# Appendix — Reynolds v. Texas Gulf Sulphur Co.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385606_0303%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1972
- **Citation:** 405 U.S. 918

## Text

ae ia tes J yee
r 4%
q aes “yy
sf ¥ a%

INDEX TO APPENDIX >

Opinion of the District Court { Decided January .
9.1970) . :

‘ene Action Opinion of the District Court —
(Entered January 13, 1970) . 3

Judgments of the District C ourt ( Entered Jamu: |
ary 13, 1970) ..

Opinior of the. Court of Appe dls (Decided April ~_
26, 1971) ran Sarna Meco cates ta *

fo ennaare

Jurisdiction ‘as to all parties exists (a). under 28 US...
Sec. 1331, the amount in controversy in each of the consoli-
dated eases being in excess of: $10 ,000.00, exclusive of i in-
terest and costs, and there being necessary diversity of eiti-

efused ..
to issue either a writ of prohibition or a writ of man amus,

_zenship between the parties in each-case,-and (b) by virtue ..

of the allegations in each case of. violations of provisions
of See. 10( oh) of the federal statute and S.E.C. Rale 10b- 5.

\e

ate va tne formes as ea iene ma
oe ee "Appendix ene ad ie District Court” erat:

: / Ctr * Facruay Backcrounp

‘Th, November, . 1963, Texas Gulf Sulphur Co. iene
sometimes ‘‘TGS’’) core drilled an anomaly® tiear Tim- »
‘mins, Ontario, Canada, which had been_ detected daring
the course of an aerial and ground geophysical survey pro-_
oer The-drilling of this hole* was completed November -
2, 1963, at a depth - 655 feet. Visual.examination of the’.
core. by the company’s chief’ geologist, Walter Holyk, indi-
cated an ‘av erage copper content of 1.15%; and an average |
zine content of 8,64% over a length of 599 feet. The core °
was split. longitudinally and: Sas half was sent to a Utah —
assay honse for chemical analysis. Che chemical assay ,
proved that the visual appraisal was uncommonly accurate.
It disclosed an av ‘erage mineral content of 1.18% copper,
8.2% zine, and 3.94 ounces of silver per ‘ton’ over a cance
of 602 feet.
: The visual appraisal of the core. prompted th company.
to take steps.to improve.its position without. waiting for |
the chemical assay. ‘The anomaly tested by this hole ' im-
* cluded lands to which the company did not at the time have
the mineral. rights, and TGS. concluded that ‘additional
tracts of adjoining land should be acquired.: Immediate ac-
‘tion was taken to maintain seerecy as to the results of the —
firsthole, . The president of the company issued ah order”
that no- one outside of the exploration group’ should be’ told
of the prospect, the drill camp was; moved to another site,
« |... all. signs ef drilling activity’ were removed and the drill »
‘site was camouflaged by standing cut ‘Saplings i in the snow.

. 5. An area where there are variations in electrical conductivity,
- from normal backgtound, of underlying rock formations.

6. - The’ initial*hole was on what was known as the Kidd-55 seg-
ment of land. It was designated K- 55- L. Subsequent’ holes were. >

designated K-55-2, K- 35- 3, te. 3 \- oe
; 7. The information was even. withheld ‘tdi other: officers, di”
; rectors and employees of TGS.. ‘Shs = “

. . .
: fe a .
/ ff rae
o , ‘ : °
: ‘
3
;

Sy ee
° ’

eet ad

Appendix. —Opinion - the District Court

A secinid heb was ‘intentionally drilled off, of the’ nada
to divert attention from Kidd- 55- 1, and the barren core was
. left lying- on the. ground near K-55- Z. oe
The importance of the, findings based- —if any thing—they hav¢ discovered in Northern Ontario.”’
The ‘ramors spread he United States and yi the
mornmg of Saturday, April 11, 1964, both the New York
Times and the New York Herald Tribune carried stories

‘ about the rumored discovery. The Times story referred to
an unverified rumor that. TGS “had made a sensational

copper strike’’ that had caused “fev erish activity in penny . -

speculatives on the Toronto market,”? and’ to a reported
_surge-of staking in various townslfips flanking Timmins,

and to hotels and motels bulging with prospectors and
would-be prospectors. The story in the Herald Tribune in’
part teported: _¢

The biggest ore strike : since ; gol was diotoverpd .
more than 60 years ago’in Canada has stampeded
speculators to the snowbound old mining city of Tim-
mins, Ontario, some 450 miles northwest of Toronto.

This time it’s copper * * *

The story of the strike goes uieitiie like this: |
Texas Gulf Sulphur bas been active in the Big Water |
‘area, accessible only by airplane, for several years. ~-

- The richness of the copper it discovered was so great

9a ven
Appendix +—Opinion of the District" Court

', that samples reportedly were flown out of the country
to be assayed. _ Jae AE Nis . ee
The huge lode is supposed to consist of a bed of
‘ copper‘sulfite (sie) 600 feet wide with a possible over-
- all copper return of 2.87 per cent through most of its
. width. This yield in itself, is considered rich in min-
‘ing cireles, + ; Re o% nie
’ .But the richest yield comes from the first 100 feet
of that 6004 got belt. It is supposed to be 5.6 per cent,
-a bovanza-if the story proves more than just a myth. |
But myth it may be * * * ; - .
The story of the strike reportedly leaked out when
it was-discovered that certain employees of Texas Gulf
Sulphur were buying into the company’s stock * * *
Press Release of April 12 ; ae

¢

With the appearance of the Times and Herald Tribune
stories TGS decided to issue a press release, The president’
of the company, Claude ( ). Stephens, difected the executive
vice president, Charles F. Fogarty, to prepare the release.
Afier consulting with public relations advisers, legal coun-
sel, ‘the vice president in charge of expldration, and others;
the following statement (quoted in pértinent part) ~was
given to newsmen and representatives of financial publica-

.

‘tions inthe late afternoon or early evening of April 12: .

_ “New York, April 12—The following statement
‘was made today by Dr. Charles F: Fogarty, Extcutive
Vice President of Texas Gulf Sulphur Company, in .
regard to the company’s-drilling operations ‘near Tim-
anins, Ontario, Canada. Dr. Fogarty said 3

' “*During.the past few days, the exploration activ- “.’
ities of Téxas Gulf Sulphur in the area of Timmins,
Ontario, have been widely reported in the press,
coupled with rumors of a. substantial copper discovery

ee

_ there._ These reports: exhggerate the scale of the oper-

marginal sulphide ore bodies.

acs, ee :

“s — ee “of the Dist riet Caurt

sitions, ind .mention plans and. Statistics of size and
grade of ore that are without factyal basix and have

evidently originated by specul: ition of pr “ople not con-

nected with TGS. :

‘**The facts are as follows. TGS has heen eXx-

ploring i in the Tinuwins area for six years as part of
everall search 4 Canada and cl. :

***Most of. the areas ‘drilled in Kasterm Canada —

have revealed either barren py rite or graphite without
value; a few have resulted.in discoveries of small or

©

** “Recent drilling on one roperty near Timmins
has led to preliminary indications that more drilling -
- would be required .for proper evaluation. of. this *.

prospect. . The drilling dane to date has not been con-

clusive,- but the- “statements made by many outside -
quarters are unreliable ‘and include ‘information and. - ‘

figures that are not,available to TGS.

“**The work done to-date. has not been sufficient. to

reach definite conclusions and any statement as to size

and grade of ore would be premature and possibly mis-

.

° a oo
; = 3
et is: mm @#4«(C Boe : ‘
, atte c
.

RN Og E eG AB OY BRL»

_for

Se eR GBA CR STM oe Gy PP Ss “y . wae t es é
. ’ > s
; wi A : oe Ta
. 1 es J
-

12a aries sf

ane? ndix. —Opinion of the District Court

April 23. Mr. Mollison further testified that because —

of the dev. elopment of the rumors in Canada and New York
they decided to invite Mr. Ackerley to come a week caNQipr.

"On the basis of w hat he’ saw and heard on,April 13, Mr.-

Ackerley prepared an .article which, in accordance with
, prevgous understanding,. he stibmitted to Mr. Mollison for

him to held until the company was ready to release the |

same. Mr. Mollison made ‘an insignificant change by adding

some names of exploration department personnel ‘and on -:-

‘.. April 15 returned the. article’to Mr. Ackerley for publica-
‘ , tion.. It was published on the morning of April 16, the same
day that TGS nofified the press in.New York that it had

made a major strike. In pertinent part Mr. sueaudis
article read: 3

“Texas Gulf + Sulphur has uithest up a brilliant ex-
ploration success * * *'a major new zinc-copper- silver
mine is definitely in the making ** * * -— 7
: Ee? on the basis ‘of seven tests either’ completed

or drilling it ean be stated that,a strike-length of

‘600 ft. minimum has been éstablished showi ing an,ore
width of roughly 300 ft. which has been- traced so far
to a maximum: vertical depth of about 800 ft: :***:*

this’ must be revorded as one’ of the: most impressive

drill holes completed .in modern times.

“Pg. a core length of a.shade better. than -600 ft.,
. the hole averaged in..excess. ‘of 1% copper, 8% zine.
and nearly four ounces of silver.

‘*And there are impressive, strong sections within 7

this width which in thémselves are quite : ‘spectacular.

-In the upper part of the hole, for example, a core —
length of 82:ft. ran 7.1% copper,’ 9.7% zine, and 2.4 -
-ozs. silver. ‘And still deeper, ‘a strong zine section of .
better. than 100 ft.. ' averaged’ out to in extess of -..

seven ounces. of silver’ in- |, addition to ore- grade zine
values * shy at a :

od

\" a
Appendix \Opini n of the District Court

‘‘From the dimensions already known, the Northern
Miner can say that something in .excess of 10,000,000
tons of ore is indicated. It is capped with something
like 20 ft. of overburden, presenting no stripping prob-
lems, and the steep dip and wide widths will lend
themselves ideally to. an opén-pit mining situation.

+ “*The- picture should unfold rapidly at this stage,
but officials emphasize that it ‘is still at the embryo .
point * * #9) Fie cere soe

On April 16, TGS announced to the press a strike of
— at least 25,000,000 tons of ore. A prepared releasé was read
_ to representatives of the pres® and of financial publications
at 10:00°A.M., and summaries pf the announcement ap-
- peared ‘onthe -private wire pense of Merrill, Lynch,
Pierce, Fenner and Smith and of Dow Jones. within the
--hour. ‘In part this release read:

‘“Texas Gulf Sulphur Company has mad¢ #ntajor
strike of zine, copper and silvgr in the Timmins area
of Ontario, Canada. aie oe

‘Seven drill holes are now essentially complete.

_and indicate an ore body of at least 800 feet in length,
800 feet in width ard having a vertical depth of more
than 800 feet * * Lies ; xe A .

‘“This/is a major“discovery.. The preliminary data
indicate a reserve of more than_25 million tons of ore.
The only hole assayed so far represents over 600 feet

of ore, indicating a@ true ore thickness of nearly 400
ee ea We ee

- ‘Visual examination of cores from the other holes

_ indicates comparable grade- and continuity of ore. |

‘Fhe ,ore body is shallow haying only 20 feet of:

ee over-burden. -This means that it ean easily be mined
initially by the open-pit method *.* *” et ee

ae o = : .: ars § ‘14a,

| Appendix. See of the District Court’ |

* Stock eiibanks and Stock Option Acquired Us by: Réverty

Bs The récord establishes that: prior to completion of the
: first test. hole on November 12, 1963, Fogarty had pur-
chased a total of 705 shares of TGS stock. On that date
he purchased 300. shares, on Nevember 15, 700 shares, on -
November 19, 500: shares and.on November 26; an additional
200 shares. On December 30 and. 31, 1963, which was ‘about ;
two weeks after the company reveived the chemical assay
‘reports on the éore taken from the’ first hole, Fogarty pu -
chased 300 shares. Dfilling was resumed on March 31,
1964, and the following diy Fégarty bought 460 ‘shares of:- =
TG® stock, and an additional 300 shares on April 6, mak- -
: is total of 3100 shares of TGS stoek purchased between.
November 12, 1963, and April 6, 1964. . .
. ~ On February 20, 1964, Fogarty Yeceived a stock: option,
—. . + for 7300 shares of TGS‘stock. Other. “TES officials also :
art) ia accepted stock- ‘options on that date. The éviderice estab- —
lishes that members ‘of the stock option committee were
not aware of the results of drilling near Timmins at the ©
time the stock options were awarded. Fogarty subsequent-
ly -surrendered- his stock option :unexergised, and’ ‘‘re- -
turned’’ to the company at his ‘cost’ all stock purchased -
| _ ~by him ‘during the pertod November 12, 1963 to April eo .phur, et al., 401 F.2d 833, 842° (adv. sheets) (2d Cir. 1968). .

