-
item garment (and its underlying specification) over the applicable royalty
period. This evidence included voluminous back-up documentation obtained
by government computer data analysis of two databases (called “Haystack”)
which provided MBOC’s experts with information on DLA military garment
contracts for each “affected” end-item specification from as far back as 1980
through the Hearing in 1992. The ASBCA had previously found this database
analysis to be a completely satisfactory, and a fair method for MBOC to
identify quantities of “affected” end-item specifications in his first Hearing
on the Stitching appeal.°

Uncontradicted proof submitted into evidence by MBOC at the ASBCA
Hearing demonstrated that BIANCHI’s interlining VECP suggestion alone
generated over $350 Million in acquisition and collateral savings over the
initial 3 year royalty period. This resulted in an uncontested interlining
quantum claim of $176,825,130.00.’ The subsequent 10 year period has
been “royalty free” to the government, and should have generated an additional
$1.1 Billion or more of additional savings...a little over $1.5 Billion of total
savings to date.

At the ASBCA Hearing the government introduced two witnesses which
strongly supported MBOC on his entitlement to these royalties. Mr. Bruce
A. Snigger, Senior Textile Technologist at the Natick, MA test lab, testified
on April 28,1992 that the government tested MBOC’s new Pellon nonwoven
fusible interlining samples and that they exhibited “unique properties...that
would perform as [DPSC] wanted it to”, and he wouldn't have accepted VECP
2181 otherwise.

Further, Ms. Susan Lynn Caso, DPSC’s Value Engineering Specialist
(who was present as the government’s consultant during the entire 9 day
trial) testified on April 27, 1992 that when a component...such as “buttons,
threads, cloth, zippers, slide fasteners...” were changed as a part of an accepted

* M._ Bianchi of California, supra note 3, at pages 128,403 and 129,405
’ M. Bianchi of California, supra note 5, at page 131,417.

5

VECP and it is used in an affected end-item garment (other than in the instant
contract), then the contractor would receive royalties on the use of his VECP
“component specification” in all affected “end-item specifications”.

This testimony was in harmonious agreement with Mr. Bianchi’s trial
testimony concerning DPSC’s Standard JO9 VEI Clause...i.e., that MBOC
would be compensated for its interlining and thread component VECP
Suggestions, once approved by the DPSC, which are used in all affected end-
item garments procured by DPSC on future contracts within the royalty period.
This was also identical to Ms. Caso’s testimony on March 1, 1991 in the
earlier ASBCA Hearing in MBOC’s Stitching claim.

Nevertheless, the ASBCA rejected MBOC’s claims. holding as a matter
of law that the doctrine of constructive acceptance does not apply to three
VECP claims (3380, 1280, 2880), and that even though VECP 2181 was
accepted by the DPSC it wasn’t “implemented” in the instant contract SO as
to have a unit cost reduction (under the instant contract) to apply to concurrent
or future contract savings. Therefore, the ASBCA erroneously concluded
that there is no legal basis for MBOC to recover future contract Savings
(contrary to the language of the VEI clause).

Further, the ASBCA rejected the fact that MBOC had submitted “new”
interlining suggestions (VECPs 1280, 3380 and 2181), even though internal
DPSC and the Natick, MA laboratory documents and government testimony
conclusively established otherwise. DPSC had “accepted” VECP 2181 asa change
to the interlining specification because it was new, unique and it worked.

Incredibly, the ASBCA also held that the record shows “no evidence” of
any changed military specifications, nor cost savings... regardless of MBOC’s
unchallenged submission of days of expert testimony and 100 volumes of
cost data, analysis and reports that proved to the contrary.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed the ASBCA
on July 21, 1995, stating that there was no constructive acceptance by DPSC
of VECPs 3380, 1280 and 2880. It also narrowly interpreted the JO9 VEI
Clause to mean that MBOC could only recover for the use of the VECP 2181
nonwoven, fusible interlining on future DPSC contracts purchasing essentially
the same [end] item garment (ie., the same Army all weather coats)...but that
since no contractor ever implemented VECP 2181 on future contracts, no
royalties were due MBOC. This finding was incorrect, and the entire record
proved it.

The Federal Circuit declined to address MBOC’s VECP 1380 (cotton
gimp) appeal by completely ignoring it in its July 21st Decision.

REASONS FOR GRANTING THE PETITION

Petitioner MBOC was a seasoned commercial garment manufacturer in
1979. He was recruited by his local Long Beach, CA Congressman to enter
into the government arena after Mr. Bianchi made a speech to local
businessmen and government personnel. He was told that DPSC had no
major supplier for uniforms West of the Mississippi River. He brought with
him a competitive eagerness, and a certain sense of patriotism...plus valuable
ideas from his commercial experience.

He quickly visited DPSC in Philadeiphia and was informed of their VEI
Program. They told him if he submitted VECPs, and they were used by the
Government that he would share in the cost savings. DPSC used examples.
If he suggested a new inexpensive type of uniform “button” then, MBOC
would share in all savings from its use on all types of uniforms that DPSC
buys. Another example was “black dye”. If MBOC submitted a better, cheaper
dye, then wherever it was used he'd share in cost savings. A strong incentive
to submit VECPs to be sure. :

MBOC took the government’s words to heart. He bid, and won, a DLA
contract for a Navy enlisted men’s raincoats in rather quick fashion in the
summer of 1979. MBOC immediately applied for a VECP suggestion for
replacing the specification’s collar, sleeve and facings with a new Pellon
SG#413 nonwoven, fusible “interlining” that used a point seal fusing process
developed and patented for the commercial industry by the Pellon Corporation
in West Germany. It had never been used anywhere in the United States. He
submitted Pellon fabric samples for testing with the VECP.

He submitted the same suggestion four more times over the next 15
months on his initial Navy garment contract, and also on two additional
competitively awarded DLA contracts for Air Force and Army garments.
DPSC thoroughly tested the new interlining at its Natick, MA laboratory
during that period and finally approved his fifth interlining VECP (No. 2181)
on March 31, 1981...over 20 months after the suggestion was first submitted
by MBOC.

That exceptional nonwoven, fusible interlining suggestion has reaped a
phenomenal cost savings for the U.S. Government since it was formally
implemented by DPSC into MBOC’s contract. The government saved over
$350 million in the first 3 year (royalty) use period...and over $1.5 billion to
date. This is the equivalent to eight new C-17 airlifter aircraft.

Wasn’t this precisely what the VEI Program was intended for?

However, there is a dark side of the MBOC story. MBOC hasn’t been
paid for his suggestion.

* — D. Fulghum, Aviation Week & Space Technology 76 (Nov.6, 1995)
7

As surely as I write this Petition, and as you read it, the outcome of
MBOC’s 15 year quest for a reasonable reward will have an important impact
on the VEI Program for the entire defense industry and all government cost
savings incentive programs.

The MBOC trilogy’ of VEI cases are being closely followed by the defense
industry in periodical articles and timely commentary. The Federal Circuit first
established a restrictive case precedent on the VEI Clause in 1987.° Its three
subsequent MBOC decisions (in 1994 and 1995) have, I believe, eroded away
any remaining credibility in the VEI Program that the DoD may have left.

This Court has never before been asked to decide how it would stimulate
defense contractors via the VEI clause. The ASBCA has generally ruled that a
liberal interpretation favoring royalty compensation should be encouraged in order
to achieve maximum savings ideas for the Government! The incorrect interpretation
of the Court of Appeals misreads the language of the clause and will effect a
contrary result. Defense contractors are extremely concerned about it. There are
special and important public reasons for this Court to hear the issue before its
impact is felt throughout the government's cost savings incentive programs.

1. The Value Engineering Incentive (VET) Clause Will No Longer Provide
Contractors With An Incentive To Submit VECPs To The Government
If It Is Interpreted So Narrowly As To Negate The Government Stated
Purposes Of The Clause And A Reasonable Reading Of The Royalty
Sharing Provisions Of The Clause Itself

It is fair to say that the Bianchi trilogy'*of VEI clause cases are being
closely followed by the defense industry. To date notable legal commentators
on MBOC’s cases have universally lamented that this is no way to incentivize
contractors! Recent 1994-95 published comments on the Bianchi decisions
have intoned (and I quote verbatim):

“As a matter of policy, the Government should find some way (by
amendment to regulations or endorsement of the implied contract theory)
to pay contractors when the Government utilizes the ideas in a value
engineering proposal on subsequent contracts. The Government’s policy
is to encourage value engineering. It is difficult to find a way more
calculated to discourage value engineering proposal preparation and
submission than to let the Government ‘appropriate’ contractor’s ideas
without payment.”?

* — M. Bianchi of California, supra notes 3, 4 and 5
John J. Kirlin v. United States, supra note 2
Gulf Apparel Corp., ASBCA No. 27784, 89-2 BCA 421,735 (1989), at p. 109,266
M. Bianchi of California, supra notes 3, 4 and 5
BRIEFING PAPERS. (January 1994), pp. 32-34.
8

“Indeed, if the Government as a policy matter really wants to encourage
contractors to generate cost savings (as many senior policy making
officials have often stated), one would have thought it could have achieved
the same result by being receptive to a more liberal interpretation of the
current VEI’ clause language than it seems to have been in cases like

Bianchi. having resisted that approach, however, it may well be that the

value engineering program unless it is willing to revise the VEI’ clause
to eliminate language that can be interpreted to discourage contractors
from spending the money needed to generate the ideas the Government
says it wants.”'* (emphasis added)

“Although the court’s decision ultimately offered Bianchi another limited
chance to prove its case, the inherent unfaimess in the court’s reliance
on Kirlin will not promote contractors’ faith in the VECP process... While
the general concept that contract completion extinguishes the
Government's right to accept a VECP is a simple, bright-line rule for the
Government, contractors and reviewing tribunals to follow, it ignores
the inequities that exist when the Government simply reject a VECP,
waits until the termination of the contractual relationship, and accepts
the same proposal offered by another contractor or independently initiates
the change on its own, allowing the Government to avoid compensating
the original developer of the savings ‘concept’.”

“The court did not discuss Bianchi’s Value Engineering clause in detail;
however, the clause’s unambiguous statement that acceptance of the VECP
could occur ‘within a reasonable time after performance has been
completed under this contract’ could have provided the necessary

springboard for undoing what appeared to be an injustice to Bianchi- ed
(emphasis added)

“One of our earliest criticisms of a decision of the U. S. Court of Appeals
for the Federal Circuit was in

Value Engineering: The Federal Circuit
Kicks a Wounded Dog, 1 THE NASH & CIBINIC REPORT, Para. 93.

We took offense at the holding in John J. Kirlin, Inc. v. ULS., 827 F.2d
1538 (Fed.Cir.1987),...that Government use of the idea in a value

engineering change proposal was not compensable if it occurred after
‘completion’ of the contract. We concluded that this was poor value

‘* 36 The Government Contractor, (Sept.21,1994)
‘SM. Clancy & V. Antonacci,

1994 Year In Review: Analysis of Significant Federal Circuit
Government Contracts Decisions, 24 Public Contract Law Journal, No. 2 (Winter 1995),
pp. 201-202

9

contract clauses were not operative after completion. The latter

assumption is clearly ridiculous and would wreak havoc if applied
generally. For example, what would it do to the Government’s rights
under the ‘Patent Rights’ or ‘Rights in Technical Data’ clauses? Where
would it leave the Disputes’ clause? Need we go on?” (emphasis added)

“It_ seems to us that this is a case of winning a battle but losing the
war...Government wins by making arguments that work against its best
interest. The Bianchi decision greatly reduces the incentive of concurrent
and future savings that the “Value Engineering” clauses give to contractors
to induce them to submit VECPs. This is particularly true in the case of
agencies that do not process VECPs promptly - where almost the only

incentive is concurrent and future savings. a ane ee nee re
willi tt Vv *'6 (emphasis added)

Mr. Ralph Nash, a highly respected legal educator, author, and consultant
to government and industry, puts the issue in the proper perspective...the
government has won the battle but will surely lose the war.

