# Joint Appendix — Norton v. Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385014_0696%3A13

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Joint Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 2004
- **Citation:** 542 U.S. 55

## Text

Supreme Court. US

' ; — ry

} |
'

| MAR 1} 2nNé

OFFICE OF > pH Fey

No. 03-101 Se re on

Jn the Supreme Court of the Gnited States

—

GALE NORTON, SECRETARY OF THE INTERIOR, ET AL..,
PETITIONERS :

v.

SOUTHERN UTAH WILDERNESS ALLIANCE, ET AL.

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT

JOINT APPENDIX
THEODORE B. OLSON PAUL M. SMITH
Solicitor General Jenner & Biock
Department of Justice 601 13th Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20580-0001 Washington, D.C. 20005
(202) 514-2217 (202) G329-GOOU

Counsel of Record

: , for Respondents Southern
Counsel of Record ao P ;
' ay Ae Utah Wilderness Alliance.
for Petitioners tal
, i .

PAUL A. TURCKE
Moore Smith Buxton &
Turke Chartered
255 North 9th Street
Suite 420
Bosie, Idaho 83702
(202) 331-1807

Counsel of Record
for Respondents Utah
Shared Access Alliance,
et al.

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI FILED: JULY 18, 2003
CERTIORARI GRANTED: NOV. 3, 2003

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Court of Appeals Docket Entries .............cccssesseseeseeseseeseees
District Court Docket Entries ..........ccccsossscssssssssscescessossees
District Court Order (Feb. 9, 2001)

Excerpts from BLM Interim Management Policy

BLM Information Bulletin No. 99-181

Excerpts from Off-Road Vehicle Implementation:

Henry Mountains Planning Area
Excerpts from San Rafael Management Plan
Excerpts from Defendants’ Response to Plaintiffs’

First Set of Requests for Admission (Apr. 27, 2000)
Excerpts from Transcript of Hearing (Aug. 28, 2000)
Excerpts from Transcript of Hearing (Aug. 29, 2000)
Excerpts from Transcript of Hearing (Aug. 30, 2000)
Excerpts from Defendants’ Response to Plaintiffs’

Supplemental Briefing (Nov. 7, 2000)

Exhibit to Plaintiffs’ Rule 28(j) Letter to Tenth

Circuit (Feb. 8, 2002)

Excerpts from Plaintiffs’ Memorandum in Support
of Motion for Preliminary Injunction (June 14,

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT

No. 01-4009
SOUTHERN UTAH WILDERNESS ALLIANCE, ET AL.

v.
GALE NORTON, SECRETARY, UNITED STATES

DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR, ET AL.,
DEFENDANTS-APPEELLEES

RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
DATE PROCEEDINGS
1/25/01 Civil case docketed. Preliminary record

filed. DATE RECEIVED: 1/22/01. Doc-
keting statement due 2/5/01 for South-
ern Utah Wilderness, et al., transcript
order form due 2/5/01 for Rebecca
Janke pursuant to r. 42.1. Notice of ap-
pearance due 2/5/01 for Anthony Chat-
terly, Elite Motorcycle, Blue Ribbon,
Shared Access, Wayne County, Kane
County, Trust Lands Admin., Emergy
County, San Juan County, Utah, BLM,
Tom Fry, Bruce Babbitt, Friends of the
Abajo, American Lands, UT Council of
Trout, Wildlands CPR, Old Broads,
Sierra Club, Wilderness Society, and
Southern Utah. (mt)

(1)

DATE

PROCEEDINGS

1/26/01

1/29/01

2/5/01

2/6/01

Notice filed that the transcript is
already on file in district court. Notice
due that record is complete 2/9/01 for
Dale A. Kimball. (sl)

* * * * *

Docketing statement filed by Wilder-
ness Society, Sierra Club, Great Old
Broads, Wildlands CPR, UT Council of
Trout, American Lands, Friends of the
Abajo, Southern Utah. Original and 4
copies c/s: y. (sl)

* * * *&

Order filed by PF (ktc) - Briefing on
the merits is tolled. Within 30 days
counsel must serve and file in this court
a district court order either granting
Rule 54 (b) certification as to the order
appealed, or explicitly adjudicating all
remaining claims. Rule 54(b) certifica-
tion due 3/7/01 for James S. Angell,
Robert B. Wiygul, Stephen H.M. Bloch
and Heidi J. McIntosh. Parties served
by mail. (mt)

* *+ *& & *

Filed notice record is complete 1/30/01
(dla)

DATE

PROCEEDINGS

2/14/01

2/22/01

3/5/01

5/14/01

Notice of appearance filed by Paul A.
Turcke as attorney for Shared Access,
Blue Ribbon, Elite Motorcycle, and
Anthony Chatterly. CERT. OF IN-
TERESTED PARTIES (y/n): y (dla)

> * *&* & *

Rule 54(b) certification filed by Stephen
H.M. Bloch, Staff Attorney for South-
ern Utah Wilderness Alliance. (mt)

Order filed by PF (ktc) referring Rule
54 (b) certification and jurisdictional
issue TO PANEL ON THE MERITS.
Appellant’s brief and appendix due
4/16/01 for Friends of the Abajo, et al.
Parties served by mail. (kjs)

+ *+ *&* *& *

Appellants’ brief filed by Southern
Utah, Wilderness Society, Sierra Club,
Great Old Broads, Wildlands CPR, UT
Council of Trout, American Lands,
Friends of the Abajo. Original and 7
copies. c/s: y. Served on 5/14/01. Oral
argument? y., Appendix filed. Original
and 1 appendix copy. Appendix Pages:
903. Appellees brief due 6/18/01 for
Anthony Chatterly, for Elite

DATE

PROCEEDINGS

5/14/01

7/18/01

7/23/01

Motorcycle, for Blue Ribbon, for
Shared Access, for Wayne County, for
Kane County, for Trust Lands Admin.,
for Emery County, for San Juan
County, for Utah, for BLM, for Nina
Rose Hatfield, for Gale Norton. (kjs)

Oversized record filed. Record can be
located at Section: T Shelf: 2 (das)

* * * *

Appellees’ brief by Shared Access, Blue
Ribbon, Elite Motorcycle and Anthony
Chatterly. Original and 7 copies. c/s: y.
Served on 7/17/01. Oral Argument? y.
Appendix filed. Original and 1 appendix
copy. Appendix Pages: 177. (afw)

Appellees’ deficient brief filed by Utah,
San Juan County, Emery County,
Trust Lands Admin., Kane County,
Wayne County. Appellee’s corrected
brief due 8/3/01 for Wayne County, for
Kane County, for Trust Lands Admin.,
for Emery County, for San Juan
County, for Utah. (no oral argument
statement on cover, no prior/related ap-
peal statement, green cover) (sl)

DATE

PROCEEDINGS

— - =

13

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

2/7/00

2/11/00

2/18/00

21

22

23

Elite Motorcycle, Anthony
Chatterley (hom) [Entry date
02/08/00]

* * *

Response by Bruce Babbitt,
Tom Fry, BLM to [5-1]
motion to intervene by UT
Shared Access, Blue Ribbon,
Elite Motorcyle, Anthony
Chatterly (hom) [Entry date
02/09/00)

* * *

Magistrate Notice of Hearing
Initial Pretrial Conference
set for 10:00 3/23/00 To be
held before Judge Boyce cc:
atty (Ntc generated by: IPT
Sheet/Chambers RNB) (hom)
[Entry date 02/11/00]

2nd Declaration of Brian
Hawthorne (hom) [Entry
date 02/22/00)

14

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

2/18/00

3/3/00

3/7/00

3/16/00

24

26

27

Reply by UT Shared Access,
Blue Ribbon, Elite Motor-
cycle, Anthony Chatterley to
response to [5-1] motion to
intervene by UT Shared Ac-
cess, Blue Ribbon, Elite Mo-
torcycle, Anthony Chatterly
(hom) [Entry date 02/22/00]

Notice of Hearing filed:
Motion hearing set for 10:00
3/16/00 for [5-1] motion to
intervene by UT Shared Ac-
cess, Blue Ribbon, Elite Mo-
torcycle, Anthony Chatterly
To be held before Judge
DAK. Ce: atty (Ntc generate
by: DAK Courtroom Deputy,
KJ) (ce) [Entry date 03/03/00)

Report of Attorney Planning
Meeting (hom) [Entry date
03/08/00}

Minute entry: Motion hearing
heid for [5-1] motion to inter-
vene by UT Shared Access,
Blue Ribbon, Elite Motor-
cycle, Anthony Chatterly [5-
1] motion to intervene by UT
Shared Access, Blue Ribbon,

ons

15

- —

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

Elite Motorcycle, Anthony
Chatterly taken under ad-
visement; Judge: DAK Court
Reporter: Kelly Hicken
Court Deputy: Kim Jones (kj)
[Entry date 03/16/00]

Order granting [5-1] motion
to intervene by UT Shared
Access, Blue Ribbon, Elite
Motorcycle, Anthony Chat-
terly signed by Judge Dale
A. Kimball, 3/21/00 ce: atty
(alf) [Entry date 03/23/00)

Scheduling order setting
deadline for filing of all
motions 4:30 10/2/00; Dis-
covery cutoff 4:30 9/1/00;
Final Pretrial Conference for
2:30 4/10/01; Jury Trial for
8:30 4/30/01 Rule 26(f)(1) enf
held. Expert witness disclo-
sure dates set. Not Referred
to ADR. Discovery limits
set. Signed by Judge Ronald
N. Boyce 3/23/00 cc: atty.
Settlement Potential: Fair
(slh) [Entry date 03/24/00)

16

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

4/4/00

5/15/00

30

31

Amended Scheduling order
Setting Deadline for filing of
all motions 4:30 10/2/00; Dis-
covery cutoff 4:30 9/1/00;
Final Pretrial Conference for
2:30 4/10/01; 10 day Bench
Trial for 8:30 4/30/01 Rule
26(f)(1) enf held. Expert
witness disclosure dates set.
Not referred to ADR. Dis-
covery limits set. Signed by
Judge Ronald N. Boyce
4/2/00 ce: atty. Settlement
Potential: Fair (hom) [Entry
date 04/04/00)

Answer by Anthony Chat-
terly, Elite Motorcycle, Blue
Ribbon, UT Shared Access to
lst amended complaint (asb)
[Entry date 04/07/00)

* * *

Unopposed Motion by So UT
Wilderness for leave to file
2nd amd cmp (kam) [Entry
date 05/15/00] [Edit date
05/15/00)

17

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

5/15/00

5/15/00

5/16/00

5/18/00

6/1/00

38

Memorandum by So UT
Wilderness in support of [37-
1] unopposed motion for
leave to file 2nd amd cmp
(kam) [Entry date 05/15/00)

Proposed document from So
UT Wilderness entitled, “Se-
cond Amended Complaint.”
Lodge until approved by
order. (kam) [Entry 05/15/00)

Order granting [37-1] motion
for leave to file 2nd amd cmp
signed by Judge Dale A.
Kimball, 5/16/00 ce: atty.
(jmo) [Entry date 05/16/00)

2nd amended complaint by
Friends of the Abajo, Amer

‘Lands Alliance, UT Council

Trout, Wildlands CPR, Great
Old Broads, Sierra Club,
Wilderness Soc, So UT
Wilderness added party(ies):
None. Amends [4-1] first
amended complaint (hom)
[Entry 05/19/00]

NTC by Friends of the
Abajo, Amer Lands Alliance,
UT Council Trout, Wildlands

18

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

19

6/5/00

6/5/00

6/14/00

53

CPR, Great Old Broads,
Sierra Club, Wilderness Soc,
So UT Wilderness herein-
after will be referred to as:
All Plaintiffs; party added
(hom) [Entry 06/02/00)

Expert report of G. Ronald
Wright filed by So UT
Wilderness (tsi) [Entry date
06/06/00)

Expert report of Dr. Howard
Wilshire filed by All Plain-
tiffs (hom) [Entry 06/07/00)

Exhibits 1-3 in the form of
photographs on compact
dises filed by all plaintiffs
RE: [44-1] expert rpt of Dr.
Howard Wilshire. Compact
discs are placed in oversized
filed labeled as Volume A &
B. (hom) [Entry date
06/07/00) [Edit date 06/07/00)

Motion by All Plaintiffs for -

preliminary injunction (ksj)
[Entry date 06/15/00]

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

6/14/00

6/14/00

6/14/00

6/15/00

55

57

Memorandum by All Plain-
tiffs in support of [53-1] mo-
tion for preliminary injunc-
tion (ksj) [Entry date
06/15/00)

Exhibits Volume 1 filed by
all plaintiffs All Plaintiffs
RE: [55-1] support memo-
randum (ksj) [Entry date
06/15/00)

Exhibit Volume 2 filed by All
Plaintiffs RE: [55-1] support
memorandum (ksj) [Entry
date 06/15/00)

+ * *

Notice of Hearing filed by All
Plaintiffs Motion hearing set
for 8:30 7/11/00 for [53-1]
motion for preliminary in-
junction To be held before
Judge DAK (Ntc generated
by: Plas’ Cnsl) (asb) [Entry
dated 06/16/00)

* * *

Clarification/Addendum to
[55-1] plas’ support memo-
randum re: mot/prelin injunc-
tion filed by All Plaintiffs.
(hom) [Entry date 06/30/00)

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

6/30/00

7/6/00

7/6/00

7/6/00

70

71

74

75

Motion by All Plaintiffs for
temporary restraining order
to prevent the threat of off-
road vehicle damamge (tsi)
[Entry date 07/06/00]

* * *

Supp! Expert report of Dr.
Howard Wilshire filed by All
Plaintiffs. Note: supp] is
contained on two digital CD’s
CD’s are in file labeled as
Volume B (hom) [Entry date
07/06/00) [Edit date 07/07/00)
* * *

Response to BLM, Tom Fry,
Bruce Babbitt to [55-1] plas’
memo in support of mot for
prelim inj (asb) [Entry date
07/07/00)

Memorandum by Anthony
Chatterly, Elite Motorcycle,
Blue Ribbon, UT Shared
Access in opposition to [70-1]
motion for temporary re-
straining order to prevent
the threat of off-road vehicle
damamge (asb) [Entry date
07/07/00)

