# Appendix — Clemente v. United States

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385018_0888%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1986
- **Citation:** 474 U.S. 1101

## Text

f —
85 ion 6 8 » ¥ | Supreme Court, U.S,

FILED
OCT 16 i968

JOSEPH F. 5

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITE] STATE6i2p. — !*

October Term, 1985

No.

tee,

LOWENE R. CLEMENTE,
Petitioner,
vs.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA;
UNITED STATES AIR FORCE, a
military department of the
United States of America,
with VERNE ORR, Secretary;
RONALD J. BISHOP, JR.; HAROLD
L. PRAY; CHARLES L. BROWER;
PHILLIP G. SENESCHAL; HARRY W.
JOHNSTONE; and JEFFREY W.
COOK,

Respondents.

i i ed

APPENDIX TO
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT

S. TIMOTHY BUYNAK, JR.
HATCH AND PARENT

21 E. Carrillo Street
Santa Barbara, CA 93101
(805) 963-9231

Attorneys for Petitioner

ie
*
oa.
a
*
7

"

INDEX TO APPENDIX

Appendix A:

Opinion, U.S. Court

of Appeals, Ninth
Circuit, dated July 24,
1985, reported at

766 F.2d 1358

Appendix B:

Decision, U.S. District
Court, Central District

of California, dated August
12, 1983, reported at

568 F.Supp. 1150

Judgment, U.S. District
Court, Central District
of California, dated
August 12, 1983

Memorandum, U.S.
Court of Appeals,
Ninth Circuit,
dated December 14,
1984

Decision and Order
Remanding Case and
Dismissing Without
Prejudice, U.S.
District Court, Central
District of California,
dated April 30, 1980
reported at 488 F.Supp.
854

38

138

145

151

Judgment Remanding
Proceeding for Admin-
istrative Processing

and Dismissing Complaint
Without Prejudice to
Reopening or to Filing of
New Complaint, U.S.
District Court, Central
District of California,

dated April 30, 1980 160
Notice of Reduction in

Force -- Job Offer,

Department of the Air

Force, dated May 12, 1977 165

Notice of Final Air

Force Decision,

Department of the Air

Force, dated November

19, 1980 170

Appendix C:

Judgment, U.S. Court

of Appeals, Ninth Circuit,

dated July 24, 1985 175
Appendix D:

Paragraph 33, Air Force

Regulation 40-713, dated
October 20, 1975 177

aiiea

APPENDIX A

FOR PUBLICATION
Filed July 24, 1985
CLERK, U.S. COURT OF APPEALS

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT

LOWENE R. CLEMENTE, ) CA No. 83-6187
) DC No. 80-5746
Plaintiff/Appellee )

UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA, UNITED

STATES AIR FORCE, a
military department

of the United States of
America, with VERNE ORR,
Secretary, of the United
States Air Force,

RONALD J. BISHOP,

JR., HARO.D L. PRAY,
CHARLES L. BROWER,
PHILLIP G. SENESCHAL,
HARRY W. JOHNSTONE,

)

)

)

)

)

)

)OPINION

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)
and JEFFREY W. COOK, )

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

Defendants/Appellants.

LOWENE R. CLEMENTE,

Plaintiff/Appellee,

CA No. 83-6186
DC No. 79-3952

UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA, UNITED STATES
AIR FORCE, a military
department of the
United States of
America, with VERNE ORR,

ele

Secretary of the

United States Air Force,
RONALD J. BISHOP, JR.,
HAROLD L. PRAY; CHARLES
L. BROWER; PHILLIP G.
SENESCHAL; HARRY W.
JOHNSTONE; and JEFFREY
W. COOK,

Defendants/Appellants.
LOWENE R. CLEMENTE,

CA No. 83-6430
DC No. 80-5746

Plaintiff/Appellee

UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT
OF THE AIR FORCE AND
VERNE ORR, SECRETARY OF
THE UNITED STATES
DEPARTMENT OF THE

AIR FORCE,

Defendants/Appellants.

ttt ttt ee ee ee ee eee

Appeal from the United States
District Court
for the Central District of California
Andrew A. Hauk, District Judge, Presiding
Argued and Submitted December 14, 1984 -
San Francisco, California

BEFORE: CHOY, CANBY AND NORRIS, CIRCUIT
JUDGES.
CANBY, CIRCUIT JUDGE:
Plaintiff, a white civilian Air Force
employee, brought an employment discrimina-

tion action after an Air Force “reduction

o2e

in force" (RIF) resulted in her reassign-
ment. She also asserted due process
violations arising out of the alleged
failure of Air Force officials fully to
process her discrimination claims.
Defendants challenge the district
court's rulings that plaintiff: (1) had
demonstrated retaliatory discrimination

entitling her to back pay and “seniority

relief;" and (2) had established a vio-
lation of her administrative due process
rights entitling her to "“Bivens-type"
compensatory and punitive damages against
the United States, the U.S. Air Force, the
Secretary of the Air Force, and named Air
Force officers and employees. Defendant
Secretary of the Air Force also chailenges
an order of the district court holding the
Secretary in contempt. We reverse the
judgment for damages and vacate the

contempt order.

o3e

Iie acclaim

BACKGROUND .

