# Joint Appendix — Denver Area Educational Telecommunications Consortium, Inc. v. Federal Communications Commission

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385013_0640%3A05

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Joint Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1996
- **Citation:** 516 U.S. 1091

## Text

_—

a a 6

Nos. 95-124 and 95-227

IN THE

Supreme Court of the United

OCTOBER TERM, 1995
—_

DENVER AREA EDUCATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS
CONSORTIUM, INC. and AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION,
Petitioners,

—

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION, et ai.,
Respondents.

ALLIANCE FOR COMMUNITY MEDIA, et al.,

Petitioners,

a Y , oe

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION, et al.,
Respondents.

ON WRITS OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS POR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

CHARLES S. SIMS* I. MICHAEL GREENBERGER*

PETER J.W. SHERWIN Shea & Gardner

Proskauer Rose Goetz 1800 Massachusetts Ave., NW
& Mendelsohn LLP Washington, D.C. 20036

1585 Broadway (202) 828-2000

New York, New York 10036 Counsel for Petitioners Alliance

(212) 969-3000 for Community Media, Alliance
Counsel for Petitioners for Communications Democracy,
in No. 95-124 and People For the American

Way in No. 95-227

DREW S. DAYS, Ill
Solicitor General
Department of Justice
Washington, D.C. 20530
(202) 514-2217

Counsel for Respondents
* Counsel of Record

(Counsel continued on inside front cover)

PETITIONS FOR CERTIORARI FILED JULY 21, 1995 AND AUGUST 9, 1995
CERTIORARI GRANTED NOVEMBER 13, 1995 I¥

\.

STEVEN R. SHAPIRO
MARJORIE HEINS
American Civil Liberties
Union Foundation
132 West 43d Street
New York, New York 10036
Counsel for Petitioners
in No. 95-124

THOMAS J. MIKULA

MICHAEL K. ISENMAN

DAVID B. GOODHAND

Shea & Gardner

1800 Massachusetts Ave., NW

Washington, D.C. 20036
Counsel for Petitioners
Alliance for Community Media,
Alliance for Communications
Democracy, and People For the
American Way in No. 95-227

JAMES N. HORWOOD
Spiegel & McDiarmid
1350 New York Ave., NW
Washington, D.C. 20005
Counsel for Petitioners
Alliance for Community Media
and Alliance for Communications
Democracy in No. 95-227

ANDREW JAY SCHWARTZMAN
GIGI SOHN

Media Access Project

2000 M Street, NW
Washington, D.C. 20036

ELLIOT MINCBERG

LAWRENCE OTTINGER

People For the American Way

2000 M Street, NW

Washington, D.C. 20036
Counsel for Petitioners
People For the American Way
in No. 95-227

ROBERT T. PERRY

509-12th Street, Apt. 2C

Brooklyn, New York 11215
Counsel for Petitioners
New York Citizens Committee for
Responsible Media, Media Access
New York, Brooklyn Producers’
Group, and David Channon in
No. 95-227

li

EDITOR'S NOTE
THE FOLLOWING PAGES WERE POOR HARD COPY
AT THE TIME OF FILMING. — IF AND WHEN A

BETTER COPY CAN BE OBTAINED, A NEW FICHE

WILL BE ISSUED.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

Opinions, Orders, and Parts of the Record Omitted from the
DUES Ei eke ee bweebeccec cece cs v
ee ee tcc cee vi

Comments of Acton Corp., Allen's Television Cable Service,

Inc., Cable Television Association of Maryland, Dela-

ware and District of Columbia, Century Communications
Corp., Columbia International, Inc., Florida Cable Tele-
vision Association, Gilmer Cable Television Company,

Inc., Monmouth Cablevision Assoc., TeleCable Corpora-
tion, Texas Cable TV Association, United Video Cable-
vision, Inc., and West Virginia Cable Television Associa-

Joint Comments of Alliance for Community Media, the Alli-

Civil Liberties Union and People For the American Way. 4
Exhibit A: Patricia Aufderheide, Cable Television and
the Public Interest, 42 J}. COMM. 52 (1992) ...... 55
Exhibit L: Patricia Aufderheide, Public Access Cable
Programming, Controversial Speech, and Free Ex-
he bere hs Géeewcerccs 61
Exhibit M: Affidavit of Joseph J. Collins submitted in
Time Warner Entertainment Co. v. FCC, No. 92-

ace ccees 74
Exhibit N: Letter from InterMedia Partners to Tucson
Community Cable Corp. of Nov. 13, 1992 ...... 77

Exhibit O: Customer Handbook, Jerrold IMPULSE
7000, Model DP71**, DPV72** and DPBB73**

Exhibit P: Customer Handbook, Jerrold STARCOM VI
Model DPV5-* Addressable Converter with Volume

i
Exhibit Q: Customer Handbook, Jerrold STARCOM 7

Model DQN7-* Digital Plain Converter ........ 133

Comments of Ann Arbor Community Access Television... 155

Joint Comments of Blade Communications, Inc., Multivision
Cable TV Corp., Parcable, Inc., Providence Journal

Company, and Sammons Communications, Inc. ..... 157
Comments of the Boston Community Access and Program-
| ss Per eres 162
Comments of Roxie Lee Cole, Citizen .............. 170
Comments of Columbus Community Cable Access, Inc
STE cennt cae cb beecesehscaseetane 172
Comments of the Community Antenna Television Associa-
Gt ccbmdeeeceso és awet até ce enteuuts 174
Comments of Continental Cablevision, Inc............ 181
Comments of Cox Cable Communications, a Division of Cox
GR, GE. oc oc hb cds ee da Cecsecedoces 196
Comments of Denver Area Educational Telecommunications
Consortium, Inc. on Notice of Proposed Rule Making . 199
Appendix A: Articles Concerning CamNet ........ 211

Mark Robichaux, Camcorders Spark Two Cable
Ventures, WALL ST. J., July 30, 1992 at BI... 212

Steve Weinstein, A Cable Network About the Real
World, L.A. TIMES, Oct. 16, 1992 at F24 .... 216

Joe Rhodes, Video: Power to the People, TV GUIDE,

Pe Ct. cconentuece oenees 220
PD cece weeeeGeeeedaseeeces 221
Appendix B: Program Segments Carried by The 90's
Channel Dealing with Sexuality ............. 224
Comments of InterMedia Partners ................. 226

Comments of the National Association of Telecommunica-
tions Officers and Advisors, National League of Cities,
United States Conference of Mayors, and the National

a ne 239
Comments of National Cable Television Association, Inc... 244
Comments of Tele-Communications Inc. ............ 246

Comments of Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P. . 249
Comments of Virginia B. Bogue and Amy Lerom, Citizens of

Tampa, Florida to Proposed Rule Making ......... 271
Comments of City of Tampa Office of Cable Communication
I, oc ncconcscccsccees: 275

Joint Reply Comments of the Alliance for Community Media,
the Alliance for Communications Democracy, the Ameri
can Civil Liberties Union and People For the American

Linda Haugsted, Warner, Access Group in Shootout,
MULTICHANNEL NEWS, May 20, 1992 at 1, 56 . 302

Linda Haugsted, Warner Cable Up for Renewal,
MULTICHANNEL NEWS, July 22, 1991 at 14... 305

System Notes, MULTICHANNEL NEWS, October 13,

EE Whol cose eed eb e ce ebs 00 307
REED ba é ballin 6 se cecchecoebicuees ci 308
Jerry Adler, Was lt Good for You, Too, NEWSWEEK,

* & rae 309

Reply Comments of Cambridge Community Television ... 311
Reply Comments of Cincinnati Community Video, Inc. ... 316
Reply Comments of the City of St. Paul... .......... 318

Reply Comments of Columbus Community Cable Access,
DL -ccceees 6668600866048 68046 327

iv

Reply Comments of the Denver Area Educational Telecom-
munications Consortium, Inc. on Notice of Proposed

GED hu ce Ce Wkwic 6 0 ohs obs hee ae ss 330
Reply Comments of the Motion Picture Association of Amer
DAG ss cw stbcthoabe'c Cee ecwbtwd Gakct' 333

Reply Comments of the National Association of Telecommu-
nications Officers and Advisors, National League of
Cities, United States Conference of Mayors, and the

National Association of Counties ............... 342
Reply Comments of the National Cable Television Associa-
«BEY SERUETTLE CITI LUT LETC TLE Le 349
Reply Comments of ‘Olelo: The Corporation for Community
WED 6. 646-0 Cd oS COWS SS ew TES 6 eh UW SES 351
Reply Comments of Viacom International Inc.......... 353
Comments of New York Citizens Committee for Responsible
Pas aGvcteesuude enced seeeeaeeeeuas 358
ee ee re 369
TV GUIDE Manhattan Cable TV Edition, Dec. 12
SE « 26 am dae er ies Abo eo © 68 370
Petition for Reconsideration of the NYNEX Telephone Com-
So ncinndeustekbcdkd teak elkade nce c We note that Section 15's system of subscriber-initiated blocking is
problematic for a reason unrelated to the concerns of these Comments.
Because the MPAA rating system does not provide the safeguards required
by the first amendment, Motion Picture Ass'n., v. Specter, 315 F. Supp.
824, 825 (E.D. Pa. 1970), government regulations may not rely upon it,
Swope v. Lubbers, 560 F. Supp. 1328, 1334 (W.D. Mich. 1983).

14

indecent. If the operator does not prohibit such programming on
leased access channels, the operator is required by Section 10(b) to
place all indecent programs (as defined by the Commission and self-
identified by the programmer) on a single channel and to block that
channel unless a subscriber requests access in writing. The
Commission is required to promulgate leased access regulations
within 120 days.

For PEG access, Section 10 follows a different approach.
Section 10(c) requires the Commission to promulgate regulations
within 180 days that will enable a cable operator to prohibit not just
sexually explicit programming, but also “material soliciting or
promoting unlawful conduct.”

In the case of both PEG and leased access, Section 10(d)
abrogates a statutory immunity and allows a cable programmer to
be held liable if it carries any program that “involves obscene
material.” Liability may be imposed whether or not the operator
has exercised the authority to prohibit programming given to it
under subsections (a) and (c).

In sum, although Section 10 treats PEG and leased access
differently, for both types of channels it allows an outright ban on
purportedly offensive programming. Rather than directly instituting
these bans, however, Section 10 follows a bifurcated approach.
First, subsections (a) and (c) allow cable operators to ban the
disfavored programming. Second, subsection (d) waives the
statutory immunity otherwise available to those operators if they fail
to ban programming that “involves obscene material.”

Section 10 and its legislative history are remarkably void of any
reference to the lockbox requirement of the 1984 Act, now codified
at 47 U.S.C. § 544(d\(2)(4). The congressional record thus
contains no legislative findings to support a conclusion that
lockboxes have somehow become ineffective in achieving the
interest of protecting minors. Rather, the portions of the bill that
were enacted as Section 10 were introduced on the floor of the
Senate without a committee report on their purpose, justification or
likely effect. Even then, no Senator so much as purported to
present a considered judgment with respect to how often or to what

15

extent minors were being exposed to cablecasts that their parents
considered unsuitable, despite the lockbox requirement.

E. The Commission’s Proposed Rule. — On November 5,
1992, the Commission instituted the instant docket in order to

promulgate a rule ander Section 10. Appendix A of its Notice of
Proposed Rule Making presents the Commission’s Proposed Rule,
which is intended to implement Section 10. In large measure, the
commission’s proposed Rule merely reiterates the provisions of
Section 10’s first three subsections, but it omits any construction of
subsection (d)’s imposition of liability.

The Commission’s Proposed Rule is accompanied by a
prefatory Notice that generally solicits suggestions for regulations
not contained in the Proposed Rule. For example, with respect to
the content-based regulation of PEG, it requests commenters to
- address “whether our regulations should provide for any additional
matters not expressly addressed in the statute,” and it “invite[s]
interested persons to comment on these and any other aspects that
they believe would be germane to proper implementation of this
provision.” Notice 4 14, at 7. See also id. 4 12, at 6 (similar
language with respect to leased access). It also speaks in general
terms about other possible regulations that are not a part of the
Proposed Rule.

In contrast to the congressional record, the Commission's
Notice does recognize that lockboxes remain an effective means to
“control access to other cable services on the system or to limit
access to [an unblocked leased access channel] to others in the
household.” Notice 49, at 5. It is nonetheless similar to the
congressional record in that it, too, is void of either evidence or
reason to support a conclusion that lockboxes have somehow
become ineffective in achieving the interest of protecting minors
from programming that their parents consider unsuitable for
children.

SUMMARY

Because the first amendment commands that “Congress shall
make no law .. . abridging the freedom of speech,” the federal
courts have held that the power to regulate “must be so exercised

16

as not, in attaining a permissible end, unduly to infringe on the
protected freedom.” Cantwell v. Connecticut, 310 U.S. 296, 304
(1940). Section 10 and the Commission's Proposed Rule violates
this basic tenet, as we discuss in detail below.

