# Amicus Curiae Brief — South Florida Water Management District v. Miccosukee Tribe of Indians

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385014_0612%3A19

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Amicus Curiae Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 2003
- **Citation:** 539 U.S. 957

## Text

== -—CS

4) Supreme Court, U.S.
Fd.

ED
No. 02-626 SEP 1 0 2003
In The | OFFICE OF THE CLERK
Supreme Court of the Anited States

¢

SOUTH FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT,

Petitioner,
v.

MICCOSUKEE TRIBE OF INDIANS, et al.,
Respondents.

¢

On Writ Of Certiorari To The
United States Court Of Appeals
For The Eleventh Circuit

¢

BRIEF FOR THE LAKE WORTH DRAINAGE
DISTRICT AND THE FLORIDA ASSOCIATION
OF SPECIAL DISTRICTS AS AMICI CURIAE
IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONER SOUTH
FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT

¢

KENNETH G. SPILLIAS

Counsel of Record
TERRY E. LEWIS
STEPHEN A. WALKER
MICHELLE DIFFENDERFER
LEWIS, LONGMAN & WALKER, P.A.
1700 Palm Beach Lakes Blvd.
Suite 1000
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
(561) 640-0820

Counsel for Amici Curiae,
Lake Worth Drainage District
and Florida Association
of Special Districts

SS e———————EEEE——llEEEESESESESESSESEE™E™E™E™“™EEOO_L_L
COCKLE LAW BRIEF PRINTING CO. (800) 225-6964
OR CALL COL! CT (402) 342-2831 47
' ai

—_— .

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
INTEREST OF AMICI CURIAE ..........0...cccccccceeeeeeees 1
SUMMARY OF THE ARGUMENT ......................0064. 5
STITT enenenasccsscsnmevetensmeteisnenssscsnniesnmsnsennces 7

I. THE MOVEMENT OF WATER CONTAIN-
ING POLLUTANTS FROM ONE NAVIGA-
BLE BODY OF WATER TO ANOTHER
THROUGH A SURFACE WATER CONVEY-
ANCE FACILITY OR STRUCTURE DOES
NOT CONSTITUTE A “DISCHARGE OF A
POLLUTANT” WHICH REQUIRES A SEC-
TION 402 NPDES POINT SOURCE PERMIT
PURSUANT TO 33 U.S.C. §1342..............0064.

CSTE coccccccsnceccsesscccnonsnscnnsoransecnnsspeonssseosooses

ii
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

CASES
Appalachian Power Company v. Train, 545 F.2d

Catskill Mountains Chapter of Trout Unlimited,
Inc. v. City of New York, 273 F.3d 481 (2nd Cir.

Colvin v. United States, 181 F. Supp. 2d 1050 (C.D.
Ss SUD ccnsivhiinticininisincininasiaiiniaineaiairpatciiaiiaei tiated aiaiinaiiel 20

Committee to Save Mokelumne River v. East Bay
Municipal Utility District, 13 F.3d 305 (9th Cir.

Dubois v. United States Department of Agriculture,
102 F.3d 1273 (1st Cir. 1996) ............ccccseeeeeee 9, 10, 17, 29

EPA v. California ex rel. State Water Resources
Control Board, 426 U.S. 200 (1976).............cccccceeeeeeeeeees 22

Kelly v. United States Environmental Protection
Agency, 203 F.3d 519 (7th Cir. 2000) .0.........cccccceeeeeeeeeees 29

Miccosukee Tribe of Indians, Sam Poole v. South
Florida Water Management District; Friends of
the Everglades v. South Florida Water
Management District, 280 F.3d 1364 (11th Cir.

National Wildlife Federation v. Consumers Power
Company, 862 F.2d 580 (6th Cir. 1988) .................000. 9,12

National Wildlife Federation v. Gorsuch, 692 F.2d
ee 7, 8, 9, 10, 28

Solid Waste Agency of Northern Cook County v.
United States Army Corps of Engineers, 531 U.S.
Sec ae li

ili

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES -— Continued

Page

United States v. Earth Sciences, Inc., 599 F.2d 368

CBB a Clie, BOTDD ...00c00ccccccececccsscccsececccsssecsccscccssscccssccossecoes 20
United States v. Riverside Bayview Homes, Inc., 474 |

TTS. 181 (C1DBB)......cccrccccccccccsccccssccccscccccccscccsscseseccsescsesseee 16
STATUTES AND LAWS
United States Codes
BS U.S.C. $1251 ef 200. ...........cccccceesccssseserseesserersessssescescseness 3
33 U.S.C. §1251(b) .............e ‘caaehiiatiiieiammmmepmammemenaten 11
SS U.S.C. SIBBEU@) .........00cceccescccscerssersceeeseseenscercssesenssensens 11
B33 U.S.C. $1S11(D)A)............ccceccccesseseeerecersscessnsesssssesnnes 15
BS U.G.C. SIBUBD) .......00c.ececccerrscecssrsecscecersersrssseecsersssencssees 11
BS U.S.C. $1SIMA) .........0....ccccecrcccssscessscsecsssnsssnsesessesnsenes 14
SS U.S.C. SISIBME)........0000.cccccrersceccssocrssserssesercessnsssssoeeoseees 11
BS U.S.C. SI1SIAD) ........0....ccccecsccecsscessscercssesssesescsssssenssenees 15
BOBTG.C. BIBI) ......000.c00cceeeeseserssreccseerecerscrssersseersreesseees 15
33 U.S.C. $13 14(f 2K) «........cccceecssceeeseeeeeseeeeseennneenannenenes 12
BB U.S.C. §$131G.............c.cccccccceceeseeeseeeeeeeeeenennnenenensnnennenennes 15
BS U.S.C. $191G(aN2)............ccccccrsseessceeeecessseenseesesensnsenseees 15
33 U.S.C. $1316(DX LMA) .........cccccccceesseeeesenenneneennnennnnnnenens 15
BSS U.B.C. BIBID...........000cceeccceressrerescseeccrserscesenseserssessoscecsees 29
BS U.B.C. BIBBD..........00..eccceeresercssersseccscerssreccescesssesscscsossees 11
BS U.B.C. BIBAEB...........000cccccecseeesseccssoressesecseessssensenssscnsseess 29
BB U.S.C. $13962(6) ..............ccccecccesssecessserneseseecsnscesnnsennenenss 13

iv

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES - Continued

Page

a ee SI ccisentiinieniniisiiiinihasiasiadsiaanieatmeeaiaceeal 3, 7,9
ne NT ccrtstcrioniiniintineanienaiaceeiiiiticc ae esti 13, 24
FEDERAL LAWS
Federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1972

(Clean Water Act)

EERE ee ee 14, 25

i Soe eeiccestesiecernintctenncetteninsieaaiinmniteniiiaitiaiiaiiastaliaaaa 15

ND CI crcseennennensinirecenenniiininiitinisiniaiinisesiaiiaieaiaatahaiaiaaaae 11

ee ire ctsisnininrcaresnemnritntienicsiinibeinnaccaiaiainaniattaiaiitiiaa passim
FLORIDA STATUTES
TT 1
I i icnnsseninnieienntoneamnintonisisinnainiatiiainneiiiaiiies 11
EE Te. 11
EN ee ETN Se 11
ee TITIIET \csticseiiccininisieencntaectinlinnen ieee 11, 13, 23
RT ee Oe 11
TTS a Ea a a LA 12
FLORIDA LAWS
Florida Air and Water Pollution Control Act .................... 11
Florida Environmental Re-organizational Act of

1993 (Chapter 93-212, Laws of Florida)........................ 11

Florida Safe Drinking Water Act..................0.ccccccceceeeeseeeee 12

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES — Continued

Page
Florida Water Resources Act of 1972...................ccceeseeeeeees 11
Florida Watershed Restoration Act of 1999 ..................0+. 11
Surface Water Improvement and Management Act
a ll
RULES
Florida Administrative Code
Oy 16
gE 22
I -seknniiintnsisinteniasntiininiainitniniimitniasiitiiennteiatis 22
EE 22
OO, 22
OTHER AUTHORITIES
A Report to the Governor and the Legislature on the
Allocation of Total Maximum Daily Loads in
Florida, date February 1, 2001, Florida
Department of Environmental Protection..................... 26
EPA, The Control of Pollution Caused by
Hydrographic Modifications (1973) ............-..-00eeeeeseeeees 12

E Sciences, Inc., National Pollutant Discharge
Elimination $ Permitting Analysic for the
Lake Worth Drainage District (September, 2003) ...4, 24, 27

Methodology for TMDL Preliminary Cost Analysis,

City of Tallahassee, Stormwater Management
ON 26

vi
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES - Continued

Senate Report No. 92-414, The Federal Water
Pollution Control Act Amendments of 1971,
Report of the Committee on Public Works .............. 14, 15

The Clean Water Act Handbook, Second Edition
SC Ee 23

1

INTEREST OF AMICI CURIAE
Amici curiae, Lake Worth Drainage District
(“LWDD”) and the Florida Association of Special Districts
(“FASD”), submit this brief in support of the Petitioner,
South Florida Water Management District (“SFWMD”),
seeking reversal of the decision of the Eleventh Circuit
Court of Appeals in Miccosukee Tribe of Indians, Sam
Poole v. South Florida Water Management District;
Friends of the Everglades v. South Florida Water Man-

agement District, 280 F.3d 1364 (11th Cir. 2002).

In Florida today there are more than one thousand
independent and dependent special districts, governed by
more than 30 statutes and involving over 500 local gov-
ernments. Special districts have a long history in the State
of Florida and all were created in order to provide specific
government services to a target population. Included
among Florida’s special districts are 96 water control
districts and five water management districts.