21

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

——

7/6/00

7/6/00

7/6/00

76

Declaration of Norman
Carroll RE: [75-1] Memoran-
dum by Anthony Chatterly,
Elite Motorcycle, Blue Rib-
bon, UT Shared Access in
opposition to [70-1] motion
for temporary restraining
order to prevent the threat
of off-road vehicle damamge
(asb) [Entry date 07/07/00)

Declaration of Wes Thomp-
son, PG Re: [75-1] Memo-
randum by Anthony Chatter-
ly, Elite Motorcycle, Blue
Ribbon, UT Shared Access in
opposition to [70-1] motion
for temporary restraining
order to prevent the threat of

off-road vehicle damamge
(asb) [Entry date 07/07/00]

Declaration of Mark Hab-
beshaw Re: [75-1] Memoran-
dum by Anthony Chatterly,
Elite Motorcycle, Blue Rib-
bon, UT Shared Access in
opposition to [70-1] motion
for temporary restraining
order to prevent the threat

22

of off-road vehicle damamge
(asb) [Entry date 07/07/00]

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

7/6/00

7/6/00

7/10/00

79

80

85

Declaration of Wes Thom-
pson, PG Re: [75-1] Memo-
randum by Anthony Chat-
terly, Elite Motorcycle, Blue
Ribbon, UT Shared Access in
opposition to [70-1] motion
for temporary restraining
order to prevent the threat of
off-road vehicle damamge
(asb) [Entry date 07/07/00]

Declaration of Margaret
Fugate Swasey, Re: [75-1]
Memorandum by Anthony
Chatterly, Elite Motorcycle,
Blue Ribbon, UT Shared
Access in opposition to [70-1]
motion for temporary re-
straining order to prevent
the threat of off-road vehicle
damamge (asb) [Entry date
07/07/00)

* * *

Motion by ST UT, San Juan
Cnty, Emery Cnty for
limited intervention (as dfts)
by ST UT, San Juan Cnty,
Emery Cnty, and to dismiss

7/10/00

7/10/00

7/10/00

86

87

88

for failure to join indispens-
able parties, and to stay pro-
ceedings (hom) [Entry date
07/10/00)

Memorandum by ST UT, San
Juan Cnty, Emery Cnty in
support of [85-1] motion for
limited intervention (as dfts)
by ST UT, San Juan Cnty,
Emery Cnty, [85-2] motion to
dismiss for failure to join
indispensable parties, [85-3]
motion to stay proceedings
(fom) [Entry date 07/10/00)
[Edit date 07/10/00)

Reply by All Plaintiffs to
response to [70-1] motion for
temporary restraining order
to prevent the threat of off-
road vehicle damamge (asb)
[Entry date 07/11/00]

Declaration of Liz Thomas
Re: [87-1] response reply to
mot for temp restraining
order (asb) [Entry date
07/11/00)

24
DOCKET

DATE NUMBER PROCEEDINGS

7/10/00 89 Declaration of Herb McHarg
Re: [87-1] response reply to
mot for temp restraining
order (asb) [Entry date
07/11/00)

7/10/00 90 Minute entry: phone enf held

in chambers to decide
whether or not to proceed w/
Mot/TRO sched 9:00 7/11/00;
after hrg argument of ensl,
Crt ruled that evidence will
be heard in the mot/TRO as
scheduled; briefing sched set
for mot/Intervene; responses
due 7/19/00, reply due
7/26/00; Motion hearing set
for 3:30 7/31/00 for [85-1]
motion for limited interven-
tion (as dfts) by ST UT, San
Juan Cnty, Emery Cnty, set
for 3:30 7/31/00 for [85-2]
motion to dismiss for failure
to join indispensable, set for
3:30 7/31/00 for [85-3] motion
to stay; Judge: DAK Re-
porter: Becky Janke Court
Deputy: Kim Jones (kj) [En-
try date 07/11/00]

- ~

Pt are ree ri lain ee oF 9 Bee _

25

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

7/11/00

7/12/00

91

91

Minute entry: Hearing held
on motion for TRO; pla in-
voked the exclusionary rule;
dft obj; Crt sustained the obj:
opening stmts made; testi-
mony & evidence heard; hrg
cont to 9:00 7/12/00; Judge:
DAK Court Reporter: Kelly
Hicken Court Deputy: Kim
Jones (kj) [Entry date
07/13/00)

Minute entry: Hrg on
Mot/Tro cont; testimony &
evidence rec’d; closing argu-
ments heard; Crt took the
motion under advisement &
will issue ruling on 7/21/00 or
advise ens] that it is
inappropriate to rule on this
motion prior to hrg on 7/31/00
for mot/intervene; Judge:
DAK Court Reporter: Becky
Janke Court Deputy: Kim
Jones (kj) [Entry date
07/13/00)

26

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

27

7/12/00

7/13/00

7/19/00

7/19/00

92

93

95

Witness and Exhibit list from
hrg on Mo/TRO held 7/11/00
and 7/12/00. Exhibits are in
custody of law clerk Anne
Morgan. (kj) [Entry date
07/13/00]

Addendum to [86-1] support
memorandum filed by ST
UT, San Juan Cnty, Emery
Cnty. (tsi) [Entry date
07/14/00)

* * *

Response/Statement of Non-
Opposition by Anthony
Chatterly, Elite Motorcycle,
Blue Ribbon, UT Shared
Access to [85-1] motion for
limited intervention (as dfts)
by ST UT, San Juan Cnty,
Emery Cnty (asb) [Entry
date 07/20/00]

Response by BLM, Tom Fry,
Bruce Babbitt to [85-1] mo-
tion for limited intervention
(as dfts) by ST UT, San Juan
Cnty, Emery Cnty, [85-2]
motion to dismiss for failure
to join indispensable parties,
[85-3] motion (asb) [Entry
date 07/20/00]

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

7/19/00

7/19/00

7/19/00

7/21/00

97

97

98

Response by All Plaintiffs to
[85-1] motion for limited
intervention (as dfts) by ST
UT, San Juan Cnty, Emery
Cnty (asb) [Entry date
07/20/00]

Memorandum by All
Plaintiffs in opposition to [85-
2] motion to dismiss for
failure to join indispensable
parties (asb) [Entry date
07/20/00]

Declaration of Jennifer Korb
(asb) [Entry date 07/20/00]

* * *

Order denying [70-1] motion
for temporary restraining
order to prevent the threat of
off-road vehicle damamge
signed by Judge Dale A.
Kimball, 7/20/00 ce: atty
(hom) [Entry date 07/21/00]

* * *

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

7/26/00

7/31/00

103

105

_ Reply by Anthony Chatterly,

Elite Motorcycle, Blue
Ribbon, UT Shared Access to
response to [85-1] motion for
limited intervention (as dfts)
by ST UT, San Juan Cnty,
Emery Cnty, [85-2] motion to
dismiss for failure to join
indispensable parties (hom)
[Entry date 07/27/00]

* * *

Minute entry: Motion hearing
held for [85-1] motion for
limited intervention (as dfts)
by ST UT, San Juan Cnty,
Emery Cnty, held for [85-2]
motion to dismiss for failure
to join indispensable parties,
held for [85-3] motion [85-1]
motion for limited interven-
tion (ad dfts) by ST UT, San

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

- ie elt SP

8/4/00

8/4/00

107

108

Juan Cnty, Emery Cnty
taken under advisement, [85-
2} motion to dismiss for fail-
ure to join indispensable
parties taken under advise-
ment, [85-3] motion to say
taken under advisement;
Judge: DAK Court Re-
porter: Becky Janke Court
Deputy: Kim Jones (kj)
[Etnry date 07/31/00)

* * *

Expert report of Andrew E.
Godfrey filed by BLM, Tom
Fry, Bruce Babbitt (hom)
[Entry date 08/07/00)

Order granting [85-1] motion
for limited intervention (as
dfts) by ST UT, San Juan
Cnty, Emery Cnty, Kane
Cnty, Wayne Cnty and
School and Institutional
Trust Lands Admin (note;
Wayne & Kane Cnty and
School Trust Lands were
added in Movant’s reply
memo) denying [85-2] motion
to dismiss for failure to join

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

109

111

111

*

indispensable mooting/ deny-
ing [85-3] motion to stay pro-
ceedings. School Trust and
counties are hereby joined in
this action and subsequent
captions should so reflect.
State will be allowed to in-
tervene if it chooses to waive
its sovereign immunity.
Signed by Judge Dale A.
Kimball, 8/4/00 ce: atty (hom)
[Entry date 08/07/00) [Edit
date 08/07/00)

Answer by BLM, Tom Fry,
Bruce Babbitt to 2nd
amended complaint (hom)
[Entry date 08/08/00)

* * *

Motion by All Plaintiffs to
dismiss plas’ 9th cause of
action in the 2nd amd cmp
(hom) [Entry date 08/09/00)

Request for Expedited
Ruling by All Plaintiffs RE:
[111-1] motion to dismiss
plas’ 9th cause of action in
the 2nd amd cmp (hom)
[Entry date 08/09/00)

> teen

31

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

8/8/00

8/10/00

8/10/00

8/15/00

112

113

114

115

Memorandum by All Plain-
tiffs in support of [111-1] ex-
pedited ruling requested,
[111-1] motion to dismiss
plas’ 9th cause of action in
the 2nd amd emp (hom)
[Entry date 08/09/00]

Notice of Hearing filed:
Motion hearing set for 9:00
8/28/00 for [53-1] motion to
preliminary injunction (4
days) To be held before
Judge Kimball ce: atty (Nte
generated by: Courtroom
Dep KJ). Changed from 8/28
at 2:00 (hom) [Entry date
08/11/00).

Answer by Anthony
Chatterley, Elite Motorcycle,
Blue Ribbon, UT Shared
Access, intervenor dfts, to
2nd amended complaint
(hom) [Entry date 08/11/00)

Expert report of Wes Thom-
pson, P.G. filed by Anthony
Chatterly, Elite Motorcycle,
Blue Ribbon, UT Shared
Access (hom) [Entry date
08/16/00)

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

8/16/00

8/17/00

8/17/00

8/17/00

116

117

118

Transcript of Proceedings for
date(s) of 7/11/00. Court
Reporter: Kelly Hicken re:
motion for TRO held before
Judge Kimball. Volume 1
(hom) [Entry date 08/16/00)

Response by Anthony
Chatterly, Elite Motorcycle,
Blue Ribbon, UT Shared
Access to [111-1] plas’ motion
to dismiss plas’ 9th cause of
action in the 2nd amd cmp
(hom) [Entry date 08/17/00)

Motion by BLM, Tom Fry,
Bruce Babbitt to dismiss
plas’ ninth cause of action
w/prej (alt) [Entry date
08/18/00)

Memorandum by BLM, Tom
Fry, Bruce Babbitt: in oppo-
sition to [111-1] plas’ motion
to dismiss plas’ 9th cause of
action in the 2nd amd cmp; in
support of [117-1] dfts’ mo-
tion to dismiss plas’ ninth
cause of action w/prej (alt)
[Entry date 08/18/00]

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

8/21/00

Reply by All Plaintiffs to
response to [111-1] motion to
dismiss plas’ 9th cause of
action in the 2nd amd emp
(hom) [Entry date 08/22/00]

ee

Supp! Memorandum by All
Plaintiffs in support of [111-
1} plas’ motion to dismiss
plas’ 9th cause of action in
the 2nd amd cmp (hom)
[Entry date 08/24/00]

. &.e

Motion by Anthony Chat-
terly, Elite Motorcycle, Blue
Ribbon, UT Shared Access,
intervenor dfts. to dismiss
portions of plas’ 2nd amd cmp
with dismissal, first, fifth,
sixth and ninth causes of ac-
tion (hom) [Entry date
08/28/00]

Memorandum by Anthony
Chatterly, Elite Motorcycle,
Blue Ribbon, UT Shared
Access in support of [123-1]
motion to dismiss portions of

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

125

127

128

plas’ 2nd amd emp with dis-
missal, first, fifth, sixth and
ninth causes of action (hom)
[Entry date 08/28/00)

* * *

Declaration of Paui A.
Turcke (hom) [Entry date
08/28/00]

Motion by Anthony Chat-
terly, Elite Motorcycle, Blue
Ribbon, UT Shared Access in
limine limiting presentation
of evidence & argument to
the appl of plas’ Ist, 5th, &
6th causes of action to the
Parunuweap, Moquith Moun-
tain, Behind the Rocks &
Sids Mountain Wilderness
Study Areas & appl of plas’
Ist & 5th causes of action to
the Factory Buttle Special
Monitoring Area (asb) (Entry
date 08/28/00]

Memorandum by Anthony
Chatterly, Elite Motorcycle,
Blue Ribbon, UT Shared
Access in support of [127-1]

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

130

131

*

motion in limine limiting
presentation of evidence &
argument to the appl of plas’
Ist, 5th, & 6th causes of
action to the Parunuweap,
Moquith Mountain, Behind
the Rocks & Sids Mountain
Wilderness Study Areas &
appl of plas’ Ist & 5th causes
of action to the Factor Butte
‘Special Monitoring Area
(asb) [Entry date 08/28/00}

* * *

Motion by ST UT, San Juan
Cnty, Emery Cnty, Kane
Cnty, Wayne Cnty in limine
re: pla’s attempt to present
evidence & req injunctive
relief from this Court re:
public lands reinventoried for
wilderness characteristics in
1996 by Dept. of Interior
Secretary Bruce Babbitt
(asb) [Entry date 08/28/00]

Memorandum by ST UT, San
Juan Cnty, Emery Cnty,
Kane Cnty, Wayne Cnty in
support of [130-1] motion in

36

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

8/28/00

132

limine re: pla’s attempt to
present evidence & req
injunctive relief from this
Court re: public lands rein-
ventoried for wilderness
characteristics in 1996 by
Dept. of Interior Secretary
Bruce Babbitt (asb) [Entry
date 08/28/00]

Minute entry: Motion hearing
held for [130-1] motion in
limine re: pla’s attempt to
present evidence & req in-
junctive relief from this
Court re: public lands rein-
ventoried for wilderness
characteristics in 1996 by
Dept..of Interior Secretary
Bruce Babbitt, held for [127-
1] motion in limine limiting
presentation of evidence &
argument to the appl of plas
Ist, 5th, & 6th causes of
action Rocks & Sids Moun-
tain Wilderness Study Areas
& appl of plas’ Ist & 5th
causes of action to the Fac-
tory Butte Special Moni-
toring Area, held for [123-1]

