# Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Heart of the Black Hills Stations v. Federal Communications Commission

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385607_0862%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Petition for Writ of Certiorari
- **Published:** January 1, 1973
- **Citation:** 414 U.S. 1002

## Text

LIBRARY : fs
SUPREME Court, u.§.3~ 269 }

IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

OCTOBER TERM, 1973

No. A-1272

HEART OF THE BLACK HILLS STATIONS,
Petitioner,

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION,
Respondent.

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

DONALD R. SHULTZ
Whiting, Lynn, Jackson,
Shultz, Ireland & Lebrun
P.O. Box 2003
Rapid City, South Dakota 57701

Attorney for Petitioners

Wastengton. OC + @ CLE PUBLISHERS INC. e (202) 393 0625

5
&

oe |

atm ete |

we rrr ne,

" (i)
TABLE OF CONTENTS

CITATION TO OPINIONS BELOW ...............-..
anes bbe bebe eee Oboe ba ae oe
Soa ie i ae 9a ik 1k a
RE ee eer ea
ge rare
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT:

I. The Commission Ignored the Public Interest
Requirement of the Communications Act, 47
ee ay wa RASS eae me 6

lI. The Commission’s Failure To Act Upon
Petitioners’ Applications for Construction Per-
mits and Other Improvements, To Construct a
New Antenna and Transmission Lines Pre-
vented Petitioners From Remedying the Very
Technical Violations Upon Which the Commis-
sion Based Its Denial for Renewal. of Peti-
RE ETS RE ne 8

II]. The Commission’s Reliance on the 1966 Waiver
of the CATV Protection Requirements Was an
Insufficient Basis for Its Findings and Decision
and Constitutes a Denial of Due Process to the
re a eee a near eke es 9
IV. The Commission’s Finding That Petitioners Had
a Decade of Serious Technical Violations and
That Said Violations Were Continuing Is
| Without Substantial Support inthe Record ....... 11
a ee a ia aah eek a 12
re en ak is waite tia el as Ak WSO la
se re Lh a oe wwe oe Oe ee we Oe 1b
| ET ee So ae ah Osa eal a 8 oa ie Ic

| ee te ak aa Wale acne wins Ww wae oe oe Id

cence ne natn

a
Be 07 Na

deere

the... PLEIN INET, : — . . .
, SSE EN TD LIE ENDL ECL E ERLE NDE SER IU LESS TE ERENT TEES NID EEN NE A Reon Mian

(ii)
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases:
Carroll Broadcasting Co. v. F.C.C. (CA-DC), 258 F.2d

Citizens Communication Center v. F.C.C. (CA-DC),

ERE 6 oF nsw d bee ned eee ee ss

City of New York Municipal Broadcasting System v.

ge Be) err

Federal Communications Commission v. Sanders
Bros. Radio Station, 309 U.S. 470, 84 L.Ed. 869,

SID ooh ao Oe ade Aa 40400 bee ee
Joseph v. F.C.C. (CA-DC), 404 F.2d 207 .........

National Labor Relations Board v. Pittsburgh S.S.

Co., 340 U.S. 498, 479, 71 S.Ct.453. ... 2.2...

U.S. v. Storer Broadcasting Co., 76 S.Ct. 763, 351

Fe & oe § eee eee ee

Universal Camera Corp. v. National Labor Relations

Board, 340 U.S. 474, 456, 71 S.Ct.456 ........

Statute:
Federal Communications Act, 47 U.S.C. §151 et

eg a ear er aera arr

Other:

82 Yale Law Journal 1575 (July 1973) ...........

“eee

“eee

eee

IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

OCTOBER TERM, 1973

No. A-1272

HEART OF THE BLACK HILLS STATIONS,
Petitioner,

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION, |
Respondent.

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

Petitioner prays for Writ of Certiorari to be issued to
review the judgment of the Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia entered February 26, 1973,
affirming the order of the Federal Communications
Commission entered on November 1, 1971, and reported
at 32 FCC 2d 169 (1971) and the order of the Federal
Communications Commission dated August 1, 1972,
denying Petitioner’s petition for a reconsideration.

2
OPINIONS BELOW

An initial decision of the Hearing Examiner, Thomas
Donahue, of the Federal Communications Commission,
dated July 17, 1970, 32 FCC 2d 201 (1971) (Appendix
A).

A decision and order of the Federal Communications
Commission was filed on November 1, 1971, denying
applications of the Petitioner for renewal of licenses of
the television broadcast stations KRSD-TV, Rapid City,
and KDSJ-TV, Lead, South Dakota, reported at 32
FCC 2d 169 (Appendix B).

An opinion denying Petitioner’s Petition for Recon-
sideration was denied by the Commission on August 1,
1972, and reported at 36 FCC 2d 568 (1972) (Appendix
C).

A judgment of the United States Court of Appeals,
District of Columbia, dated February 26, 1973, affirming
the orders of the Federal Communications Commission
(Appendix D).

PA at ONT a Oe A

vee

JURISDICTION

The Judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals was
entered on February 26, 1973, a timely Petition for
Rehearing was denied by the court on May 11, 1973. The
jurisdiction of this court is invoked under the provisions
of 28 U.S.C. §1254(1).

Sol E ICL Bi Sipe BAS ad Soh fo Ri a

KA RL OE. oral

{ QUESTIONS PRESENTED

1. Did the Commission fail to abide by the public
- interest requirement of the Communications Act, 47
© U.S.C. §309(a)?

i 2. Did the Commission’s failure to act upon
Petitioners’ applications for construction permits to

‘

r 4

4

b

Meee comer eres as

3

construct a new antenna, transmission lines and other
improvements prevent Petitioners from remedying the
very technical violations upon which the Commission
based its denial for renewal of Petitioners’ license?

3. Was the Commission’s reliance on the 1966 waiver
of the CATV protection requirements an insufficient
basis for its findings and decision and constitute a denial
of due process to the Petitioners?

4. Was the Commission’s finding that Petitioners had a
decade of serious technical violations and that said
violations were continuing without substantial support in
the record?

STATUTE INVOLVED

The Federal Communications Act, 47 U.S.C. §151 et
seq.; 47 U.S.C. §155(e); 47 U.S.C. §309(a).

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

This case involves the denial of application for the
renewal of licenses for the Petitioners’ broadcasting
stations, KRSD-TV at Rapid City and KDSJ-TV at Lead,
South Dakota.

The Petitioners, Eli and Harry Daniels, are brother-
partners and owner-operators of the licensed stations
since 1957 (KRSD-TV) and 1959 (KDSJ-TV).

They were pioneers in bringing television to western
South Dakota where the market is admittedly small,
competitive and located in a sparsely populated area.
They have been beset with usual problems confronting a
pioneer; including, costly updating of equipment made
obsolete with the rapid advance of technology,
insufficient trained manpower, a fallible source of

NEN AE IG MNES SELES TN NN oN

f
f
xy
8
3
:

Ei
i
.
3
Ed
4
B
4
i
3
#
*

ee 2

wna

iS anes

4

network signal, manpower shortage, and an _ unco-
operative weatherman. (Appendix A—p. 3a, 27a)

A renewal hearing before the Hearing Examiner in
1968 found technical violations, mainly an inferior
broadcast picture and spurious emissions. In 1967 a
tornado had seriously damaged the antenna structure of
KRSD-TV and in January 1968, Petitioners filed with the
Commission an application for construction permit for a
new antenna and transmission line to replace the
equipment damaged during the tornado. No action has
ever been taken by the Commission on this application.
(JA-32-35, 148-153, 296)

The failure of the Commission to follow the statutes
and its rules and to take any action on the application,
left the Petitioners operating with a temporary antenna
and without an opportunity for a more complete
replacement of equipment until the Commission acted
upon their application. Thereafter, the television stations
received citations from the Commission for technical
violations. Such violations were again, for a large part,
related to the deficiencies in the transmission line and
antenna, improvement in which the Commission, by its
refusal to act, had effectively prevented.

In 1966 a citation for technical violations was made by
a Commission engineer complaining that the broadcast
picture was of inferior quality and viewers were
dissatisfied. The violations cited by the F.C.C. Engineer
in 1961 and 1966 were satisfactorily answered or
corrected by the Petitioners to the Engineer (JA-SO, 51).
The technical violations consisted of temporary micro-
wave problems which were corrected (JA-51).

The Commission’s rules gave existing television
stations, such as KRSD-TV, certain protection on CATV
systems, primarily carriage and non-duplication. Carriage

5

rules required that CATV system must carry the local
television station on one of its channels. Non-duplication
required that the CATV could not carry another station
which broadcasted the same program as the local station
to avoid broadcasting of the same network program on
separate channels. The CATV Company operating in
Rapid City asked for a waiver of both carriage and
non-duplication requirements for the reason that KRSD
signal was temporarily not viewable. The Petitioners did
not respond immediately and the Commission; in 1966,
did grant a requested waiver of the carriage and
duplication requirements as to KRSD. In September
1966 Petitioners applied to the Commission to vacate the
waiver and restore the carriage and non-duplication
protections for the reason that it was then transmitting
an acceptable signal, on which the Commission never
acted. Shortly thereafter the CATV and Petitioners
voluntarily agreed to a non-duplication agreement and
CATV requested rescindment of its waiver request, which
was never acted upon by the F.C.C. (Appendix C—p. 17c)

The Hearing Examiner, after hearing, released his
initial decision July, 1970, finding that upon balancing
various technical deficiencies at various times against the
improving performance of the Petitioners and evidence of
improvements of the technical performance by the
Petitioners and taking into consideration in his opinion,
factors which were beyond the control of the Petitioners,
granted a one year short term renewal. (Appendix
A—p. 27a)

Exceptions and a brief in support thereof were filed by
the Commission’s Broadcast Bureau. The Commission
reversed the Examiner by decision and order of
November |, 1971, and denied renewal of the Petitioners’
licenses. (Appendix B)

“OVER RL EGE Re Et Reet ap aanEg Rae

POAT:

ya LEIS RITE BLE OPEL LAS LOM BRT ELE -
ss AWE Re LRG RPS LE BREN TEE) GROG IOS DE. TETRIS Rta OE Mote oere Pg eB ee i
¥ PIES ae az bare SNES

6

The Petitioners petitioned for reconsideration which
was denied by the Commission on August |, 1972
(Appendix C). The orders of the Federal Communica-
tions Commission were affirmed on appeal to the Court
of Appeals for the District of Columbia on February 26,
1973. (Appendix D)

REASONS FOR GRANTING WRIT
L.

THE COMMISSION IGNORED THE PUBLIC INTEREST
REQUIREMENT OF THE COMMUNICATIONS ACT,
47 US.C. §309%a).

The Hearing Examiner conciuded that it would be in
the public interest to grant a renewal of the license to the
Petitioners and stated:

“(3) The Examiner is by no means unaware of the
ease with which the public interest baby can be
emptied out in a tears-of-sympathy bath. On the
other hand he is convinced that the sweep of the
public interest standard is not so narrow as to
preclude thoughtful consideration of extenuating
circumstances that may accompany conduct that
otherwise would call for preemptory termination of
stewardship. Here the licensees are sore beset. They
pioneered their field. They work hard for small
remuneration. Their market is small. Their competi-
tion is great. Their purse is thin. They suffer
manpower shortage. Some of their basic equipment
is inefficient. Their source of network signals is
fallible. The weather is their enemy. And, it should
be noted that called to account they have not been
cavalier but, rather, cooperative. Moreover, their
eitorts at reform have met with some success.

(4) The question of whether or not to renew is a
hard one. On the one hand is the need to protect the

ae ee,

DA SEN AE RT

7

public from incursions on its interest by the
incompetent and inept. On the other hand, it is no
easy matter to take the bread and butter out of
men’s mouths. In the order clause below the
Examiner has attempted to reconcile these con-
flicting considerations.” (Appendix A—p. 26a)

The conclusion was sound and practical in view of the
circumstances. Public interest for western South Dakota
is far different than public interest for large metropolitan
areas. The public interest in western South Dakota will be
best served by the operation of a technically inferior
television station, offering a variety of access to network
programming rather than a deprivation to the public of
such technically inferior broadcasting without a perfect
replacement. A perfect replacement does not seem in the
realm of possibility as set forth by the evidentiary
conclusions of the examiner; i.e. small market, manpower
shortage and insufficient capitalization. Rapid City and
Lead, South Dakota, are rural areas. There is no
substantial reason to believe that any new applicant or
replacement licensee could profitably furnish better
service to the public based on these market conditions,
with the result that the public interest will be overcome
with a monopoly by the strong competitor. The general
policy of the Communications Act, evidenced by
congressional history as it relates to broadcasting, is the
promotion of competition. Federal Communications
Commission v. Sanders Bros. Radio Station, 309 U.S.
470, 84 L.Ed. 869, 60 S.Ct. 693; Joseph v. F.C.C.
(CA-DC), 404 F.2d 207; Carroll Broadcasting Co. v.
F.C.C. (CA-DC), 258 F.2d 440.

¥
a
t
7
:

&

aT creeper rere torte nog emnctmcnapeancm tne

AE RES 3H

8

DENIAL OF DUE PROCESS

THE COMMISSION’S FAILURE TO ACT UPON PETI-
TIONERS’ APPLICATIONS FOR CONSTRUCTION PER-
MITS AND OTHER IMPROVEMENTS, TO CONSTRUCT A
NEW ANTENNA AND TRANSMISSION LINES PRE-
VENTED PETITIONERS FROM REMEDYING THE VERY
TECHNICAL VIOLATIONS UPON WHICH THE COM-
MISSION BASED ITS DENIAL FOR RENEWAL OF
PETITIONERS’ LICENSE.

