# Appendix — Baum v. United States

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385605_0278%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1970
- **Citation:** 400 U.S. 916

## Text

e

4 f. : } Ss
/ & ~ —
sj} UNITED S STATES DISTRICT COURT
/ MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
{JACKSONVILLE DIVISION
caer eae No: 68-1:C1v-J
.-.'.“ LEO F.-BAUM: ane: |
os at e ia te _ Plaintif’,
a 3 , :
| UNITED STATHS OF AMERICA,

Defendant and Third Party Plaintiff,

' "
% {

ae

\

JAC KSONVIL LE. SHIPY ARDS, INC,
, Third Party Defendant,

J UDGMEN Tr. ‘

In aecordance with ‘the Pr indings of F act and Conclu-_
sions of Law ente red j in the above entitled cause, if is
- |

Giotenn AND Apivpcen:

Judgment ‘IS entered in} favor of Defendant and —
ca ‘Party Plaintiff, United States’ of Ameriea, against.
- Plaintit, Leo F, sau, and this action is dismissed,

~

2. Judgment i Is entered. for etondart and Third Party
Plaintiff, United States of America, against Third Party |
‘Defend: ait, “Jacksonville Shipyards, Ine., in the amount of
attorneys’ fees expended in the defense of this cain.

» ENTeren at Jacksonville? Florida, this 19 day of June,
3 1969, - > . eae : o
ie 3 - Wn, A. McRag, Jr. Judge

_ Copies to counsel =

an he (Al)

AZ District Court Fiudiugs and Conclusions

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE: DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
JACKSONVILLE. DIVISION

No. GS-1-Ciy-]

a ecole Kh. BAUM,
: ) Plaintiff,

°

EXITED STATES OF AMERICA,
. Mt a : “Defendant and
Third Party Plaiutiff,

FAC KSOXY I. Lie SHED YARDS, INC.
; Third Party ‘Defeudaut,

.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW.

This is a civil action of admiralty jurisdiction tn which -
plaintiff Leo JF. Baum, (Banin) seek- damages for persomal
- injuries allegedly sustained on board defendant’s vessel,
the SS Care Sax Mantis on January 10, 1967. On the date
of the alleged injury the aforesaid vessel was undergoing °
reactivation overhaul at the premises. of third party de-
fondant, Jacksonville Shipyards, Ine. (. licksonville ‘). De-
fendamt, United. States of Ainerica (United pe lias
impleaded Jacksonville under Rule 1 Fed. R. . &. om
the theory that any liability of U nited States too cee was
occasioned by. Jacksonville’s breach of its warranty of
workmanlike aes

G. Sinke his mjuries are solely traceable to acts of
Jacksenvilly, Baum has failed ‘to prove a cause’ of: action
against U hited States and is not entitled to any, recovery

from United States herein. 5

. United States is’ entitled ‘so recover tra ae aed

ville tehiatahle attorney’s fees ¢ xpended in the defense of”

Baum’s claim. If the parties cannot agree to the amount
of the recoverable attorney's fees, further Proccemings will
be had-on thjs issue. | IS

.
.

8. Judgment will be silica in ie or of United’ States
against Baum dismissing the action herein, and against
Jacksonville in the amount of attorney’s fees expended in
- —the defense of this claim. . ,

‘Darel D this ord _ of Fune, 1969.

ze | Wo. A, McRar, Jr., Judge
Copies to counsel

District Court Order — Co ae aoe

~ UNI TED STATES DISTRICT COURT
: MIDDLE DISTRIC T OF FLORIDA.
. JACKSONVILLE DIVISION ;
i

—_———_

J “
id ,
e - .

. No. 68-1-Civ-J

+ . ‘
3 ' LEOF.BAUM, © + ~ pix
Be Plaintiff, ;
fs v.
*y . UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, *
; eee aor ee Sean * fe ndant yore

Third Party Plajntiti,

ee ime eee %

JACK SC IN VILLE SHIPYARDS, INC.,
~ Third Par ty Defendant,

ORDER. .