As an initial matter, Section 10 does not escape first amendment
scrutiny merely because the programming standards contained in
subsections (a) and (c) are expressed in permissive terms. State
action is implicated because this federal legislation impinges on
locally-created PEG and leased access public fora. The leased
access blocking requirements of subsection (b) also demonstrates
direct state action. Additionally, the threat of liability contained in
subsection (d) exercises coercive government power over the
operator, thereby “convert[ing] its otherwise private conduct into
state action.” Carlin Communications, Inc. v. Mountain States Tel.
& Tel. Co., 827 F.2d 1291, 1295 (9th Cir. 1987), cert. denied, 485
U.S. 1029 (1988).

Even if the prohibitions allowed by Section 10 were not
considered state action, they would still be subject to the first
amendment, for they impinge on a public forum. Local franchising
authorities have, with Congress's approval, “intentionally open[ed}
a nontraditional forum for public discourse” and created a public
forum for “the free exchange of ideas.” International Soc'y for
Krishna Consciousness, Inc. v. Lee, 112 S. Ct. 2701, 2706 (1992).
Even private restrictions on access channels are therefore subject to
first amendment scrutiny.‘

Under appropriate first amendment analysis, Section 10 is itself
unconstitutional, for it fails the least restrictive means test. Federal
law already requires cable operators to make lockboxes available,
47 U.S.C. § 544(d)(2)(A), and these have been recognized by the
courts and the Commission as an effective and non-intrusive means
of controlling the access of unsupervised children to programming

* Missouri Knights of the Ku Klux Klan v. Kansas City, Mo., 723
F. Supp. 1347 (W.D. Mo. 1989).

17

that their parents find inappropriate.’ Content-based restrictions
are therefore unconstitutional .°

By largely reiterating the statute, the Commission has failed to
propose constitutional regulations under Section 10. First, the
Commission's Notice of Proposed Rulemaking is completely devoid
of any consideration of less restrictive means. The ban it envisions
on all sexually explicit and otherwise assertedly objectionable

programming impermissibly reduces adults to viewing only those
access programs that are suitable for a child. For that reason, such

bans have always failed, even when advanced as a scheme to
protect minors from television broadcasts.’ Moreover, even if such
a ban could be justified, it is unnecessarily restrictive in the case of
cable. The Commission has often determined that the far less
restrictive option of lockboxes sufficiently guards children from
sexually explicit programming, and it has been supported in this
determination by Congress and the courts. However, the Notice
fails to offer a reason for the Commission's change in position, and
no facts are presented on the record to support that change.
Second, because it is woefully underinclusive, the Proposed
Rule cannot be justified as necessary to serve a compelling state
interest. It mirrors the statute’s concern for programming only on
PEG and leased access channels, without preventing other sexually
explicit or otherwise objectionable cablecasts from reaching the
unsupervised children who are assertedly being protected. This is
especially suspect because Congress has recognized the existence of
other forms of sexually explicit cablecasts, but it has not given the

* ACLU v. FCC, 823 F.2d 1554, 1579 (D.C. Cir. 1987), cert. denied,
485 U.S. 959 (1988); FCC 87-306, 2 F.C.C.R. 5893, ¢ 9, at 5894 (1987).

* See, ¢.g., Cruz v. Ferre, 755 F.2d 1415, 1419 (11th Cir. 1985);

Community Television v. Roy City, 555 F. Supp. 1164 (D. Utah 1982);
Home Box Office, Inc. v. Wilkinson, 531 F. Supp. 987 (D. Utah 1982).

’ Action for Children's Television v. FCC, 932 F.2d 1504, 1508-09
(D.C. Cir. 1991), cert. denied, 112 S. Ct. 1281, and cert. denied, 112
S. Ct. 1282 (1992). See generally Butler v. Michigan, 352 U.S. 380, 383
(1957).

standard must be narrowed, see Notice at 6 n.11, but it has not
done so in the Proposed Rule, see id. App. A. In the same vein,
the immunity waiver provision of Section 10(d) is overbroad
because it subjects cable operators to liability for carrying not only
obscene programs, but also those that “involve[ }” obscenity. The
Commission has similarly failed to use its interpretive powers to
narrow this vague statutory provision.

Finally, the Commission has not proposed appropriate
procedures for the prior imposition of these content-based
restrictions on speech. Although not always invalid per se, content-
based prior restraints must be accompanied by a highly protective
system of judicial safeguards. Because the provision for imposing
liability on cable operators is vague, it, too, should only be imposed
after a court has previously found a program obscene. Such
procedures are totally absent from the Proposed Rule, however.

The Commission has not exercised its interpretive power to
narrowly construe Section 10 to avoid these constitutional
deficiencies. Rather, it has at best indicated that such steps would
be appropriate without incorporating corresponding regulatory
language into the Proposed Rule. See, ¢.g., Notice at 6 n.11
(suggesting basis for narrowing statutory prohibition standard for
PEG access). Indeed, the Commission has indicated that it intends
to incorporate a host of other measures into its Proposed Rule, but
it has not delineated the breadth of those measures. see, ¢.g., id.
4 14, at 7 (“Commenters should also address whether our

19

regulations should provide for any additional measures not expressly
addressed in the statute.”). In any circumstance, this rulemaking
approach prejudices the public's right to comment on regulatory
proposals. it should be especially disfavored in this situation,
where core first amendment rights are threatened.

The Alliance for Community Media, the Alliance for
Communications Democracy, the American Civil Liberties Union,
and People for the American Way are non-profit corporations that
represent organizations and individuals who use PEG and leased
access channels both as programmers and as viewers. The
comments that they jointly submit therefore reflect the unique
shared perspective of organizations whose members have a direct
interest in assuring that cable operators use the public rights of way
in a manner consistent with the interests of the entire community.

The Alliance for Community Media (formerly the National
Federation of Local Cable Programmers) is dedicated to both
ensuring that people have access to cable and other electronic media
and promoting community uses of such media. It is a national
membership organization comprised of more than twelve-hundred
organizations and individuals in more than seven-hundred
communities, including volunteer access producers, access center
managers and staff members, local cable advisory board members,
city cable officials, cable company staff working in community
programming, and others interested in local programming around
the country. The Alliance for Community Media assists its
members in all aspects of community programming over access
channels, from production and operations to regulatory oversight.

The Alliance for Communications Democracy supports efforts
to protect the rights of the public to speak via cable, and it
promotes the availability of the widest possible diversity of
information sources and services to the public. The Board of
Directors of the organization is composed of representatives of

20

nonprofit access corporations in communities around the country,"
who together have helped thousands of members of the public use
the access channels that have been established in their communities.

The American Civil Liberties Union (“the ACLU”) is a
nationwide, nonpartisan organization with nearly 300,000 members,
many of whom are viewers of PEG and leased access cable
channels. It is dedicated to the protection and promotion of
individual rights and liberties, primary among them freedom of
speech. In 1990 the ACLU established an Arts Censorship Project
specifically to combat an increased climate of censorship in the
United States, including in particular efforts to suppress creative
expression and information about sexuality and sexual orientation.

People for the American Way (“People For”) is a nonpartisan,
education-oriented citizens’ organization established to promote and
protect civil and constitutional rights, including first amendment
freedoms. Founded in 1980 by a group of religious, civic and
education leaders devoted to our nation’s heritage of tolerance,
pluralism and liberty, People For now has over 300,000 members
nationwide. Many of People For’s members subscribe to cable
television and watch programs on PEG and leased access channels.
People For’s members have specific and personal interests in
promoting the free flow of information and in receiving uncensored
cable programming. People For seeks to protect the intcrests of its
members, as well as the broader interest in preventing censorship
of expression protected by the first amendment.

Although the commenters generally support the goal of
protecting unsupervised children from cable programming that their
parents find inappropriate, we cannot support the commission's
Proposed Rule. The content-based restrictions that the Commission
proposes will prove seriously disruptive to access programming and
the value that it brings to local communities across the country.

* These communities include Chicago, Illinois; Montgomery County,
Maryland; Boston, Massachusetts; Grand Rapids, Michigan; Manhattan
and Staten Island, New York; Columbus, Ohio; Tucson, Arizona; and the
State of Hawaii.

21

Moreover, the Proposed Rule will work this mischief without
adding anything to the already effective requirement that cable
operators provide lockboxes to protect unsupervised children.

First, the PEG restriction on “material soliciting or promoting
unlawful conduct” presents special problems for programming that
engages in core political speech.’ For example, in Grand Rapids,
Michigan, the producers of “Lies of Our Times” have endorsed
sanctuary for Latin American refugees and encouraged blockades of
government offices in protest of various official positions.
Similarly, “The Flying Focus Video Collective” of Portland,
Oregon has hosted a speaker who advocated direct and illegal action
to protect old timber growth. Several programs have advocated the
decriminalization of marijuana, including “Libertarian Conspiracy”
of Sacramento, California, “Libertarian Review” and “Time for
Hemp” in Tucson, Arizona, and “Cannabis” in Kalamazoo,
Michigan. Patricia Aufderheide, Public Access Cable
Programming, Controversial Speech, and Free Expression, 4-5
(Nov. 1992) [hereinafter Public Access} (App., Exh. L),.

Second, the restriction on sexually explicit programming would
curtail programming on health education and sex education,
including programs that deal frankly with AIDS. This would
include programming directed at both the gay minority and
heterosexuals.

Examples of each of these types of programming are literally
too extensive to document here. For example, Cambridge
Community Television in Massachusetts could be faced with
restrictions on a program entitled “Truth or Consequences: A Guide
to Safe Sex at MIT.” /d. at 4. So could Kalamazoo Community
Access Center of Michigan for an AIDS prevention special that
involved role-playing. Jd. Similarly, the Northern Virginia Youth
Services Coalition produces the weekly cable access series, “Focus

* The description that follows is based in very large measure on Public
Access Cable Programming, Controversial Speech and Free Expression, a
draft article by Dr. Aufderheide, that is included in the Appendix as
Exhibit L.

22

on Youth.” In one program on AIDS, two professionals role-
playing a dating situation were asked, “If you were dating, how
would you get your partner to reveal his sexual history?” Cable
Access, supra, at 49.

A video of a home birth in Amherst, Massachusetts might have
fallen under scrutiny, as might have “Desperately Seeking Susan,”
a program in Olympia, Washington that is hosted by a therapist and
includes frank discussion of sexual behavior and sexual
dysfunctions. Public Access, supra, at 4. The same is true for the
“HealthVisions” series, produced by the community and
professional education department of Good Samaritan Hospital and
Medical Center of Portland, Oregon. Programs in the sefies have
included “PMS: Breaking the Cycle” and “Understanding
Impotence: A Common and Treatable Problem.” Cable Access,
supra, at 37,

Moreover, some programs would face restrictions under either
or both of the “unlawful” and “explicit” standards. For example,
access centers in Forest Park Ohio, Fort Wayne, Indiana,
Oregon have aired programs, some produced by Operation Rescue,
that have opposed abortion. Some of these programs have either
encouraged blocking access to abortion clinics or have contained
possibly offensive explicit images, or both. Public Access, Supra,
at 5.

Finally, live programming, including call-in programs, will be
particularly hindered by the commission's proposed Rule. These
shows fulfill a unique role by both making cable immediately

Live
from Chicago, included a seventeen-year-old girl asking how
respond to a boyfriend who assured her that they did not need

23

use condoms because he was loyal to her. Speakers may also hold
up items such as condoms to explain their use. /d. at 8.

Health education shows could also have the same problems, For
example, “Health in America” is produced monthly in Sacramento
and discusses alternative and holistic health-care options. It has
included graphic images of women with mastectomies and damaged
breast implants. /d. at 8.

Finally, topical call-in programs would also be threatened.
Sacramento aired “Live Wire” within hours of the Rodney King
verdict, on which callers had their volatile moments. And access
programs in Oregon hotly debated that state's ballot initiative that
would have criminalized some homosexual behavior. /d. at 5, 8.

No one can dispute the value of these programs to an adult
viewing audience. Even if some parents feel that unsupervised
minors should not be given free access to all of them, it ill serves
society to reduce adults to viewing cable that is only fit for
children. For that reason, we see lockboxes as the alternative that
is superior to allowing the prohibition of this type of programming.
Lockboxes allow adults both to control children's access and to
pertake of the robust speech and debate being aired on access
channels. They also allow parents to decide for themselves whether
or not their children will benefit from receiving information on
sensitive topics, and they allow access to be granted for just the
space of one program. Bans and blocking schemes offer none of
these advantages, yet the congressional record and the
Commission's Notice both disclose that hardly a whisper of
attention has been paid to the lockbox option.

I. SECTION 10 VIOLATES THE FIRST AMENDMENT

There can be little doubt that the purpose and effect of Section
10 of the Act is to establish a system of censorship that violates the
first amendment rights of those who wish to cablecast on PEG and
leased access channels and those who wish to view the censored
programming. As such, if the Commission is to implement this
section of the Act in haec verba (as its Proposed Rule suggests),

any final rule that it may promulgate in these proceedings will itself
be unconstitutional. We discuss the various constitutional

24

difficulties that the Commission's Proposed Rule presents in the
sections that follow this one.

