# Amicus Curiae Brief — Orff v. United States

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385016_0002%3A13

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Amicus Curiae Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 2005
- **Citation:** 545 U.S. 596

## Text

No. 03-1566

In The
Supreme Court of the United States

°

FRANCIS A. ORFF, et ai.,

Petitiorers,
V.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, et al.,
Respondents.

e

On Writ Of Certiorari To The
United States Court Of Appeals
For The Ninth Circuit

e

BRIEF OF CENTRAL ARIZONA
WATER CONSERVATION DISTRICT,
MARICOPA-STANFIELD IRRIGATION &
DRAINAGE DISTRICT, CENTRAL ARIZONA
IRRIGATION AND DRAINAGE DISTRICT
AND ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF
WATER RESOURCES AS AMICI CURIAE
IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS

+

MARVIN S. COHEN*

SACKS TIERNEY PA.

4250 North Drinkwater Blvd.,
4th Floor

Scottsdale, AZ 85251-3647

(480) 425-2600

*Counsel of Record for
Amici Curiae

{Additional Counsel On Inside Cover]

COCKLE LAW BRIEF PRINTING CO (800) 225-6964
OR CALL COLLECT (402) 342-2831

DOUGLAS K. MILLER

General Counsel

CENTRAL ARIZONA WATER
CONSERVATION DISTRICT

23636 North Seventh Street

Phoenix, AZ 85080-3020

(623) 869-2333

PavtL R. ORME

General Counsel

MARICOPA-STANFIELD IRRIGATION &
DRAINAGE DISTRICT AND CENTRAL ARIZONA
IRRIGATION AND DRAINAGE DISTRICT

1000 Orme Rd., HC 63, Box 3042

Maver, AZ 86333-3042

(623) 465-0445

W. PATRICK SCHIFFER

Chief Counsel

ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES
500 North Third Street

Phoenix, AZ 85004

602) 417-2420

MARK A. MCGINNIS

SALMON, LEWIS & WELDON, P.L.C.

2850 East Camelback Road, Suite 200

Phoenix, AZ 85016

(602) 801-9060

Attorneys for Central Arizona Irrigation
and Drainage District

DONALD M. PETERS

MILLER, LASoTA & PETERS, PLC

5225 North Central, Suite 235

Phoenix, AZ 85012

(602) 248-2900

Attorneys for Maricopa-Stanfield Irrigation
& Drainage District

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

TABLE OF CONTENTS o.oo... cccccccccccccescecceceeseceecseceees, i
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES .00.00.....cccccceccececcecceceececeeeen. iii
IDENTITY AND INTEREST OF AMICI CURIAE ...... 1
Central Arizona Water Conservation District .......... 2

Maricopa-Stanfield Irrigation & Drainage District
and Central Arizona Irrigation and Drainage Dis-
SnINIniAiindithssathdbebenieabscetbensensounisernccsceeesoseseucoseeseeess

I. SECTION 8 OF THE 1902 RECLAMATION
ACT DOES NOT APPLY TO COLORADO
RIVER WATER DELIVERED THROUGH
THE CENTRAL ARIZONA PROJECT...............

A. The Law of the River .......0....ccccccccccccecceseess
The Colorado River Compact................
The 1928 Boulder Canyon Project Act....
Arizona v. California ...........ccccccccceccesees

The 1968 Colorado River Basin Project
i deiiiibiniiiiasindesiecebesesenenteeneeesmsnsieecsone. nes

II. THE FACTS AND LAW APPLICABLE TO
FARMERS IN THE CENTRAL VALLEY PRO-
JECT ARE DIFFERENT FROM THOSE AP-
PLICABLE TO FARMERS IN THE CENTRAL
ARIZONA PROJECT..............cccccccsesescscesessesecsees

i cseeumsorenemeuees

e SF NS

co on Ww

il

TABLE OF CONTENTS -— Continued

Page
The Orff Petitioners ............::::::seeeeeeeeees 19
Smiths in ArizOna...........ccccrccocccsesccesssees 22

California v. United States, Nevada v.
United States, Nebraska v. Wyoming,

and Tches Vv. FO ..........ccccccccsssseseessereseees 22

B. The Allen Orchards Case.........::::::sccseeeeeeees 26

C. Contractual Provisions ..............:::cceeeseeeeeees 28

TET. CONCLUSION .......ccccccscccsscccscscccccscessesssessseseeees 29

ill

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Page

CASES
Arizona v. California, 373 U.S. 546 (1963).........0...... passim
Bryant v. Yellen, 447 U.S. 352, reh’g denied, 448

eae ee CETTE iciestasesssciidaliciiadidnnbonteiitaieiatindsditasisdsbeiebese 24, 25
California v. United States, 438 U.S. 645

SEP UTIE ocnsicaniehdecdeaniiasianiernitincinaiiamadiniiilie oabiendiied 21, 22, 23, 24, 25
City of Fresno v. California, 372 U.S. 627 (1963)....... 23, 24
Fox v. Ickes, 137 F.2d 30 (D.C. Cir. 1943)....0.... eee eee 27
H.F. Allen Orchards v. United States, 749 F.2d 1571

es NE Ma ictendihecibctnietihiaisarthiaidesdccinhianiiristiiiicisdau 11, 21, 26, 27
Ickes v. Fox, 300 U.S. 82 (1937).............ccccceeeeeeeees 21, 22, 26

Ivanhoe Irr. Dist. v. McCracken, 357 U.S. 275 (1958) .. 23, 24
John E. Smith, et al. v. Central Arizona Water

I 3
Long v. Salt River Valley Water Users’ Ass’n, 820

Se Ce I II ITT i inciceecsiccintiserrsnictiaiieesmnsniieinntnienndntaaidiliees 25
Nebraska v. Wyoming, 325 U.S. 589 (1945).......... 21, 22, 26
Nevada v. United States, 463 U.S. 110, reh’g denied,

Re es ED siciitittriinitiiiitnittiiccidiidaisiaiiininntans 19, 21, 22, 26
Wyoming v. Colorado, 259 U.S. 419 (1922), decree

paceted, SES U.S. GES (1GB7).......ccccccccocccccsccoccccccscescssess 13

FEDERAL STATUTES AND RULES

Sy I i ON I I a icincsesciensinilieitcsenciteiteiinpiinabaniliiintsiaiala 1
ee St iicstdiniesincniiinarineniensisuniiisainidinbiaisimaiiaitiei 9,10
ii acenicaineiisiisaiintiiiintitniascniniatiaiieiieeiatats 9, 10, 20

iV

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES — Continued

Page
BE, Be i vnctttctctescscestsensccinsssccacnvsnsenssnnsinns 14, 23
GT, Be cctccseitccetccccnsscccccesincsesnnseerenenaneinannnsictnaions 14
I , Bi ct ecsccsntctcscccscinsecncnsecesseneseceensnsnanionsnnessassin 15
GTI AE, Be FE cccciccccecscctescccecscnsssccsesnccsenessanscnssane 19
TE, © isd ssncciceccescncsccessnscccessccnsccssinisarsetnanciavese 19
1902 Reclamation Act, 32 Stat. 388, § 8 ...........0....... passim
Colorado River Compact reprinted in. Ariz. Rev.

RI, Fitts, © Ge cccescccicdsescscecsceustscnssscssosacasevasesesneneses 14
1928 Boulder Canyon Project Act, 45 Stat. 1057,

I I ccccasimncsiednencmnnicanansdbonemianiesnndinniuabiatentidasainiddicisianien passim
1968 Colorado River Basin Project Act, 88 Stat. 885....... 19
Arizona Water Settlements Act, P.L. 108-451.......0............ 1

I TID cscscseichivstetiiaiindsicencbinhiaciesoieiieadanationsinaiaeaeabiiaetiteiads 5

III, cali ia leaeiieiligeidadanniinsnmieiniansenembedubuniines 8

I BNI... a
available to the Secretary for reallocation M &I B h ; y Saaper
under subparagraph 9.2, all remaining NIA WAGE USEES TES EROS SO ers

a teria established by ADWR shall be
Priority water available under paragraph 5 dligihle to ressive Trust water.

9.3.4.3.

App. 78

ADWR shall retain a sufficient
amount of Trust water through
2030 to satisfy the rights of first re-
fusal described in paragaphs
9.3.4.3 through 9.3.4.6.

Through 2020, M&I water provid-
ers serving the area shown on Ex-
hibit 9.3.4.3 (the “CAIDD Area”)
that meet ADWR’s eligibility crite-
ria shall have a right of first refusal
to 7.8% of the Trust water offered
at each interval, up to an aggregate
maximum of 7,500 acre-feet. Ex-
hibit 9.3.4.3 shall be amended to
exclude any lands for which NIA
Priority water is being retained by
CAIDD or its assignee(s) under an
amended subcontract as provided
in paragraph 6.

9.3.4.3.1. If, at the time ADWR makes

Trust water available to non-
Indian M&I water users, NIA
Priority water is being re-
tained by CAIDD or its as-
signee(s) under an amended
subcontract as provided in
paragraph 6, the retained
water shall count against the
aggregate maximum of 7,500
acre-feet for the CAIDD Area,
but shall not count against
the 7.8% right of first refusal
unless the 7.8% plus the re-
tained water would exceed
7,500 acre-feet.

App. 79

9.3.4.3.2. If M&I water providers serv-

ing the CAIDD Area do not
exercise their full right of
first refusal, then the unex-
ercised portion of that right
shall carry forward to the
next offering of Trust water.

9.3.4.4. Through 2020, M&I water provid-

ers serving the area shown on Ex-
hibit 9.3.4.4 (the “MSIDD Area”)
that meet ADWR’s eligibility crite-
ria shall have a right of first refusal
to 7.8% of the Trust water offered
at each interval, up to an aggregate
maximum of 7,500 acre-feet. Ex-
hibit 9.3.4.4 shall be amended to
exclude any lands for which NIA
Priority water is being retained by
MSIDD or its assignee(s) under an
amended subcontract as provided
in paragraph 6

9.3.4.4.1. If, at the time ADWR makes

Trust water available to non-
Indian M&I water users, NIA
Priority water is being re-
tained by MSIDD or its as-
signee(s) under an amended
subcontract as provided in
paragraph 6, the retained
water shall count against the
-aggregate maximum of 7,500
acre-feet for the MSIDD
Area, but shall not count
against the 7.8% right of first
refusal unless the 7.8% plus
the retained water would ex-
ceed 7,500 acre-feet.

App. 80

9.3.4.4.2. If M&I water providers serv-

9.3.4.5.

9.3.4.6.

9.3.4.7.

ing the MSIDD Area do not
exercise their full right of
first refusal, then the unex-
ercised portion of that right
will carry forward to the next
offering of Trust water.

From 2021 through 2030, the rights
of first refusal described in para-
graphs 9.3.4.3 and 9.3.4.4 shall be
combined and shall be available to
M&I water providers that are serv-
ing either the CAIDD Area or the
MSIDD Area and that meet
ADWR’'s eligibility criteria.

Beginning in 2030, if M&I water
providers serving the CAIDD Area
of MSIDD Area have not exercised
their right of first refusal as to all
of the Trust water available under
paragraphs 9.3.4.3 through 9.3.4.5,
then the Pinal County Water Aug-
mentation Authority (PCWAA)
shall have a right of second refusal
as to the remainder of that water.
PCWAAA must meet the criteria
established by ADWR to be eligible
to receive Trust water.

The rights of refusal described in
paragraphs 9.3.4.3 through 9.3.4.6
do not limit the amount of Trust
water that may be reassigned to
M&I water providers in Pinal
County. If M&1 water providers in
Pinal County request additional
Trust water over and above the

App. 81

amount available to them under
their right of first or second refusal,
ADWR shall consider their request
for additional water on the same
basis as requests for Trust water
from M&I water providers serving
other areas.

9.4. All NIA Priority water reallocated under this
paragraph shall retain its NIA priority.

9.5. All reallocations made under subparagraphs 9.2
and 9.3 and all contracts for NIA Priority water
reallocated under subparagraphs 9.2 and 9.3
shall be contingent on satisfaction of all condi-
tions in subparagraph 13.3 and all conditions in
the voluntary relinquishment agreements by
the dates specified therein.

10. Reallocation of Currently Uncontracted M&I
Priority Water.

10.1. The provisions of this paragraph 10 shall be-
come effective upon enactment of the Act.

10.2. The Secretary shall allocate the Currently Un-
contracted M&I Priority water as shown in Ta-

ble 10.2.
Table 10.2
Applicant Amount Applicant Amount
(acre feet) (acre feet)
Town of Superior 285 AVRA Cooperative 808
Cave Creek 806 (CityofChandler | 4,986
Water Company
Chaparral Water} 1,931 el Lago (Vail) 1,071
Company ater Company

App. 82
‘own of 508 City of Glendale 3,053
El Mirage
City of Goodyear} 7,211 (Community 1,521
Water Company
of Green Valley
H20 Water 147 Metropolitan 4,602
Company Domestic Water
Improvement
District
City of Mesa 7,115 (Town of Oro 3,557
Valley
City of Peoria 5,527 (City of Phoenix 8,206
City of 2,981 (City of Surprise 2,876
Scottsdale
Tucson Water 8,206 Valley Utilities 250
Water Company
TOTAL 65,647
10.3. The Secretary and CAWCD shall offer M&I
subcontracts to the above listed providers re-
flecting the amount of water in this reallocation
in addition to any water already under contract
to that provider. The new subcontract or
amendment to existing subcontract shall con-
form to the requirements of subsections
104(d)(1) and (2) of the Act.
10.4. All contracts for Currently Uncontracted M&I

Priority water allocated under this paragraph
10 shall be contingent on satisfaction of all con-
ditions in subparagraph 13.3 by the date speci-
fied therein.