ORDERED: : y . be 8
‘ah the SS ¢ ‘APE Say Sie: which i Is a steam-screw vessel
owned by the defe nidant, United States of Amertea: (herein-
after the Government), and Which was unde rgoing a re-

‘ictivation overhaul in Jue ‘ksonville, Florida, pursuant to a
contract between the Goveynmeng and Jacksonville Ship-
yards, Ine. (hereinafter Jae ‘ksonville). The Governmenit

impleaded Jae ksonville under Rule 14(¢); Feder ‘al Rules of

Civil Procedure yresumably on the theory that the liability
>|

of the Government, if any, Was occasioned by Jacksonville’s

breach. of its warranty of workmanhike se rite: The Dis-

trict Court, Middle District of Florida, inade- Findings of

— Fact “and Conclusions of Law and ente red, judgment in

favor of the Government against the plaintiff dismissing

the action, and in favor of the Gove ‘rhment against Jick-

souville for attorney's fees expended in the defense. of this
claim, . | ey, ee

«Xs far as this appe: iL i Is concerned, we. need not de ter.
mine whether or not Jacksonville. has” standing to join in

this appeal under Rule. 14 (c), PLR. C. Ps as its assertion is

that we affirm the entire jidginent below, .w hich position is .
consonant with that of the Government. Neither its brief’
nor itS oral argument have raised. amy new issues or de-
fenses. ’/Phey only repeat additional factual cireumstances

‘going to the question ef whether, assuming a duty of care

owed by the Government to the plaintiff, there was ‘a breach
of that duty. T his, Is ani alternative: argument Which we’

need not reach to deeide this case, “Thus, ‘Tacksonville’s

presentations are of=no consequence,
The Government entered into a ‘*Master Lump Suit:
Repair Contraet’*! with Jacksonville. for the repair and

1. The pertinent part of which reads: ‘ “

ARTICLE 4 Workmanship and Inspection: ;

‘ (a) Unless otheawise specifically providett in the job order

all workm: ship, equipment. materials and articles, and all
~ operational praetices of the-Contractor used in the performance’

of the work, shall be the hest’ commerci lal marine practice and

-&

——-

‘

A10 a Comet of. !ppeals Opinion

>

reactivation of the | fovernment vessel, the SS Cave San ,
Martin, which hid bgen in the ‘moth-ball fleet ?? in the Hud-
son River. The vessel had been towed to Jacksonville’s
yards after the latter had been suceéssful in its bid for the
‘-eontract. In accordance. with paragraph (c) of Article 4
of the contract, one Springs, 2 marine inspector, was placed
on board the vessel, and he remained aboard during: the.
entire period of repair. Aside from the rights and duties
provided him in the contract (note 1), Springs’ duties wf re
approval and rejection of materials furnished. under the
“-terms of the contract; determination of necd for change or-
ders; certification of satistactory conpletion of work and
generally ensuring that Jacksonville'complied with the. con-

tract. at auinimum cost to the diovermnent. The vessel *.

. ° a Pr ie
was comptely drydocked at the time off the accident: and
did not have motive power of its owns The Government re-
tained title, but Jacksonville had complete custody~

i

shall be of a-suitable grade of their respective kinds. All work
; ‘performed by the Contractors shall comply with the requirements
of the American Bureau of Shipping, the Enited States Coast
Guard, and other regulatory bodies in accordance with the rules
of said regulatory bogies: . : gun? BA ae
4c) During the Contractor's’ performance théereyf, the work |
shall be subject to inspection and test by the Authorized rep-
resentative of the | Director, National. Shipping|° Authority at
> any and all times. and, placés, and any part of the: work: may
/ be rejected by said representative of the Authority if not as
specified, or because of -defctive: workmanship or materials.
Any portion of the’ work so rejected: shall f4rthwith be replaced
or corrected by the Contractors at its own cost and expenses:
(f) At the request of the authorized’ representative of
the: | Director, “National Shippiig| *\uthority the Contractor
\ shall place reasonable safegtiards , and .shall ‘put and‘ keep at
all time stfficient lights to’ prevent accidents. in spaces “and
areas in which the’ Contractor will bé& required to ‘perform or
has started work and to provide ile access aid egress to and
froth the vessel. " a i ae
> 2. The. Contract provided: ae
ARTICLE 5. Prydocking and Berthing .
(a) On entering and leaving .a’ yard, piet, drydock. or
marine’railway, the Contractor shall have charge of and be ‘re-

