# Appendix — Bugg v. United States

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385610_0103%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1944
- **Citation:** 323 U.S. 673

## Text

Re IE ek

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1943

No.

WILSON McCARTHY AND HENRY SWAN, TRUS-
TEES OF THE DENVER & RIO GRANDE WEST-
ERN RAILROAD COMPANY, AND THE DENVER
AND RIO GRANDE WESTERN RAILROAD COM-
PANY, PETITIONERS,

vs.

K. E. BRUNER

ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF UTAH

INDEX.

Record from District Court of Salt Lake County, Utah...... 1 1
CIS on ccc ce yuneca sted s tedenereseeudetencesadss 1 1
Answer of defendant, Denver and Rio Grande Western

pS SERETCEL LUT ET URC CTE OTE 7 6
Answer of defendant trustees ............eeeeeeeeeees 9 7
EE bid sees dee U VUES ehh COCKE CERET UME CEOS SO wREREsHy 10 9
Wiimtbe embry OF tela) 2c ccccccvcccccccccccscccccccces 11 9
Instructions to jury and exceptions thereto............ 12 10
Judgment on Verdict.........seceeeceeeeeceeeeececees 15 13
Notice and motion for a new trial............eseeeeees 16 13
Notice of overruling of motion for new trial............ 17 14
pO SEE SORT TTT a tee TERT TET Tr 17 15
Clerk’s certificate.............. (omitted in printing) .. 18

Jupp & Derweiter (INo.), PRINTERS, WaSHINGTON, D. C., Marcy 9, 1944,

INDEX

Record from District Court of Salt Lake County, Utah—

Continued Original
Portions of the bill of exceptions.............-+e+eeees 19
Appearances ....... seb deebudedes susccceeoendedne 19 .
Testimony of E. E. Beuner eUdpabeoedenenededvesne 19
Exhibit “A”—View of rear end of Engine 1182.. 36
Exhibit “B”’—View of sand house and coal
GED ce ciccccecsevececvenetecetecoseececes 37
Exhibit “E”—View of cinder pit.............. 40
Exhibit “1”—View of front end and left side of
Bingime T1GB occ cccccccccccccccccccvccccccs 56
Exhibit “2”—View of coal chute ............++ 58
Exhibit “3”’—View showing grab-irons of En-
gines 1149 and 1182...........scececeseeers 62
Exhibit “F”—View of rear end of Engine 1182.. 73
Testimony of Charles John Colosimo.............. 75
Exhibit “4”—View of coal chute and sand house 93
Exhibit “5”—View of coal chute............-- 94
Judge’s certification to bill of exceptions........... 99
Proceedings in Supreme Court of Utah..........-+eseeeee- 101
Opinion, Wolfe, C. J... ...cccccccccceecevcceccesecsssccess 101
Opinion, Larson, J. (concurring in part, dlesenting in
GUNG). vsvccevevese ebbedidecedeundececaes sencenaceeenres 109
Tatigment ..cccccccccccccces Sdeddadetdecstavsseerecoeeres 110
Order denying rehearing............ssceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees 110
Instruction No. 15 and defendant’s request for Instruction
No. 5 (filed in District Court of Salt Lake County)....... 111
Praccipe for Tecord ....-cccccccccccccccccccccccvcccsess .
Clerk’s certificate..... weweesebennes (omitted in printing).. 121

Order allowing certiorari ........--+-eeeeerererrerrrrret

[fol. 1]

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE THIRD JUDICIAL
DISTRICT IN AND FOR SALT LAKE COUNTY,
STATE OF UTAH

E. E. Bruner, Plaintiff,
vs.

Witson McCartuy and Henry Swan, Trustees of the Den-
ver & Rio Grande Western Railroad Company, a corpora-
tion, and the Denver & Rio Grande Western Railroad
Company, a corporation, Defendants

CompLaint—Filed February 16, 1942

Plaintiff complains of defendants and for cause of action
alleges:

1. That at all times herein mentioned the defendant, Den-
ver & Rio Grande Western Railroad Company, was, and
now is, a corporation duly organized and existing under and .
by virtue of the laws of the State of Delaware, and au-
thorized to do business in the State of Utah as a foreign
corporation, with its principal place of business in Utah at
Salt Lake City, Utah, and that prior to the occurrence of
the grievances herein complained of, the defendants, Wilson
McCarthy and Henry Swan, were duly appointed trustees
of all of the property of the defendant, Denver & Rio Grande
Western Railroad Company, by the United States District
Court for the District of Colorado in re-organization pro-
ceedings then and therein pending under the provisions of
Section 77, Chapter VIII, of the Federal Bankruptcy Act,
as amended, and that at all times herein mentioned all of
the property of the defendant, Denver & Rio Grande West-
ern Railroad Company, was in the possession and control of
said defendant trustees, and said defendant trustees ever
since their said appointment have been, and now are, op-
erating the railroad and all of the property of the defend-
[fol. 2] ant, Denver & Rio Grande Western Railroad Com-
pany, under the orders and directions of the said United
States District Court.

2. That at all times herein mentioned the defendants were
acting as a common carrier by railroad and engaged in in-

1—828

2

terstate commerce, and the plaintiff was employed by the
defendants in said interstate commerce, and the injuries to
plaintiff hereinafter complained of arose in the course of,
and while plaintiff and said defendants were engaged in the
conduct of interstate commerce.

3. That this action is brought under and by virtue of the
provisions of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, 45
U.S. C. A. 51 et seq.

4. That at all times during the 1st day of December, 1941,
and at the time of the occurrence of the grievances herein
set forth, plaintiff was employed by the defendants as a
hostler’s helper, and was engaged in the performance of
his duties under such employment in the yards of the de-
fendant corporation at Grand Junction, in the State of Col-
orado. That at about 5:15 o’clock A. M. on said 1st day of
December, 1941, and while the vicinity of the accident herein
described was enveloped in darkness, the plaintiff was or-
dered by one, Charles Colosimo, who was then and there
employed by the defendant as a hostler, and who was at said
time and place plaintiff’s immediate superior, to assist said
Colosimo in servicing defendants’ Engines No. 1182 and
No. 1149 and moving said engines from the roundhouse and
cinder pit of the defendant corporation at Grand Junction,
Colorado, to the stations where they had been assigned for
use in the movement and the handling of interstate com-
merce by defendants. That, among other things, the said
Colosimo ordered plaintiff to assist him in the sanding of
Engine No. 1182 and in the placing of coal in the tender of
each of said engines. That said engines were at said time
[fol. 3] coupled together and were being then and there
operated upon tracks which ran in an easterly and westerly
direction. That Engine No. 1149 was to the west and En-
gine No. 1182 to the east, and both engines were facing east-
ward and were being propelled and moved by Engine No.
1149. That said Colosimo was operating Engine No. 1149
and the plaintiff was in Engine No. 1182. That after said
Colosimo had spotted Engine No. 1182 under the sand
tower, and sand had been placed in the sand dome of said
Engine No. 1182, the said Colosimo then and there drove
and propelled said Engine No. 1149, to which Engine No.
1182 was attached and coupled, as aforesaid, westward until
the tender of said Engine No. 1149 was directly underneath

3

a coal chute from which coal was conveyed from bins sit-
uated on the south side of said tracks to the tenders of the
engines. That while coal was being placed in the tender of
Engine No. 1149 by the said Colosimo, the plaintiff after
checking the water level, steam pressure and fire of said
Engine No. 1182, got down from the left hand side of the
cab of said engine, went to the rear end of the tender of
said engine and proceeded to climb up on the tender of said
engine in order to reach a position from which he could by
proper signals direct said Colosimo in the movements of
said engines, to the end that the tender of Engine No. 1182
could be spotted under the coal chute, when the said Col-
osimo did suddenly and without warning and in a careless,
heedless and reckless manner, cause said Engines to be
moved and propelled westward, thereby and thus causing
the plaintiff to lose his balance and to be thrown from the
rear of the tender of Engine No. 1182 onto the rails in front
of the moving wheels of said engine, and that the wheels of
said Engine No. 1182 passed over the left leg of plaintiff,
causing him to suffer injury and damages as herein alleged.

5. That the said defendants and each and all of them were
careless, reckless and negligent at said time and place in
[fol. 4] the operation and maintenance of said locomotives
in the following particulars :

A. That at said time and place the defendants, acting
through an agent, servant and employee, other than the
plaintiff, suddenly, unexpectedly and without giving or
sounding any warning, either by bell, whistle or otherwise,
started said engines, thereby causing plaintiff to lose his
balance and to be thrown from the rear of said Engine No.
1182 onto the rails in front of the moving wheels of said
Engine, causing Plaintiff to suffer injury and damages as
herein set forth.

B. That the said Colosimo, then and there acting as
agent, employee and representative of the defendants, and
each of them, suddenly, unexpectedly and without warning,
moved said engines without knowing whether or not said
engines could be moved without endangering the plaintiff,
as a result whereof the plaintiff was thrown from the rear
of said Engine No. 1182 onto the tracks immediately in
front of the moving wheels of said Engine No. 1182, caus-
ing him to suffer injury and damage as herein set forth.

C. That at the time of the occurrence of the grievance
herein set forth, and prior thereto, there existed a custom
well known to and recognized and followed by all of the
hostlers engaged in the movement of engines and trains in
defendants’ yards at Grand Junction, Colorado, and that
according to said custom and practice, a hostler would never
start or move an engine until he had received a signal to
proceed given by the hostlers helper. That the said Col-
esimo, then and there acting as the agent, servant and rep-
resentative of the defendants, as aforesaid, suddenly, un-
expectedly and without getting any sign or signal to move
said engines from the plaintiff, who was then and there the
helper of said Colosimo, caused said engines to be moved
westward, as a result whereof the plaintiff was thrown from
the rear end of Engine No. 1182 and onto the track im-
{fol.5] mediately in front of the moving wheels of said
Engine, causing him to suffer injury and damage as herein
set forth.

D. That prior to the occurrence of the grievances herein
set forth, to-wit, on the Ist day of January, 1938, the de-
fendants had adopted, promulgated and published certain
rules and regulations of the operating department of said
defendant. That said rules were in full force and effect
at all times during the first day of December, 1941, and
that Section 30 thereof provided as follows:

‘‘The bell must be rung when an engine is about to
move and while approaching and passing stations, tun-
nels, snow sheds and public crossing at grade.’’

That ia violation of said rule, and withort giving any
warning by bell, whistle or otherwise, the said Charles
Colosimo, then and there acting as the agent and servant
of the defendants, as aforesaid, suddenly and unexpectedly
started said engine, thereby causing plaintiff to lose his
balance and te be thrown from the rear end of Engine No.
1182 and onto the track immediately in front of the moving
wheels of said Engine causing him to suffer injury and
damage as herein set forth.

E. That prior to the occurrence of the grievances herein
set forth, to-wit, on the Ist day of December, 1938, the de-
fendants adopted, promulgated and published certain safety
rules governing employees in the operating department, and
all other employees as may be required to observe said rules,

5

and that said rules and all of them were in full force and
effect at the time of the grievances herein set forth. That
one of said safety rules, namely, Section 2057, provided
as follows, to-wit:

‘‘Engine bell or whistle warning must be given be-
fore engines are moved, then wait at least one minute.’’

That in violation of said rules, and without giving any
warning by bell, whistle or otherwise, the said Colosimo
suddenly, unexpectedly and without warning, started said
engines, thereby and thus causing plaintiff to lose his
[fol. 6] balance and to be thrown from the rear end of En-
gine No. 1182 and onto the track immediately in front of
the moving wheels of said Engine No. 1182, causing plain-
tiff + suffer injury and damages as herein set forth.

6. That the aforesaid negligent, careless, heedless and
reckless conduct on the part of the defendants acting
through an agent, servant and representative other than
the plaintiff herein, in the use, maintenance, management
and OPOD

44

By Mr. Rawlings:

Q. Will you please explain to the jury what you mean by
‘spotting the engine for sand’’?

A. That is when you get the sand spout even with the
sand spout on the engine, or in that particular move, or
whatever place you want to put it, if you want it spotted at
a certain place you spot it at that place. That is what they
call ‘‘spotting the engine for sand or water’’. If it is water
you get it even with the tank. They call that spotting the
engine at any certain place that you have to have it spotted
to do your work.

Q. You placed yourself in a position where the hostler
could see your lantern and signals, so you could properly
signal for the spotting of that engine?

A. Yes, that is correct.

Q. When you spotted for coal where was it necessary for
you to be for the hostler to see you?

A. I would have to be on top of the tank so I could tell
when it got even with the apron; I would have to be on top
of the tank to make the proper spot.

Q. Was there « !adder provided on the tank for the pur-
pose of you climbing up and to be in position to spot the
car?

A. On the rear end of the tank, it is there to climb to the
top of the tank.

Q. Will you point that ladder out to us?

The Court: I believe that was indicated on direct exami-
nation by Mr. Black.

Q. There appears at the rear of 1182 a ladder—is that the
ladder that is used for that purpose of climbing up there
so you can spot for coal?

A. Yes sir.

{fol. 44] By Mr. Black:

Q. Mr. Bruner, what did you intend to do when you got
down from the cab of Engine 1182?

Mr. Bruner, during the time you worked in the yards as
hostler and hostler’s helper, what, in the ordinary course
of your employment there, would you do or be expected to
do and instructed to do, under those circumstances?