18. See sub-paragraph (2) of Rule 16b-5, supra.

oe ae

~~

a

Appendix —Opinion of the District Court ‘

_ that there was no duty at that time on the part of either
defendant to disclose the information then available with
respect to drilling results, and that Fogarty’s violations of
the-statute and the rule by purchasing TGS stock did not
cause any damage to Plaintiff Karlson. The press release

_Which the court has found to be misleading and inaccurate .

was not issued until four months after Karlson sold his
stock.

Reynolds ——_. aie

Plaintiff Reynolds-made-two-purchases of TGS-stock,

300 shares’ on. J January 7,°1960, at $185% a share, and 200
shares on May 18, 1962, at $15 per share. He sold his
500 shares early on the morning of April 16, 1964, after

hearing about a ‘‘rumor” and a “‘flurry’’ in the stock; -
ry

but before he learned that there had been an announcement
of a ‘‘major strike” or ‘‘discovery.”’ He testified that he
sold on the strength of the April 12, 1964 press release, a

summary of which came over the wires.on the morning of

_ April 13th.
An account executive with the Salt: Lake City office of a

national brokerage firm testified that-after he read the sum- “

mary af the April 12 release he telephoned Reynolds be-

_ cause he knew Reynolds was a a about TGS»
on he told Reynolds —

stock; that during their conver
that the report ‘‘didn’t make any positive statements about
what had happened’? and *‘that the report * * * didn’t
seem to substantiate the price action: of the stock to that
point.’ Reynolds. testified that on the 13th he decided to

_ hold the stock to see what happened, that he believed the °

press release, but that.it made him feel that ‘‘someoné was
throwing a wet blanket’’ and that they were trying to say
‘‘we haven’t got it.’’

Reynolds further testified that on April 16 the same-

account executive ealled him and ‘‘said there was a rumor

ry

21a

Fe: \ . ; :
\. : ta:

Appendie —Opinion of the District Court -—
eS _ —

| _ that Texas Gulf ities had made a strike’’;- that - he. e.:

(Reynolds)_Yhardly believed: it?” but ‘‘thought it was a a

: promotiofi propaganda of some kind’’ and decided to “‘get

out while the getting was good.’’ He sold his stock through eee

_ the broker for $335% per share, ‘He also testified that if it 56 jem

hadn’t been for the release “which came over the wires ie.

on the 13th he would have kept his TGS stock; that ato eal Be

‘had known of the November, 1963,.test core hole he wo i

have doubled his holdings. He did not learn of theéontents =~ *

of the April 16 release until later in the afternoon of that

day (April 16) when ‘the stock closed around $37, and’ ‘

that he did not buy back because ‘‘very few investors—wil}_—-—____——

~ ever chase-a stock’’ and because he had already sold aiid

was in a position where. he would have - pay taxes on his.

profits. oti
From the’ record the court ‘satiibial that the. press

release dated April 12, 1964, was inaccurate, misleading -.

and deceptive with respect to material matters disclosed

by the company’s drilling near Timmins. The authors of

the release knew from visual and chemical analyses that ee
__the first-eore-disclosed~ the= presence of copper and zinc. __
mineralization of .ore-grade;! that the second test hole: a ¢

(K-55-3) virtually eliminated any chance that the initial -
test hole had been drilled ‘‘dowrf#dip’’; that cores from
drill holes located 200° feet s@uth and 200 feet north of the -
initial dest hole contained similar mineralization ; -and that
still another drill hole core had disclosed similar mineral-

19. In the Memorandunf for ‘the a poevicusly referred to,

prepared on November 14, 1963, by Chief Geologist. Holyk, he wrote

- that the intersection encountered in the first drill holé was “obvi-
‘ously of ore grade.” An article in the April 24, 1964 issue of the
Wall- Street Journal (part of defendant’s Exhibit P-2 ) states that —
at the-annual meeting of TGS stockholders held April 23, 1964 \at
Houston, the president of TGS in responding to’ questions from stock-»
holders stated that “When we drilled the first hole, we knew. we had
something. But Canadian newspapers. were carrying reports with
no basis —— :

ae Appendia Opinion of the District Court”

ination at greater depths than were: ere ee by. the other

drill holes.

The release painted a bleak and gloomy picture—most

a the areas drilled in Eastern Canada revealed-either bar-
ren pyrite” or graphite without value; a few. resulted in
‘discoveries of small or marginal sulphide ore bodies, ete.
‘Not a word, however, about-the results of any of:the drill-

ing near Timmins, except that.it had led-to ‘preliminary ee

_indicatidns’’ -that more drilling would be necessary for a
- proper evaluation. The drilling ‘‘to date had not. been

conclusive’’ and has not been ‘‘sufficient to reach definite ._

—éonclusions”’ and ‘Cany”? statement ‘‘as to- size and grade

_ of ore would be premature and possibly misleading. ” But.
a, newspaper reporter’ $ finding, made on the same day the
press release was’ printed, that the drillings indicated’ more *
than 10,000,000 tons of ore, and the same reporter’s state- i

.ment that one hole: averaged in excess of -1% copper and
8% zine, went ‘unchallenged when submitted to vice presi-
dent Richard D. Mollison who released the article on April
_‘15th for publication.; Obviously, the reporter was quoting
figures given to him by officials of the company, and given

e
=

?

_ tg him on April 13th. It may very well have been that the

—* eompany officials when they. prepared the release dated .
- April 12, were trying to hold the big news until just before,.
or on the day of, the ftockholders annual meeting which’

was held on April 23rd. In any: event, the court finds the

“release dated April 12 was deceptive, misleading and inac-

curate and violated . both the statutory section 10(b) and’ — ?

the Rule provision {0b-5, and finds: that plaintiff Reynolds
was. misled and de eived to his. detriment, and is entitled
to recover damage

With respect to Mr. Aakerley? s siaatini that fron .

his examination on the 13th of April: there were in excess
of 10,900,000 tons of ore indfea ed, it interesting’ to note

the testimony of one of plainti s’ witnesses, Dr. Francis |

>
\

Wy oo Se

Appendix —Opinion of the District Couri

W. Christiansen, a geologist., Dr. Christiansen. testified

that from his examination of cores, assays,-logs and other——

. data pertaining to drilling up to 7:00 p.m_en April 10, he:
: , calculated the indicated tonnage of ore at 7,390,000 tons.
He testified further that drilling-up to 7:00 p.m. on April

"14, “added 2 ,600,000 tons of indicated ore, and that drilling “|
up to the evening of April 12 added 1,800,000 tons more, b
making a total 11,790,000 tons of i ee ore as of. ee

*\ evening, April 12th. - Qe
Mitchell Case 3 oe os

= Plaintiff Mitchell, a ©.P.A., residing in Los, ‘Rigen,
‘ purchased 420 shares of, TGS stile between. December: 11,

1953 and May 17, 1962, at prices from $15, to $8014 per .
share. On April 16, 1964, the first free day he .had had..
following the income tax season, he stopped by, to see one © id
of his-byokers between 9:00.and 9:30 a.m., to i inquire about /”

-. TGS stock which he had noticed. had. been: rising over sey*
eral weeks. His. broker’ gave him a copy of the ‘‘New York
Morning News Digest’’, dated April 13, 1964, publish d by

ee the financial. press this morning agement

ELF. Hutton & Company, 1 in whieh appeared’ the pow: f.-

of Texas Gulf Sulphur: states that reports that it hase.

‘discovered a large lode. of rich copper in Canada are
premature and possibly misleading:”’

- He also read the article in the western edition of the Wall
. Street eee: for. —_ 13, 1964, ‘the first ——— ’ “
which read: v. ge

. “New York—Texas Gulf Sulphiar Co. called reports

that it has. discovered a large lode of rich copper ore in
—- ‘premature and possibly misleading. dei :

- After- Seading the foregoing articles Mr. Mitchell re- |

turned to his office, reviewed. his file on TGS and ‘‘came to

the conclusion, based upon the report, the release of April |.-

e ;

_

-

. : | - 9
Ma

* Appendix —Opinion of the District Court —

13:-by Texas Guif Sulphur, that the stock could not sustain

its present rise and that it would fall back as sogn.as that —
release had been disseminated and recognition given to it
by the;public.’’ .He then went to a second broker and in- °
structed him to sell 400 shares. It was a ‘‘short sale against
the box.”? This was about 11:30 or 11:45 am. Later in
the afterndon he discovered he had overlooked 20 shares ~
‘and when he took the certificates for the 400 shares in to
his: broker he told the ‘clerk that he would bring in the 20

_ shares the following morning and.that they were to be sold.

They were delivered on the morning of the 17th with in- -
structions to sell short against the box. = _ Rec

At the time Mitchell sold his stock he had no knowledge _
of any press release-other than that of April 12th. ‘Under

cross-examination he téstified that ‘‘the. reason I sold short

‘was that-I did not want to part with my Texas Gulf Sul-—

phur stock.’ .I reasoned that inasmuch as the market could

_, not sustain itself in view of the report—the rélease of April

13-—that I could sell short, buy back at a lower price, and ~
in the meantime retain the stock I owned; namely, the 420
shares * * *’° On thé 16th the bid price was in the neigh- —

- borhood of $37 so he sold 400 shares at $40 a share. When

che (60k the 20 shares in on the 17th the stock had gone up

. somewhat and he put those shares in at $45. Even though
~ he gave his broker instructions to sell the 20 shares on the
17th, for some reason unknown to plaintiff Mitchell, ‘the.

20. A “short -sale” is defined as -follows in Patton’s Accourtte '
arit’s Handbook (3rd Ed.) :. “A short sale is a transaction in which»
a trader in securities ‘sells’ a block of ‘stock at the current price with-
out making immediafe delivery. - Such a sale is made in anticipation. .
of a decline in the price of the security; the trader expects to make

a profit- by buying the stock—‘covering’—at.a lower price. The post-

4 properly protected.”

.poning of delivery by the vendor is made possible through an arrange-"
ment by which the broker ‘borrows’ the stock for delivery to the

- party to whom the sale was made. Under the usual plan the trader

is not required to cover as long as*his account with the broker is .

c

: e * © . y
‘ a é , . .
= ‘ . A . 7
. - rs é
we.
g is * . 2 ° ~ . *

25a,
| Appendix. | —Opinion of the District Court :

- order to sell was not put through by the-broker until April
22, and the stock was sold on the 23rd for $46ij, per share. >
Plaintiff Mitchell testified that the article: in ‘the Wall
' Street Journal.of April 13 ‘“was the motivation that caused
me to sell short.’’ - poo a Se eee 7 oe
The court agrees. with Plaintiff Mitchell that the press’.
release dated April 12, 1964, was false, misleading, decep- - -’
.tive and fraudulent; that it contained qisstatements of
material facts. and. omittgd and ‘concealed material:‘facts ==
with respect to the progress of drilling—all in violation of ~ “L
Section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, and
S.E.C. Rule 10b-5. It omitted all.information as to the’ ~.
results of chemical and visual appraisals of cores, and gave —
ne information as to the number of holes drilled or the...
type of mineralization encountered. It was a misstatement :
to say that recent drilling had Jed to ‘preliminary indica- ~
tions that. more drilling would be required for.proper evalu-
ations of this prospect’? and it: was deceptive to state that
‘‘work done to date has not been sufficient to reach definite
conclusions: and any statement as to size and grade of ore
‘would be premature and possibly misleading”’ (emphasis
. added). The tenor of the entire statement was misleading,

%

sand, the court thinks designedly so.
Stout Case eae en |
° Arthur R. Sfout, Jr. and his. wife owned 1,000 shares °
of’ TGS stock in joint tenancy, which had been purchased )
». on- February 5, 1962, at $2114 a share. Their order to sell ie .. ’
was placed. April 21,. 1964, -and the stack was sold the, . _
following day at $42 per share. Mr. Stoyt testified that Ses
_ thé sale of the stock was motivated by information conceyn—*
ing the press release of’ April 12, 1964, which he feceived -/
‘‘probably within a week of the 13th.’’: He-fiad no recollec-
tion as to how he.received the information, but from what.
“ he leard he ‘‘coneluded. that the officers of Texas Gulf:

; into a fina savings account

TS ae

Append ‘Opinion of the District Court,’

=f Sylphur had stated ‘that the discovery wasjoverrated and

exaggerated and ‘that, as-a result of their ktatéments, the

_ stock would (go down) in price,-and therefore [ sold it.’”
Mr. Stout testified that, he had bought TGS stock for long: .
’ term ‘appreciation ; that, hie had no reed for nioney whew he

sold‘it; and that the | money : received from the sale he put

He stated: “T. received that

ot

& .