Plaintiff Lowene Clemente, a
Civilian Air Force employee, originally
filed an action in district court alleging
(1) reverse racial discrimination; (2)
coercive and retaliatory measures taken
against her for filing administrative
claims; (3) denial of reemployment priority
rights; and (4) improper implementation of
a reduction in force. The complaint was an
out growth of an EEO proceeding which began
in 1977, when Clemente appealed her RIF
reassignment, on race discrimination and
other grounds, to the Federal Employee
Appeals Authority (FEAA).

The FEAA notified the Air Force
that under applicable Civil Service
regulations, two alternative methods were
available to process Clemente's appeal:
that set forth in 5 C.F.R. Part 351 or that
in 5 C.F.R. Part 713. 7 A further
regulation then in effect provided that

she

If the appellant has not been
informed of the separate rights
of appeal, the Appeals Authority
shall refer the matter to the
agency so the agency may explain
the alternative rights of appeal
to the appellant as provided in §
713.236 of Part 713 of this
chapter and afford him the
opportunity, if appropriate, to
elect the avenue of appeal he
wishes to pursue.
5 C.F.R. section 772.306(a) (1977). The FEAA
requested the Air Force to secure plain-
tiff's election in writing. Clemente was
contacted by a representative of her
employing facility, Vandenberg Air Force
Base, and informed of the two options. On
advice of counsel, she failed to respond.
Meanwhile, the FEAA sent two letters
to Vandenberg in an effort to ascertain the
appellate option Clemente had elected. Upon

aRe

notification by Vandenberg that no response
had been received to its letter requesting
an election, the FEAA notified Clemente's
counsel that her "Part 351" appeal had been
cancelled.

Shortly thereafter, Clemente secured
new counsel. Her new attorney promptly
wrote the FEAA and Vandenberg, informing
each that Clemente assumed that her Part
713 appeal was still being processed. The
FEAA's response noted that the Part 351
appeal had been cancelled, and the Part 713
appeal was to be handled by officials at
Vandenberg.

Under Air Force regulations,

If the complainant elects to proceed

under FPM Chapter 713, after having

been specifically informed of his
right to use the other appellate
system, then the entire matter,

including the merits of the action,

will be reviewed under this regu-

lation.

AFR 40-713, section 33 (emphasis added).
Pursuant to this regulation, an EEO coun-
selor was assigned to interview Clemente
and explore her RIF and discrimination
claims. After the interview, Clemente was
notified of her right to file a formal
discrimination complaint, and she did so.
This formal complaint was rejected by the
Air Force as untimely. Her initial com-
plaint in district court followed.

In April 1980, the district court
issued a decision. Finding a failure by the
Air Force properly to process Clemente's
complaints, the court remanded the "com-
plaints of plaintiff as presented herein"
to Vandenberg AFB "for continuous and
diligent administrative processing by the
Defendants under applicable Air Force
regulations.” 568 F. Supp. at 1156. The
court admonished that "[s]aid processing

~

should be accomplished in strict compliance
with applicable Air Force regulations,
should involve all stages of administrative
processing entailed therein, and should be
conducted so as to insure Plaintiff her
full rights in said proceedings and a fair

adjudication of her complaints." Id.

Following the district court's remand
and this court's unpublished opinion
dismissing defendants’ appeal for lack of

finality, Clemente v. United States, No.

80-5508 (9th Cir. Dec. 14, 1981), defendant
Johnstone was appointed by the Air Force to
investigate Clemente's claims. In an
initial meeting, Clemente and her counsel
presented Johnstone with aR Cem Re aap ee dee Pes

retaliate against plaintiff by

-
De kde o>

‘cancelling out her position as EAM

aa aut

Project Planner (Grade 7) and

"busting” or downgrading her to Clerk

Typist (Grade 4), attempted to

oe Heine Ree RD BGR

accomplish their planned reprisal.

-132-

But this backfired when all the
government could produce was this

photocopy, which did not even have

plaintiff's name on it, was rife with
illegible handwritten notations, and
covered with blank spaces obviously
rendered blank, before photocopying,
but the use of opaque tapes and
erasures. These outrageous and

transparent ex post facto, but

-ultimately self-defeating, alterations
were only the worst of the several
efforts made at Vandenberg Air Force
Base in the vain undertaking to
legitimize the reprisals and
retaliatory activity taken against
plaintiff. When the government

finally had to admit that the original

of this Form 52 could not be found
hecause it had probably been destroyed

in violation of Air Force rules and

-133-

regulations, the misconduct of

defendants was sealed.

-134-

Footnote 2 Reference page 98
As previously described in greater
detail, the combined claims and
complaints of plaintiff could hae
been effectively processed under Air
Force Regulations, particularly AFR
40-713, thereby dispensing with the
need of an appeal to any outside
agency. Rather than looking upon the
failure and refusal to process three
of plaintiff's claims and complaints
as a forced and therefore excusable
inability to accomplish the processing
under Air Force Regulations, it is the
firm conclusion of this Court, follow-
ing its extensive review of the
exhibits in evidence and the testimony
at trial, that plaintiff's grievances
were all matters with which the Air
Force simply, stubbornly, and

contemptuously chose not to deal.

-135-

Footnote 3 Reference page 101
As the Ninth Circuit, in its
unpublished opinion of December 14,
1981, dismissing the earlier appeal of
this case, observed:

Not to be outdone by the confused
state of the proceedings, the govern-
ment seems to have changed theories of
defense at every turn. It rejected
Mrs. Clemente's first complaint as
premature and her second complaint as
untimely. Similarly, its brief on
appeal argues that Mrs. Clemente's
failure to contact an EEOC counselor
within 30 days precluded district
court jurisdiction, but at oral
argument the government contended that
her failure to exhaust administrative

remedies prevents review. Clemente v.

