# Respondent Brief in Opposition — American News Co. v. Federal Trade Commission

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385601_0436%3A3

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Respondent Brief in Opposition
- **Published:** January 1, 1962
- **Citation:** 371 U.S. 824

## Text

UNITED STATES COURT OF
‘FOR THR | SIXTH scien

" PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI |

ORARY 'Oftice- careon Court, US.
a5 f+ £ : foe et FIL ED
7 ca &
es AUG 16 1982
: JOHN F: DAVIS, SLERK
J - * .
Paes oe 7)
‘ { dN - ‘ woh . a4
: fs &
In the -
om Court of the United States
: October a 1962
THE. PENNSYLVAN IA’ RAILROAD COMPANY,
Mee ay Petitioner,
GEORGE ‘W. GOWINS,
peindy Respondent. ‘

_ C. Ricuarp Gaieser, :
8 East Broad Street, Columbus 15, Ohio, ~ —
Attorney for pe: ie

ay:
MIDWEST LAW PRINTERS AND PUBLISHERS, INC., Columbus 15, Ohio

INDEX
Curatnon Freres a). 5. ne oe ee Se See
Statutes and Regulations Involved oo. 000004... 4. ee
Statement of the Oe epee caw ene a
Argument a yan Tee iether Coy etek eee roneg i
Cases Cited =. °: : .
Afoh let vs, Ne w York hie ‘avo & St. Louis R. Ce. -
339 US. 6 eke Spey mr pew t ol Haprn fy BH rf oe Ce
( Calabritto vs. New York, New Haven & H: wtford R. |
Cos Zed Pele ese Se vines Rolie eae US DP ee Aye i
Cartervs. Atlanta & St. Andrews Bay R. Co.
See Rae. OR oe rare bea Rr pee oF ee aes eo Y
Coray vs. Southern Pacifie Company —- - - '
oy if Je eee Aenean rrr a eee Sire a
Ford vs. New York; New Haver & Hartford R. Co. | ;
on Red. 2d 342, cert. denied, 280 US. 549 ; Get ee
Gibson Vs. Elgin, Joliet & Kastern cipishei C ompany
246 Fed. Oe Be ree hee Sa eee eee WW
Givens vs. Missour- Kansas Texas R. ro 0. oF Texas. *
195 Fed. 2d 2 » = EERO a AUN AOR MORE Hin IR eal R Se ree eee
Harris vs. Pennsylvania Railroad Company.
SO es ty, DR, Seligman eg PO Pears pee Oe raat, 12.
Harsh’ vs. Terminal R. ‘oe. ‘
Td Sup. ('t. 362, reversing 114 N. K. 22d 90" i
Lavender vs. Kurn ‘ ea
ie Ue Me Rea at ie en es Coe te hte es 12, 13.
_ Jilly vs. Grand Trank We stern R. Co. *
, RIT USIASD ee, he are Satna G7, % 10, 12
i

McCarthy vs. Pennsyivania Rail coal: t. omipany a ert

- A Fed. 2a | ieee ee oe on ewe ewe eds 6 6 6% 11

Minthart v=. Southe ou he ari fic Comp its Sie geginn tee

RT Sree RS EE eae oe
Ne ™w Yawk, New Hagen & Flestford At Co.Vvs, Leary nt > ,
‘ HM Bed. 2d 461 ath Peo eee e alae: 6 1252 at a :
Rogers vs. Missouri Pacific Haile C‘ommiany . -
eet ON ee ees errs oo Ce
« Sehulz,- Adm. vs. Ponneyvivanice Railroad © company
OO Sy = BED eee eerie 3 UE earner +a
Urie ¥ » Thompson, Truster - ats
shir I ee ae es gohan 5a sn oO x oOo 11 ;
| Authorities Cited | ff
Tithe 45, Los. aii as +, Cp Sr os a er Ss Fe Oe hi. 1
“Tifle, 45.0 SO a) eee ee YY Ree ms oy ee
p22) Regulations of Inter-fate Cotumercee Commission: yer
Code of Federal Regulation-~ ar a.
ae ack Tithe 49, Part 91 , cy ans
: is) Sverimr$h2ua 4, eee cect ac eserevs aot 1h Fae
etna Sa eee: Os COD ok od oc nee 0 ee
> Section 91.229 (a) and (dp coe... sO su
. - e te * e 2 2
“ii -
alternative te stion preseple “doit that oourt,