FASD, a Florida Corporation, is an association con-
sisting of 89 special districts in the State of Florida,
including 39 of the State’s water control districts. LWDD,
a member of FASD, is an independent taxing district of the
State of Florida created on June 15, 1915. The District
currently operates pursuant to special legislative act and
Chapter 298, Florida Statutes. LWDD encompasses
approximately 218 square miles in southeastern Palm

* Counsel for a party did not author this brief in whole or in part.
No person or entity, other than the amici curiae, their members, or
their counsel made a monetary contribution to the preparation and
submission of this brief. Written consent to file this brief has been
obtained from al! parties.

2

Beach County, Florida. It includes within its boundaries 11
municipalities, 20,000 acres of agricultural land and is
bordered on the west by the Arthur R. Marshall Loxahat-
chee National Wildlife Refuge, otherwise known as Water
Conservation Area #1 (“WCA-1”).

LWDD was created for the purpose of reclaiming the
lands within its boundaries for agriculture and other types
of development and for the purpose of water control and
water supply through the construction and maintenance of
canals, ditches, water control structures and pumping
stations. Its water management system provides compre-
hensive flood control and water supply protection to over
700,000 residents, 20,000 acres of prime agricultural land
and 120,000 acres of urban development. It does this by
maintaining approximately 511 miles of canals, 20 major
water control structures and numerous other minor
structures. The district’s flood control discharges are
through control structures (pumps, weirs and dikes) to
discrete water bodies such as Lake Worth Lagoon (a part
of the Intracoastal Waterway) and the Hillsboro Canal,
which are outside the boundaries of the LWDD system, as
well as a number of lakes which are within its boundaries.
The system is also operated to provide groundwater
recharge and for the prevention of salt water intrusion.
LWDD relies for its water supply on deliveries from the U.
S. Army Corps of Engineers’ Central and Southern Florida
Flood Control Project (C&SFCP), primarily WCA-1, which
is separated from the LWDD system by a dike and control
structures. The District utilizes this water supply to
maintain canal levels that recharge public water supply
well-fields, to prevent salt water intrusion and to provide
irrigation to a vital agricultural area in Palm Beach
County. LWDD’s canal system constitutes the receiving

3

waters for much of southeast Palm Beach County’s storm-
water runoff. LWDD is the largest water contro! district in
the State of Florida.

LWDD is one of 19 water control districts located
within Palm Beach County alone. All of these districts
utilize various major and minor water control structures
such as pumps, spillways and canals which meet the
definition of “point source” found in the Clean Water Act
(“CWA”). 33 U.S.C. §1251 et seq.; see 33 U.S.C. §1362(14).
These districts serve both agricultural and urban needs.
For example, there is the South Florida Conservancy
District (“SFCD”). This water control district is located in
the Everglades Agricultural Area south of Lake Okeecho-
bee. The district’s structures, in this case pumps, provide
the SFCD with the opportunity to withdraw water from
Lake Okeechobee for agricultural water supply needs.
Likewise, these pumps provide the district with the
opportunity to discharge excess water from its geographic
boundaries to Lake Okeechobee for flood control purposes.
The district is equipped with pumps on its southernmost
boundary from Lake Okeechobee which allows it to pump
and discharge water from the Hillsboro and North New
River Canals to the south. In addition, the SFCD is served
by the S-236 pump station on the southern border of Lake

Okeechobee.

Another example is the Northern Palm Beach County
Improvement District (“NPBCID”) which services an
urban area. This water control district is located in the
northeastern portion of Palm Beach County and extends to
the county’s boundary with Martin County to the north.
The NPBCID is comprised of separate parcels separated
by levees. Each parcel is equipped with pumps that allows
it to withdraw or discharge water over district levees into

4

either the C-17 or C-18 canals operated by SFWMD, which
are navigable waters of the United States.

Districts such as LWDD, NPBGID and SFCD are
subject to various permits (e.g., diversion and impound-
ment, surface water management) issued and monitored
by the State’s water management districts. None of these
water control districts, however, has ever been required to
obtain a Section 402 National Pollution Discharge Elimi-
nation System (“NPDES”) point source permit to operate.
Under the holding of the Eleventh Circuit’s decision below,
and the broad language utilized in that holding, the
question, and concern, is raised whether the LWDD and
the FASD’s water control district members will be required
to obtain Section 402 point source permits for each of their
water control structures which merely transfer water from
one navigable body of water to another.

The impact of the Eleventh Circuit’s decision on such
water control districts is enormous. In an attempt to
quantify that potential impact, LWDD has conducted an
evaluation of the consequences of its being made subject to
the NPDES point source permitting requirements for all of -
its structures which could be deemed point sources of
discharge. The evaluation, contained in a report reviewing
LWDD’s system and the most likely permitting scenarios,’
demonstrates an extensive, burdensome and expensive
regulatory process. Neither the language of the CWA nor
its legislative history supports a finding that Congress

* E Sciences, Inc., National Pollutant Discharge Elimination
System Permitting Analysis for the Lake Worth Drainage District
(September, 2003).

5

intended such a requirement for water control and water
management districts that receive waters into their own
navigable water bodies, add no pollutants and act as a
conduit of surface water runoff to other navigable bodies
as part of a flood control and water supply protection
system. Should the Eleventh Circuit’s decision be upheld,
the scenario outlined below as it affects LWDD would be
multiplied thousands of times over throughout the State of
Florida and the country as a whole.

¢

SUMMARY OF THE ARGUMENT

The decision below, requiring as it does a Section 402
NPDES permit when water containing pollutants is
transferred through a point source from one navigable
body to another, is contrary to the express intent of Con-
gress in passing the Clean Water Act. Congress identified
the purpose of point source permits as being directed at
industrial and municipal waste dischargers of pollutants
in order that such pollutants could be addressed at their
source. It further expressed its intent to recognize, pre-
serve and protect the primary responsibilities and rights
of states with regard to the use of land and water re-

sources.

The decision below is in conflict with this Congres-
sional intent as well as previous decisions of the Fourth,
Sixth, and the District of Columbia Circuits. If permitted
to stand, it will have a significant impact on amici curiae
and other similarly situated governmental water control
and water management districts in the State of Florida as
well as across the country, requiring applications for
multiple NPDES point source permits. This is contrary to

6

long-standing policies and procedures and in conflict with
the federal/state system of preventing and reducing
pollution set out in the CWA. An analysis of the potential
cost to LWDD of being subjected to the NPDES point
source permitting program suggests that the cost of
implementation of such permits, i.e., the need to meet
discharge standards, is likely to be in the hundreds of
millions of dollars. Such enormous costs cannot be justi-
fied, and demonstrate that Congress could not have
intended such, where LWDD merely moves waters with
pre-existing pollutants (at the time it receives the surface
waters and stormwater), which have already been previ-
ously permitted through the NPDES permitting process.

The CWA establishes respective federal and state
responsibilities for water quality. It retains within the
states the responsibility for flood control, water quantity
management and regulation, land use and the like. The
Eleventh Circuit’s strict “but for” test requiring Section
402 NPDES permits in circumstances such as those
presented here and applying that requirement to water
control and water management districts, would result in
the broad and unwarranted expansion of federal regula-
tion of activities Congress intended to remain with the
states and which are otherwise regulated through both
federal and state programs. For these reasons the decision
below should be reversed.

7

ARGUMENT

I. THE MOVEMENT OF WATER CONTAINING
POLLUTANTS FROM ONE NAVIGABLE BODY
OF WATER TO ANOTHER THROUGH A SUR-
FACE WATER CONVEYANCE FACILITY OR
STRUCTURE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A
“DISCHARGE OF A POLLUTANT” WHICH RE-
QUIRES A SECTION 402 NPDES POINT
SOURCE PERMIT PURSUANT TO 33 U.S.C.

§1342.

The impact of the Eleventh Circuit’s expansive “but
for” interpretation of the “addition ... from” element set
forth in 33 U.S.C. §1362(12) which would require an
NPDES permit to transfer surface water or stormwater
from one navigable body to another, is starkly demon-
strated by a review of the requirements it would place on
LWDD, the dozens of other water control districts in the
State of Florida and the five water management districts,
including SFWMD. It is a review of the impacts on these
types of entities which also vividly demonstrates that the
Eleventh Circuit’s interpretation is not what Congress
intended in the distinctions it made between point source
and non-point sources of pollutants and pollution.

In National Wildlife Federation v. Gorsuch, 693 F.2d
156 (D.C. Cir. 1982), the Circuit Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia accepted the argument of the Envi-
ronmental Protection Agency (“EPA”) “that for addition of
a pollutant from a point source to occur, the point source
must introduce the pollutant into navigable water from
the outside world .. . ” Jd. at 165. As a result, despite dam-
induced water quality changes in water which is then
transferred from the reservoir to the downstream river, it
was held that an NPDES point source permit was not

8 .

required because this did not constitute the “addition” of
pollutants into a navigable body of water. In arriving at its
conclusion the D.C. Circuit engaged in a lengthy and
exhaustive analysis of the CWA’s legislative history to
discern the intent of Congress. Jd. 171-182. Among the
D.C. Circuit’s findings regarding Congressional intent
were the following:

1. With respect to NPDES point source
permitting, Congress’ focus was on traditional
industrial and municipal wastes; not how to
regulate facilities such as dams transferring wa-
ter (and pollutants) from upstream water to
downstream water (Jd. at 175);

2. It did not appear that Congress intended
to apply the NPDES point source permitting sys-
tem wherever feasible (Id. at 176):

3. Congress made clear and precise distinc-
tions between point sources, which would be sub-
ject to direct federal regulation under the CWA,
and non-point sources, the control of which was
specifically reserved to state and local govern-
ment.