United States of America, et al., No.

80-5508, Slip Op. at 1 (9th Cir.
1981).
-136-

Footnote 4 Reference page 110
The Court recognizes that this
assertion is directly contrary to
justice Powell's dissenting opinion in.
Owens at 445 U.S. 622, 670 n. 12.
However, the principles articulated by

the majority in Owen should be and are

extended here to the federal govern-

ment which, as conceded by Justice

Powell, has a much greater financial
| ability to absorb such judgments than

a municipal government. Id. at 670.

-137-

FILED Aug 12, 1980
CLERK, U.S. DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

LOWENE R. CLEMENTE,
Plaintiff,
-V=

UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA, and UNITED
STATES AIR FORCE, a
military department of
the United States of
America, with HANS

M. MARK, Secretary;
RONALD J. BISHOP,
JR., HAROLD L. PRAY,
CHARLES L. BROWER,
PHILLIP G. SENESCHAL,
HARRY W. JOHNSTONE,
and JEFFREY W. COOK,
individually and as
officers and/or
employees of the
United States Air
Force,

Defendants.

No. CV-80-5746
AAH

JUDGMENT

(For Plaintiff
and Against
Defendants)

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

The above entitled matter came on
regularly for non-jury trial in this Court
on May 23, 1983, and continued from day to
day thnreafter for 19 days until June 2l,
1983, whereupon argument was heard upon the
matter, including facts and law, for two
hours on each side. Thereafter the Court
took the matter under consider’tion and
submission and now after havii.g made,
signed and entered its Decision, including
its finings of fact, conclusions of law and
Order for judgment renders its Judgment:

IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED as
follows:

Under Plaintiff's Title VII Claims,

43 U.S.C. section 2000e, et seq.

l. Plaintiff shall have and recover
against and from defendant, Hans M. Mark,
Secretary of the Department of the Untied
States Air Force (Secretary), the sum of
$27,480.24, awarded as and for back pay, 42

U.S.C. section 2000e-5(g).

-139-

Y Defendant Secretary shall forth-
with promote plaintiff to the GS-12, step
4, position, and shall give her appropriate
training so that she can be prepared to be
designated to and adequé cely fulfill the
duties of such position, 42 U.S.C. section
2000e-5(g).

3 Defendant Secretary is prohibited
and enjoined from taking any or further
unlawful employment or retaliatory action
against plaintiff.

4. Defendant Secretary shall forth-
with purge and eliminate from plaintiff's
personnel file or files covering the period
July 17, 1977, to and including April 2l,
1980, all derogatory references to plain-
tiff, and shall insert and substitute in
said files covering said period appropriate
records of this case and proceeding, to
wit, the Decision and Judgment herein made,

signed, filed and entered.

-140-

5. Plaintiff shall have and recover
from defendant Secretary her reasonable
attorney's fees as part of costs hereby
awarded to plaintiff in connection with the
prosecution of her Title VII claims, 42
U.S.C. section 2000e-5(k), which fees and
costs will be determined by the Court at a
future hearing to be set in accordance with
the procedures hereinafter in paragraph 8
set forth.

Under Plaintiff's Constitutional Due

Process Claims

6. Plaintiff shall have and recover
against and from defendants Secretary of
the Air Force, United States of America
(U.S.A.), and United States Air Force
(U.S.A.F.), and all the other named defen-
dants, the sum of $26,000.00, awarded as
and for compensatory damages.

7° Plaintiff shall have and recover

against the following named defendants the

-141-

following sums, awarced as and for punitive
and exemplary damages:

(a) defendant Secretary of the
Air Force, U.S.A., and U.S.A.F. -
150,000.00

(b) defendant Ronald J. Bishop -
$1,000.00

(c) defendant Harold L. Pray -
$1,000.00

(d) detendant Charles L. Brower -
$2,500.00

(e) defendant Phillip G. Sene-
schal - $2,500.00

(f) defendant Harry W. Johnstone
- $2,500.00

(g) defendant Jeffrey W. Cook -
$1,000.00

8. Plaintiff shall have and recover

against and from defendants Secretary of
the Air Force, U.S.A. and U.S.A.F., and
other named defendants herein, reasonable
attorneys fees and expenses in connection

-142-

with the prosecution of her constitutional
due process claims, 28 U.S.C. section
2412(b) and (da), as well as costs under 28
U.S.C. section 2412(a) as enumerated in 28
U.S.C. section 1920 in amounts to be
determined at a future hearing. In this
connection, and in accordance with the
Court's order of July 5, 1982, defendants’
opposition to plaintiff's Application for
attorneys fees, expenses and costs of suit
shall be filed and served within 30 days
after receipt by the United States Attor-

ney's Office of this Judgment and accompa-

nying Decision, and counsel for plaintiff
and counsel for defendants shall confer
with the Courtroom Deputy Clerk to obtain
the earliest Court hearing date, which date
shall be noted by defendants’ counsel on
the Opposition papers title page.

Under Both Sets of Plaintiff's Claims

9. This Court retains and reserves
jurisdiction over this case and proceeding

-143-

to insure implementation of its Judgment
and Orders herein.