In January of 1968, the Petitioners filed with the
Commission its application (BPCT-4077) for construction
permits for construction of a new antenna and
transmission line to replace the equipment damaged in
the tornado of 1967. (JA-32-34, 148-153, 296)
(TR-321-323). 47 U.S.C. §155(e) requires the Com-
mission to promptly and orderly conduct its business
with the objective of rendering a final decision within
three months from the date of the filing of all
applications which are not designated for hearing. No
action has ever been had on the Petitioners’ applications
and the Commission has indicated, in its decision, that no
action was ever contemplated. In its decision the
Commission refers to its “policy” of not acting on major
facility changes during the pendancy of a renewal
hearing. (Appendix C—12c)

The applications for construction permits were filed in
January 1968, some nine months before the renewal
hearings. This “policy” is directly in violation of the
statutory mandate and has effectively denied the
Petitioners the opportunity to construct facilities which
would largely remove the technical violations and
deficiencies upon which the Commission relied. (JA-129-
131, 134-136) Congress obviously had in mind a concept

, A 202 PFs Sess ee ———

9

of due process to parties petitioning for construction
permits before the Commission, and the Commission, by
its failure to follow the congressional mandate, has
effectively denied the Petitioners due process of law in its
relations with the Commission.

Citizens Communication Center v. Federal Communi-
cations Commission (CA-DC), 447 F.2d 1201. The City
of New York Municipal Broadcasting System v. Federal
Communications Commission (CA-DC). 223 F.2d 637;
U.S. v. Storer Broadcasting Co., 76 S.Ct. 763, 351 U.S.
192, 100 L.Ed. 1081.

Hil.

THE COMMISSION’S RELIANCE ON THE 1966
WAIVER OF THE CATV PROTECTION REQUIRE-
MENTS WAS AN INSUFFICIENT BASIS FOR ITS
FINDINGS AND DECISION AND CONSTITUTES A
DENIAL OF DUE PROCESS TO THE PETITIONERS.

The Commission, in its decision and order, relied
heavily on the inference that KRSD had, in 1966 and
continuously thereafter, an inferior signal based upon the
Commission’s order in 1966 granting to the local CATV a
waiver of CATV rules. (Appendix B—3b) The Commis-
sion’s rules governing the operation of CATV systems
require that said system must carry the signal of any local
television station and an additional requirement of
non-duplication of any program of a local station of
another CATV channel.

The requirement of non-duplication is designed to
prevent the audience of a local TV station from being
diverted to another originating station foreign to the
community. The local CATV, in its request, was granted
a waiver of the carriage and non-duplication rules on the
basis that the Petitioners broadcast signal was too poor to
be usuable by the CATV system.

ES
E

10

The temporary waiver of the rules granted by the
Commission was made before the Petitioners had an
opportunity to object and a permanent stay was issued in
February of 1966. Based on the foregoing, the
Commission, in its opinion, inferred unfavorable to the
Petitioners, that the Petitioners’ poor signal had
continued since January of 1966.

“In this regard, we find it to be particularly relevant
that we were compelled in 1966 to grant an unusual
waiver of our CATV carriage and non-duplication
rules (Section 74.1103) to the Rapid City CATV

system, because KRSD-TV was providing a signal of
$ such poor quality that it was not usable by the cable
i system. Black Hills Video Corporation, 2 FCC 2d

243 and 465 (1966). Accordingly, we relieved the
cable system of the rules requirements ‘until such
time as it appears that KRSD is providing a signal of
acceptable quality. ...” 2 FCC 2d at 466. It is now
more than five years later, and the waiver is still in
effect.

“This fact, in conjunction with the continuity waiver
(CATV), raises the fundamental issue of whether
this licensee is technically qualified to remain a
licensee of these stations.” (Appendix B)

In doing so the Commission ignored the Petitioners’
efforts which resulted in the alleviation of this difficulty,
and as a result thereof, a request by CATV to withdraw
its earlier request for a waiver of the rules and CATV’s
voluntary non-duplication agreement. (JA-269, 274-278)

Further, in 1966, Petitioners requested non-
duplication protection because of an improved picture
quality. This petition was never acted on by the
Commission. (Appendix C—Sc)

Due process requirements dictate that the decisions of
the Commission must be sustained on_ substantial

Pies neces ris > EERO ETE IES TN EO a MATE So

1]

evidence when viewed in the light that the record in its
entirety furnishes. Universal Camera Corp. v. National
Labor Relations Board, 340 U.S. 474, 456, 71 S.Ct. 456;
National Labor Relations Board v. Pittsburgh S.S. Co.,
340 U.S. 498, 479, 71 S.Ct. 453.

IV.

THE COMMISSION’S FINDING THAT PETI-
TIONERS HAD A_ DECADE OF SERIOUS
TECHNICAL VIOLATIONS AND THAT SAID VIO-
LATIONS WERE CONTINUING IS WITHOUT
SUBSTANTIAL SUPPORT IN THE RECORD.

There was no finding by the hearing examiner of the
existence of any violations by Petitioners prior to 1966.
(Appendix A) The technical violations cited by the
F.C.C. Engineer since 1966 were either corrected or
satisfactorily explained by the Petitioners to the F.C.C.
Engineer (JA-50, 51). There was no evidence to base a
finding that the broadcast picture was continuously
defective. The mistaken inference drawn by _ the
Commission on the CATV waiver is without support and,
therefore, the finding of the Commission, that the
violations were continuous, is without any basis in the
record. The technical violation of the spurious signal was
not continuous and was properly rebutted by an
independent service company, RCA Co., which con-
ducted tests and found no spurious signals (JA-71, BH
Exhibit 6) and which was confirmed by the F.C.C.
Engineers’ inspection at KDSJ-TV in 1971. (JA-138, 139;
144, 146) The reliance on “continuous technical
violations” is further evidenced by the Commission’s
failure to act upon and approve the Petitioners’
applications for the construction permits of the new
antenna and transmission line previously discussed.

12

There being no substantial evidence to support the
Commission’s decision that the technical violations had
existed over a decade or in fact were continuous, renders
the Commission’s decision emasculated and without
substantial evidence in support thereof, thus violating the
Petitioners’ rights without due process of law. Universal
Camera Corp. v. National Labor Relations Board, supra,
National Labor Relations Board v. Pittsburgh S.S. Co.,

supra.

CONCLUSION

A present FCC Commissioner, Nickolas Johnson, in
this month’s Yale Law Journal, Volume 82, pages 1575
et seq. “A Day in the Life: The Federal Communications
Commission”’ observes that:

“There is reason enough to assert that everything the
FCC does is wrong.” p.. 1575

and reviews a typical weekly meeting to show the
arbitrary and capricious manner in which the FCC
conducts its decision-making process. He concludes his
treatise with the statement the article will afford:

‘“*, . the judicial branch some idea of how bad things
really are, of how tenuous is the basis for the idea
that judges should defer to the FCC’s ‘rational and
orderly process.’ Long-range reforms aside, if there
is to be any immediate hope for the FCC, it lies with
the courts.” p. 1634

The Petitioners do not assert that everything that the
Commission does is wrong; but they do assert that the
Commission clearly was arbitrary and capricious in
denying Petitioners a renewal of their licenses.

As Commissioner Johnson observes in his article, the
Staff daily manipulates the Commission (page 1633) and
this occurred in our case. The Commission repeatedly

halted ieiaiiaiari aia eee ae ad ait ah iaccn reat ayias:

SR a

Da eee ae . .
Se ee TT Le ETE NI Ne tate nee

IL BBE II AG SPRY

POA LET IM, Ne

»* Pie Paen proces

13

relied on “violations” by petitioners claimed by the Staff
Engineers and repeatedly refused to recognize petitioners’
responses to those claimed violations.

The Court of Appeals erred when, in its traditional
reluctance to overturn the decision of the FCC, it
summarily affirmed the Commission’s decision. Commis-
sioner Johnson observes that the FCC tends to punish
hardest the small broadcaster for violations of its rules.
(p. 1625) The Commissioner’s decisions involving these
Petitioners is too harsh and is thereby arbitrary and
capricious and should be reversed and a fair hearing given
to the Petitioners’ answers to the claimed violations.

Because this case presents questions of substantial and
unique importance, and because the decisions of the
Court of Appeals and the Commission deprive the
Petitioners of rights without due process, and are in
conflict with the decisions of this Court, it is submitted
that this Petition should be granted and the record
reviewed to reveal no substantial evidence that the
Petitioners were inept, careless or unwilling to abide by
the rules and regulations of the Federal Communications

Commission.

:
&
;

Respectfully submitted,

DONALD R. SHULTZ
Whiting, Lynn, Jackson, ;
Shultz, Ireland & Lebrun |
P.O. Box 2003
Rapid City, South Dakota 57701

Attorney for Petitioners

Dated this 8th day of August, 1973.

Peele hae eee

POA EER ereeoamE Ta amoer —
. iis wEnIEeT: ’ FEL RIT IS TEN SOLE NR LEP RENLT NE S ELIE SES ore |

cone eee

la

APPENDIX A

Hcart of the Black Hille Stations, The, et al. 201

BEFORE THE

¥F.C.C. 7019-28

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION

Wasuincron, D.C. 20584

In Re Applications of
Eu ano ILarny Danirrs, d..a. THE HEART or
THE Biack Hints Srations
For Renewal of License of Station
KRSD-TYV, Rapid City, S. Dak.
Ent ann Harry DAnters, D.b.A. THE HEART OF
THE Biack Hrs STATIONS
For Renewal of License of Station
KDSJ-TV, Lead, S. Dak.

APPFARANCES

Docket No. 18358
File No. BRCT-410

Docket No. 18359
File No. BRCT-364

Stephen A. Gold, Mark E. Fields, and Samuel Miller, for The

Heart of the Black Hills Stations; chard MM.

Rieht and Vergil W.

Zacy, for Chief, Broadcast Bureau, Federal Communications

Commission.

Inim1au Decision or Hearne Examiner Tuomas H. Donanvur

(Issued July 14, 1970; Released July 17, 1970)

PRELIMINARY STATEMENT

1, By Memorandum Opinion and Order released October 21, 1968,
the Commission designated the captioned applications for hearing.

These were the issues specified :

(1) To determine the nature and extent of the violations of the Com-
mission Ruies and Regulations by the licensees of Station KRSD-TYV.
Rapid City. South Dakota, as disclosed by Official Notices of Violation
issued against that station on September 27, 1966 and October 24,

1967. by the station's responses thereto, and by related documeits;

(2) To determine the nature and extent of the violation of Commis-
sion Rules and Regulations by the licensees of Station KDSJ-TV.
Lead, South Dakota, as disclosed by Official Notices of Violation
issued against that station on September 27, 1966 (corrected No-
vember -f. 1966) and October 24, 1967, by the station’s responses thereto

and by related documents;

(3) To determine whether the licensees’ management and operation
of Stations KRSD-TV and KDSJ-TV was so negligent, careless. or
inept. ov evidences such disregard for the Commission's Mules and
Regulation-, that they cannot. be relied upon to fulfill the responsibili-

ties na posed upon them; and

a. ee. 3d

ba ace al Ral ca, f tf aM
le aia = TARBR IY

a
.
‘
e

ne et ee a a
SAI, ASB

Sabb i ae

Fp esas Oh et
Eee

ATS OE LE ON

Tee PRA Pe SS aes

RAO Peewee eae

"he AROS eS thie aay,

eta eRe

2a

202 Federal Communications Commission ‘Reports

(4) To determine, in light of the evidence adduced under the tore

foing issues, whether the licensees of Stations KRSD-TV and KDS.-

Y'V ave qualified to receive renewals of these licenses and whether re-
newal of these licenses would serve the public interest.

The order directed the Broadcast Bureau to serve on tho licensees a
Bill of Particulars setting forth the facts upon which the issues were
based. On Octuber 28, 1968, this document was furvished.

2. A prehearing conference was held on November 27. 1965, in
Washington. The matter was heard in Rapid City, South Dakota, on
March 10-13, 1969, and in Washington, D.C.. on April 17, 1968. On
the latter date the record was closed. The record was reopened three
times in Washington, on May 27. 1969, on November 25, L960, and on
January 15, 1970. Proposed findings were filed by the licensees aad by
the Broadcast Bureau on February 10, 1970. Reply findings were filed.
by both parties on March 3, 1970.

FINDINGS OF FACT
Some Background Data

3. Eli and Harry Daniels are equal partners in the captioned li-
censees. They have been operators of the licensed stations since 1957
(KRSD-TYV) and 1959 (KDSJ-TV).

4. Eli Daniels oversees the day-to-day operations of both stations.
including engineering. Engineering work normally performed by a
consultant is performed by him. Born in 1911 in Wyoming he attended
a radio and ciectronics school for one year. In 1932 he took a coarse in
college algebra by correspondence from the University of Wyomiig.
While in the Army he took a course in engineering mathematics hy
correspondence from the University of Washington. In 1956 he at-
tended the Capitol Radio Institute in Washington, D.C.

5. For a munber of vears Eli Daniels held an amateur license. In
1933 he received a first-class radiotelephone license and has held it
ever since. In 1984 he built KW YO in Sheridan, Wyoming, sind served
there until 1939 as Chief Engineer. From 1939 to 1940 he owned and
operated a radio repair shop. In 1940 he enlisted in the Army and
served as a radio technician with the Alaska Communications Com-
mission. He was discharged from the Army in 1945. Shortly there-
after, he, his brother, and his father obtained a construction permit
for a radio station in Deadwood, South Dakota. They built the sta-
tion themselves and it went on the air as KDSJ (AM) in 1947.
In 1953 the same group built KRSD (AM), Rapid City. In 1957 they
built KRSD-TV in Rapid City and in 1959 KDSJ-TV in Lead.’ In
1958 they received a construction permit for an inter-city private relay
link, thereby bringing live television network programming to the
Black Hills for the first time. Since 1960 Eli and Harry Daniels have
been the licensees and have operated the two television stations. They
have received a nwnber of public service commendations for their sta-
tions’ services to such organizations as the Rapid City Chamber of
Commerce, United States Army, United States lic Force, Rapid City
Jaycees, Salvation Army, and the United States Post Oflice.

