# Opposition Brief — American Airlines, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385602_1644%3A5

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Opposition Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1966
- **Citation:** 385 U.S. 843

## Text

Ley

Lye weg ° POP ae. Tigre >

. rc. %)
Se ort sh

- IN THE

Supreme Court of ‘the United States

~ Ocroser TERM, 1966 ~

No. 304

* = te
—_ 2

AMERICAN AIRLINES, INC., TRANS WORLD ‘AIRLINES,
Inc., Unttep Amr Lines, Inc., Petitioners, aire

; v. |
| Civ. AERONAUTICS Board, ET AL., Respondents.
“a
‘- BRIEF OF RESPONDENT SLICK CORPORATION
: IN OPPOSITION TO CERTIORARI .

QUESTION PRESENTED

Whether rulemaking by a sears agency dicen.
invalid when it limits existing authority of a class of
- those regulated.

| ‘STATEMENT
‘This respondent (an intervenor in the court below)
adopts the statement of the case contained in the brief.

on behalf of the Civil Aeronautics Hoare i in Sppostiios
to certiorari.

Se:
ARGUMENT
Pig

THE DECISION BELOw IS IN ACCORD WITH THE: APPLICABLE |
DECISIONS OF THIS COURT

‘Petitioners contend, initially, that certiorari should

..° be granted because the Civil Aeronautics Board it-.

self represented to the court below, in — renee
ing en bane, that -

3 ie question of administrative law presented is -
of major importance to the administration of the

Federal ey Act and other similar regula-
tory statutes ...’’ (R. 253) *

The present contention by petitioners is a non-sequitur
in view of the ultimate decision below, which supports
the rulemaking determination by the Board.
_ This is, ve subniit, particularly clear where, as here,
the pre-existing authority, i.e., blocked space, has not
. previously been actually used by the class which claims

se Re e

SF Compare the exercise - the Federal ew p ne of
its similar statutory power of classification, in Superior Oil Com-
pany‘v. Federal Power Commission, .supra, page 2, n. 1 sie F.,
2d 601, C.A. 9, 1963, cert. dae 377 US. 922, Sarma \

4

©q .

_ oe

"Petitioners endeavor to distinguish the decisions of

.the Court. just cited by contending that they apply only

to “‘a threshold refusal to entertain a license applica- _

tion”’ (emphasis supplied), petition 21; but even if
this were a valid interpretation yof this court’s deci-

-siong—which we think it is not—we submit that a limi-

tation on hitherto unused authority is not significantly

different from a limitation on previously unheld au- -

. thority, i in the context of rulemaking.

1. The Nature of Rulemaking

We do not undertake here any ‘tia ‘enable of
the/ legislative or ‘‘rulemaking”’ function of adminis-
trative agencies, as distinguished from their adjudica-
tive function. The majority opinion en banc, below,
reviews the legal characteristics of . this dichotomy

(petition 21a-25a).. The classic statement in this‘court ©

is that of Mr. Justice Holmes. In Prentis v. Atlantic
Coast Line, 211 US. 210 (1908) he said:

“** * * A judicial inquiry snvisitteehhias: declares .

and enforces liabilities as they stand on Briay'o

or past facts and under laws supposed a lready to -
exist. That is its purpose and end. Legislation

‘on the other hand looks to the future and changes

existing conditions by making a new-rule to be |
- applied thereafter to all or some ge, of those...

. — to its power * * *.”? 211 U.

th's legislative type of hearing, such as confronted it

-here, the Civil. Aeronautics Board is not seeking to

.. determine rights of a particular carrier: vis-a-vis an-

other.carrier, but rather is. dealing in terms of cate-

| -gories and classifications of carriers, looking toward

’ the future. In-such a proceeding ‘‘it is not necessary . |
that - full. panoply of judicial ene be used. f:

_

5

Hannah v. Suaibes 363 US. 420, 449) (1960). As has.
been stated by the court below in a oie eariuicns

analogous situation ;
“# * * While fact finding may to some extent he

involved in the process, the due process. require--— |

ments of confrontation and cross-examination, the

hallmarks of the‘ judicial inquiry, are not neces-.

sarily present. Rather the quasi-legislative in-.