As a result the court in Gorsuch interpreted the
“addition” criterion as requiring the pollutant to be intro-
duced into the navigable waters from the “outside world.”
This decision was consistent with the previous determina-
tion by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals that “(tJhose

. * “Had it wanted to do so, [Congress] could easily have chosen
suitable language, e.g., ‘all pollution released through a point source.’
Instead, as we have seen, the NPDES system was limited to ‘addition’ of
‘pollutants’ ‘from’ a point source.” (Jd. at 176)

9

constituents occurring naturally in the waterways or
occurring as a result of other industrial discharges, do not
constitute an addition of pollutants by a plant through
which they pass.” Appalachian Power Company v. Train,
545 F2d 1351, 1377 (4th Cir. 1976). This reasoning was
subsequently followed in National Wildlife Federation uv.
Consumers Power Company, 862 F.2d 580 (6th Circuit
1988) (where a hydro-electric facility's release of turbine
generating water containing entrained fish, a pollutant
created by the normal operation of the facility, into Lake
Michigan (from where the water and fish originally en-
tered the reservoir) was held not to constitute the “addi-
tion” of pollutants so as to require an NPDES permit).

Relying on the First and Second Circuit decisions in
Dubois v. United States Department of Agriculture, 102
F.3d 1273 (1st Cir. 1996) and Catskill Mountains Chapter
of Trout Unlimited, Inc. v. City of New York, 273 F.3d 481
(2nd Cir. 2001), and without any discussion of the legisla-
tive history of the CWA and Congressional intent, the
Eleventh Circuit, in the case under review, rejected the
Gorsuch court’s interpretation of 33 U.S.C. §1362(12).*

The decision below imposes a strict “but for” test for
determining whether the NPDES point source permitting
process applies to transfers of water from one navigable
body of water to another. It basically establishes four

criteria:

‘ While the decision below could be viewed as attempting to limit
Gorsuch to its specific facts, i.e., applying only to dams, there is nothing
in the Gorsuch opinion itself that purports to limit its holding or its
reading of the legislative history as such.

10

1. In determining whether pollutants are
added to navigable waters from the outside world
for purposes of the CWA, the receiving body of
— is the only relevant body of navigable wa-

r;

2. For an addition of pollutants to naviga-
ble waters to require a Section 402 permit, the
addition must be from a point source;

_ 3. For an addition of pollutants to be from a
point source, the relevant inquiry is whether, but
for the point source, the pollutants would have
been added to the receiving body of water (Id. at
1368); and

. 4. The addition from a point source occurs
if a point source is the cause-in-fact of the release
of pollutants into the receiving navigable body of
water.

In addition, the Eleventh Circuit concluded that a
point source does not have to be the original source of the
pollutants. Rather, it “can ... indicate the ‘agent or in-
strumentality’ or the ‘cause or reason’ by which the pollut-
ants are added to navigable waters.” Jd. at 1368, n.6. The
Eleventh Circuit’s ultimate conclusion, then, is that the
transfer of water from a navigable body which contains
pollutants (as that term is defined in the CWA) through a
point source, which itself does not add any pollutants to
the water, to another navigable body necessarily requires
the obtaining of a Section 402 NPDES permit.

The distinction between point source pollutants and
non-point source pollution is neither academic nor
insignificant. While, as noted in Gorsuch, Congress
intended the NPDES program to play a major role in
accomplishing the purposes of the CWA, the regulatory

11

scheme provided that it remained up to the states to
address non-point sources of pollution. 33 U.S.C. §§1313(b)
and (e), 1329. In 1987, Congress added Section 319 of the
CWA (33 U.S.C. §1329) creating a three stage non-point
source management program requiring states to develop
non-point source assessment reports, non-point source
management programs and phased in implementation of
those programs with the assistance of federal funds.
Section 319, through making available federal funds to
states and local governments, encourages states to
implement best management practices to address non-
point source pollution problems. However, non-point
source pollution remains within the states’ realm of

responsibility.

The express policy of the Congress is to recognize,
preserve and protect the primary responsibilities and
rights of states not only to prevent and reduce pollution
but to plan the development and use of land and water
resources and to allocate quantities of water within their
jurisdictions. 33 U.S.C. §1251(b) and (g). This Congres-
sional intent was expressly noted and deferred to by the
Court in Solid Waste Agency of Northern Cook County v.
United States Army Corps of Engineers, 531 U.S. 159, 174
(2001).

The State of Florida has enacted a number of water
quality statutes including the Florida Water Resources Act
of 1972 (Chapter 373, Florida Statutes), the Florida
Environmental Re-organizational Act of 1993 (Chapter 93-
212, Laws of Florida), the Surface Water Improvement and
Management Act of 1987 (Florida Statutes, Section
373.453 et seq.), and the Florida Watershed Restoration
Act of 1999 (Florida Statutes, Section 403.067). See also
Florida Statutes, Chapter 403, Part I (the Florida Air and

12

Water Pollution Control Act) and Part VI (the Florida Safe
Drinking Water Act). In the State of Florida, the primary
agencies for enforcing the State water quality laws and
exercising the State’s rights and responsibilities under the
CWA are the Florida Department of Environmental
Protection (FDEP) and the water management districts.
Water control districts, such as LWDD, which are permit-
ted by water management districts, play a crucial role in
the implementation of these plans and responsibilities.

To impose upon these water management entities the
requirement of a Section 402 NPDES permit every time
water is transferred through a point source from one
navigable body to another would place an unbearable
burden on these districts, would interfere with the State’s
management of these resources and would, in essence,
preempt, by judicial fiat, the express intent of Congress.
Under the holding of the decision below, any transfer of
water from one body to another that introduces an already
existing pollutant would require an NPDES point source
permit. This is so even in those situations, as with the S-9
pump station, where the two bodies of water would be one
but for a man-made structure which separates them. The
changes to the movement, flow or circulation of these
navigable waters caused by the construction of man-made
structures or flow diversion facilities, are intended to be
and have been controlled by the states under non-point
source procedures and methods developed with guidance
from the EPA. 33 U.S.C. §1314(f(2)F); National Wildlife
Federation v. Consumers Power Company, 862 F.2d 580,
588 (6th Cir. 1988); see also EPA, The Control of Pollution
from Hydrographic Modifications (1973). |

Just as the SFWMD does, LWDD and the other water
control districts in the State receive water which can, and

13

most often will, contain pre-existing pollutants’ which
were naturally occurring or added from other sources
upstream. These waters are then transferred through
structures, which meet the definition of “point sources”,
into other navigable bodies of water without the addition
of any new pollutants or, in the case of, for example,
agricultural operations, the addition of pollutants from
exempt activities. See 33 U.S.C. §1362(14). Under the
expansive language of the decision below, a Section 402
NPDES permit would be required at each point source
where such a transfer occurs. This would, for all intents
and purposes, usurp the State’s role in the overall man-
agement of its water resources.

For a water control district such as LWDD, a require-
ment to obtain an NPDES point source permit for its
movement of water from one navigable surface water body
to another would impose significant financial and opera-
tional burdens. LWDD, which has a large number of water
control structures and moves water to and from a number
of navigable bodies, is required to obtain a diversion and
impoundment permit from SFWMD. Landowners within
the district who discharge into the district’s canals may
also be subject to the extensive total maximum daily load
(“TMDL”) program regulatory requirements of Section
403.067, Florida Statutes, which address surface waters
that do not meet the State’s water quality standards. This

* “Pollutant” is defined in 33 U.S.C. §1362(6) as meaning “dredged
spoil, solid waste, incinerator residue, sewage, garbage, sewage sludge,
munitions, chemical wastes, biological materials, radioactive materials,
heat, wrecked or discarded equipment, rock, sand, cellar dirt and
industrial, municipal, and agricultural waste discharged into water.”

14

provision of Florida law, addressing both point source
pollutants and non-point source pollution, is a state
program in accordance with the planning requirements of
Section 303(d) of the CWA. 33 U.S.C. §1313(d).

To now impose the additional regulatory requirement
of obtaining an NPDES point source permit for the trans-
fer of water from one body to another would place LWDD
and other water control districts in the position of not only
having to engage in a separate and costly permitting
process, but of potentially having to treat water at each
point source to remove already existing pollutants. And, at
least based on the Ninth Circuit’s view, this would be the
case even where there is no net increase in the level of
pollutants in the receiving body of water. See, Committee
to Save Mokelumne River v. East Bay Municipal Utility
District, 13 F.3d 305 (9th Cir. 1993). The point source/non-
point source regulatory system created by the CWA and its
implementation by the state and federal governments
militate against the Eleventh Circuit’s expansive view of
the NPDES point source permitting process and the
inordinate and unwarranted regulatory burden it would
place on state and local water management and water
control entities.

That NPDES point source permits were not intended
by the Congress to apply to the transfer of surface water
and stormwater from one navigable body to another is
readily apparent from a review of the legislative history
and the actual implementation of the NPDES point source
permitting process, at least in the State of Florida. Senate
Report No. 92-414, The Federal Water Pollution Control
Act Amendments of 1971 Report of the Committee on
Public Works, discusses in significant detail the legislative
intent behind the CWA including the reasons for, and the

15

nature of, the permit system addressing the discharge of
pollutants into the country’s navigable waters. In the
discussions regarding point sources, and the need to
regulate the discharge of pollutants from point sources, it
is abundantly clear that the focus is on industrial and
municipal waste point sources, i.e., controlling the dis-
charge of pollutants at their original source. For example,
in establishing federal standards of performance for the
control of the discharge of pollutants from “new sources”™
under Section 306 of the CWA (33 U.S.C. §1316), the
Congress specifically listed twenty-eight specified indus-
tries which “must be constructed to meet a standard that
reflects the greatest degree of effluent reduction that can
be achieved by use of the latest available control technol-
ogy.” Senate Report No. 92-414, Section 306. The entire
list contained in 33 U.S.C. §1316(b)(1)(A) consists of
industrial and manufacturing endeavors. There are no
categories which even remotely resemble a water control
district.’

