# Appendix — Urbano v. Sondern

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385603_0399%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1967
- **Citation:** 386 U.S. 1034

## Text

APPENDIX A
Opinions of Circuit Court of Appeals

carrer STATES COURT: OF APPEALS |

For THE Siicomp Cmmcurr

No. 182—September, Term, 1966.
(Submitted N evember 16, 1966 Decided November 29, ae )
: : ‘Docket No. 30740

fy.
a

Rosert F’. Ursano,

Appellant,
Yv, oe /

FREDERIC Sonnern, JR.,
‘ Appellee:

ra’
a

Before:

Luparo, Chief Judge,

Mepiwa and Kaurman, Circuit Judges.

ies —_ an order of the United States District Court
for the District of Connecticut, Zampano, J., dismissing -
appellant’s action as frivolous, pursuant to 28 U. es
$1915). ANG

Roserr F. ‘Unsano, Pro Se.

Lorp, Day & Lorp, New York, N. Y. (John W. Castles
3d, Wendell Davis, Jr., of counsel), for appellee,

| 2a,
_ Appendix. A—Opinions of Circuit Court of Appeals
Per Cur: : ae yeas E |

This is an appeal from an order*of Judge Zampano of
the District of Connecticut, dismissing appellant’s action
as frivolous, pursuant to 28 U. S. C: §1915(d)..

Appellant, Robert Urbano, was sentenced to life im-
prisonment in May 1960, following a plea of non vult to an
indictment for murder committed during a robbery of Bam- °
berger’s Department Store. in Paramus, New Jersey.
Urbano is presently serving his sentence i in the New J exisg
State Prison at Trenton. - 7

_ It appears that in September 1961, tie Federal Bureat
of Investigation issued a press: valenne describing appel-
‘ lant’s criminal career. Many newspapers and magazines
proceeded to run stories about Urbano, based in whole or ~
in part on the FBI report, and appellant responded with
_several law suits (of which Urbano v. Fawcett Publications;
- Inc.. —— F. 24 ——, (2d Cir. 1966), decided today, was
one) against the authors, the publishers, and the FBI.

The present action is against the author of an article: -
- entitled, ‘“The New-Style Bank Robber,’’ which appeared in .
‘ the December 1963 issue of Reader’s Digest. Urbano al-

leges that the article is libelous. Appellant sought leave
‘to proceed in forma pauperis, pursuant to 28 U. S. C.
§ 1915(a). On that application, the district court, while
believing that Urbano’s complaint lacked merit, permitted
him to develop and expand his contentions. Voluminous
briefs and appendices were submitted, and after studying
them in detail, Judge Zampano concluded that the action
was frivolous. He therefore dismissed the action pursuant
to 28 U. S.-C. $1915(d) which provides that ‘‘the court
may ... dismiss the case ... if satisfied that the action is. -
- frivolous. ...”? : Pk ae

=

3a
_Appendia A—Opinions of- Cirouit Court - Appeals

After careful study of the siliise record, we cusbudé
that this action was properly dismissed as frivolous, both.
' for the reasons set forth i in Judge Zampano’s well-reasoned
decision, —— F. Supp. ——,, and because it seems highly
. unlikely that appellant, who ‘has adduced no specific facts’
tending to show that he did not commit the crimes men-
tioned in defendant’s article,. could surmount either the '
defense of truth, or of qualified privilege to sTeport the
. activities of public officials. 2
' Affirmed. —

1 The ‘ieuiiae of siti for the minutés of itie oral argument
on the appeal has become moot in light of the submission of this
appeal without argument’ upon the consent of the appeliee. The’
motion is accordingly denied. .

~ ae 7

4a
Appendix A—Opinions of Circuit Court of Appeals

| “UNITED STATES. COURT OF APPEALS.
. For THE SECOND Cimcurr

No. 181—September —_— 1966.
(Submitted November 16, 1966 Decided November 29, 1966. )y
| Docket No. 30741

4».
Vv

Roser F. Unsano, fer be
Appellant,
we x e. ‘

Fawcett Pusuications, Inc.,
| 7 ' Appellee.

i-)

Before:

LmBarp, Chief Judge; |
Mepina and Kaurman, Circuit Judges. ©

Appeal from an order of the United States District Court
for the District of Connecticut, Zampano, J., dismissing
a ant’s action as frivolous, pursuant to 98 U.S. C.
™§1915(d).

Affirmed. —

Rosir F. Unsano, Pro Se.

DeWrrt, Nast & Disk, New York, N. Y. (Francis oe
: ~— John R. Coughlin, of re for appellee.

fy

. ca
Appendia A—Opinions of Circuit Court of Appeals |

‘Per Curmm:

This‘is an appeal from an order of J udge Zampano of
the District of Connecticut, dismissing appellant’s action .
as frivolous, pursuant to 28 U.S. C.§1915(d). . . Pos
_ _ This suit is against the publishers of True magazine,

alleging that appellant. was libeled by an article entitled
_ “The Case of the Three-Faced Crook,’’ which appeared in -

the January 1963 issue of True. The facts involved, in this
appeal are similar to those in Urbano v. Sondern, ——
F. 2d —— (2d Cir. 1966), decided this day. We affirm
. for the reasons stated in that opinion.1 ees,

1 The request of appellant for the minutes of the oral argument on
: the.appeal has become moot in light of the submission of this appeal .
without argument upon the consent of the appellée.- The motion is
accordingly denied.