37

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

motion to dismiss portions of
plas’ 2nd amd emp with
dismissal, first, fifth, sixth
and ninth causes of action,
held for [117-1] motion to dis-
miss plas’ ninth causes of
action w/prej, held for [111-
1] motion to dismiss plas’ 9th
cause of action in the 2nd
amd cmp, held for [53-1] mo-
tion to preliminary injunc-
tion; Dft St UT allowed to
intervene; pla invoked exclu-
sionary rule, dft objected;
Crt sustained the obj; pla
waived its opening stmt; dfts’
opening stmts made; testi-
mony & evidence rec’d; [111-

1] motion to dismiss plas’ 9th

cause of action in the 2nd

amd cmp taken under advise-

ment, [117-1] motion to dis-

miss plas’ ninth cause of

action w/prej taken under

advisement, [123-1] motion to

dismiss portions of plas’ 2nd
amd emp with dismissal,
first, fifth, sixth and ninth

38

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

causes of action taken under
advisement; Crt denied [127-
1] motion in limine limiting
presentation of evidence &
argument to the appl of plas’
1st, 5th & 6th causes of action
to the Parunuweap, Moquith
Mountain, Behind the Rocks
& Sids Mountain Wilderness
Study Areas & appl of plas’
Ist & 5th causes of action to
the Factory Butte Special
Monitoring Area; denied
[130-1] motion in limine re:
pla’s attempt to present evi-
dence & req injunctive relief
from this Court re: public
lands reinventoried for wild-
erness characteristics in 1996
by Dept. of Interior Secre-
tary Bruce Babbitt; Pla
rested; dfts’ case presented;
Crt recessed at 5:15 pm, to
resume 9:00 8/29/00; Judge:
DAK Court Reporter: Karen
Murakami/Laura Robinson
Court Deputy: Kim Jones (k))
[Entry 08/29/00]

39

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

8/29/00

8/30/00

Motion hearing re: [53-1]
motion for preliminary in-
junction cont w/all parties
present. Testimony &
evidence rec’d. Crt recessed
at 5:15 pm, to resume 9:00
8/30/00. Court Reporter:
Laura Robinson Court De-
puty: Kim Jones (kj) [Entry
date 08/30/00]

Motion hearing re: [53-1]
motion for preliminary in-
junction cont w/all parties
present. Testimony & evi-
dence rec’d. Dft St UT prof-
fered declaration of Kevin
Carter & testimony of other
witnesses. Proffer of St UT’s
claim as would be repre-
sented thru testimony of wit-
nesses was accepted; declara-
tion of Kevin Carter will be
filed in the morning. Dft St
UT offered exhibits 10-108;
ech were admitted. Crt re-
cessed at 5:30pm, to resume
9:00 8/31/00. Court Reporter:
Kelly Hicken Court Deputy:
Kim Jones (kj) [Entry date
8/31/00]

40)

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

8/31/00

8/31/00

8/31/00

133

134

Motion hearing re: [53-1]
motion for preliminary in-
junction Cont w/all parties
present. Mr. Andrews adv
Crt that declaration of Kevin
Carter has been filed &
distributed to Cnsl. Cnsl
reviewed doc & accepted it.
Testimony & evidence rec'd.
All parties rested. Crt
directed pla to file its 2 briefs
by 9/21/00; dft’s responses
due by 10/12/00; reply due
10/23/00. Closing arguments
heard. Crt took mot/prelim
inj under advisement. Court
Reporter: Kelly Hicken
Court Deputy: Kim Jones (kj)
[Entry date 08/31/00)

Witness and Exhibit list for
hrg on Mot/Preliminary In-
junction, 8/28/00-8/31/00. (kj)
[Entry date 08/31/00]

Declaration of Kevin S.
Carter (hom) [Entry date
09/06/00]

* * *

41

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

9/29/00

9/29/00

11/6/00

141

141

158

Reply by All Plaintiffs to
response to [111-1] motion to
dismiss plas’ 9th cause of
action in the 2nd amd emp,
[53-1] motion for preliminary
injunction (ce) [Entry date
10/02/00)

Memorandum by All Plain-
tiffs in opposition to [123-1]
motion to dismiss portions of
plas’ 2nd amd emp with
dismissal, first, fifth, sixth
and ninth causes of action,
[117-1] motion to dismiss
plas’ ninth cause of action
w/prej (ce) [Entry date
10/02/00)

* * &

Response/Memorandum by
Anthony Chatterly, Elite
Motorcycle, Blue Ribbon, UT
Shared Access to [117-1]
motion to dismiss ninth cause
of action w/prej, [111-1]
motion to [53-1] motion for
preliminary injunction (asb)
[Entry date 11/07/00]

42

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

11/6/00

11/6/00

11/6/00

159

162

163

Declaration of Forrest Sims
Re: [158-1] Response/Memo-
randum by Anthony Chat-
terly, Elite Motorcycle, Blue
Ribbon, UT Shared Access to
[117-1] motion to dismiss
ninth cause of action w/prej,
{111-1] motion to dismiss
plas’ 9th cause of action in
the 2nd amd cmp, [53-1]
motion to preliminary injunc-
tion (asb) [Entry date
11/07/00)

* * *

State’s Response by San
Juan Cnty, Emery Cnty,
Kane Cnty, Wayne Cnty to
[53-1] motion for preliminary
injunction and to SUWA’s
suppl briefing (hom) [Entry
date 11/07/00)

Response by BLM, Tom Fry,
Bruce Babbitt to [111-1] mo-
tion to dismiss plas’ 9th cause
of action in the 2nd amd cmp.
[53-1] motion for preliminary
injunction (hom) [Entry date
11/07/00]

* * *

DATE

DOCKET

NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

11/22/00

12/13/200

172

176

*

*

Suppl Briefing/Reply by All
Plaintiffs to response to [53-
1] motion for preliminary
injunction and seventh cause
of action -. Suppl NEPA
(hom) [Entry date 11/27/00)

* * «&*

Minute entry: Motion hearing
held for [123-1] motion to
dismiss portions of plas’ 2nd
amd cmp with dismissal,
first, fifth, sixth and ninth
causes of action, held for
[117-1] motion to dismiss
plas’ ninth cause of action
w/prej, held for [111-1] mo-
tion to dismiss plas’ 9th cause
of action in the 2nd amd cmp,
held for supp NEPA claim;
[123-1] motion to dismiss
portions of plas’ 2nd amd emp
dismissal, first, fifth, sixth
and ninth causes of action
taken under advisement,
[117-1] motion to dismiss
plas’ ninth cause of action
w/prej taken under advise-
ment, motion to dismiss plas’

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

12/22/00

178

9th cause of action in the 2nd
amd emp taken under ad-
visement. [53-1] motion for
preliminary injunction taken
under advisement; supp
NEPA claim taken under ad-
visement; Judge: DAK Court
Reporter: Becky Janke
Court Deputy: Kim Jones (kj)
[Entry date 12/14/00)

* * *

Memorandum Decision &
Order granting [123-1] Re-
creationists’ motion to
dismiss portions of plas’ 2nd
amd cmp with dismissal,
first, fifth, sixth and seventh
causes of action to the extent
they pertain to the WSAs
and 202 areas addressed
during the prelim injunction
hrg are DISMISSED with
prejudice. The ninth causes
of action, however, is not
dism based upon this motion.
Granting [111-1] plas’ motion
to dismiss plas’ 9th cause of

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

181

action in the 2nd amd emp,
dismissing the 9th cause of
action in the 2nd amd emp
without prejudice denying as
moot [53-1] plas’ motion for
preliminary injunction.
Mooting [117-1] BLM’s
motion to dismiss plas’ ninth
cause of action w/prejudice as
BLM has now stated that it
does not oppose dismissal w/o
prejudice signed by Judge
— A. Kimball, 12/22/00. Ce:
attys cc: atty (hom) [E

date 12/22/00} hain

* * &*

Notice of appeal by So UT
Wilderness, Wilderness So,
Sierra Club, Great Old
Broads, Wildlands CPR, UT
Council Trout, Amer Lands
Alliance, Friends of the
Abajo; Ra. Status: Paid,
receipt 109977, Appealing the
denial of plas motion for prel
inj and granting dft-
intervenors Utah Shared

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

1/18/01

1/22/01

1/23/01

1/24/01

182

183

184

Access Alliance, et al mot/
dism entered 12/22/00, memo
decision no. 178 (ce) [Entry
date 01/18/01}

Notice of appeal and certified
copy of docket to USCA:
[181-1] appeal. Appeal pack-
ets mailed to counsel of re-
cord. (ce) [Entry date
01/18/01)

Unopposed Motion by All
Plaintiffs to stay proceedings
pending 10th circuit dis-
position of pla’s appeal (hom)
[Entry date 01/23/01)

Order granting [183-1] mo-
tion to say proceedings pend-
ing 10th circuit’s disposition
of pla’s appeal signed by
Judge Dale A. Kimball, 1/23/1
ee: atty (hom) [Entry date
01/24/01)

Action STAYED. See Order
No. 184 (hom) [Entry date
01/24/01)

47

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

1/29/01

1/29/01

1/30/01

1/30/01

185

186

Transcript requested by
Stephen H.M. Bloch, ens! for
So UT Wilderness for [181-1]
appeal - the necessary
transcript is already on file in
the District Crt (ce) [Entry
date 01/29/01)

Transcript of Proceedings for
date(s) of 12/13/00. Court
Reporter: Rebeccs Janke re:
various motions heard and
preliminary injunction held
before Judge Kimball (hom)
[Entry date 01/29/01]

Record is complete for pur-
poses of appeal. Notice has
been mailed to ensl. (ce)
[Entry date 01/30/01]

Notice of Docketing Appeal
Letter from USCA Re: [181-
1] appeal USCA NUMBER:
01-4009 (ce) [Entry date
01/31/01)

48

DOCKET
DATE NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

2/7/01 187

2/9/01 188

Show Cause Order from the
Tenth Circuit Court of Ap-
peals signed by Kathleen T.
Clifford, Deputy Clerk ve
riefing on the merits
tolled sending further order
of this court. (jmo) [Entry
date 02/907/02]

Order. It is hereby Ordered

that the Clerk of the Court Is

directed, purs to rule 5A(b),

to enter judgment in favor of
the dfts and dft-intervenors
on plas’ first, fifth, sixth and
seventh claims for relief to
the extent these claims
pertain to the WSAs and 202
areas addressed during the
prelim injunction hrg signed
by Judge Dale A. Kimball,
9/9/1 ce: atty (hom) [Entry
date 02/09/01)

-——_-_ _——_ ~~ -

49

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

2/12/01

3/12/01

189

190

Judgment for Anthony
Chatterley, Elite Motorcycle,
Blue Ribbon, UT Shared
Access, BLM, Tom Fry,
Bruce Babbitt against All
Plaintiffs. Pursuant to the
order of the court of 2/9/1, the
jgm of the court in favor of
the dfts and dft-intervenors
on plas’ first, fifth, sixth and
seventh claims for relief to
the extent these claims
pertain to the WSAs and 202
Areas addressed during the
prelim injunction hrs, is
entered as final under Rule
54(b) of the Federal Rules of
Civil Procedure. Signed by
LSYork, Chief Deputy, 2/9/1,
ec: atty [EOD 2/12/01] (hom)
[Entry date 02/12/01]

Order from the Tenth Circuit
Court of Appeals by Kath-
leen T. Clifford, Deputy
Clerk Attorney 3/5/01. The
order states: The court
reserves jgm on the appellate
jurisdictional issue raised in
the show cause order. The

50

DATE

DOCKET

NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

7/10/02

8/16/02

9/12/02

206

207

*

*

jurisdictional issue along
with the district court’s
2/9/01 Order will be sub-
mitted to panel to handle this
civil appeal. The opening
brief and appendix of Plas
must be served and filed 40
days after the date of this
order. (jmo) [Entry date
03;12/01)

a

NTC of case reassignment to
Judge Paul G. Cassell. ce:
atty (alt) [Entry date
07/10/02}

Order affirming [148-1]
(b)(1)(A) referral order
signed by Judge Paul G.
Cassell, 8/16/02 ce: atty (alt)
[Entry date 08/19/02]

Transcript of Proceedings for
date(s) of 8/30/00 re: motion
hrg held before DAK. Court
Reporter: Kelly Brown
Hicken (alt) [Entry date
09/12/02] [Edit date 09/12/02]

51

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

9/12/02

2/28/03

3/3/03

4/14/03

208

209

Transcript of Proceedings for
date(s) of 8/31/00 re: motion
hrg held before DAK. Court
Reporter: Kelly Brown
Hicken (alt) [Entry date
09/12/02)

Certified copy of mandate
from USCA Re: [186-1] com-
plete appeal, [181-1] appeal
REVERSED and RE-
MANDED. According to the
USCA 10th Circuit the JGM
of the USDC for the District
of Utah is REVERSED and
the case is REMANDED for
further proceedings in accor-
dance with the opinion of this

court. (asp) [Entry date
03/03/03]

Copy of Appeal Mandate
Docket Ltr mailed to counsel
of record. (asp) [Entry date
03/03/03]

STAY lifted. Mandate from
the 10th Circuit 02/28/2003
(tl) [Entry date 04/14/2003]

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

4/15/03

5/5/03

5/19/03

5/19/03

210

211

212

213

Notice of Hearing filed: sta-
tus conference set for 3:30
5/22/03. To be held before
Judge PGC ce: atty (Nte
generated by: PGC’s crtrm
dep) (tsh) [Entry date
(04/15/03)

Order, Ptys to file status
memo by 5/19/03, status
conference set for 3:30
5/22/03 signed by Judge Paul
G. Cassell, 05/05/03 ce: atty
(tsh) [Entry date 05/06/03]

Memorandum RE:
Procedural Status filed by
Anthony Chatterly, Elite
Motorcycle, Blue Ribbon, UT
Shared Access (tsh) [Entry
date 05/20/03]

Memorandum RE: Status/
Scheduling Conference filed
by ST UT, San Juan Cnty,
Emery Cnty, Sch and
Institutional, Kane Cnty,
Wayne Cnty (tsh) [Entry
date 05/20/03 |