A. I was supposed——

Q. Mr. Bruner, what was the custom and practice?

A. The custom and practice for the hostler, do you mean?
. Yes.

4 Whenever you have a movement to make the hostler
would make the movement, we would make it in the usual
way, the practice that we do operate, the way we generally
do; it is an everyday occurrence.

Q. What was the custom and practice where you were
coaling two engines, both headed toward the east, where
the coal was placed in the west engine first?

A. Outside of where you make the stop where he did, the
hostler’s helper would be up there to take the coal, but
when he had instructed me not to be there, naturally I was
up on the engine that he had told me to take coal on. Other-
wise, if the helper is to take coal he would be back on that
engine to take the coal.

Q. Did you have any instructions with reference to the
engine you were to take coal on?

A. He told me I was to take coal on Engine 1182, and he
would take coal on Engine 1149, and he instructed me to
take coal on 1182.

Q. In the ordinary course of your employment, how
would you perform your duties, how would you do that?

By Mr. Black:

Mr. Bruner, had you ever coaled engines at this coal
chute before?

A. Yes.

Q. Had you ever coaled two engines connected together,
facing toward the east, before?

A. Yes.

Q. Were you acquainted with the custom and practice of
the operation at that time?

A. Yes.

Q. And, in accordance with the custom and practice, and

your usual custom, what would be your duties and how
would you perform them in accordance with that custom
and practice?
(fol. 45] A. I would place myself on the engine tank that
was to be coaled. In order to give a signal to the hostler
so he eould make the proper stop, I would have to be on
top of the tank, and get myself in a position where he
could see me, to get the signals to operate on.

Q. From what position would you give the signal?

A. On top of the tank.

Q. What signal would you give?

A. A back-up signal, around, like this, a back-up signal.
Whenever you get the coal apron in line with where the
coal had to be dropped in the engine, I would give the stop
signal. I would have to be on top of the engine in order to
see where to spot the apron, and alsc to give the signals
where to stop.

{fol. 46] Cross-examination.
By Mr. Jensen:

Q. Now, Mr. Bruner, I understond you to say that you
had seen Colosimo in and about Grand Junction during
the period that you worked there, prior to the time you
worked on this night?

. Just in the jobs, seeing him coming and going.

. Did you speak to him?

Once in a while spoke.

You saw him around?

Yes.

Like you had a lot of the other men?

. That is all.

I think you said that on this particular day the en-
gine caller had told you about this job being open, and you
could take it if you wanted it?

. The engine dispatcher.

. The engine dispatcher?

Yes.

? you were assigned to work with Colosimo?

. Yes.

You went on shift at what time?

. Eleven P. M.

You did outside work all that time?

. The job was what they call a swing job, but they paid
the outside pay, because they had to go to the main line if
they are needed. They were classed as outside hostlers.

Q You picked up these two locomotives at the cinter pit
—that is, one of them was at the cinder pit, and the other
one you brought down from the roundhouse?

A. The inside hostler brought it down and hooked it on
1149. He brought 1182 down.

9. These two locomotives were coupled together; is that
right?

>

Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A
Q.

>POPOPOPop>

. Yes.

. 1149 at the rear and 1182 in front?

. Yes.

. You got on 1182; is that right?

. Thatis right. .

. And you got on the front end?

. I was in the cab when Mr. Colosimo came up and gave
me instructions—I was in the cab.
[fol.47] Q. Do you remember whether you got over the

ilot?

. A. I don’t remember whether I got over, only I got into
the engine, I remember I was in the cab when Mr. Colosimo
came up. In getting on the engine, to begin with, I may
have gone over the engine to check the sand. Sometimes I
do that.
. This is the sand dome. Is that the first dome?
. With most engines it is the front dome.
The dome sets up about like that?
. A little larger.
Then you have another dome back here? ©
Yes.
Which is the steam dome?

©

A
Q.
A
Q.
A.
Q.

>
=

Q. Of course, this is the stack?

A. Yes.

Q. Then you have your pilot about like that?

A. Yes.

Q. Now, on 1182, as you remember isn’t it a combination
pilot and switch engine combined?

A. Yes.

Q. So that the pilot or bar is across, and on either side
there are steps that you can step on, then there are some
steps that go up here?

A. Yes, up to the running board.

Q. Then there is a running board that runs back like
that; is that right?

A. Yes.

Q. That is the running board you were talking about
when Mr. Black was asking you questions?

A. Yes.

Q. Now, up here you have a hand-rail, haven’t you?

A. Yes.

Q. And that hand-rail goes down so that when you step
up here a couple of steps, you could walk up here and hold

on the rail, and walk on the running board; is that right?

A. Yes.

[fol. 48] Q. Now, about at this point you have a window,
haven’t you?

A. Yes, and a little door.

Q. And the engineer sits about here?

A. Yes.

Q. Of course, this window sticks out; it looks out toward
the front of the locomotive?

A. Yes.

Q. You can walk from that running board through that
window, and get into the cab; is that right?

A. Yes.

Q. By the way, has 1182 got a stoker on it, or is it hand
fired?

A. Some of those engines are hand fired, some are not.
I believe that is one of the stoker engines.

Q. You don’t need to take my word, but they do hand
fire?

A. Some of the engines are stokers and some are not.
I don’t remember which ones were hand fired, and which
were stoker.

Q. In the cab you had curtains on that cab, didn’t you?

A. Yes.

Q. Of course, your tender or your tank, whatever you
call it—there is a space between the tank and the cab?

A. Yes.

Q. And of course, this goes up into a gangway, then there
is the deck of your cab in there; is that correct?

A. Yes.

Q. Then you have some gates in this tender, about up this
high, so that when you fill it with coal the coal will not run
down onto the deck of the cab; is that right?

A. Yes.

Q. Of course, you have some curtains here that hang
down over this point, around the side, so when you are
running coal and water this curtain hangs over the gang-
way, so the cold air won’t get in?

A. You have curtains on the side, too.

Q. Short curtains down from the cab to the top of the

A. They are pretty long.

49

{fol. 49] Q. There is a ring around there?

A. They slide back. There is board across it. They drop
it down into the coal tank. It comes clear into the tank, that
curtain, with a board across it.

Q. Mr. Bruner, of course this entire tank holds two things
—¢oal and water?

A. Yes.

Q. The coal comes up only to about this point?

A. Yes.

Q. So then you have got it about like that?

A. Yes, that is near enough.

Q. That holds coal?

A. Yes.

Q. And the rest of it is all water?

A. Yes.

Q. Now, if we were looking down on the top of this tank,
this tender, rather, if we were up above it, and could look
down into the top of it, it would look something like this,
wouldn’t it?

A. Well, except for your coal that goes clear across.

Q. Isn’t there a water jacket on either side?

A. That is at the top.

Q. So lower down there is a jacket, but the one compart-
ment is about like that?

A. It goes straight across.

Q. This tank part?

A. Yes.

Q. You have a hole here where you take water?

A. Yes.

Q. This is the coal place?

A. Yes.

Q. Now, on that particular 1182 there is a little kind
of a house up there that the head brakeman rides in?

A. Some engines have it on; some do not.

Q. 1182 is a road engine?

[fol. 50] A. A road engine.

Q. 1149 was strictly a switch engine?

A. Yes.

Q. When you took the sand, you had to get up on top?

A. I was inside of the cab before we moved back. I went
from the cab out.

Q. I understand you were inside the cab when you and
Mr. Colosimo had the discussion what you were to do?

4—828

50

A. Yes, we waited for them to complete the cleaning
work.

Q. He told you they did not have to take 1149 for sand?

A. Yes.

Q. He said they had to take sand on 1182, so you were
to stay with 1182; and that he would coal 1149 and you
would coal 1182?

A. Yes.

Q. Ordinarily—I think you said this before—it would
be your business to go back and coal both locomotives if he
had wanted you to do it?

A. If he had told me to, I would.

Q. It was your business?

A. Yes.

Q. That was a part of your duties?

A. My duty was to do whatever he told me to.

Q. If he had told you to go back on 1149, the locomotive
he was on, and coal that locomotive, you would have to go
back and do it?

A. Yes.

Q. But he told you to stay on 1182 and he would take the
coal on 1149; is that right?

A. He told me he would take coal on 1149, and for me
to coal 1182.

Q. Yes. All right, now you say you were in the cab when
that took place?

A. Yes.

Q. Did you go there when he came along?

A. I was when he came up; I was in the cab of 1182, and
he came by and told me that.

Q. How far is it from this board walk here on this run-
way, or whatever you call it, up to the top of the cab?
{fol.51] A. They are different heights, I don’t recall just
how high that would be.

Q. It would not be over four feet?

A. About five feet, I imagine, or six. They are at dif-
ferent heights.

Q. We are speaking of 1100 engines.

A. That is what it was. It would be probably five feet,
or a little more.

Q. How far would it be from the top of the tender to
the top of the cab?

A. Probably a step down there, two and a half, or three,
possibly.

51

Q. Do you remember how much coal you had in the
tender?

A. As a rule there is about—I can’t tell exactly how
much there is there, but they had to be coaled. I don’t
recall how much was in there.

Q. You don’t recall how much there was in there?

A. Because he told me it had to be coaled. When you
take coal on you take whatever is needed, regardless of
what is the amount. You take whatever amount is needed.

Q. Did you have occasion to observe the coal in these
tenders, to determine how much there was in them?

A. Not right then?

Q. Did you at any time, or do you know?

A. No; because you generally do that, when you take
the coal on, when you judge the amount they take and tell
the hostler the amount they take, because he has to keep a
record of it.

Q. Did you have occasion to close those doors?

A. They have to be closed before you take the coal. They
were closed. I observed they were closed.

Q. You observed they were closed?

A. Yes.

Q. Of course, they had to be closed at the cab side?

A. Yes.

Q. You can close them from the other side, but not lock
them?

A. That is right.

Q. They were locked from the cab side?

A. Yes.

(fol. 52] Q. He talked to you about how you would do it,
that you would go to the sand house and you would sand
this 1182, and then you would move down to the coal yard,
and he would coal 1149, and then they would spot 1182, and
you would coal 1182?

A. Yes.

Q. Is that correct?

A. Yes.

Q. Where were you going to take those locomotives?

A. We had to go there, to that one switching, to go to
~ — Those engines go to the yards——

. Yes.

A. (Continued.) And the 1182 would have to be set over
on another track, up at the water track.

Q. It was to go where?

52

A. On the south yard.

Q. It was going to Glenwood?

A. To Delta. Once in a while they change those runs.
He said that was a road engine, anyhow it was going out,
I could not be definite on that. They have used them
both ways.

Q. Where were you when you rode down from the sand
house to the cinder pit?

A. I was on the running-board, yet, of the engine. I
got down.

Q. From the cinder pit to the sand house?

A. I got out on the running-board.

Q. As you rode down there you rode on this running-
board ; is that correct?

A. Yes,

Q. All right. Did you give him a signal to stop at the
sand house?

A. Yes sir.

Q. When you got down to the sand house you had to get
up on top of the boiler, didn’t you?

A. Yes.

Q. And you have to lift the top of this sand dome here?

A. Yes.

Q. It hangs there by a chain, so they will not fall off?

A. Yes.

{fol. 53] Q. Then you pull the spout down from the sand
house, and when it gets full you lift the spout out?

A. Yes.

Q. Then you had to put the top on that sand dome?

A. That is right.

Q. By the way, do you remember when you started this
movement what time of the day it was?

A. I did not notice the exact time, no.

Q. Have you any idea of the time it took you up to the
time you got hurt; was it a half hour, do you think?

A. Doing that work?

Q. From the time you left the cinder pit till you got
hurt?

A. It only takes I suppose not over five minutes to
take sand, I would say—No, it would not be half an hour.

Q. Well, you only had to move fifteen feet from the
cinder pit to the sand house?

A. Yes.

Q. Then you had to drift on down to the coal chute?
About how long did it take you to take coal, have you any
idea?

A. No.

Q. Do you remember how long it took you to take coal
on that occasion, on 1149?

A. It seemed it did not take long.

Q. Did it take a minute or two—you were there?

A. I was, yes, I was not timing it, of course, I was doing
my work.

Q. What is your best judgment?

A. It generally takes a little longer than that, I guess.

Q. All right. Of course, you had to let him know when
you got through sanding this locomotive, didn’t you?

A. Yes.

Q. So you gave him a signal to back up?

A. Sure.

Q. Where were you when you gave him that signal?

A. I was still on the running-board. I got down.

Q. You got down on the running-board?

A. Yes.

[fol. 54] Q. Then, when they started back up, what did
you do?

A. I went into the cab, then, by the time I got down there,
I was getting in the cab, I was on the outside, and then when
we started I went inside through the cab then and checked
my fire and sieam.

Q. It really was not any of your business to check the
fire, was it?

A. Yes, because there are lots of time- they will go out.
The engine will be ready to go out and it will have a dead
fire.

Q. Before you made this movement, Colosimo had got
up in the cab?

A. He came to the gangway, he did not get clear into the
engine.

Q. You checked the fire. All you did was to open the
doors and look in at the fire; is that right?

A. Yes.

Q. That door is opened automatically, isn’t it? You
step on a lever and the door opens?

A. They are some of them, but some of them are opened
by hand. If the air is on——

54

Q. Yow don’t recall whether the air was on, or whether
you opened it by air or by hand?

A. I believe I opened it by hand.

A. Is that door one of the doors that splits, and part goes
up and part down? It goes on hinges?

A. Some of them will open like a butterfly door. Some
of them will open out from the middle and go both ways,
and some sideways.

