# Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Steamship Mutual Underwriting Ass'n v. Westchester Fire Insurance > Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more. URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385608_0553%3A1 ## Record - **Collection:** Supreme Court brief - **Document type:** Petition for Writ of Certiorari - **Published:** January 1, 1974 - **Citation:** 419 U.S. 1070 ## Text OCT 23 197’ | MICHAEL ROOK IF IN THE Supreme Court of the United States OCTOBER TERM, 1974 NO. 74-473 CHARLES W. FROUST "VERSUS COATING SPECIALISTS, INC. STEAMSHIP MUTUAL UNDERWRITING ASSOCIATION LIMITED VERSUS WESTCHESTER FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY, ET AL PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO REVIEW THE DECISION OF THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT TERRIBERRY, CARROLL, YANCEY & FARRELL Benjamin W. Yancey John A. Bolies 2141 International Trade Mart New Orleans, Louisiana 70130 Attorneys for Petitioner INDEX Table of Authorities ---------------- Citations to Opinion Below ---------- Jurisdiction ------------------------ Questions Presented ----------------- Statement of the Case --------------- Facts Adduced at Trial -------------- Reasons for Granting Writ ----------- Conclusion -------------------------- Proof of Service -------------------- Appendix "A" Minute Entry of U.S. District Court for Eastern District of Louisiana - December 27, 1972 ---- Appendix "B" ------------------------ Appendix "C" ------------------------ Appendix "D" ------------------------ 21-22 i TABLE OF AUTHORITIES = Page l Page Aetna Life Insurance Company of Hartford, Conn. v. Maxwell, 89 F.2d 988 (1973) ---------------- 3,45 American Mutual Liability Insurance Co. v. Agricola Furniture Co., (S.Ct. Ala., 1937) 236 Ala. 535, 183 So. 677 ----------------------- 10 Audubon Coin & Stamp Co. v. Alford Safe & Lock Co. (La. App.,1969) 230 So.2d 278 --------------------- 14 Beryllium Corporation v. American Mutual Liability Insurance Company, 223 F. 2d 71 (1955) --------------- 42.9,i1 Buckeye Cotton Oil Company v. Ragland, (5th Cir., 1926) ll F.2d 231 ----------------------- pe Canadian Radium & Uranium Corpora- tion v. Indemnity Insurance Company, (S. Ct. ILL., 1952) 411 I1l. 334 104 N.E. 2d 256 ------------------- 12 Export §.S. Corp. v. American Ins. Co., 106 F.2d 9, aff'd on reh. 108 F.2d 1013, cert.den. 309 U.S. 686, 84 L.ed. 1029, 60 S.Ct. 809 -- 3,16 Gentry v. Swann Chemical Co., (S.Ct. Ala., 1937) 234 Ala. 313, 174 So. 530 ----------------------- 10 Globe Indemnity Co. of New York v. Banner Grain Co., (8th Cir., 1937) 90 F.2d 774 ----------------------- 9 ii TABLE OF AUTHORITIES - Page 2 Page Jernigan v. Allstate Insurance Company, (5th Cir., 1959) 269 £.20 353 ) Aryog JO woNnerH\ddy “Ay !Spwog Yons Aue YsiUsNy 10 10) Kidde oy “Paunsur ayy JO UOIDaZIP ayy Ye 20 Aq payywwod woNHes/Qo Aue yNoYyM JN “yNS 10 BuIpaarosd papuajap yons Aue wi pasindau Ssajun yuapi2re Ue pawesp aq WeYs AsHEG pu yinesse “g aBeaA0D spun _—=SPUOG Jeadde UO Swnnuard We “ADHHOd