App. 83

11. Allocation of Mainstream Colorado River Water

11.1. This paragraph 11 shall become effective upon
execution of this agreement and shall survive
termination of this agreement.

11.2. Upon execution of this agreement, the Secre-
tary shall, in cooperation with the Mohave
County Water Authority, amend Bureau of Rec-
lamation Contract No. 5-07-30-W0320, dated
December 12, 1995, to accomplish the following:
(i) allocate and contract to Mohave County Wa-
ter Authority 3,500 acre-feet of Arizona fourth
priority mainstream Colorado River water; (ii)
delete the allocation and contract of 3,500 acre-
feet of Arizona fifth and sixth priority main-
stream Colorado River water; and (iii) delete
the reference to allocation of future NIA Prior-
ity water to Mohave County Water Authority.

11.3. The Secretary shall reserve 3,500 acre-feet of
currently uncontracted Arizona fourth priority
mainstream Colorado River water for use in a
future Navajo-Hopi Indian water rights settle-
ment. The water reserved under this subpara-
graph shall not be allocated, nor shall any
contract be issued under the Boulder Canyon
Project Act for the use of this water, until a fi-
nal Indian water rights settlement for the Na-
vajo Nation has been approved by Congress,
finalizing Navajo claims to the mainstream of
the Colorado River within Arizona.

12. Miscellaneous Provisions

12.1. MSIDD and CAIDD are express third party
beneficiaries as to the rights of first refusal set
forth in subparagraphs 9.3.4.3 through 9.3.4.6.

12.2.

12.3.

12.4.

App. 84

Nothing in this agreement is intended to affect
any party’s obligations under applicable law.

No party shall take any action that is inconsis-
tent with the party’s ability to perform its obli-
gations under this agreement, including
obligations that arise upon passage of the Act
and fulfillment of the conditions of subpara-
graph 13.3 and the voluntary relinquishment
agreements.

Nothing in this agreement may be used against
either CAWCD or the United States in Central
Arizona Water Conservation District v. United
States, Nos. CIV 95-625-TUC-WDB (EHC) and
CIV 95-1720-PHX-EHC (Consolidated Action).
This subparagraph shall survive termination of
this agreement.

13. Effectiveness and Termination

13.1.

13.2.

13.3.

Except as expressly provided in paragraphs 5.2,
7, 9 and 10, this agreement is effective upon
execution by the parties.

The United States may terminate this agree-
ment if the total amount of water available for
reallocation under paragraph 9 upon enactment
of the Act is less than 197,500 acre-feet.

This agreement shall terminate if all of the fol-
lowing conditions have not been satisfied by
December 31, 2007:

13.3.1. The Gila River Indian Community water
rights settlement agreement has been
executed by the parties thereto and has
been authorized, ratified and confirmed
by Congress.

13.4.

13.5.

App. 85

13.3.2. This agreement has been authorized,
ratified and confirmed by Congress.

13.3.3. Congress has passed legislation declaring
the $73,561,337 in 9(d) debt identified in
subparagraph 7.5 to be non-reimbursable
and non-returnable to the United States.

13.3.4. Congress has passed legislation declaring
land within the exterior boundaries of
CAWCD or served by CAP water to be
exempt from the Reclamation Reform Act
and any other acreage limitation or full
cost pricing provision of federal law.

13.3.5. Final judgment has been entered by the
United States District Court for the Dis-
trict of Arizona in Central Arizona Water
Conservation District v. United States,
et al., No. CIV-95-625-TUC-WDB (EHC),
No. CIV-95-1720-PHX-EHC (Consoli-
dated Action), in accordance with the
CAP Repayment Stipulation.

13.3.6. Any other action or event as to which the
Secretary is to publish a statement of
findings under section 207(d) of the Act
has occurred.

Except as expressly provided in paragraph 11
and subparagraphs 8.1 2 and 12.4, no provi-
sion of this agreement shall survive termina-
tion.

If the date by which the Secretary is required
to publisa a statement of findings under sec-
tion 207(d) of the Act is amended by subse-
quent act of Congress, then the deadline for

App. 86

satisfying the conditions in paragraph 13.3
will automatically be amended to conform.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
By:
Secretary of the Interior

CENTRAL ARIZONA WATER
CONSERVATION DISTRICT

Attest: [Illegible] By: /s/ George Renner

Secretary President

ARIZONA DEPARTMENT
OF WATER RESOURCES

By: /s/ Joseph C. Smith

Director

App. 87

J. Gordon Cook, #000586
Ronald I. Rubin, #001607
Denise J. Henslee, #011526
RENAUD, COOK & DRURY, P.A.
Two Renaissance Square

40 North Central, Suite 1600
Phoenix, Arizona 85004-4449

(602) 307-9900

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Richard N. Morrison, #005269

M. Byron Lewis, #002047

Mark A. McGinnis, #013958

SALMON, LEWIS & WELDON, P.L.C.
2850 East Camelback Road, Suite 200
Phoenix, Arizona 85016

(602) 801-9060

Attorneys for Defendants

[RELEVANT EXCERPTS]

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
THE STATE OF ARIZONA

IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF PINAL

JOHN E. SMITH and MARY
LOU SMITH, husband and wife; | No. CV 2001-00924
JOHN E. SMITH, as Trustee of | JOINT STATEMENT

the SMITH FAMILY TRUST; OF FACTS
and PRETZER LAND AND
CATTLE COMPANY, an Arizona (Assigned to the
corporation, Honorable
Kelly Marie Robertson,

Plaintiffs, Div. 5)

App. 88

MARICOPA-STANFIELD
IRRIGATION & DRAINAGE
DISTRICT, an Arizona munici-
pal corporation, and CENTRAL
ARIZONA IRRIGATION AND
DRAINAGE DISTRICT, and
Arizona municipal corporation,
political subdivisions of the
State of Arizona,

Defendants.

The parties submit this agreed-to JOINT STATEMENT
OF FACTs in an effort to clarify and limit factual and
legal issues before the Court. This Statement of Facts is
not intended to be comprehensive, and the parties do not
waive their right to allege and prove additional facts or
argue additional law not contained herein.

1. Plaintiffs are farmers who own land in Pinal
County, Arizona. Plaintiffs John and Mary Lou Smith
and the Smith Family Trust own land within the
boundaries of Defendant Maricopa-Stanfield Irrigation
& Drainage District (“MSIDD”), and Plaintiff Pretzer
Land and Cattle Company owns land within the
boundaries of Defendant Central Arizona Irrigation and
Drainage District (“CAIDD”). MSIDD and CAIDD are
also referred to herein collectively as “the Districts.”

* * *

9. On December 5, 1972, Contract No. 14-06-W-245
was entered into between the United States and CAWCD
for delivery of water and repayment of costs of the CAP
(hereafter “1972 Master Contract”). On December 1, 1988,
the Master Contract was amended (hereinafter “1988
Master Contract”). Upon judicial confirmation of the

App. 89

December 1, 1988 Amendment, the 1972 Master Con-
tract was to be superseded and replaced by the 1988
Master Contract. A true and correct copy of the 1972
Master Contract is attached hereto as Exhibit 1, and a

true and correct copy of the 1988 Master Contract is
attached as Exhibit 2.

* * *

17. Paragraph 8.8(b)(vi) of the 1972 Master Con-
tract and of the 1988 Master Contract, further provided,
in part, that the Secretary and the Contractor shall
require in each subcontract that “ ... irrigation water
made available thereunder may be made available by
the Secretary for M&I purposes if and to the extent that
such water is no longer required by the Subcontractor
for irrigation purposes and shall be made available in
all cases where lands receiving project water have been
converted to municipal or industrial use; Provided
however, That Subcontracts effectuating such transfers
are subject to the approval of the Secretary and the
Contractor, which approval shall not be withheld “un-
reasonably.”

18. On November 21, 1983, each defendant irriga-
tion district, as contemplated by the 1972 Master Con-
tract, entered into a subcontract with the United States
and the CAWCD. The terms of the District’s Subcon-
tracts are identical, except for the Districts’ names and
addresses, and amounts of water to be provided. A true
and correct copy of CAIDD’s Subcontract is attached
hereto at Exhibit 3, and a true and correct copy of
MSIDD’s Subcontract is attached as Exhibit 4.

* * *

—_ -

App. 90

20. Each Subcontract provides in Article 4.1 in
part, that the United States, subject to the Repayment
Contract (the 1972 Master Contract), “shall deliver
Project Water for Agricultural Use by the Subcontrac-
tor.” “Project Water” as used in the Subcontracts, refers
to Central Arizona Project water.

21. Each Subcontract provides in Article 4.2, in
part, that its term is “for a period of 50 years beginning
with the January 1 of the Year following that in which
the Secretary issues the Notice of Contemplation of the
Water Supply System.” The Secretary issued the Notice
of Completion of the Water Supply System during
October of 1993.

* * *

25. Articles 5.1 and 5.2 of the Subcontracts require
the Districts to pay a 2.00 per acre-foot capital charge
(subject to modification), as well as an Agricultural
Water Service Charge to cover a portion of the costs of
operating, maintaining, and replacing the CAP facilities.

26. Article 5.2(e) of the Subcontracts further pro-
vides that the Districts’ obligation to pay the charges
specified in Articles 5.1 and 5.2 “is a general obligation of
the [district] notwithstanding the manner in which the
obligation may be distributed among the [district’s] water
users and notwithstanding the default of individual water
users in their obligations to the [district].”

App. 91

27. Article 5.2(f) of the Subcontracts further
provides that payment of said charges is a condition
precedent to delivery of water under the Subcontracts.

* * *

31. In 1962, MSIDD was organized as an irrigation
and drainage district which operates and has authority
pursuant to A.R.S. § 48-2901 et seq.

32. In 1964, CAIDD was organized as an irrigation
and drainage district which operates and has authority
pursuant to A.R.S. § 48-2901 et seq.

33. Defendants MSIDD and CAIDD are political
subdivisions of the State of Arizona which were organized
in part to provide CAP water to their user landowners
pursuant to contracts. Defendant Districts deliver water to
hundreds of Pinal County farmers. CAIDD covers
87,349.25 acres and includes approximately 214 individual
landowners. MSIDD covers 87,142.6 acres and includes
approximately 263 individual landowners.

34. The MSIDD and CAIDD Subcontracts “... give
MSIDD and CAIDD the contractual right to receive
Colorado River water through the CAP” to be distrib-
uted on behalf of the landowners pursuant to the terms
of said Subcontracts, including payment of all costs set
forth in Article 5 thereof. See Paragraph 25, supra.

* * *

41. MSIDD constructed an irrigation system to dis-
tribute within the district water from the CAP and ground-
water from irrigation wells to be acquired from landowners
in the district pursuant to water service contracts. . . .

* * *

App. 92

43. In April 1989, Plaintiffs John E. and Mary Lou
Smith entered into one or more identical water service
contracts with MSIDD (entitled “Agreement”), which
generally allowed the District during the term of such
agreement to use the Smith’s irrigation wells and
irrigation grandfathered groundwater rights. Such
water was to be used in conjunction with CAP water for
irrigation as determined by the district.

* * *

46. When used in the MOUs and _ individual
agreements for project water service, the “Project” water
referred to means any water delivered through the
Districts’ entire water distribution systems but does not
refer to any particular type of water.

47. MSIDD and CAIDD were organized for the
benefit of their landowners.

RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED this 2nd day of
January, 2002.

RENAUD, COOK & DRURY, P.A.

By: /s/ [Illegible]
J. Gordon Cook
Ronald I. Rubin
Denise J. Henslee
Two Renaissance Square
40 North Central, Suite 1600
Phoenix, AZ 85004-4449
Attorneys for Plaintiffs

App. 93

SALMON, LEWIS & WELDON,
P.L.C.