{formation. Whether I read it or heard it through the | ti
news niedia, I do not recall; -but-the essence of the informa. ",

tion of the release i is what 1 based.the sale of my stock on.”

lowing :

««Conftised ia conflicting sefoeks icened by deferd-

_ants of the value of the Kidd 55 segment, plaintiffs sold:
their’ 1,000 shares on or about April: +22, 1964, at a
ay _ Price of - 00 per. share.’’’

o

tiie Stoiits ask for. teseission, or, in the alternative, |

damages, contending that the actions of defendants i in pre-
‘paring, isguing and causing the news release. dated April 12,

One of the allegations in the: sees complaint i is the fol- 2

_ 1964, to be published were fraudulent ;.that.the release mis- °

.

?

*

stated or congealed the true facts concerning | the magnitude |
"> of the. mineral discovery; that defendants knew the, faets
given were incorrect and misleading and knew, or should ;

have known,. that the facts as stated would be relied upon:

by shareholders.- The~court’ thinks these: statements con-
stitute a fair appraisal of fhe nature, purpose and effect

Fe ene April 12, 1964, news. release.

as DAMAGES |: | oo etn eae

s aX bd i

>is is unecessary for the court ‘to make any : cei

. tion as to: whether defendants were required: by the.statute °.

- OF. the rule to disclose the results-of drilling at any time
% prior to April 12, 1964. Likewise, nothing would be gained

. by exploring the question whether the wide- spread rumors

ms Cae Veen geen treed me

’

Dia haemel —Opinion of the 1 District Court

in Canada and in this country gave rise to a duty o on the oe a. ee
part of the. defendants ih mane a disclosure Prior ‘to\that. .- . ee,

date. ~ ° | , ae

-. The important fact j is‘ that debenitiaile ‘iiniee to mag a

ia public statement, which both the statute and. the rule rg-" Ze

. Company. v. Borak, 377 U.S. 426,. wherg. violations of the *

_ quired be accurate, fair and complete. Instead, the press ~~: °
releasé issued by detendante was misleading, ‘intentionally.
.deceptive,. insecurate. and knowingly deficient in material. .
“facts pertaining ° to. the results of drilling. The ye
establishes that each of the plaintiffs relied upo t
leading an naceuraty announceiient in making » is deci-.
_, sion to sell\his TGS stock. Consequently, sin t Texas.

-. Guif Sulphur must respond. i in damages. .°. 4 |
, The alm of courts in cases of this ‘type is to put the
i plafhtitts in, the positions they would-have been ‘i in if they é
had not been motivated by defendants’ fraudulent press °
release to sell.their’stock. In this connection -it is Signifi- - —
cant to point to the. periods of time plaintiffs had held their - Peony st
stock. Plaintiff Rey nolds, when he.sold 500 shares of TGS: - ess C

stock on April 16, 1964, had held 30 shares since Janwry ates
> "7, 1960, a period of more than. four -years, and had held~ | °

200.shares since. May 18, 1962, a. ‘period of 23. months. ©
Plaintiffs Stout sold, 1000-shares of TQS stock on April 21, Pe?
.1964. They had-held those shares | since February 5, 1962, A
_ more than. two ‘years. Plaintiff Mitchell, purchased 420 - ene
shares of TGS stock at various times” during the: period. ) =
Degember 11, 1953 and: May 17, 1962.. Some’ of the 400.
shares he sold on April.17, 1964, he had held for m
~fhan 10 years, some about two years.
The variety .of situations -in which a 10(b) or 10b-5

violation niay be’ found. makes it difficult to formulate. a,
comprehensivesrale of damages. In the} case. of JI. Case"

tes” 5 “ °
a
A

at SOC

Securities Excharige Act) were involved, the Supreme Comet f.. =f
obseryed that it’ is _ duty: of the courts to- be ae kd

” : . ses ; = j fl

| P ¢
| aa

28a

-

a

‘ Appendia —Opinion of the District Court

; provide such remedies as are necessary to make effective

‘the congressional purpose, that where federally secured
rights are invaded federal courts. should adjust their rem- _—

edies so as to grant necessary relief, aid that they may

“use any available remedy to make good the wrong done.

of and a reasonable time after the injured party received,

-Section.28(a) of the Securities Exchange Act™ provides

that ‘‘no person permitted to.maintain a suit for damages
under the proyisions of this title shall recover * * * a total
amount in excess of his actual damages * * *’’, but it pro-
vides no help jn determining how ‘‘actual damages”’ are
to be measured. ee , : ;

It seems to this court that the true and just measure

of damages in these «cases should be, with some qualifica-~

tion, what long ago came to be called the New York Rule.
Of necessity, it was unthinkable that the common law rule
in trover for the conversion of ordinary chattels, i.e., fair
market value at time of conversion, should be applied in
the case of corporate shares with rapidly changing values.
So.the rule evolved that the measure of damages in stock
transactions @s the highest intermediate value-reached by
the stock betweeri the time.of the wrongful act complained

or should have received’ notice of it, a time within which
he has a reasonable opportunity to replace t k. This
was arinounced by the United States Supreme Court in a
ease decided in 1888 which arose in the Territory of Utah,
Galigher v. Jones, 129 U.S. 194, 200-202.

Factors considered in making the judgment on damages:

in this ease include: the rapidity of price fluctuations in
normal trading situations on -the New York market; the

eexecéssive publicity, first having a tendency to depress the

4

of trial was repudiated. :

21. 15 U.S.C. Sec. 78bb(a). /
22. Tix former rule of highest intermediate value up to time

‘9

=~

_———

29a i
. Appendix ~—Opinion of the District Court

price of Texas Gulf Sulphur shares, and later to cause it
. to rise, the nature of the Texas Gulf’ Sulphur enterprise;
‘that is, a mining venture carrying on world wide mineral
explorations, about which there has been extensive continu-
ing publicity, all of which reasonably might have been
expected to cause stockholders’ interest to be stimrlated
and to cause them to be_on the alert for sudden changes
_ in the quotation’, and to exercise ordinary care, prudence,
and diligence in watching out for their own. interest, and
.to learn of the Texas Gulf Sulphur announcement of April
16. . 8 ee a :
The obligation of the plaintiff shareholder is to exercise
ordinary and reasonable care and diligence to look out
for himself. The notice required is that which he received,
or should have received, in the exercise of reasonable care
We must draw the line somewhere, and this is an at-
tempt to give a twenty trading day period within which the
average of the highest daily prices is the measure of
damages, and a period within which the shareholders
received, or should have received, notice of the Texas Gulf
Sulphur announcement of April 16. -
A few days, is too short a time reasonably to expect
stockholders to make a judgment and sell their stock, and
much too early to let the New York market reflect the true
value, over-stimulated upward or downward. The average
of the hi t daily sales for the 16th of April and 19
trading days subsequent thereto allows the market reac-
tions more truly to reflect actual value and allows a more
reasonable period of time within which to require the
shareholders, in the exercise of ordinary diligence and
prudence, to learn of the Texas Gulf Sulphur announce-
ment of April 16 and to protect their interest. :
There remain a couple of additional factors considered
ty the coast iif sending the Solenstet' lo @he can _ They
were suggested in Judge Henry J. Friendly’s opinion in the
oa

J

>

eee

)- Appendix —Opinion of the District Court

.

"Second Cireuit, Securities and Exchange Commission. v.

Texas Gulf Sulphur; 401 ‘F.2d 864, 866-867.

Judge Friendly was speaking of ‘negligence’? in the
- drafting of the release. Instead,+the record here discloses
that the press release issued by defendants was mislead-

- + ing, intentionally deceptive, inaccurate and knowingly defi- ©. °

cient in material facts. ..

One of the choices open to the corporation, i if it decides
‘to speak; is to tell the truth.

The measure of damages here adopted is calculated to
result in fair, reasonable and just awards.’ The damages
awarded are compensatory and not punitive or in terrorem,
Plaintiffs are onlt to be made whole, not ta be compensated
twice. When plaintiffs recover compensation for their
losses from Texas .Gulf. Sulphur their claims against
‘ Fogarty willbe deemed paid, satisfied and discharged.

‘On the day, April 16, 1964, that TGS publicly acknowl- ~

edged that it had made a substantial mineral discovery,
its stock advanced néarly $7.to a high of $57. The follow-
_ing day it advanced to a high of $42, and on the néxt trad-
ing day it advanced to a high of $44. This was followed

/»y a decline to a high of $411, then an increase of more

-—_—

than 5 points to a high 6f $47. On April 29, 1964, it reached
a high of $59. After a number of declines and a few ad-

which the stock fluctuated on each trading day, and fr
day to day, is apparent from the = ont out in the fo
note.”

vances it reached $60.50 on May 18; 1964. - The extent AS
nm

°23. The. opening, high, low and dosiag prices of TGS stock tor
20 — — starting with April 16, 1964, até as follows:

Open ~ High Lowe Close “4

April 16, 1964 (Thurs.) 30-% 37 30-% ~° 36-%
April 17, 1964 (Fri.) 39-4 42 38% 40-%
Aptil 20, 1964 (Mon.) 42 44 ©«O «Css
April 21, 1964 (Tues.) 41 41-% ~30-% 40-% ©
April 22, 1964 (Wed.) . 40-% 47 40-1%4 45-%
~y - _- [footnote continued on next page]

Sla
Appendix —Opinion of the District Court

In Section 151 of the Restatement ‘of Restitution it is
recognized that while generally the meastre of recovery
will be the-value of the property at the time of its improper
. acquisition, retention or disposition, a‘‘higher value’’ may
be recognized ‘‘if this is required to avoid’ injustice where
. the property has fluctuated,in value or additions-have been
made to it.’? Comment ¢. to Section 151 explains:

“Where the stibject matter is of fluctuating value,
and .where the persons .deprivéd of it might have
secured-a higher amount for it had he. not been so°
deprived, justice ta him may require that the measure

of recovery be more than the value at the time of
deprivation. This is ‘true where the recipient knowing-
ly déprived the owner of his property or where a
wena in violation of his duty used the property of
he beneficiary for his own benefit. In such cases the
person deprived is entitled to be put in substantially
the position in which he would have been had there not |
been the deprivation#and this may result in granting
to him an amount equal to the highest value reached
by’ the subject matter within a reasonable time after

—

[footnote continued from preceding page] | |
a ee Open. High Low Close
April 23, 1964 (Thurs.) 47-% 48-4 42-4 42-% -

April 24, 1964 (Fri.) wr a 44-3, 42-% 44-4
April 27, 1964 (Mon.) 44-4, . + 47-Y, 44-56 47 ;
April 28, 1964 . (Tues. )- 47-44 52-38 . 47-% 52-3%
April 29, 1964 (Wed.) 54+-4% - 59 53-% 56-%
April 30, 1964 (Thurs.). 54-4 58-3¢ 54+-% 54-%4
May 1; 1964 (Fri.) - 55-% 56-% 52-% ~° 52-%

« May 4, - 1964 (Mon.) 5+-Y%4 54-54 52-%- 52-% f
May 5, 1964 (Tues.) 51-% -.52 48-%. 48-% @-

. May 6, 1964 (Wed.) 48% 52-% 46-¥% = -52-%
May 7, 1964 (Thurs.). +52-% 53-¥% 49-4 49-1,
May 8, .- 1964 (Fri.) 51-% 54+-¥% 50-% 54-%
May 11, 1964 (Mon.) 54-% 57 54-56 56

May 12, 1964 (Tues.) 55-% _ 56-3% 4 53-+% 55
May 13, 1964 (Wed) 54% 55% 51-$4.. - B1256

——
. Appendix —Opinion of the Distvict Court |

_the tortious eundiint: This is done if he can prove that —
“he probably would have made a sale while the subject
matter was ‘at its highest point in value * * *”’ -

In the wrongful conversion case of Nephi Processing ;
Plant v. Talbot, 247 F.2d 771 (10th Cir. 1957) the Circuit
yop held that while Utah courts have recognized that
a general rule the measure of damagefor-conversion
care ae property is the value of the property at the time of.con- .
version ‘‘the rule has no application where the converted |
ttels are of a kind which have a fluctuating market
value. ’”? In sueh cases, the court said, ‘‘the measure - -of
_ damages is the‘highest market price of the property within
a rensengte time after the owner has notice of the conver-
sion.’ :
: What a ‘‘reasonable time’’ may be will vary from case.
* to.ease. Here, a pericd of wide-spread rumors about a
mineral discovery was followed by the deceptive and in-
accurate press release published April 13, 1964, and the
‘ , ‘publie announcement of 4 major discovery on April 16,
| - 1964. On that day the price of TGS stock jumped about
-$7, and for the next 9 trading days the stock steadily in-
; _ereased, except for two days on each of which the closing
price of the stock decreased about $2. On the 10th 1 trading
-. day (including the day of the announcement) the stock had
; Je advanced from approximately $30 to a high of $59. During
: the ensuing 11 days the stock fluctuated considerably and ~
7 then climbed to a new y high for this — # $60.50 on
; May 18, 1964.
7 : In the circumstances of these cases the court considers
that a reasonable period .would be 20 trading: days j includ-
ing April 16, 1964, the day of the announcement.
If the plaintiffs had not been led to sell their TGS.
shares and learned on April 16th, through the TGS an- ©
es \ nouncement, of the proportions of the discovery, it would

) : , 83a . ances
. * AD,

| Appendix —Opinion of the District Canes

be highly improbable, to say the least, that any- one of them peo?
would have sold at the highest price. , .