Throughout the remainder of the Senate Report all
references to point source discharges of pollutants reflect
the Senate’s intent to control industrial and municipal
waste discharges at their source, i.e., at their original

* The term “new source” is defined as “any source, the construction
of which is commenced after the publication of proposed regulations
prescribing a standard of performance under this section which will be
applicable to such source, if such standard is thereafter promulgated in
accordance with this section.” 33 U.S.C. §1316 (a)(2).

” See also 33 U.S.C. §1311(b)-(m) (addressing effluent limitations
for different categories of point sources) and 33 U.S.C. §1314(b) and (d)
(addressing levels of treatment required for industrial and municipal

waste point sources).

16

source. See United States v. Riverside Bayview Homes,
Inc., 474 U.S. 121, 132-133 (1985). Neither in this Senate
Report nor in any other part of the legislative history of
the CWA that amici curiae have discovered is there any
indication of Congress’ intent to regulate the transfer of
surface water and stormwater from one navigable body to
another by water control districts or water management
districts through the Section 402 NPDES permitting
program. Indeed, it would be a significant stretch to
classify the LWDD or any other similar entity as an
industrial or municipal waste operation or endeavor.

The permit application process itself lends additional
authoritative data to this view of Congress’ intent. In
Florida, the Section 402 NPDES permit program has been
delegated by EPA to the FDEP. The forms utilized by
FDEP in this permitting process demonstrate that the
enforcing agencies have not interpreted the CWA as
requiring, and have not contemplated, the applicability of
Section 402 NPDES permits to water control districts and
water management districts transferring surface waters
and stormwater from and to navigable waters, even
through point sources. Wastewater Facility or Activity
Permit Application Form 1 (App. 1-24) identifies the group
of forms, in addition to this general form, which are
necessary to apply for a permit for a wastewater facility or
activity under Chapter 62-620, Florida Administrative
Code. There are eight specific forms identified in Applica-
tion Form 1. (App. 1-2) The only form which could argua-
bly be applicable to the LWDD or other water control or
water management districts, is Form 2F. That form is
entitled “Permit to Discharge Stormwater Associated with
Industrial Activity.” (App. 25-54) Once again, the intent
that NPDES point source permits do not apply, and have

17

never been meant to apply, to the movement of water for
water control and management purposes is manifest. It is
no accident that for almost thirty (30) years such permits
had not been required of governmental entities that
transferred surface waters from one navigable body to
another. The language of the CWA, its legislative history,
the regulatory agencies’ application of the law and, until
Dubois, Catskill Mountains and Miccosukee Tribe of
Indians, the applicable case law established the non-
applicability of Section 402 to such activities.

LWDD has evaluated the impact of the Eleventh
Circuit’s decision in Miccosukee Tribe of Indians on its
operations and budget. It presents a case study on the
enormous cost locally and nationwide which would be
imposed by the Eleventh Circuit’s strict “but for” test for
requiring NPDES permits and demonstrates that the
Eleventh Circuit’s reading of this portion of the CWA could
not be what Congress intended.

LWDD is not an industrial plant, a publicly owned
treatment works (POTW) or a municipal separate storm
sewer system (MS4). It engages in no industrial activity,
treats no wastewater and, in the course of its operations,
introduces no pollutants into any of the waters under its
control. As previously noted, LWDD is a water control
district which operates a water management system
providing comprehensive flood control and water supply
protection. It is basically in the business of collecting and
moving water.

The LWDD consists of four separate basins. The entire
system consists of 17 major discharge structures, 13 minor
discharge structures, 56 aluminum or wood risers/gates
and 14 sheet pile weirs. The LWDD is bordered on the

18

west by the SFWMD L-40 canal which separates the
LWDD from WCA-1.

Its main source of water is WCA-1. Its canal system is
actually the receiving waters for much of Palm Beach
County, which is a regulated, NPDES permitted, Phase I
MS4 county. Phase I permits require all outfalls to waters
of the United States to have been identified and both
structural and non-structural Best Management Practices
(BMP) to have been implemented for the purpose of
improving the water quality of the receiving waters. Thus,
LWDD, whose waters are waters of the United States (see
amici curiae’s Brief in Support of Petition for Writ of
Certiorari, App. 1-19) is receiving NPDES permitted
water.

The district’s basins are defined by the direction of
water flow. Surface/stormwater is contained within each
basin, directed towards canals and, when necessary,
discharged. The four basins are the C-51 basin, the C-16
basin, the C-15 basin and the Hillsboro basin.

C-51 Basin — The C-51 Basin is approximately 65
square miles in size. It is the northernmost basin in the
LWDD. The C-51 canal (also known as the West Palm
Beach Canal) is the major collector of flow for the basin.
There are also 12 main Icteral canals (L-1 to L-12) and 5
equalizing canals (E-1, E-2E, E-2W and E-3 and E-4).
Water is directed from the lateral canals to the equalizers
to the C-51 which discharges into the Intracoastal Water-
way (ICWW), a navigable body outside the boundaries of
the LWDD. There are 3 control structures south of the C-
51 canal that discharge and maintain water levels. These
structures are known as the CS-2, CS-4 and CS-6. Along

19

its western border with the L-40 canal there is a gravity-
fed culvert that connects the LWDD L-23W canal with
WCA-1 at the SFWMD G94-C control structure. The L-
23W canal flows east to the E-1 equalizing canal and then
south into the L-30 lateral canal in the C-15 Basin from
which water is discharged by control structure CS-11.

C-16 Basin -— The C-16 Basin is approximately 65
square miles in size. It consists of 15 lateral canals (L-13
to L-27) and 4 equalizing canals (E-2W, E-2E, E-3 and E-
4). Flow in this basin is directed to the Boynton Canal, the
L-14 or the E-4. The E-4 is a partially natural channel
that runs through Lake Osborne, a navigable body within
the boundaries of LWDD. The L-14 discharges into the E-
4. E-4 and Boynton Canal discharge into the SFWMD C-16
which discharges into the ICWW. There are two control
structures to discharge and maintain water levels known
as the CS-8 and the CS-9.

C-15 Basin — The C-15 Basin is approximately 55
square miles in size. It consists of 15 lateral canals (L-28
to L-42) and 5 equalizing canals (E-1, E-2W, E-2E, E-3 and
E-4). The L-30, L-38, and E-4 canals are major collectors.
Flow from the L-30 is directed to the E-4, which is par-
tially a natural channel that runs through Lake Ida, a
navigable body within the boundaries of LWDD. The E-4
and L-38 discharge to the ICWW through the SFWMD C-
15 canal, which is the eastern extension of the L-38 canal.
There are two major control structures that discharge and
maintain water levels, known as the CS-11 and CS-12.

Hillsboro Basin — The Hillsboro Basin is approxi-
mately 60 square miles in size. It contains 9 lateral canals
(L-42 to L-50) and 6 equalizing canals (E-1W, E-1, E-2W,
E-2E, E-3 and E-4). The equalizing canals discharge to the

20

SFWMD’s Hillsboro Canal which then discharges to the
ICWW. There are 10 control structures to discharge and
maintain water levels known as the CS-1, CS-3, CS-14,
CS-15, CS-16, CS-17E, CS-17N, CS-17W, CS-19 and CS-
20.

It bears repeating that the LWDD system includes 17
major discharge structures, 13 minor discharge structures
and scores of risers/gates and weirs. All of the canals in
the LWDD are navigable bodies of water. Given the lan-
guage of the CWA and the broad interpretation EPA and
the courts® have given to the definition of “point-source,”
all of LWDD’s structures could be considered point
sources. And given the Eleventh Circuit’s decision, the
LWDD structures have the potential to discharge pollut-
ants to navigable waters because a) any of the structures
could theoretically separate waters of different quality
(e.g., a Weir can cause upstream water to be stagnant), b)
there are a number of potential land sources of pollution
(non-point sources) within LWDD that contribute to the
generation of pollutants, and c) LWDD’s canals have been
determined to be navigable waters.

Most surface waters (waters of the United States)
contain pollutants. If, as the Eleventh Circuit has now
held, simply passing that water through a drainage
structure to another surface water could be considered the
“addition of pollutants” as set forth in the CWA, thus
requiring an NPDES point source permit, it is likely that

* See, e.g., United States v. Earth Sciences, Inc., 599 F.2d 368, 374
(10th Cir. 1979); Colvin v. United States, 181 F. Supp. 2d 1050, 1056
(C.D. Cal., 2001).

IPI O NLA, 9,

eS oe oe -

21

most drainage control structures would be subject to
permitting. Therefore, based on this overly expansive view
of the concept of discharge, every LWDD structure could

require a permit. —

Historically, the EPA and the State of Florida have not
required permits from systems such as the LWDD. How-
ever, when drainage systems contain stormwater treat-
ment, the State has required permitting either through
the NPDES MS4 program or the NPDES industrial
wastewater program. Indeed, treatment, usually at the
point of discharge, is a key component of the point source
permitting process.

While theoretically each and every LWDD structure
could be required to obtain an NPDES point source per-
mit, due to the interconnected nature of the LWDD system
and assuming a permitting effort to be focused on improv-
ing the quality of discharge, LWDD has, for purposes of
this discussion, anticipated that permits would be issued
for each of the four basins within the district. The poten-
tial scenario, then, would be that permits would be issued
for the C-51, C-16, C-15 and Hillsboro Canal basins. And
since LWDD is not a municipal separate storm sewer
system, it would appear that following the lower court’s
decision the NPDES industrial program, rather than the
MS4 program, would be the permitting process LWDD
would be subjected to.