By: /s/ Richard N. Morrison

Richard N. Morrison

M. Byron Lewis

Mark A. McGinnis

2850 E. Camelback Road,
Suite 200

Phoenix, AZ 85016

Attorneys for Defendants

App. 94

DUPLICATE — ORIGINAL
Contract No. 14-06-W-245

Amendment No. 1
B.C. Draft 11/28/88

UNITED STATES

7 DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR

BUREAU OF RECLAMATION

CONTRACT BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES

AND THE CENTRAL ARIZONA WATER
CONSERVATION DISTRICT FOR DELIVERY
OF WATER AND REPAYMENT OF COSTS
OF THE CENTRAL ARIZONA PROJECT

INDEX

Article No. Title Page No.
i RR nccinthnteesisicnicisetnrsinnsnieticntnnnisenisomitidielbnaniieliuniieimieinds 1
i iniiltstrnnhiesisinstteipninsinnninieiantenaiiniaboniiaiens 1
Be iacticcettesbincdnsatetinnsiciatampsnnniemeinttiiies 2
4. ARTICLES OF AGREEMENT .......................... 3
EEE ea Ee EEO 3
6. PROJECT CONSTRUCTION ............................ 10
.1 Agreement of the United States................. 10
Be re sititnctinteiintetaiiiiitininnnieisien 11
.3 Principal Works of the Project.................... 12
.4 Changes in Project Works........................0:. 13
.5 Construction Gonditions...................:.::cee 14
A TTD 14

.7 Inability of the United States to Complete
Project on Basis of Cost Estimates............. 15

App. 95

7. PROJECT OPERATION, MAINTENANCE,
TT 15

.1 Operation and Maintenance and Water

Deliveries by the United States Prior to
Completion of Construction.............0000...06. 15

.2 Operation and Maintenance and Water

Deliveries after Completion of Construc-

GUID citiiessntecnsutitehnnnsitsienisitnasibdcnninhinhieininasipinescedinndn 18
DUNES COU CO cciccccccnssccnccssesieccsecsccsons 16
.1 Obligation of United States.........000000000.... - /16
eT i tiistetercccstendceciiaciniidatibediaiiels, 17
.3 Conditions Relating to Delivery ................. 17
F _,_ EEE EU Oa ee ROMER 19
Be i iciictnciitniditetiptedintclindtconiiémanices 20
‘6 Responsibility for Distribution of Water
after Leaving Water Supply System .......... 21
.7 Quantity of Water to be Delivered.............. 21
5 SII siscestitichinpsediliiciadticersandiasicelpsiipdtidla ace 24
o> Sanne UTIIEIII dais deselcchestenceliciinpeieeeeippetecnenidsieinaehacictetietet 27
.10 Rate of Diversions of Colorado River Water... 28
.11 Priority in Case of Shortage ....................... 29
.12 No Guarantee of Availability of Water ....... 29
.13 Secretarial Control of Return Flow............ 30
.14 Water and Air Pollution Control................. 31
I ia iacciadaiiisnicticeiteieriataidatetemaaaianies 31
BN ae ee Te I 31

.17 Rights Reserved to the United States to

Have Water Carried by Project Facilities... 32

App. 96 App. 97

.18 Wheeling Non-Project Water...................... 32 Sy SIENNA cechscsidenadeendtinatigdiahieiadnededoidinaideitibasdinatiecen 53
.19 Use of Project Power to Wheel Non-Project -9 Contingent on Appropriation or Allotment
BRNO snesesasnsesesmieneneneniccorammnninnanemneiemapesens . 33 Ec et OT 54
9. PAYMENT OF PROJECT COSTS ALLOCATED .10 Changes in Contractor’s Organization....... 54
ee iiiinnnsiniitentinevecvenintesinicuniiabeuns 33 11 Assignment Limited ~ Successors and As-
Allocation of Construction Costs ................ 33 gS A er ON 54
Repayment Concepts ................sscssssssesessees 34 .12 Judicial Remedies Not Foreclosed.............. 55
Contractor’s Construction Cost A I Cin oiciesnctcciidiciccinicaccscscuinns 55
Repayment Obligation... 36 14 Compliance with Civil Rights Laws and
.4 Payment of Contractor’s Construction ( Cost SSRN aN ee 57
Pea yaRee CNN GIAIOR ---seeeeneeeeverrnrneoreren = 15 Officials Not to Benefit .......cccccscssssssssseee 58
.5 Commercial Power Rates........................005 44 11. STATUS OF DECEMBER 15, 1972 CON-
6 Other Costs Borne by the Contractor......... 44 ITT idlsidiinietiniciinianimaitenanie ei Ett al 58
.7 Repayment of Costs of Excess Capacity in rs
Granite Reef Aqueduct ......................c.eeee0ee 47 UNITED STATES
8 Ad Valorem-Taxes, As ts, Tolls, and DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
——.. 47 BUREAU OF RECLAMATION
© Continuati f P ts after Project CONTRACT BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES
RI lial acacsarcricces see 47 AND THE CENTRAL ARIZONA WATER
CONSERVATION DISTRICT FOR DELIVERY
RIBERA Rn ce oer o~ ek ON 48 OF WATER AND REPAYMENT OF COSTS
10. GENERAL PROVISIONS .............. Siinidinndnestiee 48 OF THE CENTRAL ARIZONA PROJECT
a 48 1. PARTIES
BD FUER 00 FEOEE WECM oc cccccesevvccscescesessccssovess 48 The parties to this contract, executed as of this first
S Sees Seeks 48 day of December, 1988, are the United States of America,
haem ek REG aE ai: acting through the Department of the Interior, and the
4 Recreational Use of Water Facilities.......... 51 Central Arizona Water Conservation District, a multi-
5 Confirmation of Contract.......................0008 51 county water conservation district organized under the
6 Rules, Regulations, and Determinations... 52 laws of Arizona, with its principal place of business in
; Phoenix, Arizona.
7 Books, Records, and Reports........................ 53

App. 98

2. AUTHORITIES

This contract is made pursuant to the:

2.1 Act of June 17, 1902, 32 Stat. 388, and acts
amendatory thereof and supplementary thereto.

2.2 Boulder Canyon Project Act, approved
December 21, 1928, 45 Stat. 1057, a supplement to the
Federal Reclamation Laws.

2.3 Reclamation Project Act of 1939, approved
August 4, 1939, 53 Stat. 1187, as amended.

2.4 Colorado River Basin Project Act, approved
September 30, 1968, 82 Stat. 885, as amended, a supple-
ment to the Federal Reclamation Laws.

2.5 Arizona Revised Statutes, Section 48-3701
et seq.

3. RECITALS

3.1 The Colorado River Basin Project Act pro-
vides, among other things, that for the purposes of fur-
nishing irrigation water and municipal and industrial
water supplies to water-deficient areas in Arizona and
western New Mexico through direct diversion or exchange
of water, control of floods, conservation and development
of fish and wildlife resources, enhancement of recreation
opportunities, and for other purposes, the Secretary of the
Interior shall construct, operate, and maintain the Central
Arizona Project, consisting of the principal works hereinaf-
ter described in Article 6.3.

3.2 Pursuant to the provisions of Arizona Revised
Statutes, Section 48-3701 et seq., the Central Arizona Water

App. 99

Conservation District has been organized with the power
to enter into a contract or contracts with the Secretary of
the Interior to accomplish the purposes of Arizona Revised
Statutes, Section 48-3701 et seq.

3.3 On December 15, 1972, the United States
and the Contractor entered into a contract entitled “Con-
tract Between the United States and the Central Arizona
Water Conservation District for Delivery of Water and
Repayment of Costs of the Central Arizona “roject” (Con-
tract No. 14-06-W-245), whereby, among other things, the
United States agreed to construct the Central Arizona
Project and the Contractor agreed to repay the costs of the
project properly allocable to the Contractor.

3.4 Subarticle 9.3(b) of said contract provides
that the Contractor’s repayment obligation shall not
exceed $1.2 billion.

3.5 Subarticle 9.3(b) of said contract also pro-
vides that if the Contractor’s repayment obligation will
exceed $1.2 billion, the Contracting Officer shall consult
with the Contractor and continuation of construction will
be contingent upon the execution of an amendatory con-
tract to cover the increased repayment obligation.

3.6 Both parties acknowledge that the Contrac-
tor’s repayment obligation will exceed $1.2 billion, and
have agreed to increase the Contractor’s repayment ceiling
to a level sufficient to facilitate completion of the project.

4. ARTICLES OF AGREEMENT

NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual and
dependent stipulations and covenants herein contained, it is

agreed by and between the parties hereto as follows:

App. 100

5. DEFINITIONS

When used herein, unless otherwise distinctly ex-
pressed, or manifestly incompatible with the intent hereof,
the terms:

5.1 “Federal Reclamation Laws” or “Reclamation
Laws” shall mean the Act of June 17, 1902, 32 Stat. 388,
and all acts amendatory thereof or supplementary thereto.

5.2 “Basin Project Act” shall mean the Colorado
River Basin Project Act, 82 Stat. 885, dated September 30,
1968, as amended, which is a supplement to the Federal
Reclamation Laws.

5.3 “Secretary” shall mean the Secretary of the
Interior of the United States or his duly authorized repre-
sentative.

5.4 “Contracting Officer” shall mean the Secre-
tary or his authorized designee acting in his behalf.

5.5 “Contractor” shall mean the Central Arizona
Water Conservation District, organized pursuant to
Arizona Revised Statutes, Section 48-3701 et seq.

5.6 “Service area” shall mean the area now
included within the Central Arizona Water Conservation
District, consisting of Maricopa, Pinal, and Pima Counties
of Arizona and such other counties as may hereafter
become part of the District, exclusive of any Indian reser-
vation land lying wholly or partly within said Counties.

5.7 “Subcontractor” shall mean any irrigation
district, municipality, individual, or any entity which
enters into a water service subcontract with the United
States and the Contractor in furtherance of the provisions
of the Basin Project Act.

App. 101

5.8 “Central Arizona Project” or “project” shall
mean the project and works authorized by Section 301(a)
of the Basin Project Act and constructed by the United
States pursuant to the provisions of said Act and this
contract.

5.9 “Project works” shall mean the principal
works described in Section 301(a) of the Basin Project Act,
and appurtenances thereto, or as modified pursuant to
Article 6.4 hereof, together with lands, interests in lands,
and rights-of-way for such works and appurtenances.

5.10 “Water supply system” shall mean the
Navajo Project, Havasu Pumping Plant, the Granite Reef,
Salt Gila and Tucson aqueducts and associated pumping
plants and appurtenant works, but not including Tucson
Terminal Storage or any distribution works.

5.11 “Distribution works” shall mean those
facilities constructed or financed by the United States
under the authorization in Section 309(b) of the Basin
Project Act for the primary purpose of distributing the
project water supply within the service area after said
project water supply has been transported or delivered

through the water supply system.

5.12 “Agricultural water” or “irrigation water”
shall mean project water used primarily in the commercial
production of agricultural crops or livestock, including
domestic use incidental thereto, on tracts of land operated
in units of more than 5 acres.

5.13 “Miscellaneous water” shall mean water
delivered from the project, or by exchange for project
water, for recreational and fish and wildlife purposes at

App. 102

other than project facilities and shall have a lesser priority
of use than agricultural water.

5.14 “Municipal and industrial water,” herein
referred to as “M&I water,” shall mean project water other
than agricultural or miscellaneous water delivered by
means of the project works.

5.15 “Lands not having a recent irrigation
history” shall mean, except where otherwise determined
by the Secretary for efficiency of subcontractor’s operation,
lands which the Secretary determines were not irrigated
during the period September 30, 1958, to September 30,
1968.

5.16 “OM&R” shall mean the care, operation,
maintenance, and replacement of project works.

5.17 “Exchange water” shall mean Colorado
River water made available in exchange for or in replace-
ment of existing supplies from surface sources other than
the mainstream of the Colorado River.

5.18 “Transferred works” shall mean_ such
facilities of the water supply system or of other construc-
tion stages as to which OM&R responsibility is transferred
from the United States to the Operating Agency.

5.19 “Operating Agency” shall mean the entity
or entities authorized to assume OM&R responsibility of
transferred works and approved for that purpose by the
Contracting Officer.

5.20 “Transfer notice” shall mean a written
notice or notices, numbered consecutively, which the
Contracting Officer transmits to the Operating Agency and
which shall designate:

App. 103

(a) the transferred works;

(b) items of equipment and supplies trans-
ferred to the Operating Agency; and

(c) the date upon which such transfer will
be effected.

5.21 “Gila River system waters” shall mean
waters of the Gila River and tributaries thereof east of the
Yuma-Maricopa County line.

5.22 “Notice of completion” shall mean the
notice which the Contracting Officer issues to Contractor
to announce the substantial completion of a construction
stage. Each such notice of completion shall include the
estimated amount of the repayment obligation for the
construction stage to which the notice pertains, the date of
initiation of repayment for the construction stage and
indicate the amount and due date for the first pavment for
the construction stage.

5.23 “Development Fund” shall mean the sepa-
rate fund, known as the Lower Colorado River Basin
Development Fund, established in the Treasury of the
United States pursuant to Section 403(a) of the Basin
Project Act.

5.24 “Year” -shall mean the period January 1
through the next succeeding December 31.

5.25 “Contractor’s Construction Cost Repayment
Obligation,” hereinafter referred to as “repayment obliga-
tion,” shall mean the total amount of all construction costs
including related construction claims and interest thereon,
OM&R costs during construction, and interest on costs
allocated to the M&I water and power functions during

App. 104

construction, of the Central Arizona Project, incurred
therefor and as determined by the United States and
further described in Article 6.2 hereof, excluding reim-
bursable costs allocated to fish and wildlife and recreation,
and costs associated with the delivery of water to entities
other than the Contractor or subcontractors, and which is
determined by the Secretary, after consultation with the
Contractor, to be allocable to and repayable by the Con-
tractor in accordance with the provisions of the Basin
Project Act and this contract.

5.26 “Return flow” shall mean all agricultural,
M&I, and miscellaneous waste water, seepage, and ground
water which originates or results from water contracted
for from the Central Arizona Project, but shall not include
any water delivered through the project works for ground
water recharge purposes.

