# Joint Appendix — C & a Carbone, Inc. v. Clarkstown

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385013_0385%3A06

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Joint Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1994
- **Citation:** 511 U.S. 383

## Text

| Pilbeam ian
i; JUL 16 1993

h f

No. 92-1402 _ OFFICE OF thi Giri!

APE

In THE
Supreme Court of the United States

OCTOBER TERM, 1993

C & A CARBONE, INC.,
RECYCLING PRODUCTS OF ROCKLAND, INC.,
C & C REALTY, INc., and
ANGELO CARBONE

Petitioners,
v.

TOWN OF CLARKSTOWN,
Respondent.

On Writ of Certiorari to the Supreme Court,
Appellate Division, Second Department
of the State of New York

JOINT APPENDIX

BETTY JO CHRISTIAN WILLIAM C. BRASHARES
Counsel of Record Counsel of Record

STEPTOE & JOHNSON MINTZ, LEVIN, COHN, FERRIS,
1330 Connecticut Ave., N.W. GLOVSKY AND PoPEo, P.C.
Washington, D.C. 20036 701 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
(202) 429-3000 Washington, D.C. 20005
Counsel for Petitioners (202) 434-7300

Counsel for Respondent

PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED FEBRUARY 24, 1993
CERTIORARI GRANTED MAY 24, 1993

BEST AVAILABLE COPY

t
;

3 /

a

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Joint Appendix Page
Docket entries, New York Court of Appeals 1
Docket entries, New York Supreme Court, Appellate
LS SRE - CS oa ee 2
Docket entries, New York Supreme Court, Rockland
Ts as caieomenipninnen 3
Judgment with notice of entry (Rec. 99.94) Set esteem 4
Order to show cause for preliminary and permanent
a coenenedgnennbtennosones 7
Affidavit of Charles E. Holbrook (Rec. 58-61) .............. 9
Affidavit of Angelo Carbone (Rec. 81-82) —.......0.......... 12
Affidavit of Paul J. D’Alessandro (Rec. 113-19) ........ - 14
Affidavit of Murray N. Jacobson (Rec. 120-34) ........... 20
Minutes of public hearing, Town of Clarkstown, Nov.
14, 1989 (Rec. 142-59) ......000....... a ELS Ro a 34
Permit No. 4429 (Rec. 160-62) _.... ee ear ele ES, 69

Letter from Margaret Duke, New York State Dept. of
Environmental Conservation, to Angelo Carbone,
C & A Carbone, Inc., April 5, 1991 (Rec. 163-64) 73

Letter from Ajay R. Shah, New York State Dept. of
Environmental Conservation, to Michael A. Cech,

County of Rockland, April 2, 1991 (Rec. 165-68) _. 76
Environmental Assessment Form (Rec. 240-45) ........ 81
Map, Plan and Report for the Establishment of Town

Garbage and Refuse District (Rec. 249-80) 86
C & A Carbone, Inc. v. Holbrook (N.Y. Sup. Ct. Oct.

18, 1990) (Rec. 296-97) ............. AA) SST 110
C & A Carbone, Inc. v. Holbrook (N.Y. Sup. Ct. Feb.

es ee ee, EE enuiaabanienbenneessosesens 112
Affidavit of Angelo Carbone (Rec. 331-39) —......... : 116

Letter from Richard Gardineer, New York State Dept.
of Environmental Conservation, to Angelo Carbone,
C & A Carbone, Inc., June 8, 1991 (Rec. 382-83) ...—s—-:124

ii

TABLE OF CONTENTS—Continued

Page
Appendix to Petition for Certiorari
Town of Clarkstown v. C & A Carbone, Inc. (N.Y. App.
Div. Ang. 82, 10GB) .......cncccresscsosssssssspssssneeeee la
Town of Clarkstown v. C & A Carbone, Inc. (N.Y. Sup.
Ct. Bemt. 16, ROBB) ....ccccccecceccsccessssssssenununnsanennenee l6a
Town of Clarkstown v. C & A Carbone, Inc. (N.Y. Sup.
| Be! SB ) } enn 22a
C & A Carbone, Inc. v. Town of Clarkstown (S8.D.N.Y.
Tal 11, 1GOD) ..ccccccvecscrsessercoescsescserssessnenenneae 34a
Town of Clarkstown v. C & A Carbone, Inc. (N.Y.
Cet, BT, TDBB) ..cccecccccessscccecsscesecesseescesstiesnunsnaananee 47a
Town of Clarkstown, New York, Local Laws 1999,
WhO, BD ceccccccrccccosstccnssccecesccossscneciennneiiaunsninsnninnnnnnnnnnnnnnnEEE 48a
Town of Clarkstown v. C & A Carbone, Inc. (N.Y. Sup.
Ct.) (First Amended Answer To First Amended
Complaint) ...........cccccs-rececssserssseseeenssensesseensnnsaninnnnnnnnnnnnn 55a

NEW YORK COURT OF APPEALS

DOCKET ENTRIES

9/11/92 Moving Papers requesting permission to
appeal ;

9/11/92 Intermediate court record and brief:

9/25/92 Papers in opposition and copy of brief:

2

NEW YORK SUPREME COURT
APPELLATE DIVISION

RE: Town of Clarkstown
-against-
C & A CARBONE, RecycLtING Propucts of Rock-
LAND, INc., C&C REALTY, INC., ANGELO CARBONE,
et al.

Rockland County Clerk’s #: 1549 91 (RJS)

DOCKET ENTRIES
Appellate Division Docket—No 91/07786

Motion for State 08/22/91
Motion for Consolidation of Appeals 10/02/91
Filings:
Record & Brief 10/03/91
Respondent's Brief 10/28/91
Reply Brief 11/04/91

Decision to Dismiss Appeal 08 (31/92

ACTIONS

03/19/91
07/15/91
07/15/91
07/15/91

07/15/91
07/15/91

07/15/91
07/15/91
07/15/91
07/15/91
07/15/91
07/24/91
08/01/91
08/01/91
08/09/91
08/09/91
08/09/91
08/09/91
09/19/91
09/19/91

09/19/91
09/24/91

3

NEW YORK SUPREME COURT
ROCKLAND COUNTY

DOCKET ENTRIES

RJI—STOLARIK
EXHIBITS L-R

REPLY MEMORANDUM
ANSWER

COMPLAINT
REPLY

DECISION & ORDER—L46 P1396
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE—L46 P1394
AFFIDAVIT

SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT
EXHIBITS A-D

ORDER L46 P1998
MISCELLANEOUS PAPERS
JUDGMENT—L46 P2463
NOTICE OF APPEAL
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
NOTICE OF APPEAL
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
MEMORANDUM

MINUTES

ORDER—B47 P1834
NOTICE OF APPEAL

4

Judgment with Notice of Entry, Dated July 31, 1991 [22-24]

SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF ROCKLAND

Index No.: 154991

THE TOWN OF CLARKSTOWN,
<against- Plaintiff,
C&A CARBONE, INC.,
RECYCLING PRODUCTS OF ROCKLAND, INC.,
C&C REALTY, INC.,
ANGELO CARBONE and
“JoHN Doe 1 through 6”,
Defendants.

JUDGMENT

PRESENT: Hon. Robert J. Stolarik, J.S.C.

Plaintiff having moved this Court for an order pursuant
to CPLR § 6311 enjoining the defendants from (1) un-
lawfully disposing of solid waste in violation of Clarks-
town’s Local Law No. 9 of 1990; (2) operating a transfer
station at 183 Western Highway, West Nyack, New York
in violation of Chapter 106 of the Clarkstown Town
Code: and (3) from conducting illegal business operations
at defendants’ premises, and the application having been
fully submitted to the Hon. Robert J. Stolarik on May 16,
1991 at which time the parties stipulated that the motion
be treated as one for summary judgment in accordance
with CPLR 3212 and after reading and filing the order
to show cause dated March 18, 1991, the supporting affi-
davits and annexed exhibits, plaintiff's summons and

5

amended verified complaint, the affirmation and supple-
mental affirmation in opposition of Kenneth H. Resnik,
Esq. and opposing affidavits, defendants’ amended answer
and counterclaims, movant’s supplemental affidavits and
the attorney’s statement of Richard A. Glickel with an-
nexed exhibits submitted in support of plaintiff's applica-
tion and the memoranda of law and reply memoranda of
the respective parties, and said motion having been
granted by decision and order of this Court duly made
and entered on July 15, i991 directing, inter alia, the
submission of a judgment in favor of the plaintiff,

NOW, on motion of Richard A. Glickel, attorney for
plaintiff, it is

ADJUDGED and DECREED that Clarkstown’s Local
Law No. 1990 is valid and constitutional; and it is
further

ADJUDGED and DECREED that the defendants are
in violation of the provisions of Clarkstown’s Local Law
No. 9 of 1990; and it is further

ADJUDGED and DECREED that the plaintiff is en-
titled to the injunctive relief sought; and it is

ORDERED and ADJUDGED that the defendants are
hereby restrained and permanently enjoined from oper-
ating their respective business or suffering and or permit-
ting such business operations at the premises owned by
them, in violation of Clarkstown’s Local Law No. 9 of
1990 and the defendants are hereby directed to imme-
diately cease all such operations in violation of Clarks-
town’s Local Law No. 9 of 1990 and Chapter 106 of the
Clarkstown Town Code at the premises located at 183
Western Highway, West Nyack, New York, and it is
further

ORDERED that all counsel shall appear at chambers
on Wednesday, August 7, 1991 at 9 am. to attend a
conference for the scheduling of disclosure in furtherance
of the assessment of damages.

6

Dated: New City, New York
July 31, 1991

/s/ Robert J. Stolarik
Hon. Rosert J. STOLARIK
J.S.C.
To:

Richard A. Glickel

Special Counsel to

Murray N. Jacobson, Town Attorney
Attorney for Plaintiff

Two Crosfield Avenue—Suite 205
West Nyack, New York 10994

Granik Silverman, et al.
Attorneys for Defendants
254 South Main Street

P.O. Box 370

New City, New York 10956

7

Order to Show Cause for Preliminary and Permanent
Injunction—Proposed Summons and Verified Complaint
[45-47]

SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF ROCKLAND

[Title Omitted in Printing]

ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE

PRESENT: Hon. Joan B. LeFKowi1rTz, Justice of the
Supreme Court.

Upon reading the summons and verified complaint and
the affidavits of Paul J. D'Alessandro, Administrative
Lieutenant, John P. Kubran, Detective Lieutenant, both
of the Clarkstown Police Department, Charles E. Hol-
brook, Supervisor of the Town of Clarkstown, and Mur-
ray N. Jacobson, Town Attorney of the Town of Clarks-
town, each sworn to on the 18th day of March, 1991,
from which is appears that this action is brought for a
permanant injunction restraining and enjoining the de-
fendants from operating a transfer station ad from un-
lawfully disposing of acceptable waste in violation of
Local Law No. 9 of 1990 and those chapters of the Town
Code regulating the transportation and disposal of solid
waste within the Town of Clarkstown, and the plaintiff
having applied for a preliminary injunction and a tempo-
rary restraining order herein,

Let the defendants show cause before this Court at the
Rockland County Courthouse, Main Street, New City,
New York on the 29th day of March, 1991 at 9:30 a.m.,
or as soon thereafter as counsel can be heard why an

8

order should not be made and entered herein restraining
and enjoining the defendants from operating a transfer
station and from unlawfully disposing of solid waste in
violation of Local Law No. 9 of 1990 and those chapters
of the Town Code regulating the transportation and dis-
posal of solid waste within the Town of Clarkstown and
directing that the defendants immediately cease all illegal
business operations at the premises known as 183 West-
ern Highway, West Nyack, New York, pending the hear-
ing and determination of plaintiff's motion and why the
plaintiff should not have such other and further relief as
to the Court may seem just and proper.

Sufficient reason appearing therefore, it is

ORDERED, that pending the hearing and determina-
tion of this motion, the defendants be and they are hereby
restrained and enjoined from operating a transfer station
and from unlawfully disposing of solid waste generated
within the Town of Clarkstown, and the defendants shall
immediately cease all illegal business operations at the
premises known as 183 Western Highway, West Nyack,
New York, pending the hearing of plaintiff's motion, and
it is further

ORDERED, that service of a copy of this order and
the papers upon which it is granted upon defendants, on
or before the 21st day of March, 1991 be deemed good
and sufficient service.

Dated: New City, New York
March 18, 1991

And it is further ordered that the phrases “and with-
out” and “and determination” are stricken provided that
defendants post a bond of $10,000 with the Commissioner
of Finance of Rockland County.

s Joan B. Lefkowitz
JS.C.
March 19, 1991

9

Affidavit of Charles E. Holbrook, Sworn to March 18, 1991,
for Plaintiff, in Support of Application [58-61]

SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF ROCKLAND

[Title Omitted in Printing]

AFTIDAVIT

STATE OF NEW YorK )
Ss.
COUNTY OF ROCKLAND )

CHARLES E. HOLBROOK, being duly sworn, de-
poses and says:

1. That he is the duly elected Supervisor of the Town
of Clarkstown and a member of the Clarkstown Town
Board and he respectfully makes this affidavit in support
of the present application for an order restraining and en-
joining the defendants from operating a transfer station
and from unlawfully disposing of solid waste in violation
of Local Law No. 9 of 1990 and the Town Code of the
Town of Clarkstown and directing that the defendants
immediately cease all illegal business operations at 183
Western Highway, West Nyack, New York.