10. The Clerk of the Court shall
forthwith file and enter this judgment and
accompanying Decision, and serve copies
thereof upon all counsel of record for all

parties herein.
Dated: August 12, 1983

/s/ A. Andrew Hauk
A. ANDREW HAUK
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
2:12 p.m.

~144-

FILED
DEC 14, 1984
CLERK, U.S. COURT OF APPEALS

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT

LOWENE R. CLEMENTE,
Plaintiff-Appellee, No. 80-5508

DC No. 79-
3952-AAH (Sx)

vs.

UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA; and UNITED
STATES AIR FORCE, a
military department

of the United States of
America, with HANS M.
MARK, Secretary,

MEMORANDUM

Defendants~Appellants.

me me me re ee re eee ee ee ee eet ee ee See ee?

Appeal from the United States
District Court
For the Central District of California
Chief Justice Judge A. Andrew Hauk,
Presiding

-145-

[Argued and Submitted November 6, 1981]
Before: WRIGHT, WALLACE and ANDERSON,
Circuit Judges.

Mrs. Clemente first challenged her job
reassignment on April 8, 1977. By the time
of oral argument in this court, her action
had been rejected twice by the Air Force,
and actions were pending both in this court
and the district court.

Not to be outdone by the confused
state of the proceedings, the government
seems to have changed theories of defense
at every turn. It rejected Mrs. Clemente's
first complaint as premature and her second
complaint as untimely. Similarly, its
brief on appeal argues that Mrs. Clemente's
failure to contact an EEOC counselor within
30 days precluded district court jurisdic-
tion, but at oral argument the government
cnttintin that her failure to exhaust

administrative remedies prevents review.

-146-

Mrs. Clemente's contentions also have
lacked consistency. Her first challenge
alleged a discriminatory RIF action, while
her latest district court complaint in-
cludes constitutional claims as well.

This description of the case makes
clear that we lack jurisdiction to review
the merits of this appeal. The district
court remanded these issues for administra-
tive processing, apparently not considering
them final and appealable. Consequently,
several of the claims and defenses now
before us have yet to be evaluated below.

Without such a consideration by the
district court, these issues are not ripe
for review in this court. They require
refinement in light of any additional
underlying facts, which may develop if the
district court deems further hearings

necessary. See SEC v. Lincoln Thrift

Ass'n, 557 F.2d 1274, 1279 (9th Cir. 1977).

-147-

Those defenses already rejected and
those claims already determined, in light
of the peculiar posture of this case, fail
sufficiently to dispose of the entire
action. We do not find the necessary
finality to permit our review. 28 U.S.C.

section 1291; see Cobbledick v. United

States, 309 U.S. 323 (1940); Branch v.

Phillips Petroleum Co., 638 F.2a 877 (5th

Cir. 1981).

We reman” to the district court where,
at the discretion of the judge and as
appropriate, all of the appellee's claims
will be considered and each of appellant's
defenses will be evaluated. The district
court should determine, as it deems appro-
priate, whether: (1) Mrs. Clemente's com-
plaint should be dismissed for failure to
exhaust administrative remedies; (2) her
failure to comply with applicable statutory
or administrative filing time limits should
be excused; (3) the district court has

-148-

jurisdiction to hear the various issues,
considering that the government continues
to claim that an untimely initial contact
with an EEOC counselor is a juriscictional
defect; (4) the court's prior remand order
retains vitality, and if so, whether the
Air Force complied; and 15} other issues
should be determined or further hearings
conducted.

After whatever pzoceedings the dis-
trict judge considers necessary and appro-
priate, the judge will render a final
decision. Only then can this court conduct
a meaningful review.

The district court's remand order
granted attorneys' fees of $2,500 to

plaintiff's attorney. We vacate the award

of attorneys’ fees. Hanrahan v. Hampton,

446 U.S. 754 (1980; cf. Manhart v. City of

Los Angeles, 652 F.2d 904, 906-07 (9th Cir.

1981) (Title VII of plaintiff who secures
injunctive relief is a prevailing party).

-149-

Mrs. Clemente has yet to prevail on
the merits of any of her claims, but only
has succeeded in preserving a cause of
action. If Mrs. Clemente eventually
prevails, any award of attorneys' fees will
require consideration of the guidelines

announced by this court in Kerr v. Screen

Extras Guild, Inc., 526 F.2d 67, 70 (9th

Cir. 1975), cert. denied, 425 U.S. 951

(1976).
We dismiss the appeal in part and
vacate the portion of the district court's

order awarding attorneys fees.

-150-

FILED April 30, 1980
CLERK, U.S. DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

LOWENE R. CLEMENTE, ) No. CV=-79=-3952-
) AAH (Sx)
Plaintiff, )
) DECISION AND
UNITED STATES OF ) ORDER REMAND-
AMERICA, and UNITED ) ING CASE AND
STATES AIR FORCE, a ) DISMISSAL
military department of ) WITHOUT
the United States of ) PREJUDICE
America, with HANS M. )
)
)
)
)

MARK, Secretary,

Defendants.

The Motion of Defendants to Dismiss
this action, pursuant to Rule 12(b) (1) of
the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, for
lack of subject matter jurisdiction, came

-15l-

on regularly for hearing before the Honor-
able A. ANDREW HAUK, United States District
Judge, on the 2lst date of April, 1980.

