# Record and brief — FCC v. Fox Television Stations, Inc.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385015_0044%3A0

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Record and brief
- **Published:** January 1, 2009
- **Citation:** 556 U.S. 502

## Text

No. 07-582

Title: Federal Communications Commission, et al., Petitioners
V.
Fox Television Stations, Inc., et al.

Docketed: November |, 2007

Lower Ct: United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit

Case Nos:.: (06-1760-ag, 06-2750-ag, 06-5358-ag)
Decision Date: June 4, 2007

Questions

Presented

~~

~~~Date~~~ ~~ Proceedings and Orders

Aug 22 2007 Application (07A155) to extend the time to file a petition for a writ of
certiorari from September 2, 2007 to October 4, 2007, submitted to Justice
Ginsburg.

Aug 23 2007 Application (07A155) granted by Justice Ginsburg extending the time to
file until October 4, 2007.

Sep 24 2007 Application (07A155) to extend further the time from October 4, 2007 to
November 1, 2007, submitted to Justice Ginsburg.

Sep 24 2007 Application (07A155) granted by Justice Ginsburg extending the time to
file until November 1, 2007.

Nov | 2007 Petition for a writ of certiorari filed. (Response due December 3, 2007)

Nov 20 2007 Order extending time to file response to petition to and including January 2,
2008, for all respondents.

Dec 17 2007 Order further extending time to file response to petition to and including
February 1, 2008, for all respondents.

Feb 1 2008 Brief of respondents NBC Universal, Inc., and NBC Telemundo License
Company in opposition filed.

Feb 1 2008 Brief of respondents Fox Television Stations, Inc., CBS Broadcasting Inc.,
and ABC, Inc. in opposition filed.

Feb 13 2008 DISTRIBUTED for Conference of February 29, 2008.

Feb 15 2008 Reply of petitioners Federal Communications Commission, et al. filed.
(Distributed)

Mar 10 2008 DISTRIBUTED for Conference of March 14, 2008.

Mar 17 2008 Petition GRANTED.

Apr 10 2008 The time within which to file the joint appendix and petitioners’ brief on
the merits is extended to and including June 2, 2008.

Apr 22 2008 Consent to the filing of amicus briefs in support of either party, or neither
party, received from counsel for respondents, NBC Universal, Inc.,and
NBC Telemundo License Company.

Jun 2 2008 Joint appendix filed.

Jun 2 2008 _ Brief of petitioners Federal Communications Commission, et al. filed.

Jun 3 2008
Jun 6 2008
Jun 6 2008
Jun 9 2008

Jun 9 2008
Jun 9 2008
Jun 9 2008
Jun 9 2008
Jun 9 2008
Jun 20 2008

Jul 31 2008
Aug | 2008

Aug | 2008
Aug | 2008
Aug 6 2008

Aug 8 2008

Aug 8 2008
Aug 8 2008
Aug 8 2008

Aug 8 2008
Aug 8 2008
Aug 8 2008

Aug 8 2008

Brief amicus curiae of Decency Enforcement Center for Telvision filed.
Brief amicus curiae of National Religious Broadcasters filed.
Brief amicus curiae of Morality in Media, Inc. filed.

Brief amici curiae of Alliance Defense Fund and Family Research Council
filed.

Brief amicus curiae of Parents Television Council filed.

Brief amici curiae of American Center for Law & Justice, et al. filed.
Brief amicus curiae of Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence filed.
Brief amici curiae of Free Press, et al.in support of neither party filed.
Brief amici curiae of American Academy of Pediatrics, et al. filed.

The time to file respondents' briefs on the merits is extended to and
including August 1, 2008.

CIRCULATED

Brief of respondents NBC Universal, Inc., and NBC Telemundo License
Company filed. (Distributed)

Brief of respondent Center for Creative Voices in Media filed. (Distributed)
Brief of respondent Fox Television Stations, Inc. filed. (Distributed).

Consent to the filing of amicus curiae briefs in support of either or neither
party received from counsel for respondent ABC, Inc.

Brief amici curiae of National Assocation of Broadcasters and Radio-
Television News Directors filed. (Distributed)

Brief amicus curiae of Time Warner Inc. filed. (Distributed)

Brief amici curiae of Public Broadcasters filed. (Distributed)

Brief amici curiae of Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression
and the Media Institute filed. (Distributed)

Brief amici curiae of California Broadcasters Association, et al. filed.
(Distributed)

Brief amici curiae of American Civil Liberties Union, et al. filed.
(Distributed)

Srief amicus curiae of ABC Television Affiliates Association filed.
(Distributed)

Brief amici curiae of Former FCC Commissioners and Officials filed.
(Distributed)

Aug 18 2008 SET FOR ARGUMENT ON Tuesday, November 4, 2008.
Aug 20 2008 Brief amici curiae of Center for Democracy & Technology, et al. filed.

(Distributed).

Aug 26 2008 Record received from U.S.C.A. for the 2nd Circuit. (1 box)

Sep 2 2008

Nov 4 2008

Reply of petitioners Federal Communications Commission, et al. filed.
(Distributed)
Argued. For petitioners: Gregory G. Garre, Solicitor General, Department

of Justice, Washington, D.C. For respondents: Carter G. Phillips,
Washington, D.C

PETITION

FOR
WRIT OF

CERTIORARI

4!

52356
fo
VA
No.

Su e S.
ee g US

07-582NO0V 1 - 2007
OFFICE OF THE CLERK

Jn the Supreme Court of the Gnited States

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
AND UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PETITIONERS

Vv.

FOX ‘TELEVISION STATIONS, INC., ET AL.

ON PETITION FORA WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STA: ES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

MATTHEW B. BERRY
Acting General Counsel

JOSEPH R. PALMORE
Deputy General Counsel

DANIEL M. ARMSTRONG
JACOB M. LEWIS

Associate General Counsels
NANDAN M. JOSHI

Counsel

Federal Communications

Commission
Washington, D.C. 20554

PAUL D. CLEMENT
Solicitor General
Counsel of Record
JEFFREY S. BUCHOLTZ
Acting Assistant Attorney
General
THOMAS G. HUNGAR
Deyuty Solicitor General
ERIC D. MILLER
Assistant to the Solicitor
General
THOMAS M. BONDY
Attorney
Department of Justice
Washington, D.C. 20530-0001

(202) 514-2217

QUESTION PRESENTED

Whether the court of appeals erred in striking down
the Federal Communications Commission’s determin-
ation that the broadcast of vulgar expletives may violate
federal restrictions on the broadcast of “any obscene,
indecent, or profane language,” 18 U.S.C. 1464; see 47
C.F .R. 73.3999, when the expletives are not repeated.

(1)

PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDING

Petitioners are the Federal Communications Com-
mission and the United States of America.

Respondents who were petitioners in the court of
appeals below are Fox Television Stations, Inc.; CBS
Broadcasting Inc.; WLS Television, Inc.; KTRK Tele-
vision, Inc.; KMBC Hearst-Argyle Television, Inc.; and
ABC Ince.

Respondents who were intervenors in the court of
appeals below are NBC Universal, Inc.; NBC Telemun-
do License Co.; NBC Television Affiliates; FBC Tele-
vision Affiliates Association; CBS Television Network
Affiliates; Center for the Creative Community, Inc., do-
ing business as Center for Creative Voices in Media,
Inc.; and ABC Television Affiliates Association.

(II)

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

ed eis a des a okn hk Ce baw ean we Kees 1
ee Se conde ewalaneesves ep0eeh 1
Statutes and regulations involved ....................---. 2
Cakes ans ae 0-866 06 bbb 0e 004 60 O8 2
Reasons for granting the petition ....................... 13

A. The decision below conflicts with this Court’s

ee head ce he ie we dineeeee see 15

B. The decision below is inconsistent with settled
principles of administrative law and conflicts with a

ree 19
C. The question presented is important and warrants” -
re kes oa Caw eek omen eh easahe 26
i etek a gn gobs ORS SOs AAS ANN OOS OES OS 31
AE Sdaseenedenes (dens anhdvabuteuesene viens la
EE oi rV6dhdusbdGbdb-00 spe Gov nsd.doseuesneusee 6la
CE v6 606.6 see be bi hedheedeeudenés ined weeks 148a
PE re {78}

62a

I. INTRODUCTION

1. In this Order, we address complaints alleging that
four television programs (“The 2002 Billboard Music
Awards,” “The 2003 Billboard Music Awards,” “NYPD
Blue,” and “The Early Show”) contained indecent and/or
profane material.' After considering the comments sub-
mitted by broadcasters as well as other interested par-
ties, we find that comments made by Nicole Richie dur-
ing “The 2003 Billboard Music Awards” and by Cher
during the “The 2002 Billboard Music Awards” are in-
decent and profane as broadcast but that the
complained-of material aired on “The Early Show” is
neither indecent nor profane. In addition, we dismiss on
procedural grounds the complaints involving “NYPD
Blue” as inadequate to trigger enforcement action.

Il. BACKGROUND

2. On March 15, 2006, the Commission released No-
tices of Apparent Liability and a Memorandum Opinion
and Order (“Omnibus Order’) resolving numerous com-
plaints that television broadcasts aired between Febru-
ary 2, 2002, and March 8, 2005, contained indecent, pro-
fane, and/or obscene material.” Section IIT.A of the Om-
nibus Order proposed monetary forfeitures against six

' For purposes of this Order, we refer to all of the complained-about
episodes of “NYPD Blue” as a single “program.”

* Complaints Regarding Various Television Broadcasts Between
February 2, 2002 and March 8, 2005, Notices of Apparent Liability and
Mernorandum Opinion and Order, 21 FCC Red 2664 (2006) (“Omnibus
Order’), pets. for review pending, Fox Television Stations, Inc. v. FCC,
No. 06-1760-AG (2d Cir. filed Apr. 13, 2006), remanded and partially
stayed, Sept. 7, 2006 (“Remand Order’).

63a

different television broadcasts for apparent violations of
our prohibitions against indecency and/or profanity.”
Section III.C addressed twenty-eight broadcasts that
we concluded did not violate indecency, profanity, and/or
obscenity restrictions for various reasons.‘ In the por-
tion of the Omnibus Order at issue here, Section III.B,
the Commission considered complaints filed against four
programs.

3. “The 2002 Billboard Music Awards.” The Com-
mission received a complaint concerning “The 2002 Bill-
board Music Awards” program that aired on Station
WTTG(TV), Washington, DC, beginning at 8:00 p.m.
Eastern Standard Time on December 9, 2002.° The com-
plaint specifically alleged that during the broadcast
Cher, an award winner, stated, “‘People have been tell-
ing me I’m on the way out every year, right? So fuck
‘em.””®

4. “The 2003 Billboard Music Awards.” The Com-
mission received a number of complaints about the “The
2003 Billboard Music Awards” program that aired on
Fox Television Network stations beginning at 8:00 p.m.
Eastern Standard Time on December 10, 2003.‘ The
complaints concerned a segment in which Nicole Richie,

* Id. at 2670-90 99% 22-99.

* Jd. at 2700-20 99 146-232.

* Jd. at 2690 1101. See Letter from Lara Mahaney, Director of
Corporate and Entertainment Affairs, PTC to David Solomon, Chief,
Enforcement Bureau, Federal Communications Commission (August
22, 2003).

* Id. The Enforcement Bureau obtained a videotape of the broadcast

that confirmed the allegation in the complaint. Omnibus Order, 21
FCC Red at 2690 1 101.

* Id. at 2692 ¢ 112.

64a

an award presenter, stated, “Have you ever tried to get
cow shit out of a Prada purse? It’s not so fucking sim-
ple.”

5. “NYPD Blue.” The Commission received com-
plaints concerning the use of the term “bullshit” in sev-
eral “NYPD Blue” episodes that aired on KMBC-TYV,
Kansas City, Missouri, beginning at 9:00 p.m. Central
Standard Time on various dates between January 14 and
May 6, 2003.°

6. “The Early Show.” The Commission received a
viewer complaint that Station KDKA-TV, Pittsburgh,
Pennsylvania, licensed to CBS Broadcasting, Inc.

* Jd. at 9112 and n. 164.

* Jd. at 2696 1125. The Commission provided the following descrip-
tions of the complained-of portions of the broadcasts:

1/14/03 episode (Det. Sipowitz in response to his partner’s arrest by
Internal Affairs): “Alright, this is Bullshit!”

2/4/03 episode (Det. Sipowitz to street officer regarding that
officer’s partner framing Sipowitz’s partner): “Over time—over
what—bullshit, a beef?”

2/18/03 episode (stated by a suspect who bragged about, but now
denies, killing his daughter): “I told people I killed Samia to try
and get respect back. She had ashamed me and my community
look at me as a fool.” Det. 1: “You took credit for killing your
daughter?! Bullshit!”

4/15/03 episode (Det. harassing suspect who had harassed prosecu-
tor): “I'm hoping this bullshit about you trying to get under ADA
Haywood’s skin is a misunderstanding.”

5/6/03 episode (Captain to Det. who harassed suspect in 4/15
episode): “He said you nearly assaulted his client last night.’ Det.:
‘Well, that’s a bunec’ ¢ bullshit.”

Id. at n. 187.

65a

(“CBS”), aired the word “bullshit” during “The Early
Show” at approximately 8:10 a.m. Eastern Standard
Time on December 13, 2004." A videotape obtained
from CBS showed that during a live interview with
Twila Tanner, a contestant on the CBS program “Survi-
vor: Vanuatu,” Ms. Tanner referred to another contes-
tant as a “bullshitter.”"'

7. In Section III.B of the Omnibus Order, the Com-
mission found that the broadcasts at issue apparently
violated the statutory and regulatory prohibitions
against airing indecent and profane material.” In light
of the circumstances, however, the Commission did not
initiate forfeiture proceedings against the relevant li-
censees.”’ All of the broadcasts discussed in Section
III.B, except for the “The Early Show,” preceded the
Golden Globe Awards Order," in which the Commission

0 Id. at 2698-99 1 137.

" Id. See id. at 2699 n.199 (“In commenting on the strategy
employed by the fellow contestant, Ms. Tanner stated: ‘I knew he was
a bullshitter from Day One.’ The interviewer, Julie Chen, recognized
the inappropriateness of the language, stating: ‘Il hope we had the cue
ready on that one . . . Wecan’t say that word ... Thereisa
delay.””).