The court deems it fair and just therefore, to take the
average of all of the highest market prices on the 20 trading
days, rather than the single highest market price during the
period. —

—The average e of the high’ niarket prices : during’ such 20-
day period i is $50.75, which the court adopts as the measure .
_ of damages in these cases. °
Damages to be awarded to plaintiff Reynolds | are com- :
_ puted by deducting from $50.75 the price he received for” .
each share, $33.625, and multiplying the .resulting figure of
$17,125 by 500, the number of shares he sold, to arrive at
damages of $8,562.25. est on that amount at the rate ©
of 6% per annum from the date he sold his stock to the:
date of judgment is allowed.

Similarly, damages for Plaintiff Mitchell are computed | .
by rane from $50.75 the amount received by him for
each share‘and multiplying the resulting figure by-the num- ~
ber of shares to arrive-at damages of $4,390.00, In thegease
of Plaintiffs Stout, damages are. awarded in the sum of
$8,750.00, arrived at in the same manner. In each case
interest is awarded at the rate of 6% per’annum on the-
damages from the date on which the TGS shares of stock. ~'
were sold to the date of judgment.

' The court does not ovérloek- the claims of the Stouts
that (1) they did not learn of the ‘‘possibility’’ of an action
against defendants until ‘‘on.or after July 12, 1966’? and
(2) that they ‘“did not become aware of or learn of the -
defendants’ unlawful actions in connection with the issu-
ance of the. April 12, 1964, press release until on or about -
July 12, 1966.’’ Aside from doubts the court has as to the
credibility of these claims, he believes that in the circum-
stances of this case the Stouts knew, or should have known,
of the misre ngage and deceptions i in the April 12,
1964, release wi a — of 20 trading —

ee Ai Appendia Opinion of the District Court .
STATUTE OF ‘Liirrations
There i is no. ‘federal statute of iesitations which is ap-
plicable to violations of Section,10(b) of the Act or,of Rul®

10b-5, consequently the Utah statute of limitations, 78-12-
_-26(3) Utah Code-Annotated; 1953, controls. It provides:

‘*Within three years: *:* *

**(3) An.action for relief | on the ground of fraud
or mistake; but the cause of- action in such case shall
not. be deemed to have acerued until the discovery by
the aggrieved party of the facts ee the fraud
or mistake ** *? -. .

The action brought by puflie Reynolds was filed J uly *
12, 1966, and the action brought by Plaintiffs Stout was
. filed April 7, 1967. Each of these actions was Fr within

the statutory period,
The action icemaed by Plaintiff Mitchell was filed -
April 47,1967. Defendants contend this action: should be:
dismissed as having been filed too late. Mitchell, a C.P.A.,
testified at the trial that on April 16, 1964, the first fee
day after the close of the income tax season, he visited one .
‘of his brokers and for the first time learnéd of the press
release of April 12, 1964. He went back to his office, ob-
tained the certificate for 400 shares of TGS stock and took
it to another broker and gaye him an order to sell. At that
time he realized he had an additional 20 shares and he told
the broker he would bring them in the: next day, which he
did and gave the order to_sell the 20 shares on April 17.
He testified that at the time he gave the orders to sell he.
knew of no press release from TGS other than that of
April 12, 1964. In a depgsition takeh -by defendants,
Mitchell testified 4 im response to questions as follows: ~

*Q. Do you recall any conversation with Mr. Lewis
- with respect to your Texas Gulf Sulphur stock after

oe

_ Appentie- —Opinion of the District poet

- the ‘coniestiaibiit on the 16th at innit 1 00.
o’clock or 1:30 that you have just described to us?
“A, You mean that same week? :
# ‘*Q. Yes, any time.
‘*A. Yes, I believe it was. Wednesday or Thursday .
_ of the following week that I think Mr/ Singer told me |
oS. —I am not too sure—or did I read it in the Wall Street.
Journal something to the effect that a new. release Se
«+ come out on the 16th.’ .

:
=

) The Court Hfas examined al considered the testimony os
of Mr. Mitchell and the rather ex xte sive depositions taken
"by defendants of Mitchell and hiébrokers, and has con- -
cluded that the above quoted testimony should be accepted.
, Consequently, Mitchell’s action was filed within the time
limit set “by the Utah: statute. . |
* ‘ 4

Dated this 9th day of J anuary, 1970: }

/s/ ‘Willis W. Ritter
Wiis W. Rrirrer, Corer Jupcz .

Filed: January 13, 1970 ide : w

SE er ere ow

.
it ,
Appendix—Class Action Opinion $1, District Court
~ - f s /
> — . C13266
Geoncr, Gorpon REYNOLDS, 3

Plaintiff,
. -

Texas Gur Sutrnun Company, a Texas Corporation, and
Cuarves F. FocGarty,

: .

Pes
»
, ° «8

; 42a

- 8 a | bs
Appendix—Class Action Opinion of the District Court
than 225, in order to pe er for whom each brokerage
_house was acting. Of course, many of the transactions are
‘sales by the odd-lot houses; acting as agents for several
different persons as to each 100 share sale. The Stock
Clggring Corporation produced the code for the broker-
on We have not ascertained how many of these
were involved in transactions in Texas Gulf stock, but thev
are numerous. We do not-know what steps have vet been
-undertaken by counsel for plaintiffs in Cannon and Green
in this direction, but it is likely that this has mot begun.
It is the necessary next step in order to determine who the
members of the class are, but we believe they have not
gone ahead because of pending motions by defendants for

summary judgment, raising questions of law which have —

not vet: ‘been passed upon y Judge Bonsal.”’ -

The pending motions in 60 Sates for summary judgment
referred to by. Mr. Marden in his \affidav ‘it sworn to on October
22, 1969, and filed here October 27, were ruled on by Judge
Bonsal. October 31, 1969. Astor, et al. v. Texas Gulf Sulphur Co.,
et al; Alexander, et al. v. Texas Gulf. Sulphur Co., et al; Dar-

raugh, Jr., et al. v. Coates, et al. (CCH Fed. Sec. L. Rep. para-.

graph 92, 501)

- A hearing was held in the Cannon and Green cases on De--

cember 8, 1969, at which time Judge Bonsal directed counsel

to settle an order to obtain information from the brokers re-_

ferred to above by Mr. Marden as to who are the members of
the ‘class, and Judge Bonsal considered the kind of notice to be
sent out to the members of the class.

In reaching a judgment upon this motion, the foregoing facts
have been considered with Rule 23(b) (B) (3) in mind, par-
ticularly clauses: (B’).The extent and: nature of: any litigation

already commenced by members of the class. (C) The desir-.
ability or undesirability of concentrating the litigation in the’

48a |
e Appendix—Class Action Opinion of the District Court

particular forum: (D) The difficulties likely to be encountered
_ _in the managemenit of a class action in Salt Lake City. a

The application of these provisions of -Rule 23 to the facts
and. circumstances herein outlined seem to the Court particu-
larly appropriate. The litigation: in New York is.far advanced,
far and away the bulk of the cases are there, and the inform--
ation necessatily to be obtained from the brokérage ‘offices is
more readily and more convenieritly available in New York City.

Dated this 13th day of January, 1970.

oe) M. = Se ‘
s /s/ Willis W, Ritter
Willis W. Ritter, Chief Judge

7 i :
Filed: January 13, 1970

Judgments of the District Court
‘(Entered January 13, 1970)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT .

_ Disraict or Uran, Centrat Division :

ee
ia, - C-62-67
WaLter A. MircHELL, :
Pa ° Plaintiff,
r —— | M :

Texas Guur SutpHvr Company, a Texas Corporation, and
| . Cuarues F. Focarry, e
: Defendants.

The above-captioned matter was consolidated for trial

with three other cases, George Gordon Reynolds v. Texas -

- Gulf Sulphur Company, et al. (Civil No. C-132-66), Arthur
- R. Stout, et al. v..Texas Gulf Sulphur Company, et al., and
Lawrence L. Karlson et al. v. Texas Gulf Sulphur. Com-
pany, et al. (Civil No. C-59-67), and the consolidated mat-
Ls ter was tried to the Court, sitting without a jury, the Hon-
orable Willis W. Ritter, Chief Judge, presiding, the plaintiff

' Walter A. Mitchell being représented by Roy G. Haslam, -
Esq., and the defendants Texas Gulf Sulphur Company and

. ‘Charles F. Fogarty being represented by Calvin A. Behle,
Esq., Keith E. Taylor, Esq., Orison S. Marden, Esq., and ~
-P. B. Konrad Knake, Esq., and the Court having received

Appendix Seale of the District Court

certain stipulations of fact’ entered into by : the parties and
having received evidence, both testimonial and documen-
tary, and having heard the arguments of counsel and being
fully advised in the premises, and having filed its Amended.
Findings of Fact and Conclusion of Law:

- Iris Heresy Oxpenep, Ansvscm AND DEcRgED:

That plaintiff be awarded judgment against defendants
in the sum of $4,390.00, together with interest thereon at
the rate of six per cent (6%) per annum to the date of —
judgment herein, an@ &osts meurréd in the maintenance of
this action. Interest shall be calculated from April 16, 1964,
‘to the date of judgment herein on that portion of the total
damages incurred through the sale of 400 shares. of Texas
Gulf Sulphur Company stock, and from April 23, 1964 to
the date of judgment herein on that portion of the total
: damages incurred through the sale of 20 pee of Texas
Galf Sulphur meen stock.” .

~ Dated this 13th ier of J anuary, 1970.

| /s/ Willis W. Ritter
. -- Wis W. Rirter, Curer-Jupcr

Entered: January 13,-1970 . Sane be R

* .

| Aa: iene
Appendia ; —Judgments of the District Court
: Fae eee aa
————
C-132-66
Grorce Gorpon REYNOLDs, or |
es _ Plaintiff, | -
v.

Texas Guir Sutpuur Company, a-Texas Corporation, ‘and

.

| CHARLES F. Focarry, )
Defendants. _

\ a. . .
he above sini matter was eaeailbiaieis for trial
witlf the cases of Walter A. Mitchell v. Texas Gulf Sulphur

. Company, et al. (Civil No. C-62-67), Lawrence L. Karlson, _
et al. v. Texas Gulf Sulphur Company, et al. (Civil No. C- ~
59-67), and Arthur R. Stout et al. v. Texas Gulf Sulphur

Company et al. (Civil No. C-54-67), and the consolidated
matter was tried to. the..Court, sitting without a jury, the

_ Honorable Willis W. Ritter, Chief Judge, presiding, the

plaintiff George Gordon Reynolds being represented by
Parker NM. Nielson, Esq., and A. Reed Reynolds, Esq. . and

the defendants Charles F. Fogarty and Texas Gulf Sul-
phur Company being represented by Calvin A. Behle, Esq.,

Keith E. Taylor;.Esq., Orison S. Marden, . Esq. . and P. B.
Konrad Knake, Esq., and the Court having received cer- »

tain stipulations of fact entered mto by the parties and -

having. received: evidence, both testimonial. and documen- -
tary, and having heard the arguments of counsel and being’
fully advised in the prémises'and having made and filed
its Amended Findings of Fact and Conclusions’ of Law
herein:

ec oe i. es ; igeet
_ Appendix Bats a of the District Court /.

. Now, THEREFORE, it is = ‘Onnznen, ApsupcEp AND
DECREED:

| That Plaintiff George Gordon Reynolds is eiaiaaik judg-
ment against the defendants in the amount of $8,562. 50, to- —
_ gether with interest thereon at the rate of six per cent —
(6%) per annum from Aprit16, 1964, to the date of entry

of judgment herein, and costs incurred i in ‘the, maintenance |
x of this action. . ma s
\ | =

. Dated this 13th es of J anuary,. 1970.

cafe Willis Ww. Ritter —
Wuuis W. Rirrer, CHIEF JUDGE ©
Entered: January 13, 1970 @

, : ——— — ee
—_ = . OBES a ee , = . : ,
>

het Ba

. ee " _- Appendix—Judgments of the District Court

C.13266

Georce Gorvon REYNOLDS, wD
: Piss: Plaintiff, |
_ : “i TEXAS GuLr SuLPHUR COMPANY, a Texas Corporation, cua ae
Seo. CHARLES F. Focarty, -
io ieee ae Dejeridants.
z ee ox
| The Court, having heard oral arguments of coimsel for the
‘ parties and of counsel for persons appearing amicus curiae, on

_two occasions, relative to plaintiff's Motion for the Entry of”
. Additional Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law Concern-
ing Class Action, and having read and considered memoranda
- supplied by all parties and persons: ‘concerned, and: being fully
advised in the premises, upon the grounds and for the reasons ~
set forth at some length’ in the following Memorandum,

IT IS ORDERED, thatthe motion be, 7 the same here- .
* byheemint. one \ RS eory

- \
\

. .
~...