The Plaintiff LOWENE R. CLEMENTE appeared
and was represented by her attorney, S.
TIMOTHY BUYNAK, JR.; and Defendants ap-
peared through their attorney, ANDREA
SHERIDAN ORDIN, United States Attorney,
FREDERICK M. BROSIO, JR., Assistant United
States Attorney, Chief, Civil Division, and
PETER R. OSINOFF, Assistant United States

Attorney, by PETER R. OSINOFF.

FINDINGS OF FACT

The Court, having considered the
pleadings herein, the Certified Administra-
tive Record, the Memoranda and Declarations
submitted by both sides, and having heard
oral argument of counsei, finds that:

l. Plaintiff's failure to discuss her
case with an EEO Counsellor is not a

jurisdictional defect;

-152-

2 Defendants through their personnel
at Vandenberg Air Force Base, California,
had an affirmative duty to timely refer
Plaintiff's complaints to an EEO Counsellor
for consideration and to fully advise
Plaintiff of the administrative processing
requirement and her rights therein, which
Defendants failed to accomplish, although
Plaintiff has been consistently employed at
Vandenberg Air Force Base, California,
since lodging her complaints;

3 Because of these failures by
Defendants, Plaintiff's complaints were
never accepted and processed administra-
tively in accordance with Defendants'
regulations, which processing would aid
immensely in the resolution of the diffi-
culties herein considered, which failure
constituted and constitute arbitrary,
capricious and unreasonable denial of the

due process of law rights of Plaintiff.

-153-

4. Jurisdiction of this Court to hear
discrimination complaints under 42 United
States Code section 2000e-16 terminates
thirty days after receipt of the final
notice of agency determination by the
Plaintiff; otherwise, this Court has
continuing jurisdiction to entertain the
judicial complaint herein, beginning 180
days after Plaintiff filed her formal
initial charge with the agency;

Se Notice of the final agency deter-
mination was never received by Plaintiff.
Defendant Air Force, in violation of its
own regulations (A.F.R. 40-713, October 20,
1975, Par. 23e.), failed to send to Plain-
tiff and her representative a written
decision by certified mail, return receipt
requested. And because 180 days have
elapsed between the filing of Plaintiff's
formal initia auarge and the filing of the
complaint herein, this Court has continuing
jurisdiction.

-154-

6. Any conclusion of law deemed as or

properly constituting a finding of fact is

hereby adopted as a finding of fact.

CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

i. This Court has subject matter
jurisdiction over this action.

2. Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for
lack of subject matter jurisdiction should
be denied.

as In the interest of justice and
fairness to all parties, the complaints of
Plaintiff as presented herein should be
remanded to tie Civilian Personnel Office
of Vandenberg Air Force Base, California,
for continuous and diligent administrative
processing by the Defendants under applica-
ble Air Force regulations to final deter-
mination by the Defendant Air Force and the
other said Defendants, all of said process-

ing to be initiated within sixty (60) days

-155-

—eee

of the date of entry of the within Decision
and Order.

4. Said processing should be accom-
plished in strict compliance with applica-
ble Air Force regulations, should involve
all stages of administrative processing
entailed therein, and should be conducted
so as to insure plaintiff her full rights
in said proceedings and a fair adjudication
of her complaints.

DB. In addition to said rights and
privileges afforded by said regulations,
Plaintiff should be entitled to be present
at all states of the administrative pro-
cessing and to be represented thereat by
her legal representative.

6. Plaintiff should not be questioned
at any time without her legal representa-
tive being present and Plaintiff's legal
representative should receive copies of all
written communications involved in this
administrative processing.

-156-

ae If the defendants fail to initiate

the said administrative processing within
sixty (60) days from the date of entry of
the within Decision and Order, or to fully,
properly and diligently process said
complaints of Plaintiff through all stages
to final determination by the Air Force,
this Court, upon motion by Plaintiff,
should consider reopening of this proceed-
ing herein and granting the relief prayed
by the Plaintiff in her Complaint on file
herein.

8. This proceeding and the complaint
herein should be dismissed without preju-
dice to:

(a) the reopening of this pro-
‘ceeding upon motion of Plaintiff if the
Defendants fail to initiate said adminis-
trative processing within sixty (6C) days
from the date of entry of this Decision and
Order, or fail to fully, properly and
diligently carry on said processing to

-157-

final administrative determination in

strict compliance with the regulitions of
Defendant Air Force; or

(b) the filing by Plaintiff of a
new complaint for review of the said
administrative processing and final deter-
mination if Plaintiff is dissatisfied or
has good legal cause to complain and seek
judicial review of any portion of said
administrative processing or final deter-
mination.

9. Any finding of fact deemed as or
properly constituting a conclusion of law
is hereby adopted as a conclusion of law.

10. The Clerk of this Court should
forthwith serve copies of this Decision and

Order upon counsel for all parties herein.

-158-

ORDER

Let Judgment be entered accordingly.