Id. at 2690-2700 11 100-45. See 18 U.S.C. § 1464; 47 C.F.R.
§ 73.3999. However, with respect to complaints regarding the use of the
words “dick” and “dickhead” in episodes of “NY PD Blue,” the Commis-
sion found that in context the broadcasts of these terms were not
patently offensive under its contextual analysis and based on FCC
precedent. Omnibus Order, 21 FCC Red at 2696-97 4 127. .

8 Omnibus Order, 21 FCC Red at 2690 1 100.

'* Complaints Against Various Broadcast Licensees Regarding
Their Airing of the “Golden Globe Awards” Program, Memorandum
Opinion and Order, 18 FCC Red 19859 (Enf. Bur. 2003), review granted,
19 FCC Red 4975, 4981 919 13-14 (2004) (“Golden Globe Awards Order’),
petitions for stay and recon. pending.

66a

made clear that the isolated use of an offensive expletive
could be actionably indecent.” The FCC also stated
that its precedent at the time of “The Early Show”
broadcast “did not clearly indicate that the Commission
would take enforcement action against an isolated use”
of “shit” (the “S-Word”) or its variants." Accordingly,
consistent with its commitment to proceed with caution
and restraint in this area, the Commission decided that
it would not take any adverse action against any licensee
as a result of these apparent violations."’

8. Following release of the Omnibus Order, several
parties petitioned for judicial review of Section I11.B,
asserting a variety of constitutional and statutory chal-
lenges. Fox Television Stations, Inc. (“Fox”) and CBS
filed a joint petition for review in the United States
Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.'* ABC Televi-
sion Network (“ABC”) and Hearst-Argyle Television,
Inc. (“Hearst”) filed a joint petition for review in the
United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit,
which later transferred the petition to the Second Cir-
cuit. The Second Circuit consolidated the petitions on
June 14, 2006."”

' See Omnibus Order, 21 FCC Red at 2692 4 111, 2695 4 124, 2698
136.

"Id. at 2700 9 145.

"Jd. at 2690 1 100.

'" See supra n. 2 (noting pending petitions for review).

The Second Circuit also granted motions to intervene in the Fox-
CBS case by NBC Universal, Inc., NBC Telemundo License Co., NBC
Television Affiliates, FBC Television Affiliates Association, CBS
Television Network Affiliates Association, and the Center for Creative
Community, Inc. Before transferring the ABC-Hearst case, the D.C.
Circuit granted AKC Television Affiliates Association's motion to inter-
vene.

67a

9. At the same time, several parties complained to
the Commission about the process the Commission fol-
lowed in formulating Section III.B of the Omnibus Or-
der. The Commission ordinarily provides broadcasters
with an opportunity to file responses and raise argu-
ments before imposing forfeiture liability.” With one
exception, however, the FCC did not seek the views of
the licensees affected by Section III.B of the Omnibus
Order because the Commission did not impose any sanc-
tions on them.” Following the release of the Omnibus
Order, broadcasters complained that they should have
had an opportunity to present their views before the
Commission reached its decisions in Section III.B.
Upon reflection, the Commission agreed and stated that
it wanted to ensure that all of the affected licensees
were afforded a full opportunity to be heard before the
Commission issued a final decision with respect to the
broadcasts at issue. Accordingly, on July 5, 2006, the
Commission asked the Second Circuit for a voluntary
remand of the case and stay of the briefing schedule.
The Commission asked the court to remand the case for
60 days in order to afford interested parties an opportu-

” See 47 U.S.C. § 503(b)(4)(A); Industry Guidance on the Commis-
sion's Case Law Interpreting 18 U.S.C. § 1464 and Enforcement
Policies Regarding Broadcast Indecency, Policy Statement, 16 FCC
Red 7999, 8015-16 91 26-27 (2001) (“/ndecency Policy Statement”).

** The Commission did send a narrow Letter of Inquiry (“LOI”)
regarding “The 2003 Billboard Music Awards” broadcast, receiving a
limited response from Fox on January 30, 2004. Fox also responded to
a supplemental LOI without presenting new legal arguments. The
Commission did not send LOIs regarding the complained-of broadcasts
of “The 2002 Billboard Music Awards,” “NYPD Blue,” and “The Early
Show” prior to the court’s remand.

68a

nity to file responses and the Commission an opportu-
nity to give the issues further consideration.

10. The Second Circuit granted the Commission’s
motion on September 7, 2006, remanding for a period of
60 days “for the entry of a further final or appealable
order of the FCC following such further consideration as
the FCC may deem appropriate in the circumstances.”
On the same day, the Commission announced a two-
week filing period for interested parties wishing to sub-
mit comments concerning the four cases.” The Enforce-
ment Bureau separately issued Letters of Inquiry
(“LOIs”) to Fox, CBS, and KMBC Hearst-Argyle Tele-
vision, Inc. on September 7, 2006, and to those broad-
casters as well as other parties to the Second Circuit
proceeding on September 18, 2006.

III. DISCUSSION

11. Consistent with our commitment to consider the
comments and LOI responses filed following the Second
Circuit’s Remand Order and to take a fresh look at the
issues raised by the four programs at issue on remand,
we vacate Section III.B of the Omnibus Order in its en-
tirety and replace it with the decisions below.

= Remand Order at 2.

3 See Public Notice, FCC Announces Filing Procedures In Connec-
tion With Court Remand of Section 111.B of the Commission's March
15, 2006 Omnibus Order Resolving Numerous Broadcast Television
Indecency Complaints, DA 06-1739 (rel. Sept. 7, 2006).

69a

A. “The 2003 Billboard Music Awards”

12. The Programming. The Commission, Fox, sta-
tions licensed to Fox or its affiliated companies, and af-
filiates of the Fox Television Network all received a
number of complaints from individual viewers and orga-
nizations alleging that Fox stations aired indecent mate-
rial during “The 2003 Billboard Music Awards” program
on December 10, 2003 between 8 p.m. and 10 p.m. East-
ern Standard Time.” The complainants alleged that
Nicole Richie, who with Paris Hilton presented an award
on the program, uttered language that was indecent and
profane in violation of 18 U.S.C, § 1464 and the Commis-
sion’s rule restricting the broadcast of indecent mate-
rial. The complainants requested that the Commission
impose sanctions against each station that aired the re-
marks.

13. The Bureau sent Fox a letter of inquiry on Janu-
ary 7, 2004.” Fox responded on January 30, 2004, at-
taching a transcript of the material at issue.” According
to Fox, the program announcer introduced Paris Hilton
and Nicole Richie, stars of the Fox Television Network
show “The Simple Life,”*’ as follows: “To pre-

* FCC File Nos. EB-03-1H-0617, EB-04-1H-0295, EB-04-IH-0091.
” See Letter from William D. Freedman, Deputy Chief, Investiga-

tions and Hearings Division, Enforcement Bureau, to Fox Television
Stations, Inc. (January 7, 2004).

* See Letter from John C. Quale, Counsel, Fox Television Stations,
Inc., to Investigations and Hearings Division, Enforcement Bureau,
FCC, File No. FB-03-1H-0617 ( January 30, 2004) (“Response”).

“ “The Simple Life,” which debuted on December 2, 2003, followed
Ms. Hilton's and Ms. Richie’s fish-out-of-water adventures upon being
transplanted from Beverly Hills, California to an Arkansas farm for 30
days. A New York Times review described the show as “[a}n updated

70a

sent the award for Top 40 Mainstream Track, here are
two babes whose lives are anything but mainstream.
From their hit TV series, ‘The Simple Life,’ please wel-
come Nicole Richie and Paris Hilton.” Following that
introduction, Paris Hilton and Nicole Richie walked on-
stage to present the award. Fox-owned stations and Fox
affiliates in the Eastern and Central Time Zones then
broadcast the following exchange between them:

Paris Hilton: Now Nicole, remember, this is a live
show, watch the bad language.

Nicole Richie: Okay, God.

Paris Hilton: It feels so good to be standing here
tonight.

Nicole Richie: Yeah, instead of standing in mud
and [audio blocked]. Why do they
even call it “The Simple Life?”
Have you ever tried to get cow shit

‘Green Acres” featuring “Ms. Hilton, 22, of the hotel fortune, and Ms.
Richie, also 22, daughter of the pop singer J.ionel Richie.” Alessandra
Stanley, With a Rich Girl Here and a Rich Girl There, N.Y. Times,
Dec. 2, 2003, at E1. The cover of the Simple Life DVD describes Ms.
Hilton and Ms. Richie in the following manner: “They're Rich. They’re
Sexy. They're TOTALLY-OUT-OF-CONTROL!” Discussing Fox exe-
cutives’ original idea for the show in an interview, one executive touched
on the same excretory theme as “The 2003 Billboard Awards” script,
stating that ““[t|hey wanted to see stilettos in cow shit.’” Attp://web.
archive.org/web/200402 150403 16/http://www.tvweek.com/topstorys/1 1
2403simplelife.htmi. Daily Variety’s review of the premiere episode
also described Ms. Richie’s penchant for “bad language,” labeling her
as “potty-mouthed.” Brian Lowry, The Simple Life, Daily Variety,
Nov. 25, 2003 at 4.

Tla

out of a Prada purse? It’s not so
fucking simple.”

14. Fox contends that this broadcast was not action-
ably indecent. Although Fox concedes that it broadcast
the F-Word, it argues that the word, in context, did not
depict or describe sexual activities but rather, “at most,”
was a “vulgar expletive used to express emphasis,” and
thus is outside the scope of the Commission’s indecency
definition.” As for the use of the S-Word, Fox does not
deny that it was used in the excretory sense. [t argues,
however, that the dialogue “contained at most a passing
reference to an excretory by-product (i.e., ‘cow shit’) and
an expletive used for emphasis,” that the dialogue lasted
only 22 seconds, and that it was not pandering, titillating
or shocking.” Therefore, Fox contends that the dia-
logue is not actionably indecent.

15. Inmdecency Analysis. The Commission defines
indecent speech as material that, in context, depicts or
describes sexual or excretory activities or organs in
terms patently offensive as measured by contemporary
community standards for the broadcast medium.” Thus,
indecency findings require two primary determinations.
First, the material alleged to be indecent must fall
within the subject matter scope of our indecency defi-

* See Response at 3-4.
* Id. at 12-13.
-

* Infinity Broadcasting Corporation of Pennsylvania, Memoran-

dum Opinion and Order, 2 FCC Red 2705 (1987) (subsequent history
omitted) (citing Pacifica Foundation, Memorandum Opinion and
Order, 56 FCC 2d 94, 98 (1975), affd sub nom. FCC v. Pacifica Foun-
dation, 438 U.S. 726 (1978)).

72a

nition—that is, the material must describe or depict sex-
ual or excretory organs or activities. Second, the mate-
rial must be patently offensive as measured by contem-
porary community standards for the broadcast me-
dium.” In our assessment of whether broadcast mate-
rial is patently offensive, “the full context in which the
material appeared is critically important.”* Three prin-
cipal factors are significant to this contextual analysis:
(1) the explicitness or graphic nature of the description;
(2) whether the material dwells on or repeats at length
the descriptions; and (3) whether the material panders
to, titillates or shocks the audience.“ In examining
these three factors, we must weigh and balance them to
determine whether the broadcast material is patently
offensive because “[eJach indecency case presents its
own particular mix of these, and possibly other, fac-
tors.”” In particular cases, one or two of the factors
may outweigh the others, either rendering the broadcast
material patently offensive and consequently indecent,”

© Indecency Policy Statement, 16 FCC Red at 8002 1 8 (emphasis
in original); see Omnibus Order, 21 FCC Red at 2667 9 12.

* Indecency Policy Statement, 16 FCC Red at 8002 § 9 (emphasis
in original).

* Id. at 8002-15 1% 8-23.

® Id. at 8003 9 10.

* Id. at 8009 9 19 (citing Tempe Radio, Inc. (KUPD-FM), Notice of
Apparent Liability for Forfeiture, 12 FCC Red 21828 (Mass Media Bur.
1997) (forfeiture paid) (extremely graphic or explicit nature of refer-
ences to sex with children outweighed the fleeting nature of the
references); EZ New Orleans, Inc. (WEZB(FM)), Notice of Apparent
Liability for Forfeiture, 12 FCC Red 4147 (Mass Media Bur. 1997)
(forfeiture paid) (same)).

73a

or, alternatively, removing the broadcast material from
the realm of indecency.”

i6. With respect to the first determination, Fox does
not dispute that Ms. Richie’s comment-——“Have you ever
tricd to get cow shit out of a Prada purse?”—yefers to
excrement, and we conclude that it is clearly within the
scope of our indecency definition. Fox does contend that
Ms. Richie’s use of the “F-Word”—in the statement
“{i]t’s not so fucking simple”—does not describe sexual
activities and thus falls outside the scope of our inde-
cency definition, but we disagree. A long line of prece-
dent indicates that the use of the “F-Word” for emphasis
or as an intensifier comes within the subject matter
scope of our indecency definition.” Given the core

* Indecency Policy Statement, 16 FCC Red at 8010 4 20 (“the man-
ner and purpose of a presentation may well preclude an indecency
determination even though other factors, such as explicitness, might
weigh in favor of an indecency finding”).

