# Brief in Opposition to Petition for Writ of Certiorari — National Maritime Union v. National Labor Relations Board

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385603_0271%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Brief in Opposition to Petition for Writ of Certiorari
- **Published:** January 1, 1967
- **Citation:** 386 U.S. 959

## Text

INDEX

ro
3

SN SE inccnsewsncueunescckennawwenes
a ciccscensneerentsen eek aaa
SN SOUND ceed ecencininvntpetcceuncees
Statute involved --....-..--.---- ia wake iimmare
Statement ____--_._--- airs Sas SE eet:
(Eiackcnboveusanaas inciuntemen pA on |
(MIINNLCS cour. cboeecanteteaieneeauceenas 1

‘CITATIONS
Cases:4
~ Local 761, Electrical Workers v. National Lab
Relations Board (General Electric Corp.),

N ational Labor Relations Board v. Carpenters
(Wadsworth Building Co.), 184 F. 2d 60

_ certiorari denied, 341 U.S. 947____- Tone 6
_ National Labor Relations Board v. Fruit &
Vegetable Packers, 377 U.S. 58__._-_------ 9

' National Labor, Relations Board v.: Highway

Truck Drivers, Local 107, 300 F. 2d 317__-- 7.

N ational Labor Relations Board v. International
_ . Rice Milling Co.,; 341 U.S. 665___.-__-__- 6
N ational Labor. Relations Board v. United

Hatters, 286 F.-2d 950..-.-..-....-.-._.- 6
Seafarers Union v. National Labor Relations :
— > Ff See emenmm! 9
Stideerers v. National Labor Relations Board o-
“(Carrier Corp.), 376 U.S. 492___.._....-.-. 6, 7-8
(I) °

246—544— 67

CONN NS =

POLS Pe ay. *T

. re s mle akin ™ om LT See OS
| A :
Statute: | = anes
N alana Labor Relations rrr as amended ,
(61 Stat. 136, 73 Stat. 519, 29 U.S.C. 151,
et ET ETE avnwiaaened an
‘See, 8(6)(4)(B)----------2-2----4 sianiiad ise oars >, ae
Pe
7 td :

s 7
ORR ere een or

In he Supreme Court of the. Cinited State

OCTOBER TERM, 1966

No. 1008.
NationaL Maritimé UNION’ oF home. AFL-CIO,
ET AL., PETITIONERS
. . v. E
_- NationaL Lazsor RELatTIons Boarp

ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED |

STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR a5 EIGHTH OIROUIT |.

‘BRIEF FOR THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
‘ IN OPPOSITAON

OPINIONS BELOW

The opinion of. the court of appeals (Pet. 91-34) hee

is reported at 367 F. 2d 171. The findings of fact,
conclusions of law, and order of the National Labor

Relations Board (R. 1-2, 3-36) * are reported at 152

NLRB 1447,.

JURISDICTION

_ The decree of the court of appeals (Pet. 35-36) |
‘was entered on November 3, 1966. The petition for .

a writ of certiorari was filed on January 27, 1967.

7 “R.” refers to the record in the court below.
: qi). "

wer

FRC IE Te

EAE STR AT TERN PT AE RL TEIN INTER LR
.

. +.
WD seats i Hi 8G ken AN A mince ne ee te ll et eee oe bist ‘ Sw “ .
: ‘

9 ;

e
The jurisdiction of this Court is ‘nde under 28
US. C. 1254(1).

~~ _. QUESTION PRESENTED

‘The union, which had a primary dispute with the
owner of certain barges, picketed those barges at loca-
tions where the owner’s employees performed no work

and the barges were being operated or serviced by
‘neutral employers: The question presented:is whether,
_in the circumstances of this case, the Board properly
_concluded that the union’s picketing at those locations

was secondary -and thus violated Section 8(b) (4) (B)

: of the N ational Labor Relations Act.

STATUTE INVOLVED

The relevant provisions of the National Labor Rela-
tions Act, as amended (61 Stat. 136, 73 Stat. 519, 29
U.S.C. 151, et seq. a); are set forth at. page 20 of the

‘petition.

| STATEMENT

1. The smal i Mid-America Transportation.
Company.—Mid-America ‘Transportation Company
(‘MAT’’) transports commodities by barge on the
Mississippi River, primarily between East St. Louis,

_ Illinois and St. Paul, Minnesota; it hauls coal up-
, Stream and grain on the trip back (R. 4-5, 7). MAT
‘owns the towboats used for. these trips,. the chief one -

being the Eleanor Gordon; it either owns or charters
the barges (R. 7352-53).