Texas Gur icone Company, et al.,
A ppellant and Cross. A ppellee.

?

Nos. 282-70
i * 283-70
Guinan Gorpon Reynoups, 7
_ Appellee and Crose- A ppeliant,
ei

ote Texas GULF ne Company, et al.,
Bie oe a * and Cross- ss-Appeliee.

_.Nos. 284-70
285-70

ArtHur R. Srovt, et al., |
"Appellees and Cross- -Appetanis

v;

~

'PEXAS GuLF Soisieve Company, et di, :
—— and Cross-Appellee

Aosieal from. the United States District Cot
for the District of Utah, Central Division |

ae er

” ‘ a
Spray ct papper tesnagrtoensrserrwrEiee
Sed ee aa a a ee .
LR SLAIN EN ISI AE TOG DOR x :
.

on

~ 50a

_ —~Appenilia ; aan of the Court of Appeals

Before Lewis, Chief Judge, Hiv, and “MoWituiams, .
‘United States Cirenit Judges.

Hit, Cireuit Judge. eat te gee

Appellees and siiiiaMieies Rey nolds, Mitchell and
Stout instituted actions in the Utah district against’ appel-—
lants and cross-appellees Texas Gulf Sulphur Company
(hereinafter referred-to.as TGS) and Charles A. Fogaréy,
oneyof the principal officers of the company, to recover dam- ’
‘ages for violations of Section 10 (b) of the Securities Ex-—
change Act of 1934, 15 U.S.C, §78j(b) afid Rule 10b-5,
17 C.F.R. $240.10b-5, Heontarnas thereunder. The actions
were consolidated for trial to the. court without a: jury and
plaintiffs procured judgments in the three cases.’

While the complaints of the several parties make vary-
ing allegations of legal infractions,” the cases were tried,
ual are appealed; only upon alleged violations of Section.
10(b) and Rule 10b-5, with a cross-appeal by Reynolds and ©
‘Mitéhell on the i issues of damages and class action elaims. ~
Specifieally, the elaim is that appellees were damaged “by
the violations of. TGS and Fogarty, its executive vice pres- .

_ ident, (1) for failure to disclose on April 12 and prior to _ E

April 16, 1964, information as- to the results of drilling at
the Timmins, property ; and (2).in issuing an inaccurate,
misleading and deceptive press release published April 13,
1964. 3

The essential facts are as tliaws: Reynolds, Mitchell
and-Stout were and had been for several years stockholders .

in TGS. After several years of-extensive mineral explora- «-

tion on the Canadian Shield of eastern Canada, TGS de-

A. The trial court’s opinion, including ‘findings and conclusions,
- is is reported i in 309.F.Supp. 548. ;

2.. Oye complaint includéd ‘a count in. common Jaw teat an.”
other allfged a conspiracy’to violate the Act and Rule, and one al-
' leged violation of fiduciary duties and violations of Section 9° of the
Act.

“Appendix —Opinte of.t the cee of hietile. ;

4

more" a vreinishae anomoly on a pict of land known as

the Kidd 55.segment near Timmins; Ontario, Canada. In
November, 1963, TGS. fore: avifted the anomoly. at -its.
““strongest’’, point. THe holé* was designated K-55-1 and
was completed . Noy tber 12 at a depth of 655 feet. High
ore content was indicated ‘by visual examination, and after

the. cor¥ was split and sent‘to Utah for assay, it disclosed + Between 7:00 p.m:, April 10 and 7:00 p.m., April 12 (the-
evening prior to the first release) more data became avail-
able. K-55.5 was at the 531 foot level and had continued
te encounter substantial coppér mineralization over that
entire length. During the same interval, K-55-6 had reached
a depth of 881 feet and had found mineralization over the
length of this intermediate drilling. Meanwhile, K-55-7
was started approximafely 400 feet north of K-55-1 on a
westerly 45 degree angle td was at 91 feet and showing

i And K-55-8 was drilling at a depth of 162
feet without report as to its mineral content. ,

By the morning of April 13, K-55-5 had enéountered

substantial copper mineralization to the 580 foot mark; K- .

35-6 had found mineralization to the 946 foot level; and 50
feet of the 137 feet drilled at K-55-7 showed mineralization.
-4, -5, -6, and -8 were completed,
feet, -9 was at 373 feet, and -10-Was at

55-7 was at
123 feet.
er in which data was being aceumulatedea? the
Timmins drill site.

a thumbnail sketch, this Mustfates’ the rapid”

hea , é
Although TGS soughit to suppress the nature and extent’ -

of its discovery at Timmins by early 1964, rumors had be-
gun to generate excitement about the alleged strike. By
April, 1964, property withi® several miles of the TGS «ite
had been ‘staked’, Cynadian newspapers carried the ru-

mors, and of their effogt on the Toronto Stock Exchange, ©

proclaimed hy_one to be “the wiklest speculative spree sinee -—

Nineteen Fifties."" Evtntually the ramors worked south
to the United-States. *

On Saturday, April 11, 1964, both the New York’Times ©.
* and the Herald’ Tribune carried stories on ‘the rumored

ere

’ s84ggge fe ee aa
ot Halli HR ER Gp Hae
oy ply, | L ort = Mie aut 9G iF .
ag at gi eek i F Li HE Ca fi ins
3 alba i; a it 1 ry li ea]
Oe PAINE EEE Uf
are i sgenjsdy tps He a Hh i ald
ae a) mE: | ze : : i J at x!
ere a

54a
.- .

*

Appendix © —Opinion of the Court of Appeals

, TGS invitation,-on April 13, a reporter from a Ca-
na mining journal, the Northern Miner, visited the
Kidd-55 drilling site. The article detailing that visit was
pubshed April 16, and indicated that this ‘must be re-
corded as one of, the most impressive drill holes completed
in modern times.’’ That same day, at 10:00 a.m. Eastern

Standard Time,!Fogarty held a second press conference .

and released a statement which revealed in some detail the

.

[footnote continued front preceding pag. |

covery there. -These reports exaggerate the scale of operations, and —

mention plans and statistics of size and grade of Gre that are without

factual basis and have evidently originated by speculation of people .

not connected with TGS. ‘ _ - aan

“The facts are as follows. TGS has been exploring in the
Timmins area f6r six years as part of its overall search in Canada
and elsewhere for various nunerals—lead, copper, zinc, etc. .. During
the course of this work, in Timmins as well as in Eastern Canada,

: TGS has conducted exploration entirely-on its own, without “the

Participation’ by~others. . * .

“Numerous prospects. have been investigated by geoplrysical
means and a large number of sclected ones havé been core-drilled.
These cotes are sent to the United States for assay and detailed ex-

amination as a matter of routine and on advice of expert Canadiat

legal. counsel. No inferences as to grade can be drawn from this
procedure. * \

“Most of the areas drilleg-in Eastern Canada have revealed
either barren pyrite or graphite Without value; a few have resulted

in discoveries of stnall or marginal, sulphide ore bodies.

“Recent drilling ougone property near Timmins has led to pre- .

linxinary*indications that-more.drilling would be requied for proper
evaluation of this prospect. The drilling done to date has not been
conclusive, but: the statements made by many oyitside quarters are
unreliable and include information and figures that ate not available

to TGS.

“The work done to date has not been sufficient to reach definite’

. 2 . . .
cygnclusions and any statement as to,size and grade of ore weuld be

‘premature and possibly misleading. When we have progressed to
_ the point where reasonable and togical conclusions can be made, TGS
will: issue a definite statement to its stockholders and to the poblic

° *

in ordér to clarify the Titmmins project. * * *"s

r

a Appendix © oe of the Court of Appeals

~ magnitude of the discovery at Timmins." “Summaries of

this announcement appeared onthe private wire service of
Merrill Lynch and on the Dow-Jones wire service shortly
/ thereafter. ? 8 :

6. “Texas Gulf Sulphur Company’has made a major discovery
of zinc, copper and silver in the. Timmins area of Ontario, Canada.

“We announced last Sunday that when Texas Gulf had done,
_sufficiént work to reach firin conclusions, the company would issue

a definite public statement on the Timmins project. We are now
* prepared to make that statement. * :

“Just ten days ago TGS had but one. drilling rig operating in

this area. As we state in our release of April 12, initial drilling on
this one prospect had led to preliminary indications that more drilling
would be required for proper evaluatio ., We-immediately moved
in additional drills so chat by April 2 four drills = rating-
With four drills, considerably more data has been a ealased,

“Seven- drill holes are now essentially complete and indicate an
ore body of at least 800.feet iti length, 300 feet in width and having
a verticle depth of more than 800 feet. -

“We have not yet delimited the: ore bedy in either direction

along the strike. We have only drilled to a vertical depth of ~800

“feet. Values remain consistent to that depth. +,

“This is a major discovery. Preliminary data indicate a re-

"serve of more than 25 million ‘tons of ote. The only hole assayed

so far represents over 600 fee?-of ore, indicating a true ore thickness
of nearly:400 feet. The hole is described as follows:

“Overburden is 24 feet. The initial core recovered showed -

1 per cent copper over 24 feet. This was followed by a heavy .
-~ schalcopyrite section of 82 feet, which assayed 7 per cent copper,
, 97 per,[sic] zinc, and 2.4 ounces of silver. An additional 20
feet of massive-sulphide assayed 12 per cent zinc. Disseminated
.Sphalerite occurred through the fellowing 44 feet of rock and
this section assayed hearly 5 per cent zine. A silver-rich zone of
fect followed, assaying 0.8 per cent coppers 13 per cent zinc,
d 10.5 ounces of silver. An additional 16 feet assayed 4 per

t zinc and over 5 ounces of silver. sits

“The following 100 feet was zinc-rich and assayed 0.33 per
cent copper, 14.3 per cent zinc and 4’ounces of silver. A 106 foot _
section of core assaying 8 per cent zinc and 7.2 ounces of silver -

followed 36 feet of massive pyrite, assaying 3.4 per cent zinc.

and 4 ounces of silver. A graphitic zone for the following 86 « -°

. [footnote continued on next page]

ee

~ -

Appendix —Opinion of the Court-of Appeals -

Reynolds, Mitchell and the Stouts testified that they -
sold their TGS k after hearing of the April 12 release ~
but before becoming aware of the- April 16-release. - Soine- -
time after the first release was: published, Reynolds’ “
in Salt Lake informed him as to its general content. |
April 16, the roker relayed rumors that TGS had made
Ui strike but in the broker’s jiidgment this was mere prop-
aganda. Reynolds. then testified that he decided ‘‘to get
out. while the getting was good,’’ whereupon he sold jis
. 500 shares. Later that afternoon he learned of the favor-

[footnote continued from pr ding g page]: a .

feet contained approximately 4 per cent zinc and 2 ounces of
silver. “Tlie final 20 feet assaved 823 per cent zine and-2 ounces -
of silver. ‘The overall interval of mineralization which could
be mined in an open pit operation averaged 1.18 per cent copper,
8.1 per cent zinc, and 3.8 ounces of silver over a core Igngth of
602 feet. The true width of the overall mineral zone is approxi-

* mately 400 feet.

“Visual examination ef cores from the other holes indicates
comparable grade and continuity of ore. . é

‘. “The ore body is at shallow depth, havi ing only some 20 feet of .
overburden. _ This means that it can easily be mined initially by the
open pit method.

“This discovery is in the northeast part of iad Towttship, an
is about ten miles north of the Timmins airport.

“Our land position,is favorable. Texas Gulf holds the mineral
rights in 70 per cent of Kidd Tow ie and has substantjaf acreage ©
ini*the ad jacent-townships. saat .

“TGS has been exploring in the Tineninis area for some. six
years, using its own geophysical methods, followed by-core drilling.
* Many prospects were drilled before this strike.

“TGS is actiyely continuing in the area, and in addition to this
discovery is presently drilling on anothef prospect in the same town-
ship. We are continuing our exploration and re proud of our,
small but exceptionally competent exploration staff.