-_
,

%.

ra A -4

which alternative «juestion was based npon the claim that
certain excluded testimony sheuld have been admitted

: at the trial as evidence, The-exeluded testimony bearing
\ on the issue of the Boiler Inspection Act was that of
respondent on redirect examination, which rt-direet ex-
amination was’in response to. cross-examination on’ thé
violation of rule 1407 -6f the petitioner. The testimony

wax ordered stricken by the Distriet Court-in the follow-

e. ing proceedings (R. 80a) : .

q. Alf right. “Now, .he als 8 >.
. of [- - °
ie as .
i *
- e@
.
,
Pe
* .
. ar
wf » .
’
; ‘
°.
°
o 3 ,
s
- :
of .
6
* *
. sd .
, , aed

6
ARGUMENT. + >:

*

he Molding: that respondent's elaim tor damages nnder
the Boiler Inspection Set should have been submitted’

.to the jury, the United States Conrt of Appeals for the

Sixth Cireuit Fis applying the controlling |i&w as, ane
nounced by this Court. The evidence admitted at the

trial presented issues for the jury’s determination of |

(1)- the violation of the Boiler Tnspeéetion Act’ and (2)
whether such violation caused in whole or in part, that
is, “played any part, even the slightest, in producing,””

respondent's injuries. - Lilly vs. Grand Trunk, Western.

Ruilroad Company, 317 U.S. A481, ane Roar rs vs, Missoprie
Pacific: Railw ay Company, 352.T.S. 50). :
The respondent; cadlopts the sound opinion of the U nited
States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Cireuit on’ the fore-
going points, which opinion ‘is ‘a, conclusive atiswer to’

_the contentions made by petitioper in the Petition for

Certiorari. The respondent will elaborate only to “expose

‘further the fallacies and inaccuracies contained in the. —

Petition’
‘First, under the eltiige ‘of this Coirt in Lilly fa:
Grand Trunk Western Railroad, Company, DVT UL S48,
supra, it was encumbent ‘upon the trial court to submit
the issue of the violation of the: Boiler Inspection Act
to the jury. This. requirement stemmed both from the

command. of the. general Janguage contained in the per-

tineut section (Title 45, U.S.C., Section 23) and from

‘the regulation promulgated by the Interstate Commerce

Commission which under sii statute aequired the force
of law. (C.FLR., Title 49, Part 91, Section 91.229(a) and
(d)) This Court in the Lilly case expressly rejected the
contention which petitioner is now trying to resurrect,
namely, that the Act covers only defects in” Construction. ’

Oe Sie : ;

or mérhanical operation and does not protect agaist the

‘ presence of dangerous foreign matters or objects. In

1943, almost, twellty vears ago, this Court. “put “that eon-

‘tention ‘to rest in the case of Lally &s. Granih Trunk Western

Railroad ¢ ‘ompouy,. 317 UUS. 481: at page ABI; °°...

oo dm various cases denying recovery under The
Act, respondent attempt. to extract a general rule «
that the Net covers only defects: in construction or
nie hanical operation and atfords ne protec tion againnd

‘the presénee, of daig ons objects or foreign matter,
But there is no warrant. in the language of- the. Net
for construing it se narrowly, or for denying the
Commission power to remedy shortcomings, other
than purely niechanical defects, whiely may make opera
tion uusafe. The Act without Jimitation speaks. of

‘ eqnipment ‘in proper condition and’ safe to operate
3 . Without tinnecessary peril te life or limb" Con.
diftons other than me chanical imperteetions ean plainly
render equipment unsafe to operate without mincees
sary peril’ to life or limb. Whatever else may be
said about the cases relicd upon by wespondent, they
are sufficiently distinguishable in that they eithes
did not invelve or did not consider Rule 153 of any
comparable regulation." °

The foregoing staterhent and helelinnge be this Court is *
extremely significant, for the jury in the Lilly ease ex-
pressly and specially, found that these: was no mechanical
or physical defect (a leak im the tank) “as claimed and
alleged’ by the employee. | The presence of the dangerons.
foreign substatice (water and ice) wats sufficient, - “piet xe,
to support a. finding that the Net was violated.