While point source dischargers’ performance is in-
tended under the NPDES program to be measured by

22

strict technology-based effluent limitations,’ given the
nature of LWDD and other water control systems (i.e.,
non-industrial, non-municipal waste dischargers), treating
LWDD’s transfer of water through its control structures as
point source discharges in the permitting process would
require the district to meet traditional State criteria
establishing a discharge standard for the particular
system. In establishing the discharge standard LWDD
would need to address at least three items.

1. LWDD would need to meet Water Quality Based
Effluent Limitations (WQBEL) as that process is defined
in Chapter 62-650, Florida Administrative Code. WQBELs
establish effluent limits that a discharger must meet to
protect the water quality of the receiving water body. The
goal is to establish the quality of discharge necessary to
protect the receiving water body and the effluent limit is
based on protecting the surface water rather than being a
level of treatment that technology can readily meet. See
Rule 62-650.200, Florida Administrative Code.

2. A cause or contribute analysis must also be done
to demonstrate that the discharge at issue does not cause
or contribute to the failure of the receiving surface water
to meet all water quality criteria at all times.

3. LWDD would also be required to comply with the
anti-degradation requirements of rules 62-4.242 and 62-
302.300, Florida Administrative Code, prohibiting the
lowering of water quality that is above criteria unless the
proposed discharge is necessary or desirable under federal

* See EPA v. California ex rel. State Water Resources Control Board,
426 U.S. 200, 204-205 (1976).

23

standards and are clearly in the public interest. Lowering
of water quality below applicable criteria is deemed to be
not in the public interest and will not be permitted.

In addition, Florida is in the process of implementing
a Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) program pursuant
to Section 403.067, Florida Statutes. A TMDL is the total
pollutant loading allowed into a water of the United States
that will not cause the water body to violate water quality
standards.” Integral to the State’s TMDL program is the
requirement to address pollutant load reduction goals
through effluent limitations in NPDES permits. The
TMDL for any water body includes point and non-point
source loading, natural background loading and a margin

for error.

The Section 402 NPDES permit process also involves
an extensive water quality monitoring program. Tradi-
tionally included is a review of the industrial ‘Process
involved in the generation ef the pollutants being dis-
charged. This component of the review is not particularly
well-suited to the non-point discharges that would con-
tribute pollutants to the LWDD system. As previously
noted, the LWDD’s canal system is actually the receiving
waters for much of Palm Beach County. Almost fifty
percent of the area located within the LWDD’s boundaries
is urban and is already the subject of the BMPs of a Phase
I MS4 permit. Pollutant generation within the LWDD is
likely to depend upon land uses which generally consist of

For an overview of TMDLs see The Clean Water Act Handbook,
Second Edition (Mark Ryan, ed. 2003) (a publication of the American
Bar Association Section of Environment, Energy and Resources).

24

mixed residential, including high density properties such
as apartments, commercial and some rural property.
Residential properties can contribute significantly to non-
point source pollution through stormwater runoff from
yards that can include vegetation (e.g., grass clippings),
herbicides, pesticides, fertilizers and general debris.
Commercial property can be a source of both point and
non-point source pollution, although most point sources
would be expected to already be regulated under NPDES.
Non-point sources would include oil and grease from roads
and parking lots, pesticides, herbicides, fertilizers and
general debris. Rural areas can be a significant source of
nutrients from agricultural operations (e.g., phosphorus)
which are specifically exempt from the definition of point
sources. See 33 U.S.C. §1362(14).

To determine a potential cost for obtaining NPDES
point source permits, LWDD looked at monitoring costs,
additional software and system costs (e.g., the develop-
ment of a geographic information system), enhanced data
management costs, permit application fees, application
development costs and permit implementation costs.
Excluding permit implementation, it is estimated that the
additional costs to LWDD, including the permit renewal
fees at the end of the five year permit would range from
$238,000 to $274,000. (E Sciences Report, n.2. supra)
However, by far, the greatest element of cost is permit
implementation.

Given the goals and the function of the NPDES point
source- permit program, it must be assumed that the
process would require meeting State water quality crite-
ria. At present, LWDD provides water quantity control
only. The prospect of requiring water quality treatment
through a Section 402 NPDES permit would, in effect,

25

require the wholesale retrofit of a large portion of Palm
Beach County. While the total cost of compliance could
possibly be shared with the permitted MS4, as well as
other point source dischargers into the system, at present
it is not possible to distinguish between those sources for
the determination of a pro rata share. In any event, the
overall cost of compliance is sure to be significant.

In 1998, Florida identified water bodies for which the
ambient water quality did not meet established standards
pursuant to Section 303(d) of the CWA. Such waters are
considered impaired and are potential candidates for the
implementation of a TMDL process. According to the 1998
303(d) list, three of LWDD’s four basins discharge to
impaired waters. The fourth basin (C-15) has three listed
lateral canals and due to the interconnected nature of the
system would likely need to meet established TMDLs as

well.

As previously noted, in establishing the discharge
standard LWDD would need to address in the point source
permit program, the district would need to meet tradi-
tional criteria, including WQBELs. It is difficult to specifi- |
cally quantify the costs of plan implementation at the
present time in the absence of the presentation of relevant
data to the regulating agencies as well as the absence of
discharge standards promulgated by the agencies for the
non-industrial LWDD. There is, however, an analogy that
can be made to the cost of implementing TMDLs since,
arguably, WQBELs are nothing more than TMDL re-
quirements imposed on a point source basis.

26

A cost analysis for retrofitting urban watersheds
based on meeting TMDL requirements was included in a
study done for the City of Tallahassee." Applying this
analysis to the establishment of discharge standards
through the utilization of WQBELs and anti-degradation
criteria does provide us with a scope of the potential costs
of Section 402 NPDES permit implementation for LWDD.

The specific details of TMDL allocation procedures are
outlined in a document prepared by FDEP and titled A
Report to the Governor and the Legislature on the Alloca-
tion of Total Maximum Daily Loads in Florida, date
February 1, 2001. The initial allocation process would first
calculate the amount of pollutant reductions that would be
achieved if 45% of all agricultural and silvicultural opera-
tions implemented the appropriate BMPs, 45% of all
urban areas met stormwater treatment requirements for
new construction and 45% of homes with septic tanks
within the one hundred year flood plain were hooked up to
a regional sewer system. If the reductions obtained are not
sufficient to meet the TMDL then the same calculations
are done at a level of 90%. If the reductions are still
insufficient to meet the TMDL, reductions are to be
allocated to sources in increments of 10% until the TMDL
is met. Based on calculating the cost of compliance by
multiplying the acreage in the LWDD requiring treatment
to achieve either the 45% or 90% treatment standard by
the cost of treatment per unit area (based on available
data), the range of the estimated cost of complying with
Section 402 NPDES permits for the discharge of water

"" Methodology for TMDL Preliminary Cost Analysis, City of
Tallahassee, Stormwater Management Division (2001).

27

through LWDD’s control structures (i.e., its point-sources)
would be between 424.5 million and 849 million dollars. (E
Sciences Report, n.2, supra) And while these costs are
approximate and based upon several assumptions, it
should also be noted that costs would increase should the
described level of treatment in the first two steps (.e., at
45% and 90% levels) not be adequate to achieve the

desired result.

The relevance of this cost analysis, even if rough and
approximate, is readily apparent. First, if the range of
costs were even only one-fourth of this estimate, the
burden would be extraordinary on a district (LWDD) with
an annual budget of approximately 12 million dollars.
Second, LWDD is only one of approximately one hundred
water control and water management districts located in
the State of Florida and one of thousands located in the
country, many of which have much smaller budgets and
much less capability to handle such permit implementa-
tion costs. The cost of requiring Section 402 NPDES
permits for every point source that merely transfers water
from one navigable body to another would be astronomical.
Third, these astronomical costs would be imposed on
governmental bodies whose function it is to move and
manage water for a variety of water quantity reasons
(flood control, irrigation, public drinking, water supply,
etc.) and who have added no pollutants to the water from
their receipt of it to their transfer of it. Fourth, this
astronomical cost would be imposed by the federal gov-
ernment on state and local governments through an
expanded definition of point source discharge (i.e., “addi-
tion” of pollutants) which, for all intents and purposes,
would usurp the states’ retained (under the CWA) rights
and responsibilities when it comes to water management.

28

Finally, the potential astronomical cost of requiring a
Section 402 NPDES permit for every structure which
transfers water from one navigable body of water to
another without the introduction of additional pollutants
is itself, standing alone, strong evidence that Congress did
not intend NPDES industrial permits to apply to this
situation.

Ultimately, the Eleventh Circuit’s decision is counter-
productive to the goal of clean water. Its focus on regulat-
ing the movement of water within or among navigable
bodies is a misguided diversion. Through true point source
industrial discharge permits, non-point source processes
and permits, TMDLs and the establishment of state water
quality criteria, the focus is more appropriately on ad-
dressing and treating pollution and pollutants at their
source rather than in the course of their travels within
unitary or connected waters of the United States. If
Congress had intended otherwise it would simply have
prohibited the transfer of any waters containing any
pollutants through any point sources without the qualifi-
cation of an “addition” of pollutants to the navigable
waters of the United States. This Congress did not do,
deciding, as it did, that cost was a factor to be taken into
account in establishing effluent limits. National Wildlife
Federation v. Gorsuch, supra at 178, n.65.

Historically, EPA has never required LWDD or other
water control districts to obtain an NPDES point source
permit to transfer water from one navigable body to
another. Surface water management systems have been
established and flood control projects constructed under
state water management programs utilizing the non-point
source permitting processes to address water quality
issues in such circumstances. Nothing has changed by way

29

of Congressional enactment to modify that process. In
essence, the Eleventh Circuit’s extension of the NPDES
industrial point source permit process, expanding on cases
such as Dubois and Catskill Mountains, is tantamount to
amending the Clean Water Act, a process not properly
within the ambit of judicial authority.