Q. But they do not swing out on hinges?

A. No.

Q. They part somewhere in the middle and go up or
down, either way? ;

A. That is rignt.

Q. You opened the door and looked in the fire; is that
correct?

A. Yes.

Q. You saw the fire was going all right?

A. Yes.

Q. Did you turn off the biower?

A. Yes.

Q. Now, the blower is merely a fan that blows air through
the firebox, and creates a draft, is that right?

[fol. 55] A. No, it is steam that comes out of the pipe up
in the smoke stack that creates that draft.

Q. In other words, it blows the air out of the stack, and
a part goes through there?

A. There is a part of it goes around at the bottom of the
smokestack, and the steam is going through there.

Q. You turn that off by closing the valves in the cab?

A. Yes; you turn it to the left and close it.

Q. Left-handed threads?

A. It turns to the right; I guess you are right. You turn
it to the right to close it, I was mistaken.

Q. You turn it to the left to open it?

A. Yes.

Q. What else did you do?

A. I saw that there was plenty of water.

Q. There is a glass?

A. Yes, you look in the glass to see if there is water in
the boiler.

Q. All you had to do to see if there was water in the
boiler was to take a look at it?

A. Yes; and there is a valve.

Q. Did you open the valve?

A. I don’t believe I did. As a rule, if you can see the
water you don’t have to do it.

Q. The water is absolutely stationary; so you open the
valve and blow the water up, or you close the valve and
the water will come back in the glass so you can see it, is that

Q. How long do you think it took you to do all that?

A. It would not take very long to do that.

Q. About thirty seconds at the outside, isn’t that right?

A. It would probably be a little longer than that, I would
not know exactly, without timing it. I don’t know how
long it would take.

Q. You say there are two aprons at the coal chute?

A. Yes.

Q. But those aprons are not sufficiently far apart so you
can coal two locomotives at once?

[fol. 56] aprons you told us about, aren’t they?

A. Yes sir.

Mr. Jensen: I wonder if you would re-mark this, and put
this number up here, becanse we might have to tear that
off.

{fol. 58] (Exhibit re-marked, as indicated.)

Mr. Jensen: Do you gentlemen have any objection to
this photograph, now?

Mr. Rawlings: Let me see it again.

Mr. Black: It is looking toward the west?

Mr. Jensen: That is right. I offer Exhibit ‘‘2’’, if your
Honor please. :

Mr. Rawlings: No objection.

The Court: It may be received.

(Here follows 1 photolithograph, Exhibit ‘‘2’’)

ig

O8A

By Mr. Jensen:

Q. Do you remember how far this coal chute extends
along the track, or do you have any judgment about it,
at all?

A. You mean the width of the coal chute?

Q. I mean from this point to that point?

A. I don’t imagine it is over thirty-five or forty feet.

Q. About thirty-five or forty feet?

A. That would be my guess. I could be wrong.

Q. So that when these two locomotives were stopped, a
part of 1149 was east of the coal chute, and the entire por-
tion of 1182 was east of the coal chute; isn’t that correct?

A. Yes.

Q. You don’t know whether the stop was made at the first.
or second apron?

A. I never looked to be definite about that part of it. I
believe that is where he stopped, though.

Q. Those aprons—as I understand it, you pull them
down?

A. Yes.

Q. They are big steel slides; is that correct?

A. They are steel, they are about two and a half feet
wide, eight inches high, or some such a matter.

Q. Something like the coalmen used to use in Salt Lake
when they used to unload coal over the sidewalk; they had a
long steel chute?

A. Yes, only these are not so long.

Q. You pull this apron down so it is inclined towards the
tank?

A. Yes.

(fol. 59] Q. Then you pull another chain which lets the
coal into the apron?

A. Yes.

Q. It slides down until you have enough coal and then
you pull the chain?

A. You let go of the chain.

Q. Then the apron comes up?

A. Yes. Sometimes you have to lift it.

Q. But it is counterweighted so it goes up out of the
way; is that right?

A. Yes.

Q. Does that coal make much noise going down?

A. Not the slack does not.

Q. The slack does not?

A. No.

Q. Lump coal does?

A. If there isn’t slack in it. Ordinarily there is no need
of a great amount of noise.

Q. Do you remember hearing Colosimo take coal on this
night in question?

A. I don’t remember any noise about it, no sir. You
can take coal without making any noise. I don’t remember
of him making any undue noise.

Q. You don’t know?

A. Because he could have done it while I was in the cab,
or somewhere; I don’t remember any great out-of-the-way
noise.

Q. When you take that coal do you stand on the coal
pile or on the top of the tank?

A. Asa rule you are right on the coal. It would be a part
of the back of the tank. You would stand on a part of the
coal there toward the back of the tank.

Q. So you stand on the part of the coal toward the back
of the tank?

A. Yes.

Q. As the coal comes in off the apron, it spreads over the
tank, is that right?

A. Yes.

Q. That is within the coal compartment?

A. Sure.

Q. Now, you did not give Colosimo any stop signal when
he spotted that locomotive at the coal chute, did you?

(fol. 60] A. No.

Q. Where were you when the locomotive stopped?

A. I was just getting into the cab of the 1182.

Q. Just getting into the cab of 1182?

A. Yes, just getting in.

Q. Was it your duty to check the water?

A. Yes; we have to see the locomotives have water so they
will not blow up. If they get low on water the hostler is
responsible.

Q. Was it your duty to shut this blower off?

A. When there is nobody else around we always have to
take care of them, with that part of it. That is the practice,
if we happen to be there and it is handy.

Q. You got down on the left-hand side, is that right?

A. Yes.

Q. And wert around to the rear end of 11821

A. Yes sir.

Q. Now, in order to get up on the tank you had to cross
the drawbar?

A. Naturally.

Q. I think Mr. Black asked you about this Exhibit ‘‘A’’;
I think you are a little mixed up, or else I misund¢rstood
you. There are two rods—there appear to be two rods
going across just above the drawbar?

A. Yes.

Q. One of those is the rod by which you pull the pin in the
coupler; is that right?

A. Yes.

Q. Then the rod above that is the grab-iron?

A. Yes.

Q. I think you said this morning, although I am not
positive about it, that both of these were grab-irons?

A. That is the one he was referring to (indicating).

Q. Oh, I see, excuse me ; but that bottom rod you see above
the coupler on either side of the coupler, what do you
eall that?

A. The pin lifter.

Q. It drops down so they can grab that, to lift the pin
in the coupler?

{fol.61] A. Yes, there is a handle on the outside, out in
here there is a handle, you see, to pull the pin on this coupler,
to couple or leave the engines uncoupled.

Q. The rod going across the back part of the locomotive is
the handhold or grab-iron?

A. Yes.

Q. That appears to come down the side of the tank, across
the tank and up the other side?

A. This grab-iron going down the corner of the tank
is separate from this. Then this grab-iron is hooked to
the tank and this one is hocked to the crossbar.

Mr. Rawlings: I don’t think the jury saw that.

By Mr. Jensen:

Q. In any event, there is a grab-iron that goes all the
way across the tank?
A. Yes.

Q. The grab-iron that goes down either side of the tank
at the corner?

A. Yes.

Q. Whether there is one grab-iron or three—well, at least,
there are three grab-irons there?

A. Yea.

Q. Now, I show you what has been marked Exhibit ‘‘3’’,
you will notice the figure at the left, you can see ‘‘1182’’?

A. Yes.

Q. Now, as a matter of fact, Mr. Bruner, the locomotive,
the front end of which is shown here, is actually a picture
of 1149, does that look to you like a fair representation of
1182 and the front end of 1149, coupled together?

A. Yes.

Q. Would you say that was about the condition as it ex-
isted on the night of the accident?

A. Yes.

Q. This picture was taken from the side that you at-
tempted to get up on that tank from; is that correct?

A. That is right.

Q. This was taken from the north side?

A. Yes.

Q. Or, at least, it would have been the north side on
that particular track?

A. Yes.

[fol. 62] Q. Faced in that direction?

A. Yes, facing east.

Mr. Rawlings: Are you offering this now?
Mr. Jensen: Yes.

Mr. Black: No objection.

The Court: It may be admitted.

(Here follows 1 photolithograph, Exhibit ‘‘3’’)

Exaursrr ‘‘3’’

By Mr. Jensen:

Q. Of course, that shows the footboards on the rear end
of 1182 and the front end of 1149?

A. Yes.

Q. And it shows the two locomotives coupled together?

A. Yes.

Q. It also shows this grab-iron we were talking about a
few minutes ago?

A. Yes.

Q. Both grab-irons?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Mr. Bruner, I think yesterday you said that when
these two locomotives came to a stop, down there at the
coal chute, that you gave no signal for that stop?

A. That is right.

Q. The reason you gave no signal was that you knew
Colosimo was going to take coal on the 1149, and he could
stop his own locomotive; is that correct?

A. Yes sir.

Q. But you did give him a signal before you Jeft the sand
house, because you wanted to indicate to him tnat you had
completed taking the sand on 1182?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And when you left the cinder pit you gave him a signal
and then he whistled off—is that right—to show he was
going to back up?

A. He gave the signal, I believe the customary thing to
do is to answer the whistle.

Q. In fact, when he backed up from the cinder pit he did
give three blasts of the whistle?

A. That is the customary thing to do.

Q. Did he do it on that occasion?

(fol. 63] A. It is the customary thing to do. I believe he
must have as long as it is the customary thing to do I believe
he must have.

Q. Around that cinder pit you have fire knockers?

A. Yes.

Q. Are the fire builders there, too? :

A. The fire builders are in the house; but when they clean
the fire they gerzrally leave enough coals in there so it will
start, and catch up in due time.

i

64

Q. But there are men working around the cinder pits
who knock the fires, clean them, and so on?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Shake the clinders out?

A. Yes.

Q. Knock them out of those long bars?

A. Yes; it is necessary to get the clinkers out.

Q. Was there anybody around the sand house other
than you two fellows?

A. There may have been somebody working in the sand
house, I did not pay any attention to that.

Q. There were no other locomotives there or anybody
working around the track, that you saw?

A. There are engines coming and going all the time on
the south side of the coal chute, they operate that, and the
track to the north.

Q. Did you see anybody else around the sand house, other
then you two, when you were there?

A. I never took any particular notice of anybody around
the sand house; but they could have been inside.

Q. But you did not see anyone?

A. No, not that I remember of.

Q. There were not any other locomotives being coaled
at the coal chute, were there?

A. Not when we backed up there, no.

Q. In fact, up until you were taken out, or till the time
that you lost interest in everything, you did not see any
other locomotives around?

A. There were engines coming from the roundhouse after
we backed up from the cinder pit. Naturally they would
put other engines on there.

{fol. 64] Q. I did not ask you what they naturally do. Did
you see any other locomotives around the coal chute while
you were there?

A. They could be on the opposite side of the coal chute,
and I could not see them.

Q. I did not ask you that. I asked you if you saw them?

A. No, I did not observe any, in particular.

Q. Do you remember which glass it was that you examined
to see what the water level was in the boiler? Was it the
glass on the fireman’s side or the engineer’s?

A. It was on the fireman’s side.

65

Q.- You got down from the running-board, through the
engineer’s side of the cab?

A. Yes.

Q. You got down on the deck of the locomotive and
looked in the blower, turned off the blower, and examined
the glass?

A. I checked the water, and the fire first, then I let the
blower run a little bit, to finish catching up a little better,
I let it run a little to be sure it was caught.

Q. Then you got down on the fireman’s side of the cab?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And walked down on the north side, the left-hand side
of the locomotive?

A. Yes sir.

Q. To the rear of 1182?

A. Yes sir.

Q. The fireman sits on the left-hand side of the cab, does
he not?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And, of course, the engineer sits on the right-hand
side?

A. Yes sir.

Q. That is true of all locomotives?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And of course when I say the left-hand and right-hand
side I mean looking toward the front end of the locomotive?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Then you walked to the rear of 1182?

A. Yes sir.

(fol. 65] Q. And did you step up on the footboard, or did
you step between?

A. Right onto the footboard.

Q. Right onto the footboard?

A. Yes.

Q. You were in the act of climbing over the drawbar
when the two locomotives were moved?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You do not have any particular memory as to how
you fell, do you?

A. No, Iam rather confused.

Q. It happened rather suddenly?

A. That is right.

5—828

Q. Of course, you were not taking time to think of all the
motions you were going through; is that correct?

A. That is correct.

Q. You say there was not any sudden jerk of the engine?

A. There is always a jerk when we start out.

Q. There was not anything unusual about the jerk; it
was about the same sort of a jerk that would be made
on the movement of any locomotive under those circum-
stances?

A. Under those circumstances there would be a sudden
jerk, regardless. It would be a sudden jerk.

Q. I understand, because there is a certain amount of play
between the extension of couplers?

A. Yes.

Q. When you start pulling away you have to take up this
slack and then the locomotive gives a jerk before it starts
moving?

A. Yes.

Q. That takes place every time there is a movement;
isn’t that so?

the way, did you have your lantern with you?

A. Yes.

Q. hy

A.

Q. ie you remember whether or not it was lit?
A. Ye — it was.

Q. It was

A. Y
{fol.
I
_

A.
ried

Q. Do you remember making a statement about this
lantern, Mr. Bruner?

A. I remember something about it. When they came
up there to the hospital one time I believe that I told then:
I did not remember for sure on account of——

Q. I did not ask you that. I asked you if you remember
making a statement about it?

A. Yes.

Q. You did not sign the statement?

A. One statement I did.

Q. One statement; but do you remember Mr. Divisek
going up and talking to you sometime in December, 1941,
do you remember him coming and talking to you?

es.
66] Q. Are you sure about that?

feel quite sure that it was, because I always car-
lit.