* See, e.g., Grant Broadcasting System II, Inc. Licensee WJPR_-TV,
12 FCC Red 8277, 8279 (Mass Media Bur. 1997) (NAL issued for non-
literal uses of the “F-Word” and the “S-Word,” such as “this fucking
place is going to blow up”); Pacifica Foundation, Inc., Memorandum
Opinier ar. Order, 2 FCC Red 2698, 2699 79 12-13 (1987) (subsequent
history ovnitted) (distinguishing between the use of “expletives” and
“speech involving the description or depiction of sexual . . . functions”
but indicating that both fall within the subject matter scope of our
indecency definition). The Enforcement Bureau’s departure from this
precedent in its Golden Globe Awards decision, Complaints Against
Various Broadcast Licensees Regarding Their Airing of the “Golden
Globe Awards,” Memorandum Opinion and Order, 18 FCC Red 19859
(Enf. Bur. 2003), was contrary to this precedent and thus appropriately
overturned by the Commission. While the Bureau cited two cases for
the proposition that the use of the “F-Word” did not necessarily fall
within the subject matter scope of our indecency definition, both cases
were inapposite. First, the “F-Word” was not even an issue in Enter-
com, which addressed the words “prick” and “piss,” and, in any event,

74a

meaning of the “F-Word,” any use of that word has a
sexual connotation even if the word is not used literally.
Indeed, the first dictionary definition of the “F-Word”
is sexual in nature.” Moreover, it hardly seems debat-
able that the word’s power to “intensify” and offend de-
rives from its implicit sexual meaning.” Accordingly, we
conclude that, as we stated in Golden Globe,” its use
inherently has a sexual connotation and thus falls within
the scope of our indecency definition. The material thus
warrants further scrutiny to determine whether it is
patently offensive as measured by contemporary com-
munity standards for the broadcast medium. Looking at
the three principal factors in our contextual analysis, we
conclude that it is.

17. We will first address the first and third principal
factors iii our contextual analysis—the explicitness or
graphic nature of the material and whether the material
panders to, titillates, or shocks the audience. The com-

was a Bureau rather than a Commission decision. See Entercom
Buffalo License, LLC (WGR(AM)), Order, 17 FCC Red 11997 (Enf.
Bur. 2002). Second, in Peter Branton, the Commission did not rule that
the some uses of the “F-Word” fell outside the subject matter scope of
our indecency definition. Rather, we decided that the uses of the “F-
Word” there were not “patently offensive” in the context of the news
programming at issue in that case. See Peler Branton, 6 FCC Red 610
(1991), appeal dismissed, 993 F.2d 906 (D.C. Cir. 1993), cert. den. 511
U.S. 1052 (1994).

* See, e.g., American Heritage College Dictionary 559 (4th ed. 2002)
(defining the F-Word as “1: to have sexual intercourse with”).

* See Robert F. Bloomquist, The F-Word: A Jurisprudential
Taxonomy of American Morals (In a Nutshell), 40 Santa Clara L. Rev.
65, 98 (1999) (“all F-word usage has at least an implicit sexual mean-
ing’).

*' See Golden Globe Awards Order, 19 FCC Ked at 4979 4% 8.

Tha

plained-of material is quite graphic and explicit. Ms.
Richie’s comment referring to excrement conveys a
graphic image of Ms. Richie trying to scrape cow excre-
ment out of her designer hand bag. Because of her use
of the “S-Word.” Ms. Richie’s description also contained
quite vulgar language. Furthermore, the vulgar de-
scription of excrement was coupled with the use of the
“F-Word.” As we have previously concluded, the “F-
Word” is one of the most vulgar, graphic, and explicit
words for sexual activity in the English language.”
Here, Ms. Richie’s use of the “F-Word” coupled with her
graphic and explicit description of the handling of excre-
ment during a live broadcast of a popular music awards
ceremony when children were expected to be in the au-
dience was vulgar and shocking.* Her comments were
also presented in a pandering manner. As part of their
dialogue, Ms. Hilton reminded Ms. Richie to “watch the
bad language,” a comment that served to preview and
highlight for the viewing audience Ms. Richie’s remarks.

© See id.

*' To the extent that Fox argues that it did not present Ms. Richie’s
comment for “shock value,” see, e.g., Response at 13, it fundamentally
misunderstands the contextual analysis employed by the Commission.
“In evaluating whether material is indecent, we examine the materia!
itself and the manner in which it is presented, not the subjective state
ot mind of the broadcaster.” Complaints Against Various Television
Licensees Concerning Their February 1, 2004 Broadcast of the Super
Bowl XXXVIII Halftime Show, Order on Reconsideration, 21 FCC Red
6653, 6657-58 9% 12 (2006) (“Super Bowl Order on Reconsideration”),
pet. for review pending, CBS Corp. v. FCC, No. 06-3575 (3d Cir. filed
July 28, 2006).

76a

Moreover, Fox does not argue that there was any justifi-
cation for Ms. Richie’s comments.“

18. We note that when the Supreme Court stressed
the importance of context in Pacifica, it mentioned as
relevant contextual factors the time of day of the broad-
cast, program content as it affects “the composition of
the audience,” and the nature of the medium.” All of
these factors support the conclusion that the dialogue
here was patently offensive in context. The complained-
of materia] was broadcast early in prime time. The pro-
gram’s content was, as discussed above, graphic, explicit
and vulgar, both in its excretory description and its use
of the “F-Word.” The program was designed to draw a
large nationwide audience that could be expected to in-
clude many children interested in seeing their favorite
music stars. Although there is no requirement that we
document the presence of children in the audience for a
program that is subject to an indecency complaint and
is aired between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m.,” we note that in this
case a significant portion of the viewing audience for this
program was under 18. According to Nielsen ratings
data, during an average minute of “The 2003 Billboard
Music Awards” broadcast, 2,312,000 (23.4%) of the
9,871,000 people watching the program were under 18,

* For example, Fox does not argue that Ms. Richie’s remarks had
any artistic merit or were necessary lo convey any message.

” See Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 749-51.

* See Action for Children's Television v. FCC, 58 F.3d 654, 665
(D.C. Cir. 1995) (en bane) (“ACT 7/77") (holding that the Cummission
could rely on bright-line time channeling rule and rejecting contention
that it was required to use “station-specific and program-specific data
in assessing whether children are at risk of being exposed to broadcast
indecency”), cert. denied, 516 U.S. 1072 (1996).

77a

and 1,089,000 (11%) were between the ages of 2 and 11.
In addition, we note that this program was rated TV-
PG(DL). Such a rating would not have put parents or
others on notice of such vulgar language, and the broad-
cast contained no other warnings to viewers that it
might contain material highly unsuitable for children.”
This no doubt helps explain the strong feelings that
many of the complainants, particularly those who were
watching the program with their children, expressed

*’ Fox notes that its policy is to rate any programming containing the
“F-Word” TV-MA. See Letter from John C. Quale to Marlene H.
Dortceh, Seeretary, FCC, in FCC File Nos. EB-03-[H-0460, EB-03-IH-
0617, EB-04-IH-0295, EB-04-IH-0091 at 4 (filed Sept. 29, 2006) (“Fox
Response to 9/18/2006 LOI”). The TV-MA rating (mature audience
only) signifies that the program is specifically designed to be viewed by
adults and therefore may be unsuitable for children under 17. In the
context of a TV-MA rated program, an “L” would signify “crude inde-
cent language.” The TV-PG rating (parental guidance suggested), by
contrast, merely signifies that the program contains material that
parents may iind unsuitable for younger children, and that parents may
want to watch the program with their younger children. TV-PG is the
most common rating, covering a majority of the programs that are
rated. See Nancy Signorielli, Age-Based Ratings, Content Designa-
tions, and Television Content: Is There a Problem?, 8 Mass Comm. &
Soc’y 277, 293 (2005) (six in ten rated programs are rated TV-PG). The
“D” signifies that the program may contain some suggestive dialogue,
and the “L” signifies that the program may contain some infrequent
coarse language. Moreover, we note that the TV-PG(DL) rating
appeared only at the beginning and once in the middle of the program;
thus, a viewer tuning into this 2-hour broadcast at another time may not
even have been aware that it was rated TV-PG(DL). See Pacifica, 438
U.S. at 748 (“Because the broadcast audience is constantly tuning in
and out, prior warnings cannot completely protect the listener or viewer
from unexpected program content.”).

78a

regarding the unexpectedly vulgar content.” In light of
all of these factors, we conclude that the first and third
factors in our contextual analysis both weigh heavily in
favor of a finding that the material is patently offensive.

19. With respect to the second factor in our contex-
tual analysis—whether the complained-of material was
sustained or repeated—F ox argues that the dialogue

* See, e.g., e-mail complaint from individual to Fox station
KMSP(TV), Minneapolis, dated December 10, 2003 (“I would appreci-
ate it if you would pass on my intense opinion of the Billboard Awards
and Nicole Ritchie (sic). We teach our kids that people like her have a
potty mouth. My children were watching part of this program and
happened to catch her vulgarity. We will not finish watching the
awards nor will we continue to watch fox network in this household.”);
e-mail complaint from individual to Fox station WTVT(TV), Tampa,
dated January 21, 2004 (“Fox insults my ears and those of my wife and
children with the “f word, etc. and we leave you for good . . .”); e-mail
complaint from individual to Fox station KMSP(TV), Minneapolis,
dated December 10, 2003 (“Why are you allowing that kind of language
at 8:00 p.m. for all ages of people to hear? . . . It was disgusting and
very disturbing . . .”); e-mail complaint from individual to Fox station
KMSP(TV), Minneapolis, dated December 13, 2003 (“I was watching
the event with my 12 and 13 y/o daughters . . . the amount of swear-
ing that was done and the severity of some of the words was horrible

. . Watching TV has become very unpredictable these days .. . I
do not feel it is a safe source of entertainment for our children. . . .”);
complaint from individual to David Solomon, Chief of Enforcement
Bureau, dated December 12, 2003 (“I was horrified to learn that some
of the young children in the school that I teach in viewed the program.
Several of these children are among those children who have social
problems and are often in trouble. Is this what our children have to
look toward for example on how to live? Would you want your children

complaints except for the last one to the FCC's Enforcement Bureau
are attached to Fox’s January 30, 2004 Response.

79a

here was a “fleeting and isolated utterance” and that
such material is not actionably indecent.” We disagree.

20. Fox’s argument that a “fleeting and isolated ut-
terance” is not actionably indecent is based largely on
staff letters and dicta in decisions predating the Commis-
sion’s Golden Globe Awards Order. For example, ina
1987 decision clarifying that our indecency definition
was not restricted only to the seven words contained in
the George Carlin monologue determined to be indecent
in Pacifica, the Commission distinguished in dicta be-
tween “expletives”—words such as the “F-Word” or the
“S-Word” used outside of their core sexual or excretory
meanings—and descriptions of sexual or excretory func-
tions. And, in so doing, the Commission suggested: “If
a complaint focuses solely on the use of expletives, we
believe that . . . deliberate and repetitive use in a pa-
tently offensive manner is a requisite to a finding of in-
decency.””” The Commission made clear, however, that
repetition was not required when speech “involv[es] a
description or depiction of sexual or excretory func-
tions” and that “[t]he mere fact that specific words or
phrases are not repeated does not mandate a finding
that material that is otherwise patently offensive to the
broadcast medium is not indecent.””' In this case, Ms.
Richie’s use of the “S-Word” clearly involved “a descrip-
tion of excretory functions.”™”

* Response at 12, 13.

” Pacifica Foundation, Inc., 2 FCC Red at 2699. See also New
Indecency Enforcement Standards To Be Applied to All Broadcast and
Amateur Radio Licensees, Public Notice, 2 FCC Red 2726 (1987).

" See Pacifica Foundation, Inc., 2 FCC Red at 2699 (emphasis
added).

= i

80a

21. Subsequent to this 1987 guidance, there were
several Bureau-level decisions finding the isolated use
of an expletive not to be actionably indecent.” In no
case, however, did the Commission itself, when evaluat-
ing an actual program, find that the isolated use of an
expletive, such as the “F-Word,” as broadcast was not
indecent or could not be indecent, In our 2001 /nde-
cency Policy Statement,” we explained that “where sex-
ual or excretory references have been made once or
have been passing or fleeting in nature, this characteris-
tic has tended to weigh against a finding of indecency,””
but also noted “even relatively fleeting references may
be found indecent where other factors contribute to a
finding of patent offensiveness.”” Then, in 2004, the
Commission itself considered for the first time in an en-
foreement action whether a single use of an expletive
could be indecent. And in evaluating the broadcast of
the F-Word during “The Golden Globe Awards,” we
overturned tne Bureau-level decisions holding that an
isolated expletive could not be indecent and disavowed
our 1987 dicta on which those decisions were based.

22. While it is important to understand the history
of the Commission’s decisions in this area, we reject
Fox’s siggestion that Nicole Richie’s comments would
not have been actionably indecent prior to our Golden

* See, e.g., Golden Globe Awards Order, 19 FCC Red at 4981 4 12
n. 32 (listing Bureau-level decisions).

* Indecency Policy Statement, 16 FCC Red at 8008-09 1% 17-19.

* Id. at 8008 9 17.

* Id. at 8009 4 19.

Sla

Globe decision.” Rather, Ms. Richie’s remarks would

have been actionably indecent prior to our Golden Globe
decision for three separate reasons. First, even under
our pre-Golden Globe dicta, the offensive material here
does not consist solely of the use of expletives; as dis-
cussed above, the “S-Word” was used here in its excre-
tory sense and was integral to a graphic and vulgar de-
scription that clearly falls within the scope of our inde-
cency rule. As we stated in our 1987 guidance, “repeti-
tive use” was not required under such circumstances.”
Second, the offensive language was “repeated” in that it
included not one but two extremely graphic and offen-
sive words. Third, there seems to be little doubt that
Ms. Richie’s comments were deliberately uttered and
that she planned her comments in advance.” Ms.
Hilton’s opening remark to Ms. Richie that this was a
live show and she should “watch the bad language”
strongly suggests that the offensive language that fol-
lowed was not spontaneous. Further, there is nothing in
Ms. Richie’s confident and fluid delivery of the lines, and
her use of multiple offensive words, that suggests that
any of the language was a spontaneous slip of the
tongue. Thus, given the presence of a graphic descrip-
tion of excretory functions, the presence of multiple of-

* In this respect, our decision differs from our suggestion in Section
III.B of the Omnibus Order, now vacated, that prior to the Commis-
sion’s decision in Golden Globe this broadcast would not have warranted
enforcement action because it involved an “isoiated use of expletives.”
See Omnibus Order, 21 FCC Red at 2695 7 124. For the reasons dis-
cussed above, we du not believe that our prior suggestion accurately
reflected the context of this broadcast or Commission precedent.