“We are continuing to drill this structure as systematically and
rapidly as — deternine its limits. We hope to have more
information concetning this important discovery at the time of our
stockholders’ vases on April .23 in Heuston, Texas.”

-
-._-

a)

/ | 57a

7 Appendix —Opinion of the Court of Appeals -

able TGS report. He testified that had he known. of the |

-K-55-1 core results he would have doubled his holdings.

Mitchell visited his broker on the afternoon of the six-
teenth, at which time he was referred to the April 12 re-
lease. He concluded that the stock would not sustain j
current rise and gave instructions to sell 400. sh shor
against the box. Then, realizing he had failéd to dispos
of 20 shares; he delivered them on the seventeenth wit

similar sell instructions. According to his tesfimony, he

had no knowledge of the April 16 release when he sold.

After hearing about the April 12 release and that the TGS-.
Timmins discovery was overrated, the Stouts gave orders ~

to sell their 1,000 shares on April 21 |
This controversy was tried to the court without a jury.
“On the basis of the testimony-and exhibits produced at that

trial, the district court made -fiwffings of fact and conclu- : =
sions of law. To. the ; Si that appellants’ arguments

rest upon a relitigation a} eassesgsment of factual matters,
we will defer to the trial court unless we are satisfied:that
they were clearly erroneous... Rule 52 F.R.Civ.P., 28 U.S.C.
Fireman’s-Fund Ins. Co. v. S.E.K.° Construction Co., Inc.,
— F.2d —~— (10th Cir. 1970); Butler Paper Co. v. Ma-
page Printing Co., 424 F.2d 247 (10th Cir. 1970);

-

' Knauff v. Utah Construction and Min. Co., 408 F.2d % ws

* (10th Cir.-1969). . .
The trial court found that the press release, April 12
was false, misleading, deceptive and fraudfigft with re-
spect to material matters disclosed by the company ‘f drill-
ing efforts; that the authors knew of the presence pf ore-

. grade copper and zine in major proportions; that the mag-

nitude of the discovery was‘either misstated or concealed;

and that’ TGS and Fogarty knew the press release state-_

ments were incorrect and misleading, and knew o¢ should’
have known that’ the statements would be relied upon by
shareholders. After finding that each appellee had relied
on the April 12 release in selling his TGS stock, the court

$

ot

PO NAGI BS ee I

Day tte VR He * ER ep Se fg

| Appendix =Opinio of the-Court of Appeds

vival daniages hiatal on the j average of the highest daily ey
per share selling. price between April 16, 1964, and May 7
13, 1964, twenty adie days following the last. press: re- *
lease. ;

“Rule 10b-5 is plain, concise and unambigious: It ate.

_ vides as follows: ‘

It shall be unlawful for any person, directly or indi-

+ rectly, }y the use of : amy means or instrumentality of

interstate commerce, or of tlie mails or of any facility
of any national ‘securities’ exchayge,

(1) To employ any device, scheme, or artifice to de-
- fraud, _

(2) To make any untrue statement of a material fatt
or to omit to state a-material fact necessary in -
order to make the statements made, in the light
of the circumstances under which they were
made, npt misleading, or . os

(3) To engave in any act, practice, or course of busi-.
; ness whfch operates or would operate as a fraud
or deceyt pon any person, ~~, *

=

in ‘connection with the purchase or.sale - any security.
‘Neither Rule 10b-5 nor Seetion 10(b) in ‘terms grants
a private ‘right of action for the -nonfedsance or ,malfea-
saimes denoted in their language. But’ this is of miniscule
significance in this litigation, presumably’ because such”
right has now. been recognized in all the. federal circuits

which have had ‘occasion to-consider the issue? —.*
. . . .

7. Bank of America National Trust and Savings. Association v.
Douglas, 105 F.2d 100 (D.C.Cir. 1939) ; Rogen v. Hlikon Corp., 361
F.2d° 260 (1st Cir. 1966); Securtties and Exchange ~Commission -v.
Texas Gulf Sulphur Co., 401 F. 2d, 833 (2nd Cir.-1968) ; McClure v.
Borne Chemical Rosie 292 F:2d 824 (3rd Cir. 1961); Rekant v.

. [footnote continued on next page]

A . . ° * -

a provision ofa criminal statute designed to

. "50a. : a ee . 4 ee

-

— —Opinion of the Court of Appeats.

‘From. its origin, the private right of veaipwbes: has been
based on the general principle of tort law that violation of

ticular type of harm can give rise to a civil Tr
_don v. National Gypsum Co., 69 F.Supp. 512 (E.D.Pa. 1946).
In civil actions instituted on the basis of 10b-5 violations, —
.the keynote of which is fraud, the full panoply“of common »

law fraud elements—misrepresentation or nondisclosure, _

materiality, scienter, intent to defraud, reliance and causa-

. tion—have crept in and played. varying roles. of signifi- -

eance. However, a number of these elements have dimin-.
ished in importance in private actions, and we have stated
in Stevens v. Vowell, 343 F.2d 374,.379 (10th Cir. 1965),

‘that ‘‘[i]t is not necessary to allege or prove common law
. fraud to make out’a case under the statute and-rule. It is
only necessary to prove one of the prohibited’ actions such

as, the material misstatement of fact or the omission to
state a matgrial fact.’’ Notwithstanding, appellantS urge

that appellees have failed to establish the presence of most

af the common law fraud. ingredients, i.e., misrepresenta-°
tion or nondisclosure’ of material facts, ecienter, intent to .
defraud, reliance, and’some semblance of privity. A full

| = measure of our attention will be- devoted to each of these

constituent parts: /
The misleading, misrepresented or untruthful character

of the release may appear from the nature & the statement

considered alone, or, when the facts are’ ully disclosed,

Tfootnote continued from pre ceding page] |

Desser, 425 F.2d 872 (5th Cir.-1970); Texas Continental Life Ins.
Co. v. Dunne, 307 F.2d 242 (6th Cir: 1962) ; Jordan Building Corp.
v. Doyle, O’Connor & Co., 401 F.2d 47 (7th Cir. 1968) ; City Na-
tional Bank of Forffi Smith, Ark. v. Vanderboom, 422 F.2d 221
(8th Cir. 1970); Ellis v. Carter, ‘291 F.2d' 270 (9th Cir. 1961) ;

Gilbert v. Nixon, 429 F.2d 348 (10tl: Cir. 1970); and impliedly in

J.I. Case Co. v. Borak, 377 U.S. 426, 84 S. Ct1555, 12 L.Ed.2d 423: }

(1964) and Surowitz v. Hilton Hotels Corp., 383,U.S. 363 (1966).

Appendia —opinion. ’ the Court of Appeals

from the half truths, omissions or absence of full candor.

_ concealed therein.. See Gilbert. v: Nixon, 429 BF. 2d 348, 356s
(10th Cir. 1970) ; “Meisel v. North Jersey Trust Company,
\218 F.Supp. 274 (S.D.N.Y. 1963); Cochran-v. Channing
‘Corporation, 211 F.Supp. -239 (S.D.N.Y. 1962), Misrepre-

sented or omitted factsypecome material, hence actionable.
under 10b-5, when, considering the complaining parties as
reasonable investors, the disclosure of tlie undisclosed facts
or candid revelation of misleading facts would affect their
trading judgment. See Gilbert ¥. Nixon, supra; S.E.C. v:

a

_ Texas Gulf Sulphur Company, 401 F.2d 833, 849 (2nd Cir, —*
- 1968),-cert. den’d sub nom. Coates & Kline v. S.E.C., 394 | :
_ “TES. 976 (1969) ; Rogen’y. Ilikon’ Corporation, 361 F. 2d 260, ;
266 (st. Cir. 1966); List v. Fashion Park, Inc. "340 F.2d - §

. 457, 462 ‘(2nd Cir. 1965), cert..den’d sub nom. List v. Ler- a

- ner, 382 U.S. 811 (1965). The implicdjgyrariables to be :

_weighed in a materiality ‘analysis are the magnitude and
probability of the occurrence of the event, set agaipst the
size and total activity of the subject company.

The trial court foundthe April 12 release ‘inaccurate, .
misleading and deceptive with respect to mategial matters. ”’

" Reynolds v. Texas Gulf Sulphur Co., 309 F.Supp. 548, 559

_ (D.Utah:1970). ‘We agree upon the followi ing recitation of
‘facts found in the- record. , * °

: To put the chronicle of ev ents in slain e, iit must
be remembered that from the drilling of K-55-1 in late 1963,
_no serious drilling activity had transpired until March 31,

- 1964. On the basis: of the core analysis then availab
them, the-corporate leaders committed. themselves fo sed
erecy regarding the ‘‘prospect”’ until the adjacent pr erty
could be acquired. Qnce subsfantial holdings in comiguous »
realty was accomplished, drilling activity again came to

’ life with renewed vigor. As of April 10s three drilling rigs
were operating, with another to begin drilling on April 12, .

in an obvious effort to ascertain the dimensions of the min-

ee ea

eda tes —Opinion of ihe Court of Appeals

eral body. ‘Baily reports on drilling progress continuously °°

alteged the méasurements of the body, but the mineraliza-
tion content continued to retain the same characteristics as
the core from K-55-1. The data available to TGS at the

time of the first press release was ample to have accorded -

with a more complete) tlereby favorable, statement. - The
representation that “prelimitiary indications [are] that .
more drilling would be required for.proper evaluation of
this prospect’’ was not a statement candidly disclosing the
' available knowledge of TGS. \ Although the full magnitude
of the ore body could not be: pre isely determined, the avail-
able information allowéd more than a marginal possibility
that a commercial ‘‘mine”’ existed.
The contested press release was issued during the after- .

noon of Sundéiy,:April 12, and purported to be based on Ye

. ‘‘work done to date’’ and: “
‘

then knew it.. The full magnitude may yet have -been ie

TGS was in a position to unverl the then known ‘dimen- -

with.the approval of TGS.’ The agreement was that Ack- .

__. eee

63a" Die ere
. oT . , 8 z 4 ©
Appendix “Opinion wof the Court of Appeals,

Be ae ee a
titans: Just as the rial court, - iieligve’ this a oe

_the finding that TGS knew'a great deal more .than it told

on April 12 and that by concealing, omitting or misrepre- os,

‘senting these facts they violated Rule 10b-5. .
Even if it, is for the moment assumed that some rotation

. had been made that the information was not current, the ~ ot

release still was false, misleading and © deceptive. The

rumors were of. a. ‘substantial copper discovery.’’ In -
effect, TGS answered without. qualification that these
‘rumors weré ‘‘without factual basis.2? Then they pro: . -

ceeded to speak of niost. areas drilled as revealing ‘‘either

9 ' barren pyrite. or graphite without value? a fey have re-.
sulted .in discoveries of small. or. ‘marginal sulphide ‘ore”
-bodies.’’ It was then stated that more drilling would be -_

required for proper evaluation. Not a single note ef:en-
couragement ‘is contained tithe entire: April 12 release

regarding the Kidd 55-drilling. . The trial court found the

release painted a bleak and gloomy picture, and Wwe agree.

The substance of the release was a complete denial’ “of, the

rumors, without any attempt. to relate the favorable pros-

--pects as shown by the core 24sey of i" 55+1-and- the visual: ‘-
es 55-3, -4, -5-and -6. ‘Each. *
. core, in its ewn way, added. to/ the Ais etbe ss ‘of an ex-

éxaminations of | cores fron

ceptional ore discovery. We do’ not now ‘deffie wlicther

Ce TGS ‘would -have had -to make a statement on the 12th, ys

absent the: rumors. But with the described data av sited

it was- deceitful and f ‘raudulent to speak as TGS did.
7 By the testimony of appellees’ expert, on April 12, TGS
knew or could have conservatiy ely computed the reserves
of Kidd 55 at 7,390,000 tons of ore valued at, $183,740, 000.

And by the evening of: April 12, sufficient’ data was avail-

- able for TGS ‘to calculate tlie reserves at. 11,790,000 tons

-.. ‘vahied around $219,740, 000. When the trial court, eredit-
- ing this testimony over that tenderéd by appellants’ ex-—

pert, put those figures alongside the computation made in

Fe

. ‘
LR

\ ® - oes «gel, o » e~ «

=X - .
F , re —Opinion of the Court of Appeals

_ tne Nartherri Miner based on Aptil 14 data indicating in
excess of W,000,000 tons, its findling.ax to indeeuracy and
decepgion ary well substantiated and. thus sustai

- Appellanta seek to diminixh thé credibility Bf a ‘
expert, Dr. Chfistiansen, by pointing to his method of exal-*

° ae the reserves, by urging thal his conclusions were

ae on post-April 10 drilling information and took inte

- account the April 16 .release, dnd it is churged that con-

"© temporancous remarks, made by the judge during trial

served to diseredi{ Dr. Christiansen’s éaleulations. Ad- -
’ dressing the last allegation first, the trial judge ultimately

viewed Dr. Christiansen’ testimony as credible amd not- *

- - withstanding the contrary trial colloquy, we are bound by
. that unless there was clear error. Secor, the method em-

'. ployéd by appellees’ expert did not deviate from profes —

sfnal norms and the proof of that ix unerringly highlighted
by: the content of the April 16 release. Simply becanse one -
expert is wilting to compute ore reserves upon given data
where anather_refuses, ‘does not destroy the credibility of
the ‘first nor improve the rajabikity of the latter. Dr.

