# Opposition Brief — James Coughlin Et Ux. v. Westinghouse Broadcasting and Cable, Inc

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385012_0103%3A3

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Opposition Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1986
- **Citation:** 476 U.S. 1187

## Text

4 (Spore coor, 0. |
a\ i FILED

oY 1

| APR 25 1986
No. 85-1593 } re

} | JOSEPH Ff. SPANIOL, JR.

i —— <_< one

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

October Term, 1985

COUGHLIN, JAMES and COUGHLIN,
PATRICIA, his wife,
Petitioners,
Vv.

WESTINGHOUSE BROADCASTING
AND CABLE, INC.,
Respondent.

On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari
to the United States Court of Appeals
for the Third Circuit

RESPONDENT’S BRIEF IN
OPPOSITION TO PETITION

Jerome J. Shestack*

Carl A. Solano

SCHNADER, HARRISON, SEGAL
& LEWIS

Suite 3600

1600 Market Street

Philadelphia, Pa. 19103

(215) 751-2000

Attorneys for Respondent
Westi use Broadcasting
and Cable, Inc.

*Counsel of Record

gle, daa eas NIT ade eine iat tS

PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDING

The parties to this proceeding are James Coughlin,
Patricia Coughlin, and Westinghouse Broadcasting and
Cable, Inc., a wholly-owned subsidiary of Westinghouse
Electric Corporation.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page
PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDING..........-+>: i
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ......-----++sse++055 iii
STATEMENT OF THE CASE ......---0 55 +s5505 2
REASONS FOR DENYING THE WRIT.......--. 8

| THERE ARE NO SPECIAL OR IMPOR-
TANT REASONS WARRANTING REVIEW
OF THIS CASE BY THIS COURT ........ 8

ll. THE REASONS STATED BY PETITION-
ERS DO NOT PRESENT A SUFFICIENT
LIKELIHOOD OF REVERSAL TO MERIT
REVIEW BY THIS COURT .......--.++>> 10

A. The Courts Below Correctly Determined
That Westinghouse Was Entitled to Sum-
mary Judgment Because There Was No
Genuine Issue of Material Fact Relating
to Actual Malice ........-.ee seer rere 10

B. This Case Presents No Cause for Doing
Away With the Actual Malice Require-
_ rrrrrrrrrr yy 16

C. There Is No Merit to the Contention That
an Evidentiary Privilege for Reporters’
Materials Deprives Petitioners of Due
Process of Law........-++-- . jeeen earn 17

CONCLUSION. .....-- cece e ere eeerereceereees 21

il

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Cases Page
Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 473 U.S. , 105
S. Ct. 2672 (1985) (No. 84-1602), granting cert.
to review 746 F.2d 1563 (D.C. Cir. 1984)..... 8
Bose Corp. v. Consumers Union of United States,
Inc., 466 U.S. 485 (1984)......-.--. eee eee 15
Branzburg v. Hayes, 408 U.S. 665 a 18
Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 474 U.S. , 106 S. Ct.

342 (1985) (No. 85-198), granting cert. to re-
view Catrett v. Johns-Manville Sales Corp., 756

F.2d 181 (D.C. Cir. 1985).............------ 8
Dun & Bradstreet, Inc. v. Greenmoss Builders, Inc.,

472 US. 105 S. Ct. 2939 (1985).......- 17
Garrison v. Louisiana, 379 U.S. 64 (1964)..... 12-14
Gertz v. Robert Welch, Inc., 418 U.S. 323

RT ecu dapacceesccccccccccsees 12-13
Greenbelt Cooperative Publishing Assn. v. Bresler,

ID, occ cre scscsseceseccccce: 14
Hatchard v. Westinghouse Broadcasting Co.,

Pa. Super. ___, 504 A.2d 211 (1986), pet. for

allowance of appeal filed, No. 173 E.D. Al-

locatur Dkt. 1986 (Pa., Feb. 24, 1986)........ 18

Hepps v. Philadelphia Newspapers, Inc., 506 Pa.
304, 485 A.2d 374 (1984), rev'd, 475 U.S. __.

54 U.S.L.W. 4373 (1986) ........----eeeeeee 18
In re Taylor, 412 Pa. 32, 193 A2d 181
MERE GS Gugencssvevecccccccccccss: 18

Liberty Lobby, Inc. v. Anderson, 746 F.2d 1563
(D.C. Cir. 1984), cert. granted, 473 U.S. ;
105 S. Ct. 2672 (1985) (No. 84-1602)........ 6-7

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES— Continued )

Cases Page

Maressa v. New Jersey Monthly, 89 N.J. 176, 445
A.2d 376, cert. denied, 459 U.S. 907 (1982)... 19

Matsushita Electric Industrial Co. v. Zenith Radio

Corp. 475 US. _ 54 U.S.L.W. 4319
6)... :) Se 10-11
New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, 376 U.S. 254
(BGBE) 5c ccccccccewesesdecseees ... 12-16
Old Dominion Branch No. 496, Letter Carriers %
Austin, 418 U.S. 264 (1974) .. 14
Philadelphia Newspapers, Inc. v. Hepps 175 U.S
, D4 U.S.L.W. 4373 (1986) @ ” 16, 19
Rebozo v. Washington Post Co., 637 F.2d 3° Sth
Cir.), cert. denied, 454 U.S. 964 198] 14
Rosenblatt v. Baer, 383 U.S. 75 (1966) .. 14
Rosenbloom v. Metromedia, Inc., 403 U.S. 29
4 1) REE, 14
St. Amant v. Thompson, 390 U.S. 727
‘;,. } Pere rrireee re 8, 11-14

Tavoulareas v. Piro, 759 F.2d 90 (D.C. Cir. 1985),
vacated, 763 F.2d 1472, 1481 (D.C. Cir. 1985)
(im BANC)... 2. . cece cece cece creer eeeeeeeees 8

Time, Inc. v. Pape, 401 U.S. 5 2¢ 74) See 15

Constitutional Provisions and Statutes
First Amendment........-----+esesseeeereee passim
Pennsylvania Shield Law, 42 Pa. C.S. § 5942... 17-20

Court Rules

Federal Rules of Civil Procedure
we PSC TeT Terr eee 7, 10-11

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—(Continued )

Court Rules Page

Rules of the Supreme Court of the United States
Rule 17

Other Authorities

Advisory Committee Note to 1963 Amendment of
Federal Rule 56(e), 28 U.S.C. App., p. 626
tf} reer aes PL 11

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

October Term, 1985
No. 85-1593

COUGHLIN, JAMES and COUGHLIN,
PATRICIA, his wife,
Petitioners,
v.

WESTINGHOUSE BROADCASTING
AND CABLE, INC.,
Respondent.

On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari
to the United States Court of Appeals
for the Third Circuit

Respondent Westinghouse Broadcasting and Cable,
Inc. respectfully submits that the petition for certiorari
should be denied because it raises no questions of com-
pelling significance that merit this Court’s attention. The
decisions below did no more than to apply the definition
of actual malice to which this Court has adhered for a
quarter century and to resolve a discovery issue in full
accordance with Pennsylvania law. The petition thus
does noi present any misapplication of current law or
conflict among decisions, but only petitioners’ desire to
change that law. However, the facts of this case present
no compelling reason to do so.

2
STATEMENT OF THE CASE

This is an action for libel. Petitioner James Cou ghlin,
a Philadelphia police officer, contends _ that
Westinghouse defamed him in a television broadcast
dealing with police corruption in connection with a club
that acted as an “after-hours” bar in Philadelphia. A por-
tion of the broadcast showed Coughlin leaving the club
at about 4:00 A.M. carrying an object that appeared to be
an envelope. Coughlin claims that the report made him
appear to be corrupt. After extensive discovery, the dis-
trict court entered summary judgment in favor of
Westinghouse. It held that, although the truth of the
broadcast statements about Coughlin was disputed,
Coughlin had failed to submit evidence sufficient to cre-
ate a genuine issue of fact in support of the claim that
Westinghouse broadcast the statements with actual mal-
ice. A. 37-45.* The court of appeals affirmed without dis-
sent. A. 2-24.

Petitioners’ ten-page “Statement of the Case” con-
tains a series of misstatements, half-truths, and innuen-
dos that are unsupported by the record or the opinions
below and that falsely portray the state of the record.
Rather than engage in a point-by-point refutation, this
brief will outline the essential facts material to the issues
raised in the petition.

. In 1981. residents of a Philadelphia neighborhood
complained to Westinghouse’s television station in Phil-
adelphia, KYW-TV, about “illegal and disruptive
activities” (A. 42) at a private club on American Street
and about the failure of the police and state liquor au-
thorities to remedy the misconduct. KYW investigated
the situation for many months, and conducted surveil-
lance of the club from a low-light camera in a van and,

*Pages with an “A.” prefix are in the appendix to the petition for
certiorari. Pages with an “S.A.” prefix are in the supplemental ap-
pendix bound with this brief in opposition to the petition.

3

later, at a window in a neighbor’s house. The investiga-
tion revealed that the club served liquor to persons after
3:00 A.M., the time at which it was required to close un-
der state law; that persons leaving the club after those
hours often were rowdy and disruptive and disturbed the
peace of the neighborhood; and that police officers fre-
quently visited the club while liquor was being served
after 3:00 A.M. without making arrests, reporting viola-
tions, or otherwise correcting the misconduct or follow-
ing police directives relating to club checks.