Mr. Rawlings: What was that day?
Mr. Jensen: December 31, 1941.

A. I believe that is when I was in Denver, I believe that is
when you have reference to.

Q. You went up to see Dr. Curfman?

A. Yes.

Q. He is the chief surgeon of The Denver & Rio Grande?

A. Yes.

Q. While you were there you talked to Mr. Divisek, or he
talked to you?

A. Yes; they asked me to come up to the office.

Q. I call your attention to a statement made on De-
cember 20, 1941, and particularly to the last sheet of it
where there is some handwriting. That is your signature,
isn’t it, Mr. Bruner?

A. That is my signature.

Q. That is your handwriting?

A. No sir.

Q. Was that written in when you signed that statement?

A. I believe it was, yes, by somebody; but, at the time I
could not read the statement myself, I was unable to read
at the time.

[fol. 67] Q. You did talk to somebody about this, on De-
cember 20, 1941, didn’t you?

. Yes, while I was still in bed.

Mr. Headley—R. B. Headley?

Yes.

And a lady by the name of Ada M. Hall?

. I don’t recall the names.

Was that at the hospital?

. That was at my home.

. He talked to you about it, and then ¢ statement was
written up on the typewriter; is that correct?

A. They took it in shorthand, then they went and typed
it out and came back and wanted me to sign it.

Q. Did they read it to you?

A. They did not, no.

Q. Did somebody read it to you?

A. My wife’s sister read, but I was in such pain I could
not tell all that was going on.

Q. That was the day after you were married, wasn’t it?
You were married on the 19th of December, weren’t youn—
1941?

>

O pO PO Pro

A. That sounds about right—the 21st, I believe.

Q. It sounds about right?

A. The 21st I believe would be correct.

Q. And on December 20th was when these people came
down and talked to you about it?

A. That is right; that is according to your dates, if that is
correct,

Q. At that time, to these people there, Mr. Headley and
Miss Hall, did you say in substance or effect that you had
an electric lantern with you at the time of the accident, but
you did not know if it was lighted, or not?

A. I may have made some statement to that effect, but I
was in such pain there that it is hard to state just exactly
what I did say.

Q. Mr. Bruner, just a moment ago when I was talking
about the statement, before I found it, didn’t you make the
statement here in court that you told somebody that you had
a lantern with you, but you did not know whether or not
it was lighted ; didn’t you make that statement ten or fifteen
minutes ago?

A. Possibly.

{fol. 68] Q. You are not in pain now, are you?

A. It still hurts, yes, but not as severe as it was.

Q. You say now that you did have a lantern with you?

A. Yes sir, I know I had it with me.

Q. You say now that that lantern was lit?

A. I feel quite certain that it was lit.

Q. You feel absolutely positive that it was lit?

A. Yes.

Q. Do you know whether or not your lantern was broken
when you fell?

A. I could not find my lantern after I fell, I could not
find it.

Q. Mr. Haynie picked it up, didn’t he?

A. That is what he said.

Q. And you had borrowed the lantern from Haynie?

A. Yes sir.

Q. It was Haynie’s lantern?

A. Yes sir; I had left mine on a locomotive, and I have
not recovered it yet.

Q. So you don’t know what happened to your lantern, of
your own knowledge?

A. I dropped it there some place.

Q. Except that you dropped it?

A. I lost it in the fall.

Q. Do you recall whether or not you were out over the
drawbar when you fell?

A. I was in the act of going over.

Q. You were in the act of going over?

A. I was in the act of going over.

Q. Do you remember which side—after you were run
over, do you remember which side you crawled out on?

A. I was on the north side.

Q. You crawled out on the north side, is that right?

(fol. 69] A. That is definitely, I was on the north side of
the engine when I fell, that is the side that I got in the
clear on.

Q. That was still on the fireman’s side?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Of course, you immediately made an outery for help?

A. I grabbed for my leg the first thing. Of course, my leg
was bent forward, I was helpless, outside of crawling. I
hollered for help, I did not get any response or any as-
sistance. I finally got the flashlight out of my pocket and
flashed around and kept hollering for help, but nobody
came.

Q. Colosimo finally came?

A. After I had dragged myself up the tracks a ways,
across from the tracks, and drug myself across to the other
side of the tracks, where I figured I could probably attract
age of the men working around the coal chute, or some-

y:

Q. He finally came?

A. Yes.

Q. And he left and got Haynie?

A. Yes.

Q. And the two of them put you in Haynie’s car?

A. No, it was the machinist’s car at the pit.

Q. And they took you to the hospital?

A. Yes.

Q. Mr. Bruner, yesterday when Mr. Black was question-
ing you, he was asking you about the custom and practice.
Of course, as far as the custom and practice is concerned,
Colosimo, being the hostler, and you being his helper, he
could have had you coal 1149, couldn’t he?

A. Yes.

70

Q. He could have stayed in the cab and directed that
you get up on the tank of 1149 and coal that particular
locomotive? —

A. Yes.

Q. You can usually coal them by one spot, can you?

A. Asa rule, yes.

Q. Of course, with the bigger engines, where they have
a great big tender, sometimes you have to move the engine
two or three times to get the tank full of coal?

A. Yes.

{fol. 70] Q. Of course, where you have a big engine like
that, ordinarily you get down there and take the coal while
he moves the engine to the various spots that you want it;
is that correct?

A. Yes.

Q. You told Mr. Black yesterday, as I recall it, that of
course Colosimo was the boss; he was the man that was to
direct what was to be done; is that correct?

A. Yes.

Q. You were there to do what he told you; is that cor-
rect?

A. That is correct.

Q. Mr. Bruner, when you were in the cab there, of 1182,
down at the pit where you were discussing what you were
going to do, will you state to us again exactly what was

\said, as near as you can remember it?

A. Mr. Colosimo came to the cab and told me that both
engines needed coal; that I would have to take sand on en-
gine 1182, and he would take coal on engine 1149, and for
me to sand engine 1182, and also coal.

Q. That is the way you remember what was told you at
that time; is that right?

A. Yes, he said he would take the coal on 1149, and for
me to sand 1182, and for me to coal Engine 1182.

Q. Didn’t he state to you at that time that you should
stay on Engine 1182, and he would take the coal on 11497

A. He told me he would take the coal on Engine 1149,
and for me to coal 1182.

Q. I want you to pay particular attention to my Ques-
tion: Didn’t he state to you at that time for you to stay on
1182, and that he would take coal on 11497

71

A. I don’t believe he said, in those words, for me to stay
on Engine 1182. He told me for me to take coal and sand
on 1182.

Q. I want your best recollection about that.

A. That is correct. He just told me the work that had to
be done. He did not tell me how to do it.

Q. That is your best recollection of that conversation?

A. Yes.

Mr. Jensen: That is all.

Redirect examination.

By Mr. Black:

Q. Mr. Bruner, you stated on cross examination, that you
borrowed the lantern from Mr. Haynie?

A. Yes.

{fol. 71] Q. When did you borrow that lantern from him?

A. Along that night, when I came in contact with him to
commence that shift, I believe he said he did not need a
lantern; that I could use his that night when I went to work
on that particular shift.

Q. Is Mr. Haynie a hostler?

A. He was acting as an inside hostler at that time.

Q. You used the lantern during most of that shift?

A. Yes, I had the lantern for that shift.

Q. For what purpose did you use the lantern?

A. For giving signals for whatever movements had to be
made. I gave the signals to the hostler for whatever move-
ments were necessary.

Q. Had you used that lantern at any time after you left
the cinder pit on this movement you described to the jury?

A. Yes sir. I had used it to give signals with, to stop at
the sand house and also to let him know that I had com-
pleted taking the sand, I gave him the signal to back up.

Q. Did you have any other means of communication or
signalling to Colosimo, except this lantern’

A. That is what we used the lantern for, was to give the
signal, to know that it was ready for the engine to be moved,
and that he should not move until he did get that signal.

Q. Why did you look for the lantern after the accident?
Did you look for the lantern after the accident?

A. I reached around for it, and I could not find it.

, Q. What did you do then, after you looked for the lan-
ern?

72

A. I could not find it. I hollered for help and could not
attract anybody, then I got my flashlight out of my pocket,
and flashed that around to attract some attention; and I
kept hollering for help, and did not have any success in at-
tracting any attention there. That is when I moved up
the tracks, the best I could, a ways, to where I would be in
front of the engine far enough to cross to the other side of
the track, to see if I could attract attention at the cinder
pit or coal chute where there might be anybody around.

Q. Mr. Jensen inquired about a statement that was made
on the 20th of December. Do you recall that statement?

A. Yes.

Q. When were you taken from the hospital to your home?

A. I believe the 17th of December.

{fol. 72] Q. What was your condition at the time the
statement was made?

A. I was in great pain, due to the fact that right after I
had got out of the hospital I had started to go—I will have
to show you this. I fell on the stump of my leg; and nat-
urally the motion would be to catch my weight, which I
did. I landed right on the end of the stump, with all my
weight. I was in very great pain, to say the least. I could
hardly do anything; and I had taken over-doses of medi-
cine that I had got from the doctor, to try to ease the pain,
or get some sleep. I could not sleep after that. I lost
sleep and everything. I could not even read, or anything.
I had taken over-doses, trying to get some ease. I had
sleepless nights. I could not sleep and I was worn out.

Q. You stated that you could not read, or did not read
the statement?

A. That is correct. I did not read it.

Q. You can read, can’t you?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Why didn’t you read that one?

A. It was too blurred, I could not see the print, or any-
thing. My eyes could not focus on anything to read it.

Q. When was the statement read to you with respect to
the time you signed it?

A. It was read that same day. I don’t recall what day.
It was read that same day in the evening. It was read to
me, but so far as being able to pay very close attention to
it, all I was interested in was in getting rid of them so I

could get some sleep or rest, if I could. I was not in much
of a mood to do any concentrating.

73

Q. Did you later on make a statement to Mr. Divisek, the
claim agent of The Denver & Rio Grande? Did you make
a statement to Mr. Divisek?

A. He asked me——

Q. I don’t care what he asked you. Did you make a
statement to Mr. Divisek?

A. No, I did not sign any statement.

Q. Did you talk to Mr. Divisek?

A. I talked to him, yes.

Q. Was something said? If anything, don’t say what it
was, about the lantern?

A. Yes.

Q. You did make such a statement? Answer ‘‘Yes’’ or
‘¢No.’’

A. Yes.

[fol.73] Q. What was the date of that statement, as near
as you recall?

A. I believe it was right around December 31st, around
in that neighborhood, the 30th or 31st.

Q. I believe you explained to Mr. Jensen that whoever
operates an engine sits on the right side?

A. Yes.

Q. What side of Engine 1149 was toward the coal chute?

A. The right-hand side of the engine would be next to
the coal chute.

Q. The right-hand side?

A. Yes sir.

Q. In order for you to give any signal or communication
whatsoever to the operator of an engine, where would you
naturally get?

A. I would get up on top of the tank, and in this particu-
lar instance in order to be where I should be in order to
make the proper spot to take coal, to be in a position for
spotting and taking coal both, that is the proper place to
be, for that move, up on the back end of the tank of 1182.

Q. Would you—would it be possible for an operator of an
engine to see you from the left-hand side of the engine, to
which the moving engine was attached?

A. No, you can’t see on the left-hand side from the right
side.

Q. Mr. Bruner, I show you a photograph marked for
identification plaintiff’s Exhibit ‘‘F’’. Is that a fair like-
ness of the rear end of Engine 1182?

A. Yes.

74

Mr. Black: We offer in evidence, your Honor, this photo-

graph.
Mr. Jensen: No objection.
The Court: It may be received.

Exutstr ‘‘F’’’

(Here follows 1 photolithograph, Exhibit ‘‘F’’.)

75

By Mr. Black:

Q. Mr. Bruner, will you step over to the jury box there?
Mr. Bruner, I call your attention now to Exhibit ‘‘A’’, and
I call your attention especially to the iron that angles down
from the rear end of the engine to which I am now point-
ing.

Mr. Black: I am pointing, Mr. Jensen, if you care to step
over, to an iron that you described yesterday as being a
grab-iron.

A. Yes, they call them a grab-iron.

[fol. 74] Q. Will you show that to the jury?

A. This is it right here. It is put on there for a step.
They commonly call them a grab-iron. It is put on there for
a step.

Q. What do you use the iron for?

A. For a step up. You can step from here on this beam
across here. This beam that comes across here comes out
from the tank.

Mr. Black: May the record show he indicates the beam,
that heavy timber that runs just below the pin lifter that
was described to the jury yesterday.

Q. You say that beam protrudes out from the end of the
tender?

A. Yes.

Q. About how far?

A. From six to eight inches. It varies.

Q. Six to eight inches?

A. Yes.

Q. I call your attention to the heavy iron rod, the top iron
rod that runs above the pin lifter.

A. Yes.

Q. What do you use that for?

A. It is to hold onto. We use them when we are out in
the yards switching, to hold onto, when we are riding
around. That is for the purpose of taking hold of it, with
your hands.

Q. You may state whether or not, in the course of your
employment as a hostler, or a hostler’s helper and fire-
man, you have occasion to cross from one side to the other
3 an engine coupled to a tender, and to pass over the draw-

ar?