If this Court orders that Mr. Bianchi should be paid for the actual use of
his interlining VECPs in all “affected” military end-item garments the
beneficial result to the government would be dramatic. When word of a
positive Decision is announced to the defense contracting community it is
reasonable to expect a flood of cost savings suggestions.

This issue is of exceptional importance to the defense community, the
public and the government, particularly as the fallout from decades of deficit
budgets and deficit spending critically impacts our ability to fund essential
government programs. The government needs every cost savings idea now
more than any time in recent history.

2. A Liberal Interpretation of The VEI Clause’s Royalty Sharing
Provisions Will Benefit The Government And Makes Sense

The principle that when in doubt “liberally” interpret all VEI Clauses in
favor of royalty compensation should be encouraged. In an earlier case before
the ASBCA the DPSC was specifically advised that its VECP program
requires “open handed and ever generous administration” if it is to achieve
maximum savings ideas for the government, stating:

“If the sharing provisions were to be interpreted and administered strictly

with an eye to holding down rewards, the incentive to propose or urge

© R. Nash, VALUE ENGINEERING: Another Illusory Promise?, 9 THE NASH &
CIBINIC REPORT, No. 3 420 (March 1995), pp. 42-43

10

adoption of money-saving devices and procedures would be eliminated,

the flow of suggestions would dry up, and the program would die.”"’

This principle goes back almost 30 years at the ASBCA. Industry

comments on the Bianchi cases (quoted above) are strongly in favor of liberal
interpretation as the way to positively encourage VECPs. It is in the public
interest for this Court to consider the benefit of such a liberal policy before
the Court of Appeals conclusively establishes the latest Bianchi decision as
a major roadblock...which may fatally undercut that common sense public
policy and the intent of the current clause.
3. The Supply Contract VEI Clause Literally Contemplates Royalties
For “Concurrent” and “Future” Contracts Which Occur After
Performance Of The “Instant” Contract Has Been Completed, And
Should Be Treated Differently Than The Construction Contract VEI
Clause

The Federal Circuit applied its holding in John _J. Kirlin Inc. v. United
States, 827 F.2d 1538 (Fed.Cir.1987), a “construction” contract case, to the
VEI clause contained in MBOC’s three “supply” contracts. Although the
Kirlin opinion doesn’t otherwise identify the clause, the standard construction
contract VEI clause does not allow any cost sharing for acquisition savings
other than on the “instant contract”."*

Further, the December 15, 1980 DAC #76-7% -ersion of the VEI clause
explicitly states in ASPR § 1--706.1(b) that °(s,"aring on construction
contracts applies only to savings on the instant contract.” [see Appendix E}

In Kirlin, from the onset, the defense contractor never had any legitimate
“expectation” of future or concurrent or collateral savings if a VECP was
submitted. Conversely, MBOC’s “supply” contracts contained a different
VEI clause. Under the sharing provision of MBOC’s JO9 (VEI) clause, the
government explicitly provided for not only instant savings, but for future
and concurrent savings as well.

The Federal Circuit’s reassertion of the Kirlin holding in the latter two
Bianchi cases works an extremely harsh result.

‘7 Gulf Apparel Corp., ASBCA 27784, 89-2 BCA 421, 735 (1989) at 109,266. See also
Philco-Ford Corp., ASBCA No. 16197 BCA 49917 (1973), at 46,493; Northeastern
Manufacturing and Sales, Inc., ASBCA No. 38307, 90-1 BCA 422,562, (1980), at
113,229; W.R. Johnson, Inc,, ASBCA Nos. 40251 et al., 91-3 BCA 924,172 (1991).

at 120,913; and B.F, Goodrich Company v. United States, 398 F.3d 843,848
(Ct.C1.1968).

ASPR § 7-602.50 (entitled “Value Engineering Incentive-Construction”); If Nash &
Cibinic, Federal Procurement Law 1194 (3d ed. 1980); cf. 2 Steiger, Federal Contract
Management, $8.05[3}[a], note 5(19993); CCH Government Contract Reports,

£21,700 at p.10,401 (Feb.2,1992); accord Umpqua River Navigation Co,, ENGBCA

No. 3381, 78-1 BCA $13,051 (1978), at p, 63,740

1]

adele Radaetiins. Sine Mena

ot Gl at EH IFN MN el

The net effect of the Boxes VECP Decision last August 1994 coupled

with the instant Interlining VECP Decision is to kill “constructive acceptance”
possibilities for supply and service contractors. As indicated by several
defense industry commentators, this could perpetuate poor value engineering
policy and poor government contracting policy because it actually discourages
contractors from submitting VECPs. The public has to important an interest
in this concept not to have a hearing, and this Court’s reconsideration of the
negative implications of this precedent.
4. Under the Cardinal Rule of Contract Interpretation a Contractor’s
VEI Clause Should Be Uniformly Interpreted To Carry Out The Mutual
Intent Of The Parties. The MBOC Interlining Decision Threatens That
Principle for Government Contractors.

Hearing testimony by the government’s VECP expert witness, Susan
Caso, on April 27, 1992, and Mr. Bianchi himself earlier in the trial, indicate
that they both interpreted the DPSC’s Standard JO9 Clause in harmonious
agreement...i.e., that MBOC’s Pellon nonwoven, fusible interlining and cotton
thread component VECP suggestions, once approved by the DPSC, would
be compensated for all end-item garments procured by the DPSC on future
contracts which have incorporated his VECP suggestions within the royalty
period. Further, Ms. Caso’s testimony was identical one year earlier in the
MBOC Boxes VECP claim Hearing.

This interpretation was not only mutually understood by both parties,
but it gives a fair and reasonable interpretation to all parts of the JO9 Clause.
including that language concerning cost sharings royalties for “all affected
end-items”, which language was completely ignored by the Federal Circuit
in its July 21, 1995 opinion (and its earlier Boxes opinion onAugust 10,1994).

Prior case law in the Federal Circuit indicates that contract language
should be interpreted as a whole so as to harmonize and give meaning to all
of its provisions and the parties understanding of the clause as shown by
their conduct before the controversy. Under the cardinal rule of contract

interpretation the contract must be interpreted to carry out the mutual intent
of the parties."

In the Julius Goldman's Egg City v. United States” the Federal Circuit

interpreted the party’s mutual intent, via the entire contract, stating:

19 . e .

v. Uni , 6997 F.2d 1051,1057 (Fed.Cir.1983);
Thanet Corp. v, United States, 591 F.2d 629,633 (C1.C1.1979): Randolph Engineering
Co,, ASBCA No. 4872, 58-2 BCA $1053 (1958), at p.867; izona v. Uni

States, 575 F.2d 855,863 (Ct.Cl.1978); AID Request for Decision, B-210103. 83-2
CPD 4116 (1983), citing S. Williston, A Treatise on the Law of Contracts, (3d ed
1961) § 618; and J. Gabig & C. Cook, A Guide To Interpreting Contracts, 23 NCMA

Journal, No.1 (1989) p.1.

y. Uni , Supra note 19.
12

“Contract interpretation has been consistently viewed as a harmonizing
process in which the various parts of a disputed contract are to be
construed as a whole to give meaning to all of its provisions. In State of
Arizona v. United States, 575 F. 2d 855,863 (1978), the Court of Claims
held that: “[w]e follow the established general rules that provisions of a
contract must be so construed as to effectuate its spirit and purpose, that
' a

iV visions, and that an interpretation which
gives a reasonable meaning to all parts will be preferred to one which
leaves a portion of it useless, inexplicable, inoperative, void, insignificant,
meaningless, superfluous, or achieves a weird and whimsical result.”*'

(emphasis added)

Two Air Force officers recently wrote an excellent article on the law of
government contract interpretation.” They state, “the cardinal rule is the
highest rule of contract interpretation”, and that a judge must ascertain the
mutual intent of the parties as manifested in the contract, including evidence
of oral testimony.”

Ms. Susan Caso, the Government’s Value Engineering Specialist (the
Government's expert consultant during the entire 9 day trial) testified under
oath on April 27, 1992 that when a VECP suggestion for new component
items such as “buttons, threads, cloth, zippers and slide fasteners” are used
by the Government in an “end item” (other than on the instant contract) then
the contractor would share in cost savings for the use of his “component
specification” in all “affected” end item specifications.

In the Boxes VECP claim Hearing, on March 1, 1991 Ms. Caso similarly
testified while under direct examination by Government counsel:

“BY MS. ZIMMT-MACK:

Q.

Q. Under what circumstances?

A.
J wirement.

Q. As in your discussion of the webbing, is that correct?

A. That’s correct.” (emphasis added) ASBCA No. 36518 Transcript page
5-42.

21 ld.

2 See Generally, J. Gab & C. Cook. A Guide To Interpreting Contracts, 23 NCMA
Journal, Issue No. 1, page 55.

3 Id, note 4.

13

ye

oF Sa a ae (I te el ll

i ae et ee

9 AREY SE

yes

—————————

Ms. Caso had testified earlier in the day that a change in the construction
of “webbing” would be an example of a component VECP suggestion that
automatically resulted in its incorporation into other end items for royalty
purposes:

“Q. Would you explain a value engineered component?

A. Well, a value engineered component indicates that at the time that
the approval is loaded into the contracting tech data file, that one
action taken to incorporate it into the file resulted automatically in
the incorporation of a valued engineered component in other items.
Wells, explain what the component would be?

An example of a component would be if a contractor were to
ti webbing, if he
recommended using a shutteless loom construction in lieu of a shuttle
machine to make the webbing. When the change is loaded into the
contracting technical data file, it is loaded in for the webbing. By
loading those changes in for the webbing, anywhere that webbing is
a referenced document in some end item --
In other words, anywhere the webbing is used to make the end item?
Exactly. Anywhere that one action resulted in the incorporation of this
VE into other items, because it was listed as a component.” (emphasis
added) ASBCA Nol 36518 Transcript, pages 5-13 and 5-14.

MBOC’s VECP 2181 interlining suggestion is a component VECP
Suggestion (like webbing). The Government’s above-quoted interpretation
in that circumstance would allow him royalties when that new component
was used “for items other than the end-item which he ori ginally had a contract
for”. That was the mutual intent of the parties. This interpretation gives
reasonable meaning to all parts of the JO9 Clause.

This Court of Appeal’s finding interpreted only the words “essentially
the same items”. It ignored the words “all affected end items” in Clause JO9
and, thereby, rendered them wholly imperative, meaningless and superfluous.
That result will no doubt be confusing to the defense contractor community.

Contractors won't believe what the VEI clause Says even if its rewritten

by DoD if the courts continue to misconstrue it in order to the limit recovery
of royalties. Again, this Court has the opportunity to correct this farreaching
interpretation which undercuts the VE] Program.
5. MBOC Submitted Uncontradicted And Overwhelming Proof Into
Evidence At The Trial That VECP No. 2181 Was Accepted By The
Government, The Specification Was Changed To Incorporate MBOC’s VECP
Non-Woven Fusible Interlining Suggestion, And That Other Contractors
Did, In Fact, Implement MBOC’s Suggestion On “Future” Contracts.

At theApril 1992 ASBCA Hearing MBOC’s expert witnesses authenticated
100 thick volumes of MBOC’s Trial Exhibits of applicable garment contracts,

14

> O

» O

specifications calculations and analysis regarding “future” Government
contracts. This evidence was almost 15 feet in width. Three expert witnesses,
in addition to Mr. Bianchi, testified over 3 days at the Hearing and introduced
these one hundred Trial Exhibits into evidence without Government objection:

Wi Date Trial Exhibi
James W, Sutherland,Ph.D. 04/21/92 Nos. 1000-1039
Nos. 1049-1073
Nos. 1080-1092

George Davidson 04/22/92 No. 1094

Peter Elliott, CPA 04/23/92 Nos. 1040-1042
No.1074
No. 1093

MBOC thoroughly briefed the Court of Appeals concerning these
Exhibits, but did not include all the 100 volumes supporting cost savings
evidence into the Joint Appendix on appeal before the Federal Circuit because
it would have overloaded the Court Clerk. Nevertheless, under Fed.R. App.
P., Rule 30 (a) this evidence is a part of the Court’s record even though
they’re not phycially included in the Appendix on appeal.