This section focuses on the statute itself, and our purpose is
twofold. First, we demonstrate the propriety of applying first
amendment analysis to the content-based restrictions on free
expression that are either enshrined in Section 10 or called for by
it. Second, we show that Section 10's regulation of non-obscene
cable programming is necessarily unconstitutional.

A. STATE ACTION

As an initial matter, we are aware of certain statements in the
floor debates concerning Section 10 that attempt to categorize the
restrictions on speech contained in that enactment as non-

and hence beyond constitutional scrutiny. See, ¢.g.,
138 Cong. Rec. § 646 (daily ed. Jan. 30, 1992) (statement of Sen.
Helms); id. at § 648 (statements of Sen. Thurmond); id. at § 649
(statement of Sen. Inouye). In our view, these statements are
clearly mistaken.” As a general matter, Congress’ role in
establishing this system of censorship (as well as that of the
Commission in implementing it) involves sufficient government
action to implicate the protections of the first amendment. Access
channels are public fora that have been created by localities through
contracts between franchising authorities and cable operators.

a I I mn

25
10 establishes. First, Congress has specified that, in all instances,
leased access programming must be blocked if it constitutes
“indecent programming, as defined by Commission regulations.”
Section 10(b) (codified at 47 U.S.C. § 532(jX(1)). This provision
is an integral part of Section 10's system of censorship, it
in placing restrictions on programming under the Act. As such it
is direct state involvement that suffices to trigger first amendment
scrutiny of the entire enactment.'' Further, Section 10(b) indicates
that Congress viewed the censorship of cable programming as a
function of the state, and its delegation of a part of that power to a
private actor does not insulate the exercise of that power from
constitutional scrutiny. See, e.g., Williams v. City of St. Louis, 783
F.2d 114, 117 (8th Cir. 1986) (“This delegation under state law of
powers possessed by virtue of state law and traditionally exercised
by the City satisfies us that the City’s action here is under color of
state law.”); Ancata v. Prison Health Servs. Inc., 769 F.2d 700,
703 (11th Cir. 1985) (“Where a function which is traditionally the
exclusive prerogative of the state .. . is performed by a private
entity, state action is present.”).

Second, it is Congress in all instances that has specified what
type of programming an operator may refuse to carry over PEG or
leased access, otherwise mandating that “a cable operator shall not
exercise any editorial control” over the programming of these
channels. 47 U.S.C. § 531(e) (PEG); 47 U.S.C. § 532(c)\(2) (leased
access). This congressional specification of programming standards
is not insulated from first amendment scrutiny merely because it is
phrased in permissive terms, for it operates in tandem with Section
10(d)'s imposition of liability on private censors if they fail to
prohibit speech that “involves” obscenity. In other words, these

provisions place the operator in peril of liability and prompt it to

‘Because “[tJhe move relevant inquiry in evaluating severability is
whether the statute will function in a manner consistent with the intent of
Congress,” Alaska Airlines. Inc. vy. Brock, 480 U.S. 678, 685 (1987)
(emphasis in original), the state action that adheres in the blocking
provisions of subsection (b) cannot be severed from the rest of the statute.

26

restrict any programming that even remotely meets the permissive
censorship standards set out in subsections (a) and (c) of Section 10,
lest the speech also wander into the undefined grey area that
“involves obscene material.” Cf. Bantam Books, Inc., v. Sullivan,
372 U.S. 58, 67 (1963) (cautioning against elevating form over
substance when determining whether censorship is occurring),
Penthouse Int'l. Lid. v. McAuliffe, 610 F.2d 1353, 1360 (Sth Cir.)
(same), cert. dismissed, 447 U.S. 931 (1980).

This effect has already been felt. For example, as the
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Time Warner Cable
(“TWC”) concluded in an affidavit that was submitted in litigation
that brought a direct challenge to the 1992 Act:

“The provision of Section 10(d) . . . injurfes] TWC by
subjecting it to the risk of criminal and civil liability for
programming created by others that it does not wish to carry
but is required by law to carry. The provisions . . . of the
Cable Act permitting TWC to prohibit or restrict obscene
programming does not alleviate such injury in that they compel
TWC to determine obscenity questions that even Federal courts
regard as exceedingly difficult, and TWC remains exposed to
iminal or civil liability if a court later disagrees with its
determination.” Affidavit of Joseph J. Collins, 4 37, at 23
(App., Exh. M).

2 Of course, the threat of liability is sufficient for state action purposes;
it need not be the case, as here, that such a threat has proven to be the
direct cause of private conduct, Peterson v. City of Greenville, 373 U.S.
244, 248 (1963) (finding state action “even assuming . . . that the manager
would have acted as he did independently of the existence of the
ordinance”); Carlin Communications, Inc. v. Mountain States Tel. & Tel.
Co., 827 F.2d 1291, 1295 (9th Cir. 1987) (“Simply by ‘command]ing} a
particular result,’ the state had so involved itself that it could not claim the
conduct had actually occurred as a result of private choice.”), cert. denied.
485 U.S. 1029 (1988).

27

Cable operators thus feel compelled by their possible liability to
censor widely.

Indeed, cable operators have for that reason already begun to
institute censorship for programming that is sexually explicit but not
even arguably indecent, out of fear that some such program might
later be found to subject the operators to liability. As one cable
operator wrote to the executive director of its local public access
programmer,

“all programming which contains sexual, excretory or other

behavior or depictions, or language which potentially may be

offensive to the citizens of Tucson [must] be sent to our system
for screening before it is cablecast by TCCC over our cable
system.” Letter from InterMedia Partners to Tucson

Community Cable Corp. (Nov. 13, 1992) (App., Exh. N).
Thus, not only is programming called in to question if it concerns
sexual material of any nature, it is also subject to editorial scrutiny
if it contains “potentially .. . offensive” language. Because of
their unpredictable nature and potential to include such language,
cable operators have specifically targeted live programming
(including call-in shows):

“Moreover, no live programming should be cablecast which

contains such material. All such programming should be taped

and sent to us for screening as outlined above.” /d.

Recognizing the obvious dangers posed ty the threat of
government-imposed liability on private censors, federal courts
faced with similar schemes have not hesitated to recognize the state
action that brings first amendment principles to bear. For example,
in Carlin Communications, Inc. v. Mountain States Telephone &
Telegraph Co., 827 F.2d 1291 (9th Cir. 1987). cert. denied, 485
U.S. 1029 (1988) Arizona’s threat of criminal liability constituted
sufficient state action to subject to first amendment scrutiny a
telephone company’s decision to bar sexually explicit messages.
“With this threat, Arizona ‘exercised coercive power’ over
Mountain Bell and thereby converted its otherwise private conduct
into state action... .” Id. at 1295 (quoting Blum v. Yaretsky, 457

28

U.S. 991, 1004 (1982))." Similarly, the threat of liability
contained in Section 10(d) of the 1992 Act transforms the
censorship standards of Sections 10(a) and (c), which are otherwise
phrased in permissive terms, into state action.

Indeed, the existence of subsection (d) nullifies the state action
arguments advanced in the floor debates on Section 10. Subsection
(d) was not a part of the enactment then being debated, but was
later added as a “conforming amendment.” It is “conforming,”
however, only in the sense that it requires cable operators to
conform to censorship standards that are otherwise phrased in
permissive terms. In later proposing the addition of subsection (d),
Senator Helms specifically stated that its purpose was fo “put an
end to the kind of things going on” access channels.'* Given this
change in circumstances, it is not surprising to find inapposite the
federal cases cited in the floor debate for the proposition that the
example, Senator Helms pointed to Carlin Communication. Inc. v.
Southern Bell Telephone & Telegraph. Inc., 802 F.2d 1352 (11th
Cir. 1986), to support his contention that “it is permissible to allow
a private company to make independent decisions to exclude certain

The court went on to hold that any decision to ban speech made under
threat of state-imposed liability “was unconstitutional state action” that
violated the first amendment. 827 F.2d at 1296.

In its Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, the Commission recognized the
symbiotic relationship between the programming standards of subsections
(a) and (c) and the imposition of liability contained in subsection (d). For
example, Paragraph 13 first notes that subsection (c) “merely allows the
cable operator the option” of censoring PEG. The next sentence
immediately juxtaposes

“As pointed out earlier, however, [subsection (d)] expressly provides
that cable operators are no longer statutorily immune from liability for
carriage of obscene materials on these channels.”

However, we note that the legislative history of subsection (d)
suggests that liability cannot be imposed on cable operators with respect
to PEG. The scant floor debate was concerned wholly with leased access
channels. 138 Cong. Rec. S652 (daily ed. Jan. 30, 1992) (statement of
Sen. Helms).

29

objectionable material.” 138 Cong. Rec. $646 (daily ed. Jan. 30,
1992) (emphasis added). As others have readily recognized,
however, the threat of liability removes the independence of that
decision and renders it subject to first amendment scrutiny. See,
¢.g., Mountain States, 827 F.2d at 1295; id. at 1298 n.2 (Canby,
J., dissenting in part) (“the presence of this coercion differentiates
this case from Carlin v. Southern Bell”).

B. PUBLIC FORUM

Even were the censorial dictates of Section 10 not themselves
state action, the first amendment would still apply. Because PEG
and leased access constitute a quintessential public forum, a system
of censorship is not insulated from the first amendment simply
because Congress has vested private cable operators with the
decision to prohibit speech in that forum. When the government
destroys a public forum by empowering private actors to restrict
speech, it must do so within the bounds of the first amendment.

PEG and leased access certainly constitute such a public forum
— one that is unique because of the widespread reliance on
electronic communication. Congress recognized this status in the
legislative history of the 1984 Act, which both recognized that local
franchising authorities could provide for PEG in franchises and
required them to establish leased access, See H.R. Rep. No. 934,
98th Cong., 2d Sess. 30 (1984), reprinted in 1984 U.S.C.C.A.N.

4655, 4667 (quoted supra page 4). The legislative history of the
1992 Act similarly recognizes that Congress has heretofore
“requir[ed] cable operators to operate public and leased access
channels as a public forum open to any and all speakers.” 138
Cong. Rec. S648 (daily ed. Jan. 30, 1992) (letter from Mr. Peters):
id. at S652 (statement of Sen. Helms) (“[Tyhe intent of the [1984]
law, obviously, was to promote diversity in cable programming.
The law required cable operators to carry anything that
programmers brought along.”). In sum, “the underlying theory of
leased access channels [is] to provide a forum for people to speak
out on a diversity of issues.” /d. (statement of Sen. Thurmond).
See also S. Rep. No. 381, 101st Cong., 2d Sess. 46 (1990) (PEG
and leased access constitute “a free market of ideas”).

30

Under generally applicable first amendment principles,
therefore, localities that implement these provisions pursuant to
their franchising authority have purposefully ‘“‘openfed] a

Lee 112 S. Ct. 2701, 2706 (1992) (quoting Cornelius v. NAACP
Legal Defense & Educ. Fund. Inc., 473 U.S. 788, 800, 802
(1985))"*. The federal courts have thus recognized that PEG and
leased access constitutes a public forum for purposes of first
amendment analysis .'*

Because of the recognition that access channels are a public-
forum, as at least one commentator has noted, “for the access

See also Southeastern Promotions, Lid. v. Conrad, 420 U.S. $46, 555
(1975) (finding municipal auditorium a public forum); Cinevision Corp. v.
City of Burbank, 745 F.2d 560, 570 (9h Cir. 1984) (same for
amphitheater), cert. denied, 471 U.S. 1054 (1985); Yurkew v. Sinclair,
495 F. Supp. 1248, 1252 n.5 (D. Minn. 1980) (state fair grounds); United
States Labor Party v. Knox, 430 F. Supp. 1359, 1361-62 (D.N.C. 1977)
(parking areas adjoining state-owned liquor stores).

© See, eg., Quincy Cable TV. Inc. v. FCC, 768 F.2d 1434, 1452 (D.C.
Cir. 1985) (“access rules .. . serve countervailing First Amendment
values by providing a forum for [the] public”), cert. denied, 476 U.S.
1169 (1986); Muir v. Alabama Educ. Television Comm'n, 656 F.2d 1012,
1022 & n.19 (Sth Cir. Unit B 1981); Erie Telecommunications, Inc. v.
City of Erie, 659 F. Supp. 580, 598-600 (W.D. Pa. 1987) (“access
requirements are intended to make cable channels available to the public
on a first-come, first-served nondiscriminatory basis”). See also Berkshire
Cablevision of Rhode Island, Inc. v. Burke, 571 F. Supp. 976, 987 (D.R.1.
1983) (access rules “mandate that all individuals be given the opportunity
to appear on cable television on a nondiscriminatory first-come, first-
served basis”), vacated as moot, 773 F.2d 382 (ist Cir. 1985).