' quiry tends to consult broad relevant data avail- |

_able from surveys, studies and published experi-
ence, free from the limitations of confrontation
and cross-examination. Initially, the quasi-legis-

lative inquiry depends on staff work. As here, the ©

staff report often is presented to the interested
_ public with the invitation to appear at'a public
_ hearing to oppose or’ praise. From a practical

_ standpoint, with respect. to some forms of quasi-

legislative inquiries, * * * * this is the only feasible

way to proceed.’’ Jones, et al. v. District of Co- —

lumbia. (116 U.S. App. D.C. 301, 304;. .323 FF. 2d
306, 309 (1963).)

The estéblished distinction rene the logielative:

and judicial types of function of the administrative
agencies is grounded i in practical as well as logical con-
siderations. This is clearly demonstrated kere. The

-. record before the Civil Aeronautics Board indicates on
_ its face the large number of parties involved and the ©

complexity of issues and potential issues which were
‘ adumbrated. Whether or not such was the purpose of
the demands for hearings of an adjudicative type, the

inevitable result of such a proceeding would have been ~
to postpone any effective delineation of carrier roles in -

this: area for many years in the future; and as will

appear from an examination of the history of air
freight in the Civil Aeronautics Board, see II, below, -

- the passenger (‘combination’) carriers may well have

3

| 6 Ok
sipaiait that the struggling all-cargo carriers could not |
‘survive until-the termination of a proceedify of such
complexity and duration. Such a consideration in-

volves, we submit, a vue exercise of the hegumative
function.

IL
_ THE DECISION BELOW IS RIGHT ae
-\. The dissenting opinion below’ proceeds on the basic

. misconception that there has been no legally recognized

classification of freight or ‘‘all-cargo’’ carriers, as ‘dis-
tinguished from passenger, or ‘‘combination”’ carriers.
~ But such a classification was established by the Board
in 1947 and has.existed since. In that year, the Board
adopted a regulatién’ permitting’ qualifying carriers
- to engage in the carriage-of property only. Letters of
Registration were issued under-this regulation to nine -
carriers, including this respondent. In the Air Freight

oN Case, in 1949, the Board decided to regulate this class*

byway of certificate of public convenience and neces-
sity, and granted such certificates to four carriers, in-
cluding this, respondent. » The identity. of this class has ©
since been consistently recognized by. the Board and by
the aviation industry,‘ The dissent is in error in its.
assumption that ‘‘the Civil Aeronautics Board’s result
here is reached by a rule which has different impacts.
‘upon members of the same basic category.”’ (Peti-

‘. tion 37a). The all-cargo carriers are not ‘‘of the same -

basic category”’ as the combination carriers; they are.
of a different category and have been so- since 1947, ,
The fact that their certificates use the same word—
a

8 Section 292.5 of the Board s) Siiaaiahi Regulations adopted
May 5, 1947 (Serial No. 389).

4‘ E.g. Airfreight Certificate Renewal Case, 23 C.A.B. 186 (1956) ; ;
_ Domestic Cargo Mail Service Case, 36 C.A.B. 344 (1962).

7

a

7 Fy
Oviatt defining their authority, as do the cer-

tificates of the combination carriers, seems to have im- |
_ pressed the ee e.g. petition 33a, but. is of no .

—— :

CON CLUSION

Respondent ‘Slick Corporation submits that certi- |
orari should be. denied inasmuch as the decision below
is 1) in accord with the applicable decisions of this
— and 2) is plainly right. . :

© _ Respectfully submitted,

‘FREDERICK A. BALLARD |
— Ceci, A, Beastey, JR.
American Security Building
‘Washington, D. C. 20005
Attorneys for Respondent
The Slick Corporation

- Of Counsel:

~LipMAN RepMAN, Esq, '
815 Connecticut Avenue, N. W.
Washington, D. C. 20006 |

August 29, 1966.

w

—. F Offige Supreme Court, U.S.
Lesser y — j FILED

IPR ks COURT. Us S SEP 211966

Speen Court of the United ‘States

OcroeBER TERM, 1966

AMERICAN AIRLINES, INC., TRANS WoRLD AIRLINES, INC.,
Unirep Arr Lines, INnc., Petitioners,.
v. . |
Civin Arroxautics Boarp, ET AL, Respondents.

ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

REPLY BRIEF FOR PETITIONERS |

Ls.
oo ——

(RR RH EE EA CR RN TT TS TT TT

~Howarp (, Westwoop Y
WituiaM H. ALLEN
Kpwarp J. Grenter, Jr. :
701 Union Trust Building
Washington, D.C. 20005 . . ~

Cart 8S. Rowe
25 Broadway
New York, N. Y. 10004

Warren FE. Baker
640 Shoreham Building -
Washington, D. C. 20005

H. Tempieton Brown

. Of Counsel: ; pom am
oS ’ ha LOYD M,. IVETT
Covinarom® Busisne 231 South LaSalle Street
CHADBOURNE, PaRKE, | = Chicago, Tllinois 60604
Wuiresme & Wo xrFr. |

Attorneys for Petitioners
Mayer, Frrepiicn, Spiess,

Tierney, Brown & Piatr
September 1966.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. The Respondents’ Appeal to Irrélevant Labels ......... Pare

' II. The: Respondents’ Invocation of an Irrelevant ‘Statutory
FEU. nevseevevecierseveies bende eeegue tuhexers _3
. TIL. The Nature of Blocked ian COS ae

IV. The Illusory Assurances ‘that Petitioners ‘Will Not Be
Hurt by Their Competitor’s Low Blocked Space Rates 9

V. The Inadequacy of the Board’s Rulemaking Proceeding:.- 11

“Conclusion ....... _ ier Pee oa bape eee cee ia bass 14

Appendix—Remarks, Before the Federal Bar Association, Sep-
. tember 8, 1966, of Joseph B. Goldman, “General
| Counsel, Civil Acronanties ME kb b-0n0sGci G08 la

.. INDEX TO CITATIONS

Cases: : nae
Air Freight Rate Investigation, 9 C.A.B. 340 (1948) ........ ‘2
' . Arizowa Grocery Co. v. Atchisos, T. & S.F. Ry., 284 US. 370
CHP) cedisvccecectwesvebetes ceseavetessncgestecsess 9
CAB v. Delta Air Lines, 367 U. 8. ey WED sk ckeccesscexs 3,7
Chicago, B. & Q.R:R. v: United States, 242 F. Supp. 414 (N. D.
Ill. 1965), aff’d per curiam, 382 U.S. 422 (1966) .......... 13

FCC v. National Broadcasting Co. (KOA), 319 U.S. 239 (1943) 7

Flying Tiger Line v. Boyd, 244 F. Supp,,889 (D.D.C. 4965),
aff’d without opinion sub nom. Flying hy er Line v. Murphy,
D.C. Cir. No. 19,869, decided June 2, 1986, petition for cert, -

filed August 31, 1966 LOU GEE s eW csndencdntheeceerstse 5
Georgia v. Pennsylvania R.R., 324 U.S. 439 CRORE) s eseres ; oe
Movers Conf. of America v. Umited States, 205 F. Supp. 82

Cy Ms SUED a nied ou OG 06600) 6 0000 Cdasepedeseee sees 3

_ -Prentis v. Atlantic ‘oast Hine Co., 211 US. 210° -¢1908) sadene 2
Superior Oil Co. v. FPC, 322 F. 2d 601 (9th Cir. 1963), cert.

demed, 877 U.S. ‘922 (1964) Leave was oes SouGeweravebsnens 6

- United States v. Seatrain, Lines, 329 U.S. 424 CUNT) an ccicceis 7

United States v. Storer Broadensting Co., 351 U.S. 192 (1956) 15

VU
Pe te Contents Continued |
. Disures and Regulations: : Page

Administrative Procedure Act, 60 Stat. 237, as amended, 5
U.S.C. § 1001 et seg.
i Gkecoususeeasesdnscen SRE eR PN Tee 13

Federal perwrees Act of 1958, 72 Stat. 731, as. amended, 49
U.S.C. § 1301 et ‘seq.

RRC Nay yer rere ne reer c mere me
DEE. Uib dened dnadenseeesteneaks de etsenscetaenets 4
UE “kn hs 4.06 ek nue buedenta use ebbkesesstaneteents 6
000) eee ee ee 3

SE sale phndensandsbasaenednnneasaendatnanes ivekae 4
ID is nk hele Gh 6S RS ewe nea ekete ns Nek eunaeenes 4,5,6

CAB Economic Regulations, 14 C.F.R. Pts. 200-99
Generally ..............-. SeueasseGaassewevaswdesess 5
Bhs GON cheeses csedecdswenceseses Pshbbeasteseeeeteus S
a
: 5° o

| Supreme Court of ‘the Huited States :

OctoBER. TERM, 1966

=

a No. oe

. AMERICAN ‘AIRLINES, INC. TRANS Wortp ATRLINES, Inc. a
| -UNITEp AIR Lanes, INc., Petthionera, i

Sa : Vv.