As to Mr. Davidson, MBOC included his entire 233 page report in the
Appendix on appeal. As to Mr, Elliott, MBOC included only Trial Exhibit No.
1042 (concerning VECP 2181 calculations) which itself was 154 pages long.
Each of Mr. Elliott’s 4 other supporting Trial Exhibits were just as lengthy.

As to Dr. Sutherland, MBOC introduced into evidence no less than
ninety-four (94) separate and distinct Trial Exhibits...one for each military
specification for each of five VECPs that implemented MBOC’s VECP
suggestions. Due to the sheer number of these 94 volumes we could not
include them in the Joint Appendix on appeal; and we told the Federal Circuit
this. MBOC briefs contained a 4 page list of these 94 Trial Exhibits.

In particular, Trial Exhibit 1029 details government contracts for the
“identical” Army allweather coat that implemented MIL-C-44030 changes
due to MBOC’s VECP 2181 (i.e., non-woven fusible interlining) suggestion.

Trial Exhibit 1029 contains 217 pages of very detailed evidence on
specific “future” contracts for the identical item by contractor name, DLA
contract number, quantity, price, dates, SRC and DD numeration. MBOC’s
VECP 2181 was implemented in identical Army coat contracts, at a cost
savings alone of almost $30 million.

There is no competent evidence to support the ASBCA’s contrary findings on
this damages issue, nor the Federal Circuit's endorsement of this erroneous fact.

The Government submitted no contrary evidence whatsoever during the
April 21-28, 1992 ASBCA Hearing. It consciously chose to ignore the

15

quantum of damages. The Government also did not dispute this fact in its
brief before the Federal Circuit.

What level of VECP proof will ever satisfy a federal court? Is the court
system simply stuck on the “size” of MBOC’s potential royalties, rather than the
phenomenal size of the cost savings to date? MBOC’s royalties (if compensated
in full) would only equate to about eleven percent (1 1%) of the total cost savings
benefit realized by the government as of today. Again, defense contractors will
be frustrated and disincentivized when they learn about the level of proof that
MBOC entered into evidence only to be denied any recovery.

CONCLUSION
WHEREFORE, Petitioner respectfully prays that writ of certiorari be
granted for the Supreme Court to consider and decide this important federal
question.

S/

Robert A. Brunette

4443 Chevy Chase Drive

La Cafiada Flintridge, CA 91011
(818) 790-0956

Attorney for Petitioner
M. BIANCHI OF CALIFORNIA

APPENDIX A

OPINIONS BELOW:

U.S. COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT
ON JULY 21, 1995

17

a
Poy —————— .

* AG omg eer

aT a ee COC PCCCCOERE DER O RCO ERO RO OH CbeCeCe
4 NOTE: Pursuant to Fed. Cir. R. 47.6, this disposition is not citable as z
¢ precedent. It isa public record. The disposition will appear intables ¢
$ published periodically. bs
a

United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit

94-1166

M. BIANCHI OF CALIFORNIA,
Appellant,

v.

William J. Perry
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE,
Appellee.

DECIDED: July 21, 1995

Before RICH, NEWMAN, AND RADER, Circuit Judges.

RICH, Circuit Judge.

DECISION

M. Bianchi of California (MBOC) appeals the September 20, 1993 decision
of the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals (ASBCA or board) in
ASBCA Nos. 37395, 37798, 42243, 42244, and 42416 (consolidated), denying
MBOC royalties based on five Value Engineering Change Proposals (VECPs),
We affirm.

18

DISCUSSION

MBOC is a government contractor for military garments. This appeal
involves three contracts and five VECPs. Three of the VECPs suggest
changing the interlining in specific military garments from a woven material
to PELLON, a nonwoven fusible material. Of the other two VECPs, one
Suggests changing the type of thread around button holes, and the second
suggests combining size labels in specific garments.

MBOC submitted five claims to the Contracting Officer. A final decision
was never issued, and MBOC took five separate appeals to the board where
they were consolidated. Before the board, MBOC asked for concurrent,
collateral, and future contract savings on all items with button holes, wherever
nonwoven fusible interlining is used, and wherever separate labels are
combined claiming that they all meet “essentially the same items” clauses of
the contracts. MBOC seeks royalties, from 1988 to 1990, of approximately
$180,000,000 for these suggestions.

The board unanimously rejected MBOC’s claims holding as a matter of
law that the doctrine of constructive acceptance does not apply to MBOC’s
claims, that no instant or concurrent savings were created by MBOC’s VECPs,
and that the Value Engineering Incentive (VEI) clause does not provide for
collateral savings. Below is a table relating the contracts, the VECPs, and
the board’s findings.

Contact # Description | VECP No. |Description | ASBCA Findings
DLA-100-79-C-| Navy 3380 Change a) rejected by
2894 raincoats: interlining _| gov.
ordered from fusible
43,000 with woven b) not
option for material to | implemented
21,500; PELLON on
delivered men’s NAVY | c) none of the
43,952; raincoats. future
contract contracts
terminated were for
for default “essentially
on 10/29/81. the same
items”

19

Contact # Description | VECP No.| Description |ASBCA Findings
DLA-100-80-C-| Air Force Change a) rejected by
2290 women’s interlining —_{ gov.
pantsuit from hair,
Coat: wool, rayon, |b) not
ordered or cotton to | implemented
26,250; gov. fusible
considered PELLON on |c) none of the
performance women’s Air | future contracts
complete on Force were for
12/9/80. pantsuit “essentially
coats. the same items”
Change a) none of the
thread for | future contracts
buttonhole _| were for
gimp on “essentially the
women’s Air |same items”
Force pantsuit
coats from
silk to
polyester.
2880 Combine a) rejected by
separate gov.
size labels
on women’s |b) not
Air Force implemented
pantsuit.
Cc) none of the
future contracts
were for
“essentially
the same items”

Ne Te

Contact # Description | VECP No. |Description ASBCA Findings
DLA-100-80-C-| Army men’s | 2181 Change a) accepted by
2972 all weather interlining | gov.
coat: ordered from fusible
125,240, woven b) not
delivered material to | implemented,
25,903; PELLON on | therefore no
contract men’s Army | future
terminated all weather | contract
for default coat. royalties
in late *81.
c)contract
MIL-C-44030
was for
“essentially
the same
items,”
however no
suppliers used
the suggestion
within the
available
window,
therefore no
royalties are
available

The Contracts Disputes Act (CDA) states the standard for this court’s
review of decisions from agency contract appeals boards as follows: |
(T]he decision of the agency board on any question of law shall not
be final or conclusive, but the decision on any question of fact shall
be final and conclusive and shall not be set aside unless the decision
is fraudulent, or arbitrary, or capricious, or so grossly erroneous as
to necessarily imply bad faith, or if such decision is not supported by
substantial evidence.

41 U.S.C. § 609(b) (1988); See Federal Data Corp. v. United States, 911 F.2d
699, 702 (Fed. Cir. 1990).

Although MBOC enumerates sixteen issues on appeal, we find it
necessary to address only those issues that are dispositive.

2!

—————————

(ct pe Fee Te

ive alae VeRO Rei . lend Br EA Lah es

Nee Nie eh Rete ee We

In its opinion, the board thoroughly evaluated the legal and factual basis
for its determinations, which provide several alternative grounds for
nonallowance of all the VECPs at issue.

All three contracts at issue include the same VEI clause. Its pertinent
language is as follows:

If the VECP accepted under this contract is used on future purchases
of essentially the same items by the purchasing office, or its successor,
the Contractor shall share in the savings .... (emphasis added).

From the above language, it is clear that the VECP must be accepted
under the contract for allowance of royalties thereunder. As noted in the
table above, the board found that three of the VECPs had been rejected by
the agency, Nos. 1280, 2880, and 3380. MBOC, however, asserts that VECP
Nos. 1280, 2181, 2880, and 3380 were “constructively accepted” by the
agency when it allegedly implemented the “concepts” of these proposals in
future contracts and therefore, it is entitled to future royalties. The government
argues that MBOC’s theory of constructive acceptance was properly rejected
by the board.

The provisions of the VEI clause limit a contractor’s recovery of cost
savings arising from the agency’s adoption of a VECP to instances where the
VECP 1) is accepted by the agency, 2) is implemented on the instant contract,
and 3) requires the issuance of a change to the contract. See John J. Kirlin v.
United States, 827 F.2d 1538 (Fed. Cir. 1987). The board, in applying Kirlin,
found that VECP Nos. 1280, 2880, and 3880 were specifically rejected by
the agency and thus constructive acceptance was not a viable theory for
entitlement. Subsequent to the board’s findings, this court reaffirmed the
board’s application of the reasoning in Kirlin, which limits constructive
acceptance to cases where the contractual relationship has not ended. M.
Bianchi of California v. United States, 31 F.3d 1163, 1167 (Fed. Cir. 1994)
(“If the government rejects the proposal in good faith and the contract
terminates, the VECP terminates with the contract.”). We affirm the board’s
decision,holding that the agency rejected VECP Nos. 3380, 1280, and 2880
without bad faith before termination, as supported by substantial evidence
and based on proper application of the legal requirements for constructive
acceptance. Although the board found that VECP No. 2181 had been accepted
by the agency, it concluded that MBOC had not established entitlement to
royalties on the basis discussed below.

MBOC’s claim for future royalties also requires interpretation of the
“essentially the same items” language in the VEI clause. MBOC argues that
the “essentially the same items” language means the “components” in the
military clothing, such as thread, interlining, and labels for use on any military
items having such components, and not the particular garment that is the
subject of the contract. This court, however, has recently interpreted this

22

(lla ig

same language from one of the contracts at issue here to mean “[t]he ‘items’
referred to in the contract are the ones manufactured and shipped pursuant to
the contract.” M. Bianchi of Cal. at 1168. The “essentially the same items”
language refers to the items purchased under the contract and not to the
component parts thereof. Because the board’s interpretation in the instant
appeal is consistent with this court’s precedent, we affirm.

After careful review of the record, we hold that there is substantial
evidence to support the board’s findings that either none of the future contracts
were for “essentially the same items” or, in the case of VECP No. 2181, no
contractor ever implemented the suggestion. Therefore, MBOC is not entitled
to royalties on any future contracts.

23

Seti ena itch Tne bile

APPENDIX B

OTHER OPINIONS:

ARMED SERVICES BOARD OF CONTRACT APPEALS
ON SEPTEMBER 30, 1993

ARMED SERVICES BOARD OF CONTRACT APPEALS

Appeals of -- )
)
M. Bianchi of California )
) ASBCANos. 37395 37798 42243
) 42244 42416
Under Contract Nos. )

DLA100-80-C-2290)
DLA100-80-C-2972)
DLA100-79-C-2894)

APPEARANCE(S) FOR THEAPPELLANT: Michael A. Hordell, Esq.
Laurel A. Heneghan, Esq.
Petrillo & Hordell
Washington, DC

APPEARANCE(S) FOR THE GOVERNMENT: Thomas Hornak, Esq.
Chief Trial Attorney
John M. Logue, Esq.
Patricia A. Papas, Esq.
Trial Attorneys
Defense Personnel
Support Center (DLA)
Philadelphia, PA

N N Vv

After being awarded three contracts for the production of articles of
clothing for the military services, appellant submitted five value engineering
change proposals (VECP’s) thereunder which it contends the Government
accepted directly or constructively and for which it now seeks royalties of
approximately $180 million, as follows:

25

ASBCANo, VECPNo, Contract Description of VECP
37395 1380 DLA100- — Change thread for

80-C-2290 _ buttonhole gimp on
women’s pantsuit coats
from silk to polyester’

37798 1280 DLA100- Change interlining of
80-C-2290 women’s pantsuit coats
from hairwool, rayon, or
cotton to Pellon
non-woven material

42243 2181 DLA100- Change interlining of
80-C-2972 men’s all weather coats
from fusible woven
material to Pellon fusible
non-woven material

42244 3380 DLA100- — Change interlining of
79-C-2894 enlisted men’s raincoats
from fusible woven
material to Pellon fusible
non-woven material

42416 2880 DLA100- — Change from separate size
80-C-2290 and identification labels
for women’s pantsuit
coats to one combined
label
Quantum, as well as entitlement, is at issue in each of the appeals.