31

In a situation remarkably similar to that presented by Section
10, it vas an access channel's status as a public forum that
prompted a federal court to apply first amendment analysis to a
scheme of permissive private censorship. Missouri Knights of the
Ku Klux Klan v. Kansas City, Mo., 723 F. Supp. 1347 (W.D. No.
1989). The Kansas City case arose after members of a racist
organization declared their intention to air a program over a public
access channel. In reaction, the city council passed an ordinance
that “permitted [the local cable operator] to delete the cable channel!
if it so desired.” Jd. at 1350. In its stead, “a new channel would
be created” that “would be subject to [the operator's} editorial
control.” Jd. Recognizing that the introduction of permissive
editorial control would have intruded upon a public forum, the
court denied a motion for summary judgment that would have
eliminated a first amendment claim. It held that “[a] state may only
eliminate a designated public forum if it does so in a manner
consistent with the First Amendment.” /d. at 1352." Because

See also United States v. Grace, 461 U.S. 171, 180 (1983) (“the
destruction of public forum status... is at least presumptively
impermissible” under the first amendment). Cf United States Postal Serv.
v. Council of Greenburgh Civic Ass'ns, 453 U.S. 114, 133 (1981)
(“Congress, no more than a suburban township, may not by its own ipse

(continued...)

32

Section 10 and the Commission's proposed regulations thereunder
would similarly allow cable operators to impinge upon the PEG and
leased access public forum, they are proper objects of scrutiny
under the first amendment.

C. FIRST AMENDMENT VIOLATIONS

We have shown above that Section 10 does not escape first
amendment scrutiny. Moreover, under standards applicable to
content-based cable regulations, Section 10 is unconstitutional. As
the Commission has recognized in this docket, see Notice q 7, at 4,
differences in the characteristics of the various print and electronic
media mandate different standards of first amendment protection
against content-based regulation of expression pursued over each
such medium. Red Lion Broadcasting Co. v. FCC, 395 U.S. 367,
386 (1969). “Each method of communicating ideas is a ‘law unto
itself and that law must reflect the ‘differing natures, values,
abuses and dangers’ of each method.” Metromedia, Inc. v. City of
San Diego, 453 U.S. 490, 501 (1981) (quoting Kovacs v. Cooper,
336 U.S. 77, 97 (1949)). Attention to the peculiarities of each
medium is therefore necessary when it comes to scrutinizing
attempted government regulation of speech that, while not obscene,
may be sexually explicit."

Thus, while the legislative history of Section 10 discloses an
intent to import content-based regulations that may be appropriate
for other media into cable, see, ¢.g., 138 Cong. Rec. $646-47
(daily ed. Jan. 30, 1992) (statement of Sen. Helms) (referring to

"(...continued)

dixit destroy the ‘public forum’ status of streets and parks which have
historically been public forums.”).

Compare FCC v. Pacifica Found., 438 U.S. 726, 748 (1978)
(concerning indecency standards applicable to broadcast) with Sabie
Communications v. FCC, 492 U.S. 115, 127 (1989) (“[t}he private
commercial telephone communications at issue here are substantially
different from the public radio broadcast at issue in Pacifica”) and Bolger

v. Youngs Drug Prods. Corp., 463 U.S. 60, 74 (1983) (distinguishing
receipt of sexually explicit mail from broadcast).

33

restrictions on telephone communications), such importation does
of cable have allowed Congress to require that operators make
lockboxes available, federal courts have found that federal law
already mandates the least restrictive means available to effectively
curbing the exposure of unsupervised children to sexually explicit,
non-obscene cable programming. For that reason, Section 10's
content-based restrictions violate the first amendment.

First, unlike broadcast, cable does not involve a “captive
audience” — precisely the basis on which the Supreme Court in
Sable Communications v. FCC, 492 U.S. 1150, 127-28 (1989),
distinguished the telephone communications it was concerned with
from the broadcast at issue in Pacifica. It was also on this basis
that federal courts have stricken local cable regulations that, like
Section 10, seek to limit sexually explicit programming. Thus, in
Community Television v. Roy City, 555 F. Supp. 1164 (D. Utah
1982), the court invalidated a local ordinance that sought to regulate

indecent cable programming, reasoning that all cable viewers must
subscribe to the service and retain the power to cancel that
subscription. The court held that cable subscribers must specifically
choose to invite cable programming into their home, and it
therefore found inapplicable the captive audience rationale that
supports the regulation of broadcast indecency. /d. at 1168-69. It
was in part on the same basis that the Eleventh Circuit declared a
similar ordinance unconstitutional, finding that “[a] Cablevision
subscriber must make the affirmative decision to bring Cablevision
into his home.” Cruz v. Ferre, 755 F.2d 1415, 1419 (11th Cir.
1985). See also Quincy Cable TV. Inc. v. FCC, 768 F.2d 1434,
1448 n.31 (D.C. Cir, 1985) (citing Cruz), cert. denied, 476 U.S.
1169 (1986).

even greater control over that service than they have over either
broadcast or telephone. Cable is unique in offering subscribers the
ability to lock out their children’s receipt of specific channels that
might otherwise be objectionable, just as parents may place the
liquor cabinet under lock and key. Indeed, federal law mandates
that all cable operators make available to their subscribers just such

34

lock boxes. 47 U.S.C. § 544(d)(2)A). Thus, in finding
unconstitutional a local restriction on sexually explicit
programming, the Eleventh Circuit made special note of the
“parental manageability of cable television” afforded by “the ability
to protect children” through the use of a “‘lockbox’ or ‘parental
key"” available from Cablevision. Cruz, 755 F.2d at 1415, 1420.
Set also Quincy Cable TV, 768 F.2d at 1448 n.31.

Because cable subscribers are not a captive audience and may
use lockboxes to further control access to their service, additional
restrictions on non-obscene cable programming are unnecessary and
therefore violative of the basic first amendment principle that any
restriction on speech must be narrowly tailored to achieving a
compelling government interest. See Carey v. Brown, 447 U.S.
455, 461 (1980). See generally infra Section I]. It was on this
basis that the court in Home Box Office, Inc. v. Wilkinson, 531
F. Supp. 987 (D. Utah 1982), invalidated on first amendment
grounds a Utah statute forbidding cable operators from knowingly
distributing indecent programming, despite an asserted justification
of the protection of minors. The court held that the regulation at
issue would also have restricted the adult population to
programming suitable for children. /d. at 997.

Because of the unique nature of cable television, we strongly
agree with the federal courts that have struck down content-based
regulations that were similar to the indecency restrictions contained
in Section 10. Federal law already mandates the least restrictive
means for effectively curbing the exposure of unsupervised children
to sexually explicit cable programming. Section 10 therefore
contemplates an unnecessary additional burden on the first
amendment rights of PEG and leased access programmers and
viewers, and any final rule that mirrors the statute would itself be

Even if some content-based regulation could pass muster,
however, it is Clear that the one proposed by the Commission fails
to meet constitutional minima. By parroting Section 10, the
Proposed Rule incorporates all of the statute's constitutional
infirmities. We now turn to an examination of the Commission's
Proposed Rule

Ee ee ce.

35

il, THE COMMISSION HAS FAILED TO CONSIDER
LESS RESTRICTIVE MEANS TO IMPLEMENT
RESTRICTIONS CONTAINED IN ITS PROPOSED RULE

In order to comport with the first amendment, the content-based
restrictions contained in the Commission's Proposed Rule must both
further a governmental interest that is compelling and do so by the
least restrictive means. Sable Communications v. FCC, 492 US
115, 126 (1989), Gibson v. Florida Bar, 79% F.2d 1564, 1569
(11th Cir, 1986). cert. dismissed, 112 S$. Ct. 633 (1991). The
Commission has failed on both of these scores. It has not

First, the Commission has failed to state on the record the
compelling purpose that motivates the PEG restrictions contained in
subsection (c) of its Proposed Rule. Such an articulation is of
course a necessary predicate to determining “if it chooses the least
restrictive means to further the articulated interest.” Sable. 492
U.S. at 126. As for the leased access restrictions of subsection (a).
the Commission mentions only in passing that it is concerned with
“children’s exposure to indecent programs” over those channels
Notice, 4 9, at 5. Even if that passing reference can be taken as a

%6

full statement of the governmental interest being pursued,'? the
Commission has not developed any record evidence describing ‘he
nature and extent of that exposure. Without such a fact findine.
any means implemented cannot be considered the least restrict!V¢.
because a reviewing court is left without a standard against which
to judge the effectiveness of the various options. Burlington TT¥ck
Lines, Inc. v. United States, 371 U.S. 156, 167-68 (1962) (age™*y
must make findings based on substantial evidence in order that Our"
has something to review). See also Action for Children's Television
v. FCC, 852 F.2d 1332, 1341-42 (D.C. Cir. 1988); of. Sable, 492
U.S. at 126-27. .

Second, no government interest can support the complete
prohibition against sexually explicit programming on PEG 4m
leased access, which the Proposed Rule allows. While the feder@!
courts recognize that government may at times shield children f°O™
some sexually explicit material that is not obscene, that purpPOS*
must be served by the least restrictive means towards its effect'V®
implementation. Sable, 492 U.S. at 126. Schemes that use child
protection as an excuse to keep such material away from Poth
children and adults fall far short of this test. See, ¢.g., Butl#" ¥
Michigan, 352 U.S. 380, 383 (1957) (even when attempr!8 ‘©
protect children, regulation cannot effectively reduce @dults to
having “only what is fit for children”). Regardless of the medium
involved, therefore, child protection has failed as ar ¢xCuse for total
bans on sexually explicit material, including bevks. id., telephone

” We contend that it cannot be the requisite full statement. In the

to indecent material: the 60V€™ment does not propose to act in loco
parentis to deny childrers § 800888 Contrary to parents’ wishes.” Action for
Children's Television v. FCC, 852 F.2d 1332, 1643 (D.C. Cir. 1988)
‘ outa

os el

101

TIME CONTROLLED
PROGRAMMING

This feature allows the subscriber to program the
converter for unattended VCR recording. The unit can
be programmed to switch to a predetermined channel!
at a predetermined time and date. Once the unit has
been programmed it need not be turned on prior to lea ving
the home. However, the unit MUST be plugged into
a wall outlet; do not plug into a switched outlet.

—

In the following example, the converter will bef. >

programmed for: WY}
2,
Time: 12:30 p.m.
Channel: 32 Z
TO PROGRAM
ACTION CONVERTER | COMMENT

DISPLAY

1? { d = Day of Month
— 1 = First event
Ener dateof a 2 |
event (ic. 28th
of month). See a

Continued

>

102

ACTION _—|CONVERTER| COMMENT
y DISPLAY |
' © iS ,
| B| &
arom 5! (ht) | EE.
4 | onendue £ V
to be programmed. 44 12)

Switch between Without P
cme, =| (t, 2) | rome
arom S| (nt) | F
BD twwnne L- 3)

~| 30

a ee

i Ci Na ti. ~ ml tacts

103
Continucd
> ACTION CONVERTER |. COMMENT
ae DISPLAY
‘ 4 me
: VY; Ley (3
° ~
C9 8:
Unit is now
programmed for
12:30 PM on the
EY} pressenver £93 C | 2h
c = channel
1 = first event
Enter channel
of event a 3
2 B ON = B cable

Switch between Co
A and B cable 2
Via A/B button =—=§——
Notice B indicator

on display.

at
riAS

B OFF = A cable

Unit is now
programmed to
switch to channel!
32 at 12:30 PM on
the 28th of the
month.

d = day of month
2 = second event

11] At this point, the
above steps are repeated
for events 2 - 8.

=

To exit Time
Controlled Programming
Press TCP

Current channacl

104

PURCHASING A FUTURE
PROGRAM OR EVENT

Use the following sequence to program the converter for purchasing

an event with unattended recording.
08 DISPLAY
é °
: Oe & »
‘i YY
at “—
EB) press SELECT a o Indicates EVENT
programming.
Enter your PUR-
CHASE CODE (if
code is not pro- Display changes in
grammed, go directly E -— intensity with each
to step 9c. See page digit entered.
27 for programming a
code.)
Chaane! number
should be flashing.
Press ENTER 4 Pa if a ts est Bashing
(flashing) the purchase was
mn allowed.
Prepurchase vi
TCP has been pro-
10} Press ENTER again 4 2| grammed.
Continue with neat
event programming
TCP made

es

105

TIME CONTROLLED
PROGRAMMING

TCP
OPERATING NOTES AND SUGGESTIONS

GENERAL, INFORMATION
All single-digit entries must be preceded by a0. That is, channel 6 is entered as
06, the 7th of the month is entered as 07.

While in TCP mode, depressing anything other than a NUMBER, SELECT or
ENTER will cause the TCP mode to be aborted without retaining programming
for this particular slot. If this occurs, simply re-enter the TCP mode via the
TCP button and step back to desired programming via the ENTER bution, or
the + of — button.

If nv entry is made while in the TCP programming mode within 40 seconds, the
TCP mode will be aborted and the user will be returned to nurmal converter
operation.

No parameters are entered into memory until the ENTER bution has been
depressed and the next prompt has been displayed.

The subscriber can, at any time, review the TCP entries by pressing TCP then
pressing ENTER or + of — in order to step through and review the currently
programmed TCP parameters. Pressing TCP again will return the subscriber to
normal operation without affecting the TCP entries.

A single-day entry which has been programmed into the TCP memory will be
erased from the TCP memory after it has been executed. For this reason TCP
will not be activated the same day of the next month unless the unit is
reprogrammed to do so.