1 Lead and Deadwood are adjoining towns.
32 F.C.C. 2d

3a

Heart of the Blavk slilis Stations, Tae, et al... 903

Harry Daniels handles the finsucial atlairs of the stations, Those
affairs are not very good, The market in which the stittions operate is
listed by the American Researel Bureau as ISkrd in the nation, In
Rapid City there are another commercial television station and a nen-
commercial educational station, In both Lead and Rapid City cable
systems furnish subservihers with imported television service, The
wives of both partners ave employed outside the stations, Exeluding
allowance for depreciation, boun stations lose money, At the tine of
the hearing the two partners were eae h taking out of the two stations”
operations ‘about $3000 month in sale ‘.

KRSD-1V—Noticrs of Violations and Responses 1960-1967

7. In September 1966 KRSD-TV was inspected by two Commission
engineers, John MeKinney, Engincer ia Charge, Central TV Monitor-
ing Bureau at Grand |: dand, Nebra: ka, and Donald E,W vate of the
Denver Field Office, Following the inspection, on September 2 27, 16,
each engineer sent the station an Otlicial Notice of Violation (FCC
Form 793-. \). Speeifice violations cited in the MeKinney notice read
as follows:

Non-compliance with F.C.C. Rules and Regulations as follows:

1. Section 73.668(b). Visual te aural frequency separation unsteady and
measured as 4501.110 in one instance.

2. Section T3.682(0) (15) & (17). Reference white level and set-up level
not maintained within prescribed limits.

3. Section 73.6s2(a) (15). Aural radiated power as measured by the mobile
monitoring unit was approximately equal to the visnal radiated power.

4. Section TACST O02). With full sweep applied to the KRSD-TV visnal
transmitter variations us great as T db in amplitude were observed between the
2.1 and 4.1 Me/s portions of the radiated siguual.

&. Section T5.08T(a) 03). Visual carrier minus the colot sabeasvier frequency
(—3.58S) measured —35 dh

6. Section 73.600, Fig. 6. Color burst amplitude measured at not more than
20% of syne.

Those cited in the Wyattumotice read:

Non-compliance with the Commission's Rules Governing Radio Broadcast
Services as follows:

1. Section 73.639(b) (G6) in that authority to operate with the substitute aural
exciter in the aural transmitter was not available Telegraphic authority to
operate with the substitute aural exciter expired August 6, 1906.

2. Section 73.68(b) (4) in that the station has operated with visual output
power less than SO percent of the suthorized power in excess of 10 days without
prior Comunission authority. The station has operated with visual output power
less than $0 percent of the authorized power since August 6, 1/

3. Section 73.669(2) in that a maintenance log as required by Section 73.672
has not been maintained.

4. Section 73.672(a)(5) in that there was no record available showing that
the tower lights and tower light controls lave been inspected pursuant to Section
17.488(d) with the results entered in the maintenance log.

5. Section 73.672(4a)(6) in that there was no record available showing that
the calibration of the visual and aural power meters has been accomplisied
in accordance with Section 74.680 The results of this calibration are to be
entered in the maintenance log,

6G. Section 73.672(09(13) Gi) in that there was no record available showing
that the monthly frequency measurement has beer accomplished in accordance
With Section 73.690, The results of this measurement to be made in the maine
tenance log.

$3 F.C.C. 2d

E

SURO

ae

4 me

n

N82 REA ANTN HIMES BIE ALPE OPTI RPM INE TIT VINES RAP VEHN IIY MY PNA APREAN I ARUSHA R POM ORRIN AE. TREN V IN ERO GR

ROT IS IY He a Wa Da Re AG

4a

204 Federal Communications Commission Reports

7. Section 73.661 in that the original operator license (or FCC Form 759) of
the operator, Frank T, Etherington (on duty from 7:00 AM through 3:00 PM
on September 14, 1966) was not posted. (Only a photocopy of the license was

tel. )
" Rection 73.680(b) (2) In that the aura) tranamitter output power has been
in excess of 110 percent of the authorized power as specified by Section
73.682 (a) (19) since March 1, 1060,

8. On October 15, 1966, Eli Daniels responded to both notices.
His response to the McKinney notice reads: .

Reference: Violation notice by John McKinney, Engineer In Charge, dated
Sept. 27, 1960. Notice received on Sept. 30, 1066, FOC office in Denver
(Mr. George) was called for an extension of time in which to answer.

‘ Violation #1; We were operating with a substitute aural exciter because repairs

were being made on the regular one. Authority was obtained from the

Commission to use a substitute. The regular unit has since been installed,

“ however we are getting some drifting with temperature changes.

q Violation #2: This is a condition that whenever we are using the network we
cannot control the set-up. We can control the white level and we are watching
this more closely. We are looking into the possibility of using a local sync
generator locked to the net to correct the set-up portion of this violation.

Violation #3: Our aural transmitter was being operated according to Section

ih oS

i 73.682(a) (15) as amended eff. 5-11-64; III (64)-1; which calls for a range
8 of power between 10 & 70 percent of the visual transmitter power. Our
% visual was operating at reduced power, due to weak tubes (4X500's) in
4 the IPA stage. This violation has been corrected in that we have reduced
& our aural power to operate in the range between 10 & 20 percent of our
i visual transmitter power as advised by the inspector.

Y Note: Transmittal sheets to.up-date my copy of the FCC rules have not
% been received. I have written the GPO several times during the last yea:
4 and t. half to correct this situation and it appears that I'm finally getting
i results.

4 Violation #4: This condition was caused by a faulty transmission line which

hae heen causing the station trouble for several months. The condition was

% caused by a faulty center-conductor-connector in the transmission line. It
i was intermittent and varied with the wind. This in turn caused standing
8 waves as shown by the sweep response. After many hours of tower work
; the bad connector was located and repaired. It was located at the 350 foot
4 level. Please refer to the May 11, 66 Transmitter & Maintenance log sheet ;
% (see reverse side for maintenance details). The condition has been corrected.
Violation #5: Inspection of the minus 3.58 notch filter showed it to be tuned

rs properly. No doubt this discrepancy was caused by reflection on the trans-
a mission lines as explained above.

a Violation #6: Color burst amplitude will vary from program to program which

: we receive from our network feed; (we have no local color). This condition

cannot be corrected for the time being because we are receiving our signal
off-the-air from KFYR-TV, Bismarck, N.D. which in turn is off-the-alr
from WDAY-TV, Fargo, N.D. and which in turn is off-the-air from KSPT-
TV, Minneapolis, Minn.

) His response to the Wyatt notice included as attachments 12 pages of
copies of transmitter operating and maintenance logs. The response,
{ itself, reads:

i Reference Violation notice by Donald EB. Wyatt, Issuing Officer, dated Septcm-
ber 27, 1966, received September 30, 1966.
; Violation #1: Authority to operate with a substitute aural exciter was attached
to the unit in the transmitter, This telegraphic authority from the FCC in
* Washington, D.C. was handed to the inspector by my operator, Mr. Tom
\ Hoffman, Jt was the only instrument of nuthority received from the FCC.
It had expired and through a mistake of identity, I had had another tele-
graphic authority which was dated to expire on September 16, 1966, which I

82 F.C.C. 2d
{

¢
Bee meme vemen OPER WePNeenenare

OLN TEE

5a

Heart of the Black Hiils Stations, The, et al. 205

mistootefor the more recent authority mentioned above. Lhe repaired regular
unit bas been fnstulicd.

Vivlation #2; ‘Lhe output meter oo the transmitter is a peak reading device and
when everything is working normally it is set-np to read 507 volta for 5 kw
peak power. The low readings as noted by the inspector (around 350) did
not indicate true output power because of the condition of the transminsiou
lines, (je, faulty lines through no fault of our own), Since the reilections on
the lines were causing standing waves the peak readipg device will read
differently depending ou Where iis instilled in the me. Under the above
conditions, the most accurate method of measuring power was by the indirect
method. For turther information on the condition of the line please refer
to the May 11, 66 maintenance eutries on the reverse side of the sheet;
attached. When the transmitter was operating into a dummy load and/or
into normal transmission conditlofs, the transmitter delivered 3kw average
power with a plate voltage of S.oOkv and 1.0 umperes of plate curreut the
eiliciency factor is 459 (the manufacturer rated the transmitter at near
5050). Whereas we were operating with ap input of 3.05 kilovolts and 1.6
amperes current into the tinal amplifier. This is 6.475 input power and at

“ 45% etficiency this is 2.46 kw or 82% of 3kw average.

Violution #4: 1 believe that we kept u pretty good account of our maintenance us
required by 73.669(a). Our maintenance log is incorporated witb our trann-
mitter log since the latter is maintained daily and whenever any main-
tenance information is logged it is added to the transmitter operating sbeet.,
Please refer to the attached Xerox copies of our logs dated May 11, May 15,
May 16, June 27, June 28, July 21 and August 25, all 1966, for maintenance
entries.

Violation #4: Section 73.672(a)(5) does not appear in my copy of the rules.

_ . Page 212. (EU.1/64) of my rule book has 73.672(e) which states a record
must be made of tower Light inspection. Please refer to Transwitter & Main-
tenance log sheet dated August 25/66. We alse did tower work which included
lighting inspection on June 27 and 28th as noted on the logs.

Violation #5: 73.672(a)(6) does not appear in my copy of the rules. However
please refer to T & M log sheet dated May 16, 1966, reverse side. Calibration
was performed and noted, however it does not state results, other than
normal. The procedure is to set-up the output meter to read numerally the
peak power output. : :

Violation #6: Section 73.672(a) (S) (ii) does not appear in my rule book. Section

. 73.690(b) (3) when operating without a frequencr monitor ete. and (c) of
‘same section refers to logging results. Since we have been working with a
recently repaired monitor, we have not had the occasion to check frequencies
as often as once a month. Therefore logging was not done. | ;

Violation #7: This has been corrected.

Violation #8: Section 73.689(b) (2) states that power is to be 80 to 110% of
authorized power. And Section 73.682(a) (15) does not appear in my rule
hook, however the inspector informed me that the authorized power tis
between 10 and 20 percent of the visual power. This condition has been
complied with.

‘Please note: An extensive effort has been made during the last year and
one half to obtain transmittal sheets to up-date my copy of the rules.
Finally this last week, I seem to be getting results from the C.S.S. subscrip-
tion Unit, P.O. 1533 Wash. D.C.

On tthe same date, October 15, 1966, Daniels sent notices to both the

FCC Denver and Washington offices that: (1) KRSD-TV had rein-

stalled its regular aural exciter; (2) the station would operate tempo-

rarilv with reduced power so that transinission lines could be repaired,

9. On October 3, 1967, McKinney again inspected KRSD-TYV. Fol-

lowing this inspection. on October 24, 1967, a Notice of Violation was
sent the station. Specitic violations cited read as follows :

Non-compliance with F.C.C, Rules and Regulations as follows :

1. Section 17.56. Tower lighting has not been repaired as soon as practicable.

October 2, 1967—Entry in operating log shows that "Top (beacon) light and two

32 F.C.C. 2d
104-015—71-—-3

OAT PATENT PORN POHATAIRIEIED RFORS Frepy Parner a ognencnatr ann nna .
. pie iets kat ee a Ll aU an AOR ee -_
wow ee rw any |

ates 1.

Pee en Leataon a sv s alad al Santndal ta ei alle cumini

ear

6a

206 Federal Communications Commission Reports

lower light« out™ Signed, “Hoeffwan™. Thix some entry appears hack to Septem-
ber 8, 1807. On September §. 1067, an entry by Eli Danielx (watehstander> indi-
cates “OK” for all lights On September 7. 157. an entry says “2 lower lights and
top light eut—notitied control tower”. signed Jerry Villone. Entries from 6. 2767
to 9/6/17 indicate two lower light« out. Eutries from 5, 2/67 te 6/26/67 indicate
one lower light out. Ne entriex in log ~how that any lightx were replaced during
this period of time.

2. Section 73.060.a). Maintenance logx are not maintained. Licensee represeni. Section T2.66000). Maintenance logs were not maintained. Licensee repre-
sents that tiaaiutenwnce jogs are made a part of operating logs by logging mainte-
nance Information in Remarks Column of operating tog. Sufficient entries could
not be found to substantiate this claim.

G& Section T3109 (b). Operating loz does pot indicate time zone used at station.

ZT. Section TACT 6a 62). Numerous periods of station outage appear in eper-
ating leg without proper explanation fur same. For example. on August 30. 1967, &
operator sizned on duty at G:45 AM but there are no jog entries from 7:00 AM
through 10:30 AM. Additionally, on August 11, 12. and 24, similar blank spaces KG
appear in operating legs without cause fui interruption shown. Many of these 3
are in middle of program day and last for two to three hours.