The Eleanor Gordon has arf operating crew of about ie
13 employees, whose quarters are located on the tow-

‘boat (R. 9; 59). The crew releases and secures, at

MAT’s docks in East St. Louis, the. barges that the ”

{ .
i

:
ae
Eleanor Gordon has brought downstream, and then
prepares the barges loaded with coal for towing up
to St. Paul, Minnesota, (R. 8; 53-56). While on
the journey up the river, deckhands normally spend
about half of their time on the towboat and half on

the barges | (Re 8-9; 61-62). The barges. are towed |
to a “fleeting area’? or “parking Jot’’ near St. Paul, /

‘where they are released (R. 7, 9; 58, 60, 61-62).
Thereafter; the Eleanor. Gordon picks up its south-
bound tow and returns to St. Louis (R. % 9; 58).
No employees of MAT. remain with the bargés after
they f released at the fleeting area R. 9; 73, T5-
76, 8687, 89-91). ;

Twin City Barge & Towing Coimsindar (“Twin
. City”) provides towing and harbor services in the St.
Paul area for the major barge companies (R. 9; 91-
92, 137-138, 142)? Twin City has done business with
MAT for about six years (R. 10; 97). It transports
the MAT coal-laden barges from the fleeting area to
the dock of the Northern States Power Company, the
ultimate purchaser of the coal. , After the barges have

been emptied and cleaned, . Twin City moves them to

the dock ‘of the Farmers’ Union Grain Terminal
(“Farmers”), where they are loaded with grain, and
then back to the fleeting area (R. 9-10; 12-15; 92,

95). No MAT employees accompany Twin City when’ .

it moves the barges beyond the fleeting area, and
MAT doés not supervise the Twin City employees
in any way (R. 11; 94-95). * | 3

2The City of St. Paul owns the fleeting area, which it leases

~

to Twin City for the use of the latter’ s barge customers (R. 10; —
. 93-94). :

5
PENG SR ae

Pere oF

of: the union that represente
- who agreed to respect, the piket line (R. 15-16; 77-
78, 73).

-4

2. The picketing—On August 1, 1964, petitioner
National Mayne Union of America, which repre-
sents the urlicensed maritime employees of MAT,
ealled a strike against that Company over contract
terms. (R. 7; 126). That morning Union Agent Col-
lileux came to Farmers’ dock in St. Paul and asked
Farmers’ barge-loading employees who were at work
there to support the strike agajnst MAT and eer x.
the picket lines. Collileux was}referred to an official
Farmers’ employees,

Later that day, ame: two MAT barges were ‘eile
at Farmers’ dock,’ Collileux began picketing on public
property near those barges. His sign stated that.the
union was on strike against MAT and had no dispute

with any other employer (R. 17; 70, 71-72, 76-77,

81). Collileux picketed until the Farmers’ employees
left for the day; no MAT barges were loaded during
the picketing (R. 17; 72-73, 76). On August 5, he
returned to the dock while Farmers’ employees: were

loading a MAT barge. When Collileux began to

picket again, Farmers’ employees stopped loading (R.

17-18; 74-75, 80). Neither the employees of, MAT

nor any “of its. towboats were present duri these
two instances of picketing (R. 16, 18; 73, 79). sg
On August 11, a Twin City boat was about. to pick
up -two: MAT barges at the property: of a St. Paul
firm that services barges. ~ One of the Twin City
deckhands saw a picket on the shore with a sign iden-

* The barges had been brought there by the towboat Zom
Thumb, iain by the Pilot = Company (R. 18; -

”

cr —-— <
°

SOSA REN SCR TTS RANTS Pe TITY Te

5

tical to that previously earried by Collileux, and ad-
vised his captain that the barges could\not be han-
dled‘ (R.'5, 11, 19-20; 84-86, 106-107). ! On August
20, the same boat went to the dock of another grain
company to pick up a MAT barge loaded with grain. —
A deckhand again saw a picket on the shore and’ told

_ the captain “‘they did not want to ‘pick up the barge”
" (R. 20; 86-87). Five days later, while another Twin |
City boat was transporting “MAT barges from the.

fleeting area to the Northern States Power Company
plant, it was met by a small craft with a picket (Col-
lileux) aBoard. Collileux asked the captain to untie
the barges, which he did (R. 20-21; 87-89). During

~ all of these incidents, there were no employees of
MAT or “ied of its towboats 1 in the areas (R. 20-21; sll

87, 89-90). : ee
3. The pee and court decisions —The Board -
found that | the union’s. primary dispute was with.