VECP 1380 also contained a proposed change to use Oncore or cotton
thread for all body construction of the coats instead of polyester and
silk thread (finding 23, infra). However, appellant declared at the hear-
ing of these appeals and thereafter that it was no longer pursuing its

claim with regard to that proposed change (tr. 1/17-18; app. posthearing .
br. at 79, 312).

26

I. The Contracts
A. Contract No. DLA100-7-C-2894

1. On 13 July 1979, the Defense Personnel Support Center (DPSC) of
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Defense Logistics Agency (DLA), awarded
appellant Contract No. DLA100-79-C-2894 for the manufacture and delivery
of 43,000 Navy men’s single-breasted polyester/cotton, poplin blue shade
3346 raincoats in accordance with military specification MIL-R-82290B(SA)
for a unit price of $19.20 and a total contract price of $825,600 (R4, ASBCA
No. 42244, tabs 1-4).

2. The contract also provided for an optional quantity of 21,500 units,
which the Government ordered by Modification POOOO7 on 22 February
1980, at a unit price of $21.64, raising the contract quantity to 64,500 and
increasing the contract price to $1,290,860 (ibid., tab 5).

3. Appellant delivered 43,952 units, but the remaining quantity of 20,548
units was terminated for default by Modification POOO11 dated 29 October
1981 (ibid.).

B. Contract No. DLA100-80-C-2290

4. On 7 November 1979, DPSC awarded appellant Contract No.
DLA100-80-C-2290 for the manufacture and delivery of 26,250 polyester/
wool, tropical 10-ounce, blue shade 1578 Air Force women’s pantsuit coats
in accordance with Purchase Description ENEU 78-7 (subsequently
superseded by MIL-C-87160) for a unit price of $34.37 and a total contract
price of $902,212.50 (R4, ASBCA No. 37395, tab 1). The contract stated
that it was a production test procurement for the purpose of determining
whether the item described in ENEU 78-7 “can be manufactured in quantity
production in accordance with accepted production practices” (ibid., tab 3 at
63; tr. 1/89).

5. Appellant delivered 25,903 units which the Government paid for and
regarded as contract completion on 9 December 1980 (tr. 9/62-63; exh. G-
193).

27

C. Contract No, DLA100-80-C-2972

6. On 23 June 1980, DPSC awarded appellant Contract No. DLA100-
80-C-2972 for the manufacture and delivery of 125,240 Army men’s black
cotton and polyester poplin cloth all weather coats with removable liners at a
unit price of $31.92 and a total contract price of $3,997,366.40. The coats
were to be manufactured in accordance with Limited Purchase Description
12-77 (DES 12-77A) dated 1 November 1978 (subsequently replaced by
MIL-C-44030, dated 24 July 1980) using patterns dated 21 September 1979
issued by the United States Army Natick Research and Development
Laboratory (Natick) and were to be delivered between 4 January and 3 June
1981 (R4, ASBCA No. 42243, tabs 3, 5; tr. 1/156).

7. Appellant delivered 38,146 coats under the contract, and the
remaining 87,094 were terminated for default in late 1981 (R4, ASBCA No.
42243, tab 6).

D. Value Engineering Incentive Clause

8. All three of appellant’s contracts contained the following value
engineering incentive clause (R4, ASBCA No. 37395, tab 4; R4, ASBCA
No. 42243, tab 1; R4, ASBCA No. 42244, tab 2):

JO9 VALUE ENGINEERING INCENTIVE (DPSC 1978 Jan)

(a) Application. This clause applies to a Contractor developed and
documented Value Engineering Change Proposal (VECP) which:

(i) requires a change to this contract to implement the VECP, and

(11) reduces the overall costs to the cognizant Military Department
without impairing essential functions of characteristics, provided that
it is not based:

(A) solely on a change in deliverable end item quantities, or

(B) a change in R&D end item or test quantities due solely
to results of previous testing under this contract, or

(C) solely on a change to the contract type.
(b) Documentation. As a minimum, the following information shall
be submitted by the Contractor with each VECP.

(i) a description of the difference between the existing contract
requirement and the proposed change, and the comparative
advantages and disadvantages of each, justification when a function
or characteristic of an item is being altered, and the effect of the
change on the performance of the end item;

28

(ii) an analysis and itemization of the requirements of the
contract which must be changed if the VECP is accepted and a
recommendation as to how to make each change (¢.g., a suggested
specification revision):

(iii) a separate detailed cost estimate for both the existing
contract requirement and the proposed change to provide an estimate
of the reduction in costs, if any, that will result from acceptance of
the VECP, taking into account the costs of development and
implementation by the Contractor (including any amount attributable
to subcontracts in accordance with paragraph (h) below);

(iv) a prediction of any effects the proposed change would
have on collateral costs to the Military Department such as
Government-furnished property costs, costs of related items, and costs
of maintenance and operation.

(v) a statement of the time by which a contract modification
accepting the VECP must be issued so as to obtain the maximum
cost reduction, noting any effect on the contract completion time or
delivery schedule, and

(vi) identification of any previous submission of the VECP,
including the dates submitted, the agencies involved, the numbers of
the Government contracts involve’ and the previous actions by the
Government, if known.

(c) Submission. VECPs shall be submitted to the Procuring
Contracting Officer (PCO). When the contract is administered by
other than the purchasing office, a copy of the VECP shall be
submitted simultaneously to the Administrative Contracting Officer
(ACO). VECPs shall be processed expeditiously, however, the
Government shall not be liable for any delay in acting upon any VECP
submitted pursuant to this clause. The Contractor has the right to
withdraw, in whole or in part, any VECP not accepted by the
Government within the period specified in the VECP.

(d) Acceptance. The Contracting Officer may accept, in whole
or in part, by contract modification either before or within a reasonable
time after performance has been completed under this contract any
VECP submitted pursuant to this clause. Until a contract modification
applies a VECP to this contract, the Contractor shall remain obligated
to perform in accordance with the terms of the existing contract.
Contract modification made pursuant to this clause will so state. The
decision of the Contracting Officer as to the acceptance of any VECP

under this contract (including the decision as to which clause is

29

licabl ' Lif thi ‘ns both a “V
Engineering Incentive” aah Solel ectneatien boesoens
Requirement” clause) shall be final and shall not be subject to the

“Disputes” clause of this contract.

(e) Sharing. If a VECP submitted by the Contractor pursuant
to this clause is accepted, the Contractor shall share in savings realized
by the Government in accordance with the following provisions:

(1) Instant Contract.
(i) Definitions:

(A) Instant contract savings to the Contractor (ICS)
is the unit cost reduction times the number of units affected in the
instant contract. The proposed unit cost reduction includes estimated
allowable Contractor development and implementation costs (CC).
The Contractor’s development and implementation costs include any
subcontractor development and implementation costs and
subcontractor incentive payments (see (h) below). For purposes of
this clause, Contractor development costs are those costs incurred
after the Contractor has identified a specific VE project and prior to
acceptance by the Government.

(B) Government Costs (GC) are those DOD costs
which directly result from development and implementation of the
VECP, such as test and evaluation of the VECP, and any increased
cost in DoD operations, maintenance, and logistics support.

**e

(2) Concurrent Contracts.

(i) If the VECP accepted under this contract is also used
on concurrent contracts of the purchasing office for essentially the
same items, the Contractor shall be paid a share of any savings as
calculated in (ii) below.

(ii) Calculations

(A) Determine the reduction in the price of each
concurrent contract(s) as a result of incorporating the VECP.

(B) Subtract from the total amount in (A) any
Government costs (GC) not yet offset (if GC was greater than ICS)
in (e) (1) (ii) (C) or (D) above, and any increase in the instant contract
price, 1.e., if ICS was negative in (e) (1) (ii) (D), if the resulting
number is positive, multiply it by 50% (25% if this is a VEPRC).

Add this amount to the instant contract price.

30

(3) Future Contracts.

(i) Definition. The term unit cost reduction for future
contract sharing shall be the unit cost reduction under this instant
contract without deducting any cost of development or impletion
[sic].

(ii) If the VECP accepted under this contract is used on
future purchases of essentially the same item by the purchasing office,
or its successor, the Contractor shall share in the savings on all affected
end items scheduled for delivery not later than 3 years after acceptance
of the first item incorporating the VECP, or until the originally
scheduled delivery date of the last affected end item under the instant
contract, whichever is later. When sharing on future contracts is
expected, the Contractor shall be responsible for the following:

(A) Maintaining records adequate to support
identification of the first delivered unit to which the VECP applies.
These records are considered an integral part of contract
documentation and shall be maintained for a period of three years
after final payment on the contract under which the VECP was
accepted.

(B)Annotating the DD-250, Material Inspection and
Receiving Report, which applies to the initial unit covered by the
VECP with the following statement:

“This is the initial unit delivered which incorporates VECP NO. ,
Contract Modification No. , dated ,

(iii) Calculations. At the time each eligible future
contract is awarded:

(A) Determine the number of units scheduled to be
delivered prior to expiration of the Contractor sharing period
determined in (ii) above. Multiply this by the unit cost reduction as
defined in (e) (3) (1).

(B) Subtract from the total amount in (A) any
Government costs or instant contract increases not yet offset in (e)
(1) (11) (C) or (D), or in (e) (2) (ii) (B), or in other contracts awarded
since acceptance of the VECP. If the resulting number is positive
multiply it by 50% (25% if this is a VEPRC) and add the result to the
instant contract price.

(f) Payment. The Contractor’s concurrent and future
contract shares should be paid upon modification of concurrent
contracts or future contract award, or within six (6) month thereafter.
However, any such payments are subject to the condition that to the
extent the Government does not receive delivery and accept all items

31

.

on which the share is paid, the Contractor shall reimburse the
Government the proportionate share of the payments. If this clause
is modified to provide for lump sum payments, such payments shall
be made upon modification of the instant contract.

II. ’s Vi Vv ,

A. VECP 1280 (ASBCA No, 37798)

9. In a letter to DPSC dated 3 December 1979 (R4, ASBCA No.
37798, tab 6), appellant submitted several VECP’s under Contract 2290,
including the following proposal which the Government subsequently
designated as VECP 1280 (ibid., tab 10):

1. Change From:

MIL-C-297F Cloth Interlining, Cotton Wrap and Spun Hairwoo!
or Rayon Filling 12-1-79: $4.50 per yard 72" wide for Coat Fronts.

Change To:

Pellon Corp. fusible [sic] #3633, Color White, 45" wide at $.60
per yard.

Hair-Wool .286 yards per garment
72 x 36 equals 2592 square inches

Cost per square inch = .001736
658 square inch x .001736
= $1.14 per coat.

Pellon 45" x 36" long = 1620 square inches.
Cost per square inch = .000373
658 square inch x .000373 =
$.25 per coat.

Savings of $.89 per coat

10. An interlining is a piece of fabric that is sewn or fused between two
other layers of fabric in parts of a garment, such as collars, cuffs, and pocket
flaps, to give them body and stiffen them (tr. 5/1 87-88, 8/52).

11. Garment interlining material is either woven -- that is, resulting from
the weaving of yarns vertically and horizontally on a loom like the hairwool

32

|, aaa ii

prescribed in Contract 2290 -- or non-woven -- that is, resulting from the
pressing together of fibers with some sort of resin or by heat to cause them to
bond into a papery type configuration like the Pellon Corp. #3633 material
proposed by appellant (tr. 1/23, 82, 131-32, 141-43, 156-57, 5/188, 6/83-84).

12. Both woven and non-woven interlinings can be sewn or fused into a
garment (tr. 1/134, 5/188). A fabric like Pellon #3633, is fusible when an
adhesive is applied to it and is joined to other material by a process of time,
temperature, and pressure which melts the adhesive (tr. 3/17, 5/189-90, 8/28-
29).