* Pacifica Foundation, Inc.,2 FCC Red at 2699.
® See id. (discussing “deliberate” use of expletives).

82a

fensive words, and the deliberate nature of Ms. Richie’s
comments, we conclude that this broadcast would have
been actionably indecent consistent with prior Commis-
sion guidance even in the absence of our Golden Globe
decision.™

23. In addition, this broadcast is actionably indecent
under the Golden Globe Awards Order." In that Order,
we stated that the “mere fact that specific words or
phrases are not sustained or repeated does not mandate
a finding that material that is otherwise patently offen-
sive to the broadcast medium is not indecent.” While,
as explained above, Commission dicta and Bureau-level
decisions issued before Golden Globe had suggested that
expletives had to be repeated to be indecent but “de-
scriptions or depictions of sexual or excretory functions”
did not need to be repeated to be indecent, we believe
that this guidance was seriously flawed. We thus reaf-
firm that it was appropriate to disavow it. To begin
with, any strict dichotomy between “expletives” and
“descriptions or depictions of sexual or excretory func-
tions” is artificial and does not make sense in light of the

® For these reasons, Ms. Richie’s comments differ significantly from
the language involved in the two Bureau-level decisions finding fleeting
expletives not to be indecent that were cited in the Jndecency Policy
Statement. See Indecency Policy Statement, 16 FCC Red at 8008-09
7 18. Rather, they are more similar to the material in the LB/S Broad-
casting Company Notice of Apparent Liability cited in the Jndecency
Policy Statement because they combine a graphic and vulgar descrip-
* tion of sexual or excretory material with an expletive. Jd. at 8009 1 19,
citing LBJS Broadcasting Company, 13 FCC Red 20956 (Mass Media
Bur. 1998) (forfeiture paid) (finding broadcast apparently indecent for
use of phrase “{sJuck my dick you fucking cunt”).

" See Golden Globe Awurds Order, 19 FCC Red at 4980 9 12.
© Id.

83a

fact that an “expletive’s” power to offend derives from
its sexual or excretory meaning.™ Indeed, this is why it
has long been clear that such words fall within the sub-
ject matter scope of our indecency definition, which
since Pacifica has involved the description of sexual or
excretory organs or activities.“ Moreover, in certain
cases, it is difficult (if not impossible) to distinguish
whether a word is being used as an expletive or as a lit-
eral description of sexual or excretory functions. Fi-
nally, and perhaps most importantly, categorically re-
quiring repeated use of expletives in order to find mate-.,
rial indecent is inconsistent with our general approach
to indecency enforcement, which stresses the critical
nature of context.” In evaluating whether material is
patently offensive, the Commission’s approach has gen-
erally been to examine all factors relevant to that deter-
mination.” To the extent that Commission dicta had
previously suggested that one of these factors—whether
material had been repeated— would always be decisive
in a certain category of cases, we believe that such dicta
was at odds with the Commission’s overall enforcement
policy and was appropriately disavowed.

24. Turning back to “The 2003 Billboard Music Aw-
ards” broadcast, we believe that we need not ignore “the
first blow” to the television audience in the circumstan-
ces presented here.*’ Nor do we think that Pacifica re-
quires that approach. The major broadcast networks

63

See supra para. 16.

“ Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 742.

® Indecency Policy Statement, 16 FCC Red at 8002-03 9.
® Id. at 19 9-10.

* Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 748-49.

84a

(“Networks”) argue that the Pacifica Court “would have
never approved” an indecency enforcement regime that
applied to isolated and fleeting expletives.” But this
claim finds no support in Pacifica, in which the Court
specifically reserved the question of “an occasional ex-
pletive” and noted that it addressed only the “particular
broadcast” at issue in that ease. Indeed, we think it
significant that the “occasional expletive” contemplated
by the Court was one that occurred in “a two-way radio
conversation between a cab driver and a dispatcher,”—a
conversation not broadcast to a wide audience—“or a
telecast of an Elizabethan comedy,” settings far re-
moved from the broadcast at issue here.”

25. In explaining the special nature of the broadcast
medium, the Supreme Court emphasized the “pervasive
presence [of the broadcast medium] in the lives of all
Americans” and that indecent broadcasts invade the
privacy of the home. It rejected the argument that one
could protect oneself by turning off the broadcast upon
hearing indecent language: “To say that one may avoid
further offense by turning off the radio when he hears
indecent language is like saying that the remedy for an
assault is to run away after the first blow.” We believe
that granting an automatic exemption for “isolated or
fleeting” expletives unfairly forces viewers (including
children) to take “the first blow.” Indeed, it would as a

* Joint Comments of Fox, CBS. NBC Universal, Inc. and NBC
Telemundo License Co. in DA 06-1739 at 3 (filed Sept. 21, 2006) (“Joint
Comments’’).

® Pacifica, 438 US. at 742, 750.
Id. at 750.
"Id. at 748-49.

Sha

matter of logic permit broadcasters to air expletives at
al) hours of a day so long as they did so one at a time.
For example, broadcasters would be able to air any one
of a number of offensive sexual or excretory words, re-
gardless of context, with impunity during the middle of
the afternoon provided that they did not air more than
one expletive in any program segment.” Such a result
would be inconsistent with our obligation to enforce the
law responsibly. We do not believe that viewers of free
television broadcasts utilizing the public airwaves should
feel, as so many of the complaining viewers of “The 2003
Billboard Music Awards” clearly do, that they cannot
safely allow their families to watch prime-time broad-
casts.”

26. Nor, as discussed above, are the Networks cor-
rect in their suggestion that fleeting utterances have
never before been regulated. On the contrary, our
Golden Globe Awards decision was not the first time
that a fleeting utterance had been found to be indecent.“
We have long recognized that “even relatively fleeting
references may be found indecent” if the context makes
them patently offensive.”

® Such words could include grossly offensive sexual terms such as
“cunt.”

™ See complaints listed in note 48 supra. Like the broadcast in
Pacifica, Ms. Richie’s statements “could have enlarged a child’s
vocabulary in an instant.” Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 749.

* Indecency Policy Statement, 16 FCC Red at 8009 4 19.

® See id. (listing examples of isolated utterances found to be
actionably indecent).

86a

27. We thus conclude that the fact that the offensive
dialogue here was relatively brief is not dispositive un-
der these particular circumstances. This is not a case
involving a single, spontaneously uttered expletive.
Rather, it was two sentences, one of which contained a
graphic excretory description and the other a vulgar
expletive used to heighten the effect of the excretory
description. And, as noted above, these statements were
not spontaneous slips of the tongue, but rather were
planned by the speaker and presaged by the introduc-
tory remark to “watch the bad language.”

28. With respect to our analysis of the complained-
of material, we emphatically reject the argument made
by Fox and other broadcasters that the “contemporary
community standards” employed by the Commission
merely reflect the “subjective opinions” or “the tastes of
the individuals with seats on the Commission.” Rather,
as we have previously stated, in evaluating material, we
rely on the Commission’s “collective experience and
knowledge, developed through constant interaction with
lawmakers, courts, broadcasters, public interest groups,
and ordinary citizens.”

29. In this case, moreover, our assessment of con-
temporary community standards for the broadcast me-
dium is strongly bolstered by broadcasters’ own prac-
tices. As mentioned above, during the 10:00 p.m.-6:00
a.m. “safe harbor,” broadcasters are permitted to air
indecent and profane material. Nevertheless, with rare
exceptions, they do not allow the “F-Word” or the “S-

*® Joint Comments at 10-11.

7 Infinity Radio License, Inc., Memorandum Opinion and Order,
19 FCC Red 5022, 5026 4% 12 (2004).

87a

Word” to be broadcast during that time period. Fox, for
example, “generally prohibit{s] use of any form of the F-
word or S-word during any day part, including late-
night programming.” NBC also “does not broadcast
the ‘F-Word’ and the ‘S-Word’” during the “safe harbor”
“except in unusual circumstances” and generally does
not allow such language to be broadcast on its flagship
late-night program “The Tonight Show with Jay Leno.””
Similarly, ABC, even during safe harbor hours, “gener-
ally has not approved the broadcast of the ‘f-word’ and
the ‘s-wora.’””” For instance, during a recent broadcast
of “Nightline,” ABC deleted uses of the “F-Word” in a
piece on actor Mark Wahlberg.”' CBS, likewise, indi-
cates that “[gjenerally speaking, broadcast[s] of the ‘F-
word’ and ‘S-word’ are not permitted under CBS’s Tele-
vision Network Standards at any time of [the] day.”™
Hearst also reports that its general policy, “which ap-
plies at ali times, is that vulgar language such as the F-
Word and the S-Word [is] not to be knowingly broad-

* Fox Response to 9/18/2006 LOI at 4 (emphasis added).

™ Letter from F. William LeBeau to Marlene H. Dortch, Secretary,
FCC, File Nos. EF B-03-1H-0355, F B-03-1H-0460, F B-03-I1H-0617, EB-
04-I1H-0295, EB-04-1H-0091, EB-05-I1H-0007 at 4-5 (Sept. 29, 2006)
(“NBC Response to 9/18/2006 LOT”).

® Letter from John W. Zucker, Senior Vice President, ABC, Inc. to
Marlene H. Dortch, Secretary, FCC, File No. EB-03-IH-0355 at 2
(Sept. 29, 2006) (“ABC Response to 9/18/2006 LOI”).

*' “Nightline,” Sept. 29, 2006.

© Letter from Anne Lucey, Senior Vice President, CBS Corp. to

Marlene H. Dortch, Seeretary, FCC, File No. EB-05-IH-0007 at 2
(Sept. 29, 2006) (“CBS Response to 9/18/2006 LOI”) (emphasis added).

88a

cast.”™ To be sure, each of the broadcasters avers that
in certain contexts, such as the motion picture Saving
Private Ryan, they do permit the broadcast of the “F-
Word” and the “S-Word.” However, none of these ex-
amples bears even the slightest resemblance to Nicole
Richie’s comments during “The 2003 Billboard Music
Awards.”™ Indeed, in Congressional testimony, Fox’s
President of Entertainment recognized that the very
comments at issue here—Ms. Richie’s remarks—con-
tained “inappropriate language.”” Moreover, Fox ed-
ited out her comments in its broadcasts to the Mountain
and Pacific Time Zones.

30. Taken as a whole, broadcasters’ practices with
respect to programming aired during the safe harbor
reflect their recognition that airing the “F-Word” and
the “S-Word” on broadcast television is generally offen-
sive to the viewing audience and, in the usual case, not
consistent with contemporary community standards for
the broadcast medium. They also reinforce our conclu-
sion that Nicole Richie’s comments during “The 2003
Billboard Music Awards” were patently offensive under
contemporary community standards. For all oi these
reasons, we conclude that, given the explicit, graphic,

“ Response of Hearst-Argyle Television, Inc., File No. EB-03-I1H-
0355 at 3 (Sept. 29, 2006) (“Hearst Response to 9/18/2006 LOI”)
(emphasis added).

“ See ABC Response to 9/18/2006 LOI at 2; CBS Response to
9/18/2006 LOI at 2-3; Hearst Response to 9/18/2006 LOI at 4-5; NBC
Response to 9/18/2006 LOI at 3-4; Fox Response to 9/18/2006 LOI at 4.

“ H.R. 3717, the ‘Broadcast Decency Enforcement Act of 2004’:
Hearing Before the Subcommittee on Telecommunications and the
Internet ofthe House Comm. on Energy & Commerce, 107th Congress,
(Feb. 26, 2004) (statement of Gail Berman).

89a

vulgar, and shocking nature of Ms. Richie’s comments,
they were patently offensive under contemporary com-
munity standards for the broadcast medium and thus
indecent as broadcast.”

31. We also disagree that it would be inequitabie tu
hold Fox responsible for airing offensive language dur-
ing “The 2003 Billboard Music Awards” due to the live,
unscripted nature of the material.*’ In disclaiming re-
sponsibility, Fox states that Nicole Richie’s and Paris
Hilton’s scripted dialogue did not contain the “F-Word”
or “S-Word.” Rather, Ms. Richie’s first scripted line
read: “Yeah—instead of standing in mud and pig crap.”
When she spoke, she substituted “cow shit” (which was
blocked out in the audio feed) for “pig crap” in that line.
In the sentences at issue here, Ms. Richie was scripted
to say “Have you ever tried to get cow manure out of a
Prada purse? It’s not so freaking simple.”™

32. Fox also describes the measures it employed to
delete objectionable material from the broadcast. It says
that as in previous years—including during “The 2002
Billboard Music Awards” broadcast when it aired Cher’s
use of the phrase “fuck ‘em”— it utilized a five-second
delay that it normally used during the production of live
entertainment programming. A Broadcast Standards

“ The Networks also complain about the Commission’s analysis of

contemporary community standards in other pending proceedings, such
as The Blues: Godfathers and Sons. See Joint Comments at 10. In the
case of The Blues, the Commission has issued only a Notice of Apparent
Liability for Forfeiture, see Omnibus Order at 2683-87 19 7285, and we

will address such issues in further proceedings in that case.

* See Response at 13.

* Td. at 6.

90a

employee monitored the broadcast and operated a “de-
lay button” that enables an employee to edit out objec-
tionable content before it airs. Fox also assigned a
Broadcast Standards representative to the event to re-
view the script, attend dress rehearsals and be present
at the event, as it normally did for the production of live
entertainment events. During “The 2003 Billboard Mu-
sic Awards” program, the employee operating the delay
button edited out the vulgar phrase “cow shit” the first
time Ms. Richie said it, but failed to edit out the remain-
ing offensive language discussed above. The program
aired several hours later on stations in the Mountain and
Pacific time zones, and Fox did remove the offensive
language before it aired on those stations.”

