# Joint Appendix — Chemical Waste Management, Inc. v. Hunt

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385013_0185%3A12

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Joint Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1992
- **Citation:** 504 U.S. 334

## Text

No. 91-471

Iu the Supreme Court of the United

OCTOBER TERM, 1991

CHEMICAL WASTE MANAGEMENT, INC., PETITIONER

Guy HuNtT, GOVERNOR

OF THE

Vv.
STATE OF ALABAMA;

ALABAMA DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE; and JAMES M.
SIZEMORE, JR., COMMISSIONER OF THE ALABAMA DE-
PARTMENT OF REVENUE, RESPONDENTS

On Writ of Certiorari to the
Supreme Court of Alabama

JOINT APPENDIX

BERT S. NETTLES
Counsel of Record
ALTON B. PARKER, JR.
J. MARK HART
Spain, Gillon, Grooms
Blan & Nettles
2117 2nd Avenue North
Birmingham, AL 35203
(205) 328-4100
Counsel for Respondent

Hunt

WILLIAM D. COLEMAN
Counsel of Record

JIM B. GRANT, JR.
Capell, Howard, Knabe

& Cobbs, P.A.

57 Adams Avenue
Montgomery, AL 36104
(205) 241-8000

Counsel for Respondents

James M. Sizemore, Jr. and
the Alabama Department

of Revenue

ANDREW J. PINCUS
Counsel of Record

KENNETH S. GELLER

EVAN M. TAGER
Mayer, Brown & Platt
2000 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006
(202) 7780628

FOURNIER J. GALE III

H. THOMAS WELLS, JR.
Maynard, Cooper, Frierson

& Gale, PC.

1901 Sixth Avenue, North
2400 AmSouth, Harbert Plaza
Birmingham, AL 35203
(205) 254-1000

Counsel for Petitioner
Chemical Waste Management,
Ine.

( Additional Counsel on Inside Cover)

SL LS aN EE a a ST I ETE ETE
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI FILED SEPTEMBER 20, 1991
CERTIORARI GRANTED JANUARY 27, 1992

J. WADE HoPEe

Legal Division

Alabama Department
of Revenue

4116 Gordon Persons
Building

Montgomery, AL 36104

(205) 242-9690

TABLE OF CONTENTS *

Page
Relevant Docket Entries 200000000 1
Oral Argument on Motions (excerpts) .. 3
List of States Affected by Alabama Act 89-788 __. — 6
Testimony of Rodger Henson (excerpts)... ~
Testimony of Sue Robertson (excerpts) ....... 15
Testimony of Richard Groshong (excerpts) sae 28
Testimony of Bill Brock (excerpts)... idensenas 35
Testimony of Tom Joiner (excerpts) _. sesieodepusnasierevdsene 43
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 61 (excerpts) 54
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 62 000 57
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 77... inaiitadeas idiomas nesebbibesinndaeteiensnes 62
Peniten © ible 60 ........................................ sintetatbelissaaceds 65
Defendants’ Exhibit 14 (excerpts)... ienspaness 68
Defendants’ Exhibit 40 (excerpts) en 91
Defendants’ Exhibit 41 (excerpts). sti‘—tstsS 99
Defendants’ Exhibit 57 (excerpts)... 108
Defendants’ Exhibit 68 (excerpts) .... = ststst—

_—

w

on eH
i=) -)
fae} ~
. ;
3 E
y Ms
77) 5)
= g8 &
5S —S A
a Seas
— & cS §&
qo wo fe
4 S5Aa
a WO
5

jam ~

68/61/01 Spuels] UIZATA “SQ
68/F1/60 UO UZ UIYSE AA
68/1/60 Uu0Z20
ueg jo ajeq UOTPBULIOJUT
dA 1oj jsonbey s,ewmeqeiy

0} asuodsay Jo yor'y] jo

=

asnkoeg pauurg saqywig

$82°68 LOV VNVAVIV Ad GALOTAAV SALVLS AO LSIT

Environmental Management

1-9-90
Date

‘o
re)
of
=
=
Ey
=)
UISUOIST AA
430
sUxay
dossouue |
vUT[OABD YyNog
puvjs] epoyy
BluBA[ASUUdg
BWoYye|YO
o14o
68 /F1/60 BUIWOA VUI[OAR,) YRION
68/1/60 BIUIZUTA JSOAA ylOK MON
68/F1/60 BIUIBALA AQSAof MON
68/P1/60 JUOULIO A UpRAoN
68/F1/60 ByO¥R(] YINog BYSUAGAN
68/61/01 ory OLN ByOsoUUTY
68/61/60 ByONB YWON UBS IYI
68/b1/60 OdIXaTY MON S}JOSNYIUssV]Y
68/ F1/60 attysdwey MON puvypAaryy
68/1/60 vurqyuoyy Ayonyley
68/F1/60 LANOosst |x BUBISINO'T]
68/F1/60 tddississi py EMO]
68/F1/60 ouleyy vuvipu]
68/1/60 sesuey SIOuTI|]
68/61/01 IIEMEH oyrp]
68/PT/60 eploly BLI.1004)
68/F1/60 BiQUINIO,) JO JIAYSIG yNoQoeuU0,)
68/1/60 MBMLLIC OpR.10]O,)
68/1/60 wuozLiy VIUAOJTRD
68/ FT, 60 ByselLy SBSURYAY
uvg Jo aynq saqey aye paysyqnd Uo eansoyg
IATPIYA [Psodsiq] 40 yuoWywaa], BRL-68 PY Aq

[PIDAVUIWIOY JO yoR'] Jo
asnBoeg pouurg sozRrjg

PP9PIPV ION SAPS

[Shp “U)

eT Wael EIS 3

ahd 6 Shatin Det ee et

8

TESTIMONY OF RODGER HENSON

* - * *

[Tr.48] Q. Is there any difference among nonhazard-
ous and hazardous waste based upon the state where they
are generated or created?

A. There is no difference.

* * * *

(Tr.64] Q. I think we will pick up where we were at
lunch. As I understand it, you had testified that you take
hazardous waste and then solidify it or treat it and
then render it nonhazardous before or when you place
it into the trench; is that correct?

A. That is correct. That is with some waste.

Q. Possible with some waste, but not all waste?

A. Not all waste.

Q. And would you agree then with the statement that
although some wastes degrade or can be less hazardous
through treatment, some substances remain hazardous
forever?

A. I would agree with that.

” * * *

(Tr.83] Q. And incidentally is it not correct that
approximately 40,000 truckloads of hazardous waste came
into Emelle last vear?

A. I don’t know if that is the number or not.

Q. If you take 20 tons on the average truck?

A. 20 tons a truck.

Q. 780,000, almost 800,000, and you multiply that
out, would you get 40,000 truckloads of hazardous waste?

A. Is that how it divides out?

Q. Yes. We had a large complicated set of figures
with Mr. Hanley, and that is what it came out.

A. If you take 780,000 tons of waste and divide that
by 20 tons per truck you get the number of trucks.

* * * *

(Tr. 102] Q. I will ask you to read with me on page
4, paragraph D, reading your lawyer’s language, and you

9

will recognize the first few words of that, “Without the
unconstitutional restrictions discussed above, the total an-
nual demand for disposal capacity at the Emelle facility
for hazardous waste generated out of state is projected
to increase annually”. Do you agree with that statement
of your lawyers?

A. I agree.

Q. So, without the cap, without the additional fees,
you project that total annual demand for disposing ca-
pacity there at Emelle would increase for hazardous
wastes generated out of state annually?

A. To a point. There are some points somewhere in
the future where it won’t.

Q. I believe you stated in deposition that you see a
hundred years of operation there at Emelle?

(Tr.103] A. I stated in my deposition at the current
rate I believe the facility would last 100 years, at least.

Q. Now, isn’t it correct—I believe you said toward
the end of your testimony this morning that with respect
to—you were taking two situations, asked about what
happens on cleanup costs. We see a lot of cleanup of
hazardous waste from the government, Judge, or whoever
mandates that it be removed, and a lot of that is coming
to Emelle, is that correct?

A. Right.

” * * *

(Tr. 113] Q. Now, is it not correct that you have
monitoring facilities that will have to be maintained in-
definitely, or shall we say forever?

A. Monitoring facilities?

Q. The 70 monitoring wells already in place at Emelle,
for example?

A. Those wells will be monitored in perpetuity.

Q. Yes, sir. And that monitoring in perpetuity, by
definition, will extend well beyond 30 years?

A. It will.

Q. And likewise is there not going to be a require-
ment that continued safety desirabiilty, environmental

10

desirability factor to maintain the pumping out of the
leachate and hauling, gathering, storing and disposal of
leachate from this trench 19 and eventualiy trench 21,
and from these other trenches yet to be built?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And that gathering, collection, storage, transpor-
tation and disposal of leachate will have to be maintained
in perpetuity?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Again, by definition, beyond 30 years?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And isn’t it a fact that the premises there at
Emelle |Tr. 114] where you have the monitoring, where
you have the pumping out of leachate, will have to be
maintained and secured in perpetuity?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. For which there will be some expense?

A. Some.

Q. In fact, all of those things that we have described,
the continued monitoring, the continued pumping, the
gathering and collection and hauling away and disposal
of leachate, and the security maintenance of the facility
will have to be maintained at some expense in perpetuity?

A. That’s correct.

Q. Now, obviously you have some 50 acres in use at
the present time, and assuming, shall we say, some an-
nual increases and operations for a hundred years, you
are talking about far more than 50 acres on down the
road being placed in active operation?

A. Yes.

Q. And the greater the facility, the larger the facility,
the larger the cost eventually in perpetuity?

A. That’s correct.

Q. And is it not correct to say that the larger the
facility the more millions of tons of hazardous waste
brought in and left there forever, whatever risks there
are likewise will increase?

(Tr. 115] A. Well, I get—when you talk about risks,
what I am maintaining is that you are not increasing

11

your risk anymore by the more material that you bring
in and put in the Selma chalk.

Q. That is your testimony?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. That you can dig another hundred trenches the
size of trench 21 or trench 16, that-we saw in the photo-
raph, and not increase the risks?

, A. It is my opinion you won't, because of the in-
tegrity of the chalk. :
‘e with the operation
[Tr.116] Q. So what we have here wi |
of this ChemWaste facility at Emelle —~ Selma chalk,
all of this is based upon an inexact science:
A. In my view. The only thing that is inexact about

~ it is the measurement of migration through chalk. You've

got people that are saying 310 years it would take to
penetrate the chalk. You have other people saying a
million years, and you have people saying 10,000 years.
It is somewhere in there somewhere, is what I am saying.
. It is going to leak? ae
4 The migration potential through that chalk is in-
exact.

* * * *

(Tr. 120] Q. And ChemWaste has the responsibility
should anything go wrong, it also has the similar respon-
sibility for the present, certainly for the 30 years under
the EPA guidelines, for anything that might go wrong
in Louisiana, or at these other five facilities?

A. That’s correct. 7

Q. So, if there were a natural disaster in Louisiana
or Texas, or one of these other facilities, hazardous waste
facilities, ChemWaste would be responsible for that; is
that not correct?

A. If they own the facility, that’s right.

Q. Yes, sir. Speaking of disasters, do you have any
plan with respect to what if an earthquake comes
through there?

A. No.

ee oe i

12

[Tr. 123] Q. Relating to this
. morning, I think you
oe most of the Fortune 500 companies ship c
ardous waste to the Emelle facility for landfill ial?
A. Many of them do. ee
Q. I think you said most.
A. I might have; most, many, some, a lot.
an Most and some, in any event let’s just say with
t at, |Tr. 124] most, some, or a lot of Fortune 500 com-
panies send to Emelle their hazardous waste. Most of
those companies, most of that waste from those companies
Is generated outside of Alabama?
A. Yes, sir.
Mg Fectggeing: ae me. Is there a similar site
ama, a similar disposal si
en ar disposal site, to ChemWaste, to
A. No, sir. We are the onl i i i
a ae y commercial disposal site
THE COURT: ‘ y i i
. a You don’t have an in-state competitor?
beri = Now, is Emelle the largest landfill, haz-
é S waste operation, anywhere in the enti ntry?
A. In land size, yes, a

Q. And, in fact, do you k i
non en teae y now of any in the world as

A. I d , ad i] . M “a. .
a ee I am not famiilar with every facility in

Q. You are not aware of an i
y landfill operation lar
than the Emelle facility anywhere in the world: are ar
A. I’m not aware of any.
Q During the video tape we heard—this is just to
clarify—I think it said on the tape that the number of
acres at Emelle was, I believe, 2400 acres, and your
sare (Tr. 133] was like 1700 acres?
Az ‘o; it was 2700. We have acqui
since the tape was made. oe

13

Q. You may have said 1700 but you meant to say

2700?