S. Section 72.672(a) 63). Monthiy frequency measurements not logged. Checked Es
logs back through February 1967. 4
, a. _ T3.672(b). Entry for quarterly tuwer lighting check not signed or ;
dated. :

10. Section 73.682(a) (17). No set-up present on network programming. 3

11. Sections 73.687 (a) (2), T3.68ST (a) (3), T3.6S7¢(a) (6), 73.687 (i) (1) and 73.699
Fig 5. Measurements indicated that KDSJ-TV was transmitting a double side-
band siznal with spurious signals above and below the visual carrier. for example:

‘

Ta ake 4 ak Sees

Visual minus 4.5 Me/s=—20 db: Visnal minus 3.58=—30 db: Visual minus 9.0
Me/s=—35 db: Aural plus 4.5 Me/s=—20 db (all as referred to visual carrier).
Numerous spurious products less than 40 dh suppressed were noted in the
region hetween minus 9 Me/s and plus 9 Mc/s of the visual carrier. &
12. Section 73.GS7(b) (7). Aural modulation was measured with peaks not D
Zreater than 50 percent for a continnous period of one half hour. (One third of a
thix modulation level could be attributed to ambient noise and hiss rather than :
prezram content). ;
12. Section 73.687 (ce) (4) and (d)(3a. Transmitter was being operated with t
portions of front panelling removed exposing high voltage power supply to touch &
by operating personnel. This was obviously done to provide additional cooling for 4
the transmitter as an external fan was placed before this opening and directed *
into the transmitter. E
14. Section 72.687 (e). Wiring and shielding not in accordance with accepted &
standards of good engineering practice. Ps

15. Section 73.689ib). Station records checked back through February and
no record of output power meter calibration found.

16. Section 73.691(a). The visual waveform monitor (Teathkit scope) was
net triggering properly and a suitable wave form presentation could net be ob-
tained for proper adjustment of video levels. Color receiver/monitor was not
operative.

17. Section 73.699 Fiz 6(5). Color burst amplitude measured approximatels
5 percent of srnc. Chrominance modulation on waveform practically non-existent.

18. Section 73.933(a). Emergeney Broadcast Receiver would not trigger alarm
device.

PERI I IR MLR Ee TY

a eeoroente

32 F.C.C. 2d

patpimt

CN PN eg TY aoe ay Y

Rh lalate ain aabiniztiht ss Tablas Ma MEN thon

|

sey ee. a

12a

2r2 Federal Communications Commission Reports
Specific violations cited in the other Notice of Violation read as
follows: -

1. Section 73.609(a) Operator Harold W. Codner (21-15-5733) bad not
log when atarting daty at 8:00 PM MDT. a

2. Scction 78.671(a) (3). Operator Harvld W. Codner had not made required

half hourly entrice from 3:00 PM until 4:30 PM (time of entry by inspector).

19. On November 8, 1967, 2 Warning was sent KDSJ-TYV in respect
to the violations cited in the second October 24, 1967 Notice of
Violations. ?

20. Separate + ~~ were made to the first and second Notices
of Violations by Eli Daniels on November 10, 1967. Response to the

first notice reads as follows:
Non Compliance with FCC Rules and Regulations:

Violation 1 Thru 18

1. Mr. Roy Hicks, Supervisor, has informed the operator of this violation
and was assured that effort will be made to prevent repetition.

2. Agreement has been made with a painter to paint the tower as soon as

3. Complete tower lighting, inspection and repaired us of 10-9-67. Manaze-
ment at KDSJ-TV was uot inforined that the lights were in-operative since
April 30, 1967.

4. Aural to Visual frequency separation has been adjusted by frequency

measurement.

5. Mr. Roy Hicks Maintenance Supervisor informs me that as of June of
this year the mainteranve log was kept in a note book which was kept in the
files at the transmitter station. ;

6. Supervisor has been informed and correct measures have been instituted.
7. The first log in qnestion was August 22°. 1967... . not Aucust 29. Th:

or had signed on duty then was informed by KRSD-TV in Rapid City,
Mm source, that transmission ‘vould be late in starting. The operator
remained on duty. When transmission resumed, logging was coninued.

The other log entries mentioned were for similar reasons and/or hitSD-TV
not on the air, or outage of microwave between KRSD and KDSJ. When trans-
mission was resumed, logging was resumed.

8 Monthly frequency measurements were made, however, logging w2s not
kept up. This situation will be corrected.

9. [Ilegible on record copr.]

10. Efforts are being made to correct this discrepancy.

11. Measurements were made on KDSJ-TV trausmitter on November §, 1967.

phs were taken of the tektronic trpe 524 AD scope. The attached
figures 1, 2 and 3 are the results of pictures taken. Figure 1 shows an overall
curve with 20 DB down at —1.25 MCS. Figure 2 shows response above the
— out to 10 MCS. Figure 3 shows the response below the carrier out to

Complete measurements were made to check the requirements of the sections
mentioned in violation 11, however in the developing process the negatives
were ruined. .

It is my contention that most of the spurious products adjacent to Channel 5
at Lead are caused by the two way installations at Terry Peak. Whenever we
have had too much lower side band, we have been informed of interferring with
the two way communications by the operators thereof. This bas happened in-
frequently ; perhaps about 2 or 3 times during the last four years. Furthermore,
the C.A.T.V. System at Lead is another source of spurious emissions which we
have noted as causing interference adjacent to Channel 5.

Further measurements and corrective adjustments and repairs will be made
within two weeks. The results will be recorded and forwarded for further reply

to this violation.
$2 F.C.C. 2d

:

Pc

13a

Heart of the Block Hills Stations, The, et al. 213

1Z. Supervisor, Mr. Hicks informs that the aural modulation indicator Masher
had been flusiring quite cften ax the operator turned level down to decrense
number of flashes per minute and apparently it was turned too low. Corrective
measures have been instituted.

13. The portions of the front paneling which were removed were ibe color
filter and its power supply fer maintenance. These units have been replaced.
The fan is to cvol the modulator power supply tubes mounted on the front panel
of the cabinets.

14. Wiring and shielding as far as I'm concerned are according to standards
and practices which I have observed ut other stations. If any wiring and shield-
ing was noted by the a asx not according to accepted standards of good
engineering practices then | think it’s proper to request a more detailed and
specific explanation on this matter so that | will be able to evaluate the situa-
tion better.

15. Out put power meter calibrations are usually perforined by maintenance
men from KRSD TV iu Rapid City. Notation in the stations maintenance log
were not always made due to the fact that notes weren't made available to
Roy Hicks, the Maintenance Supervisor, at Deadwood. Corrective meaxures
to avoid violations of this sort have been taken.

16. Measures have been taken to correct this discrepancy.

17. Color burst amplitudes will vary on the network signals. There are many
variables that causes loss of color burst. Generally the incoming micro ware
is fairly decent, however due to a large amount of interference, at Terry Peck,
in the reception of Channel 7 (the program source for KDSJ-TV) we have
had to install filters, above and below the Channel 7 band. Also the receiver
has to be tuned to eliminate two way hetrodrne. This all causes degradation
of the signal. This interference to the reception of Chaunel 7 at Terry Peak
wag noted in a letter dated March 2. 1966 to the kCC office in Denver, Colorado.
Tests were made to confirm some of these sources of interference.

1S. According to Roy Hicks, supervisor, the Emergency Broadcasting Receiver
is operating properly and was on the day of the inspection. The operator on
duty reported the alarm rang when KOTA. the monitored station, changed to
night time pattern on the day of the inspection. We found no fault with the
operation of the receiver.

Response to the second notice reads:

Violation of FCC Rules Section 73.669(a) and Section 73.671(a) (3).

Operator Harvld W. Codner has been informed of the violations by his super-
visor, Mr. Roy Hick ORD Lae NTI NEE ttm te IE tar
pol Uwe $3

SAIN ORDT A os: + =* :

a as ee

19a

Heart of the Black Hilla Stations, The, et al. 219

40. A memoranduf dated May 25, 1969, from Paul R. Bateman,
RCA Service Company, Chicago, Iiinoix, to KDSJ-LV and others
stated in pertinent part :

6-21: Traveled to Rapid Clits.

5-22: Picked up teat equipment, Borrowed a diode and a directional coupler,
Traveled to transmitter near Lead. A line section (154°) Was prepared and
fitted with the diode and the 3°’ directional coupler, Made ineasurements jn-
cluding spurious with both aural and visual operating into autenia, No spuriots
responses noted. A fuse blew once in aural transmitter, Some diiticulty experi-
enced In connecting aural transmitter to dummy load, Tried to check differen-
tial phase and gain, Very jittery display. Because of limited time, this meusure-
ment cancelled.

6-23: Departed station.

41. On July 30, 1969, KRSD-TV was again inspected by McKin-
ney. Following inspection an Ofticial Notice of Violation dated Au-
gust 15, 1969, was sent the station, Specific violations cited in the
notice read :

Non-compliance with F.C.C. Rules and Regulations as follows :

1. Section 73.682(a) (12). Trangnilssion Standards, The blanking level yA
be transmitte! at 75 plus/minus 2.5 percent of the peak carrier level; dxfring
the observed time the blunking level was ST percent which is above the specified
level.

@. Section 73.682(a) (13). Transmixsion Standurds. The reference shine level
of the luminance signal mensured 20 percent, which Is above the 12 ial plus/minus
2.5 percent of the penk carrier level.

8. Section 73.682(2) (17). Transmission Stanctards, The referdnce black level
shall be separated from the blanking level by the setup intervapof 7.5 plus/minus
2.5 percent; during the observed period the setup level w ag ‘measured as 3 per-
cent which is below the specified level.

4. Section 73. Figure 6 Color burst amplitude mensured 20¢¢ of sync in
leu of the specified HO% to 110¢% of syne.

6. 73.687(1) (1) and 74.608 Figure 5. Measurements: indicated spurious siguals
above the viaual carrier as follows: Aural plus 4.5/MHz= —30 db; Aural plus
9.0 MHz==—40 db.

All measurements were reepective to visual carrier.

6. Section 73.071(a) (1). Operating Log. On Jaily 27. 1969, operator Eli Daniels
failed to indicate the time power to the antenng stopped.

7. Section 73.6711a) (3). Operating Log. OA July 27. 1969, operator Eli Daniels
failed to make entries at half hour interv algAfter 7:30 PM.

8 Section 73.069(a). On July 27, 1069, operator Ell Daniels failed to sign the
“Operating Log" when going off duty. —°

9. Section 73.671(a) (5). On July 27,4969, operator Eli Daniels failed to make
an entry concerning daily observations of tower lights.

10. Sections 73.689(b) (1) (2) and 73.672(a) (7). The last power calibration
in the maintenance log indicated calibration at only the 100% level und failed
to show calibration over the range from 80% toa point over 100% of the author-
a — output.

2. On August 15, 1969, an Official Notice of Violation was sent
Nasniian covering inspection of KDSJ-TV. The date of the inspection
is not stated on the notice. However, as will be shown below the inspec-
tion was undoubtedly made by McKinney on July 29, 1969. The notice
reads as follows:

Non-compliance with F.C.C. Rules and Regulations as follows:

1. Section 73.687(b) (7). Modulation of the nurat transmitter was 50% on
peaks of frequent recurrence during the period 1:00-1:30 PM EST. July 29,
1969; during this period one-fourth of this modulation was in the form of noise
and distortion.

2. Section 73.699 Figure 6. Color burst amplitude measured 406% of sync in
lieu of between 90 to 110% of sync from 1:00-1:30 I’M EST, July 29, 1969.

2 F.C.C. 2

5

on

20a

220 Federal Communivations Commission Reports

3. Section T2.690(¢). The interval between successive measurements of the
visual carrier frequency and the difference between the visual carrer frequency
and aural frequency shall not exceed ene month. The last frequeacey measurement
Was May 16, 1:68), prior te July 28 Tt,

4. Section T3.G72Z(a) (2) cil). No entry was made in the Maintenance Log de-
acribing the methed used in determining the monthly frequency mensurement.

G& Section 72.601 (0). The visnal color moniter was tarned off at the time of
inspection or July 29, 1969, and operater, Mr. Rey Hicks, was unable to tune in
the coler procram

6. Section 72.689(b) (1). The Power Calibration of the Visas] Transmitter on
the dates of February 9, 1969, and May 18, 1969, indicated 5.0 KW which repre-
sented 1005 power, without the ealibration from 80% power, to a point over
100%. to the maximum of 110% power.

7. Sections 73.GS7(a)(2), 7T8.6sS7(2) (5), 73.68T(n) (6), TREST(ID (1) and
73.099 Figure 5. Measurements indicated spurious signals above and below the
visual carrier as follows: Visual minus 434 MHz=—15 db; Visual minus 9.0
MH2z=—2 db; Aural plus 4.5 Milz=—15 db.

All measurements were respective to visual carrier.

& Section 17.38ic)( Ome
yolt R.F. in: Vis. set to read one volt.

Vis. minus 4.5 mbs, reading was TD imv 5S db down
Vis. minus 2.0 mbs, reading was about 70 ab down
Aur. plus 4.5 mbhs. reading was 1 mv 60 db down
0.7 volts RLF. signal inte 1.3. meter at Visual carrier
Vis. minus 4.5 mbhs. reads 0.7 mv/m 60 db down
Aur. plus 4.5 mhs. reads 0.3 miv/im 77 db down

Note: Also with 0.7 volts R.F. into Side band analyzer per Fig. 1, no discernible
spurious signals visible on scope.

Deduction was/is that when spurious signals are noted on the field strength
meter and/or sweep/scope method. the R.F. signal feed is too hich and thereupon
the instruments create spurious sienals of their own. As we reduced the KF.
signal input, the spurious readings reduced to greater leveis below the referenced
signal.

CONCLUSION:

As stated above, it is believed ibet spurious signais have been climinated from
the KDSJ-TV transmitter. We believe that the readings we do get with the tic'c-
strength method (Fig. 2). which are below 60 db, are created in the instrument.
We have on order a new field strength meter so that we may make further checks
on this issue.

CONCLUSIONS

= (1) There can be no doubt that in both 1966 and 1967 KRSD-TV

and KDSJ-TV were in substantial violation of Commission rules. So
bad were the stations’ operations that. during that period, hundreds
of viewers complained to the Commission over the poor quality of the
service they were receiving from the station.