33. As Fox points out, the FCC has long recognized
that it may be inequitable to hold a licensee responsible
for airing offensive speech during live coverage of a pub-
lic event under some circumstances.” But the Commis-
sion has not hesitated to enforce its indecency standard
where, @* ‘ere, a licensee fails to exercise “reasonable

* Jd. at 8-9. Following this broadcast, Fox implemented a longer
delay mechanism and a second delay button for all live broadcasts to
serve as a back-up. /d. at 9. Inits recent response to a LOI relating to
the broadcast of “The 2002 Billboard Music Awards,” Fox states that
it now uses a total of four delay buttons for all live broadcasts of
entertainment programming. In addition, it “recognizes that certain
performers may present more risk of spontaneous objectionable con-
tent during live performances than others” and thus “has begun to tape
in advance certain performances to air during otherwise ‘live’ broad-
casts.” See Letter from John C. Quale to Marlene H. Dortch, Secre-
tary, FCC, File No. EB-03-IH-0460 at 6 (Sept. 21, 2006) (“Fox
Response to 9/7/06 LOI”).

* Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 733 n.7, quoting Pacifica Foundation, 59
FCC 2d at 893 n.1. See Response at 12.

9la

judgment, responsibility and sensitivity to the public’s
needs and tastes to avoid patently offensive broad-
easts.”"' Here, the original script for “The 2003 Bill-
board Music Awards” increased the likelihood that Ms.
Richie would ad-lib offensive remarks; as noted above,
it called for her to make excretory references to “pig
crap” and “cow manure,” and to substitute the euphe-
mism “freaking” for the “F-Word.”” Such a script

" Pacifica Foundation, Inc.,2 FCC Red at 2700 4 18. See Liability
of San Francisco Century Broadcasting, 1..P., Memorandum Opinion
and Order, 8 FCC Red 498, 499 § 7 (1993) (“the mere fact that a show
is live does not excuse astation from exercising its editorial responsibil-
ities, especially where commonly available screening techniques can
eliminate the element of surprise.”’), citing Sound Broadcasting Corp.,
Notice of Apparent Liability, 6 FCC Red 2174 (Mass Media Bur. 1991);
Radio Station KFMH-FM, Muscatine, lowa, Notice of Apparent
Liability, 9 FCC Red 1681, 1681-82 (Mass Media Bur. 1994) (rejecting
contention that licensee should not be held responsible for broadcasting
live and unscripted offensive material from an outside source where the
broadcaster suspected “that the caller involved was the same person
who had told the objectionable joke only eight minutes earlier” but
“chose to place the call on the air rather than to discontinue the broad-
cast or to use precautions such as a delay device.”); L.M. Communica-
tions, Notice of Apparent Liability, 7 FCC Red 1595 (Mass Media Bur.
1992) (rejecting argument that broadcaster should not be sanctioned for
airing indecent material within live and unscripted programming where
“the scatological material as broadcast involved a deliberate and
repetitive use of the word ‘crap’ to heighten the audience’s awareness
of and attention to the subsequent use of the term ‘shit’ by the an-

nouncer.”).

* See Response at 6; see also Complaints Against Various Televi-

sion Licensees Concerning Their February 1, 2004 Broadcast of the
Super Bowl XXXVIII Halftime Show, Forfeiture Order, 21 FCC Red
2760, 2769 1 19 (2006) (citing evidence that “there is always a risk that
performers will ad-lib remarks or take unscripted actions, and that the
risk level varies according to the nature of the performance.”) (subse-
quent history omitted).

92a

might have posed minimal risk in the hands of some per-
formers. Relying on Ms. Hilton and Ms. Richie to avoid
vulgar language, however, involved a substantially
greater risk.” As Fox well knew, Ms. Richie frequently
used indecent language in inappropriate contexts. For
example, during the three episodes of “The Simple Life”
that it broadcast in the days leading up to the “The 2003
Billboard Music Awards,” Fox felt it necessary to bleep
expletives (the “F-Word” or “S-Word”) uttered by Ms.
Richie no fewer than nine times.” Yet Ms. Richie was
still selected as a presenter for the live, prime-time
awards show, and Fox has not claimed it made any effort
to caution Ms. Richie about its broadcast standards for
the program or that it took any special precautions (be-
yond its standard five-second delay) to guard against
her use of expletives on the air. Indeed, Fox does not

“ See supra note 27. As discussed above, Fox advertised Ms. Hilton
and Ms. Richie as being “totally-out-ofcontrol” on the cover of the
Simple Life DVD. Additionally, The Los Angeles Times review of the
first episode of “The Simple Life” describes Ms. Hilton and Ms. Richie
as “out-of-control.” Carina Chocano, Work for a Living? What a Con-
cept, L.A. Times, Dec. 2, 2003, at 1 (Calendar Section).

* “The Simple Life,” Season 1, Episodes 1-3. In addition, Ms.
Richie’s penchant for cursing is highlighted in a scene during the first
episode in which their host, reviewing the house rules with them, states
“no cussing or bad language,” at which point the camera focuses on Ms.
Richie giggling helplessly at Ms. Hilton. Their penchant for vulgarity
is also illustrated during the third episode in two scenes at a local fast
food franchise where Ms. Richie and Ms. Hilton are working for the
day. Directed to change the letters of a sign out front to read “Half
Price Burgers All Day,” they instead arrange the letters to read “1/2
Price Anal Salty Weiner Bugers.” Later, standing on the curb in cos-
tumes of the restaurant's mascot, an animated milkshake, they stick up
their respective middle fingers (which are pixilated) to passersby.

98a

even contend that it took any action against Ms. Richie
after this episode.

34. Even more significant, the particular five-second
delay and editing system that Fox used in this case had
already proved inadequate to deiete Cher’s offensive
language during Fox’s broadcast of “The 2002 Billboard
Music Awards” the previous year. During that broad-
cast, Cher, when accepting an award, had stated, “‘Peo-
ple have been telling me I’m on the way out every year,
right? So fuck ‘em.””” According to Fox, the employee
in charge of deleting objectionable material did not act
quickly enough and ended up editing out dialogue that
aired after Cher’s comment.” Despite this failure, Fox
took no additional precautions to avoid airing such mate-
rial the next year.”’ The record also demonstrates that
steps may be taken, such as adding “delay buttons” or
lengthening the delay, that allow for far more effective
editing of potentially objectionable content.” Here, Fox
itself contends that the time delay and editing system
that it used for “The 2003 Billboard Music Awards” was
inadequate, maintaining that it imposed on the operator
a “Herculean task” because he was “essentially trying to
watch two programs at once—the live version occurring
in real-time and the delayed version that was broadcast
seconds later.”” Then, if he heard or saw objectionable
content, he was required to “press the appropriate audio

® See infra para. 56.

* See Fox Response to 9/7/06 LOI at 5.

” See Response at 5.

* See, e.g., id. at 8-9.

” Fox Response to 9/18/2006 LOI at 10 n. 21.

94a

and/or video delay buttons at the precise instant neces-
sary to eliminate the objectionable content from the de-
layed feed” while at the same time “staying abreast of
the continuing live feed.”*” In short, under these cir-
cumstances, Fox should have recognized the high risk
that “The 2003 Billboard Music Awards” broadcast
raised of airing indecent material. Nevertheless, Fox
chose to rely on the same delay and editing system that
had proved inadequate the previous year to delete an
expletive during the same show. We are not persuaded,
therefore, that Fox’s efforts to edit out the offensive
language were diligent or reasonable.

35. We recognize that no delay and editing system is
foolproof and that there is always a possibility of human
error in using delay equipment to edit live program-
ming. The Commission can and will consider these facts
in deciding what, if any, remedy is appropriate. In this
case, however, as discussed above, we cunclude that
Fox’s efforts to prevent and edit out Ms. Richie’s com-
ments were not diligent or reasonable.

36. Holding Fox reaoonsible for airing indecent ma-
terial in this case does not place live broadcasts at risk
or impose undue burdens on broadcasters.'” This case
does not involve breaking news coverage that Fox and
other broadcasters have traditionally presented in so-

'® Td. By contrast, Fox states that its current time delay and editing
system “relics upon technology to cnsure that once an edit button is
pressed, the potentially objectionable content is edited at the right time
during the delayed feed.” /d. As stated above, Fox’s current system
also utilizes more than one employee “to provide redundancy.” /d. at
10.

See Joint Comments at 12-16.

ha ol

95a

called “real time.”"” Nevertheless, Fox argues that

“(t}he live presentation of awards shows . . . is what
makes this content so compelling.” Fox, however, did
not even decide to air the program live in much of the
country. Rather, viewers in the Mountain Time Zone
saw the program with a one-hour delay, and those in the
Pacific Time Zone experienced a three-hour delay. We
find it difficult to understand why viewers on the East
Coast would no longer find “live programming” to be.
“compelling” with a ten-second delay while it is evi-
dently acceptable to provide this programming to view-
ers in the western half of the country with a one-hour or
three-hour delay. Moreover, with respect to awards
shows as a whole, the record reflects that the vast ma-
jority of awards shows are not aired by major networks
live in the Pacific Time Zone.’ Rather, they are gener-
ally broadcast with a three-hour delay, thus undermin-
ing any assertion that it is important that viewers see
the presentation of the awards without the compara-

Since this case does not involve breaking news or sports program-
ming, we do not address issues involving such programming here. But
as we recognize elsewhere in this Order, “in light of the important First
Amendment interests at stake as well as the crucial role that context
plays in our indecency determinations, it is imperative that we proceed
with the utmost restraint when it comes to news programming.” See

infra, § II1.C.

‘8 See Joint Comments, Appendix X (Declaration of Peter Ligouri)
at 9 2.

'* Of the 32 awards shows that were broadcast by the major

networks and are discussed in the record, only the Academy Awards
aired live in all time zones. See ABC Response to 9/18/2006 LOI at 2;
NBC Response to 9/18/2006 LOI at 4 and Exh. C.; Fox Response to
9/18/2006 LOI at 3-4; CBS Response to 9/18/2006 LOI at 7.

96a

tively minimal delay required to remove indecent lan-
guage.

37. Under the circumstances, we fail to see how a
delay of five, ten, or even fifteen seconds meaningfully
affects the value of this programming or significantly
implicates First Amendment values. In this vein, we
note that so-called “live” programming is not literally
live—viewers at home do not see an event at the very
time that it is actually occurring. Rather, there is a nat-
ural delay caused by the time that it takes a signal to
reach viewers. The record shows that digital signals, for
example, may take up to 1.3 to 3.3 seconds to reach view-
ers over-the-air.'” And, if viewers are receiving such
signals through a cable operator or satellite provider,
there may be an additional delay of up to 3 seconds.'”
Finally, if a viewer has a digital video recorder, there is
another additional delay of approximately another half-
second.'” Thus, using a conservative estimate, a viewer
may be watching an event more than three seconds after
it occurs, even in the absence of any delay technology.
In light of this, we fail to see how there is a meaningful
adverse impact on a viewer’s experience because he or
she learns the winner of the Billboard Award for Top 40
Mainstream Track some eight to eighteen seconds after

'® Fox Response to 9/18/2006 LOI at 11.
-. o

” Id. See ABC Response to 9/18/2006 LOI at 7-8 (reporting that
transmitting signals from ABC’s New York Broadcast Center to
affiliates results in less than a two second delay, that feeding live
material from remote locations to ABC’s New York Broadcast Center
may cause an additional delay of up to a second, and that distribution
of the signals to the consumers through cable and satellite systems may
cause an additional delay).

97a

the winner is announced on stage in Las Vegas (with a
delay) as opposed to after the normal three to six sec-
onds (without one).

38. Finally, we note that our decision here will not
deprive Fox of the ability to present such programming
in substantially the same way that it has in the past.
Fox has utilized a time delay and other procedures to
avoid airing patently offensive material during live en-
tertainment broadcasts such as “The 2003 Billboard Mu-
sic Awards” for years before the Commission’s decision
in the Golden Globe Awards Order.'” We also disagree
that “delaying live broadcasts to edit potentially offen-
sive language inevitably results in overbroad censorship
of appropriate material.”"” As the D.C. Circuit ob-
served, “some degree of self-censorship is inevitable and
not necessarily undesirable so long as proper standards
are available.”'’® The possibility that an over-zealous
broadcast standards employee may “dump” material
that is not actionably indecent during the live presenta-
tion of an awards show does not outweigh the compelling

We See Response at 8; see also Fox Response to 9/7/06 LOI at 5. In
addition, Fox uses delays for live entertainment broadcasts even after
10 p.m. See id. at 5-7. The Commission’s indecency regulation does not
apply at that time, see 47 C.F.R. § 73.3999(b), so Fox obviously has
reasons apart from regulatory compulsion for using a delay.

1 = Joint Comments at 15.

"0 Action for Children’s Television v. F'CC, 59 F 3d 1249, 1261 (D.C.
Cir. 1995), cert. denied, 516 U.S. 1072 (1996) (ACT IV), citing Pacifica,
438 U.S. at 743. See ACT 111,58 F.3d at 666 (“Whatever chilling effects
may be said to inhere in the regulation of indecent specch, these have
existed ever since the Supreme Court first upheld the FCC’s enforce-
ment of section 1464 of the Radio Act.”).

98a

interest in preventing patently offensive broadcasts
such as the one that occurred in this case.

39. For all of these reasons, we conclude that Fox’s
broadcast of “The 2003 Billboard Music Awards” vio-
lated the prohibitions in 18 U.S.C. § 1464 and the Com-
mission’s rules against broadcast indecency and that it
is not inequitable to hold Fox responsible for these viola-
tions.

40. Profanity Analysis. Consistent with our deci-
sions in the Golden Globe Awards Order and the Omni-
bus Order, we also find that the complained-of language
in the program at issue violated Section 1464’s prohibi-
tion on the broadcast of “profane” utterances." In the
Golden Globe Awards Order, the Commission concluded
that the “F-Word” was profane within the meaning of
Section 1464 because, in context, it constituted vulgar
and coarse language “‘so grossly offensive to members
of the public who actually hear it as to amount to a nui-
sance.””''® Similarly, we concluded in the Omnibus Or-
der that the “S-Word” is a vulgar excretory term so
grossly offensive to members of the public that it
amounts to a nuisance and is presumptively profane.'™
In certain cases, language that is presumptively profane
will not be found to be profane where it is demonstrably
essential to the nature of an artistic or educational work

Mt 18 U.S.C. § 1464.

'® Golden Globe Awards Order, 19 FCC Red at 4981 11 13, quoting
Taliman v. United States, 465 F.2d 282, 286 (7th Cir. 1972).