After » TCP slot has been programmed for a future event purchase, the
SELECT and ENTER sequence must be repeated if any changes are made in
the event programming entries.

To cancel an event from TCP, simply press DELETE afier calling up the event
prompt (d!, d2, etc.) on the display.

106

PARENTAL CONTROL AND TCP

If the subscriber attempts to program a channel currently Parentally Controlled
inte TCP the converter will display ‘PL’. This means the channel the sub-
scriber has chosen to program into TCP is currently locked-out via Parental
Control. In order to program this channel into TCP the subscriber must first exit
TCP by pressing the ‘TCP’ Button. Once TCP has been exited the subscriber
can deactivate Parental Control by following the instructions on page 9.

Now that the converter is unlocked the subscriber can reenter TCP by pressing ©
the ‘TCP’ Button and program the unit with the desired information.

Now that the unit is programmed and TCP has been exited the subscriber can
reluck all Parental Control Channels by following the instructions on Page 10.

NOTE: Even though the converter is now in Parental Control Lock Mode, all
Parentally Controlled channels programmed into TCP will become viewable at
the time and date programmed into that particular TCP sk. To prevent viewing
of Parentally Controlled Channels after an event, program the converier to
turn off using the instructions under “Convenieace Outlet Programming” on
page 22.

DISABLING REMOTE ON CONVERTER

If the subscriber is using two converters, one for normal iclevision viewing and
the other for VCR recording, he may wish to disable the remote control
capability on the recording converter. By doing so the subscriber can operate
the viewing converter with the remote control without affecting the recording
converter.

The subscriber can disable the remote control capability by pressing LEARN
then @/O, being careful to sim the remote control at the converter to be
disabled; LO will appear on the converter display to indicate lock out. To
restore the remote control capability, the subscriber again presses LEARN and
@/0: the LO indication will disappear from the display and the wnit will be in
the normal operating mode. Any set-top key depression also disables LO. .

AUDIO QUALITY

To assure quality sudio during TCP recording, press F then MUTE (V) before
turning the converter off. When the F button is pressed the letter F will be
displayed on the converter. When the MUTE button is pressed the display will
indicate the current channel. The audio is now set for maximum recording
quality.

Cuntinurd

107

EVERYDAY PROGRAMMING

Any single programming sha can be programmed ty activate everyday fe S

pring cha mek ced eqeeceree be

ee ee | a

137

1S POWER I INES Ae nmal means |r
enh) me te becmed we the vwinty of overhead
mroet ines oe whew & con fell inee sch gomer
hor os corm When enasting se cutkde snarene

revue
Ss VV ie {he ee ceermnge te server then

'% DAMAGE REQUIRING SERVICE —
Unpheg thm cqppenens imum the wall cute: ened
crt cervacing © quatthed service perenne! ender
Og rnen en

‘ Whee te precrsepely cord or ging

» 1 ingen) hes bees peli ow cbgrte hee lefties
Ree

at SAPETY CHP Ue cmmptre 4 sey
er oe pe fe Re wel pees ot he
rene chant i peviwm sslety ches te
ere Get he vale pees me peer
oe omine

138

Your new STARCOM 7 features the latest technology
applicable to cable TV viewing. These instructions
were prepared to acquaint you with the operation of
STARCOM 7. Piease read this information carefully.
lt will help you to get the maximum enjoyment from
this product and will give you a better understanding
of its application for your cable TV system and your
home video and audio sysiem needs.

139

The material in this publication is for information purposes
Only and is subject to change without notice

140

OPERATING

Place the converter on a
smooth, flat surface. Air
should circulate freely under
and around the converter. DO
NOT place anything on top of
the converter. Adequate cool-
ing requires that the top of the
converter be clear.

Aim the remote control
directly at the converter. Be
sure there are no obstructions
between the remote control
and the converter.

Press and release butions one
at a time, firmly and deliber-
ately.

~~
.

E

14]

OPERATING

SUGGESTIONS

Be sure the TV set is tuned tw _—«?

the converter channel (CH 2,3 | Ty

of 4). Your cable installer will
tell you which channel to tune.

If the di flickers and the Pre
converte? will not change lisa * ; ]
‘

channels, unplug the converter a
from the 117 Vac walll outlet, |

wail ten seconds or longer. , KI |
plug the converter in again and

press the ON/OFF key to turn
the converter on again.

If channels can be changed
with the converter butions, but
not with the remote control,

check the battery. If the bat-

tery is weak or dead,
replace it.

if & power outage should occur, or if the converter is
unplugged. the converter memory will not “forget” which
channels have been designated favorite channels and
parental control channels. The converter will come back
on to the last channel viewed.

142

The STARCOM® 7 Model DQN?7-* converter has been
provided by your cable operator to enhance your cable
viewing pleasure. It contains a number of features to give
you greater convenience in home entertainment.

Among the many features are remote control capability.
parental control, favorite channel programming, last chan-
ne! recall, and attractive styling that is sure to match any
decor. Four butions are provided on the top of the con-
verter and corresponding buttons are included on the
remote control unit so you have the option of direct or
remote control of the converter. The remote control wnit
also provides for control of additional features which can-
not be controlled from the buttons on the converter.

Be sure to read this customer handbook , noting the use of
all the features to your new STARCOM 7 converter and its
remote control.

143

CONVERTER

CONTROLS

Press and release to select
next higher channel.

Press and hold to scan
upward.

———

a
CHANNEL DOWN

Press and release to select
neat lower channel.

Press and hold to scan
downward.

—

eo
ON/OFF

Press once to turn convertér on.

Press again to turn converter off.

——

ale
Alb

Dual Cable Sysiem:
Press to switch between cables.

Single Cable System:
Press to switch between cunverter

and VCR (if applicable).

| 44

Do not block or place objects in front of this arcs.

PARENTAL CONTROL INDICATOR “P”

0. ————————

CABLE MIDICATOR “8”
(Onty applicable when unit is equipped with an A/B swich |
I . If the unit is equipped with an A/B switch, this indicator
lights whee cable B is selected; it docs not light when

a cable A is selected. in 2 dual cable system, it will light

whea cable B is selected. In 2 single cable system. it will

light whee an shernste source is selected

_

145

REMOTE CONTROL AND
CHANNEL SELECTION

6/0 enten

WRN KEYS =) oe
Vress two keys, FAVORITE U
one ats tome, ON/OFF ne cel
c
— — aaa Press once tw turn memory bor
oye me > 4 CALL converter on Paremal Cuatrul
a — — Press again tw turn Overnde
cia ome converter off a
ae
ian —
Deal Cable System: Press and elease
Press to swiich 4 ae
between cables higher :
Single Cable System: pe
Press to switch ees
between convericr cman
and VCR iif
appl able) KA
uc C .
He | —
LAST CHANNEL or
to select next
RECALL lower chanac!
aon - Press and hold to
recall last channe! —
tuned Press again ’
to return to current
Used to set secret
code for Parental
245 Control Overnde and
to enfuock for
PARENTAL override
CONTROL ror O€LETE
Used to select oe =
Se Used to add s Used to remove a
emtal Cumrol Favurite Chanac! Fevurne Channac!

NOTE: The SELECT, VOL. MUTE. TCP. sad LEARN buttom
have so effect on your converter mode! DQN7.*

146

FAVORITE CHANNEL
TION

OPERA

TO SCAN
FAVORITE

CHANNELS ge ee Re
nt aa $a al

next higher favorite
channel.

147

PARENTAL CONTROL-
CHANNEL SELECTION

a Remove the padlock
(if already attached)
from the bracket on
the rear panel of
the converter, and O
place the switch ie . -- o
the unlocked —~
position. i:

UNLOCK

Tune the channel Press PC/PM to
which is to be select channel for
parentally parental control.
controlled.

4 | P indicator on con- Repeat steps 2, 3,
verter display will and 4 for all
light. desired parenially

' controlled

| @ (IS pr | aaa

NOTE This portion of the procedure simply identifies the
channels to be parentally controlled; it dues not lock them
out. See next page for activation of parental control
feature.

148

PARENTAL CONTROL-
ACTIVATION

NOTE: The user provides a pedioct with a shackle
diameter Y-inch or smaller.

After selecting the
channels to be con-

trolled (see

previous page). »)
push the switch on .
the rear pancl to LOCK

the locked

Pass the shackle of
the padlock
through the (wo
holes in the
bracket, and close
the pediock.

149

0-0:

DOI0-0-

4 | The P indicator
will go owt. The P
indicator will be on
only for those
channels which are
selected for paren
tal contro!

150

2 | Press the F bution

The channel indi-
cation “— —”" will
display

Press the numbered
buttons to select
your secret parents!
control override
code. Up to four
digits may be wsed
for this code. If
more than four dig
its are pressed.
only the lest fowr

digits will be wsed
for this code_

If you are slow in entering your code (more than five seconds between num-
bers). or if you press a button which is sot s number, the converter will return to
normal operation. IF YOU PRESS “ENTER™ AFTER PRESSING “F~, WITH-
OUT SELECTING A SECRET CODE, NO CODE WILL BE ENTERED. TO
ENTER A CODE, BEGIN THIS PROCEDURE AGAIN.

5 | Push the switch on
the rear pane! to
the locked posi-
tion

6 | Pass the shackle of
the padlock
through the two

_¥

holes om the
bracket, and close
the padlock

_euVCGQ_aq__—_—

iow

151

The parental control override feature allows you to view
those channels designated for parental control without
removing the padluck Tu override the parental control
kx kout, follow these instructions:

NOTE: You have three tries to enter the correct secret
code. If the wrong code is entered three times in a row, the
converter will not accept override codes for fifteen min-
utes. On the fourth attempt when you press the F bution.
the converter will display “ES™ for 2 seconds. However, if
you chose not to wait fifteen minutes. you can remove the
padiock to unlock the parental control.

152

The battery used is «

9- volt, rectangular
battery. NEDA type 1604
or equivalent

1 | Squeeze and lift tab to

Jerroid SRC Ii

KEY EQUIVALENTS

Jerrold RC 550

154

10h 0
14-400 OD

1-000 niu

| [000-0 0-00 |;

il-|+|]>|- |-lolg}f
Lon

ANCA aT

UUUEVUUU

alalel-oel5[glels|§]u

1-0-0-0:0 Roll

1-0-0-0 @-Bel}}-0

L
of]

155

FCC Caption Omitted

COMMENTS OF
Ann Arbor Community Access Television

Ann Arbor Community Access Television (AACAT) submits these
comments in response to the above captioned proceeding and in
support of the comments filed in this proceeding by the Alliance for
Community Media, Alliance for Communications Democracy,
American Civil Liberties Union and the People for the American
Way.

In particular, AACAT agrees that the provisions of Sections 10(c)
and 10(d) and the proposed rules all will be unconstitutional.
Assuming that the Commission decides to adopt rules to implement
either Section 10 (c) or 10(d):

a. The rules should be specific and as narrowly drawn as
possible, and must contain limitations that prevent cable operators
from hampering use of access channels by those who wish to
produce live or cablecast taped programming under the guise of
applying the rules. For example, would FCC rules prohibit a
program such as “Sexy Minutes”, which is produced by a
University of Michigan professor with the intent of providing
critical answers to questions of human sexuality in a “live call-in”
format? This would undoubtably be a detriment to the community!

b. Access centers have very limited resources. The FCC rules
should make it clear that any actions taken by an operator under
Section 10 must be undertaken at the operator’s own expense.

c. Approximately 240 hours of video and 240 hours text
programming are cablecast each week on the (3) access channels in
my community. Much of the programming is produced by
volunteers, and experience shows that it must be as easy as possible
for these volunteers to use. The rules must recognize that any
roadblocks that are placed in the way for rroduction will result in
a reduction in speech.

156

We believe that the rules must be developed in a manner that
the first amendment rights of our volunteer community producers
are not abridged. The issue of prior restraint and the appropriate
legal remedies should also be addressed in this proceeding.

Respectfully submitted,
/s/

Harry S. Haasch
Cable Administrator
City of Ann Arbor, Michigan

DATE: December 7, 1992

BLADE COMMUNICATIONS, INC.
MULTIVISION CABLE TV CORP.
PARCABLE, INC.

PROVIDENCE JOURNAL COMPANY
SAMMONS COMMUNICATIONS, INC.

The Commission’s Notice of Proposed Rule Making seeks
comment on proposed regulations implemented pursuant to the
provisions of The Cable Television Consumer Protection and
Competition Act of 1992 that restrict access by children to indecent
programming on leased access channels and enable cable operators
to prohibit the use of “PEG” access channels for obscene
programming. While the Companies commenting herein firmly
believe that these statutory provisions do not pass constitutional
muster, the Commission must nonetheless ensure that the proposed
regulations are workable and fair. Accordingly, the Commission
should adopt the following recommendations:

¢ define the relevant “community” for determining
standards of indecency as consisting only of cable
subscribers, or, in some cases, subscribers to a
particular channel or tier.

+ allow operators who “sequester” indecent programming
on a single leased access channel to count that channel
toward the allotment of channels that must be dedicated
to leased access and require the programmer to bear

158

any cost of blocking the channel.