6a
APPENDIX B
Opinion of District Court
Saree STATES DISTRICT COURT

District or CONNECTICUT
Civil No. 11,145 and Civil ‘No. 11,062

-,*
Vw

Rosert F’. Ursano,

Plaintiff,
Y.
Freperic SonDERN, JR., .
| Defendant,
and
Rosert F’. Urpano, 7 :
Plaintiff,
‘~
Fawcett Pusuications, Inc.,
7 Defendant.

MEMORANDUM OF DECISION

Various motions’ are before the Court in these two
separate libel actions brought. by a plaintiff who is serving ©

1 In’ Civil No. 11, 145.

(a) Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Each and Seine Defense to (se)
Fr Ne Tate s Answer;

(b). Defendant’s Cross Motion for Summary Judgment ;
(c) Plaintiff's Applications for —— of Counsel and/or
Guardian Ad Litem.
In Civil No. 11,062
(a) Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Special Silene: i
_ (b) Defendant’s Motion to: ‘Dismiss ‘Complaint.

POE OIE CR PROR LS te AG Bet ee -

7a

Appendix B—Opinion of District Court

a life sentence in the New J ersey State Prison. Since there
are common facts and issues, a single memorandum of
- decision is dispositive of both cases. . et
On May: 19, 1960, the plaintiff was sentenced to life
‘imprisonment following a plea of non vult to an indictment
for murder in the commission of a robbery. The Federal
Bureau of Investigation on September 14, 1961, big a
press release purporting to describe plaintiff’s career and
several of the crimes attributed to him. His criminal ex-
ploits as a bank and: department store robber coupled with
his reputation as a ‘‘continental playboy- and: bon vivant”?
_were naturally appealing subject matter for the news media.

‘Many newspapers and magazines carried articles based in’
whole or in part on the F.B.I. release. Following the |

publications plaintiff has instituted a rash of suits through-
out the country.” es

2 In addition to the two suits filed here, other suits involving the
plaintiff of which the Court has knowledge’are: an

(a) Urbano v. The Federal Bureau: of Investigation, J. Edgar
Hoover, et al. (D.D.C. Civil No. 616-65)—suit to enjoin the pub-
lication of allegedly false information about the plaintiff; .
' (b) Urbano v. News Syndicate, Inc. (S.D.N.Y. Civil No. 63-

3168)—libel action based* on an article published in the “Sunday |

News”; :
(c) Urbano v. Liston (D. Md. Civil No. 15092)—1libel action

against author of article appearing in True magazine, the subject:

of the suit in Civil No. 11,062; .
(d). Urbano v. The Reader’s Digest Association, Inc. (D.Mass.

Civil. No. 64-843-F)—libel action for same article as in Civid No.
~ 11,145 here;

“(e) Urbano v. DeLoach (D.D.C. Civil No. 2951-64)—action
against three F.B.I. agents and medical directors of Trenton State

Hospital for conspiracy, to publish the F:B.I. report of September.

14, 1961;
"(£) Urbano v. Paquette (Province of the Seine, France)—suit

' for alleged conversion of personal property ;

*

8a
Appendix B—Opinion of District Court

The defendant in Civil No. 11,145 is the author of an
article entitled ‘‘The New Style Bank Robber’’ which ap-
peared in the December, 1963, issue of Reader’s Digest.
The defendant in Civil No. 11,062 published ‘‘The Case of
the Three-Faced Crook’? in its January, 1963, edition of
True magazine. To the extent the former article concerns
the plaintiff, it is clearly based solely on the F.B.I. report.
The latter is primarily about the plaintiff; and while sub- —
stantially based on the report, it -is embellished with facts
apparently garnered from independent sources. |
In both cases the plaintiff has sought leave to pro-
ceed in forma pauperis pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1915(a).®
Unlike the usual pro se complaints filed by prisoners, from
the outset his presentations of claims, affidavits, and briefs

(g) Urbano v. Hughes, Governor (D. N.J. Civil No. 262-65)— —
action to compel the governor of New Jersey, the Gommissioner of
Institutions and Agencies, et al., to furnish Urbano proper Coney
for court appearances ;

(h) Urbano v. Calissi (D.N.J. Civil No. 003-65)—action against
prosecutor of Bergen County for denial of constitutional rights .in
failing to account for personal property; .

(i) Urbano v. Magee (D.N.J. Civil No. 909-64)—petition for
Ttourt order to compel officers of the New Jersey State Hospital to
supply Urbano certain information ;

(j).In the Matter of .the Application of Robert F. Citas for
a Declaratory Judgment under Rule 4:88-10 (Super. Ct. N.J.,
App.Div. No. AM-221-62)—suit challenging regulation a
inmate’s clothing.

This list does not include the several suits in’ which the plaintiff
‘has collaterally challenged the’ legality of his incarceration.

8 28 U.S.C. § 1915(a) provides:

“Any court of the United States may ‘authorize the commence-

- meng, prosecution or defense of any suit, action or proceeding,
civil or criminal, or appeal therein, without prepayment of fees
and costs or security therefor, by a person who makes affidavit
that he is unable to pay such costs or give security therefor. :. .”

| 9a
Appendia B—Opinion of District Court

have been highly articulate and detailed. Nonetheless, the
complaints appeared to lack merit, and the Court’s initial
reaction was to deny leave te proceed under this Section.
Rather than prematurely terminate the claims since there

was a possibility, albeit a remote one, that his contentions ’-

might have some substance, the plaintiff was allowed .to
develop and expand them. In both cases the filing fee was
' waived; in Civil No. 11,062 Attorney Gordon Evans was
appointed to represent the plaintiff.