"3 Omnibus Order, 21 FCC Red at 2686 4 81 (“Like tne ‘F-Word,’
[the ‘S-Word’] is one of the most offensive words in the English langu-
age, the broadcast of which is likely to shock the viewer and disturb the
peace and quiet of the home.”).

99a

or essential to informing viewers on a matter of public
importance.'"* However, such circumstances are not
present here: Fox does not contend that Ms. Richie’s
profane language was essential to informing viewers on
a2 matter of public importance or that modifying the lan-
guage would have had a material impact on its function
as a source of news and information. On the contrary,
Fox sought (albeit unsuccessfully) to delete the profane
language, and did remove it before the program aired on
time delay in the Mountain and Pacific Time Zones.’ It
is undisputed that the complained-of material, including
the “F-Word” and the “S-Word,” was broadcast within
the 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. time frame relevant to a profanity
determination.''*® Because there was a reasonable risk
that children may have been in the audience at the time
of the broadcast on December 10, 2003,'"’ the broadcast
is legally actionable.

41. Contrary to the Networks’ Joint Comments, we
believe that our interpretation of “profane” as used in
Section 1464 is appropriate.'"* The word has long car-
ried a variety of meanings, including non-religious

tia

Id. at 2669 1 19, citing Compluints Aguinst Various Television
Licensees Regarding Their Broadcast on November 11, 2004 of the
ABC Television Network’s Presentation of the Film “Saving Private
Ryan,” Memorandum Opinion and Order, 20 FCC Red 4507, 4512-14
9% 13-18 (2005).

115

Response at 8.

"6 See Omnibus Order, 21 FCC Red at 2666 1 8.

"7 See supra para. 18 (noting that, according to Nielsen ratings data,
23.4% of the people watching an average minute of “The 2002 Billboard
Music Awards” broadcast were under 18, and 11% were between the
ages of 2 and 11).

"8 See Joint Comments at 28-32; Thomas Jefferson Center For the
Protection of Free Expression Comments at 11-15 (Sept. 21, 2006).

100a

meanings.''* Several courts have interpreted the word
in a non-religious sense, consistent with the established
rule that a court should construe a statute, if reasonably
possible, to avoid constitutional problems.’ Further,

"The 1891 edition of the Century Dictionary includes this defini-
tion of profane: “2. To put to a wrong use; employ basely or unwor-
thily.” Century Dictionary 4754 (1891 ed.). In an appendix to his con-
curring opinion in Burstyn v. Wilson, 343 U.S. 495, 533-40 (1952),
Justice Frankfurter collected definitions of “sacrilege,” “blasphemy,”
and “profane” dating to 1651. The earliest of these definitions of pro-
fane is “to apply any thing sacred to common use. To be irreverent to
sacred persons or things. To put to a wrong use.” /d. at 536, quoting
Rider, A New Universal] English Dictionary (London, 1759). The next
is “To violate; to pollute.—To put to wrong use.” Jd. at 537, quoting
Kenrick, A New Dictionary of the English Language (London, 1773).
Frankfurter’s concurring opinion also notes that Funk & Wagnalls’
New Standard Dictionary of the English Language, first copyrighted
in 1913, includes a definition of “to profane” as “3. To vulgarize; give
over to the crowd.” /d. at 527 n. 48. Thus, we disagree that Congress
clearly would have understood the term in 1927 to mean only blasphe-
mous or sacrilegious. Joint Comments at 28.

' See Taliman v. United States, 465 F.2d at 286; State v. Richards,
896 P.2d 357, 364 (Id. App. 1995) (in rejecting a vagueness challenge
to state statute proscribing telephone harassment through, inter
alia, “obscene, lewd or profane language,” construing “profane” to
mean “characterized by abusive language . . . cursing or vituperation
. . .’); see also United States v. Hicks, 980 F.2d 963, 970 n.9 (5th Cir.
1992) (angry reference to flight attendant as a “bitch” and angry
admonition that she should get her “ass” to the plane’s kitchen qualified
as “profane”). We disagree with the Networks that Tallman addressed
the word’s meaning in dicta, and that the case actually refutes the Com-
mission’s interpretation because the Court cited with approval Duncan
v. United States, 48 F.2d 128 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 383 U.S. 863
(1931), and Gagliardo v. United States, 366 F.2d 720 (9th Cir. 1966).
See Joint Comments at 31. Tallman held that the word “profane” in
Section 1464 must be interpreted narrowly as, inter alia, “denoting
language which under contemporary community standards is so grossly
offensive to members of the public who actually hear it as to amount to

10la

when viewed in its statutory context with the words “ob-
scene” and “indecent,” both of which have vulgar over-
tones, we believe that the word “profane” is reasonably
interpreted in the related sense of “grossly offensive.”

a nuisance” to preserve its validity in response to a facial constitutional
challenge. Taliman, 465 F.2d at 286. The Court cited Duncan and
Gagliardo solely as examples of prior judicial interpretations available
to the trial judge had jury instructions on the word’s meaning been
necessary, without approving or even identifying such interpretations.
Id. We also reject the Networks’ argument that the rule of lenity
counsels against the Commission’s interpretation of “profane.” See
Joint Comments at 30, n.34. Among other things, the Networks make
no showing that their preferred construction of the term is any -nar-
rower than the Commission’s. Indeed, we think it likely that more
broadcast speech would be considered “profane” under the Networks’
interpretation of the term than under ours. See also infra para. 54
(explaining that the Pacifica Court squarely rejected the argument that
the FCC’s civil authority to enforce Section 1464 must be interpreted
in accordance with rules that apply to criminal statutes, such as the rule
of lenity).

"1 See State v. Richards, 896 P.2d at 364 (“when words appear in a
list or are otherwise associated, they should be given related mean-
ings.”), citing Schreiber v. Burlington Northern, Inc.,472 U.S. 1 (1985),
Jarecki v. G.D. Searle & Co., 367 U.S. 303 (1961), 2A Norman J. Singer,
Southerland’s Statutes and Statutory Construction § 47.16 at 183 (5th
ed. 1992); United States v. Hicks, 980 F.2d at 970 n.9 (“By ‘profanity’ or
‘vulgarity,’ we refer to words that, while not obscene, nevertheless are
considered generally offensive by contemporary community stan-
dards.”). The fact that the words “indecent” and “profane” in Section
1464 have “separate” meanings does not render our interpretation of
profane “implausible.” See Joint Comments at 31, quoting Pacifica, 438
U.S. at 739-40. We recognize that the two words have separate mean-
ings, and the Commission interprets the two words differently. Our
enforcement policy limiting the regulation of profane language to words
that are sexual or excretory in nature or are derived from such terms
stems from First Amendment considerations rather than the meaning
of the word. See Omnibus Order, 21 FCC Red at 2669 9 18.

102a

We do not read the cases cited by the Networks as pre-
cluding a non-religious interpretation. Duncan upheld
a conviction for broadcasting profanity where the defen-
dant “referred to an individual as ‘damned,’”” “used the
expression ‘By God’ irreverently,” and “announced his
intention to call down the curse cf God upon certain indi-
viduals.”’” But the court held only that this language
was “within the meaning of that term” as used in the
Radio Act of 1927, not that the provision only covered
such language.’ Gagliardo addressed the meaning of
“profane” in Section 1464 only in dicta, because the gov-
ernment in that case did not contend that the words at
issue were profane.’ Finally, the fact that the Commis-
sion has a specific rule addressing “obscene” and “inde-
cent” programming’ plainly does not foreclose the
agency from exercising in an adjudication its express

'@ Duncan, 48 F.2d at 133-34 (the phrase “God damn it” uttered in
anger was not profane under Section 1464).

'S Td. at 134. Duncan was decided before constitutional law evolved
to the point that such language could not be proscribed. See Burstyn
v. Wilson, 343 U.S. 495 (1952) (holding unconstitutional a New York
statute authorizing state officials to license films for public exhibition
unless the films are “sacrilegious”).

‘4 Gagliardo, 366 F.2d at 725 (“God damn it” uttered in anger not
legally profane). The FCC did not address whether “profane” could be
interpreted in a non-religious sense in Raycom America, Inc., Memo-
randum Opinion and Order, 18 FCC Red 4186 (2003) (portions of “The
West Wing” in which a character “scream[ed] at God,’ and made ir-
reverent references toward the deity—'[y ]ou’re asonofabitch, you know
that?,’ and ‘have I displeased you, you feckless thug?’” not actionably
profane), and Warren B. Appleton, 28 FCC 2d 36 (Broadcast Bur. 1971)
(“damn” notactionably profane), because those cases involved language
with religious connotations.

"5 47 C.F.R. § 73.3999.

103a

statutory authority to take enforcement action against
broadcasts that are “profane.”'”°

42. Constitutional Issues. The Networks offer a
variety of arguments attacking the constitutionality of
the Commission's indecency framework as it relates to
“The 2003 Billboard Music Awards” broadcast. We do
not find any of these arguments to be persuasive.

43. First, the Networks argue that our definition of
indecency is unconstitutionally vague.'*’ However, that
definition is essentially the same as the one that we ar-
ticulated in the order under review in F'CC v. Pacifica
Foundation.'* The Supreme Court had no difficulty in
applying that definition and using it to conclude that the
broadcast at issue in that case was indecent.’ We
agree with the D.C. Circuit that “implicit in Pacifica” is
an “acceptance of the FCC’s generic definition of ‘inde-
cent’ as capable of surviving a vagueness challenge.”'”

44. The Networks suggest that the Supreme Court’s
more recent decision in Reno v. ACLU™' has “under-
mine[d] any constitutional defense of the Commission’s
current approach” to indecency.'” In Reno, the Court
considered the constitutionality of the Communications
Decency Act of 1996 (CDA), a statute that regulated

1 47 U.S.C. § 1464; 47 U.S.C. § 503(b)(1)(D). See Joint Comments
at 32.

1 See, e.g., Joint Comments at 7-8.

Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 732.

See id. at 739, 741.

'® Action for Children's Television v. FCC, 852 F.2d 1332, 1339
(D.C. Cir. 1988) (“ACT 1”); accord ACT 1/11, 58 F.3d at 659.

8! 521 U.S. 844 (1997).

Joint Comments at 7.

104a

indecency on the Internet and that contained a defini-
tion similar to ours.'** Though the Court did not hold
that the statute was “so vague that it violates the Fifth
Amendment,” it concluded that “the many ambiguities ©
concerning the scope of its coverage render it problem-
atic for purposes of the First Amendment.”'™

45. Reno in no way undermines Pacifica. On the
contrary, the Court in Reno expressly distinguished
Pacifica, and it gave three different reasons for doing
so. First, the Court noted that the Commission is “an
agency that [has] been regulating radio stations for de-
cades,” and that the Commission’s regulations simply
“designate when—rather than whether—it would be
permissible” to air indecent material.'"” The CDA, in
contrast, was not administered by an expert agency, and
it contained “broad categorical prohibitions” that were
“not limited to particular times.”'** Second, the CDA
was a criminal statute, whereas the Commission has no
power to impose criminal sanctions for indecent broad-
casts.’ Third, unlike the Internet, the broadcast me-
dium has traditionally “received the most limited First
Amendment protection.”'* Thus, far from casting doubt
on Pacifica’s vagueness holding, Reno recognizes its
continuing vitality.

'* See 47 U.S.C. § 223(d) (1994 Supp. IT).

'* Reno, 521 U.S. at 870.

'® Td. at 867.

ae

‘See id. at 867, 872; see also Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 750 (declining to

decide whether an indecent broadcast “would justify a criminal prose-
cution”).

'* Reno, 521 U.S. at 867 (quoting Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 748).

105a

46. The Networks also argue that the more relaxed
level of First Amendment scrutiny discussed in Pacifica
should no longer apply to broadcasting in light of
changes in the media marketplace. Specifically, they
contend that because of the prevalence of other media,
such as the Internet and cable and satellite television,
“it is fanciful to believe that aggressive enforcement of
§ 1464 against broadcasters will be effective in prevent-
ing children from being exposed to potentially offensive
words.”'**

47. We disagree that technological changes have un-
dermined the validity of the reasoning in Pacifica.'” In
Pacifica, the Court identified two reasons why broad-
casting has received “the most limited First Amendment
protection.” First, “the broadcast media have estab-
lished a uniquely pervasive presence in the lives of all
Americans. Patently offensive, indecent material pre-
sented over the airwaves confronts the citizen, not only
in public, but also in the privacy of the home.”'” Second,
“broadcasting is uniquely accessible to children, even
those too young to read.”'*”

48. Notwithstanding the growth of other communica-
tions media, courts. have recognized the continuing valid-
ity of these rationales. In 1994, the Supreme Court reaf-
firmed that “our cases have permitted more intrusive

9 Joint Comments at 22.

'%© In any event, the Commission has no authority to overrule
Pacifica. Cf. Rodriguez de Quijas v. Shearson/American Express,
Inc., 490 U.S. 477, 484 (1989).

‘Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 748.
= id
Td. at 749.

106a

regulation of broadcast speakers than of speakers in
other media.”'* And the D.C. Circuit has rejected pre-
cisely the argument advanced by the Networks here:
“Despite the increasing availability of other means of
receiving television, such as cable, ... there can be no
doubt that the traditional broadcast media are properly
subject to more regulation than is generally permissible
under the First Amendment.”'”

49. The broadcast media continue to have “a unique-
ly pervasive presence” in American life. The Supreme
Court has recognized that “[dJespite the growing impor-
tance of cable television and alternative technologies,
‘broadcasting is demonstrably a principal source of in-
formation and entertainment for a great part of the Na-
tion’s population.’””'“ Though broadcast television is
“but one of many means for communication, by tradition
and use for decades now it has been an essential part of
the national discourse on subjects across the whole
broad spectrum of speech, thought, and expression.”'*
In 2003, 98.2% of households had at least one television,
and 99% had at least one radio.’ The Networks cor-
rectly point out that almost 86% of households with tele-

'* Turner Broadcasting Sys., Inc. v. FCC, 512 U.S. 622, 637 (1994);
see also Reno, 521 U.S. at 868 (recognizing “special justifications for
regulation of the broadcast media”).

' ACT 111, 58 F.3d at 660. See also Prometheus Radio Project v.