76

A. Yes, many times I have had occasion to. I did so
many times. It is a common practice to get off and go up
that way.

Q. There is no effort at all?

A. I have had occasion to.

Q. Mr. Bruner, during the time that you were employed
by the defendant corporation, did anyone ever give you
any instructions concerning leaving or getting down from
engines?

A. No sir.

[fol. 75] Further recross examination.

By Mr. Bagley:

Q. Mr. Bruner, when you are working at night, you give
signals by lantern; is that right?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And when you give the hostler a signal to move an
engine, you, of course, expect him to act on that signal,
don’t you?

A. Yes.

Q. You expect him to move that engine?

A. Yes—if it is a signal to move.

Q. Yes; and you would not give that signal at any place,
or any time, when the moving of that engine would injure
you or anyone else, would you?

A. No. |

Q. In other words, when you give him that signal to
move that engine, you expect him to act on that signal?

A. Yes.

Q. And you do not give that signal when you are in a
place where you could be injured by the immediate move-
ment of the engine, would you?

A. No; if I was going to get struck, or something.

Mr. Bagley: That is all.
Redirect examination.

By Mr. Black:

Q. Did you make any attempt to give any signal while
you were between 1149 and 1182?
A. No, absolutely not.

77

Q. Were you prepared, in any way, for the movement
of these engines at that time?
A. No.

Cuartes Joun Corostmo, called as a witness on behalf
of the defendants, being first duly sworn, testified as fol-
lows:

Direct examination.

By Mr. Jensen:

Q. State your name, please.
A. Charles John Colosimo.
Q. You spell that C-o-l-o-s-i-m-o?
A. Yes sir.
[fol. 76] Q. You reside in Grand Junction, Colorado?
A. Yes sir.
Q. How old are you, Mr. Colosimo?
A. Twenty-eight, now.
Q. You are employed by the trustees of The Denver &
Rio Grande Western Railroad?
A. Yes sir.
Q. At Grand Junction, Colorado?
A. Yes sir.
Q. You are employed by them at the present time, are
you not?
Yes.
And you were in December, last year?
. Yes sir.
. How long have you worked for the railroad?
. You mean my full service?
Yes.
. I started the service with them in 1934.
Did you start in the roundhouse?
. Yes sir.
. In what capacity?
. Engine house labor.
Q. Tell what jobs you held while you were in the round-
house?
A. Engine labor job, and I got promoted to a boiler
maker helper job.

Q. In December of 1941, in what capacity were you em-

bPOPOPOPOPOD

ployed, Mr. Colosimo?

S>OoPoPpop

. I was employed as a fireman.

You were employed as a fireman?

Yes sir.

But you were doing other work, were you not?
Yes sir.

What was the nature of that?

Hostling engines.

[fol. 77] Q. Was that at Gran Junction?

OPOPoOrPopPorpes

. Yes sir.

Did you do hostler’s work?

. Yes sir.

Did you do hostler’s helper’s work upon occasions?

. Yes sir.

At times I suppose you went out as a fireman?

. No, I never went out firing at that time.

You had not done any firing at that time?

. No, I could not hold the board.

. In other words, you did not have enough seniority to

get a fireman’s job?

Mr. Colosimo, in December of 1941, how much time had
you put in, in hostling and helping on hostling jobs at Grand
Junction?

A.

Q.
A.

Two months.

Two months?
No—just a minute—there is a mistake there—three

months.

>O PO PO PO PO PO PO PO

. Three months?
. Yes sir.

Did you know a man by the name of Mr. Bruner?
Yes sir.

E. E. Bruner?

. Yes sir.

That is the same gentleman who sits here?

. Yes sir.

You worked with him one night, did you not?

. Yes sir.

He was your helper?

. Yes sir.

What was the date of that, please?

. December 1st.

- Had you worked with Mr. Bruner prior to that time?
. No, sir.

79

[fol.78] Q. On that particular day, or morning—by the
way, what time did you go to work?

A. Eleven o’clock p.m. on the 30th or 31st, I have for-
gotten how many days there are in the month.

Mr. Rawlings: There are thirty days in November.
A. Yes.

By Mr. Jensen:

Q. It was on November 30th, is that right?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What was the nature of the work you were doing—
you and Mr. Bruner, at that time?

A. Taking engines out of the roundhouse and putting
them in the roundhouse, conditioning them to go out on the
road.

Q. In what capacity were you working?

A. As hostler.

Q. In what capacity was Mr. Bruner working?

A. Hostler’s helper. ;

Q. Do you remember picking up a couple of engines—
one No. 1182, and 1149?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Which of those locomotives did you see first, or did
you work on first, or get on first?

. 1149.

. Where was that locomotive when you got on it?
. At the roundhouse. -

Was Mr. Bruner with you at that time?

. Yes sir.

Where did you take that locomotive?

. To the cinder pit, to get the fire cleaned on it.
Where is that cinder pit from the roundhouse?
. It would be west.

About how far?

About three blocks, I don’t know how far in feet. It
was quite a ways.

Q. The engine was in the roundhouse?

A. Yes sir.

[fol. 79] Q. You took it out of the roundhouse and down
to the cinder pit?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You had to go across the turn-table, didn’t you?

POrPOPOPOPOD

A. Yes sir.

Q. By the way, was Mr. Bruner with you when you went
from the roundhouse to the cinder pit?
. Yes sir.
What did you take it down to the cinder pit for?
To get the fire cleaned on it.
When you got down there did you men clean that fire?
Did we clean it?
Yes.
. Nosir. They had men to do that.
What are those men called?
. Fire knockers—just fire knockers and fire cleaners.
How long were you at the pit, do you remember?
. Oh, I would say about ten minutes.
. When you moved from the pit—by the way, did you
move 1149 away from the pit?

A. There was another hostler who hooked 1182 on the
front end of it; then I moved them both back.

Q. Another locomotive had been hooked on the front
end of 1149?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And the number of that locomotive was 1182?
A. Yes sir.

Q. What was the name of the hostler who brought that
locomotive down there—was it Haynie?

A. Haynie.

Q. What had to be done with those locomotives?

A. They had to have the fire cleaned and sand put in the
dome, and coal in the tender, and set in their places to go
out, after we got through with them.

Q. After you got all that done it was your intention to
take them down to put them in the place where they were to
be used; is that right?

A. Yes sir.

[fol. 50] Q. Now, did you have a conversation with Mr.
Bruner about what moves you intended to do?

A. I did, at the cinder pit.

Q. At the cinder pit?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Do you recall where that conversation took place,
with reference to the cinder pit?
A. Do I recall where?

OPOPOoPOoPO>Op>

81

Q. Yes. I mean by that was it on the locomotive or to
the side of the pit, or where?
A. It was on 1182.

By Mr. Black:

Q. On 1182, did you say?
A. Yes sir.

By Mr. Jensen:

Q. Do you recall where, on 1182, it was?

A. In the cab.

Q. In the cab. Now, wiil you state what was said be-
tween you and Mr. Bruner at that time?

A. I told him that the back engine, 1149, was already
sanded, and the 1182 needed to be sanded, and I told him
to sand the 1182 and coal 1182 and I would coal 1149 as
we went by the coal chute.

Q. Was that all you said to him at that time?

A. Yes, I believe so. I told him for him to saad 1182
and stay on her and coal her, and at the same time I would
take care of the 1149.

Q. All right—then what did you do?

A. I got back on the 1149, to run the engine back to the
sand house.

Q. Did you have to go west from the pit to the sand
house?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Was it dark?

A. Yes sir.

Q. About what time of the morning was this?

A. About five-thirty or five-twenty.

Q. When you went back to get on 1149, Mr. Bruner, I
take it, was already in the cab of 1182?

A. Yes sir.

[fol.81] Q. You had had this conversation in the cab;
is that right?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Then you moved west?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You operated 1149?

A. Yes sir.

6—828

82

Q. As far as you know, was that the only engine on
which any power was being used?

A. As far as I know, yes sir.

Q. By the way, was there any signal given to make that
back-up movement?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Will you state what the signal was, and what was
done?

A. After the cinder pit men told me the engine was
okeh to go, I got up on the 1149 and whistled ‘‘back-up’’
for the cinder pit, to spot 1182 at the sand house.

Q. When you got down to the sand house what, if any-
thing, took place?

A. Did anything take place?

Q. Yes, what did you do, or what was done with refer-
ence to these locomotives?

A. Mr. Bruner was up on the running-board of 1182,
to give me a signal to stop at the proper piace, to put
sand in the 1182.

Q. And did you stop?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How long were you at that point?

A. Oh, I would say two minutes.

Q. What did you do while that stop was made?

A. I looked at the fire on the 1149.

Q. Then what was the next thing that happened?

A. Mr. Bruner got through sanding the 1149, and gave
me a go-back signal, to go to the coal chute, which I moved
back to the coal chute, and spotted the 1149, and got out
and got up over the tender and put coal in the 1149.

Q. Now, Mr. Colosimo, how did you get from the cab
of the locomotive up onto the tank of 1149?

[fol.82] A. There is a step ladder on that side of the
coal chute, I reached over and grabbed hold of the step-
ladder and jumped right over into the tender of the 1149.

Q. Did you see Mr. Bruner after you saw him at the
sand house?

A. Yes sir. Did you say if I saw him after that?

Q. Yes.

A. No sir.

Q. When was the last time you saw him?
A. After the sand house?
Q. No; when was the last time that you-saw him?

U3

A. The last time I saw him was on top of 1182, after
he got through sanding.

Q. He was on top of 1182?

A. He was up on the running-board some place; I could
not tell, it was dark, but he gave me the Go-back signal.
That was the last time I saw him.

Q. When the spot was made at the coal chute, was there
any signal given to you by Mr. Bruner?

A. When I spotted, do you mean?

Q. Yes.

A. No sir.

Q. I think you have already stated that you got on this
step-ladder that was on the side of the coal chute, then
up on the tank, and you coaled 1149?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Now, in coaling that locomotive, what did you do?

A. There is a chain that you pull down first, to lower
your chute. After I lowered the chute, there is a chain
you open to release the coal. I put about three tons of
coal on it, and lifted the chute back up.

Q. When you were on 1182, up at the cinder pit, did you
observe the condition of the coal pile on that tender?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Do you remember whether or not there was any coal
in the tank?

A. Yes sir, there was some coal.

Q. Mr. Colosimo, do you remember how long it took
you to coal 1149?

A. I would say it took me from the time I left the cab,
till I got back in the cab, about three or four minutes.
[fol. 83] Q. Then what did you dot

A. After I got in the cab?

Q. Yes.

A. I released the air, looked out of the window, but it
was dark, and started a back-up motion, to spot 1182.

Q. Mr. Colosimo, had you made that move, or a similar
move, in the Grand Junction yards prior to this time?

A. The say- way?

Q. Yes.

A. Yes sir.

Q. Mr. Colosimo, you say you made that particular move
before with two locomotives?
A. Yes sir.

84

Mr. Jensen: I will ask another preliminary question.

Q. What type of locomotives were those two that you
had?

A. I have forgotten their class—220’s, I believe; but
1100’s is what we go by.

Q. But they are rather small locomotives, aren’t they?

A. Yes.

Q. Is the tender large, or otherwise? What I am try-
ing to get at, could you coal those two locomotives with
one spot only?

A. If the tank was empty, you mean?

Q. No, I mean in the condition they were at that time?

A. Yes, with one spot.

Q. You would only have to spot them close, and put
al] the coal you needed in them?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Out of one spot; is that correct?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Is there anything unusual about your coaling the one,
and Mr. Bruner coaling the other?

A. Anything unusual?

Q. Yes.

A. No, there was not. I have done it before.

Q. You have done it before?
A. Yes.

[fol. 84] Q. Have you seen it done by others?
A. Yes, I have.

Q. Mr. Colosimo, what is the custom and practice, or
are you familiar with the custom and practice as to how
hostler’s helpers get from the front locomotive to the tank
to take coal, in Grand Junction, during this period of
time, how they would get from one point to another, in
a move of this sort? Are you familiar with how that
would be done, the custom as to how it would be done?

A. You mean after they have taken sand?

Q. Yes.

A. Well, the majority of them——

Q. Wait a minute, you don’t understand my question.
Do you know what that custom and practice was?

A. Do I know what it was?

Q. Yes, do you know how it was done?
A. Yes sir.

Q. How did the hostler’s helper get onto the tank to take
coal on that front locomotive, after moving from the sand
house?

A. Most of them are over the cab into the tender.

Q. How do they get over the cab?

A. They climb up on the boiler and just step right
up on the cab there.

Q. When they are up there at the sand house, they are
already on top of the boiler, aren’t they?

A. Yes sir.

Q. If they got down to the running-board would they
go over this way, across the cab and down into the tank?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Now, Mr. Colosimo, this track that you were on, was
that the track at the north of the coal chute?

. North?

Yes. It was on the city side of the coal chute, wasn’t
it
. Yes sir.

That is north of the coal chute, isn’t it?

. Yes sir.

. In this move from the sand house down to the coal
chute, which way were you going?

A. We were going west.

(fol. 85] Q. You were going west, and you were backing
up?

A. We were backing up, yes sir.

Q. When you spotted your locomotive at this coal chute
—there are two aprons on that coal chute, aren’t there?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Which apron did you spot at?

A. The east end apron.

Q. That is the one nearest this side?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Nearest the direction from which you were coming?