The files in both matters are now voluminous; this
Court has a complete understanding of the claims, the
background, and the defenses and is satisfied that the
actions are frivolous and ought to be dismissed. 28 U.S.C.
§ 1915(d).° uF eye Aeeg ; “

The distinction between dismissal of an action- under
‘Section -1915(d) and denial of leave to proceed in forma
- pauperis under Section 1915(a) has often been recognized,
e.g., United States v. Radio Station WENR, 209 F.2d 105
(7 Cir. 1953), and rests on sound policy grounds. To with- |
hold leave to proceed in forma pauperis at an embryonic |

* Included in the file are, inter alia,. .

(a) Pro se briefs, and exhibits which number hundreds of pages,
in addition to briefs and papers filed by ‘Attorney Evans;

(b) Lengthy affidavits, reply affidavits and “surreply” affidavits;

{c) The F.B.I. report of September 14, 1961 : :

(d) Plaintiffs conféssions to ten different bank robberies;

(e) Copy of Judge Galanti’s Order in plaintiff's application for
writ of habeas corpus. finding that plaintiff was legally competent to ©
enter his plea of non vult.. The opinion relates the testimony of sev-
eral psychiatrists which referred to plaintiff’s admissions of crimes.

528 U.S.C. § 1915(d) provides in pertinent part:

“The court . . . may dismiss the case if the allegation of pov-

erty is untrue, or if satisfied that the action is frivolous or mali-
cious.” P ; 3 oe

10a.

Appendiz B—Opinion of District Court

stage of the litigation would run the ia of ‘sain a
forum to worthy claims brought by sincere, but impecuni-
ous, persons. - Where, as here, the litigant has been given
an opportunity to amplify and clarify his claims, however,
that risk is obviated and different considerations become
controlling.
In Mattheis v. Hoyt, 136 F. Sion. 119 (W.D. Mich.
1955), an inmate of the state prison, serving a life sentence
“for murder, sued a magazine and. individuals for defama-
tion damages allegedly resulting from an articlé about
the crime for which he was convicted. The court refused
to.allaw the plaintiff to proceed in forma pauperis stating,
‘‘It is obvious that the publication of the article in question
_ four years after plaintiff’s conviction of the brutal murder
of a young girl, even though it.might have been in part
-..mntrue as to his admission of guilt, certainly did not affect
or damage his Yeputation, ‘unless possibly among his crim-
inal associates in prison.’’ Jd. at 124. This Court agrees
. that the chances of success ina suit of this nature are
virtually nonexistent, and if there were any recovery, it
. would bé at most nominal:®
There being such a patent lack of ‘eet. in these suits,
dismissal under Section 1915(d) is clearly proper. Kinney /
v. Plymouth Rock Squab Co., 236 U. S. 43, 45 (1915). It_/
should be noted, moreover, there has been a particular
judicial reluctance to render the risk-free procedures of.
Section 1915 available to prison inmates in non-habeas- —
ogre: matters. In Mattheis v. Hoyt, supra, § a state prisoner

‘se Givil No. 11062 no demand’ for retraction. was made until
August 1, 1964. Under the applicable Connecticut statute, Conn.
Gen. Stat. § 52-237 (1958), unless such a demand is made within a
reasonable time, there can be no recovery for anything but special
damages unless the plaintiff can prove actual malice. The demand
here was not made within a reasonable time. Hogan v. New York
Times Co., 211 F. Supp. 99. (D. Conn.. 1962), aff'd 313 F.2d 354
(2 Cir. 1963). In this Court’s opinion it is highly unlikely that the
plaintiff could prove either actual malice or special damages.

; ; : a
prose mi nam rigerseem emis = sepegunenmnumecenan a ; &
. : = . - .

.
cet a oe —

Appendiz B—Opinion of District Court.

‘brought a libel action similar to the present one; in
Richardson v. Hatch, 134 F.Supp. 110 (W.D. Mich. 1955),
it was a suit for damages against the sentencing judge;
in Carey v. Settle, 351 F.2d 483 (8 Cir. 1965), it was a suit
against a former warden for damages resulting from the
promulgation of a regulation which the applicant claimed
prevented him from finishing a correspondence course;
in United States ex rel. Morris v. Radio Station WENR,
supra, there was a claim that the defendant warden and
the defendant radio station were discriminating against -
petitioner by not allowing him to audition or -act as an
announcer on a program broadcast from the prison. The
range of cases illustrates the vast potential for-“abuse
inherent in Section 1915. Where there is no risk to be
run, a variety of reasons may prompt an inmate to file suit
“under this section. A desire to harass officials, a hope for a.
quick windfall by way of nuisance settlement, or simply a |
discovery of a new way to pass the monotonous hours of -
incarceration are readily identifiable motives which alone
justify careful scrutiny of prisoner complaints filed under
this section. Urbano v. News Syndicate, Inc. [358], F. 2d
[145] (2 Cir. 1966) (dissenting opinion—Lumbard, C.J.).
| Administrative Pee eta must also weigh in the balance.
Not only does the transportation of an out of state prisoner
to testify raise substantial problems of procedure, ‘but .ap-
parently there are no federal funds available for’such a
purpose. (Diaz v. Chatterton, 229 F. Supp. 19 (S.D. Cal.
1964). And as the Court of Appeals for this Circuit has
said, ‘‘ (where) the chances of success are so highly dubious
- + 4 Judge cannot properly ask a member of the bar to
assume this thankless burden.’’ Miller v. Pleasure, 296 .
F.2d 283 (2 Cir. 1961). oy .-
If the suit is frivolous, and if the chances of success are
highly dubious at best, the court has an interest in pro-
tecting its forum from being abused by persons who are
unable to pay costs or give security therefor. Fletcher v.
Young, 222 F.2d 222, 224 .(4 Cir. 1955), eért::denied 350