2. That on December 31, 1990 the Clarkstown Town
Board duly passed and adopted Local Law No. 9 of 1990
entitled “Solid Waste Transportation and Disposal.” A
certified copy of Local Law No. 9 of 1990 is annexed to
the complaint herein as exhibit “A.”

3. Local Law No. 9 of 1990 was enacted by the Town
Board in response to the closing of the TOWN’s landfill
operation at the end of 1990 and is intended to address

10

the transportation and disposal of solid waste generated
within the TOWN through the construction and operation
of a solid waste facility known as a “transfer station”
through which all acceptable solid waste generated by the
residents of the TOWN and collected by duly licensed
private carters would be weighed, baled and loaded for
transport and disposal to out-of-state landfills.

4. The contract for the construction and operation of
the TOWN’s transfer station was awarded pursuant to
proposal and bid in early 1990 and the facility has been
operational since the beginning of this year. The TOWN
is obligated to deliver for transport and disposal through
this facility a specified annual tonnage of acceptable solid
waste generated within the Towns of Clarkstown and
Orangetown ' and will be assessed a penalty for each ton
under the requisite annual minimum of 120,000 tons.

5. Local Law No. 9 of 1990 directs that ail accept-
able waste generated within the territorial limits of the
TOWN is to be transported and delivered to the TOWN’s
transfer station at Route 303 in West Nyack or to other
disposal or recycling facilities operated by the TOWN or
recycling centers established by special permit. In the case
of acceptable waste brought to a recycling facility the law
requires that the unrecycled residue be disposed of at the
TOWN’s transfer station.

6. Since 1989 residents of the TOWN have been sepa-
rating at the point of origin or generation recyclable
materials. This program has proved to be enormously
successful and the list of recyclables has been expanded
to include newspapers, glass, aluminum cans, magazines
and junk mail. By June of this year plastic bottles and

—

1 Upon information and belief on Monday, March 11, 1991, the
Orangetown Town Board unanimously enacted a local law similar
to Clarkstown’s Local Law No. 9 of 1990 requiring all carters who
pick up solid waste within the Town of Orangetown is to be trans-
ported and delivered to the Ciarkstown transfer station at Route
303, West Nyack, New York.

11

containers will be included. Thus, there remains very
little recyclable material in the acceptable solid waste
generated within the TOWN to be collected by the carters
permitted to operated within the TOWN.

7. By unlawfully bypassing the TOWN’s transfer sta-
tion, the defendants are costing the TOWN and its resi-
dents thousands of dollars daily in uncollected revenues
as well as increasing the likelihood of the TOWN’s failure
to meet is contractual obligation to the transfer station.

8. By receiving, baling, and loading for transport and
disposal solid waste generated within and without the
Town of Clarkstown, the defendants are operating a trans-
fer station in violation of Local Law No. 9 of 1990 and
Chapter 106 of the Clarkstown Town Code.

9. Without question the TOWN has already suffered
irreparable harm in losses estimated in the hundreds of
thousands of dollars. The ongoing investigation by the
TOWN’s law enforcement officers has established that the
defendants are acting in violation of said laws and or-
dinances and will continue to do so unless they are imme-
diately restrained and enjoined by order of this Court and
directed to cease all illegal business operations at the
premises owned and/or operated by said defendants at
183 Western Highway, West Nyack, New York.

WHEREFORE, deponent respectfully requests an order
of this Court restraining and enjoining the defendants
from unlawfully disposing of solid waste in violation of
Local Law No. 9 of 1990 and those chapters of the
Town Code regulating the transportation of solid waste
within the Town of Clarkstown and directing that the
defendants immediately cease all illegal business opera-
tions at 183 Western Highway, West Nyack, New York
and for such other and further relief as to the Court may

seem just and proper.
‘s’ Charles E. Holbrook

CHARLES E. HoLBrooxk

[Notary Omitted in Printing]

12

Affidavit of Angelo Carbone, Sworn to April 3, 1991,
for Defendants, in Opposition to Application [81-82]

SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF ROCKLAND

[Title Omitted in Printing]

AFFIDAVIT

1. ANGELO CARBONE, being duly sworn, deposes
and says as follows:

2. I am a defendant in the above entitled action and
an officer of C & A Carbone, Inc. and as such am fully
familiar with the underlying facts and circumstances of
the within matter. I have read plaintiff's application and
Supporting papers and make this affidavit in opposition
to plaintiff's motion for a preliminary injunction pending
a final determination of the merits of the case.

3. C & A Carbone, Inc. maintains a recycling facility
located at 183 Western Highway, West Nyack, Town of
Clarkstown, County of Rockland. At that site, waste is
received from out of state as weil as parts of New York
outside the Town of Clarkstown.

4. After receipt, the waste is “shaken down” or sep-
arated, the recyclables are removed and the remaining
waste left after separation is prepared for disposal.

5. Once the above process is completed, the various
components are shipped by ICC licensed truckers from
our site in New York to facilities in the midwest and
south including landfills, resource recovery sites and
other disposal facilities in Ohio, Delaware, Pennsylvania,

13

Kentucky, Indiana and Florida. On a weekly basis,
C & A Carbone, Inc. processes and ships over one hun-
dred fifty (150) tons of waste interstate, using ICC
licensed truckers for the transport.

/s/ Angelo Carbone
ANGELO CARBONE

[Notary Omitted in Printing]

14

Affidavit of Paul J. D’Alessandro, Sworn to April 18, 1991,
for Plaintiff, in Further Support of Application [113-119]

SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF ROCKLAND

[| Title Omitted in Printing]

AFFIDAVIT

STATE OF NEW YORK )
Ss.
COUNTY OF ROCKLAND _ )

PAUL J. DDALESSANDRO, being duly sworn, deposes
and says:

1. That he is an administrative lieutenant for the
Clarkstown Police Department and he makes this affidavit
in support of plaintiff's application for summary judgment
herein or, alternatively for an injunction pendente lite and
in reply to the allegations contained in the answering affi-
davits of the defendant Angelo Carbone and of one Gi!
Font.

2. There is no question but that following the motor
vehicle accident of March 8, 1991, (as previously de-
scribed in the affidavits of myself and Lt. John Kubran
both dated March 18, 1991) wherein a tractor trailer
load of garbage was torn open when it struck the Route
59 overpass to the Palisades Interstate Parkway, that a
number of similar vehicles’ were followed from the de-

1In all a total of eleven (11) tractor-trailer loads were diverted
to the TOWN’s transfer station from March 9 through March 18,
1991, where they were weighed and off-loaded. The said eleven loads

15

fendants’ location en route to the New York State Thru-
way, detained and directed to the Town of Clarkstown’s
transfer station on Route 303 in West Nyack, New York.
It was then and is now the position of the Town of
Clarkstown and its law enforcement officers that the de-
fendants are operating an illegal transfer station in viola-
tion of the Clarkstown Town Code, specifically, Chapter
106 entitled “Zoning”.’

3. Undoubtedly, Mr. Font was advised of the
TOWN’s position vis-a-vis the only legally permitted trans-
fer station within the Town of Clarkstown.

4. Deponent never suggested to Mr. Font that “Miele
could help him in New Jersey” nor would deponent ever
offer such advice inasmuch as solid waste transferred
from the Miele facility in New Jersey must go to the
Bergen County transfer station for baling and out-of-state
transport.

5. Not a single driver was intimidated or otherwise
threatened in any way by either, deponent or any other
member of the TOWN’s police department and the alle-
gation in the Font affidavit that a driver was “frightened”
into carrying a load to the State of Pennsylvania is a
ridiculous lie. In fact, it was only as an attempt to help
those drivers who had expressed concern over having to
travel great distances only to return empty, that they were
advised that they might be able to make arrangements
with Clarkstown Recycling Center, Inc. for their reload-
ing with acceptable solid waste which had lawfully been
delivered to and baled at the TOWN’s transfer station.

represent a minuscule percentage of the total number of loads
transported from the defendants’ location within this time frame.

2 Apparently the defendants had been operating an illegal transfer
station under the guise of a so-called “recycling facility or center”.
However, in their complaint filed in the United States District
Court on March 27, 1991, the defendants boldly assert their direct
competition with the TOWN’s transfer station,

16

6. Every vehicle that was directed to the TOWN’s
transfer station was released following weighing and off-
loading: none were impounded nor forfeited as the instru-
mentalities employed in furtherance of the defendants’
illegal activities. Mr. Font’s statement that “. . . within
the last two weeks, the Town of Clarkstown by its police
department has stopped many of our trucks on the way
into the Carbone facility directing them not to go onto the
premises,” is also untrue. Since Mr. Glickel’s in camera
agreement that. pending the further modification of the
temporary restraining order or the Court’s granting of the
injunctive relief sought, the TOWN would not continue to
divert vehicles from the defendants’ premises, no vehicles
have been stopped by the Clarkstown Police Department.

7. Prior to the incident of March 8, 1991 involving
the spillage on the PIP, it was presumed that the defend-
ants were operating a “recycling facility” (albeit without
the requisite special permit). Only following that occur-
rence and our obtaining a warrant and executing a search
of the defendants’ premises was the extent of defendants’
illegal activities revealed. Angelo Carbone states in his
affidavit to this Court that C&A Carbone “processes and
ships” over 150 tons of waste weekly. According to the
defendants’ shipping logs a total of 970 tons of “muni-
cipal solid waste” was transported from the defendants’
premises during the six-day period beginning February 25
through March 2, 1991! The shipping manifests identify
the shippers of the municipal solid waste as “C&A Car-
bone” and “R.P.R.” destined for out-of-state landfills.‘

3 Within twelve (12) hours of the search of defendants’ premises,
deponent received a subpoena duces tecum from the United States
Attorney for the Southern District of New York directing the
delivery of all of the seized documents to a special agent of the
FBI for transmission to a federal grand jury.

*“R.P.R.” presumably identifies the defendant Recycling Products
of Rockland, Inc. which, to the best of your deponent’s knowledge
and belief, is neither a licensee nor a permittee of either the DEC
or the TOWN.

17

8. As someone who by necessity became intimately
familiar with the contents of those loads originating from
defendants’ premises which were diverted and eventually
offloaded at the TOWN’s solid waste facility, deponent
would describe said contents as “garbage,” plain and
simple. Deponent wouldn't know if, prior to baling and
loading, defendants’ garbage was sifted, shaken, or picked
over for the removal of any purported recyclable; how-
ever, deponent can report to the Court that there was
found within these loads tires mounted on steel rims.
truck springs, unmounted tires, automobile fenders and
exhaust systems, putrescible household waste including
vegetable and animal matter and other foodstuffs, dis-
posable baby diapers, bathroom tissue, surgical gloves and
intravenous feeding bags.°

9. Defendants allege within their federal court com-
plaint (which they have annexed to their papers in oppo-
sition to the present application as exhibit “A”) that
deponent and Det. Lt. Kubran “directed” the off-loading
of the ill-fated trailer load of garbage onto trucks owned
by the defendant(s). In reality, several individuals were
already hard at work upon our arrival at the scene of this
accident, frantically attempting to remove the garbage
from the scene before the origin of same could be dis-
covered by law enforcement personnel. A number of
these workers identified themselves as employees of North-
eastern Recycling Co. of 77 Brookside Place. Hillsdale,
New Jersey. Northeastern Recycling, upon information
and belief. is neither owned nor operated by the Carbones
but, rather, is owned by the Franco family. In fact, Car-
mine Franco, one of the Northeastern partners, appeared
at the PIP accident scene and identified himself to NYS
Trooper Michael Utzig and an individual identifying him-
self as Angelo Franco was also at the scene. Members of

5 According te the DEC’s definition: “Recyclable” means solid
waste that exhibits the potential to be used repeatedly in place of a
virgin material (6 NYCRR § 360-1.2[b][120]).

18

the Franco family appeared at the TOWN’s transfer stat-
tion at Route 303 in West Nyack, New York when trucks
had been diverted to that facility for weighing and off-
loading. Post-accident surveillance of the defendants’
premises revealed the delivery of waste to that location
by trucks registered to Anchor Carting Co. of Wee-
hawken, New Jersey, another Franco entity. It is obvious
to your deponent that the Francos are also involved in the
illegal enterprise being conducted at defendants’ premises
and that they and their corporate alter-egos or partner-
ships are the “John Doe” defendants herein.

10. Further evidence of the involvement of the Franco
family in the defendants’ business was the presence of one
James Ribaudo at the premises at the time that your de-
ponent and other members of the Clarkstown Police De-
partment executed the aforementioned warrant. Mr.
Ribaudo is a long-time Franco employee and president of
Sal-Car Transfer Systems, Inc. of Hillsdale, New Jersey,
a transfer station owned and operated by the Francos.
According to Bergen County authorities Sal-Car has ad-
mitted to violating New Jersey State Waste Flow Regula-
tions by accepting trash that is supposed to go to the
Bergen transfer station. It is estimated that Sal-Car de-
prives the Bergen County Authority of roughly 100,000
tons of trash annually! In July, 1986 Salvatore Franco
was barred from New Jersey's garbage industry for at-
tempting to circumvent that state’s Board of Public Utili-
ties’ Regulations. In April, 1987 Carmine Franco was
barred from the New Jersey garbage industry for conspir-
ing to restrain free trade within the industry.” According
to Salvatore Franco, neither brother is in the garbage

On September 4, 1987, New Jersey’s Board of Public Utilities
upheld the April, 1987 Administrative Law Judge’s ruling to revoke
Carmine Franco's certificate of public convenience and necessity
and to bar Franco from further participation in the solid waste
collection and disposal industries. Franco and his company each
were assesed penalties of $1.1 million as a result of their anti-
competitive activities.

a centennial

19

business, “We're in the recycling business now”? It there-
fore comes as no surprise that the defendants have been
operating an illegal transfer station and will continue to
do so until enjoined by court order.