5.27 “Project water” shall mean (a) all water
allocated by the Secretary for project purposes by Federal
Register notice dated March 24, 1983, and any subsequent
reallocation by the Secretary as contemplated in para-
graph 6 of said Federal Register notice, which water is
available pursuant to contracts with the Secretary from:
(1) the Colorado River; (2) Central Arizona Project dams
and reservoirs; and (3) return flows captured by the
Secretary for project use; (b) any water delivered to enti-
ties in Arizona, through the project works, as a replace-
ment supply for Cliff Dam; (c) water delivered to water
users in Arizona, through the project works, in exchange
for water delivered to users in New Mexico from or by
means of the project works; and (d) any additional water
not included in (a) above, that is required to be delivered
by the Secretary through the project, pursuant to the Ak-
Chin Water Rights Settlement Act of 1978 (Public Law

App. 105

95-328), as amended on October 19, 1984 (Public Law 98-
530); the Southern Arizona Water Rights Settlement Act of
October 12, 1982 (Title III of Public Law 97-293); and,
subject to the execution of a settlement agreement by the
Contractor providing for the settlement of the water rights
claims of the Salt River Pima-Maricopa Indian Commu-
nity and to the Salt River Pima-Maricopa Indian Commu-
nity Water Rights Settlement Act of 1988 (Public Law 100-
512), up to 22,000 acre-feet annually of Colorado River
water to be delivered through the project works in accor-
dance with said settlement agreement and legislation.

5.28 “Indian lands” shall mean the lands within
any Indian reservation for which an allocation of project
water has or will be made by the Secretary for delivery
through project works.

5.29 “Navajo Project” shall mean the interests of
the United States in the Navajo Generating Station and
the Transmission System, or any replacement thereof, as
authorized by Section 303 of the Basin Project Act and as
described in contracts entered into pursuant to that Act.

5.30 “Construction stage” shall mean any one of
the following: (1) the water supply system; (2) New
Waddell and Modified Roosevelt Dams; (3) replacement
features or programs for Cliff Dam; (4) Tucson terminal
storage; (5) Hooker Dam or suitable alternative; and (6)
Buttes Dam.

5.31 “Plan 6” shall mean Plan 6 for the Regula-
tory Storage Division of the Central Arizona Project as
approved by Record of Decision of the Secretary dated
April 3, 1984 as amended and supplemented by Records of
Decision of the Secretary dated May 20, 1986 (Supplement
One) and June 17, 1988 (Supplement Two).

App. 106

5.32 “Allocable cost” shall mean (a) with respect
to the project, the total project cost less (1) the cost of non-
Indian distribution works, (2) the cost of the safety of
dams component of Plan 6, (3) the cost of Indian distribu-
tion systems, (4) the cost of the Colorado River Division
and the New Mexico fish hatchery, (5) the cost of cultural
resources studies, (6) the contributions provided by the
States of Arizona and New Mexico prior to execution of the
Plan 6 Funding Agreement, (7) the costs of Charleston
Dam and San Pedro Aqueduct, (8) the cost of 500 cubic feet
per second of incremental capacity in the Granite Reef
Aqueduct and related costs in the Navajo Project, and (9)
such other costs as determined appropriate by the Con-
tracting Officer; and (b) with respect to each construction
stage, the total cost of such stage less that portion of the
following costs associated with such stage: (1) the cost of
the safety of dams component of Plan 6, (2) the cost of
cultural resources studies, (3) the contributions provided
by the States of Arizona and New Mexico prior to execu-
tion of the Plan 6 Funding Agreement, (4) the cost of 500
cubic feet per second of incremental capacity in the Gran-
ite Reef Aqueduct and related costs in the Navajo Project,
and (5) such other costs as determined appropriate by the
Contracting Officer.

5.33 “OM&R Transfer Contract” shall mean the
August 5, 1987, contract entitled “Contract Between the
United States of America and the Central Arizona Water
Conservation District for the Transfer of Operation and
Maintenance of Facilities” (Contract No. 7-07-30-W0167),
and any amendment or revision thereof.

5.34 “Overall repayment period” shall mean the
period of time beginning with initiation of repayment of

f

_—

App. 107

the first construction stage and ending with final payment
of the last construction stage.

5.35 “Plan 6 Funding Agreement” shall mean
the April 15, 1986, agreement entitled “Agreement Among
the United States, the Central Arizona Water Conserva-
tion District, the Flood Control District of Maricopa
County, the Salt River Agricultural Improvement and
Power District and Salt River Valley Water Users’ Associa-
tion, the Arizona Cities of Chandler, Glendale, Mesa,
Phoenix, Scottsdale, and Tempe, the State of Arizona, and
the City of Tucson for Funding of Plan Six Facilities of the
Central Arizona Project, Arizona, and for other Purposes,”
as it may be supplemented or amended.

5.36 “Permanent service” shall mean that water
supply service commencing in the year following substan-
tial completion of the water supply system and continuing

in perpetuity. ae

5.37 “Ground water recharge” shall mean the
recharge of water pursuant to title 45, chapter 2, article
13, Arizona Revised Statutes, or the underground storage
and recovery of water pursuant to title 45, chapter 3,
Arizona Revised Statutes, or as said statutes may hereaf-
ter be amended or revised.

5.38 “Project power” shall mean the United States’
entitlement to capacity and energy from the Navajo Project.

6. PROJECT CONSTRUCTION

" 6.1 Agreement of the United States. Subject to
the terms-and-conditions of this contract and within the

limits of the funds made available therefor by Congress,
the United States will expend toward the construction of
the project, exclusive of interest costs during construction,
$832,180,000 based on 1967 cost estimates, plus or minus

App. 108

such amounts, if any, as may be justified by reason of
ordinary fluctuations in construction costs as indicated by
engineering cost indices applicable to the types of con-
struction involved therein, or so much of such amount, as
in the opinion of the Secretary, is necessary to construct
said project, whichever amount is the lesser. The afore-
mentioned amount includes the United States’ costs of
participation in the Navajo Project.

6.2 Costs of Protect.

(a) The estimated construction cost of
$832,180,000 for the project, based upon 1967 prices, has
been determined as follows:

Main System $ 1,000’s
Granite Reef Division 407,740
Orme Division 42,340
Salt-Gila Division 47,170
Tucson Aqueduct (Colorado River source) 46,300
Buttes Dam 35,240
Navajo Project 106,000

Subtotal 684,790

Other Separate Features
Hooker Dam or suitable alternative 31,730
Charlesten Dam and San Pedro
Aqueduct (San Pedro River source) 36,420

Subtotal 68,150

Miscellaneous Features
*Gila River Division 5,250
Indian Distribution System 19,970
Colorado River Division 42,450
Drainage System 11,570

Subtotal 79,240
Total Project $832,180

*Note: Fish hatchery costs, some of which may be located
on the Colorado River.

App. 109

Provided, however, That (i) the adjustment provisions of
Article 6.1 apply to the total construction costs of the
project and not to the costs of the individual line items set
out in this Subarticle 6.2(a), and (ii) in accordance with
provisions of Article 6.4 herein, the references to the
individual line items set out in this Subarticle 6.2(a) are
not to be deemed a determination that each of the features
referred to in the individual line items will be constructed
or that costs will be incurred for each of said individual
line items based upon a percentage which the estimated
costs for each individual line item bears to the project’s
total estimated construction costs.

(b) The Central Arizona Project costs in-
curred by the United States which are to be repaid by
Contractor shall include the share allocated to the Con-
tractor of (i) construction costs of the project, (ii) all ex-
penses of whatsoever kind or naiure heretofore or
hereafter incurred by the United States in connection
with, growing out of, or resulting from the construction,
and (iii) the OM&R during construction of project works.
The aforementioned share of allocated costs shall also
include, but shall not be limited to, interest during con-
struction on costs allocated to the M&I water and power
functions, the cost of labor, materials, equipment, engi-
neering, legal services, surveys, investigations, property,
superintendence, administration, overhead, general
expenses, special services, damages of all kinds and
character, inspection, repair, and protection of project
works and water supply, and the costs of all lands, inter-
ests in lands, and rights-of-way acquired by the United
States for the project, all as determined by the Secretary.

App. 110

6.3 Principal Works of the Project. The works
and facilities to be constructed under this contract shall
consist of the following principal works:

(a) A system of main conduits and canals,
including the Havasu Pumping Plant and a main canal
and pumping plants (Granite Reef Aqueduct and pumping
plants), for diverting and carrying water from Lake
Havasu to the confluence of the Salt and Verde Rivers,
which system will have a capacity of 3,000 cubic feet per
second;

(b) Salt-Gila Aqueduct and pumping plant;
(c) Tucson Aqueduct and pumping plants;

(d) New Waddell and Modified Roosevelt
Dams;

(e) replacement features or programs for
Cliff Dam;

(f) Tucson Terminal Storage (if approved by
the Secretary);

(g) Buttes Dam and Reservoir;

(h) Hooker Dam and Reservoir or suitable
alternative which shall be constructed in such manner as
to give effect to the provisions of Section 304(f) of the
Basin Project Act;

(i) Charleston Dam and Reservoir and the
San Pedro Aqueduct;

(j) related canals, regulating facilities, and
electric transmission facilities required for the operation of
said principal works;

App. 111

(k) related water distribution and drainage
works; and

(1) appurtenant works.

No works or facilities for the treatment of water are
included in the project works to be constructed by the
United States. Nothing contained herein shall be con-
strued to indicate the order in which the aforedescribed
works will be constructed.

6.4 Changes in Project Works. Should the
Secretary, either before or during construction, determine
it to be in the best interests of the project, he may, upon
the completion of the studies currently being made or to be
made, including land classifications, hydrological, engi-
neering, geological, sedimentation, water supply, and
repayment ability, and after consultation with the Con-
tractor, change the location, size, or capacity of any of the
project works, or may eliminate works, or add works to
those described above, and the Secretary’s decision on such
changes, eliminations, and additions shall be conclusive.

6.5 Construction Conditions. The United States
shall be under no obligation to commence or, having
commenced, to continue construction of project works until
transfer from the State of Arizona of such State-owned
lands or interests therein, in a form acceptable to the
Attorney General of the United States, as the Secretary
determines is necessary in the construction, operation, or
maintenance of the project.

6.6 Annual Work Program. During construction
of the project works the Contracting Officer will consult
with the Contractor and/or with any subcontractor
through or within whose service area project works are to

App. 112

be constructed to achieve maximum coordination between
such construction program and the annual programs of
any affected subcontractor. Within 30 days following the
enactment by Congress and Presidential approval of
annual or supplementary appropriation acts and the
allotment of funds thereunder for continued construction
of the project, the United States will furnish the Contrac-
tor with a notice and statement showing the proposed
construction program for the balance of the current fiscal
year and for the following fiscal year or years. If so re-
quested in writing by the Contractor within 30 days of its
receipt of such notice, the Secretary will consult with the
Contractor and/or the affected subcontractor with respect
to the proposed program. The action of the Contracting
Officer concerning the program after such consultation
shall be final.

6.7 Inability of the United States to Complete
Project on Basis of Cost Estimates. If construction of the
project works shall have been commenced but, prior to
completion, the Secretary determines that the cost of
constructing the project will exceed the maximum amount
to be expended therefor by the United States as provided
for in Article 6.1 hereof, the Secretary may after consulta-
tion with the Contractor terminate construction and
declare the obligations of the United States hereunder
with regard to completion of construction of the project to
have been fulfilled. If appropriations for the continuance
and/or completion of construction in amounts sufficient in
the opinion of the Secretary to complete said construction
are authorized by Congress and are available, the Secre-
tary shall consult with the Contractor and shall make
continuation of construction contingent upon the execution
of an amendatory contract with the Contractor wherein

App. 113

the Contractor’s maximum repayment obligation is in-
creased so as to cover the increased reimbursable costs as
determined by the Secretary; Provided, however, That the
Contractor shall not utilize any part of the completed or
unfinished project facilities in the absence of written
agreement with the Secretary for reimbursement therefor.

7. PROJECT OPERATION, MAINTENANCE, AND
REPLACEMENT —

7.1 Operation and Maintenance and Water
Deliveries by the United States Prior to Completion of
Construction. Except as provided in the OM&R Transfer
Contract, prior to completion of project works by the
United States, as determined and announced to the
Contractor in writing by the Secretary, the United States
will operate and maintain said project facilities. The cost
of said OM&R allocated to the Contractor shall be in-
cluded in the Contractor’s repayment obligation; Provided,
however, That said OM&R cost shall not be included with
the project cost ceiling set out in Article 6.1 hereof. During
the aforesaid period, project water, if available, may be
disposed of by the Secretary at charges which the Secre-
tary determines to be appropriate; Provided, however, That
to the extent deemed feasible by the Secretary, preference
will be given to subcontractors and Indian lands. Payment
for water shall be made in advance by the water user. The
places of measurement and delivery of said water shall be
established by the Secretary after consultation with the
Contractor. Except as provided in the OM&R Transfer
Contract, the proceeds accruing from the disposal of such
water shall be credited to the Development Fund and
applied toward the costs of the project as determined by
the Secretary.

App. 114

7.2 Operation and Maintenance and Water Deliv-
eries after Completion of Construction. Except as provided in
the OM&R Transfer Contract and any future agreements
for the transfer of OM&R of the project works or portions
thereof, upon completion of construction of a construction
stage or upon completion of construction of the project, the
United States shall operate and maintain such construc-
tion stage or the project and shall make project water
available to project water users.

8. DELIVERY OF WATER

8.1 Obligation of United States. Subject to the
terms, conditions, and provisions set forth herein, the
United States will deliver project water to Contractor and,
during such periods as it operates and maintains the
water supply system, the United States will also transport
and deliver said water to the subcontractors. After trans-
fer of OM&R the United States will awake deliveries of
Colorado River water to the Operating Agency; deliveries
of other project waters will be made pursuant to determi-
nations made by the Secretary.