13. Non-woven fusibles were developed by Freudenberg, the parent
company of Pellon Corp., in Germany in or before the 1960's and became
generally accepted in the garment industry by the mid-1980’s (tr. 3/64). DPSC
began testing fusibles in the late 1960’s to determine how they could be used
in military clothing (tr. 6/133); and the Army Research and Development
Center at Natick, Massachusetts, engaged in a continuous research,
development, and experimentation program concerning the use of fusible
fabrics for components of garments, including interlinings, from 1971 to
1983 and thereafter (tr. 5/170, 175-76, 193-94, 6/5-6, 16-17, 93-96, 136,
138, 192-200, 7/49, 9/115-21; exh. G-139, -143). All of the military services
participated in the Natick program, including the Marine Corps (tr. 2/58, 6/
13, 16-18, 133-34, 7/49, 116) which wrote the MIL-C-29365 (MC)
specification, entitled “CLOTH, NONWOVEN: INTERLINING, FUSIBLE,
NYLON AND POLYESTER, POLYAMID,” around a Pellon product in
February 1978 (exh. G-116, -139; tr. 6/19, 35); and the military departments
were fusing interlinings on approximately 15 items such as dress shirts,
raincoats, service caps, and optional PX-type uniform coats in the mid to late
1970's (tr. 5/199-200; exh. G-125). Although the Government had tested
250 uniform coats in 1975-76 to determine the feasibility of fusible interlinings
therein (tr. 6/5-6, 21, 133-34; exh. G-128) and had met with Pellon personnel
at its factory in New England in the mid-1970’s (tr. 6/17), it was not convinced
in late 1979 that the desired quality of dress coats could be maintained with
fusible interlinings (tr. 5/198-99, 6/57, 94-95). As stated by Mr. Bruce Snigger
of the Fabric and Fabric Technology Division of Natick, in a 14 January
1980 memorandum to the chief of that division (exh. G-128):

2. A meeting was held on 7 December 1979 with Mr. D. Cerow,
AUPO, to review the present status of the use of fusible interlinings
and discuss where new uses can be introduced as presented in
reference 1. Present from F&FT Branch, TR&ED were B. Snigger,
E. Frederick, and R. Roth.

33

2
*
3
:
a
-
7
2
7

3. From the items identified in reference 1 as potential candidates
for fusibles, it was agreed that the items listed in the attached table
should be investigated and priorities were assigned as indicated.

4. The following comments are made concerning the categories
selected for investigation:

a. Coats (items 1-3) - A wear test was performed in 1975/1976
with 250 fused polyester/wool coats. Although 68 percent of the test
subjects reporting to NARADCOM indicated preference of the fused
coats, some of the test items exhibited delamination of fused areas.
The number of faulty coats generated a reluctance to introduce
fusibles into dress items at that time. However, with the growing
popularity in commercial items, and with the experience gained in-
house and by outside contractors, a program has been initiated to
evaluate improved fusibles in 25 men’s coats in a small scale, closely
monitored wear test which could include Army Uniform Board
personnel. The coats will be made under “ideal” conditions
(temperature, pressure and dwell time) with the fusing being done in
the fusible supplier’s laboratory. Crown Textile Co. has offered to
furnish the fusibles and to assist in the fabrication of the coats.

b. Shirts and Overblouses (items 4-7) - The question was raised
as to whether fusing of the flaps would magnify the puckering of the
pocket stitching because of the flaps’ relative smoothness.
Approximately six (6) shirts will be made with fused collars, cuffs,
flaps and shoulder loops to determine what aesthetic differences result
before and after laundering.

¢. Raincoats (items 8-10) - A document modification will be
sent through AUPO to EPMO which will implement the fusing of
raincoat collar stands as an alternate to the sewn-in marquisette.
Fusing of the raincoat front with a suitable nonwoven fabric was
also determined to be worthy of investigation. Sample coats will
tentatively be made up at the Pellon Corporation Studio in New York
and evaluated.

d. Women's Uniforms (items 11 & 12) - These items are
scheduled to be phased out. AUPO has indicated that changes to
these items would not be feasible since they could be out of the system
before any modifications were implemented.

34

e. Coat, Men’s, Woven Twill, Textured Polyester, AG 434 - UQC
S-2-75 (item 13) - Since this item already utilizes fusible interlinings,
a document change is being prepared for the UQC Office through
AUPO to include fusing of the cuff wigans. This will be completed
in January 1980.

5. Total funding over a two year period should be approximately
$60,000. Action is being taken to transfer funds from AUPO to
establish a TR&ED task.

14. Delamination is the separation of a fusible interlining from the fabric
to which it is fused (tr. 1/131, 3/17, 43-44, 8/27).

15. At the time appellant submitted VECP 1280, it was aware that the
Marine Corps had prescribed fusible, non-woven interlinings in MIL-C-29365
(MC) in 1978 (tr. 2/58). Appellant itself had had no prior experience with
Pellon non-woven fabrics (tr. 2/114, 126).

16. By letter dated 28 February 1980, while the Government was
evaluating VECP 1280 (R4, ASBCA No. 37798, tabs 8-11), appellant
proposed the following Pellon products for the Government’s consideration
as “additional alternate” products to be used for interlinings on the Air Force
women’s pantsuit coats “for this procurement and all like procurements” (ibid.,
tab 12):

Pellon #SG413 36” Non-woven Fusible $1.09 1/2 per yard White

Pellon #SG413 36" Non-woven Fusible $1.16 1/2 per yard Black
.

(or, a lighter version)

Pellon #SG313 36" Non-woven Fusible $0.85 per yard White
Pellon #SG313 36" Non-woven Fusible $0.91 per yard Grey

17. In a letter dated 12 March 1980 (ibid., tab 14), appellant informed
DPSC:

Cost estimated for the difference between hairwool and fusible
interlining, as referenced in letter to DPSC dated 03Dec79, is
incorrect. Depending on the type fusible interlining used, the savings
is not $.89 but, from $1.36 for SG413 to $1.62 with Pellon #3633,
$G313 savings would be $1.49.

35

Estimated labor savings by fusing are as follows.

Labor cost deleted

Hand Operations

A. Operation 4 (E) Press undercollar .046

B. Operation 4 (T)3 Baste collar 1/4" 092
from edge to edge

C. Operation | (A) Baste interlining to front .092

D. Operation 14(A) Press fronts .092

E. Operation 14(B) Trim front interlining .092

F. Operation 21(C) Baste diagonal rows 198
across lapels

er

A. Operation 4 (A) Blindstitch collar lining 055

B. Operation 4 (H) Stitch top and side edges 055
of collar

C. Operation 13(A) Blindstitch 6 rows on lapel A]

D. Operation 14(DD) Stitch interlining from | A
armhole to shoulder seam

E. Operation 21(F) Blindstitch back of front .22
facing to interlining

F. Operation 27(C) Sew shoulder loop interlining .11
to edge

Labor cost added

Fusing of parts 20
Total labor savings are: Deleted operations $1.272

Minus added cost 22
Savings $1.052

18. After evaluation by DPSC and the Air Force specification preparing
activity and in accordance with their recommendation (ibid., tabs 13, 16-18),
the contracting officer, by letter dated 18 April 1980, disapproved VECP
1280, stating (ibid., tab 19):

36

VECP 1280 - Proposal to use Pellon fusible in lieu of cotton
warp and spun haircloth or rayon filling interlining material is not
approved. We concur in the concept of using fusible interlining
materials wherever applicable. However, one of the problems to be
resolved before any action can be taken is to have test methods that
yield reproducible data on which requirements can be based. Also,
compatibility of the Pellon material and the base cloth to which it
will be fused must first be determined. Detailed manufacturing
procedures to insure control of time, temperature, and pressure during
the fusing operation is of primary importance.

19.On 13 and 16 June 1980, appellant resubmitted VECP 1280,
proposing respectively that Pellon #3633 and Pellon #SG413 be used in the
manufacture of the pantsuit coats instead of hairwool or hair-rayon, and further
stating that the proposal contemplated a reduction in cost on all like garments
as well as the contract item (ibid., tabs 20, 21; tr. 1/126-27).

20. The Government took no action on the resubmitted VECP, and
appellant, through counsel, submitted a claim concerning VECP 1280, in the
amount of $1,023,999.86, on 4 August 1988 (exh. A-1165).

21. On 17 October 1988, the appeal in ASBCA No. 37798 was initiated
by appellant after failure of the contracting officer to issue a final decision on
its claim.

B. VECP 1380 (ASBCA No. 37395)
22. Appellant’s 3 December 1979 letter to DPSC (finding 9) also

contained the following proposal under Contract 2290 which the Government
subsequently designated as VECP 1380 (R4, ASBCA No. 37395, tabs 6, 7):

2. Change From:

V-T-301D Thread Silk 4/22/71 AM, 2 - 4-19-73 - $50.60
1750 yards per pound/Omit Completely.

Change To:
V-T-285 D Polyester -- 1750 yards $.65

Savings : $49.95 per pound

37

23. On 25 January 1980, appellant amended its proposal in the following
letter to DPSC (ibid., tab 8):

Please refer to our Valued [sic] Engineering
Recommendations dated 03 December 1979, Change #2.

The information given to us by Gudebrod, Inc. regarding 1750 yards
per pound, silk thread, is incorrect. We recommend the following
change which will reflect the pounds as being accurate according to
the management of Gudebrod, Inc.:

Change From:
V-T-301D Thread Silk 4/22/71 AM 2, 4-19-73 $50.60 per pound

Yield as follows: Type A 15,200 per pound
Type B 12,480 per pound
Type C 9,920 yards per pound
(Gimp)
Change To:
Threads, Inc,

Oncore 50 MIL-T-43548 7.02 per pound
(To be used for all body construction including topstitching)

Yield as follows: 11,000 yards per pound

Cotton A-3 V-T-276 6.30 per pound
(To be used for button hole sewing)

Yield as follows: 9,600 per pound

Cotton #8 V-T-280 5.86 per pound
(Gimp to be used for button holes)

Yield as follows: 11,000 yards per pound

Omit V-T-295D Thread Nylon 2-33-77 $28.50 per pound.
This can be utilized with Threads, Inc., as listed above:

38

Silkk: A $50.60 Threads, Inc. $ 7.02
B 50.60 Threads, Inc. 6.30

G 50.60 Threads, Inc. 5.86
$151.80 $19.18

Savings : $132.62 per three (3) pounds

24. After evaluation, the Government disapproved VECP 1380, except
the proposal to use V-T 280 cotton thread for button hole gimps
(reinforcements) which it accepted, in Modification POOOO6, dated 20 May
1980, as an alternative to the ENEU 78-7 requirement for silk thread for
gimps (tr. 1/98, 9/54-55; R4, ASBCA No. 37395, tabs 9, 10).

25. The allowance of V-T cotton thread as an alternative material for
gimps was confirmed in Modification POOO10 which was executed by
appellant on 30 October 1980 and by the contracting officer on 3 November
1980 and contained the following provisions (ibid., tab 11):

1. Pursuant to Clause JO9 entitled Value Engineering Incentive

Clause the following changes are made to the specification
requirements:

VECP #1380 - para. 3.1.15 Gimp - At the end of the paragraph
add “or the Gimp may be cotton type II, size 8 of V-T-280.”

2. The contractor and the Government hereby agree that savings as
a result of VECP #1380 will be $.0395 per unit for future contracts
utilizing this change.

3. Itis agreed that the contractor is entitled to 50% of the unit savings
or $.01975 per unit for all items utilizing this change during the royalty
period.

26. Appellant did not use the alternative V-T-280 cotton thread for gimps on
the 25,903 units which it delivered under Contract 2290 between 24 September
and 9 December 1980 (exh. A-1074, G-194; finding 5; app. posthearing br. at 78).

27. There were no concurrent contracts for the item which was the subject
of Contract 2290, and no other contractors which manufactured women’s Air
Force pantsuit coats for the Government after appellant’s submission of VECP
1380 elected to utilize the alternative V-T-280 cotton thread for gimps (tr. 4/
26-27, 35, 9/57-58).