11. The defendant Recycling Products of Rockland,
Inc., is the embodiment of the Franco-Carbone alliance.
In a corporte disclosure form submitted to the TOWN
in furtherance of Bid No. 77-89, the ownership of that
incorporation was identified as follows: “Salvatore Franco
—50%; Angelo Carbone—25%; Carmine Carbone—
25%.” Upon information and belief, Recycling Prod-
ucts of Rockland, Inc., is neither a licensee nor a
permittee of the New York State Department of Environ-
mental Conservation, the TOWN or any other agency or
department involving the regulation of the collection,
separation, processing, packaging, sale or transport of
solid waste, recyclable materials, or the residue thereof.

WHEREFORE, deponent respectfully requests an order
of this Court granting summary judgment permanently
enjoining and restraining the defendants from maintain-
ing and operating an illegal transfer station in violation of
the Clarkstown Town Code and Local Law No. 9 of
1990 and directing that the defendants immediately cease
all illegal business operations at 183 Western Highway,
West Nyack, New York or, in the alternative, granting
plaintiff's application for an injunction pendente lite, and
for such other and further relief as to the Court may
seem just and proper.

s Paul J. D'Alessandro
PauL J. DALESSANDRO

[ Notary Omitted in Printing]

7So reported The Hudson Dispatch on Monday, December 4,
1989, “Trash king still rides high despite probes”. According to
Carol Ash, the regional! director of the State of New York’s En-
vironment Office in New York City, “Suddenly, everyone wants to
call themselves recyclers”, Mob Looks at Recycling and Sees Green,
The New York Times, Wednesday, November 28, 1990.

20

Affidavit of Murray N. Jacobson, Sworn to April 19, 1991,
for Plaintiff, in Further Support of Application [120-134]

SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF ROCKLAND

[Title Omitted in Printing]

AFFIDAVIT

STATE OF NEW YORK )
Ss. :
COUNTY OF ROCKLAND _ )

MURRAY N. JACOBSON, being duly sworn, deposes
and says:

1. He is the duly appointed Town Attorney for the
Town of Clarkstown and he respectfully makes and sub-
mits this affidavit in support of the TOWN’s application
for an order granting summary judgment enjoining and
restraining the defendants from their continued operation
of a transfer station in violation of the Clarkstown Town
Code and the local laws and ordinances of the Town of
Clarkstown and in reply to defendants’ opposition thereto.

2. From the outset, it must be noted that the TOWN’s
zoning ordinance does not permit the construction and or
maintenance of a transfer station anywhere within the
TOWN. As deponent has previously stated in his affidavit
of March 18, 1991, the only lawfully permitted transfer
station within the Town of Clarsktown is the TOWN’s
facility located cu Kouic 303 in West Nyack, New York.

3. Defendants are well aware of the foregoing and do
not contest this fact. In his public comments to the

21

Clarkstown Town Board at a hearing on the defendant
CARBONE’s application for a special permit to operate a
“recycling facility,” Kenneth H. Resnik stated, on Novem-
ber 14, 1989, that his client “. . . neither intended nor
wanted a transfer station and that same is not permitted
under the TOWN’s zoning ordinance.” ' (A copy of the
minutes of the public hearing are annexed hereto and
made a part hereof as exhibit “E”).

4. As recently as last month the defendants continued
to deny any involvement in the operation of an illegal
transfer station, restating that it was their desire to oper-
ate and maintain a “recycling facility or center”; how-
ever, since the commencement of this litigation, the de-
fendants have abandoned that masquerade and now iden-
tify themselves as interstate transporters of solid waste
engaged in direct competition with the TOWN’s transfer
station.”

5. The permit issued to defendant CARBONE on or
about July 17, 1987 is for the operation of a “solid waste
transfer station.” Two (2) weeks ago, the TOWN’s

1 As defined by DEC regulations, “Transfer station means a solid
waste management facility, other than a recyclables handling and
recovery facility exclusively handling non-putrescible recyclables,
that can have a combination of structures, machinery, or devices,
where solid waste is taken from collection vehicles and placed in
other transportation units for movement to another solid waste
management facility” (6 NYCRR § 360-1.2[b][157]).

As amended May 23, 1989, Chapter 106 of the Clarkstown Code
defines “Transfer Station—An area of land upon which is located,
permanently or temporarily, structures, machinery and/or other de-
vices where any solid waste, refuse, leaves, trash, trees or soil is
taken from a collection vehicle and placed either upon the land, into
any other transportation unit or into any other device for future
movement to another location” (Clarkstown Code § 106-3).

2See paragraphs “4”, “12”, “24”, “43” and “47” as contained
in the defendants’ federal complaint filed in the United States Dis-
trict Court (SDNY) on March 27, 1991, annexed to defendants’
opposing papers as exhibit “A”.

22

supervisor was advised in writing by New York State's
Department of Environmental Conservation that the
DEC considers the defendant's facility “. . . to be pri
marily a transfer station and not a Materials Recovery
Facility (MRF).” In that same correspondence, the
DEC's regional engineer expressed that the defendants’
tactic of describing transported, baled garbage as “re-
cyclables” is “contrary to the Department’s rules and regu-
lations.” And in a separate correspondence dated April 5,
1991 the defendants were notified by the DEC’s regional
permit administrator that “. . . baled garbage bound for
incineration is not considered to be a recyclable mate-
rial. . . .” (Copies of the permit no. 4429 and corre-
spondence dated April 2, 1991 and April 5, 1991 are
annexed hereto and made a part hereof and marked as
exhibits “F,” “G” and “H,” respectively ).

6. The defendants seek to challenge the validity of the
TOWN’s Local Law No. 9 of 1990, but they have failed
to raise any objectiton to the TOWN’s zoning ordinance.
It is respectfully submitted that this Court need look no
further than defendants’ operation of a transfer station in
violation of the TOWN’s zoning ordinance in granting the
requested permanent injunction (/ncorporated Vil. of
Freeport v. Jefferson Indoor Marina, Inc., 162 AD2d
434, [2d Dept., June, 1990]). There is no question but
that a local government may ban commercial solid waste
transfer stations from its territorial limits (Town of La-
Grange v. Giovenetti Enterprises, 123 AD2d 688, 507
NYS2d 54, 55; Town of Islip v. Zalak, {[A.D. 2 Dept.].
N.Y.L.J., Tuesday, 2/26/91, p. 21, 1991 WL 18606) and
designate the town’s transfer station as the sole facility
for delivery of all solid waste (Vinnie Montes "Vaste Sys-
tem, Inc. v. Town of Oyster Bay, [A.T. 9th J.D.], 1991
WL 30383).

7. Given the heretofore constant posture of the de-
fendants that they were not operating a transfer station,
their general challenge to the constitutionality of the

23

“other chapters” of the Clarkstown Town Code cannot
pertain to the TOWN’s zoning ordinance (Moran vy. Vil-
lage of Philmont, 147 AD2d 230, 542 NYS2d 873)
which enjoys a strong presumption of constitutionality
(see, de St. Aubin v. Flacke, 68 NY2d 66, 76, 505
NYS2d 859, 496 NE2d 879). Nor can it be said that
Chapter 106 of the Town Code represents an abuse or the
improper exercise of the TOWN’s police power (Town of
Islip v. Zalak, supra; Al Turi Landfill, Inc. v. Town of
Goshen, 556 F Supp 231 [1982]).

8. Should the Court feel that'it is necessary to look
beyond the enforcement of the TOWN’s zoning ordinance
and scrutinize the implementation of the TOWN’s Local
Law No. 9 of 1990, the defendants must again fail.

9. The defendants have alleged in their amended
answer as a “third affirmative defense and first counter-
claim” a lack of compliance with Article 8 of the En-
vironmental Conservation Law (SEQRA). A review of
the opposing papers including the defendants’ District
Court pleading establishes that the defendants are not
aggrieved by the adoption of Local Law No. 9 of 1990
in a manner which would qualify them for standing to
raise a SEQRA challenge. In this regard, the defendants
must demonstrate that they will suffer an injury that is
environmental and not solely economic in nature (Mobil
Oil v. Syracuse Indus. Dev. Agency, 76 NY2d 428, 559
NYS2d 974; Greenwich Comm. v. Warren, 164 AD2d
469, [3d Dept., December 27, 1990]). The defendants
have not identified any non-economic, environmental dam-
age to their premises at 183 Western Highway, West
Nyack, New York.

10. The opposition is replete with the “buzz-words”
of modern environmental law and premised upon coun-
sel’s supposition that plaintiff must have missed a turn
in the labyrinth of statutory and procedural requirements
housed within the Environmental Conservation Law, the
applicable regulations of the Department of Environ-

24

mental Conservation and such other sections and enacting
provisions of the “Solid Waste Management Act of 1988”
(L.1988, c.70; 6 NYCRR Part 360). But how can the
defendants overcome * the properly issued permit of the
DEC for the operation of a solid waste transfer station
at the TOWN’s former landfill site? *”

11. The genesis of the TOWN’s transfer station can be
traced to the TOWN’s sanitary landfill which facility was
in operation on August 28, 1977,° the effective date of
Part 360 of 6 NYCRR. Pursuant to that statute, the
TOWN was required to submit an application for a per-
mit to operate an existing solid waste management facility
within six (6) months of the effective date of Part 360.
Such application was submitted and re-submitted and uiti-
mately denied, which resulted in the entry of an “Order
on Consent” dated May 16, 1980. That order permitted
the operation of the TOWN’s sanitary landfill through
March 1, 1983 and imposed various conditions upon the
use of the facility.”

3 Presuming that the defendants are possessed of the requisite
standing to mount a SEQRA challenge in the first instance.

*DEC permit no. 3-3920-166/1-0 issued 12/31/90 makes the fol-
lowing reference to SEQRA: “STATE ENVIRONMENTAL
QUALITY REVIEW ACT under the State Environmental Quality
Review Act (SEQRA), the project associated with this Permit is
classified as an unlisted action with the Town Board, Town of
Clarkstown designated as the lead agency. It has been determined
that the project will not have a significant effect on the environ-
ment” (a copy of the permit under the Environmental Conservation
Law is annexed hereto and marked exhibit “I’’).

5 The landfill started as the town “dump” at or near the same
location in approximately 1950.

® One such condition required the TOWN to inform the DEC by
October 1, 1980, whether the TOWN would participate in the
“county-wide solid waste disposal system” (hereinafter known as
the “Regional Plan”), outlined in the Rockland County Solid Waste
Study. To date, Rockland County has yet to implement a “regional
plan”.

25

12. The Clarkstown Sanitary Landfill continued to
operate through 1983 and thereafter a “Modified Order
on Consent” was entered on August 6, 1984, under which
the sanitary landfill remained open. A “Final Order on
Consent” providing for the closure and remediation of the
sanitary landfill site was entered on August 7, 1989. The
stated goal of that order was “the development and imple-
mentation of a remedial program for the site, which pro-
gram shall include a remedial investigation/feasibility
study and the design and implementation of the selected
remedial! alternative.” (Copies of the orders are annexed
hereto as exhibit “J,” “K” and “L,” respectively).

13. Thus confronted with the closure of its sanitary
landfill, the TOWN was required to construct and oper-
ate a solid waste transfer station,’ ideally to be located
at the landfill site. A full Environmental Assessment
Form (EAF) was prepared on behalf of the TOWN by
its consultants Velzy Associates and, following public
hearing the Town Board adopted the resolutions declar-
ing a negative declaration with respect to the proposed
construction and operation of a solid waste transfer sta-
tion at the existing Clarkstown sanitary landfill site and
adopting the TOWN’s Local Law No. 9 of 1990 entitled
“Solid Waste Transportation and Disposal.” (Copies of
the EAF and “declaration of no impact” are annexed
hereto and made a part hereof and marked exhibits “M”
and “N,” respectively ).

14. The sanitary landfit-remained open through De-
cember 31, 1990 and the TOWN’s transfer station became
operational on January 2, 1991. The following is a brief
chronology of the various steps leading to the construc-
tion and implementation of the TOWN’s facility:

a. The Consent Order was signed by the TOWN on
June 30, 1989 and by the DEC on August 7,
1989;

™The DEC’s order dated August 7, 1989 specifically anticipated
the “completion of the proposed transfer station” ( XX, 2).