It is to be recalled that there are significant civil and
even criminal penalties for violating the CWA.” As it is,
with regard to the civil penalties under the Act, CWA is a
strict liability statute. See Kelly v. United States Environ-
mental Protection Agency, 203 F.3d 519, 523 (7th Cir. 2000)
(and cases cited therein). If it was the intent of Congress
that water control and water management districts such
as LWDD were required to obtain NPDES point source
permits, thereby incurring potential costs as outlined
herein, and further subjecting such districts to strict
liability civil penalties and the potential criminal penalties
(for negligent or knowing violations), then it is incumbent
upon the Congress to make that intent manifest and clear.
Despite the Eleventh Circuit's determination to the
contrary (without any discussion of Congressional intent),
Congress has not done so.

¢

CONCLUSION

The decision below expands the reach of the NPDES
industrial point source permitting program far beyond its
historical application and in a manner not supported by

" See 33 U.S.C. Sections 1319, 1342.

30

either the language of the Clean Water Act or its legisla-
tive history. Water management and water control dis-
tricts such as those represented by amici curiae have not
previously been required to obtain NPDES industrial point
source permits for the mere movement of water within
their own systems or between their own navigable water
bodies and others. To require such permitting would
impose an inordinate burden, operationally and finan-
cially, on such districts without any showing of an appre-
ciable improvement in overall water quality. This was not
the intent of Congress in passing the Clean Water Act and
in requiring permits for the industrial discharge of pollut-
ants into the waters of the United States. Accordingly, the
decision below should be reversed.

Respectfully submitted,

KENNETH G. SPILLIAS
Counsel of Record
TERRY E. LEWIS
STEPHEN A. WALKER
MICHELLE DIFFENDERFER
LEWIS, LONGMAN & WALKER, P.A.
1700 Palm Beach Lakes Blvd.
Suite 1000
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
(561) 640-0820
Counsel for Amici Curiae,
Lake Worth Drainage District
and Florida Association of
Special Districts

1 PV YOO VEYA ST ae KOMIDPIETEK ew a

TONS yong et © & Perm\+
ae water Xa say or or ac Kvihy Und

. >
es her U a- LAD, FAC.
App. 1
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
[LOGO]

FLORIDA
WASTEWATER FACILITY OR -

ACTIVITY PERMIT
APPLICATION FORM 1
GENERAL INFORMATION

Re

ea guns jem
ae mG hapl ast OPAC sacl ee

e JOTTNAD wh eu >
Se ae ee Sim
oes by : on

; : bs Res Ce we hs

¢ Va, ° in | * ~

DESCRIPTION OF PERMIT APPLICATION FORMS

Form 1 — General information. This booklet includes
general information on applying for a permit for a waste-
water facility or activity under Chapter 62-620, Florida
Administrative Code (F.A.C.). Form 1 is required for all
permit applications.

Form 2 — Specific information. This group of forms in-
cludes the specific information required for the type of
wastewater facility or activity for which a permit is
needed. Select the appropriate form(s) to be submitted
with Form 1.

Form 2A — Domestic Wastewater Facilities.

Form 2B — Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations
and Aquatic Anima! Production Facilities.

Form 2CS — Industrial Wastewater Facilities (dis-
charging process wastewater to surface waters).

See Sore 1 to determine which other
application Syrms You will need.

App. 2

Form 2CG —- Industrial Wastewater Facilities (dis-
charging process wastewater to ground water).

Form 2ES — Industrial Wastewater Facilities (dis-
charging non-process wastewater to surface waters).

Form 2EG - Industrial Facilities (discharging non-
process wastewater to ground water).

Form 2F — Stormwater Discharge Associated with In-

dustrial Activity
Form 2CR — Non-Discharging/Closed Loop Recycle
System.

SECTION A —- GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS
Who Must Apply:

Persons who are or are going to discharge wastewater
to waters of Florida or the United States must file for and
be granted a permit under Sections 403.087, 403.088, or
403.0885, Florida Statutes (F.S.). Persons that discharge
stormwater associated with industrial activity to surface
waters of the state must file for and be granted a permit
under Section 403.0885, F.S. There are severe penalties
for discharging without a permit.

There are some exceptions to this requirement.
Discharges of domestic sewage from vessels and dis-
charges from properly operating marine engines are not
required to have a permit under the laws listed above.
However, discharges of rubbish, trash, garbage or other
such materials discharged overboard do require permits.
Vessels operated in a capacity other than as a means of
transportation are required to have a permit if they are
discharging to waters. These types include vessels used as
an energy or mining facility, a storage facility, 2 seafood

App. 3

processing facility, or an anchored facility for the purpose
of mineral or oil exploration or development.

The introduction of sewage, industrial wastes, or
other pollutants into a domestic wastewater treatment
facility does not need a permit under Sections 403.087,
403.088 or 403.0885, F.S. Persons discharging to permit-
ted wastewater treatment facilities must comply with all
applicable pretreatment standards. If a person has a plan
or an agreement to switch from direct discharge into
waters of the state to discharge to a domestic treatment
facility, it does not relieve the person from obtaining a
permit for the discharge until such time as the connection
is made and the discharge is stopped.

Most discharges from agricultura! ~nd silvicultural
activities to waters of the state do not require a permit
under Sections 403.087, 403.088, or 403.0885, F.S. How-
ever, permits under those sections are required for dis-
charges from concentrated animal feeding operations,
concentrated aquatic animal production facilities, activi-
ties associated with approved aquaculture projects, and
silvicultural point sources.

Where to Apply:

Permit applications must be filed with the Depart-
ment of Environmental Protection (DEP) district office
shown in Figure 1 for the county in which the wastewater
facility or activity is located, except for permit applications
for steam electrical generating power plants which are
filed with the DEP offices in Tallahassee. DEP officers are
located at

[Figure 1. State Map Showing DEP District Offices
Omitted In Printing]

App. 4

NORTHWEST DISTRICT NORTHEAST DISTRICT
160 Government Center, 7825 Baymeadows Way,

Ste 308 Suite B-200
Pensacola, Florida 32501-5794 Jacksonville, Florida
Phone No. (850) 585-8300 32256-7577

Phone No. (904) 448-4300

SOUTHWEST DISTRICT CENTRAL DISTRICT
3804 Coconut Palm Drive 3319 Maguire Boulevard,
Tampa, Florida 33619-8318 Suite 232

Phone No. (813) 744-6100

Orlando, Florida 32803-3767
Phone No. (407) 894-7555

SOUTH DISTRICT SOUTHEAST DISTRICT
2295 Victoria Avenue, 400 North Congress Avenue

Suite 364 West Palm Beach, Florida
Fort Myers, Florida 33901 33401

Phone No. (941) 332-6975 Phone No. (561) 681-6600

When to Apply:

Applications must be filed with the appropriate DEP
office 180 days before your current permit expires or 180
days before startup of a new or modified facility. If the
submitted application is for a new facility or for a modifi-
cation of an existing facility, the information required for
describing the construction must be filed at least 90 days
before construction begins. The DEP encourages appli-
cants to file the materials describing the construction of a
new facility or the modification of an existing facility as
early as possible to avoid problems with delays in startup
or facility redesign to achieve effluent limitations.

Federal regulations provide that a new source in the
NPDES program may not be constructed or started to be
constructed before the issuance of an operation permit.
Because of this regulation, a permit application for a new

App. 5

source may need to be submitted well in advance of the
required 180 days.

Fees:

Application fees are listed in Section 62-4.050, Florida
Administrative Code (F.A.C.). An application will not be
processed until the application fee has been paid. If the
DEP determines that a permit should be issued for less
than five years duration, the application fee will be pro
rated.

If permit is issued for a surface water discharge, the
permittee will be assessed a regulatory and surveillance
program fee annually. Those fees are listed in Section 62-
4.052, F.A.C. Failure to pay the annual fee may result in
revocation of the permit.

Availability of Information to the Public:

Information contained in these applications forms
will, upon request, be made available to the public for
inspection and copying. However, you may request confi-
dential treatment for certain information which you may
submit to supplement the information requested on these
forms. Section 62-620.302, F.A.C., and 40 CFR 2 provide
set forth the procedures for making the claim. No informa-
tion on Forms 1 and 2A through 2EG may be claimed as
confidential.

Completion of Forms:

Unless otherwise specified in instructions to the
forms, each item in each form must be answered. To
indicate that each item has been considered, enter “NA”,
for not applicable, if a particular item does not fit the
circumstances or characteristics of your facility or activity.

App. 6

If you have previously submitted information to the
DEP which answers a question, you may either repeat the
information in the space provided or attach a copy of the
previous submission. DO NOT WRITE “ON FILE”. Some
items in the form require narrative explanation. If more
space is necessary to answer a question, attach a separate
sheet entitled “Additional Information.”

SECTION B —- FORM 1 LINE-BY-LINE INSTRUCTIONS
This form must be completed by all applicants.
Completing This Form:

Please type or print in the underlined areas only.
Some items have a limited number of spaces or characters
so that your response may be entered into a computer
program. Please do not exceed this maximum number with
your response. Abbreviate if necessary to stay within the
number of characters allowed for each item. Use one space
for breaks between words, but not for punctuation marks
unless they are needed to clarify your response.

Item 1

Space is provided at the upper right hand corner of
Form 1 for insertion of your Facility Identification Num-
ber. If you have an existing facility, enter your identifica-
tion number. If you don’t know your identification number,
please contact the appropriate DEP office which will
provide you with your number. If your facility is new (not
yet constructed), leave this item blank.

Item II

Answer each question to determine which supplemen-
tary forms you need to fill out. Be sure to check the

— eee eee

App. 7

glossary in Section C of these instructions for the legal
definitions of any words you are not certain of their
meaning.