(2) At the hearing. the fact of the existence of the violations was
driven home hard to the licensee. Moreover, the areas of needed cor-
rection were clearly outlined. By the end of the Rapid City sessicn of
the hearing the licensees were in possession of chapter and verse us to

recisely where the teclinical weaknesses of their stations lay. Follow-
ing recess but before close of record, the licensees had ample time in
which to take comprehensive corrective action. However, an inspection
of the stations, carried ove after licen-ves had had plenty of time within
which to put their technicai house in order, found the stations still in
substantial violation of the Commission rules. Further, response to
these latter charges of violations. while they do reflect considerable in
the way of good faith effort to reform, follow an all too familiar pat-
tern of being Jong on explanation and short on firm assurance that the
problems which gave rise to the violations have been eliminated to the
extent that elimination is within licensees’ power. With such: a back-
ground, it is not easy to find justification for renewal of the stations’
licenses.

(3) The Examiner is by no means unaware of the ease with which
the public interest baby can be emptied out in a tears-of-syimpathy
bath. On the other hand he is convinced that the sweep of the public
interest standard is not so narrow as to preclude thought ful considera-
tion of extenuating circumstances that may accompany conduct that

32 F.C.C. 28

27a

Heart of the Biach WWiils Stations, The, et al. 2°7

otherwise would call for preeimptory termination of stewardship. Here
the licensees are sore beset. ‘They piencered their field. They work hard
for small remuneration. Their market is small. ‘Their competition is
great. Their purse is thin. They suffer manpower shortage, Seme of
their basic equipment is ineflicient. Their source of network signals is
fallible. The weather is tieir enemy. And, it shoukl be noted that
ealled to account they have not been cavalier but, rather, cooperative.
Moreover, their ctiorts at. reform have met with some suecess.

(41) The question of whether or not. to renew is a hard one, On the
one hand is the need to protect the public from incursions on its interest
by the Incompetent. pe inept. On the other hand, it is no easy matter
to take the bread and butter outof men’s mouths. Jn the ordering
clause below the Examiner has attempted to reconcile these conflicting
considerations.

Accordingly, IT IS ORDERED that, unless an appeal is taken from
this Initial Decision to the Commission by a party or the Commission
reviews the Decision on its own motion in accordance with the provi-
sions of Section 1.276 of the Rules, the applications for renewal of the
licenses covering KRSD-TY., Rapid City, South Dakota, and KDSJ-
TV, Lead, South Dakota. are GRANTED FOR A PERIOD OF ONE
YEAR. In making the foregoing recommendation it is contemplated
that prior to the next renewal application a further inspection of the
two stations will be made.

Fevers, Communications Commisston,
Tuomas H. Doxanve, Wearing Examiner.

2 In this connection the Commission may wish to review its decision in Star Stations of
Indiana, Inc., 19 F.C.c. 2d 991, 17 RR 2d 491 (1969).

32 F.C.C. 2d

a as

ig a all

we nteeeed

Ib
APPENDIX B
196 Federal Communications Commission Reports
F.C.C. 71-1102
BEFORE THE

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
Wasiurnaton, D.C. 20554

Tn the Matter of ‘
Ext ann Harry Danrers, v.p.a. Tue Heart or} Docket No. 18358
THE Buack iris Stations File No. BRC T-410

For Renewal of License of Station
KRSD-TYV, Rapid City. S. Dak.
Ext anp Harry Danxwris, »..a. ‘Tne Heart or| Docket. No. 18359
me Buack Hing Stanoxs File No. BRCT-a64
For Kenewal of License of Station
KDSJ-TYV, Lead, S. Dak.

APPEARANCES

Samuel Miller and Stephea A. Gold, on behalf of Eli end flarry
Daniels, d/b/as The ITeart. of The Black Hills Stations: and 22ichard
M. Riehl, on Behalf of the Chief, Broadcast Bureau, Federal Com
munications Commission.

DEcIsIon

(Adopted October 28, 1971; Released November 1, 1971)

Commissioner Bartiry For THE Commission : Comuussionens Rowrrt
KE. Ler anp Rew NOT PARTICIPATING.

1. This proceesling involves the applications for renewal of Heen.cs
of television Lroadeast stations KRSD-TYV, Rapid City and KDSJ-
TV. Lead. South Dakota, filed December 22. 1967. by Eli and Liarry
Daniels. db /as The Heart of The Black Hills Stations. Action on the
renewal applications was deferred on April 1, 1968. because of the

roblems and issues raised by Official Notices of Violation dated
September 27. 1966, and Octoher 24. 1967, concerning Station KNSD-
TY. and Official Notices of Violation dated September 27, 1966 (cor-
rected copy dated November 4, 1966) and October 24, 1967, concerning
Station KDSJ-TV.

2. By Memorandum Opinion and Order, FCC 68-1032, released
Ociober 21, 1968, we designated the above applications for hearing.
The following issues were specified :

(1) To determine the nature and extent of the violations of the
Commission Rules and Regulations by the licensees of Station KRSD-
TV, Rapid City. South Dakota, as disclosed by Official Notices of Vio-
lation issued against that station on September 27. 1966 and October 24,
1967, by the station’s responses thereto, and by related documents:

(2) To determine the nature and extent of the violations of Com-
mission Rules and Regulations by the licensces of Station KDS.J--TY.
Lead, South Dakota, as disclosed by Official Notices of Violation issued

82 F.CC. 2d

re
2b |

Heart of the islack Mills Stations, The, ct al. 197

against that. station on September 2... 1966 (corrected Nevember 4, |
1966) and October 24, 1967, by the station’s responses thereto and ivy

releated documents;

(3) To determine whether the licensees’ management and operation
of Stations KRSD-TV and KDSJ-TV was so negligent, careless. or
jnept. or evidenves such disregard for the Commission’s Rules and :
Regulations, that they cannot be relied upon to fulfill (he responsibili-
tics Imposed upon them; and . j

(4) To determine, in light of the evidence adduced under the fore-
going issues, whether the Jicensees of Stations KRSD-TV and KDs.1--
TV are qualified to received (sie) renewals of these licenses and :
whether renewal of these licenses would serve the public interest.

3. Subsequent to the Designation Order, but before the record was
closed, the stations were reinspected. Oficial Notices of Violation were
issued for KRSD-TV and WK DSJ-TV on August 15,1969. Jn an Tnitial
‘Decision, FCC TOD-28, released July 17, 1970, Wearing Examiner j
Thomas II. Donahue concluded that the public interest weighed in ;
favor of granting the licensee a short-term, one-year renewal even
though the stations were in substantial violation of the rules in 1966 :
and 1967 and that the licensee had failed “in impeaching, to any sub- ;
stantial degree, the validity of the violations charged” as a result of :
the inspections. (/nitial Decision at 28). The renewal recommenda-

tion was made in contemplation that the stations would be reinspected
before the next renewal period. exceptions to the Initial Decision and i
a brief in support thereof were filed by the Chief, Broadcast Kur cau 4

on August 17. 1970. ‘The Heart of the Black Hills Stations filed an
opposition to the Bureau's exceptions and supporting brief on Septem- ;
ber 2, 1970. On October 1, 1971, the Lroadcast Bureau filed a petition 4
to update the record to reflect the results of the laicsi inspections of the 1
stations: Official Notices of Violation issued against KRSD-TV on

June 22, 1971 and Official Notices of Violation against KDSJ-TV on ;
June 8 and 24, 1971. é

4. Oral argument was held before the Commission cn bane on 4
October 7, 1971. The findings and conclusions of the Examiner have 4
been considered in light of the exceptions, opposition and brief filed, j
and of the oral argument and the petition to update the record. We
hold that the applications for renewal of licenses must, in the circum- ;
stances, be denied. While we disagree with the xaminer’s ultimate a
conclusion that the applications should be granted for a one year term 4
we adopt his findings and conclusions, except as modified in this deci- 4

sion and in our rulings on the exceptions as set forth in the Appendix.

5. The licensee admits that it has “been guilty of occasional mis-
management and negligent operation of the stations,” ? but it contests
the Bureau’s position that denial of renewal is the proper penalty.
Instead, the licensee argues that there are extenuating circumstances
and that the short-term renewal recommended by the Examiner is
reasonable in light of the facts of this case.

1 The petition bas been consicered and will be grauted.
* Opposition to Broadcast Kureau's Exceptions and Brief in Suppirt of Exceptions, filed
September 2, 1970, by The Heart of the Black Hills Station at 3.

82 F.C.C. 2d

BEE Noli SSE. AA it RECN Ee en,

Mtn eed

kai Perc ibieth wn dade wel Cee

sia da eae A LE aS A i Doll Rie

Sr ee,

Pee a

=

EZ ove

Le WEY PES

3b

198 ‘ederal Communications Commission Reports

6. We disagree, While no one of the multitude of rule violations *
found to exist in this proceeding would ordinarily form a basis for
denial of renewal, the record here demonstrates that. The Heart of the
Black ILills Stations’ operation of stations KRSD-CV and KDSJ--TV
was conducted in an exceedingly careless, inept, and negligent. manner,
and that the licensee is either ineapable of correcting or unwilling to
correct the operating deficiencies shown by this uncontroverted record.
Tn this light, we are compelled to the conclusion that. renewal of these
licenses is not warranted. We take oflicial notice in this regard of the
material contained in the Broadcast: Buress’s petition to update the
record, filed October 1, 1971. to reflect. the results of the most recent
inspections of the stations and the violations found at those inspections.

7. The record in this proceeding and the Examiner's detailed find-
ings show that these stations have had a long 10-year history of re-
peated and serious violations of the Commission's Rules and Regula-
tions governing the technical requirements for operation of broadeast
stations. These violations included, but were not limited to. such basic
matiers as faulty tower lighting deficiencies, operation below author-
ized power, spurious emission, maintenance Jogs, and such serious
deficiencies in the quality of picture transmission that they were virtu-
ally unviewable. The tower lighting violations present an obviously po-

_tential air safety hazard, and the spurious emissions are ona frequency

close to that of an air trafic control frequency. With respeet to the
quality of the video signal being transmitted to the public. the record
establishes that, because of its serious technical and operating defi-
ciencies. the licensee has not twen providing the Rapid City and Lead
communities with a picture of usable quality since at least 165,
Tn this regard. we find it to be particularly relevant that we were
compelled in 1966 to grant an unusual waiver of ow CATV carriage
and non-duplication rules (Section 74.1103) to the Rapid City CATV
systein. because KRSD-TV was providing a sienal of such poor
quality that it was not usable by the cable svstom. Black Ii), Video
Torporation, 2 FCC 2d 243 and 465 (1966). Accordingly. we re-
lieved the cable system of the rules requirements “until such time
as it appears that KRSD is providing a signal of acceptable quali-
ty... .7 2 FCC 2d at 466. It is now more than five years later. and
the waiver is still in etlect.
§. Further evidence amassed in the record of the licensee's failure
to provide even a minimally adequate technical service to its public
is atforded by: a petition signed in 1967 by 2.000 viewers in Repid

* The Examiner found that one or both of the stations were guilty of. »mong others, the
following violations: (1) emission of spurions signals; (2) operation below authorized

wer; (3) reference white level and set-up not properly maintained; (+) improper color

rst amplitude: (5) susintandard wiring and shielding; (G6) antenna tower lichtiug
violations; and (7) loce not properly maintained or unavailable to Inspector at time of
inspection. Initial Decixion, FCC 7OD-28. released July 17, 1970 at 2S ane 44-45. Sev ale
Initial Deciaion at 4-11, 12--15, 19-21, 27-29 and 21-23. The licensee committed 36 In-
fractions of 33 separate rule violations during the 1968 and 1967 inspec:ions alone. ‘Lhe
net effect of these teclinical violations was to deprive the public of a viewable picture.

*KDSJ-TV, Lead. S.D. operates asa satellite of KRSD). Rapid City, being fed tie latter's
Programs via their licensed private inter-city mierownte link, Thus. the degraded quality
of the originating signal at Rapid City is likewise transmitted to KDSJ-TY at Len.

22 F.C.C. 2d

4b

Heart of the Black Hills Stations, The, ct al. 199

City concerning the poor picture quality of the stations whieh re-
qnested the Commission and NBC to attempt to improve the servige ;
the testimony to this efect at the hearing by several public witnesses :
and the fact that the Comniission’s inspector found the KRSD TY
Picture unsuitable for broadeast. as late as the July 1969 inspections.
The Examiner found. moreover, that the hearing had clearly out-
lined those areas where technical corrections were needed and that,
by the time of the July 1969 jnspections following the end of the
‘Rapid City phase of the hearing, ample time had clapsed to enable
the licensee to take comprehensive corrective steps. Yet (he 1969 in-
spection found KRSD-TV and KDSJI-TV s#/7 in substantial viola-
tion of the same rules that the 1966 and 1967 inspections found, all
of which resulted in a serious adverse impact on the quality of the
picture being broadeast to the public. Since the licensee's stations
were the NBC afliliates in the markets, it is clear that the commuani-
ties were being effectively deprived of that network's programs _Ubis.
fact, in conjunction with the continuing waiver, avprv, raises the
undamental issue of whether this licensee is technically qualified to
“Temain 2 licensee of these stations, We believe that it is not, anc we
‘are of the opinion that the Examiner failed to give suflicient weight
to this serious and adverse impact which the licensce’s violations had
on its cbligations to render a satisfactory service to the public.

9. One of the underlying purposes of the Communications Act
of 1934, as amended. is ta provide an efficient and adequate broaceast
service to the people of the United States. The Commissien is direeted
by the Act. smong other things. to “regulate the kind of apparatus
to be used with respect to its external effects and the purity and siarp-
ness of the emissions from each station and from the apparatus there-
in.” (Section 503(¢)). The Courts have long recognized that vie
Commission's regulations governing teelinieal operation of breadeast
stations “are vitally essential to the maintenance of adequate radio
Veeption and service.” and have upheld the Commission's refusal to
“renew the license ‘of a broadcast station which had repeavcdly violated
the Commission’s technical regulations. Greater. Noi peska Radio
Corp. ve. F.C.C.. 108 ¥. 205.7 (D.C. Cir. 1939).