FCC, 373 F.3d 372, 401-02 (3d Cir. 2004) (rejecting argument that
broadcast ownership regulations should be subjected to higher level of
scrutiny in light of the rise of “non-broadcast media”).

'* Turner Broadcasting Sys., Inc. v. FCC, 520 U.S. 180, 190 (1997)
(quoting U.S. v. Southwestern Cable Co., 392 U.S. 157, 177 (1968)).

7 Id. at 194.
'* U.S. Census Bureau, Statistical Abstract of the United States 737
(2006).

107a

vision subscribe to a cable or satellite service.'*” That
still leaves 15.4 million households that rely exclusively
on broadcast television, hardly an inconsequential num-
ber.” In addition, it has been estimated that almost
half of direct broadcast satellite subscribers receive
their broadcast channels over the air,’”’ and many sub-
scribers to cable and satellite still rely on broadcast for
some of the televisions in their households.'™ All told,
the National Association of Broadcasters (“NAB”) esti-
mates that there are an estimated 73 million broadcast-
only television sets in American households.” More-
over, many of those broadcast-only televisions are in chil-
dren’s bedrooms. According to a 2005 Kaiser Family
Foundation report, 68 percent of children aged eight to
18 have a television set in their bedrooms, and nearly

49 Joint Comments at 21 (citing Annual Assessment of the Status
of Competition in the Market for the Delivery of Video Programming,
Twelfth Annual Report, 21 FCC Red 2503, 1 8 (2006) (“Annual
Assessment’’)).

™ Annual Assessment, 21 FCC Red at 2508 9 15; see also Com-
ments of the Walt Disney Co. in MB Docket No. 04-210 at 2 (filed Aug.
11, 2004) (“Disney/ABC stresses that these customers [relying on
broadcast only] represent a significant portion of our potential viewing
audience.”’).

Media Bureau Staff Report Concerning Over-the-Air Broadcast
Television Viewers, No. 04-210, 1 9 (MB Feb. 28, 2005), available at
2005 WL 473322, at *2.

"Annual Assessment, 21 FCC Red at 2508 9 15.

‘3 Td. at 2552 4 97. The NAB has properly characterized this
number as “enormous.” Reply Comments of the National Association
of Broadcasters and the Association for Maximum Service Television,
Inc. in MB Docket No. 04-210 at i (filed Sept. 7, 2004).

108a

half of those sets do not have cable or satellite connee-
tions.'™

50. In addition, the bare number of cable and satel-
lite service subscribers does not reflect the large dispar-
ity in viewership that still exists between broadcast and
cable television programs. For example, during the
week of September 18, 2006, each of the top ten pro-
grams on broadcast television had more than 15 million
viewers, while only one program on cable television that
week managed to attract more than 5 million viewers.”
Similarly, of the 495 most-watched television programs
during the 2004-2005 season, 485 appeared on broadcast
television, and the highest-rated program on cable tele-
vision was only the 257th most-viewed program of the
season.’

51. The broadcast media are also “uniquely accessi-
ble to children.” In this respect, broadcast television
differs from cable and satellite television. Parents who
subscribe to cable exercise some choice in their selection
of a package of channels, and they may avoid subscrib-
ing to some channels that present programming that, in
their judgment, is inappropriate for children. Indeed,
upon the request of a subscriber, cable providers are
required by statute to “fully block the audio and video

iss

See Kaiser Family Foundation, Generation M: Media in the
Lives of 8-18 Year-olds 77 (2005).

'* See Nielsen Media Research, “Top 10 Broadcast TV Programs for
the Week cf September 18, 2006;” Nielsen Media Research, “Top 10
Cable TV Programs for the Week of September 18, 2006.”

'* See Television Bureau of Advertising, “Season-to-Date Broadcast
vs. Subscription TV Primetime Ratings: 2004-2005,” available at http://
www.tvb.org/rcentral/Viewerlrack/F ullSeason/fs-b-c.asp?ms = 2004-
2005.asp.

109a

programming of each channel carrying such program-
ming so that one not a subscriber does not receive it.”!”
In contrast, as the D.C. Circuit has observed, “broadcast
audiences have no choice but to ‘subscribe’ to the entire
output of traditional broadcasters.”'* The V-chip pro-
vides parents with some ability to control their chil-
dren’s access to broadcast programming. But most tele-
visions do not contain a V-chip, and most parents who
have a television set with a V-chip are unaware of its
existence or do not know how to use it.’*’ In addition,
the effectiveness of a V-chip depends on the accuracy of
program ratings; a V-chip is of little use when, as here,
the rating does not reflect the material that is broad-
east.'© In light of the TV-PG rating given to “The 2003
Billboard Music Awards,” even an informed use of a V-

"7 47 U.S.C. § 560 (2000); see also United States v. Playboy
Entertainment Group, Inc., 529 U.S. 803 (2000).

"8 ACT 111, 58 F.3d at 660.

89 See Super Bowl Order on Reconsideration, 21 FCC Red at 6667
137. In Congressional testimony shortly after the 2003 Billboard Music
Awards, Fox’s President of Entertainment acknowledged that the V-
chip and television ratings were “underutilized.” H.R. 3717, the ‘Broad-
cast Decency Enforcement Act of 2004’: Hearing Before the Subcom-
mittee on Telecommunications and the Internet of the House Comm.
On Energy & Commerce, 107th Congress, (Feb. 26, 2004) (statement of
Gail Berman). According to a 2003 study, parents’ low level of V-chip
use is explained in part by parents’ unawareness of the device and the
“multi-step and often confusing process” necessary to use it. Annen-
berg Public Policy Center, Parents’ Use of the V-Chip to Supervise
Children’s Television Use 3 (2003). Only 27 percent of mothers in the
study group could figure out how to program the V-Chip, and “many
mothers who might otherwise have used the V-Chip were frustrated by
an inability to get it to work properly.” /d. at 4.

0 See supra para. 18, n. 46; Super Bowl Order on Reconsideration,
21 FCC Red at 6667-68 4 37.

110a

chip would not necessarily have protected children from
Ms. Richie’s vulgar comments,” and studies demon-
strate that inaccurate ratings are far from an isolated
problem. In a Kaiser Family Foundation survey, for
example, nearly 4 in 10 parents of children aged 2-17
stated that most television programs are not rated accu-
rately.’

161

See supra para. 18, n.46.

' Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, Parents, Media and Public
Policy: A Katser Family Foundation Survey 5 (2004) (“Kaiser
Survey”). Likewise in a study published in the journal Pediatrics,
parents concluded that half of television shows the industry had rated
as appropriate for teenagers were in fact inappropriate, a finding the
study authors called “a signal that the ratings are misleading.” . David
A. Walsh & Douglas A. Gentile, A Validity Test of Movie, Television,
and Video-Game Ratings, 107 Pediatrics 1302, 1306 (2001).

Academics who have studied the television rating system share
parents’ assessment that the ratings are often inaccurate. A 2002 study
found that many shows that should carry content descriptors do not,
therefore leaving parents unaware of potentially objectionable material.
See Dale Kunkel, et al., Deciphering the V-Chip: An Examination of
the Television Industry’s Program Rating Judgments, 52 Journal of
Communications 112 (2002). For example, the study found that 68
percent of prime-time network shows without an “L” descriptor con-
tained “adult language,” averaging nearly three scenes with such lan-
guage per show. See id. at 132; see ulso id. at 131 (finding that 20 per-
cent of shows rated TV-G—supposedly appropriate for all ages—
included objectionable language, including “bastard,” “bitch,” “shit,”
and “whore”). In fact, “in all four areas of sensitive material—violence,
sexual behavior, sexual dialogue, and adult language—the large
majority of programs that contain such depictions are not identified by
a content. descriptor.” /d. at 136. The study’s authors concluded that
“{pjarents who might rely solely on the content-based categories to
block their children’s exposure to objectionable portrayals would be
making a serious miscalculation, as the content descriptors actually
identify only asmall minority of the full range of violence, sex, and adult
language found on television.” /d.

llla

52. Broadcast television is also significantly different
from the Internet. The Internet, unlike television, is not

A 2004 study also raised serious questions about the accuracy of
television ratings. It found that there was more coarse language
broadeast during TV-PG programs than those rated TV-14, just the
opposite of what these age-based ratings would lead a viewer to believe.
Barbara K. Kaye & Barry S. Sapolsky, Offensive Language in Prime-
Time Television: Four Years After Television Age and Content Rat-
ings, 48 Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 554, 563-64 (2004);
see also Parents Television Council, The Ratings Sham: TV Executives
Hiding Behind A System That Doesn't Work (April 2005) (study of 528
hours of television programming concluding that numerous shows were
inaccurately and inconsistently rated); Effectiveness of Media Rating
Systems: Subcommittee of Science, Technology, and Space of the
Senate Comm. On Commerce, Science & Transp., 107” Congress (2004)
(statement of Ms. Patti Miller, director, Children and the Media
Program for Children Now) (“Can parents depend on the accuracy of
the ratings systems? Sadly, the answer is no.”).

An economist studying the question of why broadcasters consistently
“underlabel” their programs concluded that they are likely responding
to economic incentives. See James T. Hamilton, Who Will Rate the
Ratings?, in The V-Chip Debate: Content Filtering from Television to
the Internet 133, 143, 149 (Monroe E. Price, ed. 1998). He found that
programs with more restrictive ratings command lower advertising
revenues. See id. at 143. The desire to charge more for commercials
and fear of “advertiser backlash” over shows with more restrictive
ratings “means that networks have incentives to resist the provision of
content-based information.” /d. at 149; see also Kunkel, 52 Journal of
Communications at 114 (“{T]he prospect that applying ‘higher’ ratings
to a program could reduce audience size raises a self-interest concern
regarding the accuracy with which judgments about program ratings
are determined.”).

Finally, even assuming arguendo that the content descriptors were
accurately applied, they would not assist the majority of parents
because they are not sufficiently understoud. The Kaiser Survey found

‘that only 51% of parents understand that “V” stands for violence; only
40% understand “L” stands for language; only 37% understand “S”
stands for sex; and only 4% understand that “D” stands for suggestive
or sexual dialogue. Kaiser Survey at 6.

112a

accessible to children “too young to read.”'™ And par-
ents who wish to control older children’s access to inap-
propriate material can use widely available filtering
software—an option that, whatever its flaws, lacks an
effective analog in the context of broadcast television™
in light of the numerous problems with the V-chip and
program ratings discussed above.'”

53. No Sanction Proposed. For the reasons stated
above, we conclude that “The 2003 Billboard Music
Awards” contained indecent and profane material in
violation of Section 1464 and our rules. Fox stations
broadcast indecent and profane language in an awards
show that aired between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m. and was
watched by people of all ages. Under the circumstances,

'® Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 749. See, e.g., Youth, Pornography, and the
Internet, ed. by Dick Thornburgh and Herbert S. Lin, p. 115 (National
Academy Press 2002) (“As a general rule, young children do not have
the cognitive skills needed to navigate the Internet independently.
Knowledge of search strategies is limited if not nonexistent, and typing
skills are undeveloped.’’).

'* See Reno, 521 U.S. at 877. Filtering software, for example, can
block access to a website based on the software's evaluation of the site’s
content. The V-chip, in contrast, does not evaluate television programs
itself and therefore is only effective if the programs have been given
accurate ratings. However, to the extent that filtering software is
ineffective and children are still able to access indecent material on the
Internet, we note that Congress has sought to address this problem
through the Child Online Protection Act, a statute whose validity is still
being litigated. See Ashcroft v. ACLU, 542 U.S. 656 (2004) (affirming
preliminary injunction). We note that the Networks also refer to the
availability of video game consoles as another medium that, in their
view, is as pervasive as television. See Joint Comments at 21-22. Video
games differ from broadcast television in that games must be pur-
chased individually, so a parent who purchases a video game console for
a child retains the ability to determine which games the child will play.

' See supra para. 51 and nn. 159-162.

1l3a

however, we propose no forfeiture here. We originally
declined to propose a sanction in this case because the
broadcast occurred prior to the Golden Globe Awurds
Order. As discussed above, we believe on further con-
sideration that the compiuained-of ianguage was action-
able under Commission decisions preceding the Golden
Globe Awards Order. Nevertheless, we still decline to
propose a forfeiture here. To begin with, proposing a
sanction would require issuance of a notice of apparent
liability, which would not be “a further final or appeal-
able order of the FCC,” as required by the Remand Or-
der.'® In addition, even absent the requirement that we
issue a “final or appealable order,” we would not exer-
cise our enforcement discretion to propose a forfeiture
here given the limited remand under which we are pro-
ceeding. Accordingly, we find that no forfeiture is war-
ranted in this case.'” In light of our decision not to im-
pose a forfeiture, we will not require the licensees of any
of the stations that broadcast the material to report our
finding here to us as part of their renewal applications,
and we will not consider the broadcast to have an ad-

'” Remand Order at 2. See 47 U.S.C. § 503(b)(4)(C); ACT IV, 59
F.3d at 1254, citing Pleasant Broadcasting Co. v. FCC, 564 F.2d 496
(1).C. Cir. 1977).

'? In light of recent legislation, the Networks raise the prospect of
future fines in excess of $65 million for “a single, fleeting instance of
indecent speech.” Joint Comments at 16. We do not believe, however,
that a case similar to “The 2003 Billboard Music Awards” arising in the
future would merit the maximum fine permitted under the Broadcast
Decency Enforcement Act. See Pub. L. 109-235, 102 Stat. 491 (June 15,
2006), to be codified at 47 U.S.C. § 503(b)(2)(C Mii). While that Act, once
we adopt implementing regulations, will provide the Commission with
the flexibility to impose appropriate fines in egregious cases, the
Commission will continue to follow a restrained enforcement policy in
imposing forfeitures in this area.

1l4a

verse impact upon such licensees as part of the renewal
process or in any other context.