82 Term of Contract. Subject to the terms,
conditions, and provisions set forth herein, this contract is
for permanent service.

8.3 Conditions Relating to Delivery.

(a) The obligation of the United States to
deliver water under this contract is subject to:

(i) The availability of such water for
use in Arizona under the provi-
sions of the Colorado River Com-
pact, executed November 24, 1922;

(ii)

(iii)

App. 115

the Boulder Canyon Project Act, 45
Stat. 1057, dated December 21,
1928; the Colorado River Basin
Project Act, dated September 30,
1968, 82 Stat. 885; the contract be-
tween the United States and the
State of Arizona, dated February
9, 1944; the Opinion of the Su-
preme Court of the United States
in the case of Arizona v. California
et el., 373 U.S. 546, rendered June
3, 1963; and the March 9, 1964,
Decree of that Court in said case,
376 U.S. 340, as amended on Feb-
ruary 28, 1966, at 383 U.S. 268,
and supplemented on January 9,
1979, at 439 U.S. 419, as now is-
sued or hereafter modified.

Executive A, Seventy-eighth Con-
gress, Second Session, a treaty be-
tween the United States of
America and the United Mexican
States, signed at Washington on
February 3, 1944, relating to the
utilization of the water of the
Colorado River and Tijuana River
and of the Rio Grande from Fort
Quitman, Texas, to the Gulf of
Mexico, and Executive H, Seventy-
eighth Congress, Second Session, a
protocol signed at Washington on
November 14, 1944, supplemen-
tary to the Treaty.

The express understanding and
agreement by the Contractor that
this contract is subject to the con-
dition that Hoover Dam and Lake

Nee ELK

(iv)

App. 116

Mead shall be used: first, for river
regulation, improvement of navi-
gation, and flood control; second,
for irrigation and domestic uses
and satisfaction of present per-
fected rights in pursuance of Arti-
cle VIII of the Colorado River
Compact approved by Section 13(a)
of the Boulder Canyon Project Act;
and third, for power; and further-
more, that this contract is made
upon the express condition and
with the express covenant that all
rights hereunder shall be subject
to and controlled by the Colorado
River Compact and that the
United States and the Contractor
shall observe and be subject to and
controlled by said Colorado River
Compact and Boulder Canyon Pro-
ject Act in the construction, man-
agement, and operation of Hoover
Dam, Lake Mead, canals and other
works, and the storage, diversion,
delivery, and use of water to be de-
livered to Contractor hereunder.

The right of the United States
temporarily to discontinue or re-
duce the amount of water to be de-
livered hereunder whenever such
discontinuance or reduction is
made necessary for purposes of in-
vestigations, inspections, replace-
ments, maintenance, or repairs to
any works whatsoever affecting,
utilized or, in the opinion of the
Secretary, necessary for delivery of

App. 117

water hereunder, it being under-
stood that so far as feasible the
United States will (1) do so during
periods of low water demands and
(2) give reasonable notice in ad-
vance of such temporary discon-
tinuance or reduction.

(b) Delivery of Colorado River water by the
United States under this contract shall be charged to the
State of Arizona’s apportionment under the aforemen-
tioned Supreme Court Decree of March 9, 1964, in Arizona
v. California and will discharge to that extent the obliga-
tion of the United States to deliver water under the
aforementioned contract between the United States and
the State of Arizona, dated February 9, 1944.

8.4 Delivery Points. Colorado River water to be
furnished to the Contractor pursuant to this contract will
be delivered by the United States in the Colorado River at
the point of diversion from Lake Havasu where the intake
structures of the Havasu Pumping Plant are constructed.
Aqua Fria and Upper Gila River system waters will be
delivered to the Contractor at New Waddell and Buttes
Dams, respectively. Delivery points for other project water
supplies and for return flows will be determined by the
Contracting Officer after consultation with the Contractor
and/or the affected subcontractor therefor.

8.5 Measurement.

(a) The quantity of Colorado River water
pumped from Lake Havasu for the project shall be meas-
ured by means of measuring devices to be installed as part
of the project works. If, for any reason, in the opinion of
the Secretary, said measuring devices shall fail to operate

App. 118

satisfactorily, the Secretary will, from the best information
available, estimate the amount of water delivered to the
Contractor.

(b) Deliveries of project water to the various
subcontractors shall be measured by means of measuring
devices to be installed as part of the project works at the
points along the various aqueducts at which such water
may be diverted for each of said subcontractors, and/or at
the points in the various reservoirs formed by the dams
constructed as part of the project works at which such
water may be diverted for subcontractors and/or at the
points where return flow may be delivered. These points of
measurement will be established by the Secretary after
consultation with Contractor and the affected subcontrac-
tor. If, for any reason, in the opinion of the Secretary, said
measuring devices shall fail to operate satisfactorily, the
Secretary will, from the best information available and
after consultation with the Contractor and the affected
subcontractor, estimate the amount of water delivered to
each such subcontractor. The Secretary shall at all times
have access over any lands and rights-of-way of a subcon-
tractor for the purpose of inspecting and checking said
measuring devices.

8.6 Responsibility for Distribution of Water after
Leaving Water Supply System. Whether or not the United

States operates and maintains the project facilities, the
United States shall not be responsible for the control,
carriage, handling, use, disposal, or distribution of water
after said water has been diverted from the water supply
system. At such time as the Operating Agency assumes
responsibility for the OM&R of project works, the respon-
sibility for diversion, carriage, and transportation of the
water through the water supply system shall be the sole

App. 119

responsibility of the Operating Agency. Responsibility for
distribution of water beyond the water supply system shall
be that of the subcontractors to whom said water is deliv-
ered from the water supply system. The United States, its
officers, agents, and employees, shall not be liable for
damage or claim of damage of any nature whatsoever for
which there is legal responsibility arising out of or con-
nected with the control, carriage, handling, use, disposal,
or distribution of such water, and each subcontractor shall
hold the United States, its officers, agents, and employees,
harmless from any and all such claims.

8.7 Quantity of Water to be Delivered.

(a) The Secretary reserves the right to
determine that quantity of Colorado River water to be
released each year from Lake Mead for use by the Central
Arizona project pursuant to applicable law, which shall
include the quantity of water which may be allocated by
the Secretary for use on Indian lands.

(b) The quantity of Colorado River water
available under this contract for project purposes shall not
exceed the quantity of water available to Arizona under
the aforementioned Supreme Court Decree in Arizona v.
California and in Arizona’s water delivery contract with
the United States after first providing for satisfaction of:

(i) present perfected rights and per-
fected rights described in Article
II(D) of the Decree and the rights of
other Federal reservations estab-
lished prior to September 30, 1968;
Provided, however, That the quanti-
ties of Colorado River water re-
served to satisfy the aforesaid
rights shall not, except as provided

App. 120

in said Decree, be reduced under
any circumstances or for any reason
whatsoever including, without limi-
tation, a temporary use permitted
by the Secretary by other water us-
ers in Arizona, California, or Ne-
vada, of water reserved pursuant to
the foregoing but not needed during
any calendar year; And provided
further, That no rights to the recur-
rent use of such water shall accrue
by reason of said temporary use;
and

(ii) the quantities of water provided for
in all water delivery contracts be-
tween the United States and water
users in Arizona as of September
30, 1968.

(c) The quantity of Colorado River water
available under this contract for project purposes, includ-
ing water for use on Indian lands shall have the same
priority as to delivery as the quantities of Colorado River
water delivered pursuant to water delivery contracts,
Federal reservations of water, and other arrangements
between the United States and water users in Arizona
entered into subsequent to September 30, 1968, for use of
Colorado River water on Federal, State or privately owned
lands in Arizona in total quantities not to exceed 164,652
acre-feet of diversions per year; Provided, however, That
the Contractor shall hold the United States, its officers,
agents, employees, and successors or assigns, harmless as
to any and all claims for damages to persons or to property
direct or indirect and of whatever nature, arising out of or
which may in any manner be connected with the operation
and/or effect of this Subarticle.

a are

App. 121

(d) The limitation on contracting in Subarti-
cle 8.7(c) above shall not apply to contracts with holders of
present perfected rights to Colorado River water in Ari-
zona or to the Secretary’s order of November 24, 1982,
reserving Colorado River water for the Cibola National
Wildlife Refuge. Nothing in Subarticle 8.7(c) shall restrict
the right of the Secretary under water service contracts
referred to in said Subarticle to terminate and/or reduce
any entity’s entitlement to Colorado River water and to

make that entitlement available to other water users in
Arizona.

(e) During any year when the subcontrac-
tors cannot use any portion of their entitlement to project
water, and such water cannot be resold or exchanged in
accordance with the terms and conditions of the water
service subcontracts, the Contractor shall have the right in
its discretion to resell any or all of such water or to use
any or all of such water for ground water recharge pur-
poses, including the subsequent recovery and resale of
such water, subject to Federal law, including but not
limited to the Reclamation Reform Act of 1982, State of
Arizona law, and such rules and regulations as the Secre-
tary may deem appropriate. Subject to the terms and
conditions of water service subcontracts, the water orders
of all subcontractors shall be met before any project water
is made available to the Contractor under this provision.

8.8 Subcontracts.

(a) The United States shall be a party to
subcontracts.

(b) The Secretary and the Contractor shall
require in each subcontract that:

(i)

(ii)

(111)

(iv)

App. 122

unless and until otherwise pro-
vided by Congress, water from
the Central Arizona Project shall
not be made available directly or
indirectly for the irrigation of
lands not having a recent irriga-
tion history, as determined by the
Secretary, except in the case of
Indian lands, national wildlife
refuges, and, with the approval of
the Secretary, State-administered
wildlife management areas;

there be in effect measures, ade-
quate in the judgment of the Sec-
retary and the Contractor, to
control expansion of irrigation
from aquifers affected by irriga-
tion in the Contractor’s service
area and to reduce pumping of
ground water in the agricultural
subcontractors’ service areas by
the amount of project water re-
ceived by said agricultural sub-
contractors;

the canals and distribution sys-
tems through which water is con-
veyed after its delivery to the
subcontractors shall be provided
and maintained with linings ade-
quate in the Secretary’s judgment
to prevent excessive conveyance
losses;

neither the Secretary, the Con-
tractor nor any subcontractor
shall pump or permit others to
pump ground water from within

(v)

(vi)

App. 123

the exterior boundaries of the
service area of a subcontractor
receiving water from the Central
Arizona Project for any use out-
side of said subcontractor’s ser-
vice area unless the Secretary,
the Contractor, and such subcon-
tractor shall agree, or shall have
previously agreed, that a surplus
of ground water exists and that
drainage is or was required;

except as otherwise agreed by the
Contracting Officer, neither the
Contractor nor any subcontractor
shall sell or otherwise dispose of
or permit the sale or other dispo-
sition of any project water, includ-
ing return flows, for use outside
the Contractor’s service area;

irrigation water made available
thereunder may be made avail-
able by the Secretary for M&I
purposes if and to the extent that
such water is no longer required
by the subcontractor for irrigation
purposes and shall be made
available in all cases where lands
receiving project water have been
converted to municipal and in-
dustrial use; Provided, however,
That subcontracts effectuating
such transfers are subject to the
approval of the Secretary and the
Contractor, which approval shall
not be withheld unreasonably;
And provided further, That it
shall be deemed unreasonable for

(vii)

(viii)

App. 124

the Secretary or the Contractor to
withhold such approval on the
basis that the right to convert
from irrigation to M&I use for a
specific development could better
be exercised in some other sub-
contractor’s service area. The wa-
ter so converted from irrigation to
M&I purposes will be delivered
with the same priority and at the
same rate per acre-foot as other
M&I water. Likewise, subcon-
tracts for furnishing water for
M&I purposes, including, but not
limited to, ground water recharge
to the extent ground water re-
charge is consistent with Arizona
law, shall provide that, if water to
be delivered thereunder is not
presently required for such pur-
poses, such water may be made
available by the Secretary to
other users; Provided, further,
That the subcontractor shall be
relieved of its payment obligation
under its subcontract only to the
extent of the amount paid by such
other users;

the acreage limitation provisions
of Reclamation Laws shall apply
solely to agricultural water service;

except as specifically provided
therein, it shall be the provisions
of this contract which shall be
controlling in the event of any in-
consistency between this contract
and any subcontract;

—

App. 125

(ix) the subcontractor shall levy all
necessary assessments, tolls, and
other charges and shall use all of
the authority and _ resources
available to the subcontractor to
collect the same in order that the
subcontractor may meet its obli-
gations thereunder to make in
full all payments required under
said subcontract on or before the
date such payments become due
and to meet other obligations un-
der the subcontracts;

(x) the subcontractor _ establish,
maintain, and provide the United
States and the Contractor with
land, water use, and crop census
records.