5

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

5/19/03

5/19/03

5/22/03

5/23/03

214

215

216

217

Status Report filed by BLM,
Tom Fry, Bruce Babbitt (tsh)
[Entry date 05/20/03]

Memorandum RE: Status
Conference filed by All

Plaintiffs (tsh) [Entry date
05/20/03 |}

Minute entry: terminated
deadlines; Judge: Paul Cas-
sell proposed scheduling or-
der discussed. Court will
enter a scheduling order re-
flecting the dates discussed.
If Cert is granted, the court
will stay the proceedings.
Court Reporter: Karen Mu-
rakami Court Deputy: Trisha
Little (tl) [Entry date
05/23/03]

Scheduling order setting:
Deadline for filing of all
motions 4/28/04; Discovery
cutoff: Fact - 1/14/04, Expert
- 4/14/04; Final Pretrial Con-
ference for 3:00 8/30/04; 5-
Day Bench Trial for 8:30
9/13/04. See file/image for
further details. Signed by

DATE

DOCKET
NUMBER

PROCEEDINGS

5/29/03

7/28/03

218

221

Judge Paul G. Cassell
05/22/03 ce: atty. (tsh) [Entry
date 05/27/03 |

Letter from US Supreme
Court Re: Notice of Petitions
for Writ of Certiorari Re:
USCA NUMBER: 02-1703
(asp) [Entry date 05/30/03)

* * *

THIRD Amended complaint
by Amer Lands Alliance, UT
Council Trout, Wildlands
CPR, Great Old Broads,
Sierra Club, Wilderness Co,
So UT Wilderness, Redrock
Forests added party(ies):
Redrock Forests. Removed
party Friends of the Abajos.
Substituted Gale Norton for
Bruce Babbitt and Kathleen
Clark for Tom Fry. Amends
[40-1] second amended com-
plaint. (tsh) [Entry date
07/29/03]

Letter from US Supreme
Court Re: Notice of Petition
for Writ of Certiorari Re:
USCA NUMBER: 03-101 (asp)
[Entry date 07/30/03]

DATE

DOCKET

NUMBER PROCEEDINGS

8/21/03

8/25/03

10/14/03

— >... ee.

224 Answer by ST UT, San Juan
Cnty, Emery Cnty, Sch and
Institutional, Kane Cnty
Wayne Cntry to THIRD
amended complaint (kam)
[Entry date 08/22/03]

225 Answer by Anthony
Chatterly, Elite Motorcycle
Blue Ribbon, UT Shared
Access to third amended

complaint (tsh) [Ent
08/27/03) (Entry date

230 Answer by BLM, Kathleen
Clarke, Gale Norton to third
amended complaint (tsh)
[Entry date 10/15/03]

56

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE
DISTRICT OF UTAH CENTRAL DIVISION

Case No. 2:99C V852K

SOUTHERN UTAH WILDERNESS
ALLIANCE, ET AL., PLAINTIFFS

US.
BRUCE BABBITT, ET AL., DEFENDANTS
AND

UTAH SHARED ACCESS ALLIANCE, ET AL.,
DEFENDANT-INTERVENORS

AND

SAN JUAN COUNTY, UTAH, ETAL.,
DEFENDANT-INTERVENORS

ORDER

After a six-day evidentiary hearing on Plaintiffs’
motions for a temporary restraining order and for a
preliminary injunction, and after a subsequent hearing
on Defendant-Intervenors Utah Shared Access Alli-
ance, et al.’s Motion to Dismiss, which pertained to the
claims that were the subject of the preliminary injunc-
tion hearing, this court, on December 22, 2000, issued a
Memorandum Decision and Order (the “December 2”
Order”). The December 22 Order, among other things,
dismissed with prejudice Plaintiffs’ First, Fifth, Six,
and Seventh Claims fer Relief to the extent they
pertain to the wilderness study areas (“WSAs”) and the
§ 202 Areas addressed during the preliminary injunc-

57

tion hearing. Consequent!
ring. y, the court also denied as
moot Plaintiffs’ Motion for a Preliminary Injunction. ;

a... court finds that there is no just reason for delay
expressly directs the entry of judgment on these

claims pursuant to Rule 54(b) of th
air e Fed
Civil Procedure (“Rule 54(b)”). ——

Accordingly, for good cause appeari
yea ORDERED that the Clerk of tho Cot te
— » pursuant to Rule 54(b), to enter judgment in
avor of Defendants and Defendant-Intervenors on
Plaintiffs First, Fifth, Six, and Seventh Claims for
Relief, to the extent these claims pertain to the WSAs
and N 202 Areas addressed during the preliminary
injunction hearing. '

DATED this 9th day of February, 2001.

BY THE COURT:

/s/
DALE A. KIMBALL
United States District Judge

58

INTERIM MANAGEMENT POLICY FOR LANDS
UNDER WILDERNESS REVIEW

U.S. Department of tue Interior
Bureau of Land Management

* * * #

INTRODUCTION

i ici der which the
is Ibook describes the policies un
ei of Land Management (BLM) will ———
under wilderness review until ee mony ay
these lands as wilderness or releases hn
0 purposes. This policy is referred to as the rs
terim” management policy (IMP) because it — .
specific areas of the public lands for a limited — - .
time, depending upon various stages and -- du aps
the review process. The purpose of the policies =
guide BLM staff in the specific decisions = —
every day in the management of lands under

review. meee
There are three categories of public lands to eyes
policy applies: (1) Wilderness Study a (W ~
identified by the wilderness review required by — =
patted tye waae wahs established by
LPMA), (2) legislative WwW .
Conemuanh and (3) WSAs identified through the land
use planning process in Section 202 of FLPMA. ne
categories together are referred to as “lands under
wilderness review.”
i i ified through
nt WSAs include those identi gh
FLPMA Sections 603 and 202 wilderness a a
stant study areas” (previously designated = -g ~
natural areas) which FLPMA also requ

59

studied, and one wilderness study area in the Central
Arctic Management Area of Alaska which was desig-
nated for study by the Alaska National Interest Lands
Conservation Act of 1980 (ANILCA). Additional WSAs
will be identified periodically through BLM’s land-use
planning process.

Future wilderness inventories of public lands ad-
ministered by the BLM in Alaska will be conducted
pursuant to Section 1320 of ANILCA. Special pro-
visions in ANILCA for the interim management of
future WSAs in Alaska will be developed at the time
wilderness inventories are allowed. Pending further
policy guidance from the Secretary of the Interior,
wilderness inventories and the identification of WSAs
subject to an IMP in Alaska under the provisions of

Sections 201 and 202 of FLPMA are not to be under-
taken.

Congressionally mandated studies lead to recom-
mendations from the Secretary of the Interior to the
President, and from the President to Congress. Those
studies conducted through BLM’s recurring land-use
planning system will lead to recommendations for each
area found to be suitable or nonsuitable for wilderness
designation. Only Congress can designate an area as
wilderness, or release from interim management areas

that were placed under wilderness study by Congres-
sional authority.

The IMP is temporary and applies only during the time
an area is under wilderness review and until

acts on WSAs, or where applicable, by a final decision
by the BLM. After Congress acts on the President’s
recommendations for each WSA, a different policy will
apply to the area, depending on whether or not
Congress designates the area as wilderness. Areas

60

designated as wilderness will be managed under BLM
Manual 8560—Management of Designated Wilderness
Areas and under the regulations at 43 CFR 8560.
Areas released from wilderness study will no longer be
subject to the IMP, and will be managed under general
BLM management policies and applicable land-use
plans.

The IMP is not the only policy that governs the
management of lands under wilderness review. The
BLM has many other laws and policies to carry out
which may affect whether and how an activity may take
place on lands under wilderness review.

Mandates from Congress

In FLPMA, Congress gave BLM its first unified,
comprehensive mandate on how the public lands should
be managed. The law established a policy of retaining
the public lands in Federal ownership, and it directed
the BLM to manage them under principles of multiple
use and sustained yield. Management decisions for the
public lands are made through land-use planning pro-
cesses that consider all potential uses of each land area,
including wilderness. All public lands are to be
managed so as to prevent unnecessary or undue degra-
dation of the lands as required by Section 302(b) of
FLPMA.

Under FLPMA, wilderness preservation is part of
BLM’s multiple-use mandate, and wilderness values are
recognized as part of the spectrum of resource values
considered in the land-use planning process. Section
603 of FLPMA specifically directed the BLM, for the
first time, to carry out a wilderness review of the public
lands. Continued evaluation of lands as wilderness can
be considered in the future under Section 202 of

™ — en

61

FLPMA. (The complete text of Section 603 appears in
Appendix A of this document.) “if

Section 603(c) of FLPMA tells the BLM how to manage
lands under wilderness review, in these words:

During the period of review of such areas and until
Congress has determined otherwise, the Secretary
shall continue to manage such lands according to his
authority under this Act and other applicable law in
a manner so as not to impair the suitability of such

areas for preservation as wilderness . . . hasi
: (emphasis

This ~~ ee is referred to as the “nonimpairment”

The wilderness review uired by Section 603 o
FLPMA focused on neal areas of 5,000 acres >
more and on roadless islands. The BLM as a matter of
policy used its general management authority under
Sections 302 and 202 of FLPMA to include in the
wilderness review certain other roadless areas. These
included: (1) areas smaller than 5,000 acres that were
not islands, (2) areas less than 5,000 acres that had
wilderness characteristics in association with contigu-
ous roadless lands managed by another agency, and
(3) lands place under BLM administration after the
wilderness inventory was conducted in 1978-80. The
management mandate in Section 603(c) does not apply
to roadless areas being studied under Section 202 of
FLPMA. However, as a matter of policy, the BLM will
use its management authority under Section 302 of
FLPMA to apply a modified form of interim

ment to these areas, as is explained in Chapter I.A.5.

62

There are six different practical effects of provisions in
FLPMA with respect to “interim management” of lands
under wilderness review:

1. The general standard for interim management is
that lands under wilderness review must be
managed so as not to impair their suitability for
preservation as wilderness. We will refer to this
as the “nonimpairment” standard. This applies to
all uses and activities except those specifically
exempted from this standard by FLPMA (such as
grandfathered uses).

2. Permitted activities in WSAs (except grand-
fathered and valid existing rights) are temporary
uses that create no new surface disturbance, nor
involve permanent placement of structures.

3. Those grazing, mining, and mineral leasing uses
that existed on October 21, 1976, (the date
FLPMA was approved) may continue in the same
manner and degree as on that date, even if this
would impair wilderness suitability.

4. Lands under wilderness review may not be closed
to appropriation under the mining laws in order
to preserve their wilderness character.

5. Valid existing rights must be recognized.
6. All lands must be managed to prevent un-
necessary or undue degradation.
Meaning of the Congressional Mandate of
Nonimnai }

To determine what is permissible under the general
“nonimpairment” standard, we must examine what
Congress meant by impairment of an area’s suitability
for preservation as wilderness.

TT

63

The term “suitability . . . for preservation as wild-
erness” originated in the Wilderness Act of 1964, which
directs the Secretary of Agriculture to “review, as to its
suitability or nonsuitability for preservation as wild-
erness” each of the national forest areas classified as
“primitive.”

Likewise, the Wilderness Act directs the Secretary of
the Interior to review certain roadless areas and islands
in the National Park System and in the national wildlife
refuges and game ranges and “report to the President
his recommendation as to the suitability or nonsuitabil-
ity of each such area or island for preservation as
wilderness.” The term is similarly used in Section
603(a) of FLPMA, which directs the Secretary of the
Interior to review certain roadless areas and islands
and to “report to the President his recommendation as
to the suitability or nonsuitability of each such area or

island for preservation as wilderness.” (Emphasis
added.)

In the Wilderness Act and FLPMA, the term “suit-
ability” implies two things. First, it implies that, at the
minimum, the area satisfies the definition of wilderness
in Section 2(c) of the Wilderness Act:

“A wilderness, in contrast with those areas where
man and his own works dominate the landscape, is
hereby recognized as an area where the earth and
its community of life are untrammeled by man,
where man himself is a visitor who does not remain.
An area of wilderness is further defined to mean in
this Act an area of undeveloped Federal land re-
taining its primeval character and influence, without
permanent improvements or human habitation,
which (1) generally appears to have been affected

64

primarily by the forces of nature, with the imprint of
man’s work substantially unnoticeable; (2) has out-
standing opportunities for solitude or a primitive
and unconfined type of recreation; (3) has at least
five thousand acres of land or is of sufficient size as
to make practicable its preservation and use in an
unimpaired condition; and (4) may also contain
ecological, geological, or other features of scientific,
educational, scenic, or historical value.”

The Department therefore has a responsibility under
the nonimpairment standard to ensure that each WSA
satisfies this definition at the time Congress makes a
decision on the area. As a practical matter, this means
that once identified as a WSA the area must meet this
definition until designated as wilderness or released for
other uses.

The word “suitability” takes on a second meaning in the
context of recommendations made by the Secretary and
the President to Congress. Congress made it clear in
Section 603 of FLPMA that an area with all the neces-
sary wilderness characteristics as defined in Section
2(c) of the Wilderness Act might be found by the
Secretary to be either “suitable” or “nonsuitable” for
preservation as wilderness. Since each WSA must have
wilderness characteristics in order to qualify for wild-
erness study under the mandate of FLPMA, it seems
clear that the Secretary must protect the wilderness
values of each WSA until Congress makes the final
decision regardless of the suitable/nonsuitable recom-
mendation made.

The Department therefore has a responsibility to
ensure that the existing wilderness values of all WSAs,
whether studied pursuant to Section 603 of FLPMA or
future suitable WSAs identified through BLM’s land-

65

use planning system, are not degraded so far, compared
with the area’s values for other purposes, as to signifi-
cantly constrain the Congress’s prerogative to either
designate a WSA as wilderness or release it for other
uses.

Any conflicts with this Congressional mandate would
constitute impairment of the area’s suitability for
preservation as wilderness.