54. In light of our decision not to impose a forfeiture,
we need not address whether the violations of Section
1464 and our rule were willful within the meaning of
Section 503(b)."* We disagree with the Networks, how-
ever, that Section 1464 is not violated unless a broad-
caster acts with the state of mind required for a criminal
conviction.” The Supreme Court has squarely rejected
the argument that the FCC’s civil authority to enforce
Section 1464 must be interpreted in accordance with
rules that apply to criminal statutes, explaining: “The
legislative history of the provisions establishes their
independence. As enacted in 1927 and 1934, the prohibi-
tion on indecent speech was separate from the provi-
sions imposing civil and criminal penalties for violating
the prohibition . .°. Although the 1948 codification of
the criminal laws and the addition of new civil penalties

8 See 47 U.S.C. §§ 503(b)(1)(B) & (D). We also need not address
whether responsibility would lie with independent Fox affiliates in
addition to the licensees owned by Fox. Cf, Complaints Against Va-
rious Television Licensees Concerning Their February 1, 2004 Broad-
cast of the Super Bowl XXXVIIT Halftime Show, Notice of Apparent
Liability for Forfeiture, 19 FCC Red 19230, 19240-41 9 25 (2004).

"Joint Comments at 24-26. We also reject, as contrary to the
plain meaning of the Act, the Networks’ contention that we may
not impose forfeitures for violations of our indecency rule under section
503(b)(1)(B). While the Networks suggest that the Commission’s
indecency rule, 47 C.F .R. § 73.3999, merely represents a decision by the
Commission to restate 18 U.S.C. § 1464, the indecency rule was adopted
by the Commission pursuant to the direction of Congress. See Public
Telecommunications Act of 1992, Pub. L. No. 102-356, 106 Stat. 949,
Section 16 (1992).

115a

changed the statutory structure, no substantive change
was apr arently intended . . . Accordingly, we need not
consid. « #2 question relating to the possible applica-
tion of § 1464 as a criminal statute.”’” Thus, the mens
rea necessary for a criminal conviction is not a prerequi-
site to the Commission’s finding a Section 1464 viola-
tion." ,

B. “The 2002 Billboard Music Awards”

55. The Programming. The Commission received a
complaint alleging that WT'TG(TV), Washington, DC,
broadcast indecent material during “The 2002 Billboard
Music Awards” program which aired at 8 p.m. Eastern
Standard Time on December 9, 2002.'” Specifically, the

'® Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 739 n.13.

The Networks’ reliance on FCC v. ABC, 347 U.S. 284, 296 (1954),
for the pruposition that “[t]here cannot be one construction for the
Federal Communications Commission and another for the Department
of Justice” is misplaced. Joint Comments at 24. In that case, the
Court rejected the broad construction urged by the Commission of a
statutory prohibition against a “lottery, gift enterprise, or similar
scheme” in part because “the same construction would likewise apply
in criminal cases.” FCC v. ABC, 347 U.S. at 296. In contrast, the intent
required to impose civil penalties for Section 1464 violations has no
impact on its possible application as a criminal statute. See Pacifica,
438 U.S. at 739 n. 13.

'® FCC File No. EB-03-IH-(460. See Letter from Lara Mahaney,
Director of Corporate and Entertainment Affairs, PTC to David Solo-
mon, Chief, Enforcement Bureau, Federal Communications Commis-
sion (August 22, 2003). As noted in the Golden Globe Awards Order,
the Commission’s Enforcement Bureau had dismissed an earlier com-
plaint concerning the same broadcast on the same station eight months
earlier. See Letter from Charles Kelley, Chief, Investigations and
Hearings Division, Enforcement Bureau, FCC to RadioEsq@aol.com,
EB-02-1H-O861-MT (December 18, 2002), cited wm Golden Globe
Awards Order, 19 FCC Red at 4980 91 12 n.32 (noting Bureau dismissal

116a

complainant alleged that while accepting an award, Cher
stated: “People have been telling me I’m on the way out
every year, right? So fuck ‘em.”'” The “2002 Billboard
Music Awards” was broadcast nationwide on the Fox
Television Network.

56. Examination of a videotape of the broadcast re-
veals that Cher, a singer and actress, was presented
with an “Artist Achievement Award” during “The 2002
Billboard Music Awards” program. Cher had been se-
lected to receive this award at least three weeks before
the broadcast.’ In the course of her remarks accepting
the award, she stated as follows: “I’ve had unbelievable
support in my life and I’ve worked really hard. I’ve had
great people to work with. Oh, yeah, you know what?
I’ve also had critics for the last 40 years saying that I
was on my way out every year. Right. So fuck ‘em. I
still have a job and they don’t.”

57. Following the Second Circuit’s remand, the Bu-
reau sent Fox a letter of inquiry on September 7, 2006
concerning “The 2002 Billboard Music Awards” broad-

of complaint). However, Fox has raised no claim of administrative res
judicata, and thus, because that defense has been waived, we need not
consider it. Cf Kern Oil & Ref. Co. v. Tenneco Oil Co., 840 F.2d 730,
735 (9th Cir. 1988).

im”

See Letter from Lara Mahaney, Director of Corporate and
Entertainment Affairs, PTC to David Solomon, Chief, Enforcement
Bureau, Federal Communications Commission (August 22, 2003).

'* See Press Release, “Cher to Receive the Artist Achievement
Award on the 2002 Billboard Music Awards Monday, Dec. 9 on Fox”
(Nov. 14, 2002), attached to Letter from John C. Quale, Counsel of Fox,
to Benigno E. Bartolome, Deputy Chief, Investigations and Hearings
Division, Enforcement Bureau, File No. EB-03-I1H-0460 (September
21, 2006) (“Fox Response to 9/7/2006 LOT”).

117a

east.'” Fox responded on September 21, 2006.'” Fox’s
response confirms that it broadcast the material de-
scribed in the complaint.'” Nevertheless, Fox argues
that its broadcast of the “F-Word,” in context, did not
depict or describe sexual activities but rather, “at most,”
was a “vulgar expletive directed as an insult toward an
individual or group against whom the speaker held deep-
seated feelings of ill-will,” and thus is outside the scope
of the Commission’s indecency definition.’ Further,
Fox argues that the complained-of material was not ac-
tionably indecent because it “contained at most the pass-
ing use of an expletive used to convey an insult,” it
“lasted only a couple of seconds out of a two-hour pro-
gram,” and Fox did not present it to pander to or titil-
late the audience, or for shock value.'” Therefore, Fox
contends that the dialogue is not actionably indecent.'™

58. Indecency Analysis. With respect to the first
prong of the indecency test, Fox contends that Cher’s

"> See Letter from Benigno E. Bartolome, Deputy Chief, Investiga-
tions and Hearings Division, Enforcement Bureau, to Fox Television
Stations, Inc., File No. EB-03-1H-0460 (September 7, 2006).

"See Fox Response to 9/7/2006 LOI.
~~ 2.06.

ms Id. at 10.

Po oe.

' Fox also suggests that the complaint should be dismissed because

it fails to specifically allege that the complainant viewed “The 2002
Billboard Music Awards.” See id. at 2. We disagree. Our practice has;
never been to require such an allegation in order for a complaint to be
considered. It is sufficient that the complaint originated from within
the market of the station against which the complaint is filed. See
Indecency Policy Statement, 16 FCC Red at 8015 4 24; see also Super
Bowl Order on Reconsideration, 21 FCC Red at 6665 1 30.

118a

statement “fuck ‘em” does not describe sexual activities
and thus falls outside the scope of our indecency defini-
tion. We disagree. As discussed above, a long line of
precedent indicates that both literal and non-literal uses
of the “F-Word” come within the subject matter scope of
our indecency definition.'*’ Given the core meaning of
the “F-Word,” any use of that word has a sexual conno-
tation."* Moreover, it hardly seems debatable that the
word’s power to insult and offend derives from its sexual
meaning.’ Here, for example, Cher’s use of the “F-
Word” to reference a sexual act as a metaphor to ex-
press hostility to her critics is inextricably linked to the
sexual meaning of the term.™ Accordingly, we conclude
that, as we stated in Golden Globe, its use falls within
the scope of our indecency definition. The material thus
warrants further scrutiny to determine whether it is
patently offensive as measured by contemporary com-
munity standards for the broadcast medium. Looking at
the three principal factors in our contextual analysis, we
conclude that it is.

59. We will first address the first and third principal
factors in our contextual analysis—the explicit or
graphic nature of the material and whether the material
panders to, titillates, or shocks the audience. As we

131

See supra note 38.
See supra para. 16.

ime

i See supra note 40.

‘4 See Andrew Koppelman, Why Discrimination Against Lesbians

and Gay Men Is Sex Discrimination, 69 N.Y.U.L. Rev. 197, 224 (1994)
(explaining the sexual meaning of the metaphorical use of the “F-Word”
as a verb).

'® See Golden Globe Awards Order, 19 FCC Red at 4979 & 8.

119a

have previously concluded, the “F-Word” is one of the
most vulgar, graphic, and explicit words for sexual activ-
ity in the English language.’ Moreover, the gratuitous
use of this language during a live broadcast of a popular
music awards ceremony when children were expected to
be in the audience was vulgar and shocking. The
complained-of material was broadcast in prime time, and
the program was designed to draw a large nationwide
audience that could be expected to include many chil-
dren interested in seeing their favorite musie stars.'™
As in the ease of “The 2003 Billboard Music Awards,”'™
a significant portion of the viewing audience for this pro-
gram was under 18. According to Nielsen ratings data,
during an average minute of “The 2002 Billboard Music
Awards” broadcast, 2,608,000 (27.9%) of the 9,361,000
people watching the program were under 18, and
1,186,000 (12.7%) were between the ages of 2 and 11. In
addition, the program’s TV-PG rating” would not have
put parents or others on notice of such vulgar language,
and the broadcast contained no other warnings to view-
ers that it might contain material highly unsuitable for
children.'’” Furthermore, Fox does not argue that there

6 See id.

"7 See Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 749-51 (identifying as relevant contex-
tual factors the time of day of the broadcast, program content as it
affects “the composition of the audience,” and the nature of the
medium). See also supra para. 18.

ss See supra para. 18.

'*" Fox Response to 9/7/2006 LOI at 6.

™ See supra n. 47. In the context of a broadcast rated “T'V-PG,” an
“L” content description warning would not have alerted parents to the
use of the “F-word.” See id. Nonetheless, the “2002 Billboard Music
Award,” unlike the 2008 version of the same show, did not include even
that inadequate “L” content descriptor. So parents relying on the

120a

was any justification for Cher’s comment.” In light of
all of these factors, we conclude that the first and third
factors in our contextual analysis weigh in favor of a
finding that the material is patently offensive.'”

60. We next turn to the second factor in our contex-
tual analysis—whether the complained-of material was
sustained or repeated. Fox argues that this factor pre-
cludes a finding of indecency. As reviewed above, Com-
mission dicta and Bureau-level decisions issued before
our Golden Globe decision had suggested that expletives
had to be repeated to be indecent but that such a repeti-
tion requirement would not apply to “descriptions or
depictions of sexual or excretory functions.” In this
case, Cher did more than use the “F-Word” as a mere
interjection or intensifier. Rather, she used the word to
describe or reference a sexual act as a metaphor to ex-
press hostility to her critics. The fact that she was not
literally suggesting that people engage in sexual activi-
ties does not necessarily remove the use of the term
from the realm of descriptions or depictions. This case
thus illustrates the difficulty in making the distinction
between expletives on the one hand and descriptions or
depictions on the other. Particularly in light of this lack

ratings would not have expected even mild “coarse” language, much
less the “F-Word.”

'"! For instance, Fox does not contend that Cher’s comment had any

artistic merit or was necessarv to convey any message.

‘Fox's argument that it did not present Cher’s comment for “shock
value” misunderstands the contextual analysis employed by the
Commission, under which “we examine the material itself and the
manner in which it is presented, not the subjective state of mind of the
broadcaster.” Super Bowl Order on Reconsideration, 21 FCC Red at
6657-58 § 12.

12la

of clarity, we acknowledge that it was not apparent that
Fox could be penalized for Cher’s comment at the time
it was broadcast. This case also shows that the inquiry
into whether a word is used an expletive rather than a
description or depiction is wholly artificial. Whether
used as an expletive, or as a description or depiction, the
offensive nature of the “F-Word” is inherently tied to
the term’s sexual meaning.

61. In any event, under our Golden Globe precedent,
the fact that Cher used the “F-Word” once does not re-
move her comment from the realm of actionable inde-
cency.'” We stated in Golden Globe that the “mere fact
that specific words or phrases are not sustained or re-
peated does not mandate a finding that material that is
otherwise patently offensive to the broadcast medium is
not indecent.”'” To be sure, the fact that material is not
repeated does weigh against a finding of indecency, and
in certain cases, when all of the relevant factors are con-
sidered together, this factor may tip the balance ina
decisive manner. This, however, is not one of those
cases.

62. We believe that Cher’s use of the “F-Word” here
during a program aired in prime time was patently of-
fensive under contemporary community standards for
the broadcast medium. The patent offensiveness is com-
pounded by the fact that the warnings accompanying the
broadcast were inadequate and misleading.” We do not
believe that the Commission should ignore “the first
blow” to the television audience in the particular circum-

‘See Golden Globe Awards Order, 19 FCC Red at 4980 4 12.
= #8.
‘8 See supra para. 59.

122a

stances presented here.'” Our determination, more-
over, is consistent with the networks’ own broadcast
standards during the “safe harbor,” which would not
allow the broadcast of a single use of the “F-Word” un-
der these circumstances." Such standards reflect the
networks’ recognition that even a single use of the “F-
Word” under most circumstances is not consistent with
contemporary community standards for the broadcast
medium. Indeed, Fox edited out Cher’s comment in its
broadcasts to the Mountain and Pacific Time Zones.

63. In sum, we conclude that, given the explicit, gra-
phic, vulgar, and shocking nature of Cher’s use of the
“F-Word,” Fox’s broadcast was patently offensive under
contemporary community standards for the broadcast
medium.

64. Fox also argues that it should not be held re-
sponsible for airing Cher’s comment. In particular, Fox
argues that Cher’s remarks were unscripted and that
the five-second delay and editing system that it used for
“The 2002 Billboard Music Awards” previously 1ad been
effective in preventing the airing of objectionable mate-
rial.’ We need not address these arguments, however,
because we decide that it would not be equitabl

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385015_0044%3A0. Public record. Not legal advice.