ry : x

°

° 12a: .
Anpendiz.B—Opinion of District Court

U.S. 916 (1955). A defendant should not -be put to the |
burden of further“defending such suits after it becomes
apparent that there is little, if any, likelihood of the plain-
tiff prevailing. Here the defendants have been subjected
to substantial burden in defending these actions. Until the
files were sufficiently complete to enable the Court to dis-
tinguish between the meritorious and the frivolous, this
burden could not be avoided. Now the cases are in a differ-
ent posture, and it would be most unfair to require any
further expenditure of time, effort, and money in these
frivolous and futile actions.’ - |

Accordingly it is

OnpEReED, that Civil Action No. 11,145 be, and the same
hereby i is, dismissed pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § alias and
it is further |

ORDERED, that Civil Action No. 11,062 be, and the same
hereby is, dismissed pursuant to 28 U.S. C. § 1915(d).

The Court is appreciative of the scholarly and conscien- |
tious efforts of Attorney Evans.

Dated at New i annem, Connecticut this 27th day of June,
1966.
Rosert ©. Zampano
United States District Judge

7 Since plaintiff has had a full opportunity to develop his, shite,
the case is distinguishable from Urbano v. News S yndicate, Inc.,
supra, which allowed plaintiff to proceed in forma pauperis at a much
earlier stage than in the instant litigation.. See also United S tates
v. Radio Station WENR, supra at 107.

APPENDIX C. ..

FBI “Press Release”
_ (PHOTOSTATS)
(See opposite -—_)

\
\

SO A COREE Se eter pi RL re —- - . -_ . — —_ - ,

.
s - . —
AORN at

UNITED STATES‘ DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE .
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION >

Wasuincrox 25, D.C,
¥ i 4 ; 3
\ ¥ ,
September'14, 1961

, . ROBERT FRANCIS URBANO, aka
Roberto F. Urbano y dé Blanquart,
. _ Lester Layman Brown, Edward M
Lehman, Robert G Wood;
. First National Bank of baltimore
Pulaski Highway Branch .
Pulaski Highway and Monument Streets
Baltimore, Maryland -_
March 25, 1958
BANK ROBBERY

Phe few shoppers making last-minute purchases in A: J:

+ Samberger's Department Store at the sprawling Garden State Shopping

Sawin gee en ae ee -

Center, Paramus, New Jersey, just before 6:00 p. m., Friday, January 15,
1960, had little reason to notice the neatly dressed, sad-eyed little man ‘
mincing along with short, quick steps toward the credit department on the
lower level. All eyes in that department were focused on him minutes

later, however, when, wearing a handkerchief mask, he vaulted over the ~
counter, brandished a pistol and snarled, "This is a holdup! Nobody

move!" ; ‘

___. Credit Manager John ‘Blanch, Cedar Grove, New Jersey,
grabbed at the bandit. The..32 automatic cracked twice and Blanch .
sank to the floor with bullets in his chest and Shoulder; Sales Clerk °
_ Leo Zaritsky of Rutherford, New Jersey, lunged at the gunman and again the :
pistol blazed in the bandit's small, gloved hand. A slug drilled into
| Zaritsky's head, and he‘died where he fell. Salesman Fred Kramer,
Great Notch, New Jersey, was shot in the arm as he grappled for the .
Ceath-dealing weapon. Kramer and Blanch Subsequently recovered from
their wounds. . : , ‘

; .. Charles Jony, Rochelle Park, New Jersey, rushed into the
fray from. a nearby counter and slammed his newly purchased can of

_ Cleaning fluid against the killer's skull. Dazed, Robert Francis Urbano
Sagged to the floor beside his bullet-punctured victims as Jony and others

I. C. '#.91-10942

‘ . 5 ey . F. ;
ad ; S
2 ° ; . : as
. : mie
; : ee ‘
.
. . * * j Se
i K . . a P +
) , at ee . ‘ 3 J ‘
Y sf | , ‘ ’ 4
. aI ~. > e P :
, ,
* . . ’ ’ “
re " P j ?
: 4 37
; e f AteTe 7? . £% 7
3 ‘ :
: ;
‘ s .
J er .
i *
& we!
% *
“HO atid 2% 1
. ‘ ‘ od
yeti a pare One
7
~ add ;
‘ 4 > - .
: at ;
Aj Al Dosa 4
: : ‘ |
; ‘ 4 ‘
5 g iM fi
4 ‘ ’
7 ior i> 4
PF we
. Oy yn iagne Ady
} is
S ‘ # ° : ali i RL:
i .
’ aor
my ee ‘ aay oa .
; A eA; Seni bose .6°2 a.19050" sU0u & ij :
j , “s *, ‘ . ~ ‘ **
* ‘ oe © ea beri reine Cees nl , ahs
& : te : o Fe te an In bewsiig 3 wh "i 18 helhad Yfa pa y le :
’ ry ‘ a ts ’ 44 teciewe Bight? Ait
‘onscn & yO6 330 Auste a olbly et) Shaye biskt Bisa,