M on Minatemeal Standard
Management to the nonimpairment standard does not
mean that the lands will be managed as though they has
already been designated as wilderness. For example,
some uses that could not take place in a designated
wilderness area may be permitted under the IMP
because they are only temporary uses that do not
create surface disturbance or involve permanent place-
ment of structures. For example, organized off-road
vehicle events or organized contests such as competi-
tive trial rides and endurance/survival exercises that
meet the nonimpairment criteria, might be permitted in
WSAs, but would not be allowed in designated wild-
erness. Such temporary uses may be allowed if such
use gan easily and immediately be terminated upon
designation of the lands involved as wilderness.

For the WSAs identified under the requirements of
Section 603 of FLPMA, certain activities were allowed
during the inventory and study phases if their impacts
could be reclaimed by the time the Secretary forwarded
recommendations to the President. This reclamation
opportunity ended in September 1992 for all WSAs
recommended under the requirements of Section 603.
This is the date upon which the Secretary sent these
final recommendations to the President. Generally, all

66

activities (except as listed under “Exceptions” in Sec-
tion I.B.2., such as grandfathered and valid existing
rights) permitted in WSAs after a reclamation deadline
has passed, must be temporary uses that create no
surface disturbance, nor involve permanent placement
of structures.

Some uses that were explicitly permitted by the Wild-
erness Act of 1964 in wilderness areas of the national
forests (such as mining and mineral leasing, which were
allowed to continue until December 31, 1983) have been
restricted under the IMP because their impacts clearly
would have disqualified the area from satisfying the
wilderness definition, and thus would have impaired
wilderness suitability. During the wilderness review,
and until Congress acts, it is the later and more explicit
FLPMA, and not the Wilderness Act of 1964, that
dictates what is permissible.

The final decision on permanent wilderness designation
for each WSA recommendation forwarded by the
Secretary, belongs to Congress. Management under
the nonimpairment standard protects Congress’ pre-
rogative to make the designation decision by prevent-
ing actions that would pre-empt that decision.

* cad * *

CHAPTERI. MANAGEMENT POLICY FOR LANDS
UNDER WILDERNESS REVIEW

GENERAL POLICY

1. The BLM’s management policy is to continue
resource uses on lands under wilderness review
in a manner that maintains the area’s suitability
for preservation as wilderness. The IMP will
remain in effect on all congressionally mandated
WSAs until Congress acts on the Secretary’s

67

recommendations. Areas identified as WSAs
under Section 202 of FLPMA will receive interim
management protection upon designation as a
WSA. Those WSAs studied under Section 202 of
FLPMA and subsequently found to be non-
suitable for wilderness designation may be re-
leased from interim management by the BLM
State Director 30 days after approval of the land-
use plan. Suitable WSAs studied under Section
202 of FLPMA will be studied using the Bureau’s
procedures for such areas, remaining under IMP
protection until Congress acts. In the interest of
consistency with related land-use plans, the State
Director also has the option of keeping such areas
in wilderness study status, and under interim
management, until final decisions have been made
on adjacent areas under wilderness review.

. The law provides for, and the BLM’s policy is to

allow, continuation of grazing, mining, and min-
eral leasing uses on lands under wilderness
review in the manner and degree in which these
uses being conducted on October 21, 1976, as long
as they do not cause unnecessary or undue de-
gradation of the lands These are referred to as
the “grandfathered” uses.

3. The BLM’s policy is to allow appropriate under

the mining laws; i.e., these areas, in accordance
with the congressional mandate, will not be with-
drawn from the operation of the mining laws for
the purpose of preserving their wilderness char-
acter. Activities involved in appropriation under
the mining laws after October 21, 1976,—
including location of new claims and the assess-
ment work necessary to hold claims—will be

68

allowed as long as these activities are carried out
in a manner that does not impair the area’s
wilderness suitability.

4. The BLM’s policy is to recognize valid existing

rights that existed on October 21, 1976. A further
explanation of the policy on valid existing rights
appears in Section B.9., below.

5. If a WSA is being studied under Section 202 of

FLPMA, existing and new mining operations un-
der the 1872 Mining Law will be regulated under
the regulations 43 CFR 3802 only to prevent
unnecessary of undue degradation of the lands,
not to prevent impairment of wilderness suitabil-
ity. All other activities will be managed under
the IMP. Although FLPMA does not require
Section 202 WSAs to be given interim manage-
ment protection, the Bureau has the authority
under Section 302 of FLPMA to manage these
lands similarly. The authority to regulate activi-
ties to the nonimpairment standard with respect
to the mining laws only applies to the areas that
meet the criteria of Section 603, either islands or
roadless areas of 5,000 acres or more that have
wilderness characteristics. Section 302 provides
the authority to regulate mining on all public
lands to prevent unnecessary or undue degrada-
tion.

. State Directors will assure a level of monitoring
and surveillance of each WSA adequate to pre-
vent, detect, and mitigate unauthorized activities
and to properly supervise authorized uses and
facilities. The level of monitoring and surveil-
lance will reflect the level of ongoing or antici-
pated activities within each WSA.

69

7. BLM will take all actions necessary to ensure full
compliance with the IMP. Every effort will be
made to obtain voluntary compliance with the
IMP by public land users. Where such efforts fail,
BLM will promptly initiate additional appropriate
action to achieve immediate compliance with the
IMP. Violations will not be tolerated.

8. The BLM’s policy is to attempt to immediately
reclaim the impacts caused by any unauthorized
action to a level as close as possible to the original
condition, or at least to a condition that is sub-
stantially unnoticeable.

SPECIFIC POLICY GUIDANCE

This section describes how the BLM will apply the
general policies set forth in Section A, above.

An overriding consideration before applying any of the
policies below must be that the preservation of wild-
erness values within a WSA is paramount and should
be the primary consideration when evaluating any
proposed action or use that may conflict with or be
adverse to those wilderness values. The concept of
considering wilderness values first asserts, with few
exceptions (e.g., valid existing rights, grandfathered
rights, etc.), that wilderness resource management
objectives within a WSA should take precedence over
all other resource management program objectives. In
other words, the wilderness resource will be dominant
in all management decisions where a choice must be
made between preservation of wilderness suitability
and other competing uses.

Ideally, a decision to construct facilities within a WSA
should be deferred until such time as Congress either
designates the WSA as wilderness or releases it for

70

other purposes. Ifa facility must be constructed within
a given geographic area, it would be in the best interest
for protecting wilderness values to construct the
facility outside the WSA. Other alternatives should
always be considered before deciding to allow a use or
activity within a WSA.

1. Lands Under Wilderness Review. The BLM con-
ducted a wilderness inventory under procedures
described in the Wilderness Inventory Handbook,
issued by BLM on September 27, 1978 (Organic
Act Directive No. 78-61). The inventory sorted
lands into two categories: (a) WSAs, to which the
IMP applies, and (b) lands determined not to have
wilderness characteristics and not subject to the
IMP. A complete study was conducted on all the
identified WSAs and suitable/nonsuitable wilder-
ness recommendations submitted by the Secre-
tary to the President by January 1993. All of
these WSAs remain under the IMP (except as
noted in A.5 above) until a final decision is made
by Congress. Lands being reviewed for wilder-
ness values in future planning efforts are subject
to the IMP once identified as a WSA and remain
under IMP until either released by the State
Director as nonsuitable or until a final decision is
made by the Congress on the land’s wilderness
status. |

2. Nonimpairment. BLM will review all proposals
for uses and/or facilities within WSAs to deter-
mine whether the proposal meets the criteria
below. Uses and/or facilities found to be nonim-
pairing may be permitted on lands under wilder-
ness review. Uses and/or facilities found to be
impairing will be denied.

71

The following criteria are referred to hereafter as the
“nonimpairment criteria”.

a. The use, facility, or activity must temporary.
This means a temporary use that does not
create surface disturbance or involve perma-
nent placement of facilities may be allowed if
such use can easily and immediately be ter-
minated upon wilderness designation. “Tem-
porary” means the use or facility may con-
tinue until the date the facility must be re-
moved. “Surface disturbance” is any new dis-
ruption of the soil or vegetation, including
vegetative trampling, which would necessi-
tate reclamation. The term “surface distur-
bance” is discussed further in Specific Policy
Guidance, Section 3 below. Decisions to allow
or deny proposed actions based on the non-
impairment criteria will be included in
appropriate decision documents.

b. When the use, activity, or facility is ter-
minated, the wilderness values must not have
been degraded so far as to significantly con-
strain the Congress’s prerogative regarding
the area’s suitability for preservation as wild-
erness. The wilderness values to be consid-
ered are those mentioned in Section 2(c) of
the Wilderness Act of 1964 (see Introduction,
and/or Appendix B).

The only permitted exceptions to the above rules are:

(1) Emergencies such as suppression activities
associated with wildfire or search and rescue
operations;

72

(2) Reclamation activities designed to minimize
impacts to wilderness values created by IMP
violations and emergencies;

(3) Uses and facilities which are considered
grandfathered or valid existing rights under
the IMP;

(4) Uses and facilities that clearly protect or en-
hance the land’s wilderness values or that are
the minimum necessary for public health and
safety in the use and enjoyment of the wild-
erness values; and,

(5) Reclamation of pre-F LPMA impacts.

Surface Disturbance. Surface disturbance is any
new disruption of the soil or vegetation requiring
reclamation within a WSA. Uses and facilities
necessitating reclamation (i.e., recontouring of
the topography, replacement of topsoil, and/or
restoration of native plant cover) are definitely
surface disturbing and must be denied. Cross-
country vehicle use off boundary roads and
existing ways is surface disturbing because the
tracks created by the vehicle leave depressions
or ruts, compact the soils, and trample or com-
press vegetation. Certain activities recognized as
acceptable within a WSA, such as recreational
hiking, use of pack stock, or domestic livestock
grazing, are allowable within a WSA although in
the strictest sense, they cause surface dis-
turbance.

Supporting Activities. Some activities that in
themselves are nonimpairing may require sup-
porting facilities or activities that could impair
wilderness suitability. (For example: A boat

—

VE.

73

launching ramp and associated parking as sup-
porting facilities for boating, or the cross-
country use of motor vehicles to retrieve sail-
planes or hang gliders.) When this is the case,
the supporting activity will be limited as nec-
essary to meet the nonimpairment criteria. If
the supporting activity cannot be done in a non-
impairing manner, then the principal activity will
not be approved.

Cumulative Impacts. It is recognized that many
minor impacts of nonimpairing uses or facilities
could accumulate to a point at which the total
impact would impair wilderness suitability either
by creating impacts that overall are noticeable,
or by degrading the area’s wilderness values so
far as to significantly constrain Congress’s pre-
rogative regarding the area’s suitability for
preservation as wilderness.

To prevent such cumulative impacts of ongoing
uses from impairing wilderness suitability, the
BLM will analyze and monitor the cumulative
impacts. If impacts are becoming so great that
the area’s wilderness suitability could be im-
paired, the BLM will take steps to control those
impacts by adjusting the conditions of use (such
as time, place, and quantity), by prohibiting the
expansion of the use, or by prohibiting the use
altogether.

Every new proposal for uses or facilities, al-
though individually it may be nonimpairing, will
be analyzed in all required documents (i.e.,
National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)
documents, etc.) for cumulative effects. If the
proposal will create an unacceptable additional

74

increment of impact (as described in the first
paragraph of this section above), it will not be
approved.

Enhancing Wilderness Values. Wilderness
values were identified in Section 2(c) of the
Wilderness Act of 1964. The BLM Wilderness
Inventory Handbook (Organic Act Directive No.
78-61, dated 9/19/78) further defined wilderness
values as: roadlessness, naturalness, solitude,
primitive and unconfined recreation, size, and
supplemental values. Actions that clearly bene-
fit a WSA’s wilderness values through activities
that restore, protect, or maintain these values
are allowable. Though they may enhance wild-
erness values, these allowable actions must still
be carried out in a manner which is least dis-
turbing to the site.

In order to determine whether a proposed action
enhances wilderness values within a given WSA,
one must refer to the original wilderness inven-
tory for baseline or benchmark data concerning
the particular wilderness value(s) being affected.
During the wilderness inventory, the Bureau
described in detail the state or condition of each
wilderness value or characteristic. If the pro-
posed action would result in a positive or bene-
ficial change in the state or condition of the wild-
erness value(s) as described, assessed, or calcu-
lated on the date of approval of the intensive
inventory, then the wilderness value would be
enhanced by the proposed action. Conversely, if
the proposed action would result in a negative or
detrimental change in the state or condition of
the wilderness value(s) then that wilderness

75

value would be degraded or impacted and the
proposed action must not be allowed.

To illustrate this concept, the following examples
are provided:

A mile-long drift fence is proposed in a particular
WSA for the purpose of keeping livestock from
entering an adjacent allotment. Because the
fence did not exist at the time of the intensive
wilderness inventory, it would result in a detri-
mental change in the baseline condition, thereby
negatively impacting the wilderness value of °
“naturalness” and impairing the visitor’s percep-
tion of the naturalness of the area. Conse-
quently, the drift fence proposal must be denied
because in this case wilderness values are not
enhanced.

Conversely, if the fence is intended to correct or
mitigate a situation which is degrading wilder-
ness values identified in the intensive inventory,
the fence construction project may be allowed.
For example, domestic livestock and wild horses
are altering a hot springs complex, a unique
special feature of a WSA, by damaging riparian
vegetation, harming an unusual aquatic commu-
nity, and degrading water cuality. Special con-
sideration to design and location of an enclosure
fence would be required to reduce impacts to
scenic qualities. Any negative impacts to wilder-
ness values created by this fence would be
clearly offset by the positive benefits of protect-
ing in a more natural condition a special feature
of the wilderness resource.

76

There may be some circumstances that warrant
a few permanent short gap fences or very small
enclosures around springs as long as the benefits
to wilderness values of having these structures
clearly outweigh any negative impacts to natu-
ralness or primitive recreation opportunities.

A guzzler is proposed within a certain WSA for
the purpose of providing water to a resident
population of bighorn sheep. It is clear the
guzzler will negatively impact the wilderness
value of “naturalness” because the guzzler did
not exist at the time of the intensive inventory.
If the guzzler is approved for construction within
the WSA, the quality of “naturalness” is dimin-
ished as the immediate area becomes more
affected by the forces of man rather than the
forces of nature. The imprint of man’s work
becomes increasingly more noticeable and the
WSA loses some of its primeval character. In
essence, the WSA is no longer an area where the
earth and its community of life are untrammeled
(unimpeded or unhindered) by man and his
activities. Unless specific circumstances and
conditions in Chapter III apply, the guzzler must
be denied.