A. I meant 2700.

Q. That is the size of the Emelle facility?

A. (Witness nods head up and down.)

Q. One of the first things brought out in your testi-
mony today was the location of Emelle. It is a rather
rural area; isn’t it?

A. Itis.

Q. And this landfill is actually located between Emelle
and Geiger?

A. That’s correct.

Q. In this particular facility over there is that one of

the reasons it was chosen, because it was a very sparsely
populated area?

A. It was chosen because of geology, number one; and
the second consideration was it was chosen because it

was for sale.

* * * +

[Tr. 156] Q. Would anything coming out of any one of
those be considered leachate?

A. Yes. Materials pumped out of this pipe that is
above both of the liners would be considered leachate.

THE COURT: You are getting that now?

[Tr.157] A. Yes, sir.

Q. Where is this water coming from?

A. It is rainfall. When this trench is open and we
are disposing of things inside it, and it rains on it, the
water trickles down through, hits the synthetic liner, hits
the gravel, and flows through that pipe into the pump
and we pump it out.

THE COURT: What do you do with it?

A. It is stored on site in a tank and then we ship it
to Texas for disposal.

Q. Why do you ship it to Texas for disposal instead
of disposing of it on site?

A. Because there is a deep well injection facility in
Texas. that we don’t have. The only thing we could do
would be solidify it and put it back in the trench.

hai. oe)

eae aS ee

14

Q. Are there any deep well injection facilities in the
state of Alabama?

A. I don’t know whether there are any of those still
operating privately or not. I know there is not a com-
mercial one.

Q. There is not one that would take it?

A. There is not one in Alabama that would take our
stuff.

Q. If I can describe it as a regular landfill, do the
county landfills generate leachate?

A. Iam certain they do.
| Tr. 158] Q. What about industrial landfills that ac-
cept industrial nonhazardous waste?

A. Any landfill that is operated in anyplace where it
rains generates leachate.

THE COURT: Do you have a different category for
that leachate? Do you have hazardous and nonhazardous?

A. The leachate that is collected because of rainfall in
a hazardous waste facility is, by definition of EPA, a
hazardous liquid. The leachate generated in a landfill may
or may not be hazardous, depending on what they put in
the garbage landfill.

Q. So the leachate from a garbage landfill could be
hazardous?

A. It could have hazardous characteristics, depending
on what went in that garbage landfill. It is not defined as
hazardous as a TSD facility under RCRA.

A. It is a hazardous waste landfill, transportation
storage facility.

* * _ =

15

TESTIMONY OF SUE ROBERTSON

(Tr. 194] Q. Good morning, Ms. Robertson. Would
you state your full name for the Court, please?

A. Sue R. Robertson.

Q. Where do you live?

A. Ilive in Wallsboro, Alabama.

Q. By whom are you employed?

A. The State of Alabama, specifically the Alabama
Department of Environmental Management.

Q. In what capacity?

A. I am Chief of the Land Division, which is re-
sponsible for regulation of hazardous and solid waste.

Q. Would you please give the Court a brief summary
of your educational background?

A. I have a B.S. Degree in Chemical Engineering
from the University of Alabama. I have a Master’s in
Chemical |Tr. 195] Engineering from Georgia Tech. I
have been employed with ADEM or its predecessors for
the past 18 years.

Q. And are you a registered professional engineer?

A. Yes, in the state of Alabama.

Q. In the state of Alabama. When did you receive
that designation?

A. 1977.

[Tr. 205} A. EPA has, through their regulatory proc-
ess, classified for about 455 chemicals, specific chemicals or
listings as being hazardous. In addition, they have other
characteristic procedure which says that if a waste [Tr.
206| is corrosive or if it is reactive, or if it is ignitable,
or if it fails a test procedure, which was referred to
as an EPA tox, but now there is another test procedure
that replaced that called the toxie characteristic leaching
procedure, which you will hear a lot of people refer to as
TCLP. This covers an enormous range of chemicals, and
Chemical Waste Management, through the Part B permit
and their interim status, can landfill or can manage virtu-
ally all of those different chemicals. In addition, Chemica]

ee eee ee ee

16

Waste Management is permitted to manage PCBs or poly-
chlorinated biphenyls. And, in addition to that, they are
also permitted to take CERCLA waste, which is cleanup
waste that Dr. Henson referred to yesterday, and these
could encompass an even wider range of chemicals that
are of concern under the Clean Water Act or the Air Act.
So, there is a very broad range. These chemicals are
again determined to be hazardous, because they might be
reactive. That means if they are mixed with other chemi-
cals there would be a reaction. Ignitable at other facili-
ties in the early ’70s in the past, drums would explode
and the storage facility would catch on fire. And there’s
been some large contamination and resulting cleanups
from that tyne incidents. Corrosive—if corrosive ma-
terial would eventually eat through some [Tr. 207] stor-
age containers, then that would allow them to perhaps
react with other chemicals it was stored with, and then
they are toxic. A large percentage of the chemicals are
listed as being hazardous because they are toxic. They
have been determined to be carcinogenic and mutogenic,
and have im»act on human health.

” * * *

(Tr.216] A. * * * But there is also concern about
long term, and there are some very hazardous compounds
that are landfilled there that are considered to be haz-
ardous because of their effect on human health, that
there were studies or [Tr. 217] actual verification that
these compounds when it got into the ground water caused
cancer, caused malformed babies, caused miscarriages, et
cetera; so | would say there are two types of concerns,
the sudden, which would be ignitable waste that Dr. Hen-
son talked about, and then the long term, which would be
the cancer causing agents that could get into the water
table.

Q. Ms. Robertson, we were talking about the differ-
ences between a gasoline truck which would be going to
the gasoline station and other trucks with flammable

17

liquids which may be destined for treatment at Emelle.
Are the types of liquids contained in those trucks intended
for treatment at Emelle, are they of the same type ignita-
ble characteristics that the gasoline truck would be?

A. Part of them would be, yes.

* * * *

[Tr.219] Q. Now, tell me, if you will, what are some
of the more hazardous wastes that are stored at Emelle,
please, ma’am?

A. Stored or landfilled?

Q. Landfilled at Emelle. I’m sorry.

A. Well, again, PCBs are landfilled at Emelle in large
amounts. They are considered hazardous. You have a
large amount of plating waste that goes to Emelle. Those
are contaminated with metals such as lead, cadmium,
chrome, cyanide suppressant are present many times in
plating base, and those can be released. If they are re-
leased in a gaseous state, they are considered fatal to hu-
mans in concentrations as low as, I believe, three or 400
parts per million. So, metals are considered to be pretty
much prevalent. Once they are disposed they stay as
metals in the environment, and some of them have high
solubility in water, or cyanide, and would move into the
water table if an opportunity presented itself.

Q. You mentioned a minute ago when I asked you a
question about storage of these wastes at Emelle, and
you asked me if I meant landfilled. With respect to ma-
terials that are landfilled at the Emelle facility, how long
is it anticipated that those materials and wastes will
| Tr. 220} be landfilled there?

A. Chemical Waste Management, in their closure plan,
intends to cap that waste that is landfilled, and that it
will be left there forevermore.

Q. And these wastes that are capped in the landfill in
Alabama forever will require what type of, in general
terms, continuous regulatory activity?

A. On any particular regulatory, on my part, or
maintenance on their part?

== ys = Se

18

Q. Both. I’m sorry.

A. Okay. I will continue to have to regulate that
facility even in a closed state to insure that ChemWaste
is doing what is required under the post closure provi-
sions. When you get a permit, which is referred to as a
post closure permit when a facility is closed with waste
in place, that post closure permit would require that
ChemWaste maintain the cap so that water or liquids do
not permeate the cap, get in the landfill and cause possible
ground water contamination, requires that monitoring be
carried out on a periodic basis; and at the present, those
requirements would be for 30 years after they close the
facility or the landfill.

THE COURT: Continuing regulation for 30 years?

A. Yes, sir.

THE COURT: Why are you able to stop at the end
[Tr. 221] of 30 years?

A. The federal law or EPA specified that that was all
that is required, that 20 years; but in actuality, the waste
will be there and there will still have to be monitoring
of some sort that will go on at that facility forever, be-
cause the waste will be there forever, and the longer the
waste is there the greater the probability that the liners
may deteriorate and that there might be contamination.

(Tr. 241] Q. Now, are those, all of those that you just
read, fire, explosion, spills, and materials release, and
accidents, they have listed there under emergencies in-
herent to [Tr. 242] closure operations?

A. That’s correct.

Q. Are those all risks that are attendant to handling,
managing and landfilling hazardous waste at the Emelle
facility?

A. Yes.

Q. In your judgment, is that risk increased by in-
creased volumes of hazardous waste that is managed,
stored and landfilled at that facility?

A. Yes.

19

Q. Look at paragraph 1.4.2 under natural events,
please, and tell the Court what ChemWaste says are nat-
ural events which are potential facility emergencies.

A. There are potential facility emergencies which
could result from acts of God, including major climato-
logical, geophysical or other natural events, such as heavy
rains and surface runoff, tornadoes, heavy winds and
forest fires.

Q. Is there any mention of earthquakes in that?

A. No.

Q. And with respect to those natural events which are
potential emergencies that could occur at or around the
Emelle facility, is it your judgment that the risks attend-
ant to those would be increased based on the increased
volume that is stored and landfilled at that [Tr. 243]
facility?

A. Yes.

Q. I will ask you, Ms. Robertson, has it recently come
to your attention that an earthquake did actually occur
in Sumter County in 1886?

MR. WELLS: We will stipulate that there was an
earthquake 104 years ago in Sumter County. I don’t
think we need to ask every witness.

MR. PARKER: We will accept the stipulation.

* * * *

Q. ChemWaste’s contingency plan does not address
the potential for earthquakes; does it?
A. No, it doesn’t.

* * * *

[Tr.251] Q. You mentioned earlier the newly per-
mitted BFI landfill at Last Chance, Colorado. I ask you
are there any landfills which have been started and per-
mitted since RCRA came into existence in November of
1980 for hazardous waste?

A. No. Last Chance is the only green field site, which
[Tr. 252] means there was nothing there before they came
in and put a landfill there.

a ae We ony

20

Q. All of the other hazardous waste landfills operated
and preexisted the effective date of RCRA?

A. They came in under interim status meaning they
made that demonstration that they were accepting haz-
ardous waste and they, therefore, got a Part A permit
and didn’t go through getting a Part B, as the green
field site.

MR. PARKER: Your Honor, do you understand what
the green field site means? You might explain that, if
you would.

A. When you refer to a green field site it means that
there was nothing but grass there before, and that there
was nothing there, and you came in and put some type of
industry there.

Q. Now, with respect to Last Chance, Colorado land-
fill, which is the only permitted landfill, which is a green
field site, since RCRA, how much waste has been intro-
duced into that landfill?

A. None. It became operational or could have been
operational in the spring of this year. BFI made the
corporate decision that it would no longer manage haz-
ardous waste; and, therefore, put up for sale all of its
hazardous waste facility, so this facility was [Tr. 253]
never operated and is for sale.

Q. Has it been sold at the present time, to your know!l-
edge?

A. No.

[Tr. 298] Q. Have you reviewed the records of ADEM
to determine what spills have occurred on site at Emelle?

A. Yes.

Q. And would you please tell the Court, or summarize,
those spills, the dates and types of spills they were?

A. On October 4, 1984, a solution with a pH greater
than 13 was placed in the RCRA surface impairment
number 3, which contained a low pH sludge. The co-
mingling of these wastes resulted in an orange colored

21

atmospheric emission being emitted. On August 18, 1985
there was a hazardous waste spill, which occurred on site,
which contaminated an area of on site soil. Efforts to
contain this spill weren’t effective and there was off site
contamination. ChemWaste indicated that equipment fail-
ure caused the release. On April 4, 1986, 50 gallons of
waste acid were spilled on the ground during the loading
of a tanker when the acid apparently caused the tanker
walls to fail. On September 17, 1987, approximately 30
gallons of solvent waste was spilled when a tanker hose
failed and contaminated on site soil. On March 22, 1989,
a truck driver released a 10,000 pound load of ash with
less than 500 ppm, PCBs on a paved parking lot. On
August 31, 1989, 55 gallons of D001, F003, and F005
spilled from leaking drums on [Tr. 299] a paved parking
lot.