are e10d7¢ bas yao aa aéniloiy bow onic ele ati ebleed moolk oni} 62 Hogi

.
Z . “ : P . * av a
. ' . * ° . : > a ae . = | | : |
. | |
. * ba > : | |
. ‘ ; | |
> a ‘ ‘
r . | |
. _ ; . }
. . a é ; ;
. : ; | . | |
. x : |
. , ;
| )
; A
. ‘ é | |
e
. . - . . i ¥ a d :
. ts | |
: ‘
° | |
| ee
: ‘ . . ,
é | = A . ' . .
- | | |
° | | |
° |
. - ¥ ; . :
. " ; ‘ ’
. . ; | | |
; ; . | |
. ; | | |
° . | .
.
. ; j :
. . F : :
. e ° ;
. . é
. ’ |
. . » ° e :
. z | |
. ; :
. | :
| | .
. . 7 ! . : |
, ; . . . ®
. « 7 , : | :
. sg : : , : |
. . . ‘ j : | |
. . ° a — ; : :
. - ,
. ‘ ‘ | | |
, : ‘ ‘a . 7 | |
. E | .
. : | |
* . |
. . 3
. ; , |
P | | | | $ :
.
e ” : . : | |
. Z | | | |
. bg z ;
| be
. . + s ; :
‘ or) : | |
rg , . |
.
\ ; : :
’

és 4, bib nsntdasciitos

2s he ‘0 aptly demonstrated in the A. J. Bamberger Department Store
robbery. He customarily purchased cheap clothing just prior to the
holdup, favoring plaid shirts, chino trousers, gabardine rain hats, and

_ trench coats. A handkerchief tied around his neck was Urbano's favorite

. mask.

| : Robert Francis Urbano related ‘ails details about some -
his bank robberies which could have been known only to the perpetrator.
He was subsequently viewed by witnesses to miany of his robberies and was

| identified as the counter~-leaping robber.

On May 24, 1960, Robert Francis Urbano entered New —

Seraay State Prison at Trenton, New Jersey, to begir his life commitment. 2

At this time, a warrant is filed as a detainer at New Jersey
State Prison, Trenton, New Jersey, charging Robert Francis Urbano
with the robbery of the Bridgeville National Bank, Cedarhurst Office,
St. Clair Shopping Center, Scott Township, Pennsylvania, on May 29, 1957.

United States Attorneys in Baltimore, Maryland;
Wilmington, Delaware; and Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, in September, 1960,
took the necessary steps to dismiss the rémaining Federal warrants
outstanding for bank robbery against Urbano, commenting that since
Urbano is already serving life imprisonment on first degree murder .

charges, additional prosecution would sérve no useful purpose.

Wartime aviator, student, antique dealer, continental

playboy, robber, murderer and now convict, it appears that Robert

Francis Urbano is cast in his last role. It will have the longest run.

- I4a

\ APPENDIX. D
Sondern Article |
(PHOTOSTATS)

_ (See opposite oe).

Reader's Digest, issue of December 1963

a The New-Style
Bank Robber |

Amateur or pro-
fessional, he is a lone
operator, and his
favorite target is

the small-town or.
suburban bank

By FREDERIC SONDERN, Jr.

HE stores and business places of Thornton, Texas,
] (pop. 504) had opened one November morning
in 1960 when fire broke out in the feed and grain
warehouse. As police, firemen and townspeople con-
verged on the blaze, a well-dressed man walked into the
First State Bank a few blocks away. He had just been’
hired by the nearby aircraft factory, he told the president,
atid he would like to arrange a loan on his car. The presi-
- 2 dent was sympathetic. Suddenly, satisfied that neither the
m banker nor his wife and bookkeeper, who were peering
at the excitement outside, was fiear an alarm button, the _
“stranger drewa gun, Unhurriedly he made the book-
keeper hand over the cash in the tills, herded all of them
into the vault, locked it and departed as quietly as he
had come. | EAST,
Violations of the Federal Bank Robbery Statute, which
during the late 1940's dwindled to an average of about
200 violations a year in this country, are once again on .
the rise. Last year 1250 were reported to the FBI for in-
Vestigation, topping the.1961 record by a third; 1963
promises to be worse. In his annual report to the Attor-_
ney General, J. Edgar Hoover, Director of the Federal

, 33

“

.

:
:

*

,

ais a ha

a

et
.
Par
7 >
. .
.
‘ sz
” ss a
. .
oe
Mime
a4
ee
*-
‘ *
. rhe
.
‘ 2°
vs
.
*
”
« ne
.
al
e-
s
‘
.
Ar,
ed ’
we
'
é -
, ‘ Ps
*
” .
»
Pecans a:

Ne TE insane

a . "

Bureau of Investigation, wrote:

x “Armed assaults on banking institu-

tions continue to be among the most
serious Crimes under the jurisdiction

. of the FBI.”

Fortunately, the FBI record tor
speedy catches is high by polite

- standards: many bank robberies are

solved within a_matter -of: hours,
with recovery of substantially all the
|» In the Thornton case, the FBI’s

ouston office assigned all available -
_ special agents in-the area and the .
endlessly patient work of these high-.

ly trained men began.
The . catching ua Lawrence C.