26

The TOWN had completed SEQRA proceedings
concerning the transfer station site on June 19,
1989;

On June 29, 1989, a letter was received from the
DEC, Region 3 requesting certain information
on the siting of the station;

On August 8, 1989, the Town Board commenced
the request for proposals procedure, pursuant to
General Municipal Law (GML) § 120-w for the
design, construction, operation and maintenance
of a solid waste transfer station to be located on
Route 303, West Nyack, New York, together
with transportation of the solid waste delivered
to the transfer station to an approved landfill for
final disposal;

Notices concerning the Request for Proposals
were published commencing August 11, 1989;

The 60-day public comment period on the Re-
quest for Proposals ended October 10, 1989, and
the subsequent ten-day period ended October 20,
1989, all as required by GML § 120-w;

The request for proposals was published com-
mencing October 25, 1989, -to be returnable No-
vember 24, 1989;

The transfer station site study prepared by Velzy-
Weston was completed November 10, 1989 and
forwarded to DEC for comments. This study
contained tests, borings, etc., done on the site
since June 29, 1989 as requested by the DEC;
Pre-proposal conferences were held with inter-
ested parties on Novembzer 2, 1989 and Novem-
ber 13, 1989;

On November 24, 1989, eleven (11) proposals
for the transfer station were received by the

TOWN;

72 aEEEEE—

ila

27

k. Interviews were held with ten (10) of the pro-
posers during subsequent weeks;

1. On December 29, 1989, the Town Board selected
Clarkstown Recycling Center, Inc., as the pro-
poser to whom the project would be awarded;

m. Inasmuch as Clarkstown Recycling Center, Inc.
was not the lowest proposer, a public hearing was
held on January 16, 1990 as required by GML
§ 120-w;

n. On January 2, 1990, the contract was awarded to
Clarkstown Recycling Center, Inc. and findings
were made by the Town Board as required by
Statute;

0. Meetings were held with the DEC on January 17,
1990 and January 25, 1990, at which time the
site study of Velzy-Weston was orally approved;

p. Final plans for station site were prepared and
submitted with formal applications on March 2,
1990 seeking a permit from the DEC;

q. The DEC issued a permit to Clarkstown Re-
cycling Center, Inc., on May 1, 1990, which
authorized Clarkstown Recycling Center, Inc. to
construct a solid waste transfer station at the
Clarkstown Sanitary Landfill site;

r. On May 18, 1990, the TOWN and Clarkstown
Recycling Center, Inc. entered into their agree-
ment providing for the construction and opera-
tion of a transfer station at the Clarkstown Sani-
tary Landfill and the transportation to and dis-
posal at permitted landfills outside of New York
State;

s. Thereafter, the TOWN commenced and com-

pleted the remediation of the transfer station site
of approximately 7.5 acres and construction of

28

the transfer station began in the fall of 1990 and
was completed by years end.

The TOWN looked very closely, indeed, at the potential
environmental effects of its transfer station prior to under-
taking the construction and operation of same.

15. In community recycling, Clarkstown stands among
the leaders of Rockland County’s municipalities. In 1988
the TOWN implemented its voluntary residential recycling
program which was supplanted in 1989 by the TOWN’s
mandatory recycling program.® In 1988 the TOWN re-
ceived permission of the state comptroller for the estab-
lishment of its refuse and garbage district and by contrac-
tual agreement with the Town of Orangetown dated Au-
gust 22, 1990,” all acceptable solid waste generated or
brought into those communities now flows through the

8 The TOWN’s voluntary recycling program predates the adoption
of the Solid Waste Management Act of 1988. The legislative find-
ings, L. 1988, c.70, § 1, underscored the need to reduce the genera-
tion of waste, encourage the recovery and reuse of secondary ma-
terials through recycling and related techniques, and foster con-
servation. Section 2 of L. 1988, ¢.70, provides: “The Legislature
finds and declares that the proper managemnt of solid waste is
necessary to protect public health and the environment. Toward
this end, it is necessary to reduce the generation of solid waste,
to accelerate the recovery and reuse of secondary materials within
the state, to encourage the conservation of resources ... and to
encourage a new ethic among New York’s citizens to conserve
and reuse, rather than discard, useful materials. A_ state-loca)
partnership is essential to achieving these ends’. On September
19, 1989, the TOWN adopted Local Law No. 5 of 1989, now Chapter
82 of the Clarkstown Code entitled, “Recycling”, wherein the TOWN
implemented a mandatory recycling program (see the affidavit of
Charles E. Holbrook, sworn to on March 18, 1991, submitted in
support of the TOWN’s application for a preliminary injunction).

®Clarkstown’s sanitary landfill had been an integral part of
neighboring Orangetown’s solid waste disposal system for many
years prior to closure (see “Order on Consent” dated May 16,
1980) ; logically, Orangetown elected to continue this relationship in
requiring that all acceptable solid waste generated within Orange-
town be transported and delivered to Clarkstown’s transfer station,

29

TOWN ’s transfer station for baling and loading for trans-
port to out-of-state burial sites. (Copies of Velzy Asso-
ciates’ “Plan and Report for the Establishment of the
Town’s Garbage and Refuse District” and the Depart-
ment of Audit & Control’s permit dated August 26, 1988
are annexed hereto as exhibits ““O”’ and “P”, respectively).

16. The TOWN also maintains two (2) composting
sites where leaves and grass clippings are accepted for
compost to eventually be returned to the soil as mulch
and organic fertilizer.

17. Clearly, any argument to the effect that the TOWN
neglected to take the requisite “hard look” at the environ-
mental factors relating to the construction and mainte-
nance of its solid waste transfer station and the con-
comitant transition of its solid waste management facility
from a sanitary landfill to a transfer station, is erroneous.

18. In the adoption of its local law regulating the dis-
posal of acceptable waste at the TOWN’s transfer sta-
tion, the Town Board specifically considered the facility’s
receipt of a permit from DEC and the procedures attend-
ant to the issuance of such permit and that the action
was considered to be an “unlisted action without any sig-
nificant impact upon the environment” obviating any fur-
ther processing pursuant to the State Environmental
Quality Review Act (a copy of the resolution setting a
public hearing pursuant to Section 20 of the Municipal
Home Rule Law, dated December 18, 1990, is annexed
hereto and marked exhibit “Q’’).

19. While it is beyond dispute that legislative actions
are within the purview of SEQRA (Niagara Recycling,
Inc. v. Town Bd. of Niagara, 83 AD2d 335, 443 NYS2d
951, 954), it is respectfully submitted that the Town
Board’s determination of non-significance in its adoption
of Local Law No. 9 of 1990 entitled “Solid Waste Trans-
portation and Disposal”, should not be set aside. There
is nothing in this record to suggest that the TOWN did
not give the required “hard look” or that a longer or

i

30

more detailed study of the proposed local law was in any
way warranted (Niagara Recycling, Inc. v. Town Bd. of
Niagara, supra, at 955). The adoption of Locai Law
No. 9 of 1990 cannot be viewed as an isolated action by
the TOWN as it constitutes just one element of the
TOWN ’s integrated transition of its solid waste manage-
ment facility from landfill to transfer station (Vinnie
Montes Waste System, Inc. v. Town of Oyster Bay, |A.T.
9th J.D.], 1991 WL 30383).

20. Deponent must again stress that the defendants
lack standing to challenge the adequacy of the TOWN’s
review of the entire project and that, in any event, the
Court need look no further than the defendants’ obvious
(if not, in fact, admitted) violation of Chapter 106 of the
Clarkstown Code prohibiting defendants’ operation of a
transfer station anywhere within the TOWN.

21. Neither the TOWN’s zoning ordinance (City of
Columbia v. Omni Outdoor Advertising-Co., Inc., ———
S.Ct. , 1991 WL 41544 [April 1, 1991];), nor
Local Law No. 9 of 1990 (Town of Hallie v. City of
Eau Claire, 105 S.Ct. 1713, 471 U.S. 34, 85 L.Ed.2d 24
[1985]) run afoul of the anti-trust laws."

22. As regards defendants’ “second affirmative de-
fense” averring the facial invalidity of Local Law No. 9
of 1990 and “other chapters of the Clarkstown Town
Code’, deponent can only assume that defendants allude
to Article I, § 8 of the Constitution of the United States
(the Commerce Clause). The TOWN’s zoning ordinance
enjoys a strong presumption of constitutionality (de St.
Aubin v. Flacke, 68 NY2d 66, 76, 505 NYS2d 859, 496
NE2d 879; Moran v. Village of Philmont, 147 AD2d
230, 542 NYS2d 873, 875) and does not impose an
undue burden upon interstate commerce (Town of La-
Grange v. Giovenetti Enterprises, 123 AD2d 688, 507
NYS2d 54, 55; Monroe-Livingston v. Town of Cale-

10 Presumably, this is what the defendants are asserting by their
“first affirmative defense”,

31

donia, 51 NY2d 687, 435 NYS2d 966, 968; Al Turi Land-
fill, Inc. v. Town of Goshen, 556 F Supp 231, 238). Local
Law No. 9 of 1990 regulates evenhandedly, without regard
to origin, in its treatment of acceptable solid waste. In
its application it does not look in a discriminatory or
disparate fashion at acceptable solid waste generated
within the territorial limits of the TOWN as opposed to
acceptable solid waste generated or collected outside the
territorial limits of the TOWN or, for that matter, outside
of the State. Subdivision “C” of Section 3 requires the
transportation and delivery of all acceptable waste gen-
erated within the TOWN to the TOWN’s transfer station;
Subdivision “A” of Section 5 calls for the disposal of
acceptable waste generated or collected outside of the
territorial limits of the TOWN at a “Town operated
facility”, i.e., the TOWN’s transfer station." There can

11 Subdivisions “C” and “D” of §3 of Local Law No. 9 of 1990
entitled, “Collection and Disposal of Acceptable Waste”, state:

“C. All acceptable waste generated within the territorial limits
of the Town of Clarkstown is to be transported and delivered to
the Town of Clarkstown solid waste facility located at Route 303,
West Nyack, New York or to such other disposal or recycling facili-
ties operated by the Town of Clarkstown, or to recycling centers
established by special permit pursuant to Chapter 106 of the Clarks-
town Town Code, except for recyclable materials which are sepa-
rated from solid waste at the point or origin or generation of such
solid waste, which separated recyclable materials may be trans-
ported and delivered to facilities within the Town as aforesaid or
to sites outside the Town. As to acceptable waste brought to said
recycling facilities, the unrecycled residue shall be disposed of at
a solid waste facility operated by the Town of Clarkstown.

D. It shall be unlawful to dispose of any acceptable waste gen-
erated or collected within the Town at any location other than the
facilities or sites set forth in Paragraph “C” above’.

Subdivision “A” of § 5 of Local Law No. 9 of 1990, states:

“A. It shall be unlawful, within the Town, to dispose of or at-
tempt to dispose of acceptable or unacceptable waste of any kind
generated or collected outside the territorial limits of the Town of
Clarkstown, except for acceptable waste disposed of at a Town

32

be, therefore, no claim that the law is invalid on its face
(Niagara Recycling, Inc. v. Town Bd. of Niagara, 83
AD2d 316. 443 NYS2d 939, 949, 950; Al Turi Landfill,
Inc. v. Town of Goshen, supra, at 238; Monroe-Livingston
v. Town of Caledonia, supra, at 968).

23. Local Law No. 9 does not conflict with the provi-
sions of ECL Article 27 nor has the State preempted the
regulation of solid waste management. Indeed, the ECL
has expressly included local government in the regulation
of problems endemic to waste management (ECL § 27-
0711; see Jancyn Mfg. Corp. v. Suffolk County, 71
NY2d 98, 524 NYS2d 8, 10-12: Al Turi Landfill, Inc. v.
Town of Goshen, supra, p.239; Monroe-Livingston v.
Town of Caledonia, supra, at 968).

24. The TOWN unquestionably has the power to regu-
late the operation and location of transfer stations located
within its territorial jurisdiction (Town of Islip v. Zalak,
[A.D. 2 Dept.], 1991 WL 18606) and in today’s society
it can hardly be doubted that municipalities may regulate
the disposal of refuse materials (Town of Islip v. Zalak,
supra). The enactment of the applicable laws and ordi-
nances (here questioned by the defendants) represents a
reasonable exercise of the TOWN’s authority to protect
the health, safety and well-being of its citizens and the
environment through the exercise of its police power (Al
Turi Landfill, Inc. v. Town of Goshen, 556 F Supp 231,
239: Moran v. Village of Philmont, 542 NYS2d 873,
875, citing, Matter of Town of Islip v. Caviglia, 73 NY2d
544, 550-51, 542 NYS2d 139, 540 NE2d 215; Town of
LaGrange v. Giovenetti Enters., 123 AD2d 688, 689,
507 NYS2d 54).

operated facility, pursuant to agreement with the Town of Clarks-
town and recyclables, as defined in Chapter 82 of the Clarkstown
Town Code, brought to a recycling center established by special
permit pursuant to Chapter 106 of the Clarkstown Town Code”,

33

25. In light of the fact that the defendants are, daily,
violating the ordinances and laws of the Town of Clarks-
town, deponent respectfully requests an order granting
summary judgment insofar as the TOWN requests a
permanent injunction and directing that the defendants
immediately cease and desist such violations and specif-
ically prohibiting the defendants operation of a transfer
station at their premises at 183 Western Highway, West
Nyack, New York and the continued circumvention of
the TOWN’s transfer station facility.