As stated by the district court (A. 42), the reporters
felt that the activities they observed were inconsistent
with proper law enforcement. Their suspicions were re-
inforced by a 1974 Pennsylvania Crime Commission re-
port that noted the potential for corruption that exists
when police officers monitor private clubs. The supervi-
sor of the Crime Commission's investigation confirmed
that the activities videotaped by KYW were similar to
those discussed by the Commission.

The portion of the KYW report relating to Coughlin
dealt with events on the morning of October 11, 1981.
KYW’s surveillance camera recorded persons entering
the club after 3:00 A.M. At 3:52 A.M., a police officer
(not Coughlin) entered the club, stayed for five minutes,
and then left while about 50 people remained inside;
contrary to police regulations, he did not inform the po-
lice radio of his whereabouts. At 4:04 A.M., he returned
to the club (again without informing police radio) and
stayed until 4:11 A.M. Meanwhile, Coughlin told the po-
lice radio dispatcher to “hold him out” at headquarters
for paperwork. Soon after the other policeman left the
club, Coughlin drove up to the club, slowly backed up,
looked over the street, and drove off. Coughlin returned
several minutes later. He entered the club at 4:17 A.M.,
without reporting to police radio and without donning his
standard uniform attire (jacket, hat, and nightstick).
Less than a minute later, he exited the club carrying a

4

paper object in his hand that two KYW reporters who
were eyewitnesses identified as an envelope.

KYW obtained the police logs and incident reports of
Coughlin and the other policeman observed at the club
on October 11. The logs did not show the policemen at
the Club at the times the KYW camera recorded them
there. Coughlin’s log book showed a twenty-minute gap
for the period he was at the club.

KYW asked to interview the police officers seen on
the videotape. The Police Department refused to arrange
interviews, but granted permission for KYW to approach
the policemen outside of formal channels. Coughlin had
been informed by the Police Department of accusations
that he had taken an envelope from the club, and he had
heard rumors of the KYW investigation. On February 10,
1982, KYW went to his home to interview him as he re-
turned from work, but Coughlin refused to be inter-
viewed. Although the petition for certiorari (at 9, 12)
asserts that Coughlin was not given a reasonable oppor-
tunity to state his side of the story, Coughlin himself tes-
tified during his deposition that he made a voluntary
decision not to talk to KYW.

Though unable to talk with Coughlin, KYW inter-
viewed a number of police officials, including the Police
Department’s deputy commissioner, chief inspector, and
public information officer. Interviews also were held
with neighborhvod residents and their counsel; present
and former officers of the club; state liquor authorities;
the Philadelphia district attorney, and a Pennsylvania
Crime Commission lawyer who said that the events re-
corded b: KYW suggested that Coughlin “was not in-
volved ir. official business” (S.A. 23-24).

KYW aired the investigative report, entitled “After
Hours on American Street,” on February 17 and 18,
1982. and repeated segments of the report along with
follow-up interviews on February 19. The transcript of

5

the report is very lengthy, but pertinent excerpts are ap-
pended to this brief as a supplement. The report included
the videotape of Coughlin made on October 11 and de-
scribed those events as “the most suspicious police ac-
tivity [KYW] saw on American Street.” S.A. 15, 19. While
showing Coughlin exiting the building with a paper ob-
ject in his hand, the report noted that Coughlin had told
the police dispatcher that he was out at headquarters do-
ing paperwork and added, “Well, the only paperwork we
saw him doing was carrying this envelope out of the club
less than a minute after he went in.” S.A. 16, 20. On the
February 19 telecast, KYW interviewed Tom Garvey, the
president of the Fraternal Order of Police, on the air and
asked him about the police conduct shown in the report.
Garvey responded that Coughlin had been a rookie cop
who did nothing wrong and that the object that had been
shown in his hand was a police incident report log (or “48
book”), not an envelope. S.A. 28-29.

The Police Department then conducted its own in-
vestigation of the events reported by KYW. Using labo-
ratory tests on the videotape, among other things, it,
along with the Federal Bureau. of Investigation, tried to
identify definitively the object in Coughlin’s hand, but
they were unable to reach an official conclusion concern-
ing its identity. A. 42. Police officials concluded that the
object reasonably could be said to look like either a “48
book” or an envelope. Id. The Police Department's in-
ternal charges against Coughlin have not been decided.

Coughlin sued for libel, claiming that the KYW re-
port falsely accused him of taking a bribe. His wife sued
for loss of consortium. The parties engaged in extensive
discovery, including 36 depositions, a large number of
interrogatories, and production of numerous documents.
Westinghouse objected to a small segment of petitioners’
discovery that sought material protected from disclosure
under a Pennsylvania statute protecting news sources

6

and editorial materials. Petitioners moved to compel dis-
covery, arguing that the statute infringed on their state
and federal constitutional rights. The district court re-
jected that argument and denied the motion. A. 28-34.

At the close of discovery, Westinghouse moved for
summary judgment, arguing primarily that the individ-
ual statements in the broadcast were true and that, in
any event, there was no evidence that it had acted with
actual malice. The district court held that the dispute
about whether Coughlin was carrying an envelope or a
“48 book” presented a genuine issue of material fact that
precluded summary judgment on the truth issue. A.
37-38.

With respect to truth, the petition for certiorari con-
tains repeated assertions that its version of the facts re-
garding what Coughlin was carrying is uncontroverted,
pointing to the district court’s statement (A. 38) that
“Defendant has not seriously challenged plaintiffs’ ex-
planation for the events of October 11, 1981.” Of course,
since Westinghouse had moved for summary judgment,
the rules of procedure precluded it from contesting fac-
tual issues while arguing its motion. Obviously, the fac-
tual version in the petition is disputed; KYW’s reporters
continue to believe that Coughlin carried an envelope,
while Coughlin protests that he did not. That dispute is
not at issue here, however.

The district court agreed with Westinghouse that
petitioners were required to prove actual malice because
Coughlin, as a police officer, was a public official. A.
38-39. Petitioners do not challenge that holding. The
court declined to determine whether there was sufficient
evidence to prove actual malice with “convincing
clarity,” holding that that standard applies only to trials,
not summary judgment motions. A. 44-45, citing Liberty
Lobby, Inc. v. Anderson, 746 F.2d 1563 (D.C. Cir. 1984),
cert. granted, 473 U.S. __, 105 S. Ct. 2672 (1985) (No.

7

84-1602). Nevertheless, upon surveying petitioners’
“evidence” of actual malice in light of the deferential
summary judgment standard in Rule 56 of the Federal
Rules of Civil Procedure, the court concluded that peti-
tioners had failed to create even a triable issue of fact.
Accordingly, the court entered summary judgment for
Westinghouse. A. 39-43.

The court of appeals affirmed in a per curiam opin-
ion that adopted the reasoning of the district court. A. 5.
In a separate concurrence, Judge Becker agreed with
that conclusion, and suggested that he reached that re-
sult after engaging in a plenary review of the record. A.
7, 24. The court of appeals sought extensive briefing on
petitioners’ complaint that they were denied discovery,
focusing mainly on the validity of the Pennsylvania stat-
ute protecting sources and editorial materials in light of
the right to reputation under the Constitution of Penn-
sylvania. It concluded that the statute “suffers from no
state or federal constitutional infirmity.” A. 6. After an
extensive analysis of the state and federal constitutional
arguments, Judge Becker agreed. A. 7-24. Petitioners did
not seek rehearing.

8
REASONS FOR DENYING THE WRIT

I. THERE ARE NO SPECIAL OR IMPORTANT REA-
SONS WARRANTING REVIEW OF THIS CASE BY
THIS COURT.

The petition fails to state any grounds that merit re-
view by this Court.

First, petitioners do not suggest that the decision be-
low conflicts with decisions of this Court. Indeed, the
petition studiously avoids reference to the decisions of
this Court — particularly St. Amant v. Thompson, 390
U.S. 727 (1968) — that compelled the courts below to
hold as they did.

Second, there is no conflict between the decision of
the court of appeals in this case and that of any other
court of appeals. Indeed, the petition concedes (at p. 15)
that there is a dearth of authority supporting its position.
The decision on which petitioners most heavily rely,
Tavoulareas v. Piro, 759 F.2d 90 (D.C. Cir. 1985), was
vacated by the court that entered it and now is under
reconsideration in banc. 763 F.2d 1472, 1481 (D.C. Cir.
1985).

Third, the decision below does not conflict with the
decision of a state court of last resort. As Judge Becker's
concurring opinion in the court of appeals (A. 7-24) dem-
onstrates, the court of appeals was very sensitive to the
holdings of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania in de-
ciding the due process issue advanced by petitioners in
light of the competing interests at stake under state and
federal law.

Fourth, the petition does not present novel questions
of federal law and raises none of the issues now pending
before this Court. Petitioners were not required to re-
spond to an unsupported summary judgment motion. Cf.
Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, No. 85-198. Nor were they re-
quired to meet a “convincing clarity” burden of proof. Cf.
Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., No. 84-1602.

9

Finally, petitioners have not and surely could not
claim that the court of appeals engaged in a major de-
parture from the accepted and usual course of judicial
proceedings or sanctioned such a departure by the dis-
trict court. In the district court, petitioners were given an
opportunity to conduct discovery to the fullest extent
permitted by Pennsylvania law. The procedure employed
by the district court on summary judgment, including
the standard of proof, was the most favorable that peti-
tioners could have requested. The court of appeals fully
reviewed the record; the judges viewed a videotape of the
broadcast at issue, and, according to Judge Becker, per-
formed a plenary review of the actual malice issue. See A.
24. Even though petitioners themselves deemphasized
the discovery issue on appeal, the court of appeals asked
for extensive supplemental briefing, and, as Judge
Becker’s opinion makes clear, considered the issue in
depth. Thus, there was no departure from the proper
course of judicial proceedings in this case, either in the
district court or on appeal.