Pope, who had. set fire to the feed °

store as a diversionary measure, was
not easy. He is an intelligent man,
had worked in banks from boyhood,
hhadeeven been a bank examiner for
a while, and finally president of a

-small,but prosperous Texas institu-
‘tion. Reportedly, a disagreement

with its board of directors had lost

him his job. Bank robbery seemed -

to him the only way to recoup.

This sort of robber has no‘ under-
-. world connections, so informers
_ were useless. But Pope had under-
rated the FBI’s ability to put to-
~gether the flimsiest of leads. His:

victims described him clearly. The

_ Bureau, which uses newspaper,
radio and television publicity to.
great effect, promptly broadcast his .
. description. As agents checked out

_Feports coming in from filling sta-

tions, motels, diners, Pope’s modus

operand: and direction of travel .

were established. Then came the

ows ars 7 not before he had

3 | ‘+. THE NEW-STYLE BANK ROBBER —

robbed another bank of $16,000).

' An alert operator of a motel on the
outskirts. of San Antonio phoned

the local FBI. The arsonist-brigand
was proudly inspecting a European
car he had bought, when police
closed in on him. He is now serving |

25 years in a federal penitentiary.
- The business of robbing. a bank

‘has changed radically in the last

decade. It is far less often an orga-
nized gang operation than it was in
the days of Dillinger and Legs Dia-
mond. The big-league hoodlums
know that tangling with the FBI
(which under various federal stat-
utes protects almost all of our banks)
is not worthwhile. But the new lone
operators—both amateur and profes-
sional—are far more numerous, if
less pretentious, than their subma- .
chine-gun-carrying predecessors.

An analysis of 150 recent cases

in the FBI Law Enforcement Bulle-.

tin, a police ‘officer’s handbook,
describes the average. bank robber
as a lone male from 17 to 50 years _
old. Generally operating on Mon-
day'or Friday Lime one and three
p.m., he approaches a teller, de-
mands money, threatens him with a
handgun, and “88 percent of ‘the
time obtains loot which averages | °
$6098 per robbery.” Small-town and
suburban banks are the main tar- ©
gets, California, New York and Ohio
the main sufferers. But the madness

_ seemis to be spreading in other states.

Consider the case of the remark- -
able Robert Francis Urbano. Son of
a respected family in a small Massa-

‘chusetts town, university graduate, ~"

aks 254 5b au i

be sutaek ite’

-

“Clog

cnet

~—

.
-
.
a
. of
.
’ .
° .
* 19
.
- - . . :
e .
-
¢
«
,. * é
.
-
.
.
a ae .
. . >
°
é is ; 2
-
.
; . ’
.
.
. .
° i 2
. a ’
-
.
* . .
° . :
> .
°,
. . F
.
. . al e ?
e .
$ . .
-
. a,
.
. . . os \
s ’ a ae
’ - =
. -
» ’
r
. — ‘
: .
. ‘ tag
rt . ou.
nk ow ‘ ’ :
— : . é
P" 3
-
.
e C4
Pal nis Aan Citi opie aD EE STA ie 5 ARS RAETR t iahs Paty BAS Ang Sipser ae tae tt Lott Lihat ey Cal GR agen alae te
meee --

.
.
.
.
.
a .
7 .
.
°
. ‘
“«
.
‘ .
.
. °
.
-
a . .
. x
Py .
s .
- “ .
¢ .
.
“°
o ° i. -
.
-
*
e
’
¢ e
’
.
. é y
« .
- .
. °
. >.
. .
rh
>
-
- .
. ¢ %,
. .
. . 4
.
‘
.
* 26
‘ .
a

>

%
a ipa Eg A NE OATS ES

pr’

‘THE NEW-STYLE BANK ROBBER 7

honorably discharged Air Force of-
ficer, widely traveled antique dealer,
he provided the FBI with a compli-
cated dossier,

One March day in 1954 an im-

. amaculately dressed little man

.of aw
putting down roots in France, Eng- |

minced up to the tellers’ counter in
a’ Pennsylvania bank. Drawing a
scarf over his nose, he deftly vaulted
the counter with gun in hand. “This

.is a stickup,” he shrieked in a high-

pitched voice. “Stand back from

-your buttons.” .The tellers stood

back. Watching them for any move-
ment; the bandit swiftly opened
cash drawers and shoved bundles
of notes into his pockets, Within
minutes he leaped again and was
gone. A few hours later,. having

‘collected over $10,000 from this and
a previous robbery, he was on a

plane to Paris.

Inventing the romantic alias of
Roberto Urbano y de Blanquart,
Urbano skillfully as the scion
thy noble family and began

land and Switzerland. In Europe he
behaved himself perfectly, traded
innocently in antiques and lived
pleasantly. But about every six

-months—for over five years—he

would make a quick visit to the
United States. (He used to explain
to his friends abroad that he "hed
business with his American bank-
ers.) His admitted ten bank and two
department-store. robberies netted
him some $200,000. After each rob-
bery he would board a plane bound

for his bank in Switzerland, and
thence to his cheerful apartment in

the Rue St. Ferdinand in Paris.
Urbano-Blanquart became a ma-

jor FBI headache. He moved so

‘quickly in a robbery that he left

little personal impression. He was
always masked and always in dif-

-ferent attire. Sometimes he was

shoddy, sometimes elegant. A dirty
workman's cap, a stylish Homburg
and porkpie, wrinkled blue jeans
and well-cut London suits were all
part of his wardrobe. He was an
identification officer’s nightmare.

Always gloved, he never left finger- |

prints. The FBI deduced from the
invariable method of operation that
one man was responsible for ‘the
raids. But theré were no other leads.