‘MAT; that the situs of that dispute was the MAT

alheaie and barges as they plied between East St.
Louis and the fleeting area in St. Paul; and that.
neither the MAT towboats nor any MAT employees.

- worked. in the St. Paul harbor outside the fleeting

area (R. 29). Accordingly, the Board concluded that
the union’s picketing and related conduct outside that
area was not legitimate primary activity, but sec;
ondary activity barred by Section 8(b)(4)(B) of the
Act (R. 29-34). The Board ordered the union and
its a i iy to cease and desist from the unfair labor

-prattices found (R. 34-36). : pHi ie

2

*Twin City’s deck employees are also members of petitioner

uhion (R. 11, 20). . /

.
Pe. Silla | |
‘The court of appeals sustained the Board’s findings
and enforced its order (Pet. 21-34).
The decision of the court of appeals turns. on 5 its
special facts, constitutes a correct. application of the
relevant legal principles; and is not in conflict with
other decisions. There, is no occasion for further

review. |.
1. Section. 8(b) (4)(B) of the Act (Pet. 20) bars
a union from engaging in secondary strikes or pick-

* eting, but preserves the right to engage in primary

activity. In general, union activity is primary when it
occurs at the situs of the main dispute, which usually
' is the primary employer’s own premises, and seeks no—
more thane to disrupt the normal operation of his
_ business.’ But when the activity is extended beyond
_ the situs of the: primary dispute to the premises of a
neutralemployer, it is ordinarily secondary.” :

‘Applying these principles here, the Board and the
court below Correctly concluded «that the union’s
picketing and related activity at locations above the
fleeting area was secondary. Thus, as the court noted
(Pet. 32-33), ‘‘“MAT’s towboat did no towing above
the fleeting area and ** * MAT’s crew left the
5 See National Labor Relations Board v. International Rice
Milting Co., 341 U.S. 665; Local 761, Electrical Workers v. Na-
tional Labor Relations Board (General Electric Corp.) , 366 U.S.
_ 667; Steelworkers v. National Lgbor Relations Board (Carrier

Corp.) , 376 U.S. 492. ’

6 See National Labor Relations Dowd v. Carpenters (Wads-
worth Bldg. Co.), 184 F. 2d 60 (C.A. 10), certiorari denied, 341

U.S. 947; National Eabor Relations Board v. United Hatters, —
986 F. 2d 950 (GA. ©. |

paws tes Sy Siri = ne eS bp emi Ji tl et aaa
~ °

’

aa 7 .

barges theré and performed no service of any kind
upriver.” Accordingly, when the union picketed the
MAT barges above the fleeting area and while they
were being used by the neutral employers (Twin City, -
Harbor, and Farmers), it extended its economic
pressure beyond the situs of the primary dispute to
“the normal jobsites of secondary employees alone
' * * * and affected their normal work’ at such normal
sites without the accompaniment or even proximate-
ness of primary status” (Pet. 33).. Such an expan-’
sion of the labor dispute is secondary and barred
by Section 8(b) (4) (B). See National Labor, Rela-
_ tions Board v. Highway Qruckdrivers, Local 107, 300:
_ FB. 2d 317 (C.A. 3).

.2. Petitioners contend (Pet. 8-15) that transport-
ing the barges beyond the fleeting area and loading
and cleaning them—all work performed by neutral
employers—was essential to the normal operation of
MAT’s business ;.and that under thissCourt’s decisions
in General Electric Carrier (cited, n. 5, supra),
’ the union was entitléd to picket the performance of

5 such tasks. Although the Court in those eases held

that picketing which sought to disrupt only the day-
_ to- day operations of the struck employer was ‘primary,
the picketing there occurred at, or, immediately adja-
cent to, the primary employer’s plant, which was the
situs of the primary dispute.’ As the Court explained

"In General Electric, the picketing occurred at.a gate ‘to the
primary employer’s plant which had ‘been reserved exclusively
‘for independent contractors and their employees. In Carrier,
it occurred at a railroad: gate which “adjoined company prop-

erty and was in fact the railroad entrance me to the Carrier
. plant” (376 U.S. at 500).. ; : oe

*.