We must ensure, therefore, in our consideration of
any proposal to construct a guzzler or any other
facility within a WSA, that the guzzler or other
facility will not degrade the very wilderness values
that initially qualified the area for designation as a
WSA. While the proximity of bighorn sheep within
a WSA enhances the wilderness experience, the
existence of a guzzler within

77

Consequently, districts must make certain that the
facilities or use associated with the supplemental
values of ecological, geological, or other features of
scientific, educational, scenic, or historical value,
which normally add to the primary wilderness
values of roadlessness, naturalness, solitude, primi-
tive and unconfined recreation, and size, do not
degrade these very values that initially qualified the
area for designation as a WSA.

Section 603(c) of FLPMA states, “During the period
of review of such areas and until Congress has
determined otherwise, the Secretary shall continue
to manage such lands according to his authority
under this Act and other applicable law in a manner
so as not to impair the suitability of such areas for
preservation as wilderness.” In other words, the
WSA’s wilderness values must not have been de-
graded so as to constrain or pre-empt Congressional
designation authority.

7. Existing Facilities. Some lands under wilder-
ness review may contain minor facilities that
were found in the wilderness inventory process
to be substantially unnoticeable. For example,
these may include primitive vehicle routes
(“ways”) and livestock developments. There is
nothing in this IMP that requires such facilities
to be removed or discontinued. On the contrary,
they may be used and maintained as before, as
long as this does not cause new impacts that
would impair the area’s wilderness suitability.

8. “Grandfathered” Uses.

a. General. Grazing, mining, and mineral leas-
ing uses that existed on the date of approval

-

(oa

of FLPMA (October 21, 1976) may continue
on lands under wilderness review in the same
manner and degree as on that date, even if
this impairs wilderness suitability. These are
the “grandfathered” uses, protected by the
“manner and degree” clause of Section 603(c)
of FLPMA. These uses must be regulated to
ensure that they do not cause unnecessary or
undue degradation of the lands.

Although activities on mining claims on which
a valid mineral discovery was made prior to
October 21, 1976, may qualify as “grand-
fathered” uses, these claims qualify for a
more liberal development standard under the
policy for valid existing rights (see Section
B.9, below).

Criteria. To be an “existing” use, the use
clearly must have been taking place on the
lands as of the date of approval of FLPMA
(October 21, 1976). A “grandfathered” min-
eral use must have created actual physical
impacts before that date. Existing grazing
must have been authorized as of October 21,
1976. However, new grazing (e.g., change in
numbers, kind, or class of livestock, or season
of use), expanding the area authorized for
grazing, or new facilities are not “grand-
fathered”.

If a “grandfathered” use is acquired by a
different owner, the new owner may continue
the “grandfathered” use in the same place. A
“orandfathered” use is not an absolute right
or privilege that can be uprooted from one
land area and applied to a different land area;

ee ee

—_—_——— —-

79

it is based on the place where it was being
conducted as of October 21, 1976.

The benchmark for the “manner and degree”
of an existing use is the physical and visual
impact that use was having on the area or
impacts that occurred on October 21, 1976,
because it is that impact that would have
affected the wilderness review.

* * * *

10. Appropriation Under the Mining Laws. A

11.

mandate in Section 603(c) of FLPMA, that lands
under wilderness review continue to be subject
to appropriation under the mining laws, is a
prohibition against withdrawal of lands under
wilderness review from appropriation under the
mining laws for the sole purpose of preserving
the land’s wilderness character. Lands under
wilderness review will therefore remain open to
appropriation under the 1872 Mining Law ex-
cept: (a) lands that had been withdrawn from
appropriation prior to the date of approval of
FLPMA (October 21, 1976), and (b) lands with-
drawn after October 21, 1976, for reasons other
than preservation of their wilderness character.

Motor Vehicles, Aircraft and Mechanical
Transport. Motor vehicles and mechanical
transport may be allowed off boundary roads
and existing ways for these purposes only:

a. in emergencies and search and rescue opera-

tions (as described in Section 12, below);

b. for official purposes by the BLM and other

Federal, State, and local agencies and their
agents when necessary and specifically

80

authorized by the BLM for protection of hu-
man life, safety, and property; for protection
of the lands and their resources; and,

. to build or maintain structures and installa-

tions authorized in this document, as long as
such use of vehicles is determined to satisfy
the nonimpairment criteria and is only along
routes authorized and specified by the BLM.
No grading, blading, or vegetative distur-
bance will be permitted as this would con-
stitute surface disturbance and thus not meet
the nonimpairment criteria.

In emergencies, cross-country travel will not
be held to the nonimpairment standard; but
in all other cases, cross-country travel is al-
lowed only where it is specifically authorized
by BLM and it satisfies the nonimpairment
criteria. If impacts threaten to impair the
area’s wilderness suitability, the BLM may
limit or close the affected lands to the uses
causing the problem.

Mechanical transport, including all motorized
devices as well as trail and mountain bikes,
may only be allowed on existing ways and
within “open” areas that were designated
prior to the passage of FLPMA (October 21,
1976). Use of such devices off existing ways
and trails are allowed only for the purposes
listed in the paragraph above.

Helicopters may land on existing heliports,
helispots, and on unimproved sites as long as
the nonimpairement criteria is satisfied.
Fixed-wing aircraft may land only on existing

we =a -—

12.

13.

81

airstrips or established vehicle ways as long
as the nonimpairment criteria is satisfied. No
new landing facilities may be built. In the
case of an emergency, see Section 12 below.

Examples of aircraft landings that first must
meet the nonimpairment criteria and be ap-
proved by the BLM, include informational
gathering, surveys, surveillance or monitor-
ing, placement or maintenance of projects,
animal damage control, access, or transport.
Examples of aircraft landings for emergency
situations include search and rescue, law

enforcement and fire suppression (refer to
Section 12 below).

Emergencies. In emergencies such as fire or
flood, any action necessary to prevent loss of life
or property may be taken, even if the action will
impair wilderness suitability. This may include
search and rescue operations in cases of lost or
injured persons, or removal of the deceased.
Emergency actions will be conducted in the
manner that least impairs wilderness suitabil-
ity, and the resulting impacts will be reclaimed
as soon as possible after the situation has ended.
Within 7 days after the emergency action is
completed, a record of the circumstances and
the action taken will be placed in the WSA case
file and a public notification will be mailed to all
interested parties.

Maintenance. Existing facilities may be
maintained to keep them in an effective, usable
condition. Maintenance will not be allowed to
modify a structure or installation to a condition
that would impair the area’s suitability for

14.

82

wilderness designation. Measures required to
carry out maintenance work will be allowed if
these measures do not in themselves impair
wilderness suitability. Maintenance of “grand-
fathered” livestock developments will be per-
mitted to insure that the usefulness of the pro-
ject for its intended purposes may be realized,
but will not be allowed to modify a facility to
exceed the physical and visual impacts existing
on October 21, 1976. Modifications exceeding
this standard will be evaluated under the non-
impairment standard. Maintenance of a facility
that qualifies as a VER should also be held to
the nonimpairment standard, unless that would
unreasonably interfere with the rights granted
under the VER.

Air Quality. Under the Clean Air Act (as
amended, 1977), all BLM-administered lands
were given Class II air quality classification,
which allows moderate deterioration associated
with moderate, well-controlled industrial and
population growth. The BLM will continue to
manage WSAs as Class II.

The Department of the Interior will not recom-
mend reclassification to the more strict Class I
in connection with future wilderness recommen-
dations resulting from the BLM wilderness
review. The two processes are separate and
distinct, and are accomplished under two differ-
ent laws, FLPMA and the Clean Air Act. Rec-
ommendations for wilderness designation are
made by the BLM through the Secretary of the
Interior and the President to Congress. Air
quality reclassification is the prerogative of the

ee ae

15.

16.

83

States, and it must follow a process mandated
by the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1977, in-
volving a study of health, environmental, eco-
nomic, social, and energy effects, a public hear-
ing, and a report to the Environmental Protec-
tion Agency. The Department will not recom-
mend any change in air quality classification as
part of wilderness recommendations.

Pre-F LPMA Management. Some lands under
wilderness review, particularly among the in-
stant study areas, were subject to more strict
protection prior to approval of FLPMA than the
IMP requires. For instance, some areas were
withdrawn from mineral entry. In these cases,
any use will be controlled by the more strict
protection of the wilderness resource, regard-
less of whether that is provided by the IMP or
by a pre-FLPMA withdrawal or regulation that
is still in effect.

New Discretionary Uses. To foster efficient
wilderness management, it is BLM’s policy to
minimize the establishment of new discretion-
ary uses in WSAs that would be incompatible
with possible wilderness designation, even
when the uses would not in themselves exceed
the nonimpairment standard. Some new uses,
within or adjacent to WSAs, may create con-
flicts with management and preservation of
wilderness values at a later time. Consideration
should be give to the possible effect these uses
may have on managing the WSAs as wilderness
in the future. For example, the construction of
a campground facility adjacent toa WSA would
seem to have the potential to create conflicts

17.

18.

84

with management and preservation of wilder-
ness values at a later time. Another example
might be opening up a river or other body of
water in a WSA to motorboat use. New uses, if
authorized, must be temporary.

Substantially Unnoticeable. Substantially un-
noticeable means that an action must be so
insignificant as to be only a very minor feature
or is not distinctively recognizable by the aver-
age visitor as being human made or human-
caused because of age, weathering or biological
change. The Bureau’s visual contrast rating
process (BLM Manual Section 8431, and the
Contrast Rating Worksheet, Form 8400-4) may
be used as an aid in determining whether the
impacts of a proposed action are substantially
unnoticeable. Other analysis that could be used,
include a viewshed or seen-area analysis and
the use of ground and aerial photographs. In all
cases a written narrative analyzing the poten-
tial visual impacts, both individually and cumu-
latively, must be provided.

Minimum Tool Concept. The “minimum tool”
concept relates to the management of desig-
nated wilderness areas, but the concept can be
useful as a guide when applied to the interim
management of WSAs. Under the “minimum
tool” concept, managers should scrutinize every
proposed action to determine if the action is
necessary to protect the physical, biological, and
cultural resources, as well as the quality of the
wilderness experience. If the planned action is
deemed necessary, it would be accomplished
using methods and equipment that have the

ee he ee —

85

least impact on the quality of an individual or
group’s wilderness experience, as well as the
physical, biological, and cultural resources with-
in the WSA. In a WSA, how one carries out
management actions is as important as the end
product.

For example, if a decision is made to develop a
water source for bighorn sheep within a WSA
because this would enhance wilderness values,
and the preference is for construction of a
bighorn sheep guzzler, management should first
consider and analyze other “minimum tool”
alternatives that would accomplish the same
management objectives with less degradation to
wilderness values. Some possible minimum tool
options in this example might include:

a. Restoration of existing springs and seeps
that have been altered by domestic livestock
grazing or wild horses and burros;

b. Removal of domestic livestock or wild horses

and burros from water sources frequented by
bighorn sheep;

c. Designing a very short, substantially unno-

ticeable fence that would segregate bighorn
sheep from livestock and wild horses and
burros in order that all may share the same
water source;

d. Elimination of salt cedar infestations that

may have reduced or eliminated the above-
ground flow of water available to bighorn
sheep;

e. Constructing one or more small slick rock,

concrete and rock catchments or dams; and,

86

f. Upgrading of potholes for greater water-
holding capacity by utilizing native stone and
tinted concrete.

19. Hazardous Materials. No hazardous wastes,
substances, or materials (see Glossary for com-
plete definitions) may be sued, stored, or dis-
posed of in WSAs. In emergency situations
(e.g. the cleanup of unauthorized dumping of
hazardous materials), any action necessary to
protect visitor health and safety and to protect
and natural environment may be taken, even if
the action will temporarily impair wilderness
suitability. Emergency control and cleanup
activities will be conducted in accordance with
all pertinent laws and regulations, NEPA re-
quirements, and in the manner that least
impairs wilderness suitability. Impacts result-
ing from hazardous materials cleanup will be
reclaimed as soon as possible after disposal
and/or cleanup operations have ended. Public
notification procedures will be followed for all
hazardous materials operations in WSAs.

CHAPTERII IMPLEMENTATION OF THE
INTERIM MANAGMENT POLICY

A. USES OR FACILITIES SUBJECT TO THE IMP

To determine whether a proposed use or facility is
subject to the IMP, the following question must be
considered regarding the affected lands: Does the use
or facility involve public lands identified by the BLM as
a WSA? If so, the IMP will apply. Proceed with the
evaluation described in Section B, below. If the above
criteria does not apply, then the use or facility is not
subject to the IMP.

87

B. PROCEDURES FOR EVALUATION OF PROPO
ACTIONS _

1. Step 1 - Review the Definition of Wilderness.
Before beginning any evaluation of a pro-
posed action within a WSA, review the pri-
mary mandates and definitions of wilderness
in Section 2 of the Wilderness Act of 1964.
There are some key phrases in the definition
that will assist in understanding the intent of -
Congress that guide the IMP:

— an area where the earth and its com-
munity of life are untrammeled by man,
where man himself is a visitor who does
not remain. (Note: “untrammeled” means
unconfined, unrestrained, or unimpeded.)

— an area of undeveloped Federal land re-
taining its primeval character and influ-
ence, without permanent improvements
or human habitation.

— protected and managed so as to preserve
its natural conditions.

_ generally appears to have been affected
primarily by the forces of nature, with
the imprints of man’s work substantially
unnoticeable.

2. Step 2 —- Consider Exceptions and Limita-
tions to the Nonimpairment Standard. Con-
sider whether the proposal is covered by one
of the exceptions or limitations to the
“nonimpairment” standard:

a. Does the proposal qualify as a “grand-

fathered” mineral or uae use continu-

88

ing in the same manner and degree as on
October 21, 19762 New proposed range
developments, for example, are not grand-
fathered. (Consult the applicable policies
in Chapter I.B.8 and Chapter III.B and
D.) If so, the proposal will probably be
considered acceptable under the IMP
subject to regulation ensuring that the
use or facility does not cause unnecessary
or undue degradation. In many grand-
fathered developments that predate the
NEPA, no environmental documentation
exists. Some mitigation to impacts on
wilderness values may be identified dur-
ing the environmental assessment pro-
cess.