* require programmers to notify operators whether or not
programming contains indecent material in advance of
channel use and in a specified written format.

+ define how an operator’s written indecency policy is
published, and permit operators to require appropriate
indemnification and insurance from programmers.

+ establish as grounds for an operator's “reasonable
belief” that programming contains indecent material
either a programmer's certification to that effect or a
programmer's refusal to so certify.

+ limit liability for operators who comply with the
prescribed regulatory steps for obtaining programmer

. require programmers seeking to air programs on
“PEG” access channels to certify whether or not the
program contains obscene material and limit operator

+ state that operators need not air a leased access program
found indecent or obscene by a governmental body.

FCC Caption Omitted

JOINT COMMENTS

Blade Communications, Inc., MultiVision Cable TV Corp..
ParCable. Inc., Providence Journal Company,’ and Sammons
Communications, Inc. (hereinafter “Companies”), by their
attorneys, hereby submit their Joint Comments in response to the
above-captioned Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (“Notice”). Each

Providence Journal Company conducts its cable television operations
through its subsidianes Colony Communications, Inc. and King Videocable
Company.

159

of the Joint Parties is an owner and operator of cable television
systems and, accordingly, will be directly affected by the outcome
of this proceeding.

A. Introduction

The Cable Communications Policy Act of 1984 required cable
operators to set aside certain channels for use by nonaffiliated
programmers through noncommercial “PEG” access or commercial
leased access.’ These provisions, always of questionable status
under the First Amendment’, force cable system operators to carry
programming against their own editorial judgment and without
regard to the wishes or interests of cable subscribers.

The Cable Television Consumer Protection and Competition Act
of 1992, P.L. 102-385 (the “1992 Act”), grafts new requirements
on the 1984 access provisions for the purpose of restricting the
distribution of “indecent”, “obscene” and other material over the
access channels. The new provisions run even further afoul of the
First Amendment, trampling not only on the rights of the operator,
as before, but also now on the rights of the access programmer.

Despite the fundamental constitutional infirmities of the access
provisions, the cable industry heretofore has accepted the obligation
of providing access as part of its public interest responsibilities.
These new requirements will make the burden of complying so
difficult and the risk of liability so serious that the industry can no
longer acquiesce in what has always been a highly questionable
scheme. That the new statutory provisions raise significant new
risks and burdens is evidenced by the fact that they were almost

47 U.S.C. §§ 531 and 532 (1988).

’ The status of cable systems as first amendment speakers akin to
newspapers is well recognized by the courts See Leathers v. Medlock.
111 S. Ct. 1438, 1442 (1991); City of Los Angeles v. Preferred
Communications, Inc., 476 U.S. 488, 494 (1986); and FCC v. Midwest
Video Corp., 440 U.S. 689, 707 (1979) Thus, the fundamental concept of
mandatory access is constitutionally suspect. See Miami Herald Publishing
Co. v. Tornillo, 418 U.S. 241, 258 (1974) and see also Century Federal,
Inc. v. City of Palo Alto, 710 F.Supp 1552, 1554 (N.D. Cal. 1987).

160

immediately challenged in the courts.‘

Meanwhile, the Commission faces the perplexing task of
adopting regulations to implement these difficult and legally
precarious provisions. Until the statutory provisions that require
these rules are declared unconstitutional — which the Companies

are confident they will be — the Commission has no choice but to
attempt to make something operable of a flawed and unfortunate
situation.

* - =

The Commission already recognizes that cable subscribers need
far less protection from obscene or indecent programming than do
members of the general public.* Unlike programs broadcast on
“free” TV or radio, which permeate the airwaves and often come
into the home unexpectedly, cable programming must be
affirmatively invited into the home through the viewer’s act of
subscribing to cable service. In addition, the subscriber has the
option of buying only basic cable programming and foregoing other
tiers, channels or even individual programs that might contain
programming he or she considers objectionable. Furthermore, there
already is federal legislation that requires cable operators to furnish
cable subscribers with “parental control devices” or “lock boxes”
to block off or restrict viewing of certain channels in their own
homes. See 47 U.S.C. § 544(d)(2)(A); 47 C.F.R. § 76.11; 50
Fed. Reg. 18,655 (1985). Finally, a cable subscriber who finds
cable programming in general “patently offensive” can cancel the
subscription and still receive television programming off-air or
through other delivery systems.

» * bd

* See Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P. v. FCC and United
States, Civil Action No. 92-2494 (D.D.C. filed Nov. 5, 1992); Discovery
Channel v. United States, Civil Action No. 92-2558 (D.D.C. filed
Nov. 13, 1992).

* See Report of the Commission in MM Docket No. 89-494, 67 RR2d
1714, 1726 (1990) and Notice of Inquiry in MM Docket No. 89-494, 4
FCC Red 8358, 8364 (1989).

161
Respectfully submitted,

BLADE COMMUNICATIONS, INC.
MULTIVISION CABLE TV CORP.
PARCABLE, INC.

PROVIDENCE JOURNAL COMPANY
SAMMONS COMMUNICATIONS, INC.

By: _/s/_
Donna C. Gregg

/s/
Michael K. Baker

Their Attorneys

WILEY, REIN & FIELDING
1776 K Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006

December 7, 1992

162

COMMENTS OF THE
BOSTON COMMUNITY ACCESS
AND PROGRAMMING FOUNDATION

The Boston Community Access and Programming Foundation
is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit corporation established in 1982 to provide
public access and community programming to Boston residents.
We operate two channels, known as the Boston Neighborhood
Network (BNN), on the Boston cable system. Our primary funding
comes from Cablevision of Boston.

BNN’s access operation provides training and production
facilities to Boston residents and institutions wishing to produce
programs. We also present staff-produced programming, most
notably a daily half-hour neighborhood news program. During our
last fiscal year, BNN cablecast 1,326 original access programs, plus
713 original Foundation-produced programs. Including repeats, we
cablecast 2,797 programs, or 2,319 hours of programming.

We work hard to involve ethnic, racial, and linguistic minorities
in program production in order to serve the many diverse audiences
that comprise our city. Our goal is to make the channel as rich in
diversity as the city itself.

We wish to specifically comment on the Commission’s proposed
regulation, paragraph (d), which would enable a cable operator to
prohibit certain types of programming on public, educational and
governmental access channels.

A Solution in Search of a Problem

Before promulgating a rule as far-reaching as the one the
Commission proposes, the Commission should first establish that
there is a problem that needs to be solved. In fact, neither the FCC
nor Congress has shown that any problem exists. The Commission,
in its Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, gives no information at all
about whether or not any programming actually exists on access

163

Channels that it feels is inappropriate. Congress, in its debate,
provided a single example: Senator Fowler asserted that access
channels are used to solicit prostitution through shams such as
escort services and fantasy parties, and Senator Wirth stated that he
had seen this material in New York City. Cong. Rec., Jan. 30,
1992, S649-5S0 (daily ed.). (Even this one example is questionable,

There are 250 access systems in Massachusetts alone, and
literally thousands across the country. To subject all of these

Programming Foundation has operated one of the nation’s largest
and most ethnically diverse public access operations. Over this
time, we are not aware of any programs that would fall into the
Categories of prohibited material under the proposed FCC rule, as
we understand the rule.

To be sure, we have had programs that were controversial.
including some that have offended viewers. We have responded to
the issue of “offensive” programming in a way that we feel
addresses the legitimate needs of three separate groups (1) parents
who do not want their children exposed to particular programs, (2)
adult viewers who would like the opportunity to view a diversity of
programs, and (3) producers who are exercising their First
Amendment right of free speech.

The process we have devised is as follows: First, we require
Producers to inform the Foundation, when requesting cablecast
time, if a program may be offensive to some audiences or is of a
mature nature. The Foundation may require producers to place an
appropriate viewer warning at the beginning of these programs.
Depending on the nature of the program, the Foundation may also
require that the program be cablecast after 10 p.m. or after 11 p.m

164

A producer who disagrees with staff decisions on these matters may
appeal to a Grievance Committee consisting of three Trustees and
two producers.

In fact, there have been few disputes, since staff and producers
are usually in agreement about the most appropriate time for a
program. On two occasions over the past year, the Grievance
Committee was asked to decide whether programs were too
“offensive” for 10 p.m. time slots. One was a program by an
African-American producer of “uncensored” rap music, containing
repeated use of an offensive word. The other program was a gay
drama, suggesting phone fantasies as the ultimate form of “safe
sex.” As our most risqué programs, these are the types that would
be in jeopardy under the Commission’s proposed rule. It is
interesting that the programs that would be endangered are
programs by and for minority communities— A frican-Americans and
gays.

In Boston, through a community process, we have already

Proposed Rule is Overbroad

from the Cable Consumer Protection and Competition Act to
prohibit “any programming that contains obscene material, sexually
explicit conduct, or material soliciting or promoting unlawful
conduct.” Obscenity has been defined by the courts over the years.
The public therefore has at least some idea what it means. But the
term “sexually explicit” appears to be a new term, never before
defined.

In note 11 of its Notice, the Commission hints that “sexually
explicit” might mean the types of “indecent” programming that the
Act says may be prohibited by cable operators over leased access
channels, specifically programming that “describes or depicts sexual

165

OF excretory activities or organs in a patently offensive manner as
measured by contemporary community standards for the cable
medium.”

This interpretation is flawed. The courts have repeatedly ruled
that the First Amendment does not permit a 24-hour-per-day ban on
material that is indecent but not obscene. The Commission has an
obligation to interpret the law in accordance with the Constitution.
The Commission must interpret the law to say that “sexually
explicit” programming means exactly the same as “obscenity.”

Courts have faced the issue of indecent communications in
television, and telephones. In Cruz v. Ferre, 755 F.2d 1415 (11th
Cir. 1985), the Court of Appeals overturned a City of Miami
ordinance prohibiting indecent material on the city’s cable system.
In Action for Children’s Television v. FCC, 932 F.2d 1504 (D.C.
Cir. 1991), cert. denied, 112 S.Ct. 1281 (1992), the Court of
Appeals struck down the FCC's 24-hour-per-day ban on indecent
broadcasts over radio and television. In Sable Communications v
FCC, 492 U.S. 115 (1989), the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the
FCC could not place a total ban on indecent commercial messages
(known as “dial-a-porn”) over interstate telephone lines. The
definition of “indecency” in all three cases was similar to the

iti that the Commission apparently believes applies to cable
access.

The Supreme Court in Sable summed up the constitutional
requirement:

Sexual expression which is indecent but not obscene is

protected by the First Amendment... The Government

may, however, regulate the content of constitutionally
protected speech in order to promote a compelling interest
if it chooses the least restrictive means to further the

Sable at 126 (emphasis added). The Court agreed that there was a
compelling interest in protecting the physical and psychological
well-being of minors. However, a 24-hour-a-day ban on indecent
material was not a permissible way to achieve that end, since such

166

a blanket prohibition would deprive adults of their ability to receive
Constitutionally protected speech. The Court cited Butler v.
Michigan, 352 U.S. 380 (1957), where a law was found to be too
restrictive when it “denied adults their free speech rights by
allowing them to read only what was acceptable for children. As
Justice Frankfurter said in that case, ‘Surely this is to burn the
house to roast the pig.”” Sable at 126, citing Butler at 383.

The proposed FCC rule, as its applies to cable access, does not
pass either of the two Sable tests. First, it does not “promote a
compelling interest,” since there is no evidence to indicate that any
material even exists on cable access from which minors need
protection. Second, it does not use the “least restrictive means to
further the articulated interest.” As the Court already ruled in
Sable, a 24-hour ban does not meet this test.

The Commission is indeed proposing to “burn the house to
roast the pig”—yet in this case the pig does not even exist.

Less Restrictive Means Are Available

If the Commission determines that there exists an abundance of
indecent programs on access television from which children need
protection, then there are ways to accomplish this objective that are
less intrusive than the Commission’s proposal.

Most simply, the problem could be addressed at the local level.
The procedure described above for Boston is one such approach.
Other access operations may have their own procedures that work
equally well.

Additionally, parents who do not want their children exposed
to programming on an access channel could use the parental “local-
box,” which is required to be provided by all cable operators under
the Cable Communications Policy Act of 1984 §624(d)(2)(A), 47
USC §544(d)(2)(A). A lock-box is defined as “a device by which
the subscriber can prohibit viewing of a particular cable service
during periods selected by that subscriber.”

Finally, a subscriber has the option of terminating cable service.

The FCC was given a limited power to regulate “indecency” on
radio and television because the broadcast media had established a

167

“uniquely pervasive presence” and was “uniquely accessible to
children,” FCC v. Pacifica Foundation, 438 U.S. 726 at 748-49
(1978). The Court in Cruz v. Ferre, 755 F.2d at 1420, stated that
Pacifica did not apply to cable television, because cable subscribers
have many options—including lock boxes and disconnecting
service—to control program viewing by children.

Rule’s Vagueness Will Lead to Uneven Enforcement

The wording of the proposed rule does not give cable operators,
access channel operators, or access producers a clear sense of what
programming is allowed and what is not. While the courts have
stated that the FCC definition of “indecency” is not vague when
applied to broadcasting, they did so in the context of a single
enforcement agency —the FCC—which has over the years developed
an elaborate series or policy statements and precedents. This is far
different from the case of cable access prohibitions, where
determination of whether a program is “sexually explicit” would be
made by literally thousands of individual cable system managers.
based not only on different corporate philosophies, but on the
beliefs and prejudices of each individual general manager.