Q. Are those listed hazardous wastes with EPA code
numbers?

A. Yes.

Q. Go ahead.

A. On September 14, 1989 approximately 70 pounds
of DOO8 waste spilled from a truck at the ChemWaste
scales. On September Ist, 1989, one gallon of F006 haz-
ardous waste leaked onto the pavement at the site when
a truck was parked on an incline. On October 13, 1989,
20 gallons of F003 and F005 and D001 hazardous waste
spilled on facility soil. On November 3, 1989, 25 gallons
of D002 and K062 leaked from a truck at the facility.
On November 8, 1989, 10 gallons of D007 and D008,
spilled from a truck tailgated at the facility. On Decem-
ber 5, 1989, two gallons of D001 and F02 and F005 were
spilled from an unsecured lid on a tanker truck. On
December 13, 1989 approximately 20 gallons of listed
waste spilled from a tanker at the solvent recovery area.
On December 29, 1989, approximately 15 gallons of flam-
mable liquid was spilled on the pavement from a tanker
when the top vent was not secured. On January 16, 1990,
two gallons of liquid from site D004 and D004 hazardous

Toul

ee ee he Ce eee

22

waste spilled from the rear of a rolloff. In the spring of
this year there were some brominated tablets put into the
trench and came in contact with [Tr. 300] some moisture
and caused a release, an orange colored cloud release also.

Q. Now, with respect to all of those spills that have
occurred on site, that you have just identified, were all
of those spills remediated by ChemWaste?

A. Yes, they have.

Q. Now, I notice that beginning from 1984 to 1989
there were—I’m sorry. ’84 up through the beginning of
’89 there were four spills that were reported. Since ’89,
there have been one, two, three, four, five, six, seven,
eight, nine, ten, eleven, twelve, by my count, that you
have reported. Is that approximately correct?

A. Yes.

Q. And how does the incident of spills correlate, if it
does, with the increase in the volumes that have been dis-
posed of at Emelle?

CA. Well, the volumes managed on site have increased
since 1985.

* * * *

(Tr. 301] Q. And accordingly then what—is there a
difference between the volumes of out-of-state waste that

are disposed of at Emelle and the volumes that are dis-
posed of from in state?

A. The majority of waste managed at Emelle, accord-
ing to the records provided by ChemWaste, according to
Dr. Henson’s testimony, is from out of state.

Q. And that is the 85 to 90 percent we have been talk-
ing | Tr. 302] about?

A. That is correct.

Q. Is there any reason to believe that those percent-
ages will not continue to hold true with respect to vol-
umes that are disposed of at Emelle in the absence of

the Fee Act which has been enacted, which is in litiga-
tion today?

23

A. As I previously discussed, the number of landfills
are decreasing every year. Some of these landfills have
caps placed on them. The only one that has been cited
within the last 10 years is the Denver, Colorado facility,
which has a cap. The trend is that there are fewer and
fewer landfills that can handle this waste. There are
landfills that are going to be filled up within the next
few years. The GAO reports indicate that EPA just
doesn’t have any idea or good data on the amount of
CERCLA waste that will need to be cleaned up and prop-
erly disposed of, that they don’t have a good feel on the
amount of hazardous waste that will eventually be de-
clared to be hazardous waste. And so, even though you
have the land ban restrictions and that will minimize un-
treated waste going to the landfill, you still have these
forces that are going to increase the amount of waste
that can be hazardous and at the same time the amount
of waste, the amount [Tr. 303] of permitted disposal sites
is decreasing; so, the law of supply and demand would
indicate that the waste would still, the amount of out-of-
state waste, would still be at least the 85 to 90 percent
number, if not greater.

[Tr. 305] Q. And shown on that chart would you ex-
plain what the volumes are since 1985 at the Emelle
facility?

A. Well, as the bar chart indicates, in 1985 Chem-
Waste received 341,000 tons of waste. These are approxi-
mate numbers rounded off. In 1986 they received 456,000
tons. In 1987 they received 564,000 tons. In 1988 they
received 549,000 tons of waste. In 1989 they | Tr. 306] re-
ceived 791,000 tons of waste. And through August of
this year they have received 480,000 tons of waste.

. o * *

[Tr. 310] Q. What effect, if any, have the increased
volumes of disposal at Emelle, not disposal but landfilling

a

ee

Tt al

a

Se

a Se

ee ae eae ee” eee! be ee Pee ee ea, eee

24

of waste at Emelle had on ADEM’s ability to monitor and
otherwise perform its obligations at the Emelle facility?
A. When Emelle was accepting very large tonnages
per month it increased the difficulty of our staff being
able to monitor that operation. They were operating, in
essence, around the clock. There were trucks backed up
out of the gate onto the highway. It was impossible for
ADEM to really be able to adequately monitor the site.

& * * *

(Tr. 316] Q. Now, if you will, please tell the Court the
size and type of leachate storage facilities they have at
Emelle.

A. Emelle has a tank farm that is capable of storing
five million gallons of leachate.

Q. Five million gallons?
A. Yes.

(Tr. 334] Q. For each one of those facilities the post
closure period is 30 years; itn’t it?

A. That’s correct.

Q. Now, where is that 30 years set forth?

A. In EPA and State regulations.

Q. In the EPA and State regulations?

A. That’s right. Our regulations are identical.

Q. Do your regulations have to be identical? They

don’t; do they?

A. No. The EPA, the RCRA law says that states can
be more stringent.

Q. So, if you wanted to extend the post closure care
period beyond 30 years, you could change the State regu-
lations to do it; couldn’t you?

A. I guess that is a discussion. We have considered
that and are evaluating the 11th Circuit’s opinion to
[Tr. 335] determine if we can do that.

(Tr. 336] Q. And I assume if ADEM didn’t like the
way that corporate guarantee was written, since the per-
mit he has got to certify that it is word for word identi-

25

cal with the regulations, you can change the regulations;
is that right? .

A. On the financial assurance part of the regulations,
EPA is very cautious, and I would doubt that we could
change it without stringent tests, because of the necessity
to be equal; but, in theory, you could, yes. .

Q. Okay. What you are saying is the financial assur-
ance required not only in Alabama but everywhere in the
United States has to be word for word identical?

A. That’s correct.

Q. Under EPA regulations?

A. Yes.

* + * *

(Tr. 350] Q. So it would be fair to say that the state-
ments in here where they have any criticisms of post
closure liabilities would apply pretty much equally to any
kind of facility that closes in place?

A. In theory, yes; it is saying there is that same con-
cern.

* * * %

(Tr. 361] Q. So, I take it that if the United States of
America, hypothetically, was a responsible party, that
would relieve some of your concern about the state being
ultimately stuck, if you will, if I can use the vernacular?

A. Again we're getting back on the area of where the
federal government really is liable or would choose to be
liable.

Q. I am asking you to assume, for sake of argument,
they are absolutely, strictly, jointly and severally liable
under 107A CERCLA.

A. You may make a theoretical assumption, then, yes.

* * * ”

(Tr. 364] Q. Now, earlier you were talking generally
about risk, and risk of the what ifs that occur or could
occur, might occur, earthquakes, tornadoes, or hurricanes.
The risks other than volume was the thing that you talked
about Emelle, as I recall?

A. That’s correct.

26

Q. It didn’t really have anything to do with whether
the waste was from in state or out of state?

A. That’s correct.

Q. It really had to do with volume?

A. Quantity, yes.

Q. So you would agree that the risks don’t depend on
where the waste comes from, given equivalent quantities?

(Tr. 365] Q. The risks don’t depend on whether it is
In state waste or out of state waste; your concern is
the volume?

A. The chemical composition at the landfill would not
be any different ; but you would have the transportation
risk we discussed also. And that is related to quantities;
but you have the different routes coming in.

Q. Now, some of the routes coming in, speaking of
transportation, some of the routes coming into Emelle
only travel over Alabama highways just a few miles if
they are coming from the west?

A. Yes. |

Q. And Emelle is almost to Mississippi?

A. Almost in Mississippi, yes.

_ c oe *

(Tr. 366] Q. Now, let me ask you one thing, ji
know it. I think you had talked chews what a Pe ps
calculate as the number of trucks that went into the Emelle
facility in 1989, and I think you came up with a 40,000
figure?

A. In general, yes.

| Tr. 369] Q. Okay. Now, speaking of transporters
you have said, in terms of hazardous waste transportation,
that ADEM regulates hazardous waste transportation?
7 That’s correct.
. And you give them its i i
veniam gi permits if they meet certain
A. That’s correct.

27

Q. And one of the requirements is they have to have
adequate liability insurance to take care of things like
this. This happened to be a chemical spill?

A. That’s correct.

Q. That one you didn’t regulate until it got spilled ;
is that right?

A. That’s right.

_ But the hazardous waste trucks you regulate while
they [Tr. 370] are rolling?

A. That’s correct.

Q. And you wouldn’t give a permit to a hazardous
waste transporter if it didn’t have adequate liability cov-
erage;.would you?

A. We wouldn’t give a permit unless it complied with
the regulations which require that.

Q. The regulations require adequate liability coverage?

A. Correct.

e e * *

[Tr.410] Q. Now, Ms. Robertson, you ended up, |
think, by saying, [Tr. 411] if I caught this correctly, there
are risks inherent to managing hazardous waste; is that

correct?

A. Yes.
Q. So there would be risk to managing hazardous waste

not only at the Emelle facility, not only at the Allied
Signal incinerator, but all of the other 32 additional haz-
arduus waste treatment, storage and disposal facilities;
right?

A. Yes.

ee — 1 ae NS

ee

28

TESTIMONY OF RICHARD GROSHONG

ke! pie 7 Now, Dr. Groshong, do you presently
ach at the University of Alabama as a f ?
Sheet ull professor?
Q. What is your area of concentration or teaching?
A. Structural geology, rock deformation.
a All right, sir. Is it correct that you and Dr.
— Pricey prepared a paper back in April of this
year entitle azardous Waste Disposal ji r
Crustatious Selma Group? oe
A. That is correct. That i
Ss ¢ , is actually a composite
guidebook consisting of three individual papers.

* 7 ” *

(Tr. 268] Q. Incidentally
y, what is the position
Donahoe at the University of Alabama? sae
A. She is an associate professor of geology.
i Q. Now, is it correct that in this study that you
ave done, you have made some comments on the frac-
— — faults and joints out at Emelle?
. Slight comment on that, r ; i
, rather specific comment
on work that we di arby : in FE ‘a
a we did nearby at Port Epps, in Epps, Ala-
Q. Is that Sumter County?
A. Right.
4 aa is significant about Port Epps?
. It’s an excellent exposure of th
P. | : e Selma ch
which we were able to visit and do our work at. ani
! Q. And would you tell us briefly how you may de-
scribe fractures and joints and faults? ,
A. Okay.
4 In whatever order you think appropriate.
A. A fracture is used by many geologists and en-
wn as kind of a general term. Properly it is a
agg and can be a fault with displacement parallel]
r. 269] to the surface, can be a joint with displace-
ment perpendicular to the surface,

29

So, with the paper, we tear it—

Q. Hold that up so the Court can see that. Would
you turn please and face the Court.

A. Okay. This qualifies as a fracture. Now, if it
does nothing more than this (Indicating), then it would
be known in the geological terminology as being a joint;
and a joint might move a little bit open, it might move
a fair amount open; so that would be a joint. And there
are joints in the Selma chalk. The other thing that the
fracture might do is move parallel to its face, in which
case it becomes classified as a fault in the geological
terminology. Faults may, as you can see with this one,
produce gaps and holes along the trend of the fault when
they move.

Q. Now, what you described, those fractures, faults
and joints, were they present in the Selma chalk?

A. They are.

Q. And is that what you have done your paper on?

A. Right.

* * * ad

(Tr. 274] Q. Now, I ask you to look at your paper be-
ginning the next page, Roman Numeral 421, and tell
us in layman’s language, and if you could, just give us
a quick summary of that.

A. Okay. Well, the subject was structures influencing
the permeability of the Selma group in western Alabama.
In the numerous exposures that we have worked on, in-
cluding the one at Epps, we find that there are faults
and joints fairly commonly in the Selma chalk. Both
of those are known geologically to be commonly capable
of transmitting water. So our question was, is there
(Tr. 275] any evidence that the fractures that we see in
this area are capable of transmitting water. And we
found considerable evidence that the faults do, at least
some of the faults do, transmit water. We found less
evidence that the joints transmit water; but the faults
transmit water because they do have holes along them
from place to place, and also some of them are fairly

EQ at OB SD OE Se FS We . Ml

ind ete

30

complex zones of multiple faults, which when they move
do exactly what this piece of paper does, which is they
don’t fit properly like that (Indicating), and consequently
develop holes along the fault zone. We collected some
of the fillings, because these faults are characterized by
having calcite fillings. We collected some of the fillings,
and some of them are completely filled and appear to be
nonconductive; others there are holes that you can stick
your pencil into, in these fillings, where it is simply an
incomplete filling. The fillings are calcite that was de-
posited from saturated fluids, presumably from deep un-
derground. The fillings also show evidence that they have
been subsequently chemically etched, which means they
have been attacked by unsaturated fluids which is char-
acteristic of shallow ground water. So, that is one of
the evidences that these faults are transmitting ground
water today. Other evidence is that they are [Tr. 276]
significantly stained by iron, and only the faults were
stained. We didn’t find evidence of that on the joints.
Of course, the fairly out in the field evidence is that the
water was leaking out of the faults in the outcrop and
the plants were growing on the faults in the outcrop
as opposed to no water leaking out of intact chalk, and
no plants growing on the intact chalk in this area. So
that is the basic evidence that we had.