Urbano-Blanquart might have

gone on quite a while but for an

accident in’a Paramus, N.J., depart-

ment store. At the credit counter of’

Bamberger’s, which he vaulted as

‘usual, three courageous employes

grabbed for him despite the threat-
ening gun. One was killed instantly,

the other two seriously wounded. ©

Then a customer—Charles Jony of
Rochelle Park—walked quietly up
behind the gunman and brought a
can of newly
fluid down on ‘his head. Urbano-
Blanquart is now in the New Jersey
State Prison.at Trenton for.life. .
The Frank Sprenz case caused
the FBI even more trouble. On a
quiet morning a young man looking
like a college student came into the
Plaza Branch of the First National

purchased - cleaning

Bank of Hamilton, Ohio. He pro- |
duced a paper bag and a revolver. -

“All right,” he said. as alarm,

$

-

EH (GORA iOS EMI pte et pm a ee Alpe Ans ckend
sa - a ~ ond

2 THE NEW-STYLE BANK ROBBER ©

please. Someone might get hurt.”
The tellers backed away; both the

man and the snub-ndsed, .38 looked’

businesslike. Drawers were opened
and the ggck filled. “Exhibiting
coolness and courtesy,” says the
FBI account, “and voicing his ap-
preciation, he quickly departed with

- $25,955.20 of the bank’s money.” _

In a stolen car which he had
parked nearby he drove to the local
airport.’ Browsing around the apron,
he found a small plane with the
ignition key. in the lock. A few
hours later he landed several hun-

dred miles away, hired a car and -
__ was off again, to rocket up and down -

and across the continent. In one year
he had traveled an estimated 25,000 °

miles, stolen 29 automobiles and
three aircraft. ;
Catching a criminal of this kind
entails a lot of police work. The de-
_ .scription of the Hamilton bank rob-
ber reminded an officer in the FBI's
» Identification Section of a Frank
Sprenz of Akron, Ohio, who, await-
_ ing trial for armed robbery, had
_. broken jail and disappeared.
_ The more special agents discov-

~ ered about Sprenz from: his relatives
_, and acquaintances in, Akron, the

. More certain théy were that he was
' the Hamilton bank robber. They
learned that he was an enthusiastic
~ flier and. that he had a_ peculiar

vanity. Almost bald, he wore a
" toupee and usually a hat even when

_ °, swimming—a sport he enjoyed.
_ These facts went into an FBI -

_ “Wanted” flier sent not only to po-
; lice departments, but to YMCA’s,

toupee sellers, used-car dealers and

airports all over the United States

officials. }
This sort of carefully contrived

FBI web is almost impossible to
_ escape. Sprenz, knowing that he |

was on the Ten Most Wanted Fugi-

_ tives list, managed to make his way
“to the island of Cozumel off the

southeastern coast of Mexico. He
thought he was safe and had settled

in a pleasant thatched cabin on the

beach. But while he was strolling

_—and to Canadian and Mexican -

one day. a car screeched to a halt —

beside him. Two Mexican police
officers had recognized him. Sprenz
is now serving a 25-year federal
sentence. .

To combat the. growing bank-rob-

bery menace, FBI Director Hoover

is conducting a campaign with |

banks and local police forces stress-
ing prevention. During the last year,

teams of FBI experts have been

organizing meetings of principal
bankers in states most affected by
this: peculiar crime wave. At Bear
Mountain, N.Y., recently, 300 bank
executives from New York City and
its suburbs came to hear what the
FBI had to say. They watched a film
taken by one of the new hidden
cameras (which many banks are
now using) of an actual holdup. A
teller had tripped the button that
started the camera. The film had en-
abled police to arrest the two robbers
within a few hours. ° :

The bankers were also shown an
FBI pamphlet entitled “How Banks
Can Help the FBI.” This lists‘ im-

=
E rg . .
F .
ee 9 . ;
: . - .
. ss ¥
. . 7
7
ee © ¥ . rr
. F : si :
7 : = . .
; .
. a 7
£ 2 ~ ° ‘
‘ . .
. . s ‘ i
4 . . . =
° * . x ‘
. ‘ a . . . ¥ e 4
* g ° €
° bd : :
c *. . P \ lad
. ; 3
2 on . °
e .
” :
° .
~ ‘ . °
. a ‘ : oe C :
" . .
* . . \
; .
4 ; x
by 3 : f
5 ‘ s . 7
a . ‘ -?
5 -
A , ”
FA ' : > “‘*
p * - . . ~ -
‘ .
’ - ° . 2 ° .
. .
; ‘ .
‘
4 : o - . . ‘
. be 7
. = a ‘
‘ . . i .
> é e > ,
\g be : ,
3 . . . bs .
4 * :
* : r
% 3 > + . .
. . s 2°
. . «
. \
2 a . e e .
. ' r ;
a : , ra . . oe
$ ‘ 4 ;
‘ > . -
> . F
. g 2
' .
A ‘ : ‘ &% . ‘ ; fe
. be i
. teak

r °
Ss det
SPRINT AN Ni UIE WH Silipos 4 ba see et

40 THE NEWSTYLE BANK ROBBER

". portant pointers for discouraging

bank robbers: properly trained
guards, an efficient alarm system

connected with local police head-

quarters, education of tellers to
know exactly what to do. Most im-
portant is to make a detailed mental
picture of the robber, noting height,
clothing, weapon, speech, etc. -
The FBI has also devised a series
of shrewd tactical devices ‘to help
banks protect themselves. One, for