Petitioners make no effort whatsoever to explain
what special and important reasons under Rule 17 of this
Court justify issuance of a writ. They merely seek an-
other review of the record, an unwarranted exercise in
light of the correct application of current law to that
record by the courts below. Petitioners do not like the
current law and suggest that it should be changed. But
that law is based on more than 25 years of First Amend-
ment jurisprudence painstakingly crafted to balance the
competing interests in this area. See Philadelphia News-
papers, Inc. v. Hepps, 475 U.S. __, 54 U.S.L.W. 4373
(1986). The facts of this case do not merit reconsidera-
tion of those decisions.

Because petitioners have raised no special and im-
portant reasons justifying the attention of this Court, the
petition for certiorari should be denied.

10

Il. THE REASONS STATED BY PETITIONERS DO NOT
PRESENT A SUFFICIENT LIKELIHOOD OF RE-
VERSAL TO MERIT REVIEW BY THIS COURT.

A. The Courts Below Correctly Determined That
Westinghouse Was Entitled to Summary Judgment
Because There Was No Genuine Issue of Material
Fact Relating to Actual Malice.

The main thrust of the petition is that the lower
courts erred in concluding that petitioners had failed to
present evidence of actual malice that would enable
them to reach a jury. Petitioners contend that the courts
below acted incorrectly in the way they employed the
summary judgment rules or in applying the legal stan-
dards for actual malice. Neither contention has merit.

1. The courts below correctly applied the sum-
mary judgment rules to search for triable issues
of fact.

The rules provide that summary judgment “shall be
rendered forthwith if the [evidence shows] that there is
no genuine issue as to any material fact and that the
moving party is entitled to a judgment as a matter of
law.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(c). As this Court emphasized just
one month ago, to preclude summary judgment an issue
of fact must be “genuine,” and “[w]here the record taken
as a whole could not lead a rational trier of fact to find for
the non-moving party, there is no ‘genuine issue for
trial.” ” Matsushita Electric Industrial Co. v. Zenith Ra-
dio Corp., 475 U.S. ___, 54 U.S.L.W. 4319, 4322
(1986).

Petitioners complain (at pp. 15, 21) that the courts
below somehow departed from this standard and en-
gaged in “factfinding,” but they do not identify how the
lower courts did so. The complaint that the lower courts

1]

engaged in “weighing the evidence” (p. 15) seems to re-
late merely to the fact that they assessed petitioners’ pur-
ported “evidence” of actual malice to determine whether
it was sufficient to present to a jury. But that is precisely
the courts’ role under Rule 56. “The very mission of the
summary judgment procedure is to pierce the pleadings
and to assess the proof in order to see whether there is a
genuine need for trial.” Advisory Committee Note, 28
U.S.C. App., p. 626 (1982 ed.); see Matsushita, supra,
54 U.S.L.W. at 4322.

The one example of “factfinding” that petitioners
cite is a strained misconstruction of the district court’s
opinion. At page of 21 of the petition they complain about
the district court’s statement (A. 41-42) that “the evi-
dence relevant to the state of mind of defendant’s em-
ployees indicates that, although they did not seriously
explore other possible explanations for Coughlin’s be-
havior, the conclusions which they drew based on their
observations were reasonable.” In suggesting that that
statement was a finding of fact, the petition takes the
statement out of context. In making its statement, the
district court was determining whether petitioners’ evi-
dence was “sufficient to create an issue as to whether
defendant’s statements were ‘so inherently improbable
that only a reckless man would have put them in
circulation.’” A. 41, quoting St. Amant v. Thompson,
390 U.S. 727, 732 (1968). Assessing all of the evidence
before it, the district court concluded that no rational
jury could find that the alleged accusations of corruption
were too unreasonable to be believed. That assessment
was a matter committed to the district court’s determi-
nation under Rule 56.

12

2. The courts below correctly applied this Court’s
decisions defining actual malice.

Petitioners do not contend that they submitted any
evidence that Westinghouse acted with actual malice be-
cause it knew it was publishing false statements. Rather,
they argue that a jury should have been permitted to de-
termine whether Westinghouse acted with reckless dis-
regard for the truth. See New York Times Co. v. Sullivan,
376 U.S. 254, 279-80 (1964).

This Court has explained this second prong of actual
malice many times. Under it, “[u]tterances honestly
believed” are protected, “even if [they are made] out of
hatred,” for “only those false statements made with the
high degree of awareness of their probable falsity de-
manded by New York Times may be the subject of either
civil or criminal sanctions.” Garrison v. Louisiana, 379
U.S. 64, 73-74 (1964). “There must be sufficient evi-
dence to permit the conclusion that the defendant in fact
entertained serious doubts as to the truth of his
publication.” St. Amant v. Thompson, 390 U.S. 727, 731
(1968). “[S]ubjective awareness of probable falsity” is
necessary for this type of actual malice to exist.” Gertz v.
Robert Welch, Inc., 418 U.S. 323, 334 n.6 (1974).

The district court faithfully applied these standards
in assessing petitioners’ “evidence” of actual malice. It
looked for any evidence that Westinghouse doubted the
truth of its broadcast or subjectively was aware that the
broadcast probably was false. It found none. A. 39-45.

That Westinghouse did not act with actual malice is
abundantly clear from this record. Not only is there no
direct evidence of subjective doubts by Westinghouse
personnel, but all of the facts point toward an effort by
Westinghouse objectively to report a sincerely believed
and believable story of great importance to the public.
Eyewitnesses stated that Coughlin carried an envelope

13

out of the club, and the videotape image was fully con-
sistent with that account. Those basic facts, together
with additional evidence — e.g., the concerns raised by a
Pennsylvania Crime Commission report, the failure of
the police to stop repeated incidents of misconduct and
violations at the club despite frequent complaints, the
objectively suspicious conduct of Coughlin in appearing
to “case” the club area before returning to enter it, the
false reporting by Coughlin of whereabouts different
from the club and his failure to enter his stop at the club
in his logbook, the similar failures of the other policeman
at the club that night, the failure of Coughlin to report
his entry into the club to the police radio dispatcher, and
his entry of the club out of uniform — made any state-
ments about Coughlin’s conduct on October 11 com-
pletely justifiable.

In arguing that they presented evidence that would
permit a rational jury to reach a contrary conclusion, pe-
titioners completely ignore this Court’s definition of what
actual malice requires. Indeed, they do not even cite de-
cisions such as Garrison, St. Amant, and Gertz. A quick
review of the “evidence” on which petitioners rely makes
clear that it has no bearing on whether Westinghouse
had subjective doubts about the truth of its broadcast.

1. The claim that Westinghouse harbored hostility
toward the police (Pet. at 16). All of the testimony on this
subject is undisputed; both Westinghouse personnel
and Police Department officials testified that there was
no hostility. A. 40. Petitioners’ “evidence” is no more
than unsupported speculation — denied by both the po-
lice and Westinghouse — that hostility resulted from
past incidents involving the police and reporters, such as
the incident related in the petition (at 10-11) in which
the police investigated the Westinghouse surveillance
van on American Street in response to an anonymous tip.
In any event, such “evidence” is immaterial, for preex-
isting hostility does not tend to establish subjective

14

doubts about the truth of a story. See Old Dominion
Branch No. 496, Letter Carriers v. Austin, 418 U.S. 264,
281-82 (1974); Rosenbloom v. Metromedia, Inc., 403
U.S. 29, 52 n.18 (1971); Greenbelt Cooperative Publish-
ing Assn. v. Bresler, 398 U.S. 6, 9-11 (1970); Rosenblatt
v. Baer, 383 U.S. 75, 84 (1966); Garrison, supra, 379
U.S. at 73-74, 77-79.

2. The claim that Westinghouse failed properly to
investigate the story although it could harm Coughlin’s
reputation and even though KYW was under no time
pressure (Pet. at 16-18). Contrary to petitioners’ rheto-
ric, the undisputed facts showed that Westinghouse’s in-
vestigation was extensive. KYW interviewed a number of
police officials. It tried to interview Coughlin, but
Coughlin voluntarily refused. To this day no one has
been able definitively to determine what was in
Coughlin’s hand on October 11. But even if KYW’s in-
vestigation might have been more thorough, that fact
would not show actual malice. Inadequacy of investiga-
tion is not proof of doubts about truth. See St. Amant,
supra, 390 U.S. at 731; New York Times, supra, 376
U.S. at 288. That result should not change merely be-
cause the story is not prepared under time pressure and
it results in a serious accusation; otherwise, a trial would
have to be held in every libel case arising from investi-
gative journalism leading to a potentially harmful
charge.