Siy) JO ArNigeN JO yrusN| BIQeDydde ayy JO Asayeg pue ynessy (p) SS9IKF U! JOU JUNOWE UE JO) SJUBWYIEYE aseajas 0} Spu0g UO SwNiwasd je Aed (q) . Wapiaze Aq Auntur Ayipog,, wa}, ay) UIYJIM Papnjou! you Si SB eseasip Yyons *WuaIpadxa Swaap } Se yINS 20 WHe;D Ajuo sapnjau: ,,aseasip Aq Asniuy Ayipog,, wiay ayy .yuapioze Aq Auniui Aypog,, Ave jO Juawa/yas pue VONeyosau ‘vONeBySeau! yons ayew Aew Auedwor ayy Wid} By) VIYIM Papnjour $i juapInoe Aq Asnius Ayipog e© wos Ajyoaup syinsas ING “WUI/NPNLs 30 asjey “SSajpuNoId $i YNS 40 Burpasrosd YONS 4) Vand ‘joaeyy Se aseasip yons Ajuo pue ,.juapioce Aq Aunius Appog,, we} ay) ui ,Juepioe,, ynor2e UO SaTewep Bumaas pue Asniur Yyons SuiFaye pansy; ayy suede piom ay) JO Burueaw ay} WIYJIM JUaPIDIE Ue JOU SI aSeasip JO UOHDeNjUCD oy, Uns Aue pue s}yauag YonS Bumaas Pasnsu! ayy ySuIeZe Buipaarosd Ave puayap (2) aseasig Aq Ainjuy Aypog “yuapyazy Aq Auntuy Aypog (2) “neys “RIQWNIOD JO JUYSIG ay) pues Auedwor 243 A2yod siyy yo Swe} sayjO ayy Aq papsoye souesNsU! 24) sjradsas Sy CQUaWY JO S2JEIS PAU By} JO AsOjIa] JO BJeYS Aue SUeaW ,.2}e}S,, PsOM ayy , Sywawheg Astquawajddng wuawapas ‘asuajag “14 * ees (9) *Syauag Ayyigesip jeuoiednd20-uoU apiAoid YyrYR Me} YINs Aue JO SUOISIAOIA BSOY} BPN}DUI JOU SaOP Jng “suONeJe;2ap ay} yO E War} “OYSI9Y} [eUapIoU! JO Asessadau Suoijesado ut 10 SuONese/29P ay} JO E Wa}} UI PI2JeUBIsap ajeys e ui SUOR Ul PajeUusisap ajeys @ yO me; aseasip jeuoIjedn220 Aue pue me} UdNesUadwo> ~81900 Ul J9y}12 Pasnsur ayy Aq yuaWAO|GWa siy yO aSuNC> ayy UI pUe jo yn0 Bursue $,UdaWyJOM a4} SUCIW Me} UOIeSUadWOD S.uawyJ0M,, Wa} Payiyendun aut Pasnsur ay) jO aadojdwa Aue Aq epeuesd 30 “suoIssessod 40 S$o10}UJ3} Sy “eQuaewy . me} uonesuad $,uawyiom (e) JO SLIS Paw ayy ul Paureysns “wosjaseyy Zunjnsas awry Ave ye yeop surpnys 7 MoNesuaeWwOD S,URUHION “Ul “aS¥aSip 40 JuapI22e Aq AsNiut AjPOG yO ssnesy SesewRP Se Aed 0} PajeIyQe SUONIUNEG “HE — AyeBay auoraq WeYs pasnsur ayy YrYW SwNS {Ve Psznsur ayy yO yjeYsq UO Aed OY "@ @Besan0d sapuN Ayyiqen jo Yury aqerydde ay 40 y aBeraA02 Auger] ssakojdw3—g azesaaog sapun ayqeAed syunowe ayy 0} uoNppe ui Auedwo> ayy Aq ajgeAed aue ‘sjins pue : * Sue]? JO SJuaWwa; aS Jdarxe ‘\uawaoTe BuuNsur siy) JepUN PassNduUt SJUNOWe ayy “me} UOI}ESUaUWOD S.UaWyIOM ayy Aq PouNsUF ‘ySanbas SAuedwor ayy ye pasndus 9y) JO Pasndad Syyauag 1ayjO pue vONesuadwod {jz Snp uaym Ajjdwod Aed Of | *S8uiused JO SSO} URY) JayYO ‘SasUadxa ajqeuoseas We 10; PasNsu! ay) asuNquias (p) uonesuadwo? S.uawyoy—y d3e1an09 | SINIWIIYIY ININSNE AMO Sy JO SUIa) J2YIO PUL SUOIIPUOD “SUOISNjr2xa “ApyIQey JO SprwH By) O} JaIQnS PUe suONeJe;Iap @y) Us SyuaWajeys ayy UOdN aoueHas UI PUR WniwWaId ayy JO UaWAeD ay) JO VONeJaPISUOD U! ‘joaJay Wed e apeW SUONeIe}2aP ay) UI PaweU ‘pasNsU: 24) YIM Saaudy Auedwod ay) payjed uraiay ‘Auedwod aduesnsus y20}s y ONV NOILVSNSdWOD S.NSWYYOM " AOINOd ALINSVIN .SYSAO71dW3 | OYNVONVLS ELD LIONS WEL OO Phony ante % . fe is a --- Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385608_0553%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.