A. Yes sir.

Q. When you spotted at that east end apron, which part
of the locomotive did you put under the apron?

A. The tender.

Q. The coal holding portion of the tender; is that right?

A. Yes sir.

Q. On this locomotive where would that be—about over
this center part, about where I have indicated—or would
it be farther back?

O>ror”~op>

A. On that one it is about the center of where the coal is
missing from.

Q. About the center of where the coal is missing from?

A. Yes.

Q. So the coal would roll either way and fill up the whole
space; is that correct?

A. You misunderstand me there. I mean if the tender
has some coal in it.

Q. Yes—well, on this occasion where was the tender
spotted with respect to the apron?

A. It was spotted just where you have the marking there.

Q. All right, and that is about midway in the section
holding coal; is that correct?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Do you remember about what the dimensions are of
that section of the tank that holds coal, from front to back—
your best judgment on that, Mr. Colosimo?

Mr. Jensen: I will withdraw that question for the moment.

[fol. 86] Q. About how long are those tenders, do you
know?

A. How long are those tenders?

Q. Yes.

A. I would say fifteen feet long.

Q. And this part that holds the coal, how far does that
run back from the front to the back of the tender?

A. It runs back about eight feet.

Q. A little better than half way, is that your judgment?

A. Yes sir.

Q. So that if you spotted it about midway, the apron
would be about four feet from the front part of the tender;
is that right?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Were the boiler and the cab of the locomotive east
of the coal chute, or how were the boiler and cab—how were
they situated with respect to the coal chute?

A. Part of the boiler was sticking on the east end of the
coal chute.

Q. What is your, judgment as to the length of the boiler,
including the cab?

A. About thirty feet.

Q. What is your judgment as to how much the locomotive
extended east of the coal chute?

A. Iam not very good at figuring off-hand.

judgment on it at all?
out past the coal chute.

east of the coal chute; is that correct?
A. Yes sir.

other locomotive?
A. Yes sir.
Q. 1182?
A. Yes sir.

you can run the coal into it?
{fol.87] <A. Yes sir.
Q. Does it have sides on it?
A. Yes sir.

the front?

drops down.

is that correct?
A. Just by weights.

of your tank, rather?
A. Where was it?
Q. Yes, where was it with respect to your cab?

have to reach for the ladder?
A. Yes sir.
Q. Did you get onto the ground at all?
A. No sir.

tell us how you got up that ladder?

Q. Would you say half, or a third, or have you any
A. Oh, it was over half of the boiler that was sticking
Q. So, at least fifteen feet of the boiler was extending

Q. And then east of the front end of the boiler was the

Q. Mr. Colosimo, this apron that comes down, what is it,
a sort of a steel slide—is it a piece of steel that comes down
to the coal chute, that is lowered into the locomotive so

Q. Is it a form something like a scoop shovel, except on
a larger scale, with sides on it, the flat part or opening on

A. It has sides, it is a flat piece of steel with sides on it
and a hole in the bottom of it and one end where the coal

Q. It works on a hinge, so it can be raised or lowered;

Q. When you spot, where was that ladder that you took
hold of to get onto the top of your locomotive or the top

A. You mean where it was when I was on the cab?
Q. Yes, when your locomotive came to a stop did you

Q. All right, you tell us about it then, Mr. Colosimo; you

A. The ladder—I got down on the gangway of the engine
and reached over and got hold of the ladder with my left
arm or hand, and climbed up and jumped into the tender.

87

Q. Which side of the locomotive was the coal chute on?

A. Which side?

Q. Yes.

A. It was on the right side.

Q. Is that the fireman’s side or the engineer’s side?

A. The engineer’s side.

Q. In operating this locomotive where were you sitting
as you were moving back on the engineer’s side, or the
right side? Will you tell us more about that ladder that
was on the side of the coal chute? Was it leaning against
the coal chute, or a part of it—tell us about that?

[fol. 88] A. The ladder is built right onto the coal chute.
It is always there.

Q. What is if made out of—wood—or is it rungs of iron?

A. Rungs of iron.

Q. Does it go clear to the ground, or start up above the
ground?

A. It starts up above the ground.

Q. Those rungs of iron, are they something like the
handholds you have on box cars?

A. Yes sir, just small, little rungs.

Q. A piece of iron about that shape, would it be?

A. No, they were sort of like a pipe, running from one
side to the other.

Q. How were they held onto the side of the coal chute!

_ A. I don’t recall now whether they are made out of steel
or wood.

Q. Now, Mr. Colosimo, going back to the time when you
had completed the coaling of 1149, and got down in the
cab, I think you said you released the brakes and started
to back up; is that correct?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You tell us what happened from then on?

A. After I released the brakes and put the engine in
reverse, reversing position, I opened the throttle, to go
backwards, to spot 1182. After I started back a little
ways I heard someone’s cries to stop the engine at once.

Q. You heard someone what?

A. Someone cry or holler ‘‘Help.’’ I stopped the engine
and looked down one side, and could not see nothing; then
looked down the other side. In other words, I looked down
one side and could not see nothing, so I got down on the
engineer’s side and ran up toward the front of the engine,
and found Mr. Bruner on the ground,

Q. Did you have a headlight burning on either front
or rear of 1149?

A. I have the back-up on the 1149.

Q. Did you have a headlight burning on either front or
rear?

A. Of 1182. The beam headlight was on.

Q. The headlight of 1182, and the rear light of 11491

A. Yes sir.

Q. You say you found Mr. Bruner on the ground?

A. Yes sir.

[fol. 89] Q. Tells us where he was, place?

A. He was at the front of the 1182, towards the front of
1182, about three feet from the track, on the right side?

Q. On the engineer’s side?

A. Yes sir. ,

Q. Did you see a lantern there at that time, or anywhere
around him?

A. No sir. .

Q. You did not?

A. No.

Q. Did you later see a lantern around there?

A. We found one later, after we sent Mr. Bruner to the
hospital.

Q. Where did you find the lantern?

A. It was on the left-hand side of the tracks.

Q. Whereabouts from where you found Mr. Bruner, have
you any idea?

A. No, it was farther east from where we found Mr.
Bruner—no, let us see—I am getting my directions mixed
up here. It was farther west than we found Mr. Bruner.

Q. It was nearer to the coal chute than where you found
Mr. Bruner?

A. Yes.

Q. Have you any idea how much nearer?

A. I would say an engine length, practically an engine
length.

Mr. Bagley:
Q. That is about seventy feet, isn’t it?
A. Yes sir.

By Mr. Jensen:

Q. All right. Now, Mr. Colosimo, after you found Mr.
Bruner what, if anything, did you do?

90

A. What did I do?

Q. Yes.

A. I asked him what was the trouble, and he told me his
leg had been run over; so, it being my first experience
with anybody hurt, like that, I did not know what to do, and
I ran toward the cinder pit and found hostler Haynie there,
and told him, and we both ran back up there and got Mr.
‘ Bruner. Thers happened to be a car there by the coal chute
that belonged to a machinist. We got him to take Mr.
Bruner to the hospital. y,

Q. When was it you found the lantern?

A. When?

[fol. 90] Q. Yes.

A. It was ten or fifteen minutes after it happened there,
we were taking a few of the officials around the place.

Q. Was it after you got Mr. Bruner in the car?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What kind of a lantern was it?
A. Electric lantern.

Q. A regular swtchman’s lantern?
A. Yes sir.

Q. Was anyone with you when you found it?

A. I did not find it myself—I was with someone when they
found it. Haynie found it, the other hostler.

Q. Did he pick it up, off the ground?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Was it lighted?

A. I don’t recall whether the lantern was lit or not, I
don’t believe it was lit.

Q. Did you see the lantern, examine it?

A. No, I did not examine the lantern.

Q. Could you tell us whether or not any part of it was
broken?

A. No, I could not tell you that, I did not even look at
the lantern.

Q. Did Haynie make any remark about the lantern being
his, or anything of that sort?

Mr. Black: Being his?

Mr. Jensen: Yes.

Mr. Black: I think we stipalated it was his lantern.
The Court: Yes.

Mr. Bagley: That is all right.

Mr. Rawlings: Bruner testified to that.
Mr. Jensen: Yes. ‘

By Mr. Jensen:

Q. But Haynie picked it up?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You saw him pick it up?

[fol.91] A. No, I never saw him pick it up, but I saw him
with a lantern that he said he picked up.

Q. You told us here a little while ago that the lantern
was probably an engine length away?

A. That is where Mr. Haynie told me he picked it up.

Q. But you did not see him pick it up?

A. No.

Q. Mr. Colosimo, on an occasion like that, particularly
night, where you are the hostler, and someone else is help-
ing you, whose duty is it to decide how moves are to be
made, and to direct the moves?

A. The hostler usually directs the movements.

Q. Is the hostler the boss of the two?

A. Yes sir.

Q. All right. Now, what are the hostler’s usual duties?
_ A. The hostler’s duties are to run the locomotive, and to
keep the fire in it, and water in it.

Q. What?

A. To keep fire and water in it.

Q. What are the duties of the helper?

A. The helper is to coal engines, sand engines, take water
on them, operate the turn-table and throw switches.

Q. Does he do such things as the hostler directs?

A. Yes sir.

Q. On this particular occasion, when you coaled No. 1149,
could you have directed Mr. Bruner to do that work?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Is it any part of the hostler helper’s duties to check
water and check fires, and things of that sort?

A. It isn’t their duty, but they help to do it once in a
while, just like the hostler helps the helper to do once in a
while.

Q. Whose responsibility is it, and who is held respon-
sible for the condition of the fire and the condition of the
water, and so on?

A. The hostler.

92

Q. When you were in the cab of engine 1182, down at the
cinder pit, did you say anything with respect to checking
the fire and the water?

A. Did I say anything?

[fol. 92] Q. Yes.

A. No, sir; they had not quit operating them yet.

Q. Did you do anything about it, before the move was
made?

A. No sir.

Q. You did make a check about the coal that was in the
tank of 1182, didn’t you?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Do you recall whether or not 1182 is a hand fired
locomotive?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Of course, it means that you have to fire it by throw-
ing coal in through the door with a shovel?

A. Yes sir.

Q. There are two kinds—stoker fired and hand fired?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Mr. Colosimo, 1182 and 1149, are those engines more
or less alike?

. Are they what?
Are those engines alike?

. Yes.
A. Yes, they are both the same class of engine.
Q. But one of them is used in road service?
A. Yes sir.
Q. The other one in switching service?
A. Yes sir.

Q. I call your attention to Exhibit ‘‘1’’—which is a
picture of the front end of 1182. You will notice that has
a

Q. You don’t notice any such pilot on the picture of 1149,
shown in Exhibit 3, do you?

A. No sir.

Q. The reason for that pilot, of course, is because 1182
is in road service, isn’t that right?

A. Yes sir.
[fol.93] Q. Would you say that the dimensions of 1182
are the same dimensions as you gave us as to 11491

A. The same length?

same dimensions.

Q. How about the tanks?
A. The tanks would be the same.

1149 a hand fired locomotive, too?
A. Yes sir.

you if you recognize that photograph?
A. Yes, I do.

Q. What would you say it is a photograph of?

and the river side of the sand house.
Q. And looking from where to where?

the roundhouse. It is in that direction.

sand house, aren’t you?
A. Yes sir.

Mr. Jensen: We offer it if your Honor please.
The Court: Which number is that?

Mr. Jensen: No, 4.

The Court: It may be received.

Q. The same dimensions. I mean, is the overall length
the same, or substantially the same, as you remember it?
A. From coupler to coupler, I believe they would be the

Q. I don’t know whether [ asked you this, or not, but was

Q. Mr. Colosimo, I hand you what has been marked for
identification as defendants’ Exhibit No. 4, and | will ask

A. It is a photograph of the city side of the coal chute,

A. Looking toward the roundhouse, but you don’t see

Q. You are looking from the coal chute towards the

93

(Here follows 1 photolithograph, Exhibit ‘‘4’’)

95

Q. Mr. Colosimo, I call your attention particularly to
the ladder which appears here at the side of the coal chute?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Is that the ladder you went up?

A. Yes sir.

Q. I call your attention to Exhibit ‘‘5,’’ and ask you if
you recognize that photograph?

A. Yes sir.
[fol. 94] Q. Will you tell us what it is?

A. That is the coal chute at Grand Junction, the east
side of the coal chute.

Q. And looking which way?

A. Looking west.

Q. That is, that photograph is taken in a position of the
camera standing about here, looking down this way?

A. Yes sir.

Q. That man standing there is you, isn’t it; you were
present when that picture was taken, weren’t you?

A. Yes sir.

Mr. Jensen: We offer it if your Honor please.
The Court: It may be received.

(Here follows 1 photolithograph, Exhibit ‘‘5’’)

97

Q. And on this particular photograph you can see the
ladder, can you not?
A. Yes sir.

Mr. Jensen: I think that is all.

Cross-examination.

By Mr. Black:

Q. Mr. Colosimo, had you been employed as a hostler’s
helper during this three months’ period of time that you
mentioned?

A. I helped hostler the first two days that I hired out
down there. Two times I helped hostler, out of that three
months.

Q. Had you acted as a hostler during those three months?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How many times or how often?

A. Every day for the three months.

Q. Every day you had been a hostler, for three months?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And this is the first time, of course, that you had
ever worked with Mr. Bruner, you stated?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Mr. Colosimo, when a hostler and his helper work at
night, you stated the hostler operates the engine?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And he depends on the helper for signals controlling
the various movements that you make with the engine, does
he not?