3. The claim that the conclusions drawn by
Westinghouse in the broadcast “were invariably the
most injurious speculations imaginable” (Pet. at 18-19).
There is no evidence that Westinghouse harbored
doubts about the truth and then deliberately chose to se-
lect an interpretation of events adverse to Coughlin. Cf.
Rebozo v. Washington Post Co., 637 F.2d 375, 382 (Sth
Cir. ), cert. denied, 454 U.S. 964 (1981). Westinghouse’s
alleged interpretation of the events involving Coughlin
on October 11 was, on the facts known to it, much more

15

reasonable than the story of negligent police work that
Coughlin later offered to explain them. Because the First
Amendment does not permit a media defendant to be
condemned for drawing non-reckless, let alone reason-
able, conclusions about the facts before it, this purported
“evidence” can have no bearing on petitioners’ case. As
this Court stated in Bose Corp. v. Consumers Union of
United States, Inc., 466 U.S. 485 (1984), a media de-
fendant does not lose the “First Amendment’s broad pro-
tective umbrella” merely because it chose “ ‘one of a
number of possible rational interpretations’ of an event
‘that bristled with ambiguities.’” 466 U.S. at 512-13,
quoting Time, Inc. v. Pape, 401 U.S. 279, 290 (1971).

4. The claims of an “attempt to silence” Coughlin
with an on-camera interview and of failure to retract
accusations (Pet. at 19-20). Coughlin could have spoken
to KYW’s reporters at any time, but, as he stated during
his deposition, he voluntarily chose not to do so. The su g-
gestion that Westinghouse sought to “silence” Coughlin
by approaching him for the interview with a television
camera is not a serious argument. As soon as someone
came forward to express another view about Coughlin’s
conduct, Westinghouse broadcast that view on the air in
prime time. S.A. 28-29 (interview of T. Garvey).
Westinghouse’s failure to retract its story after it was
aired surely cannot be evidence that Westinghouse had
serious doubts about the truth of its story before it was
aired. See New York Times, supra, 376 U.S. at 286-87.
Westinghouse has failed to retract because, to this day,
petitioners’ version of the truth has not been proven;
even the FBI has been unable to determine what was in
Coughlin’s hand on October 11. A. 42.

None of petitioners’ “evidence” is probative of a reck-
less disregard by Westinghouse for the truth. Taken ei-
ther separately or in combination, the items listed by
petitioners provide no basis upon which a rational jury
could conclude that Westinghouse acted with actual

16

malice. This was the conclusion reached by the district
court and the court of appeals, and it was fully consistent
with the precedents of this Court.

B. This Case Presents No Cause for Doing Away With
the Actual Malice Requirement.

Recognizing that their “evidence” is not really pro-
bative of actual malice as defined by this Court, petition-
ers suggest, timidly, that the actual malice standard itself
should be reconsidered. Pet. at 13-14, 21. The offhand
nature of the suggestion discloses that petitioners are
hardly serious about it, and Westinghouse will not bur-
den this Court with a lengthy response. This case does
not warrant a reformulation of existing First Amend-
ment law.

The actual malice requirement was fashioned to af-
ford “breathing space” to free expression about public
officials and public issues by precluding punishment of
statements honestly believed to be true. See New York
Times, supra, 376 U.S. at 271- 72. The Court recognized
that a defense of truth does not fully satisfy this objec-
tive, for proof of truth often is difficult and inexact. Id. at
279. The Court has adhered to this view for nearly three
decades. See generally Philadelphia Newspapers, Inc. v.
Hepps, 475 U.S. ___, 54 U.S.L.W. 4373 (1986).

This case illustrates the wisdom of the Court’s rea-
soning. Although the truth of some aspects of
Westinghouse’s report remains contested and has
eluded determination by law enforcement investigators,
there is no doubt that the subject of the report was of
immense public significance, and the record makes clear
beyond any genuine dispute that Westinghouse acted
with a sincere belief in its truth. Indeed, as a result of the
report and law enforcement investigations caused by it,

17

the club featured in the report was closed by the author-
ities and police procedures were re-examined. The pub-
lic interest could not be served by a change in the law
that would deter such press investigations of police cor-
ruption and violations of law.

Petitioners do not state what changes they would
make to current law that would not eviscerate First
Amendment protections. While they quote from Justice
White’s opinion in Dun & Bradstreet, Inc. v. Greenmoss
Builders, Inc., 472 U.S. __, 105 S. Ct. 2939, 2948-54
(1985), they carefully avoid mention of Justice White’s
suggestions that actions for damages be replaced with
declaratory judgment proceedings to determine truth
and that strict limitations be placed on damage awards.
Petitioners wish to recover substantial compensatory and
punitive damages in this case.

Petitioners’ argument is nothing more than the tired
refrain of many unsuccessful plaintiffs — that the law
should be changed to permit them to recover. This case
does not merit a wholesale re-examination of libel law
under the First Amendment, and certiorari should not be
granted to entertain petitioners’ suggestion.

C. There Is No Merit to the Contention That an
Evidentiary Privilege for Reporters’ Materials De-
prives Petitioners of Due Process of Law.

Petitioners’ final argument is that this Court should
declare shield statutes unconstitutional in libel cases.
Not surprisingly, petitioners cite no authority that ever
has held a shield statute or any other evidentiary privi-
lege invalid in a case such as this one, and, so far as
Westinghouse can determine, no such authorities exist.
Petitioners’ argument is without merit.

The Pennsylvania Shield Law, 42 Pa. C.S. § 5942,
provides that the press may not be required to disclose
the sources of its information. It is just one of a number

18

of Pennsylvania enactments that create evidentiary priv-
ileges to foster an important interest in the confidential-
ity of certain types of communications and information.
As Judge Becker noted in his opinion in the court of ap-
peals (A. 23), at least 26 states have shield statutes. The
district court’s application of the Pennsylvania Shield
Law in this case was fully in accord with decisions of the
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania. See Hepps v. Philadel-
phia Newspapers, Inc., 506 Pa. 304, 485 A.2d 374
(1984), rev’d on other grounds, 475 U.S. ___, 54
U.S.L.W. 4373 (1986); In re Taylor, 412 Pa. 32, 193
A.2d 181 (1963).

Petitioners suggest that the Shield Law is unconsti-
tutional as applied in libel cases because it makes it dif-
ficult for plaintiffs to obtain evidence of actual malice,
thereby depriving them of their right to reputation under
the Constitution of Pennsylvania without due process of
law. Much of petitioners’ argument is devoted to estab-
lishing that they have a state-created liberty or property
interest in reputation, a fact not disputed by
Westinghouse. However, as Judge Becker explained in
his thorough analysis of the question (A. 9-18), the
Pennsylvania constitutional right to reputation is not it-
self infringed by the Shield Law or its effect on proving
actual malice. Accord, Hatchard v. Westinghouse Broad-
casting Co.,___ Pa. Super. __, 504 A.2d 211 (1986),
pet. for allowance of appeal filed, No. 173 E.D. Allocatur
Dkt. 1986 (Pa., Feb. 24, 1986).

The result is no different under the federal due pro-
cess clause. This Court already has observed that states
deserve wide deference in their decisions to enact shield
laws (Branzburg v. Hayes, 408 U.S. 665, 706 (1972)),
and petitioners have offered no reason to interfere with
the state enactments. As Judge Becker concluded in his
analysis of the due process question (A. 18-24), the
Shield Law and its effect on proving actual malice do not
deprive anyone of reputation. While the Shield Law may

19

make proof of actual malice more difficult, it does not
make such proof impossible. See Maressa v. New Jersey
Monthly, 89 N.J. 176, 445 A.2d 376, cert. denied, 459
U.S. 907 (1982). Any risk created by the statute that libel
plaintiffs will be unable recover damages for harm to rep-
utation is more than outweighed by the substantial free
press interests that Pennsylvania has sought to advance
by enacting it. See A. 23-24. Cf. Philadelphia Newspa-
pers, supra, 54 U.S.L.W. at 4376 (Pennsylvania Shield
Law's effect on obtaining evidence of truth is not suffi-
cient to alter requirement that plaintiff has burden of
proving falsity).

Moreover, in this case the limitations placed on dis-
covery because of the Shield Law were, at most, mini-
mal. The three dozen depositions and other extensive
discovery afforded petitioners an ample opportunity to
find evidence of actual malice, if any existed. Petitioners’
one example of potential evidence of actual malice that
they claim they could not obtain because of the Shield
Law is a blatant misrepresentation of the facts. At page
13, the petition suggests that Westinghouse relied on the
Shield Law to preclude discovery by petitioners about the
absence of a videotape that showed Coughlin entering
the club on October 11 and that, petitioners say, would
have shown that Coughlin was carrying a “48 book.” In
fact, however, Westinghouse told petitioners that no tape
was made of Coughlin’s entry, and it permitted petition-
ers to depose KYW’s cameraman to inquire about what
had happened. At that deposition, the cameraman ex-
plained that he was recording events at the club from a
mounted camera at a window in a home across the street
from the club; that he was in another room of the house
when Coughlin pulled up to the club in his car; that as
soon as he was aware of Coughlin’s arrival, he ran to the
room where the camera was mounted and got there in
time to see Coughlin but not to videotape him; and that
he then stayed at the camera and was able to videotape

20

Coughlin’s exit a few moments later. The cameraman
also testified that Coughlin had nothing in his hands
when he entered the club. Petitioners’ suggestion that
Westinghouse hid behind the Shield Law to prevent dis-
covery about this issue is entirely false.

In sum, the overstated difficulties of proof advanced
by petitioners are not great enough to warrant invalidat-
ing a statute that at least 26 state legislatures have de-
termined is necessary to foster freedom of the press. This
issue lacks sufficient merit for this Court to grant cer-
tiorari to consider it.

21

CONCLUSION

The petition for certiorari does not present an issue
that merits review by this Court, and it therefore should
be denied.