39

28. Appellant received no royalties or other compensation for VECP 1380
(tr. 1/120).

29. In a letter dated 27 May 1988, appellant filed a claim in this matter,
through counsel, in the amount of $1,036.88 for instant contract savings and
indicated that the claim would be supplemented as it obtained further
information concerning the implementation of VECP 1380 by the Government
(exh. A-1166).

30. Appellant subsequently appealed from a failure of the contracting
officer to issue a final decision on VECP 1380.

C. VECP 2181 (ASBCA No, 42243)

31. By letter dated 31 October 1980 (R4, ASBCA No. 42243, tab 7),
appellant submitted to DPSC the following VECP under Contract 2972, which
was subsequently designated as VECP 2181 (ibid., tabs 8, 9):

Regarding clause J O9 Value Engineering, MBOC recommends the
following change:

Change From

100 percent cotton plain weave cloth which has a uniformly
distributed dot system of a polyvinyl chloride/polyvinyl acetate
type fusible adhesive applied to one side. (Per paragraph 3.2.9.1
of LP/P DES 12-77A)

Change To

Pellon product SG413 (#8325) non-woven fusible interlining.

Note: Pellon Corporation has notified MBOC that # SG413 and
#8325 applies to the same product. A decision is being
finalized by Pellon Corporation management as to which
number will pertain to the product.

Please refer to DLA100-79-C-2894 correspondence on VECP
#3380 and DLA100-80-C-2290 correspondence on VECP #1380
from DLA which contains all current data and testing
accomplished by the Department of Defense.

40

Cost savings can only be determined upon future evaluating by
audit. MBOC will supply this information upon request in
compliance [sic] with Clause J O9.

32. After technical review and evaluation of appellant’s proposal, the
Army Natick Research and Development Laboratories determined that the
interlining material proposed in VECP 2181 was acceptable as an alternative
to the interlining material prescribed in the contract, and it recommended the
approval of that VECP (ibid., tab 8; tr. 6/24, 43, 51).

33. Natick’s recommendation was adopted by the Government in
unilateral Modification POOOOS to the contract dated 31 March 1981, which
provided (R4, ASBCA No. 42243, tab 6):

5. In addition, VECP #2181 has also been approved. The following
changes are incorporated into the contract to MIL-C-C-44030:

CHANGES TO MIL-C-44030, 24 July 1980

a. Page 1, paragraph 2.1, under Military Specifications, add:
“MIL-C-29365 - Cloth, Nonwoven, Interlining, Fusible, Nylon and
Polyester, Polyamid.”

b. Page 4, paragraph 3.2.9.1, at the end of the paragraph add:
“As an alternative a nonwoven fusible fabric conforming to class 3
material of MIL-C-29365 may be used as a fusible interlining. Testing
for the nonwoven fusible shall be as specified in MIL-C-29365 (The
woven fusible requirements contained herein for colorfastness,
3.2.9.3; fusing conditions, 3.2.9.4; bond strength, 3.2.9.5, and
shrinkage, 3.2.9.6, shall not apply).

6. The contractor shall be entitled to 50% of the unit savings or
[sic] any unit incorporating VECP #2181. Unit savings has not yet
been determined for this VECP; modification will be issued to
definitize the savings at a later date.

7. Contractor is obligated to annotate the DD Form 250 which
applies to the initial unit covered by the VECP #2181.

34.A cost analysis of the proposed change, conducted by DPSC’s
Directorate of Manufacturing in late March 1981 disclosed that the change
in interlining material proposed in VECP 2181 would effect neither an increase
nor a decrease in production costs (tr. 5/81, 6/152-56; exh. G-140).

41

35. VECP 2181 was not implemented under Contract 2972, and appellant
received no payments for VECP 218] (tr. 1/162; exh. A-1042; app. posthearing
br. at 289-90, 384, 443-44).

36. Appellant submitted its present claim in this matter, for an unspecified
amount, on 3 August 1990 (R4, ASBCA No. 42243, tab 12) and subsequently
appealed from a failure of the contracting officer to issue a final decision
thereon (ibid., tab 14).

D. VECP 2880 (ASBCA No. 42416)

37.On 22 January 1980, appellant submitted to DPSC a VECP,
subsequently designated as VECP 2880, under Contract 2290, proposing that
two labels prescribed in the contract for attachment to the pantsuit coats, one
for size and one for contractor and personnel identification (tr. 1/165, 199, 5/
114-15), be combined as suggested in a 10 December 1979 letter from its
subcontractor, Star Printing Company, which stated (R4, ASBCA No. 42416,
tabs 6, 7, 10):

We enclose herewith 100 each of the labels required for your contract
2290 and can quote as follows for the labels as submitted:

1. 27,000 3" x 3" Type I Classes 1 & 10 Labels @$16.50M

2. 27,000 Asst. 1 1/2 x 1 1/4 Type 1 Class 2 @$5.25M
labels plus 31 size changes @ $1.50 each
27,000 Asst. 3 1/2 x 1 5/8 “paper” bag
insert” labels @$4.50M
plus 31 size changes @ $1.50 each

Maury, if it is possible for you to combine label #1 and label #2 with
1/4" sew in on four sides only, combination Type I Classes 1, 2 and
10 label, the price for 27,000 assorted 2 5/8" x 2 3/8" labels would
be at $12.50 per thousand plus 31 size changes at $1.50 each. These
labels would take the place of both 3" x 3" and the 1 1/2" x 1 1/4"
label if you are able to convince the inspector that there is a cost
saving by combining the two labels.

We will hold up processing the balance of your order and would
appreciate hearing form you at your earliest convenience how you
want to handle the balance of this order.

42

38. After consideration and evaluation of VECP 2880, the Air Force
Clothing and Textile Office, of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, the specification
preparing activity, reported that it did not concur in the proposal because the
“size label is required to be placed so that it will be visible for both storage &
issue purposes” (ibid., tab 11).

39. By letter dated 2 April 1980 (ibid., tab 12), the contracting officer
informed appellant that VECP 2880 was not adopted for the reason stated by
the specification preparing activity in its report.

40. VECP 2880 was not implemented on the subject contract, and
appellant received no payment therefor (tr. 1/168, 171).

41. Appellant submitted its present claim, in an unspecified amount, for
alleged constructive acceptance of VECP 2880 on 30 October 1990 and revised
the claim on 26 November 1990 to an amount less than $50,000; and it has

appealed from the failure of the contracting officer to issue a final decision
thereon.

E. VECP 3380 (ASBCA No, 42244)

42. On 28 February 1980, appellant sent the following VECP to DPSC
under Contract 2894, which was subsequently designated as VECP 3880
(R4, ASBCA No. 42244, tabs 6, 7).

MBOC recommends the following change:

Change From

Samuel Habers, QST, style #961/Facemate style #2320
Fusible Interlining Woven. $1.05

Change to
Pellon Corp., 36 inch SG413 Fusible $1.09 1/2
White
Non-Woven 1.16 1/2
Black

This product has been proven to be highly successful in raincoats
and all like garments for all outer-wear use.

43

This product is especially good for garments that are exposed to rain
or heavy water use. We have found that when the outer-shell becomes
saturated, the SG413 does not defuse itself from the base fabric as
easily as woven fusible facings. Its porus [sic] construction factors
and its fusible properties are of a hi gher quality than woven products
we have experienced in the past.

43. By letter to DPSC dated 7 April 1980, appellant amended VECP
3380 after learning that the Government intended to revise the provisions of
MIL-R-82290B to replace the woven fusible interlinings with sewn-in
hairwool woven cloth interlinings meeting the requirements of MIL-C-297,
as follows (ibid., tabs 8, 9, 15):

... it has been brought to MBOC’s attention that Woven Fusibles
would be changed to a loose coat front, flap, collar and stand
interlining.

MBOC received a bid (DLA! 00-80-B-0542) that indicates MIL-
C-297F Cloth, Interlining Cotton Warp and Hairwool. This
product is $4.50 per yard (72 inches wide). The Hairwool will
require hand trimming; added cost as follows:

1 Collar 025
1 Stand 025
2 Flaps @.02 each 04
2Coat Fronts @.06 each 12

A total cost for hand trimming of .21c.

Machine setting time cost will increase as follows:

1 Collar 015
| Stand O15
2 Flaps @.015 each .03
2Coat Fronts @.03 each .06
A total increase cost of .12¢ per coat. ‘

The above does not reflect arm flaps or epaulets. A cost increase
can not be evaluated.

The percentage of shrinkage is flexible [sic] in the MIL-C-297F
Cloth Interlining Cotton Warp and Hairwool. Patterns must be
graded with an over-allowance to accommodate. This over-
allowance can only be determined by the Pattern Maker and
Engineering Department in the Government. Additional material
of course will be necessary for the Hairwool Interlining.

The fabric cost difference is as follows:

a) Facemate Woven Style #2320 45 inches wide $1.06 per yard
b) MIL-C-297F Cloth Hairwool/Cotton Warp
72 inches wide 4.50 per yard
c) MBOC recommends:
Felton Corp SG a Non-woven, White 1.09 per yard
” Black 1.16 1/2 per yard
(or) Pellon Corp SG 313 Non-woven, White .85 per yard
. Grey 36 inches wide .91 per yard

The selection between SG 413 and SG 313 will determine the
Savings in this cost area.

Pellon SG 413 is heavier than SG 313. It is MBOC’s opinion
that SG 313 will accomplish an end product of quality finish and
desired stiffness. It is also MBOC’s position that bubbling will
not occur because of the open weave construction of either SG
413 or SG 313. MBOC strongly suggests an indepth laboratory
test on this product for all weather garments.

MBOC has made contact with the Pellon Corp to assume proper
fusing. All fusing can be arranged if contractors do not have the
proper fusing equipment.

This Valued Engineering Recommendation is for all like
garments.

44. VECP 3380 was considered by the Navy Clothing and Textile
Research Facility at Natick, Massachusetts, whose evaluation and
recommendation (ibid., tab 9) were adopted by the contracting officer and
reflected in the latter’s 14 October 1980 letter to appellant, as follows (ibid.
tab 10).

45

Your Value Engineering Change Proposal 3380, recommending a
nonwoven fusible interlining for man’s raincoat under MIL-R-
82290(SA) has been evaluated and final approval is still pending.

Currently, the Navy, with other military services, DCAS and DPSC
are conducting a Fusible Interlining Development Program. The
intent of this program is to develop a Government wide fool proof
method of specifying fusibles, their requirements, application and
testing in specifications.

Since problems occurred with fusibles in raincoats in the past and
since a program is currently underway, the Navy is withholding any
adoption of fusible into the subject specification until the fusible
interlining committee can agree on the adoption of specification
verbage [sic] that is considered to be the best method of selecting,
applying and testing the fusible.

In view of the above, your VECP cannot be adopted at this time. We
will inform you periodically regarding the progress of the fusible
program.

45. By letter dated 15 October 1980 (ibid., tab 11), appellant informed
the contracting officer, with reference to VECP’s 3380 and 1280:

We have been advised by the Pellon Company that the progress for
all branches of service has been verbally accepted and it is a matter
of the time of processing the proper paper work to formalize the
governments [sic] acceptance of the changes in the above reference
[sic] VECP numbers.

I would also like to advise you that for bookkeeping purposes, the
numbers only are being changed by the Pellon Company to an 8,000
number series. SG313 is now 8313 and SG413 is now 8325. The
fabric itself has not changed.

The Value Engineering, as previously stated, is to cover all branches
of service and all applicable garments.

Cost calculation of saving can only be determined upon audit and
evaluation in accordance with Value Engineering Clause [sic] JO9
DPSC Jan.

46

46. The specification for the Navy enlisted man’s raincoat, which was
the subject of Contract 2894, was never changed to include non-woven fusible
interlinings or other components, and the raincoat was “phased out” as an
authorized item starting in May 1985, and replaced by an all weather coat
(ibid., tabs 13, 15, 17; tr. 7/160).

47. VECP 3380 was not implemented on the subject contract, and
appellant received no payment therefor (tr. 1/149-50, 153).

48. Appellant submitted its present claim, in an unspecified amount,
concerning VECP 3380 on 3 August 1990 (R4, ASBCA No. 42244, tab 12)
and has appealed from a failure of the contracting officer to render a final
decision thereon (ibid., tab 14).