' example, is a “bank-opening _pro-

cedure.” Several employes arrange
to arrive for work at the same time.
One goes in and searches. If all is

well, he makes a signal visible to -

those outside. This may be the re-
moval of the cover of a certain
typewriter. The employes outside,

_ meanwhile, have observed any cars

.
4

at nearby curbs. The details of the
procedure, at FBI insistence, are
frequently changed. ae
The FBI has» developed other
rules which more and more banks
are following: delivery of payrolls,
for example, at varying hours; a
minimum of ‘cash kept in each
teller’s drawer. A number of bills
listed by denomination and serial.
number and kept in a teller’s drawer
have often been of great aid to police
in tracing the criminal. Bank em-
ployes are trained, in case of a hold-
up, to cordon off the area of attack
afterward so that possible finger-
prints left by the bandit will not be
erased, Other techniques and sys-
tems cannot be disclosed, but Jife
for the bank robber is becoming
harder. ae ae in
| Dp’

16a

APPENDIX E

na Faweett Article ; :

(PHOTOSTATS)
(See opposite our).

‘
bea
?
, .
.
7
~ .
te
'.
.
°
Dd
°
: e
.
c
®
se = : * a
wet) EL LEEI ELAM CLO LORE RENO, SG SETY IS EI hy LORE 5 EE gtr ce BS bisa
AF RN tat Chae PASE BEI 5S has > WA EAA we it I ONE E TIA . SP — ad

RRR em mentees commer reac VES MORI BERLE RNS SINE NO RSS RN RE 5 NRE MOT AM I FN NE HET AE IIE OEY

~

ibe

!
Hid

Hi

Fane ji

eli
faba
i

i

hd unig @

33

raat Hi i

-

ip

eee Ea est i
‘ ‘ia ii i i Hat F i pt ib Be ail He

Tete i ‘if i: if
ia ara int aie ley Paar

rete IMBUE Periz je ql UAE 12 He
iy iad lid! Ae al iy Ei aan a Hay a] He ji Hii i if
staid if BS thy Poe ay HE aE ais aT Hn $275 i
Hit ape ah si hii senda Heddle se
us Baath cellutita: eee at
HTT AHH ET hi HHHEHE RAIA ee
bE Lil 933: Hil BESES 52252223 2% a“ahigi Pee He ES3 5a Ph
85 8 EY rf SES SSeze Pie lel fl
kat hall ai til i au .
l caay RAP g382 445 ie si] es
; Meeiiny ti et | ‘ oy

Hadn't
Didn't

After all, didn’t he have a M.A.?
he co-authored a
and
le was a
Paris
of
=e

ee

customers back
his
went stra
out the door, and
y
scour

Coumeney begged, he went back over

saying a word, he
om ‘
ae
boy
cme 0s bs
od owen ia
Police and FBI

|
(Caillined froin poe 3s)

J
#4

a Perit TaN it
Bey Rar GAT ii i inal Bie Hie i.

»
, - -O
£& ae oe v s \ a.

Sense See

to vault the counter—he had

Soe Fe g2teg geae
ie HH si z in HEL a j us Bt
pare dete
LUHIaH EH OR ere TaHT
jae teceanay ety daeaenely
saviadlictide cantata ay :
ay. Bi esu Merit angparyas
bi bei fe ae alba
7 HCA ee Pile

seetegeggici i#8. ophasdays Tt,

ety CRP tot Eee Sears i gs
ei Ale ae
Abad date
see ae +i SOESS E25 sSacexezeyeeeaseceys p43 8 2 eeazey
Py HIRE iif i eegianieniia TUL ST ert rare
| a ak ihe aft sive fgseie i PaES CoP bu sat aP re if
hae TPP if [ii32 wine SHEL AIH ett + ER A eee
| Pah iS gage = i cf qi H H . THR 4. iP Pbde u

ails bh a it na Lae ile
bis re shady. F Eevee x. a say tja heed 3 i ia!

HH ae HE niet HHO fil Ech 48:33 alli iu Hitt its iHeeuel

so
s

{ |
° ‘
i | ’ =
. ' ‘ y ,
. | e ;
: a |
. } :
o : ,
i
Fy °
. ° x 3 z t
” : :
. ns . J ‘
é é
. . 7
a , F
. . - if
.
f. . . 2
.
. ! °
| : 7
a -
cs ate ' |
- A >
: ‘ .
. ”
F P ’ } ‘
.
anste oe * “ i
: j . . | e
Fp >
| |
- ~ |
; ° |. .
: ’ | | }
7 1 :
* ’ | >
. | 2 od
| *
. “ :
* |
. ° *
oe hex
‘ i
3 ers
. e e 7
: % . . .
= /
. o .” /
y .
x
s “”
* * CE EY SN Nias eae
. ° ee HE fi al - i ‘t iH yarn

| {ies iu fin! uel ti i
oe ay ni; hae gigs qty if itis

eae ti ul di it lee ai ily le Hp TF ij
Ae oe PEPE Hagul if F ofl At siti

. | aie uaa ny
fle} el ia ub lite i nat

aN . re aaq 22 1489 ‘tL

\. i al saat if

aN aqetlle i 4 Ey HH

0 ah ae idl i siti i
ae Hana
vee TIE palin {rut Heinantin a

we.

Sth in et

‘\
\':

\

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385603_0399%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