A. Yes sir.

{fol.95] Q. If you are going to go through a switch the
helper throws the switch and signals you through?

A. Yes sir.

Q. If you are going to leave the cinder pit, going either
toward the roundhouse or toward the sand house, the hostler
operates the engine, and the helper gives the signals?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And, of course, you both work together and depend
upon each other, do you not?

A. Yes sir.

7—-828

98

Q. And on this night you depended upon Mr. Bruner to
give you a signal so that you could stop that 1182 under
the sand spout?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And he did give you a signal?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And he signaled you with a lighted lantern, did he not?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And you operated on that signal and stopped the
engine?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You waited there until a certain process was com-
pleted, and you got another signal, and you proceeded back
towards the coal chute?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Of course, at the time that you brought those engines
to a stop there at the sand house, you were looking toward
Mr. Bruner?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You were looking eastward there, weren’t you, toward
Mr. Bruner?

A. Yes sir.

Q. As you went back toward the coal chute you were
looking west, weren’t you, you were looking back to the
coal chute?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You determined whether you should stop the tender
of 1149 underneath the first coal chute or the second, didn’t
you?

A. Yes.

Q. You are the one that made that determination?

A. Yes sir.

[fol. 96] Q. And, of course, you did not depend on anybody
to give you a signal for that at all, did you?

A. No sir.

Q. And that was a part of the pre-arranged plan that you
had before that movement left the cinder pit?

A. Yes sir.

Q. When you stopped 1149 there at the coal chute, you
did not go back out of the cab up on top of the engine, and
up onto the tender, did you?

A. Did I what?

99

Q. When you stopped 1149 there at the coal chute, you
did not get out of the cab onto the running board, on the
running board up on top of the cab and over on to the tender,
did you?

A. No sir.

Q. You found another way of doing it that suited your
purposes better?

A. Yes sir.

Q. So you got hold of the ladder, climbed up the ladder,
I suppose, and swung over onto the tender?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You never gave Mr. Bruner any instructions as to
how he should get in and out of the engine, or what he should
do, other than to work with you in this movement?

A. No sir.

Q. You never told Mr. Bruner how he should get down?
A. Down from one gangway onto the other?

Q. You did not tell him to go out of the window, up on
top of the cab, on to the tender; you did not do that at all,
did you?

A. No sir.

Q. The fact of the matter is, that was just up to him?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You testified you thought a majority of the helpers,
most of them, when they were going back to take coal, got
out of the window, on the running-board, on top of the
cab, from there over onto the tender?

A. How was that? You say if they were on top?

Q. Yes.

A. I say if they were on top of the boiler, where Mr.
Bruner was, they would just keep on going, on over the cab.
{fol.97] Q. I misunderstood the testimony there, Mr.
Colosimo. So then your testimony was that when the helper
is on top of the boiler, the ordinary movement would be on

top of the cab and then from there over onto the tender?
A. Yes sir.

Q. I see. Now, that isn’t true when the helper is in the
cab, then, is it? I mean that is not the ordinary move-
ment, where the helper is in the cab?

A. No.

Q. And when the helper is in the cab he gets down on one
side, from one gangway to the other?

100

A. Yes sir. Some of them—they have so many ways of
working—some of them crawl up over the gates and get
into them.

Q. It is more or less up to the helper what he does?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You do not pretend to tell the helpers how they should
do this part of their work?

A. No sir.

Q. Nobody ever pretended to tell you how to do it when
you were a helper?

A. No sir.

Q. You did not move those engines, after the sand had
been taken on 1182, till you got a signal, did you?

A. No sir.

Q. When you got that signal you saw Bruner there near
the sand dome?

A. Yes sir.

Q. That is the last time you saw him till you discovered
him there near the front of 1182, isn’t it?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You heard his cries, and you went back towards the
front of the engine, and discovered a man. That was the
first time you saw him since you talked to him?

A. Yes sir.

Q. When you put that 1149 in reverse and opened up the
throttle to start that backward movement, you did not
know where Mr. Bruner was?

A. I did not see him, but I thought he was on top of the
tender.

Q. But you did not know where he was?

A. I did not see him, no.

Q. You did not see him on top?

A. No.

[fol. 98] Q. You did not know where he was. That is
true, is it not?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Now, the hostler, of course, sits, as you have stated,
here at the right side of the cab?

A. Yes sir.

Q. That is the engineer’s side; that is the hostler’s side?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You were there at the right side of the cab when you
put in the throttle and commenced that back-up motion?

A. Yes sir.

Q. At the coal chute?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Could you see the top or upper part of the tender of
1182 from where you were?

A. Most of it, yes sir.

Q. And that was within the range of your vision?

A. It was dark, I could see where it was. You could not
see if anyone was there unless they had a light or something.

Q. Of course not, and you assumed that Bruner was there.
You opened up the throttle and started back?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You did not sound any whistle or ring the bell before
you started?

A. No sir.

Q. Mr. Colosimo, were you familiar with the safety rules
of the company at that time?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Were you familiar with that safety rule No. 2057,
which provides that the engine bell or whistle warning
must be given before engines are moved, and then wait at
least one minute; are you familiar with that rule?

A. Yes sir.

Mr. Black: That is all. Thank you.
Redirect examination.

By Mr. Jensen:

Q. Mr. Colosimo, the last time you saw Mr. Bruner he
was on the boiler of 1182; is that correct?

A. Yes sir.

[fol. 99] Q. You knew he had to get onto the tank of 1182,
didn’t you?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What was the ordinary way for a man to get to that
tank under those conditions as they existed that night, for
a hostler’s helper to get from the boiler of 1182 to the
tank of 1182?

A. That night it seemed to me it would have been, over
the cab into the tender would have been the easiest of the
bunck, being already up there on the boiler, just like I
stated before.

102

Q. Mr. Colosimo, at the time you talked with Mr. Bruner,
back at the cinder pit, about what you were going to do,
did you say anything to Mr. Bruner as to where he should
be and stay?

A. I just told him to stay on the 1182. That is what I
told him, just to stay on the 1182, and I would take care of
the 1149.

Mr. Jensen: That is all.
Recross-examination.

By Mr. Black:

_ Q. All you meant by that was that you would take care of
1149, and Bruner would take care of 11821

A. Yes sir.

Q. By the way, one question: Where is the valve that
turns off the blower in the cab of this engine?

A. The valve? ,

Q. Yes.

A. It is on the fireman’s side.

Q. On the left side?

A. Yes sir.

Mr. Black: That is all.

Jupee’s Crrtirication To Bru or Exceprions—August
15, 1942

I, Georce A. Faust, do hereby certify that I am one of
the judges of the above entitled court and the judge be-
fore whom the above entitled cause was tried; that the de-
fendants’ proposed bill of exceptions consisting of:

1. The official court reporter’s transcript of the evi-
dence introduced and the proceedings had in said cause
containing 238 pages marked 1 to 238 both inclusive ;

{[Fol. 100] 2. Three additional pages marked 239 to
241 both inclusive, which pages are attached to said
transcript; and

3. The exhibits introduced in evidence upon the trial
of said cause, which exhibits are attached hereto and
made a part of this bill of exceptions;

103

contains all of the evidence offered or received at the trial
of said cause and all of the exceptions taken and rulings
made and the proceedings had in the course of said trial.
Said bill of exceptions, having been served within the
time required by law and the orders of this court and no
additions, corrections or amendments thereto having been
offered or proposed by the plaintiff within the time re-
quired by law, is now signed, settled and allowed as and
for the defendants’ bill of exceptions in the above cause.
Dated this 15th day of August, 1942.
George A. Faust, Judge. (Seal.)

Attest: Alvin Keddington, Clerk. By —-————, Deputy
Clerk.

[fol. 101] In toe Supreme Court or Utan
No. 6566
E. E. Bruner, Plaintiff and Respondent,

Vv.

Wuson McCartuy anp Henry Swan, Trustees of the Den-
ver & Rio Grande Western Railroad Company, and the
Denver & Rio Grande Western Railroad Company, De-
fendants and Appellants

Optnion—Filed October 25, 1943

Wolfe, Chief Justice:

E. E. Bruner, plaintiff and respondent, who was em-
ployed as a hostler’s helper on the railroad of the defend-
ants, was injured in the course of his employment. He
commenced this action under the Federal Employers’ Lia-
bility Act, 45 U. S. C. A. 51, to recover damages from his
employers for these injuries. The trial resulted in a
verdict and judgment in favor of the plaintiff. The defend-
ants appealed.

All assignments of error, except one relating to the ad-
mission in evidence of Exhibit G, relate to various instruc-
tions given to the jury. By several of the assignments
the defendants urge that the jury was not properly in-
structed on the issue of contributory negligence, which

104

defense was pleaded by the defendants. The Federal Em-
ployers’ Liability Act provides that:

«* * * the fact that the employee may have been
guilty of contributory negligence shall not bar recov-
ery, but the damages shall be diminished by the jury
in the proportion to the amount of negligence attrib-
utable to such employee.’’

It is contended that the various instructions did not cor-
rectly submit this factor to the jury. The plaintiff counters
that there was no evidences of contributory negligence and
that no such instructions were required. Our first question
then is whether there was sufficient evidence of contributory
negligence to require the giving of an instruction relating
thereto.

The evidence adduced is not in dispute. Prior to the
accident the plaintiff had had several years’ experience
both as a hostler and hostler’s helper. On the date of the
accident, December 1, 1941, he was working for the defend-
ants as a hostler’s helper. He was assigned to aid and as-
sist one Colosimo, a hostler, with whom the plaintiff had
not previously worked. Colosimo was in charge and the
plaintiff was to perform his work as directed by Colosimo.
On this railroad the hostler and his helper serviced loco-
motives and delivered them from the roundhouse to the rail-
road crews.

On December 1, 1941, the plaintiff came on shift with
Colosimo at11p.m. After performing various other duties,
they brought Engine No. 1149 out of the roundhouse to the
[fol. 102] cinder pit. Here employees known as ‘‘ fire knock-
ers’’ cleaned the clinkers out of the fire. While they were
at the cinder pit, another hostler brought Engine 1182 from
the roundhouse and coupled it to Engine 1149. Both en-
gines were facing east. At the cinder pit Colosimo and the
plaintiff discussed the future movements of the engines and
the work to be done. Engine 1149 did not need sand. It
was decided that both engines were to be backed to the sand
chute where the plaintiff would take sand on 1182. Then
both engines were to be backed to the coal chute. Although
it was plaintiff’s duty to put coal in the tender of both en-
gines, Colosimo volunteered to coal Engine 1149 and told
plaintiff to coal Engine 1182 after he had sanded it. Pur-
suant to this conversation plaintiff boarded Engine 1182

105

and Colosimo boarded 1149. Plaintiff gave Colosimo a
back up signal and Colosimo testified that he answered with
a whistle ‘‘back up’’ signal before starting the engine. By
using the power on Engine 1149, both engines were backed
toward the sand tower and upon a signal from the plaintiff,
1182 was stopped so that it could be sanded. After plaintiff
sanded Engine 1182 he returned to the running board on
the side of the engine and gave Colosimo the signal to back
the engines toward the coal chute. Engine 1149 which was
to be coaled by Colosimo was first spotted at the coal chute
—this time it was stopped without a signal from the plain-
tiff. Colosimo coaled Engine 1149, taking about three or
four minutes for the job. While Colosimo coaled Engine
1149, plaintiff, who was still in the cab of Engine 1182,
checked the fire and turned off the blower. He then got
off the engine on the north side (the side away from the coal
chute) and walked to the rear of the engine toward the
tender. In order for the plaintiff to take coal on Engine
1182 it was necessary for him to be on top of the tender.
There were several methods by which he could have climbed
there. At the point where he was standing at the rear of
the north side of the tender there was no ladder leading to
the top of the tender. However, immediately across from
this point on the rear of the south side of the tender there
was such a ladder. To reach this ladder there were at least
two direct methods he could have used. One would have
been to cross over the pilot (a flat platform on the front
of the engine) on Engine 1149. The other way, the way
he chose to go, was to climb over the draw bar between the
two engines which were coupled together. While he was
climbing over this draw bar, Colosimo, without warning or
without knowing where the plaintiff was or receiving a
signal started the engines. Plaintiff was thrown beneath
the wheels of one engine and his left leg was cut off at a
point below the knee.