. Is the proposal part of the development of
a valid existing right (such as a valid
mining claim, mineral lease, or right-of-
way authorization in effect as of October
21, 1976)? If so, proceed under the appli-
cable policies in Chapter I.B.9, ITI.A.2 and
4, and III.B. The right will be recognized
but it is not absolute. The scope of a valid
existing right depends on any conditions,
stipulations, or limitations stated in the
law or approval document that created
the right. -

. In a WSA that is being studied under
Section 202 of FLPMA, is the proposal a
mining activity under the 1872 Mining
Law? If so, the activity will be regulated
under 43 CFR 3802 to prevent unneces-

—- -— + -_

89

sary or undue degradation of the lands
but not the nonimpairment criteria.

The determination that a proposal is not
subject to the nonimpairment standard
will be documented and recorded in ap-
propriate case files and/or included in any
decision documents and authorizations.

3. Step 3 - Notify the Public.
a. All offices must notify interested parties

of proposed actions on land within their
jurisdiction that are managed under the
IMP before such actions can be approved.
If appropriate, such notifications should
be sent directly to the interested parties.
Use of the Federal Register or the “legal
notices” section of newspapers is
permissible, but such formally published
notices by themselves are not enough.

. Proposed actions on lands subject to the

IMP requiring notification procedure
include but are not limited to:

— requests for approval of mining plans
of operations under 43 CFR 3802;

— gathering information about mineral
resources in accordance with 43 CFR
8560.4-5(b);

— applications for permit to drill;

— notices of intent to conduct oil and
gas exploration operations on exist-
ing leases;

90

— proposed changes in livestock use,
including changes in numbers, season
of use, or kinds or classes of live-
stock; and,

— BLM-initiated projects, including
implementation of decisions con-
tained in land use and activity plans.

— Public initiated projects such as
issuance of a filming permit.

It is not necessary to send notices on
extensions of existing mineral leases.

. Provide notice at least 30 days prior to
making a decision on all proposals (re-
gardless of the method of analysis or
determination), except when it is not
possible to do so because of emergency
conditions or other regulatory time-
frames, e.g., 43 CFR 3802. If public
response indicates more time is required,
the approval period may be extended,
depending upon the situation and at the
discretion of the authorized officer.
Notifications should be sent early enough
to provide recipients sufficient time to
inform BLM of their concerns prior to the
date we intend to authorize or carry out
the proposed action.

. The notice should include a map and
enough information for the recipient to
understand the purpose, location, nature,
size and expected implementation date of
the proposed action. Although not re-
quired, it may be helpful to include, a copy

91

of the Environmental Analysis (EA) or -

the IMP nonimpairment analysis with the
notice.

e. The level of interest expressed and issues
raised in scoping the EA or Environ-
mental Impact Statement (EIS) will de-
termine the interpretation of the signifi-
cance of the project and how widely to
circulate notices. States may wish to use a
State Office clearinghouse approach in
reviewing, summarizing and notifying
interested citizens or organizations in
addition to direct notifications.

f. Notification of unauthorized actions that
have caused surface disturbance in WSAs
is also required. Such notices are not in-
tended to delay or impede timely enforce-
ment or reclamation of the area. In order
to protect evidence and specific informa-
tion on an alleged violator, certain infor-
mation may be withheld pending disposi-
tion of any administrative or legal
remedies.

4. Step 4 - Conclude Whether the Use or
Facility Will Meet the Nonimpairment Stan-
dard. Conclude and provide written docu-
mentation whether the proposal is in com-
pliance with the nonimpairment criteria from
Chapter I and what impacts it will have on
wilderness values. Written documentation
must be recorded in appropriate case files
and included in any decision documents and
authorizations. The BLM field officials will
cooperate with applicants to help identify

92

ways by which a proposal can be brought into
compliance with the nonimpairment criteria
through modification of the proposal.

Step 5 - Consult the Guidelines for Specific
Activities. Chapter III of this handbook
contains guidelines and special exceptions for
many of the specific uses and facilities which
may take place or be proposed in Wilderness
Study Areas. Consult these guidelines for
specific policy guidance covering the use or
facility. If specific guidelines do not address
the proposal being evaluated, refer to the
“nonimpairment criteria” from Chapter I and
other applicable policies that may apply in
this particular case.

Step 6 - Gather Information; Prepare EA or
EIS. The information needed to reach con-
clusions on whether the proposal meets the
nonimpairment criteria (Step 4) will be
recorded in the EA or EIS that is prepared
at this stage in the analytical process. The
EA or EIS must include the information
outlined below in paragraphs a, b, c, and d,
most of which is already required by the
NEPA Handbook (H-1760-1). The use of
categorical exclusion reviews for uses and

facilities on lands under wilderness review is
not allowed.

The information required in an EA or EIS
must include the following as a minimum, and
where required by the Council on Environ-

mental Quality (CEQ) regulations:

93

a. A precise description of the proposal and
its alternatives, including:

— Purpose, need, and/or justification
for the action.

— Exact location and proposed time of
the action.

— Discussion of all alternative sites
both inside and outside the WSA.

— Discussion of all reasonable alterna-
tive methods or approaches to ac-
complishing the same management
objectives. Alternatives must be
described with the same level of
detail as the proposed action.

— Proposed facility design specifica-
tions, if applicable, including size,
color and materials. .

— Construction methods including mac-

hinery,-equipment or vehicles to be
used

— Miles, square feet, or acres of soil
and vegetation disturbance.

— Access required for proposed action
and alternatives.

— Maintenance schedules, techniques,
procedures, and required access.

94

A description of the affected environment,

considering both the specific site and the
WSA in its entirety:

Wilderness characteristics as docu-
mented in the intensive inventory
report or Wilderness Study Report.

Meaningful descriptions of soils,
erosion potential, vegetation cover
and composition, other resources, re-
clamation potential, topography and
climate (including precipitation).

A description of the natural ecosys-
tem including dominant plants and
animals.

Existing uses and facilities.

Discussion of scenery characteristics,
vistas, key viewing areas, and visitor
use areas.

c. Written assessment of anticipated im-
pacts including the following, if applicable:

Describe the physical, biological, cul-
tural, and environmental impacts to
the site or WSA.

If the project’s impacts, including
cumulative impacts, had existed at
the time of the intensive inventory,
would those impacts have disquali-
fied the area, or any portion of the
area, from being identified as a WSA
or from being included in a WSA?

95

Discuss how the proposed project
will (or will not) conform to the non-
impairment criteria as described in
Chapter 1.

Discuss how the proposed project
will (or will not) meet the conditions
of being substantially unnoticeable.
Consider the impacts of existing, as
well as proposed and future projects
on the condition of being substan-
tially unnoticeable.

Will the addition of this proposal
produce an aggregate negative effect
upon the area’s wilderness charac-
teristics and values that would con-
strain Congress’s decision to desig-
nate the area as wilderness, con-
sidering the condition of the area at
the time the Secretary sent the rec-
ommendation to the President? The
analysis must include, if applicable,
the impact of the proposal on the
following wilderness and related
values:

- soil stability, including erosion
impacts.
- condition or trend of the vegeta-

tion including plant species com-
position and vegetal cover.

- natural biological diversity in-
cluding numbers and species

96

composition of microbes, inverte-
brates, fish, reptiles, amphibians,
birds, and mammals.

- key visual resource characteris-
tics (form, line, color, and tex-
ture) of the landscape.

- naturalness.
- opportunities for solitude.

- opportunities for primitive and
unconfined types of recreation, or
quality of exiting opportunities
for primitive and unconfined
types of recreation.

- description of special features.

- quality of surface water including
dissolved solids, nutrient levels
such as nitrates, and microbial
concentrations.

- threatened or endangered plant
and animal species.

— Will the addition of this proposal
reduce or improve the overall wild-

’ erness quality of the WSA or a por-
tion of the WSA? (This is especially
important for WSAs or portions of
WSAs that are pristine in character.)

d. Analysis of reclamation for unauthorized
projects:

—_ __— — —

EF OD LPO

et ena — com.

97

— Discussion of what the particular
reclamation plan will accomplish.

— How the process will be imple-
mented (type and amounts of hand
and equipment work).

— Soils to be replaced and/or recon-
toured to a natural appearance.

— Vegetation to be reestablished.
— Schedule.
— Probability for success.

— Ifa reclamation plan is not available
or is inadequate, assess what mea-
sures would be needed to return the
disturbed areas to the required
reclamation level.

7. Step 7 - Decision/Record Keeping. The

determination to allow or deny the proposed
action and whether the action complies with
the IMP or with the 3802 regulations (for
those actions covered under these regula-
tions), must be included in the decision
document and recorded in appropriate case
files and official WSA files, which are main-
tained at the appropriate office level. In
addition to the required inventory and WSA
information, this file or a separate IMP file
should contain a summary or cross-reference
of other case files of all authorized, un-
authorized, and proposed actions, since
December 1979, within the WSA, including

98

all related NEPA documents. The file must
contain the following information for any
individual proposed use, facility, or un-
authorized action:

a. The WSA name and number.

b. A brief description of the proposed use or
facility.

ce. An accurate map of the proposal.

d. A description of action taken and author-
ized uses and facilities (i.e. approved,
disapproved, pending). A description of
uses and facilities believed to be un-
authorized.

e. A cross-reference to the pertinent case
files, decision rationale, bonding determi-
nation, documentation required in Chap-
ter II.B and the name of the staff member
handling the case.

f. Comments on problems encountered.

Chronology of events.

>

Reclamation schedule.

Evaluation of reclamation efforts.

ae
.

j. Current status of the proposal or in-
vestigation.

k. Future planned actions.

99

All subsequent compliance, noncompliance and follow-
up actions must be documented in the file.

C. DECISIONS AND APPEALS

Appeal procedures can be found in 40 CFR Part I and
regulations governing program decision in the appro-
priate CF Rs. Appellants and others who are adversely
affected by a management decision within lands under
wilderness review will be informed of appeal pro-

cedures.

D. MONITORING AND SURVEILLANCE

1.

All WSAs are to be monitored on a minimum
standard of surveillance that will insure
compliance with the IMP. A basic monitoring
level of at least once per month during the
months the area is accessible by the public
should be adhered to, or more frequently if
necessary because of potential use activities
or resource conflicts.

Alternative surveillance schedules for any
WSA that could more effectively be monitored
less frequently than once per month can be
used if approved by the State Director. In the
absence of an approved alternate surveillance
schedule, the minimum standard of surveil-
lance of once per month shall remain in effect.

Alternate surveillance schedules shall be
tailored for the special needs of the WSA
based on a consideration of factors including
but not limited to: location and proximity to
user publics, history of unauthorized activities
and violations, weather/seasons of use and
access, potential for volunteer assistance,

100

Adopt-a-WSA efforts, or other staff exten-
sions/outreach opportunities.

At a minimum, the alternate surveillance
schedule shall include the frequency of ground
and air surveillance, the resources required to
sustain the new schedule, and a justification
for replacing once a month surveillance with
the alternate schedule. The alternate surveil-
lance schedule for each WSA must be ap-

proved and maintained in the WSAs per-
manent documentation file.

_3. If possible, BLM District Offices should sub-
mit monthly written reports to the State
Office, keep patrol logs, and make use of sur-
veillance plans, diaries, and photographs. Un-
authorized uses and facilities may be
assertively prevented by using such measures
as: ranger patrol, cooperative agreements
with local law enforcement agencies, surveil-
lance by volunteers, posting signs at key
access points, notifying various user and com-

- modity groups of WSA locations, and regular
project compliance visits to monitor actions
authorized within WSAs.

E. ENFORCEMENT

If unauthorized uses and facilities result in surface
disturbance or other degradation of the area’s suit-
ability for preservation as wilderness, legal action will
be initiated as appropriate to obtain full reclamation of
the area. Impacts resulting from unauthorized
activities will not disqualify an area from WSA status.
All action to achieve compliance with the IMP will be

ee Sie

101

initiated pursuant to existing regulations governing the
noncomplying activity.

In addition to normal enforcement procedures, the
following additional steps must be taken whenever a
District Manager believes a use is taking place or an
unauthorized facility is being constructed on lands
under wilderness review that is not in compliance with
the IMP or the regulations of 43 CFR 3802:

1. Thoroughly inspect the site and determine
whether the use or facility is authorized or
unauthorized. Dertemine whether the use or
facility is permissible on the basis of “grand-
fathered” uses or valid existing rights. A
trespass operation must stop, even if it quali-
fies as “grandfathered” or a VER, until
NEPA review is complete and proper
authorizations are issued.

2. Immediately contact the person responsible
for the activity in any manner that can be
verified with documentation. Explain the
situation and, depending on the situation or
activity, seek the responsible person’s assis-
tance in bringing the operation into com-
pliance with the IMP. Document the “who,
what, where, when, how, and why” of the
activities observed.

3. If the responsible person is not willing to
comply, and the operation is causing im-
pairment of wilderness values, the BLM will
shut down the operation. Notices of noncom-
pliance and citations may be used. When
appropriate, the full range of administrative
remedies will be used before initiating legal

102

action. The State Director will be notified,
after coordination and consultation with the
responsible person, so that additional ap-
propriate action may be taken immediately to
prevent impairment. The BLM will work with
the Regional Solicitor and U.S. Attorney’s
office to initiate appropriate legal action if
necessary.

Section 303 of FLPMA provides that the use,
occupancy, or development of any portion of
the public lands contrary to any regulation of
the Secretary, or other responsible authority,
or contrary to any order issued pursuant to
any such regulation, is unlawful and pro-
hibited. Use and facilities contrary to the
provisions of the IMP and the regulations 43
CFR 3802 would be unlawful, and criminal
provisions of FLPMA [43 USC 1733(a)] may
apply. Regulations codified at 43 CFR 8360
provide the basis for criminal prosecution,
which is independent of any administrative
remedies. Possible violations of criminal law
should be referred to the law enforcement
ranger or special agent, who will take the
appropriate action. Criminal prosecution is
pursued regardless of the type of IMP
violation if circumstances warrant it.