Dated: April 30, 1980

/s/ A. Andrew Hauk
A. ANDERW HAUK
UNITED STATES DISTRICT
COURT

~159-

FILED April 30,

1980

CLERK, U.S. DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

LOWENE R. CLEMENTE,
Plaintiff,
-V=—

UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA, and UNITED
STATES AIR FORCE,

a military department
of the United States
of America, with HANS
M. MARK, Secretary

Defendants.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

No. CV-79=-3952-

AAH (Sx)

JUDGMENT
REMANDING PRO-
CEEDING FOR
ADMINISTRATIVE
PROCESSING,
AND DISMISSING
COMPLAINT
WITHOUT PREJ-
UDICE TO RE-
OPENING OR TO
FILING OF NEW
COMPLAINT

The Court having made and entered its

Decision and Order Remanding Case and for

-160-

Dismissal Without Prejudice in this matter,
and good cause appearing,

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND
DECREED AS FOLLOWS:

l. Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for
lack of subject matter jurisdiction is
denied.

as The case and proceeding herein is
remanded to Defendai.t Air Force, and *he
other Defendants, and particularly to the
Civilian Personnel Office of Vandenberg Air
Force Base, California, for continuous and
diligent administrative processing by
Defendants under applicable Air Force
regulations to final determination by the
Defendant Air Force and the other said
Defendants, such processing to be initiated
within sixty (60) days of the entry of the
aforesaid Decision and Order and the within
Judgment.

3. The Court reserves its
jurisdiction and right to reopen the within

-161-

proceeding, upon motion of Plaintiff, if
Defendants fail to initiate the said
administrative processing within said sixty
(60) day period, or fail to fully, properly
and diligently process Plaintiff's
complaints through all stages to final
determination by the Defendant Air Force,
in strict compliance with its regulations.

4. This proceeding and the complaint
herein are hereby dismissed, but without
prejudice to:

(a) the reopening of this pro-
ceeding upon motion of Plaintiff if the
Defendants fail to initiate said adminis-
trative processing within sixty (60) days
from the date of entry of this Judgment, or
fail to fully, properly and diligently
carry on said processing to final adminis-
trative determination in strict compliance
with the regulations of Defendant Air

Force; or

-162-

(b) the filing by Plaintiff of a
new complaint for review of the said
administrative processing and final deter-
mination if Plaintiff is dissatisfied or
has good legal cause to complain and seek
judicial review of any portion of said
administrative processing or final deter-
mination.

5. Plaintiff shall have and receive
her costs of suit incurred herein which are
hereby taxed in the amount of

$ , and her reasonable attor-

ney's fees which are hereby determined and
fixed in the amount of Twenty Five Hundred
Dollars ($2,500.00), all pursuant to 42
United States Code section 2000e-5(k).

6. The Clerk shall forthwith serve
copies of this Judgment and the aforesaid

Decision and Order upon counsel for all

-163-

parties herein.

Dated: April 30, 1980

/s/ A. Andrew Hauk
A. ANDREW HAUK
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

-164-

DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
HEADQUARTERS 4392D AEROSPACE
SUPPORT GROUP (SAC)

VANDENBERG AIR FORCE BASE, CALIFORNIA 93437

12 May 1977

Reply to
Attn of: DPCD

Subject: Notice of Reduction in Force -
Job Offer

To: 65961S/DOU/Lowene R. Clemente

l. We regert to advise you that a re-
duction-in-force will require your release
from your competitive level. The reason
for the reduction in force is: The recent
acquisition of Olivetti Word Processing
equipment has resulted in a reorganization
in the Data Processing Section. The
requirement for an EAM Project Planner no
longer exists. Therefore, the position you
now occupy has been identified tc be
abolished.

2. Your retention rights have been
compared with other base employees to
determine the best available position that
can be offered to you. You are offered the
position of Computer Operator, GS-332-06,
4392ASG/LGS. If you accept this offer, you
will be changed to lower grade to the
position not earlier than 17 Jul 1977. If
you decline the position you will be
separated on 15 Jul 1977.

3. The following information was used in
deternining your retention rights:

-165-

a. Competitive Area: Vandenberg,
AFB, Ca.

b. Your Competitive Level is:
GS-362-07P

c. Your position is: EAM Project
Planner

d. Your Retention Subgroup is: IB

e. Your Service Computation Date is:
1960-03-05

4. If you have any reason to believe the
above information is incorrect or if you
wish to review regulations or reduction in
force records, please call Mrs. Leidecker,
276-4714. She will be glad to answer your
questions and assist you in any way possi-
ble. Records are available in the Civilian
Personnel, Office, Bldg. 1:777.

5. Should you be separated, you may be
entitled to severance pay, employment
assistance and other benefits. Attached is
a summary of benefits and assistance
available in your case. Also attached is
an explanation of your right to appeal if,
after review, you feel that appropriate
regulations have not been followed.

6. You must accept or refuse the position
offered within five workdays after receipt
of this notice. If you refuse the position
or fail to reply within the time limit, you
will be separated by reduction in force on
the date specified above. If special
circumstances warrant, you may make a
written request for extension of the notice
period to allow retention in a leave
without pay status beyond that date.

-166-

7. We sincerely regret the need for this
action. It does not, of course, reflect in
_any way on your conduct or performance.

You will be continued in a pay status
during the notice period and we will try to
give you whatever assistance you may need.

WILLIAM M. COADY 2 attachments

Chief, Civilian 1. Appeal Rights

Personnel Branch 2. Supplemental
Information

Receipt acknowledged:

Lowene R. Clemente 5/13/77
( ) I accept the offer contained in

paragraph 1 of this letter.

( ) I decline the offer contained in
paragraph 1 and understand I will
be separated from Air Force
employment on the date set in
paragraph 2 of this letter.