8.9 Shortages. As provided in Section 301(b) of
the Basin Project Act, Article II(B)(3) of the Decree of the
Supreme Court of the United States in Arizona v. Cali-
fornia, 376 U.S. 340, dated March 9, 1964, shall be so
administered that in any year in which, as determined by
the Secretary, there is insufficient mainstream Colorado
River water available for release to satisfy the annual
consumptive use of 7,500,000 acre-feet in Arizona, Cali-
fornia, and Nevada, diversions from the mainstream of
the Colorado River for the Central Arizona Project and
for other uses in Arizona under contracts or other agree-
ments with the United States executed subsequent to
September 30, 1968, shall be so limited as to assure the
availability of water in quantities sufficient to provide for
the aggregate annual consumptive use by holders of
present perfected rights, by other users in the State of

App. 126

California served under contracts existing as of Septem-
ber 30, 1968, with the United States by diversion works
heretofore constructed, and by other Federal reservations
in California of 4,400,000 acre-feet of Colorado River
water, and by users of the same character in Arizona and
Nevada. Water users in the State of Nevada shall not be
required to bear shortages in any proportion greater than
would have been imposed in the absence of said Section
301(b), nor shall said Section affect the relative priorities,
among themselves, of water users in Arizona, California,
and Nevada which are senior to diversions for the Central
Arizona Project, or amend any provisions of said Decree.
The aforesaid limitation stated in Section 301(b) shall not
apply so long as the Secretary shall determine and pro-
claim that means are available and in operation which
augment the water supply of the Colorado River system in
such quantity as to make sufficient Colorado River main-
stream water available for release to satisfy annual
consumptive use of 7,500,000 acre-feet in Arizona, Califor-
nia, and Nevada.

8.10 Rate of Diversions of Colorado River Water.
Subject to (a) the first proviso in Section 301(a) of the
Basin Project Act, (b) the provisions of Subarticle 10.6(b)
hereof, and (c) the provisions of Subarticle 8.7(a) hereof,
any capacity in the Granite Reef Aqueduct in excess of
2,500 cubic feet per second may be utilized in the opera-
tions of the project so as to maximize project benefits;
Provided, however, That the use of such capacity shall not
result in the annual diversion of a quantity of water in
excess of the project’s legal entitlement under the Basin
Project Act.

App. 127

8.11 Priority in Case of Shortage.

(a) Subject to the provisions of Section
304(e) of the Basin Project Act and the Secretary’s alloca-
tion decisions published in the Federal Register on Decem-
ber 10, 1980, and March 24, 1983, any project water as
defined in Subarticle 5.27(a) hereof, furnished through
project facilities shall, in the event of shortages thereof, be
reduced pro rata until exhausted, first for miscellaneous
uses and next for agricultural uses, before such project
water furnished for M&I uses is reduced. Thereafter, such
project water for M&I uses will be reduced pro rata among
all M&I water users. Each subcontract or other water
delivery arrangement entered into pursuant to this con-
tract shall so provide. This article shall not apply to Indian
uses; Provided, however, That the relative priorities
between Indian and non-Indian uses shall be as deter-
mined by the Secretary. Notwithstanding the provisions of
this Subarticle, project water made available as a result of
construction and operation of modifications to Roosevelt
Dam as part of Plan 6 shall be distributed as provided in
the Plan 6 Funding Agreement, and shall not be subject to
reduction in the event of shortages of other project water
supplies.

(b) Any project water, is defined in Subarti-
cles 5.27(b), (c) and (d) hereof, shall retain its priority
relative to project water as defined in Subarticle 5.27(a)
hereof.

8.12 No Guarantee of Availability of Water. The
United States assumes no responsibility with respect to
the quantity of water available for delivery pursuant to
this contract. In no event shall the United States, its
officers, agents, or employees, be liable for any damages,

App. 128

direct or indirect, of whatsoever nature, arising out of or in
any way connected with any suspension or reduction in
the delivery of water pursuant to this contract or with any
shortage in the quantity of water available for delivery
hereunder or to any subcontractor for any cause whatso-
ever including, but not limited to, drought, delay in the
construction of the Navajo Project, the failure of the
Navajo Project to be completed, or the lack of power for

pumping.
8.13 Secretarial Control of Return Flow.

(a) The Secretary reserves the right to
capture all return flow flowing from the exterior bounda-
ries of the Contractor as a source of supply and for distri-
bution to and use of the Central Arizona Project to the
fullest extent practicable. The Secretary also reserves the
right to capture for project use return flows within the
boundaries of Contractor if in his judgment such return
flow is not being put to a beneficial use. Any subcontractor
may sell its return flow; Provided, however, That except as
otherwise agreed by the Contracting Officer, such return
flow may not be sold for use outside the Contractor’s
exterior boundaries; And provided further, That if the
price received for such return flow is higher than the price
paid for such project water, the amount of the excess price
shall be paid by such subcontractor to the Contractor for
application against the Contractor’s repayment obligation
to the United States.

(b) Any return flow captured by the United
States and determined by the Secretary to be suitable and
available for use on lands within the service area and/or
by any subcontractor therein may be delivered by the
United States to a subcontractor as a part of the water

App. 129

supply for which the subcontractor contracts hereunder
and such water shall be accounted and paid for pursuant
to the provisions hereof.

8.14 Water and Air Pollution Control. The Con-
tractor, in carrying out this contract, shall comply with all
applicable water and air pollution laws and regulations of
the United States and the State of Arizona, and shall
obtain all required permits or licenses from the appropri-
ate Federal, State, or local authorities.

8.15 Quality of Water. The operation and main-
tenance of project facilities shall be performed in such
manner as is practicable to maintain the quality of project
water made available through such facilities at the highest
level reasonably attainable as determined by the Contract-
ing Officer or the Operating Agency. Neither the United
States nor the Operating Agency warrants the quality of
water and are under no obligation to construct or furnish
water treatment facilities to maintain or better the quality
of water.

8.16 Exchange Water. Where the Secretary deter-
mines that a subcontractor is physically able to receive
Colorado River mainstream water in exchange for or in
replacement of existing supplies of surface water from
sources other than the Colorado River to provide water
supplies for users upstream from New Waddell, Modified
Roosevelt and Buttes Dams, the Secretary may require
that said subcontractor agree to accept said mainstream
water in exchange for or in replacement of said existing
supplies pursuant to the provisions of Section 304(d) of the
Basin Project Act.

8.17 Rights Reserved to the United States to
Have Water Carried by Project Facilities. As a condition to

App. 130

the construction of project facilities and the delivery of
water hereunder, the Contractor agrees that all project
facilities will be available for the diversion, transportation,
and carriage of water for Indian and non-Indian uses
pursuant to arrangements or contracts therefor entered
into on their behalf with the Secretary. In the event the
responsibility for the OM&R of project facilities is trans-
ferred to and assumed by the Operating Agency, such
transfer shall be subject to the condition that the Operat-
ing-Agency shall divert, transport, and carry such water
for such uses pursuant to the provisions of the aforesaid
arrangements or contracts; Provided, however, That the
aforesaid arrangements or contracts will include provi-
sions for the payment of applicable construction costs and
OM&R costs in accordance with Articles 9.3 and 9.6 of this
contract.

8.18 Wheeling Non-Project Water. After taking
into consideration the water delivery requirements of
contracts for project water service and subject to availabil-
ity of project capacity, non-project water may be wheeled
through project facilities pursuant to wheeling agreements
between the Contracter and the entity desiring to use
project facilities for wheeling purposes. All such agree-
ments shall be subject to the approval of the Contracting
Officer who shall consider, among other things, the impact
that the wheeling of such non-project water will have on
the quality of project water. The Contractor and the
Contracting Officer shall jointly develop a standard form
of wheeling agreement including the rate structure for
wheeling non-project water. All wheeling charges shall be
paid to the Contractor by the entity contracting for the
wheeling of non-project water. The Contractor shall be

App. 131

entitled to retain revenues from wheeling charges suffi-
cient to cover all OM&R costs associated with wheeling
such non-project water, plus an administrative charge to
be jointly determined by the Contractor and the Contract-
ing Officer. All revenues from wheeling charges in excess
of the OM&R costs and administrative charges shall be
remitted by the Contractor to the Contracting Officer and
deposited into the Development Fund.

8.19 Use of Project Power to Wheel Non-Project
Water. If the energy requirements necessary for the pump-
ing of project water are met and subject to the require-

- ments of the Navajo Power Marketing Plan published in

the Federal Register on December 21, 1987, project power
may be used to wheel non-project water through project
facilities under such conditions of use, including amounts,
times of use, losses, costs, and other conditions as are
established by the Contractor and approved by the Con-
tracting Officer.

9. PAYMENT OF PROJECT COSTS ALLOCATED
TO CONTRACTOR

9.1 Allocation of Construction Costs.

(a) Upon completion of each construction
stage, the Contracting Officer will allocate costs to the
various project purposes using the separable costs-
remaining benefits procedure.

(b) For repayment purposes the reimburs-
able cost allocated to irrigation and M&I water by the
separable costs-remaining benefits procedure will be
combined and will hereinafter be termed the “water supply
allocation.” Upon completion of each construction stage,

App. 132

and at the periodic intervals specified in Subarticle 9.3(d),
suballocation of the water supply allocation will be made
to the irrigation and M&I water functions proportional to
the water estimated to be used for each purpose during the
repayment period of each construction stage. The cost thus
suballocated to the irrigation function will hereinafter be
termed the “interest-free allocation.” The cost thus subal-
located to the M&I water function shall be added to the
cost allocated to the commercial power function, plus
interest during construction for both, and the sum will
hereinafter be termed the “interest-bearing allocation.”

(c) During construction, simple interest at the rate of
3.342 percent per annum shall be charged on costs allo-
cated to the interest-bearing function as adjusted by the
Secretary (i.e., net disbursements reduced by contract
holdbacks, revenues applied to construction cost, and nonre-
imbursable expenses financed from construction funds). The
total amount of all interest thus accumulated through the
construction period prior to the date of completion of each
construction stage shall be added to and become part of
the actual construction cost of each construction stage.
Interest during construction shall not accrue during any
period in which construction is deferred or postponed by
the United States as a result of a national emergency, as
determined by the Secretary, if authority to forego such
interest exists or is made available to the Secretary.

9.2 Repayment Concepts.

(a) Costs suballocated to non-Indian irriga-
tion water will be paid by the subcontractors to the Con-
tractor on the basis of their ability to pay as determined by
the Secretary.

App. 133

(b) Costs allocated to commercial power and
costs suballocated to M&I water use shall be combined
and repaid with interest at a rate of 3.342 percent per
annum on the unpaid balance.

(c) Reimbursable costs allocated to recrea-
tion and fish and wildlife are anticipated to be covered by
a separate contract and repaid by the beneficiaries thereof.

(d) Repayment of costs allocated to irriga-
tion of Indian lands shall be governed by the provisions of
Section 402 of the Basin Project Act.

(e) Repayment of the project will occur by
construction stages, with each stage having a separate 50-
year repayment schedule. Upon completion of each cost
allocation study referred to in Subarticle 9.1(a), subse-
quent to the initial study associated with the first con-
struction stage, the Contractor’s repayment obligation and
the obligation allocated to each construction stage will be
adjusted based on the latest cost allocation study, and the
Contractor will be provided with a revised repayment
schedule for the project and each construction stage. The
Contracting Officer will adjust previous principal and
interest payments made by the Contractor to reflect the
new repayment schedule. For each year where an adjust-
ment in payments is necessary, there will be an over or
underpayment which will accrue with interest at the rate
of 3.342 percent per annum (compounded annually) to the
adjustment date. If the adjustment indicates that the
Contractor overpaid principal and interest, the Contractor
shall be entitled to a credit against its next payments to
the United States. Conversely, if the Contractor owes
additional principal and interest to the United States,
such amount shall be paid to the United States by the

App. 134

Contractor within 12 months of receipt of a statement
therefor from the Contracting Officer. The Contractor may
use the repayment reserve fund under Subarticle 10.3(b)
-hereof for any payment to the United States required as a
result of the above adjustment.

9.3 Contractor’s Construction Cost Repayment
Obligation.

(a) The Contractor’s repayment obligation
shall consist of the total cost allocated to the water supply
and power functions plus OM&R during construction and
interest during construction on costs allocated to the M&I
water and power functions, but shall not include costs
allocated to fish and wildlife and recreation, and costs
associated with the delivery of water to entities other than
the Contractor or subcontractors. Such entities shall
include but not be limited to Indian tribes and councils in
central Arizona receiving project water and the New
Mexico recipients of water service from Hooker Dam or
suitable alternative. The costs to be excluded shall be
calculated as follows:

(i) Costs excluded from the Contrac-
tor’s repayment obligation for New
Mexico water service shall be de-
termined by multiplying the project
costs allocated to the water supply
function by the ratio developed by
dividing the quantity of project wa-
ter projected to be delivered
throughout the overall repayment
period to water users in Arizona in
exchange for water delivered to us-
ers in New Mexico from or by
means of project works, by the total
quantity of Colorado River water

App. 135

projected to be delivered by the pro-
ject throughout the overall repay-
ment period.

(ii) The amount of other project costs
which shall be excluded from the
Contractor’s repayment obligation
shall be determined by multiplying
the project costs allocated to the
water supply function by a ratio de-
veloped by dividing the quantity of
project water projected to be deliv-
ered throughout the overall repay-
ment period to entities other than
the Contractor, the subcontractors,
and those users in New Mexico to
whom water has been made avail-
able through the construction of
Hooker Dam or suitable alternative
by the total quantity of project water
projected to be delivered throughout
the overall repayment period; Pro-
vided, That project water projected
to be delivered to such users will be
computed based on an assumption
of full development not later than
the year 2005.