10, The Commission is normally reluctant to deny renewal of a
broadcast license solely for violations of its technical rules. Yet ir
must. be recognized, as we have done in the past, in carrying out our
statutory responsibilities that: eee

[OJne of the most essential duties incumbent upon the licensee of a bread-
¢ast station is that of insuring the continuous operation of the transmitting
equipment. In fact, this is an indispensable condition to the gond service of any
station. Failures of this equipment, due ‘to causes reasonably within human
control, whereby the public is deprived of service, denotes a state of carelessness
and mismanagement which this Commission, in the’exercise of its regulatory

authority, will not condone. gd
Brooklyn Browtcasting Corporation. et al, 4 FCC 521 at 531. (1937).
See also Charles C. Carlson (WIBW) et al; 12 FCC 902 (Us),
aff'd 172 F. 2d 766 (1).C. Cir. 1949), Cert. denied 337 U.S. 950 (19).
~ Therefore, when we are presented with a record, as las been es-
tablished in this hearing, of at least 10 years of violations of sub-
nan jeqetetion of Rapid City 1s 43,836. Lead has a pepelation of 5.420 (1970 Census).
net weekly circulation is 23,000 (Source: ARB Television Market Summary,

KR
Feb-March 1971). It can thus be seen that the 2,000 signatures on this petition represent a
significant portion of KRSD's audience. ° ” 4

82 F.C.C. 2d

DS igh 9p OB ATP AR i RE NA

ei

Sb

200 Federal Communications Commission Reporis

stantially the same rule requirements for satisfactory operation,
which violations have had the cumulative offect of depriving the
public of the very service for which the licenses were originally
granted, then we are virtually compelled to the conclusion that re-
newal is neither justified nor warranted, in the public interest. Wo
must, in the present circumstances, agree with the position taken
by the Broadcast Bureau that:

The vumber, vature and extent of the violations reficcted iu the record of
this proceeding represent pcrhajs the most flagrant dereliction of a licensee's
responsibility in the operation of its tclevision stations that bas yet tv come
before the Commission. ‘

(Broadcast Bureau's Exception No. 5 at 13).

11. We, therefore, conclude that the licensee cannot be relied upon
to operate these stations in the future in accordance with the require-
ments of its licenses and the Commission’s Rules; that it is either
technically incapable or unwilling to correct operating deficiencies
when brought to its attention; and that it is, therefore, not qualified
to remain a licensee of hese stations.®

12. Accordingly, IT 1S ORDERED, that the F soy to update the
record, filed October 1, 1971, by the Chief, Broadcast Bureau IS
GRANTED.

18. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, That the above-captioned
applications of The Heart of the Black Hills Stations for renewal of
licenses of television broadcast stations KRSD-TV, Rapid City, and
KDSJ-TV, Tead, South Dakota, ARE DENIED.

14. IT IS FURTILER ORDERED, Thai in order to enable Tie
Heat of the Black Hills Staiions to wind up its affairs IT IS
AUTHORIZED to operate stations KRSD-TV ani KDSJ-TV until
12:01 a.m., December 31, 1971; PROVIDED, however, thai ii The
Heart of the Black Hills Stations seeks rehearing and/or judicial
review of our Decision. it is authorized to continue to operate stations
KRSD-TV and KDSJ-TV until thirty (30) days after the final dis-
position of such appeal.

Feperat Communications Commission,
Ben F. Wapte, Secretary.

pr tl ah nn ane We iin MO Ie eS A Penh re Nee 5d T

APPENDIX
Rulings on Exceptions of the Chief, Broadcast Bureau to the Initial Decisions.
Zeception No. Rulinge

Granted for the reasons stated in paragraphs 6-10 of our

Decision herein.
$9 GRE 4... ncccccaae — The requested rulings are not decisionally signifi-

can

5 Granted. The findings and conclusions of the Examiner

as supplemented herein require denial of the reuewal
applications in the public interest. See also paragraphs

6 and 10 of our Decision herein. :
© We note that the licensee has ed, in extenuation. that it has lacked a J
resources to remedy the deficiencies above described, including replacement of a KRSDeTV 4
transmitter. This contention may, in turn, raise questions as to the licensee's Gaancial é
qualifications to continue operation. However, resolution of that issue is not necessary to
our decision.
82 F.C.C. 2d

NE Is Pee ot Ae oe

ee eee rr ete ee eT |

Py she tA Baty ds be

en ee

Ic
APPENDIX C
Before the
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20554

In the Matter of ) FCC 72-665

: ) 79946
Eli and Harry Daniels, d/b/as )
THE HEART OF THE BLACK ) DOCKET NO. 18358
HILLS STATIONS ) File No. BRCT-410
For Renewal of License of )
Station KRSD-TV )
Rapid City, South Dakota .
Eli and Harry Daniels, d/b/as )
THE HEART OF THE BLACK ) DOCKET NO. 18359
HILLS STATIONS ) File No. BRCT-564
For Renewal of License of
Station KDSJ-TV )
Lead, South Dakota )

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

Adopted: July 26, 1972

Released: August 1, 1972

By the Commission: Chairman Burch absent; Commis-
sioners Reid and Wiley abstaining
from voting; Commissioner Hooks
not participating.

1. The Commission has before it for consideration: (a)

a petition for reconsideration of our Decision, FCC
71-1102, 32 FCC 2d 196, released November 1, 1971,

denying the above-captioned applications, filed December .
1, 1971, by Eli and Harry Daniels, d/b/as The Heart of

The Black Hills Stations (Black Hills); (b) a petition to

erates Dientncnmnasta teeta

reopen and update the record, filed December 1, 1971 by
Black Hills; (c) a supplement to petition to reopen and
update the record filed December 2, 1971 by Black Hills;
(d) an opposition to the petitions for reconsideration and
to reopen and update the record, filed December 13,
1971 by Chief, Broadcast Bureau; and (e) a reply to the
Broadcast Bureau’s opposition, filed January 6, 1972.

2. The history of this proceeding has been adequately
detailed in our order designating these applications for
hearing, FCC 68-1032, released October 21, 1968, and in
Hearing Examiner Donahue’s Initial Decision, FCC
70D-28, 32 FCC 2d 201, released July 17, 1970, granting
a one year renewal of the licenses of KRSD-TV, Rapid
City, and KDSJ-TV, Lead, South Dakota. By Decision,
FCC 71-1102, 32 FCC 2d 196, released November 1,
1971, we reversed the Initial Decision and denied renewal
of these licenses in light of the licensee’s long history of
technical rule violations which have had the cumulative
effect of depriving the public of the licensed service.
Black Hills has now filed petitions for reconsideration of
the Decision and to reopen and update the record, which
petitions are opposed by the Broadcast Bureau.

3. Black Hills’ petitions for reconsideration and to
reopen and update the record, urging reconsideration of
the Commission’s denial of renewal of the licenses of
KRSD-TV and KDSJ-TV, rely principally on the
following contentions:' (1) the Commission relied upon
a mistake of fact concerning continuation of the waiver
of the CATV rules? in denying the renewal applications;

1 Arguments made in the petitions which were previously raised
by Black Hills and disposed of by the Commission, will not be
dealt with herein.

? Black Hills Video Corporation, 2 FCC 2d 243 and 465 (1966).

In 1966, we granted a waiver of our CATV carriage and
non-duplication rules to the Rapid City CATV system because

EE

» Aaah eae the. ASC dp E se: On

3c

(2) the stations’ picture quality has improved; (3) many
of the causes of the rule violations were beyond human
control; (4) its explanations of the rule violations were
disregarded by the Commission; and (5) it lacks sufficient
funds to replace inefficient equipment. The opposition
filed by the Broadcast Bureau contradicts these
arguments and strongly urges denial of both petitions. In
the interest of a more comprehensive understanding of
the points raised by these pleadings, we will deal with the
various contentions. made by the licensee, and the
Bureau’s oppositions thereto, according to the subject
matter involved.

Withdrawal of CATV Waiver Request

4. Black Hills claims that the Commission was in error
when it stated in the Decision denying renewal of KRSD
and KDSJ, that the CATV system’s requested waiver of
the carriage and non-duplication rules, Section 74.1103
of the Rules, was still in effect.? Black Hills argues,
however, that the cable system withdrew its waiver
request by letter dated July 5, 1968, as part of an
agreement between KRSD and Multi-Pix of South
Dakota, the then owner of the cable system,‘ and it

KRSD-TV was providing a signal of such poor quality that it was
not usable by the cable system. Black Hills Video Corporation, 2
FCC 2d 243 and 465 (1966). In our Decision denying Black Hills’
renewal applications, we stated that this waiver was still in effect.

332 FCC 2d 196, at 198.

“The agreement was not implemented until August 25, 1969.
This delay in implementation resulted from a provision in the
agreement requiring that KRSD receive its network signal from a
common carrier, Mountain Microwave Corporation, whose
construction permit-renewal applications were not granted by the
Commission until August 13, 1969. Mountain Microwave
Corporation, 18 FCC 2d 1016 (1969).

attaches copies of the letter and agreement to its
petitions as “Exhibits 1 and 2.”* It therefore contends
that KRSD’s signal has been of “usable quality since late
1968.” (Black Hills’ Petition for Reconsideration at p. 3).

5. The Broadcast Bureau finds meaningless the
licensee’s reliance upon the CATV operator’s request for
withdrawal of the waiver of the carriage and non-
duplication rules. First, the condition precedent which
the Commission placed on lifting the waiver, i.e.,
KRSD-TV’s providing a picture of “acceptable quality” ,®
has not been met. Additionally, the CATV operator’s
July 5, 1968 letter? to the Commission asking
withdrawal did not affirmatively advise the Commission
that KRSD was providing a picture of acceptable quality.
The withdrawal was based solely upon an agreement
between Black Hills and the CATV operator.*® Secondly,
the Bureau argues that the above agreement dispels any
inference that by 1968, Black Hills was providing a
viewable picture because, by its terms, the agreement
permits the cable operator to duplicate all KRSD-TV
network programming except for the distant station’s
local commercials and station identifications,? thereby

Sit should be noted that the aforementioned letter and
agreement, attached to Black Hills’ Petition as “Exhibits”, are not
part of the record of the hearing to date, and have not heretofore
been offered or relied upon by the licensee.

© Black Hills Video Corp., 2 FCC 2d 465 at 466, adopted
February 2, 1966.

7 Black Hills’ Petition for Reconsideration, Exhibit 1.
® Jd., Exhibit 2.
9 Jd. Exhibit 2 at p. 2 paragraph 4, which provides as follows:

“4. KRSD-TV agrees to permit CABLE [Multi-Pix] to
receive all of its programs and to receive all duplicating
programs as provided by . . . (?) (sic) [copy not legible] from

5c

insuring an alternative and dependable programming
service.

6. In repiy, Black Hills dismisses the Bureau’s opposi-
tion, arguing that, because the waiver was granted only
on the basis of pleadings, the Commission never made its
own determination of KRSD’s picture quality.’° More-
over, it claims that, in 1966, KRSD requested non-
duplication protection because of improved picture
quality prior to the request for withdrawal of the
waiver.'? However, this request was not acted upon by
the Commission.

Picture Quality

7. Black Hills argues that the record does not support
the conclusion that it has not provided a picture of usable

more distant TV broadcast stations during the term of this
Agreement, and KRSD-TV hereby waives any rights with
which it might be conferred under FCC rules to demand
deletion of programming by CABLE.”

This argument may not be in keeping with the facts. The
Commission’s files indicate that the 1966 waiver was granted not
only upon the basis of the CATV system’s pleading (to which
KRSD never responded), but also on the basis of information
available to it, disclosing that the KRSD signal “was of such poor
quality that it was not usable by the cable system.” (See
Commission Memoranda Opinions and Orders, of January 5 and
February 2, 1966, 2 FCC 2d, 243, 244, and 465, 466,
respectively.)

"The licensee’s Reply to Broadcast Bureau’s Opposition also
has attached to it what is termed “Exhibit 1”, which consists
apparently of copies of letters from its counsel and Black Hills to
the Commission, dated September 6 and 7, 1966, respectively,
requesting reimposition of the non-duplication condition by the
CATV system. Here, again, as in the situation noted in footnote 5
supra, there is no indication that these letters were offered
heretofore by the licensee for the record of the hearing herein.

i

quality since 1965. In support of its argument (in
addition to the CATV waiver argument, supra), Black
Hills claims that, while a majority of the six public
witnesses who: testified at the hearing as to picture
quality said that the picture had been unsatisfactory prior
to the fall of 1968, there had been a marked improve-
ment subsequently. Black Hills also challenges the
importance and validity of the 1967 petition signed by
2,000 viewers protesting the picture quality of the
stations, which the Commission stressed in its Decision.
In contrast, the licensee points to its Petition to Reopen
and Update the Record, which includes a compilation of
copies of viewers’ letters solicited over KRSD-TV and
KDSJ-TV,'* which Black Hills claims attest to the
viewability of the stations’ signals. In addition, petitioner
states that it has a thousand more letters in its files
which, it contends, are evidence of its service to the
public. Black Hills notes that B.H. Dail, who circulated
the 1967 petition, sent KRSD a letter attesting to the
improved quality of the service from KRSD and KDSJ.
Moreover, it is argued, the FCC Inspector’s July 1969
finding that the picture was unsuitable for broadcast
should be limited to the short period of time when he
was in Rapid City.