Christiansen carefully progressed througiy the daily series

of test epres, logs, ete, and upen ‘the then available data,
computed the reserves on the basis of each day's drilling.
“We can find no error in trusting these compatatiogs.

x These facts also provide, ample foundatian for the trial

* ++ court's finding of materiality.- K-55-1 had -been assayed’

and was kno€n to contain minerals of extraordinary qual-

"ity. The cores from K-55-3 and K-54 were vi ap- ~

prafsed.to be of the fame high quality, and the preliminary
results of K-55-5, -6 and -7 expanded the limits of the ore
. body to commercially minable proportions. Additignally,

- + ‘the ore was near the strface to facilitate nore economical

2

strip mining. Even con\dering the size of TGS and its
'. level of operations in international mineral exploration
and development, the known size an4.quality of the ore

~~

- Appendix —Opinion of the Court é Appesle
body was material information? that is, the trading judg-
ment of reasontble investors would not have been left.un-

_ touched upon receipt of such information. The trial cou

“Was unerringly correct.

TGS seeks refuge in the language of the New York _

" Stock Exchange Company Manyal which provides that in

the face of rumors without factual basis og rumors which
eciie cae ee

~ nial isthe recommended procedifre.”

\_It would be an unwarranteg contortion of this rule ta
etfold ‘TGS within its protection. First, because of ghe
f ore set forth, it cannot be said that the rumors
had yo basix in fact. Second, an S.E.C. staéement; relied
upon Gy. PGS support their proposition, is contrary to
the facts.of this cise. Directing its attentiog to- rs
circulating about the Alaskan North Slope-AAl j

* tivities,-the Commission-has warned investors against those

rumors because of thé\jntricacies and uncertainties of. oil
productiongon the North Slope. The S.E.C. has cautioned
the oil-coripanies “to weigh carefully -the conclusions and

7

- interpretations of fnformation they may use in stafements

released to the public." TGS has seized onte this. lan-
guage ax a characterization of the action they took. But
the S-E.C. continued: ‘While the absence of proved re-

; any statements which are made should be appro-
jately- qualified to indicate the limitati the sig-

Appendix —Opinion of thé Couft of Appeals

. The duty evolving upon a company facing these circum-

stances is to speak truthfully, accurately and with total.

candor as to the, material faets. That is not too much to

ask of any company with the interest of its: shareholders ©

central to its commentary. It is what the S.E.C. demands,
what, the law requires, and what every stockholder is enti-

_tled to.- Sunray DX Oil Company v. Helmerich & Payne, -

Inc., 398 F.2d 447 (10th Cir.- 1968), does not forbid this

reasoning. ln the context of the facts there present, the

court felt that. a detailed statement would not add to the
informed status of investors; but would mislead them due

to the nuanc es of technical terms used in div ulging further -~

* information. ‘The problems, gxtant in that off-shore. drill-
‘ing case are not present in the instant ‘controversy.

’ + Itis said thet. if the courts require factual data in state-
- ments such.as tuat originaHy framed by. TGS; issuance of
statements will falk out of favor and use. ‘/Thetonjecture
is that by requiring a.complete statement of material facts,

corporations will cease to issue them and the Act will be.

frustrated in its attempt to keep_stockholders informed of
material facts. We view this speculation untenable, for the
duty to-disclose facts when they become material has not

been aKered by this decision. Simply stated, when tlfe ma- -

' terial information is available and ripe for publication, the
difficulties inherent in formulating a release cannot over-
- bear thf: atenracy of* the statements -contained therein.
Nor. is it reasonable to conclude that the detail of a full
‘release will preelude its publication i in these circumstances.

Indeed, the thoroughness of. the — = release anes -

as ev idence to the contrary. >
“Another argument of appellants is : that as, a predicate

to a 10b-5 action, the corporation, its directors or other |

‘*insiders”’ must be trading in the market." At minimum,

10. Although considerable trading had been done i in the market
_ by corporate “insiders” and “tippees”’, it was stipulated yt trial that
there was no illegal trading by the instant parties at or afftr the time
of oe April 12 release. e 2 xs

.

«
* 2 ’ “
itn ee ee robes
x

oe

Se ee oan eee

\

manner reasonably “ealeulated to influence the investing
E

a.
«Vea

| Appendix * —Onpinion of the Court of Appeals .

it is urgedi that a market purpose to benefit the alleged
wrongdoer must ‘he proven before recovery can be per-
mitted. The attempt is to cireumvent the language in SEC
v. Texas Gulf Sulphur Company, 402 F.2d at 862: “Rule
10b-5 is violated whenever assertions’ are made * * * in a

publie, e.g., by means of the financial ‘media * * * if such
assertions are false or misleading or- are so incomplete as
to mislead irrespective ‘of whether the issuance of the re-.
lease was motivated by corporate’ afficiats for ulterior pur-

~poses. Tt seems clear, however, that: if corporate manage-

‘ment demonstrates that it wag diligent in ascertaining that
the information it published-was the whole trath and that -
such diligently obtained information Was dissemiziated in
good faith, Rule 10b-5 wouldot have been violated.”

In its origip, 10b-5 was intended only te give sellers
the same prowtion extended to buyers by other provisions
of the Act, and did not contemplate protection -of stock:
holders against a, breach of fiduciary duty by corporate
insiders. Within a few years, however, the federal courts
ceased to look upon the Rule in the narrow context of seller

protection and began ‘to see in it a greater purpose, i.e, -

equalization of bargaining position of the parties on both.
sides. of a transaction. -A_ Bromberg, Securities Law: |
Fraud—S.E.C. Rule 10b-5, §3.2 - (200), (300),. pp. 65-66
(1969) [hereiriafter Bromberg]. But even with this éx- |

panded visiaqn, theecourts generally required, -at minimum, .—

“‘{aJ semblance of privity hetween- the vendor arid pur-°
chaser of the seeurity in connection with which the*im-
proper act, practiee. or course of ‘business was invoked.
* = * Joseph v. Farnsworth Radio & Television Corp.,
99 F.Supp. 701, 406 (&.D.N.¥. 1951). |

_ The Second Circuit in the Texas Gulf Sulphur case ex-
panded this rationale to include protection for open market —
investors, including speculators, when misled by nontrad-

ee

‘it could be shown that the iss
motivated by a plan to benefit the corporation or a es

. -
. * a *

Appendix _—Opinion of the Court of Appeals

* ing insiders. _ After reviewing Congressional history, the

court said: ‘‘Congress when it used the phrase ‘in connec-
tion with the purchase or sale of any security* intended
only that the device employed; whatever it might be, -be of
a sort that would cause reasonable mvestors to. rely
thereon, and, in connection therewith, so relying, cause
them to purchase or sell a. corporation’s securities. * * * We

"~ -do‘not believe that Congress intended that the proserip-
- tions of ‘the Act would not be violdted unless the nmkers .

of 4 misleading statement a so artic#pated in pertinent
securities transactions in connec ion therewith, or unless
e of the statement was

at the expense of a duped investing public.” S.£.C.
Texas Gulf Sulphur Company, 401 F.2d at 860. --TGS in-

vites this cirenit to either part company with the Sécond |

Circuit: rationdle or distinguish it on the basis that it must

-be. confined te S.E.C. enforcement actions.

The Second Ci ircuit has laid to rest the argument that
tlie new ‘‘connection”’ requirement de narrowly applied to
S.EC. enforcement actiotis. Followi ing the TGS suit was
Hiet v..W ietzen, 402 F.2d 909 (2nd Cir. 1968), a private
action, Wherein the TGS *‘eonnection’? rule was applied.
Wg. also decline the invitation to ignore the forward look-

ing view of the Second Cireuit regarding the ‘‘connection.” .

requirement. “ Perhaps the first step is to realize that the

common law requitement of privity has all. but vanished

from 10b-5 proceedings" while thé distinguishable **eon-

11. Hiet v. Wietzen, 402 F.2d 909 (2nd Cir. 1968) : Texas
Continental Life Ins. Co. v. Dunne, 307 F.2d 242 (6th Cir. 1962) ;

Rippey v. Denver U. Sy National Bank, 260 F.Supp : 704 (D. Col:
1966) ; Miller-v. Bargain City, U.S.A., Ine, 229 F.Su op 33 (E.D.Pa..
filed. Jan. 14,.

1964) ; Freed v. Szabo Food Service, Inc. TN:D.Il
1964) ; Bromberg, ¥8.5 (511) at 207; III Loss, Securities Regula-

">. tions: Chap. 11C(¢) at 1767-71 and VI Loss, Ghap. LIC at 3890-97.

;
,
ee

.
————

a .
69a

Appendir —Opinion of the Court of Appeals | a

* . acy

* nection. element is retainedf* In its development, the cases

have deemed the-‘‘connection”’ requirement fulfilled if the
company has uttered false or mislead@jrig statements. con-
cerning: the seeuritjes in question, previded the complain-
ants have relied on -the misrepresented facts. "The result
which we here. support is that ‘insider trading is not a
requisite for 10b-5 violation by misrepresentation. As
appropriately stated by the Second Circuit, ‘‘a corpora-

-tion’s misleading material statenient may injure an in-

vestor irrespective of whether the corperatior itself, or

od
those indiv iduals managing its are contemporaneously buy-
-Ing or selling the stock ofthe corp

ation.”? S.EXC. v.
Texas Gulf Sulphur € ompany; 481 F.2d at S61. e.trial
court had little difficulty finding fram the testimony .of
Fogarty and ther corporate officers thatthe April 12 state-
ment was made in a manner ‘reasonably calcitated to influ-

ence the investing public, We concur. s Pe

. But even if the release was made in connection w ith
sale of thesé securities, appellants farther urge that the

overwhelining weight of authority holds that- scienter in

/
some form is Tequired ‘ina private 10b-5 damage’ action.

- . See VI Loss, Ch. 11€ at 3883-90. -In the Second: Circuit, at

least,. that description appears to be cortect. :But while

some de ‘gree of scienter is required, it does ‘not ‘equate with

the intent-to ‘defraud ;required | ma confnon law*fraud ac-

-” tion. +Globys: v- Law Research Servi ice, Ine. , 18 F.2d 1276 °

“°1970), and the Ninth Circuit, Ellis v. Carter, 291 F.2d 270.

(2nd Cir.. 1969) : iliet v. Wietzen, dujira; Astor v. ‘Texas
Gulf Sulphur-C ompany, 306 F, Sie 1333 (S.D.N.Y. 1969)...”
C ontrariwise, in the Eighth Circuit, City. National Bank of
Fort. Smith, Ark. v. Vanderboom, 422 F.2d 221 (8th Cir.

(9th Cir. 1961), the rule is that scienter is not required to’
maintain.a private 10b%5 damage action. We have dealt

12. See Rippey v. Denver U.S - National Bank, supra ; ‘Stock- ~

“+ well v. Reynolds & Co., 252 F Sapp. .215 (S. D. N. Y. 1965); Miller” -

v. pico: City, U.S. as Inc., =

: oe 4 a

4a.