It is almost certain that some over-zealous cable operators will
misinterpret the Commission’s concept of sexually explicit conduct.
The burden will be on public access speakers, who will be required
to seek court relief to obtain their First Amendment rights. Most
public access producers simply have no funds to hire lawyers, and
will lose their Constitutional rights for lack of funds.

What is most disturbing is that the types of programming that
cable operators are today most eager to eliminate are precisely the
types that the First Amendment was created to protect—programs
by gays and others with unpopular lifestyles, rap artists and others
with “offensive” manners of speech, and “hate” groups and other

168

Regulations Would Impose Unfair Burden on Access Producers
and Organizations

The “Initial Regulatory Flexibility Analysis” attached to the
Commission’s Notice notes that the regulations would impose new
burdens on cable operators—but fails to mention the far greater

burdens that would be imposed on nonprofit access organizations,
institutional access producers, and individual access producers.

The Commission suggests only one idea for a process to
actually carry out its proposed rule. In paragraph 14 of its Notice,
the Commission proposes that producers and access organizations
would need to “certify” that every program that was cablecast did
Although not stated by the Commission, the certification would
apparently be submitted to the cable operator, who would
apparently have the right to intercept and black-out any programs
that were not so certified. In order to make this certification,
independent nonprofit organizations that operate access channels
would need to pre-screen all tapes prior to cablecast. In Boston, we
would need to allocate staff time to view and evaluate each of the
1,326 individual access programs we cablecast per year, and would
need to file a certification with the cable operator for each of them.
This imposes a huge new burden of staff work and paperwork on
organizations such as ours, which, by their very nature, are already
grossly understaffed and overworked.

Furthermore, if the necessary paperwork were not filed for a
particular program in a timely fashion, the cable operator might
decide to delete that program from cablecast. There are very few,
if any, access programs that actually contain material prohibited by
the proposed rule. For every program that the cable operator takes
off the air for reasons of program content, a far greater number will
be taken off for failure to file necessary paperwork.

What will happen to live programming, such as call-in
programs, political debates, or coverage of city council meetings?
Since the cable operator can never be certain what live

programming will contain, will all live programming be banned?
Such a blanket prohibition seems a case of prior restraint.

169

It would be ironic if one of the final actions of the Reagan-Bush
FCC—a Commission dedicated to removing unnecessary
government regulations—would be to impose a burdensome, vague,
and overbroad regulation that addresses a problem that does not
exist.

Recommendations

The Commission should rewrite its proposed rule to eliminate
the category of “sexually explicit” programming, since
category must be interpreted to mean “obscene” programming.

Individual access producers should have the responsibility of
determining whether their programming is obscene or promotes
illegal activity, but should nor be required to complete unnecessary
paperwork in cases where programs are acceptable.

Respectfully submitted,

/s/
Martin Kessel, Clerk
Boston Community Access
and Programming Foundation
8 Park Plaza, Suite 2240
Boston, Massachusetts 02116

December 4, 1992

170

FCC Caption Omitted

COMMENTS OF
Roxie Lee Cole, Citizen

Roxie Lee Cole submits these comments in response to the above
captioned proceeding and in support of the comments filed in this
proceeding by the Alliance for Community Media, Alliance for
Communications Democracy, American Civil Liberties Union and
the People for the American Way.

in particular, Roxie Lee Cole agrees that the provisions of Sections
\Ovc) and 10(d) will be unconstitutional, however they are
implemented. However, assuming that the Commission decides to
adopt rules to implement either Section 10(c) or 10(d):

a) The rules should be specific and as narrowly drawn as
possible, and must contain limitations that prevent cable operators
from hampering use of access channels by those who wish to
produce live or cablecast taped programming under the guise of
applying the rules. The public access operation | was involved with
for over thirteen (13) years did live programing of community
events that ranged from professional entertainers to the very
nexperienced performer. We have live discussions that ranged
from very serious health problems to neighborhood street widenings
— al! with no problem nor need for censorship.

b) The 1984 Cable Act limited much of the support access
centers had been receiving from cable companies previously. The
access center resources are very limited and the FCC rules should
make it clear that any actions taken by an operator under Section 10
cnust be undertaken at the operator’s own expense. The 1992 Cable
Aci was intended to cut cost to the consumer; however, these new
rules will in fact increase the consumer bill.

c) More than 100 hours are video and text programming are
-ablecast each week on the access channel in my community. The
majority of the programming is produced by volunteers, and

171

experience shows that it must be as easy as possible for these
volunteers to use. Many neighborhood meetings are done with a
single camera and taped and run gavel to gavel. Any rules must
recognize that any roadbloacks that are placed in the way for
production will result in a reduction in speech.

During my 13 years of experience, many times the cable
operator and/or City representatives would have limited speech of
some citizens if they could have legally. 1 am greatly concerned for
the many citizens who now freely speak will lose this right because
of the proposed rule changes.

Respectfully submitted

/s/
Roxie Lee Cole

1145 Bishop Drive, Apt F
Dayton, Ohio - 45449

December 7, 1992

172

COMMENTS OF
Columbus Community Cable Access, Inc. (ACTV 21)

Columbus Community Cable Access (ACTV 21) submits these
comments in response to the above captioned proceeding and in
support of the comments filed in this proceeding by the Alliance for
Community Media, Alliance for Communications Democracy,
American Civil Liberties Union and the People for the American
Way.

In particular, ACTV 21 agrees that the provisions of Sections 10(c)
and 10(d) will be unconstitutional, however they are implemented.
However, assuming that the Commission decides to adopt rules to
implement either Section 10(c) or 10(d):

a. The rules should be specific and as narrowly drawn as
possible, and must contain limitations that prevent cable operators
from hampering use of access channels by those who wish to
produce live or cablecast taped programming under the guise of
applying the rules.

b. Access centers have very limited resources. It could cost
as much as $35,000.00 per year to implement the Commission's
rules for the 5,824 hours of programming which is transmitted
yearly on the public access channel alone. There are, also, an
educational access channel and a government access channel in
Columbus, each with an equivalent number of annual hours of
programming. The FCC rules should make it clear that any actions
taken by an operator under Section 10 must be undertaken at the
operator's Own expense.

c. Approximately 112 hours of video and text programming
are cablecast each week on the public access channel in our
community . Much of the programming is produced by volunteers,
and experience shows that it must be as easy as possible for these
volunteers to use the access channel. Any rules must recognize that

173

any roadblocks that are placed in the way of production will result
in a reduction in speech.

ACTV 21 is a nonprofit organization which operates the public
access channel serving more than 225,000 cable subscribers in
Franklin County, Ohio. ACTV is funded, in part, through the 3%
franchise fee from the City of Columbus.

The services provided by ACTV 21 include video training,
equipment and facility usage, program scheduling and promotion,
and a volunteer corps. The public access channel is operated as a
public forum on a first-come, first-served basis. During the last
eight years, ACTV 21 has trained 5,514 local citizens in video
production. Those individuals, community organizations and
nonprofit organizations have produced 14,892 Original programs.
The community volunteers have put in nearly 30,000 hours of
volunteer work to assist other citizens in speaking on the public
access channel.

More than 150 community organizations, nonprofits and churches
used ACTV’s services in 1991 alone. These organizations represent
a variety of local interests such as: The John Birch Society, The
Columbus Urban League, The Afro-American Center, Hispanic
Alliance of Central Ohio, National Organization for Women, The
Boy Scouts, United Way of Franklin County, Ohio Special
Olympics, the Columbus Area Chamber of Commerce, BalletMet
and the Native American Indian Center.

Any rules which the Commission may adopt must consider the
affect of those rules on the current and potential speakers on public
access channels who, often, represent unique and underrepresented
points of view in our democracy.

Respectfully Submitted,

/s/
Carl Kucharski, Executive Director
Columbus Community Cable Access, Inc. (ACTV 21)
394 Oak Street
Columbus, Ohio 43215 DATE: December 7, 1992

The Community Antenna Television Association, Inc,
(“CATA”), is a trade association representing owners and operators
of cable television systems serving approximately 80 percent of the
nation’s more than 60 million cable television subscribers, CATA
files these “Comments” on behalf of its members who will be
directly affected by the Commission’s action.

INTRODUCTION

This proceeding is in response to the mandate of Section 10 of
the Cable Television Consumer Protection and Competition Act of
1992 (“Cable Act”), that the Commission adopt rules and
regulations implementing the provisions of that section. Essentially,
Section 10 is intended to restrict the availability of programming
deemed to be indecent or obscene on cable television access
channels. First, it permits cable operators to voluntarily prohibit
indecent programming on leased channels on their systems.
Second, it requires the Commission to adopt rules that will limit
access by children to indecent programming on leased channels by
requiring operators to place all indecent programming on a single
channel whose reception is blocked except upon a written request
for it by the subscriber. Third, it permits operators to prohibit the
use of public, educational, and government access channels (“PEG
channels”) for programming that contains “obscene material,
sexually explicit conduct, or material soliciting or promoting
unlawful conduct.” Finally, Section 10 removes the operator’s

175

Statutory immunity from liability for obscene material on any access
channel.

CATA submits that the provisions of Section 10 of the Cable
Act are both unconstitutional and from a practical viewpoint,
unworkable. Nevertheless, we understand that the Commission
must attempt to carry out its mandate and we offer comments of a
constructive nature designed to help the Commission make the best
of a bad predicament.

I. THE INDECENCY AND OBSCENITY PROVISIONS
ARE UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND UNWORKABLE

CATA would be more than remiss if it did not preface its
“Comments” by firmly asserting that the provisions of Section 10
of the Cable Act are an unconstitutional infringement on the rights
of cable operators, their subscribers and access programmers. We
will not go through the legal rationale supporting our allegation in
this proceeding because it already is well stated in the court
challenge to the Cable Act filed by Time Warner (Time Warner
Entertainment Company v. FCC) in U.S. District Court, where the
issue will be decided. Suffice it to say that these provisions restrict
the editorial control over the content and packaging of the cable
operator’s product and constitute a taking of the operator’s property
without just compensation in violation of the Constitution. The
provisions of Section 10 put cable operators in the untenable
position of requiring them to do what the government cannot do by
acting as censors of programming. We will await the outcome of
the Time Warner challenge to settle this issue.

From a more practical point of view, especially for smaller
cable systems, which constitute a significant portion of CATA’s
membership, the indecency and obscenity provisions are
unworkable. As proposed, the rules for both leased access and
PEG access channels put the burden of determining whether a
program violates the statute on the operator with respect to systems
that choose to adopt a policy restricting the specified “indecent” or
“illegal” programming respectfully. This virtually eliminates any
live access programming as operators concerned about their liability
will need to review each program before allowing it on the access
channel.

176

Moreover, the provisions will require an inordinate commitment
of manpower to review all access programming. It is the system
operator who must review every program before it is carried on a
leased access channel to determine whether it is “indecent,” and
every program before it is carried on a PEG access channel to
determine whether it contains “obscene material, sexually explicit
conduct, or material soliciting or promoting unlawful conduct.”
Smaller systems will be particularly hard hit because of their limited
personnel. It is not unusual for these systems to have a small staff
performing a variety of duties often in a number of communities,
at one time. The end result we suggest, is a disincentive for
operators to adopt policies restricting indecent programming on
leased and PEG access channels.

Other practical problems exist with respect to the requirement
that all indecent programming on leased access channels be put on
a single, “blocked” channel. What happens if the channel becomes
filled? How many additional channels must the operator make
available? If none, which programmer’s programs are to be carried?
And what if the programs certified by the programmer as
“indecent” really are not, but instead constitute an effort by an
individual or group to prevent the carriage of any “indecent”
programming by occupying all the time on the only channel
available for that purpose?

The numerous constitutional and practical concerns serve to
underscore the necessity of leaving control of access channels in the
hands of the cable operator.

Il. SUGGESTIONS FOR MAKING THE REGULATORY
SCHEME MORE MANAGEABLE

CATA recognizes that the Commission is required to implement
the provisions of Section 10 of the Cable Act despite their
unconstitutional and unwieldy nature. Therefore, it offers the
following constructive suggestions that should help make the
regulatory scheme more manageable.

177

A. Operators should be given a “safety zone” within which
they will not be held liable for the carriage of indecent or
obscene programming.