Respectfully submitted,

Jerome J. Shestack

Carl A. Solano

Attorneys for Respondent

Westinghouse Broadcasting
and Cable, Inc.

SCHNADER, HARRISON, SEGAL & LEWIS
Suite 3600, 1600 Market Street
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103

Of Counsel.

Supplemental
Appendix

~~ a oe
= _ —
7
.
.
J
=
—
a a =
—

TABLE OF CONTENTS

| Page
Excerpt from Broadcast of February 17, 1982 ... SA-1
Excerpt from Broadcast of February 18, 1982,

ee SA-19
Excerpt from Broadcast of February 18, 1982,
EE Ee SA-23

Excerpt from Broadcast of February 19, 1982 .. SA-25

EXCERPT FROM BROADCAST ON
FEBRUARY 17, 1982

x * *

[MAURY] POVITCH: And right now, after months
of investigation, I-Team reporter Stan Bohrman is here
tonight with a special report. It’s calied After Hours on
American Street.

Stan.

MR. BOHRMAN: Maury, like many of the stories
the I-Team has done, this one began with a simple tele-
phone call from some people who needed help. They told
us that their Center City neighborhood was being dis-
rupted by an after-hours drinking club that appeared to
be openly flaunting State liquor laws. They told us they
had asked the police and the State Liquor Control Board
for help, but they haven’t gotten any. So they asked us to
come to their street and look for ourselves, and look we
did.

We took our hidden I-Team camera to their neigh-
borhood, and we found out they were not exaggerating at
all when they said they had a problem.

While we were on the street, we observed some very
questionable activity by some members of the Philadel-
phia Police Department. We also discovered some seri-
ous questions about the way the LCB was doing its job.

You should know from the outset that this is a story
that some people do not want you to see. But despite all
the obstacles, the I-Team stayed with the story for almost
a year, and now we want you to see it.

One final technical note on this. Much of the video
tape of this report was shot with a special nighttime lens
which records only in black and white, so don’t worry
about the color on your television set.

SA-1

SA-2

All right. Now, let’s go after hours on American
Street.

This is the 600 block of South American Street in
Queen Village. Now, you wouldn’t know it to walk down
this street during the day, but a war has been going on
here. By day, this peaceful block, wedged between South
and Bainbridge Street, is a quiet residential neighbor-
hvod that appears to offer the finest in Center City living.

And while there are many shops and restaurants just
steps away, the noise and congestion they sometimes
bring very rarely spills over onto this block.

But in the middle of the night, after most of the peo-
ple who live here have gone to bed, a light goes on in
front of this building in the middle of the block. And
that’s when the problem starts.

Groups of people, often loud and boisterous, parade
down the street headed for something called the Ukrai-
nian American Citizens Association of South Philadel-
phia.

(Demonstration )

MR. BOHRMAN: Up until a year ago, this place was
so quiet that some of the neighbors didn’t even know
there was a club here. But in the fall of 1980, a group of
people who don’t live on this block turned this place into
a full-fledged after-hours drinking club, and that’s when
the battle lines were drawn.

The people who live here say that activity in the club
has totally disrupted their lives and shattered the peace
of the neighborhood. They also insist that the activities of
the club violate the State’s liquor laws.

The people who live on American Street used to
think that the police or Liquor Control Board would help
them solve their problems that they were having with the
club. But after a year of complaining to both agencies,

SA-3

they were beginning to wonder whose side they’re on.
And that’s what prompted them to ask the I-Team to look
into the situation here.

Now, to understand how the problem here devel-
oped, you have to know something about Pennsylvania’s
liquor laws. Under those laws, regular bars or taprooms
must stop serving drinks at 2:00 in the morning. Only
non-profit private clubs licensed by the LCB are allowed
to serve liquor for an extra hour until 3:00 a.m.

The private clubs are supposed to be just that, clubs.
They’re not supposed to be fronts for bars.

To get a liquor license, the club must also have
“some primary interest in activity to which the sale of
liquor and beer is only secondary.” Those and a host of
other rules for clubs sound pretty strict. But as the people
who live on American Street have learned, there’s a big
difference between strict rules and strict enforcement,
and that’s what has them hopping mad.

Phil Behr and his family moved in across the street
from the club last summer. They had no idea what they
were getting into.

MR. BEHR: I understand the club has a capacity of
100 people, but we’ve seen as many as 200 people in the
club, and at one time. They were loud and rowdy. They
had been drinking all night.

They often throw up in our yard, which is what hap-
pened last night. They often urinate in the streets. It’s
hardly civilized living.

MS. CASTINEIRA: Nobody can sleep at night in the
street, nobody, because the noise is terrible. Police com-
ing all the time, and fights in the street.

And we have the glasses and bottles and all this stuff
in the front of the door. They urinate in my door. I saw
it. And all those noises, we cannot sleep.

SA-4

MR. BOHRMAN: Those complaints are nothing
new. For more than a year, residents of American Street
bombarded City and State officials with letters and
phone calls.

And when they didn’t get any results, they asked the
I-Team to take a look at what they were living with, and
take a look we did.

We set up our hidden camera several nights last
year, and we found that the people who live here are
right. You can hardly call this place a small ethnic social
club or even an ethnic club at all.

Here’s a sample of what we saw. Because it was shot
with a special night lens, the pictures are in black and
white.

3:00 a.m., Saturday, October the 10th, the quiet of
American Street is shattered when a woman yells at her
friends.

(Demonstration )

MR. BOHRMAN: A few minutes later, the neigh-
bors were treated to this scene.

(Demonstration )

MR. BOHRMAN: At 4:00 a.m., a full hour after the
club is supposed to be shut down, the residents of Amer-
ican Street are confronted with this scene.

(Demonstration )

MR. BOHRMAN: At 3:28 a.m., Saturday, October
17th, this man comes out of the club and shatters the
early morning silence with his portable radio.

(Demonstration )

MR. BOHRMAN: The residents here who managed
to fall asleep after that were reawakened a short time
later by this rowdy bunch.

- neem

SA-5

(Demonstration)

MR. BOHRMAN: Some of the club’s patrons have
used American Street as a public toilet.

And this gentleman left the club around 3:40 a.m.
one night in February of last year and urinated on a
neighbor’s steps.

And this man came out of the club early on a Sat-
urday morning last October and relieved himself on the
street.

Apparently, his friend also regarded American Street
as a public toilet.

Now, in case you are wondering, the club does have
a bathroom. But, apparently, some of those patrons pre-
fer the steps and sidewalks of American Street.

Neighbors here complained that they often have to
hose down their front walks in the morning. And the I-
Team found that despite repeated protests by the resi-
dents here, little has been done to stop people from
leaving the club with beer bottles. A while later, this man
walked out of the club with another beer bottle.

The problems here have all meshed together to make
life particularly unpleasant for the residents here. Like
this night last October, when we saw everything, the
noise, the beer bottles and the drunks. It’s 4:00 a.m. on
a Sunday morning, and this man has obviously done his
share of partying for the night. He was followed by this
group, some of whom left with drinks in their hand.
Someone already had left a beer bottle on the steps here.

(Demonstration )

MR. BOHRMAN: There was plenty of noise before
his friends finally led this man down the street.

(Demonstration)

SA-6

MR. BOHRMAN: When the club finally closed its
doors almost ten minutes after four, these two men came
out with their unfinished drinks. Now, more than an
hour after legal closing time, peace and quiet finally set-
tled on American Street.

(Demonstration. )

MR. BOHRMAN: The people who live on this street
are basically law-abiding citizens who say they used to
believe that local and State government would be respon-
sive to their complaints. Last fall, the frustration of being
ignored for more than a year got to be too much for some
of them and they sent their own message to the club’s
operators.

Now, in the event that you have just joined us, I
would like to remind you that you are watching a special
investigative report by Channel 3’s I-Team on this ex-
panded edition of Eyewitness News.

And as we've shown you thus far in the report, the
lives of the residents on the 600 block of South American
Street in Queen Village has been disrupted for more than
a year now by problems associated with an after-hours
drinking club, a club that opened up right in the middle
of their block.

Fed up with the drunkenness, the rowdiness, and
the late night noise of the club’s so-called clientele, the
people who live on the street did what most of us would
do, really, they asked the Police Department for help.

The trouble is that over the last year, the residents of
American Street saw a lot of police officers at the club,
but the problem there didn’t go away; if anything, they
got worse. And that’s when some of the residents began
to feel that some police officers were more interested in
taking care of the club than in helping them restore
peace and quiet in the neighborhood. And you'll see why

SA-7

they feel that way, as we continue now with our special
report, After Hours on American Street.

Dr. Judy Kodroff is a psychologist and college ad-
ministrator. She lives in the house adjacent to the Ukrai-
nian American Club, here in the 600 block of South
American Street.

She told us that on many nights, the noise from the
club was so bad, she couldn't sleep. In the fall of 1980,
Dr. Kodroff began taking notes of the activity she saw in
the street below her window, activity that sometimes in-
volved Philadelphia Police Officers.

DR. KODROFF: When I got concerned about what
police were going to be able — were going to do to help
us was when the owner and the woman that was with
him got into the police car and they drove away, and that
was, I guess, about 4:15 one night.

After that, you know, I noticed a lot of other police
officers going into the club and leaving the club during
the time it was open, and also noticed that there were
police cars when it wasn’t open.