Q. How deep do these faults and fractures extend
into the Selma chalk, in your opinion?

A. As far as we know, they could go completely
through the chalk. We really don’t know. No one knows.
as far as I am aware.

Q. Do you mean all the way down to the Eutaw
aquifer?

A. Perfectly possible.

Q. Now, is the area around the faults and fractures
more or less permeable than the chalk itself?

A. Well, I would judge that the fault zone itself would
be more permeable than the chalk itself. It could be
more permeable by many orders of magnitude.

31

Q. What do you mean by many orders of magnitude?

A. By factor of a thousand, factor of 10,000. It en-
tirely depends upon how big the hole is and whether it
has been completely filled or partially filled. oe
(Tr. 277] Q. Now, did you reach a conclusion in your
paper, reach an opinion back earlier this year as to
whether, in your opinion, the fractures, faults, rather,
at the Emelle facility had been properly mapped?

A. We find no evidence that they have been mapped.
There are certainly no maps that I have been able to see.
So, I would have to say that, to my knowledge, they have
not been properly mapped.

Q. At my request on Thursday of last week, Thursday
and Friday, did you review the Golder & Associates re-
ports which were identified and have been identified in
this case, some 12, I believe, and the two Woodward
Clyde reports which have been furnished us by the plain-
tiff which we, in turn, furnished you?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Now, after having reviewed those reports, do they,
in any way, affect that opinion you had reached back
in April?

A. Well, they confirm it in part. We inferred from
aerial photo studies that probably there were faults in
the pits at Emelle. Also we had photographs taken by
other people that showed the faults in the pits. The re-
ports confirmed that.

Q. Were those the pictures of trench 16, I think, that
were in the book?

(Tr. 278] A. That are in our book, right. So the re-
port did confirm the presence of the faults, and the
Woodward Clyde report, one of them, discussed doing
permeability tests on three of the faults, and their per-
meability tests showed, as far as they were concerned,
no difference in permeability on the faults than in the
rock around it, which doesn’t really alter my opinion,
because that would be true on the faults we saw our-
selves, depending upon where you measured the fault,

32

because the faults change their properties along the plain
of the fault. So, to actually document that the fault
doesn’t leak anywhere, you have to see the whole fault
and then you have to decide whether there are no holes
along the fault or whether, in fact, there is maybe, let’s
say, ona 50 foot exposure of a fault you might find two
significant holes six inches in length. So, I have no idea
whether the worst part of the fault was tested or not.
Q. Would there be anything in the Golder & Asso-
clates or these other two Woodward Clyde reports that
would indicate that had been done?

A. No. As far as I could tell, it was not done.

Q. What is your opinion, after having read these re-
ports, the 12 or so Golder & Associates reports and the
two Woodward Clyde reports?

[ Tr. 279] A. My opinion would be they really have no
idea whether the faults are potentially going to leak.

Q. Do you have an opinion as to whether the water
is moving laterally in the Selma chalk?

A. It certainly was in the exposures that we looked
at, otherwise we wouldn’t be able to see evidence of the
water moving out of the fault zones. I guess I really
don’t have an informed opinion about the waste site
itself.

Q. Now, did anyone pay for the paper that you pre-
pared, the time and effort that went into it?

Ln No; this was scientific research, just part of the
job.

Q. Originally who was to publish—

A. Originally this was to be published as a part of a
meeting related guidebook series to be published by the
State Geological Survey. ;
aun Did the State Geological Survey, in fact, publish

is?

A. Not this one, no.

Q. Was there any reason stated as to why not?

A. Nothing in writing. Informally I was told that
this was too controversial, they didn’t want to publish it.

33

Q. Who, in fact, did publish it, this paper?

A. The Alabama Geological Society, which is an or-
ganization | Tr. 280] of geologists.

Q. Of geologists here in Alabama?

A. Right.

Q. Approximately how many members?

A. Maybe a hundred and fifty.

Q. Are most geologists in Alabama members of that
society?

A. Probably the vast majority.

Q. Now, in your opinion, is it possible for the frac-
tures and faults to extend all the way down to the Eutaw
aquifer?

A. It is very possible. And we really don’t know why
those faults are there. Every place we have seen very
good exposures of the Selma chalk we tend to see the
faults. So, as far as I know, we have seen a fair amount
of it in different places.

Q. In your opinion, is it possible that the faults or
fractures that could extend vertically down into the Eutaw
aquifer, would they have increased permeability of sev-
eral orders of magnitude?

A. It is certainly possible.

Q. What about laterally at the surface?

A. It would be the same.

(Tr. 281] Q. Dr. Groshong, as I understand it, you did
not do a study of the Emelle facility; is that correct?

A. Not within the facility. We did a photo study, an
aerial photo, taken of the site.

Q. You did not do any studies on the ground or in
the ground at the facility?

A. No.

* o * *

(Tr. 282] Q. You have never done any hydrogeological
characterization of the Emelle facility; have you?
A. No,

|
i
|

|
1
|
|
|
|
|
)
.
|

a = -—-

SS ll ce

34

Q. All right, sir. You have also not done geochemi-
cal studies of the Emelle facility; have you?

* * * *

[Tr. 283] Q. Have you ever—I assume as a geologist
you have done permeability tests?

A. I haven’t done the test, no.

Q. You actually have never done a permeability test
of anything?

A. That’s true.

Q. Okay. Well, I guess you didn’t do any permeabil-
ity tests of any of this Selma chalk then; did you?
A. Nothing.

35
TESTIMONY OF BILL BROCK

[Tr.416] Q. Would you state your name, please?

A. My name is Bill Brock.

Q. What is your title?

A. I am the Director of the Alabama Emergency
Management Agency.

Q. What is the function of the Alabama Emergency
Management Agency?

A. My agency is one that controls, manages, monitors
any emergency situation that might occur within the state
of Alabama.

'Tr.417! Q. Well, would your agency have a role to
play, say, in the event of an accident on a highway?

A. Depending upon the severity and if it was an ac-
cident carrying some kind of hazardous material or
chemical! spills or volatile or explosive material.

Q. What about natural disasters?

A. Yes, sir, we are responsible for emergency re-
covery phase of any disaster.

Q. Mr. Brock, are you aware that Chemical Waste
Management operates a facility at Emelie, Alabama?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And that is located in Sumter County; is it not?

A. That’s correct, yes, sir.

Q. Are you aware that ChemWaste has a contingency
plan that has been introduced already as Defendant’s
Exhibit Number 55?

A. Yes, sir, I am.

Q. And the contingency plan identifies possible emer-
gencies that might occur on site; is that correct?

A. That is correct, yes, sir.

Q. And just briefly, isn’t it also correct that the
contingency plan identifies both emergencies that are
inherent to facilities operations, that is fires and acci-
dents and spills, as well as natural disasters that might
occur, such as tornadoes?

[Tr.418] A. AsT have read it, yes, sir.

36

Q. Now, would the Emergency Management Agency
play a role in the event of an emergency of any kind at
Emelle?

A. At Emelle or any other site if the emergency ex-
pands or continues to grow to the point it surpasses the
ability of that community, that subdivision, to handle it
themselves, at that point then we are there to dispatch
any other state or federal resources that are necessary in
the recovery or cleanup or any other problems that may
be occurring.

Q. In fact, the contingency plan identifies your agency
as the contact source; does it not?

A. That is correct, yes, sir.

Q. Are you familiar with the recent history of tor-
nadoes and severe thunderstorms in the Sumter County
area?

A. Yes, sir.

a And md for the last 12 months or so, can you tell
e Court whether there have been an
Sumter County? ae
A. According to our log book and the duty officers, we
maintain a duty cfficer 24 hours a day, and direct contact
by telephone and radio with the public safety people state-
wide in the region of the southeastern United States, and
also direct lines with the National Weather Service, and
any time a storm front approaches [Tr. 419] we are
notified and we have our own radar system that we mon-
itor these storms with as they develop and come in out
of > rege In the last 12 months in Sumter County
we have recorded 10 severe thundersto i
sae rm watches in Sum-
e be is a thunderstorm watch?
watch is a description issued or a cate i
gory is-
sued by the National Weather Service that said the Ae
system or cold front moving in has the potential of devel-
oping severe thunderstorms, that you need to be on the

37

Q. How does that contrast with a warning?

A. Well, in the stages as it progresses the watch oc-
curs and then when the storm starts developing and the
clouds start building in size and severity, at that point,
or some point in between, they say a severe thunderstorm
has formed. You see the intensity levels change on the
radar screen and that determines at the point a new
warning is issued, because you have seen a thunderstorm
cell build. Usually when the thunderstorm warning exists,
at that point the National Weather point will issue a
tornado watch. When the severity of the storm builds to
the point of level five or level six, the potential of a tor-
nado is forming or microbursts [Tr. 420] that are now
being identified as we have had in the last few weeks in
Alabama. They can form out of a severe thunderstorm
at any time without warning; so usually we will issue a
tornado watch at that point. Then when the tornado
watch is there, that immediately notifies us as well as the
meteorologist to be on the watch to watch those thunder-
storm cells as they travel across the state and to look
for any further development. If we see that, then a tor-
nado warning is then issued. A tornado warning can
also be issued when there is a definite hook symbol on the
radar screen or there has been a visual sighting of a
tornado.

Q. Now, you have your log book there; do you not?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. How many severe thunderstorm warnings have
been made for Sumter County in the last 12 months?

A. In the records that we maintain we had 10 thun-
derstorm watches, four of those turned into thunder-
storm warnings. Of the four thunderstorm warnings we
had eight tornado watches for Sumter County, with two
tornado warnings, which means there were at least two
tornadoes sighted. One was within a half a mile of the
Emelle facility in Sumter County.

38

Q. When did that occur?

A. The sighting of the tornado that was within half a
(Tr. 421] mile of the site, to my recollection, without
going back through the records, would be in the second
week of February.

Q. Of this year?

A. Of this year.

(Tr. 428]

Q. Would you indicate to the Court from this exhibit,
Number 60,— Would you tell the Court what accidents
(Tr. 429| have occurred involving vehicles destined for
Emelle since 1981?

A. Would you like for me to start at the top?

Q. Yes.

A. On 2/10/81 a truck carrying acid had run off I-20
spilling the material. EPA was not notified until 2/20,
some 10 days later. On 3/27/81,—

MR. DeBRAY: Judge, the exhibit has been offered,
and I assume it will be admitted into evidence. Is the
witness going to read this entire exhibit into the record?

THE COURT: Has the exhibit been—

MR. SIMON: We can move on, Your Honor. We
offer it in evidence.

THE COURT: All right, I will admit the exhibit over
their objection.

Q. Mr. Brock, do you have an opinion, based on your
experience, as to whether an increased number of trucks
going to Emelle would increase the likelihood of accidents?

MR. DeBRAY: Objection. He hasn’t laid the proper
foundation that this witness can give an opinion of that
nature.

THE COURT: Ask him if he can.

Q. Can you give an opinion on that, Mr. Brock?
[Tr. 430]
but Is not operated by AEC. c oug AEC

108
DEFENDANTS’ EXHIBIT 57

RESUME

NAME Richard Hughes Groshong, Jr.