WHEREFORE, deponent respectfully requests an or-
der of this Court granting summary judgement perma-
nently enjoining and restraining the defendants from
maintaining an illegal transfer station in violation of Chap-
ter 106 of the Clarkstown Code and the illegal transporta-
tion and disposal of solid waste generated within and
without the territorial limits of the Town of Clarkstown
in accordance with Local Law No. 9 of 1990 and direct-
ing that defendants immediately cease all illegal business
operations at 183 Western Highway, West Nyack, New
York or, in the alternative, granting plaintiff's application
for a preliminary injunction, and for such other and fur-
ther relief as to this Court may seem just and proper.

s’ Murray N. Jacobson
Murray N. JACOBSON

| Notary Omitted in Printing]

34

Exhibit E to Affidavits Submitted in Support of Plaintiff’s
Application—Minutes of Public Hearing [142-159]

TOWN OF CLARKSTOWN
PUBLIC HEARING

Town Hall 11 14 89 10:00 P.M.

Present: Supervisor Holbrook
Council Members Carey, Kunis, Maloney and
Smith
Murray N. Jacobson, Town Attorney
Patricia Sheridan, Town Clerk

RE: SPECIAL PERMIT TO OPERATE RECY-
CLING FACILITY MAP 80, BLOCK A, LOT
1S (C& A CARBONE)

On motion of Councilman Carey, seconded by Council-
man Maloney and unanimously adopted, the Public Hear-
ing was declared open. Town Clerk read notice calling
Public Hearing and testified as to proper posting and
publication.

Town Attorney read the following recommendations of
the Clarkstown Planning Board:

|) Provide gratuitous widening of Western High-
way, 30 feet from the center line of the road, and
provide deed, title report and map with metes and
bounds description for T.A. review and approval.

2) Subject to all requirements of Dept. of E.C. and
subject to all requirements of the Rockland County
Highway Department, since Wesiern Highway is a
County road.

Town Attorney said the DEC reported no environ
mental impact.

The County Planning Board approved subject to con-
ditions:

35

1. The recommendations of the Rockland County
Highway Department letter of July 5, 1989.

2. The recommendations of the Soil and Water Con-
servation District letter of June 30, 1989.

3. Obaining all required permits from the Rockland
County Drainage Agency.

4. Obtaining all required permits from the Rock-
land County Health Department.

5. Guarantee that noise and odors do not adversely
affect the nearby residential areas.

6. A traffic study be done to determine the volume
and flow of traffic coming from this site. The study
must take into consideration that there is a ban on
truck traffic going into Orangetown

Town Attorney read recommendations of the Rockland
County Highway Department:

|. Provide adequate means of preventing dirt, dust
and mud from being tracked onto Western Highway
by vehicles leaving the site.

2. As the plans are developed, they are provided to
this Department for review and comment.

3. A permit from this Department is acquired by
the owners prior to the start of any construction on
the site.

Town Attorney read recommendation of Rockland
County Drainage Agency:

The above referenced parcel is within the 100
L.F. of 100 year flood plain of the Hackensack
River. Therefore a permit from this agency is
required.

Town Attorney read recommendations of the Rock-
land County Soil & Water Conservations District Board:

36

The dominate soil on the site is Riverhead, a very
deep well drained sandy loam. Because this soil 1s
highly permeable, the town should satisfy itself that
materials stored on the site are not allowed to leach
into the soil. This soil should be considered to be a
poor filter so the potential for ground water con-
tamination has to be addressed in the planning and
design for this proposed site.

Town Attorney read comments from the Town Depart-
ment of Environmental Conservation:

|. The entranceway to the site and the exitway from
the scale area should be paved to prevent dust com-
ing onto Western Highway.

2. If the berm along Western Highway is to remain
permanent, we recommend planting evergreens.

3. The proposed retaining wall should be designed,
inspected during construction and certified that it
has been constructed according to the design by the
registered N.Y.S. Professional Engineer.

Supervisor said the applicant will make a presentation.
The Board members can ask questions of the applicant.
Then any and all questions and comments from the audi-
ence will be heard.

Appearance: Kenneth Resnick, Esq.
Granik, Garson, et al
representing C & A Carbone

Mr. Resnick said the Board has in front of it the pett-
tion. the recommendations of the Planning Board and the
various boards and agencies of the county. He said he
wanted to address some of the immediate concerns. He
said his clients inicntion as soon as the permit is granted,
if the Board is so inclined, to immediately file with the
Planning Board an application to totally enclose the facil
ity so that it will at all times be free from any noise,
dust and any odor. There will be no possibility of any

37

leaching or leachate simply because it will be all concrete
floor, The present application is based upon the map as
it is submitted in front of you but we have every hope
and intention to developing a facility here for recycling in
the method and manner which we are now utilizing but
to be wholly enclosed. He said other than that he would
rest upon the record that has been previously submitted
to the Board.

Supervisor asked if the Board members had any ques-
tions.

Councilman Kunis asked how does totally enclosing
stop odors? Mr. Resnick said it is an interesting phe-
nomena that when you take material and deodorize it you
stop the odor and if you keep it contained and provide
deodorizers there is no smell. He said he could invite the
Board to a couple of places that he is aware of that use
those materials where it is effective. One is in Hillsdale
and one is in Ramapo.

Supervisor said in regard to this facility you are talking
about a recycling facility. Mr. Resnick said this is only
recycling. This is not a transfer station. It is not per-
mitted by the zoning law and it is not his client’s inten-
tion to want a transfer station. Councilman Kunis said
the property currently holds a permit for a transfer sta-
tion from the State Department of Environmental Con-
trol, is that correct? Mr. Resnick said that was correct.
He said he thinks you will find in that connection that
that is the type of permit that comes out of Section 306
under the rules. That is essentially the permit.

Councilwoman Smith said are you saying that you
have to have that permit to have a recycling permit?
Mr. Resnick said no he is not but that is the permit that
the DEC issued. He said his client applied for that back
in 1987 but it wasn’t issued until 1988. The limitations
that existed between the zoning law and the application
at the time were different. They were both the same.

38

While it talks about a transfer permit and all of the con-
ditions under a transfer station would still be applicable—
no odor, leachate, no effluent, none of that kind of stuff.
The site itself is only for a recycling center and that is
the methodology of the Department of Environmental
Conservation.

Councilman Kunis asked what is the possibility of en-
tering that site from Gast to west and not using Western
Highway? Mr. Resnick said at this point it has not es-
caped our attention. He said we know who the adjoining
owner is—Mr. Magee. He said that his client has effected
conversations with him. They have gone nowhere at this
point. There is a very long stretch of road that would
have to be built—3,000+ feet and not an inexpensive
road. We have not done any soil tests or anything like
that but that is not liable to be compacted soil. It is
liable to be mud and that would make it a very expensive
road as well. There may be other alternatives rather than
a straight line. He said he is not in a position today to
represent to you anything with respect to the future in
that other than it has not been lost upon his client and
that there are and hopefully will be conversations that
will go on.

Supervisor said in regard to the facility itself the con-
cern about the traffic, aside from the odors, etc. has to be
addressed. Regardless of whether this was built there or
not the Board is concerned about that because Clarks-
town is impacted by a ban and everything e-se. We have
to attempt, between the Towns of Orangetown and
Clarkstown, to resolve that problem with the truck traffic
regardless of what is here. Mr. Resnick said on Western
Highway, Route 303 and this whole package we may be
able to facilitate that. He said he would point out one
advantage that this site does have it is his guess that the
availability of trucks to remove garbage from municipali-
ties to distant landfill sites is going to be scarcer and more
scarce. One of the current methods which is used now

and it is nationwide is that truckers as almost a round

39
robbin—they go from one stop to another stop to another
Stop and somewhere in between those several stops, some
of which may carry things we don’t want to be in a truck
that also carries garbage, to take material to landfill sites.

Mr. Resnick stated that we have a rail siding on that
site. We believe that within three years costs of rail
transportation vis a vis truck transportation will make rail
competitive. Not because rail is going to get cheaper but
because trucking is just going to get that much more
expensive. That would eliminate probably close to a third
of the truck motions that come about during the course
of a day because that affords us an ability to transport
substantial quantities by rail.

Councilwoman Smith said we must be made fully
aware of whatever alternative plans you may have for
traffic, other than Western Highway. Mr. Resnick said
right now we have no direct access. We are limiting some
of our truck movements by the sufferance of Mr. Magee.
He allows us to utilize some of his property at different
times and in different ways and allows us to go from
Route 303 and limit our use on Western Highway. He
said we have every intention of continuing but right now
that is at the sufferance of Mr. Magee. It is not by con-
tract and he said it is his hope that within the next
Short period of time perhaps that can be formalized but
he cannot be put into a position to guarantee something
like that. It is simply not something that he could
guarantee.

Supervisor asked if there were any other questions from
the Board. There were none. Supervisor asked if any
member of the public wished to ask a question or make
a comment?

Appearance: Mr. Stanley Hirsch
Western Highway
West Nyack, New York

40

Mr. Hirsch said he was in possession of a letter from
Mr. Resnick to Mr. Bollman which say: “recognizing the
circumstances regarding the landfill, as newspapers have
reported it my client is in a position to offer the proposed
facility as a transfer station to the Town.” He asked Mr.
Resnick is he wrote that letter and Mr. Resnick said
absolutely.

Mr. Hirsch said Carbone has in his possession a permit
to operate as a transfer station. He was surprised that
Mr. Resnick did not try to deny that. He said he wanted
to reiterate some of the points that the Town Attorney
made before. He has a copy from the Rockland County
Soil and Water Conservation District Board saying “There
is a potential for groundwater contamination.” They also
require a traffic study to see the volume and flow, noise
and odors—this is what you said Mr. Jacobson. That
study has not been done, has it? Mr. Jacobson said he
was not aware of it. Supervisor said it has not been done.

Supervisor said before any decision would be made a
traffic study would have to be done. These are condi-
tions. Mr. Hirsch said good, he wanted to understand
that. He said discussion was had regarding tremendous
truck traffic that we have on Western Highway so he
knew that the study would not change anybody’s mind on
that. We have a lot of 18 wheelers going down Western
Highway which is a residential area. We have the Car-
bone trucks handling recycling on Western Highway.
They are very noisy trucks. He asked Supervisor Hol-
brook if the Journal News had lied the other day when it
said that he (Supv. Holbrook) was offering Nyack the
use of the Carbone facility for recycling? Supervisor said
he did not see that. Mr. Hirsh asked the Supervisor if he
had said that. Supervisor said part of the Village of
Nyack is in the Town of Clarkstown so they would be
part of our recycling and part is in Orangetown so they
are part of both towns. Mr. Hirsch said Nyack is not
currently using the Carbone facility so therefore we would

41

have an increase in garbage. Supervisor stated that if the
Village of Nyack wanted to come with Clarkstown in
terms of getting rid of its recyclables, since he favored
recycling, he would not be opposed to that. He said he
could not say what was quoted in the newspaper. But he
definitely would say yes to the Village of Nyack if they
wanted to come with Clarkstown. Mr. Hirsch said but
you just said there is a tremendous amount of truck
traffic on Western Highway. Wouldn’t this increase it?
Supervisor said he did not know if it would increase it
that much. Supervisor said the recycling trucks which
pick up in Orangetown and Clarkstown are similar. The
Village of Nyack has a problem in how to go about
enhancing recycling for pickup. He said if they wanted
to come along with the Town of Clarkstown and enhance
their recycling he would be in favor of that. We would
probably use the same recycling trucks that we are using
in Clarkstown because the agencies are the same.

Mr. Hirsch said obviously there would be an increase
in truck traffic if they are handling another villages re-
cyclables. Supervisor said obviously there would be some.
Mr. Hirsch said he was working out in front of his house
the other day and Carbone’s trucks were going by every
five minutes. Supervisor said the Carter’s Association has
the recycling trucks that pick up the recyclables, not the
Carbone trucks.

Mr. Hirsch said he wanted to reiterate what was stated
before. That the Carbone facility is within 100 feet of
the Hackensack Creek and he said he believed across the
street in the swamp the water there is used by Spring
Valley Water Company and we have had trouble in that
area before, especially on Pine View with all of the wells
being contaminated.

Mr. Hirsch said if you give this permit we are going to
have an increase in traffic, an increase in noise pollution,
we'll probably have an increase in water pollution and
all of this in a residential area. He said when he attended

hacen teeter een

42

a workshop several weeks ago a gentleman offered to
have a facility in the Snake Hill Road area which is not
residential, where they would be be able to use Route 303
and it wouldn’t disrupt and pollute a residential area.
He said he would like a recycling center and put in a
transfer station at a later time you said we only want to
talk about recycling at this point. Mr. Hirsch said it is
fairly obvious from what is coming out here that re-
cycling will lead to a transfer station. Nobody is going
into the recycling business because there is no money in
it. Supervisor said the only transfer station we are going
to construct, and our zoning does not permit it in any
zone, is the one that will be constructed at the landfill
site. When we had the hearing and established the defini-
tions and then later established the zones, the Town Board
made a conscious decision not to include transfer station
in any of the zones. That was done consciously. It was
considered but it was also then considered to take that
out.

Mr. Hirsh said he heard that but he also has the permit
from Carbone to operate a transfer station. Supervisor
said that was from the New York State Department of
Environmental Conservation but you have to remember
that at the time that was issued there was no such provi-
sion for transfer stations in the Town of Clarkstown. By
creating definitions of transfer stations and then specif-
ically not applying to any of the zones, now our zoning
ordinance does deal with that particular issue. It was
not dealt with at all in our zoning up to that point.