If you answer “no” to every question, then you may
not need a permit. However, you should call the appropri-
ate district office to determine if you have made a correct
determination. If you answer “yes” to any question, then
you must complete and file the supplementary form by the
deadline listed in Section A along with this form.

Item III

Enter the facility’s official or legal name. Do not use a
colloquial name.

Item IV

Give the name, title, and work telephone number of a
person who is thoroughly familiar with the operation of
the facility, with the facts reported in this application, and
who can be contacted by reviewing offices if necessary.

Item V

Give the complete mailing address of the office where
correspondence should be sent. This often is not the
address used to designate the location of the facility or
activity.

Item VI

Give the address or location of the facility identified in
Item III of this form. If the facility lacks a street name or
route number, give the most accurate alternative geo-
graphic information (for example, section number or
quarter section number from county records or at intersec-
tion of Rts 426 and 22).

App. 8

Item VII

List four, in descending order of significance, 4-digit
standard industrial classification (SIC) codes which best
describe your facility in terms of the principal products or
services you produce or provide. Also, specify each classifi-
cation in words. These classifications may differ from the
SIC codes describing the operation generating the dis-
charge from the facility.

SIC code numbers are descriptions which may be
found in the “Standard Industrial Classification Manual”
prepared by the Executive Office of the President, Office of
Management and Budget, which is available from the
Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. Your local
library may have a copy of this publication which you may
use. Use the current edition of the manual. If you have
any questions concerning the appropriate SIC code for
your facility, please contact the appropriate DEP district
office.

Item VII-A

Give the name, as it is legally referred to, of the
person, firm, public organization, or any other entity
which operates the facility described in this application.
This may or may not be the same name as the facility. The
operator of the facility is the legal entity which controls
the facility’s operation rather than the plant or site man-
ager. Do not use a colloquial name.

Item VIII-B

Indicate whether the entity which operates the facility
also owns it by marking the appropriate box.

App. 9

Item VIII-C

Enter the appropriate letter to indicate the legal
status of the operator of the facility. Indicate “public” for a
facility solely owned by a local government, such as a city,
town, county, etc.

Items VIII-D through H

Enter the telephone number and address of the
operator identified in Item VIII-A.

Item IX

Indicate whether the facility is located on Indian
Lands.

Item X

Give the number of each presently effective wastewa-
ter and stormwater permit issued to the facility listed in
this application. List relevant federal, state, and local
permits. DO NOT LIST ALL YOUR PERMITS. LIST
ONLY CURRENT ENVIRONMENTAL PERMITS RE-
LATING TO THIS PROJECT.

Item XI

Provide a topographic map or maps of the area ex-
tending at least to one mile beyond the property bounda-
ries of the facility which clearly show the following:

The legal boundaries of the facility;

The location and serial number of each of your exist-
ing and proposed intake and discharge structures;

All hazardous waste management facilities;

Each well where you inject fluids underground; and

App. 10

All springs and surface water bodies in the area, plus
all drinking water wells within 1/4 mile of the facility
which are identified in the public record or otherwise
known to you.

If an intake or discharge structure, hazardous waste
disposal site, or injection well associated with the facility
is located more than one mile from the plan, include it on
the map, if possible. If not, attach additional sheets
describing the location of the structure, disposal site, or
well, and identify the U.S. Geological Survey (or other)
map corresponding to the location.

On each map, include the map scale, a meridian arrow
showing north, and latitude and longitude at the nearest
whole second. On all maps of rivers, show the direction of
the current, and in tidal waters, show the directions of the
ebb and flow tides. Use a 7-1/2 minute series map pub-
lished by the U.S. Geological Survey. If a 7-1/2 minute
series map has not been published for your facility site,
then you may use a 15 minute series map from the U.S.
Geological Survey. If neither a 7-1/2 nor 15 minute series
map has been published for your facility site, use a plat
map or other appropriate map, including all the requested
information; in this case, briefly describe land uses in the
map area (for example, residential, commercial).

You may trace your map from a geological survey
chart, or other map meeting the above specifications. If
you do, your map should bear a note showing the number
or title of the map or chart from which it was traced.
Include the names of nearby towns, water bodies, and
other prominent points.

App. 11

You may obtain a topographic map from:

Eastern Mapping Center

National Cartographic Information Center
U.S. Geological Survey

536 National Center

Reston, VA 22092

Item XII

Briefly describe the nature of your business (for
example, products produced or services provided).

Item XIII

Section 403.161, F.S., provides severe penalties for
submitting false information on this application form or
any reports or records required by a permit, if issued.
There are both civil and criminal penalties, in addition to
the revocation of the permit.

Rule 62-620.305, F.A.C., requires thai the application
and any reports required by the permit, if issued, to be
signed as follows:

A. For a corporation, by a responsible corporate offi-
cer as described in Rule 62-620.305, F.A.C.;

B. For partnership or sole proprietorship, by a gen-
eral partner or the proprietor, respectively; or

C. For a municipality, state, federal or other public
facility, by a principal executive officer or elected
official.

App. 12

SECTION C —- GLOSSARY

NOTE: This Glossary includes terms used in the instruc-
tions and in Forms 1, 2A through 2EG. If you have any
questions concerning the meaning of any of these terms,
please contact your DEP district office.

Activity means any action which results in a discharge of
wastes into waters of the State or that is reasonably
expected to be a source of water pollution.

Aliquot means a sample of specified volume used to make
up a total composite sample.

Animal Feeding Operation means a lot or facility (other
than an aquatic animal production facility) where the

following conditions are met:

A. Animals (other than aquatic animals) have
been, are, or will be stabled or confined and fed
or maintained for a total of 45 days or more in
any 12 month period; and

B. Crops, vegetation, forage growth, or post-
harvest residues are not sustained in the normal
growing season over any portion of the lot or fa-
cility.

Two or more animal feeding operations under
common ownership are a single animal feeding
operation if they adjoin each other or if they use
a common area or system for the disposal of
wastes.

Animal Unit means a unit of measurement for any
animal feeding operation_calculated by adding the fol-
lowing number: The number of slaughter and feeder
cattle multiplied by 1.0; plus the number of mature
dairy cattle multiplied by 1.4; plus the number of swine
weighing over 25 kilograms (approximately 55 pounds)

—

App. 13

multiplied by 0.4; plus the number of sheep multiplied
by 0.1; plus the number of horses multiplied by 2.0.

Application means the approved DEP standard forms for
applying for a permit, including any approved additions,
revisions, or modifications to the forms. Approved forms
are numbered, Form 62-620.910, and have an effective
date of October 1, 1994, or later.

Aquifer means a geological formation, group of forma-
tions, or part of a formation that is capable of yielding a
significant amount of water to a well or spring.

Best Management Practices (BMP) means schedules of
activities, prohibitions of practices, maintenance proce-
dures, and other management practices to prevent or
reduce the pollution of waters of the United States.
BMPs include treatment requirements, operation proce-
dures, and practices to control plant site runoff, spillage
or leaks, sludge or waste disposal, or drainage from raw
material storage.

Biological Monitoring Test means any test which
include the use of aquatic algal, invertebrate, or verte-
brate species to measure acute or chronic toxicity, and
any biological or chemical measure of bioaccumulation.

Bypass means the intentional diversion of wastes from
any portion of a treatment facility.

Concentrated Animal Feeding Operation means an
animal feeding operation which meets the criteria set
forth in Chapter 62-670, F.A.C.

Concentrated Aquatic Animal Production Facility
means a hatchery, fish farm, or other facility which
contains, grows or hold aquatic animals as set forth in
Chapter 62-660, F.A.C.

App. 14

Contact Cooling Water means water used to reduce
temperature which comes into contact with a raw mate-
rial, intermediate product, waste product other than
heat, or finished product.

CWA means the Clean Water Act as amended, 33 U.S.C.
1251 et seq.

Dike means any embankment or ridge of either natural or
manmade materials used to prevent the movement of
liquids, sludges, solids, or other materials.

Discharge (of a Pollutant) means any addition of any
pollutant or combination of pollutants to waters of the
State from any point source; or any addition of any pol-
lutant or combination of pollutants to the marine waters
of the State from any point source other than a vessel or
other floating craft which is being used as a means of
transportation.

This definition includes discharges into waters of the
State from surface runoff which is collected or chan-
neled by man; discharges through pipes, sewers, or
other conveyances owned by the State, a municipality,
or other person which do not lead to POTWs; and dis-
charges through pipes, sewers, or other conveyances,
leading into privately owned treatment works. This
term does not include an addition of pollutants by any
indirect discharge.

Effluent Limitation mean any restriction imposed by the
DEP on quantities, discharge rates, and concentrations
of pollutants which are discharged from point sources
into waters of the State.

Effluent Limitation Guideline means a regulation
published under Section 304(b) of the Clean Water Act
to adopt or revise effluent limitations.

EPA means the United States Environmental Protection
Agency.