8. The Bureau rejects Black Hills’ principal claim of
factual error (ie., the Decision’s finding that the stations
had failed to provide a viewable picture since 1965), and
quotes the licensee as saying that “the only time I failed
to provide the public with a viewable picture, was during
the three year period prior to the designation” order in

2The Petition to Reopen and Update the Record contains the
above letters from viewers, as well as an affidavit from Eli Daniels
explaining the reasons for the various rule violations.

Tc

1963. (Broadcast Bureau’s Opposition at p. 6).'* This
amounts to an argument by Black Hills, the Bureau
asse‘ts, that it only failed to provide a “viewable”’ picture
for 3 years. No decisional significance is found by the
Bureau in the asserted error because, they state, it is
irrelevant whether the licensee failed to provide a
viewable picture for 3 years instead of 5 years; what is
relevant is the failure for an extended period of time.

9. The Bureau points out that the licensee’s claim of
factual error is premised upon three contentions, each of
which the Bureau rejects, to wit: (1) the 1968 withdrawal
of the request for waiver of carriage and non-duplication
rules; (2) the contention that the record establishes that
the public was provided with a viewable picture from late
1968 through the hearing in March 1969; and (3) the
clain that the results of the 1969 inspection (i.e., that
KRSD was transmitting a picture unsuitable for broad-
cast) must be limited to the period when the FCC
inspector was actually in Rapid City.

1¢. The Bureau’s response to the first argument
(withdrawal of waiver request) has already been sum-
marized in para. 5, supra. As to the second argument
regaxding picture quality, the Bureau concedes that the

1%Jack Hills charges that the Bureau distorted the record and
the liensee’s contentions in “manufacturing” the quotation to the
effect that only during the three year period prior to designation
did i fail to provide a viewable picture (Reply to Broadcast
Bureat’s Opposition to Petitions for Reconsideration and to
Reopen and Update the Record at p. 2 quoting from the Broadcast
Burea’s Opposition at p. 6). Black Hills denied making such a
statenent or that such a statement could be inferred from the
recoré. It claims that the Bureau devised the word “unviewable”,
which never was used by the licensee. While Black Hills admits that
some public witnesses characterized its picture as “unsatisfactory”
or “unreliable”, it argues that such terms are not equivalent to
“unviwable”.

licensee provided to the public with a viewable picture
from late 1968 through March 1969;!* however, it does
not regard this as proof that such improved service has
continued, which it asserts is the real factor of decisional
significance. What the Bureau claims to be really signifi- .
cant is the fact that, despite the Examiner’s statement
during the hearing on April 17, 1969, that he “was
disposed to deal lightly with the licensee” if the
remaining problems were cleaned up within 90 days, the
service again reverted to its previous “unsuitable for
broadcast” level within that same 90 days after the staff
concluded the hearings in Rapid City in mid-March 1969.
The latter situation was established by the results of the
July 30, 1969, inspection. From this, the Bureau con-
cludes that apparently only the physical presence of the
Commission’s staff in Rapid City can insure that the
licensee will operate its stations satisfactorily and in
compliance with Commission Rules. As to the third
argument, the Bureau states that Black Hills misconstrues
its burden when it claims that the proof regarding picture
quality must be limited to that period in 1969 during
which the FCC inspector was in Rapid City. It points out
that the same lack of video components, which the
licensee admits made its picture unsuitable for broadcast,
was present during the inspections of 1961, 1966, 1967,
1969 and 1971; that the only proof offered by the
licensee that these deficiencies were due to causes other
than broadcast equipment were statements on those
occasions by the licensee’s principal to that effect; and
that the record establishes that such excuses had no basis
in fact. The Bureau therefore submits that Black Hills has

141t should be noted that this period coincides with and spans
the months from the designation for hearing (October 21, 1968)
through the Rapid City phase of the hearing (March 10-13, 1969).

9c

failed to show a basis in this regard for reversal of the
Commission’s Decision.

11. Turning to the viewers’ letters submitted by Black
Hills in support of its claims regarding picture quality, the
Bureau argues that they should be accorded little, if any,
weight in part because of the almost “deceptive’!’
broadcast announcements in the solicitation of the letters
by the licensee over KRSD and KDSJ. These broadcast
statements implied that the denial of the renewal
applications would permanently deprive viewers of CBS
programming and a second program source, whatever its
quality. The solicitation is characterized by the Bureau as
“deceptive” because it failed to state that the Commis-
sion has consistently taken all possible steps in other
similar cases to insure uninterrupted or promptly re-
established service. According to the Bureau, fear of a
lost program source was the primary motivation behind
F the letters and, therefore, greater weight should be
q

me Pee

accorded the reason the letters were written, rather than
the reasons advanced in the letters for renewal of these

; licenses. The Bureau contends further that even if the
3 letters were to be considered as indicating improved
; service since 1969, they could not affect this Decision
; because here the central question is whether this licensee

can be “relied upon to maintain this service in the
future.”” (Bureau’s Opposition at p. 17). The Bureau
answers this question in the negative and points out that
4 many of the letters confirm unsatisfactory service prior
$ to the designation order.

1S Broadcast Bureau's Opposition at p. 17.

10c

Rule Violations Caused by Factors
Beyond Human Control

12. Black Hills argues that the Commission’s reliance
on Brooklyn Broadcasting Corporation, 4 FCC 521
(1937), as authority for denying renewal, is misplaced.
That case, Black Hills argues, involved equipment failures
“due to causes reasonably within human control, where-
by the public is deprived of service, ...” and is net
applicable to the instant case, because here “in many
instances the violations were due to causes not within
human control.” (Black Hills Petition for Reconsidera-
tion at p. 4). In support of this argument, Black Hills
asserts: (1) that the 1967 tornado all but demolished its
antenna tower, (2) that “network service has been
poor”,’® (3) that KRSD’s Dumont transmitter, “though
type-approved at the time, is not much good” (/d.), (4)
that the picture at -the last inspection was impaired
because of water that entered the transmission line
through a crack, and (5) that VHF TV signals are subject
to fading during the summer months and that Black Hills
has had most trouble with its signal from the common
carrier from June through August, during which time the
stations were inspected.'’

13. The Bureau’s opposition takes issue with Black
Hills’ treatment of the technical violations attributed to

16In his affidavit, attached to Black Hills’ Petition to Reopen
and Update the Record, Eli Daniels states that he anticipated, at
the time of the hearing, receiving “a superior picture once service
from the common carrier,” Mountain Microwave, commenced.
However, he states that Black Hills has had picture problems with
this service. (Affidavit at p. 2).

171t should be noted, contrariwise, that the stations were in fact
inspected in September 1966, October 1967, July 1969 and May
1971. ;

Lathe Relieabhs seater’

ae Pt

ME Ok dae a BAS ES.

llc

its two television stations and its attempt to distinguish
Brooklyn Broadcasting Corporation, supra, from the
instant case. The Bureau argues that even if some of the
violations were the result of causes beyond human
control, Black Hills has failed to rebut its “long history of
failing to promptly re-establish the service when problems
did occur.” (Bureau’s Opposition at p. 10). In particular,
the Bureau notes that, for 8 years, the licensee failed to
correct transmission line support defects which permitted
the line to sway. Yet during this period, the Bureau
states, the licensee was not able to achieve and to
maintain authorized power because it claimed that wind
damage to the transmission line made it impossible to
achieve full power. Likewise, the Bureau’s opposition
points to a number of instances in the record, going back
several years, where known deficiencies were called to the
licensee’s attention and the latest inspections showed
they had not been corrected, despite the licensee’s
promises to do so. Referring to the 1967 tornado which
severely damaged KRSD’s antenna and tower causing a
multi-image picture, the Bureau notes that, in spite of
this serious damage, Black Hills did not file an application
for a new antenna to replace the damaged one until 7
months had passed. With this background, the Bureau
submits that the consequences of the wind damage were
not beyond human control. In response to the contention
that VHF signals are subject to summertime fading from
June through August, the Bureau notes that only one of
the last four inspections occurred in these months!® and,
therefore, it rejects this explanation of Black Hills’
deficient picture quality as found during the inspections.
In reply, Biack Hills seeks to clarify the VHF summer-
time fading argument by explaining that “summer”’, for

18].

|

Ban ahs Bares Nik

12c

the purposes of VHF-TV signal fading, includes the
months of May through September. Thus, the licensee
concludes that three of the four inspections were
conducted during “summer” months and that this, in
part, accounts .for its less than satisfactory picture
quality. The seven months’ delay in filing the antenna
application is defended by the licensee on two grounds:
first, that antenna problems are not quickly diagnosable,
especially absent a standby antenna; and, second, that
preparation of an antenna application is both compli-
cated and time consuming.

Lack of Funds

14. Black Hills refers to its application for a new
antenna system, filed in January 1968, to replace the one
damaged by the 1967 tornado.’® It argues that without a
grant of the new antenna system, it has been unable to
expand its net weekly circulation by increasing its “‘set
count’, and that, had it been permitted to do so, CBS
would have increased its “network rate” from $100 to
$250 “‘with this increase (sic) set count” (Affidavit of Eli
Daniels, at p. 2, contained in Black Hills’ Petition to
Reopen and Update Record). Because this anticipated
increase in revenues has not occurred, KRSD claims that
it has been unable to replace its inefficient Dumont
transmitter and make the promised improvements in
facilities.

19Black Hills also referred to the antenna application at the
October 7, 1971, oral argument in this proceeding. (Tr. pp.
669-74). The application has not been granted in accordance with
the Commission’s policy of not acting on major facility changes
during a renewal hearing. The licensee is currently operating with a
new antenna under special temporary authority.

eee, a

nn oe |

13c

15. The Bureau rejects Black Hills’ argument that
Commission failure to grant its new antenna application
was the reason for its failure to make the improvements
promised in 1969, and it disputes the validity of the
figures used by Black Hills regarding circulation and “‘set
count”. Finally, the Bureau concludes that this is the
“first time” that the licensee has raised this lack of funds
issue, as well as the contention that the promised
improvements were conditioned upon a_ substantial
increase in revenues. The Bureau asserts that Commission
precedent precludes Black Hills from relying on these
facts not previously revealed.”°

Black Hills’ Complaint Regarding the Nature
of the Commission’s Decision

16. Black Hills argues that the Commission “relied
heavily on the Broadcast Bureau in drafting its decision”
denying renewal, and that, therefore, the “decision has
completely disregarded the licensee’s explanations and
has weighed the evidence unjustifiably against it.” (Black
Hills Petition for Reconsideration at pp. 1-2).

17. The Bureau rejects Black Hills’ allegations as
unsupported by fact, and labels the argument an “‘irre-
sponsible” charge that is possibly “unconscionable’’.
(Broadcast Bureau’s Opposition pp. 2-3, citing as
authority Oral Argument in Vinita Broadcasting Com-
pany, Inc., Docket No. 18085, Tr. 685-86). Also rejected
is Black Hills’ cor’ention that its own explanations were
“completely disregarded”’ by the Commission in drafting
the Decision. The Bureau notes that the Commission did
consider these explanations in paragraphs 5 and 6 of the

Citing Central Coast Television, 3 FCC 2d 524 (1966). See

footnote 23, infra, for pertinent language of the Commission’s
holding.

a ee

14c

Decision, but found that they were insufficient to
warrant renewal of the licenses, and often short on
factual support. Moreover, the Bureau views the central
issue of this case to be “whether, based on the licensee’s
past record of performance, the Commission can rely on
the applicant in the future to operate its stations in
compliance with the Rules and provide the public with
the technical service its license requires.” (Bureau’s
Opposition at p. 5). Black Hills’ petition and claims of
error are characterized by the Bureau as picking at bits
and pieces of the Decision, none of which would affect
the Decision’s ultimate conclusion denying renewal.

18. Black Hills responds to the Bureau’s allegation of
improper advocacy, noting that it never stated that the
Commission improperly relied upon the Bureau in render-
ing the Decision. However, it contends that it is clear that
the Commission “utilized the Broadcast Bureau’s
language”, because the Decision contains many lengthy
quotes and paraphrases from Bureau pleadings, some of
which incorporated incorrect facts which were, in turn,
adopted by the Commission.

Discussion

19. It does not appear that any lengthy analysis is
required in the circumstances of this case. In our opinion,
the brief and inadequate petition for reconsideration filed
by the licensee has been wholly rebutted by the
Broadcast Bureau’s Opposition, and it is manifest that
Black Hills has not made out a case for reversal of the
Commission’s Decision denying renewal. Moreover, it
would appear that both the petition for reconsideration
and the “Petition to Reopen and Update Record” are
procedurally defective, since they do not comply with

ay eh aT Ro et

15c

the requirements of Section 1.106 of the Regulations.?!
Each of these pleadings relies on so-called “Exhibits”
(attached to the Petition) which were not heretofore
offered as part of the record herein, although they were
in the licensee’s possession and knowledge, and each
contains materials which the licensee has failed to show
involves new and changed circumstances, previously
unknown to him and which could not have been
ascertained through the exercise of ordinary diligence.
See Central Coast Television, 3 FCC 2d 524, 525 (1966).
In any event, and despite the procedural deficiencies, an
analysis of the content of the arguments and assertions
made by the licensee will, as shown below, demonstrate
that they are without merit and do not warrant a
reconsideration and reversal of the Commission’s action
herein.

20. It must be emphasized that the Commission’s
approach in considering an application for renewal of
license, though judged on the past conduct of the

"Section 1.106(c) of the Rules governing Petitions for
Reconsideration of final action provides as follows:

(c) A petition for reconsideration which relies on facts
which have not previously been presented to the Commission
or to the designated authority, as the case may be,-will be
granted only under the following circumstances.
(1) The facts relied on relate to events which have
occurred or circumstances which have changed since the
last opportunity to present such matters;
(2) The facts relied on were unknown to petitioner until
after his last opportunity to present such matters, and he
could not through the exercise of ordinary diligence have
learned of the facts in question prior to such opportunity;
or
(3) The Commission or the designated authority deter-
mines that consideration of the facts relied on is required
in the public interest.