°

7 ’

-
-

. “ - : ‘

a

Coun ‘ice Ippeuls Opinion ate ML

.'* - /
/
ag he plaintiff was an enuiboyed of ‘iabendlie andwas

assigned by his supervisor to remove the valves of an evap-_
i . ° es
orator in tlic engine room under the ship’s deck. Already.

workiig in-that same area was: a cleanup crew which was

“engaged in removing’ debris from the engine room. The

alebris was placed into a, five- gallon paint Ducket, then

hoisted by means of a black and inthe to aanding some 15,
to 18 feet above plaiattitt. There was #estimony from the |
plaintiff and from workers on. the cles w-up crew ‘that jsuch |
use of paint buckets was ‘the usual’ way’, and that it was *
safe. ‘as. long as- the bucket was rot overloaded. ‘On this
occasion, the bucket w as not OV erloaded (it w as ‘‘only half
filled ’¢, weighing ten to” iw enty pounds, whereas when filled.

with paint, it Weiglis fifty pounds). It had been hoisted

‘about fifteen fret when the: handle pulled ott from. ene =
and the bucket fell-on plaintiff’s head causing ¢ injury.

_Plaintitt? Ss Sole contention Is that the Gover nment ane

Ff duiy to plaintiff to. OXCTCINC due care to provide a- rea- ;

sonably safe plaice to werk. Plaintiff does not contend that
this:duty is based on the Good’ Samaritan rile (i.e., that
by its affirmative acts, the Government, undertook: to pro-

vide safety measures for the protection of Jacksonville's
employees, which undertaking was relied upon by Jackson-
ville, and w hich was neghgentiy carr ied-out resulting in in-

jury. .Roberson vé United States, 9 Cir, 1967, 382 F.2d
714). Nor does the Plaintiff rely.on the warranty ef sea
worthiness, recognizing | that there is no’ such Warranty

- where .the Vessel Is withdrawn from ‘navigation,: is in. dry
dock for repair, is Without a crew and motive powe epg Is
a ,
_. wiequipped for sailing: W esta, United States, 361 BS
~118 (1959) ; Moye v. New Orle ans Barge Lines, Tne. 5 Cir,

sponsible for-the vessel within the limitations of "this contract from

the. time the Contractor's lines are secured to the - vessel, until
“such time as all. of the Contractor’ s lines are cast off.”

.

XS Ba Na pt tee

wd

ae 3- 3 i . Courtof Appeals Opinion
/ , “ee

1968, age 2d Zs, cert. den. 395 U, Ss. O13} sea reli. den.

305 UL 8.987 (1969), - .
I a the. pl: intitt argues that the duty Is derived

from/the combination of two faye tors: €1) the Govermment’S

ownership of the vessel and (2)° the obligations created

under the provisions in the contract (see note 1). The Dis-.

trict Court rejected this contention, citing Robersou, supra,

Yor the Proposition that-* tthe tights of an employee of jan

/indepe nde Mt contractor with respect to the’ United States

are not expanded by rights of inspection afforded to the

United States Dy provisions in the contract between the
United States and the Injured. party's employer’ ~~ eRe

plaintiff — that Roberson is not applicable to the
ease at bar and thiit the sia iri hy the Distriet

Court was ae versible error,

The plaintiff is correct in his assertion th: at the Rober
Son dycision does not squarely answer the questions pre-

sente «di m the ease at bar, The Roberson case held that the:

Gowernment world not he subject to tlhe Good Samaritan
Yule under the partic ‘ular facts in that ease, The Good Sa-
Yuanitan rube is.a rounds for i Iiposing a duty on the-Gov-

sernment distinet from: the grounds upon which the plaintiff ae

here. relies, Hlowever, there are Inany. other cases, some

Cited.in Roberson, W hich do notre ‘ly on the Good Samaritan

rule, and which hold that the Government's retention of
the right to inspect. the. work under construction to see that
the provisions ‘of the éontract are carried ‘out is not suffi:
S¢ient, in itself, to impose a cuty on the ¢ Government, the
‘breach of which will give rise to liability to injured eniploy-
“ees of the contractor, Cated States v. Page, 10 Cir, 1965,

.