One night, I saw a police car come at — shortly after
4:00. And because I was curious as to what a policeman
would be going in there at 4:00 for, I stayed up so that I
could see when he left. And he didn’t leave until 5:00 in
the morning.

MR. BOHRMAN: Another neighbor, who said he
was afraid to talk to us on camera, said that on two dif-
ferent days, he saw uniformed police officers at the c.ub
while it was being renovated. He said the officers ap-
peared to be working for the club and were supervising
the clean-up there.

But the incident that really got Dr. Kodroff worried
took place on Valentine’s Day of last year. She told us
that as she watched from her window overlooking the

SA-8

street in front of the club, she saw an encounter between
several police officers and this man, Ken Adams, the
club’s manager. She told us the incident involved
Adams, a female officer in car 35, and two male officers
in cars C-111 and car 3A.

DR. KODROFF: 35 and C-111 went inside the club.
And when they were in the club, Ken Adams came out
and talked to 3A. When Ken went back in the club, C-
111 and 35 came out, and C-111 got into a pretty heated
argument. 3A banged his fist on the car and shouted —
(beep) — a number of times, and then he said “this is my
club.”

My judgment of what that dispute was, was that C-
111 had come to investigate something that had been
reported to him that was going on in that club that made
it necessary for him to look into what was happening
there and that 3A did not want him to do that. That —
that would have been my judgment of the argument.

MR. BOHRMAN: February, a year ago, we took our
hidden I-Team camiera to American Street to watch the
police activity, but our initial efforts weren’t very suc-
cessful.

Someone apparently didn’t want us watching, be-
cause at 2:00 a.m. on the morning of February 22nd, a
woman called the police emergency number and made
an anonymous and false complaint that a woman had
been dragged screaming into our van. That false report
resulted in seven police cars converging on the scene.
Someone could have been injured in the incident since
at least one police gun was drawn.

The officers got quite a surprise when cameraman
Greg Meyer appeared in the door of the van.

(Demonstration )

VOICE: Do you have a woman in here?

SA-9
MR. MEYER: No. We don’t have anyone in here but
a tape recorder ond the camera the whole time.

VOICE: The whole time.

MR. MEYER: The tape recorder and the camera are
on the entire time.

(Inaudible conversation)
VOICE: Is there a female in there?

MR. MEYER: No, there is not. There never was or
ever will be.

(Inaudible conversation )

VOICE: Do you have a warrant? I object to this.
(Inaudible conversation )

VOICE: We didn’t need a warrant.

VOICE: Can I make a phone call?

(Inaudible conversation )

VOICE: Okay. Now, who are you?

MR. MEYER: Greg Meyer.

VOICE: Let me see some identification.
(Inaudible conversation)

MR. BOHRMAN: That incident was investigated by
the Police Internal Affairs Bureau.

Because she had witnessed the incident, Dr. Kodroff
was questioned by detectives. She told them a lot more
than they expected, and that led to a much wider inves-
tigation.

DR. KODROFF: I decided that I was going to tell
them that I had called the 1-Team because of the activity
that was going on next-door.

SA-10

MALE INTERVIEWER: Including the police activ-
ities?

DR. KODROFF: Absolutely, yes.

MR. BOHRMAN: Internal Affairs questioned all the
officers involved in every incident Dr. Kodroff reported
seeing from her window. In each case, the officers de-
nied the incidents had taken place or gave a different
version of the events.

Take the case of the police car Dr. Kodroff said she
saw driving the club manager and a woman away from
American Street one night in November of 1980. That
was car 38. The officer assigned to that car that night
denied ever being on American Street, and offered his
written patrol log as evidence of that claim.

DR. KODROFF: When they drive under my win-
dow, the numbers on the police cars are written in — are
printed in very large letters on the top, and it would have
been 38.

MALE INTERVIEWER: And there’s no doubt in
your mind?

DR. KODROFF: Absolutely no doubt at all.

MR. BOHRMAN: Well, seeing is believing, as they
say.

And in just a few moments, our I-Team hidden cam-
era will show you some police officers at the Ukrainian
Club, whose official patrol log show that they were some-
where else.

On April 28th of last year, Police Commissioner
Morton Solomon issued a report saying the Department
had investigated Dr. Kodroff’s allegations of police mis-
conduct at the Ukrainian American Club. He stated that

Prt

SA-11

a two-week surveillance of the club by the Internal Af-
fairs Unit “failed to reveal any evidence of police mis-
conduct.” Solomon did concede that some officers had
spent unnecessary amounts of time in the club while
performing club checks, adding that “the necessary cor-
rective action” had been taken.

We asked Dr. Kodroff if she noticed any change on
American Street after the investigation.

DR. KODROFF: For quite a long time, the police
cars parked where I couldn’t see the numbers. And I
knew after that that there was still police going in the
club because I would see them walking up from
Bainbridge Street or from South Street, but I couldn’t tell
who the cars were.

MR. BOHRMAN: Dr. Kodroff and the other neigh-
bors didn’t know it when they told us about police activity
that they saw at the club, but back in 1974, the Penn-
sylvania Crime Commission issued this report on police
corruption in Philadelphia that described activities strik-
ingly similar to what the residents saw.

In this 1974 report on police corruption in social
clubs, the Commission noted that many of these clubs
stay open for at least an hour after the legal 3:00 a.m.
closing time, because that extra hour means a lot of
money. “The temptation is great, and a number of clubs -
in Philadelphia cannot resist,” the Commission stated.

The Commission also said the requirement that Phil-
adelphia Police Officers enforce the 3:00 a.m. closing
time “provides a situation ripe for corruption.”

Back in 1974, the Crime Commission conducted ex-
tensive surveillances on clubs and came to this conclu-
sion about how the police handled their duty to close
them at 3:00 a.m.

SA-12

VOICE: When the officers entered the club at 3:15
a.m., there was never any action on their part to close the
club. Often they came, chatted with the owner, made
some notations and left..It was, if anything, a sham per-
formance of their duty, intended to provide a record in
case questions of impropriety were raised in the future.
It was obvious to the agents present that 4:00 a.m. was
the intended closing time.

MR. BOHRMAN: The report cited a number of ex-
amples of clubs paying off police officers to ignore the
3:00 a.m. closing time.

Today, eight years after that report was issued, one
of the principal complaints of the residents of American
Street is that the Ukrainian American Club, in the mid-
dle of their block, has frequently stayed open after the
legal closing time.

This is the Third Police District. Officers who work
out of here patrol the neighborhood where the Ukrainian
American Club is located. Captain Russell Taylor is the
Third District Commander.

On March the 2nd of last year, he issued a written
order instructing his men to enter the club at 3:30 a.m.
and remain until all patrons left. That order superceded
an earlier order that had set the time for the club check
at 3:00 a.m.

Residents here were puzzled about why Captain
Taylor would move the club check back to 3:30, since the
law requires clubs to stop serving drinks at 3:00 a.m. It
appeared to them that he had now, in effect, given the
Ukrainian Club an opportunity to sell drinks for an extra
half hour.

Captain Taylor declined to be interviewed for this re-
port.

SA-13

Early Saturday morning on the 10th of October, a
police officer in car 314 showed up and entered the club
at 3:31. Despite Captain Taylor’s order that officers mak-
ing the club check here were to stay until all the patrons
had left, this officer left just four minutes later, making
no effort to disperse this group on the street outside.

(Demonstration )

MR. BOHRMAN: At 3:57, car 314 returned to the
Ukrainian American Club. You’re watching him write on
his patrol log. That's his official record of where he has
been during his tour of duty.

Now, the Police Department told us that this officer’s
log sheet states that between 3:55 and 4:10 a.m., he was
at two other locations in the Third District, not here at
610 South American Street. But as you can plainly see,
he was here at the club. And at 3:59, he went inside.

(Demonstration )

MR. BOHRMAN: A few moments later, a noisy mass
exodus began, almost a full hour after the legal closing
time of 3:00 a.m.

(Demonstration )

MR. BOHRMAN: Finally at 4:12, the officer left the
club and drove off after spending 15 minutes here. Now,
remember, his log says he was never here during that
time. That’s what other police officers’ logs showed in
other cases; where Dr. Kodroff told the Internal Affairs
Bureau she had seen officers hanging out here some-
times as late as 5:00 a.m.

Our camera was on American Street again early on
Saturday, October the 17th. We saw four people enter
the club after the 3:00 a.m. closing time. One of our I-
Team reporters was also in the club on this night. The
reporter had been admitted after the 3:00 a.m. closing
time, and without the required membership card. Our

SA-14

reporter also observed drinks being sold until 3:45.
That’s well past the 3:00 a.m. legal limit.

At 3:29 on this night, an officer from car 35 entered
the club, stayed for one minute and left, again disregard-
ing the written orders to remain until all patrons had left.
Despite the fact that drinks were being served illegally
when the officer checked the club, the Police Depart-
ment told us he filed an official report of his visit indi-
cating that nothing unusual took place that night.

Nothing unusual? Well, in a way, he may be right,
you see, because as far as the residents who live around
here are concerned, serving drinks here after hours re-
ally isn’t unusual at all.

At 4:01 a.m., car 35 returned to the club. Although
the officer got out of his car and went in, he failed to
inform police radio of his presence here.

MR. FAIR: When the police officer arrives at a
scene, he gives at least three pieces of information, the
car number, the location, and the nature of — of the in-
cident that he’s going in on.

MR. BOHRMAN: Police officers are frequently re-
minded of that regulation by the police radio.