-in Béievior (376-U. s. at 499), treieeas did not intend

to prohibit picketing at the situs of the primary dis-
pute that was intended to reach ‘‘employees of neutral

delivery men furnishing day-to-day service essential to

the plant’s regular operations,’’ since picketing during ~

a strike “‘has characteristically been aimed at all those
approaching the situs whose mission is selling, deliver-
ing or otherwise contributing to the operations which
the strike is endeavoring to halt.’’ ;

But the Court did not hold, as petitioners suggest,
that an appeal to a neutral employee to refrain from
performing work or services which would aid the. op-
erations of the primary employer is permissible where

that appeal is made at a location that is not the situs °

of the primary dispute and at which the employees of

_ the primary employer do not work.’. Here the Board ~

ruled that the situs of the primary dispute was: the
MAT tugboats and barges as they operated on the
river between East St. Louis and the fleeting area in
St. Paul; the union picketing took place, however, at

points in St. Paul that were’ beyond the fleeting |

area and at which no MAT employees worked on the
barges (supra, p pp. 3-5). Thus, the picketing was not

® Indeed, in Carrier tht Court pointed out that, although the
_ location of the picketing is jot decisive, it is nevertheless an
“important” factor (376 U.S. at 499). And, in finding that the
- picketing at the railroad gate was primary, the Court empha-

sized that (2d., at 500, italics added) : “For the purposes of § 8
(b) (4). picketing at a situs so prowimate and related to the em-
ployer’s day-to-day operations is no more illegal than if it had
‘occurred at a gate owned by Carrier.” Cf. the court of appeals’
example iti the present case of picketing the mine or refinery of
MAT’s fuel t suppliers (Pet, 31-82).

A

place.

7 | 7 2 (

at the situs of' the primary ‘dieavate, and it was there-
fore secondary, not primary. |
Nor is the decision below in conflict with Seofarers

9

« 7

_ Union v. National Labor Relations Board, 265 F. 2d :
- 585 (C. A.D.C.), as petitioners. contend (Pet. 15-18).

‘That case, in which the court stated (p. 590) that it :
was not -“mak[ing] a ruling broader than the case

before us,” held only that picketing of a ship in a re-

pair yard, that was primary in its inception because.

employees of the primary employer remained on.

board, did not become secondary when the employer:
temporarily removed those employees from the ship. |

_ The rationale of the decision was that an. -employer .
~* cannot “transform a picket line from a legal one to an

illegal one merely by moving his non-supervisory em-
ployees away” (ibid.). See General Electric, supra
(366 U.S. at 680), where the Court stated: “Of course

an étnployer® may ‘not, by removing all his employees

‘efrom the situs of the strike, bar the union from pub-
licizing its cause * * *.” The present case, however,
as the court below pointed out (Pet. 33), “‘is not a
situation of «the primary employees’ mere absence
from their jobsite;” instead, ‘the barges had ceased
to be the jobsite before —_ Union’s] yomne took

729

‘ ® National Labor Relations Board v. Fruit & . Vegetable
Packers, 377 U.S. 58, also relied on by petitioners (Pet. 11- -
12), is wholly inapposite. There, the union, in furtherance of
its dispute with apple growers, picketed the retail stores han-

: dling those products with signs appealing ‘to consumers not to

buy them. The picketing clearly had the secondary object
proscribed by Section 8(b)(4)(B); the only question. was

- whether Congress had proscribed the means utilized, 7.c., peace-

For the foregoing reasons, the petition for a | writ |

of certiorari should be denied. ’

aaa arc submitted.

-THURGOOD MarsHALL,
| Solicitor General.
ARNOLD ORDMAN, | a ;

. General Counsel,
Dominick L. Manoul, _
Associate General. Vounsel,
Norton J. CoE,
Assistant General Counsel,
National Labor Relations Boare

FEBRUARY 1967. . ” o

ful picketing urging consumers not to buy the disfavored prod-

uct. The present case, on the other hand, involves picketing
addressed not to consumers, but to neutral employees. There
is no question that Congress interdicted -such picketing where,
as here, it is carried on for a secondary object, irrespective of

_- whether it is limited to the primary employer’s “product,” or
calls for a more widespread disruption of the neutral’s business.

“U.S. GOvTSNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 1967

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385603_0271%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