(b) The costs determined under Subarticles
9.3(a)(i) and (ii) above shall be subtracted from the water
supply costs obtained from the separable costs-remaining
benefits procedure to determine the Contractor’s water
supply costs. The Contracting Officer shall suballocate the
Contractor’s water supply costs to each of tue construction
stages based on the ratios obtained by dividing the alloc-
able cost of the construction stage by the allocable cost
of the project (see Operation 1, Exhibit “A”). The water

App. 136

supply costs assigned to each construction stage are then
further suballocated between irrigation and M&I water
use in proportion to projected total water deliveries to each
function over the 50-year repayment period of each con-
struction stage (Operation 2, Exhibit “A”). The summari-
zation of the suballezai:ons to each construction stage
determines the total water supply cost to be assigned to
irrigation and M&I water use (Operation 3, Exhibit “MA”).
To determine the Contractor’s repayment obligation, the
Contractor’s water supply suballocation to irrigation and
M&I water uses, and the power allocation from the sepa-
rable costs-remaining benefits procedure, shall each be
adjusted for any revenues received by the United States
prior to the notice(s) of completion and for any contribu-
tions received by the United States under the Plan 6
Funding Agreement for the features constructed in that
stage, and for the 500 cubic feet per second of incremental
capacity in the Granite Reef Aqueduct and pumping plants
(see Article 9.7) to determine the net amount of each
function assigned to the Contractor (Operation 4, Exhibit
“A”). The Contractor’s repayment obligation shall be the
summation of the net amount for each function.

(c) Once the Contractor’s estimated or final
repayment obligation has been determined by the Con-
tracting Officer, the obligation shall be allocated to each
construction stage based on the ratio obtained by dividing
the allocable cost of each construction stage by the alloc-
able cost of the project. Each construction stage will have a
separate 50-year repayment period. The repayment
obligation for each stage will be divided into interest-
bearing and interest-free components. The interest-free
component shall be the amount allocable to irrigation
purposes for the stage. The interest-bearing component

App. 137

will be the amount obtained by subtracting the irrigation
allocation for the stage from the obligation for the stage.
The principal payments for each stage shall be determined
by applying the percentages in Subarticle 9.3(f) to the
repayment obligation for each stage. The total payment for
each stage for any year shall be equal to the principal
payment plus interest at the rate of 3.342 percent per
annum on the unpaid interest-bearing component of the
repayment obligation for each stage. For the water supply
system, the portion of each principal payment which it
made by the Contractor from irrigation revenues received
by the Contractor each year will be used by the United
States to reduce the interest-free obligation. The remain-
ing portion of the principal payments made by the Con-
tractor each year for the water supply system will be used
by the United States to reduce the interest-bearing obliga-
tion, and once the interest-bearing obligation has been
retired, the entire principal payment made by the Con-
tractor will be applied by the United States toward the
interest-free obligation. For the other construction stages,
the entire principal payment made by the Contractor each
year for such stages will be applied by the United States to
reduce the interest-bearing obligation first, and once such
obligation has been retired, to reduce the interest-free
obligation.

(d) At 7-year intervals following the deter-
mination of the Contractor’s repayment obligation for the
water supply system, or at more frequent intervals if it
becomes apparent to the Contracting Officer that a signifi-
cant change in water use has or will occur, until such time
as the interest-bearing obligation for each construction
stage has been repaid, the Contracting Officer wil) re-
estimate the proportions of total water deliveries to

App. 138

irrigation and M&I water use over the 50-year repayment
period for each stage. At such intervals, the Contracting
Officer will adjust the original interest-bearing and
interest-free allocation for each stage based on the new
estimates and recalculate all preceding interest payments.
Differences between amounts owed and amounts paid by
the Contractor shall be adjusted by the Contracting
Officer, who shall apply a credit against the Contractor’s
next payment due or notify the Contractor of the addi-
tional amount due, as the case may be. All such adjust-
ments shall include interest at the rate of 3.342 percent
per annum (compounded annually). Any additional pay-
ments required from the Contractor shall be made within
12 months of the Contractor’s receipt of a statement from
the Contracting Officer therefor. The Contractor may use
the repayment reserve fund under Subarticle 10.3(b)
hereof for any payment to the United States required as a
result of the above adjustment.

(e) The Contracting Officer will notify the
Contractor of (i) its estimated repayment obligation when
construction of the first construction stage is substantially
complete and upon completion of each subsequent con-
struction stage, and (ii) the actual repayment obligation
when the final construction stage has been completed, as
determined by the Contracting Officer. In the event that
the project ultimately consists only of the water supply
system, New Waddell Dam, and Modified Roosevelt Dam,
the Contractor’s actual repayment obligation shall be
limited to $2.0 billion. If prior to completion of construc-
tion of such features the Contracting Officer determines
that the Contractor’s repayment obligation for such
features will exceed $2.0 billion, the Contracting Officer
shall consult with the Contractor and continuation of

App. 139

construction will be contingent upon the execution of an
amendatory contract to cover the increased repayment
obligation. If construction of any other construction stage
will result in an increase in the Contractor’s repayment
obligation by an amount equal to or less than the respec-
tive amount identified in Exhibit “B,” which is attached
hereto and made part of this contract, the Contractor’s
repayment ceiling may, after consultation with the Con-
tractor, be increased by the Contracting Officer by an
amount equal to or less than the respective amount
identified in Exhibit “B” by written notice thereof from the
Contracting Officer to the Contractor. If construction of
such other construction stage will result in an increase in
the Contractor’s repayment obligation by an amount
greater than the respective amount identified in Exhibit
“B,” the Contracting Officer shall consult with the Con-
tractor and the Contractor and the Contracting Officer
shall agree upon one of the following courses of action
prior to initiation of construction of such construction
stage: (1) that additional repayment ceiling be made
available from other construction stages, in which event
the Contractor’s repayment ceiling will be increased to the
agreed-to amount by written notice from the Contracting
Officer to the Contractor; or (2) that this contract be
renegotiated to increase the Contractor’s repayment
ceiling; Provided, That these courses of action shall also
apply in the event that, prior to completion of construction
of such stage, the Contracting Officer determines that the
construction of such stage will result in arn increase in the
Contractor’s repayment obligation by an amount greater
than the respective amount identified in Exhibit “B.”

(f) Annual percentages of the repayment
obligation for each construction stage shall be those set

App. 140

out in the following schedule or any revision thereof
mutually agreed upon:

Percent of Repayment
Repayment Year Obligation (Annual)

1-7 1.0
8-14 1.3
15-21 1.6
22-28 2.0
29-35 2.6
36-42 2.7
43-49 2.7

50 2.7

(g) In the event that the Secretary contracts
for delivery of non-project water under the provisions of
Article 10.1, capital charges associated with such delivery
shall be calculated, charged, and utilized in the same
manner as capital charges deposited in the Development
Fund pursuant to Article 8.18.

9.4 Payment of Contractor’s Construction Cost
Repayment.

(a) The Contractor shall make annual
payments to the United States, to be credited to the
Development Fund, which shall be sufficient, when com-
bined with accruals from the other sources described in

Section 403(f) of the Basin Project Act, the Hoover Power —

Plant Act of 1984, and other miscellaneous revenues,
including but not limited to net wheeling charges, to effect
repayment of the repayment obligation for each construc-
tion stage within a period of not more than 50 years
beginning with the year following substantial completion
of each construction stage. The Contractor’s first payment
shall be due on or before January 15 of the year following
the year in which the Secretary announces the substantial

App. 141

completion of each construction stage. Annual payments
thereafter shall be due on or before January 15 of each
following year.

(b) The Contractor agrees to make annual
payments calculated by the Secretary as follows:

(i) Calculate the annual principal pay-
ments required by the schedule in
Subarticle 9.3(f) or any revision
thereof for each construction stage.

(ii) “Add to (i) the annual interest, at
3.342 percent, on the unpaid bal-
ance of the interest-bearing alloca-
tion for each construction stage.

(iii) Determine the total amount of all
interest and principal payments
due for all construction stages.

(iv) Subtract therefrom the revenues
estimated to be available from the
Development Fund enticipating a
zero balance at the end of each year
in the Development Fund.

(v) Make adjustments for differences
between estimated and actual reve-
nues for the preceding year.

(c) On or before each December 15, begin-
ning with December 15 of the year in which the Secretary
notifies the Contractor of the substantial completion of the
first construction stage, the Secretary will notify the
Contractor of the amount of the annual payment due on
the following January 15, which has been determined by
the Secretary on the basis of the aforesaid calculation.

App. 142

(d) The Contractor may make additional
payments on the repayment obligation at any time subject
to such terms and conditions as may be agreed upon by
the Contractor and the Contracting Officer; Provided,
however, That all interest due is paid at the same time,
whereupon appropriate adjustments in the schedule of
future payments will be made by the Secretary, who shall
as promptly as possible give the Contractor written notice
of the adjusted repayment schedule.

(e) It is understood and agreed that the
Contractor shall be obligated for the payments set forth in
Subarticle 9.4(a) hereof and that regardless of the delin-
quency or default in payment of any charges due to the
Contractor from any subcontractor, or a diminution in the
water supply available to the Contractor, or regardless of
any other reason, the Contractor shall complete repay-
ment of each construction stage within a 50-year period
beginning in the year following the announcement by the
Secretary of substantial completion of such construction
stage.

9.5 Commercial Power Rates. The Secretary will,
consistent with applicable law, periodically review and
provide for appropriate adjustments in the rates estab-
lished for the sales of power and energy, revenues from
which contribute to the Development Fund.

9.6 Other Costs Borne by the Contractor.

(a) In addition to the payments provided for
in Article 9.4 hereof, and subject to the provisions of
Subarticle 9.6(d) hereof, during such periods as the United
States operates and maintains completed construction
stages, the Contractor shall make advance payments for

App. 143

OM&R costs incurred by the United States. The United
States will furnish the Contractor with an estimate in
writing at least-6 months prior to substantial completion
of construction of the water supply system, of the OM&R
cost due from the Contractor to the end of the then current
year, together with an estimate of such cost for the calen-
dar year immediately following. Within a reasonable time
of the receipt of said estimates, as determined by the
Contracting Officer, the Contractor shall advance to the
United States the payments for the estimated OM&R cost
to the end of the then current year and without further
notice or demand shall on December 15 of the then current
year and on June 15 of the following year advance to the
United States in equal semiannual installments the
Contractor’s share of the estimated cost, including super-
vision and administrative expense for the OM&R of the
water supply system. Advance payments shall be made in
subsequent years by the Contractor to the United States
on the basis of estimates to be furnished by the United
States on or before November 15 preceding said subse-
quent year and the advances of said payments shall be due
and payable in equal semiannual payments on the follow-
ing December 15 and June 15. Said OM&R costs are the
total annual OM&R costs of completed construction stages
which are allocated to the irrigation and M&I water
supply functions less (i) the costs described in Subarticle
9.6(c) hereof, and (ii) an amount determined by multiply-
ing the tots’ of said annual costs by the ratio obtained by
dividing the estimated amount of project water projected
to be delivered in the subsequent year to entities other
than the Contractor, the subcontractors, and those entities
in New Mexico to which project water will be made avail-
able from Hooker Dam or suitable alternative, by the total

App. 144

amount of project water estimated to be delivered for use
in that year.

(b) Differences between actual OM&R costs
and the estimated costs shall be determined by the Con-
tracting Officer and shall be adjusted in next succeeding
estimates; Provided, however, That if in the opinion of the
Contracting Officer the amounts advanced by the Contrac-
tor for any yea: are likely to be insufficient to pay the
above-mentione:: ODM&R costs during such year, additional
and sufficient sums of money shall be paid forthwith by
the Contractor to the United States upon notice thereof
and demand therefor by the Contracting Officer; Provided,
further, That the United States will give Contractor
reasonable notice in advance of any such deficiency.

(c) The Contractor’s obligation to pay said
OM&R costs of completed construction stages will be
reduced to the extent that project water is made available
for use in New Mexico following completion of Hooker
Dam or suitable alternative. Said reduction will be in the
proportion which the quantity of project water projected to
be delivered to water users in Arizona, in exchange for
Gila River system waters delivered to water users in New
Mexico from or by means of project works, bears to the
total quantity of Colorado River water projected to be
delivered to the project that year.

(d) In the event that responsibility for
OM&R of project facilities is transferred to and assumed
by the Contractor, the Contractor shall be relieved of the
obligation to make OM&R payments associated with such
facilities under Subarticle 9.6(a) of this contract. In that
event, the United States shall pay or provide for payment

App. 145

of OM&R costs associated with delivery of water to enti-
ties other than the Contractor and the subcontractors.
Such costs shall be computed in accordance with Subarti-
cle 9.6(a) of this contract. If the Contractor does not
receive payment in advance for such costs, the Contractor
shall have no obligation to deliver such water.

(e) During the Hoover Dam cost-repayment
period, the Contractor shall pay to the United States the
sum of $0.25 for each acre-foot of water pumped from Lake
Havasu for miscellaneous and M&I water purposes as
determined by the Contracting Officer. The quantity of
water pumped for such purposes will be determined by the
Contracting Officer at the end of each calendar year and
the Contractor notified of the amount due by March 1 of
each subsequent year. Payment shall be due on May 1
following notification. Said payment shall be credited to
the Colorado River Dam Fund established by Section 2 of
the Boulder Canyon Project Act.

9.7 Repayment of Costs of Excess Capacity in
Granite Reef Aqueduct. The costs of providing any capac-
ity in the Granite Reef Aqueduct and pumping plants in
excess of 2,500 cubic feet per second shall be repaid by
Contractor from funds available to Arizona pursuant to
the provisions of Section 403(f) of the Basin Project Act, or
by funds from sources other than the Development Fund.