Civi. AERONAUTICS BOARD, ET AL., Respondents.

& e 7 ‘ ‘
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
.' UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE -
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

ad

* *

REPLY BRIEF FOR PETITIONERS

I. THE RESPONDENTS’ APPEAL TO IRRELEVANT LABELS

The briefs in opposition attempt to defend the action
_of the Civil Aeronautics Board as sustained by the
Court of Appéals by affixing labels like ‘‘legislative’’
and “prescriptive” to the Board’s action, When
action is ‘‘legislative’ rather than ‘‘judicial,”’ so
the argument runs, an agency may proceed by rule-
making rather than pursuant to more formal notice
and hearing procedures. .

oe -

~n. 6), the Board’s Gen

ab}
it is answered; Slick manages this difficulty only by its

Regardless of that, however, the General Counsel

oe question that i is important or not depending on how °

switch from “<questiori,”” which is what the Board said, -
. - to “problem,”? which is Slick ’s paraphrase.

of the Board, a signatory to the Board’s brief in oppo-
. + sition, regards the decision below as “of. coiisiderable i

significafice in the light which it throws oi the seope of ..
rule-making authority” and as holding ‘‘great promise —

for expanded use of rule making.’’ (Pp. 2a, 3a, infra)...

He made these. statements‘in his address to the Federal

Bar Association’ at its’ annual convention on Septem-:

ber 8,_to which we have referred. (Note ‘1, supra).

. His entire address, as published by. the Board, is |
. printed as an a to this — brief at peace .
la-Ta, infra. -

He said that the sit hile *‘euntaiued the Baerd’ *:

_ ~ aetion even though the rule had diminished the licenses
of the combination carriers. without hearing,” and he
‘said that one of the ‘‘ground rules” that the opinion.

suggests the court below ‘will followin its sympathetic © - .

approach "to rule making’’ is: that, ‘‘rule making can -

“be used even where the effect. is'to take action which

would. benefit one class of persons at the expense, so

to speak, of:another.’” ¢P. Ga, infra). And, although
the Board, is in its brief in opposition here by citation

analogizes this case to those cases, notably United
States v. Storer Broadcasting Co.; 351 US. 192 (1956),

earefully distinguished _ tween “rule making as.a

* means of carving out eat ories of license applications.
- that could be denied without-an adjudicatory hearing”’

(1.e., the Storer type case) and ‘‘the blocked-space type

@

in which threshohd limitations on license applications ~
~ . havé been sustained by this Court: (Br. in Opp. p. 8
il Counsel in his remarks-—~~

-of rule making that permits a diminution in the existing -

16 | note

- rights of a given is slem of aes without a hearing. oa
- (Pp. 6a-Ta, infra).

—_ the ‘‘blocked-space type of rule velaities” dimin-
ishing Ticense Tights. without a hearing, permissible
. within the terms~of the governing statute and. this
, Court’s decisions? That question is novel‘and of the
. utmost importance. The _ petition should be ns

Respectfully submittéd, | a5

at | Howarp 0. Wzstwoop ~
~ Wrenam H. AvtEN'
Epwanp J. GRENIER, JR.
701 Union Trust Building —
Washington, D:0. 20005 &
~ Cart 8, Rows
25 Broadway
Ngw York, N.Y. 10004
WakkEN E. BAKER
640 Shoreham Building -
Washington, D.C. 20005
H. TEMPLETON Brown
Rosert L. STERN :
FroyvoM.Rerr sw g
. +231 South LaSalle Street _
+ Chicago, Illinois ‘60604 .
cena : Attorneys.for Petitioners
Of Counsel: | Reet Sie = |
. CoviNeton & Buriina
_ GHapsourne, PARKE,
WHITESIDE & WOLFF
‘Mayer, FRIEDLICH, SPrEss,
‘TIERNEY, Brown & PLatr
September 1966 .

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385602_1644%3A5. Public record. Not legal advice.