While it ix true that the Lilly exe did-involve a rule of
the Interstate® Commerce Commission, the for: going lan
euage strongly (if net couelusively ) shows that the same
result ‘would follow under the provisions. of the Aét.

Even absent’ such a rule as that invelved in the imstapt
case, therefore, a jury issue was presented on the viola-

a

-

tion of the Boiler’ Inspection Net. Calabritto vs. New

York, New Haven & Hartford RR. Co. 287 Fed. 2d 394;
Minchart vs. Southern “Pacific ¢ ‘OM puny, 2887 P. 2c 999.

_ The fnterstate Commerce re OMMMISSIOn, however pur
stant to the authority ‘contained 710 the foregoihey Act:
did) promulgate a’ reguiation which applies squarely to:

the faets in the instant case. Code of F ederal Regulations,
Tithe 49, Chapter 1, Subpart {* other than steam loge

Ps ¢ 2 ‘ 6
wotives and appurtenances, Section 91.229: 7

“Cubs ad Aprous. + (ia), Delinition. The word ‘cal’
as used fi this subpart means that portion of the super

~tgueture. utilized for housing the engimemen and parts -

or aponeteni inGes of the locomotive and through which
Pussageway ts. prov ided for. the use of the engine

: .
Ten, 4
5 2 a 5 T.., & * s x $ ,
. a.

id) Flours. Deck plates ‘and Aire of cabs, puis -

~ageways and compartments shall be kept free fromm
oil, waste, or any obstruction that will Greate umieces-
msary peril, Deck: plates and metal floors shall be
-praperty ronghened, or other Provisions mule, fo af
ford: SeCUre: fboting. ee

«

raven | a a a a - : > a
The walkways involyedsin this case were ‘passageways
within the foregoing rule, for they provided .the . ouly
means of goin. into and out from the eab. The rule Spe-

cifically requires’ shat such “passageways © * "shall be

kept free from oil, * * * .°° The pertinent portion of the

wre ‘wulation involved ir the Lally case provided , that the ‘tap

of tender behind fuer space shall be kept clean,
This Court in interpreting the foregoing languhge of the
rile involved itr the cave of Lilly rs. Grand Tronk Western
Railroad C1 OnLPanit, 317 UUS=481, stated at pages 486,487

“rom thi-phrasing of "Rule a we Uetik ot aimed
at requiring the top of the tender © kept tree ot
. . foreign maiter which would rendet

*
° ’ oe
“

tla Itsecyure,
*

cd
‘

a es
‘for example . coal, dust, debris, grease, Wis ste water,
and ice, White the: locomotive ink pection rules are
generally devéted to details of construction and speci-
. fication ‘of amaterials, at least one other rule dei =
with the Gondition of surfaces upon which eitiployers

mitist stapes Tm usiie: the word * clean’ the Comunissiow
must have meat something more than mere manner of”

ceomstruction or mechanient! operation, because telean’
does nit naturaliv lend itself to sueh a limited con
notation. That something more is the contimang duty
of promoting the safety of employees by removing
from the top of ‘the tender afl extraneous substiner=

which might make standing there hazardous! < (Pun.

phax: “Is ss april ee i ee
A fortiort, the pertinent: language of the Rule ivvolp my
.in the instant case, that the passageways **shall/ be ke yt
free-from oil,’ could only mean that the © omission wits
imposing a a’ outinuing duty on the railrjad to poh the
passageways free from oil. :

Petitioner's comention that such a reinirenient relates
only:to the time of daily inspection, ancl not ‘to any sub.
sequent violations, ix completely out of harmony with the

plan language of the rules and with the decisions of this:

Court holding that the railroad has.a continuing duty

— fo conform to the’ requirements of the Boiler Inspection .
Act. Section 91.203 (a). a portion of which is set forth

-in petitioner's petition at page 3, does not limit the etree
of Section 91.2290 (d) as contended by petitioner, Seetion
91.203(a) relates only to Juspeetions and reports thercot

that ave required tobe made. It has no direet reference:

to and does not, limit the. foregoing Section 91.229(d). In
fact, Sec tion: 91.2034) specifically states -that othe rule
* preseribes eomly the minimum ‘number of inspections re

quired and is not: intended to prevent the railroad fromy

thaking additional ‘Mspections.