Mr. Hirsch asked the Supervisor to tell the good peo-
ple of West Nyack why you are so in favor of having a
recycling facility on Western Highway and still opposed
to have it on Snakehill Road. Supervisor said he is in
favor of recycling. Right now we have no place in Rock-
land County. He is in favor of taking recyclables so
that they can be removed and we can expand our re-
cycling for the benefit of not only Clarkstown but all
Rockland County residents. We need a place to bring it.

_ EEEEEEOEEEOEE—EEE—————

43

This is a site we are considering. It is not necessarily the
only site. The question of traffic which we have raised
previous to this is one that he is concerned about. He
said he did not think this Board is prepared to make a
decision in regard to that. There are also other factors
too. We are not prepared to make a decision favorable
to this until such time as the traffic situation is resolved
and that means trying to get the truck traffic off Western
Highway. He stated that he has been saying that for
some time and he would reiterate it now. It is a concern
regardless of what is constructed at this particular site.
If it was a row of stores, we would be talking about the
same type of traffic and it has to be worked out between
the Towns of Orangetown and Clarkstown.

Mr. Hirsch said you still have not answered my ques-
tion and he was getting a little tired of asking the same
question over and over and having you dance around it.
Supervisor said he is not dancing around anything. Super-
visor said you are assuming something. He said he favors
recycling. If he could eiiminate the truck traffic on West-
ern Highway he would be in favor of having a recycling
place where we could take Clarkstown’s recyclables. If
this happens to be a place, he has to consider it. It is not
necessarily the only place to be considered.

Appearance: Ms. Florence Zuvich
Blauvelt, New York

Ms. Zuvich asked approximately how big Clarkstown
is? Supervisor said it is 42 square miles and 82,000 peo-
ple. She said out of 42 square miles you have 8 toxic sites
in a radius of maybe 3 miles. She asked why out of 42
miles would you even consider adding to the problem
we've got. She said you keep trying to say Carbone is
only recycling and you keep saying that your transfer
Station is going to be at the Landfill. Supervisor said that
is correct. Ms. Zuvich said she wanted to clarify what
she thinks,

44

Ms. Zuvich said you have stated that they will become
probably County facilities eventually. Supervisor said that
is correct. Ms. Zuvich said that Mr. Resnick also said
that eventually railing it out will be cheaper than truck-
ing it out. Hence, maybe the meeting with the people in
Pennsylvania. Ms. Zuvich said if you look at the Car-
bone site and she did not know how many acres it was
but it is not really that large, it cannot possible facilitate
a County facility. The site for the so-called transfer sta-
tion is also not big enough to hold a County facility. You
will then have to graduate toward the middle of the map.
We also know who owns the property in the middle of
that map. The Magee Brothers.

Ms. Zuvich said if you look at the map the rail is
directly behind Carbone and not by the proposed transfer
Station so if you are going to put the transfer station on
Route 303 by the Landfill you will still have to truck it
or move it in some way to the rail site which has got to
be maybe 100 feet or so from Western Highway. Super-
visor said our intention from the Town’s point of view
with regard to the transfer station on Route 303, is to
bring the garbage, that is not recycled, to the site and
then transport it by truck, not by rail, to a permitted
facility which would probably be outside of New York
State. This could be Pennsylvania or even Ohio. Ms.
Zuvich asked is the rail supposed to be just for recyclables?
Supervisor said their specific site was for recyclables. The
Town of Clarkstown is not involved in the rail site. Ms.
Zuvich said you have listened to that option of railing it.
Supervisor said we have but the problem would be cross-
ing the Landfill and the wetlands with a rzil spur. He
said we would not really be able to do that. Ms. Zuvich
said that was her whole point. You would not be really
connecting it. That transfer station would have to grow
in order to accommodate a County facility. Supervisor
said we are not looking to accommodate the County facil-
ity. Ms. Zuvich said but you will, eventually.

45

Supervisor said Orangetown and Clarkstown have been
basically wedded together with regard to garbage for a
long time, with the Landfill and ultimate with this station.
What we are looking to do is to provide a facility at the
location of the Landfill which would accommodate both
the Towns of Orangetown and Clarkstown at that site.
Ms. Zuvich said but did you not say that eventually you
would go with the County facility? Supervisor said abso-
lutely and what he envisions the County plan to be is
that probably somewhere down the line in the Town of
Ramapo there would probably be using their baling sta-
tion or they would make it into a transfer station which
would be another location for Ramapo and probably
maybe even Haverstraw to use it as a site if they in fact
have to truck garbage out of New York state. Supervisor
stated that the Town Board here is not looking to make
the facility and we have not applied for it in those terms.
We are only applying for the Towns of Orangetown and
Clarkstown and there is no intention to do that. Ms.
Zuvich said she went to the County meeting on solid
waste and the main applicant for the center was Carbone
and no other was mentioned. She said also as we know
one way of getting around SEQRA is saying that you
have an existing facility. So you will have an existing
facility there so that when the County wants to come in
and expand there is little doubt that DEC will accommo-
date. Supervisor said one other point—add to that—
going down the road and we did ask the question of the
DEC at the Landfill site in West Nyack but we were talk-
ing about the transfer station. We did raise the possibil-
ity of that location having a recycling facility adjacent to
the transfer station but in trying to move the application
along they told us not to apply for that at that time.
Ultimately, the Town of Clarkstown might decide that
we want a recycling facility right at the Landfill site for
Clarkstown’s recyclables. The DEC recommended at the
time we talked to them against making that application
simultaneously with the one for the transfer station.

46

Ms. Zuvich said she understood that but also she said
you just said about moving it to the Landfill site. She
said she sincerely doubted that if Carbone is putting in
that amount of money to start it you are not about to
pull it away from them. Supervisor said we have said
even over at the County, that when the County does come
up with their plans ultimately for whatever they are going
to do with solid waste which is not really formulated,
and may never be formulated in this decade, the Town of
Clarkstown is prepared to cooperate with the County of
Rockland in whatever endeavors they do but that is not
for the foreseeable future. Essentially we are going to
construct our transfer station and maybe even try to
make a recycling thing there ultimately at that location.
Ms. Zuvich said the DEC permit expires in 1992 which
is when the County facility is supposed to go on line.
Supervisor asked what County facility would that be?
Ms. Zuvich said the County’s target date is 1992 and it
seems curious to her that while you advocate having the
County come in that Carbone’s DEC permit would be
expiring just at that time.

Appearance: Mr. Peter Beaton
Western Highway
West Nyack, New York

He said we have a Supervisor who is highly interested
in recycling and Carbone wants to put a recycling plant
on Western Highway. It follows that it is logical that we
will increase dramatically, again and again, the amount of
recyclables that are brought along Western Highway. Is
that true?) Mr. Resnick said he supposed you could say
that. Mr. Beaton asked Mr. Resnick if it was not true
that his plan is for the trucking out of stuff that has
already been trucked over Western Highway and the rail-
way has little impact on the people who live on Western
Highway and their children? Mr. Beaton asked who is
pulling the wool over whose eyes here with this recycling
plant. If they get this foot in the door and we will have

47

the transfer station just as we have the stinking stench
tonight on the dump that is supposed to be covered. Go
by it, tell me how you are going to take care of our
problems. The area stinks every day.

Supervisor said with the approval of the Town Board
he has signed a Consent Order to close the Clarkstown
Landfill and we will be undertaking a rather expensive
and lengthy remediation of that site. We are not oblivi-
ous to the environmental problems that the Landfill has
caused over the years. He said we must consider that the
Town Board has taken this measure and this Landfill site
will be remediated and there will be relief. He said he
was saying this in all sincerity. It is not going to happen
ten years from now. It is going to happen starting in
1990. In terms of odors and whatever problems are there
we will have to see what has been dumped there over
the course of fifty years, etc., that has to be remediated.
Knowing where you live and knowing that you have lived
with this for a long period of time, the remediation of the
Landfill site will, in the long run and in the immediate
run, improve the situation there. He said we have done
that. Mr. Beaton said you have promised to do it.
Supervisor said we have done it. He said he is not saying
there isn’t odor from the Landfill tonight. But he is say-
ing that with the remediation of the site in 1990 the
conditions to which you are referring will be improved.
We have consciously attempted to do that. Mr. Beaton
said the DEC did that for us. Supervisor said instead of
fighting them in the courts and delaying it ad infinitum
the Town Board did not choose that option. We chose
the option of approving a Consent Order and signing it
so that the Town of Clarkstown would be eligible to be
reimbursed for the cleanup of that site and it would hap-
pen immediately, not years down the road. Supervisor
said he wanted to make that comment. It is not as if we
are saying we don’t care what happens there. We do.

Mr. Beaton asked Mr. Jacobson, Town Attorney, where
the 30 foot widening on Western Highway was supposed

————

48

to take place? Is it the entire length of it or just in front
of Carbone? Town Attorney said this is in the recom-
mendations of the Clarkstown Planning Board and he
would assume it is only for a short distance in front of
the Carbone property. He did not think they are talking
about widening the whole of Western Highway.

Appearance: Mr. John Cuff
Pheasant Drive
West Nyack, New York

Mr. Cuff said we are light years ahead of the program.
He asked what it costs his household per week to get rid
of newspapers right now? Supervisor said he could not
say offhand what it costs but that we do get $10.00 a ton
for the newspapers. When the Landfill closes and we
have to truck that to some location for about $80.00 a
ton every ton of recycling that we do or we take out of
the waste stream would save the taxpayers of Clarkstown
$80.00. Mr. Cuff said that is very easy to say but he
said he thinks it is costing him, homeowner, probably a
couple of dollars a week to get rid of ten pounds of news-
papers. So if we were to figure that out at $2.00 for ten
pounds a hundred pounds is going to cost me maybe
$10.00 or $15.00. If you get up to a ton it’s going to
cost him well over $100.00 which is more than the cost
of virgin material to make newspapers. Mr. Cuff said he
takes what is going on right now as a big psych job. We
are paying a fortune to get rid of newspapers that there
is no market for anywhere in this country. It is costing
him and every homeowner to go along with this recycling.
kick and we are paying more to get rid of it than the
market price is if there was somebody to buy it. Un-
fortunately, there is very little market to buy newspaper
print. It has to be dry, it has to be bundled and it has
to be weighed. What we have created is a beautiful thing.
Oh! We're recycling. We're environmentalists. We're
concerned. But we are paying ten times what it would
cost us if we just put it in our garbage can every day.

49

Now, we are on a clear glass kick and he did not know
where the market is for clear glass. He said he did not
know what we get a ton. It costs money for them-tosstop
at his door every Tuesday and pick up the clear glass.
He said he knows it costs a lot of money to come and
pick up the newspapers every week. Then it is all taken
off. Do we know where this stuff is going? You were
always concerned about where our garbage is going.
Where is our newspapers going? Supervisor asked Mr.
Bollman, Director of Environmental Control to tell Mr.
Cuff where the newspapers were going. Mr. Bollman said
newspaper is given to Garden State Paper Products. We
deposit it at the Thruway Recycling Center which is part
of Garden State Paper. Mr. Cuff said and we are being
paid for that newspaper. Mr. Bollman said that is cor-
rect. Mr. Cuff asked what Mr. Bollman would say we
are making per ton on newspaper right now, taking labor,
transportation costs, costs of the truck and everything
else into effect and the cost to the homeowner, how much
are we making per ton on newspaper? Mr. Bollman said
he did not have those figures but he wanted to address
Mr. Cuffs other question. It might be more costly than
to make virgin paper but if we are going to pay, say
$100.00 per ton, to get rid of garbage—-newspaper being
part of that—and your newspaper can be collected for
$70.00 per ton and can pay $20.00 per ton for Garden
State to taken it away from me because I might have to
pay them soon to take it. That is still $90.00 versus
$100.00 and he would have to argue with Mr. Cuff it’s
better for the taxpayer to get rid of that paper at $90.00
a ton than it would be to throw it into the garbage and
transfer it to Ohio at $100.00 per ton.

Mr. Cuff said talk is in New York City they are going
to start mandatory recycling of newspaper out of New
York City. Do you think that might have a slight impact
on the newsprint market—waste print. Supervisor said
absolutely. Mr. Cuff said if there is any kind of success
with the recycling of newsprint out of New York City

nested ceemeenntintes orien

50

we are going to be paying a fortune to get rid of news-
paper. Mr. Cuff said no one is more concerned about
the environment than he is. He was born and raised here.
Mr. Cuff said we put the cart in front of the horse. We
are very chic by recycling but we are being conned all
the way. We are paying an exhorbitant price to get rid
of it now and if these other townships and municipalities
and if New York City climbs on the bandwagon and gets
into recvcling it’s going to wind up costing us three times
as much to get rid of newspapers as it is if we would just
throw the darn things into an incinerator or mass burn
facility and get rid of them. Mr. Cuff said he remem-
bered back to 1946 when the mill in Piermont was run-
ning twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week for the
war effort. Right where Manley Chevrolet sits right now
was a big tin storage shed where all the newspaper came
in for the war effort and was transferred down to Pier-
mont to be recycled in the mill. All of sudden the war
was over. There was no market whatsoever for new-
spring. Do you know where it all wound up? Right over
where we have our Landfill right now. That’s that base
coat of our Landfill because there was no market for it
in 1946. If there is ever a concerted recycling effort by
municipalities like New York City or Yonkers, etc. we
are going to be paying ten times as much as we are pay-
ing right now to get rid of newspapers. Leaves—that’s a
whole other chapter. These people probably don’t even
know it but we are importing leaves from New Jersey
now into West Nyack because we are going to set up
some kind of a composing facility by importing leaves
from New Jersey into West Nyack.