The defendants claim that the plaintiff was guilty of con-
tributory negligence in that of the several ways by which
he could have climbed to the top of the tender, he chose the
only dangerous one; that the way chosen was not customa-
rily used and was highly dangerous. Defendants also con-
tend that the plaintiff, who was to follow Colosimo’s direc-
tions, had been ordered by Colosimo to stay on Engine 1182;
that if he had obeyed this order he would not have been in-
jured; and that Colosimo had a right to assume that the

106

plaintiff would obey this order. One difficulty with this
position is that the record does not support it. There is no
testimony tending to show that it was more dangerous to
mount the tender in the manner chosen by the plaintiff.
Defendants apparently rely on Exhibit 3 which is a picture
of these two engines coupled together. This picture shows
the draw bar and other items relating to the hand holds,
etc., on the route which the plaintiff chose. However, we
cannot from this picture conclude that the manner chosen
was highly dangerous and a method not customarily used.
The evidence merely shows that there were several ways
by which the plaintiff could have gotten on top of the tender.
The manner in which he was to get there was left to his
{fol. 103] own judgment. The record does not show that
the way he chose was the more dangerous way. Nor does
the evidence show that Colosimo ordered the plaintiff to
stay on Engine 1182. True Colosimo did testify that ‘‘I
just told him to stay on 1182. That is what I told him, just
to stay on 1182, and I would take care of the 1149’’. But it
is clear that what he meant by this was merely that plaintiff
should confine his work to 1182 and Colosimo would take
care of 1149; for in response to the question: ‘‘ All you
meant by that was that you would take care of 1149 and
Bruner would take care of 118219’’, Colosimo answered:
‘*Yes, sir.’’ This interpretation of this statement is further
borne out by the remainder of Colosimo’s testimony,

We have then this situation: These two men, working to-
gether for the first time, were stopping and starting the
train according to signals given by the plaintiff. The en-
gines were stopped; Colosimo was putting coal in Engine
1149. It was the plaintiff’s duty to get on top of the tender
on Engine 1182. He chose a manner of getting there which
is not shown by the evidence to be either unusual or dan-
gerous. In fact, the only evidence is that which he gave
that he had often used this route and that it was a common
practice among yardmen to do so. Colosimo, without giv-
ing a signal or without knowing where the plaintiff was,
started the engines and threw the plaintiff to the tracks and
under the wheels of one engine. The plaintiff was doing
exactly what he was required to do in the performance of
his duties; to-wit, getting on top of the tender. While it
may be, as defendants argue in their brief, that the manner
chosen was highly dangerous, there is no evidence to show

107

this. We must conclude that the record does not show con-
tributory negligence.

Even if there were several means of reaching a point
where plaintiff was required to be and one was more safe
than the others but all were reasonably safe without move-
ment of the engine and the plaintiff had a right to rely on
the engineer and assume that he would not start the engine
until he received a signal, we do not think the choice of the
less safe route could be considered as having contributed ws
the accident when it was apparent that the unexpected ja
caused by the engine’s movement dislodged the plaintiff,
Even had the latter chosen the safest route, a jar which he
had a right not to expect, and in regard to such non-expecta-
tion it could be presumed he would have regulated his holds
and care of traversal, the dislodgment might have happened.
This is a case where the parties were members of a working
crew working on signals designed for the very safety of that
work. Where the accident has been caused by the failure
to give such signal the party working in a crew responsible
for such omission will not be heard to say that the injury
suffered could have been avoided had the injured party con-
ducted himself on the assumption that the signal would not
be given; that the consequences of the delict could have been
avoided had the injured party, as appears from hindsight,
so conducted or positioned himself as to make the delict in-
consequential. There are perhaps few instances of acci-
dents in industry where one party injured by the negligence
of another might not, had he been warned of the negligence,
have placed himself in more advantageous position to avoid
its consequences. One of the criteria in determining the
standard of care required in industry to fend off a defense
of contributory negligence i is not one fashioned by the imagi-
nation of judges sitting in their chambers but one measured
by the conduct and practices of the average experienced
workman engaged in that industry in relation to others
working with him in their immediate joint enterprise under
the system of signals designed for the safety of such par-
ties engaged in the enterprise. The care which a prudent
person will exercise not to injure others and that which he
[fol. 104] will exercise in order to protect himself from the
uncontemplated action of others are not necessarily gov-
erned by the same circumstances. One for whose benefit
such signal is to be given, may while in the conduct of the
enterprise, rely on the other to give it; and the latter may

108

not, where the other has acted according to the standard
set by the accustomed behavior under such mutual under-
takings, urge that greater care would have avoided the con-
sequences of his omission to give the signal.

It is admitted by the defendants that certain rules for
the operation of trains were put in effect by them, but they
argue that these safety rules, which were relied on by the
plaintiff to show negligence, were not designed for the pro-
tection of employees engaged in operations such as those
in which plaintiff and Colosimo were engaged. One of these
Safety Rules, Sec. 2057, provided:

‘*Engine bell or whistle warning must be given be-
fore engines are moved, then wait at least one minute.’’

The other, Sec. 30, provided:

‘*The bell must be rung when an engine is about to
move and while approaching and passing stations, tun-
nels, snow sheds and public crossing at grade.”’

This latter section was under consideration recently by
the United States Supreme Court in the case of Owens v.
Union Pacific R. Co., 63 S. Ct. 1271, June 14, 1943. It was
there argued that Sec. 30 had no application to the switch-
ing operations involved. The majority of the court held
that it was unnecessary for them on certiorari to decide this
question because it had not been considered by the Court
of Appeals. However, three justices dissented on the
grounds that the evidence showed ‘‘without contradiction
that Rule 30 was not applicable to these switching opera-
tions and that it was the practice of switching crews under
the circumstances of this movement to ‘kick’ the cars with-
out waiting for a signal from the man in decedent’s position
at the switch.’’ There is, therefore, considerable doubt that
these rules had any application to the operations undertaken
by plaintiff and Colosimo.

It is, however, unnecessary to decide this question for
even without the rules, the evidence conclusively shows neg-
ligence on the part of Colosimo. The plaintiff, in outlining
the practice followed in operations of this type stated:

‘Whenever it is to be moved they get a proper signal
to move and then give the signal to warn anybody that
the engine is to be moved, either a whistle or a bell,
it is usually the whistle around there. After they get

109

the signal, that is, from the hostler’s helper, they will
give the proper signal from the engine that is about to
be moved.

**Q. Do you know whether or not these signals, both
from the hostler to the helper and the helper to the
hostler, were used in the movement of the engines in
the yard at Grand Junction, during the time you were
working there?

‘*A, Yes, they were in effect, I always used them and
worked by them.

[fol. 105] ‘*Q. Prior to the time this accident oc-
curred, do you recall any occasion when the signals
were not used?

‘*A. No, I don’t. I always worked according to sig-
nals, that is what we have to move by, is signals.’’

The testimony of Colosimo, who was called by the de-
fendants, also seems to support the view that it was cus-
tomary to move engines in this type of an operation ac-
cording to signals between the hostler and the hostler’s
helper. His testimony shows that after he and the plaintiff
discussed the proposed movement of the engines, he boarded
1149 and the plaintiff boarded 1182. He then stated:

‘*A. After the cinder pit men told me the engine was
okeh to go, I got up on 1149 and whistled ‘back up’ for
the cinder pit, to spot 1182 at the sand house.

. . * * * .

‘*Q. When you got down to the sand house what, if
anything, took place?

‘‘A, Mr. Bruner was upon the running-board of
1182, to give a signal to stop at the proper place, to put
sand in the 1182.

‘*Q. Then what was the next thing that happened?

‘A, Mr. Bruner got through sanding the 1149, and
gave me a go back signal, to go to the coal chute, which
I moved back to the coal chute, and spotted the 1149,
and got out and got up over the tender and put coal in
the 1149.

“*Q. When the spot was made at the coal chute, was
there any signal given to you by Mr. Bruner?

‘*A. When I spotted, do you mean?

**Q. Yes.
‘“*A. No sir.’’

This evidence is not contradicted. In fact it would seem
that the practice had its birth in necessity. If the crew
member operating an engine were to move it without signal
from his co-worker when he knew the latter was engaged
about the train at a point where he could not be seen, we
might expect yard accidents to multiply greatly. There is
also no dispute concerning the fact that Colosimo did not
get a signal from his helper, the plaintiff, to back up so that
1182 could be coaled; nor did he give a whistle signal. It is
also admitted that this sudden start caused the plaintiff to
fall to the tracks. The hostler and his helper customarily
moved the trains by signals between themselves. Colosimo
started the train without either getting a signal from the
plaintiff or giving a whistle or bell signal himself. It was
dark and he could not see the plaintiff nor did he know
where the plaintiff was. Moving the train under these cir-
cumstances was negligence even apart from the safety
[fol. 106] rules. Since the evidence on negligence is such
that the court could have directed a verdict for the plaintiff,
it was not prejudicial error for the court to give instruc-
tions on these safety rules even though said rules may have
had no application to this situation.

By the next assignment it is claimed that the court auth-
orized the jury to assess double indemnity by instructing
(in part) that:

‘*You are instructed that if you find the plaintiff is
entitled to recover, you may award him such damages
not exceeding the sum of $75,000.00 as in your opinion
will compensate him for the pecuniary damages proved
to have been sustained by him and proximately caused
him by the wrong complained of ; and in estimating the
amount of such damages you may consider the physical
and mental pain suffered, if any, the nature, extent,
and severity of his injury or injuries, if any, the extent,
degree, and character of his suffering, mental or physi-
eal, if any, its duration and its severity, and the loss
vf wages and future earnings and impairment of earn-
ing capacity, if any, his.loss of power and capacity to
work, if any, and its effect upon his future.

‘*You may also consider whether the injury was tem-
porary in its nature or is permanent in its character,

111

and from all these elements you will resolve what sum
will fairly compensate plaintiff for injuries sustained.’’

It is contended that the portion of the instruction which
we have italicized permits the jury to grant double recov-
ery for a single loss; that it permits the jury to consider
lost earnings, past and future, in addition to loss of earning
capacity and power and capacity to work when the former
is necessarily included in the latter.

It would perhaps have been better had the court made it
more clear to the jury that these various items covered sub-
stantially the same loss and that the plaintiff would be en-
titled only to that amount which would fairly compensate
him for the loss of earnings.’ However, we do not think
that the jury could have been misled by the instruction
given. In Instruction 9 the jury was told that ‘‘in consider-
ing the element of the loss of wages and future earnings, it
any, which plaintiff may sustain in the future on account of
the loss of his leg, you may * * * consider and de-
termine from the evidence the loss or impairment of plain-
tiff’s earning power, if any, resulting from his injury’’.
Thus Instruction 9 in effect told the jury that loss of wages
and future earnings were included in a consideration of
impairment of earning power. And further, it does not
appear from the instruction quoted above that the jury
could have understood that it could assess damages for both
loss of wages, past and future, and in addition give damages
for impairment of earning power. There was no evidence
of impairment of earning power except as reflected in the
loss of wages, past and future. It would be attributing to
the jury more than ordinary lack of comprehension to as-
sume that it would find loss of earnings and then on the
same evidence double it for impairment of earning power
and then perhaps triple it for loss of power or capacity to
work. If it had looked around for different evidence to
support an additional amount for the latter two phrases it
could not have found it. In consequence, it is only common
sense to suppose that it would have understood these
(fol. 107] phrases to be redundent methods of repeating the
one measure of damages. The instructions when taken to-
gether are not susceptable of the interpretation contended
for by the defendants. While they are not letter perfect,
we do not believe that there was prejudicial error in this
regard.

112

The next contention is that the lower court committed
prejudicial error in giving instructions on abstract prin-
ciples of law which were outside the issues and the evidence.
Objection is made to that portion of Instruction 7 in which
the court read to the jury part of the Federal Employers’
Liability Act including that part which related to the car-
riers liability for injuries resulting from ‘‘any defect or in-
sufficiency, due to its (the carriers) negligence in its cars,
engines, appliances, machinery, track, roadbed, work boats,
wharves or other equipment.’’ Admittedly there were no
issues or evidence purporting to deal with defects or in-
sufficiencies. It would have been better had this portion of
the instruction been omitted. Yet we do not think that this
was prejudicial error. A similar objection was made in
Kusturin v. Chicago & Alton R. Co., 209 Ill. App. 55, where
the court stated:

‘‘The third instruction given at the appellee’s re-
quest stated the substance of the entire Federal Em-
ployers’ Liability Act, including provisions therein not
involved in this case. We think the portion objected to
might well have been omitted, as said by us in a former
case, but still we do not think the jury could have been
misled to believe that appellee could recover here for
any defect in appellant’s track or roadbed.’’

The defendants contend that the jury may have concluded
from this instruction that defendants were charged with
negligence in failing to keep their equipment and roadbed
in proper condition. It could not so have concluded where
there was no evidence even remotely showing any such neg-
ligence. Moreover since we have concluded that the evi-
dence shows negligence on the part of the defendants as
above demonstrated as a matter of law, we therefore must
conclude that there could be no prejudicial error in this
regard.

Likewise there was no prejudicial error in instructing
the jury on rules of the road even though those rules may
have been inapplicable to the issues raised. Such an in-
struction could have only had the effect of influencing the
jury to believe that the defendants were negligent in failing
to enforce the rules. Since we have held that the defend-
ants were negligent in other respects as-a matter of law,
they could not have been prejudiced by this instruction.

113

The same holds true as to Instruction 11 on the ‘‘assump-

tion of risk’’ doctrine. No such issue was raised by the
pleadings or the evidence and no good purpose could have
been served by the giving of such an instruction. Yet this
could not be prejudicial to the defendants for even if the
jury inferred from the giving of such an instruction that
the doctrine of ‘‘assumption of risk’’ applied, the defend-
ants could not have been prejudiced. If they had thought
that the plaintiff had possibly assumed the risk, it would
have been to the defendants’ benefit not to their disadvan-
tage or prejudice.
[fol. 108] While Instruction 16, in which the jury was
told that the plaintiff was engaged at the time of the acci-
dent in interstate commerce and that the case was therefore
governed by Federal rather than State law, may have been
unnecessary in that the source of the law was not neces-
sarily a concern of the jury, it could in no way prejudice
the defendants. The same is true as to Instruction 17 in
which the court admonished those jurors who had had pre-
vious trial experience in negligence cases to dispel from
their minds any and all conceptions that they may have in
respect to the law of negligence because this case was gov-
erned by Federal law rather than State law.

The next con

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385610_0103%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