NAME ~~ DATE

-167-

APPEAL RIGHTS

l. You have the rights to review all
records pertaining to this action and to
see copies of Air Force and Civil Service
regulations pertaining to Reduction in
Force. This includes the retention regis-
ter for your competitive level and those
for other positions for which you believe
you are qualified, down to and including
those in the same or equivalent grade (if
any) which constitutes your “best offer."
If separation is proposed, this includes
all positions equal to, and below, the
grade of your current position.

Ze If, after this review, you believe
that the provisions of Air Force or Civil
Services regulations (specifically AFR
40-351 and FPM, Chapter 351) have not been
followed, you should discuss any questions
you have with a member of the Civilian
Personnel Office staff. If, after such
discussion, you still believe that the
action does not comply with regulations,
you may submit an appeal to the Civil
Service Commission. The appeal may be
submitted at any time after receipt of this
notice, but not later than 15 calendar days
after the effective date of the action.

Se If you are separated by reduction in
force and are eligible for the reemployment
priority l‘st (RPL), you may request,
during your period of eligibility, to
review records of position vacancies at Air
Force activities in the locality which were
filled by other than Air Force employees.
If you belief that you should have been
offered a vacancy instead of a person
appointed or transferred, you should
discuss the action with an appropriate

-168-

member of the Civilian Personnel Office.
If, after discussion, you disagree with an
action, you may submit an appeal to the
Civil Service Commission.

4. Any appeal from this reduction in
force action, or subsequent action while
you have reemployment priority, should be
addressed to:

United States Civil Service Commission
Federal Employee Appeals Authority

San Francisco Field Office

450 Golden Gate Ave

San Francisco, CA 94102

A copy of this notice should be included
with the appeal letter.

DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
HEADQUARTERS 4392D AEROSPACE
SUPPORT GROUP (SAC)
VANDENBERG AIR FORCE BASE, CALIFORNIA 93437

19 NOV 1980

Reply to
Attn of: CC

Subject: Notice of Final Air Force
Decision - Lowene R. Clemente

To: S. Timothy Buynak
Hatch and Parent
21 East Carrillo Street
Santa Barbara, CA 93101

| By letter, dated 17 October 1980,
which you received 22 October 1980, Lt Col
Harold L. Pray, Chief, Personnel Division,
proposed to adoyt the findings of Mr Harry
W. Johnstone in his report of investigation
into Ms Clemente's case. Mr Johnstone q
found that the complainant's race was not a
factor in the decision to abolish her
position or in the manner in which she was
treated incident thereto. Lt Col Pray
proposed cancellation of the complaint.

Ze In that 17 October letter you were
informed that if you are dissatisfied with
the proposed disposition, you may (1)
request a hearing before an Equal Employ-
ment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) Com-
plaints Examiner, followed by a decision by
the Air Force Director of EEO, or (2)
request a decision by the Air Force Direc-
tor of EEO, without a hearing, based upon
the evidence present in the complaint file.

-170-

Lt Col Pray further explained to you that
such a request should be submitted to Ms
Carolyn McCool, the Chief EEO Counselor at
Vandenberg, within 15 calendar days of
receipt of the Notice of Proposed Decision.

3. As of this date you have neither
notified Ms McCool of your desire for an
EEOC hearing, nor have you informed Lt Col
Pray of your specific wishes. Rather, in
your 31 October 1980 reply to the Notice of
Proposed Disposition -- a reply which,
incidentally, did not reach Lt Col Pray or
Major Brower until 7 November 1980, "16
calendar days after your receipt of the
Notice of Proposed Disposition -- you
reject the EEOC hearing on the erroneous
belief that its scope would be limited to
the scope of Mr. Johnstone's evaluation,
and you inform Lt Col Pray that he may, at
his "option," make a final agency decision
or forward the case to the Air Force
Director of EEO "or whomever you like.”
Neither Lt Col Pray nor I can make this
decision for you. That is an election
which, as was explained in the 17 October
1980 letter, you and your client must make.

4. In view of the fact that you have
failed to make the election offered in the
17 October 1980 letter, as well as the fact
that your reply to the 17 October 1980
letter was late, this letter will provide
notice to you that I have adopted the
proposed disposition, i.e., cancellation of
the complaint., as the final Air Force
decision in Ms Clemente's case. You now
have the following options:

a. You may appeal to the Equal
Employment Opportunity Commission within 20
calendar days of receipt of this decision.
Your appeal to the Commission should be

-171-

addressed to the Director, Office of
Appeals’ and Review, Equal Employment
Opportunity Commission, 2401 E Street,
N.W., Washington, DC 20506. The appeal and
any representation in support thereof must
be submitted in duplicate.

(1) Except as provided in the
following paragraph of this letter, a
complainant may file a notice of appeal at
any time up to 20 calendar days after
receipt of the Air Force Notice of Final
Decision and his/her complaint. An appeal
shall be deemed filed on the date it is
postmarked or, in the absence of a post-
mark, on the date it is received by the
Commission. Any statement or brief in
support of the appeal must be submitted to
the Commission and to the Air Force within
30 days of filing the Notice of Appeal.