Supervisor said in regard to recycling, the State of New
York, Department of Environmental Conservation, has
required all municipalities in New York State to recycle.
We have a mandatory recycling law in the Town of
Clarkstown. When our Landfill closes we would then
have to truck, if we did not recycle which we are doing
now, 100% of our solid waste out of state which would

5]

jack up the cost of garbage disposal tremendously. Re-
cycling has to be done and it must be done. He did not
say that this is the site it must be done at but regardless
of that it must be done. The Town of Clarkstown will do
it. Town of Orangetown is doing it and our programs are
very similar. It has to be enhanced because when our
Landfill closes Orangetown’s source of getting rid of their
garbage also goes away. They must come up with an
alternate. We must recycle regardless of what happens
with the Carbone Recycling Facility.

Mr. Cuff said he envisions the day when Ohio and
Pennsylvania and Iowa and all these other states are
going to turn around to the State of New York and say
solve your own problems. Supervisor said he agrees with
him. Mr. Cuff said we should not be going too deep into
this stuff. He said he does not think Albany has all the
answers cither. They've never had the answers on any-
thing else so he did not know where they would have the
answers on recycling.

Supervisor said we must recycle.

Appearance: Wayne Gavioli, Esq.
representing the Blauvelt
Association residents from
Orangetown

Mr. Gavioli said they have long advocated a recycling
program and when many officials could only think of in-
cinerators and placing that incinerator in West Nyack, we
joined with our brothers and sisters in West Nyack and
successfully opposed that plant. When others were think-
ing about other sites for incineration we were in Albany
lobbying for DEC regulations that would preserve the en-
vironment for all people in the County of Rockland and
the State of New York. He said their record of advocat-
ing and promoting recycling is a long one, one that we
took long before most of the elected leaders here in the
County. Even today we are consulted by many of the

a

52

people at the County level concerning recycling. He said
they oppose the application for the special permit tonight
because they have always felt that you do not solve one
problem by creating others. He said they see the very
real need for a recycling center but we say this is the
wrong site. We cannot understand how a determination
to place a garbage center for recyclables items, first of all,
can be made without a full environmental impact state-
ment. Secondly, he said they indicate to you that there is
a very fine line indeed between recyclable garbage and
non-recyclable garbage. There are many people who indi-
cate that 90% of the waste stream is recyclable. He said
he sees the day when this Town will be boxed in to the
very real situation of just what is a recyclable. How will
you monitor this recycling center? How will you deal
with what is or is not recyclable? Who is going to
distinguish it? Who is going to go to Mr. Carbone and
say this is a recyclable but this is not when there is no
unanimity of opinion in the scientific community today.
The very real possibility exists that what you will have is
in name a recycling center but in actuality a garbage
center. History has taught us to be very wary indeed of
applicants who have tried to operate private recycling
centers. Unforiunately, the history is not a good one.
Only too recently a great deal of publicity was given in
the mass media concerning a recycling center located in
the State of New Jersey. That was licensed, that was ap-
proved and it was supposed to be for recycling. We know
the story that what it became was what this might very
well become—a garbage dump. For two years the mu-
nicipality, its Town Attorney, its municipal attornies and
the town fathers tried to close it down. For two years
they were unsuccessful. The result was the great fire that
did take place which resulted in the burning of steel and
the twisting of metal on the highways in New Jersey. We
know that this is not the only center where this has hap-
pened. It has happened in other locations here in the
State of New York, most recently out on Long Island.

53

He said we know too that this applicant has already indi-
cated to the DEC that this is not going to only be a re-
cyling center. For this evening it is. For the DEC it was
going to be a waste transfer station as well. That is his
application. Those are in fact his words, not mine. He
said the intention is obvicus. It was stated hereby a prior
speaker that this is the attempt to get the foot in the door.
Mr. Gavioli said the application itself has been an indica-
tion that there is an approval from DEC—Assemblyman
Hinckey, Assemblyman Coleman and DEC regional per-
sonnel have looked into this on our behalf. They have
indicated that the application itself seems to be fraught
with irregularities. One of the irregularities is that at a
time when this Town did not permit a recycling center for
the transfer station, the application was made and granted
without any knowledge to the DEC that it was not per-
mitted under your zoning code at that time, something
that it is customary for DEC to be advised of and impor-
tant in its determinating process as to whether or not to
grant those permits.

In answer to a question from Councilman Kunis, Mr.
Gavioli said there is no specific question but a series of
questions relating to municipality and the right to use this
particular use there. There is not a specific question no.
Mr. Gavioli referred to a DEC memo that they received
on November 10, 1989 which he would get back to in a
little while.

Mr. Gavioli said it is obvious, he thinks, moreover that
the application which was made to DEC is fraught with
even further irregularities. At that time it was indicated
that the maximum would be 50,000 cubic feet which as
DEC regional personnel indicate is mere pittance and far,
far less than anything anticipated at the current time. Mr.
Gavioli said he knew that Mr. Resnick has indicated that
this will be a wholly enclosed facility. In point of fact,
DEC’s revised regulations now mandate that so there is
nothing that they are doing gratuitously. It is something
that DEC has decided must be done.

seater easier

54

Mr. Gavioli said your own Town Planning Board has
highlighted for you very clearly that although we may
wish and we may hope the reality is Western Highway
will be the means of ingress and egress. They indicate to
you in their own memorandum that it will require a
widening of Western Highway so that we know where all
this truck traffic is going to come and it is going to go
down and most importantly impact the communities sur-
rounding it. He said as far as what is going to happen
with the Magees, etc., gentlemen and lady of the Board,
let’s not fool ourselves. These negotiations and discus-
sions have been going on since the summer. They bore no
fruit. Let’s not misrepresent that in fact tomorrow every-
one is going to sit down and we are going to resolve this.
For a period of many months this has been ongoing. It
has not been resolved and he, would daresay it is not
going to be resolved. Just to highlight for the record, the
County has indicated that this is within 100 linear feet of
the flood plain. Of course, the County’s own Highway
Department has concern too about the dirt, the dust,
the mud being trucked onto Western Highway. In point
of fact. Thomas Gill, Principal Engineering Technician,
of the County Highway Department sent no less than five
(5) memorandums to the Town of Orangetown indicating
that roadway is incapable of handling any additional truck
traffic.

Mr. Gavioli said finally he would refer to a several
page letter which he received from DEC, Alexander J.
Cresluk, Jr., Deputy Regionai Permit Administrator dated
November 10, 1989. He stated that Mr. Cresluk is con-
cerned by this proposal and indicates his concerns are for
the potential spills and waste leachate leaving the prop-
erty. He indicates furthermore that they are not neces-
sarily going to go along with this as 50,000 cubic fee
would be minimal amount far less than what they antict-
pated and “We will request the Town of Clarkstown pro-
vide specific information to us regarding the proposal it

55

is presently reviewing so as to determine whether this
proposal in fact meets DEC requirements at this time in
view of these concerns.”

Mr. Gavioli said it has been mentioned and Mr. Jacob-
son has raised the point and he (Mr. Gavioli) will answer
it whether or not there is a truck ban in the Town of
Orangetown. The answer is yes there is. It was recently
enacted several weeks ago. He said it seems inexplicable
to him that this Town Board and your fellow Town Board
members in Orangetown which only recently found that
there was too much truck traffic on Western Highway and
enacted a truck ban, in an area in which we are now talk-
ing about locating a facility that could only do more dam-
age and increase that traffic. He said quite frankly this
application has a pungent stink to it and he thinks it
smells like garbage.

Appearance: Mr. Kalinowski
83 Western Highway
West Nyack, New York

He asked how many of his neighbors were here tonight
and asked them to stand up. He addressed the Board and
said that they were impacting his and his neighbors lives.
He said we have our houses here and we will be in this
area for a number of years. He said you are deciding on
our fate and on our children’s fate. You are increasing
truck traffic immensely. You have to get together with
the County. Business sense usually dictates that volume
production reduce costs. You are going to do it alone
and all the other towns are going to do it alone. He said
he did not think so. He thought it was going to be in his
backyard. He said he would like to know how and why
you can offer up a facility of a private company to an-
other town? You are offering their business.

Supervisor said what he is saying to the Village of
Nyack is that if they want to come along with Clarkstown
with regard to recycling they are welcome. We have to

aaa nena

56

recycle regardless of this application. If the Town Board
turns this down we still have to recycle and his offer to
the Village of Nyack if they want to come with us and
use the same system we are using is fine. We are not
oblivious to what people are saying. Otherwise we would
not be engaged in public hearing. If we decide that be-
cause of traffic or any other reason that this should not
be done here we still have to recycle next year.

Mr. Kalinowski said you do not have to impact the
environment one way to resolve a problem that already
exists and you are going to impact the environment. He
said he also has the application to the DEC and if you
will note on that every question is answered with no im-
pact. There is impact. There is impact every day that
extra trucks go down that road. You have allowed a mall
to be considered to come in here now. Western Highway
is the connector down into New Jersey. There are as
many Jersey plates coming up that street now as ever and
there will be more because it is a real convenience to get
away from Route 303 and the death trap that exists there.
There is no lights. You can travel it cleanly. The truckers
know it and they use it. You promised me it would stop
at the last meeting and you haven’t done it. Supervisor
said we have had enforcement out there. He said he could
not guarantee 100%. Mr. Kalinowski asked if this re-
cycling center had gone out to open bid—is this a com-
petitive bid basis? Supervisor said this application is a
private matter. Mr. Kalinowski asked if he.was wrong in
the assumption that any business that the County or the
Town gets involved with usually goes out on competitive
bid basis. Supervisor said if it exceeds the threshold on
the bidding which is $7,000.00. Supervisor said this
would be a contractual thing based on the price of it but
it could conceivably go out to bid, yes. Mr. Kalinowski
asked why couldn't it go out to bid. Supervisor said be-
cause we don’t even know if it is going to be there. Mr.
Kalinowski said what if somebody comes in with a lower

57

bid and it is someplace else. You are not opening up all
of the possibilities is what he is getting at. You are situ-
ated at one site now. You have an offer of Snake Road.
Put it up to competitive bid between the two guys. Let
them run it from the current dump. Supervisor said that
is an alternative and Mr. Kalinowski said it is an alterna-
tive that is not being pushed right now. This is just some-
thing that is going to lay down there and if these people
don't stay on your neck every damn day of the week it’s
going to be on Western Highway and we are going to be
on your neck. He said he has tried to call and ask Mr.
Grant to come in. He’s been on vacation. We had a hard
fought victory. We need the Town and the County here
together communicating. It’s not happening. All you
have is West Nyack and Western Highway fighting you
and fighting the Town Board to reduce traffic. We suspect
that there will not be a connecting road coming through.
You have open land available. He said he has not heard
the Supervisor once this evening ask these gentlemen to
contract out with you to run a recycling facility on a site
that is already a dump. Why does he have to put it on
Western Highway when you can use the dump right now.
Supervisor said he is applying for it there because he owns
the property. Mr. Kalinowski said let him leave his trucks
there right now just as he always has. Let him contract
out to manage the service on Route 303. Why not? Su-
pervisor said you are assuming that the Town is just going
to pass on this special permit. The Yown Board has not
made that decision and the purpose of a public hearing is
to get input from the public. You were here a couple of
months ago. We told you there would be a public hear-
ing. That is why you are here. That is why we are
listening. Again, the traffic situation which you raise on
Western Highway would have to be dealt with regardless
of this facility being proposed. That is a problem that has
to be dealt with regardless. We have to recycle also, re-
gardless. You have mentioned some other alternatives.
The Town Board has to take that into consideration. It

oo

58

will. Mr. Kalinowski said he hemes they do and he hopes
they keep it off Western Highway. We really don’t need
it there and there are better alternatives.

Appearance: Ms. Maria Hertz
95 Western Highway
West Nyack, New York

She said she would like to congratulate her fellow citi-
zens who live on Western Highway for the very good job
they are doing compiling information. The first meeting
we attended we were totally raw. We did not know what
was going on because we were innocent enough to trust
you, our representative. Now we found out that we
couldn’t do that so we started digging for information.
We have done an excellent job. She said she wanted Mr.
Holbrook to know that no one is out to get him. There
have been some harsh statements made and she wanted
to tell him why. She said the first meeting when every-
body complained about the traffic you told us you were
going to do something about it. Within two days there
was a sign on Doscher Avenue and Western Highway
stating that Five (5) ton trucks were allowed. She said
not a single violation or summons has been issued to any
sixteen wheelers passing by. What is the use to have a
law if it is not enforced. She said Mrs. Smith was the only
one on the Board who accepted her invitation and came
to her house. While she was there in five minutes we
counted seven sixteen wheeler trucks going by.