”

10 -

Seetion 9YL200(a) or the contrary docs by its term

‘relate to the entire, subpart containing the rules in ques

tien, inclucting Seetion 91.229( a) and (a). The. former
seCtion, pkices upon the rairead an absolute duty that i!
“must know”? that inspections, tests, repairs and on
are made and filed, ‘cued that ‘all parts aud ap purty nance:

of every locomotive used ‘must be mainte ined int condition

to meet reqairements of the law and the rules 2 ma LP
this subpart.’ (Emphasis supplied) The foregoing rule.’
therefore; by its express terms places a duty upon =the
railroad not only te makesand file all Inspections, tests,

repairs and reports, but inj addition a’duty to maintain
‘all parts and ‘ippurtenanees in-condition to meet sthe ore

quirements’ of the ruleS in the subpart, one of which re.
quirements is the clear unqualitied command that ‘ps.

“sagveways shall be kept free from oil?’ Section 912008,"

fherefore, expressly rejects the limited effect, that pet
tioner Contemds for, in its Petition:
‘OF course, the foregoing rule is only a codification of °
common sense and in harmony with the Aet‘and the helding
in Lilly vs. Grand Trunk Westeru Railroad Company,
317, USS. 481, supra. {t would indeed be idle Lo require
the raitroad to meet the requirements of the Act and the
rules” “proniulgs ated thereunder oly at the time of daily
inspection prior to the use oft the locomotive. The Net
(Title 45, U.S.C. Section 23) specitic ally refers to a loco.

motive in ase”* oon the line. The himanit: arian PUrpose
of th Aet, InorEeoter : wonld be thwarted, for. the employer

wold be deprived of the protection at the very time when

he needs it, namely, during: the use of the locomotive,

The issue of the vielation of that Act, therefore, shontld

‘Have been submitted to the jury under. the holding of

this court and the pertinent rules of} the EnterState (Com
Fe ae r ~ . -
oO

mission. The Aet and the rules clearly protect against the

“presence of dangerous fore ‘igy Matters, in this instance.

by express réference to oil, and place pon petitioner at
- continuing duty to comply with the requirements of the
Net and the rules while the leeomotive is im use on re
spondent” ~ line. ;

Petitioner's second major premise ts ‘that if there: Wis -

evidence of a violation of the Boiler Inispection Act, pene
Viol: ition wis as ao matter of law not a proximate cause

of respondent's alleged injuries, Flix conte tion is tike-

Wise contrary fo the — of this Court. The Boiler
Tispeetion Aet (Tithe 45, US.C., Sections 22, et sed) and
the Federal Renplond Liability Net (Tithe 45, U.S.C,

Sections Olet seq) are in pari materia: or stated in anothemyp

Way, the Boiler Inspection Act is substantially, if net in
formoan Amendment te. the. Federal Employers’ Liability

Net: Utre vs: Thompson, Trustee, 337. US, 1633,. ISS-ISQ: .

MeCarthy vs. Pe wusilrania ‘Railroad Company, 16 Fed,
ZU-S77. Accordingly, if the Violation of the absolute duty

cunder-the Boiler Inspection Act (dispensing with the re..