F. RECLAMATION OF UNAUTHORIZED IMPACTS

The BLM’s goal is to immediately reclaim the impacts
caused by any unauthorized action to a level as close as
possible to the original condition, or at least to a
condition that is substantially unnoticeable. The BLM
will attempt to collect costs of reclamation from any and
all persons responsible for causing impacts. If the

RS

103

person responsible for the unauthorized impacts is not
known, BLM will undertake reclamation and initiate
action to locate the person(s) responsible and collect the
reclamation costs from these persons. If the person
responsible for the unauthorized impacts is known but
unwilling to perform the needed reclamation, BLM will
undertake reclamation and initiate action to collect the
costs from the responsible person(s). If the impacts in a
particular case are so severe as to make it impossible or
unreasonably costly to meet the requirements of the
nonimpairment criteria, or if reclamation efforts would
result in greater loss of wilderness values than natural
reclamation, the State Director will submit written
recommendations to the Director proposing an alter-
native reclamation strategy.

_-

* * * *

H. RECREATION

Most recreational activities (including fishing, hunting
and trapping) are allowed on lands under wilderness
review. However, some activities may be prohibited or
restricted because they require permanent structures
or because they depend upon cross-country use of
motor vehicles (for example: pickup vehicles for bal-
loons or sailplanes).

BLM will analyze the magnitude of all recreational
activities to ensure that such use will not cause impacts
that impair the area’s wilderness suitability. An
example might be erosion caused by increased vehicle
travel within a WSA. To prevent this impairment, the
BLM will monitor ongoing recreation uses as well as
cumulative impacts, and if necessary, adjust the time,
location, or quantity of use or prohibit that use in the

impacted area.

104

To encourage responsible use of WSAs and to promote
a proper outdoor ethic, the BLM will promote “Leave
No Trace” and “Tread Lightly” program philosophies.
The “Leave No Trace” program aims to educate and
promote non-impacting use of wildlands by visitors
participating in non-motorized recreational activities.
“Tread Lightly” programs promote the environ-
mentally responsible use of off-highway vehicles. The
BLM will take advantage of both programs when
making management decisions and promoting public
use and enjoyment of WSAs.

1. No new, permanent recreational ways, trails,
structures, or installations will be permitted,
except those that are the minimum necessary

~~.__for public health and safety in the use and
enjoyment of the public lands’ wilderness
values, and that are necessary to protect
wilderness resource values. No mechanical
transport, which includes all motorized vehi-
cles plus trail or mountain bikes, will be
allowed on such trails.

Facilities necessary for visitors’ health and
safety and to protect wilderness values may
be provided in either of two ways:

a. permanent facilities that are the minimum
necessary for public health and safety in
the use, enjoyment, and protection of
wilderness values; or,

b. temporary facilities that meet the non-
impairment criteria. These facilities will
be installed so that they are substantially
unnoticeable and minimize surface dis-
turbance. Visual resources management

—_—-

__——— - = 2s See =.

105

concepts and techniques and wilderness
specific designs will be used in the
construction and siting of such facilities.

Hobby collecting of mineral specimens (rock-
hounding) and vegetative specimens may be
allowed for personal but not commercial use,
as long as the collection activity method meets
the nonimpairment criteria.

Boating may be allowed with or without
motors. The BLM does not have authority
over all waters within the public lands; some
are under jurisdiction of the States. There-
fore the following guidelines apply only to
those waters on which the BLM has authority
to regulate boating.

a. No waters will be closed to motorboats
solely because they are in areas under
wilderness review. However, if increas-
ing impacts of boating (such as shore
erosion or water pollution) threaten to
impair wilderness suitability, the BLM
may close the affected waters to motor-
boats. In some cases, time or space re-
strictions or public education may make a
total closure unnecessary. The Bureau
also has authority under other programs
to regulate boating to minimize damage to
wildlife and other resource values.

b. River running, with or without motors,

may be permitted. Cumulative impacts
on river campsites will be monitored to

prevent impairment of wilderness suit-
ability.

106

ce. No permanent launching ramps or boat
docks will be built. A “brow log” may be
used to reduce erosion at boat landings.
Temporary launching ramps and boat
docks may be installed only if they satisfy
the nonimpairment criteria.

Environmental education and interpretive
programs may be conducted so long as no
permanent facilities are required and the use
does not cause surface disturbance.

Camping may be allowed. Camping with
recreational vehicles may occur on existing
ways as long as this use meets the non-
impairment criteria. Primitive campsites for
recreational use may be established anywhere
in the WSA as long as they meet the non-
impairment criteria. Low impact camping
techniques should be encouraged within all
WSAs.

Cross-country skiing may be allowed. Down-
hill (alpine) may be permitted only if any
support facilities within the WSA satisfy the
nonimpairment criteria. Helicopter skiing, if
nonimpairing, may be allowed at the discre-
tion of the authorized officer.

Aerial activities such as ballooning, sail-
planing, hang gliding, and parachuting (sky
diving), may be allowed as long as they do not
require cross-country use of motorized vehi-
cles or mechanical devices to retrieve equip-
ment, except in areas designated as “open”
before October 21, 1976.

8.

10.

107

hecreational gold dredging and panning, when
conducted without location of a mining claim
may be allowed as long as it is done in a
manner that satisfies the nonimpairment
criteria. If the activity would cause significant
damage to fish spawning or rearing areas, it
will be considered to impair wilderness suit-
ability, and the activity will be controlled to
prevent such impacts.

Concessions and actions that require authori-
zation under a special recreation permit will
be allowed only if the use and related facilities
satisfy the nonimpairment criteria. Examples
that may qualify include mobile refreshment
stands, river trip outfitters, guides, and pro-
viders of pack animals and saddle horses.

Rock climbing and caving will be allowed as
long as these activities meet the nonimpair-
ment criteria. The use of power driven (i.e.
fuel or electric) rock drills or permanent
anchors (e.g. bolts) is not allowed. No mar-
ring, scarring or defacing resulting in adverse
impacts to the wilderness value of naturalness
will be permitted, nor will permanent installa-
tions be permitted. Exceptions to the above
may be allowed for: (a) emergencies, such as
search and rescue operations; and (b) author-
ized actions needed for access travel within
WSAs which are the minimum necessary for
public health and safety in the use and en-
joyment of the wilderness values. Any
impacts from emergency actions (a, above),
must be reclaimed to a substantially unnotice-

108

able condition following the emergency
situation.

11. Except for emergency situations as defined in
Chapter I.B.12, vehicle designations in WSAs
are to be handled through the land-use plan-
ning process. Until WSAs are designated as
wilderness or released from study status,
vehicle use within each WSA is governed by
the terms and conditions as identified in
Chapter I.B.11 and any land-use planning
decisions. Open areas may be designated only:
(1) as sand dune or snow areas for use by the
appropriate sand or snow vehicles, or
(2) where an area was designated open prior
to October 21, 1976. No vehicle designation in
a WSA may allow vehicles to travel off
existing ways and trails, except in these two
circumstances.

12. Organized vehicle events will not be allowed
unless they can meet the nonimpairment
criteria, and are contained on existing ways
and trails or within pre-F LPMA sand dune or
snow open areas. (For clarification of defini-
tions of applicable vehicles and designation of
areas see guidance contained in 43 CFR 8340
and 1601.)

I. CULTURAL AND PALEONTOLOGICAL RE-
SOURCES

Cultural and paleontological resource inventories,
studies, and research involving surface examination
may be permitted if they satisfy the nonimpairment
criteria. Salvage of archeological and paleontological
sites; rehabilitation, stabilization, reconstruction, and

109

restoration work on historic structures; excavations;
and extensive surface collection may be permitted if the
specific project satisfies the nonimpairment criteria.

Permanent physical protection, such as fences, will be
limited to those measures needed to protect resources
eligible for the National Register of Historic Places and
will be constructed to be substantially unnoticeable.

J. FIRE MANAGEMENT

The BLM will conduct all prescribed fire and suppres-
sion activities in accordance with fire management
activity plans and subsequent operational plans (pre-
scribed fire and preattack) for all WSAs, using caution
to avoid unnecessary impairment of an area’s suitability
for preservation as wilderness. “Light-Hand-On-The-
Land” fire suppression tactics will be used. Fire is a
natural component of many wilderness ecosystems and
fire plans need to give serious consideration to this fact
before recommending one fire management technique
over another. Resource area advisors will use the fire
plans in making decisions during emergency fire
situations and prescribed ignitions. All uses of earth
moving equipment within a WSA require authorization.
Priority for placement of large fire camps should be
outside WSAs. Use of motorized vehicles and mechani-
cal equipment during mop-up should be minimized.

The fire preattack plan covering a WSA will specify the
fire management objectives and special considerations
for each WSA, taking into account a number of factors
including the existing wilderness characteristics of the
area, the need to prevent impairing actions, historic fire
occurrence, the natural role of fire, proposed degree of
suppression, expected fire behavior, acceptable sup-
pression techniques, adequate buffer zones, smoke

110

management, effect on private or other agency
inholdings and on adjacent landowners, the limits of
acceptable fire weather, fire behavior, fire effects, and
the access requirements of other agencies. In planning
firebreaks, the use of natural firebreaks and existing
roads is encouraged. Emergency fire rehabilitation
measures will continue to be carried out under
guidelines in Handbook H-1742-1 and Manual Section
1742. Efforts should be made to rehabilitate any
impacts created by suppression activities prior to
releasing fire crews and associated equipment following
fire containment.
*x* * k *

GLOSSARY OF TERMS

Some of [t]he terms used in this handhook have specific
meanings and are defined as follows:

-C-

cross-country: refers to travel that is not on existing
access routes (ways, trails, boundary roads) and
involves surface disturbance caused solely by the
passage of vehicles.

cumulative impact: the aggregate impact of existing °
and proposed activities. Individual intrusions when

considered by themselves may not impair wilderness

suitability; however, when combined with other

existing and proposed substantially unnoticeable im-

’ pacts, the total effect may be sufficient to impair an

area’s suitability for preservation as wilderness.

-E-

enhance wilderness values: an action that clearly bene-
fits a wilderness study area’s wilderness value through

111

activities that restore, protect, or maintain these
values. Wilderness values are those identified in section
2(c) of the Wilderness Act of 1964, including: road-
lessness, naturalness, solitude, primitive and uncon-
fined recreation, and size. .

existing way: a way (see definition) existing on the
date of the initial wilderness inventory.

-F-

FLPMA: the Federal Land Policy and Management
Act of 1976 (Public Law 94-579, 90 Stat. 2743, 48 USC
1701).

Jit.

hazardous materials: any substance, pollutant, or con-
taminant listed as hazardous under the Comprehensive
Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability
(CERCLA) Act of 1980, as amended, 41 U.S.C. 9601 et
seq., and any related regulations. Hazardous substances
includes any hazardous waste as defined in the
Resource Conservation and Recovery (RCRA) Act of
1976, as amended, 42 U.S.C. 6901 et seq., and related
regulations. Hazardous materials includes any nuclear
or byproduct material as defined by the Atomic Energy
Act of 1954, as amended, 42 U.S.C. 2011 et seq. In
general, hazardous substance as defined in CERCLA is
any substance that the Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA) has designated as hazardous, dangerous,
or toxic under the Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. 7401 et seq.,
the Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. 1251 et seq., or the
Toxic Substances Control Act, 15 U.S.C. et seq., as well
as any hazardous waste under RCRA. ~

112

alts
impact: the effect, influence, alteration, or imprint of
an activity.
impair: to diminish in value or excellence.

impair wilderness suitability: refers to activities that
are considered to impair an area’s suitability for
preservation as wilderness—i.e., that do not satisfy the
“nonimpairment criteria” set forth in Chapter I.B.2 of
this handbook.

instant study area: one of the 55 primitive and natural
areas formally identified by BLM through a final action
published in the Federal Register before November 1,
1975. FLPMA required an accelerated wilderness
review of these areas.

-M-

mining claim: any unpatented mining claim, millsite, or
tunnel site authorized by the United States mining
laws.

multiple use: “. . . the management of the public lands
and their various resource values so that they are
utilized in the combination that will best meet the
present and future needs of the American people;
making the most judicious use of the land for some or
all of these resources or related services over areas
large enough to provide sufficient latitude for periodic
adjustments in use to conform to changing needs and
conditions; the use of some land for less than all of the
resources; a combination of balanced and diverse
resource uses that takes into account the long-term
needs of future generations for renewable and non-
renewable resources, including, but not limited to,
recreation, range, timber, minerals, watershed, wildlife

TT

113

and fish, and natural scenic, scientific and historical
values; and harmonious and coordinated management of
the various resources without permanent impairment of
the productivity of the land-and the quality of the
environment with consideration being given to the
relative values of the resources and not necessarily to
the combination of uses that will give the greatest

economic return or the greatest unit output.” (From
Section 103, FLPMA.)

-N-

negligible: so small or unimportant or of so little
consequence as to warrant little or no attention; not
exceeding established standard(s).

-P.

pre-FLPMA: before October 21, 1976, the date of

— of the Federal Land Policy and Management

primitive and unconfined recreation: nonmotorized
and undeveloped types of outdoor recreational
activities.

public lands: for the purpose of the wilderness review
program, any lands and interest in lands owned by the
United States within the several States and adminis-
tered by the Secretary of the Interior through the
Bureau of Land Management, without regard to how
the United States acquired ownership, except:

1. Lands where the United States owns the
minerals but the surface is not Federally owned.

2. Lands being held for the benefit of Indians,
Aleuts, and Eskimos.

114

3. Lands tentatively approved for State selection
in Alaska.

4. Oregon and California (O & C) grant lands that
are managed for commercial timber production.

x ¥

reclamation: the contouring of the topography to a
natural appearance (not necessarily to the original
contour), the replacement of topsoil, and the restoration
of plant cover, if any. approximating the species com-
position and cover previously occurring on the dis-
turbed site.

reclamation deadline: the date on which temporary
post-F LPMA impacts within WSA’s were to be re-
claimed to a condition of being substantially un-
noticeable before the Secretary was scheduled to send
his recommendations on wilderness suitability or
nonsuitability to the President. This date has past.

roadless: for the purpose of the wilderness review
program, this refers to the absence of roads which have
been improved and maintained by mechanical means to
ensure relatively regular and continuous use. A way
maintained solely by the passage of vehicles does not
constitute a road. Words and phrases used in the above
def

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385014_0696%3A13. Public record. Not legal advice.