9.8 Ad Valorem Taxes, Assessments, Tolls, and
Other Charges. Within the legal limits available to it, the
Contractor shall levy ad valorem taxes upon the taxable
property within the service area of the Contractor at rates
determined necessary by the Contractor to raise funds
which, together with the revenues from the sale of water
and such financial assistance from the Development Fund

App. 146

as the Secretary determines is available therefor, are
sufficient to meet the obligations of the Contractor to
make in full all payments to the United States on or before
the date such payments become due and to meet its other
obligations under this contract.

9.9 Continuation of Payments After Project Pay-
out. Following payment to the United States of the Con-

tractor’s final payment for the last construction stage, the
Contractor shall continue to make annual payments to the
United States to be credited to the Development Fund in
amounts equal to the average annual principal payment
for the project during the overall repayment period. In the
event that no augmentation project, as contemplated in
the Basin Project Act, has been authorized or is under
active consideration by the Congress at the time project
construction costs have been repaid in full, payments
under this formula will be not required; Provided, however,
That payments will commence after repayment of the
project costs pursuant to the formula, or any adjustment
thereof agreed to by the parties, at such time as an aug-
mentation project is authorized by Congress and the costs
thereof allocated to the Contractor are determined by the
Secretary.

9.10 Defaults.

(a) The Contractor shall pay a penalty on
payments, installments or charges which become delin-
quent, computed at the rate of 1 percent per month on the
amount of such delinquent payments, installments, or
charges from and after the date when the same become
due until paid.

(b) No water shall be furnished to the
Contractor during any period in which the Contractor may

App. 147

be in arrears more than 12 months in the payments to the
United States required by Article 9.4 hereof.

(c) All rights of action for breach of this
contract are reserved to the United States as provided by
Federal law.

10. GENERAL PROVISIONS

10.1 Other Contracts. The Secretary reserves
the right to contract directly with other water using
entities concerning water supply through project facilities.

In the event this occurs, the provisions of Article 8.17
hereof shall be applicable.

10.2 Title to Project Works. Title to all water
supply system works and all project facilities constructed
pursuant to the Basin Project Act and this contract shall
be and remain in the United States until otherwise pro-
vided by Congress.

10.3. Reserve Funds.

(a) (i) Commencing with notice of transfer of
OM&R for the Granite Reef Aqueduct, including the
Havasu Pumping Plant, the Contractor shall accumulate
and maintain an emergency OM&R reserve fund, which
the Contractor shall keep available to meet costs incurred
during periods of interruption of water service.

(ii) The Contractor shall accumulate the
reserve fund with annual deposits, including interest and
dividends accruing to fund balances or holdings, of not less
than $400,000 in any year in which the fund balance is
less than $4,000,000. The fund shall be invested in a
Federally insured interest- or dividend-bearing account, or

App. 148

in securities guaranteed by the Federal Government;
Provided, That money in the reserve fund shall be avail-
able within a reasonable time to meet expenses for such
purposes as those identified in Subarticle 10.3(a)(iv)
hereof. Such annual deposits and the accumulation of
Interest and dividends to the reserve fund shall continue
until $4,000,000 is accumulated. Interest and dividends
accruing to fund balances shall be added to the fund in
any year when the fund balance is greater than
$4,000,000; Provided, That in no event shall the fund be
increased to an amount greater than the actual amount of
fixed OM&R costs for the preceding year as mutually
determined by the Contractor and the Contracting Officer.
Any balance in the fund in excess of the amount of fixed
OM&R costs for the previous year shall be considered to be
the general funds of the Contractor and available for use
as such.

(iii) Upon mutual agreement between
the Contractor and the Contracting Officer, the amount to
be accumulated and maintained in the reserve fund
provided for in this Subarticle may be adjusted in consid-
eration of the risk and uncertainty stemming from the size
and complexity of the project, the size of the annual
OM&R budget, additions to, deletions from, or changes in
project works, or OM&R costs not contemplated when this
contract was executed.

(iv) The Contractor may make expendi-
tures from such reserve fund only for meeting unforeseen
and extraordinary operation and maintenance costs,
unusual or extraordinary repair or replacement costs, and
betterment costs (in situations where recurrence of severe
“operation and maintenance problems can be avoided or
eliminated). Proposed expenditures from the fund shall be

App. 149

submitted to the Contracting Officer in writing for review
and written approval prior to disbursement.

(v) During any period in which any of
the project works are operated and maintained by the
United States, the reserve fund shall be available for like
use by the United States.

(vi) On or before February 1 of each
year, the Contractor shall provide to the Contracting
Officer an annual statement indicating the principal and
accumulated interest in the emergency OM&R reserve
fund as of December 31 of the preceding year.

(b) Gi) No later than 1 year following the
Contractor’s last construction advance under the Plan 6
Funding Agreement, the Contractor shall accumulate and
maintain a repayment reserve fund to help assure pay-
ments to the United States under this contract.

(ii) The Contractor shall accumulate
such reserve fund with annual deposits, including interest
and dividends accruing to fund balances or holdings, of not
less than $4,000,000 in any year in which the fund balance
is less than $40,000,000. The fund shall be invested in a
Federally insured interest- or dividend-bearing account, or
in securities guaranteed by the Federal Government;
Provided, That money in the reserve fund shall be avail-
able within a reasonable time to meet expenses for the
purpose for which it was established. Such annual depos-
its and the accumulation of interest to the reserve fund
shall continue until $40,000,000 is accumulated. Any
balance in the fund in excess of $40,000,000 shall be
considered to be the general funds of the Contractor and
available for use as such.

App. 150

(iii) Upon mutual agreement between
the Contractor and the Contracting Officer, the amount to
be accumulated and maintained in the reserve fund
provided for in this Subarticle may be adjusted.

(iv) Proposed expenditures from the
fund shall be submitted to the Contracting Officer in
writing for review and written approval prior to disburse-
ment.

(v) On or before February 1 of each
year, the Contractor shall provide to the Contracting
Officer an annual statement of the principal and accumu-
lated interest in the repayment reserve fund as of Decem-
ber 31 of the preceding year.

10.4 Recreational Use of Water Facilities.

(a) The enhancement of recreational oppor-
tunities in connection with the project works authorized
pursuant to Title III of the Basin Project Act shall be in
accordance with the provisions of the federal Water Project
Recreation Act, 79 Stat. 213, dated July 9, 1965, except as
provided in Subarticle 10.4(b) hereof.

(b) Recreational development at Orme Dam
and Reservoir shall be governed by the provisions of
Section 302(d) of the Basin Project Act.

10.5 Confirmation of Contract.

(a) The Contractor, after the execution of
this contract, shall promptly seek to secure a decree of a
court of competent jurisdiction of the State of Arizona
confirming the execution of this contract. The Contractor
shall furnish the United States a certified copy of the final
decree, the validation proceedings, and all pertinent

App. 151

supporting records of the court approving and confirming
this contract, and decreeing and adjudging it to be lawful,
valid, and binding on the Contractor. This contract shall
not be binding on the United States or the Contractor
until such final decree has been entered.

(b) This contract shall be indivisible for
purposes of validation and shall not be binding on the
United States or the Contractor unless validated pursuant
to the provisions of Subarticle 10.5(a) hereof in each and
all of its terms and conditions.

10.6 Rules, Regulations, and Determinations.

(a) The parties agree that the delivery of
water or the use of Federal facilities pursuant to this
contract is subject to Reclamation Law, as amended and
supplemented, and the rules and regulations promulgated
by the Secretary of the Interior under Reclamation Law.

(b) The Contracting Officer, after an oppor-
tunity has been offered to the Contractor for consultation,
shall have the right to make rules, regulations, and
determinations consistent with the provisions of this
contract, the laws of the United States and the State of
Arizona, including, without limitation, rules, regulations,
and determinations relative to maximizing project benefits
from pumping from Lake Havasu, the rate and schedule of
pumping therefrom and the rate and schedule of pumping
at the Granite Reef pumping plants, to add to or modify
said rules, regulations, and determinations as may be
deemed proper and necessary to carry out this contract,
and to supply necessary details of its administration which
are not covered by express provisions of this contract. The
Contractor and each subcontractor shall observe such

App. 152

rules, regulations, and determinations and each subcon-
tract shall so provide.

(c) Where the terms of this contract provide
for action to be based upon the opinion or determination of
either party to this contract, whether or not stated to be
conclusive, said terms shall not be construed as permitting
such action to be predicated upon arbitrary, capricious, or
unreasonable opinions or determinations. In the event
that the Contractor questions any factual determination
made by the Contracting Officer, the findings as to the
facts shall be made by the Secretary only after consulta-
tion with the Contractor and shall be conclusive upon the
parties.

10.7 Books, Records, and Reports. The Contrac-
tor shall establish and maintain accounts and other books
and records pertaining to administration of the terms and
conditions of this contract, including: the Contractor’s
financial transactions, water supply data, project opera-
tion, maintenance and replacement logs, project land and
right-of-way use agreements, and other matters specifi-
cally relating to this contract that the Contracting Officer
may require. Reports thereon shall be furnished to the
Contracting Officer in such form and on such date or dates
as the Contracting Officer may require. Subject to applica-
ble Federal laws and regulations, each party to this
contract shall have the right during office hours to exam-
ine and make copies of the other party’s books and records
relating to matters covered by this contract.

10.8 Notices. Any notice, demand, or request
authorized or required by this contract shall be deemed to
have been given, on behalf of the Contractor, when mailed,
postage prepaid, or delivered to the Regional Director,

App. 153

Lower Colorado Region, Bureau of Reclamation, PO. Box
61470, Boulder City, Nevada 89006, and on behalf of the
United States, when mailed, postage prepaid, or delivered
to the General Manager of the Contractor, 23636 North
7th Street, Phoenix, Arizona 85024. The designation of the
addressee or the address may be changed by notice given
in the same manner as provided in this article for other
notices.

10.9 Contingent on Appropriation or Allotment

of Funds. The expenditure or advance of any money or the
performance of any obligation by the United States under
this contract shall be contingent upon appropriation or
allotment of funds. Absence of appropriation or allotment
of funds shall not relieve the Contractor from any obliga-
tions under this contract. No liability shall accrue to the
United States in case funds are not appropriated or
allotted.

10.10 Changes _in Contractor’s Organization.
While this contract is in effect, no change shall be made in
the Contractor’s organization, by exclusion of lands, by
dissolution, consolidation, merger or otherwise, except
upon the Contracting Officer’s written consent; Provided,
however, That approval is hereby given to the inclusion of
other counties as part of Contractor’s service area, except,
however, that the United States shall not be required,
under this contract, to construct project facilities to serve
lands within said additional counties.

10.11 Assignment Limited-Successors and Assigns
Obligated. The provisions of this contract shall apply to

and bind the successors and assigns of the parties hereto,
but no assignment or transfer of this contract or any part

App. 154

or interest therein shall be valid until approved in writing
by the Contracting Officer.

10.12 Judicial Remedies Not Foreclosed. Noth-
ing herein shall be construed (a) as depriving either party
from pursuing and prosecuting any remedy in any appro-
priate court of the United States or the State of Arizona
which would otherwise be available to such parties even
though provisions herein may declare that determinations
or decisions of the Secretary or other persons are conclu-
sive or (b) as depriving either party of any defense thereto
which would otherwise be available.

10.13 Equal Opportunity. During the perform-
ance of this contract, the Contractor agrees as follows:

(a) The Contractor will not discriminate
against any employee or applicant for employment be-
cause of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. The
Contractor will take affirmative action to ensure that
applicants are employed, and that employees are treated
during employment, without regard to their race, color,
religion, sex, or national origin. Such action shall include,
but not be limited to, the following: Empivyment, upgrad-
ing, demotion, or transfer, recruitment or recruitment
advertising; layoff or termination; rates of pay or other
forms of compensation; and selection for training, includ-
ing apprenticeship. The Contractor agrees to post in
conspicuous places, available to employees and applicants
for employment, notices to be provided by the Contracting
Officer setting forth the provisions of this Equal Opportu-
nity clause.

(b) The Contractor will, in all solicitations
or advertisements for employees placed by or on behalf of
the Contractor, state that all qualified applicants will

App. 155

receive consideration for employment without regard to
race, color, religion, sex, or national origin.

(c) The Contractor will send to each labor
union or representative of workers with which it has a
coliective bargaining agreement or other contract or
understanding, a notice, to be provided by the Contracting
Officer, advising the labor union or workers’ representative
of the Contractor’s commitments under this Equal Oppor-
tunity clause, and shall post copies of the notice in con-
spicuous places available to employees and applicants for
employment.

(d) The Contractor will comply with all
provisions of Executive Order No. 11246 of September 24,
1965, as amended, and of the rules, regulations, and
relevant orders of the Secretary of Labor.

(e) The Contractor shall furnish all informa-
tion and reports required by said amended Executive
Order and by the rules, regulations, and orders of the
Secretary of Labor, or pursuant thereto, and will permit
access to its books, records, and accounts by the Contract-
ing Officer and the Secretary of Labor for purposes of
investigation to ascertain compliance with such rules,
regulations, and orders.

(f) In the event of the Contractor’s noncom-
pliance with the Equal Opportunity clause of this contract
or with any of the said rules, regulations, or orders, this
contract may be canceled, terminated, or suspended, in
whole or in part, and the Contractor may be declared
ineligible for further Government contract

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385016_0002%3A13. Public record. Not legal advice.