CATA suggests that the model used for the single blocked
channel, i.e., where the burden is on the programmer to notify the
Operator when a program is deemed to be indecent, be extended to
cover other leased and PEG channels in situations where the
operator has adopted a restrictive policy as contemplated by the
Statute. If an operator chooses to adopt a restrictive policy, he
should be allowed to require and rely upon certifications from
programmers that their programs do not violate the policy. If the
operator adopts and follows an established procedure of requiring
certifications from programmers, he will fall within a “safety zone”
Protecting him from liability for carriage of indecent programs on
the leased channels or the prohibited programming on the PEG

Using this approach, the Commission will protect the operator
from the unintended situation where he is more vulnerable to
liability for having adopted a policy against carriage of indecent or

CATA suggests that the same model be used in determining
liability for carriage of obscene programming as well. If the
operator can demonstrate an established procedure of requiring
certifications that programming is not obscene, he should be entitled
to the protection of the “safe zone” and not be held liable. At the
very least, it should entitle the operator to a presumption that he did

178

not have the requisite element of intent to be liable for carriage of
obscene programming.
B. “Indecency” should be defined in the context of cable

programming selected by the subscriber and only upon request and
payment of a monthly fee. Even after delivery the subscriber
continues to maintain a high degree of control over the availability
of the programming. Lockboxes may be secured (and in fact, must
be provided by the operator upon request) that enable subscribers

Cable programming is not omnipresent like a television or radio
signal. It is not likely to be stumbled upon by unwary viewers. It
must be invited into the subscriber's home and specific programs as
well as whole channels of programs, can be specifically uninvited.
Thus. the term “indecent” should be defined narrowly when used
in the context of programming on cable television systems.

S. Costs incurred in complying with these provisions must be

accounted for in determining the system's basic service
rates.

vine with the ind ar sions of Secti
10 are to be accounted for in setting the basic service rate.

As we noted above, the new requirements will impose
burdensome administrative obligations on many systems
necessitating employment of additional personnel as they may be
required to pre-screen all access programming before allowing it to

D. Cable operators need at least 60 days notice that

programming will be “indecent.”

The provisions of Section 10 require suppliers of leased access
programming to notify the cable operator when a program is
indecent and therefore required to be carried on the designated
single blocked channel. A period of at least 60 days is essential.

must be designed to be sensitive to the various difficulties. costs and
Jeopardy they impose on system operators, and particularly smaller

180

_ We offer the above proposals as constructive suggestions
for making the best of a bad situation.

Respectfully submitted,

THE COMMUNITY ANTENNA TELEVISION
ASSOCIATION, INC.

181

Continental Cablevision, Inc. (“Continental”) submits these
comments to assist the Commission in its effort to implement
Section 10 of the Cable Television Consumer Protection and
Competition Act of 1992 (“Act”). We raise three primary points.

First, in adopting rules to permit cable operators to prohibit
obscene and indecent programming on public, educational, or
governmental (“PEG”) and leased access channels, the Commission
must balance the cable operator's potential liability for obscene
programs against the desire to minimize editorial intrusion into PEG
and leased access channels. To this end, the Commission should
permit cable operators to rely on certifications by programmers and
should further provide that such reliance constitutes an affirmative
defense to liability. If the Commission does not provide such a
defense, cable operators must be permitted to make their own
determination regarding the possible obscene nature of programs
carried on leased and PEG channels.

Second, the Commission should clarify that all state and local
franchise authority regulations, as well as specific franchise
Third, when structuring the single channel requirement for
leased access channels, the Commission must adopt regulations that
will preserve the local cable operator’s choice to prohibit or restrict
indecent programming. If the regulations are unreasonable, unduly

182

FCC Caption Omitted

: ILEVISION, LS

Pursuant to the Commission’s Notice of Proposed Rulemaking
(“NPRM”), Continental Cablevision, Inc. (“Continental”) submits
these comments on the proposed regulations implementing the
provisions of the Cable Television Consumer Protection and
Competition Act of 1992 (“Act”) relating to indecent and obscene
programming .

INTRODUCTION
Continental, founded in 1963, is the third largest multiple cable
system operator and the largest privately owned cable company in
the United States. It serves nearly 2.9 million basic subscribers in
600 communities in 16 states, or roughly 5.5% of the nation’s cable
television households. Public, educational, or governmental access
(“PEG”) channels are utilized in many of the communities

183

Continental serves. Leased access channels are also available for
commercial use.

Continental operates in a decentralized manner, permitting its

: - iderable di lon and in ing

comments to assist the Commission in its effort to implement
Section 10 of the Act in a manner that will avoid

logistical and practical problems for operators and subscribers.
Adoption of rules that recognize these problems could help prevent
transforming this provision into a de facto ban on indecent
programs.

Before discussing these practical problems, we address two
threshold issues in these comments. First, because of cable
operators’ potential liability for obscene programming on PEG and
leased access channels, already in effect as of December 4, 1992,
we urge the Commission to adopt a regulatory scheme that
minimizes cable operators’ editorial intrusion in access
programming so long as their liability is corresponding ly
minimized. Second, we ask the Commiss ion to clarify that all
inconsistent franchise agreement provisions and local regulations are
preempted.

184

sromoting unlawful conduct.”' Within 60 days of passage of the
sect ¢ . as of December 4), cable operators are subject to liability
- carriage of obscene materials on the PEG channels.’ In the
“PRM. the Commission seeks comment on how cable operators can
_ategones of programming on PEG channels and on additional
.cues the Commission should consider.’

Phere are a number of issues the Commission should consider.
© est the Commission should clarify that the Act permits operators
prohibit some. but not all, of the types of programs listed in
section 10kc) of the Act. Nothing in the language of the Act, for
-xample. prevents an operator from excluding only a subset of the
~road categories included in Section 10(c) from its PEG channels.

Second. Continental views as essential the Commission’s
.egestion that cable operators should be permitted to require
--, fications from PEG programmers that no materials falling into

‘ the statutory objectionable categories will be presented on

The Cable Television Consumer Protection and Competition Act of
4) Pub. L. No. 102-385, § 10(c), 106 Stat. 1460, 1486 (1992) (to be
fed as amended at 47 U.S.C. § 532) (hereinafter “Act”).

4« the Commission noted in its NPRM, the amendment to Section 638
f the Act, which eliminates cable operators’ immunity for leased access
od PEG channels, is self-implementing and therefore effective
4 1992 NPRM at 4 2. Until such time as the Commission adopts rules
permtting cable operators to prohibit obscene programs from their PEG
nannels, therefore, cable operators are subject to liability for obscene
srogramming on PEG channels without any corresponding authority to
-xclude such programming from the PEG channels. This raises substantial

- est the Commission think that sexually explicit programming on PEG
-hannels s never an issue, we note by way of example that public access
srograms on one Continental system have included a program in which an
sceess user, frontally nude, urinated on a photograph of the President of
he United States and another concerning safe sex that involved a graphic
4S munute demonstration of how to use a condom.

185

the PEG channels.‘ Certification would minimize both the
operator's editorial intrusion and operational burden. But these
certifications can be relied on by the operator only if the
Commission also makes clear that a cable operator who relies on
such a certification has an affirmative defense to liability if material
is later found to fall within a prohibited category, notwithstanding
the programmer's prior certification to the contrary.

If the Commission does not provide for programmer
certification and permit those certifications to be an affirmative
defense to liability, the cable operator must be permitted to
(1) make its own determination, notwithstanding any certification,
that material is obscene and should be excluded, (2) word its
certification request in whatever form it desires — é.g., all sexually
explicit material, and (3) be held harmless for decisions to exclude
material the operator reasonably believes to be obscene. If the
cable operator is going to be held liable — potentially criminally
liable — for obscene programming on the PEG channels even if a
programmer certifies there is no such programming, then the
operator must be afforded the discretion to exclude material that the
operator reasonably believes to be obscene. And the operator must
be permitted to ask for certification regarding a broader category of
programming than obscenity — “sexually explicit” material, for

. In the NPRM, the Commission states that certification by “users or
operators” could be sought. NPRM at 414. Continental assumes the
Commission intended to mean programmers and program providers.

* Such a procedure would be consistent with the Commission’s decision
involving obscene or indecent programming carried on multipoint
distribution service (MDS) systems, in which the Commission concluded
that “there must be a high degree of involvement or actual notice of an
illegal use and failure to take steps to prevent such transmissions before
any liability is likely to attach.” Enforcement of Prohibitions Against the
Use of Common Carriers for the Transmission of Obscene Materials,
Memorandum Opinion, Declaratory Ruling and Order, Docket No. 83-
989, 2 FCC Red. 2819, 2820 (1987).

186

example — so that the operator can review the sexually explicit
programs to decide if it reasonably believes any of it is obscene.°

Finally, the Commission should extend its rules governing a
cable operator's ability to prohibit these kinds of programs on
leased access channels. Specifically, cable operators should be
expressly permitted to exclude from leased access channels obscene
programs only and, if they so choose, to rely on certifications (with
a defense against liability) to enforce such a policy.

Il. THE COMMISSION SHOULD CLARIFY THAT ALL
STATUTES OR REGULATIONS OF ANY STATE,
FRANCHISING AUTHORITY OR OTHER LOCAL
GOVERNING BODY THAT ARE INCONSISTENT
WITH THE ACT AND COMMISSION’S
REGULATIONS ARE PREEMPTED

Many state and local franchise authority regulations, as well as
specific franchise agreement provisions, will be directly affected by
the substantial alterations in the Act and the FCC’s rules on
indecent and obscene cable television programming on leased access
and PEG channels. Many existing franchise agreements, for
example, prohibit cable companies from exercising editorial control
over the content of programming on these channels.’ Because
those franchise provisions are inconsistent with the provisions in the
Act authorizing cable operators to prohibit or restrict certain types
of programming on PEG and leased access channels, the
Commission should clarify in its order that all inconsistent
provisions in franchise agreements and state or local regulations are
preempted by the new federal statutory provisions and implementing

* Although, as the Commission notes, these disputes involving PEG
channels are frequently resolved at the local level, NPRM at { 14, it is the
Commission that has been directed to establish the regulatory framework.

The franchise agreement between Continental's Greater Dayton (Ohio)
system and the Miami (Ohio) Valley cable Council provides, for example,
that the cable operator “shall exercise no control over program content on
any of the access channels.”

187

regulations, pursuant to the Section 656 of the Communications
Act, 47 U.S.C. § 556.

There is a related issue the Commission should clarify.
Pursuant to the enabling regulations of the local franchising
authority (or in franchise agreements), many cable operators have
entered into arrangements with independent access corporations
whereby the operators sign over editorial control for programming
on cable channels.’ Frequently, the access corporations transmit
live programs directly from their studios onto dedicated PEG
channels. Many access agreements contain a provision
indemnifying the cable operator for liability stemming from the
actions of the corporation. These indemnification provisions,
however, would not appear to (nor could they) protect the operator
from criminal liability for airing obscene material under the new
liability provisions of the Act. Thus, the Commission should also
provide that any contractual arrangements with independent access
corporations, to the extent these provisions limit a cable operator's
control over obscene or indecent programming, are also preempted
by the Act.

iil. THE COMMISSION MUST ADOPT

The Act grants cable operators the choice of either:
(1) prohibiting all indecent programming on leased access channels.
or (2) restricting indecent (but not obscene) programming, pursuant
to the regulations adopted by the commission. to a single leased
channel and restricting access to the indecent programming unless

* The franchise agreement between Continental Cablevision of
Brockton, Inc, and the Brockton, Massachusetts, nonprofit access
Corporation, for example, provides that the access corporation “shall have
sole responsibility for determining access and scheduling of time on the
allocated channels.”

188

the subscriber requests access in writing.’ Continental urges the
Commission to adopt regulations that will in fact (not just in theory)
preserve the local cable operator's choice to either prohibit or
restrict such programming. If the Commission adopts regulations
that are unreasonable, unduly cumbersome or costly, the result will
be a de facto ban, which would be contrary to Congress’ intent'®
and a clear violation of the Constitution."

The Commission should, therefore, adopt rules that (1) permit
cable operators to fully recover the costs of complying with the
single channel requirement, (2) define single channel in a manner
that maximizes efficient channel usage, (3) delay implementation of
the single channel requirement for 120 days so that cable operators
have sufficient lead time to equip themselves and their customers so
that they can comply with the requirements, (4) provide a
reasonable notification period by program producers to allow cable
operators time to restrict access to indecent programs, and
(5) require a 30-day advance, written notice of a subscriber's desire
to change access to indecent programming.

Act at § 10.

© See 138 Cong. Rec. $646,649 (daily ed. January 30, 1992). In
discussing the provision of the Act permitting cable operators to prohibit
indecent programming on leased access channels, the sponsor, Senator
Jesse Helms, stated: “The pending amendment merely gives cable
operators the legal right to make that decision. The amendment does not
require cable operators to do anything. Therefore, let me say it again, this
amendment does not in any way propose censorship.” Id. at § 646.

See Sable Communications of California, Inc. v. Federal
Communications Commission, 492 U.S. 115 (1989) (statutory ban on
indecent telephone messages violates the First Amendment); Action for
Children’s Television v. Federal Communications Commission, 932 F.2d
1504 (D.C. Cir. 1991), cert. denied, 112 S. Ct. 1281 (1992) (ban on all
radio and television broadcasts of indecent material violates the First
Amendment).

189
A. The Commission Must Permit Cable Operators To Recover

Restricting indecent programming on leased access channels to
a single channel and scrambling such programming to prevent
reception unless the subscriber has affirmatively requested access
will impose significant costs on the cable operator. If operators are
not permitted to

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385013_0640%3A05. Public record. Not legal advice.