350 F.2d 28; Kiek . Cnited States, 9 Cir, 1959, 2706F, 2a

110; Filipek v. Moore-McCoymack, Lic., 2 Cir. P1958, 258 F.

wl. aks Gallagher v, United States, 2 Cir, 1953. 20608. od

177. |See alsa Hodge v. United States, M. D. Gia., 1969,

Court of Appeals Opinion « A1S

I’. Supp. [ No. 22358, Feb. 1969], aff'd -— F. gd —
The District Court ’s statement merely reite Hrates this Ox-
tablished rule, which -is repeated ina diffe ‘rent context i
Roberson, We owas not reversible error.

The real question posed by the plaintiff is under what

cirecumstanees’ will the Gove rnment be found. to have a duty

toward employe’ s of tndependent. contractors working un-
der government coyitracts. Plaintiff contends that .the cir-
cumstances here give rise to the imposition of such a duty.
We do not agree. ‘In reaching this conclusion, the follow-

ing ‘relevant factors are considered, seriatime: what. law is

applicable; the re lationship between the Parties ; the ternis
of the contract: the acts of the -parties’ regardless of the
contract; who had control of the vessel, the work area, and
the safety program; the nature-of the risk involved; and |
When was the risk created. ; 3 ay
While this action is brought under the Suits in Ad-

“‘niralty Act, supra, and the Publie Vessels Act, supra, and 3

their concamitant adnriralty haw, in this case we find no duty
imposed thereunder any diffe ‘rent from the duty imposed on
other owners of property. Since the plaintiff is not invok-.

\ing the seaworthiness Warranty, the fact that the property |

Owned hy the Govermment here is.a sea-going vessel does:
not differenti: ite this: case from similar cases arising under

the Federal Tort Claims Act, 28 U.S. C.1546(b). Siu

Nirk. supra, (fede ral dam: project)’; Market Ins. Co. v.
fillon, 5 Cir, 1969, — F, 2d — [| No. 26,410, Sept. 8 isch
(federal: lake project) ; Lodge, supra, (airplane heuaas On
U. 8. Air Foree base),

Nor does “the ‘rel: tionship. between the parties. here

‘(e ontrac toe. contractor) give rise to the imposition of a duty

on the Government. “It is well settled ‘that a contractee is
ene rally not liable for the torts of an independent contrac-
tor or of the latter’s servants’ . Roberson, Aapra; irk, |

‘

Alf Court of Appeals Opinion

supra; 41°Am. Jur. 2d,. Independent Contractors. $ 24
(1968y.2 |
Nor do we find that the terms of the contract. impose
a duty on the Government. . Paragraph (f) (note 1) speei-
fically states that the Coutractor was to place reasonable
‘safeguards.and prov ide ade «uate lighting to protect its em-
ployees. It is unreasonable ‘to believe that the contractor
Was relying.on the government inspector to suggest alterta-
tive methods of raising debris from the engine room. This
plainly was not part of his duties, either under the terms of
the contract _or by tacit understanding. The inspector's
duties i in this case were broader, and more in the order of an
overseer of acquisitions, costs and compliance with specifi-
cations. Placing upoir the Government the responsibilities
of carelessness on the part of the employees of its contrae-
tors in their day to day work procedures would certainly be
good news to government contractors, but it would also be a
gros4 misinterpretation of the intention of the contracting
parti S. 7
-* Perhaps the decisive factor involved here is who had
.contfol of the vessel, the work area, and the safety preeau-
tions. In West, supra, the Supreme’ Court stressed the im-.
portance of this factor when it said:

. .°. it would be uianifestly unfair to apply the re-
quirement of a safe place: te work to the ship-owner
When he has no control over the ship or th repairs, and
the avork of repair in effect creates the danger which
makes the place unsafe (361 ULS, at 128).