HOME ADDRESS
14L Northwood Lake
Northport, Alabama 35476
Phone (205) 333-8326
OFFICE ADDRESS

Department of Geology

The University of Alabama
Tuscaloosa, Alabama 35487-0338
Phone (205) 348-1882

BORN August 10, 1943; Lakewood, Ohio
EDUCATION

B.S. Bucknell University, June 1965
Advisor: Richard P. Nickelsen

M.A. The University of Texas at Austin, August
1967
Advisor: Robert E. Boyer
Thesis: Geology and Fracture Patterns of
North-Central Burnet County, Texas
Ph.D. Brown University, June 1971
Advisor: William M. Chapple
Thesis: Strain in Minor Folds, Valley and
Ridge Province, Pennsylvania
PROFESSIONAL EMPLOYMENT
1970-1973 Assistant Professor, Syracuse University
1973-1976 Research Geologist, Cities Service Co.,
Tulsa

1976-1978

1978-1981

1981-1982

1981-1983

1983-1986

1986-
Fall 1988

109

Senior Research Geologist, Cities Service
Co., Tulsa

Manager, Structural Geology Research,
Cities Service Co., Tulsa

Adjunct Professor, Tulsa University,
Tulsa, Oklahoma

Senior Research Associate, Cities Service
Co., Tulsa

Associate Professor, The University of
Alabama

Professor, The University of Alabama

Visiting Chair d’honneur de |’Université
de Lausanne, Switzerland

PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS
The Geological Society of America (Fellow, 1982)
The American Geophysical Union
The American Association of Petroleum Geologists
Rocky Mountain Association of Geologists
Alabama Geological Society
Houston Geological Society

HONORS AND AWARDS

Fall 1988

1989-1990

Visiting Chair d’honneur de |’Université
de Lausanne

AAPG Distinguished Lecturer

110
DEFENDANTS’ EXHIBIT 68

PERSONNEL

TOM JOINER & ASSOCIATES, INC.
P. O. Box 5894
Tuscaloosa, AL 35405
Telephone: 205/345-2311

THOMAS J. JOINER,
CHAIRMAN AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER

Education: BS, MS—University of Alabama

Experience: 1981-Present

Chairman and founder of the firm, Mr. Joiner super-
vises and maintains responsibility for all geologic
and engineering studies and evaluation work per-
formed by the firm. His experience includes 25 years
of working with the geology in Alabama and the
southeast United States. He is very familiar with
oil and gas and industrial development in Alabama,
Florida and parts of Mississippi and Tennessee. He
coordinates project work and preparation of reports
for clients. Mr. Joiner spends much of his time rep-
resenting clients before Boards, Commissions and
legislative and congressional committees. He is ex-
perienced in presenting expert testimony In court
and before Oil and Gas Boards and Regulatory Com-
missions. Mr. Joiner served as Chairman of the
Technical Committee for the unitization of the Hat-
ter’s Pond Gas Field in Mobile County, Alabama for

Getty Oil Company.

1976-1981

State Geologist and Oil and Gas Supervisor—Directed
the program of the Survey and Board. Supervised
approximately 135 people working out of 4 offices.

111

Programs included basic and applied research in
water, minerals and energy, and environmental
problems associated in the development of re-
sources. The oil and gas responsibilities included
permitting and monitoring the oil and gas drilling
activity in the state and evaluating and approving
completion and production procedures.

1968-1976

Assistant Oil and Gas Supervisor—Director of techni-
cal operations for the State Oil and Gas Board
serving directly under the Oil and Gas Supervisor.
Duties included evaluation of petitions before the
Board concerning these matters. Acting on behalf
of the Supervisor in routine administrative oil and
gas matters. Directing field inspections and regu-
latory activities for the Board. Serving on energy
related committees, such as the Outer Continental
Shelf Research Advisory Committee, at the request
of the Governor and Oil and Gas Supervisor.

1961-1968

Chief, Paleontology, Stratigraphy and Geophysics Di-
vision—Geological Survey of Alabama. Work was
directly related to evaluation of geologic samples
from test wells, electric logs and geophysical data
to assess water, mineral and petroleum potential
in Alabama. Administrative duties included prep-
aration of agreements for cooperative projects
with other State and Federal Agencies, universi-
ties, cities, counties and private industry.

1957-1961

Carter Oil Company and Esso Standard Turkey Ine.
—both affiliates of Standard Oil Company of New
Jersey—Duties included geological and geophysical
investigations in search of oil and gas in Arkan-

sas, Louisiana, Oklahoma and a two year assign-
ment in Turkey.

1956-1957

U. S. Geological Survey—Groundwater investigation
in Alabama.

113
DEPOSITION OF LEIGH PEGUES

* * * *

Q. Prior to your testimony before the committee, had
you had any discussions with any legislators concerning
this bill?

A. Yes.

Q. Would you tell me who you had had discussions
with and when?

A. One time in Swift’s office he called me down there,
and there were some senators in the office. You probably
could describe them as floor leaders, and they were talk-
ing strategy on the bill, and I was in the meeting.

Q. To the best of your recollection, Mr. Pegues, would
you relate those discussions to me?

A. The discussions I had with it, I don’t think they
particularly asked me anything. I guess, again, I was
therefore a reference person. What probably was asked
of again about the six fifty. It was a typical floor leader
strategy meeting, and I am not one of those.

Q. When did that meeting take place?

A. Somewhere within a week of it coming up—a week
or ten days of it coming up in committee at FT.

Q. So this would have been before your testimony at
F&T?

A. That is correct.

Q. Was there any discussion in that meeting of the
lowering, the possible lowering of tonnage at the site?

A. No.

Q. Was there any discussion in that meeting of the
differential between in-state and out-of-state fees?

A. Yes.

Q. Tell me if you would to the best of your recollec-
tion what was said concerning the differential between
in-state and out-of-state fees.

A. To the best of my recollection, the discussion was
the strategy of the other side would be to make an all
out attempt to make the differential larger so they could
go in the court and fight it and give them a better op-
portunity.

114

Q. Do you recall what the differential was at the
time these discussions were being made?

A. No. :
Q. Was there any other discussion of the differential

between in-state and out-of-state fees?

A. I don’t know of any.

Q. Was there any discussion about lowering the
amount of out-of-state waste coming into Alabama?

A. No, not to my knowledge.

Q. Was there any discussion during the Senate Fi-
nance and Taxation Committee of lowering the amount
of out-of-state waste coming into Alabama by you or
any of the senators while you were present?

A. You have got to be more specific on that. I don t
understand. You know, we made the estimate of six
fifty. What are you asking me? :

Q. I am asking if during either your meeting in
Robin Swift’s office with the Senate floor leaders on in
the Senate Finance and Taxation Committee when you
testified if there was any discussion concerning the effect
of the fees being to lower the amount of out-of-state
waste?

A. Yes, I believe, and I think it was Senator Windom
mentioned the tonnage would probably be, according to
Waste Management, ninety to a hundred thousand tons,
and I believe he voiced he hoped that happened. And he
asked me. and I said, yes, I hope it does too. That was

all.

* * aa *

115

DEPOSITION OF BERNARD WEBB

* % * +.

Q. Just to back up for a second, while you were work-
ing in the insurance industry, were you ever involved in
any way the writing or the loss reserves or actuarial ex-
periences with insurance for hazardous waste disposal?

A. No.

Q. And from your recollection, what is the current
status of waste disposal technology and insurance for
waste disposal facilities?

A. It is currently developing. Very little actually is
known right now about the effectiveness of the tech-
nological things that are used right now in the process.

Q. All right, sir. What about insurance?

A. Insurance is for practical purposes almost un-
available. That is, the insurance that is available is very
limited in terms of amount. Essentially one company in
the United States is writing for waste disposal facilities
like Emelle. There are several others that write pollution
insurance for underground storage tanks for petroleum
people and things of that kind. But as far as hazardous
waste disposal site is concerned, one insurer writes some-
where in the neighborhood of a maximum of ten million
dollars of coverage. I have obtained different figures
from them at different times, but it is all in the vicinity
of ten million dollars.

Q. What company is that?

A. That’s the American International Group and
their principal pollution insurance company in the past
has been the National Union Fire Insurance Company.
They have recently formed another company which I
believe is AIG Pollution Insurance Company or words to
that general effect which may be replacing National
Union Fire, but I am not sure of that.

Q. You also indicated you had reviewed some insur-
ance industry publication?

A. Yes, sir.

116

Q. What specific publications have you reviewed?

A. I have several publications on the assessments of
pollution liability risks; The Availability of Pollution
Liability Insurance, Claims Administration and Pollution
Liability Insurance. I think there are three published by
AIRAC, A-I-R-A-C, which is an acronym for All Indus-
try Insurance Research Advisory Committee. There is
one published by the American Insurance Association
which is a trade association, and one published by an
industry advisory committee to the National Association
of Insurance Commissioners on the availability of pollu-
tion insurance, and one published by an organization in
the United Kingdom called, Insurance and Reinsurance
Research Group. Although it is published in the United
Kingdom, it deals with the U.S. pollution insurance ex-
posure.

Q. What did you determine from your review of the
insurance industry publications in terms of what you
felt was relevant to your task in this case?

A. That insurance is not available in amounts ade-
quate for the risk and that there is no significant com-
petition insofar as hazardous waste disposal facilities are
concerned. In other words, one company in the market.
It is also very expensive. What is available is very ex-
pensive, and it is frequently written on an indemnified
basis where the insured enters into a side agreement to
indemnify the insurance company for any claims they
pay.

Q. If it is entered on that indemnified basis from
your knowledge of the insurance industry, if the insured
goes belly up, the insurance company is still going to be
stuck with the coverage, are they not?

A. That’s correct, except they frequently require some
kind of security such as a letter of credit or something.

Q. But the insurance company would not be let off the
hook just because the insured’s indemnity wasn’t as good
as they thought it was to begin with?

117

A. That’s right. The insurance company would have
to take their chances on recouping.

& « x *

Q. What were you able to determine from the Chem
Waste insurance policies that you felt were relevant to
your task in this case?

A. The only thing that changed anything I already
knew actually was the fact that they limit some of their
—their gradual pollution coverage were higher than had
been indicated in the other documents I reviewed. It was
ten million per occurrence and ten million aggregate
rather than the three and six that I had found in other
documents.

Q. How long did you meet with Mr». Wood and the
other employees at Tom Joiner & Associates?

A. About two hours. I talked to Mr. Wood on the
phone at various times too.

Q. What as best as you can recall, what was the dis-
cussion in the two-hour meeting that you had at Tom
Joiner & Associates?

A. The various occurrences which might result in the
migration of pollutants out of the Emelle facilities into
other places and possible remediation cost.

Q. Can you be a little more specific about both of
those categories?

A. Yes. And probably a little more general as well.
We also discussed the potential for accidents while haz-
ardous wastes are being transported to and in some cases
from the Emelle facility. We talked about the possibility
of contamination of the aquifer under the Selma chalk,
the possibility of earthquake damage releasing pollutants,
hazardous materials, the possibility of tornado damages
to the tanks, particularly the surface tanks where PCB’s
and leachate are stored. We also talked about the possi-
bility of sabotage or terrorist attack on the facility, or
just simple carelessness on the part of employees or
mechanical failure, or the acts of a possible disgruntled

118

employee who might potentially release hazardous waste
into the environment, things of that general nature..

Q. Would it be fair to say that this was a brain storm-
ing session?

A. To a large degree that would be a fair characteri-
zation of it. We did get fairly specific. I asked them to
give me estimates of remediation cost for three specific
scenarios. One would be the possibility that a tank truck
loaded with PCB’s would go out of control and crash in
say the Warrior River releasing its cargo into the river.
Another one would be the possibility that I had already
mentioned of a tornado striking the tanks and scattering
PCB’s around the area. And the third one was the con-
tamination of the Eutaw aquifer.

Q. Did they come up with cost estimates?

A. A range of estimates. They indicated that the cost
of remediation insofar as possible to remediate in the
ease of the truck in the Warrior River would be measured
in the tens of millions of dollars; that is, it would be
somewhere between ten million and ninety-nine million.
Also it would not be possible to completely remediate that
because it would wash on downstream, and there would
be other nonfinancial losses along the way; loss of the
use of the river for various purposes, loss of fisheries, and
things of that nature.

In the case of the tornado striking the PCB tanks, they
estimated that at somewhere between a hundred thirty-
six million, which I believe they indicated was a figure
developed by somebody at Chemical Waste Management,
but I don’t know the details on that, up to a maximum
of one and nine-tenths billion, depending on how wide-
spread—how widely the tornado spread the PCB’s. And
again it would not be possible to completely remediate the
damage, so it might be additional losses in terms of
PCB’s washing into the rivers or soaking into the soil or
some of those things.

Q. What about the third?

119

A. The pollution of the aquifer, they did not come up
with figures. They said it was virtually incalculable. It
would be measured in billions, but they were not able to
come up with a precise figure, that it could be many
billions. Again, you have the same situation where it
might be a loss of the use of the aquifer or the water
from the aquifer to the extent it could not be fully
remediated.

Q. Was there anything else that was discussed at this
brainstorming meeting or that you had discussed with
Mr. Wood in phone calls subsequent to that?

A. We have discussed in fairly general terms the
possibility of hazardous waste migrating through the
Selma chalk and into the Eutaw structure.

Q. Can you elaborate on that?

A. Yes. We have discussed the possibility that there
may be—already be fissures or cracks, whatever you want
to call them, in the chalk that might permit the migration
of hazardous materials or the possibility of that since
fissures might result from earthquake activity there.

Q. Have you or to your knowledge has anyone with
Mr. Joiner attempted to quantify that possibility?

A. To the best of my knowledge it has not been
quantified, no.

Q. Have either of the other two scenarios, the tanker
truck wrecking in the Warrior River or the tornado strik-
ing the storage tanks, have the possibility of those occur-
rences been quantified to your knowledge by either you
or anyone at Tom Joiner & Associates?