See footnotes 5 and 11, supra.

16c

licensee, nevertheless requires an affirmative finding that
the licensee’s operation of the station in the future will
serve the public interest, convenience and necessity. In
this regard, we agree with the Bureau that, even when all
of the licensee’s “excuses” for his past delinquencies are
taken into account, the central issue .for determination
remains—ie. can the Commission rely on Black Hills to
operate its television station in the future in accordance
with the rules and to render a satisfactory service to the
community? In our view, the record in this proceeding
speaks overwhelmingly against any such assurance on any
reasonable grounds, even when the licensee is given every
benefit of doubt with respect to those instances which
indicate that the public in Rapid City has been deprived
of a viable second service in the community. As far as the
record of the proceeding is concerned, there is no factual
basis for Black Hills’.assertion that it is now rendering a
viable service and that it is able and qualified to do so in
the future.

21. Turning to the basic points argued by the licensee
in his petitions, it appears that two main arguments are
being made:

(1) The Commission was mistaken in fact when it
rested its Decision on the basis that KRSD was not
affording the public with a usable signal and thus
was depriving the community of the licensed service;
and (2) the technical violations attributed to the
licensee which degraded its service were not due to
the licensee’s faults.

However, as an initial complaint, the licensee claims that
the Commission disregarded its explanations of the rule
violations and relied too “heavily on the Broadcast
Bureau in drafting its decision”. There is no foundation
fer such a claim; the Decision did, in fact consider these

‘inate came ciety

17c

explanations and alleged “extenuating circumstances”,
but concluded properly that they did not justify the
conduct found to exist, and were insufficient to rebut the
conclusion that the licensee’s “operation of stations
KRSD-TV and KDSJ-TV was conducted in an exceed-
ingly careless, inept, and negligent manner, and that the
licensee is either incapable of correcting or unwilling to
correct the operating deficiencies shown by this uncon-
troverted record” (32 FCC 2d at p. 198). Neither the
petition for reconsideration nor the petition to reopen
and update the record offer new material which would
require changing this conclusion.

Picture Quality and Withdrawal of
CATV Waiver Request

22. As indicated above, Black Hills’ principal claim is
that the Decision contains the factual error that the
stations had not provided a picture of usable quality since
at least 1965. This claim is based upon three allegations:
(1) the 1968 request by the then owner of the CATV
system for withdrawal of the waiver of the carriage and
nonduplication rules (Section 74.1103); (2) a viewable
picture was provided from late 1968 through the hearings
in March 1969; and (3) the FCC inspector’s 1969 finding
that the picture transmitted was unsuitable for broadcast
must be limited to the time that the inspector actually
was in Rapid City.

23. Black Hills argues that it has provided a signal of
usable quality since late 1968 when it was granted
temporary authority to operate with a new antenna
system. This conclusion is buttressed, in Black Hills’ view,
by the fact that the request for waiver of the CATV rules
was withdrawn by the CATV operator by a letter to the

PE IT SARI We ERA LAD AMES ep EA OS

18c

Commission dated July 5, 1968.2? By way of back-
ground, the Commission granted a waiver of the carriage
and non-duplication rules in January 1966 because it
appeared that KRSD-TV’s signal was not usable by the
cable system (2 FCC 2d 243, 244 (1966)). The waiver
was premised upon a letter dated January 3, 1966, from
Black Hills Video Corporation, the then operator of the
CATV system, which alleged that it had attempted to
carry KRSD on December 31, 1965, but that the signal
was “of [a] totally unusable quality,” as well as upon
certain preliminary investigational reports by the Com-
mission’s field staff. The system had received numerous
subscriber complaints requesting either restoration of the
previously carried NBC Denver signal or cancellation of
their service (2 FCC 2d at p. 244). The Commission
granted immediate relief from the rules on January 5,
1966, but authorized Black Hills to answer the cable
system’s allegations. Black Hills, however, did not
respond to the allegations, and the Commission stayed
the carriage and non-duplication rules on February 2,
1966 (2 FCC 2d 465).

24. The Memorandum Opinion and Order staying the
rules, supra, contained the condition precedent that
“fujntil such time as it appears that KRSD-TV is
providing a signal of acceptable quality,” the order
staying the rules would remain in effect. We must reject
Black Hills’ contention that the 1968 private agreement
between it and the cable operator for carriage of KRSD’s
signal on the cable system constitutes proof of the
satisfactory quality of its signal. The cable operator’s
agreement to withdraw its waiver request (which, in

This is the letter referred to in footnote 5 and in paragraph
19, supra, as not being a part of the record and not being in
compliance with Section 1.106(c).

19c

itself, was not implemented until August 1969 (see
footnote 4, supra)), does not satisfy the above condition
precedent and does not undermine the validity of the
Commission’s reliance upon Black Hills Video Corpora-
tion, supra. That there are other reasons, aside from
improved signal quality, which may have motivated this
agreement may be inferred from a closer examination of
the text of the contract. The opening “whereas” clauses
(to which petitioner did not refer) indicate that one of
the reasons for the agreement was that “KRSD-TV
desires to utilize one (1) channel of common carrier
microwave service over the routes now used by Mountain
Microwave to serve CABLE at low rates made possible
by multi-channel services being rendered to CABLE.”
Thus, the withdrawal of the waiver based upon the
private agreement between the parties does not neces-
sarily establish, as Biack Hills submits, that it has
provided a picture of usable quality since 1968. We note
further that Paragraph 4 of the agreement (quoted in
footnote 9, supra) permits the CATV operator to
duplicate all of Black Hills’ network programming except
for the distant station’s local commercials and identifica-
tions. The effect of this paragraph was to insure the cable
system of a usable network signal from a distant station if
KRSD was not providing a usable picture.

25. Moreover, we are of the opinion that Black Hills’
failure to reply to the January 3, 1966, letter, supra,
permits a reasonable inference to be drawn that its
picture was unusable from 1965 on. ‘This view is
reinforced by Black Hills’ own petition for reconsidera-
tion which states that “KRSD’s signal has been of a
usable quality since late 1968 after the station received
temporary authority to operate with a new antenna
system” (Black Hills’ Petition for Reconsideration at p.

20c

3). This statement is tantamount to an admission that
KRSD was not providing a usable picture from at least
1965 through “late 1968.” If Black Hills did in fact
provide improved service from late 1968 through the
hearing in March 1969, this does not necessarily establish
that improved service has continued since that time or
that it will continue in the future. Indeed, we believe that
the record shows that the picture quality declined after
March 1969. After the close of the hearing, when Black
Hills had knowledge of the deficiencies and time to
correct them, and was urged by the Examiner to do so, a
July 1969 inspection established that KRSD and KDSJ
were “still in substantial violation of the same rules that
the 1966 and 1967 inspections found ... .” (32 FCC 2d
at p. 199). It must therefore be concluded that Black
Hills has failed to make an adequate showing, by these
arguments regarding the purported withdrawal of the
waiver request, that the Commission was in error regard-
ing its conclusion on Black Hills’ quality of service.

26. The remaining portion of the licensee’s argument
regarding quality of service is founded on its Petition to
Reopen and Update the Record, by including therein
over one hundred letters and multi-signature petitions
(copies attached to its Petition) which it solicited by
broadcast announcements to viewers in its area, in an
effort to have the Commission reconsider the denials of
renewals. KRSD claims that these solicited letters, “‘plus
over one thousand more on file at KRSD-TV are evidence
that the stations are providing service to the public, and
that any finding to the contrary is without basis in fact.”
As has been indicated above, as far as the record in the
proceeding compiled thus far is concerned, there is no
credible evidence that the licensee has been affording the
public in Rapid City with a usable signal of required

Parr
ITM Oe TSW,

{A aD id ea uhtel ud Zapata i adi@blgh

Mies

Te AONE WEG NS AEE

2Ic

quality. However, Black Hills now offers the letters and
petitions it has solicited as proof that it provides a
satisfactory signal to its viewers. In this connection, the
licensee was apparently aware of the threshold showing it
must make, in terms of Section 1.106, quoted above,
before the Commission will accept this “11th Hour
‘evidence’ ’’. It therefore alleges in its petition to reopen
that: ‘

Although most of the material being presented at
this time might have been offered earlier, there is
good cause for the Commission to accept the
petition and reopen the record at this time. In its
Decision, the Commission noted the uniqueness of
this case in that ordinarily, technical violations,
standing alone, would not form a basis for denial of
renewal of license. The Commission should have the
benefit of a recent sampling of opinion from the
areas most greatly affected, as well as clarification of
matters discussed in its Decision. The licensee never
attempted to solicit letters or petitions heretofore,
since at the hearing it was believed that the petitions
were brought into proper perspective by testimony
of public witnesses. Moreover, the Examiner, in his
Initial Decision, did not place much weight upon
these petitions. He noted in Paragraph 26 in his
Decision that Eli Daniels and Dail were involved in
litigation together, as well as other factors which
tended to diminish the weight attached to these
petitions. (Petition to Reopen, para. 4).

27. The foregoing hardly suffices to satisfy the con-
ditions precedent to a reopening of record, set forth in
Section 1.106 (see footnote 21, supra). Moreover, there
does not appear to be any valid basis for petitioner’s
apparent argument in this regard that these proffered
materials (including Eli Daniels’ affidavit) are necessary

act eat i eS

Se ad nk ee

22c

“to round out the record in this case which is presently
lacking in certain details and make it subject to con-
jecture and speculation” and that the materials will serve
“,.. as Clarification of matters discussed in its Decision.”
Presumably these “matters” are “the 1967 petition
signed by 2000 viewers concerning the quality of the
picture being offered by the licensee ...”” which... “led to
the finding that the licensee has not been providing Rapid
City and Lead with a picture of usable quality for a
number of years. .. .” (Petition p. 1, 2, 3). We must point
out, however, that the question of quality of service,
which was, in part, the basis of the Decision herein,
involved the same issues of which the licensee had notice
at the time of designation for hearing; and that he has not
made any showing, let alone a sufficient showing, as
required by the Rules, that he could not have produced
such evidence as the viewers’ petitions and letters at the
time of the hearing. Our rules and long held Commission
precedent do not permit the petitioner, at this late date,
to make a case which he had failed to make at the time of

the original hearing.?>

23See WWIZ, Inc., 4 FCC 2d 608 (1966), in which the
Commission stated:

The end of the judicial process cannot be regarded simply as
a signal to begin anew with pleas to the agency. Only a strong
and compelling case would warrant taking up the matter
again after the agency and judicial process has been
completed. No such showing has been made here.

Semble, La Fiesta Broadcasting, 2 FCC 2d 255 (1965), and cases
cited therein; and Central Coast Television (KCOY-TV), 3 FCC 2d
524 (1966), in which the Commission likewise held that:

Under Section 1.106(c) of the rules, a petitioner who
predicates a request for reconsideration of an order on facts
not previously submitted to the Commission must establish
either that such facts relate to new or changed circumstances
or that they were previously unknown to petitioner and

23c

28. Despite our conclusion to deny Black Hills’
Petition to Reopen and Update the Record, we have
nevertheless, in our discretion, examined the proffered
materials in the desire to afford the licensee every
consideration in the circumstances and to determine
whether public interest factors require that we take
account of the above-described letters and petitions.“
However, upon examination of the text of the letters, in
the light of the nature afid content of the broadcast
solicitations, it becomes crystal clear that the writers in
the area were primarily concerned about losing a second
source of programming, as well they might. We need not
question the “bona fide” of the letters and petitions” ;
taking them at their face value will indicate that the
letters themselves are proof not so much of the quality of
the signal (which petitioner asserts), as they are of the
demand of the viewers for continuance of the CBS
programming and the existence of two competitive
stations in the community for a choice of program-
ming.?® Since there never was any intention by the

could not have been ascertained through the exercise of

ordinary diligence.... Now that the Commission’s deter-

mination has been adverse to Kay, it proposes to try a

different approach and to rely on a new [engineering]
showing. . . . (3 FCC 2d 525).

% A similar procedure was followed in Central Coast Television,
supra.

51t might be noted that some of the letters (see e.g. exhibits
A 87, 108, 110, etc.) refer to, and are apparently in response to an
article published in the Rapid City Journal of November 2, 1971 (a
day after release of the Commission’s Decision). It would appear
from the contents of these letters that the newspaper article is a
report of Mr. Daniel’s views of the Commission’s Decision;
however, no copy of this article was submitted by the licensee in
the voluminous materials attached to the petition.

261t does not even seem necessary, in the circumstances, to
determine whether, in soliciting its viewers to write to the
Commission regarding the merits of its Decision, the licensee was in
violation of Section 1.1225(a) of the Rules regarding prohibited ex
parte presentations.

Seay eorwee wan edlinidi

iene 7
AE PNAS MO ba in

24c

Commission of deleting the allocation of Channel 7 from
Rapid City in this proceeding, and if it had bcen made
clear to the public that the real reason for the Commis-
sion’s denial of renewal was because of Black Hills’
neglect over the years of its obligation to the community,
we are convinced that the reaction by the citizens would
have been quite different.

29. In any event, these letters and petitions could only
be given very minimal weight, since they are not direcied
primarily to the crucial questions in this proceedirz,
namely, the quality of the licensee’s signal and the
assurance that he can be relied upon in the future to
observe his responsibilities as a licensee. Accordingly, we
hold that the proferred letters and petitions cannot
justify the grant of a renewal to a licensee who has failed
to uphold his obligation to operate in the public interest.

Technical Violations

30. As summarized above, the second of the licensee’s
main contentions is that the technical violations were not
attributable to the licensee’s fault. Black Hills recites
previously stated excuses for its inadequate technical
service and argues that the Com

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385607_0862%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