II. Appellant’s Claims
A. VECP’s 1280, 2181, and 3380

49. Appellant contends that its suggested changes to non-woven fusible
interlinings in VECP’s 1280, 2181, and 3380 were constructively accepted
by the Government when the latter implemented the concepts in those
proposed changes on subsequent specifications; that the Government
confirmed the constructive acceptance of VECP’s 1280 and 3380 when it
accepted VECP 2181; that it had introduced the Government, through DPSC,
to the non-woven fusible manufactured by Pellon Corp. or its functional
equivalent; that it is entitled to royalties for future contracts of the Government
for “essentially the same” items, which it defines, as it applies to VECP’s
1280, 2181, and 3380, as “any item which contains (or would contain ‘but
for’ MBOC’s VECPs) an unsatisfactory interlining requirement that can be
replaced with a nonwoven fusible, resulting in lower production or life-cycle
costs, without a diminution of the changed item's essential functions or
characteristics”; that it is also entitled to royalties for collateral savings which
the Government realized as a consequence of its constructive acceptance of
those VECP’s; and that the Government acted in bad faith in denying that its
VECP’s, particularly VECP 2181, resulted in contractor savings (app.
posthearing br. at 63-65, 310-12, 316-458).

50. Since the changes recommended in appellant’s VECP’s were not
implemented under its contracts, appellant is claiming no instant contract
savings therefor (ibid., at 289-90, 384, 443-44).

47

51. Nor is appellant claiming any royalties for concurrent contracts since
it could find no information to show that its VECP’s were used on any such
contracts (tr. 4/44; exh. B of exh. A-1040, -1041, -1042).

52.In accordance with its definition of “essentially the same item,”
appellant seeks royalties for alleged Government Savings On many contracts
awarded by the Government embracing the following military specifications
(exh. A-1, -1000 through -1042, -1094: tr. 1/1 36-37, 149-50, 159, 3/41; app.
posthearing br., vol III):

MIL-SPEC DESCRIPTION

B-29407 Belt for Man’s All Weather Coat

B-29408 Belt for Woman’s All Weather Coat

C-15507 Woman’s Garrison Cap

C-24921 Woman’s All Weather Coat With Removable Liner

C-43972 Woman’s All Weather Coat, Black, With Removable
Liner

C-44030 Man’s All Weather Coat, Black, With Removable
Liner

C-87110 Man’s All Weather Coat, Black, With Convertible
Collar and Removable Liner

C-87170 Woman's All Weather Coat, Black, With Removable
Liner

C-87230 Flyer’s Coveralls

J-88382 Man’s Flyer Jacket, Summer

C-82189 Man’s Full Dress Coat, Summer and Winter

J-83388 Flyer’s Jacket, Cold Weather

J-29451 Man’s Marine Corps Jacket, Intermediate Weight

R-24918 Man’s Double-Breasted Raincoat, Coast Guard, With
Removal Liner

R-24919 Woman’s Raincoat, Coast Guard, With Removal
Liner

R-43518 Man’s Quarpel-Treated Double-Breasted Raincoat

S-21087 Woman’s Skirt, Wool, Polyester Wool

S-29122 Woman’s Dress Skirt

S-87053 Woman’s Belted Skirt

S-87054 Woman’s Belted Slacks

S-87055 Woman’s Dress Shirt, White

C-24920 Man’s All Weather Coat, With Epaulets, and
Removable Liner

C-27438 Man’s Service Coat

48

C-44048

Combat Coat, Camouflage Pattern

C-44211 Man’s Coat, Tropical and Serge, Polyester Wool

C-44379 Woman’s Combat Coat, Polyester Wool

C-87215 Woman’s Air Force Garrison Cap

J-87250 Man’s Light Weight Jacket, With Removable Liner

J-87251 Woman’s Light Weight Jacket, With Removable
Liner

J-293964*+— Woman’s Dress Jacket, Scarlet

S-24948 Woman’s Slacks

S-29394 Woman’s Marine Corps Band Evening Dress Skirt

S-29429 Woman’s Skirt

S-44039 Man’s Long Sleeve Shirt, Polyester/Cotton, Army
Green

S-44041 Man’s Short Sleeve Shirt, Army Green

S-44090 Woman’s Short Sleeve Shirt, Polyester/Cotton, Army
Green

$-44093 Woman’s Long Sleeve Shirt, Polyester/Cotton, Army
Green

S-44299 Man’s Hospital Duty Uniforms Smock

S-83234 Woman’s Blue Skirt

S-82126 Woman’s Marine Corps Dress Skirt

T-44047 Combat Trousers, Camouflage Pattern

53. Appellant selected the foregoing military specifications and the
Government contracts referring to them after examination of the histories
and specifications of several thousand contracts (tr. 1/99-100, 104-13).
“Employing consultants with expertise in engineering, computers, apparel
manufacturing, methods-time-measurement with regard to clothing
manufacture, and cost and pricing data (tr. 2/149-54, 3/9-15, 4/11-19, 23),
appellant completed the formulation and quantification of its claims in late
March 1992 in reports prepared by the Peter Elliott Accountancy Corporation
(exh. A-1040, -1041, -1042; tr. 3/18-58, 105-61, 4/23--120) which contained
cost figures for the following:

a. Appellant’s estimate of labor and material savings by the
Government on future contracts.

b. Indirect Expense savings.

c. Profit.

49

d. Extended life savings -- i.e., estimated savings on quantities
that would have been scheduled for delivery but for implementation
of the VECP’s

e. Maintenance savings.
f. Interest, both before and after the filing of appellant’s claims.
g. Collateral savings and interest thereon.

h. Escalation -- i.e., the adjustment of material costs to the
midpoint period of performance (tr. 4/31-33).

i. Re-engineered costs for VECP 1280 reflecting an alternate
royalty period of the highest three years of planned production
because Contract 2290 was a production test contract (tr, 4/38-4] ).

54. The total amounts of appellant’s claims for its three non-woven fusible
interlining VECP’s, as constructed by the Elliott Corporation, were (exh. A-
1040, -1041, -1042):

VECP 1280 $68,629,052
VECP 2181 91,182,891
VECP 3380 17,013,187

Total $176,825,130
B. VECP 1380

55. Appellant contends that its suggestion in VECP 1380 that cotton gimp
be used for button hole sewing was implemented by the Government in future
contracts for approximately 32 “essentially the same” items as that purchased
under Contract 2290, defining “essentially the same item” as “any item which
contained (or would have contained) buttonholes prior to MBOC’s VECP” (app.
posthearing br. at 76, 287, 415; exh A-1049 through -1074; tr/ 1/99, 1 18).

56. Appellant seeks no collateral or concurrent Savings in its claim for
this VECP (tr. 1/18; exh. A-1074).

57. Appellant does not seek any instant contract savin gs since “Contract
DLA100-80-C-2290 was modified to incorporate VECP 1380, however, the
change was not implemented on that contract” (exh. A-1074 at A2, p. 1;
finding 26; tr. 3/74; app. posthearing br. at 78).

50

58. The future contracts for which appellant seeks royalties for VECP
1380 embraced the following military specifications (exh. A-1, -1049 through
-1074; tr. 1/107-12):

MIL-SPEC DESCRIPTION

T-44094 Trousers, Night Camouflage, Desert

C-24920 Man’s All Weather Coat with Removable Liner

C-24921 Woman’s All Weather Coat with Removal Liner

C-27438 Man’s Service Coat

C-44101 Woman’s Classic Design Coat, Polyester/Wool

C-44107 Ground Troops Parachutist’s Helmet Cover

C-44111 Woman’s Maternity Work Uniform Coat

C-44211 Man’s Tropical Serge Coat, Army Green

C-44379 Woman’s Classic Design Coat, Army Green

J-24949 Woman’s White Jumper

J-87250 Man’s Light Weight Jacket with Removable Liner

J-87251 Woman’s Light Weight Jacket with Removable Liner

O0-24905 Man’s Coast Guard Reefer Overcoat

O0-24906 Woman’s Coast Guard Reefer Overcoat

O0-24926 Enlisted Woman’s Overcoat

R-24918 Man’s Coast Guard Raincoat

R-24919 Woman’s Coast Guard Raincoat with Removable
Liner

S-29429 Woman’s Skirt

S-44110 Woman’s Maternity Work Uniform Skirt

S-87005 Woman’s Coast Guard Dress Skirt

S-87169 Woman’s Utility Durable Press Shirt

S-87171 Woman’s Durable Press Utility Slacks

T-29452 Man’s Polyester Wool Trousers

C-29391 Woman’s Wool Gabardine Dress Ceremony Coat

C-29393 Woman’s Marine Full Dress Coat

J-29396 Woman’s Marine Band Full Dress Jacket

J-29397 Woman’s Marine Band Full Dress Jacket

J-2945]1 Man’s Intermediate Weight Jacket, Polyester Wool

O0-29390 Woman’s Wool Gabardine Overcoat

S-29392 Woman’s Wool Gabardine Skirt

S-29394 Woman’s Marine Band Evening Dress Skirt

S-29395 Woman’s Musician Slacks

S-24902 Woman’s Polyester and Cotton Slacks

T-44291 Man’s Hospital Duty Uniform Trousers

V-29389 Man’s Scariet Dress Vest

51

59. Appellant selected the foregoing military specifications and the
Government contracts referring to them and prepared its claim for VECP
1380 in the same manner and with the same elements as for VECP’s 1280,
2181 and 3380 (finding 53; tr. 1/99-100, 104-15, 4/23-42, 45; exh A-1074),
except that the Peter Elliott report for VECP 1380 contained no collateral
Savings or re-engineered costs (tr. 4/39; exh. A-1074).

C. VECP 2880

60. Appellant contends that VECP 2880, which suggested the combining
of labels for pantsuit coats, was denied by the contracting officer “in bad
faith and without a rational basis” (app. posthearing br. at 88) and that it was
constructively accepted by the Government’s utilizing the change in contracts
involving the following 13 specifications for essentially the same item, which
appellant defines as “any place that the Government is going to use the
combination label” without restriction to any particular garment (ibid.; tr. 1/
32, 168-71; exh. A-1, -1080 through -1092):

MIL-SPEC DESCRIPTION

C-85700 Flyer’s Summer Coveralls

T-44213 Physical Fitness Trunks

C-87230 Flyer’s Cold Weather Coveralls

0-24905 Man’s Coast Guard Reefer Overcoat

0-24906 Woman’s Coast Guard Reefer Overcoat
P-44087 Night Camouflage Desert Parka

P-44188 Extended Cold Weather Camouflage Parka
S-29415 Wool Service Sweater

S-37951 Man’s Medical Assistant Polyester/Cotton Smock
S-44092 Woman’s Classic Design Polyester/Wool Slacks
S-44212 Hooded Physical Fitness Uniform Sweat Shirt
T=44094 Night Camouflage Desert Trousers

T-44189 Extended Cold Weather Camouflage Trousers

61. Appellant further contends that the first unit which incorporated
VECP 2880 was delivered to the Government on 28 February 1984 and that
therefore the royalty period for the VECP is from February 1984 to February
1987 (exh. G-308; app. posthearing br. at 89); that since Contract 2290 was a
production test contract, with a low rate of production, a second, alternative
royalty period, based on the highest 36 months of actual production, from
April 1989 toApril 1992, is applicable (ibid.); and that it is entitled to royalties
for future contract savings totalling $250,575 (ibid. at vol III, attachment 1).

$2

62. Appellant seeks no instant contract savings royalties since its proposed
change was not implemented under Contract 2290 (exh. A-1093); tr. 1/168).

63. Nor does appellant seek any concurrent contract savings royalties or
collateral savings costs (exh. A-1093).

64. Appellant prepared its claim for VECP 2880 in the same manner and
with the same elements as for its other VECP’s (findings 53, 59; exh. A-
1093; tr. 4/63-67).