A. I don’t think they are precisely quantifiable. There
have been a number of truck accidents involved. I have
seen a list of them, a relatively small number as I recall,
twenty or so. I am not sure of the exact number right
now. None of them went into the Warrior River, but it
is a possibility. There have been six reported tornadoes
in Sumter County between 1950 and 1989, so the prob-
ability—actually the probability of either of those hap-
pening is relatively small. It is just not something I

120

would anticipate happening once a year or anything like
that. But they could happen. There is no way really to
calculate the probability of a tornado hitting a specific
small area.

. * ~ a

Q. Have you reached any opinions or conclusions re-
garding this particular case?

A. Yes. I have reached a conclusion that the State
of Alabama has a very substantial financial exposure to
possible losses arising out of the operation of the Emelle
facility and that those financial losses could be into the
billions of dollars.

Q. All right, sir. On what do you base your opinion
first that the State has substantial! financial exposure, and
then later we will get into how you get to the amount
of it?

A. All right. The State appears to be the pocket of
last resort you might say. After everything else is ex-
hausted, the State will probably be required to put up
the money to correct any general pollution resulting
from—when I say general, I mean in terms of area—
resulting from the operation of the Emelle facility. Also
the State will at the very minimum have the residual
responsibility thirty years after the facility is closed and
quite possibly before if Chemical Waste Management
should become insolvent. The State of course also has
other exposures besides the financial exposure in terms
of the quality of life to the people of Alabama and things
of that nature in the event of serious pollution arising
from the facility. But the financial exposure alone could
well be into the billions.

Q. Let me see. Are these really the bases of your
opinion that the State has substantial financial exposure,
the pocket of last resort and that it may have residual
responsibilities after the facility is closed?

A. That plus the fact that I understand the State
holds title to the hazardous waste that were put into the
facility prior to 1985 which might give them a more im-
mediate liability.

121

Q. All right, sir. In what ways, if any, do the vari-
ous list of, if I can call them the list of horribles, the
horrible things that can happen, how do those factor into
your opinion and conclusion if at al]?

A. They factor in in terms of trying to put a maxi-
mum on the State’s exposure. Unsuccessful in that at-
tempt, because we are unable to quantify the worst one
of all, but trying to see what the potential exposures
were given some very serious scenarios.

Q. And in coming up with the figure of a billions of
dollars, is that based upon your discussions with the
folks at Tom Joiner & Associates?

A. Yes. That’s their evaluation or statement of
potential.

* * * *

Q. Have you in any way attempted to differentiate
in your conclusions between waste that is generated
within the State of Alabama and waste that comes from
outside the State of Alabama?

A. No.

* a * ~

Q. And in your scenario number one where you had
the tank truck with PCB’s going into the Warrior River
or you and Tom Joiner & Associates came up with a cost
of remediation of ten to ninety-nine million dollars, that
might well be the same if that tanker truck was loaded
with some chemical product and it ran off the bridge into
the Warrior River; isn’t that true?

A. Depending on the chemical, it could be, yes.

* + ye a

Q. Mr. Webb, in going back to the three scenarios
that you testified to, the first scenario is about the tank
truck that crashes into the river. In terms of either the
relative probability of that occurring or the cost of. re-
mediation it is not going to matter from your standpoint
whether that tanker truck comes from Georgia or Ala-
bama, is it?

A. No, not at all.

122

Q. And the same is true concerning the tornado strik-
ing the PCB tanks? It doesn’t matter from your analysis
whether those PCB’s came from Georgia or Alabama
initially?

A. That’s correct.

Q. And finally on the last scenario of horribles that
you came up with, the contamination of the Eutaw
aquifer, that also does not differ based upon whether the
contaminant that gets into the Eutaw aquifer originally
came from Alabama or Georgia or some other state; is
that correct?

A. That’s correct.

. - o *

Q. Now, your opinion that the State has substantial
financial exposure ultimately—I think the words you used
were the State is the pocket of last resort; is that correct?

A. Yes, that’s correct.

Q. Would it matter in your opinion or conclusion
what earlier pockets were available?

A. Yes. If the earlier pockets had sufficient resources
to absorb any potential loss, then the State would have
less risk.

Q. Now, I believe you indicated your general under-
standing of CERCLA or Superfund is that in some cir-
cumstances generators of waste may be held liable for
cleanups; is that correct?

A. That’s correct.

Q. Have you attempted to determine the list or a
listing or a review of the generators that have sent waste
to Chemical Waste Management?

A. No.

Q. Would that have an impact on your conclusion;
that is, if some of these generators in fact had pretty
deep pockets?

A. Depending on the extent of their contribution to
the problems it might, but it is my understanding there
are a large number of generators who have waste stored
at Emelle. And that of course reduces the possibility of

123

recovering from anybody because it almost certainly
would be surrounded with long and lengthy—long and
involved litigation before anybody paid anything.

* * * .

Q. Mr. Webb, we were about to break, and then it
appears that perhaps I have not yet elicited all of your
opinions or conclusions. Have you reached any other opin-
ions or conclusions other than the ones you have testified
to earlier today?

A. Yes. There is one. I was asked what amount of
insurance I would recommend the State of Alabama buy
if such insurance were available. I concluded that I would
recommend limits of one billion dollars.

Q. Limits of one billion?

A. Yes.

Q. How did you arrive at that figure?

A. From reviewing the scenarios that we discussed
earlier and other information regarding the cost of re-
mediation at various Superfund sites.

Q. Have you attempted to determine whether that
insurance might be available?

A. It is not available.

Q. So I take it you have determined that, and it is
not available?

A. That’s correct.

- * . *

Q. If I ask you, Mr. Webb, to assume as a hypotheti-
cal that one of the pockets of earlier resort as we have
been using the term concerning the Emelle facility is the
United States of America, would that have any impact
on your conclusion?

A. I think they are a reliable pocket, and therefore
if they were fully responsible for it, the State would have
a very smal] financial exposure. They may still have the
exposure for quality of life and things of that kind, but
their financial exposure would be very small.

Q. It certainly wouldn’t be anything like the one bil-
lion dollars—again, assuming my hypothetical, it wouldn’t

124

be anything like the one billion dollars that you testified
to?

A. That’s correct. In that hypothetical situation, the
State would not need that much protection.

. o *

Q. Professor Webb, you were asked a question a few
moments ago about insurance at which time you opined
that the State of Alabama should have an insurance policy
in the one billion dollar range if such a policy were
available. Do you recall that testimony?

A. Yes, I do.

Q. Do you have an opinion of the amount of the
insurance premium for such a policy assuming such a
policy were available?

A. If the insurance were available, I would estimate
that the premium for it would be in the range of a hun-
dred to a hundred fifty million dollars a year.

Q. How did you arrive at that estimate?

A. From looking at what is charged for what is avail-
able and general knowledge of how the insurance indus-
try operates and how that might translate into a premium
for a larger policy.

Q. You were asked questions by Mr. Wells about
whether you had previously performed risk management
services in the hazardous waste industry. Do you remem-
ber those questions?

A. Yes,I do.

Q. Based upon your experience as a risk manager, is
it necessary for a risk manager in the insurance industry
to be an expert in hazardous waste industry in order to
reach the conclusions that you testified about today?

A. No, it is not necessary, because the principles of
risk management that apply to hazardous waste manage-
ment apply to other areas. It is simply the technical de-
tails that differ. So the risk manager who understands
the principles of risk management would then rely on
experts in waste management for the technical detail.

125

Q. In response to questions by Mr. Wells concerning
the 10-K form of Chem Waste, as I recall you mentioned
that approximately thirty percent of the net worth was
shown to be goodwill and that thirty-six percent of the
net worth was reflected in their 10-K as land purchased
at cost. Do you recall that testimony?

A. Yes, I do.

Q. What is the significance of those percentages to
you insofar as analyzing Chem Waste’s overall situation?

A. Those have no market value in a bankruptcy situ-
ation was the thought behind it so that in the case of a
bankruptcy situation the available net worth to meet
Chemical Waste Management’s obligations would be re-
duced by at least two-thirds, quite possibly more but at
least two-thirds.

Q. So your opinion with respect to the liability the
State has as a result of Emelle would be based upon the
hazards only at Emelle; is that correct?

A. That's correct.

Q. And the fact that there are risks other places does
not diminish the risk at Emelle?

A. That’s correct.

Q. You referred to some resource books that you
looked at concerning earthquakes in Sumter County?

A. Yes.

Q. Are these generally recognized as authoritative
sources that you were referring to?

A. Yes, they are.

Q. And how many earthquakes do they reflect had
occurred in Sumter County?

A. Only one of them mentioned earthquakes in Sumter
County, and it mentioned two.

Q. Were those both in the 1986 time frame?

A. February of 1886. They were on February 4 and
February 13, 1886.

126

Q. Excuse me. I did of course mean 1886. Are you
aware of any reports that the earthquakes actually
caused the ground to move up and down by a foot?

A. Yes. There was a report in the Sumter County
newspaper that indicated that the ground at Moscow
rose a foot and then returned to its original position.
There was a report—the report in the Mobile paper in-
dicated that it rose a half a foot, so I don’t know which
one of those is correct.

a7 ood * *

Q. Mr. Webb, Are you aware of any studies subse-
quent to the 1886 earthquake that in any way indicate
that that earthquake compromised the integrity of the
Selma chalk?

A. No, sir.

127

DEPOSITION OF RODGER HENSON

* + * 7

A. My understanding is that nobody knows how long
a synthetic liner will last. And I have always maintained
since the outset of synthetic liners that synthetic liners
are not the thing that will stop hazardous waste migra-
tion in the Selma chalk.

It is the Selma chalk itself, which is infinitely better
than any synthetic liner could ever be. So I don’t know
how long a synthetic liner would last.

I do know that the Selma chalk has been there for
100,000,000 years, and probably will be there for at
least that much longer.

* aa * *

Q. What is your understanding of the length of
time, currently, of the post-closure period?

A. My understanding is that it is 30 years after
closure.

Q. Yes, sir.

A. My understanding may be wrong.

Q. But in other words, there is a period, which I be-
lieve is 30 years is what I have been hearing.

A. There is a period after closure of any hazardous
waste facility, that is called the post-closure period.

Q. for which a company has the responsibility as
mandated by EPA to be involved with the monitoring or
general liability for the landfill facility?

A. That is correct.

Q. But presently, there is no law or regulation in
place mandating such monitoring or control or liability
of the operator or owner of the landfill facility post-
closure, longer than thirty years?

A. Thirty years is the number that I am familiar
with.

Q. All right. And let me ask you this: Are you aware
of any funding by ChemWaste or its parent company of

128

post-closure responsibilities or possible liabilities for
longer than 30 years?

A. No.

- * - o

A. I would say that the facility should last at least
100 years at current rates.

Q. Capacity?

A. Maybe more.

Q. Yes, sir. This is the largest, certainly the largest
landfill hazardous waste burial or storage facility in the
United States at the present time, isn’t it, at Emelle?

A. Yes, it is.

* * * o

Q. Now with the Fee Bill enacted, and increased fees,
I understand that the hazardous waste has decreased?
You have covered tnat?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. What is the effect of that decrease upon the out-
of-state current generators? What are their options now?
A. Their options are to take it somewhere else.

Q. Where it is cheaper?

A. Where the tax is less.

Q. Yes. Do they have an option also to operate their
facility so as to reduce the amount of hazardous waste
generated?

A. They can do that, but I suspect that is not what is
happening now, because it takes time to develop those
waste reductions.

Q. The waste—

A. The waste minimization programs don’t happen
overnight.

There is probably some of that going on.

Q. Asa result of the increased fees?

A. Yes.

o * * 7.

There is water and it is waste at Emelle, created by

rainfall.

129

Q. And in addition, there is leachate?

A. In addition, there is leachate.

Q. What was the cost in 1989, the approximate cost
of the pumping, gathering, collection, and transportation,
storage and transportation, of the ground water, waste
water, or leachate as we have discussed earlier, from
the Emelle facility?

A. Ten to fifteen million gallons at twenty cents a
gallon.

Q. So we are talking about a total cost of approxi-
mately two million to three million dollars a year?

A. Yes.

Q. Now as I understand it, there are also monitoring
costs with respect to the Emelle operation?

A. Yes.

Q. What was the extent of the approximate amounts
of the monitoring costs that have been incurred with that
in 1989?

A. Oh, let’s say 50 samples a quarter, and those
analyses vill run from $100 to $300 per.

Q. Were there any other monitoring costs?

A. Not that I can think of.

Q. Do you have any personnel who are engaged full
time at Emelle with respect to monitoring activities?

A. Yes. There is a crew of four chemists and tech-
nicians who do that.

Q. So would what be a—?

A. So technicaily speaking, their time, at least part
of their time should be allotted to the monitoring costs.
They do other things as well.