She said she would like the Supervisor to answer their
questions and not be referred to Mr. Bollman all the time.
She said she was speaking not from papers but from her
heart. She asked him to please consider the health of
their children and themselves. She said the people in the
rest of the Town, Congers included, have been silent on
what is happening to the people of West Nyack. But if
this facility goes in there everybody is going to be af-
fected—healthwise for everybody. She appealed to the

59

Town Board from her heart and asked everyone of them
to vote from their conscience not to back up anybody else.

Appearance: Mr. Bruce Broadley
West Nyack, New York

Mr. Broadley said here we go again looking at a special
permit to create some wealth for somebody else—for a
property owner at the expense of the homeowners in the
area. This time the creation of the wealth would be af-
fecting not so much the pocketbook but the lives of the
people. Western Highway is a busy highway. It has
trucks on it. Unfortunately we don't do too well in
our negotiations with the other towns—Orangetown or
Ramapo. They always seem to get the best of us. There
is a limitation on the road. Unfortunately, the Clarkstown
police don’t really enforce it, because as we all know the
Clarkstown police’s job is (1) being arrogant to the citi-
zens and (2) chatting with each other and (3) having
coffee and that is the impression you get of them as you
go around the town. It is quite apparent. The current
recycling program is an interesting kind of thing. It isn’t
too effective. He said he had a lot of recycled goods this
week. The blue box was filled up with newspapers and
we had some clear glass which we put in a bucket and put
it right next to it. Unfortunately the bucket was brown so
they didn't take any of the glass that was right next to the
papers. That's the way things go in the Town. Supervisor
said they should have taken it.

Mr. Broadley said we see that West Nyack gets a lot of
this stuff. They get the Pyramid Mall, they get the dump,
they are going to get the transfer station and they are
going to get the recycling. Dump everything in West
Nyack rather than in pristine New City. It’s no secret
why New City doesn’t get anything. If you look at the
demographics of Clarkstown every politician knows that
an election can be won if you carry New City and New
City has more votes than the rest of Clarkstown com-

einiteeiesierieeneneneaeeeestieter eaten

60

bined. You have more population than the rest of Clarks-
town. Look at the Rockland County Census. That may
be wrong too. Again, it is a government report. That's
why pristine New City doesn’t get things. They have the
population. They have the power base. What you are
forcing us to do and as we get down the pike and get
more and more of this crap you are forcing West Nyack
to really seriously consider incorporation as the Village of
West Nyack. The Village of West Nyack will take tax
revenues away from Clarkstown because we would do
certain things ourselves. In today’s atmosphere where we
just want to control zoning, the Village of West Nyack
would seek to have borders which would capture proper-
ties such as Pyramid and capture properties such as the
Town dump and the recycling things within their bound-
aries so that we could not only have appropriate zoning
but so that we could have an aggressive and strict and
enforceable village code contrary to what is currently
done in Clarkstown where the town code is many times
not enforced. This is what you are doing to us and what
you are going to have is the same phenomonon you had
in Ramapo. We have had a lot of inquiries from Congers,
from Valley Cottage, from Nanuet and as you know in
Nanuet, Mr. Teplitz is looking into that. You are going
to have a situation where there is going to be villages and
Clarkstown proper will be New City. You are forcing
us into that if you don’t start responding to the needs and
requests of the West Nyack citizens.

Appearance: Mr. Ted Galloway
24 Green Road
West Nyack, New York

Mr. Galloway said his street is just north of Carbone
and is probably known to you as a dangerous intersection.
He said he wanted to give an example of the problem in
response to the request for this facility. He said his wife
was involved in an accident at the corner of Western
Highway and Green Road. She is fine but we keep get-

61

ting more trucks coming down Western Highway. He said
the next foggy morning, of which there are many and a
five or ten ton truck comes along, she isn’t going to be
here.

Appearance: Ms. Maryann Brancatelli
2 Hobbe Street
West Nyack, New York

She said she has called the Supervisor many times
about garbage being picked up at 3:00 or 4:00 A.M.
She said she wanted to know why and where it is going.
She asked if there was anyone who could answer that.
Supervisor asked if she was talking about the Carbone
facility. She said they pick up at at time at the medical
building. Many of them have called the police and it
stops for a while but then it continues again. Why are
they even allowed to pick up at 3:00 or 4:00 in the morn-
ing. The Supervisor said they shouldn’t be. We have
looked into it. He said he did not have a good answer for
that except it shouldn't be. She said she hoped that would
be resolved soon.

Ms. Brancatelli said they are against the proposal for
a transfer station here in West Nyack. She said we al-
ready have the dump and now the idea of a transfer sta-
tion transferring trash to our community is outrageous.
She said they are tired of having such a fine community
become the butt end of Rockland County’s woes. Sle
said they were tired of having anything dumped upon us
against the democratic wishes of the community. A trans-
fer station brings with it an air of ugliness and the sense
of community is becoming environmentally unsound. She
said with the opening of a transfer station comes along
the problems of added truck traffic along Doscher Avenue,
Western Highway and other nearby roads. She said we
are intolerant to this scourge. The tractor trailers and
trucks traversing across these streets pollute enough
diesel smoke to fuel the entire steel city of Pittsburgh and

I ———

62

she asked the Supervisor if they have to be forced to
breathe any more toxins? She said also remember the
fresh air of the spring, the crisp air of the fall and the
memories they bring to mind. Well, the only memories we
have are the dirty polluting air being inhaled into the
lungs of our children and the filthy diesel smoke hovering
over our homes. Is the stuff we want our children to grow
up in? Is this the stuff we want in our future? In the
Sunday New York Times they have a section which asks
Would You Like to Live in—and there was a section
once regarding Nanuet. They said in it, besides Nanuet,
the Town of Clarkstown includes—and they named the
hamlets. West Nyack wasn’t even mentioned. We didn’t
even exist. In the eyes of Clarkstown we seem to exist
only as a doormat for all to wipe their feet on us. She
said right now she can’t even open her doors and windows
because of the fumes that come pouring through. This
summer, she said she was eight and nine months preg-
nant and could not even use her house fan. She was a
prisoner in her own home because all the fan brought in
was fumes, not only from the trucks but from the dump.
Don’t create problems without solutions. We have eight
toxic areas in about three square miles. Think about all
of us in Clarkstown and don't forget about us in West
Nyack. She said she wants to live and not die with her
family in her community.

Appearance: Ms. Mary Kuhnar, President
Association of Residents in Blauvelt
Blauvelt, New York

Ms. Kuhnar said Councilman Kunis asked a question
about specific questions on the DEC permit application
for an environmental assessment form that was filled out
by Mr. Carbone she would assume. She said there is one
question which asks were any permits needed from the
town and did he have them and Mr. Carbone answers
yes and the permit number is 75-711 which should be
checked into. We will provide you with a copy of this.

63

Councilwoman Smith said 75-711 is a building permit for
the garage. Supervisor said that sounds like it was issued
in 1975. Ms. Kuhnar said this was the permit which he
presented to the DEC as his right to have a transfer
station. Supervisor asked if Mr. Carbone submitted that
and Ms. Kuhnar said yes. She said she would like to add
that she feels very sorry for the residents of West Nyack
for what is happening to them and has been happening to
them in the past. She said she wished the Town Board
would listen to them because you can find alternative
ways to have a transfer station. Have it on Route 303
but do not subject these people to the kind of truck
traffic they are going to have from the garbage trucks
that will be coming from all over the county. She said
she is sure that will happen if this goes through.

Appearance: Mr. Frank Winbush
58 Western Highway

Mr. Winbush said he works at Stewart International
Airport and right below where he works there is a re-
cycling and transfer center. It started out as a recycling
center. Now it is a transfer station. He said you should
reconsider putting it on Western Highway because of the
truck traffic. He said every morning when he goes to
make that turn to go into the airport he is either behind
trucks or people from the area who are taking papers or
recycling glass or whatever to dump it off there. The
truck problem wouldn't be your biggest problem although
they do spill things on the road. A couple of times people
have gotten into accidents because it was foggy. He felt
it should be at a better site. He said where he works is
right next to Route 87 (New York Thruway) and they
are going to build a hotel there so in the future they
probably will get rid of that transfer station because he
said he was sure that people who come to that airport on
business will not want to look out their window and see
a transfer station. It would be better to have it some-
where else. He said where he works Route 84, Route 87,
Route 9W there are tons of trucks coming all over that

tintin

64

place. He said sometimes he is late for work just because
he is stuck behind these trucks either because they are
either too slow or they have a heavy load that they
shouldn't be carrying.

Mr. Resnick spoke in rebuttal. He said he understood
the emotion of the issue. He said he also understood how
hard pressed the Board is and how careful the Board
will be in making its determination in all respects. He
said the first thing that concerned him was the 50,000
cubic feet of the proposed application. He said he did
not have the application but would get it from Mr. Car-
bone tomorrow. He said it was Mr. Carbone’s recollec-
tion that the application for for 48,000 cubic yards. He
said 50.000 cubic feet is miniscule relatively speaking.
Councilwoman Smith said they may have forgotten the
amounts but she believed it was less than 12,500 tons or
50.000 cubic yards. Then what you apply for is consid-
ered a minor application. Mr. Resnick said that was
correct. Councilwoman Smith said under those circum-
stances no municipal agency is notified that this is even
applied for. That is something that has to be changed
today because she did not think the amount that we are
dealing with but the fact that such a site is coming into
this municipality. She felt every application should be
notified through the local municipality.

Mr. Resnick said you may be right and it may well be
that it is time that particular aspect is changed so that
there is communication much in the way of a 239 review
where all affected localities or municipalities have the
opportunity to give input at the initiation stage right from
the beginning so you know where you are and you can
stop something that may prove to be imprudent at the
earliest possible opportunity. We are not dealing here
with a transfer station or garbage site. We are dealing
essentially with a recycling center that takes various kinds
of materials that are capable of being reinserted into the
stream of commerce and reinserts them in one form or
another, whether it be wood, paper, plastic, glass, metal,

65

aluminum in whatever form and that is the purpose of
the site. Mr. Resnick said he had no problem with the
definition of recyclable. He said he knows what the
ordinance says and he knows what common sense says
and it means to reintroduce materials back into the
stream of commerce not to bury them in the ground.
He said he does not have that kind of concern but he
understands the constituency’s concern. Garbage is not a
pretty subject. We want to take our packaging, throw it
away and make it go away but it doesn’t work like that.
We are a package conscious society. The problem that
Clarkstown faces is a national problem. There are all
sorts of solutions being offered. The real question he sup-
posed was why doesn’t the federal government and the
State start doing something in a comprehensive way rather
than leaving the it to local government and this kind of
trauma that we face here tonight. He said with respect
to the inspection of the facility he has a great respect for
the enforcement arm of this Town. He has seen it at
work. As part of any permit that site is open on a
virtual 24 hour basis for inspection by any member of
the Town of Clarkstown who is authorized to do it, by
any member of the DEC who is authorized to do it, by
any health inspector of the County of Rockland. In terms
of inspection for management and maintenance it is open.
It is there. It has to be. It can’t be conducted any other
way. He said with regard to the question of the trucks.
He said he has no knowledge as to what the details of the
impact of the various improvements which the Town may
have on Western Highway. Nor is he privy to any of the
potential solutions. He said he did recall hearing one of
the neighbors complaining not about the Carbone trucks
but about other trucks and that is a point that he asks
the Board to keep an open mind on. He said we are but
a miniscule portion of the truck traffic and we probably
ride at hours when we don’t impact truck traffic. Much
of it would be early in the morning, he would suspect.

ci entienitnen ene

66

Mr. Resnick said he knows that the Board is familiar
with the site. If the Board believes that a traffic study is
necessary he can understand that. He said he does not
want to pay the expense of it because traffic studies are
notoriously expensive and what they confirm is that the
road is inadequate and that somebody ought to turn
around and improve it and then it usually turns out that
it is not the municipality that needs the improvement but
it is somebody else’s road and you can’t get it done. He
said he only has to look at Main Street north of here to
know that kind of a problem and the problem the Town
faces there. It is a similar one on Western Highway. He
said the site that we are contemplating developing and
that we seek a special permit for will not by its nature
contribute to pollution because it is not taking putresci-
bles. It will be taking cans which may have some soda in
it. It will be taking cardboard which someone may have
had a pizza in an office but we are not in the business of
bringing household or industrial garbage to this site. That
is not permitted under your zoning law and it is not our
method of operation. We are strictly recyclables. He said
he believes that we do conform to the zoning law in all
respects but he said he would be pleased to help the board
in any respect that they wish in terms of specific informa-
tion or studies that it may need in order to assist it in its
decision.

Councilwoman Smith said under your current DEC per-
mit that is only valid under their regulations, not ours.
She asked Mr. Resnick what the conditions are that they
set for recycling? Mr. Resnick gave her a copy of the
DEC permit. The conditions and requirements are all
attached and submitted as part of the record. He said he
thought it had been submitted as part of the application
but he said he may be in error.

Councilman Carey asked Mr. Resnick the date on the

permit. Councilwoman Smith read that it is dated July
of 1987 and is valid through 1992 and because its already

67

been granted they are not subject to the December 31,
1988 regulations. It says they have the right to store
recyclable materials for no longer than six months. Non-
recyclable materials shall be stored at the site for no
longer than twenty-four hours.

A gentleman from the

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385013_0385%3A06. Public record. Not legal advice.