‘quirement of negligence) caused ‘in whole or iw part’
(the test) for eausation. under the Federal. Kinplovers’
Liability Act, Tithe 45, ULS.C, Si tion O1) the injuries
to respondent, the petitioner is liable. In the leading Case
of Rogers vs. Missouri-Pacific Railroad, Company, 352 US.
OOO, the statutory test for a Jury question on cabin

was held to be whether the negligence “played any part,

even the slightest; in producing? the injuries. Se here.
if the wyidence is such that it jury may conclude with
reason that oil on the swalkways plaved any part, even
the slightest, in produéing the injuries to respondent, then
that issue should have bean submitte dito the jury. Certainly

the, jury could. have found with reason that responde nf
7

Fd

12

acquired oi] on his shoes while walking on walkways covered
with oil “all the time*? and that some of the oil remained
on his shoes up until the time that he slipped and tripped _
and, therefore, caused at least in ‘the slightest part his
resulting injuries. That-such a finding would involve some
" spee ufation and conjecture or that other findings and other’
causes of the injuries could reasonably be made will not
and did not justify the District Court from taking the isstie
from the pe Rogers us. Missouri-Pacific Railroad’ Com--
pany, 3920. S. 900, 906-907, supra; Lavender vs. Kurn,
327 U.S. 64), 653: Harris vs. Pennsylvania Railroad C'om-
‘pany, 80 Sup Ct. 22; Schulz, Admrs. vs. Pemisylvania

Railroad {fompany, 390 US. 523; and Gibson vs. Elgin, «
Joliet & Eastern Railroad Company, 246, Fed. 20 834.
The. decision of the Sixth Cireuit Court of Appeals on
the issue of the Boiler Ins <pection Act was, in summary,
in coniplete accord: with the decisions of this Court and the
applic ible statutes and rues of the Interstate Commeree
Commission, [4 may or may not be that the Cirenit Court's
decision herein was in conflict: with thet “of othe Second
Cireuit rendered in 1931-in the Cue of Ford vs. New York,
N.H. d& H.R. Co. 54 Fed. 2d 342, cert. denied, 285 US.
549,’ (no: rule of the Interstate Commerce Commission
was involved therein); if so, the Ford case has heen over-
ruled by this Court in the ease of Lilly ¢s. Grand Trunk
RR. Co. 317 US. 481, supra, which squarely held that the
Act was applic ible to a foreign. substane “ although ne
defect of construction or mechanics was present. The /
controlling and. indisputable point. is that the decision ‘of -
the Sixth (ireuit was in accord with the Lilly case and
subsequent decisions tinder the Act, including the pre-.
viously cited: cases of Calabritto rs. New York: N.U. & He.
: R. Co., 287 Fed. 2d 394, supra (dee idea hy the same See ond

» ° 5 =

@ircnit’ Court of Appeals), and Minehart =o s. Southern

Pacific Co., 288 PL 24 999.

Similarly, on the isstte of causation the decision of the

Sixth Cireuit is in complete harmony With the “myriad

of cases decided by this-Court and Cirenit € ‘ourts, including
e ° r

the leaditig case articulating the controlling test for canssa

tion, Rogers rs. Missouri- ‘Pacific. Railroad Company, bab

UUS. 500, supra, the leading case permitting bread scope:

to the jiry in speeutation and conjecture, Lavendir vs.

Kurn, 327 US. GAS. supra, and the many analogous deed

sions. applying: the same pringiples to violations ef the:

Safety Appliances Act and the Boiler | ispection Act,

Harsh ics. Perminal R. Ce ie Sup. | ey: 362. reversing Ti4 |

NE. 2d 901; Coray rs, Southe ru Pacific Co, BB pe wth:
Carter vs, Athanta & 7. Aud reves Bay R. Co. 338 ELS.
$305 Affolde r V's. x. Va Chir age d St L. Re €o., 339 US.
i): Ne uw York. Ne iu Hlar on ct Hartford R. (" , om Lie anes,
204 Fed. 2d 461; GITOUS Vs, Missouri-K ausas-Teras ROCA

of Te vas, VW Fed. ee a : i a
In short, we submit to this Court that there is, no reason

to-review the decision of the Sixth Cireuit on the Boiler. -

Pispection Act by writ of certiorari whether viewed from

the consider rations set forth in Rule 19 of ase Court or

otherwise. - sa
eer submitted,

| Ricuanp GkIESER, |
S’ Kast Deans Street, Columbus 15, Ohio.-

. o \

\ ~ Attorney for Respondent,

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385601_0436%3A3. Public record. Not legal advice.