Q. What proportion?

A. Half of their time.

Q. And the facility, there is some proportion of the
cost of operation of whatever laboratory it is they use;
or is that included in the sampling cost?

A. The laboratory that is used is offsite.

Q. So all totaled, thinking about those items, and the
payment of the offsite laboratory facilities, and appro-

130

priate 50 percent or whatever portion of the chemists,
the four chemists’ salaries and fringe benefits, et cetera,
the various samples; approximately what type of costs
were you speaking of in 1989?

A. Well, I don’t have my caiculator with me.

Q. May I give you a sheet of paper.

A. I said 50 times 4; that is about 200 samples.
That is an approximation. That is based on the number
of wells and how often we have to sample them. So if it
costs $100 a sample, that would be $20,000. If it cost
$300 a sample, that would be $60,000. Chemists time,
half the chemists time; let see. If you paid him—half
the chemists time would be probably another $50,000.
So that is $110,000. I’d say $100,000 to $150,000.

_ - * *

131

DEPOSITION OF JOHN HANLEY (PART 1)

* * * *

Q. Explain to me again—I have got away from this,
and I am little vague on it now, but would you explain
to me the factors as to pricing with respect to location?

A. Location, there are only in reality, even though
there is some 30-odd landfills in the United States, about
half of those have some kind of permitting problem or
some small nature of problem, so they’re not really via-
ble. That leaves some 15. Out of the other 15, I think
there are only probably eight to ten today in the entire
United States, that can receive all the waste that is gen-
erated that is going to landfill.

So you basically have eight to ten landfills serving
some 50 states.

* * * .

Q. What amount of cleanup would you say, what
percentage of your 1989 tonnage, came from cleanup
operations as you have just described, as opposed to
currently generated waste? And I’m speaking of Emelle.

A. 70 to 90 percent.

* * - *

Q. It is also the opinion of industry that the hazard-
ous waste treatment and disposal industry that the
amount of hazardous waste being generated itself will
certainly decrease?

A. Absolutely.

Q. Why is that?

A. There is more technology. There is better tech-
nology. There is more pressure on the industry. Ninety-
five percent of all hazardous waste generated today is
either recycled, detoxified, neutralized, incinerated within
the facility of a process of which it is generated. Only
five percent of the material ever leaves the facility to go
outside to a commercial facility.

132

Q. So roughly non-hazardous waste, non-PCB waste,
just regular solid waste, would be about 25 percent in

1989?
A. Non-hazardous was 25 percent, PCB’s were 25.

RCRA waste was approximately 50, I believe.

+ * * #

A. Do you want to know how many trucks come into
the facility each year?

Q. (BY MR. NETTLES) Yes, in 1989.

A. 40,000—she is correct, that is close enough.

Q. So we are talking about approximately 40,000
truck loads coming into Emelle during 1989?

A. All right.

Q. On the basis of allocating the approximately
800,000 tons of waste landfilled there, and dividing that
by the 20—approximately 20 tons per truck?

A. Correct.

A. We ship aqueous waste water to Texas, to Corpus
Christi. That is rainwater.

Q. Describe how that is developed or what that comes
from?

A. Any rainwater that hits on any active area, any
tank or roofs inside the cell, we collect and pump it all
to one tank farm, a six million gallon tank farm.

And then as the rain accumulates, or the water accu-
mulates, we ship it by truck to Corpus Christi, Texas,
for disposal.

Q. Is that a ChemWaste facility in Corpus Christi?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Approximately how many truck loads would you
ship out per month, of the aqueous waste water, or rain-
water?

A. We haven’t shipped any in two months.

Q. Per year? What would you have handled in
1989?

133

A. We generally accumulate somewhere between—I
think the low point was nine million, and somewhere
between nine and fourteen million gallons a year of
water that we collect.

Q. In other words, this 200,000, approximately
200,000 tons of industrial waste, disposed of at Emelle
last year, was industrial waste as distinguished from
garbage or trees or things such as that?

A. Yes. That could have been disposed in those other
landfills. In a nonregulated landfill.

Q. At that time?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. But because of the potential liability of the—

A. Of future regulation changes, they choose to come
to Emelle.

Now, the back side to that is these new wastes, even
though now they are hazardous by characteristic, we can
treat them, take away the characteristic, and we can send
them to a solid waste landfill or what you eall a garbage
landfill.

We can do that next week or the next or the next.
Once you remove the characteristics and it’s nonhazard-
ous forever, then you can go ahead and put it in a sub-
title D landfill. And that’s probably what most genera-
tors are going to do.

Q. Assuming there is not some drastic current change
in regulations on down the line, not presently.—

A. This will clear it. This will totally clear it, be-
cause it’s toxie only by characteristic, not by the defini-
tion of hazardous, so you remove the characteristic, it no
longer is a hazardous waste for ever more.

Q. Explain to us the other side of the coin. What
hazardous waste is there that remains hazardous even
though it may be treated?

A. Once hazardous, always hazardous. That’s by EPA
definition. It’s because the metals—that’s by the chemi-

134

eal content of the waste. Once hazardous, it’s always
hazardous. You cannot ever remove the code.

Q. I ask you to look at page 24 of the report. With
respect to a strategy for addressing long-term post-
closure concerns, are you aware of whether or not EPA
has developed a strategic plan for addressing that issue
as described in the first two paragraphs there?

A. Well, aside from that, I know that we basically are
responsible for some thirty years. At the same time, we
also know and recognize and accept that if EPA changes
the regulations and extends that period or requires us
to do something other than what is currently specified,
then we have to comply with that by law and by the
regulations.

And I firmly believe that our company is prepared to
do that financially and in any other effort that is re-
quired. They can change the thirty years to sixty years
if EPA so chooses, and we would still have to comply.

Q. I ask you to look at page 26 in conjunction with
your last testimony. I think this ties in. Look at the
last sentence of the paragraph there on 26 of this GAO
report, Exhibit 14.

“It is generally assumed that the post-closure main-
tenance and monitoring period will be longer than thirty
years but EPA currently does not have firm plans for
extending the post-closure care period at hazardous waste
facilities.”

Now, I gather that sentence, at least, jives with your
understanding that the present post-closure maintenance
and monitoring period is no longer the thirty years?

A. Currently, it is thirty years, but we recognize that
they may change that. It was some eight or ten years
ago when that was made and wherever they change and
wherever they move the regs, we know that we have to
go with that.

It’s not a secret that EPA is under some criticism
from more than one source, i.e., the super fund and the

135

management of it and how they’ve done it, how they’ve
handled their money, and that’s obvious, that’s in the
press today.

You know, you have to pick and choose your own
news articles. But, yes, I believe the company believes
that it will be extended beyond the thirty years.

Q. What funds, if any, are presently being set aside
to fund the post-closure maintenance and monitoring and
general liabilities that may occur beyond thirty years?

A. I cannot answer that. That part of the inter-
rogatories was prepared by one of our attorneys. And I
chose not to read it before I came. Prior to that I did
not know exactly where the moneys were. I’ve never
asked the question before.

* > - *

What is the purpose of the monitoring?

To insure that there is no migration.

By migration, de you mean leakage?

Well, if you want to call it leakage, yes.

Is that just another similar synonymous term?
We don’t use leakage, because we don’t have any.
We use migration. But that’s for tracking. In setting a
background over a period of years to go ahead and test,
the main thing that you need to do in our industry as far
as monitoring is to insure that you have a great under-
standing of the background information.

Q. In 1989 approximately what was the cost to Chem-
Waste with respect to the Emelle facility in providing the
company-handled or paid monitoring services that you
have described?

A. Internalized I think it’s four or five—five people
that—it’s in excess of a million dollars a year.

Q. That would include your internal employees plus
your outside consultants?

A. Yes, sir. Depends on how far you want the pro-
gram to go. If youp want to cover any MPDS, which is
the point discharge, it has going to be tested for a water

PO PO PO

136

sample and all that stuff, it could be even higher than
that, because I think that consultant fee that set up
was over a half a million dollars.

Q. So you’re talking about over a million plus addi-
tionally—

A. Yes, it could be additions to that.

Q. —another half a million?

A. Right.

Q. I'm trying to get a handle, like on the trucks while
ago, of the total cost internally or externally paid on an
annual basis taking last year—

A. I would be comfortable in saying it’s well over a
million dollars. The numbers I can always get. I don’t
try to remember it but I know it’s in excess of a million
dollars a year.

Q. I gather probably in excess of a million and one
half?

A. Yes, sir, I believe it is.

* * * *

Q. Okay. Would you agree that the higher the fee or
tax imposed by the state the less hazardous waste would
be sent into Alabama for disposal?

A. I wouldn’t agree—I don’t agree with it, but it’s
certainly effective in making it here that way since the
tax was effected. It appears to us at this time, which is
only about four or five weeks, that it has reduced our
volume of business and whether portions of it are at-
tributable to the tax or they changed the regulations, I
don’t know at this time. But I’m sure it has had an
effect on it, yes.

Q. But you don’t know the extent of that effect?

A. We don’t know that yet. I think the worse month
or the month that can really, will tell us how significant
it is will be in October.

Q. In October?

A. I think October will be the true reflection with a
significance on how significant it has been.

137

Q. What about September? How are the receipts
running at this time?

A. About 50 percent, 40 to 50 percent of normal.

Q. Of what they were last September or what they—

A. Roughly, yes.

* a * *

Q. (BY MR. NETTLES) With respect to volumes,
increases and decreases in volumes of hazardous wastes
received at the Emelle facility in August thus far and
September, have you noticed any increase or decrease
with respect to in-state generating of hazardous waste?

A. No, none. I don’t notice that that has affected in-
State very much at all.

Q. Okay.

A. But it’s not—in-state has never been a large con-
tributor anyway.

* o ” a

A. The most we’ve ever handled—most we've ever
handled was about three fifty.

Q. Three hundred and fifty trucks in a day?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. What's the average?

A. The average, you know, I really can’t tell you.
We gave you how many loads or how many tons we did
in a year. But there is no average it can be. Like right
now, it’s only twenty-two—twenty-three for everything
all day. You know, on other days it could be around
sixty or seventy.

. * * *

138

DEPOSITION OF JOHN HANLEY (PART 2)

” od * *

But basically this trench here is on automatic pumping
system. And it goes underground up to this tank. In
addition to that, the water that is caught through the
truck wash every time we wash a vehicle, that water is
captured and also goes to the tank farm.

And these buildings, which is the seven hundred and
the seven oh two, anything that is contained in ramps or
concrete or any of the rainfall that hits on these, it’s also
captured and pumped underground up to—I’m sorry—
up to the tank farm.

Any active area that collects any type of liquid waste
from rain or from anything at all goes to this tank farm,
and that’s where we store it and that’s a six million
gallon tank farm.

* * . *

Q. So is it not correct that to that extent, to the
extent of the aqueous waste water, and particularly the
leachate or waste water that is pumped out of trench
twenty-one, you have ChemWaste actually being a waste
or hazardous waste generator?

A. That is correct.

7 o * *

Q. And so would you say that then permanent de-
struction of hazardous waste is not achieved through
buria! or disposal at Emelle?

A. Permanent destruction?

Q. Yes.

A. There is only one way known today to have per-
manent destruction, and it’s still not permanent destruc-
tion for the entire amount of volume that’s created, and
that is incineration. And you still have the residues and
ashes and the same thing and the same waste codes are
still there and they never go away by definition of the
strictest interpretation.

* * * *

139

A. * * * But Alabama only generates sixty-eight,
sixty-nine thousand tons a year.

* * * *

Q. As I understand it from ADEM docket number
OA50 there were some eleven spills at the Chemwaste
facility at Emelle in 1989? At or involved with the
Emelle facility?

A. That’s possible. Keeping in mind that a spill
could be less than a pint.

. * ~~ *

Q. Now the records we have indicate there were only
two spills in 1988, one in 1987, two in 1986, two in 1985
and one each in 1984 and 1983?

A. Okay.

Q. Assuming the accuracy of that and assuming that
there were in fact eleven spills in 1989, do you have any
opinion as to the reason for the increase in spills in 1989?

A. Two reasons. Number one, there was a greater
awareness on our part internally from our policies and
procedures of reporting everything. It’s just like in acci-
dents and incidents or anything else, we have an incident
review board that meets every Friday morning, that cov-
ers every incident you can think of that may have oc-
curred on that site, whether safety, environmental or
whatever. And we review these each week.

What may not have been reportable in ’83, ’84, ’85, ’86
now is certainly reportable within the site policies and
procedures. And then those that are currently reportable
by quantity to ADEM or EPA.