[V. Pertinent Regulations
A. Collateral Savings

65. Armed Services Procurement Regulation (ASPR) 1-1073.2 (1 July
1976), in effect at the time of award of the subject contracts, provided that
the paragraph in the standard JO9 Value Engineering Incentive clause entitling
a contractor to share in collateral savings “may be excluded from a contract
or class of contracts when the HPA [Head of the Procuring Activity] determines

that the cost of computing and tracking collateral savings will exceed benefits
to be derived.” ;

66. Pursuant to that regulation, the paragraph in the standard JO9 clause
entitling a contractor to share in collateral savings was excluded from all of
the contracts involved in these appeals (finding 8) as well as for subsequent
DPSC contracts for the acquisition of clothing and textiles (tr. 9/103-07; exh.
G-165, -166, -167, -171).

B. Profit

67. ASPR 1-1703.1 (d), in effect at the time of award of the subject
contracts, provided:

On instant and future contracts the contractor’s profit or fee shall be excluded
when calculating the net savings.

C. Altemative Royalty Period

68. Appellant contends that because Contracts 2290 and 2894 were
production test contracts, it is entitled to future contract royalties for the time
period prescribed in Defense Acquisition Circular (DAC) #76-26, dated 15
December 1980, which was in effect prior to the actual acceptance of VECP’s

53

1380 and 2181 and the constructive acceptance of VECP’s 1280, 2880, and
3380, as an alternative to the royalty period specified in the JO9 clause of the
contract (app. posthearing br. at 18). DAC #76-26 provided (exh. A-1146):

(4) Concurrent and Future Contract Savings.

a... . If the instant contract is for low rate initial
production or an earlier life-cycle phase, the future sharing period
shall encompass scheduled deliveries, equal in number to the quantity
required by the highest 36 consecutive months of planned production,
based on the Five Year Defense Program (FYDP) or other planning
documentation at the time the VECP is accepted.

V. Additional Findi 1 Conclusi
A. VECP’s 1280, 2181, and 3380

69. In VECP 1280, appellant had proposed to change only the fronts of
pantsuit coats and not other coat parts for which it seeks royalties (finding 9;
tr. 6/140, 7/13, 9/22-23).

70. The fronts of women’s pantsuit coats were never changed in military
specifications to include non-woven fusible interlinings (tr. 6/139-40, 143-
44, 147-48).

71. The change proposed in VECP 3380, from woven fusible interlining
to Pellon non-woven fusible interlining, would not have produced any savings,
but rather it would have increased the cost of the Navy enlisted man’s polyester
cotton raincoat since the proposed Pellon material cost ($1.095 per yard for
white and $1.165 per yard for black) was greater that the cost of the woven
material prescribed in the contract ($1.05 per yard) (finding 42; tr. 1/141,
146, 6/84-85, 156-58).

72. The raincoat which was the subject of Contract 2894 and VECP 3380
was phased out of the Government procurement system in 1985 (tr. 7/160).

73. The change in material proposed in VECP 2181, from woven to Pellon
non-woven interlining in the Army man’s polyester cotton all weather coat,
which the Government accepted as an alternative (findings 32, 33), would
have produced no cost savings since the cost of the Pellon material was the
same as that for the interlining material prescribed in the contract (tr. 1/162,
5/81, 6/83, 86, 152, 155-56; exhs. G-140, -141).

54

74. Contrary to appellant’s contention (finding 49), it did not introduce
the Government to the non-woven fusible manufactured by appellant. Before
appellant had submitted its VECP’s concerning Pellon products or otherwise
suggested their use by the Government, the Government had met with Pellon
personnel at the latter’s factory, had written a specification, MIL-C-29365,
around a Pellon product, and fully considered Pellon’s non-woven fusible
interlinings as part of its continuous research, development, and
experimentation program concerning the use of fusible fabrics for garment
components for all of the military services (findings 13, 15).

75. Non-woven fusibles had not been sufficiently developed by late 1979
to eliminate the likelihood of delamination and shrinkage during manufacture,
particularly during fusing, and subsequently during laundering and dry
cleaning processes (tr. 5/198-201, 6/57, 94-95, 135-36, 7/99, 122, 8/35-37;
finding 13).

76. In the 1980's, improvements in technology, particularly with regard to
fusion machines and resin-based adhesives developed for the fusion process, led
the Government, as well as the textile industry, to make more extensive use of
non-woven fusibles in the fabrication of wearing apparel and other textile products
(tr. 3/63-64, 71, 161, 5/198-202, 6/81-82, 145, 8/16-17, 43-46). :

77.Four days before appellant had submitted VECP 2181, the
Government had completed a study of a Pellon non-woven fusible and had
begun to draft changes to military specifications for all weather coats, as
indicated in the following memorandum for the record dated 27 October
1980 by Natick’s fusing program project officer (tr. 6/23, 38; exh. G-151):

1. A study of Pellon Corporation Style 8325 has been completed
by the Seams Engineering Laboratory. The nonwoven style is
compatible with the water repellent treated fabric used in the men’s,
women’s and Jr. ROTC all-weather coats. No delamination of any
samples was found, and the fused fabrics look outstanding, in my
opinion, after laundering or dry cleaning.

2. In view of the above, I am drafting the necessary changes to the
all-weather coat specifications (MIL-R-87110, MIL-R-43972 and
MIL-R-439624A) to allow the nonwoven as an alternate to the present
(woven) fusible. This decision was based on our testing, Pellon test
results and acceptance by the Marine Corps and commercial
manufacturers. In addition, a minimal cost savings should result
when the nonwoven is used.

55

78. On the record before us, we are convinced that none of the military
specifications for which appellant seeks future contract royalties (finding
52) was changed because of appellant’s VECP’s 1280, 2181, and 3380 (tr. 6/
158-71, 177-78, 183-84, 7/9-43, 8/24-30, 43-47, 50). In fact, those working
on the fusible program and garment specifications at Natick in the 1980's
had never even heard of appellant (tr. 8/46).

79. Nor are we persuaded that the Government realized any Cost savings
on any future contracts involving those military specifications because non-
woven fusibles, as opposed to other materials, were prescribed therein (tr. 6/
151-53, 155-58, 169-71, 194). In this regard, we deem it highly significant
that appellant produced no cost records of any contractor under any of those
contracts to disclose how its manufacturing costs were affected by its use of
non-woven fusibles.

80. We further conclude, after examination of the military specifications
upon which appellant bases its claims for future contract royalties (finding
52), that none of those specifications dealt with an item which was essentially
the same as the Air Force woman’s pantsuit coat prescribed in Contract 2290
with regard to design, construction, purposes, and functions, that none of
those specifications dealt with an item which was essentially the same as the
man’s cotton and polyester poplin cloth all weather coat prescribed in Contract
2972 with regard to design, construction, purposes and functions, with the
exception of MIL-C-44030; and that none of those specifications dealt with
an item which was essentially the same as the Navy enlisted man’s single-
breasted raincoat prescribed in Contract 2894 with regard to design,
construction, purposes, and functions (exh. A-1000 through -1042; tr. 2/101-
03, 3/23, 5/196, 8/31-34). Most of those specifications, such as those for
belts, caps, coveralls, skirts, slacks, shirts, and combat wear, were not even
for remotely similar items (tr. 5/196, 8/32-34; exh. A-1000 through -1042).

81. The revision to MIL-C-44030, which appellant alleges constituted
implementation of its VECP 2181, only affected items delivered after 18
September 1984 (exh. A-1, -1029), more than three years after 14 May 198]
when appellant ceased operations on all Government contracts (exh. A-1042,
attachment 5 at 2, 21).

82. We find in the record before us no evidence to persuade us that any
future contractors for the production of garments in accordance with MIL-C-
44030 elected to use the alternative non-woven fusible fabric for interlinings in
accordance with the July 1980 amendment to that specification (finding 33) or, if
they did, thereby effected any cost savings for themselves or the Government.

56

B. VECP 1380

83. None of the military specifications upon which appellant bases its
claim for future contract royalties (finding 58) dealt with an item which was
essentially the same as the Air Force woman’s pantsuit coat prescribed in
Contract 2290 with regard to design, construction, purposes, and functions;
and most of them, such as those for trousers, helmet covers, jumpers, raincoats,
skirts, shirts, slacks, and vests, were for items which were not even remotely
similar to the pantsuit coat (exh. A-1049 through -1074; tr. 2/101-03, 3/23, 5/
196, 8-31-34, 61-62).

C. VECP 2880

84. None of the military specifications upon which appellant bases its
claim for future contract royalties (finding 60) dealt with an item which was
essentially the same as the Air Force woman’s pantsuit coat prescribed in
Contract 2290 with regard to design, construction, purposes, and functions;
and most of them, such as those for coveralls, trunks, parkas, sweaters, smocks,
shirts, slacks, and trousers, were for items which were not even remotely
similar to the pantsuit coat (exh. A-1080 through -1092; tr. 2/101-03, 3/23, 5/
196, 8/31-34, 61-62).

D. All of the VECP’s

85. The Clothing and Textile Directorate of DPSC has never awarded a
low rate initial production contract, and all of its contracts have always been
firm fixed price contracts (tr. 9/63-64).

86. We find no evidence in the record of these appeals to establish that
any of the subject contracts was, or was intended to be, a low rate initial
production contract within the meaning of DAC #76-26 (finding 68) or that
the items procured in any of the subject contracts were involved in any Five
Year Defense Program or other planning documentation at the time any of
appellant’s VECP’s were accepted.

87. Although appellant alleges in its posthearing brief that the
Government acted in bad faith and without a rational basis in actions which
it took concerning the VECP’s which are the subjects of these appeals (findings
49, 60), we find no evidence in the recordd before us which supports that
allegation, and we conclude that the Government’s representatives acted in
good faith and with good and rational cause in all of their actions with regard
to those VECP’s.

$7

DECISION

Although appellant has expended years of effort, culminating in the many
volumes of documentary evidence and the extensive testimony which it has
presented to us in support of its claims in these appeals totalling approximately
$180 million, we find those claims to be wholly without merit.

It is appellant's position that it is entitled to royalties because four of its
five VECP’s 1280, 2181, 2880, and 3380, were constructively accepted by
the Government when the latter implemented the concepts in those proposed
changes on subsequent, or future, contracts (findings 49, 60).

That position, however, is invalid as to three of those VECP’s since there
car.no compensable constructive acceptance of a VECP under future contracts
if a VECP was rejected without bad faith for the contract under which it was
submitted. John J. Kirlin v. United States, 827 F.2d 1538, 1541 (1987): M.
Bianchi of California, ASBCA Nos. 37029 and 37071, 93-1 BCA para. 25,309,
at 126,089; appeal docketed, M. Bianchi of California v. Cheney, No. 93-

1087 (Fed. Cir. 2 Dec. 1992).

Since VECP’s 1280, 2880, and 3380 were rejected under appellant’s
contracts without bad faith on the part of the Government (findings 18, 39,
44, 47, 87), appellant could therefore, as a matter of law, not recover future
contract royalties for those VECP’s even if they had been implemented on
future contracts.

Although VECP 2181 was accepted under Contract 2972 as an alternative
provision, it was not implemented thereunder by appellant (findings 32, °
Consequently, there was no unit cost reduction for that VECP under Contract
2972; and without such instant contract unit cost reduction, there can be no
future contract royalties under the terms of the JO9 clause of the contract
(finding 8), since the basis of future contract royalties is clearly stated in that

clause, at (e)(3)(i) and (iii)(A), to be “the unit cost reduction under this instant
contract.”

Thus, there is no legal basis for appellant to recover future contract
royalties for VECP 2181 even though it had been accepted.

All of these appeals must be denied as to collateral savings since neither
the JO9 clause nor any other clauses in the subject contracts allow the
contractor any compensation therefor (findings 8, 65, 66).

58

Furthermore, none of appellant’s claims are supported by the facts
surrounding them.

Three of these appeals, ASBCA Nos. 37798, 42243, and 42244, deal
with VECP’s (1280, 2181, and 3380) proposing contract changes to permit
the use of Pellon fusible non-woven interlinings in various types of coats.
However, it has been clearly established that at the time appellant submitted
those VECP’s the Government was engaged -- and had b

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386002_0855%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