POLICE RADIO: Advisory to all police, patrol vehi-
cles must notify radio of their arrival on all assignments
by giving car number and the words “on location”.

MR. BOHRMAN: The purpose of that regulation is
to allow the radio room to keep track of available man-
power and to protect police officers. If an officer is at-
tacked or injured and fails to call in within a certain
period, other units could be dispatched to his location to
assist him.

Sources have told the I-Team that if an officer enters
a location without telling radio where he is, he generally
does not want it known that he’s there.

SA-15

On this occasion, police radio called for car 35 while
he was in the club and got no response. And while the
officer was in the club, patrons leaving were creating
quite a racket out in the street.

(Demonstration )

MR. BOHRMAN: At 4:07, the officer left the club
and walked to his car down the street. However, he did
not report back into police radio as being available until
4:14.

So, once again, on this night, the police allowed the
Ukrainian American Club to operate for almost a full
hour after legal closing time.

But the most suspicious police activity we saw on
American Street took place early Sunday morning on the
11th of October. We saw eight people enter the clu after
the 3:00 a.m. closing time. No police officer showed up
here until car 39 arrived and an officer went in at 3:52.
Five minutes later, the officer came out of the club and
drove away. By our count, there were at least 50 people
still in the club.

After the officer left, people started leaving, some of
them carrying beer bottles, another sore point with
neighbors who can’t understand why the police had
failed to stop this type of activity here.

Now, here’s where things really start to get interest-
ing. At 3:57, car 35 told the police radio to hold him out
at headquarters for paperwork. Now, remember that
number 35. You’re going to see it in just a moment.

Meanwhile, at 4:04, car 39 arrives back on American
Street, and the officer reenters the club, once again with-
out informing police radio of his presence here. The Po-
lice Department told us that this officer stated on his
official patrol log that he was at another location in the
Third District at this time.

SA-16

At 4:11, the officer in car 39 leaves the club and
drives away. All the patrons have left and the club ap-
pears to be closed for the night. But then car 35 drives
up. Remember, according to his call to police radio, he’s
at headquarters doing paperwork. Car 35 slowly backs
up, looks over the street and drives off.

Seven minutes later, car 35 reappears outside the
club, and the officer hurries inside. As far as police radio
knows, car 35 is still out at headquarters doing paper-
work. Well, the only paperwork we saw him doing was
carrying this envelope out of the club less than a minute
after he went in.

According to the Police Department, there’s an un-
explained 20-minute gap in car 35’s patrol log for this
time period on this night.

Early last month, word got around the Police Depart-
ment that the I-Team had been on American Street with
a hidden camera and had taped damaging video of of-
ficers at the club. Suddenly, there was a dramatic
change in the way officers in the Third District were
checking the club.

Phil Behr, who lives directly across the street, re-
ceived a visit from a sergeant one night promptly at the
3:00 a.m. club closing hour.

MR. BEHR: He and another officer were on the
street. One officer went inside the club at 3:00 to make
sure that the club was operating under the rules and that
no drinks were being served and that it was closed. The
police have generally been coming at the closing hour
and have been in the street telling people do not make
noise and to behave properly.

But the problem I have is that why did it take a year
for this all — all to come about.

SA-17

MR. BOHRMAN: Another strange turn of events
took place just one month ago, early Saturday morning,
on the 16th of January, when undercover vice squad of-
ficers raided the club. They arrested club manager Ken
Adams for serving nonmembers.

The Police Department told us that the raid resulted
from a routine check of social clubs in the area. But the
people that live here wonder where the vice squad was
during the last year when they repeatedly complained to
the Police Department about the liquor law violations
here.

And as we have just shown you, these violations
seem to have escaped the notice of the police officers
who have been right here night after night checking the
club.

Now, for those of you who may have joined us a little
late, I would like to remind you that you are watching a
special investigative report by Channel 3’s I-Team on
this expanded edition of Eyewitness News.

As we showed you earlier in this report, the residents
of South American Street began to wonder just whose
side the police were on. As the residents battled to elim-
inate the problems they were having with an after-hours
drinking club on their block, and as you've just seen
through the lens of our hidden I-Team camera, some of
the police activity that’s taken place on American Street
raises some very serious questions, indeed. The police
activity we video taped last October, the activity you just
saw, is now the subject of a new investigation by the
Police Department’s Internal Affairs Bureau.

An investigation was ordered by Police Commis-
sioner Morton Solomon after we told him what we had
seen on American Street. We'd like to point out right
here that Commissioner Solomon made every effort to
respond to our questions about those incidents. And

SA-18

those efforts included providing us with access to official
records of the cars and officers that we video taped on
American Street.

As the Chief of the Internal Affairs Bureau told us,
Commissioner Solomon wants to know if the Depart-
ment has a problem in the Third District; and if it does,
he wants it cleaned up.

And a note here on the police officer we showed you
leaving the club with an envelope on October 11th at
4:17 in the morning. That’s the same officer who told
police radio he was at headquarters doing paperwork and
then showed up at the club. We attempted to interview
that police officer, but he refused to talk to us.

We'll have more to show you about the police activity
on American Street that night in a special follow-up re-
port tomorrow on Eyewitness News.

bo xe x

SA-19

EXCERPT FROM BROADCAST OF
FEBRUARY 18, 1982, 5:30 P.M.

MR. BOHRMAN: We found, for example, that some
officers had been showing up at the Ukrainian Club and
spending time inside, while stating on their official patrol
logs that they were somewhere else.

Now, as part of their regular patrol duty, police of-
ficers are supposed to enforce the State law that requires
social clubs to stop serving drinks at 3:00 a.m. But our
investigation showed that although police officers were
present at the Ukrainian Club, they didn’t seem to be
doing much to enforce that law.

For example, on the morning of October 17th, we
saw a police officer enter the club at 3:29, stay for a
minute, and leave. He filed an official report of this visit
indicating that nothing unusual had occurred at the club
when he checked it. But we had a reporter inside the
club that morning. And our reporter saw the club’s bar-
tender serving drinks until 3:45 a.m., well past the 3:00
a.m. limit.

The officer’s failure to report or do anything about
that activity is now the subject of a Police Department
investigation.

But the most suspicious police activity we saw on
American Street took place early Sunday morning on the
1 1th of October. We saw eight people enter the club after
the 3:00 a.m. closing time. No police officer showed up
here until car 39 arrived and an officer went in at 3:52.
Five minutes later, the officer came out of the club and
drove away. By our count, there were at least 50 people
still in the club.

(Demonstration )

MR. BOHRMAN: After the officer left, people
started leaving, carrying beer bottles, another sore point

SA-20

with neighbors who can’t understand why police have
failed to stop this type of activity here.

Now, here’s where things really start to get interest-
ing. At 3:57, car 35 told the police radio to hold him out
at headquarters for paperwork. Now, remember that
number 35. You're going to see it in just a moment.

Meanwhile, at 4:04, car 39 arrives back on American
Street and the officer reenters the club, once again with-
out informing police radio of his presence here. The Po-
lice Department told us that this officer stated on his
official patrol log that he was at another location in the
Third District at this time.

At 4:11, the officer in car 39 leaves the club and
drives away. All the patrons have left, and the club ap-
pears to be closed for the night. But then car 35 drives
up. Remember, according to his call to police radio, he’s
at headquarters doing paperwork. Car 35 slowly backs
up, looks over the street and drives off.

(Demonstration )

MR. BOHRMAN: Seven minutes later, car 35 reap-
pears outside the club, and the officer hurries inside. As
far as police radio knows, car 35\is still out at headquar-
ters doing paperwork. Well, the only paperwork we saw
him doing was carrying this envelope out of the club less
than a minute after he went in. That officer is Patrolman
James Coughlin.

MR. BOHRMAN: We wanted to ask Officer
Coughlin about the events of October the 11th, so we
sent I-Teanh reporter John Toth to interview him last
week, but Officer Coughlin didn’t want to answer any of
our questions.

MR. TOTH: Can I ask you a few questions, sir?

MR. COUGHLIN: I want to know what — what’s
this about?

SA-21

MR. TOTH: Well, I wanted to ask you that on Oc-
tober 11, 1981, you were in car 35, and did you make out
a 48 report about vandalism over at the Ukrainian Club
at about a quarter after 12?

Greg, don’t go up the steps.
MR. COUGHLIN: What’s you name?
MR. TOTH: Pardon me, sir?

MR. COUGHLIN: Let me — let me — Let me get
your name, will you?

MR. TOTH: Sure.
MR. COUGHLIN: This — this here is harassment.

MR. TOTH: Sir, can you tell us if you went into
headquarters to do paperwork that night at about 4:00,
October 11th?

MR. COUGHLIN: (No response. )

MR. BOHRMAN: We wanted to ask Officer
Coughlin about the vandalism incident at the Ukrainian
Club early on the morning of October the 11th, because
his name is on the official report of that incident.

In fact, according to the report called a 48, and the
official patrol log of car 35, Officer Coughlin was in car
35 for the entire midnight to 8:00 a.m. shift on that day.

Well, our hidden I-Team camera was on American
Street at 12:50 that morning when car 35 showed up to
handle the vandalism complaint from the club. And the
problem is, is that the officer who handled this call does
not appear to be Officer Coughlin. Whoever this officer
is, he did not appear to be familiar with car 35. For ex-
ample, it took him four tries to find the right key to start
the car when he was leaving.