Certainly there is a greater awareness of that also.
And I think those two reasons is the reason that you may
see a significant increase in those reportable quantities.
Many of the reportables in 1989 primarily should have
been charged to some of the transporters, not Chemical
Waste at that facility because we were doing the reports
and signing them.

140

This year we've made a different procedure. If a trans-
porter brings it in and it’s leaking, it belongs to him. He
must report it himself.

Q. This part of the year so far, how many spills
reportable or attributable to Emelle, to the ChemWaste
operation of Emelle, how many to your knowledge have
you required to be reported by the transporter?

A. I don’t want to venture off the top of my head.
I know the number of spills that we have had.

Q. How many?

A. Relatively small, three or four I think.

* . * -

A. * * * All of the geologic studies that we do and
all of the information that we receive—you've got to
understand these—it’s only been ten years since this
whole industry started.

People are continuing to learn about leachate and water
pressures and secondaries. They don’t even know how to
estimate this. Nobody does. So there are studies ongoing
every day all across the United States, not only at Chem-
Waste, about how all of those things function.

And as things change, as the regulations change, as
our information from our own consultants becomes better
or over a longer period, then we all have to listen to that
and do what we think is best. But there is not a defini-
tive answer.

If there is a definitive answer, it needs to come from
an expert consultant. But we are very flexible with that
and we continue to study those numbers.

Q. And as you said the technology is constantly im-
proving?

A. Absolutely.

” 7. * of

Q. Is it your testimony then that in your opinion
Emelle is a safe site because of the fact that ADEM and
EPA are monitoring it and that they are requiring that
whoever operates it operate it in accordance with their
existing regulations?

141

A. That’s a portion of it, yes.

Q. But you do recognize that the state of art is always
changing with respect to the hazardous waste industry?

A. The state what?

Q. The state of the art is always changing with re-
spect to the hazardous waste industry?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. That all the environmental risks may be imper-
fectly known at this time?

A. That’s a possibility.

Q. Now, you said that you have had a reduction in
the amount of waste brought to Emelle in the past month
or so since the fee act became law?

A. Right.

Q. The effect of that is, would you agree, to cause
the generators of waste to seek other means of either
disposing of waste or means of minimizing the waste
that they generate?

A. I’ve stated once before that ten percent of what
we call generators or owners contribute ninety to ninety-
two percent of all the waste that comes to our facility.

Those are clean-up projects. These are wastes and
contaminated soils that have been generated over the last
fifty or sixty years before there was any recognition that
the environment was being contaminated or lands were
being contaminated.

The generators of today in the last five years have
done a heck of a job in minimizing their waste. Only
five percent of all the waste generated in the United
States ever leaves the facility in which it is generated.

The other ninety-five percent is recycled, neutralized,
detoxified, or whatever. It’s the clean-up from fifty years
that generates the mass volumes of waste.

* * * *

142

DEPOSITION OF WILLIAM BRUMUND

»- * * *

Q. So am I correct in saying that the Love Canal and
the problems resulting from the Love Canal cleanup in
the mid and late 1970’s really was sort of a catalyst for
the development of what we now look upon as hazardous
waste technology and regulations?

A. It certainly focused the nation’s awareness on a
particular set of problems which probably had not been
addressed directly before.

* * * *

Q. In your opinion, would you think—Based upon
your expertise, your education, your background, and
knowing generally, I assume, the topography of North
Carolina, in your opinion would there somewhere within
the state of North Carolina be a site that would be appro-
priate—meet the various regulations and design for gov-
ernment and design standards necessary for the invest-
ment a commercial hazardous waste landfill?

A. I think that from an engineering standpoint, you
can engineer a facility to meet the regulations for a haz-
ardous waste facility in North Carolina.

Q. Would that be true of most of the states in the
United States?

A. I think so.

Q. Can you think of any states generally that it would
not be true of?

A. When you say meets the regulations, probably not,
but I think there are some states which are not well suited
to the disposal of hazardous waste because I fundamen-
tally believe in geologic containment as opposed to en-
gineer containment.

Florida, which is a sandbox, has high groundwater
table, and water is a precious commodity down there.
Saline-free water is a more vulnerable area from the
standpoint of locating hazardous waste facilities.

Q. How about North or Northwest Florida?

143

A. It starts to get better, but there’s a lot of Florida
that isn’t that way.

Q. But do I understand you correctly that in your
opinion that aside from the engineering aspects from the
natural sites that would be available, that generally in
every state of the United States, there would be a suitable
landfill site available for the disposal of hazardous waste
in the landfill operation?

A. Well, I’m uncomfortable trying to generalize like
that, I think that, as I said, given a site somewhere in
a state, a design can be developed to meet the current
standards. Whether or not it’s as good as sites in other
states, we have to look at the specifics of each.

Q. Do you think there are sites available in other
states as good as the one at Emelle for the disposal, burial,
storage of hazardous waste landfill?

A. Well, of the sites I’ve seen in the United States
and elsewhere in the world, I think Emelle has many
desirable features. It has a lot going for it. In my opin-
ion, it’s one of the best geologic sites I’ve ever seen.

* 7 * *

Q. Is it not correct that hazardous waste and the
storage of hazardous waste generally presents a greater
environmental risk or problem on the one hand than the
disposal landfill of solid waste on the other?

A. I’d say so, yes, sir.

Q. Solid waste landfills by definition do not accept
hazardous waste for disposal?

A. They’re not supposed to.

* * * —

Q. All right. Is chalk a natural—a good natural
source of groundwater?

A. No.

Q. Why?

A. Because it’s relatively impermissible. The chalk at
this site is tighter than Dick’s hat band.

* - . -

144

Q. What is leachate?

A. It’s the liquid that exists in a trench within the
catchment area in which hazardous wastes are placed.

Q. What type of liquid?

A. Well, rainwater if it falls within the catchment
area of anything where hazardous waste is placed. It’s
defined regulatorily as leachate.

- ” ” *

A. Those early trenches were shallow and unlined. I
do not know—As I said before, I haven’t seen this draw-
ing before I came in here just a few minutes ago.

Q. I understand. But at the same time, I need to
know what you do know. If you don’t know something,
that’s fine. But for obvious reasons we want to be as
thorough as we can. If you don’t know something, just
tell us, and we’ll go on—we’ll just ask you impressions
or go on to another area.

But let’s go back. Is it your testimony that you do
not know whether there’s been any migration of ground-
water or liquids from Trench 6 to Trench 7?

A. I do not know if there’s been any migration from
Trench 6 to Trench 7.

Q. Has there been, so far as you know, any hy-
draulic connection between those two trenches, 6 and 7?

A. As I mentioned, all of those earlier trenches were
unlined, and they're fairly shallow and fairly near the
ground surface. It would not surprise me therefore if
there was an inner connection.

Q. How would that—why do you say that, that it
would not surprise you if there had been some migra-
tion?

A. Because I talked to you earlier about the fact that
the upper portion of the Selma chalk in places, exhibits
staining along the discontinuities.

Q. That’s the top one hundred and sixty feet?

A. Yeah. These trenches are all fairly shallow, as
I recall, probably less than thirty feet deep. And they
were not excavated, I don’t believe, very deep below

145

ground surface; so there probably is some inner con-
nection between those trench walls. They’re in close
proximity with one another.

Q. Would that likewise—If that were the case, would
there not be the possibility of migration, hydraulic mi-
gration, outside the trenches going to the north?

A. Well, it depends—This suggests that there is a
modest gradient in the chalk to the north.

Q. So what would be the answer to the question?

A. Fluid could move along these near surface defects
in the downgrading direction.

Q. Is it your opinion that liners would retard the
fluid migration?

A. Ina short term.

Q. What are you speaking of in a short term?

A. Until the liner no longer serves—no longer is an
intact and relatively and permeable membrane.

Q. What period of time would that involve in your
opinion?

A. It depends on the leachate. It depends on the
nature of things. It’s probably in terms of tens of years,
not thousands of years.

7 * « *

Q. Now, you mentioned your opinion or you made a
statement with respect to there being a travel time of
ten thousand years. What do you mean by that, sir?

A. I think it’s explained in that report. It has to do
with the time it would take a drop of water leaving the
bottom of a trench at Emelle to make its way to the
top of the Eutaw aquifer.

Q. And is it not correct that you and Golder Asso-
ciates estimated that it would take ten thousand years
for fluid to migrate from the Emelle facility down into
the Eutaw aquifer?

A. I think we are just saying the same thing. I
mean I thought that’s what I just said.

* * + .

146

Q. What, if any, estimates have been made that you
might recall with respect to travel time, through the
lateral travel time through the Selma chalk?

A. My recollection is that the lateral flow estimates
to surficial waters like Bodka Creek and elsewhere or in
the same order of magnitude as the flow to the Eutaw
largely because the gradiant is so low.

* * * *

Q. In your opinion at the present time, are there
adequate monitoring wells measuring lateral movement,
if any, at the Emelle facility of fluid or hydro-geological
movement?

A. I believe there are yes, sir.

A. Those cells which are unlined below the water
table, they will be leachate because of insufficient rain
fall during operation. This will take a while for that to
be pumped out. After a cover is put on, you’re going to
have infiltration from the surrounding water table. So
you are going to get seepage. You're going to get inflow
which can be pumped out. It’s really groundwater which
flows into the trench.

Q. And it becomes contaminated?

A. During this whole process, everything is coming
in, nothing is going out. So leachate will be generated
because of close flow into the facility. And that’s going
to happen in all these facilities. Now, there were dif-
ferent things in the lineament themselves, but the situa-
tion basically is during operation and during the closure
period. And flow will be into the facility.

Q. Well, would there be—I assume that the cells are
closed or capped off. Would there continue to be genera-
tion of some leachate?

A. The movement—I assume you're talking about—
Leachate means water. There will be inflow groundwater.
So yes, there wil! be liquid in the trenches.

Q. Which is preferable in your opinion?

147

A. When it’s removed, you always have the inward
grading. So that eliminates the problem of exfiltration.
If in the future you choose not to pump it and the gra-
dient surrounds the chalk, then you will have a downward
grading from the trench or some of the surrounding
chalk. As soon as the water level in the trenches is in
excess of a hundred and forty, there’s going to be a down-
ward grading of seepage, low pressure, depending on the
slope of the groundwater moving away from the facility.
The gradiant at this site are very slow, very small. So
you have to look at the slope, the groundwater table, the
head in the Entaw. You have to pay attention of which
flow in and what direction at what point in time.

Q. In your opinion, would it be advisable from an
environmental standpoint after closure to continue to re-
move leachate from the trenches?

A. I think that’s more a matter of public policy.
I think this site will be contained and will be diminimous
downward and the trench equilibrate. If public policy
suggests it, it should be. If you’re going to have inward
seepage, you would reduce the tendency for any.

Q. Again just in simple terms, do you have an opinion
as to whether it would be preferable to continue the re-
moval of leachate after closure?

A. If one wishes to continue to have a belt /suspender
operation, pumping leachate provides an additional meas-
ure of protection.

Q. I must ask you, what do you mean by belt/
suspender operation?

A. This is not a term that’s used in Alabama?

Q. It’s one I haven’t heard of before. Possibly all the
rest of the people have.

A. If you're interested in not having your britches
fall down around your ankle, you can put a belt on. You
can wear suspenders. It provides additional protection
from having your trousers falling down.

We're interested in keeping the environmental trousers
from dropping down. If you’re not comfortable with your

148

belt, so you’re going to wear suspenders; elements of pro-
tection. Provide an additional element of protection
against exfiltration.
* * * +

Q. So as far as you know, has ChemWaste, your
company ever collected any surface water samples from
Bodka creek or flowing well south of Bodka creek north
of the facility?

A. I believe they h«ve.

Q. Do you know whether anything, any contamina-
tion has ever been detected in those samples?

A. Ido not believe it has.

Q. One more question on leachate. Will leachate con-
tinue to form or leak from a closed cell?
Is that a generic question or at this site?
At this site.
Will leachate continue to be generated at this site?
Yes, sir.
Yes. Because those trenches are below ground-
water level, you will have some either in equilibration or
flow.

>OOO >

Q. You spoke a while ago of cleaning up contaminated
water around the Selma chaulk. What would you recom-
mend or think to be the most appropriate method on
cleaning up any contamination? We spoke earlier of
cleaning up contaminated groundwater. That may at
some future time get into the aquifer. Do you have any
opinion as to the best method or methods of cleaning up
any contamination that may get into the Selma chalk or
would that even be appropriate to undertake remedial ac-
tion efforts at that point?

A. Ithink it would depend on how close to the surface
it is. If it’s real close to the surface, it maybe difficult.
It you can regress it further, it might.

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385013_0185%3A12. Public record. Not legal advice.