- . | onitri ichloro- 1,1,2,2-
to ewer Thickening wh. any ll Mion ! Benzene bromomethane Tetrachloroe-
5-L Gravi = | Bromoform 1,1-Dichloroethane thane
y neg Carbon Tetra- 1,2-Dichloroethane Tetrachloro-
| hloride 1,1-Dichloroe- ethylene
TABLE 2F-2 . -
Chlorobenzene thylene Toluene
CONVENTIONAL AND NON-CONVENTIONAL | Chlorodi- 1,2-Dichloro- 1,2-Trans,
POLLUTANTS REQU!RED TO BE TESTED | besenestibane propane Dichloroethylene
BY EXISTING DISCHARGER IF EXPECTED Chloroethane 1,3-Dichloro- 1;1,1-Trichloroe-
TO BE PRESENT 2-Chloroethylviny!l propylene thane
Aluminum, Total Manganese, Total ) Ether Ethylbenzene 1,1,2-Trichloroe-
Barium, Total Nitrate-Nitrite | Methyl Bromide _thane
Boron, Total Nitrogen, Total Organic | Methyl Chloride Trichloroethylene

Bromide Oil and Grease | Vinyl Chloride

App. 42

Acid Compounds

2-Chlorophenol 2,4-Dinitrophenol Pentachlorophenol
2,4-Dichlorophenol 2-Nitrophenol Phenol

2,4-Dimethyl- 4-Nitrophenol 2,4,6-Trichloro-

phenol . p-Chloro-M-Cresol phenol
4,6-Dinitro-O-

Cresol

Base/Neutral

Acenaphthene 2-Chloronaphtha- Fluroanthene
Acenaphthylene lene Fluorene
Anthracene 4-Chlorophenyl Hexachlorobenzene
Benzidine : Phenyl Ether ~ Hexachlorobutadiene
Benzo(a)anthracene Chrysene Hexachloroethane’= -
Benzo(a)pyrene Dibenzo(a,hjan- Indeno(1,2,3-ed)
3,4-Benzofluroran- thracene pyrene

thene 1,2-Dichloroben- Isophorone
Benzo(ghi)perylene zene Napthalene

Benzo(k)fluoran- 1,3-Dichloroben- Nitrobenzene

App. 43

Pesticides
Aldrin Dieldrin PCB-1242
Alpha-BHC Alpha-Endosulfan PCB-1254
Beta-BHC Beta-Endosulfan PCB-1221

Gamma-BHC _ Endosulfan Sulfate PCB-1232

Delta-BHC Endrin PCB-1248
Chlordane Endrin Aldehyde PCB-1260
4,4-DDT Heptachlor PCB-1016
4,4-DDE Heptachlor Epoxide Toxaphene
4,4-DDD

TABLE 2F-4
HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES REQUIRED TO BE
IDENTIFIED BY APPLICANT IF EXPECTED

thene zene N-Nitrosodimethy]-
Bis(2-chloroe- 1,4-Dichloroben- amine
thoxy)methane zene N-Nitrosodi-N-
Bis(2-chloroe- 3,3-Dichlorobenzi- Propylamine
thylether dine N-Nitrosodipheny]-
Bis(2-chloro- Diethyl Phthalate amine
isopropyliether Dimethyl Phtha- Phenanthrene
Bis(2-ethyly- late Pyrene
hexyl)phthalate Di-N-Butyl Phtha- 1,2,4-Trichloroben-
4-Bromophenyl late zene
Phenyl Ether 2,4-Dinitrotoluene
Butylbenzyl 2,6-Dinitrotoluene
Phthalate Di-N-Octylphtha-
late
1,2-Diphenylhydra-
zine

(as Azobenzene)

TO BE PRESENT
Toxic Pollutant
Asbestos
Hazardous Substances

_Acetaldehyde Dinitrobenzene Parathion

Allyl alcohol Diquat Phenolsulfonate

Allyl chloride Disulfoton Phosgene

Amy] acetate Diuron Progargite

Aniline - Epichlorohydrin Propylene oxide

Benzonitrile Ethion Pyrethrins

Benzy!] chloride Ethylene diamine Quinoline

Butyl acetate Ethylene dibromide Resorcinol

Butylamine Formaldehyde Stronthium

Carbaryl Furfural Strychnine

Carbofuran Guthion Styrene

Carbon disulfide Isoprene 2,4,5-T (2,4,5-

Chlorpyrifos Isopropanolamine _ Trichloro-

Coumaphos Kelthane phenoxyacetic

Cresol Kepone acid)

Crotonaldehyde Malathion

App. 44
Cyclohexane Mercaptodimethur TDE (Tetrachloro-
2,4-D (2,4-dichloro- Methoxychlor diphenyl
phenoxyacetic Methylmercaptan ethane)
acid) Methyl 2,4,5-TP (2-(2,4,5-
Diazinon methacrylate Trichlorophenoxy)
Dicamba Methyl parathion _ propanoic acid)
Dichlobenil Mevinphos Trichlorofan
Dichlone Mexacarbate Triethylamine
2,2-Dichloropro- Monoethyl amine Trimethylamine
pionic acid Monomethy! amine Uranium
Dichorvos Naled Vanadium
Diethyl amine Napthenic acid _- Vinyl acetate
Dimethyl amine Nitrotoluene Xylene
Xylenol
Zirconium
FORM {LOGO}

2F

APPLICATION FOR PERMIT FOR
STORMWATER DISCHARGE ASSOCIATED
WITH INDUSTRIAL ACTIVITY

Facility 1.D. Number

Please type or print in black ink. If additional space is
needed for your answer, use plain sheets and attach to
the application form.

I. Outfall Location:

For each outfall, list the latitude and longitude of
its location to the nearest 15 seconds and the name
of the receiving water.

App. 45

A. Outfall D. Receiving
Number (list) | B. Latitude | C. Longitude | Water (Name)

II. Improvements:

A. Are you now required by any Federal, State, or
local authority to meet any implementation sched-
ule for the construction, upgrading or operation of
stormwater or wastewater treatment equipment or
practices or any other environmental programs
which may affect the discharges described in this
application? This includes, but is not limited to,
permit conditions, administrative or enforcement
orders, enforcement compliance schedule letters,
stipulations, court orders, and grant or loan condi-
tions?

1. Identification of lo. Affected Outfalls
Conditions, Agreements No

. |Source of Discharge

App. 46

3. Brief Description of Project |4. Final Compliance Date

a. required |b. projected

III.

B. You may attach additional sheets describing
any additional water pollution or other environ-
mental projects which may affect your discharge
that you now have underway or which you plan. In-
dicate whether each program is now underway or
planned, and indicate your actual or planned
schedules for construction.

Site Drainage Map:

Attach a site map showing topography depicting the
facility including each of its intake and discharge
structures; the drainage area of each stormwater
outfall; paved areas and buildings within the drain-
age area of each stormwater outfall; each known
past or present areas used for outdoor storage or
disposal of significant materials; each existing
structural control measure to reduce pollutants in
stormwater runoff, materials loading and access ar-
eas, areas where pesticides, herbicides, soil condi-
tioners and fertilizers are applied; each of its
hazardous waste treatment, storage or disposal
units; each well where fluids from the facility are
injected underground; springs, and other surface
water bodies which receive stormwater discharges
from the facility. Show hazardous waste storage or
disposal areas that do not require a RCRA permit
separate from those which do require a permit.

—— Es J>VEMIISem
11 10] wuuad sayemarsem s Ariss oy Ut parsr) 1uRIM[Jod Aue 40 0} oo(gns s1 AwpIOR) OM YOY suNapINT joN|ye UW UF PoHUNY sf HYD JHMINJOd Yow? IST] - G HEA
anal onal Hd
srucydsoyy [#10
uaSo NIN aUAIN + BENIN
uatonn fyepyaly [eo]
(ssi)
Sptios pepuadsng jo |
(GOO) pueweq
UaBAxc) jeonmey, )
(‘Gow puranc
UaBAxc) [eH UmY 201g
VIN aswoug Pur NO
musodwo- saINUTYY OL WE auisodwo) SoINUTY OF 188 ajquyrere si) saquing,
pojdues pawytiem-mojg | Buunc] uayey ajdweg quin] = — paryBiam-mojy Bung uaye, adureg quis} pu jueinjjog

SWUEIN|JOd JO $29IN0g ——e syun apnyour) sane a 23es20 (sywun apnjoui) sanye A wununut
wap jeEuCIPppe
JO} SUONINUISU! 29g JTEPNG Yow 40) 2}quH) GUO 2)2)dWO “ayqey sty Ut yuRINYJod AuaAe 404 SISAjEUR 9UO ysWD| JE JO HNSOs ay apisoud yen NEA - ¥ MEd

(Az meso 4 70 ¢ 1-47 2Bed mosy panupUC, >) Uo}euLsojUy 2BsEy>SqKCh “IIA

saqumny | Amie

App. 54

TTA (#016 Oz9-79 UBS 430
ayWUN)S2 JO JUSWAUNSEIW MOL JO POYPIW aig jo UONLOSIP & aplroug
(sun yaad ures
Apiseds) ayquunseow snoiraid jo
yaaa (sun Ajisads) pos ey (sayour ut) (saynurw ur)
ures wou | Wana ures SuUNp | jo SuTUUTdag U22amj2q ward ULOTS yuan
Se) moy fo] jars Moy waunxeyy] smoy jo s2quiny =| Surmp fyesurEs HO] | MINS JO VoHEINCT | Wang BLOIS Jo eC]
4 ; 6 im €
ajdures ay1s0dwoo pawySiam mol ay) J0J SONjA WuNWUTXEUD ou) UN PIYNsad Yorym (S)U2A2 UUIOIS au 40) BIEP SPLACAY - I HEd

ausodwo > somurpy Of 1884 ausodwo_) somnuipy OF 14 (2pqeprean ji) s2Qquinn,
pojdurs powiam-moyy = | Suunc] uaqey aiduiwg gest pory Siam mol 4 aes Ow INS HO SVD pus wemnjjod
HUEINI}Od JO $2DINOg a= 5 (swum apnyour) sane, aBesany (syun apnyour) sanye, wana yy
‘S}IMAP [|PUCHIPPE 20} SUOH NUYS
°S Uepno yore oj qui 240 araydino.y wosand s 9421}99 0 suoseas any 20 woMry WOK WML PAL PUR CAT TAT NINE. Si Mae Ns

uaquing 7] Ayoed

(gt mar0.4g Jo 1 - LA 280d wo 11,4 21981 WOAY PINUQUO.y) VOPeULsE;Uy BBrey>qIq “ILA

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385014_0612%3A19. Public record. Not legal advice.