We can’t explain all this, nor can we explain why
Officer Coughlin was not equipped for street patrol when

SA-22

he arrived at the club at 4:17 that morning. You'll notice,
he has no nightstick, no uniform jacket and no hat when
he shows up here, all standard items officers on patrol
are required to have.

We should also note that the Police Department says
the official patrol log for car 35 contains an unexplained
gap between 4:00 and 4:20 a.m., the very 20-minute pe-
riod during which we saw Officer Coughlin here on
American Street. And we should note again here, car 35
had told the police radio at 3:57 a.m. that he was at head-
quarters doing paperwork.

(Demonstration )

a

SA-23

EXCERPT FROM BROADCAST OF
FEBRUARY 18, 1982, 6:00 P.M.

MR. BOHRMAN: Using our hidden I-Team camera,
we showed how some police officers were appearing at
the club at 610 South American Street, but doing little or
nothing about apparent violations in the liquor laws
there. We also reported that the activity we saw was sim-
ilar to questionable police activity observed in 1974 by
the Pennsylvania Crime Commission in its investigation
of police conduct at social clubs in the City.

Today I-Team manager Tony Lame talked to one of
the lawyers who supervised that investigation. Agents
working for attorney Barbara Bailey back in the early
1970’s had observed police activity in a number of clubs
and concluded that many officers were engaged in what
the Commission called, “a sham performance of their
duty to enforce the 3:00 a.m. closing hour.” That’s the
same complaint the residents of American Street had
about the police on their block in 1981.

We asked Ms. Bailey to view our report and compare
the video we shot with the actions her agents saw almost
ten years ago.

MS. BAILEY: The pattern of activity was precisely
the same that we observed in 19— basically 1972
through ’74.

MR. BOHRMAN: We then showed her the video
tape we shot on American Street early October the 11th
last year. That morning, an officer in car 35 told police
radio he was at headquarters doing paperwork and then
showed up on American Street and picked up an enve-
lope at the club.

MS. BAILEY: I’m a lawyer, so I have to analyze it as
a lawyer. And what I’ve seen is a man saying he’s in point
A, when he is indeed in point B, which immediately
raises my suspicion.

SA-24

You have him drive up and sort of check out the lo-
cation, which is what people often do to make sure
they're not being watched. He then comes back and he
gets out in his shirt sleeves. That’s important because
policemen are trained, and they do it absolutely automat-
ically, to have on a hat and coat and a nightstick, or what-
ever other weapon they have in their possession when
they go up to investigate a complaint or to conduct some
official business.

All that leads me to believe that he was not involved
in official business when he went in.

MR. BOHRMAN: We wanted to ask that officer
what was in that envelope, but he wouldn’t talk to us
when we tried to interview him last week.

MR. TOTH: Sir, can you tell us if you went into
headquarters to do paperwork that night at about 4:00,
October 11th?

(Demonstration )

SA-25

EXCERPT FROM BROADCAST OF
FEBRUARY 19, 1982

MR. BOHRMAN: All right. I’d like to shift gears, if
I may, for just a moment. I'd like to talk about the Police
Department and Tom Garvey, who is the President of the
Fraternal Order of Police, is here.

Tom, what appears to be some very strange activities
by certain members of the Police Department was taking
place between the hours of 3:00 and 4:17 on a few morn-
ings. Can you explain to me what those officers were
doing?

MR. GARVEY: Well, first of all, let me explain that
I deal in evidence. I have to see what evidence is and
what evidence does and how concrete it is. And based on
what you’ve shown so far, I'll have to say either most
people are watching Dallas or they’re wondering what
happened to McClain’s Law.

MR. BOHRMAN: Be that as it may —

MR. GARVEY: Let me finish my statement. You
asked me, and I'll reply.

MR. BOHRMAN: All right.

MR. GARVEY: You made the statement that you
must know something about liquor laws. Now, I would
hope that you do know that police in the City of Phila-
delphia cannot remove anyone from a private club. We’re
not, by law, allowed to. They’re allowed to stay in any
club as long as they’re members.

Ail we can do is, if we see sales, is arrest the bar-
tender. They can stay there all night, as long as they
want. They can bring in a case of liquor, as members,
and stay there all night. They have that right.

SA-26

What appears to me has happened here, very hon-
estly, is some very affluent members of the Society Hill
neighborhood got in touch with the District Attorney’s
office and the Governor’s office and made certain things
happen that the I-Team got involved with.

But if you were going to ask me what wrongdoing
whatsoever took place by police, the answer on what you
showed here is zero.

MR. BOHRMAN: Well, let me deal with one spe-
cific. We saw two instances where police officers went by
people who were obviously inebriated, making noise be-
tween 3:00 and 4:00 in the morning, and they didn’t so
much as ask them to be quiet and to move on; they
walked right by them, and one was holding a beer bottle
at the time.

MR. GARVEY: What you showed was clips. And I
would love, I hope you would turn over to our Depart-
ment, the entire film.

You mentioned one year you worked on this. Yet,
you show three to four nights of split clips, not the entire
film.

But, understand, there are 372 clubs in the City of
Philadelphia, 2900 liquor licenses. In that district alone,
at that particular workshift, there may have been 13 ve-
hicles. So if all 13 vehicles went to check a private club,
not only the neighbors on American — their street, or
any district, or any other street in that district, there was
no police coverage if they were just checking clubs.

My opinion is that there’s one heck of a lot more se-
rious things going on than a noisy club. And every house
that lets out a private party would, in all likelihood, it
would be just as noisy.

MR. BOHRMAN: So who do you think should be
doing the club checks, if the police shouldn’t be doing it?

SA-27

MR. GARVEY: I think it could be the Liquor Con-
trol; it could be a combination. But the manpower may
not be there for either.

Then it comes down to Government to provide the
funds to do it.

MR. LAME: Let me just jump in here one minute.

Mr. Garvey, I think that’s a very serious question,
and that is, do you think the Police Department should
be tying up its manpower doing club checks in the first
place?

Let’s — let’s be realistic. The Crime Commission
looked at this once before. They said this was a situation
that was ripe for corruption. It’s — it’s a situation that
takes the officers off the street, out of patrol, where I’m
sure most people would rather have them.

And I think what we're trying to get at here is how
can the various government agencies solve the problems
that the people on American Street had and the three or
400 other people who have called this station since this
piece went on.

We're not particularly interested in saying that two
or three police officers didn’t do their job. That’s not re-
ally what this is all about. The question of — what we’re
really trying to get at here is how do we solve the prob-
lems of the people in these various neighborhoods.

MR. GARVEY: Well, I think, again, it’s priorities.
And you deal with a situation of economics, as the Sen-
ator does and City Government does.

And our priorities are a 26 percent increase in crime,
none of which was touched on this subject. So our pri-
orities are reducing crime, which none of this touches
on.

SA-28

Do we like doing club checks? I’m sure we’d prefer
to be out looking for burglars. Do we like covering school
crossings? No. I prefer to go out and look for the most
serious crime.

So the answer is, in an economic situation where the
money is not available, we perform to the best of our abil-
ity. And I think that film shows it.

MR. BOHRMAN: Mr. Garvey, obviously, you seem
to think nothing was done wrong by the police in what
you saw, and everything seems to be pretty much on the
up-and-up.

However, we have spoken with Police Commissioner
Solomon’s office, and we also have spoken with District
Attorney Ed Rendell, and they are both extremely con-
cerned about what we have shown on television. They
are concerned about the police activity we saw.

Now, are you going to just say that that’s — that
nothing happened, that it’s — in a cavalier way, that it is
just simply benign, nothing?

MR. GARVEY: No. Let me say that what you’ve
shown in my eyes says they did nothing wrong.

I'll cover just one incident where you characterize —
characterize, by innuendo, a certain officer who come
out of the club with what you portrayed as an envelope.

Let me tell you about that officer. That officer was
the first night he ever worked 12:00 to 8:00. He was a
rookie. He come off a funeral leave where his father died.

The dress that night was optional, and you said he
was without proper uniform. It was optional. He was
wearing what was proper for that night.

That officer had a 48 book in his hand, not an en-
velope as the characterization was. That officer worked
that sector for the first time that night, didn’t know

SA-29

where the club was. So that officer, in all rightfulness,
was right in what he did. But the characterization was
the opposite.

MR. BOHRMAN: What about the alleged falsifica-
tion of the official police records by some of these offic-
ers? We have seen some of the actual records, sir.

MR. GARVEY: The allegation may be made. That
officer, I’m sure, will be able to explain that log. But he’s
not had that opportunity.

MR. LAME: Mr. Garvey, let me ask you one other
question, since we're talking about this.

On at least one occasion when we were in the club
and they were serving drinks there after hours, an officer
went in, he came out, he filed a report saying nothing
unusual was going on.

We've talked to the Liquor Control Board. They say
their file on this club shows not one single report from
the Philadelphia Police Department indicating any vio-
lations at all of the liquor laws at this club. I would say
that the people who live on American Street find that
hard to understand.

MR. GARVEY: I would say, very honestly, you’re
right. There are a lot of clubs that serve drinks after the
officer leaves. They may reopen. Because we don’t have
the manpower to have them stay in there from 3:00 until
4:00 to make sure that everyone leaves, and we can’t
force them to leave.

So you're right, and she’s right. They may, in fact,
serve after the officer leaves. But that is not a priority,
trying to get clubs to get rid of people.

* * *

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40385012_0103%3A3. Public record. Not legal advice.