“The West case, which plaintiff strongly argues does not
lend support-to the Government's case, dealt with an injury

An exception to this general rule-arises, of course, when the
oe has knowledge of a diuryerous condition created by the
independent contractor.” Emelzeon, Inc. v. United States. 5 Cir.,
1968, 39k F. 2d 9. { However, there is no evidence here that the -
government inspectgr had k nowledge of any dangerous defect.

Court of. Appeals Opinion . AIS!

to the vinployee of an lidtocion contractor w orking ona
dry-docked vessel. The j JInjury there was caused by a ee
flying off the end of a pipe near which the plaintiff wa

Working, when a fellow worker turned on the water pres-

sure. T bs plaintiff cites the eases of Stark. United States,
5 Cir, 1969, 415-2 2d 253, and Van Horn v. Gulf Atlantic

‘Towing C orp., 4 Cir., 1968, 388 F. 2d 636, for’ the rule.that’
Westyis limited to ‘instances in which the repair work

ereatéd the unsafe condition.”’ He would have us distin-
guish ‘the injury’ in West from the present one on the
grounds that it enrtnated from the very object w hich was
to: be_repaired, whereas here the injury: emanated from a
work operation in the vie inity where plaintiff was w orking.
We cannot say that cleaning out pipes is more or Jess
hazardous than working’ Ina room where a clean- -up crew
is removing. debris, — Both involve a certain amount of risk,
Whether'the : actual injury is caused by the object being re-

paired or by other work being done ‘in the Vicinity is not

‘ause for.distinction where. the risk is equally present in
both situations. In both, the répair work creates the unsafe
condition. =) |

~ Thus, where the Government is not in control of the
incident which created the risk (as.in West and as in the
case at bar), and where the risk\i Is not a li itent one created
prior to the Government’ s loss of control (Van Morn, supra
White vc. United States. 4 Cir. » 1968, 400 F. 2d-74) nor an
Keene dangerous one wherein the shipowner requires
the werk to he done in a manner inherently dangerous to

-~-

human safety (alecki v. United New Yor}- and New Jersey

Sandy Hook Pilots Assn., 2-Cir., 1962, 302 F.2d S40) then
it would be ‘¢*manifesily unfair’? to impose on the Govern:
ment a duty to provide safety measures for employees of
the contractor.

‘The record indicates that the Government had _relin-

quished control ef the vessel, The Government was not-in .

:

AIG Court of -Lppeals Opinion

control of the work area, the manner of detail performance,
hor safety procedurés,and it was net a duty of the single
inspector on hoard to take control of same. In fact, there
is here much less possibility of control by the Goverment
than in Wes, supra, where the Government had placed six
inspectors aboard the dry-docked vessél. i
Therefore, we find that this case is controlled hy West,
supra, and Joye, supra,.and we affirm.

AFFIRMED.

6

Court of . hn als Judge uf Al7 >

U NIT KD STATES COURT OF AP PEALS

y For tne F IFTH Cirevir

7, Ocroser Term, 1969

. ; \

2 —_—_—_—

No. 286] 15
al prone
D. '. Doc ‘KET No, C' AGS-1. J

—

L po F. BAU M,
[ . Plaintiff-Appellant,

v.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Ra fy Defendant- Third- Party
Plaintiff- A ppe Ie 4 i

5%
AAC KSONY ILL SHIPYARDS. INC,
‘s : : . Third-Party De fendaut-
_. Appellee:
-Appean From rir Uxrrep Srates Disrricr Covert ror THE,
Mippie Districr or FLonipa- .

————

~ Before Gopsotp, Dyer and Morcay, Circuit Judges,
JUDGMENT

‘

Als. \, Court of Appeals Judgment

This cause came on to be heard.on the transcript of the
record from the United States District Court for the Middle
District of Florida, and was argued by counsel ;

Ox Coxswerarion Wnrereor, It is now here ordered
wal adjudged by this Court that the judgment of the said
‘Distriet Court -in iIhis eause be, and the same is hereby,
_aflirmed. : | Po
~~ Tteis further ordered that plaintiff-appellant pax to_
defendant-third-party. splaintiff-appellee and third-party
defendant-appellee, the costs on appeal to be taxed by the
Clerk of this Court.

June 2, 1970:

—Tssued as, Mandate: Jun 24, 1970

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385605_0278%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