(2) The 20-day time limit within
which a Notice of Appeal must be filed will
not be extended by the Commission unless,
based upon a written showing by the com-
plaint that he/she was not notified of the
prescribed time limit and was not otherwise
aware of it or that circumstances beyond
his/her control prevented the filing of a
Notice of Appeal within the prescribed time
limit, the Commission exercises its dis-
cretion to extend the time limit and accept
the appeal.

b. In lieu of an appeal to the
Commission, you may in accordance with
Judge Hauk's remand order, file in U.S.
District Court for the Central District of
California a new complaint for review of
this administrative processing. It is the
Air Force's view that such a complaint must
be filed within 30 days of your receipt of
this final decision. If you elect to

-172-

appeal to the Commission's Office of
Appeals and Review, you may file your
complaint within 30 days of receipt of the
decision.

(1) A civil action may also be
filed anytime after 180 days of the date of
initial appeal to the Commission, if a
final decision has not been rendered.

Se I should also like to comment on
misconceptions you seem to hold as indicat-
ed by your 31 October 1980 reply. First,
it is not true that the EEOC hearing is
limited to the scope of Mr. Johnstone's
investigation, and at no time has either
Major Brower, Lt Col Pray, Mr. Phillip
Seneschal or Mr Johnstone held that opin-
ion. Rather, Title 29 CFR Part 1613, which
prescribes the rules for such hearings,
allows a Complaints Examiner to expand the
scope of the hearing by either remanding to
the agency for further investigation or by
arranging for the appearance of additional
witnesses. 29 CFR 1613.218. Second, you
are mistaken in your belief that Mr.
Johnstone considers the RIF to be unsup-
ported. He has made no such assertion
either in his report or off the record.
Third, you continue to insist that Ms
Clemente is entitled to a "combined hearing
on all of her complaints,” i.e. the RIF
appeal, discrimination claim, post-RIF
priority rights grievance and reprisal
complaint. This argument ignores the fact
that Ms Clemente's formal EEO complaint,
which provides the basis for Part 713
processing, very cimply alleges that the
"RIF action taken [was] a result of reverse
racial discrimination." Mr Johnstone's
investigation appropriately focused on that
limited allegation.

-173-

6. Regarding your 10 November 1980
request to “initiate processing through
(the MSPB)," as you are already aware, the
Air Force position on this matter is that
the MSPB has no jurisdiction to hear your
case, even if it does, you, not the Air
Force, must file your own petition with the
MSPB. MSPB made this clear to you in its
29 October 1980 letter to you.

i Finally, I must remind you that
throughout this administrative process the
Air Force has acted, and continues to act,
under compulsion of court order. The Air
Force continues to assert that Ms
Clemente's complaint is untimely inasmuch
as it was not filed within the 30 days
prescribed by 5 CFR Part 713 (now 29 CFR
Part 1613). Therefore, nothing in this
letter, or in any previous correspondence
or investigation, should be interpreted as
a waiver of the 30-day statute of limita-
tions. The Air Force has simply in good
faith attempted to comply with Judge Hauk's
order. :

RONALD J. BISHOP, JR. Cy to: Carolyn
Colonel, USAF Commander McCool
4392 AEROSG/JA
(Major Brower)
Ms Clemente
Mr Peter Osinoff,
(Asst U.S.
Attorney)

-174-

APPENDIX C

Aug 16, 1985
MANDATE ISSUED
ARMS UNIT
Aug 19, 1985

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT

LOWENE R. CLEMENTE,

)
)
Plaintiff-Appellee, ) 83-6187
) 83-6188
vs. ) No. 83-6430
)
UNITED STATES OF ) CV 80-5746
AMERICA, UNITED STATES ) 79-3952
AIR FORCE, ET AL., ) 80-5746
)
)

Defendants-Appellants.

APPEAL from the United States District

Court for the

District of ‘

THIS CAUSE came on to be heard on the
Transcript of the Record from the United
States District Court for the Central
District of California and was duly

submitted.

-175-

ON CONSIDERATION WHEREOF, It is now
here ordered and adjudged by this Court,
that the judgment of the said district
Court in this Cause be, and hereby is

REVERSED, VACATED AND REMANDED.

Filed and entered July 24, 1985

-176-

APPENDIX D

AIR FORCE REGULATION 40-713,
October 20, 1975

33. Relationship to Appeal and Grievance
Procedures:

a. When the basis of a complaint of
discrimination is an action which may be
appealed directly to the Civil Service
Commission (for example, reduction-in-force
and certain adverse actions) the
complainant should be informed of the
requirement to specify under which part of
the regulations (FPM Chapter 713 or the
other appeal system) the issue of
discrimination is to be processed.

(1) If the complainant decides to
proceed by appeal to the Commission, he
must make this election in writing, signed
and dated, and a copy is furnished to the
Commission office having jurisdiction over
the appeal and the activity will close out

the discrimination complaint and thereafter

-177-

act in the matter under instructions from
the Commission.

(2) If the complainant elects to
proceed under FPM chapter 713, after having
been specifically informed of his right to
use the other appellate system, then the
entire matter, including the merits of the
action, will be reviewed under this regu-
lation.

b. If an allegation of discrimination
is made in connection with a matter that
already has been appealed to the Civil
Service Commission, the activity must
notify the Commission's appellate office
ana that office will determine whether the
agency will make an investigation. Any
investigation requested by the Commission
shall be conducted in accordance with the
Commission's specific written instructions.

C. When an employee makes an allega-
tion of discrimination in connection with a
matter that would normally be subject to

-178-

the Air Force grievance system, the matter
will be processed under this regulation

(see also AFR 40-771, section C).

-179-

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385018_0888%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