70a -

-%

. Appendix eas of the C om of ree als

Steveris v. Vowell, 348 F.2d 374 (10th Cir. 1965). But in Gil-

considered the identical issue in a case.involving Section

with the j issue ees stenifiec: intly different. iicremt inces in

bert v.- Nixon, 429 F.2d 348, 357 (10th ‘Cir. 1970), we

12(2), and Rule 10b-d. ‘The rule there articulated is ap-~

plicable here. ‘‘Qne i is not. to be he ld liable * *-* because

ef his misleading inisrepresentation or omission of ma-
‘terial fact, the truth of the matter being unknown ts the
purchaser, if the party responsible for the misreyiresenta-
‘ tion or omission sustains the burden of proving that he did
-not know, and-in the exercise of reasoriable care could
not have known that it was a misrepresentation or omis-.

sion.’ Ri

Two titnes-duting liis opinion. the trial indie recited:
1: [T]he record here discloses that the press release assed
by ‘defendants was misleading, interifionally deceptive, in-.
accurate and knowingly deficient in material facts.’? Reyn-

‘olds v. Texas Gulf Sulphur Company, 309 F.Supp. at 562,

563-64. ‘onfronted with the abundance of evidence in the
record, we cannot conclude that TGS sustained its burden
of proving that it did not know of the misrepresentation,
nor was it demonstrated that with dite diligence TGS could
not have known of the fayltiness of the stat@ment.. -*

The complainants have met the reliance. requirement -if:

-_ ae 2? ‘ “ > ar.
‘the misrepresentation 1s a substantial factor’ in-deter-
mining the course’of conduct which xesults in [the inves-
tors’| Ipss.? List v. Fashién Park, Inc., 340 F.2d 457, 462

(2nd Cir. 1965); VI Loss, Che 11C at 3876-83. . ‘Appellants 5,
‘argument on this point is two-fold: Fixst, that the trial.

court’s findings that eacir plaintiff-appellee relied. on the
April 12 release was clearly erroneous; and, second, that as
_a matter of law, onee the ‘April 16 release .was received
“by the brokerage houses ever. the Merrill Lynch and, Dow-
Jones wird services, curative information Ww as available

which should have corrected any erroneous notions. in the: -

minds of reasonable investors as to the Timmins project.

ie

*
wares d es wie eR A ge re RS RY oe eT a

Tila
Appendix =

Ft PRM OT GEES, TRENT, TR AOL PENT
. ot
=

: Appendix —Opinion of the Court of Appeals ~

which seems more reasonable in these circumstances, or

‘the seventeen additional trading days imposed:by. the trial ©

court (through Wednesday, May 13) is irrelevant to the
award. For in either event, the highest value was achieved
on, Wednesday, April 29 bis $59) prior to the expiration

-of either time limit. < °
The averaging aspect is deleted to conform with whatis —

considered the focal purpose: to award the reasonable in-
vestor an amount which offsets any loss he suffered by a
deceitfully induced sale. To award an average price-would
not fully compensate him for a number of the days within
the reasonable period following the last release. -While this

_- is an admitted compromise between the restitution rule and
_ the actual damage approach‘as taken by TGS, it seems a’

fair’ way to reinstate stockholders’ who were wrongfully
deprived of their gain because of the deceitful release and,
at the same time, deny recovery to those who suffered only
by-their own lack of due diligence. In selecting the highest
daily price the advantage works, te a greater degree,
against TGS. But where, as here, the injury is suffered by ‘
an act making difficult the exact computation of damages, .
the wrongdoer is not heard to complain.- For “‘it would
be a perversion of fundamental principles of justice to deny

all relief to the injured person, and thereby relieve the

wrongdoer from making any amerid for his acts.”*. Story
Parchment Co. v. Patterson Paper Co., 282- U.S. 555, 563

- (1981).

In their cross- appeal, Reynolds and Mitchell also argue
in fayor of awarding attorneys’ fees. We are cited to our
decisions in Esplin v. Hirshi, 402 F.2d 94 (10th Cir. 1968),

cert. den’d 394 U.S. 928 (1969), and Estate Counseling

Service, Inc. v. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner and Smith, .
303°F.2d 527 (10th Cir. 1962): It is contended*that both

decisions stand for the propesition that the policy in the ~

federal courts is to award the costs of conducting the action

e “pe f
* “i ‘
°; a4 . a a

ae
Appendix | icin of the Court of Appeals

a securities cases. Although’ in both cases we allowed -
‘ — reeovery of ‘‘other outlay legitimately attributable to the -
defendant’s fraudulent conduct,’”’ it was npt intended to
.inelude the costs of bringing the action. This is seen in
the Estate Counseling Service case where a defrauded.
buyer brought the appeal but’ was not awarded attorney ~
‘fees as ‘‘other outlay legitimately. attributable to the de- ©
‘ fendant’s fraudulent conduct.’? Attorneys’ fees are denied.
The damages awarded to Reynolds amount to $12,687.50;
aes, Mitchell’s damages are fixed at $7,600.00. The decisions by
. __...,the-trial court that both appellees are to receive interest _
computed at six’per cent per agnum from the time of sale
until the date ofthe trial court’s judgment, and that when
recovery is gained from. TGS, appellees’ claims against
‘Fogarty will be deemed paid, satisfied and ‘discharged, are
not disturbed.
\ Fogarty- asserts on. his. own behalf that the trial court re
* lacked personal: jfrisdiction over him. Section 27 of the
; Securities Exchange Act of 1934, 15 U.S. C. §78aa, provides -

’ that ‘‘[t}he district courts of the United States * * * shall ~
have exclusive jurisdiction of violations of this chapter or
the rules and regulations thereunder, and of all suits in

equity and actions at law brought to enforce liability or
duty created by this chapter or the rules and regulations

; thereunder. * * *’’ The remainder of thatstatute provides -
| for service of process, allows for review of judgments and
decrees, and designates proper venue. The latter provision
relates back to the jurisdictional portion, and allows such
actions to be brought in any district where the defendant
is found or is an inhabitant or transacts business.
‘The brunt of Fogarty’s allegations is directed at venue
—not jurisdiction. His main claim is that he has never
teen an inhabitant of Utah, was not found in Utah, and’
* transacts no business in that state. That was the identical
"issue posed to this court in Texas Gulf Sulphur Company .
v. Ritter, 371 F.2d 145, 148-49 (10th Cir. 1967), wherein.

w

.
ie 2 i

79

| Appendix —Opinion of the Court of Appeals

we said: “venue as to ‘both defendants will lie in the Utah
District if any of the acts pr transactions complained of. .
took place in that district.’’. The acts and transactions com-. : .

plained of which have now been proved were ‘‘publication
of news releases and acts incident to the sale of the stock
referred to herein * * * the release of a false and fraudulent
press release, upon which he [Reynolds] relied after read-
ing the same in the Wall Street J ournal in Salt Lake City,

which newspaper had been transmitted to him through the

United States mails. In addition the plaintiff con

press release-came to Salt Lake City’on the Dow-Jones .

broad tape.”? Thus the issue has been decided a eiiee
Fogarty and is not now open to relitigation.
The only issue left to be decided is raised individually

by Reynolds and eoneerns whether Rule 23 F.R.Civ. P., 28

U.S.C., should be applied to afford relief to all persons who

-sold TGS stock between April 12 and April 16, 1964. A
‘number of independent inquiries are included in this argu-
, ment, e.g., may an appellate court correct a class” ruling»

after a decision on’ the merits; and may parallel class .ac-

tions be conducted in two jurisdictions? But ignoring all
_~ collateral i issues, as cross-appellant has invited us to do,

the only issue is whether the trial court pee exercised”
its discretionary powers.
Rule 23(a) recites four prerequisites toa class action.

Assuming, arguendo, that the elements of ( a): have been.
~met, it appears that the trial court was convinced that a

eles action in Utah would not conform to (b) (3) of Rule
23.. That subsection requf¥es, inter alia, that the class
action be “‘superior-to other available methods for the fair
and efficient adjudication of the controversy.’? The Rule
outlines four honexhaustive matters which are to be con-

the -interest of members of the class in individually coh-

_ sidered in deciding the superiority of a class action:.‘‘(A) -

trolling the prosecution or defense of separate actions ; |

a

.

——_

~ 80a.
Appendix —Opinion of the Court of Appeals

(BY the sitet and nature of any - litigation concerning the
controversy alréady commenced by or against members of _
the class; (C) the desirability or undesirability of concen- —
trating the litigation of the claims in the particular forum;
and (D) the difficulttes likely to be encountered in the man-
agement of 4 class action.’’ In‘an opinion reported.at 309
F-Supp. 566 (D.Utah: 1970), the.trial court denied the mo-
_tionfor a class action, nti. the ree on- Rule 23 (b)"
_-~(8)(B), (C) anid:(Q).
_- The trial judge” ‘aed: that as of October 22; 1969,
-ninety-four actions had been. brought against TGS aeik in- .
- dividual defendants; that in March,’1969, two actions in the
- Southern District of New York had-been allowed to-proceed —
-. as‘elass actions; that pursuant to that ruling, tedious and-
‘time. consuming discovery had taken ‘place; and that if the. .
_ various private suits were concentrated for trial in a ‘single
district, it t should be if the Southern District of New York.
pen Sa ey he stated: ‘‘The litigation in New York is
far advanced, far and away the bulk of the cases are there,
and the information necessarily to be obtained from the
brokerage offices is more readily and more conveniently
_ available in, New York City.’’ Reynolds v. Texas Gulf
Sulphur Company, 309 F.Supp. at 570.” Our conclusion i is
~ that the trial court has wisely exercised its discretion:
‘* Tn No. 280-70,’the judgment is affirmed in all respects ?
| except as to the untimely sale of the 20 shares and as to the ©
. issue of damages. | In No. 282-70, the judgment is affirmed —
in all respects except as to the issue of damages. Accord-
ingly, No. 280-70 is rerhanded with directions tojenter judg-
ment for Mitchell for $7,600.00; and No. 282- 70 is remanded .
with directions to enter judgment for “Reynolds for
$12,687.50. . In No. 284-70, the judgment is reversed: and~
the case is remanded with directions to enter judgment in:
favor of Texas Gulf Sulphur Company, et’ al. The CYOS8<\
a ee 283-70 and 285-70, are’ denied.

Sonerey corer aareet

8la
; ee \ 3 ‘
Judgment of the United States Court of . Appeals eae
os | : for the Tenth Circuit _ Sg ee ig
i — ~ . Maron ‘Term—Aren 26, 1971 a
Before Honorable David T. ane Chief Juilee; and — a is
_ Honorable Delmag C. Hill and Honorable Robert - . ———

—#H. MeWillinms, — — rs ie are oe.

[Sanz Tire] s

_ o

These consolidated « cases eame on to be ‘heard on the’ .
record on appeal from the United Statés District Court -
for the District pf Utah, and were argued by counsel. On ©
consideration whereof, it is ordered as follows: -
In case No. 280-70; the judgment of said. dintriet pon ee -
* is affirmed in all respects except’ as to the untimely sale of
. the 20 shares and as to. the issue ‘of damages.

In Case. No. 282-70, the judgment of the said district
court is affirmed in all respects except as) sd the issue of
damages. :

Accordingly, .i .in case No. 280-70. the cause is - remanded:
with directions to enter judgment for Mitchell for $7,600.00;
and in Case No. 282-70, the cause is remanded with dires- ‘.

‘tions. to enter judgment for Reynolds for $12,687.50.
In Case No. 284-70, the judgment of said district court
‘is’ reversed and the case is remanded with directions to enter”
- judgment in favor of Texas Gulf Sulphur Company, et al.

. The ae" in sep. 281- 70, _ 70 and 285-70, are
~ denied. : :

6:

| 7 /s/ isting K. Purmrrs
ae ee es Howarp K. PHruies, Clerk.

” gm . oan es ere ¢ —

_ Order of the United States Court. at Appeals.
is _for the Tenth Circuit on Petition for Rehearing.
es. - Beak -f .. Sur Tenx—Serrenaee 10, 1971

Res
‘

Before Honorable 1 David T. Lewis, Chief JJ udge, and 3
' Honorable Delmas C. Hill’‘and Honorable Robert | 7

~

, H. MeWilliams, Cireuit — % :
Fe : : ;
- Nos. 281-70 and ae
E Gorpon Rarsoune “el Waurer rn" pone
Cross-Appellants,

ies Guur Suiruur CoMPANY and Cuaizs F. Pianinie =
Cross-Appellees.

: Crose-Appellait Reynolds, has filed a Petition for Re-
hearing urging two points, neither of | which goes to the
/ merits of the case. First, he asks us to assess’ as costs in
_ the ease certain fees paid by him to expert witnesses. As

a general rule, such fees in excess of the statutory. allow-

- ance for fees, mileage and subsistence, are not taxable as.
_ costs. In some eases, courts, in the exercise of their gen-

eral equitable powers, have permitted such allowances in ~

‘ eases involving exceptional crrcumstances, and in those -

- eases the orders of allowance, were made prior io time the
witnesses testified. 6 Moore’s F.P. 1367. In this case,. the
trial judge declined after trial to make such an allowance.

6 AoaN ;

Lars

—~_ :

a ; Sh Sage ’ eo ap aes a,
__ Appendix —Order of the United States Court of Appeals’
We are unable to conclude that the trial judge abused his
‘equitable discretion in denying the allowance and affirm the . ,
trial judge in this respect. re a oe a ee ae:
'_* By the second point, the petition asks us to-supplement.
. OUF opinion to expressly state that our denial of a class ac-
tion for Reynolds does not’ preclude the possibility of other
persons in the alleged class from. bringing actions in any .
court having jurisdiction, either in their own. behagf or
~. under Bule 23.. We see no necessity for such.a supplement “.

e

. to our opinion and decline the request." gee Res as
_ Accordingly, the petition for rehearing is denied. — .

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385606_0303%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
